Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kamalluariffin 2016
Kamalluariffin 2016
Kamalluariffin 2016
com
ScienceDirect
Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 – 165
!"
$& :
"
" ) + "
) "
" "
)
+ !0-4 + " 5 $%
/&
%
; < !"
$&
)$
" %
+ "
% 1 % :
1 $& "
%
) ) "
)
<1 )%&1 + !
) ) + "
%
) " =$ %$
&
;"
$ "
) )
" ) ; +
- %
"
$& : ) " $ " !0-4
%
%
" $
+
";
) #%
/
& > !"
$& % +& "& $ " & %&
+
" +
"
++ "& "" : " " )
$ % $
))
) " " " %
=$& ) !"
$
" "
+) +
" % " % !0-4 %$
"
% " + )
1 )%& +
"
"
:
1 "+" )%&
+
& & + $
?1 "
$
" "
+) )) % " +" )
@
)
< " !0-4
© !" #$"
$%
" %&
'(
2016 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
$
%& ) *
!+ ,
Peer-reviewed under responsibility of Universiti Tenaga Nasional
&%'
(0 +A !
A 0 +
9 0
+ $" !B 5C A ):B 5C
)*()""D$$&
2212-5671 © 2016 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-reviewed under responsibility of Universiti Tenaga Nasional
doi:10.1016/S2212-5671(16)00020-4
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 – 165 157
- ) + -4
)$ & ) "
;
;"
&
) ;+ $
%$
" ) ) E
)
"
%$ "
) $& " %
"$+" "
" )) -4 #
"%$+"1 F"
.
6)1 555A G%&1 3& . 4"1 A
+1 4"
. 7"<1 $
$&
" "
" )) "
$
)$ "
?+1 8& . /
1 C
!" +
)$ "
@ -4 %"
"
)
+
%& 7%
2:& # "
& ) )
$
=$& 8 . H+1 >
- /&
1 #<<1 #)) /" 5
" $
+ "
%
"
) + +
&
" $%
$"1 "& &< 5C $%
/&
" 5C ) 5C
" $< %
+ !")1
% " + % "
"
$ ) $+ ) "
)& " =$
)
;"
1
" %&
)
& & ")$
)&+
@ ) +
& ) &
2 ) "
+ 0-4 -4
"
!
) )
) " $+ +$
+ $"
#%
. 71 !"
&
+ " $
)$
) 0-4
!"
%$
" $
)$
) )
& " " + ) "
$
;"
"" %
;"
))& + "
) "
;+
#+ 81 #" -
1 # -
$ 0) $% #$
#-0#1
#$+ 7
' #7' #$+
' #' " +<
)
" =$ %$
) + $
!"
% %& " #7' *
7
"
)
+<
) " 7 ) #$+
0
!"
" ; )
" $ ) $
#
/&
1
" '$
/&
& ) + "$+" "
) 0" 0" 5 ) "
E
+ 4=$
) '$
/&
7$
'" 0"#" . #%1 >
'
7
$& 1
%
) " "
)
$+ ) " $
;
!"
%$
" $
"
) ""
% ) " %+ 8
"
) + $+
1
& ) - 1 "
+" "
+ " $ )
" $
$
"& $ "
& ")&& =$& )
<
/
& >
$&1 "
"
+&
@ %
" $
" "" )+
"
$%
" "
))
;"
$ " ;+ +"
- 1 "
$
" " C5 ) "
" +
) )$$ ++
""
" "
) +
& %& $+
;"
" "
+$& /"1 ) #%
7
#%
/
& >
$&1
" *8 -
"
" ) +
+ " )=$& )
158 Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 – 165
$
" ) ) " %
1 +
$
+
=$
) %
$ I !" )$ ) $ %
@
) ) % %
"
; " )
"
) " "& &+
'
1
+
+ "
" "&
@
) &
) " "
) "
" =$
33
6
,
4 5
<
/
& >
$ ;& )
" )) "
) +
!0-4 %& "
+&
" 0 #: 7;
:"+ !" !0-4
$
"$+" " $
1 $
" 1 ) )$$ )
1 "
"
) " ' C1 G& ?;J" C "++ 6+") 555
$&@
$
<
/
& >
$&1 "& "
) "
" +" )$
" !0-4
$"
&
<1 & ) %$
&1 )%&1 + "
)$
+ "
""
"
$$1 $&1 %
"
< ) % )
!"
"
+" " )) " ; %& )
$ " %
)
) " )+
1 "& : " " & ) %$
1 )%&1 +1
$ )
"
1
&
<1 =$&1
"
$$1 )
+
1 %
%
<
&
" !0-4 '$1
)$
$ "
" % !0-4 " "
%
$"
$ )
"
1 +1 )%& $&
< .
/
&1 >
# $
$& %
-
"
%& #%
/
& > "
) %
"
$$ " !0-4 " " !0-4 ";
) " #%
1 7 '& C $
$& !"& : ) + "
$
" )
) "
)
%
$"
% 1 $&1
"
$$
1
<1 )%& $ )
-
" " !0-4
& " " % )
@
") :$ )) 0
2
" !"&
)$ " +
)
+ " $
" %
'
" )+
1 "&
$++
" %
"
$$ )$ )@
!0-4 %" !"
)+
" "
+)
" ) "
) "
) &
<
"
$$ " " !0-4
373
%
%
" "&
1
%
+ "
"
) "
""
"
""
#+& "& ) "
" % " " + " " +
)
@
%") ")
) "
;+ $"& % "
" + F
. /;+1 5- 1 " "
$&+ +& "& "" "
+
A " :
$ %& " " $$
$
%& " +1 %+
A "
:
$
$ " +
& $
" + " @
$
"" $ $ " + %+
" " +
) "
" +
" @
!")1 +&
%$
) " )+
)
""
1
+
% "
+< F
. /;+1 5
$ " )
&&
!")1 " +
" ) $&
$ ) + $ "
)
&& !"
"&
$
" % "
""
"
" & " :$
0
2 + " $
" & "%& "
+
" $& )$) " %+
:<+
""
K " !" +
+
;+ $"&
" " %$
1 "&
+ $ ;+
!"
"
$& "
""
" ) " ) " & !"
$ %& #%
7 555
$& " "
" " +
) "+" )%&
)
"
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 – 165 159
383
%
7++ "&
%
" " )
$ % $
)) "
) "
%
"" =$& ) *
$&1 "
" " =$&
) )
) " $
0 /
555
: " "
$ " "
"+& ) " $
+ ) &
"+" =$& "$
" ) $&
$ " $
'
1
++ "&
$++
"
" "+" )%& & "
) +
+
"
++ "
@ )%&
$ +
$ )
2&1 E
.
"1 I1
"
" ) "
/
. 1
C
73/3
!"
$& :
"
" ) + "
) "
"
)$ "
) + !0-4 )
'$
/&
"
%
; < !"
"
$ "
" %
&
$
" %
!"
@ $ :
) " '$
/&
%
"
@ %
&<1
"
$
) % "
,"
1 " )
"
"
$ ") " )
& 5
733
I -
"
&@
;
"
M
C -
"
) $ ) "
;
"
M
-
"
) " %
M
G " =$&
" & &M
G
" & ) )$$ )
M
> G
" & " +
) " )$$
++
1
1 M
5 G
" $
%& " &M
=$
1
" $
" :
"
" =$
M
!" % ""
!0-4 ) "
&
: + !% %
" ";
) "
) #%
/
& >
<
/
&
>
" & : $ N@ ) ) "
)$
%
N@ ) &
) "
)$
%
) " &
" %
#%
.
/
&1 > #
) " ""
"" "
;
"
1
$ %&
+
" N@ L &1 N@ L ) "
" " : ) " '$
/&
@
%
7373%
!" %
$ %
" ) :$
"
#%
. 71 #+ F
/;+ 51 :$
" %
"
"
) :$
$ "& +"
" $
%" !")1 " :$
%
" % "
" "
:$
"+ %
@ ))
?)) . 0;1 ,"
1 3$ E$+ C
: " ?+ 8+
)$ " "
+
" % "
$&
$
!"
$&
"
+ /; I
$& %& $
+ 7+ )
#%
7 "" : " *8
?1 "
$& )
#%
/
& >
$ " )
"&"
"
" "
" % " % !0-4 '
1
<
/
&
$& >
)$ "
"
" % " !0-4
"+" )
" & )
" %
!")1 " )
"&"
%
A
/(
9' 9
"%
3
G
" " "+" : ;+ ) " +<
&
;+
) G"&1 E . 1 55 #%
7 : "
+ )
) "
) "
)
+ !0-4 " *8
"
E 7;
:"+ E7
!"
$& )$ " "
+ "
""
% : "
" " !0-4
%
"
:
) + + +"
) :$
& 0-4
?1 " :
) + +
" +" )
" "
" =$& ) ) "
$ !"
$&
$
" "&"
)
A
(
9'
'
"%
3
9(
9'
'
"%
3
#+ #%
7 1 $& $
" " ") :$ ))
0
2
" ) " % )
?)) 0;
" "
) "
$ %& " +& "& ) ";
%
" +@
) 3$ E$+ C )$ " 0
2 $&
" $&
$
!")1
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 – 165 161
0%$& 0 4 55 " " +
"$
" ) 0
2 "
" ) " % )
$ %& #%
7 2" #%
7
$&
" " +
" % " $&
) + *8
#%
/
& >
$& " )$ &
+)
" %
" $& !0-4 -
"
-
+&
1
<
/
& > )$
" " $&
+&
" " !0-4 !")1 " "&"
%A
7(
9'
%'
"%
3
! "##+
<
/
& >1
<
"
% + " : )
$ /
I
" " & &
+ "
< )
$"
&1 $1 $% ) &
& '
% + " +
& % %
) ;
) "&
) O1 H+ 0" C
:
" % " ) + )
< )$ " "
" !"
$ +
;& $
) "+& -! "
) + "
" + ) & ) ?))
4
" )$ " " $&
$ " + /&
" )
< "$
" # 7"1 /" ?
& . /$
)
$& 5 " " )
<
)
) %" - )
$
%& /&
- 1
"
$& "
$ "
" % " )
<
) +
!0-4 :1
<
/
& > : " )
< !0-4
+&
)$ "
+)
" % " %
!" "&"
)
A
8(
9' #'
"%
3
$
% #"1 '+
1 / 7)?
" )%& " : )
$&
$ % : )
!" )
" )% )
)
" + $ ;
" "
@ ) "
$
"
+
+ !"
)% )
) : "
) " ) " +& !")1
++ "& #&1 7 ?$
&
$&
$++
" )%
"
)
+ "
++ " )
@ )%&
" "& & $
$ +
)
2& 1 I
"
/
. 1 C /&
$
$ " "
" % " )%& "
$
/
.1 CA 2& 1 IA O 1 CA /& . #7"1
"
$
) G%& 4"1 -
" "
"
<
/
& >
" "
" % " )%& !0-4
+&
"
)+
$
" "&"
%A
0(
9'
9%'
"%
3
'
<
/
& >1 + )
" $
) )
$
$"
%
% )$
" $ =$& !"
""
"
+ "
)
@ ) %& -
1 A E . 31 A 2& 1 IA O 1 C !"
%$
"
" " "+" +
%
)& "
@
%& $%
"+ % )
" %
$ "
" "+" ) " %& & %
/"1 O C
% " " +& "& "
% $
: " +
$
" !")1
" + $ ;& $&
" ) " -
+ "
162 Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 – 165
))
) "
+ " %& )
& %
!"
)) +"
% $ )
$%
=$& $ " +&
"$+" " $ )
:
+"
" "
) ) " - -
1 '
1
<
/
& >
" "
" % " + !0-4 "" "&"
%
% A
(
9' '
"%
3
&
833"5
%
!% C 0))
7<
*
< 0))
0& 7
/ 0))
7+
' 7
' ! (-
0
5 IC
' - I 5C IC III> C C
#+ ) G
I 5 C CC
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 – 165 163
!" )
"
: "
" % " %
)
+ !0-4 " !% C %1
$
" " " %
"
+)
L IIC1 L " !0-4 !"
: " "
+) +
"
% " % !0-4 ?1 ?
$ !"
$
" $
$&
) 3$ E$+ C "" : " ?+ 8+
+ /; I
$& "" $
7+ )
,+
"
" " "+" )
%
& $& + !"
& % $ " "+" $% )
+"
& $+ ) "
@ %
"$
$+ "
)
+ " )$$ )
&
+ . /;1 I
7 %J
: " % : ""
) + + )
+" )
%&
" !0-4 !"
$
" !% C
" ) " + )
L 1
L !"$
1 ?
$ !"
$ %
" #%
7
$&
"
" " "+" + + )
"" "+" :1 " &
+ )
!" :
& ; $
) " :
" "+"
+ ) + " + ))&
% % %
%& ;
$ " " &
)
% " $
" - #%
.71 G
"1 ) " !% C1
"
" L 1 LCC % " +" )
" !0-4 "$+" "
: +
+ !"$
1 ?%
$ !"
$
" " #%
7
$& ?1
" + " "
%
" " % +" & " "
& "
%) %& &+ "
) 0-4
!" "
"
: " $& !0-4 !"
$ ) !% C " "
" % " %
L 1 L
"
!")1 ?I
$ #%
/
& >
$&
" "
$
"&
)$ &
+)
" % " $& !0-4 -
"
,
"
" "
))
) $& "
) 0-4 $"1 "
) "
"
+" % %" ) "
" 0
2 $ "" "
%
"
" "+ "
% ;
$%
""
#<1 5
$" %J ) "
$&
: % " )
< "" :& %& "
)
!0-4 !"
" %
< !0-4
)$ %
" L CI1 L 5
" + ?1 ?C
J !"
$
"
<
/
& >
$&
"" )$ "
+)
" % " %
+&
< +" + ))
"
) 0-4
%" ) " +
+" $
))$
+ "
0-4
:1 +
+" "
$
+ " ) )
"&
$ +
"
8$ , -<"1 I #
)
1 "& +" " ))$
$
& " %
@
!" ))" %J
: "
" % )%& !0-4 )%& !0-4
"
"
"
L 1 L >I "$
" ? !"
$
"
$
)
<
/
& >1 #" ,+ 8" 55C
"
" " "+" )
& $ & + " $
< .
/
&1 >
"
++ "&
" )% )
)
+ $ ;
164 Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 – 165
" "
@ ) "
$
"
+
+
#" 1 '
1 ,+ 8" 55C
"
" "+" )%&
) )
"& $ " )
$
& " "
$
!"
%J )
$&
: "
" % + )
!0-4 ""
"
%& " !% C L I51 L " )
+) !")1 ?
!"
$
"
" "
$
$"
<
/
& >1 -
1
/& #7" O C
"
" " "
""
"
+ " )
@ ) %& ") "
" " "+" +
%
)& "
@
%& $%
"+ % ) " %
$ "
" "+" ) " %& & %
-
1 A E . 31 A 2& 1 IA O
1 C #+& "&
" " + $ ;&
" ) " -
$&
+ " ))
) "
+ " %& )
& %
G%& 1
'
(
!" %$ ) "
% !" )
%$
"
$&
+
"
)) ) 0-4
" % "
$
&
)
;"
;+ ))
&
)
'
1
:
" $
))
) " %
"
%
"$+" )
$
" % $ & )) $
1 "
; )
$& $ /&
" ))
) "
"
)
+ /&
+"
% ))
#
" /&
) + :
$
)
=$
)$ $+ ) %
1 "
+" + %
"
!"
)
%
$ "
+ " $
" )
"
) " " "& &+
& % =$
% !")1 "
& )) "
@
$
"
) " )
-
) "
" %
) " +
!0-4 !"
) " )
" " $ "
) "
& $
)$ " $
&
+ " ; +"
!")1
" " ) " )
"$ % " %
+$& ?1 "
& ) " %
"$ % $ +$&
$
& ; "" " ) " %
% % + " :
%
#%
71 21 ?1 555 !" $ ) $+
$+
$ +$
)
; + $&B !"
)
+& "G !"
1 ?6 *
&1
%$+"
#%
1 21 ?1 71 G1 E1 '&1 71 /1 C 0 + %& '7
7
:
- #$+ 41 >1
>
#%
1 21 ?1 71 G1 E1 0 + "
) + %& *8
F$
) -#$+1 #$+ . !:1 1 I
#%
1 21
/
&1 #1 > !" ) %
"
$$ "
) +
) -
"
/+ IC1 55>
#"1 #1 '+
1 '1 /1 41 7)?
1 /1 !" ) $+
++ %"
"" )
& $+ %
!" #$+ 41 C1 >>5
#<1 G1 1 71 5
)$+ 8$
K - ) + F$ )
#
7
1
1 I
# 7"1 ##1 /" ?
&1 71 /$
)1 /?1 5 G
) )
$
"$+" " - %&
/&
#
4 ) #$+ 1 5
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 – 165 165
#&1 G1 71 F1 ?$
&1 81 G
) +B
)
+& /+ #$+ F$1 1
>
#
"%$+"1 F1 F"
1 81 /1 6)1 !1 G1 555 0 + " - #$+ ?<
1 II1 C
#<<1 #1 #1 #))1 ,1 ,1 /1 /"1 -1 71 5 - ) + /&
- 0) /" E+
0$+ I1 II
'1 81 C + " 7$" #) / #$& 4
"1 1
'
1
1
%1 !1 #
$& $&
$ " -B
) I
$ *
!"
- F$ ) G+ #$+ 4
"1 1
0"#"1 # '1 #%1 7 '1 > #$ & )
B #
) /&
- '$
4
"1 C1 II5
01 '1 /1 /
1 01 E1 555 + " - %& + *8
$ #$+ 41 >1 I
III
G"&1 F1 E1 # 1 G /1 55 !"
)
+ "
) " 0
2B # &
)
; ; $+
0 3B # - 41 I>I
G&1 ?1 ?;J"1 81 C 0 +B #
: %
/+1 1
G%&1 41 4"1 #1
)
) $$
$ !" - F$ ) #$+1 C1
C5>
G%& 41 3&1 31 E1 4"1 #1 !"
) - ) + F$ ) #$+ $% &1 1
II5C
+1 E1 E /;1 H1 !1 I 0 + $& $ F$ ) #$+ $% &1 1 IIC
+1 /1 4"
1 (1 F . 7"<1 71 G
) ) )
%
F$ ) #$+
$% &1 1 II5
<1 #1
/
&1 #1 > !" ) + "
) + %&
+&
/+ IC 1 >C>>
3$1 1 #1 E$+1 71 C '
"1 $
@ :
$&
$ F$ ) #$+ $%
&1 I1 II5
?))1 41 /1 0;1 !1
1 0$$1 +
$ /&
#'#0*71 I>I1 IIC>
?)1 /1 ?1 4
"1 ?1 /1 #1 !"
) $&
$
/&
B !"
) ) + *,-!#4