Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Progress in Performance Management: Marc Helmold Warda Samara
Progress in Performance Management: Marc Helmold Warda Samara
Progress in Performance Management: Marc Helmold Warda Samara
Marc Helmold
Warda Samara
Progress in
Performance
Management
Industry Insights and Case Studies
on Principles, Application Tools,
and Practice
Management for Professionals
More information about this series at http://www.springer.com/series/10101
Marc Helmold • Warda Samara
Progress in Performance
Management
Industry Insights and Case Studies
on Principles, Application Tools,
and Practice
Marc Helmold Warda Samara
IUBH IUBH
Berlin, Germany Berlin, Germany
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Switzerland AG.
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
With many little strokes a large tree is felled
(Japanese proverb)
About the Book
negotiations. Although the market offers several books in PM, practitioners and
academics stress that these books are limited to organizational performance or
financial performance.
Chapter 2 displays how PM must be part of the corporate strategy. Strategy
phases contain the strategic analysis, choice and implementation. It is important
that PM is properly executed in line with the long-term aspiration and intent of the
organization.
Chapter 3 shows the pitfalls of quantitative and qualitative methodologies in
PM. In many cases, it is recommendable not to rely on either quantitative or
qualitative approaches as both methodologies have weaknesses in terms of data
reliability.
Chapters 4, 5 and 6 focus on the primary value chain functions like procurement,
operations, marketing and sales.
Chapter 4 outlines the upstream value chain or supply side. As organizations are
increasingly shifting non-core activities to suppliers (outsourcing), it is important
that the supply side is managed well performance wise.
In Chap. 5, PM tools in operations are explained. 5S, the elimination of waste and
the focus on value-adding processes are the key success factor for performance
excellence. The chapter ends with the description of lean principles.
PM in marketing and sales is illustrated in Chap. 6 (downstream). This function is
the interface between customers and the demand side; therefore, it is a key activity to
understand customer requirements, which can be transmitted into the organization.
Chapter 7 shows PM excellence models and concepts like the balanced score card
(BSC), quality management systems (QMS), the European Foundation for Quality
Management (EFQM), the Baldrige excellence model (BEM) or the performance to
excellence model (P2EM).
Chapter 8 illustrates important tools that are of practical relevance like macro
(PESTEL analysis) and micro (Porter´s five forces) analyses. PM tools can be used
effectively in industry and service sectors as part of improving performance.
Chapter 9 concentrates on PM in complex projects. Project management has
certain characteristics and is often executed in cross-functional teams. Projects are
time-limited and unique, so that PM plays a significant role in this context.
Chapter 10 outlines financial PM including ratios and financial tools like the P &
L account, the cash flow statement or the balance sheet. This section gives
recommendations for organizations which face financial stress.
Chapter 11 illustrates PM in non-government and non-profit organizations. The
final case study shows how performance can look like in public organizations.
Chapter 12 outlines PM in the area of the support function human resources (HR).
HR has the responsibility to create an environment in which employees and
managers can develop superior performance.
Chapter 13 describes PM in the light of industry 4.0 and artificial intelligence
(AI). The fourth industrial revolution and AI technologies have severe impacts on
global value chains, which necessitates applying specific PM aspects.
Chapter 14 is the last chapter. It describes PM in different cultures and in the
context of international environments.
About the Book ix
Marc Helmold
Warda Samara
xi
Contents
xiii
xiv Contents
xix
List of Figures
xxi
xxii List of Figures
xxv
List of Acronyms and Abbreviations
AR Action research
BSC Balanced score card
BME Bundesverband Materialwirtschaft, Einkauf und Logistik
BT Bombardier Transportation
BVG Berliner Verkehrsbetriebe
CIF Cost, insurance, freight
EFQM European Foundation for Quality Management
FAS Free alongside ship
FOB Free on board
IPO International Procurement Organization
ISO International Standardization Organization
IUBH International University Bad Honnef
JIT Just in time
JV Joint venture
MB Mercedes-Benz
M.B.A. Master of Business Administration
MEP Margin enhancement plan
NCG Non-conformity goods
NGO Non-government organization
NPO Non-profit organization
OET Offer evaluation tool
PESTEL Political, economic, social, technological, environmental, legal aspects
PM2E Performance management to excellence
PO Purchase order
PROF Professor
QCD Quality, cost, delivery
QCDT Quality, cost, delivery, technology
QMS Quality management system
RFQ Request for quotation
ROP Risks and opportunities
SCM Supply chain management
SME Small and medium-sized enterprises
SWOT Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats
xxvii
xxviii List of Acronyms and Abbreviations
1.1 PM Definition
Performance Performance
Improvement Measurement
Performance
Management
collaborate in order to achieve the excellent performance. The key questions related
to performance management are:
1. PM has to be executed over the entire value chain from the upstream over the
operation to the downstream supply chain management.
2. PM is a structural and systematic approach in enterprises and organizations.
3. PM must be coordinated and implemented by top management.
4. PM deals with enterprises, processes, employees, departments and
organizations.
5. PM is using tools, mechanics and procedures necessary to measure performance
(BSC, Audits or EFQM).
6. PM goals and objectives to perform efficiently and effectively.
7. PM goals are relevant to customer and stakeholder expectations.
8. PM goals and objectives are derived from customer’s (and stakeholder)
expectations which are the bases of the strategic mission and vision.
1.2 PM Excellence 3
1.2 PM Excellence
The goal of any excellence initiative and programme must therefore be to achieve
world-class excellence as illustrated in Fig. 1.2. The system, developed by Dr. Marc
Helmold, is similar to the German school grading system (1 ¼ very good, 5 ¼ failed).
Companies usually start as so-called laggards (Level 5) (Helmold, 2019). A laggard
can be defined as organization that falls behind similar companies in the same
industry. The next level is a ‘standard’ performance (Level 4). Standard means in
this context that enterprises have an average performance level in a certain sector.
The next level is ‘maturity’ in performance including some best practices (Level 3).
After the maturity organizations will achieve the ‘industry excellence’ (Level 2)
level. In this level, performance is outstanding within the industry. The last and
highest level is the world-class excellence level, in which organizations are
benchmarks in terms of excellence on a global scale (Level 1) (Helmold, 2019).
4 1 Performance Management (PM) Over the Entire Value Chain
Word class
excellence (1)
Industry
excellence (2)
Industry maturity and
best practice (3)
Industry
standard (4)
Industry
laggard (5)
Transformed resources
Transforming resources
Transformed resources are those elements that are transformed throughout the
operation and organization to produce the goods or services that are its outputs. Cars
are transforming components into final vehicles, or goods are used to produce
consumer goods. Transforming resources are everything that are used to perform
the transformation process. Machines, knowledge or personnel are transforming
elements in this context. Many people think of operations as being mainly about
the transformation of materials or components into finished products, as when
limestone and sand are transformed into glass or an automobile is assembled from
its various parts. But all organizations that produce goods or services transform
resources: many are concerned mainly with the transformation of information
(e.g. consultancy firms or accountants) or the transformation of customers
(e.g. hairdressing or hospitals). The two types of transforming resource are staff
(the people involved directly in the transformation process or supporting it) and
facilities (land, buildings, machines and equipment). The staff involved in the
transformation process includes both people who are directly employed by the
1.3 PM in the Value Chain 5
Many transformation processes produce both goods and services. For example, a
restaurant provides a service, but also produces goods such as food and drinks.
Transformation processes may result in some undesirable outputs (such as nuclear
waste in the example above) as well as the goods and services they are designed to
deliver. An important aspect of operations management in some organizations is
minimizing the environmental impact of waste over the entire life cycle of their
products, up to the point of final disposal. Protecting the health and safety of
employees and of the local community is thus also the responsibility of operations
management. Outputs are the result of the input resources and the transformation
(Helmold, Dathe, & Hummel, 2019). The output types are tangible elements like
products or intangible elements like knowledge or services that will describe the
special requirements in performance management in the service industry. The input–
transformation–output model can therefore be regarded in relation to the key
functions of an enterprise including input, procurement; transformation, operations;
and output, marketing as illustrated in Fig. 1.3. Input factors come from in many
companies and suppliers, so that this part can be named as procurement. The
Input-transformation-output
Supply Demand
side side
Input Transformation Output
Information
technology
Finance and (IT)
accounting
Human
resources Support functions
Supplir
Value chain model
Supplier Supplier
Supplier Customer
Supplier Customer
Supplier Supplier Customer
Services
Customer
Supplier Operations
Supplier Customer
Supplier Products Customer
Supplier
Supplier Customer
Supplier
Supplier
Supplier
Upstream Supply Chain Management or Supply Side Downstream Supply Chain Management or Demand Side
Fig. 1.4 Value chain model. Source: Compiled by the Author, adopted from Slack, Chambers,
Harland, Harrison, and Johnston (1995)
the negotiation process. The human resource department will negotiate with poten-
tial employees in job interviews or with workers council and unions. Other
departments like the finance department or IT department must be involved in
investors, bank or frame contract performance management with IT service
providers. Finally, interactions with auditors, consultants or other stakeholders
require performance management in the value chain (Helmold et al., 2019).
Authors like Schranner, Orbrien or Helmold stress that successful performance
management underlie generic guidelines. The three authors have these principles in
common (Helmold et al., 2019; Obrien, 2016; Schranner, 2009). In parallel to
specific skills (schlagfertig), the elements of successful performance management
are shown below:
The elements like quality, cost, delivery and technical aspects (Q-C-D-T) as
illustrated in Fig. 1.2 (Helmold & Terry, 2016b). Within this classification, the
8 1 Performance Management (PM) Over the Entire Value Chain
Technology Quality
+ alpha
Cost &
Delivery
(Finance)
most important objectives can be defined for negotiations. If, in addition, there are
other goals of interest for one or more negotiation sides, one speaks of the alpha
(Q-C-D-T + α). Alpha is the first Greek letter α in the Greek alphabet and covers any
aspect, which is not in the first four categories like quality, cost, delivery or technical
items (Helmold et al., 2019). Alpha elements can be ethical requirements that the
supplier must meet in order to be able to sell goods and services to a customer. Other
aspects may be personnel elements, staff training or the introduction of special
information systems for connectivity (Helmold & Terry, 2016a) (Fig. 1.5).
For the seller, it is important to take into account the most important purchasing
trends and the necessary requirements. In a survey with purchasing managers and
decision-makers in supplier management, five important trends could be identified
(Helmold & Terry, 2016a). These trends are:
• Centralization
• Internationalization
• Rotation principle
• Digitization (e.g. online auctions)
• Strategic supplier management (Fig. 1.6)
The rotation in purchasing is intentionally very high. Many a buyer does not spend
more than 2 years at his post. Then he changes the category and suppliers with whom
he has business connections. Because otherwise he could build an emotional bond
with the supplier, and maybe not just look at the price. However, distribution on the
supplier side often relies on this emotional bond.
1.4 The QCDT-Plus Alpha Concept in Performance Management 9
Fig. 1.6 Objectives in the Q-C-D-T-plus alpha concept. Source: Author’s own figure
Delivery quality (0-km quality): The delivery quality describes the quality and state
of goods at receipt by the supplying company. Companies are normally obliged
by law or contracts to have sample checks of raw materials, goods or components
that are delivered.
Field quality: If the components have been received and assembled into a machine,
system, automobile, train or plane, the companies will be used by customers and
be in the field. Detection and repair of field defects are more expensive as the
components are usually integrated into a system (e.g. car, train, plane or machine)
and need to be disassembled and to be returned to the maker.
Quality management systems: A quality management system (QMS) is defined as a
formalized system that documents processes, procedures and responsibilities for
achieving quality policies and objectives. A quality management system (QMS)
is a collection of business processes focused on consistently meeting customer
10 1 Performance Management (PM) Over the Entire Value Chain
Costs objectives comprise all costs that are involved in the process of acquiring a
product or service (Helmold & Terry, 2016a). Besides direct costs (purchase cost)
there are indirect costs involved (qualification, set-up of machine). This concept of
considering direct and indirect cost is the concept of total cost of ownership (TCO).
TCO is a financial estimate intended to help buyers and owners determine the direct
and indirect costs of a product or system. It is a management accounting concept that
can be used in full cost accounting or even ecological economics where it includes
social costs. TCO covers obvious costs like recurring and non-recurring costs and
hidden costs that may occur for qualification, storage, warranty or any other process
which is connected to the procurement of goods.
Recurring cost: Recurring cost is the cost for one component. The recurring cost can
also be described as piece price.
Non-recurring cost: Non-recurring costs are costs that occur only once or twice and
not repeatedly. This can be an investment like a machine or an agreed develop-
ment fee that is paid once before delivery of goods.
Escalation: Escalation is annual price increases caused by inflationary elements like
labour cost increase, pay rise, higher energy cost or increased cost of raw
materials.
1.4 The QCDT-Plus Alpha Concept in Performance Management 11
Delivery and logistics costs include the costs of holding goods in inventory (capital
costs, warehousing, depreciation, insurance, taxation and obsolescence) and are
commonly expressed as a share of the inventory value. Labour costs involve the
physical handling of goods, including tasks such as packaging and labelling. Logis-
tics cost can make up to 50% of the actual cost of a component in international trade
(Helmold et al., 2019). International commercial terms are usually used in
negotiations to allocate the responsibilities of maker and customer (Helmold et al.,
2019). New concepts are used like vendor-managed inventory (VMI) in which
suppliers and makers own the inventory before delivery to the customer.
Projects and the purchase of components or goods often include technical aspects,
which need to be part of negotiations. Technical criteria are often negotiated in an
early state and can cause additional cost if not considered thoroughly. Engineering
objectives contain engineering expenses, cost for patents and cost for development,
technical changes, features or engineering budget items (Helmold et al., 2019).
Development and design cost: Development and design costs contain all costs that
are necessary to develop a component or project. Normally, it is estimated in
man-hours or design budget. Man-hours are the hours/days of engineers that are
required for the development of a specified project. The days and hours are
multiplied with an hourly fee of one engineer.
Development services: Development projects and design often involve third parties,
specialists, special devices, engineering programmes, testing or patents, which
are part of the technology objectives in negotiations.
Technical changes: Engineering change can be caused by an immature design or
customers’ requests and impact the technology cost and budget.
Technical options: Technical options can be part of negotiations and are usually
customer requests. Options normally lead to higher functional requirements and
increase the engineering and technical cost.
Design-to-cost initiatives and cost reduction initiatives: Design-to-cost (DTC), as
part of cost management techniques, describes a systematic approach to
controlling the costs of product development and manufacturing. DTC is often
combined with cost reduction ideas of a product without harming or affecting the
functional tasks of the product.
1.5 Performance Management in the International Context 13
Anticorruption Environment
CSR
Labour Intellectual
conditions property
Alpha objectives are all objectives which are not in the Q-C-D-T categories. Alpha
objectives contain mostly ethical or people objectives by the customer.
Ethics objectives: Business ethics and corporate social responsibility (CSR) include
norms and values that corporate social responsibility (CSR) is a business model
that helps a company to be socially accountable to itself, its stakeholders and the
organization. It contains the general norms and values of a company that
companies want to act on, in particular through acting responsibly towards
society. The company translates these principles to employees and other interests
such as suppliers. Ethics policies are often aimed at respecting human rights,
creating sound and safe working conditions, protecting the environment and
promoting sustainable development (Helmold, 2010).
Competency Goals: Competency goals include the skills of employees through a
systematic and structured corporate culture of lifelong learning. Other alpha
goals: Alpha goals are multifaceted and can be developed for negotiation from
a variety of negotiating parties’ motives (Helmold, 2010) (Fig. 1.7).
International trade has changed our world drastically over the last couple of
centuries. In this entry, we begin by analysing available data on historical trade
patterns around the world and then move on to discuss more recent data, outlining
trade patterns from the last couple of decades. In the last section, we turn to analyse
empirical evidence regarding the determinants and consequences of international
trade.
14 1 Performance Management (PM) Over the Entire Value Chain
From a historical perspective, international trade has grown remarkably in the last
couple of centuries. After a long period characterized by persistently low interna-
tional trade, over the course of the nineteenth century, technological advances
triggered a period of marked growth in world trade (the ‘first wave of globalization’).
This process of growth stopped and was eventually reversed in the interwar period,
but since the Second World War international trade started growing again, and in the
last decades, trade expansion has been faster than ever before. Today, the sum of
exports and imports across nations is higher than 50% of global production. At the
turn of the nineteenth century, this figure was below 10%.
In the last couple of decades, transport and communication costs have decreased
across the world, and preferential trade agreements have become more and more
common, particularly among developing countries. In fact, trade among developing
nations (often referred to as South–South trade) more than tripled in the period
1980–2011.
Within the context of globalization, stronger links between some of the world’s
most rapidly growing economies could be seen in 2017 and 2018 as outlined in the
report of the World Trade Organization (WTO) (WTO, 2018). Global trade in goods
and services continued growing above trend in 2017 and 2018 as the World Trade
Organization outlined (Miles, 2018; WTO, 2018). The total amount of good and
services exceeded US$6700 billion in 2017. The forecast for 2018 sees a slight
increase in international trade of goods and services. Over 70% of merchandise
exports are manufactured goods. The top three merchandise traders in 2017 were
China, the USA and Germany in 2017. The top three traders accounted for mer-
chandise exports totalling almost US$5300 billion. Besides merchandising trade,
services are getting more and more important in international business transactions
across borders (WTO, 2017). In 2017, the USA, the UK and Germany were the top
three commercial services exporters while the USA, China and Germany were the
top three importers. The combined commercial services exports of the USA, the UK
and Germany totalled about US$1400 billion in 2017 (Figs. 1.8 and 1.9).
Performance management in an international context is more important than ever
for companies in Germany, considering the trade balance in Germany (Federal
Statistical Office, 2018; Dathe & Helmold, 2018). In addition, the authors Dathe
and Helmold state that internationalization will continue, especially in countries such
as China, Japan or South Korea (Dathe & Helmold, 2018). Looking at imports and
exports in the years 2016 and 2017, one can see that Germany was export champion
in both years. In 2017, goods and goods valued at more than 1279 billion euros were
exported from Germany to other countries (Federal Statistical Office, 2018). The
most important countries for export are the USA, France, the People’s Republic of
China, the Netherlands and the UK (Federal Statistical Office, 2018). In contrast,
goods and goods worth 1034 billion euros were imported. Here again, besides Italy,
the USA, France, the People’s Republic of China and the Netherlands are among the
first five countries. As the Federal Statistical Office (Federal Statistical Office, 2018)
further reports on the basis of preliminary results, German exports were 6.3% higher
in 2017 and imports 8.3% higher than in 2016. In 2017, the highest levels in 2016
were exceeded, when goods worth 1203.8 billion euros were exported and goods
1.5 Performance Management in the International Context 15
NETHERLANDS 85.9
PR CHINA 86.2
FRANCE 105.2
U.S.A. 111.5
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Fig. 1.8 Exports from Germany. Source: Statistical federal office in Germany. Pressemitteilung
Nr.039 vom 8. Februar 2018: Deutsche Exporte im Jahr 2017: +6.3% zum Jahr 2016. Exporte und
Importe erreichen neue Rekordwerte. https://www.destatis.de/DE/PresseService/Presse/
Pressemitteilungen/2018/02/PD18_039_51.html
worth 954.9 billion euros were imported. The foreign trade balance ended in 2017
with a surplus of more than 244.9 billion euros. In 2016, the balance in the foreign
trade balance of 248.9 billion euros had reached its highest level in the history of
Germany. In 2016, the German current account had a balance of 259.3 billion euros.
The foreign trade balance closed in December 2017 with a surplus of 18.2 billion
euros. Adjusted for the calendar and seasonally adjusted, the foreign trade surplus in
December 2017 was 21.4 billion euros (Federal Statistical
Figure 1.10 shows the possibilities of internationalization through own or foreign
resources (Dathe & Helmold, 2018). In this sense, resources are buildings, machines
or installations. If a company decides to produce within its own resources outside the
borders of Germany, this is called international in-house production. Outsourcing
and the purchase of products or services from suppliers is referred to as global
sourcing or international outsourcing (Dathe & Helmold, 2018).
Performance management in the international context is getting more and more
important for companies that produce goods and services. Fierce competition, the
ongoing liberalization and trade agreements between countries force enterprises to
enter new and foreign markets across the globe (Helmold et al., 2019). International
trade has changed our world drastically over the last couple of centuries. In this
entry, we begin by analysing available data on historical trade patterns around the
world and then move on to discuss more recent data, outlining trade patterns from
16 1 Performance Management (PM) Over the Entire Value Chain
U.S.A. 61.1
1
FRANCE 64.2
4
NETHERLANDS 91.4
PR CHINA 100.5
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Fig. 1.9 Imports to Germany. Source: Statistical federal office in Germany. Pressemitteilung
Nr.039 vom 8. Februar 2018: Deutsche Exporte im Jahr 2017: +6.3% zum Jahr 2016. Exporte
und Importe erreichen neue Rekordwerte. https://www.destatis.de/DE/PresseService/Presse/
Pressemitteilungen/2018/02/PD18_039_51.html
Domestic International
Own resources & assets Not own resources & assests
(Buildings, Machines, Equipment)
locations locations
Non core competencies
Offshoring or intern.
National or domestic Buy
outsourcing strategy
outsourcing
Global sourcing
(Buildings, Machines, Equipment)
Core competencies
Offshore operations
National or domestic Make
operations International or global strategy
operations
the last couple of decades. From a historical perspective, international trade has
grown remarkably in the last couple of centuries. After a long period characterized
by persistently low international trade, over the course of the nineteenth century,
technological advances triggered a period of marked growth in world trade (the ‘first
wave of globalization’). This process of growth stopped and was eventually reversed
in the interwar period, but since the Second World War international trade started
growing again, and in the last decades trade expansion has been faster than ever
before.
In the last couple of decades, transport and communication costs have decreased
across the world, and preferential trade agreements have become more and more
common, particularly among developing countries.
Free international trade is often seen as desirable because it allows countries to
specialize, in order to produce goods that they are relatively efficient at producing,
while importing other goods. This is the essence of the comparative advantage
argument supporting gains from trade: exchange allows countries to ‘do what they
do best, and import the rest’.
In 2016, Germany maintained its position as the world’s third largest exporter of
goods (behind China, USA) and third largest importer (behind USA, China).
Germany’s share of world trade (exports and imports of goods in USD) rose to
7.44% (2015: 7.16%). With a share of 11.52% in global trade, the USA was in first
place again for the first time since 2012, just ahead of China (11.45%). The WTO
states that Germany is one of the most open countries in terms of international trade
(WTO, 2018). With a high degree of openness, characterized by imports plus exports
in relation to the gross domestic product (GDP) of 84.8%, Germany is the ‘most
open’ economy of the biggest seven economies (G7 countries) and is becoming
increasingly integrated into global and international value chains (WTO, 2018). As
Germany is highly integrated into global value chains and international trade,
employment in Germany depends on liberal and open markets. According to the
WTO, nearly 30% of jobs in Germany are directly or indirectly linked to interna-
tional trade (WTO, 2018), another good example of growing international trade and
global trade dependencies in China (WTO, 2018). China, in particular, has become
increasingly important as a trading partner for Germany. Between 2000 (1.6%) and
2016 (6.3%), German exports to China nearly quadrupled (WTO, 2018). This means
that in 2016 China was the second most important market for German exporters
outside Europe, behind the USA (8.9%). China’s share of German imports also rose
significantly in the same period: from 3.5% (2000) to 9.9% (2016). China is thus the
most important supplier for the German economy outside Europe (ahead of the USA,
which has share of 6.1%). Internationalization strategies are part of the corporate
strategies and will impact performance management in the international context
(Slack, Brandon-Jones, & Johnston, 2013). Slack et al. stress that internationaliza-
tion strategies can be pursued with own or not own resources as highlighted in
Fig. 1.2 (Helmold et al., 2019). These choices are referred to as ‘make or buy
strategy’ (Slack et al., 2013). If own resources and assets are involved, Slack et al.
talk about ‘international operations’. If companies are not using their own resources
and fixed assets, Slack et al. describe this as ‘buy strategy’. International operations
18 1 Performance Management (PM) Over the Entire Value Chain
Fig. 1.11 The value chain functions. Source: Author’s own figure
(make strategy) are those selected where companies have a competitive advantage
due to superior quality, efficient production, patents, knowledge or any other
aspects. Alternatively, companies decide to use not own resources and assets,
where they do not have a competitive advantage (non-core competencies) (Helmold,
2019; Johnson & Scholes, 1997).
International performance management engages stakeholders and representatives
from different cultural backgrounds (Helmold et al., 2019). If both negotiating
parties have knowledge about the culture of the other side in international
relationships, the performance management can start immediately without intercul-
tural expertise (Helmold et al., 2019). On condition that both or one party has little or
no knowledge about customs, culture and specifics, it is recommended by many
authors to acquire expertise through an expert and trainer (Helmold et al., 2019).
Figure 1.11 displays the options in terms of cultural knowledge of my own organi-
zation (we, knowledge of the culture of the other party) and the other party of the
culture of my organization (they, knowledge of my organization and my culture)
(Helmold et al., 2019) (Fig. 1.12).
Figure 1.13 shows the general managers of the Chinese aluminium maker Midas,
Mr. Li, and the general manager of Bombardier Transportation in China,
Dr. Helmold. The Bombardier Transportation group has long played a key role in
developing China’s urban mass transit and advanced rail networks (Bombardier
Transportation, 2018). Presently, Bombardier is actively transferring our industry-
leading technology and proven management expertise through joint ventures and
wholly foreign owned enterprises. Bombardier Transportation works with several
Chinese partners to provide the country’s major cities with state-of-the-art rail
solutions and services, from metro cars to very high-speed trains (Bombardier,
2018). More than 4000 employees work at four joint ventures and seven wholly
1.5 Performance Management in the International Context 19
Fig. 1.12 International business transactions. Source: Author’s own figure, adopted from Dathe
and Helmold (2018)
Fig. 1.13 General Manager, Dr. Helmold, and General Manager Mr. Li. Source: Marc Helmold
20 1 Performance Management (PM) Over the Entire Value Chain
area by standardized criteria and questions, to define areas for actions and to ensure
the sustainable implementation of the actions and improvement areas.
Assessment criteria in audits are based on customer and stakeholder expectations.
Audits can be clustered in systems, process, product, control and special audits as
shown in Table 1.3.
In the following case study, an audit was conducted to evaluate performance of
the Berliner Verkehrsbetriebe (BVG). The Berliner Verkehrsbetriebe (German:
‘Berlin Transport Company’) is the main public transport company of Berlin, the
capital city of Germany. It manages the city’s metro (U-Bahn) underground railway,
tram, bus and ferry networks. The generally used abbreviation, BVG, has been
retained from the company’s original name, Berliner Verkehrs Aktiengesellschaft
(Berlin Transport Corporation). The BVG has around 15,000 employees in Berlin.
The audit was conducted in four steps as outlined in Fig. 1.14. The audit was done by
approximately 70 M.B.A. and master students in groups of four to six people in
summer 2018 and repeated in the same year in autumn. In step 1, every audit must
start with systematic analysis definition of standardized performance criteria. In step
2, it is important to carry out the evaluation of each category and criteria based on
audit norm and standard. In step 3, auditors will identify deficiencies and deviations
from norm and standard. And finally, the auditors will establish a list of actions
(action and improvement plans) and improvements, which will help the organization
to achieve performance excellence.
In step 1, 10 categories of stakeholders’ importance were identified. These can be
seen in the radar chart in Fig. 1.15. The evaluated categories were:
22 1 Performance Management (PM) Over the Entire Value Chain
Systematic Evaluation of
Identification
analysis each category Establishment
of deficiencies
definition of and criteria of action plans
and deviations
standardised based on audit and
from norm
performance norm and improvements
and standard
criteria standard
Fig. 1.15 Radar chart: PM audit of the BVG. Source: Author’s own figure
Fig. 1.16 Audit results of the BVG performance evaluation. Source: Author’s own figure
In step 2, the auditors evaluated the performance in each category based on their
experience and based on customer feedback. Evaluation was from very good
(10 points) to very unsatisfactory (0 points).
Figure 1.16 shows the average result from summer 2018. The BVG achieved
77 out of 100 possible points, which can be considered as average. In certain
categories (design, appearance, reliability), the BVG overachieves; in other areas
(safety, security, Internet and visibility of staff), it underachieves performance
excellence. As a consequence, the auditors established a plan with actions for
sustainable improvement (Helmold, 2019).
References
Bombardier Transportation. (2018). Bombardier hompage China. www.bombardier.com
Dathe, T., & Helmold, M. (2018). Erfolg im Chinageschäft. Handlungsempfehlungen für kleine und
mittlere Unternehmen (KMU). Wiesbaden: Springer.
Federal Statistical Office. (2018). https://www.destatis.de/DE/Home/_inhalt.html
Helmold, M. (2010). Best-in-class Lieferantenmanagement in der Automobilindustrie. Aachen:
Shaker.
Helmold, M. (2019). Performance measurement and management script (WS 2019/2020). Iubh
University.
Helmold, M., & Terry, B. (2016a). Lieferantenmanagement 2030. Wiesbaden: Springer Gabler.
Helmold, M., & Terry, B. (2016b). Global sourcing and supply management excellence in China.
Singapore: Springer.
24 1 Performance Management (PM) Over the Entire Value Chain
Helmold, M., Dathe, T., & Hummel, F. (2019). Erfolgreiche Verhandlungen – Best-in-Class
Empfehlungen für den Verhandlungsdurchbruch. Wiesbaden: Springer.
Johnson, G., & Scholes, K. (1997). Exploring corporate strategy. Text and cases (4th ed.). London:
Prentice Hall.
Miles, T. (2018). WTO outlook indicator: Global trade growth to stay above-trend. Reuters Online
Article. Retrieved January 28, 2019, from https://www.reuters.com/article/us-trade-wto/wto-
outlook-indicator-global-tradegrowth-to-stay-above-trend-idUSKBN1FW0UP
Obrien, J. (2016). Negotiations for procurement professionals (2nd ed.). Croyden: Kogan Page.
Schranner, M. (2009). Verhandeln im Grenzbereich. Strategien und Taktiken für schwierige Fälle.
8. Auflage. München: Econ.
Slack, N., Chambers, S., Harland, C., Harrison, A., & Johnston, R. (1995). Operations manage-
ment. London: Pitman Publishing.
Slack, N., Brandon-Jones, A., & Johnston, R. (2013). Operations management (7th ed.). London:
Pearson Publishing.
WTO. (2017). www.wto.org
WTO. (2018). Highlights of the world trade 2017. Retrieved January 29, 2019, from https://www.
wto.org/english/res_e/statis_e/wts2018_e/wts2018chapter02_e.pdf
PM as Integral Part of the Corporate
Strategy 2
Marc Helmold and Warda Samara
a direction, a guide, or a course of action into the future. A pattern, which points to
consistency of behaviour over time. A position, which places specific products in
particular markets. A perspective, which refers to the fundamental manner of
accomplishing goals. A ploy, which is a specific manoeuvre intended to outwit
competitors’. Mintzberg provides five definitions of strategy, plan, ploy, pattern,
position and perspective (Mintzberg et al., 1995). Firstly, strategy is always a plan. A
plan integrates intended actions and activities based on previous assessment of the
situation. Secondly, as plan, a strategy can be a ploy too, really just a specific
manoeuvre intended to outwit an opponent or competitor. If strategies can be
intended (whether as general plans or specific ploys), they can also be realized. In
other words, defining strategy as plan is not sufficient; we also need a definition that
encompasses the resulting behaviour. Thirdly, strategy is a pattern. The definitions
of strategy as plan and pattern can be quite independent of one another. Plans may go
unrealized, while patterns may appear without preconception. Plans are intended
strategy, whereas patterns are the realized strategy. Fourthly, strategy is a perspec-
tive. A perspective is not just of a chosen position, but consists of an ingrained way
of perceiving the world (Mintzberg et al., 1995).
Strategic
triangle
Strategic Strategic
implementation choice
2.3 Strategic Analysis 27
Fig. 2.2 Generic strategies. Source: Author’s own figure, adopted from Porter (1985)
2.5 Strategic Implementation 29
high
4. Differen a on
Fig. 2.3 Strategic Clock from Bowman. Source: Author’s own figure, adopted from Johnson and
Scholes (1997)
• Organizational structure and layout: Where and how the organization is split into
European, US and Asian divisions? How autonomous should divisions be? What
parenting style should be applied?
• Resources: Enabling an organization’s resources should support the chosen
strategy: What are the appropriate human and non-human resources? What assets
need to be acquired?
• Change management: Most strategic planning and implementation will involve
change, so managing change, in particular employees’ fears and resistance, is
crucial.
Johnson and Scholes argue that for a strategy to be successful it must satisfy three
criteria (Johnson & Scholes, 1997). These criteria can be applied to any strategy
decision such as the competitive strategies, growth strategies or development
strategies:
2.5.2 Suitability
• Does the strategy exploit the company strengths, such as providing work for
skilled craftsmen or environmental opportunities, e.g. helping to establish the
organization in new growth sectors of the market?
• How far does the strategy overcome the difficulties identified in the analysis? For
example, is the strategy likely to improve the organization’s competitive position,
solve the company’s liquidity problems or decrease dependence on a particular
supplier?
• Does the option fit in with the organization’s purposes? For example, would the
strategy achieve profit targets or growth expectations, or would it retain control
for an owner–manager?
2.5.3 Acceptability
Acceptability is essentially about assessing risk and return and is strongly related to
expectations of stakeholders. The issue of ‘acceptable to whom?’ thus requires the
2.6 Strategic Pyramid 31
analysis to be thought through carefully. Some of the questions that will help identify
the likely consequences of any strategy are as follows:
• How will the strategy impact shareholder wealth? Assessing this could involve
calculations relating to profitability, e.g. net present value (NPV).
• How will the organization perform in profitability terms? The parallel in the
public sector would be cost/benefit assessment.
• How will the financial risk (e.g. liquidity) change?
• What effect will it have on capital structure (gearing or share ownership)?
• Will the function of any department, group or individual change significantly?
• Will the organization’s relationship with outside stakeholders, e.g. suppliers,
government, unions, customers, need to change?
• Will the strategy be acceptable in the organization’s environment, e.g. higher
levels of noise?
2.5.4 Feasibility
Assesses whether the organization has the resources it needs to carry out the strategy.
Factors that should be considered can be summarized under the M-word model.
A useful tool for the translation of the corporate strategy and strategic objectives into
negotiations is the strategic pyramid (Johnson & Scholes, 1997). Strategy in this
context is the long-term positioning as well as the decision of the enterprise, which
32 2 PM as Integral Part of the Corporate Strategy
Mission
Vision
Goals (generic)
ObjecƟves (specific)
Core competencies
Performance strategies
business fields and which strategies to choose. Strategy is therefore ‘the fundamen-
tal, long-term direction of 3–5 years and organization of a company in order to gain
competitive advantages in a changing environment through the use of resources and
competences and to realize the long-term goals of the stakeholders’ (Johnson &
Scholes, 1997). This chapter outlines the elements of the strategic pyramid with
examples of the start-up and consultancy firm MaHeLeanCon, which was founded
by Prof. Dr. Marc Helmold in 2016 (Fig. 2.4).
The mission and vision are followed by generic goals and specific objectives.
Generic goals are not quantified, and more general but specific objectives are
quantified and specific (Helmold et al., 2019). The strategists Johnson and Scholes
distinguish in longer-term and generic (English: Goals) as well as shorter and
quantified objectives (English: Objectives) for the company (Johnson & Scholes,
1997). Quantified goals can include sales, financial, quality, logistics, cost and alpha
goals. Goal example: Lose weight, get healthy, reach BMI index. Objectives exam-
ple: Lose 10 kg by the end of the year, reach BMI index of xyz.
The goals and objectives based on the example of MaHeLeanCon look like this.
Generic goals: Acquisition of projects and subprojects by three (few) key customers
over the next 3–5 years. Subproject A: Supporting an SME entering the Chinese
market through consulting and sales activities. Turnover of 150,000 €. over the next
3–5 years. First acquisition of projects by SMEs. Subproject B: Process improvement
of a global company with the acquisition of subprojects in the field of the upstream
value chain (upstream supply chain management) and supplier quality. Subproject C:
Negotiation training and workshops over the next 3 years. Generation of a competence
centre for negotiations and conflict management. Cooperation with at least five SMEs
and creation of a concept of excellence for buyers and sellers. In addition, other goals
include successfully conducting five to ten negotiation training courses and
conducting intercultural workshops for SMEs and MNC (Helmold et al., 2019).
The next level in the strategic pyramid is the identification of core competencies.
Core competences are those competences which allow companies to gain a superior
or competitive advantage and that are very difficult for your competitors to emulate
(Johnson & Scholes, 1997). These describe the resources, skills, knowledge or any
other feature that lead to a competitive advantage. Core competencies must be
perceived by customers and clients. Example: Talent and experience in running,
knowledge of previous plans to lose weight.
In the example of MaHeLeanCon, these competences are an extensive and
worldwide network, the many years of experience and the expertise in the respective
fields. As part of the alignment, companies must conduct a detailed analysis of their
core competencies. Johnson and Scholes define core competencies as a competitive
advantage over competitors through which companies can differentiate and differ-
entiate (Dathe & Helmold, 2018; Helmold, Dathe, & Büsch, 2017; Johnson &
Scholes, 1997).
2.6.4 Strategies
After defining mission, vision, goals and core competencies, the elements must be
translated into strategic objectives and key performance indicators (KPI). The long-
34 2 PM as Integral Part of the Corporate Strategy
The final element of the strategic pyramid is the performance control (control and
execution) and a target-performance comparison. A suitable tool for this step is the
balance score card (BSC) or an action plan. The instrument of the BSC was already
developed in 1992 by the professors Norton and Kaplan. The BSC is an instrument
in strategic management and includes four categories (Johnson & Scholes, 1997):
1. Customer satisfaction
2. Financial category
3. Internal processes and improvements
4. Learning organization
In the MaHeLeanCon consulting, there are a total of five categories based on the
model of Norton and Kaplan, but include customer-specific aspects for the success of
MaHeLeanCon. The five categories are:
Porter postulated three generic or broad alternative strategies which may be pursued
as a response to the competitive pressures. They are termed generic strategies
because they are broadly applicable to any industry or business. They are differenti-
ation, cost leadership and focus. A focus strategy may be further defined as cost
focus, differentiation focus or cost and differentiation focus.
A differentiation strategy may be based on actual unique product features or the
perception thereof, conveyed through the use of advertising and marketing tactics, in
the eyes of customers. Obviously, the product or service feature must be one the
customer needs or desires. Moreover, such enhanced features and designs or adver-
tising and marketing will increase costs, and customers must be price-insensitive—
willing to pay for the differentiated product or service. This willingness to pay for the
differentiated product of service is what provides the company relief from competi-
tive pressure, cost pressure specifically. Firms pursuing a cost leadership strategy
must make lower production and distribution costs their priority (Fig. 2.5).
Braod scope
Differentiation
Cost leadership
(value add)
Scope
Performance
Narrow scope
Differentiation
Cost leadership
(value add)
Low High
Source of performance advantage
By keeping their cost lower than those of their competitors, firms using cost
leadership can still price their products up to the level of their competitors and still
maintain higher gross profit margins. Alternatively, these firms can price their
products lower than those of their competitors in the hope of achieving greater
market share and sales volume at the expense of gross profit margins. A focus
strategy is based on a particular market, customer, product or geographic. A focus
strategy is a concentrated, narrowly focused niche strategy, which targets a specific
segment or market.
The company Siemens has outlined its mission, vision, goals, strategic objectives, core
values and cultural specifics in its strategy outline ‘Siemens, vision 2020’ (Siemens,
2019). The president and CEO Joe Kaeser outlines the key elements of the Siemens
strategy for the coming years. He stresses that with the positioning along the electrifi-
cation value chain, Siemens has know-how that extends from power generation to
power transmission, power distribution and smart grid to the efficient application of
electrical energy. And with the outstanding strengths in automation, Kaeser confirms
that Siemens is well equipped for the future and the age of digitalization. The Siemens
vision 2020 defines an entrepreneurial concept that will enable the enterprise to
consistently occupy attractive growth fields, sustainably strengthen our core business
and outpace our competitors in efficiency and performance. All goals are focused on a
long-term success (Siemens, 2019). The mission of Siemens can be defined as ‘We
make real what matters, by setting the benchmark, in the way we electrify, automate
and digitalize the world around us. Ingenuity drives us and what we create is yours.
Together we deliver’ (Siemens, 2019).
References
Dathe, T., & Helmold, M. (2018). Erfolg im Chinageschäft. Handlungsempfehlungen für kleine und
mittlere Unternehmen (KMU). Wiesbaden: Springer.
Helmold, M., Dathe, T., & Büsch, M. (2017, May 4). Praxisbericht aus der Bahnindustrie –
Bombardier Transportation. Veränderte Anforderungen durch Global Sourcing. Beschaffung
aktuell. Retrieved May 17, 2018, from https://beschaffung-aktuell.industrie.de/einkauf/
veraenderte-anforderungen-durch-global-sourcing/
Helmold, M., Dathe, T., & Hummel, F. (2019). Erfolgreiche Verhandlungen – Best-in-Class
Empfehlungen für den Verhandlungsdurchbruch. Wiesbaden: Springer.
Johnson, G., & Scholes, K. (1997). Exploring corporate strategy. Text and cases (4th ed.). London:
Prentice Hall.
Mintzberg, H., Quinn, J. B., & Ghoshal, S. (1995). The strategy process (Rev. European ed.).
London: Prentice Hall.
Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive strategy: Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors.
New York: Free Press.
References 37
Quantitative research methods are research methods dealing with numbers and
anything that is measurable in a systematic way of investigation of phenomena
and their relationships. It is used to answer questions on relationships within
measurable variables with an intention to explain, predict and control a phenome-
non. An entire quantitative study usually ends with confirmation or disconfirmation
of the hypothesis tested. Researchers using the quantitative method identify one or a
few variables that they intend to use in their research work and proceed with data
collection related to those variables. Examples of quantitative research are:
Research that consists of the percentage amounts of all the elements that make up
Earth’s atmosphere.
Survey that concludes that the average patient has to wait two hours in the waiting
room of a certain doctor before being selected.
An experiment in which group x was given two tablets of aspirin a day and group
y was given two tablets of a placebo a day where each participant is randomly
assigned to one or other of the groups. The numerical factors such as two tablets,
per cent of elements and the time of waiting make the situations and results
quantitative.
In finance, quantitative research into the stock market is used to develop models to
price complex trades, and develop algorithms to exploit investment hypotheses,
as seen in quantitative hedge funds or trading strategy indices.
Surveys, whether conducted online, by phone or in person. These rely on the same
questions being asked in the same way to a large number of people.
Observations, which may involve either counting the number of times that a
particular phenomenon occurs, such as how often a particular word is used in
interviews, or coding observational data to translate it into numbers.
Secondary data, such as company accounts.
Qualitative research is any which does not involve numbers or numerical data. It
often involves words or language, but may also use pictures or photographs and
observations. Almost any phenomenon can be examined in a qualitative way, and it is
often the preferred method of investigation in the UK and the rest of Europe; US
studies tend to use quantitative methods, although this distinction is by no means
absolute. Qualitative research is primarily exploratory research. It is used to gain an
understanding of underlying reasons, opinions and motivations. It provides insights
into the problem or helps to develop ideas or hypotheses for potential quantitative
research. Qualitative research is also used to uncover trends in thought and opinions
and dive deeper into the problem. Qualitative data collection methods vary using
unstructured or semi-structured techniques. Some common methods include focus
groups (group discussions), individual interviews and participation/observations.
The sample size is typically small, and respondents are selected to fulfil a given quota.
Qualitative analysis results in rich data that gives an in-depth picture, and it is
particularly useful for exploring how and why things have happened.
Although qualitative data is much more general than quantitative, there are still a
number of common techniques for gathering it. These include:
Key performance indicators (KPI) are a set of quantifiable measures that a company
uses to gauge its performance over time. These metrics are used to determine a
company’s progress in achieving its strategic and operational goals and also to
3.4 Case Study: Quantitative and Qualitative Data in Bombardier 41
compare a company’s finances and performance against other businesses within its
industry. A key performance indicator (KPI) is a measure of your performance
against key business objectives. High-level KPIs may focus on the overall perfor-
mance of the enterprise, while low-level KPIs may focus on processes or employees
in departments such as sales, marketing or a call centre.
The objective key results (OKR) system is a performance tool that sets,
communicates and monitors goals in an organization so that all employees work
together in one direction. The development of OKRs is generally attributed to Andy
Grove the ‘Father of OKRs’, who introduced the approach to Intel during his tenure
there and documented this in his 1983 book High output management. Objectives
and key results (OKRs) is a popular leadership process for setting, communicating
and monitoring quarterly goals and results in organizations. The goal of OKRs is to
connect company, team and personal objectives in a hierarchical way to measurable
results, making all employees work together in one unified direction. By using the
SMART-objective methodology. OKRs consist of a list of three to five high-level
objectives. Under each objective then usually three to five key measurable results are
listed. Each key result has a progress indicator or score of 0–100% or 0 to 1.0 that
shows its achievement. The advantages can be outlined as follows:
Goal-focused company alignment: align with your leadership team on top priorities
and highest leverage activities each quarter.
Fit objectives into company vision, mission and values to motivate your company
with purpose.
Visibility into company, department and individual progress, wins and road blocked
areas.
Bombardier Transportation (BT) has outsourced more than 80% of its value adding
activities to domestic and international supply networks. The category ‘supplier
quality performance’ receives therefore special focus. In 2012, Bombardier could
not deliver finished trains to the end customer in Europe allegedly due to defective
parts of the supplier XYZ from China. The managers and operational members of the
project who were responsible for profit and loss were extremely worried about
possible penalties from the end customer. For projects of this scope, delays in
delivery may cause penalties to the extent of several million EUR. During the root
cause investigation process, it became evident that a purely quantitative and numeri-
cal approach may not fully reveal the truth of the phenomena, as outlined by
42 3 Excellence in PM
Remenyi, Williams, Money and Swartz (2003) or Yin (2009). Thus, the qualitative
approach was more suitable for this kind of analysis. Quantitative KPI are not only
used by Bombardier, but also by other companies to measure supplier quality and
delivery performance. These supplier performance data hypothetically contribute to
good or bad supplier relationships between the customer and the supplier; however,
without appropriate interpretation and harmonization, such data may not indicate the
phenomena properly (Yin, 2009). The case study is representative of the weaknesses
of such systems, since all companies evaluate the quality performance of suppliers in
a standardized way on a monthly basis. All Bombardier suppliers are evaluated in
terms of delivery to the site and rate of NCGs in relation to the total quantity of goods
supplied, as shown in Fig. 3.1 (Bombardier, 2012: January to June 2012 NCG).
Every 6 months, management is informed about the performance of each individual
supplier. For example, if a supplier delivered 1000 goods within 6 months without any
non-conformity, his NCG percentage is zero. If he delivers 100 non-conforming parts,
his NCG percentage is 10. There are standard ways to determine whether a part is
NCG:
Deliveries: 34 units
1000 units
NCG%:
3.4%
Business Supplier
critical performance
Fig. 3.1 NCG ratio of supplier XYZ. Source: Author’s own figure
3.4 Case Study: Quantitative and Qualitative Data in Bombardier 43
be considered. Although the qualitative methodology went further than the quantitative
approach, no interaction ensued (Fig. 3.2).
There were ideas for improvement based on qualitatively determined realities and
evidence, but the system and the phenomena kept the ‘status quo’, since there had
been no intervention. In conclusion, it can be said that the system has shown the
advantages of the qualitative approach. The data material is more accurate and more
objective now that the root cause of NCG has been analysed. The interview approach
provided more realistic results than the quantitative method based on NCG percent-
age. In conclusion, the quantitative data showed not only one root cause but several/
more than one root causes (see RCA below), as displayed in Fig. 3.3. Qualitative and
Intralogistics
Design related
Handling
Supplier related
Fig. 3.2 Qualitative RCA and interventionist approach. Source: Author’s own figure
Quantitative
Quantitative Qualitative analysis
Quantitative
Qualitative Action
analysis research
1 2 3
Fig. 3.3 Quantitative and qualitative analysis with AR. Source: Author’s own figure
3.4 Case Study: Quantitative and Qualitative Data in Bombardier 45
narrative systems are more accurate and reflect actual supplier performance (includ-
ing soft factors) in a better way.
As there were several causal factors (not only supplier) within Bombardier which
generated NCG (e.g. intralogistics, warehousing, handling, design section, assem-
bly), it became necessary to develop question techniques to acquire more informa-
tion. In complex situations and research projects, a qualitative research approach
without intervention is considered to be effective, as recommended by Remenyi
et al. (2003). Compared to quantitative methodologies, qualitative methodologies
have certain advantages, as was illustrated in the supplier C case. Non-positivists
argue that purely positivistic approaches frequently fail, as several examples have
shown (Yin, 2009). This school of thought assumes that objects of investigation in
social sciences are social issues—a key concern is that research should acknowledge
and treat people (groups or functions like in the case study) as essentially human in
nature rather than as mere objects. Central to the above mentioned argument is the
fact that human beings have the ability to think, act and influence the world.
Positivist research strategies are unable to provide an understanding of such
human dimensions. In the UK general election in 1992, when the opinion polls
(including the exit polls) predicted a Labour Party victory, the Conservative Party
won instead (Remenyi et al., 2003, p. 92). It almost seems that voters were simply
not willing to tell the truth about how they actually intended to vote. Certain
scientists claim that qualitative research meanwhile represents a more suitable
strategy. Nevertheless, it also has some disadvantages compared with quantitative
methodologies. Remenyi et al. (2003) state that subjectivity may possibly lead to
procedural problems and that replicability is difficult to achieve. Moreover, the bias
of researchers is inherent and unavoidable. Another criticism is that qualitative
research is labour-intensive and expensive compared to quantitative research. Even
though it aims to be in depth, a comprehensive approach to data-gathering limits
scope. Finally, qualitative research is not always well understood by ‘classical’
researchers, as indicated by Remenyi et al. (2003). There is an ongoing debate
among researchers about the suitability and validity of quantitative and qualitative
methods in research (Denzin & Lincoln, 2000). Remenyi et al. (2003, p. 104) outline
characteristics of the quantitative (positivist) and qualitative (non-positivist)
approach. According to Denzin and Lincoln (2000), the key difference between
quantitative and qualitative methodology is flexibility. They state that quantitative
methods are less flexible than qualitative methods. A cross-functional task force,
which is supported by skilled process consultants, has been set up. The task force has
been given three main objectives: (1) to identify the root causes of each individual
NCG regardless of whose fault it was, (2) to describe the NCGs and allocate them to
the causal function and (3) to establish sustainable countermeasures by changing,
adjusting or adopting processes and systems. Even though action research (AR) was
not seriously considered for this study, the Jupiter case shows the potential of AR in
research and managerial practice in SRM. AR is a form of research in which
practitioners reflect systematically on their practice, implementing informed action
to bring about improvement. One widely accepted definition describes it in the
following way: AR is a form of self-reflective enquiry undertaken by participants
46 3 Excellence in PM
in social situations in order to improve the rationality and justice of their own social
or educational practices, their understanding of these practices and the situations in
which the practices are carried out. In the Jupiter case, a cross-functional task force
was set up. At a relatively early stage, certain characteristics relating to the interplay
of the task force members became obvious. All task force members were directly
responsible for making decisions. First of all, the issues to be researched were
determined. Then the enquiry was developed and implemented. The cooperation
and grouping of the individual participants significantly increased collaboration and
enriched working relationships and liaison within the task force. AR and the scope of
the project gave stakeholders the possibility to look beyond the root causes, and thus
they gained a greater understanding of their own practices in handling supplier C
material. In Fig. 3.4, it can be seen that the majority of defects could be eliminated.
The members of the task force were empowered to make informed decisions
about what to change and what not to change. They linked prior knowledge to new
information, learned from experience (even failures), asked questions and systemat-
ically found answers on the topic. With AR it would also be possible for manage-
ment and stakeholders of Jupiter to integrate theory (findings) and practice, increase
teamwork, steer more effectively towards a zero-defect philosophy and improve
discipline among task force members. It was the wish of each member to increase the
predictability of what happened in their functions. The task force acquired knowl-
edge in qualitative research methods beyond a numerical system. The white area in
the pie chart in the summary figure shows the results after intervention into the
processes and systems. About two-thirds of the NCGs could be erased within a short
period of time.
The joint task force has had fundamental implications both for the individual
project and for the general system of supplier performance within Bombardier.
Figure 3.5 shows the three approaches and their respective outcome in the
Intralogistics
Design related
Handling
Supplier related
Fig. 3.4 Root cause analysis (RCA) including action research (AR). Source: Author’s own figure
Supplier XYZ case
1 2 3
Action Research
Intralogistics
Supplier XYZ Supplier XYZ
Task forces
Not found
NCGs NCGs in WH
Handling
Bombardier Bombardier
Design
related
3.4 Case Study: Quantitative and Qualitative Data in Bombardier
Interventionist
approach
pie charts. The Jupiter quality performance was judged to be extremely bad using
quantitative methodology (1) however; the qualitative approach without inter-
vention (2) (including interviews and qualitative root causes) still revealed
weaknesses in the quantitative methodology itself. Through potential AR (3) and a
task force which includes external specialists in processes, it was possible to
intervene in and improve the system. In conclusion, one can say that AR offers
suitable features for making improvements with intervention (Remenyi et al., 2003),
as the case has shown.
These principles are the subject of discussion in the next chapter. Reason and
Bradbury (2001) emphasize that AR is a participative process in which experience
and reflection are the essential criteria for intervening in a system. Figure 3.6 shows
the different results from ‘red’ to ‘green’ (cf. traffic lights) relating to the three
approaches. AR has shown that an interventionist approach in a transformative and
improvement cycle significantly has changed the overall performance of the sup-
plier. One important principle has been the continuous reflection by all task force
members and the triggering of improvements through the pluralist structure.
Chapter 10 stresses the need for a joint and collaborative approach in supply
management based on quantitative and qualitative real facts.
References 49
References
Bombardier Transportation. (2012). Business critical suppliers 01/2013. Internal business critical
report.
Denzin, N. K., & Lincoln, Y. S. (Eds.). (2000). Handbook of qualitative research. London: Sage.
Reason, P., & Bradbury, H. (Eds.). (2001). The Sage handbook of action research. Participative
inquiry and practice (1st ed.). London: Sage.
Remenyi, D., Williams, B., Money, A., & Swartz, E. (2003). Doing research in business manage-
ment. An introduction to process and method. London: Sage.
Yin, R. K. (2009). Case study research (4th ed.). London: Sage.
PM in the Upstream Value Chain
4
Marc Helmold
Look deep into nature and then you will understand all better.
Albert Einstein (1879–1955)
Performance in the upstream value chain deals with the management of the supply
side and the purchasing of raw materials, semi-finished and finished parts or
services. Synonyms of purchasing are procurement, acquisition or supply manage-
ment. Supply management plays in this context a crucial role in securing this input
and to manage factors like quality, cost, delivery, technology and alpha elements
(Q-C-D-T-plus alpha). The essential point is here that supply management has to
link all the activities between suppliers, their own organization and the customers in
a timely manner. In recent years, there was a trend for many industries such as
automotive, railway, aerospace and machinery to reduce their own value-adding
activities. As a result, companies were becoming more and more dependent on
supply networks. That gave a crucial role to the supply management function.
Many companies had/have value-adding activities of less than 15%, which means
that 85% of their activities were/are outsourced to third parties. As a consequence,
the function of managing these outside activities, the supply management, has a
crucial role within any organization. The outside value-adding activities are
performed by several suppliers, so-called supplier networks. Supplier networks are
characterized by adding value through producing, finishing or finalizing products,
which the customers are demanding. The rapid increase in supplier activities directly
affects supplier management, as emphasized by Emmett and Crocker (2009). In
recent years, many companies have reduced their value-adding activities and
concentrated on their core competencies. Supply management has therefore become
more important in core and peripheral business areas (Trkman & McCormack, 2009)
and is aimed at managing supply, building resilient supply chains and managing
Input-transformation-output
Supply Demand
side Procurement Operations Marketing
side
(Supply) management (Sales)
Information
technology
Finance and (IT)
accounting
Human
resources Support functions
Fig. 4.1 PM in supply management and procurement. Source: Author’s own figure
Many industries are nowadays faced by fierce competition inside and outside
Europe. Globalization and other elements of international trade are influencing the
viewpoint of companies in terms of performance management. This is forcing
manufacturing companies to concentrate on core competencies and to transfer the
production of components, goods and services to external suppliers (Aberdeen
Group, 2006; Harland, Brenchley, & Walker, 2003). The number of value-adding
activities has decreased constantly and now lies between 20% and 30% in this
industry (Dyer, 1996, 2000). Such a development has had a great influence on the
structure of supply chains and supplier relationships. Supply chains (the terms
‘supply chains’ and ‘supply networks’ are used synonymously in the literature)
have become more complex and international, as pointed out by several authors
(Aberdeen Group, 2006; Harland et al., 2003). Christopher and Peck see the level of
complexity increasing in the upstream supply chain management of manufacturing
companies in the European transportation industry, a trend which is characterized by
the growing transfer of activities to suppliers, high numbers of supply chain layers
4.2 Concentration on Core Competencies 53
(tiers) and the ongoing globalization of supply chains (Christopher & Peck, 2004).
As a consequence, vulnerability and risk exposure have risen significantly. The rapid
increase in supplier activities directly affects supplier relationship management
(SRM), as emphasized by Emmett and Crocker (2009). In recent years, many
companies have reduced their value-adding activities and implemented efficiency-
oriented cost reductions, e.g. outsourcing, single sourcing, low-cost country sourc-
ing, platform concepts, lean management and design-to-cost approaches (Aberdeen
Group, 2006; Gürtler & Spinler, 2010). SRM has become more important in core
and peripheral business areas and is aimed at building resilient supply chains.
Resilience is based on being able to anticipate, manage and prevent supply chain
disruptions at an early stage (Christopher & Peck, 2004). On the other hand, supply
risks have risen due to increased dependency on supplier networks (Kersten et al.,
2008). In their research ‘An Empirical Analysis of the Effect of Supply Chain
Disruptions on Long-Run Stock Price’, Hendricks and Singhal (2005) found out
that enterprises without operational slack and redundancies in their supply chains
experience negative stock effects. The authors revealed the tremendous impact of
supply chain disruptions on stock price performance and shareholder value. Supply
disruptions can easily lead to high recovery cost, waste and sharp decreases in sales,
as pointed out in this study. External customers become dissatisfied and internal core
functions (e.g. assembly) are disturbed. In most cases, supply disruptions have
negative impacts on brand image, sales figures and the company’s own financial.
Although literature is already available on the topic, both top management and
academia underline the need for a more holistic approach towards SRM. Several
authors point out that there is a discrepancy between the proactive role of SRM in
complex and global supply networks and the traditional view of how to deal with
suppliers (Aberdeen Group, 2006). Christopher and Peck stress that supply chain
resilience and SRM is a relatively new and still largely unexplored area of manage-
ment (Christopher & Peck, 2004). Supply chain risks have mainly been investigated
on the direct level of tier-one relationships, but consideration has not been fully
extended to sub-suppliers, i.e. tiers one, two, three and beyond (Harland et al., 2003).
This chapter therefore seeks to address these concerns by identifying the phases of
supply management, by outlining performance management tools in the upstream
value chain and by outlining how performance of suppliers must be measured and
managed. Figure 4.2 outlines the six phases of supply management (Helmold &
Terry, 2016). These phases include the strategy, supplier selection, supplier evalua-
tion, supplier development, supplier integration and supplier monitoring and control
(Helmold & Terry, 2016). Prof. Dr-Ing. Dust, Professor at the Technical University
for Quality Management, comes to similar results in his survey ‘Total Supplier
Management’. Hendricks and Singhal (2005) show in their analysis that supply
chain discrepancies can harm the share value of their own company by up to 40%.
Only flat hierarchies, lean competencies and direct accountability through line
responsible people (Japanese ¼ Gemba) lead to an improved communication and
concentration on value-adding activities and core issues. Due to the importance of
the supply chain, it is necessary (Freitag, 2004; Liker, 2004). Thus, it is possible to
synchronize master production and delivery schedules and to have short lead times
54 4 PM in the Upstream Value Chain
Information
technology
Finance and (IT)
accounting
Human
resources Support functions
What is a supply network and why are they so important for companies and business
managers? Supply networks allow us to look at the big picture, giving us a better
understanding of the flow of materials and information (Dust, 2009). Often
organizations focus only on their organization that means what they produce or
provide and not what the end customer receives. Looking at a supply network
enables firms to look at the overall movement of materials and information from
start to end customer, allowing organizations to see the value in creating
partnerships. The value in working together to ensure the best possible value is
provided to the end customer. Supply chain networks describe the flow and move-
ment of materials and information, by linking organizations together to serve the end
4.4 PM in the Upstream Value Chain: Supply Networks 55
customer. Supply networks are networks of suppliers that add value to a process,
product or service. A supply network is a pattern of processes carried out at facility
nodes and over distribution links, which adds value for customers through the
manufacturing and delivery of products. It comprises the general state of business
affairs in which all kinds of material (work-in-progress material as well as finished
components) are transformed and moved between various value-added points to
maximize the value-add for customers. One of the strategic aims in supply manage-
ment is the establishment of resilient supply networks. A resilient supply network
effectively aligns its strategy, operations, management systems, governance struc-
ture and decision-support capabilities so that it can uncover and adjust to continually
changing risks, endure disruptions to its primary earnings drivers and create
advantages over less adaptive competitors. Moreover, it has the capability to respond
rapidly to unforeseen changes, even chaotic disruption. The resilience of a supply
network is the ability to bounce back and, in fact, to bounce forward with speed,
determination and precision. In recent studies, resilience is regarded as the next
phase in the evolution of traditional, place-centric enterprise structures to highly
virtualized, customer-centric structures that enable people to work anytime, any-
where. Resilient supply networks should align their strategy and operations to adapt
to risks that affect their capacities. There are four levels of supply chain resilience.
First is reactive supply chain management. Second is internal supply chain integra-
tion with planned buffers. Then comes collaboration across extended supply chain
networks. Finally, there is a dynamic supply chain adaptation and flexibility. ‘Net-
work’ describes a more complex structure, where organizations can be cross-linked
and there are two-way exchanges between them; ‘chain’ describes a simpler,
sequential set of links (Harland et al., 2003). In order to understand a supply chain
network, we need to understand what a supply chain is. A supply chain is a series of
processes linked together to form a chain. Figure 4.3 shows the hierarchy of supplier
networks from raw material supplier, component/parts suppliers, systems supplier
and module suppliers to the integrated supplier networks. Another definition for
integrated suppliers is ‘keiretsu’ supplier, a definition which comes from the Japa-
nese paradigm of working with suppliers.
A raw material supplier produces and supplies materials or substances used in the
primary production or manufacturing of a good (granulate, liquids, steel, aluminium,
etc.). Raw materials are often natural resources such as oil, iron and wood. Before
being used in the manufacturing process, raw materials often are altered or refined
(adding value) to be used in different processes. Raw materials are often referred to
as commodities, which are bought and sold on commodities exchanges around the
world. Raw materials are sold in what is called the factor or commodity markets,
some even at stock exchanges (London Metal Exchange, LME). This is because raw
materials are factors of production along with labour and capital. Raw materials are
so important to the production process that the success of a country’s economy can
56 4 PM in the Upstream Value Chain
High Competence of
Product
Supplier types A-Supplier
Integrated
supplier
Q-C-D-T plus alpha criteria
Module supplier
High Competence of
Process
Sytems supplier
be determined by the amount of natural resources the country has within its own
borders. A country that has abundant natural resources does not need to import as
many raw materials and has an opportunity to export the materials to other countries.
Raw materials are utilized to make components or parts.
Fig. 4.4 Supply strategies (preferred and alternative suppliers). Source: Author’s own figure
Segmentation in line with the process and product of the supply pyramid is
allocating resources to the creation of value-adding relationships in their own
company. Porsche classifies suppliers into four groups as shown in Fig. 4.4:
Fig. 4.5 Supplier and commodity strategies. Source: Compiled by Author, adopted from Eyholzer
et al. (2002)
Kuhlmann and Münger (2002) and is a useful tool to define suitable supplier/
material strategies for the combinations as shown in Fig. 4.5.
• Strategic suppliers/materials
• Leverage suppliers/materials
• Shortage suppliers/materials
• Standard suppliers/materials
Strategic Materials/Components
Strategic materials can be defined as special materials which are important and key to
an enterprise’s own production. Siemens and Bombardier Transportation produce
car bodies by themselves; however, aluminium and stainless steel or steel profiles
and extrusions are strategic for the production and quality of the end product.
Leverage Materials/Components
Leverage materials can be defined where the supply side is characterized by many
companies which offer the materials. The automotive industry is characterized by
more than ten to twenty different suppliers, which deliver entertainment products
(polypolistic market).
Shortage Materials/Components
Shortage materials can be defined as materials that are scarce on the market. Scarcity
represents a problem to any supply management organization and needs the right
establishment of strategies.
Figure 4.5 defines strategies for the supplier/material combinations. For the leverage
and strategic suppliers with strategic materials, it is recommended to establish long-
term and value-adding partnerships. For the second combination of strategic/lever-
age suppliers and leverage materials, it is suitable to fully exploit the market
potential. For shortage materials, it is recommended to secure supply and availability
by long-term contracts and partnerships. In this context, it is also possible for
companies to vertically integrate (via joint ventures, investments, acquisitions) and
to produce shortage material themselves.
Standard materials with a high extent of competition do not represent a threat to
their own company. Here, it is possible to take advantage of market competition. The
commodity segmentation or category management means to divide the major mate-
rial categories into sub-groups, categories or segments, which are definable, accessi-
ble, actionable and profitable and have a growth potential. The major objective of
categorization or segmentation is the standardization of suppliers and supply process
and to get the optimum benefit by bundling volumes in each category.
Apart from the material flow, supply management has to ensure sustainable green
and reverse logistics together with the suppliers. Last but not least, the operational
roles and responsibilities include the cross-functional performance evaluation on a
4.6 Supply Management Process 61
0. (Establish)
5a. Initial organisation 1. Demand
analysis analysis
(Select) (Need)
3.
9. Invoicing Qualification
(Pay) (Evaluate)
Fig. 4.6 Supply strategy management process. Source: Author’s own figure
Critics stress that supply management processes have become more complex and
that other aspects or steps such as risk management and supplier development have
to be integrated. Concerning the supply management process of supplying products,
there are several definitions from several authors available (Dust, 2009; Emmett &
Crocker, 2009). Dust (2009) emphasizes that the supply management process must
include a more holistic view and that such process must include an escalation and
risk management layer. Other supply management process models highlight the
different steps from the demand analysis up to the paid invoice for the delivered
products (Emmett & Crocker, 2009). In accordance with the models of the authors
Emmett and Crocker (2009), the following model has been derived including
10 phases (phase 0 to phase 10). Moreover, the process steps of the initial analysis
of the quotations (5a.), delivery/receipt of goods and the processing and usage of
products in their own company (10) have been supplemented by supply improve-
ment measures.
Organization (Establish)
Any supply process must start with the right organization and strategy. Organiza-
tionally all authors stress that the supply department should be the single point of
contact to the suppliers.
Qualification (Evaluate)
Product and service specifications will need to be identified in liaison with the user
(requisitioned). Specifications are a description of what the requisitioned is demand-
ing in terms of fit, form and function. This is therefore a critical stage within the
supply management process as the needs have to be communicated properly. Based
on the right specifications, the supply manager can identify and qualify the right
suppliers for this product or service. Emmett and Crocker (2009) recommend in this
stage to:
Invoice (Pay)
After final and successful processing of the supplied products, the products can be
paid for in line with the agreed payment terms. Many companies have payment terms
of 30 or 60 days after receipt of goods. Extended payment terms help the company to
improve its cash situation. Cash management is nowadays becoming more and more
important in organizations. In this regard, supply management is a contributor to
profitability of any enterprise. Chinese, South Korean and Japanese companies
sometimes have payment terms exceeding 90 or 120 days.
Delivery (Receipt)
The supply management process includes the confirmation of dispatch, transit time
and receipt of goods. In global supply such as China, it is especially important that
the lead time of goods is taken into account. Helmold and Terry (2017) emphasize
the need to have a tool which incorporates important information, in order to make
sure that the goods from China arrive at the requisitioned time. These aspects are:
possible applications in the first step with the aim of creating more transparency in
the supply chains beyond our direct suppliers’. That’s how it works (Mercedes-
Benz, 2019): A blockchain is a list of records. A decentralized database distributed
among many networked computers. All participants of the blockchain see the same
content. The individual datasets are linked together using encrypted methods.
Blockchain has so far been used primarily for the settlement of financial transactions.
But also the conclusion of contracts can be made transparent by means of
blockchain. The new blockchain prototype used at Mercedes-Benz Cars makes it
possible to transparently map and understand the passing on of the sustainability
standards of Daimler AG across the entire supply chain, in particular, the contractual
obligations relating to working conditions, human rights, environmental protection,
safety, business ethics and compliance. Should one of the sub-suppliers deviate from
this, this will be visible in the blockchain. ‘Passing on contracts to each member of
the supply chain, especially in terms of sustainability and ethical behaviour, is the
prerequisite for working with our suppliers. The blockchain prototype opens up
completely new ways to make purchasing processes simpler and safer’, says Sabine
Angermann, Head of Purchasing and Supplier Quality for Raw Materials and
Strategy, Mercedes-Benz Cars (Rau, 2019).
References
Aberdeen Group. (2006). Industry priorities for visibility. B2B Collaboration. Trade compliance
and risk management. Global supply chain benchmark report. Boston. 06/2006. Retrieved May
31, 2010, from http://www-935.ibm.com/services/us/igs/pdf/aberdeen-benchmark-report.pdf
Ahmadjian, C., & Lincoln, E. J. (1997). Changing firm boundaries in Japanese auto parts supply
networks (pp. 5–8) (Working paper). Academic Commons by Columbia University Libraries.
Ahmadjian, C., & Lincoln, E. J. (2001). Keiretsu, governance, and learning: Case studies in change
from the Japanese automotive industry. Organization Science, 12(6), 683–701.
Christopher, M., & Peck, H. (2004). Building the resilient chain. International Journal of Logistics
Management, 15(2), 1–5.
Dust, R. (2009). Process and cost potentials through total supplier management. A study of the
degree of implementation and the contribution of supplier management to safeguarding com-
petitiveness and corporate success, 11(2009), 1–35.
Dyer, J. H. (1996). Specialized supplier networks as a source of competitive advantage: Evidence
from the auto industry. Strategic Management Journal, 17(4), 271–291.
Dyer, J. H. (2000). Collaborative advantage: Winning through extended enterprise supplier
networks (Vol. 21, pp. 71–87). New York: Oxford University Press.
Emmett, S., & Crocker, B. (2009). Excellence in supplier management. How to better manage
contracts with suppliers and add value. Best practices in supplier relationship and supplier
development. Cambridge: Cambridge Academic.
Eyholzer, K., Kuhlmann, W., & Münger, T. (2002). In: K. Hildebrand (Ed.), Wirtschaftlichkeitsaspeke
eines partnershaftlichen Lieferantenmanagements. Heidelberg: Gabler.
Freitag, M. (2004). Toyota. Formel Toyota. Manager Magazin, 12, 12–14.
Gürtler, B., & Spinler, S. (2010). A network-oriented investigation of supply risk and implications
to supply risk monitoring. International Journal of Production, 12, 1–27.
Harland, C., Brenchley, R., & Walker, H. (2003). Risk in supply networks. Journal of Purchasing
and Supply Management, 9(2), 51–62.
66 4 PM in the Upstream Value Chain
The key to the Toyota Way and what makes Toyota stand out
is not any of the individual elements. But what is important is
having all the elements together as a system. It must be
practiced every day in a very consistent manner, not in spurts.
Taiichi Ohno (1912–1990)
Input-transformation-output
Supply Demand
side Procurement Operations Marketing
side
(Supply) management (Sales)
Information
technology
Finance and (IT)
accounting
Human
resources Support functions
Fig. 5.1 Operations management as part of the value chain. Source: Author’s own figure
Objectives Criteria
1. Right part • Needed part
2. Right time • Now
3. Right place • Here
4. Right quantity • One piece
5. Right quality • Zero defect
6. Right employee • Qualification
7. Right price • Optimal cost
Fig. 5.2 7R principle in operations management. Source: Author’s own figure, adopted from
Helmold and Terry (2017)
Added value can be defined as products, services, processes and activities, which
generate a certain value to the organisation and enterprise. Value add must be
regarded from the customer viewpoint and is everything for which the customer is
5.2 Optimizing Performance Through Lean Production 69
Hidden Value
waste add
(reduce) (increase)
Obvious
waste
(eliminate)
Fig. 5.3 Value add and waste. Source: Author’s own figure, adopted from Helmold and Terry
(2017)
willing to pay for. It is important that value add is recognised and perceived as value
by the client. Many studies have shown that we only add value to a product for less
than 5–15% of the time, the rest of the time is wasted (Helmold & Terry, 2017). The
opposite is non-adding value or waste as shown in Fig. 5.3. Waste (Japanese: Muda,
無駄) is anything which adds cost or time without adding any value or any activity
which does not satisfy any of the above conditions of value add is a waste or a
non-value adding activity in a process. The focus in operations management must
therefore be in eliminating such activities like waiting time or rework (Liker, 2004;
Ohno, 1990) (Fig. 5.4).
Hidden waste
• No added value for
Task •
product or service
Task is necessary for Minimize
production
Obvious waste
• No added value for
product or service
Task • Task not necessary for Eliminate
production
Fig. 5.4 Actions for value add and waste. Source: Author’s own figure
Value add
(Quality)
Advantages
– Highly visual brainstorming tool which can spark further examples of root causes
– Quickly identify if the root cause is found multiple times in the same or different
causal tree
– Allows one to see all causes simultaneously
– Good visualization for presenting issues to stakeholders
5.2 Optimizing Performance Through Lean Production 71
Value add
(Quality)
Fig. 5.6 Ishikawa diagramme with waste and value add. Source: Author’s own figure
Disadvantages
– Complex defects might yield a lot of causes which might become visually
cluttering
– Interrelationships between causes are not easily identifiable (Fig. 5.6)
5.2.4 5S-System
5S is the name of a workplace organization method that uses a list of five Japanese
words: seiri, seiton, seiso, seiketsu, and shitsuke. Transliterated into Roman
Script, they all start with the letter “S”. 5S is used to stabilise, maintain and
improve the safest, best working environment thus supporting sustainable QCD
plus alpha.
5S is a systematic and structured work place optimisation, originally be devel-
oped and used by Toyota. The objective is the identification and elimination of
waste. In simple terms, the five S methodology helps a workplace remove items that
are no longer needed (sort), organize the items to optimize efficiency and flow
(straighten), clean the area in order to more easily identify problems (shine),
implement colour coding and labels to stay consistent with other areas (standardize)
and develop behaviours that keep the workplace organized over the long term
(sustain). 5S is a workplace organization method that uses a list of five Japanese
words:
1. Seiri (整理)
2. Seiton (整頓)
3. Seisō (清掃)
4. Seiketsu (清潔)
5. Shitsuke (躾)
72 5 PM in Operations
2. Set in
5. Sustain
order
4.
3. Shine
Standardise
These five words can be translated as “Sort”, “Set In order”, “Shine”, “Standard-
ize” and “Sustain”. The 5S-methodology describes how to organize a work space for
efficiency and effectiveness by identifying and storing the items used, maintaining
the area and items, and sustaining the new order. The decision-making process
usually comes from a dialogue about standardization, which builds understanding
among employees of how they should do the work.
In some quarters, 5S has become 6S, the sixth element being safety or self-
discipline (Fig. 5.7).
The advantages of the 5S system are the following:
The first element in the 5S concept is the sorting (seiri). In this step it is important
to distinguish between necessary and unnecessary things. Things in this context are
materials, components, tools, gauges, information, things and people. Unnecessary
things must disappear. Removing these items which are not used in the working area
may take a reasonable amount of time. Classification of all equipment and materials
by frequency will help to decide if these items can be removed or not. The second
5.3 Seven Types of Waste in Operations 73
step is the setting in order (seiton). The practice of orderly storage so the right item
can be picked efficiently at the right time, easy to access for the operators. Identifi-
cation and allocation of materials, information, tools and necessary things at fixed
and visualised locations is important in this step. In the next and third step (seiso), it
is mandatory to create a clean worksite without garbage, dirt and dust, so problems
can be more easily identified (leaks, spills, excess, damage, etc.). In the fourth step
(seiketsu) standards for a neat, clean, workplace and operations will be set up
through visual management. In the fifth and last stage (shitsuke) it is important to
create the environment, patterns, management style and behaviours that established
standards are executed over the long-term, and making the workplace organization
the key to managing the process for success (Helmold & Terry, 2017).
5.3.1 Transportation
5.3.2 Inventory
1. Transportation
Consequences Examples
• Additional space for transport • Long or additional transport of:
• Blocking of capacity due to additional logistic
effort • Raw material
• Possible damage of products • Finished goods
• Tools and devices
2. Inventory
Consequences Examples
• Capital costs • Overfilled warehouses
• Double handling, possible damages based • Overfilled place in production areas
on double handling, rework • Buffer stocks in producton
• Genuine problems won’t be discovered and • Crammed corridors
therefore not solved
• Crammed desks
• Search effort
• Scrap
inventory, the lighting of the storage space, etc. Moreover, having excess inventory
can hide the original wastes of producing said inventory. The environmental impacts
of inventory waste are packaging, deterioration or damage to work-in-process,
additional materials to replace damaged or obsolete inventory, and the energy to
light, as well as either heat or cool, inventory space. Figure 5.9 displays the
definition, reasons, consequences and examples for inventory. Inventory will have
5.3 Seven Types of Waste in Operations 75
5.3.3 Motion
Motion waste is the excessive movement of man, material or machines within the
work space. Motion waste will lead to higher cost as the productivity decreases.
Another problem of motion is the necessity for more time and capacity in operations
than actually required. A proper workflow analysis and value stream mapping help
to minimise this waste. Figure 5.10 outlines the definition, possible reasons,
consequences and examples of this waste.
5.3.4 Waiting
Idle time of operators or other employees in operations and waiting for work to arrive
or to be told what-to-do is a significant waste. Waiting or standstill times must be
avoided as waiting results into reduced efficiency and productivity. Other outcomes
are longer lead times and decreasing engagement and motivation of employees as
illustrated in Fig. 5.11.
3. Motion
Consequences Examples
• Decrease of productivity • Long ways between tools, material and
• Increase of lead time and capacity product or machine
• Insufficient ergonomics • Missing material or tools
4. Waiting
Consequences Examples
• Reduced productivity • Waiting for material or tools e.g. crane
• Decreasing efficiency • Quality employees are not available
• Increased lead time • Stopped processes due to missing resources
• Increase of capacity (employees, defective machines, IT,...)
5.3.5 Overproduction
Overproduction waste is defined as producing too many products too early and in
advance. That means that parts in a big quantity are existing inside operations
management, even though these parts are not needed. Figure 5.12 display possible
reasons such as demand non-transparency or inadequate batch sizes. A consequence
of this waste is that inventory increases drastically and that work-in-progress cost
rise significantly.
5.3.6 Over-Processing
5. Overproduction
Consequences Examples
• Generation of inventory (warehouse, WIP) • A lot of material in front of machines or
• Additional use of space assembly lines
• Blocking of capacities (machines, • Crowded warehouses
employees)
• Double handling, decrease of product quality
6. Overprocessing
Consequences Examples
• High production costs • High tolerances
• Waste of material • Wrong, faulty and not needed process steps
• Low efficiency • Not optimal utilisation of resources
• High need for resources (employee, • Duplication of efforts
machine, material)
5.3.7 Defects
Defects refer to a product deviating from the standards of its design or from the
customer’s expectation. Defective products must be replaced; they require paper-
work and human labour to process it; they might potentially lose customers; the
resources put into the defective product are wasted because the product is not used.
78 5 PM in Operations
7. Defects
Definition
Definition Possible reasons
Possible reasons
• If right first time is not achieved • Lack of machine and tool maintenance
• Insufficiently trained employees
• Product not according to customer
requirements
• Unstable or not standardized processes
• No problem solving process established
Consequences Examples
• Additional need for material, tools and • Increase of non-conformities
capacity • Retrofitting and repairing defect parts
• Additional space for rework • Increased quantity of scrap
• Increase of quality employees and checks • Supply issues due to bad quality
• Increase of lead time
Moreover, a defective product implies waste at other levels that may have led to the
defect to begin with; making a more efficient production system reduces defects and
increases the resources needed to address them in the first place. Environmental costs
of defects are the raw materials consumed, the defective parts of the product
requiring disposal or recycling (which wastes other resources involved in
repurposing it), and the extra space required and increased energy use involved in
dealing with the defects (Fig. 5.14).
The checklist in Fig. 5.15 is the ideal tool to assess operations in terms of the
seven wastes. It is a proven method for identifying waste in process and activities
(Helmold & Terry, 2017).
The key to acquiring and keeping customers is by offering value. To do this, we must
first understand our customers and what they are willing to pay for—this is what we
call “value”. By definition, everything else is waste, diminishing value to the
customer and reducing profitability. Put simply, Lean Thinking (or Toyota Way
トヨタウェイ) is delivering value from the customer’s perspective and eliminating
waste (or muda 無駄).
Lean is a suite of four complementary, interconnected principles, each geared
towards increasing value to the customer by improving efficiency. By applying these
simple principles, any business in any sector can not only provide a better service or
product to their end users, but also make fundamental, sustainable improvements in
profitability. The Toyota Productions system (TPS) has been adopted by many
companies in all sectors on a global scale. The TPS has been applied by many
How many times?
Transport Which routes?
T Empty containers?
Which mistakes?
Defects How often does it happen?
d Problem solving system?
OEMs in automotive industry, railway area and other business sectors. Bombardier
Transportation is applying the Bombardier Operations System (BOS), Porsche the
Porsche Production System (PPS) and Daimler the Daimler Production System.
However, it is not always successful, as the activities are only partially introduced
and not rolled out in total. Secondly, lean principles are not synchronized with the
USCM and may thus not show the desired effects and results. It does not make sense
to establish only single lean instruments. It is of the utmost importance and a
fundamental aspect of the lean concept that principles are applied in a total approach
that involves the suppliers. In this respect, it is the crucial role of procurement and
supplier relationship management to transfer this competency to its supply chain.
Inefficiencies throughout the supply chain can thus be identified, waste can be
eliminated and processes can be harmonized in order to strive for continuous
improvements. Continuous improvement (Japanese: Kaizen) means small steps
and is part of the lean philosophy. Data show that the complete transfer of lean
principles to the supply chain can lead to significant cost reduction advantages of up
to 15–50%.
In contrast to the traditional paradigm the objectives of lean production are based
on a reduction of throughput times and the elimination of non-value-adding
activities. These activities are waste or so called “MUDA” (Japanese: 無駄). Both
concepts, the traditional and the lean concept, are directed towards customer satis-
faction. Nevertheless, the lean concept’s foundation is based on the optimal reaction
capability and not based on inventories or waste. Inventories increase the cost of
capital and have negative impacts on the shareholder value, whereas short cycle
times lead to small inventories. Lean manufacturing or lean production, often simply
“lean”, is a systematic method for the elimination of waste (“Muda”) within a
manufacturing system. Lean also takes into account waste created through overbur-
den (“Muri”) and waste created through unevenness in workloads (“Mura”). Work-
ing from the perspective of the client who consumes a product or service, “value” is
any action or process that a customer would be willing to pay for. Essentially, lean is
centered on making obvious what adds value by reducing everything else. Lean
manufacturing is a management philosophy derived mostly from the Toyota Pro-
duction System (TPS) (hence the term Toyotism is also prevalent) and identified as
“lean” only in the 1990s. TPS is renowned for its focus on reduction of the original
Toyota seven wastes to improve overall customer value, but there are varying
perspectives on how this is best achieved. The steady growth of Toyota, from a
small company to the world’s largest automaker, has focused attention on how it has
achieved this success. There are three MU’s including MUDA that support the
elimination of waste within the philosophy of Toyota. In parallel to MUDA (Japa-
nese: 無駄), there are MURA (Japanese: 無ら) and MURI (Japanese ¼ 無理) which
are the ground theory for the TPS. MURA means “in balance”, MURI “overutiliza-
tion”. While certain capacities are too scarce (Bottleneck) there are other resources
significantly below their capacity limits. The main objective of procurement and a
strategic supplier management is to apply the JIT principle to the suppliers. Value
adding activities have to be rolled out to all suppliers from raw material to module
and keiretsu suppliers. The keiretsu supplier is the closest relationship and
5.4 Principles of a Just-in-Time Production System 81
Pull Flow
principle Just-in- principle
time (JIT)
production
system
The starting point in Toyota’s success story, Zero Defects is all about identifying
errors or defects as closely as possible to where they occur. By so doing, and by
neither accepting nor passing on defects, issues are resolved quickly and efficiently,
avoiding subsequent re-work and quality issues. The zero-defect principle is a
concept of the Toyota Production System and is aimed at the reduction of defects
through error prevention (Ohno, 1990). It is directed at motivating people to prevent
mistakes by developing a constant, conscious desire to do their job right the first
time. In reality, zero defects are not possible, however, the concept ensures that there
is no waste existing in a project (Helmold & Terry, 2017). Waste refers to all
unproductive processes, tools, employees and so on. Anything that is unproductive
82 5 PM in Operations
and does not add value to a project should be eliminated, called the process of
elimination of waste. Eliminating waste creates a process of improvement and
correspondingly lowers costs. Common with the zero defects theory is the concept
of “doing it right the first time” to avoid costly and time-consuming fixes later in the
project management process. The concept of zero defects is grounded on four major
elements for implementation in real projects:
The pull system is one of the lean manufacturing principles and is used to reduce
waste in the production process. In this type of system, components used in the
manufacturing process are only replaced once they have been consumed so
companies only make enough products to meet customer demand. The opposite
principle is the push system, in which as many products as possible are generated to
be sold via marketing activities. The principles aim to avoid over-production and
stockpiling, thereby saving working capital, by letting demand dictates the rate at
which goods or services are delivered. In this way the customer, or the next step in
the chain, “pulls” value through the process.
Value should be added in a smooth, uninterrupted flow, from the start to the end of
the production process. The ultimate effect of this principle is that all process steps
are focussed and aligned to adding value, one piece at a time, removing all wasteful
and unnecessary activities from the process. The advantage of a continuous flow in
operations is that it features stability, continuity, balance, and doesn’t waste time (the
non-renewable resource). No time wasted on waiting between steps means time is
being maximized for its capabilities. Operations are not able to introduce a waste-
less process without the continuous flow, as it is the truly ideal process state.
However, the troubles with continuous flow are that it’s very hard to achieve,
process steps aren’t generally balanced, and all process contains inherent waste
activities. When one starts out to achieve continuous flow, many process problems
will appear and come to the surface. Most individuals think this is bad, but it’s
actually a good thing. The optimal process features continuous flow, and any
5.4 Principles of a Just-in-Time Production System 83
OP 1 Pre- OP 2 Assembly 1
assembly
U-type flow
OP 4 Finshing OP 3 Assembly 2
OP 1 Pre- OP 3 Assembly 2
assembly
Zick-zack-type flow
OP 2 Assembly 1 OP 4 Finishing
OP 1 Pre-
assembly OP 2 Assembly 1 OP 3 Assembly 2 OP 4 Finishing Line flow
problems that stand in your way from achieving continuous flow are problems that
are now visible and can be rectified. The ideal flow is the one-piece flow as shown in
Fig. 5.17.
The German word for timing, Tact refers to the rhythm at which goods or services
are produced to meet customer demand. With a consistent, continuous rhythm
providing a heartbeat for your production processes, it is far easier to regulate,
responding flexibly and effortlessly as demand rises or falls. Takt time is defined
as the average time available (time available minus breaks, maintenance or set-up)
divided by the customer requested quantity as shown in Fig. 5.18.
The average time between the start of production of one unit and the start of
production of the next unit, when these production starts are set to match the rate of
customer demand. For example, if a customer wants 15 units with the available time
of 9 min and the steady flow through the production line, the average time between
production starts should be 36 s for one part or unit (9 min multiplied by
60 s ¼ 540 s; 540 s divided by 15 unites requested by the customer ¼ 36 s per
part). In fact, the tact time simply reflects the rate of production needed to match the
demand. In the previous example, whether it takes 4 min or 4 years to produce the
product, the tact time is based on customer demand. If a process or a production line
is unable to produce at tact time, either demand levelling, additional resources, or
process re-engineering is needed to correct the issue (Helmold & Terry, 2017).
84 5 PM in Operations
INNOVATION KAIZEN
• Major change • Small steps
• High investment • Low investment
• Entrepreneurial risk • No risk
• Specialized team • Involvement of people
• Long term • Short term
• Management decision • Team decision approved by
management
Innovation KAIZEN
Improvements
Improvements
Time Time
Fig. 5.19 Innovation versus Kaizen. Source: Author’s own figure, adopted from Helmold (2010)
5.6 Andon
5.8 Gemba
Gemba (現場 also described as gemba) is also a Japanese term meaning “the real
place.” Japanese detectives call the crime scene gemba, and Japanese TV reporters
may refer to themselves as reporting from gemba. In business, gemba refers to the
place where value is created; in manufacturing the gemba is the factory floor. It can
be any “site” such as a construction site, sales floor or where the service provider
interacts directly with the customer. In lean production and supply management, the
idea of gemba is that the problems are visible, and the best improvement ideas will
come from going to the gemba. The gemba walk, much like Management walk
around (MBWA), is an activity that takes management to the front lines to look for
5.10 Health, Safety and Environment 87
waste and opportunities to practice gemba kaizen, or practical shop floor improve-
ment. In quality management, gemba means the manufacturing floor and the idea is
that if a problem occurs, the engineers must go there to understand the full impact of
the problem, gathering data from all sources. Unlike focus groups and surveys,
gemba visits are not scripted or bound by what one wants to ask. Glenn Mazur
introduced this term into quality function and supply management department (QFD,
a quality system for new products where manufacturing has not begun) to mean the
customer's place of business or lifestyle. The idea is that to be customer-driven, one
must go to the customer’s gemba to understand his problems and opportunities,
using all one’s senses to gather and process data.
Shadow boards are specific boards for parts, tools, equipment in operations,
manufacturing or service areas to reduce waste and waiting time.
The aim of the shadow board is to achieve an organized workplace where tools,
supplies and equipment are stored in appropriate locations close to the work area or
work stations. It provides the basis for standardization in the work place. They are a
simple and inexpensive tool which provides tangible efficiencies and cost savings as
well as intangible benefits. Figure 5.21 shows a shadow board for screws in
Mitsubishi Japan. The appropriate storage, allocation and preparation of screws
avoid waiting time and the possibility of errors. The advantages of using shadow
boards include avoiding waste, such as time looking for the appropriate tool or even
having to buy a new one, wasted time in looking for supplies and interchanging tools
between tasks. Shadow boards also provide the ability to quickly gauge the location
of tools and equipment or if they are missing. Shadow boards are used in the sort and
set in order stages of the implementation and operation of a 5S system in a workplace
and kaizen initiatives. Shadow boards can be different sizes and located in many
different areas of a process or plant. The key is that they are appropriately located
and hold all the necessary tools for the area or work station.
Health, safety and environment (HSE) is the concept and paradigm that implements
and secures practical aspects of environmental protection and safety at work. From a
health and safety standpoint, it involves creating organized efforts and procedures
for identifying workplace hazards and reducing accidents and exposure to harmful
situations and substances. It also includes training of personnel in accident preven-
tion, accident response, emergency preparedness, and use of protective clothing and
equipment. From an environmental standpoint, it involves creating a systematic
approach to complying with environmental regulations, such as managing waste or
air emissions all the way to helping operations’ departments reduce the company’s
carbon footprint. Successful HSE programs also include measures to address
88 5 PM in Operations
ergonomics, air quality, and other aspects of workplace safety that could affect the
health and well-being of employees and the overall community. Figure 5.22 displays
HSE requirements in a Chinese operations environment.
Companies such as Porsche have understood, that the low value adding activities of
the own organization lead automatically to increasing activities on the supply side
(Freitag, 2004). Porsche was also hampered by antiquated production methods.
5.11 Case Study: Porsche Using Lean Principles 89
Some 20% of its parts were delivered 3 or more days too late, for example. In
addition, supply disruptions led to severe problems in the value chain and caused
recalls (Greiml, 2010). The former head of Porsche, Dr. Wendelin Wiedeking, who
had been deeply impressed by what he had seen on visits to Japanese auto firms such
as Toyota, Nissan and Honda, believed that only a radical, “lean manufacturing”
cure would save the company. He flew in teams of the same Japanese consultants
who had helped Toyota and gave them free rein. “A cultural revolution from top to
bottom” is the way he describes what happened next, as the consultants organized
the workforce into teams and one by one eliminated poor practices. Wiedeking made
one now-fabled appearance on the assembly line wielding a circular saw, which he
used to cut down the roof-high racks of spare parts that towered over the production
line. After the lean cure of the own production facilities, Porsche extended the lean
concept to suppliers and established the supplier development department in 2006
(the name of the department is FEL, Finance-Purchasing, Supply Management).
This department is in charge of extending lean principles to the supply networks and
to synchronize production systems. In the following section the concept of lean
supply management will be discussed. Lean principles have:
• To continuously improve
• To apply a Pull-system
• To apply a learning organisation
References
Freitag, M. (2004). Toyota. Formel Toyota. Manager Magazine, 12, 12–14.
Greiml, H. (2010). The Toyota recall crisis. Toyota recalls 1.1m vehicles to fix floor mats.
Automotive News, pp. 12–15.
Helmold, M. (2010). Best-in-Class Lieferantenmanagement in der Automobilindustrie. Aachen:
Shaker.
Helmold, M., & Terry, B. (2017). Global sourcing and supply management excellence in China.
Singapore: Springer.
Kaizen Institute. (2019). Meaning of Kaizen. Retrieved March 1, 2019, from https://www.kaizen.
com/what-is-kaizen.html
Liker, J. K. (2004). The Toyota way. Madison, WI: McGraw-Hill.
Ohno, T. (1990). Toyota production system. Beyond large scale production. New York: Productiv-
ity Press.
PM in the Downstream Value Chain
6
Marc Helmold
Marketing (and sales) is the downstream activity in the value chain as illustrated in
Fig. 6.1. Marketing is a continually evolving discipline and as such can be one that
companies find themselves left very much behind the competition if they stand still
for too long. One example of this evolution has been the fundamental changes to the
basic marketing mix. Where once there were 4 Ps to explain the mix, nowadays it is
more commonly accepted that more developed 7 Ps add a much-needed additional
layer of depth to the marketing mix with some theorists going even further.
Product—The product should fit the task consumers want it for, it should work and it
should be what the consumers are expecting to get.
Place—The product should be available from where your target consumer finds it
easiest to shop. This may be high street, mail order or the more current option via
e-commerce or an online shop.
Price—The product should always be seen as representing good value for money.
This does not necessarily mean it should be the cheapest available; one of the
main tenets of the marketing concept is that customers are usually happy to pay a
little more for something that works really well for them.
Promotion—Advertising, PR, sales promotion, personal selling and, in more recent
times, social media are all key communication tools for an organisation. These
tools should be used to put across the organisation’s message to the correct
audiences in the manner they would most like to hear, whether it be informative
or appealing to their emotions.
Input-transformation-output
Supply Demand
side Procurement Operations Marketing side
(Supply) management (Sales)
Information
technology
Finance and (IT)
accounting
Human
resources Support functions
Fig. 6.1 Marketing and sales in the downstream value chain. Source: Author’s own figure
In the late 1970s, it was widely acknowledged by marketers that the marketing mix
should be updated. This led to the creation of the extended marketing mix in 1981 by
Booms and Bitner which added three new elements to the 4 Ps principles. This now
allowed the extended marketing mix to include products that are services and not just
physical things.
People—All companies are reliant on the people who run them from front-line sales
staff to the managing director. Having the right people is essential because they
are as much a part of your business offering as the products/services you are
offering.
Processes—The delivery of your service is usually done with the customer present
so how the service is delivered is once again part of what the consumer is
paying for.
Physical Evidence—Almost all services include some physical elements even if the
bulk of what the consumer is paying for is intangible. For example, a hair salon
would provide their client with a completed hairdo and an insurance company
would give their customers some form of printed material. Even if the material is
not physically printed (in the case of PDFs), they are still receiving a ‘physical
product’ by this definition.
Though in place since the 1980s, the 7 Ps are still widely taught due to their
fundamental logic being sound in the marketing environment and marketers’
abilities to adapt the marketing mix to include changes in communications such as
social media, updates in the places which you can sell a product/service or
customers’ expectations in a constantly changing commercial environment
(Fig. 6.2).
6.3 Incoterms 2010 93
Price Place
7Ps
Physical
Promotion
evidence
Process People
The International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) in Paris has been issuing ‘International
Rules for the Interpretation of Commercial Contract Formulas’ known as Incoterms
(International Commercial Terms) since 1923. The Incoterms rules have become an
essential part of the daily language of international trade. They have been incorporated in
contracts for the sale of goods worldwide and provide rules and guidance to importers,
exporters, lawyers, transporters, insurers and students of international trade. After ICC’s
creation in 1919, one of its first initiatives was to facilitate international trade activities. In
the early 1920s, the world business organization set out to understand the commercial
trade terms used by merchants. This was done through a study that was limited to six
commonly used terms in just 13 countries. The findings were published in 1923,
highlighting disparities in interpretation. To examine the discrepancies identified in the
initial survey, a second study was carried out. This time, the scope was expanded to the
interpretation of trade terms used in more than 30 countries in 1928. Based on the
findings of the studies, the first version of the Incoterms rules was published as a global
standard. The terms included FAS, FOB, C&F, CIF, ex ship and ex quay. Due to World
War II, supplementary revisions of the Incoterms rules were suspended and did not
resume again until the 1950s. The first revision of the Incoterms rules was then issued in
1953. It debuted three new trade terms for non-maritime transport. The new rules
comprised delivered costs paid (DCP), free on rail (FOR) and free on truck (FOT).
The ICC launched the third revision of the Incoterms rules, which dealt with
misinterpretations of the previous version. Two trade terms were added to address
delivery at frontier (DAF) and delivery at destination (DDP). The increased use of air
transportation gave cause for another version of the popular trade terms. This edition
94 6 PM in the Downstream Value Chain
included the new term FOB airport (free on board airport). This rule aimed to allay
confusion around the term free on board (FOB) by signifying the exact ‘vessel’ used.
With the expansion of carriage of goods in containers and new documentation processes,
came the need for another revision. This edition introduced the trade term FRC (free
carrier named at point), which provided for goods not actually received by the ship’s side
but at a reception point on shore, such as a container yard. The fifth revision simplified
the free carrier term by deleting rules for specific modes of transport (i.e. FOR, free on
rail; FOT, free on truck; and FOB airport, free on board airport). It was considered
sufficient to use the general term FCA (free carrier at named point) instead. Other provi-
sions accounted for increased use of electronic messages. The ‘License, Authorizations
and Formalities’ section of FAS and DEQ Incoterms rules were modified to comply with
the way most customs authorities address the issues of exporter and importer of record.
The Incoterms 2010 is the most current edition of the rules to date. This version
consolidated the D-family of rules, removing delivered at frontier (DAF), delivered ex
ship (DES), delivered ex quay (DEQ) and delivered duty unpaid (DDU) and adding
delivered at terminal (DAT) and delivered at place (DAP). Other modifications included
an increased obligation for buyer and seller to cooperate on information sharing and
changes to accommodate ‘string sales’. To keep pace with the ever-evolving global trade
landscape, the latest update to the trade terms is currently in progress and is set to be
unveiled in 2020. The Incoterms 2020 Drafting Group includes lawyers, traders and
company representatives from around the world. The overall process will take two years
as practical input on what works and what could possibly be improved will be collected
from a range of Incoterms rule users worldwide and studied (Table 6.1).
place. The goods can be consigned or non-consigned stock. The consigned stock is
owned by the supplier until the customer consumes it, and the non-consigned stock
is owned by the customer when the customer receives it.
Airbus SE, formerly Airbus Group SE, is a company based in the Netherlands that is
active in the aerospace and defence industry. The company operates through three
segments: Airbus Commercial Aircraft, Airbus Helicopters and Airbus Defence and
Space. The Airbus Commercial Aircraft segment focuses on the development,
manufacturing, marketing and sale of commercial jet aircraft and aircraft components,
as well as on aircraft conversion and related services. The Airbus Helicopters segment
specializes in the development, manufacturing, marketing and sale of civil and
military helicopters, as well as on the provision of helicopter-related services. The
Airbus Defence and Space segment produces military combat aircraft and training
aircraft, provides defence electronics and global security market solutions and
manufacturers and markets missiles. For the commercial side, more than 75% of the
value creation is done by suppliers. The suppliers are supplying components and
96 6 PM in the Downstream Value Chain
Fig. 6.3 Downstream supply chain of Airbus. Source: Author’s own figure, adopted from
SupplyOn (2019)
Portal Portal Portal Portal Portal Portal
AirSupply
Suppliers
Fig. 6.4 AirSupply. Source: Author’s own figure, adopted from SupplyOn (2019)
97
98 6 PM in the Downstream Value Chain
References
Helmold, M., & Terry, B. (2017). Lieferantenmanagement in China. DeGruyter: Berlin.
Helmold, M., Dathe, T., & Hummel, F. (2019). Erfolgreiche Verhandlungen. Best-in-Class Emp-
fehlungen für den Verhandlungsdurchbruch. Wiesbaden: Springer Gabler.
SupplyOn. (2019). www.supplyon.com
PM Models and Concepts
7
Marc Helmold
Financial: often renamed stewardship or other more appropriate name in the public
sector, this perspective views organizational financial performance and the use of
financial resources.
Figure 7.1 outlines the BSC including objectives, measurable, targets and actions.
For each objective on the strategy map, at least one measure or key performance
indicator (KPI) will be identified and tracked over time. KPIs indicate progress
towards a desirable outcome. Strategic KPIs monitor the implementation and effec-
tiveness of an organization’s strategies, determine the gap between actual and
targeted performance and determine organization effectiveness and operational
efficiency. The BSC ensures the following areas:
Advantages of the BSC are
Financial perspective
Measurables
Objectives
Targets
Actions
Measurables
Mission
Objectives
Objectives
Targets
Targets
Actions
Actions
Vision
Strategic Strategic
objectives Planning
Organisational
perspective
Measurables
Objectives
Targets
Actions
Fig. 7.1 Balance score card (BSC). Source: Author’s own figure
7.1 Balance Score Card (BSC) 101
It is based on historical data from the past and may thus lead to a distorted picture.
It can lead to a lack of long-term commitment and leadership for management due to
short-term objectives (micro-management).
It does not always express the interests of all stakeholders, but of few stakeholders.
It uses only quantitative key performance indicators and the approach may not show
the real world.
It has the danger to overload system with key performance indicators (KPI).
It may have a potential lack of employees’ awareness or a failure to communicate
information to all employees.
It is constructed as management reporting tool rather than improvement tool.
It shows that benchmarking based on KPIs in BSC and specific measures is difficult.
Figure 7.2 outlines the logic between the four perspectives. The balanced score-
card is used to improve the performance by strengthening the organization. The
improvements will lead to a better Q-C-D-plus alpha ratio throughout the organiza-
tion and thus satisfy the customers. As a result, financial performance will be
outstanding. The BSC is used to attain objectives, measurements, initiatives and
goals that result from these four primary functions of a business. Companies can
easily identify factors hindering company performance and outline strategic changes
tracked by future scorecards. With the balanced scorecard, they look at the company
as a whole when viewing company objectives. An organization may use the bal-
anced scorecard to implement strategy mapping to see where value is added within
an organization. A company also utilizes the balanced scorecard to develop strategic
initiatives and strategy objectives.
Cascading a balanced scorecard means to translate the corporate-wide scorecard
(referred to as Tier 1) down to first business units, support units or departments
102 7 PM Models and Concepts
Customer Q-C-D +
Satisfaction alpha Customer perspective
Organisational
Knowledge and Skills
perspective
(Tier 2) and then teams or individuals (Tier 3). The end result should be focused
across all levels of the organization that is consistent. The organization alignment
should be clearly visible through strategy, using the strategy map, performance
measures and targets and initiatives. Scorecards should be used to improve account-
ability through objective and performance measure ownership, and desired
employee behaviours should be incentivized with recognition and rewards.
There are several advantages of the BSC:
measuring what actually matters. Research shows that companies with a BSC
approach tend to report higher quality management information and better deci-
sion-making.
5. Improved Performance Reporting
The balanced scorecard can be used to guide the design of performance reports
and dashboards. This ensures that the management reporting focuses on the most
important strategic issues and helps companies monitor the execution of
their plan.
6. Better Organizational Alignment
The balanced scorecard enables companies to better align their organizational
structure with the strategic objectives. In order to execute a plan well, organizations
need to ensure that all business units and support functions are working towards the
same goals. Cascading the balanced scorecard into those units will help to achieve
that and link strategy to operations.
7. Better Process Alignment
Well-implemented balanced scorecards also help to align organizational pro-
cesses such as budgeting, risk management and analytics with the strategic
priorities. This will help to create a truly strategy focused organization.
ISO 9001 contains eight key principles of quality management which is not
auditable but do form the fundamental characteristics of quality management:
QMs are accredited by globally applied standards. The advantages of a QMS can
be outlined as follows:
tool to help organizations do this by measuring where they are on the path to
excellence, helping them understand the gaps and promoting solutions. EFQM is
an acronym that stands for the European Foundation for Quality Management.
EFQM was founded in 1988 with the objective to create a platform where
organizations can learn from each other to continuously improve their performance.
Benchmarking with other European organizations will lead to sustainable economic
growth. EFQM wants to open the chance to the organizations to define their current
‘level of excellence’ and where they need to focus on improvement efforts. More-
over, the model helps to ensure that organization decisions incorporate the needs of
all stakeholders and are aligned with the organization’s objectives, which in turn
supports managers and directors in training, sharing ideas and innovating with the
aid of the so-called EFQM model as a common framework. The EFQM model or
EFQM business excellence model is the most popular quality management tool in
Europe, used by more than 30,000 organizations to improve performance. It
supports you to self-assess and reflect. Eighty-four percent of the EFQM members
say that the EFQM model helps to improve their organization (EFQM, 2019). This
quality management model aims at sustainable excellence in which quality, effi-
ciency and sustainability are the key elements. The basis of the EFQM Model
consists of the total quality management (TQM) concept. It consists of a universal
framework of concepts, thus enabling organizations to share information in an
effective way, irrespective of the different sectors, cultures and life stages in which
they are located. Organizations can thus take other organizations as a model, so that
they obtain insights into how far they meet the image of a high-quality organization.
The EFQM model consists of nine criteria that are subdivided into five enablers and
four results: This is the model behind the European Business Excellence Award, an
award process run by the European Foundation for Quality Management (EFQM).
This framework is used as the basis for national business excellence and quality
awards across Europe. The model consists of nine categories:
1. Leadership
2. Policy and strategy
3. People
4. Partnerships and resources
5. Processes
6. Customer results
7. People results
8. Society results
9. Key performance results
The fundamental concepts that underpin the EFQM excellence model are:
Results orientation
Customer focus
Leadership and constancy of purpose
Management by processes and facts
106 7 PM Models and Concepts
The EFQM model must be read from right to left, as a result of which it becomes
clear that the result areas focus on ‘what can be achieved?’, after which it becomes
clear that these organizational areas focus on ‘how can these results be achieved?’.
The bottom arrow, ‘learning, creativity and innovation’, indicates that measuring,
evaluating and adjusting are not one-off actions but a continuous process. In the
same process organizations complete a step-by-step development.
7.3.3 Self-Assessment
The assessments allow an organization to gain insights into the quality of its current
operational management. Improvements are formulated and these can be
implemented by an organization in stages. The assessment itself consists of five
steps:
This is the model behind the US Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award, an
award process administered by the American Society for Quality (ASQ) and man-
aged by the National Institute of Science and Technology (NIST), an agency of the
US department of Commerce. This framework is used as the basis for over 70 other
7.5 Business PM Improvement Resource Model (BPIR) 107
national Business Excellence/Quality awards around the world. The model consists
of seven categories
1. Leadership
2. Strategic planning
3. Customer and market focus
4. Measurement, analysis and knowledge management
5. Workforce focus
6. Process management
7. Business results
The core concepts of the Baldrige Criteria for Performance Excellence are:
Visionary leadership
Customer-driven excellence
Organizational and personal learning
Valuing employees and partners
Agility
Focus on the future
Managing for innovation
Management by fact
Social responsibility
Focus on results and creating value
Systems perspective
The PM excellence model by Dr. Helmold focuses on the value chain with its
primary and secondary functions as outlined in Fig. 7.3. Primary functions are
supply, operations and marketing and sales. Secondary or support functions are IT,
HR or finance. The model is process oriented and focuses on 15 categories, where
value is generated. The 15 categories are (Fig. 7.4):
1. Corporate strategy
2. Organizational improvement
3. Supply management
4. Supplier and partnerships
5. Cooperation and collaboration
6. Value chain visibility
7. B2B and B2C collaboration
8. Risk management
9. Demand scheduling and operations
10. Quality performance
11. Learning and growth
Enablers Results
People People
10% results
10% Business
Processes, results
Leadership Strategy products Customer Key
10% 10% and services results performan-
10% 15% ce results
15%
Partnerships Society
& resources results
10% 10%
Innovation, Learning and Improvements
Fig. 7.3 EFQM model. Source: Author’s own figure, adjusted from the EFQM model (EFQM,
2019)
Primary value Value chain PM2E
contributors
Corporate strategy
Supply side Purchasing Operations Marketing & Demand side
OrganisaƟonl improvement
(Suppliers) Management Management Sales (Customers) Supply management
Supplier and partnerships
CooperaƟon and collaboraƟon
Value chain visiblity
B2B and B2C collaboraƟon
Risk management
Demand scheduling & operaƟons
Secondary value
Quality performance
contributors Learning and growth
7.6 Performance Management to Excellence Model (PM2E)
Fig. 7.4 PM2E excellence model by Dr. Marc Helmold. Source: Author’s own figure
109
110 7 PM Models and Concepts
In 2015, the BMW factory in Regensburg (Germany) won the EFQM excellence
award. Year by year the BMW plant Regensburg could achieve positive results in all
fields by the EFQM assessors (EFQM, 2018). Not only costs are in the target focus
but also other elements like service, quality, people and innovation. The plant agrees
each year on new, increased targets with sustainable improvements. They belong to
the EFQM criteria customer-oriented results, employee-oriented results, society
oriented results and key results. The BMW plant Regensburg’s KPI landscape
combined with necessary enablers is a real achievement which could be developed
over the years with the help of EFQM structures, assessments and feedbacks. It grew
to a perfect interaction between all technologies (quality, logistics and controlling,
paint and body shop, assembly, human resources) that work together with
harmonized targets to reach positive results. In 2010, the Plant Leadership Circle
revised the management process in order to increase its transparency. This is when
the process was given its current structure of two interconnected loops, which mark
the distinction between the long-term perspective and the short-term derivation of
activities over a 1-year period. Each year the strategic and operative excellence is
discussed and finally signed in three-level target agreements that go also down to the
shop floor.
References
EFQM. (2018). www.efqm.com
EFQM. (2019). www.efqm.com
Kaplan, R., & Norton, D. P. (1992). The balanced scorecard (BSC). Measures that drive per-
formance. Harvard Business Review. 01-02/1992.
Kaplan, R., & Norton, D. P. (1996). Using the balanced scorecard as a strategic management
system. Harvard Business Review. 01-02/1996.
Tools in PM
8
Marc Helmold
The will to win, the desire to succeed, the urge to reach your
full potential—these are the keys that will unlock the door to
personal excellence.
Kurt Tucholsky (1890–1935)
Macro analysis
Environmental Social
Technological
a business could be classified here. This can include government policy, political
stability or instability, corruption, foreign trade policy, tax policy, labour law, envi-
ronmental law and trade restrictions. Furthermore, the government may have a
profound impact on a nation’s education system, infrastructure and health regulations.
These are all factors that need to be taken into account when assessing the attractive-
ness of a potential market (Helmold et al., 2019; Johnson & Scholes, 1997).
A PESTEL analysis helps an organization identify the external forces that could
impact their market and analyse how they could directly impact their business. It’s
important when undertaking such an analysis that the factors affecting the organiza-
tion are not just identified but are also assessed—for example, what impact might
they have on the organization? The outcomes of a PESTEL analysis can then be used
to populate the opportunities and threats in an industry and the SWOT analysis
(Helmold et al., 2019; Johnson & Scholes, 1997).
114 8 Tools in PM
Porter’s five forces is a simple but powerful tool for understanding the competitive-
ness of your business environment and for identifying your strategy’s potential
profitability. The tool was created by Harvard Business School professor Michael
E. Porter to analyse an industry’s attractiveness and likely profitability. Since the first
publication in 1979, it has become one of the most popular and highly regarded
business strategy tools (Porter, 1985). Porter recognized that organizations likely
keep a close watch on their rivals, but he encouraged them to look beyond the actions
of their competitors and examine what other factors could impact the business
environment. He identified five forces that make up the competitive environment,
and which can erode your profitability. These are rivalry among competitors,
bargaining power of suppliers, bargaining power of buyers, threat of new entrants
and threat of substitutes (Helmold et al., 2019; Johnson & Scholes, 1997; Porter,
1985).
This looks at the number and strength of your competitors. How many rivals do you
have? Who are they, and how does the quality of their products and services compare
with yours?
Where rivalry is intense, companies can attract customers with aggressive price
cuts and high-impact marketing campaigns (Porter, 1985). Also, in markets with lots
of rivals, your suppliers and buyers can go elsewhere if they feel that they’re not
getting a good deal from you. On the other hand, where competitive rivalry is
minimal, and no one else is doing what you do, then you’ll likely have tremendous
strength and healthy profits (Helmold et al., 2019; Johnson & Scholes, 1997).
This is determined by how easy it is for your suppliers to increase their prices. How
many potential suppliers do you have? How unique is the product or service that they
provide, and how expensive would it be to switch from one supplier to another? The
more you have to choose from, the easier it will be to switch to a cheaper alternative.
But the fewer suppliers there are, and the more you need their help, the stronger their
position and their ability to charge you more. That can impact your profit (Porter,
1985).
8.2 Porter’s Five Forces (Industry Analysis) 115
Here, you ask yourself how easy it is for buyers to drive your prices down. How
many buyers are there, and how big are their orders? How much would it cost them
to switch from your products and services to those of a rival? Are your buyers strong
enough to dictate terms to you?
When you deal with only a few savvy customers, they have more power, but your
power increases if you have many customers (Porter, 1985).
This refers to the likelihood of your customers finding a different way of doing what
you do. For example, if you supply a unique software product that automates an
important process, people may substitute it by doing the process manually or by
outsourcing it. A substitution that is easy and cheap to make can weaken your
position and threaten your profitability.
Your position can be affected by people’s ability to enter your market. So, think
about how easily this could be done. How easy is it to get a foothold in your industry
or market? How much would it cost, and how tightly is your sector regulated?
If it takes little money and effort to enter your market and compete effectively, or
if you have little protection for your key technologies, then rivals can quickly enter
your market and weaken your position. If you have strong and durable barriers to
entry, then you can preserve a favourable position and take fair advantage of it
(Porter, 1985) (Fig. 8.2).
Threat of
subsitutes
Industry analysis
Bargaining
Rivalry amongst Bargaining
power of
competitors power of buyers
suppliers
Micro analysis
Threat of new
entrants
Opportunities Threats
(external) (external)
Monetary risks and opportunities (ROP analysis) Projects often have a multi-year
life cycle from development to delivery to after-service (Helmold & Terry, 2016a).
Each project involves risks and opportunities (ROPs) in connection with project
completion. A risk is a potential event with a negative impact. The event lies in the
8.5 Margin Enhancement Plan Analysis (MEP) 117
ROP analysis
future of the project and jeopardizes or weakens the successful achievement of the
project. These risks belittle the profitability of the project in a monetary sense. The
opportunities, on the other hand, are events that have a positive impact on the project
outcome. In practice, these risks and opportunities are correlated with probability
factors and quantified in monetary terms (Helmold & Terry, 2016b) (Fig. 8.4;
Table 8.1).
8.6 5F Concept
McKinsey 7s model (see Fig. 8.5) is a tool that analyses firm’s organizational design
by looking at seven key internal elements: strategy, structure, systems, shared
values, style, staff and skills, in order to identify if they are effectively aligned and
allow organization to achieve its objectives. McKinsey 7s model was developed in
1980s by McKinsey consultants Tom Peters, Robert Waterman and Julien Philips
with help from Richard Pascale and Anthony G. Athos. Since the introduction, the
8.9 Recommendations of Ideal Tools in Negotiations 119
Hard S categories
Structure
Strategy Systems
7-S model: McKinsey
Shared
values
Skills Style
Staff
Soft S categories
model has been widely used by academics and practitioners and remains one of the
most popular strategic planning tools. It sought to present an emphasis on human
resources (soft S), rather than the traditional mass production tangibles of capital,
infrastructure and equipment, as a key to higher organizational performance. The
goal of the model was to show how seven elements of the company, structure,
strategy, skills, staff, style, systems, and shared values, can be aligned together to
achieve effectiveness in a company. The key point of the model is that all the seven
areas are interconnected and a change in one area requires change in the rest of a firm
for it to function effectively. You can find the McKinsey model, which represents the
connections between seven areas and divides them into ‘soft Ss’ and ‘hard Ss’. The
shape of the model emphasizes interconnectedness of the elements.
Table 8.4 Recommendati- Usage of classical tools like PESTEL or the industry analysis
ons and summary of tools
Regular identification of strengths and weaknesses (SWOT)
for negotiations
Determination of opportunities and threats
Monetary quantification of risks and opportunities
Proactive plan in negotiations to improve the margin and
profitability via action
Usage of the 5F concept in negotiations
120 8 Tools in PM
The Porter’s five forces that determine the industry structure in airline are:
1. Threat of new entrants in the airline industry—If there is strong threat of new
entrants in the airline industry, then current players will be willing to earn lower
profits to reduce the threats from new players.
2. Bargaining power of buyers of Lufthansa and transportation sector—If the buyers
have strong bargaining power, then they usually tend to drive price down thus
limiting the potential of Lufthansa to earn sustainable profits.
3. Bargaining power of suppliers in airline—If suppliers have strong bargaining
power, then they will extract higher price from Lufthansa. It will impact the
potential of Lufthansa to maintain above average profits in the airline industry.
4. Threat of substitute products and services in the airline sector—If the threat of
substitute is high, then Lufthansa has to either continuously invest into R&D or it
risks losing out to disruptors in the industry.
5. Rivalry among existing players in the airline industry—If competition is intense,
then it becomes difficult for existing players such as Lufthansa to earn sustainable
profits.
The centre target of strategists and pioneers at Lufthansa is to help the organiza-
tion to assemble a supportable upper hand and impede competitive difficulties from
different players in the airline business.
Threat of new
entrants
MEDIUM
Threat of
substitutes
HIGH
Step 1—Defining relevant industry for Lufthansa. For the purpose of this paper,
Lufthansa does mostly its business in the airline industry.
Step 2—Identify the competitors of Lufthansa and group them based on the
segments within the transportation industry.
Step 3—Assess the Porter’s five forces in relation to the airline industry and assess
which forces are strong in airline and which forces are weak.
Step 4—Determine overall transportation industry structure and test analysis for
consistency
Step 5—Analyse recent and future changes in each of the forces in the airline
industry. This can help in predicting the trend in overall transportation sector.
Step 6—Identify aspects of industry structure based on Porter’s five forces that might
be influenced by Lufthansa’s competitors and new entrants in the airline industry.
To achieve above average profits compared to other players in the airline industry
in the long run, Lufthansa needs to develop a sustainable competitive advantage.
Airline industry analysis using Porter’s five forces can help Lufthansa to map the
various forces and identify spaces where Lufthansa can position itself.
By doing industry analysis using Porter’s five forces, Lufthansa can develop four
generic competitive strategies.
The four generic strategies are based on Porter’s five forces analysis of Lufthansa.
Cost Leadership
In cost leadership, Lufthansa can set out to become the low-cost producer in the
airline industry. How it can become cost leader varies based on the transportation
industry forces and structure. In pursuing cost leadership strategy, company name
can assess pursuit of economies of scale, proprietary technology, supply chain
management options, diversification of suppliers, preferential access to raw
materials and other factors.
Differentiation
Lufthansa can also pursue differentiation strategy based on the airline industry
forces. In a differentiation strategy, Lufthansa can seek to be unique in the airline
industry by providing a value proposition that is cherished by customers. Lufthansa
can select one or more attributes in terms of products and services that customers in
the airline value most. The goal is to seek premium price because of differentiation
and uniqueness of the offerings. Industry analysis of airline using Porter’s five forces
can help Lufthansa to avoid spaces that are already overpopulated by the
competitors.
(a) In cost focus, Lufthansa can seek a cost advantage in its chosen segment in the
transportation sector.
(b) In differentiation strategy, company name can differentiate itself in a target
segment in the transportation sector. Both variants of the focus strategy rest
on differences between Lufthansa’s target segment and other segments in the
airline industry.
References
Helmold, M., Dathe, T., & Hummel, F. (2019). Erfolgreiche Verhandlungen. Best-in-Class
Empfehlungen für den Verhandlungsdurchbruch. Wiesbaden: Springer Gabler.
Helmold, M., & Terry, B. (2016a). Lieferantenmanagement 2030. Wiesbaden: Springer.
Helmold, M., & Terry, B. (2016b). Global sourcing and supply management excellence in China.
Singapore: Springer.
Johnson, G., & Scholes, K. (1997). Exploring corporate strategy. Text and cases (4th ed.). London:
Prentice Hall.
Porter, M. E. (1985). Competitive advantage. Creating and sustaining superior performance.
New York: Free Press.
PM in Project Management
9
Marc Helmold
According to the project management manual, projects have certain criteria (PM,
2018). Key criteria for projects can be defined in Table 9.1 as follows. If these
project criteria are not met, there is usually no real project. This does not mean that
methods of project management cannot be put to good use beyond project work.
However, one should not speak of project work in order not to confuse.
Projects always include an organizational structure and a process organization.
The organizational structure forms the hierarchical framework of the project organi-
zation and defines the organizational framework: (1) which tasks are to be managed
by which functional units and sub-departments. By contrast, the process organiza-
tion regulates the processes that take place within this framework (process and
information processes within the project phases). Companies usually have a line
organization or a project matrix organization, whereby in many cases there is a
combination or a hybrid of both forms of organization. Projects usually take place
under pressure of costs, production and performance, so that projects involve
numerous negotiations. For the realization of projects, project teams are formed,
which consist of different functions (PM, 2018). These then take over control and
steering tasks as part of project management (PM, 2018). Projects go through four
phases as shown in Fig. 9.1. Projects start with a feasibility check. If the feasibility is
given, project planning will begin in the next phase. In this context, a project
assignment is recommended in which important key figures such as quality, costs,
time or resources are clearly defined (PM, 2018). After confirmation of all features,
the project can be started in phase three. After successful completion of the project,
the project validation takes place with a target/actual comparison. In particular,
deviations must be negotiated via the supplementary management.
Complex projects are usually carried out in cross-functional and interdisciplinary
project groups, which contain experts from departments like project management,
procurement, production, marketing and sales, quality management, finance and
controlling or other departments as shown in Fig. 9.2 (Helmold, Dathe & Hummel,
2019). Advantages of a project management organization are the following:
The project management manual defines key criteria and success factors for
controlling and steering projects (PM, 2018). These criteria comprise a total of
nine categories that must be taken into account for the successful completion of
the project.
The project scope management deals with the ongoing planning and control of the
progress of the project. As part of the scope management, it is checked at regular
intervals whether the project is within the objectives defined in the project order or
whether there are deviations. Project scope management includes project initiation,
content and scope planning, performance definition, performance verification and
performance review (PM, 2018).
Cost management includes the cost and expenses for the approved project (PM,
2018). Objective of this category is that the project is monitored and closed within
the anticipated budgets. Subcategories of the cost management are resource
planning, cost estimations, budgeting and cost control (PM, 2018).
Quality management in projects should ensure that the quality requirements defined
by the client are met or even exceeded. These include quality planning, quality
assurance and quality control (PM, 2018).
The main task of HR management is to make sure that the people involved in the
project work as efficiently as possible. The following functions and tasks can be
assigned to personnel management: project organization, personnel acquisition and
team development (PM, 2018).
Risk Management describes all the iterative processes necessary to identify, analyse
and respond to project risks. These include risk identification, risk assessment, risk
mitigating and risk tracking (PM, 2018).
Projects with complex objectives need a competent project leader or manager. This
requires both hard (e.g. project management skills) and soft skills (e.g. emotional
intelligence) to convince both internally and externally. In addition to a good and
sustainable relationship with the management, one of the key components of project
managers is to lead a team successfully. Project managers must choose their
employees to have a healthy mix of expertise and social skills. Projects should be
projected by a robust project job in which performance parameters are clearly
defined and scheduled (PM, 2018). Goals must have specific attributes and be
specific, measurable, acceptable, realistic and timed (SMART methodology:
English, specific, measurable, achievable, realistic and timely). Sustainability as
well as a permanent and regular success control completes the SMART goals.
Here an incentive system is recommended, so that employees are sufficiently
motivated by material or immaterial advantages for project success. Internationality
and diversity strengthen project teams and help to successfully implement projects in
an international context. The use of digital media supports networking, especially
across country borders and time zones. Finally, organizations should allow project
members to return to the line function. Table 9.2 summarizes the main
recommendations (PM, 2018).
The North American Chicago Transit Authority (CTA) announced that it had
awarded the order to build 846 7000-series rail cars to CRRC subsidiary CSR Sifang
America, which had submitted the most competitive bid in terms of cost, quality,
delivery time, design and other project elements. It did not name the other bidders.
The company, formed from the merger of former rivals CNR Corp and China CSR,
won its first US contract in 2014 when CNR was awarded a $567 million deal to
supply subway trains to Boston. Chicago will first place a base order of 400 cars,
References 129
with options to buy the remainder in the coming years, the CTA said. CSR will build
a new $40 million factory in the city, with the aim of seeing the first cars going into
service in 2020. CRRC undertakes design, manufacture, testing, commissioning and
maintenance of locomotives and rolling stock, including electric locomotives,
diesel-electric and diesel-hydraulic locomotives; suburban and regional transport;
trams and light rail vehicles; metro cars and passenger coaches; as well as full line of
rolling stock cars. This Chinese state-owned rail company’s assembly plant that will
produce up to 846 new rail cars for the Chicago Transit Authority. The project will
return CTA rail car manufacturing to Chicago after a 50-year absence, according to
the city. CRRC Sifang will invest $100 million in building a 380,944-square-foot
manufacturing facility on 45 acres in Chicago’s Hegewisch neighbourhood on the
Southeast Side. Production will begin in early 2019. The facility will begin testing
the new car prototype later that year and the cars will hit the rails by 2020.
References
Helmold, M., Dathe, T., & Hummel, F. (2019). Erfolgreiche Verhandlungen. Best-in-Class
Empfehlungen für den Verhandlungsdurchbruch. Wiesbaden: Springer Gabler.
PM. (2018). Retrieved July 7, 2018, from http://www.pm-handbuch.com/begriffe/
Financial PM
10
Marc Helmold
10.1 Financial PM
Financial performance is a subjective measure of how well a firm can use assets from
its primary mode of business and generate revenues. This term is also used as a
general measure of a firm’s overall financial health over a given period of time and
can be used to compare similar firms across the same industry or to compare
industries. There are many different ways to measure financial performance, but
all measures should be taken in aggregation. Line items such as revenue from
operations, operating income or cash flow from operations can be used, as well as
total unit sales. Furthermore, the analyst or investor may wish to look deeper into
financial statements and seek out margin growth rates or any declining debt.
Financial performance analysis includes analysis and interpretation of financial
statements in such a way that it undertakes full diagnosis of the profitability and
financial soundness of the business. The financial analyst programme provides vital
methodologies of financial analysis.
The balance sheet is a financial statement that reports a company’s assets, liabilities
and shareholders’ equity at a specific point in time and provides a basis for comput-
ing rates of return and evaluating its capital structure as shown in Fig. 10.1. It is a
financial statement that provides a snapshot of what a company owns and owes, as
well as the amount invested by shareholders. It is used alongside other important
financial statements such as the income statement and statement of cash flows in
Current Long-term
assets liabilities
The income statement provides a summary of operations for the entire year. The
income statement starts with sales or revenue and ends with net income. Also
referred to as the profit and loss statement, the income statement provides the
gross profit margin, the cost of goods sold, operating profit margin and net profit
margin. It also provides an overview of the number of shares outstanding as well as a
comparison against prior year performance. Figure 10.2 outlines the P & L statement
with a loss (red) or a profit (green).
The cash flow statement is a combination of both the income statement and the
balance sheet. For certain experts, the income articulation is the most vital monetary
statement since it gives a compromise between total compensation and cash flow.
This is where analysts can see how much the company is spending on stock
repurchases, dividends and capital expenditures. It also provides the source and
uses of cash flow from operations, investing and financing.
Areas of Financial Performance Analysis:
10.2 Financial Ratios in PM 133
Revenues Material
expenses
Special Salary
revenues expenses
Other
expenses
Loss Profit
Financial analysts often assess the firm’s production and productivity perfor-
mance (total business performance), profitability performance, liquidity perfor-
mance, working capital performance, fixed assets performance, fund flow
performance and social performance. Financial ratios analysis includes:
Profitability ratios: measure a company’s ability to generate profitable sales from its
assets.
Liquidity ratios: measure a company’s ability to meet its short-term obligations.
Solvency ratios: measure a company’s ability to meet its long-term obligations.
Activity ratios: measure how efficiently a company performs day-to-day tasks,
e.g. collection of receivables.
Other ratios: measure other important elements in financial PM (asset turnover or
growth rate) (Fig. 10.3).
134 10 Financial PM
Other Liquidity
ratios ratios
Activity Solvency
ratios ratios
significantly lowers its credit rating with banks, lenders, suppliers or investors
(Schmuck, 2013). Limiting access to funds typically leads to liquidity issues and
results often in a company failing as shown in Fig. 13.1 (four phases model of
Müller). Poor sales growth or decline indicates the market is not positively receiving
a company’s products or services based on its business model. When extreme
marketing activities result in no growth, the market may not be satisfied with the
offerings, and the company may close down. Likewise, if a company offers poor
quality in its products or services, consumers start buying from competitors, eventu-
ally forcing a business to close its doors. When debtors take too much time paying
their debts to the company, cash flow may be severely stretched. The business may
be unable to pay its own liabilities. The risk is especially enhanced when a company
has one or two major customers (Helmold et al., 2019). Müller describes four phases
(see Fig. 11.1): a strategic crisis, a profitability crisis, a liquidity crisis and insolvency
(Müller, 1986; Helmold et al., 2019). Müller describes the strategic crisis as threat to
the potential and substance of a company, which occurs due to inadequate strategies
in terms of differentiation, knowledge, innovation or cost advantages (Schmuck,
2013). In this strategic phase, market needs and elements are not fully taken into
account, so that the foundation of the company is gradually weakening (Helmold
et al., 2019). In this situation, the symptoms are weak, the corrective actions are long
term and the need for actions is rather low compared to the following phases (Müller,
1986). The strategic phase is followed by the profitability crisis, which is
characterized by signs of a weak financial performance in terms of revenues, cost,
cash and profitability (Schmuck, 2013). Signs in this phase are stronger, often
resulting in a loss, struggling to achieve targeted financial ratios or
non-achievement of profit targets (Schmuck, 2013). The third phase is the liquidity
crisis, in which a company is not capable of meeting its financial obligations
anymore (Schmuck, 2013). This situation is severe as the cash situation and balance
is not sufficient to pay the debts. As the credit rating decreases in this phase,
companies tend to borrow money with higher interest rates or to prolong payments
to suppliers, employees or banks where possible (Helmold et al., 2019). The last
phase of the model by Müller is insolvency (Müller, 1986). Insolvency is the state of
being unable to pay the money owed, by a person or company, on time. Those
companies in a state of insolvency are said to be insolvent. There are two forms:
cash-flow insolvency and balance-sheet insolvency. Cash-flow insolvency is when a
person or company has enough assets to pay what is owed, but does not have the
appropriate form of payment. For example, a person may own a large house and a
valuable car, but not have enough liquid assets to pay a debt when it falls due. Cash-
flow insolvency can usually be resolved by negotiation. For example, the bill
collector may wait until the car is sold and the debtor agrees to pay a penalty.
Balance-sheet insolvency is when a company does not have enough assets to pay all
of their debts. The person or company might enter bankruptcy, but not necessarily.
Once a loss is accepted by all parties, negotiation is often able to resolve the situation
without bankruptcy. A company that is balance-sheet insolvent may still have
enough cash to pay its next bill on time. However, most laws will not let the
company pay that bill unless it will directly help all their creditors. For example,
136 10 Financial PM
Impacts on acƟons
Phase 1 Phase 2 Phase 3 Phase 4
Long-term Medium-term Short-term
Insolvency
Liquidity
Profitability Crisis
Strategic crisis
StarƟng crisis
point
Fig. 10.4 Phases to financial insolvency. Source: Helmold et al. (2019), adapted from Müller’s
four phases model. Müller (1986)
an insolvent farmer may be allowed to hire people to help harvest the crop, because
not harvesting and selling the crop would be even worse for his creditors. In some
jurisdictions, it is illegal under the insolvency laws for a company to continue in
business while insolvent. In others (like the USA with its insolvency law and
Chap. 11 provisions), the business may continue under a declared protective
arrangement while alternative options to achieve recovery are worked out. Increas-
ingly, legislatures have favoured alternatives to winding up companies for good. The
major focus of modern insolvency legislation in many countries and business debt
restructuring practices no longer rests on the liquidation and elimination of insolvent
entities but on the remodelling of the financial and organizational structure of debtors
experiencing a financial crisis so as to permit the rehabilitation and continuation of
their business (Helmold et al., 2019). This is known as restructuring, business
turnaround, financial crisis mitigation or business recovery. Implementing a business
restructuring plan includes various measures and can be described (Fig. 10.4).
costs, such as payroll, operations and supplier’s cost, or reducing its size through the
sale of assets. Restructuring is often linked to external experts who help the company
to restructure its operations, performance and financials. Restructuring means to
have the appropriate actions and leads to many discussions and negotiations with
stakeholders like employees, suppliers or customers to fundamentally improve the
financial situation of a company (Schmuck, 2013; Helmold et al., 2019). Due to the
vital significance, restructuring plans must be designed, executed and controlled by
top management (Helmold et al., 2019). Restructuring involves top management and
negotiations with stakeholders (source adapted from Helmold et al., 2019). The four
types of restructuring can be outlined as shown in Fig. 11.2:
• Strategic restructuring
• Structural restructuring
• Restructuring for profit improvements
• Financial restructuring (Fig. 10.5)
Financial
turnaround
Structural Financial
restructuring restructuring
138 10 Financial PM
had diversified into wireless communication in the 1990s and fixed-line phone
service, redesigning its strategic portfolio and strategy. Mannesmann could hence
increase its value significantly and was later merged with Vodafone (Krahnen &
Schmidt, 2004). Another example are supermarket chains like REWE in Germany,
which entered the other business areas (discount, specialist and deliver service area
or tourism and travel, thus increasing business and wealth) (Rewe, 2015).
The balance sheet is a statement of the financial position of a business which states
the assets, liabilities and owner’s equity at a particular point in time. In other words,
the balance sheet illustrates your business’s net worth. The balance sheet may also
have details from previous years so you can do a back-to-back comparison of two
consecutive years. This data will help you track your performance and will identify
ways in which one can build up your finances and see where you need to improve.
One can also use the balance sheet to determine how to meet the financial obligations
and figure out the best ways in which you can use credit to finance the company’s
operations. The balance sheet is the most important of the three main financial
statements used to illustrate the financial health of a business. Figure 11.3 illustrates
the areas of negotiations and how the negotiations influence the situation of the
balance sheet (Olfert, 2013, 2015). A standard company balance sheet has two sides:
assets on the left and financing, which itself has two parts, liabilities and ownership
equity, on the right. The main categories of assets are usually listed first and typically
in order of liquidity. Assets are followed by the liabilities. The difference between
the assets and the liabilities is known as equity or the net assets or the net worth or
capital of the company, and according to the accounting equation, net worth must
equal assets minus liabilities. Another way to look at the balance sheet equation is
that total assets equal liabilities plus owner’s equity. Looking at the equation in this
way shows how assets were financed: either by borrowing money (liability) or by
using the owner’s money (owner’s or shareholders’ equity). Balance sheets are
usually presented with assets in one section and liabilities and net worth in the
other section with the two sections ‘balancing’. In a financial crisis, companies will
sell unnecessary fixed assets like land and real estate, buildings or machines in order
to obtain additional revenues and cash. Investments with a high amount of funding
must be limited to necessary purchases; in some cases, it is possible to lease instead
of purchasing. Secondly, inventories and supplies (assets) must be evaluated.
Inventories must be reduced or fully eliminated, so that any associated cost of
working capital can be reduced. A recommendation in this context is the agreement
of vendor-managed inventories (VMI), in which the suppliers (vendors) take care of
their inventories. Vendor-managed inventory (VMI) is a supply chain management
(SCM) and logistics tool, in which a supplier of goods, usually the manufacturer, is
responsible for optimizing and managing the inventory held by himself or a ware-
house attributor (Helmold & Terry, 2016). VMI requires a communication link,
usually typically electronic data interchange or Internet platforms, which provides
the supplier with the customers’ sales figures and forecasts. Based on forecasts, the
140 10 Financial PM
suppliers keep and own the inventory until the goods are called off by the customer.
The benefits of a vendor-managed inventory system include better inventory accu-
racy, forecasting and service (Helmold & Terry, 2016). Other assists like patents,
intellectual proprietary rights or brand names can be liquidated into cash to help
improve the financial situation. An example is the Ford Motor Company, which
faced financial distress in 2006. Ford had to get a life-saving loan by providing the
rights of the Ford logo to investors to receive money (Vlasic, 2012). The other side
of the balance sheet contains equity capital, which are shares and loans. In this area,
companies have to negotiate with investors on additional investments or shares. The
banks play an important role when negotiating on loan conditions, repayments or
shifting short-term debts into long-term debts (Helmold et al., 2019). In many cases,
companies also pay their invoices from suppliers or salaries later in order to improve
the balance sheet (Helmold et al., 2019) (Fig. 10.6).
The profit and loss account (P & L statement or account) or company statement is a
financial statement that summarizes the revenues, costs and expenses incurred
during a specified period. The P & L account provides information about a
company’s ability or inability to generate profit by increasing revenue, reducing
costs or both. Some refer to the P & L statement as a statement of profit and loss,
income statement, statement of operations, statement of financial results or income,
earnings statement and expense statement. Figure 11.4 shows a P & L account
including revenues (left side) and cost or expenses of the company (right side)
(Olfert, 2015). Revenues contain sales or special revenues from activities that are
not directly linked with the business of the company. Expenses normally include
material expenses, salary expenses and other expenses (Olfert, 2015). The trend to
concentrate on core competencies leads in many organizations to a high portion of
material expenses (Fig. 10.7).
Figure 11.5 outlines the way restructuring is aimed at improving the revenue
situation with a parallel reduction of expenses in order to become profitable (profit in
green). Cost reduction initiatives target elements for which the customer is not
willing to pay. These elements are described as waste and must be eliminated or
reduced. The cost emphasis focuses therefore on the efficiency of the firm’s pro-
cesses. General cost reduction efforts (e.g. lean management, downsizing) do not
necessarily improve efficiency, but quality efforts that reduce costs always
do. Successful programmes tend to increase the productivity of quality efforts by
reducing the input (labour and materials) required to produce a unit of output. These
improvements can be incremental (continuous improvement) or discontinuous (pro-
cess reengineering). In either case, the focus is internal and the goal is to reduce
costs. Customer satisfaction improvements are sought only indirectly, through such
results as increased reliability or lower prices. Cost reduction programmes thus
transfer their savings to the bottom line directly and can be applied to all areas of
the value chain (Fig. 10.8).
10.5
Balance sheet
• Land & real-estate • Common stock
• Buildings • Retained earnings Equity
Fixed • Machines • Acumen
assets • Vehicles
Fixed Equity • Other earnings
capital
• Equipment
assets capital
• Loans payable
• Cash • Notes payable Long-
Current • Money Current Long-term • Bonds payable
•Inventory
term
• Long-term payables
assets •Supplies assets liabiliƟes liabiliƟes
Balance Sheet, Profit and Loss and Cash Situation
• Restructuring
• Sale of shares Long-
• Investments stops Special Salary •Reorganisation
Special • Centralisation
• Sale of buildings term
revenues • Sale of fixed assets revenues expenses • Service Centres
• Lease back liabilities
Fig. 10.7 P & L account with improvement actions. Source: Author’s own figure
Financial PM
10.6 Recommendations for the Turnaround 143
Loss Profit
The cash flow statement is a tool which shows the movements of cash and cash
equivalents in and out of the business. Companies must have a good cash situation as
chronic negative cash flows are symptomatic of troubled businesses (Olfert, 2013,
2015). On the sales side, it is recommended to negotiate on advanced and early
payments via marketing and sales management, whereas on the supply side the
procurement function must negotiate standard and longer-term payment terms,
e.g. 60 or 90 days after receipt of goods. In severe cases, it is also possible to
negotiate with banks, investors or employees on later payments of repayments,
dividends or salaries (Helmold et al., 2019). All actions need to be thoroughly
taken into account, including positive and negative effects (Schmuck, 2013).
must incorporate detailed financial ratios, which affect positively balance sheet,
profit and loss account and the cash situation.
An integral part of restructuring is the process to bring in all key stakeholders as
necessary to increase the effectiveness of the turnaround plan (Helmold et al., 2019).
Restructuring necessitates knowledge and the urge of actions which improve the
financial side of the company quickly (Schmuck, 2013). If a company struggles with
debt management issues or serious cash flow pressures of any sort as a business, then
it is strongly recommended by various authors to get external support to get
specialist advice on the most essential subjects at key moments. Impartial expert
advice is always available and for companies in distress, third-party support and
guidance for directors can make a huge difference for the better (Schmuck, 2013).
Even if your company’s credit rating is not great or you’ve been rejected for loans by
mainstream lenders, there are other finance options available that might be able to
help you overcome your funding problems.
Increasingly popular alternative funding solutions include invoice factoring and
discounting, while asset financing and refinancing are other options well worth
considering. Crowdfunding and peer-to-peer lending are also major growth areas
at present, with both markets adding valuable variety to the funding equation for
small companies with big ideas.
146 10 Financial PM
When your business is facing significant financial problems, then it could be that you
will need to take drastic action. Liquidating assets that are not fundamental to the
way your company operates can help raise cash and open up the prospect of
satisfying creditors and overcoming the worst of your debt-related issues.
It is important to be clear in understanding precisely what is and isn’t essential to
your business in terms of tangible assets. Arriving at decisions on these points will
likely require careful consideration but by liquidating equipment, tools, vehicles,
inventory or property assets, you can give your company a potentially vital lifeline as
you look to climb out of debt and move towards sustainability.
The reality is that when your company is under severe financial pressures and one’s
are debts are mounting up, tough decisions have to be made in the longer-term
interests of your business.
It could be that long-serving employees have to be let go and relationships with
trusted suppliers have to end. From the perspective of directors, this can be a difficult
process but, where the alternative is your company going out of business entirely, it
is preferable and advisable to take that kind of tough choices before they are out of
your hands entirely.
Tesla Motors Inc. has maintained regular and efficient communication with its
stakeholders. The company publishes its annual report on its website, disclosing key
financial data, the company’s strengths and values, potential risk factors, its
products, services, network and infrastructures and other important information.
The company also communicates with its stakeholders by organizing annual
meetings for its stockholders with webcasts for those who cannot attend in person,
Q&A conference calls to share the company’s quarterly financial results and factory
tours for those who want to have a closer look at the company’s manufacturing and
operations. The company also manages its own blogs and official pages on social
media websites including Facebook and Twitter to keep stakeholders abreast of the
company’s latest developments and achievements.
In case some major crisis happens, the company also responds very promptly to
keep the crisis under control. For example, when a video showing a Tesla Model S
catching fire went viral on YouTube in 2013, Elon Musk, Tesla’s CEO, quickly
shared a post on the company’s blog to explain the reasons behind the accident,
regain customers’ trust in Tesla’s vehicles and reaffirm the company’s potentials
with the investors.
There are various financial data a company can reveal to the public and its
stakeholders, communicating different aspects of its financial performance and
financial viability. As for Tesla, with regard to the market niche of electric vehicles,
all of its vehicle models released so far have remained the best-selling electric car
models around the world. In December 2016, Tesla sold nearly 190,000 electric
vehicles in all markets, making Tesla the second largest global pure electric car
manufacturer across the globe. The forthcoming Tesla Model 3, which is expected to
come out in 2018, promises another successful product for Tesla with more than
400,000 pre-orders through sales on the company website. Tesla conducted its IPO
on NASDAQ exchange in 2010 with an initial price per share of USD 17, and it sold
out more than 13 million shares almost overnight. As of today, its share price
skyrocketed to USD 325, up nearly 20 times compared to its starting price.
As impressive as its increasing trend of its share price and sales revenue, Tesla
Motors Inc.’s financial statement for the year of 2016 showed that the company
experienced a loss of USD 674 million, resulting in negative earnings per share of
USD 4.5. Similarly, its estimated P/E ratio for the year 2017 is USD 42.71.
That these two important ratios are negative might raise serious concerns among
Tesla’s investors. Nonetheless, the company attributed most of its loss to its enor-
mous spending on research and development to achieve its ambitious growth and
production plan, and it expected to recoup these investments soon.
148 10 Financial PM
References
Deal, L. (2016). Volvo Group restructuring to brand-centric organization. Retrieved January
5, 2019, from https://www.successfuldealer.com/volvo-group-restructuring-to-brand-centric-
organization/
Gabler-Wirtschaftslexikon. (2018). Unternehmenskrise. Retrieved May 26, 2018, from https://
wirtschaftslexikon.gabler.de/definition/unternehmungskrise-49331
Handelsblatt. (2017). Handelsblatt. 13.01.2017. Finanzielle Zukunft Gläubiger verschaffen Jack
Wolfskin Luft für Verhandlungen. Die Verhandlungen über die Zukunft Jack Wolfskin haben
begonnen. Um die zu vereinfachen, verzichten die Banken vorerst auf die Rückzahlung von
Krediten. Finanzinvestor Blackstone bangt um die Kontrolle des Unternehmens. Retrieved May
26, 2018, from http://www.handelsblatt.com/unternehmen/handel-konsumgueter/finanzielle-
zukunft-glaeubiger-verschaffen-jack-wolfskin-luft-fuer-verhandlungen/19247752.html?
ticket¼ST-874329-5m5EZ42jWMfXaeA6SVbH-ap2
Helmold, M., & Terry, B. (2016). Liefeantenmanagement 2030. Sicherung der
Wettbewerbsfähigkeit durch Wertschöpfung in globalen und digitalen Märkten. Wiesbaden:
Springer.
Helmold, M., Dathe, T., & Hummel, F. (2019). Erfolgreiche Verhandlungen. Best-in-Class
Empfehlungen für den Verhandlungsdurchbruch. Wiesbaden: Springer Gabler.
Krahnen, J. P., & Schmidt, R. H. (2004). The German financial system. Oxford University Press.
Retrieved January 5, 2019, from https://books.google.de/books?id¼NS_oCwAAQBAJ&
pg¼PA267&lpg¼PA267&dq¼financial+times+mannesmann+diversifying
+telecommunications&source¼bl&ots¼EbK16_LA5U&
sig¼iSidxuQCDKwhC6hBxtwS0XobOCw&hl¼de&sa¼X&ved¼2ahUKEwj5_
bypp9bfAhXHKFAKHUlOCFkQ6AEwA3oECAQQAQ#v¼onepage&q¼financial%20times
%20mannesmann%20diversifying%20telecommunications&f¼false
Müller, R. (1986). Krisenmanagement in der Unternehmung: Vorgehen, Massnahmen und
Organisation. Bern: Peter Lang Verlag.
Olfert, K. (2013). Investition. 13. Auflage. Herne: NWB Verlag.
Olfert, K. (2015). Finanzierung. 15. Auflage. Herne: NWB Verlag.
Rewe. (2015, March 31). REWE Group is experiencing profitable national and international
growth. Rewe corporate communications group. Retrieved January 5, 2019, from https://
www.rewe-group.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/1420
Reuters. (2018, April 26). Deutsche Bank 2018 restructuring costs to rise to 800 mln from 500 mln
on new cuts. Retrieved January 5, 2019, from https://www.reuters.com/article/brief-deutsche-
bank-2018-restructuring-c/brief-deutsche-bank-2018-restructuring-costs-to-rise-to-800-mln-
from-500-mln-on-new-cuts-idUSF9N1L900W
Schmuck, M. (2013). Financial distress and turnaround. An empirical analysis of the automotive
supplier industry. Wiesbaden: Springer.
Vlasic, B. (2012). Prized logo is returned to ford. The blue oval is back home. New York Times.
Retrieved January 6, 2019, from https://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/23/business/a-prized-logo-
is-returned-to-ford.html
Zalando. (2019). Zalando SE general conditions of purchase for indirect purchase. Retrieved
January 5, 2019, from https://eprocurement.zalando.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/
Zalando-SE-General-Conditions-of-Purchase-for-Indirect-Purchase.pdf
PM in NGO and NPO
11
Marc Helmold and Warda Samara
If you have built castles in the air, your work need not be lost;
that is where they should be. Now put the foundations
under them.
Henry David Thoreau
advocate and promote a particular social cause. There are numerous NPOs in
Germany listed in Wikipedia (e.g. German association for flag protection—
Wikipedia, 2019). In contrast to enterprises, NPOs are not focusing on maximizing
profits. In economic and business terms, the NPO is an organization that uses its
surpluses and earnings for further activities to achieve the socially grounded
objectives, rather than paying a dividend to its owners and shareholders (Gabler
Wirtschaftslexikon, 2019). Due to the charity focus, NPOs have therefore tax
exempts or advantages, which mean they do not pay the same taxes as companies
(Gabler Wirtschaftslexikon, 2019). NPOs operate in all kinds of environments like in
religious, scientific, research or educational setting areas.
The key elements of NPOs are accountability, trustworthiness, honesty and openness
to every person who has invested time, money and faith into the organization. As the
NPO is not aiming to maximize profitability and to return dividends to the
shareholders, it is important to have credibility and accountability that money and
funding is used in the right way to fulfil the social purposes of the NPO. Non-profit
organizations are dependent on people, organizations and governments to obtain
support by donors, funders, volunteers, program recipients and the public commu-
nity. Public confidence is a factor in the amount of money that a non-profit organi-
zation is able to raise. The more non-profits focus on their mission, the more public
confidence they will have, and as a result, more money for the organization. NPO
must therefore achieve public confidence. NPOs can be classified as follows
(Wikipedia, 2019):
NPO’s challenges primarily stem from lack of funding. Funding can either come
from within the organization, fundraising, donations, or from the federal govern-
ment. When cutbacks are made from the federal government, the organization
suffers from devolution. This term describes when there is a shift of responsibility
11.2 Case Study: Bürgeramt to Excellence (Bü2E) 151
from a central government to a local, subnational authority. The shift is due to the
loss of funds, therefore resulting in changes of responsibilities in running
programmes. Because of this frequent challenge, management must be innovative
and effective in the pursuit of success.
The NGOs are non-profit-focused group which are organized on local, national or
international levels. The purpose to establish an NGO normally has the background
to support a social purpose or special idea. NGOs have specific aims:
Empowering community-based organizations (CBOs) and the poor among the rural
communities to use impact monitoring for project management and thus
contributing to the sustainability of their project activities.
Empowering NGOs to further improve the effectiveness, impact and sustainability
of their efforts by identifying best tools for impact monitoring and evaluation and
best practices in the area of savings and credit.
Making social changes more visible in implementing and funding NGOs, thus
improving the development policy work.
Improving public recognition of NGOs and CBOs and their contribution to
development.
Standard 3-4
Laggard: 5-6
Quality
1
Accountability 3 Cost
5
Transparency Delivery
InnovaƟon
11.2 Case Study: Bürgeramt to Excellence (Bü2E) 153
attributes that to the fact that Bürgeramt are making real progress in providing their
services on the whole value chain including the input, process and the output.
As a conclusion, the Bürgeramt has the chance to reach the excellence level on all
six PM categories if they manage to overcome the challenges with the IT department
to cope with the future plans that will improve the internal process and delivering the
services to their clients, especially that the staff of Bürgeramt are highly trained to
operate different task professionally. The capacity and the cooperation of the team
can strive towards excellence. Technology can be a tool used for better performance.
However, IT obstacles and the errors that occur at the data centre can create serious
obstacles in implementing and developing new ways to proceed their activities and
programmes. Based on the collected and analysed data in this study, the researcher
decided to provide recommendations depending on practical approach besides the
theoretical approach. Due to the complex internal and external environments of
public organizations, elected officials, members of parliament, managers of
organizations, civil officials and citizens have different expectations and demands
from performance management (Lin & Lee, 2011). Based on the case, there are some
generic recommendations for Bürgeramter in Germany:
Concepts and trainings: The former literature approved that there is different under-
standing of the performance indicator concepts. Moreover, the results of this
study show the lack of knowledge of some interviewees of the main six categories
used to examine in this research. Therefore, there is a need to improve the
definitions through conducting training to ensure that all employees have the
same understanding of the definitions.
Parker and Waller indicate that the PM tools and systems approved its contribution
to the public organizations; as it can detect the weaknesses and act up on the
collected data through the system, it helps to improve the operational level.
Where Sanderson (2001) emphasized that PM can improve the accountability
and transparency through regular performance measurement. Based on that,
Bürgeramt in Freiburg should introduce new PM tools to prepare the office to
strive towards excellence as these research results make evident that Bürgeramt in
Freiburg has the capacity to strive for excellence through using the right tools and
the professional external experts to support the process.
Referring to the Radar, it shows that PM categories specify between excellence and
best practices. This is a clear indicator that Bürgeramt in Freiburg has
implemented successful ideas that should be shared and disseminated to the
other Bürgerämter. This relates to the overall benefit of how to use data resources,
reduce overhead and avoid multiple entries (Becker, 2006). Success of ongoing
projects increases employee and organization performance in general.
The researcher recommended to the Bürgerämter in Germany to implement
Bürgeramt to Excellence Program (Bü-2-E). This term is created by the
researcher and which developed while conducting this research in discussions
with the research’s supervisor; the program aims to prepare Certified Public PM
Experts in Bürgeramt that can strive for organizational excellence through per-
formance measurement.
154 11 PM in NGO and NPO
References
Aguinis, H. (2013). Performance management. Edinburgh: Edinburgh Business School.
Becker, J. (2006). Das Bürgerbüro als Integrationspunkt: Stand und Perspektiven der Verzahnung
von Frontoffice und Backoffice in Bürgerbüros von NRW-Kommunen Eine Studie im Auftrag
des Informationsbüros d-NRW. Retrieved from https://www.d-nrw.de/fileadmin/user_upload/d-
NRW_Dateien/Informationsbuero/studie_d-NRW_Front-Backoffice.pdf
Gabler Wirtschaftslexikon. (2019). Non-profit organisation. Retrieved March 7, 2019, from https://
wirtschaftslexikon.gabler.de/definition/nonprofit-organisation-npo-39562
Gianakis, G. (2018). The promise of public sector performance measurement: Anodyne or placebo?
Florida: SPAEF.
Greiling, D. (2005). Performance measurement in the public sector: The German experience.
International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 54(7), 551–567.
Lin, J., & Lee, P. (2011). Performance management in public organizations: A complexity per-
spective. IPMN International Public Management Review, 12(2). http://journals.sfu.ca/ipmr/
index.php/ipmr/article/view/103/103
Samara, W. M. K. (2018). Performance excellence in public organisations. Bürgeramt case study.
M.L.M. thesis. Berlin: IUBH.
Sanderson, I. (2001). Performance management, evaluation and learning in ‘modern’ local govern-
ment. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/1467-9299.00257
Tilly, C., & Smart, V. (2018). New public sector performance management: Making fiscal consoli-
dation smarter. Discussion Paper. Chartered Institute of Management Accountants. Retrieved
from https://www.cimaglobal.com/Documents/Thought_leadership_docs/New%20public%
20sector%20performance%20management.pdf
Wikipedia. (2019). NGO and NGO. Retrieved March 7, 2019, from https://de.wikipedia.org/w/
index.php?title¼Kategorie:Non-Profit-Organisation&pageuntil¼Fair+Wear+Foundation#mw-
pages
World Bank. (2019). Working with NGOs: A practical guide to operational collaboration between
the World Bank and nongovernmental organizations (English). Retrieved March 7, 2019, from
http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/814581468739240860/Working-with-NGOs-a-
practical-guide-to-operational-collaboration-between-the-World-Bank-and-nongovernmental-
organizations
PM in Human Resources
12
Marc Helmold and Warda Samara
You can never cross the ocean until you have the courage to
lose sight of the shore.
Andre Gide (1869–1951)
Human resources (HR) is a support function alongside the value chain and deals with
people, jobs and the organization. Its contribution to the overall strategy and
activities of the company lies in creating the appropriate HR strategy, the organiza-
tional set-up, the designing of individual or group jobs, the interaction with
stakeholders (e.g. unions, workers council), the design of the work environment
and the allocation of working times. Daily job duties of human resources specialists
include preparing or updating employment records related to hiring, transferring,
promoting and terminating; explaining human resources policies, procedures, laws
and standards to new and existing employees; and ensuring new hire paperwork is
completed and processed (Slack et al., 1995, 2013). Human resources managers
plan, direct and coordinate the administrative functions of an organization. They
oversee specialists in their duties, consult with executives on strategic planning and
link a company’s management with its employees. The role of human resources
consists of six tasks as shown in Fig. 12.1.
Contribute to
Design the
human
working
resource
environment
strategy
Design Act as
individuals and interface to
group Jobs stakeholders
(unions, worker´s council)
Allocate work
times
Four main styles of leadership are identified in the Tannenbaum and Schmidt
Continuum of Leadership:
Manager
allows team
Manager asks to develop
group to options and
Manager make decision to decide on
presents within set actions
problem. limits and defined.
Manager Obtains
presents framework.
suggestions,
Manager tentative then makes a
presents ideas decision decision. Joins
Manager and asks subject to
makes questions change Joins
Manager decision and about it
makes sells it to the Consults
decision and employees
informs staff Consults
about it
Consults
Sells
Tells
Fig. 12.2 Leadership styles according to Tannenbaum and Schmidt. Source: Marc Helmold,
adjusted from Tannenbaum and Schmidt
Job enrichment, job rotation and job empowerment are three examples of ways
employers try to make jobs more satisfying. Whereas job enlargement adds broader
responsibilities to a position, job enrichment gives the employee more vertical
authority. The objective is to give an employee more personal accountability for
the work that he does. By doing so, the employer hopes that he feels more of a sense
of self-worth from his role in the business.
When it comes to unprecedented scale of success and growth, one company reigns
supreme: Google. Started as a research project in 1996 by then PhD students Larry
Page and Sergey Brin at Stanford University, Google has become a multinational
technology company with industry leadership in Internet-related services and
products. Between its foundation as a company in 1998 and now, Google has
gone through many transformations (the most recent one of which is its reorganiza-
tion as a holding company named Alphabet Inc.). But one thing remained a constant
at the Internet giant: its commitment to employee satisfaction and engagement.
Google’s commitment to its employees can explain why the company has topped
the Great Place to Work list in 2013 and 2014, and it has remained in the top 5 in the
preceding years. A closer look reveals another important factor in this victory:
Google’s carefully constructed and truly nurturing performance management sys-
tem. Performance reviews are customized to provide great results for Google’s smart
creative. Senior Vice President of People Operations Laszlo Bock provides great
learning about their performance management in his book titled Work Rules.
Googlers first identify a group of peer reviewers for each employee, which also
includes co-workers who are junior to them. Google has abolished numerical ratings
in April 2014, so each Googler is now subjected to a five-point scale ranging from
‘needs improvement’ to ‘superb’. Carried out semi-annually, peer reviewers are
asked to state one thing the reviewer should do more of and one thing that they
can do in a different way. After the feedback cycle, managers come together to take a
look at these peer reviews. The main aim is to prevent bias in feedback by asking
each manager to justify their decisions to each other. Managers are informed about
potential obstacles to objective feedback, one of which is the tendency to overem-
phasize an employee’s most recent performance. By keeping these obstacles in
mind, managers decide on the final evaluation of an employee. Summaries of
these assessments are shared semi-annually and compared to a set of examples to
justify the evaluation. Employees are then informed of their compensation, but
compensation is decided separately from the evaluation taking place during the
reviews. Google keeps pay discussions separate from peer feedback with an aim to
provide the right motivation to their employees, which is to grow and contribute to
Google’s success.
Learnings
A research done by Edward L Deci, a Professor of Psychology at the University of
Rochester, sheds light on the effects that two types of motivation have on achieving
goals. Desi’s research indicate that when someone is motivated using an external
reward such as money, their motivation tended to decrease. By contrast, when they
are motivated by verbal reinforcement and positive feedback, their motivation
increased. This is in line with what Google pursues with its performance manage-
ment. Bock et al. understand the importance of motivating their smart creative with
right initiatives and provide enough freedom for their ideas to flourish and become
the next big thing at Google. The ultimate goal of performance management systems
References 159
References
Slack, N., et al. (1995). Operations management. London: Pitman Publishing.
Slack, N., et al. (2013). Operations management. London: Pitman Publishing.
Tannenbaum, R., & Schmidt, W. H. (1958). How to choose a leadership pattern. Harvard Business
Review, 36/1958.
Industry 4.0 and Artificial Intelligence
(AI) in PM 13
Marc Helmold
Industry 4.0 is a name given to the current trend of automation and data exchange
in manufacturing technologies. It includes cyber-physical systems, the Internet of
Things, cloud computing and cognitive computing. Industry 4.0 is commonly
referred to as the fourth industrial revolution. Industry 4.0 fosters what has been
called a ‘smart factory’. Within modular structured smart factories, cyber-physical
systems monitor physical processes, create a virtual copy of the physical world and
make decentralized decisions. Over the Internet of Things, cyber-physical systems
communicate and cooperate with each other and with humans in real time both
internally and across organizational services offered and used by participants of the
value chain. There are four design principles in Industry 4.0. These principles
support companies in identifying and implementing Industry 4.0 scenarios:
Interconnection: The ability of machines, devices, sensors and people to connect and
communicate with each other via the Internet of Things (IoT) or the Internet of
People (IoP).
Information transparency: The transparency afforded by Industry 4.0 technology
provides operators with vast amounts of useful information needed to make
appropriate decisions. Interconnectivity allows operators to collect immense
amounts of data and information from all points in the manufacturing process,
thus aiding functionality and identifying key areas that can benefit from
innovation and improvement.
Technical assistance: First, the ability of assistance systems to support humans by
aggregating and visualizing information comprehensively for making informed
decisions and solving urgent problems on short notice. Second, the ability of
cyber-physical systems to physically support humans by conducting a range of
tasks that are unpleasant, too exhausting or unsafe for their human co-workers.
Fig. 13.1 Industry 4.0 evolution. Source: Compiled figure by the Author, adopted from Helmold
and Terry (2017)
Since its earliest days, Amazon has used AI to come up with product
recommendations based on what users already said they liked (Terdiman, 2018).
The algorithms behind those systems have been tweaked again and again over the
years. These days, thanks to machine learning, the recommendations have gotten
more dynamic, says Jeff Wilke, the CEO of Amazon’s worldwide consumer
Reference 163
division. ‘Say there’s a new piece of fashion that comes into the fall season’, he
explains, ‘In the past it might take longer for the algorithms that we use to realize that
people who bought these shoes also bought this top. And with some of the new
techniques we can detect those things earlier, those correlations. And then surface
the new top earlier in the season’.
Other Amazon AI and machine-learning efforts power the Alexa voice assistant,
give users of Amazon Web Services access to cloud-based tools, allow shoppers to
grab items and walk immediately out of Amazon Go stores, guide robots carrying
shelves full of products directly to fulfilment centre workers and much more. And
while the technology is vital to Amazon across most of its businesses, the range of its
applications is still stunning. It’s also a key reason why the company (briefly) hit $1
trillion in market cap and stands every chance of getting back there for the long haul.
A company-wide mantra at Amazon is that every day is ‘Day One’, a humble
contention that for all Jeff Bezos’s brainchild has accomplished, it’s just getting
started. When it comes to AI and machine learning, Sivasubramanian doesn’t just
pull out the standard ‘Day One’ reference. He jokes that ‘it’s Day One, but it’s so
early that we just woke up and haven’t even had a cup of coffee yet’.
Deep inside Amazon’s 855,000-square-foot fulfilment centre in Kent,
Washington, 18 miles south of Seattle, a bunch of orange Amazon robots are
doing a dance. Balanced on top of each of the orange machines is a yellow pod
with nine rows of product-packed shelves on each of four sides. Powered by AI, each
of the robots automatically sprang into action when someone somewhere in the
Pacific Northwest purchased something on Amazon.com, and each is now autono-
mously manoeuvring its way around the others in a bid to get to a station at the edge
of the fenced-off robotic field where a worker will pluck the item in question and put
it on a conveyor belt towards another worker who will box it up (Terdiman, 2018).
At the scale that Amazon processes orders, peak efficiency is essential. Magnified
over millions upon millions of orders a year, even a second or two saved per order
makes a huge bottom-line difference.
For some time, Amazon has used machine learning in its fulfilment centres ‘to
improve our ability to predict what customers are ordering and place it in the right
place’, says Wilke, ‘And also to improve the efficiency and speed with which we get
things to consumers’.
Reference
Terdiman, F. (2018). How AI is helping Amazon to become a trillion-dollar company. Fast
Company. Retrieved March 2, 2019, from https://www.fastcompany.com/90246028/how-ai-
is-helping-amazon-become-a-trillion-dollar-company
PM in Different Cultures
and Internationalization 14
Marc Helmold and Warda Samara
Invite people into life who don’t look or act like you. You
might find they challenge your assumptions and make
you grow.
Melody Hobson
Foreign trade has a long history. Yet, the cross-border exchange of goods and
services has significantly intensified in the last decades (Dathe & Helmold, 2018).
The cultural differences add another facet to the complication of negotiations. The
commercial negotiations are complex enough in the same cultural group. Dealing
with business partners with a different cultural background poses an additional
challenge for communication. Caution needs to be taken, in order to avoid culturally
based misunderstanding (Helmold, Dathe, & Hummel, 2019). The overriding ques-
tion in this context is: ‘What are cultures?’
According to Geert Hofstede, social psychologist and culture investigation
researcher, culture is ‘the collective programming of the mind that distinguishes
the members of one group or category of people from others’ (Hofstede, 1991). In
different terms, culture is the remarkable way a gathering of individuals think and
adapt. Without the learning and comprehension for different societies, such distinc-
tion in considering and practices may effortlessly cause clashes in intercultural
communications (Helmold et al., 2019). Although cultures are not limited to national
cultures (e.g. there could be cultural groups based on gender, age groups, etc.), in
this book, we will concentrate on the national cultures to talk about how to bargain
with business negotiations across cultures. Each national culture has its own tradi-
tional philosophy and methods for negotiations which may be unknown or
incomprehensive to outsiders (Helmold et al., 2019). Negotiation participants with
different cultural backgrounds often come with different expectation or even
different targets to the meetings. An analysis of the different targets and expectations
at an early stage could be very helpful, before they cause later frustrations and
mislead the negotiation into deadlock (Lanz, 2018). One of the most interesting
aspects of the analysis is how the relationship among the participants should be
established (Liker & Choi, 2004). As culture significantly influences the way people
perceive and react to information during communication, it is an essential aspect that
cannot be ignored when studying international negotiations (Helmold et al., 2019).
Intercultural training has become popular in many countries, as they are believed to
provide the understanding of the mentality and behaviour codes of another culture in
a crash course. In any case, the knowledge of the rules of the game shall have a
positive effect on the outcome of cross-cultural interactions. The following matrix
shows our recommendation on the approach of cultural training for international
negotiations (based on Helmold et al., 2019).
Edgar Schein distinguishes three levels in organizational cultures (see Fig. 14.1)
based on how easily the cultural phenomena could be observed by outsiders who are
not part of the culture (Danziger, 2008):
Artefacts and behaviours. These are the tangible, overt or verbally perceivable
elements, e.g. architecture, languages or ceremonial rituals.
Espoused values. These are the stated values and rules of behaviour in the cultural
group. These are often expressed in the public statements or literature,
e.g. national laws, the ‘family first’ philosophy.
Assumptions or shared tacit assumptions. These are the roots of the culture and the
key to understanding of the culture. However, the tacit assumptions are hard to
recognize even for insiders of the culture, because the assumptions are usually
Intercultural Independent
training for "eye-level"
me negotiation
Intercultural
Intercultural
training for
training for
my
both parties
counterpart
14.2 Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions Theory 167
Artifacts
Architecture, languages and
ceremonial rituals
and behaviors
Fig. 14.2 Schein’s three levels of culture (interpretation by Dathe). Source: Dathe and Helmold
(2018)
taken for granted and unconsciously well integrated into their behaviour. For
example in some cultures, it is assumed that every man should be treated equally,
while in others, people are entitled to different levels of privilege based on their
origin (Fig. 14.2).
We may learn the artefacts and behaviours through close observation. It doesn’t
take long for us to find out that in business contacts, the Americans tend to call each
other by the given name, the Germans by the surname and the Chinese by a
combination of the surname and the job title. One of the first things we learn is
how our counterpart greets the business partners: with kisses on the cheeks, a kiss on
the hand, shaking hands, a knock on the shoulder or somehow exotically, with a bow
like in Japan. If we are ready to invest more time with the cultures, we will also get to
know more about the written rules. But how do we deal with the shared tacit
assumptions, as even the cultural insiders are often unconscious of those, because
they simply take the assumptions for granted? Is it possible at all to identify the most
important assumptions in a culture without years of systematic study? The short
answer is, yes. Researchers in the past have developed instruments to describe the
essential features of cultures. In the following sections, we shall shed light on two
culture models—frameworks generated to assess and differentiate cultures.
Geert Hofstede is researcher in the field of organization culture. During his engage-
ment at IBM International between 1967 and 1976, he conducted employee opinion
surveys in IBM subsidiaries in 74 countries. By applying statistical methods, he
168 14 PM in Different Cultures and Internationalization
Power distance
Individualism vs. collectivism
Masculinity vs. femininity
Uncertainty avoidance
Long-term orientation
Indulgence vs. restraint
The individuals in any cultural group have different levels of influence on society.
The term power distance describes the readiness of the lower ranking individuals to
accept the uneven distribution of power. This cultural dimension shows how much
inequality is expected in a society. Based on the empirical data, a power distance
index (PDI) is generated and the comparison of different cultures allows certain
conclusions (Hofstede, 1980, 2007). In low PDI cultures, the power is distributed
less unequally. This implies that society tends to be democratic and members of
society are less dependent towards the power holders. In business organizations of
lower PDI cultures, managers and subordinates are more likely to maintain a
consultative relationship and less concerned of their status in the organizational
hierarchy. In terms of the negotiation, the decision-maker is likely to take the
objective reasoning of his subordinates into serious consideration. Examples of
low PDI countries are the USA, the UK and Germany (Hofstede, 2007; Helmold
et al., 2019). In high PDI cultures, the social hierarchy tends to be more clearly
visible and the power holders have stronger influence with more centralized power.
Although centralized power often misleads to abuse of their office and corruption,
only few in high PDI cultures will ever question the formal authorities (Chia et al.,
2007; Lee & Oh, 2007). In business organizations, leaders are more likely to dictate
their decisions to the subordinates and questions in public are often understood as
challenge to their personal authority (Hofstede, 2007; Helmold et al., 2019). When
dealing with negotiation partners from a high PDI culture, it is essential to identify
the decision-maker in the first place. Very likely, his subordinates have only limited
influence on the final decision. In the behaviour code of a high PDI culture, it is
important to treat the power holder with distinctively more respect and not to
question or even criticize him in public. Different opinions need to be ‘well
14.2 Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions Theory 169
packaged’ (Helmold et al., 2019). Examples of high PDI countries are Malaysia,
Saudi Arabia and Japan.
The cultural dimension uncertainty avoidance shows the level of anxiety uncertainty
causes and reflects a society’s tolerance for uncertainty or ambiguity (Hofstede,
2007). In a culture with a high score of uncertainty avoidance, life is often perceived
as hectic. Clear rules and structures are cherished. People prefer to be informed of all
potential risks and tend to seek the help of experts in case of uncertainty. Emotional
behaviours are interpreted as an act of losing control. In negotiations, relevant
influence factors (for instance, the flexibility and tolerance of the business partner
in addition to technical data of the products) are often quantified as far as possible.
Examples of high uncertainty avoidance countries are Germany and Switzerland
(Helmold et al., 2019). Cultures with a low score of uncertainty avoidance are
sometimes described as ‘chaotic’. Life is perceived as easygoing and fewer rules
and instructions are expected. Entrepreneurs potentially take higher risks and the
acceptance for new technologies is higher. In the negotiation, passion is a decision-
relevant factor besides the technical and commercial issues. Examples of high
uncertainty avoidance countries are India and China (Helmold et al., 2019).
This is a relatively new dimension in the VSM framework and describes the level of
subjective happiness and life control. Indulgent societies appreciate natural human
desires leading to subjective happiness. There is less moral discipline and a higher
perceived personal control of life. There are more extroverted personalities and
people tend to be optimistic, have more friends, participate more in sports and are
healthier and happier. Countries with the highest measured indulgence level are
Mexico, Nigeria and Sweden. Restricted societies are less tolerant towards natural
human desires and regulate by means of strict social norms. Professional obligations
are considered more important than private life. There is much moral discipline and
life is essentially driven by the environment. People tend to be introverted, pessi-
mistic and cynical. Having friends and participation in sports seem less important
14.3 Edward Hall’s Culture Model 171
and people feel less happy and less healthy. Countries with the lowest measured
indulgence level are Egypt, Russia, China and India.
The American anthropologist and culture researcher Edward Twitchell Hall Jr. is
best known for the introduction of the following concepts in cross-cultural studies:
Proxemics
Monochromic time vs. polychromic time
High-context cultures vs. low-context cultures
14.3.1 Proxemics
The term proxemics stands for the study of the human use of space and the influence
of population. In his work, Hall describes the interpersonal distance (horizontal) as
invisible circles (see Fig. 6.3) and divides it into the following sections (Hall, 1966):
Intimate distance
Personal distance (for interactions with close friends and family)
Social distance (for interactions among acquaintances) and
public distance (for public speech)
The space within intimate distance and personal distance forms the personal
space which is psychologically regarded as one’s own. By entering someone’s
personal space without being his close friend or family member, one usually causes
uneasiness in communication. On the other hand, significantly exceeding the per-
ceived reasonable distance may be interpreted as lack of trust of even hostility (Hall,
1966) (Fig. 14.3).
According to Hall, the interpersonal distance is variable and can be significantly
influenced by cultural differences (Hall, 1966). In Hall’s proxemics theory, there is a
further important concept ‘territory’. While ‘personal space’ refers to the immediate
space around a person, territory stands for the space and objects a person lays claim
to (e.g. the office). Intrusion in the territory may cause hostile reactions (Hall, 1966).
For international communication, knowledge of the business partner’s perceptions of
personal space and territory is helpful to avoid unnecessary misunderstandings
(Helmold et al., 2019).
Personal space
Intimate space
Space
Interruptions of job at hand may easily lead to distress of the employees. In addition,
members of a monochromic society tend to follow clear rules and show higher
respect for private properties.
In polychromic cultures, on the contrary, people tend to tackle several tasks at the
same time. Potentially, this leads to more interruptions of the job(s) at hand.
However, the jobs are not considered isolated assignments, but a part of the overall
target. The main focus is the flexibility towards the changing environment, espe-
cially by means of maintaining a good relationship with the stakeholders and the
predefined schedule is only of secondary importance (Hall, 1983).
The different working styles resulting from a different understanding of how time
and relationship shall be of value often lead to irritation and frustration in intercul-
tural collaborations. A necessary step for a successful negotiation is to get to know
the reasons for the business partner’s behaviour and to be prepared to take time till
the mutual understanding is established (Helmold et al., 2019).
Hall uses the terms high-context culture and low-context culture to describe the
importance of context in communication. In a low-context culture, the information is
explicitly stated in the wording of the message. The successful transmission of
information depends on the precision of the verbal statements by the sender of the
message. The personal relationship between the communication partners is
non-substantial (Hall, 1976).
In high-context countries, the transmission of information often involves
non-verbal communication methods, e.g. gesture, facial expression, tone of voice
14.3 Edward Hall’s Culture Model 173
or even the silence. The context situation and social norms may also be a part of the
message. A close interpersonal relationship plays an important role in communica-
tion. It usually takes an extended period of time to get to know the unwritten rules to
be able to communicate effectively (Hall, 1976).
The following table shows some amusing situations of context communication
with the Brits to demonstrate the difficulties for the outsiders of the culture
(foreigners) (see Table 14.1).
Japan is regarded as one of the high-context countries. In a Japanese company,
it is possible that sometimes essential company strategies are not discussed
explicitly at formal meetings, but at informal meetings over the lunch table with
chosen participants. Business partners from a high-text culture usually prefer to
solve problems in groups. For a sustainable success in high-context cultures, it is
important to take time to be informed of the social norms of the business partner
and to establish a trustful relationship at the very beginning of the business
transaction.
174 14 PM in Different Cultures and Internationalization
In the present world, globalization is growing and borders are shrinking as outlined
by several authors (Dathe & Helmold, 2018; Grunig & Morschett, 2017).
Companies are taking advantage of that, by internationalizing their businesses on
the sales or supply side as shown in Fig. 6.1 (Helmold et al., 2019). Companies can
thus gain new customers, gain a bigger market share, get an advantage point against
rivals on the demand side or achieve better material or third-party service cost on the
supply side (Helmold et al., 2019). Market entry strategies differentiate a lot between
each other, which makes them hard to compare to each other. Grunig and Morschett
are using the criteria of control, resources, cost, flexibility, partner resources and
knowledge to highlight advantages and disadvantages of each category (Dathe &
Helmold, 2018; Grunig & Morschett, 2017).
Direct exporting is selling directly into the market you have chosen using in the first
instance your own resources. Many companies, once they have established a sales
programme, turn to agents and/or distributors to represent them further in that
market. Agents and distributors work closely with you in representing your interests.
They become the face of your company, and thus, it is important that your choice of
agents and distributors is handled in much the same way you would hire a key staff
person.
14.4.3 Licensing
14.4.4 Franchising
Franchising is a typical North American process for rapid market expansion, but it is
gaining traction in other parts of the world. Franchising works well for firms that
have a repeatable business model (e.g. food outlets) that can be easily transferred
into other markets. Two caveats are required when considering using the franchise
model. The first is that your business model should either be very unique or have
strong brand recognition that can be utilized internationally and secondly you may
be creating your future competition in your franchisee.
14.4 Internationalization Strategies 175
Third-party sourcing can be described as a supplier (or service provider) who is not
directly controlled by either the seller (first party) or the customer (second party) in
an international business transaction. The third party is considered specialized and
independent from the other two, even if hired by them, because not all control is
vested in that connection. There can be multiple third-party sources with respect to a
given transaction, between the first and second parties. Third parties are specialized
in certain commodities and possess an infrastructure that supports international trade
and purchases beyond borders (international experts, relationships to manufacturers,
warehouses, customs, freight forwarders etc.).
Partnering is almost a necessity when entering foreign markets, and in some parts of
the world (e.g. Asia), it may be required. Partnering can take a variety of forms from
a simple co-marketing arrangement to a sophisticated strategic alliance for
manufacturing. Partnering is a particularly useful strategy in those markets where
the culture, both business and social, is substantively different than your own as local
partners bring local market knowledge, contacts and if chosen wisely customers.
A joint venture basically means two or more companies form collaboration to create
a jointly owned enterprise by investing money, know-how and sharing the risk. This
kind of venture can be permanent and the ownership can attain from minor owner-
ship to major ownership. A joint venture has many benefits. First of all, the local
partner would have the local know-how and have the familiarity with the local ways
and market condition. With a joint venture also the risks would be shared, and this
could speed up the process of entering the actual market. Joint ventures are a
particular form of partnership that involves the creation of a third independently
managed company. It is called the 1 + 1 ¼ 3 process. Two companies agree to work
together in a particular market, either geographic or product, and create a third
company to undertake this. Risks and profits are normally shared equally. One
example of a joint venture is the Sony-Ericsson in the cell phone JV.
International sourcing, and more generally the transfer of parts of the value chain to
foreign countries, is characterized by complex factors such as cultural
heterogeneities, the presence of multiple actors, relationships with different and
distant interlocutors and unfamiliar business rules and behaviours. One significant
176 14 PM in Different Cultures and Internationalization
Sales Supply
Strategies for internationalisation Own Own
company company
High
Joint
Ownership of assets and resources
Venture
Investment IPO
Franchising
3rd Party
Procurement
Licensing
Export Import
Low
In this entry mode, the company that wants to enter the new market would put up a
sales and production subsidiary, which means that the company would also produce
and have sales personnel in the target market. This entry mode has high resource
commitment, low flexibility and a higher risk than the other entry modes. The
benefits with a sales and production subsidiary are that the new customers can
clearly see that the company is committing to the new market. This method should
not be used if there is not strong enough belief that the production and sales in the
new market will have long-term potential. The benefits with this method are the local
know-how and connections through the local personnel, the close access to the
14.4 Internationalization Strategies 177
market and the domestic production will not get backlogged with work if the target
market ends up being very profitable. This could be a great method for Company X
for a more long-term strategy, but the start-up costs would be high.
Country agreements, such as the Economic Partnership Agreement between the
EU and Japan, entered into force on 1 February 2019, will increase international
relationships. EU firms already export over €58 billion in goods and €28 billion in
services to Japan every year. In the past, European firms faced trade barriers when
exporting to Japan, which made it hard for them to compete. The trade agreement
with Japan removes these barriers and helps to shape global trade rules in line with
our high standards and shared values. It sends a powerful signal that two of the
world’s biggest economies reject protectionism. In 2013, EU governments instructed
the European Commission to start negotiations with Japan. On 8 December 2017,
the negotiations were finalized. The European Parliament gave its consent in
December 2018, clearing the way for the trade agreement’s conclusion and entry
into force. Figure 14.5 shows Ann Sun, Manager Supply management, and Dr. Marc
Helmold, in Japan, when looking for new suppliers and customers, as part of the
EU–Japan negotiations.
The Jokey Group has completely realigned its group-wide purchasing. The innova-
tive concept developed for this purpose has now been presented with an award by the
Bundesverband Materialwirtschaft, Einkauf und Logistik e.V. (BME) or the Federal
Fig. 14.5 Ann Sun and Dr. Marc Helmold in Japan, Tokyo. Source: Marc Helmold
178 14 PM in Different Cultures and Internationalization
Materials Management, Purchasing & Logistics Association (BME, 2018). With the
help of the structured change process in purchasing, Jokey has managed to transfer
successive operative resources into strategic initiatives and projects. Further, trans-
parency and quality in purchasing data was successfully increased, sustainably
improving central control of purchasing in the process. Thanks to continuously
developed qualification routes, Jokey purchasers have positioned themselves as
recognized specialists at the intersection of purchasing markets. The web-based
Jokey supplier portal also contributes significantly to raised efficiency levels. It
unites individual elements in the communication workflow between Jokey and its
suppliers, creating more efficiency on both sides. The existing compliance and
sustainability regulations were expanded to include the field of purchasing and
supplemented with a supplier chart. Today, Jokey is also taking advantage of the
opportunities provided by international purchasing markets through targeted devel-
opment of global sourcing. This will guarantee an optimal supply in the long term,
with rising demand forecasts and increasingly volatile prices for raw materials.
Active communication creates company-wide acceptance and the motivation to
quickly make the necessary changes and keep them going in the long run. ‘Jokey
have ultimately only been able to see this through with the help of our many highly-
qualified and highly-motivated purchasing staff’, says Michael Schmidt, Chief
Procurement Officer of the Jokey Group. The BME Innovation Award has been
awarded every year since 1986 by the Bundesverband Materialwirtschaft, Einkauf
und Logistik e.V. The award is given for innovative and sustainable services and
concepts which increase efficiency in purchasing and logistics in the long term,
leading to clear improvements in company results (Jokey, 2018; BME, 2018).
References
BME. (2018). Bundesverband Materialwirtschaft, Einkauf und Logistik. Mittelstandspreis geht an
Jokey. 10.11.2017. Retrieved May 18, 2018, from https://www.bme.de/jokey-group-gewinnt-
den-bme-innovationspreis-2017-2330/
Chia, H.-B., Egri, C., Ralston, D., Fu, P. P., Kuo, M. C., & Lee, C. (2007). Four tigers and a dragon:
Values differences, similarities, and consensus. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 24,
305–320.
Danziger, N. (2008). The construct validity of Schein’s career anchors orientation inventory.
Emerald Group. Retrieved October 24, 2018, from https://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/abs/
10.1108/13620430810849506
Dathe & Helmold. (2018). Erfolg im Chinageschäft. Handlungsempfehlungen für kleine und
mittlere Unternehmen (KMU). Springer Wiesbaden.
Grunig, R., & Morschett, D. (2017). Developing international strategies. Heidelberg: Springer.
Hall, E. (1966). The hidden dimension. New York: Garden City.
Hall, E. (1976). Beyond culture. New York: Garden City.
Hall, E. (1983). The dance of life: The other dimension of time. Anchor Books.
Helmold, M., Dathe, T., & Hummel, F. (2019). Erfolgreiche Verhandlungen. Best-in-Class
Empfehlungen für den Verhandlungsdurchbruch. Wiesbaden: Springer.
Hofstede, G. (1980). Culture’s consequences: International differences in worked-related values.
Beverly Hills: Sage.
Hofstede, G. (1991). Cultures and organizations: Software of the mind. McGraw-Hill Maidenhead.
References 179
Hofstede, G. (2007). Asian management in the 21st century. Asia Pacific Journal of Management,
24(4), 411–420.
Hofstede, G., Hofstede, G. J., & Minkov, M. (2010). Cultures and organizations: Software for the
mind, 3. Auflage. McGraw-Hill Books.
Jokey. (2018). Jokey group wins BME innovation award. Retrieved March 2, 2019, from https://
www.jokey.com/en/service-downloads/actualites/jokey-group-wins-bme-innovation-award-
458/
Lanz, H. P. (2018). Der Kuchen ist größer als du denkst. Wirtschaftsmediation. Frankfurt.
Retrieved October 24, 2018, from https://www.wirtschaftsmediatoren-ihk.de/f%C3%BCr-
hilfesuchende/beitr%C3%A4ge-zum-konfliktmanagement/teil-3-der-kuchen-ist-gr%C3%B6%
C3%9Fer-als-du-denkst/
Lee, S.-H., & Oh, K. (2007). Corruption in Asia: Pervasiveness and arbitrariness. Asia Pacific
Journal of Management, 24(1), 97–114.
Liker, J. K., & Choi, T. Y. (2004). Building deep supplier relationships. Harvard Business Review,
82(12), 104–113+149.