Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aspects of Intergranular Corrosion of AISI 321 Stainless Steel in High-Carbon-Containing Environments
Aspects of Intergranular Corrosion of AISI 321 Stainless Steel in High-Carbon-Containing Environments
net/publication/259579110
CITATIONS READS
5 645
4 authors, including:
Joanna Wysocka
Gdansk University of Technology
32 PUBLICATIONS 273 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Electrochemical Au-Minecraft: a new approach towards the impedimetric biosensing system View project
Revisiting Aluminum Pitting Corrosion in Chloride Solutions: Metallic Nanoparticles Fabrication and a New Insight into Pitting Corrosion Mechanism View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Jacek Ryl on 23 September 2014.
Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by 117429 []
For Authors
If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please use our Emerald for Authors service
information about how to choose which publication to write for and submission guidelines are available for all. Please visit
www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information.
About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com
Emerald is a global publisher linking research and practice to the benefit of society. The company manages a portfolio of
more than 290 journals and over 2,350 books and book series volumes, as well as providing an extensive range of online
products and additional customer resources and services.
Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the Committee on Publication Ethics
(COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.
Abstract
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to present a case study of unexpected sensitization to intergranular corrosion of highly resistant AISI 321
steel in petrochemical conditions, where it was subjected to the simultaneous influence of elevated temperature of ⬃250°C and vapors from the
asphalt production process.
Design/methodology/approach – Corrosion coupons were exposed in an installation carrying asphalt vapors. To identify the susceptibility to
intergranular corrosion a standard Strauss test was performed. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) micrographs show a degree of degradation as
a result of local corrosion. Influence of the carburization process occurred during exposure and depletion of chromium in the passive layer and was
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA GDANSKA At 08:29 22 September 2014 (PT)
evaluated using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) techniques.
Findings – The paper provides information on origin of corrosion of AISI 321 steel in a high-carbon-containing environment. It was found out that
long-term exposure can lead to intergranular corrosion in temperatures that are much lower than those that have been considered to be required
for sensitization of austenitic steels. The high concentration of carbon introduced during the exposure is stated to be responsible for this effect.
Practical implications – The formation of chromium carbides, leading to intergranular corrosion of the Type 321 stainless steel, is a major concern.
The paper reports that in certain petrochemical environments, highly resistant stainless steels, such as AISI 321, can be susceptible to intergranular
carbide degradation.
Originality/value – The presence of titanium is not sufficient to increase resistance in multiple environments and sensitization can occur even at
relatively low temperatures of ⬃250°C.
Keywords Intergranular corrosion, Stainless steel, Petrochemicals, Failure investigation
Paper type Research paper
328
Aspects of intergranular corrosion of AISI 321 Anti-Corrosion Methods and Materials
Jacek Ryl et al. Volume 61 · Number 5 · 2014 · 328 –333
Accurate simulation of the specific environments that are structures and individual molecules cannot be distinguished.
present in petrochemical and chemical installations is The main components are malthenes (oils and resins) and
impossible in laboratory conditions using electrochemical asphaltenes (heavier fractions). At high temperatures of
techniques. The influences can be very complex and often are asphalt processing, volatile compounds can evaporate. Thus,
coupled with high temperatures. The presence of halide ions is in the vapor off-take installation, the most volatile and the
of great influence, destroying the passive layer of SS and simplest hydrocarbons are present. To avoid electrical contact
accelerating localized corrosion. For example, the corrosion of the samples with pipes, samples were screwed into Teflon
rate of SS is about 0.035 mm/year when exposed to 75 per cylinder sleeves and placed inside the installation. The
cent phosphoric acid in 550°C, and the concentration of Cl⫺ locations of the test assemblies were right behind outlets of
ions is 8 ppm. When the chloride concentration reaches 23 tanks with asphalt, in pipes of 150-200 mm diameter.
ppm, the corrosion rate is 13 mm/year, which is higher by After exposure was completed, the coupons were unscrewed
three orders of magnitude, making the steel unfit for use in this from the polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) cylinder sleeves and
environment (Kreysa and Schutze, 2004). Furthermore, the washed out and cleaned with a solvent, tetrahydrofurane
high service temperature can have a very negative influence on (THF) in this case. The coupons then were conditioned in a
SS, accelerating the corrosion process and leading to changes solution of corrosion inhibitors of Radiner Fs/Zn (Marcor
in the bulk of steel, such as high-temperature corrosion or Company) to remove possible corrosion products. After being
sensitization to intergranular attack. Austenitic steels with dried in an oven (at a temperature of 50°C for 1 hour), the
carbon contents ⬍ 0.03 per cent C are considered to be samples were weighed on an analytical balance, with a 0.0001
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA GDANSKA At 08:29 22 September 2014 (PT)
resistant to intergranular corrosion, so they are not sensitized g resolution, to measure the material loss. Prior to visual
during exposure to temperatures ranging from 500 to 850°C. inspection, all samples, the reference as well as examined set,
However, steels can be carburized, for example, during were etched in accordance with the ASTM Standard (Jiang
acetylene welding or electrical welding, especially when et al., 2012).
welded places are contaminated with oil or grease, and the The surface topography was examined using a scanning
carburized areas can be sensitized to intergranular corrosion. electron microscope (SEM), model VP-SEM S3400-N made
The complexity of such operating conditions means that the by Hitachi, using tungsten wire as a filament. The microscope
most popular approach to material selection for installations was equipped with an energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy
with aggressive high-temperature service environments is (EDX) attachment (from Thermo Scientific) for elemental
long-term exposure of coupons in the installation. This work is analysis of the surface. This technique has a relatively high
based on the analysis of coupon degradation after exposure to depth at which response signal is registered, making it
gas off-take facilities carrying away asphalt vapors. desirable when examining samples with high roughness.
Detailed chemical analysis was supported by the X-ray
Materials and methods photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) technique using an Escalab
250Xi spectroscope from Thermo Scientific equipped with a
In this work, AISI 321 steel was used due to its high resistance
monochromatic Al X-ray source. High-energy spectra were
to intergranular corrosion. The chemical composition of AISI
realized for a pass energy of 20 eV in constant analyzer energy
321 is almost the same as the composition of widely used AISI
(CAE) mode and an energy step-size of 0.1 eV. A
304 steel. The only difference is that the Type 321 SS has up
monochromatic radiation source with 250 m spot diameter
to 0.7 per cent titanium added to provide resistance to
was used, averaging the elemental composition to the spot
intergranular corrosion.
diameter. An ion gun operating in the 3,000V mode served to
Two identical sets of samples were prepared; each sample
remove a layer of contaminations and for depth profiling.
was 25 ⫻ 13 ⫻ 8 mm3 in size. One set was used as reference
samples and the second set were exposed in the plant prior to
examination. Part of the reference set was subjected to Results
microscopic inspection and the other samples were kept in the For a sample exposed long-term in asphalt vapors at elevated
furnace in 675°C for 24 hours to sensitize them. This temperatures, an average mass loss of cross-section Vp, was
temperature is sufficient for chromium to diffuse to grain calculated according to equation (1). It is a common way of
boundaries and create carbides. A Strauss test was performed assessing susceptibility of metals to general corrosion:
in accordance with the ASTM Standard (ASTM A262-10,
⌬m ⫻ 365 mm
关 兴
2010) to assess the susceptibility of the test material to
Vp ⫽ · (1)
intergranular corrosion. The examined set of coupons was 1000 ⫻ S ⫻ t ⫻ year
exposed to the carburizing environment for two years at a
temperature of 250°C. Before being placed in the where ⌬m is a mass loss during exposition time, S – sample
petrochemical installation, coupons were ground with abrasive surface area, t – time of exposure in expressed in days and –
paper of an increasing gradation from 400 to 2,500 and density of AISI 321 SS.
degreased with ethanol. Each of the examined samples was examined using the
Samples exposed in the industrial installation were placed SEM. The surface of the reference sample is shown in Figure
for two years in a refinery in an off-take facility used to 1(a). The sample subjected to sensitization and Strauss test
transport asphalt vapors. The temperature in the installation looked similar [Figure 1(b)]. The elemental composition of
ranged from 180 to 250°C. Asphalt consists of carbon in ⬎ 80 both; reference sample and sample that undergone Strauss test
per cent and is a composition of many kinds of hydrocarbons. are compared to the normalized composition of AISI 321 steel
In general, the ingredients of asphalt contain parts of different in Table I. Chemical compositions of above samples were
329
Aspects of intergranular corrosion of AISI 321 Anti-Corrosion Methods and Materials
Jacek Ryl et al. Volume 61 · Number 5 · 2014 · 328 –333
Figure 1 (a) SEM micrographs of reference sample and (b) sample after Strauss test ( ⫻ 3,000)
Table I Elemental composition of AISI 321 steel, according to the not take into consideration additional elements. Spectra
standard, reference sample and after Strauss test registered for both points are presented in Figure 4.
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA GDANSKA At 08:29 22 September 2014 (PT)
Elemental composition (% weight) High-resolution XPS analysis was carried out to provide
Reference Sample after further analysis of the chemical states of chromium and
Element Normalized AISI 321 sample Strauss test carbon. The surface was etched with an ion-gun for 10 ks to
ensure maximum possible removal of the passive layer and
Fe Bal 70.17 70.08 corrosion products from the sample surface. Figure 5 presents
Cr 17.00-19.00 18.00 18.01 the XPS spectra obtained for the Cr2p3/2 and C1s peaks.
Ni 9.00-12.00 9.19 9.23
C maximum 0.08 ⬍ 0.1 ⬍ 0.1
Ti 5 ⫻ per cent C-0.70 0.33 0.38 Discussion
Mn maximum 2.00 1.53 1.54 The rate of diameter decrement for the AISI 321 steel samples
Si maximum 1.00 0.78 0.76 was 0.0005 mm/year, which indicates the high resistance of
the steel to general corrosion. As a general fact, consumption
of SS resulting from general corrosion typically is very low.
determined on the basis of EDX spectroscopy, and these did However, the mass loss corrosion rate determination method
not take into account the content of other alloying elements. is inadequate in the case of SS, as the primary forms of attack
Figure 2 presents micrographs of the sample which was are pitting, crevice or intergranular corrosion. These forms of
exposed in the environment of elevated temperatures and asphalt corrosion are characterized by an incommensurately greater
vapors for two years. Pictures made at two resolutions showed decrease in strength and of the physico-chemical parameters
completely different appearance of the sample surface, compared of the alloy than would be estimated on the basis of mass loss.
to the reference samples. In Figure 3, chemical maps of iron, SEM micrographs of the sample made before the exposure
carbon and chromium distribution were compiled, together with as well as of the sample on which the Strauss test was made
the SEM image. Table II compiles the elemental composition of without prior exposure to asphalt vapors [Figures 1(a and b))
AISI 321 steel at a grain boundary (⌬) and within the grains did not reveal any traces of the localized form of corrosion.
(224), as assessed using the EDX technique. The analysis does There was no visible corrosion at grain boundaries; only
Figure 2 SEM micrographs of sample exposed to asphalt vapor for two years (a) ⫻ 500 and (b) ⫻ 3,000
330
Aspects of intergranular corrosion of AISI 321 Anti-Corrosion Methods and Materials
Jacek Ryl et al. Volume 61 · Number 5 · 2014 · 328 –333
Figure 3 SEM image (a) and chemical EDX maps for (b) iron, sample. In particular, areas between the grains were enriched
(c) carbon and (d) chromium for sample exposed to asphalt vapor in carbon, proving the occurrence of a carburization process
for two years ( ⫻ 3,000) on the steel, whereas the chromium content was
impoverished. Locally low chromium content is crucial, taking
into account its input to form a passive layer on SS. The
changes in iron distribution were less readily evident. The
presence of chromium carbides was not observed on the steel
surface. A possible explanation was that due to corrosion the
chromium carbides are loosened and detach from the grain
boundaries. This would be consistent with the depletion of
chromium at the grain boundaries, as observed on the sample.
Detailed analysis of the EDX spectrum (Table II)
confirmed that at the grain boundary, the amount of
chromium was depleted to a level that might not be sufficient
for the formation of a protective passive layer. At the same
time, the amount of carbon present strongly suggests that
carburization of the metal could take place. It is also worth
noting that the amount of titanium at the grain boundary was
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA GDANSKA At 08:29 22 September 2014 (PT)
331
Aspects of intergranular corrosion of AISI 321 Anti-Corrosion Methods and Materials
Jacek Ryl et al. Volume 61 · Number 5 · 2014 · 328 –333
Figure 4 Spectra registered with EDX technique, with peaks marked for the main elements of AISI 321 steel
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA GDANSKA At 08:29 22 September 2014 (PT)
this temperature. However, the significantly higher carbon hydrocarbons to carbon, which subsequently diffused into
content, i.e. about 2 per cent, was measured, increasing the the steel and formed chromium carbides. The presence of
influence of the sensitization conditions. The amount of Ti the sensitization process was confirmed by the XPS peaks
was constant and was approximately 0.4 per cent. It can be for energies corresponding to Cr–C bonds.
assumed that carburization resulted in a decrease in the Elemental analysis proved chromium depletion at grain
relative sensitizing temperature of AISI 321 steel to 250°C. boundaries to a value at which a stable and barrier passive
This temperature, in combination with the pressure vapor layer could not be formed. As a consequence, the metal was
of the asphalt, could lead to anaerobic decomposition of locally unprotected and corrosion cells evolved between the
Figure 5 High-resolution spectra for (a) Cr2p3/2 and (b) C1s after 10,000 seconds of etching with ion gun; 3,000 V (high), CAE 20 eV and
step size 0.1 eV
332
Aspects of intergranular corrosion of AISI 321 Anti-Corrosion Methods and Materials
Jacek Ryl et al. Volume 61 · Number 5 · 2014 · 328 –333
chromium carbide cathodic region and the anodic region at implications concerning intergranular corrosion
the grain boundary. Chromium carbides may eventually phenomena”, Journal of Electrochemical Society, Vol. 140
detach as the region surrounding them is dissolved, No. 12, pp. 3425-3435.
additionally explaining the smaller concentration of chromium Jiang, T., Wallinder, I.O. and Herting, G. (2012),
at grain boundaries and the broad corroded areas in between “Chemical stability of chromium carbide and chromium
the grains. No changes in concentrations of inert elements, nitride powders compared with chromium metal in
such as Ni, Mn or Si, were observed. synthetic biological solutions”, ISRN Corrosion,
Intergranular corrosion occurs even for materials that are Vol. 2012, doi: 10.5402/2012/379697
considered to possess resistance to this type of attack, if certain Kelly, W.K., Iyer, R.N. and Pickering, H.W. (1993),
conditions are met. In particular, the presence of elevated “Another grain boundary corrosion process in sensitized
temperatures and long-term exposure to carburizing agents stainless steel”, Journal of Electrochemical Society, Vol. 140
such as simple hydrocarbons may lead to failures and No. 11, pp. 3134-3140.
premature breakdown of industrial installations. Kreysa, G. and Schutze, M. (2004), Corrosion Handbook:
Corrosive Agents and their Interaction with Materials. Volume 3:
Summary Hypochlorites, Phosphoric Acid, Wiley-VCH, New York, NY.
● As shown for Type AISI 321 steel, exposed for two years in Lopez, N., Cid, M., Puiggali, M., Azkarate, I. and Pelayo, A.
vapor of asphalt at temperatures of 180-250°C, long-term (1997), “Application of double loop electrochemical
potentiodynamic reactivation test to austenitic and duplex
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA GDANSKA At 08:29 22 September 2014 (PT)
333