Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter III-A: Board of Directors/Trustees
Chapter III-A: Board of Directors/Trustees
Board – comprised of a select group of owners, controls, operates and exercises the powers of the corporation;
Owners – periodically elect, or when demanded by circumstances, replace the board;
Follows a stakeholder centered model:
o Owners are only one of the many corporate stakeholders; others include creditors, employees, customers,
suppliers, government and community
What Comprises of Title III:
o Regulates the relationship between the corporation (as represented by the board) and its shareholders or
members;
o Provides the powers, duties and liabilities of the board, and the right of shareholders or members to replace
them;
o Number of independent directors must be at least 20% of board membership;
Distinction between BoD and Corporate Officer:
o BoD: not necessarily within the day-to-day operations of the corporation; Corporate Officers: those who are
indicated in the By-Laws;
o BoD: mandatorily requirement: at least 1 shares of stock; Corporate Officers: not necessarily has a share of
stock;
o BoD: the power to appoint and dismiss corporate officers indicated in by-laws is vested with them;
Codal Provisions:
Board of Directors and Trustees shall exercise the corporate powers, conduct all business and control all
properties of corporation;
Term of Directors and Trustees:
o Directors: Term of 1 year from among the holders of stocks;
o Trustees: Term not exceeding 3 years from among the members of corporation;
o Condition: each officer shall hold office until the successor is elected and qualified; director who ceases to
own at least 1 share of stock or trustee ceases to be a member shall cease to be such;
Corporations required to have independent directors constituting at least 20% of such board:
o Corporations covered by Sec. 17.2 of RA 8799 (SRC):
securities registered with SEC;
with assets of at least Php 50M;
having 200 or more holders of shares each holding at least 100 shares;
o Banks and quasi-banks, NSSLAs, pawnshops, corporations engaged in money service business,
preneed, trust and insurance companies and other financial intermediaries;
o Other corporations engaged in business vested with public interest similar to the above;
Relevant factors germane to the objective and purpose of requiring election of an independent
director: (1) extent of minority ownership; (2) financial products or securities issued/offered; (3)
public interest involved; (4) other analogous factors;
Who is an independent director?
o Person, who, apart from shareholdings and fees received from the corporation is independent of management
and free from any business or other relationship which could reasonably be perceived to materially interfere
with the exercise of independent judgment in carrying out the responsibilities as a director;
o Share of Stock, Compensation and Remuneration is allowed to an independent director; but at least 1 share of
stock is not required;
o Conditions:
Must be elected by the shareholders present or entitled to vote in absentia;
Subject to rules and regulations governing qualifications, disqualifications, etc. by the Commission to
strengthen their independence and align with international best practices;
Annotation:
(1) Nomination
o Board has responsibility to nominate who will sit as directors or trustees. (Rationale: ensuring and adopting
effective succession planning program for directors and key officers to ensure growth and increase in
shareholders;
o Any shareholder or member may nominate another shareholder or member with the prescribed
qualifications and none of the disqualifications set forth by the Code;
o There must be an impartial manner of nomination and in full disclosure on the following matters:
Director or trustee profile;
Director or trustee attendance report;
Appraisals and performance reports for the board and criteria and procedure for assessment;
Profiles of directors seeking election or reelection;
(2) Election Proper (with Quorum)
o Election is the shareholders or members meeting duly called for the purpose-nominees shall be presented in
this juncture;
o Valid election: PRESENT, either in person or through representative by written proxy.
o Who: Owners of the majority of capital stock, or if no capital stock, majority of the members entitled to vote.
(3) Manner of Casting Votes:
o May vote in person or through a written proxy;
o Voting May through remote communication or in absentia if so permitted in by-laws; (may be exercised by
corps. Vested with public interest;
o By show of hand (one man, one vote, default on Non-stock) or, by poll or by ballot (on share one vote, default
on Stock Corp.);
(4) Prescribed Vote
o Follows plurality voting: nominees who receive the highest number of votes shall be elected as members of
the board;
o If only one nominee, it is sufficient that the nominee shall receive one vote cast;
(5) Distribution of Votes
o A. Straight voting:
Stockholders entitled to vote shall have the right to vote the number of shares of stock standing in
their own names, vote such number of shares for as many persons as there are directors to be
elected, and distribute them on the same principle among as many candidates as may see fit;
Total number of votes cast should not exceed 500, wherein controlling bloc casts 400 votes while the
minority bloc may cast 100 votes; Minority bloc may not be able to select its representative in the
board;
In non-stock corp., members may cast as many votes as there are trustees to be elected but may not
cast more than 1 vote for 1 candidate;
o B. Cumulative voting:
Shall at all times be permitted in stock corporation;
Stockholders entitled to vote shall have the right to vote the number of shares of stock standing in
their own name, vote such number of shares for as many persons as there are directors to be elected
and cumulate said shares and give one candidate as many votes as the number of directors to be
elected multiplied by the number of shares owned;
In this case the minority may cumulate its vote and may cast 100 votes for its representative;
May not be permitted in non-stock corp., except provided in the AoI or ByLaws;
(6) Election Contests
o Refers to any controversy or dispute involving title or claim to any elective office in a stock or non-stock corp.,
the validation of proxies, the manner and validity of elections, and qualifications of candidates, including
proclamation of winners to the office of director, trustee or other officer directly elected by stockholders; also
annulling the shareholders meeting (Ricafort, et.al vs. Calalang, et.al)
o Any shareholder or member who questions the election shall follow the procedure in ByLaws including
period to pursue election contest; if there is an arbitration clause.
o Absence of arbitration clause, the election contest must be filed in the court within 15 days from the date of
election;
The board appoints the corporate officers by the vote of majority and not simple majority of the quorum;
No one shall act as president and secretary or president and treasurer at the same time;
Doctrine of apparent authority: Corporate officers are the agents of the corporation, They have the apparent authority
to bind the corporation on matters that are generally within the domain of corporate business and within the scope of
their duties;
Chairman of the Board
o Not a statutory corporate officer, in the sense that he is not among those who must be appointed by the board
in the absence of a bylaw provisions stipulating the contrary;
o Generally sets the meeting and its agenda; (Presiding Officer)
o He may be an independent director provided he must not hold an executive position and should not be
involved in the corporations day-to-day operations;
o May not be a Filipino national provided that he limit his role to that of presiding officer;
President
o Must be a director; he is in the best position to brief members of the board on the corporations day-to-day
operations and matters needing corporate action;
o The Primary officer tasked to implement the decision of the board and the principal agent of the corporation;
o He shall manage the corporation and perform such duties as may be provided in the ByLaws;
o He may bind the corporation pursuant to the specific authority by the board or by his apparent or ostensible
authority;
o May preside meetings in the absence of Chairman; Signatory of Stock Cert. and FS;
Treasurer
o Must be a resident of the Philippines; immediate availability being the primary custodian of the corporate
funds
o Has control over the funds and/or other assets of the corporation;
o Has authority to receive in the name and for the benefit of the corporation all subscriptions, contributions or
donations paid or given by the subscribers or members, certifies the information set forth in the seventh and
eight clauses of AoI, and the paid-up portion of the subscription in cash has been received;
o Main signatories of financial statements;
o Need not be a Filipino citizen;
Secretary (Corp. Sec.)
o Must be a citizen and resident of the Philippines;
o Maintain corporate records, including the stock and transfer book;
o Sends notices and takes minutes of meetings; he is the corporate officer with whom a dissenting directors
must register his objection to a particular corporate resolution such as the issuance of watered stock (lower
price than the par value)
o The primary officer tasked to make the prescribed reports to the SEC and attest to corporate resolutions;
o Corp. Sec. should see to it that none of the information or statement in a report or certification is incomplete,
inaccurate, false, or misleading, otherwise he may be liable for willfully certifying a report;
o Should be a separate individual from the compliance officer and not a member of board of directors;
Compliance Officer (Corp. is vested with public interest)
o May hold 2 or more positions concurrently;
o Tasked to ensure that the members of the board and corporate officers comply with law, the corporate
charter and ByLaws;
o Should not be a member of the board and primarily liable to the corp. and its shareholders and not to the
Chairman or President;
Such other officers as may be provided in the ByLaws
o Could be considered as employees or subordinate officials (Matling Industrial and Commercial
Corporation vs. Coros);
Sec. 25: Report of Election of Directors, Trustees and Officers, Non-holding of Election and Cessation from Office
Codal Provisions
Within 30 days after the election of Board of Directors and Trustees, the Corp Sec shall submit to SEC the names,
nationalities, shareholdings and residence address of DT&O elected;
If No election was made: it shall be reported to the SEC with the reasons therefor within 30 days from the date of the
scheduled election; It must be included a new date for the election not later than 60 days from the scheduled date;
If No new date has been assigned or re-scheduled election is not held: Upon application of a stakeholder
(Stockholder, Member, Director or Trustee) and verification, the SEC may order that an election be held stating the
time and place of election, presiding officer and record dates for the determination of stockholders or members
entitled to vote;
If DT&O die, retired, resign or cease to hold office: Corp. Sec shall report to SEC within 7 days from knowledge
thereof;
Codal Provisions:
Annotation:
Purpose of the shotgun power of shareholders & members to remove D&T: address inefficiency, failure or abuse of the
concerned D&T;
Authority to call a special meeting: (1) President or (2) Prescribed majority of the shareholders or members;
Various situation of disputes in a corporation: Generally, through full blown litigation or arbitration clause, or the SEC
may arbitrate the dispute
o With limited shareholdings and membership:
In a close corporation, matter may be resolved by referring to the shareholders agreement.
o With controlling and minority shareholdings:
Minority shareholders cannot replace the majority of the board; on the other hand, controlling
shareholders may not generally replace the directors nominated and elected by minority
shareholders;
Cooperation of controlling to the minority shareholders is the key;
o With block but non-controlling shareholdings:
Majority of directors are elected through consensus among block shareholders; this is common in
public corporations such as SSS and GSIS;
Dispute relative to the composition of the board and management is resolved behind closed doors;
Reason: investors prefer stability and seek to avoid market disruption;
Codal provisions:
Vacancy occurring other than removal or expiration of term may be filled by:
o Vote of at least majority of remaining D&T, if there is a quorum;
o Otherwise, filled by stockholders or members in a regular or special meeting called for the purpose;
o D&T elected to fill the vacancy shall be called as the REPLACEMENT D&T and shall serve only for the
unexpired term of the predecessor in office;
Situations of Vacancy:
o If term expiration: election shall be held no later than the day of such expiration at a meeting called for the
purpose;
o If as a result of removal: election may be held on the same meeting authorizing the removal (must be stated
in agenda);
o All other cases: election must be held no more than 45 days from the time vacancy arose; must be reported
within 7 days to the SEC;
o Increase in the number of D&T: election at a regular or special meeting called for the purpose; Emergency
Board:
Emergency Board:
o If vacancy prevent the remaining directors from constituting a quorum and emergency action is required to
prevent grave, substantial and irreparable loss or damage to the corp.: TEMPORARY FILED FROM AMONG
THE OFFICER OF THE CORP. by unanimous vote of remaining D&T;
o Action shall be limited to the emergency action necessary and shall cease within a reasonable time from
termination of emergency or upon election of replacement D&T;
o Must notify SEC within 3 days of the creation of the emergency board;
Absence of provision in by-laws fixing the compensation of D&T: they shall not receive compensation in their capacity
as such except for reasonable per diems; Such compensation must be approved by the majority of stockholders
representing capital stock or members in a regular or special meeting;
Compensation shall not exceed 10% of the net income before income tax of the corp. during the preceding year;
D&T shall not participate in the determination of their per diems or compensation;
Corporations vested with public interest shall submit an annual report of the total compensation of each D&T to the
SEC and shareholders;
Annotation:
Per diem:
o D&T is only entitled to reasonable per diem, just enough to cover the costs of attending the meeting;
o not subject to tax; no income incurred;
o But excessive per diem now refers to compensation and generally subject to tax;
Compensation of non-executive directors or trustees:
o A D&T may be appointed as Corporate Officer like the President. His compensation as a corporate officer is
not subject to the above limitations and a product of negotiation between the corporation and the corporate
officer for his services and not for his appointment as a member of the board
o What prohibits is the “in their capacity as such” of the directors and trustees; not as a corporate officers.
Stock option plans and other share-based compensation schemes:
o Involve the grant to key officers and employees of the right to receive or acquire the subject shares at a fixed
price after a certain period. The concerned officer or employee acquires a vested right to receive or acquire
shares in accordance with the plan or scheme;
o Rationale: incentivize the key officers and employees into increasing the value and allow them to receive
concrete benefit in the success of the company;
Say-on-Pay rule
o In Public Corp. the law requires an annual report on the total compensation of each of D&T which will be
provided to the shareholders so they can have a say on pay (consider the reasonableness of the yearly
compensation of a particular director and determine whether he should be re-appointed). This paved way for
the shareholders to be the ultimate judge in assessing the sufficiency of compensation;
o Such compensation must be approved by the majority of stockholders representing capital stock or members
in a regular or special meeting;
Codal Provisions:
D&T Shall be liable jointly and severally for all damages suffered by the corporation, its stockholders or members and
other persons if:
o They are willfully and knowingly vote for or assent to patently unlawful acts. (Obedience)
o Guilty of gross negligence or bad faith in directing the affairs of the corporation. (Care)
o Acquire any personal or pecuniary interest in conflict with their duty. (Loyalty)
Limitations for DT&O:
o Shall not attempt to acquire or acquire any interest adverse to the corporation in respect of any
matter which has reposed in them in confidence.
o And upon which equity imposes a disability upon themselves to deal in their own behalf.
o Such DT&O will violate it shall be liable as a trustee for the corporation and must account for the profits
which otherwise would have accrued to the corporation.
Annotation:
Sec. 31: Dealings of Directors, Trustees or Officers with the Corporation (Self-Dealing Contracts)
Codal Provisions:
A contract of corp. with one or more of tis DT&O or their spouses and relatives within 4 th civil degree of consanguinity
or affinity is voidable at the option of the corporation, unless all the following conditions are present:
o Presence of such D&T in the board meeting in which the contract was approved was not necessary to
constitute a quorum for such meeting;
o Vote of D&T was not necessary for the approval of the contract;
o Contract is fair and reasonable; and
o In case of corporations vested with public interest: material contracts are approved by at least 2/3 of the
entire membership of the board; (MATERIAL RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS)
o In case of Officers: contract has been previously authorized by the board;
If first 3 conditions were absent, contract may be ratified by the stockholders representing 2/3 of outstanding
capital stock or 2/3 of the members in a meeting called for the purpose;
Annotation:
Interlocking Directors: are persons who serve as member of the board of directors of two or more competing
corporations or corporations engaged in practically the same kind of business.
Contract between 2 or more corporations having interlocking director shall not be invalidated on that ground alone
(except in cases of fraud and provided that the contract is fair and reasonable)
o Provided: if the interest of interlocking director in one corporation is SUBSTANTIAL and the interest is
merely NOMINAL (minimal), the contract shall subject to provisions of preceding section (Sec. 31)
o What constitutes substantial: stockholdings exceeding 20% of the outstanding capital stocks;
When disloyalty takes place: Director, by virtue of such office, acquires a business opportunity which should belong to
the corporation, thereby obtaining profits to prejudice of such corporation.
Liability: Must account for and refund to the latter all such profits unless the act has been ratified by a vote of
stockholders holding at least 2/3 of the outstanding capital stock.
Scope: still applicable even the director risked one’s own funds in the venture;
Corporate Opportunity:
o developed by a director making use of corporate information and/or properties;
o developed by a director who has been tasked to precisely develop such opportunity;
o came to the director because of his position in the corporation; and
o within the corporation’s existing line of business.
Treatment of Corporate Opportunity: (2 forms)
o Delaware Standard: director may not be disloyal if he previously offered the opportunity to the corporation
(Safe Harbor).
o American Law Institute approach: (1) line of business test; (2) interest test: and (3) financial or technical
inability test)
Sec. 34: Executive, Management and Other Special Committees (shall be provided in the Bylaws)
Codal Provisions:
Annotations:
Rationale: for operation efficiency; support for effective performance if the boards functions, particularly with audit,
risk management and other key corporate concerns;
Special Committees:
o Board may create special committees even not explicitly authorized by the bylaws. Need not be comprised of
directors and may be temporary or permanent.
o Board may assign to perform tasks for consideration of the board.