Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JUFGNSM - Volume 53 - Issue 1 - Pages 39-47
JUFGNSM - Volume 53 - Issue 1 - Pages 39-47
JUFGNSM - Volume 53 - Issue 1 - Pages 39-47
https://jufgnsm.ut.ac.ir
Vol. 53, No.1, June 2020, pp. 39-47
Print ISSN: 2423-6845 Online ISSN: 2423-6837
DOI: 10.22059/jufgnsm.2020.01.06
School of Metallurgy & Materials Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran, iran.
1
2
Department of Metallurgy and Materials Engineering, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University, Tehran, Iran.
A B ST R AC T
Zinc based alloys have recently attracted great attention as promising biodegradable metals. Zinc exhibits
moderate degradation rates in biological fluid and the zinc releases during the degradation process
is considered safe to human systems. However, these materials exhibit critical limitations in terms of
mechanical properties for medical applications. Adding alloying elements as well as grain refinement by
thermomechanical processing are considered as effective techniques to address this problem. Severe
plastic deformation (SPD) methods were considered in recent few years to process the zinc-based bioalloys
to achieve acceptable mechanical characteristic while retaining their desired biocorrosion behavior.
Summarizing present literature implied that Mg, Ag, Mn, and Ca containing zinc bioalloys may provide
an improved strength and ductility approaching the common mechanical criteria. However, due to low
melting temperature of zinc, there remains new uncertainties in mechanical response as future challenge,
including low creep resistance and high susceptibility to natural aging at body temperature.
Keywords: Zinc alloys; Severe plastic deformation; Microstructure; Mechanical properties
In recent years, two strategies have been in Zinc, it may easily constitute intermetallic
employed to improve the mechanical performance particles during casting, which render the Zn-Mg
of pure zinc, including alloying with other elements alloys as age-hardenable materials.
and thermo-mechanical treatments. A remarkable Aluminum is the most commonly used alloying
increase in strength and ductility could be element in current Zn alloys available on the
attained in Zn-based materials through alloying market. Zn-Al alloys are also the most documented
addition such as Mg and Mn [11]. However, grain Zn alloys in literature and they are designed for
refinement through TMP processes is considered inexpensive structural and decorative parts in
as more effective promising way in this regards. automotive, electronics and household sectors.
Modification on thermo mechanical treatment Aluminum is recognized as a neurotoxin which
enables obtaining fine grained microstructures as causes cognitive deficiency. However, Bowen et al.
well as optimizing other strengthening mechanisms [20] pointed out that, considering a potential Zn-Al
such as precipitation hardening [12]. Outstanding alloy stent, the absorbed daily dose of Al would be
refining of grain size requires, application of extreme far below the recommended value for humans.
value of plastic deformation on material[13]. Copper is a nutrition element for human
Accordingly, a possible avenue for microstructure health, which serve as an essential precursor for
refinement of metals is severe plastic deformation development of connective tissues, nerve coverings
(SPD), which has been widely used to fabricate and bone growth [21]. Therefore, trace Cu addition
ultrafine/nano grained metals and alloys through in Zn-based alloys would be of great advantages.
introducing a large plastic strain into a bulk Copper has a moderate solubility in Zn (2.75
metal. A variety of SPD methods, such as equal wt.% Cu in Zn at 425°C). As-cast Zn-Cu alloys are
channel angular pressing (ECAP), accumulative composed of two-phase, primary ε- CuZn5 dendrites
roll bonding (ARB), twist extrusion, accumulative and η-Zn solid solution. Tang et al [22] conducted
back extrusion have been proved to be feasible to research on Zn-xCu (x=1, 2, 3, and 4 wt%) alloys.
produce sub-micrometer or nanometer sized grains They revealed that as Cu content increases more Cu
in different metals and alloys, e.g. [14-17]. Zn5 phase precipitates.
However, quite rare researches could be found Manganese (Mn) is an essential trace element
in literature dealing with the SPD processing of Zinc with acceptable blood compatibility which can be
alloys. In this work, the SPD trails on Zinc based added in biodegradable Zinc based alloys [23] . On
alloys were reviewed with the focus on the alloys the other hand, Mn by removing the heavy metal
designed and developed for biomedical application. elements has much effect on corrosion properties.
The obtained microstructure, mechanical and Mn has low solubility in Zn (~ 0.8 wt % in Zn at
corrosion properties were summarized. 405°C). In as-cast Zn–(<1 wt%)Mn alloys, MnZn13
phase mainly locates at grain boundaries as a
1. Alloy systems structural component of Zn/MnZn13 Mneutectic
One of the most powerful tools to overcome structure [11].
performance limitation of Zinc is the addition Lithium is reported to be beneficial in several
of alloying elements to the pure metal matrix. treatments such as brain injury, stroke, Alzheimer’s,
Nevertheless, the biocompatibility of absorbable Huntington’s and Parkinson’s diseases and spinal
biomaterial components must be considered, given cord injury, provided that it is kept below a critical
that all elements of the metal alloy will eventually content. Based on clinical experiences, Li is nontoxic
pass through the human body [18]. To date a few in the therapeutic range of 0.6–1.0 mM, while the
researches had dealt with modifying chemical toxic level occurs at 1.4 mM or higher [10]. Li has
composition of zinc alloys. The principal alloying a relatively low solubility in Zn (about 0.12 wt. % at
elements are briefly discussed below. 403°C) and therefore, under an equilibrium cooling
Studies of Zinc alloys as a biomaterials, were condition, for any Li content above 0.12 wt% (within
started from 2011 by Vojtěch [8] who worked on the eutectic range), Li has a tendency to form a
the structure, mechanical properties and corrosion lamellar Zn+LiZn4 eutectic micro-constituent along
behavior of Zn-Mg alloys containing up to 3 wt% the α-Zn grain boundaries [24]. Zn-Li alloy showed
Mg. Magnesium is considered as the most well know good mechanical properties and biocompatibility.
biocompatible and biodegradable element [19]. The results for the Zn-Li alloy at 11 months in vivo
According to very limited solubility of Mg element indicated good biocompatibility.
40
Mollaei N, J Ultrafine Grained Nanostruct Mater, 53(1), 2020, 39-47
Calcium and Sr are well-known essential influenced by SPD processing include the grain size
nutrient elements, constituting major components distribution, dislocation substructure and second
of bone tissue [25]. Ca is the most abundant phase particles. In case of biomedical zinc alloys,
mineral element in human body, which is therefore limited works could be found in the literature with
naturally selected as an alloying element of pure a detailed discussion on microstructure evolution.
Zn and its alloys in order to adjust their properties. The main researches are summarized in Table 1 and
Ca addition can modify mechanical properties reviewed in the following.
and biocompatibility of pure Zn. Sr is known as
an osteopromotive element which can activate 2.1. Grain refinement
osteoblastic cell replication and decrease bone Deformation of zinc alloy is governed by a variety
resorption while stimulating bone formation. deformation mode including basal, pyramidal and
Calcium and Sr have no solubility in Zn and even in twinning systems [33]. At the absence of enough
dilute Zn alloy systems they react with Zn, leading slip systems, twinning is found to occur [34].
to the formation of CaZn13 and SrZn13 intermetallic Accordingly, basal slip operates at the lowest stress,
compounds [6] . Ca and Sr are attractive alloying but contributes only two independent slip systems.
elements for an orthopedic biodegradable implant To achieve a homogenous deformation, according
material. to Taylor criteria, either pyramidal slip or twinning
must operate in addition to basal slip. Pyramidal
2. Microstructural Evolutions slip is thermally activated, and is therefore favored
The main microstructure features which are at high temperatures. Thus, SPD processing of
s−1
1 s−1
℃
s−1
× 10−3 s−1
℃
× 10−3 s−1
℃
× 10−3 s−1
℃
× 10−3 s−1
× 10−3 s−1
× 10−3 s−1
× 10−3 s−1
41
Mollaei N, J Ultrafine Grained Nanostruct Mater, 53(1), 2020, 39-47
Fig. 1- Evolution of microstructure of extruded Zn-0.02Mg with different cumulative AR during drawing process (a) 0% ; (b) 24% ; (c) 97%
(In the boundary misorientation maps, blue lines for LAGB (2° ~ 15°); black lines for HAGB (> 15°); red lines for {1012} twin boundaries) [28].
42
Mollaei N, J Ultrafine Grained Nanostruct Mater, 53(1), 2020, 39-47
Fig. 2- TEM images of the dynamically precipitated phases in Zn grains with (a) low and (b) high
magnifications, and the corresponding SAED patterns inset of (b) [30].
Fig. 3- (a) SEM BSE microstructures of ZnMg [37], (b) TEM images of the eutectic structure in as-cast
Zn-1.6Mg alloy [30].
43
Mollaei N, J Ultrafine Grained Nanostruct Mater, 53(1), 2020, 39-47
ratio of 39:1 with subsequent multi pass drawing its biocompatibility, is one of the main goals
at room temperature. They demonstrated that of metallurgical engineering. The strength and
Mn-rich particles formed at the grain boundaries, ductility of the common zinc alloys are not
where with increasing the Mn content the degree sufficient according to criteria for biodegradable
of grain refinement was promoted through PSN devices. For example it has been reported an ideal
mechanism. biodegradable stent should exibit tensile strength
and fracture elongation exceeding 300 MPa
2.2.2. Pinning effect and 25% respectively and maintain mechanical
Published researches on Zn-Mn alloys implied integrity for 3-6 months [6]. SPD processed Zinc
that second phase particles may play alternative alloys exhibit a wide range of ultimate tensile
role during SPD processing by inhibiting grain strengths and elongations, from 48 to 423 MPa
growth. Guo et al [29] showed that during multi and from 4.6% to ~345%, respectively. The final
pass hot extrusion of Zn-0.5Mn, finer formed on mechanical properties data were given in Table 1.
low angle grain boundaries, may effectively hinder It can be realized that SPD process could effectively
the growth of subgrains. The pinning force as a contribute to strength and ductility of the Zn-
function of dispersion of particles per unit area of based alloys. Moreover, SPD processed alloys
grain boundary is estimated by the following [39]: present superior ductility compared the materials
produced through conventional thermomechanical
3𝑓𝑓𝑓𝑓 treatments. The degree to which SPD process
𝑃𝑃𝑓𝑓 = 𝑟𝑟 (Eq. 1) (1)
improve the mechanical characteristic is dependent
where r is the size of the second phase, γ is the grain on the strengthening mechanisms that principally
where r is surface
boundary the sizetension
of the second phase,
per unit area, γand
is the
f is grain operatesurface
the boundary in the material.
tension per unit area, and f
volume fraction of the second phase. The results reported by Dambatta et al [26] on
is the volume fraction of the second phase.
Dambatta et al [26] reported that the grain size of Zn-3Mg alloy after two pass ECAP revealed that
Zn-3Mg was decreased from about 48µm (as-cast) both strength and ductility increased from 84MPa
to 1.8µm (2-ECAP). The coarse intermetallic phase and 1.3% to 220MPa and 6.3% respectively based on
of Mn2Zn11 crushed into finer MnZn13 particles and tensile curve (Fig. 4). They explained the strength
homogenously distributes during 2-ECAP process of the processed material relying on the grain
at 210⁰C. The pinning effect of the particle could refining effect, while the ductility improvement was
restrict the growth of DRXed grains at the high justified based on the Mg2Zn11 intermetallic phase
deformation temperature. which were crushed and distributed homogenously.
Huang et al [40] obtained the highest ultimate
3. Mechanical properties tensile strength ever reported for SPD processed
Developing high strength and ductility zinc zinc bio alloys. They achieve the outstanding result
alloy with sufficient hardness, while retaining after eight ECAP passes of Zn-1.6Mg alloy.
44
Mollaei N, J Ultrafine Grained Nanostruct Mater, 53(1), 2020, 39-47
45
Mollaei N, J Ultrafine Grained Nanostruct Mater, 53(1), 2020, 39-47
Corrosion in polycrystalline materials is affected accelerated corrosion rate of the drawn wires is
by grain size, however there are contradictory related to the presence of the deformation-induced
published data about the relationship between the AgZn3 precipitates, which enhance micro-galvanic
grain size and the corrosion resistance, claiming coupling. Because the depletion of Ag from the Zn
that depending upon the ability of the environment matrix, the corrosion potential between diluted
to passivate, materials could experience an increase Zn matrix and precipitates is reduced, however
or decrease in corrosion resistance with grain previous studies demonstrated cold working in
refinement [44]. If corrosion progresses by active all metallic materials impairs corrosion resistance
anodic dissolution, grain boundaries will accelerate due to strain-induced crystalline defects, such as
the corrosion rate. Dambatta et al [26] claimed dislocations and twins. Present literature involves
uniform distribution of intermetallic phases contradictory results in this regards, while quite rare
after ECAP processing cause lower corrosion studies about the corrosion behavior of ultrafine-
rate of corrosion decreasing from 0.25mm/ grained zinc alloys were reported. Therefore,
year to 0.18mm/year but on the other hand, fundamental understanding of the corrosion
with increasing the number of passes, Zn-3Mg behavior as well as contributed mechanisms the
samples corrode faster (0.19mm/year) due to mass main challenges in this area which are yet to be
transport in solid phase such as diffusion of ions addressed.
through oxide layers. Indeed, grain boundary is
well known as a place where impurities and solutes Conclusion
are dissolved. Some impurities and solutes act as Zinc and its alloys serve as the next generation
effective cathodes, and accelerate the corrosion rate of temporary medical implant devices. However,
significantly. their insufficient mechanical properties in the
Huang et al [40] indicated that Zn-1.6Mg physiological environment may lead to premature
ECAPed samples have not obvious difference in failure of medical devices. Preliminary research
passivation behavior of the film surface with the evidences have proved that the drawbacks are
as-cast one while the corrosion rate of ECAPed tunable through combinations of different alloying
alloy showed a very small increase. However, they elements and SPD processing conditions. Adding
claimed that the SPD process could significantly the alloying elements Li, Ag, Cu and Mg can result
improves the mechanical properties despite in high strength as well as improved ductility
maintaining corrosion resistance. The corrosion in SPD processed zinc alloys, while preserving
behavior of a binary Zn-4.0Ag and ternary Zn- the biocorrosion rate. SPD methods may assist
4.0Ag-xMn (where x=0.2-0.6 wt%) alloys after in overcoming the limitation through grain
severe extrusion at 310 °C and then wire drawn at refinement, particle strengthening, PSN, particle
room temperature were investigated by Mostaed pining, twinning mechanisms. There remains large
et al [32] . They showed that cold drawing alloys room for improvement in mechanical properties of
exhibited ultrafine-grained structure along with zinc alloys to deal with uncertainties including low
a dynamic precipitation of nanosized AgZn3 creep resistance, high susceptibility to natural aging,
particles. An immersion test showed that the and static recrystallization at body temperature.
References
1. Bornapour M. Investigation of new biodegradable Review Paper. Metals. 2017;7(10):402.
magnesium alloy with improved biocorrosion, biocompatibility 6. Mostaed E, Sikora-Jasinska M, Drelich JW, Vedani M. Zinc-
and mechanical properties for use in temporary cardiovascular based alloys for degradable vascular stent applications. Acta
stents (Doctoral dissertation, McGill University). biomaterialia. 2018;71:1-23.
2. Seitz J-M, Durisin M, Goldman J, Drelich JW. Recent Advances 7. Bowen PK, Guillory RJ, 2nd, Shearier ER, Seitz J-M, Drelich
in Biodegradable Metals for Medical Sutures: A Critical Review. J, Bocks M, et al. Metallic zinc exhibits optimal biocompatibility
Advanced Healthcare Materials. 2015;4(13):1915-36. for bioabsorbable endovascular stents. Mater Sci Eng C Mater
3. Moravej M, Mantovani D. Biodegradable metals for Biol Appl. 2015;56:467-72.
cardiovascular stent application: interests and new opportunities. 8. Vojtěch D, Kubásek J, Šerák J, Novák P. Mechanical and
International journal of molecular sciences. 2011;12(7):4250-70. corrosion properties of newly developed biodegradable
4. Peuster M, Hesse C, Schloo T, Fink C, Beerbaum P, von Zn-based alloys for bone fixation. Acta Biomaterialia.
Schnakenburg C. Long-term biocompatibility of a corrodible 2011;7(9):3515-22.
peripheral iron stent in the porcine descending aorta. 9. Čapek J, Kubásek J, Pinc J, Drahokoupil J, Čavojský M,
Biomaterials. 2006;27(28):4955-62. Vojtěch D. Extrusion of the biodegradable ZnMg0.8Ca0.2 alloy
5. Katarivas Levy G, Goldman J, Aghion E. The Prospects of – The influence of extrusion parameters on microstructure and
Zinc as a Structural Material for Biodegradable Implants—A mechanical characteristics. Journal of the Mechanical Behavior
46
Mollaei N, J Ultrafine Grained Nanostruct Mater, 53(1), 2020, 39-47
47