From: P.B.Rao [mailto:pbrao@eversendai.

com]
Sent: Monday, June 14, 2010 6:57 PM
To: 'S.Ramalingam'; 'Venu Madav'
Cc: 'Kamatchi'
Subject: FW: Pentominium project - Mill calculation for CVN at 0degrees - One beam in grade
HISTAR460 with 34 Joules at -20°C shipped - Eversendai acceptance required
Importance: High

Dear Mr.Ramalingam,

Can you discuss with Mr.Ravi, hyder and see the possibility.

Regards
P.B.Rao

From: Mantho, Theodore [mailto:Theodore.Mantho@arcelormittal.com]

Sent: Monday, June 14, 2010 6:48 PM
To: P Baskara Rao; P.Subramanian
Cc: Sodhi, Gurmeet
Subject: Pentominium project - Mill calculation for CVN at 0degrees - One beam in grade HISTAR460
with 34 Joules at -20°C shipped - Eversendai acceptance required
Importance: High

Dear Mr. Rao,

Please find below the technical reply from AM Luxembourg mill R&D department concerning the CVN
values for 1 piece of beam concerned:

Quote ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The documentation of eurocode EN 1993-1-10 allows to handle this problem.

 
In particular the attached extract (full document on http://elsa.jrc.ec.europa.eu/list_pub.php?
id=94&year=2008) integrates the equation to convert the transition temperature at 27J to another energy
level or temperature.
 
T27J= TKV+41,33-8,16*SQRT(KV-1,373)
 
with T27J=-20°C (conservative hypothesis knowing that the average measure on the beam at -20°C is
35J)
 
the equation leads for a temperature TKV of 0°C to an energy KV of 55J.
 
In conclusion the criteria of 47J at 0°C is satisfied by this product.

Unquote--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Attached you have also the document which they refered.

If required, than additional testing can be done to prove that the material has a CVN value superior of
47J at 0°C.

Please advice ASAP as the material will arrive today or tomorrow at the port in Dubai.

If required I can also discuss this matter directly with your client and the consultant.

Best regards / Meilleures Salutations

 
Théodore Mantho PhD MSC | Technical Sales Manager
ArcelorMittal
 
PROJECTS I Middle East
 
Dubai Steel Trading Company LLC (ANC Compound)
P.O.Box 8386,
Al Quoz Industrial Area 4
Dubai, UAE
 
T +971 4 347 44 11 ext. 229 | F +971 4 347 25 21 | M +971 50 45 45 803 |
W www.arcelormittal.com/projects | E theodore.mantho@arcelormittal.com

From: Mantho, Theodore

Sent: Monday, June 07, 2010 8:37 AM
To: P.Subramanian
Cc: 'P Baskara Rao'; Sodhi, Gurmeet
Subject: RE: Reminder 2: Pentominium project - One beam in grade HISTAR460 with 34 Joules at -20°C
shipped - Eversendai acceptance required

Dear Subra,
 
There is no explanation in your e-mail.
 
Can you explain more in detail the reasons of refusal from the consultant?
According to the Sales Contract as I expplained below, this beam is Ok.
 
If required we can arrange a conf. call with the client for explanations.
 
Waiting your feedback.
 
best regards
Theodore

From: P.Subramanian [mailto:psubra@eversendai.com]

Sent: Mon 6/7/2010 6:36 AM
To: Mantho, Theodore
Cc: 'P Baskara Rao'
Subject: FW: Reminder 2: Pentominium project - One beam in grade HISTAR460 with 34 Joules at
-20°C shipped - Eversendai acceptance required

Dear Theo,
Good Morning.
            Here I have forwarded the projects comments about the beam. It seems that we are not in the
position o use this beam.
Please arrange the required beam as early as possible.
 
Thanks & Regards
P.Subra

From: Kamatchi [mailto:kamatchi@eversendai.com]

Sent: Sunday, 6 June 2010 10:33 AM
To: P Subramanian
Cc: 'PB Rao'; 'Venu Madav'
Subject: FW: Reminder 2: Pentominium project - One beam in grade HISTAR460 with 34 Joules at
-20°C shipped - Eversendai acceptance required
 
Dear Sir,
 
As per the Consultant instruction, the below mentioned Histar column (HD 400 X1086 -12.9M -1No)
required as per our project Specification.
 
So we request you to arrange the above mentioned columns by 1 st Aug 2010.
 
This is for your kind information & action please.
 
Thanks & regards
 
K. Kamatchi
 
 
  
From: "Mantho, Theodore" <Theodore.Mantho@arcelormittal.com>
Date: Sun, 6 Jun 2010 10:18:41 +0400
To: P.Subramanian<psubra@eversendai.com>
Cc: Sodhi, Gurmeet<Gurmeet.Sodhi@arcelormittal.com>; Kaushal,
Rajesh<Rajesh.Kaushal@arcelormittal.com>; PB Rao<pbrao@eversendai.com>
Subject: RE: Reminder 2: Pentominium project - One beam in grade HISTAR460 with 34
Joules at -20°C shipped - Eversendai acceptance required
 
Dear Subra,
 
Any news from the client?
 
best regards
Theo
 
From: P.Subramanian [mailto:psubra@eversendai.com]
Sent: Monday, May 31, 2010 1:13 PM
To: Mantho, Theodore
Cc: Sodhi, Gurmeet; Kaushal, Rajesh; 'PB Rao'
Subject: RE: Reminder 2: Pentominium project - One beam in grade HISTAR460 with 34 Joules at -20°C
shipped - Eversendai acceptance required
 
Dear Mr,Theo,
            As I explained we have to get the approval from client. We have already raised RFI to them. It will
take minimum 4-5 days. We will send detail immediately once we received from client.
 
Thanks & Regards
P.Subra
 

From: Mantho, Theodore [mailto:Theodore.Mantho@arcelormittal.com]

Sent: Monday, 31 May 2010 10:50 AM
To: P.Subramanian
Cc: Sodhi, Gurmeet; Kaushal, Rajesh
Subject: Reminder 2: Pentominium project - One beam in grade HISTAR460 with 34 Joules at -20°C
shipped - Eversendai acceptance required
Importance: High
 
Dear Subra,
 
Can we have your reply for the request below?
 
We have the problem of the documents to prepare (avoiding demurrage charges).
 
Knowing your urgency of the project I wuld appreciate your prompt feedback.
 
 
best regards
Theodore
 
From: Mantho, Theodore
Sent: Sunday, May 30, 2010 10:56 AM
To: 'P.Subramanian'
Cc: Sodhi, Gurmeet; Kaushal, Rajesh
Subject: Reminder: Pentominium project - One beam in grade HISTAR460 with 34 Joules at -20°C
shipped - Eversendai acceptance required
 
Dear Subra,
 
Any feedback from your technical department?
 
We need a quick reply as we need to prepare the shipping docs. (if it is acceptable from your client) and
avoid demurrage charges.
 
 
best regards
Theo
 
From: Mantho, Theodore
Sent: Wednesday, May 26, 2010 3:49 PM
To: 'P.Subramanian'
Cc: Sodhi, Gurmeet; Kaushal, Rajesh
Subject: Pentominium project - One beam in grade HISTAR460 with 34 Joules at -20°C shipped -
Eversendai acceptance required
 
Dear Mr. Subramanian,
 
As discussed over the phone the material produced for Pentominium Tower project has higher charpy
values.
Instead of "HISTAR460 with 47J at 0°C" the mill certified the material for the grade "HISTAR460 with 40J
at -20°C".
This grade is better, because the values of Charpy test for 0°C are much higher (in general they are 20J
higher compared with the values at -20°C as per Eurocodes formulas).
On the other side there is no impact on the values of the tensile strength.
 
Only one beam is not exactly as the required grade "HISTAR460 with 40J at -20°C" (loaded also in the
vessel Lavender).
The grade of the material is HISTAR460 with 34J at -20°C.
For this beam the tensile strength is fully complying, but the value of charpy test is 34J at -20°C.
If this value of the test would be calculated (tested) at 0°C, than it will be higher - approx. 54J. This value
again is higher compared wit the value for the grade ordered "HISTAR460 with 47J at 0°C".
The size concerned is HD400x1086. The length of the beam is 12.90m (only one piece of HD400x1086 in
this vessel with this length).
Attached it is the MTC for this beam for your checking.
 
Can you check with your colleagues of the design and confirm this size as well for your project?
As per ISO requirements in case that one of the values is not matched, the matter should be discussed
with the customer.
 
We appologize for this mistake which however does not affect the values of the material ordered as per
our Sales Contract.
As per MTC's already provided to you for the first part of the material delivered, the charpy values are
much higher than required.
The tensile strength values remain the same as per the standard.
 
We trust in your understanding and looking forward to your prompt reply.
 
 
Best regards / Meilleures Salutations
 
Théodore Mantho PhD MSC | Technical Sales Manager
ArcelorMittal
 
PROJECTS I Middle East
 
Dubai Steel Trading Company LLC (ANC Compound)
P.O.Box 8386,
Al Quoz Industrial Area 4
Dubai, UAE
 
T +971 4 347 44 11 ext. 229 | F +971 4 347 25 21 | M +971 50 45 45 803 |
W www.arcelormittal.com/projects | E theodore.mantho@arcelormittal.com