Identificación de Tendencias en Las Mediciones de La Calidad de La Energía

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Trend Identification in Power Quality Measurements

Max Domagk, Olga Zyabkina, Jan Meyer, Peter Schegner


Institute of Electrical Power Systems and High Voltage Engineering
Technische Universitaet Dresden
max.domagk@tu-dresden.de

Abstract— Power quality (PQ) levels in public low voltage grids on PQ levels as well. Subsequently, PQ levels in public LV
are influenced by many factors like type of connected customers, grids will vary over time. Beside daily, weekly and seasonal
level of distributed generation or climatic conditions. In particular, variations, long-term variations are also possible e.g. due to
type and number of the connected electronic equipment have a the introduction of new device technologies (like LED lamps)
significant impact on PQ levels. Therefore, the introduction of new on a large scale which normally needs several years. Slow
device technologies on a large scale, like the transition from changes over a number of years are also referred to as trend.
incandescent to LED lamps, might result in long-term changes to According to the time series theory shorter time intervals like
the levels of PQ parameters (e.g. harmonics). Major aims of the one year only are strictly spoken tendencies. In order to avoid
paper are the identification and quantification of long-term trends
confusion this paper will always use the term ‘trend’. The
in time series of continuous PQ parameters which can support
network operators with the early detection of fundamental changes
detailed analysis of trends can be an added value of long-term
in PQ levels. This information can e.g. support the asset measurement campaigns and enables early identification of a
management or network planning in managing PQ levels using possible increase or decrease of PQ levels and can result in
optimized costs. The paper begins with a systematic overview of proactive and punctual actions example in asset management.
major factors with impact on PQ levels and continues with a Up to now only few papers about trends in continuous PQ
classification of their typical variation behavior (short-term, parameters exist (e.g. [1-3]). Other papers like [4] cover
medium-term and long-term). The analysis of the long-term
discontinuous PQ parameters. In most cases linear regression
behavior (trend) starts with the extraction of a smoothed trend
is applied without any pre-processing. This paper aims to
component based on time series decomposition. This trend
component is used to quantify global trends (looking on the
provide a contribution to comprehensive and efficient analysis
measurement duration as a whole) and local trends (looking on of trends in continuous PQ parameters.
individual segments of the whole time series). Finally, the
application of both methods is illustrated for selected voltage and II. IMPACT FACTORS ON POWER QUALITY
current quality parameters using a set of three year measurements The different impact factors on power quality are either
from German LV grids with different consumer configuration. allocated to the electrical or to the non-electrical environment.
The electrical environment includes all factors directly related
Index Terms—Power quality, harmonics, regression analysis, time to type and number of devices connected to the grid and the
series analysis, time series decomposition grid elements itself [5]. The non-electrical environment
includes all factors having additional impact, in particular on
I. INTRODUCTION the usage behavior (e.g. climatic conditions) or penetration
Power quality (voltage and current quality) in public low ratio of electric devices.
voltage (LV) grids varies depending on location and time. It is
quantified by a set of different parameters which either are A. Electrical environment
events (discontinuous parameters like dips) or variations The factors of electrical environment at the measurement
(continuous parameters like harmonics). This paper site can be divided into three different groups [6]. The
exclusively addresses variations which provide continuous consumer configuration describes the amount and type of
time series. PQ levels are mainly influenced by the number consumers connected to the grid which is directly linked to
and type of equipment connected to the LV grid which is type and number of disturbing devices. The generation
closely linked to the behavior of the connected customers (e.g. configuration describes number, type and rated power of the
opening hours of shopping centers) as well as to the behavior generating installations connected to the grid. Most of the
of connected generating installations (e.g. PV production installations utilize inverters (e.g. in PV installations) which
during the day). Variations of network impedance can be can emit e.g. harmonics. The network configuration includes
caused for example by switching state changes of the network all factors directly related to the grid. The factors are closely
(e.g. one vs. two transformer operation) which have an impact linked to the short circuit power which determines the voltage

978-1-4799-8725-2/15/$31.00 ©2015 IEEE


quality levels for a given current emission. Sites with low increased use of equipment like illumination and subsequently
short circuit power mostly occur in rural areas whereas sites results e.g. in higher emission of harmonics. The generated
with higher short circuit power are commonly located in urban energy of PV installations in Germany is significantly higher
areas. during summer months (longer days, higher angle of
insolation). The impact of the network configuration can be
B. Non-electrical environment caused by different e.g. switching states of the grid during the
The non-electrical environment distinguishes also between different seasons. A more detailed methodology for the
three groups. The climatic characteristic like temperature or analysis of seasonal variations can be found in [6].
global irradiation can considerably affect type and number of This paper focuses on the identification of long-term
devices in use. On cloudy/rainy days or in case of early variations which are usually quantified by trends. Slow
nightfall due to seasonally changing sunset times more changes in PQ levels can be caused by the large scale
equipment like illumination is expected to be used. Sunny replacement of classical by new device technologies (e.g.
days lead to higher power production by the generating replacement of incandescent lamps by LED lamps) or the
installations. The social characteristic includes among others introduction of new types of devices like electrical vehicle
the spending power which determines if a customer can afford chargers. Depending on the interaction with the existing
the most advanced electronic equipment or not. Finally, devices (level of cancellation) this can result in either
economic factors can also impact PQ levels. For example if increasing or decreasing PQ levels, like harmonics [7]. Fig. 2
the price for energy supplied by distributed generation slightly illustrates an increasing trend behavior for the 7th harmonic
increases at a certain time a lot of units might be start feeding voltage measured in building with 26 offices and two shops.
energy into the grid at high coincidence. This was already Within the measurement interval an almost steady increase of
observed in Germany with micro combined heat power the emission levels from 1.1 % up to 1.6 % is observed.
systems (micro-CHP).
IV. DATASET FOR ANALYSIS
III. TYPES OF VARIATIONS
This study analyses voltage and current quality parameters
Variations of PQ parameters with different time periods for RMS, individual harmonics of order 3, 5, 7 and 9. In terms
mainly exist due to the impact of the electrical environment. of distortion, the voltage THD and the total harmonic current
This section provides a short summary of the different types of THC are analyzed.
variations which can be classified as shown in Fig. 1. More
details can be found in [5]. 50

short-term medium-term long-term


THC THD ˜ I (1) ¦ I
h 2
(h) 2
(1)
(days to weeks) (weeks to months) (months to years)
Due to the variation of the fundamental current the use of
vir tually low low to medium THC is more robust. It represents the total harmonic current
network

content independent of changes of the fundamental current


config.

none (different swit- (changes in net-


ching states work operation/ magnitude. As common in many standards, for each parameter
of the grid) configuration) the 95th percentiles of the 10-min-mean values for every week
are calculated. This eliminates the always existing short-term
high medium to high medium variations from the data which are not of interest for the trend
generation
impact of

config.

(daily generation (seasonal impact (global change analysis in this study. In order to represent the three major
behavior) on generation to newer
behavior) technologies)
consumer configurations at different sizes the sites:
Residential areas (R):
high medium to high medium
x R1 - multi-family houses with 337 flats
consumer
config.

(daily consumer (seasonal impact (global change


behavior) on consumer to newer x R2 - multi-family houses with 111 flats
behavior) technologies) x R3 - multi-family houses with 96 flats
x R4 - single-family houses with 63 houses
Figure 1. Classification of variation types and major impact factors in x R5 - single-family houses with 16 houses
public LV grids (based on [2])
Shopping centers (S):
Short-term variations are usually characterized by daily x S1 - electronic market and restaurants
and weekly intervals. These cycles are mainly influenced by x S2 - electronic market
the consumer and generation behavior. Certain consumer Office building (O):
configurations, like offices, show distinctive different daily x O1 - a building with 26 offices and 2 shops
patterns for current quality parameters (e.g. working days vs.
weekends). have been selected. The measurement duration amounts to at
least three years per site and varies between 173 weeks and
Medium-term variations over time periods of several 201 weeks. Due to the dominating share of single-phase
months are related to more general changes in consumer and devices and their random distribution to the phases each phase
generation behavior which are mostly linked to seasonal (L1, L2 and L3) is considered separately.
effects [5]. Early nightfall during winter months can lead to an
Figure 2. 7th harmonic voltage; 95th percentiles of the 10-min-mean values Figure 3. 3rd harmonic voltage; 95th percentiles of the 10-min-mean values
for 184 weeks from April 2011 to October 2014; site O1; phase L1; time for 173 weeks from July 2011 to October 2014; site R5; phase L1; time
series (gray) and smoothed trend component (black) series (gray) and smoothed trend component (black)

V. METHODOLOGY OF TREND IDENTIFICATION variation is assumed with 52 weeks, the span ns is set to
ns = 53. Based on recommendations in [10] the span for
As a first step of the proposed methodology the time series smoothing the trend component is set to nm = 83. It should be
of 95th percentiles has to be pre-processed. Therefore, an noted that for the application of the method a time series has
exponential smoothing using the STL method (seasonal and to consist of at least two periods of the expected seasonal
trend decomposition using locally-weighted regression) [10] is component which equals two years for this application.
applied in order to extract the trend component. For further
processing of the trend component a ‘global’ and a ‘local’ Fig. 2 exemplarily presents the 7th harmonic voltage of site
trend are introduced. While the ‘global’ trend characterizes O1 (office building). The time series shows only small
longer time intervals of three years or more (commonly the seasonal variations but a steady increase in the emission levels
whole measurement interval), the ‘local’ trend characterizes from 1.1 % to 1.6 %. The increasing trend is more clearly
only a part of the measurement interval between half a year recognized by the smoothed trend component (black trace).
and one year. Both trends are quantified by indices which are Fig. 3 presents the 3rd harmonic voltage of site R5 (residential
introduced in the following subsections. area). A seasonal variation with higher emission levels during
the weeks in winter season can be identified clearly. This
A. Pre-processing seasonal variation is efficiently removed in the smoothed trend
The additive component model for time series consists of component (black trace). The smoothed trend component itself
different components to address each type of variation does not show any significant increase or decrease during the
introduced in cp. III [8]. This method is also applied in [4] but considered time interval of 173 weeks.
for voltage sags only. In general, a time series x is modelled
B. Global trend identification
by four components (cf. to Fig. 1): a cyclic component c
(short-term variations), a seasonal component s (medium-term In order to obtain information about an existing global
variations), a trend component m (long-term variation) and the trend a linear function is fitted to the smoothed trend
residual component u which contains the part that cannot be component of the whole measurement interval:
explained by the other components. By reason of the use of
t
the weekly 95th percentiles the cyclic component is removed m D E˜ (3)
and the simplified model contains only three components: 52
x m s u (2) The parameters are obtained by using a simple least
squares approach which minimizes the sum of squared errors
STL is a robust method to decompose a time series into a (SSE):
smoothed trend component m, a seasonal component s and a
rest component u. STL provides still accurate results in ­
°n § t · ½
2
°
presence of changing seasonal components and/or outliers and SSE(Dˆ , Eˆ ) min ®¦ ¨ mi  D  E ˜ i ¸ ¾ (4)
D ,E
°i 1 ©
¯ 52 ¹ ¿°
is therefore more suitable than the classic decomposition [9].
It is based on LOESS (locally-weighted regression) which is a
special form of exponential smoothing. LOESS is used to The estimated parameters D̂ (intercept) and Eˆ (slope) per
estimate non-linear relationships [10]. The smoothing mainly year are used to calculate a gain value:
depends on the smoothing window span that is used for Eˆ
LOESS. g . (5)

In principle, STL applies LOESS two times in order to
smooth the time series and to extract the seasonal and the The gain g is independent of scale, can be compared
trend component. The user has to specify two window spans, between different PQ parameters and is used to quantify the
one for the smoothing of the seasonal component ns and one global trend. Based on the sign, increasing or decreasing
for the smoothing of the trend component nm. The span n of trends can be easily identified. The absolute value |g| measures
the window determines the number of local data points used the magnitude of the trend. Based on experiences of the
by LOESS and has to be odd. As the period of a seasonal authors, a significant trend exists for gain values |g| > 5 % per
Figure 4. 3rd harmonic current; 95th percentiles of the 10-min-mean values Figure 5. 7th harmonic current; 95th percentiles of the 10-min-mean values
for 201 weeks from January 2011 to October 2014; site R1; phase L1; time for 184 weeks from April 2011 to October 2014; site O1; phase L1; time
series (gray), smoothed trend component (black); last 4 half year segments series (gray), smoothed trend component (black); last 4 half year segments
are marked, color indicates trend (red: increasing; blue: decreasing) are marked, color indicates trend (red: increasing; blue: decreasing)

year. The gain of +10 % per year for the smoothed trend whole measurement interval. Based on the estimated
component in Fig. 2 indicates a strong increase whereas the parameters the gain g is calculated for each segment according
gain of -3 % per year in Fig. 3 represents a negligible decrease to equation (5).
which cannot be considered as trend at all.
For the examples in Fig. 4 and Fig. 5 the gain values of the
Even if the gain indicates the presence of a trend the local trend are listed in Table I and Table II respectively. Both
significance of this information can be different. In case of examples contain seven segments S1 to S7 whereas the last
Fig. 2 the variation of the original time series is small in four are indicated in the Figures. The gain values for the 7th
comparison to the magnitude of the trend itself. Fig. 3 shows harmonic current (Table II) show positive gains with small
an opposite behavior. The slightly decreasing trend is overlaid variation. Even if the last two segments show a slight decrease
by a distinctive seasonal variation. Even if the trend would of the gain the trend is still significant and consistent. This
amount -5% instead of -3% it would be less significant result confirms the result of the global trend analysis (g =
compared to Fig. 2. As first and simple approach to quantify +10% per year). For the example in Table I (Fig. 4) the global
the significance of the trend, the span s is introduced which is trend is g = +21% per year (at a span of 68%) but only the
calculated by local trend reveals that after a fast increase in segments S6 and
S7 the last three segments show a slight decrease again. This
max( xtrend )  min( xtrend ) relaxation of the trend cannot be identified from the global
s (6)
max( xoriginal )  min( xoriginal ) trend. As both global and local trend analysis show advantages
and disadvantages the local trend information is deemed to be
where xtrend is the smoothed trend component and xoriginal is the more important information for the network operator.
the original time series. The higher the span s the better is the
significance of a possibly identified trend. For the example in
Fig. 2, the span is 55 %, for the example in Fig. 3 it amounts TABLE I. GAIN FOR EACH HALF YEAR SEGMENT OF THE SMOOTHED
TREND COMPONENT FOR THE 7 HARMONIC CURRENT IN FIG 4
TH
to only 29 %. Based on experiences of the authors, a span
higher than 40% indicates a good significance. Only in case
that the gain per year is higher than 5% and the span is higher Segment S7 S6 S5 S4 S3 S2 S1
than 40 %, a global trend is identified in the time series of a Gain g / % +3 +17 +27 +9 -2 -4 -4
PQ parameter. It should be noted that the span criteria may fail
under certain circumstances and more suitable and robust
indices (e.g. based on SSE) are under development.
GAIN FOR EACH HALF YEAR SEGMENT OF THE SMOOTHED TREND COMPONENT
FOR THE 3 HARMONIC CURRENT IN FIG 5
RD

C. Local trend identification


The global trend considers only an averaged, general Segment S7 S6 S5 S4 S3 S2 S1
direction of the change and may hide trend developments
Gain g / % +6 +3 +4 +8 +4 +2 +2
within shorter time intervals. Hence, the global trend for the
example in Fig. 4 is increasing by about g = +20%. The last 80
weeks of the measurement interval show a continuous By analyzing the individual segments it becomes possible
decrease of the smoothed trend component. The global trend to detect, if a PQ parameter changes from an increasing to a
completely hides this behavior and additional information on decreasing trend or vice versa. Based on the consistency of the
local trends can be important for network operators to avoid trend (e.g. of the recent four segments) a risk index could be
misinterpretation of global trends. derived for the network operator. The local trend might also
The quantification of the local trend is based on a be updated on a weekly base which allows network operators
segmentation of the measurement interval. Half a year seems to get updated information more frequent than twice a year.
to be a suitable segmentation length for PQ parameters. However, it should be noted that a minimum measurement
Similar to the global trend identification, a linear regression is interval of two years is still required.
applied but now to each individual segment instead on the
Figure 6. Time series with an significant global Figure 7. Time series with an global trend for Figure 8. Time series with an significant global
trend for the 3th harmonic voltage (blue) and the 7th harmonic voltage (blue) and current (red) trend for the 9th harmonic voltage (blue) and
current (red) (R: residential, O: office, S: shop) (R: residential, O: office, S: shop) current (red) (R: residential, O: office, S: shop)

VI. APPLICATION RESULTS between phases and therefore multiple occurrences of one site
mean that a global trend was identified for more than one
A. Global trend phase. The 3rd and 9th harmonic show increase rates of up to
For each of the 288 time series of 95th percentiles (8 sites, +20% , the highest increase is observed for the 7th harmonic in
12 PQ parameters, 3 phases) gain and span have been one phase of site R1 with +30%. While for the 3rd and 7th
calculated automatically. Only those time series meeting the harmonic current has mostly higher gains than the 3rd and 7th
criteria |g| • 5 % per year and span s • 40 % were selected harmonic voltage the 9th harmonic shows an opposite
for further analysis. Table III provides a summary of the behavior. Significant global trends are identified for 29 % and
identified global trends. It should be noted that each phase the harmonic voltage for 38 % of the measurements. The
counts individual (cf. section IV). For instance the 2 shops measurement in O1 shows increasing global trends for the 9th
with 3 different phases result in a total amount of 6 time harmonic voltage and current in all three phases. The
series. In case of voltage quality, less than 10% of the time harmonic currents increase by about g = +10 % per year
series show an increasing global trend, whereas only 3% show steadily from 10 A up to 14 A within four years. The
a decreasing global trend. Trends are only identified for the corresponding harmonic voltages shows a gain of +16 % per
3rd, 7th and 9th harmonic voltage. For current quality year and increases from 0.3% up to 0.5 %.
parameters more global trends have been identified. About B. Local trend
15% of the time series show increasing global trends while
decreasing global trends are observed for about 13% of the If the gains calculated for all individual segments of a time
time series. Looking on the individual phases per site an series do not vary too much, the trend within the whole
interesting behavior is observed for some residential sites. measurement interval is consistent and the analysis of the
While most of the PQ parameters in one phase decrease by up global trend is reliable and sufficient (cf. to Table I). Sudden
to -15% the same PQ parameters increase by up to +20% in increases or decreases lasting only a few segments cannot be
another phase. detected by the global trend and can even exist if no global
trend is identified at all. Such local variations are important
As most of the global trends in voltage and current quality information for the network operators. A simple but efficient
parameters are observed for 3rd, 7th and 9th harmonic, a more index to quantify the level of local trend variations is the range
detailed quantitative analysis is carried out by using the Rg of the segment gains. As the gain is already scale-
gain/span plots in Fig. 6 to Fig. 8. The plots do not distinguish independent the absolute range can be used without further
TABLE II. NUMBER OF TIME SERIES WITH SIGNIFICANT INCREASING
OR DECREASING GLOBAL TREND (+/-); NUMBER IN BRACKETS NEXT TO
CONSUMER CONFIGURATION (R: RESIDENTIAL, O: OFFICE, S: SHOP)
INDICATES THE TOTAL NUMBER OF AVAILABLE TIME SERIES (PHASES
MULTIPLIED BY SITE NUMBER IN THE RESPECTIVE CONFIGURATION)

VOLTAGE QUALITY PARAMETERS:


+/- RMS THD U(3) U(5) U(7) U(9)
R (15) 0/0 0/0 2/4 0/0 0/0 6/0
O (3) 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 2/0 3/0
S (6) 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0
CURRENT QUALITY PARAMETERS:
+/- RMS THC I(3) I(5) I(7) I(9)
R (15) 0/1 3/4 2/3 3/4 4/1 2/0
Figure 9. Cumulative distribution function of range of local trends
O (3) 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 3/0 3/0 separated for voltage (blue) and current (red) quality paramters
S (6) 0/0 0/1 1/0 0/1 0/2 1/1
Figure 10. Variation range Rg of segment gains vs. its average for the 9th Figure 11. 9th harmonic current; 95th percentiles of the 10-min-mean values
harmonic current; color indicates wether a global trend was identifed (red) for 174 weeks from July 2011 to October 2014; site R5; phase L2; time
or not (blue) (R: residential, O: offices, S: shops) series (gray), smoothed trend component (black) and half year
segmentation, color indicates trend (red: increasing; blue: decreasing)

pre-processing. Fig. 9 presents the cumulative distribution that about 50% of the time series have gain variations within
functions for all 288 segmented time series separated by half-year segments of more than 10%. Furthermore, the
voltage and current quality. As expected, the time series of variation of the segment gains (local trends) is an efficient
current quality parameters show generally higher gain indicator for the consistency and reliability of a respective
variations than those of voltage quality parameters. Whereas global trend. Ongoing research is especially dedicated to the
gain variations less than 5% are negligible attention should be development of more robust indices and easy-to-interpret,
paid to gain variations higher than 10% to 15%. An easy to aggregated risk indicators. For local trend analysis all segment
interpret risk index could be derived based on the definition of gains are updated with each additional segment. The impact of
adequate ranges which qualifies the volatility of the segment this characteristic on the result interpretation is also addressed.
gains.
In order to analyze time series with high gain variations in ACKNOWLEDGMENT
more detail plots as shown in Fig. 10 can be used. The Figure The authors wish to thank the German Research
for the 9th harmonic current exemplarily proves that high gain Foundation (Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft - DFG) for
variations have not necessarily to be detected by the global funding this project.
trend analysis. The respective time series and smoothed trend
component at R5 are shown in Fig. 11. Even if the absolute REFERENCES
current magnitude is low and not worrying at all the example
[1] H.M.S.Chandana Herath, S. McHardy, “Power Quality Trends in
illustrates the importance of local trend analysis. The strong Energy Australia Distribution Network”, 13th International Conference
increase within the first 100 weeks (S4-S6) and the subsequent on Harmonics and Quality of Power (ICHQP), 2008.
decrease in segments S1 and S2 can only be analyzed and [2] S. Elphick, V. Smith, V. Gosbell, R. Barr, “The Australian Long Term
identified by the local trend information. Power Quality Survey Project Update”, 14th International Conference
on Harmonics and Quality of Power (ICHQP), 2010.
[3] M. Benedikt, „Koordinierte Messreihen zur Spannungsqualität im
VII. CONCLUSION
Rahmen des VEÖ“ (Systematic voltage quality measurements in
The paper provides a methodology to analyze trends in Austria) VDE Kongress, ETG Fachtagung Versorgungsqualität, 2008.
long-term measurements of PQ parameters. As more and more [4] E. A. Mertens, L. F. S. Dias, F. A. Fernandes, B. D. Bonatto, J. P. G.
Abreu, and H. Arango, “Evaluation and trends of power quality indices
network operators run long-term PQ measurement campaigns,
in distribution system”, 9th International Conference on Electrical
trend analysis can give valuable information in addition to the Power Quality and Utilisation, EPQU, 2007.
weekly reporting. Beside the early detection of possible [5] J. Meyer, P. Schegner, and G. Eberl, “Increasing the Reliability of
fundamental changes in PQ parameters it will be useful for Indices for Power Quality Assessment in Distribution Networks”, 13th
planning purposes. The method is based on time-series of International Conference on Harmonics and Quality of Power
weekly calculated 95th percentiles and can be applied to any (ICHQP), 2008.
[6] M. Domagk, J. Meyer, and P. Schegner, “Seasonal Variations in Long-
continuous voltage or current quality parameter. In the first Term Measurements of Power Quality Parameters”, IEEE Conference
step the STL method is used to decompose the time series and PowerTech, 2015.
extract the smoothed trend component. Global trend and local [7] A. Gil-de-Castro, S. Ronnberg, M. H. J. Bollen, A. Moreno-Munoz,
trend are quantified based on several indices like the gain g and V. Pallares-Lopez, “Harmonics from a domestic customer with
representing the scale-independent change within a defined different lamp technologies”, 15th International Conference on
Harmonics and Quality of Power (ICHQP), 2012.
time interval. While the global trend considers the time series [8] R. H. Shumway and D. S. Stoffer, Time Series Analysis and Its
as a whole which should have at least three years Applications, vol. 2. Springer, 2006.
measurement data the local trend analysis divides the whole [9] S. Makridakis, S. C. Wheelwright, and R. J. Hyndman, Forecasting:
measurement into half year segments which are individually methods and applications, 3. ed. Wiley, 1998.
analyzed. The analysis of long-term measurements at 8 [10] R. Cleveland and W. Cleveland, “STL: A seasonal-trend decomposition
procedure based on loess,” Journal of Statistical Software, vol. 6, no. 1,
different sites has shown considerable global trends
pp. 3-73, 1990.
(increasing as well as decreasing) in more than 10% of the [11] W. Cleveland and S. Devlin, “Locally weighted regression: an
time series. An annual gain |g| > 5 % is used to identify the approach to regression analysis by local fitting,” Journal of the
significance of a global trend. The local trend analysis shows American Statistical Association, vol. 83, no. 403, pp. 596–610, 1988.

You might also like