Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BSBFIM601 - Manage Finances
BSBFIM601 - Manage Finances
BSBFIM601 - Manage Finances
Acknowledgements
Writer: Nicholas Hyland
© William Angliss Institute 2017. All text and images unless otherwise stated.
All rights reserved. This Training Manual was produced by William Angliss Institute to be
used as resource material for its enrolled students only; and as such they have the authority
to print out this material. Any further copying or communicating of this material in any format
or via any means may only be done so with the prior documented permission of William
Angliss Institute. William Angliss Institute does not have the authority to give permission for
third party materials that may be included in this resource.
Disclaimer
Every effort has been made sure that this manual is free from error or omissions. However,
you should conduct your own enquiries and seek professional advice before relying on any
fact, statement or matter contained in this book. William Angliss Institute is not responsible
for any injury, loss or damage as a result of material included or omitted from this course.
Information in this module is current at the time of publication. The time of publication is
indicated in the date stamp at the bottom of each page.
Images have been sourced from Shutterstock and are used under Creative Commons
licence.
Photography suppliers and other third party copyright owners and as such are non-
transferable and non-exclusive.
Table of contents
William Angliss Institute ........................................................................................................ 1
Unit descriptor ....................................................................................................................... 3
Assessment matrix ................................................................................................................ 5
Glossary................................................................................................................................ 7
Element 1: Plan for financial management .......................................................................... 11
Element 2: Establish budgets and allocate funds ................................................................ 35
Element 3: Implement budgets............................................................................................ 53
Element 4: Report on finances ............................................................................................ 83
Presentation of written work ................................................................................................ 97
Recommended reading ....................................................................................................... 99
Trainee evaluation sheet ................................................................................................... 101
Trainee self-assessment checklist..................................................................................... 103
Unit descriptor
BSBFIM601 Manage finances
This unit deals with the skills and knowledge required to manage finances in a range of
settings within the hospitality and tourism industry.
Assessment matrix
Showing mapping of Performance Criteria against Activities, Written Questions and
Oral Questions
The Assessment Matrix indicates three of the most common assessment activities your
Assessor may use to assess your understanding of the content of this manual and your
performance - Activities, Written Questions and Oral Questions. It also indicates where
you can find the subject content related to these assessment activities in the Trainee
Manual (i.e. under which element or performance criteria). As explained in the
Introduction, however, the assessors are free to choose which assessment activities are
most suitable to best capture evidence of competency as they deem appropriate for
individual students.
Glossary
Term Explanation
Term Explanation
Term Explanation
Element 1:
Plan for financial management
1.1 Review and analyse previous financial data to
establish areas which have generated a profit or
loss
Introduction
All businesses, small or large, across all industries wish to be successful. In order to be
successful a good business should:
Earn a satisfactory profit for its owners
Use its short term and long term assets efficiently
Be able to pay its short term debts on time
Maintain adequate cash stocks to meet requirements
Provide a return on investment to the owners both in
income and growth of the value of the investment.
To measure this success, all organisations record their financial activities and consolidate
this information in reports that convey their financial achievements over arbitrary time
periods of equal length.
Accounting is often referred to as the “language of business” as it is accounting principles
and terminology that provide the structure for the information system and reports that
summarise financial activities.
Owners, managers and employees involved in decision making must appreciate this
language so that reports on activity can be read, analysed and the information applied to
enable decision making.
The hospitality industry encompasses a wide range of activities and types of organisations.
Accounting information systems must be designed to reflect the needs not only of the
industry but also of individual establishments.
From a management perspective there is a need for you to identify the range of financial
information and reports required to effectively monitor business performance at a day-to-day
management level.
For a hospitality organisation you are required to identify the different roles that undertaken
financial transaction and management of finances.
For each role identify the types of financial activity or responsibility they undertake.
In addition to the above, financial analysis helps to assess the operational efficiency of the
management of the company by comparing the actual performance against:
Budget
Forecast
Industry leaders
Industry average.
Specific ‘times’ of the year – such as ‘Christmas’, a nominated holiday period. This
general type of comparison is useful where there are movable holidays that don’t fall
on the same dates each year or a regular event.
Ascertain accuracy of information collected
Determine importance of information
Meet legally imposed taxation and other business
requirements
Demonstrate due diligence in the operation of the business
Develop a growing resource to help evaluate the performance
of the business
Compare actual business performance to budgeted/expected
figures
Identify the strengths and opportunities of the business
Identify problems in a timely manner
Identify areas requiring improvement
Create a reference base to assist in making decisions about the future direction and
operation of the business
Identify its current financial position.
For a hospitality organisation you are required to identify the different sources identifying
previous financial information.
For each source identify the types of financial information that can be obtained.
Researching income
Reviewing income components
In relation to monitoring income components, essential areas for review and research
include:
Pricing strategies
Demand for individual items
Comparison against competitors revenues and prices
Promotions - types and successes
Cash and credit transactions
Cash handling and security procedures
Credit policies and procedures
High and low volume spending periods
Management of accounts receivable
Level of overdue accounts.
All research activities associated with income is aimed at:
To determine how to increase revenue
To determine if prices can be increased or decreased to meet demand whilst
maintaining a competitive advantage
To determine whether or not staff are implementing the system as intended
To identify financial situations outside the acceptable limits set by the business
To identify fraudulent practices/theft
To determine whether or not the system can be improved
To validate the system is providing the financial and management information
necessary to enable effective management decisions to be made.
Researching expenses
The review and research of expenses is a more complex issue than that of income because
there are potentially more things to be considered.
Reviewing expense components
In relation to reviewing expenses the two essential activities that must be undertaken are:
Comparing actual costs against projections
Reviewing payments made by the business for goods and services purchased.
All research activities associated with expenses is aimed:
To determine whether or not staff are implementing
the system as intended
To identify financial situations outside the acceptable
limits set by the business
To identify fraudulent practices/theft
To determine whether or not the system can be
improved
To validate the system is providing the financial and management information
necessary to enable effective management decisions to be made.
Executive Summary
Business Profile
Your Products or Services
The Market
The Business Potential
Mission, Goals and Objectives
Strategies
Business Structure
Finance
Conclusion.
Finance Plan
Current Financial Position
Capital Requirements and Funding Proposal
Financial Budgets
Cash-flow Projection
Projected Statement of Financial Performance (Profit
& Loss)
Projected Statement of Financial Position (Balance
Sheet)
Financial Ratios
Financial Controls
Business Insurances.
Risks Plan
Risk Identification and Mitigation.
Structure and Management Plan
Organisational Chart and Structure
Key Personnel
Labour Requirements and Skills
Staffing Strategies
Professional Advisers
Staffing Controls.
Project Plan
Action Plan
Evaluation
Implementation
Appendices
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
At what stage would you start being concerned about cash flow?
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
GST
Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a tax that must be paid on goods and services purchased
from business registered for GST.
This means you have to charge GST to those who buy from you when you are registered for
GST.
Businesses register for the purposes of GST to ensure they meet their tax collection
obligations and so they may ‘claim back’ monies paid by them when purchasing goods and
services.
General questions to be answered include:
What is GST?
What goods and services are subject to GST?
When do I pay or collect GST?
Are there any GST schemes to help businesses?
Where can I download GST guides?
Where can I get help?
You are required to identify the different types of taxation legislation that applies to your
country.
What types of taxation applies to a tourism business? What are the requirement for each
type of taxation?
Requirements
Company Tax
Pay As You Go
The basics
The basic accounting and bookkeeping concepts apply to computerised systems.
On-site training and supervision together with the relevant manuals and on-line help should
show you how to:
Establish, open. close and modify individual accounts
Establish, open, close and modify journals
Make entries – debits and credits, dates, details etc.
Calculate balances including totals and cumulative
totals
Amend incorrect entries
Include narrative descriptions where required
Cross-reference entries to the appropriate account or folio
Perform reconciliations
Print required documents, accounts and reports.
You need to be able to use the computerised system to perform all the necessary functions,
transactions and reconciliations for the property, and not just the most common ones.
Computerised Accounting
In today’s business environment, the use of computerised bookkeeping and accounting has
become very widespread. It is essential however that financial managers and advisers have
a sound understanding of the principles underlying accounting and that is why you have
studied accounting units in your course.
There are a large number of accounting computer packages available, some specifically
written for certain industries. These customized packages include invoicing, end of
month/year reports, comparison with industry averages and variation analysis.
There are in addition packages, such as spreadsheet and database, that assist business to
develop information, as well as analyse and interpret their performance data. Spreadsheet
packages (e.g., Excel) assist in creating budgets, monitoring performance and investigating
variations. Database packages (Access) provide information about customers, suppliers and
potential markets.
You are required to identify four different types of accounting software systems that can be
implemented and used to manage financial information for a hospitality organisation.
You are required to identify two different types of sales/cost recording system that can be
implemented and used in a hospitality organisation.
Definition of a budget
Budgets are short-term plans of up to one year. They are
expressed in monetary terms and in terms of quantities such
as number of customers to be served per day, number of
tickets sold or the number of clients on a tour. The plan or
budget should help managers monitor the performance of the
business.
Plans for the longer term are not usually made into budgets because there are so many
unknown factors as the term grows longer that putting precise quantity or monetary values
on plans becomes difficult. Long-term plans are usually more about decisions to take on new
kinds of business and other such major changes in business direction.
For a small business such as a café, there is usually one budget showing the planned
revenue and expenses for the whole operation. Revenue is defined as money flowing into a
business such as sales. When money flows out of a business, this is called an expense.
For a larger business such as a hotel, budgets can be compiled a number of different ways.
Managers can find it useful to divide the business into segments or activity centres of two
types.
One type is called a Profit Centre. It is a part of a business that sells goods or services to
customers and incurs expenses. Part of the planning is about how to make it earn a profit.
The rooms area of a hotel, the dining room, conference centre, bars and gymnasium could
all be Profit Centres.
The other type of segment is called a Cost Centre. These are parts of a business that do not
sell anything but incur expenses. Planning focuses on managing expenses. Examples of
cost centres are Finance and Marketing departments.
Often budgets are created for each different department such as the restaurant and rooms
as well as for the hotel as a whole. Also in a larger business, there are budgets to assist in
managing specific expenses such as labour and rent as well as budgets to manage
revenues. These are neither department nor activity centre specific so provide an overview
of the planned activity for the entire business for the budgeting period.
Types of budgets
Operating a hospitality business will involve earning revenue from selling goods and services
to customers, buying goods to sell or to use in preparing finished products, buying labour
time, buying many other services from the landlord, electricity supplier, equipment supplier,
industry association, and so on
It will involve managing cash coming in, going out, and being banked. It will involve decisions
to spend money upgrading or replacing equipment and furniture, repainting, re-plumbing,
and rewiring the building or other major improvements to the facility.
It will also involve managing assets and borrowed money, profits and stock.
Each of these parts of the operation must be planned. This means that there are little
budgets for parts of the operation, and these little budgets are interconnected in a structure
that can be used to give the big Picture – an overview in a master budget for total profit and
loss of the organisation, not just for a department or activity centre.
Plans are needed for quantities and values of sales, quantities and values of purchases, and
so on.
Competition
Most businesses operate in a competitive environment, and this environment is subject to
constant and often unpredictable change.
It is part of your job and that of others involved in the budget discussions to identify the state
of the competition.
This means being able to identify:
Number of competitors and their market share
New entrants poised to enter the market
Existing competitors who are likely to leave the market
Competitors who are changing their target markets – especially if the one they are
leaving is one you also target, or if the one they intend entering is one you are
currently targeting
What the opposition is doing in terms of seeking business and what the realistic
impact of
those actions will be on your business – this
includes current initiatives and any things you have
heard of through your network of industry contacts
Action you propose taking to grow or maintain your
market share – which should be spelled out both in
the Strategic Plan and the Marketing Plan
The image the competition has created in the
market place and the way in which they have positioned themselves within the
various markets they are involved in.
It is best to have a round table discussion about the competition to capture the thoughts of
all those present, and this discussion should be supplemented with hard data.
This can include copies of their advertisements, personal reports from staff who have visited
the opposition and experienced what they have on offer, samples of their products, relevant
photographs, and any statistics that may have been gathered.
It is a common practice for nominated management to visit all competitors shortly before
these budget meetings so information shared with others has currency and relevance.
Economy
Budget considerations regarding revenue must always take into account the state of the
economy.
In many cases, it is the state of the economy of another country that may have to be looked
at, especially where a substantial part of your business comes from overseas.
The nature of tourism and hospitality businesses are they predominantly rely on the amount
of ‘disposable income’ people have: the more disposable income they have, the more they
are likely to spend within the industry.
For these reasons attention must be given to various economic matters such as:
The interest rate
The unemployment rate
Inflation
The amount of money owed by members of your
demographically identified target markets
The cost of other ‘essentials’ – such as petrol, food,
clothes etc.
The main idea in relation to this deliberation is not so much to identify specific figures or
percentages but to determine the general economic environment your guests are
experiencing, and to try to identify any trends which might be emerging.
As with competition, consideration of the economy can provide both opportunities for growth
as well as threats which may indicate the need for caution and reduction in sales figures.
History
Accounting has been described as an historic undertaking as it primarily provides historic
information about business performance.
There is no doubt an established business with a history of consistency is much better
placed to assess potential income than a business which has just opened up and has no
historic date to reflect on.
The benefit of historic information is it can, at the very least, provide a concrete basis for
discussing what did happen and what should have happened. It is this type of debate that
can be very illuminative in terms of identifying what might happen into the future.
The use of this historic data to assist in making future predictions is one of the many good
reasons accurate figures should be kept by all businesses in relation to their trading.
The budget deliberations should consider the following figures in relation to sales:
Average spend per person
Sales by target markets
Method of payment – sales to other business who take 90 days to settle an account
is not as attractive as cash sales where money is received on-the-spot
Degree to which sales resulted from special promotions – these special promotions
all cost some reduction in profit percentages as expressed as mark-up and it is
necessary to realise sales do not equate to profit.
The key point is there is no point raising $1,000,000 of sales if it has cost you
$1,200,000 to do so
Troughs and peaks in terms of trade – by the hour, day of the week and/or month of
the year.
It is important to remember when considering historic data this information is severely
contextual. That is, the data is only relevant to the factors which applied at that time.
If, for example, there was no competition in the area last year but now there are six new
competitors, the historic data may be of little or no relevance.
The historic data is most useful when comparing like with like, and arguably this is unlikely to
totally be the case in most instances.
Industry trends
There are often times when the public creates a trend for a certain product or service.
You need to be aware of any trends that are rising, as well as those which are on the wane.
Your own internal data can provide some information in relation to this and most industry
groups/ associations also generate data to assist in these deliberations.
The key in relation to trends is to:
Determine how you can benefit from trends – and what effect that will have on sales,
and what opportunities they may contain
Determine how you can protect yourself against negative trends – and what effect
that will have on sales
Determine whether those trends are emerging or established.
Sales targets
Sales targets can exist in two ways.
First, in some cases, as mentioned already, some budgets will set non-cash figures as
targets and where this is the case, this has to be factored into the consideration of sales in
terms of dollars.
If a KPI for a department is ‘the number of meals sold per week’, then the management of
that department may elect to engage in activities which will reduce selling prices in order to
attain the KPI.
This is an acceptable strategy providing the reduced
selling price does not mean an unacceptable level of
income or profit.
Where the price reduction unacceptably adversely
impacts revenue and unacceptably negatively affects
mark-up it may be necessary to revise the sales targets
or remove them as a KPI.
Second, sales targets may be dollar figures. For
example, the dining room may be required to generate $2,000,000 of sales.
The concern again is ‘sales’ are only one part of the equation. If the food cost to reach this
sales target is unacceptable then the sales target in dollar terms must also be re-considered
and perhaps revised downwards.
Seasonality
It is important to take into account seasonality factors when estimating sales.
Some businesses are hugely impacted by seasonality, while others experience almost no
affect from seasonal influence.
You can see here historic figures will be useful in predicting future seasonal influences.
When looking at seasonal sales it is also worth looking ‘behind’ those sales to be aware of
the cost of those sales. Many seasonal sales come at a cost including advertising,
commissions, wage loadings, special service standards, credit card payments, bulk
discounted sales to tour operators.
The levying of seasonal loadings helps to accommodate these expenses.
Also be aware in some cases, seasonality can cause an income downturn due to reduced
patronage whether this be caused by factors such as weather or holidays.
Whatever sales figures are finally arrived at they must be able to be supported. That is
justified and defended where necessary, by reference to
either data or logical reasoning.
Sales figures are essentially guesses but they must be
intelligent, and they must be able to withstand critical
analysis by others.
If a sales figure being proposed cannot be explained
and rationalised, it must be re-considered
Determine costs
It is important to identify all the cost that need to be budgeted. There are standard expense
elements to most businesses but there can be additional cost elements unique to individual
operations.
Reviewing previous budgets
The most common first approach to determining how funds will be spent is to take a look at
the previous budgets and see how funds were allocated to them, and how effective such
allocation was.
Given there can always be one-off events which throw a budget, the intention of reviewing
previous budgets is to learn lessons from them.
In essence you are trying to determine whether or not your previous allocations were
reasonable and responsible, and to identify the basis on which those decisions were made
with a view to using the same rationale for allocating money to the current budgets.
The one-off events should be factored out of the reality as far as is possible in order to
determine the validity of the original thinking.
Where there were no one-off events, the analysis of
previous budget allocations is relatively easy. The
main focus should be to assess the sufficiency of the
funds allocated – were enough funds allocated, or
were insufficient funds allocated?
You want to avoid allocating ‘too much’ money to a
budget because this means money cannot be
allocated/used elsewhere.
By the same token you do not want to allocate insufficient funds because this may adversely
affect the operation of the business, the service it delivers and the standards it wants to
maintain.
When reviewing the previous allocations, the current situation must also be factored in. For
example, if the previous allocation of funds for ‘cost of goods sold’ was accurate but in the
past month there has been an increase in materials cost of 20% and no corresponding
increase in selling prices, then the previous ‘formula’ used for calculating funds for materials
will be totally inappropriate.
Estimating costs
This can be a lengthy exercise and is something those involved in making input to the
budget deliberations are usually asked to research in advance of the budget meetings, so
they can come to these meetings armed with the necessary knowledge and figures.
In brief, every ‘substantial’ expense item must be looked at and this can include, for
example:
Contract labour
Compensation
Products
Rent
Advertising
Insurance
Office expenses
Maintenance
Capital expenditures.
It is important to know the quantities of these items needed in, say, the next 12 months
before such research begin.
Suppliers of materials are often prepared to negotiate prices but in return they are usually
looking for on-going business from you: it is a balancing act in many ways.
Suppliers may allow you not to pay for goods bought from them for six months but may want
to sell to you at premium prices and seek to lock you into a buying contract for, say, two
years. In effect, the supplier is providing you with ‘free’ credit but it is not 100% free of some
cost.
Performance outcomes and its impact on expenses
You should also identify the performance outcomes you are expected to meet as they will
impact on expenses.
Performance outcomes, also known as KPIs – Key Performance Indicators, can vary
between establishments both in terms of their type and in terms of the standards
performance required.
Your KPIs should be clearly stated at the start of any budget period.
In essence, your personal performance is usually judged against how well you meet these
performance outcomes. Performance outcomes are also known as performance targets and
can relate to income, expenses and service standards.
For the outlet within a hospitality organisation that you selected in Activity 12, you are
required to identify, for a one month period:
Revenue items and amounts
Expense items and amounts
EXPECTED REVENUE
EXPECTED EXPENSES
Consultation
The committee members are responsible for acting as the broadcasters of information to
their own activity centres. In each centre, staff members lower in the organisational hierarchy
are informed of the budget and its requirements. It is wise to remember that discussion and
agreement are preferable to simply giving out the draft budget. Cooperation is fundamental
to successfully managing the budget.
Communication
Activity centre managers have a wide range of options available to them to communicate the
draft budget. They must balance the need for appropriate consultation with budget
deadlines. Some of the communication methods are:
Staff meetings. Sometimes it is best to conduct
meetings with senior staff and then junior staff
depending on the size of the organisation. Managers
circulate the draft budget prior to the meeting
E-mails. Managers may choose to circulate the budget
electronically and encourage staff to send questions
the same way. Issues and questions may be resolved
individually or in the staff meeting environment
Newsletters. If time constraints are restricting the budget process, managers may decide
to prepare a newsletter detailing the organisation’s objectives and the draft budget that
will help to meet those objectives. This is a particularly effective tool for the hospitality
industry as access to email can be limited and staff commonly work shifts
Informal discussions. Activity centre managers must make themselves available to
discuss the draft budget in an informal setting.
For the outlet within a hospitality organisation that you selected in Activity 12, you are
required to identify:
How you would communicate budgets
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Objective Description
Financial records are complete All transactions are recorded and any omissions are
prevented
Financial records are valid All recorded transactions are “real” and properly
authorised
Financial records are accurate Transactions are properly valued, errors are minimised
and records are classified correctly and kept in a timely
manner
Adequate safeguards Ensure that all assets are properly safeguarded against
loss, theft and are maintained appropriately
Accountability Ensure all staff are assigned clear responsibility through
clearly defined job descriptions and duties
One common example in a tourism establishment that illustrates this point is the
responsibility for ordering goods, receiving goods and paying for the goods received. This
responsibility sits in the purchasing area. Separating these tasks to individual employees
minimises the opportunity for any one employee to order and receive goods for their own
use but authorise the business to make payment.
Separate record keeping and control of assets
One of the more important principles of internal control is to separate the functions of
recording information about assets and the actual control of the assets. For example, when a
cashier is responsible for a sales register and therefore cash sales in the department for
their shift, they should not be responsible for entering the transactions in the cash receipts
journals in the accounting system. This minimises theft and contributes to ensuring that
financial records are valid, accurate and complete.
Prepare written procedures
Once procedures have been established in all areas of an organisation and for each job or
role where control is needed, these procedures should be documented. This is particularly
important in the hospitality industry where employee turnover is high. Employees should
always be able to access these documents so that they know what the policies and
procedures are.
It is very difficult to establish a set of procedures that will fit
every possible situation in the hospitality and tourism
industry because there is such a wide variety of types,
sizes and styles of establishments. Even in two
establishments that appear similar, management policy,
the type of customer or other reasons means the
procedures for any particular control area differs.
Documentation procedures
Documents provide the basis for determining activities and events that have occurred
throughout an organisation. Tickets for tours must be numbered. These documents and
others that are similar should be pre-numbered whenever possible. In this way, individual
documents can be tracked and prevents the same document form being used more than
once. When pre-numbered documents are used, the employee receiving the document
should sign it to acknowledge responsibility and
accountability.
Forms and reports also form part of the documentation of in
an organisation. They are often used to provide management
with information about different aspects of the business so
that performance can be reviewed, evaluated and revised
when necessary. Usually the accounting department or
personnel are responsible for designing forms and reports in
consultation with appropriate management.
The accounting department or person is also responsible for
designing, ordering, storing and issuing all pre-numbered and
other documents. This is to ensure that documents are used appropriately. The sequence of
all numbered documents is checked regularly to ensure none are missing.
Expenses
Productivity
You are required to identify methods, policies or procedures that can used to control the
following financial activities.
Control of cash
Control of purchases
Control of payroll
Control of inventory
Regular review
Most managers review budgets against actuals at intervals of about 30 days. This is usually
seen as a way of keeping in close touch with what is happening in the business and fixing
anything that is going wrong before it becomes a really big
problem. It could be done once a week or 52 times a year.
Some businesses do this, but it obviously takes up a lot
more time to prepare the reports and to study them, to look
for things that need fixing and decide what to do about
them. Therefore, this examination of business
performance is always a compromise between doing it
very often and never having much time for doing anything
else, and doing it at long intervals and finding that problems have developed in the
meantime.
Variance analysis
To gauge the success of the business the manager needs to measure the budget outcomes
against the actual outcomes at regular intervals. The determination of variances between
actual and budget can be expressed in different ways:
Monetary units
Percentages
Units.
The items to which the variation applies will indicate whether it is a positive result or a
negative result. A simple rule for evaluating variances is to think about the effect of the
variance on business profit.
So in general terms:
An increase in actual costs so to be more than budgeted costs is unfavourable
A decrease in actual costs so to be less than budgeted costs is favourable
An increase in actual revenue so to be more than budgeted revenue is favourable
A decrease in actual revenue so to be less than budgeted revenue is unfavourable.
Example:
Variance
Line item Budget Actual Variance % ** Favourable/Unfavourable
Amount
Horizontal analysis
Two main types of variance analysis are performed to measure the difference between
budgeted and actual outcomes. Horizontal analysis is where actual and budgeted numbers
for each line item in financial reports are compared. These line items show the source of
income and on what expenses money is spent.
For each line item, a budget figure is matched with the actual result for the period and a
difference or a variance is calculated by subtracting the budgeted number from the actual
result. The variance is then divided by the budget figure to give a percentage, showing how
far the achieved result is from what was planned.
For example:
** - Note that standard business practice internationally is to show percentages in business reports to
one or two decimal places.
The sales variance is positive so the business sold more than planned. This increased profit
so you can record a Favourable variance.
Actual spending on food was more than planned. This reduced the business profit so an
unfavourable variance is recorded.
A full report on variances can show whether there are any serious problems between actual
and budgeted results and where any problems are located. The methods used by
businesses to deal with these problems is discussed further on in this manual
Vertical analysis
The other type of variance analysis is called vertical analysis. The sales budget is the first
budget to be prepared in the budget process. Owners and managers often budget expenses
as a percentage of sales. So these percentages can also be used to compare budget and
actual results.
Vertical analysis calculates each line item in the budget as a percentage of budget sales and
in a separate calculation, actual performance reports are used to compute the percentage of
each line to actual sales for the period.
For example:
When the budget was prepared, managers estimated that 27.1% of every sale would be
spent on food costs and 8.7% on wages, however, actual results show that only 26.9% of
sales was used to pay for food costs but 9.97% of sales contributed to wages. One of the
key roles of vertical analysis is to help managers to determine how well costs are being
controlled.
Accurate calculations
Management rely on the calculations that compare actual and
budget figures whether it is through horizontal or vertical
analysis. The results of these calculations can prompt
managers to take action and alter planned activity levels. It is
important firstly that calculations such as subtraction or
multiplication are performed accurately. However, it is mainly
about making sure that good information goes into the
calculations, for example, that your idea of how much busier
Friday is compared to Tuesday is realistic or that your idea of
what percentage of sales might be spent on buying food is
achievable.
For the outlet within a hospitality organisation that you selected in Activity 9, you are required
to identify:
Situations that may need budgets need to be changed
Causes of these situations
Examples of changes that would need to be made to budgets
Situations that may need Causes of these situations Examples of changes that
budgets need to be would need to be made to
changed budgets
Purpose of 'auditing'
In summary the purpose of an audit is to:
Make sure all accounts are accurate
Make sure departmental charges are accurate
Provide information on the financial activity of each department
Provide statistics on the financial activity of the establishment
Provide statistics on the financial activity of customers
Allow management to assess performance in relation to operational goals.
As a result of an audit process, the management of an establishment can monitor the activity
of departments on a regular basis and not have to wait until the end of a financial period.
This allows a quick response to potential problems or losses and provides accurate
information on which to base business decisions.
Internal audits
The purpose for internal audits is to continually review and study the internal control system
of an organisation. Sometimes, there is an internal audit department depending on the size
of the business and in other circumstances; the owner or most senior manager is assigned
this responsibility as part of their role.
During the year, various record keeping systems and administrative processes are reviewed
to ensure that operations are conducted effectively and documented procedures are being
followed. If a procedure, form or report is not used for its intended purpose or is not needed
anymore then the internal audit should address this and
recommend a change. One of the reasons why this is
important is that employees may begin to adjust
procedures for fraudulent purposes and if this is not
noticed, they will know the internal control system is not
working and continue this practice.
An audit trail exists in every good internal control system
that documents each transaction from the time it was
initiated through to final recording in the accounting
system. Internal auditors follow and verify this audit trail to ensure it is maintained
You are required to identify the purpose and importance of having internal audit mechanisms
as part of a financial system.
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Very few internal controls are probably required and therefore an internal audit to monitor
them would be infrequent. However, in larger establishments that feature multiple services
such as a resort, operations are organised into departments and internal controls are
extensive. Internal audits would be frequent and perhaps scheduled to rotate through the
functional areas twice or three times per year. Each workplace will detail their own internal
audit policy that you would be expected to know.
The process of an internal audit can be broken down into five key steps that are applicable
for all organisations. These are discussed briefly below.
Management meeting
Management and internal auditor personnel meet to confirm the scope, timelines and other
requirements for the audit. Any particular area of operations or procedures within any area of
operations that may be of concern to management for any reason are discussed and
included in the tasks for the audit. Any changes to the operation of the financial system such
as a change to procedures within the cash sub-system are also highlighted in this meeting.
Identify internal controls
As part of planning the internal audit, audit personnel refer to the policy and procedures
manual that details all the internal control measures management have implemented. Any
changes since the last internal audit will be documented as part of this manual. The systems
and procedures that are to be evaluated are reviewed, discussed and the audit plan
finalised.
For example these areas may be subject to audit each time an internal audit is conducted
due to the frequency of transactions:
Daily sales, allowances, cash and credit transactions, including
pricing and commissions
Purchasing, ordering and receiving goods and services
Payroll and labour costs.
Compliance with external regulations
Computer system controls
Controls over fixed asset expenditure.
Evaluate internal controls
Once the audit plan is established and agreed, auditors can begin the task of evaluating the
internal controls. An audit trail exists in every internal control system that documents each
transaction through the stages or phases of the financial system - input, processing and
output.
Internal auditors follow the trail, checking that procedures are followed and forms, reports or
other documents are used as intended. It is important to note that internal auditors test a
sample of transactions to evaluate the internal control procedure. This will usually represent
a proportion of the total transactions that management believe will verify that the system is
reliable.
Assess outcomes
If the auditors find that a procedure is not followed or documents are not used as detailed in
the procedures manual, a record of the transaction and the details are noted. This requires
internal auditors to assess the impact on internal controls of the deviation and note this for
management. It might appear to employees from one department that a particular task can
be carried out differently but may not realise that this has a detrimental impact on another
part of the system. Internal auditors would be expected to note an example such as this.
When a significant deviation from procedures is found, internal
auditors may expand the number of transactions reviewed to
check if the incident is isolated or indicative of a potential
internal control issue. This occurs if it is thought that the
deviation threatens the reliability of accounting information or
the safeguarding of assets.
Final evaluation
At the completion of the internal audit, an audit report is prepared for management. This
outlines the strengths, weaknesses, actions and follows up procedures from the internal
audit. This is an important document for managers as it serves to provide evidence that they
are fulfilling the responsibility of ensuring the reliability of financial i nformation.
Any actions that recommend changes to internal controls are discussed carefully between
managers and auditors. As appropriate, input from those employees who perform the tasks
is also sought. When changes are agreed, the policy and procedure manual is adjusted to
reflect the new procedure, any forms or reports altered and the internal audit report updated.
You are required to identify the different aspects of a financial system that you would wish to
audit as for a hospitality organisation.
Management by exception
Organisations have policies that managers can follow detailing the size of the variance that
is acceptable and variances that should be investigated further. This is called a tolerance
limit. Tolerance limits are generally expressed as percentages.
Management by exception is an approach whereby only variances that are above the
tolerance limit are investigated. Therefore, if there are 50 cost items and only three of them
show variances above the tolerance limit, only those three are investigated by managers.
Some organisations create a checklist, which managers can use as a guide to assist with the
decision to investigate variances and to guide them as to the management of such
variances.
An extract of a checklist follows:
Question Response
Is profit acceptable?
Management of deviations
A variance may indicate a problem with sales or in
managing costs. It may indicate that the budget team just
got it wrong, perhaps misreading the market or failing to
anticipate cost increases. Managers must decide how to
solve any problems above the tolerance limits that are
exposed by the variance report.
Budget managers have two possible approaches to solving
such problems:
If there are changes in the internal or external business
environment that are not controllable by the
organisation then managers must adjust the budget to reflect the new environment. For
example if the price of supplies increases due to a natural disaster, the budget changes
to reflect this
If the variance is within the control of the business, managers must identify the possible
causes of the variance and take action to manage the deviations.
The following examples are provided as areas to investigate to rectify certain types of
variances:
Variances in wages cost may prompt managers to review:
Mix of casual and full time staff
Specific training to assist staff perform tasks more efficiently
Multi-skilling. This is where staff perform duties across a number of different
departments or areas of the business. For example, a tour guide processes tickets
when they are not conducting tours
Staff morale or motivation. Lack of harmony and teamwork among staff and lack of
commitment to the organization by staff could be an issue
Possible causes and remedies for problems with sales revenue:
Was the sales forecast in the budget too optimistic?
Poor controls around sales. Are all items being charged to customers and at the
correct value and quantity or are items being carelessly or deliberately omitted from
or under-charged to customers’ accounts?
Have competitors entered the market and you have lost
sales?
Has there been a bad review in the media?
Are there unfavourable reviews spreading among existing
and potential customers?
Has a marketing campaign been ineffective?
Are the product or product mix and the image stale and out
of favour? Conduct a review and some market research to
provide products and an ambience that customers prefer.
The business has not changed to meet evolving consumer
trends.
It is important to note that these are just two examples of variances that management may
need to investigate. Management must act upon any significant deviations as soon as
possible so that control over revenue and expenses is maintained.
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
What are methods you can use to ensure you are compliant with all necessary regulations?
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
The following procedures can be applied to help ensure compliance with accounting policies
and procedures:
Involve accounting staff in the initial development of the policies and procedures – so
they become familiar with them from the outset and have a better understanding of why
they have been developed and why they are required
Explain and disseminate the policies and procedures once they have been developed
and approved – this can occur in meetings convened specially for the purpose where
copies of the documents are distributed and then carefully and fully explained
Any procedures requiring it should also be accompanied by appropriate demonstration,
including an introduction to accounting software
Where the policy or procedure requires the completion of paperwork, this too should be
shown and its completion explained
Make a full copy of all accounting policies and procedures available for ready-reference
by staff – this is usually achieved by preparing several ‘Policy manuals’ and ‘Procedures
manuals’ and making them available in the staff room as well as in departments or the
offices of department heads
Regularly used policies or procedures should be
included in a dedicated distribution to all
accounting staff when employed
Include ‘policies and procedures’ as part of your
standard in-house accounting training – this will
ensure every staff member becomes aware of the
requirements, how to comply and what is required
from an operational perspective
Provide every new accounting staff member with a copy of the policies and procedures
applicable to their work role as part of their Induction – this will ensure they have
immediate access to, and basic knowledge about their requirements. This basic
knowledge will, of course, be supplemented by the required in-house training
Develop checklists for posting at work stations – where standard procedures are
required for certain tasks it is a good idea to develop a series of short-form procedures
(known as checklists) to be posted at the relevant work stations so operational staff have
constant access to the basic requirements of every job to which a standard procedure
applies
Consistent mention of the need to adhere to policies and procedures by supervisors. The
need to implement all policies and procedures as set down by the business should be a
constant topic at every staff meeting and several briefings
The supervisor may elect to raise this topic by mentioning an infraction which has been
noted, praising a staff member for an instance of compliance noticed, or by presenting a
quick one minute review of a nominated policy or procedure
Personal observation of staff practices – to identify specific instances of compliance, to
note variations and to identify areas where policies and procedures seem to be
ineffective.
Supervisors and managers should have the discretionary power for dealing with variations
and are expected to use good judgement and common sense about how they respond to
each variation observed.
They will therefore be expected to take into account issues such as:
The level of trade at the time
The experience of the worker
Their intention – was their non-compliance deliberate or not?
The situation and the context that applied at the time
Did they know about the policy/procedure?
Dealing with variations
The possible ways to address variations can include:
Verbally mentioning the issue and advising as to how compliance
may be achieved in the future
Providing coaching or training on-the-spot as required to bring the
staff member up to speed
Providing a copy of the policy/procedure which was at the centre
of the variation and explaining it in detail
A formal verbal warning about the non-compliance
A written warning or dismissal.
You are to required to identify two examples of variations to accounting policies and
procedures that may take place, including causes, method of identifying the variance and
possible actions you could take to rectify the variance.
Structure of reports
Reports are structured to
reflect the information finding process and
the writing up of the findings
It is usually structured with the following sections:
a) summary of the contents
b) introduction or background
c) methods
d) results
e) discussion
f) conclusion or recommendations.
The extent of research required for your report depends on the scope of the report. If the
scope is limited to the company, research is easy as information can be obtained internally
within the company. However, if research requires a wider scope, extra effort is required to
source information from competitors or industry statistics. If competitors or industry
information is not easily available, research will be
difficult.
Start writing
Once you have the outline and information, start writing
the report. In the case of financial analysis report,
calculations are done at this stage and included in the
report. It is important to ensure the writing represents
honest presentation of the research.
Proofread report
When the report has been completed, print out a draft. Read the report over carefully,
marking any corrections for ease of corrections later. In the case of calculations, it is
important to check and ensure the numbers are extracted and calculations are done
correctly. In sections where it requires judgement, opinions and recommendations, it is
important to present them objectively.
Print report
After all the corrections have been made in the report, it is advisable to read the report all
over again before finalising it. Depending on the instructions given, determine how and who
the report should be distributed.
Financial analysis report
Financial analysis report contains analysis of financial statements. The scope and extent of
the report differs greatly depending on the
a) Intended audience
b) Resources of the company
Comprehensive financial analysis reports should elaborate on the strengths and
weaknesses of a company. Accurate and honest communication of the company’s strengths
and weaknesses enhances credibility of the report and gives confidence to the readers of
the report.
Writing a financial analysis report
The steps to writing a report and financial analysis report do not differ much. Below detailed
the steps in each section of the financial analysis report:
Executive summary
Summarise important findings from the financial analysis in the executive summary to give a
big picture of the report. As analysis will be outdated with the fast development of business,
it is very important to state the time period the analysis was carried out.
Introduction
Introduce the report with emphasis on the objectives of the report. Usually readers of such
reports should have some basic financial knowledge, it is good to define financial terms
necessary for understanding those objectives. If necessary, a glossary can be included in
the report to ease the readers in understanding technical terms used in the report.
Resources
Provide a general description of the analysed data and indicate the source of data. Some
examples of resource include balance sheets, profit and loss statements, and statistics on
operating costs, inventory and ratios. It is important to indicate the sources of the data for
references.
Methodology
Mention of method of data collection in the report helps to increase the credibility of the
analysis and report. Sometimes, comparatives are extracted from different sources like
government agencies or published websites. It is necessary to quote the sources in the
report so that readers can be established the reliability of the data presented. If the source
cannot be referenced or verified, readers might have to discount the reliability of the report
upon reading.
Detailed Analysis
Comprehensive analysis and observation about the investment returns, balance sheets,
profit and loss statement and ratios can be made in this section. It made good reporting to
comment on each of analysis in addition to the numbers, graphs, tables and ratios.
Recommendation
Based on the analysis reported, a recommendation section can
be included to add value to the reporting. It will boost
confidence and add interest to readers if the report provides
detailed action plans. With the detailed action plans included, it
gives the readers an impression that the company is proactive
and has taken serious view and actions on the analysis.
However, depending on the audience of the reports, it might be
competitively disadvantage for the company to include such
detailed action plans.
Conclusion
Summarise the report and end it with an appendix. It may provide information on the
problems resolution while performing the analysis. Sometimes, the report can include
statements projecting future performance on the basis of past years’ performance.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
Identify sources of data for your financial analysis report if you are asked to write one on
hotel business.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
Inclusions in a recommendation
The more important the cause and the possible effect, the more formal the recommendation
process is likely to be.
In general terms, the more costly the recommendation the greater the need for a more
formal style of recommendation such as providing a proposal that:
Detail the problem that is at the root of the recommendation
Highlights any legal compliance requirements that may be included
Describes the negative impacts of the above situation – which may include, for example,
the need to lay off staff, the need to increase prices, the eventual result if the current
situation is allowed to continue for 12 months
Identifies specific revised targets – which should
reflect the initial targets set by the business and
operational plans that are facing difficulty such as
income, expenditure, percentages, items sold, etc.
Sets revised flags to warn of unacceptable
deviations to the revised targets – this will help
identify revised circumstances when actual
performance has deviated unacceptably from
revised budgeted figures
Presents options for rectifying the position – it is always useful to present more than one
possible solution wherever possible
Sets out implementation costs for each recommendation or option – this should include
training, ‘change over’ costs where staff, etc. are operating at less than optimum during a
transitional phase and have to be allowed time to get up to speed
Identifies the benefits of each recommendation or proposal – which can include savings,
extra earnings, maintenance of service standards, reducing staff turnover, meeting
compliance requirements, increased safety, raised profile of the business
Supplies a formal cost-benefit analysis
Gives realistic timelines for introduction and implementation.
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
You are required to identify three possible financial issues that may
arise and provide recommendations for improvement.
Activity 28 -
Identify stakeholders
2. Style
Students should write in a style that is simple and concise. Short sentences and
paragraphs are easier to read and understand. It helps to write a plan and at least one
draft of the written work so that the final product will be well organised. The points
presented will then follow a logical sequence and be relevant. Students should frequently
refer to the question asked, to keep ‘on track’. Teachers recognise and are critical of work
that does not answer the question, or is ‘padded’ with irrelevant material. In summary,
remember to:
Plan ahead
Be clear and concise
Answer the question
Proofread the final draft.
Format
All written work should be presented on A4 paper, single-sided with a left-hand margin. If
work is word-processed, one-and-a-half or double spacing should be used. Handwritten
work must be legible and should also be well spaced to allow for ease of reading. New
paragraphs should not be indented but should be separated by a space. Pages must be
numbered. If headings are also to be numbered, students should use a logical and
sequential system of numbering.
Cover Sheet
All written work should be submitted with a cover sheet stapled to the front that contains:
The student’s name and student number
The name of the class/unit
The due date of the work
The title of the work
The teacher’s name
A signed declaration that the work does not involve plagiarism.
Keeping a Copy
Students must keep a copy of the written work in case it is lost. This rarely happens but it
can be disastrous if a copy has not been kept.
Inclusive language
This means language that includes every section of the population. For instance, if a
student were to write ‘A nurse is responsible for the patients in her care at all times’ it
would be implying that all nurses are female and would be excluding male nurses.
Examples of appropriate language are shown on the right:
Mankind Humankind
Host/hostess Host
Recommended reading
Alfredson, Keith & Ernst & Young; 2009 (2nd edition); Applying international financial
reporting standards; John Wiley & Sons
Andrew, William P & Schmidgall, Raymond S; 2007 (1st edition); Financial management for
the hospitality industry; Pearson Prentice Hall
Chatfield, Robert E & Dalbor, Michael C; 2009 (1st edition); Hospitality financial
management; Pearson Prentice Hall
Cornett, Marcia Millon & Adair, Troy A; 2015 (3rd edition); Finance: applications & theory;
New York McGraw-Hill Education
DeFranco, Agnes L & Lattin, Thomas W; 2007 (1st edition); Hospitality financial
management; John Wiley & Sons
Futura Training 2008; (1st edition); Manager's guide to hospitality financial management;
Futura Training
Guilding, Chris; 2013 (1st edition); Accounting essentials for hospitality managers; Abingdon,
Oxon Routledge
Jagels, Martin & Ralston, Catherine E & Ebooks Corporation; 2007 (9th edition); Hospitality
management accounting; John Wiley & Sons
Jiambalvo, James; 2013 (5th edition); Managerial accounting; Hoboken
Manage Finances within a Budget, William Angliss Institute of TAFE – 2003
Prepare and Monitor Budgets, William Angliss Institute of TAFE – 2003
Price, John Ellis & Haddock, M. David; 2015 (14th edition); College accounting; New York
McGraw-Hill Education
Rayman, R. A; 2006 (1st edition); Accounting standards: true or false? Routledge
Waybright, Jeffrey & Kemp, Robert S; 2015 (3rd edition); Financial accounting; Boston
Pearson
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
Yes No*
Element 1: Plan for financial management
1.1 Review and analyse previous financial data to establish areas
which have generated a profit or loss.
Yes No*
Element 3: Implement budgets
3.1 Circulate budgets and ensure managers and supervisors are
clear about budgets, reporting requirements and financial
delegations.
3.3 Review profit and loss statements, cash flows and ageing
summaries.
Statement by Trainee:
I believe I am ready to be assessed on the following as indicated above:
Note:
For all boxes where a No* is ticked, please provide details of the extra steps or work you
need to do to become ready for assessment.