Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mathematical Modelof Freeze Dryingon Mango
Mathematical Modelof Freeze Dryingon Mango
net/publication/317090318
CITATIONS READS
0 842
4 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Sakawduan Kaewdam on 24 May 2017.
Abstract
The mathematical model of freeze-drying on mango was examined. The mango cultivar ‘Nam
Dok Mai’ was frozen at -40oC and freeze-dried at -40oC for 6 hours then at -20oC 10 hours and then at
-10oC 6 hours, The temperature and time of secondary drying were 10, 20, 30 oC and 2, 4, 6, 8 hours
respectively, The pressure during the drying process were 20, 30, 40 and 80 Pa. It was shown that the
optimal conditions were in the secondary drying stage with at 10oC for 6 hours and 20 Pa. After drying,
the quality of mangoes was determined. The hardness was 6.1834 N and the water activity was 0.276.
The colors L* a* and b* value were 79.86, 4.29 and 53.62 respectively. The final moisture content of the
product was 6.8% and the specific energy consumption was 253.07 kWh/kg. The average drying rate was
0.294 gH2O/g dry mass-h and the effective moisture diffusivity coefficient from linear equation method ranged
from 5.54 u 10-11to 2.90 u 10-10 m2/s. Thin-layer drying models of Newton, Page , Modified Page and
Henderson and Pabis were evaluated based on coefficient of determination (R2), reduced chi-square ( F 2 )
and Root Means Square Error (RMSE). The Modified Page model was found to be the better model, with
coefficient of determination of 0.998, reduced chi-square value of 0.00026 and RMSE at 0.016215.
56
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67
is used to preserve food. Most of the initial raw Materials and Methods
material properties such as shape, appearance,
taste, color, flavor, texture, biological activity etc Preparation:
were preserved. Freeze-dried fruits are used in Fresh ripe mangoes (cultivar ‘Nam Dok
some breakfast cereal or sold as snack. They are Mai’) were selected for their homogeneity in size,
popular snacks of choice among toddlers, weight, peel color, and density by floatation in 4–
preschoolers and dieters, as well as being used 5% NaCl solution. The total soluble solid content
by some pet owners as a treat for pet birds. of mangoes was determined to be in the range of
Culinary herbs are also freeze-dried, although air- 16–20°Brix (Nathdanai et al., 2011).The mangoes
dried herbs are far more common and less were peeled, cut into 3 cm x 3 cm x 1 cm by mold
expensive. Freeze drying is an alternative for food and frozen at -40oC as shown in Figure 1. They
processing to meet the needs of consumers. were there freeze-dried in a freeze dryer (Freeze
Freeze dried food is a large industry. Due dryer Heto Powerdry PL3000).
to high production cost and the need for freeze The freeze dryer accessories which include
dryers from abroad, the small and medium a vacuum pump, condenser, chamber and heating
enterprises (SME) could not invest. This research plate. Initially a vacuum pump reduces the ambient
aims to study the mathematical model for freeze gas pressure in an external chamber to a vacuum
drying mango as a guide line to scale up the state. The sample is heated to vaporize the
manufacturing in SME and to determine the costs sublimation. Then a vacuum pump sucks the
for investors steam from the chamber which condenses into ice
in a condenser as shown in Figure 2.
57
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67
58
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67
Water activity: Water activity was measured were 'E ( L * L0 )2 (a * a0 )2 (b * b0 )2 (1)
performed using water activity meter (AQUA Lab
3TE, USA). Samples were placed in the appropriate Structures: The internal structures of freeze-dried
plates and measured. Three samples from each mangoes were characterized with a scanning
trial were used and the average water activity is electron microscope (SEM) (JEOL JSM-5410V,
reported. Tokyo, Japan). Cross-sectioned samples were affixed
Color: Color values L*, a* and b* were measured on silver-painted sample holders and covered with
using Spectrophotometer (HunterLap MiniScan a fine layer of gold in a sputter coater (PSI sputter
XE plus, Germany). To obtain representative color coater, PA, USA) under vacuum. The coated
of the samples, the dried samples were ground to samples were photographed with SEM at 10 kV
powder using a smallǦscale blender to obtain
representative colors. A 1 g sample of mango Effective moisture diffusivity coefficient, Deff
powder was put in a 5 cm plastic Petri dish. The Considering unidimensional moisture
lens of the colorimeter, covered with plastic wrap movement and assuming that the mango sample
was placed directly on the mango powder to was a continuous infinite rectangular slab (Wang
measure the color values. Three measurements and Brennan, 1995) the effective mass diffusivity
were made of each sample, and the average was estimated by using Fick’s diffusion model
value was reported. The L* color value indicates
the degree of brightness or whiteness of the product. wM w 2M
The a* and b* color values indicates the degree of D (2)
wt wz2
redness and yellowness, respectively. The Total
Color Difference ( 'E ) was determined by
Equation 1.
59
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67
Moreover, assuming uniform initial moisture an energy intensive operation of some industrial
distribution, negligible external resistance and significance (Sharma and Prasad, 2006). The SEC
isothermal process, the solution proposed by was estimated and expressed following Equation
(Crank, 1975). is: 6 when the enthalpy of drying air was estimated
from its psychometric properties.
MR
8 f
1 § (2n 1)2 S2 (Deff )t ·
¦ (2n 1) exp ¨ ¸
(3) E heater E vacuum Ecooling
(6)
S2 n 0 © L2 ¹
SEC
Mw
For sufficiently long drying times, using When Eheater is energy required to heat
the first term in the series is adequate, Equation 4 the air, (kWh) Evacuum is energy requirement of
(Doymaz, 2007). the vacuum pump. (kWh) E c o o lin g is energy
requirement of the compressor (kWh) and MW is
the amount of moisture removed during the drying
§ S 2 (D eff ) t ·
MR
8
exp ¨ ¸ (4) process (kg)
S2 ¨ L2 ¸
© ¹
60
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67
The Moisture Ratio (MR) can be calculated Boer model (G.A.B.) because It is most widely
from Equation 7 used for food with high sugar content such as
mango (Rangel et al., 2011). following Equation 8
M M eq
MR (7)
Min M eq A BCaw
M eq (8)
1 C1 C a w B C a w
When Meq is Equilibrium moisture content
and Min is Initial moisture content When aw is Water activity and A, B and C
The equilibrium moisture content can be is constant as shown in Table 3
calculated from the Guggenheim-Anderson-de
The coefficient of determination (R 2) was the relative goodness of fit. The best model
one of the primary criteria to select the best model describing the drying behavior of freeze drying
to compare with the experimental data. In addition was chosen as the one with the highest R2 and
to R2, reduced chi-square (χ2) and Root Means the least RMSE (Othman et al., 2012). This
Square Error (RMSE) were also used to compare parameter can be calculated following Table 4.
61
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67
RUN MC H aw Color
(%) (N) L* a* b* 'E
62
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67
0.40
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
0.07 0.08 0.31 0.37 0.88 2.28 3.98
Moisture content (d.b.)
Figure 4 Relationship between drying rate (gH2O/gdry mass-h) and noisture content (d.b.)
(a) (b)
Figure 5 Optimal condition (a) and non optimal condition (b)
63
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67
4E-10
3.5E-10
3E-10
Deff, m2/s
2.5E-10
2E-10
1.5E-10
1E-10
5E-11
0
0.07 0.08 0.31 0.37 0.88 2.28 3.98
Moisture Content , d.b.
Figure 6 Relationship between effective moisture diffusivity coefficient and moisture content
Effective moisture diffusivity coefficient, Deff the energy used for heating is less than the amount
Considering the slope of the graph of relation of energy. In RUN 4 , 5 and 6 shows, The SEC is
of experimental drying data in term of Ln(MR) directly proportional to time, more time for drying.
versus time, plot Deff versus moisture content of The SEC increase. RUN 6 gave the highest SEC
mango freeze dried. (Figure 6) The Deff increases of 277.12 kWh/kg And RUN 7, 8 and 9 increase
as moisture content increases and became almost in pressure reduced energy consumption because
constant at low moisture content. Deff was in the the vacuum pump performed less work.
range of 5.54 u 10-11 to 2.90 u 10-10 m2/s
Mathematical model
Specific energy consumption (SEC) in freeze The measured and predicted moisture ratio
drying process (MR) from different models is shown in Figure 7,
Table 5 shown comparison of the SEC n and the parameter of the Newton, Page, Modified
used in each experiment. In RUN 1, 2 and 3 the Page, Henderson-Pabis,
specific energy consumption did not differ, because
64
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 57-67
1.0 1.0
Experiment
0.8 Experiment 0.8
Page Model
Newton Model
0.6 0.6
MR
MR
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0
0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28
time ,hr time , hr
1.0 1.0
MR
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0
0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28
time, hr time, hr
1.0 1.0
MR
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0
0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28
time, hr time, hr
65
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67
Model k n a b c R2 RMSE F2
Logarithmic and Wang and Sing models 6.8% and the specific energy consumption was
for the drying process and summarized in Table 253.07 kWh/kg. The average drying rate was
6. The R2 values indicates that Page and Modified 0.294gH2O/g dry mass-h and the effective moisture
Page models fit reasonably well with the experimental diffusivity coefficient from linear equation method
data. Root means square error (RMSE) of Page ranged from 5.54 u 10-11to 2.90 u 10-10 m2/s. The
and Modified Page model is 0.016354 and 0.016215, Modified Page model was found to be the better
respectively. It can be seen that the Modified Page model, with coefficient of determination of 0.998,
model performed better than the Page model. It is reduced chi-square value of 0.00026 and RMSE at
recommended that the Modified Page model 0.016215. These parameters can be used as guide
should be used to predict the freeze drying of to scale up the manufacturing in SME scale
mangoes. both in production and investment.
Conclusion Acknowledgements
The optimal conditions were in the secondary The research was supported by the Graduate
drying stage at 10oC for 6 hours at the pressure School Maejo University. The authors thank the
of 20 Pa. After drying, the quality of mangoes was Faculty of Engineering and Agro-Industry, Maejo
determined. the value of hardness was 6.1834 N University for research facilites and to Professor
and the water activity was 0.276. The colors L*, a* Siriwat Wongsiri for the helpful suggestions and
and b* value were 79.86, 4.29 and 53.62, respectively. critical reviewing of this manuscript.
The final moisture content of the product was
66
Journal of Agr. Research & Extension 30(3) (Suppl.): 56-67