Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Eve 20 10 Ferrucci - EVE - 20 10
Eve 20 10 Ferrucci - EVE - 20 10
Case Report
Bacterial pneumonia and pleuropneumonia in sport horses:
17 cases (2001–2003)
F. FERRUCCI*, E. ZUCCA, C. CROCI, V. DI FABIO, P. A. MARTINO† AND E. FERRO
Department of Veterinary Clinical Sciences, Unit of Equine Internal Medicine; and †Department of Veterinary
Pathology, Hygiene and Public Health, Unit of Microbiology, University of Milan, Italy.
Keywords: horse; pneumonia; pleuropneumonia; aerobic bacteria; rate of recovery
history of poor performance, recurrent fever, coughing and/or cytological evaluation, a few drops of TW were centrifuged at
nasal discharge. For each patient the investigations listed 22.68 g for 5 min (Rotofix 32)6. The slides were air-dried,
below were performed. stained with May Gruenwald-Giemsa and with Gram stain and
observed at 400x and 1000x for differential count. In Cases 2
Physical examination and 14, the presence of a large amount of pleural fluid
necessitated the daily aspiration of fluid, by means of a human
After taking the history, a thorough physical examination of thorachocentesis device with atraumatic trochar7. For each
respiratory and cardiovascular systems was performed. sample of TW, and pleural fluid obtained by ultrasound guided
thoracocentesis in Cases 2, 12 and 14, 100 µl were inoculated
Laboratory evaluation onto blood agar plates (with 5% sheep blood)8 under
microaerophilic atmosphere and 100 µl under an anaerobic
A venous blood sample was collected from the left jugular atmosphere (GasPak Plus)9, both for 48 h at 37°C. After the
vein into vials containing sodium citrate for plasma fibrinogen incubation time, the colonies were identified using
concentration and EDTA for complete blood count. Plasma macroscopic and microscopic characteristics: haemolysis, size,
fibrinogen concentration was determined with an Iris pigmentation, positivity or negativity to the Gram stain, and
photometer1. Complete blood count was performed with an CFU count. For the identification, selective media (MacConkey
automated Technicon H12. For blood gas analysis 1.5 ml of agar, mannitol salt agar, cetrimide agar) and miniaturised
arterial blood were anaerobically collected from the right biochemical system (API System)10 were also used.
carotid artery with a heparinised syringe and immediately Antimicrobial susceptibility tests were performed according to
processed with an IL 1630 analyser3. For each sampling, the the standardised agar diffusion tests (Kirby-Bauer test) (Poli
rectal temperature of the patient was determined to et al. 2005) with antimicrobials used in equine medicine.
automatically adjust blood gas parameters. Arterial blood
oxygen and carbon dioxide partial pressures (pO2 and pCO2) Results
were determined. In a few horses (Cases 1, 2 and 8 in which
R. equi was cultured) serology for equine viral arteritis (EVA) At the time of referral, rectal temperature ranged from
and equine herpesvirus-1 (EHV-1) as well as serum protein 37.5–40.3°C (mean: 38.3 ± 0.8°C), heart rate from
electrophoresis were performed. 32–48 beats/min (mean: 38 ± 5.4 beats/min) and respiratory
rate from 12–24 breaths/min (mean: 18.8 ± 5.6 breaths/min).
Thoracic ultrasonography and radiography Coughing was present in 16 horses (94.1%) and a bilateral
mucopurulent nasal discharge was observed in 12 horses
To visualise the pleural and pulmonary surfaces, all intercostal (70.5%). Eleven horses (64.7%) had enlarged intermandibular
spaces (from 4th to 17th) of both sides were scanned in a lymph nodes. Red blood cell counts ranged from 5.91–
dorsoventral direction with a 5.0 MHz sector transducer 11.01 x 1012/l (mean: 7.64 ± 1.20 x 1012/l); 11 horses (64.7%)
(Technos MPX)4. In 14 horses, radiographs of the ventrocaudal had leucocytosis, ranging from 11.37–26.20 x 109/l (mean:
and dorsocaudal lung fields were obtained. 15.01 ± 4.59 x 109/l) and relative neutrophilia was observed in
12 horses (mean: 77.65 ± 6.16%). Plasma fibrinogen
Endoscopy and tracheal aspirate concentration was elevated (>2.50 g/l) in all patients, and
ranged from 3.05–8.08 g/l (mean: 5.068 ± 1.618 g/l). Blood
Endoscopy of upper and lower airways was performed with a gas analysis showed the presence of hypoxaemia (paO2
fibreoptic endoscope (Olympus CF30L)5, previously cleaned <90 mmHg) in 7 horses (41.1%), with paO2 ranging from
and disinfected with a glutaraldehyde solution (Olympus ETD3, 77–89 mmHg (mean: 84.3 ± 4.6 mmHg), while all animals
automatic washer)5. The nasal cavities, pharynx, guttural were normocapnic (paCO2 mean: 42.6 ± 1.8 mmHg). In Cases
pouches, larynx, trachea, carena and main bronchi were 1, 2, and 8 the antibody titres for EHV-1 were 1:48, 1:16 and
sequentially visualised and scored. Particularly, pharyngeal 1:64 respectively. In the same horses, no antibody titre was
lymphoid hyperplasia was graded 0 to IV according to Baker detected for EVA. Serum protein electrophoresis showed a
(1987), tracheal mucopus was graded 0 to V according to mild to strong elevation in the gamma-globulin fraction in all
Gerber et al. (2004) and the lower airways were subjectively cases (20.8, 51.4 and 26.5 g/l, respectively)
scored 0 to IV by the authors (0: normally sharp carena; I: little In all patients, ultrasonography of the chest showed
mucosal swelling of the carena and main bronchi; II: moderate heterogeneous variably extended portions of consolidated
mucosal swelling; III: marked mucosal swelling; IV: severe hypoechoic lung parenchyma (Fig 1) in which disseminated
mucosal swelling). Tracheal aspirate was performed during hyperechoic areas and fluid bronchograms were often
endoscopic examination, by flushing into the intrathoracic observed. These findings were consistent with pneumonic
portion of the tracheal lumen 60 ml of sterile saline at 37°C, lesions, mucopurulent and/or gaseous collections, and
through a sterile indwelling catheter previously introduced into presence of fluid into the bronchial lumen. In some cases,
the biopsy channel of the endoscope. Tracheal wash fluid (TW) hepatisation of the lung parenchyma was observed. Single or
was aspirated with a sterile 60 ml syringe and transferred into multiple pneumonic lesions were localised in the right side of
sterile tubes for submission to the laboratory. To perform the chest in 6 horses (35.3%) and in both sides in the other
528 EQUINE VETERINARY EDUCATION / AE / october 2008
11 horses (64.7%). In the majority of cases, the lesions collection. Endoscopy allowed the identification of pharyngeal
involved the medio-ventral portion of the lung. In 3 horses lymphoid hyperplasia in all patients, ranging from grade II to
(Cases 2, 12 and 14) ultrasonography showed the presence of grade IV, which involved in some cases the guttural pouch
anechoic fluid and hyperechoic fibrin in the pleural space, mucosa. Within the tracheal lumen a variable degree of
bilaterally (Fig 2). In 2 patients (Cases 2 and 14) the collection mucopus was always present: grade II in 2 horses, grade III in
was large and the fluid line reached approximately the level of 14 horses and grade IV in one horse. Tracheobronchial mucosa
the supraglenoid tubercle of the scapula. Thoracic radiography was hyperaemic and there was oedema of the carina and
revealed, in the areas of pulmonary parenchyma main bronchi, ranging in grade from II to IV. Tracheal aspirate
corresponding to the lesions shown by ultrasonography, an cytology showed neutrophilia with degenerated neutrophils
increase in radio-opacity, with irregular and ill-defined margins (kariolysis and kariorexis), often (11 horses, 64.7%) with active
(Fig 3) and presence, in some cases, of air bronchograms. The phagocytosis of cocci and/or rods (Fig 4). Coccobacilli
remaining portion of lung parenchyma often showed an phagocytised by alveolar macrophages were identified in
increase in bronchial and interstitial pattern. In pleural effusion Cases 1, 2 and 8. Neutrophilia ranged from 68–100% of the
cases, the presence of fluid resulted in an intense, diffuse differential count with a mean value of 91 ± 8%. Cultural and
opacity - that prevented the visualisation of lung parenchyma sensitivity test results are shown in Table 1.
details - which extended dorsally to the upper limit of the According to the above mentioned procedures, a
diagnosis of bacterial pneumonia in 14 cases and of bacterial
pleuropneumonia in 3 cases, was made.
TABLE 1: Bacteria isolated from TW and administered antibiotics according to sensitivity test results
Legends: 1antibiotic replaced due to occurrence of antibiotic-resistance; 2pleuropneumonia; 3estolate salt; 4Prescott 1997; *Metronidazole
administered (15 mg/kg bwt per os q.i.d.).
Antimicrobial therapy, lasting an average of 45 days presence of a large amount of pleural fluid necessitated the
(30–60 days), was established according to sensitivity test daily aspiration of 4–8 l of fluid until remission (Fig 5). A total
results (Table 1) and was suspended only after 2 successive of 81 l were aspirated from Case 2 and 25 l from Case 14. In
negative tracheal washes. In Cases 12, 14 and 17, breath and Case 12, the small amount of fluid identified with
tracheal exudate malodour suggested the possible presence of ultrasonography, spontaneously regressed after
anaerobic bacteria and metronidazole, at a dosage of pharmacological treatment. During the course of treatment
15 mg/kg bwt per os q.i.d., was administered in association serial tracheal washes were performed at weekly intervals in
with the antimicrobial selected for bacteria isolated in order to rule out the occurrence of antibiotic-resistance. In 4
microaerophilia. Antimicrobial treatment was adjuvated by cases (Cases 2, 6, 8 and 13) it was necessary to change the
inhalatory administration of bronchodilators (Ipratropium antibiotic (Table 1). After the end of antimicrobial treatment,
bromide, 3 µg/kg bwt b.i.d. or t.i.d. with an aero mask), a period of rest of 60 days was recommended for all patients.
immunomodulators (α-interferon, 50 iu per os s.i.d.) and, to After discharge, follow-up information was collected for
control hyperthermia and inflammation, flunixin meglumine all horses, by phone enquiry or, for Standardbred horses, by
(1.1. mg/kg bwt i.v. s.i.d. or b.i.d.). In Cases 2 and 14, the consulting the internet site www.anagt.it. Eleven horses
(64.7%) returned to racing satisfactorily, whereas the other
6 horses (35.3%) were retired from competition (Cases 1, 2, 5,
12, 14 and 17).
Discussion
(Di Fabio et al. 2002). In all patients, the association of microbial culture was balanced by the possible reduction in
different diagnostic imaging procedures (ultrasonography, costs of prolonged ineffective antimicrobial treatment with
radiography, endoscopy) allowed precise identification of the expensive drugs such as ceftiofur or amikacin.
localisation and extension of pneumonic lesions, and the Amongst the 6 horses that did not return to racing,
presence of fluid in pleural spaces (Chaffin et al. 1994b). The Cases 2 and 14 had severe pleural effusion, in which the
procedures were also helpful for monitoring patients during clinical remission of pleuropneumonia was not associated with
treatment, allowing evaluation of the regression of sufficient recovery of lung function. In the other 4 cases (1, 5,
pulmonary lesions and the decrease in the pleural fluid. Daily 12 and 17), whose owners were unwilling to allow
thoracocentesis with an atraumatic trochar was preferred to hospitalisation during treatment, the unsatisfactory functional
an indwelling thoracic catheter for several reasons: this recovery could be related to short duration of antibiotic
system allows slow drainage of pleural effusion to prevent treatment or insufficient monitoring during the course of the
possible collapse ex vacuo due to excessively rapid emptying disease. Additionally, Cases 1 and 2 had R. equi infection,
of the thoracic cavity; it prevents contamination of the which could be related to immune system dysfunction.
thoracic cavity due to the indwelling catheter and the The high rate of horses returning to racing activity (64.7%)
possible occurrence of pneumothorax. The procedure was suggests that prolonged antibiotic treatment, associated with
easy to perform and well tolerated by the patients. intensive monitoring of the patient, may have enhanced the
The bacterial species isolated and their prevalence complete functional recovery in those cases that were not
substantially agree with that reported for aerobic bacteria in complicated (i.e. pleural effusion and/or R. equi infection).
horses (Sweeney et al. 1991; Chaffin and Carter 1993; Lakritz Therefore, the presence of such complications, may have had
et al. 1993; Lavoie et al. 1994; Raidal 1995; Carr et al. 1997; to be considered as negative prognostic factors.
Racklyeft and Love 2000; Vengust et al. 2002; Waldridge et al.
2008). In particular, the 3 cases in which R. equi was cultured Acknowledgements
(Cases 1, 2 and 8) could have been immunodeficient.
Although the immune status of these patients was not The authors wish to acknowledge Prof. Mauro Di Giancamillo
thoroughly evaluated, serum protein electrophoresis showed a and Mr Gilberto Panigada, Section of Radiology, Department
mild to strong elevation in the γ-globulin fraction (20.8, 51.4 of Veterinary Clinical Sciences, University of Milan, for
and 26.5 g/l, respectively), which suggests normal B cell performing thoracic radiography in this group of patients.
function, and the leucogram, showed low monocyte count
(0.08, 0.05 and 0.07 x 109/l, respectively), suggestive of Manufacturers’ addresses
possible dysfunction in phagocytic activity. These results agree 1Sclavo Diagnostics International, Sovicille, Italy.
with those reported by Vengust et al. (2002) and Waldridge 2Bayer, Leverkusen, Germany.
et al. (2008), although in their cases there was a mild 3Instrumentation Laboratory UK Ltd, Warrington, Cheshire, UK.
4Esaote Biomedica, Genova, Italy.
leucopenia and also a decrease in lymphocyte count, which 5Olympus, Tokyo, Japan.
we did not observe in our horses, who had leucocytosis (11.3, 6Hettich Cyto System, Bäch, Switzerland.
26.2 and 12.6 x 109/l, respectively) and normal to elevated 7GTA Medical Product, Quistello, Italy.
8Oxoid, Milan, Italy.
lymphocyte count (5.4, 5.3 and 3.8 x 109/l, respectively). We 9Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, New Jersey, USA.
hypothesise that this difference could be related to the 10bioMérieux, Marcy l'Etoile, France.