Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Petri1997 Article EpidemiologyOfInvasiveMycosisI
Petri1997 Article EpidemiologyOfInvasiveMycosisI
inations. At an interval of 30 min to 24 h after removal of the cath- achieved. The results are given as adjusted odds ratios and 95 %
eters, new blood cultures were required for exclusion of an invasive confidence intervals [27–29].
mycosis.
Microbiology Results
At the start of the study (day 11 in the ICU), it was necessary to Patient selection
perform bacteriological and mycological tests in the local labora-
tory with blood cultures, tracheal secretions, urine specimens, stool In the course of the 11-month study period, 435 patients
specimens, and, in some cases, wound swabs, drainage, throat
swabs, cerebrospinal fluid, and sputum and to repeat these tests at
who fulfilled the inclusion criteria of the study were ad-
5-day intervals to the day of transfer out of the ICU or death. mitted to the ICUs. Twenty-six patients were excluded
because of protocol errors (absent or inadequate data),
and 5 patients under 18 years of age (2 patients aged
Serology 14, 1 patient aged 15, and 2 patients aged 17 years) re-
mained in the study; 409 patients were therefore consid-
The mycoserological investigation required serum and urine sam- ered in the final evaluation.
ples from each patient for fungal diagnostic tests 5 days before the
start of the study (day 11) and at 5-day intervals thereafter. The
samples were examined blind by the mycological reference labora-
tory (Institute for Parasitology and Mycology, University of Frei- Patients
burg, J.Müller); Roche indirect Candida HAT, Roche indirect
IFT, Candida Antigen Test (Candtec, Ramco Lab.), indirect Roche The surgical patients comprised more than 76 % of the
Aspergillus HAT, Cryptococcus Antigen Latex Test. The following group examined and medical patients 24 % (Table 1).
threshold titers were defined as pathognomonic by the mycological
reference laboratory: Candida HAT > 1:160, Candida IFT > 1:80,
The ages of the 246 male (60 %) and 163 female (40 %)
Candida Antigen Test ≥ 1:4, Aspergillus HAT > 1:10. patients ranged from 14 to 88 (median 59) years; none
was neutropenic (granulocytes < 1000/ml) during the in-
vestigation. In 407 patients, the APACHE II score was
Biostatistics between 0 and 39 (median 14) on the day of admission
to the ICU; no assessment was done in 2 cases. The
If not otherwise stated, dependencies among discrete variables MOF score on the study day 1 (day 11 in the ICU) was
were investigated by cross-tables and the chi-square test. Predis-
posing factors for the development of invasive mycosis were stud-
between 0 and 12 (median 3). Of the 409 patients, 95 %
ied by a logistic model which makes it possible to describe the were mechanically ventilated continuously or intermit-
role of one risk factor while adjusting for possible interference tently (87 % medical ICUs vs 98 % surgical ICUs, 1–
from others. Particularly, stratification for center effects is 140 days, mean intubation time 23 days). An operation
320
preceded the ICU stay in 81 % of patients on the surgi- demonstrated mycosis, peritonitis was already docu-
cal wards and in 17 % on the medical wards. This was mented at the time of ICU admission. Two patients sur-
performed between ICU days 2 and 10 in 7 and 14 % of vived the invasive mycosis and had no signs of a sepsis
the patients, respectively, and 5 and 14 %, respectively, during the clinical course. In 1 case, pneumonia findings
first underwent surgery on or after the day 11 (start of concurred with documented Candida sepsis; the pneu-
study). In 96 % of patients, at least one antibacterial monia pathogen was not clarified by bronchoalveolar la-
drug was given, and 34 % were given antimycotical vage or autopsy. The only patient from the medical
drugs.The most frequent clinical findings documented ICUs (chronic myelocytic leukemia, CML; minimally
were bronchitis (59 %), pneumonia (48 %), urinary tract 1700 granulocytes/ml) should be regarded as an excep-
infection (21 %), sepsis (20 %), peritonitis and wound tion to the rest of the group, since multiple organ in-
infection (18 % each), and enteritis/colitis (15 %). volvement with Candida (lung, liver, spleen, myocar-
dium, thyroid, kidney, and choroid plexus) was only
demonstrated by autopsy (previous positive fungal find-
Incidence of invasive mycosis ings in the tracheal secretions and urine). Fungal sepsis
as the expression of a relevant invasive mycosis was
A diagnosis of invasive candidiasis according to the cri- found in 3 of our patients, all of whom had received
teria applied was made in 8 of 408 patients (2 %). In 1 four or more antibiotics before the onset of mycosis.
further case, there was a preexisting invasive mycosis Candida was the only pathogen detected in time in
(confirmed Candida infection and suspicion of addi- blood cultures in 2 patients; a 3rd patient, additionally,
tional Aspergillus involvement); the diagnosis of an in- had polymicrobial findings from the abdominal cavity.
vasive mycosis (4 Candida peritonitis, 3 Candida sepsis, All 3 patients died (1 of septic-toxic circulatory failure,
1 disseminated candidiasis) was based on clinical find- 1 of heart failure, and 1 of MOF).
ings and results of microbiological cultures in 7/8 cases
and on the postmortem findings in 1 case (Table 2). Six
of the 8 patients died in the ICU stay (7, 14, 18, 30, 42, Colonization
and 129 days after the start of the study). Six patients re-
ceived systemic antimycotic therapy with amphotericin Fungal colonization was detected from all media exam-
B and flucytosine (5) or fluconazole (1). Four of the 6 ined in 64 % of the patients (Candida species 56 %, As-
patients on antimycotic treatment died (all receiving pergillus species 4 %, and other fungi 14 %; multiple
amphotericin B + flucytosine), as well as the two pa- sites of entry was possible). If only primarily sterile me-
tients who were not treated. In 6 of the 8 patients with dia are considered, fungal growth was found in 9 %
321
(Candida species 8 %, Aspergillus species < 1 %). Can- Table 3 Sensivity and specificity of serological findings
dida species was most frequently demonstrated in tra- Invasive mycosis Colonization
cheal secretions (36 %), throat swabs (27 %), urine
Sensivity Specificity Sensivity Specificity
(25 %), stool cultures (11 %), and wound swabs (6 %). (%) (%) (%) (%)
Candida was detected to a markedly less extent in aero-
bic (2 %) and anaerobic (1 %) blood cultures, from Candida HAT
> 1 : 160 88 26 79 31
(peritoneal) drainage (4 %) and catheter tips (3 %). All > 1 : 320 75 47 61 56
patients with invasive Candida infection were previ-
Candida IFT
ously colonized. Aspergillus species could only be culti- > 1 : 80 100 6 95 6
vated to an appreciable extent from tracheal secretions > 1 : 160 75 17 86 21
(3 %); in the other media, detection was either < 1 % or Candida AG
no growth at all could be documented. ≥ 1:4 75 48 53 48
In considering the time course of positive fungal de- ≥ 1:8 50 73 28 74
tection, a fairly constant high level was found; after a
slight increase starting on study day 1, the maximal fre-
quency of 47 % from all media was reached on study
days 10 and 15. Positive blood cultures were first de-
tected as of study day 5; urine cultures showed a gradual
increase in frequency up to study day 25.
Serological findings
Table 4 Risk factors for devel- Characteristics Present No. Incidence Odds ratio
oping invasive mycosis of invasive (95 % confidence
mycosis in 0/00 interval)
Peritonitis before day 11 at ICU No 318 6 11.3
Yes 90 67 (2.24 to 56.9)
p = 0.003
Abdominal drainage No 310 7 10
Yes 98 61 (1.99 to 60.6)
p = 0.005
Abdominal diseases/injuries No 305 10 5.14
(incl. neoplasms, no multiple injuries) Yes 103 49 (1.21 to 21.9)
p < 0.03
Gastrointestinal diseases/injuries No 335 9 8.14
(incl. neoplasms, no multiple injuries) Yes 73 69 (1.90 to 34.9)
p < 0.005
cases – means a significantly increased incidence (odds 26 % (39 of 149) of the patients without fungal coloniza-
ratio 11.3; p < 0.05). The presence of further known risk tion (p = 0.26; two-sided chi-square test).
factors, such as diabetic metabolism, hepatic cirrhosis,
and severe renal insufficiency, did not cause a significant
increase in the incidence of mycosis. Consideration of
Discussion
neoplasms also proved to be of no prognostic relevance.
Invasive measures of intensive care medicine (e. g., arte-
rial and central venous catheters, bladder catheters, me-
Prognostic factors for mortality chanical ventilation, etc.) create numerous potential
portals of entry for bacterial and mycotic pathogens. In
The overall mortality during hospitalization was 33 % addition, treatment with a multiplicity of antibiotics
(133/409; including 2 patients who died after transfer leads to germ selection [13]. Both factors cause an iatro-
from the ICU) and was significantly influenced by the genic increase in the predisposition for infections even
following: center, APACHE II score, MOF score on in non-neutropenic ICU patients. Moreover, the under-
study day 1, age, and accompanying illnesses like car- lying disease is usually associated with a poor general
diac insufficiency, hepatic cirrhosis, and diabetes. In the condition. As the stay in the ICU grows longer, an in-
combined multivariate analysis of these features in the crease is observed in fungal detection on mucous mem-
logistic model, the APACHE II score and diabetes lost branes as well as in the urine and blood [18, 20, 21]; the
their significant influence, while the other features re- significance of fungal colonization for the development
tained their importance (model 1 in Table 5). If the un- of a relevant infection and the influence on mortality,
derlying diseases are grouped with reference to the In- however, is still unclear.
ternational Classification of Diseases (ICD) 9 classifica- Based on strict clinical and microbiological criteria,
tion, an influence on mortality was only evident if no ad- the present investigations revealed a low incidence of
justment was made according to the APACHE II or the invasive mycoses in non-neutropenic patients (8 pa-
MOF score (models 2–4 in Table 5). Six of the 8 patients tients with onset after ICU day 11; 2 %, with a 95 % con-
who developed an invasive mycosis with onset after fidence interval of 0.85 to 3.8). These were almost exclu-
ICU day 11 died in the ICU. The patient with preexist- sively patients on the surgical ICUs (7/8); 1 case (CML)
ing mycosis was transferred to a peripheral ward on was a medical ICU patient (total number of surgi-
ICU day 63. Mortality was significantly increased cal:medical patients ∼ 3:1). In clinical investigations,
among patients with invasive mycosis by study day 1 only specific nosocomial clinical entities in connection
compared to the other patients; when all 9 cases of my- with fungi in comparable patient groups or single obser-
cosis were included, the odds ratio was 4.4 (p = 0.038). vations in different ICUs have been reported [14, 15,
The impact of invasive mycosis on mortality was ana- 17]. However, a study from Geneva [30] in adult surgical
lyzed in models 5–10 in Table 5. Each of the models patients reported identical results (1.7 %). The infection
showed a significant increase in mortality related to in- rates vary both between the different hospitals and be-
vasive mycosis. Of 400 patients without invasive myco- tween the wards of individual hospitals. Candida species
sis, 118 died in the ICU (30 %). In 251 patients (63 %), was isolated as an infection-relevant pathogen in all in-
at least one positive fungus culture was detected. Mor- vasive mycoses in our study; this agrees with the data in
tality for these patients was 31 % (79 of 251) versus the literature [13, 31]. A fungal sepsis (monoinfection
323
Table 5 Prognostic factors for Characteristics Evaluated characteristic(s) Odds ratio (95 %
non-survival confidence interval)
p-value
Model 1. Centers, age, MOF (day 11 Age 1.36
in ICU), cirrhosis of liver, diabetes, (1.17 to 1.58)
cardiac insufficiency p < 0.0001
MOF (day 11 at ICU) 1.81
(1.58 to 2.09)
p < 0.0001
Cirrhosis of liver 4.87
(1.50 to 15.8)
p < 0.01
Cardiac insufficiency 2.65
(1.21 to 5.78)
p = 0.015
Diabetes mellitus 1.76
(0.81 to 3.78)
p = 0.15
Model 2. Underlying diseases (grouped Effect of underlying diseases p = 0.019
according to ICD score), centers
Model 3. Underlying diseases (grouped Effect of underlying diseases p = 0.54
according to ICD score), MOF (day 11 at
ICU), centers
Model 4. Underlying diseases (grouped Effect of underlying diseases p = 0.10
according to ICD score), APACHE II
score, centers
Model 5. Invasive mycosis during ICU stay Invasive mycosis 4.39
(p = 0.04)
Model 6. Invasive mycosis during ICU stay, Invasive mycosis 9.3
APACHE II score, centers (p = 0.006)
Model 7. Invasive mycosis during ICU stay, Invasive mycosis 12.2
APACHE II score, centers, age score, (p = 0.005)
cardiac insuff., cirrhosis of liver, renal
diseases, neurologic diseases, neoplasms,
gastrointestinal diseases
Model 8. Invasive mycosis during ICU stay, Invasive mycosis 13.9
MOF (day 11in ICU), centers (p = 0.002)
Model 9. Invasive mycosis, centers, age Invasive mycosis 14.0
score, MOF (day 11in ICU), cirrhosis of (p = 0.0023)
liver, diabetes, cardiac insufficiency
Model 10. Invasive mycosis during ICU Invasive mycosis 20.7
stay, centers, age score, MOF (day 11 (p = 0.0007)
in ICU), cirrhosis of liver, diabetes,
cardiac insufficiency
with Candida species) as the expression of a relevant in- itive blood cultures were only found in 50 % of the pa-
vasive mycosis was found in 3 of our patients. All 3 pa- tients with invasive mycosis can be ascribed to the late
tients died. Not in every case, however, does fungemia dissemination or to the known problems of Candida de-
actually prove to be a disseminated mycosis. It may be tection in blood cultures [34, 35], since circulating fun-
assumed that Candida can be detected in blood (and ur- gus cells are largely caught in the peripheral capillaries
ine) from immunocompetent patients as evidence of a [23]. In the analysis of our study with respect to the risk
temporary asymptomatic fungemia without the exis- of an invasive mycosis, peritonitis by ICU day 11 was as-
tence of a severe mycosis [32, 33]. In 4 patients in our sessed as the prognostically most important factor (odds
study, blood cultures showed a single positive fungus ratio 11.3; p = 0.003), but this could be replaced, with
culture without signs of sepsis. Two patients were trans- only slight informational loss, by factors already recog-
ferred to peripheral wards in improved status. Two pa- nizable on the day of admission: “abdominal disease/in-
tients had ≥ 3 negative blood cultures. The fact that pos- jury” (odds ratio 5.14; p < 0.03) and “gastrointestinal
324
disease/injury” (odds ratio 8.14; p < 0.005). Regarding vestigation of 101 consecutively registered, ventilated
an increase in the risk of mycosis, nonlinear correlations ICU patients (mainly elective heart surgery and medical
must also be expected, since the ICU stay may be pro- emergencies) in Finland [21]. These authors found 16 %
longed in cases with a moderately severe general condi- in tracheal secretions (all Candida growth in tracheal se-
tion but will tend to be short in those in a particularly cretions) and in 8 % in urine 105 colony-forming units/
poor condition and thus a higher mortality. The results ml of urine) and described a correlation between the in-
were confirmed in the logistic model with significant tubation period and microbial colonization. The higher
odds ratios in different stratification models (odds ratios colonization rates we observed could presumably be at-
4.3–24.7). Despite high significance and extreme odds tributed to the different patient groups. An increased
ratios, it must be kept in mind that the interpretation is mortality was observed for colonized (31 %) compared
based on only 8 cases with invasive mycosis. to noncolonized (26 %) patients, but the difference was
Other studies using uni- and multivariate analyses for not significant (p = 0.25; two-sided chi-square test). In
the risk of invasive mycoses in medical and surgical pa- our study, the ICU stay was markedly longer, with a
tients describe different risk factors with varying refer- mean of 33 days, for patients with fungal colonization
ence and significance: previous antibiotic treatments, (identical for nonsurvivors and survivors) than for those
isolation of Candida species in several body regions without colonization (mean 21 days; nonsurvivors
apart from the blood, duration of mechanical ventila- 20 days, survivors 22 days).
tion, previous hemodialysis, use of catheters, azotemia,
transfer from another hospital, diarrhea, and candiduria
[5, 13, 36]. Positive fungus findings from the abdominal Serology
cavity were detectable in another 12 patients in our
study without confirmation of invasive mycosis (only The measurement of so-called significant titers prior to
once vs 2 or more in patients with invasive mycosis); the onset of invasive mycosis may be a helpful indica-
these findings were assumed to be a result of contamina- tion for early recognition and thus initiation of early
tion or suture dehiscence. The generally recognized risk treatment. With the commercially available test proce-
factor “immunosuppression” was less significant in the dures we used and the threshold titers we selected as
present study (odds ratio 1.64; p = 0.65). An explanation pathognomonic (Candida HAT > 1:160, Candida
would be the low proportion of immunosuppressed pa- IFT > 1:80, Candida Antigen Test (Ramco) ≥ 1:4), how-
tients. The immunosuppressed patient group in our ever, this was not possible because of the numerous
study frequently received no systemic antimycotic pro- findings that were false-positive according to the defini-
phylaxis and had only a negligible increased incidence tion. Determination of the Aspergillus HAT for diagno-
compared to the rest of the patients. sis of an invasive aspergillosis appears to be unimpor-
tant in the presence of a low specificity (threshold titers
1:10; specificity 29 %); this agrees with the reports of
Colonization other investigators [22, 37].
Clinical findings and relevant culture results must
Fungal colonization in our study was of a higher order of therefore continue to form the basis for the diagnosis
magnitude at 43 % in tracheal secretions and 28 % in ur- of invasive mycosis and initiation of antimycotic therapy
ine (largely Candida species in each case) then in the in- in non-neutropenic ICU patients.
References
1. Horn R, Wong B, Kiehn TE, Armstrong 3. Meunier-Carpentier F, Kiehn TE, Arm- 6. Schaberg DR, Culver DH, Gaynes RP
D (1985) Fungemia in a cancer hospital: strong D (1981) Fungemia in the immu- (1991) Major trends in the microbial
changing frequency, earlier onset and nocompromised host: changing pattern, etiology of nosocomial infection. Am J
results of therapy. Clin Infect Dis 7: antigenemia, high mortality. Am J Med Med 91[Suppl 3B]:72s–75s
646–655 71: 363–370 7. Rex JH, Bennett JE, Sugar AM, Pappas
2. Beck-Sague CM, Jarvis WR (1993) The 4. Richet HM, Andremont A, Tancrede C, PG, van der Horst CM, Edwards JE,
national nosocomial infections surveil- Pico JL, Jarvis WR (1991) Risk factors Washburn RG, Scheld WM, Karchmer
lance system: secular trends in the epi- for candidemia in patients with acute AW, Dine AP, Levenstein MJ, Webb
demiology of nosocomial fungal infec- lymphocytic leukemia. Clin Infect Dis CD, Candidemia Study Group (1994)
tions in the United States 1980–1990. J 13: 211–215 A randomized trial comparing flucon-
Infect Dis 167: 1247–1251 5. Wey SB, Mori M, Pfaller MA, Woolson azole with amphotericin B for the treat-
RF, Wenzel RP (1988) Hospital-ac- ment of candidemia in patients without
quired candidemia: the attributable neutropenia. N Engl J Med 331: 1325–
mortality and excess length of stay. 1330
Arch Intern Med 148: 2642–2645
325
8. McGowan JE Jr (1985) Changing etiol- 17. Emmerson AM (1990) The epidemiol- 27. SAS Institute (1989) SAS/STAT user’s
ogy of nosocomial bacteremia and fun- ogy of infections in intensive care units. guide, 4th ed, vol 2, Version 6
gemia and other hospital-acquired in- Intensive Care Med 16 [Suppl 3]:S197– 28. Kalbfleisch JD, Prentice RL (1980) The
fections. Clin Infect Dis 7[Suppl S200 statistical analysis of failure time data.
3]:S357–S370 18. Garvey BM, McCambley JA, Tuxen DV Wiley, New York
9. Bodey GP (1966) Fungal infections (1989) Effects of gastric alkalization on 29. Stone HH, Kolb LD, Currie CA, Ge-
complicating acute leukemia. J Clin Ep- bacterial colonization in critically ill pa- heber CE, Cuzzell JZ (1974) Candida
idemiol 19: 667–687 tients. Crit Care Med 17: 211–216 sepsis: pathogenesis and principles of
10. Hart PD, Russell E Jr, Remington JS 19. Füssle R, Biscoping J, Michaelis G, Zei- treatment. Ann Surg 179: 697–711
(1969) The compromised host and in- ler D, Sziegoleit A (1991) Intensive care 30. Pittet D, Monod M, Suter P, Frenk E,
fection: II. deep fungal infection. J In- patients: a high risk population for Can- Auckenthaler R (1994) Candida coloni-
fect Dis 120: 169–189 dida infections. Clin Intensive Care 2: zation and subsequent infections in crit-
11. Sandford GR, Merz WG, Wingard JR, 76–80 ically ill patients. Ann Surg 220: 751–
Sarache P, Saral R (1980) The value of 20. Füssle R, Biscoping, Zeiler D, Michae- 758
fungal surveillance cultures as predic- lis G, Sziegoleit A (1990) Mikro- 31. Gaines JD, Remington JS (1972) Dis-
tors of systemic fungal infections. J In- biologische Betreuung von beatmeten seminated candidiasis in the surgical pa-
fect Dis 142: 503–509 Intensivpatienten: Möglichkeiten für tient. Surgery 72: 730–736
12. Wenzel RP, Osterman CA, Donowitz Diagnostik und Therapie von pulmo- 32. Bodey GP, Anaissei EJ (1989) Chronic
LG, Hoyt JW, Sand MA, Martone WJ, nalen Infekten. Anästh Intensivther systemic candidiasis. Eur J Microbiol
Peacock JE Jr, Levine JI, Miller GB Jr Notfallmed 25: 491–496 Infect Dis 8: 855–857
(1981) Identification of procedure-re- 21. Pellinen TJ, Valtonen VV, Luomanmäki 33. Gemeinhardt H, Deicke P (1989)
lated nosocomial infections in high-risk K, Sivonen A, Virtanen KS (1983) The Mykosen des Gefässsystems. In: Ge-
patients. Clin Infect Dis 3: 701–707 microbial colonization due to medical meinhardt H (ed) Endomykosen. Gus-
13. Maki DG (1989) Risk factors for noso- devices in intensive care patients with tav Fischer, Stuttgart pp 327–329
comial infection in intensive care – de- special emphasis on C. albicans. Ann 34. Bennett JE (1978) Diagnosis and man-
vices vs. nature and goals for the next Clin Res 15: 62–65 agement of candidiasis in the immuno-
decade. Arch Intern Med 149: 30–35 22. Burnie JP (1991) Developments in the suppressed host. Scand J Infect Dis
14. Craven DE, Kunches LM, Lichtenberg serological diagnosis of opportunistic 16[Suppl]:63–67
DA, Kollisch NR, Barry A, Heeren fungal infections. J Antimicrob Che- 35. Klein JJ, Watanakunakorn C (1979)
TC, McCabe WR (1988) Nosocomial mother 28 [Suppl A]:23–33 Hospital-acquired fungemia: its natural
infections and fatality in medical and 23. Müller J (1990) Laboratory diagnosis of course and clinical significance. Am J
surgical intensive care unit patients. deep-seated candidosis. Mycoses 33 Med 67: 51–58
Arch Intern Med 148: 1161–1168 [Suppl 1]:7–13 36. Bross J, Talbot GH, Maislin G, Hurwitz
15. Daschner F (1985) Nosocomial infec- 24. Müller J, Kappe R, Kubitza D, Fessler S, Storm BL (1989) Risk factors for
tions in intensive care units. Intensive R, Scheidecker I (1987) The incidence nosocomial candidemia: a case control
Care Med 11: 284–287 of deep-seated mycoses in Freiburg im study in adults without leukemia. Am J
16. Chandrasekar PH, Kruse JA, Mathews Breisgau. Mycoses 31[Suppl 1]:9–28 Med 87: 614–620
MF (1986) Nosocomial infection among 25. Knaus WA, Draper EA, Wagner DP, 37. Young RC, Bennett JE (1971) Invasive
patients in different types of intensive Zimmermann JE (1985) APACHE II: aspergillosis: absence of of detectable
care units at a city hospital. Crit Care a severity of disease classification sys- antibody response. Am J Respir Crit
Med 14: 508–510 tem. Crit Care Med 13: 818–829 Care Med 104: 710–716
26. Goris RJA, te Boekhorst TPA, Nuy-
tinck JKS, Gimbrere JSF (1985) Multi-
ple-organ failure. Arch Surg 120: 1109–
1115