Criteria Needs help Below Satisfactory Very good At Excellent Exceeds

Standard Approaching Standard Standard

(1) point Standard (4) points

(2) points (3) points

Oral Communication Shows little Shows some Shows adequate Shows higher

The problems/issues understanding of the understanding of understanding of knowledge of the

and seriousness was main the main the main main

clearly identified in problems/issues. problems/issues problems/issues problems/issues

discussions with group

members
Critical Thinking Skill Critical issues/ key Critical issues/key Critical issues/ key Critical issues/ key

Critical and important problems not problems problems problems identified

issues/problems that identified .The case identified. The identified. The The Case Analysis

supported the Case analysis is poorly Case Analysis Case Analysis were clearly

Analysis were identified, analysed, were not clearly were partially identified,

identified, clearly and supported. identified, identified, analysed, and

analysed and supported. analysed, and analysed, and supported.

supported. supported.

Plan Effective Effective Effective Effective

-Specific recommendations recommendations recommendations recommendations,

recommendations and/or plans of and/or plans of and/or plans of solutions, and/or

and/or plans of action action not provided action inadequate action were plans of action

provided. It was and poorly or not and was not partially provided were provided and

presented and supported in a supported in a and supported in a supported in an

supported in a literate literate and effective literate and literate manner. literate and

and effective manner manner. effective manner. effective manner

Specific facts Specific data or Specific data or

-Specific facts were necessary to support facts were not Specific facts were facts were referred

referred to when the analysis and referred when occasionally when necessary to

necessary to support the conclusions was not supporting the referred when support the analysis

analysis and provided. analysis and supporting the and conclusions.

conclusions. conclusions. analysis and

conclusions.

Valuing Was unenthusiastic Showed signs of Participated in the Willingly

Participated in to participate in the trying to discussion. Participated in the

discussion. discussion. participate in the discussion.

discussion.

Little or no

Articulated articulation of Some articulation Good articulation Excellent

ideas/thoughts/feelings. thoughts/ feelings/ of thoughts/ of thoughts/ articulation of

ideas feelings/ ideas feelings/ ideas thoughts/ feelings/

ideas

Allowed other group Did not allow others Allowed others to Allowed others to

members to articulate to articulate of articulate of articulate of Allow others to

ideas/ thoughts thoughts/ feelings/ thoughts/ feelings/ thoughts/ feelings/ articulate of

/feelings. ideas ideas ideas thoughts/ feelings/

ideas