Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ied 2020 - 06 - 25
Ied 2020 - 06 - 25
Ied 2020 - 06 - 25
JOURNALISM OF COURAGE
THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020, NEW DELHI, LATE CITY, 18 PAGES SINCE 1932 `6.00 (`8 PATNA & RAIPUR, `12 SRINAGAR) WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
MUST STRICTLY RESPECT AND OBSERVE LAC: INDIA Now past Mumbai too at
Diplomats build on military talks: Both need to Covid top, Delhi to survey
all houses, ramp up testing
implement plan on disengagement of troops ASTHA SAXENA
NEW DELHI, JUNE 24
rising, the Delhi government has
prepared an ambitious plan —
house-to-housescreeningincon-
tainment zones by June 30, and
Border Affairs
group meets as
Closer to strategic WITH 3,788 new Covid-19 cases
beingreportedonTuesday,Delhi
has overtaken Mumbai as the
in the rest of the city by July 6.
The revised Covid response
plan, which places emphasis on
Chinese Defence
Ministry asserts
DBO, China opens a city with the highest case count
— 70,390 cases so far. The total
casecountinMumbai,whichre-
active surveillance followed by
rigoroustesting,wasformulated
after a high-level panel, led by
PAKISTAN
agreed Wednesday to “sincerely ASINDIAandChinagrapplewith J&K Leh Shyok also has fewer deaths (2,365)
implement the understanding rising tensions in the Galwan Srinagar Darbuk
than Mumbai (3,964). FULL COVERAGE
CHINA
on disengagement and de-esca- Valley, Hot Springs and Pangong Withthenumberofcasesstill PAGE 4
lation” along the Line of Actual Tso on the Line of Actual Control
Control in Ladakh where both (LAC), the Chinese army has
sides have massed troops in a Satellite images of road construction near Galwan Valley on June 22. Maxar Technologies via Reuters crossed the border in another
faceoff since May.
AtthemeetingoftheWorking
strategic area to the north, the
Depsang plains. This intrusion is
TRACKING INDIA’S COVID CURVE
THE WORLD
Mechanism for Consultation &
Satellite catches Chinese P5 seen as another attempt by the LOCKDOWN
DAY CASES: RECOVERED:2,58,684 | DEATHS:14,476
Coordination on India-China Chinese to shift the LAC further
PAK FAILS TERROR 92 4,56,183 TESTS:73,52,911 | DOUBLINGRATE:19.53**
BorderAffairs(WMCC),heldtwo
days after Corps Commanders of
the two armies reached a “mu-
structures back at Galwan west on the disputed boundary.
Around 30 km south-east
from the important airstrip of
TEST, SET TOSTAY IN
FATF GREY LIST
tual consensus to disengage” nel were killed. Daulat Beg Oldie (DBO), the PAGE 16
troops,theIndianside“conveyed KRISHN KAUSHIK Top sources in the Army Chinese army has moved and
its concerns” on the develop- NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 confirmed that “the tent which THE EXPRESS deployed in large numbers up to
ments in eastern Ladakh, includ-
ing the June 15 showdown in AS INDIA and China hold diplo-
was removed on June 15 has
been reported back by our INTERVIEW a place called Y-junction or
Bottleneck on the Depsang
another five kilometres further
west. This location is seven kilo- KEYSTATES
TOWATCH
TOTAL
CASES
SURGEIN
24HRS
7-DAYAVG. DOUBLING
GROWTH* RATE **
GalwanValleyinwhich20Indian matic and military talks to dis- ground troops at PP-14 plains. Sources said the Chinese metres to the north-east of
Army personnel were killed. engage troops along the Line of (Patrolling Point 14)”. Reached “GALWAN WAS deployments include troops, Burtse,aLadakhitownwhichfalls ■ Maharashtra 1,39,010 3,214 2.95% 24.44
The Ministry of External ActualControlineasternLadakh, for comment, the Army did not NEVER DISPUTED.. heavy vehicles, specialist mili- on the 255-km Darbuk-Shyok-
■ Telangana 9,553 879 8.47% 8.50
Affairs said it was emphasised new satellite images show that confirm or deny the existence CHINA BETRAYED...” tary equipment. Daulat Beg Oldie (DSDBO) road
that both sides should “strictly the Chinese have built a defen- of Chinese structures visible in Bottleneck, which derives its and has an Indian Army post. ■ Delhi 66,602 3,947 5.87% 12.27
AK ANTONY
respect and observe” the Line of sive position at the Galwan the satellite images. SENIOR CONGGRESS LEADER &
name from a rocky outcrop that When contacted, the Army’s ■ Tamil Nadu 64,603 2,516 4.33% 16.63
Actual Control. Valley site of the June 15 clashes The images from Maxar, a FORMER DEFENCE MINISTER prevents vehicular movement media wing declined to com- 495 4.85%
■ Haryana 11,520 14.86
CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 inwhich20IndianArmyperson- CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 across the Depsang plains, is the ment on the matter, with an of-
place at which the Chinese had ficer telling The Indian Express ■ West Bengal 14,728 370 3.08% 23.36
pitched tents after an ingress in that “the report can neither be * Compounded Daily Growth Rate over last 7 days ** Calculated over 7-day growth
April 2013. The standoff be- confirmed nor denied”.
CONCERN CAUTION A GLIMMER
tween the soldiers on both sides Bottleneck is known as Y-
INSIDE Ramdev Ayurvedic ‘corona kit’: no govt had then lasted three weeks and
the status quo ante was restored
junction because the track com-
ing from Burtse forks into two
DELHI: With testing
up, cases to rise too.
4,000 on Tuesday
PUNJAB: State
witnessing a
resurgence. More
UP: Slight
slowdown in last
one week, but still
nod, trials that used allopathic drugs after diplomatic talks.
Bottleneckisaround18kmon
the Indian side of the LAC, even
tracks, one going northward
along the Raki Nala to Patrolling
Point-10 (PP-10) and the other
— single-day max
for any state
than 1,000 cases
last week
growing faster than
national average
Based on daily data by Centre, ICMR, state governments
the Ministry of Ayush ordered thoughtheChineseclaimlinelies CONTINUED ON PAGE 2
KAUNAIN SHERIFF M & Patanjali to stop publicising BUSINESS AS USUAL
DEEP MUKHERJEE claims of Covid-19 cure, the
NEW DELHI, JAIPUR, JUNE 24 Uttarakhandgovernmentsaidits BY UNNY
licencing authority did not grant
A DAY AFTER Ramdev launched any approval to the Corona Kit,
an ayurvedic ‘Corona Kit’ claim- and the Rajasthan government
ing it cured Covid-19, serious toldTheIndianExpressithadno
questions have emerged over knowledge of clinical trials at
the business practices of National Institute of Medical
Patanjali Ayurved Ltd, the FMCG Sciences and Research (NIMS), a
CABINET ALLOWS company that markets Patanjali private hospital in Jaipur where
PVT SECTOR IN brand products and Divya Covid-19 patients are admitted.
SPACE; CO-OP BANKS Pharmacy, the unit producing Most significantly, when
NOW UNDER RBI the medicines. mildly symptomatic patients
PAGES 9, 17 On Wednesday, a day after CONTINUED ON PAGE 2
E
BATCH STARTING
29 JUNE 2020
SHUBHR A RANJAN Always Ahead
th
E X P L A I NE D
Abig
● challenge BATCH TIMING : 7:30 P.M. - 10:00 P.M.
LIVE Q&A :
THE move could pose 10:15 P.M. - 11:00 P.M.
complications in case of FOR DEMO - CONTACT : +9111-45612719
products with inputs
from several countries.
Also, e-commerce firms
OUR TOPPERS
do not own the inventory
sold on their platforms,
and would need to work TINA DABI
2015|01
ANMOL SINGH
2016|02
DINESH KUMAR
2016|06
ANAND VARDHAN
2016|07
GUNJAN DWIVEDI
2018|09
TRUPATI ANKUSH
2018|16
KARN SATYARTHI
2015|09
SIDHARTH B
2016|15
ANANYA DAS
2014|16
SAHIL GUPTA
2016|19
BADOLE GIRISH
2017|20
NITESH GUPTA
2016|23
VAIBHAV SUNIL
2018|25
SHAIKH TANVEER
2016|25
New Delhi
2 THE SECOND PAGE WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
DOWNLOADAPP WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
■ VISUAL STORIES
■ DAILY BRIEFING
70 YEARS OF KOREAN WAR: WHY ETHIOPIA JUMPED INTO A DISTANT WAR
EXCLUSIVE
■ PODCASTS
WEB
■ CUSTOMIZABLE IItwasthefirsttimethatEthiopiahadbeeninvolvedinawaroutsidetheAfricancontinent.Acloserlookat
Ethiopia'shistoryduringandaftertheSecondWorldWarshowswhythecountrybecameinvolvedinan
Decoding Congress’
NEWS EXPERIENCE
Indian Express
unrelatedwarsofaraway. targeting of PM Modi,
★★★★★ ■4.6
Covid testing to rise
VIDEO OF THE DAY ENTERTAINMENT
NEWEPISODEEVERYDAY
NEWLY-WEDS DONATE AARYA SHOWCASES In today’s episode for the 3 Things podcast,
50 BEDS SUSHMITA SEN we look at why the Congress is going after
A newly-wed couple in What Sen accomplishes PM Modi over the Galwan valley faceoff
SCANTHISQRCODETO Mumbai has donated 50 with Aarya, she hasn’t despite it waging a lone battle.
DOWNLOADTHEAPP
beds to a Covid centre done before.
for import of maize at Diplomats build on military talks: Need space technology company, are
from June 22 and show that the
Wednesday's meeting also
involvedfirmslike1mg,Myntra,
JioMart, Bigbasket and
New Delhi
3 THE CITY WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
Jamia student Safoora out of jail Your intention was to be a hero, now
EXPRESSNEWSSERVICE
bail applications had created
widespread outrage.
face the law: Court to riots accused
NEW DELHI, JUNE 25 Inherbailplea,shehadraised on the ground that he has to take
pregnancy as one of the grounds EXPRESSNEWSSERVICE Shahrukh careofhis76-year-oldfatherwho
TWOANDahalfmonthsafterher for relief. She was granted bail by NEW DELHI, JUNE24 Pathan was is unwell and has no one to look
arrest, Jamia Millia Islamia stu- Delhi HC Tuesday after Solicitor arrested after him. Pathan’s counsel
dentSafooraZargarwalkedoutof GeneralTusharMehta,appearing THE DELHI High Court from UP’s Asghar Khan also referred to the
TiharJailonWednesdayevening for Delhi Police, submitted that Wednesday refused to grant bail Shamli on order granting bail to Jamia stu-
after being granted bail by the theprosecutionwouldnotobject to an accused who allegedly March 3 dent Safoora Zargar on humani-
Delhi High Court on humanitar- Safoora outside Tihar Jail, herreleaseonregularbailon“hu- pointed a pistol at a police head tariangrounds,andsaidPathan's
ian grounds. The pregnant 27- Wednesday manitarian grounds”. constable during the communal pleaalsobeconsideredsimilarly.
year-oldstudentandmediacoor- The conditions imposed on violence in Northeast Delhi in not inclined to grant relief to JusticeKaitthenobserved,“While
dinator of Jamia Coordination Zargar include directions to not February,sayinghisintentionwas ShahrukhPathan,afterwhichhis committing offence, you forget
Committeehadbeenarrestedby inconnectionwiththeNortheast leave the national capital, and tobecomeaheroandnowhewill counsel withdrew the plea. The everyone. Now you are thinking
the Delhi Police’s Special Cell on Delhi riots. Her imprisonment seekingpermissionifsherequires have to face the law. Justice court then dismissed the plea as about your aged and ailing par-
April10andisfacingaUAPAcase and the previous denials of her to leave the NCT of Delhi. Suresh Kumar Kait said he was withdrawn. Pathan sought bail ents.”
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
4 THE OUTBREAK
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
THE CITY
DELHI NOW CITY WITH MOST COVID CASES
May21
May24
May27
May30
June2
June5
June8
June11
June14
June17
June20
June23
mark on July 12. Since then, except on two ple, who are admitted in Covid care centres, People are being infected and are recovering not testing a lot of asymptomatic people but
days,thenumberhasremainedabove2,000, canbedischargedafter“10daysof symptom at home. It also says that the number of peo- the numbers are higher in Delhi,” said Dr
and has been consistently hitting the 3,000- onsetandnofeverforthreedays”.Thepatient ple going back from hospitals is about the Shobha Broor, former head of the microbiol-
plus figure for the past five days. is then advised to isolate at home for 7 days. same as those being admitted,” he said. ogy department at AIIMS.
As Centre On ground, L-G order yet to take off 100 days on, Lok Nayak says
takes charge, “Ever since a visit to a Covid care centre has docs have same enthusiasm
key officers
MALLICA JOSHI beenmademandatory,patientsaresuffering.
NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 Their first concern is how they will reach a cessful,” said a senior doctor about the im-
Covid care centre for assessment and if they ASTHA SAXENA munosuppressant, commonly used to
in Covid fight
AMIDRISINGcasesinDelhi,aneworderbyL- areassignedhomeisolation,howtheywillgo NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 treat rheumatoid arthritis. He said ap-
GAnilBaijal,makingitmandatoryforallpos- back...Delhiisseeing3,000-4,000casesaday. proval for using the drug was received
itive patients to visit a Covid care centre for From where will we get ambulances to take ANTICIPATING A surge in admissions, Delhi from DGCI.
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
of Chinese incursion
FIVE INDIAN soldiers were on
Wednesday awarded
‘Commendation Cards’ by Army
Chief General M M Naravane for
demonstrating exemplary grit
and courage in dealing with
Chinese troops in two separate
in Arunachal Pradesh
clashes in Pangong Tso and
CLAMOUR GROWS GalwanValleyineasternLadakh,
sources said.
EXPRESSNEWSSERVICE
NEWDELHI,JUNE24
THE CHORUS has begun. Taking a cue from senior leaders like The Army Chief visited for-
Rajasthan Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot, who urged Rahul Army Chief General Manoj Mukund Naravane interacts with troops while reviewing ward areas in eastern Ladakh to IN THE wake of the standoff
Gandhi to return as Congress president at the CWC meeting operational situation on the ground, in eastern Ladakh on Wednesday. PTI meet the troops and held a de- betweenIndianandChineseforces
Tuesday, some Congress functionaries Wednesday wrote to tailed briefing in Leh about the in eastern Ladakh, the Congress
Congress president Sonia Gandhi with the same demand. situation on ground. Wednesday sought to corner the
While former Rajya Sabha MP Hussain Dalwai argued that General M M Naravane government over claims about
Rahul is the most acceptable face as a leader, AICC secretary
Challa Vamshi Chand Reddy said Rahul is that one voice and
therightpersontorepresentand address national challenges.
Chinese aggression at LAC reached Ladakh on Tuesday, ac-
companied by Northern Army
Commander Lt Gen YK Joshi.
Chinese incursions in Arunachal
Pradesh by a BJP MP from that
state. The opposition party asked
Manish Tewari, Tapir Gao
Dalwai has written that Rahul has dared to raise many cru-
cial issues while no leader from any other party dared to raise
issues that affect the whole country.
premeditated: US Congressman The Army chief is scheduled
to visit other forward areas in
eastern Ladakh on Thursday as
thegovernmenttocomecleanon
theissueanddemandedthecon-
vening of a special session of
posts of the Indian Army have
been occupied by the People’s
Liberation Army. Gao seems to
Department and the Region”. part of his tour to review the on- Parliament to discuss issues such contradict the Prime Minister...
SHUBHAJITROY SeveralCongressmembersin- ground military preparedness. asnationalsecurity. “This is the not the first time
CLEAR MESSAGE NEWDELHI,JUNE24 cluding Indian-American Pramila
Jayapal,SheilaJacksonLee(whois
This is his first trip to the region
afterIndianArmylost20soldiers
FacingcriticismfromtheBJPfor
its attack on the government, the
that Gao has made these revela-
tions…These are extremely seri-
WITHTHEoppositionCongresstargetingthegovernmentover DEMOCRATIC US Congressman amemberof thePakistancaucus) in Galwan Valley on June 15. Congress has also decided to ob- ous claims,” Tewari said.
the LAC issue, the BJP seems to have decided to communicate Brad Sherman, who is a senior and Ilhan Omar questioned Alice TheArmyChief reviewedthe serve‘ShaheedonKoSalaamDivas’ Congress Lok Sabha MP from
itspositiontoitssupporters.Ithasaskeditsleaderstofindways member of the powerful House Wells, then Assistant Secretary of overall security situation in the (martyrs’ day) on June 26. The Assam Gaurav Gogoi asked the
toconvincethecadrethatthegovernmentisdoingeverything Foreign Affairs Committee, on State for South and Central Asian region with Northern Army party will hold candlelight vigils governmenttobemorevigilantin
to protect the nation whereas it was the mismanagement of Wednesday described as “pre- Affairs,andRobertDestro,Assistant Commander Lt Gen YK Joshi, and launch an online campaign theNortheastandborders.“Wede-
past Congress governments that led to the current problems. meditated” the Chinese aggres- Brad Sherman Secretary of State for Democracy, commander of the 14 Corps Lt called‘SpeakUpForOurJawans’. mand that the Government of
On Wednesday, party MP and former Union minister sion in which 20 Indian troops HumanRightsandLabour. Gen Harinder Singh and other Addressingapressconference, Indiadoesnotlookatwhatishap-
Rajyavardhan Rathore, also a retired Army officer, did a died in the Galwan Valley on Sherman, who began the senior Army officials on both seniorpartyleaderManishTewari pening in Arunachal Pradesh or
Facebook Live with people in Rajasthan to explain the border June 15. “We also spoke in general re hearingbydescribingKashmiras Tuesday and Wednesday, said that Tapir Gao, BJP MP from Ladakh as isolated incidents. This
situation. He said it was important to know the history, geog- Thisisthestrongeststatement strengtheningtheU.S.-Indiarela- the“mostdangerousflashpointin sources said. Arunachal East, has said in a tele- isagranddesignandthisneedsto
raphy, Chinese intentions, why such transgressions are hap- sofarfromtheUS.TheUSadmin- tionship,” he said. theworld”,hadsaidthathehasfor “General M M Naravane visioninterviewthatthe“People's beresponded...”hesaid.Healsode-
peningandChinesestrategiestounderstandthesituation.He istration had so far just condoled Sherman is currently serving yearscondemnedtheterroristat- #COAS visited forward areas in Liberation Army, on both sides of mandedconveningofaspecialses-
too blamed Jawaharlal Nehru for the troubles at the border. the deaths. US Secretary of State his twelfth term in Congress and tacks in Kashmir and spoken Eastern #Ladakh and reviewed the Subansiri river in Asapila and sionofParliament,keepinginmind
Michael R Pompeo, the senior- has served in the House of about the Kashmiri pandits. He operational situation on the Longju sectors in the upper both social distancing and the im-
POLL SEASON
most Cabinet minister from the Representatives since 1997. Over hadsaidthatIndia’sdecisionwith ground.#COAScommendedthe Subansiri district of Arunachal portanceofnationalsecurity.
Trump administration, had the last few months, he has been respect to scrapping Article 370 troops for their high morale and Pradesh, have occupied territory Tewari slammed the govern-
tweeted “condolences”. very active commenting on wasnotindirectresponsetothese exhorted them to continue on the Indian side of the ment for not allowing
GEARING UP for the Bihar elections, the BJP has taken extra Sherman, who represents Kashmir, the NRC, and had met terrorist attacks. working with zeal and enthusi- McMahon Line”. Parliamentary Standing
care over caste equations while picking its nominees for MLC California’s San Fernando Valley, External Affairs Minister S Besides Kashmir, the NRC is- asm,” the Army said in a tweet. Tewari said that according to Committeestomeetvirtually.“Itis
polls.The party hasnamedits mediaco-headSanjayMayukh, on Wednesday tweeted, “Good Jaishankar in December last year sue had also come up for discus- GeneralMMNaravane’svisit Gao, the Chinese Army had con- extremelyunfortunatewhileyou
who belongs to an upper caste, a key support base of the BJP, speaking with India's along with other Congressmen. sion, and as Sherman had asked to the region came in the midst structed bridges, roads, houses can have Russia, India, China tri-
for the second time. It has also nominated Samrat Choudhary, Ambassador @SandhuTaranjitS In October last year, Sherman whether it is a serious legislative of Chinarapidlyincreasingnum- andhelipadsatAsapilaandMajha lateral summits virtually, while
a former minister in the Rabri Devi government. A Kushwaha today.Iofferedmycondolencesto chairedatwo-and-a-half-hourUS proposal or a “crackpot idea”, ber of troops and weaponry areas in the district. theG-20canbeheldvirtuallyand
by caste, Choudhary is expected to keep the backward caste the Ambassador for the approx. Congressionalhearing,sinceheis Destro responded: “It is a serious along the Line of Actual Control “Gao further goes on to say all-party meetings on China can
support base consolidated for the BJP-JD(U) alliance in the 20 troops who died as a result of chairman of the House legislative proposal.” When (LAC) in the eastern Ladakh re- thatthePLAhasoccupiedabaseof beheldvirtually,thisGovernment
state. Kushwaha is an influential OBC community in Bihar. premeditatedChineseaggression Subcommittee on Asia, on the Sherman asked “have we con- gion, including in Pangong Tso, theIndianArmy...Rememberthe haswalkedtheextramileinorder
BeforejoiningtheBJPin2017,ChoudharyhadstintsintheRJD, at the actual line of control in topic “Human Rights in South demned it?”, Destro replied, “We Galwan Valley and Gogra Hot Prime Minister of India at the all- tohidebehindrules,inordertoes-
JD(U) and HAM(S). Ladakh last week.” Asia: Views from the State are doing it right here.” Spring. party meeting had said that no cape Parliamentary oversight...”
Probe agreement between ‘Our claim is not just LAC — our claim goes beyond that’
Cong and CPC: plea in SC DEEPTIMANTIWARY
NEWDELHI,JUNE24
Speaking at a webinar organ-
ised by RSS mouthpiece
Panchjanya on the LAC issue,
strategic point of view”. He said,
“China thinks differently com-
pared to other countries. It has
ceptions of the LAC between the
two countries. Now we are insist-
ingonourownershipofLAC,aswe
made the introductory remarks,
said: “There some handmaidens
of China who keep justifying
nalist Savio Rodrigues claimed Madhavsaid:“Indiawillcontinue border issues with 13-14 coun- perceiveit.” Chineseactionshere....Theytryto
EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE that despite hostile relations INDIA WILL assert itself on the to stand firm on the ground. We tries. It believes in continuing to He said, “We are engaging bringmoraleoftheforcesdown.”
NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 with China, the Congress signed ground over its perception of the want peace, but not of the grave- gain territory without engaging withChinadiplomaticallybuton “WTOagreementsarenotap-
the agreement when it was rul- Line of Actual Control (LAC) and yard. We have close to 60 roads in war.” ground we are assertive. We are plicable on people. Today even a
A LAWYER and a journalist on ing the country as part of a coali- continuetoclaimAksaiChineven underconstruction(intheregion), Ram Madhav, Ram Lal Hesaid:“Today,theOpposition not letting China get away with small child knows Chinese prod-
Wednesday approached the tion,andhidthefactsanddetails as it engages with China diplo- and that work will go on. Our asksusaboutborderviolations,but semi-permanent structures on ucts are not to be purchased.
Supreme Court seeking a probe of the agreement. matically, BJP general secretary claim is not just the LAC — our it has not started in 2020. In 2013, our territory. Unlike in the past, China has been forced to think
into an “agreement” signed be- Rodrigues alleged that he RamMadhavsaidonWednesday. claimgoesbeyondthat.AfterJ&K Chin, and we have to be firm on when the Chinese entered 19-20 we are not turning our jeep that if it does anything more and
tween the Indian National urged the Congress to make de- Madhav also took on the and Ladakh were declared Union our perception of LAC.” km inside and there was standoff, aroundandcomingback.Weare India’speoplegoagainstit,theen-
CongressandCommunistPartyOf tails of the agreement public but Opposition,particularlytargeting Territories, their maps include Madhav argued that India is nothingwasbeingdoneandques- confronting and pushing (them) tire market will go out of its hand
ChinainBeijingonAugust7,2008. “no heed was shown in that re- the Congress for not addressing PoK, Gilgit Baltistan and facing such a situation because tions were raised in Parliament. back.” and it will be in economic trou-
In their petition, advocate spect which shows the malafide the issue under earlier govern- Aksai Chin. people had not tried to under- (Then PM) Manmohan Singh RSS leader and former BJP ble,” he said. FULLREPORTON
Shashank Shekhar Jha and jour- intention of the Respondents”. ments led by the party. “We continue to claim Aksai stand China from “tactical and merelysaidtherearedifferingper- general secretary Ram Lal, who www.indianexpress.com
New Delhi
6 GOVT & POLITICS WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020 GOVT & POLITICS 7
Bihar Oppn leaders meet amid rumblings in RJD, unease among partners
With just months to go for It is an opportunity to dislodge Indian Express. in charge of Bihar Shaktisinh settled,” a senior Congress leader close working relationship with
MANOJ C G & Assembly polls, all is not well in him. But, the impression that Though they are not sure Gohil, AICC general secretary K C said. But the smaller parties are theRJDandbenefitedfromtheal-
RAVISH TIWARI the RJD-led Opposition alliance. Lalu’s son (Tejashwi) is the alter- whethertheRJDwillconcedethis Venugopal, Bihar Congress chief still not convinced, and this issue liancein2015Assemblyelections
NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 Thesmallerparties—formerChief native gives Nitish an advantage. argument, the smaller players in Madan Mohan Jha and Congress isfastemergingasastickingpoint is yet to make up its mind.
Minister Jitan Ram Manjhi’s There is a lot of baggage with any the Opposition alliance are keen legislaturepartyleaderSadanand in the alliance. With polls just a few months
THEDEFECTIONof fiveRJDMLCs HAM(S), Upendra Kushwaha’s member of Lalu’s family leading to impress “this ground reality” Singh also joined. Patel and “Thishandicap(impressionof away, the Covid pandemic has
totheJD(U)andtheresignationof RLSP, and Mukesh Sahni’s Vikas- the fight,” said a top leader in the upontheCongressandareasking Venugopalattendingthemeeting Tejashwileading)canonlybead- disrupted political activities in
RJD co-founder Raghuvansh sheel Insaan Party (VIP)—are not anti-NDA alliance in Bihar. RJD’s Manoj Jha (left); and it to persuade Lalu to change tac- signifies the importance the dressed with the consent of Lalu. Bihar. But action has begun after
Prasad Singh as national vice- agreeabletotheideaofprojecting TheRJDsaiditwasopentodis- Cong leader Ahmed Patel tics. Sources said they have con- Congressattachestosmoothsail- WehopetheCongressrealisesthis senior BJPleaderAmit Shah held
president has put a spotlight on Leader of Opposition and Lalu cussion but hoped the other par- veyedthisviewtoseniorCongress ing of the alliance. and persuades Lalu about an al- a virtual rally of party workers
theanti-NDAcampinBiharahead Prasad’ssonTejashwiYadavasthe ties would understand its view. leader Ahmed Patel. It is learnt Sources said the issue of seat ternative mechanism where the early this month. Chief Minister
of Assembly elections. Amid the chief ministerial candidate. The “Wewilldiscussit.Butthefact willwetellourrankandfile?So,it thatKushwahaandManjhihada sharing or Tejashwi’s projection RJD leads the alliance but doesn’t Nitish Kumar too has begun po-
rumblingsintheRJD,seniorlead- RJD,ontheotherhand,maintains is we are numerically the is a question that others will meeting with Patel on Tuesday. did not come up on Wednesday givetheimpressionthatitisNitish litical stocktaking within his
ers of the alliance, including sen- the issue is “non-negotiable”. strongest party in Bihar, in terms soonerorlaterunderstandthatis- Patel attended Wednesday’s as it was a preliminary meeting. vs Tejashwi battle,” said the party.Thedefectionof RJDMLCs,
ior Congress functionaries, met “Nitish Kumar’s governance of seat share or vote share. If the sues are far more important. For virtual meeting with Manoj Sources said Congress president Oppositionleader,pinninghopes in fact, has virtually kickstarted
formally for the first time on has been very poor this term. party has decided something, RJD, it is non-negotiable,” RJD Kumar Jha, Manjhi, Kushwaha SoniaGandhiandTejashwiwould ontheCongresstolenditsweight. the political action of leaders
Wednesday. People are dissatisfied with him. then how can we go back? What leader Manoj Kumar Jha told The andSahni.AICCgeneralsecretary soon meet. “Everything shall be The Congress, which has a shifting camps.
RJD’s 3 MLC
candidates file
nomination
SANTOSH SINGH
PATNA, JUNE 24
Withdraw
corporatisation
plan to avoid
strike: ordnance
workers to PM
SUSHANT KULKARNI
PUNE, JUNE 24
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
8 THE OUTBREAK
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
E
begunreturningtoKerala,thein-
spection of theirdocuments and creasetheirintakeofstudentsfor police get bail
E X P L A I NE D
other details would be held at RITIKA CHOPRA the undergraduate, masters and
railwaystationsclosetothestate NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 Firstquota researchprogrammesbyaround
borders. oneconomic 6,700seats.Approximately2,300 EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE
“All those migrant workers THE MINISTRY of Human ● deprivation seats — about 500 of them in the AHMEDABAD, JUNE 24
would be sent into quarantine, Resource Development (HRD) is B.Techprogramme—wereadded
which would be theresponsibil- likely to grant centrally-run THE CONSTITUTION in 2019-20; the remaining 4,400 THE GUJARAT High Court on
ity of the contractors who bring higher education institutions an (124th Amendment) Bill seats, including around 1,300 for Tuesday granted bail to 33 mi-
theworkers.Thoseworkerswho extra year to implement the 10 to grant 10 per cent reser- B.Tech, were expected to be grant labourers, mainly from
do not have contractors as spon- per cent quota for economically vation for EWS was added this year. Jharkhand, who were in jail for
sors should be sent for institu- weaker sections (EWS), given passed by Parliament and “Inordertoaccommodatethe overamonthforclashingwithpo-
tional quarantine. That facility that many institutions have not became law in January increased student population, liceinVastrapur,withthecourtof
would be organised at the dis- beenabletocreateadditionalin- 2019. This is the first time hostel facilities for the students Justice Paresh Upadhyay observ-
trict levels,” the CM said. frastructure becauseof the coro- that reservation has been were in the process of being aug- ing that the accused were “vic-
navirus lockdown. allowed on economic mentedbyconstructingnewhos- tims,andcertainlynotcriminals.”
A proposal to this effect was grounds. An EWS benefi- tels... However, due to the recent The migrants were in jail
Bengal extends recently moved in the Ministry ciary is a person whose lockdown imposed by COVID-19 since May 18 when the FIR was
after the IITs and NITs sought a family has a gross annual outbreak leading to the subse- registered against them.
lockdown with A municipal corporation worker sprays disinfectant at a government school in Bengaluru on year's extension to the 2021 income below Rs 8 lakh. quentstopofalltheconstruction- Nirav Mishra, the advocate
Wednesday. The Karnataka Secondary Education Examination Board is set to hold the 10th deadline to add seats to accom- relatedwork,theprocesstocom- representing the accused, sub-
current standard exam from Thursday with precautionary measures in place. PTI modate the new quota. plete the above task to mitted before the court that the
A decision on the suggestion, September last year, but it was accommodatethisincreaseinstu- migrantswerewithoutanywork,
relaxations
Partial lockdown of Bengaluru
which has been made by senior not accepted. dentenrolmenthasencountered money and even food during the
West Bengal: Trinamool Rlys floats tenders for ‘Covid surveillance’ cameras
MLA dies of coronavirus AVISHEK G DASTIDAR
called “black body”temperature
in the cameras in many cases.
might not get detected and en-
ter public places,” claimed an in-
For normal/controlled move-
ment, scanners without black
NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 While the cameras with black dustry insider. body are acceptable,” he said.
EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE body sensing capability cost up- In its enforcement policy for The spokesman said the
KOLKATA, JUNE 24 INDIA IS gearing up to install AI- wardsof Rs4lakha piece,indus- telethermographic systems as South Western Railway wanted
Tamonash based ‘Covid surveillance’ cam- try sources said the ones with- part of Covid-19 public health AI-based systems with face de-
TRINAMOOL CONGRESS MLA Ghosh eras that detect body tempera- out this feature would be emergency recommendations, tection technology. “Besides the
Tamonash Ghosh, who tested turesof individualsandwhether cheaper by around half of that the US Food and Drug advantageof needingnocalibra-
positive for Covid-19 in May, a person is wearing a mask. per camera. Administration(FDA)lists“accu- tion, this specification will have
died at a hospital in West and was made the TMC treas- First off the block is Indian Railways’telecomarmRailtel rate blackbody temperature ref- higheraccuracy,”hesaid,adding,
Bengal’s South-24 Parganas dis- urer in 1998 when she founded Railways, which has called for floated a tender to purchase erence source” as one of the “the issue of specification of
trict on Wednesday. He was 60. the party. tenders to purchase the systems around 800 such camera sys- specifications for accuracy of black body is infructuous. All de-
Ghosh is the first MLA in the Banerjee offered her condo- for railway stations and other tems. It initially did not include temperature from a Covid point cisionsweretakenatzonallevels
to have died of the coronavirus. lences, saying he has “left a void placesexpectedtoseesignificant black body detection as a speci- of view in such devices. These keeping in view the best needs
The three-time MLA from which is difficult to fill”. footfall,withafewrailwayzones fication but has now issued a thermalcamerascan cover large and solutions in the given cir-
FaltaAssemblyconstituencywas Earlier, TMC MLA and state having already concluded the corrigendum to include it. areas, detecting and recording cumstances. Both types of de-
admitted to a hospital after he Fire Services Minister Sujit Bose purchase, such as in Mumbai. Tenders called by Central People line up outside the Ludhiana station. Gurmeet Singh temperaturesof multiplepeople vices are efficient and good.”
tested positive. Sources said he tested positive for Covid-19 and Officials said the cameras Railwayoverthepastonemonth at once. Around35companiespartic-
had several complications re- was admitted to a hospital. His were meant for the next phase --forinstallationatlargestations However, an Indian Railway ipated in the tender for North
lated to the heart and kidney, wife and domestic help also of containment strategy to go in Mumbai and North Frontier calledbyzonessuchasNorthern, “In the post-Covid scenario, spokesman said both types of Frontier Railway while 15 com-
and that he died of multi-organ tested positive. hand in hand with India’s grad- Railway in Guwahati -- sought Southern and South Western nothavingthisabilityincameras camerasareacceptable,depend- peted for the one floated by
failure. Bose was discharged after- ual return to normalcy. thecamerastohavetheabilityto Railway, have not included this meanttodetectfeverinaperson ing on the purpose. “Where Central Railway, signifying a
Ghoshwasakeysupporterof wardsandispresentlyunderob- However, Railways has ex- detect black body temperature, in their specifications, giving may have implications that peo- mass transit is there, scanners growingpieforthesebusinesses
Chief MinisterMamataBanerjee, servation at his residence. cluded a crucial specification but the latest crop of tenders mixed signals to the industry. ple with symptoms like fever with black body are preferable. in post-Covid India.
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
9 EXPRESS NETWORK
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
New Delhi
10 WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020 EXPRESS NETWORK 11
Retired DSP VVIP CHOPPER CASE Institute of Infrastructure Technology
shoots himself ED searches premises linked to Research And Management (IITRAM)
in Patna, former Emaar MGF director (An Autonomous University established by Government of Gujarat)
row: J&K admin 2. Smt. Pinki Mortgagor: All that part and parcel of the residential landed 05.09.2019
Kumari Smt. Pinki property along with present future construction 20.06.2020 21,61,438/-
`
W/o Shri Kumari thereon in the name of Smt. Pinki Kumari (Pinki (Rs. Twenty
appoints inquiry Naveen
Kumar
(Pinki Devi) Devi) W/o Shri Naveen Kumar measuring 01 Katha
W/o Shri 01 Dhur 10 Dhurki situated at Mouza-Saichak, PS-
one lac
sixty one
officer to look B/o: RPS Naveen
Residential Kumar
Phulwari Sharif, under Tauzi No.5119, PS No.32,
Khata No.96, Plot No.466, bearing Sale Deed
thousand
four hundred
into three deaths Public No.3816 dated 09.03.2017 recorded at SRO Patna thirty eight
School in Book No.01, Zild No.46, CD No.12, Pages 330 only)
to 338. Bounded: On the North: 5 feet wide road
after then Late Jawahar Rai & others, On the
ARUN SHARMA South-Kishun Rai Hal Jayvansh Prasad Singh,
JAMMU, JUNE 24 On the East-Road after then Ramsewak Rai Hal
Raghuvansh Prasad Singh, On the West-Smt.
Pinki Kumari W/o Sri Ajeet Kumar.
THE JAMMU and Kashmir ad-
Date : 24.06.2020 Authorised Officer
ministration Wednesday ap- Place : Patna Indian Bank (Erstwhile Allahabad Bank)
pointed Jammu Divisional
CommissionerSanjeevVermaas
inquiry officer to look into the
circumstances leading to the
death of two people during the
cremation of the body of a Covid
patient in Jammu, as well as the
death of a person lodged at an
administrative quarantine facil-
ity in Kathua.
The inquiry officer is to sub-
mit the report within 10 days.
The order came a day after
Jammu Deputy Commissioner
Sushma Chauhan submitted to
the government the report of a
magisterial inquiry into the
deaths at the cremation.
Allthreedeceasedhadtested
negative for Covid-19, raising a
controversy over the protocol
being followed in handling the
bodies of Covid-19 patients and
also those returning from other
parts of the country.
The Indian Express had on
June23reportedaboutthedeath
of two cousins at the cremation.
On the way to cremate their un-
cle, who had tested positive for
Covid-19, the two cousins suf-
fered scorching heat inside PPE
kits, pushed an ambulance
across a river bank and fell un-
conscious while officials refused
to help, their relatives have al-
leged. Family members and po-
litical parties accused the UT ad-
ministration of not following
Health Ministry guidelines on
handling the body of a coron-
avirus patient.
Meanwhile,a47-year-oldres-
identofHiranagartehsil’sChapaki
Kalan village,who was in admin-
istrative quarantine at a private
ETTcollegesinceJune15whenhe
reachedLakhanpurfromMumbai
by road, died on Sunday.
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
12
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
FOUNDED BY
1975 lesson for 2020
§
§
RAMNATH GOENKA
Ruler alone is not accountable, everyone who
BECAUSE THE TRUTH INVOLVES US ALL
succumbs to authority is no less guilty
N
when democracy was derailed. Actually, the ship laws were in force, but where there was March,theSupremeCourtrejectedtheantic-
Emergency came into effect on June 25 at a will there was a way. The Indian Express was ipatory bail pleas of journalist Gautam
EITHER DELHI NOR Beijing have given too many details on the “mutual 11.45pmwhenthenPresident,FakhruddinAli one of the rare exceptions which defied the Navlakha and professor Anand Teltumbde,
consensus” on military disengagement arrived at in Monday’s meeting Ahmed,signedtheproclamation,eventhough censorsfrequently, especiallyafterelections both respected civil rights activists, accused
of senior military commanders in eastern Ladakh. The talks at the mili- he was alerted by his secretary that it would were called in January 1977. The Express of involvement in the Bhima Koregaon vio-
tary level are being reinforced by diplomatic consultations between the be constitutionally untenable. The president founder, Ramnath Goenka, knew that he lence of 2018. The two have been detained
twogovernments.HavingseenthepreviousagreementonJune6break is expected to act only on the advice of the would have to forfeit his newspaper chain in under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
council of ministers. Indira Gandhi’s cabinet caseMrsGandhireturnedtopower,buthere- ActasamendedinJuly2019.Itisalawmeant
down,Delhiwouldbewisetobeextracautiousthistime.Evenwiththebestofgoodwilland
met the next day at 6 am as a formality. fused to bend. for terrorists which makes securing bail dif-
political trust, demobilising militaries from a line of confrontation is inherently difficult. President Ahmed was the first in a chain MrsGandhiimposedtheEmergencywith ficult.Itisthegovernment’sdiscretionwhom
Questionsontheinterpretationoftheagreement,thesequenceofwithdrawal,timelinesfor ofconstitutionalauthoritiesandautonomous a sledgehammer. But dictatorships can also to designate a terrorist, a throwback to the
implementation and the protocols for verification of the steps taken can all be deeply con- institutions in our democracy that caved in, creepinslowly,silentlyandinsidiously,with- Emergency-era MISA.
tentious. After the bloody encounter at Galwan on the night of June 15, mutual goodwill at betrayingtheiroathof officeandabandoning outanyformalannouncement.Historyshows The pandemic has delayed the next ses-
the military level and trust at the political level are unsurprisingly in short supply. professional integrity. While holding Mrs us that the ruler alone is not accountable. sionofParliamentandthereisnoindicationas
Gandhi, Sanjay and his henchmen guilty for Everyonewhosuccumbstoauthorityisnoless to when the Lok Sabha will convene and in
To make matters worse, there has been further mobilisation of military forces on both
theEmergency,wegenerallyforgettoappor- guilty.Theoftrepeatedquestionastowhether whatform.Willmeaningfuldebatesonissues,
sidessincetheGalwanclash.Itisalsonotclearif thetwosidesfullyagreeonwhattheend- tion blame to the others who succumbed anEmergencycouldoccurinIndiaagainispar- such as handling of the pandemic or the
state of the disengagement process is. Delhi has repeatedly affirmed that it would like to whenpushcametoshove.MrsGandhi’scab- ticularly relevant in 2020. A dangerous pan- Chinese intrusions, be possible? Or will the
see complete and unambiguous restoration of the situation in eastern Ladakh before the inet fell in line without a murmur. In demic has weakened the institutions tasked Housemeetmerelytorubberstamp govern-
massive Chinese military mobilisation all across the frontier in early May. While Indian Parliament,theentireCongressparty,barring A dangerous pandemic has with upholding the Constitution. The COVID ment decisions, the social distancing norms
sources seem to suggest China is ready to roll back, Beijing has not publicly confirmed twoexpelleddissidents,meeklyraisedhands weakened the institutions crisis can also provide a screen to keep reality providingahandypretexttokeepthesession
toapprove,notjusttheEmergencyproclama- tasked with upholding the from the public gaze and assist rulers in arm- brief and business-like?
that as a shared goal. Nor is it clear if Beijing agrees with Delhi on what “status quo ante”
tion, but several illegal laws. Mrs Gandhi ing themselves with more powers. AnotherCOVIDvictimisthefourthestate.
means on the ground. The story of the China frontier in the last few decades has been the demonstrated her contempt for Parliament
Constitution. The COVID Because of the pandemic, justice has Anunfoundedapprehensionthatnewspapers
PLA's small but frequent land grabs across the Line of Actual Control. Delhi has now taken bydoingawaywithQuestionHourandCalling crisis can also provide a been delayed or diverted in some com- cansomehowbecarriersofthevirushasledto
a public position that it will no longer accept an outcome where the PLA walks one step AttentionMotions,declaringthathenceforth screen to keep reality from pelling human rights matters. A telling ex- a steep fall in print circulations. Several gated
back after taking two steps across the LAC. That China continues to put across a new claim only important government business would the public gaze and assist ample is the habeas corpus petition filed by communities and apartment buildings have
for the entire Galwan Valley highlights the political challenges ahead. be transacted. the wife of the 82-year-old leader in fuelled ill-informed paranoia. The economic
The record of the courts, a major pillar of
rulers in arming themselves Kashmir, Saifuddin Soz. The Supreme Court consequencesaredevastatingfortheprintme-
Notwithstanding this structural political tension and the essential complexity of mil- with more powers. Because
anydemocracy,wasnotquiteasdismal.Nine has put off the hearing till July. Soz was de- dia,oneof thefewcrediblesourcesof newsin
itary disengagement, the fact that talks are taking place is a good sign. Equally welcome
high courts had the courage to strike down of the pandemic, justice has tained in August last year along with many anagewheresocialmediaisfloodedwithfake
is the fact that the Indian and Chinese troops marched in Moscow at an international mil- the draconian Maintenance of Internal others in Kashmir when Article 370 was nul- news and propaganda. Venerable language
been delayed or diverted in
itary event to mark the 75th anniversary of Russian victory in the Second World War. The Security Act (MISA), as being ultra vires the lified. He has yet to be informed of the rea- publications have shut shop, many newspa-
Indian and Chinese foreign ministers also joined the Russian foreign minister in a Constitution. (Thousands were detained un- some compelling human sons for his imprisonment. persgroupshaveruthlesslycutdownonout-
prescheduled video conference. This is part of the regular trilateral political interaction der MISA during the Emergency). Most of rights matters. A telling While the courts are constrained from station editions and staff.
between India, Russia and China. But Delhi appears to have declined the opportunity for these brave judges were later penalised. But example is the habeas corpus taking prompt action because of the pan- Afinanciallydebilitatedmediawillstrug-
when the habeas corpus writ came in appeal petition filed by the wife of demic, the Delhi Police, on the other hand, gle for survival after the pandemic. Another
ameetinginMoscowbetweenthevisitingdefenceministerRajnathSinghandhisChinese
to the Supreme Court (ADM Jabalpur vs S was hyper active during the lockdown, ar- disturbing trend of late is for FIRs to be filed
counterpart General Wei Fenghe. On balance, then, it is too early to celebrate the pre- Shukla) thesenior-mostjudgesof thelandlet the 82-year-old leader in resting protesters against the Citizenship on frivolous charges against journalists who
sumed agreement on military disengagement in the Ladakh frontier. India must remain down the country. Of the five-judge bench, Kashmir, Saifuddin Soz. The (Amendment)Act(CAA).Mostof the alleged ask inconvenient questions to state and cen-
vigilant, it’s a long road ahead. fourupheldtheAttorneyGeneral’sargument Supreme Court has put off trouble-makers are students and Muslims. tral governments. Over-zealous BJP bhakts,
thatapersonhasnolegalrights,noteventobe Theywerechargedwith“unlawfulactivities’’ who instigate the police to slap such cases,
the hearing till July. Soz was
produced before the court or be informed of during the riots in North East Delhi in late seemtobefollowinginthefootstepsofSanjay
detained in August last year
SAFOORA’S TRIAL
the reasons for his detention, as long as an February. The arrests are very obviously en- Gandhi’s storm troopers during the
Emergencyisinforce.Theblemishedfourin- along with many others in tirely one-sided. Even those whose inflam- Emergency.Afreemedia,oneshouldremem-
cluded two who projected themselves as Kashmir when Article 370 matory speeches and actions are a matter of ber, is the touchstone of a democracy.
championsofhumanrightsandcivilliberties. record, such as local BJP leader Kapil Mishra,
was nullified. He has yet to
Her legal ordeal, stated reason for grant of bail, raise questions. The sole dissenter, Justice H R Khanna, threw were not booked. When an arrested student The writer is consulting editor, The Indian
away his chance to be the next chief justice. be informed of the reasons recently approached a Delhi lower court, the Express and author of The Emergency: A
Bail is not charity, it flows from constitutional principles
A
LKAdvani’sfamousjibeatthemediadur- for his imprisonment. court stated that because of the pandemic it Personal History
PPEARING FOR THE DELHI Police, on Tuesday, Solicitor General Tushar
MehtasaidhehadnoobjectiontothereleaseofJamiaMilliaIslamiastude-
ntSafooraZargaron“humanitariangrounds”.The27-yearoldwasarrest-
edby theDelhi Police’sSpecial Cell in April and charged underthe draco-
nian UAPA for her alleged role in the communal violence in Northeast
Delhi in February. In her bail plea, Zargar had listed pregnancy as one of the grounds for
seekingrelief.FollowingtheSG’ssubmission,theDelhiHighCourtgrantedherbail.Butthe
27-year old’s more than two-month old ordeal — she was denied bail twice by sessions
THE RIGHT TO DIFFER
courtsinDelhi—raisesfundamentaljurisprudentialquestions.Whywasthecardinalprinci- Are we willing to place basic moral norms above our political preferences?
pleofcriminaljustice,“presumptionofinnocenceuntilprovenguilty”—enshrinedinArticle
11(1) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and invoked by the Indian judiciary in
anumberof cases—notappliedinthiscase?Whyshouldanaccusedbecompelledtoseek Rajni Bakshi
bailonhumanitariangrounds?Doesn’ttherighttolifeandliberty,guaranteedbyArticle21
ON JUNE 3, there was a nationwide protest its struggle for justice. doubt.Oncesuppressionofprotestisvalidated
of the Constitution, offer protection against prolonged imprisonment to an undertrial?
against the arrest of those who participated How can this perennial struggle between tomorrow, on some other issue, it could be
The Code of Criminal Procedure does not define bail. But in Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia vs in the anti-CAA agitation or have otherwise means and ends shape our responses today? youoryourlovedoneswhoarearrestedsim-
the State of Punjab (1980),the SupremeCourt underlined, “Theactof arrest directly affects raised their voice in dissent. While the Those who are opposed to the CAA face a ply for upholding the Constitution.
freedom of movement of the person arrested by the police, and speaking generally, an or- Citizenship Amendment Act and National rather complicated challenge. Opponents of Equally crucial is the way in which fami-
der of bail gives back to the accused that freedom on condition that he will appear to take Register of Citizens (NRC) are vital issues theCAAcorrectlysaythattheletterandspirit lies have been sharply divided — with some
his trial”. The Court talked about Article 21 and added that “personal liberty of an accused there is a deeper question at stake here. Are of India’sConstitutionareendangeredbythis members, mainly young people, passion-
or convict is fundamental, suffering eclipse only in terms of procedure established by enough Indians willing to place basic moral law.Butthisdoesnotmeanthatallthosewho ately creating posters to hold up at anti-CAA
norms above their political preferences? For wanttheCAAarenecessarilyindifferenttothe rallies,whiletheirsiblingsorparentsorother
law”. More recently, in 2018, in Dataram Singh vs State of Uttar Pradesh, the apex court
example, it should be possible for someone civillibertiesguaranteedbytheConstitution. relatives condemn and lambast them. As
held that “the grant of bail is the general rule and putting a person in jail is an exception”. whoisinfavourof CAAtoalsoopposethear- Yes,amongthosewhosoughttosuppressthe long as all sides of the dispute are free and
Delivering the verdict, Justice Madan Lokur lamented: “Unfortunately, some of these ba- rest of protesters. anti-CAA protests, many openly do not care still together as a family, an ongoing ex-
sic principles appear to have been lost sight of with the result that more and more per- In a healthy polity, there would be no forhumanrights.Butcouldtheybeinspiredto change, a shifting of perspectives, is possi-
sons are being incarcerated and for longer periods.” He, too, invoked Article 21 and said need to state this — it would be a truism. But care for human rights? Might this become ble. When those young enthusiastic protest-
that overcrowding of prisons affects the “dignity” of convicts. today, almost the entire political spectrum possible if their social and political insecuri- ers are behind bars, uncountable creative
judgesapersonnotbytheiradherencetoba- ties were to be empathically addressed? possibilities are eliminated.
The SC has repeatedly emphasised the “humane” treatment of the accused, includ-
sic norms but by the “side” on which they Ihaveseenthishappeninbilateralconver- You may say that all of the above is a pipe
ing in the Dataram Singh case. As the Court pointed out, “conditions for the grant of bail standregarding anyspecificissue.Therefore, sations. For it to be done at a larger level, the dream,thatpoliticallifeiscontrolledbypow-
ought not to be so strict as to be incapable of compliance”. It flows from the spirit of the arrests of anti-CAA protesters are a moment human rights and civil liberties movement erfulforceswhoneverputmeansaboveends
apex court’s rulings, therefore, that bail should not be made to appear as an act of char- of reckoning for all of us. would have to make room for people who, in andthusindividuals,familiesandgroupsare
ity, as in the Zargar case — because it emanates from constitutional principles. Makingexcusesforthosewhoareon“our many respects, might be deemed to be “po- bound to be swept away. This would be tan-
side” of a political position is an old problem. liticallyincorrect”.Peoplewithwhomwedis- tamount to saying that the parents, siblings
It afflicts people across the spectrum — from People with whom we agreeonaspecificissuemightwellbecapable and friends of any of the protesters now lan-
disagree on a specific issue
ROOTS MUSIC
“left” to “right”, though there may be differ- of speaking truth to power and standing guishing in prison, should just sit back and
ences in tonality. This partly explains why might well be capable of shoulder-to-shouldertoasserttherighttodis- accept their fate.
there is no public clamour for the criminal sent. But this is possible if we don’t treat each How many people find this unthinkable
speaking truth to power and
prosecution of those who openly advocated other as “political untouchables”. and unacceptable because it is anti-life, not
Barcelona reopens the opera with plants for an audience. Their violence against those opposing the CAA. standing shoulder-to- The moment of reckoning for those who just anti-democratic? This will decide the fu-
Many who want the CAA, but not violence, shoulder to assert the right are pro-CAA is relatively straight forward. tureofoursocialfabric—thatwhichisdeeper
critical review of the performance is awaited
M
may have kept quiet lest they help the to dissent. But this can only SupposeyouareconvincedthattheCAAisim- and longer lasting than any partisan political
“other”side.Similarly,therewasatimewhen portanttosecurethefuturestabilityandsafety agenda or any particular law.
USIC, THE PYTHAGOREAN school felt, has universal resonance. It
many who were appalled by murders of
be possible if we don’t treat ofHindusinIndia.Youmayevenhavecheered
has been claimed that it improves the yield of milch cows, and that “class enemies” made excuses for the each other as ‘political the arrest of anti-CAA protesters. But surely, Rajni Bakshi is author of Bapu Kuti: Journeys
singing to indoor plants is therapeutic, both for the singer and the Naxalitemovementbecausetheysupported untouchables’. at the back of your mind, there is a niggling in Rediscovery of Gandhi
listener. And Peter Tompkins and Christopher Bird’s controversial
book, The Secret Life of Plants, became a publishing phenomenon
because it suggested that humans and plants could communicate. Now, in Spain, one of
the nations hit hard by the pandemic, Barcelona’s Liceu opera has reopened after the
lockdown with a botanical performance. There was a potted plant in every seat in the JUNE 25, 1980, FORTY YEARS AGO
otherwise empty hall. They were no doubt enriched by the music, which reached parts
that impersonal industrial fertilisers cannot. V V GIRI DEAD ASSAM CLASHES congenial atmosphere.
Theperformanceacknowledgedarealitythatwasvisibleduringthelockdown—thera- FORMER PRESIDENT V V Giri died at his SECURITY ARRANGEMENTS HAVE been
pidity with which nature reclaimed its own when human footfalls became sparse. The hu- house in T Nagar in Madras. His eldest son tightened and troops have been asked to PEACE WITH CHINA
Shankar Giri and his grandsons Girinath and stage flag marches in the trouble prone ar- A TOP CHINESE Communist Party func-
man domain which civilisation polices so self-importantly is fragile, and is breached by the
Amarnath were at the bedside. The former eas of Assam where the overall situation tionary is confident that the border issue be-
wildthemomentthehumanracefalters.Inthecollectiveunconscious,wehavealwaysbeen president is survived by his four sons and continues to be tense, according to K tween India and China could be solved in a
awareofthis,fromtheerawhensacredgrovesdottedtheworld,anditisfrequentlyreferenced seven daughters. He will be given a state fu- Ramamurthy, advisor to the governor. He spirit “of give and take”. Wang Ping Nan, a
inpopularculture,whetherinthechapterof TheJungleBook titled“LettingintheJungle”,or neral with full military honours. Chief said that five persons were seriously injured cabinet minister, told UNI “there is no obsta-
inJethroTull’sJackintheGreen.ButitiscarefullyignoredineverydaylifeintheAnthropocene, Minister M G Ramachandran and his senior in clashes between two groups at Raidanga cle between us in developing friendly rela-
in which the myth of the world-shaping, omnipotent and sapient species is given free rein. cabinet colleagues, in Delhi for Sanjay village in the Nowgong district. The cause tions”.Wang,whoisalsothepresidentof the
It is not immediately known if the potted plants in Barcelona appreciated the render- Gandhi’s funeral, are expected to be back for of the clash could not be ascertained. In a Association of Chinese Peoples’ Friendship
the former president’s last rites. President related development the All Assam With Other Countries, congratulated Indira
ing of Puccini’s “Chrysanthemum”, which was chosen to go with the theme of the show.
Sanjeeva Reddy will be represented by his Students Union reiterated its willingness to Gandhi on her return to power. He said since
But really, would it not have been more impressive if the concert had been played in a military secretary. The Union cabinet will resume dialogue on the foreigners issue but Mrs Gandhi had returned to power, “we at-
sacred grove deep in a forest? Because the potted plant spells containment and breeding, meet tomorrow to condole the death of the said it was the responsibility of the govern- tachthegreatestimportancetoherspeeches
and is the very antithesis of the wild. former president. ment, and not the student body, to create a on foreign relations”.
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
New Delhi
14 WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
´fdV¨f¸ffa¨f»f d½fôb°f d½f°fSX¯f d³f¦f¸f d»f. KASHMIR POWER DISTRIBUTION CORPORATION LIMITED (KPDCL)
(Fully Owned Government of J&K Undertaking)
d½fôb°f d½f°fSX¯f J¯OX-dõX°fe¹f, ¶ff¦f´f°f OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (Planning)
A»´fIYf»fe³f-d³fd½fQf Àfc¨f³ff PLANNING & PROCUREMENT WING, KASHMIR
Email: epndcs@gmail.com
A»´fIYf»fe³f-d³fd½fQf Àfc¨f³ff: d³f¸³fd»fdJ°f I f¹fûË/ Af´fcd°fÊ IZ d»fE A³fb·f½fe, e-TENDER ABBREVIATED NOTICE
d½fV½fÀf³fe¹f E½fa SdªfÀMOÊ NZ IZ QfSûÔ ÀfZ ¸fbW S¶faQ A»f¦f-A»f¦f d³fd½fQf¹fZÔ Qû ·ff¦fûÔ ¸fZÔ e- NIT NO: SE/EPL/e-NIT-06 of 2020-21 Dated: 20.06.2020
Af¸fadÂf°f W`a ªfû dQ³ffaI 11.07.2020 I û 12.00 ¶fªfZ °fI ´fif´°f I e ªff¹fZ¦fe AüS For and on behalf of the Managing Director, KPDCL, Superintending Engineer, Planning Circle, P&P Wing, KPDCL invites online
e-bids from Govt. registered original equipment manufacturers for supply of 33KV Outdoor Vacuum Circuit Breakersfor the require-
CÀfe dQ³f 14.00 ¶fªfZ Àff½fʪfd³fI ø ´f ÀfZ Jû»fe ªff¹fZ¦feÜ d³fd½fQf IZ ´fi±f¸f ·ff¦f ¸fZÔ ment of KPDCL as under:
Sr. Material Description For ECSD Pampore
EªfZ³Àfe õfSf ´f`³f I fOÊ , Af²ffS I fOÊ °f±ff d³fd½fQf ¸fc»¹f E½fa ²fSûWS SfdVf I e No. (Qty. in No.’s)
²f³fSfdVf £f¯O I f¹ffÊ»f¹f IZ £ff°fZ ¸fZÔ AfS.Me.ªfe.EÀf/ E³f.BÊ ER .Me. IZ ¸ff²¹f¸f ÀfZ 1. 33KV OUTDOOR VACUUM CIRCUIT BREAKERS FOR USE AT 33/11KV SUBSTATION 25
ªf¸ff I SfBÊ ªff¹fZ¦fe °f±ff ¶f`ÔI ¸fZÔ ªf¸ff I f Àffùf ¹fc.Me.AfS. Àf£¹ff/ ´fZ-B³f.dÀ»f´f The complete tender document is available at website http://jktenders.gov.in. Interested bidder/tenderers may view, download the e-
Bid document, seek clarification and submit their e-Bid online up to the date and time mentioned in the table below. Bidding Documents
¸fc»f I e ´fid°f Àfa»f¦³f I e ªff¹fZ¦feÜ dõ°fe¹f ·ff¦f QSm ´fiÀ°fb°f I S³fe Wû¦feÜ d³fd½fQf £fb»f³fZ contain Qualifying Criteria for Bidders, Specifications, Bill of Quantities, Terms and Conditions of Contract and other details.
I e d°fd±f ´fS A½fI fVf Wû³fZ I e QVff ¸fZÔ ¹fW d³fd½fQfEa C´fSû¢°ff³fbÀffS A¦f»fZ i) Date and Time of downloading/Sale (Start) of Tender Document 22.06.2020; 14:00 Hrs
I f¹fÊdQ½fÀf ¸fZÔ £fû»fe ªff¹fZ¦feÜ A²fûWÀ°ffÃfSe I û A´fc¯fÊ, ÂfbdM´fc¯fÊ A±f½ff Àf¸fÀ°f ii) Date & Time of Download/Sale (End) of Tender Document 13.07.2020; 15:00 Hrs
iii) Date & Time of Bidding Queries/Clarifications 25.06.2020; 10:00 Hrs to 27.06.2020; 16:00 Hrs
d³fd½fQfEaZ d³fSÀ°f I S³fZ I f Ad²fI fS ´fc¯fÊ°f: ÀfbS dÃf°f SWZ ¦ffÜ A»´fIYf»fe³f d³fd½fQf iv) Date & Time of Bid Uploading (Start/End) 29.06.2020; 10:00 Hrs to 13.07.2020; 15:00 Hrs
Àfa. 07/ 2020-21 d½fôb°f d½f°fS¯f C´f£f¯O-¨f°fb±fÊ JZI OÞ f IZ ÃfZÂff²fe³f 33/11 v) Submission of Hard Copy (end) Date & Time 15.07.2020; 16:00 Hrs in the office of CE P&P wing,
IZ ½fe d½fôb°f C´fIZ ³ýi dR Sûªf´fbS ´fS Ãfd°f¦fiÀ°f Wb E 5 E¸f.½fe.E. ´ffg½fS ´fdS½f°fÊI IZ PDD Complex, Bemina, Srinagar
À±ff³f ´fS 33/11 IZ ½fe d½fôb°f C´fIZ ³ýi J˜f ´fiW »ffQ´fbS ´fS »f¦fZ 5 E¸f.½fe ´fdS½f°fÊI vi) Commercial/Technical Bid Opening Date & Time 17.07.2020 at 14:00 Hrs
vii) Financial Bid Opening Shall be declared later on for the technically qualified
I ûÔ ½ffW³f õfSf »ffI S 33/11 IZ ½fe d½fôb°f C´fIZ ³ýi dR Sûªf´fbS ´fS Ãfd°f¦fiÀ°f bidders
´fdS½f°fÊI IZ À±ff³f ´fS À±ffd´f°f I S³fZ I f I f¹fÊÜ Àf¸fÀ°f ´fi°¹fZI d³fd½fQfAûa I e viii) Venue of Commercial/ Technical Bid Opening Soft Copy Electronically and Hard Copy in the office of
CE P&P wing, KPDCL
²fSûWS SfdVf 2000.00 d³f²ffÊdS°f d³fd½fQf Vfb»I SfdVf 500+18 ´fid°fVf°f ªfe.EÀf.Me. ix) Cost of e-Bid document Rs.500.00 (Rupees Five Hundred only) for local firms
A´fid°fQZ¹f ÀfdW°f E½fa ²fSûWS SfdVf E³f.BÊ. ER .Me./ AfS.Me.ªfe.EÀf. IZ ¸ff²¹f¸f ÀfZ of J&K (UT) Rs.5000.00 (Rupees Five thousand Only)
for firms outside the J&K. (Non-refundable)
´faªff¶f ³fZVf³f»f ¶f`ÔI , £ûI OÞ f IZ £ff°ff Àfa.- 6444005700000019 AfBÊ.ER .Àfe. x) Amount of Earnest Money Deposit Rs.5000.00 (Rupees Five thousand only) for local
I ûO ´fe.¹fc.E³f.¶fe.-0644400 ¸fZÔ ªf¸ff I SfI S ¶f`ÔI ªf¸ff I f Àffùf ¹f±ff ¹fûª¹f. firms of J&K and Rs.188000.00 (Rupees One Lac
Eighty Eight Thousand only) for firms outside the J&K.
¹fc.Me.AfS. Àfa£¹ff ´fZ-B³f dÀ»f´f I e ¸fc»f´fid°f A³¹f Af½fV¹fI ´fi´fÂfûÔ IZ Àff±f dQ³ffaI
Superintending Engineer
11.07.2020 I û 12.00 ¶fªfZ °fI ´fif~ dI ¹fZ ªff ÀfI °fZ W`Ô Ü A³¹f d³f¹f¸f E½fa Vf°fZË DIPK-867 Planning (KPDCL)
d³fd½fQf ´fi´fÂf IZ Àff±f Àfa»f¦³f W` Ü IÈ ´f¹ff d½fÀ°fÈ°f Àfc¨f³ff d³f¦f¸f I e Website:
www.pvvnl.org ´fS QZ£fe ªff ÀfI °fe W` Ü d½fôb°f W` »´f »ffBÊ ³f 1800-180-
3002 (¸fZS N), 1800-180-8752 (»f£f³fD ) SXfáÑXe¹f dWX°f ¸fZÔ d¶fªf»fe ¶f¨ff¹fZÔÜ
WXÀ°ff./- Ad²fVffÀfe Ad·f¹f³°ff, ´fÂffaIY- 736/ d½f.d½f.£f.-dõX ¶ff./ d½fÄff´f³f,
dQ³ffaIY: 24.06.2020
New Delhi
E EXPLAINED
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
15
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
@ieExplained
#ExpressExplained
If there are questions of current or contemporary relevance that you would like
explained, please write to explained@indianexpress.com
307,682
United Kingdom
THE WORLD
238,833
Italy
212,501
Iran
606,043
Russia Evolving strategy on testing
In ICMR’s updated strategy, all symptomatic individuals anywhere in India are to be tested for Covid-19.
At one stage, ICMR was cautious about testing indiscriminately. A look at how the protocols have evolved
2,348,956
US
wide sero-survey to assess the spread. This
260,810 KARISHMA MEHROTRA was also spurred by ICMR’s validation of its
Peru
NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 own “indigenous” antibody test kit.
1,145,906 456,183 On May 30, ICMR reintroduced advice to
Brazil
246,752 India ON TUESDAY, the Indian Council of Medical states to use antibody tests, focusing on
250,767 Spain Research (ICMR) made a large shift in Covid- workers who have returned from other
Chile 19testingstrategy,callingfor“allsymptomatic states, those who live in dense settings or
TOTAL CONFIRMED: 9,295,365 DEATH COUNT: 478,289 individualsineverypartof thecountry”tobe
tested. It also urged private hospitals, offices,
poorly ventilated buildings; people who
work in certain sectors; people in contain-
Source: Johns Hopkins University, updated at 11 pm on June 24 . JHU’s India tally and Health and public sector units to conduct antibody mentzones; policeandparamilitaryperson-
Ministry’s tally (below) may not match if these are accounted at different times. testing as a surveillance measure. nel, and prison officials, among others.
A look at how ICMR’s testing protocols By May-end, the positivity rate in India
have evolved since the outbreak began: had begun to steepen just as the country be-
gan testing over 1 lakh samples a day. Along
Study projects 95k additional March: Reserved testing
OnMarch17,thestrategywasfarmorehes-
with the expanding testing strategy, facili-
tiesandtypesof kitsalsograduallyincreased.
TB deaths in India due to Covid itant than now. “To avoid indiscriminate test-
ing and reducing panic and optimally utilise
the resources of the country and scale up fa- A sample collected for rapid antigen test in New Delhi. PTI
June: rapid antigen tests
The ICMR approved on June 15 a new on-
ANEWmodellingstudyhasestimated 6,000 in China). In the worst case sce- cilities for testing,” it said, under “Objectives”. site diagnostic kit for containment zones and
thattheCovid-19pandemiccouldsig- nario, this number could rise to up to The strategy focused only on three sympto- healthcaresettings,whichcangiverapid,low-
nificantly increase the global burden 200,000 additional deaths, the re- maticpeople:internationaltravellers,contacts hotspotsandmigrantcentresonApril4,leav- lows.StateslikeUPjumpedontothestrategy. cost results without needing a laboratory.
of tuberculosis due to disruptions to searchers estimated. of a case, and healthcare workers. ing the decision to state governments. These The ICMR still faced a backlash for lack of In containment zones, the rapid antigen
health services, and delays to diagno- Theresearchersreferredtoearlyan- “Why should we go on telling people testsarenotdiagnostic,butcandetermineif a testing. Respondingto a question at the daily testwasencouragedforallpeoplewithfever
sisandtreatment.InIndia,itestimates ecdotal information from China, India who have no history of travel or any contact patienthaspreviouslyhadcoronavirus.States briefing, Dr R R Gangakhedkar, head of epi- and cough and all contacts of a case who are
TB will cause an additional 95,000 andSouthAfricathatsuggeststhatthe with an actual case?” ICMR Senior scientist likeKerala,TamilNadu,andChhattisgarhwere demiology and infectious diseases at ICMR, direct,asymptomatic,andhavehighco-mor-
deaths in the next five numberofpeoplebeing NiveditaGuptahadsaidtotheIndianExpress eager to undertake this type of surveillance. said: “As for testing strategy, your chances of bidities.Inhealthcaresettings,thetestwillbe
years.Thestudyispub- diagnosed and treated at the time. “In this process, in a huge coun- Later,theICMRreverseditsdecision,given testing positive become less as you near the usedforallpatientsof influenza-likeillnesses
lished in the European for TB has fallen signifi- try like India, I’m not able to test people who a batch of faulty kits from China. There also infection time point. It comes positive when suspectedof havingcontractedCovid-19and
Respiratory Journal. cantly. These three genuinely may need testing because I’m was divergence between the World Health there are symptoms, so keeping in mind the asymptomatic patients who are immuno-
Researchers esti- countries make up ap- wasting it on futile testing. Though we are Organization and ICMR in the beginning of cost effectiveness and risk-based approach, suppressedorhaveotherco-morbidities.The
mated additional TB proximately 40% of the maintaining a stringent inventory, we also April,withtheformersayingantibodytesting your yield will become less the sooner you test will also be available for asymptomatic
deaths and cases in global TB cases. The re- need to make sure that we are not in a situ- should be used for research. Subsequent ad- test.Eventothinkaboutchangingthetesting patientsundergoingcertainproceduressuch
China, India and South
Africaoverthenextfive
PAPER searchersmodelleddif-
ferent scenarios with
ation where I exhaust all my testing capac-
ity in futile testing and tomorrow, if there is
visoriesfromICMRdetailedantibodytesting
as “supplementary” to RT-PCR testing.
strategy now… I cannot say.” as neurosurgeries, dental work, and dialysis.
Whilepositiveresultswillbeconsideredcon-
years. They hypothe-
sised that social dis-
CLIP various implementa-
tionsofsocialdistancing
an upsurge in cases, I say that I have ex-
hausted all my tests.”
The ICMR also advised enhanced testing
in 20 hotspots, including Nizamuddin and
May: Expanded protocols
OnMay18,ICMRaddedsymptomaticmi-
firmed, in case of negative results, an RT-PCR
would be done for reconfirmation.
tancing might reduce measures and health Atthetime,privateplayershadnotyetbeen Dilshad Garden in Delhi, Pathanamthitta in grants,hospitalisedpatients,frontlinework- Maharashtra,Delhi,Gujarat,Haryana,and
NEW RESEARCH
TB incidence as the service disruption last- ropedintoconducttesting,andtheICMRwas Kerala, and Mumbai and Pune. erstothetestingstrategy.Theinclusionof all UP have procured rapid antigen testing kits.
bacteriabehindthedis- ing for six months, to justinstitutingprocessestoexpandlabcapac- On April 9, it added symptomatic patients “hospitalisedpatientswhodevelopILIsymp- “All the states are gearing upnowto start the
ease is transmitted via droplets — come up with their estimates. ity.AttheendofMarch,itgraduallyexpanded in hotspots, large migration gatherings and toms” indicated the concern over patients testing with this and almost all states will
similar to the coronavirus. Even after The study was conducted by re- testing to include hospitalised patients with evacuee centres to the testing strategy. New contracting the disease in hospital. And the eventually buy it. Many hospitals are also in-
taking this reduced transmission into searchers from the London School of severeacuterespiratoryillness(SARI)aswellas ICMR research at the time also found the per- inclusion of “returnees/migrants”, irrespec- quiringandplacingtheorderforanysympto-
account, the most likely scenario was Hygiene & Tropical Medicine and asymptomaticcontactsofcases.Thenewfocus centageof randompositivesamplesof Covid- tive of contact history or whether they are matic individuals in their hospital with a
estimated to result in more than Lancaster University. ran alongside the agency’s first surveillance 19amongSARIpatientsacrossthecountryhas travelling from a hotspot, signalled concerns heavy viral load,” said an official from SD
110,000 additional TB deaths (95,000 Source: London School of Hygiene & method — testing SARI patients to see if any increasedincrementallyoverthepastmonth. about possible community transmission. Biosensor, which is supplying the test kit.
in India, 13,000 in South Africa and Tropical Medicine were positive for Covid-19. On April 13, the ICMR detailed pooled Also in May, the Health Ministry decided The advisory on June 23 said: “Despite
sampling in areas with few cases or low pos- nottotestmildandmoderatecasesbeforetheir new types of testing kits being added, access
April: New techniques itivity rates. If any positive sample comes for dischargeorafterahomeisolationperiod. to testing still remains a huge challenge in a
ICMR advised rapid antibody tests in apoolof samples,thenindividualtestingfol- The government also initiated a nation- large country like India.”
INDIA COUNT: 4,56,183 (14,476 DEATHS)
TOP 10 STATES REST OF INDIA
AndamanandNicobarIslands 50
ArunachalPradesh
11,520
Haryana
148
Assam
Bihar
Chandigarh
5831
8153
418
How diesel got costlier than petrol in Delhi
15,627 66,602 Delhi Chhattisgarh 2362
spitegreaterhikesindieselpricesthanpetrol
Rajasthan DadraandNagarHaveli 120
18,893 UP Goa
HimachalPradesh
909
775
KARUNJIT SINGH DIESEL PRICE HIGHER ONLY IN DELHI prices over the last 18 days.
JammuandKashmir 6236 NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 STATE/REGION PETROL DIESEL
Jharkhand 2185 Why were prices frozen, and why are
Karnataka 9721 Salestax Price (`/lt) Salestax Price(`/lt)
12,261 Kerala 3451 FORTHEfirsttime,thepriceof dieselinDelhi Delhi 30%VAT 79.76 `250/klairambience 79.88 they rising now?
28,371 MP Ladakh 932 hassurpassedthatofpetrol:Dieselisupby48 charges+30%VAT OMCs stopped revising prices from
Gujarat
14,728 Manipur 921 paise per litre to Rs 79.88, compared to Rs March16toJune7wheninternationalprices
West Bengal Meghalaya 46 Gujarat 17%VAT+4%cess 77.26 17%VAT+ 4%cess 77.18
Mizoram 142 79.76 for petrol. Diesel prices remain lower of crudeoilhithistoriclows.Duringthistime,
ontownrate&VAT ontownrate&VAT
1,39,010 Nagaland 330 thanthoseof petrolelsewhereinthecountry. the only revisions in the prices of diesel and
Maharashtra Odisha 5470 Karnataka 35%salestax 82.35 24%salestax 75.51
Puducherry 402 The price of petrol has risen by Rs petrol were a result of changes in state taxes.
Punjab 4397 8.50/litre and that of diesel by Rs 10.50 since Mumbai, 26%VAT+ Rs.10.12/litre 86.54 24%VAT+Rs.3.00/l 78.22 Representativesof IndianOilCorporation,
10,002 Sikkim 79 NaviMumbai additionaltax additionaltax
64,603 Andhra Pradesh Telangana 9553
June 7, when oil marketing companies India’slargest OMC, saidthey had decided to
Tamil Nadu Tripura 1259 (OMCs)beganrevisingpricesafteran82-day TamilNadu 15%+Rs.13.02perlitre 83.04 11%+Rs.9.62/litre 77.17 stop revising pricesinlinewithinternational
Uttarakhand 2535 hiatus during which the international crude prices of petrol and diesel. Had they done so
Source:PPAC
price fell below $20/barrel. during the fall in the prices of crude in late
UnionHealthMinistryupdateasof 11pm,June24.Somestatesmayhave
March and April, it would have led to “nega-
reportedhighernumbers.Onlystates/UTswithatleastonecaselistedabove.
Why has this happened in Delhi? price within Rs 2 of the price of petrol at the difference. The prices of dieseland petrol are tive margins” for the OMCs. Now, the OMCs
2,58,685 PATIENTS DISCHARGED IN 34 STATES AND UNION TERRITORIES The price gap between petrol and diesel time; the gap has closed since with OMCs almost equal in Ahmedabad as the VAT on are revising domestic prices of petrol and
was Rs 7.30 on May 5 when the Delhi gov- hiking diesel prices more than petrol prices. both petrol and diesel is comparable. diesel are rising in line with international
Have a question on the COVID-19 outbreak and what you should/should not do? ernmentincreasedVATondieselto30%from According to experts, there is very little dif- While other states have also hiked levies prices of petrol and diesel. And international
Write to explained@indianexpress.com 16.75% and on petrol to 30% from 27%. Diesel ference between international prices of on both fuels, most have maintained lower pricesof bothdiesel andpetrol are rising due
also attracts an additional air ambience levy petrol and diesel currently, leading to taxes tax rates on diesel than on petrol, so that to increasing demand as countries ease
of Rs 250/kilolitre. This brought the diesel becoming the key component in the price diesel has remained cheaper than petrol de- Covid-induced restrictions.
` 150,000 cr plus: the govt stimulus for rural areas post lockdown
denlyfindingthemselveswithoutwork)and down,bycontrast,hasaffectedtheseindus- only feasible economic activity under the purchasing grain from farmers without vi-
HARISH DAMODARAN reducedrequirementduetoforcedinactiv- GROWTH IN GROSS VALUE ADDED tries far more than agriculture. existing circumstances. All administrative olation of social distancing norms.
NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 ity (as with the rich and better off). Thetableshowsthatagriculturalgrowth steps were, therefore, taken to permit
Either way, the outcome was the same. (% YEAR-ON-YEAR) had surpassed overall economic growth movement of labourers and machines for ■ ■ ■
THERE ARE many parallels one can draw Notebandi and gharbandi both basically Constant Current during the last two quarters of 2019-20, in farmers to harvest their rabi crop.
between the novel coronavirus-induced “flattened” farm produce prices, by shifting Prices Prices real as well as nominal terms after factor- Itistruethatfarmersthistimeround,too, Agriculture’s newfound importance is
lockdown (gharbandi) and demonetisation the demand curves to the left. The demand Farm* General Farm* General ing in inflation. Even after lockdown came haveincurredlossesonsalesofmilkandper- also reflected in the two major reforms that
(notebandi), in terms of their impact on drop wasn’t due to prices going up. Rather, into effect from March 25, farm-related op- ishableproduce,fromtomatoes,carrots,cap- mightnothavecomeaboutinnormaltimes.
India’s farm economy. Both resulted in the with consumption being limited to homes Apr-Jun 3.84 6.95 6.69 11.92 erations — from harvesting and sale of pro- sicumandgourdstograpes,bananas,water- The first one permits sale and purchase of
2018
same thing – demand destruction – albeit — manpower shortages forced many food duceinmandis,totheirintra-andinter-state melons and totapuri mangoes. The collapse farm produce outside the physical bound-
through different routes. companies to also curtail productionin fac- Jul-Sep 2.54 6.06 2.88 11.06 movement — were exempted from ghar- of institutional demand and out-of-home aries of state-regulated mandis. That, in the-
Notebandicausedahaemorrhagingofliq- tories and, hence, cut raw material pur- 2018 bandi restrictions. consumptionhasfurtherhurtpoultry,maize ory, gives farmers freedom to sell directly to
uidity from the predominantly cash-based chases — there was less demand now for Oct-Dec 1.98 5.62 2.30 9.66 The second major difference has been and sugarcane growers, whether through processors,exporters,wholesalersandretail-
farmproducemarkets.Inthepre-demoneti- milk,potatoesortomatoesevenatthesame 2018 government response. India’s imports of slide in prices or non-payment by mills. ers both within and outside their states, in-
sation era, it wasn’t uncommon for individ- price. This wasn’t, in other words, simply a Jan-Mar 1.62 5.55 6.58 9.45 pulses and edible oils peaked during 2015- Butit’salsoafactthatgovernmentagen- cludingthroughelectronictradingplatforms.
ualtraderstopurchaseproduceworthRs50 “movement along the demand curve”, but 2019 16 to 2017-18. This period, before and after cies have undertaken record procurement The second reform does away with the im-
lakhorevenRs1croredailyduringthepeak a “leftward shift in the demand curve”. Apr-Jun 2.96 4.76 8.60 8.00 demonetisation, saw the government for- of wheat (38.6 million tonnes of the 2019- position of ECA stockholding limits on food-
arrival season and make payments to farm- The other similarity between demon- 2019 mally embracing “inflation targeting” and 20crop,withminimumsupportpricevalue stuffs, save under extraordinary conditions.
ers entirely in cash. With demonetisation, etisation and lockdown is that both struck also giving the Essential Commodities Act of overRs74,200crore)andpaddy(74.3mt, Thesewerepowersthatthisverygovernment
Jul-Sep 3.51 4.33 8.53 6.23
andalsorestrictionsoncashtransactionsin- just after farmers had produced a bumper a new leaseof life. Stockholdinglimits were including15.7mtafterMarch31andworth had, ironically, been invoking until recently.
2019
troduced in the 2017-18 Union Budget, rabi crop — the former in April-June 2017 clamped from time to time on onion, pota- Rs 28,500 crore). Besides, they have bought Ittookanall-roundeconomiccrisis,which
wholesale mandis were suddenly denuded and the latter barely three years later. Oct-Dec 3.60 3.47 13.93 7.02 toes, pulses and sugar, alongside allowing about 1.8 mt of chana (valued at Rs 8,750 Covid-19 brutally lay bare, to recognise the
of liquidity and, thereby, demand. 2019 duty-free imports and placing of export crore),0.8mtof rapeseed-mustard(Rs3,300 value and potential of Indian agriculture. If
In gharbandi, demand destruction was ■ ■ ■ Jan-Mar 5.87 3.04 12.99 6.85 curbs. These measures were persisted with crore) and 0.3 mt of tur/arhar (Rs 1,750 the Rs 17,622 crore of wage payments made
wrought not by a lack of cash, but of buyers 2020 despiteconsumerfoodpriceinflationruling crore). Add the Rs 16,750 crore direct trans- under MGNREG from April 1 is also ac-
themselves. And these were institutional Notwithstanding these and other simi- *Agriculture,forestry&fishing. below general retail inflation since fersto8.37crorefarmeraccountsasfirst-in- countedfor,thegovernment’stotalspendon
buyers, as opposed to households. The clo- larities — both followed overnight 8 pm an- Source:NationalStatisticalOffice. September 2016. Import controls came in stallment payment of Rs 2,000 each under farmers and rural workers in the past three
sure of hotels, restaurants, tea stalls, street nouncements by Prime Minister Narendra only towards late 2017, partly in reaction to the PM-Kisan Samman Nidhi scheme, the months will be well in excess of Rs 150,000
food joints, sweetmeat shops, hostels and Modi — there are differences between the growing agrarian unrest. total liquidity pumped into the farm econ- crore.WiththeCovidsituationincitiesshow-
canteens—inadditiontonoweddingrecep- situations brought about by gharbandi and agri-commoditypricecrash in2014-15and The government’s approach during omy, post-lockdown, by the government ing little improvement, it is clearly laying all
tions and other public functions — led to a notebandi. 2015-16. Also, notebandi primarily hit agri- lockdown has, in comparison, been more works out to more than Rs 133,000 crore. hopes of an economic recovery on Bharat.
collapseof out-of-homefoodconsumption. To start with, when demonetisation culture and informal enterprises, while or- proactive. One reason for it might be the re- That isn’t small money, given the short (A different version of this article appeared
Even household-level food consumption happened,thefarmsectorhadalreadygone ganised manufacturing and services sector alisation that agriculture — apart from be- time span (less than three months) within this week in India in Transition, published by the
wasaffectedbyfallingincomes(inrespectof through tough times, with back-to-back firms had actually benefited from demon- ing “essential” for supplying food in a pub- whichthisliquidityinfusionhastakenplace Center for the Advanced Study of India,
poor and lower middle class families sud- droughtsin2014and2015ontopof aglobal etisation and the GST regime. The lock- lic health emergency — offered itself as the and the sheer logistics involved in physical University of Pennsylvania)
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
16 THE WORLD
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
UNITED NATIONS
UN URGES ISRAEL AGAINST ANNEXATION
United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres urged Israel on Wednesday
to abandon plans to annex settlements in the occupied West Bank, warning this
threatened prospects for peace with the Palestinians.
oppositionparty AstheUnitedStatescontinues
toreopenitseconomy,casenum-
aheadofpolls bers are rising in more than 20
states, mostly in the South and
Transporting oxygen cylinders in Conakry, Guinea. AP
PAKISTAN
Foundation
stonelaidfor
by virus worry: minister primary upset reminiscent of AOC Trump aide Flynn
Islamabad’s1st Gleeson, whom he appointed as
ASIF SHAHZAD AGENCIES REUTERS & NYT
Hindutemple ISLAMABAD, JUNE 24 WASHINGTON, JUNE 24 WASHINGTON, JUNE 24
a “friend of the court” to argue
against dropping the case.
Islamabad: Pakistan has Flynn, a retired Army lieu-
started the construction THE PILOTS of a Pakistan airliner JAMAAL BOWMAN, a liberal Jamaal AUSappealscourtonWednesday tenantgeneral,wasoneofseveral
process of a Rs 10 crore that crashed last month, killing Black middle-school principal, Bowman directed a federal judge to drop a former Trump aides charged un-
Hindu temple — the first 97 people, were distracted as was ahead in early Democratic speaks to criminal case against President derformerSpecialCounselRobert
inIslamabad.TheKrishna they talked about the coron- primaryelectionresultsTuesday supporters in Donald Trump’s former national Mueller’s investigation that de-
temple will come up in a aviruspandemicthroughoutthe in his bid to oust long-time US New York. securityadviserMichaelFlynnfor tailed Moscow’s interference in
20,000 sq ft plot at the flight before an abortive landing The plane crashed in a Representative Eliot Engel from Reuters lying to the FBI,handing a victory the2016USpresidentialelection.
capital’s H-9 area. The bid, an initial inquiry report residential area in Karachi a congressional seat represent- to the Justice Department in an-
groundbreaking cere- showed on Wednesday. last month, killing 97 ing part of New York. other twist to the politically ‘Stone case politicised’
mony for the temple was Presenting the report in par- people. Reuters If Engel, who has served in came the presumptive presi- more afraid of than anything charged case. Meanwhile, senior law en-
performed by liament, Aviation Minister Congressformorethan30years, dential nominee. else? A Black man with power. In a 2-1 decision, a panel of forcement officials intervened to
Parliamentary Secretary Ghulam Sarwar Khan said both weretolose,itwouldechoasim- Bowman, 44, was leading That is what Donald Trump is the US Court of Appeals for the seek a more lenient prison sen-
on Human Rights Lal the pilots and officials at air traf- co-pilot on the cockpit voice ilar upset in 2018, when Engel, the chairman of the afraid of,” Bowman said. Districtof ColumbiaCircuitruled tence for Trump’s friend and ally
Chand Malhi on Tuesday. fic control did not follow set pro- recorderthathesaidshowedthey Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez de- House Foreign Affairs On Twitter, Bowman wrote: in favor of Flynn and the Trump Roger Stone for political reasons,
The Hindu population in cedures, leading to the crash. were not focused on their tasks. feated Joseph Crowley, then the Committee, by 59.48% to 35.31%, “I’m a Black man raised by a sin- administrationinpreventingU.S. aformerprosecutoronthecaseis
Islamabad has increased Thepilotswerenot“focused” “Corona was dominant over No. 4 House Democrat. the New York state elections gle mother in a housing project. District Judge Emmet Sullivan expected to testify before
significantly in the last because of the coronavirus pan- their mind. Their family was af- Ocasio-Cortez was also on board said, with 627 of 732 elec- That story doesn’t usually end in fromexercisinghisdiscretionon Congress on Wednesday.
two decades and, there- demic, headded,though the air- fected, and they were dis- course for victory in her contest tion precincts reporting. Congress. But today, that 11-year whether to grant the depart- “WhatIheard—repeatedly—
fore, the temple was nec- craft had no technical fault. cussing corona.” against a challenger in a neigh- “EliotEngelusedtosayhewas old boy beaten by police is about ment’s motion to clear Flynn, was that Roger Stone was being
essary, the Dawn News “Unfortunately...the discus- The aircraft suffered no tech- boring New York district, in athorninthesideof (Republican to be your Representative. I can't who twice pleaded guilty. treateddifferentlyfromanyother
quoted Malhi as saying. sion throughout was about co- nicalflaw,Khansaid.“Theunfor- races that tested the strength of President) Donald Trump,” wait to get to DC and cause prob- The ruling prevents Sullivan defendantbecauseofhisrelation-
rona,” Khan said, referring to ex- tunate plane was 100% fit to fly,” the Democratic Party’s left wing Bowman told supporters. “But lems for those maintaining the from hearing arguments at a July ship to the President,” the prose-
changes between the pilot and he added. REUTERS after moderate Joe Biden be- youknowwhatDonaldTrumpis status quo.” 16hearingfromretiredjudgeJohn cutor, Aaron S.J. Zelinsky, said.
THEY OFTEN DEFEND CHINA AGAINST CRITICS. BUT WHEN THEY TRIED TO RETURN DURING PANDEMIC, THEY BECAME TARGETS
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
17 ECONOMY
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020
SENSEX: 34,868.98 ▼ 561.45 NIFTY: 10,305.30 ▼ 165.70 NIKKEI: 22,534.32 ▼ 14.73 HANG SENG: 24,781.58 ▼ 125.76 FTSE: 6,188.65 ▼ 131.47 DAX: 12,303.73 ▼ 220.03
International market data till 1900 IST
E
COSWITHHIGHESTRISEINNO.OFRETAILSHAREHOLDERS
expenditure to create their deposits he said. The deci- In another decision, the
EXPLAINED
ENSECONOMICBUREAU sioncomesinthebackdropofthe Cabinet approved a scheme to Company Retailshareholders Retailshareholders Increase
NEWDELHI,JUNE24 RBIgets RBI imposing restrictions on de- provide 2 per cent interest sub- asonDec31, asonMar31, (inlakh)
headroom for dovetailing IN ORDER to protect depositors’ ●
morepowers posit withdrawal at the Punjab
and Maharashtra Cooperative
ventiontoShishucategoryofbor-
rowersunderthePradhanMantri SBI
2019(lakh)
18.23
2020(lakh)
24.11 5.89
stimulus package interests, the government ap-
proved plans to bring all urban
andmulti-statecooperativebanks
CURRENTLY,URBANand
multi-statecooperative
banksareregulatedbyRBI
Banks and many other coopera-
tivebanksfailinginrecentperiod.
Unlikeinthecaseofcommer-
MUDRAYojana(PMMY),onloans
outstandingasonMarch31,2020.
Under Shishu category, lenders
YESBANK
HDFCBANK
16.18
8.78
19.97
12.56
3.78
3.78
underthedirectsupervisionofthe andRegistrarof cial banks, the RBI till now has no providecollateral-freeloansofup
RIL 22.29 25.42 3.13
AANCHALMAGAZINE The govt’s fiscal Reserve Bank of India (RBI), em- CooperativeSocieties, powerstodrawupanenforceable toRs50,000.Theinterestsubven- TATAMOTORS 10.56 13.09 2.53
NEWDELHI,JUNE24 poweringthecentralbanktoreg- withthecentralbanknot schemeof reconstructionof aco- tion will be for a period of 12 Note: Rise in March quarter; source: nseinfobase.com
stimulus in the wake of
ulate these on the lines of com- havingpowersthatithas operative bank. The Cabinet had months to eligible borrowers
WITH THE Centre rolling out the pandemic has been mercialbanks.TheUnionCabinet forcommercialbanks. in February approved amend- About9.37croreloanaccounts vestors in the year ended March
fresh expenditure rationalisa- restrained with limited Wednesdayapprovedpromulga- DirectRBIsupervisionand ment to Banking Regulation Act underthe Shishu categorywitha SANDEEPSINGH 2020, witnessed net investor ad-
tion plans for the July- cash outgo, a factor tionofanOrdinancetothiseffect. regulationwillprovide to strengthen cooperative banks total loan amount of Rs 1.62 lakh NEWDELHI,JUNE24 ditionforthefirsttimein10years.
Septemberquarter,thecurtail- “Inourcountrythereare1482 comforttodepositors. andavoidPMCBanklikecrisisaf- crore were outstanding as on Thecompany,whichhadsawade-
that economists said
mentofgovernmentspending urbancooperativesbanksand58 ter an announcement was made March31,aspergovernmentdata. TAKINGTHEsharpfallinmarkets clineinitsinvestorbasefrom35.62
to levels far lower than what has been driven by the multi-State cooperative banks, in the Budget 2020-21 to this ef- The interest relief will be pro- in the quarter ended March 31, lakhintheyearendedMarch2010
was budgeted for this fiscal concerns of debt levels They have been brought under while briefing media about the fect. videdonlytothoseShishuloanac- 2020 as an opportunity to invest, to 22.11 lakh in the year ended
raises fresh concerns that the RBI supervision process, which is Cabinet decisions. Currently, these banks come counts which are not NPA (non retail investors rushed in huge March 2019, saw it rise to 26.32
economic recovery process applicable to scheduled banks. These banks have a depositor under dual regulation of the RBI performing assets). The scheme, numberstobuypieceof bluechip lakhattheendof March2020.
could get more drawn out. headoverthelastonemonth. Depositorswillgetmoresecurity base of 8.6 crore, who have saved and the Registrar of Co-operative estimated to cost government Rs companies.The10companiesthat Pranav Haldea, MD, Prime
While the cut in budgeted Governmentspendinghas because of today’s decision,” a huge amount of Rs 4.84 lakh Societies, resulting in regulatory 1,542crore, will beimplemented witnessedthehighestadditionin Database,saidretailinvestorsgen-
spendingispresumablybeing to increase substantially, Sen Information and Broadcasting crore with these banks, and this andsupervisorylapsesatmanyof through the Small Industries shareholder numbers during the erallyarenotthemostprudentin-
done to allow enough head- said,addingonceeconomyre- Minister Prakash Javadekar said decision will provide safety on these banks. Development Bank of India. quarter added an aggregate of vestors. Stating the retail holding
room to dovetail the stimulus coversandprivateinvestment nearly 30 lakh investors in the in penny stocks is three times
packageannouncedlastmon- startspickingup,thenthegov- companies. The names include — morethanFPIsthatretailinvestors
th,economistspointtoseveral
key elements of the stimulus
ernment could start the fiscal
consolidation.“Thenyoubring ‘Concerned’ over Chinese shipments, Hinduja State Bank of India, Reliance
Industries,HDFCBank,ICICIBank
mostly fall for the wrong stock.
Stating that the retail holding in
brothers in UK
India-based US cos seek DPIIT help
package such as the distribu- down the fiscal deficit, and andITCamongothers. penny stocks is three times more
tion of funds to micro, small start lowering your debt-GDP Data sourced from nsein- thanFPIs,Haldeasaid,“UnlikeFPIs
and medium enterprises un-
der the 100 per cent Emerge-
ratio. But to hang around and
hope that the economy bot- from China (and perhaps other will send a chilling signal to fore-
High Court over fobase.com shows that while SBI
added5.89lakhretailinvestorsin
who cut losses and exit from a
companythatisonadecline,retail
ncy Credit Line Guarantee
Scheme struggling to take off,
tomsoutbyitself,itmaywork
in the long term, but the in-
ENSECONOMICBUREAU
NEWDELHI,JUNE24
destinations)atmostmajorports
and airports in India. To the best
igninvestorswholookforpredic-
tabilityandtransparency,”itsaid.
letter dispute thequarter,HDFCBankadded3.78
lakhinvestors.RelianceIndustries
investorstendtoholditinthehope
thatsomedayitwillrise.Whenthe
therebyworseningtheimpact terimcostsintermsofemploy- of our knowledge, no formal or- Aghihassoughtrestorationof and Tata Motors added 3.13 lakh priceofastockstartsfalling,while
of government expenditure ment,people’slivelihoods,per- INDIA’S BORDER dispute with ders issued by the government port operations or, “at a mini- ADITIKHANNA and 2.53 lakh respectively. ONGC existing retail investors try to av-
compressionthatisunderway. haps even lives could be very Chinahasbecomeacauseforcon- havebeensharedwiththepublic, mum”,thatthegovernmentpub- LONDON,JUNE24 (2.13 lakh), ITC (2.11 lakh), ICICI erage out their holding, new in-
Alongsidetheredflagsover large.So,whatismoreimpor- cernforAmericanfirmsmanufac- neither has any specific reason lish any change in port policy “to Bank (1.96 lakh) too added signif- vestorsgetintotimethestockfor
growth,concernsbeingraised tant,debtsustainabilitywhich turinghere,whoarefeelinganim- been provided as to why these providethebusinesscommunity UK-BASED HINDUJA brothers are icantly.Besidesthese,YesBankand quick gains and more often they
over the likelihood of debt- is something which will hit pactonavailabilityofcomponents consignments are not being with the visibility they need to lockedinalegaldisputeintheHigh Vodafone Idea that witnessed a endupwithlosses.”
GDP ratio breaching the no- you much later in time or the usually shipped from their facili- cleared,”statedUS-IndiaStrategic function.” The Indian Express re- CourtinEnglandovertheirbillion- sharp fall in their share prices on Reliance Power and Reliance
tional red line of 80 per cent tragedy that’s playing out to- ties in the neighbouring country. PartnershipForum(USISPF)pres- ported on June 23 that import aire family assets, it emerged in a account of business concerns re- Communications are among the
fromthecurrentlevelofabout day,”hesaid. In a letter to Department for identandCEODrMukeshAghiin consignmentsfromChinaatports ruling in London. The case has lating to the company, also wit- top10companiesthathavehighest
70percentisnowbeingques- An aggressive fiscal policy Promotion of Industry and Inter- theletterdatedJune23.Thelackof suchasChennaiandMumbaiare beenbroughtbySrichandParma- nessed huge inflow of retail in- numberofretailinvestors.Reliance
tioned by economists, who is the need of the hour and nal Trade (DPIIT) secretary Guru- transparency in this process learnt to be facing hurdles, with nandHinduja,84,describedasthe vestors and the two companies Power is on top with over 30.61
pointtotheperilsofbeingsole sincetherevenueslippagees- prasadMohapatra,agrouprepre- “threatens” business continuity clearances being held up by the “patriarch” of the family, against added 3.78 lakh and 2.08 lakh re- lakhretailinvestorsandisfollowed
focussedonthedebtnumbers timatesarealreadyhigh,fiscal senting some of these firms said andis“disruptive”tomanufactur- Indian Customs authorities. brothersGPHinduja,80,PPHind- tailinvestors. byRILthathas25.41lakhretailin-
ratherthantheimmediatetask deficit is anyway going to get they were “increasingly concer- ingoperationshere,itfurtherread. Thedisruptioninclearancesis uja,75,andAPHinduja,69,andre- Retail holding in companies vestors. Market players say while
of rekindlingGDPgrowth. pushed to significantly higher ned” that component parts and “Whilst we support India’s reported to have emerged over volvesaroundthe“validityandef- listed on the NSE went up during retail investors entered the two
FormerChiefStatisticianof levels, said SBI’s Group Chief other inputs “necessary” to their ambition to expand its manufac- thelastfortnight,evenasthereare fect”of aletterdatedJuly2,2014. the quarter from 6.42 per cent in companieswhentheyweredoing
IndiaPronabSensaiddebtsus- Economic Adviser Soumya manufacturing operations here turing capability, we are con- no written or verbal instructions The letter includes December2019to6.55percentas fine, they failed to exit when the
tainability always remains a KantiGhosh.“Itisnottheright were being detained at the ports. cernedabouttherepercussionsan from the customs authorities or statements to the effect that the onMarch31,2020. tideturned,evenasotherinvestors
concern,butholdingdownthe timetohavediscussionsabout “Members report that DGFT unanticipated embargo on the theCBIC.Itisunderstoodthatthe brothers appoint each other as RIL, which added 4.2 lakh in- includingDIIsandFPIsexitedthem.
debtlevelsshouldnotcompro- the ideal debt-GDP ratio. Of and Customs authorities have importofgoodsfromneighbour- Customs authorities have hinted their executors, and that assets
miseonGDPgrowthforwhich courseitwilldeteriorate.Now abruptly halted the clearance of ingcountrieswillhaveonthesup- at delays without citing any spe- held in any single brother’s name
governmentexpenditureises- it’saround72percent,itcould industryconsignmentscomingin plychainandmanufacturing.This cific reason to importers. belongtoallfour. PTI
sential. “Holding the debt go beyond 80 per cent, a large
downinasituationwherethe part of that would be because
GDP is low, maybe continues
in the negative, doesn’t help
of GDP decline. We should
now instead think about
‘Passengers wanting to fly to
you. You can still become un-
sustainable.Soit’sacall.If Iin-
growthnumbers,”Ghoshsaid.
Ghoshaddedtherevivalof Dubai need specific clearance’
crease my debt stock, not the economy is 60-70 per cent of IndianNationalswhoareholding
ratio, then if the GDP starts the sub-optimal level that it ENSECONOMICBUREAU valid Residency Permit/Work
growing strongly, it will be- was already operating at be- NEWDELHI,JUNE24 Permit of United Arab Emirates
come sustainable. But the fore the pandemic. “There is and have procured approval of
whole issue of debt sustain- talk about V-shaped recovery. DAYS AFTER the Dubai adminis- the UAE’s Federal Authority for
abilityisalong-termprocess... Thiscouldbeastatisticalarte- tration allowed residency visa- Identity and Citizenship-UAE
Peoplearetalkingabout80per fact,ifthecountryexperiences holdersandtouriststoarriveinto (ICA) of United Arab Emirates or
cent.Thereisnosuchnumber. saya5percentcontractionthis the emirate, flag carrier Air India an approval from the General
The number really has to do year, next year the economy saidthattheUnitedArabEmirates Directorate of Residency and
whatthenominalGDPwould cangrow6-7percentbutthat (UAE) aviation regulator has not Foreigners Affairs applicable to
be doing over a long period of will only take it back to what allowed passengers to fly to the Dubaiwouldneedtohavespecific
time. If by holding down the would have been the 2020 country on repatriation flights. approvalfromtheEmbassyofthe
debt, the GDP growth gets level.Weexpecttheeconomy Those who wish to travel on United Arab Emirates in New
compromised, then you may to undergo a swoosh-shaped theseflights,AirIndiasaid,would Delhi and their UAE Ministry of
bemovinginthewrongdirec- recovery,”hesaid. needa specificapprovalfrom the Foreign Affairs and International
tionaltogether,”hesaid. India’s fiscal metrics have EmbassyofUAEinNewDelhiand Cooperation to travel from India OFFICE OF THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF ENGINEER
The government’s fiscal
stimulus in the wake of the
worsened sharply, the gov-
ernment’s expenditure re-
theUAEMinistryofForeignAffairs
and International Cooperation.
toUnitedArabEmirates(UAE)on
these repatriation flights,” an Air
Public Health Engineering Department
COVID-19pandemichasbeen straint notwithstanding, due “...allpassengersincludingthe India spokesperson said. Region Office Pratap Nagar, Dadabari, Kota (Rajasthan)
restrained with limited cash to the impact of the sharp Telephone No. 0744-2503651 Fax Number 0744-2501551
Email: rj_aceko@yahoo.com
outgo, a factor which econo- growth slowdown on rev-
mists said has been driven by
theconcernsofthedebtlevels,
enue, public-sector debt
numbersandthefiscaldeficit.
Emirates to fly A380 from NOTICE INVITING TENDER
UBN No. PHE 2021 WSOB 02584
possibility of exceeding fiscal
deficittargetbyahugemargin
Morethanthedeficit,though,
rating agencies are watching Dubai to London, Paris again 1. Online tenders are invited on behalf of the Governor of Rajasthan for
the following works from contractors registered/ enlisted in Class
“AA” or above with the PHED Rajasthan in appropriate Class as per
andtheconsequentactionsby thedeteriorationofIndia’sfis- NewDelhi:Withsignsofrisingair serve our customers on flights to
PWF&AR Part II Appendix 16 dated 01.07.1999 and amendment
rating agencies. However, the calmetricsin‘thecontextof a traffic demand on its network, LondonandParisfrom15July,and issued by concerned department up to date. Contractors enlisted with
economic costs of reining in prolongedordeepslowdown Dubai-basedairlineEmiratessaid we are looking forward to gradu- other Departments of Government of Rajasthan and enlisted with
debt are being seen as high in in growth’, which “would in- it will resume flying Airbus A380 allyintroduceourA380intomore CPWD/Postal, Telecom, Railway, MES, other State Govt./ Central
terms of unemployment and vite a ratings downgrade”, as superjumbo aircraft on routes destinations according to the Govt. undertaking organizations equivalent to appropriate Class of
lossof livesandlivelihood. Moody’swarnedintheirnote suchasDubai-LondonandDubai- travel demand on specific desti- Rajasthan shall also be eligible. The duly notarized copy of
Registration Certificate is to be enclosed. Unregistered contractors
Schemes that were part of on May 8. The IMF Paris, in addition to restarting nations,” Emirates COO Adel Al shall not be allowed. The tenderers meeting eligibility criteria may
the stimulus package are Wednesday projected a con- flights to Dhaka and Munich. Redhasaid.Themovecomesclose apply after giving prescribed Earnest Money. The tender documents
struggling to take off, with tractionof 4.5percentforthe “The A380 remains a popular on the heels of the Dubai admin- can be downloaded from the website http://www.eproc.rajasthan.
banksmanagingtodisbursea economy in 2020. aircraft amongst our customers istrationallowingresidencyvisa- gov.in and the interested bidders will have to submit their tender in
little over 7 per cent of the Full report on and it offers many unique on- holders to arrive into the emirate electronic format on this website with their digital signatures. Details
of this tender notification can also be seen in NIT exhibited on
amountearmarkedunderthis www.indianexpress.com board features. We are delighted June 22 onwards and tourists to website www.dipronline.org.
to bring it back into the skies to visit July 7 onwards. ENS
2. GENERAL DETAIL OF WORKS:
S.N. NIT No 02 / 2020-21
BRIEFLY Pandemic pushing digitisation of mobile 1 Work Description Operation & Maintenance of UWSS Baran
including intake well, WTP, Pump Houses,
OHSRs, Transmission/ Distribution Lines of
PAN-Aadhaar purchases, experiences: FB-BCG report 2 Estimated Cost
Baran Town for 03 years (Executed by RUIDP)
Rs 315.13 Lacs
New Delhi: The Centre ex- 3 Earnest Money Rs 6.30 Lacs (@2%) for the contractor not
tended deadline for linking high of 60 per cent before. Social enlisted in PHED. Rs 1.58 Lacs (@0.5%) for
AadhaarwithPANtillMarch NANDAGOPALRAJAN Thereportsaid thereisa distancingwillalsomakemoreof contractor in enlisted in PHED “AA” Class. To
31 next year. PTI NEWDELHI,JUNE24 them opt for online research be- be deposit in Budget head 8443-00-108-00-00
clear trendtowardsa through e-GRAS portal in favour of 5640-Ex.
fore a purchase, even as the “im- En P.H.E.D., Baran.
largerdigitisation of
YogaDayatNFL THE PANDEMIC lockdown in
Indiahasunlockednewconsum- purchasesand
portance of pricing as a choice
driver to go up” by around 25 per
4 Cost of Tender
Documents
Rs. 5,000.00 To be deposit in Revenue head
0075-00-800-52-01 through e-GRAS portal in
New Delhi: National Fertili- erbehavioursthatwillimpacton- cent in what is already a value favour of 5640-Ex.En. P.H.E.D., Baran.
zers Ltd (NFL) observed 6th line retail and be pivoted around
experiences conscious market. 5 RISL Charges Rs 1,000.00 To be deposit in Budget head
International Yoga Day. the smartphone, Facebook India Even among those looking to 8658-00-102-16-02 through e-GRAS portal in
favour of 5640-Ex.En. P.H.E.D., Baran.
and Boston Consulting Group’s increase spends in the segments,
PompeoonJio
6 O&M Period 36 Months
(BCG) industry report on Mobile comingmonths.However,thede- 59 per cent “may trade down in
7 Availability of tender From 22.06.2020 at 10:00 Hrs to 13.07.2020
Phones, FMCG, and Apparel has creased spending power promp- their choice of purchase/look for
documents on web site (up to 18:00 Hrs)
New Delhi: US Secretary of shown. In the mobile segment, ted to 29 per cent to say they will offers and deals”.
8 Date & time for online From 22.06.2020 at 10:00 Hrs to 13.07.2020
StateMikePompeo,onTwi- there is a clear trend towards cutspendsonphonesandmaybe “Mobile as a category has had submission of tender (up to 18:00 Hrs)
tter,calledIndiantelcoRelia- larger digitisation of purchases opt for a cheaper variant. as high online affinity and 38 per 9 Date & time of opening 14.07.2020 at 14:00 Hrs
nce Jio a “clean telco” for re- andexperiences,thestudyfound. The study also found that as cent of mobile phones are being of pre- qualification bid.
jecting Chinese vendors to With the mobile phone be- consumers were triggered to re- purchased online. This will go up
Sd/-
deploy 5G, adding that coming more essential in daily place their existing phones, at further as this thing plays out,” “SAVE WATER – SAVE LIFE” ( K. D. Gupta )
world’s leading telcos were livesofconsumers,38percentre- least “70 per cent of urban con- VikashJain,wholeadsBCG’sTech- Additional Chief Engineer
becoming “Clean”. ENS spondents suggested they will sumersformobilesexpectedtobe nology,Media&Telecompractice DIPR/C/4604/2020 PHED, Region, Kota
spendmoreonthecategoryinthe digitally influenced”, up from a in India, told indianexpress.com.
New Delhi
WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM
18 SPORT
THE INDIAN EXPRESS, THURSDAY, JUNE 25, 2020 @indianexpress.com
THOSEMONTHS,THOSEMINUTES
Forced into an unprecedented lockdown, sport is staring at an
unfathomable despair. Indian athletes, though, have given the
country reasons to rejoice in the past.
JWALA GUTTA and ASHWINI PONNAPPA tell Shivani Naik how they
made badminton doubles history for India
Recognition for
NSFs on hold How Bergamo is picking up the pieces Noplantoreduce
BRIEFLY
spending: Rijiju
after HC raps As football returns to Italian city worst hit by pandemic, a citizens’ group is helping people share grief New Delhi: Sports minister Kiren Rijiju
sports ministry
assuredthenationalsportsfederations
anaccountantandwashealthyenoughtodrive onWednesdaythat‘thereisnoplanto
NIHAL KOSHIE twice a week to the firm he had set up and reduce spends on any of the verticals’.
NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 passedontohissonLuca,Fusco’sfather.Antonio Rijiju’scomment,madeonhisTwitter
PRITAM PAL SINGH was admitted at a hospital following a stroke handle, came a day after The Indian
NEW DELHI, JUNE 24 WHEN BERGAMO-BASED Atalanta played when he was infected by the virus. His body Express reported about the minister’s
their home game against Sassuolo behind was taken in a car of a funeral home and cre- meeting with federation chiefs where
THEPROVISIONAL recognitiongrantedto 54 closed doors on Sunday evening, it marked a matedawayfromBergamobecauseofshortage the issue of salary cuts of foreign
National Sports Federations (NSFs) will be winning return for the football club from the of space.HisashesarekeptatLuca’shome. coaches came up for discussion.
‘recalled’ after the Delhi High Court, on epicentre of Covid-19 in Italy’s Lombardy re- “We created a virtual community where A seniorfederationrepresentative
Wednesday, expressed its displeasure over gion. Stefano Fusco, the founder of citizens’ all of our family and friends and relatives present at the meeting had told this
the manner in which the sports ministry group Noi Denunceremo, which translates to could join and share stories about grandpa. paper that the idea was put on hold
went about the process. ‘We will report’, for bereaved relatives, did- Other people joined too and it was like a vir- after the federation representatives
A bench comprising Justice Hima Kohli n’t turn on the television to watch the team’s tual meeting room where everybody was raised fears that a pay cut might re-
and Justice Najmi Waziri confronted the first game in nearly four months. free to share pain and tell the story.” sult in a mass exodus of coaches. A
sports ministry’s counsel with its February The 31-year-old went to his best friend’s NoiDenunceremo’scoreteamconsistsof12 Sports Ministry official, present at the
7 order, in which it had directed the Indian house to catch up over dinner. He admits not members, nine of whom are lawyers from meeting, too had confirmed this.
OlympicFederation(IOA)aswellasthemin- being an Atalanta loyalist and roots for Inter acrossItaly,includingTurin,Naples,Romeand Reacting to the report, Rijiju
istry to not take a decision in relation to the Milan.Fuscodidn’ttuneintoseehisfavourite Florence.Complaintsandpetitionsarefirstfiled tweeted:“Thenewsisincorrect.There
federations without informing the court. club beat Sampdoria either. (L-R) Players observe a minute’s silence before Atalanta’s first Serie A match in onlinebeforepeopledetailexperiencesaround is no plan to reduce spends on any of
Observing that ‘in teethof the order dated Every second family in Bergamo, which Bergamo, the epicentre of the pandemic in Italy, after the lockdown was eased; the death of a family member, in order to give the verticals. All future decisions will
February 7, 2020, MYAS (Ministry of Youth registerednearly3,000deaths,haslostsome- Stefano Fusco with his late grandfather Antonio in happier times. AP/Stefano Fusco officialsasmuchinformationaspossible. be made keeping the best interests of
AffairsandSport)hasonitsownproceededto one to the pandemic. Fusco prioritising time The objective of the citizens’ group is not all stakeholders in mind & in discus-
provisionallyrenewtheannualrecognitionin with a close friend over watching a football to point fingers at doctors or hospitals, but sion with NSFs. I conveyed to NSFs in
respectof54federations’,thebenchaskedthe game was understandable. “I hadn’t met my theprosecutor’sofficeinBergamoandanother notbeallowedrightaway.Ifhehadhissay,the ask authorities to investigate what led to the yesterday's VC.” ENS
sports ministry to ‘issue a fresh notice within friend for months, so it was good to have got 220 in different parts of Italy. Top lawyers are Serie A would have restarted only next year. pandemic spiralling out of hand. The next
twodaysintimatingall54NSFsconcernedthat
its order giving provisional renewal till
some time with him,” Fusco says. Of course,
heknowsInterwon2-1.Footballisn’taprior-
working pro bono for members of the
Facebook group and prosecutors have ques-
“There were 30,000 or more people from
Bergamoatthestadiumthatnight,”hesaysre-
dateforhearingpetitionersislikelytobeJuly
6andoverathousandtestimonieshavebeen MohdHafeeztests
September 30, 2020, stands recalled.’
Theannualrecognitionfromtheministry
ity for this sales consultant involved in help-
ingpeoplegetlegalhelptopetitionofficialsto
tioned the country’s prime minister.
The pandemic curve has dipped in
ferringbackto‘GameZero’.“Wewerealready
in a pandemic emergency situation since
compiled. Fusco explains why many people
believe authorities didn’t react fast enough.
negativeforCovid-19
is of high importance for the federations, es- highlight government negligence. Bergamo, yet Fusco believes it is too early for January 31. I don’t support Atalanta so I didn’t “The first case in Bergamo was on Karachi: Former Pakistan captain
pecially the smaller ones, as they largely de- The spread of the virus in Bergamo is football to return even behind closed doors. gotothestadiumbutafriendwhowentthere February 23 but the town was locked down Mohammed Hafeez has tested nega-
pendonthegovernmentforfundingtoman- linked to an Atalanta game. “Well, I disagree with restarting the knewtwoguyswhodiedbecauseofCovid19,” only on March 8. That is two weeks later,” tive for COVID-19, a day after the PCB
age their everyday expenses. Citing the Fans returningafter a Champions League championships.FootballinItalyisnotasport, Fusco says. Haunting memories are too fresh Fusco says. The nearby town of Codogno in found him positive for the deadly
coronavirus outbreak and the consequent match against Valencia at the San Siro in it is a mix between drugs and a religion. for people in Bergamo to move on without a Lodi province was quick to act and a lock- virus ahead of the team's much-an-
lockdown as the reason, the sports ministry Milan on February 19 are believed to have People get very emotional when they speak shudder when thinking about the horrors of down was imposed on the same day the first ticipated tour of England. Hafeez and
had renewed the recognition of 54 federa- been carriers. A third of the town of 1.2 lakh about football. I am afraid people who the past few months. Fusco, who lives in the case was detected on February 21. “There is Wahab Riaz were among the 10
tions till September 30. The court's direction residents were reported to have gone to the weren’t touched by the virus can forget very countryside,narratesastoryaboutambulance a lot of anger around in Bergamo and also in Pakistan players, who tested positive
was based on an application filed by the game where there was no social distancing. quickly what happened here. The club is sirenswhenthepandemicwasatitspeakand Italy, and the public opinion is that our au- for COVID-19 on Tuesday. The team is
sports ministry, seeking certain directions. Four days later, the first positive case was re- playing really well this year. People will start coffins were being stored in churches around thorities and our government didn’t do too duetoleaveforEnglandonSundayfor
The application was moved in a pending PIL ported in Bergamo. It took a fortnight for the hugging, partying together, drinking beer Bergamo because the only cemetery was full. much to contain the virus, especially in a Test and T20 series in August. On
by sports activist and lawyer Rahul Mehra, lockdown to be enforced in the town. from the same bottle. I am Italian but I don’t places like Bergamo. For two weeks, people Wednesday, Hafeez took to twitter
who sought proper regulation and controlin Over13,500peopletestedpositiveandthe trust Italians. I know it would be a very big Counting sirens werefreetomovearoundwithoutsocialdis- and clarified that he and his family
the functioning of numerous federations. match is now called ‘Game Zero’. Health ex- danger for all of us,” Fusco tells The Indian “I am still finding a way to describe it. It tancing and without masks and that is prob- members have tested negative and
Central government’s standing counsel pertshave referred to it asa ‘biological bomb’. Express,worrying about the possibility of so- was like being in the middle of the war and ablythecauseof thepandemicwehadhere.” alsopostedthemedicalreporttoback
Anil Soni, appearing for the sports ministry, Shortly after his grandfather Antonio tested cial distancing going out of the window at your enemy is bombing you and you don’t Italy has seen a steady decline in cases his claim. The Pakistan Cricket Board
conceded before the court that the said or- positive for the coronavirus and died within bars and restaurants which are now open. knowwherethenextbombwillfall.Inanor- and the number of deaths has fallen to two saiditwasverydisappointedwiththe
derhasnotbeencompliedwith. The counsel two days of developing a fever and cough in Sunday’s win is being projected as a suc- mal situation, I hear the ambulance once in digits daily signalling a turnaround in the seniorplayer."IspoketoHafeeztoday
submitted that the ministry may be permit- mid-March,FuscoandhisfamilylaunchedNoi courtohelppeopleinBergamoovercomethe three days and during the peak of the pan- battle against Covid-19. In Bergamo, life is and I made it clear to him our disap-
ted to withdraw the decision taken along Denunceremo. His father, sister, mother and pain caused by the pandemic. Atalanta coach demic, I counted up to 128 ambulances in getting back to normal with shops opening pointmentat the way he hadhandled
with the present application. Allowing the aunt were the first members. People started Gian Piero Gasperini, who had himself tested one day, and every time you went out, for and people heading back to work and so is this entire affair," PCB CEO Khan told
same, the bench recorded in its order that it joiningindroves,withinadaythecommunity positive for coronavirus, spoke about football’s food for example, you discovered somebody Fusco.“Basicallylifehasrestarted,butpeople the Cricket Baaz YouTube channel on
is refraining from imposing any costs on the grew to 5,000 and currently there are 60,000. abilitytogivejoytothepeople.Entryof specta- you knew was dead or in hospital,” he says. here are still scared because lots of people Wednesday. PTI
MYAS for the present. Earlierthismonth,50peoplefiledpetitionsat torsattheGewissStadium,Fuscofeels,should HisoctogenariangrandfatherAntoniowas have lost family members.”
New Delhi