Expectancy Model of Fear
The expectancy model of fear (Reiss & McNally, 1985) is another fear of pain
conceptualization that is quite relevant in dentistry. The expectancy model is
based on two components to fear: expectations that certain events and/or
experiences (heart palpitation, embarrassment, or losing control of emo-
Hons) will occur in particular situations, and anxiety sensitivity, which refers
to the belief that those expected experiences are dangerous or threatening.
Taken together, these factors influence behavioral responses in the context of
(potential) threat, and in particular avoidance and escape behavior.
It is believed that anxiety sensitivity is a predisposing variable linked to
responding with fear to anxiety-related events (Reiss, 1991) and operates as.
a vulnerability to the development of an anxiety disorder (Craske, 1999). The
vast majority of empirical support for the expectancy model is taken from re-
search on anxiety disorders (e.g,, Taylor et al., 1992) and chronic pain (eg,
Greenberg, & Burns, 2003; Zvolensky et al., 2001). Gross (1992a) applied the
expectancy model of fear to dental avoidance with the development of the
Pain Sensitivity Index (PSI). Using the PSI, Gross found that pain sensitivity
among dental patients predicted pain intensity, and pain intensity predicted
denial avoidance. Although Gross asserts that anxiety sensitivity and pain
sensitivity are distinct constructs, they both ate founded on the same model
of fear learning and are closely related (Gross, 1992a; 1992b),
Norton and Asmundson (2003) integrated anxiety sensitivity, as it relates
to physiological responding, into the fear-avoidance model of chronic pain.
The authors indicated that although the fear-avoidance model focuses on
cognitive and behavioral aspects of pain responding, it does not highlight
the contributions of physiological arousal toward pain avoidance. The
amended fear-avoidance model suggests that anxiety sensitivity will impact
avoidance behavior at the level of pain catastrophizing; physiological activ-
ity (e.g., muscle tension), along with anxiety sensitivity, will contribute to
fear of pain (see Norton & Asmundson for a review). Thus, it is a patient's
experience of physiological arousal during dental treatment, and the belief
that treatment may lead to pain or lasting harm (e.g. a catastrophe in the
dental chair, such as myocardial infarction) that initiates dental fear, The
maintenance of avoidance behavior occurs through negative reinforcement.
Fear is reduced when the dental office is avoided, and the reduction of fear
increases the likelihood of the response (ie., avoidance) in the future.