Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5 - Semiannual Report April 2019 W Migration Accords
5 - Semiannual Report April 2019 W Migration Accords
Decontrolled 201913994
United States Department of State
•
~~ '
/
.,.,
' Washington, D.C 20520
'
SUBJECT: (SBU) Transmittal to Congress of the April 2019 Report on Cuban Compliance
with the Migration Accords
BLUF: (SBU) This semi-annual report to Congress details Cuba's compliance with the
Migration Accords, as well as U.S.-Cuba migration statistics. The U.S. will not
be able to meet its commitment of issuing 20,000 travel documents this fiscal
year.
Recommendation
(SBC) That you approve the semi-annual report on Cuban Compliance with the Migration
Accords and its transmittal to Congress. (Approve/Disapprove by 4/25/19)
Background
(SBU) The Secretary of State is required by Section 2245 of the Foreign Relations Authorization
Act for Fiscal Years 1998 and 1999 (Div. G, Subdiv. B, P. L.105-277) to submit a report to
Congress every six months concerning the methods employed by the Government of Cuba to
enforce the 1994 Joint Communique and the treatment of persons who have returned to Cuba
under the 1995 Joint Statement. Together with the 2017 Joint Statement, these three binding
bilateral agreements constitute the Migration Accords between the United States and Cuba. The
Migration Accords detail the two countries' common interest in preventing irregular migration
and outline the commitments to safe, legal, and orderly migration. This is a semiannual
submission; the previous report was submitted to Congress October 4, 2018. The report is due to
Congress no later than April 19.
(U) The report functions as the authoritative source for U.S.-Cuban migration statistics, which
informs interagency decision-makers. This report notes that, due to the reduction in staff at
U.S. Embassy Havana, the Deparnnent of State will not be able to issue 20,000 travel documents
in FY 2019 for immigration to the United States from Cuba consistent with the commitment in
the Migration Accords ''that total legal migration to the United States from Cuba will be a
minimum of20,000 Cubans each year." The report also notes the Cuban government accepted
returns of a limited number of Cubans with final orders of removal, an Administration priority,
and highlights some of the ongoing challenges in our dealings.with Cuba.
(U) The report does not nonnally attract attention; there is, however, renewed public interest in
migration from Cuba given the reduction in consular staffing at our embassy in Havana as a
result of the attacks on embassy staff. The report could be of interest to members of Congress
who follow Cuba policy, speci.fically Senator Marco Rubio (R-FL), Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX),
Senator Robert Menendez (D-N'J), Representative Eliot Engel (D-NY), Representative Mario
Diaz-Balart (R-FL), Representative Alex Mooney {R-WV), and Representative Albia Sires
(D-NJ).
(U) The repon has no direct effect on U.S. government funding levels. You have authority to
approve this report pursuant to the Department's Delegation of Authority 280-2.
Attachments:
Tab 1 -Repon to Congress
Tab 2 -Transmittal Letters
Tab 3 - Relevant Legislation
Tab 4 - Migration Accords
H/FO:
Harris (ok)
Donnelly ( ok)
Moore (ok)
Report to Congress on
Cuban Compliance with the Migration Accords
(October 2018 to April 2019)
This is the semiannual report ori Cuban migration policies required by section 2245 of the
Foreign Relations Authorization Act, Fiscal Years 1998 and 1999 (Div. G, Subdiv. B, P.L. I 05-
277). As outlined in the Joint Communique signed by the United States and Cuba on
September 9, 1994, the Joint Statement of May 2, 1995, and the Joint Statement of January 12,
2017 (collectively known as the "Migration Accords"), the U.S. government is committed to the
safe, legal, and orderly migration of Cuban citizens to the United States. The 1994 Joint
Communique states, "the United States ensures that total legal migration to the United States
from Cuba will be a minimum of20,000 Cubans each year, not including immediate relatives of
United States citizens." This commitment was reaffirmed in the 2017 Joint Statement.
In the wake of health attacks on Embassy Havana employees, the Department of State ordered
the departure of nonemergency U.S. government employees and their family members, and
continues to operate at reduced staffing levels. In light of this significant drawdown in
U.S. government personnel, almost all visa processing in Havana has been suspended.
Exceptions are being made for medical emergencies. The Department designated Embassy
Georgetown to handle immigrant visa processing for Cubans from Cuba, although at a much
reduced capacity. As a result, fewer than 20,000 Cubans applied for travel documents under the
Migration Accords for FY 2019. As of January 31, 2019, Embassy Georgetown has issued
1,508 travel documents in the categories specified under the Migration Accords in FY 2019.
I. MIGRATION METHODS
From October I, 2018, to January 31, 2019, the U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP)
Office of Field Operations reported 5,018 Cuban nationals that were deemed inadmissible at the
ports of entry (POEs) along the southwest border. Please see Table l below for additional details
and a comparison with FY 2018 figures.
Table l: Enforcement f:ncounters of Cuban Aliens by U.S. Customs and Border Protection
UNCJ,ASSTFIED
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 5
UXCLASSIFIED
-2-
No documents have been issued in FY 2019 under the Cuban Family Reunification Parole
(CFRP).
Consistent with general requirements for parole requests filed on behalf of individuals outside
the United States, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) requires new CFRP
program petitioners to file Form I-131 and pay the associated fee or file a fee waiver request for
each beneficiary in Cuba. As of February 13, 2019, USCIS had approved and forwarded
20,408 applications to the National Visa Center. Due to the drawdown in staffing at
U.S. Embassy Havana, CFRP processing in Havana was temporarily suspended on
September 29, 2017. The Department of State and USCIS are working together to ensure
continued operation of the CFRP Program. Consistent with the executive order on
Border Security and Immigration Enforcement, the CFRP Program, like other parole programs,
is under Department of Homeland Security review.
The U.S. Coast Guard (USCG) continues ta repatriate Cuban migrants interdicted at sea per the
1995 Joint Statement. On June 8, 2018, USCG and the Secretary of Homeland Security signed
an action memo ending the previous policy of affirmative screening of Cuban migrants subject to
direct repatriation to Cuba. The changes went into effect immediately. USCIS continues to
provide credible fear screening to all USCG interdicted Cuban migrants who manifest fear of
return.
Maritime migration attempts by Cuban nationals have significantly decreac;ed since the end of
the so-called "wet foot, dry foot" policy on January 12, 2017. The primary methods of maritime
migration continue to be rustic vessels. As of February 8, 2019, USCG's estimated FY 2019
Cuban maritime flow is J 38 migrants. Please see Table 2 below for additional details and a
comparison with FY 2017 and FY 2018 figures.
USCG and the Cuban Border Guard (TGF) routinely cooperate in all aspects of Cuban maritime
migration. Their interactions are integral to ensuring the Migration Accords' goals of safe, legal,
UNCLASSIFIED
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 6
UNCLASSIFIED
-3-
and orderly migration. "Active target hand-off' operations, in which the TGF pursues a vessel
until it leaves Cuba's territorial waters and then allows USCG to interdict the vessel, are
common, though the frequency of these hand-offs has decreased since the January 2017 Accords
went into effect. Since January 23, 2018, USCG participated in the eighth professional exchange
with the TGF, covering a wide variety of topics including strengthening existing search and
rescue, Jaw enforcement and migration procedures, advancing tactical cooperation, and
procedures for mass rescue operations. Additional professional exchanges between TGF and
USCG were scheduled in 2018; however, due to Cuban desires to hold the talks in Havana and
ongoing security concerns in-country, none occurred. There is a one-day cruise ship industry-led
Mass Rescue Operation/Search and Rescue exercise scheduled in Havana for March I 9, 2019.
No other professional exchanges events are currently scheduled.
Cuba's efforts to prevent alien smuggling include land patrols of its coastal zones and substantial
criminal penalties for offenders. Although the January 2017 repeal of the wet-foot/dry-foot
policy resulted in a dramatic decrease in migration, the TGF continues to prevent illegal
departures by raft/rustic vessel. The TGF reported nine cases of migrant departures by sea from
October 1, 2018, to February 13, 2019.
Cuban citizens no longer need an exit permit to leave the country. Medical personnel have
reported challenges receiving permission to take leave for travel. The Department of State and
Embassy Havana have also received credible reports of dissidents being denied permission to
leave.
Cuban passports cost $100 and are expensive by local standards, as the average monthly income
is approxi!Tlately $25.
Due to the drawdown of staffing, Embassy Havana is not currently accepting new applications or
processing refugee cases. Thus far in FY 2019, no Cubans were admitted to the United States as
refugees and USCIS did not conduct refugee interviews.
Although Cuba has historically demonstrated an unwillingness to accept the return of its
nationals ordered removed from the United States, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)
envisioned that the United States and Cuba's bilateral signing of the Joint Statement in January
2017 would establish a mutually agreeable, repeatable process for removing Cuban nationals
U-:-.;CLASSIFIED
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED"
...
UNCLASSIFTED
Despite the Government of Cuba's recalcitrance, the U.S. government strives to repatriate
individuals named on a list of2,746 Cuban nationals who departed Cuba from the Port of Mariel
in 1980 and were declared ineligible to enter the United States legally. As of February 13, 2019,
two Cuban nationals from the list have been repatriated in FY 2019, and one as recently as
February 22, 2019. Since 1984, ICE has removed 2,036 nationals from the list, and
254 individuals on the list are deceased. Per the 2017 Joint Statement, Cuba agreed that
individuals on this list who have not been repatriated may be replaced by other removable Cuban
nationals who departed Cuba for the United States in 1980 via the Port of Mariel and were found
by competent United States authorities to have tried to irregularly enter or remain in the
United States in violation of U.S. law. As of February 13, 2019, Cuba has denied 744 cases
under this 2017 Joint Statement category and 228 are still pending a decision. ICE has
removed 177.
Although ICE has repeatedly tried to elicit increased Cuban government cooperation through
high-level engagement, Cuba continues to deny replacement cases without rationale - and the
Joint Statement's established case-by-case category has not proven useful. From April 10, 2017,
to February 13, 2019, the Department of State, on behalf ofICE, submitted a total of
2,800 case-by-case category nominations for the Government of Cuba's consideration- of these,
the Cuban government approved only 10 for removal on December 6, 2017, and an additional
eight on November 29, 2018.
Cuba's refusal to accept for removal the majority oflCE's case nominations forced ICE to
release 423 Cubans with final orders of removal into U.S. communities in FY 2018, and 25 in the
first month of FY 2019. The issue's scope continues to widen with approximately 38,000 Cubans
with final orders of removal residing in the United States awaiting removal and an additional
51,533 in the immigration enforcement pipeline.
Due to the drawdown in staffing, the embassy has not conducted monitoring trips in FY 2019.
The Cuban government does not overtly control Cubans' access to the Consular Section. In the
wake of health attacks on Embassy Havana employees, the Department of State ordered the
departure of non-emergency U.S. government employees and their family members and has
continued to operate at reduced staffing levels.
UNCLASSIFIED
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Pages
lliCLASSIFIED
-5-
This significant drawdown in C .S. government personnel has affected embassy operations,
forcing the embassy to suspend processing of all parole, refugee, and immigrant visa cases in
Havana. Embassy Georgetown has been designated as the default visa processing post for
Cuban immigrant visa applications. The U.S. government has not yet identified the source of the
injuries affecting U.S. diplomats in Havana, but the Government of Cuba is responsible for
taking all appropriate steps to prevent attacks on diplomatic personnel in Cuba. The Department
continues to prioritize all efforts to support democracy and human rights in Cuba.
L'NCLASSJF!ED
FL-2021 -00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 5/ 19/2021 Page 9
UNCLASSIFIED
-6-
Drafted: WHA/CCA~.__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
(b_)(6_
) _ _ _ _ _ _ _----1
Cleared:
WHAIFO: Julie Chung (ok)
WHA/FO: RUlrich (ok)
~b)(5); (b)(6)
~CLASSIFIED
FL-2021-00004
. ......
A-OOQJW,il,J,ll4,J!l "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 10
,,_,. ~-""~'
, ,.,~,~
9
GI'"
•N<1l~. Thii i• • typ .. ot print of th~ o~nal h4nd tDrollml!Jll o.! o,f>1ad by tho Pre,id•nl on
October 21, l99S.. Th~ t<:>:t •• pr,n!M with~ul eorromon ...
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED"
1' ,,,·~\·Y/
/\
. -\
\ .
·\' .
'
Ff:.ESS 51P..'i:El-.Et,1 (t:.l·•OAF.GGEC U!-:'lE. 4:00 ;.i, l:!/14/8!)
,C':,
'® •
@ -
.
"UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 15
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418
came to the United States in 1980 via the port of Maciel and
returned in· any calendar mont·h. The United States stated that
measures Yere being taken so that the Cuban nationals who came
,,
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED"
time.
agi::-eements.
~
~
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 17
@-.
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED"
charges, the time the person was held in detention, a~d the
0 •
,.
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED"
these steps.
..
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 21
STATEMENT
',
~
\C'
•
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 23
1994 Communique
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED"
Joint Communique
JOINT STATEMENT
• The United States of America and the Republic of Cuba have reached agreement on steps to
nonnalize further their migration relationship. These steps build upon the September 9, 1994
agreement and seek to address safety and humanitarian concerns and to ensure that migration
between the countries is safe, legal, and orderly.
Humanitarian Parole
The United States and the Republic of Cuba recognize the special·circumstances of the Cuban
migrants currently at Guantanamo Bay. Accordingly, the two governments have agreed that the
process of humanitarian parole into the United States should continue beyond those eligible for
parole under existing criteria. The two governments agree that if the United States carries out
such paroles, it may count them towards meeting the minimum number of Cuban it is committed
to admit every year pursuant to the September 9, 1994 agreement. Up to 5,000 such paroles may
be counted towards meeting the minimum num bcr in any one year period beginning September
9, 1995, regardless of when the migrants arc paroled into the United States.
The United States and the Republic of Cuba reaffirm their common interest in preventing unsafe
departures from Cuba. Effective immediately, Cuban migrants intercepted at sea by the United
States and attempting to enter the Cnitcd States will be taken to Cuba. Similarly, migrant found
to have entered Guantanamo illegally wil! also be returned to Cuba. The United States and the
Republic of Cuba will cooperate jointly in this effort. All actions taken will be consistent with
the parties' international obligations. Migrants taken to Cuba will be informed by United States
officials about procedures to apply for legal admission to the United States at the U.S. Interest
Section in Havana.
The United States and the Republic of Cuba will ensure that no action is taken against those
migrants returned to Cuba as a consequence of their attempt to immigrate illegally. Both parties
will work together to facilitate the procedures necessary to implement these measures. The
Cnited States and the Republic of Cuba agree to the return to Cuba of Cuban nationals currently
at Guantanamo who are ineligible for admission to the Cnited States.
The United States and the Republic of Cuba agrees that the provisions of the September 9, 1994
agreement remain in effect, except as modified by the present Joint Statement. In particular,
both sides reaffinn their joint commitment to take steps to prevent unsafe departures from Cuba,
which risk loss of human life and to oppose acts of violence associated with illegal immigration.
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED"
JOINT STATEMElfT
AWARE of the necessity to facilitate regular migration to the benefit of both countries,
and to discourage irregular migration;
The United States of America and the Republic of Cuba have agreed to take a major step
toward the nonnalization of their migration relations, in order to ensure a regular, safe
and orderly migration. The Joint Communiques dated December 14, 1984 and
September 9, 1994 and the Joint Statement of May 2, 1995 remain in effect except as
modified by this Joint Statement (collectively known as 'Migration Accords'). This Joint
Statement is not intended to modify the Migration Accords with respect to the return of
Cuban nationals intercepted at sea by the United States or the return of migrants found to
have entered the Guantanamo ~aval Base illegally.
In this framework, the United States of America shall henceforth end the special parole
policy for Cuban nationals who reach the territory of the United States (commonly
referred to as the wet foot-dry foot policy), as well as the parole program for Cuban
health care professionals in third countries. The United States shall henceforth apply to
all Cuban nationals, consistent with its Jaws and international norms, the same migration
procedures and standards that are applicable to nationals of other countries, as establishe~
in this Joint Statement.
l. From the date of this Joint Statement, the United States of America, consistent
with its laws and international nonns, shall return to the Republic of Cuba, and
the Republic of Cuba, consistent with its laws and international norms, shall
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED"
receive back all Cuban nationals who after the signing of this Joint Statement are
found by the competent authorities of the United States to have tried to irregularly
enter or remain in that country in violation of United States law.
The United States of America and the Republic of Cuba state their intention to
promote changes in their respective migration laws to enable fully normalized
migration relations to occur between the two countries.
2. The United States of America and the Republic of Cuba shall apply their
migration and asylum laws to nationals of the other Party avoiding selective (in
other words, discriminatory) criteria and consistent with their international
obligations.
3. The United States of America shall continue ensuring legal migration from the
Republic of Cuba with a minimum of20,000 persons annually.
4. The United States of America and the Republic of Cuba, detennined to strongly
discourage unlawful actions related to irregular migration, shall promote effective
bilateral cooperation to prevent and prosecute alien smuggling and other crimes
related to migration movements that threaten their national security, including the
hijacking of aircraft and vessels.
5. The Republic of Cuba shall accept that individuals included in the list of2,746 to
be returned in accordance with the Joint Communique of December 14, I 984,
may be replaced by others and returned to Cuba, provided that they are Cuban
nationals who departed for the United States of America via the Port of Mariel in
1980 and were found by the competent authorities of the United States to have
tried to irregularly enter or remain in that country in violation of United States
law. The Parties shall agree on the specific list of these individuals and the
procedure for their return.
6. The Republic of Cuba shall consider and decide on a case-by-case basis the return
of other Cuban nationals presently in the United States of America who before the
signing of this Joint Statement had been found by the competent authorities of the
United States to have tried to irregularly enter or remain in that country in
violation of United States law. The competent authorities of the United States
shall focus on individuals whom the competent authorities have determined to be
priorities for return.
As from the date of signing of this Joint Statement, the Parties shall carry out the
necessary procedures for its implementation. The Parties may meet and revise such
procedures from time to time to ensure effective implementation.
2
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED"
The competent authorities of the United State.s of America and the Republic of Cuba shall
meet on a regular basis to ensure that cooperation under these Migration Accords is
carried out in confonnity with their respective laws and international obligations.
Signed on the 12th day of January, 2017, in Havana, Cuba, in the English and Spanish
languages, both texts being equally authentic.
J
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 32
IMPLEMENTATION GUIDELINES
OF THE JOINT STATEMENT
In order to implement the Joint Statement signed on January 12, 2017, and with a view
to ensuring regular, safe and orderly migration, including the return of all Cuban
nationals who are found to have tried to enter o.r remain in the United States, in violation
of U.S. law, the United States of America and the Republic of Cuba will henceforth
follow the implementation procedures set forth in these Guidelines.
I. COMPETENT AUTHORITIES
b. For the United States of America the competent authorities under these
Guidelines are U.S. Inunigrarion and Customs Enforcement, U.S. Customs
and Border Protection, and the U.S. Coast Guard.
The operational procedures ju effect from May 8, 1995, concerning the return of all
Cuban irregular migrants. intercepted at sea attempting to reach United States territory
will remain in effect with no changes.
a Principles
c. Determination of eligibility
The full name and date of birth associated with each unique identifying
nwnber will be stored electronically in an encrypted. fonnat not
susceptible to alteration. At the time the U.S. competent authorities seek
FL-2021-00004 A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 35
At the time the U.S. competent authorities seek to return such Cuban
nationals. the U.S. authorities will communicate to the Cuban authorities,
on the basis of U.S. files, official information of the criminal history of
the individual, including a description of the crime or crimes for which
the individual was convicted, the date or dates of conviction, and the
sentence or sentences imposed. Toe U.S. authorities will also
comnnm:icate available health information, including information related
to any significant medical condition or treatment
ii. The competent authorities of the United States and Cuba will work
together in good faith to reasonably determine, within thirty (30) days,
the date on which the Cuban national departed from Cuba. The
competent authorities w:ill collaborate closely during this process,
including by exchanging probative evidence on a timely basis,
reasonably evaluating all evidence exchanged, and Tegu1arly
communicating to resolve any discrepancies and improve process
efficiency.
have not been returned to Cuba by the U.S. authorities. To that end, they
will offer accurate infonnation regarding the names to be replaced on
said list. The proposals will give a priority to those interested in
returning to Cuba or with family in Cuba.
b. The return of the individuals accepted by Cuba will take place according
to the procedures established in the Implementation Guidelines of the
Communique dated December 14, 1984.
In order to strongly discourage unlawful actions related to irregular migration, U.S. and
Cuban competent authorities will regularly exchange information on the following
aspects:
©tr.CR?!' -
A-00000318418 "UNCLASSIFIED" 511912021 Page 37
are not otherwise eligible for return under the provisions of this Section.
The competent authorities of the United States will focus on individuals
whom such competent authorities have detennined to be priorities for
return.
b. Procedures
i. No later than ten (IO) days after the competent authorities of the
United States of America determine that a national of the Republic of
Cuba is not eligible to enter or remain in the United States under U.S.
law, the U.S. competent authorities Vvi.11 inform the Cuban competent
authorities of their intention to return the Cuban national to Cuba, and
will provide the Cuban authorities with the following identifying
information:
The competent authorities of the United States will also provide the date
on which the Cuban national was placed in civil or criminal proceedings
in the UTUted States that ultimately led to the determination that the
Cuban national is ineligible to remain in the United States.
Information will also be provided about the nature of any criminal.
proceedings and criminal sentence served, as well as information related
to any significant medical conditions or treatment.
In case the infmmation provided by the U.S. authorities js found
insufficient to establish the identity of the person, the Cuban authorities
will request additional data.
ii. The competent authorities of the United States will provide the
info1TI1ation described in subsection (i) to the Cuban competent
authorities on a "Record of Persons Transferred" manifest of the Cuban
nationals to be returned. The Cuban competent authorities will respond
as soon as possible but no later than seven (7) days following receipt of
this manifest, whether they are prepared to accept the return of said
Cuban nationals.
vi. Results of the criminal processes of individuals taken to trial for their
involvement in alien smuggling activities between the two countries.
6. CONCLUDING SECTIONS
b. The United States and Cuban competent authorities may meet to revise
these Guidelines when necessary.