Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Road Condition Monitoring Using On-Board Three-Axis Accelerometer and GPS Sensor
Road Condition Monitoring Using On-Board Three-Axis Accelerometer and GPS Sensor
net/publication/254054046
CITATIONS
READS
53
1,762
5 authors, including:
Mingming Lu
Xiaopeng Fan
Central South University
Chinese Academy of Sciences
54 PUBLICATIONS 1,161
CITATIONS 42 PUBLICATIONS 222 CITATIONS
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Xiaopeng Fan on 26 October 2015.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.
2011 6th International ICST Conference on Communications and Networking in China (CHINACOM)
Kongyang Chen1, Mingming Lu1,2, Xiaopeng Fan1, Mingming Wei1, and Jinwu Wu3
1
Shenzhen Institutes of Advanced Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences,Shenzhen, 518055, China
2
Central South University, Changsha, 410083, China
3
Shenzhen Transportation Depot Group, Shenzhen, 518040, China
Email :{ky.chen, lumm, xp.fan, mm.wei}@siat.ac.cn, wujw@sz95000.com
Abstract—A study by US Federal Highway Administration has considered to be disqualified. In China, the road condition
shown that road condition is an essential factor of highway level is classified into four levels, according to Technical
quality and smooth roads will lead to more comfortable driving Code of Maintenance for Urban Road CJJ36-2006, which is
experience and less municipal investment. International one of the most important industry standards [20]. Current
Roughness Index (IRI) has been widely used to measure equipment used in measuring road condition is surveyed in [4],
pavement smoothness because it can provide a consistent rating which is composed by accelerometers, distance measuring
for different measurement tools. However, existing measuring instruments, graphic displays or something other instrument.
tools based on IRI are usually very expensive. In this paper, we
But these road condition systems are much too expensive,
present a low-cost vehicle-based solution, Road Condition
which cost 8,000 to 220,000 dollars. Therefore, these methods
Monitoring with Three-axis Accelerometers and GPS Sensors
(RCM-TAGPS), by using a cheap three-axis accelerometer and a are too costly to be adopted in the whole urban district.
GPS sensor embedded in a vehicle to monitor the road condition. Different statistic metrics: Pavement roughness [5] is one
We analyze the Power Spectral Density (PSD) of pavement of the most important performance metrics of road condition,
roughness, estimate IRI, and classify the pavement roughness and it can evaluate whether the driving is comfortable and
level into four levels according to a Chinese industry standard. safety or not. Power Spectral Density (PSD) is the frequency
Experimental results show that RCM-TAGPS can evaluate characteristic of pavement roughness in the vehicle industry
pavement roughness level correctly, even under some
and academia [6]. Moreover, International Roughness Index
interference like potholes, manholes and decelerating belts, and
the total cost of RCM-TAGPS in each vehicle is no more than 50
(IRI) is another important metric, which was firstly adopted by
dollars, which is about 1/4400 to 1/160 of the existing system used the World Bank in the 1980s, and then widely used for
in civil engineering and municipal engineering. evaluating the pavement roughness [7-8]. Therefore, one of
our objectives in this paper is to find out the relationship
Keywords-Road condition monitoring; three-axis acclerate sensor; between PSD and IRI, in order to evaluate pavement
Power Spectral Density(PSD); International Roughness Index(IRI); roughness comprehensively.
pavement roughness level.
This paper describes the design, implementation and
experimental evaluation of a road condition monitoring
I. INTRODUCTION system, namely Road Condition Monitoring with Three-axis
Road condition monitoring [1-3] is a challenging problem Accelerometer and GPS Sensor (RCM-TAGPS). Each vehicle
in the field of road transportation infrastructure all over the is embedded with a three-axis accelerometer and a GPS sensor
world. A zone in bad condition may damage the vehicles on it, when traveling around the road to be monitored. Each vehicle
endanger the drivers, and even cause accidents. City also collects the information of three-axis acceleration and
municipalities have spent millions of dollars to maintain and velocity with a high frequency. We then estimate PSD and IRI
repair these roadways. However, it is still a challenging of the pavement roughness, based on these data on
problem to keep these roadways in good condition. accelerations and velocity. Finally, we classify the actual road
condition into four different levels according to Technical
Expensive road monitoring system: City municipalities Code of Maintenance for Urban Road CJJ36-2006; in order to
are much concerned with global roughness information of a provide useful suggestions for road maintenance.
certain road, because the whole road would be repaired if it is
In section II, we provide an overview of the system
This work was partially supported by the National Natural Science architecture of RCM-TAGPS. In section III, we describe the
Foundation of China under Grant No.60903222, the National S&T details of data collection by three-axis accelerometers and GPS
Major Project of China under Grant No.2009ZX03006-001-01, sensors. In section IV, we discuss a novel pavement roughness
Guangdong S&T Major Project under Grant No.2009A080207002 level algorithm based on PSD and IRI. We present the
and the National High Technology Research and Development evaluation of RCM-TAGPS in section V. Finally, we conclude
Program of China (863 Program) under Grant No. 2011AA010500 this paper in section VI.
103
s
esti ⎧ 2S( ) i
' f
mat
⎨ S ( ) t(4)
ed ⎩ y
fro 0 0
m f f
the
r
foll
owi 0 o
ng a normal stationary random m
equ Figure 3. The process in the time domain.
atio continuous three-axis t
n: accelerations According to the Wiener- h
1 Khintchine theorem [14-16], thee
E[x(t)] lim x(t)dt
(3) IV. PAVEMENT
following equations are
composed of a couple of Fouriern
ROUGHNESS
t
LEVEL transform: e
As demonstrated by Eq. 1, S ALGORITHM g
is the In this section, we present a
( bilateral our pavement roughness level t
Power algorithm. The definition and i
) solution of Power Spectral v
e
Spe Density (PSD) are described
ctralin Part A. Then we introduce
f
Denthe International Roughness
r
sity Index (IRI) and describe how
e
(BP to calculated IRI by PSD in
Part B. According to the q
SD)
u
. Chinese industry standard, the
e
Ho classification for pavement
n
wevroughness levels is presented
as a function of IRI in Part C. c
er,
y
onlyFinally, we propose the
the details of the pavement
t
singroughness level algorithm in
Part D. o
le
Pow
t
er A. Power Spectral Density
h
Spe (PSD) e
ctral Power Spectral Density
Den(PSD) is one of the most
p
sity important metrics of o
(SP pavement roughness, which is
s
SD) wildly used in the vehicle
i
is industry and academia. t
use Compared with other metrics,
i
d inPSD demonstrates the v
the frequency characteristic of
e
engipavement roughness, reflects
neerthe amplitude of roughness,
f
ing and also shows the excitation
r
proj energy under frequency e
ects variation [12-13].
q
.
Experimental results show u
The
e
refo that pavement roughness can
n
re, be modeled as a Gaussian
c
we distribution with zero mean
and isotropic random y
cha
nge character around the vibration
a
the source in the spatial domain.
s
specBased on the stochastic
tral process theory, pavement
f
den roughness can be described as
o
103
where S ' () is the SPSD of highway safety research D. Algorithm framework correlation function will
pavement roughness. institute (HDRI). The framework of our produce the PSD. The third
pavement roughness level step is carried out by the
However, it is still
Specially, if 0 , difficult to realize the algorithm is illustrated in IRI analyzer. Roughness
we can deduce Eq.5 Figure 4. standard deviation and IRI
definition and the quarter
from Eqs.1~4 as are calculated. The fourth
car model. As discussed The first step is data
follows: step is the classification of
above, PSD can easily be collection, including the pavement roughness levels.
estimated by the Fourier data from three-axis
R(0) E[x 2 (t)] We calculate RQI and
transformation of the accelerometers and GPS classify 0 pavement
temporal auto- correlation sensors. The second step
S ( )d S ' roughness into four levels.
function. Hence, we aim is carried out by the PSD
to find out the Figure 4.Pavement roughness
( )d relationship between IRI
analyzer. The auto-
level algorithm framework
and PSD, so that we can
B. International obtain IRI easier. Here,
Roughness Inedex (IRI) the roughness standard IRI
0.013 (9 V. EVA
International deviation is considered as 0 ) LUA
Roughness Index (IRI), the intermediate variable. . TIO
5 N
adopted by the World Firstly, we analyze
Bank in the 1980s, is 9 This section presents
the relationship of PSD 2 the evaluation of RCM-
the most widely used and the roughness
metric that is used to 6 TAGPS. The experiment
standard deviation. Based setting, including the road
evaluate pavement on the probability and
roughness in highway C. Pavement condition and the
statistics theories, the roughness level placement of our sensors, is
transportation agencies. relationship between the
IRI is defined as the classification described in details in Part
standard deviation and
responses of the quarter the expectation can be
car model [17-18] at a described as follows:
speed of 80km/h,
where the vehicle 2 E2 x(t) E ⎡⎣ x2
parameters are
recommended by the (t) ⎤⎦
As the vehicle vibration Nanjing have been carried out
can be modeled as a by the Ministry of A. Our
The pavement roughness evaluation standards listed in
Gaussian distribution with Communications Highway levels can be classified
zero mean and isotropic Scientific Research Institute Table I.
according
random character [12], we since 1990s [19]. The to the Technical Code of
can infer that the regression analysis results Maintenance for Urban Road TABLE I. EVALUATION
expectation is approximate show that the relationship CJJ36- 2006 [20], which is STANDARDS FOR PAVEMENT ROUGHNESS
LEVEL
to zero. Hence, the standard between IRI and the one of the industry standards
deviation can be simplified roughness standard deviation in the People's Republic of v(km/h) RQI
as follows: can be approximated by the China.
following regression Pavement
2 E ⎡⎣ x 2 (t) ⎤⎦ equation: This industry standard
shows that pavement
roughness level is evaluated RQI>
by Riding Quality Index 3.6
Combined with Eq.5,
(RQI), which is a
the relationship between the
comprehensive metric of excell
standard deviation and
driving comfort. The ent
SPSD are described as
relationship between RQI and
follows:
IRI is described as follows:
RQI = 4.98-0.34×IRI
0 S ' ()d The range of the value of RQIs
Secondly, we analyze varies from 0 to 5 normally.
the relationship between We set RQI to 0 if the value
IRI and roughness standard calculated is negative.
deviation. Finally, we classify
As we know, contrast pavement roughness into four
experiments on pavements levels, including excellent,
at Beijing, Changchun, and good, qualified and
unqualified, with the
103
pavement roughness experiments. The three- of drives, and collected data B. Evaluation
level algorithm is axis accelerometer is by the experimental vehicles
implemented based on attached to the right side equipped with RCM-TAGPS We clean the raw data
the data from field of dashboard, so that it in urban area of Beijing. The with our data cleaning
experiments in Part B. can approach the traces contain continuous algorithm, including outlier
Experimental results vibrations of the driving acceleration and GPS data. removal, data interpolation
are discussed and vehicle as far as possible. Here, the acceleration consists and so on. It is noted that
presented in Part C. Furthermore, we need of about 100 raw readings per the average velocity of our
place the three-axis second, while the GPS data is experimental vehicles is
accelerometer in a special produced once per second, as normally around 40 km/h
A. Experimental setting
direction, where its X- described in Section III. because the heavy traffic in
As mentioned urban area.
above, RCM-TAGPS axis is with the same
depends on the accurate direction as the driving Figure 6 shows the
signals like direction, its Y-axis in the continuous three-axis
acceleration and corresponding horizontal accelerations against the
velocity. As a result, direction and the Z-axis sampling points on various
the accelerometers and in the corresponding road types. Specially,
GPS sensors must be vertical direction. Figure 6(a) demonstrates
correctly placed so that However, the GPS sensor three-axis acceleration on
the acquired is fixed to the left front smooth roads, while the
information is exact. windshield in the lateral others on general roads,
Figure 5 shows the part of the vehicle, to roads with some potholes,
placement of these obtain real-time signals in roads with some manholes,
sensors in our urban area. and roads with some
decelerating belts
v 3.0<RQI<3.6 separately.
>
8 2.5<RQI<3.0
0
0<RQI<2.5
Experim
2.2<RQI<2.6
v ental
< 0<RQI<2.2
4 setting
0
of
sensors
To evaluate the
pavement roughness
level comprehensively
and effectively, we
collect data from actual
roads with various
characters, including the sands or stones, (III) roads
following types: (I) smooth with some potholes, (IV)
roads where the segments roads with some manholes,
of road surface are (V) roads with some
considered smooth, (II) decelerating belts.
general roads where there
We carried out hundreds
are small particles such as (a) smooth roads (b) general
103
roads (c) roads r
with some potholes
o
a
(d)
d
r
s
o
d w
s i
h
w
t s
h o
e
s
m d
e e
e
m
l
a
e
n
r
h
a
o
t
l
i
e
n
s
g
103
b e
e -
l a
t x
s i
i a
g c
u c
r e
e l
r
6
a
.
t
i
T
o
h
n
e
s
c
o
o
n
n
t
v
i
a
n
r
u
i
o
o
u
u
s
s
t
r
h
o
r
a
e
103
d
6.81 2.66 qualified
r
t a
t
y i
n
p
g
e
b
s e
l
t
s
TABL
E
P
ENT
ROUGH
NESS
LEVEL
S OF
VARIO
US
ROAD
TYPES
As discussed in Section III, we implement our pavement
2.88
good
roads with potholes
12.33 0.79
unqualified
roads with manholes
8.24
2.18
unqualified
road Ta roads with
type bl decele-
s are e
liste II.
d in
104
C. Experiment results REFERENCES
Experimental results of RCM-TAGPS are discussed as [1] J. Eriksson, L. Girod, and B. Hull, etc. “The Pothole Patrol: Using a
follows. Mobile Sensor Network for Road Surface Monitoring”, 6th International
Conference on Mobile Systems, Applications, and Services (MobiSys
The Z-axis accelerometer should be more concerned. 2008), Breckenridge, USA, June, 2008, pp. 29-39.
During the experimental drives, the X-axis is with the same [2] R. Bishop, “A survey of intelligent vehicle applications worldwide”,
direction as driving, while the Y-axis and the Z-axis are in the IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium (IV 2000), Dearborn, MI, USA,
May, 2000, pp. 25-30.
horizontal and vertical direction respectively. Obviously, the
[3] X. Chu, and Y. Wu, “Desigend on the low cost system framwork of road
Z- axis has a more prominent waveform on rough pavement, conditon recgonition based on roadside multi-sensoers”, Asia-Pacific
which should be investigated with priority. Confernce on Information Precessing (APCIP 2009), Guangdong, China,
July, 2009, pp. 173-176.
As illustrated in Figure 6(a), when driving on smooth [4] J. Budras, A synopsis on the current equipment used for measuring
roads, the acceleration data are very smoothly with only small pavement smoothness. http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/pavement/smoothness/
fluctuations, so that the overall road condition is outstanding. rough.cfm, August, 2001.
[5] L. Sun, “Optimum design of road-friendly vehicle suspension systems
We infer from Figure 6(b) that there are some subjected to rough pavement surfaces”, Applied Mathmatical Modelling,
instantaneous large pulses in the Z-axis acceleration on general 2002, vol. 26, pp. 635-652.
roads. It might be aroused by small particles or other [6] L. Sun, and T. Kennedy, “Spectral analysis and parametic study of
interferences on the road, and the overall road condition is stochastic pavement loads”, Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 2002,
considered to be good. vol. 128, pp. 318-327.
[7] Y. Zhang, and R. Ma, “A study of pavement roughness measurement
Figure 6(c) shows the acceleration data sampled with system based on laser ranger finder”, International Conference on Image
continuous small potholes. The acceleration data are with great Analysis and Signal Processing (IASP 2009), Zhejiang, China, April,
fluctuations, and we deduce that the vehicles vibrated strongly 2009.
when passing by these potholes. The road condition is [8] J. Dyer, D. Dyer, and J. Devore, “Estimating International Roughness
Index from noisy profilograph measurements”, International
unqualified in general. Instrumentation and Measurement Technoloty Conference (I2MTC
Figure 6(d) indicates the acceleration data sampled with 2009), Singapore, May, 2009.
some manholes, which is much similar to Figure 6(c). The [9] R. Hostettler, W. Birk, and M. Nordenvaad, “Surface mounted vehicle
property sensing for cooperative vehicle infrastructure systems”, 16th
acceleration data are also with great fluctuations, and the road ITS World Congress and Exhibition on Intelligent Transport Systems
condition is unqualified. and Services, Stockholm, Sweden, September, 2009.
From Figure 6(e), we find there is a large pulse at certain [10] Y. Qing, A. Lim, and P. Agrawal, “GPSFR: GPS-free geographic
routing protocol for intelligent vehicles”, International Conference on
points in the Z-axis acceleration when passing by several Comunications and Networks in China (Chinacom2006), Beijing, China,
narrow decelerating belts. The road condition is considered to October, 2006, pp. 1-8.
be qualified in spite of these disturbances. [11] A. Thiagarajan, L. Ravindranath, and K. Lacurts, etc. “VTrack: accurate,
energy-aware road traffic delay estimation using mobile phones”, 7th
ACM Conference on Embedded Networked Sensor Systems (SenSys
VI. CONCLUSION 2009), Berkeley, California, USA, November, 2009, pp. 85-98.
This paper describes the design, implementation and [12] L. Sun, “Simulation of Pavement Roughness and IRI Based on Power
experimental evaluation of a road condition monitoring Spectral Density”, Mathematics and Computers in Simulation, 2003, vol.
61, pp. 77-88.
system, which is called RCM-TAGPS. RCM-TAGPS uses
[13] D. Xu, A. Mohamed, and R. Yong, etc. “Development of a criterion for
mobile vehicles embedded with a three-axis accelerometer and road surface roughness based on power spectral density function”,
a GPS sensor to collect the data of three-axis acceleration and Journal of Terramechanics, 1992, vol. 29, pp. 477-486.
velocity with a high frequency. We clean the sampling raw [14] W. Gardner, "A sampling theorem for nonstationoary random process",
data with our clean algorithm, including outlier removal, data IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, 1972, vol. 18, pp. 808-809.
interpolation and so on, to deal with technical challenges like [15] L. Cohen, “Generalization of the Wiener-Khinchin theorem”, IEEE
unavailable GPS and transmission error. Then we analyze the Signal Processing Letters, 1998, vol. 5, pp. 292-294.
Power Spectral Density (PSD) of pavement surface roughness, [16] A. Fung, “A note on the Wiener-Khintchine theorem for
estimate the International Roughness Index (IRI), and classify autocorrelation”, Proceedings of the IEEE, 1967, vol. 55, pp. 594-595.
the pavement roughness levels into four levels according to the [17] T. Semiha, and A. Huseyin, “A study of random vibration characteristics
of the quarter-car model”, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2005, vol.
Technical Code of Maintenance for Urban Road CJJ36-2006. 282, pp. 111-124.
Finally we evaluate RCM-TAGPS with actual driving in urban [18] C. Dodds, and J. Robson, "The description of road surface roughness",
area of Beijing. Experimental results show that RCM-TAGPS Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1973, vol. 31, pp. 175-183.
can evaluate the pavement roughness level correctly, even [19] S. Lou, Y. Wang, and C. Xu, “Study of calculation of IRI based on
with some interference like potholes, manholes and power spectral density of pavement surface roughness”, Journal of
decelerating belts. Furthermore, RCM-TAGPS consumes no Highway and Transportantion Research and Development, 2007, vol. 24,
more than 50 dollars in total, which is only 1/4400 to 1/160 of pp. 12-15.
these existing systems [4] with a cost of about 8,000 to [20] Y. Shucong, Technical Code of Maintenance for Urban Road CJJ36-
2006, Beijing, China Architecture & Building Press, 2006.
222,000 dollars. Therefore, RCM-TAGPS is more likely to be
widely used in municipal engineering.
1037