Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Recent Advances in Nutrition 11
Recent Advances in Nutrition 11
Recent Advances in Nutrition 11
VITAMIN ANTAGONISTS
.,
The recognition of the existence of vitamin antagonists came largely
through the work of Woolley,1 Woods and Fildes. 2 A vitamin antagonist
is a structural analogue of a biologically active compound which induces
signs of specific deficiency disease. The signs of the induced deficiency
disease can be nullified by the administration of the biologic compound
in question. An example is provided by the following: a slight modifica-
tion in structure of nicotinic acid (S03 for COOH), results in an antago-
nistic compound, pyridine-3-sulfonic acid. This compound inhibits the
growth of certain bacteria. The addition of nicotinic acid nullifies the
inhibitory effect of the antagonist.
Vitamin antagonists have been found in natural occurring forms and
many may be synthetically prepared. Certain ferns contain antivitamin
BI 3; certain foods consumed by humans are known also to contain anti-
vitamins of a deleterious nature. For instance, raw clams and certain
kinds of fish such as carp contain an enzyme that has an antivitamin Bl
activity. Fortunately this enzyme is destroyed by heat.
Oxythiamine is a thiamine antagonist recently synthesized. 4 This com-
pound when given to thiamine-deficient animals may prove fataL
Oxythiamine has recently been used in experimental work with polio·
myelitis virus since the latter is known to develop less rapidly in thia-
mine-deficient ani.mals. It is interesting that mice infected with the
virus show less paralysis when they are deficient in tryptophane. The
possibility of using certain antagonists to modify certain viruses suggests
itself.5
The exact physiologic activity of antivitamin El is not known. It may
function in a manner similar to other antivitamins: (1) by inactivating
the specific vitamin (B I ) ; (2) by uniting with this vitamin forming an
irreversible compound and thus render it unavailable; (3) it may com-
petitively interfere with the action of thiamine. 6
Some synthetically prepared antivitamins have a chemotherapeutic
action. Among these are the folic acid antagonists, of whicA there are
From the Department of Medicine and the Nutrition Project, Philadelphia
General HospitaL The Nutrition Project is supported by grants-in-aid from
Swift & Co. an l National Livestock and Meat Institute.
* Associate Professor of Medicine, Temple University Medical School; Chief, Nu·
trition Institute, Philadelphia General HospitaL
1721
1722 MICHAEL G. WOHL
TABLE 1
4-AMINO-PTEROYLGLUTAMIC ACID AND DERIVATIVES
rNyNi-NH2
A--COONR-CHR1-"'N~;
NH2
1. Seeger, Smith and Hultquist, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 69: 2567, 1947.
2. Seeger, Cosulich, Smith and Hultquist, J. Am. Chem. Soc., in press.
3. Hultquist, Smith, Seeger, Cosulich and Kuh, J. Am. Chem. Soc. in press.
4. Mowat and co-workers, in press.
(Courtesy of Dr. T. H. Jukes.)
HOOCH2OH
Pyridoxol
H3 C
N 011 ~ave CHO
vitamin
B.
which Tryptophane
CH 20H HOOCH20P03H2 functions metabolism
activity.
When os 0
HOOCH20H Pyridoxine led, H3 C N --+ necessary Amino acid
>- they ~ port 01 decarboxylation
H3 C
certoin
~ N ore
partially
pyridoxal enzymes
-+ Transamination
phosphate in
converted,
CH 2NH 2
into
(co. decarboxylase )
~
HOOCH20H Pyridoxamine
CH 3
H3 C N
HOOCH20H .. -desoxypyridoxine
H3 C
N because 01 a structural
Some substances
such. as similarity to the vitamin
"- CH 2OCH3 may inhib~ these reactions
HO 0 CH 2 0H .. - methoxypyridoxine
H3 C
N
SIMILAR RELATIONSHIPS HOLD FOR OTHER MEMBERS OF THE VITAMIN B GROUP
VITAMIN COENZYME FORM NECESSARY FOR THE ACTIVITY OF ANTI-VITAMINS
NIACIN Coenzyme I, (DPNI, coenzyme 11, (TPN) Several Dehydragena,e, Pyridine-3-.ul/onic acid
3 acelylpyridine, elc.
RIBOFLAVIN Flavin Phosphale, FAD Several Oxidalive Enzymes Phenazine analog of riboRavin
.... isoriboflavin, etc.
~
PANTOTHENIC ACID Coenzyme A (unknown ,Irudure) Acetylaling Enzyme, Panloyltaurine
phenyl panlolhenone, elc.
Fig. 278.-Yitamin B complex, its functions and antagonists. (By courtesy of Wayne Umbreight and Gladys Emerson.)
172(i MICRAl'jI, G. WORL
REPORT OF CASE
* We are indebted to Dr. Augustus Gibson, of Merck & Co., and C. H. Mann,
of E. R. Squibb & Sons, for the generous supply of B 12 •
RECENT ADVANCES IN NUTRITION 1727
general appearance was that of moderate atrophy. There was a moderate tachy-
cardia and a faint apical systolic murmur. The liver was just palpable at the
costal margin. Minimal ankle edema was present. The physical examination was
otherwise unremarkable.
Neurological Consultation (Dr. A. M. Ornsteen): There are hyperactive deep
reflexes but no pathological reflexes. Sensation and vibratory senses are within
11
10
3 9 60
a
Z.S so
7
6 40
5
1.5 30
4 I
\
I
I
'"\ I
I
\
os 10
I
I
\
I I
• • ,..
-, •.-*' \to,
".--.----.--IIt-.--.-.---.--.--.--.
I "', •
o . ...••,
-'-'-y .
J 'v---",-~
IS ....,....
~% ':
o
Fig. 279.-Hematologic response of patient with pernicious anemia to vitamin
B12 • Note reticulocyte response and elevated uric acid levels.
the normal range. There was no clear evidence of peripheral neuritis or posterior
column lesions.
Laboratory Study: A bone marrow biopsy revealed hyperplastic and megalo-
blastic erythrocytopoiesis. The total plasma protein was 6.4 gm. and the albumin
was 4.5 gm. per 100 cc. The urine was negative and the patient had complete
histamine achlorhydria. Initial blood count revealed hemoglobin of 3.2 gm. and
a red cell count of 660,000 per cu. mm. Two days after the first dose of vitamin
B12 (25 micrograms) the hemoglobin was 2.95 gm. per 100 cc.
Course: On admission the patient had seemed moribund. She was too weak to
sit up or feed herself and she was deathly pale. By the end of the first week of
1728 MICHAEL G. WOHL
therapy, little change was noted. Her food intake had been negligible in spite of
strong nursing encouragement. However, by the second week she began to eat
with more interest; she was now able to sit up and there was a slight increase in
the papillae of the tongue. She progressively became stronger, mentally alert,
cheerful and cooperative. After two months she was clinically but not hemato-
logically cured. During her hospital stay, she received no treatment except fer-
rous sulfate and vitamin B 12•
The essential hematologic data are shown in Figure 279.
Commenl.-Several interesting features are to be stressed: (1) All
three of our cases showed no reticulocytosis upon the second injection of
B12 , although the red cell count was low enough for one to expect some
reticulocyte response. (2) The increase in red cells and hemoglobin began
to decline at about twenty-five days after the intramuscular injection of
25 micrograms of B12 • This would suggest that a single large dose of 25
micrograms may suffice in some patients with pernicious anemia for a
period of from three to four weeks; however, there is a wide variation
in the effective dose in different patients. (3) An extremely high uric acid
blood level (from 10 to 15 mg. per 100 cc.) was sustained for fourteen
days following the first intramuscular injection of B12 • This finding was
noted in the case cited, in which the patient showed pernicious anemia in
the most severe form (Fig. 279). (4) The second of our three patients de-
veloped hypochromic red blood cells as the maturation of erythrocytes
exceeded the available hemoglobin. Supplementary oral iron therapy
corrected the hypochromia (Fig. 280).
AMINO ACIDS
An important phase of protein research has been the development of
microbiological methods for the determination of individual amino-
acids. Such methods, first used for the determination of vitamins, have
recently been employed for the quantitative assay of ammo acids. The
"test" microorganisms used in these assays are the species of Lacto-
bacillus, such as Lactobacillus casei, arabinosis, Streptococcus faecalis,
and Leuconostoc mesenteroides.
We are coming to believe that just as there are vitamin deficiencies
of varying degrees, so too there may be amino acid deficiencies. It is
known that a deficiency of amino acids may develop much more rapidly
than a deficiency of vitamins. The difficulty has been to recognize specific
clinical patterns for amino acid deficiencies in man. A few pertinent ob-
servations are available. Holt and his associates1& have observed that a
few days after subjects are placed on a diet from which lysine has been
eliminated, they develop nausea, headache, dizziness, and abnormal
sensitivity to noise and excrete nonketogenic organic acids. When a
casein hydrolysate containing lysine is substituted for the deficient pro-
tein hydrolysate, the symptoms disappear, but recur when the deficient
hydrolysate is again taken. Three subjects on an arginine-deficient diet
showed, on the ninth day, alarmingly low figures for spermatozoa. When
supplementary arginine was supplied, a prompt rise in the sperm count
occurred, but only after many weeks of normal diet were normal figures
RECENT ADVANCES IN NU'l'RlTION 1729
for spermatozoa restored. Holt has reported that, in growing rats put on
arginine-deficient diets, marked anatomic changes occurred in the testes
as early as the third week. The rats' testicular tissue became so dis-
~
rtr
N
It]
RBC Hb REliC
0/0
0 e • ~
~
I
~
1/1 r.n /0
4.0 12- N N
o. 0
~/~\
J\ lai°
~~\
\I e
3.5 •Ii:>'ct"i
f'-fII.V 'J ,/
/e
10 0-0
o/tI.
/./\o~/e'/ •
3.0 9 /./ \ {loo
?o1 ~_eo
8 ~/TJ
2.5 25 ~IJJ
IV! e
7
•" ~J
~
2.0 6 20 /'
'e, /'
1.5
s
15
n° J.\
VO , I
/
P
I
\\
4 , I \
\
, I \
\
oft.
,
I
1.0 3 10 I \ ,
•,,
..,
.
I
2. ,
I
I \
0.5 S
.,
I
I
lit,
'-
'*lit
•
I
/
e • \'*lIt",""'--"'", "'-Ift-_-liI- ... --"'--.,.
°
/
0 5 10 15 20 ZS 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
DAYS
Fig. 280.-Hematologic response of another patient with pernicious anemia to
vitamin B l2 •
organized after two months that it was hardly recognizable; there was
no evidence of spermatogenesis and the tubules were filled with cellular
debris.l 7
With improved methods for estimation of individual amino acids it
may be possible to determine whether certain disease states are asso-
ciated with a specific pattern of amino acid urinary excretion. For ex-
1730 MICHAEL G. WOHL
vestigators who have observed that hospital patients are often on a low
intake not only of total calories but of protein.
What were the results? Where the patient was able to synthesize
protein and the protein reserves were restored upon adequate protein
supplementation, antibody formation increased significantly.
There was a group of patients in whom the synthesis of protein by the
body was markedly impaired (by disease), as, for example, cirrhosis of
the liver. In these patients the administration of additional protein did
not by itself correct the abnormal blood protein pattern. Clinical im-
provement may sometime occur, however, and interestingly enough
they showed an increased antibody titer upon supplementation.
Another interesting finding arose from this study. Supplementation
with lactalbumin hydrolysate or casein preparation enhanced antibody
formation and partially overcame the subnormal response. But the
improvement in antibody response failed to attain the high titer ob-
served in subjects with normal blood protein values receiving the same
antigenic stimulation. This indicates that, other factors being equal,
patients in normal nutritive balance have the best antibody-producing
capacity. This we believe is a very important point.
A relevant phase of our work is that of antibody response in diabetic
patients. In analyzing a large group of hypoproteinemic patients, we
observed, as others have in the past, that the diabetic patient has a
decreased capacity to form immune bodies as compared with normal
persons. We found that the hyperglycemia is apparently not related
to the decreased capacity to produce antibodies. We further found that,
as expected, diabetic patients with hypoproteinemia showed a lower
average typhoid agglutination titer than those diabetics with normal
blood protein values. Thus the lower antibody level in the circulating
blood may partly be responsible for the recognized susceptibility of
diabetics to infection. Supplementation of these hypoproteinemic di-
abetic patients with lactalbumin hydrolysate or casein concentrate, as
in our previously discussed groups, also enhanced antibody formation 2C
(Fig. 281).
Our work in patients tends to confirm the findings in animals that
protein depletion leads to a lessened capacity to form antibodies. Fur-
thermore, our experience with diabetics is in line with that of Schneider21
that patients with complications (hemorrhagic retinitis) show low plasma
albumin levels. In some patients in whom they succeeded in correcting
the plasma protein pattern by high protein diet, retinal hemorrhages
were either eliminated or lessened. Thus the treatment of diabetic
retinopathy by high protein diet seems to hold some promise. It is sur-
prising ho,' often in our routine laboratory work-up of the diabetic
patient with complications hypoproteinemia is uncovered.
It is now recognized that in time of stress larger quantities of amino
acids should be made available in order to counteract the catabolic loss
of nitrogen. 22 Surgeons have recognized this and are maintaining the
surgical patient on high protein levels.
In the management of diabetes this rule has been generally neglected.
1732 MICHAEL G. WOHL
5000
TVPHOID H AGGL.UTININ TITEF\
4800 IN DIABETES MELLITUS
4600
4400
4Z00
• NORMA~ CONTROL~
•
4000 o CLINIC. DIABETICS GROUP l:
Q C~INIC DIABETICS GROUP 11
... HOSPITAL.IZED DIABETIGS
3800 (PROTEIN SUPPI..EMENTED)
... HOSPITAL.IZ.ED DIA&ETICS
3600 (NON SUPPI..£MENTE.C»
3400
320
Z
0
§3000
.J
ii 2800
rL
bJ 2600
I-
j:
Z400
2
2 2200
j:
:>
~ 2000 0
.,..~
0
"
et 1800
0
%
Q.
>-
"..
I-:
:r ~ ~
J: J:
0 1600
0 d 0 <i
J: Cl.
Q. 1400 0
>-
I-
%
Q.
1200 ~
~
:t
III
1000 ci
SOO
600
REFERENCES
1. WooIley, D. W.: Science 100: 579, 1944.
2. Woods, D. D. and Fields, P.: J. Soc. Chem. Ind. 59: 33, 1940.
3. Weswig, P. H., Freed, A. lVI. and Haag, J. R.: J. BioI. Chem. 165: 737, 1946.
4. Soodak, lVI. and Cerecedo, L. F.: J. Am. Chem. Soc. 66: 1988, 1944.
5. Elvejem, C. A.: J. A. M. A. 136: 14 (April 3) 1948.
6. Wright, L. D.: J. Am. Dietet. A. 23 (4) : 289 (April) 1947.
7. Smith, J. M. et aI.: Tr. New York Acad. Sc. Ser. Il, 10: 82, 1948.
8. Farber, S.: New England J. Med. 238: 787 (June 3), 1948.
8a. WoIlman, I. J. and Githens, J. H.: Pennsylvania M. J. 52: 474 (Feb.) 1949.
9. WooIley, D. W.: PhysioI. Rev. 27 (2): 308 (April) 1947.
10. Fildes, P.: Quoted by Welch, Arnold D.: PhysioI. Rev. 25 (4) : 696 (Oct.) 1945.
11. Rickes, E. L. et aI.: Science 107: 396 (April 16) 1948.
12. Cary, C. A. et aI.: Fed. Proc. 5: 128, 1946.
13. Shorb, Mary S.: Science 107: 397 (April 16) 1948.
14. Ross, J. F. et aI.: Blood 3: 68 (Jan.) 1948.
15. Spies, T. D. et aI.: J. A. M. A. 139: 521 (Feb. 19) 1949.
15a. Wohl, M. G. and Waife, S. 0.: To be published.
16. Albanese, A. A., Holt, L. E., Jr.: Proc. Exper. BioI. & Med. 52: 209, 1943.
17. Holt, L. E., Jr., et aI.: Tr. Am. CoIl. Phys. 58: 143, 1944.
18. Cannon, P. R.: Advances in Protein Chemistry. New York, Academic Press,
Inc., 1945, VoI. 2.
19. Wohl, M. G., Reinhold, J., Rose, S. B. et aI.: Arch. Int. Med. 83: 402 (April)
1949.
20. Wohl, M. G., Waife, S. 0., Green, S. and Clough, G. B.: Proc. Soc. Exper
BioI. & Med. 70: 305 (Feb.) 1949.
21. Schneider, R. W. et al.: Cleveland Clin. Quart. 14: 76 (April) 1947.
22. Cannon, P. R. : J. A. M. A. 135: 1043 (Dec. 20) 1947.