Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0 Motor Speech Disorders 1021 20 BB
0 Motor Speech Disorders 1021 20 BB
Session 9
Motor Speech Disorders: Dysarthria vs. Apraxia
3
Topics
Ø Overview
Ø Dysarthria
Ø Apraxia
Ø Summary
Ø In-Class Activity 8
4
Speech Chain again
5
Speech: Initiation to Production
1. Cognitive-Linguistic processes:
Thoughts, feelings, emotions generate/integrate an
intent to communicate verbally.
2. Motor speech planning, programming, and control
Selection, sequencing, and regulation to activate
speech muscles at appropriate times, durations, and
intensities
3. Neuromuscular Execution
CNS and PNS work together to execute speech
motor programs by activating breathing, phonatory,
resonatory, and articulatory structures.
Duffy, 2013: p. 3
Motor Speech Disorders (MSDs)
• Speech disorders resulting from neurologic
impairments affecting one or more of the
following acts required for verbal communication.
– Planning
– Programming
– Control
– Execution
• MSDs include the dysarthrias and Apraxia of
Speech (AOS).
Proper Movements
• The contribution of sensory input is
indispensable. Motoric behavior is
“sensorimotor” in nature.
• Four vital elements of movements.
– Mobility
– Balance
– Coordination
– Stability
Dysarthria
• A group of neurologic speech disorders that reflect
abnormalities required for verbal communication.
– Strength
– Speed
– Range
– Steadiness
– Tone
– Accuracy of movements for the breathing,
phonatory, resonatory, articulatory, or prosodic
aspects.
Duffy, 2013: p.4
Apraxia of Speech
• A neurologic speech disorder that reflects an
impaired capacity to plan or program
sensorimotor commands necessary for
directing movements that result in
phonetically and prosodically normal speech.
Duffy, 2013: p. 4
Non-Neurologic Speech Disturbances
• Musculoskeletal defects
EXAMPLES: Laryngectomy, Cleft lip/palate,
Fractures, structural anomalies for verbal
communication.
• Non-neurologic voice disorders
EXAMPLES: Dysphonia associated with head or neck
neoplasms, Vocal abuse, or Hormonal disturbances.
• Psychogenic and related non-organic speech
disorders
EXAMPLES: Schizophrenia, depression, conversion
disorder.
Normal Variations in Speech
Production
• Gender/sex
• Variation in style
CNS
Pyramidal and Extrapyramidal Tracts
Pyramidal tract
• Largely responsible for the initiation of
voluntary motor acts.
Extrapyramidal system
• Responsible for the background tone and
movement supporting the primary acts.
• Projecting to the basal ganglia and reticular
formation.
Neurologic communication disorders: Mayo Clinic
Distribution
Distribution of
of neurologic
neurologic communication
communication disorders,
disorders, Speech
Speech pathology,
pathology, Department
Department
of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, 1987-1990 and 1993-2001. (Duffy,
of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, 1993-2008. (Duffy, 2013). 2005).
Role of SLP
• Describe symptoms
• Provide intervention
– Facilitating technique
– Physiological technique
• Measure changes
• Efficiency of entire system must be addressed
– Respiration
– Phonation
– Resonance
– Articulation
Dysarthria: Localization and Neuromotor bases
NEUROMOTOR BASES-
TYPE LOCALIZATION
GNERAL/SPECIFIC
Left (dominant)
hemisphere
The posterior frontal lobe
(in, around, or under Motor
Broca’s area). planning/programming:
AOS
Sometimes in the parietal planning/programming
lobe. errors
Occasionally in both the
frontal and parietal lobes
Subcortical areas.
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Topics
Ø Overview
Ø Dysarthria
Ø Apraxia
Ø Summary
Ø In-Class Activity 8
19
Dysarthria: Localization and Neuromotor bases
• Degenerative (40%)
• Traumatic (22%)
• Muscle Disease (9%)
• Vascular (9%)
• Myasthenia Gravis (4%)
• Infectious (4%)
• Tumor (3%)
• Demyelinating (2%)
• Anatomic malformation (1%)
• Radiation therapy, drug toxicity, and others (5%)
21
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Neuromuscular Deficits associated with
Flaccid Dysarthria
https://www.dreamstime.com/stock-illustration-synapse-labeled-diagram-image42236157
Flaccid Dysarthria
Myasthenia Gravis-cont.
• The primary symptom of weakness often
affects the speech muscle.
– Weakened vocal folds: breathy and weaker
voice over time as the person with
Myasthenia Gravis continues talking.
– Hypernasal voice: weakness of the soft
palate.
– Swallowing problems.
Flaccid Dysarthria
Myasthenia Gravis-cont.
• Examination:
– Normal laryngeal appearance early in day;
hypernasality/nasal emission as voicing continues.
– Weakened VF: breathy and weak voice
– Swallowing issues.
• Treatment:
– Respiratory control of voicing
– Intonation therapy
– Reduce laryngeal strain/hyperfunction
– Palatal lifts to reduce hypernasality
– Medications to control muscle weakness
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ekhdckujXME&feature=related
Nasalized speech
Flaccid Dysarthria
Guillain-Barré
• The onset of the disease is often expressed in
dysphonia and dysphagia.
• Unknown cause.
• Frequently preceded by viral infection.
• The focal demyelination of PNS.
• The patient often requires a tracheostomy and
ventilatory support.
• Could result in dysarthria or anarthria.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kDspLPFhkS4
Dysarthria: Localization and Neuromotor bases
• Degenerative (60%)
• Vascular (17%)
• Undetermined (10%)
• Congenital (8%)
• Traumatic (4%)
• Demyelinating (1%)
32
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Neuromuscular Deficits associated with
Spastic Dysarthria
DAMAGE TO
DIRECT ACTIVATION PATHWAY INDIRECT ACTIVATION PATHWAY
(PYRAMIDAL TRACTS) (EXTRAPYRAMIDAL TRACTS)
Duffy, J. R. (2013) 34
Upper Motor Neuron Lesions
UNILATERAL (UUMN)
• Imprecise articulation
• Many cases: slowed rate and irregular
articulatory breakdown
• Some cases: harshness, reduced loudness and
hypernasality of voice
• Often mild to moderate in severity
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Upper Motor Neuron Lesions
Bilateral: Spastic Dysarthria
• Oral musculature: It is common to
present with severe impairments of
range & rate of movement
– Limited tongue ROM and palatal movement
– Limited and slow lip ROM
– Under-reactive or over-reactive gag reflex
– Chewing and swallowing difficulties with
drooling
36
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Upper Motor Neuron Lesions
Bilateral: Spastic Dysarthria-cont.
• Speech is harsh, strained-strangled quality
• Very little variation in loudness (monoloudness) and
reduced stress
• Often hypernasality
• Articulation: Imprecise consonant production and
Vowel distortion
37
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Dysarthria: Localization and Neuromotor bases
• Degenerative (44%)
• Undetermined (13%)
• Vascular (11%)
• Demyelinating (10%)
• Tumor (6%)
• Traumatic (5%)
• Toxic/Metabolic/Endocrine (3%)
• Multiple Possible Causes (3%)
• Other (4%)
39
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Neuromuscular Deficits associated with
Ataxic Dysarthria
41
Cerebellum and Cerebellar pathway Lesions
Ataxic Dysarthrias
42
Cerebellum and Cerebellar pathway Lesions
Ataxic Dysarthrias
43
Dysarthria: Localization and Neuromotor bases
• Degenerative (87%)
• Vascular (4%)
• Multiple possible causes (3%)
• Traumatic (2%)
• Undetermined (2%)
• Infectious (1%)
• Other (1%)
45
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Neuromuscular Deficits associated with
Hypokinetic Dysarthria
57
Extrapyramidal -- Basal Ganglia Lesions
Dyskinetic Dysarthrias
Hypokinetic Dysarthria: Parkinsonism
• Oral musculature: Slow rate of movement of the
lips and tongue with some reduced range of
movement.
• Phonation: Hoarseness, roughness, breathiness
and tremulousness, Dysphonia, Monopitch, and
monoloudness.
• Speech: Varied across patients depending on
stage of disease and treatment.
58
Extrapyramidal -- Basal Ganglia Lesions
Dyskinetic Dysarthrias
Hypokinetic Dysarthria: Parkinsonism
• Articulation: Articulatory imprecision and
articulatory undershoot due to inadequate
tongue elevation
• Resonance: Hypernasality in small percentage
(10%)
• Prosody:
– Prosodic insufficiency: variable rate, short
rushes of speech, long pauses
– Palilalia: repetitions that usually involve words,
phrases, or sentences
59
Extrapyramidal -- Basal Ganglia Lesions
Dyskinetic Dysarthrias
Lee Silverman Voice Treatment (LSVT)®
• REDUCED VOCAL LOUDNESS + MONOTONOUS SPEECH
(Reduced drive to respiratory and laryngeal muscles)
Speak LOUD!
Think LOUD!
• Undetermined (89%)
• Toxic or Metabolic (3%)
• Degenerative (2%)
• Trauma (1%)
• Vascular (1%)
• Other (4%)
62
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Neuromuscular Deficits associated with
Hyperkinetic Dysarthria
Dystonia Chorea
Individual Inaccurate due to Inaccurate due to quick
Direction Movements slow involuntary > slow involuntary
movements movements
Repetitive
Rhythm Movements Irregular Irregular
Repetitive
Movements Slow Slow
Rate
Individual
Movements Slow Slow
Repetitive Reduced to normal Reduced to excessive
Movements
Range
Individual Reduced to normal Reduced to excessive
Movements
Individual
Force Movements Normal Reduced to Excessive
64
Huntington’s disease
• Huntington's disease is an inherited disease that
causes the progressive breakdown (degeneration) of
nerve cells in the brain.
• Most people with Huntington's disease develop signs
and symptoms in their 30s or 40s. But the disease
may emerge earlier or later in life. When the disease
develops before age 20, the condition is called
juvenile Huntington's disease.
• Symptoms include movement, cognitive and
psychiatric disorders.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/huntingtons-disease/symptoms-causes/syc-20356117
Huntington’s disease
Movement disorders
• Involuntary movements and impairments in
voluntary movements.
• Muscle problems, such as rigidity or muscle
contracture (dystonia).
• Slow or abnormal eye movements
• Impaired gait, posture and balance
• Difficulty with speech or swallowing
• Impairments in voluntary movements
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/huntingtons-disease/symptoms-causes/syc-20356117
Huntington’s disease
Cognitive disorders
• Difficulty organizing, prioritizing or focusing on tasks
• Lack of flexibility or the tendency to get stuck on a
thought, behavior or action (perseveration).
• Lack of impulse control that can result in outbursts,
acting without thinking and sexual promiscuity
• Lack of awareness of one's own behaviors and abilities
• Slowness in processing thoughts or ''finding'' words
• Difficulty in learning new information.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/huntingtons-disease/symptoms-causes/syc-20356117
Huntington’s disease
Psychiatric disorders
• Depression caused by the changes in brain
function.
• Signs and symptoms may include:
– Feelings of irritability, sadness or apathy
– Social withdrawal
– Insomnia
– Fatigue and loss of energy
– Frequent thoughts of death, dying or suicide
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/huntingtons-disease/symptoms-causes/syc-20356117
Huntington’s disease
Psychiatric disorders – cont.
• Obsessive-compulsive disorder — a condition
marked by recurrent, intrusive thoughts and
repetitive behaviors
• Mania, which can cause elevated mood,
overactivity, impulsive behavior and inflated self-
esteem
• Bipolar disorder — a condition with alternating
episodes of depression and mania
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/huntingtons-disease/symptoms-causes/syc-20356117
Huntington’s disease
Symptoms of juvenile Huntington's disease
• Behavioral changes
– Loss of previously learned academic or physical
skills
– Rapid, significant drop in overall school
performance
– Behavioral problems
• Physical changes
– Contracted and rigid muscles that affect gait
– Changes in fine motor skills that might be
noticeable in skills such as handwriting
– Tremors or slight involuntary movements
– Seizures
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/huntingtons-disease/symptoms-causes/syc-20356117
Dyskinetic Dysarthrias
Hyperkinetic Dysarthria: Chorea
• Huntington’s Chorea: autosomal dominantly
inherited
• Results in loss of neurons from the caudate
nucleus, pallidum, and cerebral cortex
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/huntingtons-disease/symptoms-causes/syc-20356117
Dyskinetic Dysarthrias
Hyperkinetic Dysarthria: Chorea
Three types:
§ Adductor type
§ Abductor type
§ Mixed type
74
Dysarthria: Localization and Neuromotor bases
• Degenerative (78%)
• Vascular (7%)
• Demyelinating (3%)
• Trauma (<1%)
• Toxic or Metabolic (<1%)
• Neoplastic (<1%)
• Multiple causes (1%)
• Other (9%)
76
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Mixed UMN and LMN Lesions
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
• Etiology is unknown
• Progressive, degenerative disease
affecting both UMN and LMN systems
• Not confined itself to one motor system –
affect both upper and lower motor
neuron systems.
77
Mixed UMN and LMN Lesions
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
• Muscles are weak but reflexes are
hyperactive.
• Spasticity is usually present unless the
lower motor neuron damage is well
advanced.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNLKPaThYkE 78
Mixed UMN and LMN Lesions
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
• Oral musculature: Weakness in lips,
tongue, and palate
• Reduced range of movement; sometimes
one side is slightly more affected than
other
• The tongue may show fasciculation's and
atrophy
79
Mixed UMN and LMN Lesions
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
80
Other Mixed Dysarthrias with Diverse Lesions
Multiple Sclerosis
81
Other Mixed Dysarthrias with Diverse Lesions
Multiple Sclerosis
82
Other Mixed Dysarthrias with Diverse Lesions
Multiple Sclerosis
83
Other Mixed Dysarthrias with Diverse Lesions
Multiple Sclerosis
Ø Overview
Ø Dysarthria
Ø Apraxia
Ø Summary
Ø In-Class Activity 8
85
Apraxia: subtypes
• limb-kinetic apraxia
• Ideomotor apraxia
• Ideational apraxia
• constructional apraxia
• oculomotor apraxia
• buccofacial, oral, or facial apraxia
• Apraxia of speech (AOS)
• Childhood apraxia of speech (CAS) è later
Apraxia: subtypes
• limb-kinetic apraxia
• Ideomotor apraxia
• Ideational apraxia
• Constructional apraxia
• oculomotor apraxia
• buccofacial, oral, or facial apraxia
• Apraxia of speech (AOS)
• Childhood apraxia of speech (CAS) è later
Apraxia
Oral Apraxia (Buccofacial Apraxia)
• Inability to consciously perform
oral/facial movements.
• Reflexive/automatic performance is not
impaired.
• Paralysis, significant weakness, or
incoordination of oral musculature not
noted on examination.
Oral Apraxia assessment
(Examples from ABA-2 Subtest 3, pt. B)
• “stick out your tongue”
• “whistle”
• “puff out your cheeks”
• “kiss a baby”
• “clear your throat”
• “bite your lower lip”
• “show me your teeth”
• “take a deep breath and hold it”
• “lick your lips”
• “open your mouth”
Apraxia
Apraxia of speech (AOS)
See p. 195 for Duffy’s (2005) definition
• Degenerative (54%)
• Vascular (28%)
• Neoplastic (5%)
• Trauma (3%)
• Other (10%)
91
Duffy, J. R. (2013)
Apraxia
Apraxia of speech (AOS)
McNeil, Robin, & Schmidt (1997)
• Slow speech rate (lengthened segments and
intersegment durations)
• Sound distortions
• Distorted sound substitutions (consonant/vowels)
• Sound errors that are relatively consistent in type
and location on repeated productions
• Prosodic abnormalities.
Apraxia
Apraxia of speech (AOS)
Duffy (2013)
Articulation:
• Consonant & Vowel distortions (imprecise
articulation)
• Distorted substitutions, additions, sound
prolongations, voicing features.
Apraxia
Apraxia of speech (AOS)
Duffy (2013)
Rate and Prosody:
• Slow overall rate.
• Prolonged but variable vowel duration,
interwork intervals.
• Syllable segregation
• Errors of stress placement.
Apraxia
Apraxia of speech (AOS)
Duffy (2013)
Other characteristics:
• Successful or unsuccessful attempts to self-correct
articulatory errors that cross phonemic boundaries.
• False articulatory starts and restarts.
• Effortful visible and audible trial-and-error groping for
articulatory postures.
• Sound and syllable repetitions.
• Error rates higher for volitional/purposeful vs.
automatic/reactive utterance.
Topics
Ø Overview
Ø Dysarthria
Ø Apraxia
Ø Summary
Ø In-Class Activity 8
96
Now we know…
Ø Overview
Ø Dysarthria
Ø Apraxia
Ø Summary
Ø In-Class Activity 8
98
Speech Production: Simple Summary
Ideation Communicative intent Cognitive
Word retrieval
Language Phonological mapping Linguistic
Syntactic/grammatical ordering
Motor Planning Specify movement parameters
Range of motion
Strength Motor: Praxis
Motor
Speed
Programming Direction
Degree of muscle contraction
Acoustic Motor-
Execution/Control of movements
Output Execution
Adapted from Duffy, 2013 and Lecture slide set by Dr. E. Strand: 10/18/2012
Adapted from Duffy, 2013 and Yorkston, Beukelman, Strand, & Hakel, 2010: p. 407