Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Easec16: Chien Ming Wang Vinh Dao Sritawat Kitipornchai Editors
Easec16: Chien Ming Wang Vinh Dao Sritawat Kitipornchai Editors
EASEC16
Proceedings of The 16th East
Asian-Pacific Conference on Structural
Engineering and Construction, 2019
Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering
Volume 101
Series Editors
Marco di Prisco, Politecnico di Milano, Milano, Italy
Sheng-Hong Chen, School of Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering,
Wuhan University, Wuhan, China
Ioannis Vayas, Institute of Steel Structures, National Technical University of
Athens, Athens, Greece
Sanjay Kumar Shukla, School of Engineering, Edith Cowan University, Joondalup,
WA, Australia
Anuj Sharma, Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA
Nagesh Kumar, Department of Civil Engineering, Indian Institute of Science
Bangalore, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India
Chien Ming Wang, School of Civil Engineering, The University of Queensland,
Brisbane, QLD, Australia
Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering (LNCE) publishes the latest developments in
Civil Engineering - quickly, informally and in top quality. Though original research
reported in proceedings and post-proceedings represents the core of LNCE, edited
volumes of exceptionally high quality and interest may also be considered for
publication. Volumes published in LNCE embrace all aspects and subfields of, as
well as new challenges in, Civil Engineering. Topics in the series include:
• Construction and Structural Mechanics
• Building Materials
• Concrete, Steel and Timber Structures
• Geotechnical Engineering
• Earthquake Engineering
• Coastal Engineering
• Ocean and Offshore Engineering; Ships and Floating Structures
• Hydraulics, Hydrology and Water Resources Engineering
• Environmental Engineering and Sustainability
• Structural Health and Monitoring
• Surveying and Geographical Information Systems
• Indoor Environments
• Transportation and Traffic
• Risk Analysis
• Safety and Security
To submit a proposal or request further information, please contact the appropriate
Springer Editor:
– Mr. Pierpaolo Riva at pierpaolo.riva@springer.com (Europe and Americas);
– Ms. Swati Meherishi at swati.meherishi@springer.com (Asia - except China,
and Australia, New Zealand);
– Dr. Mengchu Huang at mengchu.huang@springer.com (China).
All books in the series now indexed by Scopus and EI Compendex database!
Sritawat Kitipornchai
Editors
EASEC16
Proceedings of The 16th East Asian-Pacific
Conference on Structural Engineering
and Construction, 2019
123
Editors
Chien Ming Wang Vinh Dao
School of Civil Engineering School of Civil Engineering
The University of Queensland The University of Queensland
St. Lucia, QLD, Australia St Lucia, QLD, Australia
Sritawat Kitipornchai
School of Civil Engineering
The University of Queensland
St Lucia, QLD, Australia
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd.
The registered company address is: 152 Beach Road, #21-01/04 Gateway East, Singapore 189721,
Singapore
EASEC International Steering Committee
Chair Emeritus
Y. Fujino, Japan
H. Okamura, Japan
P. Karasudhi, Thailand
W. Kanok-Nukulchai, Thailand
S. Kitipornchai, Australia
Chair
Y. B. Yang, Taiwan
Deputy Chairs
C. M. Wang, Australia
T. Ueda, Japan
General Secretary
A. H. F. Lam, Hong Kong
Members
Hong Hao, Australia
José L. Torero, UK
Y. C. Loo, Australia
Sai On Cheung, Hong Kong
D. Hoedajanto, Japan
K. Maekawa, Japan
T. Matsumoto, Japan
J. Niwa, Japan
Y. Okui, Japan
H. M. Koh, Korea
Jung Sik Kong, Korea
v
Wan Hamidon, Malaysia
Y. Y. Chen, P. R. China
L. M. Sun, P. R. China
L. P. Yeh, P. R. China
L H. Han, P. R. China
Jiping Hao, P. R. China
T. C. Pan, Singapore
Ser Tong Quek, Singapore
L. J. Leu, Taiwan
C. S. Chen, Taiwan
P. Warnitchai, Thailand
C. Rojahn, USA
G. Chiu, USA
N. Hoang, Vietnam
Members of EASEC16 Scientific Committee
vii
viii Members of EASEC16 Scientific Committee
Chair
Chien Ming Wang
Vice-chair
Vinh Dao
Special Advisor
Sritawat Kitipornchai
Members
SangHyung Ann
ShuJian Chen
Dilum Fernando
David Lange
Matthew Mason
Cristian Maluk
Juan Hidalgo Medina
Lisa Ottenhaus
Dorival Pedroso
Conference Managers
Arosha Dabarera
Liang Li
Conference Helpers
Da Chen
Yun Il Chu
Mengmeng Han
Ba-Dinh Le
xi
xii EASEC16 Local Organising Committee
Quang Xuan Le
Junwei Lyu
Vikum Mahagamage
Hai Hoang Nguyen
Huu Phu Nguyen
Wenhao Pan
Jeong-Cheol Park
Ronja Topp
Son Duy Tran
Der-Shen Yang
Shaoyu Zhao
Contact Persons
Arosha Dabarera (Email: a.dabarera@uq.edu.au)
Liang Li (Email: liang.li@uq.edu.au)
Vinh Dao (Email: v.dao@uq.edu.au)
C. M. Wang (Email: cm.wang@uq.edu.au)
Contents
Keynote Papers
Innovation and Practice in Building Structure Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
J. M. Ding and Y. Q. Zhang
Experimental and Numerical Study of Flexural-Torsional Buckling
of Web-Tapered High-Strength Steel I-Beams . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
T. Le, M. A. Bradford, and H. R. Valipour
Personal Reflections of My Research in Structural Mechanics:
Past, Present, and Future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33
J. N. Reddy
Changing Our Understanding of Reinforcement Corrosion in Marine
Concrete Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
R. E. Melchers
xiii
xiv Contents
Steel Structures
Study on an Innovative H-Beam to SHS-Column Joint with Cast
Column-Link in Steel Frames . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1367
Dongchen Ye, Yiyi Chen, Gang Zhao, and Qingjun Shi
Structural Behavior of Steel Moment-Resisting Frames Subjected
to Multiple Earthquakes Considering Column
Strength Deterioration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1379
R. Tenderan, T. Ishida, and S. Yamada
Deterioration Behavior of SHS Steel Columns Subjected
to Small Amplitude Loading History . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1391
T. Ishida and S. Yamada
An Experimental Study on Local Buckling Strength of Welded
Box Section Stub-Columns Made of SBHS400 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1403
K. Sobajima, J. Nie, T. Miyashita, S. Okada, N. Takeshima, and K. Ono
Proposal to Improve the DSM Design of Cold-Formed Steel
Fixed-Ended Columns Failing in Global Modes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1415
P. B. Dinis, D. Camotim, A. Landesmann, and A. D. Martins
An Experimental Study on Buckling Strength of Stainless Steel
Columns with Gusset Plates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1427
A. Matsuo, S. Sthapit, A. Shibuya, Y. Shimura, Y. Kobayashi, and K. Ono
Effect of Number of Additional Bolts Outside Splice Plates
on Behaviour of Frictional Type Bolted Joints with a Filler Plate . . . . . 1439
H. Moriyama, T. Takai, T. Yamaguchi, and S. Kozai
Bearing Limit State of High-Strength Frictional Bolted Joints
Consisted of Several Bolts Based on Bolt Hole Deformation . . . . . . . . . 1453
R. Sakura, H. Moriyama, and T. Yamaguchi
Experimental Research and Parametric Study on the Fatigue
Performance of Slotted Tubular Connection Based on the Effective
Notch Stress Approach . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1467
Y. X. Luo, R. L. Ma, M. J. He, R. Fincato, and S. Tsutsumi
Experimental Study of a Prefabricated Steel Frame System
with Buckling-Restrained Braces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1479
Yuan Xu, Hong Guan, Hassan Karampour, Yew-Chaye Loo,
and Xuejun Zhou
Automatic Optimal Design of Steel Modular Buildings Under
Different Wind Load Levels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1491
J. C. Guo and X. Zhao
Contents xxv
Abstract The innovation of building structure design should satisfy the aspects of
architectural form, function using and interior space design. The process of struc-
tural innovation is the fusion of structure and architecture. Firstly, structural system
should relate to the architectural design of the building. Secondly, the structural
layout should correspond to the building space using. Finally, digital design is a
critical technology during the innovation of structural design. Therefore, this essay
is going to express how the structural innovation can be achieved during the design
of structure from eight cases in details.
Keywords Large-span stadiums Architectural form Structural system
Structural layout Digital design
1 Introduction
To combine structural design and architectural design together is always the target
that structural engineers keep trying to achieve. A lot of engineering projects are
therefore be used as the platforms by engineers for achieving structural innovation
during the design.
Structural innovation requires the structure to fulfill architectural form, function and
interior space in priority. The selection of structural system should follow the
coordination of force performance and architectural design, and thus to create a
perfect structural system from both side of force and shape.
Zhengda Stadium (Fig. 1) locates in the South District of Sports Center in Fudan
University campus. It is used as the main venue for celebrating 100th anniversary of
Fudan University, therefore it is assumed as the critical engineering project for the
anniversary. The design of the stadium is inspired by the concept of “the rising sun
on the sea”, which symbolizes the spirit of Fudan University, like a silver clarion
rung.
The combination of steel truss, cable and arch are adopted by the stadium as the
structural system. The primary structure of the roof uses ridge truss and longitudinal
truss. For secondary structure, tension cable and arch system are adopted (Fig. 2
and Fig. 3).
A steel arch with a 76° slope to the horizon spans the entire structure above the
roof. The span of the arch is 100 m, which symbolizes the 100-year history of
Fudan. The architectural shape requires the upper oblique arch to be as thin as
possible. A 20% of the load is designed to be supported by the inclined arch and
80% of the load is designed to be supported by the roof in structural design (Figs. 4
and 5).
(a) Force distribution for a single-row truss (b) Structural layout for a single-row truss
(a) Structural layout in entirety (b) Roof ring beam and beam support between
the trusses
The sag to span ratio is only 1/38, while the span of the roof structure is 81 m.
Hence, the string beam is used for the roof structure, with the primary beam is set to
match the shape of the roof. The structure can both cover the shortage of the
insufficient rigidity caused by the concave shape, and satisfy the visual effect of
transparency, without the need of a ceiling.
The sag to span ratio of the string beam is 1/9.5, which is coordinated with the
curvature of the primary beam, and thus to form a rhythmic water wave shape. This
is the cooperation between force-guided structure system and aesthetically guided
architecture (Figs. 12, 13 and 14).
Innovation and Practice in Building Structure Design 9
Fig. 13 Axonometric
drawing
Fig. 16 The measure for ensuring the out-of-plan stability of string beam structure
iii. Additional stability measures: Although the above two points are reliable
enough to guarantee the out-of-plane stability of the concave beam-string
beam, angle braces are arranged on both sides of the upper struts to improve
the safety of redundancy (Figs. 15 and 16).
The colossal size and elegant style of the structure improves this large-scaled
space with the features of neat and concise, and the classy and rhythmic structural
lines highlight the beauty and power of the building.
The exhibition halls in pairs are only connected by lenticular truss with a spacing
of 18 m, which can both maintain the design concept of rhythmic water waves and
keep the effect of transparency for the building at the same time. The extroverted
facade, huge overhanging eave, and flying eave corner highlight the vitality of the
building (Fig. 17).
Innovation and Practice in Building Structure Design 11
The gymnasium of Tongji University Jiading Campus is integrated with both struc-
tural design and architectural design. Its component design and connection design
have outstanding highlights in expressing the architect’s concept. The stadium fea-
tures a single curved building with a span of 76.5 m in length and 60 m in width,
including a stadium and a swimming pool with grandstand (Fig. 18). The gymnasium
adopts a string beam structure that perfectly fits the image of the building and creates a
satisfactory interior space (Fig. 19). The swimming pool adopts a retractable string
beam roof structure (Fig. 20). When building function is satisfied, the retractable roof
is environment friendly and can also save operating cost.
Fig. 19 Interior
For structural components, the stadium introduces the design of the light guide
tube (Figs. 21 and 22), which can introduce natural light into the room, save energy
and being environment friendly. An integrated design has been made for string
beam web and light guide tube. This design avoids the light guide tube occupying
the building space and creates an architectural expression of starry sky.
The retractable roof of the swimming pool (Fig. 23) designs the roof and vertical
façade as a whole structure. The combination of a single-layer grid roof and a
façade structure allows the rails of the roof to be placed on the ground, thereby
reducing the impact of roof sliding on the overall structure and meeting the needs of
building function.
Innovation and Practice in Building Structure Design 13
For structural connection, a smooth transition is designed for string beam strut
and upper trust of the retractable roof for the swimming pool (Fig. 24), which is
simple and beautiful in appearance. The bottom cable clamp node of the strut
adopts an integrated design, and the nodes are fine and pretty. The lower cable
clamp nodes of the string beam of the gymnasium have been refined, and the cables
are arranged on both sides of the strut to avoid the influence of the structure on the
light guide tube. When the construction is tensioned, the cable clamp node can
allow the cable to slide, after that, the cable will be locked to avoid a large bending
moment at the upper end of the strut during the construction (Fig. 25).
The swimming pool of Jining City has 4 floors above ground and 1 underground
floor. The total height of the structure is 23 m. The main structure of the roof
presents a continuous flap shape, which is symmetrical in the longitudinal axis. The
longitudinal length of the roof is 195 m and the maximum lateral width is 102 m.
Square steel pipe grid is adopted for the hexagonal honeycomb facade, which
extends to the exterior ground and thus subjects both the horizontal and vertical
loads. The facade forms an entire shape with the main structure of the roof, and this
helps the architectural shape to be expressed into structural form with a more
intuitionistic way (Figs. 26, 27 and 28).
14 J. M. Ding and Y. Q. Zhang
The prominent feature of the central roof structure of Jining Swimming Pool is
the double Y-shaped string beam, which is bifurcate for both upper primary beam
and lower cable. This scheme can efficiently reduce the amount of steel used under
a reasonable deflection control for mid span; and the inverse arch amount under
self-weight and cable prestress is more acceptable. In addition, the honeycomb steel
frame structure of the swimming pool can meet the requirement of architectural
appearance and meanwhile be used as the vertical support for the extension of roof
string beam. This improves the structural rigidity, enhances its out-of-plane sta-
bility, and makes the structural design and architectural design to be perfectly fit
(Figs. 29 and 30).
Innovation and Practice in Building Structure Design 15
With more complicated shapes are used for large-span structures, digital technology
therefore is introduced in structural design. This can improve the efficiency of
structural design and enhance the integration of architecture and structure at the
same time.
Fig. 38 Architectural
scheme
Dianchi Water Park is a shell structure with a span of 200 m. In this project,
architectural design and structural design are not limited too much at the early stage,
which makes the design can be more innovative and relative free. Therefore, digital
technology has been extremely used for this project, multiple schemes are raised by
structural engineers under the prerequisite of satisfying architectural space using
(Figs. 38, 39, 40, 41 and 42).
The innovation of structural design should not simply base on a deep understanding
of traditional structural systems and material properties, but also should base on
solving practical engineering problems; secondly, it should have a good under-
standing of the importance of innovation in the processes of design, and tries to
make it be acceptable; finally, self-cultivation should be continuously improved,
because an ideal realm of structural design is the harmony and unify of architectural
beauty and structural beauty.
References
Abstract Despite now over half a century since its manufacture, high-strength
steel (HSS) structural sections have only recently attracted the civil engineering
fraternity as a replacement for mild steel in order to achieve lighter design solutions.
Contemporary HSS is weldable, reliable and more ductile than its predecessors,
leading to designs with lower carbon footprints than those offered by conventional
mild steel that provides an entry portal to the circular economy of low emissions,
deconstructability and reuse. Further economies may be gained by tailoring the
profile of the HSS cross-section to suit the envelope of design actions based on the
load cases which it is needed to resist. This paper presents the experimental testing
of full-scale web-tapered HSS beams for the lateral buckling limit state, purported
to be the first such tests reported in the literature. Fundamental to the buckling
strength of HSS is the state of the residual stresses induced during its fabrication by
welding, and these are determined by the non-destructive technique of neutron
diffraction which is also described. Based on the results of the experimental pro-
gramme, a numerical technique embedded in the widely-used ABAQUS compu-
tational library is described, which may be used to achieve advanced solutions for
the flexural-torsional buckling of HSS beams whose webs are tapered to suit the
variation of the applied bending moments along their lengths.
Keywords High-strength steel Flexural-torsional buckling Experimental
investigation Numerical model
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Programme
Tensile stresses were measured from samples laser-cut from the virgin steel plate
whose longitudinal axis coincided with the direction of rolling. The residual stresses
were measured using the non-destructive technique of neutron diffraction, as
described by Le et al. [6, 7]. Figure 2 shows the residual stresses so obtained; these
differ considerably from those measured in fabricated column sections because the
flanges are narrower and the web deeper (Ban et al. [10]). The out-of-plumb
geometric imperfections were measured using the technique outlined by Le et al.
[7]. None of these imperfections exceeded the guidelines proposed in AS4100 [9]
of the greater of 3 mm and of the span/1000.
Figure 3 depicts the test setup, with transverse loading being applied at the
taper-prismatic intersection in order to generate the bending moments in the middle,
tapered segment. Two scenarios of end moment loading (aL = 1 ) b = −1 and
aL = 0 ) b = –1/3) were considered.
24 T. Le et al.
Hydraulic actuators applied the load to the beam through special loading boxes
that allowed free rotation of the beam about the major and minor axes, and which
also allowed free warping and downward movement of the beam but restrained the
beam against lateral deflection and twist (Fig. 4). Because the loading boxes were
hung on the top flange of the beam at the prismatic-taper intersections, a layer of
high compressive strength plaster was firstly applied beneath the steel loading plate
to support and align it in the horizontal plane. After the plaster cured, the boxes
were then placed on the steel plate. The movements of the boxes were guided by a
set of two universal columns which were assembled into a frame system and firmly
braced as shown in Fig. 3. In order to minimise friction, rollers were utilised at
contact positions between the components. The end-support was similar to the
support of uniform beams so that the beam end twist and lateral deflection were
prevented but warping and rotation about the major and minor axes, as well as
movement in the axial direction, were allowed.
Linear variable differential transformers (LVDTs) were employed for the dis-
placement measurements and strain gauges (SGs) for the strain measurements. The
layout and location of the LVDTs and the SGs mounted on a cross-section are
depicted in Fig. 5. Due to the spatial restraint beneath the loading boxes, LVDT–1
and LVDT–2 were put aside and the mean of their readings was taken as the
transverse displacement of specimens at the load level P1. A similar arrangement
was used for measuring the displacement of specimens at the load level P2.
Fig. 4 Loading box in test of web-tapered beams. (1) outer box, (2) inner box, (3–5) roller
bearings, (6) spherical roller bearings, (7) modified spherical thrust roller bearing, (8) I-beam
specimen and (9) high compressive strength plaster
26 T. Le et al.
2.4 Results
Figure 6 shows the evolution of the lateral displacements uy with the moment M,
while Table 2 summarises the test results. The buckled configuration of TB-890-2
is given in Fig. 7. For TB-890-1 under moment gradient (b = –1/3), the critical
section, at which the ratio of the applied bending moment to the plastic moment is
greatest (AS4100), was the largest tapered section (the depth of the critical section
Experimental and Numerical Study of Flexural-Torsional Buckling … 27
Hcr = H1). The buckling moment Mm = 358 kNm was significantly less than the
nominal yield bending moment My,cr = 602 kNm and the nominal plastic moment
Mp,cr = 701 kNm of the critical section so that the beam buckled in the elastic
range. The specimen responded linearly to the load before the critical load was
reached (Fig. 6). Tensile rupture did not occur in any of the tests.
For the specimens under uniform bending (b = –1), the critical section was the
smallest tapered section (the depth of critical section Hcr = H2). The tests showed
that as the taper constant aw increases, the buckling resistance of the tapered beams
increases. It is noteworthy that the buckling of these tapered beams was in the
inelastic range as the maximum applied moments were greater than the nominal
yield moments My,cr of the critical sections as shown in Fig. 6, especially for
TB-890-2 whose buckling load reached the nominal plastic moment Mp,cr of its
critical section, leading to a non-linear response when the applied load passed the
yield moment My,cr. Accordingly, it is noted the lateral buckling of these specimens
occurred not due to the yielding of the smallest tapered sections which were fully
restrained, but rather related to the yielding of the compression flange of the section
which had the largest twist displacement. While a few recent studies have proposed
first yield criteria approaches for the buckling strength of the non-prismatic steel
members, the present experiments show that more investigations are needed to
evaluate the effects of load and restraint arrangements, material and geometric
imperfections, and the variation of the steel material on the buckling resistance of
tapered beams.
28 T. Le et al.
3 Numerical Study
A non-linear ABAQUS modelling of the tested beams was undertaken, using the
meshing shown in Fig. 8 and using the stress-strain curves obtained from material
testing of the specimens. The geometric imperfections were taken as recommended
in AS4100 (SA [9].
The results for the buckling moments are given in Table 2 and comparisons of
the moment vs deformations response reported elsewhere [5] have shown accept-
able agreement.
Experimental and Numerical Study of Flexural-Torsional Buckling … 29
Mb ¼ am as Ms minfMob ; Ms g; ð1Þ
in which Mb is the buckling strength, Mob the elastic buckling moment, Ms the
section bending capacity, am a moment modifier and as the section slenderness
factor proposed as being
"sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
#
0:6 2
as ¼ c m ks þ 1
2 4
k þ 1:08 cm ks 1;
2
ð2Þ
cm s
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
in which ks ¼ ðMs =Moa Þ is the modified slenderness (Moa is the reference elastic
buckling bending moment excluding the effect of non-uniform moment distribu-
tion) and cm (= 0.7) a material factor for HSS having a yield stress exceeding
690 MPa. Figure 9 shows the proposed formulation based on AS4100 compared
with the test results, and Fig. 10 the formulation compared with the numerical
solutions from ABAQUS, from which it can be seen that the AS4100 formulation is
fairly good, albeit conservative.
4 Conclusions
This paper has described detailed experimental testing of four web-tapered HSS
beams in order to investigate the limit state of flexural-torsional buckling. The
testing required a special setup in order to handle the restraints, tapering and
loading, and it led to robust responses of the beams from the onset of loading until
buckling. Tensile rupture of the bottom flange did not occur in any of the
specimens.
A numerical model was validated against the test results and it was used to
explore a design procedure based on AS4100. This was shown to be reasonably
accurate. It is suggested that considerably more testing and numerical simulations
are needed to provide design guidance that is accurate and reliable.
Acknowledgements The work reported in this paper was supported by a research grant awarded
to the second author by the Australian Research Council (DP150100446) through its Discovery
Projects Scheme. The residual stresses were measured at the Australian Nuclear Science and
Technology Organisation Facility through Proposals 6397 and 7531. This support is also
acknowledged with thanks.
References
1. Ban H, Shi G, Shi Y, Bradford MA (2013) Experimental investigation of the overall buckling
behaviour of 960 MPa high strength steel columns. J Constr Steel Res 88:256–266
2. Ban H, Shi G (2018) A review of research on high-strength steel structures. Proc Inst Civ
Eng-Struct Build 171(8):625–641
3. Bradford MA (2006) Lateral buckling of tapered steel members (Chap 1). In:
Shanmugam NE, Wang CM (eds) Analysis and design of plated structures, vol 1.
Woodhead Publishing Limited, Cambridge, pp 1–25
4. Bradford MA, Ban H (2014) Stability of half-through girder high strength steel railway
bridges. In: 2nd international conference on railway technology: research, development and
maintenance, Ajaccio, Corsica, France, April, Paper 72
Experimental and Numerical Study of Flexural-Torsional Buckling … 31
5. Le T (2019) Buckling strength of high-strength steel beams. PhD thesis, School of Civil and
Environmental Engineering, UNSW Sydney (The University of New South Wales)
6. Le T, Bradford MA, Liu X, Valipour HR (2019a, in press) Buckling of high-strength steel
I-beams. J Constr Steel Res
7. Le T, Paradowska A, Bradford MA, Liu X, Valipour HR (2019b, in press) Residual stresses in
welded high-strength steel I-beams. J Constr Steel Res
8. Shi G, Zhu X, Ban H (2016) Material properties and partial factors for resistance of
high-strength steels in China. J Constr Steel Res 121:65–79
9. SA (2016) AS4100-1998 Steel Structures, Standards Australia, Sydney
10. Woolcock ST, Kitipornchai S, Bradford MA, Haddad GA (2011) Design of portal frame
buildings, 4th edn. AISC, Sydney
Personal Reflections of My Research
in Structural Mechanics: Past, Present,
and Future
J. N. Reddy
Keywords Shear deformation plate theory Layerwise laminate theory Bending
relationships Locking-free shell finite elements Nonlocal structural theories
1 Introduction
The author comes from a lower middle-income farming family in rural South India.
As the youngest of five children, he was the first in his family to go beyond high
school. During summer holidays, he used to help his father on the farm, which
prepared him to be a hard worker, diligent, and thorough. He went through a
five-year integrated Bachelor of Engineering degree in India that prepared him with
a broader engineering background and helped him in the later years to work not
J. N. Reddy (&)
J. Mike Walker ’66 Department of Mechanical Engineering, Texas A&M University,
College Station, TX 77843-3123, USA
e-mail: jnreddy@tamu.edu
only in solid and structural mechanics but also in heat transfer, fluid mechanics, and
applied mathematics.
The author went to USA in the spring of 1969 to do a M.S. at Oklahoma State
University. The he joined Professor J.T. Oden’s research group at the University of
Alabama in Huntsville for Ph.D. in engineering mechanics. Professor Oden was one
of the top researchers in the world and the only engineer who was beginning to
work on mathematical foundations of the finite element method. The author’s
dissertation topic was on the existence and uniqueness of mixed finite element
approximations of boundary value problems as well as the unification of variational
principles of theoretical mechanics. Both of the topics led, in addition to several
journal papers, to two books with Dr. Oden.
Following his Ph.D. (1974), he worked for a brief period with Lockheed
Missiles and Space Company, where he worked on a NASA (Glenn) research
project to develop a 3D finite element code to study hypervelocity impact, he joined
the University of Oklahoma, Norman, in January 1975. It was there where he was
introduced to the subject of composite materials and structures by Professor Charles
Bert that would change the course of his professional career and follow the legacy
of Timoshenko and Mindlin and likes to develop shear deformation theories.
Knowing the limitations of classical thin plate and shell theories in capturing
inter-laminar stresses, he started working on shear deformation theories for com-
posite laminates. His background in mathematics, mechanics, and the finite element
method enabled him not only to conceive novel and improved mathematical models
of beam, plate, and shell theories, but also to develop locking-free and robust finite
element models – an activity that continues to the present day.
During the last four decades (he was at Virginia Tech for 12 years and 27 years
and going at Texas A&M University), the author has been working on two major
fronts as far as the structural mechanics is concerned (he also has also worked in
computational fluid dynamics) with two topics: (1) development of 7-, 8-, and
12-parameter shell theories and their finite elements and (2) nonlocal and
non-classical continuum mechanics. The first topic is a continuation of many years
of his work on shear deformation theories of plates and shells to develop
locking-free shell elements for large deformation analysis of laminated composite
and functionally graded structures. He has collaborated with Professor C.M. Wang
of the National University of Singapore (now at the University of Queensland,
Australia) to develop algebraic relations between the bending, frequency, and
buckling solutions of shear deformation theories in terms of the corresponding
solutions of the classical theories. The second topic is a rejuvenation of ideas
originated and advanced by Cosserat bothers, Green, Naghdi, Mindlin, Eringen,
Hutchinson, and likes, and their implementation into structural theories. These
include: couple stress theories, strain and stress gradient theories, and micromorphic
theories. The nonlocal and non-classical continuum ideas can be used to study
architected materials and efficient modelling of large or mega structures, by
bringing material as well as structural length scales into structural theories.
In this written paper, (1) the robust shell finite elements and (2) nonlocal (mi-
cropolar) plate models are discussed. However, the oral presentation will briefly
discuss all 6 milestones.
Personal Reflections of My Research in Structural Mechanics … 35
2.1 Introduction
Here we present few results using a third-order thickness stretching theory with
eight independent parameters as an alternative to the twelve-parameter formulation.
The displacement vector is assumed to be of the form
h h h
uðni Þ ¼ uðna Þ þ n3 uðna Þ þ ðn3 Þ2 Wðna Þ^
n þ ðn3 Þ3 cðna Þ^
n ð1Þ
2 2 2
Here u denotes the mid-plane displacement vector u is the difference vector and it
gives the change in the mid-surface director, and W and c are components that are
used to circumvent the spurious stresses that occur in the thickness direction of a six
parameter formulation. The remaining theoretical development (e.g., derivation of
the Green-Lagrange strain tensor, use of the principle of virtual displacement, and
finite element model development) are not included here and the user is referred to
Gutierrez Rivera et al. [10] for additional information.
36 J. N. Reddy
x ¼ 0; L : uy ¼ uz ¼ uy ¼ uz ¼ W ¼ c ¼ 0 ð2Þ
Fig. 2 Normalized
transverse displacement
versus normalized axial
coordinate
Fig. 4 Deformed
configuration of the internally
pressurized cylindrical shell
38 J. N. Reddy
3.1 Background
3.2 Formulation
Use of the principle of virtual displacements with appropriate expressions for the
virtual strain energy potential associated with the micropolar plate theory and
introduction of suitable stress resultants, we can derive the Euler equations asso-
ciated with micropolar first-order shear deformation plate theory. For details, see
Karttunen et al. [12]. The equations of motion of the 2D micropolar plate are:
40 J. N. Reddy
where ðNxx ; Nyy ; Nxy ; Nyx Þ are the in-plane membrane forces, ðMxx ; Myy ; Mxy ; Myx Þ
are the bending and twisting moments, ðQax ; Qay Þ are antisymmetric shear forces,
ðQsx ; Qsy Þ symmetric shear forces, and ðPxx ; Pyy ; Pxy Þ are the local (couple-stress
related) bending and twisting resultants. The next step is to relate the plate degrees
of freedom to the 3D unit cell displacement degrees of freedom.
Fig. 5 Web-core 3D unit cell modeled by shell finite elements in Abaqus. The mesh is coarse for
illustrative purposes. In generating a statically condensed FE model for the two-scale constitutive
modeling approach, certain DOFs are retained on face edges A and B while all interior DOFs are
condensed out. No boundary conditions are applied
Personal Reflections of My Research in Structural Mechanics … 41
where N are the in-plane membrane forces, M are the bending and twisting
moments, Q contains symmetric and antisymmetric shear forces, and P is the local
(couple-stress related) bending and twisting resultants.
A web-core unit cell made of steel with Young’s modulus E = 206 GPa, Poisson’s
ratio ʋ = 0.3 and density q = 7850 kg/m3 is considered. The height of the unit cell
is taken to be 0.044 m. The length and width of the unit cell are both taken to be
l = 0.12 m so that the unit cell planform area is A = l2 = 0.0144 m2. The Navier
solution for bending of the simply supported 2D micropolar plate under line load is
obtained (see Fig. 5 for the plate geometry). A conventional plate under line load
yields maximum displacement that is 34% for face sheet thicknesses of 2 mm
compared to a 3D FE solution, whereas the 2D micropolar plate model gives only
small error of 2.7% as it can emulate the 3D deformations better through
non-classical antisymmetric shear behavior and local bending and twisting (see
Fig. 6). The 3D FEM model consists of 60800 shell elements of S8R5 type from
Abaqus, whereas the micropolar plate solution is obtained with a small fraction of
the FEM solution.
Fig. 6 a Transverse displacement of a 2-D micropolar web-core plate under a line load for tf
= 4 mm. b Transverse displacement of the plate mid-section calculated by different models
42 J. N. Reddy
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The author is pleased to acknowledge the research collaboration with Drs.
Miguel Gutieriez Rivera (University of Guanajuato, Mexico) and Anssi T. Karttunen (Aalto
University, Finland).
References
R. E. Melchers
1 Introduction
R. E. Melchers (&)
Centre for Infrastructure Performance and Reliability, University of Newcastle,
2308 Callaghan, Australia
e-mail: rob.melchers@newcastle.edu.au
implies that the level may be too high for some structures and too low for others,
without any indication of which is the case. The alternative view is that this indi-
cates there are other factors involved, not considered and that may be much more
important. Of course, such a view could be considered heresy, given the long
history of very extensive and detailed research investigations by many researchers.
Yet this ‘disruptive’ view is precisely that which must be taken to make progress, as
outlined below.
There is now a considerable body of evidence, from actual concrete structures,
exposed to various marine environments that, other than minor corrosion, often not
visible to the outside, serious damaging reinforcement corrosion may not occur for
many decades. Some of these cases have been described earlier [13, 14, 18, 19] and
most recently detailed for the Phoenix caissons placed off the coast of France just
after D-day on 6 June 1944 [16]. Figure 1 shows just one example of part of one of
the more than 40 caissons visible at low tide and some 30 with their upper part
always above high tide that show the serious structural damage done by storm
conditions commencing already soon after D-day [9] but the very limited evidence
of any reinforcement corrosion, such as cracking along the bars. Detailed investi-
gations using concrete coring of immersed, splash and atmospheric corrosion zones
showed pH above about 10 throughout, except the outer 1–2 mm at the exposed
surfaces, very high chloride concentrations [16] inside the concrete, and therefore at
the steel bars, the concrete to have very high strength (50–60 MPa) and therefore
also very low permeability.
The next section provides commentary on some basic factors that are essential
for studying reinforcement corrosion in laboratory studies - factors that have been
almost universally forgotten or ignored, with the result that many studies are
meaningless for translation to real concrete structures. This is followed by a sum-
mary exposition of the process for corrosion initiation, the essential preconditions to
that occurring, and the fact that for high quality concretes then corrosion stops or
progresses at a very slow rate. For such concretes the eventual condition for
damaging corrosion is loss of calcium hydroxide, aided in the case of marine
Fig. 1 Example of heavily damaged reinforced concrete caisson exposed to marine environments
since 1944, showing very limited evidence of reinforcement corrosion
Changing Our Understanding of Reinforcement Corrosion … 45
structures by the action of chlorides. The paper closes with a summary of the
practical implications and a warning about the, often neglected, occurrence of deep
transverse cracks that can cause very severe, highly localized corrosion.
2 Background
In actual concretes any reinforcement bars are surrounded by the concrete matrix
material. Usually this is of low permeability and thus any moisture conditions
around the bars can be characterized as stagnant. Under such conditions it was
established, empirically, more than 100 years ago that the rate of corrosion is only
minimally affected by the type of salt in solution (water) or its concentration [6].
They observed little difference in corrosion loss for mild steel strips immersed in
weak, but stagnant, solutions of many different salts, including NaCl. These
observations were explained much later Dora [3] that the weak passive film, first
observed in the 1930s [4] remains in place in stagnant conditions, thereby limiting
the availability of oxygen for corrosion. This does not occur under non-stagnant
conditions. Empirically this was demonstrated in carefully controlled experiments
for the effect of chlorides on corrosion [20]. They found essentially no overall
corrosion under stagnant conditions, no matter what the concentration of chlorides.
In this respect, the conventional electrochemical tests do not comply as they
almost always stir the solutions or the specimens in order to speed up the reactions.
But this destroys their relevance to corrosion in concrete. Also, such tests use
solutions representing the pore waters assumed to exist inside concretes, rather than
real concretes, adding to the problematic relationship between test conditions and
reality (cf. [23]).
The second important aspect is that new concretes present pH values of around
13.5. This is the result of alkalis NaOH, KOH and Ca(OH)2, the first two of which
are quite soluble in water and often leach out of the concrete matrix relatively
quickly, even for relatively impermeable high quality concretes. Typically this
leaves mainly Ca(OH)2 as the controlling alkali with a solution pH around 12.
Under high chloride conditions this is sufficient to inhibit generalized corrosion, but
not pitting [22]. Thus, if other conditions are met, such as oxygen availability and
water, pitting corrosion will occur.
The third important aspect is that the solubility of Ca(OH)2 increases with the
presence of chlorides, roughly in proportion to the chloride concentration [10].
Finally, it was proposed already in 2006 [17] that for good quality low per-
meability concretes the initiation of reinforcement corrosion at time ti is a transient
effect that may permit some limited amount of corrosion to occur but that this then
ceases or becomes very low until at some much later time, at tact say, serious,
damaging corrosion commences (Fig. 2). It was foreshadowed that these two
changes of state were governed by two quite different processes, the initiation phase
46 R. E. Melchers
Fig. 2 Model for development of reinforcement corrosion with increased exposure time (17), as
well as the effect of concrete permeability
by availability of oxygen and water and the active corrosion phase by loss of
alkalis. Recently convincing experimental proof of these two aspects has become
available. It might be noted that the classic Tuuti model does not recognize the
passive period tpass and thus has tact= ti [24].
Information about the time to initiation, and the mechanisms involved have been
obtained from controlled corrosion experiments conducted using a large number of
concrete specimens each 40 40 160 mm long, made seawater and with one
6 mm diam. longitudinal mild steel bar, and to various water cement and aggregate
cement ratios [13]. The specimens were cast horizontally, in high accuracy steel
molds and vibrated on a laboratory shaking-table for concrete compaction. Since
2004 they have been kept continuously in a 25 °C, near 100% relative humidity
environment (fog room). At approximately 12 month intervals some samples were
recovered and detailed observations made [13, 15].
After 2–3 years exposure, it was noticed that while the overall amount of cor-
rosion was negligible, some samples showed a very small amount of pitting or
localized corrosion, mainly along the lower part of the reinforcing bar, away from
the casting direction and the along the side closest to the shaking table top (Fig. 3a).
Close inspection of the concrete that had been in touch with the steel bar showed
that there were air-voids in the concrete corresponding to the locations of pitting
and localized corrosion (Fig. 3b). Similar observations were made in subsequent
years, but remarkably, the amount of corrosion did not increase substantially with
time, although the amount of corrosion was, relatively, greater for the more per-
meable, poor quality concretes [13–15]. For these the local areas of corrosion were
greater and there were multiple air-voids visible in the adjacent concrete (Fig. 3b).
Even after 10 years exposure the concrete pH for the higher strength, dense, low
permeable concretes was still around 12 while for the more permeable specimens
the pH had decreased to around 10. Chloride concentrations at this time were still
considerable [13]. Thus the corrosion observed is consistent with the [22] criterion
Changing Our Understanding of Reinforcement Corrosion … 47
(a) (b)
Fig. 3 a Cross-section showing typical localized (pitting) corrosion along lower part of
reinforcing bar corresponding to wet air-voids in the adjacent concrete matrix, b more extensive
corrosion along lower part of bar for permeable concrete
for pitting corrosion being possible for high chloride concentrations but that general
corrosion is, essentially, precluded.
In practice there is a long history of observations of air-voids adjacent to rein-
forcing bars, typically attributed to the degree of concrete compaction during
construction (e.g. [21]). However, voids are not always observed. For example, two
of the field studies mentioned above [18, 19] showed no visible voids next to the
reinforcement. Some research projects also have reported the presence of voids [2,
7] but there is no mention of the degree of concrete compaction. Although a number
of potential influencing factors are mentioned, no conclusions were drawn and no
mechanisms were proposed.
The experimental observations in Fig. 3 immediately indicate the corrosion
mechanism involved [11, 15]. Chlorides, high pH of the surrounding concrete and
therefore the pore-water when it is available, permit pitting corrosion according to
the [22] criterion, but not generalized corrosion. Earlier it was shown that pitting
corrosion under extended exposures in marine conditions (i.e. high chlorides) and
under rusts develops into localized corrosion owing to the sideways growth of pits
once the pitting potential has been reached [8, 12]. This produces plateaus on which
new pits can form. This process can then recycle to produce the localized corrosion
such as in Fig. 3b. All this occurs within a quite localized region, and can be
represented as in Fig. 4 [11].
48 R. E. Melchers
As hypothesized much earlier [17], the evidence from detailed observations of the
10 year laboratory specimens that included, as noted, a range of water-cement and
aggregate-cement ratios was quite clear, and are summarized in part in Fig. 5. It
shows longitudinal cross-sections of some of the specimens broken open after
10 years for a specimens made with low-heat (sulphate resistant) cement. This is
simply a cement that is slower in setting and develops less heat but is otherwise the
same as normal blended cements, except of one aspect - it has a slightly elevated
content of MnS and FeS. These impart the darker colour of the freshly made (and
freshly exposed) concrete shown particularly in Fig. 5a. Concretes made with such
cements are known to lighten in colour within 2–3 days after exposure to the
atmosphere [5]. The details of these experiments have been given elsewhere [13].
The observations from cases such as shown in Fig. 5 are:
(a) the light coloured concrete is at the external faces, indicating these were
exposed to more oxygen whereas the dark interior was not,
(b) analysis by XRD and EDS showed the dark concrete retained Ca(OH)2 whereas
the light concrete was essentially devoid of Ca(OH)2
(c) correspondingly, the pH readings are still around 12 for the dark concrete, but
much lower for the light concrete,
(d) the depth of penetration of loss of Ca(OH)2 becomes greater as the permeability
of the concrete increases, and also increases with exposure period,
(e) although not shown in Fig. 5, when examined under the microscope the light
coloured concrete showed a much more open, permeable structure than the dark
concrete.
(a) Concrete: appears dense, low permeability (b) Concrete: apparent high permeability
Dark concrete: pH 11.6-11.8; high Ca(OH)2 Dark concrete: negligible
Light concrete: pH ≈9; negligible Ca(OH)2. Light concrete: pH ≈9; negligible Ca(OH)2.
Bar: some isolated, superficial rusts Bar: considerable visible rusts
Fig. 5 Appearance of interior concrete and reinforcing bars after 10 years exposure, showing
distinct differences in colour of the concrete and associated pH spot readings
Changing Our Understanding of Reinforcement Corrosion … 49
Fig. 6 Depth (d) of loss of calcium hydroxide as a function of rebound hammer results
5 Discussion
In interpreting the results shown in Fig. 6 it must be remembered that the two upper
curves are for concretes made with seawater. That means that a high concentration
of chlorides was present right from first exposure, and that any time for the chlo-
rides to diffuse into the concrete is not considered. Such diffusion would add to the
outward rate of alkali leaching from the exterior parts of the concretes. However, in
practice the concentration of chlorides would be much less on average than that for
the experimental specimens reflected in Fig. 6 and thus the rate of leaching cor-
respondingly much lower. In addition, the rate of leaching depends, obviously, on
the permeability of the concrete, as shown in Fig. 6 but also intuitively. Figure 6
shows that for such concretes there is little difference between the depth of pene-
tration (i.e. depth of light coloured concrete) for the concretes with low permeability
(right hand side of graph), irrespective of whether or not seawater had been used in
the mix.
Conversely, the depth of penetration is much greater for poor quality, permeable
concretes (cf. Fig. 5). This can be attributed to the more open concrete matrix
structure exposing greater internal surface areas for alkali dissolution.
The results in Fig. 6 are all for specimens that were continually wet. Where this
is not the case alkali dissolution is likely to be lower and hence the rate of pene-
tration lower and subsequently the rime period tact longer. To be sure, wet concretes
generally do not permit ready entry of carbon dioxide or oxygen (and presumably
chlorides) but this restriction is much removed once the alkalis leach out and the
concrete matrix structure becomes more open as a result (Fig. 5b). Once that has
happened the concrete offers little or no protection against the corrosion of the steel
bar(s) and the rate of corrosion can then approach what it would be for steel
exposed to the local environment. With sufficient such corrosion the corrosion
products would be able to split the concrete along the bar orientations, as commonly
observed in severe environments.
To be even clearer, concretes of poor quality are likely to commence serious
corrosion from soon after ti, as shown schematically in Fig. 2. The challenge clearly
is not to have such concretes if long-term durability is expected.
Finally, In some cases very deep transverse cracks have been observed to cause
very serious corrosion at the crack - this potentially serious issue is at present not
properly addressed by code rules for durability [11, 19] Space precludes further
discussion, but some examples and explanations are available [18, 19]. It might be
noted that this behaviour stems very much from the presence of chlorides at the
crack-reinforcement interface, again highlighting the need for high quality low
permeability concretes, but now also without deep cracks.
Changing Our Understanding of Reinforcement Corrosion … 51
6 Conclusion
The following conclusions may be drawn from the material presented herein:
1. There is no evidence that chlorides directly attack reinforcement bars; instead
they aid the dissolution of the critical alkali calcium hydroxide thereby per-
mitting the earlier access of atmospheric oxygen and permitting corrosion of the
steel subject to availability of water,
2. Low concrete permeability is crucial for reducing the rate at which alkalis can
leach from the concrete and essential for long term durability of reinforcement,
3. Low permeability of concrete implies adequate concrete cement content - typ-
ically greater than currently in use,
4. Compaction should be sufficient to ensure low permeability of the concrete and
also to reduce the size/volume of air-voids at the concrete-steel interface as
much as possible. Larger air-voids produce greater volumes of corrosion
products and these may cause cracking of the concrete along the bars, followed
by severe corrosion as the atmosphere can reach the bars.
5. Electrochemical tests using pore water solutions cannot mimic the localized
corrosion effects identified herein, do not mimic the stagnant conditions inside
real concretes and therefore their results have limited implications for practical
concretes.
6. The present results indicate that the current thinking about reinforcement cor-
rosion needs a complete overhaul, with more attention given to achieving low
permeability, high alkali concrete and much less emphasis on the presence or
otherwise of chlorides.
Acknowledgements The author acknowledges the following support: the Australian Research
Council for some part of the work, the Civil Engineering laboratories at the University of
Newcastle, in particular Ian Jeans and Goran Simundic, and Dr Torill Pape and Dr Igor Chaves and
(the late) Dr Dick van der Molen for suggesting the use of sulphate-reducing cement.
References
1. Angst UM, Elsener B, Larsen CK, Vennesland O (2009) Critical chloride content in
reinforced concrete – a review. Cem Concr Res 39:1122–1138
2. Bouteiller V, Cremona C, Baroghel-Bouny V, Maloula A (2012) Corrosion initiation of
reinforced concretes based on Portland or GGBS cements: Chloride contents and electro-
chemical characteristics versus time. Cem Concr Res 42:1456–1467
3. Brasher Dora M (1967) Stability of the oxide film on metals in relation to inhibition of
corrosion. I Mild steel in the presence of aggressive ions. British Corrosion J 2:95–103
4. Evans UR (1960) The corrosion and oxidation of metals, London, E. Arnold
5. Hanson (2015) Sulphate-resisting cement: Technical data sheet, Version 3.3, November 2015,
Hanson Heidelberg Cement, Ketton, UK
6. Heyn E, Bauer O (1908) Ueber den Angriff des Eisens durch Wasser und wässerige
Losungen. Stahl Eisen 28(44):1564–1573
52 R. E. Melchers
7. Horne AT, Richardson IG, Brydson RMD (2007) Quantitative analysis of the microstructure
of interfaces in steel reinforced concrete. Cem Conc Res 37:1613–1623
8. Jeffrey R, Melchers RE (2007) The changing topography of corroding mild steel surfaces in
seawater. Corros Sci 49:2270–2288
9. Jellet JH (1948) The lay-out, assembly, and behaviour of the breakwaters at Arromanches
Harbour. In: Mulberry B The Civil Engineer at War, vol 2 - Docks and harbours, The
Institution of Civil Engineers, London, pp 291–312
10. Johnston J, Grove C (1931) The solubility of calcium hydroxide in aqueous salt solutions.
J Am Chem Soc 53(11):3976–3991
11. Melchers RE (2017) Modelling durability of reinforced concrete structures. In: Brian Cherry
International Symposium on Reinforced Concrete Corrosion, Protection, Repair and
Durability, Melbourne, 26–27 July, Australasian Corrosion Association
12. Melchers RE (2018) A review of trends for corrosion loss and pit depth in longer-term
exposures. Corros Mater Degrad 1:4
13. Melchers RE, Chaves IA (2017) Service Life Estimation of Concrete Infrastructure. In:
Pacheco-Torgal F et al (eds) Eco-efficient Repair and Rehabilitation of Concrete
Infrastructure. Woodhead, Cambridge, pp 15–42
14. Melchers RE, Chaves IA (2017) A comparative study of chlorides and longer-term
reinforcement corrosion. Mater Corros 68(6):613–621
15. Melchers RE, Chaves IA (2019) Reinforcement corrosion in marine concretes - 1. Initiation.
ACI Mater J 116(5):57–66
16. Melchers RE, Howlett CH (2019) Reinforcement corrosion of the Phoenix caissons after
75 years of marine exposure. Proc, ICE Maritime Engineering (submitted)
17. Melchers RE, Li CQ (2006) Phenomenological modeling of corrosion loss of steel
reinforcement in marine environments. ACI Mater J 103(1):25–32
18. Melchers RE, Li CQ, Davison MA (2009) Observations and analysis of a 63-year old
reinforced concrete promenade railing exposed to the North Sea. Mag. Concr. Res 61(4):233–
243
19. Melchers RE, Pape TM, Chaves IA, Heywood R (2017) Long-term durability of reinforced
concrete piles from the Hornibrook Highway bridge. Aust J Struct Eng 18(1):41–57
20. Mercer AD, Lumbard EA (1995) Corrosion of mild steel in water. B Corr J 30(1):43–55
21. Nawy EG (2008) Concrete construction engineering handbook. CRC Press, Boca Raton,
pp 30–57
22. Pourbaix M (1970) Significance of protection potential in pitting and intergranular corrosion.
Corrosion 26(10):431–438
23. Poursaee A, Hansen CM (2009) Potential pitfalls in assessing chloride-induced corrosion of
steel in concrete. Cem Concr Res 39:391–400
24. Richardson MG (2002) Fundamentals of durable reinforced concrete. SponPress, London
Structural Health Monitoring and Control
Development of Elasto-Magneto-Electric
Sensors for Total-Stress
in Large-Diameter Cables
Keywords Elasto-magnetic (EM) effect Magneto-electric (ME) principle EME
sensors Large-diameter cables Tension monitoring
1 Introduction
and performance directly. Particularly, the cable vibration caused by dynamic loads,
such as wind, rain and traffics, may lead to fatigue damage of cables, thus causing
serious potential damage to the operation safety of the bridge. Bridge accidents
caused by broken cables can be very serious. For examples, the collapse of the
Chirajara Bridge in Colombia in 2018 and the deck collapse of the Wuyi Mountain
Bridge in China in 2011 due to suspender fracture have resulted in grave economic
losses and negative societal impacts. Generally, cable tensions represent the state of
structural integrity of the cable-supported bridge. Therefore, accurate cable stress
monitoring has been an important subject in the structural health monitoring
(SHM) of those structures.
The traditional methods for measuring cable tensions generally evaluate stresses
indirectly from changes in the physical parameters of the structure caused by the
applied stresses, and have various disadvantages, such as difficulty to mount on the
cable and sensitivity to temperature (Table 1).
It is well-known that ferromagnetic materials such as steel members have dif-
ferent inherent magnetic properties under different external force [8], which is the
magnetoelastic effect. Based on the magnetoelastic effect, the elasto-magnetic
(EM) sensor has been developed by many researchers to monitor the cable stress
[10]. However, as the detecting component of an EM sensor, the secondary coil
cannot generate strong induced voltage, limiting its measuring accuracy and
engineering applications. Moreover, until now, most ME sensors are only applied
on small-diameter cables with low measuring precision. For example, the EM
sensor is applied to 128 mm cables in Adige bridge with a relative error of 5% [2].
Recently, an elasto-magneto-electric (EME) sensors was developed by replacing
the secondary coil with a smart magneto-electric (ME) sensing unit. Compared with
the secondary coil, the smart ME unit has higher magnetoelectric conversion
coefficient and magnetic field responsivity [4], which makes the sensor smaller,
more accurate, and more suitable for stress monitoring of large-diameter cables.
An ANSYS model for EME sensors was built and the feasibility of total-stress
monitoring has been confirmed [5, 12]. This paper is aimed to introduce EME
total-stress sensors for large diameter cables, covering the theory, the size of EME
sensors, the experimental calibration in the lab, and an application in an engineering
project.
Development of EME Sensors … 57
2 Theoretical Background
Fig. 1 Magnetic domain distribution in ferromagnetic materials: (a) distribution without external
magnetic field, (b) magnetic field generated by a solenoid, (c) distribution under solenoidal
magnetic field
58 X. Hu et al.
3
Er ¼ kr cos2 h ð2Þ
2
X
1
k¼ ci ðrÞ M 2i ð3Þ
i¼0
Form Eqs. (2) and (3), it is obvious that there is some proportional relationship
between Er and r, which can be expressed as:
@B @Er
¼ u1 ¼ u1 f ðk; h; MS Þ ð4Þ
@r @r
In this paper, in order to replace the secondary coil, a smart ME sensing element is
introduced, which is made from a new smart magnetoelectric laminate, Terfenol-D/
PMN-PT/Terfenol-D (TD/PMNT/TD) laminate. Owing to the magnetostrictive
effect of Terfenol-D and the piezoelectric effect of PMN-PT, this composite
material has a high magneto-electric conversion coefficient [3, 11] and can convert
the change of the magnetic field, which is resulted from the property change of the
ferromagnetic materials subjected to external force, into the detectable electrical
signal represented by the voltage. The relationship [5, 12] can be expressed as:
dVME dS dVME
aV ¼ Kð Þ ð Þ ¼ð Þ ð5Þ
dS mags dB piezo dB com
where aV represents the magnetic conversion coefficient, ðdVdSME Þmags represents the
magnetostrictive effect, while ðdB
dS
Þpiezo represents the piezoelectric effect, and K is a
Development of EME Sensors … 59
constant, only influence by the volumes fraction of the component materials. From
Eqs. 4 and 5, under a certain H, the relationship between V and r can be expressed:
@VME
¼ uf ðk; h; MS Þ ð6Þ
@r
The present EME sensor mainly consists of nylon skeleton, primary coils, smart
sensing units, and insulating layer, as shown in Fig. 2. The primary coil is wound
on the nylon skeleton in order to produce enough magnetic field. Inserted in the
pre-set slot of the skeleton, ME sensing units can produce induced voltage signal by
converting the changes of the magnetic field. The insulating layer can prevent the
EME sensor from the effect of external magnetic field. Furthermore, after mounting
the sensor on the cable, epoxy can be used to fill the gap between the cable and the
sensor to prevent possible damage and corrosion during the long service life.
(a) (b)
Fig. 2 Structure of EME sensor: (a) profile view, (b) top view
60 X. Hu et al.
4 Engineering Application
Experiment was conducted for various loads in the range from 300 kN to 12,000
kN under four different temperature. Calibration was carried out for each load level.
Five measurements were taken for each loading and the results were averaged.
After data processing, final magnetic parameter VEME was calculated. Figure 6
shows the calibration curves under four different temperature, which indicates the
monotonic increase of VEME with the external force. Quadratic equations have been
obtained with correlation coefficient R = 0.999 by curve fitting from the results.
After calibration, verification of this EME sensor was carried out. The cable was
loaded at various levels from 2500 kN to 10000 kN at room temperature, near 26 °C.
During each loading level, measuring was conducted five times and the results were
averaged. All the verification data can be seen in Table 2. It is observed that the EME
sensor shows great accuarcy in measuremnts with the max error lesss than 2%.
The present EME sensors were installed in the Lupu Bridge, which is located in the
Huangpu River of Luwan District, the city center of Shanghai, China. This is the
mid-supported steel arch bridge built at soft soil, and the pile foundation cannot bear
horizontal forces from the arch. Therefore, 16 horizontal cables were arranged in the
main girder between the two sides of the main bridge to balance the horizontal thrust
of the arch (Fig. 7.a and b). A structural health monitoring (SHM) system was
operated after the bridge construction in order to ensure the bridge safety during its
service-life. Four EME sensors were mounted on different horizontal cables, labeled
with SSZ1301, SSZ1302, SSZ1303 and SSZ1304. Figure 7.c and d shows two
cables with EME sensors and the magnetic demodulator.
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Fig. 7 Layout of EME sensors in Lupu bridge: (a) arch bridge plan, (b) cross section of the girder
in A-A to display the location of 4 horizontal cables, (c) EME sensors, (d) magnetic demodulator
64 X. Hu et al.
5 Conclusion
An EME sensor is presented to realize the automated data collection and long-term
stress monitoring on large-diameter cables on a real bridge. Based on elasto-magnetic
and magneto-electric effect of ferromagnetic material, the EME sensor can provide
reliable data for SHM to ensure the safety of the bridge structure. This paper intro-
duces the structure, sensors, experimental verification, and engineering application.
The following conclusions are drawn:
(1) The EME monitoring system can achieve long-term, non-destructive stress
monitoring on large diameter cables and measure the total stress directly, rather
than relative value.
(2) With the help of the multi-channel acquisition instrument, the EME system can
monitor multiple cables simultaneously, improving the efficiency of in situ
monitoring greatly.
(3) Full-scale calibration under several temperature and the engineering application
of the Lupu Bridge prove that the measuring results of the stress monitoring
system based on EME sensors have relatively high measurement accuracy
(error is less than 1.8%) and have strong stability under different temperature,
reaching the engineering requirements successfully.
Acknowledgement This work was funded by the National Key R&D Program of China
(2018YFE0125400) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (U1709216).
References
1. Buschow KHJ, Deboer FR (2013) Physics of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials. Kluwer
Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York
2. Carlo C, Daniele Z, Ait LH (2018) Calibration of elasto-magnetic sensors on in-service
cable-stayed bridges for stress monitoring. Sensors 18(2):466
3. Dong S, Li JF, Viehland D (2003) Ultrahigh magnetic field sensitivity in laminates of
Terfenol-D and Pb(Mg1/3Nb2/3)O3-PbTiO3 crystals. Appl Phys Lett 83(11):2265–2267
4. Duan YF, Zhang R, Zhao Y et al (2012) Steel stress monitoring sensor based on
elasto-magnetic effect and using magneto-electric laminated composite. J Appl Phys 111
(7):07E516
5. Duan YF, Zhang R, Dong CZ et al (2016) Development of elasto-magneto-electric
(EME) sensor for in-service cable force monitoring. Int J Struct Stab Dyn 16(04):15
6. Franklin AD (1951) Ferromagnetism. J Franklin Inst 252(1):93
7. Jiles DC, Thoelke JB, Devine MK (1992) Numerical determination of hysteresis parameters
for the modeling of magnetic properties using the theory of ferromagnetic hysteresis. IEEE
Trans Magn 28(1):27–35
8. Kvasnica B, Fabo P (1996) Highly precise non-contact instrumentation for magnetic
measurement of mechanical stress in low-carbon steel wires. Meas Sci Technol 7(5):763–767
9. Weiss P (1907) Hypothesis of the molecular field and ferromagnetic properties. Phys 6
(4):661–690
Development of EME Sensors … 65
10. Wang GD, Wang ML, Zhao Y, et al (2005) Application of EM stress sensors in large steel
cables. Sensing issues in civil structural health monitoring
11. Wang YJ, Cheung KF, Or SW, Chan HLW (2008) PMN-PT single crystal and Terfenol-D
alloy magnetoelectric laminated composites for electromagnetic device applications. J Ceram
Soc Jpn 116(4):540–544
12. Zhang R, Duan YF, Or S et al (2014) Smart elasto-magneto-electric (EME) sensors for stress
monitoring of steel cables: design theory and experimental validation. Sensors 14(8):13644–
13660
Multiple Tuned Mass Dampers for Wind
Induced Vibration Control
of a Cable-Supported Roof
Abstract A multiple tuned mass damper (MTMD) system is presented for vibra-
tion control of a cable-supported roof structure of a large exhibition center.
The MTMD system consists of three TMD sub-systems, which are tuned to each of
three dominating vertical modes of the structure under wind excitation. Each TMD
sub-system is composed of multiple TMDs with small masses spread at multiple
locations with large response in the corresponding mode. Several key points in the
design of MTMD scheme are discussed including determinations of dominating
modes and damping ratios of TMDs as well as MTMD performance based on wind
vibration responses. This MTMD system is going to be installed on a real structure
in the near future.
1 Introduction
Cable-supported large span structures are widely employed for public buildings,
such as large stations, exhibition centers and gymnasiums. It is typical for large
span roof structures that mode shapes are usually intricate, rendering it a difficult
task to determine the dominating modes. Furthermore, because of the complex
spatial property of large span structures and frequency dependent characteristic of
The roof consists of a bi-directional cable system, three main steel trusses with main
cables in one direction, acting as the main-support system, and ten double-layer
cable trusses in another direction, acting as the sub-support system. Length of the
structure is 174 m, and the width is 135 m (Fig. 1). The three main trusses divide
the total length into four spans, with two middle spans of 54 m and two side spans
of 27 m. Wind pressure loads with a recurrence period of 50 years are simulated
using a CFD model (Fig. 2.a). Five load conditions are considered, with five wind
directions, 0°, 22.5°, 45°, 67.5°, and 90° (Fig. 2.b). The 10 min wind speed is
23.76 m/s.
Mode shapes and frequencies of four relevant modes are shown in Fig. 3. The 1st
mode is an asymmetric mode, while the others are symmetric modes. MTMD
system proposed in this paper consists of three MTMD sub-systems tuned to each
of the frequencies of three dominating symmetric vertical modes under wind
excitation. The influence of MTMD parameters on the modal damping and the
response of the main structure are discussed.
70 X. C. Wang et al.
where, ui;k is the displacement of the kth degree-of-freedom in the ith mode shape;
qi ðtÞ is the mode general coordinate of the ith mode; l is the number of modes
considered in the response analysis. In this paper, l is twenty.
Then the modal response of the ith mode of the kth degree-of-freedom can be
obtained as,
In this study, the modal contribution of the ith mode for the response of the kth
degree-of-freedom is defined with the standard deviation of the modal response
yi;k ðtÞ. Two nodes are considered in the response analysis: N1 with the maximum
vertical displacement in a middle span under wind excitation and N3 with the
maximum vertical displacement in a side span. N1 is the one third point in the
middle span. And N3 is the center in the side span. (Fig. 1.b)
Figure 4 shows the modal contributions at N1 and N3. The 8th mode shows great
modal contribution for both nodes. The 15th mode is the most significant mode for
the response of N3. The 10th mode shows significantly larger contributions for both
nodes than the others. Therefore, the 8th, the 15th, and the 10th mode are selected as
the three dominating modes. TMDs are placed in the areas with large displacements
in the mode shapes of those three dominating modes as shown in Fig. 5.
(a) Modal contribution for responses of N3 (b) Modal contribution for responses of N1
A MTMD sub-system for the 15th mode is discussed in this section. The fre-
quencies of TMDs are designed slightly different from each other around the central
frequency (0.85 Hz) of the sub-system. The frequency bandwidth introduced will
enhance the robustness of the MTMD system against uncertainties and changes in
the dynamic properties of the roof structure. Eight TMDs are placed at two side
spans (Fig. 5). Mass of each TMD is assumed to be 400 kg. Frequency bandwidth
of TMDs is taken as 0:05 Hz (6% of the central frequency). Damping ratios of
TMDs are assumed to be equal with each other.
Eight additional modes appear around the initial 15th mode due to 8 TMDs added.
Figure 6 shows the modal damping ratios of the 9 modes (the initial 15th mode plus
8 additional modes) for various damping ratios of TMDs. Modal damping ratios of
8 modes increase along with the increase of nT , while the modal damping ratio of 1
mode decreases after nT reaches 0.06. This result match the conclusion for a SDOF
main structure drawn by Masato et al. [5].
Wind vibration response analysis is carried on under the given condition to
figure out the effect of damping ratios of TMDs nT on structural root-mean-square
(RMS) vertical displacement responses (Fig. 7). N3 is selected for response
observation. The outcome shows that the structural response decreases along with
the increase of the damping ratio of TMDs.
72 X. C. Wang et al.
Given the damping ratio of TMDs (nT ¼ 20%), wind vibration analysis is per-
formed to figure out the effect of MTMD on modal contribution. As Table 1 shows,
modal contribution of the 15th mode is dramatically reduced after installation of
MTMD, with a reduction rate up to 68%.
Multiple Tuned Mass Dampers for Wind Induced Vibration Control … 73
Table 1 Modal contribution for the vertical displacement response of N3 under wind direction of
90°
Modes 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Before (m) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.07 0.01 0.02
After (m) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.07 0.01 0.02
Modes 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Before (m) 0.00 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.25 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.00
After (m) 0.00 0.02 0.02 0.00 0.08 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.01
Moreover, it has been found that the MTMD sub-system for a certain mode (the
15th mode) has little influence on the modal contribution of other modes. This result
makes the MTMD design task easier, so that the MTMD sub-systems for domi-
nating modes may be designed separately for each mode.
Table 3 RMS responses of the roof before and after installation of MTMD system
Wind N1 N2 N3
directions Before After Reduction Before After Reduction Before After Reduction
(m) (m) rate (%) (m) (m) rate (%) (m) (m) rate (%)
0° 0.19 0.07 62 0.17 0.08 51 0.25 0.07 72
22.5° 0.13 0.08 40 0.13 0.09 27 0.14 0.06 59
45° 0.33 0.10 69 0.32 0.12 63 0.23 0.06 75
67.5° 0.12 0.07 39 0.13 0.09 32 0.18 0.06 68
90° 0.14 0.08 40 0.12 0.09 27 0.26 0.08 70
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements This research work was supported by the National Key R&D Program of
China (2018YFE0125400, 2017YFC0806100) and the National Natural Science Foundation of
China (U1709216, 51578419, 51522811, 51478429, and 90915008).
Multiple Tuned Mass Dampers for Wind Induced Vibration Control … 75
References
1. Zhou XY, Lin YJ, Gu M (2015) Optimization design of MTMD for large span roof structures.
J Vib Eng 28(2):277–284
2. Tubino F, Piccardo G (2015) Tuned mass damper optimization for the mitigation of
human-induced vibrations of pedestrian bridges. Meccanica 50(3):1–16
3. Yang F, Sedaghati R, Esmailzadeh E (2014) Optimal design of distributed tuned mass dampers
for passive vibration control of structures. Struct Control Health Monit 22(2):221–236
4. Chen X, Li AQ, Zhang ZQ, Zhou GD, Cao LL (2017) Optimization design of MTMD for
vibration comfort control of long-span roof structure. J Vib Eng 30(5):827–836
5. Abé M, Fujino Y (2010) Dynamic characterization of multiple tuned mass dampers and some
design formulas. Earthq Eng Struct Dyn 23(8):813–835
6. Tang BJ, Li YM (2007) Vibration control of large span structures with MTMD under seismic
excitation. Spec Struct 24(1):64–67
Cable Damage Identification
of Tied-Arch Bridge Using
Convolutional Neural Network
Abstract In the field of structural health monitoring, damage detection has been
commonly carried out based on the modal properties and the engineering features
related to the model. However, modal properties real-world structures are often
affected by numerous uncertain factors, and the extracted features are also subjected
to various errors, which makes the pattern recognition for damage detection still
challenging. In this article, a damage detection method using the convolutional
neural network (CNN) is presented for automated operation using raw measurement
data without complex procedure for feature extraction. A CNN is a kind of deep
neural network which typically consists of convolution, pooling, and
fully-connected layers. A numerical simulation study was carried out for damage
detection in cable hangers of a tied-arch bridge using ambient wind vibration data.
Fourier amplitude spectra (FAS) of acceleration responses at cable anchorage points
on the bridge deck are arranged as a matrix, which is used as the input to the CNN.
Numerical results show that the current CNN using FAS data can detect both
damage’ locations and extent accurately. Robustness of the present CNN has been
proven under various observational noise levels and wind speeds.
Keywords Multiple damage identification of hangers Convolutional neural
network Deep learning Fourier amplitude spectra Ambient wind vibration data
1 Introduction
Cables are major load carrying members of a cable supported bridge, which are
vulnerable to material degradation and structural damage due to severe environ-
mental and operational loads during their long life spans. The structural health
monitoring (SHM) system for a cable supported bridge generally includes sensors
on the cables as well as on the bridge deck. In order to detect the damages of the
cable supported bridge, numerous innovations have been proposed mainly from two
aspects: direct damage detection using innovative sensors or algorithms for locating
damages and indirect damage identification based on the changes of vibration
parameters of the structure.
With the rapid improvement of the computer’s hardware and software, machine
learning (ML) based researches for damage identification have made remarkable
progress. Early researches on the application of ML in SHM focused on the
algorithms such as neural network (NN), sparse coding, and autoencoder. Many
works on the ML algorithms for the SHM demonstrated their impressive ability of
feature extraction for the damage identification. Deep learning is a kind of ML
algorithm which typically consists of multiple layers of nonlinear processing units
for feature extraction and transformation [3]. As the state of the art algorithm in
computer vision tasks, a CNN generally includes convolution, pooling, and
fully-connected layers. Abdeljaber et al. [1] applied the CNN to damage identifi-
cation in a steel frame. Cha et al. [2] presented a CNN-based algorithm for crack
detection on a surface of concrete structure. Kim et al. [5] also proposed a
CNN-based methodology for identifying concrete cracks from crack-like noisy
patterns. Lin et al. [7] proposed a CNN to estimate the damage locations and
severities in a beam structure using acceleration time-history responses.
In this research, a numerical simulation study was carried out for multiple
damage identification in cable hangers using a CNN with ambient wind induced
vibration data. Acceleration responses were generated using the simulated random
wind forces on the bridge under the daily wind condition. Fourier amplitude spectra
(FAS) of the acceleration responses along the bridge deck were used as the input to
CNN because they contain both spatial and spectral information. The vector form
intrinsic finite-element (VFIFE) method [4, 9] was used to speed up the response
calculations in generating numerous samples for training the CNN. The CNN
analyses were carried out using TensorFlow machine learning framework. The
performance of the proposed CNN using FAS data was evaluated, and the
robustness were investigated under various levels of observational noise and wind
velocity.
Cable Damage Identification of Tied-Arch Bridge Using CNN 79
Typical daily wind forces are considered in this study. Only vertical acceleration
responses of the bridge are computed under the lift force, as the arch bridge is
simplified into a 2D model. The lift wind forces along the bridge deck and
arch are computed as [8] based on the equation 1.
1 2 uðx; tÞ H wðx; tÞ
FL ðx; tÞ ¼ qU B 2CL ðaÞvL þ ðCL0 ðaÞ þ CD ÞvL ð1Þ
2 U B U
where U denotes the mean horizontal wind speed; uðx; tÞ and w ðx; tÞ denotes the
simulated fluctuating wind velocity components in the lateral and vertical direc-
tions; H and B are the height and width of the girder (or arch); vL denotes aero-
dynamic admittances; CL , CD , and CL0 ðaÞ are the static wind coefficients; and a is
the attack angle of the wind.
For training sets, three cases of mean wind speed U are considered: 5, 8 and
10 m/s. For each mean wind speed, 50 sets of wind forces with different time
80 Q. Y. Chen et al.
During the training of CNN, the loss was calculated in terms of mean square error
(MSE) for 1450 sets of validation samples, and BP was conducted once in each
iteration. Testing was primarily carried out with another two data sets. Testing Set 1
included the newly generated wind forces but at the same mean wind speeds U used
in the training set. Testing Set 2 included wind forces at different wind speeds: 3, 7
and 15 m/s. The damage indices for the testing samples were also taken differently
from those for training examples as 0, 0.05, 0.15, 0.25, 0.35, and 0.45. For com-
parative evaluation of the current CNN, the damage conditions were classified into
3 damage states: minor, moderate, and severe. The maximum damage indices of
hangers for the minor damage were in the range 0–0.1, whereas ranges for moderate
and severe damage states were taken as 0.1–0.3 and 0.3–0.5, respectively.
The accuracy of the predicted damage indices is consistently excellent for var-
ious damage states. The results for Testing Sets 1 and 2 in Table 2 show that the
average relative prediction errors are less than 0.022, the standard deviations are
less than 0.025, if the observation noises are not considered. The above results
indicate excellent performance of the current CNN with FAS data for multiple
damage identification.
White Gaussian noises are introduced to the acceleration responses during the
numerical simulation. The signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) were taken as 20db and
14db, which are equivalent to the RMS levels of 10% and 20% respectively. The
procedures for generating the training, validation, and testing samples are the same
as those in the noise-free condition. The CNN architecture remains unchanged, and
it is also trained with 10,000 iterations. Example cases of the predicted damages
shown in Fig. 3 indicate that the damage locations and severities have been iden-
tified excellently under the observation noises of 10% at the RMS level. As listed in
Table 2, the average relative errors under 10% and 20% noises are less than 0.022
and 0.023, respectively. They are slightly larger than the errors without noises, but
still at an acceptable level for the purpose of damage identification and quantifi-
cation. The results indicate that noises do hinder the CNN learning process, and the
identification accuracy remains acceptable.
Fig. 3 Examples of predicted damage indices with 10% observation noise in RMS
Cable Damage Identification of Tied-Arch Bridge Using CNN 83
Table 2 Average relative errors in the predictions for 3 classes of damage states
Damage states Relative errors
Testing set 1 Testing set 2
= 5, 8, or 10 m/s)
(U = 3, 7, or 15 m/s)
(U
Without With With Without With With
noise 10% 20% noise 10% 20%
noise noise noise noise
Minor Ave 0.016 0.015 0.017 0.016 0.016 0.016
damage Max 0.069 0.040 0.074 0.072 0.060 0.068
SD 0.009 0.008 0.007 0.009 0.010 0.007
Moderate Ave 0.022 0.023 0.023 0.021 0.021 0.022
damage Max 0.092 0.092 0.091 0.093 0.091 0.089
SD 0.019 0.019 0.018 0.019 0.019 0.019
Severe Ave 0.022 0.021 0.021 0.024 0.025 0.024
damage Max 0.141 0.137 0.125 0.167 0.162 0.159
SD 0.022 0.021 0.020 0.032 0.033 0.032
Average errors 0.021 0.020 0.021 0.022 0.022 0.023
Average SD 0.019 0.018 0.018 0.025 0.026 0.025
Notes: Ave and Max indicate the average and maximum errors; SD indicates the standard
deviation; noise levels are the same in the training and testing cases; and training are using the FAS
= 5, 8, or 10 m/s
data at U
4 Conclusions
• The CNN performance is very robust against the observation noise. For samples
with 10% and 20% noises, average relative errors are less than 0.022 and 0.023
respectively, which are slightly larger but acceptable for damage localization
and quantification.
Acknowledgements This research work was supported by the National Key R&D Program of
China (2018YFE0125400, 2017YFC0806100), the National Natural Science Foundation of China
(U1709216, 51478419, 51522811, 51478429, and 90915008), and the Fundamental Research
Funds for the Central Universities (2015XZZX004-28).
References
Abstract Beams with I-shaped cross-sections have been widely used in steel
structures as major load-carrying members. The weld zone connecting the web plate
and flange plate in I-beam is vulnerable to fatigue cracks during the long service
life, which might result in a catastrophic failure. To realize quick scanning over a
long length of a structural member, ultrasonic waves based structural health
monitoring (SHM) is a promising approach. However, during the long-term mon-
itoring, guided wave signals are easily affected by various environmental factors,
such as temperature. In this paper, the principal component analysis (PCA) is
employed to eliminate the temperature effect and extract the damage information.
Lab-scale experiments were carried out on an I-beam under various ambient tem-
peratures. Reconstructed residual wave signals were obtained after the elimination
of those environmental effects. Q-statistics were used for damage detection, and the
time of flight (ToF) information was used for damage localization. Experimental
results show that inflicted small cut and mass scatterer attached on the weld zone
can be successfully detected. Damage severity can be evaluated based on the
magnitudes of Q-statistics and reconstructed residual signals. To further improve
the accuracy of damage localization, the independent component analysis
(ICA) was carried out to identify the wave packets reflected from the damage
location.
J. Q. Tu C. B. Yun (&) X. Xu
College of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China
e-mail: ycb@zju.edu.cn
J. Q. Tu
e-mail: tujiaqi@zju.edu.cn
X. Xu
e-mail: xianxu@zju.edu.cn
Z. F. Tang J. J. Wu
Institute of Advanced Digital Technologies and Instrumentation, Zhejiang University,
Hangzhou, China
e-mail: tangzhifeng@zju.edu.cn
J. J. Wu
e-mail: 11425023@zju.edu.cn
Keywords Guided waves Damage detection Damage location and severity
Temperature effect Principal component analysis Independent component
analysis
1 Introduction
I-shaped steel beams are commonly used in steel structures as major load carrying
elements. Cracks on the splicing or weld zone may cause significant stiffness
degradation and even failure of the structural member. Ultrasonic waves based SHM
system can be used to detect local damages and avoid fatal accidents. It has been
applied to inspect pipelines [1], cables [2], rails [3], and many other types of struc-
tures. Semi-analytical finite element (SAFE) method has been used to effectively
investigate the wave propagation characteristics in waveguides with irregular
cross-sections [4]. Temperature and other environmental effects on wave signals have
been studied for enhancing the robustness of this damage detection technology [5, 6].
In this paper, PCA-based temperature effect compensation is presented for
damage detection and localization. Lab-scale experiments were carried out on an
I-shaped steel beam. Two kinds of damages were considered including a mass
scatterer and an inflicted cut on the weld zone. A temperature chamber was used to
control the ambient temperature. Sensor locations and excitation frequency were
selected based on the SAFE analysis. The accuracy of damage detection and
localization are discussed under various temperature conditions. To improve the
damage localization, ICA was applied for identifying the wave packets reflected
from the damage location.
PCA is a statistical method to convert a set of general correlated variables into a set
of linearly uncorrelated variables by an orthogonal transformation. In SHM, it has
been widely used for the dimensionality reduction, removal of environmental
effects, and outlier detection on the measured vibration signals [7]. A brief trans-
formation expression is T ¼ XP, where Xðn mÞ is the original data matrix
constructed by the measured wave signals, n is the number of the measurement
cases, and m is the number of time points
in each measurement. By the eigenvalue
analysis of the covariance matrix CX CX ¼ XT X=ðn 1Þ , the principal compo-
nent matrix Pðm nÞ can be obtained as CX P ¼ PK. The eigenvectors pj ðm 1Þ in
P are called the principal components (PC) of the data matrix and usually sorted by
PCA-Based Temperature Effect Compensation … 87
the descending order of the eigenvalues. Then the score matrix T can be obtained
from X and P, where each column vector tj ðn 1Þ in T is the projection of the
original signals onto the direction of a PC pj ðm 1Þ. By choosing a reduced
number r of PCs as Pðm b r; r\nÞ, the original signals can be reconstructed as
b ðn mÞ ¼ T
X bPb , where T
T b ðn r Þ only contains scores corresponding to the first r
PCs. Residual signals between the original and reconstructed signals can be
obtained for the damage detection as X b ¼ X X. b
In this paper, guided wave signals obtained at the intact state under various
ambient temperatures are used to construct the baseline data matrix for PCA. By
checking the corresponding eigenvalue and scores of each PC, important envi-
ronmental factors like temperature can be discerned. After eliminating those
components from the new test signals, reconstructed residual signals ~xi (the i th test
signal) are obtained for further evaluation. The Q-statistic is introduced as Qi ¼
~xi~xTi to detect the damage as an outlier. The ToF information in ~xi is used for
estimating the damage location.
Table 1 Geometrical dimensions and physical parameters of the I-shape steel beam
Young Poisson’s Density Thickness Flange Web Weld
Modulus ratio width height size
206 GPa 0.28 7850 kg/m3 6 mm 120 mm 100 mm 5 mm
88 J. Q. Tu et al.
Fig. 2. Sensors
Fig. 4 Temperature effect: a intact signal at 14.7 °C; b intact signal at 15.1 °C; c residual signal;
d Cross-correlation between two intact cases at each time segment
PCA-Based Temperature Effect Compensation … 89
100 measurements at the intact state were used to construct a baseline data matrix
Xbase to build the PC model. Another 200 measurements at the intact state, 230 at
the cut damage state, and 100 at the mass-added state were used in the testing
phase. Pre-scaling of all wave signals was the first step before PCA to standardize
the data matrix [7]. Temperature variations are shown in Fig. 5. It shall be noted
that the obtained PC model is not affected by the order of the baseline signals with
different temperatures. Scores of the baseline signals and test signals corresponding
to the first PC are shown in Fig. 6. It can be found that the first PC is highly
correlated with the temperature variations. Q-statistics were then calculated after
eliminating the effect of the first PC. As can be observed, there are serious false
alarms for many intact cases. Thus scores corresponding to the following PCs with
relatively large eigenvalues were checked for their intrinsic meanings as in Figs. 7,
8 and 9. After the elimination of the first 4 PCs, the possibility of false alarm
decreases significantly, the inflicted cut and mass scatterer can be successfully
detected by observing big changes in Q-statistics as in Fig. 8(c). Hence, further
damage detection was carried out after eliminating the first 4 PCs in this study.
Fig. 6 Scores corresponding to the 1st PC: a baseline; b test signals; c Q-statistics after
eliminating the effect of the 1st PC
90 J. Q. Tu et al.
Fig. 7 Scores corresponding to the 2nd PC: a baseline; b test signals; c Q-statistics after
eliminating the effect of the first two PCs
Fig. 8 Scores corresponding to the 4th PC: a baseline; b test signals; c Q-statistics after
eliminating the effect of the first four PCs
Fig. 9 Scores corresponding to the 8th PC: a baseline; b test signals; c Q-statistics after
eliminating the effect of the first eight PCs
As can be observed in Figs. 10 and 11, there are a few other residual wave packets
with similar amplitudes appearing before the one related to the damage, which may
be caused by the uncertainty in sensors and bonding layers, and the measurement
noises that cannot be completely removed by the PCA. Those wave packets will
affect the accuracy of damage localization, particularly for small defects. To
improve the damage localization, independent component analysis (ICA) is applied
to identify the wave packets closely related to damages. Details of ICA can be
92 J. Q. Tu et al.
found in Dobson and Cawley [8]. The basic idea here is to use the higher order
statistics to further decompose the residual signals X e into independent components
(ICs). One or several ICs may contain information about damages, while the other
ICs related to noises can be disregarded for damage localization. The basic ICA
model assumes that the input data matrix X e ðn mÞ can be described as X e ¼ Ae S,
e
where each row in S ðl mÞ is a statistically independent source signal with m time
points. For the Fast-ICA [9] used in this study, the number of ICs l is no more than
the number of input signals n. Each row in the mixing matrix Aðn lÞ gives the
weight factor of each IC in one input wave signal. Each column in A therefore
records the amplitude of one IC across the input wave signals. By seeking out the
independent signals highly correlated with damages, other noises like random
sensor vibrations can be effectively excluded from damage localization. It shall be
noted that the damage existence has been already confirmed by the big change of
Q-statistics as in Fig. 8(c).
Here, residual signals for the baseline Xe base and each test residual signal ~xt were
i
assembled as the input data matrix X e i to obtain eS i and Ai .
2 3 2 base 3
~xbase a1;1 abase 2 3
7 ~si;1
1 1;l
6 . 7 6 . .. ..
6 .. 7 6 .. . . 76 .. 7
6 7¼6 74 . 5
4 ~xbase 5 4 abase base
an1;l 5
n1 n1;1
~si;l
~xti ati;1 ati;l
T
A standard step change vector V ssc [3] is defined as V ssc ¼ 01ðn1Þ 1 to
calculate its cross-correlation coefficients ri;l with each column vector ai;l in Ai
CovðV ssc ;ai;l Þ
(ri;l ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi). The weighting function ai;l represents the amplitudes of the
Var ½ai;l Var ½V ssc
l-th IC across the input data. ICs having high cross-correlation coefficients ri;l are
considered closely related to the damages.
100 baseline residual signals are used to construct X e base as set in Sect. 2.3. Every
residual signal at cut damage or mass-added state is processed by ICA for damage
localization. Two examples are shown in Figs. 13 and 14. The residual signal of the
cut damage case at 35.72 °C (Fig. 10(b) and Fig. 13(a)) was decomposed, and 43
ICs were obtained. The cross-correlation coefficient ri;l for each IC was shown in
Fig. 13(b). The first two independent signals having the highest cross-correlation
coefficients ri;l with V ssc are shown in Figs. 13(c-1) and (d-1). Their weighting
functions ai;l are shown in Figs. 13(c-2) and (d-2). The cross-correlation values
with V ssc are 0.63 and 0.62 respectively. It can be inferred that the wave packet near
PCA-Based Temperature Effect Compensation … 93
the acoustic distance (AD) of 1.0 m in Fig. 13(c-1) is the reflected waves from the
right end of the I-beam and could also be the second echo from the cut damage. On
the other hand, the wave packet near the AD of 0.5 m in Fig. 13(d-1) is the first
reflected waves from the cut position.
Similar results for a mass scatterer case at 13.67 °C are shown in Fig. 14. In
total, 44 ICs were obtained. The independent signal shown in Fig. 14(c-1) has the
highest cross-correlation coefficients with V ssc as 0.93. The wave packet near the
AD of 1.5 m could be the second echo from the mass scatterer. The wave packet
near the AD of 0.75 m in Fig. 14(d-1) can be identified as the first reflected waves
from the mass scatterer. The cross-correlation value with V ssc is 0.88. It can be seen
that the source signals (ICs) closely related to damages were identified more clearly
for damage localization by observing a step change in the weighting function of
each IC. The number of ICs obtained in different test cases is generally different, so
does the value of the highest cross-correlation coefficients ri;l . In real practice, the
reliable solution is to check the first several ICs with large wave amplitudes and
high ri;l for potential damage locations. As can be observed from the results of this
lab-scale test, the first or second IC having highest ri;l gives distinct information
about the damage locations.
4 Conclusions
A guided waves based damage detection method is presented for an I-shaped steel
beam. PCA is carried out for elimination of the prominent environmental effects
and extraction of the damage information. Principal component model is built by
the baseline wave signals at the undamaged condition. Damage detection are
achieved by calculating the Q-statistics of the residual signals after excluding the
first four PCs which represents the major environmental effects. ToF information in
the residual signals is used for damage localization. ICA is also used to identify the
wave packets reflected from the damage position. Experiments were conducted on
two damaged cases. Results show that the inflicted small cut and the attached mass
scatterer on the weld zone can be successfully detected. The detection accuracy of
the mass scatterer is found to be higher than the accuracy of the cut, because the
mass scatterer increases the cross-section area much more than the reduced area by
the inflicted cut. The damage severity can be evaluated by the magnitudes of the
Q-statistics and reconstructed residual signals.
Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the financial supports from the National Key
R&D Program of China (2017YFC0806100).
96 J. Q. Tu et al.
References
1. Mu J, Zhang L, Rose JL (2007) Defect circumferential sizing by using long range ultrasonic
guided wave focusing techniques in pipe. Nondestr Test Eval 22(4):239–253
2. Zhang P, Tang Z, Duan Y, Yun CB, Lv F (2018) Ultrasonic guided wave approach
incorporating SAFE for detecting wire breakage in bridge cable. Smart Struct Syst 22(4):481–
493
3. Wu J, Tang Z, Lv F, Yang K, Yun CB, Duan Y (2019) Ultrasonic guided wave-based switch
rail monitoring using independent component analysis. Meas Sci Technol 29(11):115102
4. Hayashi T, Song WJ, Rose JL (2003) Guided wave dispersion curves for a bar with an arbitrary
cross-section, a rod and rail example. Ultrasonics 41(3):175–183
5. Konstantinidis G, Wilcox PD, Drinkwater BW (2006) The temperature stability of guided
wave structural health monitoring systems. Smart Mater Struct 15(4):967–976
6. Lobkis O, Larsen C, Richard Roth II (2015) Separation of applied stress and temperature
effects on ultrasonic guided wave phase. AIP Conf Proc 1650:211–220
7. Mujica L, Rodellar J, Fernandez A, Guemes A (2011) Q-statistic and T2-statistic PCA-based
measures for damage assessment in structures. Struct Health Monit 10(5):539–553
8. Dobson J, Cawley P (2015) Independent component analysis for improved defect detection in
guided wave monitoring. Proc IEEE 104:1620–1631
9. Hyvarinen A, Oja E (2000) Independent component analysis: algorithms and applications.
Neural Netw 13(4):411–430
Scour Detection of Railway Bridges
by Microtremor Monitoring
Abstract This study is intended to discuss feasibility of scour detection for railway
bridges by means of remote microtremor monitoring. The impact test that applies
impact force to the bridge pier by dropping a hammer so as to measured vibrations
of the bridge pier is a laborious and time-consuming method, and has difficulties in
real time monitoring during flood. This study investigates feasibility of scour
detection from microtremor monitoring as an alternative method for the conven-
tional impact test. An in-service railway bridge has been being monitored utilizing a
sensing unit including functions of vibration measurement, data processing and
remote control. Bayesian modal analysis was adopted as a system identification
method. Identified frequencies from the microtremor data before and after a flood
event showed that target frequency was slightly decreased under increase of water
surface during flood. The decreased frequency recovered once water surface level
decreased. Scour assessment showed an extremely low probability of scour of the
target bridge.
1 Introduction
The number of bridges with scoured piers is increasing due to the deterioration,
heavy rain, and the reduction of sediment supply volume [4]. If scouring occurs
around the foundation ground, the substructure may settle, incline, or fall, and thus,
train operation should be suspended during flood. Many Japanese railway com-
panies have adopted an impact test on the railway bridge pier as a promising scour
detection method focusing on changes in frequencies. However, the impact test is a
laborious and time-consuming method, and is inapplicable for the real time mon-
itoring during heavy rains to make a proper decision on the train operation.
Therefore, a remote scour monitoring system is required.
How can we identify the frequency of the pier during flood is a challenge for the
remote scour monitoring. Usually the amplitude of vibration during the flood is too
weak to extract useful information about the structural frequency as train operation
is suspended during flood and enough excitation is not expected. For the system
identification from the microtremor, it needs higher performance system identifi-
cation approach and statistical approach as weak signals are easily affected by
noisy. Another challenge is the remote sensing system with high durability, which
will be coped with development of high durable sensing system and introducing an
edge computing concept to the sensing system which can reduce transferring data
volume.
This study aims to propose a way to monitor scour of piers of railway bridges
efficiently and quantitatively without approaching the target bridge especially
during flood. A bridge under operation is monitored as a case study. To estimate the
natural frequency of the target bridge, accelerometers are installed on the top of the
bridge pier and the connected girders for the impact test, and two sensors on the pier
top were left for scour monitoring in terms of long-term ambient vibration moni-
toring. For a higher performance system identification which even provides sta-
tistical information, Bayesian operational modal analysis (BAYOMA) [1] is
adopted for the modal identification from microtremor measurement during flood.
Scour Detection of Railway Bridges by Microtremor Monitoring 99
2 Methodology
The BAYOMA is well known method and has already been reported (e.g. [1, 3, 8]),
and this paper only briefly introduces the basic concept of the BAYOMA. Assume
that the acceleration
n o was collected under ambient condition. Let
€x^j 2 R : j ¼ 1; . . .; N denote the measured acceleration data at n degrees of
n
n o
freedom (DOFs) of a structure, abbreviated as ^ €
xj , where N is the number of
samples collected in the time domain. The jth acceleration response can be mod-
elled as follows:
where €xj 2 Rn denotes the model acceleration response; ej 2 Rn denotes the pre-
diction error between the measured and theoretical responses, mainly consisting of
the electronic noise of the data acquisition system, environmental noise and mod-
elling error. n o
The FFT of €x^j is defined as follows:
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffi N
X
^k ¼ 2Dt
F ^€xj exp 2pi ðj 1Þðk 1Þ ðk ¼ 1; 2; . . .N Þ ð2Þ
N j¼1 N
pðDjhÞpðhÞ
pðhjDÞ ¼ ð3Þ
pðDÞ
where pðDjhÞ denotes the likelihood function; pðDÞ is a constant; pðhÞ denotes the
prior PDF. Assume uniform prior information, the posterior PDF is directly pro-
portional to the likelihood function as follow:
b k , is given
in which, detð:Þ denotes the determinant; Ck , the covariance matrix of Z
by
1 U ReHk ImHk UT Se
Ck ¼ þ I2n ð6Þ
2 U ImHk ReHk UT 2
1 h
i1
Hk ði; jÞ ¼ Sij 1 b2ik þ ið2fi bik Þ 1 b2jk i 2fj bjk ð7Þ
where bik ¼ fi =f k ; Sij denotes the cross spectral density between the i th and j th
modal excitation; fi 2 R denotes the i th natural frequency in the frequency band;
fi 2 R denotes the i th damping ratio in the frequency band. It is more convenient to
write the likelihood function in term of the ‘log-likelihood function’ for the purpose
of optimization, i.e.,
The target bridge is a single railway track steel plate girder bridge. The height of
target pier is 11 m and width is 2.5 m. As there is high potential risk of scouring on
the target pier, a long-term scour monitoring has been carried out. The photo of the
target bridge pier and a picture of the remote sensing system adopted in the scour
monitoring are shown in Fig. 1. The elevation and plan views of the target bridge
are shown in Fig. 2. Eight triaxial sensors were installed on the top of the pier and
connecting girders for the impact test as shown in Fig. 2a. All sensors except two
sensors installed upstream and downstream of the pier top were removed after the
impact test. Two sensors on the pier top (see Fig. 2b) are left for the long-term
ambient vibration monitoring. The sampling frequency of the measurement was
200 Hz. A laser water level meter is also installed on the target bridge.
Modal characteristics of the bridge pier were first identified from the vibration data
excited during the impact test. Stochastic subspace identification (SSI) [7] was
utilized to identify modal parameters for the impact test. Stabilization diagram
(SD) is adopted to decide stable vibration modes.
Figure 3 shows the stabilization diagram (SD) in which the horizontal and
vertical axes respectively stand for the frequency and model order. The black dots
indicate modal frequencies associated with each model orders. The red circles
indicate stably estimated modes that satisfy predefined deviation tolerances of the
modal properties, i.e. the natural frequencies, damping ratio, and mode shapes. This
study adopted the frequency deviation tolerance of 0.25 Hz, the damping deviation
tolerance of 0.1%, and the lower bound of Modal Assurance Criteria (MAC) of
0.95.
The vertical blue broken lines show dominant modes that appear stably throughout
a wide range of model order and satisfy the deviation tolerances. The dominant
Fig. 2 Elevation view and plan view of the acceleration sensor installation position: a for the
impact test, and b for the long-term ambient vibration monitoring
frequency was identified at 9.2 Hz. Figure 4 shows the mode shape of the dominant
mode of which mode shape is relevant to the transversal rocking mode of the pier.
Scour Detection of Railway Bridges by Microtremor Monitoring 103
a) b)
c)
axis indicates time, and the vertical axis indicates frequency (Hz), wind speed (m/s),
and water level (m) from the top respectively. From 0:00 to 20:00 on September 30
before flood, identified frequencies varied widely between 8.5 and 10 Hz. However,
during flood from 20:00 on September 30 to 6:00 on October 1, variation in
frequency was quite small. One reason for scattering of identified frequency is the
quality of acceleration data as described in Sect. 4: before flood the amplitude of the
ambient vibration was around 0.1 gal, and during the flood the amplitude of the
vibration was around 1 gal.
Histograms of identified frequency for different water level are shown in Fig. 7.
Assuming all distributions follow normal distributions, the mean and variance
values are estimated as also seen in Fig. 7. The frequency decreases as the water
surface level rises (water level decreases), and the variance of the identified fre-
quency also decreases. The influence of the additional mass due to flood might be a
reason for the decrease of the frequency during flood [6]. The results show that the
natural frequency of the bridge pier is successfully identified with high accuracy
during the flood condition.
Water level Wind speed Frequency
(m) (m/s) (Hz)
a)
Water level Wind speed Frequency
(m) (m/s) (Hz)
b)
Fig. 6 Monitoring data: a 30th September 2018; and b 1st October 2018
Scour Detection of Railway Bridges by Microtremor Monitoring 105
Fig. 7 Identified frequency distribution: a water level more than 6 m (before flood); b water level
between 5 m and 6 m; and c water level between 4 m and 5 m (during flood)
Figure 8 shows that the histogram of identified frequencies during flood: i.e. the
water level between 4 and 5 m. The blue solid line is the approximate curve of the
distribution of the identified frequency. Occurrence of scour during flood is
examined following the guideline of Japanese government [5]. The guideline is
shown in the Table 1. The soundness index x is calculated by Eq. (9).
observed before flood was assumed as healthy condition in scour assessment. The
probability of exceeding the threshold was lower than 0.001%, which indicates
extremely low possibility of scour occurrence during this flood.
Figure 9 shows the distributions of the identified frequencies before and after the
flood. Considering mean values of the identified frequencies 9.23 and 9.19 Hz for
healthy condition and flood condition respectively, the soundness index takes
x = 0.996 according to Eq. (9), and categorized as B (Low possibility of abnormal
condition) according to Table 1. Observations showed low possibility of scouring
due to flood.
6 Conclusions
extremely low possibility of scour occurrence during this flood. This study also
demonstrated that it is possible to evaluate scour by using the ambient vibration
data during the flood.
References
1. Au SK (2011) Fast Bayesian FFT method for ambient modal identification with separated
modes. J Eng Mech ASCE 137(3):214–226
2. Au SK (2017) Operational modal analysis modeling, Bayesian inference, uncertainty laws.
Springer, Singapore
3. Au SK, Zhang FL, Ni YC (2013) Bayesian operational modal analysis: theory, computation
practice. Comput Struct 126:3–14
4. Keyaki T, Suzuki O (2013) Development of a new scour detector that enables monitoring of
pier soundness. JR EAST Technical Review-No. 27 Special edition paper. (in Japanese)
5. Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, Railway Bureau (2007) Railway
structures maintenance management standard and commentary (structural edition), pp 169–
170. (in Japanese)
6. Samizo M (2014) A study on the evaluation of stability of railway bridge piers during the
swelling of a river. PhD thesis, Kokushikan University, pp 126–135. (in Japanese)
7. van Overschee P, De Moor B (1993) Subspace algorithms for the stochastic identification
problem. Automatica 29(3):649–660
8. Yuen K-V (2010) Bayesian methods for structural dynamics and civil engineering. Wiley,
Hoboken
Vibration Monitoring of a Real Steel
Plate Girder Bridge Under Artificial
Local Damage and Varying
Temperature
Abstract This study is intended to investigate how the local damage and varying
temperature affect changes in modal frequencies of a steel plate girder bridge.
A damage experiment on a real bridge was conducted. Artificial cracks were
applied to the lower flange and web plate near base plate of shoe, which models
fatigue cracks observed in actual steel plate girder bridges. The longitudinal dis-
placement of the bridge at supports were also monitored to investigate structural
behaviors of supports under local damage and varying temperature. Observations
showed that frequency of the 1st bending mode increased due to artificial damage
even though frequencies of the 2nd bending mode and 3rd bending mode
decreased. For a finite element model, changes in stiffness of spring which models
the cantilever steel pivot bearings at support due to the damage as well as tem-
perature change are considered to examine the reason why the frequency of the 1st
bending mode increased while those of the 2nd and the 3rd bending modes
decreased. FE analysis demonstrated that the 1st bending mode was more sensitive
to changes in the boundary condition than changes in stiffness of girder. Seasonal
changes in longitudinal displacement of each support are also examined. In addi-
tion, FE analysis also showed that the boundary condition was changed by not only
the stiffness reduction of girder due to the damage but also thermal expansion due to
varying temperature.
1 Introduction
N
6750 6750 6750 6750 6750 6750
2810
2810 2810 2810 2810
Ab1 Ab2
D5,7 D6,9
T1 2
D1,8 D2,10
A1,6 A2,7 A3,8 A4,9 A5,10
upstream D3 D4
D1,5
A1 A2 T1 A3 A4 A5 D3 D4
D2,6
2600
D7,8 D9,10
A6 A7 T2 A8 A9 A10
downstream
40500
DMG1
DMG2
Stop hole
200
180
Ab1
Upstream
Damage Location DMG1 DMG2
In this study, the field experiment on an actual steel plate girder bridge is
conducted to detect damage by means of vibration-based SHM. In the previous
study on the same bridge [4] changes in frequencies due to fatigue cracks in steel
girder near the base plate of supports were clarified by means of stochastic subspace
identification (SSI) as a modal identification method. Observations showed that
frequency of the 1st bending mode increased due to artificial damage though fre-
quencies of the 2nd bending mode and the 3rd bending mode decreased. In general,
it has been reported that if damage occurs to the bridge frequency decreases as the
stiffness of the girder decreases. It demonstrates that the bridge must be affected by
other factors besides the stiffness reduction due to artificial damage.
This study investigates possible reasons for increasing frequency of the 1st
bending mode by means of FE model updating utilizing the data obtained from
static loading experiment. In addition, changes in the structural behavior associated
with each damage scenario are discussed using the displacement and temperature
obtained from the field experiment.
2 Field Experiment
Field experiment was conducted on an actual steel plate girder bridge shown in
Fig. 1, whose span length was 40 m long and width was 4.0 m wide. Figure 1 also
shows sensor deployment during the field experiment. Longitudinal displacements
at the both ends of the bridge were measured utilizing displacement sensors.
Artificial fatigue cracks (hereafter called artificial damage) at the girder end near the
base plate of supports are considered in the experiment by severing the lower flange
and the web plate by a cutting torch.
Sole plate
400
Abutment
Abutment
112 T. Hirooka et al.
The location of the artificial damage is on the main girder near the support of
upstream-side on Ab1 abutment as shown in Fig. 1. The artificial damage com-
prises two damage levels. One is the lower flange cut (hereafter called DMG1) and
the other is the web plate cut (hereafter called DMG2) as seen in Fig. 2. The bridge
condition before the artificial damage was assumed as the intact condition (hereafter
called INT). Types of supports at Ab1 and Ab2 are shown in Fig. 3; the Ab1
abutment adopted a line bearing, and the Ab2 abutment adopted a cantilever pivot
bearing. It should be noted that the line bearing at the Ab1 abutment was fixed due
to corrosion. The environmental condition during the field experiment is summa-
rized in Table 1. Temperatures measured from the thermocouples installed at the
center of the plate girder (Fig. 1) were 28, 38 and 43 °C during INT, DMG1 and
DMG2 experiments, respectively. The mechanical properties of the bridge were
also examined through static-loading test. The loading was given by a large sized
vehicle whose axle weight on front and rear axles were 21.66 and 54.88 kN,
respectively. In the loading test, the loading vehicle entered from Ab2 side, and
located the rear axle with 6750 mm intervals as shown in Fig. 1. The loading test
was operated two times for each scenario, and each of the displacement was also
measured twice. Hereinafter, the averaged displacement is used in discussions.
Observations from the previous study [4] showed that frequency of the 1st
bending mode increased due to artificial damage (3.15 Hz for INT, 3.25 Hz for
DMG1 and 3.28 Hz for DMG2) though frequencies of the 2nd bending mode
(9.54 Hz for INT, 9.24 Hz for DMG1 and 8.85 Hz for DMG2) and 3rd bending
mode (21.9 Hz for INT, 21.9 Hz for DMG1 and 21.6 Hz for DMG2) decreased.
3 FE Analysis
Ab2(Fixed)
West: Downstream
Specific gravities of steel and concrete were assumed as 7.85 and 2.40 respec-
tively. As previously mentioned the material properties were unknown because the
original design documents of this bridge are not available. Therefore, the material
test sample was collected and the material test was performed. The material test
showed that Young’s moduli of steel and reinforced concrete were 200 and
28.1 GPa, respectively, and Poisson’s ratios of steel and reinforced concrete were
0.27 and 0.20, respectively.
Stiffness of the longitudinal spring at Ab2 support which idealizes the cantilever
steel pivot bearing on Ab2 abutment was calibrated by means of the model update
utilizing the static longitudinal displacement at supports during each damage sce-
nario. The cross entropy (CE) method [3] was applied to update the bridge model so
that the displacement of the FE analysis is fit to the displacement monitored from the
actual bridge. The artificial damage was modelled as pseudo cracks in the FE model
to realize damage scenarios. This crack was created by removing the connection of
elements. The eigenvalue analysis was conducted for each of the damage scenarios.
For the FE analysis, the thermal expansion is evenly considered on each of the
elements in the FE model for each damage scenario considering temperature in
Table 1. The thermal conductivity of steel and reinforced concrete was assumed as
45 and 1:6 W=m K, respectively. Thermal expansion coefficient of steel and
reinforced concrete was assumed as 1:0 10 5 =K.
Table 3 Eigenvalue analysis results for model with identified spring and without the spring
(Relative error between the measured value of frequency and eigenvalue analysis results)
Spring INT DMG1 DMG2
1st bending mode Without 2.86 Hz (−9.2%) 2.86 Hz (−12.0%) 2.86 Hz (−13.3%)
With 3.19 Hz (1.3%) 3.29 Hz (0.9%) 3.29 Hz (−0.3%)
Measured 3.15 Hz (−) 3.25 Hz (–) 3.28 Hz (–)
2nd bending mode Without 9.63 Hz (1.2%) 9.58 Hz (3.6%) 9.43 Hz (6.7%)
With 9.68 Hz (1.8%) 9.66 Hz (4.5%) 9.57 Hz (8.4%)
Measured 9.54 Hz (−) 9.24 Hz (–) 8.85 Hz (–)
3rd bending mode Without 22.47 Hz (2.7%) 22.25 Hz (1.7%) 21.76 Hz (0.8%)
With 22.47 Hz (2.7%) 22.25 Hz (1.7%) 21.77 Hz (0.8%)
Measured 21.87 Hz (–) 21.87 Hz (–) 21.60 Hz (–)
Figure 5 shows that the support on Ab1 abutment allows little displacement, while
the support on Ab2 abutment allows longitudinal displacements of the bridge gir-
der. The downstream-side girder showed larger displacements than that of the
upstream-side. Focusing on damage scenarios, the relative displacement due to the
vehicular loading from the static deformation gets smaller when the damage
propagates. This observation will be discussed again in Sect. 4.2 to clarify why the
relative displacement gets smaller when the damage propagates.
Vibration Monitoring of a Real Steel Plate Girder Bridge … 115
In this section, to clarify why the relative displacement at Ab2 supports gets smaller
when damage propagates, stiffness of the longitudinal spring considered in the FE
model (Fig. 4) is estimated for each damage scenario. In addition, it is clarified how
changes of the boundary condition in the FE model affect frequency changes.
Table 2 shows estimated stiffness of the longitudinal spring for each damage sce-
nario. It is confirmed that stiffness of the longitudinal spring increases as damage
propagates. It means the supports of the target bridge has hardening behavior, and
as a result, the relative displacement at Ab2 supports gets smaller as damage
propagates.
For each frequency change, it is examined how the artificial damage and such
change of boundary condition affect each frequency change by means of eigenvalue
analysis utilizing the FE model. Table 3 shows eigenvalue analysis results for
model with identified spring and model without the spring. In addition, in paren-
theses, the relative error between the measured value of frequency and the result of
the eigenvalue analysis is shown. For the 1st bending mode, the eigenvalue analysis
results for the model without spring show that the stiffness reduction of the girder
due to artificial damage has little effect on changes in frequency. That’s why
frequency of each damage scenario doesn’t change despite of the stiffness reduction
of the girder. On the other hand, the eigenvalue analysis results for the model with
spring show that changes in boundary condition have a great effect on changes in
frequency because frequencies increase as stiffness of the longitudinal spring
increases.
For the 2nd bending mode and 3rd bending mode, the eigenvalue analysis results
for the model without spring show that the stiffness reduction of the girder due to
artificial damage has a great effect on changes in frequency because frequency of
each damage scenario decreases as the stiffness reduction of the girder due to
artificial damage. However, the eigenvalue analysis results for model with spring
show that changes in boundary condition have little effect on changes in frequency.
That’s why frequencies decrease though stiffness of the longitudinal spring
increases. In addition, the relative error in Table 3 shows that identification accu-
racy is improved for the 1st bending mode, deteriorated for the 2nd bending mode
and stayed for the 3rd bending mode, if changes in the boundary condition are
considered in the FE model.
D5 D6 D5 D6
(-0.99mm) (-1.01mm) (-1.01mm) (-1.06mm)
Upstream Upstream
Girder Girder
D1 D2 D1 D2
(-0.10mm) (-0.20mm) (-0.30mm) (-0.58mm)
Ab1 Ab2 Ab1 Ab2
D7 D9 D7 D9
(-0.97mm) (-0.99mm) (-0.90mm) (-0.99mm)
Downstream Downstream
Girder Girder
D8 D10 D8 D10
(-0.09mm) (-0.18mm) (-0.10mm) (-0.46mm)
a) From INT to DMG1 b) From DMG1 to DMG2
Fig. 8 Changes in structural behavior due to thermal expansion and artificial damage
bridge. One reason might be elongation due to temperature change during the
experiment which will be discussed in Sect. 4.4. For the elongation of the lower
flange of the downstream girder on Ab2 abutment under the DMG2, it might be
caused by torsional behaviour of the bridge under the severe damage (DMG2).
As discussed in Sect. 4.3, those structural behaviours of the bridge in the longi-
tudinal direction under propagation of damage might be caused by thermal
expansion due to the temperature change. There were non-negligible temperature
changes between INT scenario and DMG1 scenario as well as between DMG1
scenario and DMG2 scenario as summarized in Table 1. From 29th December in
2017 to 5th January in 2018, displacement data and temperature were obtained from
D2 sensor and T1 sensor, respectively. The displacement showed about 2.5 mm
changes in the longitudinal direction by changing 5 °C as shown in Fig. 7 where
the red line in Fig. 7 indicates the linear regression line between temperature
change and longitudinal displacement.
In order to investigate the thermal expansion of the bridge, an FE analysis is
conducted. In this analysis, temperature changes were 10 °C from INT to DMG1
and 5 °C from DMG1 to DMG2, and artificial damage for each damage scenario
was also considered. Deflections of the bridge from FE analysis are shown in
Fig. 8, which shows elongation at the upper flange as observed from the field
experiment. It is noted that the analytical deflection shapes under the different
temperature changes and damage scenarios showed same configuration with those
shown in Fig. 6. This result demonstrated that the thermal expansion affects the
118 T. Hirooka et al.
structural behaviour of the bridge. In addition, the shape after thermal expansion is
similar to the end girder shape in Fig. 6a, which demonstrates that thermal
expansion due to temperature change has more effect on the structural behaviour at
supports than the artificial damage during DMG1 experiment. However, under the
DMG2 scenario the FE model failed to simulate actual structural behaviours shown
in Fig. 6b.
5 Conclusions
This study investigates possible reasons for increasing frequency of the 1st bending
mode by means of FE model updating utilizing the data obtained from static
loading experiment. In addition, changes in the structural behavior associated with
each damage scenario are discussed using the displacement and temperature
obtained from the field experiment.
The eigenvalue analysis utilizing the calibrated FE model showed that the 1st
bending mode was strongly influenced by stiffness hardening effect in the can-
tilevered pivot bearing rather than changes in stiffness of the girder. On the other
hand, the other modes were strongly influenced by changes in the stiffness of the
girder rather than influence of stiffness hardening effect in the cantilevered pivot
bearing.
The FE analysis adopting spring element as the cantilever pivot bearing and
considering thermal expansion showed that one of the main reasons of the stiffness
hardening effect in the cantilevered pivot bearing is thermal expansion due to
temperature change during damage experiments. However, it was unsuccessful to
simulate the static behaviour under the most severe damage scenario (DMG2) that
might be caused by torsional behaviour.
The next step for this study is to clarify the static behaviour under the most
severe damage scenario (DMG2).
References
Abstract This study presents an approach to detect loosening bolts in steel bridges
by image processing. High-tensioned bolts have been adopted to connect members
of steel bridges. Insufficient axial tension of bolts by bolt-loosening leads to bolt
joint failure and reducing load carrying capacity of steel bridges. There are also
possibilities of accidents of pedestrian and cars under the steel bridge due to falling
bolts. Existing approaches for detecting loosening bolts are based on visual
inspection with hammer impact test, which limit their abilities to cost-effectively
detect loosened bolts in a large number of steel joints. A challenge in detecting
loosening bolts is to develop a labour- and cost-effective method. This study
focuses on a motion magnification to detect slight changes in vibrations of bolt head
due to bolt-loosening, particularly in the case of delayed fracture of bolts.
A laboratory experiment utilizing a high-speed camera demonstrated feasibility of
detecting bolt-loosening by the motion magnification.
Keywords Bolt-loosening Image processing Motion magnification Steel
bridge Structural health monitoring
A. Long
Department of Civil Engineering, The University of Sydney, Sydney 2006, Australia
e-mail: alon0121@uni.sydney.edu.au
C. W. Kim (&) Y. Kondo
Department of Civil and Earth Resources Engineering, Kyoto University,
Kyoto 615-8540, Japan
e-mail: kim.chulwoo.5u@kyoto-u.ac.jp
Y. Kondo
e-mail: kondou.yousuke.64e@st.kyoto-u.ac.jp
1 Introduction
2 Method
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1 Experimental setup of: a steel plate test, b model bridge test front-view and side-view
122 A. Long et al.
To test the feasibility of the cameras used for motion magnification in this study, a
simple experiment was formulated using a steel plate. Dimensions of the bar are
provided in Fig. 2. Four bolts were passed through holes in the bar and tightened
using a torque wrench. The beam was secured using clamps as shown in Fig. 1(a).
Using an impact hammer, the beam was excited three consecutive times on the top
edge of the bar. Subsequent vibrations were recorded by video. 4K camera video
was recorded at 480 fps. The high-speed camera was intended to be recorded at
1000 fps, but due to a technical error, ended up being recorded at 30 fps. The
experiment was repeated for a total of 4 cases with different degrees of bolt loos-
ening. Table 1 summarises the experimental scenarios used.
A similar experiment to the steel plate test was performed on a model bridge. In this
second experiment, a smaller steel plate with dimensions pictured in Fig. 3(a) was
attached to a model bridge which is shown in Fig. 3(b) and (c). The natural fre-
quency of the bridge was 3.64 Hz. A model vehicle pictured in Fig. 4(a) was
programmed to run over the model bridge at a speed of 30 km/h, causing excitation
Detecting Loosening Bolts of Highway Bridges … 123
of the steel plate. Subsequent vibrations were recorded with high speed camera and
4K camera. The high-speed camera recorded video at 1000 fps while the 4K
camera recorded video at 480 fps.
As with the steel plate test, the robot vehicle was used to excite the beam in
order to produce vibrations. Bolts were loosened to varying degrees per scenario.
The experiment was repeated for a total of four cases. Table 2 summarises the
experimental scenarios used.
(a)
(b) (c)
Fig. 3 a Dimensions of steel bar for model bridge test (units in cm), b Side view of model bridge
and dimensions, c Cross-section view and dimensions
(a) (b)
Table 3 Values for amplification factor (a), spatial frequency cutoff (kl ), frequency bands
minimum (xl ) and maximum (xh ) cutoffs and sampling rate (fs ) used to produce the steel plate test
output videos
Video a kl xl (Hz) xh (Hz) fs
Steel plate 4K camera (Case 0) 120 5 199.4 199.6 7000
Steel plate high-speed (Case 0) 100 5 96.0 97.0 5000
Bridge 4K camera (Case 4) 120 5 96.0 100.0 10000
Bridge high-speed (Case 4) 120 5 96.0 100.0 10000
The pre-existing Eulerian video magnification algorithm [5] was applied to the
input videos. For a selection of videos, where motion magnification was success-
fully observed, the chosen amplification factor, frequency band values are sum-
marized in the results section. The source videos were then input into a
custom-written code in MATLAB which converted the videos into a series of
images, which were then used to measure the amount of vertical displacement of the
loosened bolts. Screenshots of these frames are provided in the results section.
3.1 Results
To evaluate the feasibility of the motion magnification for detecting loosened bolts,
we experimented using several different cases, where bolts had been tightened to
varying degrees of tightness, as outlined in Tables 1 and 2. Motion magnification
was applied to each of the input videos, and we were able to successfully observe
magnification of bolt vibrations in the following cases: steel plate 4K (Case 0); steel
plate high-speed (Case 0); bridge 4K (Case 4); bridge high-speed (Case 4). The
parameters used to produce the output videos are outlined in Table 3.
By experimenting with different values for the above parameters, it was
observed that: a larger a produced greater motion magnification as expected from
Eq. (1) but was often accompanied with substantially more noise; a lower xl and
Detecting Loosening Bolts of Highway Bridges … 125
xh worked better the less visible the bolt motion was—suitable for high speed
camera footage—whereas a slightly higher xl and xh worked best when there was
more visible noise and/or shaking of the camera—suitable for 4K camera footage.
Figure 5 shows selected frames of some videos where motion magnification suc-
cessfully revealed the small bolt motions.
For many cases a frequency bands of approximately 96.0–100.0 Hz was suitable
for isolating the bolt motion. The narrower the frequency band (i.e. the smaller the
difference between xl and xh Þ, the more accurately we were able to target the
motion of the loosened bolt. A broader frequency band often failed to isolate the
bolt movement, instead magnifying unnecessary noise such as camera shaking and/
or overall vibration of the steel plate/bridge itself.
(c) Pre-processing (high speed camera) (d) Post-processing (high speed camera)
Fig. 5 Comparison of frames pre- and post-processing of 4K and high-speed camera video
126 A. Long et al.
The aim of this study was to demonstrate the feasibility of Eulerian video magni-
fication as a method for detecting loosened bolts in bridges. Bolts were loosened to
varying degrees as seen in Tables 1 and 2 in order to observe whether degree of
loosening had any visible effect on results after image processing was applied. From
the output videos it was observed that only bolts that were ‘‘completely loosened’’
displayed any visible movement after magnification. ‘‘Completely loosened’’ bolts
were those which were loosened to a degree of 0 Nm torque and could be freely
moved just by applying force with the fingers. It should be noted, however, that it is
not detectable just by a visual inspection even it is a completely loosened case as
can be seen in Fig. 5(a) and (c). These ‘‘completely loosened bolts’’ are unable to
support any axial load, and in real bridge applications, would theoretically behave
in the same way as a bolt that has yielded due to delayed fracture. We were
successful in amplifying the bolt motion visibly in these cases, as seen in Fig. 5.
On the other hand, bolts that retained even as little as even 10% of their yield
torque displayed no movement after Eulerian magnification was applied. While
several cases were tested with varying degrees of loosening using the torque
wrench: 47.3 to 473 N m for the steel plate experiment and 9.55 to 38.2 N m for
the bridge experiment, none yielded successful results. Hence it was concluded that
this method could be applied to detecting only bolts that had been loosened
completely for example as a result of delayed fracture.
It is important to note that Eulerian video magnification was originally used to
amplify small motions in videos with minimal ‘noise’ [5]. Our input videos
included a relatively large amount of noise compared to what Wu et al. experienced
in their videos, since in this study the target motion for amplification (bolt vibration)
was often dwarfed by motion of other, unrelated regions (vibration of entire steel
plate of bridge). We observed that in the model bridge experiment, some videos
taken by the 4K camera (480 fps) did not have a high enough frame rate and during
processing it was difficult to isolate the loosened bolt vibrations from camera noise.
We were able to avoid this problem with the high-speed camera footage, as seen in
the Bridge high speed (Case 4) example; the higher frame rate seemed to make the
output less sensitive to noise hence the magnified bolt vibration was more obvious.
Other factors such as camera angle and distance may have been of influence—in
the bridge experiment the high-speed camera was positioned directly in front of the
target specimen, while the 4K camera was slightly to the side in order to allow for
both cameras to film simultaneously. It was observed that the best results occurred
when the (high speed) camera was placed directly in front of the target, in the
closest proximity possible (due to physical constraints this was 70 cm for our
experiments) and set to a frame rate of 1000 fps.
For real life applications, it is unlikely that an actual bridge would vibrate as
much as our experimental models did, hence sensitivity to noise may not be as
much of a problem.
Detecting Loosening Bolts of Highway Bridges … 127
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements We would like to thank Gen Hayashi for his helpful feedback and
comments.
References
Abstract Periodic structures consist of a large number of repeated units, which are
joined together in an identical manner to form the whole system. It has been
revealed in the literature that periodic structures have a variety of interesting
dynamic properties including the well-known vibration band-gap phenomenon. To
our best knowledge, most of research works related to periodic structures to date
focus on the structural vibration control and optimization design by employing such
unique dynamical characteristics of periodic structures, however, there are very few
studies been carried out for the damage diagnosis with respect to this special type of
structural system. By utilizing the measured modal parameters, this paper reports a
probabilistic methodology for detecting bolt loosening on a periodically supported
beam-type structural system, which intends to represent typical pipeline structures
endowed with bolted flange joints in industry. Firstly, the entire periodic structural
system is modeled by using the spectral element (SE) method combined with the
transfer matrix approach. Then, a model-based damage detection approach is pre-
sented to identify the statistic characteristics of uncertain parameters with the most
plausible class of models selected with suitable complexity of model parameteri-
zation. The validity and efficiency of the proposed methodology is verified through
numerical case studies conducted for characterizing the connection status in a
pipeline model.
Keywords Periodic structure Bolt loosening detection Particle filter Bayesian
approach
T. Yin (&)
School of Civil Engineering, Wuhan University, Wuhan 430072, People’s Republic of China
e-mail: tyin@whu.edu.cn
H. P. Zhu
School of Civil Engineering and Mechanics, Huazhong University of Science
and Technology, Wuhan 430074, People’s Republic of China
e-mail: hpzhu@mail.hust.edu.cn
1 Introduction
Periodic structures containing a large number of repeated units which are joined
together in an identical manner to form the entire structure have obtained extensive
applications in various engineering fields, such as pipelines, rail-sleeper system,
multi-span bridges, etc. The periodic structures share some commonalities in dynamic
properties. They behave like mechanical band-pass filters, responding and radiating
noise very efficiently in certain frequency bands while not so efficiently in other
bands. Completely identical periodic units, however, do not exist in reality because of
small irregularities or disorder induced by manufacturing defects and possible
damages, the presence of which may lead to the phenomenon of vibration localization
and may alter their dynamic characteristics. At present, researches mainly focus on
investigating the vibration localization of periodic structures [2, 3, 6], but damage
detection of this special type of structures by utilizing the dynamic measurement is
rarely considered [8, 11, 14].
One of the simplest models for pipelines [9, 13], consisting of identical and
uniform finite-length beams connected to adjoining ones by couplers at junctions,
can be regarded to be periodic. For assessing the connection status of the pipeline
joints following model-based approaches, one must first model the jointed con-
nection properly. In recent decades, there are amount of researches for analyzing the
mechanical fasteners and interface discontinuity through the finite element
(FE) method [5, 7]. However, the conventional FE method has obvious disad-
vantages in terms of computational efficiency and accuracy especially for the
pipeline with a large number of joints. By utilizing the spectral element
(SE) approach, the authors recently develops an analytical model of the periodically
supported pipeline endowed with bolted-flange joints for linear dynamic analysis of
the entire periodic system [8]. In addition, with the transfer matrix method further
employed, the computational cost for dynamic analysis of the entire periodic system
can be dramatically reduced regardless of the number of identical units, which is
extremely attractive for periodic system containing a huge amount of such units.
Furthermore, a probabilistic methodology, combining the Bayesian theorem and the
particle filter-based approach, is also proposed for detecting joint loosening effi-
ciently with modal parameters based on the developed SE model of periodic
pipeline.
2 Theoretical Development
( ½ j
) ( ½ j
)
½ j UR;n ½ j UL;n
YR;n ¼ ½ j ¼ T½nj YL;n ¼ T½nj ½ j ð1Þ
FR;n FL;n
½ j ½ j ½ j
where NP denotes the number of cells in the periodic system. (UL;n , FL;n , YL;n ) and
½ j ½ j ½ j
(UR;n , FR;n , YR;n ) are the generalized displacement, force and state vectors on the
left and right ends of the jth cell, respectively. The transformation matrix T½nj relates
the state vectors at both ends of the jth cell. In addition, the continuity and com-
patibility conditions at the jth interface require continuity of U and F at the right end
of the jth cell and left end of the ðj þ 1Þth one, i.e.,
½ j I 0 ½ j þ 1 ½ j þ 1
YR;n ¼ Nm YL;n ¼ KYL;n ð2Þ
0 INm
YL;n
½ j þ 1 ½ j Y½ j
¼T ð3Þ
n L;n
½ j
¼ K1 T½ j is the transfer matrix from the left end of the jth cell to the left
where T n n
end of the ðj þ 1Þth one. Accordingly, the relationship between the state vectors at
the left end of the first cell and the left end of the last one can be given by
NY
P 1
½N
YL;nP ¼ ½ j Y½1
T ð4Þ
n L;n
j¼1
Thus, the state vectors at the beginning and the end of entire periodic structural
system can be further related by combining Eqs. (1) and (4) as
NY
P 1
½N ½N
YR;nP ¼ T½nNP YL;nP ¼ Cn YL;n ¼ T½nNP
½1 ½ j Y½1
T ð5Þ
n L;n
j¼1
where Cn represents the system transfer matrix of whole periodic structure, from
which the dynamic stiffness matrix of the entire periodic system can be obtained by
132 T. Yin and H. P. Zhu
relating the generalized displacement and force vectors at both ends of the entire
periodic system. In addition, if the forces applied to the two boundaries of the
periodic system are provided, the generalized displacements at both boundaries
½1 ½N
(i.e., YL;n and YR;nP ) for any specified frequency xn can be firstly derived from
Eq. (5), and then the state vectors at two supports of an arbitrary cell can be
obtained by further using Eq. (3) as
Y
k 1 Y
k1
½k
YL;n ¼ ½ j Y½1 ; Y½k ¼ T½k
T ½ j Y½1
T ð6Þ
n L;n R;n n n L;n
j¼1 j¼1
The proposed detection methodology involves two phases [8]. The first phase is
intended to select the most plausible class of models representing the system out of
NM prescribed classes of models by utilizing the experimental data D, including Nr
sets of measured natural frequencies and mode shapes of the first Nm modes. The
Bayesian model class selection method [1, 10, 12] is adopted to select the optimal
model class for detecting bolt loosening of the periodic system, and the probability
of model class Mj conditional on the data is given by the Bayes’ theorem as
X NM
p Mj jD ¼ p DjMj p Mj = p DjMj p Mj ð7Þ
j¼1
ðk Þ
where hl is the state vector of the dynamical system at time k, and DðkÞ is the
measurement vector at time k. f ðÞ and gðÞ are the prescribed state transition and
An Efficient Approach for Detecting Bolt Loosening … 133
measurement functions, respectively. uðkÞ and vðkÞ are the independent identically
distributed random noises
n in the systemoand measurement processes accordingly.
ð0:k Þ ð0Þ ð1Þ ðk Þ
Denoting hl ¼ hl ; hl ; . . .; hl and Dð1:kÞ ¼ Dð1Þ ; Dð2Þ ; . . .; DðkÞ as the
sequence up to time k of state vectors and measurements,
respectively, from a
ðk Þ ð1:kÞ
Bayesian perspective, the posterior PDF p hl jD ; Ml can be obtained by
ðk Þ
recursively calculating some degree of belief in the state hl at time k, given the
data Dð1:kÞ up to time k. It is assumed that the initial condition of the state vector is
available, and the posterior PDF can be obtained through the following two suc-
cessive stages.
ðk1Þ
In the first stage, providing the PDF p hl jDð1:k1Þ ; Ml at time k 1, the prior
PDF of the state at time k is obtained via the Chapman–Kolmogorov equation as
Z
ðk Þ ðkÞ ðk1Þ ðk1Þ ð1:k1Þ ðk1Þ
p hl jDð1:k1Þ ; Ml ¼ p hl jhl ; Ml p h l jD ; Ml dhl ð9Þ
where p hðkÞ jhðk1Þ ; Ml , denoting the probabilistic model of the state transition, is
defined by the state transition function and the known statistics of uðk1Þ in Eq. (8) as
Z
ðk Þ ðk1Þ ðk Þ ðk1Þ ðk1Þ ðk1Þ
p hl jhl ; Ml ¼ p hl jhl ;u ; Ml p uðk1Þ jhl ; Ml duðk1Þ ð10Þ
ðk Þ
In the latter stage, the posterior distribution of hl is obtained by using the
Bayes’ theorem to update the prior in Eq. (9) when a new measurement DðkÞ is
available at time k:
ðk Þ ðk Þ ðk Þ
p hl jDð1:kÞ ; Ml ¼ p DðkÞ jhl ; Ml p hl jDð1:k1Þ ; Ml =p DðkÞ jDð1:k1Þ ð11Þ
ðk Þ
where the conditional PDF p DðkÞ jhl ; Ml is defined through both the measure-
ment function and the known statistics of vðkÞ as
Z
ðk Þ ðk Þ ðk Þ
p DðkÞ jhl ; Ml ¼ p DðkÞ jhl ; vðkÞ ; Ml p vðkÞ jhl ; Ml dvðkÞ ð12Þ
It is noted that
the procedure
of exact Bayesian solution for calculating the
ðk Þ ð1:kÞ
posterior PDF p hl jD ; Ml has been summarized through Eqs. (8) to (12).
However, except for a few cases, the analytical evaluation of the complex
high-dimensional integrals involved in these formulas is extremely difficult. Thus,
the Monte Carlo simulation-based methods, such as the particle filter approach [4],
is especially suitable for such situation.
134 T. Yin and H. P. Zhu
3 Case Studies
Fig. 2 Ten-span periodically supported beam endowed with bolted flange joints
An Efficient Approach for Detecting Bolt Loosening … 135
that more parameters are needed to be involved to depict the distribution of con-
nection stiffness along the periodic system with the present of local damage. In
addition, it is noted that M2 is obviously much simpler than M4 , whereas the former
is not chosen as the most probable model class. This can be explained that, com-
pared with M4 , the first scaling parameter in M2 covers first five bolted joints,
which is ineffective to characterize the actual stiffness reduction occurred only in
the 2nd bolted connection. Thus, the likelihood factor of M2 tends to be significantly
smaller than that of M4 , even though the former possesses a relatively smaller
Ockham factor, making the probability of M4 to be larger. Moreover, comparing
M4 with M6 for Case 2, M6 obviously fits better to the data as more scaling
parameters are involved to decrease the discrepancy between the measured and
model-predicted modal parameters. As a results, the likelihood factor of M6 is
obviously found to be higher than M4 , but it also induces more severe penalty from
Ockham factor by the complexity of M6 . This makes M4 to be chosen as the most
plausible model class in this case. It should be noted that the probability of M6 is
indeed very close to that of M4 , implying the complicated model with a good
measure of fits is also very competitive sometimes. Thus, the proposed method-
ology provides an efficiency way to make a balance between the model complexity
and data-fit.
In the subsequent stage, the proposed methodology is intended to identify the
loose bolted connections for each damage case based on the most plausible class of
models identified in the previous stage. In this study, it is assumed that the prior of
particles follows uniform distribution, and there are 50 particles utilized for cal-
culation. The standard deviation of each element in the noise vector u is assumed to
be 1% of the range of prior values, and that of the noise vector v is set to be 5% of
the measured data. It is noted that the control parameters of particle filter approach
are kept to be unchanged for each class of models in order to ensure the consistency
for comparison. Due to the page limitation here, only the identified results for Case
2 are shown in Fig. 3 for demonstration purpose. Only three representative classes
of models are employed for illustration in this figure, including the identified most
probable model class, the model classes with the simplest and most complicated
parameterization schemes.
a b c
Fig. 3 History of iterative simultaneous estimation by the particle filter-based approach for Case 2
in the numerical study: a M1 , b M4 , c M6
An Efficient Approach for Detecting Bolt Loosening … 137
It is clear from Fig. 3 that the identified scaling parameters will eventually
converge to some constant values after a few iterative steps. Also, model class with
few parameters like M1 and M2 can only provide very limited information about
the bolt loose. Specially, the simplest model class M1 may only be employed to
detect whether the pipeline model is damaged or not while M2 can only help to
further judge if the damaged joint is located within the left or right half of the entire
periodic system. In contrast, the model class with the maximum complexity of
model parameterization in this study (i.e., M6 ) can provide more specific infor-
mation related to the damaged bolted joint. However, for the most complex model
class M6 , there exists the widest parameter space with higher dimension, within
which maximum number of uncertain parameters needs to be determined, leading to
more iterative steps required to achieve convergence for giving the same algorithm
configuration.
Although not shown in this paper due to page limitation, the posterior mean
value and standard deviation of identified uncertain scaling parameters for all model
classes with respect to both damage cases are calculated, and interested readers are
referred to Yin et al. [8]. It is clearly found a common phenomenon that the
identified scaling parameters of the most plausible model class have a relatively
smaller standard deviation value as compared to other model classes within the
same case. This implies that the connection status of joint groups can be efficiently
quantified with less uncertainty on the base of the selected optimal model class by
utilizing the proposed methodology for detecting the loosening of bolted connec-
tions, and the validity of the proposed methodology is thus fully demonstrated.
4 Conclusions
This paper reports an efficient probabilistic methodology for detecting bolt loos-
ening in a periodically supported beam-type structural system. In the first phase of
presented methodology, the dynamic model of entire periodic system endowed with
bolted connections is developed by combining the spectral element method and the
transfer matrix approach. In the second phase, a two-staged methodology is pro-
posed to first identify the most probable class of models selected with suitable
parameterization complexity for data fitting by using Bayesian model class selec-
tion approach, and then the statistic properties of uncertain scaling parameters on
the base of the optimal model class are obtained by utilizing the particle filter-based
approach. In the latter part of this paper, the validity of the proposed methodology
is verified through the numerical case studies of a periodically supported beam
structure, which is intended to represent the typical pipeline in the industry. The
obtained results clearly demonstrate the computational efficiency and accuracy of
the proposed methodology, which can efficiently model the entire periodic system
with bolted connections and correctly identify the uncertain scaling parameters with
corresponding uncertainties for characterizing the connection status of bolted joints.
138 T. Yin and H. P. Zhu
Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support provided by the
National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grants No. 51778506, 51838006).
References
1. Beck JL, Yuen KV (2004) Model selection using response measurement: a Bayesian
probabilistic approach. J Eng Mech ASCE 130(2):192–203
2. Ding L, Zhu HP, Luo H, Yin T (2016) Flexural wave propagation and localization in periodic
jointed tunnels subjected to moving loads. J Vib Control 22(11):2788–2804
3. Ding L, Zhu HP, Yin T (2013) Wave propagation in a periodic elastic-piezoelectric
axial-bending coupled beam. J Sound Vib 332(24):6377–6388
4. Gordon NJ, Salmond DJ, Smith AFM (1993) Novel approach to nonlinear/non-Gaussian
Bayesian state estimation. IEE Proc. F Radar Sig. Process. 140(2):107–113
5. Mackerle J (2003) Finite element analysis of fastening and joining: a bibliography (1990–
2002). Int J Press Vessels Pip 80(4):253–271
6. Mead DJ (1975) Wave propagation and natural modes in periodic systems: I. Mono-coupled
systems. J Sound Vib 40(1):1–18
7. Yin T, Lam HF (2013) Dynamic analysis of finite-length circular cylindrical shells with a
circumferential surface crack. J Eng Mech ASCE 139(10):1419–1434
8. Yin T, Wang XY, Zhu HP (2019) A probabilistic approach for the detection of bolt loosening
in periodically supported structures endowed with bolted flange joints. Mech Syst Signal
Process 128:588–616
9. Yin T, Yuen KV, Lam HF, Zhu HP (2017) Entropy-based optimal sensor placement for
model identification of periodic structures endowed with bolted joints. Comput Aided Civ
Infrast Eng 32(12):1007–1024
10. Yin T, Zhu HP (2019) An efficient algorithm for architecture design of Bayesian neural
network in structural model updating. Comput Aided Civ Infrast Eng. https://doi.org/10.1111/
mice.12492
11. Yin T, Zhu HP, Fu SJ (2019) Damage identification of periodically-supported structures
following the Bayesian probabilistic approach. Int J Struct Stab Dyn 19(1):1940011
12. Yin T, Zhu HP, Fu SJ (2019) Model selection for dynamic reduction-based structural health
monitoring following the Bayesian evidence approach. Mech Syst Signal Process 127:306–
327
13. Watanabe Y, Sugimoto N (2005) Flexural wave propagation in a spatially periodic structure
of articulated beams. Wave Motion 42(2):155–167
14. Zhu H, Wu M (2002) The characteristic receptance method for damage detection in large
mono-coupled periodic structures. J Sound Vib 251(2):241–259
Damage Detection Based on Bayes
Factor Using Ambient Vibration Data
Abstract This paper presents the work on developing a frequency domain method
for damage detection using ambient vibration data. Bayesian factor is used to
construct a new damage detection indicator utilizing the concept of Fast
Bayesian FFT (Fast Fourier Transform) method. Based on Bayes factor and the
properties of FFT data, the prior probability density function (PDF) and the like-
lihood function in the indicator can be constructed according to Gaussian distri-
bution. The most probable value (MPV) of modal parameters mainly including
natural frequency, damping ratio and mode shape, and the corresponding covari-
ance matrix, which can be determined by the Fast Bayesian FFT method, were also
used for the development of damage indicator. The uncertainty of modal parameters
can be taken into account in the damage detection. A simply supported bridge with
10 elements was simulated to illustrate the proposed method by generating data in
different damage cases. The damage location and degree can be identified by
instrumenting the sensors in different locations.
F. L. Zhang
School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology,
Shenzhen, China
e-mail: cezhangfengliang@163.com
F. L. Zhang C. W. Kim (&) Y. Goi
Department of Civil and Earth Resources Engineering, Kyoto University,
Kyoto 615-8540, Japan
e-mail: kim.chulwoo.5u@kyoto-u.ac.jp
Y. Goi
e-mail: goi.yoshinao.2r@kyoto-u.ac.jp
1 Introduction
Structural health monitoring (SHM) is attracting more and more attention with the
increasing of the large-scale buildings, bridges, etc. Furthermore, with the age
increasing, some structures collapse suddenly, which also sounds the alarm for the
structures owners to pay close attention to the structural safety. In the field of SHM,
damage detection is an important tool to make full use of the collected data by the
modern sensors to find the existing problems of a tested structure. It has three main
steps, i.e., to detect whether the damage appears, where the damage is and what the
damage extents are. Focused on these objectives, many methods have been
developed. Vibration based method is one of commonly used methods with the
development of ambient vibration tests, which makes the data collection more
convenient and economical. Fast Bayesian FFT method was recently developed to
analyze the ambient vibration data and determine the most probable values of
modal parameters including natural frequency, damping ratio and mode shape, and
the associated posterior uncertainty [1, 2]. It is becoming popular since the theory of
the method is very strict while the usage of the method is quite convenient and
efficient. Damage indicator can be used to show the damage status of a measured
structure and some damage indicators in the time domain have been developed to
perform damage detection [3, 4]. Based on the theory of the Fast Bayesian FFT
method, a novel damage method was developed in this work. This method is a
frequency domain method, and the well-known Bayes factor was used to define the
damage indicator. The prior PDF and likelihood function can be determined fol-
lowing the Bayesian FFT method. Numerical examples were used to illustrate the
proposed method.
2 Methodology
The basic method is based on the Bayes factor [5], whose definition can be seen as
follow:
pðDjH1 Þ
B10 ¼ ð1Þ
pðDjH0 Þ
where pðDjH1 Þ and pðDjH0 Þ denotes the PDF of data D under two hypotheses H1
and H0 , respectively. Based on the Variants on Laplace’s Method, the general form
of the PDF can be given by
1=2
b
p DjHq ¼ ð2pÞnh C L p Djb
h q ; Hq p bh q jHq ð2Þ
Damage Detection Based on Bayes Factor … 141
where q ¼ 1 or 0; p Djb
h q ; Hq denotes the likelihood function; p bh q jHq denotes
where nb denotes the number of the frequency bands used in the damage detection;
Di denotes the data in the ith frequency band; hi denotes the modal parameters to
model the data in the ith frequency band; Cik denotes the covariance matrix of Z b ik ;
b ik denotes a vector containing the real and imaginary parts of the FFT data at
Z
frequency f k in the ith frequency band; ki1 and ki2 are indexes of the starting and end
frequencies in the ith frequency band.
The prior PDF p b h jH can be determined as:
q q
Ynb Ynb
1 1 b T 1 b
pð fhi gÞ ¼ pðhi Þ ¼ exp ðhi h i Þ Chi ðhi h i
i¼1 i¼1
ð2pÞn detðChi Þ0:5 2
ð4Þ
where Chi denotes the covariance matrix of the modal parameters hi with the MPV b
hi.
By this way, the damage indicator can be calculated accordingly. The possible
damage can be observed by comparing the change of damage indicator. For the
detail of the proposed method, please refer to Zhang et al. [7].
3 Illustrative Examples
-3
10
5 6 7
3 4
1 2
[m/s √Hz]
-4
10
-5
10
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Frequency [Hz]
5
x 10
6
50%
5 45%
40%
4 35%
30%
BDI
3 25%
20%
2 15%
10%
1 5%
0
1 2 3 4 5 6
Setup (Initial DOF)
Fig. 2 Bridge damage indicators (BDI) in different damage degrees and measured DOFs with the
3rd element damaged [7]
80.00 Hz, respectively; while the damping ratios are 0.9, 0.9,1.0, 1.0, 1.0, 1.0,
1.0%, respectively. They are all quite close to the exact values. The posterior COVs
(coefficients of variation) of the natural frequency are less than 1% while those of
damping ratios are from one to fifteen percent. The MAC values between the
identified and exact mode shapes are all larger than 0.99. In total, the identification
of the modal parameters is quite accurate.
The damage was simulated in different elements. It is assumed that in that
bridge, only four sensors were available. They work together and move along the
bridge to measure all the DOFs step by step. From the left to right side, six setups
are needed to finish the whole measurement. Figure 2 shows the indicators calcu-
lated by the proposed method by simulating damage at the third element. The
damage was simulated by reducing the stiffness in the damaged element. Different
lines denote different damage degree. The x-axial shows the setups from the left to
Damage Detection Based on Bayes Factor … 143
the right. In each setup, one damage indicator was calculated. It is seen that when
the sensor is far away from the damage element, the damage indicator tends to
decrease and the largest value appears in the Setup 3, where all the four sensors are
at the right side of the damage element. On the other hand, the damage indicator
value increase with the damage degree. The results for the damage element was
simulated in other elements are also calculated and similar phenomenon can be
observed. For the details, please refer to Zhang et al. [7].
4 Conclusions
This paper presents the work on developing a novel damage indicator based on
Bayes factor. It is a frequency domain indicator, where the likelihood function and
the prior PDF in the definition can be calculated by the theory of Bayesian FFT
method. The most probable values and the posterior uncertainty were identified
efficiently by the Fast Bayesian FFT method and they are used to calculate and
update the damage indicator. Fast Bayesian FFT method has been developed more
than 7 years and it has been proved that it is quite efficient. This study first makes
full use of the modal parameters and the associated posterior uncertainty determined
by the Fast Bayesian FFT method for the purpose of damage detection and some
reasonable results can also be obtained from the numerical examples. This method
is also applied into a real structure while the result will not be presented in this
work.
Acknowledgements This study is supported by the JSPS Fellowship (P17371) and National
Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No.: 51878484). The financial support is greatly
acknowledged.
References
Keywords Increment dynamic analysis Single degree of freedom system
Seismic fortification level Seismic performance evaluation Story drift ratio
1 Introduction
Since the original works by Bertero, the incremental dynamic analysis (IDA) has
been widely developed. Han and Chopra [2] combined the IDA and MPA to
propose a MIDA procedure. Moon et al. [6] developed the IDA procedure based on
the conventional MPA idea. Lucchini et al. [4] used IDA procedure to analysis
where up(t) is the structural displacement response vector and cp is the mode
participation coefficient corresponding to up ðtÞ.
The seismic design code specifies the peak ground acceleration (PGA) of minor
and large earthquakes corresponding to different seismic intensities, and the limiting
value of the story drift ratio [h] of structural elasticity and elastoplasticity in minor
and strong earthquakes. Hence, in simplified IDA, PGA can serve as the ground
motion intensity parameter IM, and the maximum inter-story drift angle hm as the
structural performance parameter DM.
The procedure of the simplified IDA method is as follows.
(1) Calculate the standardized first mode vector u and the mode participation
coefficient c of the structure.
(2) Conduct pushover analysis on the structure based on the pushover analysis
lateral force mode obtained according to Eq. (2), establish the capacity curve in
the form of roof displacement–base shear, and simplify the curve into a bilinear
form.
Seismic Evaluation of Structures … 147
P ¼ Mu1 ð2Þ
(3) Determine the restoring force model of the equivalent SDOF system with the
capacity curve of the bilinear form as the displacement—force monotonic
relationship of the equivalent SDOF system.
(4) Select a piece of ground motion record, adjust the amplitude of the PGA of the
ground motion from small to large, and then perform dynamic time-history
analysis on the equivalent SDOF system with excitation increasing stepwise to
obtain the maximum displacement qm corresponding to different PGAs, and
plot the IDA capacity curve of the equivalent SDOF system in the form of qm—
PGA.
(5) Calculate the maximum displacement urm at the roof of the structure corre-
sponding to different PGAs according to qm in the IDA capacity curve of the
equivalent SDOF system.
(6) Perform a pushover analysis on the structure again until the urm (obtained in
Step 5) corresponding to each PGA is pushed over, determine the plastic first
mode vector up , and substitute the vector into Eq. (1) to determine the dis-
placement vector up. Further determine the hm corresponding to each urm; that
is, hm corresponding to each PGA.
(7) Plot the IDA capacity curve of the structure in the form of hm—PGA.
Based on the seismic design code, the range of the maximum story drift ratio of a
multi-story R.C. structure under different seismic fortification levels is obtained, as
shown in Table 1. Parameters in this table are used to evaluate the structural seismic
capacity for different seismic fortification levels in this paper.
According to seismic code, the seismic fortification levels in Table 1 can be
expressed as: (1) Level I: No damage under minor earthquake. (2) Level II:
Repairable under medium earthquake. (3) Level III: No collapse under strong
earthquake. (4) Level IV: Near collapse or collapse.
The set values of PGA for different earthquake levels are listed in Table 2.
The selected ground motion records are as the excitation of equivalent SDOF
system, respectively, and the IDA capacity curves of the structure in the form of
hm—PGA are obtained by the simplified IDA method. According to the capacity
Table 1 Maximum story drift ratio hm for different seismic fortification levels
Seismic fortification level Level I Level II Level III Level IV
hm <1/550 1/550–2/275 2/275–1/50 >1/50
148 F. Wang et al.
Table 2 Peak ground acceleration (PGA, cm/s2) for different earthquake levels
Earthquake level Minor earthquake Medium earthquake Strong earthquake
Seismic 6 18 49 125
fortification intensity 7 35(55) 98(147) 220(310)
8 70(110) 196(294) 400(510)
9 140 392 620
curves, and referring to Tables 1 and 2, it is possible to assess whether the seismic
performance of the structure meets the requirements of the seismic fortification
level.
Three six-story structural models were designed for hard soil sites (I0, I1), inter-
mediate soil sites (II, III), and a soft soil site (IV), and designated as structures 1, 2
and, 3, respectively. The three structural models have a story height of 3.6 m and
uniform lateral shear stiffness along the story. The interstory damping uses the
Rayleigh damping with a damping ratio of 5%. The basic period is 0.61 s and the
fortification intensity is 7. Table 3 lists the story weight, mode of vibration, and
interstory shear strength of the three structural models.
The structural models of this calculation example can be simplified to a
multi-degree-of-freedom (MDOF) system. The ideal story hysteretic relationship of
these three MDOF systems is a bilinear stiffness model, the yield stiffness coeffi-
cient is 0.024, and the stiffness degradation coefficient is 0.4.
For the example analysis, 15 horizontal earthquake motion records for hard soil
sites (I0, I1), intermediate soil sites (II, III), and soft soil site (IV), corresponding to
B, C and D respectively for USGS, are selected and listed in Table 4.
5 Example Analysis
The capacity curves of the three structural models studied are obtained based on
traditional IDA and simplified IDA methods. Figure 1 shows a comparison of the
average IDA capacity curves plotted using the traditional IDA method and the
simplified IDA method. As shown in Fig. 1, for Structures 1 and 2, when
PGA < 0.8 g, the hm obtained by the simplified IDA method is relatively large,
while for Structure 3, when PGA < 0.6 g, the hm obtained by the simplified IDA
method is comparatively large. Since the PGA of strong earthquakes usually does
not exceed 0.6 g, it is generally safer to use the simplified IDA method.
Based on the established capacity curve, multi-levels seismic evaluation for
structures can be carried out, as shown in Fig. 2.
The seismic fortification intensity of the three models are all 7, corresponding to
minor, medium, and strong earthquakes, so the PGA is set to 0.036, 0.10, and
0.22 g, respectively. The three PGAs are substituted into the IDA capacity curves
obtained by the traditional and simplified methods, and the seismic performance of
each structural model is obtained according to the ranges of hm under different
seismic levels. The results are listed in Table 5.
The following can be seen from Table 5.
(1) The seismic performances of the example structures meet or excess the
requirements of the seismic fortification levels.
(2) Comparing the two methods, it is found that the evaluation results of the two
methods are basically the same except the structure 2.
(3) For the structure 2, the response obtained by the simplified IDA is higher than
the traditional IDA, which indicates that the seismic performance evaluation
results obtained by this method tend to be more conservative.
Seismic Evaluation of Structures … 151
PGA /g
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3 IDA
0.2
Simplified IDA
0.1
0
0 0.005 0.01 0.015 0.02 0.025 0.03
Maximum interstory drift ratio /rad.
(a) Structure 1
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
PGA /g
0.5
0.4
0.3 IDA
0.2 Simplified IDA
0.1
0
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05
Maximum interstory drift ratio /rad.
(b) Structure 2
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
PGA /g
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3 IDA
0.2
Simplified IDA
0.1
0
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05
Maximum interstory drift radio /rad.
(c) Structure 3
152 F. Wang et al.
PGA /g
0.4
Y1 310cm/s2
0.3 Y2
Y3
0.2 Y4 0.15g
Y5
0.1 55cm/s2
Mean
0
0 0.005 0.01 0.015 0.02 0.025
The maximum drift radio /rad.
(a) Structure 1
0.7
620cm/s2
0.6
510cm/s2
0.5
400cm/s2
PGA /g
0.4
310cm/s2
0.3
Z1
0.2 Z2
Z3 0.15g
0.1 Z4
55cm/s2
Mean
0
0.0018 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05
The maximum drift radio /rad.
(b) Structure 2
0.7
620cm/s2
0.6
510cm/s2
0.5
400cm/s2
PGA /g
0.4
R1 310cm/s2
0.3
R2
0.2 R3
R4 0.15g
0.1 R5
Mean 55cm/s2
0
0.0018 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05
The maximum drift radio /rad.
(c) Structure 3
Seismic Evaluation of Structures … 153
6 Conclusions
(1) A simplified IDA method combining the equivalent SDOF system and push-
over analysis is proposed. To verify the accuracy of the method, the IDA result
of a multi-story structure (MDOF system model) is set as the ‘exact solution’.
Comparing the capacity curve plotted using the simplified IDA method with the
‘exact solution’, it can be seen that the capacity curve in the form of hm—PGA
obtained by the simplified method deviates from the exact solution by a certain
amount, but the deviation is within a small range and the curve can be used
once the deviation is corrected.
(2) According to the relationship between the set anti-seismic level and the max-
imum story drift ratio, a seismic performance evaluation method of structures
based on simplified IDA is proposed. According to an analysis of examples,
this method is clearly defined and easy to operate, and the analysis results are
conservative.
Acknowledgements This research described in this paper was supported by the National Natural
Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51478091), the Liaoning Natural Science Foundation
(Grant No. 201602198), and the project of Dalian Minzu University.
References
1 Introduction
In recent years, with the widely use of new materials and constructions, as well as
better structural analysis and optimization approach, newly built structures, espe-
cially long-span public structures such as sports stadiums, gymnasiums, shopping
malls, music concerts, airport terminal corridors and different types of footbridges,
tend to become slender, lighter, with lower natural frequency and damping ratio.
Coherent crowd harmonic movements like people walking, jumping or bouncing
can produce resonant or near-resonant structural vibrations that are uncomfortable
and intolerable for some occupants (Ebrahimpour and Sack [4]). These kinds of
vibration serviceability problems can not only make people feel discomfort or
annoying, but can also cause crowd panic or large economic losses (Dallard et al.
[3]). For this reason, many criteria have proposed design and evaluation guides for
human induced loads and vibration serviceability, such as ISO2631, ISO 10137,
AISC design guide 11, and Hivoss (International Standard Organization [8, 9];
Murray and Allen [11]; Feldmann et al. [5]).
To suppress excessive structural vibration, many control methods have been
implemented successfully. Classified by energy consumption, there are passive
control, active control, semi active control and hybrid control (Housner et al. [7]).
The idea of passive structural control is energy absorption, so as to reduce dis-
placement in the structure (Teng et al. [13]). However, this kind of control provides
no extra assistance, and often lacks of flexibility. Taking tuned mass damper as an
example, it can only control the resonant or near resonant response effectively, and
may even cause negative effects when it’s off tuned. After Yao [16] introduced the
concept of structural active control, many control algorithms and devices have been
developed and performed well. However, requirements for sensor, actuator power
supply and regular maintenance make active control cost too much and not reliable
during huge disasters, thus not commonly used in practical structures. Facing the
shortcoming of passive and active control, semi active and hybrid control were
developed to reduce the negative effects and power consumption.
The vibration serviceability problem, which mainly judged by human subjective
feeling of perception, discomfort, annoyance or intolerability, is quite different in
different circumstance, person or body position (Griffin [6]) and usually described
by linguistic indexes, i.e. is actually a fuzzy concept. After fuzzy set theory was
firstly introduced by Zadeh [17] and successfully use of ‘IF-THEN’ rules on
automatic operating control of steam generator by Mamdani [10], fuzzy control
become a new approach for structural vibration control and is naturally suitable for
vibration serviceability problems.
In this paper, a fuzzy logic control method based on a vibration serviceability
criterion was proposed and compared to two other passive and active control
methods in MATLAB/Simulink simulation. The structure model to be controlled
was introduced in Sect. 2, control effects of tuned mass damper (TMD), direct
velocity feedback (DVF), and the proposed fuzzy logic controller (FLC) were
introduced and compared in Sect. 3 and Sect. 4, and conclusions were given in
Sect. 5.
2 Structure Model
The floor’s dynamic properties were measured by ambient vibration and impact
hammer test, results shown in following Table 1. As the natural frequency of higher
modes show little influence in practical walking, jumping and bouncing tests, the
floor was simplified as a single degree of freedom (SDOF) system in the simulation
work.
3 0.5
Acceleration[m/s ]
-2
2
Force[kN]
0
1
0 -0.5
0 1 2 3 4 5 0 10 20 30 40 50
Time[s] Time[s]
0.2
0.1
0
-0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.5
0 10 20 30 40 50
Time[s]
One of the most classic and commonly used passive vibration control approach is
attaching the tuned mass damper (TMD). During the past decades, dozens of
optimum TMD parameters for different circumstances have been raised (Warburton
[15], parameters based on sinusoidal excitation was chosen in this research, shown
in Eq. (1).
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
fTMD 1 3l
¼ fTMD ¼ ð1Þ
fStr 1þl 8ð1 þ l=2Þ
In which l is mass ratio between TMD moving mass and the structure to control,
fTMD and fStr are natural frequencies of the TMD and structure, fTMD is the damping
ratio of the TMD. Chose mass ratio as 2% (moving mass weight 600 kg), the
structural response under control was shown in following Fig. 3.
A Fuzzy Logic Vibration Control Method … 159
0.5
Without Control
0.4
-3
0.3 δ dead=1 ×10 m/s
Acceleration[m/s ]
-2 0.2 δ =1×10 -5m/s
dead
0.1 -6
0 δ dead=1 ×10 m/s
-0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.5
0 10 20 30 40 50
Time[s]
Since the concept of active vibration control was proposed in 1972, many control
methods have been proposed, such as H2 control, H∞ control, PID control, LQR/
LQG control, direct velocity/acceleration feedback control. Some of the control
methods only need the structural response, but some also require the specific
structural and controller properties. To make the comparison work clearer, an on-off
nonlinear feedback control law (NLDVF) was chosen for this research, shown in
Eq. (2) (Reynolds et al. [12]).
0 jy_ ðtÞj ddead
V0 ðtÞ ¼ ð2Þ
Vs signð_yðtÞÞ jy_ ðtÞj [ ddead
In which ddead is the dead zone level and Vs is the saturation voltage to the
actuator. In this research, an ideal actuator with maximum force of 450 N was
simulated for the control, structural response with different dead zone selection is
shown in Fig. 4.
The main advantage of the fuzzy logic controller (FLC) is its inherent robustness
and ability to handle any non-linear behaviour of the structure (Aldawod et al. [1]).
However, the membership functions of the controller are normally designed
empirically, highly rely on designer’s engineering experience. Thus, by combining
the fuzzy logic controller with vibration serviceability criteria, the FLC may
become more reasonable and meets the control target directly. In this research, the
Germany guideline VDI 2057 [14] was selected as the design guide for FLC
membership functions, shown in Table 2.
160 Z. P. Han and J. Chen
0.1
0
-0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.5
0 10 20 30 40 50
Time[s]
A Fuzzy Logic Vibration Control Method … 161
1s running RMS[m/s ]
-2
0.3 DVF
FLC
0.2
0.1
0
0 10 20 30 40 50
Time[s]
One second running root mean square (RMS) value of structural acceleration
response was chosen as the controller input, shown in Fig. 5. Structural response
under the FLC is shown in Fig. 6.
4 Comparison
5 Conclusions
In this research, a fuzzy logic active control method based on VDI 2057 guideline
was proposed and simulated comparing to several other control methods on a
SDOF long span floor model. Simulation results show that after the introduce of
fuzzy logic and vibration serviceability criterion, design of active controller is more
directly towards the control target, can save more energy and provide more
robustness.
Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge the financial support provided by
National Natural Science Foundation of China (51778465) and State Key Laboratory for Disaster
Reduction of Civil Engineering (SLDRCE14-B-16).
162 Z. P. Han and J. Chen
References
1. Aldawod M, Samali B, Naghdy F, Kwok KC (2001) Active control of along wind response of
tall building using a fuzzy controller. Eng Struct 23(11):1512–1522
2. Chen J, Zhang M, Liu W (2015) Vibration serviceability performance of an externally
prestressed concrete floor during daily use and under controlled human activities. J. Perform
Constructed Facil 30(2):04015007
3. Dallard P, Fitzpatrick T, Flint A, Low A, Smith RR, Willford M, Roche M (2001) London
millennium bridge: pedestrian-induced lateral vibration. J Bridge Eng 6(6):412–417
4. Ebrahimpour A, Sack RL (2005) A review of vibration serviceability criteria for floor
structures. Comput Struct 83(28–30):2488–2494
5. Feldmann M, Heinemeyer C, Lukic M (2010) Human-induced vibration of steel structures
(Hivoss). Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg
6. Griffin MJ (2012) Handbook of human vibration. Academic press, London
7. Housner GW, Bergman LA, Caughey TK, Chassiakos AG, Claus RO, Masri SF, Yao JT
(1997) Structural control: past, present, and future. J Eng Mech 123(9):897–971
8. International Standard Organization (1989) Evaluation of human exposure to whole body
vibration—Part 2: human exposure to continuous and shock-induced vibrations in buildings
(1 to 80 Hz). ISO 2631-2
9. International Standard Organization (2005) Bases for design of structures Serviceability of
buildings and pedestrian walkways against vibration, ISO/CD 10137. International
Standardization Organization, Geneva, Switzerland
10. Mamdani EH (1974) Application of fuzzy algorithms for control of simple dynamic plant. In:
Proceedings of the institution of electrical engineers, vol. 121, no. 12, pp. 1585-1588. IET
11. Murray TM, Allen DE (1997) Ungar EE. Floor vibrations due to human activity. Steel design
guide 11. American Institute of Steel Construction
12. Reynolds P, Díaz IM, Nyawako DS (2009) Vibration testing and active control of an office
floor. In: Proceedings of the 27th international modal analysis conference, Orlando, Florida,
USA
13. Teng TL, Peng CP, Chuang C (2000) A study on the application of fuzzy theory to structural
active control. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 189(2):439–448
14. Verein Deutscher Ingenieure (2002) VDI 2057 Human exposure to mechanical vibrations.
Whole-body vibration. Berling
15. Warburton GB (1982) Optimum absorber parameters for various combinations of response
and excitation parameters. Earthq Eng Struct Dyn 10(3):381–401
16. Yao JT (1972) Concept of structural control. J Struct Div 98(st 7):1567–1574
17. Zadeh LA (1965) Fuzzy sets. Inf Control 8(3):338–353
Damage Detection for Rotating Flexible
Beam Based on Time Domain Sensitivity
Analysis
Abstract The rotating beam structure has been used widely in many fields of
engineering. It is important to conduct damage detection in such structure in order
to maintain its safety and durability. In this paper, damage detection study is
investigated on a rotating flexible beam driven by the rigid hub. In doing so, the
equation of motion for in-plane vibration including axial and chordwise deforma-
tion is established at first. Then damage detection as an inverse problem is for-
mulated as a nonlinear least-squares optimization problem which is solved from the
time domain sensitivity analysis. Trust region constraint and the Tikhonov regu-
larization are called to enhance the convergence. A Numerical example is studied to
illustrate the feasibility and efficiency of the present approach.
Keywords Rotating flexible beam Time domain analysis Response sensitivity
Trust region Tikhonov regularization
1 Introduction
Rotating structural components, such as wind turbine blade and helicopter blade,
etc., are widely used in many engineering fields. To ensure the safety of the whole
structure, it is necessary to detect the damage in the serving life time. In many
literatures, such a rotating structure was modelled as rotating flexible beam, for
instance, Roy studied the damage detection of helicopter blade [12]. Two main
mathematical models are most used for rotating beam [5]. One model is established
under the Cartesian variables such as axial, chordwise (or lagwise) and flapwise
deformations [6, 13, 14]. While another is established under the non-Cartesian
deformation variables, i.e., the stretch (the extensional deformation along the curve
of a deformed beam), chordwise and flapwise deformations [1, 5, 15].
In each model, it can be divided into the linear model and nonlinear model for
taking account about the coriolis and centrifugal forces, nonlinear von Karman
strain, linearized stress or nonlinear stress. The equation can be established by the
kinetic, potential energies and virtual work done by external torque and force
through generalized Hamilton principle. After that it can be discretized by finite
element method, Galerkin method, Rayleigh-Ritz method, and so on. As the model
under the Cartesian variables are simple and used widely, it is chosen for vibration
analysis in this paper with considering the centrifugal stiffening effect. It is inter-
esting that the axial (stretch) and chordwise vibration are coupled in the in-plane
deformations, while the flapwise motion is only the out-of-plane deformation. As
the in-plane vibration is more attracting and common, it is discussed in this paper.
Regarding damage identification for rotating beams, the frequency-based,
model-based approaches are applied widely. Roy and Ganguli modelled the rotating
blade as rotating beam, and the damage is modelled as the reduction of the elasticity
modulus [12]. By applying indicator that the difference between the frequency of
the damaged and undamaged blade, the damage of rotating beam is identified.
Hoshyarmanesh and Abbasi found that the frequency shift of the impedance sig-
nature at antiresonance peaks appears compared to the corresponding baseline,
which can help to damage detection [3]. Similarly, the variation of a single natural
frequency was also developed to detect the crack location based on the assumed
mode method and Lagrange’s equations by Masoud and Al-Said [9]. Another
model parameter that operational mode were used to detect the damage of the blade
by Kidd and Pines with an eigenstructure assignment technique [4]. Using mea-
sured modal parameters, the experiments were conducted by Mironov et al. to
detect damage of rotating blades on helicopters [10].
As reviewed above, frequency domain methods have been widely applied to
damage identification in rotating structures. Time domain damage identification
method is rarely found in the literature. In this paper, an enhanced response sen-
sitivity method is extended to detect the damage in such rotating beam structures.
The measured acceleration responses of the beam are used in the identification. The
advantages of the method lie in, (1) only a few points of measurement are needed,
(2) it is insensitive to measurement noise, (3) it has well convergence with
Tikhonov regularization and trust-region constraint. The rest of the paper is orga-
nized as follows. The dynamic equation of rotating beam is established in Sect. 2.
In Sect. 3, the enhanced response sensitivity method with trust-region constraint is
introduced. Numerical example is carried out to elaborate the efficiency of such
method in Sect. 4 and final conclusions are drawn in Sect. 5.
As shown in Fig. 1, a flexible cantilever beam fixed to a rigid hub with radius a and
inertia Ih is studied. It is modelled as uniform Euler-Bernoulli beam with mass
density q, Young’s modulus E, length L, moment inertia I, cross-sectional area A.
Damage Detection for Rotating Flexible Beam … 165
Fig. 1 Configuration of a
rotating flexible cantilever
beam in-plane deformation
The reference frame XOY and the inertial frame X 0 O0 Y 0 have the flowing
relationship
eX cosa sina eX 0
¼ ð1Þ
eY sina cosa eY 0
where u and v are axial and chordwise deformation respectively. Form discussion
above, the velocity of P0 is:
In this paper the rigid body motion is driven by a torque produced by rigid hub,
e.g., the rotating speed is not known as a priori. Hence the kinetic energy of the
system is written as follows
L
T ¼ 12 qA R r_ T r_ dx þ 12 Ih a_ 2 ð5Þ
0
L 0
1 LR 002 LR
U ¼ 12 R EAu 2 dx þ 2 EIv dx þ Pðx; tÞðds dxÞ ð6Þ
0 0 0
166 D. Yang et al.
The last term of potential energy equation is the energy of the axial force arising
from centrifugal effects [14],
L
Pðx; tÞ ¼ R qAa_ 2 ða þ nÞdn ¼ 12 qAa_ 2 ðL2 x2 Þ þ qAa_ 2 aðL xÞ ð7Þ
x
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
ds dx ¼ ðdxÞ2 þ ðv0 dxÞ2 dx 12 dxðv0 Þ2 ð8Þ
dW ¼ M ðtÞda ð9Þ
t2
ðdT dU þ dWÞdt ¼ 0
R
ð10Þ
t1
0
2 0
ð12Þ
½Ih þ Ib þ fvgT Kv1 Kı2 fvg€a þ 2½f_vgT Kv1 Kv2 fvga_ þ ½Cv f€vg ¼ M
ð16Þ
Damage Detection for Rotating Flexible Beam … 167
Zl Zl
½mv ¼ qA½N Tv ½N v dx; ½k v1 ¼ qA½N Tv ½N v dx ð17Þ
0 0
l h 0 h 0
½kv2 ¼ R qA aðL Li xÞ þ 12 ðL þ Li þ xÞðL Li xÞ NvT Nv dx ð18Þ
0
l l
½cv ¼ R qAða þ Li þ xÞ½Nv dx; Ib ¼ qA R ða þ Li þ xÞ2 dx ð19Þ
0 0
½kv ¼ R EI½N00T 00
l
v ½Nv dx ð20Þ
0
fvgT ¼ ½ v1 h1 v2 h2 ð22Þ
It is clear that the dynamic equation is coupled. Because driven by rigid hub, it is
easier to obtain the dynamic vibration of rotating flexible beam for damage
detection without any desired rotating speed profile.
The structure with damage can be simulated as the reduction of local stiffness, e.g. a
reduction in Young’s modulus E of an element [12]. If there is a damage in the ith
element, only the elemental stiffness matrix ½kiv will change
P
Ne
½kivd ¼ bi ½k iv ; ½Kvd ¼ ½kivd ð23Þ
i¼1
The response sensitivity with respect to the parameter bi can be deduced by the
derivation of bi on both sides of Eq. (15), (16). It is expressed in the following.
@ f€vg @€a
@ a_
½ M v þ ½CTv þ 2ð½Kv1 þ Kv2 fvg
@bi @bi @bi
ð24Þ
@ fv g
@ fv g
þ ½Kv þ a_ 2 ð½Kv1 þ Kv2 ¼ ½k iv fvg
@bi @bi
@ f€vg
@€ a
@ a_
½C v þ ½Ih þ Ib þ fvgT ð Kv1 Kı2 fvg þ 2f_vgT Kv1 Kv2 fvg
@bi @bi @bi
T
@ fv_ g
@ fv g
@ fv g
þ 2a_ fvg Kv1 Kv2 _ vg ð½Kv1 Kv2
þ 2af_ T
þ 2€ T
afvg ð½Kv1 Kı2 ¼0
@bi @bi @bi
ð25Þ
The coupling Eqs. (15), (16) and the sensitivity Eqs. (24), (25) can be reshaped
by vector x ¼ ½a; vT and then solved by Runge-Kutta method.
Set the measured responses as R ¼ d ðt1 Þ; d ðt2 Þ; . . .; d ðtn Þ and the calculated
response of the structure from equations of motion (15), (16) as
Rðb Þ ¼ ½d ðb; t1 Þ; d ðb; t2 Þ; . . .d ðb; tn Þ. Hence, the damage detection can be formu-
lated as a general way that to find parameter bi 2 ½01 so that the objective function
Eq. (26) is minimized.
gðbÞ ¼ fR RgT ½W R R ð26Þ
where kk denotes the usual L2 norm of vectors and SðbÞ is sensitivity matrix
obtained from Eqs. (24) and (25)
Damage Detection for Rotating Flexible Beam … 169
0 1
@xðb;t1 Þ @xðb;t1 Þ @xðb;t1 Þ
B @x@b 1 @b2 @bm
C
B ðb;t2 Þ @xðb;t2 Þ
@xðb;t2 Þ C
B @b1 @b2 @bm C
SðbÞ ¼ rp RðbÞ := B .. .. .. .. C ð28Þ
B C
@ . . . . A
@xðb;tL Þ @xðb;tL Þ @xðb;tL Þ
@b1 @b2 @bm
The problem (27) may be ill-posed and therefore Tikhonov regularization is chosen
to get the update.
dbk ¼ arg min k dRðbÞ SðbÞdb k2 þ k k db k2
dp
1 ð29Þ
¼ S ðbÞSðbÞ þ kI
T
ST ðbÞdRðbÞ
gðbÞ gðdb þ bÞ
qðdb; bÞ ¼
gð0; bÞ gðdb; bÞ
ð30Þ
k dRðbÞ k2 k dRðb þ dbÞ k2
¼ qcr 2 ½0:25; 0:75
k dRðbÞ k2 k dRðbÞ SðbÞdb k2
4 Numerical Simulation
The rotating flexible beam studied by Yang et al. [13] is examined. It was dis-
cretized into 11 elements with mass density q ¼ 2700 kg=m3 , Young’s modulus
E ¼ 71 109 N=m2 , length L ¼ 1:10 m, moment inertia I ¼ 8:33 1012 m4 ,
cross-sectional area A ¼ 104 m2 . The rigid hub with radius a ¼ 0:1 m and inertia
Ih ¼ 3:84 kg=m2 : The fundamental natural frequency of non-rotating beam is
0.6742 Hz.
The dynamic response of the rotating beam is discussed. The external torque is
assumed to be MðtÞ ¼ 10 Nm, and the rotating speed profiles is obtained from
Eqs. (15), (16) as shown in Fig. 2. When the torque is fixed, the rotating speed is
Damage Detection for Rotating Flexible Beam … 171
increasing linearly approximately. The tip velocity of the beam is shown in Fig. 3
which agree well with the result from Kim and Chung [5]. It is noteworthy that the
tip vibration is found attempting to be stable even that the rotating speed is still
increasing.
The acceleration responses at the 4th, 7th and 12th node is used in the identification.
The sampling rate is 1000 Hz with a duration of 2 s. The external torque is MðtÞ ¼
10 sinð10ptÞNm: Measurement data is obtained through numerical simulation along
with addition of the measurement noise, that is,
The rotating beam usually first occurs damage at the root. Hence the first damage
is assumed to be near the root of the beam as Fig. 4a) shows. When there is large
damage in element 2, the large error appears in the last element with 2.5%. When
there two damage located at the root, the large error located at element 4 with
0.97%. Even the two damage locates far away, the large error occurred in the
element 2 with 0.98%. In multiply damage conditions, even the root and the tip of
the rotating beam have damages, the identification is acceptable within 1% error. In
all scenarios, the number of iterations is less than 60. In conclusion, all the damages
can be identified efficiently and accurately from the propose approach and it is not
sensitive to the artificial measurement noise.
Damage Detection for Rotating Flexible Beam … 173
a)Scenario 1 b) Scenario 2
c) Scenario 3 d) Scenario 4
5 Conclusions
This paper has analysed the dynamic response of rotating flexible beam that driven
by a rigid hub. It is found that under the constant torque, the chordwise vibration
will attempt to be stable. The dynamic acceleration responses of the rotating beam
are used to detect the damages in the beam. Single damage and multiple damages in
the rotating beam can be identified successfully from proposed method. It is found
that the present method is not sensitive to measurement noise. Even under 5%
measurement noise, good identification results can be obtained.
Acknowledgements The present investigation was performed under the support of National
Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 11702336), Guangdong Province Natural Science
Foundation (No. 2017A03031300716 and No. 2018B030311001) and the Fundamental Research
Funds of the Central Universities (No. 17lgpy54).
174 D. Yang et al.
References
1. Chung J, Yoo HH (2002) Dynamic analysis of a rotating cantilever beam by using the finite
element method. J Sound Vib 249:147–164
2. Hansen PC (1992) Analysis of discrete ill-posed problems by means of the L-curve. SIAM
Rev 34:561–580
3. Hoshyarmanesh H, Abbasi A (2018) Structural health monitoring of rotary aerospace
structures based on electromechanical impedance of integrated piezoelectric transducers.
J Intell Mater Syst Struct 29:1799–1817
4. Kiddy J, Pines D (1998) Eigenstructure assignment technique for damage detection in rotating
structures. AIAA J 36:1680–1685
5. Kim H, Chung J (2016) Nonlinear modeling for dynamic analysis of a rotating cantilever
beam. Nonlinear Dyn 86:1981–2002
6. Kim H, Hee Yoo H, Chung J (2013) Dynamic model for free vibration and response analysis
of rotating beams. J Sound Vib 332:5917–5928
7. Lu Z-R, Wang L (2017) An enhanced response sensitivity approach for structural damage
identification: convergence and performance: enhanced response sensitivity approach. Int J
Numer Meth Eng 111:1231–1251
8. Lu Z-R, Zhou J, Wang L (2019) On choice and effect of weight matrix for response
sensitivity-based damage identification with measurement and model errors. Mech Syst Signal
Process 114:1–24
9. Masoud AA, Al-Said S (2009) A new algorithm for crack localization in a rotating
Timoshenko beam. J Vib Control 15:1541–1561
10. Mironov A, Doronkin P, Priklonsky A (2016) Structural health monitoring of rotating blades
on helicopters. Aviation 20:110–122
11. Moré JJ (1978) The Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm: implementation and theory. In:
Watson GA (ed) Numerical Analysis. Lecture Notes in Mathematics. Springer, Berlin
Heidelberg, pp 105–116
12. Roy N, Ganguli R (2005) Helicopter rotor blade frequency evolution with damage growth and
signal processing. J Sound Vib 283:821–851
13. Yang JB, Jiang LJ, Chen DCh (2004) Dynamic modelling and control of a rotating
Euler-Bernoulli beam. J Sound Vib 274:863–875
14. Yigit A, Scott RA, Galip Ulsoy A (1988) Flexural motion of a radially rotating beam attached
to a rigid body. J Sound Vib 121:201–210
15. Yoo HH, Shin SH (1998) Vibration analysis of rotating cantilever beams. J Sound Vib
212:807–828
Output-Only Modal Analysis
of a Footbridge Based
on Compact-Bandwidth Regularization
Keywords Output-only modal analysis Compact bandwidth regularization
Alternating minimization algorithm Real footbridge
1 Introduction
traffic loads induced base motion, the pedestrian loads and the wind loads. In this
way, modal analysis should be proceeded upon the output, but without the
knowledge of the input; this calls for output-only modal analysis [8, 12] or oper-
ational modal analysis [11].
Due to the wide applicability in engineering, output-only modal analysis has
received tremendous interests from industry and academic communities. Over the
years, a number of approaches have been proposed for output-only modal analysis.
A widely-recognized one is the stochastic subspace identification approach
(SSI) [8]. The SSI relies on first establishment of a state evolution model from the
dynamic equation and then estimating the state model from the output via the
singular value decomposition (SVD) of the Hankel matrix. Once the model is
estimated, the modal parameters are directly computable. Note that the system
model is involved in the SSI and therefore, the SSI belongs to the model-based
modal analysis approaches [14]. Other model-based approaches include Ibrahim
time-domain method [5], eigen-system realization algorithm [6], poly-reference
least-squares complex frequency domain method [9], ARMA model-based methods
[13], expectation maximization algorithm [3] to cite a few. A common feature of the
model-based approaches is the dependence on the model order and more often,
spurious modes may be obtained. To properly exclude the spurious modes, the
stabilization diagram [13] as the model order vs. the frequency shall be plotted. In
addition, there are also approaches that identify the modes as the peak of some
spectrum plot; these are known as the peak-based approaches [14]. One of the
well-known approaches is the frequency domain decomposition method (FDD) [2].
The key idea behind the FDD is that the singular values of the power spectral
density matrix would reach local maximums at the natural frequencies. The FDD is
simple and it is able to detect closely spaced modes: more than one singular values
will reach a local maximum around the close frequencies [10]. However, the
selection of the peaks may be subjective if the peaks are not very clear.
In this paper, a new compact-bandwidth approach is developed for output-only
modal analysis. It directly manipulates on the modal separation equation along with
the compact-bandwidth constraint where an arbitrary structural mode should be
compact in the frequency domain. In this way, the following features are invoked:
• It does not require the system model, being free from the possible spurious
modes;
• There is also no need to seek exactly the peaks of some spectrum plot and as a
consequence, it is not subjective;
• It can identify more modes than the measurements.
The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2, the theoretic
background for output-only modal analysis is briefly recalled. In particular, the
compact-bandwidth constraint for the modal coordinates is additionally introduced,
along with which modal separation is formulated. In Sect. 3, how to solve the
modal separation problem with the alternating minimization algorithm is
Output-Only Modal Analysis of a Footbridge … 177
2 Theoretic Background
Let yðtÞ 2 Rm be the measured acceleration data from the acceleration transducers
on a real structure. By the modal expansion theorem, there is
Xn
yðtÞ ¼ /qðtÞ þ wðtÞ ¼ i¼1
u i qi ð t Þ þ w ð t Þ ð1Þ
where tr() denotes the trace of a matrix and I is the identity matrix. Such a nor-
malization constraint (2) is still not enough for modal separation and in this paper, a
novel compact-bandwidth constraint is additionally introduced.
To proceed further, let b
q ðxÞ with a hat symbol at the top designate the frequency
domain data after Fourier transformation of the time domain data qðtÞ. In this way,
the mode expansion (1) is alternatively expressed as,
Xn
by ðxÞ ¼ /b b ðxÞ ¼
q ðx Þ þ w ui b b ðxÞ:
q i ðx Þ þ w ð3Þ
i¼1
The more compact ^qi ðxÞ is around xi , the less CB(^qi ðxÞ; xi Þ is. As for the
n modes qðtÞ or b q ðxÞ, the compact-bandwidth is the simple addition of that of
every mode, i.e.,
178 L. Wang et al.
Xn Z þ1
q ðxÞ; fxi gni¼1 Þ
CBðb ¼ i¼1
4ðx xi Þ2 jb
q i ðxÞj2 dx:: ð5Þ
0
þZ1
minimize kby ðxÞ /b
q ðxÞk22 ¼ 2 ðby ðxÞ /b
q ðxÞÞH ðby ðxÞ /b
q ðxÞÞdx;
0
Xn þZ1
ð6Þ
and CB b
q ðxÞ; fxi gni¼1 ¼ i¼1
4ðx xi Þ2 jb
q i ðxÞj2 dx;
0
subject to diag /T / I ¼ 0
ðk1Þ ðk1Þ n
q ðkÞ ðxÞ ¼ arg minbq ðxÞ gl fxi
b ; ui gi¼1 ; b
q ðxÞ ; ð8Þ
• Step 2: update the modal parameters upon the recovered modal coordinates
q ðkÞ ðxÞ,
b
ðk Þ ðk Þ ðk Þ
fxi ; ui gni¼1 ¼ arg minfxi ;u gn g fx ; u g n
; b
q ð xÞ ; ð9Þ
i¼1 :diagð/ /I Þ¼0
T l i i i¼1
i
While for step 2 modal parameters update, minimization over the frequency xi
gives rise to
2
þ1 ðkÞ
R
xb
0 q i ðxÞ dx
ðk Þ
xi ¼ 2 ; i ¼ 1; 2; . . .; n: ð11Þ
R þ 1 ðk Þ
0 b
q i ð x Þ dx
On the other hand, minimization over the mode shapes / should resort to the
following quadratic optimization problem,
180 L. Wang et al.
Z þ1 H
mintrð/T /Þ¼I by ðxÞ /b q ðkÞ ðxÞ q ðkÞ ðxÞ dx
by ðxÞ /b
0
¼ tr /AðkÞ /T 2BðkÞ /T þ c;
Z þ 1 H ð12Þ
AðkÞ ¼ real q ðkÞ ðxÞ b
b q ðkÞ ðxÞ dx
0
Z þ 1 H
BðkÞ ¼ real by ðxÞ b q ðkÞ ðxÞ dx
0
Assume that all modal coordinates have separated frequencies and further consid-
ering the fact that b
q i ðxÞ is compact around xi , it is obtainable that
X
n
q i ðxi Þj b
jb q j ðxi Þ; j 6¼ i ) by ðxi Þ ¼ uj b b ðxi Þ ui b
q j ðx i Þ þ w q i ðxi Þ: ð14Þ
j¼1
Equation (14) indicates that by ðxi Þ=kby ðxi Þk2 is to some extent a good approx-
imation of ui . Motivated by this, a spectrum-peak-based rule could be invoked for
ð0Þ ð0Þ
selection of initial modal parameters fxi ; ui gni¼1 , that is,
ð0Þ ð0Þ
• Spectrum-peak-based selection of fxi ; ui gni¼1 :
– Plot the by ðxÞ2 vs x curve over the interested frequency domain [xmin ; xmax ];
ð0Þ
– Roughly estimate the initial frequencies fxi gni¼1 at the peak of the curve;
n on
ð0Þ ð0Þ ð0Þ
– The initial mode shapes are estimated as ui ¼ by xi = by xi .
2 i¼1
Output-Only Modal Analysis of a Footbridge … 181
Herein, a real footbridge—the Zhongda footbridge is under test (see Fig. 1) for
modal analysis. The footbridge is of three spans and the test is conducted under
ambient excitations, including the base motion induced by the tranffic loads and the
pedestrian loads on the deck. Ten wireless acceleration transducers are used to get
the vertical accelerations at the middle line of the deck by referring to Fig. 1(c) and
the accelerations are sampled at the frequency of 128 Hz with the duration of
15 min. For instance, the measured accelerations from the four transducers 1, 4, 7,
10 are depicted in Fig. 2. Both the SSI [8] and the proposed CBR are used to get the
modal parameters of the footbridge.
As for the SSI, the stabilization diagram is exhibited in Fig. 3 from which five
modes are identified. While for the proposed CBR, the L-curve is plotted in Fig. 4
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The present investigation was performed under the support of National
Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 11702336 and No. 11972380), Guangdong Province
Natural Science Foundation (No. 2017A030313007 and No. 2018B030311001) and the
Fundamental Research Funds of the Central Universities (No. 17lgpy54).
References
1. Beck A (2015) On the convergence of alternating minimization for convex programming with
applications to iteratively reweighted least squares and decomposition schemes. SIAM J
Optim 25(1):185–209
2. Brincker R, Zhang L, Andersen P (2001) Modal identification of output-only systems using
frequency domain decomposition. Smart Mater Struct 10:441–445
3. Cara FJ, Carpio J, Juan J, Alarcon E (2012) An approach to operational modal analysis using
the expectation maximization algorithm. Mech Syst Signal Process 31:109–129
4. Hansen PC (1992) Analysis of discrete ill-posed problems by means of the L-curves. SIAM
Rev 34(4):561–580
5. Ibrahim SR, Mikulcik EC (1973) A time domain modal vibration test technique. Shock Vibr
Bull 43:21–37
6. Juang JS, Pappa RS (1985) An eigen system realization algorithm for modal parameter
identification and model reduction. AIAA J Guidance Control Dyn 12:620–627
7. Marler RT, Arora JS (2010) The weighted sum method for multi-objective optimization: new
insights. Struct Mult Optim 41(6):853–862
8. Peeters B, de Roeck G (1999) Reference-based stochastic subspace identification for
output-only modal analysis. Mech Syst Signal Process 13:855–878
9. Peeters B, Van Der Auweraer H, Guillaume P (2004) The PolyMAX frequency domain
method: a new standard for modal parameter estimation. Shock Vib 11:395–409
10. Qu CX, Yi TH, Li HN, Chen B (2018) Closely spaced modes identification through modified
frequency domain decomposition. Measurement 128:388–392
11. Reynders E, Houbrechts J, De Roeck G (2012) Fully automated (operational) modal analysis.
Mech Syst Signal Process 29:228–250
12. Sadhu A, Narasimhan S, Antoni J (2017) A review of output-only structural mode
identification literature employing blind source separation methods. Mech Syst Signal Process
94:415–431
186 L. Wang et al.
13. Van Der Auweraer H, Peeters B (2004) Discriminating physical poles from mathematical
poles in high-order systems: use and automation of the stabilization diagram. In: Proceedings
of the 2004 IEEE instrumentation and measurement technology conference, Como, Italy,
pp 2193–2198
14. Wang L, Huang M, Lu ZR (2019) Blind separation of structural modes by
compact-bandwidth regularization. Mech Syst Signal Process 131:288–316
Analysis of Wind Induced Vibration
of Stayed Cable of Sea-crossing Bridge
Based on Monitoring Data
Abstract Based on the real-time health monitoring system, the wind field changes
and cable vibration at Jintang Bridge site were continuously observed by using a
three-dimensional supersonic anemometer, propeller anemometers, and acceleration
sensors on cable. The work presented in this paper focuses on the characteristics of
wind speed and wind direction, turbulence intensity and power spectral density of
fluctuating wind during typhoon Canhong are analyzed. In addition, the accelera-
tion time history data are decomposed and recomposed in different frequency bands
based on wavelet multi-scale analysis, and the characteristics of wind field variation
and frequency band distribution of wind-induced cable vibration energy are
obtained. The results show that there is a strong correlation between turbulence
intensity along wind direction and across wind direction. The root mean square
acceleration of cables during typhoon landfall is more than 5 times of normal, and
vibration energy is mainly distributed in high frequency band.
Keywords Cable-stayed bridge Typhoon period Wind induced vibration
Wavelet analysis Monitoring on-site
J. Guo (&) J. X. He C. J. Hu J. Y. Wu
Institute of Bridge Engineering, Zhejiang University of Technology,
Hangzhou 310023, China
e-mail: guoj@zjut.edu.cn
J. X. He
e-mail: jxhe7@zjut.edu.cn
C. J. Hu
e-mail: huchengjie@zjut.edu.cn
J. Y. Wu
e-mail: wu-jiyi@zjut.edu.cn
1 Introduction
With the development of transportation, many sea-crossing bridges have been built
in the coastal areas of China. Long-span cable-stayed bridges have become the
main choice of these sea-crossing bridges. Following the increase of span of
cable-stayed bridge, the length of cable as the main stress component is getting
longer and longer, and the flexibility is also getting larger and larger. Vibration
problems caused by wind field changes near stayed cables have become a very
serious challenge because of being prone to fatigue damage and affecting the safety
and durability of bridges.
Some scholars have done a lot of work in the research of bridge monitoring data,
and have achieved many useful results. Hu Jun and Ou Jinping measured and
studied the wind field characteristics of a suspension bridge in the East China Sea
[1]. Liu Zhiqiang and Li Na used the structure monitoring system of Xihoumen
Bridge to monitor the long-term wind field changes and bridge vibration [2]. M.C.
H. Hui et al. measured the wind field characteristics of the Shizhu Island Bridge in
Hong Kong [3]. After more than ten years of development, the health monitoring
system of long-span bridge structure is becoming more and more perfect, which
provides convenient conditions for obtaining the wind field environment and
vibration response of the bridge. The monitoring data can provide a reference for
future bridge design.
The main methods of studying wind-rain vibration of stay cables are field
monitoring, wind tunnel test, numerical simulation and theoretical research, and a
lot of research results have been achieved. Field monitoring has become the most
objective and direct means of wind field research because it can get real-time data
and transmit it to researchers’ computers by wireless. The sea area of Jintang Bridge
is seriously affected by a typhoons and monsoons, which caused wind field char-
acteristics are very complex. Therefore, based on the structural health monitoring
system of Jintang Bridge and local monitoring of the long cable, this paper carried
out analysis of the wind field and vibration response of cable, providing valuable
reference for wind resistance of this kind bridge.
Jintang Bridge is a cable-stayed bridge with two towers and double cable planes
with 620 m main span, and its span combination is 77+218+620+218+77 m. It is
the first span cable-stayed bridge constructed in China under sea conditions. In this
paper, a streamlined flat steel box girder with orthogonal special-shaped plates is
adopted. Parallel steel cables are used for stayed cables. Moreover, double towers
and double cable planes are used for stayed cables. The typical length of long cables
in stayed cables can reach 331 m. The sea area of Jintang Bridge is greatly affected
by typhoon and monsoon, and the characteristics of wind field in this area are very
Analysis of Wind Induced Vibration of Stayed Cable … 189
Fig. 1 The layout of the partial sensors installed on the Jintang Bridge
with sampling frequency of 1 Hz were arranged at the top of East and west main
towers. What`s more, a wind anemometer with sampling frequency of 4 Hz was
installed at CAC20 cables in the later stage, which is located on the street lamp pole
nearest to CAC20 cables and 4 m away from the bridge deck. In addition, to obtain the
vibration parameters of cable, a 50 Hz unidirectional acceleration sensor was
installed on each of the 20 representative cables on the bridge. The layout of the partial
sensors installed on the Jintang Bridge is shown in Fig. 1, in which a) is the physical
picture of the supersonic anemometer, b) is the physical picture of the propeller
anemometer, c) is the physical picture of the acceleration sensor. The wind field and
vibration acceleration data collected from typhoon Canhong in 2015 were selected to
conduct the detail analysis presented in this paper.
a) The overall layout of monitoring device
b) The layout of three-dimensional supersonic anemometer
c) The layout of propeller anemomete
Taking the data of typhoon Canhong during its landing in July 2015 as an example,
72 h of data had been collected since 8:00 am. on July 10, 2015, on which the wind
field characteristics are studied.
The analysis of average wind speed and direction usually takes the basic time
interval of 1 min or 10 min, which is calculated here according to the time interval
of 10 min. The 72-hour data collected by the propeller anemometer installed at the
top of the eastern cable tower and the western cable tower are divided into 432
sections. Average wind speed and wind direction are shown in Figs. 2 and 3.
From Figs. 2 and 3, it can be seen that the measured wind speed and wind
direction show obvious similarity, which verifies the effectiveness of the health
monitoring system of Jintang Bridge. When the typhoon landed, the wind speed at the
top of the eastern and western cable towers was very similar and the wind speed
increased significantly. The maximum wind speed reached 28.67 m/s and the average
wind speed reached 15.39 m/s at the top of the eastern cable tower, in addition, the
maximum wind speed reached 31.57 m/s and the average wind speed reached
15.74 m/s at the top of the western cable tower. With the departure of typhoon, the
wind speed gradually decreased and stabilized. The change of wind direction is rather
unstable. It only concentrates at 150–200° in the first 17 h, and then maintains about
Analysis of Wind Induced Vibration of Stayed Cable … 191
75° with the departure of typhoon. Wind speed variation has a very important impact
on cable vibration, which can be reflected in the acceleration analysis.
The turbulence intensity and pulsating wind power spectrum are two important
parameters to describe the turbulent characteristics of a wind field. Turbulence
intensity is a physical quantity describing the degree of variation of wind speed with
time scale and space scale and reflecting the relative intensity of fluctuation. The
calculation method of turbulence intensity is the ratio of the standard difference of
192 J. Guo et al.
fluctuating wind speed to the average wind speed. Kaimal spectrum is currently used
as the wind spectrum along the wind direction and Panofsky spectrum as the vertical
wind spectrum in the code for wind resistance of bridges in China [4–7]. The tur-
bulence intensity and power spectrum can be calculated by formulas (1), (2), and (3).
ru rv rw
Iu ¼ ; Iv ¼ ; Iw ¼ ð1Þ
U U U
nSu ðz; nÞ 200fz
2
¼ ð2Þ
u ð1 þ 50fz Þ5=3
Kaimal spectrum, but slightly higher than Kaimal spectrum. The measured power
spectrum of the vertical fluctuating wind can not match the Panofsky spectrum.
This difference is mainly caused by the characteristics of typhoon itself. It also
shows obviously that the turbulent energy distribution of the fluctuating wind in the
vertical direction is much lower than that in the downwind direction.
194 J. Guo et al.
The wavelet analysis can be used for signal local analysis, which has higher fre-
quency resolution and lower time resolution in the low frequency part, high time
resolution and low frequency resolution in the high frequency part. In order to
monitor the vibration of Jintang Bridge’s stay cables, a one-way acceleration sensor
is installed on 20 representative cables on the bridge, and its sampling frequency is
50 Hz. As shown in Fig. 8, the original acceleration data for one hour during the
typhoon period. The acceleration signal data of CAC20 cable is used for wavelet
analysis. The original signal is decomposed by three scales of wavelet transform
and is distributed to different scales according to its frequency components. A1 is
the first layer approximation signal, A2 is the second layer approximation signal and
Analysis of Wind Induced Vibration of Stayed Cable … 195
A3 is the third layer approximation signal. D1 is the first layer detail signal, D2 is the
second layer detail signal and D3 is the third layer detail signal. The frequency
bands on each scale are as follows:
A1 : 0 25 Hz D1 : 25 50 Hz
A2 : 0 12:5 Hz D2 : 12:5 25 Hz
A3 : 0 6:25 Hz D3 : 6:25 12:5 Hz
The acceleration data are decomposed by wavelet basis function db8, which is
usually used to analyze non-stationary signals, then the outline signal and the detail
signal are reconstructed, and the frequency band distribution characteristics of the
cable vibration energy are obtained by analyzing the power spectrum of each signal.
Figure 9 is the result of multi-scale decomposition and reconstruction of the orig-
inal signal. Figure 10 is the power spectrum of the outline signal and the detail
signal. Acceleration time-history signal is obtained by sensor monitoring, which
includes all vibration frequency bands of stay cables [11–13].
From Fig. 10, it can be seen that the cable vibration during typhoon is dis-
tributed in different frequency bands, but mainly concentrated in the high frequency
band. It shows that the cable vibration is mainly high-order, and it can be con-
sidered to increase the damper to reduce the high frequency vibration of the cable.
The wind field data measured from typhoon Canhong by the anemometers installed
on the bridge were analyzed in detail in this study. Some main conclusions are as
follows:
1) The measured turbulence intensity results are higher than the standard ones, and
the variation of turbulence intensity along and across the wind direction has a
greater correlation. During the first 16 h of typhoon landing, the turbulence
intensity increased significantly, and then gradually decreased and tended to be
stable with the typhoon leaving, and the cable vibration decreased with the
increase of turbulence intensity.
2) The power spectrum of the downwind pulsating wind basically coincides with
Kaimal spectrum, but slightly higher than Kaimal spectrum. The vertical fluc-
tuating wind power spectrum can not match the Panofsky spectrum, which is
lower than the theoretical spectrum. This difference is mainly caused by the
characteristics of typhoon itself.
3) The root mean square acceleration of cables during typhoon landing is more
than 5 times of normal. The multi-scale decomposition and reconstruction of
measured signals by wavelet can effectively identify the distribution of vibration
energy in different frequency bands and the vibration energy of cables during
typhoon Canhong is mainly distributed in high frequency band.
Acknowledgements The presented work was supported by the National Natural Science
Foundation of China (U1709207, 51578506 ).
References
J. T. Li and X. Q. Zhu
1 Introduction
Due to the fact that a large amount of bridge infrastructures are subjected to gradual
deterioration and structurally deficient, monitoring the condition of these bridges is
very important. Bridge parameter identification is a critical component in bridge
J. T. Li X. Q. Zhu (&)
School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Technology Sydney, Ultimo,
NSW 2007, Australia
e-mail: xinqun.zhu@uts.edu.au
J. T. Li
e-mail: Jiantao.li@uts.edu.au
structure health monitoring. The measured bridge modal parameters, such as the
modal frequencies, damping and mode shapes can be effective indicators of the
structure degradation and damage. Conventional modal parameter identification
requires extensive instrumentation on the bridge structure to get the dynamic
responses from sensors on different locations of the bridge [1]. This direct approach
can pose a number of practical problems, such as the need of bridge closure,
accidental damage to installed equipment, the high initial and recurring cost of the
sensory system, etc. The idea of an indirect approach, also referred as drive-by
inspection, was proposed by Yang et al. [9] that the dynamic parameters of bridge
were extracted from the response of a passing instrumented vehicle. Without
requirement of bridge instrumentation, the drive-by inspection technique is con-
venient, efficient and low-cost. Over the past decade, a great deal of research has
been conducted in the field of indirect bridge modal identification. Besides the
frequency identification, the indirect approach was also extended to the estimation
of bridge damping and mode shapes. González et al. [2] and Keenahan et al. [3]
identified the bridge damping using a moving instrumented vehicle or a
trailer-truck. The vehicle response had also been used for the bridge mode shape
identification [7, 10]. A review paper was presented by Zhu and Law [13] for
structural health monitoring based on the VBI data. Bridge identification techniques
using vehicle responses and both vehicle and bridge responses were reviewed.
Malekjafarian et al. [6] and Yang and Yang [11] presented critical review of
indirect methods for bridge modal parameter identification and the challenges for
successful implementation of drive-by inspection in practice. Recently, some
experimental investigations have been conducted by the authors to identify the
bridge modal parameters using responses of vehicle models in the lab which is
presented in this paper. The VBI system is time-variant with the operational vari-
ations of traffic excitation on the structure. Time-frequency characteristic of a VBI
system due to the interaction is important factor for the accurate bridge parameter
identification. A recently proposed time-frequency (TF) analysis method, syn-
chroextracting transform [12], is used to extract the time-varying characteristic of
the VBI system. The instantaneous frequency trajectories of a filed cable-stayed
bridge under the excitation of a truck are extracted to show the time-varying fre-
quency features.
€ þ Cd_ þ Kd ¼ F
Md ð1Þ
where M, C, and K are the mass, damping and stiffness matrices of the system,
respectively; F is the force vector and d is the response vector of the system. The
vehicle response contains dynamic information of the bridge. Thus, the bridge
modal parameters can be estimated from the vehicle response.
With the premise that the multiple excitations to the bridge were modelled as white
noise excitation to the bridge supports, stochastic subspace identification
(SSI) based technique was adopted by Li et al. [5] to identify bridge modal fre-
quencies and mode shapes with instrumented vehicles. The bridge frequencies can
be easily extracted from responses of moving vehicle when the bridge surface
roughness is smooth. For a rough surface, the subtraction of the responses measured
from two successive identical vehicles can greatly reduce the effect of road surface
roughness. To identified the bridge mode shapes, two instrumented vehicles were
used with one remain stationary on the bridge as reference sensor and the other one
moving over the bridge as a moving sensor. The responses measured from two
vehicles were segmented into multi datasets based on the number of selected beam
elements for analysis. Within each dataset, the response was assumed stationary due
to the short measure time for each signal segment. A short time SSI method with a
rescale procedure was proposed to analyze the segmented responses and get the
bridge mode shapes.
its moving over the bridge. The acquired response was first decomposed into a
multichannel datasets using SSA, and a blind modal identification method was
implemented to analyze the datasets to extract the different response components
contained in the vehicle response. The bridge modal frequencies were identified
from the corresponding components. The method was found robust to the mea-
surement noise and can identify bridge modal frequencies without requirement of
subtraction technique when there is road surface roughness. Hilbert transform could
be used to analyze bridge related components and their instantaneous frequencies.
Experimental tests in the lab were conducted to verify the proposed indirect bridge
modal identification techniques. A vehicle bridge interaction testbed were built as
shown in Fig. 2. The bridge model consists of three rectangular section steel beams.
The one in the middle is the main beam with a length of 6 m and the width and
depth of the steel beams are 100 mm and 15 mm, respectively. The main beam is in
a two-span continuous simply-supported configuration. Half-cylinder steel bar and
cylinder steel bar are used to simulate the pinned support and roller support to the
beam, respectively. A leading beam and a trailing beam are sitting in front of and at
the rear of the main beam to allow for acceleration and deceleration of the vehicle.
The length of the side beams is 3 m. Vehicle model with different configurations
including one and two-axle vehicles were manufactured for study. One-axle vehicle
was manufactured to simulate the SDOF vehicle mode used in the analytical pro-
gram. The two-axle vehicle model runs on four rubber wheels. The one-axle vehicle
was connected with the two-axle vehicle when they were passing over the bridge.
The mass of the one- and two-axle vehicles are 2 and 4 kg, respectively. The model
vehicles are pulled along the guide with an electric motor.
The modal testing has been carried out on the vehicle and bridge models with an
impulse hammer. The first two natural bridge frequencies were obtained as 5.68,
and 8.48 Hz, respectively. Spectrum analysis on the vehicle responses gave the
modal frequency of the single-axle vehicle as 29.37 Hz.
In drive-by bridge modal parameter identification test, a wireless sensory system
was setup and wireless accelerometers were used to measure the responses. For the
bridge mode shape identification using SSI based method, a wireless sensor was
installed on the single-axle vehicle as a moving sensor with the other one installed
on the beam (at 1.1 m to the right support) as the reference sensor. The vehicles
were pulled with three different speeds at approximately 0.10, 0.14 and 0.21 m/s,
respectively which were denoted respectively by v1, v2 and v3. Measurements from
the moving and stationary sensors were analyzed with the proposed method to
identify the first mode shape of the beam. Each signal was divided into eight
segments. The identified operational mode shape values were compared with those
from modal testing using MAC values. Figure 3 the results for three different
moving speeds. The MAC value decreases from about 0.98 to 0.94 when the speed
increases from 0.10 to 0.21 m/s. The accuracy of the identification is acceptable.
For the verification of proposed blind modal identification with SSA, only the
response from the single-axle vehicle was used. The decomposed components using
proposed method are presented in Fig. 4 when the speed was 0.10 m/s. The first
component has the frequency 5.21 Hz that is close to the first modal frequency of
the bridge. Similarly, the frequency 8.32 Hz in Fig. 4(b) is related to the second
bridge mode. The vehicle modal frequency is identified in the third component as
29.35 Hz.
1
0.8 v1, MAC=0.9768
0.6 v2, MAC=0.9666
Normalized mode shape
0.4 v3,MAC=0.9359
0.2 Modal test
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1
Locations on the beam (m)
(a) First component and its spectrum (b) Second component and its spectrum
This section introduces the time-frequency analysis on the responses measured from
an actual bridge. Time-varying characteristic of the frequencies due to the vehicle
bridge interaction was investigated. A recent proposed time-frequency (TF) analysis
method termed synchroextracting transform (SET) was used to get the instanta-
neous frequency (IF) trajectories. A short-span cable-stayed bridge over the Great
Western Highway (as shown in Fig. 5) in New South Wales, Australia was tested. It
is a single lane highway bridge with a span 46 m and a width 6 m. A long-term
monitoring system has been installed on the bridge. This system provides an
integrated and reliable device to log high-quality data with 24-bit resolution with
bandwidth capability of 0–3 kHz. The hardware combines instrument excitation,
voltage regulation, digitization, anti-aliasing filters, and data logging. The logging
software is Catman Version 5, which collects all channels at a default sample rate of
Drive-By Bridge Parameter Identification: An Overview 205
600 Hz [8]. A dense array of strain gauges and the accelerometers were installed
under the bridge deck and timely synchronized to measure the structure responses.
Figure 6 shows the accelerometer array on the deck. Modal analysis using the
acceleration measurements from sensors on the deck was conducted under ambient
excitation. A bridge vibration mode with the frequency 2.00 Hz was identified as
shown in Fig. 7. It can be seen the vibration is related to the vertical bending mode.
Responses under different traffic conditions at sensor location A10 were mea-
sured and used for analysis. The acceleration responses and the spectra are pre-
sented in Fig. 8. When no traffic on bridge, only the first bridge frequency can be
identified in the response spectrum. For the condition with a moving vehicle on top
of the bridge, the vehicular excitation makes the higher bridge vibration modes
206 J. T. Li and X. Q. Zhu
more prominent. The TFA results of the responses under different traffic conditions
are presented in Fig. 9. For the condition of without traffic on bridge, the IF
trajectory of the first bridge vibration mode show little variation. For the conditions
of with moving vehicle, the IF trajectories corresponding to the bridge vibration
modes show great variations. For the first three modes, the frequency variation
becomes very small, while the frequency of the 4th bridge vibration mode varies
periodically after about 6 s. The composite effects of vehicle and cables account for
the complicated variation behaviors of the bridge frequencies.
4 Conclusions
This work presents a concise overview on the authors’ recent study on the drive-by
bridge parameter identification. Using instrumented vehicles, the bridge frequencies
and mode shapes can be identified with stochastic subspace identification based
method under the assumption of white-noise excitation. With SSA based blind
modal identification method, the response components can be extracted from a set
of vehicle responses. The bridge frequencies can be estimated from the bridge
related components. Further study will focus on the identification of other modal
parameters from the extracted components. A time-frequency analysis on the bridge
responses under heavy traffic excitation reveals the time-varying characteristics of
the vehicle-bridge interaction system. Further investigation on the bridge damage
detection using the time-varying features is recommended.
References
1. Carden EP, Fanning P (2004) Vibration based condition monitoring: a review. Struct Health
Monit 3:355–377
2. González A, OBrien EJ, McGetrick P (2012) Identification of damping in a bridge using a
moving instrumented vehicle. J Sound Vib 331:4115–4131
3. Keenahan J, OBrien EJ, McGetrick PJ et al (2014) The use of a dynamic truck–trailer
drive-by system to monitor bridge damping. Struct Health Monit 13:143–157
4. Li JT, Zhu XQ, Law SS et al (2019) Drive-by blind modal identification with singular
spectrum analysis. J Aerosp Eng ASCE 32:04019050
5. Li JT, Zhu XQ, Law SS et al (2019) Indirect bridge modal parameters identification with one
stationary and one moving sensors and stochastic subspace identification. J Sound Vib 446:1–
21
6. Malekjafarian A, McGetrick PJ, OBrien EJ (2015) A review of indirect bridge monitoring
using passing vehicles. Shock Vib 2015:286139
7. Malekjafarian A, OBrien EJ (2017) On the use of a passing vehicle for the estimation of
bridge mode shapes. J Sound Vib 397:77–91
208 J. T. Li and X. Q. Zhu
1 Introduction
There are now over 50,000 bridges and over 900,000 km of roads in Australia.
Millions of travelers rely on the transportation network. The safety and reliability of
these infrastructure elements are critical to the Australian economy [7].
2 Project Methodology
In this study, four bridges with varying types and sizes were inspected using RPAs
to study the effectiveness of this technology. A detailed drone inspection was
conducted to collect images at varying elevations, angles and distances from the
structure. The objective of the inspection was to collect sufficiently detailed data
that a desktop review could be conducted and reporting produced in line with the
requirements of a Level 2 Inspection in accordance with the RMS Bridge Inspection
Manual. This includes information about the extent, locality and orientation of
defects for each individual component (Fig. 1).
St Albans Bridge, completed in 1902, St Albans Bridge is a representative but
early example of a DeBurgh timber truss bridge, a type of construction that was the
Health Monitoring of Bridges Using RPAs 211
first to use significant amounts of steel and iron, and did so in spite of its high cost
and the government’s historical preference for timber.
Rip Bridge is a Pre-stressed Concrete Truss Bridge (PTRUS) built in 1974 over
Brisbane Water in the Hunter region. The Bridge 330 m long consists of two
prestressed concrete cantilever trusses with a central 36.6 m suspended slab. The
Bridge carries two lanes of traffic with a carriage way width of 8.54 m between the
kerbs. It carries 1.5 m footpath on downstream side of the carriageway.
Old Peats Ferry Bridge (BN 341) is a K type steel truss bridge (STRUS) built in
1945 over Hawkesbury River on Pacific Hwy at Peats Ferry in Sydney Region. The
601.98 m long Bridge consists of two steel truss span of 134.11 m and nine steel
girder (SGIRD) and eight steel beam (SBEAM) approach spans.
Mooney Mooney Bridge, is a twin cantilever bridge that spans Mooney Mooney
Creek in Brisbane Water National Park. It is the highest road bridge in Australia as
measured from the road bed to the water 75 m below. The twin bridges consist of
three spans per carriageway of post-tensioned concrete box girders. The bridge was
built in 1986. The carriageway width between kerbs is 12.3 m and it carries three
lanes of traffic (Fig. 2).
The project utilised Falcon 8+ drones with a precise 36 MP full-frame DSLM
camera. The intel Falcon 8+ drone is designed to provide stable flights in the face of
external influences such as weak GPS signals and high winds, as well as creating
resistance to magnetic field disturbances.
212 M. Rashidi and B. Samali
The remoteness of the working locations provides an added layer of difficulty for
the project, due to the associated costs of rework in case insufficient detail was
captured by the RPA or a photogrammetric model was unable to be produced. As
data processing must be completed off-site, the quality of data was not known until
after inspections were complete. Additionally, there was the need to capture images
systematically such that a standardised approach could be adopted during the
desktop review and report. To minimise these risks, the project planning and data
capture methodology became critical. An initial pass with the drone was conducted,
capturing images at a distance of approximately 25 m from the structure to ensure
that enough coverage was achieved by all images to produce an initial baseline
point cloud model. From this, more detailed images could be built into the final
photogrammetric model. The RPA would fly parallel to the bridge at a slight offset
(about 5 m) from the line of the top and bottom chords. This would enable the
camera to be angled slightly and allow greater inspection of the areas between
crevices or connections. As illustrated, several passes would be made in each
direction to capture sufficient resolution of data for all sides of the key structural
components, with additional passes made below the level of the deck to capture
images of the soffit [1].
RPAs through their autopilot computer and external sensors, come with some
type of autonomous control. Navigation and control are important issues in all RPA
applications, and most pilots are heavily reliant on GPS signals and basic stabili-
sation methods to maintain position. A 3D hold allows for safe control of a RPA in
harsh environmental conditions as well as stabilisation for obtaining adequate
Health Monitoring of Bridges Using RPAs 213
With the use of RPA’s technical abilities today, complex and large bridge inspec-
tions can be completed at a significantly faster time than conventional methods. For
example, it only took 40 min to complete a full bridge inspection on the 116 m long
St Alban Bridge through the use of RPAs. The 40 min consisted of 18-min setup
time, 22-min flight.
Besides the safety and speed of operation, cost effectiveness is another advantage;
many of the cost savings are associated with time reductions and safety. If RPAs are
used instead of traditional inspection, cost for just the deck inspection can decrease
from $4600 to $250 [2].
However, there are some unseen costs such as cost of renting a pilot and RPA,
that are normally ignored in these studies. For many transportation authorities, the
visual inspection of a simple bridge with low traffic and easy access may take only
15–30 min and needs only one bridge inspector. In these cases, drone inspection
will not improve the time or cost associated. Our pilot study for large-scale bridges,
showed that RPA-inspection was 46% faster and 61% cheaper than the conven-
tional inspection.
Health Monitoring of Bridges Using RPAs 215
The advantages mentioned in Sect. 3 are possible under relatively ideal conditions.
Ideal conditions include a skilled pilot, no software and hardware malfunctions, an
appropriate RPA, and no adverse weather conditions.
Currently, there are some challenges associated with bridge inspections. Some
challenges are due to the availability of this emerging technology, and some are due
to the regulations associated with governing bodies such as the CASA and bridge
authorities. The main challenges are as follows:
– Regulations (Regulations governed by CASA to assure safety and functionality
of the operations)
– Flight control in GPS-denied or high wind environment and also poor weather
conditions
– Time spent on post processing operations
– Functionalities limited to visual inspection. Manned inspections are still
required for detailed assessment and clean ups of the asset.
– Fail-safe programming and obstacle avoidance
In order to validate and consolidate the experimental study, a survey has been
conducted and casted out to about 180 transportation authorities around NSW
(including local and state government). The objective of the survey was to evaluate
local government’s perspective on utilising drones for bridge inspections and make
a comparison between different aspects of drone inspection and its conventional
counterpart. This was done to facilitate the decision-making process for asset
management professionals to achieve the objectives of this project [5]. Cost, time,
quality, safety, traffic Disruption and legal and environmental impact have been
216 M. Rashidi and B. Samali
identified as the major criteria for selection of the best inspection methods (Please
see Fig. 3).
The rankings given for both the conventional and RPA methods were obtained
through researching past and current projects involving bridge inspections. These
rankings were appropriately given according to the performance of each the
methods during the inspections. Evident from Table 1, the RPA method’s total
score was significantly higher than the total of the conventional method’s score, this
suggests that the RPA methods may not only be feasible but better than its con-
ventional inspection counterparts.
77% of the respondents saying that RPA technology will positively transform
the bridge inspection process. Respondents stated that the RPA technology speeds
up and streamlines the inspection process and will be an essential tool for bridge
inspections in the future.
Majority of respondents agreed that RPAs reduce risk and increase safety, are
quicker and less disruptive. The respondents also stated the challenges faced with
RPA based inspections. The most common challenges and barriers for inspection
were the satisfaction of regulations set by the CASA, weather and obstacles or
confined spaces. RPAs are also unable to perform inspection that require physical
contact with the structure.
Overall, 23% of respondents stated that RPA technology will replace conven-
tional methods for level 1 and 2 bridge inspections and 77% stated that the con-
ventional methods will not be replaced, instead, RPAs will be used in cooperation
with conventional methods to improve inspections. No respondents stated that
conventional methods are far superior to RPA based methods.
7 Conclusions
This report has outlined the state-of-the-art for bridge inspections and RPA tech-
nology with the aim of educating and informing academics and decision makers
about the current and future capabilities of RPA-assisted or automated bridge
inspections. RPAs have shown promising results in civilian applications as well as
civil engineering purposes, and many asset managers have performed feasibility
studies and found significant successes, but also some disadvantages. The most
common RPA applications in engineering were traffic monitoring and surveillance,
road condition assessment, and mapping; however, significant effort has been put
into bridge inspection with varying degrees of success. The current state of practice
for bridge inspections is heavily tied to visual inspections. RPA-assisted bridge
inspections have the potential to not only improve the safety and decrease costs, but
potentially increasing inspection accuracy; however, sometimes RPA inspections
face major challenges.
The perception of RPA effectiveness for bridge inspection is tied to several
factors, including pilot skill, asset owners’ expectations and weather condition.
Ideally, RPA s can provide inspections, with lower cost and time, for under-bridge
regions without traffic closure, but not in all situations and there are obstacles to
overcome. CASA regulations have recently relaxed, but impose significant limi-
tations, including required line of sight and RPA certification.
218 M. Rashidi and B. Samali
References
1 Introduction
Structural and mechanical systems such as bridges, buildings, offshore oil plat-
forms, aircraft, rotating machinery, etc. are key infrastructure assets of a society.
Construction defects, aging, and environmental circumstances can adversely affect
the life and reliability of these systems. The fact that failure to these systems can
cause life-safety and economic consequences highlights that the onset of damage
should be detected [28]. Damage detection is usually carried out in the context of
one or more closely related disciplines including structural health monitoring
(SHM), condition monitoring, nondestructive evaluation, health and usage moni-
toring system, statistical process control, and damage prognosis. SHM is the pro-
cess of implementing a damage identification strategy for aerospace, civil or
mechanical engineering infrastructure [11]. Note that this paper focuses on the
application of machine learning algorithms in SHM of civil infrastructures.
Many portions of our civil infrastructures are approaching or exceeding their
initial design life. Because of economic challenges, these civil infrastructures are
still being used in spite of aging and the associated damage accumulation.
Therefore, the ability to monitor the health of these structures is becoming
increasingly important [11].
Generally speaking, damage can be defined as changes introduced into a system
that causes a disturbance in its current or future performance. In this study, the
definition of damage is narrowed down to the changes to the material and/or
geometric properties of structural systems, including changes to the boundary
conditions and system connectivity. This can adversely affect the current or future
performance of these systems [26].
SHM approaches were first used in the aerospace and mechanical engineering
industries for damage diagnosis and were then introduced to offshore platform
structures in the 1970s [29]. In the following three decades, the number of studies
and the application of SHM to civil engineering structures, such as bridges, dams,
etc., have been increased [34]. So far, numerous SHM approaches and techniques
have been proposed by different researchers. As SHM is a multidisciplinary
research, the number of studies in this area has become more significant. That is
also the reason why literature review papers with different perspectives in this area
have been published. References [7, 16, 20, 21, 26] are examples that provide
literature reviews in the area of SHM with different applications and perspectives.
In order to make an informed decision on damage detection, it is required to
compare the current properties of the structure with a baseline [30]. In general, with
respect to the baseline data, SHM approaches are categorized into two classes:
model-based and data-driven approaches. Model-based approaches require estab-
lishing a physical model of the structure, usually by the finite element method.
Identifying the occurrence, location, and severity of the damage in model-based
approaches can be achieved by the solution of an inverse problem. Friswell [13]
prepared an overview of some common methods for solving the inverse problem.
Application of Machine Learning Algorithms … 221
The third step of developing a data-driven SHM system, feature extraction and data
compression, has a profound influence on the performance of a SHM system.
Feature extraction is defined as turning the raw signals into low dimensional vectors
which are sensitive to the existence of damage. It is usually necessary to convert
measured data into features. This has the obvious benefit of retaining the necessary
information and discarding the redundant information from raw signals [31].
Different methods have been proposed for extracting damage sensitive features. In
some cases, machine learning algorithms are used to reduce the dimension of data.
There are several machine learning algorithms that are used to discover the better
representation of the inputs and to reduce the dimension of input data [2]. Among
222 Y. Hamishebahar et al.
these algorithms, a classic example which is popular in the area of SHM would be
principal component analysis (PCA).
PCA has various applications in data mining and in analyzing fields such as
dimensionality reduction, data visualization, outlier detection, and correlation
analysis. In the area of SHM, PCA has been used for dimensionality reduction and
visualization. PCA was utilized for both dimensionality reduction and for data
visualization in a proposed SHM approach to detect damage in experimental and
numerical structures [18]. They also used another technique, i.e., selection of
subsets of auto-regressive (AR) coefficients for dimensionality reduction. Their
results showed that for larger feature dimensions, PCA outperforms the selection of
subsets of AR coefficients. PCA along with continuous Daubechies wavelet is used
for feature extraction [17]. In this study, damage sensitive features are obtained by
extracting the minimum variance obtained by the PCA of wavelet energies.
Implementation of PCA is simple and effective for dealing with linear cases.
However, for complicated cases, especially nonlinear cases, PCA is unsuccessful as
it is linear by nature. As a modification of PCA, kernel principal component
analysis (KPCA) has been used in recent years for dealing with nonlinear problems.
In the area of fault diagnosis, Yuqing et al. [33] utilized a data-dependent KPCA
technique to transform original high-dimensional data into low-dimensional man-
ifold feature space with the intrinsic dimensionality. They compared the results with
the approach including PCA instead of KPCA. It was observed that the
KPCA-based method outperforms the PCA-based one. Another comparison
between PCA and KPCA for dimensionality reduction in the area of damage
detection was investigated by Santos et al. [25]. They expressed that for the feature
vector, the fact that there is a large number of features and a small number of
measurements highlights the need for dimensionality reduction. Their results
showed that KPCA can maintain a monotonic relationship between the progressive
level of damage and the amplitude of damage indicator. In contrast, the PCA failed
to achieve the monotonic relationship and exhibited many false-negative indications
of damage for both scenarios.
In the last step of developing a data-driven SHM system, the goal is to perform a
statistical comparison with the baseline. The decision on using the type of learning
(i.e. supervised and unsupervised) is made based on the availability of data from
damaged states of the structure. If the data from the damaged state of the structure is
available (e.g. extracted from either an experimental or numerical model), the
learning type would be supervised. In contrast, in the context of SHM, the unsu-
pervised learning requires data only from the undamaged state of the structure (i.e.
the input data). It is concerned with determining the underlying structure in data
from undamaged states of the structure [31].
Application of Machine Learning Algorithms … 223
In the area of SHM, by relying on data from undamaged states only, the approaches
seek to flag data acquired from a damaged state of the structure as anomaly or
outlier [19]. In data mining, anomaly detection (also outlier detection) is the
identification of rare items, events or observations which raise suspicions by dif-
fering significantly from the majority of the data [36]. Different approaches have
been considered for detecting anomalies so far.
Several studies have used measures of distance for multivariate statistics outlier
detection. Mahalanobis squared distance (MSD) is one of the popular measures of
distance to perform an anomaly detection approach. One of the earliest studies with
an unsupervised anomaly detection manner was done by Worden et al. [32]. They
proposed a method of damage detection adapting anomaly detection based on
MSD. They expressed that in choosing the MSD, there is an implicit assumption
that the normal condition datasets have Gaussian statistics. MSD was utilized in
another study to compete with three other unsupervised algorithms to detect
damage in a benchmark base-excited laboratory frame structure proposed by Los
Alamos [12]. They concluded that the MSD-based algorithm is revealed to be the
best data normalization approach in terms of the classification performance, the
reduced computational efforts, and the fact that no assumptions are required
regarding its architecture. MSD is also compared with a novel distance method
called as partition-based Kullback-Leibler divergence (PKLD) proposed by
Entezami et al. [9]. They used PKLD to measure the discrepancy between the AR
model residuals of undamaged and damaged conditions for damage detection and
localization. They stated that the comparative analysis of the performances of the
PKLD and MSD methods demonstrates that both of them are able to detect and
locate damage. However, the proposed PKLD method outperforms MSD in terms
of false-positive and false-negative indication of damage.
Another way of implementing an anomaly detection approach is to develop a
statistical model on normal data. Then, an investigation is done to see whether the
newly acquired data come from the same source or distribution. If the new test data
come from different source or distributions, they might be flagged as data related to
a possible damaged state [31]. One of the popular algorithms in the aforementioned
approach is One-Class SVM (OCSVM). Das et al. [8] presented an approach to
Application of Machine Learning Algorithms … 225
4 Conclusion
In this paper, a brief review of the application of machine learning algorithms in the
area of SHM for dimensionality reduction and statistical model development was
conducted. Statistical model development was categorized into two classes of
supervised and unsupervised approaches. Although different SHM studies have
been done with a supervised setting, the limitation of obtaining the data from
damaged states of the structure which requires establishing either a finite element or
experimental model is a disadvantage for the supervised setting. The unsupervised
setting is more compatible with the type of data existed for real structures and the
authors are going to focus on SHM approaches with this learning manner. As it was
observed, mainly, the novelty related to the studies in this area comes from intro-
ducing a new combination of algorithms for both feature extraction and statistical
model development steps. Both of the aforementioned steps deeply affect the
performance of a SHM system. The authors are going to link the feature extraction
step to the statistical model development step. In other words, the development of a
new feature fusion method based on the mechanism of anomaly detection algo-
rithms is going to be investigated. The proposed approach is going to fuse the
promising feature extraction methods in a way guaranteeing that the best possible
accuracy will be obtained in the next step. This makes the SHM process more
automated and in turn, the human intervention can be much less required.
References
33. Yuqing Z, et al. (2015) NC machine tools fault diagnosis based on kernel PCA and-nearest
neighbor using vibration signals. Shock and Vibration 2015
34. Zhou L et al (2013) Review of benchmark studies and guidelines for structural health
monitoring. Adv Struct Eng 16(7):1187–1206
35. Zhou Q et al (2014) Structure damage detection based on random forest recursive feature
elimination. Mech Syst Signal Process 46(1):82–90
36. Zimek A, Schubert E (2017) Outlier detection BT. In: Liu L, Özsu MT (eds) Encyclopedia of
Database Systems, pp. 1–5. Springer, New York. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4899-7993-
3_80719-1
Using Deep Learning Technique
for Recovering the Lost Measurement
Data
Keywords Data recovery Structural health monitoring Transmission lost
Deep learning Convolutional neural networks
1 Introduction
Ensuring the safety and reliability of civil infrastructure is significant for public
safety and normal operation of society. The strength of structures degrades due to the
ageing of materials, extreme loading conditions and human-induced damages.
Consequently, condition assessment and damage detection of structures are one of
the crucial tasks for civil engineers. In addressing these issues, structural health
monitoring (SHM) techniques have been developed and have gained vast research
interests recently. The vibration-based long-term SHM is becoming one of the most
popular research areas. Compared to short-term periodical monitoring, it is advanced
in continuously measuring the structural vibration to report earlier the abnormal
conditions of structures by real time analyzing the measurement. Meanwhile, a
long-term SHM system can measure both the structural vibration responses and
ambient conditions at the same time by a comprehensive sensing network, including
multiple types of sensors. The geometries and boundary conditions of structures are
strongly correlated with ambient conditions, where the variation of the vibrational
characteristics due to the change of ambient conditions may mask the damage effect.
Under this circumstance, long-term SHM capturing comprehensive information of
structure can provide a more reliable condition assessment of structures. A growing
number of long-term SHM systems has been installed on civil infrastructure such as
bridges and buildings in the past decades [3, 14].
The traditional wired-based SHM system can provide a stable measurement
whereas it is expensive in facility and labor and time consuming for the installation
[15]. Alternatively, the wireless sensing that can provide a more flexible selection of
sensor locations is attracting more attention [11]. A remarkable number of civil
infrastructures have been monitored by using the wireless sensor based SHM
systems [7, 21, 16]. The studies on improving wireless sensors for serving the SHM
of civil engineering structures concentrate on both hardware and software.
However, data loss still occurs in wireless transmission and has seriously affected
the development and application of wireless sensors for practical SHM.
The proposed method for the recovery of lost data is totally data driven, where
no finite element model is required. Compared to the model-based methods [9, 5,
20] with an accurate finite element model required, data-driven methods are more
reliable for large scale civil engineering structures. Bao et al. [1] proposed an
approach based on the compressive sampling technique to recover the lost data of
wireless sensor networks installed on a real bridge. The recovery accuracy was
good but depended significantly on the selected domain that the time-domain signal
is transferred to, and the threshold value that makes the output matrix sparse to
overcome the ill-posed issue. Wan and Ni [18] leveraged the Bayesian multi-task
learning methodology to recover the blocked SHM missing data including tem-
perature data and acceleration responses. It is reported that the choice of the
covariance function has a great influence on recovery performance.
Using Deep Learning Technique for Recovering … 231
Deep learning has been recently received a strong attention in the area of ‘big
data analytics’. The long-term SHM system continuously measures the structural
vibrations and collects a large volume of data, which fully satisfies the requirement
and superiority of exploring deep learning techniques. Moreover, deep learning
based methods have been investigated in the damaged photo recovery [19] and
image [4] and audio super resolution [8], where the concept is similar as the
vibrational signal recovery. Deep neural networks have been developed for the
condition assessment and damage detection using the crack images [2], vibration
signals [10] and vibration characteristics [17]. In this paper, deep learning tech-
niques is developed for lost data recovery in the field of SHM.
2 Methodology
The proposed network is a fully Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) with bot-
tleneck structure, supported by skip connection, dropout and sub-pixel shuffling
operations. It consists of one input layer, ten hidden convolutional layers and one
output layer. The architecture of the proposed CNN is illustrated in Fig. 1. In
addition, the detailed configurations of each layer are summarized in Table 1.
C1
Input
Output
R1 Final
C2
R2
C3
R3
C4
Bottleneck R4
It should be highlighted that the input and output sizes of each layer are com-
puted based on the input size with 1024 points. The proposed CNN, in fact, accepts
the input with an arbitrary size which is more applicable for the real measurement
where the length of lost cannot be controlled. The architecture of the CNN is
bottleneck shaped. It utilized the advantage of Auto-Encoder [6] which automati-
cally extracts the higher-level features gradually from the input data meanwhile sifts
the noise by reducing the dimension of features in each layer. The compression of
input is realized by the compression layers and bottleneck layer illustrate as C1 to
C4 and Bottleneck in Fig. 1 and Table 1. The network then turns to reconstruct the
complete measurement using the extracted features from the incomplete input data
by the reconstruction layers (R4 to R1). The final layer (Final) conducts the con-
volution of the features from the R1 to extract the same level of features with the
input data and then reshape the feature to have the same dimension with input by
sub-pixel sampling. The target of the model is to minimize the discrepancy between
the recovered and the original measurement (the incomplete input data is simulated
using the original complete measurement) during the training process to fine-tuning
the parameters. Therefore, the objective function used here is the mean of the
L2-norm error of each training sample in a mini batch as follows
1X N
yk H/ ðxk Þ2
Loss ¼ 2
ð1Þ
N k¼1
where N is the number of samples in each mini batch. The CNN is simply depicted
as a nonlinear model H/ (x) that parameterized by /. The target of the training
process is to determine / by minimizing the loss function based on the entire
dataset. The activation function for transferring the linear mapping as nonlinear
mapping used in this study is Leaky Rectified Linear Unit (ReLU). Dropout
technique is used throughout all the layers to alleviate the effect of overfitting.
Using Deep Learning Technique for Recovering … 233
As shown in Fig. 1, the original output feature maps from the reconstruction layers
have the half length of the feature maps of the corresponding compression layer. To
keep those feature maps with a consistent size, the output feature maps from the
reconstruction layer are resized by a sub-pixel shuffling operation, which doubles
the length and half divides the number of feature maps. The shuffling operation is
implemented by splitting the feature maps as two groups and combining two feature
maps at the same order of each group as one by interpolating one to another.
2.4 Datasets
The datasets for training the network are generated from the previous complete
measurement. As mentioned in [1], the received data in the receiver of the base
station from the wireless sensors are in a time sequence, which means that the
locations of lost points in the time history is known. The wireless transmission lost
is simulated by setting a proportion of points as 0 in a random pattern corre-
sponding to the severity of data lost.
Experimental study is conducted with data measured form a long-term SHM system
of Dowling Hall Footbridge as shown in Fig. 2. The details of this bridge and the
installed SHM system can be found in [13]. The frequency of interest of this bridge
between 4 Hz and 14 Hz containing 6 vibrational modes as reported by [12].
Therefore, the measured data sampled at 128 Hz are pre-processed by a low-pass
filter with a cutoff frequency at 16 Hz and a downsampling process to lower the
sampling rate to 32 Hz. The data are then scaled to the range between −1 to 1 by
234 G. Fan et al.
dividing the maximum absolute value of the series, to improve the stability of
training the network. The pre-processing significantly reduces the size of datasets
and consequently increases the training efficiency. Meanwhile, the filtering of data
also eliminates the redundant information merged in the signals that exceeds the
frequency of interest.
The measurement of the 2nd channel of the SHM system is selected to validate
the proposed method. The first week acceleration data are processed for generating
the datasets. The SHM system record 5 min of data each hour and totally 14 h
acceleration data are recorded in the first week. The 14 h acceleration is processed
as paired simulated incomplete data and the original data, which are used as the
input and output of the CNN. The data loss in the incomplete data is simulated as
mentioned in Sect. 2.4 where a proportion of sampling points are randomly set as
zero. The datasets consist of original and incomplete data with the lost proportion
increased from 10% to 90% with a 20% step. Directly inputting a batch of 5 min
time series to train the CNN will take massive memory and cause a large com-
putational burden. Alternatively, the data are processed as small patches segmented
from the full time series of the acceleration data. A window with a length of 1024
points (32 s) is designed to produce the patches (samples) by scanning these 5
groups of data from the beginning to the end with a 50% overlap. The generated
patches are assembled as two datasets including 90% samples for training and 10%
samples for validation.
The testing data are 5 min-long acceleration measurement randomly selected
from the subsequent weeks. It processed as incomplete data with 10% to 90% data
loss with a 10% increase to test the performance of the trained network.
4 Performance Evaluation
The training samples are used as input to the CNN in batches and the whole datasets
are repeatedly used for 100 times to fine-tuning the parameters of CNN. A batch
contains 32 randomly selected samples from different times with varying lost
proportions. The computer used for training this network is built with a GTX1060
Graphics card with a 6 GB GPU, an i7-6700 K CPU and 8 GB memory. The
training process takes two hours and testing of the trained network is almost real
time. The comparison between the recovered signal originated from incomplete
data with 50% data loss and the original signal in both time domain and frequency
domain are shown in Fig. 3(a) and (b), respectively. The recovered signal almost
overlaps with the original signal in the time domain as shown in Fig. 3(a).
Meanwhile, the recovered signal is highly consistent with the original signal in the
frequency domain as shown in Fig. 3(b). Four well-excited modes between 4 Hz
and 10 Hz at the sensor location are accurately recovered on both the resonant
frequencies and amplitudes, indicating that the natural frequencies and mode shapes
of these four recovered vibrational modes are consistent with the original ones.
The errors with the increasing loss proportion are shown in Fig. 4. The error is
computed as
Pn 0 2
ky y 0 k 1 yi yi
n¼ ¼ Pn 2 ð2Þ
k yk 1 yi
where y and y’ are the original and the recovered signal. The errors become large
with the increase of the lost proportion and reaches 48% and 42% in the time and
frequency domain when using only 1/10 of the original points. The error as shown
in Fig. 4(b) is quantified and the error of signal in the frequency domain is 17%
when lost proportion reaches 50%. However, by observing Fig. 3(b), those errors
are mainly contributed by noise components distributed in the non-resonant fre-
quency bandwidths. This phenomenon confirms the previously mentioned advan-
tage of the bottlenecked structure where the noise components are eliminated in the
(a) (b)
Fig. 3 Comparison of original and recovered signals in a time domain and b frequency domain
236 G. Fan et al.
higher level of feature maps among the compression layers. The reconstructed
signals recovered using the high-level features have less noise effect. The recon-
struction error is much smaller if only the frequency bandwidths of the vibration
modes are considered.
60 50
Recovery error (%)
5 Conclusion
This paper proposes a SHM lost data recovery method based on the deep learning
technique. A fully CNN is designed which extracts the higher level of features from
the incomplete data and recover the original data using the extracted features. The
proposed method is validated by experimental studies with measured acceleration
data from Dowling Hall Footbridge. The recovered signal is highly consistent with
the original signal in both time and frequency domains, which demonstrate the
effectiveness and robustness of the proposed method on recovering the lost SHM
data.
References
Keywords Empirical wavelet transform Time-varying structure
Synchroextracting transform Instantaneous frequency Identification
1 Introduction
System identification for the structures with time-varying structural properties and
vibration characteristics has attracted a large amount of attention over the past
decades. Numerous methods have been reported and studied [1]. In general, the
existing methods can be classified into two categories: (1) Time-frequency analysis
techniques, i.e. Short-time Fourier transform (STFT), Wavelet transform (WT),
S-transform (ST) [3]; (2) The adaptively iteration algorithm, i.e. Least-square
algorithms, Kalman filtering methods [2].
2 Theoretical Background
sn ¼ c x n ð1Þ
xn þ 1 xn
0\c\minn ð2Þ
xn þ 1 þ xn
Using Novel Time Frequency Analysis Method … 241
The empirical scaling function and the empirical wavelets can be then defined as
follows:
8
> 1 if jxj ð1 cÞxn
< h i
;^n ðxÞ ¼ cos p
2b
1
ðjxj ð1 cÞxn Þ if ð1 cÞxn jxj ð1 þ cÞxn ð3Þ
>
:
2cxn
0 otherwise
8
> 1 if xn þ sn jxj xn þ 1 sn þ 1
>
> h i
>
>
< cos p2 b 2s 1 ðjxj xn þ 1 sn þ 1 Þ if xn þ 1 sn þ 1 jxj xn þ 1 þ sn þ 1
^ n ðxÞ ¼
W h
nþ1
i
>
> sin p2 b 2s1n ðjxj xn þ sn Þ if xn sn jxj xn þ sn
>
>
>
:
0 otherwise
ð4Þ
The filter bank of the empirical wavelets can be constructed by adopting Fourier
spectrum segment information into Eqs. (3) and (4). When ;^n ðxÞ and W ^ n ðxÞ are
derived, the detail coefficients can be calculated as
Z
Wx ðn; tÞ ¼ xðsÞWn ðs tÞds ¼ F 1 X ^ n ðxÞ
^ ðxÞW ð6Þ
Then, Eqs. (8) and (9) can be performed to extract the mono-components from
the target signal, which can be described as
in which Ai ðtÞ and xi ðtÞ denote the instantaneous amplitude and frequency of the
ith time-varying mode, respectively. The different components can be effectively
decomposed based on a sufficient frequency distance, i.e.,
where D represents the frequency support of the window function. The STFT
representation Ge ðt; xÞ of the target signal xðtÞ can be expressed as the following
first-order approximation [6].
XN R
xi ðtÞdt
Ge ðt; xÞ i¼1
Ai ðtÞ ^gðx xi ðtÞÞej ð13Þ
;Ti f ðtÞ
€qi ðtÞ þ 2h0i q_ i ðtÞ þ x20i qi ðtÞ ¼ ði ¼ 1; 2; . . .nÞ ð19Þ
Mi
where M i ¼ ;Ti M;i denotes the ith modal mass, ;i is the ith mode shape vector. The
natural frequency of the ith modal response is represented by x0i . When zero mean
Gaussian white noise is assumed as the external excitation of the system, the IF of
the ith modal response can be written as
h i
;Ti f ðtÞ ;Ti f ðtÞ
Mi q þ H Mi H ½ q
x2i ðtÞ ¼ x20i ðtÞ h i ð20Þ
q2 þ ð H ½ q Þ 2
where H denotes HT, and the second term of Eq. (20) is about a zero-mean fast
time-varying function. The natural frequency of the time-variant system can be
obtained from the identified IF of its analytical signal by filtering out the fast
varying component.
3 Numerical Studies
stiffness of the 2nd storey is set to be linearly reduced from 1.05 105 kN∙m to
244 Y. Xin et al.
0.7 105 kN∙m in a time duration between 4 s and 8 s. In this study, two cases are
conducted to verify the effectiveness and reliability of the proposed method. In Case
1, 1940 El Centro ground acceleration record is set as the external excitation of the
building model. The excitation of a Gaussian white noise process with zero mean and
a standard deviation of 0.1 g is considered in Case 2.
For these two cases, a 30 s displacement signal of the 1st floor is recorded as the
measured structural dynamic responses, and the sampling rate is set as 50 Hz. Since
the dynamic characteristics of the time-variant structure system under the external
excitations are previously unknown, SET approach is first employed to identify the
numbers and locations of filtering boundaries which will be used for EWT analysis.
As can be seen from Fig. 2, it is clearly observed that a frequency interval can be
defined between the IFs of these two time-varying frequency components. Thus, it
indicates that the boundaries of EWT approach can be accurately determined based
on SET. When the filtering boundaries are determined, EWT approach is applied to
extract the two time-varying mono-components from the structural dynamic
responses. The identified IF of these two cases by using Hilbert transform are
shown in Figs. 3(a) and (b). It can be observed from Fig. 3 that the identified
frequencies using Hilbert transform are strongly fluctuant by comparing with the
exact values. Then, the average value of these identified frequencies can be
obtained by filtering out the rapidly-varying frequency components. As shown in
Fig. 3, it can be observed that the average results can accurately denote the
time-varying frequency components of the building structure.
Using Novel Time Frequency Analysis Method … 245
(a) (b)
(a) (b)
Fig. 3 The detected instantaneous frequencies by using EWT-SET: (a) Case1; (b) Case 2
4 Conclusions
In this paper, EWT- SET method is developed for TVSI. Firstly, a non-stationary
vibration signal is analysed by using SET. Based on the analysis results of SET, the
corresponding filtering boundaries for EWT analysis can be determined. Then EWT
is performed to decompose the target signal into several mono-components using
the identified filtering boundaries. Once these mono-components are extracted from
the target signal, Hilbert transform is further conducted to extract the IF of each
mode.
References
1. Bao CX, Hao H, Li ZX, Zhu HP (2009) Time-varying system identification using a newly
improved HHT algorithm. Comput Struct 87(23–24):1611–1623
2. Yang JN, Huang HW (2007) Sequential non-linear least-squares estimation for damage
identification of structures with unknown inputs and unknown outputs. Int J Non-Linear Mech
42(5):789–801
246 Y. Xin et al.
3. Wang ZC, Ren WX, Chen GD (2018) Time-frequency analysis and applications in
time-varying nonlinear structural systems: a state-of-the-art review. Adv Struct Eng 21
(10):1562–1584
4. Daubechies I, Lu JF, Wu HT (2011) Synchrosqueezed wavelet transforms: an empirical mode
decomposition-like tool. Appl Comput Harmonic Anal. 30(2):243–261
5. Liu JL, Wang ZC, Ren WX, Li XX (2015) Structural time-varying damage detection using
Synchrosqueezing wavelet transform. Smart Struct Syst 15(1):119–133
6. Yu G, Yu MJ, Xu CY (2017) Synchroextracting transform. IEEE Trans Industr Electron 64
(10):8042–8054
7. Gilles J (2013) Empirical wavelet transform. IEEE Trans Signal Process 61(16):3999–4010
8. Xin Y, Hao H, Li J (2019) Operational modal identification of structures based on improved
empirical wavelet transform. Struct Control Health Monit 26:e2323
Advanced Applications of Emerging 2D
Nanomaterials in Construction
Materials
Keywords Construction materials 2D nanomaterials Smart sensing Structural
health monitoring Energy conservation
1 Introduction
exfoliation which can lead to high yield of the 2D materials [17]. It has been utilised to
fabricate 2D layered materials in solution for cement reinforcement [4, 23] and dip
coating for interface tailoring applications [27]. However, the drawbacks of this
method include affected crystal quality as well as poor layer number control of 2D
nanomaterials. Alternatively, the bottom-up synthesis of chemical vapour deposition
(CVD) demonstrates strong potential for industrial applications owing to its ability to
obtain large-area 2D materials. It has the merits of good crystal quality and good
control over the thickness, which is advantageous for the multifunctional applications
of 2D TMDs in construction industry [15]. Large-scale synthesis of atomically thin
MoS2 and WS2 via CVD have been reported by several groups [2, 5, 20]. However,
one of the critical issues that hinder the wide applications of these approaches is the
poor repeatability due to the extremely sensitive nature of CVD process.
To address this problem, we developed a one-step CVD strategy for the syn-
thesis of large-scale 2D MoS2 and WS2 single crystals, films and heterostructures in
ambient pressure. The schematic in Fig. 1a shows the setup of CVD process for
WS2 growth as an example. The precursor of sulphur at upstream was heated at 180
C into the vapour phase, which was brought to the centre of the furnace to react
with WO3 vapour at 860 °C for 5 min in an Ar environment. H2 was introduced to
assist in the reduction of WO3. The following fast cooling down procedure allows
the WS2 to epitaxy on the sapphire substrates to form large single crystals (Fig. 1b)
and uniform monolayer film (Fig. 1c). Via the patterning of pre-deposited graphene
films using photolithography, the centimetre-scale fabrication of graphene-WS2
heterostructures can be achieved where the WS2 nucleated at the edge of the
graphene and grew epitaxially in the bare regions between patterned graphene
stripes (Fig. 1d).
However, since the CVD reactions for 2D TMDs are highly sensitive to the
growth environment, it has been found that with the same growth parameters, the
growth procedure yielded crystals and films with smaller size and increased
thickness after the reaction quartz tube and crucibles have been used for multiple
growth procedures. The intermediate growth products of (Mo, W)O3-x have been
identified as the governing factor for the controllable and repeatable seeding and
epitaxy, which is crucial for the size and crystal quality of the grown 2D TMDs.
We have found that the contamination of (Mo, W)O3-x can be removed via a
simple and industrially scalable acid clean process where the quartz tube and
crucibles were sequentially cleaned by hydrochloric acid (HCl), sulfuric acid
(H2SO4), and aqua regia [a mixture of nitric acid (HNO3) and HCl in 1:3 molar
ratio], followed by an oxygen cleaning at 1050 °C to remove the residual acids.
Thus, via the stabilisation of the growth environment by acid cleaning and the
optimisation of critical parameters of temperatures, annealing duration and gas flow
rate in the CVD process, controllable and repeatable synthesis of the 2D materials
in centimetre scale are achieved for the first time towards potential industrial pro-
ductions with high quality, high yield and low cost.
CVD process usually requires specific types of substrates such as sapphire owing to
the requirement of the surface energy and rigidity of the substrates. Thus, a versatile
transfer method to transfer the as-grown 2D nanomaterials to a broad range of
substrates in a clean and non-defective manner is crucial for realising the novel
functionalities of these ultrathin nanosheets in practice.
Currently the most widely used transfer methods for 2D nanomaterials are
polymer-assisted wet transfer techniques where a spin-coated thin polymer film
such as poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) or polystyrene (PS) acts as the sup-
porting layer for the transfer of the 2D materials [8, 25]. However, the delamination
of 2D nanomaterials from the original substrate using PMMA usually require
etching using an alkaline solution, which causes damage to the 2D layers.
Moreover, the removal of the polymer supporting layers after transfer suffers from
problems of contamination from polymer residue that affect the intrinsic properties
of the 2D materials and tearing of the transferred 2D materials due to solvent
stripping.
To address these issues, we developed a novel transfer strategy named volatile
polymer stamp (VPS) for large-scale transfer and assembly of 2D nanomaterials in
an etch-free and ultraclean manner by employing a volatile polymer of polyph-
thalaldehyde (PPA) together with PS. Due to the relatively high rigidity of PS and
the hydrophobic surface of PPA, the 2D layers can be delaminated from the growth
substrate by the surface tension of a DI water droplet. After depositing on the target
substrate, a unique two-step polymer removal process was adopted where the PS is
firstly washed off by soaking in toluene, followed by the thorough removal of the
Advanced Applications of Emerging 2D Nanomaterials … 251
remaining PPA layer by thermal annealing at *180 °C. By introducing PPA as the
contact polymer layer with the 2D nanomaterials which can protect the 2D layers
from solvents and polymer residue, ultraclean transfer results can be achieved in an
ultrafast and etch-free manner.
This novel transfer technique has demonstrated the ability to transfer 2D
nanomaterials with excellent surface cleanness as well as exceptional optical and
electrical properties, fabrication of van der Waals heterostructures with
contamination-free interfaces by simple stacking, showing the great potential of
fabricating high-performance devices such as sensors and solar cells to be applied
in the construction industry.
(Fig. 2d). These results indicate that for 2D TMD materials to be employed in
stretchable electronics and strain sensors, a linear relationship between optical
spectral shift to tensile strain only applies when the tensile strain is small. Beyond a
critical strain value, a new relationship must be established for correct strain
indication taking wrinkle formation into consideration.
Furthermore, we found that the wrinkle distribution was dramatically different
when the angle between an edge of the triangular WS2 crystal and the direction of
substrate elongation changes. While the wrinkles were distributed uniformly across
the triangular WS2 crystal with an edge parallel to the tensile direction, localised
wrinkles were formed within the crystal with an edge perpendicular to the tensile
direction. These observations were explained by the FE simulations which indicated
that the pattern of wrinkling reflects the pattern of strain distribution within each
crystal (Fig. 3). Thus, the conclusion can be drawn that triangular TMD crystals
with one edge oriented parallel to the tensile strain direction are preferred for
straintronics due to more uniform strain distribution. These results benefit the
understanding of the mechanical properties of TMD crystals and shed light on the
design of high-quality straintronics and flexible electronics.
Fig. 3 FE simulation of WS2 under tensile strain. a–d FE model and simulation results of WS2/
PDMS sample under tensile strain with one edge of WS2 oriented parallel to the strain direction. e–
h FE model and simulation results of WS2/PDMS sample under tensile strain with one edge of
WS2 oriented perpendicular to the strain direction [28]
The 2D TMDs also attract significant interest as they have the ability to be applied
in a broad range of energy applications such as solar energy harvesting [16, 19],
catalysis for water splitting and hydrogen evolution reaction [7, 26], energy gen-
erator [24] and energy storage [18, 22].
Owing to the unique features of nearly transparent and lightweight and a direct
bandgap at the infrared range, 2D TMD can be integrated into smart windows for
green buildings. The smart window is an advanced glazing technology developed in
recent years based on phase changing materials such as thermochromic VO2 which
can regulate the solar heat influx in response to temperature variation while
maintaining the visible light transmittance [30]. It has been demonstrated that
monolayer TMDs has the potential to form p-n junctions with the VO2 thin film, as
shown in the band alignment plots in Fig. 4a [11]. Thus, a transparent solar cell
device is proposed via the van der Waals heterostructure formation of VO2 and
monolayer TMDs, with graphene serving as low contact resistance electrodes, as
shown in Fig. 4b. The demonstrated photovoltaic effect of the transparent 2D TMD/
VO2 offers promising possibilities of incorporating solar harvesting techniques into
smart window applications for high energy efficient green buildings.
254 Q. Zhang et al.
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the support from Australian Research Council
(ARC).
References
1. Choi W, Choudhary N, Han GH, Park J, Akinwande D, Lee YH (2017) Recent development
of two-dimensional transition metal dichalcogenides and their applications. Mater Today 20
(3):116–130
2. Cong C, Shang J, Wu X, Cao B, Peimyoo N, Qiu C, Sun L, Yu T (2014) Synthesis and
Optical Properties of Large-Area Single-Crystalline 2D Semiconductor WS2 Monolayer from
Chemical Vapor Deposition. Adv Opt Mater 2(2):131–136
3. Conley HJ, Wang B, Ziegler JI, Haglund RF Jr, Pantelides ST, Bolotin KI (2013) Bandgap
engineering of strained monolayer and bilayer MoS2. Nano Lett 13(8):3626–3630
4. Gong K, Pan Z, Korayem AH, Qiu L, Li D, Collins F, Wang CM, Duan WH (2014)
Reinforcing effects of graphene oxide on Portland cement paste. J Mater Civ Eng 27(2):
A4014010
5. Kang K, Xie S, Huang L, Han Y, Huang PY, Mak KF, Kim C-J, Muller D, Park J (2015)
High-mobility three-atom-thick semiconducting films with wafer-scale homogeneity. Nature
520(7549):656
6. Li H, Shi Y, Chiu M-H, Li L-J (2015) Emerging energy applications of two-dimensional
layered transition metal dichalcogenides. Nano Energy 18:293–305
Advanced Applications of Emerging 2D Nanomaterials … 255
27. Yao X, Shamsaei E, Chen S, Zhang QH, de Souza FB, Sagoe-Crentsil K, Duan W (2019)
Graphene oxide-coated Poly (vinyl alcohol) fibers for enhanced fiber-reinforced cementitious
composites. Compos Part B: Eng 174:107010
28. Zhang Q, Chang Z, Xu G, Wang Z, Zhang Y, Xu ZQ, Chen S, Bao Q, Liu JZ, Mai YW
(2016) Strain relaxation of monolayer WS2 on plastic substrate. Adv Func Mater 26
(47):8707–8714
29. Zhang Q, Lu J, Wang Z, Dai Z, Zhang Y, Huang F, Bao Q, Duan W, Fuhrer MS, Zheng C
(2018) Reliable synthesis of large-area monolayer WS2 single crystals, films, and
heterostructures with extraordinary photoluminescence induced by water intercalation. Adv
Opt Mater 6(12):1701347
30. Zhou J, Gao Y, Zhang Z, Luo H, Cao C, Chen Z, Dai L, Liu X (2013) VO2 thermochromic
smart window for energy savings and generation. Sci Rep 3:3029
Single Shot MultiBox Detector Based
Active Monitoring for Anti-collision
Between Vessels and Bridges
1 Introduction
Maintenance of civil infrastructure has become critical with the social development
[7, 8]. We propose a technical framework of the active monitoring system for
anti-collision between vessel and bridge based on deep-learning object detection
and the detection module of it is discussed in detail [4, 5, 6]. In comparison with the
existing systems using motion based method, the utilization of deep-learning based
object detection method gives it more stability and intelligence in dealing with
complicated and changeable situation [1, 3].
2 Framework
There are several particularities and difficulties of navigational object detection task,
including complicated and changeable environment, variety of appearance,
expansive monitoring area and rendezvous and overlap among targets [2].
Single shot multibox detector is one of the most advanced deep-learning object
detection methods. It integrates feature extraction, box regression and classification
into a one-stage convolutional network and has higher operation speed for heavy
work of wide-area monitoring. Thus SSD is chose as the basic model of naviga-
tional object detection modules (see Fig. 2).
The overall training object loss function of SSD is a weighted sum of the
localization loss and the confidence loss:
1
Lðx; c; l; gÞ ¼ Lconf ðx; cÞ þ aLloc ðx; l; gÞ ð1Þ
N
where N is the number of matched default boxes and the loss would be 0 if N = 0,
and the weight term a is set to 1. The confidence loss is a softmax loss over multiple
classes confidences:
XN X
Lconf ðx; cÞ ¼ xp logð^cpi Þ
i2Pos ij i2Neg
log ^c0i ð2Þ
expðcpi Þ
^cpi ¼ P p ð3Þ
p expðci Þ
where xpij ¼ f1; 0g is the indicator for matching the i-th default box to the j-th
ground truth box of category p and the category 0 is background. The localization
loss is a Smooth L1 loss between the predicted box (l) and the ground truth box
(g) parameters. The localization parameters of the predicted box are expressed as
the relative offsets to the default bounding box (d).
3.2 Dataset
where H and W are the height and width of the image, h and w are the height and
width of the object bounding. It is indicated that SSD applicable to object with a k
at 0.1 to 1 and the detection accuracy decreases with falling k, while the scale
parameters of many vessels in practical surveillance pictures are much smaller than
0.1. The SSD architecture contributes to its limited capability dealing with small
object.
4 Contrast
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements This paper is supported by the National Key R&D Program of China
(2018YFC0809606), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (51978508), the Science
and Technology Commission of Shanghai Municipality (17DZ1204301), and the Fundamental
Research Funds for the Central Universities.
References
1. Dalal N, Triggs B (2005) Histograms of oriented gradients for human detection. In: IEEE
computer society conference on computer vision and pattern recognition (CVPR 2005). IEEE,
San Diego, pp 886–893
2. Girshick R (2015) Fast R-CNN. In: 2015 IEEE international conference on computer vision
(ICCV 2015). IEEE, Santiago, pp 1440–1448
3. Jian XD, Xia Y, Lozano-Galant JA, Sun LM (2019) Traffic sensing methodology combining
influence line theory and computer vision techniques for girder bridges. J Sens 2019:15.
3409525
4. Liu W et al (2016) SSD: single shot MultiBox detector. In: Proceedings of the 14th european
conference on computer vision, ECCV, pp 21–37
5. Redmon J et al (2016) You only look once: unified, real-time object detection. In: 2016 IEEE
conference on computer vision and pattern recognition (CVPR 2016). IEEE, Las Vegas,
pp 779–788
6. Ren S et al (2017) Faster R-CNN: towards real-time object detection with region proposal
networks. IEEE Trans Pattern Anal Mach Intell 39(6):1137–1149
7. Xia Y, Nassif HH, Dan S (2017) Early-age cracking in high performance concrete decks of
typical curved steel girder bridges. J Aerosp Eng 30(2):B4016003
8. Xia Y, Wang P, Sun LM (2019) Neutral axis position based health monitoring and condition
assessment techniques for concrete box girder bridges. Int J Struct Stab Dyn 19(1):1940015
Advances in Structural Engineering
Composites for Alternative Railway
Sleepers
Abstract Approximately 200 million timber sleepers are currently being used in
rail networks around the world due to their availability, affordability and depend-
ability. It is estimated that nearly 90% of the existing timber sleepers will need
replacement by 2030. Recently, increasing costs, declining quality, hardwood
timber scarcity and environmental sensitivity has challenged the continuing use of
timber sleepers in rail track. Consequently, the Australian rail industry is now
looking an alternative materials to replace existing timber sleepers and it is pro-
jected that in next five years they will move from a traditional timber-based system
(15 years lifespan) to that of an engineered composites system (at least 50 years
lifespan). This paper critically reviewed the recent development of composite
sleepers, identified the potential issues and provided guidelines to overcome the
challenges.
1 Introduction
Australia has the sixth largest rail network in the world and traditionally timber
sleepers have been used due to their low cost, availability, ease of handling and
fittings, excellent resistance to shocks and vibrations, and good electrical resistance.
Recently, rising costs, declining quality, hardwood timber scarcity and environ-
mental sensitivity has challenged the continuing use of timber sleepers in rail track.
Currently 200 million timber sleepers are laid in Australian rail networks that are
worth over $1.3 billion per year. It is estimated that nearly 90% of these existing
timber sleepers will need replacement by 2030. Due to this, the Australian rail
industry is now looking alternative materials to replace existing timber sleepers.
Polymer composite sleeper technologies have emerged as a potential alternative
to timber sleepers. Different from steel and concrete, composite sleepers can be
designed to mimic timber behaviour (an essential requirement for timber track
maintenance), are almost maintenance free, and are more sustainable from an
environmental perspective. Despite the many advantages of composite sleepers,
they have gained a very limited acceptance by rail industry to date. Polymer
sleepers manufactured from recycled plastic materials are low cost but they have
limited strength, stiffness and dynamic properties which in most cases, are
incompatible with those of timber. Moreover, the prohibitive cost of fibre con-
taining polymer sleepers’ limit their widespread application.
This paper provides an overview of recent developments of composite railway
sleepers and their limitations, and suggests a solution which overcomes the chal-
lenges inherent in their utilisation and acceptance. The outcome of this paper will
benefit sleeper design engineers in rail industry to understand the current challenges
and possible solutions.
2 Recent Developments
Sleepers that consist of recycled plastic (plastic bags, scrapped vehicle tyres, plastic
coffee cups, milk jugs, laundry detergent bottles etc.) or bitumen with fillers (sand,
gravel, recycled glass or short glass fibres <20 mm) falls under the category. The
load coming to the sleeper is mainly carried by the polymer. While some of these
technologies introduced short glass fibre to increase the stiffness and/or resist crack,
they do not have major reinforcing effect to improve the structural performance
required for heavy duty railway sleeper application. The high demand for alter-
native sleeper materials has resulted in some railway maintenance companies to
adopt and trial the usage of these materials. As a sleeper material, no/short fibre
sleepers offer a range of benefits including the ease of drill and cut, good durability,
consumption of waste materials, reasonable price, and toughness. The notable
sleepers in this category are TieTek [1, 35], Axion [3, 28], IntegriCo [5, 20], I-Plas
[6, 32], Tufflex [7, 36], Natural rubber [8, 31], Kunststof Lankhorst Product
(KLP) [24, 26], Mixed Plastic Waste (MPW) [19] and Wood-core [38] are shown in
Fig. 1.
Fig. 1 No or short fibre reinforced recycled plastic sleepers (References given in the text)
270 W. Ferdous et al.
In this category, the sleeper technologies are reinforced with long continuous glass
fibre reinforcement in the longitudinal direction and no or very short random fibre
in the transverse direction. The strength and stiffness in the longitudinal direction is
primarily governed by long glass fibre while it is dominated by polymer in the
transverse direction. These sleepers are primarily suitable for ballasted rail track
where the stresses in sleepers are governed by flexural loading. Although some of
these sleepers have been installed in bridge applications but the major concern is
their limited shear capacity that makes them less than ideal where the sleepers are
subjected to high level of combined flexural and shear forces. Easy to drill and cut,
good durability, superior flexural strength and modulus of elasticity are the
advantages of the sleeper in this category. The FFU (Fibre-reinforced Foamed
Urethane) synthetic sleeper [17, 22, 34] is classified in this sleeper category. The
key features of this material include its light weight, good resistance to water
absorption, heat and corrosion, its ease of drilling, and its more than 50 years of
design life. FFU material has been used in railway industry as plain-track sleepers,
bridge transoms, and turnout bearers with a wide range of sleeper height from
100 mm to 450 mm. This material has been installed (Fig. 2) in more than
1300 km of track (approximately 2 million sleepers) with its main application in
turnouts, open steel girder structures and tunnels. Apart from Japan, Sekisui FFU
components have been installed in Germany, Austria, Taiwan, Netherland, USA
and Australia. In 2010, the aged timber sleepers at Hornsby, NSW, Australia was
renewed using FFU alternative sleepers [23]. Their applicability is also now
investigated for a long span rail bridge in Chongqing city, China [27].
(a) FFU sleepers in track (b) dust may produce in cutting and drilling
Polymer sleepers have been developed with long reinforcement fibres in both
longitudinal and transverse directions and consequently both the flexural and shear
behaviour are dominated by fibres. The structural performance of this sleeper can be
engineered through the adjustment of the fibre reinforcements in each direction
according to the specified performance requirements. The sandwich polymer
sleeper (Fig. 3) [29, 37] and the hybrid composite [14] sleeper wherein fibres are
oriented in the two directions to resist flexural stresses as well as shear forces falls
under this category. The author published a series of research work towards the
development of this innovative composite sleeper technology [9–16].
Table 1 compared the performance of different fibre composite sleeper tech-
nologies with the traditional timber sleepers specified by American Railway
Engineering and Maintenance-of-Way Association (AREMA) standard. It can be
seen that the modulus of elasticity and modulus of rupture of no/short fibre com-
posite sleepers are significantly lower than the softwood sleepers. The
unidirectional fibre reinforced sleeper can meet the performance requirements and
the multidirectional one further improved the shear capacity. The negative
impression of heavy weight of prestressed concrete sleeper can be solved using
composite technology. However, there are few challenges of these sleepers that
need to overcome before their widespread applications.
The composite sleeper technologies have been developed to replace existing timber
sleepers, therefore, the strength and stiffness of composite sleepers are expected to
be similar to timber. Table 1 indicated that the strength and stiffness of no/short
fibre sleepers (17.2–20.6 MPa and 1.5–1.8 GPa) are significantly lower than the
softwood timber (49.3 MPa and 7.4 GPa). One approach to improve the strength
and stiffness of this type of sleeper is to reinforce them either with long fibres or
Composites for Alternative Railway Sleepers 273
steel bars. However, the strength and stiffness of unidirectional and multidirectional
fibre sleepers are comparable to timber. The high shear strength of multidirectional
fibre sleepers makes them ideal for bridge application.
3.2 Drillability
The polymer sleeper should be designed in such a way so that can be drilled easily
and quickly, while it should possess high pull out resistance at the same time.
A hardwood timber sleeper has a screw-spike resistance of 40 kN [4, 22] and it
requires approximately 10 s to drill using standard drilling equipment. The drilling
of no/short fibre sleeper (recycled plastic) could be easier than the other available
polymer sleepers, however, the loosening of a fastener over time could be an issue
due to the nature of plastic materials that cannot grip the screw firmly like concrete,
especially under dynamic loading conditions. The dust produced during cutting and
drilling of unidirectional fibre sleeper (Fig. 2b) may require a protective dust mask
which is uncomfortable to the workers on site. The polymer concrete sleeper [15]
offers superior screw withdrawal resistance but it takes longer time to drill com-
paring with the other two. To make the drilling faster, the materials at the rail seat
region of polymer sleeper could be modified. Moreover, the pre-drilling of railway
sleepers on one or two sides may reduce the on-site installation time.
Van Erp and Mckay [37] indicated that the price of high fibre containing composite
sleeper technologies (unidirectional and multidirectional fibre sleeper) is approxi-
mately 5 to 10 times higher than that of a standard timber sleeper. On the other
hand, the Recycled Technologies International (RTI) stated that the costs of no/
short fibre reinforced sleeper range from 85 to 105 USD per sleeper, a price not
including installation which represents a significant value and can range from 70 to
200 USD per sleeper [30]. However, the lower life cycle cost is anticipated to offset
its high initial cost [3, 20, 30] which to attract the attention of the rail industry,
needs to be similar to, or insignificantly higher than, that of traditional ones.
Similarly, optimising the manufacturing process and material usage would result in
a more cost competitive sleeper.
A complete design guideline for composite railway sleeper has not been established
yet. However, standard provisions containing specifications for alternative sleepers
274 W. Ferdous et al.
are provided by the Queensland Rail [18] in Australia, and American Railway
Engineering and Maintenance-of-way Association (AREMA) in the USA [2].
International Organization for Standardisation (ISO) published material character-
isation guidelines for plastic railway sleepers in ISO 12856-1 document [21]. In
Australia, currently the Rail Industry Safety and Standards Board (RISSB) is
developing a new Specification for Alternative Material Sleepers—Timber
Replacement (Standard) [33]. Once completed, this standard is expected to provide
the performance-based requirements to allow rail infrastructure managers (RIMS)
to select appropriate alternative material sleepers.
4 Conclusions
References
1. Anne, Evans R (2006) Rubber/plastic composite rail sleepers. The waste & resources action
programme, UK
2. AREMA (2013) Manual for railway engineering, Chapter 30: Ties. American Railway
Engineering and Maintenance-of-way Association, USA
Composites for Alternative Railway Sleepers 275
29. Manalo AC, Aravinthan T (2012) Behaviour of full-scale railway turnout sleepers from
glue-laminated fibre composite sandwich structures. J Compos Constr 16:724–736
30. McConnell VP (2008) Rail – an evolving market for FRP components. In: Reinforced
plastics, pp 24–29
31. Pattamaprom C, Dechojarassri D, Sirisinha C, Kanok-Nukulchai W (2005) Natural rubber
composites for railway sleepers: a feasibility study
32. PRS £100 m deal to supply plastic railway sleepers. www.railwaysleepers.com. Accessed 13
Aug 2014
33. RISSB (2018) Call for development group members – specification for alternative material
sleepers – timber replacement (standard). The Rail Industry Safety and Standards Board
(RISSB)
34. Takai H, Sato Y, Sato K (2006) Japanese twenty five years experiences and standardization of
synthetic sleeper
35. TieTek Increase productive track time and reduce costs with TieTek™ composite ties. www.
tietek.net. Accessed 07 Aug 2014
36. Tufflex Plastic polymer & intrusion products. Tufflex Plastic Products Pty. Ltd. www.tufflex.
co.za. Accessed 12 Aug 2014
37. Van Erp G, Mckay M (2013) Recent Australian developments in fibre composite railway
sleepers. Electron J Struct Eng 13:62–66
38. Wood-core Plastic composite wood core railroad ties 270lbs near indestructible,
Southwest RV and Marine. www.swrvandmarine.com. Accessed 12 Aug 2014
Modal Analysis Experiments
on Prestressed Concrete Sleepers
1 Introduction
Sleepers are a critical component of the track infrastructure and are essential to safe
train operations. Concrete sleepers are becoming the most common sleeper types
found in mixed traffic rail networks due to their long life, excellent reliability, high
track stability and ease of resurfacing using track machines.
Many concrete sleepers have been in-track and successfully operating for over
40 years in heavy haul traffic conditions and their current performance indicates
that they will last much longer than the predicted design life expectation of at least
50 years. As the minimum expected service life is fast approaching, it has prompted
questions about how long concrete sleepers might last and what will be the early
signs of failure.
Sleeper life has a significant implication on future replacement budget planning.
The Australian railway network contains over 30 million concrete sleepers, with a
replacement value over AU$18B. Equally important is an understanding of whether
they will fail sporadically (at different times) or relatively uniformly (over a few
years), presenting different budget needs and operational risks.
Identifying faulty sleepers before they fail will have a significant impact on any
railway business in the future. Concrete sleeper condition assessment is visual and
usually limited to the top of the sleeper. Assignment of sleeper condition category is
predominately based on surface cracking and fastener condition. Currently,
Australian concrete sleeper failures causing derailments and train delays are very
rare. This is expected as all Australian concrete sleepers having been operating
within their design life. However, as sleepers continue to age and deteriorate, early
detection of defective sleepers will become increasingly important.
This research explores existing concrete analysis methods with the aim of
selecting an appropriate in-service assessment approach to identify concrete
sleepers that are nearing the end of their service life. It is envisaged that the
proposed testing methodology will provide additional information to support effi-
cient asset management of track components. Furthermore, this research is the first
to collect long-term compliance and analysis data from multiple Australian sleeper
manufacturers.
Concrete sleepers play an essential role in responding to the varying dynamic
loads which are generated at the rail/wheel interface. Existing studies of dynamic
rail impact include a focus on elements such as natural frequencies, modal shapes,
damping characteristics, failure modes, residual strength and energy absorption
[12]. The imparted energy is transmitted through the rails and rail pads (where
present) before it is absorbed by the sleeper through means of vibration, defor-
mation and fracture. In one particular study conducted in soft track conditions
(typical track modulus of 10–20 MPa) by Kaewunruen and Remennikov [4], it was
noted that approximately 45% of the energy was absorbed as bending and fracture
while the remainder was dissipated through wheel damage, rail pad wear, sleeper
crack acceleration and the breakdown of ballast material.
Modal Analysis Experiments on Prestressed Concrete Sleepers 279
It has been noted that defects in the rails, wheels, and supporting structures can
all contribute to the imposition of dynamic loads as high as 750 kN [9].
Unsurprisingly, train velocity has been shown through many studies to be a
dominating factor in dynamic load generation and the ratio of rail-seat load to wheel
load has appeared to have a linear relation to wheel speed [1, 8, 10].
Modal analysis is a desirable means of structural testing due to its
non-destructive nature and relatively low cost. A potential application of this
technology is to identify the mode shapes of in situ concrete sleepers at natural
frequencies and then correlate with existing data to speculate on the in-service
condition of the test sample. The assessment would require an understanding of
dynamical sensitivity and stochastic analysis [3].
Existing studies have used modal analysis to measure the dynamic response in
Australian concrete sleeper specimens [1, 8]. In a previous lab test by Remennikov
and Kaewunruen [8], four different sleepers were surrounded by ballast to replicate
an actual track condition. Two different boundary conditions were tested: free-free
and in situ. The free-free boundary condition was provided by hanging the sleeper
with soft springs. The in situ boundary conditions were provided by placing the
sleeper into a box of ballast.
An impact hammer was used to excite vibrations at different points on the
sleeper [8] and accelerometers were installed to measure the structural response due
to hammer blows. The frequency response functions (FRF) were obtained using a
pulse vibration analyser. The recorded FRFs were analysed to identify natural
frequencies and corresponding mode shapes. The impact hammer provided sleepers
with excitations in the range of 0 to 1600 Hz. Five different vibration modes were
detected at different frequencies for both the free-free and in situ boundary con-
ditions as follows:
• First frequency represents the lowest frequency corresponding to the funda-
mental bending mode.
• Second frequency represents the second bending mode.
• Third frequency represents the lowest torsional mode.
• Fourth frequency represents the third bending mode.
• Fifth frequency represents the second torsional mode.
One study performed by Sadeghi [11] measured the impact hammer excitations
at 26 points equally spaced along the sleeper. Two accelerometers were installed at
the middle and near one end of the sleeper. The data from both the accelerometer
and hammer were amplified and transferred to the Fast Fourier Analyser (FFA). The
following observations were made:
• The installation of a rail pad showed a slight reduction in the natural frequency
of the sleeper.
• Compacted ballast contributed to considerably higher responses than specimens
tested on a bed of degraded material.
• Mode shapes from specimens with rail pads showed less bending in lower
modes and greater torsion in higher modes.
280 D. Nielsen and E. Palmer
The rail industry recognises vibration and noise from wheels on rail to be
destructive and problematic [12]. The ability of rail components to attenuate this
form of energy is quantified as a damping ratio. The addition of rail pads between
the rail-sleeper interface was a direct effort to increase the system damping prop-
erties, but many studies have concluded that their overall effectiveness on low
frequency, high magnitude impacts is insignificant [11].
2 Experimental Overview
2.1 Aim
The study aims to analyse the dynamic responses of concrete sleepers with the
intent of finding a quick method of evaluating the effectiveness of in situ concrete
sleepers. The study builds on previous research to identify changes in dynamic
responses from sleepers in various states of deterioration and in various support
conditions.
Each sleeper was assessed using vibration analysis with vibrations originating from
an impact hammer. The mass of the hammer is 1.34 kg and the height of drop was
0.217 m. The impact was applied at different locations on the sleeper and a
piezoelectric microphone and accelerometer recorded the resulting wave form from
one end of the sleeper. Sleepers were tested in a range of supporting conditions
including on timber, attached to rail and on ground without ballast, and in an
operating track environment with rail and ballast.
The vibration waveform was captured and the Fast Fourier Transform
(FFT) applied using Matlab to determine the natural frequencies. In particular, a
section containing the vibration waveform was taken from the recorded waveform
for each impact. An FFT was then taken of the rectangular windowed data and a
periodogram formed from the square of the FFT magnitude [5]. Three experiments
were conducted using this approach.
2.3.1 Experiment 1
Using three healthy control sleepers, a control periodogram was formed as the
average of the periodograms of the individual sleepers. Concrete sleeper design is
symmetrical, and this experiment confirms symmetry with modal responses. The
test that exhibits the richest frequency responses would be selected for all further
tests. Four symmetry tests were conducted:
Test A: striking the sleeper in the centre with the sensor on the left-hand end,
Test B: striking the sleeper in the centre with the sensor on the right-hand end,
Test C: striking the sleeper on the right-hand end with the sensor on the left-hand
end of the sleeper,
Test D: striking the sleeper on the left-hand end with the sensor on the right-hand
end of the sleeper.
2.3.2 Experiment 2
2.3.3 Experiment 3
3.1 Experiment 1
The comparative results of three healthy ‘control’ sleeper FFT analyses shows a
consistency in modal frequency in the spectra and with tests C and D displaying the
richest spectra, as shown in Fig. 1. This experiment showed that the locations of the
sensor and impact can be conducted from either end of the sleeper, resulting in the
same frequency response, albeit with different magnitudes. Based on the richer
spectra response from tests C and D, it was decided to use these tests to compare the
results for the remaining sleepers.
3.2 Experiment 2
The comparative analysis has shown that every frequency response is increased
by approximately 197 Hz. This result aligns with existing knowledge on increasing
frequency responses from shorter lengths.
3.3 Experiment 3
The sleepers tested in Experiment 3 had a different gauge, axle load and design
from Experiment 2. Therefore, a different frequency was needed for comparative
analysis.
Dynamic response results obtained from an FFT analysis of in situ sleepers
identified that natural frequencies were clearly identifiable and suitable for use in a
comparative analysis. However, the damping increases when sleepers are in situ
with rail attached and surrounded by ballast.
Modal Analysis Experiments on Prestressed Concrete Sleepers 285
Damping was not measured in this experiment. Damping changes can also
provide insight into changes in sleeper dynamics. Variations in damping require the
employment of other methods such as the Chirp Z transform [7] or Prony’s method
[2, 6]. Further work will be directed along these lines.
The results of dynamic response analysis of three in situ sleepers are shown in
Fig. 4(a) to (c). It is seen that the in situ sleepers can be characterised by strong
modal signatures. The damping effect is evidenced by the lower magnitudes based
on the modal signatures. It may be possible to determine the nature of the foun-
dations or ballast condition on which they are sitting. The different sleeper
responses could be due to the different ballast support conditions or rail/sleeper
connection, highlighting that further work is needed in this area.
A dynamic response test of a sleeper supported on timber (without rails attached)
is shown in Fig. 5(a) and a similar sleeper placed on soft loamy soil with two rails
attached (including rail pads) is shown in Fig. 5(b). A comparison of response
modes shows that the sleeper placed on soft loamy soil (with rails attached) has
significant damping of the response frequencies and identifying frequency shifts
would be difficult.
286 D. Nielsen and E. Palmer
4 Conclusion
This research has shown that prestressed concrete sleepers have a symmetrical
design and the location of impact and sensor are also symmetric and produce the
same dynamic response frequencies.
A frequency shift was observed on prestressed concrete sleepers with lower
concrete compressive strengths. The frequency shift was larger at the higher fre-
quencies and smaller at the lower frequencies. A correlation coefficient of 0.918
was recorded between the frequency shift and compressive concrete strength.
Lower compressive strengths resulted in a comparatively lower frequency response.
Concrete sleepers broken under the rail seat exhibited a uniform frequency shift
on all modes. The reduced length of the sleeper resulted in a frequency increase
which supports existing mathematical equations based on frequency responses and
beam lengths.
Sleepers with rails attached and placed on soft loamy soils exhibit significant
damping of all spectra, which will make it difficult to determine sleeper condition.
However, the sleeper damping can be measured and may lead to advancements in
ballast condition monitoring. Furthermore, it was shown that in situ sleepers exhibit
characteristic spectral signatures which may lend themselves to better diagnosis of
sleeper and ballast condition.
With additional research, there is potential for non-destructive, in situ sleeper
testing and ballast condition assessment. The successful outcome of this research
has the potential for commercial implementation. Further research investigating
changes in damping as well as modal frequency changes is on-going. This will
further assist in the identification and categorisation of defective sleepers and
sleeper support conditions.
Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the support of the Australasian Centre for Rail
Innovation (ACRI) for funding this research project, Project HH#19: Developing methodology for
concrete sleeper life prediction. The authors also acknowledge the support of the Centre for
Railway Engineering at Central Queensland University and the industry partners that have con-
tributed to this project.
References
1. Ahlbeck DR, Hadden JA (1985) Measurement and prediction of impact loads from worn
railroad wheel and rail surface profiles. J Eng Ind 107:197–205
2. Hauer JF (1991) Application of Prony analysis to the determination of modal content and
equivalent models for measured power system response. IEEE Trans Power Syst 6:1062–
1068
3. Kaewunruen S, Remennikov AM (2009) Trends in vibration-based structural health
monitoring of railway sleepers. In: SAPRI RC (ed) Mechanical vibrations: measurement,
effects and control. Nova Science Publishers, Inc
Modal Analysis Experiments on Prestressed Concrete Sleepers 287
1 Introduction
The track lateral stability is defined as the track ability to resist lateral loads to keep
the track geometry within safe limits. This parameter controls two important track
structural problems including the track lateral misalignment and track buckling.
Track lateral misalignment can be generated due to lateral dynamic excitations from
train wheels, temperature variations or the seismic events. For example, earthquakes
can cause significant structural damages to railway tracks through permanent lateral
displacements. In 2010 Canterbury earthquake in New Zealand, the track lateral
displacement varied from minor to meters off from its original position. Usually the
rails were still fastened to the sleepers while shifting laterally.
The resistance of track to lateral loads or excitations is affected by a combination
of different factors. This phenomenon has been studied by many researchers either
through field or lab experiments or through finite element simulations such as those
reported in Zand and Moraal [8], Kabo [3], Kish [5], Zakeri et al. [7], Arbabi and
Khalighi [1], Koike et al. [6]. The majority of the studies reported in the literature
deal with the local stability with focus on parameters such as the sleeper shape,
sleeper/ballast friction, and ballast properties (mainly from geotechnical aspects).
However, very limited results are reported where the global lateral stability is
examined where the effect of other track design parameters such as the rail type
(flexural rigidity) or sleeper material (rigidity) or sleeper spacing are compared or
discussed.
Therefore, in this study, a structural model of railway track with the length of
20 m is developed where the rail and sleepers are modelled as steel and concrete
beams respectively. The connection between the rails and sleepers and between
sleepers and the ground are modelled as spring layers. The model is employed to
conduct a series of analyses to evaluate the global track lateral stability examining
the effect of rail type, ballast lateral stiffness, sleeper material and sleeper spacing
on the track lateral shift magnitudes. The model is developed in structural analysis
software SPACE GASS that is a multi-purpose structural analysis program for 2D
and 3D structures. Application of such structural software in modelling the railway
track is rarely reported in the literature.
2 Model Development
The track structure can be classified into superstructure and substructure. In con-
ventional ballasted track system, the superstructure is composed of rails, sleepers
and fastening system. The substructure consists of ballast layer, capping layer (or
sub-ballast layer) and subgrade. The rails are manufactured in different sizes and
lengths and assembled either by welding or bolted connections in the field. Sleepers
are located between the rail and the ballast in transverse direction to the rail. The
sleepers transfer the loads from the rail to the track substructure and also restrain the
rail in the lateral, longitudinal and vertical directions. The fastening system
including clips and pads is used to fix the rail to the sleeper. They help with
maintaining the track gauge and acting as an elastic and damping layer between the
rail and the sleepers. Ballast layer is the select crushed granular material beneath the
sleepers to provide resiliency, transfer the loads to subgrade safely and to keep track
superstructure in the required position.
There are many methods of modelling and analysis of rail track system
depending on the purpose of the study. In general, in track structural modelling,
Effect of Different Structural Parameters on Track Lateral Stability 291
rails are considered as infinite uniform beams laid on elastic foundation modelled
either as continuous or discrete elastic supports representing the sleepers, fastening
and track substructure [2]. In this study, the track model was considered as a
structure that consists of beams and spring connections. The rail was modelled as
NZR 50 kg rail profile. The Sleepers were modelled as concrete beams with a
trapezoid cross section connected to the rails by fastenings. The standard concrete
sleeper type used in New Zealand railways is 2130 mm long, 207 mm wide on top
and 254 mm at the bottom. The depth of concrete sleeper at the ends are 174 mm;
the depth varies from 194 mm at rail seat to 164 mm in the middle. Here, for the
modelling the geometry of the sleeper was simplified with constant depth of
174 mm. The sleeper spacing is defined as 700 mm centre to centre as the common
spacing in New Zealand Railways. The Rails sit on High density polyethylene pads
and are fastened to the sleepers with clips. For modelling, the fastening was sim-
plified as a node connection restrained through springs.
The model was developed with the length of 20 m to minimise the effect of
boundary conditions (Fig. 1). In the SPACE GASS software the structural items are
treated as frame elements, so defining different restraint conditions for the top and
bottom surfaces of an element is challenging. For example, the top surface of the
sleepers are connected to the rail and the bottom surface is sitting on the ballast
layer. To overcome this challenge, a number of equally spaced vertical members
were defined underneath each sleeper connected to the ground using spring
connections.
To verify the model, the global behaviour of the model under static and dynamic
excitations is examined. Figure 2 shows the typical track displacement under a
tentative lateral load. It can be observed that, the model behaves logically under a
lateral static load. Additionally, the dynamic mode shapes of the model are shown in
Fig. 3. The three dominant mode shapes are associated with lateral bending motions
as expected, consistent with literature on track lateral dynamic behaviour [4].
In the next stage, a conventional Single Tie Push Test (STPT) is simulated where
a single sleeper is laterally pushed and the displacement of the track is measured.
The results obtained from the model is compared with some experimental and
simulated STPT results reported in the literature (Fig. 4). The results show that the
force/displacement magnitudes are within the sensible range of typical responses in
railway track even though the non-linear behaviour is not simulated. This confirms
that the model structural parameters and stiffnesses are suitably defined.
3 Parametric Study
The developed track model was used in a series of simulations applying systematic
changes to few track parameters. Through the simulations, the sensitivity of track
lateral stability (deflection) were examined. The simulations were undertaken by
changing one parameter at a time while keeping all other parameters constant as per
the standard case. The standard case parameters considered in these simulations
includes NZR50 kg rail, concrete sleepers with 700 mm centre to centre spacing,
and 2500 kN/m ballast lateral stiffness. The simulations were undertaken for two
lateral loads of 90 kN and 45 kN applied to the sleeper end. It should be noted that
the focus of this study is on the main track structural parameters and the parameters
such as frictional interactions between sleeper and ballast and the track shoulder
width are not simulated in this study.
Figure 5 shows the sensitivity of track lateral displacement to change in different
track parameters. Figure 5(a) demonstrates the effect of rail type. Two NZ rail types
(NZR41 and NZR50) and three common Australian rail types (AS53, AS60 and
AS68) are compared. It can be seen that changing NZR50 to AS68, the lateral
displacement is reduced by about 21%. Figure 5(b) presents the effect of sleeper
spacing. Four values of sleeper spacing (500 mm, 600 mm, 700 mm and 800 mm)
are simulated. It is observed that by reducing the sleeper spacing from 700 mm to
500 mm, the track lateral displacement is dropped by 37%. Figure 5 (c) shows the
effect of ballast lateral stiffness. It is observed that the lateral displacement is
decreased by 24% if the ballast horizontal stiffness is increased from 2500 kN/m
(Standard case) to 4500 kN/m. The term “ballast stiffness” used in this study refers
to the overall track sub-structures stiffness, which highly depends on substructure
properties and maintenance condition.
Figure 5(d) presents the effect of sleeper material. For this study, the size of the
sleeper is kept unchanged and only the material types is varied. Two types of
Timber material are considered. Types 1 (E = 21.5 GPa) and Type 2 (E = 6.1 GPa).
The results show that the track lateral displacement is affected by about 22%
changing the sleeper material from concrete to timber (Type 2).
294 H. Askarinejad et al.
To summarize the results obtained from above analyses, the sensitivity of track
lateral stability to different track parameters is compared in Fig. 6, so the relative
effects can be better observed. The results obtained here are based on the model
with specific properties and variables considered in this study and cannot neces-
sarily be generalized as different track parameters have different practical range of
variability in different railways. For example, the ballast stiffness is significantly
more variable compared to other parameters as it is affected by various track quality
and maintenance/consolidation condition.
5
90kN 45kN 5 90kN 45kN
4.5
4.5
4
4
3.5
3.5
3
3
2.5 2.5
2 2
1.5 1.5
1
1
40 45 50 55 60 65 70 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 800 850
5.00 6
90 kN 45 kN 90kN 45kN
4.50
5
4.00
4
3.50
3.00 3
2.50 2
2.00
1
1.50
0
1.00 Concrete Timber (Type 1) Timber (Type 2)
2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500
Sleeper Material
Ballast Lateral Stiffness (kN/m)
c) Effect of ballast lateral stiffness
d) Effect of sleeper material
40
Change in lateral displacement (%)
35
30
25
20
15
10
0
Rail Type Sleeper Spacing Ballast Lateral Stiffness Sleeper Material
Track Parameter
However, comparing the variables considered in this study, the results show the
sleeper spacing as a quite significant factor which has been overlooked in the
majority of the literature on track stability studies. The results obtained here,
highlight the importance of sleeper spacing in particular in railways where the
lateral stability is a major issue due to either temperature variations or seismic
events. The sleeper spacing is variable in different railways; for example, in the
majority of Australian rail lines the standard sleeper spacing is 600 mm while in
New Zealand is mostly 700 mm. This parameter practically depends on various
design, maintenance and operational aspects; however, considering the vulnera-
bility of rail lines in New Zealand to lateral instabilities due to seismic events, the
possibility of reducing this design parameter in the major rail lines should be
examined.
4 Conclusion
A railway track model was developed and employed to simulate the track lateral
stability (lateral deflection) for different scenarios. The model was developed with
the length of 20 m incorporating the major track structural components. It was
shown that a practical structural software such as SPACE GASS can provide an
efficient tool for simulation of rail track global behaviour. Even though, such
modelling tool/approach has limitation in terms of incorporating the material
non-linearity or frictional interactions, the relative effects of different structural
parameters on track global behaviour can be reasonably compared. The efficiency
of the model allowed for a large section of the track to be modelled, so minimising
the effect of boundary conditions on the global behaviour. Through multiple sim-
ulations, the effect of rail type, sleeper spacing, ballast stiffness and sleeper material
was examined and compared. The results in particular highlights the importance of
sleeper spacing and can contribute to optimum design changes in railways where
the track is prone to track lateral shift and instabilities either from vehicle or
environmental causes.
References
1. Arbabi F, Khalighi M (2011) Stability of railroad tracks under the effects of temperature change
and earthquake. J Seismol Earthq Eng 12(3):119–129
2. Askarinejad H, Dhanasekar M (2016) A multi-body dynamic model for localised track
responses in vicinity of rail discontinuities. J Struct Stab Dyn 16(9):1550058
3. Kabo E (2006) A numerical study of the lateral ballast resistance in railway tracks. Proc Inst
Mech Eng Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 220:425–433
4. Kaewunruen S, Remennikov AM, Aikawa A, Sakai H (2014) Free vibrations of interspersed
railway track systems in three-dimensional space. Acoust Australia 42(1):20–26
296 H. Askarinejad et al.
5. Kish A (2011) On the fundamentals of track lateral resistance. In: AREMA conference,
Minneapolis, USA
6. Koike Y, Nakamura T, Hayano K, Momoya Y (2014) Numerical method for evaluating the
lateral resistance of sleepers in ballasted tracks. Soils Found 54(3):502–514
7. Zakeri JA, Mirfattahi B, Fakhari M (2012) Lateral resistance of railway track with frictional
sleepers. Proc Inst Civil Eng: Transp 165(2):151–155
8. van’t Zand J, Moraal J (1997) Ballast resistance under three dimensional loading. Report
7-97-103-4, Roads and Railways Research Laboratory, TU Delft
Structural Strengthening of Concrete
Footings Using External Prestressing
X. Lu and R. Aboutaha
X. Lu R. Aboutaha (&)
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Syracuse University,
Syracuse, NY, USA
e-mail: rsabouta@syr.edu
X. Lu
e-mail: xlu118@syr.edu
1 Introduction
According to the latest Infrastructure Report Card (ASCE 2017), nearly 9.1% of
bridges were determined as structurally deficient, indicating that some critical
members in those bridges are deteriorated, and the bridges will be closed if no
rehabilitations are made. Retrofitting of bridges initially took place in California in
the 1970s, driven by the 1971 San Fernando earthquake [2]. However, only limited
studies have been carried out on bridge footings. Thus, retrofit strategies for bridge
footings are still under-developed.
Bridge footing plays an essential role in transferring the load from superstructure
to the soil underneath. It may be structurally deficient due to inadequate flexural or
shear capacities, insufficient load carrying capacity, inadequate steel embedment
length or poor column-footing connection. Generally, the punching shear failure is
the dominating failure mode.
In this paper, the traditional retrofit systems for bridge footings were reviewed,
with their shortcomings being addressed. The proposed retrofit system utilizing
external circular prestressing strands was introduced, with its advantages being
highlighted. Totally 18 models were analyzed using the finite element software
Abaqus CAE, and all the models were typical spread footings with square section.
Material properties, adopted concrete models and boundary conditions were
described. The parameters investigated in this research included the size of spread
footing, the flexural reinforcement ratio, and the number of prestressing strands.
Results indicated the proposed new retrofit system using external circular pre-
stressing significantly improved the punching shear capacity of square spread
footing.
McLean et al. [3] retrofitted one pile cap and one spread footing with different
methods, and the two retrofitted pile caps are shown in Fig. 1. In Fig. 1(a), the
depth of footing was increased by a reinforced concrete overlay, which was con-
nected to the existing footing by shear friction dowels. In addition to that, in Fig. 1
(b), the plan dimensions of the pile cap were also enlarged, and the connection at
the interface was achieved by splicing the existing and the additional reinforce-
ments. Test results indicated that overturning capacity of the pile cap was increased
by enlarging the plan dimensions. Also, both bending and shear capacities were
enhanced by adding the reinforced concrete overlay. Similar retrofit methods were
also tested by Xiao et al. [6] and Saiidi et al. [5], with the same conclusions being
made.
FEMA (2006) proposed three types of strategies to retrofit a spread footing,
depending on the different deficiencies. For footings with deficient overturning
capacity, the plan dimensions can be enlarged. Inadequate shear capacity can be
Structural Strengthening of Concrete Footings ... 299
reduce friction; (3) placing regular reinforcements in the grooves; (4) placing
formwork and casting the additional footing part; and (5) stressing the prestressing
strands when concrete has gained strength.
With the proposed retrofit system, the original square footing is enlarged to a
circular footing, therefore the axial load capacity can be enhanced. Shear capacity
and flexural capacity are also expected to be improved, contributed by the con-
finement action provided by the external circular prestressing.
2 Research Significance
For spread footings, punching shear failure is the dominating fail mode. Therefore,
in this paper, the efficiency of the proposed retrofit system on the improvement of
the punching shear capacity of spread footings was investigated. The parameters
considered include the size of spread footing, the flexural reinforcement ratio, and
the number of prestressing strands.
The tendons are installed at the location with the largest eccentricity, and the
thickness of the concrete cover is assumed as 75 mm. For all footings with different
sizes, the shear span to depth ratio a/de is set as a constant value 1.5 (Fig. 4(b)).
The explicit dynamic analysis is employed to investigate all models. Compared
to the implicit analysis in ABAQUS, the explicit analysis has remarkable advan-
tages in solving problems with contact and material nonlinearities, since the for-
mation of the tangent stiffness matrix is not required, and the convergence problems
can also be avoided. Therefore, it is appropriate in this research, where
non-convergence occurs because of either the nonlinear contact between circular
tendon and concrete, or the stiffness reduction in the shear failure.
e0 þ b1
0
e0 is the strain corresponding to the compressive strength of concrete fc , and
0
f
e0 ¼ 0:0016 exp 240 c ð2Þ
Ec
40 3.5
35 3.0 ( , )
30
Stress (MPa)
2.5
Stress (MPa)
25
Primary
2.0
Cracking Stage
20
1.5
15
Secondary
10 1.0
Cracking Stage
5 0.5
4 10
0
0.0
0 1 2 3 4
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2
The key parameter b1 is developed to determine the slope of both the ascending
and descending branches, and
0:2 expð0:73nÞ; for ec \e0
b1 ¼ ð3Þ
0:41 expð0:77nÞ; for ec [ e0
For steel reinforcement, a simplified elastic-plastic behaviour was used. The yield
strength is 420 MPa. The Young’s modulus and Poisson ratio are 200 GPa and 0.3,
respectively. 270 ksi strands were considered, and the stress-strain relationship
specified by PCI Design Handbook (2014) was followed.
In this research, all flexural reinforcements are considered fully bonded with con-
crete. The contact between ducts and prestressing strands is modelled as friction-
less. The interaction between the original and additional concrete is also considered
as fully bonded.
As the footing is symmetric in both transverse directions, in each model, only a
quarter of the footing is simulated. The nodes on the top surface of the column are
constrained in all degrees of freedom. Nodes on the section perpendicular to
Axial X is set as XSYMM, and notes on the section perpendicular to Axial Y is set
as YSYMM (Fig. 6).
304 X. Lu and R. Aboutaha
All models failed by punching shear, including three original square footings. The
flexural reinforcements did not yield, regardless of the reinforcement ratio. At the
failure point, an obvious shear crack could be observed on the cross-section of each
model (Fig. 7).
Specified by ACI 318-14 [1], the punching shear shall be resisted by the critical
sections which are located a distance d/2 from the edge of the column. Therefore,
to better understand the failure mechanism and the efficiency of the proposed
retrofit system, the load acting on the area outside of the critical sections is defined
as the punching load, which is the load resulting in the punching shear failure, and
it can be expressed as:
Atotal Apunching
Ppunching ¼ Ptotal ð5Þ
Atotal
Fig. 7 Shear cracks at the failure point in 3 m original and retrofitted footings
Structural Strengthening of Concrete Footings ... 305
Where, Ptotal is the total load carried by the column during analysis; Atotal is the
total area of either a original footing or a enlarged footing; Apunching is the area
enclosed by the critical sections. It is noteworthy that in this paper, each
load-displacement curve was created using Ppunching , instead of Ptotal . Punching
capacity of each model is the load Ppunching when the punching shear failure occurs.
The results are listed in Table 1.
For 3 m and 5 m footings with the lower reinforcement ratio 0.75%, the
load-deflection curves of original and retrofitted models are shown in Fig. 8. For
both sizes, the application of the external prestressing strands significantly
improved the punching shear capacity. The more the strands were employed, the
larger the improvement was achieved. Besides, stiffness was also enhanced, and the
displacement at the failure point was also increased.
30 60
P30 P30
P10 P10
25 50
3m - Original 5m - Original
20 40
15 30
10 20
5 10
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 0 10 20 30 40
Displacement (mm) Displacement (mm)
30 40
3m - Original 3m (10 Strands)
35
15 20
15
10
10
5
5
0 0
0 5 10 15 20 0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Displacement (mm) Displacement (mm)
14 25
3m - 0.75% - Original 3m - 0.75% - 10 Strands
Punching Load (≤106 N)
15
8
6
10
4
5
2
0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Displacement (mm) Title
5 Conclusions
Based on this research, the following conclusions could be drawn: (1) The proposed
retrofit system utilizing the external circular prestressing strands obviously
enhanced the punching shear capacity of spread footings; (2) the amount of pre-
stressing strands had a significant effect on the enhancement of the punching shear
capacity, and the more the strands were used, the larger the improvement was
achieved; and (3) the footings with larger sizes or higher flexural reinforcement
ratios exhibited higher punching shear capacities.
References
1. ACI Committee 318 (2014) Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete, American
Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Michigan
2. Buckle I, Friedland I, Mander J, Martin G, Nutt R, Power M (2006) Seismic retrofitting manual
for highway structures: Part 1 - Bridges
3. McLean DI, Saunders TD, Hahnenkratt HH (1995) Seismic Evaluation and Retrofit of Bridge
Substructures with Spread and Pile-Supported Foundations, Pullman
4. Nayal R, Rasheed HA (2006) Tension stiffening model for concrete beams reinforced with
steel and FRP bars. J Mater Civ Eng 18(6):831–841
5. Saiidi MS, Sanders D, Acharya S (2001) Seismic retrofit of spread footings supporting bridge
columns with short dowels. Constr Build Mater 15(4):177–185
6. Xiao Y, Nigel Priestley MJ, Seible F (1996) Seismic assessment and retrofit of bridge column
footings. ACI Struct J 93(1):79–94
7. Yang KH, Mun JH, Cho MS, Kang THK (2014) Stress-strain model for various unconfined
concretes in compression. ACI Struct J 111(4):819–826
Flexural Behavior Degradation
of Corroded Aashto Type II
Pretensioned Concrete Girder-Deck
System
Keywords Prestressed Girder-deck system Corrosion Residual flexural
strength Failure mode Ductility
1 Introduction
Bridges with prestressed concrete (PC) girders have been built in large numbers
over the past few decades. According to the National Transportation Statistics, as of
2016, around 25% of bridges were constructed with PC superstructures in U.S.
Compared with conventional reinforced concrete (RC) bridge, PC bridges have
higher load-bearing capacity, and improved crack control. However, PC bridges
built in cold regions with an increasing use of de-icing salts are quite sensitive to
corrosion damage. According to a technical report by PennDOT in April 2009, the
proportion of deficient PC bridges was around 15% of the total PC bridges,
state-wide. Among all the damage affecting the performance of existing PC girders,
corrosion is the most common source [11].
Since it was not until the 1980s that corrosion-induced deterioration was first
observed in PC structures, studies about corroded PC members became available
only in recent decades. Based on previous experimental studies [9, 15, 19, 20, 24–
27], it was found that reduction in flexural strength was approximately proportional
to the number of strands affected by corrosion.
Previous work on FEA modeling of PC members are available [3, 4, 6, 7, 16,
23], however, FEA study on corroded (or unbonded) PC members are very limited
[10, 12, 13].
This paper presents the flexural behavior of corroded AASHTO Type II pre-
tensioned PC girders with a cast-in-place (CIP) concrete deck using finite element
analysis (FEA). The reduction of cross-sectional area, corrosion-induced deterio-
ration of material properties of prestressing strands, and loss of bond between
strands and surrounding concrete were considered in the FEA modeling.
2.1.1 Concrete
Grade 270 seven-wire low-relaxation prestressing strand was used in the model and
the stress-strain relationship of uncorroded strands was determined per PCI Design
Handbook (7th edition) [18]. The modulus of elasticity, tensile strength, and ulti-
mate tensile strain of prestressing steel will be degraded due to corrosion.
Prestressing strands with a higher corrosion level will have a brittle tensile behavior
[8, 20, 21, 26–28]. Material properties and stress-strain relationship of corroded
Grade 270 seven-wire low-relaxation prestressing strand proposed by [26, 27] were
adopted in the FEA model as shown in Fig. 2.
Fig. 2 Stress-strain diagram of corroded strands: a corrosion level is smaller than 8%; b corrosion
level is equal or larger than 8% [26, 27]
The first-order linear brick element with reduced integration and hourglass control
(C3D8R) was adopted for concrete in the FEA model. Compared with first-order
elements with full integration points (C3D8), C3D8R elements take less time to
solve and avoid shear and volumetric locking. Prestressing strand was modeled as a
simplified circular cross-section with an area equivalent to the actual seven-wire
strand with linear triangular prism elements (C3D6). Conventional non-prestressed
bars and stirrups were modeled using 3-D linear truss elements (T3D2).
Contacts between prestressing strands and concrete were simulated using extrusion
technique. A friction-based model was employed that consisted of two components:
(1) tangential behavior, and (2) normal behavior [3, 13]. A coefficient of friction of
1.4 appeared to be adequate to provide the interface interactions between fully
Flexural Behavior Degradation … 313
bonded strands and concrete [3]. Since corroded strands were assumed completely
unbonded with concrete within the corrosion length, zero coefficient of friction was
applied to the interface between corroded strands and concrete within the corrosion
length. Normal behavior between strands and concrete was simulated using the
“hard” contact pressure-overclosure relationship, which could minimize the pene-
tration of concrete surface into strand surface at constraint locations and prevent
transfer of tensile stress across the interface.
Non-prestressed steel bars were assumed fully bonded with concrete girder using
embedment technique. Translational degrees of freedom of the truss elements were
constrained to the interpolated values of the corresponding degrees of freedom of
the host concrete elements.
Due to symmetry, only a quarter of the pretensioned girder-deck system was simu-
lated. To model the z-direction symmetry, the pretensioned girder-deck system was
cut with a plane parallel to x-y plane. Displacement in z-direction and rotation around
x, y-direction were constrained with roller supports (U3 = UR1 = UR2 = 0). To
model the x-direction symmetry, the system was cut with a plane parallel to y-z plane.
Displacement in x-direction and rotation around y, z-direction were constrained with a
roller supports (U1 = UR2 = UR3 = 0). The system was supported with roller sup-
ports. Displacement in y-direction at supports was restricted (U2 = 0).
Loading schemes of the FEA model were as follows: (1) Prestressing all strands
in the longitudinal z-direction. Bond between strands and concrete was invalid at
this stage; (2) Casting concrete girder through defining the bond between concrete
and prestressing strands. Elements of concrete deck were deactivated; (3) Applying
self-weight of concrete girder and deck. Assuming un-shored construction of
concrete deck in this study, girder supported the entire weight of deck; (4) Applying
service load (about 40% of the ultimate load of a section with fully bonded strands)
on the pretensioned girder-deck system. Elements of concrete deck deactivated in
previous steps became fully active immediately in the current step; (5) Including
corrosion-induced deteriorations in the girder-deck system; (6) Applying remaining
external load on the pretensioned girder-deck system.
2.5 Verifications
The developed FEA model was verified against experimental data tested by Kim
et al. [14] and Ozkul et al. [17], as shown in Fig. 3(a) and (b). It can be seen that the
model predicts the flexural response of PC girders with bonded (or unbonded)
strands well.
314 B. Yan and R. Aboutaha
Fig. 3 Load-deflection FEA results compared to test results: a Kim et al. [14] b Ozkul et al. [17]
1,829 #4 Reinforcement @
20 30 204 (8) centers
152 76 #4 Reinforcement @
76 #4 Reinforcement
()
15 #4 Top flange Reinforcement
381 915 #4 Web stirrup bars
#4 Bottom flange Reinforcement
152 12.7mm-dia. low relaxation strands
152 152 50
70
19 (3/4) Chamfer
45 Unit [mm] 7 spaces @ Unit [mm]
(a) (b)
Fig. 4 AASHTO Type II girder with deck: a section dimensions; b reinforcement details
(qp = 0.131%)
Flexural Behavior Degradation … 315
For girders investigated in this study, the development length of strands was ade-
quate to prevent bond failure and girders had shear reinforcement necessary to
prevent shear failure, therefore only flexural failure was considered as the only
possible mode of failure. Failure was identified when concrete strain at the top fiber
on the compression side reached the failure strain of concrete in compression (CC),
or the tensile stress in corroded strands reached the tensile strength (SR).
Based on results from the FEA model, failure modes of specimens with corroded
strands were primarily affected by corrosion levels. Pretensioned girder-deck sys-
tems with a corrosion level below 5% failed in flexural due to concrete crushing. As
corrosion level was 15%, specimens failed in flexural due to strand rupture. For
specimens with a corrosion level of 10%, the failure mode would be either CC or
SR, depending on values of other parameters.
After studying all cases, it was concluded that, number of corroded strand index and
corrosion level had major impacts on the ultimate flexural strength of corroded
pretensioned girder-deck systems. As 25% of strands were corroded, the reduction
of flexural strength was about 3% to 30%. As 50% of strands were corroded, the
reduction was between 8% to 33%. If all strands were corroded, the reduction of
flexural strength was approximately 17% to 42%. Since corroded strands had lower
ultimate stress due to bond deterioration and degradation of material properties, and
the neutral axis at ultimate for a girder-deck system with corroded strands was not
affected significantly due to the existence of concrete deck, increasing the number
of corroded strands reduced the total force in strands and resulted in a lower flexural
strength of the section.
Flexural strength also decreased as corrosion level increased. As corrosion level
was 5%, the reduction of flexural capacity was about 3% to 27%. As corrosion level
increased to 10%, flexural capacity decreased about 5% to 30%. As corrosion level
was 15%, the pretensioned girder-deck system lost approximately 13% to 42% of
the original flexural capacity.
For a girder-deck system failed due to concrete crushing, as corrosion length
increased from 20% to 60% of the span, the reduction of flexural strength was less
than 5%. However, as a system failed due to strand rupture, a reduction in corrosion
length resulted in a lower flexural strength. This was because, as corrosion length
increased, stress in corroded strands would decrease, which would allow more
external load to be carried by the specimen before reaching the stress limit.
Therefore, the flexural strength decreased with a reduction in corrosion length. For
pretensioned girder-deck systems having a 15% corrosion level, as corrosion length
316 B. Yan and R. Aboutaha
decreased from 60% to 20% of the span, flexural strength decreased around 2% to
8%, depending on the number of corroded strand index.
Span-depth ratio and prestressing reinforcement ratio have negligible impacts on
the reduction of flexural strength of corroded pretensioned girder-deck system.
3.3 Ductility
ρp = 0.107%, L/dp=18, ηsl = 0.4, ηs= 10% ρp = 0.107%, L/dp=18, ηsl = 0.4, ηsn= 0.5
240 240
Number of Corroded Strand Index (ηsn) Corrosion Level (ηs)
180 180
Total Load (kips)
Total Load (kips)
120 120
60 60 5%
0.25
0.5 10%
1 15%
0 0
0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8
Deflecon (in) Deflecon (in)
(a) (b)
ρp = 0.107%, L/dp=18, ηs = 5%, ηsn= 0.5 ρp = 0.107%, L/dp=18, ηs = 15%, ηsn= 0.5
240 240
Corrosion Length Index (ηsl) Corrosion Length Index (ηsl)
180 180
Total Load (kips)
120 120
60 0.2 60 0.2
0.4 0.4
0.6 0.6
0 0
0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8
Deflecon (in) Deflecon (in)
(c) (d)
4 Conclusions
References
11. Harries KA, Kasan J, Aktas J (2009) Repair methods for prestressed concrete bridges,
Research report, University of Pittsburgh
12. Kang T, Huang Y (2012) Computer modeling of post-tensioned structures. In: 4th
international conference on computer modeling and simulation, vol 22, pp 41–45
13. Kang T, Huang Y, Shin M, Lee JD, Cho AS (2015) Experimental and numerical assessment
of bonded and unbonded post-tensioned concrete members. ACI Struct J 112:735–748
14. Kim YH, Hueste MBD, Trejo D (2015) Flexural behavior of high-early-strength
self-consolidating concrete pretensioned bridge girders: experimental evaluation. J Bridge
Eng 20:1–13
15. Menoufy AE, Soudki K (2014) Flexural behavior of corroded pretensioned girders repaired
with CFRP sheets. PCI J 59:129–143
16. Okumus P, Oliva MG, Becker S (2012) Nonlinear finite element modeling of cracking at ends
of pretensioned bridge girders. Eng Struct 40:267–275
17. Ozkul O, Nassif H, Tanchan P, Harajli M (2008) Rational approach for predicting stress in
beams with unbonded tendons. ACI Struct J 105:338–347
18. PCI, Precast and prestressed concrete handbook (7th edition), Precast/Prestressed Concrete
Institute, 2010, Chicago, IL
19. Rinaldi Z, Imperatore S, Valente C (2010) Experimental evaluation of the flexural behavior of
corroded P/C beams. Constr Build Mater 24:2267–2278
20. Rogers RA, Wotherspoon L, Scott A, Ingham JM (2012) Residual strength assessment and
destructive testing of decommissioned concrete bridge beams with corroded pretensioned
reinforcement. PCI J. 100–118
21. Vu NA, Castel A, Francois R (2009) Effect of stress corrosion cracking on stress-strain
response of steel wires used in prestressed concrete beams. Corros Sci 51:1453–1459
22. Yang K-H, Mun J-H, Cho M-S, Kang TH-K (2014) Stress-strain model for various
unconfined concretes in compression. ACI Struct J 111:819–826
23. Yapar O, Basu P, Nordendale N (2015) Accurate finite element modeling of pretensioned
prestressed concrete beams. Eng Struct 101:163–178
24. Young S-G, Kim E-K (2006) Deterioration of bonded post-tensioned concrete bridges and
research topics on the strength evaluation in ISARC. In: Proceedings of JSCE-KSCE joint
seminar on maintenance and management strategy of infrastructure in Japan and Korea
25. Yu F (2013) Study on mechanical performance of partial prestressed concrete beams with
corroded strand. Ph.D. thesis, Dalian University of Technology (in Chinese)
26. Zeng YH, Huang QH, Gu XL, Zhang WP (2010) Experimental study on bending behavior of
corroded post-tensioned concrete beams. In: Earth and space 2010: engineering, science,
construction, and operations in challenging environments, pp 3521–3528
27. Zeng YH, Ling GX, Zhang WP, Huang QH (2010) Study on mechanical properties of
corroded prestressed tendons. J Build Mater 13:169–175
28. Zhang XH, Wang L, Zhang JR, Liu Y (2017) Corrosion-induced flexural behavior degradation
of locally ungrouted post-tensioned concrete beams. Constr Build Mater 134:7–17
Anti-plane Response Induced
by a Partially Filled Trapezoidal
Alluvial Valley
Abstract This study proposes a novel strategy for the investigation of displace-
ment amplitude near and along a partially filled trapezoidal alluvial valley subjected
to shear horizontal (SH) waves. The proposed hybrid method, combining finite
element method with a Lamb series, was applied to study the effects of the irregular
alluvial valley geometry, the incident angle of SH waves, a dimensionless fre-
quency, and a filling ratio on displacements. Modified transfinite interpolation was
used to obtain the coordinates of nodes and determine the sequence of node
numbering in the inner finite region including the irregular alluvial valley.
Furthermore, we present a detailed description of the amplification of displacement
at the surface of the alluvial valley. According to the numerical results, the filling
ratio plays an important role in the value of displacements, and variations in
incident angles and dimensionless frequencies dominate the patterns of displace-
ments. The results of numerical simulation are helpful to understand the site effects
in irregular alluvial valleys.
Keywords SH wave Partially filled trapezoidal alluvial valley Filling ratio
Hybrid method Modified transfinite interpolation
W. S. Shyu (&)
Department of Civil Engineering, National Pingtung University of Science and Technology,
Pingtung, Taiwan
e-mail: wsshyu@mail.npust.edu.tw
T. J. Teng
National Center for Research on Earthquake Engineering, Taipei, Taiwan
C. S. Chou
Department of Mechanical Engineering,
National Pingtung University of Science and Technology, Pingtung, Taiwan
1 Introduction
At the site of alluvial valleys, ground motion resulting from earthquakes can
increase the amplitude of responses in the frequency domain. The site effect of
alluvial valley can be summarized to the scattering, diffraction, and standing waves
in the fixed region of alluvial valley. For obtaining the mechanisms in a 2-D alluvial
valley embedded in an elastic half-space, the wave function expansion method has
been proposed for solving the SH waves induced by various types of alluvial
valleys, such as semi-cylindrical alluvial valley [6] semi-elliptical alluvial valleys
[8]. However, a partially filled alluvial valley is closer to the ground truth found in
the field. Therefore, combining wave function expansion method with Graf’s
addition theorem is required to solve the scattering of SH waves by partially filled
semi-circular alluvial valleys [7, 9].
Since numerical methods have been developed to solve the scattering problems,
a hybrid method combining finite element method (FEM) and Lamb’s series
functions, in conjunction with a transfinite interpolation [1] was successfully to
solve the anti-plane scattering problems [2–5]. The scattering problems due to a
partially filled semi-circular alluvial valley or a circular-arc-layered alluvial valley
were solved by the hybrid method with a modified transfinite interpolation [4].
In this study, the novel strategy following Shyu et al. [4] is to investigate the
scattering of SH waves induced by a partially filled trapezoidal alluvial valley
(PFTAV) embedded in an elastic half-space. We investigated the influences of the
incident SH wave angle (h), the dimensionless frequency (g), and the filling ratio
(FR) on the displacement along the anti-plane direction (uy ). We then compared
the numerical results of a special case of the PFTAV (i.e. completely filled trape-
zoidal alluvial valley) to the results obtained by Shyu and Teng [2].
2 Numerical Model
By referring to the functional presented by Shyu and Teng [2], the equation of the
functional is as follows:
ZZ Z Z
1 0 2 0 0 1 s
P¼ W q x uy uy dX þ
0 0
uy uy ty dS þ
0 s
uyf tys dS
X0 2 2
Z C C
0 f
uy ty dS ð2Þ
C
It was proven the functional in Eq. (2) equals to the governing equations and
boundary conditions of the scattering problem shown in Fig. 1, by choosing the
scattered wave function which satisfied the condition of traction-free boundaries at
free surfaces as well as the condition of radiation. Therefore, the Lamb series was
using to express the displacement and traction in the scattered field. Hence, the
functional in Eq. (2) can be written as the following matrix equation:
Kaa x2 Maa Kac u0y Pa
¼ ð3Þ
Kca Kcc c Pc
In this study, two different sub-regions (comprising an irregular soft alluvial valley
X1 and a partial region of an elastic half-space X2 ) are combined in a physical
region X0 . Therefore, two sets of transfinite interpolation functions are introduced
to map X0 (including X1 and X2 ) to logical region D0 , comprising two unit-squares
D1 and D2 . Figure 2 presents a schematic diagram showing the physical and logical
regions of the partially field trapezoidal alluvial valley. In Fig. 2, six points at the
boundary of D0 with a rectangular geometry (0 X 1; 0 Z 2) are numbered
with I to VI. The boundaries of D0 are represented with vectors XiL , XiR , XiB , and XiT
respectively in sub-region Di (i ¼ 1; 2).
Due to the regular shape, we can obtain the coordinates of inner points in D0
easily. For example, N is given by subtracting 1 from the number of nodes at the
boundary of D (or D2 ), leading to dX ¼ dZ ¼ 1=N.
1 Then we defined the coor-
dinates of inner points as follow:
Anti-plane Response Induced by a Partially Filled Trapezoidal ... 323
Xn ; Zn ¼ Xn ; Zm ¼ Xn ¼ ðn 1ÞdX; Zm ¼ ðm 1ÞdZ ;
n
þ 1Þ
¼ n þ ð m 1Þ ð N ð4Þ
þ 1 in D1 , and n ¼ 1; 2; N
where n; m ¼ 1; 2; N þ 1 as well as m ¼
N þ 2; 2N þ 1 in D . Then, the nodal coordinates xn ; zn inside irregular
2
ð5Þ
where i ¼ 1; 2. Therefore, with known boundaries, such as xi‘ , xir , xib , and xit in
sub-region Xi (i ¼ 1; 2), makes it possible to systematically determine the nodal
coordinates inside X0 , including a PFTAV. The application of modified transfinite
interpolation was detailed by Shyu et al. [4].
dimensionless frequency g ¼ xa=pCs , which is the ratio of the top width of the
symmetric trapezoidal canyon to the wavelength of the incident half-plane shear
wave. Substituting the incident angle of SH wave (h) and dimensionless frequency
(g) into the numerical calculation based on the presented hybrid method makes it
possible to obtain the displacement responses in the field.
The curves in Fig. 4(a) and (b) present variations in uy with x/a in the com-
pletely filled trapezoidal alluvial valley at g ¼ 0:5, and g ¼ 2:0 (i.e., Case1),
respectively. The symbols in Fig. 4 represent the results from the formula and
numerical calculation by Shyu and Teng [2]. The results obtained in this study are
in good agreement with those of Shyu and Teng [2].
This comparison demonstrates the efficacy of the modified transfinite interpo-
lation proposed in this study for the meshing of PFTAV. This provides results that
the hybrid method in conjunction with modified transfinite interpolation could be
used to systematically solve SH wave scattering in cases of PFTAV.
(a) (b)
Fig. 3 FEM mesh of an inner finite region X0 (including X1 and X2 ): (a) Case1; (b) Case4
Anti-plane Response Induced by a Partially Filled Trapezoidal ... 325
(a) θ = 0 (b)
θ = 30
θ = 60
θ = 90
Fig. 4 Variations in uy in Case1 with x=a at a g ¼ 0:5; b g ¼ 2:0
(c) (d)
Fig. 5 Variations in uy with x=a at g ¼ 0:5, with a h ¼ 0 ; b h ¼ 30 ; c h ¼ 60 ; d h ¼ 90
(Case4; FR ¼ 18:2%) shown in Fig. 5(a), respectively. This can be attributed to the
fact that enlargement effect do exist in soft alluvial valley. It represents that theFR
is influenced the enlargement effect. For example, the extreme value of uy max
occurred in Case3, which nearly only half of the volume of trapezoidal canyon
326 W. S. Shyu et al.
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Fig. 6 Variations in uy with x=a at g ¼ 2:0, with a h ¼ 0 ; b h ¼ 30 ; c h ¼ 60 ; d h ¼ 90
filled with sedimentary soil. Though the value of uy max occurred in Case3 at
g ¼ 0:5, we can observe the values of uy max increasing as h increasing form 0 to
90 , except in Case4. It could be summarized as following: (1) At a lower g,
enlargement effect could be found in PFTAV, and shown in great contribution in
Case3. (2) As h increasing form 0 to 90 , the enlargement effect could be
apparently shown in the response of uy max . (3) In Case4, a low value of FR leading
to the pattern of PFTAV is closer to the site effect of canyon [3].
In Fig. 6, under a higher frequency incident wave impinging (i.e., g ¼ 2:0), we
can observe a multi-peak pattern in the region of soft alluvial valley (i.e., X1 ), as
well as the illuminated zone of the half-space (i.e., x=a 1:0). Comparing to the
results in Fig. 5, it is interested to find the positions of uy max are not near the center
of PFTAV but the corner of PFTAV (i.e., x=a ¼ 1:0). It could be summarized as
following: (1) At higher g, enlargement effect combined with a multi-peak pattern
shown in uy is observed in PFTAV. (2) Under g ¼ 2:0, the extreme value of
uy among fours cases occurred in Case3 only appears at smaller h, such as
max
h ¼ 0 , and 30 . (3) At large h (such as h ¼ 90 ), the values of uy are decayed
4 Conclusions
This paper reports on a hybrid method combined FEM with Lamb series to
investigate the scattering of SH waves induced by a PFTAV embedded in an elastic
half-plane. We used a simple systematic modified transfinite interpolation to mesh
the inner finite region including a PFTAV. It is useful to obtain the coordinates of
nodes and the sequence of node numbering in the irregular regions.
To demonstrate
the validity of the hybrid method in this study, we compared uy in a special case to
the results by Shyu and Teng [2].
To discuss the site effects of PFTAV, four cases of PFTAV with various FR are
impinging by SH waves with h and g. Our results demonstrate the following: (1) At
a lower dimensionless frequency (such as g ¼ 0:5), the effect of FR exceeds the
influence of h; therefore, a larger uy can be generated in PFTAV with a medium
FR (such as Case3). (2) At a higher dimensionless frequency (such as g ¼ 2:0), the
incident angle of SH waves (h) and FR provide similar weights of site effect on uy .
(3) The peak amplitude in a partially filled alluvial valley (such as PFTAV) with
medium FR is larger than that found in a completely filled alluvial valley.
The proposed hybrid method with modified transfinite interpolation overcomes
the disadvantages to solve the SH wave scattering problems. Importantly, this study
provides a deeper understanding of the site effect associated with partially filled
alluvial valley (such as PFTAV), and helps to deal with the scattering problems of
in-plane P-, SV-, and Rayleigh incident waves induced by irregular alluvial valley.
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank the Ministry of Science and Technology,
Taiwan R. O. C. for financially supporting this research under Contract No. MOST
108-2221-E-020-016.
References
5. Shyu WS, Teng TJ, Chou CS (2017) Anti-plane response caused by interactions between a
dike and the surrounding soil. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng 92:408–418
6. Trifunac MD (1971) Surface motion of a semi-cylindrical alluvial valley for incident plane SH
waves. Bull Seismol Soc Am 61:1755–1770
7. Tsaur DH, Chang KH (2008) SH-waves scattering from a partially filled semi-circular alluvial
valley. Geophys J Int 173:157–167
8. Wong HL, Trifunac MD (1974) Surface motion of a semi-elliptical alluvial valley for incident
plane SH waves. Bull Seismol Soc Am 64:1389–1408
9. Zhang N, Gao Y, Yang J, Xu C (2015) An analytical solution to the scattering of cylindrical SH
waves by a partially filled semi-circular alluvial valley: near-source site effects. Earthq Eng Eng
Vib 14:189–201
Case Study of Soft Ground
Countermeasure with More than 100M
Thickness in Japanese Expressway
Abstract This study shows the vacuum consolidation method in the soft ground
section of about 3 km length at the construction site in Japanese Expressway. This
soft ground is covered with high soft organic soil under the ground level, and soft
clay soil, loose sandy soil and this highly soft organic soil are deposited as the
mutual layer at the bottom part within more than 100 m thickness. Soft ground has
a possibility to cause a serious problem at the maintenance stage when the
long-term large scale settlement happen, however, there was no experience of
expressway construction on such a quite thick soft ground in Japan. Therefore, full
scale test embankment was constructed to confirm the effective method. Vacuum
consolidation method was adopted from the result of full scale test. By this method,
the construction cost can be reduced by about 60% compared with the deep mixing
treatment method, and the construction period has been shortened by about 50%.
Total settlement amount for 10 years is estimated to be around 10 to 20 cm based
on the analysis of observation during construction.
1 Introduction
The Tohoku-Chuo Expressway is located in the Tohoku region of Japan and has
268 km length. It connects to main cities in the Tohoku region including Yamagata
Prefecture. As it goes through the Yamagata Prefecture, passes about 3 km
extensive soft ground section (Fig. 1). The soft soil is a deposit over 100 m thick
composed of organic soil and clay mutually sandwiching loose sandy layers. In
particular, the layer about 10 m depth from the ground surface is a deposition of
quite soft and highly organic soil. In Japan, there has never been experience of
expressway construction with extremely thick layer of soft soil such as this area.
Therefore, we constructed a full-size trial embankment to confirm the effects of soft
soil improvement methods and identify problems prior to construction of the actual
embankment. According to the test results, embankment work was constructed by
appropriate ways. This report shows the countermeasure of a large-scale soft
ground, and focuses on effectiveness of the vacuum consolidation method in par-
ticular with embanking speed, residual settlement and the behaviour of the sur-
rounding ground.
Lake Hakuryu is located about 1.5 km northeast of the Akayu Onsen hot spring,
Nanyo City, Yamagata Prefecture, and is used as paddy fields (Photo 1). The area
started to become marshland about 100,000 years ago, and there used to be many
lakes and marshes of various sizes. They gradually diminished and vanished, and
the only remaining water area is Lake Hakuryu. Figure 2 shoes the presumed
geological profile of the soft soil area prepared based on a geological survey
conducted at about 100 boring locations supplemented by Electric Cone Penetration
testing (about 70 locations). Soft organic layers are distributed near the ground
surface for a thickness of about 10 m at the soft soil section, and under it lie mutual
layers of clay soil and sandy soil. Tuff layer is confirmed to exist about 600 m from
the Akayu Tunnel partly, however, no such rock layer is confirmed even at a depth
of over 100 m at whole sections. Analysis of core samples taken from boring tests
reveal that volcanic ash exists continuously at similar elevations/depth, it shows that
such volcanic ash had been deposited over a flat terrain for tens of thousands of
years in the past. However, considering the presence of extremely complicated
changes in mutual layers of sandy soil or gravelly soil, it is presumed that rivers
frequently meandered or flooded in this area.
The natural water content ratio of highly organic soil distributed near the ground
surface is relatively high, or over 1,000% at some points. Even at depths from 30 to
50 m level, there are layers with a high water content ratio (200 to 300%). High water
content ratios are observed at this depth in many areas. Such areas are generally
excessively consolidated, and the condition changes to normal consolidation condi-
tion from the area to the boundary/ending side. Considering these kinds of distribution
characteristics of soil and sandy layers, the embankment section is divided into
Section A, which features relatively good ground conditions by sandy layers and, and
Section B, which features soft cohesive layers with fewer sandy layers.
A trial embankment was constructed prior to construction of the actual work, and
field observation was conducted in order to understand the improvement effect of
the vacuum consolidation method or the degree of impact on the surrounding/
road-side ground. Figure 3 shows how the trial embankment was constructed. The
trial embankment work was conducted in three areas (area numbers in ascending
order from the starting side). Regarding the vacuum consolidation method,
sheet-type vacuum consolidation was used in Area 1 and Area 3, and cap-type
vacuum consolidation was used in Area 2. Sheet pile work was conducted in Area 1
to separate the improvement area from the surrounding/road-side ground.
According to the result, settlement of Areas 1 and 3 (sheet-type vacuum consoli-
dation) was less than about 1.0 m, Area 2 was about 0.3 m. The reason is con-
sidered that the pressure level reached only 10 kN/m2 just after the start of vacuum
pump operation in Area 2 though, the pressure level reached 70 kN/m2 in Area 1
and Area 3 compared with the target pressure level of 60 kN/m2 due to the unstable
initial pressure level. And the reason of the unstable initial pressure level in Area 2
is assumed that the air-tightness of highly organic sand layer (pressure sealing
layer) was lower than expected. For the impact on the surrounding/road-side area, it
emerged that greater displacement occurred in Area 3 than in Area 1 (sheet piles
section). As explained above, it was confirmed that the sheet-type vacuum con-
solidation method shows greater improvement effects at this embankment area than
others, and that separation of the improved area by sheet piles is effective in
reducing impacts on the surrounding/road-side ground.
Case Study of Soft Ground Countermeasure … 333
Fig. 4 Deformation in surrounding/road side ground with and without steel sheet piles
Fig. 5 Lateral profile of the vacuum consolidation method determined from the trial embankment
(left: Section A; right: Section B)
334 Y. Oda et al.
Prior to construction of the actual embankment in the soft soil area, the special
committee (Lake Hakuryu Soft Ground Control Review Committee) was set up in
2007 to select an appropriate method for soft soil improvement. Various soft ground
improvement methods were compared and reviewed for Sections A and B in
Table 1. Based on the comparison results, the effectiveness of the vacuum consol-
idation method was verified by trial work. Figure 4 shows differences of deforma-
tion in the surrounding/road side ground between with and without steel sheet piles.
It indicates that deformation was reduced in Area 1, where steel sheet piles were
used. The adopted method for Section A (case3) and B (case2) is shown in Fig. 5.
Photo 2 shows the expressway road embankment work procedure using the vacuum
consolidation method. Regarding Photo 2 (4) “Road embankment underway,” trial
embankment work was conducted at various daily embanking speed: 11, 12, 15,
and 19 cm. In each case, it was confirmed that there was no negative impact on
embankment stability. Based on this trial work, the actual embankment work was
conducted at a speed of 15 cm per day.
Case Study of Soft Ground Countermeasure … 335
The ground improvement depth in the case of vacuum consolidation was about
11 m deep in Section A, and about 35 m deep in Section B. Section B was in the
largest scale of ground improvement work in Japan. Pressure level of the air-tight
sheets during the operation of vacuum pumps was stabilized in both Sections A and
B, and there was little negative pressure loss. This is the effect of the steam-water
separation method.
In steam-water separation method, water and air collected by vacuum pump are
sent to a steam-water separation tank installed under air-tight sheets, water is
drained by the draining pump from the tank and air is discharged by vacuum pump
336 Y. Oda et al.
(Fig. 6). This allows the negative pressure generated by the vacuum pump effec-
tively applied inside the ground. As a result, excessive pore water pressure is
dissipated when the timing of vacuum pump stop, and primary consolidation is
completed. The amount of settlement at the center of the embankment when the
vacuum pump stopped was about 140 to 380 cm in Area A (average settlement of
about 220 cm) and about 420 to 570 cm in Area B (average settlement of about
500 cm) (Fig. 7).
Figure 8 shows the residual settlement data for 10 years after the opening of
expressway. The black circles show the actual results of field observations, while
the red circles show the estimated values calculated from the Mesri equation to
evaluate the without case of the any improvement. The residual settlement (black
circles) is more than 20 cm in Section B, but it is less than 10 cm in Section A. In
contrast, settlement of the ground with no improvement (red circles) is considerably
larger, or about 20 to 40 cm. This means the residual settlement was successfully
reduced to about 25 to 50%.
Fig. 9 Displacement of the surrounding/road-side ground with (upper) and without (bellow) of
vacuum consolidation
338 Y. Oda et al.
5 Summary
6 Conclusion
Embankment work by the vacuum consolidation method in high soft ground area
was successfully completed during a long duration of work by the sufficient trial
embankment work and field observation. The work was also completed without
causing major settlement or upheaval.
There are two major tasks to solve in the future. One is maintenance for residual
settlement after the start of expressway service. According to the estimation result,
residual settlement of 20 cm or more may occur in some places in the future. So it’s
necessary for the road administrator to continue and check the field observation and
conduct pavement repair as required.
The second task is to take care of paddy fields around the embankment site. The
ground deformation of the surrounding/road-side was effectively reduced to some
extent by some treatment. However, it’s essential to communicate with the relevant
parties among land owners or users in the area around the work site and take
appropriate action depending on the surrounding ground condition in the future.
Case Study of Soft Ground Countermeasure … 339
Reference
M. H. TSAI
1 Introduction
M. H. TSAI (&)
Department of Civil Engineering, National Pingtung University of Science and Technology,
Pingtung County 912, Taiwan
e-mail: mhtsai@mail.npust.edu.tw
be provided for each direction in one or two layers, depending on the thickness of
the wall. The opening style is dominated by architects in most cases. Only the
weight of the opening walls is accounted for in the structural design process. Thus,
they are regarded as non-structural elements and their mechanical effects on the
building frame are neglected. A very common type of the exterior open walls is
defined as parapet walls, as shown in Fig. 1. It is usually around 1 m high above the
floor and quite popular for buildings without balconies.
Ou et al. [6] have investigated the effects of openings on the seismic resistance of
external RC walls. They indicated that the locations of openings could influence the
lateral strength of the wall specimens. On the other hand, experimental studies were
also conducted to investigate the effects of masonry infilled walls without and with
openings on the collapse resistance of building frames under column loss [3, 7, 9].
The test results indicated that the non-structural infilled walls with and without
openings could both moderately increase the collapse resistance building frames.
Erena et al. [1] indicated that the structural span length and story height may affect
the contribution of the concrete bricks to the collapse.
RC walls, with or without openings, were usually considered as structural
components in most published studies with their seismic strengths as the main
concerns. Very limited studies were related to their structural resistance contribu-
tion as they were regarded as non-structural components. The numerical study by
Tsai and Huang [10] indicated that with a same opening rate, different types of
exterior non-structural RC walls could have different influence on the collapse
resistances. However, the variations of structural design parameters may also
generate varied mechanical interaction with the exterior RC walls. Therefore, this
study focused on the influence of some selected structural design parameters on the
resistance contribution from the parapet walls. An inverted T-section model was
validated for simulating the integral flexural strength of the wall and underneath
beam. Seven RC building frames with varied span lengths, number of stories, and
seismic coefficients were designed. Nonlinear static pushover and pushdown
analyses were respectively conducted for the lateral seismic and progressive col-
lapse resistance of the building frames with and with considering the parapet walls.
Effects of the design parameters on the variation of resistance were clarified from
the analysis results.
Wall reinforcement
a Single layer #3@20 2 b 1400
410 #3@20 #6
30 50 250 50 30 30 1200
50
50
1000
Load (kN)
Wall
reinforcement
#3@30 Single layer 800
170
170
#3@20
600
60
1 #6 1
400
70
70
Experiment
95 60 95
80 200 Shell + beam-column elements
50 50 250 50 50
Section 2-2
#3@30
2
0
#6
0 1 2 3 4 5
30
50 250 50
Unit: cm
Displacement (cm)
350
Section 1-1
Fig. 2 a The WO1D specimen b Comparison of the cyclic loading test and the simulation results
344 M. H. TSAI
by Mander et al. [4] was adopted for the concrete, as shown in Fig. 3(a).
A simplified stress-strain model was used for the reinforcement, as shown in Fig. 3
(b). As mentioned in the previous paragraph, the 12 cm opening shear walls were
simulated with multi-layered shell elements. Full body constraints were imposed on
the frame joints and the corner nodes of the shear walls. Partial equal constraints
(except the one along the longitudinal axis of frame members) were imposed on the
interfaces between the frame and the shear walls. Lumped plastic hinges were
assigned to the ends of frame members. The plastic hinges properties were deter-
mined from the strengths of sectional cracking moment, crash moment, and 70%
crash moment, which were estimated from sectional analysis. Figure 2(b) show the
comparison between the envelope of the cyclic loading test by Tseng et al. [12] and
the pushover curve of the shell-frame model. The numerical model could be vali-
dated from the consistent results.
Although the shell-frame model was shown to be capable of capturing the nonlinear
response of the RC frame with opening wall, the required execution time could be
very long for a prototype RC building frame with parapet walls. Since the parapet
wall is monolithically cast with the underneath rectangular beam section, a planar
beam-column sub-assemblage was used to evaluate if they could be simulated with
an inverted T-section model. The beam-column sub-assemblage was extracted from
the first floor of a seismically designed five-story RC frame, which is introduced in
a later section. It had four bays with a constant 6 m span length and the middle
bottom column was removed, as shown in Fig. 4.
Pinned-end conditions were assumed for all the column stubs. Uniformly dis-
tributed gravitational loadings were imposed on the beam members. Two different
finite element models were constructed for the sub-assemblage. One was con-
structed with rectangular beam elements and layered shell elements as the parapet
a b
fc f c' xr fs
fc = 2 fc' r ε − εc
r −1 + x r fc = ( cu ) fu
f’c r −1 + 2 r ε cu − 2ε c'
fy
x = ε c / ε c' f s = f y + ( fu − f y )
ε − ε sh
r = E /( E − fc' / ε c' ) ε u − ε sh
1 15
w w w w
100
#3@15
600
#3@10
1
6-#7
60
600 600 600 600 3-#7
walls. However, they were combined into inverted T-section beam elements in the
other model. Lumped hinges were assigned to the ends of the rectangular beam
elements in the former model and the ends of the inverted T-section members in the
latter. The hinge properties were determined from the sectional analysis results.
Figures 5(a) and 5(b) show the normalized moment-rotation curves of the rectan-
gular and inverted-T sections, respectively. The piecewise linear approximations of
the curves for the structural models were also shown in the figures. Nonlinear static
pushdown analyses were carried out for the two models under uniformly distributed
beam loads. The loading resistance versus deflection of the column-removed joint
responses of the two models is compared in Fig. 6(a). It is seen that although the
inverted T-section model revealed slightly larger initial stiffness than the more
rigorous shell-frame model, they had similar variations of loading resistance. In
addition, they had similar variations of the accumulated strain energy as shown in
Fig. 6(b). Hence, the inverted T-section members could be used to account for the
influence of the exterior parapet walls.
a 2 b 1.5
Rectangular section Inverted T-section
1.5 1
1
0.5
0.5
M/My
M/My
0
0
-0.5
-0.5
Hinge model
Hinge model
-1 -1 Sectional analysis
Sectional analysis
-1.5 -1.5
-0.2 -0.15 -0.1 -0.05 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 -0.15 -0.1 -0.05 0 0.05 0.1 0.15
Rotation (rad) Rotation (rad)
a 3500 b 1200
3000 1000
800
2000
600
1500
400
1000
Inverted T-section Inverted T-section
500 200
Layered shell + beam-column Layered shell + beam-column
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Displacement (cm) Displacement (cm)
Fig. 6 a The load-deflection curves of the two models b Cumulative energy curves of the two
models
3
Ly
2
Ly
C1
1
Lx Lx Lx Lx
A B C D E
Plan view
The Influence of Non-structural Exterior Wall … 347
inversely triangular pattern. The effective structural weight was equal to (1.0DL +
0.25LL). Load combinations of (1.2DL + 1.6LL) and (1.2DL + 1.0LL + 1.0EQ)
were used for the structural design. A minimum beam depth equal to one tenth of its
center-to-center span length was used in the sectional design for minimizing the
elastic deflection under service loads. Also, the maximum reinforcement ratio of
beam sections was set as 1.2%. Since the building frames have fewer bays in the
transverse direction, more reinforcement was required for the transverse beams.
However, for the sake of simplicity, same reinforcement ratio was used in both the
longitudinal and transverse directions and same section dimensions were used in each
building frame. The column sections were determined according to the strong
column-and-weak beam mechanism. Table 1 shows the longitudinal fundamental
periods of the building frames. In the table, the buildings were designated by their
number of stories, span lengths, and seismic coefficients. For example, the desig-
nation of 10S06R10 stands for the ten-story building frame with span length of 6 m
and seismic coefficient of 0.10.
Nonlinear static (NS) analyses were conducted for the lateral seismic resistances
and column-loss resistances of the aforementioned building models. The former
was obtained from the NS pushover analyses under the inversely triangular loads in
the longitudinal direction, while the latter was from the NS pushdown analyses
under the bottom C1-column loss scenario, as indicated in Fig. 7, and subject to
uniformly distributed gravitational loads. As mentioned in an earlier section,
lumped plastic hinges were assigned to the end of structural members. Piece-wise
linear hinge properties determined from sectional analysis were adopted for the
rectangular and inverted-T beam sections. However, the hinge properties suggested
in the FEMA-356 guidelines [2] were adopted for the column members. The lon-
gitudinal pushover and downward pushdown curves of the seven building frames
with and without the parapet walls were compared.
The longitudinal (X) pushover curves of the seven building frames without and
with parapet walls are shown in Figs. 8(a) and 8(b), respectively. In the figures, the
ordinate is the base shear normalized by the design structural weight
(1.0DL + 0.25LL) and the abscissa is the global drift ratio determined from
dividing the roof displacement by the building height. The yield base shear, Vy,
which was determined as the base shear corresponding to the first appearance of
structural hinges, of the seven building frames without parapet walls and the cor-
responding seismic coefficient (Cs) are summarized in Table 1. The frames with
10 m span length present apparently larger normalized seismic resistance than the
others in the figures. This is because that the bottom reinforcement at the beam ends
were determined by the minimum reinforcement requirement that the positive
moment strength at joint faces shall be not less than one-half the negative moment
strength provided at that face of the joint. Table 1 indicates that resulting seismic
coefficients generally agree with the original design values.
The comparison of Fig. 8(a) and 8(b) reveals that the peak pushover resistance
generally increased with consideration of the parapet walls. However, the roof drift
ratio corresponding to the peak resistance decreased. From the hinge development
process during the pushover analysis, it was observed that the strong-column and
weak-beam mechanism could not be held with the parapet walls. Since the flexural
strengths of the inverted-T sections were significantly larger than that of the original
rectangular ones, the plastic hinges could thus appear on the column ends earlier
than on the beam ends. Due to the larger flexural strength and smaller plastic
rotation capacity of the column hinges, the horizontal seismic resistance may
increase, but with reduced corresponding drift ratio.
a 0.5 b 0.5
Without parapet walls 05S04R15 With parapet walls 05S04R15
0.45 0.45
05S06R15 05S06R15
0.4 0.4
R/(1.2DL+0.25LL)
R/(1.2DL+0.25LL)
05S10R15
05S10R15
0.35 0.35 10S06R10
10S06R10
0.3 0.3 10S06R15
10S06R15
0.25 0.25 10S06R22
10S06R22
15S06R15
0.2 15S06R15 0.2
0.15 0.15
0.1 0.1
0.05 0.05
0 0
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05
Roof drift (rad) Roof drift (rad)
Fig. 8 a Pushover curves without parapet walls b Pushover curves with parapet walls
The Influence of Non-structural Exterior Wall … 349
Uniform loading pattern was adopted in the NS pushdown analysis. The dynamic
effect under column loss was not considered in the NS analysis. Therefore, the
dynamic collapse resistance was determined from the pseudo-static response curve,
which was constructed from the NS pushdown curve by using the work-energy
principle as [11]
Zud
PCC ðud Þ ¼ PNS ðuÞdu=ud ð1Þ
0
where PNS ðuÞ is the loading resistance from the NS pushdown curve and PCC ðud Þ is
the pseudo-static loading resistance at the deflection demand ud . Figures 9(a) and 9
(b) show the pseudo-static response curves of the seven building frames without
and with parapet walls, respectively. The ordinate in the figures is the total imposed
gravitational loading normalized by the design structural weight (1.0DL + 0.25LL).
The abscissa is the chord rotation defined as the displacement of the
column-removed joint divided by the span length. The dynamic collapse resistance
of the seven building frames under the column loss were then determined from the
peak pseudo-static loading response. It is observed from the figures that the collapse
resistance was generally increased with the parapet walls, especially for the
buildings with shorter span, less story number, and lower seismic design coefficient.
Except for the 10S06R22 and 15S06R15 buildings, the collapse resistance was
developed at a much smaller chord rotation. This means that although the collapse
resistance was increased with the parapet walls, the corresponding ductility capacity
was significantly reduced. Therefore, it is more probable to fail in a brittle manner
under the column loss conditions.
a 10 b 10
9 With parapet walls
9 Without parapet walls
05S04R15 05S06R15 05S10R15 10S06R10
8 05S04R15 05S06R15 05S10R15 10S06R10 8
R/(1.2DL+0.25LL)
R/(1.2DL+0.25LL)
Fig. 9 a Pseudo-static response curves without parapet walls b Pseudo-static response curves
with parapet walls
350 M. H. TSAI
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The financial support provided by the Ministry of Science and Technology,
Taiwan, under the grant number MOST 07-2221-E-020-005 is gratefully acknowledged.
References
Abstract A spherical sliding bearing (SSB) has been only used as a seismic iso-
lation bearing for buildings in Japan. In order to apply the SSB to bridges, it is
necessary to ensure that the SSB performs properly under design loads. This study
investigates the behavior of the SSB under live load action by static loading tests on
a bridge superstructure model supported by SSBs. Also, the finite element analyses
were carried out to simulate the tests and to understand the behavior of the bearings.
1 Introduction
Although laminated rubber bearings are widely used as seismic isolation bearings in
many bridges in Japan, some of them were damaged during major earthquakes in
recent years. These damages were assumed to be due to the combination of aging
degradation of laminated rubber and earthquake forces. Therefore, there is a need to
develop another type of bearings as well as the laminated rubber bearings for
seismic isolation. Spherical sliding bearings have been applied for seismic isolation
since the 1990s in some seismic regions. There are some advantages in using SSB.
The SSB has a restoring mechanism by pendulum motion and a damping mecha-
nism by frictional force. Also, because the natural period of the SSB depends on the
radius of the concave plate, it is easy to achieve the long natural period of the
H. Oyabu (&)
Graduate School of Engineering, Utsunomiya University, Utsunomiya, Japan
e-mail: h.oyabu@civitec.co.jp
S. Fujikura N. M. Hai A. Nakajima
Department of Civil Engineering and Regional Design, Utsunomiya University,
Utsunomiya, Japan
S. Takeuchi
Tokyo Division, Sogo Engineering Consultant, Tokyo, Japan
structure. In order to apply the SSB to bridges, the bearings are required to transfer
live loads from a superstructure to a substructure and to perform properly under live
load action and also displacement due to temperature changes. Therefore, this study
investigates the behavior of the SSB, especially double SSB, under live load action
by static loading tests on a bridge superstructure model supported by double SSBs.
In particular, we wish to investigate the rotation of the bearings and the displace-
ment of the sliders due to the deflection of the superstructure.
A static loading was applied at the center of the beam supported by two SSBs to
replicate the deflection angle at the bearings from the design calculations. Figure 1
shows the details of the double SSB. The double SSB consisted of a slider and two
concave plates. The slider had two spherical convex surfaces at its top and bottom
which interface with sliding surfaces. The two sliding surfaces of the slider are
coated with a sliding sheet with PTFE composite material. The concave plate had a
concave surface with a spherical radius of 2500 mm.
Figure 2 shows the details of experimental setup. A steel H-beam specimen was
supported by two SSBs, Bearing A and Bearing B have a 4 m span. Two different
steel H-beams were used as shown in Fig. 3; Beam 1 was H-200 200 8 12
and Beam 2 was H-300 150 6.5 9. A cycle static loading was applied at
the center of the span, and the maximum load of 20, 50 and 100 kN was applied at
each cycle. The vertical reaction force of both bearings were measured by the load
cells placed under the bearings as shown in Fig. 2. Some of the displacements
around the bearings were also measured by a displacement gauges. The deflection
Behavior of Bridge Superstructure Model … 355
angle at the bearings, h, was calculated by using the vertical displacements at two
sides of the bearing placed 400 mm apart (VD1 and VD2) as follows (Fig. 4);
1 VD2 VD1
h ¼ tan ð1Þ
400
Finite element analyses were performed by using ABAQUS. Figure 5 presents one
half of the analytical model based on symmetric conditions. The specimen was
modeled in 2-dimension by using shell elements for all members. The width of the
member was given as its thickness of the shell element. The boundary conditions at
the center span are no horizontal displacement and no rotation but the vertical
displacement is free. The one at the bottom of lower bearing was to fix the vertical
displacement and the rotation, and a spring was attached in the horizontal direction
356 H. Oyabu et al.
as shown in Fig. 6 because the base of the bearing slightly moved during the
experiment. Its spring constant was set as 5 kN/mm. The contact between the slider
and concave plates was modeled using frictional contact in parallel to the surface
and allowing uplift in perpendicular to the surface. The other members are con-
nected as a rigid connection. The coefficient of friction for the sliding surface, l,
was defined as [2];
l ¼ l0 c ð2Þ
3 Experimental Results
Figures 7 and 8 show the experimental results of the deflection angle-slider dis-
placement relationship for Beam 1 and Beam 2, respectively, along with the ana-
lytical results. The load was applied to generate more than the deflection angle of
0.00465 rad and 0.00544 rad for live load and allowable displacement, respec-
tively. The maximum deflection angle of Beam 1 and Beam 2 is 0.01110 rad and
0.00706 rad, respectively. The hysteresis loop of the slider is similar to a triangular
shape or a trapezoidal shape. At the beginning of loading or unloading, the slider
does not slide for a certain deflection angle, and then the slider starts sliding. After a
cycle of loading, the slider returns to an original position. The hysteresis loop of
analyses is close to the average one of experiments.
Average
0.00544rad
0.005
0.00465rad
0
0 1 2 3
Displacement of slider (mm)
358 H. Oyabu et al.
0.00544rad
0.005
0.00465rad
0
0 1 2 3
Displacement of slider (mm)
The frictional force is calculated by considering the equilibrium at the edge of the
slider assuming that the slider contacted at its edge due to the rotation of the
bearing. While loading, the horizontal reaction force, H, is the sum of the horizontal
component of the friction force, F’, and normal force of reaction, N, as shown in
Fig. 9 and is calculated as follows;
where W is a force including self-weight and the applied load and hL is a contact
angle which is the tangent angle at the edge of the slider.
While unloading, the horizontal reaction force is calculated as
Load (kN)
50
Unloading Loading
0
−2 0 2
Horizontal reaction force (kN)
Figure 10 compares the horizontal reaction force between the analytical results
and the theoretical Eqs. (4) in red line and (5) in blue line. The theoretical equations
are close to the analysis values. Note that the analytical results also show the
transition between loading and unloading.
4 Conclusions
The behaviour of the double SSB under live load was investigated herein. The
results are summarized as follows;
1. The slider returned to the original position after a cycle of loadings, and the
hysteresis loop was similar to a triangular shape or a trapezoidal shape.
2. The horizontal reaction force is the sum of the horizontal component of the
friction force and the normal force of reaction.
Acknowledgements Supports and advice from Mr. Tadayuki Noro and Dr. Shinsuke Yamazaki,
Nippon Steel Engineering Co., Ltd, are gratefully acknowledged.
References
1. Japan Road Association (2017) Specifications for highway bridges”, Part 1 (General), 93–102.
(in Japanese)
2. Nishimoto K, Nakamura S, Hasegawa H, Wakita N (2016) Bearing stress and velocity
dependency of spherical sliding bearing through large-scale tests. Summaries of technical
papers of annual meeting in Architectural Institute of Japan 2016, pp 445–446
Numerical Analysis of Seepage
for Saturated-Unsaturated Pavement
Structure Under Rainfall Conditions
1 Introduction
Water damage is one of the main kinds of pavement distress in rainy area. Although
there are numerous reasons that lead to water damage of pavement structure, in
essence, it is closely related with the saturated-unsaturated seepage in the pavement.
Moisture has significant impact on the strength, stiffness and stability of the
pavement. When moisture penetrate into the pavement, the strength, stiffness and
stability of the pavement will decline to varying degrees. If not treated well in time,
water damage will occur in the pavement structure inevitably [10]. Based on the
above reasons, the study of seepage characteristics of pavement structure has both
theoretical and practical value.
The seepage problems in the pavement structure engineering are mostly
saturated-unsaturated. The researchers have done numerous numerical analysis on
this problem. However, in the past, due to the limitation of theory and method, only
seepage in the saturated zone under phreatic line was analyzed and the unsaturated
zone was neglected. It is obvious that this assumption was unable to give a true and
comprehensive show of the seepage of saturated-unsaturated pavement, which
would naturally cause poor accuracy in analysis results [2]. In 1973, Neuman
presented a finite element method (FEM) to solve the seepage problem, which
regarded saturated zone and unsaturated zone as a whole, laying a foundation for
numerical analysis of saturated-unsaturated seepage [6]. The basic theory for
numerical analysis of saturated-unsaturated seepage is Richards’ equation, which
can be expressed as follows in tensor symbols [8]:
where the hydraulic conductivity kij ¼ kij ðhÞ is a function of pressure head coor-
dinate h; vi is the velocity of water flow; denotes the derivative with respect to
spatial coordinate k; Hjk is the hydraulic head, which is the summation of pressure
head hdjk and elevation Djk;
where dij is the Kronecker d function; Djk equals to 0 except for j = k = 3, i.e. On the
basis of Richards’ equation, Miller proposed that the hydraulic conductivity in
unsaturated zone is a function of pressure head or moisture content, which provided
theoretical basis for the application of Darcy’s law to saturated-unsaturated seepage [5].
In the numerical analysis process of saturated-unsaturated seepage, the deter-
mination of unsaturated permeability is one of the most important parts in numerical
computation. Whether the numerical solution is reasonable highly depends on the
unsaturated permeability is right or wrong. Unsaturated permeability mainly con-
tains SWCC and unsaturated hydraulic conductivity [3]. The former one is an index
to the capacity of porous media containing water and the latter one demonstrates the
Numerical Analysis of Seepage … 363
In the saturated seepage process, the hydraulic conductivity of any point in the
material is often regarded as a fixed value, while in the unsaturated seepage process,
the water content and hydraulic conductivity of the material are time-dependent
variables. In this section, a governing PDE for saturated-unsaturated seepage is
derived by using principle of effective stress and material compressibility, and a
solution to saturated-unsaturated seepage problem is presented.
0
rij ¼ rij þ uw dij ð3Þ
where rij is the total stress resulting from external load; r0ij is the effective stress, a
good approximation of the stress transmitted through the skeleton; uw is the water
pressure acting over the entire water area. When rij changes, r0ij and uw will change
as well. Equation (3) can be expressed using incremental format as follows:
where a superimposed dot indicates the variation rate with respect to time. If rij
is kept to be a constant while uw varies, Eq. (4) can be deduced to be as follows:
1 @Vw 1 @q
b¼ ¼ ð6Þ
Vw @uw q @uw
where Vw and q are volume and density of a given mass of water subjected to
pressure changes respectively. The minus sign indicates decrease in volume as
pressure increases. The solid matrix of the aquifer is elastic and not rigid. In a
similar way, the elastic property of the solid matrix is expressed by its coefficient of
compressibility a, defined as follows:
1 @V
adij ¼ ð7Þ
V @r0ij
where V is the bulk volume of a porous medium. The deformation of solid matrix
involves a movement of the solid particles and their rearrangement, such that the
porosity of the porous medium changes. It should be assumed that the deformation
of the solid particles is much smaller than the solid matrix as a whole, so that the
Numerical Analysis of Seepage … 365
@Vs
¼0 ð9Þ
@r0ij
where e is the porosity. Substituting Eqs. (5), (8), and (9) into Eq. (7), it can be
derived that:
1 @e
a¼ ð10Þ
1 e @uw
The most common approach to model liquid flow in porous media is to combine the
equation of linear momentum balance with the mass balance equation. Neglecting
the inertial and viscous effects, the PDE of seepage flow for saturated pavement
(Darcy’s law) can be written as follows:
h i
c_ qkij hdjk þ Djk ;k ¼ 0 ð11Þ
;i
where kij is a constant; c is the product of porosity e and density q, just as follows:
c ¼ eq ð12Þ
Assuming the Darcy’s law is suitable for unsaturated seepage, the PDE of
seepage flow for unsaturated pavement can be obtained from Eq. (11) as follows:
h i
c_ 0 qkij ðhÞ hdjk þ Djk ;k ¼ 0 ð13Þ
;i
where kij(h) is not a constant but a function of pressure head; c0 is the product of
porosity e, density q and saturation Sw, just as follows:
c0 ¼ eqSw ð14Þ
Considering that water pressure uw and pressure head h have the following
relation:
366 J. H. Zheng et al.
uw ¼ qgh ð15Þ
where g is the acceleration of gravity. Substituting Eqs. (6), (10) and (15) into the
first term of Eq. (13), we have
að1 eÞ @Sw
c_ 0 ¼ qe Sw þ Sw b þ u_ w ¼ ðqSw S þ qCÞh_ ð16Þ
e @uw
where S is the storage coefficient and C is the moisture capacity, which can be
expressed as follows:
@Sw @hw
C ¼ qge ¼ ð18Þ
@uw @h
2.4 SWCC
SWCC is used to describe the relation between moisture content and pressure head
or matrix suction [1]. In this section, the relation between moisture content and
pressure head will be discussed. Pressure head will change as moisture content
increases or decreases in the unsaturated domain, which means that pressure head is
Numerical Analysis of Seepage … 367
the variable function of moisture content and vice versa. At the present, SWCC
can’t be obtained through the theoretical analysis but is drawn through experimental
tests or correction based on existing models [7]. In recent years, as the unsaturated
soil mechanics are gradually applied in engineering, the research of SWCC takes a
further step and more and more mathematical models are used to simulate SWCC.
These models provide convenience for unsaturated soil mechanic theory being used
in practical engineering. In this paper, VG model will be used for numerical
analysis of seepage of saturated-unsaturated pavement structure, which has a wide
acceptance for most researchers. It is expressed as follows [11]:
m
1
hw ð hÞ ¼ hr þ ð hs hr Þ ð20Þ
1 þ jahjn
where hr and hs are residual water content and saturated water content respectively;
a, m and n are three parameters for the SWCC model. From Eq. (20), moisture
capacity C and saturation Sw can be obtained and saturated-unsaturated seepage
problems can be solved with Eqs. (19) and (20).
3 Numerical Examples
3.1 Modelling
In this example, the modeling domain is made up of the three permeable soil layers,
each of which is represented by a rectangular domain of 2D. The top layer is the
bituminous concrete mixture. The second layer is the graded aggregate base and the
bottom one is the roadbed. The water moves through the asphaltic concrete and
graded broken stone into the roadbed. The rainfall intensity and the groundwater
level are known and there is no flow through the vertical walls. The geometry
model is shown in Fig. 1.
In order to get the storage coefficient S of each layer, we should know its
mechanical properties firstly. The relationship between bulk modulus K and elastic
modulus E is shown as follows:
368 J. H. Zheng et al.
300cm
226cm
300cm
Q2<<Q1
-(z+a)
Numerical Analysis of Seepage … 369
E
K¼ ð21Þ
3ð1 2lÞ
where l is the poisson ratio. And S is the inverse of K. Scan be calculated with
Table 2.
The material parameters that will be needed in modelling for each layer are
shown in Table 3.
In this model, the groundwater level G is set to be from −1.0 to −2.5 m with the
interval being −0.3 m. And the rainfall intensity Q is taken from 1e−8 to 5e−6 m/s,
which include the cases of light rain, moderate rain, heavy rain, torrential rain,
downpour and rainstorm.
The boundary and initial conditions are shown in Fig. 2.
3.2 Results
For convenience, the saturation of point A (1.5, −0.5) and point B (1.5, −0.7) at
different time is studied to show the seepage effects due to different rainfall
intensities and groundwater levels, which are presented by Figs. 3 and 4.
Figures 3a and 4a have respectively demonstrated the variation of saturation at
points A and B due to different rainfall intensities over time. From Figs. 3a and 4a,
it can be seen that with the increase of the rainfall intensity, the time needed to reach
to be saturated is decreasing gradually. Figures 3b and 4b separately stand for the
changes of saturation at the two points due to different groundwater levels as time
goes on. From Figs. 3b and 4b, it is known that during the process of rainfall, the
increment of saturation at a certain time remains to be the same before the saturated
Q=1e-7m/s G=-1.0m
Q=3e-7m/s G=-1.3m
1.00 Q=6e-7m/s 1.00 G=-1.6m
Q=1e-6m/s 0.95 G=-1.9m
Q=3e-6m/s G=-2.2m
0.95 0.90
Q=5e-6m/s G=-2.5m
0.85
0.90
0.80
Saturation
Saturation
0.85 0.75
0.70
0.80
0.65
0.75 0.60
0.55
0.70 0.50
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Time (h) Time (h)
a. The variation of saturation of point A at b. The variation of saturation of point A at
different time when the groundwater level is different time when the rainfall intensity is
-1.5m 1e-6m/s
Q=1e-7m/s G=1.0m
Q=3e-7m/s G=1.3m
Q=6e-7m/s 1.00 G=1.6m
1.00 Q=1e-6m/s G=1.9m
0.95
Q=3e-6m/s G=2.2m
Q=5e-6m/s 0.90 G=2.5m
0.95
0.85
Saturation
Saturation
0.80
0.90
0.75
0.70
0.85 0.65
0.60
0.80 0.55
0.50
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Time (h) Time (h)
a. The variation of saturation of point B at b. The variation of saturation of point B at
different time when the groundwater level is different time when the rainfall intensity is
-1.5m 1e-6m/s
state is reached, which means that the groundwater level has a definite effect in the
process of rainfall infiltration.
As to analyse the variation of saturation at different depths, the saturation curves
after 10 and 15 h are calculated and drawn in Figs. 5 and 6.
Figures 5a and 6a have respectively demonstrated the variation of saturation
after 10 and 15 h due to different rainfall intensities changing with depth. From
Figs. 5a and 6a, it can be seen that with the increase of the rainfall intensity, the
rainfall infiltration becomes faster. Figures 5b and 6b separately stand for the
variation of saturation after 10 and 15 h due to different groundwater levels
changing with depth. According to Figs. 5b and 6b, it is known that the pavement
with higher groundwater level reaches to be saturated faster than with lower
groundwater level under the same rainfall condition. From Figs. 5 and 6, we can
know that the saturations at 0.18 and 0.74 m below the pavement have sudden
Q=1e-7m/s G=-1.0m
Q=3e-7m/s G=-1.3m
Q=6e-7m/s G=-1.6m
0.0 Q=1e-6m/s 0.0 G=-1.9m
Q=3e-6m/s G=-2.2m
Q=5e-6m/s G=-2.5m
-0.5 -0.5
Y (m)
Y (m)
-1.0 -1.0
-1.5 -1.5
0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00
Saturation Saturation
a. The variation of saturation after 10 hours b. The variation of saturation after 10 hours
at different depths when the groundwater at different depths when the rainfall
level is -1.5m intensity is 1e-6m/s
G=1.0m
Q=1e-7m/s
G=1.3m
Q=3e-7m/s
G=1.6m
Q=6e-7m/s
0.0 G=1.9m
0.0 Q=1e-6m/s
Q=3e-6m/s G=2.2m
Q=5e-6m/s G=2.5m
-0.5 -0.5
Y (m)
Y (m)
-1.0 -1.0
-1.5 -1.5
change. The reason is that at these two positions two different layers are connected,
and the critical positions of different layers have the same water content hw but the
different saturated water contents hs .
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of
China (No. 51508305). The authors are solely responsible for the content.
References
1. Fredlund DG, Xing AQ (1994) Equations for the soil-water characteristic curve. Can
Geotech J 31(4):521–532
2. Klute A (1952) Some theoretical aspects of the flow of water in unsaturated soils. Soil Sci Soc
Am Proc 16(2):144–148
3. Kuang X, Sansalone J, Ying G (2011) Pore-structure models of hydraulic conductivity for
permeable pavement. J Hydrol 399(3–4):148–157
4. Mahboub KC, Liu YH, Allen DL (2005) Asphalt overlay and subsurface drainage of broken
and seated concrete pavement. J Transp Eng 131(8):617–622
372 J. H. Zheng et al.
5. Miller EE, Topp GC (1966) Hysteretic moisture characteristics and hydraulic conductivities
for glass-bead media. Soil Sci Soc Am Proc 30(2):156–162
6. Neuman Shlomo P (1973) Saturated-unsaturated seepage by finite elements. ASCE J Hydraul
Div 99(12):2233–2250
7. Norambuena CJ, Arbat G, Garcia Nieto PJ (2014) FEM-based numerical simulation of water
flow through a road shoulder structure. Int J Nonlinear Sci Num Simul 15(1):57–67
8. Richards LA (1931) Capillary conduction of liquids through porous medium. Phys (Am Inst
Phys Am Phys Soc Soc Rheol) 1(5):318–333
9. Rabab’ah S, Liang RY (2007) Finite element modelling of field performance of permeable
bases under asphalt pavement. Transp Res Rec 2004:163–172
10. Stormont JC, Zhou SX (2005) Impact of unsaturated flow on pavement edgedrain
performance. J Transp Eng 131(1):46–53
11. Van Genuchten MT (1982) A comparison of numerical solutions of the one-dimensional
unsaturated-saturated flow and mass transport equations. Adv Water Resour 5(1):47–55
Composite Action Between Steel Girder
and Precast Concrete Considering
Haunches/Mortar and Stud’s
Geometrical Configurations
Abstract Due to deterioration and damages of existing RC decks for steel girders
in Japan, redecking to PCaPC deck is significantly increasing under limited budget
and construction period. By considering cover concrete and arrangement of PC
cables and rebars, it needed to design superstructure as a non-composite steel girder
after redecking, strengthening of the main girder tends to increase. To restrain
strengthening of the main girder, it should be urgently clarified composite action
between a deck and a main girder jointed by headed studs. Authors conducted a
push-out test for RC and PCaPC deck considering geometrical configuration at the
field, such as haunch and thin layer mortar. From the experimental results, it is
found that cracks of thin mortar layer of PCaPC specimen might lead deterioration
of the shear resistance partially, however, its yield strength could be similar to that
of the RC specimen. It is also found that composite action between concrete slab
and a girder by headed studs for PCaPC deck could be expected as the same as that
of RC deck, considering the relative slip at the stud position and its regions’
slip. Furthermore, it is confirmed that the arrangement and the number of studs will
affect the yield strength of composite structure consisted by thin mortar layer which
is connected by the studs.
T. Matsumoto N. Mitsukawa
CTI Engineering, Co. Ltd., Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: matsumoto-takashi@ctie.co.jp
N. Mitsukawa
e-mail: mitukawa@ctie.co.jp
F. Asano (&) T. Yamaguchi
Department of Civil Engineering, Osaka City University, Osaka, Japan
e-mail: asano@brdg.civil.eng.osaka-cu.ac.jp
T. Yamaguchi
e-mail: yamaguti-t@osaka-cu.ac.jp
1 Introduction
Headed Stud
Pocket
Pre-stressed Precast Pocket
Deck (PCaPC deck)
Detail of Pocket
Thin Mortar
Layer
Main Girder
2 Specification of Specimen
Table 1 and Fig. 2 shows the specific details of the specimens. For each specimen,
the deck thickness, haunch height and haunch gradient are set commonly as
200 mm, 30 mm and 1:3, respectively.
Based on the NEXCO criteria, more than 20 mm of thin layer mortar is stan-
dardly provided among PCaPC deck and main girder, to adjust the height of road
surface and attachment between them by considering the splice plates and bolt nuts.
Therefore, in this test, 20 mm thickness of thin mortar layer is provided for the
PCaPC deck specimens.
Arrangement of stud for each specimen subjected to JSHB criteria. For the
specimen PCa1_n4, PCa3_n4, PCa4_n8 series, center to center spacing of stud is
set as more than stud’s diameter +30 mm. On the other hand, the center of stud is
set as 25 mm from the edge of flange for the PCa2_n4 specimens.
Table 2 Concrete and mortar strength tested on the day of push-out test
Series of RC1_n4 PCa1_n4 PCa2_n4 PCa3_n6 PCa4_n8
specimen
Material Conc. Conc. Mor. Conc. Mor. Conc. Mor. Conc. Mor.
Ave. 50.3 65.1 57.9 64.2 64.0 63.4 66.1 72.8 68.0
Compression
Strength (N/
mm2)
Ave. Tensile 3.27 4.45 3.60 3.90 3.46 3.93 4.27 4.62 3.34
Strength (N/
mm2)
Ave. Young’s 38.3 38.5 26.4 38.2 27.2 39.1 26.9 40.9 30.4
Modules (kN/
mm2)
Ave. Poisson 0.185 0.190 0.213 0.191 0.232 0.211 0.214 0.202 0.241
Ratio
The design strength of concrete for RC deck and PCaPC deck specimens aimed
to gain 24 and 50 N/mm2 on the day of test, respectively. Table 2 shows the
strength of the concrete and mortar conducted at the day of experiment. It is known
from the test result that the strength of concrete and mortar was tends to be high
compared to the design strength. Tensile strength is also summarized in same table.
Product procedure of PCaPC deck specimens is shown in Fig. 3. Firstly, con-
crete slab with a pocket is product. After slab has hardened, they are set to the
formwork, and pour the mortar from pocket to connect between deck and flange.
Posision A
75mm
Posision B
75mm
Posision C
3 Measurements
4 Sequence of Tests
4.0mm
...(+0.5mm)
1.5mm
1.0mm
...(+0.2mm)
0.4mm …. ….
0 2 mm
Sequence Step
5 Experiment Results
5.1.1 Relationship Between Shear Force Per Stud and Relative Slip
at Stud Position
Figure 6(a) and (b) show the relationship between shear force per stud and overall
displacement/relative slip for RC1 and PCa1 specimens, respectively. Shear force
per stud is defined here by load applied dividing number of studs. Maximum shear
force per stud for RC and PCa1 specimen is 100.9 and 156.8 kN (value for PCa1 is
average of PCa-1, PCa-2, PCa-3), respectively. This means that the ultimate
resistance of PCa1 was 36% lower than that of RC1.
From Fig. 6, decrease of shear resistance is occurred for all PCa1 specimens
when relative slip reaches 0.4 mm, which was the first cracking of thin mortar layer
as shown in Fig. 7. For RC1 specimen, nor noticeable cracking or damage at the
haunch or deck is observed and decrease of shear resistance does not occurred.
(a) Shear force per stud vs. global displacement (b) Shear force per stud vs. relative slip
(a) Crack at the thin mortar layer (b) Cracking occurred region
Fig. 7 Cracking of the thin mortar layer at 0.4 mm relative slip phase
Figure 8 shows the progress of cracking of PCa1-1 at the thin mortar layer.
Number of crack and its width are increased and widened around the stud, and
finally peeled off due to the density concentration of crack. Vulnerable of thin
mortar layer causes the exposure of stud, which induces not only shear force but
with bending moment to the studs. On the other hand, crack and peeling of concrete
at haunch are not observed for RC1 during the test, which indicates that only shear
force is applied to the stud.
It concludes that cracking of thin mortar layer causes the decrease of resistance
shear force for composite structure connected by studs, and reduction of maximum
shear force of PCa specimen, which is governed by combination of shear and
bending moment acted on the studs.
Table 3 shows the response of relative slip at position A, B and C for the yield
shear strength level specified in JSSC. Definition of yield shear strength Qy stated in
JSSC is the intersection point strength between 1/3 of the maximum shear force and
0.2 mm offset line from its origin of relative slip having the same initial gradient
(shown in Fig. 6). The relative slip normalized by the obtained response at position
B are shown in Fig. 9(b) and (c) for the yield strength of each specimen.
(a) 1.0 mm relative slip phase (b) 4.0 mm relative slip phase (c) After final loading
Table 3 Summary of yield shear strength and relative slip for RC1 and PC1 specimen
Position Specimens Average Relative Slip
RC1 PCa1 of PCa1 (mm)
PCa1-1 PCa1-2 PCa1-3
Yield Shear Strength 63.25 48.50 41.80 44.40 –
Qy(kN) Average: 44.90
Relative A 0.963 0.256 0.160 0.242 0.219
Slip (mm) B 0.930 0.242 0.209 0.222 0.224
C 0.950 0.238 0.216 0.160 0.205
RC1 PCa1
It is noted that the yield shear strength of PCaPC is decreased to 71% of that of
RC, however, relative slip is about 4.2 times bigger than that of RC. This suggests
that PCaPC deck will behave as ductile structure as for considering the actual field
Composite Action Between Steel Girder … 381
Stud fracture surfaces after the test of RC1 and PCa1 are shown in Fig. 10. Due to
the predominant shear force action on the stud for RC1, the fracture surface is cut
straightly along vertically direction as shown in Fig. 10(a). On the other hand,
fracture surface of PCa1 stud is curved as shown in Fig. 10(b) because of applying
both bending moment and shear force after cracking of thin mortar layer.
To clarify the damage progress around studs of RC1 and PCa1, they are cut by
diamond wire as shown in Fig. 11(a) through (c), which show cut section of deck at
No. 2 position after the test respectively. From those surface observations, it is
noted that cracking and destruction of concrete and mortar occurred only around the
roots of the studs. This means that the resistance strength and relative slip between
concrete/mortar and flange connected by studs is depended on the damage around
stud roots.
7
(a) Cut position (b) RC1, section No.2 (c) PCa1-3, section No.2
Table 4 summaries the maximum shear force of each stud for specimen PCa1 to
PCa4. The maximum shear force of each stud is largest for PCa3 and, the lowest for
PCa4 which is decreased to about 88% of that of PCa3.
Figure 12 shows relation between shear force per stud and relative slip for PCa
specimens. It is found that PCaPC behave elastically until it reaches yield shear
strength, which is before the crack at the thin mortar occurred. Accordingly, it is
concluded that the strength and composite action of PCaPC deck used for redecking
depends on the thin mortar layer.
Figure 13 shows the fracture surface of studs and mortar section No. 2 for PCa1 to
PCa4. Red line shows a region of crack and crushing of thin mortar layer due to
compressive and shear force by deformation of the stud.
As shown in Figs. 13(a) and (b), the maximum shear strength of PCa2 was
higher than that of PCa1 due to overlap of cracking and destruction adjacent studs
does not appear in the case of PCa2, because studs are arranged enough apart. On
the other hand, the close arrangement of studs like PCa4 decreases the yield shear
strength because of widespread overlap of cracks and crushing around studs as
shown in Fig. 13(d). Even though the overlap of cracking and crushing are pro-
gressed widely in the case of PCa3 as shown in Fig. 13(c), the maximum shear
force of PCa3 was the highest among them.
This result state that the arrangement and number of studs severely influence the
yield shear strength, the maximum shear strength and damage progression.
Table 4 Maximum shear force and yield shear strength of each stud
Specimen Number Average Maximum Average Yield Average
of Stud Shear Force for each Shear Strength Qy Relative Slip at
Stud (kN) (kN) Qy (mm)
PCa1 4 100.9 {0.89} 44.90 0.22
PCa2 4 107.7 {0.95} 44.49 0.27
PCa3 6 113.3 {1.00} 41.20 0.25
PCa4 8 100.3 {0.88} 40.50 0.43
Composite Action Between Steel Girder … 383
Fig. 12 Comparison of shear force per stud vs. relative slip for each specimen
(a)PCa1-3 (b)PCa2-1
(c)PCa3-2 (d)PCa4-2
Fig. 13 Fracture surface of stud and mortar for PCa1 to PCa4 specimens
384 T. Matsumoto et al.
6 Conclusions
Push-out test conducted for RC and PCaPC deck, considering actual field config-
urations such as haunch and thin mortar layer to clarify the composite action
between deck and girder jointed by studs. The obtained conclusions from the study
are as followings:
• Cracking of thin mortar layer between the deck and the girder for the PCaPC
deck would cause deterioration of the resistance shear force. It is necessary to
establish the design criteria and the way to prevent/measure the progress of such
damages at thin mortar layer in the case of re-decking and connecting them by
many studs.
• Fracture of thin mortar layer of PCaPC deck will results in action of shear and
bending moment to the studs, which induces the deterioration of maximum
resistance strength compared to RC deck.
• Close arrangement of studs causes deterioration of the yield shear strength due
to combination of compression, bending and shear fracture.
• Yield shear strength for composite structure connected by many studs through a
thin mortar layer like PCaPC deck, cannot be controlled by adjusting the
arrangement and increasing the number of studs. Further experimental investi-
gation is required to clarify the optimize arrangement and number of studs, in
order to expect composite action connected by many studs for a non-composite
steel girder bridge.
References
1. Japan Road Association (2012) Japanese Specifications for Highway Bridges PartI and II
2. Nagao K, Nakajima A, et al (2013) Study on behaviour of push-out test on headed studs in slab
model of holed precast concrete and layer of mortar. JSCE, 47.1–47.7
3. Nakajima A, Okazaki Y, et al (2016) Study on limit state of composite girder with various stud
arrangement in replacing RC slab. In: Proceedings of the fourteenth east Asia-pacific
conference on structural engineering and construction, pp 1003–1010
Development of an Emergency Bridge
with the Double End Plate Connection
Using High Strength Bolt
Abstract Recently some emergency bridges have been developed for road
restoration at the time of disaster due to flood, landslide, earthquake, and tsunami.
On the other hand, temporary work girders are often used in a construction site, and
it is expected that temporary work girders are utilized as the emergency bridge.
In this study, for shortening erection term of temporary work girders, we propose
to use the double end plate connection using high strength bolt at the connection of
the emergency bridges. The past experiment has confirmed that double end plate
connection using high strength bolts can apply bridge main girder connection.
We have applied it to the actual temporary work girders to investigate the
structural behavior of the emergency bridge with the double end plate connection
through field loading tests.
It was found from the results of the field measurement that the proposed double
end plate connection has enough performance, and it can apply to the emergency
bridge. This paper also introduces the concept of the emergency bridge with the
double end plate connection using high strength bolts.
Keywords Field loading test High strength bolt Tensile joint Emergency
bridge
1 Introduction
Recently natural disasters such as flood, landslide, earthquake, and tsunami, have
frequently occurred due to climate change. In preparation for such disasters, several
emergency bridges have been developed. Temporary work girders are often used in
a construction site, and it is expected to be utilized as emergency bridges.
Besides, it is required to reduce social impacts as much as possible in the
maintenance of infrastructures, and construction time of temporary work girders are
also required to be shortened. For that purpose, we are proposing to change the
connection of the main girder from high strength bolted friction joints to high
strength bolted tensile joints paying attentions to reduce the number of connecting
bolts. Nevertheless, few cases are adopted high strength bolted tensile joints to the
connection of the bridge main girder. As an application example of high strength
bolted tensile joints for the main girder connection, “Emergency Portable Bridge”
has been developed by the Kinki Regional Development Bureau of the Ministry of
Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism of Japan(hereinafter called “the Kinki
Regional Development Bureau”). Also, no design method for such main connec-
tions has been specified.
In this study, for the purpose of shortening erection period of temporary work
girders, we propose to apply the double end plate connection using high strength
bolts to the connection of the emergency bridges as shown in Fig. 1. Considering
our previous experimental results, it was found that the double end plate connection
using high strength bolts can use the main girder connection of the emergency
bridge [1, 2].
We have also applied it to the actual temporary work girders to confirm its
structural behavior through the field loading test.
This paper introduces the results of the field measurement and also the concept
of the emergency bridge with the double end plate connection.
We are developing an emergency bridge that can contribute to life-saving and early
road restoration by using the temporary work girders. The “Emergency Portable
Bridge” developed by the Kinki Regional Development Bureau has high strength
bolted tensile joints for a connection of the main girder. We are wondering about
applying it to the temporary work girders.
Table 1 shows the structural specifications of the emergency bridge. The plane
view of the emergency bridge is shown in Fig. 2. Since a simple structural form is
required due to shortening an erection period of temporary work girders, high
strength bolted tensile joint is adopted to the connection of the main girder from the
viewpoint of reducing the number of bolts and easy construction which can be
assembled even by the less experienced workers easily. By using the high strength
bolted tensile joint, the number of bolts was reduced by about 40% compared to the
high strength bolted friction joints.
Maximum passable vehicle assumed is one emergency vehicle (ambulance and
fire engine) or one 250 kN rough terrain crane (total weight 270 kN). Because the
number of the bridge which span length is less than 30 m is approximately 50% of
the whole national bridges which is categorized in long-class distinction table [3],
and in consideration of seat length of a girder at the support for around 3 m, we set
the maximum girder length 36 m with variable girder length.
In this study, the number of bolts at the tensile side was determined to assume that
eight bolts in the hatched area as shown in Fig. 3 resist tensile cross-sectional force.
The following equation calculates Pt of the first row and the second row. Stress was
calculated assuming that the web, the upper flange, and the horizontal rib are
effective for the cross-section.
The divided value of Pt by a number of bolts (eight bolts) means the bolt axial
force acting on one bolt. Bolt axial force of one bolt should be designed to be less
than allowable bolt axial force. Assuming that the end plate is sufficiently thick,
prying force described in a recommendation for design of high strength tensile
bolted connections for steel bridges (hereinafter called “JSSC Specification”) [4] is
not taken into consideration.
The allowable bolt axial force is set 0.97 times of the yield bolt axial force By,
taking into consideration an increase factor of the allowable stress, 1.5. According
to the JSSC Specification, the range from the initial bolt axial force, 0.75By to the
yield bolt axial force, 1.0 By is the range in which the bolt axial force can be varied
by the applying force. The allowable bolt axial force is specified as 0.9 By (= 0.75
By + 0.25 By/1.7) by the JSSC Specification, in consideration of the safety factor of
1.7 within the axial force range of 0.25By. From the above, the allowable bolt axial
force is decided 0.97 By in this study.
Development of an Emergency Bridge … 389
4 Field Measurement
We have applied it to the actual temporary work girders to confirm the structural
behavior of the emergency bridges with double end plate connection through the
field loading tests. Figure 4 shows a plane view of the measured temporary work
girders on site. The measured bridge is temporary work girders that cross the river,
which structural type is a simple bridge with four main girders. A1-P1 is a standard
temporary work girder with no connection at the center of the span, and P1-P2 has a
double end plate connection at the center of the span. The general section of P1-P2
is same as that of A1-P1. The connection at the center of the span of P1-P2 is shown
in Fig. 5. Vertical displacement at the center of the span, bolt axial force of double
end plate connection, the distance between the end plates, and strain of the web near
the center of the span are measured in the case of P1-P2. For comparison, vertical
displacement at the center of the span and strain of the web near the center of the
span is measured in the case of A1-P1. Bolt axial forces are measured for the first
row and second row. A 70t crawler crane was used for loading. Loading position
was the location where a maximum positive bending moment occurs, as shown in
Fig. 6 shows just loading. Figure 7 shows a photo of loading status.
390 Y. Mineyama et al.
Vertical displacement at the center of the span during the loading of a 70t crawler
crane was 5.0 mm for P1-P2 and 3.1 mm for A1-P1. Vertical displacement was
calculated as the difference between vertical displacement before and after loading.
By Bernoulli-Euler hypothesis, design values of deflection are 5.2 mm for P1-P2
and 3.5 mm for A1-P1, and these are almost same as the obtained values. The
design deflection of P1-P2 was calculated by assuming web, upper flange, and
horizontal rib effective.
5.2 Bolt Axial Force and Gap Between the Connected End
Plates
Figure 8 shows bolt axial force increment. Figure 9 shows the contact pressure
distribution on the end plate connection surface. Bolt axial force increment was
calculated as the difference between bolt axial forces before and after loading. The
bolt axial force increment of the bolt located near the web-flange intersection (1TC,
5TC) is smaller than that of the outer bolt (2TC, 6TC). That is, the bolt axial force
increment is small where the contact pressure occurs, and the difference of the bolt
axial force increment is determined by the dispersion of contact pressure distri-
bution. It is considered that bolt axial force increment of 1TC and 5TC was small
due to the scar wrap (Fig. 5) provided on the web of the end plate and lower flange
intersection.
392 Y. Mineyama et al.
(a)G2-girder (b)G3-girder
(a)G2-girder (b)G3-girder
Also, the maximum gap between the connected endplate surfaces was 0.08 mm,
and this concludes no separation between the end plates is occurred.
Figure 10 shows the strain distribution of the web plate. The red dashed line shown
in Fig. 10 was calculated by an effective cross-section, not including the lower
flange as shown in Fig. 11(a). The blue dashed line shown in Fig. 10 was calculated
by an effective cross-section from the reference as shown in Fig. 11(b). The
measured values were almost the same as the reference values. The number of bolts
at the double end plate connection is calculated by using the stress gradient under
the assumption in which an effective cross-section is shown in Fig. 11(a), not
including the lower flange. This makes it possible to design on the safe side.
Development of an Emergency Bridge … 393
(a)P1 P2 (b)A1 P1
Fig. 11 Effective
Cross-section
6 Conclusions
An emergency bridge with double end plate connections has been applied to the
actual temporary bridge, and field measurements were performed. As a result, the
measured vertical displacement was almost the same as the design value, and the
strain distribution of the web showed a smaller than those of the design values.
Also, almost no separation between end plates subjected to loading a 70t crawler
crane has been observed. Accordingly, it concludes that the double end plate
connection can be applicable to the emergency bridge, and it is possible to design
the connection by using a stress gradient calculated by an effective cross-section,
not including the lower flange.
Based on the field measurement, further research on manufacturing method to
reduce the variation of the contact pressure distribution on the connection surface
should be needed in order to reduce the variation of the bolt axial force increase.
References
1 Introduction
Figure 1 gives the location of Kao Ping Hsi Cable-Stayed Bridge, which carries the
Freeway 3 over Gaoping River connecting Dashu, Kaohsiung and Jiuru, Pingtung
County in Taiwan.
Kaohsiung
Kao Ping Hsi Bridge
Pintung
Kao Ping Hsi Cable-Stayed Bridge
This study collected and analyzed the one-year monitoring data of Kao Ping Hsi
Cable-Stayed Bridge (dated from December 2017 to November 2018). The result of
the analysis is then used to establish a design-based warning system, which helps
check if the cables need inspection, repair or replacement.
The data was collected using the sensors numbered as B101, B107, B108, B109,
B111, F106, F107, F108, F114 and F101. Table 3 gives an example illustrating the
data analysis for the B101 cable. In detail, one day was selected per month and
three time periods were chosen for further study. 10-min data was taken at 07:00,
17:00 and 23:00 respectively in the same day. The first two were selected for traffic
rush hours in the morning and evening. The last one was for no cars in the
398 C. H. Chen et al.
midnight. For each data, the monitoring time is 10 min, the sampling frequency is
100 Hz, and the sampling point is 60,000 points.
Fourier transform analysis was then made to find the frequency for the 1st and
2nd modes (denoted as f1 and f2 respectively), and the frequency difference
(Df ¼ f2 f1 ). Figure 3 depicts the result of frequency analysis for the one-year
data recorded by the B101 sensor. The results didn’t show seasonal effects.
0.7
Frequency (Hz)
0.6
0.5
0.4
07:00
0.3 17:00
0.2 23:00
0.1
Date
Fig. 3 Analysis result of frequency difference (Df ) for the B101 cable
The results indicate that the cable frequency and force may vary depending on the
cable location and time period. In detail, some of the cables had a great frequency
Investigation into Seasonal Effects … 399
difference and the variation was not the same for the 3 time periods (i.e. the B108
and B109 cables of the edge span, and F114 and F101 cables of the main span).
Some of the cables had a small frequency difference and the variation was also
limited (i.e. the B101 and B107 cables of the edge span, and F106, F107 and F108
cables of the main span). The force varied greater for a longer cable. This trend was
also observed before [5]. The B101 cable is the longest cable of the edge span, and
the frequency had a variation of 0.1 Hz at maximum (approximated to 20%) (see
the details in Table 2 and Fig. 3).
As mentioned, the 10-min data was selected and analyzed for three different time
periods. The maximum frequency was often recorded at 7:00, and the minimum
was recorded at 23:00. The former was for a traffic rush hour. The latter was for no
cars in the midnight. There are many factors affecting the cable vibrations, such as
wind force and vehicle traffic flow. The wind effects include vortex-induced
vibration, wake galloping and rain-wind-induced vibration. Based on the 8-month
measurement, it was concluded that for the Kao Ping Hsi Cable-Stayed Bridge, the
vortex-induced vibration may affect to a greater extent, in comparison to the other
factors such as rainfall, traffic flow and so on [2].
3 Warning Systems
The structure system of a cable-stayed bridge is to fix the pylon through one end of
the cable and is to connect the other end with the deck, as to pull up the bridge
structure. If some of the cables got broken, the broken cables would affect the
structural safety of the bridge structure, and in the worst case the bridge would
collapse [3]. It is important to evaluate the structural integrity of the cables and
bridge, especially based on the long-term monitoring data. It is also important to
establish an early warning system as to provide a basis or standard for determining
whether the cables need further inspection, repairs or replacement.
Previous studies evaluated the structural integrity of a stayed cable using the
frequency and cable force [4, 5]. The results have showed that the cable frequency
may increase or decrease for a typhoon and earthquake attack, and can return to the
origin after the event. In this study, the structural integrity of a stayed cable was
evaluated in detail based on the cable frequency and design force. The force of a
stayed cable can be estimated using the string theory with the 1st mode frequency of
the cable. Using the string theory, the characteristic frequency was first calculated
for the design force of the cable. The warning frequency was then defined for 90%
of the design cable force. In the same way, the action-taking frequency was also
defined for 80% of the design cable force.
400 C. H. Chen et al.
These warning values are useful in making judgement about the cable force and
safety margin. The design force of a stayed cable is smaller than the yield strength,
and allows the evaluation keeping a safety margin.
Figure 4 depicts the frequency values of the B101 cable and the forces. For warning,
the cable force is 803.6 ton, and the frequency is 0.61 Hz. For taking action, the
cable force is 904 ton, and the frequency is 0.65 Hz. The cable force is 553.87 ton for
the measured max frequency of 0.51 Hz (see the details in Table 2(b)). The cable
frequency and force are smaller than the warning and action-taking values. Thus, the
B101 cable doesn’t need any inspection or repair at the current stage.
1500
Cable force (ton)
0.69, 1004.5
1000 0.65, 904.05
0.61, 803.6
500 0.51, 553.87
B101
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Frequency(Hz)
Table 3 summarizes the 1st-mode frequency of the stayed cables and compares
to the warning and action-taking values. Except the F114 cable, the measured
frequency was lower than the warning and action-taking ones. The measured fre-
quency of the F114 cable was 1.39 Hz, and was slightly higher than the warning
value. As illustrated by Fig. 2, the F114 cable was located close to the bridge tower.
The sag of the cable was easily affected by the gravity force. The cable force
therefore can hardly be predicted using the string theory with a good accuracy. As
mentioned, the design force of a stayed cable is smaller than the yield strength, and
allows the evaluation keeping a safety margin. In sum, the F114 cable was still
considered to remain in good structural healthy.
Investigation into Seasonal Effects … 401
4 Conclusions
This study analyzed the long-term monitoring data of Kao Ping Hsi Cable-Stayed
Bridge and established a design-based warning system. In detail, the monitoring
data were collected from December 2017 to November 2018. This one-year data
was then analyzed using Fourier transform and used to determine the cable fre-
quency and force. The maximum frequency was often recorded at 7:00, and the
minimum was recorded at 23:00. The former was for a traffic rush hour, and the
latter was for no cars in the mid-night. The results didn’t show any seasonal effects.
The structural integrity of a stayed cable was then evaluated in detail based on
the cable frequency and design force. The 90%- and 80%-design forces were
defined as the limits of warning and taking action, respectively. The design force of
a stayed cable is smaller than the yield strength, and allows the evaluation keeping a
safety margin against cable failures and bridge collapse. The results of case study
analyses showed that almost all the frequency values are smaller than the warning
values, and thus the cables don’t need any inspection or repair at the current stage.
References
Abstract The traditional TMD and AMD are ineffective for the swing vibration
control of suspended structures. Although the recently proposed tuned rotary inertia
damper (TRID) is effective for swing vibration control, it has the limitations of low
robustness and limited application range. The Active Rotary Inertia Driver (ARID)
is proposed in this paper. Firstly, the simplified analytical model of the suspended
structure subjected to point source excitations with ARID is established based on
Lagrangian principles. The control algorithm is developed based on the LQR (linear
quadratic regulator) algorithm. Then the numerical analysis of the small-scale
model with five kinds of multi-hazards excitations (free vibration, forced vibration,
sweep vibration, earthquake vibration and sea wave vibration) were carried out
using Simulink. Lastly, a series of shaking-table experiments were carried out to
verify the numerical analysis results. The effectiveness of the ARID system for
swing vibration control of the suspended structure is validated. Furthermore, the
better robustness and wide application range of the ARID system is also verified by
the numerical analyses and experiments of the small-scale model with multi-type
excitations.
1 Introduction
Vibration control devices have been widely applied in civil engineering, mechanical
engineering, aerospace engineering, ocean engineering and many other fields. For
the civil engineering structures, the reasonable installation of the vibration control
system can effectively reduce the dynamic response and damage to the structures. It
is meaningful to achieve a reasonable balance of economy, safety and reliability.
Many studies have proposed that the structural vibration control system can
effectively reduce the reaction and damage of structures under the excitations of
wind, waves, currents, ice and earthquakes. It can effectively improve the disaster
resistance of structures. It is the most effective countermeasure for disaster pre-
vention and mitigation.
In the field of marine engineering, studies have shown that structural vibration
control devices are very useful. It has been verified that vibration control devices
can reduce the dynamic stress amplitude of the ocean platform structure by 15%.
The structural lives can be extended by more than two times. At the same time, the
detection and maintenance cost of the offshore platform can be greatly reduced,
which has important practical significance. With the development of offshore
engineering, the vibrations of deep-water offshore platform structures under the
influence of wind, waves, currents, ice and earthquakes are no longer control
problems of single motion mode. They involve structural translational motions
(floating, swaying, and heaving), rotational motions (rolling, pitching, and yawing)
and their complex problems of coupled vibration and motion (Chandrasekaran et al.
[1]). Therefore, it is of great theoretical and practical significance to study the
structural swing vibration control methods. It can ensure the safe service of deep
ocean engineering structures and prolong the fatigue life of structures. Marine
vessels working at sea are subjected to dynamic loads such as wind, waves and
inrush currents. The complex loads can lead to vibrations of the hull and hook. It
may impact other structures or workers on the vessel and pose a serious threat to the
stability of the marine vessel. Figure 1 (a) is a photo of a large lifting pipe laying
vessel and its main hooks. Figure 1 (b) is a photo of the accident of the main and
auxiliary hooks during the operation.
Not only the marine engineering but also the hook system of various cranes on
the land, the window cleaning machine used for cleaning high-rise buildings and
the construction hanging basket during construction all have the swing motion
component. They can be simplified into a suspended structure model. For cranes
with fixed bases such as tower cranes and bridge cranes, the operator’s improper
operation or environmental disturbances (such as wind disturbances) can cause the
hooks vibrations. The vibrations can delay the lifting time and reduce accuracy,
safety. They even lead to the accident. Furthermore, such kind of vibration is
approximately undamped and needs a long time to be stable. Therefore, appropriate
control measures are needed for the vibration control of suspended structures.
Although the researchers have proposed some control methods, the wind, the
nonlinearity of the suspension cable and other factors make the hook vibration
greatly uncertainty. The current method of mitigating hook vibration relies on the
operator’s experience to manually control the vibration. Manually controlling the
vibration of the hook requires the operator to pay attention to the movement of the
hook, which will reduce the efficiency of the lifting process. In order to reduce the
burden on the operator and improve the efficiency and safety of the crane operation,
it is necessary to study the practical vibration control method. In addition, the
The Active Rotary Inertia Driver for Vibration Control … 405
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Fig. 1 Marine crane laying works ship and Tacoma narrow bridge a Large crane laying barge;
b Winding accident of main and auxiliary hooks; c Tacoma narrow bridge; d Wind flutter
instability failure
suspension structural vibration control principle and methods can also be applied to
the vibration control of large-scale civil engineering structures under specific loads
such as wind-induced flutter control of long-span bridges. Figures 1(c) and (d) are
photos of the damage caused by wind-induced flutter instability of the Tacoma
narrow bridge. It is obvious that the severe torsional vibrational divergence ulti-
mately leads to structural failure.
The pendulum motion of suspended structures is a common and very typical form
of basic motion. In the previous research work of the author (Zhang et al. [2]), the
pendulum motion of the suspension mass system is divided into two basic forms
according to the relationship between the structural motion direction and the
406 Chunwei Zhang and H. Wang
suspended direction: tangential sway motion and vertical swing motion. For sim-
plicity, the suspended structure is assumed to be concentrated mass point, and all
the mass is assumed to be concentrated into the hanging point. The TMD control
system is simplified to an undamped mass-spring oscillator. Therefore, the dissi-
pative force will not be presented in the equation, which may facilitate comparisons
on relations among inertial force, restoring force and disturbance force of the mass.
In the sway motion mode, the force is absolutely irrelated to stroke of TMD
mass and only related to the structural pendular angle. The bigger the pendular
angle, the bigger the disturbance force will be, which behaves like state-feedback
control force exerted onto the main structure. The control equation force can be
expressed as:
1 g _2
FSway ¼ 2m h sin h €
h cos h ð1Þ
x
ma þ 1 0
Based on the above equation, the control force is shown to be approaching the
minimum values when structure comes back to the balance position with maximum
velocities, whereas the maximum force will be achieved when the structure reaches
the maximum amplitude position while the velocity is zero. Thus, the control force
is shown to be increasing with the pendular angle of the structure, which behaves
like a negative stiffness force. Different from the sway motion, in the swing motion
mode, the control force equation is expressed as:
1 g x _ 2 €
FSwing ¼ 2m h h x20 sin h ð2Þ
x l
ma þ 1 0
The force is obviously different from the sway motion mode case, which is more
complicated. As regards to the latter two items shown in the definition above, they
satisfy the condition of idea single pendulum. Therefore, either the structure pen-
dulum does not satisfy the ideal condition or the suspended main structure was
disturbed greatly by the TMD system, the last two forces in the equation can be
effective for suppressing the structural motion. In this case, the main control force
comes from the first item given in the right part of the Eq. (2). However, this force
is also dependent on the mass stroke x. Under different initial settings of x/l, it can
be concluded that: (1) only if the value of |x/l| is big enough, the TMD system can
be fully excited, thus to take effect on suppressing the structural pendular motions,
but the initial stroke of mass cannot be big enough; (2) based on the significant
difference between the results corresponding to x/l = ±l, the sign of x is shown to
be critical influential on the behavior of force. Therefore, it is complicated to
consider the effects of the direct relation between x and h.
The Active Rotary Inertia Driver for Vibration Control … 407
It has been verified that TMD is invalid for swing motion control. The concept of
TRID (Tuned Rotary Inertia Damper) was proposed before (Zhang et al. [3]). Since
the TRID system is consistent with the TMD system in the basic principle, it is
subject to the passive tuning vibration damping control theory. Therefore, the
control capability of the TRID system will be limited by the general laws and
conditions that need to be met by tuning vibration damping control theory. In view
of the particularity of the suspended structure, the TRID system is extremely
sensitive to the frequency modulation ratio and the moment of inertia ratio.
Furthermore, there are strong coupling relationships between several key parame-
ters of the system. The parameter optimization method is more complex than the
traditional TMD control system. The robustness and flexibility of passive control
systems will also be greatly challenged. As the research deepened, the concept of
the Active Rotary Inertia Driver (ARID) control system for structural anti-rolling
control is proposed based on the work of the author’s previous research. Based on
the theory of AMD and the basic principle of TRID, the ARID is designed into a
kind of active control driver. The mathematical model of the suspended structure
with the ARID system is shown in Fig. 2.
The suspended particle mass is m. The ARID system rotary inertia mass is ma
and the system rotary inertia is Ja. The length of the structure is l. The model
consists of two degrees of freedom used as generalized coordinators, which are the
structural swing angle h and the mass inertia relative rotation angle / with respect
to the ground base (Zhang et al. [4]). The motion equations of the structure with the
ARID system can be achieved as
h þ ch_ þ ðm þ ma Þglsinh ¼ ðm þ ma Þlcoshax0 ðtÞ þ ca ;_ h_ þ ka ð; hÞ Ta ðtÞ
ðm þ ma Þl2 €
ð3Þ
Ja ;€þ ca ;_ h_ þ ka ð; hÞ ¼ Ta ðtÞ ð4Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
where Ja ¼ ma r 2 , c ¼ 2½ðm þ ma Þl2 xn, x ¼ g=l, ca ¼ 2ma r 2 xa na , xa ¼
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
ka =Ja are the needed parameters. r is the radius of the mass inertia, n is the
structural damping ratio, na is the ARID damping ratio. The structural damping
coefficient is c. The ARID system rotational stiffness coefficient is ka and the
damping coefficient is ca. The acceleration at the suspended structure lifting point is
ax0(t), and output torque of the ARID system is Ta(t). Similar to the AMD control
system, the ARID system is supposed to no damped and rotating restoring force.
The control torque is the control torque Ta(t). The numerical analysis can be carried
out based on the control algorithm.
The total sampling time is 40 s. The excitation is the harmonic excitation. The
excitation amplitude is 20 mm and frequency is 0.65 Hz (the excitation frequency
is closed to the natural structural frequency). The structures are under resonance
harmonic excitation in the first 15 s and then decay freely. After 15 s excitation, in
the ARID ON case, the ARID system starts to work. However, in the ARID OFF
case, the ARID system still keeps off. The simulation and experimental results
The Active Rotary Inertia Driver for Vibration Control … 409
50 35
ARID OFF ARID ON
ARID ON 30 ARID OFF
25 25
Angle(°)
|Y(f)|
20
0
15
10
-25
5
-50 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
Time(s) Frequency (Hz)
(a) (b)
50 35
Simulation Experiment ARID ON
Experiment 30 Experiment ARID OFF
Simulation ARID ON
25 Simulation ARID OFF
25
Angle(°)
|Y(f)|
20
0
15
-25 10
5
-50 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
Time(s) Frequency (Hz)
(c) (d)
Fig. 3 Analysis of the structure under free vibration a Time history of structural swing angle
(simulation); b Amplitude-frequency curve of structural swing angle (simulation); c Experimental
and numerical time histories of structure with ARID control; d Amplitude-frequency curves of
experiment and simulation
including swing angle time history and power spectral density curves are shown in
Fig. 3. It can be seen that the ARID system has a good control effect under free
vibration.
The total sampling time is 80 s. The hang point excitation is the sinusoidal wave.
The amplitude is 20 mm and the frequency is 0.65 Hz. In the ARID ON case, the
ARID system keeps working. In the ARID OFF case, the ARID system keeps not
working. The simulation and experimental results are shown in Fig. 4. Comparing
the simulation results of ARID ON and OFF, the structural swing response RMS
attenuation rate is 84% and the peak attenuation rate is 87%.
410 Chunwei Zhang and H. Wang
50 25
ARID OFF ARID ON
ARID ON ARID OFF
20
25
15
Angle(°)
|Y(f)|
0
10
-25 5
-50 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
Time(s) Frequency (Hz)
(a) (b)
30
Experiment ARID ON
Experiment ARID OFF
25 Simulation ARID ON
Simulation ARID OFF
20
|Y(f)|
15
10
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
Frequency (Hz)
(c)
Fig. 4 Analysis of the structure under resonance harmonic excitation vibration a Time history of
structural swing angle (simulation); b Amplitude-frequency curve of structural swing angle
(simulation); c Amplitude-frequency curves of experiment and simulation
In this condition, the total sample time is 110 s. The excitation amplitude is 10 mm,
the initial frequency is 0.4 Hz, and the ending frequency is 1.5 Hz. In the ARID ON
case, the ARID system keeps working. In the ARID OFF case, the ARID system
keeps not working. The simulation and experimental results are shown in Fig. 5.
Comparing the experimental results of ARID ON and OFF, the structural swing
response RMS attenuation rate is 90% and the peak attenuation rate is 90%.
In this condition, the total sample time is 40 s. The El Centro earthquake accel-
eration time history is input into the structure. In the ARID ON case, the ARID
system keeps working. In the ARID OFF case, the ARID system keeps not
working. The simulation and experimental results are shown in Fig. 6. Comparing
the experimental results of ARID ON and OFF, the structural swing response RMS
attenuation rate is 91% and the peak attenuation rate is 97%.
The Active Rotary Inertia Driver for Vibration Control … 411
30
ARID OFF 20
ARID ON ARID ON
20 ARID OFF
15
10
Angle(°)
|Y(f)|
0 10
-10
5
-20
-30 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
(a) (b)
12
Experiment ARID ON
Experiment ARID OFF
10 Simulation ARID ON
Simulation ARID OFF
8
|Y(f)|
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
Frequency (Hz)
(c)
Fig. 5 Analysis of the structure under sweep excitation vibration a Time history of structural
swing angle (experiment); b Amplitude-frequency curve of structural swing angle (experiment);
c Amplitude-frequency curves of experiment and simulation
30
ARID OFF
ARID ON 15
ARID ON
20 ARID OFF
10
Angle(°)
10
|Y(f)|
-10 5
-20
-30 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
15
Experiment ARID ON
Experiment ARID OFF
Simulation ARID ON
Simulation ARID OFF
10
|Y(f)|
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
Frequency (Hz)
(c)
Fig. 6 Analysis of the structure under El Centro earthquake vibration a Time history of structural
swing angle (experiment); b Amplitude-frequency curve of structural swing angle (experiment);
c Amplitude-frequency curves of experiment and simulation
412 Chunwei Zhang and H. Wang
15 8
ARID OFF
ARID ON
ARID ON
10 7 ARID OFF
6
5
Angle(°)
|Y(f)|
0 4
3
-5
2
-10 1
-15 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
Time(s) Frequency (Hz)
(a) (b)
10
Experiment ARID ON
Experiment ARID OFF
8 Simulation ARID ON
Simulation ARID OFF
6
|Y(f)|
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
Frequency (Hz)
(c)
Fig. 7 Analysis of the structure under sea wave vibration a Time history of structural swing angle
(simulation); b Amplitude-frequency curve of structural swing angle (simulation);
c Amplitude-frequency curves of experiment and simulation
In this condition, the total sample time is 80 s. The sea wave acceleration time
history is made from Gaussian stationary white noise function. In the ARID ON
case, the ARID system keeps working. In the ARID OFF case, the ARID system
keeps not working. The simulation and experimental results are shown in Fig. 7.
Comparing the simulation results of ARID ON and OFF, the structural swing
response RMS attenuation rate is 80% and the peak attenuation rate is 74%.
5 Conclusions
The Active Rotary Inertia Driver (ARID) system for swing vibration control is
proposed in this paper. The motion equations of the simplified model with the
ARID system is established. The numerical analysis of the small-scale model with
five kinds of multi-hazards excitations (free vibration, forced vibration, sweep
vibration, earthquake vibration and sea wave vibration) were carried out using
The Active Rotary Inertia Driver for Vibration Control … 413
References
1. Chandrasekaran S., Kumar D, Ramanthan R (2016) Response control of tension leg platform
with passive damper: experimental investigations. Ships Offshore Struc, 1–11
2. Zhang C, Li L, Ou J (2010) Swinging motion control of suspended structures: Principles and
applications. Struct Control Health Monit 17(5):549–562
3. Zhang C, Ou J (2006) Modeling and Active Control of Flexible Suspended Structural System,
7th World Congress on Computational mechanics, 16−22 July Los Angeles, California, USA
4. Zhang C, Wang H (2020) Swing vibration control of suspended structures using the active
rotary inertia driver system: theoretical modeling and experimental verification. Struct Control
Health Monit 27(6):e2543
5. Zhang C, Wang H (2019) Swing vibration control of suspended structure using active rotary
inertia driver system: parametric analysis and experimental verification. Appl Sci 9(15):3144
Estimations for Equivalent Static Wind
Loads of Dome Roof Structures
Y. L. Lo and C. H. Wu
Abstract Estimation of equivalent static wind loads for structures is one of the most
important issues in wind engineering. So far, the well-known Davenport Chain has
been commonly used and put in several international codes or regulations for struc-
tural engineers. However, due to its strict hypotheses, this method can be applied to
limited structures and need certain modifications when conflicts with real designs.
Other methodologies have been developed in the past thirty years, such as the
load-response-correlation method [1], POD based universal equivalent static wind
load [2], the consistent coupling method (Ke et al. 2012), the principal static wind load
(Blaise and Denoel 2013), and so on. Recently, the load-response-correlation method
has been added in ISO 4354 Appendix D10 as an option to estimate wind loads instead
of applying gust loading factor method which is originally derived from the Davenport
Chain. These developed methodologies can be categorized into two: (1) the one that
needs the preliminary information from time-domain analysis results and (2) the one
that needs specific hypotheses for calculations. The former usually takes more cal-
culation time than the latter and is sometimes questioned for lack of practical meaning
since the time domain analysis has been done in advance. None of these method-
ologies can hardly be responsible for precise calculations of all structures. This paper
intends to introduce the advantages and shortcomings of the two main approaches in
estimating wind loads via thirty-five different parametric cases of a two-dimensional
large span roof structure. Time-domain analysis based on the direct integration
method is also included for comparison. Finally, a general suggestion table is given for
these methods for reasonable application ranges.
Keywords Equivalent static wind load Wind tunnel test Davenport chain
Time-domain analysis Structural response
Y. L. Lo (&) C. H. Wu
Department of Civil Engineering, Tamkang University, New Taipei, Taiwan
e-mail: yllo@mail.tku.edu.tw
C. H. Wu
e-mail: jacquline.wu@gmail.com
1 Introduction
The present study intends to compare the two main approaches of estimation of
equivalent static wind loads with time-domain analysis. Generally speaking,
up-to-now developed methodologies can be categorized into two: (1) the one that
needs the preliminary information from time-domain analysis results and (2) the
one that needs specific hypotheses for calculations. The former usually takes more
calculation time than the latter and is sometimes questioned for lack of practical
meaning since the time domain analysis has been done in advance. None of these
methodologies can hardly be responsible for precise calculations of all structures.
This paper intends to introduce the advantages and shortcomings of the two main
approaches in estimating wind loads via thirty-five different parametric cases of a
two-dimensional large span roof structure. Time-domain analysis based on the
direct integration method is also included for comparison. Finally, a general sug-
gestion table is given for these methods for reasonable application ranges.
The indoor closed-circuit type Eiffel wind tunnel simulator in University of Tokyo
is designed and built to generate laminar flow and turbulent boundary layer flow for
the experiments of building sizes. The cross geometric size of the working section is
1.8 1.8 m. The development length to the working section is 12.5 m and the
boundary layer height is about 1.2 m. The contraction ratio the wind tunnel is
1/3.16. The minimum wind speed generated by the fan is 0.5 m/s and the maximum
wind speed is 13.0 m/s. Figure 1 shows the outlook of the wind tunnel facility.
Turbulent wind flow inside the wind tunnel is simulated by the arrangement of
Fig. 3 Mean wind speed profile (left), turbulent intensity profile (middle), and turbulent length
scale profile (right)
spires and roughness blocks. Larger vortices are generated by the spires and smaller
vortices near the ground are generated by a certain development length consisted of
roughness blocks. The arrangement of roughness blocks is shown in Fig. 2.
Figure 3 shows the normalized profiles of mean wind speeds and turbulence
intensities in the turbulent boundary layer. The solid curves represents terrain IV
(Index a = 0.27) in AIJ standards.
Turbulent flow field can be considered as consisted of various sizes of vortices.
Generally speaking, vortices of larger scales can be considered as inviscid flow
while the movements of vortices of smaller scales are fully dominated by the
viscous force. In the flow field, vortices of larger scales stretch and then convert into
smaller scales. The energy is passed to smaller scales by the inertia term and the
smallest size of vortex dissipate the energy to heat due to viscosity. Kolmogorov
proposed that the movement of small vortices can be determined by the energy
dissipation rate and the viscous constant of flow (Kolmogorov’s first rule). Further,
when the movement has nothing to do with the viscosity, the movement can be
fully determined by the energy dissipation rate, which is called Kolmogorov’s
second rule. Power spectra of fluctuating wind speeds at elevations along the profile
are shown with Karman’s model in Fig. 4. Fairly good agreement is observed at
any elevation.
The dome models in this research are composed of two acrylic models, roof models
and cylinder models, to have more variety for geometric sizes to include the dome
structures in the real world. Vinyl tubes are installed on the surface of roof models
and connected to the micro-pressure measuring system. Each of the testing models
is fixed by screws on the turntable in the working section.
The definition of geometric symbol of a testing model is shown in Fig. 5. The
span of the roof models is 300 mm and denominated D. The heights of the roof
models and the cylinder models are denominated “f” and “h” respectively. Both
these two heights are adjusted to have a parametric study of geometric changes.
Table 1 lists the sizes of the geometric dimensions of the roof models and cylinder
models and the terminology of the testing models. There are six ratios of the roof
height to the span and six ratios of the cylinder height to the span. Except for the
combination of f/D = 0 and h/D = 0, there are totally 35 testing models.
Pressure taps are installed on the median line of the dome model and parallel to
the wind direction. In this research, the author intends to investigate the differences
in evaluating wind loads by two approaches—LRC method and Universal method.
Therefore, the wind direction is ignored and those measured pressures are con-
sidered for the subsequent analysis of wind forces. The three-dimensional geo-
metric feature of a dome model may cause different flow separation points over the
curved surface; however, it is ignored in this research.
Estimations for Equivalent Static Wind Loads of Dome Roof Structures 419
The sampling condition of the wind pressure measurements is assumed 1000 Hz for
2 min recording. Number of samples for further analysis is 12,000. In this research,
the length of a 10-min record is 8192 and there are 14 segments of 10-min records
in the 2 min. For statistical calculation, the average value of 14 segments is esti-
mated for observation.
420 Y. L. Lo and C. H. Wu
Wind pressure data (in Pa) is then conducted the 1-s moving averaging in every
10-min record, which is converted from the model to the field. To calculate the
wind pressure coefficients, the reference velocity pressure at the height of the
domed model, qH, is applied for normalization.
1 2
qH ¼ q U ð1Þ
2 H
where q represents air density; U H represents mean wind speed at the height of the
dome model. Wind pressure data is recorded from the pressure tap through the vinyl
tube and then transmitted to the pressure transducer. However, when the pressure
data is transmitted through the vinyl tube, signal distortion is caused by the vinyl
tube itself. Although the mean value is unchanged, fluctuating part of the signal is
somehow interfered. Therefore, the modification of the distorted signal is necessary
before calculation of aerodynamic parameters or further analysis. In this research,
the scanned pressures are processed by the following gain function and the asso-
ciate phase function in Fig. 6. In this research, the vinyl tube length is 90 cm.
To observe the characteristics of wind pressures on testing models, aerodynamic
parameters of wind pressure data are defined as follows.
Instantaneous pressure coefficient:
pi ps
Cp;i ¼ ð2Þ
qH
1X N
Cp;mean ¼ Cp;i ð3Þ
N i¼1
Fig. 6 Gain functions (left) and phase functions (right) of vinyl tube in three lengths
The research adopts two main approaches to compare how different the method-
ologies provide estimated wind loads. Although these two approaches have been
further developed or modified by recent researchers, the present study applies the
original proposal of these two approaches to show its basic methodologic spirits.
Kasperski [1] proposed a load-response correlated method (L. R. C., hereafter
LRC method) to efficiently predict the wind load distribution corresponding to a
specific condition where one target load response reaches its maximum value. This
method provides good agreements with time-domain analysis in linear systems and
in some mildly nonlinear systems. Currently the LRC method has been appended to
ISO 4354 Appendix D10 for reference. The equivalent static wind load is deter-
mined as
where Cpi ;mean is the mean pressure coefficient; Cpi ;rms is the R.M.S pressure
coefficient; qrpi is the correlation coefficient of the response r caused by the loading
at i; gr is the response peak factor. In Eq. (5), the correlation coefficient qrpi is
further defined as
P
j aj qpi pj Cpj ;rms
qrpi ¼ P P ð6Þ
i j ai aj qpi pj Cpi ;rms Cpj ;rms
where aj is the influence factor at loading j. The number of equivalent static wind
load distribution is decided by the number of key responses. If the designer con-
cerns all the structural responses of all members, then this method provides equally
the same number of load distributions and theoretically overall extreme responses
as well.
Katsumura [2] proposed a equivalent static wind load distribution based on
time-domain analysis results. This method is mainly developed in an idea providing
the designers an initial load distribution which leads to good agreements with
422 Y. L. Lo and C. H. Wu
where ½IR is the influence matrix and ½u is the characteristic load vector which can
be replaced by POD mode (vector). ½R0 is then processed by singular value
decomposition to obtain
Contribution vector is then calculated by Eq. (11) to have weighting factors for
corresponding POD modes.
^
fCg ¼ ½V ½S1 ½U T R ð9Þ
where R ^ is the target structural responses in vector form obtained from
time-domain analysis results.
^ ¼ c1 ff1 g þ c2 ff2 g þ . . . ¼ ½F fCg
F ð10Þ
where ½F is the POD modes representing any combinations of force vectors with
their associated weighting factors fC g.
Figure 7 shows the variations of mean wind pressure coefficients. From the dis-
tributions of mean pressure coefficients, three categories of models can be found
again clearly: (1) flat models; (2) dome models with f/D = 0.1; and (3) dome
models with f/D > 0.1. For flat models and dome models with f/D = 0.1, negative
values of mean pressure coefficients are generally observed along the meridian.
Large negative values occur at the front edge in the upstream for flat models. For
dome models with f/D > 0.1, positive values are generally observed in the upstream
and increases in proportional to the curvature of the dome model. Negative values
at the dome apex also increase with the curvature of the dome model. For the
negative values in the downstream (wake region), the effect of curvature is less
significant.
Estimations for Equivalent Static Wind Loads of Dome Roof Structures 423
Fig. 7 Mean pressure coefficient variations along the meridian line of dome models
The discrepancies caused by the height of the cylinder model are clearly indi-
cated for the aforementioned three categories of models. For mean coefficients in
flat models, gradual variation of large negative values in the upstream is clearly
shown. With the increase of the cylinder height, the area of negative values
becomes larger and the slope becomes smaller. For mean coefficients in dome
models with f/D = 0.1, the variation at the very front edge is distinct and indicated
that as the cylinder height increases, the distribution at the front edge is like a flat
model rather than a domed model. For the overall distributions, negative becomes
larger when the cylinder height is larger. For the domed models with f/D > 0.1, the
cylinder height results in an overall shift-up distribution in general.
Figure 8 shows the variations of mean wind pressure coefficients. R.M.S pres-
sure coefficients along the meridian can also show three categories of distributions.
The effect of curvature is clear for f/D = 0.2 * 0.4 in the turbulent boundary layer
flow and almost the same for f/D = 0.4 * 0.5. Same as the mean coefficients, the
effect caused by the cylinder height in the R.M.S coefficients is also discussed in
424 Y. L. Lo and C. H. Wu
Fig. 8 R.M.S pressure coefficient variations along the meridian line of dome models
three categories of models. For flat models, the cylinder height significantly affects
the pressure fluctuation at the front edge. For models with f/D = 0.1, the cylinder
height also has the same effect at the very front edge. For curved domed models
with f/D > 0.1, the effect caused by the cylinder model can be indicated in two
turbulent boundary layer flows individually.
In order to simplify the comparison and meet the requirement of page limitation, the
authors select C2 dome model for explanation. And furthermore, in order to
compare LRC and Universal methods fairly, the finite element model of C2 is tuned
to have its first frequency more than 2 Hz and higher for other modes. Figure 9
shows the C2 comparison results of LRC method and Universal method in terms of
moment response in the Y-direction respectively. In general, the structural response
can be fairly fitted with the LRC method; however, if the number of POD modes is
not enough, the prediction will be seriously biased and leads to an unreal load
Estimations for Equivalent Static Wind Loads of Dome Roof Structures 425
distribution pattern. If the eigenvalues of POD modes are compared with the
accumulated POD modes for wind load estimation, it is indicated that they are not
necessarily in a same tendency for energy percentage accumulated. This indicates
that the application of Universal method needs further modifications to ensure how
efficient the POD modes can affect the final prediction (Fig. 10).
426 Y. L. Lo and C. H. Wu
4 Conclusions
Based on estimation results of thirty-five dome models, it is found that, although the
accumulated POD energy of the first few modes can reach over 80% of fluctuating
pressure field, it does not directly to the number of POD modes which can provide
good agreements with time-domain analysis results. On the other hand, the LRC
method provides a general good results at each member; however, the number of load
distribution patterns is one-to-one relationship with the target structural response. It is
time-consuming if the structure is in a complicated degree-of-freedom system.
Another shortcoming is, the LRC method reflects the background structural responses
without the consideration of resonance-induced responses.
References
1 Introduction
The Xinghai Bay Bridge (Fig. 1) in Dalian, China, is a double-deck steel truss
cross-sea suspension bridge.
The main span is 460 m in length, whereas the two end spans are 180 m. The
width between the two main cables is 25.2 m. The radius crest vertical curve of the
bridge is 13500 m with longitudinal slope 1.5% (Fig. 2). The bridge is a
double-deck bridge due to lots of traffic. The upper deck consists of four lanes and
two sidewalks, and the lower deck consists of four lanes. The upper deck lanes are
for vehicles driving from east to west, and the lower deck is for vehicles driving
from west to east.
The vehicle load of the bridge meets Chinese Vehicle Load level-I, which
includes a concentrated load 360 KN and an arbitrary length uniform load
10.5 KN/m in one traffic line. The pedestrian load is 3.0 kN/m2. The construction
period is from October 2011 to October 2015.
2 Structure Design
2.1 Truss
The girder is a steel truss structure, which is 10 m high and 10 m long for a
standard segment (Fig. 3). The truss is composed of a chord member, web member,
diagonal web member, diaphragm plate and lateral brace. All members are
thin-walled box-shaped and made of steel plate with a nominal yield strength of
Design and Experimental Research … 429
345 MPa. The section sizes of upper and lower chord are 920 840 mm. The
section size of vertical web member are 800 740 mm. The section size of
diagonal web member are 800 640 mm. The section size of cross beam are
1500 740 mm. The chord members are connected to the other members by
integrating joint.
The orthotropic steel plate forms the bridge deck (Fig. 4), which is 21.26 m width.
The bridge deck thickness is 16 mm, and the U-rib thickness is 8 mm. The lon-
gitudinal beam height varies from 664 to 784 mm, and the distance between lon-
gitudinal beams is 2620 mm. The diaphragm plate height is 596 mm, and the
distance between diaphragm plates is 2500 mm.
2.3 Tower
The 112.31 m tall tower is a reinforced concrete frame with D-shaped hollow
section. The external contour size of the upper uniform cross section is
4.10 6.50 m, and the root part changes to 6.30 8.20 m. A platform with
dimensions of 17.2 23.5 6.0 m is beneath each tower column, and 12 pieces
430 W. Huili et al.
of U2.5 m bored piles are set under the platform (Fig. 5). A prestressed concrete
cross beam between the two pylons is under the girder.
The main cable is made of the prefabricated parallel wire. Each main cable has 61
strands of parallel steel wire cables (Fig. 6), which contains 127 strands U5 mm
galvanized high strength steel wires. The main cable is wrapped with an s-shape
wire. The rise span ratio of the main cable mid-span is 1:6.667. The rise span ratio
of the side span is 1:16.67.
There are two kinds of hanger, flexible hanger and the rigid hanger. The flexible
hanger is made of 73U7 mm high-strength galvanized steel wires with a poly-
ethylene cover. The ultimate tensile strength of the hanger is 1670 MPa. Cold cast
anchors are at both ends of the hanger. The rigid hanger is made of U90 mm steel
alloy rod. Each hanging point has two pieces of hanger.
Design and Experimental Research … 431
The cable clamps are cast with a wear-resistant steel alloy. The bolts are made with
ASTM4340 steel, and the pins are made with ASTM5140 steel (Fig. 7).
432 W. Huili et al.
Cable saddles include the main saddle and splay saddle (Fig. 8). These saddles are
cast in a welding hybrid structure. The saddle groove is cast with steel. The saddle
seat is welded with ASTM A266 Grade 2 steel and the cable clamps are 45 mm
thick, casted with steel alloy.
Design and Experimental Research … 433
Fig. 9 Cross-section diagram of the eastern anchor block foundation bed (The unit is cm except
elevation unit is m)
The anchor body is poured on the foundation of the caissons (Fig. 9). In order to
reduce the whole anchor body weight, a triangular hollowed-out structure is set
between the splay cable saddle buttress and the anchor block.
The covering layer of the eastern anchorage is approximately 15 m thick and is
formatted with sludge and sandy gravels, under which a weathered rock layer laid
(Fig. 9). The covering layer of the western anchorage is only approximately 6 m
thick, and this layer is above a weathered rock layer. The anchorage foundation
treatment process included excavating the covering layer, rock rip-rap, leveling,
setting of a caisson, and foundation consolidation through grouting. Because the
covering layer above the western anchorage is quite thin, an extra partial reef
explosion is required.
434 W. Huili et al.
3 Experimental Research
4 Conclusion
Xinghai Bay Bridge is an important part of the Dalian South Link Line and solves
problematic traffic jams in this region. This bridge has achieved the status of an
urban landmark in Dalian. The friction coefficient between the gravel bed and the
concrete caisson is determined with the anchorage slippage experiment. The dry
friction coefficient is 0.520, and the underwater friction coefficient is 0.516, which
indicates that water decreases the friction coefficient.
References
1. Adanur S et al (2012) Construction stage analysis of Humber Suspension Bridge. Appl Math
Model 36(11):5492–5505
2. Furuya N, Yamaoka R, Paulson BC (1994) Construction of akashi-kaikyo bridge west
anchorage. J Constr Eng Manag 120(2):337–356
3. Chiou J-S et al (2012) Testing and analysis of a laterally loaded bridge caisson foundation in
gravel. Soils Found 52(3):562–573
4. Tang M-C (2018) Forms and aesthetics of bridges. Engineering 4(5):267–276
5. Zhang Z (2015) Bridge research and development for 30 years. Nova Science Publishers,
New York
Evaluation of Vibration Characteristics
of RC and PRC Beam Members Under
Cyclic Train Loading
Abstract Resonance phenomenon during train passing has been observed because
of the increased in train operation speed in high-speed railway, the spread of low
rigidity girder such as PRC and SRC girder, and the advances in measurement
technology. An example has been reported in which significant resonance is gen-
erated, which is caused by a decrease in rigidity due to the progress of cracks in
concrete members. The stiffness of members must be evaluated in consideration of
the action hysteresis during the design life time, i.e. the magnitude and the cyclic
number of the load. The aim of this paper is to evaluate the vibration characteristics
of RC and PRC beam members in operating condition and the variation of stiffness
and damping of the beam after repeated loads of about 2 million times based on
fatigue tests of 4 specimens. Static loading tests made it clear that the effective
stiffness of RC members decreases with respect to increasing load magnitude and it
is consistent with the previous evaluation formula. On the other hand, the effective
stiffness of the PRC member is overestimated in the case of the previous evaluation
formula, and is consistent with Branson’s cubic law. From the fatigue tests, the
effective stiffness decreases by about 6 to 16% for RC members and 10 to 33% for
PRC members after 2 million cyclic loading. The equivalent damping is from 4.0%
for RC members, according to the load magnitude and decreases to about 0.5%, and
1.5% to 0.5% for PRC members after 2 million cyclic loading. This means that the
repeated loading accompanying the train pass contributes to increasing the dynamic
response, especially with a large degree of influence on the PRC members.
1 Introduction
The phenomenon of vibrational resonance during train passing has been confirmed
following the enhanced operational speeds of high-speed railways, the spread of
low-rigidity girder such as the PRC and SRC girders, and the advances in mea-
surement technology [5]. For example, there was a study reporting that significant
resonance was generated from a decrease in rigidity of concrete members owing to
crack progression. As such, further refinement of the impact coefficient is required
in the dynamic response evaluation of such members, largely depending on their
natural frequencies or their rigidities (Sogabe et al. 2019). In view of this, the
stiffness of concrete members must be evaluated in consideration of their experi-
ence during the design lifetime, i.e. the magnitude and cyclic number of the
repeated loads. Thus, the rigidity of RC members was evaluated herein, under the
assumption of an operational condition [10]. Moreover, the hysteresis characteris-
tics of PRC members were evaluated under the same use condition, whereas in the
past such characteristics were partially studied in the architectural field, under the
occurrence of earthquakes [9], Sugino [4, 7].
This paper aims to evaluate the vibration characteristics of RC and PRC beam
members under a specific operational condition in beam stiffness and damping
variations after a fatigue test of approximately two million times of repeated
loading.
2 Experimental Method
2.1 Specimen
Figure 1 shows the design details of the specimens, which consists of both RC and
PRC members, of which the latter has become widely popular in railway structures
in recent years. Herein, the ratio of tensile rebars and the amount of introduced
pre-stress were assumed by reference to specifications of general railway bridges.
The tensile reinforcement ratio of RC and PRC member are 1 and 0.6%, respec-
tively. The prestressing coefficient of PRC member k is 0.71.
P/2 P/2
600 D10
D10 200 200 D10
D10 PC steel bar
50 300 50
400
50 300 50
100 200
D22 (B-type
2200 No.1 φ17)
2500 D13
(a) Side view (b) RC section (c) PRC section
+20kN
50kN
2 106 times
Loading step Loading step
(a) Static cyclic loading (b) Dynamic cyclic loading
Figure 2 illustrates the static cyclic loading test for evaluating the basic hysteresis
characteristics of the members, with increments of 20 kN in the load control
through the tensile rebar’s yield point and 2 mm as displacement control after yield.
At each increasing load level, the number of repetitions was three times. Moreover,
a 5-kN load was maintained during unloading.
In the dynamic loading test, the upper limit load was increased to 70, 120 and
170 kN, with assumed 50 kN reinforcement stress (of approximately 100 MPa) of
dead load based on a 5 Hz excitation frequency. In this test, the number of repe-
titions at each load level was two million.
3 Experimental Results
Figure 3 shows the load–displacement relationship obtained from the static and
dynamic loading test. Apparently, the stiffness (effective stiffness Keq) at unloading
and reloading decreased in the region where cracks occurred, whereas it decreased
on the skeleton curve (after dc in the figure). Moreover, the residual displacement at
unloading in the RC members increased with respect to increasing load as com-
pared to the PRC members. The hysteresis characteristics of PRC members
exhibited a stronger tendency to point towards the origin during unloading when
compared with those of the RC members; as the residual displacement decreased,
the effective stiffness showed decreasing tendency. That is, the prestress introduced
for the purpose of reducing the crack width was found to influence reduction in the
rigidity of the entire beam system.
440 M. Tokunaga and K. Narita
300 300
Static test Yield of tensile steel bar
Fiber Analysis Yield of PC bar
250 250 Yield of tensile steel bar
Crack of concrete
200 200 Crack of concrete
Load P (kN)
Load P (kN)
150 150
100 100
50 50
0 0
0 1 2 3 4 5 0 1 2 3 4 5
Displacement δ (mm) Displacement δ (mm)
(a) RC member (b) PRC member
where K0 is the gross sectional stiffness (uncracked concrete section); Kcr the
sectional stiffness of the fully cracked section; Mmax the applied maximum bending
moment; Mcr the cracking moment. In practical designs, the secant stiffness is
calculated by Eq. (1) [6].
Wakui et al. (1996) proposed a method to predict the flexural rigidity at reloading
by using the following equation.
1:6 ( 1:6 )
Mcr Mcr
Ks;RC ¼ K0 þ 1 Ke ð2Þ
Mmax Mmax
Evaluation of Vibration Characteristics of RC and PRC … 441
300
(kN/mm)
200
Static loading results
150
100
50 Equation(1)
0
0 100 200 300
Maximum load P (kN)
(a) Static cyclic loading
50-120kN ξeq
250 50-170kN 0.08
(kN/mm)
200
0.06
150
0.04
100
50 0.02
0 0
100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107
Cyclic loading number
(b) Dynamic cyclic loading
Hereafter, test results are compared with above two equations for the sake of
conforming the applicability especially for PRC members under cyclic loading
condition.
For the RC member, the static loading test results confirmed that the effective
stiffness decreases with an increase of loading amplitude after dc . The obtained
effective stiffness Keq of the RC member was consistent with stiffness Ks;RC during
reloading by the static cyclic loading test.
Results of the fatigue test by dynamic loading indicated that the RC members
achieved Keq of approximately 220 kN/mm to about 11% at 50–90 kN and
approximately 189 kN/mm to nearly 6% at 50–120 kN in 50–90 kN. At 170-kN
load, Keq decreased from 184 kN/mm to approximately 16%. Moreover, neq showed
the tendency to increase with increasing load and to decrease with increasing
number of repeated loads. Specifically, it decreased from 4.0 to 0.5% at 50–90 kN
and from 167 kN/mm to within 4.5–1.2% at 50–120 kN. The change was small at
nearly 1.5% at 50–170 kN. Keq exhibited a sharp decline of roughly 25% while neq
increased rapidly from approximately 1.5 to 9% at repetitions of almost 500 to
20,000 times at 50–170 kN. Crack width and residual displacement in this region
increased simultaneously, indicating that there is a possibility of deterioration of
aggregate mesh in the concrete at the cracked area. Nonetheless, the mesh was
442 M. Tokunaga and K. Narita
improved by repeated loading thereafter, where Keq , neq must have settled to the
value prior to 500 times of repeated loadings.
For the PRC member, the effective stiffness decreases with respect to increasing
loading amplitude after dc . These results were consistent with the stiffness Ke
obtained by using Branson’s law, with overestimated Ks;RC .
Figures 5 shows the effective stiffness and equivalent damping of PRC members
obtained from the static and dynamic loading tests. For the PRC members, results
for the dynamic loading test indicated that Keq decreased almost 10% from the
initial stiffness 275 kN/mm when the cyclic loading amplitude is 50–90 kN loading.
It decreased almost 33% from 240 kN/mm when the loading amplitude is 50–120
kN and almost 20% from 167 kN/mm when the loading amplitude is 50–170 kN.
These results show the stiffness of PRC member significantly decreases when
compared to RC members due to cyclic loading. neq exhibited a tendency to
increase with respect to increasing loading amplitude and to decrease with
increasing frequency of repeated loads. Particularly, it ranged within 0.5–1.5%
when the cyclic loading amplitude is 50–90 kN. It decreased from 1.5 to 0.5% when
the amplitude is 50–120 kN and from 2.3 to 1.2% when the amplitude is 50–170
kN. Both RC and PRC members showed a tendency of stiffness reduction and
damping reduction by the repeated loading, towards a greater or a lesser extent.
Especially for PRC members, the dynamic response is expected to shift to the
direction of increase due to repeated loading accompanying the train passing.
Effective stiffness Keq (kN/mm)
300
Equation(2)
250 K0
200 Static loading results
150
100
Equation(1)
50
0
0 100 200 300
Maximum load P (kN)
50-90kN Keq
(a) Static cyclic loading 50-120kN ξeq
50-170kN
Effective damping ratio ξeq
300 0.10
Effective stiffness Keq
250 0.08
(kN/mm)
200
0.06
150
0.04
100
50 0.02
0 0
100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107
Cyclic loading number
(b) Dynamic cyclic loading
4 Conclusions
This study has evaluated the vibration characteristics of RC and PRC beam
members under operational condition, based on fatigue tests. From these results, the
following conclusions may be drawn:
• From static loading tests, it is found that the effective stiffness of RC members
decreases with respect to increasing load, which is consistent with a previous
evaluation formula. Nevertheless, the effective stiffness of the PRC members is
overestimated relative to the same previous evaluation formula, which is con-
sistent with Branson’s cubic law.
• As a result of repeated dynamic loading, the effective stiffness decreases by
approximately 6% to 16% for the RC members and 10% to 33% for the PRC
members. Equivalent damping for the RC members is from 4.0% (relative to
load size) and decreases to around 0.5%, whereas for the PRC members it
decreases from 1.5% to 0.5%. This means that repeated loading accompanying
the train passing contributes to the shift towards increasing dynamic response,
especially directing a large degree of influence on the PRC members.
Nonlinear finite element analysis will be extended in the future for an in-depth
study focusing on the relation between the adhesion deterioration in the rebar and
concrete and the whole structural characteristics.
References
1. ACI Committee 318 (2008) Building code requirements for structural concrete. ACI 318-08
and Commentary. ACI, Farmington Hills, Michigan
2. Branson DE (1963) Instantaneous and time-dependent deflections of simple and continuous
reinforced concrete beams, HPR Report, vol 7, pp 1–78
3. Branson DE (1977) Deformation of concrete structures. McGraw-Hill, New York
4. Hayashi M, Okamoto S, Otani S, Kato H, Fu J (1995) Hysteresis model for prestressed
concrete members and its effect on earthquake response. J Prestress Concr Japan Prestress
Concr Eng Assoc 37(4):57–67 (in Japanese)
5. Ito Y, Oono Y, Yoshida K, Nishiyama S, Tanabe A (2017) Proposal of simple health index
for double reinforced RC slab girder railway bridges. J Struct Eng 63A:876–887 (in Japanese)
6. Railway Technical Research Institute (2004) Design standards for railway structures and
commentary (Concrete Structures). Maruzen Co., Ltd. Tokyo (in Japanese)
7. Sugano S (1970) Experimental study on restoring force characteristic of reinforced concrete
members, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Tokyo (in Japanese)
8. Sogaba M, Matsumoto N, Kanamori M, Sato M, Wakui H (2005) Impact factors of concrete
girders coping with train speed-up. Q Rep RTRI 46(1):46–52
9. Takeda T, Sozen MA, Nielsen NN (1970) Reinforced concrete response to simulated
earthquakes. J Struct Div 96(2):2557–2573
10. Wakui H, Matsumoto N, Watanabe T (1991) An evaluation method of flexural rigidity of
reinforced concrete girders for computing deflection. RTRI Rep 5(11):55–62
The Role of Reinforced Piles in Stability
Analysis of Road Embankment on Soft
Ground
Keywords Soft ground Slope Reinforced pile Piled embankment Stability
analysis Structural engineering Construction
1 Introduction
The Mekong Delta is in the southern part of Vietnam where its soil geology
comprises a variety of low and deep layers of clay or silty clay. This region owns a
complex system of rivers, channels, slopes and various civil infrastructure like
bridges, abutments, and steep slopes. Therefore, constructions in this region have to
be supported on reinforced basement by piles or gravel layer.
In road designs, the embankment is the most important part of the total pavement
structure and therefore it must be stable. Embankment setups are commonly used to
elevate the platform of roads. In case of soft ground settlement in the Mekong
Delta’s areas (which feature river estuaries, harbour foreshore areas, low-lying
marshy or slopes) [2], civil constructions face stability challenges.
H. H. Nguyen (&)
Ho Chi Minh City University of Transport, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
e-mail: hai.nguyen@ut.edu.vn; nghaimail@gmail.com
2 Embankment Design
During the last decade, erosion continues to happen without abating in the Western
of Mekong Delta. For example, in My Tho province the first channel (1819) of
Mekong Delta region what is now Bao Dinh river, happened disaster when a part of
riverside collapsed as soon as after its exploitation. (Fig. 1). It destroyed a lot of
steep slopes, road embankments and agricultural channels.
In this section, a model of a roadway with an embankment that rests on 5 layers
of soft soil will be analyzed. At the beginning, It was decided that a single piling
wall be installed at the side of riverbed (Fig. 2) because this route has light weight
traffic. A differential settlement will be assumed when investigating the role of
reinforced piles in stability analysis of the road embankment.
Fig. 1 Bao Dinh embankment collapsed after exploitation (My Tho, Mekong Delta 06.2016)
The Role of Reinforced Piles in Stability Analysis … 447
The soil profile near the ground surface consists of sand, silty clay and very soft
silty clay as shown in Table 1.
The embankment has a crest width of 3 m and the height is over 2 m. It is
supported by concrete piles. The original design has a range of sheet piles (type
SW-350) with length of 9 m.
By assuming a differential settlement, this embankment was strengthened by a
new range of spun piles (type D400) with lengths varying from 7 m to 11 m, next
to the previous piles (SW-350) what is near the riverbed (Fig. 4). The analysis of
this piled embankment was carried out by using a two-dimensional finite element
model and the Plaxis 2D computer program (Fig. 3).
The Role of Reinforced Piles in Stability Analysis … 449
A coupled solution of two types of pile will be carried out in several parametric
studies:
• Various lateral loads (p): 5 kN/m, 7.5 kN/m, 10 kN/m, 11 kN/m;
• Various D400 pile lengths (L): 7 m, 9 m, 10 m, 11 m;
• Various embankment sloped (i = V:H): 1.25%, 1.5%, 2.0%, 2.5%.
It can be seen from the results given in Table 2 that displacement of both horizontal
and vertical changed a less. Although, the lateral load is increased, the moment piles
and factor of stability almost keep its suitable values (Table 2). Even though the
horizontal displacement of piles was increased with respect to increasing lateral
load. However, the factor of stability (FOS) is negligibly changed and maintains an
allowable value (Table 2).
A Safety calculation was performed using the principal of the failure mechanism
and the corresponding RMsf, which is the safety factor. The RMsf-value of a
particular calculation step can be found in the Calculation information window
displayed as the corresponding option is selected in the Project menu of the Plaxis
2D Output program. The factor of safety is given by:
available strength
SF ¼ ¼ FOS
strength at failure
The development of deformation shown in Fig. 5 will define the role of lateral
loads. It’s also performed load-displacement curve (Fig. 6). The result is the more
load lateral is applied, the more horizontal displacement is happened.
240
Horizontal displacement, mm
238 237.94
236
235.21
234
232
230 229.6
228
226
224
223.3
222
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Lateral load, kN/m
In this scenario, Table 3 presents the results for varying pile length. It can be seen
that the horizontal displacement of piles decreased significantly when the pile
length was made longer. Hence, the factor of stability (FOS) is changed much
(K > 1.2). In Fig. 7, the embankment was more stable, when using longer piles. But
value of vertical displacement decreased effectively (Table 3). Moreover, FOS is
stayed with the same value and this point will help to find the optimal length for
embankment (Fig. 8).
The Role of Reinforced Piles in Stability Analysis … 451
This scenario shows (Table 4) the results for various steep slopes of embankment. It
can be seen that the embankment slope affects the horizontal displacement of piles.
A lower slope (i = 2.5%) is associated with a lesser displacement. The
slope-displacement curve (Fig. 9) shown that the steep slope is efficient (i%) in
control displacement control.
452 H. H. Nguyen
230
Horizontal displacement, mm
228 228.13
226
224
223.3
222
220 220.14
218
216
213.62
214
212
1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 2.2 2.4
Steep slope (i), %
3 Conclusions
Embankment over soft clay is commonly seen in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam. In
this study, we seek a suitable embankment design for civil constructions. After
considering various scenarios and analysing the results, the following conclusions
may be drawn:
• For the Mekong Delta’s stratum like Tien Giang, My Tho province or Western
parts, embankments are more stable if they are reinforced with coupled type of
piles (SW350A and D400). Hence, the previous designs with single pile type
should be added.
• Reinforced piles added in the embankment are more efficient when the steep
slope stands in suitable angle. This point is very important for design because it
helps in getting the optimal dimensions for the embankment.
• The length of D400 piles could be determined from the optimal value of the
stability (FOS). For example, the piles could have the length of 7 m instead of
10 m because the embankment had the same value of FOS (K = 1.22, see
Table 3). Therefore, the engineer could decide the most economical settlement
for current situation.
• The amount of load traffic on the embankment could be determined, regard to
the effect of the lateral load (p), Table 2 shows that the embankment size
depends on the value of the lateral load.
References
Abstract The median strip connecting twin bridges has effects on the rigidity and
dynamic characteristics of the bridges, but the effects are usually ignored, resulting
in unexpected dynamic performance or even structural resonance. In this paper, the
mechanism of median strips as a connection role between twin bridges is analyzed.
Finite element models of the twin bridges and median strip are developed to
analysis the effects on the overall system. Experimental study of typical twin
bridges with a median strip was conducted to explore the relationship between the
median strip and the vibration. Based on these analyses, recommendations related
to overall structural performance are made to ensure a safe and rational design for
twin bridges with median strip especially on dynamic performance in the future.
1 Introduction
Greenbelts are often used for many bridges to separate the round-trip traffic, which
induces sight and increase lateral width and improve the speed, safety and comfort.
Different types of plants can make different separation effects. For example, the
trees with certain height can be used as greenbelts to ensure that drivers are not
disturbed by the vehicles coming from the opposite directions [5, 6]. As well as the
connection of the twin bridges, some requirements are paid attention to use
H. Y. Ma Y. Xia (&)
College of Civil Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, China
e-mail: yxia@tongji.edu.cn
H. Y. Ma
e-mail: mahaiying@tongji.edu.cn
M. L. Ma
Shanghai Municipal Maintenance Management Co., Ltd., Shanghai 201100, China
e-mail: anycalllei@163.com
Three models were built including: (1) Model 1: no connection between the two
bridges; (2) Model 2: as an elastic connection between the two bridges; (3) Model
3: as a hinged connection between the two bridges (Fig. 2).
For Model 1, the bridge is not affected by the median strip. as a result there is no
connection. When analyze the dynamic characteristics, the half can represent the
whole dynamic performance of the bridge (Fig. 3).
For Model 2, the median strip is assumed as an elastic connection, like a spring.
The stronger the restraint, the greater the elastic modulus of the spring is. When it is
strong enough, we can consider it as a rigid connection (Fig. 4).
Resonance Effect of Separate Twin Bridges … 457
Fig. 3 The model with an elastic connection between the two bridges
Fig. 4 The model with a hinged connection n between the two bridges
For Model 3, the constraint of the median strip on the two bridges is mainly
reflected in the displacement, while the relative rotation between the two bridges
only has a little effect.
The result of finite element analysis shows that when the median strip is regarded
as an elastic connection, the corresponding vibration frequency will increase with
the elastic increasing. And the vertical rigidity of the bridge may increase slightly.
When the median strip is regarded as a hinged connection, the lateral and vertical
rigidity of the bridge will improve, but compared with the elastic connection, it may
have a small reduction in rigidity of the actual structure. And for torsional rigidity,
it is larger than that of rigid connections, but not as good as connectionless one.
Fig. 5 Model 1
Fig. 6 Model 2
With the help of the block Lanczos method, which is applicable to large model
multi-mode in ABAQUS, we can get the dynamic characteristics of the simply
supported bridge (Table 1).
From the shape of vibration modes, the shape of fundamental frequency is
different. In the fourth-order mode, the vertical rigidity of bridges is the smallest, so
the first-order mode is mainly vertical bending. In the previous modes, the single
box girder did not appear torsional vibration, while the double box girder appeared
torsional vibration in the second mode, indicating that the torsional rigidity of the
double box section is small and the integrity is poor. Therefore the lateral bending
mode appears later.
3 Experimental Study
See Fig. 7.
Resonance Effect of Separate Twin Bridges … 459
In the main bridge there are 24 vibration sensors, including 17 vertical sensors and
6 transverse sensors. In the approach bridge, 10 sensors are installed in 30 m/span,
including 8 vertical sensors and 2 transverse ones; 10 sensors are installed in 40 m/
span, including 8 vertical sensors and 2 transverse ones.
The special vibration detection includes three working conditions: vehicles working
condition, natural excitation working condition and normal operation working
condition.
460 H. Y. Ma et al.
The working conditions of vehicles are carried out under two-way traffic conditions
closed. An experimental vehicle with known weight passes through the bridge at
the specified speed and lane. According to different combinations of vehicle weight,
speed and lane, the running conditions of vehicles include 24 sub-working condi-
tions. The specific information of sub-working conditions is shown in Table 2.
The natural excitation is carried out under the condition of the traffic closed. The
bridge only bears the action of wind and earth pulsation, except for a few non-motor
vehicles which have little influence. The natural excitation condition lasts for 1 h,
and the vibration response of the bridge is collected to understand the vibration
characteristics.
Normal operation working conditions are carried out without enclosed traffic. It
continued for 24 h. In addition to collecting the vibration response of bridge under
the daily traffic load, the video of road traffic is also taken to record the traffic scene
and traffic flow at the time of severe vibration of the structure.
3.3 Results
Table 3 The limits of Reduced comfort boundary for human exposure to whole-body vibration in
GB/T3442-92
Vibration Frequency RMS of value of acceleration m/s2
direction Hz Exposure time
24 h 16 h 8h 4h 2.5 h 1h 25 min 16 min 1 min
Vertical 4’8 0.04 0.07 0.10 0.17 0.23 0.37 0.57 0.67 0.89
Transverse 1–2 0.03 0.05 0.07 0.11 0.16 0.27 0.40 0.48 0.63
Resonance Effect of Separate Twin Bridges … 461
4 Conclusions
According to the structural analysis, finite element analysis and experimental study,
some conclusions are made as follows,
(1) The median strip has a connection function, and meanwhile affects the trans-
verse and torsional rigidity and dynamic characteristics of the bridge.
(2) The soil filling in the median strip may have a function of energy dissipation
and vibration reduction, it needs further study in the future.
Therefore, some suggestions are made as follows:
(1) The design of median strip should be considered at the design stage, and
corresponding measures should be taken to reduce its adverse impact on the
bridge body according to its significant influence.
(2) The damping effect of soil filling in the median strip can be used appropriately
as the seismic mitigation measures of the bridge to ensure the safety and
reliability of the structure.
462 H. Y. Ma et al.
Acknowledgment This paper is supported by the National Key R&D Program of China
(2017YFC1500603), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (51978508, 51608378),
the Science and Technology Commission of Shanghai Municipality (18DZ1201200), and the
Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities.
References
Abstract Rubber marine fenders have been the most prevalent type to berth
vessels due to their reusability. However, variance in life of these rubber marine
fenders has been one of the major causes for the unplanned downtime of com-
mercial ports and terminals. The mechanism of metal cutting is investigated in this
paper as an impact energy absorption element. A series of experiment to investigate
the impact energy absorbing characteristics of aluminium and brass rods with
various cutting depths and impact energy were carried out and cross-checked by a
numerical study using explicit dynamics. The behaviour of reaction force at impact
was found to be highly reliant on cutting depth. This material removal process was
also found to be efficient in dissipating impact energy to provide sufficient structural
protection. Acceleration Severity Index was defined to demonstrate the occupant
protection with acceptable declarative forces during impact. A hybrid fender system
with the metal cutting mechanism as a backup system incorporated into the current
elastic marine fender is proposed in this study to reduce downtime and improve
turnaround times of port operators.
1 Introduction
The role of marine fenders is to berth vessels without damaging the berthing
structure and vessel by absorbing the impact energy of a berthing vessel. A cost
factor is one of the key criteria in choosing the ideal fender system which causes
elastic types to be the most widespread fender system in the globe [8]. Due to its
nature, elastic energy absorbers are suitable for repeatable low energy collision
without causing significant damage [12]. However, elastic energy absorbers are
made of highly non-linear materials so that they may not be suitable for high energy
collision. The reaction forces and the energy absorbing behaviour of elastic fenders
are highly dependent upon temperature and impact velocity. Because of the harsh
marine environment, strict maintenance schedules are required for marine fenders.
75% of 200 port operators around the world have reported to experience
unscheduled downtime in 2014, 38% of which were related to damaged jetty
structures from the failure of fenders [10]. The current marine fender systems,
therefore, demand an emergency backup system in case that the primary system is
in failure.
The performance of marine fenders can be significantly improved if berthing
energy can be dissipated/absorbed in a controlled manner with an ideal decelerative
force. Numerous experimental and numerical studies have been reported to char-
acterise the non-linear behaviour of plastic impact energy absorbers with good
repeatability. Amongst various types of impact energy absorbers using plastic
deformation of materials, the mechanics of metal cutting in absorbing impact
energy has been studied by a few investigators [2–4, 7]. The idea of metal cutting to
absorb impact energy was first introduced by Shaw [7] with a metal rod in a vehicle
bumper bar to be pushed through a cutting tool when impact. The impact energy is
dissipated via the formation of metal chips, thereby stopping the vehicle. A similar
concept was implemented by Kirk [2] in an emergency stopping device for a
subway train. This experimental work proved impact energy was absorbed/
dissipated effectively in consistent behaviour independent of cutting velocity.
The aim of this study is hence to systematically explore the feasibility of
implementing the metal cutting mechanism for a backup in a conventional marine
fender system. Due to the complexity and non-linearity of this mechanism, both
experimental and numerical investigations were carried out. A custom-built drop
tower was used to apply various impact energy to cut the specimens and finite
element methods (FEM) were used to validate its experimental work. A hybrid
design with the metal cutting mechanism embedded in the existing marine fender is
suggested at the end of the paper with a practical implementation study.
A Backup Marine Fender System 465
2 Methodology
A drop tower was custom-made with a 250UC universal column and a 15 kg drop
mass as shown in Fig. 1. In this apparatus, the maximum drop height was 3 metres
and a removable mass supporter were used within 254 mm of the existing 250UC
universal column.
Two cutting tools with rake and clearance angles of 10° were installed using
cold-worked tool K245 steel whose Brinell hardness is 642. The drop tower was
equipped with a guidance rod connecting the cutting rod and the stopper. This
guidance rod ensures a completely vertical drop of the 15 kg mass upon the removal
of the mass supporter that imparts an impact force by hitting the stopper.
Fig. 1 a Schematic diagram of the drop tower and b actual photo of the circled part in a
466 J. Sul et al.
Fig. 2 a Schematic diagram, b actual photo of aluminium cutting rod and c numerical model of a
quarter of the cutting rod with one cutting tool (all dimensions in millimetres)
Aluminium 2011 and Brass 385 were implemented and tested to investigate the
behaviour of metal cutting at impact. The cutting rods were fabricated by machining
the bar stock materials to the dimensions shown in Fig. 2(a). The photo of an
aluminium 2011 cutting rod is shown in Fig. 2(b).
A Backup Marine Fender System 467
Diameter of cutting rods, cutting depth and drop height adopted for experimental
variables to investigate the dependence of each parameter. The metal cutting test
was performed with 10 aluminium 2011 and 2 brass 385 specimens, and each tested
cutting rod was rotated by 90° to cut the intact part, totalling 24 data sets. The
specimen IDs and corresponding test parameters are presented in Table 1.
Zl
Eabsorption ¼ Fdl ð1Þ
0
where Eabsorption is the energy absorbed by the cutting rod during impact, F is the
cutting force and l is the cutting length. Specific energy absorption (U) can be
defined by dividing the absorbed energy by the mass of eroded elements from the
impact:
Eabsorption
U¼ ð2Þ
Verosion
where Verosion is the volume of the eroded elements in the numerical modelling.
This specific energy absorption is equivalent to the specific cutting energy in the
metal cutting mechanism.
468 J. Sul et al.
The cutting length of each specimen was measured on all four sides and averaged in
the experimental work. Numerical analysis was conducted with the same test
parameters and its results are used for the validation purpose. For the numerical
study, the total work done, cutting volume, reaction force and deceleration were
calculated along with the cutting length, which is shown and compared in Table 2.
The experimental cutting lengths are in good agreement with the numerical ones
with the maximum difference of 6.74% for A8–A10.
The reaction forces at the cutting tool (fixed boundary) were monitored over the
total simulation time for each specimen and presented in Fig. 3(a). It is shown that
the trend for the reaction forces and specific cutting energy of each specimen can be
grouped on the basis of cutting depth instead of their drop height. Each cutting depth
clearly presents distinctive behaviour with the maximum reaction forces of speci-
mens A8-10 (3 mm cutting depth) and A4–A7 (2 mm cutting depth) tripled and
doubled, respectively, from that of A1–A3. Furthermore, the reaction forces between
B1 and B2 remain similar with the same cutting depth despite different drop height.
The cutting chips generated from the experiment were mostly a discontinuous
type. Specimens A1–A3 with 1 mm cutting depth were with curled chips while the
rest with 2 mm and 3 mm cutting depth were with serrated chips. The characteristics
of curled chips are well presented in the result of the numerical study (Fig. 3(a)) with
relatively low reaction forces with the shallow cutting depth. On the other hand,
serrated chips are the evidence of deep cutting to bulge and separate with localised
intensive shear [5]. This cutting behaviour is accompanied with pronouncedly
increasing cutting forces [9], which are evidenced in the numerical study with
excessive reaction forces as compared to that of A1–A3.
Fig. 3 a Reaction forces from the numerical study and b Acceleration severity index for each
specimen with each cutting depth presented in the bracket
The collision and cutting processes occur over a very brief time interval. An
impact from a collision causes serious injuries to humans even in the absence of a
physical contact. The Acceleration Severity Index (ASI) implemented in European
Standard, EN 1317-2 [1], describes the occupant safety level in the event of a
vehicle crash by comparing the gravitational force in a collision to predetermined
threshold values. ASI less than 1.0 indicated no/minimal injury and ASI greater
than 1.4 indicates potential severe injury for the occupants. By using the gravita-
tional forces at impact, ASI can be evaluated using:
ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
s 2 2
ax 2 ay az
ASIðtÞ ¼ þ þ ð3Þ
^ax ^ay ^
az
A hybrid fender system that benefits from the reusability of elastic fenders, and
predictability and controllability of the metal cutting mechanism is proposed for an
economic design in this Section. 8 brass rods with 2 mm cutting depth are installed
in a conventional Super Cone Fender system, SCN1000 [11] that has the maximum
energy absorption capacity of 500 kJ. The maximum cutting length is assumed to
be 280 mm with 72% deflection zone of SCN1000 (metal cutting starts after the
SCN1000 is compressed by 72% in case of emergency). This cutting length in turn
470 J. Sul et al.
provides an energy absorbing capacity of 23.26 kJ for a single rod and additional
186.08 kJ to a single SCN1000.
For an implementation scenario, the proposed hybrid fender system is assumed
in the worst-case scenario where the conventional SCN1000 functions only with its
50% capacity in a severe weather condition. Based on PIANC guidelines [6] with
all factors being unity (worst-case), the berthing energy of a bulk carrier with its
displacement tonnage at 95% confidence level of 464,000 tonnes is calculated to be
3,341 kJ. In consideration of the vessel length and 150% design allowance imposed
by PIANC [6], 10 SCN1000 fenders with 80 brass cutting rods are assumed to
absorb the berthing energy of the design vessel. Based on the assumptions and the
capacity of each energy absorbing mechanism, the backup fender system using the
metal cutting mechanism can provide an additional berthing energy capacity of
1860.8 kJ. As a result, the berthing structure will be protected in an emergency
situation in which the elastic fenders functions only at 30% of its full capacity
without causing injury on the occupants of the berthing vessel.
4 Conclusions
A new backup fender system using a metal cutting mechanism has been proposed in
this study. A series of experiment and numerical modelling have shown that the
metal cutting mechanism could absorb impact energy at berthing in a safe and
controllable way with high repeatability. Various test parameters were used in this
experimental and numerical investigation, including input energy, material and
cutting depth. The results clearly indicate that the trend of reaction force, the
maximum reaction force and specific cutting energy are highly dependent on cut-
ting depth. It was found that 1 mm cutting depth provides the minimum reaction
force but for the prolonged time whereas 3 mm cutting depth results in an
approximately 3 times greater reaction force than that of 1 mm cutting depth. ASIs
were evaluated to investigate the influence of the reaction forces resulted from the
metal cutting process on the human body. Regardless of cutting depth, all test cases
were within the recommended limit to protect the occupants.
This new system has been suggested to be embedded in an existing elastic
marine fender to maximise its economic factor. A brass cutting rod with 2 mm
cutting depth was implemented for the worst-case scenario to berth a cargo vessel.
Even with hostile conditions assumed in the implementation case, the new hybrid
marine fender system is capable of safely berthing the design vessel without
damaging the berthing structure, vessel and/or occupants with the elastic fenders
functioning only at 30% of their capacity.
A Backup Marine Fender System 471
References
Abstract The Borneo Camphor with its scientific name, Dryobalanops aromatica
is a type of tropical tree that possesses winged seeds that gyrate for propagation.
The Borneo Camphor seed is unique as it consists of 5 pre-coning flexible wings
which allow it to track the oncoming relative wind and expands its rotor diameter
due to centrifugal forces induced by rotation. This subsequently increases drag
which reduces its terminal velocity, furthering its propagation distance from the
mother tree. The mechanical and flight characteristics of the Borneo Camphor seed
was mimicked into the design of a novel biomimetic downwind, flexible,
pre-coning and sheetlike blades wind turbine. This biomimetic wind turbine fea-
tures the abilities to track the wind direction passively due to its pre-coning blades,
enables cheap fabrication method due to the lightweight polypropylene sheet, easy
transport and packaging due to the sheetlike blades, and passive extreme wind
protection system which will be triggered by coupling the collapsible blades and
also internal mechanical brakes. A preliminary study was conducted to predict the
power performance of a 0.7 m diameter biomimetic wind turbine by using
Fluid-Structure Interaction (FSI) simulation while the yaw recovery speed was
tested by using a simple blower fan setup with a free yawing wind turbine proto-
type. The FSI prediction shows that the maximum power coefficient, CP_max was
22.9% higher than a flat plate benchmark turbine at a wind speed of 3 m/s. The
wind turbine prototype rotor was able to turn from 90 to 0° yaw error in approx-
imately 1 s at an averaged wind speed of 3.73 m/s. This preliminary result shows
the potential of the biomimetic wind turbine in distributed wind applications such as
green energy housing, portable wind turbines, and temporary off-grid wind energy
systems.
1 Introduction
The wind turbine is a rotating device capable of harvesting wind power to generate
electricity. The Horizontal Axis Wind Turbine (HAWT) where its rotational axis
lies on the horizontal plane is the main type of wind turbine available in the market
nowadays [6]. The HAWT has become the popular wind power technology due to
its high performance [9]. There are two configurations of HAWT namely the
upwind HAWT and the downwind HAWT. The upwind HAWT has the rotor
situated in the upstream of support tower while the downwind HAWT rotor is at
downstream. The upwind HAWT needs active yaw mechanism while the down-
wind HAWT tracks the wind passively [3].
The downwind wind turbine can be a good investment as there are several
notable advantages compared with the upwind wind turbine. Firstly, the downwind
wind turbine has its blades situated at the downstream location which allows fast
passive yaw against changing wind direction [11]. This passive yawing mechanism
allows the downwind wind turbine to have simpler yaw bearing system where
additional motor for active yaw is not needed. Thus, minimizing the total cost of the
wind turbine structure. The investigations were done by Kress et al. [4] also show
that the downwind wind turbine outperform the upwind wind turbine as it exhibits
more controllability. However, the generated power of the downwind wind turbine
is expected to be lower than the upwind wind turbine due to the tower shadow effect
towards the blades [2]. Thus, the tower radius has to be small or tower fairing is
needed to reduce the effect of tower wake on the wind turbine blades.
Conventional tapered and twisted wind turbine blades were made rigid in order
to resist thrust from wind load. This is because the deformation effect of the blades
that are not considered in calculations will reduce the performance of the wind
turbine significantly. Thus, strong and expensive material such as the carbon fiber
reinforced polymer (CFRP) and glass fiber reinforced polymer (GFRP) was used in
fabricating the blades [1]. Apart from the conventional rigid blades wind turbines,
there are some notable flexible wind turbines which possess unique features for
certain applications. For example, MacPhee and Beyene [5] designed a small
flexible blades wind turbine which has maximum efficiency increased by 32.6%
compared with a rigid benchmark wind turbine. The mentioned example proves that
the flexible blade wind turbine is worthy of investments in the wind power industry.
Based on the abovementioned references, it is proposed that the combination of
downwind configuration and flexible blades will have a synergistic effect that will
increase the total performance of a HAWT. The downwind configuration with
pre-cone blades will enable fast passive yaw mechanism that will align the wind
turbine quickly against on-coming. The flexible blades allow expansion of the rotor
diameter by rotation induced centrifugal forces and this will increase the wind
A Preliminary Study on the Performance … 475
power generation. Stress-stiffening due to rotation will increase the stiffness of the
blades and increase their natural frequency, subsequently reduce the fluttering of
blades. In addition, the sheetlike blade sections with constant thickness allow cheap
material and fabrication method. Thus, it is expected that this novel design of
flexible blade downwind HAWT will be a cost-effective alternative to the con-
ventional tapered and twisted wind turbines.
2 Numerical Setup
2.2 Equation
Equations for the power, thrust coefficients, rotor area, tip speed ratio, and simu-
lation error are as follows:
Qx
CP ¼ ð1Þ
0:5qV 3 A
T
CT ¼ ð2Þ
0:5qV 2 A
A ¼ pR2 ð3Þ
xR
TSR ¼ ð4Þ
V
E ¼ S TR ð5Þ
The fluid-structure interaction (FSI) was conducted by utilizing the ANSYS System
Coupling application which involved a 2-way interaction between the Transient
Structural and Fluent solvers. The Fluent solver power coefficients results were
validated by comparing with the result from QBlade which is an open source wind
turbine calculation software according to Marten et al. [7]. The CL and CD of the flat
plate wind turbine airfoil section were generated by using the in-built XFOIL 2D
airfoil analysis while the turbine power performance was calculated by using the
Blade Element Momentum (BEM) algorithms in QBlade. The thickness of the flat
plate was set to 1% of the chord in the XFOIL module assuming it to be
infinitesimally thin similar to the research of Sanders [10]. It was assumed that the
1 mm thickness of the ANSYS flat plate turbine blade is also infinitesimally thin so
as to allow validation from the QBlade analysis results. Steel and polypropylene
were set as the materials for the benchmark and biomimetic wind turbines
respectively. It was observed that the Fluent over predicted the CP. Thus, presuming
that the QBlade result to be able to represent the reality as BEM and DMS method
are known to be accurate especially in low wind speed while not consuming
computational resources excessively as shown in the torque validation in Marten
et al. [7], the Fluent results were corrected according to the validation. By assuming
the QBlade result represent the truth value and referring to the numerical error
478 Y.-J. Chu and H.-F. Lam
equation from Stern et al. [12], Eq. (5) was used to calculate the numerical errors of
CP at each TSRs of the flat plate turbine. The corrected power coefficient, CPcor of
the biomimetic wind turbine was then calculated based on the numerical errors of
the flat plate turbine. Prism cells were generated for the Transient structural meshes
while tetrahedral cells were generated for the Fluent meshes. Coarse meshes were
used to simulate all cases due to the limitation of computational power and time.
For the case of the benchmark turbine, the Transient structural mesh element
number is 948 while it is 8090 for the Fluent fluid domain. For the case of the
biomimetic turbine, Transient structural mesh element number is 2710 while it is
10043 for the Fluent fluid domain. The larger surface area of the biomimetic turbine
causes a higher number of mesh elements. Table 1 shows the settings and initial
conditions of the FSI simulation. Figure 3 shows the 3D view of the turbine and the
fluid domain.
The fabrication of the prototype wind turbine blades was proposed to be made of
polypropylene sheets through cutting and bending process according to a crease
pattern as shown in Fig. 1. A plastic bending device was used to bend the plastic
sheets into the desired shape. Figure 4 shows a flexible blade downwind HAWT
prototype with blades made of polypropylene sheets. A preliminary yaw mecha-
nism test on the flexible blade downwind HAWT prototype was done by using 50
FPS video camera, fan blower and hot-wire anemometer. Figure 5 shows the
preliminary yaw mechanism test setup with 1D denotes 1 rotor diameter distance.
Fig. 5 Preliminary turbine passive yaw mechanism test fan blower setup
The power coefficients at various TSRs of the benchmark and biomimetic wind
turbine were plotted by using Eqs. (1)—(4). Base on the results, the maximum
power coefficient, CP_max of the biomimetic wind turbine is 22.9% higher than the
CP_max of the flat plate wind turbine while the maximum thrust coefficient, CT_max
of the biomimetic wind turbine is 18.9% lower than the CT_max of the flat plate wind
turbine. This shows that the proposed biomimetic wind turbine has higher power
output while induced lower thrust force. The corrected power and thrust coeffi-
cients, CPcor_max and CTcor_max of the biomimetic wind turbine are 0.366 and 0.535
0.7 1.1
Biomimetic FSI Biomimetic FSI
Corrected Bio. 1.0 Corrected Bio.
0.6 Flat plate FSI Flat plate FSI
Flat plate QBlade 0.9 Flat plate QBlade
0.5
0.8
0.4 0.7
CT
CP
0.3 0.6
0.2 0.5
0.4
0.1
0.3
0.0 0.2
-0.1 0.1
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
TSR TSR
respectively. The ability to increase the rotor diameter by bending and reducing the
cone angle made the biomimetic wind turbine able to harvest more wind power
after the wind direction is tracked. The operating TSR range of the biomimetic wind
turbine is expected to be lower than the benchmark wind turbine where its positive
CP is up until TSR = 9 while the benchmark turbine is able to reach TSR = 14.
Figure 6 shows the CP and CT versus TSR graph while Fig. 7 shows the deflected
flexible blades with decreased coning angle.
The wind turbine prototype rotor was able to turn from the 90 to 0° yaw in
approximately 1 s and it reaches a steady rotational speed at the 5th s. Average wind
speed at one rotor diameter upstream of the flexible blade downwind HAWT
prototype is 3.73 m/s as measured by using a hot-wire anemometer. The prelimi-
nary yaw mechanism test result shows that the 0.7 m diameter flexible blade
downwind HAWT prototype has fast response towards changing wind direction.
This shows that the biomimetic wind turbine has the ability to fold its rotor blades
by bending and increase the cone angle to track the wind direction by means of a
wind vane.
482 Y.-J. Chu and H.-F. Lam
There are several expected advantages of the proposed biomimetic wind turbine
where the preconed blades increase yaw capability, sheetlike blades enable stacking
to ease transport and packaging. The flexible blades reduce blade root stresses by
utilizing centrifugal forces, lightweight blade with cheap material e.g. polypropy-
lene which allows better yaw performance and lower gyroscopic loads. Easier and
cheaper fabrication method e.g. plastic bending method can be used to fabricate the
biomimetic turbine blades from plastic sheets compared with the expensive injec-
tion molding and casting. It has strong and simple connections at blade root and
yaw bearing which will result in sturdy wind turbine structure. Its flexible blades
enable extreme wind protection by utilizing a passive mechanical braking mecha-
nism which will stop rotating at certain wind speed that allows wind to fold the
blades towards the downstream direction, reducing the rotor area and subsequently
reducing drag.
There are a few expected potential applications of the biomimetic wind turbine
where the flexible blade downwind HAWT is suitable to be invested in small and
medium scale wind farm due to the fast passive yaw mechanism which is much
cheaper than a sophisticated active yaw control system. The flexible blade down-
wind HAWT is expected to have good self-start capability which made it suitable to
operate water pumping machines. Due to the flat plate blade sections, the fabri-
cation and material cost of the flexible blade downwind HAWT are expected to be
cheap and it is suitable for low-cost green energy housing. Due to the stacking
feature of the blades, the flexible blade downwind HAWT design can be imple-
mented into portable wind turbines which can be assembled and packed easily. The
unique biomimetic wind turbine is suitable for temporary applications such as
power up a site office made of a container for 1–3 years so that it can be powered
off the grid.
4 Conclusions
This preliminary study predicted that the proposed flexible sheetlike blade biomi-
metic wind turbine outperforms the benchmark turbine while having comparable
CPcor_max of 0.366 and low CTcor_max of 0.535. The ability to fold and unfold its
flexible blades made the biomimetic wind turbine able to attain high power output
and fast yaw recovery speed. The single thickness of its sheetlike blades ease the
fabrication process and thus greatly reduce the manufacturing cost. In conclusion,
the proposed biomimetic flexible sheetlike blade has the potential to become a
cheap and cost-effective wind turbine which is worthy of further investments.
A Preliminary Study on the Performance … 483
Acknowledgements The study presented in the paper was fully funded by a grant from the
Research Grants Council of the Hong Kong SAR, China [Project No. 9042509 (CityU
11210517)].
References
1. Brøndsted P, Nijssen RP (2013) Advances in wind turbine blade design and materials.
Woodhead publishing series in energy. Elsevier Science, Sawston, Cambridge
2. Glasgow JC, Miller DR, Corrigan RD (1981) Comparison of upwind and downwind rotor
operation of the DOE/NASA 100-kW MOD-0 wind turbine. In: Proceedings of 2nd DOE/
NASA wind turbine dynamics workshop, Cleveland, 24–26 February 1981, vol 1, pp 24–26
3. Koh JH, Ng EYK (2016) Downwind offshore wind turbines: opportunities, trends and
technical challenges. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 54:797–808
4. Kress C, Chokani N, Abhari RS (2015) Downwind wind turbine yaw stability and
performance. Renew Energy 83:1157–1165
5. MacPhee DW, Beyene A (2018) Performance analysis of a small wind turbine equipped with
flexible blades. Renew Energy 132:497–508
6. Manwel JF, McGowan JG, Rogers AL (2009) Wind energy explained: theory, design and
application, 2nd edn. Wiley, New York
7. Marten D, Wendler J, Pechlivanoglou G, Nayeri CN, Paschereit CO (2013) QBLADE: an
open source tool for design and simulation of horizontal and vertical axis wind turbines. Int J
Emerg Technol Adv Eng 3(3):264–269
8. McCormick BW (1979) Aerodynamics, aeronautics, and flight mechanics. Wiley, New York
9. Pope K, Dincer I, Naterer GF (2010) Energy and exergy efficiency comparison of horizontal
and vertical axis wind turbines. Renew Energy 35(9):2102–2113
10. Sanders M (2014) The boundary layer over a flat plate. Bachelor thesis, University of Twente.
http://essay.utwente.nl/65492/
11. Snel H, Schepers JG (1995) Joint investigation of dynamic inflow effects and implementation
of an engineering method. Netherlands Energy Research Foundation ECN
12. Stern F, Wilson RV, Coleman HW, Paterson EG (2001) Comprehensive approach to
verification and validation of CFD simulations—part 1: methodology and procedures. J Fluids
Eng 123(4):793–802
Study on Timber Wall Reinforcing
with High-Performance Fiber Webbing
Keywords Timber structure Timber wall Reinforcement High-performance
fiber webbing Aramid fiber
1 Introduction
Earthquakes with more than magnitude 6.0 strike 326 times in Japan from 2003 to
2013, which account for 20% of the earthquakes in the world. Japanese Seismic
Resistance Law has been changed every huge earthquake occurred. However,
houses build with old standard does not satisfy the present law. In fact, the main
reason for collapse of timber house by earthquake is disqualification in the existing
building law. Investigation by the government reveals that over 60% houses are
timber structure in Japan. In 2013 the Japanese government has reported that over
45% timber houses were built before the new building standards law. They also
predict that number of collapses of timber houses may increase in the future without
reinforcement. However, reinforcement requires a time and expenses to owners, so
earthquake proof on timber houses are barely progressed in these days.
Fig. 1 Details of
high-performance fiber
17mm 12mm
webbing
This chapter reports on validity of the method to jointing the webbing with screw.
At first, tensile experiment was carried out to investigate its initial tensile strength
with screws joint. Figure 1 and Table 1 shows details of High-Performance fiber
webbing and its original characteristics.
This experiment was carried out preparing 2 webbings and 2 pieces of wooden
board, joining with screw for every 50 mm against the grain. Specimen No.1 is
webbing with 1 screw on both side of wooden board, Specimen No.2 is webbing
with 3 screws, Specimen No.3 is webbing with 5 screws, Specimen No.4 is web-
bing with 7 screws. Figure 2 shows specimens No.1 to No.4 before and after the
experiment. Then tensile tests on each specimen were carried out as pulling each
side of wooden boards by Amsler universal testing machine.
Figure 3 shows the result of the tensile test. Speech bubbles on Fig. 3 show the
maximum load during the experiment. According to Fig. 2, destruction properties
are same in all specimens; load decreased suddenly after screws tore off the web-
bing. As increasing number of screws, maximum load has increased about 1.0–1.5
kN by one screw. Therefore, tensile strength of webbing will increase as number of
screws increasing. However, this result also reveals that rigidity of the webbing
were not affected by amount of screws.
488 Y. Inoue and O. Takahashi
Specimen
No.2
Specimen
No.3
Specimen
No.4
10
9 9.01
8
7 6.66
6
Load(kN)
5 No.1
4 No.2
3 3.34
No.3
2
1.50 No.4
1
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Displacement (mm)
In order to compare the method of application on the wall, specimens were dif-
ferentiated by changing the place to connect the webbing. Two types of wall were
designed. Specimen No.5 was a benchmark wall to investigate general effect of the
webbing which is applied as a brace. Lattice wall was designed for Specimen No.6
and No.7 assuming more practical use. The Fig. 4 shows outline of three speci-
mens. Specimen No.6 was the lattice wall with reinforced column’s bottom with the
webbing. Specimen No.7 was No.6 with webbing’s brace.
Figure 5 shows the result of the experiment. Experiment was done for Specimen
No.5 until 300 mm displacement on the beam, which was maximum displacement
of the jack. There were no damages observed on screws and the webbing.
Specimen No.7 was pulled until its total collapse, and the column was pulled out
from the beam. According to Fig. 5, stiffness of specimen No.5 was comparably
low and load against displacement was huge. This would be observed because
webbing was joined at only edge of the wall and displacement got great at not
jointed area. By comparing two specimens, maximum load increases about 2 kN at
deformation of 1/60 rad. In this both specimens, the wall was more rigid and
possible to joint with screws at 100–150 mm spacing. Generally, conventional post
and beam structural systems timber wall has certain rigid wall with Stud. Therefore,
this method would be effective for reinforcing old and deteriorated wall (Fig. 6).
490 Y. Inoue and O. Takahashi
5
Load(kN) 4
0
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12
Deformation angle (rad)
14
Specimen No.6
12 Specimen No.7
10
Loads(kN)
8
6
4
2
0
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08
Displacement(rad)
This chapter reports on the experimental study of reinforced timber wall using
specially designed joint for the webbing. Figure 7 shows the overview of the
specially designed metal joints. These joints could wind the webbing and placed on
each edges of the wall. In-plane shear test was carried out until 300 mm dis-
placement. This experiment is based on “Evaluation and method of each members
in timber framework house” from “Allowable stress design method of timber
framework house”.
Study on Timber Wall Reinforcing … 491
Figure 8 shows Specimen No.8 and No.9. Only metal joints were applied in
Specimen No.8 and No.9 was with metal joints and webbing.
Figure 9 shows the result of in-plane shear test. The test has been done until
300 mm displacement of the beam. At the maximum displacement, there were no
damages on the metal joints, but tore on the webbing was observed in both
492 Y. Inoue and O. Takahashi
8
7
6
Load (kN)
5
4
3 Specimen
2 No.8
Specimen
1 No.9
0
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12
Deformation angle (rad)
Fig. 9 Result of in-plane shear test among specimen No.8 and No.9
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements I wish to acknowledge POLUS Co., Ltd for experimental design and Teijin
Limited for funding. I wish to thank Natsuki YASUI for her help in interpreting the significance of
the results of this study.
Study on Timber Wall Reinforcing … 493
References
1. Ministry of land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, HOWTEC (2018) Evaluation and
method of each members in timber framework house. Allowable stress design method of
timber framework house
2. Yasui N, Takahashi O (2019) Study on application of high-performance fiber for structural
members part5 strength test by knot and in-face shearing test of bearing wall using fiber rope.
Summery of technical papers of annual meeting Architectural Institute of Japan
Optimal Design for Stability
Performance of Super Tall Residential
Tower Equipped with Reinforced
Concrete Outriggers
Abstract With the increasing height of super tall buildings, the overall stability
performance design of buildings is also facing challenges. As an important index to
control the overall stability of super tall buildings, the rigidity-weight ratio is not
easy to meet the requirements of the code when the height-width ratio of the
structure is particularly large. In view of the fact that the height-width ratio of super
tall residential buildings is generally large and the rigidity-weight ratio does not
meet the requirements of the code, a reinforced concrete outrigger is proposed. The
reinforced concrete outrigger can not only effectively solve the rigidity-weight ratio
problem of the building, make the overall stability of the building meet the
requirements, but also have some advantages that the steel outrigger does not have,
such as reducing the construction period, no need for later maintenance, etc.
Finally, combined with the engineering example of Chengdu La Cadiere Center
(249.8 m), the actual effect of reinforced concrete outrigger on the performance
optimization of super tall residential buildings is elaborated.
Keywords Super tall residential buildings Reinforced concrete outriggers
Stability optimization Rigidity-weight ratio adjustment
1 Introduction
Optimal design has attracted more and more attention in the construction industry,
especially in the optimization design of super high-rise buildings. For super
high-rise buildings with large height and volume, their overall stability often
becomes the focus of optimization design. The additional effect of gravity load due
to lateral displacement is called gravity P-Delta effect after horizontal displacement
of building under wind load or horizontal earthquake. In super-high-rise buildings,
gravity P-Delta effect is an important factor leading to the overall structural
instability. With the increase of height, the lateral stiffness of super high-rise
buildings decreases relatively, which leads to the increase of internal force and
displacement, and the P-Delta effect of gravity becomes obvious gradually, even
leads to structural instability. Both ASCE 7 and European codes stipulate the limit
value of stability coefficient theta to ensure structural stability. The ratio of lateral
stiffness to gravity load, rigidity-weight ratio is adopted as the control index of
overall stability in Chinese codes.
As an innovative and efficient structural lateral resistance system, the outrigger
system can economically and effectively adjust the rigidity-weight ratio of the
building, and then optimize the overall stability of the building. Outrigger system
has been widely used in super high-rise buildings in recent decades. However, this
system usually uses steel outrigger, which often has high cost, long construction
period and needs late maintenance. There is still room for optimization. In this
paper, a reinforced concrete outrigger is proposed, which overcomes the short-
comings of steel outrigger and has its functions. It is of great significance to the
overall stability optimization design of super high-rise residential buildings. Finally,
according to the engineering example of Chengdu La Cadiere Center, the feasibility
of concrete outrigger is discussed comparatively.
2 Theoretical Basis
As the height of structure increases, the lateral deflection of the structure caused by
lateral loads is amplified by gravity loads, which is called P-Delta effect in Chinese
Code. The P-Delta effect may be significant in slender structures. If the weight of
the structure is high in proportion to the lateral stiffness of the structure, P-Delta
effect can change displacements and internal forces by 25 or 30% under certain
circumstances [5], which will cause structure instability. To ensure structure sta-
bility, P-Delta effect limitations are specified in Chinese Code:
EJd
k¼ P
n 1:4 ð1Þ
H 2 Gi
i¼1
11qH 4
EJd ¼ ð2Þ
120u
Where q is the peak value of lateral force; u is the peak horizontal displacement
under the lateral force.
The above formulas are derived based on the assumption that the weight is
uniformly distributed along the building height and the lateral force is in an inverse
triangle distribution. Actually, for many tall structures, the weight isn’t uniformly
distributed along the building height. And actual lateral loads are not in inverse
triangle distributions at all. As a result of this, sometimes the limitations specified in
Chinese Code may be too strict and somewhat unreasonable. In consideration of the
non-uniform distribution of vertical loads, correction factor should be introduced in
calculation of rigidity-gravity ratio.
0
k ¼ bk ð3Þ
P
n
Gi
1 i¼1
b¼ P h 2 i ð4Þ
3 n
Gi HHi
i¼1
0
Where k is modified rigidity-gravity ratio; b is correction factor; Hi is the
elevation from the ground to the its story. The weight distribution factor is written
as A. So the modified rigidity-gravity ratio can be expressed as:
0 11qH 2
k ¼ ð5Þ
360uA
So, once the relationship between u and structural member cost, the relationship
0
between A and structural member cost are established, the relationship between k
and structural member cost can be established to perform sensitivity analysis.
0
@k
sck ¼ ¼ scku þ sckA ð6Þ
@cok
0 0
@k @u k @u
scku ¼ ¼ ð7Þ
@u @co k u @cok
0 0
@k @A k @A
sckA ¼ ¼ ð8Þ
@A @co k A @cok
0
Where sck is the modified rigidity-gravity ratio k sensitivity coefficient for
material cost of member k; cok is the material cost of member k; scku is sensitivity
coefficient caused by change of horizontal displacement; sckA is sensitivity coeffi-
cient caused by change of weight distribution factor. For reinforced concrete
structures, the sensitivity coefficient derived from rigidity-weight ratio can be used
to optimize the cost of components and reduce the cost of components.
In Fig. 1 Steel outrigger form truss systems by connecting with giant columns,
concrete core tubes and horizontal chords, thus effectively resisting transverse loads
and increasing the overall stability of the structure [3]. Like steel outrigger, rein-
forced concrete outrigger forms truss system by special reinforcement and opening,
as shown in Fig. 2, and we call this truss strut-and-tie model [1].
A strut-and-tie model may be applied where opening sizes and locations permit.
This requires clear paths with adequate face width and wall thickness for com-
pression struts, bands of continuous reinforcement or embedded tension members
for tension ties, and adequate room at strut/tie intersections for force-transfer nodes.
Strut-and-tie can efficiently resolve forces from outriggers on opposite sides of the
core acting in opposite directions, as when resisting overturning. Additional tension
ties and compression struts are needed for outriggers acting in the same direction.
Strut-and-tie modeling can be complicated when outriggers at right angles meet at
the same corner of a core. As force magnitudes and directions from those outriggers
vary with time, conditions at the nodes will also vary dramatically [4].
Concrete to concrete connections may also be complex, depending on outrigger
geometry. Transitioning diagonal reinforcing into horizontal and vertical rein-
forcement, developing bars, lapping bars, and anticipating and resolving different
strain values and patterns for compression and tension in the outrigger member
must all be addressed [1].
3 Engineering Case
This paper takes the third building of the La Cadiere Center as an example. The
project is located in Chengdu with 7 degrees of fortification intensity and 0.3 kN/m2
of basic wind pressure. The height of the house is about 249.80 m and 67 floors
above ground; the first floor is 9 m, the standard floor is 3.4 m and the shelter floor
is 4.5 m; the equipment/shelter floor is 12F (4.0 m), 24F (4.5 m), 37F (4.5 m), 49F
(4.5 m) and F55 (4.0 m).
There are three design options:
A: two steel outriggers on the 24 and 37 floors;
B: one reinforced concrete outrigger on the 24 floors;
C: three deep beams on the 12, 24 and 37 floors.
Scheme A: SRC frame + reinforced concrete core tube + two steel outrig-
gers + reinforced concrete floor (floor height 600 mm), See Fig. 3.
500 X. Zhao et al.
Scheme B: SRC frame + reinforced concrete core tube + one reinforced con-
crete outrigger + reinforced concrete floor (floor height 600 mm), See Fig. 4.
Scheme C: SRC frame + reinforced concrete core tube + three deep
beams + reinforced concrete floor (floor height 650 mm), See Fig. 5.
Referring to the data obtained from the comparison of schemes A, B and C, the
following Table 1 is given:
It can be seen that scheme B, that is, the use of reinforced concrete outrigger on
the floor height control role is obvious, can meet the owner’s demand for floor
space.
We can see that the structural cost and construction period of scheme C are the
best, but the control of floor height of scheme C mentioned in Table 1 is not as good
as that of scheme A and B. For super high-rise residential buildings, too large floor
height is difficult to satisfy the owners. Therefore, considering various factors,
scheme B of a reinforced concrete outrigger is the best one.
4 Conclusions
Starting from the overall stability of super high-rise residential buildings, this paper
focuses on an important index to control the overall stability: rigidity-weight ratio,
and puts forward the modification of rigidity-weight ratio. Then, a reinforced
concrete outrigger is proposed, and the working principle of reinforced concrete
outrigger and its role in adjusting rigidity-weight ratio are introduced. We can draw
the following conclusions from this paper:
(1) Like steel outrigger, reinforced concrete outrigger can adjust and control the
rigidity-weight ratio of super high-rise buildings, so as to meet the requirements
of overall stability of buildings.
(2) The effect of adjusting rigidity-weight ratio of reinforced concrete outrigger is
better than that of steel outrigger.
(3) The reinforced concrete outrigger also has the advantages that the steel
outrigger does not have: low cost, short construction period and no need for
later maintenance.
References
1. Hi SC, Goman H, Leonard J, Neville M (2017) Outrigger design for high-rise buildings.
CTBUH technical guide, pp 51–55
2. Qin L, Zhao X (2016) Sensitivity analysis based optimal seismic design of tall buildings under
story drift constraint. In: Proceedings of IABSE conference on bridges and structures
sustainability: seeking intelligent solutions, Guangzhou, China, September 2016, pp 873–880
3. Richard T, Dennis P, Ling-en H (2001) The tallest concrete building in Shanghai, China Plaza
66. CTBUH 2001 6th world congress, Melbourne, pp 720–725
4. Wang B, Chen YY, Zhao XZ (2014) A simplified model on strength and stiffness of outrigger
truss in super high-rise structure. J Tongji Univ (Nat Sci Ed) 2014:358–364
5. Wilson EL, Habibullab A (1987) Static and dynamic analysis of multi-story buildings,
including p-delta effects. Earthq Spectra 3(2):289–298
Study on Practical Application
of Damping Control Ceiling
Abstract In Japan, including the Great East Japan Earthquake, the fall of ceiling
caused by earthquake has repeatedly occurred every time. In the year of 2013,
“ceiling notice” was enforced. As a countermeasure, the technology of setting up
diagonal members and improving the stiffness and bearing strength of seismic
ceiling has become the mainstream. However, the ceiling notice is supposed to be a
medium earthquake level, and even larger inputs can be considered at the large
earthquake encountered in the future. As a result, it is necessary to increase the
proof stress of the components in order to respond to earthquakes and resonance
with buildings with earthquake-resistant ceilings.
Therefore, in this research, we aim to add damping to suspended ceilings and to
prevent damage and fall of suspended ceilings from large earthquakes. The
damping control ceiling system we proposed allows a certain amount of defor-
mation not only during the mid-earthquake targeted by the current ceiling notifi-
cation but also during severe input during a large earthquake, and can suppress the
acceleration response of the ceiling surface. In addition, considering the application
to an actual building, we will conduct vibration experiments using the placement
method, damper installation angle, and vibrating direction as parameters to confirm
the usefulness of the damping ceiling system.
In this experiment, it was confirmed that the acceleration response was reduced in
the entire region including the resonance region by installing the damping control
ceiling system. It was confirmed that the difference in additional damping was
confirmed by the damper installation angle, and that the difference in the
arrangement method and vibrating direction had a small effect on the damping
control ceiling system.
As a result, it was confirmed that the response of the ceiling surface can be
reduced by the damping control ceiling system even under various conditions.
Keywords Suspended ceiling Earthquake resistant ceiling Damping control
ceiling Vibration tests Oil damper
1 Introduction
In Japan, ceiling collapse in earthquake often give rise to casualties, the Great East
Japan Earthquake, for example. The ceiling was regarded as a finishing to arrange
architectural spaces, but also it has been re-recognized as a serious hazard for
residents due to collapsing. In 2013, “A matter of determining a structural method
that is safe on the structural tolerance of a specific ceiling (hereinafter referred to as
“ceiling notice”)” was enforced, and a specific ceiling, which is in a certain con-
dition, was is obliged to have earthquake-resistance. After this enforcement,
earthquake-resistant ceiling have been frequently researched, and the way of
proofing ceilings from earthquake is mainly with diagonal materials and enhanced
rigidity and yield strength.
In order to respond such excessive input during earthquake than assumed in
“ceiling notice”, it is necessary to have further stiffness on the diagonal material and
the ceiling substrate, and as the while cost is increasing. In that case, flexibility of
designing the architectural space is also limited.
In addition, the acceleration response of the ceiling surface becomes excessive,
and the risk of falling down of the ceiling material and equipment increases.
Based on these facts, the authors propose a damping control ceiling system that
adds damping to the ceiling. If we only to suppress deformation of the ceiling, the
strengthened earthquake resistant ceiling is superior, but even if in the case of tough
input, if a certain deformation (for example, about 6 to 10 cm of general ceiling
clearance) can be accepted new system makes possible to suppress the acceleration
response more than previous one.
Also, it is expected to reduce the excessive response at the resonance point of the
suspended ceiling and the building.
Considering the applicating new system to general ceiling, the cost of ceiling and
workability is also an important viewpoint. Therefore, the authors investigate the
possibility of a damping addition system which can be realized simply and at low
cost by combining more versatile techniques.
Study on Practical Application … 505
The proposed damping control ceiling system can add moderate damping and also
takes into existing ceilings, aims for high general versatility that reduces costs and
eliminates special joints as much as possible. Adopted as a device that gives
damping is a stay damper that is also used for backdoors of automobiles and
mass-produced and can reduce costs (Fig. 1). The stay damper is a damper that
exerts a damping force only in the tensile direction and has no resistance in the
compression direction. Also, it is assumed that the members around the damper and
the interlocking are not special, and the bracing of the earthquake resistant ceiling is
simply replaced with an oil damper. Therefore, by setting the maximum damping
force of the damper is equal to that of the current earthquake ceiling bracing and set
them in a distributed arrangement with our utilized knowledge of joints etc.
accumulated by seismic ceiling technology. Furthermore, consideration should be
given to the ease of installation in general ceiling construction.
The basic type of the proposed damping control ceiling system is shown in Fig. 2.
The basic unit of the damping control ceiling system consists of a stay damper and a
bundle material for balancing with the damping force on the tension side of the stay
damper. Since the damping force is one side effect on the tensile side, it is used as a
pair in principle, but there is no risk of buckling of the damper, the damper part has
a simple attachment for adjusting the length and it is easy to construct at work site.
The concept and outline of the damping ceiling system with the possibility to
cope with harsh inputs are shown up to here.
POST
Adjustment
Attachment
Stay Damper
2 Experiment Outline
Vibration tests were carried out by accelerating the oscillating table with a gate-type
frame and a hydraulic actuator for vibrating on one side, and confirming the
responsiveness of the ceiling suspended from the oscillating table. By providing a
linear guide at the attachment part of the portal frame and the oscillating table, it
moves smoothly in the excitation direction and movement in the out-of-plane
direction is restrained. The measurement items are the displacement of the hydraulic
actuator (DISP 1), the acceleration of the vibration table (ACC 1), the displacement
of the ceiling surface (DISP 2), the acceleration of the ceiling surface (ACC 2), and
the outline of the vibration system is shown in Fig. 3.
2.2 Specimens
The ceiling area was 6.3 m2, 3.0 m 2.1 m, and the constitution of the ceiling was
aseismic ceiling which was confirmed the allowable tolerance of 4,200 N in the
horizontal direction, according to the evaluation method described in the technical
reference 2 on the technical standard on the falling off of the ceiling in the building
based on the composition of the construction method, vibration was performed
using eleven kinds of specimens. Table 1 shows the constitution of these speci-
mens. Figure 4 shows the difference of specimens.
The weight of the ceiling was multiplied by plaster plates so that the weight of
the ceiling was about 420 kg equivalent to 25 m2 from the unit area mass (16.8 kg/
m2) at the unit test of the earthquake resistant ceiling construction method.
The damping control ceiling system has a pair of oil damper placed diagonally
and a length adjustment attachment to cope with the difference in ceiling hanging
length and the damping force of the tension side damper when the damper acts on
the compression side Each bundle material is integrated.
The oil damper is a modification of the gas spring for automobiles and the
damping force has damping performance of damping coefficient C = 7.85 N/(cm/
sec)2. The damper is a type that generates damping force only on the tension side.
Table 2 shows specifications the oil damper.
Cradling Receiver
Contiguity Separate ( 45 ) Cradling
Arrangement Method
Vibration Vibration
Direction Direction
stories). These response waves are a middle-layer response wave and super
highrise-layer response wave, respectively. These response waves were standard-
ized to 120 mm for the effective stroke of the vibration system, and vibration was
performed. Figure 5 shows the waveform of the response waves, and Fig. 6 shows
the displacement response spectrum and the acceleration response spectrum.
Time[s]
middle-layer response wave
ACC[gal] Maximum acceleration 96gal
Time[s]
super highrise-layer response wave
Displacement Acceleration
response spectrum[mm] response spectrum[gal]
Period[s] Period[s]
middle-layer response wave
Displacement Acceleration
response spectrum[mm] response spectrum[gal]
Period[s] Period[s]
super highrise-layer response wave
Fig. 6 Response spectrum
3 Results of Experiment
The natural period and damping constant of each specimen were calculated from
the transfer function of the acceleration of the ceiling (ACC①) to the acceleration
of the shaking table (ACC②) obtained by white noise vibration. The natural period
was calculated by the maximum point of the transfer function, and the damping
constant was calculated by the √1/2 method. Table 4 shows a list of natural periods
and damping rations.
Study on Practical Application … 511
Table 5 shows the maximum response acceleration and maximum relative dis-
placement of the ceiling surface for each test condition obtained by sinusoidal
vibration.The measurement results were subjected to LPF processing (20 Hz) only
for response acceleration in order to eliminate noise.
Regardless of the direction of vibration, the acceleration response of the
damping control ceiling was reduced compared with the earthquake-resistant ceil-
ing under all vibration conditions, and a sufficient reduction was observed even near
the natural period of the damping control ceiling. In addition, the maximum
response acceleration of the ceiling surface reached about 2.5G in the seismic
ceiling when the 7 Hz 10 mm cradling receiver vibration was applied, and the brace
joint was damaged. The response acceleration of the ceiling surface was also
suppressed to about 1.1G.
As for the installation angle, it was confirmed that the acceleration response was
reduced and the response was smaller as the installation angle was smaller under the
vibration condition near the natural period of the damping control ceiling. On the
other hand, it was confirmed that the reduction in response is proportional to the
size of the installation angle as the vibration condition is further away from the
natural period of the damping control ceiling.
1200 1200
45_DCD_Y_C 45_DCD_X_S
1000 (cradling) 1000 (separate)
800 800
600 600
400 400
Figure 7 shows the vibration direction and the maximum response acceleration
of the installation method arranged on the horizontal and vertical axes. As a result,
it was confirmed that the influence on the acceleration response due to the differ-
ence in excitation direction and installation method was not significant.
Table 6 shows the maximum response acceleration and maximum relative dis-
placement of each test piece during response wave excitation, and Fig. 8 shows the
ceiling response acceleration waveforms of 45_DCD_X_C (damped control ceil-
ing) and 45_DCB_X (seismic ceiling). The measurement result was subjected to
20 Hz LPF processing to remove noise.
In both response wave excitations, it was confirmed that the acceleration response
of the vibration-damping ceiling was reduced compared to the earthquake-resistant
ceiling.
With regard to the maximum relative displacement between the vibration surface
and the ceiling surface, all the test specimens of the damping control ceiling sat-
isfied the deformation of 6-10 cm under the vibration conditions of this experiment.
4 Conclusions
For the damping control ceiling system proposed in this study, we confirmed the
additional damping effect of the installation of a pair of damping control ceiling
systems against a test specimen assuming a damping ceiling area of 25 m2. The
damper installation angle was 35° when the additional damping was increased to
about 75%, the ideal installation case was about 40% at 45°, and the installation
angle was 60° to reduce the additional damping effect to about 17%. It was con-
firmed that the acceleration response was reduced in all regions including the
resonance region by this effect.
In addition, it was confirmed that the influence by the difference in the
arrangement method of the damping control ceiling unit was not significant.
Similarly, it was confirmed that there was little influence due to the difference in the
vibration direction of the damping control ceiling.
Through this experiment, we confirmed that the acceleration response of the
ceiling surface can be reduced even in various arrangement conditions such as the
assumed arrangement method of the damping control ceiling system and the dif-
ference in the damper angle when applied to an actual building.
Reference
S. Keita (&)
Department of Architecture, Graduate School of Engineering, Tokyo University of Science,
Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: 4119534@ed.tus.ac.jp
T. Osamu
Department of Architecture, Faculty of Engineering, Doctor Engineering,
Tokyo University of Science, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: o.taka@rs.tus.ac.jp
T. Mikiya O. Junji
DAISUN Company Limited, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: taomoto@daisun-web.com
O. Junji
e-mail: j-okimoto@daisun-web.com
M. Jun N. Toshihiko
TEIJIN LIMITED, Smart & Safety Business Development Project,
Material New Business Division, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: ju.matsuo@teijin.co.jp
N. Toshihiko
e-mail: t.nishikawa@teijin.co.jp
both tapes attached were prepared. Test specimens were laid down sideways, the
center part was pushed with an Amsler Testing Machine, and a bending test was
carried out until the center part was deformed to 40 mm. Specimens are required to
have seismic performance that can withstand a horizontal load of (self-weight) x
(1G).
As a result, it was found that all reinforced specimens had seismic performance
exceeding that required. Moreover, the effect of these reinforcements was con-
firmed from several points in this experiment.
Keywords Masonry Concrete brock Polyurea resin Aramid fiber tape Brick
1 Introduction
For a long time, it has been customary to build a masonry wall by concrete blocks
around the house in Japan. These concrete block walls were easy to construct and
widely used as a sturdy fence. However, in recent years, there have been numerous
cases of large earthquakes occurring frequently in Japan, many concrete block walls
collapsed. As a result, it caused people became the underlay of the walls or hindered
rescue of disasters. Concrete block walls were designed according to the standard
established in Japan, but since the earthquake which has occurred in Japan recently
exceeds the power of the earthquake assumed by the standard at that time, it is not
able to withstand a big earthquake, and it collapses. Even today, it is a very
dangerous situation that concrete walls which were designed with the old standard
without necessary reinforcing bars or necessary counterfort are scattered in Japan.
Also, in the Netherlands, earthquakes occur frequently due to the influence of
gas sampling in recent years. There are many masonry using bricks, but such a
masonry is very vulnerable to earthquakes. In recent years, major earthquakes have
occurred not only in the Netherlands, but also around the world. Masonry buildings
around the world are at risk of earthquakes.
Therefore, in this research, we investigate how much resistance to seismic force
is improved and practical by various reinforcement for such existing dangerous
masonry walls. The seismic force is a force horizontal against the wall, and the
seismic force applied to book walls are assumed generally (the wall’s dead
weight) (gravity acceleration) (1.0). Therefore, specimen walls must have
sufficient strength against this force and do not collapse.
Research on Prevention of Collapse of Existing Dangerous Masonry Walls ... 517
Fig. 3 Overview
2 Test Outline
The specimen is a square (straight) joint block wall of 2 columns and 6 rows of
blocks of about 800 mm and 1,200 mm in length shown in the following design
drawing, with 2 reinforcing rods installed, 5 bodies without arrangement, a total of
7 bodies are tested. The concrete blocks and reinforcing bars used are suitable for
the current Japanese building standards and have chosen widely used in general.
Mortar was used as the adhesive for the joint and the joint thickness was 10 mm
(Fig. 1).
The brick wall specimen was made of basic bricks commonly used in Japan. This
brick wall is made up of 17 layers of bricks. Mortar was used as the adhesive for the
joint and the joint thickness was 10 mm (Fig. 1).
Research on Prevention of Collapse of Existing Dangerous Masonry Walls ... 519
The aramid tape used this time has a blue one with a width of 15 mm (Fig. 7) and a
black one with a width of 45 mm (Fig. 8). The tensile (break) strength of this tape
is 25 kN. These tapes reinforce specimens by attaching it to the specimen by hitting
it with screws (Fig. 9).
There are 11 specimens in total including 7 concrete block walls and 4 brick walls
(Fig. 10). Reinforcing rods, polyurea and aramid tape was used to reinforce these
masonry walls (Table 1).
Specimen list
Polyurea 5mm Aramid fiber tape
Specimen name Rods (Thickness) Thin tape Thick tape
CB-1
CB-2
CB-3
Concrete
CB-4
block wall
CB-5
CB-6
CB-7
R-1
R-2
Brick wall
R-3
R-4
522 S. Keita et al.
CB-1 is a specimen wall reinforced with steel bars and made according to Japanese
standards. CB-1 is used as a reference for comparison with each reinforced spec-
imen. (CB-2 * CB-7).
The polyurea that reinforces the concrete block wall was green, but the polyurea
that reinforces the brick wall is gray, that is, different type of polyurea is used to
reinforce brick wall. As a result of bending test with each polyurea applied to
Styrofoam (Fig. 13), there was almost no difference in strength and rigidity
(Fig. 11). R-3 is a specimen attached with crossed tapes, and verifies the difference
between this specimen and the specimen with the tape attached vertically (R-2)
(Fig. 12).
4 Test Result
specimens have a higher strength. This shows that brick walls are more likely to
benefit from these reinforcements (Table 2).
5 Conclusion
From the test results, it was confirmed that all reinforcing methods can give strength
exceeding the required strength. From here, we will focus on the benefits of each
reinforcement method and consider the experimental results.
The concrete block wall specimen reinforced with polyurea (CB-2) significantly
exceeded the required strength, and showed higher strength than the current Japanese
standard specimen wall (CB-1). When the specimens CB-1 and CB-5 are compared,
an increase in strength of about 12 kN by polyurea reinforcement can be confirmed. In
addition, when the specimens CB-2 and CB-6 (CB-7) were compared, an increase in
the strength of 3 to 4 kN was confirmed, and it was found that a cumulative rein-
forcement effect can be expected by reinforcing combined with the tape.
The maximum stress of the specimen R-1 is about 30 kN, which is considerably
larger than the concrete block wall specimens. This indicates that the polyurea
reinforcement has good compatibility with brick walls and can be expected to have
better reinforcement effect. We have concluded this is due to the small size of brick
wall’s brickwork unit.
526 S. Keita et al.
It was found that a proof strength slightly higher than the required strength can be
obtained by the tape reinforcement. However, as described above, the combined use
of polyurea and tape provides a cumulative reinforcement effect, and the specimens
R-2 and R-3 show a dramatic increase in strength.
The maximum load does not differ between specimens R-2 and R-3, but the
slope of R-3’s graph in the stiffness range is smaller. From this, it was found that the
initial stiffness was lowered when the tape was applied to the specimen by crossing.
We have identified that this may be due to the fact that it is difficult to apply initial
tension to the tape by attaching the tape crossed to the specimen.
We can confirm that the brick itself is damaged as can be seen from Fig. 20.
From this, we conclude that it is difficult to prevent the collapse of the wall due to
damage or plastic deformation of masonry walls such as concrete block walls and
brick walls with tape alone.
We conclude that any of these reinforcement methods can provide higher strength
than necessary, and that these reinforcement methods are very effective as rein-
forcement to prevent masonry collapse. Although only the case in which bending is
applied to the central part of the specimen wall is examined in this experiment, in
fact, the base part of the wall body is often bent. Therefore, it is necessary to
examine the seismic performance of the base of the wall and search for rein-
forcement plans.
Reference
1 Introduction
For the purpose of confirming the detailed structural performance of the semi-rigid
column base with tapered part, a force experiment was carried out under constant
axial force with taper angle and concrete strength as parameters.
Table 1 shows the specimen list, Fig. 1 is a conceptual diagram for setting speci-
men and its parameters, and Fig. 2 shows a configuration diagram. The specimen
was designed with a combination of axial force ratio (0.25, 0.45, 0.65) with taper
angle (3/9, 2/9, 1/9) and concrete strength (Fc60-100, Fc30-60) as parameters.
There were a total of 5 specimens. In previous experiments, the specimen
Research on the Development of the Semi-rigid Column Base ... 531
No. 26 showed bending fracture and stable toughness, The specimen No. 23 decline
of abrupt strength due to burst fracture. Table 2 shows the loading history. The
loading is performed by controlling the member angle, and the loading is repeated
gradually under a constant axial force. For the specimen No. 29 increases the
constant axial force were increased for each target member angle.
reduced part
cross section concrete strength reinforcement
specimen
B D Lt Lh Fc other
2
main shear
mm mm mm mm N/mm
No. 28 s0.7, ta2/9, Fc60-100
256.5 12-D19 2-D6@38
No. 29 266 266 38 100 s0.7, ta2/9, Fc60-100
pt=1.89% pw=0.63%
No. 30 513 SD490 SHD685 s0.7, ta1/9, Fc60-100
No. 31 202.5 16-D19 4-D6@45 s0.7, ta3/9, Fc30-60
315 315 45 60
No. 32 303.8 pt=1.68% pw=0.89% s0.7, ta2/9, Fc30-60
Lg : Length from the column base to the applied point s : squeezing ratio The inseide of ( ) represents
Lt : Taper length ta : taper angle the section from tapered part start
Lh : Length from the column base to the taper part starting point point to 380mm (1D)
Fc : Based on the strength on the test piece on the 28th day after placing the concrete
burst fracture is column general part : Fc60 burst fracture is column general part : Fc30
likely to occur column reduced part : Fc100 likely to occur column reduced part : Fc60
squeezing ratio : 0.7 squeezing ratio : 0.7
taper angle taper angle
bending fracture burst fracture
concrete : Fc60
main : 12-D19 (SD490)
shear : 2-D6@38 (SHD685)
concrete : Fc60
main : 12-D19 (SD490)
outer shear : 4-D6@38 (SHD685)
inner shear : 2-D6@38 (SHD685)
concrete : Fc100
vertical shear : 12-D6 (SD295)
lateral shear :
[-D6double@38 (SD295)
concrete : Fc100
main : 12-D19 (SD490)
shear : 2-D6@38 (SHD685)
Figure 3 shows the relationship between shear force (Q) and member angle (R) of
each specimen. The specimen No. 31 showed a stable up to the final cycle, but with
all the specimens, the strength decreased rapidly with the occurrence of burst
fracture at the cross-section switching part. In addition, it was confirmed that the
yield shear reinforcements and the tensile fracture occurred at the reduced part. The
specimens No. 30 and 32 ended the force application after losing ability to hold the
axial force.
Research on the Development of the Semi-rigid Column Base ... 533
<No.28> <No.29>
η=0.45, s=0.7, η=0.65, s=0.7,
ta=2/9, Fc60-100 ta=2/9, Fc60-100
<No.30> <No.31>
η=0.65, s=0.7, η=0.25, s=0.7,
ta=1/9, Fc60-100 ta=3/9, Fc30-60
bending crack
shear crack
lengthwise crack
lengthwise crack
compression yield
compression yield
corner burst crack
tensile yield
shear yield
corner burst crack
<No.32>
η=0.65, s=0.7,
ta=2/9, Fc30-60
bending crack
lengthwise crack
compression yield
corner burst crack
shear yield
Figure 4 shows a comparison of the Q-R relationships of the specimens (No. 23,
No. 29, No. 30) with different taper angles under high axial force. After the
decrease in yield strength due to burst fracture at the corners, the fracture occurred
at the taper angle 1/9 without recovery of the yield strength. Therefore, destruction
properties in specimens with taper angle 1/9 were differ from angle of 3/9 and 2/9.
Figure 5 shows a comparison of strain distribution in each specimen; the
compression side of burst direction the shear reinforcement. At the taper angle 3/9,
the strain at the cross-section switching part increases, and at the taper angle 1/9, the
strain at the tapered part after the decline of yield strength. The taper angle 2/9 has
both properties observed in other taper angles, but the value of strain was small so
that, distribution of strain is well balanced.
534 H. Yoshida et al.
300
<No.23, No.29, No.30> Q (kN)
η=0.65, s=0.7, Fc60-100
R (rad)
0
-0.015 -0.01 -0.005 0 0.005 0.01 0.015
-150
-300
Fig. 4 Comparison of the Q-R relationships (taper angle: 1/9, 2/9, 3/9)
Fig. 5 Comparison of strain distribution in the compression side of burst direction of the shear
reinforcement (taper angle: 1/9, 2/9, 3/9)
It is probable that the shear reinforcement yielding and tensile fracture in the
reduced part occurred because the amount of shear reinforcement was designed
only with respect to the shear strength at the time of specimen design. Therefore,
the amount of shear reinforcement required for securing the deformation perfor-
mance was examined using reference. Table 3 shows the calculated values of shear
reinforcement composition and critical member angle during this experiment and
when the maximum amount of shear reinforcement is arranged. From this, it is
understood that sufficient deformation performance cannot be ensured during this
experiment.
Research on the Development of the Semi-rigid Column Base ... 535
Table 3 The calculated values of shear reinforcement composition and critical member angle
Figure 6 shows the initial Q-R relationship at each axial force ratio for each of the
positive and negative applied forces of the specimen No. 29, and Table 4 shows a
list of calculation results for the initial rigidity at each axial force ratio. It was found
that there was no correlation between the axial force ratio and the initial rigidity.
Also, the fluctuation range was small.
536 H. Yoshida et al.
100
-100
50 η=0.666
η=0.458 -150 η=0.458
η=0.354 η=0.354
η=0.302 R (rad)
η=0.302 0
Q (kN)
-200 0 0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002 0.0025 0.003
Table 4 The calculation results of initial rigidity at each axial force ratio
axial force ratio initial rigidity (×103)kN/rad maximum error rate percentange of theoretical value
η positive force negative force positive force negative force positive force negative force
0.302 57.60 53.67 74% 69%
0.354 56.33 54.34 72% 70%
14% 5%
0.458 58.23 51.57 74% 66%
0.666 64.42 - 82% -
from origin to 1/800
Figure 7 shows the correspondence between the experimental value and the cal-
culated value of the ratio of cover concrete expected in the core concrete section.
This figure proves that the higher axial force has safer evaluation under the same
condition. Under the same conditions, the higher the axial force, the safer the
evaluation. When the cover concrete is expected to be 40%, the Fc60-100 specimen
has 25% even with a high axial force, and it is considered that it can be evaluated
relatively appropriately. However, in order to evaluate more appropriately, it is
considered that correction by concrete strength and axial force ratio is necessary.
Research on the Development of the Semi-rigid Column Base ... 537
(Mu experimental value) / (Mu calculated value) (Mu experimental value) / (Mu calculated value)
1.75 1.75
cover 0% cover 20% cover 0% cover 20%
cover 40% cover 60% cover 40% cover 60%
1.50 1.50
cover 80% cover 100% cover 80% cover 100%
1.25 1.25
1.00 1.00
4 Conclusions
[1] Different characteristics in fracture properties and strain distribution were found
depending on the taper angle under high axial force.
[2] It was shown that there is a possibility of preventing damage due to lack of
reinforcements by designing the amount of shear reinforcements deformation
performance.
[3] It was confirmed that there were no needs to design the initial rigidity fluctuation
due to the axial force.
[4] It was confirmed that ratio of cover concrete expected in the core concrete cross
section when calculating the ultimate bending strength was 40% and could be
generally evaluated.
In the future, the design formula for the strength of semi-rigid columns will be
studied. In addition, we will proceed with the study of the column base shape that
can simplify the shear reinforcement arrangement and improve the strength. Also,
we will study application of this column in the building to investigate designing
process.
References
Keywords Super tall buildings High-intensity seismic areas Story drift ratio
Rigid outriggers Sensitivity vector algorithm
1 Introduction
Super tall buildings have high-flexibility characteristics, and the natural vibration
period of the structure is generally long, which is more sensitive to earthquakes. In
practical engineering, buildings with larger periods will have larger deformation
problems and comfort problems under earthquake action. The story drift ratio is an
important index to reflect the deformation and comfort of buildings. Limiting its
maximum value is a common method to reduce seismic vibration. The number and
the position of the outrigger set have a significant influence on the structural
rigidity. Generally, the more the outrigger truss is placed, the smaller the period of
the structure and the greater the rigidity. However, as the number of outriggers
increases, the natural period of the structure and the amount of steel used increase.
Therefore, one of the key issues in the design of super-tall buildings is to determine
the minimum number of outriggers and the optimal position of the outrigger truss
settings that meet the design criteria. In addition, it is necessary to study the
influence of the number of different outriggers and position on the structural
performance.
Outrigger systems were widely adopted in modern tall buildings. Since the first
example of the system as configured in steel, the 42-story U.S. Bank Center in
Milwaukee, this tall building outrigger system has got a widespread popularity. It
can be seen as a response to fundamental disadvantages of the perimeter and
bundled tube frames developed in the 1960s and 1970s in the United States [1]. Due
to the super height and flexible structure, the super tall buildings may get large
deformation from the overturning moments and the lateral displacements at the
upper floors. A tall building structure which incorporates an outrigger system can
experience a reduction in core overturning moment up to 40% compared to a free
cantilever, as well as a significant reduction in drift depending on the rigidities of
the core and the outrigger system [3]. Smith and Nwaka analyzed the internal force
and displacement of the enhanced story structure, and gave simplified formulas for
restraint moment of the enhanced story, reduction of top displacement and optimal
position of the reinforced story [4]. Coull and Lau analyzed the top displacement
and the base moment of the structure with multiple reinforcement stories under the
action of horizontal concentrated load at the top and horizontal load with triangular
distribution, and gave the general formula for determining the optimal position of
the reinforcement stories by using linear regression method [2]. Zhao and Liu
proposed sensitivity vector method for determining optimum outrigger Number and
position of super high-rise structures with outriggers [5].
In this paper, by analyzing the variation of the maximum story drift ratio and the
natural vibration period of the structure when the single outrigger is placed, the
influence of the setting of the outrigger truss on the structural stiffness character-
istics is explained. On this basis, the number and position of the outrigger truss can
be determined quickly by using the independence of the action of the outrigger truss
in different positions and the vector product algorithm.
Optimal Placement of Rigid Outriggers ... 541
The calculation of the story drift ratio of a building under earthquake is mainly
based on the modal story drift ratio of each mode bj , bj multiplied by the modal
amplitude kj , and the component of mode j of the story drift ratio can be obtained.
dj ¼ bj kj ð1Þ
aj c j
kj ¼ ð2Þ
x2j
In the formula: kj is the modal amplitude of the mode j; aj the acceleration of the
mode j, which is the period of the first mode multiplied by the acceleration of
gravity in the seismic response spectrum; cj is the modal participation factor of the
mode j; and xj is the circular frequency of the mode j.
For each order modal component of the story drift ratio, the SRSS mode com-
bination method is used to obtain the story drift ratio, that is:
vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
u N
uX 2
d¼t dj ð3Þ
j¼1
It should be noted that the structural response is different from the first-order
mode control under wind load. The structural response analysis under seismic
action should consider the higher-order mode and adopt the mode-superposition
response spectrum method.
The basic principle of the sensitivity vector method is to calculate the relative
independence of the influence of different outrigger positions on the structure when
the distance between the outriggers is large. The calculation process can be as
follows: use S0 to indicate the structure without the outrigger truss status.
The vector d0 represents a vector composed of the story drift ratio of the layers
corresponding to the structural state S0 , Si represents the structural state of the
outrigger truss only in the region i, and the vector di represents the story drift ratio
vector of the corresponding structural state Si . If the number of rigid outriggers is
more than one, the position of the set outrigger can be written in the lower right
corner. For example, indicates structural state of the outrigger truss in zone i and
542 X. Zhao et al.
zone j. d2;8 denotes the story drift ratio vector corresponding to the structural state
S2;8 . Define the dimensionless story drift ratio sensitivity ri . vector as:
Here ./represents the division operation of the vector. Actually, ri expressed the
influence of the setting of the outrigger truss on story drift ratio of the structure in
Zone i, reflecting the correlation between the setting of the outrigger truss and the
story drift ratio of the structure. The outrigger truss is generally combined with the
building partition, and the interval is about 10 layers. It can be considered that the
impact of the outrigger truss of each area on the overall structural rigidity is
independent of each other, and the following relationship can be obtained:
ri;j;k ¼ fri g frj g frk g ð5Þ
Finally, the optimal setting scheme of the outriggers under different number of
outriggers is compared, and the optimal setting scheme of the outriggers with the
fewest number of outriggers is obtained.
3 Case Study
7.300
7.172
7.200
7.136
7.089 7.084
1st mode period/s
7.100
6.941
7.000
6.844
6.900
6.800
6.700
6.576
6.600
6.500
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Outrigger number
1/476
1/488
Story Drift
1/500
1/513
1/526
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Outtrigger Location
5. In the super high-rise mixed structure, the maximum story drift ratio generally
appears in the upper part of the structure. It is obviously a more effective scheme to
set the upper outrigger truss first, and the lower outrigger setting outrigger has a
poor control effect on the maximum story drift ratio. It even makes the story drift
ratio increase.
According to the story drift ratio of different outrigger positions, the optimal
outrigger position calculated by the sensitivity vector method is shown in Table 2.
Figure 4 shows a more intuitive representation of the story drift ratio plot for the
optimal placement of the different number of outriggers systems.
In this project, the outrigger is arranged in the 4,5 area to optimize the story drift
ratio, and the arrangement in the 1,2 area increases maximum story drift ratio.
The final solution selects the rigid outrigger arrangement position as the area 4,
5, a total of 2 outriggers. It can also be seen from the model analysis results that the
optimal position of the rigid outrigger arrangement is about 2/3 of the height of the
structure, and the excessive number of outriggers is arranged to increase the overall
stiffness of the structure. But for the maximum story drift ratio, overall indicator
optimization is not necessarily effective.
Based on the data in Table 1, Table 2, it can be found that the sensitivity of
position of the rigid outrigger to the story drift ratio is 5, 4, 3, 6, 2, 1, and the 4, 5
areas is the most effective. And its combination effect is the best. However, if only
three outriggers are arranged, the 456 combination is better than 345 combinations,
which shows that the optimal position of the three outriggers is not determined by
the three most sensitive positions. If only two outriggers are arranged, 46 combi-
nations is better than 56 combinations also show that the optimal combination of
story drift ratio is not necessarily the most sensitive combination of several
outrigger regions.
From the above analysis, the sensitivity vector method is suitable for the
structure of the high-intensity seismic zone in the case where the number of the
outriggers is relatively small. However, as the number of outrigger trusses
increases, the rigidity of the structure becomes larger and larger, and the seismic
force of the structure is also increased. Therefore, from this point of view, the
number of outriggers is not as good as possible.
5 Conclusions
References
Abstract Structural response and response sensitivity play an important role in the
fields of model updating, damage identification and dynamic optimization.
Calculation of response and response sensitivity of a large and complex structure
usually takes up considerable computational time. This paper proposes a sub-
structuring method to calculate the structural response and response sensitivity,
where the vibration equation is represented by a few master eigenvectors of inde-
pendent substructures and compensated by a residue. The response sensitivity with
respect to a parameter is calculated from the eigenvector derivatives of its related
substructure solely whereas the derivatives of other substructures are zeros. The size
of the simplified vibration equation is equal to that of the master eigenvectors
retained, which is much smaller than the original vibration equation. The proposed
method is applied to a practical bridge structure. The case study verifies that the
proposed method is highly efficient and accurate to calculate the structural response
and response sensitivity.
J. J. Li S. Weng (&)
School of Civil Engineering and Mechanics, Huazhong University of Science and
Technology, Wuhan 430074, Hubei, People’s Republic of China
e-mail: wengshun@hust.edu.cn
J. J. Li
e-mail: jiajingli@hust.edu.cn
G. J. Yang Y. Y. Yan
Department of Science and Technology, China Railway Eryuan Engineering Group Co. Ltd,
Chengdu 610031, Sichuan, China
e-mail: 445380616@qq.com
Y. Y. Yan
e-mail: 513874195@qq.com
1 Introduction
Structural response and response sensitivity are widely used in the vibration-based
model updating, optimization design and damage identification. In the
sensitivity-based model updating and optimization [9, 10]. The objective function is
formed by a weighted sum of difference between the measured and calculated
structural response. The design parameters are modified iteratively to minimize the
objective function. Response sensitivity, which is the first derivative of the struc-
tural response with respect to design parameters, indicates the searching direction in
the process of optimization [1].
There are a wide range of methods dedicated to calculate the structural response
and response sensitivity. For example, Newmark integration [3], state space method
[2], condensation method [4], etc. However, methods mentioned above, which are
classified into global methods, need tremendous computer memory and computa-
tional time to calculate structural response and response sensitivity of a large-scale
structure with thousands of degrees of freedom (DOFs) and a large number of
design parameters.
The substructuring method is superior to the global method for large-scale
structures and receives great attention in recent decades [5]. The basic procedure of
the substructuring method begins with dividing the global structure into several
independent substructures of smaller size. After analyzed separately, these sub-
structures are assembled based on compatibility and equilibrium conditions to
obtain the designated solution of the global structure. The substructuring method is
more advantageous than the global method in several aspects. Firstly, substructures
have smaller size and fewer design parameters compared with that of the global
structure. Secondly, to recognize the local behavior, the substructuring method
allows the analysis of a few related substructures solely instead of re-analyzing the
global system as a whole. For example, in the process of model updating, only
substructures which contain the design parameters need to be re-analyzed while
other substructures remain untouched. Thirdly, the substructuring method can be
more efficient when combined with model reduction technique [6, 7].
This paper proposes a substructuring method to calculate structural response and
response sensitivity of a structure. The global structure is divided into several
independent substructures with smaller size. The vibration equation of the global
structure is expressed by the eigenvectors of independent substructures. The size of
global vibration equation is reduced by retaining the master (lower) eigenvectors of
substructures, whereas the contribution of slave (higher) counterparts are com-
pensated by a residue. The dynamic response of the global structure are calculated
from the reduced vibration equation efficiently. The response sensitivity with
respect to a design parameter of the global structure are calculated by directly
differentiating the reduced vibration equation, in which the derivatives of one
substructure that contains the designed element are computed while the derivatives
of other substructures are zeros. Therefore, the proposed substructuring method is
time-saving because it reduces the size of the dynamic vibration equation and
Calculation of Structural Response and Response Sensitivity … 549
The substructuring method requires the global structure divided into NS indepen-
dent substructures. The jth (j = 1, 2, …, NS) substructure of nj DOFs has the
stiffness matrix Kð jÞ and mass matrix Mð jÞ . The Rayleigh damping matrix is
Cð jÞ ¼ a1 Mð jÞ þ a2 Kð jÞ . The vibration equation of the jth substructure is written as
n o n o n o
Mð jÞ €xðtÞð jÞ þ Cð jÞ x_ ðtÞð jÞ þ Kð jÞ xðtÞð jÞ ¼ f ðtÞðextjÞ þ f ðtÞðcon
jÞ
ð1Þ
The independent substructure is excited by the external excitation f ðtÞðextjÞ and the
connection forces f ðtÞðcon
jÞ
from the adjacent substructures. €xðtÞð jÞ , x_ ðtÞð jÞ , xðtÞð jÞ are
the acceleration, velocity and displacement response of the jth substructure,
respectively.
Assembling the variables of the independent substructures to the primitive form
gives
h i
Mp ¼ Diag Mð1Þ ; Mð2Þ ; . . .; MðNs Þ ð2Þ
h i
Cp ¼ Diag Cð1Þ ; Cð2Þ ; . . .; CðNS Þ ð3Þ
h i
Kp ¼ Diag Kð1Þ ; Kð2Þ ; . . .; KðNS Þ ð4Þ
8 9 8 9 8 9
>
> €xðtÞð1Þ > > >
> x_ ðtÞð1Þ > > >
> xðtÞð1Þ > >
>
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
< €xðtÞð2Þ >
> = < x_ ðtÞð2Þ >
> = < xðtÞð2Þ >
> =
p p p
€xðtÞ ¼ ; _
x ðtÞ ¼ ; xðtÞ ¼ ;
> ... >
>
> >
>
>
>
>
.. >
. > >
>
>
>
>
.. >
. > >
>
>
> >
> >
> > >
> >
: ; : ; : ;
€xðtÞðNS Þ x_ ðtÞðNS Þ xðtÞðNS Þ
8 9 8 9 ð5Þ
>
> f ðtÞðext1Þ
>
> >
> f ðtÞðcon
1Þ
>
>
>
> >
> >
> >
>
>
< f ðtÞ = ð 2Þ > < f ðtÞ >
> ð2 Þ =
p ext p con
f ðtÞext ¼ ; f ðtÞcon ¼
>
> .. > > .. >
>
> . > >
>
>
>
> . > >
>
>
: >
; >
: >
ðNS Þ ð NS Þ ;
f ðtÞext f ðtÞcon
550 J. J. Li et al.
DfxðtÞp g ¼ 0 ð7Þ
where D is a connection matrix to make sure the nodes at the interfaces have
identical displacements.
D relates the primitive connection force and its local companion like
where fsg is the local connection force at the interfaces. Combining Eqs. (6), (7)
and (8), the vibration equation of the global structure is written as
Mp 0 €xðtÞp Cp 0 x_ ðtÞp Kp DT xðtÞp f ðtÞpext
þ þ ¼
0 0 €s 0 0 s_ D 0 s 0
ð9Þ
where qðtÞ denotes the coordinates of range space in terms of complete eigen-
vectors, and Kp and Up are diagonally assembled eigenvalues and eigenvectors of
substructures as
h i
Kp ¼ Diag Kð1Þ ; Kð2Þ ; . . .; Kð jÞ ; . . .; KðNS Þ ;
h i ð12Þ
Up ¼ Diag Uð1Þ ; Uð2Þ ; . . .; Uð jÞ ; . . .; UðNS Þ
Calculation of Structural Response and Response Sensitivity … 551
Eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the jth substructure are calculated from its
eigenequation Kð jÞ Uð jÞ ¼Kð jÞ Mð jÞ Uð jÞ
The eigenpairs in primitive form also satisfy the orthogonal properties of
Due to the orthogonal conditions of the structure as Eq. (13), the vibration
equation of the structure Eq. (11) is therefore simplified to
p
Ip 0 €qðtÞ a I þ a2 Kp 0 _
qðtÞ Kp ½DUp T qðtÞ
þ 1 þ
0 0 €s 0 0 s_ DUp 0 s
p T p
½U f ðtÞext
¼
0
ð14Þ
The vibration equation without considering damping force is used to derive the
simplified vibration equation for brevity in the following,
Ip 0 €qðtÞ Kp ½DUp T qðtÞ ½Up T f ðtÞpext
þ ¼ ð15Þ
0 0 €s DUp 0 s 0
2 38 9 2 p 38 9
Ipm 0 0 < €qðtÞm = Km 0 Cm < qðtÞm =
4 0 Ip 0 5 €qðtÞ þ 4 0 Kps Cs 5 qðtÞs
s
: s
; : ;
0 80 0 €s 9 CTm CTs 0 s
p T
< Um f ðtÞext >
> p
=
p T
¼ p
U f ðtÞext > ð18Þ
>
: s ;
0
Combining the second line of Eq. (18) and Eq. (19) leads to
1
1
s ¼ CTs Kps Cs CTm qðtÞm ð20Þ
Submitting Eq. (20) into the first line of Eq. (19) gives
1 T
1
€qðtÞm þ Kpm qðtÞm þ Cm CTs Kps Cs CTm qðtÞm ¼ Upm f ðtÞpext ð21Þ
Including the damping matrix, the vibration Eq. (21) of the structure is rewritten
as
1
1
€qðtÞm þ a1 Ipm þ a2 Kpm qðtÞ
_ m þ Kpm qðtÞm þ Cm CTs Kps Cs CTm qðtÞm
p T
¼ Um f ðtÞpext ð22Þ
ð24Þ
which can be calculated from the master eigenvectors. In the jth substructure,
1 h iT
1
1 h iT
Uðs jÞ Kðs jÞ Uðs jÞ ¼ Kð jÞ UðmjÞ KðmjÞ UðmjÞ ð25Þ
Calculation of Structural Response and Response Sensitivity … 553
The size of reduced vibration equation (Eq. (22)) is equal to that of the retained
master eigenvectors, which is much smaller than the original one (Eq. (9)). Besides,
the contribution of discarded eigenvectors in the proposed method is taken into
consideration by a residue. Predictably, calculation of structural response by the
proposed method is faster than the global method and is accurate at the same time.
ð27Þ
The right side of Eq. (27) is considered as an equivalent force. The coordinate
_ m =@r and @€qðtÞm =@r) related to structural sensitivity
derivatives (@qðtÞm =@r,@ qðtÞ
are calculated from Eq. (27) by the Newmark method. The derivative associated
with the residue is written as
1
1
1 1
@Cm CTs Kps Cs CTm @ CTs Kps Cs
1 @CT
1
¼ Cm CTm þ 2Cm CTs Kps Cs m
@r @r @r
ð28Þ
where @ Upm =@r and @Kpm =@r are the diagonal assemblies of the eigenvalue
derivatives and eigenvector derivatives of substructures, respectively.
1
1
@ CTs Kps Cs =@r is the derivative matrix related to @ Upm =@r and @Kpm =@r.
Substructures are independent. If the design parameter r is contained in the Rth
substructure, the derivative matrices are calculated in the Rth substructure only.
Other substructures are not related to the parameter, and the derivative matrices of
other substructures are zeros.
554 J. J. Li et al.
2 3 2 3
0 0 0 0 0 0
6 .. .. .. .. .. 7 6 .. . . .. .. .. 7
6. . . . . 7 p 6 . . . . .7
@Kpm 6 ðRÞ
@Km 7 @ Um 6 @ ½Um
ðRÞ 7
¼6
6
0 @r 0 7;
7
6
¼ 60 @r 07 7 ð29Þ
@r 6 .. .. .. .. .. 7 @r 6. . .. .. .. 7
4. . . . .5 4 .. .. . . .5
0 0 0 0 0 0
Within the Rth substructure, the master eigenvalue derivatives @KðmRÞ =@r and
master eigenvector derivatives @ UðmRÞ =@r can be calculated by treating it as an
independent structure [8].
In consequence, structural response of the global structure are recovered by
@xðtÞp @ Upm @qðtÞm
¼ qðtÞm þ Upm ð30Þ
@r @r @r
@ x_ ðtÞp @ Upm @ qðtÞ
_ m
¼ _ m þ Upm
qðtÞ ð31Þ
@r @r @r
@€xðtÞp @ Upm @€qðtÞm
¼ €qðtÞm þ Upm ð32Þ
@r @r @r
Z
Y
X
Table 2 The running time of the substructuring method and traditional global method
Scheme Response Total Relative Sensitivity Total Relative
Assemble Newmark ratio Assemble Newmark ratio
It can be seen from Table 2 that, the proposed method takes 5.3045 s to calculate
the master eigensolutions and form the reduced vibration equation, and takes
16.5054 s to solve the vibration equation by Newmark method. The substructuring
method takes only 21.8101 s to calculate structural response, just 10.09% of that
consumed by global method (216.1765 s). The proposed method takes 1.4068 s to
form the reduced sensitivity equation, and 20.6515 s to solve the reduced sensi-
tivity equation by Newmark method. The global method takes 219.9126 s to solve
the global sensitivity equation. The substructuring method takes 22.0586 s to cal-
culate the response sensitivity, about 10.03% of the global method. Obviously, the
proposed method greatly improves the efficiency of calculating structural response
and response sensitivity up to almost ten times as fast as the traditional global
method. This is because, the size of original vibration equation is 5400 5400,
which is reduced to 600 600 by employing the proposed substructuring method.
Since the computational effort of the structural analysis is approximately propor-
tional to the cubic of the size of the vibration equation, the computational work
could be reduced drastically with a decrease in the size of the vibration equation.
It is noted that, the assemble time is negligible as compared to that of Newmark
method with a long-time excitation and a large number of time steps. In this paper,
there are only 15001 time steps (Dt = 1/500 s) considered in this case study to
calculate the structural responses and response sensitivities, and a middle-scale
bridge with 5400 DOFs are used for illustration. The proposed method can be more
promising if a large structure with more DOFs and a larger amount of time step is
employed.
5 Conclusions
References
1. Lu ZR, Law SS (2007) Features of dynamic response sensitivity and its application in damage
detection. J Sound Vib 303(1–2):305–329
2. Lu ZR, Law SS (2004) State-space approach to calculate sensitivity of dynamic response. In:
Proceedings of IMECE04, ASME international mechanical engineering congress and
exposition, Anaheim, California, USA
3. Newmark NM (1959) A method of computation for structural dynamics. J Eng Mech
Div ASCE 85(1):67–94
4. Weng S, Tian W, Zhu HP, Xia Y, Gao F, Zhang YT, Li JJ (2017) Dynamic condensation
approach to calculation of structural response and response sensitivity. Mech Syst Signal
Process 88:302–317
5. Klerk DD, Rixen DJ, Voormeeren SN (2008) General framework for dynamic substructuring:
history, review, and classification of techniques. AIAA J 46(5):1169–1181
6. Weng S, Xia Y, Xu YL, Zhou XQ, Zhu HP (2009) Improved substructuring method for
eigensolutions of large-scale structures. J Sound Vib 323(3–5):718–736
7. Craig RR, Bampton MCC (1968) Coupling of substructures for dynamic analyses. AIAA J 6
(7):1313–1319
8. Nelson RB (1976) Simplified calculation of eigenvector derivatives. AIAA J 24(14):1201–
1205
9. Zhu HP, Mao L, Weng S (2014) A sensitivity-based structural damage identification method
with unknown input excitation using transmissibility concept. J Sound Vib 333:7135–7150
10. Ebrahimian H, Astroza R, Conte JP (2015) Extended Kalman filter for material parameter
estimation in nonlinear structural finite element models using direct differentiation method.
Earthquake Eng Struct Dynam 44:1495–1522
Influence of Soil-Structure Interaction
on Dynamics of Offshore Wind Turbine
Structure
Keywords Offshore wind turbine Natural frequency Soil-structure interaction
Foundation stiffness Dynamics Monopile p-y curve
1 Introduction
Offshore wind turbines provide an alternative source for clean renewable energy [9,
12, 13]. Monopile support is among the most commonly used foundations for
offshore wind turbine systems. In order to avoid the dynamic amplification and
fatigue damage, the structures for offshore wind turbine are dynamically sensitive
and must be designed so that the natural frequency of the structures is kept away
from the excitation frequencies. The estimation of the natural frequency of wind
turbine structures is therefore of crucial importance in the design phase.
Analysis of offshore wind turbine structures is challenging due to the dynamic
nature of offshore loadings such as wind and wave loadings, the rotational fre-
quency of the turbine and the blade passing frequency. The soft-stiff design
approach is widely used for offshore wind turbine. Its underlying design philosophy
is to the design the fundamental frequency of the offshore wind turbine to fall in the
gap between the rotational frequency of the turbine and the blade passing fre-
quency. Owing to the soil-structure interaction, which significantly influences the
dynamic behavior of offshore wind turbines, many researchers have developed
different methods to address this issue. Arany et al. [3] showed that the predicted
natural frequency of offshore wind turbines based on Rayleigh beam and shear
deformable Timoshenko beam do not provide a significant improvement in the
results and concluded that the Euler–Bernoulli model is sufficiently accurate. In
addition, Arany et al. [4] developed a simplified model of the wind turbine structure
in which the tapered tower is replaced by an idealized tower with an equivalent
uniform cross-sectional area. The average diameter from the actual top and bottom
diameters of the tower is employed in their idealized model together with a coef-
ficient introduced for the correction of bending stiffness of the wind turbine tower.
Adhikari and Bhattacharya [1] developed a simplified approach for dynamic
analysis of wind turbine towers with flexible foundations. Zaaijer [15] predicted
natural frequencies and studied the sensitivity for several foundation models. Bisoi
et al. [5] studied the parameters that affect the dynamic responses for offshore wind
turbine in clay considering soil–structure interaction on a p-y curve foundation
model. The natural frequency is compared by initial stiffness and secant stiffness on
varying load condition. Yi et al. [14] studied the influence of pile-soil-interaction on
natural frequency of bottom-fixed offshore wind turbines with allowance for
material uncertainties. Linearization is carried out to approximate the secant stiff-
ness of nonlinear spring for investigating the natural frequencies. The result indi-
cated that the variation of load significantly affects the natural frequency of offshore
wind turbine structure in monopile foundation type. More recently, Jalbi et al. [10]
presented a method to predict the cyclic loading profiles for offshore wind turbine
and compared ratios of max/min loading in case studies of offshore wind turbine
which will be analyzed in this paper.
A finite element-based dynamic analysis of offshore wind turbines with mono-
pile foundations including the soil-structure interaction effects is developed to
assess the natural frequencies of wind turbine systems. The dynamic model of wind
turbine structure is based on the Euler-Bernoulli beam-column theory with varying
stiffness. The soil-structure-interaction between the wind turbine structure and the
foundation is accounted by two foundation models, i.e., a non-linear p-y foundation
model and an elastic end-support model with a set of springs. Selected numerical
results are presented to portray the influence of various foundation systems on
natural frequency of offshore wind turbines.
Influence of Soil-Structure Interaction on Dynamics … 561
Lt Lt
Transition piece Ls Ls
p-y curve
Mud line
t-z curve
Lp
Lp
q-z curve
(a) (b)
Figure 1(a) shows a typical monopile offshore wind turbine system. The wind
turbine system comprises a tower, transition piece and a monopile foundation as
shown in Fig. 1. The tower is typically a tubular tapered column. The mean sea
level and mud line are also depicted in Fig. 1. The foundation is defined as the part
of the wind turbine system embedded below the mudline in the ground (see Fig. 1
(a)) in which the interaction between the monopile foundation and the surrounding
soil was considered.
The model of offshore wind turbine system considered is shown in Fig. 1(b).
The actual dimensions of tapered tower are used for the analysis. The analysis was
carried out by using SAP2000 finite element-based program. The tower and the
substructure are represented by Euler-Bernoulli beams. The rotor nacelle assembly
is considered as a lumped mass at the top head. Foundation system is considered by
a nonlinear p-y model.
The p-y curve is a widely used method to analyze the horizontal load–dis-
placement behavior of piles [5, 6, 16]. The surrounding soils are discretized by set
of nonlinear springs which represented the soil behavior as shown in Fig. 1(b). In
the foundation system of wind turbine, the lateral resistances of the soil against the
foundation movements (p-y spring) and the vertical springs attached to the
562 T. Wansuwan and Y. Sapsathiarn
monopile are applied to simulate the shaft friction (t-z spring) and end bearing
capacity at the tip of the monopile (q-z spring) as shown in Fig. 1. The properties of
the soil springs are described by the p-y, t-z and q-z curves as recommended in API
[2] and DNV-OS-J101 [8].
The influence of various parameters on the fundamental natural frequency is
investigated based on the following three case studies of wind turbines with
available data from the paper by Arany et al. [4]:
• Case study I: Belwind offshore wind farm, Vestas V90 3 MW (Belgium)
• Case study II: Barrow offshore wind farm, Vestas V90 3 MW (UK)
• Case study III: Kentish Flats offshore wind farm, Vestas V90 3 MW (UK)
Parameters for all three case studies are given in Table 1 [4]. Table 2 presents
parameters for monopile and the corresponding stiffness of the offshore wind tur-
bines considered [4]. Soil parameters for Belwind offshore wind farm (Case study I)
are presented in Table 3. Soil data for the other cases can be found in Jalbi et al.
[10] and Damgaard et al. [7] but the data is not presented herein.
Table 3 Detailed soil Type of soil Depth (m) c′ (kN/m3) u (deg) cu (kPa)
conditions for offshore wind
turbine structure at Belwind Dense sand −15 9.0 40 –
offshore wind farm (Case Stiff clay −17 8.5 – 175
study I) Dense sand −30 9.0 40 –
800 800
400 400
0 0
0 100 200 300 400 0 100 200 300 400
(a) (b)
Fig. 2 a Thrust force time history with wind speeds of 5, 10 and 15 m/s and b wave load time
history for significant wave heights 0.5, 1 and 3 m
In this section, selected numerical results are presented to show the influence of
various parameters on the natural frequencies of offshore wind turbine systems.
Linearization is employed for transforming the nonlinear p-y model to equivalent
linear system. The secant stiffness is calculated by considering the magnitude of
pile stiffness which depends on the dynamic loads (i.e., wind and wave loads). The
secant stiffness is determined by increasing lateral load in increments of 10% up to
the extreme loading conditions of the wind turbine [15]. Nonlinear dynamic anal-
ysis is carried out when the loading time history data are available.
The nonlinear soil springs are linearized by considering the wind and wave loads
which are determined from thrust forces based on time history analysis [11]. The
thrust forces acting on offshore wind turbines are considered at the rated wind speed
in which high thrust forces with significant fluctuations are generated [14]. Figure 2
(a) shows the time history of thrust forces with wind speed of 5, 10 and 15 m/s for
normal turbulence models. For wave loading, the JONSWAP spectrum and Morison
equation are used to simulate the wave load time history. The total wave load is
obtained as the summation of drag and inertia components arising from the velocity
and acceleration of water particles, respectively [10]. The time history data of wave
loading for significant wave height = 0.5, 1 and 3 m is presented in Fig. 2(b).
564 T. Wansuwan and Y. Sapsathiarn
Table 4 Numerical results for fundamental frequency of offshore wind turbines considered
Case Wind First natural frequency (Hz)
study farm Measurement Fixed-support Elastic end-support p-
[4] model y model
I Belwind 0.372 0.475 0.381 0.375
II Barrow 0.369 0.460 0.380 0.379
III Kentish 0.339 0.415 0.348 0.335
Flats
p-y curve
KR KL
t-z curve
KLR
q-z curve
In order to calculate the secant stiffness of p-y analysis, the lowest total loading
condition under normal operating conditions is considered [10]. The wind load
applied at the top of the wind turbine tower is 500 kN and the wave load applied at
the mean sea level is 250 kN.
Table 4 presents the numerical results for the natural frequency of offshore wind
turbines considered. Three foundation models for offshore wind turbine systems are
considered in the analysis, namely, fixed support, elastic end-support model with a set
of springs and nonlinear p-y model as shown in Figs. 3(a), (b) and (c), respectively.
Influence of Soil-Structure Interaction on Dynamics … 565
For an elastic end-support model (see Fig. 3(b)), the foundation is represented
by three elastic springs, e.g., lateral KL , rotational KR and cross coupling stiffness
KLR . The force-displacement relation of the foundation may be written as
Fx KL KLR v
¼ ð1Þ
My KLR KR v0
where v and v0 denote the displacement and slope at the foundation, respectively, Fx
is the lateral force, and My is the fore-aft moment.
The numerical results shown in Table 4 show a significant dependence of the
natural frequency on the interaction between foundation and wind turbine structure
and the assumptions used in the various foundation models. As shown in Table 4,
natural frequencies of wind turbines with fixed support are 0.475, 0.460 and
0.415 Hz for Belwind, Barrow and Kentish Flats offshore wind turbine farms,
respectively. Analysis of offshore wind turbines with fixed-support model implies
that the foundation stiffness from the monopile is considered infinite in the analysis
and therefore the soil-structure interaction is not taken into account. It can be seen
from the numerical results in Table 4 that the natural frequencies of offshore wind
turbines with fixed-support are relatively higher than the corresponding natural
frequencies of wind turbines with elastic end-support model and with p-y model for
all case studies considered. The differences in natural frequencies between wind
turbine with fixed-support and the measurement reported by Arany et al. [4] are
27.7, 24.7 and 22.4%, respectively, for Belwind, Barrow and Kentish Flats offshore
wind turbine farms. The analysis for natural frequencies of wind turbines with
elastic end-support model and p-y model show a good agreement with the mea-
surement results reported by Arany et al. [4]. The differences of natural frequencies
are less than 3% for both wind turbines with elastic end-support model and
p-y model cases when compared to the measurements by Arany et al. [4]. The
numerical results suggest that the interaction between the foundation and wind
turbine structure should be taken into account in the analysis for evaluating the
natural frequency of offshore wind turbine systems.
4 Conclusions
In this paper, a finite element model for dynamic analysis of offshore wind turbines
with monopile foundations including the soil-structure interaction effects is
developed to assess the natural frequencies of wind turbines systems. The model of
wind turbine structure developed is based on the Euler-Bernoulli beam-column
theory with varying stiffness. The soil-structure-interaction between the wind tur-
bine structure and the foundation is represented by a non-linear p-y foundation
model. Selected numerical results are presented to portray the influence of various
foundation systems, i.e., fixed support, elastic end-support model with a set of
springs and nonlinear p-y model, on natural frequency of offshore wind turbines.
566 T. Wansuwan and Y. Sapsathiarn
The investigation is based on three case studies of wind turbines, i.e., Belwind,
Barrow and Kentish Flats offshore wind farms with available data from the liter-
ature. The differences in natural frequencies between wind turbine with
fixed-support and the measurement reported in the literature are relatively high
when compared to the wind turbines with elastic end-support model and p-y model
for all case studies considered.
Acknowledgements This project is partially supported by the European Union’s Horizon 2020
Research and Innovation Programme RISE under grant agreement no. 730888 (RESET) and
partially supported by Graduate Studies of Mahidol University Alumni Association, Mahidol
University.
References
14. Yi JH, Kim SB, Yoon GL, Andersen L (2015) Natural frequency of bottom-fixed offshore
wind turbines considering pile-soil-interaction with material uncertainties and scouring depth.
Wind Struct 21:625–639
15. Zaaijer M (2004) Design methods for offshore wind turbines at exposed sites, Report
No. 2317/BR/22D, Delft University of Technology
16. Zuo H, Bi K, Hao H (2018) Dynamic analyses of operating offshore wind turbines including
soil-structure interaction. Eng Struct 157:42–62
Combined Spar and Partially Porous
Wall Fish Cage for Offshore Site
Abstract Presented herein is a design concept for an offshore fish farm that
combines a spar platform and a partially porous wall fish cage, named COSPAR
fish cage. The design features a cylindrical cage with an open net for its bottom
portion and a partially porous wall (with specially designed internal section to
attenuate strong surface waves) for its top portion. A hybrid concrete and steel, deep
draft spar platform carries a wind turbine and a control unit for power supply for
remotely controlled fish farming operations. The central spar is connected to the top
and bottom of the cylindrical fish cage by frame structures. The top frames are also
used as walkways to access the central spar and the bottom frames as ballast
compartments for adjusting the draft. By combining fish cage and spar, the meta
centre height can be adjusted to induce a low frequency motion response.
Moreover, an inherently unbalanced mooring tension problem of a mega-scale cage
alone can be resolved by a 4 mooring line system attached to the central spar just
below the bottom of the cage. This novel concept of a combined spar and fish cage
design is able to overcome challenges of a high energy environment, lack of power
supply, and stable mooring system for an offshore fish farm.
Keywords Offshore fish farming Fish cage Spar platform Wind turbine
Partially porous wall Wave attenuation
1 Introduction
Nearshore fish farming industry has to bear criticisms about the degradation of the
sheltered sea environment due to fish wastes and uneaten feedstock. Also, nearshore
fish farms pose a present risk from competing users for the common nearshore sea
offshore installation in water depths of 100 to 300 m and the cage structure is able
to withstand 8 to 10 m significant waves over its 20 years of operating life.
Shenlan 1 (see Fig. 1b) was built by Wuchang Shipbuilding industry Group Co.
and it is deployed at 240 km off the shore of Rizhao in East China’s Shandong
province. This offshore fish cage has a diameter of 60 m, height of 35 m and a
volume of 50,000 m3 that is able to hold 300,000 salmons. The cage has a large
ballast volume at the bottom pontoons and columns that allows the cage to be
submerged up to 50 m below the sea level. Shenlan 1 is a kind of sister fish cage
that shares many similarities to Ocean Farm 1 with regard to shape,
semi-submergibility and mooring method. However, Shenlan 1 features a centre
buoy that is used to generate power for the fish cage by vertical oscillating motions.
The aforementioned Ocean Farm 1 and Shenlan 1 adopt the semi-submergible
solution that can temporarily protect the fish and the cage from extreme weather
conditions by sinking the cage under water for a period of time. However, these
cage designs do not fully protect the fish for the entire farming period when the sites
have daily high energetic waves as they are open net cages. It is desirable to have a
calm sea state under normal operating condition to ensure fish growth. This
requirement poses a strict constraint on the selection of a suitable offshore site. In
Australia, Tassal’s salmon farmers cannot perform normal duties when the sites are
dominated by wave condition exceeding 3 m significant wave height (Hs) in a
30-year return period. In addition, cost-effective and constant power supply for fish
farm operations are questionable. Despite Shenlan 1 has a power supply from wave
energy convertors to harvest wave energy from vertical oscillating motions, it
appears contradictory to be harvesting wave energy while at the same time desiring
a quiet and conducive environment for fish’s well-being and growth.
The authors opine that the following five features are to be incorporated in the
development of a feasible and cost-effective offshore fish cage design:
1. Ensure stable dynamic motions such as heave and pitch to maintain structural
integrity of floating system and a safe working condition for workers.
2. Dissipate surface wave energy to produce calm and conducive water environ-
ment for fish’s well-being and for solving feeding process.
3. Provide a stand-alone power supply to facilitate unmanned surveillance and
autonomous systems.
4. Have a simple and stable interactive mooring solution that minimizes and bal-
ances the tension forces both windward and leeward mooring lines.
5. Have an integrated system that encompass all the above features.
In view of the above features, the authors propose a novel design concept for
offshore fish cage which will be referred to as COSPAR fish cage; an acronym for a
COmbined Spar and PARtially porous wall fish cage. The design will allow fish
farming companies to expand the choice of potential offshore sites. In this paper, 4
design features of the COSPAR fish cage are presented with some evidential results
of diffraction and coupled mooring analysis based on the potential flow theory and
followed by concluding remarks and suggested future work.
Figure 2 shows the COSPAR fish cage design. It comprises 3 parts: (1) a cylindrical
open net fish cage with a partially porous wall (wave fence) at the top portion to
block strong surface waves as well as to protect the fish from floating debris and
predators, (2) a centrally placed hybrid concrete-steel spar platform that provides
the buoyancy for holding a fish cage as well as to carry a wind turbine and control
unit and (3) a mounted control unit and wind turbine on the top of the spar to
provide the power supply.
The cylindrical cage has an 80 m diameter, 39 m height and 36 m draft. The
steel cage has 8 columns, 2 horizontal ring members and 16 radial beams at the
base. All steel members have a hollow circular section. The upper part of the cage
adjacent to the still water line (SWL) is a 6 m high (3 m above and 3 m below
SWL) porous wall with special internal members installed to dissipate waves of
3 m high. By arranging a range of porous plates such as high, medium and low for
wave transmission, wave run-up and wave reflection, respectively, the incident
wave may be reduced by half; thereby creating a reasonable calm internal sea
environment that is suitable for fish farming.
The central spar platform has an 82 m height, 7.8 m diameter and 76 m draft.
The lower part of the spar up to 38 m from the keel line is made from concrete for
cost effectiveness as well as to lower the centre of gravity. The upper part is made of
steel which is both light and strong.
Combined Spar and Partially Porous Wall Fish Cage… 573
The cylindrical cage is connected by 4 truss girders (above water) and 16 girders
at the base to the spar so that both cage and spar work as a monolithic rigid body.
The 4 top girders form walkways to access for the control unit and the wind turbine.
Four fairleads are attached to the spar between 38 m and 40 m from the keel line
that will tie 4 catenary chains for station keeping. The fairleads are located outside
the cage to prevent interference between lines and cage structure as well as to gather
the mooring lines to produce a small benthic footprint. The total water volume of
the fish cage is about 180,000 m3 that can accommodate about 720,000 salmons by
assuming a stock density of 20 kg/m3 and 5 kg for matured fish ready for har-
vesting. Table 1 summarizes the dimensions of the structure and usage of ballast
compartments of the COSPAR fish cage.
Below, we highlight the design features of COSPAR cage design,
• Design feature 1: Partially porous wall (wave fence) to dissipate wave energy
Attenuating strong waves is an imperative requirement to overcome site
restrictions for offshore fish farming. In order to lower wave energy transmission
inside the cages, it is necessary to design the cage structures as wave dissipative
members that is able to reduce energy from not only incident wave but also from
diffraction and reflection waves. As a possible solution, thin porous structure
574 Y. I. Chu and C. M. Wang
members are introduced as in a breakwater system to protect coastal assets [1, 12].
A breakwater made of material having fine pores has been shown to reduce the
hydrodynamic pressure exerted on it. A double porous barrier system is able to
reduce both wave transmission and reflection [11]. However, owing to the complex
wave-wave and wave-structure interactions, the breakwater system tends to sig-
nificantly affect the hydrodynamic performance of the floating structure [20]. There
have been several considerations in the design of such a floating breakwater system
with respect to buoyancy and floating stability, wave transmission, mooring forces
and design of structure for breakwater units [4, 11]. However, it would be costly to
build a breakwater system to surround the fish cage in a deep offshore site.
Therefore, it is proposed that the breakwater system forms the upper portion of the
COSPAR cage design and it will be referred as the wave fence. Figure 3 shows a
clearer design of the wave fence that comprises a high porous outer barrier and a
low porous inner barrier. Such a design will contribute to controlling the wave
transmission and wave reflection, respectively. In addition, internal medium porous
plates sloping upwards for incident wave and downwards for reflection wave dis-
sipate energy via wave run-up. Table 2 shows the detail hole sizes to create the
different porosities.
The cage system holds fish by suspending the flexible net at the inner porous
barrier and gratings are applied to the outer barrier so as to protect fish from floating
debris and invasion of predators. The cage system still keeps the advantage of an
open net system for replenishment of water and removal of wastes. Moreover, the
solution allows a monolithic rigid body motion that maximizes the efficiency of the
Combined Spar and Partially Porous Wall Fish Cage… 575
Picture
wave fence through stable motion response. In addition, by sharing the mooring
system for both the cage and the wave fence, capital expenditure may be reduced.
• Design feature 2: Combined spar and cage for stable wave response motion
In the offshore wind energy industry, a Spar platform has been tested through
experimental and numerical methods as a floater for wind turbine to generate power
in an open and deep ocean space. The spar platform has great stability in wave
response motions due to its deep draft, low centre of gravity and small wetted
surface area. Consequently, the world’s first commercialized floating wind farm,
Hywind Scotland, adopted a spar platform and successfully deployed it in 2017.
Moreover, Utsunomiya et al. [18] proposed a hybrid spar comprising a prestressed
576 Y. I. Chu and C. M. Wang
concrete lower half body and a steel upper half body to save construction costs.
However, when the spar is used as a floater for wind turbine, wave response
motions of the spar is still critical as it significantly affects the performance of the
wind turbine. Especially for the horizontal axis wind turbine, pitching motion leads
to the unsteady aerodynamic effects on the rotating blades. This results in a large
variation of the aerodynamic performance of a floating offshore wind turbine sys-
tem [13–15].
On the other hand, in the offshore fish farming industry, semi-submergible
floaters are often chosen due to their capability to produce a large farming space by
having stiff and strong frame members and submergibility capability (using ballast
tanks) to protect cage from extreme storms. However, when the size of floaters
become very large, the windward mooring lines are exposed to a far greater tension
forces than those lines on the leeward side and this may result in the breaking of the
highly stressed lines [21]. Moreover, when a wave fence is incorporated as in
COSPAR cage design, the semi-submersible floaters may not suitable to produce
enough buoyancy force by the slender columns and motion response to the wave
resonance may become more susceptible.
Although both offshore fish farming and wind energy industries have not yet
developed an ideal design solution to resolve the rigid body motion problem, the
authors see great benefits by combining and co-locating the cylindrical fish cage and
the floating spar that carries the wind turbine. This is because the cylindrical fish cage
has a great horizontal and vertical mass of moment inertia, but it has a relatively large
metacentric height that generates too much angular acceleration. On the other hand, a
spar has relatively small metacentric height and low angular acceleration that results in
a low frequency motion, but its horizontal and vertical stiffnesses are small compare to
cage. By combining the two systems and adopting a partially porous wave fence, the
harmonized system can share the buoyancy force, reduce wetted surface by porous
members, truncated metacentric height, a shifted natural frequency to the low zone
and an increased mass moment of inertia. In order to validate the aforementioned
A comparison test has been performed for cage only case and COSPAR case by
using ANSYS AQWA for the coupled analysis of diffraction analysis of floating
structure interacting with mooring lines. The results show tension force response
amplitude operator (RAO) against a unit wave amplitude. Cage only case (Fig. 5)
has a wide frequency ranged motion and dominating tension on windward lines
whereas COSPAR case (Fig. 6) shows a relatively narrow frequency motion and an
evenly distributed motion response.
Note: This study does not include the partially porous wave fence as the mod-
elling of a porous surface is not supported in the ANSYS AQWA Therefore, a
buoyant wave fence is considered for both cases.
• Design feature 4: Reduction of carbon footprint and efficient power system
The fish farming industry currently rely heavily on fossil fuels for venturation,
feeding, lighting, net cleaning, fish bathing and harvesting operations. For example,
Tassal (Australia) consume 30 litres of diesel per hour for their 25 fish cages. For a
1.5 year-round operation, this translates to 335 tons of diesel. On the other hand,
wind energy industry incurs a significant cost to deliver power over longer distances
when the site is far from the coast. By co-locating the floating wind turbine and the
fish farm (the end user), it saves costs for the wind energy company and the fish
farm operator.
580 Y. I. Chu and C. M. Wang
3 Concluding Remarks
Presented herein is COSPAR - a novel fish cage design that has integrated design
features of providing stable dynamic motions by coupled spar and cylindrical fish
cage, calm water by attenuating wave energy through porous wave fence, a
stand-alone power system by having a wind turbine and stable interactive mooring
solution with 4 catenary lines attached to the spar and anchored to the seabed.
Although diffraction and radiation analyses were carried out to determine the
dynamic motion responses of COSPAR that shows its stability against wave forces,
more work is necessary to refine the design. There are still many uncertainties
regarding non-linear viscosity effect such as drag and damping that have to be
incorporated in the analysis. Strength evaluation of porous plates is another issue to
be considered in final design such as edge reinforcement or protection against
corrosion and biofouling. Other alternative material such as a fibre reinforced
composite material can be tested when it suits for the design to have more durability
in open sea condition.
References
1. Besio G, Losada M (2008) Sediment transport patterns at Trafalgar offshore windfarm. Ocean
Eng 35(7):653–665
2. DNV GL (2011) Hull equipment and safety, DNV Rules for classification of SHIPS Pt.3
Ch.3, Det Norske Veritas and Germanischer Lloyd, Norway
Combined Spar and Partially Porous Wall Fish Cage… 581
3. DNV GL (2015) Offshore standard: Position mooring, DNVGL-OS-E301, Det Norske Veritas
and Germanischer Lloyd, Norway
4. Hegde AV, Kamath K, Deepak J (2008) Mooring forces in horizontal interlaced moored
floating pipe breakwater with three layers. Ocean Eng 35(1):165–173
5. Holm P, Buck BH, Langan R (2017) Introduction: new approaches to sustainable offshore
food production and the development of offshore platforms. In: Aquaculture perspective of
multi-use sites in the open ocean. Springer, Cham, pp 1–20
6. Huguenin JE (1997) The design, operations and economics of cage culture systems. Aquacult
Eng 16(3):167–203
7. Jansen HM, Van Den Burg S, Bolman B, Jak RG, Kamermans P, Poelman M, Stuiver M
(2016) The feasibility of offshore aquaculture and its potential for multi-use in the North Sea.
Aquacult Int 24(3):735–756
8. Jeon S, Cho Y, Seo M, Cho J, Jeong W (2013) Dynamic response of floating substructure of
spar-type offshore wind turbine with catenary mooring cables. Ocean Eng 72:356–364
9. Kankainen M, Mikalsen R (2014) Offshore fish farm investment and competitiveness in the
Baltic Sea. Reports of Aquabest Project 2
10. Papandroulakis N, Thomsen C, Mintenbeck K, Mayorga P, Hernández-Brito JJ (2017) The
EU-Project “TROPOS”. In: Aquaculture perspective of multi-use sites in the open ocean.
Springer, Cham, pp 355–374
11. Qiao W, Wang K-H, Sun Y (2017) Scattering of water waves by a floating body with two
vertically attached porous walls. J Eng Mech 144(2):04017162
12. Sahoo T, Lee M, Chwang A (2000) Trapping and generation of waves by vertical porous
structures. J Eng Mech 126(10):1074–1082
13. Sebastian T, Lackner MA (2012) Analysis of the induction and wake evolution of an offshore
floating wind turbine. Energies 5(4):968–1000
14. Sebastian T, Lackner MA (2012) Development of a free vortex wake method code for
offshore floating wind turbines. Renew Energy 46:269–275
15. Sebastian T, Lackner MA (2012) Characterization of the unsteady aerodynamics of offshore
floating wind turbines. Wind Energy 16(3):339–352
16. Tidwell JH (2012) Aquaculture production systems. Wiley-Blackwell, Ames
17. Troell M, Tyedmers P, Kautsky N, Rönnbäck P (2004) Aquaculture and energy use. Encycl
Energy 1:97–108
18. Utsunomiya T, Matsukuma H, Minoura S, Ko K, Hamamura H, Kobayashi O, Yasui K
(2013) At sea experiment of a hybrid spar for floating offshore wind turbine using 1/10-scale
model. J Offshore Mech Arct Eng 135(3):034503
19. Wang CM, Chu YI, Park JC (2019) Moving offshore for fish farming. J Aquacul Mar Biol 8.
https://medcraveonline.com/JAMB/JAMB-08-00240.pdf. Accessed 26 July 2019
20. Xiao L, Kou Y, Tao L, Yang L (2016) Comparative study of hydrodynamic performances of
breakwaters with double-layered perforated walls attached to ring-shaped very large floating
structures. Ocean Eng 111:279–291
21. Zhao Y, Guan C, Bi C, Liu H, Cui Y (2019) Experimental investigations on hydrodynamic
responses of a semi-submersible offshore fish farm in waves. J Mar Sci Eng 7(7):238
Development of Energyhub@Sea
Concept
1 Introduction
There has been a significant growth in the number and capacity of offshore wind
turbines over the last decades. The increase in distances from the shore, logistics
and transportation challenges are demanding and have to be addressed when
developing potential solutions for offshore operations. In the future, an offshore
on-site maintenance base will be an important counterpart to the land-based one in
order to save transport costs and time required to offshore wind parks. In this
regard, Energyhub@Sea (see Fig. 1) aims to offer a technical solution for offshore
wind operation and maintenance (O&M) targeting a low levelized cost of energy.
The Energyhub@Sea concept is one of the four applications of floating islands
considered in the Space@Sea project. The major goal is to develop a cost-effective
and energy self-sufficient maintenance platform for offshore wind farms. The design
concept encompasses a multitude of O&M hub for offshore wind services,
accommodation facilities for industrial personnel and renewable energy extractions
and housing of spare parts. The primary energy source of the hub will be a medium
sized wind turbine coupled with photovoltaic (PV) system and another source will
be wave energy converters. In order to be energy self-sustaining, a smart energy
storage and smart grid were optimized based on the energy demand and energy
supply of the entire hub.
While other similar research studies have been done in the offshore renewable
energy sector, the Energyhub@Sea adds value to these by its technical synergies
opportunities between O&M hub, crew accommodation, wind, wave and solar
energy converters and the Space@Sea modular floating solution. Owing to the
shared use of common infrastructures, the following technical synergies opportu-
nities exist within the Energyhub@Sea concept:
• Location
• Support structure
• Superstructure
• Mooring system
Fig. 1 Energyhub@Sea
concept for North Sea site
Development of Energyhub@Sea Concept 585
• Grid connection
• Installation equipment
Beside the Energyhub@Sea other applications like farming, logistics or living at
sea are important to consider and they influence the design. The design consider-
ations are therefore described in Sect. 2 by considering all four kinds of
applications.
The Mediterranean Sea, to be more precise, the Gulf du Lion located near southern
France coastline is characterized by benign environmental conditions in terms of
wave, but the site has relatively deep waters and good wind conditions that are ideal
for floating offshore wind development. Figure 2 shows the possible site location of
the energy hub in the Mediterranean Sea site with a summary of characterisation of
environmental conditions in this region
• Water depth 150–200 m
• Distance from shore 60 km
• Significant wave height 5.6 m
• Extreme wave up to 10 m above mean sea level
• Average wind speed at 100 m 10–11 m/s
• Temperature 0 to 30 °C
• Ice condition no icing, some snow
• Storm condition winter storms, thunderstorms in summer
Fig. 2 Map of proposed location for Mediterranean Sea site in the Gulf du Lion
586 F. Adam et al.
2 Design Considerations
As part of the basic design, three considerations were distinguished for the modules
making up the island. All three were blind scored by the consortium and external
experts.
• Module size
• Module shape
• Module principle
For the first principle design of the arbitrary module principal dimensions range of
12.5, 25, 50, 100 and 200 m were investigated. The following aspects play a role
when considering the module size:
• Building possibilities: A yard market survey implies that modules with a
maximum principal dimension of about 45 m can be built in a large number of
places. For larger modules the options are limited. On the other hand, it is very
likely that when a floating island will become reality, a dedicated dock or docks
will be built. In practice, this implies that existing building facilities should not
weigh hard on the decision between say a module with a principal dimension of
say 50 m or 100 m. However, when the decision falls to a principal dimension
of 50 m choosing there is a benefit of then having a maximum dimension of
about 45 m.
• Transport and installation: The transport of single modules becomes easier with
decreasing size. At least per module. For installation, smaller module sizes are
still favourable and are more easily manageable. Depending on the chosen
mooring system the installation ease decreases significantly for smaller module
sizes when the effort is put in relation to the installed area. Therefore, the
transport of modules that are smaller than say 50 m, it can be seen as resolvable,
while the installation procedures might be cumbersome.
• Functionality: For ship unloading and loading sides, the bigger the better as it
gives flexibility to possibly mount multiple containers. A module length of
200 m would enable a proper integration of all envisaged functionalities. For
harbour operations, loading equipment, apron, storage and logistics could be
well placed on a module. As container ships are typically served by one crane
per 100 m berth length, even ships longer than 200 m could be served without
losses in efficiency when compared to onshore facilities if two modules are used.
With a deck area of 40,000 m2 it is hard to imagine that any restrictions will
arise regarding applications in the scope of living, farming or Energy@Sea.
A module length of 100 m would also meet this criterion. Storage size and
flexibility regarding trans-shipment gear are however restricted. The minimum
Development of Energyhub@Sea Concept 587
For the basic design of the module the following shapes were investigated: trian-
gular, right triangle, square, rectangle, hexagonal and circular. The following
aspects play a role when considering the shape of the module.
• Building ease: Building a square or rectangular module does not require new
insights. Triangular and hexagonal modules, although slightly less convenient,
are not considered an issue. Circular will require a totally different approach in
building since only radial lines are straight, and everything else will require
customized work. If the deck space of the modules per unit is used as a measure
588 F. Adam et al.
of success, the rectangular shape offers the most promising form with regard to
the currently available construction sites.
• Compliance and forces: It is noted that the design of the shape is related to the
design of the joints. Hinge joints are restrictive and would favor for more
compliance axis, hence a triangular shape. More flexible interconnecting joints
however might cope with less compliance axis, and hence squares. Therefore,
the design of the joints is closely related to the choice of the shape.
• Gaps: From the shapes under investigation, only a circular module will result in
islands with gaps or voids even larger than the widest indispensable slit between
the modules. For the general application these voids will be highly undesirable.
The other shapes under investigation can be combined together without leaving
large voids. It should be noted though that the triangular shapes can be put
together in two different configurations.
• Aboard logistics: Most existing buildings are rectangular buildings, and the
same holds for standardized cargo such as containers and swap bodies. From
this point of view, it seems most straightforward to also make the module
rectangular. Here it should be noted that two right triangles ‘rigidly’ connected
form a square and thus it has the same advantages. The isosceles triangles under
consideration, however, will be rigidly connected to form a rhombus and it will
not cure the problem of mismatching building- and cargo-shapes. It should be
mentioned though that if the overall dimensions of the island are much larger
than the dimensions of a cargo unit, i.e. a 40 ft container versus a 100 m
triangular island, the loss of storage space due to non-orthogonal corners is
small when compared to the overall available deck space.
A square or rectangular module is thus the preferred solution.
For the basic design of the module the following principles were investigated:
Barge type, Air cushion, Semi-submersible and Tension leg platform (TLP). The
following aspects play a role when considering the module principle:
• Fabrication costs: A barge type structure is well in line with what is currently
build and the most easily buildable solution. As such the barge type seems most
advantageous in fabrication costs. An air cushion type structure is not that more
difficult to build as it is mainly a barge without a bottom. The air cushion type
floaters will, when aiming for a similar draft, be however, associated with a
small increase in building effort, as the overall structure height will increase by a
significant portion of the barge-draft. The semi-sub type and the TLP type are
significantly more expensive. The semi-sub and TLP types are deemed of
similar order, when the installation cost is seen as part of the installation
procedure.
Development of Energyhub@Sea Concept 589
According to basic design of the floater in Sect. 2, the final basic design of the
floater was concluded as a square of 45 m side length with 4 m height. Therefore,
an appropriate design of O&M super structure was further refined with a wide range
of additional benefits, integrating the results of other work packages in the design.
Especially the list of functional requirements for the design developed by living
criteria, the architectural design and the inventory HSE regulations were taken into
account. Furthermore, an internal benefit analysis was carried out to find a com-
promise between engineering and architectural demands. Figure 1 illustrates a
rendered 3D-model of the final design of the energy hub. The accommodation
module is oriented in such a way that motion-induced infrastructure like wind
energy turbine is kept a safe distance from it and the entire module is stabilized
under extreme wave conditions.
Like a self-sufficient artificial island, the hub is equipped with fresh and
wastewater infrastructures, accommodation building with offices, workshops,
apartments, laundry, social rooms, kitchen and canteen, heating, ventilation and air
590 F. Adam et al.
conditioning unit (HVAC), a hospital with required first aid facilities and para-
medics as well as a helicopter deck which functions as evacuation and emergency
transport. The assumption is that each floater has 45 m edge length and the O&M
hub itself has two levels with a total net area of about 1900 m2 located in the middle
of the floater. The helicopter deck on top of the accommodation building is
accessible via hatches above the accommodation building. The centre of the
building is a 140 m2 covered patio with plants and recreation areas.
The basic design specifications and estimated space requirements for accom-
modation building are listed in Table 1. The estimated hot and cold water con-
sumption is 4–5 m3 per day for approximately 32 persons. The water desalination,
the water treatment units as well as the waste storage are placed in the storage hall.
The building technology for keeping the temperature and humidity at comfortable
levels (air condition unit and ventilation system, supply air flow according to ISO
8861), the cooling chambers and food storage rooms are integrated in the topside
building. All storage units used for food and drink supply including fresh water
must cover a capacity of minimum 30 days.
Depending on the region of operation, the configuration of the energy hub can be
adapted. Thereby, the main changes are related to the length of the columns and the
HVAC system. At the Mediterranean site, the accommodation building will be
placed directly on the storage hall and an air condition system is needed in summer.
The energy needed for heating and cooling will be almost the same in winter and
summer for the Mediterranean site.
Being a permanently manned offshore platform, safe manning plays a vital role.
Depending on the number and type of wind turbines which is needed to be
maintained, the required number of personnel for maintenance services can vary. In
order to define the performance of technician distribution at the appropriate levels
of responsibility for the energy hub, firstly the number and type of wind turbines to
which the energy hub can offer services is confined to 100 units of large scale
10 MW wind turbine generator (WTG). After consultation with technical expertise
from offshore O&M sectors and learning from other experiences, the following
rule-of-thumb assumptions are made within this concept:
Service Technicians
Based on estimated failure rates of the wind turbines, regular maintenance service,
special oil and coolant changes, average transfer and waiting times, the required
number of service technicians can be assumed as follow:
Service technicians = round (0.18 * number of WT to maintain)
This depends strongly on the type of turbine as well as on the maintenance
regulations given by the wind turbine manufacturer. Other factors are the local
environmental conditions (weather and waves) and the wind farm design, especially
the contour of the field, the position of the O&M hub in the field and the distances
between the turbines.
Crew Transfer Vessel (CTV) Crews
Depending on the assumed number of 100 wind turbines one CTV should be
sufficient for transportation of personnel and normal maintenance equipment
between the energy hub and the wind farm. The number of crew members is set to 3
persons.
CTV boat crew = round (3 * number of service technicians/10)
Office Crew
The office crew has to organize all service and maintenance tasks on site, the
material flow and also the communication for technical issues.
Office crew = round (number of service technicians/10)
Board and Lodging (B&L) Staff
The B&L staff has to guarantee the supply of food, clean linen and work clothes for
all persons living on the hub. They are also responsible for housekeeping such as
routines in kitchen and canteen, laundry as well as for firefighting. The minimum
team size is 3 persons; one extra staff member is needed for each additional seven
persons on the hub.
Board and lodging staff = 3 + round (number of (service technicians + ship
crew + office workers)/7)
All industrial personnel are accommodated on board. However, daily working
hours and day off for each personnel depend mainly on the region of operation. For
instance, maximum continuous stay of 2 weeks is allowed for a crew who works
more than 10 h per day according to the German offshore working time regulations
(Offshore-ArbZV). Therefore, a total of 12 h daily working hours, which includes
592 F. Adam et al.
2 h for crew transfer and waiting time for the service technicians, with a maximum
stay of 14 days was assumed.
Accordingly, the number of personnel complements for the energy hub at the
Mediterranean Sea site are described in Table 2. A total of approximately 32
persons is needed to provide preventive maintenance of 100 wind turbines.
The amount of operating days increases in south European regions. The weather
conditions in these regions allow a nearly continuous operation of the O&M hub
throughout the year. Therefore, there is no difference in the number of required
persons between summer and winter at the Mediterranean Sea site.
The energy hub comprises multiple functions and the available areas are optimized
to ensure an efficient co-use of space and deliver maximum performance in an
integrated way. The configuration of the energy hub is a square shape 2-story
building supported by four steel columns. These columns will provide the stability
and secure the building against extreme waves. They will hoist two lifts, two
staircases and all supply lines for electricity, water and others. The high flexibility,
modularity and structural integrity allow downsizing or upsizing of accommodation
module over time. For example, in the case of larger accommodation complexes, it
can be stacked to form a multi-storey building supplemented by coffee shops, gym
etc.
In order to get the best possible efficiency, the quantity of space in terms of floor
area is calculated as a starting point. Thereby the accommodation building was
designed to meet a compromise between the architectural and engineering demands
and ensure compliance with several standards and guidelines. The number of users,
duration of stay and the minimum necessary space for the respective functions are
properly considered. After making a benefit analysis, it is assumed an area of
approximately 1242 m2 will accommodate comfortably around 32 persons and
other necessary functions for the energy hub, supplemented by conference room
and green spaces.
The storage hall has an edge length of 30 m and this leaves a clear working deck
of 7.5 m width on each side for cargo handling operations and safe walk way at the
quay. Thus, overall area planning contributes a high ratio of usable area to gross
built area.
Space distribution for the accommodation area was done under consideration of
ergonomic issues for the users and all activities, which will be carried out on the
hub. Here, spaces with similar functions are segregated to be in proximity to each
other. For instance, food sectors such as kitchen and dining rooms are close to the
galley on the same floor. Moreover, noise emission is an important factor to ensure
a comfortable stay. Therefore, an adequate buffer zone is designed for corridors in
the accommodation areas and cabins are not located directly adjacent to high-noise
induced rooms like galley. Each cabin is furnished with its respective bed, mattress,
working desk, lockable storage space for personal belongings, shower and toilet
and is designed to provide enough comfort and adequate span for planned overstay.
Thus, the total area planning can be seen in Table 3.
The Energyhub@Sea is designed in such a way that about 32 service staff can stay
on the accommodation module for at least 30 days without any outside support.
Obviously, the energy demand for such a manned hub is high since several factors
and activities which magnify daily power usage must be taken into account. For
instance, regular heating and cooling of compartments will be required to provide
the minimum temperature of about 18 °C in the storage hall and about 20 °C in the
accommodation building. The main source of energy consumption for the
Mediterranean Sea is temperature adjustment in summer, whereby air conditionings
are necessary to ensure all personnel have a comfortable stay and working envi-
ronment. In this case, uncontrolled outside air leakage into the energy hub can cause
a large amount of energy loss. The ventilation has to be optimized in terms of
energy saving by using heat exchangers and controlled air flow.
Table 4 summarize the estimated annual power demand of the energy hub in
winter and summer for the Mediterranean Sea site. Under energy consumers all
appliances which needs access to energy resources are considered and assumptions
were made.
A stable power supply is vital for the O&M hub for continuous operation. The
energy supply in Energyhub@Sea will focus on renewable energies such as wind,
wave and solar power. Energy from these resources will be harvested, and these
energies will be supplied for entire on-site applications. All these resources strongly
depend on weather and climate conditions and their power production peaks and
valleys are not always concurrent. This means, a storage system must be included
and need to be big enough to balance energy demand and energy supply during low
energy production and high energy demand.
In order to harvest energy from wind, a medium sized wind turbine was designed as
robust solution for on- and off-grid-applications with relatively low demands of
electrical energy like secluded villages. Figure 4 shows the so-called CART turbine
mounted on one of the 45 45 m Space@Sea-floater.
The turbine is a gearless two blade device with stall-regulation and variable
rotation speed. Owing to this, the delivered capacity can be regulated as desired.
The rotor has a diameter of 28 m. For a stand-alone CART-device the hub height
was chosen to be 35 m above mean sea level (MSL). This leads to a tower height of
around 30 m. The turbines nominal capacity is 125 kW and its predicted lifetime is
25 years. For the Mediterranean Sea site, the calculated annual yield of the wind
turbine lies about 605 MWh/a, which is equivalent to 4,840 full load hours.
This enormous production rates are caused by the layout of the used wind
turbine, which is designed for a high energy production even in low winds and the
high wind availability, which is typical for offshore sites.
During the ongoing design process, it was decided that the planned wave energy
converter (WEC) should consist of an additional smaller floater instead of har-
vesting energy from relative motions between the regular modules. This step was
taken in order to adjust the WEC to the wave conditions at the proposed locations.
By analysing the wave conditions at the two locations, it was determined that the
5 Conclusions
In this paper, the basic design of the energy hub was described for the
Mediterranean Sea site. The design process involved a variety of factors different
from those customarily designed. The energy hub was equipped with four main
functions such as O&M services for offshore wind parks, permanent accommo-
dation facilities for service staffs, renewable energy extraction and housing of spare
parts and equipment, enabling the platform to perform maintenance of offshore
gearless wind turbines with a capacity of up to 10 MW.
Acknowledgements This project is funded by the Horizon 2020 research and innovation pro-
gram of the European Union, under the grant agreement no. 774253.
References
1. Fernandez RP, Pardo ML (2013) Offshore concrete structures. Ocean Eng 58:304–316
2. Hahn B, Durstewitz M, Rohrig K (2007) Reliability of wind turbines. In: Wind energy.
Springer, Heidelberg, pp 329–332
3. Nianxin R, Chi Z, Allan RM, Øyvind H, Jian D, Kok KA (2019) Hydrodynamic analysis of a
modular multi-purpose floating structure system with different outermost connector types.
J Ocean Eng 176:158–168
4. Pérez R, Lamas M, Carral LM (2012) Classification and damage stability of flotel ships. J Marit
Res 9(1):33–38
Design and Construction of the Large
Concrete Floating Pier at Incheon
Harbor
Abstract There are two 200 m long floating piers for berthing car ferries at
Incheon harbor, South Korea. Each floating pier has almost same dimensions but
these piers are made of steel and concrete, respectively. This paper focus on the
design and construction of a concrete floating pier. In the design, it was proposed as
an alternative instead of a steel floating pier having two inner moorings and sep-
arated three parts (L: 66 m 3 ea). So it was composed of only one structure (L:
200 m) without inner mooring dolphins, not only to maximize the use of top-side
space but also to minimize the number of mooring dolphins. In the construction, the
modular construction method fabricating concrete segments on land and assembling
them as modules on the seawater was applied instead of the conventional method
using a big floating dock not only to increase the construction efficiency but also to
enhance the concrete quality of modules.
1 Introduction
Figure 1 shows the design concept for two T-shape floating piers used for both sides
berthing 30,000 ton class car-ferry ships (L: 196 m W: 27 m) having 6.7 m draft.
Basically, each floating pier has floating bodies composed of a sub module (L:
200 m W: 30 m) and a main module (L: 85 m W: 30 m), and several mooring
dolphins as a station keeping system. However, the number of dolphins and sub
modules are different. The conventional concept for the steel floating pier was
composed of three sub module parts (L: 66 m 3 ea) and total six mooring dol-
phins including two inner dolphins shown in Fig. 2. But the applied design for the
concrete floating pier proposed only one sub module (L: 200 m 1 ea) without two
inner dolphins in order to fully utilize topside space. So it has total four mooring
dolphins, and the width of a main module can be extended as 39 m because it has no
gaps between sub module parts like the steel floating pier. To provide suitable
freeboard for berthing a car-ferry ship, about 2 m, the steel and concrete floating
piers are required to have 2.9 m and 5.0 m of total height, respectively, as the
concrete floating pier has heavy self-weight and high stiffness compared to the steel
floating pier. Finally, it can be summarized that the main design concept of the
concrete floating pier is not only to maximize the use of topside space but also to
minimize the number of mooring dolphins.
Figure 2 presents operational plans for these floating piers by tidal levels. They
are connected to the land by access bridges (L: 60 m) having hinge supports on the
land and roller supports on the main module. When the tidal level goes up to the
maximum level, the sub and main modules move up together and access bridges
reach at the flat level with modules. On the other hand, when the tidal level goes
down to the minimum level, the sub and main modules move down together and
access bridges are inclined as shown in Fig. 2.
Design and Construction of the Large Concrete Floating Pier … 601
Figure 3 presents the applied systems in this design for free up-down movement.
In order to safely go up and down by tidal levels, special devices such as rubber
rollers, frictionless pads can reduce the friction between dolphins and modules can
be considered. In case of the concrete floating pier, frictionless pads are attached on
the surfaces of the concrete dolphins as shown in Fig. 3(a). And the roller systems
of access bridges go forward and backward by up-down movement of floating pier
as shown in Fig. 3(b). At the same time, the hinge systems on the land are rotated
so that whole floating pier can be safely inclined.
The environmental conditions such as wave, current and wind can be directly
related to the stability and safety of a floating structure. Table 1 shows the
602 K. H. Jung et al.
applied. Finally, bollard forces and berthing forces by 30,000 ton class car-ferry
ships are regarded as an essential design load. Based on these design loads, all
possible load combinations in the ultimate and service limit states were considered.
It was a big issue how to efficiently fabricate and safely install this huge concrete
floating structure. It was estimated that self-weights of main and sub modules are
approximately 18,000 ton and 9,000 ton, respectively. Conventionally, the con-
struction method using a large floating dock having 50,000 ton class capacity (W:
51.5 m L: 298 m) was decided. Figure 5 shows the construction steps of this
method. The 200 m long sub module is composed of 5 segments (L: 40 m) because
concrete works cannot be done in one time. In the first step, Seg. 1 is initially
fabricated on this floating dock, and then two segments (Seg. 2 and 3) at both sides
of Seg. 1 are also fabricated together. And the second step, these three segments are
longitudinally prestressed (1st prestressing). And the third step, last segments (Seg.
4 and 5) at both sides of Seg. 2 and 3 are fabricated and total five segments are
longitudinally prestressed (2nd prestressing). In the last fourth step, the concrete sub
module is launched using this floating dock on the sea and installed at the desti-
nation. If this unique equipment, a large floating dock, were available at the
required period, it was regarded that it would be as a reasonable and safe con-
struction method.
604 K. H. Jung et al.
In the real construction, the conventional construction method was invalid because
the 50,000 ton class floating dock was not available during the required period and
concrete quality control on that was not easy in the restricted working area. Finally,
this modular construction method using a floating crane having 3,600 ton capacity
was developed and applied in this project. It can be explained that all segments
were fabricated on the land, lifted by this floating crane, connected on the sea, and
installed by tug boats.
Figure 6 shows the construction steps of this modular construction method. The
200 m long sub module is composed of 6 segments (L: 33 m) because the
dimensions and weight of each segment should be in accordance with the floating
crane capacity. In the first step, each segment was fabricated on the land at the same
time and respectively prestressed. Each segment has connection holes for PS bars as
well as longitudinal tendons to assemble with neighbor segments. The second step,
all segments are lifted and launched by the floating crane one by one. The third step,
all segments were connected each other by PS pars on the sea to make a 200 m long
sub module. In the last fourth step, this concrete sub module was towed and
installed by tug boats. Although segment connections on the sea are not easy, but it
was regarded as an alternative method because it can reduce the construction time
and enhance concrete quality.
Design and Construction of the Large Concrete Floating Pier … 605
Figure 7 shows the plan view of the concrete floating pier composed of main and
sub modules, access bridges, and concrete mooring dolphins. Applying the modular
construction method, the main module comprises three segments and the sub
module comprises six segments as due to the capacity limit of the floating crane,
3,600 ton, for lifting and launching. So the weight of each segment is approxi-
mately 3,200 ton to fully utilize this lifting capacity.
Figure 8 are photos taken by a drone during main and sub module installation.
Those photos show the fabrication yard for making segments and a floating crane in
the project site. Figure 9 shows the main module connections. When one segment
(M1) of main module is installed at the mooring dolphin and hanging by the
floating crane through the lifting device, another segment (M2) is towed by tug
boats at the proper position to connect each other.
The construction method for this large floating structure was a critical issue,
because it can be directly affected to construction period and cost. Table 2 presents
the comparison of two construction methods (conventional vs. modular). In view of
equipment use, the conventional method is required to use a big floating dock
(50,000 ton) for six month as all segments are fabricated on it at one time, but the
modular method is required to bring a floating crane (3,600 ton) for only one month
because all segments are made on fabrication yard utilizing project site. In view of
workability for segment fabrication and concrete quality control, it can be said that
the modular method is better than the conventional method because all segments are
made on land at the same time and it can provide enough space for workers and
fabrication devices. However, in view of works on the sea, it can be explained that
the conventional method is better than modular method because it can reduce sea
works such as ballasting and segment connections by prestressing bars.
Finally, it was thought that the modular construction method is better than the
conventional construction method judging from fabrication efficiency and concrete
quality control as well as construction cost and period, but it is required very careful
construction control to safely connect segments on the sea. Figure 10 shows the
200 m long concrete floating piers at Incheon harbor completed in the end of 2018.
4 Conclusions
This paper illustrated on the design considerations and construction methods for the
200 m long concrete floating pier. In the design, not only to maximize the use of
topside space but also to minimize the number of mooring dolphins, only one
concrete structure (L: 200 m) without inner mooring dolphins was proposed as an
608 K. H. Jung et al.
alternative instead of a steel floating pier having two inner moorings and separated
three parts (L: 66 m 3 ea). In the construction, not only to increase the con-
struction efficiency but also to enhance the concrete quality of modules, the modular
construction method fabricating concrete segments on land and assembling them as
modules on the seawater was applied instead of the conventional method using a
big floating dock (50,000 ton).
References
1. Jung KH, Lee SH, Kim HS, Kang S (2019) Design and construction of the concrete floating
pier in Golden harbor, Incheon. In: Proceedings of world conference on floating solutions
(WCFS 2019), Singapore
2. Kang S, Jung KH, Lee SH, Kim HS, Choi YH (2018) Modular construction method for
concrete floating quay at Incheon harbor. In: Proceedings of the 25th Australian conference on
mechanics of structures and materials (ACMSM25), Brisbane, Australia
3. Kang S, Wang X, Jung KH (2017) Study of pontoon-type very large floating structure (VLFS)
supported with dolphin mooring system. In: Proceedings of Singapore maritime technology
conference (SMTC2017), Singapore
4. Kang S, Wang X, Jung KH (2017) Motion reduced floating response of very large structure
under wave loads. In: Proceedings of Korean concrete institute conference, Seoul, Korea
5. Hyundai Engineering and Construction (2016) Design Report on Incheon Port Passenger
Terminal. Incheon Port Authority Institute, South Korea
Structures Under Extreme Loadings
Fused Bridge Structures for Higher
Impact Resistance
Y. F. Wu (&)
School of Engineering, RMIT University, Melbourne, VIC 3001, Australia
e-mail: yufei.wu@rmit.edu.au
Y. W. Zhou B. Hu X. X. Huang
Guangdong Provincial Key Laboratory of Durability for Marine Civil Engineering, Shenzhen
University, Shenzhen, China
e-mail: ywzhou@szu.edu.cn
B. Hu
e-mail: biaohu3-c@szu.edu.cn
X. X. Huang
e-mail: xxhruby@szu.edu.cn
S. T. Smith
School of Environment, Science and Engineering, Southern Cross University,
Lismore, NSW 2480, Australia
e-mail: scott.smith@scu.edu.au
1 Introduction
has been found so far [8]. The only solution recommended by ACI 440.1R [2] for
the ductility problem of FRP RC structures is to design for higher strength reserve
or to over-design the member. However, over-design is not only uneconomical but
also impractical or impossible in many cases. Therefore, conventional structural
technologies cannot provide a solution to this ductility problem. Leading authorities
have long pointed out that “unless ductility requirements are satisfied, FRP mate-
rials cannot be used reliably in structural engineering applications” [8]. This critical
problem has been ignored by the research community so far. As a result, there is
little progress in the practical use of FRP bars to replace steel bars in the con-
struction of structures.
Fig. 2 Properties of
materials
As the structures containing a fuse fail in a safer manner, the safety factors or failure
probability used for the design of structures containing a fuse should be different
from conventional RC structures. Neglecting maintenance, demolition and associ-
ated indirect costs, the total cost of a structure Ct can be viewed as the product of
failure probability Pf and failure cost Cf plus the initial cost [9]:
Ct ¼ Ci þ Pf Cf ð1Þ
Pf ¼ c expðb=dÞ ð3Þ
Equation (4) consists of two parts that are both functions of b, which is quali-
tatively depicted in Fig. 4. The first part is an increasing function of b, whereas the
second part is a decreasing one. It is evident that an optimum design can be
achieved by adopting a certain value of b that minimizes the total cost Ct. This
optimal value of b is the target reliability index bT (Fig. 4).
As the adoption of a fuse should not significantly increase construction costs, the
first part of Eq. (4) is considered the same for both conventional and fused struc-
tures. The failure of a fused structure is simply the replacement of fuse. Therefore,
the cost of failure, or the second part of Eq. (4) is much smaller for a fused structure
(Fig. 4). Figure 4 shows that at bT, both the first and second parts are smaller for
fused structures. Meanwhile, a fused structure achieves a lower cost if the same b as
that for conventional structures is adopted (Fig. 4), which demonstrates the eco-
nomic advantage of fused structures.
Normally, bT is provided by codes and may differ in different codes. In China, bT
at the ultimate limit state under a 50-year period is determined by considering both
safety measures and failure modes [4], as summarized in Table 1. Since the use of
fuse can prevent dangerous failure modes and minimize losses, RC structures
containing a fuse can have a smaller design reliability index b.
616 Y. F. Wu et al.
β
β too small, underdesign βT2 βT1 β too large, overdesign
Table 1 Target reliability index bT at ultimate state of structures under 50-year period
Structural class Consequences of failure Target reliability index bT
Ductile failure Brittle failure
Class I High 3.7 4.2
Class II Medium 3.2 3.7
Class III Low 2.7 3.2
Roughened interface
Compared with normal RC beams, the flexural behavior of fused beams involved
three more variables, namely, height and width ratios of the CY block η and a,
reinforcement ratio qf, and four variables related to the material properties of the
CY block (Fig. 6) that include the relative yield strength fb/fc (where, fb and fc are
the yielding strength of the CY block and concrete strength), yield strain eby,
ultimate strain ebu, and strain hardening/softening modulus ratio n.
A performance-based design methodology that explicitly and quantitatively
addresses the ductility and strength requirements of the fused beams has been
developed [16]. As a certain requirement can be fulfilled by different designs with
different dimensions and material properties of the CY block, the method provides
an optimal design approach that delivers the maximum possible ductility with a
minimum CY block. To facilitate convenient use by engineers, the optimal design
approach is criterion-based to avoid numerical iteration.
As the displacement ductility is directly related to curvature ductility [13], the
optimal solution can be found in two steps. Firstly, the optimal curvature ductility is
found (i.e. determine a set of values for n, fb and η at which the optimal curvature,
l/, is achieved). Secondly, the plastic hinge length ratio, a, from Eq. (5) [16] is
determined.
the failure of the CY block at e = ebu occurs simultaneously at the onset of the
maximum allowable RMD = dd. The optimal ductility can mathematically be
expressed as
where Mmin = the failure moment which can be determined according to key fea-
tures of the moment-curvature curve [16]; and Mm = the peak moment of the fused
beam. The determination of Mmin can be found in the work by Wu et al. [16].
Besides the ductility requirement, the CY beam has to meet the following
strength requirement
Mm Md ð7Þ
4 Application
Longitudinal Arch
beam
l=2
Truss 2m
4m
b=
T
y
Fx
x
Fy
The equation for the appropriate arch axis of the footbridge is determined so that
the arch is only under compression along its axis. This gives the following
relationship
4f ðlx x2 Þ
y¼ ð8Þ
l2
According to GB50068 [4], the live load qL = 5 kN/m2. The total weight of the
footbridge is estimated to be 9000 kg, thus qD = 1 kN/m2. Equilibrium leads to
Fx
TðxÞ ¼ ð9Þ
cosðarctanðdy=dxÞÞ
qL bl2 qD bl2
Fx ¼ þ ð10Þ
16f 16f
where T(x) = the compression force along arch axis; Fx = the horizontal force;
b and l = the width and span of the bridge, respectively (Fig. 8).
The load and resistance factor design (LFRD) is used for reliability-based
design. Based on ACI318 [1] and given that the live and dead loads dominate the
design, the LFRD expression under ultimate limit state can be expressed as:
620 Y. F. Wu et al.
qD bl2 =ð16f Þ
Dn ¼ ð12Þ
cosðarctanðdy=dxÞÞ
qL bl2 =ð16f Þ
Ln ¼ ð13Þ
cosðarctanðdy=dxÞÞ
The limit state function of this case can be represented by the following
equation:
Z ¼RDL ð14Þ
in which R, D and L = random variables for resistance, dead load effect and live
load effect, respectively. In reliability analysis, failure occurs if Z < 0. That is, the
combined load effect (D + L) is larger than the resistance (R). Therefore, the failure
probability Pf can be expressed as [10]
ZZZ
Pf ¼ PrðR D L\0Þ ¼ fR ðRÞfD ðDÞfL ðLÞdRdDdL ¼ 1 UðbÞ ð15Þ
RDL\0
where fR(R), fD(D) and fL(L) = the probability density functions for R, D and L;
U = the cumulative distribution function of standard normal distribution; and
b = the reliability index.
The resistance (R) is assumed to follow a lognormal distribution with the mean
value equal to the nominal value Rn = (1.2Dn+ 1.6Ln)// based on Eq. (11). The
coefficient of variation (COV) equals to 0.1 GB 50068 [4]. The dead load effect
(D) follows a normal distribution with the mean value and COV to be 1.05 times of
the nominal value Dn and 0.1, respectively [3]. The live load effect (L) follows an
extreme value distribution (type I) with the mean value and COV being the nominal
value Ln and 0.25, respectively [3].
Based on the stochastic information mentioned above, the probability density
functions fR(R), fD(D) and fL(L) can be developed. In the following reliability
analysis, resistance factor / ranging from 0.7 to 1.0 with a step size of 0.025 are
considered. Since the nominal values for Dn and Ln are known, for a given value of
/, the nominal value Rn is given by Eq. (11). Therefore, the reliability index in
Eq. (15) can be evaluated by either a Monte Carlo Simulation or First Order
Reliability Method [5] using the probability density function fR(R), fD(D) and fL(L).
Fused Bridge Structures for Higher Impact Resistance 621
The relationship between the resistance reduction factor / and reliability index b is
thus obtained by repeating this process for each /, as shown in Fig. 10.
According to Table 1, bT can be 3.7 for a fused structure and 4.2 for a con-
ventional structure. Their corresponding resistance reduction factor / can be
obtained based on linear regression, which is 0.87 and 0.8, respectively, as illus-
trated in Fig. 10. That means / for a structure containing a fuse is larger than a
conventional structure, which indicates that the initial cost of materials can be
reduced. In addition, for the arch with the fuse, the failure cost is simply the
replacement of the fuse and hence significantly lower than that of the arch without a
fuse.
5 Impact Resistance
The fused structure can tolerate much larger deformation without significant loss of
load - carrying capacity (Fig. 3). The structural system is superior to impact loading
from an energy dissipation point of view. The CY beam is directly applicable to
bridge construction where more economical design can be achieved for bridge
beams under vertical impact loading from vehicles. The CY concept can also be
applied to other impact resistant structures, e.g. the CY material (Fig. 3(a)) can be
used as shock absorber to reduce impact force to structures.
6 Conclusions
The inclusion of fuse can change the failure mode of a structure into a safer one and
thus reduce the consequences of structural failure. This leads to a smaller safety
margin in design and reduced costs of construction. Such advantages of fused
622 Y. F. Wu et al.
structures are more significant for structures under impact loadings. Although this
work is based on structures with CY fuses, the design philosophy is general and
applicable to different structures containing different fuses.
The design reliability index or capacity reduction factor of fused structures
should be different from those recommended by current design codes which are
based on the failure consequences of conventional structures. A reliability-based
approach is presented in this work to derive the capacity reduction factor for the
design of an arch bridge. Saving in structural cost is made from the larger value of
capacity reduction factor for the fused structure. Different fused structures require
different design parameters that can be developed using the reliability-based
approaches.
It is noted that the cost reduction from the above method comes only from the
change of failure mode. No reduction in the partial safety factors for loading is
considered. As overloading is prevented by the use of fuse in structures. Further
reduction in structural cost can be achieved when a reduction in the safety margin
of loading is considered.
References
1. ACI 318-14 (2014) Building code requirements for structural concrete and commentary. ACI,
Farmington Hills, MI, USA
2. ACI 440.1R-15 (2015) Guide for the design and construction of structural concrete reinforced
with fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) bars. ACI, Farmington Hills, MI, USA
3. Galambos TV, Ellingwood B, MacGregor JG, Cornell CA (1982) Probability based load
criteria: assessment of current design practice. J Struct Div 108:959–977
4. GB50068 (2001) Unified standard for reliability design of building structures. China Building
Industry Press, Beijing (in Chinese)
5. Huang X, Chen J, Zhu H (2016) Assessing small failure probabilities by AK-SS: an active
learning method combining kriging and subset simulation. Struct Saf 59:86–95
6. Melchers RE (2007) Structural reliability theory in the context of structural safety. Civ Eng
Environ Syst 24(1):55–69
7. Melchers RE, Beck AT (2017) Structural reliability analysis and prediction. Wiley, New York
8. Naaman A (2003) FRP reinforcements in structural concrete: assessment, progress and
prospects. In: Tan KH (ed) Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Reinforcement for Concrete Structures,
FRPRCS-6. World Scientific, Singapore, pp 3–24
9. Nowak AS, Collins KR (2000) Reliability of structures. McGraw-Hill Inc, New York
10. Rubinstein RY, Kroese DP (2016) Simulation and the Monte Carlo method. Wiley, New York
11. Schossig W (2007) Introduction to the history of selective protection. PAC Mag 70–74
12. Shoeibi S, Ali Kafi M, Gholhaki M (2017) New performance-based seismic design method
for structures with structural fuse system. Eng Struct 132:745–760
13. Wu YF (2008) Ductility demand of compression yielding fiber-reinforced polymer-reinforced
concrete beams. ACI Struct J 105(1):104–110
14. Wu YF, Jiang JF, Liu K (2010) Perforated SIFCON blocks-An extraordinarily ductile
material ideal for use in compression yielding structural systems. Constr Build Mater 24
(12):2454–2465
15. Wu YF, Zhou YW (2011) Controlling the damage of concrete columns through compression
yielding. Struct Control Health Monit 18(8):890–907
Fused Bridge Structures for Higher Impact Resistance 623
Keywords Bio-inspired Porcupine quill Cellular structures Computational
geometry Protective structures
1 Introduction
Cellular structures have shown potential in absorbing energy, which makes them
attractive for mitigating the effects of impulsive loads. Honeycomb and re-entrant
geometries, which have been extensively investigated by researchers, are prone to
premature buckling and collapse in the vicinity of the loading. In effect, this
behaviour may amplify the reaction forces on the protected target [1, 2]. Porcupines
have evolved their light protective systems over many years for mitigating predator
attacks. Porcupine quills are light and absorb significant energy, and mimicking
their structural features can lead to the development of a superior system for pro-
tecting structures against impulsive loads.
Porcupines exist in several species that typically inhabit North-Africa, Europe,
Asia and America. Quills are the key feature that protects the porcupine from
predator attacks, which are assembled to form a protective system. They are
needle-like hairs that are arranged such that they form a dense outer shell (cortex)
and a foam-like core [3]. Researchers have expended efforts to uncover the superior
resistance of the quill to bending and buckling. Torres et al. [4] tested a Amazonian
porcupine quill in axial compression, some samples with the core intact and others
with the core removed. They observed that delamination between the layers of the
cortex had a prominent effect on lowering the buckling stress. Yang et al. [5]
conducted similar experiments and reported that the soft foam core was responsible
for increasing the buckling strength of the quill.
This study mimics several features of the porcupine quill and investigates their
influence on mitigating blast loads. To this effect, a finite element model of a
quill-like cellular structure is developed, and its efficacy is investigated in terms of
its total dissipated energy and the reaction forces transmitted to the target. The
model is benchmarked against existing cellular structures investigated in the liter-
ature, namely honeycomb and re-entrant.
2 Numerical Model
Several structures are investigated as shown in Fig. 1, which mimic the concave
and convex cell geometries, and the stiffeners or bracing observed in the porcupine
quill. These designs can simply be obtained by modifying the pentagonal structure
(Fig. 1b). Manipulating these designs can also result in other unit cells such as the
re-entrant structure shown in Fig. 1e. The hexagonal (Fig. 1a) and the re-entrant
configurations (Fig. 1e) were chosen as the benchmark cases for assessing the
performance of the bio-inspired quill-like cellular structures shown in Fig. 1b–d
[1, 2, 6, 7]. The re-entrant configuration has a longer cell wall angle, which thereby
Performance of Bio-mimetic Cellular Structures … 627
leads to an increase in mass, which in turn increases its effective length [1]. These
unit cells are assembled and meshed to develop the baseline design as shown in
Fig. 2.
Where: A represents the yield stress; 2 is the equivalent plastic strain; B and n
account for the effects of strain hardening; 2_ ¼ 2=
_ 2_ 0 is the dimensionless strain
_ 1
rate for the reference strain rate 20 ¼ 0:001 s ; the constant C is obtained from
experiment (tension, torsion, etc.); and the temperature Tm is ignored, assuming
isothermal conditions. The material employed in this work is armour graded alu-
minium (AA5083-H116), with the properties listed in Table 1.
Fig. 1 a Different unit cell arrangements that mimic the porcupine quill: a Hexagonal;
b Pentagonal; c Hybrid quad-hexagonal; d Oriented hexagonal; e Re-entrant unit cell
628 A. Ghazlan et al.
3.5
60
20
20
60
Fig. 2 The meshed bio-mimetic cellular structure (mesh density of 0.5 mm) obtained from the
oriented hexagonal design. The unit cell is also shown with simplified design parameters extracted
from some of the structural features of the porcupine quill
The model (Fig. 2) is clamped at the base and subjected to a TNT charge of weight
W ¼ 0:1 kg at a stand-off distance of R ¼ 0:1 m from the front face of the load
transfer plate (see Fig. 3). These blast parameters were to chosen to ensure adequate
deformation of the structure. The reflected blast pressure history is plotted in Fig. 3
below. The Conventional Weapons Effects (CONWEP) program, which determines
the air blast parameters based on empirical data from explosive tests conducted by
Kingery and Bulmash was used to generate the blast pressure profile [9, 10]. This
model is also adopted in the Unified Facilities Criteria (UFC 3-340-02) in graphical
form for designing structures to resist explosions [11]. The blast pressure profile is
modelled using the modified Friedlander equation, which is representative of an
exponentially decaying pressure as follows:
Performance of Bio-mimetic Cellular Structures … 629
Fig. 3 Reflected blast pressure history at the center of the blast face
Fig. 4 Convergence study on the hexagonal structure using the resultant reaction force, which is
indicated by R
t bt
Ps ðtÞ ¼ Ps0 1 e td ð2Þ
t0
Where Ps0 is the peak overpressure; td is the positive phase duration of the
impulse; t is the time and b is the blast waveform parameter, which typically varies
with standoff distance.
A convergence study was conducted on the hexagonal unit cell (Fig. 1a) model
using the reaction force as shown in Fig. 3, with mesh densities of 1, 0.5 and
0.25 mm. It The peak compressive and uplift reaction forces were captured for all
three cases. For the case with a mesh density of 1 mm, intermediate jumps in the
reaction force are observed due to the increased stiffness of the structure. The model
with a mesh size of 0.5 mm was thereby chosen to proceed with this study (Fig. 4).
630 A. Ghazlan et al.
The baseline model was adapted to mimic the stiffener concept adopted in the
porcupine quill to safeguard certain regions of the bio-mimetic structure from
buckling. Design 4 was used for this study, with upper and lower sub-cell wall
angles of a = 25° and b = 45°, respectively as shown in Fig. 5. It can be observed
that the collapse mechanisms between this structure (with and without bracing)
whereby densification occurs in the same regions. However, the bracing (0:5 mm
thick) slightly stiffens the structure such that the braced walls of the lower sub-cells
do not completely collapse. This, in effect, slightly increases the peak initial
reaction force but not to the point where it exceeds that of the re-entrant configu-
ration. Furthermore, it can also be observed that the subsequent spike in the reaction
force was also reduced at t ¼ 350 ls but an earlier spike at t ¼ 150 ls was
developed due to the additional stiffness provided by the bracing. Hence, the
sub-cell wall angles and the bracing thickness should be tuned to obtain the optimal
structural performance. Regardless, the braced bio-mimetic structure outperforms
the re-entrant structure in terms of reducing the peak initial reaction force where the
blast impulse is prominent (around t ¼ 50 ls) and reducing the subsequent peak
reaction force experienced by the structure. It is important to note that introducing
bracing in the lower sub-cells did not add significant mass to the structure, and the
Fig. 5 Comparing the collapse mechanisms of the oriented hexagonal structure (design 4 with
a ¼ 25 ; b ¼ 45 ) when bracing (0:5 mm thick) is introduced into the lower sub-cell with the
re-entrant structure (design 5)
Performance of Bio-mimetic Cellular Structures … 631
mass of the re-entrant structure is still 14% higher than that of the bio-mimetic
structure (Fig. 6 and Table 2).
For completeness, the energy dissipated between the braced bio-mimetic struc-
ture (design 4) is also compared with the benchmark re-entrant structure. By
observing the collapsed configurations in Fig. 5, it is evident that the bio-mimetic
structure outperforms the re-entrant structure because its design facilitates a better
distribution of plastic deformation, whereas the deformation in the re-entrant
structure is highly localised. This is a prominent result, particularly given that the
re-entrant structure with the same number of unit cells is still heavier than the
bio-mimetic structure by approximately 14% (Fig. 7).
Design 4 Design 5
Fig. 6 The effect of introducing bracing (0:5 mm thick) into the lower sub-cell of the oriented
hexagonal structure (design 4 with a ¼ 25 ; b ¼ 45 ) on the reaction force compared to the
re-entrant structure (design 5)
Table 2 Summary of the peak reaction forces observed when introducing bracing (0:5 mm thick)
to the lower sub-cell of the oriented hexagonal structure (design 4 with a ¼ 25 ; b ¼ 45 ). The
peak reaction forces for the re-entrant structure are shown for comparison
Design Mass Upper/lower cell wall Peak initial reaction Peak Spike in
(g) angle (a=bÞ force (kN) reaction force (kN)
Design 4 14.8 63 =63 3.7 3.2
Design 4 15.6 25 =45 1.5 2.8
Design 4 15.9 25 =45 =LB0:5 mm 1.6 2.2
Re-entrant 18.2 N/A 1.9 2.4
632 A. Ghazlan et al.
Design 4 Design 5
Fig. 7 The effect of introducing bracing (0:5 mm thick) into the lower sub-cell of the oriented
hexagonal structure (design 4 with a ¼ 25 ; b ¼ 45 ) on the dissipated energy compared to the
re-entrant structure (design 5)
4 Conclusion
This research mimicked several structural features that were identified in the cel-
lular structure of the porcupine quill, namely the concavity and convexity of the cell
geometries, and the stiffeners/bracing in critical regions where the stresses are most
prominent. To this effect, several periodic bio-mimetic designs were generated with
easily tunable design parameters, and their performance was benchmarked against
hexagonal and re-entrant structures, which have been extensively investigated in the
literature. The re-entrant design ended up being the benchmark case because it
outperformed the biomimetic structures in terms of alleviating the reaction force
transmitted to the base through its collapse mechanism. The bio-mimetic structure
shown significant potential as a protective system due to its higher energy dissi-
pation capability and lower reaction force transmitted to the protected structure.
References
1. Imbalzano G, Ngo T, Tran P (2015) A numerical study of auxetic composite panels under
blast loadings. Compos Struct 135:339–352
2. Imbalzano G, Tran P, Ngo T, Lee PV (2015) Three-dimensional modelling of auxetic
sandwich panels for localised impact resistance. J Sandwich Struct Mater 1-26
3. Chou SF, Overfelt RA (2011) Tensile deformation and failure of North American porcupine
quills. Mater Sci EngC 31:1729–1736
4. Torres FG, Troncoso OP, Diaz J, Arce D (2014) Failure analysis of porcupine quills under
axial compression reveals their mechanical response during buckling. J Mech Behav Biomed
Mater 39:111–118
5. Yang W, McKittrick J (2013) Separating the influence of the cortex and foam on the
mechanical properties of porcupine quills. Acta Biomater 9:9065–9074
Performance of Bio-mimetic Cellular Structures … 633
6. Qi C, Remennikov A, Pei LZ, Yang S, Yu ZH, Ngo TD (2017) Impact and close-in blast
response of auxetic honeycomb-cored sandwich panels: experimental tests and numerical
simulations. Compos Struct 180:161–178
7. Imbalzano G, Linforth S, Ngo TD, Lee PVS, Tran P (2018) Blast resistance of auxetic and
honeycomb sandwich panels: comparisons and parametric designs. Compos Struct 183:242–
261
8. Johnson GR, Cook WH (1983) A constitutive model and data for metals subjected to large
strains, high strain rates and high temperatures. In: Proceedings of the 7th international
symposium on ballistics
9. Hyde D (1992) ConWep—Application of TM 5-855-1. In: Fundamentals of protective design
for conventional weapons. USACE Waterways Experiment Station: Vicksburg, MS
10. Kingery CN, Bulmash G (1984) Airblast parameters from TNT spherical air burst and
hemispherical surface burst. Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, MD: Ballistic Research
Laboratory
11. Engineers, U.A.C.o., UFC 3-340-02: Structures to Resist the Effects of Explosions, U.D.o.
Defense, Editor. 2008: Washington, DC
Experimental Study on Cross Arms
Inserted in Concrete-Filled
Circular GFRP Tubular Columns
F. Xie X. L. Dong
Faculty of Mechanical Engineering and Mechanics, Ningbo University,
Ningbo 315211, China
e-mail: xiefangusx@163.com
X. L. Dong
e-mail: XinlongDong_2000@163.com
F. Xie
Department of Civil Engineering, Shaoxing University, Shaoxing 312000, China
J. Chen
Department of Civil Engineering, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310058, China
e-mail: cecj@zju.edu.cn
Q. Q. Yu (&)
Department of Structural Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, China
e-mail: qianqian.yu@tongji.edu.cn
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Program
The specimens were made of steel bars inserted into concrete-filled GFRP tubes
(Fig. 1). The GFRP tubes had a diameter of 180 mm and a wall thickness of
10 mm. Different dimensions of steel bars were selected, as listed in Table 1. In this
study, steel bars rather than GFRP tubes were adopted to serve as the cross arm. It
was because the steel bars had a larger stiffness and consequently more detrimental
effect on the GFRP tube, which was intended to simulate a more unfavorable
scenario.
The GFRP tubes were filament wound of unidirectional G-glass fibers at 45
angle and PET resin. The infilled concrete had a 28-day cubic compressive strength
of 22.7 MPa. The cross arm was Q235b steel [6]. According to the tensile coupon
test, the average yield strength, ultimate tensile strength, and Young’s modulus
were 304 MPa, 475 MPa, and 204 GPa, respectively.
During the preparation of the specimens, the cross arm was inserted into the
GFRP tube through two holes with the same dimension of the steel bar. Afterward,
Grade C30 concrete was poured into the tubes and fully vibrated. All the specimens
were cured in the room condition for 28 days before testing.
The specimens were monotonically loaded by two actuators on the steel bar to
simulate the load transferred by wires to the cross arms and columns in a trans-
mission tower (Fig. 2). Displacement control at a rate of 0.2 mm/min was adopted.
The distance from the loading point to the boundary of the GFRP tube was
200 mm.
GFRP tube
Steel bar
1000
Concrete
2000
Table 1 Specimen geometry Specimen Cross-sectional dimension of the steel bar (mm)
D150-20 20 20
D150-30 30 30
D150-40 40 40
200 200
Actuator
Specimen
The deformation of the cross arm is an important index and was monitored by
using two dial indicators mounted to the steel bar at the loading points (Fig. 2). The
strain on the cross arm and the GFRP tube was also carefully recorded by 2 and 8
strain gauges, as illustrated in Figs. 3(a) and (b), respectively. It should be pointed
out that, the strain gauges on the GFRP tubes were attached along the fiber
direction, i.e., two were perpendicularly mounted to a certain position. Four (M1 to
M4) were applied to detect the strain development on the GFRP tube in the middle
of the steel bar while the other four (C1 to C4) were intended to read the strain
affected by the corner of the steel bar.
GFRP tube
L1 L2 Cross
M1, M2 M3, M4
10 10 arm
C1, C2 C3, C4
Cross arm
GFRP 10 10
tube
Strain gauge
Fig. 3 Layout of the strain gauges on the steel bar and the GFRP tube
Experimental Study on Cross Arms Inserted … 639
All the specimens failed due to yielding of the steel bar, and no cracks were
observed in the GFRP tube. Figure 4 presents the strain development on the steel
bar and GFRP tube of a typical specimen. As the load was increased, the com-
pressive strain on the GFRP tube and tensile strain on the steel bar were both
increased. Due to the mechanical profile of GFRP and steel, the variation of the
strain reading showed a linear and nonlinear trend, respectively. Based on the
mechanical properties presented in Sect. 2.1, it was easy to know that the maximum
strain on the GFRP (7948 le) was apparently less than the ultimate strain of the
GFRP (9310 le) while the maximum strain on the steel (2323 le) had exceeded the
yield strain of 1940 le. It was also interesting to find that the strain of C series was
significantly larger than that of the M series, indicating a severe stress concentra-
tion. Therefore, the GFRP tube at the corner of the cross arm is more prone to
damage and calls for special attention.
In terms of the effect of the dimension of the cross arm, the relationship between
strain and load of specimens with different cross-sections of steel bars is displayed
in Fig. 5. The strains of the four gauges at both the corner and middle of the cross
arm were averaged and are denoted by the final letter of C and M in Fig. 5,
respectively. When the side length of the cross arm was increased from 20 mm to
40 mm, the strain on the GFRP tube at the corner of the steel bar was considerably
decreased, which implied an improved specimen stiffness. Taking the load of 28 kN
as an example, the strain reading was decreased from 3439 le (D150-20) to 1562
le (D150-30) and 1019 le (D150-40). The corresponding reduction percentage was
55% and 70%, respectively. Differently, with the increase of the load, the strain on
the GFRP tube in the middle of the steel bar was always kept below 1000 le.
(specimen D150-40) 40 C2
C3
35
C4
Load (kN)
30
M1
25
M2
20
M3
15
M4
10
L1
5
L2
0
-10000 -8000 -6000 -4000 -2000 0 2000 4000
Strain (με)
640 F. Xie et al.
Load (kN)
30
D150-30-C
D150-40-C
20
D150-20-M
D150-30-M
10
D150-40-M
0
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000
Strain (με)
30
D150-20
20 D150-30
D150-40
10
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Displacement (mm)
Figure 6 plots the deformation of the cross arm observed in the experiment. It was
found that increase the size of the steel bar was beneficial to increase the specimen
stiffness and consequently to lead to a smaller deformation. At the load of 40 kN,
the displacement on the cross arm was decreased from 11.14 mm (D150-20) to
7.16 mm (D150-30) and 2.67 mm (D150-40). The corresponding reduction per-
centage was of 36% and 76%, respectively.
4 Conclusions
consequently, the rotation was well restrained. The strain on the GFRP tube at the
corner was noticeably larger than that in the middle of the steel bar, indicating a
server strain and stress concentration. However, no visible cracks were found in the
GFRP tube and all the specimens were failed due to yielding of the steel bar. As the
dimension of the cross arm increased, the strain on the GFRP tube at the corner of
the cross arm hole and the displacement of the steel bar was decreased. Based on
the limited test results, the connection between the concrete-filled GFRP column
and the cross arm adopted in this study showed a promising response.
Acknowledgements This research was supported by the National Science Foundation of China
(grant No. 11390361) and Zhejiang Provincial Natural Science Foundation of China
(LQ17E080010).
References
1. ASCE Manuals and Reports on Engineering Practice No. 104, Recommended practice for
Fiber-Reinforced polymer products for overhead utility line structures
2. Becque J, Patnaik AK, Rizkalla SH (2003) Analytical models for concrete confined with FRP
tubes. J Compos Constr 7:31–38
3. Cole B, Fam A (2006) Flexural load testing of concrete-filled FRP tubes with longitudinal
steel and FRP rebar. J Compos Constr 10:161–171
4. Fam AZ, Rizkalla SH (2002) Flexural behavior of concrete-filled fiber-reinforced polymer
circular tubes. J Compos Constr 6:123–132
5. Fam A, Rizkalla SH (2003) Large scale testing and analysis of hybrid concrete/composite
tubes for circular beam-column applications. Constr Build Mater 17:507–516
6. GB 50017-2003 (2003) Code for design of steel structures. Ministry of Housing and
Urban-Rural Development of the People’s Republic of China. (in Chinese)
7. Godat A, Légeron F, Gagné V, Marmion B (2013) Use of FRP pultruded members for
electricity transmission towers. Compos Struct 105:408–421
8. Guades E, Aravinthan T, Islam MM (2014) Characterisation of the mechanical properties of
pultruded fibre-reinforced polymer tube. Mater Design 63:305–315
9. Hong WK, Kim HC (2004) Behavior of concrete columns confined by carbon composite
tubes. Can J Civ Eng 31:178–188
10. Ibrahim S, Polyzois D (1999) Ovalization analysis of fiber-reinforced plastic poles. Compos
Struct 45:7–12
11. Li PD, Wu YF, Zhou YW, Xing F (2019) Stress-strain model for FRP-confined concrete
subject to arbitrary load path. Compos Part B: Eng 163:9–25
12. Ghafoori E, Motavalli M, Zhao XL, Nussbaumer A, Fontana M (2015) Fatigue design criteria
for strengthening metallic beams with bonded CFRP plates. Eng Struct 101:542–557
13. Ghafoori E, Schumacher A, Motavalli M (2012) Fatigue behavior of notched steel beams
reinforced with bonded CFRP plates: determination of prestressing level for crack arrest. Eng
Struct 45:270–283
14. Marzuki HFA, Mariatti J (2016) Laminate design of lightweight glass fiber reinforced epoxy
composite for electrical transmission structure. Proc Chem 19:871–878
15. Mirmiran A, Shahawy M, Beitleman T (2001) Slenderness limit for hybrid FRP-concrete
columns. J Compos Constr 5:26–34
16. Ozbakkaloglu T, Oehlers DJ (2008) Concrete-filled square and rectangular FRP tubes under
axial compression. J Compos Constr 12:469–477
642 F. Xie et al.
17. Wang YL, Wang YS, Wan BL, Han BG, Cai GC, Chang RJ (2018) Strain and damage
self-sensing of basalt fiber reinforced polymer laminates fabricated with carbon nanofibers/
epoxy composites under tension. Compos Part A: Appl Sci Manuf 113:40–52
18. Wei Y, Wu G, Li GF (2014) Performance of circular concrete-filled fiber-reinforced
polymer-steel composite tube columns under axial compression. J Reinf Plast Compos
33:1911–1928
19. Yu QQ, Chen T, Gu XL, Zhao XL, Xiao ZG (2013) Fatigue behaviour of CFRP strengthened
steel plates with different degrees of damage. Thin-Walled Struct 69:10–17
20. Yu QQ, Chen T, Gu XL, Zhao XL, Xiao ZG (2015) Boundary element analysis of fatigue
crack growth for CFRP-strengthened steel plates with longitudinal weld attachments.
J Compos Constr 19:04014044
21. Yu QQ, Gu XL, Zhao XL, Zhang D, Huang H, Jiang C (2019) Characterization of model
uncertainty of adhesively bonded CFRP-to-steel joints. Compos Struct 215:150–165
22. Yu QQ, Wu YF (2017) Fatigue strengthening of cracked steel beams with different
configurations and materials. J Compos Constr 21:04016093
23. Yu QQ, Wu YF (2018) Fatigue retrofitting of cracked steel beams with CFRP laminates.
Compos Struct 192:232–244
24. Zhang DM, Gu XL, Yu QQ, Huang H, Wan B, Jiang C (2018) Fully probabilistic analysis of
FRP-to-concrete bonded joints considering model uncertainty. Compos Struct 185:786–806
25. Zhang X, Wang YL, Wan BL, Cai GC, Qu Y (2019) Effect of specimen thicknesses on water
absorption and flexural strength of CFRP laminates subjected to water or alkaline solution
immersion. Constr Build Mater 208:314–325
26. Zhou A, Chow CL, Lau D (2018) Structural behavior of GFRP reinforced concrete columns
under the influence of chloride at casting and service stages. Compos Part B: Eng 136:1–9
27. Zhou A, Qin RY, Chow CL, Lau D (2019) Structural performance of FRP confined seawater
concrete columns under chloride environment. Compos Struct 216:12–19
28. Yeh HY, Yang SC (1997) Building of composite transmission tower. J Reinf Plast Compos
16:414–424
29. Yeh HY, Yeh HL (2001) A simple failure analysis of the composite transmission tower.
J Reinf Plast Compos 20:1054–1065
Local Failure Mechanism of RC Slabs
Subjected to Deformable Projectile
Impact
1 Introduction
In recent years, tornado events and volcanic eruptions have increased owing to
climate change and crustal movement. For instance, 24 fatalities and 387 injuries
were caused by the Moore tornado in Oklahoma, United States in 2013 [13].
A volcanic eruption at Mt. Ontake in Japan in 2014 [1] left 58 humans dead, while
several were injured by the volcanic cinders in addition to the pyroclastic and debris
2 Experimental Program
A projectile impact test machine was used to conduct impact tests. This machine
can launch a projectile of 8.4 kg at velocities of 20–90 m/s by adjusting air pres-
sure. A schematic of the projectile launching test and the experimental setup are
shown in Figs. 1 and 2, respectively. A pair of laser velocity sensors is fixed at the
muzzle of an acceleration tube to measure the average velocity at intervals of
50 cm. The muzzle of the acceleration tube was approximately at a distance of
0.5 m from an RC slab because of attachment of a projectile catcher which holds
the projectile after rebounding. The impact velocity was set between 50 and 70 m/s.
Figure 3 shows a photograph of a steel deformable projectile. A 500 g steel tube
with a thickness of 2 mm was installed between a spherical nose part and rear body.
Total mass of the projectile was 8.4 kg. The RC specimens, which were cast in
National Defense Academy, each had a length, width, and thickness of 1100, 1100,
and 150 mm, respectively, as shown in Fig. 4. As the local failure was expected
under the impact condition, the dimension of the RC slab is enough to cover the
local damage area. The specimens were reinforced with reinforcing bars with a
diameter of 10 mm and yield stress of 409 MPa at intervals of 120 mm in the both
direction on the bottom sides. The specimen was fixed on four sides. Single impact
test was conducted for impact velocities of 52 and 60 m/s, respectively. The
displacement-time history of the projectile was obtained by analyzing the images
captured by a high-speed camera (50000 frames per second) after the collision. The
velocity and acceleration of the projectile were calculated by differentiating the
displacement-time history, while the impact load of the projectile was indirectly
obtained by multiplying the mass of the projectile with the acceleration.
Figure 5 shows the failure states of the RC slabs. In this test condition using a
rigid projectile, the perforation failure was expected to be occurred by the modified
NDRC equation [9]. The RC slab showed spall failure at an impact velocity of
52 m/s and scabbing at an impact velocity of 60 m/s. The test result revealed that
the scabbing limit velocity of the test condition existed between 52 and 60 m/s. As
compared to the rigid projectile impact case, the failure of the RC slab was sig-
nificantly suppressed because the deformable projectile absorbed the kinetic energy
of the projectile
Fig. 2 A view of
experimental setup
Fig. 4 RC slab
D10
8@120mm
1100mm
115mm
150mm
8@120mm
1100mm
Local Failure Mechanism of RC Slabs Subjected … 647
3 Numerical Investigation
0 0:006½logðe_e_ Þ1:05
fcd e_ s
¼ ð1Þ
fcs0 e_ s
0
" #
ftd e_ 3:373
¼ exp 0:00126 log ð2Þ
fts0 e_ s
0 0 0
where, fcd and ftd are the dynamic compressive and tensile strengths respectively, fcs
0
and fts are the static compressive and tensile strengths respectively, and e_ and e_ s are
the dynamic and static strain rate respectively.
The projectile was modeled as elastic, and the steel material of the reinforcing
bar and steel tube was modeled with the Johnson-Cook yield criterion [7].
N
rf ;s ¼ A þ B epeff ð1 þ C ln e_ Þ ð3Þ
where rf,s is the yield stress, epeff is the effective plastic strain. The parameters of the
Johnson-Cook model used in the literature [17] were adopted.
Figure 8 shows the deformation of the steel tube and velocity distribution in the
RC slab at an impact velocity of 52 m/s, comparing with a rigid projectile impact
case simulated numerically. The deformation due to the local buckling was greater
than that of the experimental one by 9.5%, but the buckling in the upper portion
was quite similar to the experimental one. Although the velocity distribution in the
RC slab, in the deformable projectile case, slightly concentrated in the central
portion of the RC slab, the overall velocity was quite less. In contrast, the RC slab
in the 8.4 kg rigid projectile case shows clear scabbing. The numerical simulation
indicates that the buckling of the steel projectile mitigated the failure of the RC slab.
Figure 9 shows the velocity-time history of the projectile and impact force-time
history obtained by multiplying the acceleration calculated based on the image
analysis with the projectile mass. In the figure, “Nose” and “Body” denote the nose
and rear body respectively, as shown in Figs. 3 and 6. The velocity of the nose and
body parts obtained in the simulation successfully reproduced the experimental one.
The equilibrium condition between the nose part, the steel tube and the rear body as
shown in Fig. 10 was given as follows;
Fc ¼ Fp ma ð4Þ
where, Fc is the resistant force from RC slab (the impact force acting on the RC
slab), Fp is the buckling force and ma is the inertia force of the projectile nose, m is
the mass of the projectile nose, a is the acceleration of the projectile nose.
In Fig. 9 (b), the impact force acting on the RC slab in the deformable impact
case rose to 800 kN in 0.3 ms as similar to the rigid projectile case, while it dropped
suddenly and oscillated due to the buckling of the steel tube. By comparing Figs. 8
and 9, the reduced maximum impact force and elongated duration due to the
buckling changed the failure mode of the RC slab.
Figure 11 illustrates the inertia force of the rear body of the projectile simulated
numerically in the cases of spalling and scabbing, which is equivalent to the
buckling force time-history of the steel tube based on the equilibrium condition. It is
seen from the figure that the maximum force is approximately 300 kN in both cases
and oscillates with peak forces of 200 kN after 0.5 ms, which corresponds to the
buckling force of the steel tube as shown in Fig. 12. That is, the projectile pene-
tration into concrete is completed with the resistance of concrete in 0.5 ms. After
the nose part rapidly decelerates, the buckling of the steel tube develops by the
inertia force of the rear part. A schematic diagram of the impact force-time history
of the projectile is depicted in Fig. 13. Peak force Fmax could be generated by the
penetration of the projectile into concrete and the penetration completed at t1. After
that, the inertia force of the nose part can be negligible and the buckling force of the
steel tube acts on the RC slab.
Figure 14 illustrates the acceleration distribution on the back face of the RC slab
simulated numerically in the case of spalling failure. It is seen from the figure that
the peak acceleration was approximately 150000 m/s2 within 100 mm from the
center of the RC slab. The positive and negative peak accelerations at the center of
RC slab are very close because the point extremely oscillated due to the impact.
This local acceleration response revealed that the inertia force distribution in the
central area caused the local damage of the RC slab based on the dynamic equi-
librium condition.
Local Failure Mechanism of RC Slabs Subjected … 651
Fig. 11 The inertia force-time history of body part of projectile (The buckling force of circular
tube)
Figure 15(a) enlarged the impact force-time history calculated for a rigid pro-
jectile with the same mass and the deformable projectile colliding with the RC slab
at a velocity of 52 m/s. The peak force in the rigid projectile case showed
approximately 1000 kN at 0.4 ms and the duration is 1.0 ms. On the other hand, the
peak force in the deformable projectile case showed approximately 800 kN at
652 M. Beppu et al.
Fig. 15 Comparison deformable projectile to rigid projectile with 8.4 kg mass and impact
velocity of 52 m/s
0.3 ms, which is 20% less than that in the case of the rigid projectile case. After the
peak force, the impact force oscillates with the peak force of 200 kN due to the
buckling of the steel tube. Herein, the both impulse caused by the deformable
projectile are approximately 434 N s. Failure status and velocity distribution of
the RC slab as shown in Fig. 15(b) indicates that the diagonal cracks in the cross
section in the rigid projectile impact are widely opened as compared to those in the
deformable projectile impact. Velocity distribution as shown in Fig. 15(b) also
revealed that the peak velocity on the back side in the deformable projectile impact
is significantly less at 3.0 ms, while the failure mode in the rigid projectile impact is
scabbing with the peak velocity of 10 m/s on the back side. The numerical result
indicates that the decreased impulse in 1.0 ms in the deformable projectile impact
mitigated the local damage.
Local Failure Mechanism of RC Slabs Subjected … 653
4 Conclusions
This study investigated the local failure of RC slabs that were subjected to
deformable projectile impact. In the experimental work, buckling deformation of
the deformable projectile and failure mode of an RC slab were examined by con-
ducting projectile impact tests. The scabbing damage was suppressed due to
buckling deformation of the deformable projectile. Numerical simulations revealed
that the impact force characteristics were changed significantly due to the buckling
of the steel tube, which mitigated the failure mode of the RC slab.
References
1. Cabinet Office Japan (2015) A guidance for enhancement of shelter on active volcano (in
Japanese)
2. Cabinet Office Japan (2015) A present condition of volcanic eruption in Mt. Ontake (in
Japanese)
3. Chen XW, Li XL, Huang FL, Wu HJ, Chen YZ (2008) Normal perforation of reinforced
concrete target by rigid projectile. Int J Impact Eng 35:1119–1129
4. Fujikake K, Mori K, Uebayashi K, Ohno T, Mizuno J (2000) Dynamic properties of concrete
materials with high rates of tri-axial compressive loads. Structures under shock & Impact VI
5. Ito C, Shirai K, Ohnuma H (1995) Design formula of reinforced concrete structures against
rigid missile impact. JSCE J 507(I-30):201–208 (in Japanese)
6. Itoh M, Matsuzawa R, Beppu M (2016) A dual-limit-erosion approach to estimate fracture
zone of rc slabs subjected to high velocity impact loads. In: Proceedings of the ASME 2016
35th international conference on ocean, offshore and arctic engineering
7. Johnson GR, Cook WH (1983) A constitutive model and data for metals subjected to large
strains, high strain rates and high temperatures. In: Proceedings of the 7th international
symposium on ballistics
8. Kataoka S, Beppu M, Ichino H, Mase T, Nakada T, Matsuzawa R (2017) Failure behavior of
reinforced concrete slabs subjected to moderate-velocity impact by a steel projectile. Int J
Protect Struct 8(3):384–406
9. Kennedy RP (1976) A review of procedures for the analysis and design of concrete structures
to resist missile impact effects. Nuclear Eng Design 37:183–203
10. Li QM, Ye ZQ, Ma GW, Reid SR (2007) Influence of overall structural response on
perforation of concrete targets. Int J Impact Eng 34:926–941
11. Miyamoto A, King MW, Fujii M (1991) Nonlinear dynamic analysis of reinforced concrete
slabs under impulsive loads. ACI Struct J 88(4):538–545
12. Miyamoto A, King MW, Ishibashi T (1994) Design concept for concrete slab structures
subjected to impact load. JSMS Mater J 43(491):1010–1015 (in Japanese)
13. National Institute of Standards and Technology (2013) Preliminary reconnaissance of the May
20, 2013, Newcastle–Moore Tornado in Oklahoma, NIST Special Publication 1164
14. Nuclear Regulation Authority (2013) Japan, Assessment guide for tornado effect on nuclear
power plants (in Japanese)
15. Othman H, Marzouk H (2016) An experimental investigation on the effect of steel
reinforcement on impact response of reinforced concrete plates. Int J Impact Eng 88:12–21
16. Ross CA, Thompson PY, Tedesco JW (1989) Split-hopkinson pressure-bar tests on concrete
and mortar in tension and compression. AC I Mater J 86:475–481
654 M. Beppu et al.
17. Schwer L (2007) Optional strain-rate forms for the John-son Cook constitutive model and the
role of the parameter epsilon_01. In: Proceedings of LS-DYNA Anwenderforum
18. Yankelevsky DZ (1997) Local response of concrete slabs to low velocity missile impact. Int J
Impact Eng 19:331–343
19. Xiao Y, Li B, Fujikake K (2016) Experimental study of reinforced concrete slabs under
different loading rates. ACI Struct J 113:157–168
20. Zineddin M, Krauthammer T (2007) Dynamic response of reinforced concrete slabs under
impact loading. Int J Impact Eng 34:1517–1534
Flexural Performance of Precast
Segmental Concrete Beams Prestressed
with CFRP Tendons
Keywords Segmental concrete beams Unbonded tendons Fiber reinforced
polymer (FRP) tendons Numerical analysis Abaqus
1 Introduction
Precast segmental prestressed concrete beams (PSBs) have been widely used in
bridge construction projects owing to their time-saving and economic benefits [7].
So far steel tendons are used as the only prestressing material to join individual
segments of the structure. Inappropriate design choices and poor quality con-
struction of anti-corrosion systems, however, caused major damage to the structures
and in extreme cases, the entire structure was even completely collapsed as reported
in the literature [4]. This made corrosion problems of the steel tendons at segment
joints a great concern to PSBs, especially in the case the structure is exposed to
harsh conditions.
This study investigates the use of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) tendons on
PSBs as an alternative solution for steel tendons to tackle the corrosion-induced
damages on the structure. FRP tendon is corrosion free, has high tensile strength
and is lighter than steel, which allows easier handling and reduces dead load of the
structure. The use of FRP tendon on monolithic concrete beams has been exten-
sively reported, however, its application on PSBs has not been reported yet [6, 7, 9].
It is worth noting that FRP tendon shows linear stress-strain relationship up to
failure, has lower elastic modulus and is weak in shear as compared to steel ten-
dons. It is, therefore, important to investigate the behavior of PSBs prestressed with
FRP tendons before its possible practical applications.
This study also presents a numerical approach to simulate the flexural behaviour
of PSBs with unbonded tendons using ABAQUS CAE [1] commercial software. To
the authors’ best knowledge, this is the first time three-dimensional solid finite
elements are used in the numerical model that provides visual observations for
better understandings of the flexural behaviour of the structure under the applied
loads.
2 Experimental Program
Four large-scale segmental beams with internal unbonded CFRP tendons and one
segmental beams with internal unbonded steel tendons were fabricated and tested in
this study. All the beams had T-shape cross-section of 400 mm height and 3.9 m
overall length. Each beam consisted of four segments which were made of rein-
forced concrete ranging from 800 mm to 1150 mm length (Fig. 1). The segments in
each beam were joined together by two steel or CFRP tendons, which were
internally unbonded or bonded to the concrete using the post-tensioning technique.
Table 1 gives details of the beams’ configuration.
Two 12-mm diameter deformed bars were used for the longitudinal bars at the
bottom layer while 10-mm diameter deformed bars were for the top layer.
Flexural Performance of Precast Segmental Concrete … 657
These steel bars were cut-off at the joint locations. 10-mm diameter deformed bars
were used for the transverse reinforcements, which were placed at 100-mm spacing
for the two middle segments and at 75-mm spacing for the two end segments to
strengthen beams in shear.
2.2 Materials
The concrete average compressive strength on the testing day was 44 MPa. The
ultimate tensile strength of 12-mm deformed bars N12 and 10-mm deformed bars
N10 were 587 MPa and 538 MPa, respectively, as provided by the manufacturer.
12.7-mm diameter steel tendons and single strand 12.9-mm diameter CFRP tendons
were used in the specimens. The nominal area, ultimate tensile strength, and elastic
modulus of the steel tendons were 100 mm2, 1860 MPa, and 195 GPa and those
values for CFRP tendons were 126.7 mm2, 2450 MPa and 145 GPa, respectively.
More details on the material properties and beams’ configuration can be found
elsewhere [7, 8].
658 T. M. Pham et al.
Hydraulic jack
The segments were cast using match-casting. The joint surfaces and holes of each
segment were carefully cleaned before the application of epoxy and grout.
Sikadur-30 was used for joining epoxied joints and SikaGrout-300PT was used for
creating bonded tendons. The beams were prestressed using post-tensioning tech-
nique. The effective prestresses in the tendons after transferred were recorded by
load cells and are given in Table 1 for all the beams. Figure 2 shows a typical test
setup. The applied load was generated by two vertical hydraulic jacks, which were
placed equally at one-third span. Load cells were used to monitor the applied load
generated by the hydraulic jacks and the force in the tendons. Linear variable
differential transformers (LVDTs) were used to measure the beams’ deflection and
opening of joints. All the beams were cyclically tested under four-point loading test
up to failure. All the tests were conducted under the load control at a rate of
approximately 3 to 5 kN/min.
The envelop load-deflection curves for all the beams under the applied load are
shown in Fig. 3. Two stages can be identified for the load-deflection curve of each
beam. In the first stage, all the beams had high stiffness and exhibited a linear
relationship between the applied load and deflection. In the second stage, the
beams’ stiffness considerably reduced and the beams deformed in a non-linear
manner up to failure. The transition from the first stage to the second stage is related
to the opening of the middle joint J2 under the applied load. The only difference is
that the load-deflection curve of Beam BS1 showed more non-linear behaviour in
Flexural Performance of Precast Segmental Concrete … 659
Fig. 3 Load-deflection
curves
the second stage compared to the curves of the other beams especially after the
yielding of the steel tendons. Table 2 summaries the test results of all the beams, in
which Pu, dmid,u and DJ,u are the applied load, midspan deflection, and opening of
the middle joint of the specimens at the ultimate stage, respectively.
660 T. M. Pham et al.
Joint interface
Vertical
crack
Vertical
crack
d) BC3 e) BC4
Photos of the specimens’ failures are presented in Fig. 5, which clearly shows
different failure modes of the tested beams. Beams BS1 failed by the yielding of
steel tendons and then the top concrete crushed when the beams underwent large
deflection. Beam BC1 and BC2 with unbonded CFRP tendons failed by concrete
crushing on the compressive zone and CFRP tendons rupturing. The crushing of
concrete and rupturing of tendons occurred at the middle joint at the midspan for all
the specimens. In contrast, Beams BC3 and BC4 with bonded tendons failed by the
rupture of CFRP tendons without any concrete damage on the top.
Flexural Performance of Precast Segmental Concrete … 661
Bonding condition between the tendons and concrete greatly affected the flexural
behavior of the segmental beams with CFRP tendons. The use of bonded tendons
greatly increased the strength of the beam as observed in the case of Beams BC3
and BC4 while the use of unbonded tendons greatly improved the deflection
capacity of the beams as seen in Beams BC1 and BC2. Bonding condition had no
effect on the initial stiffness of the epoxied-joint beams but considerably affected the
beams’ stiffness after the joint opened as observed in the load-deflection curves of
Beams BC2 and BC4. The failure modes of the beams were also affected by the
bonding condition of the tendons as discussed previously. The use of unbonded
tendons shifted the failure mode from tension controlled (as observed in Beams
BC3 and BC4) to compression controlled (as observed in Beams BC1 and BC2). In
Beams BC1 and BC2, severe concrete crushing was observed on the compression
zone before the rupture of the CFRP tendons at the ultimate stage.
By comparing the load-deflection curves of Beams BC1 versus BC2 and Beams
BC3 versus BC4, it can be observed that for the same tendon bonding condition, the
type of joints had only a slight effect on the overall load-carrying capacity and
ductility of the beams. Both Beams BC1 and BC2 had similar strength and
deflection at the ultimate stage as seen in Fig. 3 and that was also true for the cases
of Beams BC3 and BC4, although the beams with epoxied joints showed a higher
ultimate strength than those with dry joints (Table 2). The joint type had an
insignificant effect on the opening of joints either. As can be seen from Fig. 4,
Beams BC1/BC2 and BC3/BC4 showed almost similar load-joint opening curves
under the applied load.
4 Numerical Model
This part describes the use of ABAQUS CAE (2012) software to simulate the
behaviour of segmental concrete beams internally prestressed with unbonded ten-
dons. To simulate the beams, three-dimensional solid finite elements are used to
capture the response of the different components in the finite element models.
Eight-node linear brick, reduced integration hexahedral elements (C3D8R) are
selected to model the concrete elements, prestressing steel tendons, and auxiliary
elements such as steel loading plates, anchor blocks and steel plates at beams’ ends.
Two-node linear 3-D truss elements are selected to model the conventional steel
reinforcements. Details on the material models, contact relationships and modelling
procedure are discussed in sequence.
662 T. M. Pham et al.
The beam model is built symmetrically with regard to the XY plane at the
centroid of the beam’s cross-section (Fig. 5). For the concrete elements, the most
critical areas were at joint locations where the cracks happened as observed from the
experiment [7, 8]. As such, a finer mesh with element size of 20 mm is applied for
these areas while element size of 40 mm is used for the other areas. The prestressing
tendons and the conventional steel reinforcement are meshed with element size of
20 mm. Remaining components are meshed with element size of 40 mm.
The prestressing effects in the model is specified using Predefined Fields func-
tion provided in Abaqus [1]. The applied load is exerted by creating two boundary
conditions moving vertically downward which are also placed symmetrically at the
one-third span length of the beam as shown in Fig. 6.
Numerical results are validated against the experimental results in terms of the
load-deflection response and the failure modes. As observed from Fig. 7, the
numerical models well capture the load-deflection responses of the tested beams
BS1 and BC1. For Beams BS1 with steel tendons, the test was stopped for the
safety reason. At that point, the applied load was 96 kN and its corresponding
mid-span deflection was 89.4 mm. In the numerical model, the applied load cor-
responding to the deflection of 89.4 mm is 91 kN, which deviates approximately
−5.7% compared to the experimental result. In the case of Beam BC1 with CFRP
tendons, the numerical model slightly overestimates the applied load by 1.8%
compared to the experimental result.
The numerical models also well capture the failure modes of the tested beams.
The numerical model draws similar failure modes of concrete compared to the
tested beams. Only the failure mode of Beam S1 is provided in Fig. 8 for brevity
since both the beams BS1 and BC2 showed similar responses of concrete up to the
ultimate stage as discussed above. It is worth noting that the yielding of the
Boundary
conditions
Finer mesh at joint Unbonded tendons
locations Anchor block
and steel plate
Fig. 7 Load-deflection curve: simulation vs experiment. Note: The curve of beam BS1 is plotted
to 89.4 mm deflection, which is equal to expt. value for comparison purpose
prestressing steel takes place before the crushing of the concrete as observed in the
numerical model which was very difficult to determine accurately during the test. In
the case of Beam BC1, the rupture of the CFRP tendons is also captured in the
numerical model near the middle joint J2, which is similar to the test. It is noted
from the numerical model that the rupture of the CFRP tendons is due to the shear
stress generated in the tendons by the applied load, which exceeds its nominal shear
resistance, which could not be measured in the test. From the above discussions, it
is evident that the numerical model developed in this study is reliable and entirely
capable of simulating the behaviour of PSBs with unbonded tendons of either steel
or CFRP materials.
Flexural Performance of Precast Segmental Concrete … 665
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The author acknowledge the financial support from the Australian Research
Council Laureate Fellowships FL180100196.
References
J. D. Li and H. Hao
Abstract The accidental gas explosions are major safety concerns in the oil and
gas sectors. A typical gas explosion associates with complex interaction between
obstacles and turbulence. Compared to the gas explosion, the chemical explosion
such as TNT explosion has much shorter blast duration. There are more than a few
engineering design rules for TNT explosion safety design in the literature.
However, for fast deflagration/detonation, no rigorous method has been published
in the open literature to study the blast wave propagation under different distances.
Therefore, this article focuses on the numerical simulation of fast deflagration
resulted from gas explosion. FLACS is used to model the decay of blast waves from
the equivalent vessel blast explosion. Safety distance, which is well-known as the
cheapest and one of most efficient measures to protect people and structures from
gas explosion, is thoroughly investigated. The parametric study by means of
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations is carried out to examine the
efficiency of safety distance in blast wave mitigation.
1 Introduction
Safety distance is one of the most efficient and cheapest gas explosion overpressure
mitigation ways in oil and gas industry. In the industrial standards, the safety
distance requirements for gas storage tanks are mainly regulated on the basis of
J. D. Li (&) H. Hao
Tianjin University and Curtin University Joint Research Centre of Structural Monitoring and
Protection, School of Civil and Mechanical Engineering, Curtin University, Kent St, Bentley,
WA 6102, Australia
e-mail: jingde.li@curtin.edu.au
H. Hao
e-mail: hong.hao@curtin.edu.au
2 Experiment
As a first step, the experimental data for far-field pressure prediction of vented gas
explosion from the authors’ previous experiments [5] are extracted in this section
and used to validate the blast wave propagation in CFD simulation.
Investigation of Safety Distance Effect … 669
As seen in Fig. 1(a), a cylindrical tank with diameter of 1.5 m and height of 1.0 m
was used. The tank walls were made of Q345B steel according to the standard [1].
A rectangular vent (dimensions of 305 610 mm2) on the left side of the tank roof
was used, the tank roof and walls were welded to ensure the tank is well confined
during combustion. The bottom of the tank was anchored to a reinforced concrete
foundation to ensure the tank was stationary when it was subjected to vented
explosion.
Three piezo-resistive sensors (CYG 1409, Kunshan Shuangqiao Sensors,
China), namely, Sensor 1, Sensor 2 and Sensor 3, were mounted on the truss to
monitor external pressures from venting. Fire-resistant coating was applied for all
sensors. Signals from all sensors were logged on a 16-bit A/D converter sampling at
50–100 kHz. The separation distance between two sensors was 500 mm which was
also the separation distance between the bottom sensor and the vent.
As demonstrated in Fig. 1(b), a fan and a recirculation pump and were connected
to the tank to uniformly mix the flammable atmosphere in the tank. A measuring
tube was inserted into different location of the tank to ensure the mixture has
uniform data (i.e. gas concentration data). An infrared methane-air concentration
analyzer (QGS-08C, Nanjing Xinfen, China) was used to measure the gas con-
centration. A high-speed camera (FASTCAM SA-Z, Photron Co., Ltd., Japan) and
digital controlling system (Donghua 5927, Donghua, Testing Technology Co., Ltd.,
China) located about 25 m away the tank were used.
An electric spark was used to ignite the fuel-air mixture inside tank. The ignition
was controlled remotely in a shielded room far away from the tank. Center ignition
inside the tank was used. Water cooling system was applied to circulate cold water
so that all pressure sensors were protected from the hot flame during the test.
Fig. 1 Gas explosion experimental setup: a details of sensor, tank and truss in test; b Gas flow
control system scheme [5]
670 J. D. Li and H. Hao
Since this article focuses on the study of far field blast wave, only the external
pressures recorded by sensor 1 to 3 were extracted. The starting times of the raw
data were adjusted to zero to facilitate comparison with the CFD simulation data.
The Fast Fourier transform (FFT) method of data filtering was used and a
1000 Hz low pass filter was chosen for all testing results. It is seen from sensor
No. 1 to sensor No. 3 (i.e. the distance from 500 mm to 1500 mm away the vent) in
Fig. 2, the pressure peak decreases, which is within expectation. Since the further
the sensor is, the more pressure decays in the air.
The CFD-based software FLACS version 10.4 (Gexcon, 2017), which relies on the
k-e model for turbulence simulation, is utilized to calculate the external pressures.
FLACS solves compressible Navier-Stokes equations on a 3D Cartesian grid for
turbulence, burning velocities and development of overpressure, etc. The SIMPLE
pressure correction algorithm is used [7, 12].
For vented gas explosion, the external overpressure (over 1 barg or Mach
number >1) associated with acoustic effect propagates with supersonic flow speed
in the open air, which resembles the blast wave originated from the vessel burst
propagates in far field. In order to simplify the simulation and calculation of such
fast propagating blast wave in far field, the vented gas explosion involving a fast
Fig. 2 External
overpressures recorded from
sensor No. 1, No. 2 and No. 3
Investigation of Safety Distance Effect … 671
Fig. 4 Pressure data in FLACS and experiment: a pressure-time history in FLACS; b pressure
peak comparison between FLACS data and experimental data
Fig. 5 Comparison of experiment and CFD data for individual sensors: a sensor 1; b sensor 2;
c sensor 3
Compared to the experimental data, the pressure peaks in FLACS decay slightly
faster, as seen Fig. 4(b). The main reason is the pressure recorded in experiment
resulted from the interaction between internal and external explosions. The
deflagration near the vent are more influenced by the internal explosion. In the
internal explosion, the combustion of unburned gas is much slower than the blast
wave propagation outside the tank. Therefore, during the time when external blast
wave propagates at sonic/supersonic speed, internal explosion provides postponed
pressures, which are recorded in experiment. Whereas in the equivalent vessel burst
problem, the setup-file in FLACS only models the blast propagation in open air
without simulating the combustion associated with the deflagration and venting
process. Overall, the differences between the experimental pressure peaks and
FLACS pressures peaks for all sensors are within 10% as seen in Fig. 5, although
the combustion duration in the experiments are much longer than the duration in
equivalent vessel burst explosion. It is worth pointing that the starting times of the
burst explosion are adjusted to facilitate comparison with the experimental simu-
lation data in Fig. 5.
Investigation of Safety Distance Effect … 673
Since this article focuses on the investigation of blast wave propagation in far
field instead of the study of vented explosion. Moreover, compared to experimental
data, the pressure peaks and pressure decay tendencies predicted by FLACS are
satisfactory. Therefore, simulating equivalent vessel burst problem by using a
setup-file in FLACS is used to study the safety distance effect on blast wave decay
in far field.
In order to study the safety distance effect on blast wave decay, additional tanks are
added in the simulation. The safety distance between two tanks varies from 1 m to
10 m, two different safety distance examples can be seen in Fig. 6. A hemispherical
blast reservoir, which has the same combustion energy of the blast reservoir in the
CFD validation, is used in this section.
Since the safety distance is extending in y direction (i.e. the pressure accepting
tank on the right varies from 1 m to 10 m away the left tank), the worst case study
is conducted by locating the blast reservoir on the side wall of the left tank as seen
in Fig. 7(a). It is also seen in Fig. 7(a), one monitor at half height of the tank is
located on the pressure accepting tank wall, and another monitor is placed on the
ground corner near the tank wall.
The pressure-time data for three representative safety distance cases are shown in
Fig. 7(b). In Fig. 7(b), monitors in the free field are located at the same locations of
the monitors used in the safety distance cases. It is seen that pressure on the ground
corner is about 3 time larger than the pressure in free field case for the 1 m safety
distance scenario, which is mainly due to the blast wave reflections from the tank
wall and ground. Whereas the pressure on the tank wall is only about 1.7 times
larger than the free-field-recorded pressure, the blast wave reflection is mainly from
the curved tank wall. As the safety distance increases from 1 to 7 m, the blast wave
Fig. 6 3D view of blast wave propagation in two different safety distances: a safety
distance = 1 m; b safety distance = 5 m
674 J. D. Li and H. Hao
Fig. 7 Blast simulation monitor point location and recorded data: a monitor locations;
b pressure-time data from monitors
Fig. 8 Pressure-time data for cases with and without a pressure accepting tank at different safety
distances: a pressure in open space without a secondary tank; b pressure on tank wall with a
secondary tank
reflection from the tank wall and ground becomes smaller and smaller, which can
be seen from the overlapping waves for 7 m safety distance case after 0.015 s in
Fig. 7(b).
In order to better understand the blast wave decay in the far field and the safety
distance effect on blast wave, the pressure-time data for the single tank case (i.e. blast
wave propagates from the blast reservoir to the free field) are charted in Fig. 8(a) and
compared with the data from the cases with two tanks in Fig. 8(b).
In general, the increase of safety distance results in the decrease of pressure in far
field for both cases. In comparison, for individual safety distance cases, the pres-
sures are greater in the dual tank cases due to the blast wave reflection on the tank
wall. However, the pressure wave decay tendencies are nonlinear. At further dis-
tance, for example at safety distance of 10 m, the pressure reflection from walls are
minimum.
Investigation of Safety Distance Effect … 675
The blast chart from Multi-Energy Method (MEM) is utilized in this study to
compare with the far-field pressures predicted by FLACS. The initial blast energy is
estimated by the Sedov solution [11], while the dimensionless scaled distance in
MEM is calculated as:
R
R¼ ð1Þ
ðE=Po Þ1=3
As seen in Fig. 9, the blast decaying tendencies in both of free field case and
dual tank case are faster than the MEM data, such observation is consistent with the
findings in the work by [5]. In other words, the MEM model is more conservative in
far-field pressure prediction for the fast deflagration from a vessel burst problem.
Moreover, it is seen in Fig. 9(a) that two curves from the aforementioned cases
are not parallel. As the distance increases, the pressure differences between two
cases become smaller, which again indicates that the pressure reflection in far field
becomes less and less influential.
Additionally, the pressures recorded behind the secondary tank wall are also
plotted in the blast chart in Fig. 9(b). It is seen the pressures behind the tank are
significantly decreased as the tank itself acts like a blast wall which mitigates blast
wave. It is worth noting the blast mitigation on the monitor behind the wall is also
more effective for the shorter safety distance cases. Large safety distance decreases
the blast mitigation effect of a solid wall (i.e. a tank wall).
Fig. 9 Relation between the distance and pressure in the blast chart: a pressure in free field vs.
pressure on tank wall; b pressure in free field vs. pressure behind tank wall
676 J. D. Li and H. Hao
5 Conclusions
This paper focuses on the CFD simulation of fast deflagration from gas explosion.
FLACS is used to model the blast wave decay from the equivalent vessel blast
problem. The efficiency of safety distance in blast wave mitigation is investigated.
Experimental data are used to validate the FLACS simulation results.
Satisfactory CFD simulation results are seen in terms of the accuracy of pressure
peak and pressure decaying tendency predicted by using FLACS.
It is concluded that increase of safety distance in free field and increase of safety
distance between tanks both result in blast wave decay/mitigation in far field. Blast
wave reflections from walls and ground are more influential for shorter safety
distance cases.
Pressure behind the tank wall are mitigated due to the tank’s wall shielding
effect. However, the blast mitigation effect weakens in far field once safety distance
increases.
Compared to the blast waves calculated by MEM model, blast waves predicted
by FLACS are smaller in far field, which is in consistent with the observation of the
authors’ previous study. However, more experimental data in the future are required
to verify such findings.
References
1. API-650 (2007) Welded steel tanks for oil strorage. 11 edn. American Petroleum Institute
2. Diaz-Ovalle C, Vazquez-Roman R, Mannan MS (2010) An approach to solve the facility
layout problem based on the worst-case scenario. J Loss Prev Process Ind 23(3):385–392
3. EN-1473 (2016) EN, BS. Installation and equipment for liquefied natural gas—design of
onshore installations
4. Jung SH, Ng D, Diaz-Ovalle C, Vazquez-Roman R, Mannan MS (2011) New approach to
optimizing the facility siting and layout for fire and explosion scenarios. Ind Eng Chem Res
50(7):3928–3937
5. Li JD, Hao H (2018) Far-field pressure prediction of a vented gas explosion from storage
tanks by using new CFD simulation guidance. Process Saf Environ Prot 119:360–378
6. Li JD, Hao H, Shi YC, Fang Q, Li Z, Chen L (2018) Experimental and computational fluid
dynamics study of separation gap effect on gas explosion mitigation for methane storage
tanks. J Loss Prev Process Ind 55:359–380
7. Li JD, Hernandes F, Hao H, Fang Q, Xiang H, Li Z, Li C (2017) Vented methane-air
explosion overpressure calculation - a simplified approach based on CFD. Saf Environ Protect
109:489–508
8. NFPA-59A (2016) National Fire Protection Association. Standard for the Production,
Storage, and Handling of Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG)
9. Raj PK, Lemoff T (2009) Risk analysis based LNG facility siting standard in NFPA 59A.
J Loss Prev Process Ind 22(6):820–829
10. Santos FD, Landesmann A (2014) Thermal performance-based analysis of minimum safe
distances between fuel storage tanks exposed to fire. Fire Saf J 69:57–68
11. Sedov LI (1993) Similarity and dimensional methods in mechanics. CRC Press, Boca Raton
12. Vyazmina E, Jallais S, Beccantini A, Trelat S (2018) Protective walls against effects of vapor
cloud fast deflagration: CFD recommendations for design. Process Saf Prog 37(1):56–66
Dynamic Tensile Properties of Clay
Brick at High Strain Rates
1 Introduction
It is commonly known that material behaves differently under static and dynamic
loading conditions. To accurately analyze and predict structural responses under
dynamic loads such as impact and blast loading, much efforts have been paid to
investigate the dynamic material properties of various construction materials
including concrete, steel, rock, glass, polymers etc. [3, 4, 12, 14–16]. Nevertheless,
brick as one of the most widely used materials have been less studied. This is
primarily because normal clay brick structures have low blast and impact resistant
capacity and therefore less focus has been made on brick dynamic material prop-
erties. Also, the different brick materials used in different regions and areas for
constructions exhibit different mechanical properties due to different chemical
compositions. Studying the dynamic properties of clay bricks with different
chemical compositions will not only augment the literature and database of the
strain rate effect on brick materials, but also lead to more accurate analyse and
design of masonry structures subjected to high-rate dynamic loads.
Due to limited test results available on clay brick dynamic properties, most
current researches on masonry structures subjected to impact and blast loadings
adopt static material properties for bricks or dynamic material properties at par-
ticular strain rates only [5], which do not necessarily lead to accurate predictions of
structural responses. Some dynamic test data have been released in literatures on the
dynamic material properties of clay bricks. However, the reported data on the
dynamic increase effect differ substantially. Dynamic increase factor (DIF) of brick
compressive strength are generally from 1.2 to 2.5. Larcher et al. [5] carried out
SHPB test on bricks and found DIF of 1.38 at strain rate 189 s−1. Pereira et al. [7]
quantified clay brick compressive strength at quasi-static state and 176 s−1. Hao and
Tarasov [2] tested the unconfined compressive strength of clay bricks at strain rates
between 2.1 10−6 s−1 and 200 s−1 with a triaxial static-dynamic testing machine.
Recently, the authors conducted both quasi-static and SHPB dynamic tests on three
types of WA clay bricks at strain rate up to 337 s−1, and combined previous testing
data by different researchers to derive an empirical formula for clay brick com-
pressive DIF [13]. Till now, very limited data are available on the dynamic tensile
properties of clay bricks. In a recent paper [5] three different types of bricks, i.e.
terracotta, clinker and abode bricks were examined under quasi-static and dynamic
states using Brazilian disk method. A DIF for tensile strength of up to 3.0 was
found. There is still a serious short of data on the dynamic tensile properties of brick
to derive a reliable DIF versus strain rate relation for proper analysis and design
practise.
The aim of this study is to experimentally investigate the dynamic tensile
properties of clay bricks used in Western Australia. Two different types of clay
bricks (Limestone Hues solid and St Common Solid) were tested. The tests covered
strain rate from 1.13 10−5 s−1 to 10 s−1. The split-tensile strength, corresponding
failure strain and modulus at different strain rates were measured. Brick specimen
dynamic failure process was monitored. DIF for tensile strength were derived and
compared with existing data.
2 Experimental Setup
Two types of clay bricks were provided by major local brick supplier Midland
Bricks with mixtures of Western Australian local clays. Table 1 lists the chemical
compositions of the two bricks. 74 mm diameter by 37 mm cylindrical specimens
were core-drilled from 230 mm 110 mm 76 mm solid brick and finely
Dynamic Tensile Properties of Clay Brick at High Strain Rates 679
grinded for the Brazilian disc tests. The specimens were then dried in an oven at
40 °C for 48 h until the extra moisture was removed. Figure 1 shows the two types
of brick specimens. The densities for the two types of bricks are 1903.5 kg/m3 and
1960.7 kg/m3.
The quasi-static tests were conducted on a Shimadzu-300 testing system with
reference to ASTM-D3967 [11] (as illustrated in Fig. 1). The failure of each
specimen took about 5-10 min which resulted in a strain rate in the split direction of
1.13 10−5 s−1 (measured by the strain gauge). Three specimens for each type of
brick were tested at the loading speed. The dynamic split-tensile tests were con-
ducted on the SHPB testing system at the Structural Dynamics Laboratory in Curtin
University. The testing system comprises of 100 mm diameter incident bar
(5000 mm in length) and transmitter bar (3000 mm in length). The striker bar was
also 100 mm in diameter and 500 mm long. The bars are made of high strength tool
steel with density of 7800 kg/m3 and Young’s modulus of 200 GPa. Strain gages
were glued to the centres of the incident and transmitter bars to monitor stress
waves. Figure 2a shows the typical stress wave signal recorded in the incident and
transmitter bars. Dynamic equilibrium was checked to ensure the validity of each
high-speed compressive test (Fig. 2b). Considering the challenge in predicting the
strain rate that a specimen experienced in Brazilian disc test using SHPB system,
most researchers utilized loading rate (unit MPa/s from transmitted stress) and some
researchers further process the loading rate into strain rate [17]. Equation (1) gives
the formula for calculating split-tensile strength. Strain gauges were also glued to
the centre of the specimen in the split-tensile direction to monitor specimen strain.
The strain rates that specimens experienced were calculated by differentiating the
recorded strain time histories, which were validated with those estimated using
transmitted stress signal. Both strain rate and loading rate are used to describe
dynamic testing results in this study.
2P
rt ¼ ð1Þ
pDL
where P is the applied load, D and L are the diameter and length of the specimen.
a) b)
Fig 1 Brick specimens: a Limestone Hues solid; b St common solid
Figure 3 shows the fracturing process of brick specimens, which was recorded
using a high-speed camera with a filming rate was 40 kHz. Figure 3a and b show
the fracture processes of the limestone hue brick. It is clear that under 3.5/s strain
rate at t = 168 ls crack initiated from the centre of the cylinder which grew wider
and extended towards both ends of the specimen leading to the failure of the
specimen. Under increased strain rate (9.4/s), crack was formed at the centre of the
specimen at earlier stage (t = 96 ls) with the contacting end crushed at the left-end
of the cylinder. A thorough split failure was formed at 192 ls with both ends of the
specimen crushed. Similar fracture processes can be observed on the Common
Solids specimens as illustrated in Fig. 3c and d. Because of the dark red colour of
the brick, in the dynamic tests the specimens were painted into white colour. It is
worth noting that more severe end crushing was observed on the St Common Solids
specimen at high strain rate (9.3/s) as well as multiple cracks in the centre of the
specimen. This is because of the increased incident wave on the specimen.
Dynamic Tensile Properties of Clay Brick at High Strain Rates 681
Fig 3 Dynamic fracture processes of the specimens from high-speed camera images
Tables 2 and 3 tabulate the testing results of the two types of bricks. Typical
stress-strain curves of the specimens at different loading rates are shown in Fig. 4.
As depicted, both bricks exhibit strong strain rate sensitivity. For the Limestone
Hue block, a split-tensile strength of 2 MPa was measured at quasi-static state,
which increased apparently as loading rate increased. Under 23.35 MPa/s loading
rate, the tensile strength rose to about 3.6 MPa, and at 66.56 MPa/s loading rate the
tensile strength further increased to about 7 MPa. The modulus also appears to
increase at increased loading rate. Under quasi-static state, a modulus of about
7.6 GPas was measured, which increased slightly to about 7.8 GPa under
23.35 MPa/s loading rate. Under 41.87 MPa/s loading, the modulus further
increased to about 8.7 GPa. Similar observation can be found on the Common Solid
blocks that both the tensile strength and the modulus measured increased as loading
rate is increased. It is worth noting that the failure strain (corresponding to peak
tensile stress) of the Common Solid blocks are larger than those of the Limestone
Hue blocks, indicating the latter is more brittle.
DIF for brick tensile strength are derived by dividing the dynamic tensile
strength with the quasi-static strength. Figure 5 shows the tensile DIF vs. strain rate
relation for the two types of bricks. It is apparent that the tensile DIF of both types
of bricks are strongly strain rate sensitive. For the limestone Hue block, a DIF of
around 2.0 was found at around 3.5/s strain rate which increased to about 3.5 at 10/s
strain rate. Similar trend but slightly smaller tensile DIF can be observed for the
Common Solid blocks. A DIF of about 2.0 was found at about 4/s strain rate which
increased to about 3.0 at strain rate of 10/s. The difference is mainly because of the
different chemical composition in the two bricks since the specimens were of the
same dimension. Available testing data on mortar [1, 9] and concrete [8–10] are
also included in Fig. 5 for comparison. As can be found, smaller DIF was measured
on mortar by Chen et al. [1] but very close trend between DIF and strain rates like
those for the two bricks. Higher DIF on mortar was reported by Ross et al. [9]. The
DIFs for concrete by Ross and his co-works [8–10] scatter between 1.0 to 4.0 at
strain rate 1/s to 12/s. It was mainly because of different specimen diameters,
682 Y. W. Chiu et al.
mixtures, and testing methods (Brazilian disc or direct tension). Nevertheless, the
overall trends on concrete also agree with the two types of bricks herein.
Figure 6 compares the DIFs of the two types of bricks with available popular
tensile DIF-strain rate relations for concrete. As shown, the DIF scatters for bricks
from this study aligns with the empirical trendlines by Malvar and Crawford [6] and
Ross et al. [8–10]. It is worth noting that Larcher et al. [5] measured a DIF of about
2.2 and 3.0 for Clinker and Terracotta bricks at strain rate of about 100/s through
Brazilian disc method using SHPB system. The strain rates were much higher
potentially because of much smaller diameter specimens used (40 mm diameter).
Further studies covering a wider strain rate range and using different testing
methods, i.e. Brazilian split-tension and direct tension are needed and are currently
under progress by the authors.
4 Conclusion
This study carried out Brazilian disc tests on two types of clay bricks under
quasi-static and dynamic states, which covers strain rate at 1.13 10−5/s to 10/s. It
found that the split-tensile properties of bricks are very strain rate sensitive.
Significant dynamic increase effect is found on brick strength. The corresponding
failure strain and modulus are also found to be strain rate sensitive. Through
comparing with existing data on concrete and mortar, it shows that the DIF relations
for the two tested bricks are close to the trends by Ross as well as Malvar and
Crawford for low strength concrete. Further studies are still needed to confirm
existing data on brick and to cover wider strain rate range.
References
6. Malvar LJ, Crawford JE (1998) Dynamic increase factors for concrete. Retrieved from
7. Pereira JM, Dias A, Lourenço PB (2013) Dynamic properties of clay brick at different strain
rates. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 12th canadian masonry symposium
8. Ross CA, Jerome DM, Tedesco JW, Hughes ML (1996) Moisture and strain rate effects on
concrete strength. Mater J 93(3):293–300
9. Ross CA, Tedesco JW (1989) Split-Hopkinson pressure-bar tests on concrete and mortar in
tension and compression. Mater J 86(5):475–481
10. Ross CA, Tedesco JW, Kuennen ST (1995) Effects of strain rate on concrete strength. Mater J
92(1):37–47
11. ASTM International, West Conshohocken, USA (2008) Standard test method for splitting
tensile strength of intact rock core specimens
12. Xia K, Yao W (2015) Dynamic rock tests using split Hopkinson (Kolsky) bar system–a
review. J Rock Mech Geotech Eng 7(1):27–59
13. Zhang X, Chiu Y-W, Hao H, Hsieh A, Salter N, Cui J (2018) Dynamic compressive material
properties of clay bricks at different strain rates. Constr Build Mater 192:754–767
14. Zhang X, Hao H, Shi Y, Cui J (2015) The mechanical properties of Polyvinyl Butyral
(PVB) at high strain rates. Constr Build Mater 93(Supplement C):404–415
15. Zhang X, Hao H, Shi Y, Cui J, Zhang X (2016) Static and dynamic material properties of
CFRP/epoxy laminates. Constr Build Mater 114(Supplement C):638–649
16. Zhang X, Zou Y, Hao H, Li X, Ma G, Liu K (2012) Laboratory test on dynamic material
properties of annealed float glass. Int J Protective Struct 3(4):407–430
17. Zhou Z, Ma G, Li X (2007) Dynamic Brazilian splitting and spalling tests for granite. Paper
presented at the 11th ISRM congress
Effect of Relative Density
on the Mechanical Behavior of Coral
Sand Under High Strain Rate
Xiao Yu, Li Chen, Qin Fang, Yadong Zhang, and Junyu Fan
Abstract The dry coral sand specimens confined by a steel sleeve were tested by
the spilt Hopkinson pressure bar (SHPB) system with a striker-impact velocity of
10 m/s. The effect of relative density on the mechanical behaviour of dry coral sand
was investigated. Specimens of three relative densities, namely, 10%, 50%, and
90%, which were corresponding to mass densities of 1248 kg/m3, 1373 kg/m3, and
1526 kg/m3, were tested at high strain rate around 750 s−1. Higher relative density
of coral sand contributes to higher amplitude of stress-strain curve, higher yield
stress, lower compressibility, and less energy absorption. The positive linear rela-
tionship and negative linear relationship for yield stress versus relative density and
compressibility versus relative density were respectively found; some correspond-
ing formulae were also proposed. Coral sand of lower relative density was rec-
ommended for energy absorption in the protective structures under blast loads or
impact loads.
X. Yu
Research Institute for National Defense Engineering of Academy of Military Sciences PLA
China, Beijing 100036, China
e-mail: yuxiao10@foxmail.com
L. Chen (&) Q. Fang Y. Zhang J. Fan
School of Civil Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing 210096, China
e-mail: li.chen@seu.edu.cn
Q. Fang
e-mail: fangqinjs@139.com
Y. Zhang
e-mail: zhydjs@139.com
J. Fan
e-mail: fjy7361@sina.com
1 Introduction
The design and construction of protective structures greatly depend on the local
geological environment. Coral sand, which is generated by bio-erosion of limestone
skeletal material of marine organisms, is abundant in the tropical and subtropical
marine environment. Exploration and exploitation of the ocean in recent decades
powerfully drive the bloom on investigation of mechanical properties of coral sand.
A comparative study [5] shows that the coral sand performs very different
mechanical responses from the silica sand under static loads. By using a newly
developed testing method [9], a better performance of coral sand on the
stress-wave-attenuation under impact or blast loads than silica sand was revealed
[10, 11]. The special mechanical responses under high strain rate make the coral
sand be incapable of being directly applied into the construction of protective
structures in the marine environment. Therefore, it makes the related research
become imperative.
As a typical kind of granular material, the mechanical behavior of sand can be
greatly affected by its initial physical properties, such as relative density, particle
size, and moisture content [7]. The investigation on the normal silica sand con-
ducted by Luo et al. [4] shows that the dynamic mechanical properties, such as
yield stress, compressibility, and energy-absorption capacity, can be significantly
affected by the relative density. However, the related research on the coral sand is
not reported yet.
To study the effect of relative density on the mechanical behaviors of coral sand
under high strain rate, impact experiments for the confined coral sand specimens
were conducted by using an SHPB system. The influences of relative density on the
stress-strain curve, yield stress, compressibility of coral sand, were analyzed and
discussed. Moreover, related formulae considering variation of the relative density
were also proposed.
The coral sand in the test was taken and transported from the South China Sea. The
original samples of coral sand are damp with a strong fishy smell. It is commonly
known that the coral particles own numerous micro-holes and cavities. Big particles
(bigger than 10 mm) also can be observed in the original samples, as shown in
Fig. 1. In order to meet the requirements of the test, the coral sand was processed as
the following steps. Firstly, the coral sand was dried in the drying oven at 105 °C
for 24 h. Secondly, the dry samples were then sorted by the standard sieves and a
vibrating screen machine [6], particles whose sizes were larger than 1.18 mm or
smaller than 0.075 mm were removed. The particle size distribution of the prepared
Effect of Relative Density on the Mechanical Behavior … 689
coral sand is shown in Fig. 2. Thirdly, specimens of coral sand were assembled by a
specially designed sleeve and two platens according to the particle size distribution.
The maximum and minimum mass density of coral sand were measured as
1220 kg/m3 and 1570 kg/m3 [6]. Three relative density (Dr) 10%, 50%, and 90%,
which were corresponding to mass densities of 1248 kg/m3, 1373 kg/m3, and
1526 kg/m3, were tested. Each kind of tests were conducted three times for the
cross calibration.
The specific gravities (Gs) of the coral sand was measured, and the average value
was 2.803, which agreed well with previous studies, namely, 2.88 of Lade et al. [3]
and 2.82 of Lv et al. [5].
The diameter and thickness of the cylinder sand specimen are 20 mm and 10 mm,
respectively. A steel sleeve and a pair of aluminum platens were specially designed
to assemble the sand specimen, as shown in Fig. 3. The sleeve was made of 1045
steel which is considered ‘rigid enough’ to prevent radial deformation of the sand
specimen. The inner diameter, the wall thickness, and the length of the sleeve are
20 mm, 5 mm, and 50 mm, respectively. Two pairs of screw holes were drilled
along the axial direction of the steel sleeve to fix the platens vertically to the sleeve.
The tests were conducted by an SHPB system. The diagrammatic sketch of the
apparatus is shown in Fig. 4. The length of the striker, the incident bar and the
transmission bar are 0.8 m, 6.0 m and 3.5 m, respectively. The bars share a com-
mon diameter of 20 mm. They are made of aluminum, which owns elastic modulus
and density of 70 GPa and 2700 kg/m3, respectively.
In order to keep the high strain rates around 750 s−1, the impact velocity of the
striker was set as 10 m/s. A rubber circular pulse shaper, which owns the diameter
and thickness of 14 mm and 1.0 mm, respectively, was used to increase the rising
Effect of Relative Density on the Mechanical Behavior … 691
time of the incident wave to achieve the stress equilibrium in the specimen during
the impact process.
The two-wave-method was applied to process the recorded data. The equilibrium
of stress in the specimen can be expressed as
where ei ðtÞ, et ðtÞ, and er ðtÞ denote the strain histories of incident wave, transmitted
wave, and reflected wave, respectively.
The engineering stress rðtÞ, the engineering strain rate eðtÞ and the engineering
strain eðtÞ are respectively calculated by
where E0 and C0 are the elastic modulus and the velocity of elastic wave in the bar
material. LS is the thickness of the specimen.
Stress-strain curves of the coral sand of different Dr under high strain rate are
shown in Fig. 8. It is obvious that varying of Dr certainly affects the compressive
behaviors of coral sand. Increasing of Dr can contribute to higher stress the spec-
imen sustained at the same strain, similar conclusions were also drawn by Song
et al. [8] for silica sand.
The compression curves of coral sand, namely, void ratio (e)-axial stress curves,
are shown in Fig. 9. The void ratio, which is defined as the volume of the voids
over the volume of the specimen, can be calculated by the axial strain of the
specimen as
1e
e¼ 1 ð5Þ
1 n0
694 X. Yu et al.
where n0 is the initial porosity of the sand specimen. The yield stress, which is
denoted as r0 , is the stress at the maximum curvature of the compression curves [2].
The yield stress indicates the beginning of the breakage of the sand particle. After
yielding, the specimen enters the hardening stage of strain, where the compression
curve in the semi-logarithmic scale reaches approximately a linear relation [1]. The
slope of this linear relation is defined as the compressibility, which is denoted as Cc.
r0 and Cc for coral sand of different Dr are calculated and plotted, as shown in Fig. 9.
Under the same high strain rates around 750 s−1, r0 for coral sand of Dr at 10%,
50%, and 90% are 2.88 MPa, 3.75 MPa, and 6.51 MPa, respectively. It is evident
that the increase of Dr contributes to the increase of r0 . The higher Dr means the
lower pore volume of the coral sand specimen. It makes the contact between
particles become more sufficient. As an assembled structure of particles, specimen
becomes more difficult to be compressed, which results in the ascending of r0 .
Effect of Relative Density on the Mechanical Behavior … 695
The relation between r0 and Dr is shown in Fig. 10, a linear increasing relation is
observed and fitted as
Cc for coral sand of Dr at 10%, 50%, and 90% are 0.2168, 0.1937, 0.1919,
respectively. A negative correlation represents that a higher Dr makes the coral sand
harder to be compressed. The relation between Cc and Dr is shown in Fig. 11, a
linear decrease relation is observed and fitted as
In considering the energy absorption of the sand specimen, relation between the
energy absorption per unit volume (W) and the axial stress (r) of the specimen can
be obtained by integrating the uniaxial stress-strain curve, which is expressed as
Z e
W¼ rde ð8Þ
0
The W-r curves of coral sand of Dr with 10%, 50%, and 90% are shown in
Fig. 12. As Dr decreases, the W-r curve of coral sand shifts upward, which indi-
cates a better performance of energy absorption in the specimen at high strain rate.
It is because that for the coral sand with lower Dr, insufficient contact between the
particles and a large amount of void volume allow the particles to provide larger
displacement and deformation, therefore, the specimen shows better performance of
energy absorption in the macroscopic scale under high strain rate.
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the financial supports from the National Natural
Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 51622812, 51427807, 51738011), Postdoctoral Science
Foundation (No. 2017M613379).
References
1 Introduction
2 Experiment
The SPRCC beam samples were designed according to the beams of general
concrete buildings. The dimensions and reinforcement layout of the beams are
shown in Fig. 1. Three beams were casted with the same dimensions of 1800 mm
in length, 150 mm in width and 300 mm in depth. Two main steel bars with 12 mm
in diameter were horizontally placed at the top of the beam, and another two main
steel bars with the same diameter were horizontally placed at the bottom of beam.
The stirrups with 6 mm in diameter were placed by a regular spacing of 150 mm.
The steel plate with 3 mm in thickness was welded to the stirrups at bottom of
beams. The assemblage of the steel plate and the reinforcement bars is shown in
Fig. 2. The cylinder compressive strength of the concrete was 35.7 MPa the tensile
strength was 3.8 MPa, and the Young’s modulus was 27.3 GPa. The yield strength
of the reinforcement was 335 MPa, the tensile strength was 490 MPa, and the
Young’s modulus of 200 GPa. The yield strength of the steel plate was 335 MPa,
the tensile strength was 570 MPa, and the Young’s modulus was 200 GPa.
Fig. 1 The dimensions and reinforcement layout of the SPRCC beam (in mm)
Test setting is shown in Fig. 3. In all the three tests, the SPRCC beam was
simply supported and the span was 1400 mm. The TNT explosive was placed in the
center of the top surface of the beam. The mass of TNT was set at 100, 200, and
600 g to investigate effect of charge mass on the damage of the beam.
Figure 4 shows the damage of the SPRCC beam samples after the explosion test.
There are craters generated by the explosion at the top surface of the beams, and
spalling damage occurs at both the two lateral surfaces. As shown in Fig. 4, the
depth of the craters and the damage area on lateral surface increase with TNT
charge mass increasing. Under 600 g TNT explosion, Two thick shear cracks
symmetrically appear near the lower edge of the lateral damage areas, as shown in
Fig. 4(h), and some flexure cracks appear near midspan of the beam. The com-
pressive shock wave due to the explosion caused the compressive damage of the top
surface of the beams. When the compressive wave reflected on the side and bottom
surface, the rarefaction waves were generated and caused swelling of the steel plate
and spalling of the concrete in the side and bottom of beams.
(a) Top of the sample 1 (b) Side of the sample 1 (c) Bottom of the sample 1
(100g TNT) (100g TNT) (100g TNT)
(d) Top of the sample 2 (e) Side of the sample 2 (f) Bottom of the sample 2
(200g TNT) (200g TNT) (200g TNT)
(g) Top of the sample 3 (h) Side of the sample 3 (i) Bottom of the sample 3
(600g TNT) (600g TNT) (600g TNT)
Fig. 6 Reinforcement
arrangement
3 Numerical Simulations
at that moment. The erosion technique was used to deal with the mesh distortion by
large deformation of Lagrangian element in simulation of the damage process. The
failure rule of instantaneous geometric strain was used for erosion algorithm, and its
value was set as 0.08. Only if severe damage occurred in the beam, such as
cratering and spalling, the erosion technique was employed.
3.2.1 Concrete
The RHT material model, developed by Riedel, Hiermayer and Thoma [8], was
used for modelling of concrete. This model consists of three different strength
surfaces which are the elastic limit surface, the failure surface, and the residual
strength surface. It is suitable for simulating the dynamic behaviour of concrete
from elasticity to failure under explosion and impact loading.
The parameters of the RHT material model from AUTODYN standard material
library [9]were employed for concrete, except the compressive strength and tensile
strength which were determined by concrete strength standard tests. The parameters
were: reference density q = 2.314 g/cm3; shear modulus G = 16.7 GPa; compres-
sive strength fc = 35.7 MPa; tensile strength ft = 3.8 MPa; intact failure surface
constant A = 1.6; intact failure surface exponent N = 0.61; fractured strength
constant B = 1.6; fractured strength exponent M = 0.61; damage constant
D1 = 0.04; damage constant D2 = 1; minimum strain to failure emin f = 0.01.
Figure 8 shows a comparison between the damaged areas of the SPRCC beams
obtained from the numerical simulations and those from the tests. The damage areas
of the beams from the simulations were consistent with the experiments, as shown
in Fig. 8. The concrete cracking, crack propagation and spalling process of the
SPRCC beam under the explosive loading were well simulated. The damage radius
R on side surface of the beam and midspan deflection d from the tests were
compared with the calculated results from the numerical simulations, as shown in
Table 2. Because the calculation time was shorter than the tests, the midspan
(a) 100g TNT Test (b) 200g TNT Test (c) 600g TNT Test
(d) 100g TNT Simulation (e) 200g TNT Simulation (f) 600g TNT Simulation
deflections from the simulations were smaller than those from the tests. However,
the damage radiuses on side surface of the beam from the numerical simulations
were in good agreement with the experimental results.
Figure 9 shows the variety of vertical velocity of the center points of the bottom
surface of the SPRCC beams with time under different blast loadings corresponding
to different charge mass. The maximum velocity appeared at the moment of about
0.1 ms, and the beam continued to move downward under the action of inertia. At
the time t = 5 ms, the vertical velocity was 0 m/s when the charge mass was 100 g,
indicating that the beam was already in equilibrium. At the time t = 5 ms, the
vertical velocity was 0.65 m/s when the charge mass was 200 g, indicating that the
beam was rebounding. At the time t = 5 ms, the vertical velocity was –0.76 m/s
when the charge mass was 600 g, indicating that the beam was still moving
downward.
The damage phenomena of the top and side surface of the SPRCC beams from
numerical simulations are shown in Fig. 10. The red color in the figure indicates
that the damage degree D reaches 1.0 when the concrete had been completely
damaged, whereas the blue color indicated that the damage degree D was 0 when
the concrete was not damaged [8, 9]. Under different explosive loads, the com-
pressive stress wave induced compressive damage and generated blast craters on
the top surface of the beams. After contact explosions take place, the compressive
stress wave propagated through the beams and reflected on the bottom surface of
the beams. Then the compressive stress wave turned into a tensile wave, resulting in
spalling of the concrete near the bottom of the beams and even swelling of the steel
plate.
706 X. F. Wang et al.
As the charge increased, the damage of the beams became more severe and
exhibited different modes of damage, as shown in Fig. 9. When the TNT charge
mass is 100 g, two small flexure cracks appears in the tension zone. In this case, the
damage mode of the beam was considered as locale flexure damage. When the TNT
charge mass increases to 200 g, five coarse flexure cracks appears in the tension
zone. Meanwhile, fine punching shear cracks appears on the lower side surface and
extends to the flexure cracks at the bottom of the beam. In this case, the damage
mode of the beam was considered as flexure damage coupled with weak shear.
When the TNT charge mass increases to 600 g, seven obvious flexure cracks appear
in the tension zone. Meanwhile, obvious punching shear cracks appear on the lower
side surface and extend to the bottom of the beam. An evident bulge can be seen at
the bottom of the beam, and the steel plate is partially separated from the concrete.
In this case, the damage mode of the beam was considered as composite damage of
flexure and punching shear.
Experimental Study and Numerical Simulation … 707
However, the restraint by the steel plate can prevent the spalling delamination
and crush of the concrete, which can significantly improve blast-resistance of the
RC beams. Due to the constraints of the steel plate, the SPRCC beams have good
anti-explosion performance.
5 Conclusions
The explosion tests and numerical simulations were conducted to study the damage
modes of the SPRCC beams under contact explosion load of different TNT charge
mass detonations.
A three-dimensional numerical model, including the air, the explosive and the
SPRCC beams was established to simulate the experiments. The dynamic response
of the SPRCC beam was simulated by using appropriate material models which
considered strain rate effects. The fluid-solid interface was modelled by employing
proper contact model. The damage process of the concrete was simulated by using
the erosion technique. The comparison between the numerical simulation results
and the experimental data indicated that the present simulation method can reliably
predicts the damage of all the SPRCC beams in this study.
After contact explosions take place, the compressive stress wave propagates
through the beams and reflects on the bottom surface of the beams. Then the
compressive stress wave turns into a tensile wave, resulting in spalling of the
concrete near the bottom of the beams. With increasing of the explosive charge
mass, damage mode of the SPRCC beam gradually changes from local flexure
damage to composite damage of local flexure and punching shear.
Based on the experimental and numerical results, the SPRCC beams have good
anti-explosion performance, due to the constraints of the steel plate.
References
1. Nie JG, Zhao J (2008) Experimental study on simply supported steel plate-concrete composite
beams. China Civ Eng J 44(12):28–34
2. Nie JG, Yu ZW (1999) Research and practice of composite steel-concrete beams in china.
China Civ Eng J 32(2):3–8
3. Oduyemi TOS, Wright HD (1989) An experimental investigation into the behaviour of
double-skin sandwich beams. J Constr Steel Res 14(3):197–220
4. Wright HD, Oduyemi TOS, Evans HR (1991) The experimental behaviour of double skin
composite elements. J Constr Steel Res 19(2):97–110
5. Watson AJ, Hulton FG, Pope DJ (1997) An experimental study of steel plate bonding to
concrete slabs under close-in explosions. In: Proceeding of the 8th international symposium
on interaction of the effects of munitions with structures. Defense Nuclear Agency, Mclean,
pp 971–979
6. Tian ZM, Zhan JH, Jiang SY (2015) Damage assessment for steel-concrete composite beams
subjected to blast loading. J Vib Shock 35(4):42–48
708 X. F. Wang et al.
7. Han Y, Fan DZ, Liu S (2017) Tests for Effect of encased steel plate on anti-impact
performance of a RC Pier. J Vib Shock 36(23):175–180
8. Riedel W, Thoma K, Hiermaier S, Schmolinske E (1999) Penetration of reinforced concrete
by BETA-B-500 numerical analysis using a new macroscopic concrete model for hydrocodes.
In: Proceeding of the ninth international symposium on interaction of the effects of munitions
with structures. Federal Republic of Germany, Berlin, pp 315–322
9. AUTODYN (2006) Theory Manual, Revision 4.3. Century Dynamics Inc., Horseham
10. Johnson GR, Cook WK (1983) A constitutive model and data for metals subjected to large
strains high strain rates and high temperatures. In: Proceedings of the seventh international
symposium on Ballistics, American Defense Preparedness Association, Hague, pp 541–547
Resistance of Lattice Core Sandwich
Cylinders to Internal Blast Loading
Abstract Explosion has been a serious threat in military and civil, accordingly the
blast resistance capacity is an important indication in design and optimization of
structure to ensure the safety of device and person. Here the resistance of sandwich
cylinder with different lattice cores to internal blast loading is explored numerically.
Six core geometries are selected: square, hexagonal, semi-re-entrant, re-entrant,
sinusoidal and Kagome honeycombs, and each geometry have two arrangements:
circular and axial. Based on the numerical results, the effects of core geometry and
arrangement on the dynamic response, deformation mode and energy dissipation of
sandwich cylinders are discussed in detail. Results reveal that sandwich cylinders
experience progressive deformation during blasting and the final deformation
modes are closely affected by core geometries and arrangements. Analysis about the
blast resistance shows that circular arrangement improves the deformation extent of
outer shell and energy absorption efficiency of sandwich cylinder, however the
weak radial stiffness leads to the heavily compression extent and energy absorption
scale of lattice core with axial arrangement.
Keywords Metal sandwich cylinder Lattice core Blast resistance Dynamic
plasticity Finite element simulation
1 Introduction
Over the past decades, the blast resistance capacity becomes an important indication
in design and optimization of structure to ensure the safety of the internal device
and person. Comparing with other configurations, sandwich structures enhanced by
various cores take predominate advantageous in explosion-proof because of diverse
deformation and energy dissipation mechanisms [3], hence sandwich structure
become a competitive candidate for safety protection.
Many researches about the dynamic response and blast resistance of sandwich
structures have been reported [1, 2, 6], and varies factors on the performance of
sandwich structures have been investigated. However, some competing conclusions
from different references are obtained because of the distinct materials and test
methods, therefore more systematic investigations are required.
The objective of this work is to numerically investigate dynamic response of
sandwich cylinders with various lattice cores subjected to internal blast loading in
order to give an insight into deformation mechanism and energy absorption
capacity with the help of software LS-DYNA. The organization of this paper is as
follows. Firstly, the problem of sandwich cylinder subjected to internal blast
loading and details to establish the finite element model are briefly described. Then,
we present dynamic response of sandwich cylinders with various lattice cores and
discuss effects of core geometry and arrangement, also the blast resistance of
sandwich cylinders is studied. Finally, concluding remarks are presented.
Consider a closed sandwich cylinder subjected to the internal blast loading, the
cylinder consists of lattice core, inner and outer shells, and two covers. The lattice
core has the dimension of height Hc, internal diameter Din, external diameter Dout,
and core wall thickness tc, and the thickness of inner shell, outer shell, and cover are
denoted by tin, tout and tco, respectively, the TNT charge with mass of mTNT is
located at the centre, Fig. 1 shows the scheme and parameters of sandwich cylinder.
To study the effect of configuration of lattice core on the performance of cylinder,
six core geometries are selected: square, hexagonal, semi-re-entrant, re-entrant,
sinusoidal and Kagome (increased by relative density of cell), meanwhile two
arrangements so called circular and axial are employed for each core geometry,
hence twelve configurations of lattice cores are proposed herein, see Fig. 2.
Resistance of Lattice Core Sandwich Cylinders … 711
Fig. 1 Scheme of sandwich cylinder against internal blasting, where Hc = 160 mm, Din
= 200 mm, Dout = 260 mm, tc = 0.66 mm, tin = tout= 2 mm, tco = 10 mm, mTNT = 80 g (tc and
mTNT are not marked here)
Fig. 2 Scheme of a cell geometries, b front view for circular arranged cores and c top view for
axial arranged cores, where the lowest relative density of core geometry is square, followed by
hexagonal, semi-re-entrant, re-entrant, sinusoidal and Kagome
Fig. 4 Movement histories of a circular arranged and b axial arranged sandwich cylinders with
square cells
714 J. F. Li et al.
Fig. 5 Final deformations of lattice cores a circular arrangement and b axial arrangement
deformation mode for circular arranged cores, whereas the significant compression
and folding of cells are observed for axial arranged cores.
Figure 6 depicts the dimensionless maximum radial deflections of outer shells of
closed sandwich cylinders (Dout ¼ DDout =Dout ), from which it is observed that
circular arrangement significantly increase the deformation extent of outer shell,
which is attributed to the higher radial stiffness of circular arranged cylinders. At the
same time, the radial deflections of circular arranged cylinders tend to first increase
then decrease with the increase of relative density of cells, whereas the perfor-
mances of axial arranged sandwich cylinders are somewhat irregular. One credible
explain for this difference is that higher relative density of cell improves the radial
Resistance of Lattice Core Sandwich Cylinders … 715
stiffness of circular arranged core, hence the ability to transmit radial force to outer
shell become stronger correspondingly, however, high stiffness of lattice core
strengthen the protection of outer shell, as a result, under these two contradictory
effects, the tendency that first increase then decrease is observed. When it comes to
axial arranged cylinders, force capacity of lattice cores mainly depend on the core
geometries, such as hexagonal cell would expand under compression but
semi-re-entrant cell would fully fold, consequently the different mechanical char-
acters of core geometries make the performances of outer shells and the final radial
deflections seems to be somewhat irregular.
Figure 7 depicts the final internal energy of various sandwich cylinders, and
energy ratio of each part is displayed. For circular arranged cylinders, configuration
with re-entrant cells presents the most energy absorption capacity but the hexagonal
cell contributes the least energy absorption capacity. However, for axial arranged
cylinders, configurations with re-entrant and hexagonal cells possess the least and
the most energy absorption capacities respectively, this interesting contradiction
reveals that the energy absorption of cylinder is not simply depends on the core
geometry or core arrangement but the comprehensive effect of these two factors.
Furthermore, comparison between Fig. 7 (a) and (b) shows that covers of circular
arranged cylinders occupy the least scale of internal energy and the other three parts
occupy the roughly equivalent proportion, when it comes to axial arranged cylin-
ders, outer shell plays the least role in energy absorption and the internal energy of
lattice core is much more than other parts. Combining with the previous conclu-
sions it is certainly that axial arrangement cannot effectively resist blast loading and
transmit radial force, therefore the compression extent of lattice cores of axial
arranged cylinders is much heavily than circular arranged cylinders.
716 J. F. Li et al.
Fig. 7 Energy absorptions of sandwich cylinders with a circular arrangements and b axial
arrangements
4 Concluding Remarks
The resistance of closed sandwich cylinders with different lattice cores subjected to
internal blast loading is investigated by using finite element method, and the
influences of core geometry and arrangement on the performance of cylinder are
discussed in detail. Numerical results point out that cylinders undergo progressive
dynamic response during blasting, and the regions that closest to TNT charge
present the most remarkable deformations. Analysis about the resistance perfor-
mance reveals that circular arrangement improves the deformation extent of outer
shell and energy absorption efficiency of sandwich cylinder. Furthermore, the radial
stiffness of axial arranged cylinders are significantly stronger than those of axial
arranged cylinders, consequently the compression extent of lattice cores of axial
arranged cylinders is much heavily than those of circular arranged cylinders.
Acknowledgements The authors are gratefully acknowledge financial support from NSFC
(11572234 and 11502189), opening project of State Key Laboratory of Explosion Science and
Technology (Beijing Institute of Technology, KFJJ18-07 M), Natural Science Basic Research Plan
in Shaanxi Province of China (2017JM1020), China Postdoctoral Science Foundation funded
project (2015M572546), and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities.
References
1. Imbalzano G, Linforth S, Ngo TD, Lee PVS, Tran P (2018) Blast resistance of auxetic and
honeycomb sandwich panels: comparisons and parametric designs. Compos Struct 183:242–
261
2. Li S, Li X, Wang Z, Wu G, Lu G, Zhao L (2016) Finite element analysis of sandwich panels
with stepwise graded aluminum honeycomb cores under blast loading. Compos A Appl Sci
Manuf 80:1–12
3. Pan Z, Liu J, Cheng Y, Hou H, Wang C, Yong L (2015) Dynamic response of metallic
trapezoidal corrugated-core sandwich panels subjected to air blast loading – an experimental
study. Mater Des 65(65):221–230
4. Suazo G, Villavicencio G (2018) Numerical simulation of the blast response of cemented paste
backfilled stopes. Comput Geotech 100:1–14
5. Zhu F, Zhao L, Lu G, Gad E (2009) A numerical simulation of the blast impact of square
metallic sandwich panels. Int J Impact Eng 36(5):687–699
6. Zhu F, Zhao L, Lu G, Wang Z (2008) Deformation and failure of blast-loaded metallic
sandwich panels—experimental investigations. Int J Impact Eng 35(8):937–951
Dynamic Behavior of Jacket Foundation
for Offshore Wind Turbine Subjected
to Ship Impact
Abstract Offshore wind energy has been widely used and becomes a new strategy
for promoting sustainable development in coastal countries. Foundation is the
support structure of the offshore wind turbine (OWT), and its safety relates to the
normal operation of the whole wind turbine generator system. Dynamic response of
the jacket foundation for OWT caused by ship impact has been investigated
numerically. The impact processes between a jacket foundation for 3.0 MW OWT
and a cargo with the dead weight of 3000t have been modelled using ADINA
considering the effect of ship speed, collision position and joint strength. The
influence of impact damage on the load-bearing capacity of the jacket foundation
has also be discussed in this study. Results show that a positive correlation exists
between impact force and impact velocity. Impact upon the tubular joints results in
larger impact force but smaller indentation than that happened to chords and braces.
Increasing the wall thickness of tubular joints will decrease the impact displacement
but increase the impact force. Impact damage may not result in the collapse of the
jacket foundation, but the bending moment and shear force increase dramatically in
the structure members adjacent to the damaged structural elements due to the
internal force redistribution. The findings in this paper contribute to the design and
retrofit of the jacket foundation for OWTs.
Keywords Ship impact Offshore wind turbine Energy absorption Finite
element method Load-bearing capacity
1 Introduction
2 Numerical Simulations
mass points added to the top of the tower. The FE model including the distribution
of concentrated mass points is shown in Fig. 3.
The damage of ship caused by collision was not considered in the present study,
it was simplified into a bow and a centralized mass point on the ship’s mass centre.
The bow and the centralized mass point are connected by means of master-slave
constrains in ADINA. The bow was regarded as a rigid body and moves in the same
way as the master node, as shown in Fig. 4. It is assumed that the ship-OWT
collision occurs in the diagonal direction of the jacket foundation, and the initial
distance between the collision point and the ship is 620 mm. The four legs were
fixed at the mud surface without considering the pile-soil interaction. The whole FE
model included 1296 beam elements and 8026 shell elements, and the other ele-
ments were rigid body elements and mass elements.
The bilinear plastic model was assigned to the collision zone considering the von
Mises yield criterion, and element deletion was controlled by failure strain. The
non-collision zone was assumed to keep elastic under impact loading. The specific
material parameters used in the study are reported in Table 2.
In order to prevent the structural components from penetrating each other,
contact pairs was defined in the collision zone. The self-contact was also defined for
Dynamic Behavior of Jacket Foundation … 723
Fig. 3 Distribution of
concentrated mass points for
the simplified tower model
the possible contact within a single component due to the large deformation. Apart
from the contact nonlinear behaviour, the geometric nonlinearity including large
displacement and the large strain was also considered for the elements in the
collision zone.
724 D. W. Gao and C. W. Zhang
Fig. 5 Maximum displacement histories of collision zone under different collision speed
In order to assess the collision speed on the dynamic behaviour of the jacket
foundation, ship-OWT collision is simulated by changing the ship speed v to be 5, 3
and 1 m/s. The collision zone is the top of the jacket leg. Figure 5 plots the
maximum displacement histories of the jacket leg at different collision speed. It can
be seen that the jacket leg experienced a peak deformation followed by a rebound
Dynamic Behavior of Jacket Foundation … 725
process, then the collision process ceased, leading to the permanent structural
deformations. It is clear that the increase in the collision speed significantly causes
an increase in structural peak displacement.
Figure 6 shows the deformation and stress distribution of jacket legs at three dif-
ferent collision locations. It is observed that the area of stress distribution corre-
sponding to the middle collision is relatively small compared to that caused by the
collision at other locations, but the stress value is relatively large. The is due to the
middle zone of tubular joint possesses relatively high stiffness. Therefore, in order
to ensure the safety of tubular joints, this zone should be properly strengthened.
The effect of tubular joint thickness on the displacement histories of tubular K-Joint
(Fig. 7) is studied considering three wall thickness of 25, 30 and 35 mm. Figure 8
shows the displacement-time curves where the collision velocity is kept constant,
while the wall thickness is increased from 25 to 35 mm. It is observed that
increasing the wall thickness can significantly decrease the deformation of the joint
zone and reduce the time duration of the collision process.
Fig. 6 Deformation and stress of jacket leg at different collision locations, A top position;
B middle position; C bottom position
726 D. W. Gao and C. W. Zhang
Local damage or collapse of OWTs may occur after encountering ship collision.
When local damage exists, the strength of the component will decrease, and the
path of force transmission may change greatly, which may ultimately reduce the
overall load-bearing capacity of the foundation structure.
In order to study the effect of local collision damage on the load-bearing capacity
of OWT, the damaged jacket foundation which is collided by the ship at speed of
5 m/s is introduced, and the OWT is loaded by an extreme marine loading at the
foundation flange as shown in Fig. 9. The loading value and direction are reported
in Table 3. The response of the OWT structure before and after damage under
concentrated forces and bending moments is obtained in terms of the tower-top
displacement, maximum bending moment and maximum shear force, as shown in
Table 4. it can be seen that the displacement of the top of the tower increases after
the damage of the structural members under extreme loads in both directions, but
the increment is small. This is due to the loading position is close to the foundation
which still has great lateral stiffness after the local damage. Compared to tower-top
displacement, the maximum bending moment and maximum shear force of the
structural components increase greatly under extreme loading in two directions
because of the damage, which increases the “burden” of some structural compo-
nents and reduces the load-bearing capacity of the OWT foundation.
Table 4 Structural response before and after damage under extreme load
Loading Before damage After damage
direction Tower-top Maximum Maximum Tower-top Maximum Maximum
displacement bending shear force displacement bending shear force
(mm) moment of of (mm) moment of of
component component component component
(kN m) (kN) (kN m) (kN)
X 372.98 67.7 6.3 392.92 716.2 184.2
Same as 344.99 150.1 20.7 345.76 1144.8 380.0
collision
direction
3 Conclusions
In this paper, the ship-OWT collision is simulated by the explicit dynamic finite
element analysis method using ADINA. The effects of ship speed, collision location
and wall thickness of tubular K-Joints on the collision processes are investigated.
The influence of impact damage on the load-bearing capacity of OWT is studied
based on damaged OWT structure. It is observed that higher ship speed results in
increasing indentation, because the ship has a larger amount of kinetic energy. The
collision at tubular joint zone results in smaller stress area but higher stress value
because of the higher stiffness. Increasing the wall thickness at tubular joint zone
contributes to the decrease of structural deformation and reduces the time duration
of the collision process. The OWT structure may still have sufficient load-bearing
capacity after collision damage. However, due to the redistribution of force, the
bending moment and shear force of the structural components will greatly increase.
Hence, in order to improve the safety of OWT after collision damage, the structural
components adjacent to the collision zone should be strengthened.
References
1. Biehl F, Lehmann E (2006) Collisions of ships with offshore wind turbines: calculation and
risk evaluation. In: Offshore wind energy. Springer, pp 281–304
2. De Oliveria J (1981) The behavior of steel offshore structures under accidental collisions.
Paper presented at the offshore technology conference
3. Graczykowski C, Holnicki-Szulc J (2009) Protecting offshore wind turbines against ship
impacts by means of adaptive inflatable structures. Shock Vibr 16(4):335–353
4. Hu Z, Cui W, Xiao L, Yang J (2007) Research on collision mechanism for a ship colliding
with a spar platform. Paper presented at the ASME 2007 26th international conference on
offshore mechanics and arctic engineering
5. Jones N, Jouri W (1987) A study of plate tearing for ship collision and grounding damage.
J Ship Res 31(04):253–268
6. Kroondijk R (2012) High energy ship collisions with bottom supported offshore wind
turbines. Institutt for marin teknikk
7. Lee K (2013) Effects on the various rubber fenders of a tripod offshore wind turbine
substructure collision strength due to boat. Ocean Eng 72:188–194
8. McDermott JF, Kline RG, Jones E, Maniar NM, Chiang WP (1974) Tanker structural analysis
for minor collisions
9. Pedersen PT (2002) Collision risk for fixed offshore structures close to high-density shipping
lanes. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part M J Eng Maritime Environ 216(1):29–44
10. Samsonovs A, Giuliani L, Zania V (2014) Soil structure interaction in offshore wind turbine
collisions. Paper presented at the IX international conference on structural dynamics
(EURODYN 2014)
11. Tabri K, Broekhuijsen J, Matusiak J, Varsta P (2009) Analytical modelling of ship collision
based on full-scale experiments. Marine Struct 22(1):42–61
12. Tabri K, Matusiak J, Varsta P (2009) Sloshing interaction in ship collisions—an experimental
and numerical study. Ocean Eng 36(17–18):1366–1376
13. Vaughan H (1978) Bending and tearing of plate with application to ship-bottom damage.
Naval Architect 97–99
14. Wang G, Ohtsubo H (1997) Deformation of ship plate subjected to very large load. Paper
presented at the proceedings of the international conference on offshore mechanics and arctic
engineering
15. Wang L, Yang L, Huang D, Zhang Z, Chen G (2008) An impact dynamics analysis on a new
crashworthy device against ship–bridge collision. Int J Impact Eng 35(8):895–904
16. Chen W, Pham TM, Elchalakani M, Li H, Hao H, Chen L (2020) Experimental and numerical
study of basalt FRP Strip strengthened RC slabs under impact loads. Int J Struct Stab Dyn 20
(06):2040001
17. Gao D, Zhang C (2018) Theoretical and numerical investigation on in-plane impact
performance of chiral honeycomb core structure. J Struct Integrity Maint 3(2):95–105
18. Zhang X, Zhang C, Duan Z (2009) Numerical simulation on impact responses and failure
modes of steel frame structural columns subject to blast loads. J Shenyang Jianzhu Univ
(Natural Science) 25(4):656–662
19. Zhang X, Duan Z, Zhang C (2008) Numerical simulation of dynamic response and collapse
for steel frame structures subjected to blast load. Trans Tianjin Univ 14(SUPPL):523–529
20. Gholipour G, Zhang C, Mousavi AA (2020) Nonlinear numerical analysis and progressive
damage assessment of a cable-stayed bridge pier subjected to ship collision. Marine Struct
69:102662
Interfacial Bond Behaviour of Fiber
Reinforced Polymer Sheets Externally
Bonded to Geopolymer Concrete
1 Introduction
To reduce the emission of CO2 from the Ordinary Portland cement concrete
(OPC) industry, geopolymer concrete (GPC) has been developed and used as green
construction material [4]. Fibre-reinforced polymer sheet has been widely used to
strengthen the existing concrete structures [7]. Interfacial bonding behaviour is a
critical factor determining the composite action between FRP and concrete [2, 8].
The bonding mechanism between FRP and OPC has been well studied [9]; however
no study has been conducted on the bonding behaviour between FRP and GPC.
2 Experimental Study
Three GPC and three OPC blocks with dimension of 150 150 350 mm were
prepared in this test program. The designed concrete grade was 40 MPa for both
GPC and OPC. The coarse aggregate size was in the range of 5–10 mm. The mix
proportions of the GPC and OPC are provided in Table 1. The average compressive
strength and tensile strength after 28 days was 40.03 and 4.75 MPa for OPC and
43.40 and 4.27 MPa for GPC, respectively. The bonding length and width of BFRP
sheet was 200 and 40 mm, respectively. The nominal thickness of BFRP sheet was
0.12 mm. The strength and Young’s modulus of the BFRP was 1333 MPa and 73
GPa, respectively. Two layers of BFRP sheets were used to bond the concrete
substrate. A 50 mm unbonded region was reserved to eliminate the effect of con-
crete edge.
The single-lap shear tests were performed by using the universal testing
machine, as shown in Fig. 1 (L). The loading rate was 0.3 mm/min in this testing
program. Figure 2 shows the graphs of debonding failure after testing. It was
observed that the debonding initiated from the concrete layer for both GPC and
OPC, indicating that the debonding cracking penetrated from the tensile side of
concrete. As compared to the OPC, the fracture depth of GPC was shallower and
less amount of coarse aggregates were pulled out from concrete substrate. It might
be due to the stronger interfacial transition zone (ITZ) of GPC than OPC. The
BFRP-OPC experiences higher bond strength and peak shear stress than
BFRP-GPC as shown in Fig. 1 (R). It is because the OPC has slightly higher
average tensile strength (4.75 MPa) than GPC (4.27 MPa).
Figure 3 illustrates the strain contours of the tested specimens. Based on the DIC
technique, the FRP surface strain distributions can be obtained accordingly.
Fig. 1 (L) Testing setup; (R) Testing results (3 OPC-BFRP and 3 GPC-BFRP specimens)
Different loading stages before initial debonding stage (i.e. 0.4P, 0.6P, 0.8P, P) and
loading stages after P (i.e. P1, P2, P3 and P4) representing debonding propagation
were selected to represent the debonding process, as shown in Fig. 4. The GPC and
OPC exhibited similar strain profile in general. The ultimate strain of BFRP-GPC
and BFRP-OPC was 1.437 and 1.684%, respectively. The ultimate debonding strain
of the BFRP-OPC was higher than BFRP-GPC, which was due to the higher tensile
strength of OPC.
Figure 5 shows the obtained bond-slip responses. It should be noted that the
distance of 100, 130 and 160 mm refers to the strain transfer length at different time
instants. It was observed that OPC and GPC exhibited similar results. The
ascending branch and descending branch were observed for all the tested speci-
mens. The ascending and descending branches refer to the elastic stage and
microcracking stage, respectively. The average peak shear stress of BFRP-GPC and
BFRP-OPC was 5.29 and 5.67 MPa, respectively.
734 C. Yuan et al.
1.2
P3
1.0 P4
0.8 Debonding propagation
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0 50 100 150 200
Distance from the loaded end (mm)
10 10
100 mm 100 mm
130 mm 130 mm
8 8 160 mm
160 mm
Shear stress (MPa)
Shear stress (MPa)
6 6
4 4
2 2
0 0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Slip (mm) Slip (mm)
(a) OPC_2B_2 (b) GPC_2B_2
Fig. 6 Comparison of
16 y=x
predicted and experimental ACI modified model
debonding loads for CNR modified model
14
BFRP-GPC fib modified model
12
Pexp. (kN)
10
6
6 8 10 12 14 16
Ppre. (kN)
3 Analytical Study
Based on the existing codes, such as ACI 440.2R [1], CNR-DT 200 [3] and fib
Bulletin 14 [5], the bonding strength empirical models were proposed for the
BFRP-GPC. The coefficients A, B and C from the existing codes were re-calibrated
based on the testing data. The coefficients and the proposed equations are sum-
marized in Table 2. Figure 6 compares the predicted and experimental debonding
loads for BFRP-GPC interfaces. The predicted debonding loads by using modified
bond strength models are in good agreement with the testing data.
4 Conclusion
References
1. ACI (2004) Guide test methods for fiber-reinforced polymers (FRP) for reinforcing or
strengthening concrete structures. Michigan (USA): American Concrete Institute (ACI)
2. Chen W, Pham TM, Sichembe H, Chen L, Hao H (2018) Experimental study of flexural
behaviour of RC beams strengthened by longitudinal and U-shaped basalt FRP sheet. Compos
Part B Eng 134:114–126
3. Council NR (2013) Guide for the design and construction of externally bonded FRP systems
for strengthening existing structures CNR-DT200
4. Davidovits J (1988) Geopolymer chemistry and properties. Paper presented at the Geopolymer
5. du Béton FI fib (CEB-FIP) Model Code 2010: First complete draft. Bulletin, 55
6. Nath P, Sarker PK (2014) Effect of GGBFS on setting, workability and early strength
properties of fly ash geopolymer concrete cured in ambient condition. Constr Build Mater
66:163–171. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2014.05.080
7. Smith ST, Teng J (2002) FRP-strengthened RC beams. I: review of debonding strength models.
Eng Struct 24(4):385–395
8. Wu Y-F, Jiang C (2013) Quantification of bond-slip relationship for externally bonded
FRP-to-concrete joints. J Compos Constr 17(5):673–686
9. Yuan C, Chen W, Pham TM, Hao H (2019) Effect of aggregate size on bond behaviour
between basalt fibre reinforced polymer sheets and concrete. Compos Part B Eng 158:459–474
Experimental and Theoretical Research
on Tensile Resistance Capacity
of Eight-Bolted Footplate in Steel
Transmission Tower
Abstract Nowadays transmission line tower have been developing towards high
voltage, large capacity and multi loop in electric transmission projects. The load on
those towers constantly increases resulting in the strength of the tower foundation
needs to be updated as well. The traditional foundation with four-bolted baseplate
therefore can no longer achieve the requirement of existing new projects, while the
eight-bolted one gains wider attention and shows much more application potential.
However, the relevant theoretical research and design specifications of the bearing
capacity of the eight-bolted baseplate are still far complete, which severely affect its
practical applications. Given this, this paper carries out the experimental and the-
oretical research on the tensile capacity of the eight-bolted baseplate. First, groups
of test specimens were selected to conduct the static loading test, in which their
stress state and failure mode were observed, and the influence of baseplate thickness
and bolt locations on the tensile capacity was investigated. On the basis, Yield
Hinge Line (YHL) method for calculating tensile resistance capacity of this kind of
baseplates is presented in the paper. It considers some critical factors such as
baseplate thickness and bolt locations. It additionally considers an appropriate
safety reserve under the idea of “plastic analysis and elastic design” so as to
X. M. Xue (&)
Department of Civil Engineering, Xi’an Jiaotong University, 710049 Xi’an, China
e-mail: xuexm@xjtu.edu.cn
H. L. Yuan
Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology, Xi’an 710055, China
e-mail: 742901334@qq.com
X. M. Wang F. Wen
Northwest Electric Power Design Institute of China Power Engineering Consulting Group,
Xi’an 710075, China
e-mail: 149202553@qq.com
F. Wen
e-mail: 23210434@qq.com
facilitate structural design. Finally, the results calculated by the method are com-
pared to the others by design specification and experiment. It shows more consistent
and close to the experimental results, which is testified preferable in real
engineering.
1 Introduction
Transmission towers are often installed with certain foundations that connect the
upper tower structure that associates overhead power lines [8]. The tower is sub-
jected to various unexpected damages from a wide range of extreme weather events
such as hurricanes, tornadoes, and ice storm. Figure 1 shows the broken shield wire
and damaged the tower wings with lifted foundation caused by heavy ice loading
(Allteck report).
The size of transmission towers increases with electric demand and the size of
their foundation also increases to efficiently support the larger transmission towers
[3]. A foundation reinforced with additional structures is often used to improve
foundation performance. For example, a protective baseplate anchored by several
bolts [5] (also called bolted baseplate) under the tower structure to reduce the
differential settlement of the foundation [11]. Due to its high carrying capacity as
well as flexible construction, the bolted baseplate connection is then widely used as
an important component especially in China. It is typically fabricated by welding a
steel base plate across the boot plate end and using several anchor bolts placed
around the base plate [5] (see Fig. 2). As one type of the bolted plate, baseplate with
four bolts was the most common in the related projects, however it cannot meet the
needs of the actual projects. Instead, another type baseplate with eight bolts gains
more attention because it is more suitable for larger loads. The eight-bolted one can
be divided into two types: flexible plate and rigid plate. Among them, the flexible
one has a simple structure and less welds. The rigid plate has a larger rigidity, and
presents less deformation with more uniform stress distribution.
Boot plate
Base plate
A large number of completed studies have carried out on bolted flange plate
connection in between the main structures (mostly in latticed column). Kato
developed 3D model with yield line pattern to simulate the flange-plate connections
with bolts along four sides of a hollow structure [2]. Pack developed investigations
on the behavior of bolted flange-plate connections between rectangular hollow
structure sections [9]. Wang studied the behavior of flange-plate connection under
pure-bending and next proposed a design model for its prediction bending capacity
[10]. As for the eight-bolted baseplate connection at foundation, there are no
industry standards that provide specific requirements for the analysis in latticed
steel transmission structures [5]. Since current design code in China [1] has stip-
ulated a certain design method, but it is far away to perfection. Thus, it is very
crucial to investigate the force mechanism of this connection in depth for conve-
nience of practical engineering design.
In consideration of the background, this paper is set out to study eight-bolted
baseplate connection experimentally and theoretically. Firstly tensile test is carried
out to aim at investigating the mechanical characteristics and the bearing capacities
under different design configurations. On the basis, a design method is proposed for
predicting the tensile bearing capacity of this connection by using the Yield Line
Method (YLM). And the proposed approach is finally verified accurately and
practicably with a good agreement to the test data. Note the paper use “baseplate” to
represent “eight-bolted baseplate connection” later for short.
2 Tensile Experiment
Firstly, the tensile bearing capacity test of the baseplate is carried out to investigate
the mechanical characteristics and the bearing capacities under different configu-
rations (different baseplate thickness, bolt position, etc.).
740 X. M. Xue et al.
In this paper, 14 specimens were selected in the test whose configuration dimen-
sions are designed in Table 1. The test setup and its loading are schematically
explained in Fig. 3. Firstly reaction set converts the pressure to tension under the
action of pressure jack. Then by the delivery function of loading set from reaction
set, connection device finally realizes the uploading the horizontal tension to the
specimen. Figure 4 shows the basic construction of a flexible baseplate. And this
test considered the flexible as well as rigid baseplates in Fig. 5 and 6.
As referred in Fig. 5 and 6, note t is the baseplate’s thickness, S1, S2, S3, S4 are
the distances as referred, St, Sl and Sh are separately thickness, length and height of
stiffener, Ct and Ch are separately thickness and height of the baseplate, and r is the
diameter of the bolt hole.
The measuring points are arranged on one side of the baseplate. In Fig. 5, the points
of strain gauge is chosen based on the simulation results that presented relative
large strain values. As for the points of displacement gauge, they are chosen
according to the maximum deformation (point 4) and some reference points (point 2
and point 3) in Fig. 6.
bootplate
S3 S3
S2 S2
Stiffener
Anchor bolt hole
baseplate
As shown in Fig. 7(a), the X-direction strain at 23 point reaches a maximum value
of 3096 106 while the ultimate tensile load is 426 ton. In Fig. 5(b), the max
Y-direction strain at 42 point is 2290 106 at the same ultimate load. It can be
seen that the strain of all the measuring points is lower than 3116 106 (i.e. the
average value of measured yield strain from the material performance test before)
except for some few points. It demonstrates that the specimen is basically intact
within yield strength. The capacity failure is mainly attributed to the other weaker
components.
Next by the case of specimen No. 10, the X-direction strain at 45 point reaches a
maximum value of 10118 106 while the ultimate tensile load is 250 ton (see
Fig. 8(a)). Similarly the max Y-direction strain at 8 point is 8812 106 in Fig. 8
(b). The strain at most of the measuring points is much higher than yield strain. It
demonstrates overused far beyond yield strength.
From the load-displacement curve in Fig. 9, the deformation rule is consistent with
the strain one. The curve is roughly divided into linear phase and nonlinear phase.
When the specimen goes though the second phase to the maximum load, it can no
Experimental and Theoretical Research … 743
longer continue to bear anymore load. With a view to certain safety reserve, the
actual bearing capacity should be used below the maximum one to a reasonable
extent. Hence double tangent method is adopted here to determine the bearing
capacity of baseplate connection in real usage.
Double tangent method is executed as follows. As shown in Fig. 9, two tangent
lines can be found out separately from the linear phase and nonlinear phase in every
specimen case. Then the intersection point of these two lines shows up, whose
corresponding load value is just the bearing capacity we are searching for.
Since the load-displacement curve isn’t actually smooth due to its discreteness of
the test data, the selection of the tangent needs to set a specific rule. First remove
few divergent data points. Herein define ki as the tangent slope that is the slope of
the connecting line from the i + 1 th point to the i th point. Next we also define
dðiÞ ¼ ðki þ 1 ki Þ=ki as tangent slop rate that explains the change rate of slope at
the i th point. The two tangents will stand out as soon as tangent slope rate is less
than 3% and meanwhile its mean value within 5 points is less than 10% (in case
few slopes are not uniformly changed along load progressing). By double tangent
method the specimen are all predicted of the bearing capacities, which can guar-
antee at least 25% safety to its ultimate capacities.
744 X. M. Xue et al.
3mm 8mm
a 7 b 9
In light of it, this paper employs Yield Hinge Line (YHL) to predict bearing
capacity. It uses a plastic collapse mechanism approach, based on interpretation of
experiment evidence [4]. As shown in Fig. 11, baseplate are axial symmetric,
whereby it can be divided by four sections (labeled Section I). By using YHL,
Section I would be divided into 6 rigid pieces by several yield hinge lines (see
Fig. 11(b)), where the section can deform along these hinge lines. In addition,
tensile load on baseplate would be dispersed into anchor bolts (at the bolt centers O
and P). In there, we assume a minute displacement d arises perpendicularly to the
plate plane.
(1) Rotation angle along yield lines
Geometric deformation of Section I is based on the assumption of 6 rigid pieces
coordinated along the yield lines. Thus the rotation angle of each yield line can be
given by the follows.
The rotation angle of the piece AOB (BOC) along the support hinge line AB
(BC) is
d d
h1 ¼ h2 ¼ ð1Þ
Y1 X2
d d
h5 ¼ ðctga1 þ ctgb1 Þ ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
ffi ðctga1 þ ctgb1 ÞÞ ð3Þ
OB X1 þ Y22
2
plastic bending moments and their corresponding rotation angles. In this case, the
total inner energy of plastic bending moments work on yield lines organized by
b1 a1 b2 a2 1 1
Win ¼ 2Mp d þ þ 2Mp d þ þ Mp dd1 þ ð4Þ
X1 Y1 X2 Y2 d2 d3
t2 fy
where Mp is plastic ultimate bending moment that equals 4 based on Mises yield
condition.
(3) External virtual work
Assume the tensile load on bolts centers (point O and P) is Ti where it is
deformed slightly by d, thus the external virtual work in Section I is obtained by
By the same method, we also deduced the design formula for the rigid baseplate as
8 2 b a a
T ¼ t fy þ þ ð8Þ
3 Y1 Y2 Y3
Experimental and Theoretical Research … 747
By using YHL method, the specimens in the test are all calculated of their bearing
capacities, whose results are found out fitting very well with the test data in Fig. 12.
And their calculation errors are averagely at 11.5%, which is far superior to the
errors by current design code DL/T [1] as observed in Fig. 13. Therefore the
proposed method is preferable with good reasonability and economical efficiency.
5 Conclusions
In this paper, we carried out the tensile test of the eight-bolted baseplate, and
observed the influence of its main parameters on the tensile bearing capacity.
Several design suggestions are proposed. (1) Increasing the thickness of the base-
plate is beneficial to improving the tensile load capacity within actual engineering
needs. (2) Bolts’ layout should be considered it as close as possible to the boot
plate. (3) Stiffener is very useful to improve the integral rigidity of the baseplate,
and its length should be design as long as the distance S1.
748 X. M. Xue et al.
In addition, based on the preceding test results, this paper proposes a design
formula for calculating the tensile bearing capacity of the eight-bolted baseplate by
using YHL method theory. The formula can take into account various factors such
as bolt positions, stiffeners and baseplate thickness. By means of theoretical concept
“plastic analysis, elastic design”, it can guarantee an appropriate safety reserve in
entire strength of the baseplate, which is economic practicable in engineering
design. In general, the proposed method has good application foreground in related
design fields.
Acknowledgements This research is financially supported by the science and technology project
from Ltd. of China Power Engineering Consulting Group, People’s Republic of china, grant
No. XB1-TM04-2017. And it is also supported by the National Natural Science Foundation,
People’s Republic of China, grant No. 11502188. These supports are gratefully acknowledged.
References
1. DT/T5154 (2012) Technical Code for Design of Tower and Pole Structures of Overhead
Transmission Line, China Planning Press, Beijing
2. Kato B, Mukai A (1985) Bolted tension flanges joining square hollow section members.
J Constr Steel Res 5(3):163–177
3. Kyung DC (2015) Improved performance of electrical transmission tower structure using
connected foundation in soft ground. Energies 8:4963–4982
4. Lavan (1995) Behaviour of Steel Structures in Seismic Areas – Sixth International
Conference- Behavior of steel structures in seismic areas
5. Liu H, Liu Y, Li Z et al (2018) Limit analysis for stiffened eight-bolted base plate connections
in EHV transmission towers. J Constr Steel Res 145:70–81
6. Profession Standard of The People’s Republic of China GB 51022 (2015) Technical
specification for steel structure of light-weight buildings with gabled frames. China
construction metal structure association
7. Profession Standard of The People’s Republic of China JGJ82 (2011) Technical specification
for high strength bolt connections of steel structures: Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural
Construction of the People’s Republic of China
8. Rattley MJ, Richards DJ, Lehane BM (2008) Uplift performance of transmission tower
foundations embedded in clay. J Geotech Geoenvironmental Eng 134(4):531–540
9. Willibald S, Packer JA, Puthli RS (2003) Design recommendations for bolted rectangular
HSS flange-plate connections in axial tension. Eng J 40:15–24
10. Wang YQ, Zong L, Shi YJ (2013) Bending behavior and design model of bolted flange-plate
connection. J Constr Steel Res 84:1–16
11. Yuan GL, Li SM, Xu GA et al (2009) The anti-deformation performance of composite
foundation of transmission tower in mining subsidence area. Procedia Earth Planet Sci 1
(1):571–576
Influence of Detonation Point on Blast
Loads Induced With Cylindrical
Charges
Abstract Design values of overpressure have been reported for spherical charges
detonated at the center of the sphere. This paper focuses on the influence of det-
onation point on the distributions of incident overpressure and impulse of cylin-
drical charges. A numerical model was developed by using AUTODYN-2D.
Numerical analyses were performed by calculating cylindrical TNT charges deto-
nated at different positions and at scaled distances from 0.42 to 4.2 m/kg1/3. The L/
D ratio of calculated cylindrical charge ranges from 1 to 5. The results show that the
non-central detonation leads to highly non-uniform pressure and impulse in the
close-in range, and the pressure and impulse are enhanced in different directions.
The relationship between the blast overpressure of different detonation point and
different angles, and the corresponding distances is summarized.
Y. Fan H. B. Xiang
State Key Laboratory of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation of Explosion and Impact,
Army Engineering University of PLA, Nanjing 210007, China
e-mail: translate111@qq.com
H. B. Xiang
e-mail: xhb3188@163.com
L. Chen (&) Q. Fang
School of Civil Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing 210096, China
e-mail: li.chen@seu.edu.cn
Q. Fang
e-mail: fangqinjs@139.com
1 Introduction
2 Development of FE Model
the position of the initiator. Pressure monitoring points are placed along the radials at
increments of 22.5°, as shown in the second stage of Fig. 2. Analyses are performed
with cylindrical charges of the same mass, but L/D equals to 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5,
respectively. The actual dimensions of the spherical charge and five cylindrical
charges are listed in Table 1. The element sizes near the origin were altered to suit
the dimensions of the cylindrical charge. The dimensions of the cylindrical charges
in the models differ from the target values by extremely small percentages owing to
the modeling constraints.
First stage
Mirror symmetry
430 mm
boundary Calculate
Axial symmetry
boundary
Transmitting boundary
430 mm Map
4300 mm
Initiation point
Pressure transducer
TNT
Air Second stage
Symmetry boundary
4300 mm
There are three different initiation styles, as shown in Fig. 3. A centrally initiated
cylindrical charge is used as the reference explosive.
At 0°, compared with the centrally initiated cylindrical charges, the overpressures of
the single-end initiated cylindrical charges increase by an average of 10%, and the
pressure shows a similar trend. The peak overpressures of the single-end initiated
cylindrical charges at 180° are less than those at 0° and that of the spherical charge
at Z < 2.4 m/kg1/3. The difference between the peak overpressures of the
double-end initiated charges at 0° and single-end initiated charges at 180° is less
than 10% at Z < 2.4 m/kg1/3, and the trend is basically the same. The Pcyl/Psph of
the single-end initiated charges at 180° (the double-end initiated charges at 0°) is
about 0.4 at the scaled distances from 1 to 3 (2.5) m/kg1/3 (Fig. 4).
At 90°, the difference between the peak overpressures of the centrally initiated
and single-end initiated cylindrical charges is less than 5% at most of the distances.
This means that the effect of a single-end initiation on the peak overpressure at 90°
cannot be considered. The peak overpressure of a double-end initiated cylindrical
charge is greater than that of a centrally initiated one at Z < 2 m/kg1/3. The peak
754 Y. Fan et al.
Pcyl/Psph
Pcyl/Psph
Pcyl/Psph
1.5 1.5 1.5
1.0 1.0 1.0
0.5 0.5 0.5
0.0 0.0 0.0
0 0 0
1 90.0 1 180 1
90.0
Z
67.5
Z
2 135 2
Z
2 67.5
/m
/m
45.0
/m
3 3 90 3 45.0 /°
22.5 45 /°
/kg
/°
/kg
/kg
22.5
4 0.0 g le Angle Angle
1/3
n 4 0
1/3
4 0.0
1/3
A
(a) centrally initiated (b) single-end initiated (c) double-end initiated
Fig. 4 Pcyl/Psph of cylindrical charges initiated at different locations, Pcyl/Psph is the ratio of peak
overpressure of cylindrical charge to peak overpressure of spherical charge at same distance,
L/D = 4
3.2 Impulse
At 0°, compared with the centrally initiated cylindrical charges, the impulses of the
single-end initiated cylindrical charges are around 17% greater at Z < 2 m/kg1/3,
but around 5% smaller at Z < 2 m/kg1/3. The trend is basically the same. The
impulses of single-end initiated cylindrical charges at 180° are less than those in 0°
Influence of Detonation Point on Blast Loads Induced … 755
when Z < 1.6 m/kg1/3, and the difference between the impulses of the single-end
initiated cylindrical charge at 180° and the spherical charge is around 20% at
Z < 1.6 m/kg1/3. The difference between the impulses of doubled-end initiated
charges at 0° and single-end initiated charges at 180° is less than 10% at most of the
distances. The impulse curves of the single-end initiated charge at 45° and 135°
show a similar trend, Icyl/Isph reach the minimum values of 0.7 and 0.6 at
Z = 0.8 m/kg1/3 (Fig. 5).
At 90°, compared with the centrally initiated cylindrical charges, the impulses of
single-end initiated cylindrical charges are around 10% smaller at Z < 1 m/kg1/3, but
around 2% smaller at Z > 1 m/kg1/3. The impulses of double-end initiated cylin-
drical charge are greater than those of centrally initiated ones at Z < 1.37 m/kg1/3.
The impulses of the double-end initiated charges are 1.61 times greater than those of
the centrally initiated ones and 2.4 times greater than those of the spherical charges at
Z = 0.84 m/kg1/3. The impulses of the double-end initiated charges are slightly
smaller than those of the centrally initiated ones at Z > 1.37 m/kg1/3, and the dif-
ference is smaller than 10%. The conclusion is in good agreement with that of
Anastacio and Knock [1], who found that the impulse for double-end initiation was
the same as that for single-end initiated charges at 90° when Z > 1.4 m/kg1/3.
The impulse from 22.5° to 67.5° is less than that of the spherical charge at
Z < 2 m/kg1/3. The difference between the impulse from 22.5° to 67.5° and the
impulse of the spherical charge is less than 10% at Z > 2 m/kg1/3. The impulse
increases as the direction changes from 22.5° to 90° at Z < 2 m/kg1/3 for the
double-end initiated cylindrical charge.
Held [2] studied the impulse distribution of single-end initiated cylindrical
charges in the near field and found that the impulse at 0° is higher than that at 180°,
while the impulse at 90° is much higher than that in diagonal directions. These
results are consistent with the conclusions drawn from the analysis of the numerical
model.
In conclusion, compared to the results of central initiation, the peak overpressure
and impulse of single-end initiation increase by an average of 10% at 0° but
decrease drastically at 180°, while the pressure and impulse at 90° are slightly
3.0
3.0 3.0
2.5
2.5 2.5
2.0
2.0 2.0
Pcyl/Psph
Icyl/Isph
1.5
Icyl/Isph
1.5 1.5
1.0 1.0 1.0
0.5 0.5 0.5
0.0 0.0 0.0
0 0 0
1 90.0 1 1
180 90.0
Z/
2
Z
45.0
m/
3 90 45.0
22.5 ngle /° 3 45 Angle / ° 3 22.5 ngle /°
/kg
/kg
kg
1/3
A
1/3
1/3
4 0.0 40 4 0.0 A
(a) centrally initiated (b) single-end initiated (c) double-end initiated
Fig. 5 Icyl/Isph of cylindrical charges initiated at different locations, Icyl/Isph is the ratio of impulse
of cylindrical charge to impulse of spherical charge at same distance, L/D = 4
756 Y. Fan et al.
4 Conclusions
Compared to the central initiation, the peak overpressure and impulse of single-end
initiation increase by an average of 10% at 0° but decrease drastically at 180°, while
Z < 2 m/kg1/3. The maximum amplifying ratio of the peak overpressure and impulse
of single-end initiated cylindrical charge at 0° and 180° reaches 3.5 and 2.2, respec-
tively, but the overpressure and the impulse at 90° is affected slightly. The peak
overpressure and impulse of double-end initiation decrease drastically at 0° and
increase considerably at 90° in the close-in range. The maximum amplifying ratio of
peak overpressure induced by double-end initiated charge to that induced by centrally
initiated charge is around 1.6 at 90° with the scaled distance around 1 m/kg1/3. The
maximum amplifying ratio of peak overpressure induced by the double-end initiated
charge to that induced by the spherical charge is about 2.4. The peak overpressure of
double-end initiation at 90° is similar to that of central initiation at 0°.
Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the financial supports from the National Natural
Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 51978166, 51678403, 51738011), the Fundamental
Research Funds for the Central Universities.
References
1. Anastacio AC, Knock C (2016) Radial blast prediction for high explosive cylinders initiated
at both ends. Propellants Explos Pyrotech 41:682–687
2. Held M (1999) Impulse method for the blast contour of cylindrical high explosive charges.
Propellants Explos Pyrotech 24:17–26
3. Hryci WZ, Borkowski W, Rybak P, Wysocki J (2014) Influence of the shape of the explosive
charge on blast profile. J Kones 21:169–176
4. Katselis G, Anderson J (2001) Estimation of blast overpressure from a cylindrical charge
using time of arrival sensors. In: The 14th Australasian fluid mechanics conference, Adelaide
University Australia
5. Plooster MN (1982) Blast effects from cylindrical explosive charges: experimental
measurements
6. Shen HM, Li WB, Wang XM, Li WB, Dong XL (2017) Velocity distribution of fragments
resulted by explosion of a cylindrical shell charge on multi-spots eccentric initiation.
Explosion Shock Waves 37:1039–1045
7. Sherkar P, Shin J, Whittaker AS, Aref AA (2016) Influence of charge shape and point of
detonation on blast-resistant design. J Struct Eng 142:04015109
Influence of Detonation Point on Blast Loads Induced … 757
Keywords Equivalent linearization method Ductility demand spectrum
Reliability Reinforced concrete Building structure
1 Introduction
In the last few decades, several displacement-based seismic design procedures have
been developed for controlling damage to both structural members and
non-structural components of a building structure. The ductility demand spectrum
of a building structure, which shows the relationship between the displacement
ductility demand and structural period of a single-degree-of-freedom (SDOF)
system with a specified yielding lateral strength [11], can help engineers in
displacement-based seismic design. Some of the related literature treats the ductility
demand spectrum as the constant strength response spectrum (CSRS) because of the
constant value of the lateral strength or base shear coefficient for a SDOF system.
Besides of CSRS, the constant ductility response spectrum (CDRS) is also widely
used to derive the inelastic response spectrum of seismic design; however, the target
ductility of a structure must be determined by an iterative procedure, whereas the
lateral load capacity of a structure is relatively easily estimated.
Panyakapo [8] pointed out that CDRS cannot be reliably used for determining
strength demand. A more reliable strength demand should be calculated based on the
simultaneous consideration of the ductility ratio and other response parameters, such
as hysteretic energy that is absorbed by the structure, the number of yielding reversals
and the cumulative ductility ratio [13]. Panyakapo [8] also found that a design
approach that is developed based on the constant-damage strength demand spectrum
(CDASDS) is more reliable than one based on the constant-displacement-ductility
strength demand spectrum (CDDSDS). Therefore, the constant-damage concept
should be considered in the construction of a ductility demand spectrum for the
practical engineering purpose.
In the construction of a ductility demand spectrum, time-consuming and com-
plicated nonlinear time history analyses for determining the maximum displacement
response of the equivalent SDOF system for a building structure can be avoided
using an equivalent linearization method. This work proposes an equivalent lin-
earization method that is developed based on the seismic design code of building in
Taiwan and the past research [7], called modified equivalent linearization method
(MELM), for use in Taiwan [4]. For a building structure designed based on the
code-suggested static design procedure, engineers can use CDDDS to determine the
ductility demand related to an allowable damage state under a specified earthquake.
Additionally, a closed-form formula for CDDDS that corresponds to a specified
reliability can be derived.
2 Literature Review
Based on the research conducted by Okano and Miyamoto [7], the basic assump-
tions of the equivalent linearization method are given in Eqs. (1) to (3):
Reliability-Based Constant-Damage Ductility Demand Spectra … 761
SA F h ¼ ay ð1Þ
1:5
Fh ¼ ð2Þ
1 þ 10neq
1
neq ¼ c1 ð1 pffiffiffiÞ þ 0:05 ð3Þ
l
2p
SA ¼ SV ð5Þ
Teq
!2
SV
DM ¼ a pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi þ b Dy ð6Þ
Cy Hr Ry g
Teq
SD ¼ SV ð9Þ
2p
2p
SA ¼ SV aT Teq ð10Þ
Teq
Teq
SD ¼ SV aT Teq ð11Þ
2p
MELM is an equivalent linear method that is consistent with the seismic design
code of Taiwan. According to US IBC [5], ATC-40 [1], FEMA-273 [3], the
modification factors of seismic force are divided into Bs for the short period and B1
for 1-s period in the seismic design code of Taiwan [2]. In the code, the reduction
factor of seismic design force Fh differs between the short period zone and long
period zone in the elastic acceleration response spectrum, and is thus given by
Eqs. (12) and (13). On the basis of the concept proposed by Okano and Miyamoto
[7], MELM uses Eqs. (12)–(14) to calculate the reduction factor of seismic design
force Fh and equivalent height Hr of an SDOF system, respectively.
1
1:5
40neq þ 1 þ 0:5
Fh ¼ ¼ ð12Þ
Bs 1:1
1 1:5
Fh ¼ ¼ þ 0:5 ð13Þ
B1 40neq þ 1
P
hi mi /i
Hr ¼ Pi ð14Þ
i mi /i
Since Eqs. (12) and (13) related to the reduction factors of seismic design force are
suggested based on the references [1, 3, 5], MELM can still be applied to various
counties besides of Taiwan. However, for the practical use, the nonlinear dynamic
analysis (NDA) of a SDOF system should be used to investigate the accuracy of
MELM. Obviously, MELM with aT = 0.85 used in this work tends provides a
relatively good and a conservative prediction.
In MELM, the equivalent period of a SDOF system is assumed equal to that
obtained by Okano and Miyamoto [7] (Eq. (4)), which determines the equivalent
period using the secant stiffness at the maximum displacement point. Additionally,
a modification factor j is used to modify the hysterical energy area in determining
the equivalent damping ratio as shown in Eq. (15) [12].
2 ðl 1Þ
neq ¼ j þ 0:05 ð15Þ
p l
Say ¼ Cy g ¼ SA Fh ; Cy ¼ Fy =W ð16Þ
1
0:177
DM ¼ 1:354 Dy ð17Þ
1:1Cy g=SA 0:5
For a SDOF system in the equivalent acceleration, Eqs. (12) and (15) are sub-
stituted into Eq. (16). Then, Eq. (17) for estimating the maximum deformation
response can be derived by assuming j = 1/3 and l ¼ DDMy . Following the same
derivation procedure of Eqs. (17), (20) can be derived on the basis of Eqs. (4), (5),
(13), (15) and (16) to estimate the maximum deformation response of a SDOF
system in the equivalent velocity zone in the design response spectrum (Eq. (18)).
Similarly, Eq. (21) can be derived on the basis of Eqs. (4), (9), (13), (15) and (16)
to estimate the maximum deformation response of a SDOF system in the equivalent
displacement zones in the design response spectrum (Eq. (19)).
SV ¼ T0D =2p SA ð18Þ
SD ¼ 2:5T0D =2p SV ð19Þ
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
1 1:5l Cy Hr Ry g DM
pffiffiffi þ 0:5 ¼ ;l ¼ ð20Þ
l 11:48l 8:48 SV Dy
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi!
B þ B2 194:7C
DM ¼ Dy ð21Þ
22:96C
where B ¼ 8.48C 7.24, C ¼ Hr Ry =SD , Cy is the yielding base shear coef-
ficient ¼Fy =W ¼ Say =g , Ry is the yielding drift ratio ¼Dy =Hr , and g is the
gravity acceleration (=9.81 m/s2).
764 L. Z. Nugroho et al.
Additionally, the time histories of acceleration during earthquakes that are used
to investigate the accuracy of MELM are scaled to be compatible with the design
acceleration response spectra based on the specified site conditions (Eq. (22)). This
work adopts Takeda model [10] in NDA is used to simulate the hysteretic behavior
of the equivalent SDOF system for an RC building structure. For Taipei Basin area,
the value of SDS and SMS are 0.6 and 0.8, respectively. Especially for Taipei Basin 1,
the value of T0D is 1.60.
8
>
> SDS 0:4 þ 3 TTD ! T 0:2T0D
>
< 0
SaD ¼ S DS ! 0:2T 0 \T T0
D D
; T0D ¼
SD1
ð22Þ
>
> T ! T0 \T
SD1 D
2:5T0
D SDS
>
: 2
2:5SDS T0D =T ! T [ 2:5T0D
where SDS and SD1 are the site-adjusted spectral accelerations at short period and at
1 s, respectively; and T0D is the corner period ratio between the short and the mid
period ranges of the design response spectrum. The term SaD , SDS , and SD1 cor-
respond to the uniform seismic hazard level with the exceedance probability of 10%
within 50 years.
In addition, since Eq. (20) is an implicit function, the maximum displacement
response in the constant velocity region cannot be obtained from the equation
easily. Therefore, for the practical use, this work simplifies Eq. (20) to be Eq. (23).
In the constant velocity region, statistical regression analyses are carried out to
minimize the sum of the residuals that are obtained when the results of Eq. (23) is
compared to the results of NDA.
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
Cy Hr Ry g Dmax
c1 l ¼
c2
;l ¼ ð23Þ
SV Dy
where c1 and c2 obtained from regression analysis are 0.83 and −0.68, respectively.
MELM, including Eqs. (17), (21) and (23), can be used to obtain the ductility
demand curves that correspond to different site conditions and building heights.
Figure 1 presents the ductility demand curves for Taipei Basin 1. Since the mod-
ification of equivalent period is determined based on the target maximum dis-
placement response, the calculated maximum displacements from MELM are close
to the mean values plus one standard deviations of the maximum displacements that
are obtained from the nonlinear dynamic analysis. The typical trends of MELM are
observed from the Taipei Basin area. MELM tends to give a good prediction for the
high building structures (Hr 20 m) while for the low building structures, the
prediction is conservative for Cy \ 0.35, and slightly underestimates the target
maximum displacement response for Cy 0.35.
Reliability-Based Constant-Damage Ductility Demand Spectra … 765
4 Reliability-Based CDDDS
Park and Ang [9] proposed a mechanistic seismic damage model for reinforced
concrete members. A common attractive feature of this damage index is that it
offers simple mathematical expressions between the ground motion demands and
the structural capacities of two basic parameters: deformation ductility and inelastic
hysteretic energy dissipation as shown in Eq. (24).
Dmax EH
DI ¼ þb ð24Þ
Dmon Fy Dmon
Based on Eq. (25), the damage spectra can be constructed for various site
conditions to understand the damage state of an RC building with a specified lateral
strength and ductility capacity after an earthquake. Herein, the damage classifica-
tion considering the damage index (b ¼ 0:2) as reported in NCREE-08-023 (2008)
[14], is adopted in constructing the damage spectrum. Based on experimental result
obtained for the full-scale structural models of a typical school building under
766 L. Z. Nugroho et al.
cyclic loading. Previously, Park and Ang [9] suggested DI is equal to 0.4 as the
limit between repairable and irreparable damage. However, based on damage
classification in NCREE-08-023, DI = 0.6 will be used in this study as the limit
value for the dividing point between the repairable and irreparable condition.
Figures 2 and 3 plot the relationship between the damage index and yielding
base-shear force for a building structure located in Taipei Basin 1. The damage
index was calculated using Eq. (25) based on the result of the nonlinear dynamic
analysis and by assuming Ry = 1/150. The dissipated energy per unit mass given by
Eq. (25), was obtained by step-by-step integration. Furthermore, as the yielding
base-shear coefficient and ductility capacity increase, the DI tends to decrease
because a system with a higher yielding base-shear coefficient and ductility capacity
more effectively to dissipates the input energy from the excitation as a result of
ground motion.
ðlmon 1Þ Ry
D1 ¼ þ Ry Hr ð26Þ
3
Fig. 2 Damage spectra of Taipei Basin 1 with lmon = 3.2 and 3.6
Reliability-Based Constant-Damage Ductility Demand Spectra … 767
Fig. 3 Damage spectra of Taipei Basin 1 with lmon = 4.2 and 4.8
ln D1 k
Pf ðD D1 Þ ¼ 1 U ð27Þ
n
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
ffi
r2D
n ¼ ln 1 þ 2 ð28Þ
lD
1
k ¼ ln lD n2 ð29Þ
2
where k and n are parameter of the lognormal distribution; lD and rD are the mean
value and the standard deviation of the maximum displacement response, which can
be calculated using Eqs. (17), (21), and (23) with using modification factor
aT ¼ 0:85.
Substituting Eq. (26) into Eq. (27) and setting the failure probability (to
Pf ðD D2 Þ ¼ 10% for example), yields a closed-form formula for the ductility
demand as shown in Eq. (30).
3 exp U1 1 Pf n þ k
lD ¼ 2 ð30Þ
Hr Ry
768 L. Z. Nugroho et al.
5 Conclusions
This work proposed modified equivalent linearization method (MELM) for esti-
mating the maximum displacement response of the equivalent SDOF system for a
mid-rise RC building structure. Additionally, according to the nonlinear dynamic
analysis, the modification factor aT of 0.85 for the equivalent period was suggested
to improve the accuracy of MELM. Based on the proposed MELM, a closed-form
formula for the constant-damage ductility demand spectrum (CDDDS) that corre-
sponds to a specified reliability was derived in this work. Restated, for a mid-rise
RC building structure, the engineers can set a target reliability and allowable
damage state to determine CDDDS for the displacement-based seismic design.
However, the ground motions that were used in the nonlinear dynamic analysis
herein excludes the near-fault earthquakes. Therefore, the accuracy of MELM for
the near-fault earthquakes should be investigated in the future.
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank the Ministry of Science and Technology of
the Republic of China, Taiwan, for financially supporting this research under contract MOST
107-2221-E-011-012-MY3.
References
1. ATC 40 (1996) Seismic evaluation and retrofit of concrete buildings, vol 1. Applied
Technology Council, Redwood City, California
2. Chai J-F, Teng T-J, Tsai K-C (2009) Development of seismic force requirements for building
in Taiwan. Earthq Eng Eng Vib 8:349–358
3. FEMA-273 (1997) Guidelines for the seismic rehabilitation of buildings, Federal Emergency
Management Agency Publication 273, Washington, D.C.
4. Hsu YT (2015) Study on ductility demand with equivalent linearization method for reinforced
concrete buildings (Master thesis). National Taiwan University of Science and Technology,
Taipei, Taiwan (in Chinese)
5. International Code Council (2000) International Building Code of USA
6. Kabeyasawa T (2004) Guidelines for performance evaluation of earthquake resistant
reinforced concrete buildings (Draft). Archit Inst Jpn 42(7):3–8
7. Okano H, Miyamoto Y (2002) Equation derived from equivalent linearization method -
Consideration based on energy and its application to evaluation probability of excess of
deformation capacity. J Struct Constr Eng (AIJ) 67(562):45–52
8. Panyakapo P (2004) Evaluation of site-dependent constant-damage design spectra for
reinforced concrete structures. Earthquake Eng Struct Dynam 33(12):1211–1231
9. Park YJ, Ang AHS (1985) Mechanistic seismic damage model for reinforced concrete.
J Struct Eng 111(4):722–739
10. Takeda T, Sozen MA, Nielson NN (1970) Reinforced concrete response to simulated
earthquakes. J Struct Div 96(12):2557–2573
11. Tena-Colunga A (2001) Displacement ductility demand spectra for the seismic evaluation of
structures. Eng Struct 23:1319–1330
Reliability-Based Constant-Damage Ductility Demand Spectra … 769
12. Tsai KC, Loh CH, Yeh CH, Su CM (2001) Design examples and the recommended
modifications of the tentative seismic force provisions for building structure in Taiwan.
Architecture & Building Research Institute, Ministry of Interior, Research Project Report (in
Chinese)
13. Uang CM, Bertero VV (1998) Implication of recorded earthquake ground motions on seismic
design of building structures (Report No. 88(13), 1–43), University of California, Berkeley,
California: UCB/EERC
14. Yeh YK, Chung LL, Chien WY, Chai JF, Hsiao FP, Shen WC (2008) Technology Handbook
for Seismic Evaluation and Retrofit of School Buildings, Taipei, Taiwan: National Center For
Research on Earthquake Engineering, NCREE-08-023 (in Chinese)
Study on Structural Collapse Behavior
of Reinforced Concrete Building Under
Near-Fault Earthquakes
1 Introduction
buildings which are considered as old buildings with insufficient seismic capacity.
Among many cases, seismic retrofitting for public school is one of the programs
which is promoted by the Ministry of Education and is executed by NCREE. It is
considered a success as 90% of these public school buildings have been retrofitted,
leaving only less than 10% remaining. However, the recent earthquakes such as
0206 Meinong Earthquake and Hualien Earthquake have shifted our retrofitting
attention from public buildings to private buildings as many of them are not pro-
viding enough seismic performance. Among all, commercial and residential mixed
buildings are easily damaged under the earthquake due to the soft and weak story
behavior, as shown in Fig. 1. Similarly, same behavior is also found in Japan, as
shown in Fig. 2.
(a) Residential and Commercial Mixed (b) Residential and Commercial Mixed
Building before Collapse Building after Collapse
Fig. 1 Photo of the collapse of residential and commercial mixed building subjected to Meinong
earthquake
774 F. P. Hsiao et al.
(a) Building with Soft and Weak Story (b) Building with Soft and Weak Story
before Collapse after Collapse
Fig. 2 Photo of the collapse of building with soft and weak story subjected to Kumamoto
earthquake
perform a series of start-up tests during the grand opening and an international blind
competition with this new facility.
Figures 3, 4 and 5 show the test setup with the start-up tests of 3-, 7- and 9-story
RC structures (in 1/2 scaling). It is planned to perform the demonstration test with
3-story specimen for the grand opening with NCREE Tainan laboratory on Aug.
9th in 2017. The 7-story specimen would be tested for an international blind
competition in the next year.
A development platform of collapse prevention technology for mid- to high-rise
buildings would be established after this project. Numerical analysis is used to
compare with experimental results to understand the structural behavior of rein-
forced concrete buildings under near-fault earthquake effect. In this study, it focuses
on the experimental result of collapse tests and discusses the failure type of spec-
imens. After the shaking table tests, the test result is compared with the existing
analytical models. The comparison result can reveal the insufficiency of the existing
analytical models. This experiment can offer abundant information of RC frames
collapse behavior and help the researchers to upgrade existing analytical models to
make better prediction for RC buildings’ seismic behavior, also, to raise up the
more economical improvement.
776 F. P. Hsiao et al.
The specimen design of 7-story reinforced concrete building with soft and weak
story behavior is following the characteristics as below:
1. Half scale reinforced concrete structure with non-ductile detailing.
2. Modulus design and can be assembled with 9-story, 7-story, 5-story, or 3-story.
3. The structure is asymmetric design.
4. High ceiling at 1st floor and soft story behavior.
(a) small column side view of (b) large column side view of
specimen specimen
Fig. 8 7-story RC frame building specimen with soft and weak story on shaking table tests
778 F. P. Hsiao et al.
(a) overview of (b) damage status of small (c) damage status of large
specimen column column
4 Conclusions
In past years, NCREE had done some experimental researches on the collapse
mechanism of column. However, it has not yet expanded to either vertical members
or structural systems. Unfortunately, there are lots of active faults in Taiwan.
A near-fault effective area is defined as within 10 km on both sides of a first type
active fault and it is affecting 1/3 of Taiwan populations which is over 8.6 millions
of people. Due to its characteristics of high-velocity pulses and large displacement
of the near-fault earthquakes, the damage of buildings affected by near-fault effects
is much serious than that of general earthquakes. Therefore, further research on the
collapse behavior of buildings affected by near faults is needed.
In 2017, NCREE has finished its construction on the advanced tri-axial seismic
simulator in the Tainan Laboratory located at National Cheng Kung University,
Kuei-Jen Campus. This shaking table system has the capability of reproducing
near-fault earthquake acceleration ground motion. In order to study the influence of
near-fault seismic waves on the collapse behavior of structures, this current program
carries out mega-structure experiments with this newly acquired shaking table
system. In respond to the opening ceremony, a 3-story RC building structure
shaking table test is carried out. In this test, the acceleration ground motion from
TCU075 and CHY047 were input to compare the influences of far-field earthquake
and near-fault earthquake. On November 2018, NCREE continues to carry out a
Study on Structural Collapse Behavior … 779
7-story RC Frame Building with soft and weak story collapse experiment. To take
near-fault earthquake influences into considerations, the acceleration ground motion
from CHY015 and CHY063 were input. At the same time, an international blind
analysis contest is held to attract the attentions from global earthquake engineering
researchers or scholars and to increase the international visibility of the newly built
Tainan laboratory of NCREE.
References
Abstract Cyclic loading tests on the reinforced concrete bridge pier model were
conducted to clarify the effect of seismic retrofit in the case of applying the pro-
posed method, in which the seismic retrofit rebars were embedded into the surfaces
of the pier and jacketed them with AFRP sheets. From this study, the following
results were obtained: (1) lateral load-carrying capacities of the piers were increased
by applying the proposed method; (2) the capacities were abruptly decreased due to
low cycle fatigue fracture of seismic retrofit rebar; (3) a seismic retrofit design
method applying an additional rebar may be used to restrain the low-cycle fatigue
fracture of the rebar; however (4), the buckling length of the rebar must be predicted
accurately.
1 Introduction
The thickness enlargement method and the steel plate jacketing method are gen-
erally applied to upgrade the load-carrying capacities of RC bridge piers. However,
since the cross-sectional area of the piers are increased by applying the thickness
enlargement method, an inhibition ratio of cross-sectional area of river may be
increased in the case of the river bridge piers, and the ratio is strictly controlled by
the river administrators. The dead load of the pier is also increased. In the case of
retrofitting RC bridge piers, it is sometimes required to minimize these
cross-sectional dimensions due to site and design conditions.
In order to develop a seismic retrofitting method not only to minimize increasing
cross-sectional dimensions but also to be economical, and increase load-carrying
capacities and the ductility of the piers, the authors proposed a new method. The
method involves embedding longitudinal rebars (referred to hereinafter as retro-
fitting rebars) which are distributed over the original concrete cover (Photo 1), and
jacketing them with aramid fiber reinforced polymer (AFRP) sheet.
In this study, a cyclic loading test was conducted by using small-scale RC bridge
pier models to investigate the applicability of the proposed method. Also, it is
aimed to predict the appropriate amount of volume for the retrofitting rebar.
2.1 Specimens
Table 1 shows details of the test specimens that are modeled as approximately 1/4
scale of typical RC bridge piers. The reference model without retrofitting was
designated as Specimen R, and the models with retrofitting, as Specimen RF.
Cyclic Loading Tests on Seismic Retrofit … 783
Specimen R was designed for longitudinal rebar ratio as to be smaller than that
determined following the current design code. Therefore, the value was set to about
0.3% and the flexural-shear capacity ratio was about 2.
Specimen RF was designed based on the Japanese Standards [1, 2] so that the
load-carrying capacities were increased by about 1.5 times that of specimen R. The
retrofitting rebar of specimen RF was anchored to the footing.
Dimensions of the specimens and the rebar arrangement are shown in Fig. 1. The
column of the specimen has dimensions of 600 mm 600 mm and a height of
1,800 mm. The shear span ratio of the column is 3.8. Two D10 retrofitting rebars
are embedded into each side of the column. Each rebar is fixed by filling epoxy
resin into a longitudinal groove of cross section 20 mm 20 mm in the concrete
cover of the column and into the circular hole of diameter u26 mm for the footing.
The retrofitting rebar was 1,200 mm long and was anchored to a depth of 400 mm
in the footing.
The material properties of the AFRP sheet are listed in Table 2. In this study, an
AFRP sheet of unit mass 350 g/m2 and width of 500 mm was chosen. One layer of
the sheet was wrapped around the whole column. The concrete surface of the
column was grit-blasted and the corners were chamfered before wrapping the sheet.
Primer was applied and afterwards the AFRP sheet was bonded by using an epoxy
resin. The AFRP sheet was circumferentially overlapped alternately over a length of
200 mm at the side-surfaces parallel to the loading direction.
Figure 2 shows the test setup. The specimen was rigidly fixed at the base to the
testing floor. Horizontal lateral cyclic loading was applied by using an electric jack
at the swivel type loading jig installed at the top of the column. A load of 180 kN
Specimen
1800
3005
900
(mm)
Cyclic Loading Tests on Seismic Retrofit … 785
(0.5 N/mm2) evaluated as the reaction of the superstructure was vertically sur-
charged through the loading jig.
The cyclic loading test was conducted using the displacement control method.
First, one half of the flexural yield load of the originally cast rebar was laterally
applied in one cycle, during which cracks occurred at the base of the column. Then
three cycles of loading were applied sequentially as an incremental displacement of
a reference displacement dy at the loading point. The reference displacement dy for
each specimen was the horizontal one at rebar yielding. Those of Specimens R and
RF were 3.0 mm and 2.7 mm, respectively.
In this test, the horizontal displacement and surcharged load were measured by
using wire-type LVDT and a load cell, respectively.
3 Experiment Result
Figure 3 shows the hysteresis loops of lateral load and displacement. In this figure,
the skeleton curves are also drawn that are based on the design standards [1, 2] and
by using the material test results. The rebar yield point and the ultimate limit state
were marked and the horizontal displacement at which the retrofitting rebar frac-
tured is indicated by the broken line, which was obtained by using a low-cycle
fatigue evaluation that will be discussed later.
In the case of Specimen R, the maximum load was reached at 10 dy for the
push-loading and at 15 dy for the pull-loading. Lateral load-carrying capacities
decreased at the push-loading of the first cycle for 11 dy, and these abruptly
decreased at the pull-loading of the first cycle for 16 dy because the rebar fractured.
However, in the case of Specimen RF, the maximum load was reached at 9 dy for
both the push- and pull-loading and the load decreased at the push-loading of the
first cycle at 10 dy. Since the load abruptly decreased under the state from 13 dy to
14 dy, the retrofitting and originally existing rebars might fracture during this
loading cycle.
Comparing the test results with the design values, it is seen that the former
results for lateral load-carrying capacities and ultimate displacement are in good
agreement with the latter.
In the case of specimen RF, the lateral load-carrying capacities were increased to
about 1.5 times that of the Specimen R, which is a target value for seismic retro-
fitting. However, the horizontal displacement has not reached the ultimate value
based on the design standards. This may be that even though the design standard is
specified as the ultimate state as the concrete reaches compression failure,
Specimen RF reached the ultimate state due to retrofitting and the existing rebars
fractured.
Figure 4 shows crack patterns and the area failed in compression on the four sides
of the specimens after cyclic loading. In the case of Specimen RF, these were
sketched after removing the AFRP sheet. In these figures, both sides F and B are
perpendicular to the loading direction.
1800
Photo 3 Damage state of retrofitting rebar at column base after cyclic loading
In the case of Specimen RF, cracks occurred in the epoxy-resin impregnated into
the aramid fibers in the region from the column base to the height of 280 mm
during the loading steps from 3 dy to 4 dy and in the area at a height of around
600 mm for the loading step of 5 dy. These continuously developed until the
loading step was increased to 5 dy. After removing the AFRP sheet from the
column, cracks were found in the concrete surface at the same locations as those in
the epoxy-resin. The concrete cover failed in compression in the region from the
column base to a height of around 160 mm and the average height of the damaged
area was about 110 mm for sides F and B.
The locations of crack patterns and the magnitude of the damaged area with
compression failure were clearly different between Specimens R and RF. This may
be because Specimen RF was strengthened by installing the retrofitting rebar near
the base and jacketing the column with an AFRP sheet, so that the flexural
deformation of the column was concentrated at the base due to the column stiffness
increasing.
Photo 2 shows the damaged state of Specimen RF at the column base due to
compression failure of the concrete. From this photo, it is observed that the dam-
aged area was limited to the concrete cover and the core concrete has not been
damaged entirely. Therefore, it suggests that the ductility of the column can be
improved using the retrofitting rebar without fracturing and corresponding to the
deformation of the column base.
Photo 3 shows the damage state of the retrofitting rebar at the column base after
cyclic loading. The following can be observed from this photo: the retrofitting rebar
buckled in the region of about 100 mm length and fractured near the top of the
buckled area. It is reported [3] that in the case of the cyclic loading test for the RC
column, the axial rebar sometimes fractured early due to low-cycle fatigue after the
axial rebar buckled. Therefore, based on the damage state of the fractured surface of
the rebar and the base of the column, the retrofitting rebar may fracture due to
low-cycle fatigue similar to that mentioned above.
Fig. 5 Distributions of
cumulative fatigue damage
ratio D
ðkw l0 LÞ2
N ¼ 2:94 103 ðkw l0 =r Þ þ 1:96 102 þ1 ð1Þ
ðkd d dÞ2
in which N: number of loading cycles; kw: correction factor for buckling length l′ in
the cyclic loading (=1.0); r: diameter of the rebar; kd: ratio of the buckling length to
the length between the plastic hinges (=0.6); d: horizontal displacement; L: shear
span; d: effective depth of the cross-section, and
n1 n2 ni X ni
D¼ þ þ...þ ¼ ð2Þ
N1 N2 Ni Ni
in which D: cumulative fatigue damage ratio; ni: number of loading cycles in each
loading step i (=3); Ni: number of loading cycles when the rebar fractured under the
loading conditions for loading step i.
The predicted displacement of the column obtained by using the above equations
was plotted with a red dotted line in Fig. 3(b). In this numerical calculation, the
buckling length l′ of the retrofitting rebar was assumed to be l′ = 100 mm based on
the test results and the loading step i at cumulative fatigue damage ratio D reaching
more than one was assumed to be the same step in which the rebar fractured with
low-cycle fatigue in the test. From this figure, it is seen that the predicted dis-
placement is in good agreement with that at the load-carrying capacities abruptly
decreasing in the test. Therefore, using the prediction equations given above, the
790 T. Terasawa et al.
volume of the retrofitting rebar taking into consideration the low-cycle fatigue of
the rebar can be rationally evaluated.
However, in this proposed method, the buckling length of the rebar corre-
sponding to the estimated volume must be appropriately evaluated. For practical
use, the buckling length of the rebar jacketed with AFRP sheet must be evaluated,
even though the value obtained from the test results was used in this study.
Figure 5 shows the distributions of cumulated fatigue damage ratios D on
varying the buckling length of the rebar l′ as: 75 mm; 100 mm; and 125 mm,
respectively, taking horizontal displacement of the column as the abscissa. From
this figure, it is seen that the horizontal displacement of the column when the rebar
fractured tends to increase with increasing buckling length of the rebar l′ and the
buckling length of the rebar l′ should be accurately predicted for practical design,
because the displacement was greatly influenced by the buckling length.
4 Summary
References
1. Aramid Reinforcement Study Group (1998) Design and construction guideline for retrofitting
RC bridge piers with aramid fiber sheet (Draft) (in Japanese)
2. Japan Road Association (2002) Specifications for highway bridges, Part V Seismic design
3. Takiguchi M, Ikenaga T, Otsuka H (2008) Evaluation of failure of axial rebar in cyclic loading
tests on RC columns. In: Proceedings of the 63rd annual conference of JSCE, Division V,
pp 939–940 (in Japanese)
Evaluation of Pulse Wave Effect
in Inland Crustal Earthquake Ground
Motion
Abstract An evaluation method has been proposed for pulse wave effect on
structural response. First, time-frequency analysis by use of energy input rate
(EIR) was performed. The combination of the sign and amplitude of both accel-
eration pulse input and structural velocity response was found to determine the
structural response. Next, taking advantage of energy input to structure, a new
definition of strong motion duration was defined. On this basis, dynamic effects of
pulse waves were characterized with emphasis on the impulsive effects. Numerical
examples were shown using eight ground motion records observed during recent
inland crustal earthquakes in Japan. Considering both amplitude and duration,
dynamic effects were compared among various records. In long-period range, peak
velocity response was reached in extremely short time and occurs almost simul-
taneously regardless of the natural period. As a result, velocity response spectra
remained high and flat in wide range of long-period. Such impulsive effects are
considered to be representative of the pulse waves.
Keywords Pulse wave effect Inland crustal earthquake Energy input Velocity
response Time-frequency analysis
1 Introduction
the dynamic effect of pulse-like wave to structures, many studies were devoted to
mathematically model the pulse-like wave and derive theoretical solutions of
structural responses (e.g., [9]).
In this study, an evaluation method is proposed for pulse wave effect on
structural response with emphasis on temporal energy input to structures [7, 8].
First, time-frequency analysis by use of energy input rate (EIR) is performed. Next,
a new kind of strong motion duration is proposed. Numerical examples are shown
using eight ground motion records observed during recent inland crustal earth-
quakes in Japan.
2 Analytical Methods
where T ¼ 2p=x0 : natural period. Temporal derivative of Eq. (3) is called “energy
input rate (EIR)” [5], which represents enhancement and suppression of response
according to the sign and amplitude of the product of ground acceleration and
velocity response.
_
eðT; tÞ ¼ EðT; tÞ ¼ €z0 ðtÞ_yðT; tÞ ð4Þ
The time histories of EIR for various natural periods T is called “energy input
rate spectrum (EIR spectrum)” [5]. In this study, the time histories cumulative
Evaluation of Pulse Wave Effect … 793
energy input in Eq. (3) for all natural periods T is defined as “cumulative energy
input spectrum.” In addition, “evolutionary power spectrum” [3] defined by the
following equation is also used in order to visualize response envelope of the SDOF
system.
2hx0 ðx20 y2 þ y_ 2 Þ
GðT; tÞ ¼ ð5Þ
p
The time history of accumulated power normalized to its total power, known as
“Husid plot,” is calculated as the equation below [6].
Rt
0€ z20 ðsÞds
PC ðtÞ ¼ 100 R tend ð6Þ
0 € z20 ðsÞds
where tend represents the length of the record. Significant duration Da-b is defined as
the time period occupying from a up to b% of PC. In this study, the duration is
calculated by using the cumulative energy input of Eq. (3). While Husid plot is
monotonously increasing function, cumulative energy input is not, since EIR can
take on negative values, therefore, percentiles cannot be identified uniquely. To
cope with this problem, Eq. (3) is divided into PE+ and PE+ according to the sign of
EIR as follows.
Z t
PE þ ðT; tÞ ¼ maxf€z0 ðsÞ_yðT; sÞ; 0gds;
0
Z t ð7Þ
PE ðT; tÞ ¼ minf€z0 ðsÞ_yðT; sÞ; 0gds
0
By using the positive term represented by the first equation of Eq. (7) only,
“normalized cumulative energy input HE+” can be calculated by:
PE þ ðT; tÞ
HE þ ðT; tÞ ¼ 100 ð8Þ
PE þ ðT; td Þ
Furthermore, let pmax(T) and tpmax(T) represent percentile value and the per-
centile time when maximum velocity response for predominant period T is reached,
respectively. Duration corresponding to accumulation of energy input from 5% to
pmax(T) is defined as D5-pmax.
Velocity-equivalent value of ultimate cumulative energy input E(T, tend) of Eq. (3)
for various natural period is called “energy spectrum” [1].
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
VE ðTÞ ¼ 2EðT; tend Þ ¼ 2PE þ ðT; tend Þ 2PE ðT; tend Þ ð11Þ
Figure 1 shows an example of energy input using the ground motion acceleration
recorded at KiK-net Mashiki station (KMMH16, EW component) during the main
shock of Kumamoto Earthquake, 2016 for predominant period of velocity response
T = 1.05 s [7]. Figure 1(a) shows ground acceleration and relative response
velocity. Figure 1(b) and (c) show energy input rate (EIR) and cumulative energy
input, respectively. EIR suddenly increased and reached its maximum at t = 20.7 s
when local peak response and peak ground acceleration coincidently occur. During
t = 19.5–21.8 s, EIR keeps positive value and cumulative energy input drastically
increased. Response enhancement effect within extremely short time due to
impulsive ground motion input is observed. After this point, EIR is mixed with
Evaluation of Pulse Wave Effect … 795
1500 300000
Relave response velocity(cm/s)
Acceleraon
1000 Relave response velocity(T=1.05s) 200000
Acceleraon(cm/s2 ),
EIR(cm2/s3 )
500 100000
0 0
-500 -100000
-1000 -200000
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
Time(s) Time(s)
(a) Ground acceleration and relative velocity response (b) Energy input rate (EIR)
250000
Cumulave energy input
Cumulave energy input(cm2 /s2 )
150000
100000
50000
0
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
Time(s)
(c) Cumulative energy input and its positive and negative terms
positive and negative values, energy input and response velocity do not increase
very much. Durations calculated from positive terms of Fig. 1(c) are
D5-pmax = 1.57 s, D5-75 = 2.48 s and D5-95 = 4.71 s.
Figure 2 shows the result of time-frequency analysis using energy input. Figure 2
(a) and (b) show ground acceleration and evolutionary power spectrum [8].
Figure 2(c) and Fig. 2(d) are EIR spectrum and cumulative energy input spectrum
which are spectral representations of Fig. 1 (b) and Fig. 1(c) for various natural
periods, respectively. Evolutionary power spectrum apparently has peak at around
T = 1 s and t = 21–24 s. Due to several pulse-like inputs during t = 19.5–22 s, EIR
spectrum consecutively kept positive values, and cumulative energy spectrum
reached almost its final value at t = 22.5 s. It can be observed that small number of
intensive pulse waves caused very quick amplification of response because of
effective energy input. In other ranges of natural period, EIR spectrum becomes
positive and negative by turns. Energy input is canceled one after another, therefore,
velocity response is suppressed.
796 N. Nojima and T. Yamamoto
From top to bottom, (a) Ground acceleration, (b) Evolutionary power spectrum,
(c) EIR spectrum, (d) Cumulative energy input spectrum
Figure 3(a) compares response velocity spectrum SV, pseudo velocity spectrum pSV
and energy spectrum VE, and its decomposition to positive and negative terms, VE+
and VE-, respectively. Figure 3(b) shows energy input efficiency RE. At around
predominant period of response velocity spectrum, T = 1.05 s, VE and VE+ are
similar values, and energy input efficiency RE is over 0.8. On the other hand, VE+
and VE- are similar values, and RE is small at long period.
Figure 3(c) and (d) show i-percentile time ti and duration Da-b, respectively.
Blue dots in Fig. 3(c) represent i-percentile time t1 to t99 for various natural period,
and t5, t75, t95 and tpmax are highlighted by color solid lines. Blue dots are highly
dense during t = 20–25 s, which means intensive concentration of energy input.
According to Fig. 3(d), approximate durations are D5-75 = 2–6 s, D5-95 = 3–18 s
and D5-pmax = 1–5 s. All kinds of durations are relatively short at around pre-
dominant period representing abrupt amplification of velocity response. D5-75 and
D5-95 gradually become longer for shorter- and longer-period. However, D5-pmax
keeps almost constantly D5-pmax = 1 s at wide range of long-period, which is
Upper left: (a) Velocity spectra and energy spectra, Upper right: (b) Energy input efficiency
Lower left: (c) i-percentile time ti, Lower right: (d) Duration Da-b
Fig. 4 Ground acceleration and relative response velocities (KiK-net Mashiki, h = 0.05)
800 N. Nojima and T. Yamamoto
Fig. 6 Normalized
cumulative energy input
5 Conclusions
Large amplitude pulse-like wave at fault rupture zone is one of the significant
engineering issues. In this study, an evaluation method was proposed for pulse
wave effect on structural response with emphasis on temporal energy input to
structures. Time-frequency analysis by use of energy input rate (EIR) was per-
formed and several kinds of duration indices were examined. Considering both
amplitude and duration, dynamic effects were compared among eight ground
motion records in recent inland crustal earthquakes in Japan. In long-period range,
peak velocity response is reached in extremely short time and occurs almost
simultaneously regardless of the natural period. As a result, velocity response
spectra remain high and flat in wide range of long-period. Such impulsive effects
are considered to be representative of the pulse waves.
Acknowledgements This study was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers JP17H02068
and JP17H03297. Ground motion records obtained at K-NET and KiK-net by NIED (National
Research Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Prevention) and those at JMA (Japan
Meteorological Agency) were used in this study.
References
1. Akiyama H (1999) Earthquake-resistant design method for buildings based on energy balance,
Gihodo, 228 p. (in Japanese)
2. Hisada Y (2008) Active fault and mitigation of building damage. Active Fault Res 28:77–87
(in Japanese)
3. Kameda H (1975) Evolutionary spectra of seismogram by multifilter. J Eng Mech Div 101
(6):787–801
4. Kato B, Akiyama H (1975) Energy input and damages in structures subjected to severe
earthquakes. J Struct Constr Eng 235:9–18 (in Japanese)
5. Ohi K, Takanashi K, Honma Y (1991) Energy input rate spectra of earthquake ground motions.
J Struct Constr Eng 420:1–7 (in Japanese)
6. Trifunac MD, Brady AG (1975) A study on the duration of strong earthquake ground motion.
Bull Seismol Soc Am 65(3):581–626
7. Yamamoto T, Nojima N (2018) An evaluation method for ground motion characteristics
considering the effects of constituent pulse waves. J Jpn Soc Civil Eng Ser A1 74(4):I_1023–
I_1034 (in Japanese)
8. Yamamoto T, Nojima N (2019) Evaluation of impulsive effect of pulse wave by use of energy
input to structures. J Jpn Soc Civil Eng Ser A1 (in Japanese, in printing)
9. Yasui M, Nishikage T, Mikami T, Kamei I, Suzuki K, Hayashi Y (2010) Theoretical solutions
and response properties of maximum response of a single-degree-of-freedom system for
pulse-wave ground motions. J Struct Constr Eng 75(650):731–739 (in Japanese)
Study of Bridge Damages Induced
Earthquakes in Japan and Strength
Hierarchy Design
Abstract Research of the bridge elements damaged in the large earthquakes that
occurred in Japan was carried out. And the correlations of the bridge design con-
ditions and seismic damaged elements of the bridges were analyzed. Using the
design documents of the seismic damaged bridge, the strength of the elements
including bearings, bearing mounting components and piers were calculated. The
strength hierarchy of the bridge elements was evaluated with the actual bridge
damage. And strength hierarchy design of bridges to induce damage to the element
that was desired in the viewpoint of serviceability and repairability of the damaged
bridge when the over design earthquake occur was discussed.
Keywords Seismic damage Extreme seismic force Resilience
Anti-catastrophe Strength hierarchy design, damage induction
1 Introduction
In the seismic design of bridges, the design earthquakes are assumed and the bridges
are designed so as not to damage, or within an acceptable level of damages in safety,
serviceability and repairability. However, earthquakes are natural phenomena and it
is difficult to predict their upper limits. Therefore, the risks of the damages of the
bridge caused by the large over design earthquakes will be recognized, and the
bridge damages will be controlled in order to be reduced the risks of lost perfor-
mances of safety, serviceability and repairability.
In this research, the tendency of the damages of the bridges caused by the large
earthquakes occurred in Japan was investigated, and the correlations of the strength
hierarchies of the bridge elements and the actual bridge damages were analyzed.
Strength hierarchy design of the bridges to induce the damages to the elements that
were desired in the viewpoint of serviceability and repairability of the damaged
bridges when the over design earthquake occur was discussed.
By the 13 earthquakes that occurred in Japan and the caused some bridges dam-
aged, from 1964 Niigata earthquake to 2011 Tohoku region Pacific Ocean earth-
quake, the status of the 76 damaged bridges were investigated.
The seismic design of the bridge before the 1995 Hyogoken Nanbu Earthquake was
conducted by the seismic intensity method with a horizontal seismic intensity of
0.15 to 0.3. Some of these bridges have been damaged by earthquakes equivalent to
today’s Level 1 earthquakes [4]. Therefore, for 9 earthquakes from 1964 Niigata
Earthquake to 1994 Hokkaido Toho-oki Earthquake, the design seismic accelera-
tions of the damaged bridges were compared with the actual seismic accelerations.
36 of 41 bridges were surveyed, and 5 very old bridges were excluded because
those were not applied the seismic design. Actual seismic accelerations were
observed PGA (Peak Ground Acceleration) that recorded at the observation cites
nearest the bridges. If there was no observation point near the bridge, PGA was
calculated using the distance attenuation formula [2] otherwise. Since the average
values of calculated PGA to be lower than the observed values, a 1.7-fold correction
coefficient equivalent to adding the standard deviation to the average value was
applied.
Figure 1 shows the comparisons of the accelerations in design and the actual
earthquake that caused the bridges damages. (a) shows the plots of the bridges that
damaged only in pier columns (10 bridges) and (b) shoes plots of bridges damaged
in bearing or bearing mounting components (26 bridge), and only 5 bridges of those
were also damaged in piers. In this figure, the horizontal axis represents the design
Study of Bridge Damages Induced Earthquakes … 805
600 600
500 500
earthquakes in acceleration, and the vertical axis represents the actual PGA of the
earthquakes. Above the diagonal line, the bridges were broken due to the “Over
Design Earthquake”. And the bellow the diagonal line, the bridges were damaged
due to the earthquake smaller than the design earthquakes.
Figure 2 shows the number of the bridges grouping in damaged elements and
year of the applied seismic design codes. Figures 1(a) and 2 show that 9 bridge of
10 bridges that have only damages in pier columns were damaged caused by the
over design earthquake. The other hand, in Figs. 1(b) and 2 show that 14 bridges,
about half of 36 bridges were damaged due to the earthquakes smaller than the
design earthquakes. No obvious differences were seen in the years of the applied
design codes.
The reason why the pier columns were hardly damaged due to the earthquakes
smaller than the design earthquakes is considered to be that the strength of the RC
pier columns were well calculated in accuracy and had not been suffered from the
irregular forces that not considered in the design.
The reason why the bearings and bearing mounting components were damaged
due to the earthquakes smaller than the design earthquakes is considered to be that
metal products had no redundancy of strength for the seismic loads, and these
bearing components would had been suffered from irregular forces induced by the
seismic action of the bridges. For example, the lateral bending of the girders that
were not considered in the seismic design of the bearings.
From Fig. 2, it will be said that the pier columns with no damaged bearings were
damaged due to the over design earthquakes, and that the pier columns with
damaged bearings were prevent from being damaged under the over design
earthquakes. It is suggested that if the bearings had been damaged, the pier columns
would have not been damaged because of the isolation from the seismic reaction
from the bearings caused by the very large earthquakes.
806 R. Tokuhashi et al.
14
Actual < De sign
12 Actual > De sign
Number of Bridges
10 6
8
6
9 2 3
4 7
2 3 3 1
01 1
0 0 0
Before 1971 1971 1980 Before 1971 Before 1971 1971 1980
Only Piers Damaged Piers And Only Bearings Damaged
Bearings
Applied Seismic Design Code And Damaged Elemnts
The 1995 Hyogoken Nanbu Earthquake caused heavy damages to many bridges in
the Hanshin area. This earthquake had a PGA of up to 848 gal (0.86 G), which far
exceeded the design strengths of the bridges at that time, 0.2 G to 0.3 G. For this
reason, there were damages in the pier columns and the bearings or bearing
mounting components including steel girders near the bearing and bearing base
mortars on top of the piers. And it is difficult to discuss the tendency from the
viewpoint of the bridge strength hierarchy.
After this earthquake, “Level 2 earthquakes” [4] are described in the seismic
design code and the bridges were designed ore retrofitted so that the bridges have
sufficient seismic performance against large earthquake that rarely occurs in the life
of the bridges.
When the 2011 Tohoku region Pacific Ocean earthquake occurred, damage
occurred to both the bridges that designed or retrofitted and the bridges that have
not been retrofitted against the Level 2 earthquakes. For the existing bridges
without seismic retrofit, this earthquake would have been earthquake loadings
exceeding the design earthquakes.
The correlations between the damage index of the pier columns and the presence
or absence of damage of the bearings or bearing mounting components is shown in
Fig. 3. In this figure, the number of piers was counted in the targeted bridges that
were damaged caused by that earthquake and that had not been retrofitted when that
earthquake occurs. The damage indexes are as follows: D: no damage, C: small
damage, B: medium damage, A: large damage [3].
10 bridges that the details of the damages were reported were targeted for the
survey, and there are 54 piers damaged in the bridges. 41 piers were damaged in the
bearings or bearing mounting components and 31 piers did not have damages in the
pier column. On the other hand, in the 23 piers damaged in the pier columns, only
10 piers, less than half of those, were damaged in the bearings or bearing mounting
Study of Bridge Damages Induced Earthquakes … 807
1.00
35 1.00
[1]Piers with Bearings Not Damged
0.90
30 [2]Piers with Bearings Damged
Ratio of [1] to ([1] + [2]) 0.80
0.60
20
0.50
0.50
0.40
15
0.40
10 0.30
0.20
5
0.10
0 0.00
D C B,A
Damage Index of Piers
components. From this, it can be understood that, for earthquakes exceeding the
design level, the damaged portion of the bridge tends to be either bearings including
bearing mounting components or pier columns.
In addition, the damages of the pier columns were not seen in the bridges
designed or retrofitted against Level 2 earthquake. And only a few bridges were
damaged in the bearing or bearing mounting components.
This survey also suggests the possibility of strength hierarchy design that pier
column damages would not progress by inducing damages to the bearings under the
earthquakes larger than the design earthquakes.
Among the bridges damaged by the earthquake, the strength hierarchies of each
members was organized for the 6 bridges for which the design documents were
available. As a result, in all 6 bridges, the damaged portions were the lowest
members in the calculated bridge strength hierarchies. Here, the results of the bridge
strength hierarchies of the A bridge [6] damaged by the Urakawa earthquake of
1982 and the B bridge [5] damaged by the 2011 Tohoku earthquake are shown.
The A bridge was a river bridge consisting of three of continuous steel I-girders
with three spans and had column type piers with circular cross sections. The A
bridge had foundations on the Type III ground, and had eight caisson foundations
and one direct foundation. The design seismic intensity was 0.2, and the PGA of the
earthquake was estimated to be 324 gal (0.33 G). Damages occurred from P2 to P7
piers, and shear failure occurred at the reinforcement reduction section of the P3
pier column (damage index: A).
808 R. Tokuhashi et al.
Figure 4 shows the damage situation of the P3 pier column and the strength
hierarchy of P3 including the pier base, reinforcement reduction section and the
bearings in the transvers direction. The strengths of each members were converted
to horizontal seismic intensities. The shear strength of the reinforcement reduction
section is the lowest at the hierarchy and that is consistent with the damaged portion
of the pier.
The B bridge was a river bridge consisting of four continuous steel I-girders with
three or four spans, for a total of 13 spans. The B bridge had 4 fixed piers with oval
cross section and 8 movable piers with circular cross section. The B bridge had
foundations on the type II ground, and had three type foundations: a direct foun-
dation, 6 caisson foundations and 5 pile foundations. The design seismic intensity
was 0.2, and the PGA of the earthquake was estimated to be 379 gal (0.39 G).
Damage occurred to the bearings and bearing mounting components in 9 of 12
piers, and the damage indexes were determined B or C. Damage occurred at the two
pier columns, and the damage indexes were determined A and B. On the piers with
damaged pier column, there were slightly damages in bearings or bearing mounting
components with damage index of C or D (no damage).
Figure 5 shows the hierarchies of the heavy damaged (damage indexes A and B)
6 piers. The strength of the piers were calculated based on the design documents.
Because of the design documents not available, strengths of the bearings were
figured as a range of seismic intensity of 0.2 to 0.3. This range was assumed that
bearings would have Level 1 seismic strength with its seismic design. In addition,
these strengths were calculated in transverse direction in consideration of the state
of damages.
In the circular cross section piers of P2, P3, P6, and P7, the smallest strength
members in calculations were the bending strength of the reinforcement reduction
sections in converted seismic intensity 0.20 to 0.24. It is thought that if the strength
0.8
0.7
Strength in Seismic Intensity
1.8
P2(Bearings Damaged)
1.6 P3(Bearings Damaged)
P6(Pier Damaged)
Strength in Seismic Intensity 1.4 P7(Pier Damaged)
P8(Bearings Damaged)
1.2
P11(Bearings Damaged)
1.0 Bearing Upper Strength
Bearing Lower Strength
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
Bending Shear Bending Shear
Pier Base Reinforcement Reduction
of the bearings and bearing mounting components exceeded this value the damage
of the pier columns would be caused (P6, P7), and if the strength of those were
below this value the damage of the bearings or bearing mounting components
would be caused (P2, P3). In the oval cross section piers of P8 and P11 had its large
cross sectional and had high strength in the transverse direction. For this reason, it is
considered that the bearings had a relatively low strength and those were damaged.
From the examination of the stratification of the strength of the bridge where the
excess external force which exceeds the design earthquake motion acts, it was
confirmed that the place with the lowest hierarchy becomes the damaged place in
each case. From this, If the load resistance of each part can be made hierarchical, it
is considered that damage can be induced to a desirable part against excessive
action exceeding level 2 earthquake motion, and serviceability and repairability can
be secured.
As a result investigating the damaged member of the bridge caused the large
earthquake and the correlations of serviceability and repairability in the Sect. 2, the
lower connection of the bearings were the most desirable damaged portions from
the following three viewpoints. Figure 6 shows an example of the bearing damage
broken in the lower bearing connection.
810 R. Tokuhashi et al.
(1) The horizontal reactions would not be transmitted from the bearing, it is pos-
sible to prevent the development of damage of the pier columns under the
external large earthquakes.
(2) It is possible to prevent the step of the road surface in the expansion joints after
the earthquake, and to release the traffic promptly.
(3) There is space left for the jack in the support, allowing for permanent
restoration to be facilitated.
When the damage is induced to the bearing under the external large earthquakes, it
is desirable for the pier columns to have a load-bearing capacity characteristic such
Study of Bridge Damages Induced Earthquakes … 811
that the maximum strength is large enough to the yield strength Py, as shown in
Fig. 7.
As a result of surveying the existing papers, as shown in Fig. 8(a), in the RC
piers, the maximum strength is 1.0 times to 1.2 times the yield strength, and no
correlation with the design conditions was found. On the other hand, as shown in
Fig. 8(b), the SRC piers had the maximum strength enough larger to the yield
strength, and the difference of 1.2 to 2 times was found respectively in design
conditions. This is considered that in the case of SRC, the steel frame arranged at
the centre of the cross section is still elastic even after the edge reinforcements were
yielded, and the maximum strength increased before those steel frames were
yielded.
In order to induce the damages to the bearings under the external large earth-
quakes, the strength of the bearings should be smaller than the maximum pier
column strength. For this purpose, the total of the strength of the bearings should be
set to be intermediate between the level 2 earthquake load and the maximum pier
strength.
It had been confirmed by the previous studies that the steel components and the
laminated rubbers constituting the bearings that were designed against the Level 2
earthquakes, the actual maximum strengths would become much larger than the
applied load. Therefore, in the case where an upper limit is given to the strength of
the bearings, for example, structural consideration such as providing a shear
breakable notched bolts installed at the lower bearing connections so as to have the
lower strength than the pier maximum strength. In reference [1], notched bolts were
installed in the lower connections of the bearing plate type bearings, and the shear
strengths of the notched bolts were designed so as not to exceed the strength of the
piers.
As the stress state is pure shear, the upper limit of the proof stress can be
calculated accurately for the notched knock-off bolt. If the lower bearing connection
bolts were located much below the height of the horizontal reaction acted, axial
tensile force would be exerted by the bending moment. If the tensile stress existed,
2.5 2.5
Square Cross Section Multi Core Steel
Square, with Round Bar Single Core Steel
Strength Ratio Pmax /Py
2.0 2.0
Interlocking Piers
Circular Cross Section
1.5 1.5
1.0 1.0
0.5 0.5
0.0 0.0
0 1 2 3 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Axial Stress (N/mm2 ) Axial Stress (N/mm2 )
the bolt would be undergo strain hardening when yielding, and there would be no
intended failure with the desired strength. In reference [1], it is confirmed by
experiments that failure occurs at the intended loads as shown in the Fig. 9.
The authors want to be induced the damages for the bearings under external
earthquakes by providing a notched bolts in the lower bearing connections of the
Menshin bearings. Whether the notched knock-off bolts break with the intended
loads, whether the combination of the bearings and the pier columns causes the
failure as expected in the strength hierarchy, further researches by analysis and
experiment will be undergo by the authors.
4 Conclusions
(4) So as to set the upper limit of the strengths of the bearings, it is desirable to
provide a notched bolts to be knock off under the designed loadings. However,
in order to provide such a function in the bearings, it is necessary to be con-
firmed by experiments.
References
1 Introduction
In Japan nowadays, the development of residential land has been extended close to
steep slopes and road networks have also been constructed along cliffs and slopes.
However, mudflows and other severe natural disasters have sometimes occurred in
these areas due to torrential rains caused by climate changes in recent years.
Usually, many check-dams have been constructed to control mudflows in steep
valleys. However, earth and sand were deposited on these dams with the passage of
time and, as a result, driftwood and large rocks flow down to the foot of mountains
when mudflows occur. In order to restrain such mudflows, protection fences were
installed at the tops of the dams.
On the cliff side of roads, rockfall protection fences were installed in the top
surface of the rockfall protection retaining wall in order to ensure the safety of
transportation networks from the falling rocks as shown in Fig. 1 [2]. Generally, the
check-dams and rockfall protection retaining walls were designed as gravity-type
plain concrete structures. Therefore, the steel posts for supporting the fence were
placed in a prepared hole left at the top of the wall and back-filled with the same
concrete as in the walls.
Photo 1 An example of
damaged retaining wall due to
falling rocks
Dynamic Behavior of Foundation for Steel Post … 817
At present, these steel posts are designed following the Rockfall Countermeasures
Handbook [3] (referred to hereinafter as Handbook). But, the dynamic response
characteristics of the posts under impact loading due to rock fall, mudflows, and/or
similar events have not been accounted for in the Handbook and these impact loads
were assumed to act as static loads. However, it was reported that the posts subjected
to impact loads due to falling rocks were actually severely damaged as shown in
Photo 1 [1], in which the concrete walls near the embedded post were spalled.
Therefore, in order to ensure greater safety of the transportation networks from falling
rocks, it is very important to establish a rational design method for the steel posts of
the rockfall protection fences considering the impact-resistant characteristics.
From this point of view, we investigate the dynamic response characteristics of
the posts. These impact loading tests on the steel posts supported by embedding one
end into the plain concrete block (referred to hereinafter as foundation) were
conducted. Here, a static loading test was also carried out for comparison.
2 Experimental Overview
Figure 2 shows the dimensions of test specimens and rebar arrangement. The
foundation models have dimensions of 700 400 1,300 mm (width height
length), in which a part of 60 cm length from its front surface was taken as the
footing for the steel post and the other part as the anchorage of the model. In order
to minimize the reinforcing effects of rebars on the load-carrying capacities of the
footing, axial rebar and stirrups were placed at the location of 30 cm from the center
of the footing in the cross-sectional plane. The diameters of the axial rebar and
stirrup were 19 and 10 mm, respectively.
Here, H-section steel members of 100 mm width and height were used for the
steel post model, even though members of 100 mm width and 200 mm height
H-section posts have been widely used for the actual ones of a conventional rockfall
protection fence. However, in this study, the small sized members were used so as
to save size and weight of the foundation models. The height of the footing may be
similar to the depth of the top surface of a conventional retaining wall.
The loading point for the H-section post for static and drop-weight impact tests
was 800 mm from the front surface (base) of the footing for bending action to be
predominant. The 6 mm thick stiffener plates were welded to the flange and web of
the posts at the loading point to restrain these against local buckling.
The foundations were anchored to the rigid steel jig by fastening with bolts and
nuts. At the start of the tests, the compressive strength of the concrete fc was
34.5 N/mm2. Also, the yield stress fy and ultimate strength fu of the H-section steel
posts obtained from the mill sheet were 354 and 449 N/mm2, respectively.
In order to investigate the dynamic response characteristics, the failure behavior
of the steel post and footing, and the anchoring depth of the posts, impact loading
tests were conducted while varying the drop height of the weight through 4 levels:
0.1; 0.5; 1.0; and 1.5 m, respectively. The tests were conducted following a single
loading method, in which a steel weight with a mass of 300 kg and a tip diameter of
200 mm was allowed to drop freely onto the H-section steel post from the pre-
scribed height once only. Here, the static loading test was also conducted for
comparisons with the dynamic response characteristics by using a hydraulic jack.
Photo 2 shows the test setups for static and drop-weight impact loading.
Dynamic Behavior of Foundation for Steel Post … 819
Figure 3 shows the measuring points of axial strains of H-section posts and the
vertical displacements of the specimens. Strain gauges were glued at 30 mm upper
and lower points from the center of the post for a total of 19 sections in the whole
span area to investigate the dynamic behavior and anchoring depth of the post.
Fig. 4 Load-displacement
curve under static loading
The vertical displacements of the post and foundation were measured by using a
laser-type LVDT. Displacements of the anchorage area of the foundation were also
measured to see whether it was uplifted or not. The impact force generated by the
drop weight was measured by using a load cell installed in the weight.
These analog data were converted into digital data and recorded in the digital
data recorders with a sampling time of 0.1 ms.
Figure 4 shows the load Ps and displacement D at the loading point (referred to
hereinafter as displacement) curve obtained from the static loading test. In this
figure, the calculated yield load Py of the H-section post was also indicated which
was estimated by using the calculated yield bending moment My. From this figure,
it is observed that the load Ps almost linearly increased until a displacement
D reached around 12 mm, and after that the load gradually increased and then kept
constant after the displacement reaching 24 mm. However, the maximum load did
not reach the calculated yield load Py. This may be due to the load being estimated
by using a nominal section modulus and the value of the yield stress from the mill
sheet.
Figure 5 shows the axial strain distribution eu at the upper fiber of the H-section
post at a displacement reaching some typical values. Here, the upper fiber strains
were evaluated based on the plane conservation concept and two measured strain
values of euw and elw. In this figure, the yield strain ey of the post was evaluated by
using the yield stress obtained from the mill sheet and is also shown.
Figure 6 shows configurations of the time history of the weight impact force Pi and
the displacement D at each drop height of the weight (referred to hereinafter as drop
height) H. In these figures, the origin of the time axis was taken as the actual time
when the weight impacted the H-section post.
From Fig. 6(a), the following can be observed: (1) time histories of the impact
forces Pi were composed of half sine and/or trapezoidal-shaped waves and
high-frequency components; and (2) even though the maximum impact forces Pi tend
to increase with increasing drop height H, the forces Pi reduced to zero after keeping a
constant value around 40 kN for 15 to 30 ms except when the drop height H = 0.1 m.
Since the constant value of the impact force was approximately the same as the plastic
load Pz (= 38.2 kN) which was estimated assuming perfect elasto-plastic behavior,
this may be due to a plastic hinge forming near the base of the footing.
822 S. Kondo et al.
Fig. 9 Comparisons of
load-displacement curves
between static and impact
loading
From the experimental results for the drop height H = 0.1 m, since the maxi-
mum impact force (Pi max = 31.3 kN) was smaller than the static maximum load (Ps
max = 33.5 kN) and the deflection was perfectly restored as shown in Fig. 6(b), the
specimen behaved elastically.
From Fig. 6(b), these findings indicate that: (1) the maximum displacement
tends to increase with increasing drop height H; and (2) the time passed from the
beginning of impact (referred to hereinafter as passed time) on reaching the max-
imum displacement was similar to that when the impact force decreased.
Figure 7 shows the time histories of the upper and lower fiber strains eu and el at
the measuring points S6 and C1, which are near the base of the footing. From this
figure, it is observed that: (1) if the drop height is H 0.5 m, the upper and lower
fiber strains were almost symmetrically distributed; however, (2) in the case of a
drop height greater than H = 0.5 m, the strains were not symmetrically distributed
and were considerably greater than the yield strain.
Figure 8 shows the upper fiber strain distributions of the H-section posts at
maximum displacement. From this figure, the following details can be observed:
(1) in the case of a drop height H = 0.1 m, the strains are almost linearly distributed
from the loading point to the base of the footing; after that, (2) these gradually
Dynamic Behavior of Foundation for Steel Post … 823
decreased inside of the footing and then reached zero strain at the location of
450 mm from the base surface. These distribution characteristics are similar to
those within the elastic state at static loading.
In the case of a drop height H = 0.5 m, the strain of the H-section post near the
base of the footing exceeded the yield value. Furthermore, in the cases of H = 1.0
and 1.5 m, a plastic hinge may be formed in this area because the strain was greater.
On the other hand, each strain of the H-section post excluding the loading point and
the area near the base of the footing was almost the same irrespective of the
magnitude of the drop height H. This suggests that a plastic hinge was formed near
the base of the footing similarly to the static loading case. Also, the strain distri-
bution of the post inside the footing was qualitatively similar to that under static
loading.
The impact load Pi and displacement Di curves under impact loading are shown in
Fig. 9 compared to those under static loading. From this figure, it is observed that
when the drop height H was equal to or greater than 1.0 m, the curves tend to be
similar to that under static loading with increasing displacement. In the case of
H = 0.1 m, since the curve was almost linearly distributed accompanied by some
noise, the post must behave elastically as mentioned above.
In the Handbook, for designing the anchoring depth of the post in the footing it is
recommended that the bending and punching shear load-carrying capacities of the
824 S. Kondo et al.
footing should be checked. In the specification, the bending moment and shear
impact force at a point one half of the anchoring depth d of the post in the footing
were modeled by considering the anchoring part of the post as a short pillar. The
anchoring depth d prescribed in the specification will be compared with the
experimental results obtained from this study.
The bending compressive stress r at the base B of the footing (see Fig. 10) was
specified so as to be less than the allowable bending compressive stress ra of
concrete. The stress r is described as follows:
Py M
r¼ þ ara ð1Þ
A Z
in which Py: yield load when a plastic hinge is formed near the base of the post; A:
area of flange surface of the post inside the footing (= bd); Z: section modulus of the
area which is equal to that of the flange of the post (= bd 2/6); a: overdesign factor
(= 1.5); and M: bending moment at point A shown in Fig. 10. The bending moment
M is given as follows:
d
M ¼ Py h2 þ ð2Þ
2
where h2 is a distance from the base to the impacted point of a falling rock; and d is
the assumed anchoring depth of the post.
However, the shear stress s in the wall, obtained by assuming the shear failure
surface shown in Fig. 10, is specified to be less than the allowable punching shear
stress sa. The stress s is given by the depth of the concrete cover l as follows:
Py
s¼ asa ð3Þ
2ld
Here, the allowable bending compressive stress ra and the punching shear stress
sa were estimated by using compressive strength of concrete f’c and following the
Specifications for Highway Bridges [4, 5] as: ra = 11.5 N/mm2; and sa = 1.09 N/
mm2, respectively.
Estimating the anchoring depths using Eqs. (1) and (3), the following results
were obtained: dm = 346 mm and ds = 68 mm, respectively, for the bending
compressive stress r and punching shear stress s. Therefore, the required anchoring
depth for design purposes in the case of this test is d 350 mm.
On the other hand, experimental results for the anchoring depth de for static and
impact loading are as follows: (1) in the case of static loading, considering the strain
distribution of the H-section post at the displacement D reaching 12 mm, de was
evaluated as de st = 450 mm (Fig. 5); and (2) in the case of impact loading, the
depth de i was evaluated as 450 mm at the drop height H = 0.1 m; however, (3) the
depth de i may be larger than the value of 450 mm at a higher drop height than
H = 0.1 m (Fig. 8).
Dynamic Behavior of Foundation for Steel Post … 825
The strain distribution in the post may not be directly compared with the
specified anchoring depth determined from the Handbook, because the post model
assumes full penetration into the foundation. However, it is confirmed that the
anchoring depths of the tests were larger than the design value, but the concrete
blocks have not yet debonded from the footing.
4 Conclusions
In this paper, in order to investigate the dynamic behavior and actual anchoring
depth of the posts for protection fences installed into the rockfall protection
retaining walls, static and impact loading tests were carried out on the specimens.
The specimens were made of an H-section steel post fully penetrated into the
foundation model. The results obtained from this study can be summarized as
follows:
1. The H-section steel post models reached the ultimate state, forming a plastic
hinge near the base of the footing at both static and impact loading; and
2. The anchoring depth of the post in the footing obtained from the experiments
may be larger than the specific design value; however, the concrete cover has
still not yet debonded from the footing.
References
Abstract A friction damper (FD) can be an effective energy dissipation device for
the seismic protection of structural systems. The level of the constant slip force in a
passive FD is a critical design parameter, since it will determine the amount of
energy dissipated by the damper in an earthquake. A passive FD will behave like a
bracing without energy dissipation capacity when the seismic load is lower than the
slip force, while the amount of energy dissipated by the passive FD may not be
sufficient if the seismic load is much higher than the designed slip force. In order to
improve the control performance, a novel leverage-type variable friction damper
(LVFD), whose friction force can be adjusted in real time through a leverage
mechanism, depending on the earthquake intensity, is introduced in this study.
Different from most existing variable FDs that are usually controlled by adjusting
the clamping force applied on friction interfaces, the LVFD system combines a
passive FD and a leverage mechanism with a movable central pivot. By simply
controlling the pivot position, the frictional damping force generated by the LVFD
can be adjusted in real time; therefore, precision control of the clamping force,
which is usually substantially larger than the slip force, can be avoided.
Furthermore, by considering 16 different ground motions with two different
intensities, the adaptive feature and control performance of the LVFD for the
seismic protection of a 3-story shear structure is further demonstrated numerically,
by comparing with those of its counterpart passive FD systems.
L.-Y. Lu (&)
Department of Civil Engineering, National Cheng Kung University,
Tainan 701, Taiwan
e-mail: lylu@mail.ncku.edu.tw
T.-K. Lin
Department of Civil Engineering, National Chiao Tung University,
Hsinchu 300, Taiwan
e-mail: tklin@nctu.edu.tw
R.-J. Jheng
Department of Construction Engineering,
National Kaohsiung University of Science and Technology, Kaohsiung 801, Taiwan
e-mail: too7811com@yahoo.com.tw
Keywords Friction damper Semi-active control Position control Leverage
mechanism Energy dissipation device
1 Introduction
Friction dampers are one kind of energy dissipation devices for seismic protection
of structural systems [8]. Generally, a friction damper consists of one or more
friction interfaces. A normal force is then applied on the interfaces to generate an
energy-dissipating friction force when a seismic force is exerted on the structure in
which the damper is installed, and the damper will provide an additional energy
dissipation mechanism for the structure. This type of “passive” friction damper
(PFD) does not require additional control energy to operate, and is thus easier to
implement and more reliable. However, the slip force (the maximum friction) of a
PFD is usually a fixed value. In practice, the level of the slip force is predetermined
according to a given design earthquake load. Once the damper is designed and
manufactured, the slip force may no longer be altered. As a result, a PFD may not
be activated in a moderate earthquake, since its slip force is usually designed for a
strong earthquake. In other cases, a PFD may not exhibit sufficient energy dissi-
pation capacity under a severe earthquake, if its slip force is designed for an
earthquake of lower intensity.
In response to the aforementioned drawbacks regarding PFDs, some researchers
have conceived the idea of semi-active friction dampers (SAFDs) recently. Also
called a variable or controllable friction damper, an SAFD is able to alter its slip
force in real-time, according to the structural response or external excitation. In a
traditional SAFD, the slip force is usually adjusted through controlling the normal
contact force on the friction interface of the SAFD, by using a hydraulic power [1],
electromagnetic device [9], piezoelectric actuators [4, 5, 7] (Varela and Llera 2015),
or drum brake components [2]. This kind of traditional SAFDs, whose slip forces
are primarily altered through directly controlling the normal forces, may be referred
to as force-controlled SAFDs that generally require a large control force, since the
controlled normal force may be several times of the desired slip force, depending on
the material friction coefficient. The precise control over this large force in real time
may become difficult and expensive. In view of this, this study proposes a
displacement-controlled SAFD called the leverage-type variable friction damper
(LVFD). This damper consists of a conventional PFD and a leverage mechanism
with a movable central pivot. By controlling the pivot position on the lever-arm, the
equivalent friction force of the LVFD can be altered instantaneously without
changing the damper clamping force. The concept, formulation and performance of
this novel LVFD will be discussed in this paper.
A Leverage-Type Variable Friction Damper … 829
The governing equations of motion for the mathematic model of a structure with
a LVFD shown in Figs. 1 and 2 may be derived by using the Lagrange’s forumula.
The derivation will lead to the following matrix equation [6].
where €xg denotes the ground acceleration, matrices Ms , Cs , and Ks represent the
structural mass, damping and stiffness matrices, respectively. Moreover, x(t) rep-
resents the displacement vector that contains xi (i = 1, 2, n); Bs represents the
damper placement matrix; Es represents the seismic force distribution matrix. In
Eq. (1), the adjustable friction force u(t), which physically represents the equivalent
friction force of the LVFD exerted on the structure, can be written explicitly as
L þ 2xp ðtÞ
rp ðtÞ ¼ ð3Þ
L 2xp ðtÞ
where rp(t) denotes the leverage amplification factor, which is dimensionless and
determined by the pivot position xp(t). Equation (2) states that by adjusting rp(t), the
originally passive friction force uf (t) is converted to a controllable force u(t). In
view of Eq. (3), this semi-active force u(t) is controlled by adjusting the pivot
A Leverage-Type Variable Friction Damper … 831
4 L uf ðtÞ
Fp ðtÞ ¼ ðxb ðtÞ x1 ðtÞÞ ð4Þ
ðL 2xp ðtÞÞ2
where xb denotes bracing deformation. The equation shows that pivot force Fp is
inversely proportional to the lever-arm length L.
where rp; max and rp; min denote the upper and lower bounds of rp (t), respectively,
and x1;max represents a threshold value of the first-story drift beyond which rp (t) is
set to its maximum value rp; max . The PDC controller, is developed based on the
assumption that an increased story drift of the structure usually implies an increased
seismic force exerted on the structure. Therefore, the LVFD should generate a
larger friction force to suppress the structural response when the story drift
increases. Under this assumption and in view of Eq. (2), the PDC described in
Eq. (5) intends to maintain a direct proportionality between the equivalent friction u
(t) of the LVFD and the story drift. As a result, the PDC only requires the mea-
surement of the first-story drift x1 (t) of the structure, and thus it is convenient and
easy to implement. Once rp (t) is determined from Eq. (5), the displacement com-
mand for pivot P can be computed using the following equation, which is obtained
by solving Eq. (3).
Lðrp ðtÞ 1Þ
xp ðtÞ ¼ ð6Þ
2ðrp ðtÞ þ 1Þ
832 L.-Y. Lu et al.
In order to demonstrate the adaptability of the LVFD system, in this section, the
seismic responses of structures with the LVFD and PDC controller will be simu-
lated. In the simulation, two types of structural systems will be considered: one is a
single-DOF structure (let n ¼ 1 in Fig. 1) and the other is a 3-story shear structure
(let n ¼ 3 in Fig. 1). Tables 1 and 2 list the system parameters for the single-DOF
and 3-DOF structural systems with an LVFD, respectively. For comparison pur-
pose, in each structure type, the responses of the LVFD(PDC) will be compared
with those of two passive control schemes named Passive-max and Passive-min, so
that the adaptive feature of the LVFD can be further highlighted. The Passive-max
system refers to the case where the value of rp of the LVFD is fixed at its upper
bound (i.e., rp ¼ rp;max ), so Passive-max is equivalent to a PFD system with a
higher slip force. In the Passive-min system, rp is fixed at its lower bound (i.e.,
rp ¼ rp;min ), so Passive-min is equivalent to a PFD system with a lower slip force.
Table 2 Structural and system parameters of the 3-story structure with LVFD
System Parameter Value
3-story shear Mass of each story (mi) 10.914, 11.213, 11.213
structure ton
Modal frequencies (fi) 1.07, 3.48 and 5.98 Hz
Modal damping ratio (fi) 1.41, 0.44, 0.31%
LVFD parameter (all parameters are the same as those in Table 1)
PDC controller Amplification factor range (rp,max, rp, (2.45, 0.41)
min)
Threshold structural disp. (x1,max) 0.02 m
In this sub-section, the seismic responses of a single-DOF structural system with the
LVFD are simulated by using the system parameters listed in Table 1. Under the
Newhall earthquake, Fig. 3 compares the hysteresis loops of the LVFD using the
three control schemes, namely, PDC, Passive-max and Passive-min controls.
Two PGA levels, i.e., 0.1 g and 0.6 g, are considered in the figure. PGA = 0.1 g is
meant to represent an earthquake with small intensity, while PGA = 0.6 g repre-
sents a severe earthquake. Figure 4 compares the time histories of the accumulative
energy Eu ðtÞ dissipated by the three control schemes for the two different earth-
quake intensities. In Fig. 4, the energy dissipation Eu ðtÞ at a given time instant is
calculated by using the following equation
Z t
Eu ðtÞ ¼ uðsÞdxD ðsÞ ð7Þ
0
where xD ðtÞ denotes the displacement of point D in Fig. 2. Figures 3(a) reveals that
in the small earthquake (PGA = 0.1 g) the hysteresis loop of the LVFD with PDC
controller is closer to that of Passive-min; while Fig. 4(a) shows that the PDC and
Passive-min dissipate almost the same amount of seismic energy and is much larger
than that of Passive-max, since the friction damper in the Passive-max was not
activated during the most of earthquake duration.
On the other hand, in a severe earthquake (PGA = 0.6 g), Fig. 3(b) shows that
the hysteresis loop of the PDC is enlarged and dissipates much more energy than
that of the Passive-min. Figure 4(b) indicates that the amount of energy dissipated
by the PDC at PGA = 0.6 g is much larger than that of the Passive-min, and is even
larger than that of the Passive-max. Therefore, Figs. 3 and 4 together have
demonstrated the superior adaptability of the LVFD with the PDC controller.
Notably, although in Fig. 3(a) the Passive-max seems to have least story drift, it
also exerts the highest force on the structure, which could lead to a higher structural
acceleration.
834 L.-Y. Lu et al.
Fig. 3 Hysteresis loops of LVFD with three control schemes (Newhall earthquake)
Fig. 4 Energy dissipated by LVFD with three control schemes (Newhall earthquake)
To consider a more realistic case of multiple DOF structure, in this sub-section, the
seismic responses of a 3-story shear structure with a LVFD installed in the first floor
and subjected to 16 earthquake records were simulated. The schematic diagram of
this structure with the LVFD is depicted by Fig. 1 for n ¼ 3, and the structural
modal properties that were obtained from a system identification test performed on
a real steel frame are listed in Table 2 [3]. As shown in Table 2, the three natural
A Leverage-Type Variable Friction Damper … 835
frequencies of the 3-story frame were 1.07, 3.48 and 5.98 Hz. In the simulation, the
16 ground motion records were carefully selected to be representative of earth-
quakes with different characteristics, and some of them are near-fault earthquakes
with a long-period pulse component. The peak responses of this structure with the
three control systems, namely, the LVFD(PDC), Passive-max and Passive-min are
compared. The control parameters for the LVFD(PDC) used in the simulation are
also listed in the lower part of Table 2. Basically, these PDC parameters resemble
those in Table 1 used for the single-DOF structure. Notably, the threshold value of
the first-story drift for the PDC controller is taken as x1;max ¼ 0:02 m, which is
about one-third of x1;max in the single-DOF structure (see Table 1), since the
structure has three stories. The bracing stiffness for the LVFD is taken to be
kb ¼ 97371 kN/m that yields about the same bracing-to-structure stiffness ratio for
the single-DOF structure.
To investigate the adaptive feature of the LVFD, Figs. 5 and 6 compare the
average peak responses of the 3-story structure controlled by the three LVFD
control schemes and subjected to the 16 ground motions with the PGA scaled to
0.1 g (low intensity) and 0.3 g (high intensity), respectively. The averages of the
peak displacement and story-shear at each floor level are depicted in subplots
(a) and (b), respectively. In the figures, the average peak responses of an uncon-
trolled system, which refers to the structure without any kind of damper systems,
are also depicted for comparison. From Figs. 5(a) and 5(b), it is observed that for
lower-intensity earthquakes (PGA = 0.1 g), the LVFD(PDC) has the lowest dis-
placement responses at the second and third floors, while its story-shears are close
to those of the Passive-min, which has the lowest story shears at all floor levels. The
Passive-max performs as poorly as the uncontrolled system for story-shear
response, since Passive-max may not be activated in small earthquakes of
PGA = 0.1 g. On the other hand, for earthquakes with a higher intensity
(PGA = 0.3 g), Figs. 6(a) and 6(b) show that the LVFD(PDC) has the second
lowest displacement and shear responses at all floor-levels, and are very close to
those of the Passive-max, which has the lowest responses. Both the Passive-min
and uncontrolled system induce the floor-displacement responses that are sub-
stantially higher than those of the LVFD(PDC) and Passive-max. This implies that
the seismic energy dissipated by the Passive-min and uncontrolled systems are
insufficient in earthquake with higher intensity of PGA = 0.3 g. Figures 5 and 6
together demonstrate that the variable friction property has made the LVFD system
adaptive to the earthquake intensity and is advantageous for the seismic response
mitigation of a multiple-DOF structural system.
836 L.-Y. Lu et al.
3 3
Uncontrolled
Passive-Min
Passive-Max
LCFD(PDC)
2 2
Floor level
Floor level
Uncontrolled
Passive-Min
Passive-Max
LCFD(PDC)
1 1
0 0
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 2 4 6 8 10
4
Displacement(m) Total shear(N) x 10
(a) Average peak floor displacement (b) Average peak story shear
Fig. 5 Comparison of average peak responses for the 3-story structure (PGA = 0.1 g)
3 3
Uncontrolled
Passive-Min
Passive-Max
LCFD(PDC)
2 2
Floor level
Floor level
Uncontrolled
Passive-Min 1
1
Passive-Max
LCFD(PDC)
0 0
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
5
Displacement(m) Total shear(N) x 10
(a) Average peak floor displacement (b) Average peak story shear
Fig. 6 Comparison of average peak responses for the 3-story structure (PGA = 0.3 g)
5 Conclusions
A semi-active friction damper (SAFD), whose slip force can be controlled in real
time, may provide better seismic protection for a structural system than a passive
damper. However, a conventional SAFD, that employs a force-control method to
regulate the clamping force applied on the friction interface, usually require precise
control of the huge clamping force. To avert this problem, the notion of
leverage-type variable friction damper (LVFD) is proposed and its control perfor-
mance is evalued numerically in this study. The LVFD that regulates its friction
damping force by a displacement-control approach is primarily composed of a
passive friction damper and a leverage mechanism with a movable central pivot. By
controlling the pivot position in real time, the equivalent friction force of the LVFD
A Leverage-Type Variable Friction Damper … 837
system can be adjusted precisely. Moreover, in order to determine the pivot position
effectively, a simple control law called “proportional displacement control (PDC)”
is adopted. Finally, considering a single-DOF and a 3-story shear structures, the
adaptive feature of the LVFD with the PDC controller was demonstrated by
comparing the responses of the LVFD with those of two types of passive control
schemes, one with a lower slip-force (Passive-min) and the other with higher
slip-force (Passive-max), respectively. The numerical results showed that the
energy dissipation capacity and the peak responses of the LVFD with the PDC
controller resemble those of the Passive-min system in a lower-intensity earthquake,
and resemble those of the Passive-max system in a higher-intensity earthquake.
This demonstrates that the friction behavior of the LVFD system is adaptive to
seismic excitations, so that better energy dissipation capacity can be achieved for
earthquakes with different intensities.
Acknowledgements This research was supported in part by the Ministry of Science and
Technology of R.O.C. (Taiwan), through grant MOST103-2625-M-006-010.
References
1. Kannan S, Uras HM, Aktan HM (1995) Active control of building seismic response by energy
dissipation. Earthquake Eng Struct Dynam 24(5):747–759
2. Laflamme M, Taylor D, Abdellaoui Maane M, Connor JJ (2012) Modified friction device for
control of large-scale systems. Struct Control Health Monit 19(4):548–564
3. Lu LY, Chung LL (2001) Modal control of seismic structures using augmented state matrix.
Earthquake Eng Struct Dynam 30(2):237–256
4. Lu LY, Lin CC, Lin GL, Lin CY (2010) Experiment and analysis of a fuzzy-controlled
piezoelectric seismic isolation system. J Sound Vib 329(11):1992–2014
5. Lu LY, Lin GL, Lin CY (2011) Experimental verification of a piezoelectric smart isolation
system. Struct Control Health Monit 18(8):869–889
6. Lu LY, Lin TK, Jheng RJ, Wu HH (2018) Theoretical and experimental investigation of a
displacement-controlled semi-active friction damper for seismic structures. J Sound Vib
412:184–206
7. Ozbulut E, Bitaraf M (2011) Adaptive control of base-isolated structures against near-field
earthquakes using variable friction dampers. Eng Struct 33:3143–3154
8. Pall RT, Gauthier G, Delisle S, Pall A (2000) Friction-dampers for seismic upgrade police
headquarters. In: Proceedings of the 12th world conferences on earthquake engineering, New
Zealand, paper no. 2014
9. Yang JN, Agrawal AK (2002) Semi-active hybrid control systems for nonlinear building
against near-fault earthquakes. Eng Struct 24(3):271–280
Inelastic Deformation Ratio Evaluation
and Application to the Seismic Codes
Abstract This paper present a new semi-analytical approach aims to estimating the
inelastic deformation ratio for SDOF bilinear systems. The new proposed approach
combines both the inelastic and elastic maximum lateral displacement demands
instead of combining the yield-strength reduction factor and the ductility factor. The
new inelastic deformation ratio on one hand depends on the inelastic properties of
systems (the period, the post-to-preyield stiffness ratio, the yield strength coeffi-
cient, the normalized yield strength coefficient), on the other hand the elastic
spectral response acceleration ðSa Þ that is presented in seismic design codes, such as
the Federal Emergency Management Agency FEMA and Eurocode8. The results
are compared to those of the Nonlinear Time History Analysis (NL-THA) and some
existing formulations for three different reinforced concrete (R.C.) 2D-frames
subjected to the record ground motion of El-Centro 1940 (N/S).
1 Introduction
During an earthquake engineers always try to predict the maximum lateral dis-
placement of the structure which leads us to estimate the seismic demand. The most
useful methods to assess the inelastic response can be divide in two categories,
force-based methods and displacement-based methods. This latter depends on both
the inelastic and elastic response spectrum. Nowadays in the current seismic codes
many studies have focused on the Displacement Coefficient Method (DCM). The
basic idea of the DCM is converting the elastic linear displacement of an equivalent
Single Degree of Freedom (SDOF) system to achieve the inelastic displacement of a
Multi-Degree of Freedom (MDOF) system. This approach depend on such modi-
fication coefficients as the inelastic deformation ratio (Ratio between the inelastic
and elastic maximum lateral displacement demands) which depend on systems that
is known either as the yield-strength reduction factor or the ductility factor.
The first research that investigated the inelastic deformation ratios was by
Veletsos and Newmark [13], after that many researchers have studied, some of
them developed an ensemble of empirical approaches of the inelastic deformation
ratio [6, 9, 11, 12, 14–18, 19].
Recently, FEMA 440 (ATC-55 2005) planned by the Applied Technology
Council for the evaluation the performance of current procedures and suggested
certain improvements. Akkar and Metin [2] evaluated the improved Capacity
Spectrum Method (CSM) and improved displacement coefficient method (DCM) of
FEMA 440 (ATC 2005) by conducting numerous nonlinear response history
analyses on SDOF and MDOF systems under near-fault ground motions with pulse.
For most structure FEMA400 propose a new expression may be used for the
coefficient C1 (the inelastic deformation ratio).
More recently, Chikh et al. [4, 5] proposed a theoretical approach to estimates
the inelastic deformation ratio for equivalent SDOF bilinear systems. This latter
unifies and combines both Cl and CR effects and depends on the normalized yield
strength coefficient.
Mechaala et al. [10] proposed a new theoretical approach to estimates the
inelastic deformation ratio by including the effect of the higher modes of vibration.
In this paper, we first present the background of the nonlinear equations of
motion, and then is following the development of the inelastic and elastic response
spectra. Next, new design equations for the inelastic deformation ratio are devel-
oped. The equations should be useful in estimating the inelastic deformations ratios
for the seismic design and evaluation of structures. Finally, a simplified expression
of inelastic deformation ratio formula is proposed for the current and future Seismic
Codes.
Inelastic Deformation Ratio Evaluation … 841
The inelastic deformation ratio is defined as the relationship between the peak of
inelastic deformation and corresponding elastic deformation [6]. This ratio will be
denoted by Eq. (1):
xm l
C1 ¼ or ð1Þ
x0 R y
Where: x0 and xm are the peak of elastic and inelastic deformations of the SDOF
system, respectively (see Fig. 1).
Note that f 0 is the peak resisting force of elastic system, f y is yield strength of the
inelastic SDOF system and xy is the yield displacement (see Fig. 1).
xm
Cl ¼ ð4Þ
x0
And the second with known yield strength reduction factor Ry [5] defined by
Eq. (5):
xm
CR ¼ ð5Þ
x0
Chikh et al. [4, 5], proposed new model of the inelastic deformation ratio which
depends on the period, the post-to-preyield stiffness ratio, the yield strength and the
peak ground acceleration which is expressed by Eq. (6)
8
< 1
abT T gc T 1 sec
g1
Cg ¼ 1 T 1 sec ð6Þ
:
g1 1 for all values of T
Where: a; b and c are derived from the non-linear regression analysis for each
specific a value and each of the three specific intervals for T
Where: m, c and f represent the mass, damping, and the resisting force of the
system, respectively. €xg ðtÞ denotes the earthquake acceleration, f is usually reported
as the sum of a linear part and a hysteretic part [3] and expressed by Eq. (8):
f ¼ kp x þ Qz ð8Þ
In the above equation, kp and Q represent the post yield stiffness and the yield
strength, respectively. z is the dimensionless variable that characterizes the
Bouc-Wen model of hysteresis [18], it is given by Eq. (9):
x_
z_ ¼ ½A jzjg ðcsgnðx_ zÞ þ bÞ ð9Þ
xy
Inelastic Deformation Ratio Evaluation … 843
Fig. 2 Behavior of an
(SDOF) bilinear system [3, 4]
kp Q
€x þ 2nx_x þ x þ z ¼ €xg ðtÞ ð10Þ
m m
Where:
The procedure to construct the elastic and inelastic response spectra for inelastic
and corresponding elastic SDOF systems with specified levels of yield strength q
and post-to-preyield stiffness ratio a, is summarized in the following section:
1. Define the ground motion €xg ðtÞ;
2. Select and fix the damping ratio n and the post-to-preyield stiffness ratio a for
which the spectrum is to be plotted;
3. Specify a value for the yield strength q;
4. Select a value for elastic period T;
5. Solve Eq. (11) and Eq. (13) and determine the inelastic and elastic displacement
response xðtÞ according to the values selected for T; n; q and a.
6. Derive and select the maximum value of the inelastic and elastic displacement.
7. Repeat steps 3 to 6 for the given range of periods T.
8. Calculate the inelastic deformation ratios C ðn; T; a; qÞ.
Once the elastic and inelastic responses have been found and the influence of a
and q have been analyzed Abdelmounaim et al. [1], the inelastic deformation ratio
should be determined as a function of q and a using the El Centro 1940 earthquake
(N/S) ground motion for more explanation about the influence of these parameters
of control.
Abdelmounaim et al. [1] studied the influence of the post-to-preyield stiffness
ratio a and the yield strength coefficient q using the inelastic deformation ratio
spectra, the main results showed that:
– For periods T [ 1 s and for different values of both post-to-preyield stiffness
ratio a and the yield strength coefficient q, the inelastic deformation ratio
C ¼ 1.
Furthermore when q [ 0:3 and for any period T; the inelastic deformation ratio
is close to the unity (C 1Þ.
– The post-to-preyield stiffness ratio a has no effect when T [ 1 s , however it has
a small slightly influence when periods T\1 s.
The inelastic deformation ratio formulas presented above have been developed, in
order to simplify the estimation of this latter. Recently, Benazouz et al. [3] proposed
simplified expressions to compute the peak inelastic deformation xm by using a
parameter called the normalized yield strength coefficient (defined as yield strength
coefficient to the Peak Ground Acceleration PGA), given by Eq. (15):
Inelastic Deformation Ratio Evaluation … 845
qg
g¼ ð15Þ
PGA
Where: a, b and c are parameters arranged in Table 3 below for the different
values of g and a. Table 1 resumes the main results according to parameters a; b
and c.
Furthermore, for periods greater than 0:6 s [2], a simplified equation may be
used to calculate the inelastic deformation xm , which is given by using the fol-
lowing expression of Eq. (17):
Several studies have been investigated to develop a simplified expression for the
inelastic deformation ratio considering SDOF systems. The new proposed proce-
dure allows us to assess the inelastic deformation ratio without using neither yield
strength nor the post-to-preyield stiffness ratio. It provides a good estimation of
inelastic deformation ratio for new or rehabilitated structures, using only the elastic
response spectrum and xm obtained from Eqs. (16) and (17). The Eq. (18) shows us
the simplified expressions given by:
8 1
>
> PGA aðbÞT ðTÞ
g þ 2c
< 4p2 ð1aÞ =SD 0\T\0:6 s
q 0:3 Cq ¼ 0:6 s T 1:0 s
>
> 0:027 T 0:84 PGA=SD ð18Þ
: T [ 1:0 s
1:0
q 0:3 Cq ¼ 1:0 For all values of T
F T2 Sa Te2
SD ¼ ¼ mSa 2e ¼ ð19Þ
k 4p m 4p2
5 5
Proposed C
4 T heoretical C 4
NH
KN
3 3
RM
CR
C
CC
2 FEMA356 2
FEMA440
1 1
0 0
0 1 2 3 0 1 2 3
Period, sec Period, sec
Fig. 3 Inelastic deformations ratio for El-Centro 1940 (PGA = 0.319, q = 0.2, a = 0.1)
Where:
3 Application
In order to evaluate the inelastic deformation ratio three examples of three (3St),
seven (7St) and ten (10St) story reinforced concrete frames are used to evaluate the
coefficient C1 that represents the inelastic deformation of structures in the
Displacement Coefficient Method (DCM). where in all consisting three-bay frame
with 4 m spaced and typical story height of 3 m.
The intent of the study is to analytically confirm the application of the proposed
expressions when using the nonlinear time history analysis. For this purpose,
reinforcements yield strength has been modeled using a bilinear curve (yield
strength 413 MPa, concrete compressive strength 25 MPa, and concrete density
Inelastic Deformation Ratio Evaluation … 847
50 1000 1000
0 0 0
0 0.5 1 1.5 0 10 20 0 20 40
x, cm x, cm x, cm
Fig. 4 Pushover curve and capacity diagram of 3St, 7St and 10St structures
Table 2 Inelastic deformation form Eq. (15), Eq. (16) and NL-THA with El Centro (1940)
ground motion (N/S)
Structure T ðsÞ a(%) q g xm NL-THA xm xm Eq. 16 and x0
(cm) Theoretical 17 (cm) (cm)
3St 0.30 24 0.299 0.94 1.718 1.20 1.56 1.70
7St 0.96 3.1 0.263 0.83 12.671 8.20 8.19 8.5
10St 1.40 2.5 0.256 0.81 13.133 8.70 11.19 9.31
2:5 t/m3 and concrete Young’s modulus 3:21107 KN/m2 ). The capacity curve in
this application is obtained by applying the adaptive Pushover Analysis (Reinhorn
et al. 2006). The capacity curve of each structure is shown in Fig. 4.
To estimate the inelastic deformation ratio more accurately, once the analysis has
been completed, the results obtained from the idealization of the Pushover curve are
shown in Table 2, (where a ¼ kp =ke is the post-to-preyield stiffness ratio). The next
step in the analysis is to determine the dynamic inelastic displacement using the
nonlinear time history analysis with the IDARC program. The results of the new
proposed procedure and theoretical expression (from MATLAB) are illustrated in
Table 2.
Figure 5 shows different inelastic response spectra of three (3St), seven (7St) and
ten (10St) story reinforced concrete frames with El-Centro 1940 (N/S) ground
motion. In order to verify the exactitude of the proposed theoretical and empirical
approaches, the obtained results are compared and summarized in Table 3 with
some existing formulations.
One can notice that, for the considered examples, the Eq. (18) gives a good
result in comparison with the results obtained when using the existing formulations.
848 A. Mechaala et al.
0.35
0.3
St3
St7
0.25
St10
0.2
xm, m
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0 0.3 0.96 1.4 2 3
Period, sec
Fig. 5 Inelastic response spectra for each structure obtained with El-Centro 1940 (N/S) ground
motion
Table 3 Comparison of the proposed inelastic deformation ratio with those obtained from the
NL-THA with El Centro (1940) ground motion (N/S) and some existing formulations
Structure CNLTHA Theoretical C CEq:18 CNH CKN C FEMA CRM CCC C FEMA Cg
356 440
3St 1.01 0.70 0.92 1.00 1.03 1.00 1.03 1.07 1.00 0.80
7St 1.49 0.96 0.96 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.99
10St 1.41 0.93 1.20 1.00 0.99 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
4 Conclusions
The main target of this investigation is to develop a new theoretical equation for the
inelastic deformation ratio, which allows the estimation of the maximum inelastic
deformation by using the maximum elastic deformation. This equation is expressed
by a series of parameters (the natural period, the post-to-preyield stiffness ratio, the
normalized yield strength coefficient and the peak ground acceleration) taking in
consideration a SDOF bilinear system. In this study El-Centro 1940 (N/S) record
ground motions was used. According to the results above, the new inelastic
deformation ratio (C) shows a sensitive to the post-to-preyield stiffness ratio (a),
yield strength coefficient q and the normalized yield strength coefficient (g).
The main conclusions for this investigation could be summarized as follows:
The new proposed procedure provides us to evaluate the inelastic deformation
ratio without using neither yield strength nor the post-to-preyield stiffness ratio.
The accuracy of C depends strongly on the inelastic properties of systems, i.e.
a; q and PGA (peak ground acceleration).
Inelastic Deformation Ratio Evaluation … 849
Simplified expression for the inelastic deformation ratio have been developed
ðCq ), as a function of T, a, x0 , q and PGA. This equation provides a good estimation
of inelastic deformation ratio for new or rehabilitated structures when the elastic
response spectrum is known in comparison with the other results obtained from
existing formulations.
New design equations are developed and proposed for the current and future
Seismic Codes to estimate the inelastic deformations ratios for the assessment of
structures, based on the design response spectrum of this latter and the peak
inelastic deformation parameters.
References
16. Ruiz-García J, Miranda E (2003) Inelastic displacement ratios for evaluation of existing
structures. Earthquake Eng Struct Dynam 32(8):1237–1258
17. Shimazaki K, Sozen MA (1984) Seismic drift of reinforced concrete structures. Hazama-gumi
18. Wen YK (1976) Method for random vibration of hysteretic systems. J Eng Mech Div 102
(2):249–263
19. Zhai C, Li S, Xie L, Sun Y (2007) Study on inelastic displacement ratio spectra for near-fault
pulse-type ground motions. Earthq Eng Eng Vib 6(4):351–355
Development of 1D and 2D Portable
Shaking Table Test System
as Educational Materials
1 Introduction
A questionnaire survey to the students who had difficulties in the vibration engi-
neering class at our college revealed the importance of the enhancement of
understandings of the relation between the phenomenon of vibration and the related
equation and the intuitive understanding of the strength of vibration such as the
seismic intensity and acceleration [3]. Shaking table tests are considered to be
effective to give the intuitive understandings in the subjects such as earthquake
disaster prevention, vibration and earthquake resistance in the department of civil
engineering and architecture. However, those systems are generally installed at
higher education institutions and are mainly used for the purpose of research. Data
of vibration of structure models on the shaking table are measured by the measuring
device such as accelerometers and proceeded offline. It is not expected to be fre-
quently used in the classrooms. Therefore, the development of portable shaking
table test systems which can be often used in the classrooms to demonstrate the
phenomena of vibration is required.
Recently, some portable shaking tables have been developed which is easy to be
carried to classrooms. The hand-turned type shaking table including some building
models, which was developed by [1], is commercially supplied at a low price. The
motor-driven portable shaking table was also developed by [1]. They support the
visual understandings about the phenomena of vibration. However, the functions to
support the verification of the theory and the quantitative understandings of the
scale of vibration are also required. [3] developed the portable shaking table device
which enabled real-time measurement of motions and calculation of their seismic
intensity and Fourier spectra. The values of seismic intensity and the graphs of
waveform and Fourier spectra can be visualized in real time. [4] developed the
virtual portable vibration experiment device, in which the shaking table and
structure models were built virtually in the computer display and the table was
controlled in response to the movement of one’s hand. Also, [5] improved the
experiment system, using a commercially available compact 1-axis actuator, in
which the real shaking table could be used.
In this study, a new portable shaking test system which is composed of a motion
controller, two actuators and a PC is introduced.
2.1 Hardware
The hardware is composed of a motion controller, one or two actuators and their
drivers, and a PC as shown in Fig. 1. Figure 2 shows PMC-S4/00/00A-U produced
by Y2 co. ltd. and EASM6X-D020-ARAC produced by Oriental Motor co. ltd.
used as the motion controller and the actuator with its driver, respectively. The cost
of these devices except PC in total is under 2,500 US dollar.
The actuator is driven by the stepping motor. The primary specification of the
actuator is shown in Table 1. The lead denotes the shift amount of the actuator per 1
rotation of the motor. The shift amount and the moving velocity are controlled by
the number of pulse and pulse velocity, respectively. They can be calculated by the
following equations.
ðnumber of pulse in ½pulseÞ¼ðrequired shift amount in ½mmÞ=ðminimum shift amount in ½mmÞ ð1Þ
ðpulse velocity in ½HzÞ¼ðrequired moving velocity in ½mm/sÞ / (minimum shift amount in ½mm]) ð2Þ
Development of 1D and 2D Portable Shaking Table Test System … 853
Fig. 2 Motion controller (upper left), driver (upper right) and actuator (lower)
2.2 Software
The software is built using VB.NET. The API functions prepared as the accessary
of the motion controller are used to control the actuator. The actuator is basically
controlled by receiving the values of velocity and displacement at regular intervals.
Two ways are prepared for the control of the actuator. One is the way that the
prepared set of time series of data is sent to the actuator. The other is the way that
the values of velocity and displace, which are obtained by the integration of the
acceleration, are sent to the actuator.
3 Behavior of Actuator
The comparison of the wave forms of velocity in case of sinusoidal input are shown
in Fig. 3. Though slight disagreements between the transmitted data and the
behavior of the shaking table are recognized, the wave forms are almost identical.
Sine sine-waves up to about 10 Hz can be expressed by this shaking table
depending on the amplitude.
Figure 4 shows the comparison of wave forms in case of random vibration input,
in which the scaled acceleration in the event of an actual earthquake was used.
Partially disagreement can be recognized between the wave forms. The velocity of
the shaking table is larger in some peaks of the wave form.
Fig. 3 Comparison of wave forms of velocity between behavior of shaking table and transmitted
data in case of sinusoidal input
Development of 1D and 2D Portable Shaking Table Test System … 855
Fig. 4 Comparison of wave forms of velocity between behavior of shaking table and transmitted
data in case of random vibration input
4 Applications
The structure model of shear deformation type is shown in Fig. 5. The material of
the model is aluminium plate with thickness of 1 mm.
The records of free vibration of the structure model can be used for the estimation of
the natural period and damping constant of the structure model. Figure 6 shows the
waveform and the Fourier spectrum of the acceleration of the structure model. The
natural period can be estimated directly from the peak frequency of the Fourier
spectrum. The data of acceleration can be saved as text data. By reading the data in
Microsoft Excel and drawing the waveform, the damping constant can be estimated
from the ratio of two peak values of acceleration. The natural period and damping
constant of this structure model were identified as 0.196 s and 0.008, respectively.
The structure model is excited by the shaking table. It is recognized that the
response of the structural model may be several times greater than that of the
vibrating table, depending on how the shaking table is controlled In addition, if the
shaking table is moved at a cycle close to the natural period of the structure model,
the resonance can be quantitatively evaluated from the waveforms and the Fourier
spectra.
856 O. Tsujihara et al.
€
€y þ 2hn_y þ n2 y ¼ / ð3Þ
Development of 1D and 2D Portable Shaking Table Test System … 857
Fig. 7 Comparison between analytical model responses excited by shaking table and recorded
motion
As shown in Fig. 8, 2 actuators are mounted at right angle on the base to realize the
2D shaking table. The dedicated rails that move with the moving part of the
actuators are required. The most difficult part was the development of the 2-axis
slide mechanism (see Fig. 9) that played the role of transmitting the rail movement
in two directions to the sliding table. Figure 10 shows the vibrating of 3-story
structure model excited by the 2-axis shaking table.
858 O. Tsujihara et al.
Fig. 11 8-story structure models excited in same direction but different period and amplitude
The two actuators can be used to move the wide diorama model as shown in
Fig. 12. The diorama model is attached to the actuators arranged in parallel. Then,
the two actuators are required to move completely in unison.
860 O. Tsujihara et al.
5 Conclusions
References
Keywords FRP sheet Flexural strengthening Consecutive impact loading RC
beams Sheet debonding
1 Introduction
In Japan, after the Great Hanshin Awaji Earthquake on Jan. 17, 1995, strengthening
and/or retrofitting of the reinforced concrete (RC) bridge piers were carried out
nationwide. Generally, the thickness increasing method and/or steel plate jacketing
method have been usually applied for these strengthening works. However, recently
the fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) sheet bonding method has been sometimes used
because of the unique advantages of the FRP materials such as corrosion resistance,
high strength-to-weight ratio, and easy installation. Now, design methods for
strengthening RC members with FRP materials have been established [1, 5] and the
method was widely applied worldwide.
While FRP materials may be applicable for strengthening the RC structures
under not only static loads but also extreme loads such as blast and impact loads [2–
4, 10–12], the authors have also investigated the applicability of the FRP materials
for strengthening RC structures under impact loading, both experimentally and
numerically [7, 9]. However, design specifications for RC members strengthened
with FRP materials under impact loading have not been established yet, and further
studies are required.
From this point of view, in this paper, to investigate impact-resistant charac-
teristics of the RC members strengthened with FRP sheets, consecutive drop-weight
impact loading tests of the RC beams strengthened with bonding aramid FRP
(AFRP) sheet were carried out. To investigate the strengthening effects of the AFRP
sheets on impact-resistant capacities of the beams, unstrengthened beams were also
tested as a reference. Based on the test results, the failure behavior of the beams and
relationships between maximum/residual deflections and the input impact energy
were discussed.
2 Experimental Overview
In this study, a total of 8 specimens were used. Drop height of the weight, input
impact energy, material properties of concrete and rebar, and calculated flexural and
shear load-carrying capacities of the specimens are listed in Table 1. In this table,
the nominal name of the specimen was designated in the order of strengthening
material (N: none and AS: AFRP), loading method (S: static loading, and CI:
consecutive impact loading), and set drop height of the weight (Hm-n) (m and n:
drop height for the initial and subsequent loadings, respectively, in metric unit). The
estimated drop height of the weight (referred to hereinafter as drop height) was
evaluated using the measured drop velocity of the weight just before impacting the
upper surface of the beam.
The calculated static flexural and shear load-carrying capacities of each speci-
men were estimated according to the Standard Specification for Concrete Structure
[6] using material properties of concrete, rebar, and AFRP sheet (see, Table 2).
Table 1 List of specimens
Specimen Experimental Set Measured Measured Accumulated Compressive Yield Yield Calculated Calculated Debonding
case drop drop input input impact strength of stress stress flexural shear of AFRP
height height of impact energy Eai concrete f’c of axial of capacity capacity sheet
of weight energy Ei (kJ) (MPa) rebar fya stirrup Pusc (kN) Vusc (kN)
weight H’(m) (kJ) (MPa) fys
H (m) (MPa)
N-S N-S Static – – – 32.4 381.7 461.9 55.0 329.0 –
N-CI-H1 N-CI-H1-1 1 1.01 2.97 2.97 33.7 371.0 401.9 54.0 298.8 –
N-CI-H1-2 2 1.99 5.85 8.82
Experimental Study on Dynamic Behaviors …
–
N-CI-H2.5 N-CI-H2.5-2.5 2.5 2.49 6.73 6.73 32.4 381.7 461.9 55.0 329.0 –
AS-S AS-S Static – – – 33.7 371.0 401.9 126.1 298.8 Yes
AS-CI-H1 AS-CI-H1-1 1 1.01 2.97 2.97 No
AS-CI-H1-2 2 1.99 5.85 8.82 No
AS-CI-H1-2.5 2.5 2.49 7.33 16.15 Yes
AS-CI-H2 AS-CI-H2-2 2.0 1.99 5.85 5.85 No
AS-CI-H2-2.5 2.5 2.61 7.69 13.54 Yes
AS-CI-H2.5 AS-CI-H2.5 2.5 2.49 7.33 7.33 Yes
AS-CI-H3 AS-CI-H3.0 3.0 3.04 8.95 8.95 Yes
865
866 S. Le Huy et al.
Figure 1 shows the dimensions of the specimens and the layout of rebars and
AFRP sheets. All beams have a rectangular cross-section of 200 mm width,
250 mm depth, and 3 m clear span length. The axial rebars were welded to the steel
plate at the ends of the beams to ensure full anchorage. Stirrups were placed at
intervals of 100 mm and the AFRP sheets were bonded to the tension-side surface
of the beams leaving 50 mm between the end of the sheet and support point.
Beam AS was strengthened by bonding two-ply AFRP sheets with a density of
1660 g/m2. Material properties of the AFRP sheets used in this study are listed in
Table 2.
Static loading tests were carried out following the three-point-loading test
method. The load was surcharged using the loading jig with 100 mm width in the
span direction by using a hydraulic jack at the mid-span of the beam.
Impact load was applied by dropping a 300 kg steel weight from a predeter-
mined height onto the mid-span of the beam. The height was increased in the order
of 1, 2, 2.5, and 3 m until the beams reached the ultimate state due to the AFRP
sheet debonding or fracturing. The weight was made of a steel solid cylinder with a
height of 1.4 m and a diameter of 200 mm for the striking part, and its impacting
surface has a taper with a height of 2 mm to prevent from one-sided contact.
In this experiment, time histories of the impact force P, the reaction force R, and
the mid-span deflection (hereinafter, deflection)d, and axial strain distribution of the
AFRP sheets were measured. The deflection was measured by using a laser-type
Linear Variable Displacement Transducer (LVDT). These output data were con-
tinuously recorded by using digital data recorders with a sampling time of 0.1 ms.
After each test, the residual deflection was measured, and the crack patterns of the
beam were also sketched.
Fig. 3 Comparisons of
load-deflection curves
between Beams N-S and
AS-S
Figure 4 shows comparisons of the crack patterns between Beams N-S and AS-S
after the static loading. From this figure, the following findings indicate that: (1) in
the case of Beam N-S, the flexural cracks developed concentrating around the
loading area and the beam was permanently deformed near the area; (2) in the case
of Beam AS-S, the flexural cracks were more widely distributed than those for
Beam N-S; and (3) Beam AS-S was not permanently deformed due to the
strengthening effects of the AFRP sheet.
Figure 5 shows the comparisons of time histories of the impact force P, the reaction
force R, and the displacement d between Beams N-CI-H1 and AS-CI-H1. Figure 5
(a) shows the comparisons of the dynamic responses at the drop height H = 1 m
between Beams N/AS-CI-H1. From the figures, it is observed that: (1) time his-
tories of the main response on the impact force P and the reaction force R were
similar to each other; but (2) the maximum and residual deflections for Beam AS
were smaller than those of Beam N.
Figure 5(b) shows the comparisons of dynamic responses at the drop height
H = 2 m between Beams N/AS-CI-H1. From these figures, the followings can be
observed; (1) time histories of the impact force P were similar to each other;
(2) time duration of the main response of the reaction force R for Beam N was
prolonged for 20 ms comparing to that of Beam AS; and (3) maximum and residual
deflections for Beam AS were also remarkably smaller than those for Beam N.
Figure 6 shows comparisons of time histories on dynamic responses of
Beam AS between the same initial drop heights H. In these comparisons, each time
history was for only the specified loading step and the accumulated responses due
to consecutive loadings have not been included. From the figures, it is observed that
the responses have similar time histories except maximum amplitude, time duration
of the main response, and the natural vibration period of the damped-free vibration
for the beam after unloading irrespective of the magnitude of the initial and sub-
sequent drop heights.
From Figs. 5 and 6, the negative reaction forces were observed at the beginning
of impact. This means that both ends of the beams may be uplifted due to rebound.
Figure 6(a) shows comparisons of experimental results for Beam AS-CI-H1. From
Fig. 5 Comparisons of time histories of impact force P, reaction force R, and deflection d
between Beam N and AS: a Beam N/AS-CI-H1-1; and b Beam N/AS-CI-H1-2
870 S. Le Huy et al.
Fig. 6 Comparisons of time histories of impact P, reaction force R, and deflection d: a Beam
AS-CI-H1; b Beam AS-CI-H2; c Beam AS-CI-H2.5; and d Beam AS-CI-H3
this figure, the findings indicate that: (1) the minimum and maximum impact forces
excited at the drop heights H = 1 m and H = 2 m were 766 kN and 1047 kN,
respectively; (2) maximum reaction force tends to increase with increasing the drop
height H although the maximum impact force at H = 2.5 m was less than that at
H = 2 m; and (3) time duration of the main response of the reaction force R for the
case at H = 2.5 m was prolonged for 25 ms comparing with that at H = 2 m
because of the sheet debonding.
From the results of the deflection time histories, it is seen that maximum and
residual deflections for each loading step increased with increasing the subsequent
drop height H and natural period of the damped-free vibration also prolonged
similarly. Even though the AFRP sheet debonded at the drop height H = 2.5 m, the
influence was not clearly shown in the time history. However, since the residual
deflection at H = 2.5 m increased by a factor of about five comparing to that at
H = 2 m, this suggests that the sheet debonded at this loading step.
Figure 6(b) shows comparisons of experimental results for Beam AS-CI-H2. In
this case, beam reached the ultimate state at the drop height H = 2.5 m due to
AFRP sheet debonding. From these figures, the following finding can be indicated:
Experimental Study on Dynamic Behaviors … 871
(1) both the maximum impact and reaction forces increased corresponding to
increasing the drop height H; and (2) time duration of the main response at
H = 2.5 m was prolonged for 20 ms comparing to that at H = 2 m due to the AFRP
sheet debonding. Comparing maximum and residual deflections at the drop heights
H = 2 and 2.5 m between Beams AS-CI-H1 (see, Fig. 6a) and Beam AS-CI-H2, it
is seen that: (1) in the case at the drop height H = 2 m (AS-CI-H1-2 and
AS-CI-H2-2), maximum and residual deflections were approximately same to each
other; however, (2) in the case of H = 2.5 m (AS-CI-H1-2.5 and AS-CI-H2-2.5),
maximum and residual deflections for Beam AS-CI-H2 were about 4 mm smaller
than those for Beam AS-CI-H1. Thus, even though the beams are strengthened in
flexure with FRP sheet, damage may accumulate due to consecutive loading.
Figure 6(c) shows the experimental results for Beam AS-CI-H2.5. In this case,
the impact test was finished after the initial load was applied because the AFRP
sheet debonded at this loading step. From these figures, the maximum impact force
reached about 1,346 kN, and the maximum reaction force stayed around 238 kN.
The impact and reaction forces for Beam AS-CI-H2.5 were larger than those for
Beam AS-CI-H1-2.5 and are smaller than for Beam AS-CI-H2-2.5, respectively.
From the results of deflection time histories, the maximum and residual
deflections for Beam AS-CI-H2.5 decreased remarkably comparing to those for
Beams AS-CI-H1-2.5 and AS-CI-H2-2.5. This suggests that in the cases of Beams
AS-CI-H1/2.5, the damage was accumulated due to consecutive loading.
Figure 6(d) shows the experimental results for Beam AS-CI-H3. Comparing the
dynamic responses between Beams AS-CI-H2.5/3, it is seen that: (1) the maximum
impact force and reaction force for Beam AS-CI-H3 were a little greater than those
for Beam AS-CI-H2.5; (2) even though the main response of reaction force for
Beam AS-CI-H2.5 had a trapezoidal shape, that for Beam AS-CI-H3 shifted to
triangular shape; and (3) dynamic response characteristics of deflection were similar
to each other except maximum and residual deflections and natural period of the
damped-free vibration after unloading.
Figure 7 shows relationships between the absolute maximum deflection and the
accumulated input impact energy Ea and between the absolute residual deflection
and the accumulated input impact energy Ea. In these figures, the painted marks
mean that the AFRP sheet debonded.
From Fig. 7(a), it is seen that the absolute maximum deflections for all
Beams AS under consecutive impact loading may be linearly distributed including
the cases of the sheet debonding, even though those for unstrengthened Beams N
were linearly distributed [8].
From the results for the absolute residual deflections shown in Fig. 7(b), it can
be observed that the residual deflections for Beams AS except the results in the
cases of sheet debonding were also linearly distributed.
872 S. Le Huy et al.
Fig. 7 Relationship between absolute maximum response values and accumulated input impact
energy Ea: a absolute maximum deflection; and b absolute residual deflection
Fig. 8 Crack patterns after consecutive impact loading: a Beam N-CI-H1; and b Beam AS-CI-H1
Figure 8 shows comparisons of the crack patterns after the tests between the beams
with/without strengthening. From this figure, following details can be observed:
(1) the flexural and diagonal cracks developed for the beams under impact loading;
(2) the flexural cracks from the upper surface toward to the bottom occurred due to
a fixed beam with short span length being formed until flexural wave reached the
support points; (3) the area near the loading point was damaged accompanying with
the compressive failure, irrespective of with/without strengthening; (4) even though
Beams N were permanently deformed near the loading point, Beams AS were less
deformed than Beams N due to strengthening effect of the AFRP sheet; and
(5) Beams AS reached the ultimate state with the AFRP sheet debonding for all
loading cases.
Experimental Study on Dynamic Behaviors … 873
4 Conclusions
(1) Maximum and residual deflections for RC beams under impact loading were
decreased effectively by flexural strengthening with FRP sheet;
(2) Absolute maximum and residual deflections of the beams strengthened with
FRP sheet were linearly distributed corresponding to an accumulated input
impact energy; and
(3) The RC beams strengthened with AFRP sheet having a density of 1660 g/m2
reached the ultimate state with the sheet debonding.
Acknowledgements This work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number JP17K06527.
AFRP sheet and adhesive were provided by Fibex, Co. Ltd. and Sumitomo Rubber Industries, Co.
Ltd., respectively.
References
1. ACI Committee 440 (2008) ACI 440.2R-08. Guide for the Design and Construction of
Externally Bonded FRP Systems for Strengthening Concrete Structures
2. Buchan PA, Chen JF (2007) Blast resistance of FRP composites and polymer strengthened
concrete and masonry structures - a state-of-the-art review. Compos B Eng 38(5–6):509–522
3. Erki MA, Meier U (2002) Impact loading of concrete beams externally strengthened with
CFRP laminates. J Compos Constr 3(3):117–124
4. Hamed E, Rabinovitch O (2005) Dynamic behavior of reinforced concrete beams
strengthened with composite materials. J Compos Constr 9(5):429–440
5. JSCE (Japan Society of Civil Engineers) (2012) Guideline for strengthening and repairing of
concrete structures using FRP sheet. Concrete Library 101, Yotsuya, Tokyo (in Japanese)
6. JSCE (Japan Society of Civil Engineers) (2007) Standard Specification for Concrete
Structures-2007 Design, Yotsuya, Tokyo, Japan
7. Kishi N, Komuro M, Kurihashi Y, Mikami H (2018) Impact test of RC beams flexurally
strengthened with CFRP material. In: Proceedings of FRPRCS-13, Anaheim, USA, 14–15
October, CD-ROM
8. Kishi N, Mikami H (2012) Empirical formulas for designing reinforced concrete beams under
impact loading. ACI Struct J 109(4):509–519
9. Komuro M, Kurihashi Y, Kawarai T, Kishi N (2018) Numerical simulation of AFRP
Rod NSM RC beams under falling-weight impact loading. Technical Publication SP-327,
ACI, pp 17.1–17.14
10. Pham TM, Hao H (2016) Impact resistance of FRP strengthened RC beams. In: Proceeding
EASEC-14, Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam, 6–8 January 2016
11. Tang T, Saadatmanesh H (2003) Behavior of concrete beams strengthened with
fiber-reinforced polymer laminates under impact loading. J Compos Constr 7(3):209–218
12. White TW, Soudki KA, Erki M-A (2001) Response of RC beams strengthened with CFRP
laminates and subjected to a high rate of loading. J Compos Constr 5(3):153–162
Mechanical Properties and Seismic
Performance Research
on Primary-Secondary Structure
for High-Rise Building
Keywords Primary-secondary structure Mechanical properties Simplified cal-
culation method Two-level distribution of internal force Periodicity and
replicability
1 Introduction
Beams
Primary
SM-IV SM-III SM-II
Beams
Secondary
Primary
Story
168m @ 42m
Braces
Mega
Secondary
Story
Columns
Secondary
Columns
Primary
SM-I
(a) (b) (c) (d)
The mega braces in PSFDB and PSFXB are connected to main structure after the
construction of main structure, and braces don’t work under vertical loads. So, we
can delete braces when analyzing structural mechanical characteristics under ver-
tical loads. Considering self-weight, dead and live load, the internal force distri-
butions of primary-secondary structure are shown in Fig. 2. The primary columns
bear the main vertical load in the form of axial forces, and the primary beams
transmit the load borne by the secondary structures to the primary columns in the
form of shear force. The axial force, bending moment, and shear force of the
primary structures are obviously higher than that of the secondary structures, and
the primary-secondary structure exhibits the characteristic of two-level distribution
of internal forces.
878 J. Teng et al.
20 Z2
Z3
10 Z4
Z5
Z6
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Axial force (×103kN)
The axial force of secondary columns is transferred to the foundation via primary
beams and primary columns. The secondary columns only bear the self-weight and
the vertical load of the structural module where it is located. The axial force of
secondary columns in different structural modules are almost equal at the same
position in each story, as shown in Fig. 3. Obviously, the axial force distribution of
secondary structures varies periodically along the height, and the secondary com-
ponents of each structural module are reproducible. The periodicity of force dis-
tribution and replicability of secondary components can realize the modularized
design, production, and assembly of the secondary components.
The axial force FN, shear force Fs and bending moment M of three models under
lateral loads is shown in Fig. 4. The internal force of primary structures is obviously
larger than that of secondary structures, and the primary-secondary structure
Mechanical Properties and Seismic Performance Research … 879
40 Push direction
30
Z1
Story
20
PSF
PSFDB
10
PSFXB
0
-1 0 1 2
FN Fs M FN Fs M FN Fs M Bending moment (×10 kN·m)
2
Fig. 4 Internal force distribution under lateral loads: a PSF model, b PSFDB model, c PSFXB
model, d Bending moment distribution with normalized roof displacement
40 Push direction
1000 1000
100
Moment (kN·m)
30 100
Force (kN)
10
Story
20 Z2
10
1 1
10 PSF
0.1 Primary columns 0.1 Primary columns
PSFDB Secondary beams Secondary beams
0 PSFXB
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 0 10 20 30 40 0 10 20 30 40
Axial force (kN) Story Story
(a) (b) (c)
Fig. 5 Internal force distribution of secondary a Axial force of secondary column; b Shear force
of secondary beam versus. Axial force of primary column, b Bending moment of secondary beam
versus. Bending moment of primary column
880 J. Teng et al.
Fig. 6 Displacement ratio distribution: a PSF model, b PSFDB model, c PSFXB model
2 A-DB
Relative stiffness
60 A-DB
A-PC 1 A-PC
40 S-PC S-PC
S-PB 1/2 S-PB
20 S-PF S-PF
1/4 A-SF
A-SF
0 S-SF 1/8 S-SF
1/16 1/8 1/4 1/2 1 2 4 8 16 1/16 1/8 1/4 1/2 1 2 4 8 16
Ratio of parameter change Ratio of parameter change
(a) Sensitivity of roof displacement (b) Sensitivity of relative value of lateral stiffness
Epc Ipc
Kv;pf ¼ 12 apf ð1Þ
L3pc
1 Di Esc Isc
Kv;sf ¼ P ¼ 12 asf ð2Þ
1=Di n L3sc
n
where apf and asf are the correction coefficients of primary frame and secondary
frame. Epc , Lpc , Ipc are the elastic modulus, the length and the inertia moments of
primary columns; Esc , Lsc , Isc are the elastic modulus, the length and the inertia
moments of secondary columns. The n is the number of structural story in each
structural module, and Lpc ¼ n Lsc . The Di is the shear stiffness provided by
secondary frame in each structural story.
The schematic diagram of shear deformation of a structural module under lateral
load is shown in Fig. 8(a). The shear stiffness provided by mega brace Kv;mb is the
horizontal component of axial force of mega brace when DH ¼ 1.
where eN;mb , Lmb , Dmb , Emb , Amb , FH;mb are the axial strain, the length, the axial
deformation, the elastic modulus, the cross-sectional area and the horizontal
882 J. Teng et al.
ΔΔHH ββ
ΔΔ
VV
LLmb
mb LLmb
mb
LLpc Lpc
L
pc pc
θ θ
LLpbpb LLpbpb
(a) Shear deformation (b) Bending deformation
DV 1 b Lpb
eN;pc ¼ ¼ ð6Þ
Lpc 2 Lpc
1 Epc Apc 2
KM ¼ Epc Apc eN;pc Lpb ¼ Lpb ð7Þ
2 Lpc
where eN;pc , Epc , Apc are axial strain, elastic modulus and cross-sectional area of
primary column. DV and b are vertical displacement of primary column top and
primary beam angle.
structural modules at the lower height, and the bending displacement inside the
structural modules. That is:
Xn
Vi Xn
Vi V1
DV;n ¼ ¼ þ ð8Þ
K
i¼1 Vi
K
i¼2 V;mid
K V;bot
X
n
Mi
hM;n ¼ hM;1 þ hM;2 þ þ hM;n ¼ ð9Þ
i¼1
KM
1 Mn
DM;n ¼ DM;ðn1Þ þ hM;ðn1Þ H þ H ð10Þ
2 KM
where KVi , KV;bot and KV;mid are the shear stiffness of i-th structural module, bottom
module and intermediate module. DV;n and DM;n are the shear and the bending
displacement of the n-th structural module. hM;i is the rotation angle at the top of the
i-th structural module. Vi and Mi are the shear moment and bending moment of the
i-th structural module.
The primary-secondary structure model has a total of N structural modules, and
H represents the height of a structural module. Assuming that the load distribution
is Vn ¼ V (n = N) in concentrated distributed load, Vn ¼ V (n = 1*N) in uni-
formly distributed load and Vn ¼ n q=N in triangularly distributed load. The
expressions of shear force Vn and bending moment Mn at n-th structural module are
shown in Table 2. Substitute shear force and bending moment into Eqs. (8)–(10),
the shear and bending displacement at n-th structural module are obtained as shown
in Table 2. The total displacement is DTotal;n ¼ DV;n þ DM;n . The results of the
simplified lateral displacement calculation method proposed in this paper agree well
with the results of finite element analysis, as shown in Fig. 9.
Bend Mn ¼ V H ðN n þ 2Þ
1
DM;n ¼ VH 2
ð6Nn2 2n3 þ 3n2 nÞ
KM 12
2 DM;n ¼ VH
KM 24
Vn ¼ Nq ðNn þ 1ÞðN þ nÞ
DV;n ¼ ð1nÞðn þ6mK
n 3Nð1 þ NÞÞq
þ ðN2KþV;bot
2
Triangularly Shear 1Þq
2 V;mid
" # " #
Bend ð1 þ N nÞ ð2 þ N nÞ 10Nð1 þ NÞð5 þ 4NÞn 10Nð1 þ NÞ
NqH 2
ð2N þ nÞ H q 20Nð1 þ NÞn2 5n3 þ 2n4 2 þ 5n
Mn ¼ 6N DM;n ¼ 240KM
884 J. Teng et al.
40 40 40
30 30 30
Story
Story
Story
20 20 20
10 10 10
FEM FEM FEM
Simplied Simplied Simplied
0 0 0
0 5 10 15 20 0 10 20 30 40 0 5 10 15 20 25
Displacement (mm) Displacement (mm) Displacement (mm)
(a) Concentrated (b) Uniformly (c) Triangularly
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements This research is supported by the National Key Research and Development
Program of China under Grant No. 2016YFC0701102, the Major Program of National Natural
Science Foundation of China under Grant No. 51538003.
Mechanical Properties and Seismic Performance Research … 885
References
1. Bao L, Wang D, Zhou J, Chen J, Tong J, Lu D (2014) Design and rethinking of mega brace in
Tianjin 117 tower. Prog Steel Build Structu 16(2):43–48
2. Fu XY (2010) Applied structural design of tall building. China Architecture & Building Press,
Beijing
3. Huang T, Ren X, Li J (2017) Incremental dynamic analysis of seismic collapse of super-tall
building structures. Struct Des Tall Spec Build 26(8):e1370
4. Liu P, Yin C, Kevin L, Liu G, Huang X, Goman H, Alexis L (2012) Structural system design
and study of Tianjin Goldin 117 mega tower. Build Struct 42(3):1–9, 19
5. Lu X, Lu X, Guan H, Xie L (2016) Application of earthquake-induced collapse analysis in
design optimization of a supertall building. Struct Des Tall Spec Build 25(17):926–946
6. Lu X, Lu X, Guan H, Zhang W, Ye L (2013) Earthquake-induced collapse simulation of a
super-tall mega-braced frame-core tube building. J Constr Steel Res 82:59–71
7. Lu X, Xie L, Yu C, Lu X (2016) Development and application of a simplified model for the
design of a super-tall mega-braced frame-core tube building. Eng Struct 110:116–126
8. Moon K, Connor JJ, Fernandez JE (2007) Diagrid structural systems for tall buildings:
characteristics and methodology for preliminary design. Struct Des Tall Spec Build 16
(2):205–230
9. Yang XQ, Fu XY, Huang YJ (2011) Dynamic elasto-plastic analysis of the Shenzhen
Ping’An Financial Center Tower. J Build Struct 32(07):40–49
10. Yu DM, Homing L, Lv WJ (2017) Structural scheme selection for Wuhan CTF Finance
Centre. Build Struct 47(S2):6–11
Evaluating and Enhancing Seismic
Performance of Water Distribution
System in Terms of Fire Suppression
G. J. Hou and Q. W. Li
Keywords Seismic performance Water distribution network Fire suppression
Hydraulic analysis
1 Introduction
G. J. Hou (&) Q. W. Li
Department of Civil Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China
e-mail: hougj17@mails.tsinghua.edu.cn
Q. W. Li
e-mail: li_quanwang@tsinghua.edu.cn
2 Methodology
Urban water distribution system is composed with several basic components such
as water works, pipelines, pumps, tanks and etc. Within the system, the nodal
elements like tanks and water works are vulnerable to wind, while the linear
Evaluating and Enhancing Seismic Performance … 889
elements like pipelines are vulnerable in seismic events because of ground shaking
and permanent ground deformation [4]. Plenty of researches have been carried out
to model the seismic fragility of buried pipeline system [6, 7, 10]. Most models are
derived from fitting available data from earthquake inspection. Among these, model
proposed by American Lifeline Alliance (ALA) has the most comprehensive data
base, thus is adopted in this paper. The repair rate (RR), which gives the numbers of
repairs for a unit length of pipe, can be obtained based on earthquake intensity
together with pipeline properties as follows [1]:
0:00241 K1 PGV for wave propagation
RR ¼ ð1Þ
2:44 K2 PGD0:319 for permanent ground deformation
where RR is the repair rate of a pipe in km−1; K1, K2 are factors related to local
geological condition and pipe properties including pipe material, joint type and pipe
diameters. which can be found in the citation; PGV is the peak ground velocity in
cm/s; PGD is the peak ground deformation in centimeters. With the RR of each
pipe, a Poisson probability distribution is implemented to assess the damage
probability:
ðRR LÞn
PðN ¼ nÞ ¼ eRRL ð2Þ
n!
where Qi;avl is the actual demand supplied to node i; Qi;req is the original demand at
node i; Hi is the actual pressure head at node i; Hs is the service pressure head
required to satisfy all nodal demand and Hm is the minimum working pressure head.
In this work, the pressure-driven analysis is performed using MATLAB together
with EPANET Toolkit [11]. The available fire flow at each node can be determined
as flow through an emitter, suggested by the EPANET user’s manual [11].
We use the System Fire-suppression Index (SFI), the percentage of building
floor area where the fire demand can be satisfied, as the functionality index to
measure the fire suppression capability of the WDS:
P
n
Ai Ii
i¼1
SFI ¼ ð5Þ
Pn
Ai
i¼1
where Ai is the total building floor area of buildings within the service area of
demand node i in the WDS; Ii is an indicator whose value is 1 if the available fire
flow from node i meets the requirement, otherwise is 0.
where E(SFI) is the expectation of original functionality level; E(SFI | upgrade pipe
j) is the functionality level after pipe j is upgraded; costj is the cost of upgrading
pipe j in a certain monetary unit. The upgrade of any pipe in the WDS should have a
positive influence on the overall performance, thus the REIj should be larger than 0.
The relative value of REIj shows improvement significance of unit retrofit cost.
Therefore, pipe with a higher REI has a relatively higher priority of upgrading.
We illustrate the proposed method in a real WDS of a Chinese city. The city is
situated at the east end of the Himalaya seismic belt, and has a seismic fortification
intensity of VIII. The main water distribution network of the city includes 1 source
node and 18 demand nodes, connected by buried cast iron pipelines with a total
length of around 7.6 km. The topological configuration is shown in Fig. 1. Only the
ground shaking induced pipe failure is considered because the probability of the
liquefaction of the city is neglectable. Based on Chinese fire codes and local
fire-fighting experience, a required fire flow is set to be 31.5L/s (500 gallon per
minute) at a residual pressure of 138 kPa (20 psi).
In this study, we evaluate the seismic performance of the WDS under earth-
quakes with MMI = VII and VIII respectively. For each earthquake intensity, a
unique value of PGV is assumed because the area of WDS is relatively small
compared with the range of action of an earthquake. The empirical expression
relating MMI to PGV proposed by Wald et al. [16] is applied to estimate the PGV:
which is valid if the MMI is within the range of V to IX [16]. The estimated mean
value of PGV is 21.88 cm/s for MMI = VII earthquakes and is 42.49 cm/s for
MMI = VIII ones.
For each earthquake intensity, a Monte Carlo simulation with 10,000 simulation
runs is conducted considering the randomness of pipe failures. In each simulation
run, the pipe failure scenario is generated firstly based on the failure probability of
each pipe, and the hydraulic model is modified accordingly. Then, a pressure-driven
hydraulic analysis is conducted to obtain the available fire flow on each node.
Detailed evaluation results are shown in the following parts.
Fig. 2 Cumulative probability of SFI after earthquake with MMI = VII and VIII
node, it has a relatively higher failure probability because of the greater spatial
distance between node 5 and the source node. Meanwhile, node 4 is the most
dangerous node because it is located the farthest from the source node. This indi-
cates that nodes closer to the source node topologically and geometrically tend to
have better performance. Besides, node 2 is farther from the source node compared
with node 1, but has a lower probability of insufficient fire flow, because node 2 has
a higher degree according to graph theory. This is also true for node 8 and node 18,
which indicates that the nodes with higher degree tend to have better performance.
In order to calculate the REI for each pipe, several assumptions are made in this
work. First, we consider upgrading a pipe by replacing the original cast iron pipe by
a welded steel pipe, which could reduce the repair rate of the pipe by 70% based on
Eq. (1). Also, the upgrading cost of each pipe is assumed proportional to the pipe
length. This assumption is reasonable because cost of pipeline itself is much higher
than other costs in pipeline upgrading, including hiring workers, rental of equip-
ment and etc. Besides, the unit cost is the same for all pipes because pipelines in the
illustrated WDS have the same diameter.
Based on above assumptions, the REIs for all pipes can be calculated based on
simulation results. The top eight pipes of the optimal retrofit sequences against
earthquake with MMI = VII and VIII are shown in Table 1. Except for the first
several pipes of the sequence, the rest pipes have REIs with relatively slight dif-
ference, thus are not shown here. From the table we can see that the top five choices
are the same, indicating that optimal retrofit strategy against earthquakes with
different intensities can be similar. Besides, critical pipes tend to be close to the
source node, which is consistent with operating experience. For example, pipe 11,
19, 22 are connected directly to the source node, and all of them have high
Evaluating and Enhancing Seismic Performance … 895
upgrading priorities. But pipe 26 appears to be more prior to pipes closer to the
source node, such as pipe 23, 25, 16, which is conflictive to the experience. Thus,
topological model cannot truly reflect the real behavior of the WDS because
physical-based principles of pipeline network hydraulics are not considered. The
flow-based analysis, on the other hand, is able to give more realistic results.
4 Conclusions
References
1. American Lifeline Alliance (ALA) (2001) Seismic fragility formulations for water systems:
Guidelines. American Lifelines Alliance and Federal Emergency Management Agency
(FEMA), ASCE, Reston, VA
2. American Water Works Association (AWWA) (1998) Distribution system requirements for
fire protection. American Water Works Association, Denver
3. American Water Works Association (AWWA) (2012) Buried no longer: confronting
America’s water infrastructure challenge. American Water Works Association, Denver
896 G. J. Hou and Q. W. Li
Keywords Steel chimney Suspended tuned mass damper (STMD) Wind
vibration control Fluctuating wind simulation
1 Introduction
Tuned Mass Damper (TMD) consists of mass, spring and viscous damper. It is
installed to reduce the vibration response on the top of high-rise structure, or the
middle of a long span structure (Lu et al. 2017) [2]. After adjusting the frequency of
TMD to be identical with that of the main structure, the TMD will produces a force
with opposite direction when the vibration of structure is excited by external forces
(wind, earthquake, human load, etc.). Then the vibration energy of the main
structure will be partially dissipated by TMD.
Livesey and Søndergaard (1996) tested the torsional vibration of a bridge
installed with a TMD via wind tunnel experiments. The results show that the
torsional vibration reduced to 10% off the uncontrolled structure. They also pro-
posed an optimization design of TMD. Wirsching and Shehata [1] inferred that
wind-induced response of first mode of the high-rise structure accounts for more
than 80% of the total. Xu et al. [2] conducted a study of TMD parameters directly
using the wind spectrum obtained from the wind tunnel test, and proposed a
semi-analytical method for calculating the wind-induced vibration response. It is
proved that the results of semi-analytical method coincide with wind tunnel test.
Wang [3] introduced the basic theory of wind vibration control of TMD, and the
design process of Jiading TV tower. Ou and Wang [4] proposed the analysis and
design method of TMD/TLD for high-rise buildings under wind load. Ricciardelli
[5] introduced a linear model which can be applied to the analysis of wind vibration
control of TMD. The model was suitable for the vibration control of along-wind
and cross-wind of high-rise buildings, as well as for multiple modes and multiple
TMDs. Li [6] proposed an optimized design method of TMD for high-rise buildings
under wind load.
The chimney is always a high-rise structure. Suspended TMD (STMD) has been
proved to be an effective vibration control device, which can effectively reduce the
dynamic response of high-rise structures caused by wind and ensure it meets the
requirements of deformation and comfort. The frequency of STMD will be coin-
cident with that of the chimney by adjusting the pendulum length. The relationship
between pendulum length and period of STMD are as follows:
rffiffiffi
1 1 g
fd ¼ ¼ ð1Þ
Td 2p l
A steel boiler chimney located in the seaside city is 55 m high, and has a circular
cross-section, while the outer diameter is 5640 mm. The wall of the chimney
gradually becomes thinner as the height increases. The thickness of the bottom is
20 mm, and that of the top is 10 mm. Steel of the chimney is A36 (from ASTM
Research on Suspended Tuned Mass Damper … 899
In Eq. (3), Kz is the Height variation coefficient, Kzt is the topographic coeffi-
cient (take as 1), Kd is the wind direction coefficient, its value can be found in [7].
The wind load on the chimney is:
F ¼ qz;t G Cf Af ð4Þ
In Eq. (4), G is gust factor, Cf is wind shape coefficient (its value can also be
chose from ASCE7-10), Af is projection area perpendicular to the wind direction.
The gust factor takes into account the fact that the instantaneous wind is larger than
the time-average wind. G takes as 1, since the dynamic effect of the fluctuating
wind load has been considered.
The time-average wind is in accordance with the height variation of wind speed.
Exponential function expression:
vðzÞ z /
¼ ð5Þ
v10 10
v10 indicates the wind speed observed by an anemoneter at the standard height
(10 m). / is the roughness index of open floor, take as 0.15 [8].
900 X. W. Li et al.
In Eq. (6), SðnÞ is the power spectrum of fluctuating wind speed (m2 =s), K is
ground roughness factor [9], n is the wind frequency (Hz).
The simulation of along-wind applied with linear white noise AR model has
been proved universal and practical. The accuracy and stability of the model have
been confirmed as well. The simulation process of speed-time history function
vðz; tÞ of fluctuating along-wind with AR method is shown in Fig. 1 [10].
The 55-meter-high chimney is divided into seven wind segment from the bottom
to up. And each point of the same segment is assumed to suffer the same fluctuating
wind load. Segment diagram and related parameters is shown in Fig. 2. The
speed-time history of along-wind is simulated by AR model, considering the spatial
correlation between each point. The basic parameters of the simulation are shown in
Table 1.
Figures 3 and 4 respectively shows the speed-time history diagram of fluctuating
wind and the comparison chart of power spectral density function with the target
spectrum (Davenport target spectrum) of point 1 and point 7. As can be seen form
the figures, the speed-time history change over time in a random variation, but
graphics of power spectral density function and target power spectrum are identical.
For point 1 (7 m), the time-average wind speed is 37 m/s. And for point 7
(48.24 m), the time-average wind speed is 56.5 m/s. The results are consistent with
the exponential function expression of time-average wind along the height variation
(Eq. (5)). Consequently, the simulation of fluctuating wind by AR method is proved
suitable.
902 X. W. Li et al.
(a) wind load power spectrum of point 1 (b) wind load power spectrum of point 7
Two rows of vortexes alternately shed and rotate in opposite directions when the
airflow bypasses the building and rejoins after it. It will generate force on the
structure in the crosswind direction if the vortex shed asymmetrically, that is,
vortex-induced vibration.
As for the circular cross section structure, Reynolds number can be divided into
three critical ranges according to the relationship between the resistance coefficient
and Reynolds number (Niu 2004, Tang 2009). They are sub-critical range
(300 < Re < 3 105 ), supercritical range (3 105 \Re\3:5 106 ) and transcrit-
ical range (Re > 3:5 106 Þ. Structures in the sub-critical range just suffer the breeze
Research on Suspended Tuned Mass Damper … 903
1
pL ðz; tÞ ¼ qU2 ðzÞBðzÞlL sinxv t ð7Þ
2
To achieve the best control effect, STMD will be mounted outside the chimney wall
at a height of 54.174–53.905 m (nearly top). Once the location of STMD has been
determined, parameters of STMD, such as mass, frequency and damping, should be
adjusted to ensure the STMD system absorb more vibration energy and then reduce
the response of main structure. The mass block of STMD is a steel ring plate along
the chimney’s outside wall. There are 8 suspension points via which the mass block
is suspended to the stiffening ribs of the chimney. Viscous dampers installed
between the mass block and the external wall of chimney belong to a same hori-
zontal plane. All of the parameters of STMD are listed in Table 3, and diagram of
STMD is shown in Fig. 6.
Comparison of structures with and without STMD on modal is shown in
Table 4. The period of structure with STMD is slightly larger than that of structure
without STMD. Moreover, the first four modes of structure with STMD are mainly
based on the vibration of the mass ring of STMD.
As can be seen from Tables 5 and 6:
The displacement of each point of the structure with STMD in two load cases is
smaller than that of structure without STMD, except the results of point 1, 2, 3, 4 in
load case 1. But the increase in displacement is not significant. Moreover, the
displacement distribution of the structure with STMD along the whole height is
more uniform than the structure without STMD, which is beneficial for the main
Research on Suspended Tuned Mass Damper … 905
(a) Photo of STMD in factory (b) elevation of the chimney with STMD (c) plan of the
chimney with STMD
Table 4 Comparison of structures with and without STMD on period and frequency
Mode Structure without STMD Structure with STMD
Period Frequency Mainly Period Frequency Mainly
(s) (Hz) direction of (s) (Hz) direction of
the mode the mode
1 1.04 0.96 Dy, Rx, Rz 1.10 0.90 Dy, Rx, Rz
2 0.92 1.07 Dy, Rx, Rz 1.08 0.92 Dx, Ry
3 0.86 1.15 Dx, Ry 0.98 1.01 Dy, Rx, Rz
4 0.63 1.58 Dy, Rx, Rz 0.78 1.27 Dy, Rx, Rz
5 0.56 1.76 Dx, Ry 0.70 1.41 Dy, Rx, Rz
structure. In general, the displacement at the top of the chimney can be reduced to
40% off the original, and the decrease amplitude from the top to the bottom is
40–10%. The displacement of the top is no more than H/500 = 55 cm, meeting the
requirements of codes.
906 X. W. Li et al.
Table 5 Comparison of structures with and without STMD on velocity and acceleration (load
case 1)
Point Height Structure without STMD Structure with STMD
(m) Displacement Acceleration Displacement Acceleration
(cm) (cm/s2) (cm) (cm/s2)
Top 54.17 35.6 42.15 15.0 16.32
7 48.18 28.6 25.57 17.8 22.40
6 41.21 21.8 17.84 16.7 24.48
5 33.79 14.9 13.08 14.1 23.71
4 27.27 10.0 10.69 10.8 18.69
3 22.73 7.3 9.94 8.3 15.04
2 14.62 3.3 6.11 4.1 7.81
1 6.96 0.8 1.86 1.1 2.19
*Note: displacement and acceleration of load case 1 are all in X-direction
Table 6 Comparison of structures with and without STMD on velocity and acceleration (load
case 2)
Point Height Structure without STMD Structure with STMD
(m) Displacement Acceleration Displacement Acceleration
(cm) (cm/s2) (cm) (cm/s2)
Top 54.17 22.9/5.6 25.34/0.84 8.8/1.1 9.67/0.74
7 48.18 21.4/5.1 16.93/0.78 12.4/0.9 13.37/0.57
6 41.21 18.3/4.1 12.24/0.61 10.0/0.6 14.57/0.37
5 33.79 13.4/3.0 8.92/0.51 8.4/0.4 14.05/0.28
4 27.27 9.3/2.1 7.54/0.31 6.5/0.2 11.11/0.20
3 22.73 6.7/1.5 6.75/0.22 5.0/0.2 8.94/0.15
2 14.62 3.0/0.7 3.99/0.09 2.5/0.01 4.65/0.03
1 6.96 0.7/0.2 1.19/0.02 0.7/0.0002 1.30/0.01
*Note: displacement and acceleration of load case 2 are all in X-direction/Y-direction
Fig. 7 Vibration data of the chimney with and without STMD measured on site
should be no more than 22 cm/s2 to ensure the comfort of the staffs on the chimney
[32]. The acceleration of the chimney installed with STMD is reduced form 25.3 to
14.5 cm/s2 , and its amplitude meets the comfort requirements.
The vibration data measured on site of the chimney with and without STMD is
shown in Fig. 7. Figure 7(a) is the measured acceleration -time curve at the top of
the chimney, and the data length is intercepted to 60 s. Figure 7(b) is the frequency
identification curve via applying Fourier transform and removing interference fre-
quency. The frequency of the chimney is 0.87. The pendulum length of STMD
should be adjusted to coordinate its own frequency with the real frequency of
chimney. The maximum acceleration of the chimney without STMD is 13.56 cm/s2
(at top point) during the measured time period, and the acceleration of the chimney
with STMD is 7.93 cm/s2 . The rate of vibration attenuation is 41.5%, achieved the
damping target.
4 Conclusions
The displacement and acceleration at the top of the chimney can be attenuated once
installed the STMD, according to the damper design and wind induced vibration
analysis. The reduction amplitude can reach 40–60%. In this paper, a STMD with a
ring mass is hung on the top of the chimney. Its swing frequency can be adjusted by
changing the pendulum length to coordinate with the natural frequency of the
chimney. The STMD achieves vibration control in multi-degree of freedom, and
consequently realize multi-direction wind control.
Owing to the difference between the model and actual structure in dynamic
characteristics, such as mode and frequency, the adjustable measures in pendulum
length must be taken into consideration. The frequency adjustable range should be
above ±15%. The natural frequency of the main structure must be determined after
the on-site dynamic test. Then the pendulum length of STMD should be adjusted
according to the natural frequency to maximize the damping effect.
908 X. W. Li et al.
References
1. Wirsching PH, Shehata AM (1977) Fatigue under wide band random stresses using the
rain-flow method. J Eng Mater Technol 99(3):205–211
2. Xu YL, Kwok KCS, Samali B (1992) Control of wind-induced tall building vibration by
tuned mass dampers. J Wind Eng Ind Aerodyn 40(1):1–32
3. Wang Z (1994) Study and design of TMD wind vibration control of TV tower structures.
J Build Struct 5
4. Ou J, Wang Y (1995) Wind induced vibration analyses and design methods of tall buildings
with tuned mass dampers or tuned liquid dampers. In: Chinese science abstracts series B, vol
5, no 14, p 56
5. Ricciardelli F (1999) A linear model for structures with tuned mass dampers. Wind Struct 2
(3):151–171
6. Li C (2001) Optimum design of TMD for suppressing vibration of tall buildings subjected to
wind. Jsuan Lixue Xuebao (Chinese J Comput Mech) (China) 18(1):69–73
7. ASCE (2010) Minimum design loads for buildings and other structures. ASCE 7, Reston, VA
8. GB 50009‐2012 (2012) Load code for the design of building structures
9. Raupach MR, Gillette DA, Leys JF (1993) The effect of roughness elements on wind erosion
threshold. J Geophys Res Atmos 98(D2):3023–3029
10. Davenport AG (1961) The application of statistical concepts to the wind loading of structures.
Proc Inst Civ Eng 19(4):449–472
11. Chunliang N (2004) The calculation of chimney across-wind sympathetic vibration. Special
Struct 3
12. Yajun TQZST (2009) Analysis of wind vibration of a 60 m high steel chimney for a factory in
Tianjin. Steel Constr 2
13. Milford RV (1982) Structural reliability and crosswind response of tall chimneys. Eng Struct
4(4):263–270
14. Damgaard M, Ibsen LB, Andersen LV, Andersen JK (2013) Cross-wind modal properties of
offshore wind turbines identified by full scale testing. J Wind Eng Ind Aerodyn 116:94–108
15. Huang G, Chen X (2007) Wind load effects and equivalent static wind loads of tall buildings
based on synchronous pressure measurements. Eng Struct 29(10):2641–2653
16. Zhou Y, Kareem A, Gu M (2000) Equivalent static buffeting loads on structures. J Struct Eng
126(8):989–992
Viscous Dampers Based Standardized
Design of Modular Steel Structures
in Different Seismic Zones
B. J. Du and X. Zhao
Keywords Modular structure Seismic design Viscous damper Optimal design
B. J. Du X. Zhao (&)
Tongji University, No. 1239 Siping Road, Shanghai 200092, China
B. J. Du
e-mail: 1832617@tongji.edu.cn
X. Zhao
Tongji Architectural Design Group, No. 1230 Siping Road, Shanghai 200092, China
e-mail:22zx@tjad.cn
1 Introduction
The two basic modules of the modular steel structure are shown in Fig. 1. The
length of the module is 6 m, the width is 3.5 m (ultra-wide)/3 m/2.4 m (sea
transportation), the height is 3.2 m (suitable for central air conditioning)/3 m
(suitable for common air conditioning), and the distance from the middle column to
the side column is 1.5 m. Standard module A is the basic module with no brace,
open space and flexible layout. Standard module B adds middle columns and braces
on the basis of standard module A, which is suitable for the case that the long side
stiffness of the structure is insufficient but has certain influence on the building
space, module A and module B can be arranged flexibly according to the overall
model stiffness. Modular steel structure members include floor beam, roof beam,
side column, middle column and brace, all components are standardized compo-
nents. The same kind of components in a structure should have the same peripheral
size, and the thickness of components should decrease along the vertical height of
the structure.
The target additional damping ratio of the structure needs to be calculated first for
the seismic design of structure by installing viscous dampers. The response spec-
trum analysis of the initial structure is carried out, and the story drifts in X and Y
directions are calculated. If the requirements of the code are met, the target
additional damping ratio is 0%, the structure does not need to be installed by VD. If
it does not, the additional damping ratio is increased by 1% in the unsatisfied
direction and carry out the response spectrum analysis again, this cycle continues
until the story-drifts limit is met, and the target additional damping ratios in X and
Y directions are obtained, which can be used in the subsequent VD design.
3.2 VD Design
Although VD can dissipate energy under small deformation, the efficiency is very
low using the traditional diagonal connection and herringbone connection, so it
usually requires motion amplification device [4]. In this paper, the toggle brace
motion amplification device [2] is selected, and its main geometric parameters are
shown in Fig. 2, which mainly includes the length of two supporting rods and VD
rods L1, L2, L3, and three angles h1, h2, h3.
The deformation amplification coefficient of reverse toggle brace type viscous
device is:
sin h2 cosðh3 h1 Þ
f ¼ þ sin h1 ð1Þ
cosðh1 þ h2 Þ
f ð h1 Þ 3 ð8Þ
Start
Yes
End
Based on the above methods, the overall design process of the viscous dampers
based standardized design of modular steel structures in different seismic zones is as
follows: first, the strength design of the initial structure is carried out, and if the
strength of the member is insufficient, the cross section of the member is increased
until satisfied. Then the stiffness of the structure is judged, if the story drift has met
the code requirement, then the structure does not need to install VD, design ends. If
the story drift does not meet the code requirement, the target additional damping
ratio is calculated by response spectrum analysis and applied to the subsequent VD
design to get the optimal install scheme of VD satisfying the code requirement,
design ends. The specific process is shown in Fig. 4. The method proposed in this
paper is compiled by programming software (C#), the rapid design of modular steel
structure in different seismic zones can be realized and the engineering efficiency
can be greatly improved.
Viscous Dampers Based Standardized Design … 915
Start
Yes
VD design
End
Fig. 4 Overall process of viscous dampers based standardized design of modular steel structures
in different seismic zones
4 Case Study
A ten-story modular steel structure is shown in Fig. 5(a). The size of the module is
length 6 m, width 3.5 m and height 3 m. The plane layout is 3 modules connected
by long side, in which the middle module is provided with middle columns and
braces, the net horizontal spacing of the columns between the modules is 10 mm,
and the net vertical spacing of the beams between the modules is 20 mm. The total
height of the structure is 30.18 m. The structure is divided into three zones, 1F to
4F for the first zone, 5F to 7F for the second zone, and 8F to 10F for the third zone.
The dimensions of structural members for each zone are shown in Table 1.
This structure is designed in the 7-degree area (0.10 g) and is now planned to be
built in the 7-degree (0.15 g). The design characteristic period of ground motion is
0.40 s, and the natural damping ratio of the structure under the action of small
earthquakes is 3%. The results of structural analysis are shown in Table 2. It can be
seen that the structural members meet the strength requirements before and after the
site change, and the Y-direction story drift of the structure meets the code limit
916 B. J. Du and X. Zhao
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
a(m/s )
2
0
-0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.5
-0.6
0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40
T(s)
(a) Structure diagram (b) VD selectable position (c) Earthquake time-history wave
1/250, but the X-direction story drift exceeds the limit, so the VD design of the
structure should be carried out in the X direction.
The selectable position of the structure VD is located in the middle span of the
structure, as shown in Fig. 5(b), each storey has one selectable position. Through the
calculation of the response spectrum method, the X-direction story drift can meet the
code limit when the additional damping ratio of the X-direction structure is 2%,
Then, with 2% as the target additional damping ratio, using the small earthquake
time wave as shown in Fig. 5(c), the VD design of the structure is carried out.
Viscous Dampers Based Standardized Design … 917
Fig. 6 VD energy 12
dissipation of each group
Energy Dissipation(Nm)
9
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Group Number
The structure consists grids of one dimension: 3.5 m wide and 3 m high. The
geometric parameters of the grid are designed, and the results are shown in Table 3.
The deformation amplification coefficients of the grid is close to 3.0.
The virtual VD model is used to analyze the priority install sequence of VD.
The VD energy dissipation of each group is shown in Fig. 6. Taking the VD energy
dissipation as the index to judge, the priority VD install sequence of X-direction can
be obtained as shown in Table 4.
The initial damping coefficient of VD is 10000 N/(m) ^ 0.3 and the damping
index is 0.3. After three iterations, it can be obtained that when two sets of VD are
placed in the X direction on floor 5 and 3, the additional damping ratio in the X
direction of the structure reaches 1.98%. The VD install scheme for each iteration
918 B. J. Du and X. Zhao
21 21
Hight/m
Hight/m
14 14
7 7
0 0
0 1 2 3 4 5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
-3 5
Story drift x 10 Story shear force/N x 10
5 Conclusion
References
Keywords Seismic risk evaluation Probable Maximum Loss Base-isolated
buildings Disaster prevention Life cycle cost
A. Satoshi (&)
Department of Architecture, Graduate School of Engineering, Tokyo University of Science,
Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: 4118503@ed.tus.ac.jp
K. Yuna
First-Corporation Inc, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: katori@1st-corp.com
K. Yasuko
TAKAHASHI Osamu Laboratory, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Engineering,
Tokyo University of Science, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: y.kaito@rs.tus.ac.jp
T. Osamu
Department of Architecture, Faculty of Engineering, Doctor of Engineering,
Tokyo University of Science, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: o.taka@rs.tus.ac.jp
1 Introduction
The building design method should be corrected each time a major earthquake
occurs that causes human and material damage. However, since these are designed
not to be destroyed and not to cause damage, buildings damaged by the earthquake
must be repaired, reinforced and used or rebuilt. Therefore, it is important to know
in advance how much damage a building will be caused by an earthquake.
PML (Probable Maximum Loss) is often used in seismic risk assessment of
buildings, but the definition of PML has not been clarified. Also, for seismic
hazards used in PML evaluation, a probabilistic seismic motion prediction map is
released that summarizes the relationship information of strength, duration, and
probability of seismic motion at the J-SHIS Seismic Hazard Station by
Headquarters for Earthquake Research Promotion. Although the hazard curve at the
point of can be evaluated, the results differ because the evaluation intervals differ in
the interval of earthquake activity and the setting of the index of seismic intensity.
Therefore, in this paper, we study seismic risk in various parts of Japan based on
dynamic response analysis and aim to establish an appropriate evaluation method.
Seismic hazard assessment assesses the risk of a site being subjected to large
ground motions, considering all earthquakes that affect the site. Earthquakes
assumed in the Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Maps are roughly classified into three
categories shown in Table 1. In this study, as shown in Table 1, ten points with
largely different categories are considered. At each site, the site amplification factor
was selected at 1.4 ± 0.1.
Seismic hazard is an assessment of the risk of a site being subjected to large ground
motions, considering all earthquakes that affect the site. Headquarters for
Earthquake Research Promotion publishes two types of hazards, taking the average
activity interval and the latest activity time of earthquakes from major active fault
zones as the average case and the maximum case. Moreover, the variation between
the maximum case and the average case is small at a point where the degree of
influence of the earthquake category I is large, and the variation tends to be large at
a point where the degree of influence of the earthquake category III is large.
To calculate the loss curve, the integrated structure calculation software “Super
Build/SS3” (UNION SYSTEM Inc) is used to calculate the maximum velocity
exceeding the interlayer deformation angle of the damage form defined as shown in
Table 2. The average damage cost ratio for each damage level is 10, 20, and 100%
for small, medium and large damage, regardless of the building size, and the loss
curve is calculated. The cost for rebuilding is used as the replacement price, and the
risk curve is calculated from the hazard curve and the loss curve.
The reinforced concrete 5F, 10F, 15F and 30F earthquake-resistant buildings to be
examined in this study are modeled using the “Super Build/SS3” as shown in
Fig. 2. PML is a ratio of loss magnitude to replacement price and is 0.0 for no
damage and 1.0 for total loss.
In the 15th floor building with Category III earthquakes, both 5% and 2% PMLs
were found to be quite large compared to PMLs with 50 years excess probability
10%. Especially in Fukuoka City, the probability of excess is generally defined as
PML and the loss rate increases at 10% or less, so the probability of occurrence of
an earthquake is small, but if it occurs, the possibility of a large earthquake motion
becomes high. Therefore, to consider PML, you need to consider the excess
probability depending on the use.
In order to make a mutual comparison with the seismic risk for aseismatic build-
ings, the buildings examined in Sect. 3 were designed as seismic isolation build-
ings, and the seismic risk evaluation was performed.
The results of PML when the 10F and 15F.30F buildings are isolated are shown in
Table 4. Since the average case and the maximum case are as close to 0.00 as
possible at any point with an excess probability of 10%, it can be said that the
amount of reduction of the expected maximum loss due to seismic isolation is close
to the amount of loss when earthquake resistance is used in both cases. Since there
is a gap in PML values depending on whether the average case or the maximum
case is used in earthquake-resistant buildings at the point of earthquake category III,
a difference appears when comparing the effects of seismic isolation.
The results of PML at excess probability 10%, 5% and 2% are shown in Table 5.
As for the earthquake category I point, the PML of the seismic building is large at
30F with an excess probability of 10%, so the effect of seismic isolation is large in
the examination with an excess probability of 10%. On the other hand, at the 30F
earthquake category III point, the excess probability is 10%, PML is 0.01 in the
average case and 0.02 in the maximum case. Therefore, if it is the general definition
of PML, there is no effect of seismic isolation.
Regarding the life cycle cost considering the seismic risk during the operation
period, evaluate the seismic risk reduction effect by seismic isolation. The life-cycle
cost of the earthquake-resistant building and the base-isolated building in this
research is the sum of the initial cost and the expected value of the loss that may be
incurred in 50 years. In addition, the life-cycle costs of seismically isolated
buildings are assessed not only for initial costs but also for later inspection costs. It
is assumed that it will be implemented for 500,000 yen once at the completion,
5 years, 10 years and every 10 years thereafter. The inspection cost of the seismic
isolation system is based on the standards of The Japan Society of Seismic Isolation
(JSSI). The number of years for cost-effectiveness is shown in Table 6.
Although there are differences depending on the building, sites with earthquake
categories I and II with 10% probability of excess will be cost effective in about
20 years. However, many earthquake category III sites cannot be acquired within
60 years when replacement of seismic isolation devices is required. However, if the
seismic isolation is the most effective 2% over chance, then even earthquake cat-
egory III points will be cost effective within 60 years.
Table 7 show the years of cost-effectiveness when it is estimated that the
replacement cost of the seismic isolation system will be three times the equipment
cost. If the loss is more than 10%, it will be cost effective only in earthquake
category I within 60 years, but if it is more than 2%, earthquake categories II and III
are also available.
Table 5 PML evaluation results with excess probability as a variable (average case_30F)
Nakano
Hamamatsu Kochi Nagoya Mito Sendai Osaka Kanazawa Fukuoka Sapporo
(Tokyo)
PML_10% 0.17 0.15 0.09 0.10 0.08 0.04 0.06 0.01 0.01 0.00
Earthquake resistance PML_5% 0.19 0.16 0.11 0.12 0.10 0.06 0.08 0.05 0.03 0.01
PML_2% 0.21 0.18 0.13 0.14 0.12 0.09 0.13 0.09 0.10 0.02
PML_10% 0.07 0.03 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Seismic isolation PML_5% 0.12 0.06 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
PML_2% 0.20 0.12 0.01 0.03 0.01 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00
928 A. Satoshi et al.
5 Conclusion
In this study, PML was examined in the 5th, 10th, 15th and 30th floor buildings. In
the case of 15F and 30F, compared with 5F and 10F, the magnitude of the reduction
effect of the isolation amount was clear. In the average case where the excess
probability is 10%, the cost-effectiveness of the seismic isolation of a seismic
isolation building with a PML of 0.20 can be obtained with a service life of
approximately 15 years. In addition, it is necessary to clarify which information
should be used when making an evaluation, as the difference between the earth-
quake category III points tends to be remarkable when the earthquake hazard is
maximum and average. By performing the assessment in the average case with a
probability of more than 2%, you get results that reduce the error between the
average case and the largest case when compared to locations across the country.
This is effective as a presentation of the risk reduction effect by seismic isolation
when compared with earthquake resistance, and it is suitable as a new index of
PML if it is predicted that seismic isolation of buildings in the world will further
progress in the future.
Economical Evaluation of Comprehensive Seismic Risk … 929
References
1. Architectural Institute of Japan (2011) Seismic risk evaluation and risk communication
2. National Research Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Resilience (2018) J-SHIS
Earthquake Hazard Station Nationwide Ground Motion Prediction Map 2018 Edition. http://
www.j-shis.bosai.go.jp/map/
3. Hayashi Y, Suzuki Y, Miyakoshi J, Watanabe M (2000) Seismic Risk Evaluation of
Existing RC Buildings Based on Seismic Performance Indices
4. Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism (2018) Land Price Announcement
2018 Edition. http://www.mlit.go.jp/totikensangyo/H30kouji_index.html
Developed Research to Carry Out
Prediction Damage from Measuring
Microtremor
1 Introduction
Buildings that encounter earthquakes may look healthy at first glance, but may be
damaged by the earthquake. During aftershocks, a secondary disaster is caused by
the fall of building materials from buildings that are underway and the collapse of
the building itself. In order to prevent the occurrence of secondary disasters, it is
necessary to determine the immediate availability of the building by investigating
the damage situation of the building in a relatively short period of time from the
occurrence of the earthquake. It is “Temporary Risk Evaluation” that the country
and the municipality are doing to play the role.
The Temporary Risk Evaluation is that a qualified technician investigates the
damage situation of a building after an earthquake and makes a judgment at three
stages: “Surveyed Green”, “Attention Yellow”, and “Dangerous Red”, and a
judgment indicator based on the decision is posted on the building.
However, the system or understaffed, because the investigators determine the
decision only by their own visual, there is a problem, such as variations in the
results occur.
Ground YES
Ground analysis
survey results Earthquake
response
analysis NO
Predic on of ground-
NO Set unique cycle
specific cycle sa ated YES Building earthquake
by ground type
during earthquakes response forecast
value
Building constant YES
FFT
tremor Building
Conversion
measurement earthquake
response analysis
Set unique cycle supine by
NO structure type and
number of floors
Resonant
rela onship curve
output
Ground -
Building risk END
assessment
Fig. 1 Flowchart
Developed Research to Carry Out Prediction Damage … 933
Fig. 3 Microtremor
measurement point
2 Measuring Microtremor
First, stable waveform data of 20.48 s was cut out into 10 sections from the data
obtained from the microtremor measuring microtremor at all times. Fourier spectra
were then obtained for each of the X, Y, and Z directions for 10 sections by Fourier
transformation, and at that time noise of 10 Hz or more was cut off with a low pass
filter. From the Fourier spectrum in three directions, the H/V spectral is calculated
in order to remove the Rayleigh wave. Then, the average of the H/V spectrum ratios
for the 10 sections is averaged, and the period at the peak of the average H/V
spectrum ratio in the period of 0.1 to 1.4 s is taken. Let the period be the dominant
period of the ground constantly obtained from microtremor measurements.
Laptop
Conversion unit
Vibra on meter
After extracting waveform data similarly to the ground, Fourier transform was
carried out to obtain a Fourier spectrum. Then, the transfer function was calculated
by dividing the Fourier spectrum in the X and Y directions measured in the building
by the Fourier spectrum in the same direction of the ground. The peak period of the
transfer function was taken as the natural period of the building. For buildings that
were able to constantly measure microtremors on both the first and second floors,
the transfer function when the Fourier spectrum on the second floor was divided by
the Fourier spectrum in the same direction on the first floor was also calculated and
evaluated did.
Also, if it is not possible to perform the measuring microtremor of the building,
the substantial value estimated based on the shape of the building is set as the
natural period of the building.
3 Various Analyses
The ground causes nonlinear behavior when a constant distortion is applied, but the
period of excellence obtained by the measuring microtremor is in a state where there
is no distortion, so it is necessary to consider the nonlinearity separately from it.
Therefore, from the boring columnar diagram in the vicinity of the measuring
microtremor point, to perform the analysis using ShakePRO-L (Union System Co.,
Ltd.). Incident wave and the notification number of phase level 2, using both as a
level 1 which the magnification of the seismic wave was 1/5 times.
In addition, if the boring columnar diagram as in this Taiwan measurement can
not be obtained is set by a value based on the ground type determined by the
Building Standards Law.
Interlayer
deforma on angle
1/120 1/60 1/30
The target building is a detached house of the steel frame of the floor built in
Kanamachi, Katsushika-ku, Tokyo. The plane is a short side direction 3 span long
side direction 3 span in the plane dimension ratio is 1:1.2. Reinforced concrete
continuous cloth foundation for the foundation, square steel pipe for pillars, H-type
steel pipe for beams, ALC is used for floors, exterior walls, roofs.
Create an analysis model of a building from a drawing and perform a load incre-
mental analysis. The analysis was made using the structural integrated calculation
software SS7 (Union System Co., Ltd.). Based on the load-displacement relation-
ship graph of each floor determined by the load incremental analysis, it approxi-
mates by bilinear, and the resiliency characteristics required for earthquake
response analysis are modeled.
Developed Research to Carry Out Prediction Damage … 937
Load[kN]
Load[kN]
600 600 400
500 500
300
400 400
300 300 200
200 200
100
100 100
0 0 0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 0 50 100 150 200 0 10 20 30 40 50
Displacement[mm] Displacement[mm] Displacement[mm]
The building-specific period was calculated for each interlayer deformation angle of
the building by the earthquake response analysis. The comparison results are shown
in Table 2 below. In the earthquake response analysis of this building, the maxi-
mum interlayer deformation angle is 1/54. Comparing the building-specific period
in the interlayer deformation angle 1/30 was not performed. The predicted value of
the specific period at the interlayer deformation angle 1/120 is about 6% shorter
than the analysis value. On the other hand, the predicted value of the period is about
9% longer than the analysis value. In addition, the elongation ratio of the interlayer
deformation angle to 1/60 in the predicted value defined by this method is
pffiffiffi
2 = 1.414, but the elongation ratio of the analysis value is 1.227. It is believed
that it was possible to exhibit sufficient accuracy as a prediction value although a
little difference is seen in the prediction value and the analysis value than the above
results.
4 Prediction Damage
The lower limit of the smaller of the outstanding period of the four ground deter-
mined from the above, the upper limit of the larger limit of the outstanding period at
the time of earthquake, to provide a criteria by the ground cycle.
Further, as the determination index of the building provides a determination
index of four stages in accordance with the interlayer deformation angle as shown in
Table 3.
Although determining the risk from the two overlapping conditions as an index
color, if the criteria overlaps a plurality of index color regions, employs a larger
overlapping area.
The determination results are summarized in Table 4.
Developed Research to Carry Out Prediction Damage … 939
Wooden
Interlayer deforma on
The state of the building Indicators
angle
Steel frame
Interlayer deforma on
The state of the building Indicators
angle
Reinforced concrete
Interlayer deforma on
The state of the building Indicators
angle
Risk assessment
Building Informa on
Level 1 Level 2
Place
Columnar Building Type of
Uses NS EW NS EW
drawing measurement structure
Reinforced
Housing R Y R Y
concrete
Kanamachi
Housing Steel frame Y Y R Y
Housing wooden G Y Y R
Nakano
Housing wooden Y Y Y Y
Housing wooden G Y Y R
Housing wooden G G G Y
Kumamoto
Housing wooden G Y G Y
Housing wooden R G R G
Reinforced
School Y G G G
concrete
Housing wooden G G G G
Reinforced
Bank Y R R B
concrete
Taiwan
Reinforced
Building G G Y Y
concrete
Developed Research to Carry Out Prediction Damage … 941
1.2
Ground H/V EW
1
SHAKE(const)
SHAKE(earthquake)
0.8
Min
0.6 Max
building EW
0.4 Analysis
0.2
0
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 1.1 1.2
Period[s]
5 Conclusions
Although there were some errors in the earthquake response prediction and analysis
values targeted in this study, the risk determination was the same as seen in Fig. 7.
Structural statements are essential for earthquake response analysis, and it takes
time to analyze them.
In the future, it is considered that the earthquake response prediction value that
can be issued the risk determination in a short time only by constant tremor
measurement if there is no difference in the predicted value and the analysis value
will play a very important role.
In order to do so, we would like to take a little more time to carefully evaluate
and analyze individual ground and buildings so that we can evaluate them that are
useful to society (Fig. 8).
Acknowledgements IMV Co., Ltd. helped us in this research, and many of you cooperated in the
continuous microtremor measurement.
Reference
1 Introduction
The vehicle and the bridge are the main components in a typical VBI system.
Particularly, the vehicle model has a decisive influence on the extraction of bridge
frequencies, whereas the bridge is usually assumed to be a simply supported bridge
modelled by beam elements. When the test vehicle moves over the bridge, the beam
element directly acted upon by the test vehicle forms the so-called VBI element.
At first, the vehicle model was assumed to be a single-degree-of-freedom sprung
mass moving over a beam. With such a simple idea of the VBI system, the iden-
tification of the first bridge frequency can be achieved [5]. In order to better capture
the dynamic behavior of the VBI system, a two-mass vehicle model was proposed
by including the unsprung mass in addition to the sprung mass [3], in which the
unsprung mass of the vehicle refers to the axle mass below the vehicle’s suspension
system in the automotive design. With the aid of two-mass vehicle model, the
dynamic responses of the bridge can be faithfully reflected, and the second bridge
frequency can be identified. Nevertheless, when a vehicle travels on the uneven
pavement, the front wheel and rear wheel may suffer different degrees of oscillation,
thereby causing the vehicle body to displace vertically and rotate in such a way. In
the literature, the pitching effect was discussed through the use of a train modelled
as a rigid beam moving over the bridge, where the main focus was the design of
high-speed railroad bridges [2]. As motivated by the aforementioned work, a
rigid-mass vehicle model is proposed in this work to take the pitching effect of the
vehicle into consideration, in which both vertical and rotational DOFs of the vehicle
body are assumed [4].
Figure 1 depicts the schematic diagram of the VBI system, in which the test vehicle
is modelled as a rigid beam with mass mv and pitching moment of inertia Iv moving
with constant velocity v, and it is supported by a spring of stiffness kv and a dashpot
of damping coefficient cv . It is assumed that the vehicle is in contact with the bridge
through the front wheel (on the ith beam element) and rear wheel (on the jth beam
element) spanned with axle length d while the mass of the wheels is ignored in this
work. qv and hv denote the vertical displacement and rotation about the central point
of the vehicle body. The equation of motion of the vehicle is
mv 0 €qv 2cv 0 q_ v 2kv 0 qv fver
€hv þ þ ¼
0 Iv 0 0:5cv d 2 h_ v 0 0:5kv d 2 hv frot
ð1Þ
fver cv u_ i þ u_ j þ
kv ui þ uj þ kv ri þ rj
¼ ð2Þ
frot 0:5d cv u_ i u_ j þ kv ui uj þ kv ri rj
Rigid-Mass Vehicle Model … 947
qb
j i x
d
L
1
fci ¼ mv g þ cv u_ i q_ v 0:5d h_ v þ kv ðui þ ri qv 0:5dhv Þ
2 ð4Þ
1
fcj ¼ mv g þ cv u_ j q_ v þ 0:5d h_ v þ kv uj þ rj qv þ 0:5dhv
2
3 Numerical Results
The parameters of the vehicle and bridge adopted in this study are given as follows:
For the vehicle, mv = 1500 kg, Iv ¼ 2738 kg m2 , axle distance d ¼ 2:5 m,
v ¼ 11 m/s, and kv ¼ 85 kN/m for each wheel. For the bridge, m ¼ 1000 kg/m,
L ¼ 30 m, E ¼ 27:5 GPa, and I ¼ 0:175 m4 . The frequencies of vehicle and
bridge are computed as fv ¼ 1:6943 Hz and fb ¼ 3:8288 Hz, respectively.
-1
5 10 15 20 25 30
(a)
Roughness (cm)
-1
5 10 15 20 25 30
(b)
1
-1
5 10 15 20 25 30
(c)
The corresponding vehicle’s spectra are shown in Fig. 3, in which the highest
two peaks are either the vehicle’s frequency or the bridge’s first frequency except
for the case under the highest level of road irregularity.
To understand the influence of pitching effect arising from the rigid-mass vehicle,
the output data are recorded from the following three locations of the test vehicle:
center of the vehicle, front wheel, and rear wheel in the test vehicle. For the three
levels of road irregularity introduced in Sect. 3.1, the identified frequencies of the
vehicle and bridge are respectively summarized in Table 1 and Table 2.
Referring to Table 1, it is observed that the vehicle frequencies can be identified
clearly for all cases when the output data are obtained in the center of the vehicle in
spite of high level of road irregularity. In contrast, a shifting amount of vehicle
frequencies are observed under high level of road irregularity when the output data
are obtained in the locations of front wheel and rear wheel of the vehicle in this
regard.
Referring to Table 2, it is observed that the identification of bridge frequencies
shows identical results for all cases. Especially, the bridge frequency does not
appear as either the first or the second peak in the spectrum under high road
irregularity.
Rigid-Mass Vehicle Model … 949
(a)
(b) (c)
From the above results, it is suggested that the center of the test vehicle might be
an adequate location to install the instrument such as the sensors in order to record
and process the vehicle’s responses in the on-site experiments.
4 Conclusions
This work proposes a rigid-mass vehicle model that allows for the pitching effect on
the identification of bridge frequencies. From the numerical results, it is shown that
the rigid-mass vehicle model is able to identify the frequencies of both vehicle and
bridge under all road conditions, while this cannot be done by the traditional sprung
mass vehicle model. For identifying vehicle frequencies, the dynamic responses of
the vehicle obtained in the center of vehicle yields best results under all road
conditions. For identifying bridge frequencies, the numerical results suggest that the
three locations considered can be used to install the sensors and record the dynamic
responses of the test vehicle under most road conditions. Based on the results
obtained in this study, the inclusion of vehicle’s wheels will be adopted in the future
work in order to better understand the pitching effect in this regard.
Acknowledgements This work is supported by the Ministry of Science and Technology of the
Republic of China (Taiwan) under the Grant MOST 107-2221-E-009-141-MY3.
References
D. Vo and P. Nanakorn
Abstract Circular arches are often used as parts of engineering structures due to
their effectiveness in resisting vertical loads. An understanding of nonlinear
structural behavior of circular arches is crucial to obtaining their good designs.
Points of interest are the effects of the rise-to-span ratio on their nonlinear structural
behavior. In this paper, large displacement analysis of pinned-fixed circular arches
with different rise-to-span ratios using an isogeometric approach is presented. In the
analysis, the Euler-Bernoulli beam theory is used. The exact reference axis of each
arch and its deformed axis are represented by non-uniform rational B-spline
(NURBS) curves. The effects of the rise-to-span ratio on the nonlinear structural
behavior of the arches are studied. Some well-established examples, exhibiting
snap-through and snap-back phenomena, are considered, and the accuracy and
efficiency of the proposed approach are discussed.
Keywords Isogeometric analysis (IGA) Non-uniform rational B-spline
(NURBS) Large displacement analysis Thin circular arch Rise-to-span ratio
D. Vo (&) P. Nanakorn
School of Civil Engineering and Technology, Sirindhorn International Institute of
Technology, Thammasat University, Pathumthani, Thailand
e-mail: duyvo.ce@gmail.com
P. Nanakorn
e-mail: nanakorn@siit.tu.ac.th
D. Vo
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Tokyo Institute of Technology,
2-12-1-W8-22, Ookayama, Meguro-ku, Tokyo 152-8552, Japan
1 Introduction
D v f
B C
The tangent vectors of the beam axis in the reference and current configurations
are, respectively, defined as
In this study, the prime notations indicate the derivatives with respect to n.
The unit vectors normal to the beam axis in the reference and current configu-
rations are, respectively, determined as
A1 a1
A2 ¼ K ; a2 ¼ K ð4Þ
kA 1 k ka1 k
where K is defined as
0 1
K¼ : ð5Þ
1 0
For Euler-Bernoulli beams, the cross-sections are always orthogonal to the beam
axis. By using the unit normal vectors, the position vectors of a generic point can be
described in the reference and current configurations, respectively, as
Covariant basis vectors are defined for the reference and current configurations as
@Rðn; gÞ 0 @Rðn; gÞ
G1 ¼ ¼ A1 þ gA2 ; G2 ¼ ¼ A2 ; ð7Þ
@n @g
@rðn; gÞ 0 @rðn; gÞ
g1 ¼ ¼ a1 þ ga2 ; g2 ¼ ¼ a2 : ð8Þ
@n @g
For the reference configuration, contravariant basis vectors are defined by the
following relation, i.e.,
0 a 6¼ b
Ga Gb ¼ : ð9Þ
1 a¼b
G ¼ Gab Ga Gb ð10Þ
F ¼ ga G a : ð11Þ
1 T
E¼ F FG : ð12Þ
2
1
E¼ gab Gab Ga Gb ð13Þ
2
where gab ¼ ga gb .
The components of the Green-Lagrange strain tensor E are determined as
1
Eab ¼ gab Gab : ð14Þ
2
1 0 0
E11 ¼ ða1 a1 A1 A1 Þ g a1 a2 A1 A2 : ð15Þ
2
Note that the higher order term, Oðg2 Þ, in E11 is neglected because g is small.
The membrane strain and bending curvature are defined, respectively, as
1 0 0
C11 ¼ ða1 a1 A1 A1 Þ; K11 ¼ A1 A2 a1 a2 : ð16Þ
2
S ¼ Sab Ga Gb : ð18Þ
11
S11 ¼ EE ð19Þ
Z
11
M 11 ¼ S11 gdA ¼ EIK ð21Þ
A
where N 11 and M 11 are the axial force and bending moment, respectively. In
addition, A is the cross-sectional area, and I is the moment of inertia.
The kinematic descriptions shown above can be used for any planar Euler-Bernoulli
beams. However, in this paper, only the pinned-fixed circular arch in Fig. 1 is con-
sidered. As a result, the virtual work principle can be particularly written for the arch as
956 D. Vo and P. Nanakorn
Z ZS
dE11 S11 dV ¼ dC11 N 11 þ dK11 M 11 dS ¼ dvP ð22Þ
V 0
where V and S are, respectively, the initial volume and initial length of the arch. In
addition, dv is the virtual central displacement, and P is the concentrated force (see
Fig. 1).
By following the fundamental concept of IGA, NURBS basis functions are used
to approximate both the arch axis and the displacements. Thorough studies of
NURBS basis functions can be found elsewhere [12]. Herein, NURBS basis
functions are used without introduction. The arch axis in the reference and current
configurations are approximated as NURBS curves, respectively, as
X
n X
n
R0 ðnÞ ¼ Ri ðnÞPi ; r0 ðnÞ ¼ Ri ðnÞpi ð23Þ
i¼1 i¼1
where Pi and pi are, respectively, the positions of the i-th control point in the
reference and current configurations. In addition, Ri ðnÞ is the NURBS basis func-
tion for the i-th control point. Obviously, n is the number of the control points used.
The displacement of the arch axis is determined as
X
n
u0 ðnÞ ¼ r0 ðnÞ R0 ðnÞ ¼ Ri ðnÞui ð24Þ
i¼1
where ui is the displacement vector of the i-th control point. In this study, the
displacements of the control points ui are considered as the unknowns.
Once the arch axis is expressed in terms of the unknowns ui , all the kinematic
quantities can be written in terms of the unknowns ui . Subsequently, the
NURBS-based discrete equations are determined by means of Eqs. (22) and (24).
The obtained discrete equations are nonlinear with respect to the unknowns and are
solved in this study by the Newton-Raphson method. The formulation presented so
far involves only the displacements of the beam axis. For straightforward pre-
scriptions of the concentrated force and rotational boundary conditions, the arches
are represented using two NURBS patches, and the approach in [16] is considered,
i.e., incorporating the end rotations of patches as discrete unknowns.
3 Numerical Results
Fig. 2 Normalized load versus normalized central deflection, comparison with Marc-Mentat:
a f =L ¼ 0:015, b f =L ¼ 0:03
The arch in Fig. 1 is analyzed by the proposed approach and simulated in MSC
Marc-Mentat, a commercial finite element software package, using its B52
two-noded beam elements. Here, two values of the rise-to-span ratio, i.e., f =L ¼
0:015 and f =L ¼ 0:03, are considered. The obtained results for the central deflec-
tion are plotted in Fig. 2, where the normalized load PL2 =EI and the normalized
central deflection v=f are used. Here, E is Young’s modulus, and I is the moment of
inertia. When f =L ¼ 0:015, the difference between the results obtained by the
proposed approach and Marc-Mentat is not significant. However, when f =L ¼ 0:03,
more degrees of freedom are required by Marc-Mentat in order to obtain the same
accuracy as the proposed approach, i.e., 93 degrees of freedom for Marc-Mentat and
29 degrees of freedom for the proposed approach. With these results, the efficiency
of the proposed approach is clearly verified.
The central deflections obtained with f =L ¼ 0:015 and f =L ¼ 0:03 are plotted
together in Fig. 3. The two normalized load-central deflection curves show sig-
nificantly different behavior of the two arch configurations. When f =L ¼ 0:015, the
normalized load-central deflection curve exhibits only snap-through behavior with
2 limit points, i.e., points a and b. In contrast, when f =L ¼ 0:03, the normalized
958 D. Vo and P. Nanakorn
Fig. 4 Normalized
load-central deflection curves
with different rise-to-span
ratios
Large Displacement Analysis of Pinned-Fixed Circular Arches … 959
load-central deflection curve changes from a snap-through curve with 2 limit points
to a snap-back curve with 4 limit points when the rise-to-span ratio exceeds a
certain value.
4 Conclusions
In this paper, IGA of pinned-fixed circular arches with various rise-to-span ratios,
each subjected to a central concentrated force, is presented. The obtained numerical
results are compared with those obtained by Marc-Mentat. The efficiency of the
proposed IGA approach is validated when the same accuracy with Marc-Mentat is
obtained by the proposed approach using less degrees of freedom.
The nonlinear structural behavior of a pinned-fixed circular arch depends sig-
nificantly on its rise-to-span ratio. The load-deflection curve changes from a
snap-through curve to a snap-back curve when the magnitude of the rise-to-span
ratio is greater than a certain value.
Although the accuracy and efficiency of the proposed approach have been val-
idated, only pinned-fixed circular arches are analyzed in this paper. Therefore, a
complete numerical study using the IGA approach for the nonlinear behavior of
circular arches with different boundary conditions, i.e., pinned-pinned and
fixed-fixed, should also be performed.
References
Keywords Large displacement analysis of beams Total Lagrangian formulation
Timoshenko beams Isogeometric analysis (IGA) B-spline basis functions
1 Introduction
Large displacement analysis of beams and frames has been extensively studied by
many researchers [7–9]. For large displacement analysis of beams, the choices of
kinematic assumptions, reference configurations, and interpolation schemes are the
key issues. The commonly used kinematic assumptions are those given by the
Euler-Bernoulli beam theory and the Timoshenko beam theory. The main difference
between them is the consideration of shear deformation. Shear deformation is
ignored in the Euler-Bernoulli beam theory but considered in the Timoshenko beam
theory. As a result, the Euler-Bernoulli beam theory is only suitable for thin beams
while the Timoshenko beam theory is applicable to both thin and thick beams.
Regarding reference configurations in large displacement analysis, there exist
three widely used descriptions, i.e. the total Lagrangian description, the updated
Lagrangian description, and the co-rotational description. Among them, the total
Lagrangian description can be considered as the most uncomplicated one since it
employs the undeformed configuration as the only reference configuration
throughout the analysis.
In conventional finite element analysis, polynomials written in the standard form
are usually used for the approximation of geometry and unknown kinematic fields.
However, in large displacement analysis, deformed configurations are normally
complex, and polynomials in the standard form cannot effectively represent these
configurations. Recently, basis functions used in computer-aided design (CAD) are
employed as alternatives to standard polynomials in representing both geometry
and unknown kinematic fields. This approach, first introduced by Hughes et al. [3],
is called Isogeometric Analysis (IGA). Good results by IGA are reported in many
works [1, 2, 10]. From this observation, using CAD basis functions in large dis-
placement analysis of beams, where complex deformed configurations are expected,
can be beneficial.
In this paper, an isogeometric Timoshenko beam formulation is proposed for
large displacement analysis of beams and frames. The total Lagrangian description
is used. In addition, B-spline basis functions are used for the approximation of
geometry and unknown kinematic fields. Some benchmark problems are solved,
and the obtained results are compared with those in the literature. The efficiency and
accuracy of the proposed approach are discussed.
The kinematic assumptions in the Timoshenko beam theory are illustrated in Fig. 1.
The initial configuration C0 is considered as the reference configuration, and the
deformed configuration is denoted by C. The coordinate systems for the reference
and deformed configurations are OXY and Oxy, respectively. They are set to
coincide with each other. Consider a point P0 ðX; Y Þ and its projection on the beam
axis in C0 . Due to the deformation, P0 ðX; Y Þ moves to Pðx; yÞ in C, as shown in
Fig. 1. It follows that
Here, uX and uY are the horizontal and vertical displacements of the projection of
P0 ðX; Y Þ on the beam axis. In addition, h is the rotational displacement of the
A Total Lagrangian Isogeometric Timoshenko Beam Formulation … 963
@X @Y
cos h
1 T
E¼ F FI ð3Þ
2
as
Define a matrix F
¼ QðhÞF ¼ I þ L
F ð5Þ
964 V. Chorn et al.
where
0
1 þ uX cos h þ uY sin h Yh0 1
0
0
L¼ 0 0 : ð6Þ
1 þ uX sin h þ uY cos h 0
1 T 1 T
E¼ F FI ¼ F I ¼ 1 L þ LT þ LT L 1 L þ LT :
F ð7Þ
2 2 2 2
where
0
0
C11 ¼ 1 þ uX cos h þ uY sin h 1; ð9Þ
0
0
C12 ¼ 1 þ uX sin h þ uY cos h; ð10Þ
where E and G are Young’s modulus and the shear modulus, respectively.
The resultant forces are defined as
Z
N11 ¼ S11 dA ¼ EAC11 ; ð13Þ
A
Z
M11 ¼ S11 YdA ¼ EIK11 ; ð14Þ
A
Z
N12 ¼ S12 dA ¼ GAC12 ð15Þ
A
where L is the length of the beam. Here, the displacement vector v and the dis-
tributed load vector q are defined as
v ¼ ½ uX uY h T ; q ¼ ½ qX qY m T : ð17Þ
In addition, dvð0Þ and dvðLÞ are the virtual displacements at the ends of the
beam. Moreover, f 0 and f L are the concentrated load vectors at these end locations.
In this study, B-spline basis functions are used without introduction. Details
about these basis functions can be found in CAD reference books [5]. The unknown
displacements are approximated using B-spline basis functions as
X
n
uX ¼ Bi ðnÞuXi ; ð18Þ
i¼1
X
n
uY ¼ Bi ðnÞuYi ; ð19Þ
i¼1
X
n
h¼ Bi ðnÞhi ð20Þ
i¼1
where Bi ðnÞ are the B-spline basis functions, and uXi , uYi , hi are the control vari-
ables. In addition, n is the parametric variable for the B-spline basis functions, while
n denotes the number of the control points used. All the kinematic quantities can be
expressed in terms of the control variables by means of Eqs. (18)–(20), and the
discrete equations can subsequently be obtained from the virtual work principle in
Eq. (16). The obtained discrete equations are nonlinear in terms of the control
variables, and they are solved in this study by the Newton-Raphson method.
3 Results
Two benchmark problems are solved, and the accuracy and efficiency of the pro-
posed formulation are discussed.
966 V. Chorn et al.
or 63 degrees of freedom for one quarter of the frame, are also available. In this
study, septic B-spline basis functions with 15 control points are used to approxi-
mate the displacements. In other words, the number of degrees of freedom is 45.
The results by Mattiasson [4], Wu et al. [8], and this study are compared in Fig. 3.
Good agreement is observed.
4 Conclusions
In this paper, a total Lagrangian Timoshenko beam formulation using the isogeo-
metric approach is proposed for large displacement analysis of frames. B-spline
basis functions are used to approximate the unknown displacements, which include
the translational displacements of the beam axis and the cross-sectional rotation.
Two benchmark problems are solved. The obtained results agree well with those
found in the literature. The numbers of degrees of freedom used in this study are
smaller than those used in the literature. These comparison results illustrate the
accuracy and efficiency of the proposed formulation.
References
1. Benson DJ, Bazilevs Y, Hsu MC, Hughes TJR (2010) Isogeometric shell analysis: the
Reissner-Mindlin shell. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 199(5):276–289
2. Cottrell JA, Hughes TJR, Reali A (2007) Studies of refinement and continuity in isogeometric
structural analysis. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 196(41):4160–4183
3. Hughes TJ, Cottrell JA, Bazilevs Y (2005) Isogeometric analysis: CAD, finite elements,
NURBS, exact geometry and mesh refinement. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 194(39–
41):4135–4195
4. Mattiasson K (1981) Numerical results from large deflection beam and frame problems
analysed by means of elliptic integrals. Int J Numer Meth Eng 17(1):145–153
5. Piegl L, Tiller W (1997) The NURBS book. Springer, New York
6. Williams F (1964) An approach to the non-linear behaviour of the members of a rigid jointed
plane framework with finite deflections. Q J Mech Appl Math 17(4):451–469
7. Wood RD, Zienkiewicz OC (1977) Geometrically nonlinear finite element analysis of beams,
frames, arches and axisymmetric shells. Comput Struct 7(6):725–735
8. Wu TY, Wang RZ, Wang CY (2006) Large deflection analysis of flexible planar frames.
J Chin Inst Eng 29(4):593–606
9. Yang YB, Leu LJ, Yang JP (2007) Key considerations in tracing the postbuckling response of
structures with multi winding loops. Mech Adv Mater Struct 14(3):175–189
10. Vo D, Nanakorn P (2020) Geometrically nonlinear multi-patch isogeometric analysis of
planar curved Euler-Bernoulli beams. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 366:113078
Experimental and Analytical Study
on Lead Rubber Bearings Under
Non-proportional Plane Loading
Abstract In this study, lead rubber bearings, which have been extensively applied
in many seismic isolation designs for buildings, infrastructures, and facilities
worldwide, are tested under unilateral reversal loading as well as non-proportional
plane loading, including circular, figure-eight, and square orbits. The test results
indicate that unlike the unilateral hysteretic behavior, the bilateral one of lead
rubber bearings is too complicated to be characterized adequately by a simplified
bilinear hysteretic model. The applicability of adopting Abe et al.’s and Hwang
et al.’s models as well as the Bouc-Wen model for describing the coupled bilateral
hysteretic behavior of lead rubber bearings are demonstrated by comparing their
predictions with the non-proportional plane loading test results.
1 Introduction
The hysteretic model, which was either ideally deduced under unilateral loading or
simply determined by unilateral reversal loading test results, was utilized to
numerically characterize the mechanical properties of LR bearings under dynamic
plane loading. However, the differences, if there are any and even if they are not
S. J. Wang J. S. Hwang
Department of Civil and Construction Engineering,
National Taiwan University of Science and Technology, Taipei, Taiwan
e-mail: sjwang@narlabs.org.tw
S. J. Wang W. C. Lin (&) J. S. Hwang (&)
Division of Structural Control, National Applied Research Laboratories National Center
for Research on Earthquake Engineering, Taipei, Taiwan
e-mail: wclin@narlabs.org.tw
J. S. Hwang
e-mail: jshwang@narlabs.org.tw
very noticeable, between the unilateral and bilateral behavior of LR bearings, or any
damage owing to bilateral loading, might cause inaccurate and even not conser-
vative design results [1, 2]. In this study, the LR bearings are tested with different
loading patterns, including unilateral reversal loading and non-proportional plane
loading [3–5]. Three previously developed analytical models, Abe et al.’s [3] and
Hwang et al.’s [5] models as well as the Bouc-Wen model [6], are selected for
describing the coupled bilateral hysteretic behavior of LR bearings. The applica-
bility of these models are demonstrated by comparing their predictions in which the
parameters are identified from the identical plane loading test with the test results.
In addition, the bilateral coupling effect on the hysteresis behavior of LR bearings is
experimentally discussed.
The LR bearings are configured to be tested under unilateral reversal loading and
non-proportional plane loading. The LR bearings are designed with a single, central
lead plug whose diameter is 30 mm. It is comprised of 16 layers of rubber each with
a thickness of 2 mm and 15 layers of steel shim with a thickness of 2 mm each. The
diameter and height of the LR bearings are 128 and 62 mm, respectively. The test
setup is illustrated in Fig. 1. As shown in Fig. 1, the vertical load on the bearing is
exerted by the servo-hydraulic actuator, while the lateral displacement is controlled
by two mutually orthogonal servo-hydraulic actuators connected with the bilateral
sliding platform. A linear guide system is installed underneath the platform to
reduce the friction force induced by the dynamic tri-axial testing facility. An
external load cell is installed to measure the actual force responses of the bearing
during testing.
The unilateral test protocols under triangular and sinusoidal reversal loading are
respectively detailed in Table 1, and the bilateral ones under non-proportional plane
loading, including circular, figure-eight, and square loading paths, are described in
Table 1. The equations of the plane loading paths shown in Fig. 2 are given by
(1) Circular orbit:
Ux ðtÞ ¼ U0 cos xðt T=4Þ and Uy ðtÞ ¼ U0 sin xðt T=4Þ; when t
¼ p=2x 5p=2x ð2Þ
Ux ðtÞ ¼ U0 and Uy ðtÞ ¼ U0 sin xðt T=4Þ; when t ¼ p=2x p=x ð6Þ
972 S. J. Wang et al.
Ux ðtÞ ¼ U0 cos xðt 2T=4Þ and Uy ðtÞ ¼ U0 ; when t ¼ p=x 2p=x ð7Þ
Ux ðtÞ ¼ U0 and Uy ðtÞ ¼ U0 cos xðt 4T=4Þ; when t ¼ 2p=x 3p=x ð8Þ
Ux ðtÞ ¼ U0 cos xðt 6T=4Þ and Uy ðtÞ ¼ U0 ; when t ¼ 3p=x 4p=x
ð9Þ
Ux ðtÞ ¼ U0 and Uy ðtÞ ¼ U0 cos xðt 8T=4Þ; when t ¼ 4p=x 9p=2x
ð10Þ
where Ux ðtÞ and Uy ðtÞ are the displacement components at time t in two prin-
cipal horizontal directions, respectively; U0 is the displacement amplitude; x is the
angular frequency; and T ¼ 2p=x.
The hysteresis loops of the LR bearings under a compression stress of 50 kg/
cm2, triangular reversal loading with a constant rate of 16 mm/s, and sinusoidal
reversal loading with a frequency of 0.0125 Hz are depicted in Fig. 3 and Fig. 4.
The test observations show that the tested bearings have an excellent and stable
energy dissipation capability without strain hardening and cyclic softening phe-
nomena under both unilateral loadings. The only discrepancy observed is that under
triangular reversal loading, the hysteresis loops become slightly sharper at the
transition from loading to unloading compared to those under sinusoidal reversal
loading. In addition, the hysteresis loops of the tested bearings under unilateral
reversal loading can be adequately described by a simplified bilinear hysteretic
model.
Uy Uy Uy
Ux Ux Ux
Fig. 4 Hysteresis loops under sinusoidal reversal loading before and after non-proportional plane
loading tests
(a) under circular plane (b) under figure-eight plane (c) under square plane
loading loading loading
ð14Þ
Experimental and Analytical Study on Lead Rubber Bearings … 975
a13
jUj
F3A ¼ a12 U ð15Þ
a8
where F, U, and U_ are the restoring force, displacement, and velocity vectors
composed of X and Y directional components at time t; respectively; F1A , F2A , and
F3A are the force vectors composed of X and Y directional components at time
t provided by nonlinear elastic, elastoplastic, and hardening springs, respectively;
and a1 * a13 are the coefficients that are required to be identified from test results.
(2) Bouc-Wen Model:
In this analytical model, the restoring force was decomposed to elastic and
hysteretic components. By employing the plane vector concept in this study, the
Bouc-Wen model can be further extended in the form of vectors and is given by [6,
8]
T
F ¼ F1W þ F2W ¼ f Fx ðtÞ Fy ðtÞ g ð16Þ
F1W ¼ a5 a6 U ð17Þ
z ¼ f zx ðt Þ zy ðtÞ gT ð20Þ
where F1W and F2W are correspondingly the elastic and hysteretic force vectors
composed of X and Y directional components at time t; z is the hysteretic dis-
placement vector composed of X and Y directional components at time t; and
a1 * a6 are the coefficients that are required to be identified from test results.
(3) Hwang et al.’s Model:
Taking the shear force experienced by elastomeric bearings as a combination of
restoring force and damping force [9, 10], and assuming that the cyclic softening
effect is insignificant, a mathematical model in the form of vectors for character-
izing their hysteretic behavior under non-proportional plane loading was proposed
by Hwang et al. [5] and is given by:
T
F ¼ F1H þ F2H ¼ f Fx ðtÞ Fy ðtÞ g ð21Þ
F1H ¼ a1 U þ a2 U3 þ a3 U5 ð22Þ
976 S. J. Wang et al.
Z ( a6 1 )
F2H U_ F2H
F2H ¼ a4 þ a5 U 2 _
U a dt ð23Þ
ja7 þ ½1 þ ðjUj=a8 Þa9 j 6
where F1H and F2H correspond to the restoring and damping force vectors composed
of X and Y directional components at time t, and a1 * a9 are the coefficients that
are required to be determined from test results.
The three analytical models are examined by comparing their predictions to
non-proportional plane loading test results, as shown in Fig. 6 to Fig. 8, respec-
tively. The coefficients of the model are mathematically determined by using the
Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm [11] in the optimization routine to achieve the
following objective function.
X
m
2
min Ftest Fprediction ð24Þ
i¼1
where m is the total number of data points, and Ftest and Fprediction are the experi-
mental and predicted shear forces, respectively. An expedient representation to
quantitatively evaluate the correlation between test results and predictions, the
coefficient of determination (R2), is also provided in Fig. 6 and can be calculated by:
SSE
R2 ¼ 1 ð25Þ
SST
X
m
2
SSE ¼ ðFtest Þi Fprediction i ð26Þ
i¼1
(a) under circular plane (b) under figure-eight plane (c) under square plane
loading loading loading
Fig. 6 Comparison between non-proportional plane loading test results and predictions by
Bouc-Wen model
Experimental and Analytical Study on Lead Rubber Bearings … 977
(a) under circular plane (b) under figure-eight plane (c) under square plane
loading loading loading
Fig. 7 Comparison between non-proportional plane loading test results and predictions by Abe
et al.’s model
(a) under circular plane (b) under figure-eight plane (c) under square plane
loading loading loading
Fig. 8 Comparison between non-proportional plane loading test results and predictions by Hwang
et al.’s model
978
Table 2 Identified coefficients of the three models for predicting hysteretic behavior of LR bearings under non-proportional plane loading
Coefficient Bouc-Wen model Abe et al.’s model Hwang et al.’s model
Circular Figure-eight Square Circular Figure-eight Square Circular Figure-eight Square
a1 4.9933 5.0054 5.1077 0.2106 0.0003 0.3014 0.1844 0.1374 0.2073
a2 0.1255 0.0498 0.0206 3.9567 5.57 10−8 3.9932 −1.17 10−5 1.26 10−6 −4.98 10−5
a3 0.0323 0.0041 2.2672 −0.0629 −0.1878 0.2736 1.68 10−9 −4.08 10−10 1.44 10−8
a4 5.0046 4.9911 −0.0166 4.9443 2.3842 3.7262 3.2179 3.3372 4.9249
a5 0.0074 0.0025 0.2920 0.0494 0.0838 0.0790 0.0007 −0.0004 0.0044
a6 22.1775 56.9703 0.5732 0.9310 0.3908 0.4747 1.1729 0.4370 0.9377
a7 – – – 8.6407 10.2074 8.6779 2.3215 8.0256 3.8709
a8 – – – 128.1823 177.8156 120.5360 0.0028 0.0000 0.4198
a9 – – – 2.2792 15.3206 2.1735 0.1192 −0.0447 0.0790
a10 – – – 0.8168 1.5198 0.6494 – – –
a11 – – – 18.4678 29.2730 41.6796 – – –
a12 – – – 0.1224 0.1338 0.0157 – – –
a13 – – – 0.3330 0.3350 3.0609 – – –
S. J. Wang et al.
Experimental and Analytical Study on Lead Rubber Bearings … 979
m h
X
i2
SST ¼ ðFtest Þi Fprediction mean ð27Þ
i¼1
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The study was financially aided by the Ministry of Science and Technology
(MOST) of Taiwan [105-2221-E-011-169-MY2], and was experimentally supported by the
National Center for Research on Earthquake Engineering (NCREE), National Applied Research
Laboratories (NARL) of Taiwan. The support is greatly acknowledged.
References
1. Huang WH, Fenves GL, Whittaker AS, Mahin SA (2000) Characterization of seismic
isolation bearings for bridges from bi-directional testing. In: Proceedings of the 12th world
conference on earthquake engineering, Auckland, New Zealand
980 S. J. Wang et al.
Keywords Rubber bearing Deterioration Fatigue Bridge Cold region Low
temperature
1 Introduction
In order to verify the effect of low temperature, cyclic compression tests were
conducted under normal temperature and low temperature environment. The test
was carried out using the outdoor servo fatigue testing device located in the site of
The Civil Engineering Research Institute for Cold Region. This test is based on the
cyclic compression fatigue test method of JIS K 6411. However, when the test is
performed on different dates for each test model, the atmosphere condition at the
time of the test is different. Therefore, as shown in Fig. 3, the bearings were
vertically connected, and the rubber bearings were arranged on the bearing fixed
guides so that the vertical direction of the rubber bearings became horizontal, and
the tests were conducted under the same atmosphere (See Fig. 4). Figure 5 shows
the arrangement of the test equipment and test model. And test conditions are
shown in Table 2. In order to check the temperature of the test model, a dummy
rubber bearing was installed near the testing machine, and the internal temperature
and surface temperature of the rubber bearing were measured.
In addition, because it was connected including the highly energy-absorbing
bearing, the bearing arrangement was changed every 500,000 times in order to
eliminate the influence of bearing arrangement from the loading point (See Fig. 6.).
In order to confirm the characteristic change of the rubber bearing by the com-
pression fatigue test under the low temperature environment, the shear rigidity was
examined before the compression fatigue test and every 500,000 loadings. The test
conditions are as shown in Table 3. The test was based on “JIS K 6411 Shear test
for rubber bearing test”. However, due to the limitations of the testing machine
shown in Fig. 7, the rotation of the rubber bearing during shear loading is
permitted.
986 T. Sato et al.
Table 3 Test conditions for Number of times to load RB; 5 times, HDR, LRB; 11 times
shear property evaluation
Vertical load 345.6 kN (6 N/mm2)
Shear strain amplitude 175% (±49 mm)
Loading cycle 0.05 Hz or 0.1 Hz
actuator
test model
Shear stiffness was calculated as the average stiffness according to the method
specified for each rubber bearing. RB (CR) and RB (NR) are the third of the history
loop, and HDR and LRB are the shear stiffness of the fifth time. The change in
equivalent stiffness after each loading cycle is shown in Fig. 8 as the rate of change
from the equivalent stiffness before the fatigue test. The change in damping con-
stant is shown in Fig. 9 as the rate of change from damping before fatigue testing.
Natural rubber system is shown in a) and synthetic rubber system is shown in b).
The change in stiffness with the number of repetitions is as small as ±5% in both
natural temperature and low temperature environments. Even if the number of
repetitions is 4 million, no major change has occurred. On the other hand, the
damping constant has a large variation and can’t be evaluated for the influence. As
for the damping characteristics of LRB with damping function, damping increased
with the test results at room temperature and decreased by about 15% with the test
results at low temperature.
Synthetic rubbers, unlike natural rubbers, have higher equivalent stiffness as the
number of repetitions increases in both normal temperature and low temperature
environments. The rate of change is up to 19%. The damping constant of HDR with
a damping function decreases by about 10% at both normal temperature and low
temperature after 2 million repetitions. However, the change in the attenuation
characteristics is small in the low temperature results after 4 million repetitions.
a) natural rubber bearing (RB(NR), LRB) b) synthec rubber bearing (RB(CR), HDR)
Fig. 8 Change in equivalent stiffness of a rubber bearing subjected to cyclic compressive loading
988 T. Sato et al.
a) natural rubber bearing (RB(NR), LRB) b) synthec rubber bearing (RB(CR), HDR)
The natural rubber system is shown in Fig. 10(a) and the synthetic rubber system is
shown in Fig. 10(b) as the rate of change of the compression stiffness constant after
the loading cycle based on the compression stiffness before the fatigue test.
In natural rubber bearings, vertical stiffness tends to decrease as the number of
loading increases. In RB (NR), the vertical stiffness decreases as the number of
loading increases. In the test results of normal temperature, the reduction rate of
vertical rigidity is large from 10% to 20% due to the reduction rate of 25% at 2
million times and the increase of loading frequency at low temperature.
a) natural rubber bearing (RB(NR), LRB) b) synthec rubber bearing (RB(CR), HDR)
The reduction rate of the LRB damping constant is confirmed from the figure.
After 2 million loadings, the reduction rate is about 10%, which is the same level at
both normal temperature and low temperature. Furthermore, although it is the result
only of the low temperature test, after loading of 4 million times, the reduction rate
after loading of 2 million times is almost the same value, and the change converges.
The result of RB (NR) is different from that the reduction rate decreases with the
increase of loading frequency.
In synthetic rubber bearings, the change in HDR is small. The rate of change is
around 5%. It is not clear that the stiffness changes in the stiffness evaluation after 4
million loadings. In RB (CR), the reduction rate of 2 million times at normal
temperature and the reduction rate of 4 million times at low temperature are almost
the same.
Figure 11 shows a photo of the surface of a rubber bearing after a shear property
test (horizontal displacement 175%) after 4 million fatigue tests. The photo on the
left shown in a) to d) is a plane perpendicular to the bridge axis direction. On the
other hand, the picture on the right is the side perpendicular to the plane shown in
the picture on the left and is the plane in the fatigue loading direction (See Fig. 12).
The appearance differs depending on the bearing type, regardless of the type of
rubber. For RB (NR) and RB (CR), residual deformation is small, and no wrinkles
or cracks on the surface are confirmed. Although LRB has large residual defor-
mation, it can’t identify surface wrinkles and cracks. HDR had large residual
deformation and wrinkles occurred on the surface. However, no crack could be
confirmed in any of the bearing.
a) RB(NR) (le; direcon 1, right; direcon 2) b) LRB (le; direcon 1, right; direcon 2)
c) RB(CR) (le; direcon 1, right; direcon 2) d) HDR (le; direcon 1, right; direcon 2)
Fig. 11 The surface immediately after the end of the shear property test after 4,000,000 fatigue
loadings
990 T. Sato et al.
4 Conclusions
Reference
Abstract Facing the problems of damaged bridge piers with box sections due to
the rupture of the corner welds, cold press-bent steel structure was considered as a
possible solution. However, strain aging induced by cold-forming may lead to
decrease in toughness and elongation, as well as increase in hardness and strength.
This paper focuses on the adverse effects of strain aging on the test pieces made of
steel SM520C, which were evaluated through Vicker’s hardness test and Charpy
impact tests. The test pieces were taken from different locations of the cold
press-bent corner parts, and the Charpy impact test was conducted after one month,
six months and one year correspondingly. The hardness of the material increased
due to the effect of strain aging, especially at both edges at the maximum curvature
of the corner part. Small effect of strain aging on the Charpy absorbed energy was
found under 0 °C, while larger reduction ratio was obtained under a lower tem-
perature −60 °C. In the future, steel materials with high toughness are suggested to
be studied in order to widen the usage of cold-formed structures.
1 Introduction
Collapse of two bridge piers with rectangular cross-sections in the 1995 Kobe
earthquake were found due to the unexpected loading conditions at the welded
joints. Facing such vital damage in bridges, corner sections without welding
through the cold-forming of steel plates is considered as a possible solution.
However, strain aging effect caused by the cold-forming may lead to decrease in
toughness and elongation, as well as increase in hardness and strength. Strain aging
describes the change of material properties after the metallic material reached its
plastic strain [1]. The reduced toughness of the steel material may lead to higher
risks of rupture and eventually failure at the steel piers. To deal with this problem,
the adverse effect of strain aging should be investigated in detail. The conventional
steel SM520C was studied to confirm the possibility of cold-forming using con-
ventional steel materials. In the previous studies [4, 5], pre-strain was induced by
applying tensile load with the corresponding magnitude of the actual strain, which
was considered to be evenly distributed. Also, conditions for strain aging effect
were simulated by the accelerated treatment of heating up the test pieces.
Conversely, the test pieces used in this study were cold-pressed into corner shape
with an angle of 90º, which is significantly similar to the actual curved corner parts.
As a consequence, different than the strain induced by the tension test, a linear
distribution of actual strain along the plate thickness direction can be found in the
test pieces of the current study.
2 Methods
It is described in the Specification for Highway Bridges [7] that the design of the
radius of inner surface should be 15 times larger than the plate thickness. However,
exceptions can be found for steel materials with little impurities of N content of
lower than 0.006%, and higher Charpy absorbed energy. When the Charpy
absorbed energy of the base material is higher than 150 J, the radius of bend should
Charpy Absorbed Energy of Cold Press-Bent Steel Plates Made of SM520C 993
be 7 times larger than the plate thickness; while the radius of bend should be 5 times
larger than the plate thickness when the Charpy absorbed energy is higher than
200 J [4]. The chemical composition of SM520C used in this study can be found in
Table 1. The test piece being cold press-formed was designed that the radius of
bend (= 225 mm) was 5 times larger than the plate thickness (= 45 mm), as shown
in Fig. 1.
In the previous studies [4], Charpy impact test was conducted after inducing the
tensile strain according to the magnitude of the corresponding bending strain. Also,
the strain aging effect was simulated in the laboratory and accelerated by temper-
ature control. However, in the present study, the test pieces were not only
cold-formed into actual corner shape, but also were exposed to natural duration of
the strain aging effects. Due to the fact that the cross-section remains plane and
perpendicular to the longitudinal axis, the strain induced by bending can be rep-
resented as follows [3]:
e ¼ g=R ð1Þ
Vicker’s hardness test was conducted one year after the steel plates being cold
press-bent. The actual linear strain distribution, where compressive strain is induced
near the inner surface while tensile strain can be found near the outer surface
correspondingly, as shown in Fig. 1. As a result, the test pieces in this study were
taken from five different locations at each angle as shown in Fig. 3 to confirm the
effect of strain aging on the hardness of the material. The measurement lines for
Vicker’s hardness test were taken where the angle from the horizontal line (where
the radius of the curvature is perpendicular to the flat plate) is equal to 5, 22.5, 45,
67.5, and 85º. The distance from the outer surface was regarded as 0 mm at each
measurement line along the plate thickness direction. The thickness of the test
pieces was 10 mm. Vicker’s hardness tests were conducted at the locations
[Unit: mm]
[Unit: mm]
mentioned above with interval of 0.5 mm near both edges and 1 mm near the
center. Flat plates without being cold press-bent are considered to be free of the
strain aging effect.
Charpy Absorbed Energy of Cold Press-Bent Steel Plates Made of SM520C 995
Table 2 Number of the test Flat 39 days 182 days 365 days
pieces plates
(°C) 0 −60 0 −60 0 −60 0 −60
Outside 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Center 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Inside 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Total 18 18 18 18
(a) Location and orientation of the test pieces (b) Dimension of the test piece
Taking consideration of the strain distribution induced by the bending of steel plate,
test pieces made for Charpy impact test were taken at the location of the maximum
curvature of the corner part (where the angle from the radius at the beginning of the
bent corner is equal to 45º) with different orientations, as shown in Fig. 4(a).
Charpy impact tests with V-notch test pieces were conducted following JIS Z2242:
Method for Charpy pendulum impact test of metallic materials. The dimension of
the test pieces is shown in Fig. 4(b). The measurement locations were decided to be
near the outer surface (outside), the inner surface (inside), and the center line. The
tests were conducted after nearly one month (39 days), six months (182 days) and
one year (365 days) of exposure from day of the cold-forming of the steel plates.
Flat plates can be regarded to be free of the strain aging effect for comparison. For
the cold press-bent steel plates, the test pieces were all along the direction per-
pendicular to the rolling direction. The number of test pieces is shown in Table 2.
3 Experimental Results
The hardness of the material can be indicated by the HV value from the Vicker’s
hardness test. The distribution of HV value is shown in Fig. 5. Comparing with the
996 D. Kitazume et al.
flat surface, test pieces being cold press-bent are subjected to distribution where the
HV value is the lowest along the center of the plate thickness. Furthermore, the
average values of HV near both inner (40–45 mm) and outer surfaces (0–5 mm), as
well as the center line (17.5–27.5 mm) along the plate thickness direction were
compared in Fig. 6. Data obtained on the flat surface was represented as 0º. As the
results show, hardness near the center line was always lower than that near both the
inner and outer surfaces. The smallest difference between the three locations was
found at the flat surface. Moreover at the angle of 45º, the highest HV values were
found near both surfaces, while the HV near the center line was similar to the other
locations. The increase in hardness near both edges can be observed as a result of
the strain aging effect caused by cold-bending.
The dependence of strain aging effect on the duration of natural exposure was
investigated. The test results of the Charpy absorbed energy with respect to the
duration can be found in Fig. 7, and the averaged values are shown in Fig. 8. In the
previous studies [2], relationships between temperature and time for the dislocations
of carbon and nitrogen atoms are described by logarithmic equations. Therefore, the
averaged values for the Charpy absorbed energy are plotted on semi-logarithmic
graphs as shown in Fig. 9. The vertical axis represents the ratio between the Charpy
absorbed energy measured at the corresponding dates and the Charpy absorbed
energy of the flat plates, which were free of the strain aging effect. As a matter of
fact, the data of Charpy absorbed energy for all test pieces were largely scattered.
The failure cross-section after Charpy impact test is related to the ductility of a
material. It can be represented by the ratio of brittle failure (B), which is the area of
the brittle fracture (C) over the whole cross-sectional area (A) as shown in Eq. 2.
The ratio of brittle failure was calculated for the cross-sections of all test pieces
after the Charpy impact test. The results in Fig. 10 show that little area of brittle
failure could be observed after the exposure to strain aging effect under the test
temperature of 0 °C. Conversely, under −60 °C, much larger ratios of brittle failure
were found, and the effect of strain aging can be clearly observed at the center and
the inner side of the plate.
Charpy Absorbed Energy of Cold Press-Bent Steel Plates Made of SM520C 999
4 Future Directions
As shown in the experimental results, effect of strain aging on the hardness and
toughness of the steel material can be observed. In the light of this situation, steel
materials with significantly high toughness are desired to make up for the degra-
dation induced by the cold press-bending of the steel plates. SBHS (Steels for
Bridge High Performance Structure) was introduced in Japan for its superior
mechanical properties such as high yield strength, toughness, and workability [6].
Such advantages of SBHS are closely related to its fine micro-structure and well
balanced chemical composition. As specified by JIS, the minimum Charpy absor-
bed energy is 100 J along the transverse direction for SBHS. The high toughness of
SBHS indicates the possibility to be a fitting steel material for cold press-bent
structures compared with the conventional steel materials. Therefore, future studies
are expected to be conducted on such new steel materials with high toughness for
the use of cold press-bent steel plates.
5 Conclusions
In this study, the effect of strain aging on the cold press-bent structure made of
SM520C was evaluated by Vicker’s hardness test and Charpy impact test. The
hardness of the material increased due to the effect of strain aging, especially at both
edges at the maximum curvature of the corner part. The experimental data of
Charpy absorbed energy were largely scattered and the effect of strain aging was
not distinctively identified especially under the test temperature of 0 °C. However
under −60 °C, a slightly larger reduction ratio could be observed on the
semi-logarithmic plot. New steel materials with significantly high Charpy absorbed
energy are desired to make up for the adverse effects caused by cold-forming.
1000 D. Kitazume et al.
Therefore, future studies are expected to be conducted on such new steel materials
with high toughness for the cold press-bent steel plates.
Acknowledgements This work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI (grant number 18K04331)
and the Japan Iron and Steel Federation.
References
1. Baird JD (1971) The effects of strain-ageing due to interstitial solutes on the mechanical
properties of metals. Metall Rev 16:1–18
2. Baird JD (1963) Strain aging of Steel a critical review. Iron Steel 36:186–192
3. Gaylord Jr. EH, Gaylord CN, Stallmeyer JE (1992) Design of steel structures, 3 edn.
McGraw-Hill, Inc., p 284
4. Homma K, Miki C, Soya I, Sasao H, Okumura T, Hara S (1997) A study on strain aging of
cold worked structural steel and allowable cold working radius. In: Proceedings of JSCE, no
570, pp 153–162 (in Japanese)
5. Horikawa K (1980) Strain aging embrittlement of structural steel due to cold forming. J JSCE
300:13–20 (in Japanese)
6. Japanese Industrial Standards Committee (2011) JIS G3140: Higher yield strength steel plates
for bridges (in Japanese)
7. Japan Road Association (JRA) (2012) Specifications for highway, bridges part II: steel bridges
and steel members (in Japanese)
A Study on the Vertical Pull-off Testing
and Horizontal Shear Testing Strength
of External Wall Tile Adhesion
Abstract Most of the exterior wall tiles deterioration appears in the adhesive layer,
because of grooves and tile caulking marks on adhesion layer are clearly be seen
from the fallen tile scene. The current strength test of adhesive layer is pull-off
testing which is vertical to the exterior wall. The author developed a new shear test
machine, and carries out the experiment with the universal pull-off testing machine.
In this study, pull-off testing and shear testing which is horizontal to the exterior
wall were both proceed for a more comprehensive discussion.
To understand the relation between adhesive strength and hollow ratio, there are
four hollow proportion of adhesion layer be set, 0%, 25%, 50%, and 75%. And the
author into a variable with the experiment, if the structure is sprinkled or not. The
pull-off testing strength is higher in the structural watering area, and 60% of the tile
failure layer appears in the cement mortar layer. According to statistics from shear
testing and pull-off testing of watering area, we get 1.62 and 12.77 kgf/cm2 on the
0% ratio of hollow, 0.77 and 5.67 kgf/cm2 on the 25% ratio of hollow, and 0.63 and
5.39 kgf/cm2 on the 50% ratio of hollow. The tiles adhesive strength of 25% ratio of
hollow is less than half of the 0%. In the case of 0% ratio of hollow, the ratio of
shear testing to pull-off testing is about 1:8. Comparing with current pull-off testing,
shear test shows that even small strength can cause damage. It is suggested that the
condition need to be aware when external wall tiles are determined to have hollow,
their adhesion strength also becomes extremely weaker.
1 Introduction—Major Heading
Tile is one of the most popular materials for constructing the exterior walls of
buildings in Taiwan. Therefore, the Public Works Bureau of the Kaohsiung City
government inspected all the apartment buildings six stories or taller (4,256
buildings) in their city in 2014. Their general survey showed that 98% of these
buildings’ façades were covered with tiles. However, 20% of the apartments (859
buildings) had deteriorated wall tiles that needed immediate repair [1].
Most of the exterior wall tiles deterioration appears in the adhesive layer,
because of grooves and tile caulking marks on adhesion layer are clearly be seen
from the fallen tile scene. To understand the relation between adhesive strength and
hollow ratio, there are four hollow ratios of adhesion layer be set, 0, 25, 50, and
75%. Some construction-site workers watered a concrete structure before adding a
mortar-bed interface to improve the structure’s overall tensile strength. However,
the effect of watering a structure to improve the tensile strength of tile was
uncertain. Therefore, the structural sprinkling is set as the variation of the test body
in the construction method. The experimental specimen is divided into the upper
half (without watering) and the lower half (watering).
The current strength test of adhesive layer is pull-off testing which is vertical to
the exterior wall. The author developed a new shear test machine, and carries out
the experiment with the common pull-off testing machine. The phenomenon of
spalling caused by the deterioration of the tile should also be affected by the force in
the horizontal direction of the exterior tile surface. There is almost no relevant
literature for this discussion. In this study, pull-off testing and shear testing which is
horizontal to the exterior wall were both proceed for a more comprehensive dis-
cussion (Fig. 1).
Pull-off testing
(vertical to the exterior wall)
Shear testing
(horizontal to the exterior wall)
2 Literature Review
Reviewing the research literature related to the external wall tiles in Taiwan, it is
found that the investigation of the deterioration of the tiles is mostly the cases, and
the research on the strength is mostly related to the pull-off test.
The surface properties of various types of tiles (such as groove form, porosity,
release agent adhesion) have an effect on tile adhesive performance [2].
Interfaces damaged of external wall tiles include: tile, tile and adhesive layer,
adhesive layer, adhesive layer and cement mortar layer, cement mortar layer,
cement mortar layer and outer wall structure. The damage of the interface between
the tile and the adhesive layer is most valued [3].
The external wall tile pull-off testing method is based on the tile manual published
by National Magnetic Tiles Association of Japan. After two weeks of construction,
the tile is visually inspected and the required part is selected for the pull-off testing
on the outer wall [4].
Specification No. 09310 were enacted by the Taiwanese government’s Public
Construction Commission Tensile. Adhesive strength of 10kgf/cm2 was recom-
mended by the Public Construction Commission [5].
3 Experiment Planning
3.1 Specimen
The experimental specimen adopts the hard bottom construction method, and
construction process is: structure ! cement mortar layer ! waterproof
layer ! adhesive layer ! tile. The main variables are due to the structure watering
and the hollow proportion of the adhesive layer. The specimen planning is shown in
Fig. 2.
1004 C.-T. Liao and P.-J. Wu
Legend
3.2 Instrument
The specimen was placed on the Kaohsiung University campus and the tile shear
test was conducted from December 13, 2017 to December 19, 2017. Pull-off testing
was conducted from April 9, 2018 to April 15, 2018.
3.2.2 Instrument
The tile shear tester is a hand-cranked hoist with a maximum reading scale of
1000 kgf. The rate is 5 s/turn, and the shear strength value is kgf. The CR-10X data
recorder is used to record the load cell tension data for a certain period of time. The
diagram of shear tester is shown in Fig. 3.
The pull-off tester used a type tensioner (R-30000ND) manufactured by Sanko
Techno CO., LTD. The instrument is hand-operated, with a maximum pulling force
of 30 KN, a minimum judgment scale of 0.1 N, a speed of 3 s/turn, and a machine
value of N/mm2. The domestic values are expressed in kgf/cm2, so the test data of
this study is expressed as kgf/cm2 after conversion. The diagram of the pull-off
testing machine is shown in Fig. 4.
A Study on the Vertical Pull-off Testing ... 1005
The number of tiles for each strength test are three pieces. There are eight areas for
each shear and pull-off testing: without watering the structure and have the adhesive
hollow proportion of 75, 50, 25 and 0%; watering the structure and have the
adhesive hollow proportion of 75, 50, 25 and 0%. The shear strength of hollow
proportion is shown in Fig. 5 and Table 1. The pull-off strength of hollow pro-
portion is shown in Fig. 6 and Table 2.
Comparing the shear test and pull-off test ratios for the “watering the structure”
work area:
(1) The shear testing strength of the 75% hollow proportion is 0.57, the pull-off
testing strength is 1.33 kgf/cm2, and the ratio is 0.43.
(2) The shear testing strength of the 50% hollow proportion is 0.63, the pull-off
testing strength is 5.39 kgf/cm2, and the ratio is 0.12.
1006 C.-T. Liao and P.-J. Wu
1.5 1.62
1.18
1
0.91
0.72
0.77
0.5 0.63
0.57
0
75% 50% 25% 0%
HOLLOW PROPORTION
Fig. 5 Trend graph of shear strength (kgf/cm2) for “watering the structure” and “without watering
the structure”
12 11.94
10
8
5.39 5.67
6
6.22
4
1.64
2
1.33 1.90
0
75% 50% 25% 0%
HOLLOW PROPORTION
Fig. 6 Trend graph of pull-off strength (kgf/cm2) for “watering the structure” and “without
watering the structure”
(3) The shear testing strength of the 25% hollow proportion is 0.77, the pull-off
testing strength is 5.67 kgf/cm2, and the ratio is 0.14.
(4) The shear testing strength of the 0% hollow proportion is 1.62, the pull-off
testing strength is 12.77 (kgf/cm2). The ratio is 0.13 (Table 1and 2).
Table 3 show the photograph of the current situation of the tile after the shear
test with the structural sprinkler. For the 0% hollow-rate tile of the adhesive layer, it
was found that the damage interface of the specimen was 30% at the cement mortar
layer and 70% at the adhesive layer. The destruction interface of the structure
watering water is located on the cement mortar layer, and the adhesive layer is
completely fell off.
75%
Back of the tile
75%
Specimen
surface
50%
Back of the tile
50%
Specimen
surface
25%
Back of the tile
25%
Specimen
surface
0%
Back of the tile
0%
Specimen
surface
A Study on the Vertical Pull-off Testing ... 1009
14 1.00
12.77 0.90
12
0.80
ADHESIVE STRENGTH
Fig. 7 Comparison chart between shear testing and pull-off testing of ``watering the structure''
work area
5 Conclusions
The shear testing data of the structure without watering, the strength of the adhesive
layer from hollow proportion 75% to 0% is 0.72:0.91:1.18:1.75 kgf/cm2. The ratio
of 0% and 25% hollow proportion is about 3:2. While watering the structure, the
strength of the adhesive layer from 75% to 0% is 0.57, 0.63, 0.77, 1.62 kgf/cm2.
The ratio of 0% to 25% hollow proportion is about 2: 1. Adhesive strength could be
regarded as reducing to half of the original when the tile adhesive layer appears
25% hollow. Shear testing to the pull-off testing is about 1:8 on the ratio of 0%
hollow. The shear testing requires only a small force to cause damage. (Table 4
and Fig. 7)
It is recommended to pay attention when detecting the phenomenon of hollow
on the outer wall tiles, because the adhesion strength has also been affected. In
addition, compared with the current testing strength standard, the construction
program of the Public Works Committee standardizes 10 kgf/cm2, but the shear
force requires only a small external force to cause damage.
1010 C.-T. Liao and P.-J. Wu
Acknowledgements The authors are grateful that this study was funded by the Taiwanese
government’s Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST 105-2221-E-390-002).
References
1. Public Works Bureau of the Kaohsiung City Government (2014) Achievements promoting
building public safety for 103 years in Kaohsiung City
2. Lee C-Y (2013) The study of cement based tile adhesive’s performance with different type of
the tiles. A thesis from the National Taipei University of Technology
3. Lu T-J (2011) Discussion on the causes of the falling exterior wall of high-rise residential
buildings and the countermeasures. Architecture and Building Research Institute, Ministry of
the Interior, ROC
4. Wei-Hsiu H (2016) A study on the influence of under and waterproof layer of tile installation of
high-rise building exterior wall on adhesion strength. A thesis from the National University of
Kaohsiung
5. Public Construction Commission Specification No. 09310 (2011) Taiwanese government’s
Public Construction Commission
The Roles of Mechanics Courses
in Student-Centered Civil Engineering
Education
Q. Y. Xing
Abstract With the development of big data, AI and other modern technologies, the
traditional engineering education, which centers on disciplines and pays attention to
the systematic imparting of disciplinary knowledge, has been facing severe chal-
lenges in recent years. It has been gradually transforming into the new engineering
education, which focuses on students and pays attention to the cultivation of stu-
dents’ learning mode and thinking capability. Firstly, the newest and most advanced
research work and contributions in engineering education were studied and intro-
duced, which shows the total background of the present study. Secondly, the
mechanical curriculum in universities’ civil engineering education of China is
described. And then the roles that mechanics courses playing in cultivation of
students’ thinking abilities are discussed and two detailed reform activities in
practical teaching process are proposed, which aims at improving the students’
ability of creative thinking.
Following the new round of industrial revolution and transformation all over the
world, new science and technology generates and new requirements have been
proposed for engineers [6]. As a result, engineering education is facing severe
Q. Y. Xing (&)
Department of Civil Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084,
People’s Republic of China
e-mail: xingqy@tsinghua.edu.cn
challenges, and many countries have initiated their own reform and innovation on
engineering education.
In 2016, a study considering the global state of the art in engineering under-
graduate education was undertaken in Massachusetts Institute of Technology
(MIT) in the USA for the project named New Engineering Education
Transformation (NEET) [5], and the final study report “The global state-of-the-art
in engineering education” was published in 2018 [3]. It has been another great
contribution to reform of engineering education of the USA ever since the
University of Michigan proposed their study report in the Millennium Project in
2008, which is named “Engineering for a changing world: a roadmap to the future
of engineering practice, research and education” [2]. In this MIT’s research report,
it is presented that the study was structured in two phases, both of which used
one-to-one interviews as the primary evidence gathering tool, and in Phase 2, case
studies of four selected institutions as being ‘emerging leaders’ in engineering
education were implemented, including Singapore University of Technology and
Design (Singapore), University College London (UK), Charles Sturt University
(Australia) and TU Delft (Netherlands). The report mainly addressed five key
questions outlined below:
1. Which institutions are considered to be the ‘current leaders’ in engineering
education?
2. Which institutions are considered to be ‘emerging leaders’ in engineering
education?
3. What features distinguish the ‘current leaders’ and ‘emerging leaders’ in
engineering education?
4. What key challenges are likely to constrain the progress of engineering edu-
cation in the future?
5. What is the future direction for the engineering education sector?
Among the replies to these questions, what should be noticed is the close
concern to the student-centered learning all through the report. It is proposed that
there is still a range of barriers that continue to constrain positive change in
engineering education worldwide, among which the most important one is the
challenge of delivering student-centered active learning to large student cohorts. As
the anticipated trends for the future direction of engineering education, it is
emergent for a new generation of leaders in engineering education to deliver
integrated student-centered curricula at scale. According to the study, a move
towards socially-relevant and outward-facing engineering curricula has taken place.
The student’s choice and flexibility has been one focus of such curricula. However,
many of the engineering programs at the ‘current leader’ institutions are often
“bolt-on activities” and are isolated within the curriculum, which means that much
of the benefit of these experiences remains unexploited because they are uncon-
nected with other curricular components and students are not encouraged to reflect
upon and apply what they have learned in other areas of the degree program. In this
case, distinctive, student-centered curricular experiences within an integrated and
The Roles of Mechanics Courses in Student-Centered Civil Engineering Education 1013
During the past years in the 21st century, China has already realized the challenging
and opportunity in the engineering education sector and has carried out a series of
reform and innovation on concepts and system of engineering education. In 2006,
the pilot program of engineering education certification was launched, which started
the arduous exploration of joining the organization of the international union of
Washington Accord for ten years. In 2008, the pilot working group was established
to propel CDIO (Conceive, Design, Implement and Operate) mode based on the
newest international concepts of engineering education at that time. In 2010, the
Excellent Engineer Education and Cultivation Project was implemented, and
comprehensive reform of personnel cultivation mode for engineering education was
started. In June 2016, China formally joined the Washington Accord, meanwhile,
the Emerging Engineering Education (EEE) project was launched [7]. In this EEE
project in China, three concepts to guarantee the quality were proposed: insisting on
promoting the student-centered learning mode, insisting on outcome-based educa-
tion, and insisting on continuous improvements. Student-centered learning was
emphasized in the systemic reform of engineering education in China as well.
Based on such a background at home and abroad, Tsinghua University has
started to implement its own education reform and innovation for nearly a decade.
In 2014, The 40 articles of Tsinghua University Education was issued on com-
prehensively deepening education and teaching reform. The ‘trinity’ education
mode of value shaping, ability training and knowledge transmission was presented,
which is a further development for the famous four pillars of education “Learning
to know, learning to do, learning to live together and learning to be”, which was
firstly proposed in 2011 by French economist and politician Jacques Delors, the
former President of the European Commission, and then deeply reviewed in the
report entitled Learning: The treasure within by UNESCO (United Nations
Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization) [1]. As a result, a number of
projects for reform of curriculum and coursed have been carried out, with
student-centered active learning being furthest emphasized even than before. Many
remarkable reforms in engineering education have been made in Tsinghua
University, e.g. the International Centre for Engineering Education (ICEE) under
the auspices of UNESCO was set up in Tsinghua in 2016.
1014 Q. Y. Xing
Within such a strong wave of reforms in science, technology and education, the
discipline reconstruction and instruction innovation have already been started and
implemented step-by-step in Department of Civil Engineering in Tsinghua. In the
view of pedagogy, construction of innovative education model involves three
levels, i.e. construction of the overall socially environmental system, of the total
engineering education system, and of the instruction system [4]. As a common
teacher within this reform wave, the author of the present paper lays on the level of
instruction system to discuss the roles of mechanics courses playing in civil
engineering education with the new concept mentioned above. In the following
sections, the situation of mechanics courses from the year 2012 to 2019 in the
author’s department was introduced; the role that mechanics courses played in
engineering thinking ability training was analyzed, with the corresponding reform
activities in teaching being described. However, what is the possible future direc-
tion for mechanics courses in civil engineering education? Indeed, it is raising the
question more than giving the conclusion that the present paper aims at.
In the last twenty years of the last century, an integrated mechanical curriculum has
been established for undergraduate education of civil engineering in universities of
China, which involves the so-called fundamental mechanics courses and the
so-called specialized mechanics courses. The fundamental mechanics courses
mainly refer to theoretical mechanics, material mechanics and engineering
mechanics, while the specialized mechanics courses refer to the ones specialized for
the major of civil engineering, such as structural mechanics, elasticity, fluid
mechanics, etc. This curriculum has been used until the present. Taking the dis-
cipline of civil engineering in Tsinghua University as the example, from 2012 to
2019, such a curriculum includes totally six required mechanics courses for
undergraduates, the details of which are listed in Table 1. The situation of other
universities containing civil engineering discipline is mainly the same as that.
The Roles of Mechanics Courses in Student-Centered Civil Engineering Education 1015
In the last 1980s, the Ministry of Education of China set up the higher education
teaching steering committees for each main discipline of universities, which are
composed of experts invited to conduct the research, consultation, guidance,
evaluation and service on higher education teaching work under the leadership of
the Ministry of Education. Such a teaching steering committee has developed
distinctive syllabuses for the undergraduate programs of the corresponding major.
For example, the teaching steering committee of fundamental courses of mechanics
has developed the teaching syllabus for structural mechanics course. This syllabus
contains three main parts: the nature and tasks of the course, basic contents and
requirements of the course, and ability training requirements, which fully embodies
the objectives, concepts and designs of engineering education at that time. It can be
seen that besides of learning to know, learning to do has already been noticed and
considered in this syllabus. It defines the four requirements of ability training for
students as follows:
1. Analytical ability: have the preliminary ability to select the simplified compu-
tation model for commonly used skeletal structures, and can choose the
appropriate calculation method for the specific problems.
2. Calculation ability: be capable of calculating various statically determinate and
statically indeterminate structures, and be able to use structural calculation
program initially.
3. Judgment ability: have the ability to check the computation results and make
qualitative judgment on the rationality of internal force distributions.
4. Self-learning ability: have the ability of self-learning and reading the reference
books of structural mechanics.
All these abilities are pointing at ability of computation and calculation, con-
sequently, it is obviously insufficient for the present engineering education.
However, this syllabus has been used even at present. It is really emergent for
1016 Q. Y. Xing
As a matter of fact, the knowledge system of mechanics is a fertile soil for logical
thinking. Logical thinking is the foundation of critical thinking and creative
thinking. Creative thinking is different from critical thinking, but they interact with
each other. In the teaching process of mechanics, the author explores and practices
the cultivation of students’ creative thinking under the traditional knowledge sys-
tem, and introduces the relevant design based on heuristic teaching principles and
methods in practice.
Heuristic teaching is a kind of classical teaching method and thought. Socrates is
the forerunner of heuristic teaching, and the German educator, Friedrich Adolf
Wilhelm Diesterweg (1790–1866) said, “a bad teacher gives truth, and a good
teacher makes people discover truth”. It has been pointed out in the classic textbook
of pedagogy that the enlightening principle is one of the basic principles of
teaching. The traditional inspiration means to inspire students to learn and master
scientific knowledge independently so as to solve problems and complete home-
work independently, while the newest concept of heuristic is to inspire students to
develop the habit and value of critical and creative thinking, and train their thinking
ability, which is the core of this section.
The Roles of Mechanics Courses in Student-Centered Civil Engineering Education 1017
As one of the four basic principles of logic, the law of sufficient reason states that
everything has a sufficient reason for being. A good logical and critical thinker must
get to the bottom of the matter, make a painstaking investigation, and know exactly
what it is, until he understands the nature of the truth. The deep exploration of the
origin enables us to essentially control the influence and development of real things,
and the process is often exciting, which greatly encourages curiosity. Therefore,
tracing back to the origin and searching to the bottom has become one of the
important characteristics of creative thinking, and one of the effective measures to
cultivate creative thinking as well. Structural mechanics teaching has already
noticed it before, but confined to trace conditions or assumptions of a method or
theorem, no further exploration to touch the nature. As a result, students only
recited the knowledge items, and the focus of teaching was set only on learning to
known.
A small reform can deepen the effect of learning to known to that of learning to
do even learning to be. For example, not the assumption but the development of the
method or theorem is traced and investigated in the field of science history. It is
well-known that bending moment is one of the most important concepts in struc-
tural mechanics. Traditional knowledge instruction tries to clearly present the
computational methods of bending moment and then to let students rationally judge
the computational result is right or wrong. This is the training of ‘how’, i.e. letting
students know how to compute or calculate. In fact, when tracing to the origins, one
cannot help asking a more important question—what is bending moment. There
exist a series of classical hypotheses of solid mechanics in the answer to this
question, e.g. plane cross-section hypothesis, Hooke’s law, small deformation
hypothesis, etc. There also exist a number of scientists and physicists behind these
hypotheses and their breakthrough contributions through creative ideas together
with many mistakes and failures. We can find the answer to the ‘what’ question
there. In teaching practice of Tsinghua, the teacher designed the clues and situations
of the questions, inspired doubts by asking questions, and led students to ask and
trace by themselves. The students are likely to be guided by the teacher to expe-
rience a complex process of creative thinking. From the perspective of knowledge
transmission, students integrate the knowledge of theoretical mechanics, material
mechanics, structural mechanics and elasticity, and thoroughly understand the
concept of bending moment. From the perspective of ability cultivation, students’
ability of logical thinking and critical thinking are directly trained. Inspired by this
creative process, students are stimulated to explore the source power of science, and
to some extent, curiosity is reshaped, creative thinking is cultivated, and the goal of
value shaping is realized.
1018 Q. Y. Xing
Observation is one of the most important activities of thinking and one of the most
effective ways to cultivate creative thinking, and the world of real life contains an
infinite number of scientific implications. The meticulous observation and sensi-
tivity to life and things are important characteristics of the great creative and
outstanding people. In the training program of civil engineering, structural
mechanics can be traced back to fundamental mechanics and physics, and applied
to structural design, high-rise building computation and analysis, bridge engi-
neering, earthquake engineering and other scientific and technological practice
fields. The important creative thinking in science and technology is innovation in
practice. Structural innovation comes from a lot of engineering practice, and at the
same time, it is used to meet the requirements of engineering practice corre-
spondingly—the functional requirements brought by social and life demands.
Therefore, through the multi-dimensional heuristic teaching design of small
teaching aids, daily-life examples and big projects in the course of structural
mechanics, students are trained to be observant people, to draw innovative sources
from life and practice, so as to lay the foundation of creative thinking.
For example, droplight reveals the concept of geometrically unstable system for
which it is stable under a certain kind of load while unstable under other kinds of
loads. Stapler can give a clear model of hinge between two bars under different
coupling conditions, and a series of toy balls can simulate the vibration system of
multi-degrees of freedom, etc. Students are also encouraged to discover these small
examples or models themselves, and the curiosity of science and technology are
explored through such a simple way. Of course, in civil engineering, so many
outstanding structural projects—in ancient times and modern times, around China
and abroad—they can directly stimulate the students’ interest in the discipline and
give them encouragement in self-direction of creative thinking. Small practical
examples and great practical projects are not independent but dependent with each
other. The relationship between them should be clearly revealed by teachers, which
gives another way of creative thinking and innovation. This can be summarized
with a famous Chinese idiom “with a small see big”, which means that from the first
small beginnings one can see how things will develop.
4 Conclusions
The present paper studied the current situation and severs challenges which civil
engineering education are facing in the reform and innovation of science and
technology of new generation. The recent projects and worldwide research about
engineering education are reported. After that, the mechanical curriculum in uni-
versities of China for civil engineering education is introduced. The roles of
mechanics courses playing in cultivation of students’ thinking ability are then
The Roles of Mechanics Courses in Student-Centered Civil Engineering Education 1019
Acknowledgements This work is part of the project supported by Graduate Education Innovation
Grants, Tsinghua University.
References
1. Delors J (2013) The treasure within: Learning to know, learning to do, learning to live together
and learning to be. What is the value of that treasure 15 years after its publication? Int J Rev
Educ 59:319–330
2. Duderstadt JJ (2008) Engineering for a changing world: a road map to the future of engineering
practice, research and education. Holistic Engineering Education, pp 17–35
3. Graham Ruth (2018). The global state-of-the-art in engineering education. http://neet.mit.edu/
wp-content/uploads/2018/03/MIT_NEET_GlobalStateEngineeringEducation2018.pdf
4. Kong HB, Ye M et al (2014) Research on the innovative models of engineering education from
an international perspective. Zhejiang University Press, Hangzhou
5. Pan HS, Peng QG (2019) Engineering education discipline construction: drawing lessons from
American universities. J High Eng Educ Res 3:180–186 (in Chinese)
6. Schwab K (2016) The fourth industrial revolution. World Economic Forum, Geneva
7. Wu AH, Yang QB, Hao J (2019) The innovation and reform of higher education under the
leadership of emerging engineering education. J High Eng Educ Res 1(1–7):61 (in Chinese)
Investigation on Dynamic Bond-Slip
Behaviour Between Steel Reinforcement
and Concrete Under Various
Loading Rate
1 Introduction
In reinforced concrete structures, it is the reliable bond between reinforcing bars and
concrete that enables the two types of materials to work in a compatible way. As
early as in 1939, Menzel [1] made a systematic study of the influencing factors on
the bond behaviour of deformed steel bars by pull-out tests. In 1987, Shima, Chou
and Okamura [2] observed that the bond stress decreased rapidly after the yielding
of embedded reinforcement, mainly due to the shearing-off of concrete keys
between steel lug and stress redistribution at the interface of the steel bar and the
surrounding concrete. Extensive experimental and analytical studies on bond
behaviour have been carried out under static or low loading rates conditions in the
past few decades. However, when it comes to high loading rates, limited data are
available at present.
Mindess [3] demonstrated that concrete is a strain rate sensitive material. Since
the bond strength depends to a great extent upon the strength of the concrete
surrounding the rebar, the loading rate should have a considerable effect on the
bond behaviour. Mindess and Banthia [4] observed that the enhanced bond stress
limited the deformations to a small area, leading to ductile fracture of the steel.
This paper describes an experimental study on the bond strength of steel rein-
forcement embedded in conventional concrete and subjected to different loading
rates. The bond strength and failure mode were quantified through experimental
tests. The experimental results can be used for dynamic analysis of embedded steel
reinforcement.
2 Experimental Programme
Figure 1 shows the geometry of specimens in the pull-out tests. A steel rein-
forcement with 12 mm diameter was placed in the centre. At each end of the
reinforcement, a PVC sleeve was used to prevent the formation of failure cone.
Additional steel reinforcement was also provided to avoid concrete splitting failure.
5D
5D
150
70 80 80 70
40 110 110 40
Investigation on Dynamic Bond-Slip Behaviour … 1023
Figure 2 and Fig. 3 show the setup for pull-out tests. The applied load was applied
to the reinforcement by using a hydraulic actuator. To measure the slip of steel
reinforcement relative to the concrete, two steel plates were fixed to the rein-
forcement and their displacements were captured by using two linear variable
displacement transducers. In addition to the applied load and the associated slip, the
strains along the embedment length were also measured during testing. Steel
reinforcement was grooved along the longitudinal ribs, as shown in Fig. 4, and
three strain gauges were mounted in the groove at a spacing of 45 mm. Note that
SG-1 was near the loaded end.
Prior to pull-out tests, the material properties of concrete and steel reinforcement
were determined through tension and compression tests. Three concrete cubes of
150 mm dimensions were tested in compression. The average value of the mea-
sured cube strength was 65.6 MPa. For the steel reinforcement, the average yield
and ultimate strengths were 491.1 MPa and 630.1 MPa, respectively.
plate
LVDT
concrete block
test bottom
plate
LVDT
3 Experimental Results
Strain gauges were mounted in the grooves to measure the strain distribution along
the embedment length. Figure 7 shows the variation of steel strains with the slip at
the loaded end. In the figure, the numerals of the legend represent the distance from
the loaded end. At the initial stage, the measured strain increased rapidly. When the
reinforcement yielded at the loaded end, the variation of strain along the embed-
ment length exhibited a plateau stage. The yield strain of LS12 was 2176 le, and
was increased to 2552 le for FS12.
Figure 8 shows the distribution of strain along the embedment length. The
numerals of the legend denote the ratio of the calculated tensile stress at the loaded
end to the static yield stress of the reinforcement. It can be observed that steel
strains increased approximately linearly from the free end to the loaded end.
Comparisons between LS12 and FS12 suggest that by increasing the loading rate,
the measured strain near the free end can be reduced.
At the elastic stage of steel reinforcement, the bond stress along the embedment
length of steel reinforcement could be calculated from the measured strains by
Investigation on Dynamic Bond-Slip Behaviour … 1027
assuming a constant bond stress distribution between two adjacent strain gauges
(see Eq. (1)).
An Es De
s= ð1Þ
Ce Dl
where s is the bond stress, An is the net cross-sectional area of grooved rein-
forcement, Es is the elastic modulus of reinforcement, De is the difference of strains
measured at two adjacent sections, Ce is the effective circumference of grooved
reinforcement, and Dl is the spacing of strain gauges.
Figure 9 shows the bond stress distribution along the embedment length. It is
apparent that when the loading rate was 0.1 mm/s, the bond stress varied more
uniformly along the rebar length, as shown in Fig. 9(a). By increasing the loading
rate to 100 mm/s, the bond stress near the loaded end was significantly increased,
1028 X. J. Huang et al.
and the bond stress decreased from the loaded end to the free end, as shown in
Fig. 9(b). This phenomenon was induced by the limited propagation of radial
cracks around the steel reinforcement and the increased yield and ultimate strengths
of steel reinforcement at a higher loading rate. Moreover, the average bond stress
along the embedment length was also increased, as listed in Table 3.
4 Conclusions
This paper studies the bond behaviour of embedded steel reinforcement under
different loading rates. The following conclusions could be drawn from this study:
1. With 60 mm embedment length, all specimens achieved their ultimate strengths
under different loading rates. The specimens exhibited fracture of the embedded
Investigation on Dynamic Bond-Slip Behaviour … 1029
steel reinforcement near the loaded end, and the failure mode was independent
of the loading rate.
2. By increasing the loading rate, the yield and ultimate strengths of steel rein-
forcement were increased, but the slip associated with the yield strength was
reduced. Calculated results showed that the bond stress near the loaded end was
increased and decreased near the free end, and the average bond stress increases
with the increase of loading rate.
Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support provided by the
National Natural Science Foundation (No.51608068), Fundamental and Frontier Research Project
of Chongqing (No. cstc2016jcyjA0450) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central
Universities (No. 2019CDXYTM0032).
References
1. Menzel CA (1939) Some factors influencing results of pull-out bond tests. ACI J Proc
35(6):517–542
2. Shima H, Chou LL, Okamura H (1987) Micro and macro model for bond in reinforced
concrete. J Fac Eng 39:133–194
3. Mindess S (1989) Effects of dynamic loading on bond. ACI Commit 446: State Art Rep
Section 4.2.3(5):51–63
4. Mindess S, Banthia NP, Ritter A, Skalny JP (1986) Crack development in cementitious
materials under impact loading and cement-based composites: strain rate effects on fracture.
ACI J 64:217–223
Experimental Study on Seismic
Behaviors of a New Type
of Transferring Joint with Top Steel
Column Embedded to the Panel Zone
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Program
Four specimens are made and tested to study the seismic performance of the
embedded steel column-reinforced concrete (RC) column transferring joint, which
is proposed by inserting the steel column into the concrete of the panel zone. Details
of the specimens are shown in Fig. 1.
Axial compression ratio and the height of upper-panel zone concrete are selected
as the key investigating parameters of the study. The axial compression ratio is for
the steel column section. The upper-panel zone concrete refers to the concrete
inside the steel column right above the panel zone. The test parameters of each
specimen are shown in Table 1.
The test setup used for the experimental program is shown in Fig. 2. RC columns
are pin-connected at their bottom end to represent inflection points at the midspan
of the member length. The pinned connection is achieved by using a
three-dimensional spherical plain bearing. Axial compression load is applied to the
top end of the steel column using a hydraulic actuator. RC beams are supported by
Experimental Study on Seismic Behaviors ... 1033
16 14
500
16 14
440
A-A
16 14
8 60
500
16 14
440
B-B
32 16
8 60
600
C-C
(a) JD-1 and JD-2
16 14
500
16 14
440
A-A
16 14
8 60
500
16 14
440
B-B
32 16
8 60
600
C-C
(b) JD-3 and JD-4
two sliding bearings at their end to represent inflection points at the midspan of the
member. The sliding bearing is a vertical support device specially made for the
experiment, which only constrains the vertical displacement of the beam ends.
Horizontal cyclic loading (force or displacement) is applied at the top of the steel
column using a horizontal hydraulic actuator.
The loading process for specimen testing is composed of two steps. First, the
axial compression load is applied and is kept constant for the rest of the process.
Second, the horizontal load is applied to the top of the steel column. The loading
history of horizontal load consists of a force control stage followed by a dis-
placement control stage as shown in Fig. 3.
Experimental Study on Seismic Behaviors ... 1035
Displacement(D/D y)
240 3
160 2
Load(kN)
80 1
0 0
-80 -1
-160 -2
-240 -3
-320 -4
-400 -5
-480 -6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Number of cycles
The steel used for the specimens is type Q345B. The longitudinal reinforcement is
type HRB400 while the stirrup is type HPB300. For each plate thickness or rein-
forcement diameter, three coupons were tested in tension. The concrete used for the
specimens is C40 and six 150-mm cubic blocks are tested for compression strength.
The mean values of yield strength (fy) and ultimate strength (fu) of steels together
with the average cubic compressive strength fcu are listed in Table 2.
The typical damage patterns of the specimens are shown in Fig. 4, including:
(a) concrete spall at panel zone; (b) deformation of longitudinal bars of the beam;
(c) huge vertical crack at the connecting part of beam and panel zone; (d) concrete
1036 J.-Y. Gao et al.
crushing and spalling at beam end; (e) column base damage. The damages suffered
by each specimen are listed in Table 3.
The load versus column top displacement curves are shown in Fig. 5 for all the
specimens and the key results are summarized in Table 4. Specifically, Py and Dy
denote the yielding load and corresponding displacement of the steel column top,
respectively. Pu denotes the maximum load, Du denotes the corresponding column
top displacement. Pult corresponds to the ultimate load at the end of the test while
Dult denotes the corresponding displacement.
For all the specimens, the load versus displacement curve is nearly symmetrical
and full hysteresis loops are observed. The curves have obvious yield point together
with platform segment and demonstrate good ductility and energy dissipation
ability.
As we can see from the curves of all specimens, JD-3 has the narrowest curve
while JD-2 has the plumpest one. It can be easily noticed that specimens tested
under a large compression ratio (JD-2 and JD-4) have a plumper curve than those
tested under a small compression ratio (JD-1 and JD-3), implying axial compression
ratio can effectively influence the seismic performance of joints. The curves of
specimens with upper-panel zone concrete do not have an obvious difference with
curves of specimens without it, indicating the influence of the upper-panel zone
might be very small.
A joint is considered tough and stable under cyclic loading if the loss of stiffness is
negligible at large inelastic deformations. Figure 6 shows the degradation of joint
stiffness with the load step, where the x-axis represents the ratio of the peak dis-
placement in each load step to the yielding displacement for each specimen. The
stiffness is defined as the ratio of the average peak load to the average peak
displacement in each load step.
The energy dissipation capacity of the joints is typically evaluated by the
equivalent viscous damping coefficient, ne , defined as follows:
1 SABCD
ne ¼ : ð1Þ
2p SOBE þ SODF
where SABCD is the area of loop ABCD, while SOBE and SODF are the shadowed
areas within the triangles OBE and ODF, respectively, as shown in Fig. 7.
The calculated equivalent viscous damping coefficients is shown in Fig. 8. The
results show that for all the specimens, with the loading process goes on, the
equivalent viscous damping coefficient decreases rapidly at the beginning, and then
F A D
O C E
it increases until the end of the experiment. The damping coefficient of JD-2 and
JD-4 is obviously larger than that of JD-1 and JD-3, indicating that the axial
compression ratio can significantly improve the energy dissipation capacity of the
joints. The damping coefficient of specimen JD-2 is larger than that of JD-4 only
after yielding, and the difference is not large, showing that the effect of upper-panel
zone concrete on energy dissipation capacity is little. The average equivalent vis-
cous damping coefficients of all specimens at the final stage is 0.450, which is far
above that of reinforced concrete joints and close to that of steel reinforced concrete
joints.
1040 J.-Y. Gao et al.
The skeleton curves of the specimens are shown in Fig. 9. The skeleton curve can
be divided into four stages, that is, the elastic stage, the elastic-plastic stage, the
yielding and hardening stage, and the descending stage.
The factors influencing the seismic performance of transferring joints can be
figured out by comparing the skeleton curves of two different specimens and are
discussed as followed. The value of index used for comparison (load, stiffness,
energy dissipation capacity, etc.) is the average of positive loading and negative
loading.
Specimens JD-2 and JD-4 is loaded under a large axial compression ratio while
specimens JD-1 and JD-3 is loaded under a small axial compression ratio. The
effect of the axial compression ratio is shown in Fig. 10 by comparing the skeleton
curves of load versus displacement of the two specimens.
For specimens JD-1 and JD-2, the stiffness of JD-2 is about 50% larger than that
of JD-1 at the elastic stage. In the following stages, the stiffness of JD-2 is about
31% larger and the peak load is about 27% larger. Additionally, the energy dissi-
pation capacity of specimen JD-2 is almost 21% larger than that of JD-1.
For specimens JD-3 and JD-4, the stiffness of JD-4 is about 165% larger than
that of JD-3 at the elastic stage, which is really a significant difference. In the
following stages, the stiffness of JD-4 is about 105% larger and the peak load is
about 41% larger. Additionally, the energy dissipation capacity of specimen JD-4 is
almost 106% larger than that of JD-3.
Specimens JD-1 and JD-2 have concrete inside the steel column upon the panel
zone, while JD-3 and JD-4 don’t. The effect of the upper-panel zone concrete is
shown in Fig. 11.
For specimens JD-1 and JD-3, the stiffness of JD-1 is about 92% larger than that
of JD-3 at the elastic stage. In the following stages, the stiffness of JD-1 is about
1042 J.-Y. Gao et al.
49% larger and the peak load is about 14% larger. Additionally, the energy dissi-
pation capacity of specimen JD-1 is almost 55% larger than that of JD-3.
For specimens JD-2 and JD-4, the skeleton curves almost coincide with each
other and the stiffness, strength and energy dissipation capacity are almost the same.
Specimen JD-2 performs a little bit better, but the difference is relatively small,
which is less than 10%. The difference of the peak load is especially small, which is
only 2%. This indicates that the existence of the upper-panel zone concrete has
almost no influence on the seismic performance of specimens loaded under a large
axial compression ratio. For specimens loaded under small axial compression ratio,
it has an obvious effect on stiffness and energy dissipation capacity, while its effect
on strength is not large.
5 Conclusions
1. The failure patterns of the specimens include plastic hinge failure at the beam
ends, concrete crushing failure at the bottom of the RC column, and shear failure
at the panel zone.
2. Increasing the axial compression ratio can effectively improve the stiffness and
bearing capacity of the joint, as well as the energy dissipation capacity.
3. The existence of upper-panel zone concrete is of very little effect under large
axial compression ratio. While under small axial compression ratio, it can sig-
nificantly increase the stiffness and energy dissipation capacity of the joint, and
increase the bearing capacity to some extent.
References
1. Lu XL (2007) Seismic theory and application to complex high-rise buildings. Science Press,
Beijing (in Chinese)
2. Kimuta E, Konno T (1975) Earthquake effects on steel tower for microwave antennas atop
building. Review of the Electrical Communication Laboratories (Tokyo)
3. Xu J, Zhu QD, Shen T (2018) Integrated analysis of vertical-combined structure of steel and
reinforced concrete under horizontal force. Eng J Wuhan Univ 51(S1):106–110 (in Chinese)
4. Lu XL, Liu F, Lu WS (2009) Shaking table model test on Pudong International Airport
Terminal 2 building in Shanghai. J Earthq Eng Eng Vibr 29(03):22–31 (in Chinese)
5. Lu Z, Li JZ, Zhou Y (2018) Shaking table test and numerical simulation on a vertical hybrid
structure under seismic excitation. Struct Design Tall Spec Build 27:e1497
6. Yue JG (2018) Mechanical behaviour analysis of Y-type S-SRC column in a large-space
vertical hybrid structure using local fine numerical simulation method. Adv Mater Sci Eng
Buckling Analysis of Nanoplates
Incorporating Surface Stress Effects
1 Introduction
plate theory, the eigenvalue equation of the nanoplates is derived and solved by the
p-Ritz method. The buckling behaviours of the nanoplates with certain crystallo-
graphic directions, both with and without considering the surface stresses, are
presented and discussed in details.
2 Mathematical Modelling
Based on the first order shear deformation plate theory [7], the displacement fields
are assumed to be
where X0 denotes the undeformed midplane of the plate, and the stress resultants
Nxx , Nyy , Mxx , Myy , Qyz , Qxz , Nxy , Mxy are defined as
8 9 8 9 8 9 8 9
> = Z h2 >
< Nxx > < rxx >
= > < rxx >
= Z h2 >
< Mxx > =
Qxz
Z h
2
rxz
Nyy ¼ ryy dz Myy ¼ ryy zdz ¼K dz
>
: >
; h2 >
: >
; >
: >
; h2 >
: >
; Qyz h2 ryz
Nxy rxy Mxy rxy
ð5Þ
in which K is the shear correction factor and assumed to take the value of 5/6.
In the current formulation, the surface region is considered as zero mathematical
thickness. The virtual strain energy in the surface dU s is
8 9
>
> 2E s @u0 @du0
þ h2 s @/x @d/x
E >
>
>
> xx @x @x 2 xx @x @x >
>
>
> >
>
>
> @v @dv @/y @d/y >
>
> þ 2Eyy @y @y þ 2 Eyy @y @y
>
s 0 0 h2
s >
>
Z > < 2 >
3=
dU s ¼ @u 0 @du 0 @u 0 @dv 0 @v 0 @du 0 @v 0 @dv 0 h 2
dX0
X0 >
>
> 6 2Gs þ þ þ þ Gs 7 >
>
>
>
> 6 @y @y @y @x @x @y @x @x 2 7>>
>
> þ6 7>>
>
> 4 @/ @d/ @/ @d/ @/ @d/ @/ @d/ 5 >
>
>
> x x
þ x y
þ
y x
þ
y y >
>
: ;
@y @y @y @x @x @y @x @x
ð6Þ
s s
in which Exx , Eyy , Gs are the surface Young’s moduli and shear modulus, respec-
tively. The work done by residual surface stress dV 0s is
Buckling Analysis of Nanoplates Incorporating Surface Stress Effects 1047
2 3
@w0 @dw0 @w0 @dw0
Z 6 sxx þ syy 2
0 0
2
6 @x @x @y @y 7 7
dV 0s ¼ 6 7dX0 : ð7Þ
X0 4 @w 0 @dw 0 @w 0 @dw 0 5
þ s0xy 2 þ2
@x @y @y @x
dU b þ dU s þ dV 0s þ dV 0b ¼ 0 ð9Þ
The p-Ritz method [5] is employed to derive the eigenvalue equation for the
nanoplates from Eq. (9). Three types of boundary conditions are considered in this
study, i.e. (1) Pinned (P) end with u0 = 0, v0 = 0, w0 = 0, /x = 0,/y = 0;
(2) Hard-Clamped (HC) with u0 = 0,v0 = 0, w0 = 0, /x = 0, /y = 0, dw0 =dx = 0,
dw0 =dy = 0; and (3) Free (F) end with no displacement constraints, respectively.
The p-Ritz basic functions are used to impose the boundary conditions.
Consider three different materials: Platinum (Pt), Gold (Au), and Silver (Ag). Their
material properties are listed in Table 1. The surface stress and surface elasticity
values are listed in Table 2, s011 ¼ s022 , and s012 ¼ 0 [8].
A convergence study was carried out and it was found that the degree set of
complete polynomial used for the trial function ps 7 could furnish reasonably
accurate buckling results. We chose ps ¼ 7 for subsquent calculations.
Table 2 Surface stresses and surface elasticities of Platinum, Gold and Silver
Surface Pt Au Ag
(100) (111) (100) (111) (100) (111)
s011 ¼ s022 (eV/Å2) 0.1426 0.1585 0.0877 0.1025 0.0556 0.0405
Es (eV/Å2) −0.4694 −0.6203 −0.2265 −0.4124 0.0760 −0.0870
Comparison studies were first carried out against existing results in literature
[12] of plate buckling without the surface effect. The buckling load factor of a
CNTRC plate with four edges simply supported is kp ¼ Ncr b =ðEm h3 Þ. The plate is
0 2
Case studies were carried out for buckling analysis of square nanoplates with
surface stresses. The nondimensional buckling load factor is kp ¼ Ncr
0 2
L =D110 ,
b 3
E11 h
where D110 ¼ .
½ ð b12 mb21 Þ
12 1m
Figure 2 shows the uniaxial and biaxial compressive buckling load factors of a
square Au (100) nanoplate with simply supported edges (P-P-P-P). The plate
length-to-thickness ratio L/h = 50. The solid lines are buckling curves with surface
stress while the dashed lines are the ones without considering the surface stress.
Figure 2 shows that in general the existence of surface stresses increases the
buckling load factor for the Au plate under both uniaxial and biaxial compressions.
As the plate becomes thinner, the influences of surface stress are more pronounced.
For the plate with the thickness of 30 nm, the buckling load factor with the surface
stress effect is about 2.5 times its counterpart without the surface stress effect. As
the plate becomes thicker, the difference between buckling load factors with and
without the surface stress effect decreases.
Figure 3 shows the uniaxial and biaxial buckling load factors for a simply
supported square Ag (111) nanoplate with different length-to-thickness ratios L/
h = 50, 30, 10, and thickness h = 50 nm. The results in Fig. 3 show that for thinner
plates such as plate with L/h = 50, there is a considerable increase in the buckling
load factors when surface stress is considered; estimated to be around 34%. In
contrast, there is negligible difference between the buckling load factors with and
without the surface stress effect for thicker plates with L/h = 10.
Table 4 lists the biaxial and uniaxial compressive buckling load factors of
simply supported square Pt, Au, Ag nanoplates with different surfaces of (100) and
(111). It is observed in Table 4 that the existence of surface stress enhances the
buckling capacity of the plates. However the percentage increase in the buckling
load factors depends on the materials as well as surfaces. The buckling load factor
of the Au (100) plate is increased by 37.3% while for the Ag (111) plate, the
increase is 12.3%.
Table 5 shows the uniaxial and biaxial buckling load factors of a square Au
(100) nanoplate with different boundary conditions. For the uniaxial compression
cases with F-HC-HC-HC and F-P-P-P boundary conditions, the free boundary edge
(F) is assumed to be parallel to the load direction. It can be seen in Table 5 that as
the boundary conditions become weaker, there are larger deviations between
Table 4 Biaxial and uniaxial buckling load factors of square Pt, Au, Ag nanoplates with
(100) and (111) surfaces (L/h = 30, h = 50 nm)
Pt Au Ag
Biaxial compression
(100) (111) (100) (111) (100) (111)
Without surface stress 22.785 17.351 28.811 15.844 29.927 15.325
With surface stress 28.568 21.587 39.564 20.861 36.175 17.207
Differences 25.4% 24.4% 37.3% 31.7% 20.9% 12.3%
Uniaxial compression
(100) (111) (100) (111) (100) (111)
Without surface stress 44.445 34.045 55.835 31.140 57.928 30.137
With surface stress 55.733 42.360 76.692 41.004 70.024 33.839
Differences 25.4% 24.4% 37.4% 31.7% 20.9% 12.3%
Table 5 Biaxial and uniaxial buckling load factors of a square Au (100) nanoplate with different
boundary conditions (L/h = 20, h = 50 nm)
Boundary conditions Buckling factors
Without surface stress With surface stress Differences
Biaxial compression
HC-HC-HC-HC 63.481 68.008 7.13%
F-HC-HC-HC 36.414 41.094 12.85%
P-P-P-P 29.608 34.402 16.19%
F-P-P-P 14.176 19.075 34.56%
Uniaxial compression
HC-HC-HC-HC 119.447 127.274 6.55%
F-HC-HC-HC 49.704 55.539 11.74%
P-P-P-P 59.216 68.803 16.19%
F-P-P-P 18.426 24.705 34.08%
buckling load factors with and without the effect of surface stress. For the biaxial
compression case, the buckling load factors for the plate with F-HC-HC-HC
boundaries are larger than the ones with P-P-P-P boundaries, while for the uniaxial
compression case, the trend is reversed.
4 Conclusions
Based on the first order shear deformation plate theory and the energy variational
principle, the buckling behaviours of single crystalline metallic nanoplates subject
to the influence of surface stresses are investigated. The surface stresses and surface
Buckling Analysis of Nanoplates Incorporating Surface Stress Effects 1051
elasticity for three metals were evaluated from existing molecular dynamics sim-
ulations and are incorporated into the energy formulation. Large discrepancies have
been observed for the buckling load factors with and without the surface stress
effect. For all three metals studied, the surface stresses are found to enhance the
buckling capacity of the nanoplates. Case studies indicate that as the nanoplates
become thinner or subject to weaker boundary conditions, the influence of surface
stresses becomes more significant. In addition, it is found that the percentage
increase of the buckling load factor depends on the type of material and its crys-
tallographic surfaces and directions. The buckling load factor for the square Au
(100) nanoplate increases by 37.3% while for the square Ag (111) plate with the
same dimension and support conditions, the increase is only 12.3%. It is expected
that the study presented herein may be useful when evaluating the buckling
behaviours of the structural components in next generation NEMS.
Acknowledgements This study was supported by the Australian Research Council (Grant
DP160104462). The authors are very grateful for this financial support.
References
the conventional concrete, the percentage water absorption of the RHA concrete
cured with 5% NaCl absorbs less water with increase in replacement proportions of
RHA [9]. In conclusion, calcium carbonate improves mechanical strength while fly
ash reduces water absorption.
1 Introduction
The optimum percentage of 10% of fly ash in the GFRP yield strength for all
mechanical properties [7]. The formation of chemical bonding of fly ash with the
glass fibres has been identified as the main reason for the improvement [1].
Sravani et al. [8] modified the GFRP composition by introducing Calcium
Carbonate (CaCO3) as a filler material has resulted in reducing the percentage of
water absorption. This reduction can be anticipated as the presence of glass fibres
influenced the water absorption of these composites. Three main pathways for water
absorption have been identified within the body of the composite material, i.e. the
cell wall, the lumen, weak interface adhesion and gaps between the fibres and resin
[4]. Experimentally, water absorption of GFRP with 10% CaCO3 filler is less than
GFRP without filler at 96 h, which was of about 3.7% and 5.0% respectively [8].
There have been several other research works in trying to discover materials to
lessen water absorption in various material mixes, such as the research on RHA
concrete. It was discovered that compared to the conventional concrete, the per-
centage water absorption of the RHA concrete cured with 5% NaCl absorbs less
water with increase in replacement proportions of RHA [9]. In flood environment,
GFRP for structures should have low water absorption level as possible as it will
degrade the mechanical properties of GFRP by 27.9% [5].
Therefore, the main objective of this research is to investigate the mechanical
properties and water absorption properties of the composite material consists of
GFRP material with varying percentages (0, 5 and 10 wt%) of CaCO3 and fly ash
fillers. The mechanical properties including the ultimate tensile strength, com-
pressive strength, flexural strength, and water absorption were investigated and
discussed.
2 Materials
Woven glass fabric which is a strong and lightweight material is adopted in this
research. The raw material is not expensive and much less brittle than carbon fibre.
Woven glass fabrics are available and have significant range in the market. It is also
available in other forms such as chopped strand mat and powder. The different type
of form offers the engineer some options that satisfy the design need.
polyester resin. MEKP produce heat in the polyester resin mixture to harden the
resin. Increasing the MEKP content will accelerate the hardening rate of the resin.
3 Methodology
The preparation of the GFRP composite involved mixing different weight per-
centages of calcium carbonate and fly ash with polyester resin and hardener.
Polyester resin and MEKP hardener (2% mass of polyester) were mixed and stirred
together for both specimen types, i.e. specimens with and without filler materials.
The whole preparation process was done manually, using a hand lay-up technique
in a 200 mm 200 mm 4 mm size mild steel mould. Before the wet mixture
being placed in the mould, a releasing agent (Polyvinyl Alcohol) was coated onto
the inner base and walls of mould. An initial thin layer of the composite mixture is
placed into the mould, and smoothen with the help of a brush. A layer
200 200 mm woven fibreglass fabric is then placed on top of the first layer of
wet mixture. After placement, the fabric is submerged with more pour of the
mixture to a certain level below the top of the mould. Further, another layer of the
woven fibreglass fabric is placed into the mould, after which, the remaining spaces
above the second layer of glass fibre fabric is then filled up with the mixture until
the mould is filled to its brink. The whole process thus completes the preparation of
the 4 mm thick GFRP specimens. Mild steel roller was used to roll the mixture to
ensure uniform distribution within the mixture to avoid air bubbles entrapment. The
composition weight percentages of the composite materials used in the research are
shown in Table 1. The samples are cured to harden at room temperature for 24 h.
After that, the main sample was cut into different sizes of smaller samples as per the
ISO standards for different type of tests (tensile, compression, flexural and water
absorption tests).
Polymer-Based Composite Materials ... 1057
The tensile, compressive and flexural strengths tests were conducted using com-
puterised Universal Testing Machine with 100 kN capacity, as shown in Fig. 1.
Tensile test samples were prepared according to ISO 527 standard. Tensile tests
were conducted at a speed of 10 mm/min to obtain tensile strength. Compression
tests were performed using the same machine at the speed of 1 mm/min according
to ISO 604 standard to obtain compression strength. Flexural test samples were
prepared by ISO 178, and were also conducted in the same machine at the speed of
2 mm/min to obtain three-point flexural strength. All the mechanical strengths are
measured in MPa unit.
Study of moisture absorption on the GFRP specimens was done by ISO 62 standard
for moisture absorption of plastic. Three samples with dimensions of 76 mm
length 25 mm width 4 mm thickness were prepared and tested (see Fig. 2).
The initial weights of samples were taken, and then they were dipped in distilled
water. The weights of the samples were taken after 2, 8, and 24 h. At the mentioned
times, the samples were taken out of the distilled water, and the moisture on the
surfaces was removed by using tissue paper. The weight was then measured to the
nearest 0.01 g after 1 min of removal of the moisture on the surface of samples. The
water absorption was calculated by weight difference. The percentage of water
absorbed is obtained by the weight that was gained in the percentage to the initial
weight of the samples.
Figure 3 presents the tensile strength values for the three different mixtures (A, B
and C) that have varied percentages of fillers in GFRP composites. The results
1058 E. N. Saharuddin et al.
a) Tensile test
showed that the sample B with a composition of 10% CaCO3 and 10% fly ash has
the highest ultimate tensile strength. This mix proportion is the optimum mix to
gain the highest strength. The tensile strength is lower when the CaCO3 filler is
added below or above the 10% level, as shown by the results from samples A (5%
CaCO3) and C (15% CaCO3), respectively. The decrease in tensile strength of the
composite as the CaCO3 filler increases is may be due to the presence of pores in
between the matrix, CaCO3 and fly ash filler particles that weaken the adhesion.
Polymer-Based Composite Materials ... 1059
tested samples
160
172.8
120
133.4
113.1
80
40
0
A
B
Samples C
The results of the compressive strength tests are shown in Fig. 4 with different
content of fillers in the GFRP composites. From this figure, it is observed that the
increment weight percentage of CaCO3 filler with lesser fly ash (sample C) has
resulted in higher ultimate compressive strength compared to other samples (A and
B). This behaviour is perhaps due to two reasons that affect the compressive
strength of GFRP:
• CaCO3 filler has a good contribution to compressive strength.
• There is a uniform distribution of resin mixture in all the samples.
169.2
139.3
120
106.3
80
40
0
A
B
Samples C
tested samples
300
327.3
293.2
299.4
250
200
150
100
50
0
A
B
C
Samples
as the CaCO3 filler content increases with decreasing fly ash content (sample C).
The highest flexural strength was for sample C at 327.3 MPa with CaCO3 and fly
ash weight percentage of 15% and 5% respectively. The reasons for this increment
in the flexural strengths could be due to the following points:
• Interfacial bonding between matrix and both fillers is high.
• The distribution of the resin mixture was uniformly distributed on glass fabrics.
0.8
0.74
0.6
0.66
0.56
0.52
2 hours
0.45
0.4
0.37
8 hours
0.33
0.2
24 hours
0.22
0.2
0
A
B
C
Samples
content of fly ash experienced highest water absorption. Three reasons made the
water reside in composite which are the cell wall, the lumen, weak interface
adhesion and gap between fibre and resin [4].
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support for the research
provided by Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) under the project code No. DIP-2017-015.
1062 E. N. Saharuddin et al.
References
1 Introduction
This section presents two different approaches, namely the experimental method
and the hybrid method, in measuring the fracture resistance from the single-edge
notched tension, SE(T) specimen, for which a testing standard to measure the
fracture resistance curve, or J-R curve has yet to evolve.
A Fracture Mechanics Approach ... 1065
This study extends the single specimen η approach, originally proposed by Rice
et al. [23], to measure the fracture resistance in SE(T) specimens. The measurement
of J-R curve consists the measurement of the J-integral, which represents the energy
release rate, and the measurement of the crack extension, Da. The energy release
rate derives from the η approach,
ð1 v2 ÞKI2 gUpl
J¼ þ ð1Þ
E Bb
where Upl denotes the plastic strain energy equal to the area under the load versus
the plastic deformation, B and b are the thickness and remaining ligament of the
specimen, respectively. The first term in Eq. (1) quantifies the linear-elastic con-
tribution to the total energy release rate and derives from the stress-intensity factor,
KI, elastic modulus, E, and the Poisson’s ratio, v.
The experimental procedure introduces partial unloading events to measure the
compliance of the specimen, defined by the ratio of the crack-mouth opening
displacement (CMOD) and the load. The crack size of the specimen derives from
the compliance (C) and crack depth ratio (a/W) relationship determined from
linear-elastic analyses,
DCMOD a 3 a 2 a
C¼ ¼ 0:0391 0:0289 þ 0:0197 0:00234 ð2Þ
DP W W W
Figure 1 illustrates the test setup for the SE(T) specimens and material true
stress-true strain curve for the S355 steel material. Figure 2 presents the fracture
resistance curve, or J-R curve measured from three duplicated SE(T) specimens.
Liu et al. [14] have further demonstrated that the J-R curve from the η approach
coincides with that predicted from a node release method.
Fig. 1 Test setup for the SE(T) specimens and true stress-true strain curve of the material
1066 X. Qian and T. Liu
300
B = 10.5 mm
200 a / W = 0.5
SE(T)_01
100 SE(T)_02
SE(T)_03
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4
Δ a (mm)
The hybrid method originates from the multiple specimen approach to measure
J values proposed by Begley and Landes [4]. Subsequent researchers have extended
this approach to standard fracture specimens [22]. The energy release rate,
J integral, derives from the change of potential energy with respect to the increasing
crack size,
1 dU
J¼ ð3Þ
B da
where the potential energy U refers to the area under the load-displacement curve,
while the change in crack size equals the difference in crack size a among different
fracture specimens.
The fundamental idea behind the hybrid method, as illustrated in Fig. 3, remains
the same as that of the multiple specimen approach, by retaining one experimental
specimen with an extending crack and replacing the rest of the test specimens by
finite element models, each with a different non-growing crack. Figure 3a illustrates
the load-deformation curve for a single test specimen with an extending crack,
together with the load-deformation curves computed from different FE models. At
each intersection point between the test load-deformation curve and numerical
load-deformation curve, the crack size in the test specimen assumes the same size as
that in the numerical model. The strain energy in the test specimen is subsequently
calculated at each intersection point, with the corresponding crack size, as indicated
in Fig. 3b. The slope of each curve in Fig. 3b represents the term dU/da in Eq. (3).
Figure 4 demonstrates the close agreement in the J-R curves measured from the η
approach and the hybrid method for the aluminium SE(T) specimen reported by Liu
et al. [15].
A Fracture Mechanics Approach ... 1067
Fig. 3 a Load-deformation curves for the SE(T) specimens from the test and FE specimens; b the
corresponding changes in strain energy with respect to crack size
80
40
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Δa (mm)
This study extends the above approaches to measure the fracture resistance curve
from circular hollow section (CHS) members with circumferential welds. The
welded pipe considered in this study has an outer diameter of 244.5 mm and a wall
thickness of 12 mm, and is made from S355 steels. The specimen fabrication
introduces a machined notch of 85 mm in length and 7 mm in depth near the weld
toe of the pipe. The testing procedure consists of two stages: 1) fatigue pre-cracking
to generate a sharp crack front ahead of the machined surface notch; 2) monotonic
loading with partial unloading cycles to measure the fracture resistance and the
compliance based crack size. Figure 5 illustrates the test setup on a
machine-notched pipe with a length of 2000 mm.
The welded pipe contains a curved surface crack near the weld toe, which entails
varying J-integral values along the crack front. The experimental procedure, based
on Eq. (1), however, leads to a single average J value (Jav) along the crack front,
which follows,
1068 X. Qian and T. Liu
Load
Butt welds
Pipe specimen
Machined notch
Pin Roller
LVDT COD Gauge
P
n
B i Ji
Jav ¼ i¼1 ð4Þ
BT
where a/t denotes the crack depth over the thickness ratio.
Figure 6a compares the fracture resistance curve estimated from the above
procedure at different crack-front locations, denoted by the crack-front angle, /, in
Fig. 6a. The fracture resistance measured at different crack-front locations remains
similar to that measured from the SE(T) specimen at a small crack extension level.
Figure 6b demonstrates that the hybrid method to measure the fracture resistance
curves remains applicable to welded CHS members with circumferential welds.
A Fracture Mechanics Approach ... 1069
Fig. 6 Comparison of the J-R curves in the CHS member: a at different crack front locations and
that from the SE(T) specimen; b using hybrid method and η approach
Acrack
Pu;cracked ¼ Pu 1 ð6Þ
Lw t0
where Lwt0 represents the area along the weld line [20]. At the end of the ductile
tearing, the joint often experiences an unstable fracture failure. This study imple-
ments a conservative approach to represent this unstable fracture failure in the
welded joint, by forcing an unstable failure at a crack extension corresponding to
the maximum crack extension allowed in the ASTM E1820 [3] for the material
fracture specimens. Figure 7b validates the proposed load-deformation relationship
shown in Fig. 7a against a CHS X-joint fabricated from S690 steels reported by
Qian et al. [21]. Figure 7b also includes the test setup and dimensions of the CHS
X-joint specimen.
(a)
5944 P (kN) (b)
600
1524
356ODx12.7WT
400
5123
300
200
Test
100 Rigid
1524
Proposed
0
All members168OD 4.5WT 0 0.3 0.6 0.9 1.2 1.5
Fig. 8 a Configuration of the large-scale K-frame reported by Bolt [6]; b validation of the fracture
modified representation in a frame analysis
in the experiment. The proposed fracture modified joint formulation, on the other
hand, predicts successfully the softening of the frame response caused by the ductile
tearing in the K-joint and the subsequent unstable frame failure caused by the
unstable fracture in the K-joint.
5 Conclusions
This paper presents the fracture mechanics based approach: a) to measure the
fracture resistance (J-R curve) from the material specimens; b) to estimate the J-
R curve from welded CHS members; and c) to develop a load-deformation rela-
tionship incorporating the effect of ductile tearing and the unstable fracture failure.
Compared to the reported experiments for the material fracture specimens and the
welded CHS members, the J-R curve estimation demonstrates sufficient accuracies.
The fracture-modified load-deformation relationship resembles closely the experi-
mentally measured load-displacement curve for a high-strength steel CHS X-joint
with an unstable fracture failure. Incorporating the fracture-modified
load-deformation relationship in the analysis of a single bay K frame leads to
close agreement with the experimental observation in both the failure mechanisms
and the load-displacement responses.
1072 X. Qian and T. Liu
References
1. Ahmed A, Qian X (2015) A toughness based deformation limit for fatigue-cracked X-joints
under in-plane bending. Marine Struct 42:33–52
2. Architectural Institute of Japan (AIJ) (1995) Preliminary Reconnaissance Report of the 1995
Hyogoken-Nanbu Earthquake, English Edition
3. ASTM E-1820 (2018) American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) International.
ASTM E1820. Standard test method for measurement of fracture toughness
4. Begley JA, Landes JD (1972) The J-integral as a fracture criterion. ASTM STP 514,
American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, PA, pp 1–20
5. Bertero VV, Anderson JC, Krawinkler H (1994) Performance of Steel Building Structures
During the Northridge Earthquake. College of Engineering, U. C. Berkeley
6. Bolt H (1994) Results from large scale ultimate strength tests of K-braced jacket frame
structures. In: Offshore technology conference, Houston, Texas, USA
7. Boyd GM (1970) Brittle fracture in steel structures. Butterworth, London
8. Choo YS, Qian X, Wardenier J (2006) Effects of boundary conditions and chord stresses on
static strength of thick-walled CHS K-joints. J Constr Steel Res 62(4):303–412
9. Gu B, Qian X, Ahmed A (2016) A toughness based deformation limit for X- and K-joints
under brace axial tension. Front Struct Civ Eng 10:345–362
10. Gullerud AS, Koppenhoefer KC, Roy A, RoyChowdhury S, Walters M, Bichon B,
Cochran K, Dodds Jr RH (2004) WARP3D release 15 manual. Civil Engineering, Report
No. UIUCENG-95-2012, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
11. Jia LJ, Fujie W, Ikai T, Yoshida W, Ge H (2019) Dependency of mesh size and loading
history on crack propagation energy of cyclic ductile fracture model. Eng Fract Mech
215:117–137
12. Lancaster J (1996) Engineering Catastrophes, Causes and Effects of Major Accidents.
Abington Publishing
13. Liao FF, Wang W, Chen YY (2015) Ductile fracture prediction for welded steel connections
under monotonic loading based on micromechanical fracture criteria. Eng Struct 94:16–28
14. Liu TY, Qian X, Wang W, Chen YY (2019) A node release approach to estimate J-R curve
for single-edge-notched tension specimen under reversed loading. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater
Struct 42:1595–1608
15. Liu T, Qian X, Wang W, Chen YY (2019) Fracture resistance curve for single edge notched
tension specimens under low cycle actions. Eng Fract Mech 211:47–60
16. Ma XX, Wang W, Chen YY, Qian X (2015) Simulation of ductile fracture in welded tubular
connections using a simplified damage plasticity model considering the effect of stress
triaxiality and Lode angle. J Constr Steel Res 114:217–236
17. Maranian P (2010) Reducing brittle and fatigue failures in steel structures, ASCE, Virginia
18. Parool N, Qian X, Koh CG (2017) An η-compliance method to estimate the J-Da curve for
pipes with a circumferential surface crack. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct 40:1624–1639
19. Parool N, Qian X, Koh CG (2018) A modified hybrid method to estimate fracture resistance
curve for pipes with a circumferential surface crack. Eng Fract Mech 188:1–19
20. Qian X (2013) Failure assessment diagrams for circular hollow section X- and K-joints. Int J
Pressure Vessels Piping 104:43–56
21. Qian X, Li Y, Ou Z (2013) Ductile tearing assessment of high-strength steel X-joints under
in-plane bending. Eng Failure Anal 28:176–191
22. Qian X, Yang W (2011) A hybrid approach to determine mode I and mixed-mode I and II
fracture resistance. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct 34:305–320
23. Rice J, Paris PC, Merkle JG (1973) Some further results of J-integral analysis and estimates.
ASTM STP 536:231–245
24. Seah TT, Qian X (2018) An interaction factor to estimate the over-constraining effect in plates
with co-planar cracks. Eng Fract Mech 199:13–28
A Fracture Mechanics Approach ... 1073
25. Wang X, Wu J, Qian X (2011) Crack driving force and ultimate strength of thick-walled CHS
X-joints. In: Proceedings of the annual international offshore and polar engineering
conference & exhibition (ISOPE), 19–24 June, Maui, Hawaii, USA
26. Xiang P, Jia LJ, Ke K, Chen YY, Ge H (2017) Ductile cracking simulation of uncracked high
strength steel using an energy approach. J Constr Steel Res 138:117–130
27. Zhang Y, Qian X (2013) An eta-approach to evaluate the elastic-plastic energy release rate for
weld-toe cracks in tubular K-joints. Eng Struct 51:88–98
Comparison of Numerical
and Semi-analytical Dynamic Results
for Inclined Beam Under Moving Load
Keywords Inclined beam Moving load Finite element method Fourier series
Dynamic response
1 Introduction
Research on moving load problem has attracted considerable attention from the
1990s century onwards. A quick search in the Web of Science database reveals that
there are only 4 papers written on moving load problem in the year 1990. This
number jumps to 52 in the year 1995 and to 322 in the year 2018. The total number
of papers on moving load problem is over 4000 since 1990.
The most basic moving load problem is a horizontal beam subjected to a moving
point load (Krýlov 1905). This problem has since been extended to moving mass [8],
and then to moving sprung mass [2] and more recently to very complicated multiple
loads that simulate train wheels over a rail. Following the advent of computers,
researchers were able to adopt more realistic vehicle-bridge interaction
(VBI) models in their analysis [3, 13]. Recent research studies on moving load
problem are focusing on health monitoring. Due to its simplicity and mobility, we
can monitor the bridge structure by installing the sensor on a passing vehicle [4, 12].
All aforementioned studies dealt with vertical moving load or loads on hori-
zontal beams or bridges or soil foundation. We now find many inclined structures
constructed over uneven terrains and side of mountains. Wu [9] developed the
moving mass element method to study the dynamic response of an inclined beam
with allowances for the effects of inertial mass, centrifugal force and Coriolis force.
Mamandi et al. [6] presented a formulation that coupled the longitudinal and
transverse vibrations of an inclined beam under a moving load to determine the
nonlinear dynamic response. They extended their work by using the Timoshenko
beam model to allow for the effect of transverse shear deformation [5].
In this paper, we present two methods for solving the transverse motion of an
inclined Eule-Bernoulli under a moving vertical point load. Such a problem finds
applications in inclined bridges, pipelines, crane rails, roller coasters and slides.
Unlike earlier studies on moving load on inclined beams, Yang and Wang [10]
considered the effect of the compressive axial component of the moving load on the
beam stiffness. For solution, they discretized the beam by using finite element
method and employed the Newmark method to solve the equation of motion. In a
sequel study, Yang and Wang [11] revisited the problem by solving it in a
semi-analytical way. They do so by making use of the Fourier sine series to
describe the vibration mode shape of simply supported beam and using the
Runge-Kutta method to do the time integration for the dynamic response of the
inclined beam. In this paper, we wish to highlight the differences between these two
methods.
2 Mathematical Formulation
where EI denotes the flexural rigidity, m the mass per unit length, w the transverse
deflection with respect to the inclined beam axis, dðx vtÞ the Dirac delta function
and H ðx vtÞ the Heaviside step function. The boundary conditions for the simply
supported ends are given by
ð0; tÞ ¼ 0; ðL; tÞ ¼ 0; EI @@xw2 ð0; tÞ ¼ 0; EI @@xw2 ðL; tÞ ¼ 0 ð2Þ
2 2
w w
where L is the length of the inclined beam (see Fig. 1). The initial conditions are
given by
@w
ðx; 0Þ ¼ 0;
w @t ð
x ; 0Þ ¼0 ð3Þ
vp2
S¼ ð5Þ
1L
x
pffiffiffi
1 ¼ pL22
where v is the constant speed of the moving load and x EI
m is the fundamental
free vibration frequency of a simply supported beam [1].
3 Numerical Method
The numerical method is based on the finite element method. First, we divide the
space domain X 2 ½0; 1 of the problem into a set of N equal sub-intervals
Xe ¼ ðxe ; xe þ 1 Þ, so that we can isolate a typical element Xe and construct the weak
form of Eq. (4) over the element.
In dealing with time-dependent problems, we choose the decoupled formulation
where time and spatial variations are assumed to be separable. Thus, the approxi-
mation form is
X
n
wðx; tÞ weh ðx; tÞ ¼ wej ðtÞwej ð xÞ ð6Þ
j¼1
where wej is an interpolant of wðx; tÞ through nodes j and j + 1 and wej is the
interpolation function which we adopt Hermite Cubic Interpolation functions in
here.
Z xe þ 1
r ðwÞgð xÞdx ¼ 0 ð8Þ
xe
Equation (8) holds for any continuous function gð xÞ, for all x in ð0; 1Þ. By
expanding Eq. (8), and exchanging differentiation form w to g by using integration
by parts for the first two terms, one obtains
Z
@2w @2g
xe þ 1
@w @g 2@ w
2
^ @w
þ k sin hH ð x t Þ þ S g k cos h þ sin h gd ð x t Þ dx
xe @x2 @x2 @x @x @t2 @x
Q ^ 2 g @g Q
^ 3 gðxe þ 1 Þ Q
^ 1 gðxe Þ Q ^ 4 g @g ¼ 0
@x @x
xe xe þ 1
ð9Þ
=@x ¼
where the secondary variables follow the sign convention (h ¼ @ w
@w=@x)
h
i h
i
^ 1 ¼ k sin hH ðx tÞ @w þ @ @ 2 w2 ;
Q ^2 ¼
Q
@2w
@x @x @x @x2
h
i xe h 2 i
xe
ð10Þ
^ @w @ @2 w ^ @ w
Q3 ¼ k sin hH ðx tÞ @x þ @x @x2 ; Q4 ¼ @x2
xe þ 1 xe þ 1
With sufficiently small time steps, it is now possible to obtain accurate solutions
even for those problems inseparable in time and space. However, the finite element
solution that we obtain in the end is continuous in space but not in time. The
approximation form is given by
X
n n
e
X
wðx; ts Þ ¼ wej ðts Þwej ð xÞ ¼ wsj wej ð xÞ ðs ¼ 1; 2; . . .Þ ð11Þ
j¼1 j¼1
e
where wsj is the value of wðx; tÞ at dimensionless time unit t ¼ ts and node j of
the element Xe .
By using Galerkin’s method, we substitute g ¼ wi ð xÞ and Eq. (6) into Eq. (9),
we obtain the i th algebraic equation of the system:
" #
X
n
@ 2 e
wj
kij1 þ kij2 wj þ Mij 2 Fi ¼ 0 ð12Þ
j¼1
@t
½Kfwg þ ½Mf€
wg ¼ fFg ð13Þ
where
½K ¼ ½K 1 þ ½K 2 ð14Þ
R xe þ 1 Rx @we @we
Mij ¼ S2 wej wei dxS Kij1 ¼ xee þ 1 k sin hH ðx tÞ @xj @xi dx
x
R xee þ 1 @ 2 wej @ 2 wei Rx ð15Þ
Kij2 ¼ xe @x2 @x2 dx Fi ¼ xee þ 1 k cos hd ðx tÞwei dx þ c Qi
4 Semi-analytical Method
In view of the boundary conditions given in Eq. (2), and in order to ensure the
smoothness of the solution to be C 2 continuity throughout the space domain
1 x 1, we shall assume the spatial part of the deflection wðx; tÞ to be
approximated by the Fourier sine series, i.e.
X
Nf
wðx; tÞ ¼ qn ðtÞ sinðnpxÞ ð16Þ
n¼1
where Nf is the total number of Fourier terms and qn ðtÞ the generalized coordinate
in time.
First, we substitute Eq. (16) into Eq. (4) and multiply both sides of equation
with sinðmpx
L Þ for m ¼ 1; 2; ; Nf . By integrating both sides of the equation with
respect to x with the integration limits x ¼ 0 to x ¼ L, we obtain
Comparison of Numerical and Semi-Analytical Dynamic Results … 1081
P
Nf R1
qn ðtÞðnpÞ4 0 sinðnpxÞ sinðmpxÞdx
n¼1
P
Nf R vt
k sin h qn ðtÞðnpÞ2 0 sinðnpxÞ sinðmpxÞdx
n¼1
ð17Þ
P @ 2 qn ðtÞ R 1
Nf
þ S2 @t2 0 sinðnpxÞ sinðmpxÞdx
n¼1
P
Nf
¼ k cos h sinðmpvtÞ þ k sin h qn ðtÞðnpÞ cosðnpvtÞ sinðmpvtÞ
n¼1
R1
Noting that the integral 0 sinðnpxÞ sinðmpxÞdx equals to zero when n ¼ m and
equals to 12 when n 6¼ m, Eq. (17) may be expressed in the following matrix form
where
8 9 2 3 8 9
> q1 ðtÞ > p4 =2 0 0 > sinðptÞ >
>
> >
> 6 7 >
> >
>
< q2 ðtÞ >
> = 6 0 ð2pÞ =2 4
0 7 < sinð2ptÞ >
> =
6 7
fqg ¼ . ; ½Ke ¼ 6 . .. .. 7 ; fE g ¼ . :
>
> . >
> 6 .. 7 >
> . >
>
> . >
>
: >
;
4 .
.
4
5 >
>
:
. >
>
;
qNf ðtÞ Nf 1 0 0 Nf p =2 sinðNf ptÞ Nf 1
Nf Nf
ð19Þ
2 3 2 3
ðG1 Þ11 0 0 0 ðG2 Þ12 ðG2 Þ1Nf
6 7 6 ðG Þ ðG2 Þ2Nf 7
6 0 ðG1 Þ22 0 7 6 2 21 0 7
6 7 6 7
½KG ¼ 6 .. .. .. 7 þ 6 .. .. .. 7 ;
6 . . . 7 6 . . . 7
4 5 4 5
0 0 ð G 1 Þ Nf Nf ð G 2 Þ Nf 1 ðG2 ÞNf 2 0
Nf Nf Nf Nf
ð20Þ
ðnpÞ2 sinð2ntÞ
ðG1 Þn;n ¼ tþ ; ð21Þ
2 2np
ðnpÞðmpÞ sinððn mÞptÞ sinððn þ mÞptÞ
ðG2 Þn;m ¼ þ ð22Þ
2 ðn mÞp ðn þ mÞp
Nc
X
i1
i ¼ fqgt¼j=Nc fqgt¼j=Nc 106
i
ð23Þ
j¼0
where i indicates the iteration step and Nc is number of time collocation points. In
this study, we took the Fourier sine series up to the 5th mode which will suffice in
representing the dynamic response.
Consider a vehicle with a constant speed passing through a single span bridge with
an inclination angle h ¼ 60 with respect to the horizontal ground. The bridge is
model as a simply-supported beam of span length L ¼ 25 m and it is subjected to a
vertical moving load which models a moving vehicle without the inertial effect. The
following properties are adopted: modulus of elasticity E ¼ 2:92 GPa, moment of
inertia I ¼ 2:88 m4, mass per unit length m ¼ 2351 kg/m, moving load P ¼ 50 kN
and the speed of the moving load v ¼ 100 km/hr. The non-dimensional quantities
are: the force parameter k ¼ 0:0037 and the speed parameter S ¼ 0:3672.
Figure 1 shows the dynamic deflection responses of the inclined beam obtained
from the two aforementioned methods. The results match perfectly but the
semi-analytical method requires significantly more computational effort (about 6
times more in computer running time). It can be seen from Fig. 2 that the dynamic
velocity responses did not match as well as the deflection responses. The velocity
response obtained from the semi-analytical method shows small oscillations due to
the inclusion of higher modes of vibration in the Fourier sine series (Fig. 3).
Consider the moving load problem with force parameter k ¼ 1:5, speed parameter
S ¼ 0:002 and beam inclination angle h ¼ 60 . In order to see the non-stationary
dynamic response more clearly, we examine the transition of the exciting fre-
quency. Unlike moving load on a horizontal beam, the first exciting frequency of
the beam gradually becomes lower as the load moves up. Recognizing the fre-
pffiffi
quency is related to the stiffness by xn ¼ 2p1 mk , the compressive axial load com-
ponent degrades the stiffness of the beam, and this leads to a lower dominant
frequency in the dynamic system.
In the numerical method, we extract the transition of the first exciting frequency
in Fig. 4 by applying the Short-Time Fourier transform (STFT) on the midspan
velocity. Noting that there exists a tradeoff between the frequency resolution and
transition time of the signal, it is likely to capture the trend instead of the magnitude
over time.
The advantage of the semi-analytical method is that one can observe the
dynamic characteristics of the inclined beam clearly. Consider the free vibration
problem (i.e. without the forcing function in the right of Eq. (18)), the exciting
frequencies may be expressed in a matrix form
2 2
X ¼ 2 ð½Ke k½KG Þ ð24Þ
S
By focusing on the first principal diagonal term in the matrix X2 , we can
extract the first exciting frequency of the inclined beam and it is given by
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
p sinð2ptÞ
X1 ¼ p k sin h t þ
2 : ð25Þ
S 2p
Figure 5 shows the variation of the first exciting frequency with respect to the
moving load position according to Eq. (25). Such a closed form solution given by
Eq. (29) shows clearly the effects of the speed parameter S, force parameter k and
the angle of inclination h on the exciting frequency which would not be possible
when one uses the numerical method for solution.
6 Conclusions
By comparing the numerical method and the semi-analytical method for solving the
moving load problem on a simply supported inclined beam, results from both
methods are in good agreement. However, the numerical method is easier to handle
complicated multiple moving loads and it is more computational efficient. On the
other hand, the semi-analytical method that makes use of Fourier sine series for the
vibration mode shapes allow the analyst to obtain the exciting frequencies in a
closed form solution that reveal clearly the influences of the various parameters on
the exciting frequencies. The semi-analytical method is certainly useful to verify the
solutions of the numerical method for a simple moving load problem before using
the numerical method to solve more complex moving load problems.
Comparison of Numerical and Semi-Analytical Dynamic Results … 1085
References
1 Introduction
The majority of the world’s most efficient transportation network – railway – runs
on ballasted tracks. However, the deformation of tracks, primarily influenced by the
substructure, including the ballast layer [7], accounts for a large chunk of track
maintenance costs. Since the present technologies available to the railway industry
are inefficient in identifying damage in the ballast layer across the transverse section
of a track segment, developing a non-destructive test (NDT) methodology for
damage detection is therefore very necessary. The resilient behavior of ballast
generally depends on the loading stress path, degree of compaction, and stiffness
amongst other factors, and the permanent settlement of ballast is a function of the
maximal stress in the ballast [9]. The strain-hardening property of ballast, which
results from the complexities in the ballast compositions, lead to a non-linear
stress-strain relationship and influences the strength parameters listed above.
The usage of vibration data and structural model updating is popular in structural
health monitoring and damage detection, usually based on the identified changes in
the stiffness of structural members. However, the effectiveness of this method is
undermined by the discrepancies between the behaviors of the model and the real
structure; and so, for better structural identification and/or damage detection pur-
pose, the important mechanics of the investigated structure must be well repre-
sented [1]. Thus, a phenomenon like the strain-hardening of ballast is indispensable
in railway track models for health assessment purposes. The ballast “damage”
concept in this work may refer to the pulverization of ballast and/or mud-pumping,
which reduced the support provided to the overlying sleeper over time. Undetected
ballast damage or insufficient track remedial practices will lead to uneven track
support, increase the chance of fault developments in other track elements, pas-
sengers’ discomfort, and vehicle derailment, amongst other problems [2]. In this
study, only the vertical settlement of the ballast is considered, as it accounts for
majority of track geometry deteriorations.
The uncertainties from the modeling errors, as well as measured data, are
explicitly addressed from a Bayesian probabilistic viewpoint. For identifying the
system model parameters and quantifying their uncertainties, the proposed
methodology estimates the marginal posterior probability density function (PDF) of
various model parameters using the time domain variation of the adaptive Markov
Chain Monte Carlo Bayesian Scheme, based on the vibration response data from an
Impact hammer test. Time-domain responses were utilized to remove the limitations
associated with modal parameters in non-linear problems. The Bayesian model
class selection tool was employed to select the choicest model from amongst the
five variations of the Ludwik model used in modeling the non-linear ballast springs.
Bayesian Modeling of Axial Strain-Hardening Behaviour … 1091
2 Methodology
In this study, the section of the ballasted railway track across a single sleeper is
considered. The track section is modelled as a Timoshenko beam on series of
non-linear springs, following the beam on elastic foundation theory (BOEF). The
rail and fastening system are considered as mass-spring elements sitting atop the
beam. 48 elements of the concrete sleeper (with nodes having 2 DOFs each) was
considered in the finite element formulation, with the mass matrix of each element
formulated using the consistent mass matrix, while the stiffness matrix of the track
system follows the common BOEF methods in the literature. The damping matrices
are constructed using the superposition of modal damping matrices method.
The stress-strain behavior of granular materials, according to Suiker and De
Borst [6], is believed to move from being fully elastic to progressive plastic
deformations under increasing stress. Indraratna et al. [3], as well as other
researchers, have demonstrated the conformation of the hardening soil model with
test results from the large-scale triaxial tests. In most works considering
non-linearity of ballast, models from triaxial tests are used (e.g., Sun et al. [7]),
often involving large number of parameters. Also, test conditions vary between
studies and are difficult to replicate on the field, resulting in inconsistent settlement
predictions. Thus, to model the general uniaxial strain-hardening behavior of the
non-linear ballast springs empirically, the Ludiwk power law [5] is re-produced in
five different forms as in Table 1 below. The incorporation of a certain pre-strain
value e0 differentiates the Swift model [8] and its modification from the other
considered models. While the pre-strain only affects the plastic region for the Swift
model, in the modified Swift model, the total strain is taken as ðe þ e0 Þ at all points.
For all considered models, only the expressions for the stress in the non-linear
plastic region are presented in Table 1. The stress in the linear region,
r ¼ Ee for e eY .
The parameters used in defining the models are: the elastic modulus E, the yield
strain eY , the yield stress rY , the hardening strength K, the pre-strain e0 , the total
axial strain e, the total axial stress r, and the strain-hardening exponent n.
The time-domain responses of the system are computed by employing an iter-
ative procedure using the constant average acceleration Newmark b technique,
which is stable for any time step Dt. The non-linear time-integration technique is
integrated into a self-developed MATLAB® finite element analysis tool.
To calibrate the developed track structural model using experimental data for better
system response predictions, the adaptive MCMC-based Bayesian model updating
algorithm developed in Lam et al. [4] is extended to allow usage of time-domain
information instead of modal-domain ones. Owing to space limitation, only the
most essential formulations are presented herein. The goal is to minimize the dis-
crepancies between the model-predicted responses €zðn; hÞ and the measured
responses b€z ðnÞ at the nth time step, as represented by the goodness-of-fit function,
J ðhÞ.
No 2
1 X b
J ð hÞ ¼ €z i ðnÞ €zi ðn; hÞ ð1Þ
No Nt i¼1
In Eq. (1), h is the uncertain model parameters vector, Nt is the number of time
steps, No is the number of observed system degree of freedoms (DOFs), while kk
is the standard Euclidean 2-norm. Minimizing the J ðhÞ function is synonymous to
maximizing the posterior PDF of the uncertain model parameters h conditional on
the set of measurement D. The posterior PDF is constructed to have a Gaussian
form according to the Bayes’ theorem as:
Nt No
pðhjD; MÞ ¼ c exp 2 J ðhÞ ð2Þ
2d
where c is the normalizing constant combining the evidence as well as the Gaussian
constant terms and d2 is the variance of the prediction error. The sampling method
utilized in this paper was developed following the simulated annealing method,
such that the sampling process is divided into several levels, using a target PDF in
each level to connect the initial prior PDF and the posterior PDF. The importance
region of this target PDF is methodically reduced by a defined geometric ratio from
one level to the other until the target PDF can approximate to the posterior PDF at
the final level.
Bayesian Modeling of Axial Strain-Hardening Behaviour … 1093
For selecting the most plausible model class Mm in the set of chosen model
classes M, the Bayesian method of using the evidence value of model classes is
adopted. To curb problems arising from numerical overflow, the logarithm of the
evidence is expressed through MCMC approximation as:
X
Nss X
Nss !
1 pðhm jD; Mm Þ
lnðpðDjMm ÞÞ lnðpðDjhm ; Mm ÞÞ ln ð3Þ
Nss l¼1 l¼1
pðhm jMm Þ
Impact hammer test was carried out on a full-scale indoor test track section under
laboratory conditions, as shown in Fig. 1(a). The ballasted track section consists of
two UIC60 rails of 60 kg/m mass per unit length on F40 mono-block prestressed
concrete sleepers at 700 mm c/c spacing, with the ballast being 350 mm in thick-
ness. Rail pads of nominal stiffness of 100MN/m are installed at the rail seats.
Ballast damage was artificially simulated under the right-end and middle of a
sleeper (2/3 of the sleeper length) by replacing the normal-sized ballast (*60 mm)
with small-sized ballast (*15 mm) as in Fig. 1(b); thus, three ballast regions are
considered in the structural model. The labor-intensiveness of the ballasting oper-
ation may lead to regions with different compaction levels. The nominal values of
the sleeper’s elastic modulus, ballast stiffness, ballast hardening strength, the
strain-hardening exponent, ballast yield strain, track system damping ratio, concrete
sleeper density, concrete Poisson’s ratio, ballast pre-strain are 38.45 GN/m2,
150 MN/m2, 70 kN/m2, 0.3, 1 10−4, 18%, 2750 kg/m3, 0.25 and 1 10−4
respectively. The vibration responses of the sleeper were obtained using 13 uniaxial
accelerometers assembled on the top surface of the sleeper along the centerline,
from right to left. The sleeper is excited at the right end with an impact force of
about 1.2 kN.
Using each of the five strain-hardening models, model updating was carried out
on the described track system model, considering each model with uncertain
parameters scaling vector defined as h ¼ fhM ; hc ; hMr ; hMl ; hKr ; hKl ; hKB1 ; hKB2 ;
hKB3 g; where hc ; hMr ; hMl ; hKr and hKl are the scaling factors for the track system’s
damping ratio, right and left rail mass, and right and left effective rail stiffness
respectively, while hKB1 ; hKB2 and hKB3 represents the ballast stiffness scaling fac-
tors for the three ballast regions, from right to left. hM is the vector of scaling factors
for the ballast model parameters in each case, as presented in Table 1.
The results of the Bayesian model class selection for the 5 models considered is
presented in Table 2. As the model with the highest log-evidence value of 1.6971
103, the Swift model is selected as the most probable model to model the ballast
spring. It is noteworthy to state that the selected model is the same as the modified
Ludwik’s model except that a pre-strain is involved.
1094 M. O. Adeagbo and H. F. Lam
(a) (b)
Fig. 1 a The indoor full-scale test panel showing sensor arrangements (OP1-13) b Simulated
ballast damage at sleeper’s mid-section
Using the final MCMC samples for all model classes, Bayesian model updating
was carried out on the model classes. The marginal posterior PDFs for all model
parameters are constructed using MCMC approximation, and Gaussian PDFs were
fitted to the distributions to estimate the most probable values (MPVs) as well as the
associated uncertainties in terms of COV%. An example of the marginal posterior
PDFs showing the spread of values (uncertainty) for the yield strain scaling factor is
presented in Fig. 2, where the mean values are taken as the MPVs. Owing to space
limitation, only the results of model updating for the yield strains and regional
ballast stiffness factors in each considered model class are presented in Table 2.
It is conspicuous that the uncertainty of the yield strain scaling factor in the
Adaptive Ludwik model is higher than for the other models. This explains the
differences in the J ðh Þ calculated for the investigated model classes. The MPV of
heY for the modified Swift model also incorporates the pre-strain, hence the higher
value. The results of model updating show that the MPVs for the stiffness of the
ballast in the three regions accurately portray the simulated damage scenario
regardless of the strain-hardening model utilized. The stiffnesses of the middle and
right ballast regions have very similar factors (with damaged ballasts), which are
lower compared to the left region stiffness factor (with good ballasts) in all con-
sidered models; thus, demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed methodology
in ballast damage detection.
After updating the classes of model using the calibrated parameter factors, the
model predicted vibration responses at the measured DOFs were re-calculated and
compared with the measured data. In Fig. 3, the responses from both the calibrated
model and experimental test are plotted at two sensor locations (OP1 and OP3), and
only small discrepancies were observed, buttressing the accuracy of the method-
ology employed.
Bayesian Modeling of Axial Strain-Hardening Behaviour … 1095
Table 2 Results of MCMC-based Bayesian model updating and model class selection
Parameter Ludwik Modified Ludwik Adaptive Ludwik Swift Modified swift
factors MPV CoV % MPV CoV % MPV CoV % MPV CoV % MPV CoV %
heY 2.2455 2.3626 2.2593 1.6683 4.4763 20.2468 2.2142 3.0618 4.0128 3.3194
hKB1 0.2826 1.9660 0.2825 1.3249 0.2622 0.8445 0.2876 2.1058 0.2908 0.8117
hKB2 0.3335 6.8126 0.3265 2.9082 0.3424 2.2922 0.3133 9.2075 0.3127 2.6133
hKB3 0.7615 4.9490 0.7446 2.7503 0.7249 2.7467 0.7781 6.5187 0.7906 2.4317
J ðh Þ 0.0103 0.0103 0.0106 0.0103 0.0103
Log-evidence 1695.60 1695.85 1675.89 1697.10 1692.40
Fig. 2 Marginal Posterior PDF for the yield strain factor, heY
Fig. 3 Model predicted and measured time domain responses at OP1 and OP3
although the Ludwik, modified Ludwik and Swift models have very similar
behavior. Also, it is observed that the only distinguishing property between the
modified Swift’s model and the three models is in the location of the yield strain.
Hence, the modified Swift curve is exactly a replica of the Ludwik, modified
Ludwik, and Swift curves with the positive strain axis moved by the pre-strain
1.8221 10−4, and the stress axis moved by the pre-stress 1.8221 10−4 kN/m2.
Since the peak stress and stress evolution plays an important role in permanent
ballast settlement, necessary cautions must be taken in selecting suitable empirical
stress-strain model for reliable long-term track monitoring studies.
In Fig. 4(b), the stress-strain curves of the ballast under elements 1, 24, and 48 of
the sleeper, which are representatives of the sleeper elements within the right,
middle, and left ballast regions, are presented for the selected model. It can be
observed that the curve of element 48 in the good ballast region has the highest
modulus compared to element 24 in the damaged region, whose modulus is a bit
higher than that of element 1 in the damaged and less-compacted ballast region.
More so, the stress-strain plots indicate that only element 1, which is near the
excitation point, experiences non-linearity; thus, affirming that the non-linearity
effects decline with the amplitude of vibration as well as the distance between the
observation and excitation points.
Bayesian Modeling of Axial Strain-Hardening Behaviour … 1097
(a)
(b)
Fig. 4 a Stress-strain plots for the ballast under element 1 using all model classes b Stress-strain
plot for the selected model at elements 1, 24 and 48 corresponding to different regions
1098 M. O. Adeagbo and H. F. Lam
4 Conclusions
Axial strain-hardening of the ballast layer in ballasted tracks was investigated using
five plastic power-law models, for better representation of the track section as a
beam on elastic foundation. For model updating purposes, an adaptive
MCMC-based scheme was utilized to tackle the uncertainties involved, while the
Bayesian model class selection was used to select the most appropriate
strain-hardening model conditional on measured system acceleration data set from
an Impact hammer test. The proposed methodology was then demonstrated to be
applicable in identifying the location and severity of simulated ballast damage in an
indoor track panel, with high accuracy. The Bayesian model class selection was
also used to select the Swift model as the most plausible non-linear model (con-
ditional on the set of measured data) to represent the dynamics of the ballast. Even
though the predicted time-domain responses at all observed DOFs are almost equal
using the various models, the effects in terms of stress and strain are quite different.
The influence of the relative size of ballast particles, as well as the degree of
compaction on the effective stiffness of the ballast layer, was also showcased and
proved to be credible criteria for assessing the health of railway ballast. More
investigations are however needed to buttress the findings from this work.
Acknowledgements The work described in this paper was supported by a grant from the
Research Grants Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China (Project
No. CityU 11242716 (GRF 9042336)).
References
1. Adeagbo MO, Lam HF (2018) A feasibility study on damage detection of nonlinear railway
ballast by measured vibration of in-situ sleeper. In: proceedings of 25th Australasian
conference on mechanics of structures and materials, Brisbane, Australia
2. Esveld C (2001) Modern railway track. MRT-Productions Press, The Netherlands
3. Indraratna B, Salim W, Rujikiatkamjorn C (2011) Advanced rail geotechnology-ballasted
track. CRC
4. Lam HF, Yang JH, Au SK (2015) Bayesian model updating of a coupled-slab system using
field test data utilizing an enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo simulation algorithm. Eng
Struct 102:144–155
5. Ludwik P (1909) Elemente der technologischen mechanik, vol 32. Julius Springer, Berlin
6. Suiker A, De Borst R (2003) A numerical model for the cyclic deterioration of railway tracks.
Int J Numer Methods Eng 57:441–470
7. Sun Q, Indraratna B, Nimbalkar S (2016) An elasto-plastic method for analysing the
deformation of the railway ballast. Proc Eng 143:954–960 Advances in Transportation
Geotechnics 3
8. Swift HW (1952) Plastic instability under plane stress. J Mech Phys Solids 1(1):1–18
9. Wang H, Markine V (2018) Modelling of the long-term behaviour of transition zones:
Prediction of track settlement. Eng Struct 156:294–304
Bayesian Learning and Model Class
Selection for Complex Dynamic Systems
Abstract A huge amount of data is available almost every second nowadays due to
fast development of technology. This provides a perfect opportunity to improve
mathematical modeling using measured data for understanding and predicting
behaviors of dynamic systems, but at the same time it also poses a challenge on
how to effectively and efficiently extract information from a large amount of data,
because it means that a large computational power is required. This paper addresses
the problem of identifying mathematical models of large-scale complex dynamic
systems in civil engineering based on measured data. This problem is especially
challenging in practice because identifying a mathematical model in
high-dimensional parameter space is time-consuming (sometimes the model is
unidentifiable), and the information contained in data is always incomplete and
there are uncertainties. The identification problem is formulated as a Bayesian
learning problem where the plausible models and the associated uncertainties are
learned by identifying the posterior PDF of the model of a dynamic system.
Bayesian model class selection is also discussed, i.e., how to select an appropriate
model class that is not too simple and not too complicated based on the same set of
data. Because conventional methods are not applicable in the current case, an
efficient Markov chain Monte Carlo method is proposed to sample from the pos-
terior PDF in a complex high-dimensional parameter space. The proposed Bayesian
method is applied on a full-scale building.
Keywords Bayesian learning Bayesian model class selection Markov chain
Monte Carlo Uncertainty quantification
J. H. Yang (&)
Department of Disaster Mitigation for Structures, College of Civil Engineering,
Tongji University, Shanghai, China
e-mail: javayang@tongji.edu.cn
H. F. Lam
Department of Architecture and Civil Engineering, City University of Hong Kong,
Hong Kong, China
e-mail: paullam@cityu.edu.hk
1 Introduction
A huge amount of data is available almost every second nowadays due to fast
development of technology. In civil engineering, buildings, bridges and tunnels are
heavily instrumented to collect valuable data in operational conditions. It is
important to process these data to gain knowledge, but it is at the same time a
challenging task, considering the large size and complexity of the data in civil
engineering. Development of theories and algorithms for processing the data will
help effectively extract information from the seemingly random data and improve
mathematical modeling of complicated structural dynamic systems. Bayesian
methods are powerful to analyze the data, because they can rigorously extract
information from data and quantify associated uncertainties that are consistent with
modeling assumptions. Bayesian methods are known to be computationally
expensive, but successfully solving the computational problem gives the premise of
rigorously processing data. A Bayesian framework [1, 3] has been developed to
provide the theory for Bayesian system identification and data analysis. In this
framework, system identification is viewed as a Bayesian inference problem. The
parameters of a mathematical model are treated as stochastic variables. Given data
and modeling assumptions, the posterior probability density function (PDF) of these
uncertain parameters will be identified. Instead of pinpointing one single model, the
relative plausibility of multiple models in the parameter space is provided and the
associated uncertainties can be quantified. When data is continuously available,
which is usually the case in civil engineering nowadays, the mathematical model of
a structural dynamic system can be continuously updated by continuously updating
the posterior PDF, so valuable information can be provided by the huge amount of
data. Depending on how mathematical modeling is done, data processing for sys-
tem identification in civil engineering usually has two categories: (1) modeling is
done for data directly (modal analysis) [10] and (2) modeling is done for structural
dynamic systems (model updating) [9]. The common problem of the two categories
is that the posterior PDF of uncertain parameters is to be identified.
However, identifying a probability distribution of uncertain parameters follow-
ing the Bayesian framework is computationally demanding, and even prohibitive
for a full-scale structure if the computation is not properly handled, because the
posterior PDF to be identified for a full-scale structure is extremely complicated.
Efficient Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithms have been developed to
tackle the computational problem [2, 5–7, 9, 11]. Samples of uncertain parameters
are efficiently drawn in the important regions (regions with high probability) of the
parameter space to approximate the complicated posterior PDF.
Another problem when using Bayesian methods to learn mathematical models
from data is how to choose a good model class. One usually tends to select com-
plicated model classes over simple ones, partly because a complicated model class
is more powerful than a simple one and the predicted responses of a complicated
model class may fit data better than a simple one. When one does this, the purpose
is to fit data as well as possible, so the most complicated model class will always be
Bayesian Learning and Model Class Selection ... 1101
chosen. However, given the amount of data, the information in the data might not
be enough to identify a very complicated model and the problem may become
unidentifiable. On the contrary, if the model class is too simple, the behaviors of a
system cannot be well captured. Following the Bayesian framework, evidences of
different model classes are calculated, so that different model classes can be
compared and the model class with the largest evidence is selected. This is Bayesian
model class selection problem [4].
Given measured data D and a model class M, the Bayesian learning problem is to
identify the posterior PDF of uncertain parameters x:
pðxÞpðDjx; M Þ
pðxjD; M Þ ¼ ð1Þ
pðDjM Þ
where pðxjD; M Þ is the posterior PDF of x conditional on D and M; pðxÞ is the prior
PDF that describes the initial knowledge on the model; pðDjx; M Þ is the likelihood
function that gives the probability of getting data given a model; and pðDjM Þ is a
normalizing constant and is also called the evidence of a model class. To let the
inference fully rely on data, a uniform PDF is chosen for the prior PDF, so the
posterior PDF is proportional to the likelihood function. If data consist of natural
frequencies and mode shapes, D ¼ ^fm ; u ^ m : m ¼ 1; 2; . . .; Nm , where ^fm and u
^m
are the measured natural frequency and mode shape of the m-th mode, respectively;
Nm is the number of modes. The likelihood function is formulated by using a
probabilistic model for the fractional prediction errors of natural frequencies and
mode shapes. The posterior PDF can then be written as [5, 9]:
1
pðxjD; M Þ ¼ cexp 2 J ðxÞ ð2Þ
2r
The posterior PDF is usually complicated and cannot be obtained in close form,
especially when full-scale structures are considered. A MCMC algorithm is used to
sample according to the posterior PDF and the samples are used to approximate the
posterior PDF. The algorithm is a multi-level MCMC algorithm. It is briefly
introduced here, and more information can be found in Yang and Lam [9] and Lam
et al. [5]. The idea is that in each level g, samples are generated using the
Metropolis-Hastings (MH) algorithm, with the target PDF pg constructed by the
form of the posterior PDF:
!
1
pg ¼ cg exp 2 J ðxÞ ð4Þ
2rg
Note that r2g controls the size of the support of pg . r2g is constructed in such a
way that r21 [ r22 [ . . . [ r2g [ . . .r2Ng , so that samples can move smoothly from a
large parameter space at the beginning to the important regions (i.e., regions with
high probability) at the end. The proposal PDF of the MH algorithm is constructed
adaptively as a weighted sum of Gaussian PDFs, with each of them centered at one
sample of the previous level. The procedures of the MCMC algorithm is summa-
rized as follows.
(1) Set up the target PDF pg at the current level g.
(2) Constructed the proposal PDF qg at level g based on the samples at the previous
level g 1:
X
Ns
qg ¼ whg1 N xhg1 ; Cg1 ð5Þ
h¼1
where Ns is the number of samples in each level; whg1 is the weight of the h-th
sample at level g 1, xhg1 ; N xhg1 ; Cg1 is a Gaussian PDF with mean at the
h-th sample at level g 1 and covariance matrix Cg1 .
(3) Generated Ns samples for level g using the MH algorithm.
(4) Repeat steps (1)–(3) until the final level Ng is reached.
Given the same set of data, an important question to ask in practice is how to
choose an appropriate model class. If a model class is too simple, it cannot fit data
and capture a dynamic system’s behaviors. If a model class is too complicated, it
Bayesian Learning and Model Class Selection ... 1103
will try to fit the noise is data, and the information in data may not enough to
identify the model. The Bayesian framework provides a rigorous way to compare
different model classes by considering uncertainties. According to Bayes’ theorem,
the probability of one model class Mj conditional on data among Nj competing
model classes is given by
p DjMj P Mj
P Mj D ¼ ð6Þ
pðDÞ
where p DjMj is the probability of getting data based on the whole model class Mj ,
A full-scale building was used to demonstrate the Bayesian learning and model
class selection. Figure 1 shows the target building. This building has 22 stories and
the height is about 97.00 m. The floor measures about 55.00 m length 38.84 m
width. Sensors were instrumented at each floor in the three stairs of the building to
measured accelerations. Sensors were also placed on the 19-th floor, so that mode
shapes of the three stairs could be assembled. Only six tri-axial sensors were
available, so multiple setups were conducted to cover different locations of the
building.
For Bayesian updating, the 17-story three-dimensional shear building model was
used to model the dynamics of the structural system. Three degrees of freedom
(DOFs) were considered for each floor, i.e., x-direction DOF, y-direction DOF and
a torsional DOF, which corresponds to x-direction, y-direction and torsional stiff-
ness at each floor. The uncertain parameters to be learned by the Bayesian method
were the three stiffness parameters at each floor. The nominal values of these
stiffness parameters were estimated from the drawing of the building. Moreover, the
measured mode shapes of the three stairs were processed to provide the mode
1104 J. H. Yang and H. F. Lam
shapes corresponding to the three DOFs at each floor of the shear building model,
i.e., the x- and y- direction displacements and rotational angles.
Bayesian updating was conducted for this three-dimensional shear building.
Four model classes were considered. In model class 1, two uncertain parameters
were used to scale the x- and y-direction stiffness of all the floors, respectively. In
model class 2, two uncertain parameters were used to scale the x-direction and
torsional stiffness of all the floors, respectively. In model class 3, two uncertain
parameters were used to scale the y-direction and torsional stiffness of all the floors,
respectively. In model class 4, three uncertain parameters were used to scale the
x-direction, y-direction and torsional stiffness of all the floors respectively.
By applying the Bayesian framework and the proposed MCMC algorithm, the
evidences of the four model classes were calculated and summarized in Table 1.
Note that natural logarithm was taken on the evidences to avoid the numerical
overflow problem. The explanations in the parentheses remind how the model
classes are set up. It is observed that for the two-parameter model classes (model
classes 1, 2 and 3), the evidence of model class 1 is larger than the other two. It
means that model class 1 can capture the system dynamics better than the other two.
Allowing acceptable numerical errors, model classes 2 and 3 almost have the same
evidence. It makes sense because these two model classes have the common
Bayesian Learning and Model Class Selection ... 1105
(a) (b)
Fig. 2 Comparison of the measured and calculated mode shapes: (a) mode 1; (b) mode 2
1106 J. H. Yang and H. F. Lam
characteristics, i.e., one uncertain parameter is assigned for the translational stiff-
ness and the other is assigned for the torsional stiffness. The more complicated
model class 4 (with three uncertain parameters) has the largest evidence, indicating
that this is the best model class among the four competing model classes. It means
that we need a model class that is complicated enough to capture dynamics along
x-, y- and torsional directions.
For illustration purpose, Fig. 2 compares calculated mode shapes from model
class 4 with the measured ones. The red dash lines correspond to the calculated
mode shapes, blue solid lines correspond to measured mode shapes and black dash
lines correspond to the undeformed shape. It can be seen that the matching is good.
4 Conclusions
This paper develops the framework and algorithm for Bayesian learning and model
class selection. The proposed MCMC algorithm makes it efficient to identify the
posterior PDF and calculate model evidences that involve high-dimensional inte-
grals. The proposed method is particularly suitable for tackling complex dynamic
systems in practice. A full-scale building was used to demonstrate the proposed
method. In the future, more detailed theoretical investigation will be conducted to
improve the efficiency of the MCMC algorithm. Bayesian mode class selection will
also be studied in more detail.
Acknowledgements The first author is funded by National Natural Science Foundation of China
(Grant No. 51808400), China, Shanghai Sailing Program (Grant No. 18YF1424500), Shanghai,
China, and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (Grant
No. 22120180007), China. The second author is funded by a grant from the Research Grants
Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China [Project No. 9042509 (CityU
11210517)]. The authors are grateful for the generous support. The contributions of Dr. Stephen
Alabi, Dr. Jun Hu, Dr. Qin Hu, Dr. Yan-Chun Ni, Dr. Hua-Yi Peng and Dr. Feng-Liang Zhang to
the field test are greatly appreciated.
References
1. Beck JL (2010) Bayesian system identification based on probability logic. Struct Control
Health Monit 17(7):825–847
2. Beck JL, Au SK (2002) Bayesian updating of structural models and reliability using Markov
chain Monte Carlo simulation. J Eng Mech 128(4):380–391
3. Beck JL, Katafygiotis LS (1998) Updating models and their uncertainties. I: Bayesian
statistical framework. J Eng Mech 124(4):455–461
4. Beck JL, Yuen KV (2004) Model selection using response measurements: Bayesian
probabilistic approach. J Eng Mech 130(2):192–203
5. Lam HF, Yang JH, Au SK (2015) Bayesian model updating of a coupled-slab system using
field test data utilizing an enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo simulation algorithm. Eng
Struct 102:144–155
Bayesian Learning and Model Class Selection ... 1107
6. Lam HF, Yang JH, Au SK (2018) Markov chain Monte Carlo-based Bayesian method for
structural model updating and damage detection. Struct Control Health Monit 25(4):e2140
7. Lam HF, Yang JH, Beck JL (2019) Bayesian operational modal analysis and assessment of a
full-scale coupled structural system using the Bayes-Mode-ID method. Eng Struct 186:183–
202
8. Yang JH (2015) Development of Bayesian structural damage detection methodologies
utilizing advanced Monte Carlo simulation. Ph.D. Thesis, City University of Hong Kong
9. Yang JH, Lam HF (2018) An efficient adaptive sequential Monte Carlo method for Bayesian
model updating and damage detection. Struct Control Health Monit 25(12):e2260
10. Yang JH, Lam HF (2019) An innovative Bayesian system identification method using
autoregressive model. Mech Syst Signal Process 133:106289
11. Yang JH, Lam HF, Beck JL (2019) Bayes-mode-ID: a Bayesian modal-component-sampling
method for operational modal analysis. Eng Struct 189:222–240
Reliability Analysis of Reinforced
Concrete Beam Under Differential
Settlement
1 Introduction
The general principle of design is that every structure must satisfy the requirements
of safety and serviceability for its intended use throughout its service life. However,
in reality, every structure has a probability of failure spite every safety method and
QUD
DCR ¼ 2:0 ð1Þ
QCE
where QUD is the acting force determined in the component (i.e., STAAD.pro
results); and QCE is the expected ultimate, un-factored capacity of the component.
Being that concrete is not a homogenous material, QCE is factored by applying a
partial safety factor of 1.5 to the characteristic strength of concrete to account for
any irregularity in the concrete elements. Generally, beams are used for resisting
bending moments. To obtain the moment of resistance of the beam, assuming the
concrete section fails in compression, the factored ultimate moment of resistance is:
1112 S. A. Alabi et al.
Fig. 2 Plan view of the structure showing beams on 1st floor and columns
Reliability Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Beam … 1113
Mu ¼ 0:45fcu bd 2 ð2Þ
The reliability of the structural member can be determined when the probability
level exceeds a certain value in an operational loading case. Consider a structure
with resistance, Q, subjected to a single load, L, if both Q and L are statistically
independent normally distributed random variable, then the limit state function or
safety margin, G, can be expressed as in Eq. (3)
where h= h1, h2, … hN denote N basic random variables and G(h) denotes a function
of all design variables. In general, the function G(h) can take any form provided that
the structure are defined when G 0 and the survival of the structure is defined
when G > 0. Thus, the probability of failure Pf can be determined as
Z
Pf ¼ PfGðhÞ\0g ¼ fh ðhÞdh ð4Þ
GðhÞ\0
or
b ¼ U1 Pf ð6Þ
The functional relationship between the demand-capacity ratio and acting force
determined in component or connection/joint (moment, axial force, shear, and
possible combined forces)-expected ultimate, unfactored capacity of the component
and/or connection/joint (moment, axial force, shear, and possible combined forces)
ratio can be expressed in terms of the safety margin as given in Eq. (7)
Mmax
G ð hÞ ¼ 2 0 ð7Þ
Mc
1114 S. A. Alabi et al.
Mmax
GðhÞ ¼ 2 0 where h ¼ fMmax ; fcu ; b; d g ð8Þ
Mc
Now the reliability index can determine by substituting Eq. (9), into Eq. (6)
1
1 Mmax
b ¼ U pf ðGðh ¼fMmax ; fcu ; b; d gÞ 0Þ ¼ U P 2 0
0:45fcu bd 2
ð10Þ
The results obtained from the deterministic design of the progressive failure of a
reinforced concrete building frame under the differential settlement were used to
carry out a reliability analysis of the beam based on FORM. Table 1 shows the
assumed general statistical data for the analysis of the structural elements. The
target reliability index (bT) level for all beams is 3.5 based on recommendation
according to ACI 318-99 [1] and Szerszen and Nowak [13].
The results of the reliability estimates under the differential settlement for the RC
beams are presented in Figs. 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15. From the
figures for all the frame types the beams on the first floor were seen to be more
prone to progressive failure as the safety indices (b) for the beams in that level are
lower when compared to beams on other floors levels. The reliability indices b, for
the beam members, increases upwards from the first floor to the third floor. Also,
for the frame type I, type II and type III at first floor, the beams were seen to fail at
75, 100, 125, and 150 mm settlements; 50, 75, 100, 125, and 150 mm settlements
and 75, 100, 125 and 150 mm settlements at which the reliability indexes b were
zero except for beams B2 and B36 respectively. This implies that at such degrees of
differential settlement the structure is more vulnerable to progressive failure as the
level of potential for progressive failure is very severe. Within this range of dif-
ferential settlement, the structure is unable to adjust itself to a state of stable
equilibrium. Though the reliability Indexes for the members is high in all frame
type for the settlement range between 25 and 75 mm, it does not mean the structure
suffers the same stress within that range of settlement.
Table 1 - Probability distribution and the statistical parameters for the basic variables
Variable Probability density Mean Standard Coefficient of
function values E(h) deviation S(h) variations (%)
Mmax Lognormal Varying Varying Varying
fcu Lognormal 25 kN/mm2 7.5 kN/mm2 30
b Normal 225 mm 22.5 mm 10
d Normal Varying Varying 10
1116 S. A. Alabi et al.
However, it can be seen from Figs. 14 and 15 respectively, that only beams in a
group of B42 with frame type III (550 225 mm) and type IV (600 225 mm)
respectively, on the third floor meets the required target reliability index of 3.5
beams, irrespective of the values of assumed settlement. The results of the relia-
bility estimates for the beams further indicate that beams in the groups of B7, B8,
B9, and B43 will no longer be safe when the settlement increases beyond the
assumed settlement of 25 mm. Again, beams in the group of B1, B3, and B37 were
badly affected by settlement. This is because they were very close to where the
assumed settlement was imposed.
4 Conclusions
The First-Order Reliability Method (FORM) has been employed to ascertain the
performance of the progressive failure of the RC beam under the differential set-
tlement. All relevant variables were considered random with assumed probability
density function (PDFs). From the results, the beams on the first floor were well
found to be more prone to progressive under the assumed settlement as the relia-
bility indexes (b) for the beams in that level were lower when compared to beams
on the other floor levels. However, where a settlement of more than 25 mm is
envisaged, special foundation-type should be used to reduce differential settlement
to a level that can be borne by the structural members of the building.
Acknowledgements This paper was supported by the Tertiary Education Trust Fund
(TETFUND) of Nigeria.
References
1. ACI 318-99, 1999: Building code requirement for structural Concrete. American Concrete
Institute, Farmington Hills, Michigan
2. Ioani AM, Cucu HL (2010) Vulnerability to progressive collapse of seismically designed RC
framed structures: corner column case, Buletinul Institutului Politehnic Din Iaşi Publicat De
Universitatea Tehnică “Gheorghe Asachi” Din Iaşi Tomul Lvi (Lx), Fasc. 4, 2010 Secţia
Construcţii. Ărhitectură, pp 21–30
3. Adewumi OJ, Oluwatuyi OE, Afolayan JO (2017) Reliability assessment of BS 8110 (1997)
ultimate limit state design requirement for reinforced concrete columns. Jordan J Civ Eng 11
(3):512–524
4. Afolayan JO (1995) Inequality problems and their applications in structural safety. J Eng Appl
Sci 2:11–14
5. Afolayan JO (2005) Probability-based design of glued thin-webbed timber beams. Asian J
Civ Eng (Build Hous) 6(1–2):75–84
6. Akinpelu JA (2002) The need for code of conduct, building regulations and by-laws for the
building industry in Nigeria. The Professional Builder, Nigeria Institute of Building, pp. 11–
14
Reliability Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Beam … 1121
7. Ayininuola JM, Olalusi OO (2006) Assessment of building failures in Nigeria; case study of
Ibadan. Afr J Sci Technol Sci Eng Ser 5(1):73–78
8. Faber MH, Sorensen JD (2002) Reliability based code calibration. Paper for the Joint
Committee on Structural Safety, pp 1–16
9. General Service Administration (GSA) (2003) Progressive failure analysis and design
guidelines for new Federal Office building and major modernization project, USA
10. Oyewande B (1992) A research for quality in the construction industry. Builder’s Magazine,
June/July Ed., Lagos
11. Olagunju R, Aremu S, Ogundele J (2013) Incessant collapse of buildings in Nigeria: an
architect’s view. Civ Environ Res 3(4):49–54
12. Sule S, Nwafor TC, Onwuka DO (2015) Probabilistic risk assessment of concrete component
of an existing building. Int J Sci Eng Res 6(5):1668–1773
13. Szerszen MM, Nowak AS (2003) Calibration of design code for buildings (ACI 318) Part 2:
reliability analysis and Resistance factors. ACI Struct J 100(3): 383–391
14. Wang C, Zhang H, Li Q (2017) Reliability assessment of aging structures subjected to gradual
and shock deterioration. Reliab Eng Syst Saf 161(2017):78–86
15. Yi WJ, He QF, Yan X, Sashi KK (2008) Experimental study on progressive collapse-resistant
behaviour of reinforced concrete frame structures. ACI Struct J 105:433–439
16. Ying T (2010) Progressive collapse resistance of concrete buildings. Department of Civil and
Environmental Engineering, University of Nevada Las Vegas
Analysis of Scattering and Mode
Conversion of Torsional Guided Waves
by Cracks in Pipes Using Time-Domain
Spectral Element Method
Keywords Spectral element method Torsional guided waves Mode
conversion Scattering waves Crack Pipe
1 Introduction
C. Yeung (&) C. T. Ng
School of Civil, Environmental and Mining Engineering, The University of Adelaide,
Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia
e-mail: carman.yeung@adelaide.edu.au
uses higher-order shape function. Due to the property of the Kronecker delta in a
shape function, the diagonalized mass matrix with Gauss-Lobatto-Legendre
(GLL) of SEM reduces the computational cost [10].
Research on SEM modelling wave propagation and scattering at cracks in pipes,
which is considered as a one-dimensional waveguide, is limited. In this study, the
mode conversion effect at the crack in pipes is investigated using the proposed
time-domain SEM with a cracked element. The study can provide a better under-
standing in wave scattering and mode conversion phenomena of torsional guided
wave at the cracks in pipes.
The paper is structured as follows. A mathematical framework of time-domain
SEM and a cracked model are introduced in Sect. 2. In Sect. 3, the results of the
simulation using the proposed SEM is compared with the experimental data and the
results are discussed in detail. Conclusions are given in the last section.
The wave propagation modelled in SEM can be written in the time-domain dynamic
equilibrium analogical to finite element method [11, 19]
€ þ CU
MU _ þ KU ¼ FðtÞ ð1Þ
where M, K, F(t), U; U_ and U € are the global mass matrix, global stiffness matrix
and global force vector, displacement vector, velocity vector and acceleration
vector, respectively. C is the global damping matrix where C = ηM with damping
parameter η [12].
The local components, Me ; Ke and Fe , are expressed as follows
Xn
Me i¼1
wi He ðni ÞT lHe ðni ÞdetðJe ðni ÞÞ ð2Þ
Xn
Ke i¼1
wi Be ðni ÞT DBe ðni ÞdetðJe ðni ÞÞ ð3Þ
Xn
Fe i¼1
wi He ðni ÞT f ðni ÞdetðJe ðni ÞÞ ð4Þ
@x
where n is the number of integration points. Je ¼ @n is the Jacobian function. f ðni Þ is
the external force. D and l are stress-strain matrix and mass density matrix, which
are defined as
Analysis of Scattering and Mode Conversion … 1125
2 3
GJ 0 0
D¼4 0 K1Tim GA 0 5 ð5Þ
0 0 EI
2 3
qIo 0 0
l¼4 0 qA 0 5 ð6Þ
0 0 K2Tim qI
where q, A, I, J, Io, E and G are the mass density of the pipe and the corresponding
cross-section area, second moment of inertia, the polar moment of inertia, second
moment of inertia, Young’s modulus and shear modulus, respectively. The
parameters are KTim1 = 0.28 and KTim
2 = 45KTim 2
1 /p [13].
Lobatto polynomials are used as the derivatives of the Legendre polynomials.
GLL nodes are applied to achieve diagonal mass matrix [14]. The local coordinate
ni can be determined from the roots of the given equation
dLn1 ðni Þ
1 n2i ¼ 0 for ni 2 ½1; 1 and i 2 1; . . .; n ð7Þ
dni
where Ln1 is the Legendre polynomial of degree (n-1) and the corresponding
weights wi of the GLL point ni are
2
wi ¼ ð8Þ
nðn 1ÞðLn1 ðni ÞÞ2
He ¼ H I ð9Þ
The formulation of the time-domain SEM is based on the elementary rod theory
[15] and Timoshenko beam theory [16]. The previous theory considers the torsional
movement while the latter theory takes into account the horizontal movement and
the shear deformation defect. The governing equations are [17]
1126 C. Yeung and C. T. Ng
@2h
GJ þ Fh ðx; tÞ ¼ qIo €
h ð11Þ
@x2
@ @v
K1Tim GA @x u ¼ qA€v FV ðx; tÞ
@x
@2u
EI þ K1Tim GA @v Tim
€
@x u ¼ K2 qI u ð12Þ
@x2
where h, v and u are the rotation, displacement, and bending. Fh and Fv are the
function for the function of time located at variable x. The strain field e,
strain-displacement operator B and displacement vector q are expressed as
e ¼ Be q ð13Þ
2 @ 3
@x 0 0
B¼4 0 @
@x 1 5He ð14Þ
@
0 0 @x
q ¼ ½h v u T ð15Þ
Mode coupling effect can be simulated by the cracked element model in pipes using
SEM. The cracked element is derived from the model of Darpe et al. [18]. The
proposed model has two nodes and each node has 3 DoFs (h, v and u). The
notations in Fig. 1 are the parameters used in the calculation of the model. The local
stiffness matrix Kec is presented when a crack appears in a pipe. Therefore, the
values of the cracked stiffness matrix are different from that of the normal stiffness
matrix.
The cracked stiffness matrix Kec is converted by transformation matrix T and
flexibility matrix G [19]
l kl l3 l
g11 ¼ þ Ig1 þ Ig2 g22 ¼ þ þ Ig4 þ s2 Ig3 g33 ¼ þ Ig3
GIo GA 3EI EI
ð19Þ
l2
g12 ¼ g21 ¼ Ig5 g23 ¼ g32 ¼ þ sIg3 g13 ¼ g31 ¼ 0
2EI
With
R 8ab2 FII 2
R 2mah2 FIII 2
R 32ab2 F1 2
Ig1 ¼ A pE ðR4 r4 Þ2 dA Ig2 ¼ A pE ðR4 r4 Þ2 dA Ig3 ¼ pE ðR4 r 4 Þ2
dA
A
R 2mk 2 aðR2 þ r2 Þ FIII 2
2
R 2mkahðR2 þ r 2 ÞFIII 2
Ig4 ¼ A pE ðR4 r4 Þ2
dA Ig5 ¼ A pE ðR4 r 4 Þ2
dA
The pipe, which is assumed to be made by aluminium, was modelled using the
proposed time-domain SEM. The Young’s Modulus, density and Poisson’s ratio are
68.9 GPa, 2700 kg/m3 and 0.3, respectively. A 0.01 m long crack was simulated at
the middle of the pipe. The inner and outer diameters are 22 mm and 25 mm,
respectively. The time step was set as 1 10−7 s in the model, where eight GLL
nodes were used in each uncracked element. Tangential force was applied at a node
in rotation h about x-axis to generate torsional wave T(0, 1). A 50 kHz 5-cycle
narrow band sinusoidal tone burst modulated by a Hann window was excited.
Explicit central difference method was applied to solve the dynamic equation.
An aluminium pipe with the same geometry as the numerical model was used to
validate in the experiment. A slot cut was made in the half way of the sample (Fig. 2).
Four piezoceramic shear transducers were bonded with conductive epoxy adhesive
1128 C. Yeung and C. T. Ng
Fig. 4 Amplitude as a function of crack depth to thickness ratio for incident T(0, 1) guided wave
in SEM and experiment [19]
4 Conclusions
A time-domain SEM has been proposed to simulate the torsional guided waves with
mode conversion phenomenon in pipes. The SEM has been developed based on
one-dimensional waveguide, and Timoshenko beam and elementary rod theory. In
order to simulate mode conversion effect due to asymmetric crack, the cracked
element has been proposed. Experimental validation has been carried out to validate
the accuracy of the results simulated by the proposed SEM. Good agreement has
been found by comparing two sets of data obtained from SEM and experiment. This
study can extend the use of SEM for the development of damage detection tech-
niques using guided wave.
References
1. Lee JH, Lee SJ (2009) Application of laser-generated guided wave for evaluation of corrosion
in carbon steel pipe. NDT and E Int 42(3):222–227
2. Løvstad A, Cawley P (2012) The reflection of the fundamental torsional mode from pit
clusters in pipes. NDT and E Int 46:83–93
3. Papadopoulou KA, Shamout MN, Lennox B, Mackay D, Taylor AR, Turner JT, Wang X
(2008) An evaluation of acoustic reflectometry for leakage and blockage detection. Proc Inst
Mech Eng Part C: J Mech Eng Sci 222(6):959–966
4. Rose JL, Jiao D, Spanner J (1996) Ultrasonic guided wave NDE for piping
5. Lowe MJ, Alleyne DN, Cawley P (1998) Defect detection in pipes using guided waves.
Ultrasonics 36(1–5):147–154
6. Xu F, Zhang Y, Hong W, Wu K, Cui TJ (2003) Finite-difference frequency-domain algorithm
for modeling guided-wave properties of substrate integrated waveguide. IEEE Trans Microw
Theory Tech 51(11):2221–2227
7. Zhao X, Rose J (2003) Boundary element modeling for defect characterization potential in a
wave guide. Int J Solids Struct 40:2645–2658
8. Aryan P, Kotousov A, Ng CT, Cazzolato B (2017) A model-based method for damage
detection with guided waves. Struct Control Health Monit 24(3):e1884
1130 C. Yeung and C. T. Ng
Abstract Guided wave testing is one of the most reliable structural health moni-
toring techniques to identify and evaluate damage in structures. However, guided
waves in submerged structures often strongly attenuate that challenges their prac-
ticability for safety inspection. This paper presents a numerical study of guided
wave propagation in a steel plate that has one side immersed in water.
A three-dimensional (3D) finite element (FE) model is employed to provide a
visualization of the ultrasonic field in both the plate and the water. It is found that at
low frequency range, normal vibrations on the water-free surface of the one side
water immersed steel plate predominantly generate quasi-Scholte wave which is an
interface mode with low attenuation,. In addition, the fundamental anti-symmetric
wave (leaky A0) and fundamental symmetric wave (leaky S0) are too weak to be
observed at low frequency but become discernible when the excitation frequency
increases. It seems that the interface wave at low frequency range dominating the
measured signal from the water free surface can be a promising wave mode to
detect damage in storage tanks and pipes filled with water. To further verify the
accuracy of the FE simulation, the group and phase velocity of quasi-Scholte wave
have been calculated from the simulated out-of-plane displacements measured on
the water free surface. Good agreement has been observed between the numerical
simulation and analytical solutions. Therefore, it is concluded that the FE model can
accurately simulate guided wave propagation for the water immersed plate.
Keywords Non-destructive testing Guided waves Quasi-Scholte wave Finite
element method Fluid-solid interface
X. W. Hu (&) C. T. Ng A. Kotousov
School of Civil, Environmental and Mining Engineering, The University of Adelaide,
Adelaide, Australia
e-mail: xianwen.hu@adelaide.edu.au
C. T. Ng
e-mail: alex.ng@adelaide.edu.au
A. Kotousov
e-mail: andrei.kotousov@adelaide.edu.au
1 Introduction
Structural health monitoring (SHM) techniques using guided waves are based on
the understanding of wave propagation and interaction with damage in the struc-
tures. Although guided waves have been applied for identifying damage in sub-
merged structures, such as water tanks and pipes [7, 10, 11], using guided waves to
quantify changes in plate surface condition with the presence of water is not fully
understood. When a plate is immersed in water, the boundary conditions of the
water-plate interface are changed and guided wave energy can leak into the sur-
rounding water so that guided waves in the submerged plate have different char-
acteristics compared to those in a water free plate [3, 9]. In addition, there is an
interface wave mode, quasi-Scholte wave, presented at the water plate interface.
Cegla, Cawley and Lowe [2] studied quasi-Scholte wave in a plate which is fully
immersed in fluid. They found that at low frequencies, quasi-Scholte wave energy is
concentrated mainly in the plate but at higher frequencies most of the wave energy
goes into the fluid. Tian and Yu [13–15] experimentally investigated the guided
wave propagation in a one-side water-immersed steel plate. They showed that
quasi-Scholte wave can be directly excited and detected on the water-free surface of
the plate. Hayashi and Fujishima [4] applied the quasi-Scholte wave to detect a
through-width notch in a water-loaded flat aluminum alloy plate. They confirmed
that scattered waves could be generated by interaction between quasi-Scholte wave
and the defect. However, the scattered waves can only be detected at low frequency
range. All the aforementioned studies were carried out through experimental
measurements, which are limited by a small amount of measurement points and
accuracy of the sensors.
This paper presents a numerical analysis of guided wave propagation in a steel
plate that has only one side immersed in water. The guided wave propagation is
simulated using a 3D FE model. The numerical simulation can provide additional
information that helps to interpret experiment data. This paper is organized as
follows. Section 2 describes the FE model in detail. Section 3 presents the simu-
lation results. The accuracy of the FE model is verified by means of comparing the
phase and group velocity with analytical solution. Finally, the paper is concluded
with discussion in Sect. 4.
2 3D FE Simulation
Fig. 1 Schematic diagram of FE model for a one-side water immersed steel plate with absorbing
regions
1134 X. W. Hu et al.
Fig. 2 Contour snapshots of guided wave propagating in a plate without absorbing layers a when
the incident wave arrived at the boundary; b soon after the wave is reflected from the plate edge;
with absorbing layers c when the incident waves passed through the interface of the steel plate and
the absorbing regions; d soon after the incident wave is being absorbed
from the plate edges. This technique enables a small FE model to simulate wave
propagation in a large structure, significantly saving computational efforts.
Figure 3(a) shows the contour snapshot of the simulated displacements of the plate
and the acoustic pressure in the water at 50 ls for the inner half of the model cut by
the dash line (Fig. 1). One the plate, there are only one wave mode discernible, of
which the acoustic pressure (denoted by the color line in the water layer) is confined
to the plate-water interface. It is recognized that this wave mode is quasi-Scholte
wave [6]. Figures 3(b) and (c) present the simulated out-of-plane displacements at
points A and B located at 100 mm and 172 mm away from the excitation center on
the top water free surface (Fig. 1). Their corresponding scalograms are shown in
Figs. 3(d) and (e). Figures 3(f) and (g) display the power density at 150 kHz over
time for points A and B, respectively. The corresponding time coordinates at the
peak in Figs. 3(f) and (g) are 63.4 ls and 95.5 ls, respectively, based on which the
group velocity is calculated as 2051 m/s similar to the analytically predicted
2150 m/s by DISPERSE. It should be noted that the leaky A0 wave and leaky S0
mode are too weak to be observed at 150 kHz in the simulation. This is consistent
with experiment measurements reported by Yu and Tian [16].
Then, the simulation is run with the signal being a five cycle tone pulse with the
central frequency of 250 kHz modulated by hanning window with the maximum
amplitude equal to 1 lm. Figure 4(a) gives the contour snapshot of simulation
results at 50 ls, where three wave packets can be observed. Figures 4(b) and
(c) presents the simulated out-of-plane displacements at points A and B. Compared
to their counterparts with the excitation frequency of 150 kHz as shown in Figs. 3
(b) and (c), the overall amplitudes significantly reduced. Their corresponding
scalograms are shown is Figs. 4(d) and (e). The fast wave is leaky S0 wave detected
with energy density peak at about 28 ls for point A and at 42 ls for point B. The
second wave packet detected at about 48 ls in point A is highly dispersive, indi-
cated by longer arrive time at lower frequency and shorter arrive time at higher
frequency. This is the typical behavior of leaky A0 wave. However, this wave mode
attenuates fast and it almost vanished at point B as shown in Fig. 4(e). Figures 4(f)
and (g) display the power density at 250 kHz over time for points A and B,
respectively. It can be seen that the second peak has the greatest amplitude in Fig. 4
(f) but decreases significantly as shown in Fig. 4(g). Based on the time difference of
the three energy density peaks, the group velocity of the three wave packets is
calculated as 5333, 2978 and 1702 m/s which are consistent with the theoretical
derivation for leaky S0 wave, leaky A0 wave and quasi-Scholte wave. It is con-
cluded that the simulation results are theoretically verified.
Compare the simulation results with two different excitation frequencies, it can
be seen that at low frequency, the measured signal from the top water-free surface is
dominated by quasi-Scholte wave. But at higher frequency, the measured
quasi-Scholte wave decreases in magnitudes and most of its energy confined to
frequency components slightly lower than the excitation frequency as shown in
Figs. 4(d) and (e). This is reasonable since the wave energy of quasi-Scholte wave
is mainly taken up by the plate at low frequency but concentrates to water side at
higher frequency [5]. In addition, the amplitudes of leaky S0 and leaky A0 are
observable at higher frequency, which makes the measured signal more compli-
cated than that at low excitation frequency. Therefore, conclusion can be drawn that
1136 X. W. Hu et al.
quasi-Scholte wave at low frequency range dominates the measured signal from
water-free surface of one side water immersed plate structure. With the absence of
other wave modes, the interface mode can be a very promising wave mode to detect
damage in structures such as storage tanks and pipes, which does not involve the
difficulty in signal processing due to multimodal features of guided waves [13].
To further validate the accuracy of FE model, the phase velocity and group
velocity dispersion curves are calculated for the quasi-Scholte wave. It should be
noted that the displacement of quasi-Scholte wave is dominated by the out-of-plane
displacements. Thus, the simulated phase and group velocity are calculated based
on the out-of-plane displacement as [17,18].
2pf D/
Cp ¼ ð1Þ
Dx
Dx
Cg ðfc Þ ¼ ð2Þ
Dt
The simulated results are then compared with the analytical derivation by
DISPERSE. This study considers excitation frequency from 70 kHz to 200 kHz
with steps of 10 kHz. Figures 5(a) and (b) show the phase and group velocity
dispersion curves calculated by the FE simulation and DISPERSE. There is good
agreement between the FE simulations and DISPERSE. The largest discrepancy is
shown in the group velocity, which is less than 5%. Therefore, it can be concluded
that the 3D FE model is able to predict guided wave propagation in the one-side
water-immersed plate.
Fig. 5 Comparison between ABAQUS and DISPERSE a phase velocity; b group velocity (solid
black line denotes the analytical solution by DISPERSE; blue circles represent numerical
simulations)
Ultrasonic Guided Wave Field Modeling … 1139
4 Conclusions
This paper has presented a numerical analysis on the guided wave propagation in a
steel plate with one side immersed in water. A 3D FE model has been used for
numerical simulations. It has been demonstrated that normal vibrations on the
surface of the water loaded steel plate predominantly generate quasi-Scholte wave.
The amplitudes of the measured signal on the top water free surface decrease with
the excitation frequency increases. The numerical results of group and phase
velocity of quasi-Scholte wave have been calculated and compared with
DISPERSE. Good agreement has been observed between the numerical simulation
and analytical solutions. The 3D FE model provides a powerful tool to visualize
guided wave propagation and to distinguish leaky S0 wave, leaky A0 wave,
quasi-Scholte wave, and pressure wave in water. Future research can employ the 3D
FE model to study the sensitivity of the quasi-Scholte to identify damage. The
scattering characteristics of guided waves at damage have been extensively studied
by means of scattering directive patterns (SDPs) for water-free structures [8, 12]
(Diligent et al. 2002; Ng and Veidt 2012) but there has been no study describe the
SDPs for submerged structures. The proposed 3D FE model has the potential to
study the influence of the surrounding water on the SDPs of guided waves in
submerged structures.
References
1. Abaqus (2013) Abaqus 6.13 analysis user’s guide. Dassault Systems, Providence, RI
2. Cegla FB, Cawley P, Lowe MJS (2005) Material property measurement using the
quasi-Scholte mode—a waveguide sensor. J Acoust Soc Am 117(3):1098–1107
3. Chen J, Su Z, Cheng L (2009) Identification of corrosion damage in submerged structures
using fundamental anti-symmetric lamb waves. Smart Mater Struct 19(1):015004
4. Hayashi T, Fujishima R (2016) Defect detection using quasi-scholte wave for plate loaded
with water on single surface. Mater Trans 57(9):1602–1608
5. Hayashi T, Inoue D (2016) Guided wave propagation in metallic and resin plates loaded with
water on single surface. In: AIP conference proceedings, vol 1706, p 030003
6. Inoue D, Hayashi T (2015) Transient analysis of leaky Lamb waves with a semi-analytical
finite element method. Ultrasonics 62:80–88
7. Malinowski PH, Moll J, Wandowski T, Golub M, Ostachowicz WM (2017) Study of guided
wave propagation in water immersed samples with protective coating. In: Proceedings of
Structural Health Monitoring 2017:14061
8. Ng C-T, Veidt M (2011) Scattering of the fundamental anti-symmetric lamb wave at
delaminations in composite laminates. J Acoust Soc Am 129(3):1288–1296
9. Pistone E, Li K, Rizzo P (2013) Noncontact monitoring of immersed plates by means of
laser-induced ultrasounds. Struct Health Monit 12(5–6):549–565
10. Rizzo P, Han J-G, Ni X-L (2010) Structural health monitoring of immersed structures by
means of guided ultrasonic waves. J Intell Mater Syst Struct 21(14):1397–1407
1140 X. W. Hu et al.
Abstract This study tries to detect the earthquake-induced damage to the roadways
and road closures due to collapsed buildings using the images captured by a
vehicle-mounted camera. The images employed by this study were sequentially
taken after the 2016 Kumamoto earthquake with a camera installed in an auto-
mobile. To achieve the objective, the authors try to develop an image classifier to
detect the earthquake-induced damage to the roadways and road closures based on
deep learning algorithm. The 31,951 images captured on April 17 and 20, 2016
were employed to develop the image classifier. The images were visually classified
into the three classes: damage to roadway, road closure, and no damage, and they
were divided into training and test sets. The overall accuracy of the image classifier
was calculated using the test set, and it reached 81%. The image classifier properly
recognized the images with no damage on roadway with the accuracy of 90%. It
was difficult to detect the damage to roadway because some of the images include
only minor cracks.
Keywords Deep learning 2016 Kumamoto earthquake Damage to roadway
Road closure due to collapsed building
1 Introduction
The images used in this study were captured by a vehicle-mounted camera. The
images were sequentially acquired with an interval of 5 m. Global Survey
Corp. (GLC) surveyed damage situations using an automobile, which is equipped
Use of Deep Learning Algorithm to Detect Road Damage … 1143
with six cameras, in the damage-stricken areas after the 2016 Kumamoto earth-
quake [2]. The images captured by a camera installed in front are used in this study.
The moving trajectories of the automobile are shown in Fig. 1. The images were
mainly acquired in Mashiki Town, Nishihara Village, and Kumamoto City from
April 17 to April 28, 2016.
The vehicle-mounted camera captures a 2048 1536 image. The bottom
quarter of the image was cropped so as to focus on the roadway, and it was resized
to a 512 75 image. The images were normalized to apply to the deep learning
algorithm. Figure 2 shows an example of image used in this study.
First, six investigators visually inspected a total of 31,951 images to classify into
the three classes: damage to roadway, roadway closure, and no damage. The images
classified into the same class by more than five investigators were used to develop
an image classifier in this study. Totally, 512 images for damage to roadway, 673
for roadway closure, and 14,346 for no damage were selected by the six investi-
gators. The authors randomly selected 100 images for each class, which were used
as a test set for validation of the image classifier. The other images were employed
as a training set for deep learning. The contrast of an original image of the training
set was changed, and two images were newly obtained from the original image. The
mirror-reversed images were also illustrated from the original images. Hence, the
number of images of the training set is six times as large as that of the original
images.
Fig. 1 Moving trajectories of the automobile to capture the images after the 2016 Kumamoto
earthquake
1144 Y. Maruyama et al.
A deep learning module Caffe (Jia et al. 2014) was employed in this study. The
authors assumed the convolutional neural network (CNN) as shown in Fig. 3,
which consists of five convolutional layers, five pooling layers, two fully connected
layers, and an output layer. Each convolutional layer is associated with ReLU
activation function f(x) to introduce nonlinearities to the model.
X
f ð xÞ ¼ max 0; i;j
wij x ij ð1Þ
where wij and xij are a weight for each neuron, and input in the previous layer,
respectively. The output layer provides the probability of the image with respect to
each class through the softmax function (Eq. (2)). The image is assigned to the class
associated with the highest probability.
X3
yj ¼ exp zj = k¼1
expðzk Þ ð2Þ
The image classifier was built using the training set of images and the CNN
shown in Fig. 3. The maximum number of iterations to update the weights in the
CNN was set to be 60,000. The images of the training set were divided into the two
sets, i.e. training and validation sets, with the ratio of 6:1. The training set was
Use of Deep Learning Algorithm to Detect Road Damage … 1145
employed to obtain the values of loss function every 100 iterations, and the vali-
dation set was employed to calculate the values of loss function and accuracy of
classification every 500 iterations. As for the loss function, the cross-entropy loss is
assumed in this study.
X3
En ¼ t logynk
k¼1 nk
ð4Þ
ynk is the probability of the image n associated with the class k, which is calculated
using Eq. (2). tnk represents the truth data. If the image n actually belongs to the
class k, tnk is set to be 1. tnk is set to be 0 if the image n belongs to the other classes.
Figure 4 shows the values of loss function and the accuracy of classification with
respect to the number of iteration. The values of loss function decreases as the
number of iteration increases. The loss function for the training set reaches 0, and
that for the validation set reaches 0.2. The accuracy of classification for the vali-
dation set reaches 0.95 as the number of iterations increases.
The image classifiers were sequentially built when the number of iterations
reaches multiple of 1,000. The accuracy of the image classifiers was evaluated
using the test set (Fig. 5). The highest accuracy of 81.0% was realized when the
number of iterations was 8,000. Hence, the image classifier constructed with the
number of iterations of 8,000 was adopted in this study. Table 1 shows the result of
image classification using the test set. The images with no damage were identified
with the accuracy of 90%. On the other hand, the images which captured damage to
roadway were detected with the accuracy of 66.0%. The images with minor cracks
were visually classified as the images which captured damage to roadway. The
image classifier tends to misclassify these images as those with no damage, and the
accuracy decreases.
Fig. 4 Values of loss function and accuracy of classification with respect to the number of
iterations
1146 Y. Maruyama et al.
Accuracy
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000
Number of Calculation
The image classifier developed in the previous section was applied to the images
captured by a vehicle-mounted camera. As is described in the previous section, the
images acquired on April 17 and 20, 2016 were employed to construct the image
classifier in this study. In order to evaluate versatility of the image classifier, it was
applied to the images captured on April 22, 25, and 26, and the classification accuracy
was investigated. First, the images were visually inspected by one investigator. The
images were classified into the three classes: damage to roadway, roadway closure,
and no damage. The image classifier was applied to the images, and then the results
Use of Deep Learning Algorithm to Detect Road Damage … 1147
were compared with those of visual inspection. Table 2 summarizes the specifications
of images employed in this section. The images captured in the four areas were
selected.
Table 3 compares the results of visual inspection and image classification in the
four areas. The accuracy to detect the images with no damage is in the range of 76–
92%, and it shows the highest value of the three classes. The accuracy to detect the
images which captured the closures of roadways is in the range of 56–79%. More
than half of the images which were not properly identified by the image classifier
were mistakenly detected as the images which captured damage to roadways. The
detection accuracy for the images which captured damage to roadways is in the range
of 18–48%, and it shows the lowest value of the three classes. Minor cracks on the
roadways due to the earthquake were difficult to detect by the image classifier, and
the images with minor cracks were mistakenly detected as those with no damage.
Figure 6 shows the results of visual inspection and those of image classification
in the four areas. According to the results, the road sections with no damage are
Fig. 6 Comparisons between the results of visual inspection (left) and those of image
classification (right)
Use of Deep Learning Algorithm to Detect Road Damage … 1149
Fig. 7 Comparisons between a the result of visual inspection and b that of image classification
with respect to the 50 50 m2 grid cell
4 Conclusions
This study constructed the image classifier based on deep learning algorithm to
detect the roadway closure and damage to roadway because of an earthquake. In
order to achieve the objective, the images captured by a vehicle-mounted camera
after the 2016 Kumamoto earthquake were employed in this study. First, the six
investigators performed visual inspection of the images to classify into three
classes: roadway closure, damage to roadway, and no damage. Then, a deep
learning module Caffe (convolutional architecture for fast feature embedding) was
used to construct the image classifier.
The images acquired on April 17 and 20, 2016 were divided into the training and
test sets. The test set was used to evaluate the accuracy of the image classifier, and
1150 Y. Maruyama et al.
the overall accuracy was 81.0%. The detection accuracy for the images with no
damage was quite high, but that for the images which capture damage to roadways
was not sufficient. The image classifier was applied to the images captured on other
dates, and the result was compared with that of visual inspection. It was difficult to
reveal the damage pattern of roadways, however, the image classifier was effective
to identify the anomalous road sections due to an earthquake.
References
Abstract Wakkanai Port, located in the northernmost part of Japan, has a break-
water called “North Breakwater Dome”, which is reminiscent of ancient Greek
architecture. The Dome has played an important role not only as a seawall, but also
as a central tourist facility in the area. Currently, the deterioration of the dome is
becoming apparent. Accordingly, it was decided to conduct a comprehensive
rehabilitation covering a survey, diagnosis, evaluation, and repair. Particularly for
the Dome, which has high historical value and is important as a tourism resource,
special evaluation criteria that fully take the characteristics of the structure and
environmental conditions into consideration are required. This paper discusses a
series of ideas that provided the basis for realizing the repair work, which is still
underway. The discussed topics include basic ideas related to 1) inspection and
diagnosis methods for the Dome; 2) evaluation of the structural members with five
deterioration grades; 3) repair and prevention methods particularly suitable for a
civil engineering heritage; and 4) execution of repair and prevention to enhance the
durability of the Dome.
K. Hase (&)
Civil Engineering Research Institute for Cold Region, Sapporo, Japan
e-mail: hase-k22ac@ceri.go.jp
A. Saitou S. Tomisawa I. Sakashita
Hokkaido Regional Development Bureau, MLIT, Sapporo, Japan
e-mail: saitou-a22ac@mlit.go.jp
S. Tomisawa
e-mail: tomisawa-s22aa@mlit.go.jp
I. Sakashita
e-mail: sakashita-i22aa@mlit.go.jp
H. Yokota
Faculty of Engineering, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Japan
e-mail: yokota@eng.hokudai.ac.jp
1 Introduction
Wakkanai Port, which is located in the northernmost part of Japan, has an unusually
shaped breakwater called the North Breakwater Dome, which is reminiscent of
ancient Greek architecture (Fig. 1). Construction of the North Breakwater Dome
was completed in 1936, and the structure has played an extremely important role as
a breakwater for a pier that was developed to secure sea transport between
Wakkanai and Sakhalin. This facility, which also plays a role as a venue for events
attended by residents and tourists, was selected as a “civil engineering heritage” by
the Japan Society of Civil Engineers and as a “Hokkaido heritage” by the
Government of Hokkaido, and has been playing a new role as a landmark of
Wakkanai City.
The North Breakwater Dome, which faces the outer sea in an extremely cold
region, had deteriorated more severely than had been expected. A complete reha-
bilitation, including repair of the footing beams and the superstructure, was con-
ducted from 1978 to 1981. From 1999 to 2002, repairs—mainly of the seismic
retrofit of the columns—were conducted to address revisions to the seismic design
standards. More than 30 years after the first complete repair, deterioration of the
facility had progressed again, and the name plate fell off in 2012, an incident that
had the potential to cause harm to third parties. As described earlier, this facility has
played an important role not only as a facility to protect a mooring facility and a
port transportation facility behind it from wave overtopping, but also as a central
tourist facility in the area; therefore, it is necessary to maintain its value as a civil
engineering heritage and tourist facility. In light of the above, deterioration
inspection, structural evaluation and planning for appropriate repairs based on a
careful consideration of priorities had been called for, and the Technical
Examination Committee for the Wakkanai Harbor North Breakwater Dome, chaired
by one of the authors, was established by the Hokkaido Regional Development
Bureau of the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism.
This paper discusses a series of ideas that provided the basis for realizing the
repair work, which is still underway.
transverse lines on the inner surface. For measurements of the chloride ion con-
centration on the outer surface of the wall, 7 blocks with visibly exposed rebar or
rust stain were selected. To determine how the chloride ion concentration differed
by height on the structure, measurements were taken along TL1 (transverse line 1),
TL4 and TL7. Measurements of the inner surface of the wall were done for 4 blocks
that were selected as representative blocks. Sampling from each block was done at
the location where the concrete surface was considered to be sound.
Next, rebar corrosion was predicted based on the inspection results. This pre-
diction was based on the diffusion of chloride ions (JSCE-G 573 [1]) in which the
measured chloride ions during the inspection were used and was based on the cover
concrete thickness over the rebar. From the relationship between the corrosion of
the rebar on the outer surface of the Dome and the chloride ion concentration, the
critical chloride ion concentration for the occurrence of corrosion for this facility
was set at 3.2 kg/m3.
Assessment and Repair for North Breakwater Dome in Wakkanai Port 1155
Block No.5
In the inspection of the outer surface of the Dome, damage, including severe
honeycombing, was found. An example is shown in Fig. 4. Many damages were
found on the sloped section from TL4 to TL6. As causes of these damages, it was
estimated that the work for applying cover concrete had been difficult in this area
because of its curved shape and that this area tended to receive a disproportionate
amount of ocean waves because of its height. The causes of rebar exposure were
determined to be the insufficient cover concrete thickness at the curved section and
the honeycombing and other damage.
As a result of the measured cover concrete thickness, the location where the
cover concrete thickness was less than the design thickness of 85 mm concentrated
on TL5 on block No.15. On the other blocks, the specified cover concrete thickness
was secured.
As a result of the corrosion inspection of rebar using half-cell potential and
ASTM standards [2], about 5% of the 1,475 measured locations were judged to
have a high likelihood of rebar corrosion.
Chloride ion concentrations exceeding 3.2 kg/m3 were not found for the mea-
surements at the rebar locations. Changes in chloride ion amounts were predicted
for the coming 50 years based on the data obtained in the inspection. It was found
that, except for No. 15, whose cover concrete thickness was insufficient, the like-
lihood of rebar corrosion before the end of the coming 50 years was predicted to be
low. This prediction was for the locations where the soundness of the concrete
1156 K. Hase et al.
surface had been maintained at the time of inspection. The locations where planar
and linear damage had progressed were considered to have undergone rebar cor-
rosion earlier than had been predicted.
Cracks and 9 other types of planer and linear damages were found on the inner side
of the Dome. Most of them were cracks and cold joints. Even though the numbers
were not large, missing parts and damage with loose parts and rust stain at previously
repaired locations were found. On the inner surface of the wall, unlike on the outer
surface, no marked differences depending on the elevation of the parts were found.
The measurement results for the cover concrete thickness did not differ by block. In
all of the blocks, the cover concrete thickness roughly satisfied the design value.
In the inspection for rebar corrosion, half-cell potentials that indicate the like-
lihood that corrosion occurs were obtained at most of the measurement locations
along the handrail and wheel guard. On the other hand, for other members such as
the wall, except for the locations with exposed rebar, the measured half-cell
potentials indicated that the likelihood of corrosion was small. Loose concrete was
not detected at these locations in the hammering sound test either. In inspection for
rebar corrosion, which was done for some parts of the structure by chipping the
cover concrete, corroded rebar was not found. We judged that corrosion did not
occur at these locations.
Based on the data obtained in these inspections, we predicted the transition of
the amount of chloride ions for the coming 50 years. As a result, we found the
likelihood of rebar corrosion would be low even in the 50th year after the survey.
A repair plan was formulated based on the concept of preventive maintenance. The
design service life of this facility was determined to be 50 years. In setting the range
for repair, deterioration was categorized into 5 grades of severity. This catego-
rization was done based on the idea of sorting damage from the most severe, i.e.,
that which might have been affecting the structural capacity at the time of the
inspection, to the least severe, i.e., that which would have the potential to degrade
the structural capacity near the end of the coming 50 years if the planned repair was
not conducted. The concept behind this categorization is shown in Table 2 and
Assessment and Repair for North Breakwater Dome in Wakkanai Port 1157
capacity (%)
10%
20%
destruction increases
8080
30%
A risk of the
6060 40%
Life during which the Life during which 50%
4040 structural capacity is the structural capacity
maintained. decrease.
2020
Preventive Measures Corrective Measures
00
1 2 3 4 5 or more
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Deterioration grade
Fig. 6 A map of A B C D E F G H I
deterioration grade
TL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
TL 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
TL 3 1 Stage 3 3 3 3 3 3
TL 4 2 1 1 1 1 Stage 2 1
TL 5 2 1 3 3 1 3 3 3 2
TL 6 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
TL 7 1 1 1 3 4 1 1 1 3
Fig. 7 Image of color after repair (Outer surfaces of the wall (No. 5))
Assessment and Repair for North Breakwater Dome in Wakkanai Port 1159
of Stage 2, because the outer surface of the Dome is seen from ferries sailing
offshore and from the coast. Furthermore, if the Stage 3 setting were employed, the
repair would also cover the sound areas. Such excess repair had to be avoided.
Unlike the outer surface, the inner surface of the Dome wall, which is a major
member of the structure, is less exposed to moisture, salinity, temperature changes
and waves. The influence of external factors on rebar corrosion was considered to
be less on the inner surface than that on the outer surface. Therefore, the same
concept for categorizing the grade of deterioration was used for the inner surface
and the outer surface. However, when the environmental conditions were consid-
ered, we determined that linear damage, which corresponds to Grade 3 deteriora-
tion, had the low potential to greatly degrade the structural capacity.
Most of the horizontal cracks were minute ones of 0.2 mm or less in width, and
rust stain was not found along them. We considered the cracks to be from concrete
shrinkage and we estimated that the likelihood of these cracks progressing would be
low. Many of the vertical cracks, however, were 0.2 mm or wider. Judging from the
sizes and locations of those cracks, it was probable that those cracks were caused by
external confining pressure and thermal stress. However, rust stain was not seen
along those cracks, either. It was concluded that these cracks do not require urgent
repair.
In evaluating the inner surface of the wall, the factors necessary for maintaining
structural capacity were considered, including the soundness of the concrete and the
rebar. In addition to these factors, aesthetic appearance was considered because the
facility is used as a tourist attraction. In the evaluation, we examined the impres-
sions of risk and appearance held by ordinary people regarding the cracks and other
deterioration on the facility. People without professional knowledge of the deteri-
oration of concrete structures participated. Figures 8 and 9 show the conditions of
damage at locations subject to this impression assessment. The areas enclosed in
green squares in the figure, are those for which the influence of cracks on aesthetic
appearance was examined. The red circles in Fig. 9 indicate the locations where the
inspection subjects considered the cracks to affect the aesthetic appearance. Based
on the results of this examination, we judged that the vertical cracks, which are
easily spotted by people walking or standing near the cracks, required measures of
some kind. It was possible that the vertical cracks affect the structural performance,
in addition to affect the aesthetic appearance. As a result of this impression
assessment, deterioration evaluation of the inner surface of the wall and the criteria
for repair were clarified as shown in Fig. 10.
The red broken line in the figure indicates the boundary between the grade of
deterioration that requires repair and that which do not require repair. When a
1160 K. Hase et al.
Loose parts
Leakage trace
coating 䕿 䕿 coating
䕿
Fig. 10 The inner degradation evaluation classification and repair implementation criteria
Assessment and Repair for North Breakwater Dome in Wakkanai Port 1161
TL 7 2 5 3 3 3 3 3 2 2
TL 8 2 2 3 2 3 3 3 3 2
TL 9 3 3 3 3 2 3 3 4 3
TL 10 2 2 3 3 2 3 3 2 3
TL 11 3 2 3 3 2 3 3 2 3
TL 12 2 1 3 3 2 3 2 2 3
certain location was evaluated as having a grade of deterioration exceeding this red
line, we judged that the location required repair. Considering boundary conditions
and structural capacity, the grade of deterioration that required repair was deter-
mined as 3a. However, based on considerations of aesthetic appearance and the
relationship between the locations of damage and the eye level of people, the grade
of deterioration 3b was subdivided into 3b+ and 3b−.
A map of the deterioration grade of the inner surface of wall, based on the
deterioration evaluation in Fig. 10, is shown in Fig. 11. In this figure, areas with a
deterioration grade of 3 that are enclosed with double lines indicate the areas subject
to repair. The other areas with a deterioration grade of 3 corresponded to those with
3b+ in Fig. 10. It was judged that these areas with 3b+ are subject to follow-up
monitoring. Areas with deterioration grades of 4 and 5 were those with planar
damage. We determined that these areas require planar repair.
The outer surface of the wall will be repaired in the range indicated as Stage 2 areas,
as explained earlier. Chipping was planned to be done in units of 2 m 2 m. In
consideration of the need to afford workability and to control deterioration from
chipping, we decided that chipping for cross-sectional repair should be basically
done using a water jet.
In selecting materials for repair, the following items were considered. 1) Given
that the facility was a historical structure and a landmark in the district, we needed
to select materials that did not decease the textural and color unity of the existing
structure; 2) To prevent the intrusion of agents that cause deterioration, we planned
to select materials with low chloride diffusion velocities and high crack resistance;
and 3) As this structure was exposed to a severe cold environment, we decided to
select materials resistant to frost damage.
Part of the outer surface of the structure under repair is shown in Fig. 12.
Shotcreting was selected because it excels in workability and economy. We decided
1162 K. Hase et al.
to use polymer cement mortar mixed with short fibers, because this material had
been used successfully as a repair material in cold regions.
On the other hand, for the repair of the inner surface of the wall, we decided to
repair the cracks wider than 0.2 mm in the lowest zone to enhance the aesthetic
appearance. The injection method was selected for repairing these cracks.
6 Conclusions
In this paper, we reported on the inspection, and the concept and methods for repair
based on the preventive maintenance for the North Breakwater Dome focusing on
walls. The major findings are as follows:
1) For the repair of the outer surface of the wall, the inspection results were sorted
by unit area of 2 m 2 m. The grade of deterioration for each unit was clarified
in 5 categories of planar and linear damages. The range of repair was decided
based on the grade of deterioration.
2) For the repair of the inner surface of the wall, which had played an important
role as a central tourist attraction of the area, aesthetic appearance was taken into
consideration in the evaluation. The range of repair was decided based on the
grade of deterioration categorized into 7, which was more detailed than the
5-grade categorization of deterioration for the outer surface.
3) At repairing, we put our efforts in securing aesthetic value and improving
durability by selecting materials which would not damage the unity in texture
and color of the North Breakwater Dome. Frost-resilient materials which would
prevent intrusion of agents causing deterioration were also selected.
Acknowledgements We would like to express our gratitude to the members of the Technical
Examination Committee for Wakkanai Harbor North Breakwater Dome for their cooperation in
realizing this study. At the time of onsite inspection, the persons in charge of the North Breakwater
Assessment and Repair for North Breakwater Dome in Wakkanai Port 1163
Dome of the Wakkanai Port Office of Hokkaido Regional Development Bureau, City of
Wakkanai, and Cold Region Port and Harbor Engineering Research Centre assisted us in many
ways. We would like to thank all of the persons who cooperated in the onsite inspection.
References
1. JSCE-G-573 (2003) Measurement Method for Distribution of Total Chloride Ion in Concrete
Structure
2. ASTM C876, Standard Test Method for Half-Cell Potentials of Uncoated Reinforcing in
Concrete
Infrared Thermography for Detecting
Subsurface Defects of Concrete
Structures
1 Introduction
The reinforced concrete structures are designed to carry large loads and are always
exposed to extreme weather conditions, such as thermal loadings, freeze and thaw
cycles and other ambient environmental conditions, thus they are subjected to
continuous degradation [17, 19]. Subsurface delamination is one of the major
problems affecting reinforced concrete structures and normally caused by corrosion
of reinforcing steel. Once the environmental agents penetrate the material and come
in contact with reinforcement bars, a layer of oxides begin to form on the rebar
surface which leads to the local expansion of steel. This expansion imposes the
local tensile stresses on concrete and eventually causes the cracking along rebar and
weakens the bond between reinforcement and concrete, ultimately causing sub-
surface delamination, cracking or even spalling of concrete [2, 19]. Delamination is
very common in concrete bridge decks and pavements where de-icing agents are
used [20]. Similarly, premature finishing of burnished slabs is another common
cause of delamination in concrete structures [11]. The delamination is normally not
detectable with routine inspection techniques and by the time it is detectable, it has
been widespread and urgent and extensive maintenance is required [7]. Early
detection and maintenance of delamination is essential to avoid uncontrolled
spalling and rebar exposure and to ensure the overall integrity of structure [24].
Traditionally, sounding techniques (hammer sounding or chain drag) are used
under the supervision of qualified engineer to detect the delaminations within the
concrete structure [8]. A clear ringing sound indicates an intact area while a dull or
hollow sound is an indication of delaminated area [6]. These techniques are very
subjective in nature as the quality of concrete is determined by generated sounds
heard by inspector. Further, such techniques require direct access to the structure,
and in case of bridges it may need the lane closure and traffic disruption which
limits the effectiveness of these methods [20].
Infrared thermography (IRT) is one the advanced and efficient way of rapid and
safe evaluation of concrete subsurface damages [15, 16, 18]. It uses the temperature
difference between intact and defected concrete areas to identify the potential
delamination in concrete. Every object with temperature over absolute zero radiates
energy to ambient environment based on their temperature and other physical
properties [5]. Infrared cameras are used to detect those radiations and convert them
into a thermal image, often called thermograph. The presence of any subsurface
anomaly, especially air void or delamination disrupt the heat transfer through the
mass and the influence is projected on the surface by variation in temperature
distribution [3].
Available IRT is categorized into two types, active and passive thermography.
Passive thermography uses the ambient environmental conditions to measure the
temperature difference in structures, whereas active thermographic techniques
require external stimulus to generate thermal gradient in the object [14]. Civil
engineering structures are usually large in size and external stimulation is not
economical for such structures. Therefore, passive infrared thermography is
Thermography for Detecting Subsurface Defects … 1167
commonly adopted method for these structures. ASTM D4788-03 [4] has defined a
standard test procedure for inspection of concrete bridge deck using passive IRT.
The standard defines some limitations for environmental conditions feasible for
accurate data collection of subsurface delamination.
Previous studies have highlighted some of the important parameters that effect
the passive IRT results including weather conditions, solar loading, wind speed,
size and depth of delamination. Regarding data collection time, there are lot of
inconsistencies in literature and different studies have different recommendations
based on their experimental conditions. Researchers have normally argued upon the
number of hours after sunrise and recommended a time frame suitable to collect the
data [1, 4, 9, 12, 21–25]. However, none of these studies defined the optimal
conditions and time for IR thermography. Effective critical parameters that affect
the results are identified as radiation heat flux, wind velocity, ambient temperature
as well as size and depth of delamination. The current study aims to address, how
radiation heat flux and defect parameters influence the data collection time using
experimental studies and numerical modelling. This study will come out with some
quantitative values to suggest the ideal time of data collection instead of a range of
time frame.
2 Methods
2.1 Materials
A reinforced concrete slab 500 500 175 mm was prepared for the experiment.
A Styrofoam of size 142 142 5 mm was used in center of slab to mimic the
internal defect as its thermal conductivity is very close to air. (air: 0.0241 W/moC,
Styrofoam: 0.033 W/moC) [9]. Figure 1 shows schematic diagram and photos of
test slab before and after casting. The sides of slabs were insulated using wooden
formwork to ensure no heat loss or gain from sides. Depth of delamination was kept
63 mm to make is close to concrete bridge deck, as normal clear cover for deck slab
is 50 mm and delamination usually appears along the rebar.
The experimental setup for the infrared thermography is depicted in Fig. 2. The
setup consisted of four halogen lamps (500 W each) to irradiate the slab, an infrared
camera (FLIR T1050sc) for thermal images, a RS pro IM-750 solar power meter
(b) to determine radiation intensity and DigiTech weather station (c) for environ-
mental parameters recording.
At the beginning of experiment the environmental conditions (i.e., humidity and
ambient temperature) were recorded. The halogen lamps were used to heat up the slab
through irradiation and the radiation intensity was measured using solar power meter
in term of W/m2. The uniform heat flux was ensured on the slab surface by adjusting
the position, height and angle of halogen lamps. IR camera was used to record the
thermographs throughout the experiments. The camera was positioned perpendicular
to the slab at 1 m from surface. The thermal sensitivity of camera is less than 0.02 K
and frame rate was set to 30 Hz with image resolution of 1024 768 pixels. The slab
was heated up by halogen lamps for 60 min through face, facing towards the camera
and then allowed to cool down under ambient environmental conditions for further
60 min. The slab was placed on 3inches high wooden supports to allow air flow all
around the sample. Figure 2d shows a typical thermograph taken by IR camera during
the experiment. The thermal contrast developed between defected and sound region
was obtained by determining the absolute temperature difference between delami-
nated (Td) and intact region (Ts) as follow.
DT ¼ Td Ts ð1Þ
hc ¼ 3:83v þ c ð3Þ
Once the experiment setup was completed, the test slab was subjected to external
radiations through halogen lamps. The height and angle of lamps were adjusted and
a uniform heat flux of 220 W/m2 was achieved thorough out the surface of slab. To
ascertain the uniformity of radiation, the solar power meter shown in Fig. 2b, was
used to measure the flux at all four corners as well as middle of the slab. The slab
was irradiated for 60 min and then allowed to cool down under ambient environ-
mental conditions (surrounding temperature 24 °C and humidity 40%). Change in
temperature on slab surface was recorded with IR camera with an average sampling
frequency of 30 Hz throughout the experiment, the results are averaged over the
interval of 15 s and are presented in Fig. 3. The same experimental scenario was
then numerically simulated using FEM software COMSOL Multiphysics and
thermal outputs on surface are plotted in Fig. 3 along with the experimental results.
The absolute thermal contrast is obtained using Eq. 1. The numerical predictions
and experimental results match rationally well. Figure 3a shows the total heat flux
and absolute thermal contrast and Fig. 3b presents the surface temperature on slab
over sound (Ts) and delaminated (Td) areas.
2.5 300 32
radiant flux Td (experimental)
2 200 Ts (experimental)
External irridiaon (W/m2)
30
Experimental result Td (numerical )
1.5 Ts (Numerical )
Numerical predictions 100
28
Irridiation
abs. thermal contrast
(oC)
T (oC)
1 0
26
0.5 -100
24
0 -200
-0.5 -300 22
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Time (min) Time (min)
a) b)
Fig. 3 Experimental and numerical results. a absolute thermal contrast b surface temperature of
slab for sound and defected areas
Thermography for Detecting Subsurface Defects … 1171
The presence of water or moisture content on surface can interfere the quality of
thermal contrast. This would become consideration after the rainfall event. As water
has higher thermal mass and different emissivity than concrete so it can disrupt the
thermographic images to some extent [24]. Also, if the water saturates the
delamination, the thermal contrast will be lost as the water has much higher thermal
conductivity than air. Similarly, the object colour is one of the important compo-
nents that defines the surface emissivity. So, for different surface colour of concrete
there can be difference in the obtained thermal contrast.
The total heat input is taken as hourly average of radiation intensity (W/m2)
integrated over the time and presented in term W-hr/m2. The total heat input applied to
the system is varied from 220 W-hr/m2 to 900 W-hr/m2 under two different types of
radiation intensities (heating rate) and heating durations (i.e., Type 1 with higher heat
intensity and short duration, and Type 2 for lower heat intensity and longer heating
duration). For both cases, the total heat input was kept constant in order to see the
effect of heating rate and durations. The values of irradiation were chosen such that, it
could be associated with the diurnal solar radiation variation. Also, the hourly average
was adopted as the results are intended to present guidelines for passive thermography
for non-destructive health assessment in practice. To incorporate the effect of geo-
metric parameters of defects (i.e. size and depth), different geometric parameters are
defined (Table 3) for the above described parametric heating conditions. As in con-
ventional reinforced concrete structures the delaminations usually appear around
depth of 25 to 65 mm, a same depth range is considered for parametric study and
delamination area is considered from 50 to 300 cm2.
As illustrated in Fig. 3a, the maximum contrast appears somewhere in early cooling
phase. However, to avoid unquantifiable correlation between heat input and thermal
contrast, the peak contrast achieved during cooling phase is considered as sup-
plementary rise in contrast. And the maximum contrast taken as the one at the end
of heating phase only. Figure 4 presents the results of numerical parametric study,
where the slab was irradiated with two different types of radiation intensity and
durations as shown in Tables 2 and 3. Figure 4a shows the effect of total heat input
on absolute thermal contrast (ΔT) development for different depths of delamination
under aforementioned radiation types. It has been observed that absolute thermal
contrast (ΔT) has linear relationship with total heat input. However, the rate of
change in ΔT with total heat input varies with the depth of delamination and is more
sensitive for relatively shallow delamination. Similarly, for shallow depths it’s not
just total heat input that governs the thermal contrast development, but the radiation
intensity also plays a significant role. For example, as seen in Fig. 4a for a 25 mm
deep delamination under same total heat input but different radiation intensity (Type
1 and Type 2) ΔT is different. With increase in depth of delamination, this differ-
ence gradually reduces and in our case for example for a 63 mm deep delamination,
the ΔT values almost overlap for both Type 1 and Type 2 heating conditions.
Therefore, the governing factor is total heat input only for deep delamination.
Fig. 4 Numerical parametric study results a total heat input vs abs. thermal contrast for different
depths of delamination (area 200 cm2). b total heat required to generate 0.5 °C thermal contrast for
different depths. c total heat input vs. abs. thermal contrast for different areas of delamination
(depth 50 mm). d total heat input required to generate 0.5 °C thermal contrast for different areas
1174 B. N. K. Raja et al.
400
R² = 0.9875
200
100
0
500 1500 2500 3500 4500
Depth square z2 (mm2)
Fig. 5 Total heat flux as a function of square of depth of delamination to develop a thermal
contrast of 0.5 °C (area of delamination 200 cm2)
4 Conclusions
Infrared thermography has is a useful NDT technique for quick scanning of rein-
forced concrete structures. Due to large size of RC structures, usually passive
thermography is adopted. This technique depends upon environmental heat sources
and hence very sensitive to environmental conditions. The primary heat source for
passive thermography is solar radiations. In addition, the thermographic result is
dependent upon the defect parameters itself. In this study, we experimentally and
numerically investigated the influence of these parameters (external irradiation, size
and depth of delamination) on IRT result. The following are the major conclusions.
• The numerical model developed for this study, simulates the experimental data
reasonably well.
• The thermal contrast (ΔT) development in RC structures due to subsurface
defects has a positive linear relationship with total heat influx into the system. In
addition, heat flux rate and duration have a certain impact on DT based on
geometric characteristic of delamination.
• The influence of radiation heat flux and duration is more prominent for shallow
delamination and reduces with the of the delamination depth. Similarly, radia-
tion flux and duration have positive impact on detection of small size delami-
nation, but this impact diminishes with the increase delamination size (i.e.,
300 cm2 in our case).
• There is a linear relationship between delamination depth and the total heat input
required to generate a certain ΔT.
In summary, after certain depth and size of delamination (63 and 300 cm2 for
our study) the radiation duration and intensity has least effect on thermal contrast
development independently. It is the total heat input that governs the DT
Thermography for Detecting Subsurface Defects … 1175
Acknowledgements The authors wish to thank the Australian Research Council (ARC
IH150100006), Higher Education Commission (HEC), Pakistan and The University of Melbourne
for their support.
References
Abstract Corrosion may cause not only a reduction in thickness but a change in
the surface geometry, as well. Recent studies have shown that ductility capacity is
reduced by the presence of corrosion surface roughness. The current study inves-
tigated the role of the surface roughness in the reduction of the static ductility.
Standard uniaxial tensile tests were conducted on corroded steel plates exhibiting
varying surface roughness characteristics. The specimens were obtained from nat-
urally corroded steels having different material properties and corroded in different
environments. First, 3D surface heights measurements were performed to obtain
surface profile data for statistical quantification of surface roughness features. The
remaining load and elongation capacities were determined experimentally from the
tensile tests. The distribution of the surface strains was studied employing digital
image correlation techniques. From this work, the mechanism of ductility decrease
was confirmed to proceed as follows: Surface unevenness due to corrosion was
found to cause stress concentration and uneven yielding, and strain localization
after yielding during the tensile test. This translates to an early necking initiation,
resulting in reduced ductility in corroded specimens. Finally, empirical equations
for estimating remaining ductility of corroded steel based on surface roughness
characteristics are proposed.
Keywords Corrosion Ductility Surface roughness Digital image correlation
Residual capacity
N. Gathimba (&)
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Nagoya University,
Nagoya 464-8603, Japan
e-mail: gathimba.naftary.kimenju@i.mbox.nagoya-u.ac.jp
Y. Kitane
Department of Civil and Earth Resources Engineering, Kyoto University,
Kyoto 615-8540, Japan
e-mail: kitane.yasuo.2x@kyoto-u.ac.jp
1 Introduction
One of the important characteristics that have made carbon steel to become a
commonly preferred construction material in structural engineering is its high
ductility. In this study, ductility is defined as elongation of steel at fracture or at the
maximum load divided by the elongation at yield. Nevertheless, the steel is highly
prone to corrosion damage. Corrosion may cause a change in surface geometry in
addition to a reduction in thickness. A reduction in the thickness results in reduced
load-bearing capacity. However, ductility may not be significantly affected when
there is minimal variation in the surface configuration [8]. Studies on ductility
performance of steel with respect to surface geometry are very limited.
Ductility has been reported to decrease in a decreasing manner as the coefficient
of variation (COV) of the remaining thickness of a corroded specimen increased
[7]. In a recent study on the behavior of corroded steel subjected to cyclic loading
[3], it has been reported that the hysteretic energy dissipation capacity decreases
with an increase in surface roughness. However, it remains unresolved how static
ductility can be determined based on the surface roughness characteristics.
The purpose of this paper is to elucidate the role of corrosion surface roughness
in ductility reduction and hence seek possible ways of estimating remaining duc-
tility based on the surface roughness characteristics. To this end, thickness mea-
surement, as well as, analysis of thickness loss and surface roughness
characteristics, for steel plates corroded in different natural environments, and
having different material properties have been carried out. Then, the remaining load
and elongation capacities have been determined experimentally from the standard
uniaxial tensile test. From the distribution of surface strains, identified using DIC
techniques, the mechanism of ductility decrease due to surface roughness has been
clarified. In addition, regression models for estimating ductility based on surface
roughness characteristics are proposed.
The specimens were prepared from five different structural steel members, namely,
a bridge girder, sheet piles, weathering steel plates, channel sections, and a web of
H-section, corroded in different environments and possessing different material
properties. A total of 128 coupon specimens were prepared. Figure 1 shows the
sequence of preparing specimens from a typical corroded member. Corroded
coupon specimens were prepared by welding a corroded rectangular plate to
uncorroded tapered grip tabs to create a typical tensile coupon specimen (#5 in JIS
Z2241). The control specimens were prepared by removing corrosion unevenness
via milling, as shown in Fig. 1(d). Removing corrosion unevenness results in a
Estimating Remaining Ductility of Corroded Steel … 1179
First, the surface of the corroded coupon specimens was cleaned sufficiently so as to
remove corrosion products adhered to the surface using sand-blasting method,
while ensuring that the underlying surface profile was left unaltered as much as
possible. Then, the surface profiles on the corroded coupon specimens were mea-
sured using a laser displacement meter, for characterizing the condition of the
surface, as well as for estimating the remaining thickness. A 500 kN capacity
material testing machine was used in conducting the tensile tests. Specimens were
subjected to monotonic uniaxial tension by displacement control where the loading
rate was set at 0.1 and 1 mm/min before and after the onset of strain hardening,
respectively. During the loading, photographs were taken at a 5-s interval for
purposes of strain measurements over the entire gauge length section, measuring
50 mm long, using digital image correlation (DIC) techniques in order to obtain the
strain distribution characteristics.
Fig. 1 Sequence of preparing test specimens from a corroded steel bridge member
1180 N. Gathimba and Y. Kitane
Surface roughness data was obtained by removal of the nominal form, i.e., sub-
tracting a first order linear least squares mean plane from the measured surface
heights data. Surface roughness parameters, specified by ISO 25178-2 [6], were
then calculated on the resultant surface profile. A brief description of the roughness
parameters considered in the current study is given in Table 1. Parameters were
calculated for both the top and bottom surfaces of the coupon, and the average value
of the two surfaces was calculated for each specimen and used for subsequent
discussions.
Results of the computed surface roughness parameters are summarized in Fig. 2.
The largest variability of the surface roughness parameters was observed in the
bridge girder specimens. The relative standard deviation for the Sz, Sa, Sdq, and Sdr
parameters was calculated as 80, 106, 46 and 44%, respectively, depicting signif-
icantly varying corrosion surface characteristics. Detailed results of the surface
roughness parameters for the specimens from the channel section are shown in
Table 2.
Table 2 Surface roughness parameters and deformation indices for the specimen from the
channel section
Specimen Sz Sa Sdq Sdr Elongation (%) Plastic ductility
name (mm) (mm) Uniform Total Uniform Total
1C1-C1 – – – – 16.4 29.8 48.0 87.3
1C1-C2 – – – – 15.7 30.1 44.0 84.7
1C1-1 1.32 0.121 0.187 0.153 12.0 16.2 34.4 46.5
1C2-4 1.39 0.147 0.184 0.155 12.3 19.7 35.4 56.4
1C2-5 1.58 0.193 0.214 0.178 8.76 10.6 25.1 30.3
1C2-6 1.68 0.229 0.237 0.190 9.66 14.0 27.7 40.1
1C3-2 1.15 0.110 0.167 0.142 8.28 10.1 23.8 29.0
1C3-3 1.19 0.130 0.181 0.152 10.9 15.9 31.2 45.6
1C3-4 1.01 0.110 0.171 0.143 11.3 15.5 32.3 44.4
1C3-5 1.89 0.163 0.240 0.199 10.5 13.7 30.1 39.3
2C1-1 0.817 0.0572 0.170 0.142 15.7 25.5 45.1 73.3
2C1-2 1.04 0.0895 0.197 0.163 12.5 15.3 35.8 44.0
2C1-5 1.10 0.121 0.209 0.175 10.6 13.0 30.4 37.4
3.85 0.6
H-section
3.35 Sheet piles 0.5
Bridge girder
2.85
Channel section
0.4
1.85 0.3
1.35 0.2
0.85
0.1
0.35
0
-0.15
Sz Sa Sdq Sdr
Roughness parameter name
-0.65 -0.1
Fig. 2 Amplitude and hybrid surface roughness parameters for different specimens
Typical load-elongation curves for the tested coupon specimens are shown in Fig. 3
using specimens from the channel section. The control specimens, which do not have
1182 N. Gathimba and Y. Kitane
corroded surface, are denoted by suffices “C1”, “C2” and “C3”. Elongation was
expressed as percent elongation for the gauge length of 50 mm. The elongation
indices used for quantifying the elongation capacity are: uniform elongation, dm ,
which is the elongation at the point of the maximum load, total elongation, df , which is
the elongation at fracture, and necking elongation, dneck , which is the elongation
measured from the point of maximum load up to the fracture point ¼ df dm . The
computed elongation indices for the specimens from the channel section are tabulated
in Table 2.
The control specimens exhibit a significantly reduced load-bearing capacity due
to their reduced tmean resulting from the removal of corrosion unevenness. However,
the elongation capacity of these control specimens is more than that of the corroded
specimens. For example, specimen 1C1-C1 (tmean = 3.5 mm) has a df of 30% of the
initial gauge length, while the df of specimen 2C1-1 (tmean = 5.5 mm) that showed
the longest elongation among the corroded specimens, is 26%.
Again, a clearly defined yield plateau is manifested once the surface roughness is
eliminated from the control specimens, as can be seen on the inset in Fig. 3. The
yield plateau region represents the formation of Lüders bands [5], where the
material undergoes plastic deformation at the same rate until the whole gauge length
becomes fully-plastically deformed. For the corroded specimens, the absence of this
stable deformation region implies that initiation of yielding and consequently,
plastic deformation occur at different times. Therefore, surface unevenness causes
non-uniform yielding.
The dneck for the corroded specimens ranges from 13% to 52% of the dneck of the
control specimen. The dneck for the corroded specimens varies from 17% to 38% of
the df of the individual specimen, while the dneck of the control specimen was 47%
of df . The necking zone corresponds to the zone of diffuse and localized necking,
70
60 50
50
40
Load (kN)
40
30
30 0 2 4 6
20 1C1-C2 1C1-C1 1C1-1 1C2-4
1C2-5 1C2-6 1C3-2 1C3-3
10 1C3-4 1C3-5 2C1-1 2C1-2
2C1-5
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Elongation (%)
1.2
μm
1
Nomalized ductility
μf
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
Channel sheet piles H-section weathering
section steel
Specimen source
Fig. 4 Deformation capacity for corroded specimens having different material properties
1184 N. Gathimba and Y. Kitane
Strains over the entire gauge length section were measured employing a DIC
software. Strain distribution was examined at three loading stages, i.e., Stage 1: at
an elongation of 0.5%, Stage 2: at the maximum load and, Stage 3: just before final
fracture. Table 3 shows the distribution of remaining thickness and surface
roughness for specimen N2-1, one of the corroded specimens from the bridge
girder. The remaining thickness values vary between 1.0 mm and 9.0 mm. The
surface height values fluctuate within a range of 3.5 mm and 4.3 mm on the sides
‘A’ and ‘B’, respectively. Due to these thickness variation and surface unevenness,
variation in surface strains due to differential straining is anticipated.
Table 4 shows the distribution of the in-plane tensile strains on the surface of the
specimen N2-1 and the corresponding control specimen X1-C1. The maximum
strain value was set to a value of 5, 20, and 40% for the different stages of loading
for ease of comparison between specimens with different levels of corrosion. For
specimen X1-C1, Stage 1 corresponds to the yield plateau region. For this speci-
men, uniform plastic deformation initiated from the edges of the gauge length and
progressed towards the mid-section forming the Lüders bands, as seen in Table 4.
The strain varied from 0 to 2.4%. For specimen N2-1, strain concentration was
manifested at Stage 1. Strain values in specimen N2-1 varied from 0 to 5.5%, where
approximately 0.3% of the gauge length area has strain values of over 5.0%. The
valleys on the surface act as stress raisers which leads to stress concentration and
consequently strain concentration, i.e. non-uniformity in strain distribution.
A significant non-uniform strain distribution was observed at Stage 2 for the
corroded specimen. Whereas surface strains varied from 10 to 24% for specimen
X1-C1, the values varied from 0 to 51% for N2-1. Strain is more localized for the
corrosion case (N2-1), as can be seen in Table 4. As an illustration, specimen N2-1
N2-1
Estimating Remaining Ductility of Corroded Steel … 1185
Table 4 Comparison between surface strain distribution, at different levels of loading, for
specimens with and without surface roughness
X1-C1
N2-1
has an area of 4.1% of the total gauge length area undergoing straining of over 20%,
while for the specimen X1-C1, the percent area experiencing strains of over 20% is
about 11%. For the control specimen, strain localization may initiate at this point,
which is the onset of necking.
Past Stage 2, the geometry of the specimens starts to change as a result of the
initiation of diffuse necking. As the specimen approaches fracture point, strain
localization becomes more apparent, as is manifested in Table 4. For instance, at
Stage 3, about 12% of the gauge length area experiences a strain of over 40% for
the specimen X1-C1, while it is only 4.7% for the specimens N2-1. Therefore, it can
be seen that strain localization for specimen with corrosion roughness is more
pronounced than for the uncorroded specimens although the failure strains, ef , for
these specimens are almost equal at the fracture initiation point (ef ¼ 68.0% for X1-
C1 and 67.6% for N2-1).
In conclusion, corrosion surface unevenness causes stress and strain concen-
tration and non-uniform yielding. Thereafter, strain localization after yielding
occurs during the tensile test. This translates to an early necking initiation, resulting
in reduced ductility in corroded specimens. In addition, the reduced dneck resulting
in early failure, i.e., failure occurring immediately after the maximum load.
1186 N. Gathimba and Y. Kitane
0.4
0.2
0
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2
Average surface height ratio, ζSa
1
¼
l ð1Þ
1 þ kfp
where l is the normalized uniform or total plastic ductility of the corroded steel, fp
is a roughness parameter ratio obtained by normalizing a particular surface
roughness parameter with tmean , and k is a constant. Figure 5 shows a typical
combined plot for the tested specimens, where the trend of the normalized uniform
m with average surface height ratio, fSa ¼ Sa=tmean , is shown as m e,
ductility, l
where m is the mean, and e is the standard error of the estimation. Empirical
relationships of the form given by Eq. (1) were developed utilizing data from all the
specimens. A summary of the value of coefficient k and the value of e for different
ductility indices and surface roughness parameter ratios are given in Table 5. In the
f = normalized plastic ductility and fSz ¼ Sz=tmean .
table, l
Estimating Remaining Ductility of Corroded Steel … 1187
4 Conclusions
References
1 Introduction
Field investigations conducted after the 2011 Great East Japan earthquake con-
firmed that many road structures were inflicted severe damage due to the strong
ground motion and/or subsequent tsunami. For example, although RC bridge piers
of Utatsu Bridge on Route 45 were retrofitted by jacketing before the 2011 Great
East Japan earthquake to improve their seismic capacity against the strong ground
motion, the superstructure was washed away by giant tsunami [1]. It is of vital
importance to identify the dominant hazard when developing the retrofitting strat-
egy of infrastructures.
Since bridges are most vulnerable components in road networks, it is necessary
to pay special attention to prevent their damage [2]. In addition, the damage to
bridges caused significant economic losses and degradation of the functionality of
bridge networks. Therefore, it is important to determine the retrofitting prioritization
based on not only structural reliability but also risk considering the associated
consequence in terms of monetary loss, personal injury and death, and environ-
mental damage [3].
In this paper, a flowchart for estimating the risk of road networks subjected to
both seismic and tsunami hazards is presented. It is expected that economic losses
due to the damage to road structures resulting from the anticipated Nankai Trough
earthquake would be larger than those resulting from the 2011 Great East Japan
earthquake. In an illustrative example, the risk given the occurrence of anticipated
Nankai Trough earthquake is estimated. The procedure of risk-based retrofitting
prioritization of road structures is presented.
Figure 1 shows the procedure of risk estimation of road networks subjected to both
strong ground motion and tsunami caused by the anticipated Nankai Trough
earthquake. The seismic and tsunami faults are modeled considering uncertainties
associated with the average stress drop and slip angle based on the parameters
provided by Cabinet Office, Government of Japan [4]. These fault parameters are
used to estimate the seismic and tsunami intensities.
Non-linear dynamic analysis is performed in the seismic fragility analyses of
bridges and embankments. The amplitudes of seismic waves provided by Cabinet
Office, Government of Japan [4] are adjusted to be equal to specified seismic
intensities.
Hydrodynamic wave forces are calculated by the software CADMAS-SURF/3D
[5] and used in Push-over analysis to estimate tsunami fragility curves of bridges. In
addition, vertical wave forces are estimated to check against floating of the bridge
Risk Estimation of Bridges and Bridge Networks … 1191
Fig. 1 Procedure of risk estimation of road networks under both strong ground motion and
tsunami caused by anticipated Nankai Trough earthquake
embankments in the road network. The direct loss is calculated by multiplying the
failure probability and recovery cost. Lind is the indirect loss due to the increment of
the running time and traveling distance. This loss is estimated based on the func-
tionality deterioration and recovery time of the road network. The economic
effectiveness of retrofitting can be evaluated by using the benefit cost ratio (BCR).
A retrofitting is efficient if BCR is larger than 1.0.
3 Illustrative Example
Links in the road network shown in Fig. 2 are used in this case study. Old and new
bridges in the road network were designed according to the Japanese seismic
specifications published in 1964 and 1996, respectively [7, 8]. The design param-
eters of embankments were determined according to Shinoda [9].
Figure 3 shows the numerical results of BCR. It is assumed that only an old
bridge or an embankment in the road network is retrofitted. As shown in Fig. 3, the
retrofitting of Bridges 8 and 9 significantly results in large BCRs. The retrofitting of
these bridges can decrease failure probabilities effectively because tsunami hazard
intensity can be smaller with the increasing distance from the coastline. Therefore,
the highest priority should be given to the retrofitting Bridges 8 and 9.
North
8
C
E
Link 3
New bridge A
D
Old bridge
Embankment South
2
BCR = 1
4 Conclusions
The procedure of estimating the risk of road networks under both seismic and
tsunami hazards was proposed. In an illustrative example, the risk given the
occurrence of the anticipated Nankai Trough earthquake is estimated. Risk-based
approach is useful to make the decision on the retrofitting prioritization for road
structures.
References
3. Akiyama M, Frangopol DM, Ishibashi H (2020) Toward life-cycle reliability-, risk-, and
resilience-based design and assessment of bridges and bridge networks under independent and
interacting hazards. Struct Infrastruct Eng 16(1):26–50
4. Cabinet Office, Government of Japan (2012) Investigative commission on the modelling of
giant earthquake caused by Nankai Trough: Modelling of seismic fault. (in Japanese)
5. Coastal Development Institute of Technology (2010) CADMAS-SURF/3D Research and
development of numerical wave tank, Coastal Technology Library, No.39, 1–235
6. Shuto N (2001) Traffic hinderance after tsunamis. In: Hebenstreit, GT (ed) Tsunami research at
the end of a critical decade, vol 18, pp 65–74
7. Japan Road Association (1964) Design Specification for highway steel bridges
8. Japan Road Association (1996) specification for highway bridges. Part V: Seismic design
9. Shinoda M (2007) Quasi-Monte Carlo simulation with low-discrepancy sequence for
reinforced soil slopes. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 133(4):393–404
Device Development for Compressive
Stress Field Using Piezoelectric Actuator
Abstract It is important to control the growth of fatigue cracks for a long time.
These cracks usually occur from stress concentrations at corners, at heat-stress areas
from welding heat, and so on. Once started, fatigue cracks grow due to vibration.
When a crack reaches a certain threshold length, it is said to be in an unstable
fracture state and cannot be controlled. The aims of this study are to relax the stress
on stress-concentrated parts and to suppress crack growth. By using a piezoelectric
actuator to suppress crack growth, we were able to relax the stress on
stress-concentrated parts. However, if the piezoelectric actuator adhered to a test
piece directly, problems arose. For example, an amount of deformation escaped to
the outside, or repeated attachment and detachment damaged the actuator. We need
a method to locally and efficiently compress stress-concentrated areas. We also
need to learn how to detach the piezoelectric actuator from the test piece. Therefore,
we developed a device to create a compressive stress field that is easy to set. By
using this device, we can create compression locally and simply. We also per-
formed fatigue tests to confirm that this device prolonged the life of the material.
Keywords Fatigue Piezoelectric actuator Stress concentration Stress relax-
ation Infrastructure
1 Introduction
Japan‘s existing bridges were built during the period of high economic growth.
There are about 160,000 bridges and huge stocks of road bridges with bridge
lengths of 15 [m] or more (Fig. 1). Now about 15 [%] of the bridges in Japan are at
least 50 years old. Japan’s steel bridges need repair not only because of the
60 600
50 500
40 400
30 300
New bridges
20 Total bridges 200
10 100
0 0
Year
Fig. 1 Transitive graph of new bridges and total bridges over 15 [m]
unexpected increase in heavy vehicle traffic but also because the welding methods
used during construction are now obsolete. These fatigue cracks usually occur from
stress concentrations in corners, in welding-heat-stressed areas of the steel beams,
and so on (Fig. 2). Thus, for a long time it has been important to analyze stress
around cracks to assess the linear fracture mechanics based on elasticity. These
cracks usually grow due to vibration. Metropolitan expressways have many narrow
parts, and it is difficult, time-consuming, and expensive to repair fatigue cracks in
steel bridges under construction conditions. In steel bridges, an efficient mainte-
nance plan is important for repair and inspection. Also, municipalities possess many
road bridges with lengths of 2 [m] or more (Fig. 3) [1]. New repair and maintenance
methods for steel bridges must be developed.
The aims of this study are to relax the stress of stress-concentrated parts and to
suppress crack growth. To suppress crack growth, stress is relaxed by applying a
piezoelectric actuator to the area of crack growth. Figure 4 shows a pattern diagram
of the piezoelectric actuator.
The piezoelectric effect is the interactive effect between dynamic quantities, such
as strain and stress, and electric quantities, such as electric field and electric dis-
placement. A piezoelectric element makes use of this piezoelectric effect.
A piezoelectric actuator is one such element, and it has excellent responsiveness
and high occurrence. In this study, the actuator provided local force.
Device Development for Compressive Stress Field … 1197
3%
5%
26%
100%
66%
Fig. 3 Number of bridges by road type and total bridges over 2 [m] in length
1198 K. Obuchi et al.
2.1 Purpose
We use the piezoelectric actuator to apply the generated force in the crack closing
direction. This reduces stress concentration near the crack tip. We then relieve stress in
the fatigue test by applying a voltage to the piezoelectric actuator through the control
circuit. Figure 5 outlines the stress relaxation induced by the piezoelectric actuator.
In this experiment, in accordance with the standards for JIS plate-like test piece
No. 13A, test pieces are made using a wire electric discharge machine. The test
piece’s thickness is 2 [mm] and material is SS400 (yield point 235 [MPa], tensile
strength 400 [MPa]). A preliminary crack is made to determine the point of fatigue
crack initiation in the fatigue test. The preliminary crack length is 5 [mm] and the
tip shape is circular. The load on the test piece is 0—tension 7 [kN] (nominal stress
140 [MPa]). The test frequency is 10 [Hz]. The strain gauge is pasted at 10 [mm]
from the preliminary crack tip, and we measure the strain during the experiment.
The piezoelectric actuator used this experiment is the AE1010D16DF [2] made by
NEC/TOKIN (maximum output 3500 [N]) (Fig. 6).
Device Development for Compressive Stress Field … 1199
σ ∞y
Piezoelectric
actuator
a
Δa εy
2b ≈ 0
Strain gage
Test piece
σ ∞y
4000
Voltage load
3500
Voltage unload
Generative force F [N]
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Input voltage V [V]
4 Conclusion
In this study, in order to generate a load in the direction opposite that of the
generated stress, a high-power piezoelectric actuator was applied and a fatigue test
was performed. As a result of the stress relaxation experiments near the crack tip
under cyclic loading, we confirmed our predictions for crack growth and the effect
of stress relaxation; that is, when the amount of growth of the fatigue crack was in a
stable fracture state, we confirmed a life prolongation effect of about 160 [%].
When discussing repair work on steel bridges, butt plate repair [3], TIG welding,
and so on can be mentioned, but all are difficult to do under construction conditions.
As a new proposal for repair work, life extension experiments were conducted
focusing on the characteristics of “high response” and “high output” of a piezo-
electric actuator. In addition, various loads such as those in in-plane and
out-of-plane directions, are actually applied. Therefore, it is thought that the
applicable range of the piezoelectric actuator is expanded by identifying the pasting
position and direction of the piezoelectric actuator, and by optimizing the applied
voltage.
1202 K. Obuchi et al.
References
Abstract Due to the requirements of open space, there are almost no walls on the
ground floor of these buildings. The stiffness and strength of the ground floors are
weak compared to other levels. The buildings collapse in past earthquake due to
damage in the weak and soft stories is common situation. If the vertical members of
the soft stories are only shear-critical columns, the problem becomes even more
severe. To effectively evaluate and retrofit such buildings, it is necessary to clearly
define the stiffness and strength behavior of the shear-critical reinforced concrete
columns. According to the experimental observations, the shear failure and the
shear deformation caused by shear cracking occur in the D-regions with stress
concentration. Therefore, the method of dividing the range of the D-region, the
force transfer mechanism, and the corresponding lateral displacement prediction
model are proposed. To facilitate engineers to perform nonlinear pushover analysis,
a simple lateral load displacement curve for the shear critical reinforced concrete
columns is established in this paper. The proposed model can provide reasonable
prediction results in comparison with the experimental data. In this paper, it is
suggested that the shear deformation caused by shear crack expansion is included in
the lateral displacement calculation of strength point, which can accurately predict
the lateral stiffness of the shear-critical reinforced concrete column and improve the
reliability of seismic evaluation.
Keywords D-region Force transfer mechanism Non-ductile Shear critical
column Shear deformation
1 Introduction
Due to the requirements of open space, there are almost no walls on the ground
floor of soft story buildings. The stiffness and strength of the ground floors are weak
compared to other levels. The buildings collapse in past earthquake due to damage
in the weak and soft stories is common situation (Pujol et al. [8]). If the vertical
members of the soft stories are only shear-critical columns, the problem becomes
even more severe. Based on recent reconnaissance observations, the plastic hinge
zone or D-region of structural members is vulnerable under earthquake loading.
These types structural members are usually dominated by shear behavior due to
inadequate reinforcement. However, the deformation capacity of the shear critical
members is not small, as commonly expected according to reconnaissance obser-
vations. Therefore, a clear understanding of the seismic behavior of the shear
critical members is essential to the evaluation of the seismic performance of
buildings.
The D-region of a reinforced concrete structure contains a geometry disconti-
nuity and stress disturbed area. The shear strength analysis in the D-region is
difficult for engineers because of the complex force transfer mechanism. Based on
the D-region macro model, there are two different types of concrete struts (shown in
Fig. 1). One is the bottle-shaped concrete strut for short and deep structural
members, and the second is a fan-shaped concrete strut for longer members. The
prediction of shear strength in these two concrete strut shapes is different because of
the failure modes. The objective of this study is to propose an analytical model to
evaluate the shear behavior and force transfer mechanisms in these two types of
structural members.
concrete
crushing
For short and deep members with bottle-shaped strut, the shear strength can be
reasonably modeled using the strut-and-tie model. This paper utilizes the softened
strut-and-tie model (SST model) proposed by Hwang and Lee [2] to estimate the
shear strength. On the basis of the force transfer mechanism in the SST model,
combined with softening behaviors after reinforced concrete cracking, the concrete
crushing strength at the ends of diagonal struts is obtained. Figure 1a shows the
force transfer mechanism in the SST model used to predict the shear strength of
bottle-shaped strut.
For intermediate and typical columns, described by the force transfer mechanism
in Fig. 1b, the concrete struts between the fan-shaped main inclined strut cannot be
directly connected from the loading end to the reaction end. As shown in Fig. 1b,
there are two strengths in the compression fan; the first is the concrete crushing
strength (Vn;c ) in the compression zone at the column end of the compression fan
and the other is the tensile strength (Vn;t ) induced by the insufficient internal support
at the node. The concrete crush strength (Vn;c ) in the compression zone of the
column end can be predicted by the softened strut-and-tie model (Hwang and Lee
[2]), as shown in Eq. (1).
Vn;prop: ¼ smaller of Vn;c ; Vn;t ð3Þ
After determining how to evaluate the shear strength of shear critical members,
the proposed curve could be established by a tri-linear relationship to simulate the
shear behavior of a D-region under Earthquake Loading, as shown in Fig. 2. The
first segment indicates elastic behavior up to the shear cracking point. The strength
at the concrete shear cracking point is Vcr , and the corresponding displacement is
Dcr . The second segment represents the portion from the shear cracking point to the
shear strength point. Shear cracking of concrete results in a rapid increase in lateral
displacement. The main source of this displacement is shear deformation from
cracking. Therefore, the change in the gradient is due to the reduction in column
stiffness caused by shear cracking. As cracks propagate, concrete struts are formed
in the cracks, and the crushing strength of the struts is subsequently reached. The
corresponding shear strength and displacement are Vn;prop: and Dn;prop: , respectively.
The shear strength of shear critical members (Vn;prop: ) was proposed as above, and
the prediction of the lateral displacement at the strength point for shear critical
members under double curvature bending is described by Li et al [5].
The third segment is from post-peak shear strength degradation to axial failure at
the loss of vertical load-carrying capacity. This paper refers to the approach in
ASCE/SEI 41-13 [1] to predict the collapse point. Based on the hypothesis that the
lateral strength decay of the collapse point is zero, the lateral displacement of the
collapse point (Da;prop: ) can be predicted by:
where H = net column height; b = parameter from Table 10-8 in ASCE/SEI 41-13 [1].
Experimental data of short columns used in this study is a testing on 8 short column
specimens (Li et al. [3]), and the material properties of these experiments are listed
in Table 1. In addition, a paper by Moretti and Tassios [7] were also included.
Fig. 2 Proposed V
load-displacement curve for strength point
shear critical structural Vn , proposed
members
V cr cracking
point collapse
point
Δ
Δcr Δ n , proposed Δa , proposed
Seismic Evaluation of Non-ductile Reinforced ... 1207
Moretti and Tassios [7] reported experimental data on four short column specimens,
excluding specimens containing diagonal reinforcements.
Figure 3 presents the comparison between experimental envelopes and the
proposed lateral load displacement curve for the test specimens tested by Li et al.
[3] and Moretti and Tassios [7]. It can be seen that prior to reaching shear strength,
as concrete cracks in shear, the turning point of stiffness in the proposed curves and
experimental envelopes are in good agreement (Li and Hwang [4]. However,
ASCE/SEI 41-13 [1] assumes the shear strength drops rapidly after reaching the
peak strength, which is evidently inconsistent with the actual behavior. The
assumption of rapid loss of lateral strength will significantly affect the prediction of
internal force redistribution within the structure.
Table 1 contains the ratio of test results and calculated values using the proposed
curve. In terms of shear strength, the average ratio (AVG) of measured strength to
the analytical strength by the proposed model is 1.21 with a coefficient of variation
(COV) of 0.15. For the prediction of displacement at strength point by the proposed
model (Table 1), average test-to-calculation ratio is 1.40 with a coefficient of
variation of 0.30. The proposed method utilizes the SST model (Hwang and Lee
[2], which makes it easier to capture characteristics in the mechanical behavior of
short columns, leading to more accurate predictions.
According to the test-to-calculation ratio in Table 1, for shear strength prediction
of ASCE/SEI 41-13 [1], the average ratio is 1.00 with a coefficient of variation of
1208 Y. A. Li et al.
0
0 4 3 3 3
1 3 4
250 250
0
0 3 0 3 0 3 6
Drift Ratio (%)
Fig. 3 Comparison of proposed curve and ASCE/SEI 41-13 for short columns (Li and Hwang [4])
0.39. Although the average ratio is 1.00, there is a greater discrepancy among the
analytical values. The values in Table 3 also indicate that ASCE/SEI 41-13 [1]
significantly underestimates the displacement at the strength point. Its average
test-to-calculation ratio is 5.86 with a coefficient of variation of 0.45. This is due to
under-estimation of shear deformation.
This paper compares experimental data of intermediate short columns with the
existing analytical model, and based on those results, suggests a lateral load dis-
placement curve for intermediate short columns failed in shear with height-to-depth
ratios of between 2 and 4 (Li et al. [5]). The existing analytical model refers to the
evaluation method in ASCE/SEI 41-13 [1], but the experimental database follows
the experimental results of this paper, and the material properties of these experi-
ments are listed in Table 2.
Figure 4 shows the comparison of envelope curves of specimens in the exper-
imental and proposed lateral load displacement curve, the envelope curves of the
experiments in this paper can be seen in Fig. 4. Before intermediate short columns
reach their shear strength, stiffness softening can occur as the expansion of shear
cracks, this indicates the requirement to consider shear deformation induced by
Seismic Evaluation of Non-ductile Reinforced ... 1209
500
1000
4 3 3 3
3DL 3DH 3NL 3NH
500
0 4 8 3 6 3 6 3 6
shear cracking. After intermediate short columns reaching their shear strength, the
lateral strength decreases rapidly, and the straight line of negative stiffness of the
proposed curves matches the results of experiments. The prediction of the proposed
curve is rational and conservative.
Table 2 shows the prediction of shear strength in the proposed curves and
compares it with experimental results. The average value of the test-analytical
strength ratio is 0.99, and the coefficient of variation is 0.11. In terms of the
prediction of failure mode in the proposed model, the predictions are all shear
tensile failure, so the prediction complies with the results of ASCE/SEI 41-13 [1].
Table 2 also indicates the prediction of lateral displacement at the strength point
in the proposed curves and compares it with experimental values, the average value
1210 Y. A. Li et al.
5 Conclusions
References
1. American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) (2014) Seismic evaluation and retrofit of existing
buildings (41-13), ASCE/SEI 41-13. Reston, VA, p 518
2. Hwang SJ, Lee HJ (2002) Strength prediction for discontinuity regions by softened
strut-and-tie model. J Struct Eng ASCE 128(12):1519–1526
3. Li YA, Huang YT, Hwang SJ (2014) Seismic response of reinforced concrete short columns
failed in shear. ACI Struct J 111(4):945–954
4. Li YA, Hwang SJ (2017) Prediction of lateral load displacement curves for reinforced concrete
short columns failed in shear. J Struct Eng ASCE 143(2):04016164
5. Li YA, Weng PW, Hwang SJ (2019) Seismic performance of RC intermediate short columns
failed in shear. ACI Struct J 116(3):195–206
6. Lopes, MMPS (1991) Seismic behavior of reinforced concrete walls with low shear ratio, Ph.D.
Thesis, Department of Civil Engineering, University of London
7. Moretti ML, Tassios TP (2006) Behavior and ductility of reinforced concrete short columns
using global truss model. ACI Struct. J. 103(3):319–327
8. Pujol S, Irfanoglu A, Jahanshahi M, Laughery LA, Puranam A, Cheng LH, Hesam P, Lund A,
Wu RT, Hwang SJ, Chiou TC, Chung LL, Wu CL, Shen WC, Li YA, Weng PW, Hsiao FP,
Tsai TC, Lam WK, Lin CC, Li CH (2017) Performance of reinforced concrete buildings in the
2016 Taiwan (Meinong) earthquake, Purdue University Research Repository. https://doi.org/
10.4231/r7m32sz3
Design of an Experimental Set-up
to Capture the Dynamic Response
of Mass Timber Post-and-Beam Systems
Under a Column Removal Scenario
Abstract Mid-rise to tall mass timber buildings are required to be designed for
progressive collapse, as specified in the Australian National Construction Code
(NCC). Owing to the computational complexity of nonlinear dynamic procedures,
static procedures are usually adopted in the design practice. To take into account of
the dynamic and nonlinear characteristics of progressive collapse, the current design
guidelines, such as DoD [6] and GSA [9], suggest multiplying the static responses
by a dynamic increase factor to replicate the actual structural behaviour. However,
existing research on the progressive collapse of mass timber structures is extremely
limited, especially regarding their dynamic responses. This paper will firstly
introduce a literature review on existing designs of dynamic test set-ups under a
column removal scenario. Thereafter, the final design of a test set-up to capture the
dynamic behaviour of timber post-and-beam systems under a sudden column
removal scenario will be presented. Preliminary results are discussed showing the
effectiveness of the dynamic experimental set-up.
Keywords Mass timber building Progressive collapse Disproportionate col-
lapse Dynamic response Connectors
1 Introduction
Engineered wood products, such as cross laminated timber (CLT), glue laminated
timber (Glulam) and laminated veneer lumber (LVL), make it possible to build
mid-rise to tall timber buildings, as these products minimise the strength reduction
and variations from natural defects and anisotropic material characteristics. Such
buildings assembled from engineered wood products are referred to “mass timber
buildings” and are attracting international attention. Compared to concrete and steel
structures, mass timber buildings are advantageous of reduced global carbon
emissions, allow faster erection, require less onsite workforce requirement and
aesthetically pleasing. Moreover, in case of catastrophic events, lower density of
timber results in less inertia force and debris loads (Huber, Ekevad, Girhammar and
Berg [10]). Emblematic examples of mass timber buildings worthwhile to be
mentioned are: (1) The Crossroads, completed in 2013 in the USA, was the first
large-scale commercial utilisation of CLT panels manufactured in North America;
(2) The tallest (8 floors) mass timber building in the USA, Carbon 12, completed in
2018 with only 8 weeks of construction for the structure above the ground; (3) In
Brisbane (Australia), the 52-m tall “25 King Street”, completed in 2018, is the
world’s tallest and largest mass timber office building. Given the increasing height
of mass timber buildings, the social and economic consequences of a potential
progressive collapse event of one of these buildings would be devastating.
Therefore, mid-rise to tall mass timber buildings are required to be designed for
progressive collapse, as specified in the Australian National Construction Code
(NCC) (ABCB [1]). Progressive collapse is characterised by a disproportionate and
catastrophic failure of a structure due to a local damage caused by abnormal and
accidental events such as explosions, vehicle impacts or natural disasters
(Ellingwood [7]). Progressive collapse is essentially a dynamic and nonlinear event.
If the dynamic internal forces exceed the bearing capacity of the structural elements
adjacent to the local damage, it will cause sudden failures of these elements and in
turn, additional dynamic forces will be transferred throughout the remaining part of
building. This will eventually result in either stabilisation (reaching a new equi-
librium state) or collapse of the structure, depending on whether the internal energy
can be fully absorbed or otherwise (Marjanishvili [16]).
In design practice, linear and nonlinear static procedures are broadly used due to
their time and computational efficiencies when compared to complex nonlinear
dynamic analyses. Considering the dynamic effects and nonlinearity, the static
responses are multiplied by a dynamic increase factor (DIF) which is specified as
2.0 for wooden structures under load bearing wall removal scenario (DoD [6]; GSA
[9]). However, a rational DIF for mass timber post-and-beam structure under col-
umn removal scenarios has not yet been investigated. Hence, more experimental
and numerical research are needed urgently to gain a better understanding of
dynamic behaviours of mass timber post-and-beam systems (Arup [2]; Bita and
Tannert [5]; Ellis and Bougard [8]; Huber et al. [10]). This paper will firstly
introduce a comprehensive literature review regarding the existing designs of
Design of an Experimental Set-up to Capture … 1215
A quick release system plays an important role in progressive collapse tests under a
sudden column loss scenario, since it controls the release time of the experiments.
To trigger the dynamic responses, it is required that the release time should be less
than 1/10 of the natural period of the dominate structure above the removed column
(Biggs [4]; DoD [6]; GSA [9]).
Four typical quick release systems are found in the literature. (1) As shown in
Fig. 1a, the lost column was replaced by a dummy column mechanism which was
assembled with a three-hinged strut (Li et al. [12]). One glass rod was inserted to
the middle hinge to fix the strut then was broken by a pendulum hammer during the
experiments. (2) Similar mechanism can be found in Fig. 1b that the removed
column was support by a pin, with a small contact area between the tip of a
hemisphere steel ball and the surface of a steel stub (Qian and Li [20]). During the
test, the load release was triggered by a heavy hammer knocking down the steel
stub. (3) Apart from the concept of temporary supports underneath the removed
column, the quick release hook is also a common design (Liu, Fung and Tan [13];
Liu, Tan and Fung [14]; Pham and Tan [19]), as shown in Fig. 1c. The hook was
manually opened by jerking the rope, which could be easily operated under labo-
ratory conditions. (4) Another innovative quick release system was by using
electromagnets in conjunction with a scissors-type clamper (Fig. 1d) (Zhao, Yan,
Chen, Xu and Lu [22]). The member was welded with trapezoid grooved steel
cylinders which were interlocked by the scissors-type clamper. Once the power of
Fig. 1 Typical release systems a Three-hinged strut column quick release mechanism(Li, Li,
Jiang, & Lu, [12]); b Pin supported steel column quick release system (Qian & Li, [20]); c Quick
release hook (Liu et al., [13]; Liu et al., [14]; Pham and Tan, [19]); d Scissors-type truss member
breaking device (Zhao et al. [22])
1216 X. Cheng et al.
the electromagnets was switched off, with the help of pre-tension and
pre-compression springs, the clamp opens up to simulate a sudden breaking of the
load bearing element. Regarding the satisfaction of the loading procedure
requirement, the first (Fig. 1a) and the second (Fig. 1b) quick release designs are
the most suitable for triggering the dynamic effects with the release time less than
4% of the natural period measured during the tests, while the third (Fig. 1c) and the
last (Fig. 1d) have the percentage (release time to natural period) of around 20 and
10% respectively. However, the design of the quick release hook (Fig. 1c) is the
most convenient one under the laboratory conditions. Therefore, the quick release
hook concept has been adopted and improved in this study.
In static tests, a complete load-deflection curve can be obtained from a single test.
However, one dynamic test can produce only a single load-deflection data point,
because each test is performed under a single constant loading resulting to a cor-
responding maximum displacement. Therefore, the design of loading stages is of
vital importance in terms of getting as much information as possible through a
limited number of experiments. Static tests are often recommended prior to the
dynamic loading design, as they will provide a clear indication of the magnitude of
the dynamic initial release loads applied to the structure (Liu, Fung and Tan [13];
Liu, Tan and Fung [14]; Pham and Tan [19]; Tsai and You [21]). Theoretically, in
the elastic stage, the dynamic load is half the amount of the static load under the
same displacement (Biggs [4]). To validate the elastic response, specimens can be
loaded multiple times (i.e., 21.7, 30.4, 38.4 and 54.4% of the static yield load) in the
linear elastic stage (Tsai and You [21]), under the assumption that no significant
damage occurs during this stage. Thereafter, each specimen can be reused to test the
nonlinear dynamic responses, with the release loads usually less than 50% of the
static ultimate load (Liu et al. [14]; Peng, Orton, Liu and Tian [17]; Pham and Tan
[19] ∛; Tsai and You [21]).
static yield load, as well as between the static yield load and up to 65% of the static
ultimate capacity) were executed to collect sufficient data whilst making the best
utilisation of the test specimens.
Three types of beam-to-column connectors (referred to as T-section,
Double-beam and Knapp connectors) used in mass timber buildings were adopted,
which were the same as the ones used in the static tests reported in Lyu et al. [15].
The overall length of the two-bay substructure was 4 m with a short middle column
stud being considered as the removed column. All the LVL softwood timber col-
umns (90 90 1500 mm3) and beams (150 63 1998 mm3 for
Double-beam connectors or 150 63 1910 mm3 for Knapp connectors) were
from hySPAN with veneer species Radiata pine or Douglas fir. The clearance
height was designed to be twice that in the static tests, to avoid potential contact
between the substructure and the floor before collapse. Both side columns were pin
connected to rigid support to simulate the horizontal restraints from adjacent bays in
the actual structure. The mass was rigidly and symmetrically attached to the middle
column and was sudden released by a specially designed quick release system
(Sect. 3.2) to replicate the free-fall acceleration. Roller supports were placed at the
bottom of side columns to release the shear force between them and the floor.
A 250kN capacity Moog servo-controlled hydraulic actuator was pin connected to
the top of the quick release system to adjust the height of the frame in a controlled
and precise way. Moreover, the out-of-plane movement of the frame was also
prevented in the set-up (Sect. 3.3).
To meet the loading procedure requirements specified in the guidelines (DoD [6];
GSA [9]), a quick release system consisted of a snap hook and a lever arm handle
was designed, as shown in Fig. 3a. A rope was attached to the lever arm, allowing
the hook to be opened by simply yanking the rope from a safe distance.
1218 X. Cheng et al.
(a) (b)
To allow the 2D timber frame to undergo in-plane displacement during the tests, its
out-of-plane movement must be restrained. A specially designed column cap with a
single ring ball bearing was screwed to the top end of each side column and was
positioned in a channel made by steel RHS (Fig. 3b), which allowed the column to
move freely in-plane but its out-of-plane movement was restricted.
As mentioned previously, the test specimens were scaled down to ¼ of the original
design. This practice is commonly done in researches on progressive collapse to
account for budget and laboratory size restrictions. Design guidelines for concrete
and steel buildings, such as DoD [6] and GSA [9], were mainly developed from
such tests. It is well known that timber structures are sensitive to size effects
(Isaksson [11]), a phenomenon also encountered in concrete structures (Bažant and
Yu [3]). Research in Masaeli, Gilbert, Karampour, Underhill, Lyu, Gunalan and
Guan [16] proved that the nonlinear moment and shear behavior of the ¼ scaled
connections used in this study, and in which the deformation mainly occurs, are
similar to the behaviours of the full scaled connections. The scaling effect mainly
impacted the capacity of the connections, not their behavior. Therefore, while the
scaling effect may affect the experimental capacities, the overall structural beha-
viours under the dynamic loading scenarios will not change and will provide
in-depth understanding of the dynamic behaviour of post-and-beam timber build-
ings under a column removal scenario.
Design of an Experimental Set-up to Capture … 1219
Four pinned 75kN S-shaped load cells (LC1-LC4 in Fig. 4) were attached to the
side columns and rigid frame to measure the axial force in the beam and the
moment developed in the connector (Lyu et al. [15]). Another 10kN S-shaped load
cell (LC5 in Fig. 4) was connected to the quick release system to measure the
dynamic initial release load as well as to capture the release time. The vertical
reaction forces were measured by two 10kN pancake load cells (LC6 & LC7 in
Fig. 4) positioned at the bottom of each side column. Laser displacement sensors
(L1 & L2 in Fig. 4) were used to directly measure the rapid change of the vertical
displacement (average value the readings from L1 & L2) of the middle column. In
addition, the vertical displacement at the mid-point of each beam was measured by
two laser displacement sensors (L5 & L6 in Fig. 4). Another two pairs of laser
displacement sensors (RL1-RL4 in Fig. 4) were attached to the middle column to
obtain the relative beam to column rotations (Fig. 5), i.e., the average relative
horizontal displacement between the two pairs of sensors divided by their vertical
distance. Two strain gauges (SG1 & SG2 in Fig. 4) were placed on the top and
bottom surface at the mid-span of the right-hand beam to capture the strain profile
during the tests. Moreover, the acceleration response of the substructure was
recorded by two accelerometers (AC1 & AC2 in Fig. 4) with a 5 g measurement
range. All the sensors were recorded at a sampling rate of 1000 Hz.
Typical test results of the test specimen with Knapp connectors, under a dynamic
initial release load of 50% of the static yield load are shown to validate the
effectiveness of the dynamic test set-up (Fig. 6). Duration of the release time (tr) can
be analysed from the force-time history plot of LC5 (Fig. 6a), based on the period
between the moment when the initial release load started to drop and the moment
when the load decreased to zero. The results indicate that the release time was
around 3 ms. On the other hand, the natural period (T) of the substructure can be
determined from the vertical displacement (middle column) - time history results
(Fig. 6b) and was around 230 ms. Using the same principles, the release times of all
the tested substructures were significantly less than 1/10 of their respective natural
periods, which met the loading procedure requirement mentioned in Sect. 2.1.
Moreover, the vertical displacement results also indicated a large damping in the
system.
Thereafter, the average moment developed in the Knapp connector (Fig. 6c), the
average beam-to-column rotation (Fig. 6d), the total vertical reaction (Fig. 6e) and
the acceleration response (Fig. 6f) of the specimen are presented, showing that the
dynamic effects have been triggered during the tests. In the moment-time history
curve of the connector (Fig. 6c), a large fluctuation has been observed around the
equilibrium state. In addition, the average rotation curve (Fig. 6d) showed a
time-history similar to the other responses of the specimen (Fig. 6b, c, e, f),
revealing that the beam-to-column rotation measurement set-up was effective. To
confirm that no vertical load has been transferred through the horizontal column
side load cells (L1-L4), the total vertical reaction is plotted with time in Fig. 6e,
showing almost the same value as the initial release load measured from the top
S-shaped load cell (LC5) (Fig. 6a), with an average of 2.5% difference.
Two types of connectors were tested, and different failure modes were observed in
each. In the test specimens with Double beam connectors, timber tensile failure
Design of an Experimental Set-up to Capture … 1221
perpendicular to the grain occurred in the middle column at the bolts location
(Fig. 7a). On the other hand, failure happened in the aluminum bracket for the
specimens with Knapp connectors (Fig. 7b). The failure modes have shown a
significant similarity with the ones observed in the static tests (Lyu et al. [15]).
However, failures of the dynamic test specimens were more likely to be
unsymmetrical.
1222 X. Cheng et al.
Fig. 7 Dynamic test failure modes of a Double beam connector; b Knapp connector
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank PhD candidates Mr Chunhao Lyu and Mr
Mahyar Masaeli for their valuable assistance in making these experiments possible. The financial
support provided by the ARC Industrial Transformation Research Hub IH150100030 and the
School of Engineering and Built Environment, Griffith University is also gratefully acknowledged.
References
10. Huber JA, Ekevad M, Girhammar UA, Berg S (2019) Structural robustness and timber
buildings–a review. Wood Mat Sci Eng 14(2):107–128
11. Isaksson T (2003) Structural timber—variability and statistical modelling. Timber engineer-
ing. Wiley, Chichester, pp 45–66
12. Li GQ, Li LL, Jiang B, Lu Y (2018) Experimental study on progressive collapse resistance of
steel frames under a sudden column removal scenario. J Constr Steel Res 147:1–15
13. Liu C, Fung TC, Tan KH (2015) Dynamic performance of flush end-plate beam-column
connections and design applications in progressive collapse. J Struct Eng 142(1):04015074
14. Liu C, Tan KH, Fung TC (2013) Dynamic behaviour of web cleat connections subjected to
sudden column removal scenario. J Constr Steel Res 86:92–106
15. Lyu C, et al. (2018) Progressive collapse (Robustness) behaviour of mid-rise mass timber
frame buildings. In: World Conference on Timber Engineering (WCET), 20–23 August 2018,
Seoul, Republic of Korea
16. Marjanishvili SM (2004) Progressive analysis procedure for progressive collapse. J Perform
Constr Facilit 18(2):79–85
17. Peng Z, Orton SL, Liu J, Tian Y (2017) Experimental study of dynamic progressive collapse
in flat-plate buildings subjected to exterior column removal. J Struct Eng 143(9):04017125
18. Masaeli M, et al. (2018) Full-scale and quarter-scale moment and shear behaviour of three
types of beam-to-column connectors used in mass timber buildings. In: Australasian
Conference on the Mechanics of Structures and Materials (ACMSM25), Brisbane, Australia
(2018)
19. Pham AT, Tan KH (2017) Experimental study on dynamic responses of reinforced concrete
frames under sudden column removal applying concentrated loading. Eng Struct 139:31–45
20. Qian K, Li B (2013) Quantification of slab influences on the dynamic performance of RC
frames against progressive collapse. J Performan Constr Facilit 29(1):04014029
21. Tsai M-H, You Z-K (2012) Experimental evaluation of inelastic dynamic amplification
factors for progressive collapse analysis under sudden support loss. Mech Res Commun
40:56–62
22. Zhao X, Yan S, Chen Y, Xu Z, Lu Y (2017) Experimental study on progressive
collapse-resistant behavior of planar trusses. Eng Struct 135:104–116
A Voxel-Based Method for Automated
Road Surface Extraction from Mobile
Laser Scanning Data in Expressway
Environment
1 Introduction
Poor road surface quality of expressway can lead to the severe traffic casualty.
Periodical maintenance and assessment of road surface should, therefore, be
checked by the maintenance expressway authorities so as to make convenience,
comfort, and safety for the driver. Collecting and updating all road surface infor-
mation of expressway such as road surface quality, lane’s number, lane’s width,
manhole, road slope, road marking, road curb, road crack status are essential for the
maintenance agency. Conventionally, all expressway information data are manually
collected on–site by the inspector and then the on–site information was combined
with two–dimensional (2D) as–built drawing to create a historical database of
expressway infrastructure. Due to the complex and large scale of expressway
infrastructure, this traditional method had disadvantages such as tedious, time–
consuming, labor cost and occasionally incomplete data collection.
Recently, there are several emerging advanced methods such as aerial photog-
raphy, satellite imagery, satellite remote sensing, aerial laser scanning (ALS) and
mobile laser scanning (MLS) to collect the large–scale information in 2D and 3D
format. Capturing precise and accurate 3D spatial data along the expressway in an
urban environment, MLS are broadly used in the recent decade for the purpose of
collecting road geometries data for maintenance management inside the city.
Producing dense and huge geospatial data in the vast expressway area with road
speeds is one of an advantage of mobile laser scanning. Using point cloud data
collected from MLS, all road surface geometry can be obtained by post–processing
3D point clouds, and each geometry can be extracted individually for the purpose of
maintenance work. However, it is a big challenge to deal with the complicated
characters of 3D point cloud collected from MLS such as density variation, dense
(3,000 points/m2), massive volume, unstructured pattern (Wu et at. [5]). Thus, it is
essential to propose the robust, reliable and accurate method to extract road surface
in an automated and effective way by inheriting the advantage of MLS.
To this end, we are motivated to develop an algorithm for automated extraction
road surface from point cloud data collected by MLS. The research reported in this
paper is a part of a larger study that aims at developing InfraDoctor System for
enhancing efficiency and effectiveness in maintenance and management work of
expressway infrastructure in Japan and Southeast Asia.
2 Literature Review
To extract the road surface, some authors developed the algorithm to detect the road
edge first, and then the road surface point data were recovered from the extracted
road edge in such a way that all points located inside the road edge were obtained to
construct the road surface. Cabo et al. [2] suggested the method to automatic
extraction road asphalt edge by applying the line clouds concept. A transformation
A Voxel-Based Method for Automated Road Surface Extraction ... 1227
from the initial point clouds into line clouds data was performed, and then quasi–
planar constraint was applied to assemble all lines whose having a similar character.
Subsequently, all points located at the end of the line group were obtained to
construct the road edge, and two–step smoothing approach was used finally to
recover some incorrect points which were not detected from the previous
step. Miraliakbari et al. [3] used two– and four–neighborhood region growing to
extract the curbstone edge and the road surface. Zhang [9] extracted road surface
from LiDAR data based on the combination of elevation information and prior
knowledge of the minimal road width. Yang et al. [7] proposed a scan line–based
approach to detect the road curb, and then the road surface was constructed from
that road curb.
Apart from using the road edge as the preparatory step for extracting the road
surface, several methods were processed to extract the road surface via integrating
the 3D point cloud data with additional road feature information or based on some
assumption of a road surface. Wu et al. [5] presented the method to detect the road
surface in the urban environment consisting of three–phase as follows: trajectory
data were used to reorganize the point cloud into vertical profile; an adaptive alpha
shapes algorithm was built to detect the ground points; an elevation variation filter
was performed to refine the road surface point. Yadav et al. [6] used some addi-
tional information of the road such as road roughness, road spatial geometry, and
point clouds density, to extract the road surface. Yang et al. [8] developed the
binary kernel descriptor (BKD) that represented 3D local features to extract the road
curbs and road surfaces. However, the method was expensive computation due to
kernel density estimation step.
In summary, many methods were proposed to automatically extract the road
surface by using the 3D point data. However, most of the above–mentioned
reviewed methods extracted the road surface based on the additional information
such as road roughness, road spatial geometry, returned pulse width, returned
intensity, local point density, GPS time, scan line information. In the expressway
environment, it is observed that there is a presence of the road edge/road curb which
is the noticeable character of all expressways in an urban environment. Thus, the
authors proposed the approach to extract road surface for expressway based on the
existence of the road edge/road curb.
3 Methodology
The proposed method consists of three steps (Fig. 1): (1) determine the seeding
voxel via integrating seeding points and voxel model; (2) extraction of road surface
points by employing voxel–based segmentation algorithm; (3) road surface
refinement.
1228 T. T. Ha et al.
Fig. 1 Workflow for road surface extraction from MLS point cloud data
The procedure consists of three substeps: (i) voxel model was built via octree
structure; (ii) determine the seeding points which solely belong to road surface;
(iii) the seeding voxels is extracted by selecting voxels which contain only the
seeding points.
From the set of point cloud Pi = (xi, yi, zi) R3, i = 1,…, n, where n is the total
number of point clouds, the initial bounding box enclosing entire data can be
determined by two components, that is, the origin O(xmin, ymin, zmin) and the length
of voxel Δx = Δy = Δz = max[|xmax-xmin,|ymax- ymin|, |zmax- zmin|]; where (xmin, ymin,
zmin) and (xmax, ymax, zmax) are minimum and maximum of the x, y, z coordinates of
the point cloud, respectively. The octree was then recursively subdivided the
bounding box along x, y, z directions until reaching the termination conditions. In
this implementation, the voxel size was chosen as a termination condition.
Moreover, the voxel was classified as “full” if the voxel contains at least 3 points,
otherwise, “empty”. It is noted that the subdivision was applied to only the full
voxels.
Since the road surface is an objective of this segmentation, the points within the
voxel were assumed to describe a patch of the road surface. In this implementation,
principal component analysis (PCA) was employed to estimate a normal vector of
each full voxel (see Eq. 1, 2), while the root mean square of orthogonal distances
from the points to the fitting surface was considered as the residual (Eq. 3).
A Voxel-Based Method for Automated Road Surface Extraction ... 1229
1 X m
CV ¼ ð pi pÞ ð pi pÞ T ð1Þ
m 1 i¼1
1X m
1X m
1X m
pX ¼ xi ; pY ¼ yi ;
pZ ¼ zi ; ð2Þ
m i¼1 m i¼1 m i¼1
vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
uP
um 2
u di
ti¼1
r¼ ð3Þ
m
where CV represents the covariance matrix of a set of points in each full voxel; pi is
the coordinate of each point in voxel; pðpX ; pY ; pZ Þ denotes the mean of a set of
points in each full voxel; m represents the total number of points in each voxel; r is
residual; di is referred to as the orthogonal distance from point ith to its fitting plane;
xj, yj, zj represent the value of coordinate of point ith in each voxel.
In addition, the centroid’s coordinate of voxel VJ = (VXj , VYj , VZj ) R3, j = 1,…,k,
where k are the total number of voxels in the octree structure, was calculated as
follows:
1X 1X 1X
Pj j P j P
VjX ¼ xj ; VjY ¼ yj ; VjZ ¼ zj ; ð4Þ
Pj j¼1 Pj j¼1 Pj j¼1
where Pj are the total number of data points within voxel Vj.
The candidate seeding points were extracted based on the trajectory data. It is
observed that the road surface points are located under or away from the trajectory
data at a certain distance (Fig. 2a). Thus, the point cloud was first projected onto XY
plane, and then the 2D neighborhood search function with a certain radius was
employed to find the candidate seeding points. As shown in (Fig. 2b), the cluster of
the neighboring points of the trajectory point T1 was determined. It is seen that the
value of searching radius (R) in neighborhood search function could affect the
seeding point result; for example, if R is less than the minimum voxel size, the
seeding voxel may not be found by the intersection between the seeding point and
the cluster point in each voxel. Thus, the value of R should be larger than the voxel
size to expose all candidate seeding points. As a result, the set of candidate seeding
points A2D 2D
XY , was obtained corresponding to the trajectory point T1. From AXY , the
points with Z coordinate and having the same value X, Y coordinate, that is, A3D XYZ,
1230 T. T. Ha et al.
2D
Point clouds AXY Trajectory point T1
(a) (b)
Fig. 2 Point cloud data. (a) Trajectory data; (b) 2D neighborhood search function
were retrieved from MLS point clouds. However, some non–candidate seeding
points where coordinate is the same value of X and Y with the road surface points,
but different in Z value, are still present in the set of A3D
XYZ. Therefore, the further
filtering process is needed for eliminating the non–candidate seeding points out of
A3D
XYZ.
The density distribution of the seeding points (ground points) is always greater
than that of the non–candidate points due to the high density of ground points
which is located nearby the trajectory data (Armesto et al. [1]). By employing the
statistic analysis, the probability density function of the seeding point which is
characterized by kernel distribution can be obtained. The kernel density estimator
^ h) is used on Z value of the set of candidate seeding points A3D
(F XYZ to eliminate the
non–candidate seeding points, and is given as Eq. 5:
Xn3D
^ h ðZ Þ ¼ 1 XYZ
Z Zi
F K ð5Þ
n3D
XYZ h i¼1 h
where n3D XYZ denotes the total number of candidate seeding points in the set of
candidate seeding points A3D XYZ; K presents the kernel function, and h is the band-
width. The value h of 0.1 is used in this paper.
For each set of A3DXYZ with respect to each trajectory point T, the kernel density
estimator of all points in each set was computed. As above–mentioned, the value of
kernel density estimator of seeding point which belongs to road surface always
higher than that of the non–candidate seeding points. Thus, the point having the ZF^h
^
h value corresponding to the highest Fh value was chosen as the representative of
the elevation for the cluster of seeding point. However, due to the elevation vari-
ation or roughness of the road surface, all points having the |Z F ^h ± h| value were
experimentally selected as the seeding point (Fig. 3). As a result, the set of seeding
points were generated, that is, Pseeding
i (i = 1 to ntrajectory), where ntrajectory is the
total of trajectory points.
A Voxel-Based Method for Automated Road Surface Extraction ... 1231
the cluster of
(kernel density)
h
seeding point
Z (Elevation)
After the set of seeding points, Pseeding, was obtained, the seeding voxel can be
determined in such a way that only the voxel containing the seeding points was
selected as the seeding voxel. The set of seeding voxel was generated using Eq. 6:
ifPj 2 Vj and Pj 2 Pseeding : Vseeding
8Vj ð0 j kÞ : ð6Þ
else
It is observed that all voxels which contain only road surface point belonging to the
one segment. The region growing was similar to the procedure that was performed
in Vo et al. [4], except that the seeding voxel (Vseeding) was used as the initial seed
instead of the voxel with the minimum residual. Additionally, the condition of the
Z elevation difference between the current voxel and its neighbors was added to
remove the voxel that satisfied the angle threshold condition which is defined by the
angle between normal vectors of two adjoining voxels. The Z elevation difference
between two neighbors voxel should be smaller than the rise in cross–section of the
road which is defined by the cross slope function. After the segment R1 including all
voxels that satisfied the feature condition such as angle, residual and slope condi-
tion were obtained, there were present of some voxels along the boundary of the
road consist of both road surface and non–road surface points. It is thus necessary to
delete that voxels out of the segment R1. If the difference Z elevation which is
characterized by the difference between the maximum and minimum of
Z coordinate of all points in each voxel is higher than the slope function, the voxel
was removed out of the segment R1. Finally, the set of voxel which contained only
1232 T. T. Ha et al.
the road surface points was generated (R2). However, there are missing some road
surface points which are located near the road boundary. Thus, the additional
process is required to recover the missing points.
First, the list of voxel located on the boundary of the segment R2, namely, boundary
voxel (Vb) was generated based on the definition that the voxel on the boundary of
the segment often had less than eight neighborhood voxels from the same segment
(Vo et al. [4]). Next, each voxel (vh) in the boundary voxel was used to find the
adjoining voxel (vt) from the remaining voxel that was not present in the list of
voxel R2. The orthogonal distances from each point (pt) inside adjoining voxel to
the plane (xh ) that fitting through all points located within voxel vh were computed,
and if the distance is less than the distance threshold Δth, the point pt was added to
the segment R2. The value of the distance threshold Δth (user–defined) was chosen
based on the accumulation of two parameters, that is, the noise level accuracy of
laser scanner and the roughness of the road surface near the curb where the different
height is obviously observed between the road surface and sidewalk in expressway
environment.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 4 Point clouds of: (a) BangNa elevated expressway. (b) Rama IX Bridge
representative of the evaluation metrics for the comparison. The three indices, that
is, recall, precision, and quality, were obtained using Eq. 7:
TP TP
Recall ¼ 100%; Precision ¼ 100%; Quality
TP + FN TP + FP
TP
¼ 100% ð7Þ
TP + FP + FN
where TP is the detected road surface points belong to ground truth and proposed
method, FN is road surface points in the ground truth data but not detect in the
proposed method data, FP is the detected road surface points in the proposed
method data but not found in the ground truth.
As shown in Table 2, the value of recall, precision, and quality for Site 1 were
99.9%, 97.4%, and 97.4%, respectively; whereas Site 2 achieved 99.1%, 95.2%,
and 94.4%, respectively. It can be seen that the proposed algorithm detected and
extracted the road surface in Site 1 at higher accuracy than those from Site 2. In Site
2, the points at the road boundary in the main span length of the bridge were
misclassified as non–road points (Table 2). That is because there is no presence of
noticeable height jump at the boundary along the bridge.
1234 T. T. Ha et al.
Fig. 5 Road surface extraction. (a) BangNa elevated expressway. (b) Rama IX Bridge
5 Conclusion
In this paper, the method was introduced for automated extraction of the road
surface in an expressway environment from point cloud data collected by MLS.
Observe that there is a presence of the road curb along the road which is the
noticeable character of all expressways, the voxel– and curved–based segmentation
algorithm was proposed to extract the road surface out of the huge point cloud data
in the vast expressway area. The proposed method consists of three steps: (1) define
the seeding voxel by combining seeding points and voxel model; (2) voxel–based
segmentation algorithm was applied to extract the road surface; (3) curved–based
segmentation algorithm was employed for road surface refinement. Two test sites
including flat and bumpy with a high slope of road surfaces were then used to assess
the efficiency of the proposed method. With the average recall, precision and
quality results of 99.5%, 96.3%, and 95.9% at two test sites. This proved that the
proposed algorithm was a reliable, robust method to extract road surface at high
accuracy.
References
1. Armesto J, Pardiñas RJ, Lorenzo H, Arias P (2010) Modelling masonry arches shape using
terrestrial laser scanning data and nonparametric methods. Eng Struct 32:607–615
2. Cabo C, Kukko A, García-Cortés S, Kaartinen H, Hyyppä J, Ordoñez C (2016) An algorithm
for automatic road asphalt edge delineation from mobile laser scanner data using the line clouds
concept. Remote Sensing 8(9):1–20
3. Miraliakbari A, Hahn M, Sok S (2015) Automatic extraction of road surface and curbstone
edges from mobile laser scanning data. In: International Archives of the Photogrammetry,
Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences XL-4/W5, pp. 118–124
4. Vo AV, Hong LT, Laefer DF, Bertolotto M (2015) Octree-based region growing for point
cloud segmentation. ISPRS J. Photogrammetry Remote Sensing 104:88–100
5. Wu B, Yu B, Huang C, Wu Q, Wu J (2016) Automated extraction of ground surface along
urban roads from mobile laser scanning point clouds. Remote Sensing Lett. 7(2):170–179
6. Yadav M, Singh AK, Lohani B (2017) Extraction of road surface from mobile lidar data of
complex road environment. Int J Remote Sens 38(16):4655–4682
7. Yang B, Fang L, Li J (2013) Semi-automated extraction and delineation of 3d roads of street
scene from mobile laser scanning point clouds. ISPRS J. Photogrammetry Remote Sens.
79:80–93
8. Yang B, Liu Y, Dong Z, Liang F, Li B, Peng X (2017) 3D local feature BKD to extract road
information from mobile laser scanning point clouds. ISPRS J Photogrammetry Remote Sens
130:329–343
9. Zhang W (2010) Lidar based road and road-edge detection. In: Proceedings of IEEE Intelligent
Vehicles Symposium (IV), San Diego, pp. 845–848
Optimal Bridge Maintenance
Algorithms Considering Subordinate
Relation with Bridge Members
Abstract Recently, social interest in the deteriorated bridges and infrastructure has
been increasing. Also, studies on performance prediction and maintenance decision
making of structures are underway. In this study, it was proposed an algorithm to
create an optimal maintenance scenario that takes into consideration the relationship
between the members of bridge that affect each other, rather than the conventional
maintenance that is focused on single members of the bridge.
Since maintenance scenario creation is discrete in terms of time and cost. So in
this study, it is used a genetic algorithm. Each member of bridge has a subordinate
relation that takes into account member damage transitions effect and the elimi-
nation of duplication maintenance cost, which was established through the Korean
bridge maintenance manual and expert opinion. In order to predict the performance
change of each member, the algorithm used the condition prediction model of each
member of the bridge, which was created by multiple regression analysis based on
the actual bridge case. Also, it used the maintenance cost model of members for
cost estimation, it has created and applied it through actual maintenance case
analysis. The constraint of the algorithm is set to the minimum maintenance level of
the bridge by the bridge administrator. And, it was conducted the case study about
real bridge model using the optimal maintenance model, analyzed the cost-effect
and made maintenance scenario.
1 Introduction
To optimize time point and cost for maintenance are required to satisfy correlation
in each member and various constraints. And then, a genetic algorithm has some
effective advantages to estimate various variables and constraints. So, in this study,
there is suggested the model to predict optimal time point and cost for bridge
maintenance, using a genetic algorithm(G,A).
The prediction model of bridge member condition is made to forecast each member
condition rate up to the target life of the bridge. And this model is based on safety
inspection and in-depth inspection data of the national road bridges in Korea since
1995. In Fig. 1, the condition prediction model was developed by polynomial
Optimal Bridge Maintenance Algorithms … 1239
Fig. 1 Concept about prediction model of bridge member condition and maintenance cost
regression results which were based on bridge condition ratings, and the difference
in the degree of deterioration expressed the deterioration ratio in the point of
maintenance before and before after.
The rating maintenance cost function was proposed by specialists’ opinions and
maintenance rating cost data, and it was shown that the curve was newly updated by
rating resulting from maintenance.
In this study, to confirm the applicated performance ability about the optimal algo-
rithm, it conducts a case study using by deck and pavement members of the common
bridge in Korea. As shown from the Table 1, it is represented factors - the deterio-
ration ratio, deterioration increase ratio, C.I.- Cost function, and constraints. Each
factor is set into the algorithm and calculates the optimal time point and cost of
maintenance. And then, it makes the maintenance scenarios with the member-specific
correlation. The deck and pavement maintenance scenario of Fig. 3 is represented the
optimal maintenance scenario considering the member-specific correlation and scale
for the target life of 100 years.
Fig. 2 Optimal algorithm for bridge maintenance about time point and cost using G.A.
Optimal Bridge Maintenance Algorithms … 1241
4 Conclusions
In this study, to optimize time point and cost for maintenance, there is suggested the
model to predict optimal time point and cost for bridge maintenance. Then, it is
represented the optimal algorithm about maintenance of bridge using and genetic
algorithm.
This algorithm can establish an optimal maintenance scenario considering cor-
relation about each member of bridge to maintenance efficiently and reasonably. In
addition, it is expected to be able to further apply a variety of member-specific
correlations.
1242 S. Jin et al.
References
1. Mohan A, Poobal S (2018) Crack detection using image processing: a critical review and
analysis. Alexandria Eng J 57(2):787–798
2. Korea Agency for Technology Infrastructure Advancement (KAIA) (2013) Bridge life-span
extension using ICT, partial replacement and low-carbon materials
3. Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport (2014) Korea Infrastructure Safety Corporation,
Bridge Maintenance Manual
4. Ministry of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs (2012) Z Developing Bridge Management
System Considering Life-Cycle Cost and Performance of Bridges
5. Lee JH, Lee KY, Ahn SM, Kong JS (2018) Proposal of maintenance scenario and feasibility
analysis of bridge inspection using bayesian approach. J Korean Soc Civil Eng 38(4):505–516
Scaled Boundary Finite Element Method
for Two-Dimensional Crack Problems
in Multi-field Media
Abstract This paper presents a numerical procedure, based on the scaled boundary
finite element method (SBFEM) that is capable of modeling cracks in a
two-dimensional linear multi-field medium. The formulation is established in a
broad setting to handle various classes of linear boundary value problems, in a
unified fashion, such as those related to linear elasticity, piezoelectricity,
magneto-elasticity, and magneto-electro-elasticity. A scaled boundary finite ele-
ment approximation is also implemented within a general framework integrating the
influence of the distributed body source, general boundary conditions, contributions
of general prescribed data on side-faces, and the flexibility of the scaling boundary
approximations. The implemented SBFEM is then verified with available bench-
mark solutions for crack problems in multi-field media. Obtained results for various
scenarios have clearly indicated the accuracy, vast capability and robustness of the
proposed method.
Keywords Scaled boundary finite element methods Multi-field media Cracks
Stress intensity factors Surface flux State variables
1 Introduction
A scaled boundary finite element method (SBFEM) has been proved, for the past
two decades, as one of powerful solution techniques for the analysis of various
engineering problems. The technique has increasingly gained popularity from many
C. V. Nguyen (&)
Faculty of Civil Engineering, HCMC University of Technology and Education,
Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
e-mail: chungnv@hcmute.edu.vn
J. Rungamornrat
Applied Mechanics and Structures Research Unit, Department of Civil Engineering,
Faculty of Engineering, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand
e-mail: jaroon.r@chula.ac.th
researchers, since its emergence, due to the key feature resulting from its underlying
formulation and the discretization scheme (e.g., Wolf [9]). In particular, the
introduction of scaled boundary coordinates to describe the geometry and all
involved spatial differential operators allows the reduction of spatial discretization;
more specifically, only the representative boundary requires the discretization.
Several versions of the SBFEM have been continuously proposed to further
enhance its capability and computational performance. For instance, Deeks and
Wolf [2] integrated an h-adaptive procedure in the SBFEM. Object-oriented and
sub-structuring approaches were employed in their study. The positive feature of
the SBFEM was then exploited to model the stress singularities at the scaling center
and to avoid the discretization of certain adjacent segments of the boundary. Later,
Vu and Deeks [8] explored the use of high-order elements (e.g., spectral-element
and hierarchical approaches) in the SBFEM. They found that the spectral element
approach was better than the hierarchical approach. He et al. [4] developed a new
element-free Galerkin SBFEM to solve a number of standard linear elasticity
problems. It was found that the technique offers the better rate of convergence than
that of the original SBFEM. Li et al. [5] developed the SBFEM to solve
two-dimensional crack problems in linear piezoelectricity. Both static and dynamic
stress and electric displacement intensity factors were evaluated. In such procedure,
no asymptotic solution, local mesh refinement or special treatment around a crack
tip was required. Furthermore, Dieringer and Becker [3] developed the SBFEM to
handle problems within the framework of a classical laminated plate theory. In their
study, the scaled boundary finite element equations in terms of the displacements
for composites were derived and used to examine the stress singularities at a notch.
They also demonstrated the enhancement of the SBFEM in evaluating the singular
stress field as a function of the notch opening for the wide variety of composites.
Besides the capability of treating the stress singularity, the accuracy and efficiency
of the SBFEM to handle arbitrarily laminated plates was also confirmed. Most
recently, Nguyen et al. [6] and Rungamornrat and Nguyen [7] proposed a general
SBFEM for the analysis of two-dimensional linear multi-field problems. In their
work, the underlying formulation and the implementation of solution procedure
were established in a broad framework allowing various classes of linear boundary
value problems to be handled in a unified setting with a general set of prescribed
data. In addition, the accuracy enhancement of SBFE solutions via the use of exact
defining curve was also investigated.
The present study aims mainly to extend the work of Nguyen et al. [6] to further
enhance the capability of the SBFEM to analyze cracks in both single-field and
multi-field media. Remaining sections of this paper are organized to include the
problem description, basic equations, the scaled boundary finite element formula-
tion, its performance in handling crack problems, and concluding remarks.
Scaled Boundary Finite Element Method ... 1245
LT r þ b ¼ 0 ð1Þ
r ¼ De ð2Þ
e ¼ Lu ð3Þ
Fig. 1 Schematic of
two-dimensional, multi-field
body
1246 C. V. Nguyen and J. Rungamornrat
3 SBFE Formulation
The geometry of the body can be fully described by a rectangular region ½n1 ; n2
½s1 ; s2 in the n s plane via the following coordinate transformation
x ¼ x0 þ n^xðsÞ ð6Þ
where n; s are termed the scaled boundary coordinates; x0 is the scaling center; and
x^ðsÞ is a locus of points along a defining curve relative to x0 as shown in Fig. 2. If
the defining curve is not a closed curve, the boundary of @X corresponding to
s ¼ s1 and s ¼ s2 are termed the side faces. If the defining curve is a closed curve,
the boundary of @X contains no side face. If n1 is finite, the body X is said to be
finite; otherwise (i.e., n2 ¼ 1), it is said to be infinite. If n1 ¼ 0, the body X
contains the scaling center x0 ; otherwise (i.e., n1 [ 0), the body X does not contain
the scaling center x0 . Portions of the boundary @X associated with n ¼ n1 [ 0 and
n ¼ n2 \1 are termed the inner and outer boundaries, respectively. With the
coordinate transformation [6], the differential area dA can be related to differential
area dnds in the n s plane by dA ¼ Jndnds with J ¼ ^x1 ðd^x2 =dsÞ ^x2 ðd^x1 =dsÞ
and the length dl of the differential vector dx along the boundary and along the side
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
face are given, respectively, by dl ¼ ðd^x1 =dsÞ2 þ ðd^x2 =dsÞ2 nds ¼ J s ðsÞnds and
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
dl ¼ ^x21 þ ^x22 dn ¼ J n ðsÞdn. The linear differential operator L given by [4] can
now be expressed in terms of partial derivatives with respect to n and s by
@ 1@ 1 ðd^x2 =dsÞI 1 ^x2 I
L ¼ b1 þ b2 ; b1 ¼ ; b2 ¼ ð7Þ
@n n @s J ðd^x1 =dsÞI J ^x1 I
Scaled Boundary Finite Element Method ... 1247
The state variables u, the body flux r, and the weight function w can be
approximated by
uh ¼ uh ðn; sÞ ¼ N S U h ð8Þ
h i
rh ¼ D B1 U h;n þ ð1=nÞB2 U h ð9Þ
wh ¼ wh ðn; sÞ ¼ N S W h ð10Þ
where N S is a matrix containing all basis functions used for approximating the state
variables, U h is a vector containing all unknown nodal functions, W h is a vector
containing all arbitrary nodal functions, B1 ¼ bh1 N S , B2 ¼ bh2 BS , BS ¼ dN S =ds, and
the superscript “h” is used to designate quantities resulting from the approximation.
A set of scaled boundary finite element equations is established for a generic,
two-dimensional body X shown in Fig. 3. As a result of the boundary partition
@X ¼ @X1 [ @X2 [ @Xs1 [ @Xs1 together with the coordinate transformation [6], the
manipulation of all involved matrix algebra, and the integration by parts with
respect to the coordinate n, the weak-form [5] becomes
1248 C. V. Nguyen and J. Rungamornrat
Zn2
1
ðW h ÞT nE0 U h;nn þ ðE1 ET1 E0 ÞU h;n þ E2 U h Ft nFb dn
n
n1
n o n o
þ ðW h2 ÞT nE0 U h;n þ ET1 U h P2 ðW h1 ÞT nE0 U h;n þ ET1 U h þ P1 ¼ 0
n¼n2 n¼n1
ð11Þ
Zso Zso
S T
P1 ¼ ðN Þ t1 ðsÞn1 J ðsÞds; P2 ¼
s
ðN S ÞT t2 ðsÞn2 J s ðsÞds ð13Þ
si si
Ft1 ¼ Ft1 ðnÞ ¼ ðN S1 ÞT ts1 ðnÞJ n ðs1 Þ; Ft2 ¼ Ft2 ðnÞ ¼ ðN S2 ÞT ts2 ðnÞJ n ðs2 Þ; Ft ¼ Ft1 þ Ft2
ð14Þ
Zs2
F ¼ F ðnÞ ¼
b b
ðN S ÞT bJds ð15Þ
s1
Qh ðn2 Þ ¼ P2 ð18Þ
where Qh ¼ Qh ðnÞ ¼ nE0 U h;n þ ET1 U h is commonly known as the nodal internal
flux. By partitioning U h into f Uhu U hc gT where U hu and U hc denote unknown
and prescribed state variables, the system of differential Eqs. (16) and the nodal
internal flux can be expressed, in a partitioned form, as
Scaled Boundary Finite Element Method ... 1249
" #( ) " #( )
Euu
0 Euc
0 Uhu
;nn Euu uu T
0 þ ðE1 Þ E1
uu
Euc cu T
0 þ ðE1 Þ E1
uc U hu
;n
n 2
T þn
ðEuc
0 Þ Ecc
0 Uhc
;nn ðEuc T uc T
0 Þ þ ðE1 Þ E1
cu cc T
0 þ ðE1 Þ E1
Ecc cc Uhc
;n
" uu # ( ) tu ( )
E2 Euc
2 U hu F F bu
T þn þ n2 ¼0
ðEuc
2 Þ Ecc
2 Uhc Ftc Fbc
ð19Þ
( )
Qhu Euu Euc U hu
;n 1 Þ
ðEuu T
ðEcu
1 Þ
T
U hu
¼n 0
T
0
þ ð20Þ
Qhc ðEuc
0 Þ Ecc
0 U hc
;n ðEuc
1 Þ
T
ðEcc
1 Þ
T
U hc
cu T
Fsuu ¼ n2 Euc
0 U ;nn þ nðE0 þ ðE1 Þ E1 ÞU ;n E2 U
hc uc uc hc uc hc
ð23Þ
T hu uc T uc T
hu uc T hu
Fsuc ¼ n2 ðEuc
0 Þ U ;nn þ n ðE0 Þ þ ðE1 Þ E1 U ;n ðE2 Þ U
cu
ð24Þ
cc cc T
hc
Fscc ¼ n2 Ecc
0 U ;nn þ n E0 þ ðE1 Þ E1 U ;n E2 U
hc cc cc hc
ð25Þ
By following the same procedure, the Eq. (20) can also be separated into two
systems:
uu T hu
Qhu ðnÞ ¼ nEuu
0 U ;n þ ðE1 Þ U þ Q
hu huc
ðnÞ ð26Þ
T hu uc T hu
Qhc ðnÞ ¼ nðEuc
0 Þ U ;n þ ðE1 Þ U þ Q ðnÞ
hcc
ð27Þ
where the known vectors Qhuc ðnÞ and Qhcc ðnÞ are defined by
cu T hc cc T hc
Qhuc ðnÞ ¼ nEuc
0 U ;n þ ðE1 Þ U ; Q
hc huc
ðnÞ ¼ nEcc
0 U ;n þ ðE1 Þ U
hc
ð28Þ
A system of differential Eqs. (21) along with the boundary conditions on the
inner and outer boundaries,Qhc ðn1 Þ ¼ Pu1 and Qhu ðn2 Þ ¼ Pu2 , is sufficient for
determining the general solution of U hu . A homogeneous solution of (21), denoted
by Uhu
0 , must satisfy
1250 C. V. Nguyen and J. Rungamornrat
uu uu T
hu
n2 Euu
0 U 0;nn þ n E0 þ ðE1 Þ E1 U 0;n E2 U 0 ¼ 0
hu uu uu hu
ð29Þ
uu T hu
0 ðnÞ ¼ nE0 U 0;n þ ðE1 Þ U 0
Qhu ð30Þ
uu hu
AX i ¼ ki X i ð31Þ
wþ
0 ðnÞ ¼ U
U hu P þ ðnÞC þ þ Uw P ðnÞC ð33Þ
qþ
0 ðnÞ ¼ U
Qhu P þ ðnÞC þ þ Uq P ðnÞC ð34Þ
where P þ and P are diagonal matrices obtained by simply replacing the diagonal
entries ki of the matrices k þ and k by the function nki , respectively; and C þ and
C are vectors containing arbitrary constants representing the contribution of each
mode.
A particular solution of (21), denoted by Uhu 1 , associated with the distributed
body source, the surface flux on the side face and the prescribed state variables on
Scaled Boundary Finite Element Method ... 1251
the side faces can also be obtained from a standard procedure in the theory of
differential equations such as the method of undetermined coefficient. Once the
1 is obtained, the corresponding particular nodal internal flux
particular solution U hu
hu
Q1 can be calculated. Finally, the general solution of (21) and the corresponding
nodal internal flux are then given by
wþ
U hu ðnÞ ¼ U hu
0 ðnÞ þ U 1 ðnÞ ¼ U
hu
P þ ðnÞC þ þ Uw P ðnÞC þ U hu
1 ðnÞ ð35Þ
qþ
Qhu ðnÞ ¼ Qhu
0 ðnÞ þ Q1 ðnÞ ¼ U
hu
P þ ðnÞC þ þ Uq P ðnÞC þ Qhu
1 ðnÞ ð36Þ
where the coefficient matrix K, commonly termed the stiffness matrix, is given by
1
Uq þ P þ ðn1 Þ Uq P ðn1 Þ Uw þ P þ ðn1 Þ Uw P ðn1 Þ
K¼ ð38Þ
Uq þ P þ ðn2 Þ Uq P ðn2 Þ Uw þ P þ ðn2 Þ Uw P ðn2 Þ
Once the unknowns on both the inner and outer boundaries are solved, the
approximate field quantities such as the state variables and the body flux within the
body can readily post-processed; in particular, the approximated state variables and
body flux can be computed from (8)–(9) as
where fN Su ; N Sc g, fBu1 ; Bc1 g, and fBu2 ; Bc2 g are matrices resulting from the partition
of N S ,B1 and B2 , respectively. The intensity factors along the crack front are
determined by (Li et al. [5])
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ðsÞ
fKðhÞg ¼ 2pL½wrL ðhÞfcðsÞ g ð41Þ
ðsÞ
where ½wrL ðhÞ are the singular body flux modes at the characteristic length L and
fcðsÞ g are the integration constants corresponding to the singular modes.
1252 C. V. Nguyen and J. Rungamornrat
(a) (b)
Fig. 4 Schematic of (a) plane-strain rectangular plate containing edged notch and (b) scaling
center and defining curve used in scale boundary finite element analysis
Two numerical examples, associated with an edged notch contained in both the
elastic and piezoelectric finite plates, are considered to investigate the computa-
tional performance of the proposed technique. In addition, reference solutions
available in the literature are employed to verify the formulation and
implementations.
a
a
2 a
3 a
4
C ¼ 1:12 0:231 þ 10:55 21:72 þ 30:39 ð42Þ
W W W W
In the analysis, the scaling center is selected at the notch tip; the defining curve is
discretized by N identical linear elements; and the dimensions of the plate are
chosen such that a ¼ b and W ¼ L. The mode-I stress intensity factors generated by
the implemented technique are shown in Table 1 along with the benchmark solu-
tion. To further demonstrate the efficiency of the present technique at least in terms
of the number of degrees of freedom required, a solution generated by a reliable
finite element program with 6–node triangular elements is also reported. It is seen
that numerical solutions generated by the proposed SBFEM converge and also
exhibit excellent agreement with the reference solution with the used of relatively
coarse meshes. In addition, the standard FEM clearly requires a significantly large
number of degrees of freedom to obtain the stress intensity factor with the same
level of accuracy. The order of singularity (i.e., one of eigenvalues obtained from
the present method) is also reported in Table 2. It is evident that the order of
singularity converges to the theoretical value (i.e., 0.5) as expected.
1254 C. V. Nguyen and J. Rungamornrat
5 Conclusion
A numerical technique, based on the scaled boundary finite element method, has
been successfully implemented to solve two-dimensional, multi-field crack prob-
lems. Both the formulation and implementations have been established in a general
framework allowing a variety of linear boundary value problems and the general
associated data, such as the domain geometry, the prescribed distributed body
source, boundary conditions, contribution of the side face, and the flexibility of the
scaled boundary approximations, to be treated in a single, unified fashion. Results
from an extensive numerical study have confirmed the validity, accuracy, conver-
gence, and capability of the prosed technique.
Scaled Boundary Finite Element Method ... 1255
References
1. Brown WLJ, Srawley J (1966) Plane strain crack toughness testing of high strength metallic
materials, ASTM 410
2. Deeks AJ, Wolf JP (2002) An h-hierarchical adaptive procedure for the scaled boundary
finite-element method. Int J Numer Meth Eng 54:585–605
3. Dieringer R, Becker W (2014) A new scaled boundary finite element formulation for
computation of singularity orders at cracks and notches in arbitrary laminated composites.
Composite Structures. https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.compstruct.2014.12.036
4. He Y, Yang H, Deeks AJ (2012) An Element-free Galerkin scaled boundary method. Finite
Elem Anal Des 62:28–36
5. Li C, Man H, Song C, Gao W (2013) Fracture analysis of piezoelectric materials using the
scaled boundary finite element method. Eng Fract Mech 97:52–71
6. Nguyen CV, Rungamornrat J, Pheinsusom P (2017) Scaled boundary finite element method for
two-dimensional linear multi-field media. Eng J 21(7):333–360
7. Rungamornrat J, Nguyen CV (2019) Scaled boundary finite element method with exact
defining curves for two-dimensional linear multi-field media. Front Struct Civil Eng 13(1):201–
214
8. Vu TH, Deeks AJ (2006) Use of higher-order shape functions in the scaled boundary finite
element method. Int J Numer Meth Eng 65:1714–1733
9. Wolf JP (2003) The scaled boundary finite element method. Wiley, Chichester
A Simplified Method for Estimating
Differential Displacement
in Consideration of Structural
Nonlinearity and Coupling Between
Adjacent Viaducts During Earthquake
Keywords Seismic analysis Nonlinear Differential displacement Relative
displacement Railway viaducts
1 Introduction
Yield strength(khy, j)
Yield strength(khy,j)
S.D.=0.11 S.D.=0.17
1.5 S.D.=0.12 1.5 S.D.=0.25
S.D.=0.10
0.5 S.D.=0.10 0.5
S.D.=0.10 S.D.=0.19
0 0 0 0
0 0.5 1.0 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 0.5 1.0 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
Yield strength(khy,i) Vibration period(Teq,i) Yield strength(khy,i) Vibration period(Teq,i)
(a) Section A (b) Section B
1.0 2.0 1.0 2.0
Vibration period(Teq, j)
Vibration period(Teq, j)
Yield strength(khy, j)
Yield strength(khy, j)
S.D.=0.08 S.D.=0.09
1.5 S.D.=0.15 1.5 S.D.=0.10
S.D.=0.07
0.5 0.5
S.D.=0.07
S.D.=0.11 S.D.=0.07
0 0 0 0
0 0.5 1.0 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 0.5 1.0 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
Yield strength(khy,i) Vibration period(Teq,i) Yield strength(khy,i) Vibration period(Teq,i)
(c) Section C (d) Section D
Same Structural type Differential structural type
to inadequacy. That aside, the current railway seismic design code in Japan spec-
ifies a simple method for estimating the differential displacements, which is
applicable only for elastic structural behaviors.
This study aims to establish a simple method for estimating the differential
displacement cased on the vibration characteristics of a single structure in con-
sideration of structural nonlinearity and coupling between adjacent viaducts at the
instance of an earthquake.
2 Analysis Method
Differential displacement occurs easily when the adjacent viaduct has a different
structural type that has significantly different vibration characteristics, i.e., yield
strength and vibration period. Herein, the vibration characteristics of the existing
structures of Japanese high-speed railway sections were statistically investigated for
an assessment of the influence of vibration period and yield strength of viaducts on
differential displacement.
Typical yield strength and vibration period on an existing Japanese railway
structure are depicted in Fig. 2, where i and j denote the start and end sides.
Sections A, B, C, and D of the Japanese high-speed railway was evaluated within
13.0, 6.1, 10.0, and 8.0 km, respectively, there are service life of 30–50 years, and
including the girder, rigid frame and adjustment girder viaduct, tunnel, and
embankment. Moreover, the standard deviation (S.D.) values of yield strength and
vibration period between i and j sides was calculated. At yield strength greater than
1.0, the S.D. was also more than 1.0 in Fig. 2(a)–(d). Vibration period differed in
the ranged 0.09–0.17 s with the adjacent viaducts having the same structural type,
and 0.12–0.25 s with different structural types. Moreover, seismic yield coefficient
differed by approximately 0.10 in the same structural type and 0.10–0.19 in dif-
ferent structural types.
Acceleration (gal) Damping ratio Damping ratio Damping ratio Damping ratio
Acceleration(gal)
Acceleration(gal)
Acceleration(gal)
h=5% h=5% h=5% h=5%
1000 1000 1000 1000
Figure 3 shows the dynamic model of the structure. Principally, the dynamic behavior
of a railway structure can be often expressed by a single degree-of-freedom (SDOF).
Structures in this study were modeled from a SDOF system with trilinear skeleton
curve and standard type hysteric characters, as depicted in Fig. 3(a). For the skeleton
curve, yield seismic coefficient khy, maximum seismic coefficient khmax, yield fre-
quency feq, and structural unit weight/length ws, were set as the parameters. The
second gradient was fixed at 1/10 of the first gradient, whereas the third gradient was
fixed as infinitesimal. Meanwhile, the hysteric character of structures is displayed in
Fig. 3(b). A 5% modal damping was considered for each mode [3]. When the
structure is nonlinear behavior, its damping can be evaluated as the viscous damping,
including the energy loss due to the hysteric character. Figure 3(b) is a simple and
widely used model in practical seismic design.
Equations of motion for the structures were solved in the model coordinates for
each time increment Δt by the Newmark time difference scheme. Given the non-
linear equations, iterative calculations were needed for each time increment until the
unbalanced force becomes sufficiently small.
The elastic acceleration response using seismic wave is shown in Fig. 4.
Particularly, seismic waves were input on the ground surface analysis design for
earthquake motion L1 and L2 in spectrum I and II standard for Japanese seismic
design [1]. Earthquake motions data were recorded for Mid-Nigata (observed in
Mid-Niigata), Tohoku (observed in Sendai), Kumamoto (observed in Kasuga), and
Kobe(observed in Kobe). As reference for the evaluation of the existing structures,
the analytical parameters of the structures were defined as follows: initial stiffness
of structure (Teq) was in the range of 0.3–2.0 s, and the yield seismic coefficient of
structure (khy) was within 0.2–0.7 in both the nonlinear and linear cases [4].
A Simplified Method for Estimating Differential Displacement ... 1261
dijmax
DRD ¼ ð1Þ
dimax þ djmax
where is dmax
ij is the absolute maximum relative displacement of time history
response and dmax
k (k = i, j) is the absolute maximum displacement each structure.
Moreover, b is defined by,
Figure 5 shows the influence of b on the DRD for a structure with linear charac-
teristics based on the design and the recorded seismic data. Analytical results
demonstrated that an increase in b is corresponded by a relative increase in DRD.
With the value of b close to 1.5, DRD was near 0.8, describing an out-phase
situation. This result showed good agreement with that of the design parameters and
the recorded seismic data. Moreover, when b is less than 1.25, DRD increased with
sharply increase of b. Basically, relative displacement happens when the equivalent
vibration period on the adjacent structures are in different conditions. Here, larger
differential equivalent period between the adjacent structures leads to higher relative
displacement ratio.
1262 K. Narita and M. Tokunaga
Displacement (DRD)
structure with linear 1.0
characteristics 0.8
0.6 L2spe.I(G2)
L2spe.I(G5)
0.4 L1(G2) L2spe.II(G2)
0.2 L1(G5) L2spe.II(G5)
0
1 2 3 4 5
Ratio of equivalent natural period
(a) Design earthquakes Linear
1.2
Displacement (DRD)
1.0
0.8
0.6 Mid-Nigata
0.4 Kumamoto
0.2 Tohoku
Kobe
0
1 2 3 4 5
Ratio of equivalent period
(b) Record earthquakes Linear
1.2
Displacement(DRD)
0.8
0.6 L2spe.I(G2)
0.4 L2spe.I(G5)
L1(G2) L2spe.II(G2)
0.2 L1(G5) L2spe.II(G5)
0
1 2 3 4 5
Ratio of equivalent natural period
(a) Design earthquakes khy=0.7
1.2
Displacement (DRD)
1.0
0.8
0.6 Mid-Nigata
0.4 Kumamoto
Tohoku
0.2 Kobe
0
1 2 3 4 5
Ratio of equivalent natural period
(b) Record earthquakes khy=0.7
1.2
Displacement (DRD)
1.0
0.8
0.6 L2spe.I(G2)
0.4 L1(G2)
L2spe.I(G5)
L2spe.II(G2)
0.2 L1(G5) L2spe.II(G5)
0
1 2 3 4 5
Ratio of equivalent natural period
(c) Design earthquakes khy=0.3
Dimensionless Relative
1.2
Displacement (DRD)
1.0
0.8
0.6 Mid-Nigata
0.4 Kumamoto
0.2 Tohoku
Kobe
0
1 2 3 4 5
Ratio of equivalent natural period
(d) Record earthquakes khy=0.3
Unequal displacement response has been presumed to differ between the case where
the viaducts are divided into vibration units and the case describing a coupling of
continuous viaducts; nonetheless, the degree of influence remains unclear [2].
Section A of the railway investigated, as mentioned in Chapter 2, was considered
herein for clarifying the influence of coupling between adjacent structures on dif-
ferential displacement. Figure 8(a) displays the vibration characteristics of some of
the structures in the line model of the existing structures. Yield seismic coefficient
for the line section target varied from 0.2 to 0.5 except for a part, and the equivalent
natural period was in the range of 0.8 to 1.4 s.
Figures 8(b) and 8(c) show the response displacement when L1G5 wave was
input, it was divided and calculated using a vibration unit (hereinafter referred to as
“single system”), considering the coupling between the adjacent structures. The
figures also show the influence on the maximum displacement dmax k (k = i, j) and the
maximum relative displacement dmax ij in the case of calculation (hereinafter referred
to as “coupled system”). Apparently, the maximum displacement was reduced by
the coupling at the point where the equivalent natural period of the structure greatly
decreased at around 0.6 km. Moreover, with L1 as the input seismic wave, the
influence of yield seismic coefficient was considered to be small. Relatively, at
locations where the change of equivalent natural period of the structure at 0.6 to
0.7 km was small, the maximum displacement tended to be equal due to the
Yield coefficient( k hy )
Equivalent vibration
2.0 1.0
displacement Teq khy 0.8
relative displacement (m) displacement (m) period (Teq ) (s)
1.5
0.6
1.0 0.4
0.5 0.2
0 0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Distance (km)
(a)vibration characteristics in the line model
0.3
Single
Maximum
0.2 Couple
0.1
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
Distance (km)
(b)Maximum displacement
0.3
Single
Maximum
0.2 Couple
0.1
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
Distance (km)
(c)Maximum relative displacement
A Simplified Method for Estimating Differential Displacement ... 1265
coupling between the adjacent structures. From Fig. 8(c), at 0.1–0.2 km associated
to a large change in equivalent natural period, the maximum relative displacement
decreased due to the coupling between the adjacent structures; nonetheless, it
tended to be large at 0.2 to 0.4 km, where the change of the equivalent natural
period of the object was small. Furthermore, the response displacement of the long
natural period structure decreased under the influence of the low natural period
structure, and otherwise increased for the short natural period structural response.
As DRD exhibits the same tendency in both design and actual ground motion and
shows high correlation with the equivalent natural period ratio of adjacent struc-
tures, Eq. (4) was proposed for estimating dimensionless relative displacement
DERD. Although the conventional method described above easily evaluates the rel-
ative displacement between buildings by focusing on problem of coupling between
adjacent buildings during earthquake, such is only a specific character model of a
railway structure and cannot be applied on certain scenarios depending on the type
of the structure. On the contrary, Eq. (4) acts as a response spectrum method that
1266 K. Narita and M. Tokunaga
Moreover, after the structure has been nonlinearized, the damping ratio heq is
evaluated with Eq. (6), in which a is the ratio of the second slope to the first slope
of the hysteresis character model
8 ðl1Þð1aÞ
< 2 plð1 þ alaÞ ; ðfrom yield to maximum momentÞ
heq ¼ ðb1Þ2
ð6Þ
: 2 lb 2b1 þ a ; ðafter maximum momentÞ
plb
and b (= khmax/khy) is the ratio of the maximum seismic coefficient to the yield
seismic coefficient.
The ductility factor was calculated by relative displacement rate as the ratio of
response displacement drel
k to maximum displacement dk
max
for each structure at the
max
time of maximum relative displacement dij . The damping ratio was then added to
the initial damping ratio by calculating the equivalent viscous damping ratio heq to
the history in consideration of the energy loss (Fig. 3(b)). Figure 10 shows an
example of time history response of displacement and relative displacement of a
single structure by SDOF model. Here, note that it was possible to confirm the
tendency for the dmax
ij appearing at the dmax
i after Ti/2 s. On such basis, relative
A Simplified Method for Estimating Differential Displacement ... 1267
0.6
Displacement(m)
0.6
0.4 Relative displacement dijmax
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4 Ti/2
-0.6
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Time(s)
15000 1500
Num 18000 Num 18000
Frequency
rj=djrel/djmax
Frequency
10000 ri=direl/dimax 1000
5000 500
0 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0
7
0
ri rj
※ CM: Conventional Method, PM: Proposed Method, ※ CM: Conventional Method, PM: Proposed Method,
DCM: Design Code Method in Japan DCM: Design Code Method in Japan
2.0 2.0
CM NM DCM C.V. CM NM DCM C.V.
Low limit of DCM Ave. Low limit of DCM Ave.
1.5 1.5
Est Ana
Est Ana
1.0 1.0
0.5 0.5
0 0
L2spe.II(G1)
L2spe.II(G2)
L2spe.II(G4)
L2spe.II(G0)
L2spe.II(G3)
L2spe.II(G5)
L2spe.I(G2)
L2spe.I(G4)
L2spe.I(G0)
L2spe.I(G1)
L2spe.I(G3)
L2spe.I(G5)
L2spe.II(G2)
L2spe.II(G4)
L2spe.II(G1)
L2spe.II(G0)
L2spe.II(G3)
L2spe.II(G5)
L2spe.I(G2)
L2spe.I(G4)
L2spe.I(G1)
L2spe.I(G0)
L2spe.I(G3)
L2spe.I(G5)
L1(G4)
L1(G6)
L1(G0)
L1(G2)
L1(G5)
L1(G7)
L1(G1)
L1(G3)
L1(G4)
L1(G6)
L1(G0)
L1(G2)
L1(G5)
L1(G7)
L1(G1)
L1(G3)
(a) The estimation accuracy of linear behavior (b) The estimation accuracy of linear behavior (khy=0.3)
6 Conclusion
This paper presented a simplified method for estimating the differential displace-
ment on railway structures based on the vibration characteristics of a single
structure, in consideration of the structural nonlinearity and coupling between
adjacent viaducts during earthquake. The findings can be generalized as follows:
1. Statistical investigation of the vibration characteristics of the existing structure
revealed that equivalent natural period ratio ranges within 1.0 to 2.0 and the
difference in yield seismic coefficient ranged in approximately ±0.4 when the
adjacent structures in the line section is different types.
2. Relative displacement increase with differential equivalent period between the
adjacent structures. Due to decrease of yield seismic coefficient khy, dimen-
sionless relative displacement DRD was within 0.4–0.8 when the ratio of
equivalent vibration period on adjacent structure b was close to 1.5 and khy was
0.7, whereas DRD had a value of 0.2–0.8 at b close to 1.5 and khy of 0.3.
A Simplified Method for Estimating Differential Displacement ... 1269
References
1. Railway Technical Research Institute (2012) Design standards for railway structures and
commentary (seismic design). Maruzen co., Ltd., Tokyo(in Japan)
2. Railway Technical Research Institute (2007) Design standards for railway structures and
commentary (displacement limits). Maruzen co., Ltd, Tokyo(in Japan)
3. Sogabe M, Ikeda M, Yanagisawa Y Train-running quality during earthquakes and its
improvement for railway long span bridge. Q. Rep. RTRI, 48(3):186–189
4. Tokunaga M, Sogabe M, Watanabe T, Santo T, Tamai S (2016) Seismic response
characteristics of tall noise barrier on railway structures and its seismic design method.
J Struct Eng 62A:291–302
5. Kasai K, Jagiasi AR, Jeng V (1996) Inelastic vibration phase theory for seismic pounding
mitigation. J Struct Eng, ASCE 122(10):1136–1146
6. Der Kiureghian A (1980) A response spectrum method for random vibration, Earthquake
Engineering Research Center, University of California
Utilization of Machine Learning
for Analyzing Concrete Material
Consumption in Japan
Abstract Concrete is one of the most widely used construction material in the
world. For developed countries like Japan, the trend of concrete consumption is
affected by significant changes over time. These changes can be attributed to the
decrease in population, stability of the economy, declining need of new infras-
tructures and other hidden factors that might not be easily recognizable with con-
ventional statistical modeling. Understanding these drivers of concrete material
consumption is important in evaluating construction resource efficiency. As such,
this paper aims to understand concrete material consumption trends in Japan by
utilizing machine learning techniques. Machine learning has gained popularity
mainly due to its self-learning characteristics that allows performance enhancement
without being explicitly programmed. A backward approach of stepwise regression
analysis was performed to quantify the contribution of socioeconomic factors to
concrete consumption. After which, an agglomerative hierarchical clustering was
made to identify similar patterns of concrete consumption behavior across the
prefectures of Japan and group these prefectures together. Through the detection of
patterns in the historical data, understanding the drivers of concrete consumption
leads to the enhancement of the efficiency of resource consumption in the future.
1 Introduction
As reliable statistical data is essential for such an analysis, the paper focuses on
Japan as a case study. Japan as a whole appears to be a relatively homogeneous as a
country. Its 47 prefectures, however, have great diversity such as those that are
densely populated like Tokyo to the sparsely inhabited like Tottori. These varied
attributes may imply varied behavior of concrete consumption among prefectures.
With this, this paper aims to understand the drivers of concrete consumption of
Japanese prefectures by identifying commonalities in the concrete consumption
behavior across the different prefectures. The utilization of machine learning
approaches to detect patterns in the historical data is a tool in understanding the
drivers of concrete consumption of the prefectures which will eventually lead to the
enhancement of the efficiency of resource consumption in the future.
2 Methodology
To learn more about the relationship between concrete consumption and its drivers,
the concrete production (CP) data was utilized to explain concrete consumption. As
this research is on an exploratory stage, three variables were particularly chosen as
initial factors to influence concrete production based on literature review. These
variables are construction investment (CI), population (POP) and gross domestic
product (GDP) from 1994 to 2014 (21-year period) reflecting socioeconomic
conditions. Moreover, the span of time stated earlier was particularly chosen as this
reflects a distinct phase of the development of Japan when the infrastructure system
became saturated and mature. Thus, the concrete production (CP) is referred to as
the dependent variable – the main factor to be understood, and the socioeconomic
factors (CI, POP, GDP) are the independent variables – the factors that are
hypothesized to have an impact on the dependent variable.
Data for each factors were collected primarily from available online resources
made publicly available by the Japanese government such as the Ministry of Land,
Infrastructure and Transportation for concrete production and construction invest-
ment data, the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry for gross domestic product
and e-Stat, a portal site of official statistics in Japan for population.
The raw data of the 47 prefectures for all of the variables considered from 1994
to 2014 are illustrated in Fig. 1 below. It can be deduced from this figure that
though the general trend among the prefectures are similar, that is, concrete pro-
duction and concrete investment are decreasing over time and population and GDP
are either stable or increasing at a low rate, the degrees of this trend is different
among prefectures.
1274 N. A. Vios et al.
25 10
Construction Investment
Concrete Production
(in millions of m3)
(a) (b)
16 100
14
80
10 60
8
6 40
4
20
2
0 0
1994 1999 2004 2009 2014 1994 1999 2004 2009 2014
Year Year
(c) (d)
Fig. 1 Raw data from 1994 to 2014; (a) concrete production, (b) construction investment,
(c) population and (d) gross domestic product
2.2 Analysis
model, then the variables that do not significantly predict anything on the dependent
variable based on the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) are removed from the
model one by one to retain the relevant variables was utilized in this study [3]. AIC
compares the quality of a set of statistical models to each other by taking each
possible model and rank them from best to worst [4]. To perform this analysis, R, a
free open source software for data analysis was used [10]. For each of the pre-
fectures, a backward approach of the stepwise regression analysis was performed
for data points from 1994 to 2014 to obtain the corresponding coefficients of each
socioeconomic factors that will determine its contribution to the concrete produc-
tion. Equation (1) below shows the general regression equation considering the
three socioeconomic factors.
where:
i = prefectures (Hokkaido, Aomori, Iwate, …)
CP = concrete production
a = intercept term
CI = construction investment
POP = population
GDP = gross domestic product
bCI = regression coefficient of construction investment
bPOP = regression coefficient of population
bGDP = regression coefficient of gross domestic product
e = residual term
The regression analysis may or may not consider the inclusion of the intercept.
However, for the purposes of this study, the intercept term was not included in the
analysis for simplicity and to emphasize the contribution of each independent
variable to concrete production. Thus, only the regression coefficients are utilized in
the cluster analysis discussed in Sect. 2.2.2.
The stepwise regression analysis result is summarized in Table 1. The table colors
shown represent cluster membership which will be further explained in Sect. 3.2.
The values indicate the corresponding regression coefficient for each socioeco-
nomic factor per prefecture as in Eq. (1). A value of ‘0’ was set by the authors to
imply that for that certain prefecture, this socioeconomic factor is not significant in
describing the concrete production based on the AIC criterion of the regression
analysis which lead the regression model to eliminate this certain socioeconomic
factor.
From this procedure, it can be seen that for all the prefectures CI has a significant
positive contribution to CP ranging from 0.979 of Miyagi to 4.8479 of Kochi. In
terms of POP contributions to CP, it varies from −5.8954 of Osaka to 4.523 of
Okinawa. Of the three socioeconomic factors, GDP has the least contribution to CP,
as the coefficients ranges from −1.5945 of Okinawa to 1.5185 of Osaka. These
estimates describe the relationship between concrete production and the socioeco-
nomic factors considered. Prefectures like Aichi, Okayama, Tottori, Nara, Ehime,
Gifu and Kochi, only CI and POP have significant contribution to CP. Also, pre-
fectures like Shiga, Saga, Fukushima, Ibaraki, Hiroshima, Gunma, Kyoto, Kagawa,
Utilization of Machine Learning for Analyzing Concrete Material ... 1277
A box plot of the different clusters against the socioeconomic factors is illustrated in
Fig. 3 to visualize the distribution of the data of each cluster. The overall dissim-
ilarity between prefectures is explained by the height of the tree (see Fig. 2) at
which the branches of the prefectures merge. Clusters 1 and 2 can be said to be the
most dissimilar clusters as they join the rest of the tree at the top of the dendrogram,
followed by Clusters 3 and 4 and finally Clusters 5 and 6.
Utilization of Machine Learning for Analyzing Concrete Material ... 1279
In Clusters 1 and 2, POP is negatively contributing to CP, while CI and GDP are
positively contributing to concrete consumption, but to varying degrees – Cluster 1
at a lower rate compared to Cluster 2. This explains why these two clusters though
joining the rest of the clusters at the top of the tree are best explained when
separated to clarify its dissimilarity. In Clusters 3 and 4, both CI and POP are
positively contributing to CP, while GDP is negatively contributing to CP but in
varying degrees – Cluster 3 at higher rate compared to that of Cluster 4. This also
explains why these two clusters though joining the rest of the clusters second from
the top of the tree are best explained when separated to elucidate its dissimilarity. In
Cluster 5, though the trend is similar to Clusters 3 and 4 wherein both CI and POP
are positively contributing to CP, while GDP is negatively contributing to CP, these
factors contribute at a lower rate. In Cluster 6, CI is positively contributing to CP,
while both POP and GDP shows little to no contribution to CP. In Cluster 7, despite
showing similar trend to Cluster 6 wherein only CI is positively contributing to CP
and both POP and GDP show little to no contribution to CP, it does so in a higher
rate than cluster 6. Finally, in Cluster 8 the trend is similar to Clusters 6 and 7 but
the rate is much higher.
It can be deduced from the clustering results that the prefectures exhibited varied
degrees of contributions of the socioeconomic factors (construction investment,
population and gross domestic product) to concrete production. As stated earlier, all
of the clusters exhibited a positive contribution of construction investment to
concrete production, but the degrees vary. This implies that, for some clusters,
concrete is widely used in construction reinforced by the large value of the
regression coefficient and for others it is otherwise which can be attributed to the
use of other construction materials. As to population, its contribution to concrete
production is ranging from a high negative to high positive value among clusters.
This entails that for some clusters, the increase or decrease in population does not
contribute to the demand in concrete production as there are enough buildings or
infrastructures available to accommodate this change in population. As to GDP, its
contribution to concrete production is ranging from a low negative to a low positive
value among clusters. Which signifies that this variable has less contribution to
concrete production. Its increase or decrease does not significantly affect concrete
production which can be associated to other components of GDP such as personal
consumption or net exports which are not directly related to concrete production.
4 Conclusions
This paper utilized machine learning as a tool for understanding the drivers of
concrete consumption across the prefectures of Japan. By clustering, not only does
this method demonstrated how a developed countries’ characteristics drive concrete
consumption, but also it narrowed down which prefectures demonstrated similar
and dissimilar patterns on what socioeconomic factors contribute to the concrete
consumption behavior and its corresponding degree of contribution. Furthermore,
the outcome unfolds the possibility of extending the analysis to developing coun-
tries and see which factors are driving the developing countries’ concrete con-
sumption and eventually compare and contrast these to developed countries.
The paper’s objective, though realized, lacks clarity of the robustness of the
evaluation. The socioeconomic factors selected may not be a strong representation
of concrete consumption, thus, additional factors such as cement consumption
intensity, steel consumption and urbanization level should be considered. Extending
the analysis for a longer historical period, say 50 years can also be considered.
Additionally, to strengthen the methodology and enhance decision making in the
clustering method different clustering type, distance metric and linkage function can
be examined to obtain the most appropriate procedure.
Utilization of Machine Learning for Analyzing Concrete Material ... 1281
References
1. Akram T (2018) The Japanese Economy: Stagnation, Recovery and Challenges, Aeaweb.org.
https://www.aeaweb.org/conference/2019/preliminary/paper/7ST9Hi4A. Accessed 30 June
2019
2. Crow J (2008) The Concrete Conundrum, Chemistry World – Construction, p. 63
3. Gerard N (2009) Statistics – Forward and Backward Stepwise (Selection|Regression). https://
gerardnico.com/data_mining/stepwise_regression. Accessed 1 July 2019
4. Glen S (2015) Akaike’s Information Criterion: Definition, Formulas, Statistics How To.
https://www.statisticshowto.datasciencecentral.com/akaikes-information-criterion/. Accessed
1 July 2019
5. Global Information, Inc. (2019) Construction in the Philippines – Key Trends and
Opportunities to 2023, GII Research. https://www.giiresearch.com/report/time237680-
construction-philippines-key-trends-opportunities.html. Accessed 26 June 2019
6. Kassambara A (2017) Practical Guide to Cluster Analysis in R, STHDA. http://www.sthda.
com. Accessed 26 June 2019
7. Saito J (2017) Post-war japan: growth, security, and uncertainty since 1945, center for
strategic and international studies. Rowman & Littlefield, Maryland
8. Sasaki Y (2013) A historical review of aesthetic design of infrastructure and the current main
issues in Japan, Department of Creative Science and Engineering, Waseda University
9. Theobald O (2017) Machine Learning for Absolute Beginners Second Edition
10. R Core Team (2018) A language and environment for statistical computing, R Foundation for
Statistical Computing, Vienna. https://www.R-project.org/. Accessed 26 June 2019
Updating the Reliability of Existing RC
Structures in a Marine Environment
Incorporating Spatial Variations
1 Introduction
X
n
ð jÞ ð jÞ
pðxk jZk Þ ¼ ak d xk xkjk1 ð1Þ
j¼1
where
ð jÞ ð jÞ
qk ¼ p zk xkjk1 ð2Þ
ð jÞ
ð jÞ q
ak ¼ Pn k ð3Þ
ðiÞ
qk
i¼1
where |i − j| is the distance between two given points and d is the correlation length
of the stochastic field.
1286 K. Masuda et al.
4 Illustrative Example
Visual inspection results of corrosion crack width are considered in this case study.
Since the corrosion crack is induced due to the corrosion product expansion, it
relates to the amounts of steel weight loss. Based on the survey of marine RC
structures by Kodama et al. [10], the relationship between the amount of steel
weight loss and corrosion crack width is classified as shown in Table 1 (Akiyama
et al. [6]). Steel weight loss classified in four categories 1, 2, 3 and 4 is less than
2.3%, between 2.3% and 5%, between 5% and 20%, and larger than 20%,
respectively. The corresponding thresholds of crack width to classify into four
categories, I, II, III and IV, are 0.1, 0.2 and 0.5 mm, respectively. Given the
category of steel weight loss, the probability of each category of crack width can be
calculated from Table 1. These probabilities are used to estimate the weight in
Eq. 3.
Fig. 1 Five samples of steel weight loss distributions at 50 years after the construction
25 2.5
Mean of steel weight loss (%)
15 1.5
10 1.0
Fig. 2 Statistics of 100,000 samples of steel weight loss distributions at 50 years after the
construction: (a) mean, (b) coefficient of variation (COV)
shown in Fig. 1. Mean value and coefficient of variation (COV) of steel weight loss
are shown in Figs. 2 (a) and (b). Since crack widths provided by visual inspection
are more severe than those provided by the computational model (Akiyama et al.
[6]), the mean with updating is larger than that without updating. Because of the
reduction of uncertainties, COV is lower, especially, at near the inspection points.
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Prof. Maruyama at Tokyo City University,
Japan for his suggestions on the topic of stochastic field analysis.
References
Abstract Based on the excellent feature extraction and non-linear learning ability
of a convolutional neural network (CNN), a structural damage detection method is
proposed in this paper. When the structure is damaged, the changes of its modal
parameters reflect the damage information of the structure. A simply supported
beam was used and structural damage was introduced at different locations. The
finite element method was used to simulate the free vibration of the beam and
obtain the first-order modal strain energy for various damage scenarios. The
obtained modal parameters and the damage information were used as the training
samples of the neural network. A CNN was designed to detect damage (both
location and level), which detected damage location with 100% accuracy and
damage level with 5% relative error. Compared with a traditional Back Propagation
(BP) neural network, the CNN had more advantages than the BP neural network in
detecting damage location, and it was more economical in computational costs, the
uptime of the CNN was about 5%–40% that of the BP neural network. It is found
the CNN has excellent performance in detection of both damage locations and
levels, the detection effect exceeds BP neural network, and it is more economical in
computational cost than a BP neural network as it uses convolutional operation.
Keywords Structural damage detection Convolutional neural networks Modal
strain energy Feature extraction Simply supported beam
1 Introduction
2 Methods
The CNN was trained with the modal strain energy of various damage scenarios and
then used to predict new damage scenarios. In this paper, the collected data were
arranged into a two-dimensional matrix as the CNN input data. The abnormality of
the modal strain energy was extracted by the CNN to predict the damage location
and damage level.
The beam model used in this paper had a length of 9 m and a rectangular cross
section of 0.3 m 0.2 m. The structure was divided into 36 elements as numbered
in Fig. 1.
The Young’s modulus, Poisson’s ratio and density of the steel beam model were
211 GPa, 0.288, and 7800 kg/m3 respectively. Structural damage was simulated by
reducing the Young’s modulus of the concerned element. Totally 18 damage levels
for each element were simulated, which were from 5% to 90% with an increment of
5%. In-house python scripts were used to prepare the training samples for the CNN.
Firstly, the detection of damage location is studied. The validation set was based
on the cases with 45% damage in an element and the intact case (totally 37 sam-
ples), and the testing sets included the cases with either 10% or 60% damage in an
element (72 samples).The training set included the following five groups, each
group included 37 samples, i.e., 36 scenarios with damage in only one element plus
the intact case.
Dataset (A): only 15% damage in one element for each damage scenario plus the
intact case;
Element number:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 34 35 36
Dataset (B): only 30% damage in one element for each damage scenario plus the
intact case;
Dataset (C): only 75% damage in one element for each damage scenario plus the
intact case;
Dataset (D): only 90% damage in one element for each damage scenario plus the
intact case.
Then, the detection of damage level is studied. The validation set was based on
the data of 45% damage in an element and the intact case (37 samples), the samples
for 60% damage in an element (36 samples) were used to test the CNN fitting effect,
the training set included the following five groups.
Dataset (A): Every element was simulated with 15% damage levels, thus there were
36 damage scenarios, plus 1 intact case, and thus there were totally 37 samples.
Dataset (B): Every element was simulated with 75% damage levels, thus there were
36 damage scenarios, plus 1 intact case, and thus there were totally 37 samples.
Dataset (C): Every element was simulated with 15%, 30%, 75% and 90% damage
levels, thus there were 144 damage scenarios, plus 1 intact case, and thus there were
totally 145 samples.
Dataset (D): Every element was simulated with 16 damage levels from 5% to 90%
with an increment of 5%, thus there were 36 16 = 576 damage scenarios, plus 1
intact case, and thus there were totally 577 samples.
The CNN was designed and trained using the Deep Learning Toolbox in MATLAB
(MathWorks Inc, Natick, MA, US). The network included an input layer, 2 con-
volution layers, 1 pooling layer, an activation layer, a fully connected layer and
output layer (classification layer or regression layer); for classification problems, a
softmax layer was added after the fully connected layer. The explanations for the
activation function and convolution and pooling processes were seen in the
appendix A. In this paper, a CNN was designed for damage detection. The network
architecture and structural parameters of the CNN were shown in Fig. 2 and
Table 1.
The CNN input data, i.e., the modal strain energy of each element, was collected for
each damage scenario, and a matrix of 6 6 was constructed as the input. This
paper used a classification method to detect the damage location, which was set to
Structural Damage Detection with Modal Strain Energy ... 1293
1
Raw data 6 6 spread
799 36
C1 P C2
800
FC
Fig. 2 CNN framework. C1, C2: Convolution layers; P: Pooling layer; FC: Fully Connected layer
different categories, i.e. the intact condition was set to 0, the damage on the element
1 set to 1, the damage on the element 2 set to 2, and so on.
For detection damage level, by replacing the softmax layer and classification
layer with a regression layer of the CNN, the classification problem was trans-
formed into a regression problem. The network output was set as a vector consisting
of 36 elements, i.e. the 15% damage in Element 1 was set as [0.15, 0, 0… 0, 0, 0],
30% damage of Element 1 was set to [0.3, 0, 0, 0… 0, 0, 0], and so on; the intact
case was defined to be a vector of 36 zeros.
3 Results
The CNN was trained with the 4 training sets described in Sect. 2.1 separately. The
detection results were shown in Table 2.
1294 G. Chen and S. Teng
According to the detection effect of the four different Datasets, no matter which
dataset was used for training, the prediction accuracy was 100% for the testing set
with the damage level of 60%. For the testing set with the damage level of 10%, the
prediction accuracy reached 100% only for the CNN trained by Dataset (A).
In order to compare the detection effect between the CNN and a traditional BP
neural network, Dataset (A) was inputted into BP neural networks, and the pre-
diction results were shown in Table 3.
Table 3 showed that the detection effect of the BP neural networks was worse
than that of the CNN, and the detection effect of BP neural networks did not change
significantly with the node number of the hidden layer. The best detection effect
was 77.8%.
The testing sets were inputted into the trained network as described in Sect. 2.1.
The detection results were shown in Table 4, the relative error decreases with the
increase of training samples, and the minimum relative error of the damage level
was about 5%.
The relative error was used to evaluate the detection effect of damage level, and
the formula was as follows:
yp yt
RError ¼ 100% ð1Þ
yt
where yp and yt were the predicted value and target value of a testing sample. The
relative error for n testing samples was:
1 Xn yp yt
R Error ¼ 100% ð2Þ
n 1 yt
The Dataset (D) were inputted into the BP neural networks. After training, the
detection effect was obtained and shown in Table 5.
As shown in Table 5, with the increase of the nodes of the hidden layer, the
relative error of the BP neural networks decreased gradually, and the error was
lower than that of the CNN, but the training time increased significantly. The fitting
effect of the BP neural networks for damage level was better than that of the CNN.
Table 6 showed the uptimes of the CNN and the BP neural networks which had the
most comparative relative errors to that of the CNN.
When the relative errors were similar, the uptime of the CNN was about 5%–
40% that of the BP neural networks, the iteration time of the CNN was only about
1% that of the BP neural networks. For the smallest relative error (1%) of the BP
neural network in Table 5, the relative error of CNN was only 5%, but its uptime
was only 2% that of the BP neural network.
4 Discussions
The comparisons of damage locations detected between the CNNs and BP neural
networks showed that the CNNs had better classification ability than BP neural
networks to extract damage location features. The CNNs used partially connected
network structure to extract the main damage features, ignoring trivial information.
While the BP neural networks adopted a fully connected network structure, each
element in the raw data had an impact on the results.
It can be seen from Sect. 3.2 that the detection effect (damage level) of the BP
neural networks was slightly better than that of the CNN. When the BP neural
network had 36 and 42 nodes in the hidden layer, the relative errors were 6% and
2%, respectively, and the CNN were 5%. The uptime was 10 min 24 s, 78 min
58 s, 4 min 21 s, respectively. Thus, when the relative error was similar, the uptime
of CNN was 5%–40% that of the BP neural networks.
Structural Damage Detection with Modal Strain Energy ... 1297
In summary, the BP neural networks had excellent regression fitting effects but
consumed a lot of computing resources. Because of its partial connection, the CNN
lost some information and its fitting effect was sacrificed in the training process, but
the calculation speed was faster than that of the BP neural network.
5 Conclusion
References
12. Krizhevsky A, Hinton G (2009) Learning multiple layers of features from tiny images.
Technical report, University of Toronto
13. Lawrence S, Giles CL, Tsoi AC, Back AD (1997) Face recognition: a convolutional
neural-network approach. IEEE Trans Neural Networks 8(1):98–113
14. Li R, Yuan Y, Wei Z, Yuan Y (2018) Unified vision‐based methodology for simultaneous
concrete defect detection and geolocalization. Comput-Aided Civil Infrastruct Eng
15. Lin YZ, Nie ZH, Ma HW (2017) Structural Damage Detection with Automatic Feature
extraction through Deep Learning. Comput-Aided Civil Infrastruct Eng (6)
16. Pal J, Banerjee S (2015) A combined modal strain energy and particle swarm optimization for
health monitoring of structures. J Civil Struct Health Monitor 5(4):1–11
17. Pandey AK, Biswas M, Samman MM (1991) Damage detection from changes in curvature
mode shapes. J Sound Vibration 145(2):321–332
18. Qiao P, Lu K (2007) Curvature Mode Shape-Based Damage Detection in Composite
Laminated Plates. Compos Struct 80(3):409–428
19. Seyedpoor SM (2012) A two stage method for structural damage detection using a modal
strain energy based index and particle swarm optimization. Int J Non-Linear Mech 47(1):1–8
20. Shen MHH, Grady JE (1992) Free vibrations of delaminated beams. AIAA J 30(5):1361–
1370
21. Shi ZY, Law SS, Zhang LM (2000) Structural damage localization from modal strain energy
change. J Eng Mech 218(5):1216–1223
22. Tensmeyer C, Saunders D, Martinez T (2017) Convolutional Neural Networks for Font
Classification. In Paper presented at the International Conference on Document Analysis and
Recognition
23. Xu H, Humar JM (2010) Damage detection in a girder bridge by artificial neural network
technique. Comput Aided Civil Infrastruct Eng 21(6):450–464
24. Yan YJ, Cheng L, Wu ZY, Yam LH (2007) Development in vibration-based structural
damage detection technique. Mech Syst Signal Process 21(5):2198–2211
25. Yao D, Zhu W, Chen Y, Zhang L (2018) Chinese license plate character recognition based on
convolution neural network. In: Chinese Automation Congress
26. Yao WS (2004) The Researching Overview of Evolutionary Neural Networks. Computer
Science
27. Yao X (1993) Evolutionary artificial neural networks. Int J Neural Syst 4(03):203–222
28. Yuan ZW, Zhang J (2016) Feature extraction and image retrieval based on AlexNet. In:
Eighth International Conference on Digital Image Processing
29. Zou Y, Tong L, Steven GP (2017) vibration-based model-dependent damage (delamination)
identification and health monitoring for composite structures — a review. J Sound Vib 10
(1):165–193
Simplified Model for Wind-Induced
Comfort Analysis and Design
of Mega-Structures with Viscous
Damped Outriggers
1 Introduction
As shown in Fig. 1, the simplified model proposed in this paper simplifies the core
tube of supertalls into a shear wall element that can simulate the bending defor-
mation of the core tube under lateral loads; the mega column is simplified as a
Simplified Model for Wind-Induced Comfort Analysis… 1301
Fig. 1 Composition of
acceleration prediction
simplified model
column element in the shear wall plane which can simulate the axial deformation of
the mega column under lateral loads; and the outrigger element simplified as the
beam which can simulate the self-deformation under load. Only one slice of the
prototype models is taken to simplify the model, and only the main components in
the lateral resistance system are considered in the simplification process.
There are three components in the simplified model, which is wall, column and
beam.
The wall in the simplified mode has the same geometry as the web wall and
flange wall in the prototype, where the flange wall effective thickness equals to 6
times flange wall thickness plus web wall thickness in accordance with Chinese
code (Code for Seismic Design of Buildings (GB 50011-2010 [3])) as shown in
formula (5). If there is a narrow hole in the middle of the web wall, it is believed
that the wall bending stiffness weakening is relatively small and the wall still accord
with the plan-section assumption, so the web wall can be simplified to a piece of
integrated wall with a length of LW shown in Fig. 2. Otherwise the hole should be
included in the simplified model.
ð1Þ
.
Where Lf is the length of the flange wall, TW is the thickness of web wall and TF
is the thickness of flange wall.
The column in the simplified model should have same section as the prototype as
shown by b and h in Fig. 2. And in order to get unidirectional reaction the column and
wall was simplified as a plane model in whichL_{{\text{f}}} = T_{W} + 6T_{F} the
1302 Y. Yang et al.
H
H
TW 6TF
TW 6TF
LW TW LW TW
H LF
H
h
h
b
b
Mega Column
Core Wall
Outrigger
Outrigger Beam
column is pushed horizontally into the web wall plane. So, the distance in vertical
direction is just as same as the prototype, which is shown by the H in Fig. 2.
The simplified method of wall and column is shown in Fig. 2.
As shown in Fig. 3, the mega beam between the core and column in prototype
can be divided into 3 categories: one is the rigid outrigger, one is the damped
outrigger, and one is no outrigger. The simplify methods differ correspondingly.
For the rigid and damped outrigger, it will be simplified to normal beam with the
same stiffness. For the region without outrigger and the gap between the column
and damped outrigger, they will be simplified as a rigid bar with both ends released
to simulate the horizontal restriction provided by the slab.
Simplified Model for Wind-Induced Comfort Analysis… 1303
Because the force arm between the columns is large, it provides a huge
anti-overturning moment and greatly reduces the overturning moment borne by the
core tube. It can be inferred that the axial stiffness and angle of column is key to the
structure stiffness which is embodied by the structure period. Just as shown in the
Fig. 5, when the axial stiffness is reduced to half the period increase by 1.2 s.
Although the structure stiffness is sensitive to the column axial stiffness, the
cross-section area and angle can be got easily and be expressed as exactly same as
the prototype.
1304 Y. Yang et al.
Period (S)
7
6
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Column axis stiffness coefficient
7.1
0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
Column shear stiffness coefficient
Since the column has large slenderness ratio, the column can only provide the
shearing capacity by bending deformation, and as shown in Fig. 6 the picture below
changing the section shear stiffness from half two double almost has no influence on
the structure period.
That is to say, the simulation of height-width ratio of column section is not the
key factor affecting the accuracy of prediction results of simplified model.
Simplified Model for Wind-Induced Comfort Analysis… 1305
(S)
7
Period
6
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Column bending stiffness coefficient
Since the slenderness ration of column is relatively large and the section is much
smaller than the core wall tube, which means that the bending stiffness provided by
the column is much less than that provided by the core wall tube, the bending
stiffness coefficient of column has small influence on the structure. As shown in
Fig. 7, when double the column stiffness the period drops down by 0.2 s and even
when reduce the stiffness to 1/10 the period increases by no more than 0.5 s, which
shows that the bending stiffness has almost no influence the structure stiffness.
That is to say, the simulation of height-width ratio of column section is not the
key factor affecting the accuracy of prediction results of simplified model.
It can be inferred that the beam section has a greater impact base on the fact that the
axial force in column is transferred by beam as shear force. It is shown is the Fig. 9
that when the beam is too weak to coordinate the core tube and periphery frame the
period is much elongated, but when the beam line stiffness is pretty much larger
than that of the column the period cannot increase along with it further. While, from
Fig. 8 it can be inferred that in the scope of normal size of mega frame, the stiffness
of the outrigger is much larger than the column from the fact that when the stiffness
is double or half the period only change about 0.2 s, which is in accordance with
the fact that the outrigger normally occupies one or two stories which equals to 5 to
10 m and the column section usually ranges from 0.8 to maximum 5 m.
1306 Y. Yang et al.
Period (S)
12
11
10
9
8
7
6
10-7 10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 105
Beam bending stiffness coefficient
7
Period
6
0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0
Beam bending stiffness coefficient
That is to say, in the regular size range, the beam section is large enough that the
accuracy of its simulation has little effect on the results.
Because of the hinged connection between the floor beams and the columns cannot
restrain the deformation of mega columns, even when the beams and columns are
rigidly connected the coordinated effect of the beams on ordinary floors can be
neglected due to its small cross section area. Based on the previous argument, it can
be seen that even if the introduction of beams can improve the coordination effect
Simplified Model for Wind-Induced Comfort Analysis… 1307
between the core and column or can improve the flexural and shear stiffness of
columns a little, the impact of structural stiffness and period is not significant.
Because the supertall is high, the wall can be seen as a cantilever beam member and
the bending stiffness will impact the structure stiffness a lot. The bending stiffness is
mainly decided by the flange wall while the web wall mainly transfer the shear
force, which resembles the H-shape beams. This point can be verified by Table 1
that the period significantly drop down from 7.3 s to 6.3 s when adding up the
flange wall to the simplified model without flange wall.
In order to compare the correlation of first order modes between the simplified
model and prototype, the concept of mode confidence criterion (MAC) is intro-
duced as below.
T 2
/ /j
i
MACij ¼
/Ti /i /Tj /j
Where /i ; /j is mode vector. The closer the MAC is near to 1, the more
correlative the two modes are.
Change the flange wall stiffness coefficient, and extracted data from the two
models. The normalized first-order mode shapes are drawn in the following Fig. 10
and the MAC is listed in Table 2.
1308 Y. Yang et al.
600
500
400
Structure Height(m)
Fig. 10 Sensitivity of the first order mode shape to the flange wall stiffness of simplified model
The results show that the MAC values are bigger than 0.999 when the flexural
stiffness of the wall doubles or decreases to half. That is to say, the mode distri-
bution is not sensitive to the absolute size of the simplified model wall members
and the relative stiffness of the wall-column members. It is easy for the first mode
shapes of the simplified model resembling that of the prototype, which ensures the
accuracy of the predicted results of the simplified model. It can be seen from the
following Figure that when the stiffness correction factor of the flange wall is close
to 1, the shape of the simplified model is closest to that of the prototype model,
which verifies the feasibility of the flange wall effective width methodology.
Simplified Model for Wind-Induced Comfort Analysis… 1309
4 Conclusions
References
1. Chen Y, Mcfarland DM, Wang Z et al (2010) Analysis of tall buildings with damped
outriggers. J Struct Eng 136(11):1435–1443
2. Cheng P, Ma LZ, Chen YQ (2015) Application of outrigger damping system in high-rise
building structures. In: Papers collection of the fifth national building structure technology
exchange conference, vol. 2
3. China Ministry of Construction (CMC) 2010. Code for Seismic Design of Buildings (GB
50011-2010). China Architecture & Building Press: Beijing. (in Chinese)
4. He S, Yu ZW (2009) A review of research on seismic performance of mega-frame structure
systems. Ind Constr 39(5):101–105
5. Huang B, Takeuchi T (2017) Dynamic response evaluation of damped-outrigger systems with
various heights. Earthquake Spectra 33(2):665–685
6. O’Neill JC (2015) Application of damping in high-rise building. Massachusetts Institute of
Technology 2006
7. Tan P, Fang CJ, Chang CM et al (2016) Dynamic characteristics of novel energy dissipation
systems with damped outriggers. Eng Struct 98:128–140
8. Wang LL, Zhao X, Zheng YM (2016) A combined tuned damper and an optimal design
method for wind-induced vibration control for super tall buildings. Struct Des Tall Spec Build
25(10):468–502
9. Wang DY, Zhang YS, Zhou Y (2017) Study on occupant comfort evaluation mode of tall
buildings in wind excitation based on fuzzy probability method. Struct Des Tall Spec Build
26:e1365. https://doi.org/10.1002/tal.1365
10. Zhu JJ, Lu XL, Zou Y (2005) Shake-table test and theoretical analysis for shanghai world
financial center scale model. China Civil Eng J 10:18–26
Porcupine Quill: Buckling Resistance
Analysis and Design for 3D Printing
Abstract Recently, materials with lightweight and high mechanical strength are on
high demand. These characteristics are exceptionally important in various field,
particularly in structural engineering. Nature offers inspirational solutions which are
beyond our expectations. Plants and animals are made of well-architectured
structures and materials to protect themselves against harsh environments and
enemies, same goes to porcupines. Under emergency condition, porcupine protects
itself by jabbing the quills into the skin of the assailant. The long and sharp
cylindrical quill possesses outstanding mechanical properties including lightweight
and high buckling resistance. At present, research focusing on the mechanical
analysis of porcupine quills in the literature is limited. The extraordinary features of
the quills are known but not fully-explored. At different cross-sections within a
same quill, different microstructural patterns are observed. To better understand the
buckling property of porcupine quill, compression test is performed. This paper is
aimed to microstructurally investigate the mechanism of buckling resistance in
porcupine quill at different cross-sections. Theoretical analysis is performed via
buckling theory proposed in the literature. Based on the understanding of this
biological structure, a design approach is proposed to mimic the porcupine quills
for 3D printing.
1 Introduction
Nature has created living things with unique biological structures as means to
protect themselves against harsh environments and predators (Malik et al. [6]). The
well-architectured designs equipped with high strength and lightweight are often the
source of inspirations for researchers to solve structural problems. This leads to the
emergence of new research area: bio-inspiration [11, 14, 16].
Sophisticated structures with lightweight and good mechanical properties are
gaining attentions [8]. Porcupine quill is known for its exceptional buckling
resistant. Recent years, researchers are exploring the mechanical properties of
porcupine quills [1, 13, 17]. Based on the reported results, the buckling stress varies
depending on a few factors, including quill species and condition of the quill [1,
17]. Microstructure of quill consist of mainly the outer shell and inner core. Vincent
and Owers [15] reported that denser shell delays local buckling of a filled cylinder.
However, the role of the core in resisting buckling is not clearly defined.
The theory of buckling analysis of hollow cylinder is proposed by Timoshenko
[12]. Karam and Gibson [4] improvised the theory which consider the buckling
stress contributed by both the shell and the core. Both theory of hollow cylinder and
filled cylinder are used to calculate the buckling stress and comparisons are made
with the experimental values. In most scenario, theoretical buckling stress are found
to be much higher than the experimental values obtained [13, 17]. There is no
explanation on the reason for the mismatched values up to date.
Research works based on additive manufacturing or 3D printing has increased
dramatically in recent decades. Being an efficient tool for rapid prototyping with
low production cost, more attention is given to produce complex geometries [2].
Podrouzek et al. incorporated bio-inspiration of 3D infill patterns for structural
application [9]. They mainly focus on Gyroid and Schwarz patterns. A better
representation of nature could be introduced, such as a Voronoi infill to mimic the
core structure of porcupine quill.
The paper is organized as follows. The next section gives information on the
experimental setup. This is followed by the buckling analysis and 3D printing of
cylinder with different infills. The final part includes conclusions and future works.
2 Experimental Setup
African porcupine quills were purchased. Due to the non-uniform diameter at both
ends of the quill, the specimens were cut using surgical tools, each with the length
of approximately 5 mm. Samples were prepared from the same strand of quill to
avoid data discrepancy due to nature properties. Figure 1a shows the purchased
quill with middle section as the region of interest. Three types of samples were
Porcupine Quill: Buckling Resistance Analysis ... 1313
prepared as presented in Fig. 1b, the whole quill, Fig. 1c, shell only and Fig. 1d,
foam only. Experimental buckling stress were calculated based on the whole
cross-section of the quills.
2.3.1 3D Printing
Cylinder with different infills were designed and formed into two groups, uniform
and Voronoi respectively. The designed structures were printed using Zortrax M200
Plus printing machine using Z-Ultrat filament. The parameters were by default
mode.
The microstructures of porcupine quills are shown in Fig. 2. The porcupine quill
consists of the shells, foam and stiffeners. The foam size is smaller near the shell
and larger towards the centre of the quills. There are stiffeners along the longitu-
dinal direction of the quills. The thickness of the shell is approximately 0.13 mm,
while the diameter of the quills was between 2 to 4.5 mm.
The microstructure of quill during buckling was captured as shown in Fig. 3. It
can be observed that the shell was compressed in a wavy form. Foam structure
remained attached to the shell after buckling.
Fig. 2 Structure of porcupine quill via micro-CT scan before compression: (left) transverse
cross-section and (right) longitudinal cross-section
Porcupine Quill: Buckling Resistance Analysis ... 1315
Fig. 3 Structure of porcupine quill after compression: a transverse cross-section and b longitu-
dinal cross-section
Axial compression test was conducted on whole quill, shell and core. Figure 4
shows the stress-strain curve of a quill under axial compression. Although quills in
the original state were subjected to mechanical loading, the curves exhibited were
similar to the core-only compression as described by Gibson [3], Reddy and Wall
[10], McKittrick et al. [7] and Liu et al. [5].
Different strain rates were imposed onto the quills during compression, however
strain rate plays minimum role in axial compression. No significant variation
between the results at different strain rates. The stress-strain curves were consistent
as the samples were originated from a single quill. The specimens exhibited elastic
region up to 12 MPa, followed by a plateau with fluctuant serration and finally
densification. Elastic modulus of the foam was obtained at linear elastic region.
Differ from the presented data by McKittrick et al. [7], Torres et al. [13] and Yang
et al., no initial peak stress and load drop before plateau. One interesting phe-
nomenon that differ from the data in the literature is the slight drop of stress before
densification. This could be explained from the microscopic point of view. Each
component of the foam and shell failed consecutively during the plateau regime.
Individual cell in the foam collapsed gradually leading to the slight drop in stress.
Densification is initiated when the foam structure started to collapse.
Figure 5 shows the representative stress-strain curves of whole quill, shell and
core. Both whole quill and shell shows elastic region prior to buckling. They are
followed by fluctuated stress. This could be explained by the occurrence of local
failure in the samples. Similar to the whole quill and shell, the stress-strain curve of
foam initiated with an elastic region. There is a plateau region before densification
occur. It is worth to note that there is no load drop as for the case of whole quill
sample.
1316 Y. L. Tee et al.
Table 1 shows the properties of porcupine quills samples before axial com-
pression loading and their corresponding experimental buckling stress and theo-
retical buckling stress based on Karam and Gibson’s model [4].
Et
r0 ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð1Þ
a 3ð 1 v 2 Þ
where v is the Poisson’s ratio, E is the Young’s modulus, t is the thickness and R is
the radius.
Porcupine Quill: Buckling Resistance Analysis ... 1317
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
rcr ¼ 3ð1 v2 Þr0 f1 ð2Þ
Two groups of infill patterns were designed. The first group of patterns are shown in
Fig. 6. Figure 6a(i–iii) and (iv–vi) illustrates the isometric view and top view of the
CAD designs respectively. From left to right showing hollow, angular stiffeners and
grid infills. The next group of patterns were inspired from porcupine quill as shown
in Fig. 7. Figure 7a are the isotropic views and top views of the CAD designs. The
patterns are generated via Grasshopper and graphically integrated into Rhinoceros
6. Voronoi structure is generated according to the allocated seed number and cell
size. The wall thickness is then imposed via offset function. The infill of the
cylinder is uniform along the z-axis, which is applied via extrusion.
The designed cylindrical shell with infills are then converted into STL files and
sliced using Z-Suite software. The parameter such as layer thickness and nozzle size
are by default mode, 0.9 mm and 0.4 mm respectively.
1318 Y. L. Tee et al.
Fig. 6 CAD design of cylindrical structures with uniform infills (left) and 3D printed structures
(right)
Fig. 7 CAD design of cylindrical structures with Voronoi infills (left) and 3D printed structures
(right)
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the facilities, and the scientific and technical
assistance, of the Advanced Manufacturing Precinct (AMP) and the Rheology and Materials
Characterisation (RMPC) laboratory at RMIT University.
Porcupine Quill: Buckling Resistance Analysis ... 1319
References
1. Chou S, Overfelt R (2011) Tensile deformation and failure of North American porcupine
quills. Mater Sci Eng, C 31(8):1729–1736
2. du Plessis A, Broeckhoven C, Yadroitsava I, Yadroitsev I, Hands CH, Kunju R, Bhate D
(2019) Beautiful and functional: a review of biomimetic design in additive manufacturing.
Additive Manufacturing
3. Gibson LJ (2005) Biomechanics of cellular solids. J Biomech 38(3):377–399
4. Karam G, Gibson L. (1995) Elastic buckling of cylindrical shells with elastic cores - I.
Analysis. Int J Solids Struct, 32(8–9):1259-1283
5. Liu Q, Fu J, Wang J, Ma J, Chen H, Li Q, Hui D (2017) Axial and lateral crushing responses
of aluminum honeycombs filled with EPP foam. Compos B Eng 130:236–247
6. Malik IA, Mirkhalaf M, Barthelat F (2017) Bio-inspired “jigsaw”-like interlocking sutures:
modeling, optimization, 3D printing and testing. J Mech Phys Solids. 102:224–238
7. McKittrick J, Chen P-Y, Bodde S, Yang W, Novitskaya E, Meyers M (2012) The structure,
functions, and mechanical properties of keratin. JOM 64(4):449–468
8. Meyers MAe, McKittrick J, Chen P-Y (2013) Structural biological materials: critical
mechanics-materials connections. Science 339(6121):773–779
9. Podrouzekz J, Marcon M, Nincevic K, Wan-Wendner R (2019) Bio-Inspired 3D Infill
Patterns for Additive Manufacturing and Structural Applications. Materials 12(3):499
10. Reddy T, Wall R (1988) Axial compression of foam-filled thin-walled circular tubes. Int J
Impact Eng 7(2):151–166
11. Sanchez C, Arribart H, Guille, MMGJNm (2005) Biomimetism and bioinspiration as tools for
the design of innovative materials and systems. 4(4):277
12. Timoshenko S (1914) Buckling of cylinders (exact title unknown). Bull Electrotech Inst St
Petersburg
13. Torres FG, Troncoso OP, Diaz J, Arce D (2014) Failure analysis of porcupine quills under
axial compression reveals their mechanical response during buckling. Journal of the
mechanical behavior of biomedical materials, 39111–118
14. Vincent JF (2009) Biomimetics - a review. Proc Inst Mech Eng [H] 223(8):919–939
15. Vincent JF, Owers P (1986) Mechanical design of hedgehog spines and porcupine quills.
J Zool 210(1):55–75
16. Whitesides, GMJIf (2015) Bioinspiration: something for everyone, 5(4):20150031
17. Yang W, McKittrick J (2013) Separating the influence of the cortex and foam on the
mechanical properties of porcupine quills. Acta Biomater 9(11):9065–9074
Investigation into Application
of Artificial Intelligence to Facade
Abstract Glazed curtain wall (GCW) facades have increasing popularity on newly
constructed high-rise buildings and match with current aesthetics of urban com-
munities. Traditional routine inspection procedure of these façade involves
obtaining building inspection scope, accessing the building with suitable equip-
ment, recording the conditions and results from hands-on inspection, and lastly,
providing a proper inspection report with advices on the facades. Qualified
inspectors are usually stayed up in the mid-air for hours to detect all potential
falling threats and defects on the exterior facade. This form of inspection is time
consuming and risky, and thus Artificial intelligence (AI) could be a suitable
alternative in this façade inspections. This paper reviews the capability of using AI
damage detection framework through a detail literature review. Following this, a
suitable AI framework is developed to assist the façade inspection for structural
damage. This proposed façade detection system is designed to utilise drones to
capture façade images at height while using Convolution Neural Network
(CNN) model with deep learning algorithms to process those images for damage
identification. In this damage detection AI framework VGG16 and a modified CNN
were recommended for the detection of the corrosion of aluminium, gasket and
silicone sealant degradation and cracks in glass. This can potentially reduce the
risks associated with the current façade inspection practices.
Keywords Deep learning Facade inspection Convolutional Neural Network
Artificial intelligence Glazed facades
1 Introduction
Façades are the exterior skin of a building, which separate the inside and outside
environments in order to protect the occupants from wind, rain, temperature and
other environmental actions. Various types of façade systems are available, such as
solid masonry walls, pre-cast concrete walls and glazed curtain walls. Glazed
curtain wall (GCW) façade system is now increasingly used in high-rise buildings
due to its aesthetic appearance, ease of construction and economy. Therefore, the
scope of this research is limited to GCW façade system. GCW facade system
comprises glass panes, aluminium frame, gaskets and sealants. Glass panes are
supported by the aluminium frame, which is made of vertical (mullions) and hor-
izontal (transoms) members. Furthermore, depending of the type of glazing it is
categorized as structural (glass panes are bonded to the frame using structural
silicone sealants) or captive (glass panes are placed in between rubber gaskets)
glazing system.
In industry annealed, heat strengthened, tempered and laminated glass types are
used. In comparison with ordinary annealed glass and heat strengthened glass,
tempered glass is stronger and can resist higher loads. However, when tempered
glass is broken its small beads falling from a height of more than three storeys can
still cause severe injuries to a person. Therefore, laminated glass panes are used,
where glass panes are laminated using an interlayer that prevents falling of glass
pieces. For lamination, either annealed or tempered glass types can be used in order
to get laminated annealed or laminated tempered glass. Aluminium is widely used
in façade framing due to its light weight, high strength to weight ratio, and par-
ticularly, extrudability. Aluminium is protected using anodising, powder coating
and PVDF coating. Aluminium anodising is most commonly used in industry since
anodising process thickens the oxidation layer, which already exists on the alu-
minium surface and has high resistance to physical damage.
One of the aims of this research investigation is to identify the potential damage/
defect types of GCW components, particularly glass panes and aluminium frame. In
terms of glass pane, the damage type is glass cracking that can be due to thermal
expansion and contraction of the frame structure, or physical impacts such as wind
born debris attack. For the heat strengthened glass and laminated glass without
tempering, the cracking pattern would look the same as ordinary annealed glass,
which breaks into large jagged and sharp fragments (Fig. 1). When a tempered
glass pane is impacted it would shatter into relatively small non-pointed cube beads
as shown in Fig. 1. Crack pattern in a laminated glass will depends on the crack
pattern of the glass used for lamination.
Investigation into Application of Artificial Intelligence to Facade 1323
Fig. 1 Breakage Patterns Based on Glass Type (Image from https://rocklinglass.com [Accessed
on September 12, 2019])
The corrosion is a chemical reaction, where it reacts with the environment and
leads to aluminium deterioration. Aluminium will react with water/moisture and
atmospheric oxygen to form a thin and dense layer of aluminium oxide. This
coherent surface oxide, a stable passive layer that is about 4 nm thick, is the reason
why aluminium materials have very high resistance to corrosion and can resist
further oxidation or corrosion caused by the environment. However when the oxide
layer become unstable, the aluminium corrosion will continue to proceed. Such
corrosion on aluminium can be crevice, galvanic and filiform corrosion (Fig. 2). As
the corrosion process continues it may lead to failure of the facade.
Crevice corrosion can arise when saltwater and water enters a crevice, which can
be located at surface holes, underneath a gasket where two parts are overlapped, lap
joints under bolts or under rivet heads (see Fig. 2(a)). This can lead to corrosion on
the surface (water spots). Galvanic corrosion is also known as dissimilar metal
corrosion. This type of corrosion is regarding as electrochemical corrosion. It
occurs when two different metals are electrically connected and share the same
electrolyte with one of the metal being more nobler. This creates a potential dif-
ference that flow liked a circuit where a more active (negative) metal flows to a
more noble (positive) metal. This is called galvanic coupling. With most of the
materials, aluminium is the less noble metal. This poses a greater risk of galvanic
corrosion on aluminium (see Fig. 2(b)). Filiform Corrosion is a special form of
corrosion that occurs normally under a protective film or metallic coatings on
aluminium, like crevice corrosion. Filiform corrosion requires both chlorides and
relatively high level of humidity for the moisture to permeate the coating layer. If
humidity is over 95%, blister corrosion can occur. After moisture went underneath
of the painted surfaces, filiform corrosion starts to occur in between the layers as
shown in Fig. 2(c).
1324 M. Bowman et al.
Cha et al. [4] conducted a study on corrosion and cracks detection using AI. Their
study gives details on developing AI-based solution through Convolutional Neural
Networks (CNN) to detect and locate the defects on buildings [4]. Figure 3 describes
the hierarchical components AI-based solutions. Machine Learning is a field of
computer science that deals with developing computational systems to learn [8],
which is developing meaningful information from a set of input data. This can be
developed in Unsupervised or Supervised manner depending on the availability of
the input-data. In Supervised learning system, the learning is conducted with inputs
and information containing the desired outputs from the learning as shown in [10].
improve the system. For this process, the is needed [9]. There are many neurons in
the output layer. Therefore, there will be multiple gradient descents recommended
to improve the system. To compute all the recommendations for the previous layer
of neurons Backpropagation is used [9]. The Backpropagation takes in all the
recommended changes for a downstream layer and assigns changes to the upstream
layer to induce the desired result. From implementing this method, the NN can learn
from given certain training data. Now that SL learning for NN has been explained,
in its basics, the operation and application of CNN can be touched upon.
The pooling layer is responsible for reduction in the array sizes in NN. To do
this, averaging or maximum pooling methods can be used [5]. However, maximum
pooling method is recommended since it is more effective in training the NN. By
using the maximum pooling layer, the data is reduced, and therefore, the demand on
the hardware is reduced. The ReLU is responsible of converting all the numbers in
the array to a value between zero and a positive number [9]. The softmax layer is
the layer responsible for relating the output to a probabilistic value, a value between
one and zero. Converting the outputs to a probabilistic form benefits the CNN in
multiple classifications [4]. By combining all the different components a CNN can
be constructed, and developing a CNN for damage detection in GCW applications
can be approached.
Few studies were conducted in the past on corrosion and crack detection using
CNN. For corrosion of aluminium mullions, colour and shapes are the key features
to identify the damage, and NNs can be used to detect these features. Deegan
recommended a CNN by comparing different previously implemented corrosion
detection models considering their robustness in categorising images. For the CNN,
Deegan specified that a VGG16 model would be a robust model to use. The
robustness of the CNN was attributed to its convolutional layers. It also noted, as
more corrosion types are classified, the fully connected layer becomes important.
1328 M. Bowman et al.
Within the VGG16 model, it was suggested to set the sliding window to 128 128
and to use either RGB or YCbCr colour space to help classification. Based on these,
Atha and Jahanshahi [2] showed that CNN is possible for corrosion detection
(Fig. 6).
Based on the recommendations of this paper, an AI framework for the GCW
could be developed, which could feature a CNN for the classification of the dif-
ferent defects of aluminium. In that the VGG16 could be used to detecting the
damages. This would be possible as the main damage types for mullions are cor-
rosion types. From applying a VGG16 model to the AI, the aluminium corrosion
aspect of the AI could be generated.
Cha et al. [4] recommended the use of CNN for detection of cracks in concrete
since concrete cracks are in inhomogeneous environments. They recommended to
have two convolutional layers, two pooling layers and a Softmax layer. The con-
volutional layers used initial randomly generated weights. The test results showed
positive results to varied image inputs [4]. Since concrete and glass are different
materials, this CNN cannot be directly applied to glass crack detection. However, it
can be used as a base for developing a CNN for detecting cracks in glass.
Furthermore, the main damage types in GCWs are aluminium corrosion and glass
cracks. Therefore, by using the recommended CNNs a CNN framework could be
developed for GCWs.
to be detected by the AI. As previously noted, a CNN can be able to perform the
categorization adequately for each of these features.
As the scope of the research is tailored to GCWs, the AI classification will be
focused towards this. Figure 7 shows recommended overall layout of the AI
framework. When inspecting the site, there are two main elements for the facade:
mullions, and the glass panels. AI would have to be able to detect between glass and
aluminium elements. After the materials have been classified the corresponding
damage detections could be made. Details of the layer-architecture of the proposed
CNN is shown in Table 1.
It would be recommended to extrapolate research from damage detection from
other materials and applications. Therefore, the aluminium corrosion detection, a
VGG16 CNN will be utilized to detect the defects. The benefit of this model is the
CNN can categorize corrosion and has been noted as a robust build. For the crack
detection, it will be recommended to use the crack detection previously for concrete
and attempt to apply it to glass panel cracks. Appendix C contains a summary of the
layout of their structures. For the design and optimization of the AI framework, data
will be needed to develop the different CNN. These labels should reflect the
classifications the AI will have to be made. After testing and optimization, a proof
of concept could be completed. Following that it would be investigating the ways of
implementing the AI in a façade inspection. If it can be used in façade inspection of
GCWs, risks and safety issues associated with the conventional visual inspection
methods can be reduced.
1330 M. Bowman et al.
4 Conclusions
This paper presents an artificial intelligence (AI) framework for assisting the con-
ventional inspection method of Glazed Curtain Wall (GCW) façades of buildings.
This proposed façade detection system is designed to utilise the flying drone’s
ability to capture the façade image at height. This will reduce the need for tech-
nicians to conduct inspections while suspended in mid-air. Application of this
proposed system could possibly reduce both the risk and the associated costs of the
conventional inspection approach. Furthermore, the system will process the façade
images by using Convolution Neural Network (CNN) model with deep learning
algorithms. This CNN model will help to reduce the amount of labour when
inspecting a façade. This is possible because of the visual recognition CNN.
References
1. Andrew NgJN, Chuan YF, Yifan M, Caroline S, Adam C, Andrew M, Awni H, Brody H,
Tao W, Sameep T (2013) Feature Extraction Using Convolution. http://ufldl.stanford.edu/
tutorial/supervised/FeatureExtractionUsingConvolution/
Investigation into Application of Artificial Intelligence to Facade 1331
Keywords Deep learning Facade inspection Convolutional Neural Network
Artificial intelligence Rope-access
1 Introduction
Glass Curtain Walls (GCWs) are becoming popular facade system in building
construction. During operation of a building it is important to perform routine
façade inspections in order to ensure its life span and safety since materials degrade
with time. Facade inspection is the practice of locating and assessing facade
damages of a building [17]. The purpose of this exercise is to actively check the risk
of facades harming the public or other structural elements 1]. In order to do this,
visual inspections and possible ‘hands-on’ testing are conducted so that health of
facade elements can be recorded and highlighted [17, 12]. With the advancement in
computer technology damage detection methods that use Artificial Intelligence
(AI) becomes possible, and thus possibility of using Convolutional Neural Network
(CNN) method in the field of facade inspections should be investigated. This paper
investigates the possible barriers in implementing CNN damage detection method,
with the use of drones, in the field of facade inspections in Australia.
By using drone technology, safety of façade inspection operation could be
increased, and also the time spent on manual inspection method (rope access) could
be reduced (Choi and Kim [2]. On the other hand, a preliminary investigation of a
façade could be conducted using drone so that the time or the need for an individual
to conduct a rope access inspection could be reduced [14]. As a result, the liabilities
of a company in regards to the safety of workers could be reduced. In addition,
damage inspections may become more accessible for clients through preliminary
inspections. If these potential benefits need to be achieved, factors that resist the
deployment of such technology must be understood and considered.
In the context of Information Technology (IT), barriers are something that hinder
the progression of IT developments. These can be social, technological or cost
related constructs that pose a problem. For instance, 18 month legal battle of Waste
Management and SAP costing $100 million is an example for this [9]. This incident
was about SAP’s implementation of a software called ERP. Waste management
claimed SAP’s ‘failure’ of the system was due to fraudulent sales and SAP was
claiming Waste Management did not define their business requirements. In this
scenario, the communication of the stakeholder’s perceptions played a large factor
in hindering such technology to emerge [9]. This is an example of social factors
being a barrier, but it is worth noting there are many other factors that can impact
the successful implementation of such technologies. Through proper investigations
such potential barriers to CNN damage detection approach can be successfully
managed. For non-technological barriers, in the context of IT, it was identified that
stakeholder communication and input played a key role for the successful imple-
mentation [10]. Therefore, increasing client and stakeholder interactions through a
forum to allow better communication are important.
When reviewing the challenges faced with implementation of IT systems in
small to medium size enterprise businesses, particularly in the Australian con-
struction industry, it was found planning had a greater importance [11]. It was
recommended for these size businesses that a strategic planning need to be
implemented within their respective businesses [11]. This plan was regarding how
the IT would work within their business. The reason for this solution surrounds the
impact IT systems had in their industry. By considering the recommendations and
findings of barriers for the past examples, barriers associated with façade inspec-
tions can be identified and managed.
Barriers in Implementing the Convolutional Neural Network Damage Detector 1335
As the use of drone technology is being used, regulations towards commercial use
of unmanned aircraft come in effect. In Australia, the governing body that manages
the use of drones is the Australian Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). It has
implemented the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 and Civil Aviation
Legislation Amendment Regulation 2016, which stipulates the requirements for
operating drones. In the specifications, it classify the size and the use that must be
considered in practice. Drones are classified into four different classes, which are
very small, small, medium, and large. In fact, very small, small, medium and large
means weight less than 2 kg, between 2 and 25 kg, between 25 and 150 kg and
above 150 kg, respectively. Once the size of a drone size is classified, its use needs
to be defined. Table 1 gives a summary of the details of the categories and the
regulations of drones that are relevant to commercial use. Depending on the type of
application and the technical specifications of drones to be used for GCW
inspections, appropriate regulations need to be adopted in practice.
In addition to the aforementioned regulations, there are other important regu-
lations that apply to a drone-based inspection [3–8]. They are:
• The aircraft must operate within visual line of site, which can be changed if
CASA grant it.
• The drone should be below 120 m during day time.
• The drone should be operating 30 m away from people who are not associated
with the operation of the drone.
• The drone should operate within an approved airspace. This will depend on
whether it is in a public zone or not, and the type of zone allowances or
restrictions are applied on that location.
The rules stated above are general rules applied to the operation of an aircraft.
CASA provides changes to the above regulations, but they are under certain cir-
cumstances. In addition, façade inspection relates to recording information in a
public environment, and hence, laws that governs privacy and visual recordings
come into effect. In Australia, the predominate law that regulates visual recording
for drones is the Privacy Act 1988 [13]; [16]. The act indicates the rights of
individuals to protect their information through privacy. Therefore, businesses
using drones should comply with the appropriate regulations of the 1988 Privacy
Act, since drones would record individuals.
(a) Abian tower (b) Capri hotel (c) Rio Tinto office
By holding approvals for the above forms and certificates, droned based façade
inspection can be carried out.
Fig. 2 Zoning information for flying drones around the Brisbane CBD [3]
2016. The business stakeholders and inspection process may be affected by these
laws.
For the stakeholders of façade inspections, introducing drone inspections will
evoke change. Based on the preliminary investigation it was recommended to
consider the stakeholders’ perspectives in the implementation of the technology. In
addition, the facade inspection personal will have to undertake training prior to
operate the drone. It would be of recommendation to what key elements they desire
from the upgrade. At the same time, it would be worth developing actual per-
spectives within the business on the change.
When conducting this change, like mentioned previously, planning should be
conducted for the business to incorporate the technology. The planning recom-
mended was a strategic planning that would incorporate the new technology with
Barriers in Implementing the Convolutional Neural Network Damage Detector 1339
4 Conclusions
The aim of this paper was to identify and provide insight into the barriers associated
with the implementation of drone-based façade inspections. Based on background
reading, it was identified that strategic planning and stakeholder perspectives were
key concerns in regards to the implementation of information technology in façade
inspection. Following the findings, an investigation was made into the disparities
between rope access and drone-based inspection by considering the relevant laws.
The Privacy Act 1988, Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 and Civil Aviation
1340 M. Bowman et al.
Legislation Amendment Regulation 2016 are key pieces of legislation that influence
the drone-based inspection. Therefore, it is concluded based on these laws that a
company should conduct a strategic plan to train its staff personnel with the nec-
essary skills that comply with these regulations.
References
1. Anonymous (2001) Facade failures spur cities to act, In, vol. 48, p. 14. Trade Press Publishing
Company, Milwaukee
2. Choi S, Kim E (2015) Building crack inspection using small UAV. In: Proceedings of the
17th international conference on advanced communication technology (ICACT)
3. Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) (2018) Can I Fly There?. https://casa.dronecomplier.
com/external
4. Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) (2018) Commercial unmanned flight - remotely
piloted aircraft under 2 kg. https://www.casa.gov.au/standard-page/commercial-unmanned-
flight-remotely-piloted-aircraft-under-2kg
5. Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) (2018) Get permission to fly. https://www.casa.gov.
au/standard-page/get-permission-fly
6. Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) (2018) Get your remote pilot licence. https://www.
casa.gov.au/standard-page/get-your-remote-pilot-licence
7. Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) (2018) Get your RPA operator’s certificate,
Retrieved from Get your RPA operator’s certificate
8. Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) (2018) Information about submitting NOTAMs.
https://www.casa.gov.au/
9. Dwivedi YK, Wastell D, Laumer S, Henriksen HZ, Myers MD, Bunker D, Srivastava SC
(2015) Research on information systems failures and successes: status update and future
directions. J Res Innov 17(1):143–157. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10796-014-9500-y
10. Ericsson S (2014) Barriers of developing and implementing IT-innovation in healthcare: A
process study of challenges in eHealth development, MSc dissertation, Umeå University,
Sweden
11. Love PED, Irani Z (2004) An exploratory study of information technology evaluation and
benefits management practices of SMEs in the construction industry. Inf Manag 42(1):227–
242. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.im.2003.12.011
12. McCurley L (2016) Professional rope access: a guide to working safely at height, pp 245–256.
https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119085416.ch14
13. Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) (2018), Privacy Act. https://www.
oaic.gov.au/privacy-law/privacy-act/
14. Peng KC, Feng L, Hsieh YC, Yang TH, Hsiung SH, Tsai YD, Kuo C (2017) Unmanned
Aerial Vehicle for infrastructure inspection with image processing for quantification of
measurement and formation of facade map, IEEE, pp 1969–1972
15. Queensland Government (2018) Queensland Globe. https://qldglobe.information.qld.gov.au/
16. Volovelsky U (2014) Civilian uses of unmanned aerial vehicles and the threat to the right to
privacy – an Israeli case study. Comput Law Secur Rep BI-Monthly Rep Comput Secur Law
Govern Inf Technol Comput Use 30(3):306–320. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clsr.2014.03.008
17. Vossoughi H, Siddiqui R (2004) Industrial rope access - an alternate means for inspection,
maintenance, and repair of building facades and structures, building facade maintenance,
repair, and inspection, pp 116–118
Development of New Oil Damper
with Stiffness for Architectural
Vibration Control and Experimental
Research on Structural Characterization
Abstract This paper shows test and analyses results of a new oil damper, “The Oil
Damper with Stiffness”. It was developed to solve some issues around seismic
retrofit. There are difficulties in reinforcing buildings which were designed before
1981 in accordance with The Old Buildings Standards Act and many buildings have
low stiffness. Therefore, it has become common to retrofit old buildings using
braces and oil dampers, but this requires many areas to be reinforced. It causes
some problems relating to construction period, cost, and convenience of access.
This paper confirms that the test specimens have sufficient capabilities regarding
stiffness, constant slip force, durability, etc. in test results and advantages of this
damper in analyses using the factory model and the high-rise building model.
Keywords Oil damper Viscoelastic material Seismic retrofit High-Rise
building Long-Period earthquake
1 Introduction
Japan is a country where earthquakes hit many times, and The Building Standards
Act has been revised because of damage from earthquakes. There are many
buildings designed according to The Old Building Standards Act before 1981. It is
now common to retrofit these buildings using braces and oil dampers. However,
this requires many areas to be reinforced. It causes some problems such as
increasing the construction period, cost, and inconvenience due to blocking access
to frames. The new oil damper has been developed in order to solve these problems.
Oil Damper
Spring Unit
This paper shows tests and analyses results of the new oil damper. The new oil
damper is referred to BOD (Banetsuki Oil Damper) in this paper.
Some tests were carried out to confirm the performance of the spring unit. Figure 2
shows the relationships between displacement and force in Sine Wave Tests. As
shown by Fig. 2, these specimens have stiffness and slip force nearly in accordance
with design values regardless of the frequency and amplitude of sine waves.
Figure 3 shows results of Sine Wave Test before and after Endurance Test of
viscoelastic material. Endurance Test uses 100-Cycle Sine Wave with a frequency
of 1 Hz. Figure 4 shows the 50 and 99 cycle loops of Endurance Test of Slip
Mechanism. Figure 5 shows the results of Random Wave Test. This test uses the
wave made by earthquake recorded in Kobe 1995. Based on these results from
Figs. 3, 4 and 5, it could be confirmed that these specimens have sufficient dura-
bility and stability. (Red dashed lines in Figs. 2, 4, and Fig. 5 show slip force of
design value).
Development of New Oil Damper with Stiffness … 1343
St iffness [kN/mm] 25 50
2 Layers 4 Layers
Fig. 3 Results of Sine Wave Tests (Regarding Endurance Test (viscoelastic material))
0 0 0
Not Reinforced
Knee Blace
Oil Damper
BOD
Analyses were conducted using the factory building analysis model with BOD
installed as a knee-brace. Two kinds of analyses were conducted: static load analysis
using wind load in a large typhoon and time history response analysis. Figure 8
shows the factory analysis model. Table 3 shows analysis cases. There are five
analyses cases: no reinforcement, knee brace, oil damper, oil damper and knee brace,
and BOD. Tables 4, 5, 6 show the characteristics of the knee brace, spring unit, and
oil damper. Time history response analysis is calculated with settings of 2.0 damping
ratio by initial stiffness proportion and New-markb (b = 0.25). These analyses were
calculated by the software, SNAP Ver.7. Table 7 shows the displacement values of
each case’s reaction. As a result, cases 2, 4, and 5 reduce displacement reaction
against wind load. Table 8 shows characteristics of earthquake waves, Table 9
shows maximum story deformation angles and Table 10 shows maximum absolute
response acceleration in time history response analysis. Each result confirmed cases
2 to 4 reduce these values respectively. Furthermore, Fig. 9 describes the relation-
ships between force and displacement of oil dampers at X1 in each analysis model. It
could be confirmed that case 5 has the smallest amount of energy absorption. This is
the result of the difference of each model’s proper frequency, the frequency of
dependency of the oil damper, and the fact that BOD’s deformation is less than that
of oil damper only because of the stiffness of BOD.
Development of New Oil Damper with Stiffness … 1347
Max. Abs. Res. Acc. [cm/s 2] Max. St ory Shearing F orce [kN] Max. St ory Defomat ion Angle [rad]
Lv.1 Lv.2 Lv.1 Lv.2 Lv.1 Lv.2
ELCE_NO 254 507 41363 82726 1/377 1/188
ELCE_OD 254 507 42108 84216 1/507 1/253
ELCE_BO 254 507 81088 159857 1/490 1/238
TAF T_NO 248 496 42594 85187 1/490 1/245
TAF T_OD 248 496 42520 85040 1/572 1/286
TAF T_BO 249 498 71691 143343 1/518 1/264
HACH_NO 179 358 35888 71777 1/51 1/26
HACH_OD 179 358 35194 70385 1/120 1/60
HACH_BO 185 371 56572 115321 1/273 1/88
Max. Abs. Res. Acc. [cm/s 2] Max. St ory Shearing F orce [kN] Max. St ory Defomat ion Angle [rad]
Lv.2 Lv.3 Lv.2 Lv.3 Lv.2 Lv.3
KOBE_NO 495 821 92256 152995 1/362 1/218
KOBE_OD 495 821 92947 154079 1/380 1/228
KOBE_BO 505 844 158055 260365 1/289 1/171
HAGA_NO 178 277 23914 37250 1/218 1/140
HAGA_OD 178 277 24092 37515 1/304 1/195
HAGA_BO 187 292 46825 72678 1/914 1/360
Three cases of analyses (no reinforcement (NO), using oil damper (OD), BOD
(BO)) were carried out in time history response analysis. The design criteria of story
deformation angle in every case are 1/200 in Lv.1 earthquake and 1/75 in Lv.2 and
3 earthquake. Table 14 and Table 15 show results of maximum absolute response
acceleration, maximum story sheer force, and maximum story deformation angle. It
could be confirmed that cases of NO and OD do not satisfy design criteria in The
Tokachi-Oki Earthquake which has a huge spectrum in Long-Period. However, the
case of BOD satisfies design criteria in all cases and has nearly the same reaction in
maximum absolute response acceleration as the case of NO (Table 13).
Development of New Oil Damper with Stiffness … 1351
7 Conclusions
In conclusion, test results show the BOD has nearly the same performance as the
design values and analysis results show the following merits of BOD.
(1) BOD reduces reactions of factory model against wind load.
(2) BOD is effective on high-rise building against Long-Period Earthquake.
References
1. Yokoyama A, Takahashi O (2016) Development of new oil damper for architectual vibration
control and experimental research on structural characterization. In: 6th Asia conference on
earthquake engineering, no 1, p 47
2. Takahashi O, Tsuyuki Y, Ikahata N, Matsuzaki Y, Fujita T (2005) A research on damping
performances analysis model of brace-type oil damper. J Struct Constr Eng, AIJ, no 594,
pp 57–64
Assessing the Viability of Visual
Vibrometry for Use in Structural
Engineering
1 Introduction
Modal analysis has been widely used for many decades within various fields of
engineering, to detect the natural frequencies of objects and structures (Fu and He
[6]. In the field of structural engineering, modal analysis has proven to be effective
for ascertaining the dynamic properties of a huge range of engineered structures and
is a key technique for applications in structural dynamics, structural health moni-
toring, and quality control for manufactured building products [3].
Modal testing is typically undertaken using an impact hammer or shaker for
excitation of the test specimen, with structural response then measured using
contact or non-contact based methods [6]. Contact-based methods typically involve
attaching accelerometers directly to the structure. Collected data is highly precise,
but set-up can be time and labour intensive, so it is impractical for many appli-
cations outside of geometrically simple specimens in laboratory environments [2].
Non-contact methods were developed to reduce these limitations and commonly
involve the use of Laser Doppler Vibrometers for remote measurement of structural
displacement [5]. Laser vibrometers can typically only measure a single location on
a given surface and have a relatively high price point, again limiting their use for
continuous displacement field measurement or measurement of structures in situ.
Camera-based computer vision technologies have recently seen much interest as
a non-contact method that can aid or replace conventional modal analysis methods.
Computer vision processing of video from a basic camera has been shown to allow
for quasi-real time bolt tightness monitoring, overcoming many of the shortcomings
associated with conventional human inspection-based structural health monitoring
techniques [1]. A methodology referred to as visual vibrometry has been found
capable of extracting the frequencies of vibration modes and subsequently deducing
material properties of a vibrating object, using both high speed and regular video
cameras [5]. Visual vibrometry approaches are highly appealing as they avoid many
of the impracticalities associated with laser vibrometry and it are likely to be
significantly cheaper than a scanning or multi-beam laser vibrometer, even with use
of a high-speed camera. Video cameras are also easier to operate and likely to be
more adaptable and compatible with varying test circumstances. These benefits give
visual vibrometry great potential for improving the efficiency of structural health
monitoring and quality control.
This paper describes an initial benchmarking of the effectiveness of the visual
vibrometry technique in structural modal analysis. Testing is first conducted on a
simply supported beam, using both visual vibrometry and classical contact-based
methods, verified by analytical and numerical methods. A complex semi-rigid
frame structure is then also tested, again with both measurement methods and with
results verified against a calibrated numerical model.
Assessing the Viability of Visual Vibrometry ... 1355
2.1 Specimen
The tested beam was a non-structural grade timber stud, with cross sectional
dimension of 90 mm by 45 mm and a length of 2400 mm, as shown in Fig. 1. It
had a mass of 2.26 kg/m and was oriented about its weak axis for all tests con-
ducted. Timber is not naturally a homogeneous material; thus, the Young’s mod-
ulus of any given stud varies with length, however for the purposes of this
comparative study, overall average Young’s modulus was considered. The tested
stud had an average Young’s modulus of 4757.4 MPa, provided by the manufac-
turer Hyne Timber from their in-house mechanical grading process.
Visual vibrometry modal testing was conducted by exciting the beam at mid-span
using a hammer, with the subsequent vibrations recorded by standard smartphone at
30 Hz and 120 Hz. To minimise noise, the camera was mounted firmly at a distance
and the footage was taken outside in bright natural light and with a still background.
This minimised potential flickering from artificial light.
Fig. 1 Tested specimens: simply-supported beam (left) and semi-rigid timber frame (right)
1356 V. Slinger et al.
Fig. 2 Measured beam frequents. On left, normalized movement with visual vibrometry
frequency sampling at 120 Hz. On right, contact-based test 1, Accelerometer 1, acceleration
with frequency
The modal test was conducted using impact hammer excitation and contact-based
accelerometer response measurement. The beam was positioned to vibrate about its
minor axis, with an effective length of 2360 mm caused by 20 mm overhang at
each support. Seven accelerometers were positioned symmetrically about mid-span,
at 1/6, 1/4, 1/3 and 1/2 span length as measured from beam ends. These positions
were selected such that the first three natural frequency modes and their corre-
sponding mode shapes could be detected. The beam was excited via single impulse
at the mid span and data acquisition collected at a sampling rate of 2000 Hz. This
was repeated a total of 13 times, with separate data sets collected each time for
post-processing.
2.2.3 Results
The data obtained from the visual vibrometry (VV) test was post-processed in
MATLAB based on modified code from Davis et al. [4] and transformed to the
frequency domain by Fast Fourier Transformation (FFT). At 30 Hz, no discernible
trends were evident in the frequency domain data, however at 120 Hz a peak in the
normalised movement data is evident at 10.14 Hz. This can be observed in Fig. 2.
From the contact-based (CB) test, analysis was performed on data from
accelerometer 1 (at 1/6 span length) as it was able to detect vibration from all of the
Assessing the Viability of Visual Vibrometry ... 1357
first three natural vibration modes. The data from accelerometer 1 was transformed
to the frequency domain using MATLAB’s in-built FFT function. In order to
improve the accuracy of frequency estimates and avoid inferences based on single
data sets, the frequency values determined from the 13 separate tests were examined
and averaged together. Results are shown in Fig. 2. The first three natural fre-
quencies of the beam are easily discernible as 10.629 Hz, 39.325 Hz and
93.710 Hz, with VV and CB results summarised in Table 1.
p rffiffiffiffiffi
D0
fn ¼ n 2
ð1Þ
2L 2 m0
Given that n represents the vibration mode, the frequency of the 2nd mode is 4
times that of the 1st mode, the frequency of the 3rd mode is 9 times that of the 1st
mode, et cetera. For a rectangular cross section:
bd 3
D0 ¼ E ð2Þ
12
Using the beam properties described in Sect. 2.1, a numerical model of the beam
was developed in structural analysis software SPACEGASS to provide a numerical
prediction for the frequencies of the first three vibration modes, also summarised in
Table 1.
2.4 Discussion
The first natural frequency observed in the vibrometry test correlates well with the
experimental contact-based modal analysis prediction as well as the analytical and
numerical solutions, implying that the technique employed has effectively detected
this natural frequency. Variation between the specific natural frequency values
predicted could be attributed to a variety of errors, including inaccuracies in data
collection and imperfect simply supported test conditions.
Since the Nyquist frequency of the 30 Hz test is 15 Hz, theoretically the first
mode should have been detected in this vibrometry test, however it was not.
Equally, the Nyquist frequency of the 120 Hz test is 60 Hz, implying that it should
have also detected the 2nd mode but it did not. This could be attributed to the
vibrometry methodology utilizing displacement data. Transforming this into the
frequency domain generates a frequency receptance response, which is known to
exaggerate low frequency responses and suppress intermediate or high frequency
responses.
Even just with detection of the first mode, the visual vibrometry technique is
sufficiently accurate for prediction of the specimen material properties. Substituting
Eq. 2 into Eq. 1 and re-arranging for E gives a predicted Young’s modulus a value
of 4639.6 MPa, which is within a few percent of the actual average specimen value
of 4757.5 MPa.
3.1 Specimen
The test structure, shown in Fig. 1, is a complex semi-rigid arch frame composed of
MGP10 timber elements held together via tension straps. The x and y dimensions
were defined for in plane horizontal and vertical movement, and the z direction was
defined for out of plane movement.
The visual vibrometry test was conducted by exciting the frame in the x direction,
with the subsequent vibrations recorded by standard smartphone at 30 Hz and
120 Hz. Video was captured from a front and side view. Data collection and
processing was otherwise as described for the simply-supported beam. As was the
case with the simply supported beam visual vibrometry test, no discernible trends
were evident in the frequency domain data transformed from the 30 Hz video,
however at 120 Hz peaks within normalised movement data are evident. This can
be seen in Fig. 3.
The modal analysis was conducted using an impact hammer for excitation and
contact accelerometers for response measurement. The frame was free to move in
any direction and thus a total of 6 accelerometers were used, 3 for each of the x and
y spatial dimensions. Data was logged and processed using a Dewesoft SIRIUS HD
ACC DAQ (data acquisition) system and the Dewesoft X3 DAQ software package.
Fig. 3 (a) Front and (b) side view normalized movement with frequency sampling at 120 Hz
1360 V. Slinger et al.
Two tests were conducted, once with the frame excited in the x direction and once
excited in the y direction. For each contact-based test conducted, 5 separate hammer
strikes were performed, and these results were averaged within the Dewesoft X3
software. The results are shown in Fig. 4, displayed as mode indicator function
values to more clearly highlight frequency spikes.
Given that the structure is complex, it is significantly more difficult to validate the
obtained experimental modal frequencies. There are no analytical solutions avail-
able for this structure, so instead a numerical model of the frame was constructed in
structural analysis software SPACEGASS. Members were designated as MGP10
from the SPACEGASS AustTimb library, which assigns them a Young’s modulus
value of 10000 MPa. Connections between frame members were simulated as
semi-rigid by inserting very short intermediate members of significantly reduced
cross-section. By adjusting the dimensions of these intermediate members, the
stiffness of the joints in the frame model can be adjusted.
Assessing the Viability of Visual Vibrometry ... 1361
Calibrating the numerical model requires calibrating the rotational stiffness of the
frame joints until the first numerical modal frequencies align with experimental
results. Since the frame was free to move in all directions, in plane and out of plane
(transverse) vibration modes influenced the experimental results obtained. The
stiffness of joints was iteratively calibrated by restraining the frame model such that
the in plane and out of plane modal frequencies could be isolated. These were then
matched as closely as possible with the experimental results obtained from the
vibrometry test.
The first two clear data peaks come from the front view test (Fig. 3a) which are
at frequencies of approximately 2 and 2.8 Hz. This closely aligns with the first out
of plane and in plane modal frequencies predicted by the SPACEGASS model for
intermediate member sizes of 20 by 30 mm and 17 by 20 mm, respectively. The
validity of these initial frequencies is supported by the modal analysis results, which
also shows MIF peaks at approximately 2 and 2.8 Hz.
3.4 Discussion
Tables 2 and 3 summarise the numerical and experimental frequency findings for
both in plane (XY) and out of plane (Z) vibration modes. As was observed from the
results of the simply supported beam vibrometry test, the receptance frequency
response highlighted low frequencies but did not detect any frequencies higher than
about 20 Hz, with the highest frequency peak detected being 17.87 Hz.
After adjusting the numerical model to fit the first two modal frequencies, the
subsequent modal frequencies below the 20 Hz limit could be correlated with the
vibrometry results and these with the modal analysis results. Some of these cor-
relations were not as clear as the correlation between the first two frequencies across
the test types and varied by up to 1 Hz in some instances. Despite this, an overall
correlation between the numerical results and vibrometry results exists and this
reinforces the method’s validity for structural characterisation.
4 Conclusion
The results of the study suggest that visual vibrometry can be used to detect the
natural frequencies of structures both simple and complex in nature. When com-
bined with numerical or analytical models, this could be an effective means of
obtaining properties of numerous types of structure, from simple to very complex.
Given the quick set-up, low-cost equipment, and fast post-processing time,
visual vibrometry can be concluded to be significantly easier to implement than
contact based modal testing. The viability of this technology suggests that it could
hold great potential for use in improving the efficiency of a variety of industries
such as structural verification and health monitoring, and could also create new
opportunities in digital building certification.
The results suggest that there are practical limitations associated with receptance
frequency response functions, which are an integral component of visual vibrom-
etry. Since the low frequency region of a sample is highlighted when transformed,
Assessing the Viability of Visual Vibrometry ... 1363
structures with very high modal frequencies would likely require high speed
cameras in order to effectively detect them. Further research should be conducted to
ascertain the limitations of high-speed cameras used for visual vibrometry of
building structures.
References
1. Cha YJ, You K, Choi W (2016) Vision-based detection of loosened bolts using the Hough
transform and support vector machines. Automat Constr 71:181–188
2. Chen JG, Wadhwa N, Cha YJ, Durand F, Freeman WT, Buyukozturk O (2015) Modal
identification of simple structures with high-speed video using motion magnification. J Sound
Vib 345:58–71
3. Choi FC, Li J, Samali B, Crews K (2007) An experimental study on damage detection of
structures using a timber beam. J Mech Sci Technol 21(6):903–907
4. Davis A, Rubinstein M, Wadhwa N, Mysore GJ, Durand F, Freeman WT (2014) The visual
microphone: passive recovery of sound from video
5. Davis A, Bouman KL, Chen JG, Rubinstein M, Durand F, Freeman WT (2015) Visual
vibrometry: estimating material properties from small motion in video. In Proceedings of the
IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, pp. 5335–5343
6. Fu ZF, He J (2001) Modal analysis. Elsevier
7. Nilsson A, Liu B (2015) Vibro-acoustics, vol. 2. Springer
Steel Structures
Study on an Innovative H-Beam
to SHS-Column Joint with Cast
Column-Link in Steel Frames
Keywords Beam-to-Column joint Closed-section column Steel casting Steel
frame structure Industrialized building
D. Ye (&) Y. Chen
Department of Structural Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai, China
e-mail: ydc1111@tongji.edu.cn
Y. Chen
e-mail: yiyichen@tongji.edu.cn
Y. Chen
State Key Laboratory of Disaster Reduction in Civil Engineering, Tongji University,
Shanghai, China
G. Zhao Q. Shi
BMEI Co., Ltd., Beijing, China
e-mail: zhaogang@bmei.com
Q. Shi
e-mail: shiqingjun@bmei.com
1 Introduction
Panel zone
Bolts
H-beam
SHS column
Study on an Innovative H-Beam to SHS-Column Joint … 1369
The joint is developed in order to realize a more effective construction mode for
H-beam and closed-section column. To accomplish this objective, several features
are included:
(1) The column-link is shop welded to the panel zone and column while the
beam-link is bolted to the column-link and beam in situ. A transition is needed
if the column section is circular or elliptical as Fig. 2. However this is still
under development thus it will not be discussed in this paper.
(2) The column-link is manufactured by casting because of the complex configu-
ration, Fig. 3. Inner-stiffeners are cast for improving the bearing capacity and
stiffness of the joint as well as diminishing the welding deformation. Besides
the welding backing is added to ensure the welding quality. Loose pieces are
applied during the casting process so that backing with different curvatures of
the corner could be manufactured in order to satisfy several different thick-
nesses of SHS column of the same depth. More importantly, threads are drilled
through the wall of column-link and boss, which makes bolts could be tight-
ened from one side.
(3) As illustrated in Fig. 4, the beam-link is similar to Kaiser bolted bracket [1] but
it is regarded to be evolved from the end-plate in bolted connection. One
end-plate is separated into two beam-links and with the combination of over-
sized bolt-holes, it could achieve a higher construction tolerance and a more
flexible assembly. Moreover, it is tapered in order to shorten the load path.
(4) The panel zone uses the existing profile steel and its height depends on the
depth of the beam.
(5) Although the beam-link and column-link are designed into a series of standard
specifications (some examples given in Fig. 5), their bolt-hole position is
expected to be compatible so that different modules could match each other.
1370 D. Ye et al.
Welding backing
Inner-stiffeners
Boss
End-plate Beam-link
Hole for casting
Col umn-link
Loadi ng path
H-shaped beam H-shaped beam
( a) ( b)
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
fy;r h 2 i
t D D2 D ðD tr Þ2 ð1Þ
fy;c
Where D is outer width of the square hollow section. fy,r, fy,c and tr, t are the
yield strength and section thickness of column and column-link respectively. The
curvature of the SHS corners is neglected.
Table 1 indicates that tmin/tr approximately equals fy,r/fy,c thus Eq. (1) is sim-
plified to:
fy;r
t tr ð2Þ
fy;c
The length of the thread engagement could be easily obtained by Eq. (3) [4]. The
shear area of the thread is regarded to be parallel to the screw axis.
Pl cosða qÞ
Leng ¼ p p ð3Þ
pd 2 þ ðd d2 Þ tan a cos a cos q
The geometric parameters are given in Fig. 6, where d, d2, p and a represents
bolt major diameter, bolt mean diameter, pitch and half-thread angle respectively.
The friction factor q in the screw takes 0.15 and the pledge load Pl of nuts are given
in a Chinese specification [3].
1372 D. Ye et al.
d
d2
p
shear surface
thread
Fig. 6 Details of thread
Fig. 7 Deformation of a
plate with the boss
F
Nut
Plate
Screw
d
Lf
df
df d
f¼ 100% ð4Þ
d
200
Force(kN)
150
100
thread details
50 thread contact
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Displacement(mm)
across the edge of plate thickness for sections in bending. The reference point is
coupling to the nut.
Two modeling methods are applied when creating the contact between bolt and
plate as Fig. 8 (a)–(b). One is to use the surface-to-surface contact which is
determined by parameters including half-thread angle, pitch, and bolt diameter. The
other one is to model every detail of the screw. The load-displacement curves of the
reference point in Fig. 9 indicates that there are little differences between these two
methods. For the sake of simplicity, the first modeling method is adopted. Adding
the thermal expansion coefficient to the bolt material and changing the temperature
field, the bolt preload is set due to the initial axial strain along the screw. This
method produces a little fluctuation of the bolt preload for different plate thickness.
1374 D. Ye et al.
l l l
l/2 l/2 l/3 2l/3 l/2 l/2
Boundary
condition and bolt
l/2
l/2
2l/3
position
l
l
l
l/2
l/2
fixed edge
l/3
sliding edge
S1 S2 S3
10
8 S1,M16,ζ=5% S1,M22,ζ=5% S1,M24,ζ=5% S1,M30,ζ=5%
6
Lf(mm)
4
2
0
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
F(kN) F(kN) F(kN) F(kN)
10
8 S2,M16,ζ=1% S2,M22,ζ=1% S2,M24,ζ=1% S2,M30,ζ=1%
6
Lf(mm)
4
2
0
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
F(kN) F(kN) F(kN) F(kN)
t=6mm t=8mm t=10mm t=12mm t=16mm
Forty-five Abaqus models of the square plate with 4 bolt specifications, 5 plate
thickness, 2 bolt positions, and 2 boundary condition were established as Table 2.
The relationship between the failure length Lf and tensile load F are discussed
respectively under f of 1%, 2%, 3%, 4%, and 5%. The obtained results are similar
thus only part of them are plotted in Fig. 10 for the reason of space. It is obvious
that Lf keeps zero at first and then increases rapidly. The turning point of each Lf –
F curve is defined as the failure load, Ff.
Study on an Innovative H-Beam to SHS-Column Joint … 1375
2.5
S1,ζ=1% S1,ζ=2% S1,ζ=3% S1,ζ=4% S1,ζ=5%
2.0
Ff/Fy
1.5
1.0
0.5
0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8
P/Fy P/Fy P/Fy P/Fy P/Fy
2.5
S2,ζ=1% S2,ζ=2% S2,ζ=3% S2,ζ=4% S2,ζ=5%
2.0
Ff/Fy
1.5
1.0
0.5
0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8
P/Fy P/Fy P/Fy P/Fy P/Fy
2.5
S3,ζ=1% S3,ζ=2% S3,ζ=3% S3,ζ=4% S3,ζ=5%
2.0
Ff/Fy
1.5
1.0
0.5
0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8
P/Fy P/Fy P/Fy P/Fy P/Fy
It has been found from Fig. 11 that despite different plate thickness and bolt
specification, the ratio of failure load to plate yield load grows linearly with the ratio
of bolt preload to plate yield load. Here the yield load is calculated on the basis of
yield line theory [6]. To describe this relationship, two coefficients k and b are
introduced as Eq. (5).
Ff P
¼k þb ð5Þ
Fy Fy
Multiplying both sides by Fy, we obtain Eq. (6). This equation reveals that the
failure load is ruled by bolt preload P and plate yield load Fy.
Ff ¼ kP þ bFy ð6Þ
k and b are obtained by linear fitting and their value are plotted in Fig. 12.
Generally, we found that k grows as f increases while b keeps unchanged. The
value for k of S1 and S2 is similar but obviously different from that of S3 thus it is
concluded that k may be influenced by the plate boundary condition. The value for
b of S1, S2, and S3 are close with the average value of 0.68 which is coincidentally
consistent with the ratio of elastic to plastic section modulus of rectangle section.
1376 D. Ye et al.
0.31 0.95
0.28
0.8
0.25
0.22 0.65
b
k
0.19 0.5
k-S1 b-S1
0.16
k-S2 0.35 b-S2
0.13
k-S3 b-S3
0.1 0.2
0.00%1.00%2.00%3.00%4.00%5.00%6.00% 0.00%1.00%2.00%3.00%4.00%5.00%6.00%
ζ ζ
As a result, bFy is assumed to be the bearing capacity of the plate at elastic limit
stage with the further support illustrated by load-displacement curves of the
Reference point in Fig. 13. In addition, one special situation that the failure load Ff
is equal to bFy when the bolt preload is zero could be explained that after the plate
yields, the plate deformation will increase rapidly which make the thread lose its
function. Thus this assumption seems plausible.
Two facts need to be considered that the bolt preload may difficult to satisfy the
construction requirement in practical, and bFy takes the major part of the Ff.
Therefore for sake of safety and simplicity, it is recommended to neglect the
contribution of the bolt preload to failure load as Eq. (7). Another assumption is
made that the failure length Lf equals the plate thickness when the plate fully yields.
Study on an Innovative H-Beam to SHS-Column Joint … 1377
10
8 S1,M16,ζ=1% S1,M22,ζ=1% S1,M24,ζ=1% S1,M30,ζ=1%
6
Lf(kN)
4
2
0
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
F(mm) F(mm) F(mm) F(mm)
t=6mm t=8mm t=10mm t=12mm t=16mm —— Abaqus results
t=6mm t=8mm t=10mm t=12mm t=16mm —— Design method
Fig. 14 Comparison of the Lf-F curve obtained by Abaqus and Recommended method
Therefore, the relationship between tensile force F and Lf could be finally deter-
mined. Part of the results are shown in Fig. 14.
Ff ¼ bFy ð7Þ
4 Conclusion
References
1. American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC). (2016). Prequalified connections for special
and intermediate steel moment frames for seismic applications. ANSI/AISC 358-05, AISC,
Chicago
2. Cao X, Li X, Zhu Y, Zhang Z (2015) A comparative study of environmental performance
between prefabricated and traditional residential buildings in China. J Clean Prod 109:131–143
3. GB/T 1231-2006 (2006): Specifications of high strength bolts with large hexagon head, large
hexagon nuts, plain washers for steel structures, China Standards Press, Beijing, China
4. Jiujing Z, Chai Z (2016) Connection engineering of thread fastener. China Machine Press,
Beijing
5. Wang W, Li M, Chen Y, Jian X (2017) Cyclic behavior of endplate connections to tubular
columns with novel slip-critical blind bolts. Eng Struct 148:949–962
6. Ye D, Chen Y (2019) Plastic limit state analysis of bending perforated plates based on
segmentation method. Eng Mech 36(6):36–48
7. Zhang X, Skitmore M, Peng Y (2014) Exploring the challenges to industrialized residential
building in China. Habitat Int 41:176–184
Structural Behavior of Steel
Moment-Resisting Frames Subjected
to Multiple Earthquakes Considering
Column Strength Deterioration
1 Introduction
The occurrence of multiple strong shocks in a short period of time has been wit-
nessed in many earthquake events (e.g., the 2011 Tohoku earthquake and 2016
Kumamoto earthquake). Within this short period of time, any structural repairs
could hardly be done; thus, the structure should be able to sustain multiple strong
shocks at once. On the other hand, the current seismic design utilizes the inelastic
deformation capacity of the member to dissipate seismic energy. This design means
that theoretically, the structures will undergo some damage (i.e., permanent
deformation) if shaken by an earthquake with an intensity that is equal to or larger
than the design level intensity. Consequently, a structure having been shaken by a
strong shock might not have sufficient strength to resist subsequent strong shocks.
The structural behavior of nondeteriorated steel moment-resisting frames
(SMRFs) has been analyzed by Tenderan et al. [4]. Their analysis is focusing on the
cumulative damage of beam assuming that with the application of strong column –
weak beam principle, the column will be stronger than beam; thus, the energy is
mostly dissipated by the plastic hinges of the beams. However, in the current
seismic design practice, to achieve the sway mechanism, the forming of plastic
hinges in the 1st story column and top column is still allowed. Thus, there is a
possibility that the column will be deteriorated after plastification. Since columns
are bearing an increased amount of axial force during the seismic excitation, the
main possible cause of column strength deterioration is the occurrence of local
buckling. Therefore, in this study, the hysteric model of RHS column taking into
account the strength deterioration due to local buckling is applied to the SMRFs
model and the inelastic time history analysis considering multiple strong ground
motion excitations is conducted.
2 Analytical Model
The analytical model is an infinite uniform plane frame model, the same type of
model that is used by Tenderan et al. [4]. In this model, an infinite number of
uniform single-bay frames is assumed to exist throughout the plane; thus, the
response of every single-bay frame is uniform as well, and the analytical result of
the single-bay frame model can be used to represent the response of the whole
frame. The analytical frame has a typical height of 3.5 m, typical span of 7 m, and
typical weight per story per span of 400 kN; the column section and panel zone are
square hollow section (SHS) with BCR295 steel grade (nominal yield strength of
295 N/mm2 and nominal tensile strength of 400 N/mm2); the beam section is a
wide-flange section with SN400 steel grade (nominal yield strength of 235 N/mm2
and nominal tensile strength of 400 N/mm2); and the column base is an
exposed-type column base. The sizes of the columns, beams, and column bases are
designed according to the parameters of the model. The first parameter, the number
Structural Behavior of Steel Moment-Resisting Frames … 1381
of stories, consists of three variations, i.e., 3-, 6-, and 9-story. Considering that
variation, the models are designed with the typical section every three stories. In
addition, the second parameter, the column width-to-thickness (D/t) ratio, consists
of two variations, i.e., D/t = 29.45 and 20.
By combining those two parameters, a total of six different models are created.
These models are named according to the parameters, i.e., models 3_29, 6_29,
9_29, 3_20, 6_20, and 9_20. All six models are designed to comply with the
Japanese seismic design code. The column-to-beam moment capacity ratio
(cMp/bMp) is set to equal to or larger than 1.5 according to the code (The Building
Center of Japan [2]. Since the deterioration of the column is the main focus in the
analysis, the column base is designed to be stronger than the 1st story column to
prevent any slip or plastification of the column base; thus, the damage is concen-
trated on the column. The sizes of the column and beam members and cMp/bMp are
shown in Table 1.
In the time history response analysis, the average acceleration method is used for
the numerical integration with a time step of 1/2000s. In addition, the 2% Rayleigh
damping for the 1st and 2nd natural periods and the P-D effect are considered in this
analysis. The 1st and 2nd mode natural periods of all the models are also shown in
Table 1.
Table 1 Member sizes, column-to-beam moment capacity ratio, & natural periods
Story Model 3_29 (T1 = 0.925 s; T2 = 0.277 s) Model 3_20 (T1 = 0.957 s; T2 = 0.290 s)
Column Beam cMp/bMp Column Beam c M p /b M p
1–3 □ − 353 12 H − 493 211 812 1.53 * 1.58 □ − 312 16 H − 493 211 812 1.52–
1.56
Story Model 6_29 (T1 = 1.135 s; T2 = 0.369 s) Model 6_20 (T1 = 1.158 s; T2 = 0.380 s)
Column Beam cMp/bMp Column Beam c M p /b M p
4–6 □ − 425 14 H − 602 258 10 14 1.51 * 1.54 □ − 377 19 H − 602 258 10 14 1.51–
1.53
3 □ − 470 16 H − 602 258 10 14 1.76 □ − 415 21 H − 602 258 10 14 1.74
1–2 □ − 470 16 H − 653 280 10 16 1.52 * 1.56 □ − 415 21 H − 653 280 10 16 1.52–
1.55
Story Model 9_29 (T1 = 1.367 s; T2 = 0.491 s) Model 9_20 (T1 = 1.389 s; T2 = 0.501 s)
Column Beam cMp/bMp Column Beam c M p /b M p
7–9 □ − 436 15 H − 618 265 10 15 1.51 * 1.53 □ − 387 19 H − 618 265 10 15 1.51–
1.52
6 □ − 509 17 H − 618 265 10 15 1.94 □ − 450 23 H − 618 265 10 15 1.93
4–5 □ − 509 17 H − 713 306 11 17 1.52 * 1.54 □ − 450 23 H − 713 306 11 17 1.51–
1.53
3 □ − 538 18 H − 713 306 11 17 1.63 □ − 474 24 H − 713 306 11 17 1.62
1–2 □ − 538 18 H − 740 317 12 18 1.52 * 1.56 □ − 474 24 H − 740 317 12 18 1.52–
1.54
1382 R. Tenderan et al.
3 Hysteretic Model
For the beam members, the same hysteretic model as that used by Tenderan et al.
[4] is employed in the analytical model. The hysteretic model is based on the
decomposition of hysteretic loops into the skeleton part, the Bauschinger part, and
the elastic unloading part. The skeleton part corresponds to the load-deformation
relationship under the monotonic loading test, and in this analysis, the skeleton part
is idealized into a trilinear model considering material strain hardening (Fig. 1(a));
the Bauschinger part is modeled using the Kato-Akiyama model (Akiyama and
Takahashi [1]; and the elastic unloading part is the unloading part having stiffness
equal to the elastic stiffness.
The deteriorated hysteretic model proposed by Yamada et al. [5] is employed for
the column members. This model also adopts the concept of decomposition of
hysteretic loops. However, the model is divided into two ranges, named the non-
deteriorating range and deteriorating range as shown in Fig. 2. The nondeteriorating
range is the range before reaching the maximum strength; the hysteretic behavior in
this range is the same as that in the hysteretic model of the beam. Additionally, the
deteriorating range is the range after reaching the maximum strength. In this
deteriorating range, every progression of plastic deformation contributes to strength
deterioration. The skeleton curves of the 1st story column of every model are shown
in Fig. 1(b). cMp is the plastic moment of the column; chp is the elastic rotation
angle that corresponds to cMp.
(a) Trilinear model of beam skeleton curve (b) Column skeleton curve at the 1st story
Ten earthquake records are used as the input ground motion, i.e., (1) 1940 Imperial
Valley EQ El Centro NS record; (2) 1952 Kern Country EQ Taft EW record;
(3) 1968 Tokachi-oki EQ Hachinohe EW record; (4) 1989 Loma Prieta EQ Gilroy
Array#3 90o record; (5-6) 1994 Northridge EQ Newhall NS & Olive View NS
records; (7) 1995 Kobe EQ JMA Kobe NS record; (8) 1999 Chi-Chi EQ
TCU129 EW record; (9) 2011 Tohoku EQ JMA Sendai NS record; and (10) 2016
Kumamoto EQ Kik-net Mashiki EW record. To standardize the input energy, all the
input ground motions are scaled to peak ground velocity (PGV) = 0.5, 0.75, and
1.0 m/s. The intensity of PGV = 0.5 m/s is also known as the design level in Japan
since the time history analysis for building structural design is conducted with the
intensity of PGV = 0.5 m/s. To simulate the occurrence of multiple strong earth-
quakes, an earthquake sequence is created by repeating the same ground motion
with the same intensity for five excitations, and 30 s of zero acceleration is inserted
between two consecutive excitations to allow the structure to stop vibrating before
continuing to the next excitation. The repeated sequence type is chosen because it is
useful to simply evaluate the effect of column strength deterioration on the struc-
tural behavior of SMRFs. In addition, the limitation to a maximum of five exci-
tations is used to standardize the number of excitations performed during the
analysis, and five excitations are considered to be proper because the occurrence of
more than five strong excitations in a short period of time is a relatively rare case.
5 Analytical Result
model, input ground motion, and input intensity, the analytical result can be divided
into two typical cases, i.e., (i) column strength deterioration does not occur within
five excitations, and (ii) column strength deterioration occurs within five
excitations.
Figure 3 shows the example case of the case (i). It can be seen that the distri-
bution of dissipated energy is barely changed from 1st to 5th excitation. In the 1st
excitation, the skeleton part could be observed in the 1st story beam and 1st story
column lower end M–h curve. However, in the next 2nd to 5th excitation, the energy
is mostly dissipated by the Bauschinger part. There is no strength deterioration
occurred within five excitations, and the structure is able to maintain its stability and
sway mechanism. This behavior agrees with the stable behavior found by Tenderan
et al. [4] based on the analytical results of SMRFs under multiple strong ground
motions using a nondeteriorated hysteretic model.
Figure 4 shows the example of case (ii). In this case, both column strength
deterioration and story collapse occurred within five excitations. Story collapse is
defined to occur when the story shear (Q) becomes zero. As shown in the figure, at
the 1st excitation, no deterioration occurred at the 1st story column lower end hinge,
and the 1st story column upper end hinge remained elastic. However, at the 2nd
excitation, strength deterioration occurred at the 1st story column lower end, and the
plastic hinge was formed at the 1st story upper end. In addition, it can also be seen
that the distribution of dissipated energy changed gradually and resulted in the
concentration of damage to the 1st story column. This change indicated a shift from
the sway mechanism to the weak story mechanism. Finally, at the 5th excitation, the
1st story column lower end hinge completely lost its restoring force and became like
a pin joint, and this effect caused moment redistribution to the upper end of the 1st
Fig. 3 Analytical results of model 3_29 excited by PGV 0.5 m/s Olive View NS record
Structural Behavior of Steel Moment-Resisting Frames … 1385
story column. Hence, the 1st story column upper end hinge also deteriorated until
the 1st story completely lost its resistance, as indicated by the story shear of the 1st
story becoming less than zero at 5th excitation. This collapse mechanism is similar
to the one found during the shaking table test of 4-story SMRFs under exceedingly
large ground motions (Suita et al. [3].
The typical behavior found in the previous section indicates that the plastic hinge
condition of the 1st story column lower end can be a good damage index to rep-
resent the whole state of the structure. In case of the case (i), the stable behavior
could be achieved if the deterioration of the 1st story column lower end does not
occur. Meanwhile, in the case (ii), the amount of deterioration of the 1st story
column lower end corresponds to the remaining strength in the 1st story. Thus, to
simplify the display of the results, the 1st story column lower end hinge state is used
as the main damage index. The quantitative index of the 1st story column lower end
hinge state is represented by the nondeterioration margin (NM) and deterioration
index (DI), as explained in Fig. 5. NM indicates the margin to reach the maximum
Fig. 4 Analytical results of model 3_29 excited by PGV 0.5 m/s JMA Kobe NS record
1386 R. Tenderan et al.
moment (cMu) or to start deterioration, and DI indicates how much the strength has
been deteriorated.
Figures 6 shows the NM and DI damage index vs. the number of excitations.
However, some results are not shown because of space limitations. The mark in the
graphs shows the state of the 1st story column lower end hinge as no deterioration
(○), deteriorated (●), or complete loss of moment resistance (x). From the graphs,
it can be seen that the increment of NM tends to decrease when the number of
excitation increase, and once the structure reaches the stable behavior, the incre-
ment is nearly zero. However, when the structure starts deteriorating, the pro-
gression of damage (increment of DI) is in the rate that is mainly affected by the D/t
of the models. The lower the D/t, the slower the progression of damage.
In terms of the number of stories, it can be seen that the 3-story models suffer the
largest damage then followed by 6-story models and then 9-story models. The main
cause is the distribution of the dissipated energy of a low-rise building tends to be
concentrated in the lower story (e.g., 1st story). Meanwhile, for mid-rise building, it
tends to concentrate in the middle story. In this analysis, in all cases of the 3-story
model, more than 50% of the energy is dissipated by the 1st story at the 1st exci-
tation, while in most cases of 6- and 9-story model, the amount is less than 50%.
This trend also can be seen from the graphs in which the value of NM at the 1st
excitation of the 3-story models is generally larger than that of 6- and 9-story
models.
In terms of D/t, it can be seen that lowering D/t can greatly enhance the per-
formance of the structure. Because as shown in Fig. 1(b), lowering D/t is not only
increasing the maximum moment (decreasing NM at the 1st excitation) but also
slowing down the rate of deterioration (decreasing the increment rate of DI).
Regardless of the number of stories, input ground motion record, and input ground
motion intensity, for models with D/t = 29.45 (X_29 series models), the number of
deteriorations and collapses are 53 and 45 out of 90 cases, respectively. However,
for models with D/t = 20 (X_20 series models), the number of deteriorations and
collapses are only 26 and 9 out of 90 cases, respectively.
Fig. 5 Definitions of the nondeterioration margin (NM) and deterioration index (DI)
Structural Behavior of Steel Moment-Resisting Frames … 1387
Since the stable behavior is the more desirable behavior of SMRFs under
multiple earthquake excitations, the value of NM at the 1st excitation can be a good
index to predict whether the deterioration will occur within the five excitations. In
this analysis, it is found that if NM at the 1st excitation is less than approximately –
50% then the strength deterioration could be prevented (the case ended up in case
(i), the stable behavior). This finding indicates that a certain target value of NM due
to one excitation could be adopted in the design process to ensure the structure is
1388 R. Tenderan et al.
6 Conclusions
The seismic performance of SMRFs was evaluated in the present study by con-
sidering column strength deterioration due to local buckling under multiple strong
ground motion excitations. The summary of the findings from the analytical results
is listed below.
(1) The typical structural behavior can be grouped into two cases. In the case of no
deterioration, the structure shows a stable behavior and maintains the sway
mechanism. In case of 1st story column lower end deteriorated, the story shear
strength at the 1st story is decreased, which in subsequent excitations, it results
in the concentration of damage the 1st story column, deterioration at 1st story
column upper end, and finally weak story collapse at the 1st story.
(2) The damage progression in the nondeteriorating range (NM) tend to decrease by
the number of excitations and nearly equal to zero when the structure reaches a
stable behavior. Meanwhile, in the deterioration range, the damage progression
rate (DI) is greatly affected by the D/t of the 1st story column. The lower the D/
t, the slower the damage progression.
(3) In terms of the number of stories, the 3-story model is the most vulnerable to
excitation of multiple strong ground motions because of the tendency of con-
centration of dissipated energy to the 1st story. Meanwhile, in terms of column
D/t, lowering D/t can greatly improve the performance of the structure. By
comparing the analytical results of models with D/t = 29.45 and D/t = 20, the
number of deteriorated cases (53 cases vs. 26 cases) and story collapse cases
(45 cases vs. 9 cases) is greatly reduced.
(4) To ensure the structure could end up in the stable behavior, a certain target
value of NM due to one excitation could be adopted in the design process. In
the present analysis, it is found that in case NM at the 1st excitation is less than
approximately –50%, the structure can achieve stable behavior.
Acknowledgements This work is supported by the Japanese Society for the Promotion of
Science KAKENHI Grant Number JP17H01302 and JST Program on Open Innovation Platform
with Enterprises, Research Institute and Academia. Their financial support is gratefully
acknowledged.
Structural Behavior of Steel Moment-Resisting Frames … 1389
References
Abstract This study investigates the effect of small amplitude loading histories to
strength deterioration behaviors of square hollow section (SHS) steel columns due
to local buckling. Cyclic loading tests of cold-formed SHS columns are conducted
and test parameters are the loading history, the width-to-thickness ratio and the
compressive axial load ratio. Several constant small deformation amplitude cyclic
loading histories, and the large deformation loading history such as the monotonic
loading which is commonly used in previous studies, are employed. The effect of
the loading amplitude is observed in the strength deterioration range caused by local
buckling i.e. the strength deterioration under small amplitude loading histories is
smaller than that under the large amplitude loading history. This reason is that the
progress of the axial shortening of the flange plate due to local buckling of each
cycle is reduced because the effect of a tensile force induced due to bending become
significant as the loading amplitude decrease.
Keywords Square hollow section steel column Small deformation amplitude
Cyclic loading test Local buckling Deterioration behavior
1 Introduction
2 Test Plan
Test specimens were cold-formed SHS columns (BCR295 steel grade, nominal
yield strength is 295 N/mm2 and nominal tensile strength is 400 N/mm2) □-
200 200 9 and □-200 200 6. Results of the tensile coupon test of the flat
part of SHS column using JIS-1A testing sample are shown in Table 1.
The test setup is shown in Fig. 1. The upper end of the specimen was pin
supported and the lower end is fixed support to the loading table. The specimen was
subjected to a lateral force by the horizontal jack. Constant compressive axial force
was applied by three vertical jacks through the upper reaction frame and the vertical
jacks were controlled so that the reaction frame keep horizontal. The horizontal jack
was controlled by the column end rotation angle h of the specimen (Fig. 2).
500
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3
Nominal strain
Q
Pin jig
Specimen
860mm
M
N
2.2 Measurement
The load acting on the specimen was measured by the load cell installed in each
jack, and the horizontal and the vertical deformation of the specimen were mea-
sured by displacement transducers. In addition, to measure the deformation of the
local buckling zone as shown in Fig. 3, displacement transducers were installed at a
position 1.1D (D is column depth) from the lower end of the specimen. The rotation
angle, hb, and the axial deformation of the flange plate, db, of the local buckling
zone are calculated by Eq. (1), (2), respectively.
1394 T. Ishida and S. Yamada
Lb Target is connected to a θb
coupling nut welded to
d1 d2 δb
the center of the column
web.
1.1D
D
D
Fig. 3 Measurement of the deformation of the local buckling zone
d1 þ d 2 D
db ¼ þ hb ð2Þ
2 2
where, d1 and d2 are vertical deformations at 1.1D from the lower end of the
specimen, Lb is the horizontal distance between the displacement transducers which
measure d1 and d2.
Deterioration Behavior of SHS Steel Columns ... 1395
Test parameters are the width-to-thickness ratio (D/t) and the loading history. Test
parameters are summarized in Table 1. Width-to-thickness ratios are 22.2 and 33.3.
For D/t = 22.2 specimen, the axial load ratio, N/Ny, was set to 0.35. For D/t = 33.3
specimen, N/Ny was set to 0.2. Loading histories used in this test could be divided
into three gropes: constant, variable, and monotonic deformation amplitude loading.
For constant deformation amplitude, two peak-to-peak amplitudes were used:
1.5hpc, and 2.0hpc, where hpc is the calculated elastic rotation angle which corre-
sponds the plastic moment considering the effect of the axial load. For variable
deformation amplitude, one set was determined, and this set would be repeated. The
peak-to-peak deformation amplitude of variable loading consisted of four cycles of
1.5hpc, two cycles of 2.0hpc, and one cycle of 2.5hpc, as shown in Fig. 3.
3 Test Result
Column end moment, M, and the axial deformation of the flange plate in the local
buckling zone, db, relationships are shown in Fig. 6. The increment of db of each
half cycle under cyclic loading became large as the strength got deteriorate. The
envelope curve of M – db relationship under positive bending moment for each
cyclic loading test result approximately corresponds to M – db relationship under
monotonic loading, that is, the strength deterioration due to local buckling is
dependent on db regardless of loading history.
To investigate the progress of db for each half cycle, the ratio of the rotation
angle due to axial shortening of the flange plate in the local buckling zone of each
half cycle, Dhbc, to the rotation angle of the local buckling zone of each half cycle,
Dhb, was calculated (see Fig. 7). Dhbc is obtained by Eq. (3).
subjected to compression
Elongation Contraction load when M is positive Monotonic Cyclic
250 M [kNm] M( ) 250 M [kNm] 250 M [kNm]
200 200 200
150 b 150 150
100 100 100
50 50 50
0 0 0
-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
-50 -50 -50
b [mm] b [mm] [mm]
-100 M( )
-100 -100
b
50 50 50
0 0 0
-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50
-50 b [mm] -50 b [mm] -50 b [mm]
Fig. 6 Axial deformation of the flange plate in the local buckling zone
M Δθ b M
Δδbt
Δδbc
δb Δθbc δb
Δδbt Δδbc
D
where, D denotes the increment of half cycle and Ddbc is the increment of the axial
shortening of the flange plate in the local buckling zone of half cycle. Note that
Dhbc/Dhb = 0.5 indicates the axial elongation and shortening of the flange plate in
the local buckling zone of a half cycle, which are caused by tensile and compression
load due to bending, respectively, are equal; Dhbc/Dhb > 0.5 indicates that the axial
shortening in the local buckling zone increases.
Figure 8 shows Dhbc/Dhb – db relationships for the cyclic loading test results.
Also, db of the monotonic loading test result when reaching the maximum strength
(hereafter, db,u) and Dhbc/Dhb = 0.5 are also shown by black broken line and gray
broken line in Fig. 8, respectively. Dhbc/Dhb was approximately constant and
ranged from 0.5 to 0.6 until db reaches db,u of the monotonic loading test result.
1398 T. Ishida and S. Yamada
0.8 0.8
0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4
Δθbc/Δθb =0.5 Δθbc/Δθb =0.5
0.2 0.2
δ b [mm] δ b [mm]
0 0
0 20 40 60 0 2 4 6 8 10
Whole Enlarged view
(a) D/t = 22.2, N/Ny = 0.35
Δθbc/Δθb Δθbc/Δθb
1.2 1.2
δb when reaching the maximum δb when reaching the maximu m
1 strength under monotonic loading 1 strength under monotonic loading
: “Stability limit”
0.8 0.8
0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4
Δθbc/Δθb =0.5 Δθbc/Δθb =0.5
0.2 0.2
δ b [mm] δb [mm]
0 0
0 20 40 60 0 2 4 6
Whole Enlarged view
(b) D/t = 33.3, N/N = 0.2
However, after db reaches db,u, Dhbc/Dhb was significantly increase; that is; the
cyclic behavior is no longer stable due to the progress of local buckling. Hereafter,
the point when db reaches db,u, is defined as “stable limit”.
The modification method of the extended skeleton curve under small deformation
amplitude loading is proposed based on the stable limit and the ratio Dhbc/Dhb.
Figure 9 shows the schematic diagram of the modification method of the extended
skeleton curve. First, since the progress of the axial shortening of the flange part in
the local buckling zone is small and the strength deterioration can be assumed to be
negligible before reaching the stable limit, the cumulative deformation which is
from after reaching the maximum strength to reaching the stability limit is elimi-
nated from the extended skeleton curve. Also, the extended skeleton curve after
reaching the stable limit is offset by hs,cr – hu from the original position as shown in
Deterioration Behavior of SHS Steel Columns ... 1399
θs
θu θs,cr multiply Δθbc/Δθb for each half
cycle as shown in Fig. 9 (b)
(a) Schematic diagram of modification
M
after modified
before modified
θs
Δ θs * Δθs*= Δθs Δθbc /Δθb
Δ θs
(b) Modification of each half cycle’s s after reaching the stability limit
Fig. 9 (a). In which hs,cr is the deformation of the extended skeleton curve when
reaching the stability limit under cyclic loading and hu is the deformation corre-
sponding to the maximum strength under monotonic loading.
Figure 6 showed that the strength deterioration after reaching the stability limit
is governed by the axial shortening of the flange plate in the local buckling zone
regardless of loading histories; however, the deformation of the extended skeleton
curve after reaching the stability limit includes both axial shortening and elongation
components due to bending. Therefore, since only the axial shortening component
can be assumed to affect to the deterioration behavior due to local buckling, a half
cycle increment of the deformation of the extended skeleton curve is modified by
multiplying the ratio Dhbc/Dhb of each half cycle, as shown in Fig. 9 (b).
Figure 10 shows comparisons of the modified extended skeleton curve and
hysteresis curve under monotonic loading. The deterioration behavior corresponds
regardless of loading history.
1400 T. Ishida and S. Yamada
200 100
100 50
0 θs [rad] 0 θs [rad]
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0 0.1 0.2 0.3
-100 -50
-200 -100
-300 -150
(a) D/t = 22.2, N/Ny = 0.35 (b) D/t = 33.3, N/Ny = 0.2
Fig. 10 Comparison of the modified extended skeleton curve and hysteresis curve under
monotonic loading
5 Conclusions
In this study, cyclic loading tests under small deformation amplitude were con-
ducted and the strength deterioration behavior was investigated.
1) The strength of each specimen deteriorated due to local buckling. Comparing
extended skeleton curves under cyclic loading and hysteresis curve under
monotonic loading, the strength deterioration was reduced as the decrease of the
deformation amplitude. Especially, the strength deterioration behavior of the
amplitude of 1.5hpc significantly differ because the number of cycles from after
reaching the maximum strength until initiating the obvious deterioration of the
strength significantly increased.
2) The strength deterioration was dependent on the axial shortening of the flange
plate in the local buckling zone, db, regardless of loading history.
3) After db under cyclic loading exceeded db,u of the monotonic loading test result,
the ratio of the rotation angle due to axial shortening of the flange plate in the
local buckling zone of each half cycle, Dhbc, to the rotation angle of the local
buckling zone of each half cycle, Dhb, was significantly increase. Therefore, the
point when db under cyclic loading reaches db,u, can be defined as “stable limit”.
4) The extended skeleton curve was modified based on the stable limit and the ratio
Dhbc/Dhb, as follows. (A) The extended skeleton curve after reaching the sta-
bility limit is offset. The offset distance is set to hs,cr – hu in which hs,cr is the
deformation of the extended skeleton curve when reaching the stability limit
under cyclic loading and hu is the deformation corresponding to the maximum
Deterioration Behavior of SHS Steel Columns ... 1401
strength under monotonic loading. (B) A half cycle increment of the deforma-
tion of the extended skeleton curve after reaching the stability limit is modified
by multiplying the ratio Dhbc/Dhb of each half cycle.
5) The modified extended skeleton curve corresponded to the hysteresis curve
under monotonic loading regardless of loading history.
Acknowledgements This experiment is financially supported by the Japan Iron and Steel
Federation and JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number 17H01302.
References
1. Kido M, Tsuda K et al (2019) Behavior of square concreate filled steel tubular beam-columns
subjected to lateral load with constant cyclic displacement. J Struct Constr Eng 84(759):725–
735 (in Japanese)
2. Kiyokawa T, et al. (2011) (2012) Study on safety assessment methods for super-high-rise steel
buildings against long-period earthquake ground motions Part 6 – 7, Part 13 – 14. In:
Summaries of technical paper of annual meeting. Architectural Institute of Japan, pp. 1023–
1026, 1057–1060. (in Japanese)
3. Kuwamura H et al (1999) Collapse and residual drift during post-local-buckling behaviors
under earthquake. J Struct Constr Eng 64(526):169–176 (in Japanese)
4. Narihara H, et al. (2014) Study on safety assessment methods for super-high-rise steel
buildings against long-period earthquake ground motions Part 27 – 31. In: Summaries of
Technical Paper of Annual Meeting. Architectural Institute of Japan, pp. 1251 – 1260. (in
Japanese)
5. Yamada S, Ishida T, Jiao Y (2018) Hysteretic behavior of RHS columns under random cyclic
loading considering local buckling. Int J Steel Struct 18(5):1761–1771
An Experimental Study on Local
Buckling Strength of Welded
Box Section Stub-Columns Made
of SBHS400
Abstract “SBHS” has been standardized in Japanese Industrial Standards [1]. The
major features of SBHS are high yield point, high toughness and better weldability.
In some bridges in Japan, SBHS has been already used as steel members. However,
the information on the buckling strength of steel members made of SBHS400 is not
sufficient compared to conventional steel materials. In this study, the compression
tests on welded box section stub-columns were conducted to obtain information on
buckling strength of SBHS400. As a result, basic information on the buckling
strength of box section stub-columns was obtained. The experimental data indicate
the possibility that the previous ultimate strength curves may be applicable to
simply supported plates of SBHS400.
1 Introduction
Higher yield strength steel plates for bridges, “SBHS” is a high-performance steel
plate that has been standardized in Japanese Industrial Standard [1]. The major
features of SBHS are high yield point, better toughness and weldability. SBHS is
available in three types, which are SHBS400, SBHS500 and SHBS700. SBHS400
was the last to be standardized among the three types. SBHS400 and SBHS500
were specified in ‘‘Specification for highway bridges’’ [2]. Some studies on SBHS
have been conducted [3–7]. However, the information on the buckling strength of
steel members made of SBHS400 is not sufficient compared to conventional steel
materials. It is necessary to obtain more information in order to establish rational
design method. This study focuses on the buckling strength of simply supported
plates of SBHS400. The compression tests on welded box section stub-columns
were conducted in order to obtain the information on the buckling strength and an
investigation on the buckling behavior was carried out. The experimental data
indicate the possibility that the previous ultimate strength curves may be applicable
to simply supported plates of SBHS400.
The test specimens of box sections stub-columns in this study are made of
SBHS400. The major mechanical properties of SBHS400 obtained from tensile
tests are presented in Table 1. Figure 1 shows the nominal stress-nominal strain
relationship.
Table 1 The mechanical Steel type Yield stress Tensile strength Yield ratio
property of SBHS400
ry (MPa) ru (MPa) ry/ru
SBHS400 483 551 0.88
An Experimental Study on Local Buckling Strength … 1405
Fig. 1 Nominal
stress-nominal strain
relationship
around 0.7 and 1.1 and the length L was decided to prevent the overall buckling of
test specimens.
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
B ry 12ð1 m2 Þ
RR ¼ ð1Þ
t E p2 k
where, B = width of steel plates of test panels; t = thickness of steel plates of test
panels; E = Young’s modulus; m = Poisson’s ratio; kR(=4.0) = buckling coefficient;
ry = yield stress gained from tensile tests.
Strain gauges were attached on all plates and displacement transducers were
set along both the horizontal and vertical directions. Using a large scale test
machine, the compressive axial force was applied to each specimen at 0.01 mm/s
by the displacement control. Figure 3 shows the actual condition of the compres-
sion tests.
1406 K. Sobajima et al.
2 Test Results
Figure 4 shows the P/Py − d/dy relationship of each specimen. The vertical axis is
the ratio between compressive axial force and yield force “P/Py” and the horizontal
axis is the ratio between axial displacement and yield axial displacement “d=dy ”.
Where, P is the compressive axial force, Py is the yield axial force, d is the axial
An Experimental Study on Local Buckling Strength … 1407
displacement and dy is yield axial displacement. From this figure, it is obvious that
B07 has a higher buckling strength Pmax/Py than that of B11.
For each specimen, out-of-plane deformations at three locations along the height
direction were measured on two plates. P − d relationships were shown in Fig. 5
and Fig. 6. The development of the out-of-plane deformation was shown by the
horizontal displacement data taken at five different times shown in Fig. 7 and
Fig. 8. In these figures, ‘ ’ is 0.75 times of the maximum load. ‘ ’ is the load at
bifurcation point shown in the dotted lines in Fig. 9. ‘ ’ is the maximum load. ‘ ’
is the 0.9 times of the maximum load. ‘ ’ is the 0.8 times of the maximum load.
Figure 10 shows the locations of strain gages of B07. The bifurcation points were
defined as the points when the difference between strains on inside and outside
surfaces as shown in Fig. 10(b) reach approximately 1000l. The result of
out-of-plane deformation at plate B is similar to that of plate A and the result of
Fig. 5 P − d relationship of
B07
Fig. 6 P − d relationship of
B11
1408 K. Sobajima et al.
unit: mm
unit: mm
After the compression tests, residual out-of-plane deformations were measured for
both test specimens. Figure 11 shows the plots of residual deformations and Fig. 12
shows the deformations of plates at the mid-height cross section of B07 and B11.
As shown in these figures, the direction of the residual deformation of plate A and
plate B of B07was outward, while that of plate C and plate D was inward.
1410 K. Sobajima et al.
Plate A Plate A
Plate B Plate B
(a) B07 (b) B11
Plate A
unit: microstrains
Plate D
Plate C
0.75Pmax
Pmax
The deformations at the mid-height of B11 can be found little. From these results, a
half sine waveform was found in all steel plates of B07 and two-half sine wave-
forms were found in all steel plates of B11.
Figure 13 indicates the transition of the strain distribution measured from strain
gauges attached on the outside surface at the mid-height cross-section of B07.
An Experimental Study on Local Buckling Strength … 1411
P P
P P
M M
P P
P P
(a)-1 (a)-2 (a)-3 (b)-1 (b)-2 (b)-3
For plate C and plate D, the compressive strain values at all locations became
higher as the loading was progressing. For plate A and plate B, similar transitions of
the strain were observed at both edges of the plates. However, the compressive
strain became smaller at the center of the plates. This phenomenon was related to
the difference in the shape of out-of-plane deformation as shown at ‘(a)-1’ and ‘(b)-
1’ in Fig. 14. During the stage when the out-of-plane deformation was small, the
compressive strains occurred on both inside and outside surfaces of steel plates as
shown at ‘(a)-2’ and ‘(b)-2’ in Fig. 14. With the development of larger out-of-plane
deformation, tensile strain on outside surface of the steel plates was induced by the
outward deformation found on plate A and B, as shown at ‘(b)-3’ in Fig. 14. and the
total magnitude of compressive strain decreased due to the increase in tensile strain
by the out-of-plane deformation. On the other hand, compressive strain on outside
surface on the steel plates was induced by the inward deformation found on plate C
and D, as shown at ‘(a)-3’ in Fig. 14. and the total magnitude of the compressive
strain increased due to the increase in the compressive strain by the out-of-plane
deformation. As a result, it is considered to be the reason why the difference in the
transition of the strain distribution was observed.
Figure 15 shows the comparison between the test results and the ultimate strength
curves. The vertical axis is the value of rcr =ry (Pmax/Py) and the horizontal axis is
the width-thickness ratio parameter RR. As for the ultimate strength curves, the
following ultimate strength curve for simply supported steel plate are focused on in
this study.
1412 K. Sobajima et al.
Equation (2) shows the ultimate strength curve proposed by Fukumoto et al. [8]
and Eq. (3) shows the ultimate strength curve specified in “Specifications for
highway bridges” by Japan Road Associations (JRA) [2]. As shown in Fig. 15, rcr/
ry of B07 is found to be a little below the ultimate strength curves and that of B11 is
found to be above the ultimate strength curves. These plots indicate that there is a
possibility that the previous design method is applicable to the simply supported
plate made of SBHS400. However, the number of studies on buckling strength of
box section stub-columns made of SBHS400 is not enough to propose more
appropriate evaluation method. Hence, it is necessary to obtain more information on
the buckling strength of steel plates under compression force by not only experi-
mental studies but also numerical studies.
An Experimental Study on Local Buckling Strength … 1413
3 Conclusions
Ackowledgements This work was supported by the Japan Iron and Steel Federation.
References
1. Japan Industrial Standards Committee (2011) Higher yield strength steel plates for bridges, JIS
G3140. (in Japanese)
2. Japan Road Association (JRA) (2017) Specifications for highway bridges, Part II; Steel
Bridges, (in Japanese)
3. Adake T, Ono K, Miyashita T (2017) Load-carrying capacity of cruciform columns made of
SBHS400. In: 9th international symposium on steel structures
4. Ono K, Adake T, Kato K, Kitane Y, Matsumura M (2016) Load-carrying capacity of box
stub-columns made of SBHS500. In: Proceedings of 14th East Asia-Pacific conference on
structural engineering and construction, pp 1839–1843
5. Ono K, Ishikawa T, Hashimoto S, Okada S (2015) A study on residual stress and ultimate
strength of steel columns made of SBHS500. In: Proceedings of 8th international symposium
on steel structures
6. Hashimoto S, Ono K, Okada S (2013) An experimental study on mechanical properties and
constitutive equation of SBHS500. In: Proceedings of the 13th East Asia-Pacific conference on
structural engineering and construction (EASEC-13)
7. Ono K, Aizawa H, Miyashita T, Yamada S, Miyazaki Y (2016) An experimental study on
constitutive equation of SBHS400 under cyclic loading. In: Proceedings of 14th East
Asia-Pacific conference on structural engineering and construction (EASEC-14), pp 1833–
1838
8. Fukumoto Y, et al (1990) Approach to the unified evaluation of ultimate strength of steel
framed structures. Achievement Report of Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research. (in Japanese)
Proposal to Improve the DSM Design
of Cold-Formed Steel Fixed-Ended
Columns Failing in Global Modes
Abstract This paper presents a proposal to improve the failure load prediction
quality provided by the current Direct Strength Method (DSM) design curve for
cold-formed steel fixed-ended columns failing in global modes, namely flexural and
flexural-torsional ones. After (i) collecting the available numerical failure load data,
comprising columns with several geometries (cross-section dimensions and length)
and covering a wide slenderness range, and (ii) showing that the currently codified
DSM column global design curve is unable to predict them adequately, the
development of new strength curves, aimed at estimating more efficiently the
column global failure loads, is addressed. Their merits are assessed through (i) the
quality of the estimates of the available failure load data and (ii) the determination
of the corresponding Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) resistance factors.
It is shown that the failure load predictions provided by either of the two proposed/
modified DSM global design curves (i) exhibit a very high quality and (ii) clearly
outperform those yielded by the currently codified strength curve for the whole set
of columns considered in this work.
Keywords Cold-formed steel columns Fixed-ended columns Flexural and
flexural-torsional failures Direct Strength Method (DSM) design Proposal of
novel strength curves
1 Introduction
Most cold-formed steel members display very slender thin-walled open cross-
sections, a feature making them highly susceptible to several instability phenomena,
namely local, distortional and global (flexural or flexural-torsional) buckling—
Figs. 1(a)–(d) show cross-section deformed configurations of lipped channel col-
umns buckling in these modes. Depending on the member length and cross-section
shape and/or dimensions, any of the above buckling modes may be critical.
In the context of numerical investigations on local-distortional-global and
distortional-global mode interaction in cold-formed steel columns, Dinis and
Camotim [6] and Martins et al. [10] reported that the current Direct Strength Method
(DSM—e.g., [4]) global design curve underestimates, often substantially, the ulti-
mate strength of slender cold-formed steel columns failing in flexural-torsional
modes, thus leading to uneconomic designs. These authors also noted that this
design curve estimates much more accurately column flexural failure loads—not
surprising, since its roots are in hot-rolled steel specifications, concerning almost
exclusively doubly symmetric members. These findings prompted Dinis et al. [7, 8]
to perform extensive numerical investigations, involving columns with several
commonly used cross-section shapes, intended to (i) assess the accuracy of the
current DSM design curve in predicting column flexural-torsional and flexural
failure loads, (ii) acquire knowledge on the column post-buckling behaviour and
(iii) gather large failure load data, to help develop improved DSM-based design
approaches for these columns. The analysis of the above failure loads confirmed that
the current DSM design curve (i) predicts quite well flexural failure loads (even if
there is still room for some improvement) and (ii) often strongly underestimates
flexural-torsional failure loads of columns with moderate or high slenderness—the
underestimation depends on the cross-section geometry (shape/dimensions) and
increases with the slenderness.
The objective of this paper is to provide an overview of the research effort men-
tioned above, and to propose DSM-based design curves to estimate more efficiently
column global failure loads. After collecting the available failure loads, concerning
fixed-ended columns buckling and failing in flexural-torsional (FMT) or flexural (Fm)
modes, it is shown that the current DSM global strength curve is unable to estimate
them adequately, thus justifying the need to improve the prediction quality provided
by the current curve. The strength curve proposed to predict flexural failure loads only
differs (slightly) from the current one in the low and moderate slenderness ranges.
Conversely, it is also shown that the flexural-torsional failure loads can only be
adequately predicted, for columns with moderate or high slenderness and an arbitrary
cross-section shape, by means of a strength curve set dependent on a geometric
parameter involving the cross-section area, major/minor moments of inertia and
warping constant. Indeed, the predictions of the two proposed/modified DSM-based
global design curves have very high quality and clearly outperform those yielded by
the current strength curve, leading to Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD)
resistance factors higher than 0.90 for all the columns analysed in this work—this
value is considerably above that currently recommended by the North American
Specification [1] for compression members (/c = 0.85).
According to Section K2.1.1 of AISI [1], the LFRD resistance factor is given by
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
ffi
/ ¼ C/ (Mm Fm Pm ) eb0 VM þ VF þ CP VP þ VQ
2 2 2 2
ð1Þ
where (i) C/ = 1.52 (calibration coefficient for LRFD), (ii) Mm = 1.10 and
Fm = 1.00 (taken from Table K2.1.1-1 of the specification) are the material and
fabrication factor mean values, (iii) b0 is the target reliability value (b0 = 2.5 for
structural members in LRFD), (iv) VM = 0.10 and VF = 0.05 (also taken from
Table K2.1.1-1) are the material and fabrication factors, (v) VQ = 0.21 is the
coefficient of variation of the load effect, and (vi) Cp is a correction factor dependent
on the number of tests. The Pm and Vp values are the mean and coefficient of
variation of the “exact”-to-predicted failure load ratios. The value recommended for
compression members is /c = 0.85, regardless of the column failure mode nature.
The numerical failure loads collected by Dinis et al. [7] concern columns with a wide
variety of cross-section shapes: plain channels (U), unstiffened (C), return lip (RLC),
web-stiffened (WSC) and web/flange-stiffened (WFSC) lipped channels, hat-sections
(H) and rack-sections (R)—(i) C, H, Z column trios with the same cross-section
dimensions, such that 2.00 bw/bf 1.09, 10.00 bf/bl 4.09 and 4.0
t 1.0 mm, (ii) R and RLC column pairs with the same cross-section dimensions,
such that 2.00 bw/bf 1.09, 8.75 bf/bl 3.00 and 2.5 t 1.0 mm,
(iii) WSC and WFSC columns such that 2.00 bw/bf 1.09, 11.00
bf/bl 3.50 and 4.0 t 1.2 mm, and (iv) I columns with 2.50 bw/bf
0.83—see Fig. 2. Note that (i) the WCS and WFSC column “v-shaped” intermediate
1418 P. B. Dinis et al.
d4
bs bf bf bf d3 bf
d1 d1
bf bf bs
bw bw bw bw bl bw bl bw d2 bw d2 bw
bs bf bs bs
bs bs
(a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) bf (h)
stiffeners are such that d1 = d3 = 10 mm and d2 = d4 = 20 mm, and (ii) the I column
web thickness is 2 t = 4.0 mm. The fixed-ended columns (i) have lengths selected to
ensure buckling in FMT or Fm modes, more or less equally spaced in the interval
LT < L min {3 LT; 1000 cm}, (ii) contain critical-mode initial geometrical
imperfections with amplitude L/1000 and (iii) have yield stresses fy selected to cover
wide critical slenderness ranges—the values considered are 75, 150, 300, 450,
600 MPa (to achieve low slenderness value completion, some fy values are unreal-
istically low). A total of 1710 columns buckling/failing in FMT modes, associated
with 11.00 fbF/fcrFT 1.17, and 600 columns buckling/failing in Fm modes are
analysed—all cross-section dimensions, lengths, critical buckling stresses fcr and
column failure loads Pu can be found in Dinis et al. [7, 8]. The failure load data also
include six experimental values reported by Bandula Heva and Mahendran [2] and
concerning fixed-ended lipped channel columns with 1.57 bw/bf 1.50,
1.95 t 0.95 mm, and 2800 L 1800 mm.
The current DSM column global design curve (Pne) combines Johnson parabola
with a lowered Euler curve and was first codified for hot-rolled steel members used
in buildings. Later, due to the work of Peköz and Sümer [11], it was included in the
cold-formed steel specification [1]—the nominal strength Pne is given by
8
< Py 0:658k2c if kc 1:5 0:5
Pne ¼ with kc ¼ Py =Pcre ; ð2Þ
: Py 0:877 if kc [ 1:5
k 2
c
where (i) kc is the global slenderness value, (ii) Pcre is the column global buckling
load and (iii) Py is the squash load—they are calculated on the basis of the gross
cross-section area (A) and the elastic buckling (fcr) or the steel yield (fy) stresses.
Proposal to Improve the DSM Design … 1419
Figures 3(a)–(g) and 4(a)–(c) plot the Pu/Pne ratios obtained for nine column sets (U,
C, H, R, RLC, WSC, WSFC, Z, I), grouped according to the buckling/failure mode
nature: Fm (Pu.F —Fig. 3) or FMT (Pu.FT—Fig. 4)—these figures also include the Pu/
Pne means, standard deviations, maximum/minimum values. These results clearly
show that (i) the Pu/Pne values “clouds” are similar for all the FMT and Fm column sets,
and (ii) the current DSM global design curve is not able to handle adequately columns
failing in both mode types. Indeed, this curve (i) overestimates, mostly by small
amounts, the flexural failure loads of columns with low-to-moderate slenderness
(kc 2.0) and (ii) underestimates, often by large amounts, the flexural-torsional
failure loads of columns with moderate or high slenderness (kc > 1.5). The next
section addresses the improvements proposed by the authors in order to overcome the
shortcomings just identified.
1.0 1.0
2.0 2.0
1.0 1.0
Mean=1.601 Max=3.130 Mean=1.321 Max=2.740 Mean=1.361 Max=3.320
St.Dev.=0.582 Min=1.020 St.Dev.=0.396 Min=0.950 St.Dev.=0.458 Min=0.990
c 0.0 0.0 c
0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0
(a) (b) (c)
R columns RLC columns Pu.FT /Pne WSC columns WFSC columns
3.0
2.0
1.0
Mean=1.329 Max=2.814 Mean=1.290 Max=2.791 Mean=1.328 Max=2.279 Mean=1.343 Max=2.700
c St.Dev.=0.363 Min=0.953 St.Dev.=0.347 Min=0.939 St.Dev.=0.330 Min=1.010 St.Dev.=0.379 Min=0.982 c
0.0
0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0
(d) (e) (f) (g)
The U column failure load data assembled by Dinis et al. [7] provided the means to
propose and validate strength curves that improve the failure load prediction quality
for columns buckling and failing in FMT and Fm modes—such curves provide
failure load estimates termed PnFT and PnF, respectively. Then, the merits of the two
proposed/modified DSM-based design curves were assessed by predicting the
whole set of column global failure loads collected in Sect. 2.
In order to achieve a better failure load prediction quality for columns buckling and
failing in FMT modes and exhibiting moderate or high slenderness (kc > 1.5—this
means that the Johnson parabola is kept in the low-to-moderate slenderness range),
a new DSM-based approach was initially proposed, involving a set of strength
curves dependent on a geometric parameter b = II/III, relating the cross-section
major (II) and minor (III) moments of inertia [7]. Although using this geometric
parameter enabled a fairly good estimation of the numerical failure loads obtained,
it was also found that distinct strength curve sets were needed for columns with
one-wall and two-wall end stiffeners—the latter are the R and RLC columns. The
search for a single set of strength curves able to handle columns with arbitrary
cross-sections led to the proposal of a new geometric parameter involving not only
the moments of inertia (II, III), but also the warping constant Iw [8]—note that this
constant can be nowadays easily calculated numerically, by means of freely
available codes such as CUFSM [9] or GBTUL [3]. The parameter, termed bFT, is
given by
II þ Iw =A
bFT ¼ ; ð3Þ
III
where A is the gross cross-section area, included in the expression to keep its
non-dimensional nature. Thus, for kc kFT > 1.5 (to distinguish the current and
proposed DSM design curves, kFT replaces kc in the latter), the strength curve is
bFT-dependent and defined by a general “Euler-type” expression, similar to that
appearing in Eq. (2)—this strength curve set is provided by the expressions
8 2
< Py 0:658kFT if kFT 1:5 0:5
PnFT ¼ with kFT ¼ Py =PcrFT ; ð4Þ
: Py ab if kFT [ 1:5
k FT
Proposal to Improve the DSM Design … 1421
0.0 Pne FT
0.0 Pne FT
0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0
(a) (b)
Fig. 5 Comparison between the Pu.FT/Py values concerning R columns exhibiting a bFT = 6.53
and b bFT = 11.96 with the current and proposed DSM design curves (Pne and PnFT)
where the bFT-dependence is felt through parameters a and b, which are functions
of bFT given by
To illustrate the prediction quality achieved by the proposed strength curve set,
Figs. 5(a), (b) plot, against kFT, the Pu.FT/Py values concerning R columns with two
bFT values (bFT = 6.53-11.96) and compare them with the current DSM column
global design curve and the strength curve set obtained with Eq. (4) (solid and
dashed lines, respectively). It is clear that the proposed DSM strength curves follow
the Pu.FT/Py trends quite well, providing close underestimations of the numerical
failure loads.
In order to assess the performance and merits of the proposed strength curve set,
Figs. 6(a), (b) plot, against kFT, the Pu.FT/PnFT ratios of (i) all the numerical failure
loads considered in this work and (ii) the six experimental failure loads reported by
Bandula Heva and Mahendran [2]—these figures also include the failure-to-predicted
means, standard deviations, maximum/minimum values, as well as the LRFD resis-
tance factors they lead to. These results lead to the following remarks:
(i) The proposed strength curve set leads to a fairly uniform failure load prediction
quality along the whole slenderness range. For the various column sets, the
Pu.FT/PnFT statistical indicators read 1.074-0.069-1.207-0.845 (U), 1.056-
0.051-1.234-0.875 (C), 1.093-0.067-1.308-0.906 (H), 1.054-0.049-1.225-
0.888 (R), 1.040-0.039-1.147-0.939 (RLC), 1.059-0.044-1.157-0.901 (WSC)
and 1.060-0.062-1.288-0.860 (WFSC)—these indicators are quite close to
those obtained for the whole set of numerical failure loads: 1.061-0.054-
1.308-0.845.
1422 P. B. Dinis et al.
Fig. 6 Plots Pu.FT/PnFT vs. kFT for the a numerical and b experimental column failure loads
(ii) The LRFD resistance factors concerning all the Pu.FT/PnFT ratios for
kFT 1.5 and kFT > 1.5 are practically identical and well above /c = 0.85
—value recommended for compression members in AISI [1]. Indeed, they
read / = 0.96 (n = 698, Pm = 1.051, VP = 0.031) and / = 0.97 (n = 1012,
Pm = 1.068, VP = 0.060), respectively.
(iii) Since only three C columns tested by Bandula Heva and Mahendran [2]
exhibit kFT 1.5, further experimental studies involving slender column
specimens are required in order to provide adequate experimental validation
for the proposed strength curve set. Nevertheless, the six-value (three below
kFT = 1.5 and three above kFT = 1.5) Pu.FT/PnFT statistical indicators
obtained are quite good: average, standard deviation and maximum/
minimum values equal to 0.999-0.075-1.114-0.915—the associated LRFD
resistance factor is also above 0.85.
As for the FMT columns, the above search was carried out by means of a
“trial-and-error curve fitting procedure” that led to
(
Py if kF 0:422 0:5
PnF ¼ h i with kF ¼ Py =PcrF :
Py 1 0:24 k2 þ 0:42
1 1
k2 þ 0:42
if kF [ 0:422
F F
ð7Þ
It is worth noting that, if coefficient 0.42 is changed to 0.60, this curve practi-
cally coincides with the Eurocode 3 [5] curve c. Figure 7 compares the Pu,F/Py
values of U columns buckling and failing in Fm modes with the current (solid—Pne)
and proposed (dashed—PnF) DSM strength curves. It is readily noticed that the two
strength curves only differ for kF 2.0.
In order to assess the merits of the proposed PnF strength curve, Fig. 8 plots,
against kF, the Pu.F/PnF values concerning all the numerical failure loads considered
in this work–the figure also includes the statistical indicators of the Pu.F/PnF values.
These results lead to the following comments:
(i) The proposed strength curve leads to a fairly uniform failure load prediction
quality along the whole slenderness range. Indeed, the statistical indicators of
the Pu.F/PnF values are 0.995-0.040-1.100-0.910 (U), 1.042-0.059-1.200-
0.910 (Z) and 1.053-0.059-1.201-0.897 (I)—these indicators are close to
those obtained for the whole set of numerical failure loads: 1.042-0.060-
1.201-0.897.
(ii) Although the failure load prediction quality improvement achieved by the
PnF strength curve is much less pronounced than that of its PnFT counterpart,
it is by no means negligible for kF 2.0. Indeed, for this slenderness range,
the minor-axis flexural failure loads obtained in this work lead to
failure-to-predicted ratios with averages and minimum values equal to
1.055-0.897 (Pu.F/PnF) and 0.969-0.800 (Pu.F/Pne), respectively, which
constitutes a visible improvement.
(iii) The associated LRFD resistance factor is / = 0.94 (n = 600, Pm = 1.042,
VP = 0.060). For kF 2.0 and kF > 2.0, one has / = 0.95 (n = 398,
Pm = 1.055, VP = 0.067) and / = 0.93 (n = 202, Pm = 1.017, VP = 0.031),
respectively.
0.0 F
0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0
1424 P. B. Dinis et al.
Fig. 8 Plots Pu.F/PnF vs. kF for all the available numerical column failure loads
On the basis of the fixed-ended column numerical failure loads obtained in this
work, it was found that it is essential to distinguish between the DSM-based global
strength curves used to design columns against major-axis flexural-torsional (PnFT)
and minor-axis flexural (PnF) failures. In the first case, a strength curve set were
proposed, (i) dependent on bFT = (II+ Iw/A)/III (II, III: cross-section major and minor
moments of inertia; Iw: warping constant; A: gross cross-section area) and (ii) dif-
fering from the current global curve only for kFT > 1.5—it is defined by the
expressions
8 2
< Py 0:658kFT if kFT 1:5 0:5
PnFT ¼ with kFT ¼ Py =PcrFT ; ð8Þ
: Py ab if kFT [ 1:5
k FT
ð10Þ
Proposal to Improve the DSM Design … 1425
6 Conclusions
This paper presented a proposal to improve the failure load prediction quality
provided by the current Direct Strength Method (DSM) for cold-formed steel
fixed-ended columns failing in global modes, namely flexural (Fm) and
flexural-torsional (FMT) ones. Initially, the available numerical failure load data,
concerning columns with several geometries (cross-section shape/dimensions and
length) and covering a wide slenderness range, were collected and subsequently
used to show that a single DSM design curve, such as the currently one, is unable to
handle adequately columns failing in both mode types. Indeed, it was shown that
the current strength curve (i) underestimates, often by large amounts, the failure
loads of columns with moderate or high slenderness (kc > 1.5) that fail in FMT
modes, and (ii) overestimates, usually by small amounts, the failure loads of col-
umns with low-to-moderate slenderness (kc 2.0) that fail in Fm modes. Then, the
paper presented modified DSM-based design curves that improve the failure load
prediction quality for columns buckling/failing in both global modes. It was shown
that the failure load predictions provided by either of the proposed/modified DSM
global design curves (i) exhibit a very high quality and (ii) clearly outperform those
yielded by the current strength curve, for the whole set of columns considered in
this work.
Finally, one last word to mention that the possible codification of the proposed
DSM-based column global design curves must be preceded by (i) experimental
validation and (ii) an assessment of their applicability to columns exhibiting other/
arbitrary support conditions.
References
1. AISI (American Iron and Steel Institute) (2016) North American Specification (NAS) for the
Design of Cold-Formed Steel Structural Members (AISI-S100-16)+Commentary, Washington
DC
2. Bandula Heva Y, Mahendran M (2012) Flexural-torsional buckling tests of cold-formed steel
compression members at elevated temperatures. Steel Compos Struct 14(3):205–227
3. Bebiano R, Camotim D, Gonçalves R (2018) GBTUL 2.0 – a second-generation code for the
GBT-based buckling and vibration analysis of thin-walled members. Thin Walled Struct
124:235–277
4. Camotim D, Dinis PB, Martins AD (2016). Direct Strength Method (DSM) − a general
approach for the design of cold-formed steel structures. In: Yu C (ed) Recent trends in
cold-formed steel construction. Series in Civil & Structural Engineering. Woodhead
Publishing, Amsterdam, pp 69–105
5. CEN (Comité Européen de Normalisation) (2005) Eurocode 3: Design of Steel Structures –
Part 1-1: General Rules and Rules for Buildings, EN 1993-1-1:2005, Brussels, Belgium
6. Dinis PB Camotim D (2016) Behaviour and DSM design of hat, zed and rack columns
experiencing local-distortional-global interaction. In: Young B, Cai Y (eds) USB Key Drive
Proceedings of 8th International Conference on Steel and Aluminium Structures (ICSAS
2016), Hong Kong, 7–9/12, Paper 60
1426 P. B. Dinis et al.
7. Dinis PB, Camotim D, Landesmann A, Martins AD (2019) On the direct strength method
design of columns against global failure. Thin Walled Struct 139(June):242–270
8. Dinis PB, Camotim D, Landesmann A, Martins AD (2019) Accurate direct strength method
(DSM) prediction of column flexural-torsional failure loads. In: Website proceedings of
structural stability research council (SSRC) annual stability conference, St. Louis, 2–5/4
9. Li Z, Abreu JCB, Leng J, Ádány S, Schafer BW (2014) Review: constrained finite strip
method developments and applications in cold-formed steel design. Thin Walled Struct 81
(August):2–18
10. Martins AD, Camotim D, Dinis PB (2017) On the distortional-global interaction of
cold-formed steel columns: relevance, post-buckling, strength and DSM design. In: Website
proceedings of structural stability research council (SSRC) annual stability conference, San
Antonio, 21–24/3
11. Peköz T, Sümer O (1992) Design provisions for cold-formed steel columns and
beam-column. Research Report RP92-1, American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI),
Washington DC
An Experimental Study on Buckling
Strength of Stainless Steel Columns
with Gusset Plates
Abstract The damage of corrosion at lateral bracings and sway bracings has been
reported and some of them are serious damage. Stainless steel has high corrosion
resistance. Therefore, by applying stainless steel to such members, it is expected
that the maintenance cost for corrosion can be reduced. In order to use stainless
steel for lateral bracings and sway bracings, it is necessary to grasp the buckling
strength. However, there are insufficient data of stainless steel compared with the
conventional steel. Therefore, the compression test on the stainless steel column
was conducted in this study. The test specimen was designed based on the inves-
tigation of the configurations of lateral bracings and sway bracings in actual
existing steel bridges. The experimental results show the displacement of the col-
umn was increased rapidly and the slippage in bolted connection was observed after
the maximum load. The test results were compared with the ultimate strength curve
described in “Specifications for Highway Bridges” in Japan. The result indicates the
possibility that the buckling strength of the stainless steel column can be evaluated
by ultimate strength curve in the current design specifications.
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Designs
The test specimen consists of the column and the gusset plates. The column is angle
steel. The steel type of the column is SUS316 and that of the gusset plates is
SM400A. The bolts are made of SUS630. Figure 1, Tables 1 and 2 show the con-
figurations of the test specimen. The yield stress of SUS316 and SM400A obtained
from tensile tests are shown in Table 3. The yield stress of SM400A was the value
provided by the inspection certificate. The slenderness ratio parameter
k, the ratio of
fixed point distance and plate thickness a/t were decided based on the survey of
An Experimental Study on Buckling Strength … 1429
existing steel bridges. Figures 2 and 3 show the results of the survey. k is represented
in Eq. (1). a/t is used as the parameter that is related to the local buckling strength of
the gusset plates. a/t was designed to be close to the value of 15, which exist in the
most frequent range of the data according to the survey of existing bridges. In order to
avoid the galvanic corrosion, epoxy resin sheets were installed on the washer and
between the column and gusset plates as shown in Fig. 1(e).
rffiffiffiffiffi
k ¼ L 1 ry
ð1Þ
rx p E
The uniaxial compression force was applied by displacement control with a test
machine whose total capacity was 1000 kN. Figure 4 shows the photograph of the
installation of the test specimen. The support condition at both ends of the test
specimen was fixed. The loading was repeated in the elastic region and after the
maximum load. Table 4 and Fig. 5 show the loading process.
x axis
Centroid
y axis
Gusset plate
SM400A
Washer
Unit: [mm] : Epoxy resin sheet
SUS316 SM400A
Yield stress (N/mm2) 260* 293
10
0
An Experimental Study on Buckling Strength … 1431
30
20
10
0
Less 5 10 10 15 15 20 20 25 25 30 30 35 35 40
than 5
200
150
100
50
Average
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Axial Displacement δ (mm)
1432 A. Matsuo et al.
3 Experimental Results
The relationship between axial load P and axial displacement d (P-d relationship) of
the test specimen is indicated in Fig. 6. The displacement of d is the average of four
axial displacements (Fig. 7). The test specimen reached the maximum loads Pmax
that was less than the yield load Py (495 kN). After reaching Pmax, the displacement
increased rapidly.
The relationships between the load and the displacement of the slippage in
bolted connection are shown in Fig. 8. The slippage in bolted connection did not
occur before reaching Pmax but occurred after reaching Pmax in the upper side.
The principal stress diagram at the maximum axial load ‘(A)’ in Fig. 9 and the
unloading point ‘(B)’ in Fig. 9 are shown in Fig. 10. Comparing Fig. 10 (a) with
Fig. 10 (b), the stress at ‘(B)’ is much smaller than that at ‘(A)’. The results indicate
the possibility that the residual strains may be smaller than those shown in ‘(B)’ in
Fig. 9 if unloading was conducted at the maximum load ‘(A)’.
An Experimental Study on Buckling Strength … 1433
150
100
50 Average
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Axial Displacement δ (mm)
VSE VNE
VSW,VSE VNW,VNE
In order to examine the design methods of the buckling strength of the columns
with gusset plates, the experimental result was compared with the ultimate strength
curve in “Specifications for Highway Bridges”. The ultimate strength curve
excluding the welded box section columns is represented as Eq. (2) and that for the
angle section is expressed as Eq. (3) under the influence of eccentricity. The result
of the compression test is shown in Table 5. Figure 11 indicates that the experi-
mental result was plotted above the ultimate strength curve. Therefore, there is a
1434 A. Matsuo et al.
300 300
Pmax Pmax
250 250
Axial Load P (kN)
150 150
100 100
50 HUL1 50 HDL1
0 0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
Displacement (mm) Displacement (mm)
150
100
50
Average
(B)
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Axial Displacement δ (mm)
An Experimental Study on Buckling Strength … 1435
Experimental results
Maximum load Pmax (kN) 240
Cross secsional area A (mm2) 1900
Buckling stress σ cr (N/mm2) 126
Yield stress σy (N/mm2) 260
σ cr /σ y 0.484
Slenderness ratio parameter λ 0.768
1436 A. Matsuo et al.
σcr/σy
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0
Slenderness ratio parameter
possibility that the buckling strength of the stainless steel columns can be evaluated
by the ultimate strength curve of the current design specifications.
rcr 1:00 ðk 0:2Þ
¼ ð2Þ
ry 1:109 0:545k ð0:2 \ k 1:0Þ
1
0:733 þ k2
ð1:0 \
kÞ
rcud rcr L=rx ð3Þ
¼ ð0:5 þ Þ
ry ry 1000
4 Conclusions
The uniaxial compression test was conducted on stainless steel columns with gusset
plates. After the maximum load, the axial displacement of the column was
increased rapidly and the slippage in bolted connection was observed. The principal
stress of the gusset plates after unloading was much smaller than at the maximum
load. In this study, the test result was plotted above the ultimate strength curve.
Therefore, there is a possibility that the buckling strength of the stainless steel
column can be evaluated by the ultimate strength curve in the current design
specifications. However, it is necessary to obtain more experimental data of the
buckling strength of the stainless steel columns with gusset plates and numerical
studies that verify the experimental data.
Acknowledgements This study was conducted as a part of the joint projects on application of high
performance steel to the highway bridges and was supported by Public Works Research Institute,
Japanese Society of Steel Construction, Japan Bridge Association, Nagaoka University of
Technology, National Institute of Technology, Nagaoka College, Waseda University and
Honshu-Shikoku Bridge Expressway Company Limited. The authors gratefully acknowledge them.
An Experimental Study on Buckling Strength … 1437
References
1. Japan Road Association (2017) Specifications for Highway Bridges, Part II; Steel Bridges (in
Japanese)
2. Usami T, Fukumoto Y (1972) Compressive strength and design of bracing members with angle
or tee section. J Jpn Soc Civil Eng 201:43–50
3. Usami T, Galambos TV (1971) Eccentrically Loaded Single-Angle Columns, Pub1. IABSE,
vol 31-II, pp 153–184
4. Yuan HX, Wang YQ, Gardner L, Du XX, Shi YJ (2015) Local–overall interactive buckling
behaviour of welded stainless steel I-section columns. J Constr Steel Res 111:75–87
Effect of Number of Additional Bolts
Outside Splice Plates on Behaviour
of Frictional Type Bolted Joints
with a Filler Plate
H. Moriyama (&)
Department of Civil and Architectural Engineering, Kumamoto University,
Kumamoto, Japan
e-mail: moriyama@kumamoto-u.ac.jp
T. Takai
Department of Civil and Architectural Engineering, Kyusu Institute of Technology,
Fukuoka, Japan
e-mail: takai@civil.kyutech.ac.jp
T. Yamaguchi
Department of Civil Engineering, Osaka City University, Osaka, Japan
e-mail: yamaguti-t@osaka-cu.ac.jp
S. Kozai
Department of Bridge Design, Takada Kiko Co. Ltd., Osaka, Japan
e-mail: s_kozai@takadakiko.co.jp
Keywords Frictional bolted joints Filler plate Bolt shear resistance Loose
filler Tight filler
1 Introduction
2 Tensile Tests
2.1 Specimens
Table 1 Structural
configurations and bolt
arrangement
Constant Configraitons Considered Parameters
Bolt Bolt Width Width/ End End Bolt Pitch Thickness of Thickness Designed Number Thickness of Thickness Change Rate
Number Diamter Hole Bolt Distance Distance Pitch /Bolt Connected of Spice Bolt of Connected of Filler of Thickness
Specimen /Bolt
of Diameter Diamater Diamter Plate in Plates Tensions Bolts Plate in Plate of Connected
Name Diamter
Specimens Non-slip Side Slip-sidde Plate
d d0 w w/d e1 e1 / d p p/d t mf t spl Nd n t ms tf η
(mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (kN) (mm) (mm) (%)
n3-NF 80 5.00 3
28 0 0
n4-NF 100 6.25 4
n4-LF20
125 7.81 22 6 21
n4-TF20
3 16 17.8 40 2.50 50 3.13 28 19 116
n4-LF30
140 8.75 4 19 9 32
n4-TF30
n4-LF50
180 11.25 14 14 50
n4-TF50
Table 2 Mechanical
properties based on material
test
(a) Connected plate, filler plate and splice plates
Thickness Young's Modulus Poisson's Ratio Yield Stress Tensile Strength Yield Strain
Apprication
t E ν σy σt εy= σ y / E
Parts 2
(mm) (N/mm ) (N/mm )
2
(N/mm )
2 -6
(×10 )
6 Filler 215,797 0.280 408 571 1,892
9 Filler 214,841 0.283 400 519 1,862
Filler
14 210,558 0.278 401 532 1,906
Connected Plate
Connected Plate
19 210,949 0.283 413 557 1,958
Splice Plates
22 Connected Plate 210,991 0.286 424 563 2,010
28 Connected Plate 209,472 0.281 377 525 1,798
The mechanical properties of plates and high-strength bolt are shown in Table 2.
All properties of plates were obtained by material tests. As for high-strength bolt, its
yield stress and tensile strength were quoted from the mill test certificate, and
Young’s modulus was determine by tensile tests with the bolt stuck on strain gauge.
The faying surface was coated with inorganic zinc-rich paint after shot blast
processing.
Table 3 shows the design resistance of connected plate, filler plate and
high-strength bolt calculated based on the mechanical properties shown in Table 2.
The design slip resistance Psd and net cross-section yield resistance Pynd are
calculated by Eqs. (1) and (2), respectively. And also, the ratio of these resistance b,
which is related to the slip behaviour, is obtained by Eq. (3). The net cross-section
failure resistance Ptnd, bolt shear failure resistance Pbod are calculated by Eq. (4)
and (5), respectively.
Psd
b¼ ð3Þ
Pynd
Effect of Number of Additional Bolts Outside Splice Plates … 1443
Ptnd ¼ ðw d0 Þt rt ð4Þ
pffiffiffi
Pbod ¼ nmAe stb ¼ rtb = 3 ð5Þ
Figure 3 shows measuring items and these measuring points. To evaluate the
overall behavior of joint, its displacement was measured. Investigating the net
cross-sectional yield strength and shear yield strength at the end portion, the strain
of the side surface of the connected plate was measured. The bolt tension was
installed by referring to the strain of the bolt shank.
Obtained experimental results are summarized in Table 4, and load versus dis-
placement curves are shown in Fig. 4.
Slip coefficient was calculated by Eq. (6).
P
l1 ¼ Ps ð6Þ
m i Ni1
where; Ps is the slip strength, Ni−1 is tension of each bolts before the test.
Net cross-section yield strength Pyn−m and shear yield strength Pye were deter-
mined with the strain of the side surface and end portion of the connected plate.
When one of strains measured at side surface reaches yield strain ey , its peripheral
Table 4 Experimental
results
Slip Limit State (SLS) Yield Limit State (SLS) Maximum Load and Failure Mode (ULS)
Actual Average Slip
Slip Net Cross Shear Yield Shear Yield/ Maximum Maximum
Change Rate Bolt Maximum Load Actual Failure
Strength Coefficient -Section Strength of Net Cross- Load Load / Bolt Maximum Load Ratio
Speci Speci of Thickness Tensions Ratioof the Joint Mode (Number
Evaluated Yield Connected Section Shear Failure of the Joint with and
-men -men of Connected before with and without of Broken Bolts
with N 1 Strength of Pl. at Strength Resistance without Filler Plate
Name No. Plate Tests Filler Plate /Total Bolts)
Connected Pl. End Portion Ratio
η N1 Ps P ye / P yn-m
-Number of Shear P max /P bod P max /P ma P max /P ma
μ1 P s /P s P s /P s P yn-m P ye P max
(%) (kN) Failure Plane
(kN) |n3-NF |n4-NF (kN) (kN) (kN) x |n3-NF x |n4-NF
1 0.0 115.9 543 0.78 593 748 1.26 BO (3/3)-2 845 1.13
n3-NF 2 0.0 115.9 554 549 0.80 0.79 - - 600 588 706 718 1.18 1.22 BO(3/3)-1 and 2 850 843 1.14 1.13 - -
3 0.0 116.2 549 0.79 573 698 1.22 BO(3/3)-2 835 1.12
1 0.0 116.0 783 0.84 776 1090 1.40 1147 1.15
n4-NF 2 0.0 117.5 814 809 0.87 0.87 - - 777 797 1087 1063 1.40 1.34 BO (4/4)-2 1177 1165 1.18 1.17 - -
3 0.0 116.8 830 0.89 839 1011 1.20 1171 1.18
1 21.9 115.7 687 0.74 853 935 1.10 1060 1.06
n4-
2 21.9 116.2 715 700 0.77 0.75 1.27 0.86 844 839 972 950 1.15 1.13 BO (4/4)-1 1066 1066 1.07 1.07 1.26 0.91
LF20
3 21.9 116.4 696 0.75 820 943 Do 1.15 1071 1.08
1 21.8 116.2 558 0.60 820 729 wn 0.89 855 0.86
n4-
2 21.9 116.2 550 543 0.59 0.58 0.99 0.67 - 820 724 720 - 0.89 BO (3/4)-1 851 847 0.85 0.85 1.00 0.73
TF20
3 22.0 116.2 521 0.56 - 708 - 834 0.84
1 33.3 116.1 763 0.82 738 958 1.30 1070 1.07
n4-
2 33.4 116.3 754 766 0.81 0.82 1.40 0.95 741 739 929 933 1.25 1.26 BO (4/4)-1 1101 1095 1.11 1.10 1.30 0.94
LF30
3 33.5 116.1 780 0.84 738 913 Do 1.24 1116 1.12
1 33.4 116.7 626 0.67 816 805 wn 0.99 890 0.89
n4-
2 33.4 115.8 636 629 0.69 0.67 1.15 0.78 782 791 827 805 1.06 1.02 BO (3/4)-1 896 893 0.90 0.90 1.06 0.77
TF30
3 33.4 117.2 626 0.67 776 783 1.01 892 0.90
1 50.3 116.5 703 0.75 772 873 1.13 1003 1.01
n4-
2 50.2 116.3 743 716 0.80 0.77 1.31 0.89 775 796 873 838 1.13 1.06 BO (4/4)-1 1036 1022 1.04 1.03 1.21 0.88
LF50
3 50.2 116.4 704 0.76 841 767 Do 0.91 1026 1.03
1 49.9 116.2 601 0.65 707 698
wn 0.99 838 0.84
n4-
2 50.1 117.1 583 585 0.62 0.63 1.07 0.72 726 713 722 730 0.99 1.02 BO (3/4)-1 837 834 0.84 0.84 0.99 0.72
TF50
3 50.0 116.6 571 0.61 705 771 1.09 826 0.83
Effect of Number of Additional Bolts Outside Splice Plates … 1445
1200
1000
800
P (kN)
600
400
region was regarded to be yielded, applied load at the time was defined as Pyn−m.
When the strain at end portion reaches ey , the load at the time was defined as Pye.
As shown in Table 4 and Fig. 4, load carrying capacity of joint was influenced
by presence of a filler plate and its connection method. The slip coefficient and
maximum load of all cases with filler plate were the same as or larger than the case
“n3-NF” which has three bolts without a filler plate, and lower than the case
“n4-NF” which has four bolts without a filler plate. The load carrying capacity of
the joint with a tight filler was lower than a loose filler. The shear yield strength of
the former is lower than that of latter, so the difference of filler type affect the load
transfer mechanism of the joint with a filler plate.
Figure 5 shows load versus the strain of bolt shank curves, and Fig. 6 shows an
appearance of deformation of bolts after tensile tests. As can be seen in Table 4 and
Fig. 6, in all cases, confirmed failure mode in the test was bolt shear failure. But
number of shear failure plane was changed according to the presence of a filler
plate. The specimen “n3-NF” and “n4-NF” were broken mainly because of shear
force considering these deformation. On the other hand the joint with a filler plate
was broken because of bending moment and shear force. The additional bolt outside
splice plates in the tight filler type joint, wasn’t broken.
Figure 5 shows that the axial strain derived from the bending moment increases
as thickness of the filler plate becomes larger. In cases of tight filler type joint, the
additional bolt was not almost deformed and other bolts was more deformed instead
of it. Another influence of the tight filler is to make more shear deformation of “B1”
bolt which located near joint center considering the behaviour of the specimen
“n4-LF20” shown in Fig. 5. From these results, the load sharing ratio of “B1” bolt
was increased so that the shear yield strength of tight filler type joint is smaller than
loose filler type joint as shown in Table 4.
1446 H. Moriyama et al.
B1 2 3 B1 2 3 4 B1 2 3 4 B1 2 3 4
1.0
0.8
P / Pmax
n4- n4-
0.6 n4- n4- LF50
n4-NF TF50
LF20 LF20 B1
0.4 n3-NF B1 B1
B1 B1 B2
B1 B2 B2
B2 B2 B3
B2 B3 B3 B3
0.2 B3 B4
B3
B4
B4 B4 B4
ε=εy ε=εy ε=εy ε=εy ε=εy ε=εy
0.0
0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 2.4 0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 2.4 0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 2.4 0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 2.4 0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 2.4 0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 2.4
εbi / εybi (%) εbi / εybi (%) εbi / εybi (%) εbi / εybi (%) εbi / εybi (%) εbi / εybi (%)
3.3.1 FE Model
Herein, FEA was conducted with Abaqus/Standard 2018 [1] to investigate the effect
of number of additional bolts outside splice plates on the behaviour of the joint.
Figure 7 shows examples of FE model and Fig. 8 shows its boundary condi-
tions. The contact-separate-cohesive condition is applied in the faying surface
related to the friction. Since the dynamic friction can be considered in Abaqus only
when slip velocity is known, static friction with Coulomb’s model is only con-
sidered in this study. As shown in Fig. 8, the frictional coefficient between two
plates is 0.65 and it is 0.20 between a plate and washer.
Table 5 shows summary of each analysis cases. Thickness of splice plates and
connected plate in non-slip side are constant in all cases. The width of joint is
adjusted to make the ratio of net cross-section failure Ptnd by bolt shear failure Pbod
constant (Ptnd−m/Pbod = 0.72).
Table 6 shows the material properties of all component of joint based on
Japanese Specifications of Highway Bridges [2]. Figure 9 shows the stress-strain
curves. The constitutive law of bolt, nut and washer is tri-linear model, the law of
plates is multi-linear expressed by Eq. (7) by referring to JSCE specifications [3].
r 1 Est e est
¼ 1 exp nm þ1 ð7Þ
r y nm E ey ey
where; r is the nominal stress, e is the nominal strain, est is the strain when the
strain-hardening occurs, Est is the slope at e = est , nm is the material parameter.
Fixed
Cases
(ui and θi = 0, i = x, y, z) without Filler Pl.
Considering
F10T-M16 bolt
structural symmetry
Introduced Bolt
both in width direction and
Tensions = 116.6 kN
in longitudinal direction
μ = 0.65
σ (N/mm2)
600 6,667 1,625 11,375 0.06
500
400
300
200
Bolt, Nut, Washer
100
all plates
0
0 20,000 40,000 60,000 80,000 100,000
ε( 10-6)
Table 7 Summary of
numerical results
Slip Maximum
Analysis Load Load
Case Ps P max
(kN) (kN)
n1-NF 151 283
n2-NF 298 559
n2-LF20 308 533
n2-TF20-a1 154 276
n3-NF 448 854
n3-LF20 461 829
n3-LF20-a1 312 563
n3-LF20-a2 155 278
n4-NF 589 1,142
n4-LF20 613 1,090
n4-TF20-a1 467 859
n4-TF20-a2 312 556
n4-TF20-a3 153 275
Table 7 shows summary of numerical results. Figure 10 shows load sharing ratios
of splice plates. Horizontal axis shows the ratio of applied load by maximum load
confirmed in FEA, and vertical axis shows the ratio of cross-sectional force of a
splice plate by total cross-sectional force of them. Figure 11 shows Mises stress
1450 H. Moriyama et al.
56 LF20
Ni: Cross-sectional force (H)
of splice pl. (i = H or N) LF20
54 (N)
TF20-a1
52 (H)
TF20-a1
Ni / P
(N)
50 TF20-a2
(H)
TF20-a2
48 (N)
TF20-a3
(H)
46
TF20-a3
(N)
44 NF (H
0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 and N)
P / Pmax P / Pmax
(a) Total bolts n = 3 (b) Total bolts n = 4
(e) n4-TF20-a3
distributions at maximum load. As shown in Table 7 and Fig. 11, it’s understood
that additional bolts outside splice plates can hardly improve the resistance of joint
with filler plate, and only bolts inside splice plates resist applied load. On the other
hand, in cases of the joint with loose filler plate, their maximum load were almost
same as the joint without filler plate.
As shown in Fig. 10, the effect of additional bolts on the mechanical perfor-
mance of joint is to equalize the load sharing ratio of splice plates. Therefore, in
case that eccentric moment can’t be disregarded because change rate of thickness of
connected plate η is large, tight type filler may prevent failure of the splice plate
which is contacted with connected plate, that is, has more cross-sectional force than
the other one. And also by that, number of shear failure planes is increased from
Effect of Number of Additional Bolts Outside Splice Plates … 1451
one to two so that we can utilize the resistance of a bolt although the overall
resistance of the joint is determined only by bolts inside splice plates.
4 Conclusions
Tensile tests and FEA of high-strength frictional bolted joints with/without filler
plates were conducted to investigate these load transfer mechanism and the dif-
ference of performance between the joint with a loose and tight filler plate.
Obtained concluding remarks are as follows.
1) Load carrying capacity of joint such as slip coefficient, maximum load and shear
yield strength of the connected plate was decreased by presence of a filler plate
and its connection method. These strength of the joint with a tight filler was
lower than that with a loose filler.
2) The failure mode of all specimens was bolt shear failure. But number of shear
failure plane varied according to the presence of a filler plate. The joint without
it was broken mainly because of shear force, and the joint with it was broken
because of bending moment and shear force considering these appearance and
axial strain of bolts. As for the tight filler type joint, its additional bolt outside
splice plates wasn’t almost deformed and broken, and other bolts was more
deformed instead of it. Numerical analysis also shows the same results as tensile
tests.
3) From above results, it’s concluded that loose type filler is more preferably used
than tight type filler because additional bolts outside splice plates can hardly
contribute to the performance enhancement of the joint with a filler plate.
4) The effect of additional bolts on the mechanical performance of joint is to
equalize the load sharing ratio of splice plates. Therefore, in case that eccentric
moment can’t be disregarded because change rate of thickness of connected
plate η is large, tight type filler may prevent failure of the splice plate which is
contacted with connected plate. And also by that, number of shear failure planes
is increased from one to two so that we can utilize the resistance of a bolt
although the overall resistance of the joint is determined only by bolts inside
splice plates.
References
1 Introduction
Ultimate Load
Failure
Load P
νDuctility = δmax / x
Limited bolt hole deformation x = 10%
for Restoration Defining the ULS by the bolt hole
deformation which is deeply related to the
Ultimate Limit State (ULS) bearing force , we can manage the safety
: Deformed Bearing Limit State margin of resistance and ductility for
failure indirectly through the ultimate load.
Serviceability Limit State (SLS)
: Slip Limit State Displacement δ
In this study, tensile tests for high-strength frictional bolted joints consisted of
four bolts arrayed along two rows and columns, which varies the pitch and edge
distance, was conducted to clarify the relationship between these parameters and the
deformed bearing limit state.
2 Tensile Tests
2.1 Specimens
40 65 40 e p e
1 1
d
57
0
10
N S N S
S S
H TB H TB
18
g
120
120
136
4,5
w
N S
O2 N S
O1
8
S S
H TB H TB
57
9 9
2
m
9 9
t
t
Thickness Young's Modulus Poisson's Ratio Yield Stress Tensile Strength Yield Ratio Yield Strain
Steel
t E ν σy σt γ=σ y /σ t ε y =σ y /E
grade
(mm) (N/mm2) (N/mm2) (N/mm2) (×10-6)
SM490Y 9 208,000 0.283 382.8 503.8 0.76 1,841
The design slip resistance Psd and net cross-section yield resistance Pynd are cal-
culated by Eqs. (1) and (2) respectively. And also, the ratio of these resistance b,
which is related to the slip behaviour, is obtained by Eq. (3).
Psd
b¼ ð3Þ
Pynd
Bearing Limit State of High-Strength Frictional Bolted Joints … 1457
2.2.2 Ultimate Load and Expected Failure Mode (For Ultimate Limit
State)
rt
Psid ¼ Ant rt þ Ans ð6Þ
2
rt
Psod ¼ Ant rt þ Ans ð7Þ
2
ðk1 ab rt dtÞ
Pb Euro ¼ ð9Þ
cM
rt
ab ¼ min ad ; bolt ; 1:0 ð10Þ
rt
e1 e1 1
ad ¼ ; ð11Þ
3d0 3d0 4
2:8e2
k1 ¼ min 1:7; 2:5 ð12Þ
d0
where; RPb_Euro is the design bearing resistance of a row of joint, Pb_Euro is the
design bearing resistance per bolt, k1 is the parameter of bolt arrangement per-
pendicular to the direction of load transfer, ab is the parameter of bolt arrangement
in direction of load transfer, rt_bolt is the tensile strength of bolt, e2 is edge distance,
cM is the partial safety factor of joints.
Figure 4 shows measuring items and these measuring points. To evaluate the
overall bihaviour of joint, its displacement and the relative displacement between
connected plate and splice plates were measured. Investigating the strain distribu-
tions after major slip, the strain of the side surface of the connected plate was
measured. The bolt hole deformation was measured by using the device shown in
Fig. 5. Figure 6 shows the way of calculating the bolt hole deformation from the
relative displacement between the side surface of the connected plate and the bolt
Bearing Limit State of High-Strength Frictional Bolted Joints … 1459
CL
1 2 34 5 6 7 8
1-0 2e1+p+4.75d mm
(b) p / d = 4.0, 4.5
2.5d 2.5d 4.5d
CL 1.5d 1.5d 1.5d 1.875d
1 23 56 7 8
(a) p / d = 3.5
Relative displacement
P
after slip. The bolt tension is installed by referring to the strain of the bolt shank.
The tightened tensions is 10% higher than design bolt tensions shown in Table 3 by
considering the relaxation of faying surface with inorganic zinc-rich paint. The
experiment is carried out more than one week after tightening.
Obtained experimental results are summarized in Table 4, and load versus dis-
placement curves are shown in Fig. 7. Figure 8 shows failure modes of specimens
confirmed in this test.
As shown in Fig. 7, displacement of joint of maximum load was enhanced by
increasing the pitch. As for failure modes, the actual failure modes were same as the
expected failure modes in any cases. The behaviour before major slip was not
influenced by the pitch and edge distance.
Shear Net Cross- 10% Deformed 10% Deformed Maximum Maximum Load Ultimate
Yield Section Yield Bearing Bearing Load /Design Ultimate Bearing Limit
Expected Actual
Specimen Strength Strength Limit Stress Limit Strength Strengh Stress
Failure Failure
Name
Mode Mode
P ye /P max P yn /P max σ c10 /σ y P c10 /P max P max P max /P ud σ max /σ t
(kN)
p/d 3.5-e 2 /d 2.5 0.80 0.66 3.10 0.82 836 1.17 2.88 OS OS
p/d 3.5-e 2 /d 3.0 0.73 0.67 3.24 0.80 890 1.13 3.07 OS OS
p/d 3.5-e 2 /d4.0 0.73 0.79 3.12 0.82 837 1.11 2.88 IS IS
p/d 4.0-e 2 /d 2.5 0.75 0.69 3.19 0.82 857 1.14 2.95 OS OS
p/d 4.0-e 2 /d 3.0 0.73 0.74 3.19 0.77 908 1.11 3.13 N N
p/d 4.0-e 2 /d 4.0 0.74 0.87 3.15 0.83 842 1.07 2.90 IS IS
p/d 4.5-e 2 /d 2.5 0.73 0.66 3.25 0.81 885 1.12 3.05 OS OS
Bearing Limit State of High-Strength Frictional Bolted Joints … 1461
Figure 8 shows the failure modes confirmed through tensile tests. With the strain of
the side surface and the end portion of the connected plate, shear yield strength Pye
and net cross-section yield strength Pyn were evaluated. When the value of the strain
gauge reaches yield strain ey (= ry/E), its peripheral region was regarded to be
yielded. Comparing the ratio of these yield strength by maximum load in all
specimens, it’s understood that the ratio (Pye/Pmax, Pyn/Pmax) were related to the
failure modes of the connected plate. In case of inner block shear failure (IS),
Pye/Pmax is larger than Pyn/Pmax. In case of outer block shear failure, Pyn/Pmax is
larger than Pye/Pmax. In case of net cross-section failure (N), Pyn/Pmax is nearly the
same value as Pye/Pmax.
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
P/Pmax
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3 p/d3.5-e2/d2.5 p/d3.5-e2/d3.0 p/d3.5-e2/d4.0
0.2 p/d4.0-e2/d2.5
0.1 p/d4.5-e2/d2.5 p/d4.0-e2/d3.0 p/d4.0-e2/d4.0
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 0 5 10 15 20 25 30
δ(mm) δ(mm) δ(mm)
(a) Net cross-section (b) Inner Block Shear (c) Outer Block Shear
failure (F. M.: N) failure (F. M.: IS) failure (F. M.: OS)
The deformed bearing limit state is determined by the bolt hole deformation. When
the deformation of one of all bolt holes db reaches 10% diameter of bolt shank d, the
joint is judged in 10% deformed bearing limit state. The 10% deformed bearing
limit stress rc10 is calculated with nominal bearing area as expressed in Eq. (13).
Pc10
rc10 ¼ ð13Þ
n dtm
where; Pc10 is the applied load at 10% deformed bearing limit state, n is the number
of bolts, d is the nominal bolt diameter, tm is the thickness of the connected plate.
Figure 9 shows the relationship of the 10% deformed bearing limit stress rc10 and
dimensional parameters. The vertical axis shows the stress rc10 normalized by the
yield stress of connected plate. Circle and triangle plots present the experimental
results. The purple and orange colored lines present the normalized design bearing
resistance in EC3.
As shown in Fig. 9, the stress rc10 was more than three times of the yield stress.
In the case of e2/d = 2.5 and p/d = 4.5, rc10 is nearly the same as the design bearing
stress specified in EC3.
Figure 10 shows the strain distributions at P/Pmax = 0.80, 0.85. The color of plotted
data distinguishes the magnitude of e2/d, and the symbol of plotted data distin-
guishes the magnitude of p/d. As for measured points of No. 3 and No. 5, their
strains became larger as the pitch and edge distance increase. Especially about the
influence of edge distance, the strain at No. 3 and No. 5 points in case of e2/d = 4.0
is smaller than e2/d = 2.5 and 3.5. If the edge distance is smaller than 2.5d, it’s
assumed that the plastic area develops in width direction early, and so that the
failure modes become outer block shear failure.
Bearing Limit State of High-Strength Frictional Bolted Joints … 1463
Fig. 9 Deformed bearing limit stress (the data shows the average value of 3 specimens)
Fig. 10 Strain distributions of connected plate (the data shows the average value of 3 specimens)
1464 R. Sakura et al.
Table 5 shows safety margins of the resistance and ductility in 10% deformed
bearing limit state for failure. These safety margins mR and mD are calculated by
Eqs. (14) and (15).
0
max dbi
mD ¼ ð14Þ
maxðdbic10 Þ ¼ 0:1d
Pmax
mR ¼ ð15Þ
Pc10
where; dbi′ is the bolt hole deformation at maximum load, dbi-c10 is the bolt hole
deformation at 10% deformed bearing limit state.
As the pitch/the edge distance increases, each mR and mD become larger. The
overall displacement of the specimen “p/d4.0-e2/d3.0”, which mode was net
cross-section failure, was the largest. The overall displacement of the joint at the
maximum load was changed by its failure mode.
Although the maximum load and corresponding overall displacement of the
specimen “p/d4.0-e2/d4.0” is smaller than that of the specimen “p/d4.0-e2/d3.0”, the
strain of the specimen “p/d4.0-e2/d4.0” at each measured point became more
equally and its ductile safety margin mD was also higher than that of the specimen
“p/d4.0-e2/d3.0”. It is considered that the structural configurations of the specimen
“p/d4.0-e2/d4.0” is desirable.
Ductility and
Displacement Maximum Bolt
Resistance
of Joint Hole
for Failure Actual
Specimen at Maximum Deformation of
Failure
Name Load Maximum Load
Mode
δ max δ b-max νD νR
(mm) (mm)
p/d 3.5-e 2 /d 2.5 17.05 11.06 6.91 1.25 OS
p/d 3.5-e 2 /d 3.0 22.63 12.20 7.34 1.37 OS
p/d 3.5-e 2 /d4.0 20.01 11.70 7.31 1.37 IS
p/d 4.0-e 2 /d 2.5 19.16 11.43 7.14 1.33 OS
p/d 4.0-e 2 /d 3.0 27.69 11.72 7.33 1.36 N
p/d 4.0-e 2 /d 4.0 21.58 12.30 7.69 1.36 IS
p/d 4.5-e 2 /d 2.5 20.12 11.70 7.31 1.37 OS
Bearing Limit State of High-Strength Frictional Bolted Joints … 1465
4 Conclusions
In this study, tensile tests for high-strength frictional bolted joints consisted of four
bolts arrayed along two rows and columns, which varies the pitch and edge dis-
tance, was conducted to clarify the relationship between these parameters and the
deformed bearing limit state such as its stress and its safety margin of resistance and
ductility for the failure. Obtained concluding remarks are as follows.
1) The ratio of the yield strength by maximum load (Pye/Pmax, Pyn/Pmax) were
related to the failure modes of the connected plate. In case of inner block shear
failure (IS), Pye/Pmax is larger than Pyn/Pmax. In case of outer block shear failure,
Pyn/Pmax is larger than Pye/Pmax. In case of net cross-section failure (N), Pyn/Pmax
is nearly the same value as Pye/Pmax.
2) 10% deformed bearing limit stress rc10 was more than three times of the yield
stress of the connected plate in all cases. In case of e2/d = 2.5 and p/d = 4.5, that
is the specimen “p/d4.5-e2/d2.5”, its stress rc10 is the same as design bearing
stress of EC3. Therefore, number of bolts can be reduced by considering the bolt
arrangement to expect high bearing resistance and a certain bearing deformation
of bolt hole.
3) The strain at measured points No. 3 and No. 5 located at the net cross-section of
connected plate, become larger as the pitch and edge distance increase. The
influence of the edge distance on the strain distribution was larger than that of
pitch. It is concluded that, in the case that the edge distance is smaller than 2.5d,
the plastic area develops in width direction early, and the failure mode is outer
block shear failure.
4) As the pitch increases, the safety margins of the resistance and ductility at 10%
deformed bearing limit state for the failure, mR and mD became almost the same or
larger than their original values which case is “p/d3.5-e2/d2.5”. As the edge
distance increases, mR and mD were also enhanced.
5) Since strain distributions of the specimen “p/d4.0-e2/d4.0” became almost equal
at each measuring point, the ductile safety margin mD was the highest. It is
concluded that the specimen “p/d4.0-e2/d4.0” has one of the desirable structural
configurations from the viewpoints of the ductile safety margin mD and insen-
sitivity to the contact condition between a bolt and the bolt hole due to some
construction errors.
Acknowledgements This work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number JP18J15508.
1466 R. Sakura et al.
References
1. Japan Road Association (2012) Specifications for Highway Bridges, 2012.3 (in Japanese)
2. Može P, Beg D (2010) High strength steel tension splices with one or two bolts. J Constr Steel
Res 66:1000–1010
3. CEN, European Committee for Standardization (2005) Eurocode 3 Design of steel
structures-part1-8: design of joints, EN 1993-1-1, 2005.3
4. Japanese Industrial Standards Committee (2011) Metallic Materials-Tensile Testing-Method of
test at room temperature, JIS Z 2241
5. Architectural Institute of Japan (2012) Recommendation for Design of Connections in Steel
Structures
Experimental Research and Parametric
Study on the Fatigue Performance
of Slotted Tubular Connection Based
on the Effective Notch Stress Approach
Abstract The slotted circular hollow section (CHS) tube-to-plate welded joints are
extensively used in steel structures to connect CHS bracings to main members.
Nevertheless, brittle failure within the weld fatigue spot of this joint is still an
urgent issue. In this paper, fatigue experiments in the high cycle regime were
conducted on four large-scale specimens of slotted CHS tubular joints.
Subsequently, 162 test data from existing literature were collected and re-analyzed
with the effective notch stress approach (ENSA). Besides, a comprehensive para-
metric study was executed to determine the elastic notch stress concentration factor
(SCF) of the joints with various weld types and geometries. The results indicate that
the weld type is the most significant parameter affecting the fatigue behavior of this
joint. The notch S-N curve FAT 225 for the ENSA recommended by the
International Institute of Welding (IIW) is rather conservative for the fatigue
assessment of this joint. Finally, optimal structural solutions to reduce the notch
SCF at fatigue spot were recommended based on the parametric study.
Keywords Tubular connection Gusset plate Circular hollow section Fatigue
experiments Effective notch stress
Y. X. Luo (&) R. L. Ma M. J. He
Department of Structural Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, China
e-mail: luoyuxiao@yahoo.com
R. L. Ma
e-mail: marenle@tongji.edu.cn
M. J. He
e-mail: hemj@tongji.edu.cn
R. Fincato S. Tsutsumi
Joining and Welding Research Institute, Osaka University,
11-1 Mihogaoka, Ibaraki, Osaka 567-0047, Japan
e-mail: fincato@jwri.osaka-u.ac.jp
S. Tsutsumi
e-mail: tsutsumi@jwri.osaka-u.ac.jp
1 Introduction
Circular hollow sections (CHS) are extensively used as bracings in steel structures
owing to the excellent material utilization and relatively low drag coefficient.
Various slotted CHS tube-to-plate welded joints are applied to connect CHS
bracings to main members in practical projects as shown in Fig. 1. To achieve this
kind of joints, a gusset plate is inserted into the slits at the end of the CHS tube and
connected with weld seams. The fatigue behavior assessment of this type of joints is
of importance when the joints are subjected to cyclic loads in their service life, such
as in steel bridges and steel towers.
The weld around the tip of the gusset is one of the most critical fatigue spots of
this joint. Figure 2 shows the geometric details of this fatigue spot in three different
weld types. It is believed that the weld type has a significant effect on the fatigue
behavior of this joint. Besides, many geometric parameters influence the fatigue
behavior of this joint as well, such as the geometric shape of the gusset plate and the
tube (as shown in Fig. 1 A–I), the dimensional ratio of the gusset plate to the tube.
However, only a few experimental results can be found in literature. Zirn [6]
conducted a series of fatigue experiments on slotted tube-to-plate welded joints in
which configurations of geometric detail (Fig. 1 A–C, E), weld type and materials
were tested. Experimental results of the variant of the joints that commonly used in
transmission towers in Japan (Fig. 1 H–I) were reported by Harada and Kurobane
2 Experimental Procedure
Four sets of fatigue experiments on the CHS tube-to-plate welded joint with open
holes at the end of the slits were carried out. In order to meet the needs of a practical
project, L-shape sealing plates were fixed to the end of the CHS tube as shown in
Fig. 3. The open hole at the end of the slit was manufactured by drilling, and all the
specimens were fabricated by Q345-B steel with the yield strength of 345 MPa.
Full penetration weld was adopted as shown in Fig. 2 (weld type B). All the
weld seams were checked by roentgen ray, and sandblast was executed to both sides
of the gusset plate before the welding procedure.
In order to meet the special conditions of a practical project, in three of the four test
specimens, four long bolts were fixed inside the tubes and pre-stretched before the
fatigue test (see Table 1 No. 2–4). The actual nominal stress ranges and the
effective stress ratios for these three cases were computed in the CHS tubes inde-
pendently. The loading frequencies were kept at 4 Hz. Strain gauges were applied
on the critical fatigue spots of the specimens, 5% rate of change of the strain range
was considered to be the crack initiation life, and the observation of a large or
through-wall crack was taken as the failure of the specimens.
3 Results
Three crack patterns were found in experiments as shown in Fig. 4. Besides the
open hole at the slit end, the weld at the tube end (on gusset plate) is the other
critical fatigue spot (Fig. 4 (c)), especially for thin gusset plate cases.
Due to the limited number of specimens, the test results have no statistically
significance. Therefore, the test data were plotted with the results of the same
geometry (open hole at the slit end) by Baptista et al. [1]. In order to convert the
effective stress ratio to R = 0.1, the stress ranges were modified according to the
recommendations by the International Institute of Welding (IIW) [5] when plotting
the diagram. The crack on the hole edge (Fig. 4 (a)) and the crack on the weld seam
(Fig. 4 (b)) are regarded as category I and II defined by IIW [5] respectively when
converting the stress ratio.
(a) Crack at the hole edge (b) Crack at the weld end (c) Crack on the gusset
on the tube
Table 1 presents the test results. No crack was observed at the open hole on the
tube in No. 3 specimen before the gusset plate completely ruptured at 4 million
cycles. Figure 5 shows the other three test results after the conversion of stress ratio.
It can be seen from Fig. 5, the test results in this paper after the stress ratio
conversion are consistent well with the results by Baptista et al. [1]. A mean curve
FAT 55 with slope m = 3 was obtained by linear regression.
The specimens tested by Zirn [6] (L1–L3) and by Baptista et al. [1] (C1–C4) were
modeled and re-analyzed with the ENSA by means of 3D finite element method
Experimental Research and Parametric Study … 1473
(FEM). Table 2 presents the results of Kt at both the weld toe and the weld root.
The dimensions of the specimens refer to the literature (Zirn [6]; Baptista et al. [1]).
Figure 6 shows the typical stress distribution results at the weld toe and the weld
root.
Kt
Specimen Geometry Weld type
Toe Root
C1
8.3 5.2
tp =18mm
C2
5.5 (hole edge)
tp =18mm
C3
3.7 7.8
tp =18mm
C4
10.3 -
tp =18mm
L1
7.2 10.0
tp =15mm
L1
3.4 7.3
tp =15mm
L2 3.5 4.7
tp =15mm (outer toe) (inner toe)
L2
4.4 6.9
tp =10mm
L2
3.9 6.4
tp =15mm
L2
3.7 5.9
tp =20mm
L2*
3.7 6.0
tp =15mm
L3
8.3 10.4
tp =15mm
L3
4.7 6.0
tp =15mm
tp : the thickness of the gusset plate. Bold values represent the higher Kt
1474 Y. X. Luo et al.
(a) Weld toe (b) Weld root (filletweld) (c) Weld root (full penetration)
Fig. 6 Typical stress distribution results at the weld toe and the weld root
The results of Kt given in Table 2 are compared with the results computed by
Baptista et al. [1]. Although the Kt results for C1–C4 have a good agreement with
the results by Baptista et al. [1], notable differences are found in L1–L3. The Kt
results for L1–L3 by Baptista et al. [1] are much lower than that obtained in this
paper. Nevertheless, the crack locations in C1–C4 predicted by the results with the
highest Kt are consistent well with the crack locations reported by Baptista et al. [1].
It can be noticed that the weld type is the dominant parameter that influences the
Kt values most as listed in Table 2, fillet welds lead to significantly higher Kt value
than full penetration welds. The geometry of the joint also has an obvious effect on
Kt values. While the thickness of the gusset plate has only a slight effect on the Kt
values.
The fatigue test results by Zirn [6] and Baptista et al. [1] are plotted in the S-N
diagram in the nominal stress range in Fig. 7, in which the FAT 45 and the FAT 56
curve are the recommended design categories by Baptista et al. [1] for the fillet
welds and the full penetration welds respectively. Besides, based on the results of
the Kt obtained in this paper, the test results are plotted in the S-N diagram in the
notch stress range as well, see Fig. 8.
A contradiction can be noticed between Figs. 7 and 8, the joints with full
penetration welds become more disadvantageous based on the ENSA evaluation.
Nevertheless, the notch S-N curve FAT 225 with slope m = 3, which is recom-
mended by IIW [3] and considered to have 97.7% survival probability for steel
material, is rather conservative for the fatigue assessment of CHS slotted
tube-to-plate welded joints.
Besides the weld type and the plate thickness that has been discussed in Sect. 4.1,
other parameters also have non-negligible effects on the elastic notch SCF Kt of the
joints, such as the geometries of the gusset plate, tube chamfer, sealing plate and the
length of the weld seam. Baptista et al. [1] have discussed a part of the parameters
by the parametric study. Similarly, by means of 3D FEM, this paper executed a
series of numerical simulations to investigate the effects of various parameters on
the Kt values for both the fillet welds and the full penetration welds. The results are
displayed in Table 3.
From Table 3 it can be seen that the gusset chamfer has a beneficial effect on
decreasing the Kt only for the full penetration welds, no obvious effect was found
for the fillet welds. A sealing plate and the relatively long weld seam are the feasible
measures to decrease the Kt for both the fillet welds and the full penetration welds.
In addition, it is worth noting that the tube chamfer, which may have a beneficial
effect on reducing the stress concentration degree at the tube extremity on the gusset
(see Fig. 4 (c)), slightly increases the Kt at the weld around the tip of the gusset.
1476 Y. X. Luo et al.
Without gusset
3.3 8.6 7.2 10.8
chamfer
Without tube
3.6 7.2 7.0 10.3
chamfer
With Sealing
3.5 6.7 6.6 9.4
plate
lw
=0.7 3.7 9.3 7.9 12.4
D
lw
=1.4 3.7 7.8 7.3 10.8
Weld seam D
length lw
=2.1 3.6 7.3 7.0 10.1
D
lw
=2.8 3.5 7.0 6.9 9.8
D
*the specimen C3 tested by Baptista et al. [1] was chosen as the baseline model.
lw : the length of the weld seam
D: the diameter of the steel tube
5 Conclusions
Two fatigue critical spots were found in the experiments of the slotted CHS
tube-to-plate welded joints with open holes at the end of the slit. Based on the test
data in this paper and reported by Baptista et al. [1], a mean S-N curve FAT 55 with
slope m = 3 for this type of connections was obtained by linear regression.
The ENSA proved to be effective in predicting the crack locations, and the notch
S-N curve FAT 225 with slope m = 3 recommended by IIW [3] is rather conser-
vative for the fatigue assessment of this kind of joints. The joints with full pene-
tration welds are recommended. Besides, the sealing plate fixed to tube extremity,
the chamfer on the gusset plate, a relatively thick gusset plate and the relatively long
weld seam all have beneficial effects on decreasing the notch SCF at the welds
around the tip of the gusset.
Experimental Research and Parametric Study … 1477
References
1. Baptista C, Kannuna S, Pedro JO, Nussbaumer A (2017) Fatigue behaviour of CHS tubular
bracings in steel bridges. Int J Fatig 96:127–141
2. EN 1993 1-9 (2005) Eurocode 3: design of steel structures - Part 1-9: Fatigue. European
Committee for Standardization (CEN)
3. Fricke W (2012) IIW recommendations for the fatigue assessment of welded structures by
notch stress analysis: IIW-2006-09 Woodhead Publishing
4. Harada K, Kurobane Y (1982) Fatigue of welded tube to gusset plate joints applicable for use
in transmission towers. Trans AIJ 318:62–70 [in Japanese]
5. Hobbacher A (2009) IIW recommendations for fatigue design of welded joints and
components. Welding Research Council, New York
6. Zirn R (1975) Schwingfestigkeitsverhalten geschweißter Rohrknotenpunkte und
Rohrlaschenverbindungen, Ph.D. thesis, Universität Stuttgart. [in Germany]
Experimental Study of a Prefabricated
Steel Frame System
with Buckling-Restrained Braces
1 Introduction
In recent years, building and construction industry has been facing ever-increasing
challenges in safeguarding civil infrastructure against natural hazards like earth-
quakes. Conventional structural design approaches can no longer satisfy the needs
2 Experimental Design
In this study, the testing frames include three different specimens. The first two are
standard frames consisting of a BRB frame (BRBF) and an adjoining
non-moment-resisting frame. The difference between the two is the assembly of the
Experimental Study of a Prefabricated Steel Frame System … 1481
(a) Standard BRBF with non-moment resisting frame (b) Single BRBF
The frames were designed using software package SAP2000 in accordance with
the current Chinese seismic design provision [3]. The design dead load (DL) of the
floor is 3.68 kN/m2 and that of the roof is 2.94 kN/m2. The design live load (LL) is
2 kN/m2 for each floor. The design load combinations considered 1.2DL + 1.6LL.
Note that the selection of the beams and columns where also constrained by the
profile steel supplied by the manufacturer. Therefore, the availability of the steel
sections was also considered for the design. According to the above considerations,
the size and material properties of all members of the frame specimen are sum-
marised in Tables 1, 2 and 3.
This experiment employed the low cyclic loading method. The lateral cyclic load
was provided by MTS electro-hydraulic servo actuator which was fixed to the
reaction wall on one side and bolted to the top left of the frame on the other side.
The travel distance of the actuator is ±150 mm. The static vertical loads exerted at
the columns were applied through three hydraulic jacks. To ensure consistent
vertical loads during the horizontal motion of the frame, roller sliding blocks were
placed between the column top and the hydraulic jack. To achieve the fixed end
constraint for the boundary condition, the columns were welded to the ground
beams. The schematic of the experimental set up is presented in Fig. 3.
Experimental Study of a Prefabricated Steel Frame System … 1483
The first test was for BRBF-EF, and Dfe adopted 4.8 mm according to the numerical
prediction. In the initial stage of the loading process, there was no obvious phe-
nomenon observed in the testing frame. At Df = 28.8 mm, “popping” noises were
heard from the BRBs which could be from the internal concrete crushing.
Meanwhile, the steel core of BRBs began to display visible axial extension from the
bond preventing material, as shown in Fig. 4. From then, during the “push-pull”
actions, the extension and compression of BRB cores were constantly observed,
which implies adequate axial deformation capability of BRBs. Not surprisingly, no
noticeable yielding was observed in the beam, columns or gusset plates during the
entire loading process.
1484 Y. Xu et al.
At Df = 38.4 mm, KL1 connecting to the actuator started to show the tendency
of out-of-plane deformation. Therefore, in case when KL1 buckled, the test was
terminated at Df = 38.4 mm. After unloading, no visible plastic deformation was
observed in the test frame, implying sufficient ductility and energy-dissipation
capacity of the structural system.
The observations of the second test for BRBF-FF are very similar to those for
BRBF-EF. Dfe is identical to the first test. At Df = 33.6 mm, small, yet noticeable
out-of-plane rotation was found at the actuator, due to the tendency of buckling at
KL1. Then, the test was ended.
The third test was for the single BRBF. This test also adopted 4.8 mm as the
maximum elastic displacement for the loading. Similar to the first two cyclic
loading tests, crushing sound from BRB4 was heard when the horizontal dis-
placement Df reached 28.8 mm. It should be noted that the BRBs in the single
BRBF yielded at the same displacement with those in specimens BRBF-EF and
BRBF-FF. This is because the non-moment-resisting bays in BRBF-EF and
BRBF-FF provide very limited stiffness to the BRBF, therefore results in a simi-
larity of the structural behaviours of the three specimens. Subsequently, as the BRB
steel core was observed to be pulled out from the steel tube, the BRBs yielded
successively. The test ended when the displacement went up to 52.8 mm.
The finite element analysis software OpenSees [6] was used to predict the structural
behaviour of the three test specimens, i.e. BRBF-EF, BRBF-FF, and single BRBF.
In the OpenSees models, displacement-based beam-column elements “steel 01”
with fibre sections are used to simulate the beams and columns. A total of five
integration points are used in the element state determination. In order to account
Experimental Study of a Prefabricated Steel Frame System … 1485
for the material non-linearity, elastic-plastic bilinear behaviour is considered for the
beams and columns. Truss elements are used to model BRBs, and “steel 02”
material type with similar hysteretic behaviours in tension and compression [7] is
employed. To capture the geometric non-linearity, the P-d effects in the columns
and BRBs are taken into account. For the pin connections exhibiting zero rotational
stiffness, pairs of slave and master nodes are defined at the corresponding
beam-column connections and are connected using zero-length spring elements.
Note that for the numerical models of all three specimens, the columns were
assumed to be fully fixed to the ground. Furthermore, the numerical models for
BRBF-EF and BRBF-FF were identical as the beam-column connections (end-plate
connections for BRBF-EF and fin-plate connections for BRBF-FF) in the
non-moment-resisting bays were all assumed to be purely pinned, therefore the
non-moment-resisting bays provide no stiffness to the BRBF in the numerical
models.
Figures 5, 6 and 7 show the comparisons between the numerical values and the
experimental ones in the form of the overall hysteresis behaviour and skeleton
curve. Note that the energy dissipation and stiffness degradation capabilities can be
directly calculated from these curves. In these figures, the experimental base shear
force takes the value of the actuator force.
It can be observed from the hysteresis curves of the three tests (blue lines), that
the tensile force is always greater than the compressive force in a cyclic circulation.
This is possibly due to the slight loosening of the bolts connecting the actuator and
the tested specimen during the loading process. When the bolts were tightened up
again, the specimen might not have been placed back at the exact original position,
therefore led to the slight difference in tension and compression.
As illustrated in Figs. 5 (a) and 6 (a), the hysteresis behaviours of BRBF-EF and
BRBF-FF are very close to the ideal behaviour which displays stable and
non-degenerating loops. The amount of area enclosed by the hysteresis loops is
large and the loops follow approximately the same path for each of the higher
loading cycles.
Nevertheless, in the cyclic test for BRBF-EF, the supporting system was not
reinforced properly, which resulted in a slight out-of-plane rotation of the 2nd story
beam during pushing action. As can be seen in Fig. 5 (a), the hysteresis loop in the
first quadrant increases almost linearly when the displacement is greater than
9.6 mm, this is because the 2nd story beam started to slightly lean onto the sup-
porting system when being pushed at a relatively large force-displacement level.
This problem was corrected in the following tests. In Fig. 6 (a), the sudden change
in the first quadrant for BRBF-FF is due to the unexpected rotation of the actuator,
and when this happened, the test was terminated.
1486 Y. Xu et al.
While BRBF-EF and BRBF-FF displayed almost ideal hysteresis behaviour, the
single BRBF demonstrates slightly pinched hysteresis loops. Typically, pinched
hysteresis loops reflect the behaviour of a structure that have members buckled
when subjected to compressive loads. However, in the case of the single BRBF, the
pinched loops are not due to the buckling of members but are the result of the
change in stiffness due to the deformation of the BRBs after yielding.
It can be seen from the skeleton curves obtained from the tests of the three
specimens (Figs. 5 (b), 6 (b) and 7 (b)), except that the actuator rotated at the end of
the test for BRBF-FF, there is no decrease found in the curves. This implies that
there was no strength degradation in tension or compression for the specimens
throughout the tests. Note that all three tests reached point A where the elastic
deformation is 4.8 mm. However, none of the tests reached point B due to the
capacity limitation of the experimental equipment.
All the skeleton curves demonstrate a clear bilinear behaviour differentiating the
elastic and plastic stages by Dfe = 4.8 mm. The actual base shear forces for
Specimens BRBF-EF, BRBF-FF and single BRBF when BRB started yielding (the
structural behaviour entered the plastic stage) are 135 kN, 140 kN and 155 kN,
respectively, which are very close to the numerical prediction. Also in Figs. 5, 6
and 7, the numerical model predicts slightly larger displacements than those
observed in the tests, this is due to the assumed infinitely rigid boundary conditions
in the numerical model.
For the analysis results presented, only flexural and axial deformations are
considered. The imperfections of the experimental setup is also believed to con-
tribute to the discrepancies to a certain extent. Furthermore, as the instantaneous
horizontal actuator forces obtained from the tests are only approximate, especially
for the later cycles, the correlation of the numerical and experimental results is
considered to be satisfactory.
Fig. 7 Comparison between experimental and numerical results for the single BRBF
j þ Fi j þ jFi j
Ki ¼ ð1Þ
j þ Xi j þ jXi j
where ±Fi are the maximum base shear forces (actuator forces) in loop i, ±Xi are
the maximum displacements in loop i.
The Ki values are calculated for each loop of the tests and numerical analyses for
all three specimens, and are summarised in Table 4. It can be observed that the
numerically predicted horizontal secant stiffnesses for BRBF-EF and BRBF-FF
systems are slightly larger than that of the single BRBF as expected. However the
test results show smaller stiffnesses especially for BRBF-EF, which could be due to
the pin connections in the non-moment resisting bay not being fully tightened,
thereby causing frictions at the pin joints. Such a phenomenon was less obvious in
the later loading cycles because the increased applied load became more dominant.
1488 Y. Xu et al.
5 Conclusions
References
1. Black CJ, Makris N, Aiken ID (2004) Component testing, seismic evaluation and
characterization of buckling-restrained braces. J Struct Eng 130:880–894
2. Blismas N, Pasquire C, Gibb A (2006) Benefit evaluation for off-site production in
construction. Constr Manage Econ 24:121–130
3. GB50011 (2010) Code for seismic design of buildings. China Building Industry Press, Beijing
4. Jaillon L, Poon C-S (2008) Sustainable construction aspects of using prefabrication in dense
urban environment: a Hong Kong case study. Constr Manage Econ 26:953–966
Experimental Study of a Prefabricated Steel Frame System … 1489
5. JGJ/T 101 (2015) Specification for seismic test of buildings. Ministry of Housing and
Urban-Rural Development of the People’s Republic of China, Beijing
6. McKenna F, Mazzoni S, Scott MH, Fenves GL (2006) OpenSees command language manual.
Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center, University of California, Berkeley, vol 264
7. Uriz P, Mahin S (2008) Toward earthquake-resistant design of concentrically braced
steel-frame structures. PEER rep no. 2008/08, Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research
Center, College of Engineering, University of California, Berkeley
8. Xie Q (2005) State of the art of buckling-restrained braces in Asia. J Constr Steel Res 61:727–
748
9. Xu Y, Guan H, Zhou XJ, Loo YC (2015) Preliminary seismic analysis of fabricated steel frame
systems with pin beam-column connections and buckling restrained braces. In: International
conference on performance-based and life-cycle structural engineering, Brisbane, Australia,
09–11 December 2015, pp 768–775
Automatic Optimal Design of Steel
Modular Buildings Under Different
Wind Load Levels
Abstract The modular structure is ideal for buildings with repeatable units as its
advantages of the reduced on-site construction schedule, improved quality, and
reduced environmental impacts. The design of modular structure doesn’t need to be
the same as the traditional structural design which adopts the process of trial and
error methodology to try to search a “feasible solution” that satisfies the structural
design criteria. In this paper, an automatic optimal design method is developed for
steel modular buildings. The proposed design method integrates computer tech-
nology and advanced optimal method into engineering practice to make the
structural design of steel modular buildings automatically, quickly, and accurately
under different wind load levels. The critical components are firstly indicated by
redundancy and sensitivity analysis results, and the optimal design results are then
obtained by the iteration procedure. This study realized the proposed design method
by coding a program. The design results of a steel frame structure obtained by
traditional design method and the automatic optimal design method developed in
this paper are compared to show the accuracy and efficiency of the automatic
optimal design method.
1 Introduction
Modular building refers to the building is divided into a number of space modules,
all the equipment, pipelines, decoration, fixed furniture have been done. The
modular building is ideal for buildings with repeatable units as its advantages of the
reduced on-site construction schedule, improved quality, and reduced environ-
mental impacts. In the face of the increasing shortage of urban land, the demand for
high-rise modular buildings is becoming more and more urgent.
In China, there is a correlation between wind load and construction site. Because
of its small lateral stiffness, the modular steel structure will be controlled by the
horizontal load in structural design with the increase of structural height. That
means the wind resistance design become one of the key points of the modular
structural design.
Traditional structure design usually adopts the process of modeling-analysis-
calculation-artificial modify to try to search a “feasible solution” that satisfied the
structural design requirements. This process is complex and inefficient. As the
components of modular buildings are standardized. It’s convenient to integrate
computer technology and advanced optimal method into engineering practice to
make the structural design of steel modular buildings automatically, quickly, and
accurately under different wind load levels, which is advance research in the field of
engineering structure design.
Previous studies are mainly through the study of artificial optimal methods.
Dong Y.M proposed an optimal design for the structure lateral system of super tall
buildings under multiple constraints [2]. Cao B.F developed a multilevel con-
strained optimal structural design method for reinforced concrete tall buildings [1].
Ma H.J offered an integrated optimal design method by adding supplement
damping technology-reverse toggle brace damper (TBD) system [3]. The sensi-
tivities of wind-induced acceleration on design variables of typical structural
members for super tall buildings was addressed [5]. Sensitivity analysis based
optimization method to optimize structures subject to story drift constraint under
earthquake action was studied [4].
Base on wind resistance optimal design theory, this paper proposes an automatic
optimal design of steel modular buildings under different wind load levels, A
ten-stories plane frame structure is exemplified in this paper to illustrate the char-
acteristics and advantages of the method.
2 Structure
Modular steel structure members include floor beam, roof beam, side column,
middle column and brace, all components are standardized components. The same
kind of components in a structure usually have the same peripheral size, and the
thickness of components can decrease along with the vertical height of the structure.
Automatic Optimal Design of Steel Modular Buildings… 1493
The size of the module can be customized. In general, the length of the module is
6 m, the width is 3.5 m (ultra-wide)/3 m/2.4 m, the height is 3.2 m (suitable for
central air conditioning)/3 m (suitable for common air conditioning), and the dis-
tance from the middle column to the side column is 1.5 m. Standard module A is
the basic module with no brace which is suitable for free space layout. Standard
module B adds middle columns and braces on the basis of standard module A,
which is suitable for the case that the stiffness of the structure is insufficient and
haven’t too many requirements for space layout. Module A and module B can be
arranged flexibly according to the overall model stiffness. The two basic modules of
the modular steel structure are shown in Fig. 1.
3 Theoretical Basis
In the optimal design based on sensitivity analysis, the order of constraint opti-
mization should be selected first. There are many constraints in the design of a
structure, which can be divided into global constraints, assembly constraints,
component constraints, sectional constraints and detailing constraints. If the con-
straints satisfy the requirements of the standard, ascend the constraint. Otherwise,
the constraints are further optimized as driven constraints until all of the constraints
satisfy the requirements of the standard. As shown in Fig. 2.
After that, the redundancy is a measure of the margin of a performance metric to
the design standard limits, which needs to be calculated to determine whether the
When Dvk tends to 0, the formula (1) can be expressed as a formula (2):
where ski refers to the sensitivity coefficient of i-th constraint on the k-th design
variable; gi refers to the value of i-th constraint; vk refers to the value of k-th design
variable.
Constraint sensitivity can be solved by virtual work based sensitivity method,
which use the principle of virtual work to deduce the explicit relation between
design variables and constraints. According to the principle of conservation of
energy, the external work is equal to the internal energy, the relationship between
the optimization variables and story drift angle is first established, which can be
realized by the principle of virtual work, such as the Eqs. (3).
ZLbi
FX fX FY fY F fZ MX mX MY mY MZ mZ
edi ¼ ð þ þ Z þ þ þ Þ dx
EA GAY GAZ GIX EIY EIZ i ð3Þ
0
ðBeam, columnÞ
where Lbi refers to the length of the i-th beam and column elements, FX , FY , FZ ,
MX , MY , MZ refer to the internal forces of the element under external loads; fX , fY ,
fZ , mX , mY , mZ refer to the internal force of the element under the virtual load; A
refers to the cross section area of beam and column element; AY and AZ refer to the
shear area of beam and column elements; IX , IY and IZ refers to the torsion and
bending moment of beam and column under inertia force.
If the optimization model is statically determinate, the change of the structural
constraint is equal to the change of the internal energy of the i-th element, The
sensitivity coefficient (SIdi ) of the i-th element can be defined as follow:
dd dedi
SIdi ¼ ¼ ð4Þ
dvoi dvoi
Automatic Optimal Design of Steel Modular Buildings… 1495
Fig. 3 Optimization
strategies
Aa Ba Aa Ba
a+ status a- status
In order to reduce the number of reanalysis and improve the efficiency of cal-
culation, the a simplified sensitivity coefficient of story drift is defined [2] as follow:
edi
SSIdi ¼ ð5Þ
voi
After calculating the sensitivity coefficient SSI of the component, the opti-
mization strategy is shown in Fig. 3. Status a+ refers to that the structure is
under-constrained and a- refers to the structure is over-constrained. Aa indicates
those components that are sensitive to the controlling constraint and Ba indicate
those components that are insensitive to the controlling constraint. Black up arrow
means increase corresponding components and black down arrow means decrease
corresponding components.
The design of
component constraint
Satisfied
Output
In this paper, the CCACD process judged the compliance of each component at the
component constraint through the iteration, so that the whole building components
satisfied the component constraints.
Then, the structure enters the global constraint automatic design (GCAD) pro-
cess based on the redundancy analysis method, ascending order constraint theory,
sensitivity analysis method and single driven constraint optimal strategy, which
including redundancy analysis under wind load, the global constraint automatic
optimal design (GCAOD) process and the global constraint automatic compliant
design (GCAPD) process. By considering the convergence of the optimal strategy.
The sensitivity analysis of GCAPD calculate the sensitivity index of the whole
structural components, However, the sensitivity analysis of GCAOD only calcu-
lates the sensitivity index of the beam and column components of the calculated
story.
The GCAD can design the structure under different wind load levels by entering
different wind load parameters automatically. Combine all of them, the automatic
optimal design of steel modular buildings under different wind load levels process
is shown in Fig. 5.
Automatic Optimal Design of Steel Modular Buildings… 1497
Start
Structural analysis
Compliance Design of
component constraint
Redundancy analysis of
story drift under wind load.
Grouping by redundancy
Yes Yes
Fig. 5 The automatic optimal design of steel modular buildings under different wind load levels
process
4 Case Study
In this case, a 10-story plane steel frame structure is selected. The height of the
structural model layer is 3 m, the bay is 3.5 m, the depth is 6 m. The beam uses
rectangular steel pipe, the column selects square steel pipe, the connection of
structural and ground are hinges. The beam element model is used to simulate each
component element, and the shear deformation is not considered. The seismic
action is 6° (0.05 g), and the wind load is taken as the larger load to ensure the wind
load as the control load. The calculate parameters is shown in Tables 1a and 1b.
1498 J. C. Guo and X. Zhao
3m
3.5m 6m
Fig. 6 10-story plane steel frame structure diagram and modular unit
Table 6 The comparison between automatic optimal design and manual design
Contrast option Automatic optimal design method Manual design method
Time usage 30 s 1.5 h
Total cast (yuan) 67185 76315
Cost difference 11.96%
Automatic Optimal Design of Steel Modular Buildings… 1501
Based on the automatic optimal design of steel modular buildings under different
wind load levels process, the design results are obtained by realizing the design
automation. The results of optimal sections and redundancy are shown in Tables 4
and 5.
The results of comparison between automatic optimal design and manual design
are shown in Table 6:
The time usage of automatic optimal design is much lower than that of manual
design method, and the result of automatic optimal design is also lower than the
result of manual design method.
5 Conclusions
References
1. Cao BF (2015) Optimal design for reinforced concrete structure of tall building under multiple
constraints, Tongji University
2. Dong YM (2015) Optimal design for structure lateral system of super tall buildings under
multiple constraints, Tongji University
3. Ma HJ, Zhao X (2016) Performance based optimal human comfort design of
toggle-brace-damper system for super tall buildings. In: IABSE conference Guangzhou
2016, pp 481–488
1502 J. C. Guo and X. Zhao
4. Qin L, Zhao X (2016) Sensitivity analysis based optimal seismic design of tall buildings under
story drift constraint. In: Proceedings of IABSE conference on bridges and structures
sustainability: seeking intelligent solutions, pp 873–880
5. Zhao X, Jiang X (2015), Sensitivity analysis of wind-induced acceleration on design variables
for super tall buildings. In: Proceedings of IABSE conference on structural engineering:
providing solutions to global challenges, pp 593–599
Instability of Metal Scaffold
with and Without Settlement
1 Introduction
S. H. Lo J. L. Y. Chan (&)
Department of Civil Engineering, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Road, Pokfulam,
Hong Kong
e-mail: lokychan@hku.hk
S. H. Lo
e-mail: hreclsh@hku.hk
imperfection, yield stress and load eccentricity on the structural strength of steel
scaffolding structures were investigated by Zhang and Rasmussen et al. Zhao and
Chen investigated studied the influence of screw jack stiffness and found that the
influence is larger for pinned-fixed condition compared to free-fixed condition. The
influence is also found to be negligible for scaffold systems more than two stories.
The reliability of numerical analytical approach considering the P-d and P-D effects
with notional disturbance force was proven to be quite consistent with full-scale test
results by an acceptable margin of 11.08% with 3-story and 2-story metal scaffolds
connected by couplers by the works of Liu and Jia et al. Increasing a 2-story
single-row steel scaffold from 1 bay to 4 bays also improved the load-carrying
capacity by up to 2.3 times as reported by the Pang and Wang et al. The lowest
Eigen-buckling mode of scaffold systems by rigorous computer simulation multi-
plied by the P-D effects to account for complex geometrical imperfections of
irregular scaffold structures are reported by Chu et al. The Eigen-buckling approach
was integrated into P-D effects of the scaffold models studied in this paper. A brief
discussion on the analysis and design method is given here for determining the
design failure load of scaffolds. DA has been used by the authors in design of
various scaffolds in Hong Kong with great success. Nearly all failed scaffolds,
although infrequent in Hong Kong, were designed by other methods like the ELM
and test-based approach where the load capacity was taken directly from test of
scaffolds with similar height.
In order to establish a simple soil spring model compatible with Direct Analysis
(DA), a perfectly elastic spring was used in this paper as shown in Fig. 1. A model
for elastic soil which accounts for the behavior of both the foundation and soil was
developed by Winkler. The model as a simplified mathematical formulation
describes a system of mutually independent elastic springs represents the soil
beneath the foundation. This formulation assumes a homogeneous pressure zone
within the soil layer which ignores the deeper soil interaction known as the bulb
pressure for simplification. An elastic model based on model was developed by
Vesic which introduced the elastic parameters of soils as well as the shape factor of
the foundation (Ip). The stiffness matrix of a beam on single parameter foundation
is derived based of displacement shape functions or differential equations governing
the behavior. An infinite beam under a concentrated load resting over the foun-
dation of an elastic continuum was studied by Biot. Shear interaction between
adjacent soil medium may exist in reality and was omitted in this paper to simplify
the process.
Instability of Metal Scaffold with and Without Settlement 1505
Fig. 1 a Typical soil spring stiffness; b Soil spring model for the current study
3 Parametric Studies
This section covers the analytical results to the investigation of several design
parameters on the failure load of a wide range of freestanding and putlog scaffolding
systems as shown in Fig. 2 and Table 1. The findings are important in assessing
whether or not engineers can rely on manufacturer’s performance data or to carry
out their own design analysis using Direct Analysis.
1506 S. H. Lo and J. L. Y. Chan
and loading capacity are found to suffer by 40% compared to the smaller structure
Type 1A. Furthermore, with weaker soil and larger settlement area, the degree of
reduction would likely be much greater, as indicated by Type 4 scaffold system.
Meanwhile, Type 5 and 6 scaffolding systems with a soil stiffness of 7840 kN/m
(loose gravel) was used throughout the investigation. An overall spring-to-support
ratio of 40% was adopted. It is noted from the Eigen-buckling analysis that set-
tlement in the middle bays of the plan for Type 5 did not resulted in its weakest
mode due to the counter-weight effect.
The load-displacement graphs reveal that a taller Type 5 or Type 6 structure
would result in a lower overall stiffness compared to their shorter counterparts, with
their loading capacities slightly affected (less than 5% difference). However, Type 6
Instability of Metal Scaffold with and Without Settlement 1509
The influence of partial settlement on putlog scaffolding systems with height pro-
files between 5.79 m and 23.16 m is investigated. Lateral restrains are introduced
for the putlog scaffolding systems to prevent out-of-plane movement while vertical
and sideway movements are allowed. Such arrangement is considered safe to the
design of typical putlog scaffolding systems by assuming lateral stability of scaffold
being derived strictly from diagonal bracing members on the scaffolding system
rather than the putlog-wall interaction.
In general, a reduction in failure pressure ranging between 8% to 12.3% based
on DA is noted for a Type 2 scaffolding system with partial settlement. However,
such reduction for ELM is noticeably larger, with a range between 19% to 34.5%.
The stress distribution for Type 2 scaffolding systems with partial settlement is less
uniform, as first yielding occurred in only one of the stand column as opposed to
simultaneously on four stand columns for system without partial settlement.
A nonlinear relationship between lateral displacement and loading can be
observed for Type 2 scaffold systems of various heights with ground settlement. For
Type 3 systems, the portion of settlement is again set at 50% of the total number of
supports with a soil spring stiffness k1 of 4000 kN/m. The scaffold front length
increases from 7 to 15 bays while the height is fixed to 5.79 m (the height of 3
stacked scaffold units).
A uniform distribution between the number of horizontal bays and the pressure
at failure was observed. A larger span created a larger maximum bending moment
at the middle span compared to a smaller span. This causes the larger structure to
yields under a smaller load. The reduction in structure’s overall stiffness for more
bays also suggests a weaker structure.
1510 S. H. Lo and J. L. Y. Chan
4 Conclusions
4. ELM cannot cater for the behaviour of second order effects due to partial settle-
ment and could underestimate the actual effective length of scaffolding systems.
For scaffolds of lower stories, the effective length assumption of 2xLoriginal leads
to acceptable results. For scaffolds of higher stories, the actual Leff could only be
calculated by DA. Without settlement, the error of under design was up to 53.6%
based on ELM.
References
1. Andresen J (2012) Investigation of a collapsed scaffold structure. Proc Inst Civil Eng Forensic
Eng 165(FE2):95–104
2. Biot MA (1934) A Fourier-integral solution of the problem of the bending under a
concentrated load of an infinitely long beam resting on an elastic continuum. In: Proceedings
fourth international congress applied mechanics
3. Chu AYT, Zhou ZH, Koon CM, Chan SL, Peng JL, Pan AD (1996) Design of steel
scaffolding using an integrated design and analysis approach. In: Proceedings of the first
international conference on advances in steel structures, Hong Kong, pp 245–250
4. Rasmussen JR, Zhang X (2016) Beam-element-based analysis of locally and/or distortionally
buckled members. Thin-Wall Struct 98:285–292
5. Hongbo L, Jia L (2016) Experimental and theoretical studies on the stability of steel tube–
coupler scaffolds with different connection joints. Eng Struct 106:80–95
6. Peng J-L, Wang C-S (2017) Stability of independent heavy-duty scaffolds: an experimental
study. Adv Steel Constr 13(4):318–342
7. Vesic AB (1961) Beam on elastic subgrade and the winckler’s hypothesis. In: Proceedings of
5th international conference on soil mechanics and foundation engineering, vol 1, pp 845–850
8. Winkler E (1867) Die Lehre Von Elasticitaet Und Festigkeit, 1st edn. H. Dominicus, Prague
9. Yu WK, Chan KF, Chan SL (2002) Structural stability of modular steel scaffolding systems.
In: Proceedings of the second international conference of stability and dynamics, Singapore,
pp 418–423
10. Yu WK, Chung KF, Chan SL (2004) Structural instability of multi-storey door-type modular
steel scaffolds. Eng Struct 26(7):867–881
11. Zhao ZW, Chen ZH (2016) Analysis of door-type modular steel scaffolds based on a novel
numerical method. Adv Steel Constr 12(3), 316–327
Experimental and Numerical Analysis
on the Mechanical Behaviour
of Box Beam Cold-Formed Steel
Built-up C-Sections
Abstract The box beam composed of two face-to-face C-section beams is getting
popular in the cold-formed steel construction due to its advantage in strength.
However, at present, no clear design rules are available for this type of built-up box
beam. In this study, the mechanical behaviour of this box beam built-up C-section
is investigated both experimentally and numerically. The finite element model using
ABAQUS is conducted to verify experimental results. Four connection spacings are
considered for each of the five C-sections, and thus 20 built-up beams are tested.
Keywords Cold-formed steel Built-up box beam Face-to-face C-sections
Moment capacity Connection spacing
1 Introduction
The structural behaviour of cold-formed steel beams has been studied for a long
time. Yu and Schafer [3, 4] did a series of bending tests on CFS C- and Z-section
beams to deal with distortional buckling and local buckling phenomena. Wang and
Zhang [5] carried out a numerical and experimental study on the behaviour of
various C-section beams with different edge stiffeners subjected to bending. The
results revealed that the beam strength is greatly affected by the edge stiffener. Laím
et al. [6] conducted a series of bending test and numerical analysis of CFS beams,
including box beams.
The increasing use of the CFS beam is a direct result of continuing research.
Wang and Young [7] studied the flexural behaviour of cold-formed steel built-up
box beam composed of two face-to-face plain sections with circular web holes
about failure modes and the moment capacities. The test and numerical results were
compared with the strength calculated by the direct strength method given in North
American Specification AISI Standard [8, 9]. Wang and Young [10] investigated
the local buckling and/or distortional buckling behavior of the built-up closed
sections with intermediate stiffeners using self-tapping screws located at web or
flange. Wang and Young [11] presented the influence of different screw arrange-
ments on the behaviour of cold-formed steel built-up box beams. The study indi-
cated that the screw spacing affected significantly on the moment capacities of those
beams.
Currently, no clear design rules are available for this type of built-up box beam
(Australian/New Zealand Standard [12], AISI Standard [8, 9]). There have been a
lot of researches about the built-up box. However, the research about the connection
method, such as the connection spacing, is somewhat limited. Therefore, the
objective of this research is to propose a design method for a box beam composed
of two face-to-face CFS C-section beams. The impact of connection spacing on the
beam’s strength is primarily investigated.
2 Experimental Investigation
Five different C-sections shown in Table 1 are employed in this study. Variables in
the table are defined in Fig. 1.a. Two identical C-sections form a box section, as
illustrated in Fig. 1.b. A thin batten plate with the length of 80 mm, the width of
80 mm and the thickness of 1.9 mm is screwed to the top and bottom flanges of the
box beam, respectively, to fasten the C-section beams intermittently. Four 4.8 mm
self-drilling screws are used for each batten plate (Figs. 1.b and 2).
Experimental and Numerical Analysis on the Mechanical Behaviour … 1515
Fig. 1 Cross-section
The overall length of the beam specimen is 4000 mm, and the distance between
the centers of two bearings is 3800 mm. The distance between the center of the
outer batten plate on the bottom side and the outer end of the beam is always
250 mm because the screwed connection can’t be placed right on the bearing. Four
different spacings between the adjacent screwed connections are considered. The
center-to-center spacings in the four cases are L/2 (1750 mm), L/3 (1167 mm), L/4
(875 mm) and L/6 (583 mm), respectively. The schematic of the box-beam spec-
imen with the connection spacing of L/6 is presented in Fig. 3.
With the five C-sections and the four connection spacings, 20 box beam spec-
imens are experimentally conducted for this study. The specimens are listed in
Table 2.
1516 V. T. Trung et al.
Fig. 3 The schematic of the box-beam specimen with connection spacing of L/6
At the beginning, a small load is applied for the beam specimen to settle in the
position. The load is then increased gradually. The vertical and horizontal dis-
placements are measured at Cross-section M shown in Fig. 3 and recorded together
with the load. Linear variable displacement transducers (LVDTs; Nos. 8 and 9) are
used for measuring the displacements at Cross-section M. As shown in Fig. 3,
Cross-section M is located 100 mm away from the mid-span.
Tensile coupon tests are carried out, following the procedure specified in the
Australian Standard Australia Standard [13]. The following values of the yield
strength Fy have been obtained: 536 MPa for the thickness of 1.2 mm, 504 MPa for
1.5 mm, 510 MPa for 1.9 mm, and 484 MPa for 2.4 mm. The yield strengths
obtained are all larger than the respective minimum yield strengths given in
Material Specification from NS BlueScope Lysaght (Thailand) Limited [14].
Table 2 reveals that the connection spacing influences on the mechanical behaviour
of the built-up box beam considerably. As the spacing becomes smaller, the
strength PEXP increases. The exception is observed in the result of the C15024
series of box beams: the strength of C15024-L4 is 48.70 kN while that of
C15024-L3 is 50.61 kN, of the C10012 series: the strength of C10012-L4 is 8.55
kN while that of C10012-L3 is 8.69 kN. In all the other tests, the shorter spacing
has resulted in a larger strength.
Failure modes are also influenced by connection spacing. The basic failure
modes associated with the CFS C-section beam are lateral–torsional buckling
(LTB), local buckling (LB) and distortional buckling (DB). The three modes are
illustrated schematically in Fig. 5. Indeed, the test beams have failed in those
modes. But pure DB didn’t occur. It tended to go with LB, resulting in the mixed
mode of DB and LB. DB + LB in Table 2 indicates this mixed-mode failure.
Figure 6 presents the typical failures observed in the experiments.
1518 V. T. Trung et al.
(a) Lateral–torsional buckling (LTB) (b) Local buckling (LB) (c) Distortional buckling (DB)
Table 2 shows that the beam fails in LB when the connection spacing is equal to
or less than L/4. For a larger spacing, the beam undergoes DB + LB or LTB except
for C15024-L3 that fails in LB. The connection spacing influences the failure mode
then changes in strength. The connection spacing becomes smaller, the two
C-section beams tend to behave together, increasing the member stiffness and thus
failing not in the member buckling but rather locally.
The change in the failure mode is also recognized in the load-displacement
curve. For example, Fig. 7 shows the experimental results of the C20019 series of
box beams. When the connection spacing is large, horizontal displacement starts
increasing nonlinearly at a very early stage of loading. At the failure, Cross-section
M has displaced over 30 mm horizontally. The vertical displacement also starts
deviating from the linear response at an early stage in case of the beams with large
connection spacing. On the other hand, for the box beams with the smaller spacings
(L/4 and L/6), the horizontal displacement was very small until failure (less than
3 mm); the load-displacement relationship is almost linear up to the failure. The
load-displacement curve is thus another evidence for the influence of the connection
spacing on the failure mode.
All the experimental results prove that the connection spacing of L/4 would have
two face-to-face C-section beams fastened sufficiently.
3 Numerical Analysis
C-sections and stiffening plates were modelled with shell elements (S4R). Based on
Kirchhoff theory, when one dimension was very small compared with the other two
dimensions, the shell element is recommended for the calculation process. Load
bearing plates and support bearing plates were modelled by using solid elements
(C3D8R).
Material nonlinearity (plasticity) was considered for the CFS C-sections profile.
A yield strength and a Young’s Modulus were obtained from the coupon test.
Elastic stress-strain was considered for the stiffening plate because there was no
failure at the stiffening plate during the testing process. Besides, the material
properties for load bearing plates and support bearing plates were assumed as rigid
steel with the value of Young’s Modulus equal to one thousand times greater than
that of normal steel. The elastic modulus of steel was equal to 208 GPa and the
Poisson’s ratio to 0.3.
Based on the set-up of the test beam, all beams were simulated through a
three-dimensional numerical model. All components included the beams, the beam
support system, the loading system and the screws were modelled with high
accuracy in the ABAQUS simulations, as shown in Fig. 8.
Since there was no failure at the screw connection during the test, so the function
fastener in ABAQUS Faridmehr et al. [16] was used to represent the screws to be
simple in the calculation process. The contact between two lips of both C-sections,
load-bearing plate with the beam, and C-sections with the support bearing plate
were also defined in the modelling analysis.
Each of the models was analysed in two steps. Firstly, linear buckling analysis was
performed to get the buckling shape (eigenvectors). The buckling shape has been
used to represent initial imperfection shape with scale factors. Mode 1 in the
analysis was taken to be the mode shape. Then, general material and geometrical
nonlinear static analysis with imperfections were conducted to simulate the struc-
tural behaviour of CFS built-up box beam.
The ultimate load and main failure mode of cold-formed steel beam obtained from
numerical analysis are compared with test results, as summarized in Table 3. It is
seen that the ultimate load obtained numerical analysis is consistent with the test
results. Table 3 shows that the differences in the FEM-to-test ultimate loading
capacity ratio are from 0.90 to 1.12. Table 3 indicates that most of the failure modes
of numerical analysis are the same with the test results, except C15024 beam with
connector spacing L/3. The load–vertical displacement curves at midspan of C20019
beam are plotted and compared with test results, as seen in Fig. 9. The FEM failure
modes of C20019 beam are also presented and compared with test results, as seen in
Fig. 10. It can be concluded that the finite element model predicted with acceptable
accuracy about the behavior of cold-formed steel beams. Load capacity increases
when the thickness of the steel C-section increases and connection spacing
decreases. The FEM curves agree well with the test curves from beginning to
maximum loading stage.
a. L/2 b. L/3
c. L/4 d. L/6
Fig. 10 The failure modes comparison between experimental and FEM results (C20019)
Table 3 (continued)
Specimen Experimental results FEM results Ratio
PFEM/
PEXP
PEXP Failure mode PFEM Failure mode
(kN) C-section 1 C-section 2 (kN) C-section 1 C-section 2
C15024-L4 48.70 LB LB 45.43 LB LB 0.93
C15024-L3 50.61 LB LB 45.97 DB + LB DB + LB 0.91
C15024-L2 45.22 DB + LB LTB 42.62 DB + LB LTB 0.94
C20019-L6 48.00 LB LB 45.72 LB LB 0.95
C20019-L4 47.50 LB LB 44.14 LB LB 0.93
C20019-L3 40.48 DB + LB DB + LB 44.33 DB + LB DB + LB 1.10
C20019-L2 36.70 DB + LB LTB 39.52 DB + LB LTB 1.08
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to NS BlueScope Lysaght (Thailand) Limited for
providing the CFS beam specimens. The authors would also like to especially thank Mr. Wasan
Patwichaichote and the Structures Laboratory of the Chulachomklao Royal Military Academy,
Thailand for their supports.
References
Abstract Over the past twenty years, conflicting research findings have been
reported on mechanical properties of high strength S690 welded sections due to
different welding procedures and parameters adopted during welding. In order to
quantify adverse effects on mechanical properties of these S690 steel welded sec-
tions, a total of 12 spliced S690 welded H-sections with different heat input energy
adopted in the welding processes have been conducted to examine their deforma-
tion characteristics under compression, in particular, their cross section resistances.
It is demonstrated that by a proper control on the heat input energy during welding,
it is possible to control or even eliminate any reduction to the mechanical properties
of these spliced S690 welded H-sections under compression.
K. F. Chung (&) H. C. Ho Y. F. Hu
Chinese National Engineering Research Centre for Steel Construction (Hong Kong Branch),
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR
e-mail: kwok-fai.chung@polyu.edu.hk
H. C. Ho
e-mail: hc.ho@polyu.edu.hk
Y. F. Hu
e-mail: yi-fei.hu@polyu.edu.hk
K. F. Chung H. C. Ho X. Liu K. Wang Y. F. Hu
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The Hong Kong Polytechnic
University, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR
e-mail: leo-xiao.liu@connect.polyu.hk
K. Wang
e-mail: leon.kai@connect.polyu.hk
1 Introduction
High strength S690 steels are efficient steel constructional products which possess
mechanical strengths two to three times to those of normal strength steels, such as
S235 and S355 steels. Owing to their excellent strength-to-self weight ratios, they
are highly desirable to be used in heavily loaded structures, leading to a potential
saving in both materials and costs in the order of 30 to 50%. Since 2000, high
strength steels have been successfully used in key structural members of large
lifting equipment, machinery and offshore structures. However, they have not been
widely adopted in construction owing to potential adverse effects of welding on
their microstructures which lead to significant reductions in their mechanical
properties [8]. Hence, it is necessary to examine structural adequacy of these S690
welded sections with different heat input energy in order to ensure satisfactory
structural performance of S690 welded members in construction.
In general, welding in normal strength S355 steels does not cause any significant
strength reduction as they are primarily ferritic or ferritic-pearlitic steels which
microstructures do not undergo phase transformation during welding. However,
high strength steels are primarily manufactured with heat treatments during
steel-making, such as Quenching and Tempering for QT steels. These high strength
steels possess highly favourable properties of strength, ductility and toughness.
However, large heating/cooling cycles induced during a practical welding process
will trigger phase transformation, recrystallization and grain growth in
heat-affected-zones (HAZ) of their welded joints. QT steels possess different con-
tinuous cooling transformation (CCT) characteristics, and thus, various phases of
the QT steels will be formed. Hence, significant adverse effects on mechanical
properties of these welded joints at locations within the HAZ, in particular
decreased hardening due to softening, will be resulted, if the heat input energy, q
(kJ/mm), adopted during welding is not properly controlled [1].
In order to promote effective use of the high strength S690 steels in construction, it
is essential to examine mechanical properties and structural behaviour of the S690
steel members and their joints. A comprehensive research programme on experi-
mental and numerical investigations was conducted by the authors on i) mechanical
properties of the S690 steels and their welded sections under monotonic and cyclic
Compression Tests on High Strength S690 Welded Sections … 1527
2 Experimental Tests
In order to assess any adverse effect of welding onto the mechanical properties of
the S690 welded H-sections, a total of 12 compression tests on 4 different cross
sections, namely, Sections C1 to C4 with butt welded joints at mid-height, i.e. S690
spliced welded H-sections, were carried out. Figure 1 illustrates these four welded
H-sections with different cross-sectional dimensions, and steel plates with three
different thicknesses, i.e. 6, 10 and 16 mm, are used in these sections. Table 1
presents their mechanical properties obtained in standard coupon tests.
Table 3 summarizes the test programme of the compression tests, and a total of 12
sections with welded splices at mid-height of the sections are tested. It should be
noted that in this test series, only three different values of the heat input energy q are
adopted during welding of the butt welded joints, i.e. q = 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 kJ/mm.
Refer to Table 2 for various welding procedures and parameters adopted during
butt welding of the steel plates of these sections. Two different testing systems are
employed to conduct compression tests on various sections according to expected
failure loads of these stocky columns. The testing systems are shown in Fig. 2, i.e.
Sections C1 and C2 are tested with a MTS Testing System with a loading capacity
of 4,000 kN while Sections C3 and C4 are tested with a Hydraulic Servo Control
Testing System with a loading capacity of 10,000 kN. Both ends of the H-sections
are properly welded onto thick end plates to ensure consistent deformations of the
sections under compression.
Compression Tests on High Strength S690 Welded Sections … 1529
(a) MTS 400 tons Testing System (b) 1000 tons Hydraulic Servo Control
Testing System
All the tests have been conducted successfully. Typical deformed shapes of these
spliced welded H-sections after tests are shown in Fig. 3. It should be noted that, in
1530 K. F. Chung et al.
all cases, symmetrical local buckling appears in both flanges of these spliced
welded H-sections while complementary local buckling is also found in their web
plates. Hence, the failure mode of these stocky columns is shown to be plastic local
buckling in both the flange and the web plates of these H-sections.
The measured applied load vs axial shortening curves of all these spliced sec-
tions are plotted onto the same graph in Fig. 4 for easy comparison. It is evident
that all these curves extend above the respective design section resistances Nc,Rd of
these Sections. All Sections C1S and C3S exhibit significant deformation ductility
under compression, but there is little ductility in all Sections C2S and C4S. This
agrees with the section classification obtained in accordance with the current
classification rules for welded cross-sections given in EN 1993-1-1 [1].
Table 3 presents the measured section resistances of all these S690 spliced
welded H-sections, Nc,Rt, together with their design section resistances, Nc,Rd. The
design resistances of the spliced welded H-sections are given by:
where
fy,f and fy,w are the measured yield strengths of the flange and the web plates of
the welded H-section respectively;
A f ¼ b tf ð2Þ
where
b and tf are the measured width and the measured thickness of the flange plate
respectively; and
10000 10000
C1S-1 C2S-1
9000 C1S-2 C2S-2
C1S-3 9000
C2S-3
8000 8000
Applied load, N (kN)
10000 10000
C3S-1 C4S-1
9000 C3S-2 9000 C4S-2
C3S-3 Class 3 C4S-3
8000 8000
Applied load, N (kN)
Class 2
Applied load, N (kN)
Fig. 4 Measured applied load vs axial shortening curves of S690 welded H-sections
h and tw are the measured overall depth and the measured thickness of the web
plate of the welded H-section respectively.
It is shown that all the measured section resistances, Nc,Rt, are larger than the
design section resistances, Nc,Rd, and the ratios of Nc,Rt to Nc,Rd range from 1.02 to
1.11 with an average value of 1.06. Hence, there is no reduction in the section
resistances of these spliced welded H-sections when the heat input energy q adopted
during welding ranges from 1.0 to 2.0 kJ/mm. Consequently, Eq. (1) is shown to be
applicable to predict the section resistances of these stocky columns of S690 spliced
welded H-sections under compression.
1532 K. F. Chung et al.
3 Conclusions
In order to assess any adverse effect of welding onto the mechanical properties of
the S690 welded sections, a total of 12 compression tests on 4 different cross
sections, namely, Sections C1 to C4, with butt welded joints at mid-height were
carried out.
It should be noted that key test results, including the failure modes, the measured
deformation characteristics, and the measured section resistances of all the 12 tests
are presented in this paper. It is demonstrated that by a proper control on the heat
input energy during welding, it is possible to eliminate any reduction to the
mechanical properties of these S690 welded sections under compression.
Consequently, experimental evidence on structural adequacy of these high strength
S690 steel welded joints with different heat input energy adopted in the welding
processes is provided scientifically to confirm applications of these high strength
S690 steel in construction.
Acknowledgements The authors are grateful for the financial support provided by the Research
Grants Council of the University Grants Committee of the Government of Hong Kong SAR
(Project Nos. 152194/15E, 152687/16E, and 152231/17E). The projects leading to publication of
this paper are also partially funded by the Chinese National Engineering Research Centre for Steel
Construction (Hong Kong Branch) under the Innovation and Technology Commission of the
Government of Hong Kong (Project No. BBY3), and the Research Committee of the Hong Kong
Polytechnic University (Project Nos. BBY4 and BBY6). Moreover, the research studentships
provided by the Research Committee of the Hong Kong Polytechnic University is acknowledged
(Project Nos. RTK3, RTZX, and RUQV). All structural tests on high strength S690 steels were
conducted at the Structural Engineering Research Laboratory of the Department of Civil and
Environmental Engineering at the Hong Kong Polytechnic University, and supports from the
technicians are gratefully acknowledged.
References
1. CEN (2005) EN-1993-1-1:2005, Eurocode 3: Design of steel structures – Part 1–1: General
rules and rules for buildings, European Committee for Standardization, Brussels, Belgium
2. Easterling KE(1992) Introduction to the physical metallurgy of welding 1992.
Butterworth-Heinemann
3. Liu X, Ho HC, Chung KF (2017) Strength reduction of S690-QT welded sections under
various heat input energy. In: Fifteenth East Asia-Pacific conference on structural engineering
and construction (EASEC-15), 11–13 October 2017, Xi’an, China (Paper No.: P1412)
4. Liu X, Chung KF, Ho HC, Xiao M, Hou ZX, Nethercot DA (2018) Mechanical behaviour of
high strength S690-QT steel welded sections with various heat input energy. Eng Struct
175:245–256
5. Ma TY, Liu X, Hu YF, Chung KF, Li GQ (2017a) Structural behavior of slender columns of
high-strength Q690 steel welded H-sections under compression. Eng Struct 157:75–85
6. Ma TY, Li GQ, Chung KF (2017b) Numerical investigation into high strength Q690 steel
columns of welded H-sections under combined compression and bending. J Constr Steel Res
144:119–134
Compression Tests on High Strength S690 Welded Sections … 1533
7. Ma TY, Hu YF, Liu X, Li GQ, Chung KF (2017c) Experimental investigation into high
strength Q690 steel welded H-sections under combined compression and bending. J Constr
Steel Res 138:449–462
8. Willms R (2009) High strength steel for steel construction. In: Proceedings of nordic steel
construction conference, pp 597–604
Transformation Rules on Engineering
Stress Strain Curves of S690
Funnel-Shaped Coupons
Abstract Funnel-shaped coupons are widely adopted for various steels low cycle
high strain cyclic tests to investigate hysteretic behaviour of structural steels under
cyclic actions in order to avoid plastic axial buckling. However, a technical problem
is induced that the engineering stress strain curves obtained from these
funnel-shaped coupons are not comparable to those curves obtained from standard
cylindrical coupons. Hence, it is essential to correlate the engineering stress-strain
characteristics obtained from monotonic tensile tests using these two types of
coupons. This paper presents a theoretical study into such a correlation on the stress
strain characteristics between the funnel-shaped coupons and the standard cylin-
drical coupons. A series of transformation formulae are proposed for various
deformation ranges, namely i) Elastic range; ii) Plateau range; iii) Hardening range
and iv) Necking range. The proposed transformation formulae have been calibrated
with tensile test results and FE models of the S690 funnel-shaped coupons. These
test results provide strong evidence to the effectiveness of the proposed transfor-
mation rules for subsequent investigations into hysteretic behaviour of steel
materials.
H. C. Ho (&) K. F. Chung
Chinese National Engineering Research Centre for Steel Construction (Hong Kong Branch),
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR
e-mail: hc.ho@polyu.edu.hk
K. F. Chung
e-mail: cekchung@polyu.edu.hk
H. C. Ho K. F. Chung Y. B. Guo
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The Hong Kong Polytechnic
University, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR
e-mail: liz.guo@connect.polyu.hk
1 Introduction
----------------------- (1)
d=5mm
2
d=5mm
2
Tensile tests of both funnel shaped and cylindrical coupons were carried out [3]. All
coupons are in 5 mm diameter. The measured engineering stress-strain curves are
plotted in Fig. 3. Key data and test results are presented in Table 1. The test results
will be used for calibration of the proposed analytical method for evaluation of
deformation of funnel-shaped coupon under different deformation stages in sub-
sequent sections.
1538 H. C. Ho et al.
The authors (Ho et al. 2018) [8] carried out a series of research projects to inves-
tigate the true stress characteristics of S690 steels using a newly developed
Instantaneous Area Method. In general, a typical stress strain curve of high strength
S690 steel can be classified into four deformation stages, namely i) Elastic stage; ii)
Plateau stage; iii) Hardening stage; and iv) Necking stage, as shown in Fig. 4. The
localized deformation within the gauge length of the funnel-shaped coupon is
visually presented in Fig. 5.
Y H N
Elastic stage
F
Plateau stage
Hardening stage
Necking stage
I
In the elastic stage, all materials of the funnel-shaped coupon are elastic until the
stresses within the minimum cross-section reaches the yield strength. Thus, the
elongation of the coupon within the gauge length, Δ, is given by
Xr Z d Z d
F F F
D¼ ¼2 dl ¼ 2 dl ¼ 0:459 ð2Þ
E 0 EA 0 Epr 2 A
fy 4 751 4
D ¼ 0:459 ¼ 0:459 ¼ 0:034 mm
E pd 2 200000 25p
After the elastic stage, the deformation would enter the plateau stage, in which
limited hardening effect is localized in the shaded area of the coupon as shown in
Fig. 6. At the end of plateau stage, the stresses within the minimum cross-section
reaches fh, i.e. Point H—Onset of hardening. It is essential to identify the yielding
zone of the coupon by direct determination of the critical length as illustrated in
Fig. 6. Based on the stress ratio between fh and the yield strength fy, i.e. fh =fy , the
critical value of the cross-sectional diameter / at which material yielding begins, as
well as the critical length of yielding zone, lc, could be determined by the principle
of force equilibrium.
p/2 pd 2
fy ¼ fh
4 4
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
) critical diameter / ¼ d fh =fy
1540 H. C. Ho et al.
2
Lo E = 200kN/mm
After the hardening stage, the deformation is highly localized in the minimum
cross-section of the funnel-shaped coupon, and thus, the test coupon undergoes a
large deformation leading to a very different longitudinal profile. Therefore, Eq. (1)
describing the longitudinal profile of the test coupon is not valid at the hardening
stage. Hence, the elongation of the coupon within the gauge length cannot be
assessed using Eq. (2).
Transformation Rules on Engineering Stress Strain Curves … 1541
di = 2.77mm
d = 5.00mm di = 4.84mm
Pixel = 88
Pixel = 159 Pixel = 154
Instead of using analytical solutions, digital image correlation method (Ho et al.
2019) [7] is applied to determine the point of the tensile strength. Figure 7 illus-
trates the measured instantaneous diameter of the funnel-shaped coupon under
different deformation ranges.
Stage 3 - Point of Tensile Strength (i.e. Onset of Necking), N
At the point of tensile strength, the diameter is reduced from 5.00 mm to 4.84 mm.
Thus, the reduction ratio to the cross-sectional area is 4.842/5.002 = 0.939.
Accordingly,
True strain e = ln (1/0.939) = 0.065 = 6.5%
Corresponding engineering strain eu = ee 1 = 6.7%
Tensile strength = 15.68kN/19.63 mm2 = 798.6 N/mm2
Stage 4 - Point of Fracture, F
After onset of necking, the applied load reduced with the instantaneous area.
Meanwhile, the deformation is highly localized in the necking region. From Point H to
Point F, the total deformation is Dneck ¼ 2d eL 2d eh ¼ 2:58 0:12 ¼ 2:46 mm.
Hence, the total elongation eL ¼ eu þ eneck ¼ 0:067 þ 2:46=5d ¼ 0:1654 ¼
16:54%.
In the current study, the ratio d/2R = 0.083 at small deformation range. Hence,
the stress correction factor, gr , is equal to 0.95.
2
by FEM
Test data
Test data
Fig. 8 Predicted engineering stress strain curves of funnel-shaped and cylindrical coupons
6 Conclusions
This paper presents a theoretical study into the correlation on the stress strain
characteristics between a funnel-shaped coupon and a standard cylindrical coupon.
A series of transformation formulae are proposed for various deformation ranges,
namely i) Elastic range; ii) Plateau range; iii) Hardening range; and iv) Necking
range. The test results provide strong evidence to the effectiveness of the proposed
transformation rules. The research findings are considered to be very important to
subsequent investigations into the hysteretic behaviour of the S690 steels.
1544 H. C. Ho et al.
Acknowledgements The project leading to publication of this paper is partially funded by the
Research Grants Council of the Government of Hong Kong SAR (Project No. PolyU 5148/13E,
PolyU 152194/15E, and PolyU 152687/16E) and the Research Committee of the Hong Kong
Polytechnic University (Project No. RTZX). Both technical and financial support from the Chinese
National Engineering Research Centre for Steel Construction (Hong Kong Branch) (Project
No. 1-BBY3 & 6) of the Hong Kong Polytechnic University is also gratefully acknowledged.
Special thanks go to the Nanjing Iron and Steel Company Ltd. in Nanjing for supply of high
strength steel materials.
(continued)
General formula of deformation of funnel-shaped coupon
Dyielding
Z Point Y Point H
fh fy pd 2 1
lc
¼ dx f
0 Eh 4 pr 2 h
Z lc f
fy pd 2 1 E
þ dx y h
0 E 4 pr 2
Z lc 2 2
fh fy d 1 E = 200kN/mm
¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi2 dx
4Eh
2 36d x
0 13d 2 2
Z lc 2
fy d 1 ε ε
þ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi2 dx
y h
0 4E
2 36d x
13d 2 2
fh fh fy fy
D ¼ 5:57 þ 3:45 þ
E Eh E
767 16 751
¼ 5:57 þ 3:45 þ
200000 900 200000
¼ 0:0214 þ 0:0743
¼ 0:0957m
References
1. Bridgman P (1952) Studies in large plastic and fracture. McGraw-Hill, New York
2. BS 3518-3 (1963) Method of fatigue testing – Part 3: Direct stress fatigue tests. British
Standards Institution
3. BS EN ISO 6892-1 (2009) Metallic materials – Tensile testing Part 1: Method of test at
ambient temperature. British Standards Institution
4. Fournier B, Sauzay M, Caes C, Noblecourt M, Mottot M (2006) Analysis of the hysteresis
loops of a martensitic steel – Part I: Study of the influence of strain amplitude and temperature
under pure fatigue loadings using an enhanced stress partitioning method. Mater Sci Eng, A
437:183–196
5. FEMA-461 (2007) Interim testing Protocols for determining the seismic performance
characteristics of structural and non-structural components. Federal Emergency Management
Agency
6. GB/T 15248 (1994) Metallic materials – constant amplitude strain controlled axial fatigue –
method of test. Standard Press of China, Beijing, China. (In Chinese)
7. Ho HC, Chung KF, Liu X, Xiao M, Nethercot DA (2019) Modelling tensile tests on high
strength S690 steel materials undergoing large deformations. Eng Struct 192:305–322
8. Ho HC, Liu X, Chung KF, Xiao M, Yam MCH, Nethercot DA (2018) True stress-strain
characteristics of high strength S690 steels. In: International Conference on Engineering
Research and Practice for Steel Construction 2018, Hong Kong, pp 160–167
9. ISO 12106 (2003) Metallic materials – Fatigue testing – Axial-strain-controlled method.
International Organization for Standardization
10. Khan S, Wilde F, Beckmann F, Mosler J (2012) Low cycle fatigue mechanism of the
lightweight alloy Al2024. Int J Fatigue 38:92–99
11. Nip KH, Gardner L, Davies CM, Elghazouli AY (2010) Extremely low cycle fatigue tests on
structural carbon steel and stainless steel. J Constr Steel Res 66:96–110
Investigations into Compression
Behaviour of T-Joints Between S690
Circular Hollow Sections Under Brace
Axial Force
Y. F. Hu and K. F. Chung
Abstract This paper presents an experimental and numerical investigation into the
compression behaviour of T-joints between S690 cold-formed circular hollow
sections (CFCHS). A total of four T-joints between S690 CFCHS were tested under
axial compression in brace members. A typical failure mode was observed that all
joints failed in an interaction between the local plastification of the chords and
overall plastic bending of the chords. Three dimensional finite element models with
geometrical and material non-linearity have been established and verified after
calibration against test results. Both measured geometrical dimensions and material
properties of these CFCHS are incorporated into the proposed models. Both the
experimental and the numerical results are compared with design resistances
obtained from existing design codes, including EN 1993-1-8 and CIDECT Design
Guide 1. The investigation will facilitate development of efficient design rules for
resistances of T-joints between S690 CFCHS under brace axial compression.
Y. F. Hu K. F. Chung (&)
Chinese National Engineering Research Centre for Steel Construction (Hong Kong Branch),
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR
e-mail: kwok-fai.chung@polyu.edu.hk
Y. F. Hu
e-mail: yi-fei.hu@polyu.edu.hk
Y. F. Hu K. F. Chung
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The Hong Kong Polytechnic
University, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR
1 Introduction
Structural behaviour of tubular joints between normal strength steel hollow sections
have been extensively investigated in the past decades. The research findings have
been developed into various design rules adopted by some international design
specifications for application. Design recommendations for these tubular joints were
proposed by the International Institute of Welding (IIW) Subcommission XV-E in
1981 and 1991(IIW [6] and 1991). Eurocode EN 1993-1-8 CEN [3, 4] adopted the
design recommendations proposed by the 2nd edition of IIW recommendations IIW
[7]. The latest version of CIDECT Design Guide 1 [11] follows the 3rd editions of
IIW recommendations IIW [8]. Current design rules for high strength steel tubular
joints were developed based on extensive numerical results and re-assessment of
existing experimental results [10]. Since there were insufficient experimental results
for high strength steel tubular joints available at that time, both strength reduction
factors and limitations on the tensile to yield strength ratio, fu/fy, were set to ensure
a safety margin for practical design. In recent years, there has been an increasing
number of research on high strength steel tubular joints. Various joint types with
different cross-section geometry were studied to enrich the database on high
strength steel tubular joints, for re-evaluating the current design rules. As many
current design rules for high strength CHS T-joints are developed based on the test
results on normal strength steel CHS T-joints and extensive numerical analyses
results, it is necessary to carry out structural tests on high strength CHS T-joints
under brace axial compression to enrich the existing database.
It is also highly desirable to develop finite element models with a high precision
to analyze suitability of existing reduction factors on high strength steel CHS
T-joints to see whether the design could be improved. Effects of cold-forming,
weld-induced residual stresses and strength reduction in heat affected zones on the
structural behaviour of these high strength tubular joints are necessary to be further
investigated.
2 Experimental Investigation
In order to investigate the structural behaviour of these high strength S690 welded
steel T-joints, a total of four T-joints between cold-formed circular hollow sections
(CFCHS) were fabricated and tested under axial compression in brace members.
The test programme is presented in Table 1 while Fig. 1 presents detailed config-
uration of a T-joint. The lengths of both the chords and the braces of the joints, L0
and L1 are 1200 mm and 600 mm respectively. The span between two pinned
supports, L, is 1500 mm.
Investigations into Compression Behaviour of T-Joints … 1549
N
α = 2L0/d0
Brace d1 β = d1/d0
L1
2γ = d0/t0
Chord t1 τ = t1/t0
t0
Crown
d0 Saddle
L0
The following geometrical parameters are covered: i) the brace to chord diameter
ratio ðb ¼ d1 =d0 Þ is assigned to range from 0.6 to 0.8, ii) the ratio of brace wall
thickness to chord wall thickness ðs ¼ t1 =t0 Þ is assigned to range from 0.8 to 1.0.
The diameter of the chord is assigned to be 250 mm, and its thickness is 10 mm.
The measured geometric dimensions of the four T-joint specimens are summarized
in Table 2.
Standard tensile tests were conducted to obtain basic material properties of the
S690 steel plates. A summary of key results of the standard tensile tests are shown
1550 Y. F. Hu and K. F. Chung
in Table 3. Edge preparation was performed at the ends of the braces in order to
make profiled connecting surfaces for joint welding. The chords and the braces
were then connected together through a combination of partial penetration butt
welds and fillet welds. Welding of all these T-joints was performed by a highly
skilled welder in a well-equipped fabricator. The welding electrode ER110S-G
(with a diameter of 1.2 mm) according to AWS A5.28 [2] was employed for
GMAW of high strength S690 steels. The nominal yield strength of the welding
electrode is 720 N/mm2.
Figure 2 illustrates typical test setup and instrumentation for the joint tests. All
these tests were carried out at the Structural Engineering Research Laboratory of the
Hong Kong Polytechnic University. Both ends of the chord of each T-joint were
attached to two vertical supports through two steel pins. Only in-plane rotations
were allowed at both ends of the chord. Two laser levels were installed in front of
and at the left of the T-joint during testing to ensure the centre of the brace was
carefully aligned with the centre of the loading attachment.
Investigations into Compression Behaviour of T-Joints … 1551
All the T-joints were tested successfully and they all failed in an interaction
between a global failure mode and a local failure mode as follows:
• Overall plastic bending of the chord
• Local plastification of the chord at the joint panel zone
This is because the axial compression force acting on the brace induces a
bending moment and a shear force in the chord. The chord section at the joint panel
zone is, therefore, under compressive stresses. Such compressive chord stresses will
reduce the joint resistance. The deformed shapes and the typical failure mode of
these T-joints are illustrated in Fig. 3. No weld cracking was observed in all these
tests.
The vertical displacement at the mid-span of the chord of each T-joint is calculated
as follows
D6 þ D7
d¼ ð1Þ
2
D ¼ maxðD4 d; D5 dÞ ð2Þ
The applied load versus chord indentation curve of Joint T2A is shown in Fig. 4.
In the present study, the maximum load resistance of each T-joint is defined by the
lower value of: i) the applied ultimate load, and ii) the applied load corresponding
to an ultimate deformation limit, where the deformation limit is proposed by [9].
This out-of-plane deformation limit is defined as 3% of the outer diameter of the
chord, i.e. 0.03d0, according to CIDECT Design Guide 1. It is observed from the
applied load versus chord indentation curves that all the tested joints reached the
ultimate loads prior to the deformation limit, i.e. 0.03d0 or 7.5 mm. Hence, the
applied ultimate load of each joint is determined as its axial compressive resistance.
The design resistances of all the T-joints are summarized in Table 4. For Joints T4
and T5, the calculated maximum bending moments in the chords all exceed the
plastic moment resistances of the chords. Hence, an overall failure mode of chord
bending is considered to be dominant in these joints. However, a local failure mode
of chord plastification is considered to be dominant in Joints T2A and T2B through
a back analysis on the maximum bending moments in the chords.
By comparing results of Joints T4 and T5, it is shown that the resistance of a
T-joint does not always increase by increasing the wall thickness of the brace.
Both CIDECT Design Guide 1 and EN1993-1-8 are considered to be structurally
adequate for prediction of the axial resistances of these T-joints without the need of
Investigations into Compression Behaviour of T-Joints … 1553
applying a reduction factor of 0.9 or 0.8. With these reduction factors, both for-
mulae give an under-prediction of about 25 to 71%. The safety margin is considered
to be quite large. Therefore, the strength reduction factor of 0.8 defined by EN
1993-1-12 CEN [5] is considered to be very conservative for these T-joints.
3 Numerical Investigation
Nonlinear finite element models of these four T-joints between S690 CFCHS with
brace axial compression are established and analyzed using the commercial finite
element programme ABAQUS [1]. In the present study, solid elements C3D8R are
employed for modeling the T-joints. Three layers of solid elements are employed
through the thickness of the CFCHS in order to capture local bending behaviour.
A general mesh size of 6 mm is determined through a mesh sensitivity study, after
considering both computational efficiency and accuracy of the numerical results. An
overall view of the finite element mesh of a typical T-joint is shown in Fig. 5.
Partial penetration butt-welds are simplified as deep penetration fillet welds in
accordance with EN 1993-1-8. The stress-strain curves of the S690 steel plates of 6
and 10 mm thick obtained from standard tensile tests are converted to true
stress-strain curves, as illustrated in Fig. 6. Stress-strain curves of S690 welds are
simplified using an elastic-perfect plastic model. The initial elastic modulus of the
weld metal is taken as 210 kN/mm2, according to EN 1993-1-1 [3, 4] while the
yield strength of the weld metal is 720 N/mm2. The Poisson’s ratio is taken as 0.3.
Isotropic hardening rule and von Mises yield criterion are adopted.
The boundary conditions of the proposed FE models are shown in Fig. 7. Three
reference points are set, and they are coupled with the nodes on both surfaces of the
chord ends and the top surface of the brace with all six degrees of freedom. An axial
load is applied onto Reference Point A through the static Risks method given in
ABAQUS/Standard.
1554 Y. F. Hu and K. F. Chung
1200 900
800 f y = 720 N/mm2
True stress (N/mm2)
True stress (N/mm2)
1000
700
800 600
500
600
400
400 300
S690-6mm 200
200 S690-Weld
S690-10mm 100
0 0
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1
True strain True strain
Both the measured and the predicted axial load versus chord indentation curves of
Joint T2A are compared in Fig. 8. Figure 9 illustrates the predicted deformed
shapes and stress contours of Joint T2A. The axial resistances from the numerical
results are also compared with the test results in Table 3. The differences between
the measured and the predicted axial resistances of these T-joints are lower than
6%, with a mean value of the axial resistance ratio Nc,FE/Nc,Test of 1.02. Therefore,
the proposed numerical models are found to be able to predict structural behaviour
of these T-joints under brace axial compression well.
Joint T2A
1400
3% d0
Applied axial load, N (kN)
1200 Test
FEM for d0 = 250 mm
1000
800
600
400
200
0
0 2.5 5 7.5 10 12.5 15 17.5 20
Chord indentation Δ (mm)
Stress (N/mm2)
1000
800
600
400
200
0
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The project leading to publication of this paper is partially funded by the
Research Grants Committee of the Hong Kong Polytechnic University (Project No. RTZX) and the
Research Grants Council of the University Grants Committee of the Government of Hong
Kong SAR (Project Nos. PolyU 152194/15E, PolyU 152687/16E and PolyU 152331/17E). The
authors also wish to acknowledge the Chinese National Engineering Research Centre for Steel
Construction (Hong Kong Branch) at the Hong Kong Polytechnic University for financial support.
References
1. ABAQUS 6.12 (2009) Theory Manual 2009, Providence, Dassault Systems Simulia Corp, US
2. AWS (2005) Specification for Low-Alloy Steel Electrodes and Rods for Gas Shielded Arc
Welding, Structural Welding Code – Steel. American Welding Society, Miami, United States
3. CEN (2005) BS EN 1993-1-1, Eurocode 3: Design of steel structures Part 1-1: General rules
and rules for buildings, European Committee for Standardization
4. CEN (2005) BS EN 1993-1-8, Eurocode 3: Design of steel structures Part 1-8: Design of
joints, European Committee for Standardization
5. CEN (2007) BS EN 1993-1-12, Eurocode 3: Design of steel structures Part 1-12: Additional
rules for the extension of EN 1993 up to steel grades S700, European Committee for
Standardization
6. International Institute of Welding (IIW) (1981) Design recommendations for hollow section
joints—predominantly statically loaded, IIW Doc. XV-701-89, 1st edn
7. International Institute of Welding (IIW) (1989) Design recommendations for hollow section
joints—predominantly statically loaded, IIW Doc. XV-701-89, 2nd edn
8. International Institute of Welding (IIW) (2009) Design recommendations for hollow section
joints—predominantly statically loaded, IIW Doc. XV-701-89, 3rd edn
9. Lu LH, De Winkel GD, Yu Y, Wardenier J (1994) Deformation limit for the ultimate strength
of hollow section joints. In: 6th international symposium on tubular structures, pp 341–347
Investigations into Compression Behaviour of T-Joints … 1557
10. Qian XD, Choo YS, Van Der Vegte GJ, Wardenier J (2008) Evaluation of the new IIW CHS
strength formulae for thick-walled joints. In: Proceedings of the 12th international symposium
on tubular structures, Shanghai, pp 271–280
11. Wardenier J, Kurobane Y, Packer JA, Van der Vegte GJ, Zhao XL (2008) Design guide for
circular hollow section (CHS) joints under predominantly static loading, CIDECT
Structural Behaviour of High Strength
S690 Cold-Formed Structural Hollow
Sections Under Compression
Keywords High strength steels Cold-formed sections Classification of
cross-sections Section resistances Member resistances
1 Introduction
High strength steels are considered as efficient constructional materials due to their
high strength-to-self-weight ratios. With this remarkable advantage, low costs and
energy consumption during production per unit weight have become the other two
main advantages of high strength steels. Over the past years, a large number of
investigations into structural members made of high strength steels have proved that
they meet various design requirements in both strength and ductility under various
actions [7, 8]. However, their fabrication processes are quite different from those
members made of normal strength steels, in particular, the presence of residual
stresses due to both cold-forming and welding are generally considered to affect
adversely the structural performance of these cold-formed sections. Recently, the
experimental studies into residual stresses of high strength steels have been carried out
by several researchers, and the most commonly used methods to obtain residual
stresses are the hole-drilling method and the sectioning method. Many researchers
have compared measurements of the residual stresses among sections of different steel
grades [11]. Numerical simulation is another effective method to study residual
stresses. The coupled thermomechanical welding analysis has been developed with a
calibrated heat source model [3], and it enables accurate predictions on residual stress
patterns for different sections with minimum laboratory work [4, 6, 9]. The residual
stresses in the S690 welded H-sections obtained by finite element models or physical
measurements may be directly incorporated into structural analyses, and buckling
behaviour of both stocky and slender columns is subsequently simulated. These
studies incorporating realistic residual stresses into column buckling are recently
employed in high strength steel columns. It is found that these residual stresses have
little effects on stocky columns of S690 welded H-sections, but they play an important
role in slender columns of the same sections [5, 10]. In the current study, a total of eight
S690 cold-formed structural hollow sections (CFSHS) with different dimensions and
fabrication methods are designed, and the structural performance of these sections are
examined by with a total of 8 stocky column tests and 16 slender column tests.
symmetric while Series SB sections are uniaxially symmetric; (2) Series SA sec-
tions have four cold-bent corners and two butt-welded side joints while Series SB
sections have only two cold-bent corners and two butt-welded corner joints.
The residual stresses due to welding are predicted by using the coupled ther-
momechanical welding analysis, and the calibrated heat source model [3] is adopted
to simulate movement of the welding arch during welding. The simplified longi-
tudinal residual stress patterns for these two series of sections are shown in Fig. 2.
In the current study, 6 and 10 mm thick S690 plates are used to fabricate these
CFSHS, and the results of standard coupon tests on these steel plates are presented
in Table 1. The measured mechanical properties of the steel plates are compared
with the requirements of EN 1993-1-12 [2], and it should be noted that all these
requirements are satisfied.
Fig. 2 Simplified
longitudinal residual stress
patterns
The section resistances of a total of eight stocky columns of S690 CFSHS are
examined under compression, and the corresponding test programme is shown in
Table 2. In order to avoid failure of overall buckling, these columns are designed to
be short, i.e. their member lengths, Lm, are designed at 3 h. Except for those stocky
columns with Class 4 sections (Sections S2A and S2B), all stocky columns with
Class 1 or 2 sections are expected to mobilize readily their full plastic resistances of
the sections, and the measured maximum applied load, Nc,Et, should be larger than
the design resistance of the section, Nc,Rd.
Table 2 summarizes the key test results. It is shown that Sections S2A and S2B
achieve only about 82% of their design resistances of the sections. For all the other
sections, their measured section resistances are all larger than their design resis-
N
tances. Figure 3 shows a direct comparison on the section resistance ratios, N c;Et ,
c;Rd
against axial shortenings of various sections. Since Sections S3A and S3B have
very small h/t ratios, they not only exceed their design resistances of the sections,
Structural Behaviour of High Strength S690 … 1563
but also exhibit high degree of ductility. Sections S2A and S2B fail to reach their
design resistances of the sections because they are Class 4, and hence, a part of the
cross-sectional area may be defined as non-effective that do not bear any com-
pression. For Sections S1A, S1B, S4A and S4B, their measured section resistances
just exceed their design section resistances with a limited degree of ductility.
Although these four sections are Class 1 or 2 according to the current section
classification rules of EN 1993-1-1 [1], it is more reasonable to categorize them as
Class 3 according to their low degree of ductility. Typical failure modes of these
sections are shown in Fig. 3, and it is found that there is no significant difference in
the failure modes between Series SA and SB sections since local buckling occur at
similar locations in these stocky columns.
Fig. 3 Applied load ratio-axial shortening curves and typical failure modes of stocky columns
1564 M. Xiao and K. F. Chung
Table 3 summarizes the test results of a total of 16 slender column tests under
compression, where the measured maximum applied loads, Nb,Et, in each test is
recorded. Besides, the design section resistance of the section, Nc,Rd, and the design
member resistance of the column, Nb,Rd, are presented. It should be noted that Nb,Rd
in the current study is calculated based on the buckling curve c (imperfection factor,
a = 0.49) according to EN 1993-1-1 for member resistance design of slender
N
columns of CFSHS against overall buckling. It should be noted that the ratios N b;Et
b;Rd
of all slender columns with Classes 1 or 2 sections exceed 1.0. For those of Class 4
sections, there are parts of the cross-sectional area non-effective which have no
contribution to their section resistances. For typical failure mode of these slender
column tests, many of them fail in overall buckling. Figure 4 demonstrates typical
relationships of the applied load against displacements of Test S3A-P. As depicted
by Fig. 4(a), there is a significant decrease in the applied load after reaching the
maximum load. A similar trend is also evident in the applied load-horizontal dis-
placement curve, as shown by Fig. 4(b), where the horizontal displacement
increases quickly after the maximum load is reached, and this indicates that an
obvious overall buckling has occurred herein.
As above-mentioned, many of the slender column tests exceed their Nb,Rd pre-
dicted by the buckling curve c, which means that it is too conservative to design
these slender columns of CFSHS by simply adopting the current design rules of EN
Fig. 4 Applied load-displacement curves and typical failure modes of slender columns
1566 M. Xiao and K. F. Chung
Series SA
Fig. 5 Design buckling curves and test data: EN 1993-1-1 and Series SA
Series SB
Fig. 6 Design buckling curves and test data: EN 1993-1-1 and Series SB
1993-1-1. Figures 5 and 6 show differences in the member resistances between the
slender columns of Series SA and SB sections. Obviously, the slender columns of
N
Series SB sections have higher ratios v ¼ N b;Et than those of Series SA sections.
c;Rd
Based on a direct comparison between the test results and the predictions provided
Structural Behaviour of High Strength S690 … 1567
5 Conclusions
In this paper, a total of eight cold-formed structural hollow sections (CFSHS) are
examined, and an experimental investigation into the structural behaviour of 8
S690 CFSHS stocky columns under compression and 16 S690 CFSHS slender
columns under compression are presented.
In general, all stocky columns with Class 1 and 2 sections are able to mobilize
their full cross-section resistances, except Sections S2A and S2B which are Class 4
sections. Similarly, all slender columns with Class 1 and 2 sections are able to
mobilize their member resistances, except Column S2B-P which is Class 4 section.
Based on a direct comparison between the measured and the predicted resistances
provided by those buckling design curves given in EN 1993-1-1, it is proposed to
improve the design method such that a higher curve with a smaller imperfection
factor should be used. Numerical models will be established after calibration
against these test results, and both material and geometrical initial imperfections of
these members with practical magnitudes will be incorporated to generate numer-
ical resistances for development of the improved design method.
Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to the financial support provided by the Research
Grant Council of the Government of Hong Kong SAR (Project Nos. PolyU 152687/16E and
152231/17E). The project leading to the publication of this paper is also partially funded by the
Research Committee (Project No. RUQV) and the Chinese National Engineering Research Centre
for Steel Construction (Hong Kong Branch) (Project No. 1-BBY3) of the Hong Kong Polytechnic
University. The research studentship of the first author provided by the Hong Kong Polytechnic
University is acknowledged. Special thanks go to the Nanjing Iron and Steel Company Ltd. in
Nanjing, and to Dongguan Pristine Metal Works Ltd. in Dongguan. All structural tests on
S690 CFSHS were carried out at the Structural Engineering Research Laboratory at the Hong
Kong Polytechnic University, and supports from the technicians are gratefully acknowledged.
References
1. BSI (2005) EN 1993-1-1. Eurocode 3: Design of structures – Part 1-1: General rules and rules
for buildings. British Standards Institution
2. BSI (2007) EN 1993-1-12. Eurocode 3: Design of structures – Part 1-12: Additional rules for
the extension of EN 1993 up to steel grades S 700. British Standards Institution
3. Goldak J, Chakravarti A, Bibby M (1984) A new finite element model for welding heat
sources. Metallurg Trans B 15(2):299–305
4. Hu YF (2019) Structural behaviour of high strength S690 steel cold-formed circular hollow
sections (Doctoral dissertation, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University)
1568 M. Xiao and K. F. Chung
5. Li TJ, Liu SW, Li GQ, Chan SL, Wang YB (2016) Behaviour of Q690 high-strength steel
columns: Part 2: parametric study and design recommendations. J Constr Steel Res 122:379–
394
6. Liu X, Chung KF (2018) Experimental and numerical investigation into temperature histories
and residual stress distributions of high strength steel S690 welded H-sections. Eng Struct
165:396–411
7. Ma TY, Hu YF, Liu X, Li GQ, Chung KF (2017) Experimental investigation into high
strength Q690 steel welded H-sections under combined compression and bending. J Constr
Steel Res 138:449–462
8. Somodi B, Kövesdi B (2017) Flexural buckling resistance of cold-formed HSS hollow section
members. J Constr Steel Res 128:179–192
9. Wang K (2018) Study on structural behaviour of high strength steel s690 welded H-and
I-sections (Doctoral dissertation, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University)
10. Wang YB, Li GQ, Chen SW, Sun FF (2014) Experimental and numerical study on the
behaviour of axially compressed high strength steel box-columns. Eng Struct 58:79–91
11. Yang C, Yang J, Su M, Li Y (2016) Residual stress in high-strength-steel welded circular
tube. Proc Inst Civil Eng Struct Build 170(9):631–640
Structural Responses of High Strength
S690 Welded Sections Under Different
Cyclic Actions
Abstract Structural engineers are constantly looking for high strength construc-
tional materials as they face huge challenges in providing structural solutions to
build heavily loaded structures, such as high-rise buildings and long span bridges.
Applications of high strength S690 steels to building structures are very attractive
owing to their high strength to self-weight ratios which often provide significant
savings in costs and time. However, there are concerns on mechanical properties of
welded S690 members, in particular, in both strength and ductility, and there is a
lack of technical guidance on how to assess any adverse effect on these mechanical
properties. This paper presents an experimental investigation into structural
responses of S690 steel plates and welded sections under cyclic actions with both
constant and varying strain amplitudes, and comparison on cyclic deformation
characteristics of both steel plates and their welded sections is presented.
1 Introduction
Structural engineers are constantly looking for high strength constructional mate-
rials as they face huge challenges in providing structural solutions to build heavily
loaded structures, such as high-rise buildings and long span bridges. Applications
of high strength S690 steels to building structures are very attractive owing to their
high strength to self-weight ratios which often provide significant savings in costs
and time [8]. However, there are concerns on mechanical properties of welded S690
members, in particular, in both strength and ductility. In general, welding in normal
strength S355 steels does not cause any significant strength reduction as they are
primarily ferritic or ferritic-pearlitic steels which microstructures do not undergo
phase transformation during welding. However, high strength steels are primarily
manufactured with heat treatments during steel-making, such as Quenching and
Tempering for QT steels. It should be noted that large heating/cooling cycles
induced during a practical welding process will trigger phase transformation,
recrystallization and grain growth in heat-affected-zones (HAZ) of their welded
joints. Hence, significant adverse effects on mechanical properties of these welded
joints at locations within the HAZ, in particular, both strength and ductility will be
resulted, if the heat input energy, q (kJ/mm), adopted during welding is not properly
controlled [4].
In most current structural steel design codes, there are specific clauses on duc-
tility requirements for steel materials. For example, according to EN 1993-1-1 [1],
the ductility requirements of normal strength S235 to S460 steels are:
i) fu/fy 1.10; ii) eL 15%; and iii) eu 15 ey .
where ey , eu , and eL are the strains corresponding to the yield strength, fy, the
tensile strength, fu, and fracture of the coupons.
For high strength steels up to S700, the relevant ductility requirements given in
EN 1993-1-12 [2] are:
i) fu/fy 1.05; ii) eL 10%; and iii) eu 15 ey .
These requirements are generally believed to be derived from experiences in
both engineering and research projects in accordance with materials tests under
monotonic tensile actions. However, many recent research works [6, 7] suggested
that the mechanical properties of the S355 and the S690 steels in monotonic and
cyclic tests differ significantly. Hence, it is argued that these ductility requirements
on mechanical properties of both the S355 and the S690 steels may not be directly
applicable for seismic design. Moreover, there is little technical guidance on the
ductility requirements of welded sections under monotonic and cyclic actions.
Structural Responses of High Strength S690 … 1571
2 Experimental Investigations
It is highly desirable to investigate the structural responses of both the S690 steel
plates and the S690 welded sections under cyclic actions, and to quantify their
cyclic deformation characteristics under different loading protocols with different
strain amplitudes. Hence, a total of 16 cyclic tests on the S690 steel plates and the
S690 welded sections under different loading protocols were conducted to compare
their deformation characteristics of these steels, and to investigate their hysteretic
behaviour at large deformations. Figure 1 illustrates the two loading protocols
adopted in the present study: i) Loading Protocol C, and ii) Loading Protocol V [5].
It should be noted that all these cyclic actions are applied with different fre-
quencies, i.e. 0.1 and 1.0 Hz. Two values of target strain amplitudes, i.e. ±5.0%
and ±10.0%, are adopted for cyclic tests with both varying and constant strain
amplitudes. In contrast to those standard cylindrical coupons recommended in many
codes and standards for monotonic tensile coupon tests, funnel-shaped coupons are
used in these tests to enable direct comparisons on test results obtained from both
the monotonic and the cyclic tests. The geometry and dimensions of the
funnel-shaped coupons are illustrated in Fig. 2.
All tests were conducted on an Instron Servohydraulic Testing Machine with a
capacity of 500 kN, as shown in Fig. 3. It should be noted that a high precision
extensometer and a high resolution digital camera are used to measure deformations
of the coupons throughout testing.
FEMA-461
(b) Coupon of S690 steel plates (c) Coupon of S690 welded sections
Table 1 Test programme of monotonic tensile tests on S690 steels and welded sections
Coupon Shape of Thickness of Diameter Gauge Total
coupons steel plates d (mm) length L0 length
(mm) (mm) L (mm)
S690-T1 Funnel-shaped 10 5 10 184
S690-T2
S690H-T1 Funnel-shaped 10 5 10 184
S690H-T2
In order to obtain the basic material properties of both the S690 steel plates and the
S690 welded sections under investigation, a total of 4 monotonic tensile coupon
tests are conducted in accordance with BS EN ISO 6892-1 [3], and the test pro-
gramme is shown in Table 1.
Figure 4 plots the engineering stress–strain curves of both the S690 steel plates
and the S690 welded sections onto the same graph for direct comparison. It is
shown that both the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded sections exhibit a linear
deformation under initial loading application up to their yield points, and then, a
nonlinear deformation with different extents of hardening, i.e. a steady increase in
strength with strains.
The mechanical properties of both the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded
sections are summarized in Table 2. Hence, it is shown that both the S690 steel
plates and the S690 welded sections have very similar deformation characteristics in
these engineering stress-strain curves under monotonic tension forces, and these
curves form the basis for subsequent investigations into their deformation charac-
teristics under cyclic actions.
Structural Responses of High Strength S690 … 1573
Table 2 Test results of monotonic tensile tests on S690 steels and welded sections
Coupon Thickness Young’s Yield Tensile Elongation fu/fy
of original modulus strength strength at fracture
plates (mm) E (kN/ fy (N/ fu (N/ eL (%)
mm2) mm2) mm2)
S690-T1 10 231.3 872 922 24.1 1.06
S690-T2 225.8 895 933 23.6 1.04
Average 228.6 883 927 23.8 1.05
COV 0.012 0.013 0.006 0.011 0.007
S690H-T1 10 202.8 833 936 19.1 1.12
S690H-T2 207.6 828 946 20.8 1.14
Average 205.2 830 941 20.0 1.13
COV 0.012 0.003 0.005 0.041 0.007
1574 Y. B. Guo et al.
Table 3 summaries the test programme and results of the cyclic tests on the coupons
of both the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded sections. All these cyclic tests are
performed under a strain control mode during testing. It should be noted that all
cyclic tests have been completed successfully, and the funnel-shaped coupons are
shown in Fig. 5 after testing.
The test results of cyclic tests on both the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded
sections are summarized in Table 3 while the engineering stress-strain curves of
both the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded sections under the two different
loading protocols, target strains and loading frequencies are illustrated in Figs. 6
and 7.
It should be noted that:
i) For cyclic tests under Loading Protocol C with em = ±5% and f = 0.1 Hz
• the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded sections are able to complete 16
and 8 cycles respectively, and
• the engineering stress-strain curves of both the S690 steel plates and the
S690 welded plates do not overlap one another well, and there is a sig-
nificant softening after a number of cycles completed.
ii) For cyclic tests under Loading Protocol C with em = ±10% and f = 0.1 Hz
• the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded sections are able to complete
only 6 and 1 cycles respectively, and
• there is a significant softening in the engineering stress-strain curves of
both the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded sections.
iii) For cyclic tests under Loading Protocol V with em = ±5% and f = 0.1 Hz
• both the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded sections are able to
complete all 20 cycles, and
• the engineering stress-strain curves of the S690 steel plates overlap one
another very well along the full range of deformations, and hence, there is
no evident of softening.
(b) Fractured coupon of steel plates after test (c) Fractured coupon of welded sections after test
iv) For cyclic tests under Loading Protocol V with em = ±10% and f = 0.1 Hz
• the S690 steel plates are able to complete 19 cycles while the S690 welded
sections are able to complete only 16 cycles, and
• the engineering stress-strain curves of the S690 steel plates overlap one another
very well along the full range of deformations, and hence, there is no evident of
softening.
Similar observations on cyclic tests with f = 1.0 Hz are also found.
Hence, it is shown that these cyclic tests are able to identify different defor-
mation characteristics of the S690 steel plates and the S690 welded sections, and
differences in their engineering stress-strain curves in terms of the number of cycles
completed and whether there is any softening after repeated cyclic actions.
Moreover, an overall inspection on all these graphs reveals that whether the
curves are of S690 steel plates and the S690 welded sections under either Loading
Protocols C or V, the cyclic deformation characteristics are unsymmetrically. That
is, their deformations under tension are very different from those under compres-
sion. Such differences are very apparent when the coupons undergo large defor-
mations, i.e. 5%. Instantaneous diameters may be used to re-plot these graphs to
give symmetrical cyclic deformation characteristics.
S690
steels
S690
welded
sections
S690
steels
S690
welded
sections
S690
steels
S690
welded
sections
S690
steels
S690
welded
sections
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors are grateful for the financial support provided by the Research
Grants Council of the University Grants Committee of the Government of Hong Kong SAR
(Project Nos. 152687/16E, 152231/17E, 152157/18E). The projects leading to publication of this
paper are also partially funded by the Chinese National Engineering Research Centre for Steel
Construction (Hong Kong Branch) under the Innovation and Technology Commission of the
Government of Hong Kong (Project No. BBY3), and the Research Committee of the Hong Kong
Polytechnic University (Project Nos. BBY4 and BBY6). Moreover, the research studentships
provided by the Research Committee of the Hong Kong Polytechnic University is acknowledged
(Project Nos. RJKB, RUQV and RTK3). All structural tests on high strength S690 steels were
conducted at the Structural Engineering Research Laboratory of the Department of Civil and
Environmental Engineering at the Hong Kong Polytechnic University.
References
1. BS EN 1993-1-1 (2005) Design of Steel Structures – Part 1–1: General rules and rules for
buildings. British Standards Institution
2. BS EN 1993-1-12 (2007) Design of Steel Structures – Part 1–12: Additional rules for the
extension of EN 1993 up to steel grades S700. British Standards Institution
3. BS EN ISO 6892-1 (2009) Metallic materials – Tensile testing: Part 1: Method of test at
ambient temperature, British Standards Institution
4. Easterling KE (1992) Introduction to physical metallurgy of welding, Butterworth -Heinemann
5. Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) (2007) Interim testing protocols for
determining the seismic performance characteristics of structural and nonstructural compo-
nents, Report No. FEMA-461
6. Ho HC, Liu X, Chung KF, Elghazouli AY, Xiao M (2018) Hysteretic behaviour of high
strength S690 steel materials under low cycle high strain tests. Eng Struct 165:222–236
7. Wang YB, Li GQ, Sun X, Chen S, Hai LT (2017) Evaluation and prediction of cyclic response
of Q690D steel. Proc Inst Civil Eng Struct Build 170(11):788–803
8. Willms R (2009) High strength steel for steel construction. In: Proceedings of nordic steel
construction conference, pp 597–604
Concrete and Composite Structures
Restoring Force Drift Angle
Relationship Models of Reinforced
Concrete Columns with Side Walls
1 Introduction
Reinforced concrete (RC) secondary walls, such as side walls, are used because they
increase the stiffness and strength of structures. From this view-point, experimental
studies of RC columns with sidewalls have been conducted recently, and evaluation
methods of the strength and ultimate drift angle have been proposed [4, 7] etc.
The restoring force drift angle relationship of columns with side walls was
characterized by initially high strength portion, which was mainly a contribution of
side walls, followed by ductile behavior, which was mainly a contribution of col-
umns after the failure of side walls. However, in the practical design, only initially
high strength portion is the objective. In other words, the ductile behavior after the
failure of side walls is not considered; although many types of design options can
be provided considering this ductile behavior [6].
This neglect is mainly due to the lack of knowledge on the behavior after the
maximum strength. In this study, backbone curve models of restoring force drift
angle relationships are proposed considering the characteristics of columns with
side walls.
The accuracies of the models are discussed using a variety of experimental data
including those conducted by other researchers [3–5, 8]. A total of 29 specimens
were examined. Among them 12 specimens are columns with one side wall, and
other 17 specimens are columns with side walls on both sides of the column.
Regarding the failure mode reported in the original papers, 13 specimens failed in
flexure, and other 16 specimens failed in shear. The thickness of the cover concrete
of the column and side wall section, which is necessary for the evaluation as
discussed later, is not commonly described in the original papers. In those cases,
thicknesses of 10 mm and 20 mm are assumed for the member section with less
than a thickness of 100 mm and more than a thickness of 100 mm, respectively.
The authors reported that the characteristic behavior of a column with side walls
could be simulated with two independent models: side wall model and column
model, generated from the original section [7]. Figure 1 shows assumptions of the
effective sections of the models. The side wall model represents an undamaged
section before loading. The column model represents an imaginary section without
a side wall subjected to compressive axial force, assuming that the side wall is
hardly damaged and ineffective.
Finally, the backbone curve of the restoring force drift angle relationship of a
column with side walls can be obtained as the envelope curve of the side wall
model and column model, as shown in Fig. 2. The failure mode, flexural failure or
shear failure, is determined for each model in accordance with the evaluation
equations, as shown later. Thus, regarding the failure mode of the original member,
four cases are considered. Figures 2(a) and (b) illustrate the cases when both the
side wall and column models fail in flexure and in shear, respectively.
Restoring Force Drift Angle Relationship Models … 1583
Fig. 1 Assumptions of the effective sections of the column model and sidewall model
Colum
n Column
l
Fig. 2 Examples of the restoring force – drift angle relationships of columns with sidewalls
The model of the restoring force drift angle relationship for each model is
expressed by four lines connecting four characteristic points of the model: cracking
point (C), yielding point (Y), ultimate point (U) and limit point (L). In the case of
shear failing models, the ultimate point is replaced by the yielding point, which
leads to a model with three lines.
Table 1 shows the evaluation methods of the characteristic points of the side wall
model and column model. Herein, the cracking strength is assumed to be one third of
the yielding strength. The drift angles at yielding are assumed to be 1/250 rad. and
1/150 rad. for the side wall model and the column model, respectively. The yielding
strength is assumed to be equivalent to the ultimate strength. The limit strength is
assumed to be zero. These rough assumptions are introduced for simplification. Other
important points are discussed in Sects. 2.2 and 2.3.
1584 D. Kato et al.
Table 1 Evaluation methods of the characteristic points of the side wall and column models
Sidewall model Column model
Cracking Strength One third of the yielding strength
point (C) Drift angle Calculated with the initial stiffness
Yielding Strength Equivalent to the ultimate strength
point (Y) Drift angle 1/250 (rad.) 1/150 (rad.)
Ultimate Flexure Strength Equation (1)
point (U) Drift Equation (2) Minimum value of Eq. (2)
angle (m = 3.8) (m = 3.8) and Eq. (3)
Shear Strength Equation (4) Currently used design equation
Drift 1/250 (rad.) 1/150 (rad.)
angle
Limit point Strength 0
(L) Drift angle Equation (2) (m = 10)
The ultimate flexural strength sw Mu in both the side wall and column models is
given by Eq. (1) considering the effective sections shown in Fig. 1. Equation (1)
was introduced in AIJ Standard [1] and represents the maximum flexural strength
assuming that all tensile longitudinal bars yield.
X
sw Mu ¼ at ry jt þ N jN ð1Þ
where at , ry , jt and N denote the cross-sectional area, yielding stress of the lon-
gitudinal reinforcing bar in tension, distance between the longitudinal reinforcing
bar and the center of the concrete compressive zone, and the subjected axial force,
respectively. jN denotes the distance between the subjected position of the axial
load and the center of the concrete compressive zone. Refer to AIJ Standard [1] for
details.
In general, the ultimate drift angle is given as the smaller value of the two values:
the ultimate drift angle determined by concrete compressive failure of the edge of
the side wall subjected to compression and that determined by shear failure of the
member. However, regarding the column with side walls the ultimate drift angle is
usually determined by concrete compressive failure because the side wall is thin.
Thus, the ultimate drift angle sw Ruf is given by Eq. (2) in accordance with the
Restoring Force Drift Angle Relationship Models … 1585
proposal by Kato et al. [7] considering the concrete compressive failure of the edge
portion of the side wall. Additionally the ultimate curvature determined by concrete
compressive failure is given by the larger value of the two values: that considering
concrete confinement by transverse reinforcement (sw ;u1 ) and that neglecting the
confinement (sw ;u2 ).
sw Ruf ¼ sw Ry þ max sw ;u1 ; sw ;u2 tw
m sw eC 2 m e0 2 ð2Þ
sw ;u1 ¼ ; sw ;u2 ¼
j
sw e 3 sw ge sw D 3 sw g
where sw Ry is the drift angle at yielding, which is 1/150 rad., as shown previously.
tw denotes the width of the side wall. sw eC and e0 denote the strains at the maximum
stress of confined and unconfined concrete. sw je and sw D denote the depth of the
core and overall section. sw ge and sw g denote the equivalent axial load ratio of the
core and overall section, which are given in accordance with AIJ Design Guidelines
[2]. m denotes the empirically obtained coefficient and it is suggested to be 3.8 for
the conservative design equation of the ultimate drift angle.
The ultimate drift angle cl Ru in the column model is given by considering the drift
angle determined by shear failure of the member cl Rus in addition to the drift angle
determined by concrete compressive failure cl Ruf , as shown previously by Eq. (2).
Thus, the drift angle is given by Eq. (3).
cl Ru ¼ min cl Rus ; cl Ruf cl Rus ¼ cl Ry þ Rp ð3Þ
where Rp denotes the incremental drift angle after yielding until shear failure and it
is obtained in accordance with AIJ Design Guidelines [2].
The limit drift angle in the side wall model and the column model is also given by
previously shown Eq. (2) of the ultimate drift angle. However, the coefficient m is
suggested to be 10 for the conservative design equation of the limit drift angle in
accordance with AIJ Design Guidelines [2].
1586 D. Kato et al.
The ultimate shear strength in the side wall model sw Qsu can be obtained by Eq. (4),
the empirical shear equation based on the divided fiber sections proposed in AIJ
Standard [1]. The total section is divided into two rectangular sections: side wall
section and residual column section. For each section, the empirical design equation
Qsuw or Qsuc commonly used in practical design in Japan is applied. The shear
strength of this member can be obtained by summing these two values and the
contribution of axial load, as shown in Eq. (4).
The ultimate shear strength of the column model cl Qsu can be obtained by the
empirical shear equation used frequently in Japan.
The limit drift angle of the side wall and column models failing in shear can be
given by the same method of that failing in flexure discussed in Sect. 2.2.4.
The ultimate strength and drift angle of the side wall and column models discussed
previously in Sect. 2 are compared to experimental data presented in Sect. 4. Thus,
in this section, the determination methods of these points of the test results are
discussed. Table 2 shows the determination methods of the ultimate strength and
drift angle of the test results using the sidewall and column models. Figure 3
illustrates the concept of the methods.
In the side wall model, the observed ultimate strength is determined as the
maximum strength. The observed ultimate drift angle is determined as the drift
angle at the point where the observed restoring lateral force degrades to 80% of the
maximum strength. On the other hand, the determination methods in the column
model are a little bit debatable because the influence of the behavior of side walls
after failure remains for a while. Despite this issue, in this study, those are deter-
mined as follows. The ultimate strength is determined as the observed restoring
Restoring Force Drift Angle Relationship Models … 1587
Table 2 Determination of the ultimate strength and drift angle of the test results in the sidewall
and column models
Characteristic points Determination method
Side wall Ultimate Maximum strength
model strength
Ultimate Drift angle at the point where the observed restoring lateral
drift angle force degrades to 80% of the maximum strength
Column Ultimate Observed restoring lateral force where the drift angle equals to
model strength the calculated drift angle of the ultimate point of the column
model. (If it is not defined, the restoring force of the final
loading step is taken.)
Ultimate Observed drift angle where the restoring lateral force equals to
drift angle the calculated strength of the ultimate point of the column
model. (If it is not defined, the drift angle of the final loading
step is taken.)
Ul mate strength
of a column
lateral force where the drift angle is equivalent to the calculated ultimate drift angle
of the column model. Furthermore, the ultimate drift angle is determined as the
observed drift angle where the restoring lateral force is equivalent to the calculated
ultimate strength of the column model.
Herein, it must be noted that neither the ultimate strength nor the drift angle can
be determined using these methods when loading is terminated before the defined
point. For such cases, the restoring force and the drift angle of the final loading step
are taken for the ultimate strength and drift angle, respectively. Furthermore, if the
loading is not terminated and the ultimate strength and drift angle are obtained, the
assumed ultimate strength and drift angle must be smaller and larger, respectively.
1588 D. Kato et al.
Figures 4(a) and (b) illustrate the comparisons of the ultimate strength of the side
wall model between the modeled and test results. Figure 4(a) shows those of the
side wall model failing in flexure and Fig. 4(b) shows those failing in shear.
Furthermore, Figs. 5(a) and (b) illustrate the same comparisons as Figs. 4(a) and
(b) regarding the ultimate drift angle.
Figures 4(a) and (b) indicate that the modeled ultimate strengths approximate the
test results conservatively for both flexural and shear failures. On the other hand,
Figs. 5(a) and (b) indicate that the modeled drift angles underestimate the test
results more significantly compared to the ultimate strength. However, it is con-
cluded that both the calculated strength and drift angle can be applied
conservatively.
Figures 6(a) and (b) illustrate the comparisons of the ultimate strength of the col-
umn model between the modeled and test results. These figures are presented in the
same way as Figs. 4(a) and (b) regarding the side wall model. However, each figure
is divided into two figures classifying them according to the failure mode of the
column model. Hollow marks in these figures represent the specimens whose
1200 1200
Experiment
Experiment
800 800
400 400
0 0
0 400 800 1200 0 400 800 1200
CalculaƟon CalculaƟon
(a) Side wall model (b) Side wall model
failing in flexure failing in shear
Fig. 4 Comparison of the ultimate strength of the side wall models between the test and the
calculation (in kN)
Restoring Force Drift Angle Relationship Models … 1589
0.05 0.05
0.04 0.04
Experiment
Experiment
0.03 0.03
0.02 0.02
0.01 0.01
0 0
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05
CalculaƟon CalculaƟon
(a) Side wall model (b) Side wall model
failing in flexure failing in shear
Fig. 5 Comparison of the ultimate drift angle of the sidewall models between the test and the
calculation (in rad)
loadings were terminated before the defined ultimate points of the column models.
As for the ultimate strength, the assumed strength must be smaller if the loading is
not terminated, as previously discussed in Sect. 3.
Figure 6(a-1) shows the comparisons of the combination of the flexural failing
side wall and flexural failing column. This figure indicates that the ultimate
strengths calculated using the column model approximate the test results conser-
vatively even though two hollow circle marks may locate slightly downward. Note
that there is no specimen classified as a combination of the flexural failing side wall
and shear failing column, as shown in Fig. 6(a-2).
Figure 6(b-1) shows the comparisons of the combination of the shear failing side
wall and flexural failing column, and Fig. 6(b-2) shows the comparisons of the
combination of the shear failing side wall and shear failing column. Figure 6(b-1)
indicates that the modeled drift angles overestimate the test results significantly, and
it is concluded that the calculated drift angle cannot be applied conservatively.
Figures 7(a) and (b) illustrate the comparisons of the ultimate drift angle of the
column model between the models and test results. These figures are presented in
the same way as Figs. 6(a) and (b) regarding the ultimate strength. The assumed
drift angles shown by hollow marks must be larger if the loading is not terminated,
as previously discussed in Sect. 3.
Figure 7(a-1) illustrates those of the combination of the flexural failing side wall
and flexural failing column. Even though two hollow circle marks overestimate the
test results, they may be located upwards. Furthermore, considering that the ulti-
mate drift angles calculated using the column model almost approximate the test
results conservatively, it is concluded that the calculated drift angle can be applied
conservatively.
Figure 7(b-1) shows those of the combination of the shear failing side wall and
flexural failing column, and Fig. 7(b-2) shows those of the combination of the shear
failing side wall and shear failing column. Figure 7(b-1) indicates that half of the
1590 D. Kato et al.
800 800
Experiment
Experiment
400 400
0 0
0 400 800 0 400 800
CalculaƟon CalculaƟon
(a-1) Column model (b-1) Column model
failing in flexure failing in flexure
800 800
Experiment
Experiment
400 400
0 0
0 400 800 0 400 800
CalculaƟon CalculaƟon
(a-2) Column model (b-2) Column model
failing in shear failing in shear
(a) Side wall model (b) Side wall model
failing in flexure failing in shear
Fig. 6 Comparison of the ultimate strength of the column models between the test and the
calculation (in KN)
modeled drift angles overestimate the test results significantly, and it is concluded
that the calculated drift angle cannot be applied conservatively.
Figures 8(a)–(h) show examples of comparisons of the restoring force drift angle
relationships between the modeled and test results. The failure modes of the side
wall model of four specimens illustrated in Figs. 8(a)–(d) were flexure, and those of
Restoring Force Drift Angle Relationship Models … 1591
0.1 0.1
Experiment
Experiment
0.05 0.05
0 0
0 0.05 0.1 0 0.05 0.1
CalculaƟon CalculaƟon
(a-1) Column model (b-1) Column model
failing in flexure failing in flexure
0.1 0.1
Experiment
Experiment
0.05 0.05
0 0
0 0.05 0.1 0 0.05 0.1
CalculaƟon CalculaƟon
(a-2) Column model (b-2) Column model
failing in shear failing in shear
(a) Side wall model (b) Side wall model
failing in flexure failing in shear
Fig. 7 Comparison of the ultimate drift angle of the column models between the test and the
calculation (in rad)
other four specimens illustrated in Figs. 8(e)–(h) were shear. On the other hand, the
failure modes of the column model of eight specimens were flexure.
These figures indicate that the ultimate strength calculated using the side wall
model underestimates the test results, and the behaviors simulate the test results
around the maximum strength, which means that the side wall model can be used as
conservative design equations. However, regarding the column model the calcu-
lated restoring forces overestimate the test results if the column models fail in shear,
as shown in Figs. 8(e)–(h); although the calculated restoring forces underestimate
the test results if the column models fail in flexure, as shown in Figs. 8(a)–(d).
1592
Fig. 8 Comparison of the restoring force drift angle relationships between the tests and the models
D. Kato et al.
Restoring Force Drift Angle Relationship Models … 1593
5 Concluding Remarks
Methods to calculate the ultimate strength and the drift angle of the side wall and
column models are proposed. The backbone curves of the restoring force – drift
angle relationships of columns with side walls can be evaluated with these char-
acteristic points. The accuracies of the models are examined using a variety of
experimental data. The conclusions are:
1) Regarding the ultimate strength and drift angle of the side wall model, calcu-
lations underestimate the test results and are found to be useful for conservative
design equations.
2) Regarding the ultimate strength and drift angle of the column model, calcula-
tions underestimate the test results only when the failure modes of the side wall
model are flexure. Thus, the method cannot be applied when the failure modes
of the side wall are shear.
3) The evaluated backbone curve of the restoring force drift angle relationship of
the column with side walls simulates the behavior of the column with side walls
when the failure mode of the side wall model is flexure. However, when the
failure mode of the side wall is shear, the behavior of the column model should
be neglected.
References
1. Architectural Institute of Japan (2016) AIJ Standard for Lateral Load-carrying Capacity
Calculation of Reinforced Concrete Structures (Draft) (in Japanese)
2. Architectural Institute of Japan (1999) Design Guidelines for Earthquake Resistant Reinforced
Concrete Buildings Based on Inelastic Displacement Concept (in Japanese)
3. Iso M, Tajiri S, Sawai Y, Fukuyama H, Mukai T (2008) The research on the seismic behavior
of RC columns with side-walls - with different failure modes- Part 1 Outline of experiment,
summaries of technical papers of annual meeting, Architecture Institute of Japan (in Japanese)
4. Toshimi K, Kim Y, Sato M, Hyunseong H, Toshikazu K, Fukuyama H (2012) Evaluation on
deformability of reinforced concrete columns with wing walls. In: 15th world conference on
earthquake engineering (15WCEE), Lisbon (Portugal), 24–28 September 1 (No.2573), IAEE
5. Toshimi K, Toshikazu K, Kim Y, Toshinori K, Kunkuk Bae (2009) Tests on reinforced
concrete columns with wing walls for hyper-earthquake resistant system. In: Proceedings of the
3rd international conference on advances in experimental structural engineering, San Francisco,
15–16 October, PEER
6. Kato D, Kobayashi M, Takamatsu T, Oshio K (2015) Study on damaged RC school buildings
paying attention to columns with sidewalls. J Struct Constr Eng Architect Inst Jpn 80
(718):1931–1939 (in Japanese)
7. Kato D, Sun HY (2003) Evaluating method of post peak behavior of R/C columns with side
walls. J Struct Constr Eng Architect Inst Jpn, no 566, pp 97–103 (in Japanese)
8. Takahashi S, Yoshida K, Ichinose T, et al (2011) Flexural deformation capacity of RC shear
walls without column on compressive side. J Struct Constr Eng Architect Inst Jpn, No.660 (in
Japanese)
Seismic Response of RC Frame
Buildings Considering In-Plane
and Out-of-Plane Behaviour
of Unreinforced Masonry Infills
Abstract UnReinforced Masonry (URM) infills can significantly affect the seismic
response of frame buildings. Typical numerical models, however, do not account
for the In-Plane/Out-Of-Plane (IP/OOP) interaction that characterizes the damage/
collapse mechanism of masonry infills. The main objective of this study is to
investigate the seismic performance of RC frame buildings accounting for the IP/
OOP interaction of URM infill walls, using a refined nonlinear macro-model
recently implemented in OpenSees. To this end, the seismic performance of a
case-study building, representative of typical residential buildings realized in Italy
before ‘70 s, is examined, at different earthquake intensity levels, with return period
ranging from 30 to 2500 years. A set of fragility curves is then derived to express
the probability of exceedance of given building performance levels as a function of
the earthquake intensity level, considering (or neglecting) the IP/OOP interaction of
masonry infill walls.
Keywords Seismic performance RC buildings Masonry infill walls In-plane/
out-of-plane interaction Non-linear Time-history analyses
1 Introduction
UnReinforced Masonry (URM) infill walls are a common solution widely adopted
in Reinforced Concrete (RC) frame buildings for internal partitions and exterior
enclosure walls. Typical configurations of URM walls include single or double
layers of hollow clay bricks inserted in, and rigidly connected to, the RC frame.
URM infills are usually considered as non-structural elements, and are neglected in
the seismic design of the building. Past earthquakes, however, clearly pointed out
that the presence of URM infills can significantly affect the structural strength and
stiffness of the building, compared to its bare configuration, and modify the
inelastic mechanism of the structure. Moreover, URM infills can strongly interact
with the surrounding RC frame, triggering the brittle shear failure of RC columns.
In-Plane (IP) and Out-Of-Plane (OOP) failure are the two important brittle damage
mechanisms observed in URM walls during seismic events, both characterized by
degradation of strength, stiffness and low energy dissipation. Extensive damage to
masonry infills can jeopardize the usability and immediate occupancy of the
building after the earthquake with obvious important socio-economic conse-
quences, including large economic losses for building repairing [3]. It is also
important to note that the OOP collapse of URM walls is a very dangerous failure
mechanism because it might seriously threaten human life either inside or outside
the building.
In the last years efforts have been made to develop analytical tools and com-
putational macro-models able to capture the IP cyclic behavior of URM infills and
their interaction with RC frames. Based on experimental tests, Mainstone [5]
proposed a simple and low time-consuming macro-model based on the assumption
of an equivalent “strut” for simulating the in-plane global response of masonry infill
under seismic actions.
Experimental tests aimed at investigating the IP/OOP interaction of URM infills,
considering different slenderness ratio and load conditions demonstrate that the IP
damage can reduce up to 50% the corresponding OOP resistance, depending on the
slenderness of the wall (e.g. see [1]). Simplified expressions derived from the
observation of experimental results have been then proposed (e.g. see [7]) to esti-
mate the lateral strength and seismic demand to non-structural elements. Moreover,
efforts have been made to capture the OOP behavior of URM infills in RC frame
buildings when subjected to seismic loading (e.g. see [6]. Recently, Di Domenico
et al. [9] developed a refined lumped-plasticity macro-model, which relies on
appropriate degradation-modelling relationships, derived from experimental results
and empirical observations. The new model has been implemented in OpenSees [8].
In this study, the influence of the IP/OOP behavior of URM infills on the seismic
performance of older RC frame buildings is investigated. A suitable case-study
building has been selected and a refined lumped-plasticity model has been imple-
mented in OpenSees. Extensive Nonlinear response-Time History Analyses
(NTHA) have been carried out, using nine sets of ground motions, with increasing
seismic intensity. The comparison of results (with and w/o IP/OOP interaction)
clearly points out the great relevance of the OOP behavior towards the seismic
performance of RC frame buildings. Based on the results of this study, a set of
fragility curves are tentatively proposed to express the probability of exceedance of
different building performance levels as a function of the earthquake intensity level.
Seismic Response of RC Frame Buildings Considering … 1597
The influence of the IP/OOP interaction of URM walls on the seismic response of
RC frame buildings has been investigated following a four steps methodology:
(i) Step 1: Selection of case-study, Modeling assumptions, Ground motion selec-
tion; (ii) Step 2: Definition of seismic Performance Levels (PLs); (iii) Step 3:
Non-linear Time History Analyses (NTHA); (iv) Step 4: Derivation of fragility
curves for each PL, considering, or alternatively neglecting, the IP/OOP interaction
of masonry infills.
(a) (b)
periods ranging from 30 years (0.118 g PGA on soil type C) to 2475 years (0.467 g
PGA on soil type C), have been selected for NTHA. For each seismic intensity, a
set of ten ground motion pairs, compatible with suitable Conditional Mean Spectra
(Baker 2011), derived considering the M-R-e (Magnitude-Distance-Deviation)
disaggregation and a proper attenuation relationship for the city of L’Aquila, has
been used.
The seismic behavior of the selected case-study building has been described
thorough a refined 3D lumped-plasticity model implemented in OpenSees [8]. The
beam with hinges element has been used to describe the mechanical behavior of RC
members. Plastic hinges are characterized by a tri-linear cyclic hysteretic behavior,
described by the modified Ibarra-Medina-Krawinkler deterioration model, cali-
brated based on an accurate moment-curvature analysis of the critical cross section
of each beam and column. The plastic hinges of the short columns around the stairs
have been modified in order to capture possible brittle failure, considering the shear
resistance formulation proposed by Sezen and Moehle (2004). More details on
modeling assumptions are reported in Cardone and Perrone [3].
The IP behavior of masonry infills has been modelled using a “revised” Decanini
model (Sassun et al. 2016) assuming a compressive strength of 1.2 N/mm2, a shear
strength of 0.3 N/mm2 and an elastic modulus of 990 N/mm2, respectively. The IP/
OOP interaction has been captured using the macro-model recently developed by
Di Domenico et al. [9]. It consists of two rigid truss elements, aligned along each
diagonal, pinned at the outer extremities to the RC frame and connected at their
inner-ends, corresponding to the central node where a tributary mass of the wall is
lumped (see Fig. 2a). Two groups of 2n + 1 zero-length plastic hinges elements
have been defined in order to capture the IP/OOP interaction as a function of the
Interstorey Drift Ratio (IDR) and out-of-plane displacement. The first skeleton
curve corresponds to the “undamaged” URM infill, while the other 2n couples of
skeleton curves correspond to the “degraded” behavior of the infill, defined as a
function of the IDR and OOP displacement, respectively, attained in the other
direction.
During numerical analyses, the jump from one couple of backbone curves to
another is governed by appropriate semi-empirical relationships derived from
experimental results, which express the OOP stiffness, strength and displacement
capacity reduction due to IP damage and vice versa. A specific algorithm is
implemented in Opensees to remove from the structural model the macro-elements
when either IP or OOP collapse occurs (attainment of the ultimate displacement in
the relevant curve). Figure 2b shows the 2n + 1=19 IP and OOP backbone curves
adopted in this study to model the double layer (100 + 100 mm) clay bricks infills.
It is worth noting that, due to the large openings present in the masonry infills in the
X-Direction (see Fig. 1(b)), they have been neglected in the numerical model.
Seismic Response of RC Frame Buildings Considering … 1599
(a) (b)
Fig. 2 a Schematic representation of the macro-model used for URM infills; b IP and OOP
backbone curves adopted for the double layer infills considered in this study
Wa
Fh ¼ Sa ðTa Þ ð1Þ
gq
1600 M. Albano et al.
ZL UPD LS CP
With IP/OOP interaction Without IP/OOP interaction
2500 2500
2000 2000
Force (kN)
Force (kN)
1500 1500
1000 1000
500 500
0 0
0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50
Displacement (m) Displacement (m)
(a) (b)
Fig. 3 Pushover curves of the selected 8-storey RC frame building a with and b without IP/OOP
interaction, and corresponding Performance Points
Seismic Response of RC Frame Buildings Considering … 1601
4 NTHA Results
NTHA have been performed with OpenSees [8] on the same numerical models
adopted for POA. NTHA results have been processed by comparing the maximum
top displacements recorded during the analyses (average over 10 ground motion
pairs) with the top displacement associated with each PL, as derived from POA.
A given PL is deemed being attained for a given IM when the corresponding limit
displacement from POA (see Fig. 3) exceeds the average (over 10 ground motion
pairs) top displacement from NTHA. The OOP collapse of the first URM wall (first
condition for the attainment of LS, see Table 1) has been identified directly from
NTHA (again as average over 10 ground motion pairs). Based on the results of this
study, which focuses on a single 8-storey RC frame building, designed for gravity
loads only, and representative of typical residential buildings realized in Italy before
‘70 s, the following observation can be done:
1602 M. Albano et al.
– For this class of buildings, the ZL PL is attained for earthquake intensity levels
with return period lower than 30 years, due to the premature IP damage of
masonry infills;
– Taking into account IP/OOP interaction, the first OOP collapse of masonry
infills is recorded for an earthquake intensity level with return period as low as
50 years (IM2) at the upper storeys of the building (8th storey precisely). Then,
the OOP collapse spreads over almost the entire building, propagating down-
wards from the top storey to the 4th storey of the building (see Fig. 4);
– According to the simplified approach adopted in the current version of the
Italian seismic Code (NTC2018) for the verification of non-structural elements
(which is similar to those adopted also in other codes and guidelines world-
wide), no OOP collapse is expected up to earthquake intensity levels with return
periods as high as 2475 years (in the model without IP/OOP interaction, the first
IP collapse of masonry infills is observed for an earthquake intensity level with
return period equal to 975 years (IM8) at mid-height of the building);
– Accounting for IP/OOP interaction, the attainment of the LS performance level
occurs much earlier, almost at the same time (for the case-study building under
consideration) of the UPD performance level (see Fig. 3);
– The ratio between the spectral accelerations (Sa(T*)) associated with the
attainment of the LS PL, predicted by the model without and with IP/OOP
interaction, is around 3.
– Taking into account IP/OOP interaction, the CP performance level is attained for
an earthquake intensity level with return period of the order of 475 years.
Neglecting IP/OOP interaction, the CP performance level is not reached, in the
range of earthquake intensity levels examined in this study;
– At the lowest seismic intensities (i.e. IM2-IM3), the seismic behavior of URM
walls is mainly governed by the IP damage/failure mechanism (see Fig. 4(a));
while increasing the earthquake intensity level, the IP damage triggers the
premature OOP collapse of more and more masonry infills. As a matter of fact,
0% 0% - 20% 20% - 40% 40% -60% 60% -80% 80% - 100% 100%
IM1 IM2 IM3 IM4 IM5 IM6 IM7 IM8 IM9 IM1 IM2 IM3 IM4 IM5 IM6 IM7 IM8 IM9
S1 S1
S2 S2
S3 S3
S4 S4
S5 S5
S6 S6
S7 S7
S8 S8
(a) (b)
Fig. 4 Occurrence of collapse (either due to IP or OOP mechanism) of URM walls at each storey
of the building, recorded during NTHA at different earthquake Intensity Measures (IMs),
a considering and b neglecting IP/OOP interaction
Seismic Response of RC Frame Buildings Considering … 1603
the OOP collapse mechanism tends to govern the seismic response of URM
walls at the highest seismic intensities (i.e. from IM5 to IM9) (see Fig. 4(a));
– The OOP collapse mechanism strongly affects the seismic response of older
high-rise RC frame buildings. For the case-study under consideration, indeed,
approximately all the masonry infills of the upper storeys of the building (i.e.
from 8th to 5th storey, see Fig. 4(a)) are lost for an earthquake intensity level
with return period around 140 years (IM5). At the highest seismic intensities
(IM8-IM9), almost all the masonry infills of 6 storeys out of 8 (see Fig. 4(a)) are
collapsed due to the IP/OOP interaction;
– A completely different non-structural (and structural) damage scenario is
observed when IP/OOP interaction is neglected (see Fig. 4(b)). As a matter of
fact, indeed, no (IP) collapse of masonry infills is observed up to IM7. As a
consequence, using the traditional equivalent diagonal strut models (neglecting
IP/OP interaction), the seismic performance of the building is overestimated
(especially those relevant to LS and CP limit states) and expected losses sig-
nificantly underestimated (simply compare the percentage of masonry infills lost
at any IM between Fig. 4(a) and (b)).
To conclude, it is not possible to capture with accuracy the seismic performance
of older high-rise RC frame buildings neglecting the IP/OOP interaction.
A set of Fragility Curves (FCs) has been tentatively derived for the pre-70 RC
frame building under consideration. The spectral acceleration at the effective period
of vibration of the building (mean value in the two horizontal directions), Sa(T*),
has been selected as IM. FCs are expressed by a cumulative lognormal distribution
with median value 0 and logarithmic standard deviation (or dispersion) b. Each FC
provides the conditional probability of the structures to exceed a given PL. The total
dispersion b should take into account different sources of uncertainty including:
(i) record-to-record variability (br ), (ii) modeling variability (bm ) and (iii) uncer-
tainties in the definition of the threshold limits for each PL (bth ). In this study, a best
fit regression of the frequencies of occurrence of the accelerograms corresponding
to the attainment of a given PL has been performed to estimate the values of 0 and
br , considering and neglecting the IP/OOP interaction, respectively (see Fig. 5).
The uncertainty related to modeling variability, bm , has been derived from [2],
considering the quality/completeness of the two analytical models (with and w/o the
IP/OOP interaction). In particular, bm has been set equal to 0.1 for the model with
IP/OOP interaction and equal to 0.4 for the model without IP/OOP interaction. For
simplicity, uncertainties relevant to the definition of the PLs have been neglected.
The total dispersion, b, has been derived by combining br and bm with the SRSS
rule. The values thus obtained are reported in Table 2, for each PL, separately for
the model with and w/o IP/OOP interaction.
1604 M. Albano et al.
UPD LS CP
1.0 1.0
βr = 0.266 βr = 0.194
0.8 θ = 0.159 0.8 θ = 0.185
P(PL ≥ dsi)
P(PL ≥ dsi)
0.5 βr = 0.407 0.5
← UPD=LS θ = 0.634 βr = 0.352
0.3 0.3 θ = 0.613
0.0 0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Sa (g) Sa (g)
(a) (b)
Fig. 5 Fragility curves derived accounting for record-to-record variability for the model a with
and b without IP/OOP interaction
6 Conclusions
The results of this study clearly point out the great relevance of the IP/OOP
interaction of masonry infills with regard to the seismic performance of RC frame
buildings. Future research should investigate further RC frame buildings, including
buildings with different number of storeys and/or configuration of URM walls, as
well as buildings of different age of construction, in order to consolidate the results
and derive reliable fragility curves.
References
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Programme
A total of 8 circular RC columns were tested, and the objective of this experimental
program is to compare the effectiveness of CFRP and steel jackets for repairing
fire-damaged circular RC columns and investigate the impact of removing loose concrete.
All 8 circular RC columns were identical with a 300 mm diameter and a length of
1000 mm. Columns were reinforced by six 16 mm diameter longitudinal rein-
forcing bars with equal spacing throughout the cross-section, and confined by 6 mm
diameter spirals with 40 mm spacing throughout the length. The concrete cover was
25 mm for all columns. Figure 1 shows the cross-sectional details for the columns.
Fig. 1 Cross-sectional
Details of Specimen
Experimental Investigations of Fire-Damaged … 1609
Columns were divided into two groups based on the concrete strength. Group 1
was normal strength concrete group, and group 2 was high strength concrete
group. Columns from the same group were casted from the same batch in the same
day. The average compressive concrete strength at the test day for group 1 and 2
were 44 and 90 MPa, respectively. The condition for each specimen is listed in
Table 1.
8 columns were exposed to fire for 2 h in the gas furnace, and the temperature in the
furnace followed the ISO834 standard fire curve. One column from each group was
instrumented with four type-K thermocouples to investigate the cross-sectional
temperature distribution during heating and cooling procedure. Three type-K
thermocouples were embedded at concrete core, 50 and 100 mm from concrete
core at mid-height, and one was tied at the mid-height of a steel bar. The tem-
perature in the furnace was controlled by two type-K thermocouples attached on the
furnace walls. After 2 h fire exposure, the furnace was turned off, and the door was
opened to let columns cool down to the ambient temperature by air. The maximum
temperature at each location are summarized in Table 2, and temperature in the
column for both heating and cooling procedure is plotted in Figs. 2 and 3. Since
columns in the same group were fire exposed at the same time, it was assumed that
the temperature field recorded from the column instructed with thermocouples was
the same as the other columns in this group. The test results indicated that higher
temperature was developed in HSC columns compared with NSC columns.
1610 J. Xu et al.
Table 2 Maximum temperature in the column during heating and cooling procedure
Location cc (°C) 50 mm form cc (°C) 100 mm from cc (°C) Steel (°C) Furnace (°C)
Group 1 321.5 313.8 350.4 412.6 937
Group 2 380.8 375.4 406.2 467.2 931.5
cc—concrete core
After fire exposure, visual inspections were performed to each column. It was
observed that concrete cover was severely damaged and cracks were developed as
seen in Fig. 4. The HSC columns had larger spalling area compared with the NSC
columns (Fig. 5).
For columns N-FD-CJ2L, N-FD-ST, H-FD-CJ2L, and H-FD-ST, loose
fire-damaged concrete was removed by using steel wire brushes. To apply CFRP
jackets, oiled PVC pipe molds with 370 mm diameter were placed around
fire-damaged columns. High strength mortar was applied to fill out the spalling area
and enlarge the cross section diameter from 300 to 370 mm. After mortar cured,
PVC pipe molds were removed and two layers of uni-directional transverse CFRP
wrappings were applied to repair fire-damaged columns. For columns with steel
jackets, steel tubes with 370 mm diameter were used as mold, and high strength
mortar was applied to restore the original circular shape of the columns and enlarge
the cross-sectional area to 370 mm. All repaired columns were cured at room
temperature for one month.
Fig. 4 Side and top views for NSC columns after fire exposure
Fig. 5 Side and top views for HSC columns after fire exposure
1612 J. Xu et al.
After being repaired, all columns were tested to failure under axial compression
using a testing machine with 10000 kN capacity, and the loading rate was set as 1
kN/s. Two steel plates with 300 mm diameter were placed at top and bottom to
make all columns have the same loading area.
Test results of the ultimate capacity for each columns are shown in Fig. 6, and
load-displacement response for each specimen are presented in Figs. 7 and 8. The
failure mode for CFRP jacketing fire-damaged columns is CFRP ruptured and
concrete crushed. For steel jacketing columns, dilation of steel tube was observed.
Compared with NSC columns, HSC fire-damaged columns behaved more brittle.
3.2 Discussion
Based on the test results, both CFRP and steel jackets showed improvement on the
axial strength of fire-damaged columns. Table 3 summarized the increasing per-
centage of the axial strength for fire-damaged columns with different retrofitted
systems, compared with the fire-damaged reference columns. Steel jacketing shows
the best result on improving the compressive strength and the stiffness of
fire-damaged columns for both NSC and HSC. The axial strength was increased
more than 100% of the axial strength for fire-damaged reference columns. CFRP
jacketing also showed good results on the axial strength and stiffness improve-
ments. Two layers unidirectional CFRP can increase more than 50% of the axial
strength for fire-damaged reference columns. CFRP jacketing with loose fire-
damage concrete removed can effective improve the stiffness and the ductility for
NSC fire-damaged columns as shown in Fig. 7. For HSC fire-damaged columns,
CFRP jacketing with loose fire-damaged concrete removed showed higher com-
pressive strength. However, there is no significant impact on stiffness for HSC
fire-damaged columns with loose concrete removed.
1614 J. Xu et al.
Table 3 Comparison of axial strength improvement for fire-damaged columns with CFRP and
steel jacketing
Retrofitting system NSC HSC
2 layers CFRP jacket without loose concrete removed 87.8% 58.5%
2 layers CFRP jacket without loose concrete removed 95.7% 77.5%
Steel jacket with loose concrete removed 157.5% 104.1%
4 Conclusions
Concrete can be an effective shield for RC column during fire due to its low thermal
conductivity and high heat capacity. Large temperature gradient could be developed
between concrete core and concrete cover. Spalling is more significant for HSC
columns compared with NSC columns. Therefore, it should be properly accounted
for fire performance evaluations on HSC applications. CFRP and steel jacketing can
effectively improve the axial strength and the stiffness for fire-damaged columns.
Removing loose concrete has impact on the stiffness improvement for NSC
fire-damaged columns and improve the axial strength for HSC fire-damaged
columns.
References
1. ISO834 (2012). Fire resistance tests- Elements of building construction, s.l.: International
Organization for Standardization
2. Kodur V (2014) Properties of Concrete at Elevated Temperatures. ISRN Civil Engineering
3. Yaqub M, Bailey C (2010) Repair of fire damaged circular reinforced concrete columns with
FRP composites. Constr Build Mater 25:359–370
Evaluation of Compressive Arch Action
of Reinforced Concrete Beams
1 Introduction
Compressive action arch (CAA) in beams results from jamming of the beam seg-
ments between boundary restraints under vertical loads, which causes the beam to
form an arch between boundaries. A number of research studies have been con-
ducted on compressive arch action in reinforced concrete beams. It is found that
CAA can improve structural resistance by 30–150%, as indicated in the existing
studies [1]. Many analytical studies on the estimation of CAA capacities have been
proposed, among which the model by Park and Gamble has been widely accepted
by researchers all over the world [2]. In recent years, Yu and Tan improved the
model and calculated the load-deflection relationship of beam-column
sub-assemblages [3]. Lu et al. [4] presented an explicit method for beams with
and without slabs. However, the simplified equation overestimated the compressive
arch action capacity by assuming that the tensile and compressive reinforcement
had yielded. Moreover, the simplified equation can only be used for fixed boundary
conditions.
This paper proposes an analytical model for CAA of reinforced concrete beams
by using rigid-plastic assumption. In the model, different boundary conditions are
taken into consideration. Comparisons are made among test results and different
models to demonstrate the accuracy of the proposed model in predicting the load
capacity of beam-column sub-assemblages with various levels of axial and rota-
tional stiffnesses.
Park’s analytical model for CAA was derived based on a rigid-plastic assumption
[2], as shown in Fig. 1. In the model, flexural deformation was concentrated in the
plastic hinge regions at the beam ends, and equilibrium and compatibility were
established based on the deformed geometry.
In order to calculate the CAA capacity, the following assumptions were made in
the model.
(1) The critical sections in the plastic hinge regions remain plane.
(2) Tensile reinforcement has yielded, and the extreme compression concrete fibre
has reached its ultimate strain.
(3) The areas of the top and the bottom steel reinforcement remain constant along
the beam length, but the top and bottom steel reinforcement may be different.
Based on the assumptions, the equilibrium and compatibility of the beam can be
established, as shown in Fig. 2. Equation (1) shows the equilibrium of beams under
CAA and Eq. (2) expresses the relationship of the neutral axis depths, the beam end
rotation and the axial compressive strain.
where N is the axial force of the beam, T1 and T2 are the tension forces of rein-
forcement, Cs1 and Cs2 are the compressive forces of reinforcement, Cc1 and Cc2 are
the compressive force of concrete, at Sects. 1 and 2, respectively, l is the total
length of the two-span beam, b is the ratio of the net span to the total span l, eb is the
axial compressive strain of beams, t is the lateral movement of the support, c1 and
c2 are the neutral axis depths at Sects. 1 and 2, h is the height of the beam, and u is
the rotation angle of the beam.
When the beam is subjected to a concentrated point load, the axial compression
force and bending moments in the plastic hinge regions can be calculated in
accordance with the force equilibrium and compatibility. However, the model
generally overestimates the load capacity, as the rotation of supports and the actual
strain of compressive reinforcement was not considered in the model. The model
was later modified by [3] to take account of the effect of rotational restraint, but it
was only applicable to the plastic stage of beams.
T1 φ (1-εb)l δ
φ
1 Top
steel
c2 Cc2
Cc1 h C s2
c1
C s1
2
Botto
m ste
el
φ
T2
1618 S. Wang et al.
N
t¼ ð3Þ
Ka
M
h¼ ð4Þ
Kr
Top s
teel
ε's1 l1
c1 Inflec
tion p εc2
oint
εc1
l2
Inflec εs2 c2
tion p
oint
Botto
m ste
el
ε's2
ε's2
Evaluation of Compressive Arch Action of Reinforced Concrete Beams 1619
c1 0
ec1 ¼ 0 es1 ð8Þ
c1 as1
c2
ec2 ¼ es2 ð9Þ
c2 as2
0
where es1 and es1 are the strains of top and bottom reinforcements at Sect. 1; as1 and
0
as1 are the distances from the centroid of the top and bottom reinforcements to the
0
corresponding outer surface at Sect. 1; es2 and es2 are the strains of top and bottom
0
reinforcements at Sect. 2; as2 and as2 are the distances from the centroid of the top
and bottom reinforcements to the corresponding outer surface at Sect. 2; and ec1 and
ec2 are the strains of compressive concrete at Sect. 1 and Sect. 2.
Moreover, to calculate the whole load-displacement curve, the stress-strain
model for concrete proposed by Mander et al. [6] was utilised in the analytical
model instead of equivalent compressive stress block. Compression force in con-
crete was calculated through the integration of compressive stresses across the
compression zone. A similar method was employed to determine the bending
moment. A bilinear stress-strain relationship was determined for the tensile steel
reinforcement, and a linear unloading branch was also defined for the compressive
reinforcement, with its modulus identical to the elastic modulus.
With equilibrium, compatibility and constitutive models for concrete and steel
reinforcement, a set of solution procedures was proposed for the analytical model.
By assuming a rotation of the beam and the neutral axial depths, the strain of
reinforcements and concrete can be calculated through Eqs. (6)–(9). Equilibrium
and compatibility in Eqs. (1) and (2) are examined. If they are satisfied, the vertical
load applied to the middle joint and the associated displacement can be quantified;
otherwise, the rotation and neutral axial depths have to be re-assumed, until Eqs. (1)
and (2) are satisfied.
To verify the accuracy of the analytical model, the load capacities of beam-column
sub-assemblages tested by [7] are predicted by using the model. Table 1 includes
the material and geometric properties of the sub-assemblages. The load capacities of
F1 and F4 obtained from experimental tests were 40.5 kN and 40.1 kN,
respectively.
1620 S. Wang et al.
Park and Gamble [2] derived two formulae to explicitly calculate the neutral axis
depths at the beam ends, as expressed in Eqs. (10) and (11). With the neutral axis
depths, flexural theories can be used to calculate the bending moments and the axial
compression force in beams. The CAA capacity of beams can be determined from
force equilibrium. However, there are four unknowns in the expressions, namely, d,
0
eb , Cs and Cs , which hinder the further application of the equations.
h d bl2 2t T1 T Cs1 þ Cs2
c1 ¼ eb þ þ ð10Þ
2 4 4d l 1:7fc0 b1 b
h d bl2 2t T1 T2 Cs1 þ Cs2
c¼ eb þ ð11Þ
2 4 4d l 1:7fc0 b1 b
where d is the vertical displacement corresponding to the peak vertical load, b is the
width of the beam.
To use these two formulae in design, Lu et al. [4] assumed that all compressive
reinforcement had attained the yield strength, and thus the compression force in
steel reinforcement could be calculated accordingly. Besides, the vertical dis-
placement at the CAA capacity was defined as a function of the beam span and
depth, as expressed in Eq. (12).
Evaluation of Compressive Arch Action of Reinforced Concrete Beams 1621
50 50
Test results Test results
Analytical results Analytical results
Vertical load (kN) 40 40
20 20
10 10
0 0
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 0 30 60 90 120 150 180
d ¼ 0:0005 l2 h ð12Þ
In the following section, comparisons are made among the results calculated
according to different models. In the comparison, the effects of axial and rotational
restraints on CAA capacity and axial compression force are also studied through the
model. Note that the four parameters required in Park’s simplified equations are
extracted from the proposed analytical model, so that the neutral axis depths can be
directly calculated.
The axial stiffness of F1 and F4 were 1.0 106 N/mm. To demonstrate the effects
of axial stiffness, the stiffness is gradually reduced, as included in Table 2. It can be
observed that the CAA capacity and the associated axial force decrease with
decreasing axial stiffness. When the four parameters used in Park’s simplified
equations are taken from the analytical model, the analytical results are in good
agreement with the values predicted by Park’s equations. The average ratios of
vertical load and axial force are 1.018 and 1.022, respectively. It indicates that if the
four parameters are known, Park’s simplified equations can accurately predict the
CAA capacity and the associated axial force.
Figure 5 shows the comparisons of vertical load and axial force among different
models. It suggests that the effects of axial stiffness on CAA capacity and axial
force can be well predicted by using the analytical model and Park’s equations,
whereas Lu’s model is only applicable to beams with fairly rigid axial restraints. By
reducing the axial stiffness, Lu’s model tends to substantially overestimate both the
CAA capacity and the axial compression force.
1622 S. Wang et al.
Table 2 Comparisons of vertical load and axial compression force with different axial stiffnesses
Specimen Axial Beam Axial force associated with maximum Maximum vertical load (kN)
Stiffness depth vertical load (kN)
(N/mm) (mm) Park’s Analytical Analytical Park’s Analytical Analytical
model model model/ model model model/
Park’s model Park’s model
F1 1.0 106 180 185.7 197.0 1.060 35.8 37.7 1.053
5.0 105 180 172.8 179.9 1.041 35.3 37.1 1.051
2.5 105 180 154.0 147.4 0.957 34.7 35.8 1.032
1.2 105 180 127.4 115.0 0.902 33.6 34.0 1.012
6.5 104 180 88.5 91.1 1.029 32.0 32.4 1.013
F4 1.0 106 180 157.0 168.2 1.071 38.1 38.6 1.013
5.0 105 180 145.0 154.1 1.063 38.1 38.4 1.008
2.5 105 180 127.2 134.3 1.056 37.5 38.0 1.013
1.2 105 180 100.1 101.5 1.014 36.4 37.1 1.019
6.5 104 180 77.9 77.3 0.992 35.7 35.8 1.003
Mean value 1.018 1.022
Coefficient of variation 0.053 0.017
44 350
42 300
Axial compression force
Vertical force(kN)
40
250
38
200
36
150
34 Lu's model Lu's model
Park's model 100 Park's model
32 Analytical model Analytical model
50
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2
Normalised axial stiffness Normalised axial stiffness
(a) Vertical force (b) Axial compression force
Fig. 5 Variation of vertical load and axial force of F4 with normalised axial stiffness
The rotational stiffness of F1 and F4 measured during testing were 1.4 106 N.
mm/rad and 1.8 106 N.mm/rad, respectively. Table 3 shows the effects of rota-
tional stiffness on the CAA capacity and the axial force. It can be seen from the
analytical model that both the vertical load and the corresponding compression
force decrease with decreasing rotational stiffness. The effect of rotational stiffness
was not considered in Park’s simplified design equation, and thus, the axial com-
pression force predicted by the simplified equation remains nearly unchanged.
However, the vertical load can still be relatively accurately predicted through the
simplified equations.
Evaluation of Compressive Arch Action of Reinforced Concrete Beams 1623
Table 3 Comparisons of vertical load and axial compression force with different rotational
stiffness
Specimen Rotational Beam Axial force associated with maximum Maximum vertical load (kN)
stiffness depth vertical load (kN)
(N.mm/rad) (mm) Park’s Analytical Analytical Park’s Analytical Analytical
model model model/ model model model/
Park’s model Park’s model
F1 1.4 1010 180 185.7 196.9 1.060 36.3 37.7 1.039
7.2 109 180 186.8 181.0 0.969 36.0 37.0 1.028
3.6 109 180 188.5 174.6 0.926 35.2 35.8 1.017
1.8 109 180 186.4 166.7 0.894 33.0 33.6 1.018
F4 1.8 1010 180 157.0 168.1 1.071 37.3 38.6 1.035
9.0 109 180 156.0 167.5 1.074 37.0 38.1 1.030
4.5 109 180 155.4 161.9 1.042 36.0 37.0 1.028
2.2 109 180 149.2 150.8 1.011 34.4 35.3 1.026
Mean value 1.006 1.028
44 350
Axial compression force
42 300
Vertical force(kN)
40
250
38
200
36
150
34 Lu's model Lu's model
Park's model 100 Park's model
32 Analytical model Analytical model
50
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2
Normalised rotational stiffness Normalised rotationtal stiffness
Fig. 6 Variation of vertical load and axial force of F4 with normalised rotational stiffness
By using Lu’s method, the vertical force and the axial compressive load remain
at constant values of 41.7 kN and 258.9 kN, respectively. It should be noted that
similar to the effects of axial restraint, the discrepancies between Lu’s model and
the analytical model become increasingly large by decreasing the rotational stiff-
ness, as shown in Fig. 6.
5 Conclusions
In this paper, an analytical model was proposed to evaluate the CAA of reinforced
concrete beams with different axial and rotational restraints. The model was validated
against the experimental results of beam-column sub-assemblages. Comparisons
1624 S. Wang et al.
were also made among several models to show the effects of axial and rotational
restraints. The following conclusions could be drawn from the study:
(1) The proposed analytical model can accurately predict the CAA of reinforced
concrete beams in terms of the vertical load-displacement curve and the axial
compression force-displacement curve. However, iteration procedures are
required for the calculation, which makes it difficult to directly use the model in
design.
(2) The equations proposed by Park can be used to evaluate the CAA of beams if
the forces in compressive reinforcement, the axial compressive strain and the
vertical displacement of beams are known. However, it is challenging to
determine these four parameters explicitly.
It should be noted that the proposed model is developed by iterative calculation.
Accurate values can be obtained by computer calculation. Future studies are
therefore needed to investigate a simple yet accurate method or equations to
explicitly consider CAA in the design of reinforced concrete beams.
Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support provided by the
National Natural Science Foundation (No. 51608068), Fundamental and Frontier Research Project
of Chongqing (No. cstc2016jcyjA0450) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central
Universities (No. 2019CDXYTM0032).
References
Abstract The use of flat plate floor systems consisting of a post-tensioned concrete
slab-column system incorporating shear reinforcement within the slab-column
connection region has become increasingly popular in medium to high-rise build-
ings in Thailand. However, no experimental studies of bonded PT slab-column
connections involving shear reinforcements subjected to earthquake-type loading
have been found in literatures. Very few guidelines and little information are
available to designers for design the connections under earthquake loading.
Therefore, experimental data on seismic behavior of bonded PT slab-column
connections with shear reinforcements is needed. This paper presents the results of
reversed-cyclic tests to failure on a three-fifth scaled model of bonded
post-tensioned interior slab-column connections with shear stud. The main objec-
tive of this study is to investigate the seismic performance of bonded post-tensioned
interior slab-column connections containing shear reinforcements in the form of
double head studs. A lateral quasi-static cyclic loading routine, simulating earth-
quake actions, was adopted to investigate the seismic performance. Overall per-
formance is examined in term of lateral load-carrying capacity, maximum drift, and
stiffness degradation. The results show that the model with double head studs is
able to undergo up to 4.00% drift prior to failure and the mode of failure is flexural
punching failure. Comparing results with the model without shear reinforcement,
which has been tested earlier. The model with shear studs can carry more drift
capacity than the model without shear reinforcement approximately twice. The test
results from this study will be useful for seismic design and evaluation of seismic
performance of the entire slab-column frame building in the future.
Keywords Slab-column connection Bonded post-tensioned Shear stud Cyclic
test
1 Introduction
Post-tensioned (PT) slab is divided into two types; bonded system and unbonded
system. In Thailand, bonded system is much more popular than unbonded system.
Under earthquake type loading, it is widely known that brittle punching failure may
occur in the slab near the column due to transfer of shear forces and unbalance
moments between the slab and column. Hawkins and Mitchell [7] have shown that
the punching failure at an interior slab-column connection can sometimes initiate a
progressive collapse throughout the entire structure.
To protect slab-column connections from punching shear failure, several
methods were used in design practice. A common method is to provide shear
reinforcement within slab around the column perimeter as recommended by
ACI-421-R08. This method allows the use of shear reinforcement in the form of
closed-hoop stirrup and vertical shear stud. Nevertheless, the experimental inves-
tigation by Prawatwong et al. [11] has pointed out that under earthquake type
loading shear reinforcement in the form of closed-hoop stirrup may not provide a
significant increase in punching shear strength of the thin bonded PT slabs. Thus,
the use of vertical shear stud is an another choice. In case of unbonded slab-column
connections, a number of experimental studies were found in literature. [6, 8]. Ghali
and Youakim [4] suggested that the main advantages of using double-headed stud
are more efficient anchorage, simpler installation, less congestion of reinforcement,
more improved confinement, and more effective with thin slab. Recently, Yan Zhou
and Hueste [12] has reviewed of test data for unbonded PT interior slab-column
connections with moment transfer. The data shows that drifts capacity of PT
slab-column connections with shear stud are higher than without shear stud.
However, it should be note that the bonded PT slab-column connection with shear
stud has not been found in the review or any other researches. Therefore, the
seismic performance of PT bonded slab-column connections with shear stud is still
unclear.
This paper deals with reversed-cyclic tests to failure on a three-fifth scale model
of bonded PT interior slab-column connections with shear reinforcement in the
form of double headed stud. The specimen was subjected to a lateral quasi-static
cyclic loading routine to investigate its seismic performance through the elastic,
inelastic ranges and finally until failure. The effect of incorporating shear stud in the
PT slab-column region on its seismic performance was identified by comparing the
test results with those of connection model without shear reinforcement, which has
Cyclic Testing of Bonded Post-tensioned Interior Slab-Column … 1627
been tested earlier [10]. The results from this study will provide useful information
on cyclic performance of bonded PT interior slab-column connections with shear
reinforcement. It will be a guideline for structural designers in the future.
2 Experimental Program
Condo 5800 400 1200 0.31 15.43 2.18 0.23 3.20 0.18 0.35
Apartment 10700 300 600 0.39 12.66 1.59 0.42 5.10 0.24 0.63
Personal 5700 250 250 0.33 10.25 1.00 0.39 4.38 0.31 0.63
house
Average 0.34 12.75 1.57 0.35 4.23 0.24 0.54
Value
Specimen in this research
S1 (without 5000 250 500 0.28 18.29 1.70 0.27 – – –
stud rails)
SS2 (with stud 5000 250 500 0.28 18.29 2.00 0.29 4.42 0.42 0.50
rails)
*Detailed definitions of parameter can find more in ACI 421.1 R-08 and [10]
1628 A. Luckkikanun et al.
Figure 1 shows the dimension of the tested specimen. The typical span, story
height, and slab thickness of flat plate with shear reinforcement building in Thailand
were in the range of 5.70 to 10.70 meters, 3.00 meters and 0.25 m, respectively.
The test specimen was scaled to 3/5 of full-scale. At 3/5-scale, the span length of
full-scale prototype structure was scaled down to 4.80 m, the 3.00 m story height to
1.80 m, and the 0.25 m slab thickness to 0.15 m. The slab was supported along
each transverse edge by 5 pin-ended bars to simulate a moment-free boundary
condition. The validation of this model and assumption for interior slab-column
connections are well explained by Pan and Moehle [9].
Figure 2(a) shows the layout of bonded PT strands in the specimen. The strands
were grade 270, 12.7 mm (1/2 in) diameter. Every strand was tensioned to about
80% of ultimate strength (0:8fpu ). Eight tendons with ten strands were banded in the
direction of loading with a spacing of 300 mm, except the two strands located near
to the column had spacing of 290 mm. The other eight tendons with ten strands
were distributed uniformly in perpendicular to the loading direction.
Figure 2(b) shows the layout of bonded reinforcing bars in slab. The deformed
bars diameter 10 mm (DB10) were used for top and bottom reinforcement. The
minimum top reinforcement at least 0:00075Acf was placed within an effective slab
width of c þ 3h and extends away from the column face at least ln =6 in accordance
with ACI 318-14 (Sect. 8.6.2.3, 8.7.5.3, 8.7.5.5.1), where Acf is the larger gross
sectional area of the slab-beam strips in two orthogonal equivalent frames inter-
secting a column, and c is the column width, h is the slab thickness, and ln is length
of clear span. For bottom reinforcement, DB10 bar were mesh bottom bar was
provided as temperature and shrinkage reinforcement. In addition, the quantity of
slab-bottom reinforcement through the column head, satisfied the ACI-ASCE 352.1
R-89 [2], was provided in both directions.
Figure 3(a) shows column reinforcement detail. Twelve bars DB28 yielding
stresses of 40 MPa were continuous from bottom to top part of the column. The shear
reinforcements of the column were stirrups fabricated from bars type DB10 with
500
250
825
2500 2500
5700
5700
500
1335
C1+3h Top bars
500 12DB10 @80mm
(2000 mm Long)
300 500
300
300 550
4800 290 125 C2+3h
300 550
300 Top bars
ALL PRESTRESSING STRANDS DIA 500 10DB10 @80mm
300
0.5 IN GRADE 270K (2200 mm Long)
BOTTOM BARS
500 4DB10 PASS OVER THE COLUMN
All BOTTOM BARS: DB10 GRADE SD30
1335
LENGTH (N-S): 5600 mm LONG
500
LENGTH (W-E): 4600 mm LONG
ANCHORAGE
Shear critical sections
PLATE .
SECTION a-a
60
.
.
.
.
.
3DB10@60 mm STR
.
60
.
.
.
50 Column 60 210
.
.
.
.
530
.
.
.
3DB10@60 mm STR
.
ANCHORAGE
.
.
PLATE
.
DEAD
END 230 230
spacing of about 60 mm. The nominal clear cover for the column reinforcement is
15 mm. It is expected that the column could behave in elastic manner during the test.
Figure 3(b) shows the shear studs layout in the test specimen. All of them were
type 2 double headed stud following ASTM A1044/A1044M. Total height of stud
rails were 120 mm. From the average value of parameters related to shear studs, ten
1630 A. Luckkikanun et al.
stud rails were placed around the column. Stud spacing were 60 mm (0.5d). The
first studs were placed away from the column face 50 mm (Table 2).
Figure 4 shows the experimental setup. The simulation of gravity load was simu-
lated by a large number of sand bags. They were piled up on and hanged underneath
the slab in order to correctly simulate the gravity load effect. The amount and
distribution of sand bags were determined by finite element analysis such that the
computed gravity shear ratio ðVg =V0 Þ was equal to 0.28. After the application of the
gravity loading, the lateral load was applied to the top column by MTS servo
controlled hydraulic actuator mounted horizontally to a rigid reaction wall. The
hydraulic actuator was pined at its ends to allow rotation during the test. The bottom
part of the column was connected to concrete strong floor of the structural labo-
ratory. Torsional restraining systems were installed in both end of the slab to
prevent this rigid-body twisting of the specimen. The systems consisted of two wire
Strong floor
Hinge support Bolts Pin-ended link
Fig. 4 Experimental setup
Cyclic Testing of Bonded Post-tensioned Interior Slab-Column … 1631
50
3 4 1 2
40
DISPLACEMENT (MILLIMETER)
30
20
10 2
1 4
0 TIME
3
-10
-20
-30
-40
ropes on each side, which diagonally crossed from either of the slab corners to the
channel firmly anchored to the strong floor.
Figure 5 shows the pattern of lateral loading. A typical displacement controlled
cyclic loading test was carried out with monotonically increasing drift levels
of ±0.25%, ±0.50%, ±0.75%, ±1.00%, ±1.25%, ±1.50%, ±2.00%, ±2.50%,
±3.00%, ±4.00%, and ±5.00%. For each drift level, two completed cyclic dis-
placement loops were made.
During the test, all measurement data were recorded at each loading step. The
data measured and recorded in the experiment include: 1) lateral force and dis-
placement at the top column end, 2) strain in stud rails, 3) strain in top and bottom
bars of slab at various locations, and 4) strain distribution along some prestressing
strands. Photo were taken and at peak positive and negative drift every cycle of
loading to record the development of visible cracks on the top and bottom slab
surface. Five video security cameras were also continue recorded throughout the
testing.
Due to space limitation, only some results are presented in this paper. The relation
between lateral force and lateral drift is shown in Fig. 6. The first stage (0.00
to ±1.5%), hysteretic loop in every loading cycle was long and narrow, indicating a
limited ability to dissipate energy. Afterward, the second stages ±2.00%
to ±4.00% loop 1 hysteretic loop began to grow larger and lateral force has sat-
urated, indicating a yielding of the connections occur in this stage. The stiffness was
degrading down. The final stage punching, at ±4.00% loop 2, shows lateral load
1632 A. Luckkikanun et al.
decrease about 77% from peak load. The specimen has failed at 4.51% while
specimen was going to +5.00% loop 1. Lateral load decreased down from 100 kN
to 76 kN, suddenly. The specimen has failed by flexural punching mode.
Figure 7 shows comparing the backbone curve between the results from this
study and the model without shear reinforcement. As can be seen in Fig. 7, the
model S1, without shear reinforcement, could only withstand 2.0% drift. After the
maximum lateral load of 107 kN was attained, this specimen suddenly failed in
brittle punching shear and completely lost its lateral strength and stiffness while no
peak load saturation was perceived in advance. On the other hand, SS2 with double
head studs attained 65% higher lateral load-carrying capacity than the control
250
200
150
Lateral force, kN
100
50
0
-50
-100
-150
-200
-250
-6.0 -4.0 -2.0 0.0 2.0 4.0 6.0
Lateral drift, %
250
200
150
Lateral forces (kN)
100
50
0
-50
S1 without shear stud
-100 (Prawatwong et al. 2012)
-150 SS2 with shear stud
-200 (This study)
-250
-6.0 -4.0 -2.0 0.0 2.0 4.0 6.0
Specimen drift (%)
specimen (S1). In addition, the specimen SS2 with double head studs apparently
failed in a more ductile manner than the one without shear studs. As can be seen in
Fig. 6 and 7, SS2 exhibited a saturation of peak load for a drift of 2% to 4%,
indicating that flexural yielding took place long before punching failure. Until the
end of the test, the specimen with double head studs showed much higher drift
capacity at about 4% at punching failure than the one without shear reinforcement.
Acknowledgements This experimental work was conducted with funding provided by National
Research Council of Thailand (NRCT). The prestressing strands, ducts and anchors used in the
tests were donated by Concrete Products and Aggregate Company (CPAC) Limited. Double head
studs were donated by SNP Post-tension co., Ltd. For initial backgrounds data was supported by
Postteck Prestressing co., Ltd. Heartfelt gratitude is conveyed to them for their great supports in
the research program.
1634 A. Luckkikanun et al.
References
1. ACI Committee 318 (2014) Building code requirements requirement for structural concrete
and commentary (ACI 318R-14), American concrete institute
2. ACI Committee 352.1R-89 (1989) Recommendations for design of slab-column connections
in monolithic reinforced concrete structures, American concrete institute
3. ACI Committee 421.1R-08 (2008) Guide to shear reinforcement for slab, American concrete
institute
4. Ghali Amin, Youakim Samer A (2005) Headed studs in concrete: state of the art. ACI Struct J
102(67):657–667
5. ASTM A1044/A1044M-16a (2016) Standard specification for steel stud assemblies for shear
reinforcement of concrete
6. Gayed RB, Ghali A (2006) Seismic-resistant joints of interior columns with prestressed slab.
ACI Struct J 103(5):710–719
7. Hawkins NM, Mitchell D (1979) Progressive collapse of flat-plate structure. ACI Struct J 76
(7):775–809
8. Kang THK (2004) Shake table tests and analytical studies of reinforced and post-tensioned
concrete flat plate frames, Ph.D. dissertation, Univ. of California, LA, 309 p
9. Pan AP, Moehle JP (1988) Reinforced concrete flat plates under lateral loading: an
experimental study including biaxial effect, report UCB/EERC-88/16, Earthquake engineering
research center, University of California – Berkeley, California USA
10. Prawatwong U, Warnitchai P, Tandian CH (2012) Seismic performance of
bonded-post-tensioned slab-column connections with and without drop panels. Adv Struct
Eng 15:1653–1672
11. Prawatwong U, Warnitchai P, Luckkikanun A (2018) Cyclic testing of bonded posttensioned
interior slab-column connections with shear reinforcement, International conference on
continental earthquakes. In: 4th ICEE-0000000139, Chengdu, Sichuan, China
12. Zhou Y, Hueste MBD (2016) Review of test data for interior slab-column connections with
moment transfer. In: ACI-fib international symposium punching shear of structural concrete
slab, pp 141–166
Long-Term Experiments on Composite
Slabs Exposed to Different Surface
Drying Conditions
1 Introduction
Composite steel-concrete slabs are widely used throughout the world for building
floor applications and consist of thin-walled profiled steel sheeting, non-prestressed
reinforcement and concrete. Over the last decades, research carried out on the
behavior and design of composite slabs has mainly focused at the ultimate limit
state conditions, with particular attention devoted to aspects related to strength and
ductility, while only limited work has been dedicated to the long-term response
under in-service conditions [20]. This trend has changed in recent years with a
growing number of studies aimed at the evaluation of the time-dependent response
of composite floors, mainly triggered by recent experimental observations reporting
the development of a non-uniform shrinkage gradient that takes place through the
thickness of composite slabs, first noted experimentally in [3]. The shrinkage
gradient is produced by the inability of the slab to dry from its underside due to the
presence of the profiled steel sheeting. Subsequent work has focused at the char-
acterization of the non-uniform shrinkage profile and of the consequent long-term
member response, e.g. [2, 12–14, 19, 21, 23] and at the development of suitable
methods of analysis that have dealt with composite and post-tensioned composite
slabs, e.g. [8, 9, 22]. Most recent work in this area has focused at predicting relative
humidity profiles through the slab thickness and how these influence the
shrinkage-induced deformations exhibited by a composite slab. For example, the
analytical solution of the diffusion problem proposed in [17] was used in [1] to
determine the moisture distribution and consequent shrinkage effects in composite
slabs. The use of a hygro-thermo-chemical-mechanical model was proposed in [5,
6], based on previous work [10], to describe the relative humidity and temperature
profiles that develop over time through the thickness of composite slabs and to
adopt these for the determination of the shrinkage profiles to be used for the
structural modelling. The main difficulty in adopting multi-physics models to
capture the concrete time-dependent response relies in the identification of the
numerous material parameters required to describe the moisture and heat transfer
mechanisms. For this purpose, a robust inverse analysis procedure was proposed in
[5, 6] to characterize the material parameters and this approach was applied to
predict the deflections measured during long-term composite experiments in [7].
Among available design guidelines, the Australian composite code [4] provides
guidance on the effects of the non-uniform shrinkage based on a simplified design
model, e.g. [18]. Guidance is provided in [4] for the determination of the shrinkage
profile to be used in design. Its representation is based on a linearly-varying
approximation that is regarded acceptable for routine design [15]. The composite
standard allows the engineer to account for the possible beneficial effects induced
by the presence of surface treatments or floor coverings applied on top of the slab
that could influence the time-dependent drying of the slab and, consequently, the
occurrence of the shrinkage gradient. This possibility is available to the engineer
only if he/she can ensure that the surface treatments or floor coverings are to be
present in the constructed slab at the locations and for the duration of time assumed
in the design.
The European guidelines do not contemplate the need to perform design checks
for the service response of composite slabs associated to shrinkage effects [11].
Despite this, it is envisaged that these requirements will be considered for possible
inclusion in the coming code revisions [16] based on work carried out for the
Australian composite code.
Long-Term Experiments on Composite Slabs … 1637
In this context, this paper intends to provide new experimental data that aims at
demonstrating the influence of permanent surface finishes on the time-dependent
response of composite floor slabs. The vision at the basis of this approach is to
consider the possibility of achieving a structural composite floor installation in
which the drying components of time effects are reduced or eliminated by adjusting
the drying exposure conditions of the top surface of the slab. This is particularly
relevant to mitigate the influence of the shrinkage gradient that has been shown,
based on both modelling and experimental work, to significantly influence the floor
deflections of composite and post-tensioned composite slabs. To the knowledge of
the authors, the beneficial effects in reducing time-dependent deflections by
applying surface finishes has never been demonstrated experimentally.
In this study, a total of six specimens have been prepared and are currently being
monitored over time to observe the long-term behavior. Three samples have been
arranged in a simply-supported and the remaining three specimens consist of
continuous slabs. For each static configuration, three identical companion speci-
mens have been prepared and these only differ for the exposure conditions specified
on the top surface of the slab, varying from the condition in which the top surface of
a specimen is sealed immediately after casting to the situation in which the top
surface is left exposed for drying throughout the test. In the following sections, the
preparation of the samples is presented and it is followed by the outline of the
long-term measurements and by the discussion of the results. This work highlights
the possible beneficial effects in sealing the top surface of a composite slab in order
to minimize or eliminate the drying components of time effects and, in particular,
those associated to shrinkage.
2 Description of Samples
The experimental program presented in this paper includes the preparation and
long-term testing of three simply-supported composite slabs and three continuous
composite slabs.
The geometry of the simply-supported slabs is presented in Fig. 1a. The total
length of the samples is 3200 mm with an internal span between supports of
3000 mm. With this arrangement, each slab has an overhang of 100 mm at each
end. The width of the slab and its thickness are 634 mm and 120 mm, respectively,
as shown in Fig. 1c. The simply-supported samples have been denoted as SS1, SS2
and SS3. As depicted in Table 1, the top surface of specimen SS1 has been exposed
for drying from the time of casting (Fig. 2a), while the top surface of sample SS2,
initially exposed for drying has been sealed with wax and plastic after 37 days from
casting (Fig. 2b). Sample SS3 has been sealed immediately after casting (Fig. 2b).
The layout of the continuous samples is outlined in Fig. 1b and adopts the
distance between the roller supports already specified for the simply-supported
specimens. With a total length of 6200 mm, an overhang of 100 mm is present at
each end. The cross-sectional geometries are those adopted for samples SS1-SS3
1638 G. Ranzi et al.
120
Table 1 Summary of exposure conditions of the top slab surface of the samples
Sample Exposure conditions of the top the surface
ID
SS1 Exposed for drying
SS2 Exposed for drying till 37 days from casting and sealed with wax and plastic at
37 days from casting
SS3 Sealed with wax and plastic on same day of casting
CS1 Exposed for drying
CS2 Exposed for drying till 37 days from casting and sealed with wax and plastic at
37 days from casting
CS3 Sealed with wax and plastic on same day of casting
and depicted in Fig. 1c. The continuous specimens are referred to as CS1, CS2 and
CS3 and their exposure conditions are summarized in Table 1. In particular,
samples CS1 and CS2 have been exposed for drying from the time of casting, with
CS2 being sealed with wax and plastic after 37 days from casting. The top surface
of specimen CS3 has been sealed immediately after casting.
All slabs have been cast on a Stramit Condeck HP Profiled sheeting with
nominal thickness of 1 mm whose geometry is depicted in Fig. 3 [24]. The adopted
reinforcement reflected typical detailing for building applications. For this purpose,
a SL62 steel reinforcing mesh has been placed in all specimens in the higher part of
the concrete slab at a cover of 20 mm. For the continuous samples, two additional
Long-Term Experiments on Composite Slabs … 1639
sealed side
edges (typ.)
(a) exposed for drying on top surface and sealed with wax and plastic on side edges
sealed side
edges (typ.)
N12 reinforcing bars have been placed on top of the sheeting at the internal support
over the hogging moment region.
To reflect the continuity that the slab samples would have in a real floor, the side
edges of all specimens, i.e. SS1-SS3 and CS1-CS3, have been sealed with wax and
plastic as highlighted in Fig. 2.
A nominal 32 MPa concrete has been used in this study and, as for standard
practice, a wet curing has been carried out for 7 days for the samples exposed to dry
from their top surface.
All samples have been cast under propped conditions and, once the props were
removed after 14 days from casting, the samples have been monitored over time
subjected to shrinkage effects and to creep of the self-weight, as the specimens were
cast propped. The long-term tests are currently underway and the measurements
reported in this paper relate to the first 267 days from casting.
An overview of the long-term tests is depicted in Fig. 4. All specimens have
been placed in close proximity to each other to expose them to similar environ-
mental conditions.
300
1640 G. Ranzi et al.
RH-10,-20,-40,
T-10
SG-M-T T-60 RH-60,-110
SG-M-B LVDT-M
= =
3 Instrumentation Layout
Thermocouples (referred to as T-10 and T-60 in Fig. 5) have been used to gain
insight into the thermal variations taking place in the concrete, especially for the
first few days from casting. Relative humidity and temperature sensors (denoted as
RH-10, −20, −40, and RH-60, −110 in Fig. 5) have been included to capture the
time-dependent moisture variations and to collect information how the drying
process develops through the slab thickness. The recording of the latter measure-
ments started 3 days after casting. In the continuous samples, two load cells (re-
ferred to as LC-L1, -L2, LC-M1, -M2 and LC-R1, -R2 in Fig. 5) have been placed
at each support to observe the time-dependent changes of the internal redundant
reaction.
4 Long-Term Measurements
Fig. 6 Mid-span deflections measured for samples SS1, SS2 and SS3
1642 G. Ranzi et al.
Fig. 7 Mid-span deflections measured for samples CS1, CS2 and CS3
wax and plastic. After this point, the slabs have undergone a reduction in deflec-
tions for a period of time due to the redistribution of the humidity profile from a
highly non-uniform variation, with a pronounced drying component in the top part
of the slab, to a more uniform distribution.
5 Conclusions
This paper presented new experimental data describing the long-term behavior of
composite steel-concrete slabs subjected to different exposure conditions. A total of
three simply-supported composite slabs and three continuous composite slabs have
been prepared and monitored over time subjected to its self-weight and the asso-
ciated creep (as the specimens were cast under propped conditions) and to
shrinkage effects. For each static configuration, the three companion samples were
identical and only varied for the exposure conditions of the top surface of the slab.
One companion specimen was exposed for drying for the entire duration of the test,
while a second companion sample was sealed with wax and plastic on the day of
casting to prevent any drying to take place from the slab. The third sample was kept
exposed for drying until 37 days from casting, time at which it was then sealed with
wax and plastic.
These experimental results highlighted the beneficial influence in sealing the top
surface of the slab to reduce the influence of the drying components of concrete
time effects and, in particular, of shrinkage effects that have been shown to lead to
significant flexural deflections due to the non-uniform shrinkage gradients that
forms in a composite member due to its inability to dry from the underside of the
slab because of the presence of the profiled steel sheeting. The reported measure-
ments highlighted the beneficial effects that could be achieved in sealing the top
Long-Term Experiments on Composite Slabs … 1643
surface of a composite slab to avoid drying to take place to the environment. These
considerations have been based on long-term tests monitored for a period of
267 days from casting.
Acknowledgements The work presented in this paper was supported by the Australian Research
Council through its Future Fellowship scheme (FT140100130).
References
20. Ranzi G, Leoni G, Zandonini R (2013) State of the art on the time-dependent behaviour of
composite steel-concrete structures. J Constr Steel Res 80:252–263
21. Ranzi G, Ostinelli A, Uy B (2012) An experimental study on the shrinkage and ultimate
behaviour of post-tensioned composite slabs. In: Proceedings of the 22nd Australasian
conference on the mechanics of structures and materials (ACMSM22), Sydney (Australia),
11–14 December 2012
22. Ranzi G, Vrcelj Z (2009) Closed form solutions for the long-term analysis of composite
steel-concrete members subjected to non-uniform shrinkage distributions. In: Proceedings of
the 5th international conference on advances in steel structures (ICASS 2009), Hong Kong
16–18 December 2009
23. Shayan S, Al-Deen S, Ranzi G, Vrcelj Z (2010) Long-term behaviour of composite concrete
slabs: an experimental study. In: Proceedings of the 4th international conference on steel &
composite structures (ICSCS 2010), Sydney 21–23 July 2010
24. Stramit (2019) stramit.com.au
Shear Behavior of Steel Reinforced
Ultra High Performance Concrete
Members with Hybrid Fibers
Abstract Current design codes require a dense array of steel reinforcement for
shear-critical structural elements in earthquake-resistant structures, such as col-
umns, walls, coupling beams, and beam-column joints. However, this leads to
congested reinforcement in such elements during construction, which could cause
extensively prolonged construction and reduced construction quality. This paper
aims to investigate the potential of utilizing Ultra High Performance Concrete with
hybrid fibers to reduce shear reinforcement in shear-critical structural elements.
A series of beams reinforced with longitudinal steel bars and various combinations
of hybrid fibers were tested in a four-point loading setup. Two different shear spans
to depth ratio were used to evaluate the effect of the hybridization in the shear
response of the member. The test results showed that the presence of hybrid fibers
enhanced the shear cracking strength, ultimate shear strength, and crack width
controlled ability of the specimens compared to the monofiber beams. The results
also indicated that the hybrid specimen with a less volume fraction of fibers could
delay the appearance of cracking in the member.
Keywords Hybrid fibers Synergy Shear strength UHPC beams without shear
reinforcement
1 Introduction
investigated the synergy performance of hybrid fibers in UHPC. Juárez et al. [18],
Zakaria et al. [25], and Rafeeqi and Ayub [21] indicated that the use of hybrid fibers
could increase the tensile strength of the matrix, promote the multiple narrow
cracking patterns, and delay the initiation of critical shear cracks.
Banthia et al. [3] indicated that reinforcing concrete with short randomly dis-
tributed fibers could address some of the concerns related to concrete brittleness and
poor resistance to crack growth. Therefore, by choosing adequately the types of
fibers added to the mixture, several properties of the concrete might be enhanced.
Yao et al. [23] mentioned that the presence of one fiber enables the more efficient
utilization of the potential properties of the other fiber. Steel fiber on its own can
reach higher levels of strength for the matrix and contribute to crack control, but the
confinement effect granted by the hybrid with microfibers can lead to more durable
material. Jen et al. [17] indicated that fibers present in the fracture process zone
ahead of the crack tip could subdue and delay crack propagation, while fibers
incorporated in the crack wake provide a load transfer path to maintain load car-
rying capacity and restrict crack growth. Thus, hybrid fiber concrete will display an
increased post cracking ductility due to the process of crack control.
Due to the superior mechanical performance of UHPC, abundant studies have
been performed to investigate the applicability of UHPC for earthquake-resistant
structures, structural retrofitting and rehabilitation, and connections of precast
members. Nevertheless, while the tensile and compressive behaviors of UHPC have
been widely studied, the shear behavior of UHPC remain to be explored. In par-
ticular, the shear capacity of UHPC has to be adequately quantified before such an
innovative material can be applied to shear-critical members. In this research, the
shear behavior of UHPC beam members without stirrups was studied. The exper-
imental parameters included the amount and type of fibers and the shear
span-to-depth ratio of the beam. The synergy of the mixture with three different
types of fibers was studied. In particular, its effect on the shear strength of the beam
was investigated.
2 Experimental Program
The beam specimens had cross-sectional dimensions of 165 mm by 350 mm. The
length of the beam members was 1750 mm or 2300 mm. A total of 24 beam
specimens, with detailed dimensions shown in Fig. 1, were tested in the study.
Details of the experimental and design parameters are listed in Table 1. Three
different types of fibers were used in this study, i.e., short steel hooked fibers with
∅: 0.38 mm and length: 30 mm; long steel hooked fibers with ∅: 0.90 mm and
length: 60 mm; and PVA fiber with ∅: 0.038 mm and length: 8 mm.
Shear Behavior of Steel Reinforced Ultra High Performance… 1647
The mix components of the UHPC material were Type I ordinary Portland
cement, silica fume, silica sand, quartz powder, water and polycarboxylate-based
superplasticizer. The design water-to-binder ratio was 0.25 but it was slightly
adjusted for the mixes with different types and amounts of fibers in order for the
fresh UHPC to have an adequate workability. The UHPC compressive and splitting
tensile strength were obtained by cylinders, which were prepared according to
ASTM C172, fabricated and cured following ASTM C31, and tested following
ASTM C39 and ASTM C496. The mean fc0 was 116 MPa. The uniaxial tensile
strength of UHPC was obtained by direct tension tests on UHPC dogbone-shaped
specimens and the average uniaxial tensile strength ft0 was 4.1 MPa.
1648 M. Bermudez and C. C. Hung
1
* Note: The results of the test with No Fiber, 0.75% SF and 1.50 SF for a/d of 1.50 and 3.31 were done by Wen et al. (2018).
All beams failed due to the development of localized, diagonal shear cracks before
major flexural cracks occurred, except for L-75SF + 150LF that failed in flexure.
Figure 2 presents the representative failure patterns of the beams. The test results
were discussed in this section in terms of the shear strength and the influences of
fibers and beam slenderness.
Shear Behavior of Steel Reinforced Ultra High Performance… 1649
The obtained shear strengths of the beams were summarized in Table 2. The
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
highest shear strengths for the short and long UHPC beams were 1:74 f 0c ðMPaÞ
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
and 0:86 f 0c ðMPaÞ, respectively. These shear strengths were 2.2 and 3.4 times
greater than that of the control beams without fibers for short and long beams,
respectively. For beams with fibers, the lowest shear strength for the short beam
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
was 0:93 f 0c ðMPaÞ occurring to B1.5-F075-N; and for the long beam was
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
0:37 f 0c ðMPaÞ occurring to L—75PVA. Both beams had the lowest volume
fraction of fibers among the tested beams with fibers, i.e., 0.75%. It is worth
mentioning this level of shear strength was still 1.2 and 1.5 times greater than that
of their corresponding control specimens.
Figure 3 shows the relationship between the shear cracking strength and the volume
fraction of fibers for the beams reinforced with monofibers. It can be seen that
increasing the amount of fibers considerably enhanced the shear cracking strength
for the short beams whereas the effect was relatively minor for long beams.
For the short beams with Vf = 0.75%, the shear cracking strengths of the beams
were similar for three types of fibers. As Vf was increased, both short and long steel
fibers performed better than the PVA ones in terms of the enhancement in the shear
cracking strength. In the case of the long beams with Vf = 0.75%, the short steel
fibers led to a shear cracking strength twice greater than those of the beams rein-
forced with long steel fibers and PVA fibers. It is worth mentioning that for the long
Cracking Strength/
Cracking Strength/
Vf (%) Vf (%)
(a)Short beams (b) Long beams
Fig. 3 Relationships between the Vf and the shear cracking strength for the beams with
monofibers (in MPa units)
Shear Behavior of Steel Reinforced Ultra High Performance… 1651
beams, the short steel fibers at Vf = 1.5% led to a greater cracking strength than that
of the long steel fibers at Vf = 2.25%, suggesting the effectiveness of short steel
fibers in enhancing the shear cracking strength of UHPC beams. Overall, the beams
reinforced PVA fibers had the lowest cracking strength.
Figure 4 presents the effect of Vf on the ultimate shear strength of the beams
with monofibers. When compared to the results of the control specimen without
fibers, the ultimate shear strengths of the short beams with Vf = 0.75% were
enhanced by at least 20%, regardless of the type of fibers. In the case of long beams,
the ultimate shear strengths of the fiber reinforced beams were 1.5 times greater
than that of the beams without fibers. For the beams with a short shear span and
reinforced with fibers at Vf = 0.75%, the different types of fibers led to similar
ultimate shear strengths. When Vf was increased, the short steel fibers with
Vf = 1.5% led to an ultimate shear strength that was essentially the same as the
short beam with 2.25% long steel fibers and was 23% greater than that of the short
beam with 2.25% PVA fibers.
For the long beams with Vf = 0.75%, when PVA or long steel fibers were used,
the resulting ultimate shear strengths of the beams were essentially the same,
whereas the short steel fibers led to an ultimate shear strength that was 19% greater
than the other two fibers. Similarly, it can be observed that the addition of 1.5%
short steel fibers led to a greater ultimate shear strength than that of the specimens
having 2.25% PVA or long steel fibers.
The impacts of Vf and the shear span-to-depth ratio on the ultimate shear strength
for beams with hybrid fibers are illustrated in Fig. 5. It can be seen that for short and
long beams, the ultimate shear strengths of the beams with hybrid fibers were at least
1.8 and 2.8 times greater than that of the control beam specimen having no fibers,
respectively. The results also indicated that the combination of short and long steel
fibers in the beams achieved the greatest synergy, leading to the largest ultimate shear
strengths when compared to other combinations of hybrid fibers.
Ultimate Strength/
Ultimate Strength/
Vf (%) Vf (%)
(a)Short beams (b)Long beams
Fig. 4 Relationships between the Vf and the ultimate shear strength for beams with monofibers
(in MPa units)
1652 M. Bermudez and C. C. Hung
When Vf = 0.75%, it can be observed in Fig. 5(a) that different types of fibers led
to similar shear strengths of the beams. The influence of fibers on the strength
however became more obvious with the increase in the shear span-to-depth ratio;
particularly, the use of short steel fibers in conjunction with other types of fibers led
to a greater strength. When the Vf was increased to 1.50%, the hybrid fibers with
0.75% short steel fibers in conjunction with 0.75% long steel fibers led to a greater
strength than the 1.5% short steel fibers for both cases of a/d ratios. In the case of
Vf = 2.25%, it can be seen in Fig. 5(c) that for the short beams, the presence of
more short steel fiber in the hybrid fibers led to a greater ultimate shear strength
than the case when more long steel fibers were used. Interestingly, when the shear
span was increased, the beneficial effects of long steel fibers became similarly well
as the short steel fibers. The results also indicated that when Vf = 2.25%, the beams
with hybrid fibers had a higher ultimate shear strength than the ones with mono-
fibers. It can be seen in Fig. 5(c) that the beam with 0.75% of each type of fibers
had a shear strength close to that with 2.25% long steel fibers. Overall, the beams
with 2.25% hybrid fibers had an ultimate shear strength that was 1.4-2.2 times and
2.5-3.5 times higher than that of the corresponding ones without fiber for short and
slender beams, respectively.
Ultimate Strength/
Ultimate Strength/
Ultimate Strength/
Fig. 5 Relationships between the Vf and the ultimate shear strength for beams with hybrid fibers
(in MPa units)
Shear Behavior of Steel Reinforced Ultra High Performance… 1653
4 Conclusions
Based on the results obtained in this experimental study, the following conclusions
were drawn:
• The shear cracking strength, ultimate shear strength, and critical shear crack
width of UHPC beams without stirrups could be considerably improved by
using hybrid fibers when compared to the results of beams having monofibers or
no fibers.
• The study showed that when slender UHPC beams containing hybrid fibers with
Vf larger than 1.5%, it could provide a unit shear strength greater than
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
0:7 f 0c ðMPaÞ, even without the use of stirrups. The result implies that when
UHPC is used to replacement conventional concrete materials in shear critical
structural members, the amount of shear reinforcement could be fully eliminated
or greatly reduced. In comparison with the design of conventional reinforced
concrete beams that has an upper limit on the design shear strength of
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
0:83 f 0c ðMPaÞ specified by ACI 318 (2019), it was found that the shear
strength of the fiber reinforced deep UHPC beams could surpass the limit
without any signs of diagonal compression failure.
• The investigation also revealed that the most effective synergy of fibers occurred
when the short steel fibers were present. On the other hand, the PVA fibers
appeared to have the least enhancement in the shear strength of the UHPC
beams when compared to other types of fibers employed in this study.
• The combination of short and long steel fibers was found to be effective in
carrying the loads through localized cracks and delaying the shear failure.
Furthermore, the results of the slender beam L-75SF + 150LF demonstrated that
the proper combination of fibers could significantly enhance the shear strength
of the UHPC beam, which ultimately led to a flexurally-dominated behavior
even the UHPC beam had no stirrups.
References
1. ACI Committee 318 (2014) building code requirements for structural concrete. American
concrete institute, September
2. Banthia N, Gupta R (2004) Hybrid fiber reinforced concrete (HyFRC): fiber synergy in high
strength matrices. Mater Struct 37(10):707–716
3. Banthia N, Majdzadeh F, Wu, J., and Bindiganavile, V. (2014) “Fiber Synergy in Hybrid
Fiber Reinforced Concrete (HyFRC) in Flexure and Direct Shear,” Cement & Concrete
Composites, pp. 94–97
4. Fantilli AP, Kwon S, Mihashi H, Nishiwaki T (2018) Synergy assessment in hybrid
Ultra-high performance fiber-reinforced concrete (UHP-FRC). Cement Concr Compos 86:19–
29
5. Hung C-C, Hu F-Y, Yen C-H (2018) Behavior of slender UHPC columns under eccentric
loading. Eng Struct 174(2018):701–711
1654 M. Bermudez and C. C. Hung
6. Hung C-C, Hu F-Y (2018) Behavior of high-strength concrete slender columns strengthened
with steel fibers under concentric axial loading. Constr Build Mater 175:422–433
7. Hung C-C, Su Y-F, Su Y-M (2018) Mechanical properties and self-healing evaluation of
strain-hardening cementitious composites with high volumes of hybrid pozzolan materials.
Compos B Eng 133:15–25
8. Hung C-C, Li H, Chen H-C (2017) High-strength steel reinforced squat UHPFRC shear walls:
cyclic behavior and design implications. Eng Struct 141:59–74
9. Hung C-C, Su Y-F, Hung H-H (2017) Impact of natural weathering on medium-term
self-healing performance of fiber reinforced cementitious composites with intrinsic
crack-width control capability. Cem Concr Compos 80:200–209
10. Hung C-C, Chueh C-Y (2016) Cyclic behavior of UHPFRC flexural members reinforced with
high-strength steel rebar. Eng Struct 122:108–120
11. Hung C-C, Yen W-M (2014) Experimental evaluation of ductile fiber reinforced
cement-based composite beams incorporating shape memory alloy bars. Proc Eng 79:506–
512
12. Hung C-C, Su Y-F (2013) On modeling coupling beams incorporating strain-hardening
cement-based composites. Comput Concr 12(4):243–259
13. Hung C-C, Su Y-F, Yu K-H (2013) Modeling the shear hysteretic response for high
performance fiber reinforced cementitious composites. Constr Build Mater 41:37–48
14. Hung C-C, Li S-H (2013) Three-dimensional model for analysis of high performance fiber
reinforced cement-based composites. Compos B Eng 45:1441–1447
15. Hung C-C, El-Tawil S (2011) Seismic behavior of a coupled wall system with HPFRC
materials in critical regions. ASCE J Struct Eng ASCE 137(12):1499–1507
16. Hung C-C, El-Tawil S (2010) Hybrid rotating/fixed-crack model for high performance fiber
reinforced cementitious composites. ACI Mater J 107(6):569–577
17. Jen G, Trono W, Ostertag CP (2016) Self-consolidating hybrid fiber reinforced concrete:
development, properties and composite behavior. Constr Build Mater 104:63–71
18. Juárez C, Valdez P, Durán A, Sobolev K (2007) The diagonal tension behavior of fiber
reinforced concrete beams. Cement Concr Compos 29(5):402–408
19. Li VC (2012) Tailoring ECC for special attributes: a review. Int J Concr Struct Mater 6
(3):135–144
20. Naaman AE, Reinhardt HW (1996) Characterization of high performance fiber reinforced
cement composites—HPFRCC. In: High performance fiber reinforced cement composites
(Vol. 2, pp. 1–24)
21. Rafeeqi SFA, Ayub T (2013) Behaviour of reinforced concrete beams detailed for shear in
compliance with compressive force path method. NED Univ J of Res 10(1):13
22. Wen K (2018) Shear behavior of ultra high performance fiber reinforced concrete beam.
Master Thesis, Department of Civil Engineering, National Cheng Kung University, Taiwan
23. Yao W, Li J, Wu K (2003) Mechanical properties of hybrid fiber-reinforced concrete atlow
fiber volume fraction. Cement and Concrete Research 33(1):27–30
24. Yoo DY, Yoon YS (2016) A review on structural behavior, design, and application of
ultra-high-performance fiber-reinforced concrete. Int J Concr Struct Mater 10(2):125–142
25. Zakaria M, Ueda T, Wu Z, Meng L (2009) Experimental investigation on shear cracking
behavior in reinforced concrete beams with shear reinforcement. J Adv Concr Technol 7
(1):79–96
Experimental Study on Compressive
Response of Large Rupture Strain FRP
Confined Reinforced Concrete
1 Introduction
S. Saleem
Department of Civil Engineering, University of Engineering and Technology,
Taxila 47080, Pakistan
e-mail: shahzad.saleem@uettaxila.edu.pk
A. Pimanmas (&)
Department of Civil Engineering, Kasetsart University, Bangkok 10900, Thailand
e-mail: amorn.pi@ku.th
2 Experimental Program
In this study, experimental results of eight square specimens tested under mono-
tonic axial compression are presented. Among these specimens, two specimens
served as the control specimens. The variable of this study is the number of
PET FRP layers (one, two and three). The details of the specimens and test results
are given in Fig. 1(a) and Table 1, respectively. The height of all specimens was
325 mm. The specimens were cast in square molds. The molds were manufactured
with plywood sheets with 26 mm corner radius, as shown in Fig. 1(b). The 26 mm
corner radius represents a well-rounded corner.
In the specimens’ designation, first capital letter S represents the square speci-
mens followed by a numeric digit in subscript which indicates the first or second
identical specimen. The next capital letter U represents the unsupported length of
longitudinal steel bars followed by a numeric digit in subscript which indicates the
unsupported length in mm. The last capital letter L represents the PET FRP layers
followed by a numeric digit which indicates the number of PET FRP layers.
The mechanical properties of PET FRP are similar to those reported in Saleem
et al. [9], and their tensile stress-strain curves obtained from the coupon test are
reproduced in Fig. 2. As shown in Fig. 1(a), four longitudinal steel bars with
10 mm diameter were used in each column. This corresponds to a reinforcement
ratio of 1.43%. The unsupported length of 155 mm corresponds to a slenderness
ratio of 15.5 which represents maximum chances of bar buckling. For steel ties,
plain bars with 6 mm diameter were used.
150 x 150 R = 26
4 # 10
#6
155
325
L/D = 15.5
(a) (b)
Fig. 1 a Specimens details, b Rounded corners of square mold
1658 S. Saleem and A. Pimanmas
The specimens in each series were wrapped with one, two and three PET FRP
layers by the wet layup process. A minimum overlap length of 150 mm was pro-
vided to avoid any possible slippage. Both ends of each specimen were additionally
strengthened by roving carbon fiber to avoid any local failure.
To measure the strains in longitudinal steel bars, two 5 mm gauge length strain
gauges were fixed at the middle height on the inner and outer sides of two diag-
onally opposite steel bars. To measure the strains in steel ties near the both ends of
unsupported segment of longitudinal bars, two 5 mm gauge length strain gauges
were fixed on each tie at the outer face on opposite sides. The location of strain
gauges on steel cage is shown in Fig. 1(a).
In this study, linear variable differential transducers (LVDTs) were also used to
measure the axial and horizontal displacements. It is to be noted that, to avoid
recording the closing of gap between the specimen’s top surface and steel plate, two
Experimental Study on Compressive Response … 1659
steel bars were welded on the top of two diagonally opposite longitudinal steel bars
and were projected out, as shown in Fig. 1(a). Two horizontal LVDTs were placed
at the middle of two opposite flat sides while two horizontal LVDTs were placed at
opposite corners in the diagonal direction. The confined specimens were tested
under displacement controlled manner at a rate of 0.5 mm/min. The test data
including all LVDTs and strain gauges were recorded automatically by using a data
logger to a computer. Test setup and position of LVDTs are shown in Fig. 3.
3 Test Results
The typical failure modes of unconfined RC square specimens are shown in Fig. 4.
Small vertical cracks first appeared close to the top end of specimens when the load
reached near the peak strength. These cracks grew faster after crossing the peak
strength and projected down towards the mid height of specimens. After the for-
mation of major vertical cracks in the concrete cover, the longitudinal steel rein-
forcement buckled and resulted in a major almost vertical crack around the corner
zone, as shown in Fig. 4(a). At further axial deformation, concrete cover was
completely separated from the intact concrete core. No stirrup opening was
observed as the concrete damage was more concentrated with in the central zone.
Figure 4(b-c) show the failed RC square specimens.
The failure modes of confined specimens are shown in Fig. 5. For specimen
S1U155L1, PET FRP overlap debonding occurred (Fig. 5(a)). For this specimen,
local interfacial failure between FRP and concrete surface was observed above and
below the mid-height section. For the other specimens, FRP ruptured at the corner
locations quietly. For all the confined specimens, after removing the FRP shell and
loose concrete, the inside longitudinal steel bars were found to be buckled badly in
the central zone, as shown in Fig. 5(b, e and h). It is interesting to note that, unlike
in unconfined specimens, in PET FRP-confined specimens the lateral deformation
of buckled bars was significantly reduced and buckling was concentrated over the
short length in the mid-height of unsupported bars. The transverse stirrups remained
closed. The inside concrete core was found badly crushed and fragmented.
Figure 5(c, f and i) shows the FRP-concrete interface after failure. Some concrete
was still attached with FRP, particularly around the corner location which shows the
presence of a good bond between FRP and cover concrete.
1660 S. Saleem and A. Pimanmas
The effect of PET FRP layers on the force-strain response of confined specimens is
shown in Fig. 6(a). It can be seen that the compressive response of both unconfined
and confined specimens is almost identical in the first ascending part; however, the
stiffness of confined specimens is slightly higher than the unconfined specimens.
In PET FRP-confined specimens, the concrete in central zone was also confined by
FRP; hence, exhibited slightly high stiffness.
After the unconfined peak strength (Fco), the curve continued to ascend in the
transition zone, although with gradually reducing slope until the peak strength (Fcc)
is reached. It can be seen in Fig. 6(a) that the slope of the transition zone and the
peak strength as well as the corresponding axial strain were increased with an
increase in number of PET FRP layers. However, external confinement of one
PET FRP layer was not sufficient to further delay the stiffness degradaion due to bar
Experimental Study on Compressive Response … 1661
1000 1L
S2U155L2 600
800 0L
600 400
S2U155L1
400
S2U155L0 S1U155L1 200
200 S1U155L0
0 0
-0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 -0.01 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 0.1
-200 -200
Axial strain Longitudinal bar strain
(a) (b)
buckling. As a result, after the peak strength a slight strength softening was
observed in specimens S1U155L1 and S2U155L1. In specimens S1U155L2 and
S2U155L2, no strength softening was observed after the transition zone, whereas in
specimens S1U155L3 and S2U155L3, confined by three PET FRP layers, the curve
continued to ascend with a much reduced slope compared to the transition zone.
It is interesting to note in Fig. 6(b) that the onset of buckling was delayed to
higher load level with an increase in FRP layers. Table 1 shows that the average
ultimate strength ratio ðFcu =Fco Þavg was 1.40, 2.25 and 3.02 for one, two and three
PET FRP layers, respectively. Similarly, the average strain enhancement ratio
ðecu =eco Þavg for these specimens was 19.79, 23.23 and 27.88.
The effect of PET FRP layers on the lateral strain-axial strain response of square
specimens is shown Fig. 7(a). An interesting observation in these figures is the
significant difference between the lateral expansions measured in the two directions,
as also observed for PET FRP-confined plain concrete column specimens in Saleem
et al. [10], which clearly shows highly non-uniform damage of concrete core. The
0.18 2.5
3 L-middle Control
0.16 1 L-middle
2 L-middle
Poisson's ratio
0.14 2
Lateral strain
2 L-middle 3 L-middle
0.12
1 L-middle
0.1 1.5
0.08 1 L-corner
1 L-corner 1
0.06 Control 2 L-corner 2 L-corner
0.04 3 L-corner 0.5 3 L-corner
0.02
0 0
-0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 -0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12
Axial strain Axial strain
(a) (b)
first linear portion had a very small and similar slope in both directions, however,
the steepness of the transition zone was reduced with an increase in number of
PET FRP layers, particularly on the flat sides. It is also noticed in Fig. 7(a) for the
second linear segment that with an increase in number of PET FRP layers, the
expansion was efficiently restrained for a given axial strain level.
Figure 7(b) shows the effect of PET FRP layers on the variation of Poisson’s ratio
along the axial strain history of confined specimens. These figures clearly show that
the peak Poisson’s ratio measured on the flat side is remarkably higher than that
measured in the diagonal direction. In addition, the peak value was reduced sig-
nificantly when the number of PET FRP layers was increased from one to three.
After the peak value, the instability of the Poisson’s ratio was then recovered
gradually as the PET FRP effective confinement was increased, reaching a stable
lower value until FRP ruptured. The recovery in unstable Poisson’s ratio was more
obvious in specimens confined with 1 PET FRP layer.
The dilation rate of these specimens is shown in Fig. 8. It can be observed that the
dilation rate was considerably higher in the middle of flat sides than in the diagonal
direction. This figure shows that the dilation rate, particularly the peak value,
decreased as the number of PET FRP layers increased, as also observed for PET
FRP-confined plain concrete specimens [8]. Interestingly, at the failure of specimen
with 1 FRP layer, the dilation rate was almost similar for all the specimens with
different number of PET FRP layers.
5
1 L-middle
4
2 L-middle
3 3 L-middle
Dilation rate
1 L-corner 2 L-corner
3 L-corner
2
0
-0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12
-1 Axial strain
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Maeda Kosen Co. LTD.-Japan, Prof.
Tamon Ueda from Hokkaido University and Mr. Nakai Hiroshi for their assistance and gra-
ciousness in providing the necessary materials (PET FRP) for this experimental study.
References
1. Bai YL, Dai JG, Teng JG (2017) Buckling of steel reinforcing bars in FRP-confined RC
columns: an experimental study. Constr Build Mater 140:403–415
2. Bai YL, Dai JG, Teng JG (2017) Monotonic stress–strain behavior of steel rebars embedded
in FRP-confined concrete including buckling. J Compos Constr 21(5):04017043
3. Bai YL, Dai JG, Ozbakkaloglu T (2017) Cyclic stress-strain model incorporating buckling
effect for steel reinforcing bars embedded in FRP-confined concrete. Compos Struct 182:54–66
4. Dai JG, Bai YL, Teng JG (2011) Behavior and modeling of concrete confined with FRP
composites of large deformability. J Compos Constr 15(6):963–973
5. Ilki A, Kumbasar N, Koc V (2004) Low strength concrete members externally confined with
FRP sheets. Struct Eng Mech 18(2):167–194
Experimental Study on Compressive Response … 1665
6. Ispir M (2014) Monotonic and cyclic compression tests on concrete confined with PET-FRP.
J Compos Constr 19(1):04014034
7. Lam L, Teng JG (2003) Design-oriented stress-strain model for FRP-confined concrete in
rectangular columns. J Reinf Plast Compos 22(13):1149–1186
8. Pimanmas A, Saleem S (2018) Dilation characteristics of PET FRP–confined concrete.
J Compos Constr 22(3):04018006
9. Saleem S, Qudeer H, Amorn P (2017) Compressive behavior of PET FRP–confined circular,
square, and rectangular concrete columns. J Compos Constr 21(3):04016097
10. Saleem S, Pimanmas A, Rattanapitikon W (2018) Lateral response of PET FRP-confined
concrete. Constr Build Mater 159:390–407
11. Tastani SP, Pantazopoulou SJ (2004) Experimental evaluation of FRP jackets in upgrading
RC corroded columns with substandard detailing. Eng Struct 26(6):817–829
12. Tastani SP, Pantazopoulou SJ, Zdoumba D, Plakantaras V, Akritidis E (2006) Limitations of
FRP jacketing in confining old-type reinforced concrete members in axial compression.
J Compos Constr 10(1):13–25
Effects of Web Position on Shear
Resistance Mechanism of Ultra High
Strength Fiber Reinforced Concrete
(UFC) Beams
Abstract The objective of this study is to clarify the effects of web position on the
shear resistance mechanism of Ultra High Strength Fiber Reinforced Concrete
(UFC) beams. Four-point bending tests were conducted on total three beams with
different web positions, i.e. centered web, two webs arranged at the quarter of the
flange and two webs at the edge of the flange. The results revealed the structural
performances such as shear capacity, flexural rigidity, displacement at the shear
failure and post peak behavior differed in each specimen. The different structural
performances can be explained by the difference in the area resisting the shear force,
which is determined by the existence of flange overhang and whether webs were
distributed in the flange.
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Outline
Figures 1 and 2 show the outline and the pictures of all three specimens in this
study. Table 1 summarizes the specimen details. All three specimens were designed
to fail in shear. Since the web width was defined as the sum of width of two webs in
II-beam and Box-beam, which is 60 mm, the parameter was only the web position.
Therefore, the structural performances such as the stiffness and the shear capacity of
each specimen became same in theory by assuming that all cross section was
effective. A small hunch was created on the boundaries between webs and flanges
for reducing the stress concentration. The sheaths were arranged at the appropriate
positions on the tensile flange during casting. After removing the formwork, the
tensile steel bars were inserted and all sheaths were filled with grouting material.
Tables 2 and 3 summarize the mix proportion of UFC and the mechanical
properties of tensile steel bars and steel fibers. The combination of 15 mm and
22 mm short steel fibers with diameter of 0.2 mm were used.
(a) I- beam (b) II- beam (c) Box-beam (d) Side view
Table 2 Mix proportion of Air [%] Unit weight [kg/m3] Fiber [kg]
UFC
W C S SP
2.0 195 1287 905 32.2 137.4
W: Water, C: Premix binder
S: Sand, SP: Superplasticizer
Static four-point bending tests with simply supported condition were conducted
on all specimens. Teflon sheets and silicon grease were inserted between the
specimen and the supports to prevent the horizontal friction. During the loading
tests, the applied load and the displacement at the mid span were measured.
3 Experimental Results
700
II-beam
600 Box-beam
500
Load (kN)
400 I-beam
300
200 Diagonal
cracking load
100
0 Ultimate load
0 5 10 15 20
Displacement (mm)
specimens was determined as the shear failure. The calculated shear capacity is
obtained by Eq. (1)–(3) based on the UFC guideline.
Vf ¼ fv cotbu bw z ð3Þ
where, Vu cal : calculated shear capacity (N), Vrpc : shear carried by matrix (N), Vf :
0
shear carried by fiber (N), fc : compressive strength (N/mm2), bw : web width (mm),
d: effective depth (mm), fv : average tensile strength (=7.35 N/mm2), bu : angle of the
diagonal crack (=40°), z: lever arm length (=d/1.15).
From Fig. 3 and Table 4, it was observed that the shear capacity, the flexural
rigidity, the displacement at the shear failure and the post peak behavior were
different in each specimen. Comparisons of them are mentioned below.
Effects of Web Position on Shear Resistance Mechanism … 1671
The shear capacity of II-beam was the highest in all specimens, which was 1.26 and
1.11 times higher than that of I-beam and Box-beam, respectively. The shear
capacity of I-beam was the lowest. The experimental shear capacity of all speci-
mens greatly exceeded the calculated values, which were 1.47 to 1.87 times higher
as listed in Table 4.
The initial flexural rigidity of II-beam was slightly larger than that of the other
specimens as shown in Fig. 3. After diagonal cracks appeared at the load around
170 kN, the flexural rigidity of each specimen declined and the difference of the
flexural rigidity between II-beam and the other two specimens became larger. The
flexural rigidity of I-beam and Box-beam were almost same until the load around
400 kN.
In Box-beam, the load kept increasing even after the displacement became over
13 mm as shown in Fig. 3 and the shear failure occurred at the displacement of
16.8 mm. On the other hand, in I-beam and II-beam, the shear failure occured at the
displacement of around 13.1 mm. Therefore, it can be considered that the defor-
mation performance of Box-beam was better than that of other specimens.
In I-beam, the load decreased gradually after the ultimate load with continuously
increasing the displacement. On the other hand, in II-beam and Box-beam, the load
decreased sharply after the ultimate load and brittle failure occured. Therefore, the
toughness in failure of I-beam was relatively higher than that of the other two
specimens.
Figures 4 and 5 show the diagonal crack patterns of the web and the flanges at the
ultimate load and the maximum displacement in each specimen, respectively. The
widely opened cracks are represented in thick lines. The arrows illustrate the
direction of the critical crack propagation and the compressive flange deformation.
1672 M. Kato et al.
Figure 6 shows the conceivable main area resisting the shear force at the ulti-
mate load by the black hatching and at the postpeak by red hatching. It was
determined by assuming that the failed area at the ultimate load and postpeak could
resist the shear force mainly. The shear failure behaviors and the shear resisting area
of each specimen are mentioned below.
3.2.1 I-Beam
As load increased, the flexural cracks and the diagonal cracks appeared from the
tensile flange and the web, respectively. Before the ultimate load, a lot of diagonal
cracks were observed in the shear span near the loading point. After that, one of the
diagonal cracks opened widely just before the ultimate load, which was considered
to be the critical crack. The critical crack occurred from the mid shear span to the
loading point. At the ultimate load, the load decreased gradually due to the opening
of the critical crack in the web. Meanwhile the critical crack did not propagate to the
compressive and tensile flanges (Fig. 4(a)).
In terms of the shear resisting area, it appears that the shear failure occurred
because of the decrease in shear resistance of the web before the failure of the
compressive and tensile flanges. Therefore, only limited area of the web from the
mid shear span to the loading point seems to have resisted the shear force at the
ultimate load (Fig. 6(a)).
Effects of Web Position on Shear Resistance Mechanism … 1673
After the ultimate load, the load decreased gradually and another diagonal cracks
occurred from near the support to the mid shear span in the web. Finally, the
compressive flange was lifted and bent due to the punching force from the web in
the mid shear span (Fig. 5(a)).
In terms of the shear resisting area in the post peak, it can be said that the wide
area of the compressive flange and the web which did not fail at the ultimate load
could still resist the shear force (Fig. 6(a)).
3.2.2 II-Beam
Unsimilarly to the I-beam, diagonal cracks appeared dispersedly over the whole
area of the web before the ultimate load. The critical crack occurred from near the
support to the mid shear span (Fig. 4(b)).
At the ultimate load, the load decreased sharply because of the lifting and
bending of the compressive flange by the punching force from the web at the mid
shear span. This shear failure behavior was similar to that of I-beam in the post
peak. Then, the critical crack propagated to the loading point along the bottom of
the compressive flange. Since the wide area of the web and the compressive flange
were failed at the shear failure with large deformation, another shear failure
behavior in the post peak like I-beam could not be observed (Fig. 5(b)).
In terms of the shear resisting area, it was considered that the area of the com-
pressive flange from the mid shear span to the loading point and almost the whole
area of the web could mainly resist the shear force at the ultimate load (Fig. 6(b)).
3.2.3 Box-Beam
Similar to I-beam, a lot of the diagonal cracks were observed in the shear span near
the loading point before the ultimate load. The critical crack occurred from the mid
shear span to the loading point, and started to propagate to the tensile flange from
the web at the displacement of around 13 mm (Fig. 4(c)).
At the ultimate load, the load dropped suddenly due to the concrete crush of the
compressive flange near the loading point. The concrete crush occurred over the
entire flange along the loading plate. Then the critical crack propagated to near the
support in the tensile flange. Same as II-beam, since the shear failure occurred at the
relatively wide area with large deformation, another shear failure behavior in the
post peak like I-beam could not be observed (Fig. 5(c)).
In terms of the shear resisting area, the area of the web from the mid shear span
to the loading point, the compressive flange near the loading point and the tensile
flange from the support to the mid shear span could resist the shear force at the
ultimate load (Fig. 6(c)).
1674 M. Kato et al.
4 Discussion
As shown in Fig. 6, it can be confirmed that the shear resisting area of I-beam at the
ultimate load was much smaller than that of II-beam and Box-beam, which was
only the limited area in the web. This implication suggests that the shear capacity of
I-beam was the lowest since the smallest area resisted the shear force at the ultimate
load.
Comparing II-beam with Box-beam, though Box-beam could resist the shear
force by the web and the compressive and tensile flanges, II-beam could resist it by
the wider area in the web and the compressive flange. Therefore, it seems that the
total area effective in resisting the external shear force was larger in II-beam. These
differences might contribute to the highest shear capacity in II-beam.
As shown in Fig. 3, after the diagonal cracks were observed in the web, the flexural
rigidity of each specimen declined and the decrement of II-beam was smaller than
the other specimens. Thus, it can be assumed that the flexural rigidity of each
specimen was greatly affected by the shear deformation of the web. Focusing on the
shear resisting area of the web in Fig. 6, I-beam and Box-beam resisted the shear
force by only partial area. On the other hand, II-beam could resist the shear force
with the whole area of the web. Therefore, the shear deformation of the web might
be smaller because the expansion of each crack was suppressed. From this point, it
is considered that the flexural rigidity became the largest in II-beam and those of
I-beam and Box-beam were almost the same.
same time. In addition, the load kept constant due to the critical crack propagating
to the tensile flange even when the critical crack opened widely in the webs. This
mechanism seems to have contributed to higher deformation performance in
Box-beam.
As shown in Fig. 6, in case of I-beam, different areas resisted the shear force at the
ultimate load and in the post peak. This was because the only limited area of the
web failed at the ultimate load and there was still another area in the web and
flanges to resist the shear force in the post peak. On the other hand, in the case of
II-beam and Box-beam, it can be considered that the load decreased sharply since
the shear failure occured in the wide area of the web and the flanges with large
deformations. Due to this reason, the toughness in failure of I-beam might be
relatively higher than those of the other two specimens.
Since the parameter in this study was only the web position, the effects of the web
position on the shear resisting area are discussed below. Figure 7 shows the crack
patterns on the compressive flange just before the ultimate load. Figures 8 and 9
show the crack propagation behaviors from the web to the compressive and tensile
flanges, respectively.
In II-beam, two webs were located at the quarter of the flange width from the edge.
Thus, the distance between the webs was shorter than that in Box-beam, and the
flange overhang length was also shorter than that in I-beam. It suggests that the
Web
Cracks Web Cracks
Web
(a) I-beam (b) II-beam (c) Box-beam
Interrupt Transfer
Interrupt
deformation deformation
deformation
Transfer
deformation
integrity of the webs and the flanges of II-beam was higher than other specimens.
Actually, cracks along the webs could be observed on the compressive flange in
I-beam and Box-beam due to the concentration of the punching force from the webs
to the compressive flange (Figs. 7(a) and (c)). On the other hand, there was no crack
in II-beam (Fig. 7(b)) and the punching force seems to have been distributed over
the compressive flange widely.
Therefore, in the case of II-beam, the web and the compressive flange together
could resist the shear force as a whole and the shear force could be dispersed
through the compressive flange in axial direction. From this, it can be concluded
that only in II-beam almost the whole area of the webs could resist the shear force.
Since there was no flange overhang in Box-beam, the side of the specimen was flat
without roughness in the boundary between the webs and the flanges. Therefore, the
shear deformation like the propagation of the diagonal cracks tended to transfer
continuously. Actually, in Box-beam, the concrete crush occurred on the com-
pressive flange due to the shear deformation from the webs (Fig. 8(c)). Moreover,
the critical crack propagated to the tensile flange continuously without being
interrupted by the flange overhang (Fig. 9(c)). On the other hand, in the case of
I-beam and II-beam with flange overhang, the propagation of the critical cracks
from the webs to the compressive flange were interrupted by the flange overhang
Effects of Web Position on Shear Resistance Mechanism … 1677
(Figs. 8(a) and (b)). Furthermore, the critical cracks could not be observed in the
side of the tensile flange (Figs. 9(a) and (b)).
From this, it can be concluded that the webs, the compressive and tensile flanges
could resist the shear force at the ultimate load in Box-beam.
5 Conclusions
Experimental studies were conducted on total three UFC beams considering the
different web positions, whose cross sectional dimensions such as web width, flange
width and effective depth were completely same. The effects of the web position on
its shear resistance mechanism were investigated. The following conclusions can be
obtained under the conditions of this study;
1) The structural performances such as the shear capacity, the flexural rigidity, the
displacement at the failure and the post peak behavior were different in each
specimen with different web positions.
2) Completely different area resisting the shear force at the ultimate load was
observed, i.e. with or without of the contribution of the flanges as well as the
wider or limited area in the web and the flanges. The different shear resisting
area is considered to affect the structural performance of each specimen.
3) With two webs distributed in flange, the integrity of webs and flanges became
higher. Herewith, the shear force could be dispersed widely through the com-
pressive flange in axial direction and almost the whole area in the webs and the
compressive flange could resist the shear force.
4) In case of a specimen without flange overhang, the shear deformation trans-
ferred from webs to flanges continuously, hence the tensile flange could con-
tribute to the shear resistance apart from the webs and the compressive flange.
References
1. Musha H, Watanabe N, Inahara H, Ohshima K (2009) Feature and application of UFC (Ductal)
structure, Report of Taisei Technology Center No. 42, pp 20-1–20-8. (in Japanese)
2. Japan Society of Civil Engineers (2004) Recommendations for design and construction of ultra
high strength fiber reinforced concrete structures, -draft, JSCE guidelines for concrete, pp 31–
35. (in Japanese)
The Effects of Shear Span Ratio
on Shear Properties of RC Beams Using
Fiber Reinforced Porosity Free Concrete
Abstract The objective of this research is to clarify the effects of shear span ratio
on shear properties of RC beams using fiber reinforced Porosity Free Concrete
(PFC beams). Therefore, the static four points bending tests were conducted with
different shear span ratio. When the shear span ratio increased, the initial rigidity,
the flexural cracking load and the diagonal cracking load decreased, but the density
of diagonal cracks became large. Furthermore, the increased shear span ratio also
led to the decrease in shear capacity when the failure modes were the same.
Moreover, it was confirmed that the experimental shear capacity of PFC beams is
higher than calculated shear capacity by following Recommendations for design
and construction of Ultra High Strength Fiber Reinforced Concrete structures (UFC
guideline).
Keywords RC beam using PFC Shear span ratio Shear property Failure
mode Tied arch
1 Introduction
High strength concrete enables the concrete structures to have longer span, higher
height and higher durability. Recently, with the development of Ultra High Strength
Fiber Reinforced Concrete (UFC), there are several applications of UFC to the
actual structures such as bridges and airport runway slabs. In 2015, Porosity Free
Concrete (PFC) was newly developed in Japan and compressive strength of PFC
was more than 400 N/mm2 [3].
2 Experimental Outline
2.1 Specimens
Table 1 and Fig. 1 show the details and the outline of specimens.
The parameter of the specimens was shear span ratio which was 3.0, 4.0 and 5.0.
In all specimens, the effective depth was 210 mm and the web width was 60 mm as
shown in section A-A’ of Fig. 1. Mechanical properties of steel bars are also
summarized in Table 1. Mix proportion of PFC and the details of materials are
summarized in Tables 2 and 3, respectively. After casting, the specimens were
cured with steam (40 °C) for 12 h. After the removal of formwork, the deuterating
process was also carried out for 30 min to absorb the water into specimens. When
the water-absorbing process was finished, the specimens were cured with steam
(90 °C) for 48 h, and then a heat curing process (1 atm, 180 °C) for 48 h was
carried out [5]. The arrangement of the longitudinal reinforcement is shown in
Fig. 1. SBPD 1080/1230 with nominal diameter of 25 mm was used as the tensile
steel bar. SBPR 1080/1230 with nominal diameter of 13 mm was used as the
compressive steel bar. Sheaths with diameter of 38 and 22.5 mm were used to make
ducts in concrete for tensile and compressive steel bars, respectively. Ultra low
viscosity PC grouting material was used.
A-A’ 60 B’ A’ CL
B-B’
SBPR 1080/1230 ( 13) 35
210 100 630 250
150
250 B A 250
SBPD 1080/1230 (D25) (a) ad3.0
A-A’ 60 B’ A’
B-B’
35
210 100 840 150 250
250 B A 250
(b) ad4.0
A-A’ 60 B’ A’
B-B’
35
210 100 1050 150 250
250 B A 250
(c) ad5.0
Table 3 Materials
Material Type Symbol Characteristic
Binder Premixed B Density: 2.82 g/cm3
binder
Sand High strength S Max size: 0.3 mm, Density: 2.63 g/cm3
sand
Fiber Steel fiber F Diameter: 0.2 mm, Length: 15 mm, Density:
7.84 g/cm3, Tensile strength: 2800 N/mm2
Chemical Superplasticizer SP Polycarboxylic acid-based admixture
admixiture Deforming DF Polyglycolic admixture
agent
1682 H. Wakayama et al.
The static four points bending tests were conducted for all specimens. The width of
the steel plates used in the loading points and the supporting points were 65 and
70 mm, respectively. The horizontal friction from the support was minimized by
using anti-friction pads.
During the loading test, applied load, displacement of the mid span and sup-
porting points and strain of concrete were measured. Figure 2 shows the position of
gauge and transducer. The displacement of the mid span was measured at two
places to prepare when one displacement transducer came off. 3 PI gauges were set
at the bottom surface in the equal bending moment region to determine the flexural
cracking load. The longitudinal strain of concrete at the mid span was measured at
10 mm from the top surface. The concrete strain at the mid of shear spans was also
measured at 5 points (10, 35, 105, 210 and 240 mm from the top surface).
Figure 3 shows the load-deflection curves of all specimens. All specimens failed in
shear. The dot line of the specimen ad4.0 shows the values of alternative mea-
surement because the displacement transducer came off at the peak load. Table 4
summarizes the flexural cracking load (Pcr_exp), the diagonal cracking load
(Pdia_exp) and the peak load (Pu_exp) of all specimens. In this research, when the
diagonal crack reached the height of d/2 (=105 mm) from top surface, the load was
defined as Pdia_exp. The background of this definition is that it is difficult to confirm
the initial diagonal crack because the width of the initial diagonal crack is too thin
to watch. Hence, this definition was adopted to unify the decision of the diagonal
cracking load.
As shown in Fig. 3, the initial rigidity, Pcr_exp and Pdia_exp tended to decrease
when shear span ratio (a/d) increased. The specimen ad4.0 had the largest peak load
due to the different failure mode from the other specimens. This will be discussed in
following Sect. 3.2. From the results of the specimens ad3.0 and ad5.0 which had
The Effects of Shear Span Ratio on Shear Properties of RC Beams … 1683
Load (kN)
300
200
100
0
0 10 20 30 40
Deflection (mm)
the same failure mode, the shear capacity of ad5.0 was lower than ad3.0 for nearly
30%. Taking this into account, it can be said that the shear capacity of PFC beams
tended to decrease when a/d increased.
Figure 4 shows the crack patterns of all specimens. Figure 4 also shows the critical
diagonal crack and concrete crush. It can be observed from Fig. 4, the density of
diagonal cracks increased when a/d increased.
Two types of failure modes were observed from Fig. 4. In the first type, the
compression failure occurred before the critical diagonal crack opening. This type
of failure mode was observed in the specimen ad4.0. In the second type, the critical
diagonal crack opening occurred before the compression failure. This type of failure
mode was observed in the specimens ad3.0 and ad5.0.
Table 5 shows the concrete compressive strain of 10 mm from top surface of
mid span at the peak load in all specimens. From Table 5, the compressive strains
of the specimen ad3.0 and ad5.0 were 35 and 25% smaller than the specimen ad4.0,
respectively. It can be considered that the specimen ad4.0 had strong compression
zone near the loading point so that the compressive strain of the specimen ad4.0
was higher than the other 2 specimens. Furthermore, it can be considered that in
case of the specimen ad4.0, strong compression zone led to the failure mode in
which compression failure occurred before the critical diagonal crack opening.
1684 H. Wakayama et al.
C
L
(a) ad3.0
(b) ad4.0
(c) ad5.0
Figure 5 shows the distribution of concrete strain at the mid of shear span under
different load levels (Pdia_exp, 300, 400 kN and Pu_exp). Figure 5 shows the distri-
bution at the span of failure side. From this figure, it can be seen that the com-
pressive strain at 105 mm from top surface at Pu_exp became large, and the
compressive strain near top surface at Pu_exp was lower than that at the load before
Pu_exp. This tendency was more obvious when a/d decreased. In the specimens
ad3.0 this tendency becomes remarkable.
It can be considered that the concrete compressive strain at 105 mm from top
surface increased because it located in the tied arch part as shown in Fig. 6. In case
of RC beams using normal strength concrete, when a/d is lower than 1.0, the beam
is called as a deep beam and the shear capacity becomes larger due to the mech-
anism like a tied arch [4]. In this research, since the compressive strength of PFC
was extremely high, even in the slender beam (the specimen ad3.0), the shear
resisting mechanism was similar to deep beams.
The Effects of Shear Span Ratio on Shear Properties of RC Beams … 1685
0 0
Pdia_exp
top surface (mm) Pdia_exp
300 kN
100 400 kN 100
Pu_exp 400 kN
150 150
Pu_exp
200 200
250 250
-2000 0 2000 4000 -2000 0 2000 4000
Strain (με) Strain (με)
(a) ad3.0 (b) ad4.0
0
top surface (mm)
50 Pdia_exp
Distance from
100 300 kN
Pu_exp
150
200
250
-2000 -1000 0 1000 2000
Strain (με)
(c) ad5.0
Fig. 5 Distribution of concrete strain at the mid of shear span (failure side)
Compression strut
105mm
Table 6 shows compressive strength of PFC (f’c), calculated shear capacity carried
by matrix (Vrpc_cal), calculated shear capacity carried by fiber (Vf_cal), calculated
shear capacity (Vy_cal), experimental shear capacity (Vy_exp) and the ratio of
experimental shear capacity to calculated shear capacity (Vy_exp/Vy_cal). Vrpc_cal,
Vf_cal and Vy_cal were calculated by using Eqs. (1)–(4) from Recommendations for
design and construction of Ultra High Strength Fiber Reinforced Concrete struc-
tures [2]. In all specimens, Vy_exp/Vy_cal was more than 1.0. Moreover, Vy_exp/Vy_cal
was even higher than 1.4 in case of the specimens ad3.0 and ad4.0. It can be
considered that shear capacity was underestimated without considering the effect of
a/d on Vrpc_cal. Hence, more detailed researches are required to improve the
1686 H. Wakayama et al.
calculating process of shear capacity, for example calculating the shear capacity
with considering a/d.
1 2s
bu ¼ tan1 ð 0 Þ b0 ð4Þ
2 rxu r0yu
where bw: web width, d: effective depth, fv: average tensile strength in vertical
direction of diagonal crack (=7.84 N/mm2) [6], bu: angle of diagonal crack, z: lever
arm length (=d/1.15), s: average shear stress, r’xu, r’yu: average compressive stress
in each direction, b0 = 5°
4 Conclusions
The static four points bending tests were conducted for 3 specimens to clarify the
effects of shear span ratio on shear properties of RC beams using fiber reinforced
PFC. The following conclusions can be obtained.
(1) When shear span ratio increased, the initial rigidity, the flexural cracking load
and the diagonal cracking load decreased, but the density of diagonal cracks
became large. Furthermore, when shear span ratio increased, the shear capacity
tended to decrease with the same failure mode of the specimens ad3.0 and
ad5.0.
(2) It was confirmed that the experimental shear capacity of fiber reinforced PFC
beams was larger than calculated shear capacity using UFC guideline.
It is recommended that further structural performance of fiber reinforced PFC
needs to be investigated in order to be applied to actual structures.
The Effects of Shear Span Ratio on Shear Properties of RC Beams … 1687
References
Abstract The previous studies confirmed that Carbon Fiber Reinforced Plastics
(CFRP) is well suited for application in concrete structures as internal reinforce-
ment. In precast slabs, using CFRP is a method not only mitigate against the steel
corrosion by the salt damage environment, improve the durability and serviceability
of the structures but also reduce the structural weight. However, other studies
showed that the drawback of the precast slabs is the in situ joints. Focusing on the
development of precast slabs reinforced by CFRP, this study considers how to using
CFRP in joint positions to enhance the durability and reduce the width as short as
possible of the joint. A series of pull-out specimens were carried out as fundamental
experiments to consider the increase of the bond between CFRP and concrete in the
joints. Specimens have the differences in diameter of CFRP, the fixation length, and
method using CFRP in the joint. From achieved experimental results, the method
using CFRP with a diameter of 15.2 mm, fixation length of 15Ø, and F-type (filling
inside tuft body) has been selected, proposed for further development and research.
1 Introduction
Specimens were prepared for the fundamental experiment with two main materials
including concrete and CFRP. The differences in these specimens were CFRP
diameter, the fixation length, and the method using CFRP in the joint.
Compressive strength for concrete was designed of 50 N/mm2. Concrete was
mixed with fly ash. The detail of compounding of concrete was shown in Table 1.
In here, Gmax is maximum aggregate size; W/B is water-binder ratio; W is water; B
is powder amount, and it was calculated as the following equation B = C +
EX + FA; EX is expansion agent; C is early-strength Portland cement; FA15 is fly
ash from Hokuriku Electric Power Nanao with rate 15%; s/A is fine aggregate
percentage; S (fine aggregate) and G (coarse aggregate) are respectively crushed
sand and crushed stone, they were from Sakurawaga, Ibaraki Prefecture; AE is
high-performance AE water reducing agent.
CFRP was used to replace the regular steel in slabs in this study. A normal slab
was reinforced by steel of diameter of D16 or D19 corresponding with Ø10.5 mm
of CFRP. However, after considering the design and the cost, diameter 12.5 and
15.2 mm of CFRP were selected. Table 2 shows the standard specification of CFRP
from the manufacturer (Tokyo Rope).
The fixation length means the part of CFRP inside of concrete specimen and it
has the relationship with the width of the joint. Normally, the width of in situ joints
was roughly 600 mm in the pre-cast slabs when the conventional steel of D19 and
the lap-splice method were chosen. If the width of the joint is shortened and the
durability of the structure is still guaranteed, this work will save a lot of costs on
materials, labour and construction time for a project. Moreover, previous studies
show that the bond between CFRP and concrete was 7.32 MPa, which was two
times larger than the value of conventional steel. Therefore, the fixation length in
this study was designed to be CFRP diameter multiples of 10, 15 and 20 (10Ø, 15Ø
and 20Ø) to investigate the possibility of reducing joint width.
CFRP was set up in a joint with three different methods to find the most effective
method, which can enhance the durability of the joint. Firstly, CFRP was used with
the ordinary type, which was the straight type, and called S-type. Secondly,
non-twisted CFRP type has been chosen as the next method, in which the poly-
urethane foam was put inside the tuft body. Consequently, concrete cannot be
completely filled and the diameter of the CFRP tuft body could be narrowed. It’
name was N-type or no filling inside tuft body. Finally, F-type or filling inside type
was the kind of the non-twisted type but the tuft body was freedom and concrete
can filling inside. Figure 2(a), 2(b) and 2(c) show three methods mentioned above.
The detail of the setup for specimens was shown in Table 3.
CFRP Ø12.5 15Ø (188 mm) Ø27.2 250 940 230 1170
CFRP Ø15.2 15Ø (228 mm) Ø31.8 350 993 270 1263
specimens were twice as larger as the S-type and N-type specimens. This type was
expected to achieve the highest adhesive force in the group of three types using in
the joint.
Figure 3(a), 3(b) and 3(c) show the situation of specimens after the first series was
carried out. Here, the name “Ø12.5–10Ø-S” means the CFRP diameter of 12.5 mm,
the fixation length (10Ø), and the method of using CFRP in the joint part was
S-type. The failure mode of specimens included pull-out CFRP and split concrete.
Table 4 summarised the experimental results of the first series. Firstly, the results
were evaluated between two groups of CFRP diameter. As shown in Table 4, the
diameter of CFRP in the specimens was larger, the pull-out load was higher. Secondly,
the pull-out load was considered in specimens having different fixation length.
Experimental results indicated that the fixation length increased, the pull-out load also
increased accordingly. When the results were compared among three types of CFRP,
F-type achieved the highest-maximum load in the group having the same diameter and
fixation length as expected. In F-type, the ratio of the maximum pull-out load to CFRP
guaranteed break force reached from 60% to 76% in group having fixation length of
An Investigation into Application of Carbon Fiber … 1695
Table 4 (continued)
STT Name Maximum Maximum Ratio of Ratio of Adhesive
load Pmax displacement Pmax to Pmax to strength
(kN) dmax (mm) guaranteed Pmax of (N/mm2)
break force Straight
type
17 Ø12.5– 146.6 2.032 54% 100% 13.46
15Ø-S
18 Ø15.2– 126 3.2 47% 86% 11.57
15Ø-N
19 Ø15.2– 243.7 1.218 90% 166% 22.38
15Ø-
F1
20 Ø15.2– 247.1 1.194 92% 169% 22.70
15Ø-
F2
21 Ø15.2– 182.8 1.148 68% 100% 12.59
20Ø-S
22 Ø15.2– 198.7 3.452 74% 109% 13.69
20Ø-N
23 Ø15.2– 270 0.984 100% 148% 18.60
20Ø-
F1
24 Ø15.2– 204.7 1.092 76% 112% 14.10
20Ø-
F2
(a) Fixation length 10Ø (b) Fixation length 15Ø (c) Fixation length 20Ø
10Ø and from 90% to 95% in the group having fixation length of 15Ø. Regarding the
group having fixation length of 20Ø of F-type, this number was over 100% in three
specimens. However, the specimen of Ø15.2–20Ø-F destroyed due to the concrete
splitting. The maximum pull-out load of this specimen was 204.7 kN, which was
lower than the guaranteed break force of CFRP. This was the reason to consider the
second series of experiments. Furthermore, the failure mode of F-type was split and
fractured, the accuracy of bond strength was not obtained this time, but the bond
strength still exceeded 20 N/mm2.
An Investigation into Application of Carbon Fiber … 1697
Fig. 6 The relationship between the pull-out load and the length of tuft-body corresponding with
Fa-type and Fb-type
Fig. 8 The relationship between the pull-out load and the length of tuft-body corresponding with
Fa-type and Fb-type
An Investigation into Application of Carbon Fiber … 1699
This consequence may come from the quality of filling inside the tuft body.
Polymer cement mortar was remained with a large amount in the second specimen,
whereas only a small amount was found in other specimens (see Fig. 7). It may be
the part of polymer cement mortar did not break because the contact surface
between polymer cement mortar, fixation length and concrete was not good.
Figure 8(a) and 8(b) show the relationship between pull-out load and CFRP’s
displacement of both types Fa and Fb in 9Ø group. From these figures, the dis-
placement of Fb-type at the failure time is larger than that of Fa-type. It seems that
the polymer cement mortar in the tuft body of the CFRP broken slowly and made
the pull-out process slower.
4 Conclusions
From the results and discussions above, some remarkable conclusions were derived
as follows:
1. F-type achieved the highest pull-out load and bond strength in comparing with
N-type and S-type. When the specimen using CFRP with diameter 15.2 mm, the
pull-out load achieved the higher value than that using CFRP with diameter
12.5 mm. The force in the case using the fixation length of 20Ø was the highest
among three types of the fixation length. Therefore, the specimen of F-type,
Ø15.2 mm, and 20Ø would be a great combination for the actual bridge.
However, after considering the ultimate load, bond strength, the ratio of ultimate
load to the breaking force of CFRP, and the fixation length; the method using
CFRP with a diameter of 15.2 mm, the fixation length of 15Ø, and F-type
(filling inside tuft body) was proposed to apply in the pre-cast slabs.
2. If the pre-cast slabs use the proposed method, the width of the joints will
improve, only a half with the fixation length 15Ø (228 mm). Besides, the weight
of the slabs reduces significantly.
3. From the results of the second series of experiments, the method filling inside
tuft body should consider in the future.
References
1. Enomoto T (2012) Use of CFCC tendons and reinforcements in concrete structures for
durability. In: APFIS 2012, Hokkaido University, Japan
2. Enomoto T, Grace NF, Harada T (2012) Life extension of prestressed concrete bridges using
CFCC tendons and reinforcements. In: Proceedings conference on FRP composites in civil
engineering, Rome Italy
3. Erki MA, Rizkalla S (1993) FRP reinforcement for concrete structures. ACI Concr Int 15
(6):48–53
4. Green MF (2017) Long-term applications of CFRP prestressing in Canada. In: Fourth
conference on smart monitoring, assessment and rehabilitation of civil structures
5. Grace NF et al (2002) Design - construction of bridge street bridge - first CFRP bridge in the
United States. PCI J 47(5):20–35
6. Nguyen HT et al. (2018) Long-term application of carbon fiber composite cable tendon in the
prestressed concrete bridge - shinmiya bridge in Japan. In: MATEC web of Conferences, vol
206, pp 02011
Stable Limit Axial Load Ratios
of Concrete Filled Steel Tubular
Beam-Columns Under Varying Axial
Loads
L. Li
Keywords Cyclic loading Drift angle Strength of concrete Yield stress of
steel Width-to-thickness ratio
L. Li (&)
Division of Human Habitat, Faculty of Environmental and Symbiotic Sciences,
Prefectural University of Kumamoto, Kumamoto, Japan
e-mail: lili@pu-kumamoto.ac.jp
1 Introduction
In recent years, CFT structures have been widely used in high-rise buildings. The
axial loads acting on the exterior beam-columns in the lower floors of high-rise
buildings vary due to horizontal forces such as seismic or wind forces. Behaviour of
the beam-columns changes depending on the magnitude of the axial force acting on
them.
Structural analysis [2] on a high-rise framed building (20-story, 3-bay) showed
that the axial load of a beam-column could vary from n = 0.05 to n = 0.3, where
n is the ratio of the axial load to the axial load-carrying capacity. In addition, it
doesn’t only occur in the exterior beam-columns but also the variation in axil loads
of the interior beam-columns could be n = 0.05–0.5 when dampers were located in
the middle bay.
In the analysis of Saisho et al. [5], the axial load of the ground floor
beam-columns in a 15-story, 3-bay frame varied remarkably so that the axial load
ratio varied from its normal value of 0.2 in compression to 0.3 in tension and 0.8 in
compression under an extremely strong ground motion (maximum of spectral
acceleration 6g in NS direction and 4g in UD direction), which is twice the strength
of JMA-KOBE.
Dastourianjamnani et al. [1] showed by dynamic analysis that the variation of
axial loads affects not only the local buckling or steel tube cracks of CFT columns
but also the bending restoring forces of CFT columns in a 12-story, 4 4-bay
frame. As with the analysis of Saisho et al. [5], it was clear that not only the exterior
columns but also the interior columns are subjected to varied axial loads under
vertical ground motions.
This study analytically investigates the stability limit axial load of a square CFT
beam-column subjected to repeated bending under varying axial loads at constant
drift angle amplitudes. The objective is to clarify the influences of
width-to-thickness ratios of the steel tubes in CFT beam-columns and material
strengths which are analytical variables on the stability limit axial loads.
2 Analysis
2.1 Assumptions
Rigid portion
Lp
Curved portion
nc
-R 0
R0 R
nc-nvl
2.2 Parameters
The CFT columns to be analyzed are using square steel tubes: the nominal
cross-section of dimensions of width (b = 750 mm) height (D = 750 mm)
thickness (t), and a length of L = 2250 mm. The thicknesses of steel tubes are 19
and 28 mm; the design standard strengths of concrete (Fc) are 36 and 60 N/mm2;
and the yield stresses of steel tubes (ry) are 325 and 440 N/mm2. In total, there are
eight combinations of the variables.
The drift angle amplitudes (Ra) are 0.5%, 1.0%, 1.5%, and 2.0%.
1704 L. Li
A Popovics stress-strain relationship [4] is used, and the confining effects of a steel
tube on the filled concrete is considered according to Mander’s proposal [3].
Stress-strain relations of concrete considering the refining effects of a steel tube of a
thickness of 28 mm are presented in Fig. 3 by dotted lines. However, in the
analysis, the design standard strengths (Fc) and the strain at the confined strengths
are used, as shown in Fig. 3 by solid lines. An idealized multi-linear model is used
for a steel tube on both the tensile and compressive sides as shown in Fig. 4. The
ultimate strains are 15% and 25% for steel of ry = 325 N/mm2 and ry = 440
N/mm2, respectively.
60 Fc=60MPa
40
20
F c=30MPa
0
0 1 2 3 4 5
ε (%)
0
-30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30
ε (%)
-400
-800
Stable Limit Axial Load Ratios of Concrete Filled Steel … 1705
Under a given displacement (d) at the free end of the analytical model and a given
applied axial load (Napplied), the depth of the neutral axis can be obtained by
iterative calculation to satisfy the equilibrium condition: the calculated axial load
(Nanalysis) = Napplied. Then the flexural moment at the fixed end of the cantilever
corresponding to the given drift angle (R = d/L) can be calculated. Therefore, the
moment-drift angle relations can be obtained by changing the value of R at intervals
of 0.1% between a given amplitude ±R0 and repeating 10 times from +R0 to –R0.
The applied axial load is divided into a constant axial load (Nc) corresponding to
long-term axial loads and a varying one (Nv) due to seismic or wind loads. The
varying axial load increases or decreases in proportion to the drift angle (R) as
shown in Fig. 2.
When a beam-column is subjected to a constant axial load at a drift angle of
amplitude ±R0, there is a limitation (maximum value) on the axial load so that the
beam-column has stable behaviour. The maximum axial load ratio (ncl) under a
constant axial load at a drift angle amplitude can be determined by analysis, where
an axial load ratio is a ratio of axial load to the ultimate compressive strength of a
CFT column. The maximum axial load ratio ncl is called the stability limit axial load
ratio (SLALR) and is defined as the maximum axial load ratio when the decrease of
the flexural moments is within 10% of the maximum flexural moment during 10
times cyclic loading under a drift angle amplitude. The value of ncl of a CFT
beam-column is found through analyses by increasing the axial load ratio from 0.0
at increments of 0.05.
The constant part (nc) of an axial force ratio is changed from 0.00 to the value of
ncl at increments of 0.10 and the varying axial load ratio (nv) under each nc is
changed at increments of 0.05 to find the maximum varying axial load ratio (nvl).
The determination condition for nvl is the same as that to determine a value of ncl,
which is the maximum axial load ratio (nv) at a given nc under which the
beam-column is able to maintain its flexural resistance with less than 10% strength
degradation even subjected to 10 times of repeated bending.
Figure 5 shows the results of a CFT column of Fc = 36 N/mm2, ry = 325
N/mm2 and t = 19 mm under nc = 0.30 at Ra = 1.0%, and the varying axial load
ratios nv = 0.15 and 0.20 respectively. The decrease in flexural moments (M) under
nv = 0.15 is 7.7% as shown in Fig. 5(a), and under nv = 0.20 in Fig. 5(b) is 11.3%.
When the constant part of axial force ratio is 0.30, the maximum varying axial load
ratio (nvl = 0.15) can keep the beam-column stable under 10 cycles of loading;
when nv > 0.15, the beam-column will lose more than 10% of its flexural strength
and the bigger nv is, the sharper the decrease in flexural moments. Therefore, the
stable limit axial load ratio is 0.30 ± 0.15 which means that the axial load ratio can
changes from 0.15 to 0.45.
1706 L. Li
Μ (kNm) Μ (kN m)
10000 10000
Decrease
Decrease
6000 6000 11.3%
7.7%
2000 2000
-2 -1 -2000 0 1 2 -2 -1 -2000 0 1 2
R (%) R (%)
-6000 -6000
-10000 -10000
(a) Varying axial load ratio = 0.15 (b) Varying axial load ratio = 0.20
Fig. 5 Moment-drift angle relations of a CFT beam column when Fc = 36 N/mm2, ry = 325
N/mm2, t = 19 mm, nc = 0.30 and Ra = 1.0%
3 Analysis Results
Figures 6 and 7 and Figs. 8 and 9 show the analytical results when Ra = 1.0% and
Ra = 2.0%, respectively. In these figures, the lines with black painted circles (•) are
the relations of nc to nvl; the lines with white circles ðÞ are the relations of nc to the
range of axial load ratio (nc ± nvl).
The values of nc under Ra = 1.0% are bigger than those under Ra = 2.0%.
When the value of nc is smaller than about 0.20, all the beam-columns can bear
some tensile axial loads. When nc 0.30, the beam-columns can only resist
compressive axial loads.
The influences on the values of nc and nvl due to the width-to-thickness ratios of
steel tubes, concrete strengths and steel strengths are discussed in Sects. 3.1–3.3.
The values of nc (the values when nvl = 0) increase 0.1 while the width-to-thickness
ratio (b/t) is 27 (thickness t = 28 mm) as can be seen by comparing Figs. 6(a) and
(b) or comparing Figs. 6(c) and (d). When high strength steel tubes are used, the
values of nc are not affected by width-to-thickness ratios (see Fig. 7).
The difference of nvl at nc = 0 is 0.10–0.20 due to the width-to-thickness ratios.
However, in a real building, no beam-column is subjected to a long-term axial load
of zero. The values of nvl at each level of nc (nc 0.10) are almost the same as can
be seen by comparing the figures (a) with (b), or (c) with (d) in Figs. 6 and 7.
Stable Limit Axial Load Ratios of Concrete Filled Steel … 1707
Constant portion, nc
Constant portion, nc
ncl nc nvl
0.6 σy 325 nc nvl 0.6 σy 325
b/t 39 ncl b/t 27
0.4 Ra 1.0% 0.4 Ra 1.0%
0.2 0.2
0 0
-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Variation nvl , nc nvl Variation nvl , nc nvl
(a) Fc =36 MPa; t =19 mm (b) Fc =36 MPa; t =28 mm
0.8 0.8
Fc 60 nvl Fc 60 nvl
Constant portion, nc
Constant portion, nc
0.2 0.2
0 0
-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Variation nvl , nc nvl Variation nvl , nc nvl
(c) Fc =60 MPa; t =19 mm (d) Fc =60 MPa; t =28 mm
Therefore, it can be concluded that the width-to-thickness ratio will not influence
the values of nvl to a significant extent.
Comparing Figs. 8(a) and (b) or Figs. 8(c) and (d) shows that the value of nc when
b/t = 27 is 0.1 larger than that when b/t = 39. Comparisons of Figs. 9(a) and (b) or
Figs. 9(c) and 9(d) indicate that the values of nc are not affected by the
width-to-thickness ratios.
The values of nvl at each level of nc are almost the same when nc is between 0.10
and 0.30 for normal strength steel tubes; between 0.1 and 0.2 for high strength steel
tubes.
1708 L. Li
0.8 0.8
Fc 36 nvl Fc 36 nvl
Constant portion, nc
Constant portion, nc
0.2 0.2
0 0
-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Variation nvl , nc nvl Variation nvl , nc nvl
(a)Fc =36 MPa; t =19 mm (b) Fc =36 MPa; t =28 mm
0.8 0.8
Fc 60 nvl Fc 60 nvl
Constant portion, nc
Constant portion, nc
0.2 0.2
0 0
-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Variation nvl , nc nvl Variation nvl , nc nvl
(c) Fc =60 MPa; t =19 mm (d) Fc =60 MPa; t =28 mm
Fig. 7 Analytical results (ry = 440 MPa and Ra = 1.0%)
Comparisons of the figures (a) and (c), (b) and (d) in Fig. 6 (normal strength steel
tubes) reveal that the values of ncl is 0.05 higher when Fc = 36 MPa than those
when Fc = 60 MPa. When high strength steel is used (Fig. 7), there are no dif-
ferences in the values of nc due to concrete strengths.
The values of nvl at each level of nc are almost the same when nc is between 0.10
and 0.40 for normal strength steel tubes; between 0.1 and 0.3 for high strength steel
tubes. There are no differences caused by concrete strengths.
Stable Limit Axial Load Ratios of Concrete Filled Steel … 1709
0.8 0.8
Fc 36 nvl nvl
Fc 36
Constant portion, nc
Constant portion, nc
0.2 0.2
0 0
-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Variation nvl , nc nvl Variation nvl , nc nvl
(a) Fc =36 MPa; t =19 mm (b) Fc =36 MPa; t =28 mm
0.8 0.8
Fc 60 nvl nvl
Fc 36
Constant portion, nc
Constant portion, nc
0.2 0.2
0 0
-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Variation nvl , nc nvl Variation nvl , nc nvl
(c) Fc =60 MPa; t =19 mm (d) Fc =60 MPa; t =28 mm
Comparisons of (a) and (c), (b) and (d) in Fig. 8 (normal strength steel tubes) and
also (a) and (c), (b) and (d) Fig. 9 (high strength steel tubes) show that differences
only occurred in the values of nvl at nc = 0 or nc = ncl.
Decreases in the values of ncl are 0.05–0.2 when high strength steel tubes are used,
and the decreases are larger when normal concrete (Fc = 36 MPa) and thick steel
tubes (b/t = 27) are used. The differences in the values of nvl at nc = 0.1 or 0.3 are
0.05 that can be ignored.
1710 L. Li
0.8 0.8
nvl Fc 36 nvl
Constant portion, nc
Fc 36
Constant portion, nc
0 0
-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Variation nvl , nc nvl Variation nvl , nc nvl
(a) Fc =36 MPa; t =19 mm (b) Fc =36 MPa; t =28 mm
0.8 0.8
Fc 60 nvl Fc 60 nvl
Constant portion, nc
Constant portion, nc
0.2 0.2
0 0
-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Variation nvl , nc nvl Variation nvl , nc nvl
(c) Fc =60 MPa; t =19 mm (d) Fc =60 MPa; t =28 mm
Decreases in the values of ncl are 0.1 when high strength steel tubes are used except
the case of Fc = 36 MPa and b/t = 27 where the decrease in the value of nc is 0.2.
The differences in the values of nvl at nc = 0.1 or 0.2 are 0.05, as with that of
Ra = 1.0%.
lines. The approximate expression give safe evaluations on the values of nvl except
when Fc = 36 MPa and ry = 325 MPa at Ra = 1.0%.
4 Conclusions
From the analysis of square CFT beam-columns subjected to varying axial loads
and repeated flexural bending, the following can be summarized.
(1) The value of constant stable limit axial load ratio (ncl) decreases corresponding
to the increase in the drift angle amplitude when the other perimeters are the
same.
(2) There is a slight tendency to increase the value of ncl when b/t = 27 and normal
strength materials are used.
(3) When the value of nc is equal to or smaller than 0.20, all the beam-columns can
bear some tensile axial loads up to n = 0.20–0.25 in tension. When 0.30
nc ncl, the beam-columns can only resist compressive axial loads.
(4) The varying stable limit axial load ratio (nvl) decreases when the value of nc
(nc 0.10) increases. A value of nvl at a given nc can be interpolated linearly
between (ncl, 0.0) and (0.1, ncvl) to obtain a conservative value.
(5) The influence of concrete strengths on the values of ncl, nvl is so little that it can
be ignored except for the combination of Fc = 36 MPa, ry = 325 MPa,
Ra = 1% and b/t = 27.
(6) The most influential variable is steel tube yield strength that caused a maximum
difference in the value of ncl up to 0.2 in the case of Fc = 36 MPa and b/t = 27
at Ra = 1%.
(7) In general, the influences of all the three variables on the values of nvl are not
significant because the difference of nvl caused by each variable does not exceed
0.1.
1712 L. Li
References
1 Introduction
Steel girder end of bridge structure with section loss due to corrosion can lead to the
reduction load-carrying capacity. Therefore, many analytical and experimental
studied have been conducted to investigate the existing load-carrying capacity and
to recover the performance of steel girder [8]. For the repair and strengthening
method of cross section loss in steel members, high-strength bolted joint method or
steel plate adhesively bonded joint method are generally used [14]. Moreover, with
the advantage of corrosion resistance, light weight and high rigidity, CFRP plate
adhesively bonded joint have been recently focused and studied [1, 2]. However,
high rigidity and excellence in construction work of CFRP plate cannot be properly
applied by adhesively boned joint to rough and discontinuous surfaces or complex
shapes of steel members. Here, carbon fiber (CF) sheets are flexible materials,
which are convenient for applying on discontinuous surfaces or complex shapes.
The application of CF sheets bonded to steel girder end has been verified [10–13]
and the design and construction manual is being published [9]. However, the
efficiency of work on site may become poor when the number of CF sheet layers
increase due the thinness of CF sheets. Regarding to this problem, Vacuum assisted
Resin Transfer Molding (VaRTM) presented in Fig. 1, as a composite fabricating
technique, can be used to apply Carbon Fiber (CF) sheets on cross section loss of
steel members in a time, which can shorter the construction time. It has been proved
in previous studied that it is possible to repair and strengthening on cross section
loss of steel members [3, 5–7]. Base on previous study [4], this paper deals with the
enhancement of load-carrying capacity in case of girder end of steel bridge is
subjected to severe cross section loss by analytically and experimentally investi-
gating the appropriate arrangement and its application of CFRP members adhe-
sively bonded by VaRTM technique.
Vent
Resin Steel member (Vacuum)
Study on Repair and Strengthening of Steel Girder End … 1715
Figure 2 shows the specimen of girder end and the range of cross section loss due to
corrosion. Table 1 shows the dimensions of the specimen. For the analytical model
of girder end of steel bridge, it is supposed for the three-point bending load test with
the span of 1,700 mm and the aspect ratio of 1.0.
As presented in Fig. 2, the cross section loss is vertical stiffeners and lower end
of web at 100 mm, where the flange is not considered for cross section loss. The
shape of cross section loss is considered for constant or complete loss. 50% cross
section loss of 12 mm of vertical stiffeners and 100% cross section loss of web are
defined.
12
800
824
12 12 12 12 12
12
In analytical model of specimen, vertical stiffeners, webs and flanges are modelled
as a shell element, while sole plate and loading plate as a solid element, and
adhesive layers as a spring element with equivalent stiffness are modelled. The
minimum element size is 10 10 mm. The initial imperfection of 1/1,000 (max-
imum of 0.8 mm) against the height of web with sine half wave shape is introduced.
The steel type is JIS SM400 with its material properties shown in Table 2. The
finite element analysis (FEA) is conducted using general-purpose analysis program,
MSC Marc 2018, with elasto-plasticity finite displacement analysis. The model
without and with cross section loss are defined as non-defect model and defect
model. Furthermore, in order to investigate the target value of strengthening in this
specimen, the reference model are modelled with vertical stiffeners at the center of
web on both sides (Fig. 3(a)).
12
800
824
12 12 12 12 12 12
6
12
45
300
255
100
250 180
270 100 800 100 400 400 100
1900
12
12
0
800
824
45
300
255
100
250 180
270 100 800 100 400 400 100
1900
First, coating and mill scale are removed from the specimen using bristle blaster and
then the surface is cleaned by acetone before coating by cold hardening type epoxy
resin with low-viscosity epoxy resin (Toray ACE AUP40), the same to epoxy resin
using to bonded CF sheets. CF sheets and PF materials are installed to the speci-
men. Material properties of epoxy resin (Toray ACE AUP40) are shown in Table 4.
To prevent the corrosion due to electrochemical action and to facilitate the
impregnation of the epoxy resin, one layer of fiberglass chopped strand mat (CSM),
which its material properties are presented in Table 3, is installed as the first layer
between steel plate and CF sheets. Then secondary materials such as one layer peel
ply (to remove secondary materials after hardening), 3 layers of distribution media
(to secure the fluidity of resin), etc. are set and enclosed in bagging film. The system
is operated by vacuum pump in resin impregnation process. The impregnation time
is within the pot life of resin (approx. 1.5 h) and it is cured at 40 °C for 24 h. Last,
secondary materials are removed. The process of adhesion by VaRTM are can be
done part by part. However, the whole surface (one side) is conducted in one time
for this target specimen.
Figure 4 shows the failure modes of defect and non-defect model from analytical
studies. Shear buckling of web can be confirmed in non-defect model, while local
buckling at vertical stiffeners of 50% cross section loss is seen. In comparison to
Study on Repair and Strengthening of Steel Girder End … 1719
non-defect model, the load-carrying capacity of the defect specimen model decreased
by 35%. Figure 5 shows the relationship between load and vertical displacement
below loading point from experimental and analytical studies. In comparison of both,
the defect and non-defect between experimental and analytical studies, good agree-
ment of maximum load, vertical displacement behavior can be verified. In addition,
the failure mode of reference model is shear buckling at web and the shear buckling
capacity increased approximately 20% in comparison to non-defect model from
analytical study. Therefore, with the dimensions of current cross section, the
strengthening of shear buckling capacity can be estimated to be upper limit.
Figure 6 shows relationship between amount of CF sheets and strengthening
effect of model CFP_SH90N10 and CFP_SH ± 45N10. From the figure, the
strengthening effect becomes stable in constant from the 10 layers of PF material in
call cases. Therefore, 10 layers of PF material are conducted in both the analytical
study and experimental study.
As presented in Fig. 7, although the deformation in-plan and out-of-plane in
CFP strengthened model (CFP_SH90N10) is effectively controlled, the failure of
CFRP at girder end is occurred. The maximum load is enhanced to the equivalent
level of load-carrying capacity in reference model. However, shear buckling at web
strengthened by vertical stiffeners cannot be confirm. This is due to the advance
failure of CFRP.
As presented in Fig. 8, in CFP strengthened model (CFP_SH ± 45N10), the
maximum load increases by 34% compare to non-defect model. However, in this
case, the actual maximum load is considered to be even higher due to the buckling
preceded in another web which are not arranged by CFRP. Although the debonding
of CFRP occurred ahead of maximum load, the influence on shear buckling
capacity is small.
Figure 9 shows relationship between load and vertical displacement below
loading point. From the figure, good agreement of maximum load, vertical dis-
placement behavior can be verified in each cases. Furthermore, the effectiveness of
the design in compression and tension direction on both sides is considered in
comparison to reference model. All the results of analytical and experimental
studies and strengthening effect are mentioned in Table 5.
(a) Defect model (Pmax=913.1 kN) (b) Non-defect model (Pmax=1419.1 kN)
Fig. 4 Relationship between load and vertical displacement below loading point
1720 V. Thay et al.
1800
Vertical displacement
1600
Non-defect 31.1%
1400 Defect 102.7%
Basler's equation (1303.3 kN)
1200
Load (kN)
1000
Non-defect (exp. 1330.1 kN)
800 Shear buckling (766.9 kN) Non-defect (ana. 1353.3 kN)
Defect (exp. 860.3 kN)
600 Defect (ana. 913.1 kN)
Reference (ana. 1743.9 kN)
400
Non-defect Basler's equation (the.)
200 Elastic shear buckling (the.)
Vertical displacement (the.)
0
0 3 6 9 12 15 18
Displacement (mm)
Fig. 5 Relationship between load and vertical displacement below loading point
35 35
P-N1L800B120SH-90 P-N1L1130B120SH±45
P-N2L800B120SH-90 P-N2L1130B120SH±45
P-N3L800B120SH-90 30 P-N3L1130B120SH±45
30
P-N4L800B120SH-90 P-N4L1130B120SH±45
P-N5L800B120SH-90 P-N5L1130B120SH±45
25 P-N6L800B120SH-90 25 P-N6L1130B120SH±45
Strengthening effect
Strengthening effect
P-N7L800B120SH-90 P-N7L1130B120SH±45
P-N8L800B120SH-90 P-N8L1130B120SH±45
20 P-N9L800B120SH-90 20 P-N9L1130B120SH±45
P-N10L800B120SH-90 P-N10L1130B120SH±45
P-N11L800B120SH-90 P-N11L1130B120SH±45
15 P-N12L800B120SH-90 15 P-N12L1130B120SH±45
P-N13L800B120SH-90 P-N13L1130B120SH±45
P-N14L800B120SH-90 P-N14L1130B120SH±45
10 P-N15L800B120SH-90 10 P-N15L1130B120SH±45
P-N16L800B120SH-90 P-N16L1130B120SH±45
P-N17L800B120SH-90 P-N17L1130B120SH±45
5 P-N18L800B120SH-90 5 P-N18L1130B120SH±45
P-N19L800B120SH-90 P-N19L1130B120SH±45
P-N20L800B120SH-90 P-N20L1130B120SH±45
0 0
0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10
Amount of CF sheets (m2) Amount of CF sheets (m2)
(a) CFP Strengthened model (CFP_SH90N10) (b) CFP Strengthened model (CFP_SH±45N10)
(a) Analytical result (Pmax=1670.5 kN) (b) Experimental result (Pmax=1642.6 kN)
(a) Analytical result (Pmax=1779.6 kN) (b) Experimental result (Pmax=1781.9 kN)
2000
Vertical displacement Reference (ana.)
1800
1200
CFP_SH±45N10 (ana.)
1000
CFP_SH±45N10 (exp.)
800 Elastic shear buckling 766.9kN
200
Elastic shear buckling (the.)
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Displacement (mm)
Fig. 9 Relationship between load and vertical displacement below loading point
7 Conclusions
References
1. Japan Society of Civil Engineers (JSCE) (2007) Application of advanced composite materials
to infrastructures, Hybrid structure reports 01. (in Japanese)
2. Japan Society of Civil Engineers (JSCE) (2012) Advanced technology of repair and
strengthening of steel structures using externally-bonded FRP composites, Hybrid structure
reports 05. (in Japanese)
3. Kobayashi K, Kondo R, Nakamura H, Matsumoto Y, Matsui T, Ochi Y (2017) Repair of
section loss in girder end by CFRP using vacuum assisted resin transfer molding technology.
J JSCE 73(5):II_20–II_31. (in Japanese)
4. Kobayashi K, Kondo R, Thay V, Nakamura H, Matsumoto Y, Matsui T, Ochi Y (2018) Study
on strengthening of steel girder end using CFRP members fabricated by VaRTM technique.
J JSCE 74(5):II_44–II_55. (in Japanese)
5. Kondo F, Matsui T (2012) Recent topics about CFRP large structural molding in other fields –
the report of the task committee for FRP hybrid structures (H208). In: JSCE –, Proceedings of
the 4th symposium on FRP (Fiber Reinforced Polymer) hybrid structures and bridges, pp 23–
26
6. Matsuyama A, Sato J, Thay V, Nakamura H, Matsumoto Y, Matsui T, Ochi Y (2018) Repair
and strengthening of steel compression members using CFRP members fabricated by VaRTM
technique, J JSCE 74(5):II_67–II_80. (in Japanese)
7. Nakamura H, Kobayashi K, Kondo R, Thay V, Matsumoto Y, Matsui T, Ochi Y (2017)
Experimental study on repair of section loss in girder end by externally bonded carbon fiber
sheets using VaRTM. In: The 6th Asia-Pacific conference on FRP in structures (APFIS2017),
pp 36-1–36-4
8. National Institute for Land and Infrastructure Management (Ministry of Land, Infrastructure
and Transport (2006) Research on local corrosion of highway steel bridges, technical note of
national institute for land and infrastructure management, No 294. (in Japanese)
Study on Repair and Strengthening of Steel Girder End … 1723
9. Nippon Expressway Research Institute (NEXCO) (2013) Design and construction manual of
repair and strengthening method in steel structures by carbon fiber sheets. (in Japanese)
10. Okuyama Y, Miyashita T, Ogata T, Fujino K, Ohgaki K, Hidekuma Y, Horimoto W, Nagai M
(2011) Uniaxial compression test of steel plate bonded FRP sheet for rational repair and
reinforcement of web in steel girder bridge. JSCE J Struct Eng 57A:735–746 (in Japanese)
11. Okuyama Y, Miyashita T, Wakabayashi D, Koide N, Hidekuma Y, Horimoto W, Nagai M
(2012) Experimental study on repair method using CFRP for corroded web in steel girder
bridge. JSCE J Struct Eng 58A:710–720 (in Japanese)
12. Okuyama Y, Miyashita T, Wakabayashi D, Koide N, Kobayashi A, Hidekuma Y,
Horimoto W, Nagai M (2012) Shear buckling test and prediction of shear load carrying
capacity for steel girder bonded CFRP on its web. J JSCE 68(3):635–654 (in Japanese)
13. Okuyama Y, Miyashita T, Nagai M, Wakabayashi D, Koide N, Hidekuma Y, Kobayashi A,
Horimoto W (2012) Experimental study on repair method of corroded vertical stiffeners at
supporting points using carbon fiber sheets. In: Proceedings of the 30th annual conference of
JSCE, Kanto branch, Niigata association, pp 60–63. (in Japanese)
14. Tamba Y, Hashimoto K, Tanaka D, Sugiura K (2014) Experimental study about the repair
method of the steel girder end with the corrosion damage. JSCE J Struct Eng 60A:94–104 (in
Japanese)
FE Simulation of a New Type
of Concrete-Filled Double Skin Steel
Tube with Stiffeners Under Axial
Loading
Abstract Proposed herein is a new type of concrete-filled double skin steel tube
(CFDST) that uses webs to connect the inner and outer steel tubes so as to increase
the collaborative performance of this column. The outer square steel tube was
formed by welding steel plate and T-shaped section, while the webs of T-shaped
steel were also welded on the inner steel tube as stiffeners. Based on past experi-
ments, the finite element model (FEM) of CFDST under axial loading was estab-
lished and verified by comparing against the results from tests. The verified FE
models were developed to analyze the compressive behavior of these new stub
columns. The effects of stiffener (number and thickness), width-to-thickness (Bo/to)
ratios and hollow ratio on the compressive behavior were studied. It was found that
stiffeners could delay local buckling of the tube and change its mode and stress
path.
1 Introduction
Concrete filled double skin tube (CFDST) stub columns consist of double con-
centric steel tubes, and the space between the tubes filled with concrete. When
compared with concrete filled steel tube (CFST) column, CFDST column is lighter,
has a higher bending stiffness, higher section modulus, better local stability and
cyclic performance.
In recent years, researchers have carried out experiments and finite element
analyses to investigate the behavior of concrete filled double-skin stub members
under compressive forces. The performance of CFDST column under axial loading,
eccentric loading and bending moment was studied by Elchalakani et al. [1], Han
et al. [3], Huang et al. [5], and Uenaka [10]. The corresponding calculation method
of bearing capacity was proposed. The results indicated that local buckling occurred
not only on the outer steel tube but also on the inner steel tube before their ultimate
strength was developed.
In order to investigate the effect of stiffeners, Liang et al. [7] studied the com-
pressive behavior of CFDSTs with different types, arrangements of stiffeners, and
varied slenderness ratios under both axial and eccentric loading. Shekastehband
et al. [8] analyzed the cyclic behavior of CFDST columns with different patterns of
stiffeners embedded in the interior or exterior surfaces of the inner or outer tubes.
Wang et al. [11] investigated the effects of the eccentricity and slenderness ratio on
the compressive behaviors of concrete-filled double-skin steel tubular columns with
an outer stiffened thin-walled steel tube. All results indicated that the ductility of the
CFDST specimens was improved greatly by the presence of stiffeners. However,
the stiffener stiffness has no significant effect on the load-bearing capacity of the
CFDST.
In general, it is clear that there is little information regarding the stiffeners of the
CFDST column. To increase the collaborative performance of this column, the
authors proposed a new type of concrete-filled double skin steel tube (CFDST) that
uses webs to connect the inner and outer steel tubes as shown in Fig. 1. The outer
square steel tube was formed by welding steel plate and T-shaped section, while the
webs of T-shaped steel were also welded on the inner steel tube as stiffeners. The
outer square steel tube facilitates the connection of the beam-column joints, and the
circular steel tube acts as an inner tube to prevent the occurrence of local buckling.
CFDSTs with longitudinal stiffeners can effectively delay the buckling of the steel
tube, increase the interaction between tube and concrete, and thus have the
advantages of ductility, good integrity and economical superiority.
In order to examine the compressive behavior of this new type of CFDST stub
column, FE simulations of CFDST stub columns with outer steel tubes (square) and
inner steel tubes (circular) under axial force were performed by using ABAQUS.
Material nonlinearity and geometric nonlinearity were considered in the model.
The FE results were verified against the test data reported by Han et al. [3]. The
verified FE model was then used to study the new column with stiffeners con-
necting the outer steel tube and inner steel tube. An extensive parametric study was
conducted to investigate the effects of stiffener number, width-to-thickness (Bo/to)
ratios and hollow ratio on column behaviors.
2.1.1 Steel
2.1.2 Concrete
It was found that the failure features of the CFDST specimens were very similar to
those of CFST columns [9]. Therefore, Han [4] uniaxial stress-strain model for
concrete in CFSTs is used for the analysis of CFDST members, i.e.
2x x2 ð x 1Þ
y¼f x
ð x [ 1Þ ð1Þ
b0 ðx1Þg þ x
e r
x¼ ;y ¼ ð2Þ
e0 r0
0
r 0 ¼ fc ð3Þ
The inner and outer steel tubes of a CFDST were modelled by reduced-integration
shell elements (S4R), and the concrete was modelled by 8-node brick elements
(C3D8R). The approximate global mesh size of the steel tubes and concrete was
20 20 mm. Two reference points (RP-1, RP-2) were created to couple the area
where the steel tube and concrete were located in order to define the boundary
conditions. The first reference point (RP-1) was restrained against all degrees of
freedom. The second reference point (RP-2) was restrained against lateral dis-
placements (x and y directions) and all types of rotations. The load was specified as
a displacement on RP-2 along the longitudinal (z) axis. The finite element meshes
and boundary conditions of a model are shown in Fig. 2.
R P -1
R P -2
In ABAQUS, the “normal behavior” was selected as a “hard contact”. The tan-
gential mechanical property of the contact interaction is simulated by an isotropic
Coulomb friction model. The coefficient of friction (l) is assumed to be 0.6.
The predicted ultimate strengths NFE from the FE modelling were compared with
12 published test results Ntest from Han et al. [3], as shown in Table 1. The dif-
ferences between NFE and Ntest are less than 5%. The predicted axial load N versus
axial strain curves were compared with the test curves in Fig. 3. It can be seen that
the simulation and test results are in good agreement; demonstrating the FE models
are efficient and can be applied for further analysis.
0 0 0
0 10000 20000 30000 0 10000 20000 30000 0 10000 20000 30000
Strain(με) Strain(με) Strain(με)
0 0 0
0 10000 20000 30000 0 10000 20000 30000 0 10000 20000 30000
Strain(με) Strain(με) Strain(με)
Fig. 3 Axial load versus axial strain for the verified models
Group B was used to investigate the effect of Bo =to , the number and thickness of
stiffener on the capacity of columns with the constant hollow ratio of 0.51. The
failure mode, axial load-displacement curves and capacity will be discussed below.
From Figs. 4 and 5, it can be seen that the outward displacement of outer steel tubes
was clearly constrained due to the presence of stiffeners. For group A, as the hollow
ratio increased, local buckling occurred not only on the outer steel tube but also on
the inner steel tube. When compared to specimens having only two stiffeners, the
buckling deformation of the two outer steel plates without stiffening was more
serious. This may be caused by the pressing force in the process of concrete
extrusion. For specimens with four stiffeners, even if the hollow ratio was large, the
buckling of the inner and outer tube can be well limited. For group B, as the ratio of
Bo =to increased, the deformation of outer tubes was significant regardless of the
presence stiffeners. When the ratio was equal to three (like B3), the buckling of the
outer steel tube was difficult to be restricted.
Figures 6 and 7 show the axial load-displacement curves for Group A and Group B,
respectively. All curves appeared approximately linear at the beginning. It can be
seen that the existence of stiffener can improve the ultimate strength of columns.
After reaching the peak strength, the load of CFDSTs generally dropped slowly. For
the stiffened specimens, the capacity decreased more slowly than that of the
unstiffened one, showing better deformation coordination ability. After the load
dropped, the residual load capacity remained almost unchanged. The residual
strength part after the ultimate load seemed parallel to each other. The curves in A3
were very close to one another which indicated that stiffeners had a small effect
when the hollow ratio was large. The curves behaved slightly differently for B3,
maintaining a large ratio of Bo/to. When compared to Group A, all curves in
Group B differed only in the descending segment with varing the Bo/to ratio.
Table 3 shows the results for Group A and Group B. The ultimate loads of most
stiffened specimens of types A1, A2, and A3 increased by 5.1–15.2%, 3.2–10.8%,
FE Simulation of a New Type of CFDST … 1733
A1-00 A2-00
A3-00
500 A1-22 500 A2-22 500
A3-22
A1-23 A2-23
A3-23
250 A1-42 250 A2-42 250 A3-42
A1-43 A2-43
A3-43
0 0 0
0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4
Axial displacement (mm) Axial displacement (mm) Axial displacement (mm)
1500
Load (kN)
750 3000
and 1.8–5.4%, respectively, as compared with the unstiffened ones. For A3, the
effect of stiffener on bearing capacity was not significant, because of the large
hollow ratio (v = 0.77). It can be seen that the influence of stiffener number and
thickness on the ultimate bearing capacity of the specimens was obvious. In the
same group like A1, the more number and the thicker of stiffener, the larger the
capacity can be gained. In Group B, the ultimate loads of most stiffened specimens
of types B1, B2, and B3 increased by 3.2–10.8%, 3.0–8.9%, and 2.3–6.9%,
respectively, compared with the unstiffened ones. It was obvious to find that the
increment of capacity of the specimens in Group B was smaller than that of
Group A.
1734 M. Ding et al.
4 Conclusions
Based on the verified FE model, the compressive behavior of the new type stiffened
CFDST short column was studied. The following conclusions may be drawn for the
study:
1) Stiffeners can delay the local buckling of both inner and outer steel tubes.
Moreover, the efficiency of 4 stiffeners was much better for the specimen with
large Bo =to ratio.
2) Stiffeners can improve the ultimate strength of columns. However, the increase
ratio of the bearing capacity decreases as the hollow ratio increases.
FE Simulation of a New Type of CFDST … 1735
3) After peak load, the load-displacement curve of stiffened columns became more
gradual and maintained a higher residual bearing capacity than unstiffened ones.
All the above results show that this novel stiffened CFDST has potential
application value.
References
1. Elchalakani M, Zhao XL, Grzebieta R (2002) Tests on concrete filled double-skin (CHS outer
and SHS inner) composite short columns under axial compression. Thin Walled Struct
40:415–441
2. En, 1993-1-2. (2005) EN 1993-1-2: Eurocode 3: design of steel structures. Part 1-2: general
rules and rules for buildings. In: Comité Europeo de Normalización
3. Han LH, Tao Z, Huang H, Zhao XL (2004) Concrete-filled double skin (SHS outer and CHS
inner) steel tubular beam-columns. Thin Walled Struct 42:1329–1355
4. Han LH (2016) Concrete Filled Steel Tubular Structures—Theory and Practice. Science
Press, Beijing
5. Huang H, Sun W, Chen MC, Zeng GP (2015) Experimental study on concrete-filled
double-skin circular steel tubes under combined loadings. J Build Struct 36:53–59
6. Institute, American Concrete (2005) Building code requirements for structural concrete and
commentary. In: Concrete Construction. ACI Committee 318 (ACI318), Detroit, USA
7. Liang W, Dong JF, Wang QY (2019) Mechanical behaviour of concrete-filled double-skin
steel tube (CFDST) with stiffeners under axial and eccentric loading. Thin Walled Struct
138:215–230
8. Shekastehband B, Mohammadbagheri S, Taromi A (2018) Seismic behavior of stiffened
concrete-filled double-skin tubular columns. Steel Compos Struct 27:577–598
9. Tao Z, Han LH, Zhao XL (2004) Behaviour of concrete-filled double skin (CHS inner and
CHS outer) steel tubular stub columns and beam-columns. J Constr Steel Res 60:1129–1158
10. Uenaka Kojiro (2016) CFDST stub columns having outer circular and inner square sections
under compression. J Constr Steel Res 120:1–7
11. Wang ZB, Gao YH, Chi SY, Liao FY (2018) Behavior of concrete-filled double-skin
thin-walled steel tubular columns under eccentric compression. J Build Struct 39:124–131
Experimental Study on Stress-Strain
Properties of Ultra-High Performance
Fibre Reinforced Concrete Under
Uniaxial Compression and Tension
Keywords UHPFRC Uniaxial compressive testing techniques Uniaxial tensile
testing techniques Stress-strain curve
1 Introduction
buildings, determining its tensile and compressive properties are critical to its
structural behavior, numerical simulation and fracture mechanics. A number of
studies about the behavior of UHPFRC under static loading have been investigated
[3, 6, 7], each with its own interpretation to develop appropriate tensile and com-
pression test methods. However, the influence of the mix ratio, raw materials and
test instruments on the static properties of UHPFRC, especially the post-cracking
behavior, is significant, and the stiffness of most test machines is not enough to
capture the full stress-strain curve, so a relatively common test method has not been
found. At the same time, the research on the influence of different steel fiber
contents and water-cement ratio on the full stress-strain curve is still insufficient.
This paper was developed for the determination of UHPFRC and UHPC (re-
inforced without steel fibers) test method for uniaxial tensile and compressive
properties. In the compression test, a rigid element and a deformation test frame
were used to obtain a method for capturing the UHPFRC stress-strain curve falling
section on a conventional electro-hydraulic servo test machine. Large cross-section
specimens were used in the tensile test to ensure the random distribution of the
fibers. In the mixture used in this study, Steel fiber is 13 mm long and the diameter
is 0.2 mm, The yield strength is 2850 MPa. The ultimate compression and tensile
stresses of the six concrete mixtures and their corresponding strains were deter-
mined. The effects of different steel fiber content and water-to-binder ratio on
strength and ductility were determined.
The detailed information of the mixing ratio of UHPFRC and UHPC used in this
study is shown in Table 1. Its mix design is developed on the basis of other
researchers [8].
A total of six different concrete mixtures (UHPFRC and UHPC) were cast and
numbered. The six mixtures contained different steel fiber content or water to binder
ratio. Among them, W18F1 indicates that the water-to-binder ratio is 0.18. The steel
fiber content is 1% of the total volume. All specimens were kept at the laboratory
temperature (20 °C) for 24 h. After checking the initial solidification of all samples,
demolding was carried out in about 24 h. All samples were placed in a 90 °C
high-temperature water bath for the next 48 h. Finally, the specimen was stored at
the laboratory temperature until the test day.
3 Experimental Test
The compressive strength test is the most common test for UHPFRC. Many
accepted standards (AFGC; ASTM C469-94) provide detailed guidance for mea-
suring the compressive strength and modulus of elasticity of concrete using
cylindrical specimens. However, it has been found that the test methods recom-
mended by the two specifications are not very suitable, especially when measuring
the post-cracking behavior of UHPFRC samples. those methods only capture the
peak strength of the UHPFRC sample. When the bearing capacity of the specimen
reaches the maximum value and starts to fall, the test machine recovers deformation
due to the reduced force and rapidly releases energy. A large additional strain is
applied to the specimens, causing the specimens to be destroyed rapidly. It shows
the characteristic of a steep drop in stress on the curve.
By modifying the standard tests, a simple method has been developed. This
method allows the general electro-hydraulic servo tester to obtain the entire
stress-strain range. A uniaxial compression test was performed on a cylindrical
specimen with a diameter of 100 mm and a height of 200 mm. Grub screws were
used to secure two rigid rings to two-thirds of the specimen. Two displacement
meters were introduced in the middle of the two rigid rings and are fixed on
opposite sides of the sample. The specimens were loaded at a rate of 0.1 mm/min
and the measured values were recorded.
To obtain a stable full curve of stress and strain, the main difficulty is the falling
part of the curve. As shown in Fig. 1, in this study, by inserting four screw jacks
with a maximum bearing capacity of 32t, the overall stiffness of the test device was
increased and exceeded the maximum line stiffness of the falling section of the
specimen. The elastic strain energy released by the test machine was absorbed by
those four screw jacks when the specimen was damaged, so a stable concrete
stress-strain full curve is obtained. Prior to each test, All the cylindrical specimens
1740 J.-H. Liu et al.
Rigid
auxiliary
Deforma on
Test frame
Strain
gauge
were polished to both ends with an unevenness of less than 0.1 mm. High strength
gypsum was applied to minimize stress concentration at the ends.
a b
Grip for
Strain
gauge Deforma on
For each test in tension and compression, 6 specimens from six concrete mixtures
were tested, and the average curve after interpolation is given here. The strain is
obtained by dividing the average of the displacement meter with the gauge length.
The stress is obtained by dividing the load captured by the pressure sensor with the
smallest cross section of the specimen. The material behavior of the six concretes
can be summarized as follows.
For the compression performance of UHPFRC, the steel fiber mainly acts as a fine
aggregate in the rising section of the compressive stress-strain curve and does not
play the role of tension. However, its effect on the performance and failure
mechanism after cracking is significant. It can be seen in Fig. 3a that the elastic
phases of the four concrete with different steel fiber contents follow a similar trend
up to the proportional limit.
When the steel fiber content is 0, the UHPC sample is destroyed by a sudden
explosion at this time. As shown in Fig. 4a, the concrete fragments are splashed
because there is no fiber pulling action. In contrast, the elastic phase of the
UHPFRC specimen can extend up to about 90–95% of its peak strength, followed
1742 J.-H. Liu et al.
a b
175 175
W16F0 W16F2
W16F1 W18F2
150 150
W16F2 W20F2
W16F3
125 125
100 100
75 75
50 50
25 25
0 0
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000
Fig. 3 Compressive stress–strain curve: a the stress-strain curve with respect to steel fibers
content. b the stress-strain curve with respect to water-cement ratio
(a) The failure mode of UHPC. (b) The failure mode of UHPFRC.
by a strain hardening process up to the peak strength. After the peak intensity, a
sudden strain softening occurs where the presence of fibers controls the softening
phase. When the fiber content is 1%, the interaction between the fiber and the
matrix is still not enough to cause strain softening of UHPFRC, but its failure mode
is shown in Fig. 4b, which is transformed into ductile compression failure, even
under the total strength loss. The surface remains intact.
With the further increase of steel fiber content, the strain softening stage of
UHPFRC is more gradual, and the area under the entire stress-strain curve
increases. This is because the bridging effect of the fiber slows down the further
development of the crack after the cracking of the specimen.
Compared with the steel fiber content, the water-binder ratio has no significant
effect on the strain softening stage of UHPFRC, as shown in Fig. 3b. As the
water-to-binder ratio increases, the stiffness of UHPFRC decreases accordingly.
With the increases of water-to-binder ratio, although the workability of the concrete
Experimental Study on Stress-Strain Properties … 1743
mixture improved, it is easier to leave a larger pore in the test block. Those large
pores result in a corresponding decrease in the elastic modulus of the UHPFRC. As
the water-to-binder ratio increased from 0.16 to 0.18, the peak strength of UHPFRC
was basically the same, but it decreased by 12.54% from 0.18 to 0.2. The reason is
that when the water-to-binder ratio is increased to a certain extent, the interface
between the fiber and the cement matrix is more likely to form a water film. It has a
looser structure than the matrix structure, so the steel fiber is liable to be pulled off
due to insufficient bond strength.
As shown in Fig. 5a, the tensile properties of the four concretes with different steel
fiber contents are significantly different. The entire curve can be divided into a line
elastic phase, a crack development phase, and a failure phase. In the Linear elastic
phase, similar to the uniaxial compression experiment, the fiber content does not
significantly affect the behavior of the material. The maximum tensile strength that
can be obtained at this stage is the cracking strength of the concrete matrix. When
the first micro crack appears, the curve enters the crack development stage. At this
stage, the UHPC with a steel fiber content of 0 is rapidly destroyed at the first crack
as shown in Fig. 6a. In contrast, the strength of the UHPFRC specimen is main-
tained by the composite action of the steel fibers that bridge the concrete crack.
Tensile strength begins to increase at a very small rate. With the increase of the steel
fiber content, the strain hardening behavior becomes more pronounced. At this
stage, a large number of microcracks are formed around the first main crack as
shown in Fig. 6b. Strain hardening behavior is the most significant difference
between UHPFRC and all other types of concrete. When the ultimate tensile
strength of UHPFRC is reached at the end of the strain hardening state, the curve
enters the failure phase. The microcracks formed in the crack development stage
form the main crack, and the width gradually increases after the transverse pene-
tration. The steel fiber continues to be pulled out, and the bearing capacity is
gradually reduced until the specimen is broken, as shown in Fig. 6b.
As shown in Fig. 5b, the difference between the tensile stress-strain curves of the
three concretes with different water-to-binder ratios is mainly the difference in
cracking strength. The reason is that water-to-binder ratio mainly affects the
strength of the UHPFRC concrete matrix. As the water-to-binder ratio decreases,
the strength of the concrete matrix increases, and the corresponding cracking
strength also increases. The bond between the steel fiber and the concrete matrix is
too small when the water-to-binder ratio is 0.2. Therefore, the strain hardening
phase does not occur, but directly enters the failure phase.
1744 J.-H. Liu et al.
10
a W16F0
b
W16F1 W16F2
W16F2 8 W18F2
8 W16F3 W20F2
Tensile stress (Mpa)
4
4
2
2
0 0
0 1500 3000 4500 6000 7500 9000 10500 12000 13500 0 1500 3000 4500 6000 7500 9000 10500 12000 13500 15000
Strain (µε) Strain (µε)
Fig. 5 Tensile stress-strain curve: a the stress-strain curve with respect to steel fibers content.
b the stress-strain curve with respect to water-cement ratio
(a) The failure mode of UHPC. (b) The failure mode of UHPFRC.
5 Conclusions
The increase of steel fiber content has little effect on the peak strain and elastic
modulus of UHPFRC tensile and compressive stress. However, there is a significant
improvement in the form of failure and the ductility after cracking, which is the
decisive factor for the transformation of UHPFRC from brittleness to ductility. 2%
of the steel fiber content is proved to be able to make the failure form of UHPFRC
into ductile failure.
The value of the water-to-binder ratio affects the strength of the UHPFRC
concrete matrix and the modulus of elasticity. Tests have shown that a
water-to-binder ratio of 0.18 is the most suitable choice without reducing the
strength of UHPFRC.
Experimental Study on Stress-Strain Properties … 1745
References
1. ASTM C (2002) 469, Standard test method for static modulus of elasticity and Poisson’s ratio
of concrete in compression. Annual book of ASTM standards, 4
2. AFGC SETRA (2013) Ultra high performance fiber-reinforced concrete. Recommendations.
AFGC-SETRA Working Group, Bagneux
3. Duque LFM, Graybeal B (2017) Fiber orientation distribution and tensile mechanical response
in UHPFRC. Mater Struct 50(1):55
4. de Larrard F, Sedran T (1994) Optimization of ultra-high-performance concrete by the use of a
packing model. Cem Concr Res 24(6):997–1009
5. Kanakubo T (2006) Tensile characteristics evaluation method for ductile fiber-reinforced
cementitious composites. J Adv Concr Technol 4(1):3–17
6. Prabha SL, Dattatreya JK, Neelamegam M, Seshagirirao MV (2010) Study on stress-strain
properties of reactive powder concrete under uniaxial compression. Int J Eng Sci Technol
2(11):6408–6416
7. Wille K, El-Tawil S, Naaman AE (2014) Properties of strain hardening ultra high performance
fiber reinforced concrete (UHP-FRC) under direct tensile loading. Cement Concr Compos
48:53–66
8. Yu R, Spiesz P, Brouwers HJH (2014) Mix design and properties assessment of ultra-high
performance fiber reinforced concrete (UHPFRC). Cem Concr Res 56:29–39
Complexities and Effectiveness
of Australian Standard for Concrete
Structures—AS 3600-2018
Abstract The first of the AS 3600 standard series, Australian Standard for
Concrete Structures AS 3600-1988 was published in March 1988. It was a unified
code for providing design guides for reinforced and prestressed concrete structures.
Since then, AS 3600 has been revised four times and published consecutively at
between six to nine-year intervals as AS 3600-1994, AS 3600-2001, AS 3600-2009
and the latest, AS 3600-2018.
The changes and/or updates made in AS 3600-2018 are mainly in the following
requirements:
• Values of capacity reduction factor, /, for different strengths of reinforced and
prestressed members
• Stress-block configuration for the analysis and design of reinforced and pre-
stressed members in bending
• Shear and torsional strengths of reinforced and prestressed members
• Effective moment of inertia for deflection calculation of reinforced and pre-
stressed members
Examples illustrating the application of the relevant new design procedures and
formulas have been worked out in detail and presented elsewhere by the authors.
Being a rather mature discipline, research worldwide on the mechanics and
strength of concrete structures is sustaining a state of diminishing return. Australia
is no exception. In particular, much of the abovementioned modifications have
resulted in more complicated procedures and computational efforts. Academically,
such added complexity might be considered as a disciplinary upgrade. On the other
hand, the practitioners definitely deserve to be advised of the effectiveness, or
worthiness, of such an advance.
In each of the concerned topics, analysis and design calculations have been
carried out using the updated specifications given in AS 3600-2018, as well as those
available in the superseded AS 3600-2009. Based on the numerical data and design
outcomes, observations are made in this paper in regard to the complexity and
effectiveness of this Australia’s premier concrete structures code.
1 Introduction
Australian Standard (AS) 3600-1988 Concrete Structures, the first of the AS 3600
series, was published in March 1988. In line with European practices, it was a
unified code covering reinforced and prestressed concrete structures. In effect, AS
3600-1988 Concrete Structures was the revised and amalgamated version of AS
1480-1982 SAA Concrete Structures Code [1] and AS 1481-1978 SAA Prestressed
Concrete Code [2], which it then superseded. Limit state design philosophy was
adopted in AS 3600-1988 [3]. Many of the design equations for shear, torsion, slabs
and columns were changed, but the strength design procedure was basically the
same, that is, to ensure /Ru S . For a given section of any structural member to be
designed, S* was the ‘action effect’ or axial force, moment, shear or torsion due to
the most critical combination of the external service loads, each multiplied by a
corresponding load factor; Ru was the computed ultimate resistance (or strength) of
the member at that section against the said type of action effect; and ϕ was the
capacity reduction factor specified for the type of ultimate strength in question.
Since 1988, AS 3600 has been revised and updated four times and published
consecutively at approximately six to nine-year intervals as AS 3600-1994 [4], AS
3600-2001 [5], AS 3600-2009 [6], and the latest AS 3600-2018 [7]. However, the
limit state design philosophy remains unchanged in the latest version of the
Standard in which Clause 2.2.2 states that Rd Ed , where Rd ¼ /Ru is the ‘design
capacity’, and Ed ¼ S , the design action effect.
In AS 3600-2001, N-grade or 500 MPa steel was specified, leading to modifi-
cations in serviceability specifications and other consequential changes. In AS
3600-2001, an additional strength grade for concrete was introduced with the
characteristic compressive strength fc0 = 65 MPa. Two more grades were provided
0
in AS 3600-2009 [6], i.e. fc = 80 MPa and 100 MPa. This has resulted in modi-
fication to many of the design equations. However, these design equations are
further modified and/or made more complex in some cases in AS 3600-2018 [7].
Complexities and Effectiveness of Australian Standard … 1749
The changes and/or updates made in AS 3600-2018 [7] are mainly in the fol-
lowing requirements:
• Stress-block configuration for the analysis and design of reinforced and pre-
stressed members in bending
• Values of capacity reduction factor, /, for different member strengths
• Shear and torsional strengths of members
• Effective moment of inertia for deflection calculations.
Being a rather mature discipline, research worldwide on the mechanics and
strength of concrete structures is sustaining a state of diminishing return. Australia is
no exception. The abovementioned modifications have resulted in more complicated
procedures and added computational efforts. Academically, such increased com-
plexity might be considered as a disciplinary upgrade. On the other hand, the prac-
titioners deserve to be advised of the effectiveness, or worthiness, of such an advance.
In view of the above, for each of the concerned topics, analysis and design
calculations have been carried out using the updated specifications given in AS
3600-2018 [7], as well as those available in the superseded AS 3600-2009 [6].
Based on the numerical data and design outcomes, observations are made in this
paper regarding the complexity and effectiveness of this the latest version of
Australia’s premier concrete structures code.
2.1 Complexities
The widely accepted ‘actual’ stress block is as shown in Fig. 1(a). The factor g < 1
accounts for the difference between the crushing strength of concrete cylinders and
0
the concrete in the beam; a and b, each being a function of fc , define the geometry
of the stress block. Empirical but complicated formulas have been given for g, a
and b. Although the concept of the curved stress block was acknowledged as an
advance, it was tedious to apply. The equivalent (rectangular) stress block, as
shown in Fig. 1(b), was so defined that its use would give the same Mu as that
computed using the ‘actual’ stress block.
In AS 3600-2009 [6], a2 and c for all section types were given as:
For circular sections, a2 is to be reduced by 5% and for any section for which
width reduces from the neutral axis towards the compression face, a2 is to be
reduced by 10%.
On the other hand, for all section types,
ηf c' α 2 f c'
βk ud γ k ud / 2
Neutral Axis
(a) (b)
but for beams with Class N reinforcement only, 0:6 / 0:8 and for beams with
Class L reinforcement, 0:6 / 0:64:
In Eq. (5), kuo ¼ kduod in which do is the distance between the extreme compres-
sion fibre and the centroid of the outermost layer of the tension bars.
In AS 3600-2018 [7], ϕ values are changed to:
but for beams with Class N reinforcement only, 0:65 / 0:85 and for beams with
Class L reinforcement, / ¼ 0:65:
2.2 Effectiveness
Analysis and design calculations have been carried out using the updated specifi-
cations given in AS 3600-2018 [7] and those available in the superseded AS
3600-2009 [6] for several problems. These helps investigate the effectiveness of
introducing the complexities as described above in determining α2, γ and ϕ. The
results are presented in detail elsewhere [11].
As a demonstration, for a singly reinforced rectangular section with
b = 250 mm, d = 500 mm, fc0 = 50 MPa, and Class N reinforcement only
(fsy = 500 MPa), the reliable moment capacities for the following reinforcement
cases were calculated using provisions of both AS 3600-2009 [6] and AS
3600-2018 [7]:
(a) Ast = 1500 mm2
(b) Ast = 9000 mm2
(c) a ‘balanced’ design
(d) with the maximum allowable reinforcement ratio (pall)
(e) Ast = 4500 mm2.
The results are tabulated in Table 1 for comparison. As can be seen from
Table 1, the ultimate moment capacities for different reinforcement cases differ very
little while reliable moment capacities varying to slightly larger extents mainly
because of increase in ϕ values in AS 3600-2018 [7]. Similar minor variations in
moment capacities were observed for all other problems even for non-standard and
circular sections [11].
As for design examples, these changes made no difference at all in reinforcement
requirements and sectional dimensions [11] for any of the worked problems which
include all section types (rectangular and flanged) and reinforcement details (singly-
and doubly-reinforced).
1752 S. H. Chowdhury and Y. C. Loo
Table 1 Comparison between AS 3600-2009 [6] and AS 3600-2018 [7] for the analysis problem
Reinforcement case (Ast As per AS 3600-2009 [6] As per AS 3600-2018 [7]
values) Mu ϕ ϕMu Mu ϕ ϕMu
(kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm)
(a) Ast = 1500 mm2 348.5 0.8 278.8 346.0 0.85 294.1
(b) Ast = 9000 mm2 964.2 0.6 578.5 978.5 0.65 636.0
(c) balanced pt = pB 819.5 0.6 491.7 858.7 0.65 558.2
(d) maximum pt = pall 639.6 0.757 484.2 680.4 0.807 549.1
(e) Ast = 4500 mm2 840.7 0.6 504.4 860.4 0.65 559.3
3.1 Complexities
The nominal maximum shear force that can be carried by a beam is limited by the
crushing strength of the web, Vu.max, given in AS 3600-2009 [6] by
Vu:max ¼ 0:2fc0 bw do , where bw is the width of the web of the beam.
On the other hand, Vu.max is to be calculated in a much more complicated manner
in AS 3600-2018 [7], as
cot hv
Vu:max ¼ 0:55 fc0 bw dv ð7Þ
1 þ cot2 hv
where effective shear depth, dv, shall be taken as the greater of 0.72D or 0.9d and
the angle of inclination of the compression strut (θv) shall be calculated as, hv ¼
ð29 þ 7000ex Þ; in which, the longitudinal strain in concrete for shear, ex , at the
mid-depth of the section is calculated as
jM =dv j þ jV j þ 0:5N
ex ¼ 3:0 103 ð8Þ
2Es Ast
where M* and V* are absolute values and M* ≥ V*dv and N* is the axial force acting
on the section and is taken as positive for tension and negative for compression.
Complexities and Effectiveness of Australian Standard … 1753
Alternatively, θv may be taken as 36° for N* = 0, fsy ≤ 500 MPa, fc0 65 MPa
and maximum aggregate size not less than 10 mm.
Concrete contribution to shear strength, Vuc, is given by the following in AS
3600-2009 [6]:
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
Ast
Vuc ¼ b1 b2 b3 bw do fcv ð9Þ
3
b w do
where β1, β2 and β3 can be computed using simple formulas and/or taken as equal to
pffiffiffiffi
1, and fcv = 3 fc0 .
In AS 3600-2018 [7], the determination of Vuc, requires much more computa-
pffiffiffiffi
tional efforts in a rather complex way. Or, Vuc, is given as Vuc ¼ kv bw dv fc0 ; where
pffiffiffiffi
fc0 is not to exceed 8.0 MPa, the strut angle θv is calculated using equations as
above and kv is determined as elaborated below.
h ih i
0
(a) For Asv < Asv.min: kv ¼ 1 þ 0:4
1500ex 1000 þ kdg dv , where for fc ≤ 65 MPa and not
1300
h i
light-weight concrete, kdg ¼ ð1632þ aÞ 0:8, in which a is the maximum nom-
inal aggregate size and for a not less than 16 mm, kdg may be taken as 1.0. For
fc0 > 65 MPa or light-weight concrete kdg = 2.0.
h i
(b) For Asv ≥ Asv.min: kv ¼ 1 þ 0:4
1500ex .
Alternatively, for N* = 0, fsy ≤ 500 MPa, fc0 65 MPa and maximum aggregate
size not less than 10 mm, kv mayh be determined
i as follows.
(a) For Asv < Asv.min: kv ¼ 200
1000 þ 1:3dv 0:10 and (b) For Asv ≥ Asv.min:
kv = 0.15.
Finally, transverse shear reinforcement is to be provided in all regions where
V [ /Vuc or in which the overall depth of the member D ≥ 750 mm.
For torsional design, even though the basic principles were still the same, the
computations and formulas used are made a lot more complicated—not to mention
the extra computational efforts required.
For brevity, these are not re-produced here but Vu.max, which is required for
torsional design check, itself is calculated using Eq. (7) but for the determination of
θv, the longitudinal strain in the concrete at the mid-depth of the section, εx, sub-
jected to shear and torsion is determined as
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
h i2ffi
M
dv þ jV j þ 0:9T
2
2Ao
uh
þ 0:5N
ex ¼ 3:0 103 ð10Þ
2Es Ast
where Ao = area enclosed by shear flow path, including any area of holes therein
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
h i2ffi
and M and V are absolute values and M dv jV j þ 0:9T
* * 2
2Ao
uh
.
1754 S. H. Chowdhury and Y. C. Loo
3.2 Effectiveness
Calculations for design of reinforced concrete for shear and torsion have been
carried out using the updated specifications given in AS 3600-2018 [7], as well as
those available in the superseded AS 3600-2009 [6] for several practical problems.
These are presented in detail elsewhere [11].
A summary of some of the worked problems for shear design using AS
3600-2009 and AS 3600-2018 is presented in Table 2 for comparison.
As obvious in Table 2, the final designs for shear varied rather little for most of
the problems. In fact, for the lower range of design shear values, where the max-
imum spacing for shear reinforcement allowed by the Standard governed, there are
no difference in the final design. Cases where the final design varied significantly
are beams subjected to large axial forces together with design shear forces.
Interested readers may find further details elsewhere [11].
Table 2 Comparison between AS 3600-2009 [6] and AS 3600-2018 [7] for shear design
problems
Problem Design As per AS 3600-2009 [6] As per AS 3600-2018 [7]
no. V* (kN) Vu.max Vuc Final Vu.max Vuc Final
(kN) (kN) design (kN) (kN) design
1 248.76 430.0 108.2 R10@ 506.1 58.05 R10@
75 mm 75 mm
2 537.73 987.0 218.2 N16@ 1112.2 127.6 N16@
285 mm 245 mm
3 334.61 1658.9 260.3 N12@ 1876.5 190.4 N12@
300 mm 300 mm
4 478.36 1316.3 210.1 N10@ 1474.5 154.5 N10@
155 mm 125 mm
5 876.60 2165.8 394.7 N12@ 2375.4 241.0 N12@
165 mm 130 mm
6 228.69 420.0 98.3 R10@ 494.3 56.7 R10@
85 mm 90 mm
7 1180.7 2030.4 328.7 N12@ 2392.6 101.9 N12@
75 mm 45 mm
Complexities and Effectiveness of Australian Standard … 1755
Similar observations have also been made for torsion design in that little or no
variations can be found in the outcomes.
4 Deflection
The empirical Branson formula for calculating the effective moment of inertia (Ief)
has been adopted in the AS 3600-2009 [6] and several other major codes of practice
including that of the American Concrete Institute (see [12]). Taking into consid-
eration the stiffening effects of the concrete in tension between cracks (i.e. tension
stiffening), the formula is explicit and all-encompassing. That is
3
Mcr
Ief ¼ Icr þ ðIg Icr Þ Ief:max ð11Þ
Ms
where Ief.max = Ig for pt ≥ 0.005 and Ief.max = 0.6Ig for pt < 0.005, which indicates
that the Branson formula in its original form underestimates the deflection of very
lightly reinforced beams (see [8]).
The quantity Ms is the maximum bending moment at the section due to the
short-term serviceability load under consideration, and Mcr is the cracking moment.
In AS 3600-2018 [7], the formula for calculating Ief is modified as follows with
the same limiting values for Ief.max as in Eq. (11):
Icr
Ief ¼ 2 Ief:max ð12Þ
1 1 IIcrg MMcrs
To investigate the effectiveness of the changes made to the Ief formula, calcu-
lations for several deflection problems have been made using the provisions given
in AS 3600-2018 [7], as well as those available in the superseded AS 3600-2009
[6]. The outcomes are detailed elsewhere [11]. Little or no variations in deflection
results were observed for all of the problems attempted in the said investigation.
5 Conclusions
Significant changes and/or updates have been made in AS 3600-2018 [7], the latest
Australian Standard for Concrete Structures. These are mainly in the requirements
for configuring the stress-block, calculating the capacity reduction factor ϕ, eval-
uating the shear and torsional strengths of concrete members, as well as in esti-
mating the effective moment of inertia Ief.
1756 S. H. Chowdhury and Y. C. Loo
References
Abstract In reinforced concrete (RC) structures, bond between concrete and rebar is
a key to form load bearing mechanism. When rebar is corroded, it is said that the bond
of concrete-rebar is deteriorated and structural performance is also influenced. To
improve accuracy in assessment of the residual structural performance for deterio-
rated structures, it is important to understand the influence of bond deterioration more
deeply. This research aims to investigate the influence of concrete-rebar bond
deterioration on structural performance. Three beams with physically different state
of the bond, 100% mechanical bond, 50% mechanical bond and 0% mechanical
bond, were tested with a static loading. According to the test results, all bond con-
ditions presented differences in the crack spacing, load capacities, and failure modes.
The specimens with 0% mechanical bond were much inferior to the other cases in the
bond performance. Due to bond deterioration, rigidity of 0% mechanical bond
specimen was decreased. However, shear capacity of 0% mechanical bond specimen
was enhanced by forming of tied arch mechanism. With regard to 50% mechanical
bond specimens, the bond performance degraded to some extent and it leaded rigidity
reduction and high shear capacity due to forming tied arch mechanism. However, the
presence of shear reinforcement affected the bond performance of 50% bond spec-
imen. When the shear reinforcement was arranged, it improved the bond performance
of the main rebar and concrete, and the bond performance did not degrade as sig-
nificant as expected from physical contact loss. As a result, the structural behavior of
50% bond specimen with shear reinforcement was similar to 100% bond specimen.
Keywords Bond Deformed bar Crack dispersion-effect Tied arch mechanism
1 Introduction
2 Methodology
Beam specimens with 3 kinds of bond conditions, 100%, 50%, and 0% were casted.
These apparent bond ratios were the proportion of bonding area by interlocking
mechanism because interlocking mechanism by contacted points has more signif-
icant effect than the other mechanisms like friction and adhesion. The specimen
with 100% bond was a sound RC beam. The specimen with 50% bond was a RC
beam whose bottom half cover concrete on the main rebar was artificially removed.
In other words, a half of rebar was exposed in this specimen. The specimen with 0%
bond was a RC beam with round bar, and this beam had no interlocking resistance
by contacted points. However, resistance by friction and chemical adhesion still
existed. Table 1 shows bond conditions of beam specimens.
The Influence of the Deterioration of Concrete-Rebar Bond ... 1759
The shear reinforcement restraints the main rebar, and it is thought that shear
reinforcement affects the bond performance of the main rebar. To investigate the
effect of shear reinforcement, 2 series of specimens, ST series and PL series were
prepared. ST means specimens with stirrup, and PL means specimens without
stirrup in shear span. Table 2 shows a list of experimental cases.
PL series
ST series
2.2 Specimens
Figure 1 shows the detailed design of beam specimens. Nuts anchored the edge of
rebar. Table 3 shows the dimensions of all beam specimens, and Table 4 shows the
material properties of concrete and rebar.
3 Results
500 500
400 400
Load (kN)
Load (kN)
300 300
200 200
100 100
0 0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Deflection (mm) Deflection (mm)
PL-0 PL-50 PL-100 ST-0 ST-50 ST-100
(a) PL series (b) ST series
stress acting on the main rebar because the bond along the surface was small. This
stress exceeded compressive strength of concrete and anchorage failure occurred.
PL-50 was failed by flexural compression failure. The failure modes of ST-50 and
100% bond specimens were shear compression failure.
In the static loading test, the deflection at the center of span and magnitude of the
load were measured by displacement transducer and load cell. The load deflection
curves were obtained as shown in Fig. 3. As shown in the load deflection curves, in
the case of specimens with 0% bond, the rigidity declines significantly after the
middle stage of loading. The rigidity of specimens with 50% bond also declines
after the middle stage of loading, but the rigidity reduction is small and the behavior
is similar to 100% bond case.
The differences in the bond conditions changed the load-bearing mechanisms,
and it leads the differences in failure modes and load capacities.
The strain of the main rebar was measured by strain gauges. Figure 4 shows the
positions of strain gauges. The strain distribution of the main rebar is obtained from
the test results. Figure 5 shows the relationship of load and strain at each position.
1762 Y. Ito et al.
PL series
ST series
Load (kN)
400
Load (kN)
200 300
200
100
100
0 0
0 1000 2000 0 1000 2000 3000
Strain (μ) Strain (μ)
G4 G3 G2 G1 G4 G3 G2 G1
(c) PL-50 (d) ST-50
300 500
Load (kN)
400
Load (kN)
200 300
200
100
100
0 0
0 1000 2000 0 1000 2000 3000
Strain (μ) Strain (μ)
G4 G3 G2 G1 G4 G3 G2 G1
(e) PL-100 (f) ST-100
300 500
Load (kN)
Load (kN)
400
200 300
200
100
100
0 0
0 1000 2000 0 1000 2000 3000
Strain (μ) Strain (μ)
G4 G3 G2 G1 G4 G3 G2 G1
The bond performance of each specimen during loading can be inferred from the
strain distribution of the main rebar. As you can see in Fig. 5, the magnitude of
strain at each position was different. The magnitude of strain was maximum at the
center of span, and it decreased as the position got close to the supports. These
differences in the magnitude of strain came from bond. Looking at (a) PL-0 and
(b) ST-0 in Fig. 5, there were differences of strain value depending on the position
at initial period of loading; however, the differences disappeared at middle period of
loading. It can be said that chemical adhesion worked at initial period, and it lost
gradually in the specimens with 0% bond. In PL-0 and ST-0, they can be found that
each curves starts to asymptote when the load exceeds 100 kN, and the curves
almost matches from 170 kN. Therefore, it is thought that chemical adhesion lost
gradually from 100 kN, and when the load exceeded 170 kN, chemical adhesion did
not work. This type of beams had no interlocking by contact points. So the bond
performance degraded rapidly when chemical adhesion was lost.
Looking at (c) PL-50 in Fig. 5, the curves of G1, G2 and G3 showed similar
behaviour to the case of PL-0 and ST-0. And, the strain value of G4 had difference
from G1, G2 and G3. As well as the specimens with 0% bond, the bond deterio-
ration could be found in PL-50; however, the bond performance was kept by the
upper half of the contact points to some extent.
On the other hand, looking at (d) ST-50 in Fig. 5, the shapes of curves are
almost same as the case of ST-100 and PL-100. The differences of strain value at
each position kept until the end of loading. That means the bond performance of
ST-50 specimen did not degrade so much even if the bonding area was halved.
From these results, in the case of 50% bond specimens, the presence of shear
reinforcement affected the bond performance of the main rebar and concrete. It is
thought that the shear reinforcement restrained the main rebar upward, and
improved the interlocking mechanism of concrete and contact points of rebar.
4 Discussion
The bond of concrete and rebar has crack-dispersion effect, and it prevents local-
ization of cracks. Conversely, the bond performance can be estimated from the
degree of the dispersion of cracks at certain extent. So the number of flexural cracks
has important meaning. Figure 6 shows relationships of the number of flexural
cracks and apparent bond ratio.
1764 Y. Ito et al.
Number of flexural
number of flexural cracks and
apparent bond ratio 8
PL
6
cracks
4
2
0
0 50 100
Apparent bond ratio (%)
In PL series, the number of flexural cracks were fewer as the apparent bond ratio
were smaller. Therefore, from the viewpoint of crack-dispersion effect, the bond
performance of specimens of PL series degraded as the apparent bond ratio
decreased. On the other hand, in ST series, 0% bond specimen had fewer cracks;
however, 50% bond specimen had same number of flexural cracks as 100% bond
specimen. It is thought that shear reinforcement improved interlocking mechanism
of concrete and contact points of rebar in ST-50. In ST-0, this specimen had no
contact points of main rebar, and the effect of shear reinforcement on the bond
performance could not found from the degree of crack dispersion.
From the viewpoint of the crack-dispersion effect, the bond performance was
degraded as the apparent bond ratio decreased in PL-series. In ST series, the bond
performance was degraded; however, it of 50% bond specimen improved by the
presence of shear reinforcement and the degradation of bond performance was
slight.
From the strain distribution of the main rebar and the degree of crack dispersion, the
bond performances of beam specimens under loading were revealed. The bond
performance of the specimen with 0% bond degraded gradually, and it was much
inferior to the other cases. The degradation of the bond performance was also found
in 50% bond specimens. However, the bond performance degradation of specimen
with shear reinforcement was slight due to the bond enhancement effect by shear
reinforcement.
At first, the bond condition influenced the rigidity of beam. The initial rigidity of
beam specimens was checked by load-deflection curves in Fig. 7. Until the flexural
cracks were generated, the entire cross section resisted bending, and the flexural
rigidity was decided by only the section of beam and Young’s modulus of mate-
rials. So, the bond performance did not affect the initial rigidity. As you can see in
Fig. 7, the initial rigidity (before generated flexural cracks at about 50 kN) of 100%
bond and 0% bond specimens were almost same; in addition, 50% bond specimen
The Influence of the Deterioration of Concrete-Rebar Bond ... 1765
200 200
150 150
Load (kN)
Load (kN)
100 100
50 50
0 0
0 1 2 0 1 2
Deflection (mm) Deflection (mm)
PL-0 PL-50 PL-100 ST-0 ST-50 ST-100
(a) PL series (b) ST series
was lower than other cases. The 50% bond specimen has no concrete under the
main rebar, so the cross section was smaller than the other cases. This is a reason of
small rigidity of the specimens with 50% bond.
On the other hand, the bond performance influenced the rigidity after generated
flexural cracks. When the concrete-rebar bond does not work, cracked concrete
does not resist tension completely. However, if the concrete and rebar are integrated
by bond, the concrete between the flexural cracks contributes to carry stress.
Therefore, it is thought that the rigidity dropped sharply and simultaneously with
generation of flexural cracks in the specimens with 0% bond. On the other hand, the
bond made the rigidity reduction due to the generation of flexural cracks be
moderate in the specimens with 50% bond and 100% bond.
Looking at Fig. 3, common to PL series and ST series, the curves of 50% bond
specimen and 100% bond specimen showed the similar behaviour. However, the
bond performance of PL-50 was degraded, and it was thought that different
load-bearing mechanisms worked in this case. Comparing the curves of PL-50 and
PL-100 in Fig. 3(a), the rigidity of PL-50 reduced from about 100 kN. This rigidity
reduction was due to bond deterioration. And, from about 170 kN, the rigidity of
PL-100 reduced, and the curves of PL-50 and PL-100 were overlapped. This
rigidity reduction of PL-100 was due to the generation of shear cracks. On the other
hand, in the case of PL-50, such rigidity reduction did not occur. The reason
seemed to be that tied arch mechanism was formed due to the bond deterioration,
and shear cracks formation was supressed. As a result, the curves of PL-50 and
PL-100 showed similar trend after 170 kN. However, it was thought that the
load-bearing mechanisms were different.
The slopes of the load-deflection curves of ST-50 and ST-100 were almost same
immediately after generated flexural cracks (Fig. 7), however, a slight difference
began to occur in the slopes of these two curves in the middle stage of loading
(Fig. 3). According to the discussion about strain of the main rebar, the bond
performance of ST-50 was slightly degraded. And it is thought that this slight bond
deterioration reduced the rigidity of beam.
The bond conditions influenced the load capacity and the failure mode. The
failure modes of PL-50, PL-0 and ST-0 were different from sound cases (PL-100
and ST-100). The load capacity of PL-50 was also a little higher than that of
1766 Y. Ito et al.
PL-100. It is thought that tied arch mechanism was formed in PL-50 due to bond
deterioration, and it contributed to high shear capacity. As a result, failure mode
shifted from shear failure to flexural failure.
In the case of specimens with 0% bond, tied arch mechanism were formed as
well as the case of PL-50. The bond deterioration of 0% bond specimens was more
severe than PL-50. It is thought that the tide arch effect was stronger, and these
beams exerted high shear capacity. Because those beams failed by anchorage
failure, it is thought that the shear capacity of PL-0 and ST-0 can be higher when
they have stronger anchorage zone.
On the other hand, the failure mode of ST-50 was same as the sound cases (PL-100
and ST-100). The bond performance of ST-50 did not degrade so much, and tide arch
mechanism seen in other cases was not formed. Therefore, improvement of shear
capacity due to bond deterioration was not found, and the shear capacity of ST-50
was smaller than that of ST-100. It is thought that the slight degradation of bond
performance reduced the load capacity. The bond deterioration changed the shear
cracks behaviour such as the degree of dispersion and the angle. The shear cracks of
50% bond specimen were more concentrated than 100% bond case. It is thought that
interlocking resistance due to aggregates at crack surface became weaker by con-
centration of shear cracks, and shear capacity reduced in ST-50.
5 Conclusion
The static loading behavior of the beam specimens with different bond conditions
were investigated. The specimen with 100% bond (sound beam), 50% bond (a half
of rebar were exposed) and 0% bond (round bar) were considered. From the results
of static loading tests, the following facts were revealed.
1. In the case of the specimens with 0% bond, the chemical adhesion was gradually
lost and the bond performance degraded significantly.
2. With regard to 50% bond specimens, the bond performance was degraded to
some extent; however, the shear reinforcement restrained the main rebar upward
and the bond performance did not degrade as significant as expected from
physical contact loss in the case of the 50% bond specimen with shear
reinforcement.
3. The bond enables concrete between cracks to resist tension, so the bond dete-
rioration leads to the rigidity reduction of RC beam.
4. The bond deterioration affects the degree of dispersion of shear cracks and it
leads to the reduction of shear capacity. However, when the bond deterioration
is severe, tied arch mechanism is formed and it contributes to high shear
capacity.
The Influence of the Deterioration of Concrete-Rebar Bond ... 1767
References
Keywords Concrete Cracking Thermal stress Temperature stress testing
machine Construction
G. F. Ou (&)
Department of Civil Engineering, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: gfeng-ou@iis.u-tokyo.ac.jp
T. Kishi Z. H. Lin T. Kamada
Institute of Industrial Science, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: kishi@iis.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Z. H. Lin
e-mail: 970202371@qq.com
T. Kamada
e-mail: tkamada@iis.u-tokyo.ac.jp
1 Introduction
2 Test Method
2.2 Experimental
The cement type used is ordinary Portland cement. The mix proportion discussed in
this study is listed in Table 1. The coarse and fine aggregate used was crushed
limestone and river sand respectively, with a lumped thermal expansion coefficient
around 8 le/ C.
The experimental condition consists of free deformation test and the full restraint
test. During the free deformation test, the deformation was measured by limiting the
axial stress within a negligible value ±0.01 MPa. While for the full restraint test,
the longitudinal deformation is controlled by two cross heads and the threshold
value for the specimen is within ±0.5 lm. When the deformation of the specimen
reached this threshold value, the step motor will apply a restraining force to drive it
Theoretical Modeling and Evaluation … 1773
back to the original position, as shown in Fig. 1(b). Noted that during free defor-
mation and full restraint tests, the temperature rise conditions should be kept
approximately identical, in order to compare and obtain the early-age effect. The
measurement will start automatically right after the casting of the concrete.
The low temperature rise condition signifies the heat generated by the specimen can
release normally, without applying any heat source or insulation. Whereas in the
high temperature rise conditions, the specimen was insulated by polystyrene with a
thickness of 30 mm, the air inside the temperature cabinet was heated and con-
trolled by the heater to achieve a semi-adiabatic condition. In this study, only the
sealed curing condition is discussed, in which the wet towels were wrapped around
the specimen and sealed by gum tape at about 2 h after casting. The drying effect
can be assumed to be excluded in this case.
DrðtÞ
E ðt Þ ¼ l ð1Þ
DDðtÞ
where, DrðtÞ denotes the stress variation, DDðtÞ the deformation variation and l the
specimen length, respectively.
Under the free deformation condition, the sample can deform freely without
restriction. The maximum expansion under the low and high temperature rise
conditions are around 100 and 250 le respectively. As the temperature starts to
1774 G. F. Ou et al.
decline, the specimen starts to shrink and it can be easily observed that under the
high temperature case, the deformation of concrete witnesses a sharper change, as
shown in Fig. 2.
When the deformation is fully confined, internal stress will be generated. The
restrained stress in the first few hours are negligibly small and only after the
solidification, it starts to grow, revealing a rise and drop pattern as temperature
changes. The evolution of restraint stress and elastic modulus as time elapses are
shown in Figs. 3 and 6, respectively. It can be found that during low temperature
rise condition, both the maximum compressive stress and tensile stress are lower
than that in the high temperature rise condition, demonstrating a higher cracking
risk under high temperature rise. The occurring time of zero stress in a high tem-
perature rise condition (i.e., around 40 h) is much later than in the low one (16 h),
due to the larger compressive stress built up during the period of temperature
increase. The sudden reduction of tensile stress can be observed in the circled
region Fig. 3, which is attributed to the generated micro-cracking invisible to the
naked eye. The reasons for the micro-cracking probably can be owing to the
existence of interfacial transition zone (ITZ) between the aggregate and cement
matrix, which is considered as the weakest link inside the concrete materials. The
calculation of theoretical elastic stress can be determined as Eq. (2).
Xt
re ðtÞ ¼ t¼0
efree ðt þ DtÞ efree ðtÞ E ðtÞ ð2Þ
where re ðtÞ, efree ðtÞ; EðtÞ are the theoretical elastic stress, free strain and elastic
modulus at time t, respectively. The relaxed stress could be given as Eq. (3).
Fig. 3 Restrained stress evolution under a low temperature rise condition; b high temperature
condition
The interactive behavior between aggregate and cement matrix has been modeled
by many researchers using FEM method [5, 7], in which the spring element with
varied rheological models are considered to simulate the early age solidification
process of concrete materials, as shown in Fig. 4(a). In this study, the interaction
will be analyzed and modeled as a one-dimensional case (which will not lose
justification since the slenderness ratio is large) and validated by experimental
results from TSTM.
The parallel or serial relation between aggregate and cement matrix has been
considered in many researches, also known as the Voigt and Reuss model.
However, all of these models are proposed for hardened concrete rather than
1776 G. F. Ou et al.
where Eag, Em,p, Egc denotes the elastic modulus of aggregate, parallel cement
matrix, and the composite matrix respectively. Cag and Cm,p represents proportions
of their volume ratio. The elastic modulus of the whole system can then be cal-
culated as the serial relation between the composite matrix and the serial matrix,
determined as Eq. (5):
where E, Em are elastic modulus of the composite matrix and cement matrix
respectively. Cm,s represents the proportion of the serial matrix, and it always yields
cm;p þ cm;s þ cag ¼ 1.
In this way, it could be considered as a time-dependent interaction between
cement matrix and the composite matrix, as shown in Fig. 4(b). Under certain
temperature rise condition, if the free deformation at each time interval of com-
posite matrix and serial cement matrix is denoted as dDgc and dDm respectively, and
the balanced deformation is dD, the constitutive law in the full restraint condition
can be given as Eq. (6):
where Sm ðtÞ ¼ Em ðtÞ A=lm , Sgc ðtÞ ¼ Egc ðtÞ A=lgc and A is the area of cross
section.
Theoretical Modeling and Evaluation … 1777
Substituting Eq. (7) into dr ¼ eðtÞ dDlmm dD Em ðtÞ, The stress increment at time
t yields,
The equations above are formulated by consideration of e(t), i.e., the elastic
proportion of the total free deformation, similar to the concept of creep coefficient.
If formulated in the manner of stress relaxation, the theoretical elastic stress can be
given as:
Z th i 1
re ðtÞ ¼ D0m ðtÞ þ D0gc ðtÞ dt ð10Þ
0 A Sm ðtÞ þ
1 1
Sgc ðtÞ
where dDgc ¼ f dDg ; dDm;p . The restrained stress can be computed by subtracting
the relaxed stress rr ðtÞ from theoretical elastic stress, as determined in Eq. (11):
In this study, the feasibility of the proposed analytical method is verified by the
latter method. The time-dependent function including free deformation, relaxed
stress and elastic modulus from TSTM tests are used as known input. In the future,
the free deformation of cement matrix could be computed by a summation of the
autogenous shrinkage, thermal deformation and artificial expansion, and the creep
effect can also be modeled. Following the computation flow shown in Fig. 4(c), the
stiffness and deformation-related properties and eventually the restrained stress
could be obtained step-by-step. Within this scope, since the exact mathematical
expression of those time-dependent functions are hard to be acquired, the stress
evolution could be approximated by the method of discrete integral with acceptable
accuracy.
As shown in Fig. 5, the modeled stress evolution can agree well with the
experimental results from TSTM, tracing the increasing and decreasing patterns and
branching from low to high temperature case.
1778 G. F. Ou et al.
Fig. 5 Modeled stress evolution of C45 under a Low temperature rise b high temperature rise
As shown in Fig. 6(a), experimental results reveal that elastic modulus under high
temperature rise is lower than that under low temperature, which can probably be
attributed to the greater tension during sharper decline of temperature. Actually,
though the final values are lower, the elastic modulus in high temperature case
evolves 1–2 h earlier, as shown in Fig. 6(b). It is also found that after reaching the
maximum values, the elastic modulus will be reduced to some extent for both low
and high temperature cases. This analytical model attempts to consider the effect of
ITZ by considering this lower tensile modulus, different from three-phase (cement
matrix, aggregate and ITZ) FEM model. As shown in Fig. 6(c), if the elastic
modulus is assumed to grow continually or at least keep stable as age increases
(which holds true for compressive modulus), the final restrained stress will be
higher than that using reduced tensile modulus. Therefore, it is necessary to con-
sider the effect of tensile modulus, since the stiffness of concrete materials under
tension will always be weaker than compression.
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The first author would like to express gratitude to Sho-bond scholarship.
References
1. Dao VTN, Nguyen D, Lura P (2016) Early-age thermal cracking in concrete structures-the role
of zero-stress temperature? In: EASEC-14. Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
2. Lim S, Lin ZH, Kishi T (2008) Thermal cracking sensitivity of slag and fly ash concretes by the
uniaxial restraint test. Proc Jpn Concr Inst 30:175–180
3. Lin ZH (2006) Quantitative evaluation of the effectiveness of expansive concrete as a
countermeasure for thermal cracking and the development of its practical application. PhD
Thesis, The University of Tokyo
4. Lin ZH, Kishi T (2006) Cracking resistance of expansive concrete mixed with lightweight
aggregate. Proc Jpn Concr Inst 28:647–652
5. Maekawa K, Ishida T, Kishi T (2009) Multi-scale Modeling of Structural Concrete. Taylor &
Francis
6. Springenschmid R (1994) Development of the cracking frame and the temperature-stress
testing machine. In: RILEM Proceedings, Munich, Germany
7. Springenschmid R (1995) Thermal Cracking in Concrete at Early Ages. Technical University
of Munich, Germany, E & FN SPON
Effect of Confining Pressure
on Compressive Strength and Ductility
of Square Section Concrete Filled
Tube Column
1 Introduction
Concrete-filled steel tubes (CFT) are a type of structural element where structural
concrete is placed inside a structural steel shell, which have been widely used in tall
buildings, arch bridges and structural rehabilitation [5, 22]. The steel tube and
concrete work together, to resist applied loads. The external steel tube provides
confinement for the inner concrete which in turn delays local buckling of the tube
and so increases the stability and strength of the column as a system. Previous
studies have shown that CFT structural members have several distinct advantages
over equivalent steel, reinforced concrete, or steel-reinforced concrete members.
These advantages include high stiffness and strength, large energy absorption and
enhanced ductility and stability [22]. However, it was found that the square or
rectangular CFT columns present less gain of the advantages than the circular CFT
due to some loss of the confinement effect, as shown in Fig. 1, but they are still
better than concrete columns [1, 7, 10, 13, 15, 17, 18].
The development of the CFT column needs a full understanding of the con-
finement effect. However, most previous research has focused on the passive
confinement of CFT columns [4, 8, 9, 12, 14, 16]. Several studies have been
conducted on the effect of active confinement of the circular CFT columns on its
mechanical behavior [1, 5¸10, 21]. Nevertheless, there is still a lack of knowledge
and experimental data on the behavior of the square or rectangular CFT columns
under active confinement pressure.
The purpose of this study is to investigate the influence of preconfining pressure
(flp ) on the strength and ductility performance of the square sections of CFT columns.
The steel jacket was used to confine pressure to the CFT column. The steel tubes with
external dimensions of 98 98 2.3 mm (width depth thickness) were used
0
to confine the infill concrete with compressive strength (fco ) of 20.98 MPa [2].
The CFT columns were experimentally investigated for its strength and ductility
Effect of Confining Pressure on Compressive Strength … 1783
2 Experimental Investigation
In this study, the effect of confining pressure on compressive strength and ductility
of the CFT column was investigated. The experimental study was carried out in
four steps: specimen preparation, testing of compressive strength, determination of
the mechanical properties and conclusion as shown in Fig. 2. Altogether four series
of CFT column specimen were produced and conducted to investigate the influence
of preconfining pressure by varying the preconfining pressure from 0.0, 2.4, 4.8,
and 7.2 MPa which were equivalent to 0.0, 11.4, 22.9 and 34.3% of the infill
concrete strength, respectively.
The details of the specimen series are summarized and shown in Table 1. For
each series, two identical CFT specimens were cast and experimentally investigated
for its strength and ductility performance based on its compressive strength and
axial stress-strain relation characteristics under uni-axial load test. The compressive
strength, ductility factor (lcu ) and the energy absorption capacity were obtained by
taking the average of these specimens.
In this study, a concrete compressive strength of 20.98 MPa [2] was used filled
materials place inside steel tubes. The steel tube grade TIS SM490 with a dimension
of 98 98 2.3 mm was used as CFT shell. The yield stress and tensile strength
of the steel tube were 324 MPa and 490 MPa, respectively.
The steel tube having the dimension of 98 98 350 and 2.3 mm in thickness
was used to make steel mold. In order to make the CFT specimen, the core concrete
was mixed and cast in the steel mold having a longitudinal gap of 1 mm as shown
in Fig. 3a. After casting, all CFT specimen were cured for a period of 28 days and
allowed to air-dry under laboratory environment until the time of jacketing and
preconfining. After curing, the CFT specimen was assembled into the steel jacket as
shown in Fig. 3b. The hydraulic ramp was used to apply to confine the sample over
the steel jacket, as shown in Fig. 3c, until the confining pressure was reached the
aimed level. After that, the longitudinal gabs of steel shell were welded and the steel
jacket was removed. The CFT specimen after preconfining, as shown in Fig. 3d,
were conducted to install strain gauges and allowed in laboratory environment until
the time of the compressive strength testing.
In this experiment, the universal testing machine with a maximum load of 2,000 kN
was adopted for the uniaxial compression test. The details of the test set-up and
instrumentation are shown in Fig. 4. Two linear variable differential transducers
(LVDTs) with 50 mm stroke were installed to record the full-length axial dis-
placement of the CFT columns by measuring the relative displacement between the
top and bottom loading platens. Four numbers of one-directional strain gauges were
installed at the two un-welding external faces of the tested specimens. At each face,
two of one-directional strain gauges were installed at around the midheight of the
tested specimens in order to measure the longitudinal and transverse strains of the
CFT column.
All the CFT columns were tested under displacement control. The initial loading
rate was 0.5 mm/min. The loading rate would then increase at a rate of 0.05 mm/
min for every 2 mm increase in the axial displacement after the specimens had
yielded. The loading application would stop when the axial deformation was larger
than 10 mm, or when the applied load dropped to less than 80% of the measured
maximum load, or when the applied load reached 90% of the machine capacity,
whichever was the earliest. During the compressive strength test, the axial load and
the corresponding axial deformation, the longitudinal and lateral strain were
recorded every 1 s until the loading application was stopped.
1786 V. Greepala et al.
0 Pmax
fcmax ¼ ð1Þ
Agross
Ductility factor (lcu ) of the specimens is determined using the following Eq. (2):
ecu
lcu ¼ ð2Þ
e1
Energy absorption capacity factor (ecu ) is defined as the area under the
stress-strain curve up to the rupture of the CFT jacket (Fig. 5).
Work index (Wcu ) is a dimensionless parameter calculated by normalizing the
energy absorption capacity (Eq. (3)) which is considered to be a reasonable
parameter in evaluating the ductility of confined concrete.
ecu
Wcu ¼ 0
ð3Þ
fcmax e1
Effect of Confining Pressure on Compressive Strength … 1787
In the conclusion step, the compressive strength, ductility factor (lcu ) and the
energy absorption capacity of each series were obtained by taking the average of
two specimens. The effects of preconfining on these parameters were compared and
discussed.
3 Results
The experimental stress-strain relations of the four series of CFT specimens are
0
shown in Fig. 6. The compressive strength (fcmax ), ductility factor (lcu ) and the
energy absorption capacity of the squared CFT columns which were determined in
accordance with the stress-strain respond suggested by Sheikh et al. [19] are
summarized and shown in Table 2.
It is of interest to note that the ultimate strain of CFT column (ecu ) for samples
are about 0.0048–0.0105 which is higher than the ultimate strain of unconfined
concrete (0.003) about 1.6–3.5 times. The improvement of the ultimate strain shows
1788 V. Greepala et al.
that the confining of squared steel tube improves the ductility of the core concrete in
CFT column, although the confinement in the squared section was found to be less
effective than the circular section [6, 11].
The CFT specimen having a steel shell of 2.3 mm were tested to ascertain the
influence of the preconfining pressure (flp ) from 0, 2.4, 4.8 and 7.2 MPa which were
equivalent to 0, 11.4, 22.9, and 34.3% of the compressive strength of core concrete,
0
respectively. The test results of the compressive strength (fcmax ) for each series of
CFT specimens which were determined from the average of 2 samples are sum-
marized and shown in Table 2. The influence of the confining pressure on the
compressive strength of CFT specimen is shown in Fig. 7; test results reveal that
increasing of confining pressure of 2.4–7.2 MPa significantly improved the com-
pressive strength of the square section of CFT column by 1.5–9.5 MPa which are
equivalent to 3.0–19.2% of the control specimen. It is of interest to note that the
increase in preconfining pressure beyond 22.9% (4.8 MPa) of concrete strength
resulted in a gradual increase of the compressive strength of CFT specimen, even
though in the low confining pressure the compressive strength of CFT specimen
slightly increase as the preconfining pressure increase. The slight improvement in
compressive strength presents that the squared CFT section has inefficiency for
preconfining. This result due to uninformed lateral pressure which is higher
occurred only at the center and corner of the section [11]. Moreover, the squared
section did not provide a large confining effect especially when the
width-to-thickness ratio was large (B/t > 30); in this study B/t is 42.6. The effects of
concrete confinement for columns with large plate slenderness ratios were also
found to be less pronounced, as local buckling may occur [6, 20].
3.2 Ductility
The CFT specimen was tested and the ductility factor (lcu ) was determined to
ascertain the influence of the preconfining pressure (flp ) from 0, 2.4, 4.8 and
7.2 MPa which were equivalent to 0, 11.4, 22.9, and 34.3% of the compressive
0
strength of core concrete (fco ), respectively. The test results of the ductility factor
(lcu ) and work index (Wcu ) which were determined from the average of two
samples are summarized and shown in Table 2. The influence of the confining
pressure on the ductility parameter is shown in Fig. 8. When compared with the
control samples, it was found that the incorporation of confining pressure induced a
reduction of both ductility factor (lcu ) and work index (Wcu ). However, in pre-
confining pressure beyond 2.4 MPa (11.4%), both parameters slightly increase as
the preconfining pressure increase as shown in Fig. 8a and b. It can be concluded
that the use of preconfining steel jacket is not effective in improving the ductility
and energy absorption of CFT column. This results may due to the tension hoop
developed along the side of the tube was not constant [18]. In preconfining process
of most of the hoop stress and hoop strain of the square section occurred at the
pre-stressing side unlike the hoop stress and hoop strain in a circular which are
constantly distributed along the hoop ring as shown in Fig. 9. At the loading state,
the ultimate hoop stress and hoop strain at the pre-stressing side may reach the yield
limit early results in poor improvement of compressive strength and ductility of the
square section.
Fig. 8 Effect of preconfining pressure on ductility parameters of the squared CFT column
1790 V. Greepala et al.
4 Conclusions
References
6. Jamaluddin N (2011) Behaviour of elliptical concrete-filled steel tube (CFT) columns under
axial compression load. School of Civil Engineering, The University of Leeds. Doctor of
Philosophy, p 44
7. Johansson M, Gylltoft K (2001) Structural behavior of slender circular steel-concrete
composite columns under various means of load application. Steel Compos Struct 1(4):393–
410
8. Kuranovas A, et al (2009) Load-bearing capacity of concrete-filled steel columns. J Civ Eng
Manag 15(1):21–33
9. Morino S, Tsuda K (2005) Design and construction of concrete-filled steel tube column
system in japan. Earthq Eng Eng Seismol 4(1):51–74
10. Namvijitr N (2011) Strengthening of axial compressive circular reinforced concrete columns
by preconfining with steel jackets. Civil Engineering, Suranaree University of Technology.
Master of Engineering, p 178
11. Nardin SD, EL Debs ALHC (2007) Axial load behaviour of concrete-filled steel tubular
columns. Proc Inst Civ Eng Struct Build 160:13–22
12. Nishiyama I, et al (2002) Summary of research on concrete-filled structural tube column
system carried out under the USJapan cooperative research program on composite and hybrid
structures, Building Research Institute (BRI)
13. Oliveira WLA et al (2010) Evaluation of passive confinement in CFT columns. J Constr Steel
Res 66:487–495
14. Sakino K et al (2004) Behavior of centrally loaded concrete-filled steel-tube short columns.
ASCE J Struct Eng 130:180–188
15. Schneider S (1998) Axially loaded concrete-filled steel tubes. ASCE J Struct Eng 124
(10):1125–1138
16. Seangatith S, Thumrongvut J (2009) Experimental investigation on square steel tubed rc
columns under axial compression. Suranaree J Sci Technol 16(3):205–220
17. Shams M, Saadeghvaziri M (1997) State of the art of concrete-filled steel tubular columns.
ACI Struct. J 94(5):558–571
18. Shanmugam N, Lakshmi B (2001) State of the art report on steel-concrete composite
columns. J Constr Steel Res 57(10):1041–1080
19. Sheikh SA et al (1994) Confinement of high strength concrete columns. ACI Struct J 91
(1):100–111
20. Uy B (1998) Concrete-filled fabricated steel box columns for multi-storey buildings:
behaviour and design. Progress Struct Eng Mater 1(12):150–158
21. Xiao Y et al (2005) Confined concrete filled tubular columns. J Struct Eng ASCE 131(3):488–
497
22. Zhu C et al (2013) Mechanical behavior of concrete filled glass fiber reinforced polymer-steel
tube under cyclic loading. J Zhejiang Univ Sci A (Appl Phys Eng) 14(11):778–788
A Proposal of Data Driven Maintenance
of RC Decks Focusing on Deterioration
Mechanism
1 Introduction
During the period of high economic growth, massive bridge structures were con-
structed. After almost 40 year pasted, the safety of this aged structures become a
non-negligible issue. In urban area of Japan, the fatigue damage of reinforced
concrete (RC) bridge decks from accumulated traffic load is one of the most serious
problem in highway structures. Therefore, a more effective inspection system which
can prolong the life of RC decks is becoming highly demanded.
In this paper, we focus on the fatigue damage of RC decks in Tokyo region. By
integrating existing technologies, a new inspection system is proposed referring to
the concept of “Society5.0”. Firstly, inspection data of decks regarding structural
and traffic information together with the crack information are analyzed by using
two different methods, which are survival analysis and fatigue life analysis. Then,
the two methods are compared by analyzing real RC decks from site in dry and
water submerged states. Finally, a comprehensive maintenance plan is introduced in
terms of inspection system and countermeasures.
In this chapter, the two technologies, ‘survival analysis’ and ‘fatigue life analysis’
are discussed and a part of previous results are shown.
Survival analysis is a statistical method that can be used to quantify risk factors
for large amounts of data. On the other hand, fatigue life analysis is used for life
prediction of RC deck based on site-inspected crack.
Survival analysis is based on the relationship between a time period start from the
observation time until an event occurs. It does not only quantity the risk factors, but
also has the advantage of considering censoring comparing with linear model. Cox
regression model is one of the most frequently used survival analysis method.
Moreover, there is no assumption about distribution of the hazard, which makes it
more practical.
research [2]. The event is defined as the appearance of two-dimensional cracks and
the appearance of efflorescence at the bottom of an RC deck slab. Additionally, the
deterioration rate will be changed since the repairing work is conducted before
inspection. Therefore, the repairing should also be considered. If steel plate
bonding, replacing, carbon fiber reinforcement and crack injection were conducted,
an extra event will be assumed. The cox regression model is defined as Eq. (1).
h0 ðtÞexpðx1 ; bÞ
HR ¼ ¼ exp½bðx1 x0 Þ ð2Þ
h0 ðtÞexpðx0 ; bÞ
The hazard ratio can be interpreted as the ratio of mortality for two samples with
covariate x0 and x1 for any time duration. Risk increases as variate increases when
hazard ratio is higher than one, and vice versa. Efron method is used to estimate b.
The partial likelihood function is shown in Eq. (3).
Y
m
exi þ b
lðbÞ ¼ Qdi P xj b k1
P xj b
ð3Þ
i¼1 k¼1 j2Rðti Þ e di j2Rðti Þ e
Fatigue life analysis is conducted with the data assimilation technology of the
integrated system of the multi-scale simulation program (DuCOM-COM3) together
with the pseudo cracking method (PCM) [4–7]. In the multi-scale simulation, the
constitutive laws for high cycle fatigue loading were already integrated in order to
consider the concrete’s damage of high cycle fatigue loading in terms of reduction
in both stiffness and strength and increase in time dependent deformation.
On the other hand, PCM is a numerical technique to estimate fatigue life of RC
decks based upon site-inspected cracks. The visual cracks at the bottom surfaces are
assumed to be flexure ones up to the neural axis of the RC decks and they are
considered as the first candidates for fatigue lifetime simulation. Then, inner
unknown cracks are numerically produced during the early age of fatigue cycles by
the means of corrector-predictor approach based on energy principles. Finally,
remaining fatigue life can be successfully achieved.
Moreover, multi-scale simulation was upgraded to consider concrete-water
interaction based on Biot’s theory, where the impact of stagnant water on RC decks
can be simulated. It should be noted that multi-scale simulation program can deal
with any crack patterns for fatigue life prediction of RC decks in dry or
water-submerged states, but it takes huge computation cost. Thus, ANN models has
been developed to achieve high-speed quantitative assessment [5, 6].
dL;N
3:0 ð6Þ
dL;0
where dL,N is central live load deflection at Nth number of cycles, d1,N is central total
deflection at Nth number of cycles during loading time, d2,N is central total
deflection at Nth number of cycles during unloading time, dL,0 is the initial live load
deflection, Nf is the number of cycles at failure corresponding to (dL,N calculated
from Eq. 6).
Figure 1 shows the methodology for building up the developed ANN models for
dry and water-submerged states (Fathalla et al. [5, 6]).
A Proposal of Data Driven Maintenance of RC Decks ... 1797
Fatigue failure is the main reason to cause the deterioration of RC bridge in Tokyo
region [2] and up to now our ANN model can only deal with specific environmental
condition. Therefore, in this research, data of RC slab from Metropolitan
Expressway is randomly selected. The analysis object is a panel, which is defined as
an area surrounded by longitudinal-main girders and transverse-cross girders. For
survival analysis, all data are simulated in the same process which have been done
before to calculate the risk score [2]. Then, 55 panels from Line 5 under different
situations are selected. On the other hand, for ANN model, not only structural
information but also the crack information, which are extracted from slab
bottom-side photos of the slab are used to conduct ANN models. However, since
the crack width cannot be determined from the photo, all crack width is assumed as
0.1 mm for simplification based on previous site investigations.
The relation of ANN model and risk score from the target RC slab are shown in
Fig. 2. The vertical axis expresses the remaining fatigue life estimated by ANN
model in dry case in logarithmic scale and the horizontal axis expresses the risk
score calculated by survival analysis. High-risk score means serious deterioration
possibility with low remaining life. Although the two methods are completely
different, it can be seen that as the risk score increases, the remaining fatigue life
reduces with a high correlation coefficient of R = 0.83. Thus, the reliability of both
terminologies to be integrated together is demonstrated.
Now, in Japan, all bridges are under a 5-years periodic inspection, which was
launched by government. However, it has been pointed out that the current
inspection strategy is not smart enough to handle different deterioration stages.
Therefore, depending on these results, inspection interval can be updated based on
Fig. 5 Comparison of
increasing deck’s thickness
and waterproof installation for
extending life of RC decks
the real performances of RC decks in order to save unnecessary and excessive costs.
As shown in Fig. 3, for high-risk zone, the inspection can be set as 5-years, and for
the low-risk zone, the inspection can be set as 15-years. In this graph, the threshold
is based on 95% confidence interval. Considering the actual application of deciding
the inspection-span by using these results, the threshold can be set depending on
company’s circumstance and budget.
1800 T. Furukawa et al.
In reality, RC decks under water-submerge state are very rare, in most of the cases,
where this assumption is overestimating their deterioration risk. In the past few
decades, there was no feasible technique to detect the location of the stagnant water
on RC decks below the pavement layers. Recently, a non-destructive testing
(NDT) has been developed to detect stagnant water locations by signal processing
of data collected from site by utilizing ground penetration radar (GPR) installed on
vehicle that can travel up to 80 km/h [9].
Fig. 6 Proposed model for life prediction based on site-inspected wetting locations
A Proposal of Data Driven Maintenance of RC Decks ... 1801
Moreover, a predictive model was proposed for the fatigue life prediction of RC
decks based on site-inspected wetting locations [10], as shown in Fig. 6 and Eqs. 7
and 8.
where D.I. is the damage index of water impact, (WR1, WR2, WR3, WR4) are wetting
rates for each of the zones shown in Fig. 6, k is the kth ponding region at the top
surface, Ak is the wetting-area of the kth ponding region, and A is the total area of
top surface of RC deck. This D.I. can be used as a threshold for checking the
significance of water impact.
Based on the previous result, it is found that inspection interval can be changed
according to the level of risk. In addition, it is important to install waterproof in
order to prevent further deterioration of RC decks. Finally, a new inspection system
is introduced by combining the current developed technologies, as shown in Fig. 7.
At first, GPR is used to check the stagnant water at the top layer of RC slab.
Then, D.I. can be calculated based detected wetting locations. If D.I. is higher than
the threshold, the panel is needed to be waterproofed quickly or replaced. If D.I. is
lower than the threshold, monitoring the progress and dispersion of ponding by
GPR system is needed in order to check whether D.I. exceeds the threshold value or
not. Then, for close inspection, crack and peeling information need to be collected.
Any missing information (compressive strength, reinforcement details, etc.) can be
obtained by NDTs. Moreover, by using the information of cracks, remaining fatigue
life can be estimated and updated. In dry case, inspection interval of crack can be
changed regrading to risk score as discussed in Sect. 3. For the RC decks with
higher risk of fatigue failure, more investigations should be conducted by using
high definition cameras, UAV, etc., in order to obtain reliable estimation. Finally,
this information is accumulated in database and combined with environmental
information in order to provide rational counter measure plans.
6 Conclusion
In this paper, survival analysis and ANN models for fatigue life are discussed.
Then, these two methods are compared by using real decks from site. Finally, new
inspection system is proposed. The conclusions can be summarized as follows.
(1) Although the terminologies and methodologies of two model are different, they
are integrated together for decision making of deterioration risk of RC decks
since their results show high correlation. Here, inspection interval can be
extended for RC decks with lower risk to reduce costs.
(2) Stagnant water has been proven to be the main factor to cause the reduction of
lifetime of RC decks. Thus, applying waterproof works with regular mainte-
nance is an indispensable way to effectively slow down the degradation rate of
RC decks.
(3) A comprehensive inspection system of RC decks is proposed in detail. Thus,
feasible maintenance plans can be successfully implemented.
References
3. Ishak KJ, Kreif N, Benedict A, Muszbek N (2013) Overview of parametric survival analysis
for health-economic applications. Pharmacoeconomics 31(8):663–675
4. Fathalla E, Tanaka Y, Maekawa K (2018) Remaining fatigue life assessment of in-service
road bridge decks based upon artificial neural networks. Eng Struct 171:602–616
5. Fathalla E, Tanaka Y, Maekawa K (2018) Quantitative deterioration assessment of road
bridge decks based on site inspected cracks. Appl Sci 8:1197
6. Fathalla E, Tanaka Y, Maekawa K, Sakurai A (2019) Quantitative deterioration assessment of
road bridge decks based on site inspected cracks under stagnant water. J Adv Concr Technol
17(1):16–33
7. Fathalla E, Tanaka Y, Maekawa K (2019) Effect of crack orientation on fatigue life of
reinforced concrete bridge decks. Appl Sci 9(8):1644
8. Japan Road Association (2012) Specification for Highway Bridges-Part III Concrete Bridges.
Tokyo, Japan
9. Mizutani T, Nakamura N, Yamaguchi T, Tarumi M, Hara I (2017) Bridge slab damage
detection by signal processing of uhf-band ground penetrating radar data. J Disast Res 12
(3):415–421
10. Fathalla E, Tanaka Y, Maekawa K (2019) Fatigue life of RC bridge decks affected by
non-uniformly dispersed stagnant water. Appl Sci 9(3):607
11. Tanaka Y, Maekawa K, Maeshima T, Iwaki I, Nishida T, Shiotani T (2017) Data assimilation
for fatigue life assessment of RC bridge decks coupled with hygro-mechanistic model and
nondestructive inspection. J Disaster Res 12:422–431
Effects of Slab Thickness on the Fatigue
Performance of RC Slabs: An Analytical
Investigation
Keywords RC slab Punching shear failure Fatigue Slab thickness Crack
bridging degradation
1 Introduction
reproduced. In addition, it is observed that the RC slab was gradually divided into a
series of RC beams perpendicular to the slab axis, which is known as a
slab-to-beam phenomenon. Finally, the punching shear failure of a critical RC beam
at the mid-span leads to the failure. According to experimental observations, a
group of empirical life prediction equations were formulated with the static
punching shear capacity of this critical RC beam through fitting different sets of
experiment data [1, 5, 6]. Moreover, it is concluded that the punching shear failure
of RC bridge deck slabs stems from the insufficient slab thickness due to the
overvalue of economy in past design codes. The effect of slab thickness has been
experimentally investigated in lab tests and implicitly accounted for in the empirical
life prediction equations as an essential factor. However, to uncover the effect of
slab thickness mechanically, a mechanism-based analytical study on this effect is
necessary and meaningful, which is the purpose of this study. The analytically
obtained effects can provide a solid theory foundation and reference for the
improvement of related design codes.
In this study, the fatigue behaviors of RC slabs with different thicknesses are
studied employing a fracture mechanics based analytical method, where two gen-
erally accepted dominant degradation mechanisms, i.e. rebar/concrete bond slip
degradation and concrete bridging degradation, are considered as the source of the
propagation of the critical punching shear cracks [3, 4]. From this method, one can
not only predict the fatigue life but also obtain the cracking states after every
loading cycle. Obviously, the different fatigue life of the slabs clearly manifests the
effect of slab thickness. In addition, the effect is investigated in detail through
analyzing the evolutions of the critical punching shear cracks, i.e. crack depth,
tensile depth and crack mouth opening displacement (CMOD), in the slabs.
2 Method
For an RC slab under cyclic moving loads, the RC slab is gradually divided into a
series of RC beams perpendicular to the slab axis and the punching shear failure of
a critical beam located in the mid-span leads to the failure of the RC slab.
According to the cracking process and failure mode, Matsui proposed a method of
determining the dimensions and static punching shear capacity of the critical RC
beam. Moreover, empirical life prediction S-N relations were formulated using this
capacity through fitting different sets of experimental data. Therefore, the fatigue
analysis of an RC slab under a moving wheel load can be simplified into the life
prediction of a critical RC beam focusing on the propagation of punching shear
cracks which are assumed to propagate along 45º lines symmetrical with respect to
the moving load.
Effects of Slab Thickness on the Fatigue Performance … 1807
For the critical RC beam subjected to general loads, the sectional stresses and
forces acting along the punching shear cracks are shown in Fig. 1. To determine all
the sectional forces and stresses, three widely accepted assumptions are employed
as follows: (1) plane cross-section assumption; (2) the cracked cross-section is
assumed to rotate around the neutral axis; (3) the crack has a linear crack opening
profile. From these three assumptions, the strain distributions of all materials and
the crack opening displacement (COD) profile can be expressed three cracking
parameters, i.e. a, b, and d (CMOD). And then, substituting the strains and COD
profile into material models, one can express all the stresses and forces with a, b,
and d. To get a, b, and d after every loading cycle, at least three independent
equations with unknown of a, b, and d should be established.
Referencing to the Fig. 1, there are one force equilibrium equation along x di-
rection and one moment equilibrium equation can be easily established. In order to
obtain the three unknown a, b, and d, another relationship is necessary. According
to the cracking analysis of RC structures in [2], a CMOD decomposition equation
can be established, where the total CMOD is assumed to consist of crack openings
due to applied loads and rebar/concrete bond slip and crack closings due to rebar
and concrete bridging stresses.
Therefore, if all stresses and forces can be expressed with a, b, and d, one can
obtain them after every loading cycle through solving these three governing
equations.
along the punching shear crack line in the absence of the crack can be easily
expressed with a, b, and d from sectional analysis. Secondly, stresses from
uncracked concrete can be expressed with a, b, and d through multiplying the
concrete strain and elastic modulus of concrete. Thirdly, in terms of the stresses
from cracked concrete, in the 1st cycle, it can be expressed with a, b, and d
following an empirical concrete bridging model and using the COD profile. From
2nd loading cycle to the final failure, a concrete bridging degradation is accounted
for by introducing a concrete bridging degradation model. Finally, the rebar stresses
are determined by substituting the rebar strains from the plane cross-section and
cross-section rotation assumptions into a modified stress-strain relation of rebars
embedded in concrete. After this modification, the rebar/concrete interface bond
slip known as the tension stiffening effect as well as the bond slip degradation can
be included in this method.
As is generally accepted, the total shear capacity resistance for a traditional RC slab
is from the vertical component of the shear strength of concrete and dowel action of
flexural reinforcement. Under cyclic moving loads, the formed cracks experience
repeated opening and closing process, which keeps polishing the interface of
aggregates and mortar. As a result, only the concrete in the compression region can
provide shear resistance. Therefore, in this study, the total shear capacity is obtained
by integrating the vertical components of the tensile stresses in compressed concrete
following the AASHTO and ACI equations for punching shear.
In terms of the ultimate dowel forces of both tensile and compressive rebar are
calculated following an equation in [5]. However, post-mortem inspections of tested
specimens showed that a delamination at the upper rebars level occurs in the
mid-span cross-section of specimens subjected to cyclic moving loads. This is
probably a result of high-fatigue shear stresses at that depth due to the existence of
upper rebars and a short distance from the neutral axis. Therefore, the dowel effect
of upper rebars should not be included in determining the punching shear capacity
after the crack tip reaches upper rebars.
Using the obtained cracking state parameters after every loading cycle, the final
failure moment is determined following the mentioned shear capacity-based failure
criterion and considerations.
3 Numerical Results
In this study, RC slabs with three normally used thicknesses are employed. Detail
information of dimensions, boundary conditions, load conditions and reinforcement
arrangements of the RC slabs are shown in Fig. 2. The highlighted thickness of the
Effects of Slab Thickness on the Fatigue Performance … 1809
slabs, h, varies from 140 to 180 mm with a step of 20 mm. The material properties
of concrete and steel rebars are assumed as the same for these three slabs and listed
in Table 1. Applying the introduced method, one can obtain the evolutions of the
cracking state parameters and the predict the fatigue life.
The cracked depth/beam depth ratios under different loading levels for the three
thicknesses of RC slabs are plotted with the number of loading cycles on the
semi-logarithmic scale as shown in Fig. 3. If the relations for each thickness of RC
slabs are investigated, it is found that the generally initiate two stages of fatigue
growth of a bridged crack in concrete structures, i.e. initial decelerated growth stage
and the second steady growth stage, can be captured by the analysis. However, the
relative relations between these two stages varies from loading levels and slab
thickness. More specifically, the number of cycles occupied by the initial stage
decreases with the increasing loading level and slab thickness. These phenomena
can be explained by the dominant degradation mechanisms for these two stages.
According to the analysis, the concrete bridging degradation is dominant the initial
stage, nevertheless as the degradation of cracked concrete is fast and accelerates
with the enlarging crack width, the bridging effect from concrete reduces rapidly to
almost negligible. And the force which was carried by the concrete is transferred to
rebars. Due to the increasing rebar stresses, the rebar/concrete interface bond slip
degradation becomes more significant. As a result, the dominant degradation
mechanism transforms into the rebar/concrete bond slip degradation in the second
stage. Compared with the concrete bridging degradation, the rebar/concrete bond
slip degradation tends to the more stable and less apparent. Thus, it is demonstrated
that the length of the initial stage depends on the extend of the initial crack opening
10
Matsui equation
PWRI equation
Abe equation
JSCE equation
1
0.1
Table 2 Fatigue life of RC slab with different thickness under different loading levels
Thickness (mm) Predicted fatigue life (cycles)
100 125 150 175 200 225
180 – – – 3,626,813 305,632 8,922
160 – – 501,087 9,859 644 –
140 3,682,651 96,123 1,429 – – –
With the obtained cracking state parameters, the fatigue life of the three RC slabs
under the employed loading levels can be predicted and listed in Table 2. Under a
same absolute value of moving wheel load, it can be found that the fatigue life is
extended to about 400 times if the thickness of the RC slab increases for only
20 mm. In addition, the S-N diagrams of the three RC slabs are shown in Fig. 6
together with four empirical life prediction equations and experimental fatigue life
of three RC slabs from [7, 8]. These three tested RC slabs are with three different
thickness, i.e. 140, 160, 180 mm, but with the same other dimensions. Since the
three thickness are identical with the analyzed ones, they are suitable for this
Effects of Slab Thickness on the Fatigue Performance … 1813
comparison. From this figure, it is found that the analytical S-N relation agrees well
with the experimental fatigue life and the four reported life prediction equations.
These good agreements further verify the reliability of the proposed method and
confirmed the significant fatigue life extension effect of a slight increase of slab
thickness.
4 Conclusions
A fatigue analysis method which was developed specific for studying the RC slab
subjected to moving loads was employed to analyze RC slabs with three normally
used thicknesses. The crack propagation was assumed to be induced by the concrete
bridging and rebar/concrete bond slip degradations.
From analyses, the evolutions of the critical punching shear cracks are obtained,
where the initial two stages of crack propagation were captured. In particular, the
cracks in thicker slabs tend to enter the steady growth stage faster than in thinner
slabs under a similar level of load to static punching shear capacity ratio.
Furthermore, the fatigue life was predicted analytically and presented to provide a
straight forward image about the effect of slab thickness. An about 400 times of life
extension was achieved by a 20 mm increment of slab thickness, which clearly
demonstrated the primary role played by the thickness in the punching shear failure
of RC bridge slabs and also provided theoretical references for design code
improvement.
References
1. Abe T (2005) Study on punching shear load-carrying capacity of RC slab. J Coll Ind Tech
Nihon Univ 38(2):11–21 (in Japanese)
2. Deng P, Matsumoto T (2017) Estimation of the rebar force in RC members from the analysis of
the crack mouth opening displacement based on fracture mechanics. J Adv Concr Technol 15
(2):81–93
3. Deng P, Matsumoto T (2018) Determination of dominant degradation mechanisms of RC
bridge deck slabs under cyclic moving loads. Int J Fatigue 112:328–340
4. Deng P, Matsumoto T (2019) Fracture mechanics based fatigue life prediction method for RC
slabs in a punching shear failure mode. J Struct Eng (Accepted)
5. Matsui S (1987) Fatigue strength and water effect on the RC slab of highway bridge under the
running load. Proc JCI 9(2):627–632 (in Japanese)
6. Matsui S (2007) Road bridge deck: design, construction, and maintenance. Morikita Publishing
(in Japanese)
7. Mitamura H, Syakushiro K, Matsumoto T, Matsui S (2012) Experimental study on fatigue
durability of RC deck slabs with overlay retrofit. J Struct Eng A 58:1166–1177 (in Japanese)
8. Yokoyama H, Kakuma K, Sato K, Masuya H (2017) Study on the curvature of the road bridge
deck under live load action. J Struct Eng A 63:1296–1303 (in Japanese)
Nonlinear Analysis for Hysteretic
Behavior of RC Joints
Considering Bond-Slip
D. Y. Kim
Abstract This paper presents a numerical model for the analysis of reinforced
concrete (RC) joints that explicitly accounts for the bond-slip between the rein-
forcing bars and the surrounding concrete. A frame element whose displacement
fields for the concrete and the reinforcing bars are different from each other to
permit slip is introduced. From the fiber section concept, compatibility equations
for the concrete, reinforcing bar, and bond are incorporated in the formulation of the
element stiffness matrix. For analyses of general loading cases, cyclic stress-strain
relations of concrete and reinforcing bar are defined in the material model. For the
constitutive model of bond, local bond stress-slip relations for monotonic loads are
updated according to the accumulated bond damage at each slip reversal. The
numerical applications to the reinforcing bar embedded in the concrete block, RC
column anchored in the foundation, and RC beam-column sub-assemblage validate
the analysis model and show the effect of bond-slip for the assessment of energy
dissipation during loading histories.
1 Introduction
The fundamental seismic design adopted in the design codes follows the concept of
strong column-weak beam so that most of the strain energy is dissipated through the
plastic hinge in the beam to prohibit collapse of whole structural system. For a
desirable seismic design of the RC joints, one needs to investigate the nonlinear
behavior and failure mechanism of the RC joint through analytical modeling as well
as an experimental study. Especially, the RC joint shows a complicated structural
behavior due to load transfer through bond and shear resistance in the concrete core.
D. Y. Kim (&)
Civil, Architectural and Environmental Engineering Department, KEPCO E&C,
39660 Gimcheon, Republic of Korea
e-mail: ehdus11@gmail.com
To develop a frame element considering bond-slip, the beam element [7] which is
derived based on the Timoshenko’s beam theory is used herein. In this element, the
lateral and rotational displacement fields are represented by the nodal lateral and
rotational displacements, respectively. Hence, this element could be used effectively
to express the compatibility condition of discontinuous slip separating the rotational
displacement field of reinforcing bars from that of concrete. The frame element could
then be constructed by adding an axial degree of freedom in the beam element [3].
A planar frame element has axial, lateral, and rotational displacement fields. Apart
from the displacement field of concrete, the displacement field of reinforcing bars is
introduced and connected with a bond spring to account for the slip between two
materials (see Fig. 1). Since the reinforcing bars have small sectional area com-
pared to their lengths, the transverse shear deformation of the reinforcing bars could
be neglected.
Nonlinear Analysis for Hysteretic Behavior … 1817
vc1 vc2
θ c2
y uc1 uc2
θ c1
Concrete
vc(x) θ c(x) θ s(x) x
uc(x) us(x) +
θ s2
Reinforced Concrete us1 us2
θ s1
Steel
where the subscript c is for the concrete and the subscript s is for the reinforcing
bar. As shown on the right side of Fig. 1, this displacement field vector is expressed
as the nodal displacement components of concrete and reinforcing bars at each
node, i.e.
U ¼ fuc1 vc1 hc1 us1 hs1 juc2 vc2 hc2 us2 hs2 gT ð2Þ
Because the reinforcing bars and concrete have different displacement fields, the
fiber model in which a section is divided into layers or grids and appropriate
material properties are assigned at the corresponding locations is adopted.
1818 D. Y. Kim
i th fiber
yi
z
yj
j th bar
Fig. 3 Compatibility
elongation = us -uc
condition for slip Initial
elongation
+
Final
-yj
rotation
Figure 2 shows a typical section configuration for the fiber model which discretizes
the section by grids and calculates the secant modulus, strain, and stress at each
grid.
The strain of the concrete at an arbitrary grid is calculated from the axial strain,
curvature, and grid location as follows:
in which eci is the strain of i-th fiber (see Fig. 2) and jc h0c ðxÞ. Similarly, the
strain of the reinforcing bar is calculated from the distance yj between centroidal
axis and center of the reinforcing bar as
in which, js h0s ðxÞ. Besides the compatibility conditions for the bending defor-
mation, an additional compatibility condition for the shear deformation is consid-
ered. With the assumption that only concrete resists shear deformation, an
additional compatibility condition has the following form [3, 7]:
The sectional stiffness of the RC frame element is calculated from the construction
of sectional stiffness of each material, such as the axial rigidity and moment of
inertia, and bond stiffness between the two materials. The axial and rotational
components in the sectional stiffness matrix are calculated from the material and
sectional information of each grid and reinforcing bar as given by
m
X Xn
Eci Aci 0 Esj Asj 0
Dc ¼ ; Ds ¼ ð8aÞ
0 y2i Eci Aci 0 y2j Esj Asj
i¼1 j¼1
Dc ¼ GA ð8bÞ
in which m is the total number of grids in the section, Eci the Young’s modulus, Aci
the area of ith grid, n the number of reinforcing bars in the section, and Esj and Asj
are the Young’s modulus and area of jth reinforcing bar, respectively. For the shear,
G is sectional shear modulus and A* is effective area [3]. Since this study is focused
on the combination of bending and axial behavior, the shear behavior is assumed to
be elastic.
1820 D. Y. Kim
Generally, the amount of slip in each reinforcing bar is different from each other.
Hence, the stiffness matrix for the bond could be constructed by extending the bond
property of each reinforcing bar to the whole of reinforcing bars as follows:
2 3
Eb1 p1 0
6 .. .. .. 7
DD ¼ 4 . . . 5 ð9Þ
0 Ebn pn nn
where Ebj is the Young’s modulus obtained from hysteresis curve of bond-slip
material model of jth reinforcing bar and pj is the perimeter of jth reinforcing bar.
The element stiffness matrix and internal force vector of the frame element are
then obtained from applying the principle of virtual work.
3 Material Model
For the cyclic bond-stress slip relationship, very limited experimental researches
for model development are performed [5]. A hysteretic bond stress-slip model is
proposed by Eligehausen et al. [4] through pull-out tests of reinforcing bar
embedded in concrete block and is adopted in this study. In this model, a damage
parameter, d, which is defined by the accumulated area of hysteretic bond stress-slip
curve during slip history and the area of monotonic curve, is introduced (see
Fig. 5).
1822 D. Y. Kim
4 Numerical Analysis
For a fundamental study of bond behavior in the RC member and verification of the
bond-slip model, a numerical analysis is conducted with the test specimen of
reinforcing bar embedded in the concrete block [12]. The specimen is subjected to
cyclic push-pull displacements at the ends of the reinforcing bar. The embedment
length of test specimen is 25 times the diameter of reinforcing bar and other
material properties of the reinforcing bar are summarized in Table 1.
600 600
400 400
Steel Stress (MPa)
Steel Stress (MPa)
25db
200 200
0 0
-200 -200
-400 -400
-600 -600
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
Displacement (mm) Displacement (mm)
600
400
Steel Stress (MPa)
200
-200
-400
-600
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
Displacement (mm)
(c) Analysis w/o damage para.
In this example, axial degrees of freedom of reinforcing bar and concrete in the
frame element are used only. Since this test is performed with fully confined
condition, the displacement of concrete could be ignored and the pull-out failure
could be assumed in the material model. Evenly spaced twenty-five elements are
used to model the specimen. Figure 6(a) shows the experimental result of
stress-displacement history of reinforcing bar at the rightmost side of the specimen.
To see the analytical effect of bond damage accumulated during slip histories,
analysis results with and without consideration of damage parameter, d in the
bond-slip hysteresis curve are shown in Figs. 6(b) and (c), respectively.
If the reinforcing bar experiences small displacement with low level of slip
reversal before yielding, stresses are transferred well along the length of the
specimen. However, as the bond damage increases after yielding of reinforcing bar
at both ends, a bond failure occurs before stresses are developed inside the block,
resulting in abrupt decrease of resisting force. The analysis results with consider-
ation of damage parameter shows a good agreement with experimental results. An
overestimation of the energy absorption is observed in the analysis results without
consideration of damage parameter.
4.2 RC Column
y
b3
b2 b1
Anchorage
Zone 127.0mm
177.8mm
Bar No. fy
b1 #3 447.5 MPa
b2 #2 444.0 MPa
b3 #2 504.0 MPa
1824 D. Y. Kim
20@25.4=508.0mm
Column
14@12.7=177.8mm
30 Anchorage
30
Lateral Force (kN)
20 20
Lateral Force (kN)
10 10
0 0
-10 -10
Experiment Experiment
-20 Analysis with
-20 Analysis without
bond-slip bond-slip
-30 -30
-30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30
Displacement (mm) Displacement (mm)
(a) With bond- slip effect (b) Without bond- slip effect
From the analysis results, it is shown that the effect of bond-slip on the peak
strength after yielding is not so much. This is due to the fact that the peak strength is
maintained regardless of increase of displacement due to the embedment length and
modeling of hooked anchorage. Hence, as shown in the experiment, bond failure
does not occur in the analysis. However, the simulated unloading and reloading
curves considering bond-slip show better agreement with the experimental results
and evaluate energy dissipation capacity exactly.
4.3 Beam-Column
To simulate the RC joint behavior under lateral loading history and to see the
bond-slip effect of the developed frame element, one of the beam-column speci-
mens tested by Soleimani et al. [11] is analyzed. This specimen governs bond
failure of the reinforcing bar rather than joint shear failure. The geometry and
cross-section dimensions of the test specimen is presented in Fig. 10. The material
properties of concrete and reinforcing bars used in the analysis are the same as those
of the test specimen and summarized in Table 2.
1828.8mm
1422.4mm
1206.5mm
B B Shear
800.1mm Transducer
A
25.4mm
#2 Ties
#2 Ties
19.1mm
3@#5 19.1mm
Section A-A Section B-B
Elevation View
Beam Cross Section Column Cross Section
Splitting Failure
Pull-out Failure
Confined
Concrete
Unconfined
Concrete
250
250
200
200
Horizontal Force (kN)
150
Horizontal Force (kN)
150
100
100
50
50
0
0
-50
-50
-100
-100
-150
-150
-200 Analysis w/ Bond-Slip
-200 Experiment -250
-250 -125 -100 -75 -50 -25 0 25 50 75 100 125
-125 -100 -75 -50 -25 0 25 50 75 100 125 Displacement (mm)
Displacement (mm)
(b) Analysis w/ bond-slip
(a) Experiment
250
200
Horizontal Force (kN)
150
100
50
0
-50
-100
-150
-200 Analysis w/o Bond-Slip
-250
-125 -100 -75 -50 -25 0 25 50 75 100 125
Displacement (mm)
(c) Analysis w/o bond-slip
As shown in Fig. 11, a dense finite element mesh is used to model the joint
location. To ignore the deformation of concrete in the beam elements inside the
joint, relatively large axial and rotational stiffnesses are assumed. Because the
unconfined part which is outside the stirrup in the column is governed by a splitting
failure, different bond-stress slip relations (see Fig. 4) are assigned in the inside and
outside the stirrup (see the dotted enlarged part in Fig. 11). A constant axial load of
2,091 kN is applied first at the bottom of column, and then the lateral displacement
history is applied at the same location based on the concept of ductility. In order to
investigate the contribution of bond-slip effect to the nonlinear structural response,
the hysteretic force-displacement relationships obtained from the analysis with and
without consideration of bond-slip are compared with those from the experiment in
Fig. 12.
As displacement histories are accumulated, slip of the main reinforcing bar at the
joint increases causing a bond failure when the ductility ratio is over 6. This leads to
an abrupt reduction of energy absorption. Figure 12 shows that the analysis with
consideration of bond-slip predicts well the bond failure and reduction of energy
dissipation capacity.
5 Conclusions
A numerical model and its application to the hysteretic analyses of RC joints are
introduced in this study. A frame element which has independent displacement
fields for the concrete and reinforcing bars is developed to account explicitly for the
slip between the two materials. Based on the different displacement fields of the two
materials, fiber section concept, and compatibility conditions for strain and slip with
material models, a finite element is constructed.
The developed model is validated through comparison of the obtained numerical
results with experimental data from embedded reinforcing bar, RC column, and
beam-column joint. The hysteretic behaviors are well predicted with consideration
of bond-slip simulating appropriately the accumulated bond damage and energy
dissipation during loading histories.
Acknowledgements This work was supported by the Basic Science Research Program received
through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Science and
ICT (NRF-2017M2A8A4014828). The information presented in this paper represents the opinions
and views of the author and does not necessarily reflect the views of the sponsoring agencies.
1828 D. Y. Kim
References
Abstract This paper presents the general prediction model of compressive strength
which can be applied for concrete confined by any material. Prediction models of
confined concrete have been developed at every appearance of new confining
material. Confined concrete has steel tube, spiral or hoops and FRP jacket as
external confining material. However, steel and FRP have deferent responses to
tensile stress. Existing prediction models regard confining stress as a function of
steel yielding strength for steel confinement and rupture stress/strain of FRP jacket
and predict compressive strength by one variable function of confining stress. The
main feature in this general model is the intersecting line between lateral stress and
strain relationship of confining material and relationship between axial stress and
lateral strain under constant lateral stress, in three-dimensional space among axial
stress, lateral stress and lateral strain. Therefore, the prediction model is with lateral
strain as the additional variable. Application to concrete which has low compressive
strength is also considered. Agreement of predicted and experimental compression
strength as well as predicted and experimental failure mode are examined.
Keywords Fibre-reinforced polymer Confined concrete Compressive stress
Lateral confining pressure Prediction model
1 Introduction
Many researchers have proposed the prediction model of compressive behavior for
each jacket material. Existing prediction models regard confining stress as a
function of steel yielding strength for steel confinement and rupture stress/strain of
FRP jacket and predict compressive strength by one variable function of confining
stress. This study aims to find the general model which considers every relationship
between tension stress and strain of confining material. In this study, the applica-
bility of the general model is examined by comparing predicted and experimental
compression strength as well as predicted and experimental failure mode for the test
data of normal strength and low strength concrete confined by Jute-FRP jacket.
2 Modeling Process
Target equation of this general model is the intersecting line between lateral stress
and strain relationship of confining material and relationship between axial stress
and lateral strain under constant lateral stress, in three-dimensional space among
axial stress rc , lateral stress rl and lateral strain el (see Fig. 1). This equation was
obtained from two experimentally obtained planes: the plane of rc el relationship
under different rl and the plane of rc el relationship for each confining material.
2.1 rc el Plane
Test data presented by Candappa et al. [1] was used to obtain relationship between
axial compressive stress and lateral strain of cylinder concrete confined by constant
lateral pressure. 4, 8 and 12 MPa of confining pressure was applied by a pressure
where
Ec
n¼ ð4Þ
ðEc rcc =ecc Þ
Curves provided by the above equations and the test data by Candappa et al. [1]
are shown in Fig. 3(1) to (4).
(1) U40 series ( c 41.9 MPa) (2) U60 series ( c = 60.6 MPa)
(3) U75 series ( c = 73.1 MPa) (4) U100 series ( c = 103.3 MPa)
2.2 rl el Plane
2tf rt
rl ¼ ð5Þ
D
where tf is the thickness of FRP jacket, D the diameter of concrete cylinder, rt the
tensile stress (hoop stress) of FRP. rt is a unique function for jacketing material.
The insertion of rt for each jacketing condition provides rl el relationship.
In this paper, result of this prediction model is compared to experimental data of
concrete confined with Jute-FRP jacketing. Tensile properties of Jute-FRP is shown
General Prediction Model … 1833
The intersecting line of rc el Plane and rl el Plane is obtained for each con-
fining condition; 1-layer wrapping to 4-layer wrapping. Comparisons of predicted
and experimental curves are shown in Fig. 5. Measured rupture strain from the
tension coupon test of Jute-FRP is shown on the horizontal coordinate. Predicted
curves is observed to have the same behaviour which is increasing up to fracture of
FRP jacket as experimental curves. Mechanical properties of Jute-FRP is those
shown in Table 1 and compressive strength of unconfined concrete is 33.1 MPa.
Predicted axial stress-lateral strain curve for 1-layer confined concrete showed high
accuracy. Curves of confined concrete more than 2 layers show larger value in axial
1834 H. Minakawa et al.
Fig. 5 Axial stress-lateral strain relationship of Jute-FRP confined concrete (normal strength)
Figure 6 shows the intersecting line of rc el Plane and rl el Plane when low
strength concrete is confined with Jute-FRP and measured rupture strain of
Jute-FRP obtained from tension test. Compressive strength of unconfined concrete
is 7.69 MPa. Curves obtained by this model overestimated the axial behaviour of
confined low strength concrete. Predicted compressive strength at fracture of jacket
General Prediction Model … 1835
Fig. 6 Axial stress-lateral strain relationship of Jute-FRP confined concrete (low strength)
is larger than those obtain in experimental test. Maximum axial stress at rupture
strain of Jute-FRP obtained by the model is larger than experimental result by
130%–149%. The cause of this discrepancy can be considered as the same as the
case of normal strength concrete (Table 3).
4 Conclusions
concrete confined concrete obtained from this method overestimate axial stresses
for given lateral strains. Applicability for another confining material such as steel
and CFRP can be investigated in future research to improve the proposed general
model.
References
1. Candappa DC, Sanjayan JG, Setunge S (2001) Complete triaxial tress-strain curves of
high-strength concrete. J Mater Civ Eng 13(3):209–215
2. Popovics S (1973) A numerical approach to the complete stress-strain curves for concrete. Cem
Concr Res 3(5):583–599
Equal-Capacity Design Method
of Precast RC Shear Wall
with Unconnected Vertical Distributing
Reinforcement
Abstract To solve the problem of grouted spliced sleeve in PC shear wall such as
increasing material costs and poor quality, a new type of PC shear wall had been
developed whose vertical distributing reinforcement were unconnected. The lon-
gitudinal reinforcements in boundary elements were enlarged by Equal-capacity
Design Method proposed in this paper to offset the reduction of bearing capacity
caused by unconnected vertical distributing reinforcement. To verify the accuracy
of the design method and the rationality of the new type shear wall, 10 models had
been analysed by finite element method. The results shown that models with
unconnected vertical distributing reinforcement had lower bearing capacity, and the
contribution of vertical distributing reinforcement to bearing capacity was inversely
proportional to axial compression ratio. On this basis, if the longitudinal rein-
forcements were enlarged by the proposed design method, the capacity of PC
models were as well as cast-in-situ ones which proved that the new type of shear
wall designed by proposed method was reasonable and available.
Keywords Design method PC shear wall Grouted spliced sleeve Vertical
distributing reinforcement Finite element analysis
1 Introduction
Shear walls are known to be quite effective to resist wind and earthquake action due
to their high lateral stiffness. It is the fact that majority of researches were focused
on the cast-in-situ concrete shear walls in recent years [1–3]. However, there are
many disadvantages to construct by traditional cast-in-situ construction, such as
requiring much more labours and resources. Nowadays, precast concrete
(PC) structures develop quickly due to the cost of labour increasing.
The PC elements are basically connected at their joints and installed at the
construction site. The seismic performance of PC structures mainly depends on the
behaviour of the connecting joints. The joints of PC shear wall can be divided into
dry- and wet-type joints. And at present the main joints used in PC walls in China
generally include joint of grouted spliced sleeve, lap-spliced joint by restraint
grouting-anchoring (see Fig. 1). The grouted spliced sleeve is used widely in PC
members in Asian.
However, there are also some shortcomings about the grouted spliced sleeve
during practical engineering application. First, too many reinforcements across the
section of vertical joint means few fabrication errors will lead PC component hard
to install. Second, effective detection method of the grouting quality is limited
which may lead to potential safety hazard of connection joint in the future.
Moreover, so many sleeves in a building project increases material costs. Therefore,
the configuration of PC shear wall need to be improved to meet the requirement of
production and construction.
Scholars from home and abroad have been conducting extensive and detailed
research on vertical distributing reinforcement of shear wall. Qian [4] tested 5 RC
walls with different connecting patterns of vertical reinforcement and found that RC
wall with unconnected vertical distributing reinforcements had lower capacity and
worse ductility performance. Wood [5] analyzed the results of 37 RC walls tested
prior to 1985 and found that walls with total vertical reinforcement contents less
than 1% were susceptible to premature fracture of vertical reinforcement. Dazio
et al. [6] tested three walls with vertical reinforcement ratios between 0.39 and
0.54%, and Li et al. [7] tested eight walls with vertical reinforcement ratios of 0.8%;
however, all these walls had concentrated vertical reinforcement at the wall ends,
which assisted in the formation of secondary cracking.
(a) (b)
Fig. 1 The vertical joints used in PC walls. a Grouted-coupling sleeve; b Lap-spliced joint by
restraint grouting-anchoring
Equal-Capacity Design Method of Precast RC Shear Wall … 1839
To solve the problem of increasing costs and poor quality of grouted spliced
sleeve, a new type of PC shear wall structural system with unconnected vertical
distributing reinforcement was proposed (see Fig. 2). The longitudinal reinforce-
ments in boundary elements were enlarged by design method proposed in this paper
to offset the decrease of flexural capacity due to unconnected vertical distributing
reinforcement. The vertical distributing reinforcement could be configured by
minimum reinforcement ratio of 0.20% base on “Code for Design of Concrete
Structures” of China. The boundary elements were cast in site which means no
sleeve in the new type of PC shear wall structural system. Finite element analysis
has been conducted to verified the rationality of the equal-capacity design method.
2 Proposed Methods
(a) (b)
Fig. 3 Sketch for flexural strength with large eccentricity pressing a Traditional shear wall; b new
type of PC shear wall
The equilibrium equations of the force and moment were obtained as:
When x nb hw0 ,
rs ¼ f y ð3Þ
When x [ nb hw0 ,
fy x
rs ¼ bc ð4Þ
nb 0:8 hw0
bc
nb ¼ fy
ð5Þ
1þ Es ecu
Three specimens were collected from Qian [4] for analysis. The dimensions of the
specimens were 2800 mm height, 1300 mm length and 160 mm thickness (see
Fig. 4). The lateral loads were transferred through a rectangular beam on the top of
each shear wall with the dimensions of 250 mm height and 250 mm width. SW-1
was monolithic RC wall. Shear wall, top beam and footing were cast as a whole.
SW-2 and SW-3 were PC shear walls, vertical distributing reinforcement of both
specimens were unconnected, the longitudinal reinforcement of SW-2 were
Equal-Capacity Design Method of Precast RC Shear Wall … 1841
C3D8R unit and the concrete damage plasticity (CDP) model available in the
ABAQUS library were selected to simulate the mechanical property of concrete.
The density and Poisson’s ratio of concrete were respectively taken as 2500 kg/m3
and 0.2 based on “Code for Design of Concrete Structures”. Cubic compressive
strength of concrete was obtained by material test with the mean value of 40.9 MPa.
Other plastic damage parameters were presented in Table 1.
T3D2 unit was selected to simulate the mechanical property of reinforcement.
Elasticity modulus and Poisson’s ratio were respectively taken as 2.1 105 MPa
and 0.3. Measured value of reinforcement strength were shown in Table 2.
1842 Z. W. Cao et al.
(a) (b)
Fig. 6 Comparation between simulated result and test result. a SW-1 result; b SW-2 result;
c SW-3 result
The simulated result of specimens had been compared with test result to verify the
accuracy and rationality of the finite element analysis (see Fig. 6). The test result
was consistent with that by finite element analysis which proved that the finite
element method in this paper was reasonable.
1844 Z. W. Cao et al.
10 specimens had been analysed with the finite element model above, the parameter
information of specimens were shown in Table 3.
The longitudinal reinforcements of SW-2(Da), SW-3(Da), SW-2(Db) and SW-3
(Db) were enlarged by equal-capacity design method under different axial com-
pression ratio.
(a) (b)
However, when axial compression ratio was 0.35, the capacity of SW-2(b) and
SW-3(b) didn’t decrease so much although the vertical distributing reinforcement
were unconnected. The enlarged longitudinal reinforcement of SW-2(Db) and
SW-3(Db) was 4C18, smaller than 4C20 of SW-2(Da) and SW-3(Da), which
shown that the contribution of vertical distributing reinforcement to bearing
capacity had an inverse relation to axial compression ratio.
The CDP model adopts damage factor to indicate the crack and crushing of
concrete (see Fig. 8). It could be seen that specimen with unconnected vertical
distributing reinforcement had the smaller damage scope. On this basis, when the
longitudinal reinforcements were enlarged, the damage scope had been increased.
1846 Z. W. Cao et al.
(d) (e)
(i) (j)
5 Conclusions
In this paper, a new precast shear wall was developed whose vertical distributing
reinforcements were unconnected. A design method and FE verification were first
conducted. Afterward, FE parametric analysis was performed on the critical
parameters. The conclusions drawn from the study are as follows:
(1) The new type of PC shear wall could solve the problem of grouted spliced
sleeve in PC shear wall such as increasing costs and poor quality with
mechanical behavior as well as cast-in-situ shear wall.
(2) The equal-capacity design method could use to satisfy the requirement on
offsetting the reduction of bearing capacity from unconnected vertical dis-
tributing reinforcement by enlarging the longitudinal reinforcement. The finite
element analysis result proved that design method was accurate and reasonable.
(3) The specimens with unconnected vertical distributing reinforcement had the
smaller damage scope and lower capacity, which meant that connection pattern
of vertical distributing reinforcement had impact on mechanical and deforma-
tion performance of shear wall.
(4) Unconnected vertical distributing reinforcement had less impact on the capacity
of the specimens with higher axial compression ratio.
Acknowledgements This work was financially supported by the National Key R&D Program
of China (No. 2016YFC0701906-3) and China construction technology R&D Program
(CSCEC-2016-Z-16).
References
1. Dazio A, Beyer K, Bachmann H (2009) Quasi-static cyclic tests and plastic hinge analysis of
RC structural walls. Eng Struct 31:1556–1571
2. Beyer K, Dazio A, Priestley MJN (2011) Shear deformations of slender reinforced concrete
walls under seismic loading. ACI Struct J 108(2):167–177
3. Jiang HJ, Wang B, Lu XL (2013) Experimental study on damage behavior of reinforced
concrete shear walls subjected to cyclic loads. J Earthq Eng 17(7):958–971
4. Qian JR, Yang XK, Qin H (2011) Tests on seismic behavior of pre-cast shear walls with
various methods of vertical reinforcement splicing. J Build Struct 32(06):51–59
5. Wood SL (1989) Minimum tensile reinforcement requirements in walls. ACI Struct J 86
(5):582–591
6. Dazio A, Beyer K, Bachmann H (2009) Quasi-static cyclic tests and plastic hinge analysis of
RC structural walls. Eng Struct 31(7):1556–1571
7. Li B, Pan Z, Xiang W (2012) Experimental evaluation of seismic performance of squat RC
structural walls with limited ductility reinforcing details. J Earthq Eng 19(2):313–331
Prediction of Restrained Expansion
and Shrinkage Strains of Reinforced
Concrete Specimens by Using Finite
Element Analysis
S. H. Myint S. Tangtermsirikul
School of Civil Engineering and Technology, Sirindhorn International Institute of
Technology, Thammasat University, Pathum Thani, Thailand
e-mail: suhlaingmyint134@gmail.com
S. Tangtermsirikul
e-mail: somnuk@siit.tu.ac.th
G. Tanapornraweekit (&)
Construction and Maintenance Technology Research Centre (CONTEC), School of Civil
Engineering and Technology, Sirindhorn International Institute of Technology,
Thammasat University, Pathum Thani, Thailand
e-mail: ganchai@siit.tu.ac.th
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Program
Laboratory specimens were cast with concrete which was used for casting slab in a
construction site. Strain profiles were measured in free and restrained conditions by
following ASTM C157/C157M-08 and ASTM C878/C878M-08, respectively.
Restrained expansion/shrinkage concrete prims conformed to ASTM C878 with a
slight modification. The details of the modification are explained later in Sect. 2.2.
The mix proportions of the concrete are given in Table 1.
were brought back to the laboratory and the strain measurement was started from
the first day (day 1). In this study, three specimens were taken from each mix
proportion in order to obtain average strain profiles.
The strain measurement in restrained specimens is based on ASTM C878 with
some slight modifications. In the modification test method, the specimen size is
100 100 350 mm, and a 12 mm diameter deformed bar is placed at the centre
of the specimen. Also, an electrical resistance strain gauge was installed on the
reinforcing bar at the mid-length of the rebar to measure the strain of the specimen
(see Fig. 1). Measurements were started immediately after the concrete was cast in
the mould (day 0). Three specimens were collected for each mix proportions to
obtain the average strain value.
3 Experimental Results
According to the test data in Fig. 2, the normal concrete specimens show higher
compressive strength than those of the expansive concrete specimens, although the
water to binder ratios of all mix proportions are the same. Moreover, the com-
pressive strength of expansive concrete-1 is lower than the expansive concrete-2 as
the amount of expansive additive is high in the expansive concrete-1.
According to the experimental results, the highest shrinkage can be observed in the
normal concrete specimen (see Fig. 3). It is noted that, since the length change
method was employed to measure the free strain profiles of all concrete types, the
free strain measurement was started after day 1 when it was possible to remove the
specimen mould. On the other hand, the measurement of restrained strain profiles
which relies on the results from the installed strain gauges can be started since day
0. Therefore, the measured free expansion was lower than those of the measured
restrained expansion due to difference in starting of the measurement as presented
in Figs. 3(a) and (b). In addition, measurement results show that although the
Prediction of Restrained Expansion and Shrinkage Strains … 1853
Strength (MPa)
50
Compressive
40
30
20
10
0
1D 3D 7D 28D
Age (days)
Expansion
Shrinkage Expansion
300 300
Normal Concrete
Normal Concrete Expansive Concrete-1
100 Expansive Concrete-1 100 Expansive Concrete-2
Strain (με)
Strain (με)
Expansive Concrete-2
-100 -100
Shrinkage
-300 -300
-500 -500
1 21 41 61 81 101 120 0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Age (days) Age (days)
(a) (b)
ratio and the unconfined compressive strength of concrete. The background theory
of this concrete model is provided in detail by Schwer et al. [9] and Wu et al. [10].
This material model was used to model both specimens and concrete base slab with
respect to their input material properties.
MAT_THERMAL EXPANSION is required to convert the equivalent temper-
ature profile to a strain profile. This material card can be used to simulate expansion
of both isotropic and anisotropic material. Since the expansion and shrinkage of the
concrete body of the specimen were concerned, this material card was only used for
the concrete body.
MAT_PIECEWISE_LINEAR_PLASTICITY, an elastoplastic material model, is
employed to model the reinforcing bar. The input parameters for steel are the yield
strength of 12 mm diameter bar of 513 MPa, Young’s modulus of 200 GPa, and
Poisson’s ratio of 0.3.
In order to apply free expansion and shrinkage profiles to the model, the relation
between strain (e) and temperature change (DT) was used to obtain the equivalent
temperature profile. The coefficient of thermal expansion of concrete (ac) is adopted
to be 10 le/°C [8]. The equivalent temperature profiles (from DT = e/ac) of all
types of concrete in this study are shown in Fig. 4. It is noted here again that the
free strains were measured 1 day after concrete casting, therefore, the equivalent
temperature loadings were applied to the model from day 1. Apart from applying
equivalent temperature load to the concrete, the self-weight of the specimen was
applied as a body load.
-20
-30
-40
1 21 41 61 81 101 120
Age (days)
Prediction of Restrained Expansion and Shrinkage Strains … 1855
used to lock the rebar with the endplates where the endplates were installed to obtain
uniform stress on the specimen cross-section, therefore, the displacement at the
intersections of the endplate and reinforcing bar was restrained in all the directions as
shown in Fig. 5. Constrained beam in solid function was used to specify the perfect
bond between concrete and rebar. The base slab was also modelled so as to account
for the frictional restraint from the base. Surface to surface contact card is used to
specify frictional effects between the specimen and the base slab. The friction
coefficients between steel endplate and concrete specimen and between the concrete
specimen and base slab are 0.1 and 0.4, respectively [6].
Initially, the prediction of steel strain was conducted by FE analysis, and compared
with the measured restrained strain from the experiment. Thereafter, the strain
contours at the mid-depth of the specimens were investigated to capture the strain
data between the end and the middle parts of the specimens.
As can be seen from Fig. 6(a), the measured expansion strain for normal concrete is
significantly low (<30 le), and the shrinkage strain reaches approximately 300 le
from 80 days of age. However, the measured restrained expansion strains are nearly
300 le, and the measured restrained shrinkage strains are reduced to 100 le in both
expansive concrete-1 and expansive concrete-2, which can be seen from Figs. 6(b)
and (c), respectively.
It is noted that the level of free expansion under restrained condition is actually
lower than that under free condition. The term “effective free expansion” should be
used to specify the free expansion under restrained condition. However, since the
starting point of free strain was 1 day after concrete casting, the obtained free strain
profiles were actually lower than they should be. In order to discard the effects of
current unknown level of effective free expansion and difference in starting of the
1856 S. H. Myint et al.
300
Expansion
200 Measured-Steel Strain
FEM-Steel Strain
100
0
Shrinkage
-100
-200
-300
-400
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Age (days)
(a)
300
Shrinkage Expansion
Shrinkage Expansion
300
200 200
100 100
0 0
-100 -100
-200 Measured-Steel Strain -200 Measured-Steel Strain
-300 FEM-Steel Strain -300 FEM-Steel Strain
-400 -400
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Age (days) Age (days)
(b) (c)
Fig. 6 Comparison of experimental and FEM results a Normal Concrete b Expansive Concrete-1
c Expansive Concrete-2
measurement, the initial obtained restrained strains (only the maximum expansion
of restrained strain) were offset to be the same as those from the measurement
results. Figures 6(a), (b) and (c) show that the predicted (analysed) restrained strain
profiles of all the specimens agree well with the test results.
T
T
με)
Middle
C Strain (με
C Strain (με
με)
C Strain (με
)
)
0 0 0
Fig. 8 Maximum principal strain at end and middle part of specimens a normal concrete
b expansive concrete-1 c expansive concrete-2. (C denotes “compressive strain” and D denotes
“tensile strain”)
due to the compression strain from the expansive concrete which can compensate
for the tensile strain resulted from the higher degree of restraint. The highest tensile
strain can be seen from the normal concrete specimen which is over 1200 µe.
Expansive concrete-1 was also used to cast the reinforced concrete jointless slab in
the construction site. The slab dimension is 30 m in long direction and 13.2 m in
short direction as shown in Fig. 9(a). Strain gauges were installed at the mid-depth
of the slab in both short and long directions in order to obtain the restrained strain
profiles in the real structure. According to Fig. 9(b), the measured restrained strains
show the compressive strains in concrete as well, similar to those presented in
Sect. 5.2. By using expansive concrete, compressive strains instead of tensile
strains are initiated in concrete, implying that no shrinkage crack is developed in
expansive concrete structures.
1858 S. H. Myint et al.
600
Shrinkage Expansion
400
με)
Strain (με
200
8 0
Short Direction Short direction of Slab
-200 Long direction of Slab
Long Direction
-400
0 20 40 60 80 100
Time (days)
(a) (b)
Fig. 9 a Floor plan of the slab b Concrte strain at mid-depth of the slab
7 Conclusions
The proposed methodology is to predict the restrained strain from the known profile
of the free strain. The FE analysis requires the basic properties of concrete and steel,
and equivalent temperature profile calculated from the free strain profile. A good
agreement between the predicted and the measured restrained strain profiles can be
observed in both normal concrete and expansive concrete. Moreover, the effec-
tiveness of expansive concrete for compensating tensile strain can be seen from the
strain distribution obtained from FE results, and from the measurement in the real
structure.
Acknowledgements The first author would like to express a special thanks to Sirindhorn
International Institute of Technology, Thammasat University for providing Excellent Foreign
Scholarship (EFS) during this study. The authors wish to thank Siam Research and Innovation Co.,
Ltd and Denka Co., Ltd for providing research funds for this study. This study is also supported by
the Center of Excellence in Material Science, Construction and Maintenance Technology Project,
Thammasat University. The authors would like to thank Rachot Chatchawan for conducting the
laboratory experiment.
References
1. ACI 223.R-10. Guide for the use of shrinkage-compensating concrete, Am. Conc. Inst.
(2010). 16 p
2. ASTM C157/C157M-08 (2008) Standard Test Method for Length Change of Hardened
Hydraulic-Cement Mortar and Concrete, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA.
www.astm.org
3. ASTM C878/C878M-08 (2008) Standard Test Method for Restrained Expansion of
Shrinkage-Compensating Concrete, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA. www.
astm.org
4. Bissonnette B et al (2018) Characterization tools for shrinkage-compensating repair materials.
MATEC Web Conf 199:07002. https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201819907002
Prediction of Restrained Expansion and Shrinkage Strains … 1859
1 Introduction
Concrete structures lose their integrity and durability by cracking. Cracks in con-
crete structures are generated with many mechanisms such as excessive stresses
from the external loading, shrinkage of concrete, and physiochemical reaction of
P. Chindasiriphan (&)
Graduate School of Engineering, Hokkaido University, Sapporo 060-8628, Japan
e-mail: pattarapon2005@eis.hokudai.ac.jp
H. Yokota
Faculty of Engineering, Hokkaido University, Sapporo 060-8628, Japan
e-mail: yokota@eng.hokudai.ac.jp
2 Methodology
The experimental test was conducted using cement mortar specimens. The chemical
compositions of cement and fly ash are presented in Table 1, and the specific
information of the SAP is given in Table 2. Ordinary Portland cement (OPC) and fly
ash type F according to ASTM C618 were premixed along with sand and SAP for
2 min. The premixing was carried out to obtain a uniform distribution of materials
and decrease the potential of an adhesive effects of swelling SAP. Water was then
added, and continually mixed at a medium speed for 3 min. The SAP mixtures were
designed at different replacement ratios of 1, 2, 3 and 4% by weight of cement, and
fly ash contents were 0 and 25% by weight of cement. The designed mix proportions
are given in Table 3. The fresh mortar was casted into /100 200 mm cylinder
molds. After 24 h, they were demolded and immersed in water for 28 days.
Effect of Fly Ash and Superabsorbent Polymer … 1865
Table 2 Properties of SAP Material Apparent density (g/cm3) Water absorption (g/g)
SAP 0.7 417
Each mix produced 6 cylinders. Three of them were for the compressive strength
test at the age of 28 days as per ASTM C39. Another 3 of them were for
self-healing capability tests. The cylinder was cut into four /100 50 mm thick
disks. In each cylinder, the middle 2 disks were noted as “the specimen” while the
top-most and bottom-most were disposed. Accordingly, a total of 6 disks were
prepared for the self-healing capability test.
For the self-healing capability test, a control crack of 0.2 ± 0.1 mm wide was
induced in the specimen by a splitting tensile load. The splitting loads range of 19–
30 kN were used to generate a control crack width. Then, the cracked specimens
were self-healed in water for 28 days. After the evaluation of self-healing capa-
bility, the specimens were stored in dry laboratory environment for 2 years. The
results of self-healing capability were reported in the authors’ other paper [2].
1866 P. Chindasiriphan and H. Yokota
The carbonated region is referred to the area that the concrete high alkalinity has been
neutralized by CO2. The carbonation depth can be identified by using phenolphthalein
solution which changes red/pink for uncarbonated concrete and remain colorless for
carbonated concrete (pH < 9) [5]. The self-healed specimens were cut into two pieces
perpendicular to the crack. One specimen produced 2 half circular prisms. Then the
phenolphthalein solution was sprayed onto the cut area at the time of the extraction.
The determination of carbonation front was made using the two parameters: dc and ds,
where dc and ds denote for the averaged carbonation depth from the cracked zone
inside the core of healed crack and that from the specimen surface, respectively. These
measurements were done at 4 locations as presented in Fig. 1.
The carbonation depth is governed by diffusion of carbon dioxide that occurs through
concrete’s pore structure. The diffusion rate is influenced by many parameters such as
concrete permeability, temperature, moisture content and CO2 concentration. It was
specified in the JSCE Standard Specifications for Concrete Structure [6] that the
prediction of carbonation can be made according to Fick’s first law.
pffi
x¼k t ð1Þ
where x represents the carbonation depth (mm), t represents the period of car-
bonation (year) and k represents the coefficient of the rate of carbonation
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
(mm= year).
Fig. 1 Measurement
locations of dc (orange) and
ds (blue)
Effect of Fly Ash and Superabsorbent Polymer … 1867
The influence of fly ash and SAP on carbonation of self-healed concrete was
investigated by thermogravimetric/differential thermal analysis (TG/DTA). The
extracted powder sample was immersed in acetone to terminate cement hydration,
before oven dried at 50 °C for 24 h and stored in the desiccator to minimize
carbonation effects. The powder sample was heated at a constant heating rate of
10 °C/min until reaching 1000 °C under a controlled nitrogen (N2) atmosphere.
The high alkalinity of concrete is due to the presence of portlandite (Ca(OH)2)
produced by the solid phase of cement gel. Carbonation occurs with the reaction
between the dissolved CO2 and portlandite, which produces calcite (CaCO3).
Through the TG/DTA analysis, the quantity of portlandite was determined through
mass change at approximately 400–500 °C while the amount of CaCO3 was cal-
culated at approximately 501–900 °C [1]. Harilal et al. [3] found the relation
between mass lost and molecular mass of decomposed products as given in Eqs. (2)
and (3).
MðCHÞ
CHð%Þ ¼ M1 ð2Þ
MðH2 OÞ
where M1 is the mass loss due to dehydration, MðCH Þ is the molecular mass of
portlandite and MðH2 OÞ is the molecular mass of water.
MðCaCO3 Þ
CaCO3 ð% Þ ¼ M2 ð3Þ
MðCO2 Þ
where M2 is the mass loss due to decarbonation, MðCaCO3 Þ is the molecular mass of
CaCO3 and MðCO2 Þ is the molecular mass of CO2.
The carbonation depths measured are illustrated in Fig. 2. The averaged carbona-
tion depth from the surface of the specimen (ds) was largest in F25S1, followed by
F00 and F25S4. The carbonation depths of F00S1, F25, F25S2 and F25S3 were
small. Therefore, mixing fly ash and SAP in mortar does not have a significant
effect on the carbonation resistivity of mortar. In contrast, the averaged carbonation
depth at the cracked zone (dc) demonstrates the positive effect of fly ash and SAP on
the carbonation resistivity as the carbonation depths decreased with increase in the
SAP replacement ratio. This is in good agreement with the authors’ previous study
[2], in which they reported that concrete self-healing performance increases with
increase in the SAP replacement ratio which results in the recovery of concrete
permeability. It is found that the permeability reduction is facilitated by SAP’s
ability to release water in the cracked area, which consequently results in crack
closure and densification of concrete pore structures due to a further hydration.
are not connected each other and have no significant influence on the permeability
of mortar. In addition, extra water was not added to compensate the water absorbed
by SAP during the fresh stage of mortar. It means that the tendency of decreasing an
effective w/c ratio is found in the mortar with the higher SAP replacement ratio. As
a consequence, the number of capillary pores of mortar with high SAP contents is
expected to be lower than those with the low SAP contents. As a result, the
potential of carbon dioxide infiltration into sound concrete is inferior. To under-
stand the relationship between carbonation resistance and the contents of SAP and
fly-ash, the information on specimens’ pore structure needs to be investigated in the
future.
The results of derivative thermogravimetric curve (DTG) and % weight loss are
shown in Fig. 4. In Fig. 4(a), several materials can be determined by analysing
mass change observed through the different peaks. This study mainly investigated
the derivative of mass which occurs at approximately 450 and 600–800 °C as they
represent dehydroxylation and decarbonation reactions. The mass change of F00 is
clearly noticeable at approximately 450 °C, which denotes that the significant
amount of portlandite is found. In contrast, the reduction of portlandite content is
found to be associated with the presence of fly ash, which potentially results in the
tendency of pH drop. It was reported by many studies that portlandite is produced
due to the process within cement hydration while pozzolanic reaction from fly ash
reacts to consume portlandite producing calcium silicate hydrate (C-S-H).
It is interesting to note that the portlandite content of F00S1 is lower than that of
the reference specimen (F00), and the calcite content of F00S1 was considerably
(a) DTG curves for portlandite and calcite (b) TGA curves for powder fired to various
temperature regimes
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0
(a) Contents of portlandite and calcite (b) Contents of chemically bound water
higher than that of F00. As shown in Fig. 4(b), F00S1 shows a great mass loss at
the temperature range of 650–750 °C which was caused by the decomposition of
calcite. This draws an attention to the influence of SAP on carbonation acceleration.
In contrast, specimens in F25Sx series show no significant gain in calcite content
compared with F00S1. In F25Sx series, it is assumed that portlandite is the control
reactant. Once portlandite is consumed by fly ash, carbonation progress is restrained
due to absent of coupling substrate. However, specimens are encountered with pH
reduction through the pozzolanic reaction of fly ash.
The results of quantitative analysis on portlandite and calcite contents are shown
in Fig. 5(a), whereas the amount of chemically bound water is shown in Fig. 5(b).
The chemically bound water is recognised as the water that chemically bonded into
the structure of hydrates. The chemically bound water can be used to determine the
degree of hydration. The results show that the change in chemically bound water is
related to the fly ash and SAP contents that lead to a higher value of chemically
bound water.
In consideration of the pozzolanic reaction, the reduction of portlandite in fly ash
containing specimens is reflected with increase in bound water, which indicates that
the main hydrated product is expected to be C-S-H. In case of SAP mortar, there is
no clear evidence that shows any chemical reaction related to SAP and the increase
of bound water. However, the effect of SAP on promoting internal curing which
further improves the degree of hydration is profound. The change in chemically
bound water gives a brief overview on phase transformation among hydrate
products which tentatively shows the increase in the C-S-H content.
4 Conclusions
In this paper, the effect fly ash and SAP on carbonation of self-healed mortar was
focused using phenolphthalein indicator and thermal analysis technique. The pro-
gress of carbonation within 20 years was predicted in terms of the carbonation
depth. The thermal analysis allows to quantify portlandite and calcite contents
1872 P. Chindasiriphan and H. Yokota
Acknowledgements The superabsorbent polymer used in this study was kindly supplied by
Nippon Shokubai, Co., Ltd.
References
Abstract Derelict fishing nets are becoming an environmental issue. Since those
fishing nets are threatening many marine creatures, it is necessary to find suitable
recycling solutions. In this study, recycled nylon fiber from waste fishing nets was
used as a reinforcing material in mortar. Parameters which are likely to have effect
on the changes in mechanical property of the mortar such as geometry of fiber and
percent fiber content by volume were examined. Furthermore, compressive
strength, flexural capacity, flowability of fresh mortar, and failure behavior were
extensively investigated to evaluate the effectiveness of the reinforcement.
Experimental results showed higher flexural capacity of the mortar reinforced with
recycled nylon fiber. In addition, post-peak behavior and flexural capacity after the
peak load were investigated. Adding fibers also shows improvement in ductility of
the beams and postpones beam failure.
Keywords Recycled nylon fiber Waste fishing nets Cement mortar Flexural
capacity
1 Introduction
Ocean ecology and many of marine species are being threatened from marine debris
especially from waste fishing nets. Waste fishing nets account at least 46% of the
plastic in the “Great Pacific garbage patch” which is approximately 41,000 tonnes
[3]. In addition, it was estimated that 640,000 tonnes of fishing nets are lost or
discarded into ocean annually [7]. Therefore, recycling and those waste fishing nets
is an urgent action to mitigate the environmental problem.
Fishing nets usually made of a strong and durable material such as nylon; thus, it
can be utilized into many products such as homewares, accessories and clothes [1].
For engineering applications, recycled plastics have long been used in concrete [4,
8]; however, the application of using waste fishing nets are not still well studied.
Synthetic fibers including polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), recycled polyethylene tereph-
thalate (PET), and recycled nylon (RN) from waste fishing nets were found to
improve mechanical properties of mortar; for instance, flexural capacity, toughness,
and ductility [5]. Moreover, Karahan and Atis [2] reported that synthetic fibers such
as polypropylene contributes the durability enhancement of concrete by reducing
drying shrinkage and increasing freeze-thaw resistance. However, slightly reduction
of flowability and compressive strength were observed with the addition of fiber. It
has been studied that nylon fiber from waste fishing nets are stable under alkaline
environment in concrete with no harmful effect to human [9]. In common practice,
fishing nets are usually stored to prevent degradation from sunlight.
This paper investigates the effectiveness of recycled nylon short fiber from waste
fishing nets for the reinforcing of mortar. Influences of fiber geometry and percent
fiber content on the mechanical properties were focused. Compressive strength,
flexural capacity, flowability, and bending behavior were extensively investigated.
2 Experimental Program
Recycled nylon (RN) fibers from waste fishing net were used as a reinforcing
material in mortar. Discarded fishing nets were received from fishermen in
Hokkaido, then cleaned with water and manually cut into specified lengths. Only
the straight part of the nets was used to prevent the formation of fiber lumps during
the mixing of mortar. Two types of RN fibers were used in this study: type A with
0.24 mm in diameter and type B with 0.52 mm in diameter as shown in Fig. 1.
Ordinary Portland cement (OPC) mortar with the water-to-cement ratio of 0.45 was
prepared. RN fibers were added during the mix with carefully monitoring to ensure
uniformly distribution.
Mortar flow tests and flexural strength tests were conducted as specified in JIS R
5201. Compressive strengths were determined in accordance with JIS A 1108.
Flexural strength was determined with three-point bending tests as shown in Fig. 2.
Mechanical Properties of Mortar … 1875
(a) (b)
Two linear variable differential transformers (LVDTs) were installed to measure the
midspan deflection. The flexural tests and compressive tests were conducted on
40 40 160 mm prism and 50 100 mm cylinder specimens respectively. All
the specimens were cured for 28 days under wet condition. Details of specimens are
listed in Table 1.
3.1 Flowability
Flow diameters of mortar with respected to diameter of fiber, length of fiber, and
percent fiber fraction by volume are presented in Table 1. Aspect ratio which is the
ratio between length and diameter of fiber (L/D) and the percent differences in flow
diameter compared to plain mortar (%Dflow) were calculated. Adding RN fibers
resulted in the reduction of flow diameter up to 19% for type A and 8% for type B.
Especially in type A, the more fiber fraction, the greater reduction of flow diameter
was observed. Using the long fiber (e.g. 40 mm long) reduced the flow diameter of
type A and the mix of types A and B. The mix of types A and B expressed the same
tendency as type A. This behavior was observed on PET fiber and PVA fiber [5].
On the contrary, increase in fiber length or fiber fraction did not show clear
effects on the reduction of flow diameter for type B. This behavior might be due to
the lower aspect ratio of type B. Fiber with higher aspect ratio accounts more
surface area at the same quantity of fiber, so it reduces flowability of the mix. For
the fiber with the same modulus of elasticity, fibers with larger diameter tends to be
stiffer; therefore, it is difficult to form fiber knots during the mix. In addition, it was
observed during the mix that type B tends to be more dispersed than type A.
Results from the average of 2 compressive tests and 3 flexural tests for each
condition are summarized in Table 2. The addition of fiber reduced the compressive
strength up to 27% for type B and 19% for type A. Especially, type B showed
greater reduction in compressive strength. Karahan and Atis [2] suggested that
modulus of elasticity of concrete is decreased with the addition of fiber since it
increases void in cement matrix.
Mechanical Properties of Mortar … 1877
Flexural strength increased up to 27% for the type A and 18% for type B. The
increasing in flexural strength was found because adding fibers improves tensile
strength of mortar [6]. Using fiber with 40 mm long tends to provide higher
strength due to better bond between fibers and cement matrix because of greater
surface area. Specimens with higher fiber fraction also expressed higher flexural
strength since fibers transfer tensile stresses and enhance tensile strength.
(c) Type B with 20 mm long fiber (d) Type B with 30 mm long fiber
(e) Type B with 40 mm long fiber (f) Mix of RN type A and type B
with 20 and 40 mm long fiber
This behavior might be concluded that RN fibers have the ability to bridge the
cracks and transfer stress through the cracks. Beams reinforced with RN fibers can
sustain loads until it completely failed.
4 Conclusions
The study on the recycled nylon fiber reinforced mortar reveals several findings on
its mechanical behavior. Experimental results confirmed that recycled nylon fiber
from waste fishing nets has the potential for strengthening cement mortar.
Parameters influencing the mechanical behavior were studied including fiber
diameter, fiber length, and fiber fraction by volume.
Adding fibers results in the reduction of compressive strength. Increasing fiber
diameter causes greater reduction. The addition of fibers results in the reduction of
mortar flowability especially for type A fiber. Flexural strength is improved with the
addition of both type A and type B fiber. The mix of types A and B fiber does not
show a noticeable effect on the flexural strength comparing to the used of one fiber
type. Post-peak behavior with some residual load-carrying capacity is found on the
fiber reinforced beams under the bending tests. The residual load-carrying capacity
increases with the increasing in fiber fraction and the fiber length. Adding RN fibers
improve ductility of the beams; however, beams with RN type B become more
stiffen when fiber fraction is increased.
It is noted that adding RN fiber in mortar gives better performance in term of
flexural strength and ductility. Moreover, adding fibers also delay the failure pro-
cess since fiber helps in transferring tensile stress through the cracks. Further
studies are needed to investigate the applicability of RN fibers in real structures. In
experimental scale, RN fibers were manually cut by hand to control the fiber
quality. However, in real application which require large amount of fibers,
pre-treatment and quality control of fiber are still the challenge for practical used.
Acknowledgements This research has been supported by JSPS Grant-in-Aid for Scientific
Research (B), Grant Number 17H03293.
References
1. Charter M, Carruthers R, Jensen S (2018) Product from waste fishing nets. Circ Ocean Rep
Type 04–2017:1–29
2. Karahan O, Atis CD (2011) The durability properties of polypropylene fiber reinforced fly ash
concrete. Mater Des 32:1044–1049
3. Lebreton L, Salt B, Ferrari F, Sainte-Rose B, Aitken J, Marthouse R, Hajbane S, Cunsolo S,
Schwarz A, Levivier A, Noble K, Debelijak P, Maral H, Schoeneich-Argent R, Brambini R,
Reisser J (2018) Evidence that the Great Pacific Garbage Patch is rapidly accumulating plastic.
Nat Sci Rep 4666:1–15
1880 T. Srimahachota et al.
4. Mercante I, Alejandrino C, Ojeda J, Chini J, Maroto C, Fajardo N (2018) Mortar and concrete
composites with recycled plastics: a review. Sci Technol Mat 30:69–79
5. Orasutthikul S, Unno D, Yokota H (2017) Effectiveness of recycled nylon fiber from waste
fishing nets with respect to fiber reinforced mortar. Constr Build Mater 146:594–602
6. Ozger OB, Girardi F, Giannuzzi GM, Salomoni VA, Majorana CE, Fambri L, Baldassino N, Di
Maggio R (2013) Effect of nylon fibers on mechanical and thermal properties of hardened
concrete for energy storage systems. Mater Des 51:989–997
7. Sea Around Us. http://www.seaaroundus.org/can-we-end-ghost-fishing/. Accessed 22 June
2019
8. Siddique R, Khatib J, Kaur I (2007) Use of recycled plastic in concrete: a review. Waste Manag
28:1835–1852
9. Spadea S, Farina I, Carrafiello A, Fraternali F (2015) Recycled nylon fibers as cement mortar
reinforcement. Constr Build Mater 80:200–209
Macroscale and Microscale Studies
on Time-Dependent Mechanical
Properties of Concrete with Alkali Silica
Reactions
1 Introduction
Si O R þ R O Si þ Ca2 þ þ 2OH ! Si O Ca O Si
þ 2ROH
ð1Þ
The change of the chemical composition of ASR gel can affect its physical
properties. In past experimental results (e.g. [3]), different stiffnesses were observed
with the ASR gel with different calcium contents. It was found that ASR gel is
stiffer when it is placed on the edge of the aggregate than inside the aggregate.
However, the physical properties of ASR gel located outside the aggregate have not
been understood.
The objective of this study was to reveal the relationships between the change of
physical properties of ASR gel and the mechanical performance of concrete.
Understanding the characteristics of existing concrete with ASR expansions can be
helpful to make a proper decision in the maintenance of these concrete structures.
2 Experimental Conditions
Mixed concrete was cast into /10 20 cm cylindrical molds. Each specimen was
sealed for three days after casting and, after that, exposed to each environmental
condition.
The series of specimens is given in Table 2. Specimens for compression tests
and nanoindentation tests were prepared. For the specimens for compression tests,
several target strains of the expansion were set; they were approximately 0, 2000,
and 4000 l and labeled N (no acceleration), M (moderate expansion), and H (high
expansion), respectively. After eight weeks of sealed curing, the specimens of the
M and H series were exposed to ASR acceleration conditions in which specimens
were soaked in 40 °C 3% NaCl solution until the expansions reached target strains
of expansion, and then the specimens were moved to a 20 °C sealed environment in
a sealed condition. The N-series specimens were just sealed and placed in a constant
20 °C environment. Thus, an attempt was made to prepare the specimens with
different expansions and material ages. After 14, 26, and 52 weeks, compression
tests were conducted on the specimens. Another series of specimens, the I series,
was prepared for the nanoindentation test; the specimens were soaked in 40 °C 3%
NaCl solution after eight weeks of sealed curing, and nanoindentation tests were
conducted at 26 weeks of material age. Three specimens were prepared for each
series.
gel were detected. The detected areas were analyzed by EDS. The ratio of calcium
and silica (Ca/Si) in ASR gel was focused on in the analyses as the parameter to
represent the calcium content in ASR gel.
2.4 Nanoindentation
Fig. 3 SEM-EDS results of M-series, 52-week specimen (red: Si, green: Na, blue: Ca for EDS
mapping)
aggregate part contains much sodium and silicon, which are plotted by red and
green colors, respectively. ASR gel in Fig. 3(b) is shown as the color mixed by red,
blue, and green, because it mainly contains these three elements.
The chemical compositions of the ASR gels at different places and material ages
were compared based on the results of SEM-EDS. The area of the ASR gel was
divided into three areas: edge inside aggregate, surface of aggregate, and outside of
aggregate. The Ca/Si of each area in the specimens of M series, 14 and 52 weeks,
was calculated from the SEM-EDS results and is plotted in Fig. 4. Different Ca/Si is
observed at different times and areas. ASR gel in the 52-week specimen has higher
Ca/Si than that in the 14-week specimen. ASR gel outside the aggregate has higher
Ca/Si than inside the aggregate for each specimen. Higher Ca/Si is the result of the
calcium replacement described by Eq. (1), and the EDS results clearly show the
tendency that the matured ASR gel and ASR gel far from the aggregate center have
higher Ca/Si.
Macroscale and Microscale Studies … 1887
3.3 Nanoindentation
Fig. 5 SEM-EDS image of the area of nanoindentation (red: Si, green: Na, blue: Ca)
Fig. 6 Chemical composition and stiffness of ASR gel along the ASR gel
Figure 8 shows the relationships between Ca/Si and stiffness from indentation of
ASR gel. Some previous studies have measured stiffness and the chemical com-
position of ASR gel located inside aggregate [1, 3, 8]. Their results are also plotted
in Fig. 8. The measurement results of previous studies are mainly focused on the
ASR gel inside the aggregate, whereas this study focused on the ASR gel outside
the aggregate. The plots of this study seem to be located on the extension of the
plots of previous studies, which means that the relationships between stiffness and
Ca/Si are irrespective of the location of the ASR gel. In addition, the stiffness of
ASR gel measured by indentation can vary from several gigapascals to several
dozens of gigapascals.
From the compression test results shown in Figs. 1 and 2, the stiffness of the
ASR-expanded specimen increased and recovered with time. Considering that there
were drastic changes of ASR gel in terms of stiffness in concrete, as shown in
Fig. 8, it can be concluded that the change of chemical compositions and micro-
scopic mechanical properties of ASR gel resulting from calcium exchange can be
Macroscale and Microscale Studies … 1889
Fig. 7 Chemical composition and stiffness of ASR gel across the crack
4 Conclusions
Concrete specimens with ASR expansions were prepared, and the mechanical
properties of the specimens were investigated on a macro scale by compression
testing and on a micro scale by nanoindentation. The macroscopic measurement
revealed that the concrete expanded by ASR had a smaller stiffness at an early age;
then, the stiffness recovered to undamaged concrete as time passed. The micro-
scopic observations showed that the changes of chemical composition and Young’s
moduli of ASR gel could have some influence on the macroscopic stiffness of
concrete. However, there should be other dominant factors to explain the recovery
of mechanical performance of concrete affected by ASR expansion.
References
Abstract While the slump test is widely used in conventional in situ concrete
construction, no field test has yet been proposed for additive manufacturing of
cementitious materials. In the extrusion-based 3D printing technology, one of the
important material characteristics is buildability; when deposited fresh mortar is not
stiff enough, the 3D printed object could collapse during the printing process,
resulting in a limited number of buildable layers. The buildability is likely to
depend on environmental conditions. Therefore, to apply the innovative 3D con-
crete printing technology to in situ field construction, the buildability of materials
on site under varying temperature and humidity needs to be evaluated. In this
research, the applicability of an evaluation method of buildability based on shear
strength has been studied. The shear strength of fresh cement mortar is measured by
shear vane test, which can be easily conducted on site. At an arbitrary point of the
3D printed structure, the shear stress is calculated based on the self-weight of upper
layers. By comparing the strength and applied stress, potential risks of collapsing
can be evaluated over the entire object and the maximum buildable height can be
predicted. To verify the evaluation method, square thin-walled structures were
printed by using a 3D concrete printer and the actual pintable height observed was
compared with the prediction. The objects were printed with varying test param-
eters, including temperature conditions of 10 and 20 °C, three mix designs of
cement mortar, and different sizes of 3D printers. The shear vane test was conducted
under each condition during the printing process. The result showed that the
evaluation method significantly underestimates the actual printable height. The
discrepancy might be attributed to the significant amount of air voids in deposited
1 Introduction
Concrete can be easily formed into various shapes and sizes because of its plastic
consistency. This has been true only when prefabricated formwork is readily
available; today, so-called three-dimensional concrete printing (3DCP) technologies
are expected to change the paradigm.
Among a variety of 3DCP methods, fused deposition modeling (FDM) is one of
the most widely used processes in the construction industry. Notable examples are
Contour Crafting [2, 3] and Concrete Printing [4, 5]. This additive manufacturing
process is based on extruding continuous cement-paste/mortar filament to build a
structure layer by layer. With this technology, cost- and labor-intensive formwork is
not required in concrete construction, while the ease of forming any shapes and
sizes can be maintained or even improved (i.e. freeform construction).
When printing cementitious material in the extrusion-based method, the fresh
material should be stiff enough to support the weight of subsequent upper layers as
well as its self-weight without collapsing. This characteristic, referred to as build-
ability, is one of the key properties of 3DCP materials for additive manufacturing
[5]. There have been several previous studies on prediction and evaluation of the
buildability for a given cementitious material.
Wolfs et al. [8] focused on the similarity in mechanical behaviors of fresh 3DCP
mortar and soil, thus conducted geotechnical test methods to measure the cohesion,
angle of internal friction, Young’s modulus and Poisson’s ratio. Based on the
measured material properties and a time-dependent Mohr-Coulomb failure crite-
rion, finite element method (FEM) analyses were performed to simulate deforma-
tion and collapse of 3D printed cylinder objects during the printing. It has been
demonstrated that the numerical model can qualitatively predict the
failure-deformation mode, while the maximum number of buildable layers are
overestimated. Roussel [7], on the other hand, focused on rheological properties of
3DCP materials for predicting the buildability. The proposed model predicts the
critical object height at which either strength-based failure or self-buckling of the
printed object occurs, based on the shear yield stress, plastic viscosity, elastic
modulus, critical strain, and structuration rate of the fresh 3DCP material.
Validation of the proposed model has yet to be done in actual printing experiment.
One of the factors that could significantly affect the buildability but have not
been fully investigated in previous studies is environmental conditions. For
example, the time-dependent development of cohesion, elastic modulus, shear yield
stress and viscosity would highly depend on the temperature of the fresh 3DCP
Quantitative Evaluation of Buildability … 1893
A pocket vane testing apparatus was used for the shear vane test. The diameter and
height of the blade are 2 and 4 mm, respectively. After mixing, a portion of the
fresh mortar was poured into a 500-mL container. The container was covered with a
plastic wrap (except during the shear vane test) to avoid moisture evaporation. The
maximum torque was measured at three different points in the same sample and
take the averaged value. The shear strength sy was calculated based on the fol-
lowing formula (JGS1411-2012):
M
sy ¼ D 2 H ð1Þ
p 2 þ D3
6
where M is the measured maximum torque, D is the blade diameter, and H is the
blade height.
The test was conducted approximately every 15 min during the printing
experiments to see the development of shear strength of the mortar over time. After
each test, the container was manually shaken to fill the holes made by the vane and
kept at rest until the next test.
qgh
s0 ¼ p ð2Þ
3
where q, g, and h are the density of the mortar, gravitational acceleration, and
height of one layer, respectively. Here, it is assumed that the maximum shear stress
occurs in the bottom layer and progressively increases while new layers are
deposited on top. Then, the shear stress in the bottom layer s(t) can be expressed as:
1896 K. Nishijo et al.
Fig. 2 Illustration of
development of shear stress
caused by the self-weight of
upper layers and shear
strength of the mortar
X
sðtÞ ¼ s0 H ft ðt0 þ ntc Þg ð3Þ
n
where H(t) is the Heaviside step function; t, t0, and tc are the time after mixing, time
when the printing starts, and the time needed to print one layer, respectively; n is a
summation index representing the number of layers built. Here, the Heaviside step
function is defined as:
1; x0
H ð xÞ ¼ ð4Þ
0; x\0
It is assumed that each layer is added with a constant time interval tc and thus the
shear stress in the bottom layer increases stepwise, which is represented by the
summation of the Heaviside step functions. Then, adopting a simple strength-based
criterion, the collapse of the printed object is assumed to occur when the
gravity-induced shear stress s(t) reaches the shear strength of the mortar sy(t).
Figure 3 shows the shear strength development of the S260 mortar under constant
temperature conditions. Linear regression equations of the data are plotted as
dashed lines. The results show that the temperature difference of 10 °C causes a
remarkable difference in the trend. Under the temperature of 10 °C, the shear
strength is almost constant during the printing experiments. On the other hand,
significant increases can be seen in the case of 20 °C, especially in Batch 2. It
should be also noted that, while the shear vane test on Batch 1 was stopped at
47 min after the printed object collapsed, a highly nonlinear increase might have
been observed in this case as well if the vane test was continued. Thus, linear
regression seems inappropriate for the S260 series under 20 °C.
Quantitative Evaluation of Buildability … 1897
Fig. 3 Temperature effect on shear strength development of 3DCP mortar: (Left) S260 mix under
a constant temperature of 10 °C, (Right) S260 mix under 20 °C
Although a higher shear strength leads to a higher buildability, too viscous fresh
mortar cannot be extruded from the nozzle. To prevent the substantial increase in
shear strength during printing, a larger amount of the retarder should be employed
in the mix. This indicates the difficulty in determining the appropriate mix design of
3DCP mortar used for in situ printing construction. For example, in a region with
high diurnal temperature variation, a mix design that has adequate buildability and
extrudability in the morning might be impossible to extrude in the afternoon if the
temperature rises substantially. Therefore, the mix design needs to be adjusted
based on the environmental conditions, for which the on-site shear vane test and
measured shear strength should be useful.
Figure 4 shows the shear strength development of L250 and L240 in the outside
environment with their linear regression lines. The L250 series exhibits the almost
constant shear strength of about 0.5 kPa, while a significant increase can be seen in
the case of L240. The temperature variation during the printing was relatively
small; the average temperatures during the printing of L250 and L240 were 7.8 and
9.9 °C, respectively. Thus, the shear strength evolution is also sensitive to the unit
water content.
1898 K. Nishijo et al.
In each printing experiment, the buildable height was predicted based on the
obtained linear regression equation of shear strength and the evolution of
gravity-induced shear stress. Table 3 summarizes the predictions and observed
buildable heights in the printing experiments. In all series, the prediction under-
estimates the actual buildability. The biggest difference is found in the Batch 1 of
S260 under 20 °C; in fact, the printing reached the height limit of the gantry system,
thus the actual buildability should be higher than the reported value. This is the
series that exhibits the nonlinear increase in the shear strength development as
shown in Fig. 3.
Despite the large discrepancies, the concept of the proposed model (i.e. pre-
dicting buildability based on shear strength) seems valid unless a highly nonlinear
evolution of shear strength occurs. Figure 5 plots the observed buildable heights
and the shear strengths measured when the printed object collapsed. If the series of
S260-20 °C (Batch 1) is excluded as an outlier, a significant correlation can be
found in the other series. It should be also noted that the predictions evenly
overestimated the buildability; about two-fold overestimation is found in all the
series other than the possible outlier. Therefore, the overall discrepancies between
the prediction and actual buildability might be attributed to inappropriate estima-
tions of parameters in the model.
There are several probable causes of the discrepancies regarding the model
parameters. Firstly, although the mortar density q was calculated based on the mix
design and the designed air content, the actual density of the printed mortar could
be smaller. In fact, as shown in Fig. 6, a highly porous texture was observed in the
surface of the printed object, especially in the large-scale printing experiments.
Thus, the gravity-induced shear stress was overestimated, which resulted in some
underestimation of buildability.
The second probable cause is significant moisture evaporation in the printed
object. While the sample of the shear vane test was covered with plastic wrap
Table 3 Prediction parameters and comparison of the predicted and observed buildability
ID s0 * (kPa) tc * (min) t0 * (min) Buildable height (cm)
Prediction Observed
S260-10 °C (Batch1) 0.063 0.17 60 5.5 11
S260-10 °C (Batch2) 90 5.5 12
S260-20 °C (Batch1) 44 11.5 37.5**
S260-20 °C (Batch2) 14 5.5 14.5
L250 0.125 0.61 30 4 9
L240 0.131 30 9 15
*See Eq. (3) in Sect. 2.4
**The maximum buildable height of the gantry system was reached
Quantitative Evaluation of Buildability … 1899
except during the test, the extruded mortar in the printing experiments starts to lose
moisture right after deposition. This is especially the case in 3D printed structures
that are not sealed by molds and often have a high surface-area-to-volume ratio. If
the moisture evaporation is significant, the shear strength development in the
printed object could be accelerated, as implied by the effect of water content shown
in Fig. 4. Thus, the underestimated strength in the shear vane test leads to another
underestimation of buildability.
It might be also possible that the procedure of the shear vane test is inappro-
priate. As mentioned in Sect. 2.2, the test was performed approximately every
15 min on the same sample, and the sample was manually vibrated after each test to
fill the holes made by the vane. This vibration might have broken up flocculated
cement particles and delayed the shear strength development. On the other hand, the
extruded mortar in the printed object is not disturbed, which is beneficial for shear
strength development.
1900 K. Nishijo et al.
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements This study was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number 18H05915.
The support is gratefully acknowledged. The authors also acknowledge Taisei Corporation, Japan,
for providing materials and 3D printers used in this study.
References
1. Japanese Geotechnical Society (JGS) (2017) JGS 1411-2012: Method for field vane shear test.
Japanese Geotechnical Society Standards Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Investigation
Methods, vol 2
2. Khoshnevis B (2004) Automated construction by contour crafting – related robotics and
information technologies. Autom Constr 13:5–19
3. Khoshnevis B, Hwang D, Yan K, Yeh Z (2006) Mega-scale fabrication by contour crafting.
Int J Ind Syst Eng 1(3):301–320
4. Lim S, Le TT, Webster J, Buswell RA, Austin SA, Gibb AGF, Thorpe T (2009) Fabricating
construction components using layer manufacturing technology. In: Global innovation in
construction conference. Loughborough University, Leicestershire, UK, 13–16 September
5. Lim S, Buswell RA, Le TT, Austin SA, Gibb AGF, Thorpe T (2012) Developments in
construction-scale additive manufacturing processes. Autom Constr 21:262–268
Quantitative Evaluation of Buildability … 1901
6. Roussel N, Coussot P (2005) “Fifty-cent rheometer” for yield stress measurements: from slump
to spreading flow. Rheology 49(3):705–718
7. Roussel N (2018) Rheological requirements for printable concretes. Cem Concr Res 112:76–85
8. Wolfs RJM, Bos FP, Salet TAM (2018) Early age mechanical behaviour of 3D printed
concrete: Numerical modelling and experimental testing. Cem Concr Res 106:103–116
Investigation of Combined ASR
and DEF Induced Damage on Concrete
by Using RBSM Simulation
Abstract In this study, a 3 dimensional rigid body spring model (RBSM) was used
to simulate the combined effects of alkali-silica reaction (ASR) and delayed
ettringite formation (DEF) induced concrete damage. To model the mechanical
reduction of concrete after deterioration, expansion was considered as the index and
the initial strain was introduced as the damage history. Firstly, for each damage
type, the simulated cracking patterns and mechanical reduction of concrete were
compared with the existing experimental findings, good agreement was reached
which verified the reliability of the proposed simulation method. Then the para-
metric study was conducted to understand the combined effects of ASR and DEF
since they may coexist in site. Surface cracking and internal crack numbers were
analyzed to correlate the mechanical reduction. More importantly, the quantitative
interaction of the two type damages was further discussed to clarify the mechanical
properties loss of concrete under the combined effects, which is hard to achieve
from experimental studies. The proposed method is efficient in simulating of
durability problems of concrete and the simulated results are significant to the
concrete structure design and durability evaluation under harsh environmental
exposure.
1 Introduction
Alkali-silica reaction (ASR) and delayed ettringite formation (DEF) can both cause
surface map cracking of concrete, which are typical durability problems. It was
reported that the two damage mechanisms in some cases are coexisted and it is
difficult to distinguish them [1]. In addition to the surface map cracking, the internal
cracks could also be induced by the expansion due to ASR gel or delayed ettringite
formation. Because of the cracking inside, the mechanical properties of concrete
could be decreased consistently with the expansion [2]. Although the mechanical
property degradations of concrete after ASR and DEF damages are widely studied,
for their combined effects, the investigation is still limited on structural level [3].
Because of the testing difficulties, there are few experimental data available for
concrete deterioration due to the combined ASR and DEF. Therefore, prior to
reaching the reliable test results, simulation of the mechanical property degradation
of concrete by using computer tool could be a good option.
Since concrete is a heterogeneous material and the cracking of concrete could be
randomly distributed. It is better to analyze the concrete cracks by using a discrete
model. Rigid body spring model (RBSM) is one type of discrete analysis method,
which has advantages in simulating the cracking and small deformation of concrete
materials. In this study, a three dimensional (3D) RBSM model was used to
examine the mechanical property degradation of concrete under combined effects of
ASR and DEF. Firstly, the simulations for the ASR and DEF damage of concrete
were verified with the existing test results, respectively. Then the model was used to
study the expansion and surface cracking difference between the single damages
and combined damage. The mechanical properties degradation and the cracks
distribution were further analyzed. Finally, the damage mechanism of the combined
effects was preliminarily revealed.
RBSM was initially proposed by Kawai [4], and then the concept was adopted by
many researchers to develop this method. In this paper, a 3D RBSM model was
developed on the basis of Nagai et al. [5]. The concept and constitutive models of
RBSM simulation method are shown in Fig. 1. Concrete was meshed by using
Voronoi diagram with two types of polyhedron rigid elements (mortar and aggre-
gate). Each element has six degree of freedoms, consisting three translational and
three rotational ones. Elements connect with each other via springs (one normal and
two shear springs). The concrete sample dimension is 100 100 100 mm, both
mortar and aggregate elements are meshed with a size of 2–3 mm. The aggregate
percentage in this simulation is 28.8% and the maximum size is 20 mm, and the
aggregate distribution is based on JSCE standard. The mechanical properties of
mortar, aggregate and the ITZ are presented in Table 1.
Investigation of Combined ASR and DEF … 1905
3.1 Expansion
The expansion induced by the combined effects was calculated based on method
shown in Fig. 2(c) and can be seen in Table 2. It seems the expansion was only
slightly larger than the case of single effect, instead of the sum of them. In par-
ticular, when the expansion is small, the expansion of specimen under the combined
effect has no much difference compared with the single effect. The discrepancy
increased with the expansion level, but the amount is still no large in the severe
expansion case.
After expansion simulation, the internal stress and cracking pattern were further
analyzed and presented in Fig. 3. All cases show map cracking phenomena on the
surface of concrete. In case of ASR (Fig. 3(a)), since the expansion can be initiated
around the reactive coarse aggregate, the cracks distribute evenly inside. However,
due to the intensive expansion, in case of DEF (Fig. 3(b)), the cracking occurred in
the outer part of concrete instead of inside and the corner. When the ASR and DEF
expansions occur simultaneously (Fig. 3(c)), the compressive stress is not only
appeared at the center, but also the corner. With the expansion increase, the cracks
develop gradually and the compressive stress was distributed. Due to the existence
of compressive stress, similar to the case of DEF, the cracks were not appeared at
the center part of specimen. However, both outer parts and the corner cracked
severely, which is obviously due to respective contribution of the two effects.
Fig. 2 Concept for a ASR and b DEF damage simulation c expansion calculation
Investigation of Combined ASR and DEF … 1907
Fig. 3 Internal stress and surface cracking pattern of concrete damaged by a ASR b DEF c ASR
+DEF
1908 Y. Wang et al.
As shown in the Fig. 4, the three cases show similar cracks increase tendency,
despite some discrepancies can still be observed. The number of cracked faces
increased more slowly in case of combined effects with comparison to the others.
The total number of cracks mainly increased before the expansion increased to
0.4%. The value is the smallest in case of the combined effects. For cracked faces
over than 0.03 mm, ASR and DEF cases initiated at expansion around 0.4% and
0.2%, respectively, while the combined effect case initiated at expansion about
0.5%, which means that the strength degradation or large cracks development was
delayed due to the interaction effect. Because of the simultaneous expansions from
distributed ITZ and mortar elements at the center part, they can provide a con-
finement to each other for expansion or cracking development. As a result, com-
pared with their free expansions, the strength degradation could be impeded.
After the expansion simulation, the compressive loading was simulated. The typical
compressive stress-strain curves are shown in Fig. 5, as well as the internal stress
condition for typical load levels (0.2Pu, 0.5Pu and Pu). As shown in Fig. 6, to verify
the reliability of the proposed method, the published experimental results were
picked up to compare with our simulated results. As the expansion increases,
compressive strength decreases gradually in both cases of ASR and DEF. The rapid
decrease was mainly occurred in the initial 1% expansion and then the strength was
almost kept constant. A good agreement was obtained by comparing the experi-
mental and simulated results. Therefore, the method can be used to simulate the
ASR and DEF induced damage and its combined effects, providing some insights
about these durability problems.
The mechanical properties degradation due to the combined effect of ASR and
DEF can be seen in Fig. 7. As shown, there is a slight difference between single
ASR, single DEF and combined effects of ASR and DEF. All cases show consistent
decrease of compressive strength with the increase of expansion. The decrease rate
was largest in case of ASR and the combined effects of ASR and DEF is the least,
regardless of compressive strength and elastic modulus.
Investigation of Combined ASR and DEF … 1909
5 5
5x10 5x10 >0 mm >0.0005 mm >0.001 mm
>0 mm >0.0005 mm >0.001 mm
>0.002 mm >0.005 mm >0.01 mm ASR >0.002 mm >0.005 mm >0.01 mm DEF
>0.03 mm >0.1 mm >0.3 mm >0.03 mm >0.1 mm >0.3 mm
4x10 4x10
5 5
3x10 3x10
5 5
2x10 2x10
5 5
1x10 1x10
0 0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2
5
4x10
ASR+DEF
5
3x10
5
2x10
5
1x10
0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2
Fig. 4 Number of cracked faces increases with expansion a ASR b DEF c ASR+DEF
Fig. 5 Internal stress and cracking development of ASR, DEF, and ASR+DEF damaged concrete
(middle cross-section) under compressive loading (all cases expansion 1%)
1910 Y. Wang et al.
1.4 1.4
0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
Fig. 6 Comparison between simulated compressive strength with existing test results a ASR
b DEF
1.0 1.0
Normalized compressive strength
ASR ASR
Nor malized elastic modulus
DEF DEF
0.9 0.8 ASR+DEF
ASR+DEF
0.8 0.6
0.7 0.4
0.6 0.2
0.5 0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4
Fig. 7 Comparison between mechanical properties loss of specimens damaged by ASR, DEF,
ASR+DEF a Normalized compressive strength b Normalized elastic modulus
The relationships between the number of cracked faces and the normalized
compressive strength, and the number of cracked faces and the normalized elastic
modulus change are shown in Figs. 8 and 9, respectively. For smaller faces (w > 0
and w > 0.0005 mm), the number of cracked face and compressive strength are in a
non-linear relationship for all cases. However, the linear relationship is very clear
for larger cracks (w > 0.01 mm and w > 0.03 mm). It means that the compressive
strength is highly dependent on the large cracks. On the other hand, for the case
with smaller cracks, the linear relationship was observed between the number of
Investigation of Combined ASR and DEF … 1911
5 5
5x10 5x10
w>0 mm w>0.0005 mm
4x10 4x10
5 5
3x10 3x10
5 5
2x10 2x10
5 ASR 5 ASR
1x10 1x10
DEF DEF
ASR+DEF ASR+DEF
0 0
1.0 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6
5 5
3.0x10 1.2x10
ASR ASR
2.5x10
5 DEF DEF
ASR+DEF 9.0x10
4 ASR+DEF
5
2.0x10 w>0.01 mm w>0.03 mm
5 4
1.5x10 6.0x10
5
1.0x10
4
3.0x10
4
5.0x10
0.0 0.0
1.0 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6
Fig. 8 Number of cracked faces changed with normalized compressive strength for ASR, DEF,
ASR+DEF damaged specimens a w > 0 mm b w > 0.0005 mm c w > 0.01 mm d w > 0.03 mm
cracked faces and normalized elastic modulus, while the relationship between the
number of cracked faces and the normalized compressive strength is rather
non-linear. The results imply that the stiffness is very related to the smaller cracks.
Interestingly, for the combined effects, the curve was in the middle of single ASR
and DEF curves with regard to compressive strength. However, the slop of the
ascending curve is the smallest among the three with regard to the elastic modulus.
It indicates that to decrease the same degree of elastic modulus, smaller amount of
cracked face is needed. More importantly, the mechanical properties degradation is
dominated by the cracking inside, instead of the surface cracking pattern or
expansion degree. The strength reduction trend is consistent for all cases as the
large cracks developing.
1912 Y. Wang et al.
5 5
5x10 5x10
w>0 mm w>0.0005 mm
5 5
4x10 4x10
5 5
3x10 3x10
5 5
2x10 2x10
1x10
5 ASR 1x10
5 ASR
DEF DEF
ASR+DEF ASR+DEF
0 0
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
ASR+DEF 9.0x10
4 ASR+DEF
5
2.0x10 w>0.01 mm w>0.03 mm
5 4
1.5x10 6.0x10
5
1.0x10
4
3.0x10
4
5.0x10
0.0 0.0
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
(c) Normalized elastic modulus (d) Normalized elastic modulus
Fig. 9 Number of cracked faces changed with normalized elastic modulus for ASR, DEF, ASR
+DEF damaged specimens a w > 0 mm b w > 0.0005 mm c w > 0.01 mm d w > 0.03 mm
4 Conclusions
(3) The mechanical properties change tendency is consistent with the cracks
development in all cases. While the compressive strength is dominated by the
larger cracks, the elastic modulus is largely affected by the smaller cracks. For
the compressive strength degradation, it seems the combined effects case is in
the middle of the single ones. Still, the combined effect case shows less increase
slop in elastic modulus loss and cracked face numbers relationship.
Acknowledgements The first author would like to express his sincere thanks to Japan Society for
the Promotion of Science (JSPS) for providing fellowship (P18348) to his postdoctoral study.
References
1 Introduction
to the validity of using the recycling rate as the difficulty of the use of recyclable
resources. The present study aims at evaluating Iw4 for cement, steel and paper
production, which are typical venous industries in Japan, by using some types of
recycling rates to investigate the applicability of Iw4 as an environmental indicator.
2 Evaluation Method
In the present study, the Iw4 for three industries including cement, steel and paper
industries was examined. These industries play a role in resource recycling, but
each industry has different scenarios in resource recycling as shown in Fig. 1.
Wastes and by-products used in the cement industry are discharged from other
industries. On the other hand, the steel and paper industries have characteristics of
the horizontal recycling that they collect and use their own by-products as recycling
resources. In addition, while the steel and paper industries discharge wastes in the
manufacturing process, the cement industry does not discharge wastes in the
manufacturing process in Japan.
The usage of the recyclable resources (wk ) of each industry is shown in Table 1.
The amount of waste generation (ck ) of each industry is shown in Table 2. The data
for cement industry were collected from the Cement Hand Book published by the
Japan Cement Association [6]. For the steel and paper industries, there is no lit-
erature that gathers data on the industries as a whole. For this reason, the data were
collected from several references [2–4].
The situation of discharge, treatment and disposal for wastes and by-products has
been investigated by various administrative agencies and industrial groups, but the
data of the recycling rate are different since the investigation methods are different.
In the present study, the data on recycling rate were mainly adopted from the report
of industrial waste discharge and treatment in 2011 published by the Ministry of
the Environment in Japan [2]. This report divides industrial waste generation into
three categories: recycling amount, reduction amount, final disposal amount. This
report also classifies industrial wastes into 19 types, but some of data for industrial
wastes used in this study are classified into more than 19 types. In this study, blast
furnace slag, fly ash, by-product gypsum and iron scrap are not included in the
above-mentioned reported data, so the recycling rates of those resources were
adopted from other references [4, 5]. In addition, since waste paper is included in
general wastes, data from the Ministry of the Environment cannot be used; there-
fore, the recycling rates of this resource was also adopted from other reference [3].
Table 1 The amount of recyclable resources used and each recycling rate
Kind The amount of recyclable Recycling rate (%)
resources used in each
industry (kg/t)
Cement Steel Paper Rk1 Rk2 Rk3
Blast furnace slag 140.7 0.0 0.0 100 100 100
Fly ash 3.5 0.0 0.0 100 100 100
Coal ash 113.2 0.0 0.0 98 98 98
Sewage sludge, Sludge 52.0 0.0 0.0 6 98 75
By-product gypsum 37.6 0.0 0.0 100 100 100
Waste soil from construction 33.9 0.0 0.0 88 88 88
Incineration ash, Soot 24.3 0.0 0.0 67 74 71
Non-ferrous slag 11.8 0.0 0.0 92 93 92
Wood chips 10.2 0.0 0.0 79 96 94
Foundry sand 9.2 0.0 0.0 92 93 92
Waste plastics 8.2 3.8 0.0 54 81 73
Steel slag 7.8 0.0 0.0 92 93 92
Waste oil 4.6 0.0 0.0 39 96 91
Waste white clay 4.3 0.0 0.0 39 96 91
Recycled oil 3.3 0.0 0.0 92 93 92
Waste tire 1.3 0.0 0.0 54 81 73
Meat and bone meal 1.1 0.0 0.0 66 98 97
Iron scrap 0.0 283.0 0.0 99 98 99
Waste paper 0.0 0.0 809.9 72 78 81
Others 10.0 0.0 0.0 52 96 95
Evaluation of Waste Recycling in Venous Industry … 1919
In the present study, the recycling rates according to the three definitions were
proposed as follows:
Recycling amount
Rk1 ¼ ð2Þ
Recycling amount þ Reduction amount þ Final disposal amount
Recycling amount
Rk3 ¼ ð4Þ
Recycling amount þ Final disposal amount
Based on this definition, the recycling rates of the recycled resources are shown
in Table 1, and the recycling rates of waste generation are shown in Table 2. When
the recycling rate is defined as Rk1 , the wastes reduction leads to the environment
impact, and the recycling rate shows a low value for all resources. When the
recycling rate is defined as Rk2 , the wastes reduction leads to the reduction of
environmental impact, and the recycling rate shows a high value for all resources.
In addition, ck represents the final disposal rate. When the recycling rate is defined
as Rk3 , the wastes reduction does not lead to either the environmental impact or the
reduction of environmental impact. Although Rk3 shows the ratio of the amount of
recycling as Rk1 , the reduction amount is not included in the denominator, so Rk3 is
higher than Rk1 . For industrial wastes with a low percentage of reduction such as
1920 Y. Shibazaki et al.
steel slag and waste metal, the difference in the value of recycling rate by definition
is small, whereas for industrial wastes with a high percentage of reduction such as
sludge and waste oil, the difference in the value of recycling rate by definition is
large. The Iw4 of each industry was calculated using these three recycling rates.
The evaluated Iw4 by using Rk1 , Rk2 and Rk3 is shown in Figs. 2, 3 and 4,
respectively. When the recycling rate is defined as Rk1 and Rk3 , the Iw4 for the
cement industry is the highest, followed by the steel industry and the paper
industry. When the recycling rate is defined as Rk2 , the Iw4 for the paper industry is
the highest, followed by the cement industry and the steel industry. Thus, it can be
said that Iw4 changes according to the definition of the recycling rate. In the paper
industry, there are significant changes in Iw4 as positive and negative values. This is
attributed to the large amount of sludge generated from paper industry with a large
amount of reduction. That is, Iw4 was significantly changed by whether the
reduction is included in the recycling rate or not. In addition, the cement industry
shows a positive value for any indicator value using any recycling rate, and it is
considered that cement industry contributes to the reduction of environmental
impact by performing resource recycling.
-200
-400
-600
-800
-1000
Cement Steel Paper
Evaluation of Waste Recycling in Venous Industry … 1921
Iw4 (kg/t)
80
60
40
20
0
-20
-40
Cement Steel Paper
0
LIME2 (yen/t)
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
Cement Steel Paper
The evaluation results of the indicator for recyclable resources were compared with
the results of LIME2 (Life-cycle impact assessment method based on endpoint
modeling) which is typical LCA method in Japan [7]. The waste evaluation results
by LIME2 are shown in Fig. 5. The relationship between waste evaluation results
by LIME2 and waste indicator values of each industry using Rk1 , Rk2 and Rk3 is
shown in Figs. 6, 7 and 8, respectively. The lower evaluation value for waste by
LIME2 indicates the greater contribution to the reduction of the environmental load.
The value estimated by LIME2 for the cement industry is the lowest, followed by
the steel industry and the paper industry. This result shows similar trend as the waste
1922 Y. Shibazaki et al.
-400
-600
Paper
-800
-1000
30000 20000 10000 0 -10000
Integrated assessment results of environmental
impact of wastes by LIME2 (yen/t)
indicator using Rk1 and Rk3 . When the recycling rate of Iw4 is defined as Rk1 and Rk3 ,
the correlation with evaluation result of LIME2 was confirmed. Therefore, it can be
said that Iw4 can be applied to venous industries other than cement industry.
Furthermore, in order to conduct a unified evaluation in research on this indicator,
the optimal recycling rate was selected. From the role as an indicator value used for
comparative evaluation, it is considered preferably that the value of indicator becomes
larger as in the case of using Rk1 . However, according to the definition of Rk1 , both the
recycling amount and final disposal amount show small values when the reduction
Evaluation of Waste Recycling in Venous Industry … 1923
amount is extremely large. This cannot reflect the original intention of this indicator.
On the other hand, Rk3 fully reflects the original intention of using recycling rates as
reflecting the difficulty of effective use of recycled resources.
Consequently, the waste indicator using Rk3 as the recycling rate in this study is
considered to have the highest validity.
4 Conclusions
In the present study, Iw4 in the cement, steel and paper industries were evaluated
and compared with waste evaluation results by LIME2 to show the validity of the
application of the waste indicator in the venous industries. In addition, the effects of
the differences in the definitions of the recycling rate, which shows the difficulty of
wastes recycling, on the waste indicator value were investigated. Based on the
results, the following conclusions can be drawn:
(1) As a result of applying the waste indicator to the cement, steel and paper
industries, the Iw4 changed significantly according to the definition of the
recycling rate.
(2) When the recycling rate of Iw4 is defined as Rk1 and Rk3 , the correlation with
evaluation result of LIME2 was confirmed, and it can be said that Iw4 can be
applied to venous industries other than cement industry.
(3) The Rk3 , which was defined as a ratio of the recycling amount to the sum of
recycling amount and final disposal amount, fully reflects the original intention
of using recycling rates as reflecting the difficulty of effective use of recycled
resources. Based on this, the waste indicator using Rk3 as the recycling rate in
this study is considered to have the highest validity.
References
Abstract The main focus of this study is to investigate the pozzolanic attribute of
the recycled waste glass powder used as cement replacement. A coarser glass
powder (<150 µm) was used and the substitution levels employed were 0, 15 and
30% by weight of cement. A mix design similar to that of fly ash was used in the
current experimental program in order to enhance the performance of the glass
powder (GP) under investigation. In addition to principal tests like workability,
density and compressive strength durability tests like drying shrinkage and resis-
tance to chloride ion penetration were performed. Temperature of the mixes was
also evaluated to ascertain the effect of GP on heat of hydration. Test results show
that 30% is the ideal replacement level which lead to higher strength reporting a
strength activity index (SAI) of over 100%, improved resistance to chloride per-
meability and lower density, drying shrinkage and temperature.
1 Introduction
Waste Glass disposal is fast becoming an upheaval task globally, owing to low
recycling rate, limited storage spaces and shortage in new spaces for landfills [2, 16].
Since glass is non-biodegradable, disposing it in the landfill is environmentally
unsustainable. On the other hand, cement production is one of the main reasons for the
global warming since leading to discharge of almost similar amount of carbon dioxide
in the atmosphere. There has been numerous studies, reported in the literature which
successfully employed pozzolanic materials like fly ash; blast furnace slag and silica
fume as partial replacement of cement but as the methodology is value-added it is
imperative to look out for other readily available waste materials which can exhibit
cementitious properties [1, 11–13, 19, 23]. Recently it’s revealed that glass when
grinded to a particular fineness exhibits pozzolanic characteristics.
In the early days, waste glass was used in concrete as an aggregate replacement
and it was observed that the mechanical and durability properties of the modified
concrete were degraded due to the increased potential of Alkali-Silica Reaction
(ASR) (Etris et al. 1974), [18, 25]. The main reason for this deterioration was due to
high percentage of silica in glass cullets which increased the chances of ASR in the
concrete. Taha and Nounu [24] explained that ASR is a deleterious expansion
occurring in concrete due to the reaction between siliceous minerals present in
aggregate and the alkaline pore solution in concrete. Later, Investigations have
shown that ASR occurrence in concrete is dependent on the particle size distri-
bution of glass used, as the particle size decreases the ASR probability reduces [20,
21]. The suppressive effect of glass powders on the ASR expansion in concrete was
due to the pozzolanic characteristic of glass powder, similar to other pozzolanic
materials such as fly ash, silica fume and metakaolin [7, 17]. These results moti-
vated the application of recycled waste glass powder with microscopic particle size
distribution as cement replacement in concrete.
Experimental investigations have reported that glass when grinded to about
300 µm showed negligible ASR but beyond 300 µm, silica in glass tend to react with
the alkalis and would lead to cracks owing to ASR (Farshad et al. 2010), [3, 4, 21].
Mehta [14] stated that the pozzolanic reaction in glass particle initiates at approxi-
mately below 300 µm and when the fineness is reduced to about 100 µm the poz-
zolanicity of the glass exceeds that of fly ash at low cement replacement levels and
after curing of 90 days. Shao et al. [20] is foremost in the research pertaining to GP as
cement replacement and the size of the glass particle ranged from 38–150 µm. Of late,
the researchers concentrated on finer glass particle size ranging from 0–100 µm and
the maximum percentage of cement replacement is 60% [5, 6, 10, 15]. There is no
agreement on the ideal replacement level of GP reported in the numerous studies done
so far as the performance of GP is dependent on several factors including: particle size;
chemical composition; and experimental parameters.
Most of the research done in the past relating to GP as binder replacement
employed a finer GP (<100 µm), this is one of the few studies in which a coarser
GP is employed and the pozzolanic performance of the GP is improved by modi-
fying the mix design.
Recycled Waste Glass Powder as Binder … 1927
2 Experimental Program
The cement used in this project was general purpose cement which complies with
all the regulations and requirements highlighted in AS 3972 for general purpose and
blended cement. GP (95% < 150 µm) used in the current study was obtained from
a recycling centre based in Brisbane (Envirosand). Fine aggregate passing 4.75 mm
sieve was used in the preparation of the mixtures having a specific gravity of 2.48,
water absorption of 1.5% and fineness modulus of 2.5. A weight based mix design
was used to design a control target strength of 32 MPa and details of which are
shown in Table 1. GP tends to increase the workability due to its water reducing
ability, additionally the specific gravity of GP (2.46) is similar to that of fly ash (2.5)
hence applied an efficiency factor (k = 0.3) akin to that of fly ash mix design [9].
Super plasticizer (SP) content was slightly reduced in GP mixes in order to maintain
similar slump with the control mix as seen in Table 1. Concrete cylinders of
dimension 100 mm (diameter) and 200 mm (height) were prepared in accordance
with AS 1012.8.1, each mix had 15 cylinders for density, strength and chloride
resistance measurements, additionally 3 prisms of 75 75 275 mm were cast
for measuring the drying shrinkage as per AS 1012.13. Drying shrinkage testing
was done for a period of 56 days and heat of hydration of the mixes was evaluated
using an EL-USB-TC-LCD thermocouple data logger for a period of seven days.
Fresh concrete was poured in a vacuum flask, the lid of the flask was drilled to
enable one end of the K-type temperature probe in the mortar while the other end is
connected to the thermocouple data logger to monitor the temperature of the mix
every 5 min.
The workability of the fresh concrete is determined by slump cone test in
accordance with the standard AS 1012.3.1. AS 1012.12 was used to measure the
hardened density of cylindrical samples at 7, 28 and 91 days of curing. The
compressive strength test of all the concrete cylinders was performed at 7, 28 and
91 days of curing in accordance with AS 1012.9. An average of five cylinders was
taken for each testing age in order to keep the standard deviation to a bare mini-
mum. Resistance to chloride ion penetration was evaluated by using Resipod which
complies with the standard AASHTO TP 95. Resipod is a fully integrated 4-point
Wenner probe used to measure the electrical resistivity of concrete cylinders
non-destructively. Current is applied at the two outer probes and the resulting
potential difference between the two inner probes is reported as the resistivity of the
specimen, the applied current is passed by the ions in the pore liquid. For each
cylinder, an average of eight readings is taken as the final resistivity value which is
expressed in kXcm. In majority of the cases, the resistivity results from the Resipod
have shown a good correlation with chloride exposure tests, like ASTM C-1556, on
cylinders cast from the same concrete mix [8].
3 Results
Density of all the mixes increases linearly with an increase in curing age as seen in
Fig. 1. There is a minor reduction in the densities with the increasing GP content,
mix with 30% GP recorded the least densities at all curing ages. The possible reason
may be due to the fact that the specific gravity of GP used is 2.45 compared to the
cement which has a specific gravity of 3.15.
2200
2190
Hardened Density (kg/m3)
2180
2170
2160
2150
2140
2130
2120
M1-0% M2-15% M3-30%
Mix Id
40
105
Strength Acitivty Index (%)
90
75
60
45
30
15
0
7-d 28-d 91-d
Time (days)
M2-15% M3-30%
Chloride resistance of the mixes measured using Resipod are depicted in Fig. 4. As
can be seen, higher the GP content, more would be the resistance value. Both 15
and 30% GP mixes showed a higher resistance to chloride ion penetration compared
to the control mix at all testing ages. The resistance value increased with the curing
age in all mixes, mix with 0, 15 and 30% GP showed a resistivity of 19, 23 and
25 kXcm respectively at 91 days of curing. GP illustrated a much improved
resistance compared to the control mix especially at 91-days of curing and hence
fell in the category of low risk of chloride permeability.
Results of drying shrinkage of the mixes can be seen in Fig. 5. Both the GP mixes
showed a slightly higher shrinkage value compared to the control mix until 28 days
but subsequently ended up a bit on the lower side with respect to the control mix at
final drying age of 56 days.
At 56 days, the lowest shrinkage of 690 microstrain was recorded by the mix
with 30% GP, while the control and 15% GP reported 730 and 710 microstrain
respectively. The slight improvement in the shrinkage of GP mixes compared to the
plain mix is due to the lower water content owing to water reductions of 12.5 and
20 kg/m3 applied to mixes with 15 and 30% GP respectively in accordance with fly
ash mix design [9]. Another study reported similar shrinkage results with a higher
30
25 Low
Resistivity (kΩcm)
20
Moderate
15
10
High
5
0
M1-0% M2-15% M3-30%
Mix Id
0
-100
Shrinkage (microstrain)
-200
-300
-400
-500
-600
-700
-800
0 7 14 21 28 35 42 49 56
Drying period (days)
The heat of hydration of the mixes was evaluated using EL-USB thermocouple data
logger, the results of which are shown in Fig. 6. It can be seen that as the GP
content increases the temperature reduces, mix with 30% GP recorded the lowest
temperature of 41.5 °C, while 15% GP resulted in 49 °C, the highest temperature of
52 °C was reported by the control mix with 0% GP. The lower heat of hydration in
53
48
Temperature (°C)
43
38
33
28
23
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
Time (Minutes)
M1-0% M2-15% M3-30%
GP mixes is most likely due to the combined effect of decrease in cement content
and increased secondary hydration owing to pozzolanic characteristic of GP.
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements Special thanks to Mr. Paul Howard and Mr. Des Chalmers (Envirosand,
Brisbane), for providing the GP for the research project at their own expense.
References
4. Du H, Tan KH (2014) Effect of particle size on alkali–silica reaction in recycled glass mortars.
Constr Build Mater 66:275–285
5. Du H, Tan KH (2015) Transport properties of concrete with glass powder as supplementary
cementitious material. ACI Mater J 112(3):429
6. Du H, Tan KH (2017) Properties of high volume glass powder concrete. Cement Concr
Compos 75:22–29
7. Duchesne J, Bérubé MA (1994) The effectiveness of supplementary cementing materials in
suppressing expansion due to ASR: another look at the reaction mechanisms part 2: pore
solution chemistry. Cem Concr Res 24(2):221–230
8. Hamilton HR, Boyd AJ, Vivas EA (2007) Permeability of concrete–comparison of conductive
and diffusion methods. Final Report submitted to Florida Department of Transportation”
(Contract No. BD536)
9. Hobbs DW (1980) The effect of pulverized-fuel ash upon the workability of cement paste and
concrete. Mag Concr Res 32(113):219–226
10. Kamali M, Ghahremaninezhad A (2016) An investigation into the hydration and
microstructure of cement pastes modified with glass powders. Constr Build Mater
112:915–924
11. Liu F, Meng LY, Ning GF, Li LJ (2015) Fatigue performance of rubber-modified recycled
aggregate concrete (RRAC) for pavement. Constr Build Mater 95:207–217
12. López-Gayarre F, Viñuela RB, Serrano-López MA, López-Colina C (2015) Influence of the
water variation on the mechanical properties of concrete manufactured with recycled mixed
aggregates for pre-stressed components. Constr Build Mater 94:844–850
13. Lotfi S, Eggimann M, Wagner E, Mróz R, Deja J (2015) Performance of recycled aggregate
concrete based on a new concrete recycling technology. Constr Build Mater 95:243–256
14. Mehta PK (2002) Greening of the concrete industry for sustainable development. Concr Int 24
(7):23–28
15. Omran A, Tagnit-Hamou A (2016) Performance of glass-powder concrete in field
applications. Constr Build Mater 109:84–95
16. Pereira-de-Oliveira LA, Castro-Gomes JP, Santos PM (2012) The potential pozzolanic
activity of glass and red-clay ceramic waste as cement mortars components. Constr Build
Mater 31:197–203
17. Ramlochan T, Thomas M, Gruber KA (2000) The effect of metakaolin on alkali–silica
reaction in concrete. Cem Concr Res 30(3):339–344
18. Saccani A, Bignozzi MC (2010) ASR expansion behavior of recycled glass fine aggregates in
concrete. Cem Concr Res 40(4):531–536
19. Shang HS, Zhao TJ, Cao WQ (2015) Bond behavior between steel bar and recycled aggregate
concrete after freeze–thaw cycles. Cold Reg Sci Technol 118:38–44
20. Shao Y, Lefort T, Moras S, Rodriguez D (2000) Studies on concrete containing ground waste
glass. Cem Concr Res 30(1):91–100
21. Shayan A (2002) Value-added utilisation of waste glass in concrete. In: IABSE symposium
report, vol 86, no 6, pp 12–21. International Association for Bridge and Structural
Engineering
22. Shayan A, Xu A (2006) Performance of glass powder as a pozzolanic material in concrete: a
field trial on concrete slabs. Cem Concr Res 36(3):457–468
23. Silva RV, Neves R, De Brito J, Dhir RK (2015) Carbonation behaviour of recycled aggregate
concrete. Cem Concr Compos 62:22–32
24. Taha B, Nounu G (2008) Using lithium nitrate and pozzolanic glass powder in concrete as
ASR suppressors. Cem Concr Compos 30(6):497–505
25. Topcu IB, Canbaz M (2004) Properties of concrete containing waste glass. Cem Concr Res 34
(2):267–274
Engineering Properties of Cement Paste
with Fly Ash Substitution and Addition
of Alkaline Activator
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Program
Type I Portland cement in accordance to ASTM C150 was used for control spec-
imens. Low calcium FA (class F FA) produced by Ya Tung Ready Mixed Concrete,
Co. Ltd in accordance to ASTM C618 was used as partial replacement of cement
with ratios of 0, 10, 30, and 50 wt% of cement. Physical and chemical properties of
PC and FA are shown in Table 1. Sodium silicate (SS) solution type 3 from Rong
Xiang Industrial, Co. Ltd was used as alkaline activator. SS was used to partially
replace the mixing water with ratios of 5 and 10 wt% of water. The properties of SS
are shown in Table 2. Blended paste specimens were cast at a fixed water-to-binder
(w/b) ratio of 0.3. Mixture proportions of blended paste specimens and activated
paste specimens are shown in Tables 3 and 4, respectively.
Workability and setting time tests were carried out to understand the fresh prop-
erties of blended paste. Workability test was conducted using flow table test in
accordance to ASTM C230. Vicat needle method in accordance to ASTM C191
was used to determine the setting time of blended paste. Fresh paste specimens for
Engineering Properties of Cement Paste … 1937
setting time test were placed in a curing chamber with controlled temperature at
23 °C with relative humidity of 65%.
Hardened properties of blended paste including compressive strength and drying
shrinkage were examined. 50 50 50 mm cubes were casted for compressive
strength test in accordance to ASTM C109. The compressive strength was tested at
the age of 3, 7, 14, 28, and 56 days. Drying shrinkage test specimens were casted in
size of 25 25 295 mm in accordance to ASTM C157 and were tested at the
age of 1, 3, 5, 7, 14, 28, and 56 days.
1938 A. Thymotie et al.
3.1.1 Workability
The utilization of FA led to the retardation of both initial and final setting time. As
shown in Table 5, the retardations of initial setting time were approximately 20, 60,
and 120 min for 10, 30, and 50% FA substitution, respectively. FA exhibits a lower
hydration rate compared to that of PC. Therefore, increasing the amount of FA led
to the decrease of hydration products formed by PC [11]. The incorporation of SS
accelerated the setting time of specimens, indicating that the addition of SS might
contribute to the acceleration of hydration reaction of fresh pastes.
As shown in Figs. 1a and b, the early age compressive strength was decreased as
the amount of FA increased due to its lower pozzolanic reaction activity [11]. With
the increase of curing time, the strength of FA blended pastes began to increase.
The early compressive strengths of 10% FA and 30% FA paste increased for 22%
and 17% at 56 days, respectively, compared to that of PC specimen. At later curing
period, the calcium hydroxide (CH) from PC hydration began to react with FA to
produce a secondary hydration that resulted in strength increase of FA blended
pastes [7, 9, 10, 11].
Proper incorporation of SS on blended paste did generate a good result for
compressive strength. As presented in Fig. 1b, both of the additions of 5% SS for
PC paste and 10% of SS for FA blended paste somehow led to slight increase of
respective compressive strength, but, in contrast, the other two additions resulted in
the strength reduction. The reason for strength decrease by the addition of SS was
suggested due to the ratio of SiO2/Na2O of 2.98 was too high, thus lowered the
alkalinity of paste and decreased the strength.
On Fig. 2a, the addition of FA on w/b of 0.3 specimens increased the drying
shrinkage. This result is contrary with some literature review that mentioned that
the addition of FA could reduce the drying shrinkage [4, 6]. Therefore, it is sug-
gested that the increase of shrinkage in this research might have been caused by the
1940 A. Thymotie et al.
100 100
a) w/b = 0.3 b) w/b = 0.3 - SS specimens
Compressive Strength (MPa)
60 60
40 40
Fig. 1 Compressive strength of hardened pastes: a w/b = 0.3; b w/b = 0.3—SS specimens
200 400
a) w/b = 0.3 b) w/b = 0.3 - SS specimens
Drying Shrinkage × 10-6 (mm/mm)
Drying Shrinkage × 10-6 (mm/mm)
-100 -200
-200 -400
-300 -600
-400 -800
-500 -1000
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Age (days) Age (days)
Fig. 2 Drying shrinkage of hardened pastes: a w/b = 0.3; b w/b = 0.3—SS specimens
4 Conclusions
References
1. Al-Kutti W, Nasir M, Johari MAM, Islam ABMS, Manda AA, Blaisi NI (2017) An overview
and experimental study on hybrid binders containing date palm ash, fly ash. OPC Activ
Compos Constr Build Mat 159:567–577
2. Altoubat S, Junaid MT, Leblouba M, Badran D (2017) Effectiveness of fly ash on the restrained
shrinkage cracking resistance of self-compacting concrete. Cem Concr Compos 79:9–20
3. Anand S, Vrat P, Dahiya RP (2006) Application of system dynamics approach for assessment
and mitigation of CO2 emissions from the cement industry. J Environ Manage 79(4):383–398
4. Atis CD (2003) High-volume fly ash concrete with high strength and low drying shrinkage.
J Mater Civ Eng 15(2):153–156
5. Durán-Herrera A, Juárez CA, Valdez P, Bentz DP (2010) Evaluation of sustainability
high-volume fly ash concretes. Cem Concr Compos 33(1):39–45
6. Gesoglu M, Güneyisi E, Özbay E (2008) Properties of self-compacting concretes made with
binary, ternary, and quaternary cementitious blends of fly ash, blast furnace slag, and silica
fume. Constr Build Mater 23:1847–1854
7. Hannesson G, Kuder K, Shogren R, Lehman D (2012) The influence of high volume of fly ash
and slag on the compressive strength of self-consolidating concrete. Constr Build Mater
30:161–168
8. Mirza J, Mirza M, Roy V, Saleh K (2002) Basic rheological and mechanical properties of
high-volume fly ash grouts. Constr Build Mater 16(6):353–363
9. Poon CS, Lam L, Wong YL (2000) A study on high strength concrete prepared with large
volumes of low calcium fly ash. Cem Concr Res 30(3):447–455
10. Zhang YM, Sun W, Yan HD (2000) Hydration of high-volume fly ash cement pastes. Cem
Concr Compos 22(6):445–452
11. Zhao H, Sun W, Wu X, Gao B (2015) The properties of the self-compacting concrete with fly
ash and ground granulated blast furnace slag mineral admixtures. J Clean Prod 95:66–74
Carbonation Progress Mechanism
of Cement Containing Different
Amounts of Powder Admixtures
Takeshi Iyoda
Abstract The cement industry is also reducing carbon dioxide emissions to pre-
vent the global warming. As one of the methods, the use of many powder
admixtures are considered. While the use of admixtures is highly advantageous in
various terms of durability, it is known that carbonation resistance is inferior when
compared to ordinary Portland cement. In this study, we investigated the progress
mechanism of carbonation using cement with high content of powder admixtures.
First, we compared the progress of carbonation in the real environment and
accelerated environment. As a result, it was confirmed that, although carbonation is
delayed in a real environment, the progress of carbonation is quicker than when not
using large amount of admixtures. The effect is more remarkable as the curing
period decrease, and it is found that it has correlation with the compressive strength.
Next, the progress of carbonation was considered to be influenced by the pH and
the hydrate products of the sample. The pH and hydrate and carbonate products
were evaluated quantitatively at depth positions from the surface before and after
carbonation. As a result, it was confirmed that the carbonation depth increased as
the pH was lowered by the high content of the admixture, and the calcium
hydroxide is converted to calcium carbonate. It was also confirmed that the type of
calcium carbonate produced was different. Furthermore, with the change of the pore
structure, the tendency of carbonation to accelerate was also recognized. On the
other hand, it was also confirmed that the carbonation depth identified by the
phenolphthalein solution was different from the actual formation position of cal-
cium carbonate.
T. Iyoda (&)
Department of Civil Engineering, Shibaura Institute of Technology, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: iyoda@shibaura-it.ac.jp
1 Introduction
According protect for global warming, we are working to reduce carbon dioxide in
cement production. Cement has a significant amount of carbon dioxide emissions
during clinker production, and reducing clinker production is most effective for
carbon dioxide emission limitation. Therefore, active use of admixture materials
such as ground granulated blast furnace slag (BFS) and fly ash (FA) is important in
the cement industry. Table 1 shows the carbon dioxide emission of each materials
for concrete shown in “Guideline for checking the environmental performance of
concrete structures” of Japan Society of Civil Engineers. Cement that burns at high
temperature during production generates a large amount of carbon dioxide, while
replacing industrial by-products such as BFS and FA with a part of the cement can
significantly suppress the emission of carbon dioxide. So, it is very effective to use
admixtures for concrete in terms of environmental impact reduction. In addition,
mixed cement in which cement is replaced with admixture material has advantages
such as improvement of salt damage resistance and chemical resistance, and
improving of long-term strength. However, on the other hand, resistance to initial
strength and carbonation decreases due to the small amount of cement. In this study,
we focused on the carbonation resistance, which is considered to be a drawback of
this mixed cement [1, 2].
When carbonation progresses in the RC structure, the passive film of the rebar is
broken, the rebar corrodes, and the expansion pressure causes the concrete to crack.
The JSCE Standard specifications for concrete structures [Design edition] proposes
a carbonation progress prediction formula, and for concrete using admixtures, the
carbonation rate is evaluated by using a constant determined for each admixture.
Concrete using blast furnace slag fine powder is said to have low resistance to
carbonation. However, this regression does not take into consideration the effects of
curing and environment of concrete. Also, Matsuda et al. [3] reported that the
carbonation depth in the actual environment was almost same between normal
concrete and concrete using blast furnace slag fine powder. Generally, calcium
hydroxide [Ca(OH)2] or calcium silicate hydrate is achieved by replacing a part of
the cement with the admixture as a reason for the decrease in carbonation resistance
It is pointed out that the use of a large amount of various admixtures for reducing
the content of OPC and reduces the resistance to carbonation. Here, the purpose is
to experimentally clarify whether there is a difference in the progress by comparing
the accelerated and the real environment.
Table 2 shows a list of cements used in the tests conducted to understand the
difference between the progress of carbonation in the real environment and the
accelerated environment. Ten types of cement were prepared by changing the
combination using ground granulated blast furnace slag having hydraulic properties
and fly ash having pozzolan material based on ordinary Portland cement. A mortar
was produced using these binders. The water-binder ratio was 0.5, and the
sand-cement ratio was 3. The mortar was set to 40 * 40 * 160 mm, and was
deformed 24 h. It was carried out during 7 days and 28 days of sealed curing. The
change in curing expressed the difference in initial strength.
2.1.2 Measurements
A mortar strength test based on JIS R 5201 was performed after curing. The
specimen which sealed by the aluminum tape was prepared except one side surface
1946 T. Iyoda
for carbonation test. The samples were allowed to stand in an accelerated car-
bonation test (20 °C, RH 60%, concentration of carbon dioxide is 5%) and in real
condition test as constant temperature and humidity chamber (20 °C, RH 60%,
concentration of carbon dioxide is about 0.05%). The specimen was cut at setting
age, and the carbonation depth was measured in accordance with JIS.
A phenolphthalein solution was sprayed, and 6 points of a portion colored in red
purple from the surface were measured, and the average value was taken as the
carbonization depth.
Figure 1 shows the relationship between the contents of OPC in the binder and the
compressive strength. It can be seen that the compressive strength decreases with
the decrease in the contents of OPC in the binder. In addition, it was confirmed that
the strength was progressed in any of kind of binders by increasing the curing
periods.
Figure 2 shows the relationship between the OPC ratio in the binder and the car-
bonation depth on accelerated and real environment. It can be seen that the
accelerated carbonation depth and the real environment carbonation depth increase
Carbonation Progress Mechanism of Cement … 1947
Compressive strength
50
40
(N/mm 2)
30
20
10
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Contents of OPC in binder (%)
20 20
Accelerated Real Accelerated Real
Carbonation Depth (mm)
15 15
10 10
5 5
0 0
100 80 60 40 20 0 100 80 60 40 20 0
Contents of OPC in Binder (%) Contents of OPC in Binder (%)
Fig. 2 Relationship between contents of OPC in binder and Carbonation depth on accelerated and
real carbonation environments (Left: 7-day curing, Right 28-day curing)
with a decrease in the contents of OPC in the binder. However, it can be seen that
the difference between the accelerated carbonation depth and the real environment
carbonation depth is large when the contents of OPC in the binder decreased. In
addition, even if the curing days were set long from 7 to 28 days, the accelerated
carbonation depth was significantly large when the contents of OPC in the binder
decreased. From these results, it can be said that the difference between the car-
bonation depth in the accelerated environment and in the real environment is large
in which the contents of OPC in the binder decreased.
Figure 3 left shows the relationship between compressive strength and the real
environment carbonation depth. It can be seen that the carbonation depth decreases
as the compressive strength increases, regardless of the curing periods and the
contents of OPC in binder. Next, Fig. 3 right shows the relationship between
1948 T. Iyoda
20
20
OPC rate : 0 15 , 40
10 10
5 5
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Compressive strength (N/mm2) Compressive strength (N/mm2)
Fig. 3 Relationship between the compressive strength and carbonation depth on different
environments (Left: in real, Right: in accelerated)
compressive strength and the accelerated carbonation depth. Also the carbonation
depth generally decreases as the compressive strength increases regardless of the
contents of OPC in binder. However, the result of on 28 days curing period was
different from the result of the real environment, that cement with a small amount of
OPC in binder did not decrease the carbonation depth while the compressive
strength increased. That is, although the strength is progressed by the extension of
curing, it can be said that the carbonation resistance is not increased by the
accelerated test.
From these results, it is necessary to consider curing period when examining
compressive strength and carbonation resistance in accelerated tests on highly
replacement for admixtures (especially when the contents of OPC in binder is less
than 15%) is necessary. However, if the contents of OPC in binder is less than 15%,
the compressive strength at 28 days is considered to be insufficient in strength
expression, so it is necessary to further study on long term curing periods in the
future.
pH and the amount of carbonation products in the mixed cement, which is inher-
ently low in pH, and consider why carbonation is fast.
Table 3 shows the composition of the mortar which examined pH and a hydration
product in a depth position. In Series 2, three blast furnace cements were used. Such
as B50 equivalent to blast furnace cement type B, B65 equivalent to blast furnace
cement type C, and B85, which have a higher BFS replacement ratio. In addition, in
each of B50, B65 and B85, a study was made on a ternary cement in which 15% of
BFS was replaced with FA.
3.1.2 Measurements
After curing, the specimen was split before accelerated carbonation, and samples
were taken to determine the pH before carbonation and the amount of hydration
products. After that, the specimen sealed with aluminum tape except for one side
was left in the accelerated carbonation test. After measuring the carbonation depth
in the same method as in Series 1, cutting was performed each 6 mm in the depth
direction, and samples for measuring the pH of each layer and the amount of
hydration products were analyzed.
The measurement of pH was performed according to “the method of measuring
pH (JIS Z 8802)” using a digital pH meter of the glass electrode method. The
calibration reagent was a two-point calibration using 0.01 mol/L aqueous sodium
borate solution and 0.05 mol/L aqueous potassium hydrogen phthalate solution.
The pH measuring device used had a measuring range of 0.00–14.00 and a
Figure 4 shows the pH before carbonation. The pH slightly decreases with the
decrease of the OPC ratio in the binder. However, except for B85 and B70F15, the
proportion of OPC in the binder was 15%, the pH values were almost the same.
Focusing on admixtures, it can be seen that the ternary cement has a slightly higher
pH than the binary cement. The reason for this is considered to be that the pH is
raised by replacing part of BFS with FA, which is a low alkali. Next, Fig. 5 shows
the contents of Ca(OH)2 and CaCO3 before carbonation. It is confirmed that the
amount of CaCO3 shown the small amount of mixed component contained in OPC.
That is, the amount of CaCO3 decreases at a rate corresponding to the decrease in
the rate of OPC in the binder. On the other hand, it can be seen that the hydrate Ca
(OH)2 decreases as the mixing and mixing interest of the admixture increases due to
the effect of hydration.
11.5
pH
11.0
10.5
10.0
N100 B50 B35F15 B65 B50F15 B85 B70F15
OPC 100 50 35 15
Carbonation Progress Mechanism of Cement … 1951
8.0
2.0
0.0
N100 B50 B35F15 B65 B50F15 B85 B70F15
OPC 100 50 35 15
Figures 6, 7 and 8 show the pH and the contents of the amount of Ca(OH)2 and
CaCO3 on each depth. Here, the results of B65, B85 and B70F15 are shown. First,
focusing on the pH, the pH decreases in carbonation zone with phenolphthalein. It
can be confirmed that this is related to 10.2–10.3 of the color boundary of phe-
nolphthalein. With the progress of the carbonation, the pH at the measurement
position decreases and we can be clearly confirmed the progress of the carbonation
from pH value. In B65, focusing on the change in pH in the first layer, pH value
significantly decreases from pre-carbonation to the second week of accelerated
carbonation. If the rebar corrosion because of carbonation is due to the decrease of
pH, the decrease rate of pH and the value of pH after judging as the carbonation
zone with phenolphthalein are very important. Next, we focused on the mineral
content. In the case of highly substituted admixtures with cement as in this study,
the amount of Ca(OH)2 formed is very small. Although the difference is not clear in
all figures, it can be said that Ca(OH)2 disappears as much as the progress of
carbonation. On the other hand, focusing on the amount of CaCO3 produced by
carbonation, it can be seen that although a large amount of CaCO3 is produced in
the carbonation zone, there is no significant difference in the amount for each
composition.
Moreover, in B70F15, the amount of CaCO3 increases greatly over the inner-
most layer. This is considered to be due to insufficient sealing when sealing the
specimen with aluminum tape. There was no difference between the
two-component cement (B85) and the three-component cement (B70F15) in which
the proportion of OPC in the binder was the same.
From these results, when the different mix proportions were compared, it was
found that, in the region judged to be a carbonation zone with phenolphthalein, the
change of pH and the lower limit pH value were different, however the amount of
CaCO3 was almost the same. This indicates that care should be taken for
1952 T. Iyoda
Fig. 6 Result of pH and contents of amount of Ca(OH)2 and CaCO3 on each depth [B65]
Fig. 7 Result of pH and contents of amount of Ca(OH)2 and CaCO3 on each depth [B85]
Fig. 8 Result of pH and contents of amount of Ca(OH)2 and CaCO3 on each depth [B70F15]
carbonation of C-S-H in cements with low Ca(OH)2 such as cements with highly
substituted admixtures. There are two types of CaCO3 present in concrete, Calcite
and Vaterite. Toyomura et al. [1, 2] reported that the CaCO3 produced changes with
the change of the replacement rate of ground granulated blast furnace slag. Also,
Harasawa et al. reported changes in pore size distribution before and after car-
bonation for each cement type, and that the cumulative pore volume after car-
bonation increased with the combination of 50% blast furnace slag. From these
Carbonation Progress Mechanism of Cement … 1953
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements This research is in master work of Mr. Takafumi Ito who is graduated
student from Shibaura Institute of Technology.
References
Abstract In the cement industry, ground granulated blast furnace slag, which is an
admixture, is used as an effort to reduce environmental impact. There are various
characteristics of ground granulated blast furnace slag which can be useful as a
substitute material for cement. However, carbonation resistance is low, and it can be
a problem. In this study, it was investigated the effect of carbonation using ground
granulated blast furnace slag on water permeability and it was also measured the
porosity by Archimedes method and mercury intrusion porosity method. It was
investigated the alteration by measuring the pore structure before and after car-
bonation of using ground granulated blast furnace slag. As a result, it was found
that using blast furnace cement can easily permeate water after carbonation. About
the influence of different curing periods, when the curing period was short, it was
found that water can easily permeate in the samples. The result measured by
Archimedes method showed that the porosity increased when carbonation occurred.
As a result of mercury intrusion porosity method, there are many small diameter
pores when carbonated, and it has a complicated pore structure. In conclusion,
carbonation when using blast-furnace cement is considered to reduce the mass
transfer resistance by forming a continuous pore structure.
1 Introduction
Recently, the construction industry is promoting the use of admixtures from the
viewpoint of reducing the environmental impact. There are various kinds of
admixtures. Generally, fly ash and ground granulated blast furnace slag fine powder
(GGBFS) are used in Japan. By using the admixture as an alternative material for
cement, it is possible to reduce the CO2 emissions significantly. Especially GGBFS
can replace the cement in high volume and, as a result of that, it can greatly
contribute to reduce environmental impacts. In addition, GGBFS cement charac-
teristics such as increase salt damage resistance, suppression of ASR, enhancement
of long-term strength and mass transfer resistance is also improved by curing.
However, its resistance to carbonation can decrease.
Carbonation, which is one of the deterioration phenomena of reinforced concrete
structures (RC), destroys the passive film of reinforced bar by decreasing the
alkalinity in concrete and causes rebar corrosion. In general, carbonation of con-
crete is represented by Eqs. (1) and (2).
Table 1 shows the details of the materials used in this research. Table 2 shows the
mix proportion of concrete. The water binder ratio was set to 60% in order to
accelerate the progress of carbonation. Concrete was prepared by replacing GGBFS
with 0, 50, and 70% of the cement.
Table 3 shows the curing condition of the specimens. The samples were cylindrical
with the size of U100 50 mm. The curing condition were non-curing (S1) and
sealed curing 7 days (S7). After curing, the specimens were allowed to stand in a
constant temperature and humidity chamber (temperature 20 ± 2 °C, relative
humidity 60%) until the age of 28 days. The carbonated specimens were allowed to
stand after 28 days in an accelerated environment (inside a chamber with con-
centration 5% of CO2). In order to investigate the effect of carbonation on water
permeability, all the tests were conducted at the 20th week of age when the test
specimens placed in the accelerated environment were completely carbonated.
A prismatic specimen was also prepared, and it was judged that carbonation of the
cylindrical specimen was completely finished when the carbonation depth reached
25 mm.
0 1 1 4 20
Curing
Day Day week weeks weeks
Constant Temperature and Humidity Room
S1
(temperature 20±2°C, relative humidity 60%)
Carbonation Accelerated
Constant Room
S1 Form Carbonation
Cast Demold Test
Placement
S7 Constant Room
Sealing Curing
Carbonation Accelerated
Constant Room
S7 Carbonation
The water penetration test was conducted with reference to the standard specifi-
cation for concrete structure [test method and specifications] of Japanese Society of
Civil Engineering (JSCE) [4]. Figure 1 shows the test method. The side of the
specimen was sealed with aluminum tape and the top and bottom were left opened.
The water absorption method was immersed to a height of 10 mm from the lower
end of the specimen. Tap water was used as a test solution. The specimens were
split at 1, 2, 3 h after immersion and sprayed with an indicator. The water pene-
tration depth was measured at 5 points using an electronic caliper for the colored
part by the indicator, and the average value was taken.
Figure 2 shows the fractured surface of the specimen after 3 h of water absorption.
The blue part shows that water has penetrated. Water penetration was found to be
smaller in GGBFS than OPC in uncarbonated samples. On the other hand, when
carbonation is carried out, the water penetration of GGBFS significantly increased.
Figures 3 and 4 show the results of measuring the water penetration depth of S1
and S7. In S1, the water penetration depth is smaller as GGBFS is replaced, and it
can be seen that water penetration is suppressed by GGBFS replacement. The water
penetration depth for S7 had around the same value at any replacement rate.
Figures 5 and 6 show the measurement results after carbonation of S1 and S7.
The water penetration depth in OPC was significantly reduced by carbonation. On
the other hand, the water penetration of B50 and B70 were increased by carbon-
ation. Particularly in S1, the penetration depth of water reached 50 mm in 2 h of
water absorption. From the above, it was shown that the resistance to water pen-
etration is lowered when blast furnace cement samples were carbonated.
From the results of the water penetration test, it is considered that the changes in
water penetration resistance due to carbonation were because of the modifications in
the pore structures. Therefore, the amount of pore and its structure were measured
by the Archimedes method and the mercury intrusion method using the specimens
subjected to the water penetration test.
The sample was crushed and used with a size of about 5 mm square, so the porosity
was calculated by Eq. (3). The sample was immersed in acetone for 24 h and
vacuum degassed to obtain a dry mass W1. After that, the sample was put in water
and depressurized to fill with water inside the air gaps and calculate the water
saturated mass W2. The mass in water W3 was calculated using the sample mass
when immersed in water.
ðW2 W1Þ
Porosityð%Þ ¼ 100 ð3Þ
ðW2 W3Þ
Figure 7 shows the results of porosity for uncarbonated and after carbonation of
S1. The porosity of the OPC was reduced by carbonation. However, the porosity in
GGBFS was increased by carbonation. Figure 8 shows the result of S7. As a result,
it was found that the porosity of GGBFS increases after carbonation in S7 as well as
in S1. From this fact, carbonation when using blast-furnace cement may increase
the pore volume.
The specimen used were the same as the Archimedes method. In this study, we
focused on the continuity of the porosity, which greatly affects the water perme-
ability. The pore in the cement-hardened structures are connected to each other in
large and small pores to form a complex pore structure. In the mercury intrusion
method, the pore size is calculated on the assumption that mercury continuously
penetrates from the large pore size to the small pore size. However, when a large
pore such as an ink bottle pore exists, the large diameter pore is evaluated as a small
diameter pore. Therefore, assuming the difference as the ink bottle pore effect from
the relation of hysteresis generated in the process of pressurization and depres-
surization of mercury, it was evaluated the continuity of the pores.
1962 J. Nakamura et al.
20
Porosity (%)
15
10
0
OPC B50 B70
20
15
10
0
OPC B50 B70
S1-B70
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00
1 10 100 1000 10000 100000
pore diameter (nm)
Figure 9 shows the result of cumulative pore size of S1. The total pore volume
of OPC was the smallest. On the other hand, the total pore volume of B50 and B70
are larger than OPC, resulting in a large pore volume of small diameter pores. That
is, when blast furnace slag fine powder is replaced, it is conceivable that many small
diameter pores exist and that it has a complicated pore structure.
Influence of Pore Structure Changed by Carbonation … 1963
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00
1 10 100 1000 10000 100000
pore diameter (nm)
S1-B70-C
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00
1 10 100 1000 10000 100000
pore diameter (nm)
S7-B70-C
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00
1 10 100 1000 10000 100000
pore diameter (nm)
Figure 10 shows the result of cumulative pore size of S7. The total pore volume
of OPC was the smallest, and B50 and B70 resulted in a large pore volume of small
diameter pores. It follows the same tendency as S1.
Figure 11 shows the results after carbonation of S1. The difference in total pore
volume due to the presence or absence of carbonation in OPC is small. On the other
1964 J. Nakamura et al.
hand, B50 and B70 had an increased in the amount of the large diameter pores by
carbonation.
Figure 12 shows the results after carbonation of S7. There was no significant
change in OPC compared to the results of carbonation of S1. On the other hand,
B50 shows that the total pore volume is reduced by carbonation. In addition, the
total pore volume of B70 became the largest.
Figure 13 and 14 show the volume ratio of the ink bottle pore contained in the
total pores. The result is the value obtained by dividing the difference between the
pressurization process and the decompression process by the total pore volume.
This value is defined in this research as the ink bottle pore existing in the cement
hardened structure. The larger this value is, the smaller the difference between the
pressurizing process and the depressurizing process, which means that the structure
has a complicated pore structure. In the case of uncarbonated S1, the value becomes
larger when GGBFS is replaced when compared with OPC, and it is considered that
a complex pore structure is obtained by replacing GGBFS. However, in the results
after carbonation, the value of OPC increases, but the value GGBFS replacement
results in a smaller value. From this result, it is considered that the carbonation of
OPC densifies the pore structure to form complicated pores with ink bottle pores.
On the other hand, it is considered that when the GGBFS is replaced, carbonation
changes the pore structure from densified to continuous. Also, in the result of S7,
the value for OPC increased due to carbonation. On the other hand, in the case of
GGBFS replacement, the difference due to the presence or absence of carbonation
was small.
From the above, it was considered that the hardened cement structures for blast
furnace cement had a complex pore structure but became a continuous pore due to
carbonation. And the tendency was remarkable as the number of days for curing
decreased. Previous studies have shown that the carbonate which hydrates when
GGBFS is substituted is superior to calcium hydroxide in carbonation of C-S-H.
From previous studies (5), it has been reported that C-S-H is superior to calcium
hydroxide in carbonation when GGBFS is replaced. From this, it is shown that
carbonation of C-S-H forms a continuous pore structure and reduces the mass
transfer resistance such as water permeability.
70
Ink bottle pore
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
OPC B50 B70
Influence of Pore Structure Changed by Carbonation … 1965
Percentage volume of
0.7
5 Conclusions
References
1. Suzuki K, Nishikawa N, Hayashi T (1989) Carbonation of the C-S-H with various Ca/Si ratios.
Cement Sci Concr Technol (43), 18–23
2. Maehara S, Iyoda T (2018) Study on the effect of rain exposure on carbonation-induced
spalling/falling of the cover concrete. J Jpn Soc Civ Eng 74(2):80–87
3. Harasawa Y, Honda K, Iyoda T (2014) Effects of different carbonation environments on pore
characteristics and carbonation progress. Proc Jpn Concr Inst 36(2):808–813
4. Japan social of civil engineers (2018) Test method for water penetration rate coefficient of
concrete subjected to water in short term, The standard specification for concrete structure [test
method and specifications] of JSCE, pp 448–452
5. Ito T, Iyoda T (2017) Investigation of carbonation progress mechanism in cement with high
replacement of admixtures. Proc Jpn Concr Inst 39(1):637–642
Examination of Evaluation Method
of Hydration Potential of Dry Sludge
Powder Focusing on Hydration Reaction
Abstract In recent years, dry sludge powder has attracted attention for reducing
environmental impact as a method of reusing ready mixed concrete waste.
Manufacturing process of the dry sludge powder is different from the ordinary
portland cement. In the manufacturing process, there is drying process, and it is
performed at high temperature. A characteristic of dry sludge powder is that it
contains hydration products. However, few studies have focused on the effects of
high temperature treatment and the hydration products contained in dry sludge
powder. Therefore, in this study, we focused on the influence of hydration products
contained in dry sludge powder and the high temperature treatment on hydration
reaction. Firstly, we analyzed hydration products contained in the dry sludge
powder. Next, the progress of hydration was examined by measuring the rate of
heat of hydration. In addition, a sample was prepared by simulating the dry sludge
powder process and it was treated at different temperatures and times. By exam-
ining this sample, the relationship between hydration product and hydration reac-
tion was investigated. As a result, it was found that, as the amount of calcium
hydroxide in the dry sludge powder decrease, the strength development becomes
easier. Furthermore, the hydration potential of the dry sludge powder, can be
derived by subtracting the ignition loss value of the raw dry sludge powder state
from the measured ignition loss value.
Keywords Dry sludge powder Hydration product Hydration potential
formula Strength development Ignition loss
1 Introduction
In recent years, various efforts have been made to reduce environmental impact in
many industries. In the ready-mixed concrete industry, along with CO2 reduction,
the reduction of residual concrete and return concrete is one of the major issues.
Annually, about 1.5 to 2 million m3 of concrete are returned and it is expensive to
dispose this material so it became a problem. Returned concrete is divided into
aggregate and sludge water by the washing process. Figure 1 shows the washing
process of the returned concrete. It is specified by the Japanese Industrial Standard
(JIS) A 5308 for Ready-Mixed Concrete, that this washed aggregate can be reused
as a collected aggregate. The supernatant water, that can be filtered and recovered
from the sludge water, can also be reused as the mixing water of ready-mixed
concrete. However, in the present situation, most of the material left after filtration
of sludge water (sludge cake) is discarded as industrial waste. This disposal process
is expensive and an economic burden for ready-mixed concrete plants. Therefore,
Ohkawa et al. have studied methods in which dry sludge powder (DSP), obtained
by drying and crushing sludge cake, is used as a substitute for cement. Figure 1
shows the process of producing dry sludge fine powder. In the drying process, the
burner is heated at about 300 to 500 °C, and the inside of the rotary drum is
processed at an actual temperature of about 100 to 200 °C. Also, as shown in the
figure, the time from when the water comes in contact with ready mixed concrete
until the sludge cake is dried is referred to as the processing time. Returned concrete
and leftover concrete are also washed immediately when they are returned to the
ready-mixed concrete plant to collect aggregate. At this time, regarding to the dry
crushing process, since the amount that can be processed at once by the drum-type
burner to be dried is limited, there is also a time for stirring and storing in the state
of sludge water. Therefore, there are DSP with different processing times. The
difference in DSP processing time refers to the difference in time of agitation of the
sludge water. Previous studies have reported that DSP has different density and
specific surface area depending on the processing time. In addition, tests have been
conducted to confirm strength and durability of structures using DSP. However, few
studies have examined the relationship between hydration product, strength and the
hydration reaction of the DSP, focusing on the correlation between the contained
ingredients in the DSP raw powder. In this study, we investigated hydration
reaction and hydration products from water contact of several DSPs with different
processing times. In addition, in order to clarify the influence of hydration products
contained in DSP on hydration reaction, the production process of DSP was sim-
ulated, and DSP samples were prepared and tested for different processing times
and drying temperatures. The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship
between these hydration-formed hydrates and the hydration reaction.
Examination of Evaluation Method of Hydration Potential … 1969
Processing time
Ready-mixed
concrete Returned Sludge water
concrete Sludge cake
Dry sludge powder
Reuse (DSP)
JIS A 5308
Recovered Supernatant
aggregate water
Fig. 1 Process of washing method and production process of dry sludge powder
First, the hydration products contained in the raw powder were confirmed. During
the processing time, the DSP is in contact with the water so it is considered that raw
powder already contains hydration products because the hydration reaction is in
progress. Hydration products contained in the raw powder were qualitatively ana-
lyzed by X-ray diffraction, and the quantitative analysis was performed by differ-
ential thermogravimetric analysis. At this time, in order to clarify the influence of
the hydration products contained in the DSP on the hydration reaction, it was
simulated the production process of the DSP and hydrated samples were produced
with different processing times and the drying temperature. Thermogravimetric
analysis was also performed.
Next, the influence of the hydration products contained in the raw powder
submitted to the hydration reaction was examined. A cement paste was prepared,
and powder X-ray diffraction was performed to confirm the hydrates formed as the
hydration reaction proceeds. Differential thermogravimetric analysis was also per-
formed to determine hydration products. Furthermore, the total hydration heat of
cement paste was measured using a conduction calorimeter, and the progress of
hydration reaction was confirmed. After that, mortar was made using DSP, and it
was examined the relationship between strength and the degree of hydration pro-
gress of DSP affected mortar.
1970 M. Araki et al.
For this study, it was used five kinds of DSP made with different processing times and
prepared by simulating the method of making DSP and also ordinary portland cement
(OPC) as reference. The details of each DSP and OPC are shown in Table 1, and for
hydrated cement, it is shown in Table 2. The specific surface area, that is shown in
Table 1, was measured using a braine permeation device. The processing time was
chosen to be short and long, so that the differences in the progress of hydration
between DSPs could be considered. The fine aggregate used in this study is a mountain
sand from Kimitsu at Chiba Prefecture in Japan (Surface dry density: 2.62 g/cm3).
The hydrated cement samples were made using a W/C factor of 200% with OPC
cement paste mixed together using a stirrer devise. In this study, three hours and
24 h were set as the processing time for mixing with the stirrer. After the prede-
termined time, the cement paste was dewatered with a suction funnel and dried
using an electric furnace until the mass loss became constant at a set temperature.
The drying temperature was set at 105 °C, close to the actual drying temperature,
and it was also used the 40 °C and 300 °C for comparison. After drying, the sample
was ground using a grinding mill to obtain the DSP.
The mix proportion of mortar used in this research was 1:3 according to the cement
strength test standard JIS R 5201. The size of the specimen was 40 40 160
mm. After demolding on the next day of placement, the samples were transferred to
Measurement of the total hydration heat was performed to confirm the progress of
hydration. The heat of hydration was measured over time using a conduction
calorimeter. It is known that there is a correlation between the cement hydration
speed and the total hydration heat. In this test, the binders OPC, DSP-B, DSP-C,
and DSP-E were used. The cement paste used was W/C = 55%. The specimens
were weighed so the total amount of water and cement reach 4 g, so after put
together, they were mixed for 30 s. Following, a conduction calorimeter was
installed, and hydration heat from immediately to 48 h after water contact with
material was measured at a constant temperature environment (20 °C). X-ray
diffraction was used to identify the hydration products contained. The raw powder
of DSP, hydrated cement and OPC were analyzed. Differential thermogravimetric
analysis was performed using TG-DTA for measurement at a heating rate of
20 °C/min from 40 °C to 1000 °C under an N2 flow environment. The amount of
production was calculated from the TG curve by the dehydrated weight of the
product from the inflection point of the DTA curve. The analysis was carried out
using the DSP, the hydrated cement, and the raw powder of OPC as samples.
Figure 4 shows the results of powder X-ray diffraction of DSP raw material and
hydrated cement. Unlike the other samples, the peak of ettringite was confirmed at
24 h_40 °C and 24 h_105 °C. The hydrates that can be identified in the raw powder
are generally the same for any sample. However, focusing on the intensities of these
peaks, different results were obtained depending on the powder. From this result,
quantitative analysis of hydrate was performed.
The amount of hydration products contained in the raw powder of OPC, DSP
and hydrated cement were measured, and the ratio was calculated. Figure 2 shows
the content of calcium hydroxide and Fig. 3 shows the content of calcium car-
bonate. DSP and hydrated cement are compared with OPC, and it turns out that
both calcium hydroxide and calcium carbonate are contained. The amount of cal-
cium hydroxide varie for DSP and hydrated cement. The longer the processing
1972 M. Araki et al.
time, the more calcium hydroxide is contained. From this, it is considered that the
calcium hydroxide contained in the sample is generated due to the progress of the
hydration reaction during the water processing time. The amount of calcium car-
bonate contained in DSP was almost equal regardless of the processing time. Also,
the hydrated cement contains less calcium carbonate than DSP. Calcium carbonate
is derived from cement because the amount contained in the sample is equivalent to
OPC. From this, it is thought that calcium carbonate contained in DSP is increased
by the influence of fine particles derived from aggregate which could not be dis-
charged by washing treatment and classification treatment. The samples that were
stirred for 24 h and dried at 40 °C decreased in the amount of calcium hydroxide
and increased in the amount of calcium carbonate compared to the other samples
stirred for 24 h. This is due to carbonation of part of the sample during the drying
process.
Examination of Evaluation Method of Hydration Potential … 1973
Figure 4 shows the powder X-ray diffraction results of the 3 days old cement paste
manufactured using DSP and the hydrated cement. The hydration products that
could be confirmed were generally similar. However, in DSP, different peaks can be
confirmed around 2h = 10°. This was considered to require further study. Figure 5
shows the results of total hydration heat measured with a conduction calorimeter.
Figure 5 shows the results of total hydration heat amount. As shown in the figures,
the shorter the DSP processing time, the larger the hydration reaction peak and the
higher the integrated temperature. It is considered that this is due to the already
developed hydration reaction affecting the processing time of DSP and hydrated
cement. As the processing time is shorter, the hydration reaction does not progress
within the processing time. Therefore, it is considered that there is a remaining
capacity of hydration when water is put in contact with DSP and hydrated cement.
The results of making a cement paste using DSP and performing differential
thermogravimetric analysis for each material age are shown. Figure 6 shows the
progress of calcium hydroxide content. From this graph, the tendency of the
transition of the amount of calcium hydroxide is divided into two. The calcium
hydroxide content of the DSP exceeds the OPC in the raw powder state. After water
contact, the OPC far exceeds the DSP and reverses. DSP-C, DSP-D, and DSP-E
have the largest amount of calcium hydroxide in the raw powder state, and after
contact with water, calcium hydroxide has decreased. The amount of calcium
hydroxide in OPC, DSP-A and DSP-B increased with age. As the processing time
of DSP-C, DSP-D, and DSP-E became longer, the amount of calcium hydroxide
showed was smaller than the raw powder state. It can be seen that the DSP, with a
short processing time, has a large amount of hydration products when compared to
the DSP having a longer processing time.
Calcium hydroxide
Raw Calcium hydroxide
powder Calcium carbonate 3days
Calcium carbonate
Ettringite
OPC
24h_40
OPC 24h_105
24h_40 24h_300
24h_105
24h_300 DSP-A
DSP-A DSP-E
DSP-E
Figure 7 shows the progress of calcium hydroxide ratio of hydrated cement and
DSP, and Fig. 8 shows the progress of calcium carbonate ratio. From the figures, it
can be seen that the calcium hydroxide content of the hydrated cement, that was
dried at 105 °C and 300 °C, exceeds the DSP and is equivalent to the OPC. When
the drying temperature was 40 °C the hydrated cement for 3 h and 8 h had calcium
hydroxide equivalent to that of DSP-A. However, when the treatment time is 24 h
with drying temperature of 40 °C, almost no calcium hydroxide is produced below
DSP-E. On the other hand, calcium carbonate is considered to not contribute to
hydration because it hardly changed in proportion by 3 days of material age.
Examination of Evaluation Method of Hydration Potential … 1975
Fig. 10 Relationship
between compressive strength
and hydration potential
Examination of Evaluation Method of Hydration Potential … 1977
hydration potential increased. This result suggests that the drying temperature of
105 °C or more may affect the hydration reaction, and it is thought that further study
is necessary in the future.
4 Conclusions
1) The total hydration heat of DSP decreased as the treatment time increased. Also,
the total hydration heat of DSP with short processing time was increased. This is
the effect of the hydration reaction that has already progressed, because the
degree of progression of hydration varies depending on the processing time of
DSP.
2) The hydration potential of DSP can be calculated by subtracting the ignition loss
value of the raw powder state of DSP from the measured ignition loss value.
3) Strength development can be evaluated by calculating hydration potential. By
using this, it was shown that the smaller the amount of calcium hydroxide
contained, the easier it is for strength to be developed.
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thanks Mr. Y. Kengo, Ms. N. Yukari and Mr.
M. Kanta from Shibaura Institute of Technology for their help in this study.
References
1 Introduction
Earthquakes often occur in Japan. The recent biggest earthquake that occurred on
March 11th, 2011 caused huge damages. Disaster wastes became a problem after
the earthquakes. Preplaced-aggregate concrete has attracted attention as one a
method of using concrete waste among the disaster waste’s. In the method of
2 Outline of Experiments
It was used normal coarse aggregate (C-40), recycled aggregate (RC-40), and
railway waste ballast (Ballast). Table 1 shows the physical properties of the
aggregates used. Figure 2 and Fig. 3 show the distribution of particle size.
In preplaced concrete, aggregates with a particle size of 10 mm or less are not
used because the spaces between the aggregates have to be filled.
In Table 2, the specified mix proportion are indicated. Water-binder ratio is 45%.
The mortar used for preplaced concrete is a non-shrinkage premixed mortar and
contains 40% of ground granulated blast-furnace slag (BFS). Therefore, in normal
concrete, the replacement ratio of BFS was also set to 40%.
80% RC-40
passed through
Ballast
60%
40%
20%
0%
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Particle size (mm)
80% RC-40
Percentage of aggregate
Ballast
passed through
60%
40%
20%
0%
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Particle size (mm)
1982 A. Shibuya and T. Iyoda
The specimens for compressive strength test were cast using formwork as shown in
Fig. 4. This test was performed on 3 specimens from the same mix proportion.
For splitting tensile strength test, specimens were prepared by removing cores from
the sample (size of / 100 mm 200), as shown in Fig. 5. This test was conducted
by removing 3 cores from the sample in the upper, middle and lower position.
Air permeability test was performed by using specimens cut off the core. The core
of Fig. 5 was cut into four equal parts and made into size of / 100 mm 50 mm.
Figure 6 shows curing method and test flow. The curing is for 7 days. The spec-
imens in Fig. 5 were demolded after 3 days and the core as shown in the figure was
removed. The splitting tensile strength test was done before cutting.
Figure 7 shows the results of compressive strength test. Normal concrete was
stronger than preplaced concrete. Preplaced concrete had the same strength for all
aggregates. Therefore, in preplaced concrete, the kind of aggregate did not affect
compressive strength.
Figure 8 shows the results of splitting tensile strength test. Normal concrete and
preplaced concrete showed the same trend. The concrete using C-40 had the
strongest result for split tensile strength, and the concrete using ballast had the
weakest result.
After this test, the appearance of specimens looked like Fig. 9. Normal concrete
was destroyed in the paste part. On the other hand, preplaced concrete was broken
along the aggregate. Therefore, it was considered that the aggregate interface of
preplaced concrete is weak.
Figure 10 shows the results of air permeability test. For preplaced concrete, there
was a large difference in air permeability coefficient due to the core removal
30
Compressive strength(N/mm2)
25
20
15
10
0
C-40 RC-40 Ballast C-40 RC-40 Ballast
(N/mm2)
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
position. Normal concrete had the same value. In addition, normal concrete had
smaller value than preplaced concrete. Considering the result for splitting tensile
strength test, it is believed that the weak aggregate interface has pores connected
and air can easily pass through that parts.
0.0001
0.1
1
C-40 RC-40 Ballast C-40 RC-40 Ballast
Figure 12 shows the relationship between air permeability coefficient and com-
pressive strength. Preplaced concrete and normal concrete tended to be different.
C-40
Air permeability coefficient
RC-40
0.1
Ballast
(cm4/N s)
Preplaced
0.01 concrete
0.001
Normal concrete
0.0001
0 10 20 30
Compressive strength (N/mm2)
3.6 Carbonation
Figure 13 shows the result of accelerated carbonation test. In normal concrete, there
is no much difference in carbonation depth by the kind of aggregate. However, in
preplaced concrete, the difference was large depending on the kind of aggregate.
Preplaced concrete used ballast was the most carbonated. It was considered that the
air gaps were connected, and it was easier for preplaced concrete to carbonate.
Because the results were different depending on the aggregate, it was assumed that
the gaps at the aggregate interface were connected. Figure 12 shows relationship
between air permeability coefficient and carbonation depth. The low correlation
between the results of the air permeability test and the carbonation test are con-
sidered to be caused by the difference in pressure (Fig. 14).
0.1
Preplaced
concrete
Air permeability coefficient
0.01
(cm4/N s)
0.001
C-40
RC-40 Normal concrete
Ballast
0.0001
0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0
Compressive strength (N/mm2)
8
Carbonation depth (mm)
0
0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1
Air permeability coefficient(cm4/N s)
4 Conclusion
(1) Since preplaced concrete collapses at the part where the weak parts around the
aggregate are connected, the compressive strength does not depend on the type
of aggregate and has only a low strength.
(2) In preplaced concrete, aggregate interface is weak and air gaps on the of
aggregate interface are connected, and there is a big air passage.
(3) The large amount of aggregate and the closeness between the aggregates is the
cause of the difference between preplaced concrete and normal concrete.
Acknowledgements This research summarizes the results of Mr. Otsuka, Asahi, student from
Civil Engineering Department at Shibaura Institute of Technology.
Impacts of Global Warming
and Variable Airborne Chloride
Exposure on Concrete Structures
in Hokkaido, Japan
Abstract Global warming has become a threat to human societies due to its myriad
and complex impacts. Among these are sea level rise and climate change, which
carry significant implications for the life-cycle management of concrete infras-
tructure in coastal areas due to unforeseen changes in chloride exposure, which may
lead to uncertainty about structural safety. This may be attributed to the inability of
chloride diffusion prediction methods to account for temporal changes in exposure,
as conventional methods assume a constant surface chloride ion concentration.
However, it may be expected that, due to changes in airborne chloride exposure as a
result of global warming, the surface chloride concentration is not constant over
time. It is therefore necessary to account for its impacts in the life-cycle manage-
ment of concrete infrastructure by considering temporal changes in the exposure to
airborne chloride. In this study, a method is developed that facilitates the prediction
of chloride penetration into concrete under non-constant surface chloride concen-
trations, which are estimated from the airborne chloride exposure based on sea wind
ratio, wind speed, and distance from coastline. The impacts of global warming on
chloride diffusion are then estimated at a specified coastal location in Hokkaido,
Japan, over a 50-year period using forecasted climate data and simulated sea level
rise. Although the numerical simulation results did not find that the chloride con-
centration limit necessary to initiate corrosion will be reached in even the most
severe prediction scenario, variability in the surface chloride concentration may
reduce the safety factor against chloride-induced corrosion, as not considering the
effects of global warming may lead to underestimating the actual chloride exposure.
1 Introduction
The Standard Specifications for Concrete Structures (Design) of the Japan Society
of Civil Engineers (JSCE) provides Eq. 1 for calculating chloride diffusion in
concrete.
0:1c
C ¼ C0 1 erf pffiffiffiffiffi ð1Þ
2 Dt
where W/C: the water-cement ratio, by mass. The chloride ion diffusion coefficient
D also varies by the cement type and water-cement ratio. Equations 4 and 5 outline
the estimation of the diffusion coefficient for OPC concrete.
w
D ¼ cc Dk þ 1:5 D0 ð4Þ
l
W
log10 Dk ¼ 3:0 1:8 ð5Þ
C
where cc: concrete material coefficient; Dk: characteristic diffusion coefficient value
(cm2/year); w/l: ratio of crack width to length; and D0: a constant representing the
effect of cracks (generally set to 400 cm2/year).
1992 M. Henry and Y. Tojo
Dt t
Cxt þ 1 ¼ Cxt þ D Cx1 2Cxt þ Cxt þ 1 ð6Þ
Dx 2
where Cxt : chloride ion concentration (kg/m3) at depth x from the concrete surface
(mm) at t (years); and DxDt2 : a scaled value depending on the analysis conditions (set as
0.25). It is noted that C0t : surface chloride ion concentration (kg/m3) at year t. By
setting a new surface chloride content as the boundary condition at each analysis
time step t, Eq. 6 enables the calculation of the chloride diffusion under
non-constant chloride exposure conditions.
Equations 7 and 8 were adopted to link the effects of global warming with the
temporal change in the surface chloride concentration [1]. First, in Eq. 7, the
amount of airborne chlorides is shown as a function of sea wind ratio, wind speed,
and the distance from coastline. This equation was developed by statistical fitting of
historical data taken at measurement stations around Japan.
where Cair: airborne chloride content (100 mg/m2/day); r: sea wind ratio (ratio of
the time period during which the wind is blowing from the sea to the total time
during which the wind is blowing); u: average wind speed at a height of 10 m (m/s);
and d: distance from the coastline (m).
The surface chloride concentration can then be calculated from the airborne
chloride content as shown in Eq. 8. This relationship was obtained using actual
values of surface chloride content from concrete specimens measured simultane-
ously with the airborne chloride content, wind speed and direction, and distance
from coastline used to develop the Eq. 7.
C0 ¼ 0:988Cair
0:379
ð8Þ
where rt: sea wind ratio at year t; ut: average wind speed at year t; and dt: distance to
coastline at year t. Equation 9 can thus be used to calculate the boundary condition
at each time step t in Eq. 6.
The analytical flow is illustrated in Fig. 1. First, forecasts were made for sea wind
ratio, wind speed, and distance to coastline. The individual projections were then
synthesized into a set of prediction scenarios. Next, for each scenario, the surface
chloride concentrations were calculated at each time step, and the diffusion in concrete
was simulated using the surface concentrations and structural characteristics. This was
1994 M. Henry and Y. Tojo
repeated for the whole analysis period. Finally, the chloride concentration at the depth
of reinforcement at the end of the analysis period was compared with the limit to
initiate corrosion.
The conditions and methods for creating the forecast data are summarized in
Table 3. Historical data on wind speed and wind direction for coastal Ishikari from
1980 to 2018 were collected from the Japan Meteorological Agency. The data were
segmented into three-month periods considering the regional seasonal changes
(Dec.-Jan.-Feb., Mar.-Apr.-May, June-July-Aug., Sep.-Oct.-Nov.), and the
three-month averages were calculated for each year.
Forecasting was carried out by fitting a second order polynomial curve to the
historical data from 1980 to 2018 with a target value in 2070. As it is unknown how
the environment will change in the future, three target values were set in 2070
according to the maximum, average, and minimum values from the 1980 to 2018
period (Fig. 2(a)). Forecast values for each three-month period for the 2020 to 2070
analysis period were then calculated, and combining the values of all periods for
each year created continuous forecast data. These are shown in Fig. 2(b) and 2(c)
for sea wind ratio and wind speed, respectively.
The distance from the hypothetical bridge in Ishikari to the coastline was cal-
culated using a geographic information system for the 50-year analysis period
beginning in 2020. However, the coastline was recalculated each year based on
projected global sea level rise data reported by IPCC using two sea level rise
Prediction scenarios for 2020 to 2070 Surface chloride Chloride diffusion progress in Comparison with
based on projected environmental data concentrations for concrete from 2020 to 2070 concentration limit to
→ Wind speed u, sea wind ratio r, each time step t For t=1 → Equation 1 initiate corrosion
distance to coastline d → Equation 9 For t>1 → Equation 6 → Equation 2
6.0 0.7
Maximum Maximum
5.0 0.6
Average
Sea wind ratio
Wind speed (m/s)
0.5
4.0
Average 0.4
3.0
0.3
Minimum
2.0
0.2
1.0 Historical data Forecast data 0.1 Minimum
0.0 0.0
1980 2000 2020 2040 2060 2080 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 2070
Year Year
(a) Example of forecasting for MAM period (b) Sea wind ratio, r
7.0 482
Maximum
480 RCP2.6
Distance to coastline (m)
6.0
Average 478
Wind speed (m/s)
5.0
476
4.0
474
3.0
472
2.0 RCP8.5
470
1.0 Minimum 468
0.0 466
2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 2070 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 2070
Year Year
(c) Wind speed, r (d) Distance to coastline, d
Fig. 2 Example of forecasting method and forecast changes in the environmental conditions at the
target site from 2020 to 2070
1996 M. Henry and Y. Tojo
scenarios: RCP8.5 and RCP2.6. The forecast change in the distance to coastline is
shown in Fig. 2(d), with an initial distance of 479 m in 2020.
The forecast data for sea wind ratio, wind speed, and distance to coastline were
synthesized as shown in Fig. 3 to produce 18 prediction scenarios for the surface
chloride concentration. Each scenario reflects a different potential combination of
future environmental conditions that may lead to varying surface chloride con-
centrations. However, as there are no means to assess the likelihood of each
individual combination, prediction of chloride diffusion over the 50-year period was
carried out for all 18 scenarios following the flow in Fig. 1.
The predicted chloride ion concentrations at the reinforcement depth for the 18
prediction scenarios over the 50-year period are shown in Fig. 4. The scenarios in
the legend are arranged in descending order according to their values in 2070.
First, it can be seen that no scenario reaches the estimated Clim of 1.9 kg/m3;
indeed, no concentration even exceeds 1.0 kg/m3 by the end of the analysis period,
with the most severe projection scenario (max/max/8.5) only reaching 0.917 kg/m3
after 50 years. Although the increases in wind speed (3.57 m/s to 5.24 m/s) and sea
wind ratio (40.8% to 53.6%) in this scenario are relatively large compared to their
initial values, the distance from coastline only decreases by approximately 5 meters
due to the local geography and resolution of the geospatial data used in this
analysis. Furthermore, the initial distance from the coastline is approximately 500
meters, so the change in distance due to sea level rise is relatively small. As a result,
it is concluded that the impacts of global warming on concrete structures at the site
Distance to Prediction
Sea wind ratio Wind speed
coastline scenarios
1.0
max / max / 8.5
0.9 max / max / 2.6
Chlroide concentration C (t, 50), kg/m3
Fig. 4 Predicted change in chloride concentration at reinforcement depth over 50-year analysis
period (Scenario key: sea wind ratio/wind speed/sea level rise)
in Ishikari, Hokkaido, are not so severe due to the distance from the coastline and
the relatively small change in this distance due to sea level rise.
Although none of the projection scenarios resulted in chloride concentrations
that exceeded the limit necessary to induce reinforcement corrosion, considering the
analysis assumptions and limitations it cannot be concluded that the risk from
global warming is zero. First, all variables used the average values, so the chloride
concentration at the reinforcement depth also represents an average condition.
However, infrastructure management should take into consideration the risk that
may occur due to variability of the design, construction, and exposure conditions. In
this case, a probabilistic approach would be useful to consider the uncertainty of
various factors, such as the annual variability in sea wind ratio and wind speed. The
previous literature has demonstrated such an approach by utilizing Monte Carlo
simulation to probabilistically model chloride-induced reinforcement corrosion.
Applying a similar approach to the method utilized in this paper, together with
statistical distributions of the wind speed, sea wind ratio, distance from coastline,
and other influencing variables, could obtain a more accurate representation of the
risk to concrete structures associated with global warming.
1998 M. Henry and Y. Tojo
Another means for examining the impact of global warming on concrete structures,
although still deterministic, is to compare the chloride diffusion considering vari-
able conditions with the diffusion calculated by the conventional approach. Three
situations were compared: diffusion under variable surface chloride concentration
using the “max/max/8.5” prediction scenario; diffusion under constant surface
concentration calculated from the 2020 environmental data and Eq. 9; and diffusion
under constant surface concentration using the value specified for the Ishikari site
per the JSCE Standard Specification (Table 1). The two scenarios with constant
surface concentrations modeled diffusion using Eq. 1, while the scenario with
variable surface concentration used Eq. 6. The calculation results are shown in
Fig. 5.
It can be seen that the constant surface concentration calculated from the 2020
data is less than the value suggested by the Standard Specification; consequently,
the calculated chloride concentration at the reinforcement depth at the end of the
analysis period is higher when following the Standard Specification. The surface
chloride concentration calculated from the 2020 data is also less than the variable
surface concentration, which fluctuates seasonally but increases over time; subse-
quently, the chloride concentration at the reinforcement under the variable condi-
tion after 50 years is also greater than that under the constant condition.
As the Standard Specification assumes a comparatively extreme prediction of the
chloride diffusion, material and structural design following this result will be more
conservative. The ratio of the prediction result for the chloride concentration at the
reinforcement depth by the Standard Specification to that of other methods can
therefore be considered as a kind of safety factor for durability design. From the
preceding, the safety factors relative to the constant surface chloride concentration
based on the 2020 data and the variable surface chloride concentration were
2.5 1.6
Chloride conentration C(50,t), kg/m3
Surface chloride conc. C(0,t), kg/m3
0.0 0.0
2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 2070 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 2070
Year Year
(a) Surface concentration (b) Concentration at reinforcement depth
calculated as 1.74 and 1.52, respectively. It can thus be seen that the impact of
global warming - as represented by the variable surface chloride concentration -
reduces the safety factor by around 12.5% for the projection scenario demonstrated
here. Consequently, it can be concluded that not considering these impacts may
lead to overestimation of the safety factor for durability against chloride diffusion
and reinforcement corrosion.
5 Conclusions
This study aimed to improve the evaluation of the impacts of global warming on
concrete structures by developing a new analytical method that considers
non-constant surface chloride exposure caused by sea level rise and climate change.
This method was then demonstrated through the analysis of a hypothetical concrete
bridge in Hokkaido, Japan, using an ensemble of prediction scenarios based on
forecast environmental data and simulated coastline erosion. Although none of the
prediction scenarios resulted in chloride concentrations that could initiate rein-
forcement corrosion by the end of the 50-year analysis period, it was concluded that
not considering the impacts of global warming could lead to an overestimation of
the safety factor for durability against chloride diffusion. The proposed analytical
method may be improved by obtaining more accurate projections for the changes in
sea wind ratio, wind speed, and coastal distance; utilizing a scientific model to
calculate surface chloride concentration from the environmental data; including
other temporal changes, such as in material properties; and integrating these into a
comprehensive, probabilistic durability assessment framework.
References
1. Akiyama M, Frangopol DM, Suzuki M (2012) Integration of the effects of airborne chlorides
into reliability-based durability design of reinforced concrete structures in a marine
environment. Struct Infrastruct Eng 8(2):125–134
2. Bastidas-Arteaga E, Schoefs F, Stewart MG, Wang X (2013) Influence of global warming on
durability of corroding RC structures: a probabilistic approach. Eng Struct 51:259–266
3. Bastidas-Arteaga E, Stewart MG (2015) Damage risks and economic assessment of climate
change adaptation strategies for design of new concrete structure subject to chloride-induced
corrosion. Struct Saf 52:40–53
4. El Hassan J, Bressolette P, Chateauneuf A, El Tawil K (2010) Reliability-based assessment of
the effect of climatic conditions on the corrosion of RC structures subject to chloride ingress.
Eng Struct 32:3279–3287
2000 M. Henry and Y. Tojo
5. IPCC (2014) climate change 2014: synthesis report, contribution of working groups I, II and III
to the fifth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change [Core Writing
Team, R.K. Pachauri and L.A. Meyer (eds.)] IPCC: Geneva, Switzerland
6. Mase H, Tamada T, Yasuda T (2015) Analysis of climate change effects on seawall reliability,
Coastal Eng J 57(3): 1550010-1–1550010-18
7. Stewart MG, Wang X, Nguyen MN (2012) Climate change adaptation for corrosion control of
concrete infrastructure. Struct Saf 35:29–39
8. Yokota H (2017) Practical application of life-cycle management system for shore protection
facilities. Struct Infrastruct Eng 13:34–43
Sulfuric Acid Resistance of Cement
Pastes Containing Fly Ash
and Limestone Powder
Abstract This research studies the deterioration in sulfuric acid solution (pH 1) of
cement pastes incorporating fly ash and limestone powder. Two types of fly ashes,
with high CaO and low CaO contents, as well as limestone powder were used as
cement replacements in binary and ternary binder systems. The replacement per-
centages were 30% of total binder for binary binder paste with fly ashes and 10% of
total binder for binary binder paste with limestone powder. In the case of ternary
binder paste, the contents of OPC, fly ash, and limestone powder were 70%, 20%,
and 10% by weight of total binders, respectively. The cement paste specimens were
immersed in sulfuric acid solution for 420 days and their weight changes were
measured every week during the test period. The test results indicated that the use
of fly ashes significantly improves the resistance of cement pastes against sulfuric
acid attack while limestone powder can slightly decrease the deterioration of paste
in sulfuric acid solution when compared to OPC paste. In addition, it was found that
the low CaO fly ash is more effective for enhancing the sulfuric acid resistance of
cement pastes than the high CaO fly ash. Moreover, the combination of fly ash and
limestone powder in the ternary binder paste provides a satisfactory performance in
sulfuric acid resistance and is better than the OPC paste and the binary binder paste
S. Wanna S. Tangtermsirikul
School of Civil Engineering and Technology, Sirindhorn International Institute
of Technology (SIIT), Thammasat University, Pathum Thani, Thailand
e-mail: w.surachet24@gmail.com
S. Tangtermsirikul
e-mail: somnuk@siit.tu.ac.th
W. Saengsoy (&)
Construction and Maintenance Technology Research Center (CONTEC) School of Civil
Engineering and Technology, Sirindhorn International Institute of Technology (SIIT),
Thammasat University, Pathum Thani, Thailand
e-mail: warangkana@siit.tu.ac.th
P. Toochinda
School of Bio-Chemical Engineering and Technology, Sirindhorn International Institute of
Technology (SIIT), Thammasat University, Pathum Thani, Thailand
e-mail: pisanu@siit.tu.ac.th
with limestone powder, but is slightly less effective than the binary binder pastes
with fly ashes.
Keywords Sulfuric acid resistance Fly ash Limestone powder Weight loss
Cement paste
1 Introduction
2.1 Materials
The Portland cements used in this study were Ordinary Portland cement type 1,
Thailand which followed ASTM standards C150 and Thai Industrial Standard (TIS
15). In case of cement replacing materials, this study used two different types of fly
ash, one from Mae Moh electric power plant of the Electricity Generating Authority
of Thailand (EGAT) in Lampang province, northern of Thailand that produces fly
ash with high CaO content, and another one from BLCP Power Co., Ltd. in Rayong
province, eastern of Thailand that produces fly ash with low CaO content. All of the
fly ashes followed Thai Industrial Standard (TIS 2135–2545). Limestone powder
which was used in this experiment had a mean particle size of 8 micron and was
provided by Surint Omya Company, Thailand. Chemical compositions and physical
properties of each binder are shown in Table 1. The Mae Moh fly ash
(FAM) contained high calcium oxide (CaO) content of 13.63%, and so is classified
as TIS 2135-2545 class 2b. On the other hand, BLCP fly ash (FAR) contained low
calcium oxide (CaO) content of 2.32%, which is classified as TIS 2135-2545 class
2a. In case of physical properties, the Blaine fineness and particle size are
2,460 cm2/g and 17.74 microns for FAM and are 3,400 cm2/g and 15.91 microns
for FAR, respectively.
Table 1 Chemical compositions and physical properties of Portland cement type 1, limestone
powder, and fly ashes
Chemical Portland cement Limestone Fly ash
composition type1 (C) powder (LP) Mae Moh BLCP
(% by weight) (FAM) (FAR)
SiO2 19.70 0.46 40.93 61.91
Al2O3 5.19 0.06 22.42 20.35
Fe2O3 3.34 0.03 13.64 5.20
CaO 64.80 55.25 13.63 2.32
MgO 1.20 0.37 2.93 1.35
Na2O 0.16 0.01 0.89 0.79
K2O 0.44 0.01 2.39 1.36
SO3 2.54 0.01 1.93 0.28
Free lime 0.87 – 0.22 0.19
LOI 2.10 43.79 0.46 5.68
Specific gravity 3.13 2.70 2.26 2.16
Blaine fineness 3,660 7,500 2,460 3,400
(cm2/g)
Mean diameter 15.41 8.00 17.74 15.91
(µm)
2004 S. Wanna et al.
There were 12 different mixtures for the experiment. The cement paste mixtures
were designed with w/b ratios of 0.25 and 0.40. The percentages of cement
replacing materials (CRMs) in binary binders were 30% for each type of fly ash
(FAM or FAR) and was 10% for limestone powder. In ternary binder case, fly ash
and limestone powder were used to replace cement at 20% and 10% of total binder,
respectively. The mix proportions are given in Table 2. All of the mixtures were
cast to obtain cube specimens (50 50 50 mm.) following ASTM standard
C109. Each test specimen was removed from the mold one day after casting, then
cured in lime water for 28 days before exposed to sulfuric acid solutions with a pH
of 1.
To simulate acidic environment, the acid solution was prepared by using sulfuric
acid (95–97%, EMSURE of Merck) dissolved in reverse osmosis water to obtain a
solution with a pH of 1. The pH of sulfuric acid solutions was controlled at 1
throughout the test period.
After curing in lime water for 28 days, each sample was measured to obtain initial
weight before immersing the cement samples in the sulfuric acid solution. The
cement samples were brought out to record the weight change every week. Before
weighting, the cement samples were washed by water and brushed with a soft brush
to eliminate the unsounds and dried by clean towel. After that, weights of the
specimens were measured. The weight change can be calculated as shown in Eq. 1.
The weight loss of each cement paste specimen was calculated from the average
weight loss of three specimens.
where; wt = weight of the paste sample after immersion in the sulfuric acid solution
(g).
wi = weight of the paste sample before immersion in the sulfuric acid solution
(g).
The surface structure of each cement paste sample was analyzed to find reaction
products after having been immersed in the sulfuric acid solution for 30 days. The
specimens were washed with water, brushed, dried, and then left at room temper-
ature for 24 h. After that, the powders that were scraped from the specimen surface
were dried at 60°C in a desiccator for 5 h to eliminate moisture. The dried speci-
mens were ground to a particle size range of 45–75 lm by a planetary ball mill. The
ground sample was mixed with corundum as an internal standard with a ground
powder to corundum ratio of 9:1 by weight. The mixed samples were characterized
using XRD technique (XRD, Bruker D4 Endeavor with Cu ka1 radiation at 35 kV
and 45 mA, 5° to 70° 2 theta, 0.02° step size, and 0.2 s). EVA software was used to
identify the compounds in the sample, and Rietveld analysis of the XRD pattern of
each sample was used to quantify the amount of each compound.
2006 S. Wanna et al.
Sulfuric acid resistance of cement pates containing fly ash and limestone powder of
this research was studied by comparing weight loss of samples immersed in sulfuric
acid solution for 420 days.
Figures 1a and 1b show the weight loss of binary binder pastes with w/b of 0.25
and 0.40, respectively, exposed to the sulfuric acid solution for 420 days. The
results show similar trend that both fly ashes, FAM and FAR, can improve the
resistance to sulfuric acid attack of the paste specimens. The results of the weight
loss for paste specimens show small differences up to the first 30 days. However,
clear differences were observed after that. The control paste specimen, C100,
showed the highest weight loss. Moreover, the control specimens, C100, with a w/b
of 0.25 were completely disintegrated at 300 days of immersion. The next was
C90LP10 with a w/b of 0.25 which was completely disintegrated at 330 days of
immersion. In contrast, the resistance to sulfuric acid attack was improved when fly
ashes were used. The mix C70FAR30 showed the lowest weight loss which was
followed by the mix C70FAM30. In case of different type of fly ash, fly ash with
low CaO (FAR) shows better performance than fly ash with high CaO (FAM).
Moreover, the weight loss of specimens with a w/b of 0.40 is lower than that of the
specimens with a w/b of 0.25. The specimens with a lower w/b ratio showed higher
degradation than those with a higher w/b ratio. This was reported to be due to the
larger pore sizes and the higher number of pores in the paste with a higher water to
C100 w/b 0.25 C90LP10 w/b 0.25 C100 w/b 0.40 C90LP10 w/b 0.40
C70FAM30 w/b 0.25 C70FAR30 w/b 0.25 C70FAM30 w/b 0.40 C70FAR30 w/b 0.40
40
40
w/b of 0.25 20 w/b of 0.40
20
Wwight Change (%)
Weight Change (%)
0
0
-20 -20
-40 -40
-60 -60
-80 -80
-100 -100
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420
Age (days) Age (days)
Fig. 1 Weight loss of binary binder pastes immersed in sulfuric acid solution pH of 1 for
420 days
Sulfuric Acid Resistance of Cement Pastes Containing Fly Ash … 2007
Figures 2a and 2b show weight loss comparison of binary binder pastes and ternary
binder paste with FAM. C100 still shows highest weight loss, followed by
C90LP10. It should be noted that the two mixtures with FAM, both binary and
ternary (C70FAM30 and C70FAM20LP10), show very similar weight loss, which
is lower than that of the C100 and C90LP10.
Figures 3a and 3b show weight loss comparison of binary binder pastes and
ternary binder paste with FAR. The mixture C100 still shows highest weight loss,
followed by C90LP10. In case of w/b of 0.25, the two mixtures with FAR, both
binary and ternary (C70FAR30 and C70FAR20LP10), show small differences of
weight loss. However, for w/b of 0.40, C70FAR30 shows slightly better perfor-
mance than C70FAR20LP10.
These results can be explained that the use of fly ash can improve the resistance
of cement pastes to sulfuric acid attack because of the ability of fly ash to reduce the
amount of calcium hydroxide, which over time is vulnerable to sulfuric acid attack.
Degradation by sulfuric acid attack begins when the sulfate ions react with calcium
ions to mainly form gypsum, causing expansion. The mechanism of sulfuric acid
attack in paste specimens is shown by the following chemical reactions [9].
C100 w/b 0.25 C90LP10 w/b 0.25 C100 w/b 0.40 C90LP10 w/b 0.40
C70FAM30 w/b 0.25 C70FAM20LP10 w/b 0.25 C70FAM30 w/b 0.40 C70FAM20LP10 w/b 0.40
40 40
20 w/b of 0.25 20 w/b of 0.40
Weight Change (%)
Weight Change (%)
0 0
-20 -20
-40 -40
-60 -60
-80 -80
-100 -100
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420
Age (days) Age (days)
(a) w/b of 0.25 (b) w/b of 0.40
Fig. 2 Weight loss of binary binder pastes compared with ternary binder pastes (FAM system)
2008 S. Wanna et al.
C100 w/b 0.25 C90LP10 w/b 0.25 C100 w/b 0.40 C90LP10 w/b 0.40
C70FAR20LP10 w/b 0.25 C70FAR30 w/b 0.25 C70FAR20LP10 w/b 0.40 C70FAR30 w/b 0.40
40
40
20 w/b of 0.25 w/b of 0.40
20
Weight Change (%)
-80 -80
-100
-100 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 390 420
Age (days) Age (days)
Fig. 3 Weight loss of binary binder pastes compared with ternary binder pastes (FAR system)
From the above mechanism, fly ash can decrease the weight loss of cement paste
specimens in sulfuric acid solution by decreasing the amount of calcium hydroxide.
However, in addition to the benefits of fly ash to decrease calcium hydroxide
(CH) amount, it also produces a stronger calcium silicate structure against the acid
attack. This was confirmed by a previous research which reported that C-S-H
produced by pozzolanic reactions of SCMs has a different structure and calcium to
silicate ratio (CaO/SiO2 of below 1.0) from that of the conventional C-S-H (CaO/
SiO2 of about 3.0) produced by OPC hydration [2].
The calcium to silicate ratio of the mixture (CaO/SiO2) was calculated using Eq. 5.
CaO ðCaOc Wc Þ þ CaOf Wf
¼ ð5Þ
SiO2 ðSiO2c Wc Þ þ SiO2f Wf
where CaOc and CaOf are percentages of CaO in the cement and fly ash, respec-
tively (%). SiO2c and SiO2f are percentages of SiO2 in the cement and fly ash,
respectively (%). Wc and Wf are unit weight of cement and fly ash in the mixture,
respectively (kg/m3).
The relationship between the CaO/SiO2 ratio, which was calculated from the
chemical composition of all binders in the tested mixtures, and the weight loss after
240 days of immersion, is shown in Fig. 4a and Fig. 4b. Though the CaO/SiO2
ratio computed from Eq. 5 is different from the CaO/SiO2 ratio of the C-S-H, they
are correlated. It was observed that the incorporation of FAR and FAM in the pastes
results in lower CaO/SiO2 ratios when compared to the ratio of the control mixture.
The CaO/SiO2 ratio of the C100 and C90LP10 mixture are 3.29. It is noted here that
the contribution of limestone powder in the CaO/SiO2 ratio was still not considered
here. The fly ash replacement decreases the CaO/SiO2 ratio to 1.42 for
Sulfuric Acid Resistance of Cement Pastes Containing Fly Ash … 2009
C70FAMR30, 1.75 for C70FAR20LP10, 1.90 for C70FAM30 and 2.19 for
C70FAM20LP10.
Regarding CaO/SiO2 ratios, Fig. 4 shows that a mix with a lower CaO/SiO2 ratio
has a lower weight loss than that with a higher CaO/SiO2 ratio. For the mixtures
with fly ashes, fly ashes improve the bonding capacity of the C-S-H structure in the
long term. Moreover, low calcium oxide (CaO) and high silica dioxide (SiO2)
contents in fly ashes can contribute to a higher acid resistance of paste specimens as
silica is a strong compound which is hard to deteriorate in acid and sulfate solution
attack [8].
Figures 5a and 5b show that C100 and C90LP10 specimens disintegrate into
clay-like particles. For fly ash replaced specimens, the deterioration of the paste
surface was in the form of a surface hard layer as shown in Figs. 5c and 5d. To
analyze the actual products of reactions of the cement paste with the sulfuric acid,
the unsound portions (both the clay-like material and the hard layer on the surfaces
of the specimens in Fig. 5) were removed. After that, the specimen surfaces were
scraped to obtained samples for XRD analysis. A quantitative analysis to obtain the
amount of gypsum on the surface of paste specimens with a w/b of 0.25 is shown in
Fig. 6. The figure shows that the amount of gypsum of specimens with C70FAR30
is the lowest, 58.67%, due to cement dilution and pozzolanic reaction effects,
followed by C70FAM30, 67.12%. Next is the group of ternary binder pastes,
67.79% for C70FAR20LP10 and 72.34% for C70FAM20LP10. The amounts of
gypsum of C90LP10 and C100 are 75.12% and 75.79%, respectively. The char-
acteristics of the deterioration of paste specimens due to sulfuric acid attack was
2010 S. Wanna et al.
100
75.79 75.12 72.34
80 67.12 67.79
58.67
60
40
20
0
C100 C90LP10 C70FAM30 C70FAR30 C70FAM20LP10 C70FAR20LP10
Fig. 6 Amount of gypsum of paste specimens after immersed in sulfuric acid solution for 30 days
found to correlate well with CaO/SiO2 ratios, as shown in Fig. 4. It was found that
the group of low CaO/SiO2 ratios show the deterioration in form of a hard layer. On
the other hand, the group of high CaO/SiO2 ratios shows the deterioration in form
of clay-like material.
4 Conclusions
From the above discussion, the tested low CaO fly ash (FAR) is more effective for
enhancing the sulfuric acid resistance of the pastes than the high CaO fly ash
(FAM), mainly due to three reasons. First, low CaO fly ash mixtures have a lower
Ca(OH)2 content than the high CaO fly ash mixtures. Second, the pozzolanic
reaction of low CaO fly ash produces C-S-H with a lower CaO/SiO2 ratio than high
CaO fly ash does. Third, less gypsum is produced when the mixtures incorporate
low CaO fly ash. The characteristics of the deterioration of specimen in sulfuric acid
solution depend on CaO/SiO2 ratios that low CaO/SiO2 ratios show the deterio-
ration in form of a hard layer, while high CaO/SiO2 ratios shows the deterioration in
form of clay like material.
Sulfuric Acid Resistance of Cement Pastes Containing Fly Ash … 2011
Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge the research support from the
National Research Council of Thailand and the Center of Excellence in Material Science
Construction and Maintenance Technology, Thammasat University.
References
1. Aydın S, Yazıcı H, Yiğiter H, Baradan B (2007) Sulfuric acid resistance of high-volume fly ash
concrete. Build Environ 42(2):717–721
2. Bassuoni MT, Nehdi ML (2007) Resistance of self-consolidating concrete to sulfuric acid
attack with consecutive pH reduction. Cem Concr Res 37(7):1070–1084
3. Cyr M (2013) Influence of supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) on concrete
durability. In: Pacheco-Torgal F, Jalali S, Labrincha J, John VM (eds) Eco-efficient concrete.
Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, pp 153–197
4. Fattuhi NI, Hughes BP (1988) The performance of cement paste and concrete subjected to
sulphuric acid attack. Cem Concr Res 18(4):545–553
5. Herisson J, Van Hullebusch ED, Moletta-Denat M, Taquet P, Chaussadent T (2013) Toward an
accelerated biodeterioration test to understand the behavior of Portland and calcium aluminate
cementitious materials in sewer networks. Int Biodeterior Biodegradation 84:236–243
6. Kaewmanee K, Tangtermsirikul S (2014) Properties of binder systems containing cement, fly
ash and limestone powder. Songklanakarin J Sci Technol 36(5):569–576
7. Kawai K, Yamaji S, Shinmi T April 2005 Concrete deterioration caused by sulfuric acid attack.
In: International Conference on Durability of Building Materials and Components, pp 17–20
8. Kunther W, Lothenbach B, Skibsted J (2015) Influence of the Ca/Si ratio of the C-S–H phase
on the interaction with sulfate ions and its impact on the ettringite crystallization pressure. Cem
Concr Res 69:37–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cemconres.2014.12.002
9. Monteny J, Vincke E, Beeldens A, De Belie N, Taerwe L, Van Gemert D, Verstraete W (2000)
Chemical, microbiological and in situ test method for biogenic sulfuric acid corrosion of
concrete. Cem Concr Res 30(4):623–634
Influence of PVA and PP Fibres
at Different Volume Fractions
on Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed
Concrete
Abstract This research primarily aims to investigate the effect of polyvinyl alcohol
(PVA) and polypropylene (PP) fibres at different volume fractions of 0.25, 0.5, 0.75
and 1% on mechanical properties of high-performance printing concrete. For
concrete without fibres, there is no noticeable discrepancy in the compressive
strengths between printed and cast specimens, which are around 90 MPa. In terms
of bending resistance, the flexural strength in direction Z (perpendicular to printing
direction) is 46% and 15% higher than that in direction X (parallel to printing
direction) and that of cast specimen, respectively. For fibre-reinforced concrete,
PVA and PP fibres at different contents lead to no positive impact on both com-
pressive and flexural strengths although specimens with PP fibres show less brittle
failure in these tests. Based on the experimental investigation, reinforcing printed
concrete with PVA and PP fibres with the length of 6 mm might not be recom-
mended. X-ray micro-computed tomography (Micro-CT) measurement is per-
formed for visualization of porosity.
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Programme
fibres and eight mixtures with PP and PVA fibres at different volumetric fractions
(0.25, 0.5, 0.75 and 1%).
Mixing procedure, as displayed in Table 2, is implemented by mixing all dry
powder materials in 5 min. After that two-third of water blended with superplas-
ticizer and retarder is poured into the pre-mixed materials, which are mixed for
12 min until the wet mix is consistent. Finally, fibres are added, and the mixing
process lasts for extra 3 min to distribute fibres evenly.
Dimensions and weights of cast and printed cubic samples are measured for cal-
culating density, which is defined as the weight per unit volume. The density of
2018 L. Pham et al.
each mix is averaged at least 6 samples out and densities of cast and printed
concrete are average values of all mixes with and without fibres.
Cast and printed cubic samples are tested for compressive strengths with a
loading rate of 900 N/s according to ASTM C109 by using a 1000 kN MTS
machine. Here, printed specimens are loaded into three different directions, as
defined in Fig. 3.
For flexural strengths, cast and printed prisms are tested under a loading rate of
20 N/s in accordance with ASTM C348. Two loading directions, namely direction
Z (D1) and direction X (D3), as illustrated in Fig. 3, are applied on printed
specimens.
X-ray micro-computed tomography testing, known as non-destructive detection
method, is carried out to visualize pores in the sample. Scanning parameters are
selected with a tube voltage of 175 kV, a tube current of 110 lm, a resolution of
40 lm. The sample is scanned for 50 min to collect 1500 radiography images.
3.1 Density
The density of printed specimens is 2300 kg/m3, which is slightly lower than the
value of 2350 kg/m3 for that of cast samples.
Fig. 4 Compressive
strengths of cast and printed
specimens without fibres
Fig. 5 Compressive strengths of all printed and cast specimens at different fibre contents: a PVA
fibres and b PP fibres
counterparts with PP fibres (except for 0.75% fibres in direction Y), as shown in
Fig. 6. On the contrary, cast and printed specimens with 1% by volume of PP fibres
demonstrate considerably higher compressive strengths than their PVA counterparts
(except for printed specimen in direction X).
2020 L. Pham et al.
Fig. 6 Comparison of compressive strengths of specimens with PVA and PP fibres: a Cast
specimens; b Printed specimens in direction Z; c Printed specimens in direction X; d Printed
specimens in direction Y
The flexural strength of cast specimens without fibres is 11 MPa relative to 7 MPa
and 13 MPa of its printed counterparts in direction X and Z, respectively
(Fig. 7), which agree with test results published by Le et al. [7] except for the
strength in direction Z. It can be seen in Fig. 8a that the addition of PVA fibres at
different volume fractions leads to no positive effect on the flexural strengths on
both cast and printed specimens.
Adding PP fibres at different contents results in almost no change in the flexural
strength in cast specimens, which is around 11 MPa, as exhibited in Fig. 8. There is
a slight difference in the flexural strengths of printed specimens with PP fibre at
0.25%, 0.5% and 0.75% tested in direction X, which are 28% higher than those of
samples without fibres. Meanwhile, 1% by volume of PP fibres increases the
flexural strength in this direction by 14%. In general, the flexural strengths in
direction X are lower than those in direction Z and those of cast specimens. The
result is understandable because the weakness at the interface between layers is
attributed to the layer-by-layer printing process [3, 8, 9]. Printed specimens with PP
fibres in direction Z have higher flexural strengths than their cast counterparts.
Only 0.5% by volume of PP fibres leads to an increase in the flexural strength in
direction Z compared to its counterpart without fibres.
Figures 9 and 10 show that the flexural strengths of both cast and printed
specimens adding PP fibres are higher than those with PVA fibres in all directions
at any fibre content except for in the case of 1% fibre content (Fig. 7).
Fig. 8 Flexural strengths of all printed and cast specimens at different fibre contents: a PVA fibres
and b PP fibres
2022 L. Pham et al.
Fig. 9 Comparison of
flexural strengths of cast
specimens with PVA and PP
fibres
Fig. 10 Comparison of flexural strengths of printed specimens with PVA and PP fibres: a Printed
specimens in direction Z; b Printed specimens in direction X
Influence of PVA and PP Fibres at Different Volume Fractions … 2023
Fig. 11 Pore distribution of printed sample without fibres. 2D images presenting all pores and 3D
images presenting pores with the diameter above 2 mm
4 Conclusions
The compressive strengths of printed samples without fibres are relatively similar to
their cast counterpart. As anticipated, printed specimens without fibres tested in
direction Z have higher flexural strengths than cast specimens and printed speci-
mens in direction X. The addition of PVA and PP fibres have some positive impacts
on the compressive and flexural strengths of printed specimens, but more negative
influences are found. Specimens with PP fibres show less catastrophic failure in
comparison with specimens with PVA fibres. Based on these experimental results,
using PVA and PP fibres with 6 mm length for reinforcing high-performance
printing concrete needs to be reconsidered. The research contributes to the under-
standing of the influence of PVA and PP fibres on the material properties of printed
objects.
2024 L. Pham et al.
References
1. Hopkinson N, Gao Y, McAfee DJ (2006) Design for environment analyses applied to rapid
manufacturing. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part D J Automobile Eng 220:1363–1372
2. Khoshnevis B (2004) Automated construction by contour crafting—related robotics and
information technologies. Autom Constr 13:5–19
3. Le TT et al (2012) Hardened properties of high-performance printing concrete. Cem Concr Res
42:558–566
4. Kazemian A, Yuan X, Cochran E, Khoshnevis B (2017) Cementitious materials for
construction-scale 3D printing: Laboratory testing of fresh printing mixture. Constr Build
Mate 145:639–647
5. Thong CC, Teo DCL, Ng CK (2016) Application of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) in cement-based
composite materials: A review of its engineering properties and microstructure behaviour.
Construction and Building Materials 107:172–180
6. Nili M, Afroughsabet V (2010) The effects of silica fume and polypropylene fibers on the
impact resistance and mechanical properties of concrete. Constr Build Mater 24:927–933
7. Wu Z, Shi C, He W, Wang D (2017) Static and dynamic compressive properties of ultra-high
performance concrete (UHPC) with hybrid steel fiber reinforcements. Cem Concr Compos
79:148–157
8. Feng P, Meng X, Chen J-F, Ye L (2015) Mechanical properties of structures 3D printed with
cementitious powders. Constr Build Mater 93:486–497
9. Nerella VN, Hempel S, Mechtcherine V (2019) Effects of layer-interface properties on
mechanical performance of concrete elements produced by extrusion-based 3D-printing. Const
Build Mater 205:586–601
Fatigue Behavior of Air-Entrained High
Strength Concrete with Blast Furnace
Slag Fine Aggregates Under Freezing
and Thawing
Keywords Fatigue Freeze-thaw Air-entrainment High strength concrete
Blast furnace slag sand
M. A. Farooq (&)
Graduate School of Engineering, Hokkaido University, Sapporo 060-8628, Japan
e-mail: engr.mabf@yahoo.com
Y. Sato
Faculty of Science and Engineering, Waseda University, Tokyo 169-8555, Japan
e-mail: y.sato@waseda.jp
K. Niitani
Research Institute, Oriental Shiraishi Corporation, Moka 321-4367, Japan
e-mail: k.niitani@orsc.co.jp
H. Yokota
Faculty of Engineering, Hokkaido University, Sapporo 060-8628, Japan
e-mail: yokota@eng.hokudai.ac.jp
1 Introduction
Fatigue behavior of high strength concrete has gained attention owing to its
increasing use in bridge and off-shore structures [4] and because of slender sections
obtained from high strength concrete [16]. There has been much progress in the
development of high strength and durable concrete by using admixtures, steel fibers
and industrial wastes like silica fume and blast furnace slag (BFS). It has been
found that the frost resistance of concrete can be improved by incorporating ground
granulated BFS (GGBFS) as percentage of binder and BFS sand as full amount of
fine aggregates [2]. Farooq et al. [5] found overall improved monotonic and fatigue
behavior of mortar with BFS fine aggregates compared to ordinary mortar in air.
However, the fatigue behavior of high strength concrete with BFS fine aggregates is
not investigated yet and moreover, understanding the fatigue behavior of high
strength plain concrete (HSPC) is still a main concern due to its brittle nature
compared to normal concrete and owing to conflicting information in the literature,
whether the compressive fatigue strength of concrete reduces [12], Tue and Mucha
[17], remains same [16], Do et al. [4], Hordijk et al. [10], Oneschkow [14] or
increases with the increase in compressive strength (f′c).
Moreover, the usage of air-entrainment (AE) concrete in reinforced concrete
(RC) structures becomes inevitable in cold regions, where these structures are
subjected to mechanical actions combined with freezing and thawing. It is well
understood that the mechanical properties of concrete become inferior with the
increase in porosity and air entrainment. However, Antrim [1] reported that overall
fatigue behavior of AE normal concrete is not significantly different than non-AE
normal concrete, however, at lower value of maximum stress levels (Smax), the
fatigue life (Nf) of AE concrete is comparatively longer than non-AE concrete,
while it is shorter at higher Smax. In addition, limited studies have focused on the
investigation of fatigue behavior of frost-damaged concrete. Hasan [9] reported the
reduction in fatigue life of non-AE normal concrete with the increase in frost
damage. However, detailed studies related to AE high strength concrete under
combined action of freeze-thaw and fatigue are nearly non-existent. Ayano et al. [2]
reported the improved fatigue performance of frost-damaged high strength concrete
with BFS fine aggregates at lower Smax in water compared to ordinary concrete.
Nevertheless, no report on fatigue behavior of intact and frost-damaged AE high
strength concrete with BFS fine aggregates in compression in air at higher Smax is
available.
Therefore, the experimental investigation is carried out to study the fatigue
behavior of AE high strength concrete with BFS fine aggregates subjected to dif-
ferent number of freeze-thaw cycles in comparison with AE normal concrete of high
strength. The Smax-Nf relationship of AE high strength concretes with BFS sand and
crushed sand are compared to those of developed for non-AE HSPC using the data
extracted from literature and for normal concrete proposed by different codes.
Fatigue Behavior of Air-Entrained High Strength Concrete … 2027
2 Experimental Outline
The cylindrical specimens of (100Ф 200) mm from two series of concrete i.e. air
entrained blast furnace slag concrete (AEBFS) and air entrained high strength
normal (AEHSN) concrete are used in this study, the mix proportions of which are
presented in Table 1. High early strength Portland cement with density and Blaine
fineness of 3.13 g/cm3 and 4490 cm2/g respectively, is used as binder. Blast fur-
nace slag (BFS) sand is incorporated in AEBFS concrete specimens, whereas
crushed sand is used in AEHSN concrete, with the particle size of 0.15 to 5 mm.
After demoulding, the specimens were cured in water for 28 days at room tem-
perature. Later, the specimens were stored in controlled temperature at 20 °C until
the start of freeze-thaw test.
ASTM C-666 type-A test procedure was adopted to carry out the freeze-thaw test in
3% NaCl solution at the age of 51=2 months of concrete specimens in freeze-thaw
chamber. Each freeze-thaw cycle (FTC) lasted for 8-h with temperature change
between −25 °C and +20 °C. Before freeze-thaw test, the specimens were sub-
merged in 3% NaCl solution for proper saturation. Then, the specimens were put
inside the rubber tubes filled with 3% NaCl solution up to 25 mm above the
concrete specimens. The rubber tubes were then placed in the thermal exchange
fluid of the freeze-thaw chamber. The temperature variations during the freeze-thaw
test was recorded using the thermocouples embedded at the center, placed on
surface of specimens in addition to the thermal exchange fluid of the chamber.
Moreover, the strain measurement during freeze-thaw test was made by mold
gauges embedded in the concrete specimens and foil gauges of 70 mm attached to
the surface of specimen. The relative dynamic modulus of elasticity (RDME) was
To determine the uniaxial compressive strength ðfc0 Þ, the static tests were performed
on cylindrical specimens of each concrete for 0, 250 and 400 FTC at the age of
around 1-year. The static tests were performed in accordance with ASTM C39/39M
at a loading rate of 0.01 mm/s.
The fatigue tests in compression for intact and frost-damaged specimens of each
concrete were carried out using servo hydraulic machine just after static tests. The
maximum stress levels of 70% and 80% of f′c were adopted and the minimums
stress level of 5% of ðfc0 Þ was maintained. The load was applied using the sinusoidal
wave with a constant amplitude as shown in Fig. 1(a). Minimal effect of loading
frequency on the fatigue strength of concrete was reported within the range of 1–
15 Hz for Smax of 75% of ðfc0 Þ [11]. In this study, the loading frequency of
3.5 Hz was opted considering the likelihood of instability of loading arrangement.
Two strain gauges of 60 mm gauge length were mounted on the specimens using
adhesive in the axial direction. For recording strains, high speed measuring system
with 100 Hz sampling frequency was used. Loading cycles were applied until the
failure of specimens or 2 million cycles (i.e. 63=5 days) whichever reached earlier.
The diagram of loading arrangement is shown in Fig. 1(b).
Hinge
Concrete Specimen
Strain gauges
f = 3.5Hz '
σmin = 0.05f c Steel Basement
300 300.285 300.571
Time (sec)
Figure 2(a) represents the histories of input temperature and measured at the center
and surface of specimens and in the thermal exchange fluid of freeze-thaw chamber
during 225th FTC. The temperature of thermal exchange fluid and on the surface of
specimen are close to input temperature, however, the temperature at the center of
specimens of both types of concrete was bit behind the input temperature. The
similar tendency of temperature change was observed during the whole freeze-thaw
test.
The RDME and mass change of specimens of AEBFS and AEHSN concrete
corresponding to FTC number are shown in Fig. 2(b) along with for AE normal
strength normal (AENSN) concrete from past study [6]. No significant reduction in
RDME was found during the whole freeze-thaw test for AEBFS and AEHSN
concrete, which is because the AE voids in the concrete specimens provided the
space to compensate the freezing of the pore water preventing the micro-cracking
inside the specimens, while the RDME of AENSN concrete reduced slightly.
However, the amount of scaled mass for AENSN concrete is more than that of
AEBFS and AEHSN concrete, which might be because of lower f′c of AENSN
concrete. The equivalent plastic strain development due to FTC (Ep,ftc) for each
concrete is calculated from plastic strain in axial and lateral direction by
elasto-plastic and fracture (EPF) model [13] as shown in Fig. 2(c) along with for
AENSN concrete [6], Hasan [9]. The rate of increment of FTC equivalent plastic
strain with the increase in FTC number is almost similar and very small for AEBFS
and AEHSN concrete, which is due to provision of AE voids and high strength
concrete. The similar tendency of Ep,ftc increment was observed in the previous
studies for AENSN concrete with a slightly higher rate.
20 0.5
FTC Eq. Plastic Strain, Ep,ftc
Specimen's Center
RDME (%)
10 AEBFS
12 AENSN (Hasan 2003)
60 AEHSN 0.3
0 AENSN (Farooq et al. 2018)
1792 1794 1796 1798 1800 40 8 0.2
-10 Time (hrs) Mass loss
20 4 0.1
-20 Input
0 0 0.0
-30 0 100 200 300 400 0 100 200 300 400
FTC Number FTC Number
(a) Temperature histories (b) RDME change and mass (c) Equivalent plastic strain
(225th FTC) loss development due to FTC
The Wöhler curves, generally known as Smax-Nf relationships, for AEBFS and
AEHSN concrete for 0, 250 and 400 FTC are shown in Fig. 4. No significant
difference in fatigue life of each concrete for higher number of FTC is found,
because of very low FTC induced plastic strain and minimal change in monotonic
properties of each concrete. Therefore, the experimental data for 0-FTC is used for
regression, for which the equations are given by Eqs. (1) and (2) for AEBFS and
AEHSN concrete respectively.
50
0
80
300
70 40
60
Average ε'co (μ)
fc' (MPa)
Ec0 (GPa)
50 30
0
200
40
20
30
20
0
10 AENSN (Farooq et al. 2018) AENSN (Farooq et al. 2018) AENSN (Farooq et al. 2018)
0 AENSN (Hasan 2003) 0 AENSN (Hasan 2003) AENSN (Hasan 2003)
0 100 200 300 400
0
For all frost-damage levels, the overall fatigue life of AEBFS concrete is longer
than that of AEHSN concrete. The similar tendency of longer fatigue life for BFS
mortar compared to high strength ordinary mortar was observed by authors [5].
This difference in fatigue life can be due to weaker interfacial transition zone
(ITZ) of AEHSN concrete between matrix and aggregates compared to AEBFS
concrete. It has been reported that with usage of GGBFS, the ITZ is improved due
to additional CSH gel in the matrix and matrix-aggregate ITZ because of pozzolanic
reaction of GGBFS grains [8] resulting in better crack resistance and fatigue per-
formance of concrete with slag. Moreover, Onoue [15] reported that energy con-
sumed to form new microcracks in concrete with granulated BFS sand under cyclic
loading is less compared to normal concrete, indicating lower fatigue damage and
higher fatigue durability of concrete with BFS sand.
At 70% Smax, some specimens of AEHSN concrete and all the tested specimens
of AEBFS concrete didn’t fail until 2 million cycles. The static test was performed
on the “run-out” fatigue test specimens and the increase in f′c within the range of 0
to 5% was observed compared to f′c of specimens without fatigue loading. This
might be because of stiffening of the specimens owing to increase in temperature
from cyclic loading [3].
The comparison between data points of Nf at different Smax for non-AE HSPC and
normal concrete extracted from literature is shown in Fig. 5 along with those of
AEBFS and AEHSN concrete for 0-FTC. The Smax-Nf relationship for non-AE
HSPC is obtained using the regression of extracted data points for Smin of 5% and
for various frequencies and compressive strengths. The Smax-Nf relationships for
normal concrete calculated by equations for CEB/FIP MC1990, Eurocode 2, fib
MC 2010, JSCE specification 2007 are also drawn along with proposed by Hsu
(1981). CEB/FIP MC 1990 underestimates the fatigue life of non-AE HSPC.
However, the regression of data points for non-AE HSPC having strength class
( C45: fib MC 2010) show that overall fatigue performance of non-AE HSPC is
2032 M. A. Farooq et al.
The stress-strain loops recorded throughout the fatigue tests were analyzed to get the
stiffness reduction and cycle-strain curves. The cycle-strain curve represents the
relationship of plastic strain and total axial strain development with the increase in
loading cycles. The total or maximum strain ðe0max Þ is the value of strain of
stress-strain loop at Smax for respective loading cycle, and the plastic strain ðe0p Þ is
determined by extending the line joining the highest point of strain at Smax and lowest
point of strain at Smin towards the horizontal axis, and the slope of this line gives the
stiffness (Eth
c,i cycle) for that particular loading cycle (Ni). The change of stiffness with
the increase in loading cycles is represented by the stiffness reduction curve.
1.0 Legends
Smin = 0.05 C80 (f=10Hz) [Oneschkow 2016, Hohsberg 2004a],
C80 (f=5Hz), [Oneschkow 2016],
0.9 run-out C80 (f=1Hz) [Oneschkow 2016],
Stress Level (Smax)
Fig. 5 Comparison of Smax-Nf relationships of AEBFS and AEHSN concrete with data of non-AE
HSPC from literature
Fatigue Behavior of Air-Entrained High Strength Concrete … 2033
The stiffness reduction and cycle-strain curves with respect to cycle ratio and
number of cycles are shown in Fig. 6 for 0, 250 and 400 FTC. The cycle-strain
curve consists of three phases i.e. phase-I is the rapid increase in strain due to
initiation of microcracks up to 8–10% of Nf, followed by uniform increment due to
progress of formation of microcracks until 90–93% of Nf, while in phase-III
microcracks lead to macro-cracks resulting in rapid increment in strain until failure.
The stage-II for AE high strength concrete is almost similar to that of non-AE
HSPC from past studies [14], Petkovic et al. [16] and longer compared to normal
concrete. The rate of change of stiffness reduction and strain development for each
concrete and for all FTC number is almost similar with respect to cycle ratio as
shown in Fig. 6(a). However, the rate of plastic strain development with the
increase in number of loading cycle is higher for AEHSN concrete for each FTC
number, consequently the stiffness reduces rapidly depicting higher damage per
cycle compared to AEBFS concrete as shown in Fig. 6(b). Therefore, the fatigue
life of AEHSN concrete is shorter compared to AEBFS concrete.
The change in fracture parameter (K) and plastic strain development with the
increase in normalized axial strain under cyclic loading are shown in Figs. 7((a) and
(b)) respectively, along with for AE high strength concrete under static loading [7],
Farooq et al. [19], and for normal concrete (NC) in EPF model [13]. The fracture
parameter and plastic strain change at almost similar rate for both AEBFS and
AEHSN concrete and no significant effect of FTC is found due to very low frost
damage. However, the plastic strain development of each concrete under cyclic
loading is more than that of static loading. This is because of involvement of time
dependent strain during fatigue loading due to creep and cyclic effect. Moreover,
the fracture parameter of both AEBFS and AEHSN concretes under cyclic loading
is more than that of normal concrete and it reduces at higher rate compared to static
loading, which might be due to collapse of AE voids and damage at ITZ under
cyclic loading.
Stiffness Reduction, Ec,i cycle(GPa)
40 40 40
0-FTC 4,000 250-FTC 4,000 Stiffness 400-FTC 4,000
35 Stiffness 35 Stiffness 35
3,500 3,500 3,500
30 3,000 30 3,000 30 3,000
ε'p and ε'max (μ)
AEHSN-250FT-80% AEHSN-400FT-80%
εp' and ε'max(μ)
th
th
25 AEHSN-0FT-80% 25 25
AEBFS-0FT-80% 2,500 AEBFS-250FT-80% 2,500 AEBFS-400FT-80% 2,500
20 2,000 20 2,000 20 2,000
15 Total Strain 1,500 15 1,500 15 Total Strain 1,500
Total Strain
10 1,000 10 1,000 10 1,000
5 5 Plastic Strain 5
Plastic Strain 500 500 Plastic Strain 500
0 0 0
0 20 40 60 80 100 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 0
Cycle Ratio (Ni/Nf) Cycle Ratio (Ni/Nf) Cycle Ratio (Ni/Nf)
(a) with respect to cycle ratio
Stiffness Reduction, Ec,i cycle(GPa)
(μ)
th
th
)
AEBFS-0FT-80%
1.0
'
AEBFS-250FT-80%
AEBFS-400FT-80%
0.8
th
AEHSN-0FT-80%
AEBFS-0FT-80% 0.3 AEHSN-250FT-80%
0.6 AEBFS-250FT-80% AEHSN-400FT-80%
AEBFS-400FT-80%
AEHSN-0FT-80% 0.2 Farooq, 2019:
0.4 Static Model-AEBFS-0FT
AEHSN-250FT-80% Static Model-AEHSN-0FT
AEHSN-400FT-80% 0.1 Maekawa, 1983:
0.2 EPF Model for NC (Maekawa 1983) EPF Model for NC
Static Model for AEHS (Farooq 2019)
0.0 0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Normalized Axial Strain, ε'max/ε'co Normalized Axial Strain (ε /ε )' '
max co
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The first author would like to thank the Japan Concrete Institute (JCI) for
awarding the International Conference Participation Grant to present this research work at
EASEC16.
Fatigue Behavior of Air-Entrained High Strength Concrete … 2035
References
1. Antrim J (1958) A study of the fatigue properties of air-entrained concrete, Joint Highway
Research Project No. C36-58-B, Purdue University, USA
2. Ayano T, Fujii T, Niitani K, Takahashi K, Hosotani K (2017) Improvement of durability of
precast concrete member by granulated blast furnace slag sand. J Disaster Res 12(3):459–469
3. Bennett EW, Muir SE (1967) Some fatigue tests of high-strength concrete in axial
compression. Mag Concr Res 19(19):113–117
4. Do M-T, Chaallal O, Aitin PC (1993) Fatigue behavior of high-performance concrete.
ASCE J Mater Civ Eng 5(1):96–111
5. Farooq MA, Sato Y, Ayano T, Niitani T (2017) Experimental and numerical investigation of
static and fatigue behavior of mortar with blast furnace slag sand as fine aggregates in air and
water. Constr Build Mater 143:429–443
6. Farooq MA, Takeda T, Sato Y, Niitani K (2018) Mechanical properties of concrete with blast
furnace slag fine aggregates subjected to freeze-thaw cycle. In: Hordijk D, Luković M
(eds) High tech concrete: where technology and engineering meet. Springer, Cham, pp 65–72
7. Farooq MA (2019) Compressive mechanical models of high strength mortar and concrete
under severe environmental action, PhD dissertation, Hokkaido University, Japan
8. Guo LP, Carpinteri A, Spagnoli A, Sun W (2010) Experimental and numerical investigation
on fatigue damage propagation and life prediction of high-performance concrete containing
reactive mineral admixture, Intl. J Fatigue 32:227–237
9. Hasan M (2003) Modeling of stress-strain relationships for concrete damaged by freezing and
thawing cycles, Doctoral dissertation, Hokkaido University, Japan
10. Hordijk DA, Wolsink GM, Vries J (1995) Fracture and fatigue behavior of a high strength
limestone concrete as compared to gravel concrete. Heron 40(2):125–146
11. Kesler CE (1953) Effect of speed of testing on flexural fatigue strength of plain concrete.
Highway Res Board 32:251–258
12. Kim J-K, Kim Y-Y (1996) Experimental study of fatigue behavior of high strength concrete.
J Cem Concr Res 26(10):1513–1523
13. Maekawa K, Okamura H (1983) The deformational behavior and constitutive equation of
concrete using elasto-plastic and fracture model. J Fac Eng 2:253–328 The University of
Tokyo, XXXVII
14. Oneschkow N (2016) Fatigue behavior of high-strength concrete with respect to strain and
stiffness. Int J Fatigue 87:38–49
15. Onoue K (2019) Energy consumption characteristics of concrete using granulated
blast-furnace slag sand related to nucleation and propagation of microcracks. Constr Build
Mater 218:404–412
16. Petkovic G, Lenschow R, Stemland H, Rosseland S (1990) Fatigue of high-strength concrete,
ACI SP-121: High-strength Concrete, pp 505–525
17. Tue NV, Mucha S (2006) Ermüdungsfestigkeit von hochfestem Beton unter
Druckbeanspruchung. Bautechnik 83(7):497–504
18. Vicente MA, Gonzáleza DC, Míngueza J, Tarifac MA, Ruizd G, Hindi R (2018) Influence of
the pore morphology of high strength concrete on its fatigue life. Int J Fatigue 112:106–116
19. Farooq MA, Sato Y, Niitani K (2020) Experimental investigation of monotonic behavior and
stress-strain models of AE and non-AE high strength concrete with BFS fine aggregates under
freezing and thawing. Constr Build Mater 249:118679
Effects of Seawater and Sea-Sand
on Concrete Properties: A Review Paper
Abstract In this paper, the most important observations of the effect of seawater
(SW) and/or sea-sand (SS) on the properties of concrete are presented and critically
reviewed. Concrete is responsible for about 9% of global annual industrial water
and almost 70% of the extracted natural sands use. During last decades many
researchers focused on replacing them by SW and SS and many promising results
have been reported. SW and SS affect the fresh concrete properties by decreasing
setting time. They increase the early age strength while their effects on 28-days and
long-term strength is insignificant. Durability of seawater sea-sand concrete
(SWSSC) and corrosion resistance of embedded steel can be improved by using
supplementary cementitious materials.
Keywords Seawater Sea-sand Fresh concrete properties Mechanical
properties Durability
1 Introduction
of the extracted natural sands use [39]. So, the idea of replacing fresh water with
seawater as well as natural sand with sea-sand will have a considerable positive
effect on these natural resources.
Using seawater and/or sea sand in concrete is not a new idea. From the begin-
ning of 1960s, researchers from the US and UK studied the effect of seawater and
sea-sand used in concrete [4, 26, 33, 35], Griffin and Henry [9]. This was followed
by Japanese researchers who used desalted sea sand as one of the main sources of
fine aggregate in concrete [42]. More recently, other countries such as Netherlands,
Hong Kong, South Korea, Germany, Denmark and France has extensively used
desalted sea-sand for various civil engineering applications [7].
Today all the design codes restrict the level of chloride in concrete to avoid the
corrosion of reinforcing steel in high chloride environment. Sea-water and sea-sand
include a high level of chloride, hence, based on the current international code
criteria, washing sea-sand using fresh water is inevitable. Washing sea-sands and
the process involved leads to extra cost in making concrete. Furthermore, fresh
water is used for washing which is not environmentally friendly. To tackle these
limitations, researchers started to work on directly using sea-sand without desalting
as well as seawater in concrete. Figure 1 shows some structures in Japan where
seawater mixed concrete (SWC) was used in the concrete mix. Figure 1a shows a
port where concrete breakwater armours are used to protect the jetty and costal
structures against wave loads, and Fig. 1b shows a reinforced concrete coastal
lighthouse built in 1959, both constructed out of SWC. Existing studies indicates
that chloride ions are unlikely to affect the properties of concrete beyond a slight
effect of the acceleration of the setting time and hardening rate of concrete. The
main concern about chloride-induced is the corrosion of steel reinforcement that is
the main reason why using SW and SS in construction is not well accepted.
Interestingly, the coastal lighthouse shown in Fig. 1b has been used for about
60 years, without any major problem or any sign of concrete deterioration or
reinforcement corrosion. This indicates the feasibility of using seawater and
unwashed sea-sand if concrete is designed and manufactured properly.
Furthermore, promising results of using supplementary cementitious materials
(SCMs), specially blast furnace slag (BFS) in increasing durability of concrete and
immobilizing chloride ions, and invention of corrosion inhibitors such as calcium
nitrite and more durable reinforcements such as coated steel, stainless steel, fiber
reinforced polymers (FRPs) and FRP-steel hybrid rebars provide potential solutions
to seawater sea-sand concrete problems. The following sections contain a critical
review of the previous studies on the effect of using SW and/or SS in the concrete
mix on the fresh properties and mechanical characteristics of hardened concrete as
well as the durability resistance concrete. The effect of using SCMs on various
properties of SWSSC reported in the previous studies is also presented and
discussed.
Effects of Seawater and Sea-Sand on Concrete Properties … 2039
Fig. 1 a Breakwater armour produced by seawater mixing concrete, Soma Port, Japan, b Hizen
Nagasaki Nao lighthouse, Ukushima Island, Japan- Reinforced concrete structure made up of
seawater mixing concrete built in 1959 [29]
To understand the workability of fresh concrete mixed with SW and/or SS, different
properties including the initial and final setting time, slump/spread flow, and air
content have been investigated in the previous studies. It has been shown that using
SW and SS in concrete decrease both the initial and final setting time [5, 11, 38].
Younis et al. observed that initial setting time of SW mixed concrete was
approximately 30% lower than conventional concrete (CC) (285 min in SWC
compared to 395 min in CC). This reduction is due to the high chloride content of
the SW and SS [44] which is explored in more detail in the following section. To
tackle this problem and increase the setting time, using retarding admixtures is
recommended by some researchers [12].
The effects of SW and SS on the workability properties of concrete is not clear
and contradictory observations have been reported in the previous studies. Some
studies reported that seawater reduces the initial slump flow [44] and increases
dredged marine sand incorporation in concrete (from 25% to 50%) resulting in a
considerable loss of fluidity [17, 18]. On the other hand, some researchers reported
that the workability of concrete is not affected by changing the type of water used in
the mix [5] and concluded that there is no clear difference between the slump of
sea-sand and river-sand concretes [20]. Interestingly, the results of an old study
shows that SWSSC had a higher average slump (53 mm) than those of sea-sand
concrete (SSC) (45 mm) and conventional concrete (40 mm) [32].
There are very limited studies on the effect of SW and SS on the concrete air
content all of which focused on SWC. It has been reported that the effects of SW on
the air content of the fresh concrete is negligible [11, 13, 44]. IN terms of the
2040 D. Vafaei et al.
density of the fresh concrete, no effect of the seawater of freshwater were reported
in the literature [13]. More studies need to be conducted on fresh concrete to better
understand the effects of SW and SS mixing on the air content of the concrete.
Sodium chloride (NaCl) from the SW or SS reacts with the calcium hydroxide in
concrete to form calcium chloride (CaCl2 in Eq. 2). Calcium chloride is a strong
accelerator of cement hydration that accelerate both the setting and early age
hardening of concrete [3, 14, 44].
Different observations have been reported on the short- and long-term com-
pressive strength of SSC. While the results of several studies indicated that the
compressive strength of SSC at 28 days is higher than conventional concrete, some
other researchers observed opposite behavior where lower compressive strength,
and some other showed that SS does not have significant effect on the compressive
strength of concrete. In Fig. 2, compressive strength of SSC is plotted against
conventional concrete. As can be seen in the figure, the minimum compressive
strength of concrete with SS was more than 90% of that of conventional concrete,
regardless of its age. Similar to SSC there are various and sometimes contradictory
observations reported for SWC. Most of these studies showed that SWC has a
significantly higher 7-day compressive strength, a comparable 28-day compressive
strength and a similar long-term compressive strength to conventional concrete
[41]. The effects of SW and/or SS on flexural strength and elastic modulus of
concrete has been reported to be negligible as compared with conventional concrete
[18]. Regarding to other mechanical properties of SW and/or SS concrete, such as
Effects of Seawater and Sea-Sand on Concrete Properties … 2041
tensile strength, toughness, impact and fatigue behaviour, there are not any infor-
mation and more studies are necessary to gain comprehensive insight about
mechanical properties of these kinds of concrete.
Concrete durability includes many aspects such as chloride and sulphate diffusion,
carbonation behaviour, freeze–thaw resistance, drying shrinkage, creep and in
special exposure conditions acid resistance. Regarding the long-term performance
of SW and/or SS mixed concrete there are very limited research, most of which
were written in Chinese or Japanese.
For SSC, in addition to the phenomenon that chloride ions (Cl ) may penetrate
into concrete from the external environment, the chloride diffusion from the sand
inside the concrete is an extra concern. The penetration process of these inside Cl
to the cement hydration products completely differs from the case where Cl is
directly added. Furthermore, their reduction is a continuous process which cause the
long-term acceleration of cement hydration. With the accumulation of Cl , Ca
(OH)2 produced by free Ca2 þ and OH from hydration leads to a decrease in the
Calcium-Silicate-Hydrate (C-S-H) gel. The increase of Ca(OH)2 and ettringite make
the pore structure of SS mortar inhomogeneous [41].
Girish et al. [8] demonstrated that the average chloride ions passing through the
concrete mixed with offshore sand almost doubled that of the CC, but it was still
within the acceptable range specified by ASTM. In another study, the relationship
Fig. 2 Normalized strength of sea-sand concrete (horizontal axis is the year of publication of the
results) [41]
Effects of Seawater and Sea-Sand on Concrete Properties … 2043
BFS refers to all slags of blast furnace (i.e. BFS, GBFS and GGBS)
Fig. 3 Researchers opinions about concrete mixed with seawater before 2015 [27]
between permeability and the chloride content was tested. To produce artificial SS
with different chloride content, the river sands were soaked in solutions with var-
ious NaCl concentration. The finding was that by increasing chloride concentration,
the permeability of mortar reduces [41]. Younis et al. [44] studied the permeability
performance of hardened SWC. In their study, mixing SW in concrete had
insignificant effects on the chloride permeability, chloride ingression, and water
absorption behaviour of concrete. The lower average pore size for SWC was
reported by Etxeberria et al. [5]. They concluded that the water permeability of
SWC was half of the freshwater concrete. Furthermore, SW significantly reduced
the capillary absorption capacity of the concrete.
Freeze-thaw resistance of SSC is somewhat lower than conventional concrete
[41], and by increasing NaCl content of the concrete to more than 0.5% of the
oven-dry sand the freeze-thaw resistance will decrease [37]. For freeze-thaw
resistance of SWC, two opposite results were reported. Selicato et al. [34] claimed
that SW improved the freeze-thaw resistance of the concrete while Otsuki et al. [29]
concluded that freeze-thaw resistance of SWC was inferior to that of conventional
concrete. Carbonation depth of the SSC is less than conventional concrete. It is due
to the presence of Cl of the DMS that can reduce the porosity of cement paste and
optimize the pore distribution [19].
Similarly, SW mixing improved short- and long-term (25-year exposure) car-
bonation resistance of concrete compared with freshwater mixing [1]. However, some
studies claimed that there was no significant difference in the carbonation depth
development between seawater and freshwater concretes [12], Otsuki et al. [29]. It
was also found that SSC has lower resistance than CC against sulphate attack [41].
Using SW in concrete mix increases both autogenous [13] and drying [13, 23,
31, 44] shrinkages. A study by Khatibmasjedi [13] showed high value of autoge-
nous shrinkage in mixtures with SW because the Cl accelerated cement hydration
process at early ages. Moreover, increasing drying shrinkage was observed due to a
finer pore size distribution and internal water movement. He also reported that the
use of fly ash in SWC could be problematic in applications where drying shrinkage
may be a concern. Regarding the effect of using both SW and SS in shrinkage
2044 D. Vafaei et al.
performance of concrete Zhang et al. [45] reported that SWSS concrete followed
the same trend as that of CC while Katano et al. [11] concluded that SWSS concrete
had a lower drying shrinkage strain.
4 Future Studies
• For some properties of SW and SS concrete, such as air content and compressive
strength, there are contradicting results. So, to gain a reliable insight more
researches are essential.
• There is not any information about tensile strength, toughness, impact and
fatigue behaviour of SWC and SSC. Furthermore, the resistance of these kinds
of concrete against physical (abrasion, hydration cracks and salt crystallisation)
and chemical (sulphate, chloride and acid) attacks is not clear.
• In case of permeability of SSC as well as chloride ingress and chloride
migration, there are no enough information and the existing studies mostly have
various observations. In case of effects of SW although there are some positive
results about decreasing the permeability and chloride ingress of SWC, but still
further researches are needed.
• Using SCMs could improve various properties of concrete. Researches on
SWSSC with SCMs is highly recommended.
• There are other types of concrete, such as high strength, high performance and
ultra high-performance concrete that SW and SS have the potential of using in
their production.
5 Conclusions
This paper reviews existing literature on the effects of using seawater and/or
sea-sand in concrete. The following conclusions can be made.
• Fresh Concrete Properties:
• Both SW and/or SS decrease the initial and final setting time.
2046 D. Vafaei et al.
Acknowledgements The first author would like to thank Australian Research Training Program
(RTP) for financial support.
References
19. Liu W, Cui H, Dong Z, Xing F, Zhang H, Lo TY (2016) Carbonation of concrete made with
dredged marine sand and its effect on chloride binding. Constr Build Mater 120:1–9
20. Liu W, Xie YJ, Dong BQ, Xing F (2014) Study on the characteristics of dredged marine sand
and the mechanical properties of concrete made with dredged marine sand. Bull Chin Ceram
Soc 33(1):15–22
21. Lothenbach B, Scrivener K, Hooton RD (2011) Supplementary cementitious materials. Cem
Concr Res 41(12):1244–1256
22. Miller SA, Horvath A, Monteiro PJM (2018) Impacts of booming concrete production on
water resources worldwide. Nat Sustain 1(1):69–76
23. Modupeola AG, Olutoge FA (2014) The effect of seawater on shrinkage properties of
concrete. Int J Res Eng Technol 2(10):1–12
24. Monteiro PJM, Miller SA, Horvath A (2017) Towards sustainable concrete. Nat Mater 16:698
25. Mori Y et al (1981) 10 years exposure test of concrete mixed with seawater under marine
environment. J Cem Assoc 35:341–344
26. Newman K (1968) Sea-dredged aggregates for concrete. In: Proceedings of the symposium:
sea-dredged aggregates for concrete, sand and gravel association Great Britain
Buckinghamshire, UK
27. Nishida T, Otsuki N, Ohara H, Garba-Say Zoulkanel M, Nagata T (2015) Some
considerations for applicability of seawater as mixing water in concrete. J Mater Civ Eng
27(7):B4014004
28. Otsuki N, Furuya D, Saito T, Tadokoro Y (2011) Possibility of sea water as mixing water in
concrete. In: 36th conference on our world in concrete & structures. Singapore
29. Otsuki N, Hamada H, Takeda N, Imamoto K.-I, Yamaji T, Habuchi T, Nishida T (2014)
Technical Committee on the use of sea water in concrete
30. Otsuki N, Min AK, Nagata T, Yi C (2016) Durability of seawater mixed concrete with
different replacement ratio of BFS (Blast Furnace Slag) and FA (Fly Ash). Civ Eng Architect
10:568–580
31. Park SS, Kwon S-J, Song H-W (2011) Analysis technique for restrained shrinkage of concrete
containing chlorides. Mater Struct 44(2):475–486
32. Ramaswamy SD, Aziz MA, Murthy CK (1982) Sea dredged sand for concrete, extending
aggregate resources. ASTM Int 774:167–177
33. Roeder AR (1968) Some technical data on sea-dredged aggregates. In: Proceedings of the
symposium: sea-dredged aggregates for concrete, sand and gravel association Great Britain
Buckinghamshire, UK
34. Selicato F, Moro M, Bertolini L Nanni A (2015) Sustainable concrete without chloride limits.
In: 2015 international concrete sustainability conference. Miami, USA
35. Shacklock BW (1968) Durability of concrete made with sea-dredged aggregate. In:
Proceedings of the symposium: sea-dredged aggregates for concrete, sand and gravel
association Great Britain Buckinghamshire, UK
36. Sun W, Liu J, Dai Y, Yan J (2016) Study on the influence of chloride ions content on the sea
sand concrete performance. American Journal of Civil Engineering 4(2):50–54
37. Takeshi Yamato YE Masashi S (1987) Freezing and thawing resistance of concrete containing
chloride. Spec Publi 100: 901–918
38. Thomas K, Lisk WEA (1970) Effect of sea water from tropical areas on setting times of
cements. Mater Struct 3(14):101–105
39. UNEP (2014) Sand, rarer than one thinks, United Nations environment programme, global
environmental alert service
40. Wegian FM (2010) Effect of seawater for mixing and curing on structural concrete. IES J Part
A Civ Struct Eng 3(4):235–243
41. Xiao J, Qiang C, Nanni A, Zhang K (2017) Use of sea-sand and seawater in concrete
construction: Current status and future opportunities. Constr Build Mater 155:1101–1111
42. Yamazaki K (1974) Viewpoints on using sea sand in concrete as fine aggregates in Japan.
Concr J 12(10):72–76
Effects of Seawater and Sea-Sand on Concrete Properties … 2049
43. Yoda A et al (1981) Concrete with blast furnace slag affected by seawater for 10 years. J Cem
Assoc 35:333–336
44. Younis A, Ebead U, Suraneni P, Nanni A (2018) Fresh and hardened properties of
seawater-mixed concrete. Constr Build Mater 190:276–286
45. Zhang Z, Sang Z, Zhang L, Ma Z, Zhang Y (2013) Experimental research on durability of
concrete made by seawater and sea-sand. Adv Mater Res 641–642:385–388
Current Issues in Construction
Motivators of Implementing
Construction Incentivisation
in Hong Kong
1 Introduction
2 Motivators of Incentivisation
Incentivisation also acts as one of the vehicles that actually set up the commercial
inter-organizational relationship between the contracting parties [19]. Oliver [24]
concluded six generalizable determinants of inter-organizational relationship for-
mation: efficiency, asymmetry, reciprocity, necessity, stability and legitimacy. As
the owner-contractor relationship is more a contractual relationship, necessity (re-
lationship are formulated because of legal requirements), stability (an adaptive
response to environmental uncertainty) and legitimacy (environment pressure
motive organizations to interconnect for social reputation) all stress the external
effects towards organizations while efficiency, asymmetry and reciprocity are all
internally oriented [20]. These three major factors are therefore analysed as intrinsic
motivates:
(1) Efficiency
Based on transaction cost economics theory [34], the formation of
inter-organizational relationship is prompted by an organization’s attempt to
improve its internal commercial benefits. Organizations will seek out or be
receptive to inter organizational cooperation when faced with situations of
resource scarcity or performance distress. The motivation by establishing
incentives shows organizations’ attempts for business achievements. Some
incentives for the purposes of improving efficiency may be the organization’s
anticipation of increases in return on assets or reductions in unit costs, waste,
downtime, or cost per patient [24]. For construction projects, the main purpose
for the clients to set cost and schedule incentives is to improve project
efficiency.
(2) Asymmetry
Asymmetry refers to organizational relationship building by the potential to
exercise power or control over another organization or its resources [24]. When
using incentives, organizations generally seeks to guide others to engage the
specific activity [26]. Much of the spirit behind the use of incentives is therefore
to shape, influence or outright control others’ behaviour so as to increase some
desirable behaviour or to decrease some undesirable behaviour. For construc-
tion projects, some monitoring methods are included into project assessment
systems for safety or schedule purposes [1, 13] as a performance control
mechanism within highly detailed contractual specifications. The use of
financial incentives in a respectful contractual environment which avoid the
perception that the client is untrustworthy and suspicious of the contractor’s
behaviour, and encourage the idea that the client aims to promote respect and
recognition [29].
(3) Reciprocity
In some cases, the demand for affiliation is manifested by the fear of losing
some intimacy and the avoidance of interpersonal conflict [22]. The human
Motivators of Implementing Construction Incentivisation … 2057
3 Case Study
A case study approach was selected to examine these issues. It is a good way of
capturing a wide range of views and opinions of respondents selected from different
organizations and across a variety of management levels [9]. Five construction
projects located in Hong Kong with incentivisations were studied. The methodol-
ogy is mainly through interview, document study and participant observations.
Table 2 gives the particulars of the five projects:
Table 3 shows the summary of the motivation dimensions for these projects.
The motivation dimensions of these incentive schemes are mapped with the
motivators framework. Comparatively, there are some differences in terms of dif-
ferent types of project objectives. For IOR development, the attempt to improve
organizational efficiency is the most common objective for incentivisation planning.
The monetary rewards were therefore commonly distributed in different stages to
make sure that these rewards were achievable and increase their expectancy for
obtaining all the incentives.
For cost incentive schemes (Case A and B), the consideration of reciprocity was
detected through interviews. The attitudes towards pain/gain share arrangements
were positive and considered useful to moderate unequal project risks. In both
cases, cost incentive schemes are closely incorporated with the whole contract, the
focusing point in the contract are mainly about defining the scope and share ratio of
benefits and the intension for collaborative working. For Case A, flexibility was
allowed for the contractors to have a more comfortable working climate. An
innovative foundation design was proposed by the contractor. It became the key
core of the savings in construction cost and time. The project is considered as a
success with over HK$ 60 million have been saved and earlier completion.
Differing from cost incentives, schedule (Case C) and quality incentive scheme
(Case D and E) show a stronger intention for project controlling and project ori-
entation governances. More attention is directed to the assessment of project
behaviour and put them into specific details. For the schedule incentive scheme in
Case C, milestones were set to award and monitor contractor’s behaviours. As a
historic building revitalisation project, it encountered more unforeseeable risks than
Table 3 Summary of the motivation dimensions detected under financial incentive schemes
No. Name Case A Case B Case C Case D Case E
1 Project Cost √ √
2 performance Quality √ √
3 improvement Schedule √
4 Innovation √ √
5 Promotions of project √ √
performance
6 Long-term commitment √
7 IOR Efficiency √ √ √ √ √
8 maintenance Asymmetry √ √ √
9 Reciprocity √ √
Reach anticipated outcome (Y/N) Y N Y N Y
expected and accident happened. The schedule incentive scheme is therefore set to
motivate the contractor to finish this project with the best endeavour. In the end, the
completion date is 2 months’ earlier than original plan.
For Case D and E, specific criteria were set in different dimensions to evaluate
the performance of contractors. Investment were made for labour training, man-
agement team forming, management system generating and so on. To attract the
contractors, these tasks are exposed along with rewards. Safety incentives were
used in Case D. The assessment criteria were set for each Quarter. The assessment
consists of three parts: Effective Safety Management, Safety Performance and Legal
Compliance. The behaviour of the contractor was monitored by developer’s safety
manager. For case E, the client also intends to build positive feedback mechanism
and try to incorporate project performance into a profound long-term development.
the Bonus scheme goes hand in hand with Performance Assessment Scoring
System (PASS). PASS consists of outputs (Works) Assessment and Input (Goals)
Assessment to be conducted during the construction project and the substantial
completion stage of the building contract. The most concern was taken in schedule,
safety performance, clean disciplinary record and no offence, malpractice, or mis-
conduct causing damage to the client’s image. Differ with other quality incentives,
PASS also provides database of contractors for conferring tendering opportunities
in works contracts commensurate. It takes around 30% of the tendering score when
doing tendering analysis. Better previous project performance has more chance to
tender than under-performer. A long-term commitment is therefore offered for
contractor with good performance.
2060 L. Zhu and S. O. Cheung
4 Discussion
5 Conclusions
under investigation are concluded as: (1) It is difficult to attribute project success or
failure is the result of use of CI; (2) The partner matters even though using the same
type of CI. All these points shall be noted when analysing the effectiveness of
incentivisation for the further study.
References
20. Locke EA, Latham GP Erez M (1988) The determinants of goal commitment. Acad Manage
Rev 13(1):23–39. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1988.4306771
21. Lui SS, Ngo H, Yue (2004) The role of trust and contractual safeguards on cooperation in
non-equity alliances. J Manage 30(4):471–485. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jm.2004.02.002
22. McClelland D, Burnham D (2008) Power is the great motivator. Harvard Bus Rev 73(1):126–
139
23. Meng X, Gallagher B (2012) ‘The impact of incentive mechanisms on project performance.
Int J Project Manage 30(3):352–362. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2011.08.006 Elsevier
Ltd and IPMA
24. Oliver C (1990) Determinants of interorganizational relationships: integration and future
directions published by: academy of management linked references are available on jstor for
this article: determinants of interorganizational relationships: integration and futu. Acad
Manag Rev 15(2):241–265
25. Oliver P (1980) Rewards and punishments as selective incentives for collective action:
theoretical investigations. Univ Chicago Press J 85(6):1356–1375
26. Reeve J (2009) Understanding motivation and emotion, 5th edn. Wiley, Hoboken
27. Richmond-Coggan D (2001) Construction contract incentive schemes : lessons from
experience
28. Rose T, Manley K (2011a) Motivation toward financial incentive goals on construction
projects. J Bus Res 64(7):765–773. Elsevier Inc., https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2010.07.
003
29. Rose T, Manley K (2011b) Motivation toward financial incentive goals on construction
projects. J Bus Res 64(7):765–773. Elsevier Inc., https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2010.07.
003
30. Schermerhorn JR (1975) Determinants of Interorganizational Cooperation. Acad Manag J 18
(4):846–856. https://doi.org/10.5465/255382
31. Suprapto M et al (2016) How do contract types and incentives matter to project performance?
Int J Project Manage 34(6):1071–1087. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2015.08.003
Elsevier Ltd and Association for Project Management and the International Project
Management Association
32. Suprapto M, Bakker HLM, Mooi HG (2015) Relational factors in owner-contractor
collaboration: the mediating role of teamworking. Int J Project Manage 33(6):1347–1363.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2015.03.015 Elsevier Ltd and IPMA
33. Teitelbaum P (1967) Physiological psychology: Fundamental principles. Prentice-Hall,
Englewood Cliffs, NewJersey
34 Williamson OE (1985) The economic institutions of capitalism. In: Hayek F, Law L,
Liberty V (eds) China social sciences publishing house. Chengcheng Books ltd, China.
https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1987.4308003
A Concenptual Framework
on the Effects of Apology
on Psychological Aggression
in Construction Dispute Negotiation
Abstract Most construction projects end with major disputes. Resolving dispute
consumes considerable resources that would have better deployed for the benefits of
the project. Almost all construction industries across the globe are seeking ways to
minimising the occurrence of disputes. In July 2017, the Hong Kong Government
enacted an Apology Ordinance as part of the campaign in promoting use of
mediation to resolve civil disputes. Construction disputes appear to be the inevitable
destiny of construction projects. An Apology may suppress aggressive behaviour
that is quite common in hearted arguments. This study examines the effect of
apology on psychological aggression. It was found that the apology has the effect to
(1) reduce the expected liability; (2) repair conflict in a damaged relationship and
(3) determinant the willingness to forgive in aggression.
1 Introduction
Dispute can be defined as “a situation where two parties typically differ in the
assertion of a contractual right, resulting in a decision being given under the con-
tract, which in turn becomes a formal dispute” [2]. The five main causes of disputes
in Asia construction projects in 2014 are: (1) failure to properly administer the
contract; (2) failure to make interim awards on the extension of time and com-
pensation; (3) poorly drafted, incomplete and unsubstantiated claims; and (4) biased
project manager or engineer [1]. The ARCADIS Global Construction Disputes
Report indicates that the length of dispute was around 11.4 months in 2010 and has
risen to 19.5 months in 2015. Time is also of the essence in construction projects,
resolving disputes at the shortest time will alleviate the negative impact of disputes
on project performance. With the aim of minimising the occurrence of disputes and
facilitate amicable resolution, the Hong Kong Government promotes the use of
alternative dispute resolution in general and mediation in particular. Whilst nego-
tiation is the most efficient way to settle dispute as among all the dispute resolution,
mediation as a form of assisted negotiation can be the second best alternative. In
this connection, the Hong Kong Government enacted an Apology Ordinance at the
end of December 2017 with the aim of enabling apology to be offered without
running the risk of admitting liability. With that, it is expected that more disputes
could be settled and in a faster manner.
Many researches on psychological aggression have mainly focused on the
children’s development, intimate relationship, workplace bullying and medical
aspect. The above aggression research prospect is well developed in both theories
and research methods. In fact, it has been found that failing construction dispute
negotiations are fuelled aggressive behaviours of the disputants.
This study posits to examine the effects of an apology on aggressive behaviours
of disputants. This study therefor has three main objects:
(1) Identify psychological aggression behaviours that damage construction dispute
negotiation;
(2) Discuss the effects of apology on aggressive behaviours and dispute negotiation
outcomes; and
(3) Propose a conceptual apology-aggressive behaviours relationship framework.
Non-cooperative behaviour
Psychological
Relational Aggression Non-equality distribution
Aggression
Indirect Aggression
other parties in a relationship [11, 27]. Figure 1 shows the categories of psycho-
logical aggression:
Social aggression is defined as the aggressors are having the intention of manip-
ulating the acceptance in group and harm against other parties’ social status through
the acts such as verbal refusal, undesirable facial expressions or body movement [3,
13]. Three factors of aggression can be generated from the definition of social
aggression, they are non-cooperation behaviour, over control and non-equality
distribution. These factors can be commonly found in the conflict among the
contracting parties during the construction period:
(1) Non-cooperative Behaviour
Cooperation is particularly important as construction project requires different
parties’ collaboration to run the project smoothly. The negative reaction of the
aggressive parties such as verbal rejections or slanderous rumours in the con-
struction conflict affects their cooperative behaviour in the project. The inten-
tion to harm is an important element that prevent forgiveness in the situation of
conflict [14].
Two types of non-cooperative behaviour could be generated, first is subjective
non-cooperative aggression, the other one is negatively non-cooperative reac-
tion. For subjective non-cooperative aggression, the aggressor is the leading
party and try to imply negative reactions in the construction cooperation
relationship. The happening of psychological aggression can be demonstrated
by the following examples. First, the aggressor would point out to their partners
that another party is more attractive to cooperate with [12]. This is intended to
harm the partner’s social status and also implies that the counterpart is not a
good partner to cooperate with. It also damages the reputation and affect the
counterpart’s further cooperation opportunity. Another example is negative
non-cooperative aggression that describes the situation when the aggressive
parties are not willing to cooperate [20], the aggressive party intents to harm the
counterpart by not being cooperative and having negative reaction during the
negotiation or conflict towards the other parties.
(2) Over Control
Over control means that the aggressor has the intention of manipulating the
behaviour of a group [3, 13]. In a construction project, if one party has greater
power than the others and in favour of exercising this power, dissatisfaction and
conflicts may arise. In this situation, the party with greater power can inten-
tionally threaten the other parties to abandon collaboration and in extreme
circumstances terminate the project [12].
2068 L. Zhu et al.
Relational aggression is that the aggressor harms the encounter party through the
manipulation to damage the encounter party’s relationship or feelings of acceptance
or group inclusion in the form of covert [3]; Crick and Grotpeter [9]. The
aggression has an emphasis on the intention to harm a relationship or group
members. “Silent treatment” is given from the aggressor to the encounter party. Or
it was told that the encounter party is excluded from the social group unless they
comply with what the aggressor desires, which the encounter parties know who the
aggressors are and what they are doing [3], Crick and Grotpeter [9]. Examples of
relational aggression can be found as the aggressor says something harmful that
reduce the opportunity of other parties to express opinions, dismiss others’ opinions
openly or reduce or increase the duties of the other parties in order to hamper their
work [3]. It shows that the aggressor has the intention to harm the other parties and
have a bad influence on the organizational relationship in construction project.
certain group activities [28]. Further examples include the aggressor attempts to
cause psychological harm to the targeted person or parties through social manip-
ulation; attack the target often in circuitous ways through a third person in order to
conceal the aggressive intent or pretend that the attack was not aggressive at all [3].
The above situation may also occur during the construction conflict or negotiation.
Aggression is one of the sources of conflict in construction projects. Once
disputes crystallise, negotiation is likely the first step to get them resolved.
However, when aggression in embedded in the conflict, resolution becomes more
complicated and rational decisions are less forthcoming. Manifested conflict
involves openly aggressive behaviours which the aggressor aims to frustrate the
goals of the counterpart(s) [16]. Section 3 will discuss the negative effects of
aggression for negotiation outcome.
3.3 Inaction
The third outcome is inaction that is identified as one of the outcomes of negotiation
due to withdrawal of one of more of the negotiating parties [8]. There are some
examples can be found in the construction industry such as the counterpart with-
drawing from a threatening situation or the issue being postponed until a better time
[8]. It can be defined as “some people forgive after they had got back what was
taken away from them or when their rights had been restored by the appropriate
instance or when the consequences had vanished with time” [15].
The aggressor may bring an unforeseeable psychological aggression’s conse-
quences to the counterpart that may potentially last indefinitely due to the
aggressor’s behavior or the social circumstances [14, 31]. Therefore, whether the
consequence of aggression could be cancelled will be the items to measure the
extent of aggression’s impact towards construction conflict or negotiation.
apology [14]. One of the essential representation of a sincere apology is the promise
by the aggressor that the aggression will not be repeated. Therefore, an aggressor
giving a sincere apology may help the encounter party reducing the level of fear
they feel towards the aggressor [14, 24]. One of the advantages of sincere apology
is the encounter party are more likely to grant forgiveness once they believe the
aggressor is apologizing sincerely and this is classified as the most effective strategy
to ensure forgiveness are given [4], McCullough et al. [21]. Examples can be found
during the construction dispute such as the aggressor apologise sincerely for the
dispute, the aggressor was truly sorry for the harm caused by our parties or the
aggressor felt genuine remorse for the harm caused [5].
(2) Partial Apology
Partial apology is defined as the apology which expresses the sympathy only and
without admitting responsibility [23, 30]. This type of apology would be useful
when the offender is unclear about the fault or the injury is not severe [23]. The
greatest difference between full apology and partial apology is the admission of
responsibility. For full apology, the apology will unequivocally admit responsibility
while partial apology will not. Examples can be found in the construction industry
such as the aggressor was sorry that there was dispute and hoping the dispute will
end soon [23].
Whether to forgive is one of the factors that can be found in measuring the extent of
psychological aggression [14]. Some people could forgive psychological aggres-
sion due to the other parties putting pressure on them to forgive [15], (Neblett
1974). It is therefore suggested that this attitude will affect the successfulness of
dispute when there is aggression found in the negotiation or conflicts. For example,
when the aggressor insisted that all the problems were the fault of other parties [12],
avoiding openly discussions about both parties’ differences, not willing to negotiate
in order to compromise [20], an apology by the aggressor may effect an attitude
change of the apology recipients. There are a number of studies describing the
impacts of apology towards negotiation. For the effect for aggressive behaviours,
the apology takes effects as follows:
(1) Firstly, the aggressors would like to reduce the expected liability by apolo-
gizing in the settlement of negotiations [7]. This means the present of apology
could generate the positive relationship and ease the settlement of negotiations
even aggression is included.
2072 L. Zhu et al.
Apology
Negotiation
Aggression
Outcome
(2) Secondly, apology is useful in repairing conflict that damages relationship [25].
This means the apology can patch create a positive relationship towards the
aggression and construction negotiation process but to what extent different
types of apology help in the relationship of aggression and construction
negotiation outcome will be the focus of this study.
(3) Thirdly, the apology is important to determine the willingness to forgive in
aggression [14, 29]. This means that an apology can heal the harm caused by
the aggression and thereby reignite the chance of successful negotiation. This
study further examines how different types of apology could bring a positive
impact on negotiation outcome and aggression.
A conceptual framework formulating the foregoing constructs is presented in
Fig. 2.
5 Conclusions
proposed that offering an apology would bring the following aggression soothing
effects: (1) reduce the expected liability; (2) repair conflict that damages relation-
ship and (3) engender the willingness to forgive the aggressor. A conceptual
framework is therefore proposed to illustrate the moderating role of apology in
construction dispute negotiation.
References
22. Orenstein A (1998) Apology excepted: incorporating a feminist analysis into evidence policy
where you least expect it. Sw UL Rev 28:221
23. Robbennolt JK (2003) Apologies and legal settlement: An empirical examination. Mich Law
Rev 102:460–516
24. Rogers K-A, Kelloway EK (1997) Violence at work: personal and organizational outcomes.
J Occup Health Psychol 2:63
25. Ren H, Gray B (2009) Repairing relationship conflict: How violation types and culture
influence the effectiveness of restoration rituals. Acad Manag Rev 34:105–126
26. Schlenker BR, Darby BW (1981) The use of apologies in social predicaments. Soc Psychol Q
44:271–278
27. Shorey RC, Temple JR, Febres J, Brasfield H, Sherman AE, Stuart GL (2012) The
consequences of perpetrating psychological aggression in dating relationships: a descriptive
investigation. J Interpersonal Violence 27:2980–2998
28. Tapper K, Boulton MJ (2004) Sex differences in levels of physical, verbal, and indirect
aggression amongst primary school children and their associations with beliefs about
aggression. Aggressive Behav 30:123–145
29. Takaku S, Weiner B, Ohbuchi K-I (2001) A cross-cultural examination of the effects of
apology and perspective taking on forgiveness. J Lang Soc Psychol 20:144–166
30. Itoh K, Andersen HB (2010) Patient reactions to staff apology after adverse event and changes
of their views in four-year interval. In: Palanque P, Vanderdonckt J, Winckler M (eds) Human
error, safety and systems development. Springer, Berlin
31. Zechmeister JS, Romero C (2002) Victim and offender accounts of interpersonal conflict:
autobiographical narratives of forgiveness and unforgiveness. J Pers Soc Psychol 82:675
A Study of Construction Disputes
in the New Zealand Context
1 Introduction
The construction industry is one of the pillars of New Zealand (NZ)’s economy,
contributing to commerce, GDP and employment [9]. In spite of the national sig-
nificance, NZ construction industry also features in the lack of momentum in
productivity, relatively smaller market size in the global context and an acute
shortage of skills [12]. Meanwhile, construction dispute is an epidemic facing the
whole industry worldwide, costing disputants a considerable amount of time and
money and undermining the mutual trust [1]. Therefore, the characteristics of NZ
construction industry and the detrimental effects of construction disputes necessitate
the research on construction disputes mitigation. This behavioral study has focused
on identifying the significance of human factors in the occurrence, escalation and
T. W. Yiu (&)
School of Built Environment, Massey University, Albany, New Zealand
e-mail: tyiu@massey.ac.nz
Z. Lu K. P. Ang
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Auckland, Auckland,
New Zealand
2 Literature Review
The construction industry plays a vital role in NZ economy [9], accounting for
6.3% of GDP and 7.6% of the workforce even in the year of 2010 when the whole
industry remained distressed. This industry is a fast-growing industry with signif-
icant momentum, which has experienced a sustained growth rate 7% since 2011 and
is expected to reach the value of $37 billion between 2017 and 2018, approximately
20% higher than that of 2015 [9]. Relatively smaller industry size in a global
context, the lack of large-scale developments and low productivity are also the
major characteristics of NZ construction industry [12]. Hence, the construction
industry in NZ differentiates it from that in other common reference countries, e.g.
the UK, US or Australia [11]. The critical role of NZ construction industry’s
economy and various constraints facing the industry necessitate the needs of
avoiding and mitigating construction disputes to better allocate resources and serve
the national economy. Due to the high costs associated with the traditional litigation
approach and the uncertainties of its outcome, Alternative Dispute Resolution
(ADR) has become more commonly adopted by the construction industry [2].
Poirot [10] opined that ADR approaches should include internal negotiation,
mediation, mini-trials and dispute resolution boards.
Chan and Tse [3] and Gad et al. [6] suggested that the resolution of construction
disputes may be prone to cultural influence. This could be better elaborated by the
way construction disputes are usually handled in China. Xu and Cheung [13]
opined that the core moral values rooted in the traditional Confucianism and
Taoism make Chinese people tend to resolve disputes in a peaceful way without
undermining the so-called “face” and harmony. Moreover, disputes may have
detrimental effects on the project performance, causing unpredictable delay, addi-
tional expenditure, loss of productivity, and damage to the relationship [7], Cheung
and Pang, [5]. Chen et al. [4] further investigated the impact of disputes or the
generalised “conflicts” in the construction industry and suggested that task-related
conflicts could have a positive impact on project performance given the
well-established mutual trust between both parties prior to entering the contract. In
terms of human factors, a number of studies have been conducted [8], Yiu and Lee
[14], Zhang et al. [15], Cheung et al. [4]. A knowledge gap has been identified to
exist between the prestigious international research achievements and their feasi-
bility and application in the New Zealand context.
A Study of Construction Disputes in the New Zealand Context 2077
3 Methodology
4 Results
A total of 40 interviews were conducted. Except for one interviewee who shared
with the author some experience on observing other people dealing with con-
struction disputes, all the other 39 participants answered that they had been
2078 T. W. Yiu et al.
5 Discussion
The causes of the dispute cases were analyzed by classifying them into
human-related causes and non-human-related causes. With regards to this classi-
fication, the principle adopted by the author could be described by a common
Chinese idiom, “See through the appurtenance to perceive the essence”. For
example, the interviewee answered “unrealistic expectation” as the main cause of
the dispute which might appear to be human-related. However, after an in-depth
discussion about the specific dispute example, the cause of the dispute could be
further explained as resulting from the unforeseeable underground conditions and
both parties had acted professionally and with good faith throughout the process. It
is believed that the likelihood of such a dispute cannot be substantially reduced
regardless of how differently both parties, the “human factor”, could have behaved.
Therefore, the cause of this dispute case was classified as non-human-related. Using
the same principle, it has been found that approximately 76% of the dispute cases
were caused to a certain extent by human factors which could have been rectified.
This result demonstrated that human factors are likely to be the most common cause
of construction disputes in NZ and identified the focus of the subsequent analysis.
2080 T. W. Yiu et al.
In regard to the difficulty and room for improvement in resolving dispute cases as
well as the external and internal factors that affect the interviewees’ performance or
decision-making, 78% of the answers for “the most difficult part in the dispute
resolution process” are related to human factors with non-professionalism and
confrontational behaviours as the major issues. When asked about “what might
have been done” to improve the resolution outcome, 85% of the interviewees’
responses centered on human-related factors, e.g. improving their own or the other
party’s work behaviors, more professional decision-making. 70% of the “external
influence” and 65% of the “internal influence” during the resolution process was
found to be human-related while the organizational pressure, public perception and
professional knowledge were the main contributors. The qualitative and descriptive
answers, which were classified as human-related, were then transformed into
quantitative data based on the significance of human factors in these responses, i.e.
to what extent the participants and the resolution outcome have been adversely
impacted by the human-related factors. Human-relate factors such as
non-professionalism, confrontational behaviours or excessive external pressure
have a significant influence on disputants’ performance and the resolution outcome.
Over half of the interviewees, who were taking managerial-level roles, have
expressed and agreed on the idea that a peer-review platform between clients and
contractors should be established and perfected. This idea stemmed from, the lack
of tools to assess a client’s or a contractor’s previous performance in contracts, e.g.
behaviours, good faith, business style, etc. In more detail, both the client and the
contractor could have the opportunity to comment on the performance of each other
and post the comments on the platform. The comments may be posted anony-
mously but the users should be encouraged to comment with real names to ensure
the data authenticity. Meanwhile, there should also be an assessment panel set up to
verify the reliability of each comment so that the defendant, i.e. the party being
commented on, may have the right to appeal. The interviewees who proposed or
commented on this mechanism generally believed that such a platform could help
A Study of Construction Disputes in the New Zealand Context 2081
exchange information between previous and future contractual parties and allow
clients and contractors to build a better understanding of the other contractual party.
For some organisations which have already internally developed a similar platform,
according to a few interviewees working for local government agencies, more effort
should be put on promoting the awareness and utilization of the peer-review system
while considering introducing the system across the industry.
The concept of Scope Lock Point originated from an intellectual conversation with
an interviewee who is taking a chief managerial role in a local government agency
with more than 35 years of experience in the industry. A dispute case worth more
than $20 million was thoroughly discussed in the interview. The main cause of the
dispute was a late change of scope during the construction stage as a compromise to
offset the significantly increased project cost which was initially based on an
inaccurate cost estimation. The cost for change of scope could increase exponen-
tially past a certain point between development design and detailed design, which
was defined as the Scope Lock Point (SLP). It is thus recommended that the scope
of a project should be defined as early as possible with regards to functionality,
major deliverables, etc. and the best effort should be made to incorporate the
concept of Scope Lock Point into the detailed design, which means that no sub-
stantial change of scope should be made or expected past the SLP. It is believed that
the consensual acceptance and understanding of the SLP by both parties could
dramatically reduce the likelihood of construction disputes and the incurred cost of
time, money and opportunity.
surveyor’s cost estimation during the design stage. Therefore, as the client’s rep-
resentative, after settling the claim with the contractor the interviewee decided to
claim indemnity from the quantity surveyor. This might seem to be an isolated case;
however, the universal principle embodied in this example could be applied to
many other situations, which is the spirit of finding the truth from facts and holding
each other accountable. It is this philosophy that NZ construction industry urgently
needs to foster an environment which values professionalism and accountability.
6 Conclusions
References
1 Introduction
The percentage of New Zealanders over the age of 65 has been projected to increase
from being 14% of the population in 2012 to approximately 24% of the population
by 2036 [11]. This fluctuation is expected to be reflected within the nation’s work
force as larger proportions of older people will opt to work for longer years due to
reasons such as financial hardshi [12]. The proportion of the nation’s labour force
that is over the age of 65 is projected to grow from 6% in 2017 to between 8–11%
by 2038 and between 9-15% by 2068 [12]. As such New Zealand (NZ) is predicted
to experience a substantial growth in population as well as an ongoing shift in age
T. W. Yiu (&)
School of Built Environment, Massey University, Albany, New Zealand
e-mail: tyiu@massey.ac.nz
H. Hayalie R. Zhong
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The University of Auckland, Auckland,
New Zealand
band proportions over the coming years [9]. This change is also expected to be
reflected within the population of workers employed within the construction
industry [12]. This has created an issue that requires immediate attention as con-
struction is known for being punishing on the well-being and health of those that
work within the industry [1]. NZ construction industry had highest number of
work-related injury in the Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) claims in
2017. This accounted for 16.1 percent of all occupational claims in New Zealand
[12]. Research has shown that one of the greatest hurdles the NZ construction
industry faces is a commonly held carelessness towards work safety, establishing a
counterproductive work culture [14]. This sense of recklessness is associated with
workers tolerating and embracing the idea of there being risk [14]. Rather than
acting upon work-related dangers, studies show that NZ construction workers are
more likely to accept being endangered [14]. It has been suggested that the ability
for construction workers to claim injuries to the ACC significantly attributes to their
sense of carelessness [14]. In addition, the natural decline of people’s health will
likely develop more injury cases (in particular musculoskeletal disorders, MSD) in
construction sector [5]. This makes it vital to explore and identify the areas for
improvement within NZ construction industry to become more accommodating and
less dangerous for older workers [5]. The nature of the musculoskeletal disorders
workers within the construction industry are at risk of developing vary depending
on the type of occupation the worker is employed within [1]. Lower back pain is the
most frequently experienced musculoskeletal disorder for worker within construc-
tion [13]. Winkel and Mathiassen [15] identified three potential risk categories for
back pain. These are: (a) individual factors, such as a person’s age, body weight and
muscle strength, (b) biomechanical factors, such as the frequency of physically
lifting heavy objects, twisting of the trunk, prolonged awkward postures and
exposure to whole body vibration, (c) psychosocial factors, such as job satisfaction
and job control [15]. A Swedish study examined the patterns of 73,631 construction
workers of various ages and their development of musculoskeletal disorders [5].
This study found that there was a steady increase in the prevalence of lower back
pain as the age groups increased in age [5]. This puts older workers at higher risk of
developing chronic injuries that plague their quality of life, as well as forcing them
to retire early due to their inability to meet the physical requirements of their job
[8]. The construction industry should prepare for accommodating ageing workforce
in the coming decade. It is necessary to provide recourses and services to reduce the
negative effects associated with an ageing workforce [3]. The more ‘ready’ a
company is, the more likely they are to address and reduce the physical burden
experienced by senior construction workers [10]. Building a positive work envi-
ronment to increase the comfortability of senior employees in communicating
which aspects of their job cause them physical strain is suggested to be the first step
[3]. In order for these problems to be communicated and acted upon, employers
must actively build positive relationships with employees [4]. More specifically, a
Dutch study gained information from 637 senior construction workers in relation to
their work, health, career preferences, ability and expectations [2]. It was discov-
ered that among 56% of men who developed musculoskeletal disorders, the most
Commitment to Construction Health and Safety … 2087
preferred preventative measure was to reduce the overall physical workload [2].
This study reinforces the importance of gaining information from workers, via a
questionnaire survey, as a means of increasing the construction industry’s readiness
for confronting the problems faced by senior employees [2]. The primary objective
of this project is to investigate the perceptions of construction workers within NZ
relating to their healthy ageing. The secondary objective is to identify key areas
requiring improvement within NZ construction industry in relation to accommo-
dating older workers, and the methods necessary to help reduce the negative effects
on this demographic.
2 Methodology
The questionnaire developed for this study was based on the review of relevant
literature. More specifically, recommendations made by industry professionals and
studies from existing literature on how to ease the transition of older workers into a
workplace. Literature has typically defined ‘older worker’ as one who is
approaching the age of retirement. The most commonly accepted retirement age in
NZ is 65 as this is when New Zealanders become eligible to receive their super-
annuation benefits. However, literature in medical discipline suggests that the
decline in biological function begins decades prior to this age [7]. Cross-sectional
studies indicate that muscular strengths peak between the second and third decade
for males [7]. This level generally plateaus throughout the fourth decade and then
declines from the fifth to the eighth decade by about 35–45% [7]. The peak
strengths in woman are observed to occur earlier, with losses in strength also
occurring at a younger age [7]. Given the strenuous, muscular strength and
endurance demanding tasks typically associated with work within the construction
sector, it may be appropriate to define older workers in relation to this decline [6].
As such this study defines ‘older worker’ as person aged 40 or above. The survey
was designed and intended for workers employed within various labour intensive
jobs in NZ construction industry. Socio-demographic questions were included to
2088 T. W. Yiu et al.
categorize the participants on their gender, age groups, work experience and current
work circumstances such as typical number of hours worked per week. Questions
were asked to gauge the thoughts of the participants on their employer’s contri-
bution to facilitating the healthy ageing of their employees. Similar perception
questions were asked about the participants own contributions to their healthy
ageing. This was included to help identify any trends and patterns which exist, to
create a starting point for policy makers within companies and government to
review when deciding which methods of intervention would be most effective to
implement. The perception questions were answered according to a 5-point Likert
Scale where participants could choose the option which best represented their
perceptions towards a certain statement. The options available were defined as;
1 = Strongly disagree, 2 = Disagree, 3 = Neutral, 4 = Agree, 5 = Strongly Agree.
To analyze the collected data, the participants were first divided into two age
groups, ‘Below 40 years of age’, and ‘40 years and above’. The mean value of each
age group were calculated. Mann-Whitney U tests were used to check if attitude
variables were statistically significant between the < 40 age group and the 40 + age
group. Variables which showed mean scores below 3 (representing some degree of
disagreement) were identified and discussed. Similarly, those which showed sta-
tistically significant associations (p < 0.05) between the two age groups in relation
to their answers were also analyzed and discussed. These associations were further
investigated by breaking the groups up into their specific age bands (16–29, 30–39,
40–49, 50–59, 60 +) to see if more intricate patterns existed within the specific age
bands.
3 Results
3.1 Socio-Demographics
The age of the participants were relatively well-scattered. The number of partici-
pants from the different age groups are shown in Table 1.
After dividing the participants into the two age groups ‘Below 40 years of age’,
and ‘40 years and above’, the sample was split at 28 and 32 respectively.
The most common range of weekly hours worked was 40–50 h which over a third
of the participants (24 out of 60) answered. The second most common response was
50 + hours which 16 participants answered.
The overwhelming majority of participants were employed full time (46 out of 60).
The survey also showed that 5 of the participants were self-employed. Part-time and
casual employment received 7 and 2 responses respectively (Table 3).
Table 1 Participants’ Profile Age group 16–29 30–39 40–49 50–59 60+
(by age groups)
# of participant 18 10 11 14 7
Table 2 Participants’ Profile Size of company <5 5–15 16–30 31–49 50+
(by company size) (number of employee)
# of participant 8 19 13 9 11
Both age groups disagreed (p-value = 0.247) that their respective management
provided frequent breaks to ensure their employees were not exhausted (< 40
mean = 2.34, 40 + mean = 2.57). Similarly, both groups also disagreed
(p-value = 0.096) that their respective companies were frequently improving the
health and safety facilities to accommodate current and future employees. (< 40
mean = 2.39, 40 + mean = 2.78). There is evidence (p-value = 0.014) that a sig-
nificantly larger proportion of workers in the older age group disagree that man-
agement delegates age-suitable tasks (mean = 2.25) compared to the younger group
(mean = 3.11). This inversely proportional relationship was also consistent within
the specific age bands. The mean values decrease from 3.17 for the youngest band
(16-29 years) to 1.86 for the oldest band (65 + years). Both age groups responded
strongly against the questions that related to their company’s provision of: quality
health insurance, subsidized health examinations, and frequent health examinations.
The mean values of the responses for the < 40 years of age group were 1.68, 1.68
and 1.39 respectively. Similarly for the 40 + years of age group, the mean scores
were, 1.41, 1.34 and 1.16 respectively. This was irrespective to company size. The
two groups mutually disagreed upon the statement that their employer provided
facilities which assisted employees with personal or work related issues (e.g.:
counselling services) (p-value = 0.485). The mean values reported were 2.5 for
the < 40 group and 1.81 for the 40 + group. However, when comparing the
responses to this question against the size of the company the participants were
from, there is very strong evidence suggesting that larger companies are much more
likely to provide such facilities (p-value = 0.001). All of the participants which
strongly agreed with this statement worked for companies which employed at least
31 employees, with 82% of these responses coming from those working in com-
panies which employed 50 + employees.
Very strong evidence suggest a difference in opinion exists between the < 40 years
of age group (mean = 3.64) and the 40 + years of age group (mean = 2.75) in
response to the statement of not wanting to appear ‘unmanly’ by being overly safe
(p-value = 0.001). 68% of the < 40 years group either agreed or strongly agreed
with this statement compared to 22% from the 40 + years group.
There was also very strong evidence suggesting a significant disparity between
the two age groups relating to their willingness to caution co-workers when they are
working unsafely (p-value = < 0.001). The < 40 years of age group responded that
they were less likely (mean = 2.54) to do so than the 40 + age group (mean =
3.97). This trend was also seen to exist within the specific age bands with
exception of the age bands 40–49 and 50–59.
Commitment to Construction Health and Safety … 2091
These show that the younger group responded more positively (mean = 4.11) to
always wearing the correct PPE compared to the older group (mean = 3.47)
(p-value = 0.041). (Talk about self-employment). However, there was mutual
agreement in regards to skipping breaks often to finish jobs in a timely manner,
where the mean values of both groups were above 3 (neutral).
Very strong evidence (p-value = < 0.001) suggests that the younger group are less
likely to attend regular health examinations (mean = 1.54) as well as ensure they
are well rested before participating in work related activities (mean = 2.32) when
compare to the older group (mean = 2.97, and 3.44 respectively). However, it is
worth noting that there is very strong evidence to support that < 40 years of age
group are significantly more likely to show interest in learning new safety tech-
niques to enhance their well-being (mean = 3.43) compared to their older group
(mean = 2.44) (p-value = 0.001).
Very strong evidence indicates that the disparity between the perceptions of whe-
ther it was commonplace to sustain a work-related injury (p-value = < 0.001). The
younger group disagreed for the most part with 0% strongly agreeing and only 7%
agreeing. Compared to the 40 + years of age group whom 25% strongly agreed and
another 25% agreed with the statement.
Similarly, there is very strong evidence to suggest large disparities between the
two age groups in relation to the statements “My mobility has been affected by
work-related activities” and “I experience aches and pains during my regular work
activities” (p-value = < 0.001 for both). These discrepancies were the most sig-
nificant differences within the entire questionnaire, with the < 40 years old group
having a mean of 1.79 and 2.29 respectively, and the 40 + years age group having a
mean of 4.09 and 4.34 respectively (Fig. 1).
Q1- I do not want to be seen as ‘unmanly’ or ‘weak’ being overly safe; Q2-
When I see co-workers working unsafely I caution them; Q3- I always wear the
correct Personal Protection Equipment (PPE); Q4- I attend regular health exami-
nations to ensure I am fit to work (e.g. eyesight, hearing, mobility); Q5- I ensure I
am well rested before partaking in work related activities. (e.g. Enough sleep the
night before); Q6- I feel it is common to sustain a work-related injury within my
current job; Q7- My mobility has been affected by work-related activities.
Q8- I experience aches and pains during my regular work activities; Q9- I am
interested in learning new safety techniques to improve my well-being at work.
2092 T. W. Yiu et al.
4 Discussion
This study shows that dissatisfaction with the frequency of breaks provided was
unanimous between the two age groups. These results indicate a flaw on man-
agement’s behalf as the administration of frequent breaks is essential in providing
workers with time to recover and rest. Regular breaks were one of the mitigation
strategies indicated within the literature as being effective in reducing the workload
on older workers [6]. This result could be attributed to the negative work culture
where workers are willing to compromise their breaks in order to finish jobs in a
timely manner.
Similarly, the survey results showed unanimously strong disagreements with the
statements relating to companies providing quality health insurance, subsidized
health examinations, and frequent health examinations. This lack of medical sup-
port on behalf of the companies of those participating in the survey could contribute
to the hesitation of workers seeking medical aid for injuries due to financial con-
straints. As indicated by medical literature, early management of injuries is vital
when reducing the negative affects felt by workers [16]. This however would have
to be at the expense of the companies, which may not be financially feasible for
them. Government’s support may be helpful to reduce the injuries. This could
therefore minimize their effects on demographics vulnerable to sustaining injuries
such as older workers [6]. It is found that smaller companies were significantly less
likely to provide their employees with facilities such as counselling, to assist with
personal or work related issues. These services could benefit workers by increasing
their enjoyment with their work. This could be reflected by a decrease in MSD
developed due to improvement in the workforce’s psychosocial factors, as indicated
by existing literature [15].
Commitment to Construction Health and Safety … 2093
The study found that there were numerous significant disparities between the
perceptions of younger and older workers. Many of these relate to habits and
precautions taken to increase the health and safety of the employees. The difference
in responses relating to the reporting of aches, pains and loss of mobility demon-
strates that older workers are far more likely to develop MSD’s compared to
younger workers. This also agrees with the survey result that older workers are
more likely to perceive that injuries are commonplace within construction. This
indicates that there is an unhealthy disconnect between the younger worker’s
perception of their biological resilience and the reality of the likelihood of sus-
taining work related injuries within the construction industry. This disconnect is
especially problematic as the younger workers may develop unhealthy habits
relating to serious factors which affect their healthy ageing due to maintaining the
false impression that these patterns will eventually likely lead them to injuries.
These results coincide with the study completed by Holmström and Engholm [5]
where older workers were also far more likely to develop MSD’s within con-
struction. Early intervention where younger workers are educated on the realities of
neglecting their well-being within the construction industry could have significant
impacts on the upcoming generation’s ability to age in a sustainable manner within
the construction industry.
The difference in perception relating to how appropriately management delegates
tasks to suit the abilities of the workers, highlights this disconnect and the fact that
older workers have different requirements to younger workers. Judging by the
responses, the younger age group’s perception was relatively unaware of this issue
whereas older workers collectively felt the delegation efforts were insufficient in
relation to what they could offer. According to relevant literature, the mitigation
strategy of tasking each worker with physically compatible tasks is an essential
measure to be considered to improve a company’s ‘readiness’ in better accom-
modating older workers [6]. This also coincides with the Dutch study of 637 senior
construction employees where of those 56% who had developed MSD’s, the most
preferred preventative measure was to reduce the overall workload [2].
damaging movements associated with construction work [5]. This could explain
why the older workers prioritize rest and medical check-ups more than their
younger colleagues. It should also be noted that the increased frequency of health
check-ups reported by the older workers could also likely be due to the higher
prevalence of injuries observed within this age group. Again, educating the younger
workers on the significance of maintaining healthy habits such as regular check-ups
and ensuring sufficient sleep prior to working could help break the cycle of younger
workers contributing to negative well-being statistics as they age within the con-
struction industry.
5 Conclusions
This study revealed that the fundamental disparities existed between the younger
workers (<40 years of age) and older workers (40+ years of age). Management was
perceived to be flawed in certain key areas which would exacerbate the issues of
unhealthy ageing. Impact reduction strategies including improved administration of
breaks, smarter delegation of tasks and providing services to cope with stress
should be considered by companies to enhance the healthy ageing of their
employees. The reporting of injuries as well as the expectation of developing an
injury within the construction industry were significantly higher within the older
group compared to the younger group. This disparity in the expectation of devel-
oping an injury suggests that younger workers are oblivious to the dangers of
maintaining bad habits such as not ensuring they are well rested before work. These
could eventually prevent them from ageing in a healthy manner. Improving the
efforts to educated employees on the statistics associated with the prevalence of
injuries within construction could help cut the cycle of workers contributing to the
detriment of their well-being.
References
1. Boschman J, van der Molen H, Sluiter J, Frings-Dresen M (2010) Occupational demands and
health effects for bricklayers and construction supervisors: a systematic review. Am J Ind Med
54(1):55–77
2. De Zwart CHB, Frings-Dresen MHW, Van Duivenbooden JC (1999) Senior workers in the
dutch construction industry: a search for age-related work and health issues. Exp Aging Res
25(4):385–391
3. Gahan P, Healy J (2017) The challenge and opportunity of an ageing workforce. https://
pursuit.unimelb.edu.au/articles/the-challenge-and-opportunity-of-an-ageing-workforce
4. Goonrey A, Mandel J (2018) How to manage the challenges of an ageing workforce. http://
www.hrmonline.com.au/mature-age-workers/manage-challenges-ageing-workforce/
5. Holmström E, Engholm G (2003) Musculoskeletal disorders in relation to age and occupation
in Swedish construction workers. Am J Ind Med 44(4):377–384
Commitment to Construction Health and Safety … 2095
1 Introduction
2 Methodology
and Jackson [4]. Meanwhile, during the process of coding, the relationships were
established by participators’ response. The types of relationships were coded by
“supportive”, “unsupportive”, and “main decision”, based on the structure of the
interview outline. The “supportive” or “unsupportive” means who (the role of
interviewee) believed the innovation adoption is (un)supportive by the person (or
organization) (see the direction of the arrow). For example, one developer reported
“there are both developer and builders that do embrace it (innovation)”, thus, the
developer thought developer and builder are supportive of innovation adoption,
then they have a relationship with “supportive”. The similar built the relationship
between developer and developer. However, the majority of them reported client as
a factor, and some of them mentioned developer after they talked about the client,
while, few used government clients instead of the client. In order to clearly make
sure what the client was included, they were asking to explain what client it was.
29.4% of them reported client consisted of both developer and government, and two
interviewees made sure they mentioned the client only as a developer. Therefore,
the coding of this study was used the specific term that participants mentioned
during the interviews.
The concepts of construction innovation were originated from the business research
field [36]. Murphy et al. [30] linked the concepts of innovation in businesses
practices to the construction field and described construction innovation as the
adoption of a new idea that will benefit stakeholders. Slaughter [38, p. 226] defined
construction innovation as “actual use of a nontrivial change and improvement in a
process, product or system that is novel to institution developing change.” Scholars
defined construction innovation in different perspectives, with some focused into
the change of process e.g., Motawa et al. [28], and some emphasised on the per-
spective of technology, e.g., Tatum [40], others defined from spanning both sides
from technology and process, e.g., Dale [9]. Views from the interviewees are
generally in line with the literature review. It was found that 70.6% of the partic-
ipants define innovation as both the adoption of new technologies and processes,
23.5% described construction innovation as merely an adoption of new process and
5.9% defined it as the adoption of new technology.
What Affects Construction Innovation Adoption in Building … 2101
A typical construction project generally consists of a client, design and cost con-
sultants, main-contractor (builders), sub-contractors [32]. According to CIOB [8],
the client is defined as “entity, individual or organisation commissioning and
funding the project, directly or indirectly.” The role of the developer is constructing,
redeveloping or refurbishing buildings in regard to make a profit [19]. The con-
struction supply chain and its management are significantly regarded as a set of
practices sought to manage and coordinate the entire supply chain from raw
material suppliers to end customers [2]. New materials created as the crucial ele-
ments consist of innovation [33]. Customers promote innovation by placing pres-
sure on project participants to provide a high standard of work/products [3],
increase performance [13], or may present new requirements challenging traditional
practices and products [37]. Nam and Tatum [31] found consultants have a sig-
nificant impact on product innovation. They have the potential to combine the
knowledge of construction design science, process, materials, and constraints with
technology tool and equipment in the innovative design [23]. The relationships
between consultants and customers have become important with the ever-increasing
competition in the construction industry [18]. Often it is the consultant who is hired
by customers that promote the need for advanced technology implementation
through alternative products of building design [5]. Additionally, consultants liaise
between the builders and the customers.
Akintoye et al. [1] identified the main stakeholders within the industry that
influence the adoption of innovation include suppliers, design consultants, builders
and sub-contractors. In the Australian construction industry, Unsworth et al. [41]
identified stakeholders impact on innovation adoption including clients, suppliers
[17]; Mehrtens et al. [26], competitors, and government branches [10]. Moreover,
Steinhardt et al. [39] identified traders and sub-contractors, consumers, government
and regulatory bodies, finance industry/banks, suppliers, industry representative
bodies, architects and designers, clients, and engineers that influenced prefabrica-
tion adoption.
Similar to the literature reviews, participants of the semi-structured interviews
generally believe the existence of dynamics among developer/government/client,
architect/engineer/quantity surveyor, builder/sub-contractor and suppliers in regard
to innovation adoption. Such dynamics can be shown in sociograms with centrality
measures generated through NVivo 12 plus. The degree of centrality is the count of
the number of vertices directly connected by the vertex. “Degree is often used as a
measure of a vertex’s degree of connectedness and consequently, their popularity
and influence” (QSR International n.d.). This can be used to determine which
conditions are critical to disseminating information and affecting others in the
network. For example, how many people can this person reach directly? Nvivo is
used to calculate centrality measures by the Stanford Network Analysis Project
(SNAP), which is a network analysis and graphics mining library. “It is written in
2102 L. Qi et al.
Table 1 Top seven most impactful stakeholders in construction innovation adoption – ranked by
Centrality Measures
Case Degree Degree in Degree out Betweenness Closeness
Builder 13 5 11 51.786 0.056
Architect 12 4 12 44.919 0.053
Engineer 11 3 11 33.033 0.050
Quantity Surveyor 10 2 9 28.167 0.048
Developer 9 4 7 8.952 0.045
Senior management 5 5 0 0.286 0.040
Government 5 5 0 0.286 0.040
prefabrication has become more extensive used in projects. In recent years, inno-
vative ideas in prefabrication emerged for reducing on-site skilled labours,
decreasing project cost and shortening the construction period [21].
From the interviews, 41.2% of the participants clearly indicate builder/main
contractor as the most impactful CPOs in construction innovation adoption. They
reckon decisions of builders are mostly affected by the developers/clients willing-
ness to ‘try new thing’. Builders are sensitive to price and efficiency and they would
only adopt innovation that can bring a positive effect to the project outcomes.
17.6% of the participants highlighted that builders may react negatively to inno-
vation implementation if the benefits are not justified. The builder needs proofs and
evidence to support behavior change.
In this study, interviewees generally described ‘senior management’ in two
folds: personnel at senior positions within the CPOs and personnel at senior
positions from the CPOs. Interviewees from consultants’ and contractors’ firms
often mentioned “senior management” is playing a decisive role in innovation
adoption. ‘Senior management’ is described as a group of personnel that would give
a broad view of what they need to do in the next stage and had a strong power to
lead them to adopt innovation. 35.3% of interviewees articulated senior manage-
ment made a positive attitude of innovation adoption. While 11.8% commented
senior management would against innovation adoption refers to afraid of change
and they want to use in the traditional ways. Therefore, the company’s manager
may have to adopt or develop new technology to provide a price, schedule, or
quality performance equivalent to the competition [40]. From the interviews, 54.5%
reported senior management as the main decision-maker to impact on a project
innovation adoption. The leader could show the employees by adopting an inno-
vation, although they might not get affected immediately, they could share the
reward, and if the employees meet that, they would adopt it. Therefore, instead of
assessing stakeholders’ general influences, this research highlights the relationship
among the internal stakeholder groups to seek better collaboration to implement
innovation in the construction industry.
2104 L. Qi et al.
4 Conclusion
References
34. Poirier E, Staub-French S, Forgues D (2015) Embedded contexts of innovation: BIM adoption
and implementation for a specialty contracting SME. Constr Innov 15(1):42–65
35. QSR International n.d., Understand Sociogram Centrality Measures, QSR International,
viewed 1 July. http://help-nv11.qsrinternational.com/desktop/concepts/understand_sociogram_
centrality_measures.htm#MiniTOCBookMark3
36. Rothwell R (1976) Innovation in textile machinery: some significant factors in success and
failure. Science Policy Research Unit, University of Sussex, Sussex, UK
37. Seaden G, Manseau A (2001) Public policy and construction innovation. Build Res Inf
29(3):182–196
38. Slaughter ES (1998) Models of construction innovation. J Constr Eng Manag 124(3):226–231
39. Steinhardt DA, Manley K, Miller W(2014) What’s driving the uptake of prefabricated
housing in Australia?, QUT. https://eprints.qut.edu.au/81178/
40. Tatum C (1987) Process of innovation in construction firm. J Constr Eng Manag 113(4):648–663
41. Unsworth KL, Sawang S, Murray J, Sorbello TM (2009) Developing an integrative model for
understanding innovation adoption. In Proceedings of Academy of Management Annual
Meeting - Green Management Matters, Chicago, Illinois, 7–11 August, pp. 1-6
42. Winch G (1998) Zephyrs of creative destruction: understanding the management of
innovation in construction. Build Res Inf 26(5):268–279
43. Xue X, Zhang R, Yang R, Dai J (2014) Innovation in construction: a critical review and future
research. Int J Innov Sci 6(2):111–126
Towards Applying Virtual Reality
Techniques in Fostering Blended
Learning of the Construction
Technology
1 Introduction
Building technology usually stands out as the core competencies of the construction
professionals Autralian Institute of Quantity Surveyors [1] 2012. Effective learning
of building technology is founded on persistent practices in transforming infor-
mation from construction drawings to real actions on site and documents with
precise and consistent descriptions in compliance with the industry standards and
the government requirements [29]. This type of training has been delivered in a
conventional fashion involving formal lectures and studios-based practice sessions.
Learners without relevant working experience usually encounter difficulties in class
when they were asked to base on learning materials that are mainly
two-dimensional (2-D) drawings/pictures to delineate three-dimensional (3-D)
objects in the construction sites. Worse still, an integral part of similar types of
professional training is to adopt continuous assessment to compliment lectures.
With insufficient information and experience, it is understandable that learners may
have far from satisfactory learning experience in these courses and demand for
more intensive guidance [3]. Unfortunately, this issue is more critical as academics
in this area with enough industry experience is not readily available. Devising more
effective delivery of building technology courses shall be invaluable to the students,
industry, professional bodies and the academia.
In recent years, both industry and the academia invested remarkably in Building
Information Modelling (BIM)—a platform that digitizes and accommodates 2-D
and 3-D drawings, as well as all essential project information that can be extracted,
networked and shared among project stakeholders to foster effective decision
making and operations [27]. BIM enables visualisation of end-products in 3-D
forms before physical construction work commence. This facilitates project
stakeholders to better link the designs to their operations and coordination. This
fosters better project planning to reduce design and opeartional errors, minimise
waste, optimise schedule, and rationalise budgeting and subcontracting.
Notwithstanding, BIM is merely an information visualization technique that only
provides a non-immersive virtual environment on the desktop screens and projec-
tors. Furthermore, information abstracted from BIM is merely 3-D computerised
models in a virtual environment that cannot help learners to develop spatial skills as
much as site visits guided by experts with hands-on experience sharing. Traditional
way of course delivery, even with an introduction of BIM as a complement, has its
constraints to present real construction site environments in classroom [11].
In this aspect, some described that adopting virtual reality (VR) technique in
professional training can facilitate academics/trainers to provide new instructional
element to learners that received traditional mode of training. This foster blended
learning with integration among real-life site environment. In recent years, several
studies were conducted in applying VR techniques in the construction education
Towards Applying Virtual Reality Techniques … 2109
[28]. Nonetheless, various approaches were adopted and their strengths and
weaknesses in articulating concepts through real-life construction site environment
were not reviewed in a holistic manner. This paper presents a study that seeks to
identify the strengths and weaknesses of implementing VR techniques in fostering
blended learning of construction technology. A systemic review was conducted to
uncover the optimal match between strengths/weaknesses and the goal of
improving learners’ understanding about real-life construction site conditions and
its links to 2-D and 3-D environments. The rest of the paper are arranged as follows:
First, the definition of VR is reviewed, and the definition used in this study is
articulated. Second, data collection and analysis methods are presented. Third, the
results and implication of findings are reported.
The groundwork of VR dates to the early 1960’s. The first immersive man-machine
graphical communication system mock-up named ‘Sketchpad’ was invented to
interpret information drawn directly on a computer display [24]. The actual term
‘Virtual Reality’ first appears in 1986 and is attributed to Jaron Lanier, early virtual
reality entrepreneur. Since then, several taxonomies have been raised by scholars to
illustrate rigorous VR concept that aligns continuum of reality to virtuality
including virtual reality, augmented reality and mixed reality. Subsequent research
produced working models of the various elements required to construct usable VR
visual display systems. For instance, virtual reality systems were used all areas of
industrial design, computer gaming, defence strategy development and training, real
time military battlespace planning and management, medical research and training,
nuclear research, and a growing array of real-time control systems and robotics [5].
Moving to a further advanced platform, Shields [21] emphasised on positioning
the user to experience a range of interaction within a computer-generated virtual
world far beyond the human physical capabilities in the real world. In doing so,
automated software agents of real-world human actors, named ‘dramatis personae’
were used in VR. The definition by McCloy and Stone [12] stresses the role of user
interaction within a virtual world using their natural physical and cognitive senses,
skills and capabilities. Thus, VR comforts to be in an environment that can be
perceived as a realistic place with enough interaction to perform tasks more effi-
ciently. In a nutshell, virtual reality is a term that implies a broad range of 3-D
computer simulated environments with its associated hardware to experience
unique insights into the real-world scenarios. Sherman and Craig [20] combined all
the elements and defined VR as: ‘a medium composed of interactive computer
simulations that sense the participant’s position and actions and replace or augment
the feedback to one or more senses, giving the feeling of being mentally immersed
or present in the simulation (a virtual world)’ (p. 16).
Given the board range of VR applications that were reported, this study focuses
on the specific insights into the use of VR in improving the learners’ understanding
2110 P. S. P. Wong et al.
3 Research Methodology
4 Results
classroom setting Levesque-Bristol et al. [8]. Although field trips and internship
programs are the main two approaches applied in construction academic programs,
their success depends on intrinsic motivation and active learning participation of the
students [8]. Therefore, having an alternate approach to present these encounters in
a classroom context would be a more viable option for delivering a more effective
learning experience. An evolving body of literature traces the use of reality tech-
niques to enhance student learning experiences. Types of VR techniques can
broadly be categorised into (i) Non-immersive VR and (ii) Immersive VR. Yet,
(iii) Game-based VR, (iv) Web-based VR, (v) BIM-enabled reality techniques are
also discussed.
4.2 Non-immersive VR
4.3 Immersive VR
Within an immersive environment, Waly and Thabet [26] investigated the Cave
Automatic Virtual Environment (CAVE) for further development of the virtual
construction environment. The CAVE is a multi-person collaborative, room-sized
with four-sided displays (front, left, right and down), 3D video and audio envi-
ronment. As the user wearing a position sensor (tracking equipment) moves within
2112 P. S. P. Wong et al.
the boundaries, the user’s potion in the virtual environment also moves with and
surround the user. 3D models are created in a 3D modeling software such as
AutoCAD and then converted into the CAVE. Wang et al. [27, 28] used Autodesk
3D Studio Max Design 2015 and Unity 5.3.4 to enable the head-mounted display/
360-degree display of the immersive system in their development of VR-embedded
BIM immersive system. Teizer, et al. [25] integrated 3D immersive data visuali-
sation techniques and real-time location tracking in existing construction iron-
workers’ education and training environments. 3D models of the existing training
facility created in Sketchup were converted into 3D Studio Max data and then
imported into the real-time 3D virtual environment software. Each trainee is
equipped with an Ultra-Wideband (UWB) tag so that all their locations are tracked
and recorded in real-time. Safety and operation information can be monitored and
visualised for increasing workers’ situational awareness through real-time feedback.
Engaging all training participants through data visualisation in an immersive VR
environment can increase learning effectiveness. Therefore, the real-time sense in
the immersive VR provides more advantages compared to desktop-based VR.
consuming significant energy. To overcome this hurdle, Pham, et al. [14] developed
an energy-efficient interactive constructive safety education (eCSE) using
web-based panoramic virtual photo-reality technology. A photo-reality scene can be
captured by portable devices such as Samsung Gear 360. Furthermore, the recent
proliferation of wearable devices such as VR-glasses provides major potential
applications to support both the industry and education. However, photo-reality
technology by itself cannot provide float object interactions, as in 3D-VR models
but the emergence of Web3D technology address this limitation. Shelbourn et al.
[19] demonstrated how multimedia can be used as an interface for complex systems
using VR techniques. The use of web-based VR Modeling Language (VRML) as
multimedia provides the ease of access and real-time integration. Similarly,
Sawhney et al. [18] developed an internet-based interactive construction manage-
ment learning system (ICMLS). The key features of the system include using the
internet as the launching medium, employing multimedia databases, hypertext, 3D
modeling, and simulation to provide students with an interactive and adaptive
learning environment.
Despite the several studies of adapting virtual reality techniques, level of detail with
VR contents has not been achieved. A combination of the features of 3D BIM
model and VR is capable of providing students engaging, self-motivating, and
immersive contents, which would induce virtual interaction and experiential
learning [7]. Wang et al. [27, 28] developed a VR-embedded BIM immersive
system for quantity surveying practice and education, which consists of an
immersive system (head-mounted display/360-degree display) and a non-immersive
system (Desktop VR). This VR application was developed to improve the accuracy
and efficiencies of taking off quantities using BIM. In doing so, learners can
visualise context and hidden features otherwise unattainable through traditional
lecture-based teaching.
5 Implications of Findings
5.1 Strengths
5.2 Weaknesses
Irrespective of the benefits, the cost and time consumed for the model development
should be further considered [13]. Kim, et al. [6] mentioned their system limitations
in terms of its hardware as to equip all workers with wearable devices are expen-
sive. In addition, it would be expensive to build a strong network and computing
system. Le, et al. [7] explains that their the game creation process was
time-consuming due to the complicated game scenarios and required instructors and
students to spend extra efforts to gain new skills for using this education system. As
such complex VR models are time-consuming, require a large amount of capital,
the decision for technology acceptance likely to remain with the financial experts,
rather than the technical experts of a company [2]. Although it requires more
upfront capital, training efforts can pay big dividends in the form of improved
labour productivity and safe operation [25]. The lack of standardisation of infor-
mation and communication technology (ICT) tools is another issue. The informa-
tion has been handled inconsistently with several software tools and datasets [14].
VR devise configuration might have limitations in mobility. Some immersive VR
techniques require laboratory space and learners need to use hand-held devises or
sensors to interact with the immersive environment. Learning within a virtual
environment needs to be well understood by learners in terms of understanding the
interface and interaction tools before navigating within the environment [14].
Otherwise, bad experience with the technology can demotivate students to learn and
explore the environment [25].
6 Conclusion
References
1. Autralian Institute of Quantity Surveyors (AIQS) (2012) Competency standards for quantity
surveyors, construction economists and cost engineers, AIQS
2. Fernandes KJ, Raja V, White A, Tsinopoulos CD (2006) Adoption of virtual reality within
construction processes: a factor analysis approach. Technovation 26(1):111–120
3. Fogarty J, McCormick J, El-Tawil S (2017) Improving student understanding of complex
spatial arrangements with virtual reality. J Prof Issues Eng Educ Pract 144(2):04017013
4. Goedert J, Cho Y, Subramaniam M, Guo HF, Xiao L (2011) A framework for Virtual
Interactive Construction Education (VICE). Autom Constr 20(1):76–87
5. Gutierrez M, Vexo F, Thalmann D (2008) Stepping into virtual reality. Springer, Heidelberg
6. Kim K, Kim H, Kim H (2017) Image-based construction hazard avoidance system using
augmented reality in wearable device. Autom Constr 83:390–403
7. Le QT, Pedro A, Park CS (2015) A social virtual reality based construction safety education
system for experiential learning. J Intell Rob Syst 79(3–4):487–506
8. Levesque-Bristol C, Knapp TD, Fisher BJ (2011) The effectiveness of service-learning: it’s
not always what you think. J Exp Educ 33(3):208–224
9. Li H, Chan G, Skitmore M (2012) Multiuser virtual safety training system for tower crane
dismantlement. J Comput Civ Eng 26(5):638–647
10. Jiao Y, Zhang SH, Li YK, Wang YH, Yang BM (2013) Towards cloud augmented reality for
construction application by BIM and SNS integration. Autom Constr 33:37–47
11. Johnson-Glenberg MC, Birchfield DA, Tolentino L, Koziupa T (2014) Collaborative
embodied learning in mixed reality motion-capture environments: two science studies. J Educ
Psychol 106(1):86
12. McCloy R, Stone R (2001) ‘Science, medicine, and the future. Virtual reality in surgery. Br
Med J 323:912–915
13. Park CS, Le QT, Pedro A, Lim CR (2016) Interactive building anatomy modeling for
experiential building construction education. J Prof Issues Eng Educ Pract 142(3):1–9
14. Pham HC, Dao NN, Kim JU, Cho S, Park CS (2018) Energy-efficient learning system using
web-based panoramic virtual photoreality for interactive construction safety education.
Sustain (Switzerland) 10(7):1–8
15. Rezazadeh IM, Wang XY, Firoozabadi M, Golpayegani MRH (2011) Using affective
human-machine interface to increase the operation performance in virtual construction crane
training system: a novel approach. Autom Constr 20(3):289–298
16. Sampaio AZ, Rosario DP, Gomes AR, Santos JP (2013) Virtual reality applied on civil
engineering education: construction activity supported on interactive models. Int J Eng Educ
29(6):1331–1347
17. Saunders M, Lewis P, Thornhill A (2016) Research methods for business students, 7th edn.
Pearson Education Limited, Harlow
18. Sawhney A, Marble J, Mund A, Vamadevan A (2000) Internet based interactive construction
management learning system. In: Construction congress Vi, proceeding: building together for
a better tomorrow in an increasingly complex world
19. Shelbourn M, Aouad G, Hoxley M (2001) Multimedia in construction education: new
dimensions. Autom Constr 10(2):265–274
20. Sherman WR, Craig AB (2018) Understanding virtual reality: interface, application, and
design. Morgan Kaufmann
21. Shields R (2005) The virtual. Routledge, Abingdon
22. So JC, Proctor RW, Dunston PS, Wang X (2013) Better retention of skill operating a
simulated hydraulic excavator after part-task than after whole-task training. Hum Factors 55
(2):449–460
23. Su X, Dunston PS, Proctor RW, Wang XY (2013) Influence of training schedule on
development of perceptual-motor control skills for construction equipment operators in a
virtual training system. Autom Constr 35:439–447
Towards Applying Virtual Reality Techniques … 2117
Keywords Undergraduate programmes Integrated Multidisciplinary Building
Information Modelling (BIM)
1 Introduction
collaboration skillsets that are essential for them to deal with new challenges in the
BIM implementation stage.
Construction is a professional training that adopts long-established curriculum.
As such, changes are necessary to incorporate BIM into the existing curriculum.
BIM education can be an isolated new subject or the change of the existing subjects
[9]. However, BIM education is not the pure computer software training in any
particular courses. Rather, the curriculum should be designed to offer opportunities
for more teamwork and collaboration between courses. The most important com-
ponent is to let the students to learn team cooperation and how they can work
collaboratively under BIM environment [1, 8]. The IBPD course supports the
students’ interdisciplinary learning and strong team collaboration under a hypo-
thetical building project. With the mandatory use of BIM in the IBPD course, an
excellent opportunity is created for the students to achieve full-team BIM collab-
oration in the aspects of design coordination, construction planning and cost
management. The students shall demonstrate their BIM capabilities to accomplish
the building project according to the BIM project execution plan provided by the
departmental BIM coordinator.
The BIM project execution plan is a core document for BIM adoption in the
IBPD course. Same as the real-life BIM projects in the industry, the BIM project
execution plan outlines the client’s BIM goals and objectives for the successful
completion of the IBPD project. It is expected that BIM adoption can offer effi-
ciency benefits to the students and bring greater co-ordination between them par-
ticularly at an early project stage. At the beginning of the IBPD course, the students
shall form a number of teams and each team shall accomplish the required tasks by
utilizing the BIM technology. The course intended learning outcomes are designed
to suit the five disciplines (i.e. AS, CVSE, BSE SURV and CEM) and six
dimensions of BIM are ultimately achieved. Table 1 lists out the BIM deliverables
to be submitted by each discipline under the IBPD course.
Based on the interdisciplinary setting of the IBPD course, the students shall
demonstrate their capabilities of interpreting the client’s information requirements
and transforming them into feasible BIM solutions. iBIM implementation is
accomplished by the students in this regard. For example, the students from the AS,
the CVSE and the BSE disciplines are the design team members who use the design
authoring software for 3D design and 6D analysis of their respective discipline
models. The CEM students carry out 4D simulation based on the construction
programme and act as coordinator to detect clashes from the design team’s models.
The SURV students are responsible for automatic quantity take-off and cost esti-
mating. With the integration of the 4D scheduling from the CEM discipline, 5D
BIM solution is also provided for the project cash flow forecast. Figure 1 provides
some examples of BIM deliverables produced by the students. In addition, the
degree of collaboration between the students can be increased on a centralized
platform that is the departmental BIM server. With the aid of the server, the stu-
dents can practice team communication and data exchange on a BIM data platform.
Figure 2 illustrates the framework of iBIM implementation in the IBPD course.
Collaboration is of particular importance in the IBPD course. The BIM col-
laboration teams under the IBPD course consist of the five core disciplines who
have their own responsibilities associated with the BIM incorporation into the IBPD
project workflow. The project execution plan specifies the BIM process in which
the collaboration teams need to reach consensus on how the model is set-up,
organized, communicated and controlled. To enable the team members to work
individually at the early design stage, the models are being created by each disci-
pline model author based on a common structure developed and agreed by them. In
addition, to allow successful BIM implementation, model changes should be
tracked and documented. Each team is required to record the latest design changes
incorporated in the model and the version of the model to be shared or exchanged
among the team members. Each discipline model developed during project pro-
gression and development should be well planned by considering model content
and format before distribution to the team members for design coordination. Each
discipline model author shall create a model in sufficient detail in order to illustrate
that all elements are properly sized, coordinated and documented. To ensure the
desired BIM maturity, Level of Development (LOD) is specified for the content of
the models and it allows the team members to realize the usability and the limi-
tations of the models received.
The Application of BIM in the Undergraduate Course … 2123
Fig. 1 Some examples of BIM deliverables produced by the students under IBPD
2124 C. C. W. Keung and W. H. Fok
A BIM server is set up by the ACE Department for the students who can practice
BIM team communication and data exchange on a centralized platform. Exclusive
rights to access the server are authorized for the students and the team supervisors
throughout the IBPD course period. The server is custom configured for a
team-based structure that offers a shared repository for the collaboration teams to
retrieve, archive and store their massive digital data for the IBPD project. The
server authenticates each team member by requesting login and it supports
in-campus or remote access through VPN. In order to support efficient BIM
workflow and increase the degree of team collaboration, the team members’ digital
models should be stored on common data environment and made available to the
appropriate team members. In order to achieve common data environment, if
alternative BIM software is chosen, all models should be delivered in a neutral file
format like IFC or other open standard format that supports interoperability between
BIM software packages.
The BIM server aims to offer efficiency benefit to the collaboration teams and
brings greater coordination between them. To facilitate efficient digital data
exchange and modelling data consistency, a standardized folder structure is pre-
scribed in the BIM project execution plan by the departmental BIM coordinator.
For instance, the folder of “working models” is reserved for work-in-progress BIM
The Application of BIM in the Undergraduate Course … 2125
models so that the draft models can be stored in the corresponding sub-folders until
they are ready to be shared with other team members. The folder of “published
models” is used to store the BIM models ready for exchange in design stages.
Furthermore, an individual folder is used for cost management deliverables,
whereas a separate folder is reserved for filing the weekly team meeting reports. To
enhance the traceability of the updated BIM data, date of model revision should be
clearly stated by the team members as the file name. Once the folder structure is
agreed among the team members and established in the server, the team members
are restricted from modifying it. Figure 3 displays the BIM server architecture
established in the IBPD course.
The server security is another key issue addressed in the BIM project execution
plan for the students to pay attention. For example, the students are recommended
to log out the server at once after finishing the file sharing and storing. The reason is
continuous server connection may cause high risk to the server such as virus
attacks, hacking, and any unauthorized acts. Moreover, the server is provided for
each IBPD team to retrieve, archive and store their digital data and models
exclusively for the IBPD project collaboration. Any storage of non-IBPD-related
files in the server is strictly prohibited. The students are not permitted to let other
non-IBPD users access the server. Additionally, the students are not allowed to
perform any unintended amendment or alteration of the models and other data
stored on the server. The students are strongly recommended to back up and store
the models and other data in their personal storage devices. The students should be
responsible for safeguarding all digital data for their IBPD projects in order to avoid
any information loss arising from their misuse of the server.
In response to the Hong Kong government’s BIM initiative, BIM becomes the key
curriculum of the undergraduate programmes of the ACE Department, a department
that is quite unique in the academic world as it embraces the five core disciplines in
construction. This unique feature supports the students’ interdisciplinary learning,
in particular the project-based IBPD course that requires strong team collaboration.
The IBPD course successfully demonstrates that, through the adoption of the
intelligent BIM tools, the students’ innovation can be energized and the interdis-
ciplinary designs are efficiently coordinated. Furthermore, with the aid of the
departmental BIM server, the team members can collaborate on a centralized
platform for data exchange and team communication. In this regard, the iBIM
implementation in the IBPD course could pave the way for future BIM teaching and
learning in its pursuit of the three core objectives: (i) design innovation, (ii) mul-
tidisciplinary coordination and (iii) project team collaboration.
As the construction industry lacks full-team BIM project showcase, the IBPD
course is expected to be an exemplar of collaborative BIM applications in Hong
Kong and other BIM-developing countries. The outcomes of the iBIM imple-
mentation can sensitize the practitioners to the transformation of BIM adoption
from individual-based to interdisciplinary-based. Thus, the IBPD exhibition cum
competition organised annually by the ACE Department is a good occasion for the
students to showcase their BIM competencies to the public. The last event was held
in February 2019 at CityU with six participating teams selected based on their
overall performance in the IBPD course. As in previous years, very senior practi-
tioners of various disciplines of the construction industry were invited as judges of
the competition.
During the exhibition, the participating teams not only display their final out-
comes of the building project but also present how BIM was fully adopted
according to the BIM project execution plan. The students effectively used a wide
variety of innovative tools to showcase their BIM deliverables such as BIM model
viewer, 3D printing model and VR device. Additionally, a video of model walk-
through was produced for each team and played during the exhibition to illustrate
students’ creative design in an immersive view. Figure 4 illustrates the students’
BIM showcases during the exhibition. The exhibition was well received by the
guests and visitors and they absolutely agree that IBPD gives the students a
competitive edge over other university students as they are now BIM ready.
The Application of BIM in the Undergraduate Course … 2127
5 Conclusions
BIM has been adopted in the IBPD course since 2018 and this creates a platform for
the students to achieve BIM collaboration in the aspects of design coordination,
construction planning and cost management. The development of an interdisci-
plinary course content in BIM is vital in preparation of future professionals for the
contemporary architecture, engineering and construction environment. The IBPD is
a unique course that supports the students’ interdisciplinary BIM learning and they
can exchange the BIM data for collaboration through the departmental BIM server.
After the course, opportunities are provided for the students to showcase their
excellence in BIM adoption to senior practitioners who probably are their
prospective employers. In conclusion, the concepts of iBIM implementation in
IBPD demonstrate a successful case in BIM education and pave the way for future
BIM teaching and learning in tertiary institutions.
Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the endless support from the
Department of Architecture and Civil Engineering of the City University of Hong Kong on BIM
adoption in IBPD.
References
1. Barison MB, Santos ET (2010) BIM teaching strategies: An overview of the current
approaches. In: Proceedings of the international conference on computing in civil and building
engineering, ICCCBE 2010, Nottingham, UK
2. Becerik-Gerber B, Ku K, Jazizadeh F (2012) BIM-enabled virtual and collaborative
construction engineering and management. J Prof Issues Eng Educ Pract 138(3):234–245
3. Eastman C, Teicholz P, Liston K (2008) BIM handbook: a guide to building information
modeling for owners, managers, designers, engineers and contractors. Wiley, New York
4. Fok WH (2017) An integrated building project development course for construction-related
undergraduate programmes. EASEC-15, Xian, China
2128 C. C. W. Keung and W. H. Fok
5. Keung CW (2017) A conceptual model of cloud-based virtual community for BIM innovation
and promotion. In: Proceedings of the 21st international conference on advancement of
construction management and real estate, construction research institute of construction
management, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
6. Rezgui Y, Beach T, Rana O (2013) A governance approach for BIM management across
lifecycle and supply chains using mixed-modes of information delivery. J Civ Eng Manage 19
(2):239–258
7. Singh V, Gu N, Wang X (2011) A theoretical framework of a BIM-based multi-disciplinary
collaboration platform. Autom Constr 20:134–144
8. Tisdel RC, Mulva S (2007) A case study of a design-build competition in a construction
program. In: Proceedings of the 43rd annual conference by associated schools of construction,
Northern Arizona University, Flagstaff, Arizona, USA
9. Wong KA, Wong KF, Nadeem A (2011) Building information modelling for tertiary
construction education in Hong Kong. J Inf Technol Constr 16:467–476
Application of Knowledge Management
and BIM Technology for Maintenance
Management of Concrete Structures
1 Introduction
3 Research Methodology
The KM system focuses mainly on managing the expertise required for mainte-
nance decision-making, especially on the condition analysis of concrete structures
during maintenance management. BIM technology is adopted as the information
carrier. Figure 1 demonstrates the flow of the KM system in this paper.
The KM system includes two groups of people in different backgrounds and a
transfer procedure, explained as follows:
The prototype is the materialization of the knowledge from the expert’s brain, which is
also difficult for a non-expert (user) to understand. Moreover, non-experts are not
concerned about the details of knowledge (e.g., the basic principles, theoretical rela-
tionships or logical framework). What they really care is how to apply the prototype to
solve a new problem. Before transferring the knowledge to non-experts, experts should
simplify the prototype to meet non-expert’s needs. The simplified prototype hides some
For expertise
of the complex knowledge but reserves full functionalities. A carrier for the transfer of
prototype from experts to non-experts is necessary. Application with easy-to-operate
user interfaces can be made to carry the knowledge. Usually, referring to expertise of
many disciplines is required to make decision for even one maintenance action;
therefore, choosing a platform to store and share the knowledge can benefit the main-
tenance management participants. The platform can be built up by using BIM with
secondary development.
In the process of knowledge use, non-experts get the permission to access the
application and then understand the usage method. It is the most important to know
where to input data and control parameters as well as how to obtain the results from
the user interface of the application. Non-experts can finally apply the knowledge to
solve a new similar problem.
A complete KM system is proposed with the usage of BIM. During the procedure,
the most important step is to set up the integrated platform, which can receive the
expertise from experts as well as deliver the expertise to non-experts. An infor-
mation platform that can aggregate as well as store information is efficient for
long-term knowledge sharing. A BIM software is designed to be applied to the life
cycle management of structures due to its 3D visualization model and the feasibility
of customizing new features via API. The platform integrates a wide variety of
information: 3D geometry information provided by BIM and a functional module
provided by another software and placed on the platform by BIM plugin (Fig. 2).
The basic platform is flexible since the work sharing feature can allow multiple
users from different locations to access the central model by internet with BIM
software. That is, the integrated platform can be set up anywhere once users have
the BIM software with a central model license and a knowledge plugin.
This platform can realize the knowledge aggregation and knowledge sharing
among participants of different knowledge backgrounds and realize the integration
of multidisciplinary knowledge based on visualization.
4 Case Study
From the beginning, experts conceive the simulation models in their minds by using
a lot of scientific knowledge. Chloride ion penetration into concrete can be
described as a mixed form of moisture transport and chloride ion immobilization
and transfer. From the microscopic point of view, the fluid-solid coupling inter-
action between porosity change and permeability change under hydrostatic pressure
in unsaturated concrete cannot be ignored in the process of chloride ion penetration.
To fully reveal the mechanism of chloride ion penetration, three parts of knowledge
should be considered as follows (Fig. 3):
Application of Knowledge Management and BIM Technology … 2135
(1) Moisture transport with Richards’ equation is employed to explain the water
penetration into the structure. Richards’ equation as given in Eq. (1) in pressure
head is used as a governing differential equation for isothermal
saturated-unsaturated single-phase flow [12].
(2) Fluid-solid coupling in the process is used to explain the concrete porosity
changing with pore pressure. According to Cui et al. [2], the relationship
between porosity and pore pressure is given in Eq. (2).
(3) Equation (3) simulates the chloride ion transfer process in concrete
(diffusion-convection equation). A convective term is added to the Fick’s
second law of diffusion to explain the mechanisms of diffusion-convection [11].
To transform the tacit knowledge in the expert brain into explicit knowledge,
visualization computational software is needed, such as a simulation software for
solving the partial differential equations and image software for displaying the
calculation results. Experts can conduct chloride ion penetration simulation with
their theoretical knowledge and environmental parameters by using numerical
software. The numerical software encompasses the whole workflow from modelling
to simulating—from building up geometric model, defining boundaries, assigning
material properties, describing specific phenomena, to finally solving and post
processing models for producing accurate and trustworthy results. The
second-development method in numerical software allows experts to create cus-
tomized and easy-to-use applications based on the complicated simulation. Experts
can simplify the simulation process by creating and/or customizing applications
with open partial parameters related to the numerical model of chloride ion pene-
tration process. Then a cloud technology is adopted to deploy the application and
deliver the application to non-experts through internet. Experts upload the appli-
cation to internet, and non-experts can run the application on any computer with a
2136 Y. F. Zhang et al.
Fig. 4 Knowledge creating, simplifying and transferring process for chloride ion penetration
simulation
network through web browsers. The process for the simulation knowledge creating,
simplifying and transferring is shown in Fig. 4.
As the representative of the BIM software, Autodesk Revit [3] was selected as the
basis of the maintenance management platform in this paper. The maintenance
management platform is built up, as shown in Fig. 5, containing two kinds of
information: a 3D visual model and a knowledge plugin module on chloride ion
penetration simulation. The 3D visual model is important during the maintenance
management of concrete structure by bringing us a strong visual impact and a
perfect reproduction of the real world. The expertise plugin module linking to the
on-cloud application makes it possible for decision makers of maintenance man-
agement to trigger the applications in local computer.
Application of Knowledge Management and BIM Technology … 2137
5 Conclusions
BIM has been widely adopted in the design and construction stages of concrete
structures with the advantage of building a 3D virtual reality digital model to
facilitate the collaboration of workers. Knowledge management proposes the
concept of making full use of knowledge which is critical to improve the pro-
ductivity and efficiency of maintenance management. From the research presented
in the paper, the efficient information communication approach can be implemented
by using the knowledge management to illustrate the information flow and using
BIM as a platform for information integration and sharing. The case study
demonstrates the process of the proposed efficient information communication
approach.
This approach enables people from different backgrounds to enter the knowledge
sharing system, in which knowledge is created by experts, aggregated in sharing
platform and distributed to non-experts. The form of knowledge is very flexible
because the explicitness degree and the simplification degree of knowledge can be
customized to meet user needs. Additionally, the integrated information platform
proposed in this approach improves the working efficiency and productivity com-
pared to managing knowledge separately.
The approach proposed in this paper is an effective real-time communication
platform for project team members with internet access which can change the
conventional knowledge communication modes, eliminate time and space barriers
for information communication, break the knowledge isolated island and reuse the
knowledge.
Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge the financial support from China
Scholarship Council (CSC).
2138 Y. F. Zhang et al.
References
1. Azhar S (2011) Building information modeling (BIM): trends, benefits, risks, and challenges
for the AEC industry. Leadersh Manage Eng 11(3):241–252
2. Cui X, Marc Bustin R (2005) Volumetric strain associated with methane desorption and its
impact on coalbed gas production from deep coal seams. AAPG Bull 89(9):1181–1202
3. Eastman C, Teicholz P, Sacks R, Liston K (2011) BIM handbook: a guide to building
information modeling for owners, managers, designers, engineers and contractors. Wiley,
Hoboken
4. Hamzah N, Ismail ZA, Kamaruzzaman SNA, Mutalib A, Ani AIC (2016) A CMMS expert
using BIM for IBS building maintenance. In: MATEC Web of Conferences, vol 66
5. Ivona O (2009) The importance of tacit knowledge within the organization, The Annals of the
University of Oradea
6. Johnson WHA (2007) Mechanisms of tacit knowledge: pattern recognition and synthesis.
J Knowl Manage 11(4):123–139
7. Liu F, Jallow AK, Anumba CJ, Wu D (2013) Building knowledge modelling: integrating
knowledge in BIM. In: Proceedings of the CIB W78
8. Ministry of land, infrastructure, transport and tourism (2003) Proposal of concept in
maintenance and renewal of road structures (Japanese)
9. Miettinen R, Paavola S (2014) Beyond the BIM utopia: approaches to the development and
implementation of building information modelling. Autom Constr 43:84–91
10. Nonaka I (1994) A dynamic theory of organizational knowledge creation. Organ Sci 5(1):14–
37
11. Nguyen PT, Bastidas-Arteaga E, Amiri O et al (2017) An efficient chloride ingress model for
long term lifetime assessment of reinforced concrete structures under realistic climate and
exposure conditions. Int J Concr Struct Mater 11(2):199–213
12. Richards LA (1931) Capillary conduction of liquids through porous mediums. Physics 1
(5):318–333
13. Smith EA (2001) The role of tacit and explicit knowledge in the workplace. J Knowl Manage
5(4):311–321
14. Seki H (1997) Research activities on maintenance of concrete structures (Japanese). Proc
Japan Soc Civ Eng 1997(557):1–14
15. Tan HC, Anumba CJ, Carrillo PM, Bouchlaghem D, Kamara J, Udeaja C (2010) Capture and
reuse of project knowledge in construction. Wiley, Hoboken
16. Volk R, Stengel J, Schultmann F (2014) Building Information Modeling (BIM) for existing
buildings—literature review and future needs. Autom Constr 38:109–127
17. Young N, Jones S, Bernstein HM (2008) Building information modeling (BIM) -
transforming design and construction to achieve greater industry productivity. SmartMarket
Report. McGraw Hill, New York
18. Yokota H, Hashimoto K (2013) Life-cycle management of concrete structures. Int J Struct 4
(1/2):138–145
Applicability of Building Information
Modeling Integrated Augmented Reality
in Building Facility Management
Keywords Augmented reality Building information modeling Digital con-
struction Facility management Visualisation
1 Introduction
2 Literature Review
Facility management (FM) is the integration of people, place, process and tech-
nology within an organization to maintain and develop the agreed services which
support and improve the effectiveness of its primary activities. It is an effective form
of outreach business management which aims to provide relevant, cost-effective
services to support and optimize the working activities [5].
Facility managers (FMs) are responsible for making sure systems of the built
environment, or facility, work, harmoniously. They could have many different
titles, but they share common roles within their respective organizations such as
building operation and maintenance, sustainability, risk management, communi-
cation, performance and quality, project management, etc. Based on experiences,
Applicability of Building Information Modeling Integrated Augmented Reality … 2141
facility managers are able to define the requirements for the use of the future
operational costs. Facility manager indicates a limited functional program of the
building’s space usage from the perspective of users. As, some parts of the building
concerns about the future maintenance and repairs, details of the structure and
equipment necessary for the technical support are needed. Facility manager in
co-appointment with the investor and designers characterizes the requirements for
the building from the perspective of users, and this can help reduce the costs and
better achieve building services for the users [7].
Chotipanich [3] studied facility management practices in Thailand and found
that facility management services mostly involve building operations, maintenance
and routine services. Strategic facility management, planning and consulting ser-
vices are being used at the minimum levels. More, the development of facility
management practice is hindered by the attitudes of building owners who regard
their own physical resources as risky, burdensome obstacles to daily work. Physical
resources have a low priority in most organizations. Decision-makers take a
short-term view of investments in construction and set close limits on budgets for
maintenance and operation costs. The author concluded that facility management in
Thailand appears to take place on operational levels. Many facility managers are
constrained by their own business culture from trying to imagine their mission in a
broader scope. In short, facility management practice in Thailand has been adapted
and implemented in line with constraints of local knowledge, technology, invest-
ment and cultural preferences [3].
3 Methodology
(See Fig. 2)
The BIMAR system will be developed through software and plug-ins as listed:
Unity (Game engine), Vuforia, Microsoft Visual Studio, Android Studio, Autodesk
Revit, Autodesk 3D Studio Max, and Autodesk CAD. Plus, the hardware used for
BIMAR system: an android device “Samsung Galaxy Note 9” and a gaming/design
laptop “Asus ROG G501 JW”.
Applicability of Building Information Modeling Integrated Augmented Reality … 2145
4 Preliminary Work
To implement the system with the existing building, an exploratory study was
conducted to understand a baseline situation of the current building facility man-
agement practice of the selected laboratory building. An interview with the building
and ground division’s staff of SIIT was conducted to gain some information about
the current practices. It was found that a preventive maintenance was being used to
operate the building to maintain serviceability and efficiency, which consists of the
following activities:
1. Inspection: daily/monthly/yearly check due to its lifetime.
2. Cleaning: clean/clear dust/something that stick with object and make it work
better.
3. Repair or replace: fix small issue by repair or replace some part before the whole
system breakdown.
In the inspection part, paper-forms of inspection will be printed out to record the
work. After that, there will be another request-form for the replacement if there is a
part needing replacement. All data records are in a paper-based format and stored in
folders that are kept at the office.
The BIMAR system will be experimented with a new lab building at SIIT. It would
help the team to visualize the pipe system, check for its information, make a record,
and save the data to the online database system by using a mobile device. It would
help the team to save time, reduce papers, and improve productivity.
The prototype of the BIMAR system will be experimented by staffs of Building
and Ground division of SIIT, who is currently working as a facility management
team. The prototype will focus on the sprinkler and aircon system of a room in the
newly constructed laboratory building. Before the test, participants will be guided
to understand how the utilize of the BIMAR system. During the test, the partici-
pants will be able to use the application to visualize the digital model on a real
environment by scanning the target attached to a specific position in the room. They
could choose to see the model of the whole system or a specific part, and also an
information panel when the participants click on the AR model. After getting to see
the digital model on the real physical building and its information (properties,
maintenance history, supplier, etc.).
After the test, the participants will be asked to complete a questionnaire about
the usability of the developed system including its usefulness, information, and
2148 S. Khan and K. Panuwatwanich
interface quality of the application. Feedback will be taken to determine the par-
ticipants’ satisfaction of the BIMAR system as well as any recommendation for
further improvement.
5 Conclusion
BIM is a useful concept that has been widely adopted in the construction industry as
a tool to enhance collaboration and project delivery, including facility management.
Augmented reality is a technology that can be used to overlay BIM model onto the
real world. In facility management, visualizing the exact model on the exact
location within the real-world environment is very important to better understand
the parts requiring maintenance and to retrieve important information such as its
service life, past maintenance records, suppliers, etc. By integrated BIM with AR, a
system has been proposed and developed to be used to improve the work in the
building facility management. A study was conducted to investigate the current
practices of building facility management within a university campus in Thailand,
as an experimental case. Six research tasks have been proposed to develop and test
a BIMAR system. By capitalizing on the BIM and AR technology, it is expected
that the developed system will help the facility management team to improve their
work efficiency and productivity.
References
1. Ahmed S (2018) A review on using opportunities of augmented reality and virtual reality in
construction project management. Organ Technol Manage Constr Int J 10(1):1839–1852
2. Baek F, Ha I, Kim H (2019) Augmented reality system for facility management using
image-based indoor localization. Autom Constr 99:18–26
3. Chotipanich S (2002) Principles and concepts of facility management in thailand. note for
presentation in FM Thailand Seminar 2002. Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok
4. Gao X, Pishdad-Bozorgi P (2019) Bim-enabled facilities operation and maintenance: A review.
Adv Eng Inform 39:227–247
5. IFMA (2019) What is facility management? Houston, USA. https://www.ifma.org/about/what-
is-facility-management. Accessed 2019
6. Kubba S (2017) Building information modeling (bim). In: Kubba S (ed) Handbook of green
building design and construction. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford
7. Potkany M, Vetrakova M, Babiakova M (2015) Facility management and its importance in the
analysis of building life cycle. Proc Econ Financ 26:202–208
8. Volk R, Stengel J, Schultmann F (2014) Building information modeling (bim) for existing
buildings—literature review and future needs. Autom Constr 38:109–127
9. Wang J, Pour Rahimian F, Ibrahim R, Wang X, Shou W, Xu B (2014) Integrating bim and
augmented reality for interactive architectural visualisation. Constr Innov 14(4):453–476
Project Management for the Out Patient
Department Building-Planning
for Hospital Design and Construction
1 Introduction
Hospital building is always complicate and concerns many disciplines, more than
normal buildings. Project Management Consultant (PMC) is, therefore, important
for smooth and successful project outcome, as preoccupation of all aspects con-
cerning efficiency, safety and hygiene of operations and maintenance.
The project of Out Patient Department Building is to construct a new building
which would replace old and small hospital buildings. The building is to be 15
stories with 4 basements. The construction site has a very close perimeter with other
existing buildings and the hospital infrastructures which is continuously operational
throughout the construction. Therefore, demolition and construction planning is to
To achieve the Project Management’s role of quality, time and budget, consider-
ation and implementation of the following factors are to be taken seriously.
Project Management for the Out Patient Department Building … 2151
Project owner’s expectation might differ and it results in the design concept and the
construction details. PMC had to acquire the exact expectation of the Project
Owner. In order not to miss out any important requirements, PMC had a checklist
of basic expectation of the owner, for instance, the expectation of the hospital
standard, either the local standard of the international standard such as Joint
Commission International (JCI) and the building conservation standard such as
LEADS of Green Building Standard. PMC had to inform the consequences of these
standards that will affect the project parameters such as construction cost and time.
Planning is the earliest step of the project. It has to be done in accordance with the
Owner’s Expectations. Planning of this project is very sensitive because it affects
timing and cost. It would be extremely difficult to have a planning for a project to
replace and construct a new building on a tight existing site while the whole
operations are still on. Relocation by preparing new space in other building and
migrating all equipments and staffs to a temporary site is to be planned carefully
with the black-out period to be shortest. PMC had to acquire full information from
the relevant departments to make a planning and phasing of the project. After the
planning is approved by the owner’s administration committee, it was distributed
among the concerning parties and the planning was strictly enforced.
2152 P. Chaiseri and T. Issariyarutthanon
In term of space and area design program, proper location and size of each
department and each room is to be considered. PMC had to derive proper location
from Function Program and Connection Flow Diagram. The space and area of each
room was discussed with the users based on their requirement and the PMC’s
recommendations. For example, the route of each medical service for staffs and
patients should be short, even inside separated room. For example, the doctor’s
check-up room should not be too small or too large. Too small room will be not
practical for doctor and assistant to move around whilst too large room will
lengthen the moving time from point-to-point. Thus, it would not be efficient.
type of socket and relevant system could be installed in the exact sequence of
construction as planned.
When all requirements are obtained, these will be set as a Design Basis that Design
Consultant would be obliged. The Design Consult (DC), then, has to perform his
professional practice conforming to the local building laws and regulations. With
the owner’s requirement to meet the hospital standard, either local or international
one, the Design Consultant has to comply with such standard.
While the standard has to be abided for the design basis, the construction details
have to be carefully designated. For some special purpose room such as detail for
radiated room, the pressurized system for the Operation Room, etc. PMC should be
able to monitor the detail design as the inappropriate detail would mean unsatis-
factory condition to use safely.
PMC urged that DC use Building Information Management (BIM) program.
This helped to integrate and monitor every part of the building from design to
construction. It gives Building Operation & Maintenance more efficiency.
Infection is one of the most crucial threats in the hospital. Because there are many
patients who carry various kind of germs and in the environment that transport
many kind of microbiology such as bacteria, virus and fungus, design of the
2154 P. Chaiseri and T. Issariyarutthanon
building has to be done with caution of the infection by means of both physical and
building ventilation system.
Physical design to prevent infection is to separate the Clean Zone and the
Contaminated Zone completely. The Clean Zone is where medical staffs, normal
people and patients are. The Contaminated Zone is where contaminated waste is.
The two zones must be completely separated with walls and closed doors. Corridors
of the two zones must not cross each other. Furthermore, the department with
respiration disease should be located in a separately closed zone or the farthest zone
because infection to other people might be easy.
Building ventilation system would play an important task in order to carry away
germs to the outside and bring fresh air from the outside in. Because fresh air
contain moisture and usually has higher temperature that the inside (as in tropical
area such as Thailand), it should be dehumidified and pre-cooled before entering the
inner atmosphere to prevent fungus from growing inside the unventilated area such
as air duct, ceiling and store.
PMC had to implement this precaution during the design stage and have a
thorough inspection during the construction.
To achieve the goal for efficient Operation & Maintenance (O&M) after the
building is handed over from the contractor, precautions are to be thoroughly
considered from the beginning of the conceptual design. O&M for the hospital
building could be divided into two aspects; Building O&M and Medical O&M.
Building O&M concerns about main facilities of the building; lighting,
air-conditioning system, building ventilation, fire alarm and fire fighting, power
supply, water supply & sanitary system, waste disposal & treatment system,
Information Technology system, cleaning, repairing, security system, structural
health monitoring and energy conservation monitoring.
Medical O&M concerns medical services operation, patient service, internal
document & sample transport system, medical equipment, food catering, laundry.
As for medical O&M, it is rather sensitive that the flow of each medical service
must be learned and developed furthermore. Medical staffs and patients should not
commute a long distance from the start until the finish of the process and all
directions must be clear in a straight manner. Clean Zone and Dirty Zone are to be
separated completely to meet the standard of hygiene.
Space planning and design in accordance with the requirements for O&M is one
of the success factors for the hospital project. Careless consideration will lead to
difficulties and inefficiency in the long run.
Project Management for the Out Patient Department Building … 2155
In order to achieve all requirements, the design work, which is done by Design
Consultant, is the first key step of the execution stage. Even though all requirements
are complete, sharp and clear, the design work still could not be complete and
correct without the design control process. Experiences of the design team
including the comprehensive attention of requirements and working are the main
factor of success. Number of designers in the design team does not guarantee the
delivery of perfect design work. Experienced staffs who actually work for the
project does matter. In terms of risk management and reality, the responsibility of
design team could not be relied on and just blame them when mistake occurs. The
damages are going to happen and, certainly, there is not beneficial to the project.
Therefore, the preventive thinking is the issue that the Project Management
Consultant has to consider. The design control with efficient tool is to be formulated
once all requirements have been settled and it is to be shared with the design team.
As the hospital project is one of the most complex buildings, in terms of building
system and complicates medical equipment, the allocation for scope of work for
each contractor is one of the most important matters. The Project Management
Consultant has to execute a strategic plan in order to compromise risk management,
cost management and quality management. The procurement strategy includes
package of procurement (Main Contractor/Owner Direct Contractor), work break-
down matrix, identification of nominated subcontractor and suppliers.
The construction is the final key step of the execution stage. Besides the normal
construction control process of time control, quality control, cost control, the
success of the project is to ensure that the construction is in compliance with
drawing & specification. The other factor that could lead to the success of the
project is the experience of Construction Supervision Consultant (CSC). The detail
of construction specifically for hospital project is the last mechanism to assure the
completeness of hospital. Do & Don’t List and Detail Handbook derived from
lessons learned in many projects shall be valuable to project and ensure that con-
struction is in control.
2156 P. Chaiseri and T. Issariyarutthanon
Considering the aforementioned success factors for the Extended OPD building of
Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, obstacles, solutions and lessons were learned
and recorded for academic benefit;
i) Function Program and Connection Flow Diagram had to be obtained from the
very beginning and had to be reviewed from occasionally by each department to see
whether there was any development is their requirement. Some of the later
requirements could not be fulfill since the main structure and system were already
in place.
ii) Expectation of the owner was a major requirement that had to be achieved.
High standard with lower cost is a key requirement since the hospital is a public
hospital under control of the Thai Red Cross and the role of the hospital is to serve
patients regardless of status at high medical standard.
iii) Planning and Phasing of the project was very crucial since the building was
to be constructed by replacing three small and outdated building while keeping one
conserved building in a very closed adjacent. Moving and migrating existing
department from the three small building to a temporary place and having a very
short pause of operation is to be brain-stormed. One small building was kept as a
site office for PMC, CSC and Contractors. The location of this building, after the
demolition, was designed to be a waste treatment plant for the building itself and
the adjacent buildings.
Planning for pedestrian traffic and road for vehicles had to be done with
diversion from the current one. Full protection had to be implemented.
iv) Space and Area Program was designed to have optimum and efficient size in
proper location.
v) Planning for future upgrade was implemented in the building skeletons.
Overall area is spacious for future renovation and relocation. Structural system was
determined to be concrete column and Reinforced Concrete flat slab system so that
any modification would be easily applicable. Main vertical shafts provide flexibility
for future retrofit of building and IT system.
vi) Selection of medical equipment was based on the compatibility with the
existing equipment so that users are acquainted with the system. The storage of
equipment parts and accessories became less.
vii) PMC set the Design Basis as per the requirements obtained from the owner.
BIM was requested for evaluating and monitoring the design and construction and
help reducing the in-site incompatible conflict.
viii) Demolition and site preparing needed very careful procedure. There were
many underground pipes and cables that were not known before. Thorough
checking was done to find out. Underground structure of the buildings to be
demolished and the adjacent buildings were found in the perimeter of the con-
struction site. Designers had to adjust the design in order to avoid these structures
Project Management for the Out Patient Department Building … 2157
Protection for pollution of dust, waste water, garbage and noise that might annoy
hospital staffs and patients are very serious and was one of the key valuations at the
time of evaluation the bidding contractors.
ix) For the prevention of infection, Clean Zone and Contaminated Zone were
separated completely. Higher pressurized air is applied in the Clean Zone to prevent
air from Contaminated Zone to flow into. Department of respiration disease was
separated and located on its own floor, as well as other departments.
Dehumidifier and filter is utilized for fresh air in the ventilation system. The air
is pre-cooled to prevent condensation that would let fungus grow which is not
acceptable for the hospital.
x) Operation and Maintenance issues were taken into design to provide effi-
ciency of the building and its system to serve the need of the hospital both the
building physical and the medical services.
For the physical of the building, utilities were rearranged in order to be easily
maintained. Cleaning equipments for the external facade were prepared. Modern
computer monitoring and control system was implemented with flexibility to
upgrade in the future.
For the medical services, O&M was included into space planning so that the
operation should be smoothest and efficient. Maintenance route line was consid-
ered that it would not block the medical operation
4 Conclusion
It is clear that comprehensive planning for both design and construction is benefitial
for the success of hospital project. Various factors have to be considered thoroughly
without ignoring any concerning matters. The key goals of the project; Quality,
Time and Budget could be achieved by means of integration of all relevant
expertise. Project Management Consultant plays important role to integrate and
control the input of all parties of the project team for the benefit of the project owner
as well as the project users; the hospital staffs and the patient.
Acknowledgements The authors would like to express sincere gratitude to Mr. Nimit
Phattarathanachote of Arun Chaiseri Consulting Engineers Co., Ltd. who contributed his vast and
useful experience of hospital construction.
Factors Affecting the International
Training Transfer for Capacity
Development of Road Asset
Management in Lao PDR
1 Introduction
This study was motivated by the Project for Improvement of Road Management
Capability to develop planning and technical ability of road maintenance works in
Lao PDR. The training program was known as the key element for better works on
road management supported by JICA, which aimed to improve infrastructure main-
tenance works together with improving the capability of human resource. There were
six external training programs under the improvement road management capability,
including: four trainings between 2012 and 2015 in Japan; and two trainings in
Thailand (1st external training in 2013 and 2nd training in 2017 which is the last
training under the program). Trainings in Japan were hosted by Ministry of Land,
Infrastructure and Transport (MLIT). Additional, two trainings in Thailand were
hosted by Department of Highway of Thailand. Each training invited five to six
departments under MPWT Lao PDR to attend each training. Through a series of
external trainings, the trainees were expected to gain knowledge and skills such as:
Asset management of road/bridge infrastructure, planning of road/bridge mainte-
nances including budget making, Human resources development, Controlling over
Factors Affecting the International Training Transfer … 2161
loaded vehicle. There are road infrastructure management projects and activities
which directly needed to use the transfer of learning after the training programs. It is
also the main support for the effectiveness on improvement of road management and
human resource in Lao PDR.
1.2 Objective
Based on the background of current issues on road infrastructure of Lao PDR, this
study emphasizes the study on transfer of training which can be viewed in two areas
such as (1) methodology and measurement of transfer and (2) what factor most
influences the transfer. This study integrated these two areas to describe the training
transfer process and gain insight into better understanding of the most influential
factors of training transfer which can be developing framework of the training pro-
gram. In particular, the study aims to understand the effect of the work environment on
the training transfer, due to the encouragement to attend, goal activities, reinforce-
ment activities, and behaviours modelling are descriptive by the supervisory support.
Transfer of training:
Rapid change in economy, society, technology, dynamic environment and the
effect of globalization encouraged organizational leaders to implement training to
improve the performance of their employees to get effective project [9]. Many
companies in U.S. operating domestic and international spend billions of dollars
annually on training initiatives for their workforces. The transfer of training in work
organization have seen large investment in many organizations recently due to it
becoming an important issue [8]. Also, many organizations in developing countries
encourage their employees to participate in domestic and overseas training [3].
For more than three decades, many researchers have tried to provide the answer
of the influence of factors on the training transfer process [1, 2]. Many studies have
led to a better understand of the training transfer process and system. Many models
and systems have been developed to explain how effective training transfer char-
acteristic [10]. It is important to consider the role of trainees’ individual and work
environment characteristics as influencing training effectiveness because it needed
to fully understand the effective cause by trainee [7].
For many years, studies on transfer of learning issues and concerns are
increasing. The main issue of learning transfer motivates on how knowledge, skills
and attitudes can apply or fail to apply in new situations. There are three areas effect
on the training transfer involving (1) training design, (2) trainee characteristic and
(3) work environment [1, 2] and [5].
2162 A. Bounnak and M. Henry
Work Environment:
A literature review found the work environment strongly affects the training transfer
[1], Trainees responded how the important and needed in their workplace of the
training transfer depend on the opportunity [6]. According to the LTSI model in the
work environment, there are five main factors are focused on in this study,
including positive and negative aspects of personal outcomes, support and sanction
of supervisor, and motivation to transfer.
The work environment is the most influential element among three main ele-
ments for many studies on training transfer. Work environment characteristic define
as strong support for the important of environmental and motivation to transfer.
Moreover, there are several factors related to the work environment which is the
personal behaviour or motivated of transfer, supervisor support, peers support and
rule of effort transfer [1].
2 Overview of Investigation
The LTSI model adopted to this study is based on the work environment influence
theme. This model is the starting point for collaborative planning with affected
employees [6] which led to the result of the influence of organizational factors on
trainees’ transfer of learning. The theme of LTSI model consists of seven elements;
however, this study covered only five elements. As the outline of the interview did
not cover the other two elements, the study will focus on the elements as positive
personal outcome, negative personal outcome, supervisor support, supervisor
sanction, and motivation to transfer. This model was adopted to analyze the
interview results.
The general interview outlines by Burke [2] were used as a guideline due to the
many variables involved in explaining the training transfer process. This content
carried on the three sections in the Table 2. Section 1 covers the general back-
ground of the trainees, including the position and responsibility during training
course and current position of trainee in order to recall their benefits from training
program and also to make comfort atmosphere for trainee. Section 2 was about the
usefulness of training contents after training program, and aimed to evaluate the
direction to see how the trainees expressed on applying experience and knowledge
from training program in their job and work environment in various ways.
Section 2 also aimed to classify the usefulness and better understand their needed
together with observing trainees’ expectation with the training program. Section 3
focused on sharing new knowledge to their organization, target on diverse
multi-sharing strategy expressive in order to get the result on the most effective
factor from work environment individually and alliance.
2164 A. Bounnak and M. Henry
The expecting result emphases on what and how the factors of work environ-
ment or organization affected the trainees in order to encourage them sharing the
new knowledge from the external training in their organization. Moreover, the
direction of these contents also led to the multi-sharing strategy for individuals and
alliances in their work climate, as well as the motivation to transfer.
The target of this study consisted of participants from Ministry of Public Works and
Transport of Lao PDR who participated in external training programs under the
project of the improvement of building capacity on road management in Lao PDR
between 2012 and 2017. The external training consisted of six training programs,
with four trainings in Japan and two trainings in Thailand. Each of trainees par-
ticipated in at least one external training program. The sample included 16 out of 24
trainees in the total from the JICA recorded who attended the external trainings
under this project. As the external training was held outside of Lao PDR, the
participant was selected based on requirements such as intermediate English level,
at least three years work experience together with senior level, able to make
decisions on road works, and be able to continue the future plan on road man-
agement development project. The sample was slightly dominated by female
respondents among six departments under MPWT Lao PDR. Respectively of
position and responsibility on work, more than five interviewees are senior level
with one female and about 11 technical officers. Moreover, this data collection was
transcribed in Lao language, then translated to English by the interviewer. The
interviewees were contacted to get permission through email from the interviewer
directly in order to schedule before the actual interview date.
Factors Affecting the International Training Transfer … 2165
The result of this study relied on the LTSI model as a guideline, with the contents of
the interview following the work environment theme. Work environment is the
center of the key elements for evaluating the training transfer process. The interview
outline covered only five elements, or sub-themes, of the work environment,
including positive personal outcome, negative personal outcome, supervisor sup-
port, supervisor sanction and motivation to transfer.
Personal outcome in the positive way can be applied for trainees who were suc-
cessful in their work after the training finished. This positive outcome also refers to
successfully applying knowledge and experience in work and get promoted to
higher position individually. It was found that trainees gained advantage and got
promoted based on their performance, which evaluated as an excellent performance.
During the interview session, trainees willing to share their experience of training to
researcher lead to the different perspectives on the benefits of training transfer. One
trainee shared many interesting experiences related to the positive outcome, such as,
“…for governance performance, I got promoted from technical officer to be deputy
director, after then I was a director of division. Another part of the project I was promoted
from engineer to be senior and now I am vice team project…”
In this part, it was found that the trainee was successful and led to a positive
outcome for the individual, as well as created the benefit to their organization as a
whole. The action taken by trainees provided positive impact on work as a suc-
cessful project could not happen without their performance.
The result of this element refers to unsuccessful application of the lessons learned to
their work; in other words, the trainees were unable to transfer their knowledge.
Negative outcome also refers to the negative result of personal action taken by
trainees that complicated the transfer of learning. The consequences from this issue
came from various situations of trainees’ expressions during the interview. For
example, the below was conveyed from trainee:
“…this training showed me the current road management system they are using. All
contents were directly pair of my works, unfortunately they are only benefit for our future
plan which not applicable to implement now due to different condition. For example: they
showed us how do they maintenance asphalt pavement, but in our area, we don’t have
asphalt yet…”
2166 A. Bounnak and M. Henry
There are two major situations came out as negative outcome. The first situation
is an expectation of the training contents met trainees’ expectation, but only had
benefit for future plans. Another situation is sharing new knowledge to coworkers
under the same organization is optional, e.g. trainees did not have any requirement
to transfer due to many circumstances of work environment, which did not create
benefits for anybody involved.
Many studies have found that support by the organization has the largest impact on
transfer of training, especially that the supervisor is the key element to inspire this
process. Specifically, the involvement of the supporting supervisor and approval
and encouragement by supervisor before and after participated the training program
are key factors. We found the organization, as well as the support tool from
supervisors, were big inspirations for the trainees’ behavior to sharing and applying
new knowledge from the training program to their job and work environment.
This result is also supported by Faizal et al. [4], which found that the supervisor
opposes the use of new skills, knowledge and new techniques that are difference
from what was taught in training due to some difficult in applying to the current
situation in the job.
This item corresponds to the interview question: Are there any policies for sup-
porting the sharing of new knowledge that was learned from the external training?
Factors Affecting the International Training Transfer … 2167
It was found out that trainees were willing to share information directly and indi-
rectly to their coworkers in different ways due to their specific and non-specific
sharing regulation at their organization. Having a specific policy is a strong key
element of training transfer, and many trainees responded to this topic during the
interview, such as:
“…we have special rule of sharing information after international training by presenting
the summarize of new knowledge in the annual workshop of our department within one
month after the training program have been done…”
This factor focuses on the strength of training transfer. It is the strong motivation
to transfer, and trainees strongly believed in the specific policy of sharing knowl-
edge after training as the key element for effective training transfer. This result is
supported by many studies on work environment and found that it has the largest
effect on the trainees when sharing new knowledge in their organization, and that it
is the strong enforcement in the training transfer process by Baldwin [1].
4 Conclusions
This paper has presented some issues on transfer of training due to the influence of
factors in the work environment. It also provided discussion based on the Learning
Transfer System Inventory (LTSI) as an evaluation unit of the data collection. In
this context, the training transfer process was examined from the five factors of
work environment involved: positive and negative personal outcome, support and
sanctions from supervisor and motivation to transfer. It was found that organiza-
tions which have specific policy supporting sharing have a deep relationship with
training transfer. Moreover, the climate of the work environment related directly to
moderate the training transfer process.
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank the Japan International Cooperation Agency
(JICA) for the financial support and providing information on the Project for Improvement of Road
Management Capability in Lao PDR, as well as the kind cooperation of the Ministry of Public
Works and Transport of Laos (MPWT-Laos) for providing information on the training of Road
Management in Laos.
References
1. Baldwain TT, Ford KJ (1988) Transfer of training: a review and directions for future research.
Pers Psychol 41(1):63–105
2. Burke LA, Hutchins HM (2007) Training transfer: an integrative literature review. Hum
Resour Dev Rev 6(3):263–296
3. Dirani K (2017) Understanding the process of transfer of training in military context:
marching into new role. Adv Develop Hum Resour 19(1):101–112
2168 A. Bounnak and M. Henry
4. Faizal ANY, Saiful HM, Bekri R, Jamil AB, Amiruddin MH, Ruhizan MY, Arasinah K
(2017) Impact of work environment on learning transfer of skills. Pertanika-Soc Sci Humanit
254(8):33–40
5. Hamid WHW, Saman MZM, Saud MS (2012) Exploring factors influencing the transfer of
training using a grounded theory study: issues and research agenda. Procedia-Soc Behav Sci
56(2012):662–672
6. Holton EF, Bates RA, Ruona WEA (2000) Development of a generalized learning transfer
system inventory. Hum Resour Dev Q 11(4):333–360
7. Homklin T, Takahasi Y, Techakanont K (2013) Effects of individual and work environment
characteristics on training effectiveness: evidence from skill certification system for
automotive industry in Thailand. Int Bus Res 6(12):1–16
8. Hillsman TL, Kupritz VW (2006) A Conceptual Model of Training That Includes the Physical
Environment
9. Noorizan MM, Afzan NF, Norfazlina AZ, Akma AS (2016) The moderating effects of
motivation on work environment and training transfer: a preliminary analysis. Procedia-Econ
Finan 37(2016):158–163
10. Velada R, Caetano A, Michel JW, Lyons BD, Kavanagh MJ (2007) The effects of training
design, individual characteristics and work environment on transfer of training. Int J Train
Dev 11(4):282–294
A Real-Time Computer Vision System
for Workers’ PPE and Posture Detection
in Actual Construction Site
Environment
1 Introduction
2 Methodology
The CV used in this research refers to the process of transferring the knowledge of
site workers and their postures onto a computer to interpret site videos and retrieve
meaningful information. The CV system included three main parts: a data acqui-
sition unit; a processing and understanding unit; and a reporting unit.
This research used a 2D camera designed for the construction site applications
rather than off-the-shelf cameras. The camera included four main parts: a power
A Real-Time Computer Vision System for Workers … 2171
unit, a processing unit, a data storage unit and a camera, as shown in Fig. 1.
Construction site environments include dust, direct sunlight, rain and the movement
of heavy equipment; therefore, the cameras needed protection to prevent them from
being damaged. A plastic box was used for this purpose and designed to sit at the
top of a tripod that can reach heights of up to three meters to ensure the coverage of
a wide area. The recording system included a 2D camera with a framerate of 24 fps
and a resolution of 1024 by 720. The camera recorded video clips that were 41 s
long. It also sent each frame to a cloud browser that shows one fps. The camera gets
5-v from the processing unit and sent back the footage to the same unit. The
processing unit then saved the footage as videos on the external hard drive and sent
images to the cloud browser.
It can be challenging to have a constant electrical power connection on a con-
struction site as additional arrangements are needed. The position of the camera
may need to be changed as the construction work progresses. Therefore, the camera
was designed to run on solar power. The CVA system also included a small battery
of 12-v that the transformer converted into 5-v power. The processor unit organised
the power connection between the transformer and the camera. It also controlled the
storage of the footage storage on the hard drive and in the cloud browser. Three
cameras were deployed on three different construction sites at allocated locations.
The orientation of the cameras at the top of the tripods helped to cover a flat area of
up to 20 m2 at ground level. The CVA system detected multiple objects, such as
helmets, gear and workers, as well as the workers’ postures. The distance between
the camera and the targeted workstation was around 30 to 40 m.
2172 A. Moohialdin et al.
1. Initialization;
2. Input1: Request_To_Upload_A_Video_Record;
3. Get_Information_About_ The_Video;
4. Output1: Show_Video_ Duration,Resolution,FrameRate,Number_Of_Frames;
5. Input2: Request_To_Inter_The_Required<Video_Resolution>;
6. Input3: Request_To_Inter_The_Required<Frame_Rate>;
7. Set_Timer_Start_Point;
8. Create_Output_Folder<Resized_Frames,Segemented_Frames, Frames_With_Bounding_Box>;
9. For i==1: Number_Of_Frames;
10. Stract_Frames_From_Video;
11. Resize_Frames_As<Input2>;
12. Output2: Save_Step11Otcomes_Into_ Resized_Frames_Floder<Frame_Name_
ìframeî_sequential_number_of_three_ digits>;
13. Segment_Moving_Objects_From_Each_Frame;
14. Output3: Save_ Step13Otcomes _Into_ Segmented_Frames_Floder<Frame_Name_
ìframeî_sequential_number_of_three_ digits>;
15. Set_Fliters_For_Human_Detection;
16. Draw_Bounding_Box_Arround_Moving_Objects;
17. Output4: Save_ Step16Otcomes _Into_Frames_With_Bounding _Floder<Frame_
Name_ìframeî_sequential_number_of_three_ digits>;
18. Count_Number_Of_Bounding_Boxes;
19. Output5: WriteVideo<For_ALL_Frames_In_Resized_Frames_Floder>; Video_Name
<îResized_Videoî>;
20. Output6: WriteVideo<For_ALL_Frames_In_Segmented_Frames_Floder>; Video_
Name<îSegmented_Videoî>;
21. Output7: WriteVideo<For_ALL_Frames_In_ Frames_With_Bounding_Box _Folder>;
Video_Name<î Bounding_Box_Videoî>;
22. Display<Output5, Output6, Output7>;
23. Set_Timer_End_Point;
24. End;
25. Display<îNum ber_Of_Workersî== Number_Of_Bounding_Boxes>;
26. Display<îProcessing_Timeî==Timer_Counts>;
27. End
Fig. 2 The pseudocode of video resolution and frame rate sensitivity analysis
A Real-Time Computer Vision System for Workers … 2173
r ðx; yÞ
f ðx; yÞ ¼ bðx; yÞ ð1Þ
gðx; yÞ
where, f ðx; yÞ is the image function and represents each pixel in the image; x and y
are integer variables representing the location of each pixel; and r; b and g is the
colour channel. The colour intensity range is an integer number within 0 and 255.
The images were defined as a function of the location of the pixels and the time
f ðx; y; tÞ, where t denotes the time domain. The colour intensity of the moving
pixels changes from the image at a time (t) to time (t þ DtÞ: The RGB image
function can be formulated as:
r ðx; y; tÞ
f ðx; y; tÞ ¼ bðx; y; tÞ ð2Þ
gðx; y; tÞ
TensorFlow has multiple models that have different processing speeds and levels of
accuracy, such as SSD-Mobilenet, R-CNN, Faster-RCNN and Mask-RCNN mod-
els. This research compared Tensorflow models to assess their ability to achieve the
required rate of 10 fps. The methodology also considered 0.30 s per 10 frames as a
safety margin of the processing speed and 25 mAP (mean average precision) as the
minimum accepted accuracy level. Only two models met the criteria:
SSD-Mobilenet-V1-FPN and Faster-RCNN-Inception-V2. In term of processing
speed, the two models are very similar, but Faster-RCNN has been proven to be the
most accurate model [8]. Therefore, Faster-RCNN-Inception-V2 was chosen to
build the detection model.
2174 A. Moohialdin et al.
The first stage of the video analysis involved detecting if there were workers in each
frame using the highly visible items, i.e., the safety helmets and highly visible
clothing (gear). The worker detection algorithm considered three main classes
(helmet, gear and worker’s body) to detect the site workers in a real environment.
The outcomes of this step provided bounding boxes around helmets and gear, as
Fig. 3-a illustrates.
The automated postures identification process provided information on a limited
number of worker body postures. It also included the identification of the upper and
lower parts of the workers’ bodies based on the bounding boxes around the
workers. As the workers perform different activities, their posture changes and their
upper and lower body parts form different lines and angles. In this research, both
parts were assumed to create only two lines with one angle. There is also one angle
connecting the two parts. Based on this simplified definition of the workers’ body
postures, the decision tree defined five different postures positions (see Fig. 3-b).
Initially, the proposed was designed to detect five postures including standing,
sitting, kneeling, bending and overhead. Then, the model has been modified to use
these five postures as a base to estimate four more postures including walking,
pushing, carrying and climbing. The primary assumption of the posture detection
still depends on the number of lines and angles created from the postures. For
instance, in case the worker is walking, the upper body part will create a similar
pattern as the standing posture while the lower body part will create two inter-
secting lines with an angle between 30° and 60°.
(a) (b)
Image Cropping
Video Record Start at time t Tack 10 fps and Size
Adjustment
Image Colour
00
Enhancement
Safety
Helmet
Safety Colour
Gear Intensity?
No
Yes No
Workers
No
Human
Shape?
Body
Yes
Initiate Detections
All Workers Yes
Bounding Box Counts
No
No
01 Cycle
00
Determination
Fig. 3 The proposed decision tree of the task and worker detection process
A Real-Time Computer Vision System for Workers … 2175
In case the video framerate equals the average number of processed frames per
minute, the PR value will be one. The appropriate framerate for the real-time video
processing has been found between 8 and 10 fps and the resolution 576P and
480P. These combination sets of video framerates and resolutions can provide
around 50% extra processing capacity in a real-time manner.
This research utilises the TensorBoard to visualise the model training process and
its outcomes. It also presents the performance matrices that measures the accuracy
of the model compared to time and training iterations. The first performance
indicator is the total loss that describes the ability of the model to classifying each
detected object into its assigned class and to what extent this classification is
accurate. As observed in the visualised graph (see Fig. 4), there are two continuous
plots with different colours, dark and faded orange, indicating the actual and
2176 A. Moohialdin et al.
smoothed total loss. Initially, the training process was set to include 120,000 iter-
ations. The gradient update of the prediction accuracy increased, while the total loss
rapidly decreased and reached to around 0.4 at the 37,000 iterations. Thus, the
training process was stopped at 37,000 iterations as there is no further improvement
in the total loss. The prediction accuracy pattern also shows normal consistent
changes from 20,000 iterations, which means that around 20,000 and 30,000 iter-
ations will also give the same detection accuracy level.
The first measure of the PPE and worker detection is the identification rate (IR) and
recall reate (RR), which was calculated for each class: helmet (H), gear (G) and
worker (W). 10% of the 3,000 frames have been used to test the detection model.
The training and testing datasets included a variety of helmet and gear colures and
shapes. The most common colure of the helmet is white colure (93.8%). The
dataset also consists of some other colours such as blue, yellow and green helmets.
Similarly, various gear colours were included in the training and testing datasets
with different gear designs. For instance, some of the workers wore yellow gears
with blue colour and grey reflective tape, while others wore orange gear without
reflective tape. The most commonly used gear colure and design in the dataset
under study is yellow-blue colure without reflective tape. The variety in helmet and
gear colours and shapes help to enhance the diversity of the PPE that this model can
detect effectively in a real-site environment. Table 1 illustrates some examples of
the detection outcomes.
A Real-Time Computer Vision System for Workers … 2177
√ √ √ Walking √ √ √ Climbing
√ √ √ Bending √ √ √ Standing
To evaluate the performance of the detection model, a video of 1000 frames has
been used for testing and another video of 1000 frames has been used for valida-
tion. IR and RR are calculated as per the definition of each detection class including
helmet, gear and worker. The validation process includes 200 frames from a dif-
ferent construction site and 100 frames of different capturing angle, which include
different site environment, video recording angles, illumination levels and occlusion
cases. The results of the model testing and validation are summarised in Table 2.
Four main measures were used to calculate the model performance indicators
including: [1] true-positive (TP) indicates to cases in which the model correctly
predicts and labels objects as positive that are actually showing in the scene; [2]
true-negative (TN) are the cases where the model correctly does not predict and
label objects as positive that are actually not showing in the scene; [3] false-positive
(FP) indicates to the cases in which the model incorrectly predicts and labels objects
as positive while they are actually not showing in the scene; [4] false-negative
(FN) indicates to the cases where the model incorrectly does not predict and label
objects as positive while they are actually showing in the scene.
The IR measures the ability of the model to correctly detect the number of
objects in each frame as correctly as they belong to one of the three classes H, G
and W. The testing results in Table 2 reveals that the proposed detection model
achieved an IR of 95, 96.83 and 97.15% for the H, G and W, respectively. The IR
validation results yielded 86.14, 80.41 and 82.63% for the H, G and W, respec-
tively. Compared to the testing results, the validation results show on average
13.27% decline of the IR. These slight declination in the IR can be explained in part
by the significant difference in the illumination level as difference capturing angles
were also included in the validation dataset. Meanwhile, the validation IR is still
maintained above 80% in the three classes.
2178 A. Moohialdin et al.
Predicted
1285 42 1941 473
Gear 96.83% 98.47% 80.41% 99.18%
20 1 16 0
1602 47 2084 438
Worker 97.15% 99.38% 82.63% 99.81%
10 1 4 0
The average prediction accuracy measure was employed to examine the perfor-
mance of the proposed model on two datasets composed of various sequencing
postures. The datasets included a video of 1000 frames for model testing and
another video of 1000 frames for model validation. Since nine positions were
included, a multiclass comparison approach was adopted to construct the confusion
matrix of the proposed model. Separate Python code has been developed to perform
the multiclass comparisons based on three main python libraries including Seaborn,
Pandas, Matplotlib and Numpy. The pseudocode in Fig. 5-c describes the algorithm
applied to build the confusion matrix.
A Real-Time Computer Vision System for Workers … 2179
Figure 5 summarises the results of the confusion matrix for the model testing
and validation. These results explain how the proposed model is performing when
considering similarities between different postures and identifies the effects of the
misclassification among these postures. The results also provide insight into the
misclassified detections and, more importantly, to what class that have been mis-
classified. Overall, the results of model testing (Fig. 5-a) shows higher accuracy
when classifying the postures in which the upper and lower body parts are clearly
shown. For instance, the model achieved a higher accuracy (on average 0.89) in
classifying standing, walking, overhead, carrying and pushing postures.
In contrast, the postures of sitting, kneeling, climbing and bending have a lower
accuracy (on average 0.77) compared to other classes. Also, the results revealed that
climbing, bending, kneeling and walking postures have more crossed confusions
with at least three different classes. Meanwhile, the highest misclassification rates
were identified between walking-standing (0.072) and standing-walking due to
strong similarities in the extracted line and angle features from upper and lower
body parts. Interestingly, the model has no misclassification cases in pushing and
sitting classes, which can be explained to the wide distinctiveness of these type of
postures compared to the other classes.
In the case of validation results (Fig. 5-b), it can be observed that all classes have
at the minimum one confusion instances. It can also be observed that the model
achieved a classification accuracy over 0.75 in the first seven classes while
achieving the accuracy of 0.67 and 0.64 on the last two classes, respectively. An
analysis the validation dataset and confusion instances reveals that most of the
misclassifications have resulted from walking-standing strong similarities; and the
200 additional validation frames as they include more repeated occlusions instances
due to the improper camera position, high illumination levels as the sunlight was
directly hitting the camera’s viewfinder, as the workstation was one meter more
elevated than the surface on which the camera was mounted and 50 meters away
from the camera. On top of these, the 200 frames consist of different site activities,
concreting activities, which the model has not been trained on. The dataset also
includes 100 frames of a varying camera angle such that the camera was mounted
about 8 meters over the work area s
4 Conclusion
This paper presented a novel CV system for automated workers’ PPE and postures
detections, which is equipped with a practical design for site cameras. Two layers of
decision algorithms have been developed to perform the detection in a real-time
manner based on the Tensorflow environment. The proposed system has been tested
and validated in real site conditions and the results show that the average perfor-
mance identification rate to be 90.57, 88.62 and 89.89%, while the recall rate was
93.67, 98.83 and 99.60% for W, H and G, respectively. Meanwhile, the model
confusion analysis reveals a higher accuracy when classifying workers’ postures, in
2180 A. Moohialdin et al.
particular, postures in which the upper and lower body parts are clearly shown in
the scene such as standing, walking, overhead, carrying and pushing. In turn, the
results show that climbing, bending, kneeling and walking postures have more
misclassification rates compared to other postures. The proposed CV system testing
and validation results carry the promise of practical application on the construction
site in a real-time manner. The ongoing future work involves the opportunities of
applying the prosed system for construction site safety and productivity purposes.
Future work also includes more analysis of various types of site occlusions and their
effects on the model performance, as well as methods that can be applied to
overcome these effects.
Acknowledgements The first author thanks Queensland University of Technology (QUT) for the
finical support to this research in the form of PhD scholarship. The authors also would like to
acknowledge Dr Miljenka Perovic and Mr Nathan Sianidis for their support in getting access to the
construction site for data collection. The authors also acknowledge the QUT’s High-Performance
Centre (HPC) for providing access to large data storage and computational resources.
References
1. Chan APC, Yam MCH, Chung JWY, Yi W (2012) Developing a heat stress model for
construction workers. J Facilities Manage 10(1):59–74. https://doi.org/10.1108/
14725961211200405
2. Chan APC, Yi W, Wong DP, Yam MCH, Chan DWM (2012) Determining an optimal
recovery time for construction rebar workers after working to exhaustion in a hot and humid
environment. Build Environ 58:163–171. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2012.07.006
3. Chi S, Caldas CH (2011) Automated object identification using optical video cameras on
construction sites. Comput Aided Civil Infrastruct Eng 26(5):368–380. https://doi.org/10.
1111/j.1467-8667.2010.00690.x
4. Dimitrov A, Golparvar-Fard M (2014) Vision-based material recognition for automated
monitoring of construction progress and generating building information modeling from
unordered site image collections. Adv Eng Inf 28(1):37–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aei.
2013.11.002
5. Gatti U, Migliaccio G, Bogus SM, Priyadarshini S, Scharrer A (2013) Using workforce’s
physiological strain monitoring to enhance social sustainability of construction. J Architect
Eng 19(3):179–185. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)AE.1943-5568.0000110
6. Gong J, Caldas CH (2010) Computer vision-based video interpretation model for automated
productivity analysis of construction operations. J Comput Civil Eng 24(3):252–263. https://
doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CP.1943-5487.0000027
7. Han S, Lee S (2013) A vision-based motion capture and recognition framework for
behavior-based safety management. Autom Constr 35:131–141. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
autcon.2013.05.001
8. Huang J, Rathod V, Sun C, Zhu M, Korattikara A, Fathi A, Fischer I, Wojna Z, Song Y,
Guadarrama S, Murphy K (2017). Speed/accuracy trade-offs for modern convolutional object
detectors. In: IEEE conference on computer vision and pattern recognition. pp. 7310–7311.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1611.10012.pdf
9. Liang C, Zheng G, Zhu N, Tian Z, Lu S, Chen Y (2011) A new environmental heat stress
index for indoor hot and humid environments based on Cox regression. Build Environ 46
(12):2472–2479. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2011.06.013
A Real-Time Computer Vision System for Workers … 2181