Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SHENAAZ Surgical Chronicles - Final Version
SHENAAZ Surgical Chronicles - Final Version
subsequent multi-system organ failure. Thus, a information was required (regarding receipt of social grants
multidisciplinary team approach is required to manage these and prosthesis and methods of ambulation post LLA),
conditions thereby decreasing the risk of death from other patients were contacted telephonically and responses
comorbidities [13]. recorded. The study outcomes were determined from
In general for those with non-traumatic amputations patient discharge summaries. Data was entered and
there is a decline in health status following the procedure managed using the Microsoft Excel programme.
with five year mortality rate as high as 77% [14]. Statistical Analyses
Management should be directed towards preserving Baseline variables were summarized as follows: percentages
functional status of individuals and minimizing long term for categorical variables, and mean or median for continuous
care and institutionalization. Maintenance of ambulation; be variables. The age variable was categorized as follows: <20
it limb salvage or prosthesis is a key determinant associated years, 20-24 years, 25-49 and ≥50 years. Due to the small
with maintaining independence of individuals. The sample size (n=206) and lack of an appropriate comparison
procedure for attaining prosthesis in South Africa is a group, the study was not powered to test for statistical
complicated one, with lack of resources and adequately associations and only descriptive statistics are presented as
trained prosthetic staff being important factors to consider per the study protocol. Data were analyzed with SAS
[14]. statistical package version 9.4 (SAS Institute, Inc., Cary).
Ambulation after major lower limb amputation has not Ethical approval
been well researched. Studies are required to evaluate the The study was approved by the Biomedical Research Ethics
various preoperative characteristics and postoperative Committee of the University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa
functional outcomes to design management (Protocol BE501/15).
recommendations for patients requiring major LLA [9].
“Patients with limited preoperative ambulation, age >70, Results
dementia, end-stage renal disease (ESRD) and advanced Demographic characteristics
coronary artery disease (CAD) perform poorly and should be The study population comprised 206 patients (Table 1). The
categorized with patients who are bedridden”. These median age of patients was 60 years old (interquartile range
patients are best managed with a palliative above knee [IQR]: 50-69 years). Just over half (n=105; 50.9%) of patients
amputation (AKA). Younger, healthy patients with a below were female. The predominant ethnicities in the study
knee amputation (BKA) have good functional outcomes population were Black African (n=96; 46.6%) and Indian
comparable to those who have had lower limb (n=82; 39.8%), with whites comprising a relatively small
revascularization [15], [16], [13]. This study aims to audit proportion of the study population (n=10; 4.9%). Most
major LLA and mobility of patients post major LLA at a patients had emergency (n=191; 92.7%), guillotine BKAs
regional hospital in Durban, South Africa. (n=157; 76.2%). Twelve patients had elective procedures
namely revision of the amputation stump, the primary
Patients and methods procedure being a guillotine amputation done prior to the
Study design, population, and setting period of data collection. Information on time to revision of
A retrospective clinical audit was conducted. All adult the stump from initial procedure was not available from
patients (≥18 years old) who underwent primary, non- hospital records analyzed.
traumatic unilateral lower limb amputations (LLA) between Comorbidities were documented as per Figure 1 below.
1st January 2011 and 31st December 2012 at the Addington Diabetes mellitus and hypertension were the most prevalent
Hospital in Durban, South Africa were included in the study. comorbidities in the study population (prevalence of 74.3%
We specifically studied primary unilateral AKA, BKA and [153/206] and 49.5% [102/206] respectively). 33.5%
through knee amputation (TKA) as these LLA procedures are (69/206) had both diabetes mellitus and hypertension.
the most commonly performed and have been associated Among Black African patients: prevalence of hypertension
with high postoperative mortality in other settings [17] [18]. was 44.8% (43/96) and diabetes mellitus was 68.8% (66/96).
Addington Hospital is a 571-bed regional hospital and offers Prevalence of hypertension and diabetes mellitus among
various general specialist services, including surgical Indian patients was higher at 57.3% (47/82) and 82.9%
services. Generalist surgeons performed the amputations (68/82) respectively. Among White patients, prevalence of
according to standardized surgical protocols at Addington hypertension was 50.0% (5/10) and diabetes mellitus 80.0%
Hospital. (8/10).
Data collection
Eligible patients were identified from theatre logs and
electronic patient records at the hospital over the two-year
study period. Data on demographic characteristics (age,
gender, ethnicity); preoperative comorbidities (diabetes
mellitus, hypertension, coronary artery disease, chronic
kidney disease and occlusive vascular disease); and
procedural characteristics (urgency of procedure, level of
amputation, duration of surgery and duration of hospital
stay) were collected for each patient. Where additional
2
Shenaaz I., et al Surg Chron 2019; 24(2): 64-69.
Category Distribution
Age in years <20 1.5% (3/206)
20-24 1.5% (3/206)
25-49 20.8% (43/206)
≥ 50 72.8% (150/206)
Missing information 3.4% (7/206)
Gender Female 50.9% (105/206)
Male 48.1% (99/206)
Missing information 1.0% (2/206)
Ethnicity Black 46.6% (96/206)
White 4.9% (10/206)
Indian 39.8% (82/206) Figure 2: Distribution of duration of procedure by amputation
Missing information 8.7% (18/206) type. AKA: above knee amputation, BKA: below knee
Type of Above knee 23.3% (48/206) amputation and TKA: through knee amputation
amputation amputation
Below knee 76.2% (157/206) Duration of Hospital Stay
amputation
Through knee 0.5% (1/206)
The overall length of hospital stay had a median of 13 days
amputation (IQR: 10-15 days). The median duration of hospital stay for
Type of procedure Emergency 92.7% (191/206) patients who underwent AKA and BKA was similar: 13 days
Elective (Revision of 5.8% (12/206) (IQR: 8-15 days) and 13 days (IQR: 10-15 days) respectively.
the stump) Only one patient had a TKA and length of hospital stay was
Missing information 1.5% (3/206)
21 days (Figure 3).
Peripheral Vascular… 34
Hypertension 102
AKA [27]. We also found that patients who received a 5. Sumpio BE. Contemporary evaluation and management of the diabetic
foot. Scientifica 2012; 2012: 17
prosthesis following AKA were younger compared to BKA
6. Hennion DR, Siano KA. Diagnosis and treatment of peripheral arterial
prosthesis recipients suggesting that these patients were disease. American Family Physician 2013; 88: 306-310.
more likely to have a better overall functional state and 7. Apelqvist J, Larsson J. What is the most effective way to reduce
therefore able to cope with an above knee prosthesis. incidence of amputation in the diabetic foot? Diabetes/Metabolism
Research and Reviews 2000; 16: S75-S83.
Our study had strengths and limitations. A strength of
8. Basu NN, Fassiadis N, McIrvine A. Mobility one year after unilateral
this study is that we present data from a South African lower limb amputation: a modern, UK institutional report. Interactive
setting. This is important as findings from developing Cardiovascular Thoracic Surgery 2008; 7: 1024-1026.
countries and African settings are not well described in the 9. Barnes R, Souroullas P, Lane RA, Chetter I. The Impact of Previous
Surgery and Revisions on Outcome after Major Lower Limb
literature. A limitation of this study is that it was a
Amputation. Annals of Vascular Surgery 2014; 28: 1166-1171.
retrospective study from a single regional facility, with 10. Godlwana L, Nadasan T, Puckree T. Global trends in incidence of lower
limited numbers of patients. We could not explore findings limb amputation: A review of the literature. South African Journal of
related to wound healing and morbidity related to LLA as this Physiotherapy 2008; 64: 8-12.
11. Peacock JM, Keo HH, Duval S et al. Peer Reviewed: The Incidence and
data was not available from the records used. Similarly, data
Health Economic Burden of Ischemic Amputation in Minnesota, 2005-
on the clinical assessment of patients such as preoperative 2008. Preventing Chronic Disease 2011; 8.
medications used, Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) 12. Thanni LOA, Tade AO. Extremity amputation in Nigeria — a review of
status, smoking, clinical examination findings related to the indications and mortality. The Surgeon 2007; 5: 213-217.
13. Viswanathan V, Wadud JR, Madhavan S et al. Comparison of post
level of peripheral vascular disease, and anaesthetic-related
amputation outcome in patients with type 2 diabetes from specialized
factors were not available. Furthermore, we did not have foot care centres in three developing countries. Diabetes Research and
information on whether or not patients had undergone Clinical Practice 2010; 88: 146-150.
reconstructive vascular operations prior to amputation. This 14. Roffman CE, Buchanan J, Allison GT. Predictors of non-use of prostheses
by people with lower limb amputation after discharge from
reflects challenges in using hospital records for data
rehabilitation: development and validation of clinical prediction rules.
collection and perhaps the need for prospective, Journal of Physiotherapy 2014; 60: 224-231.
comprehensive data collection methods for future similar 15. Ali MM, Loretz L, Shea A et al. A Contemporary Comparative Analysis of
studies. Another limitation is the lack of access to accurate Immediate Postoperative Prosthesis Placement Following Below-Knee
Amputation. Annals of Vascular Surgery 2012; 27: 1146-1153.
patient telephone records, and the need to improve the
16. Taylor SM, Kalbaugh CA, Blackhurst DW et al. Preoperative clinical
current system to allow reliable patient follow-up. It is an factors predict postoperative functional outcomes after major lower
integral part of medicine to ensure that patients are followed limb amputation: an analysis of 553 consecutive patients. Journal of
up timeously, therefore improving systems for patient Vascular Surgery 2005; 42: 227-234.
17. Aulivola B, Hile CN, Hamdan AD et al. Major lower extremity
follow-up will significantly improve our patient care.
amputation: outcome of a modern series. Archives of Surgery 2004;
139: 395-399.
Conclusion 18. Karam J, Shepard A, Rubinfeld I. Predictors of operative mortality
The prevalence of postoperative inpatient mortality following major lower extremity amputations using the National
Surgical Quality Improvement Program public use data. Journal of
following LLA in our study was high, but within the estimated
Vascular Surgery 2013; 58: 1276-1282.
range reported in overseas settings, suggesting the need for 19. Biccard B. Anaesthesia for vascular procedures: how do South African
better risk communication and risk stratification in patients patients differ? Southern African Journal of Anaesthesia and Analgesia
undergoing LLA at South African hospitals. Also, there is a 2008; 14: 109-115.
20. Basu NN, Fassiadis N, McIrvine A. Mobility one year after unilateral
need to strengthen existing patient education and primary
lower limb amputation: a modern, UK institutional report. Interactive
healthcare initiatives on diabetic foot care, chronic disease Cardiovascular and Thoracic Surgery 2008; 7: 1024-1026.
management and optimization of medical treatment in 21. van Netten JJ, Fortington LV, Hinchliffe RJ, Hijmans JM. Early Post-
order to prevent these morbid complications. Accurate operative Mortality After Major Lower Limb Amputation: A Systematic
Review of Population and Regional Based Studies. European Journal of
patient record keeping is of paramount importance to
Vascular and Endovascular Surgery 2016; 51: 248-257.
ensure adequate patient follow-up and continuity of care. 22. Hambleton IR, Jonnalagadda R, Davis CR et al. All-Cause Mortality After
We recommend additional research be conducted, with Diabetes-Related Amputation in Barbados: A prospective case-control
more sites and larger patient numbers to confirm our study. Diabetes Care 2009; 32: 306-307.
23. Keagy BA, Schwartz JA, Kotb M et al. Lower extremity amputation: the
findings and address the study limitations we have
control series. Journal of Vascular Surgery 1986; 4: 321-326.
identified. 24. Jones WS, Patel MR, Dai D et al. High mortality risks after major lower
extremity amputation in Medicare patients with peripheral artery
References disease. American Heart Journal 2013; 165: 809-815.e801.
1. Mayosi BM, Flisher AJ, Lalloo UG et al. The burden of non- 25. Scott SW, Bowrey S, Clarke D et al. Factors influencing short- and long-
communicable diseases in South Africa. The Lancet 2009; 374: 934-947. term mortality after lower limb amputation. Anaesthesia 2014; 69: 249-
2. Bradshaw D, Groenewald P, Laubscher R et al. Initial burden of disease 258.
estimates for South Africa, 2000. South African Medical Journal 2003; 26. Obalum DC, Okeke GCE. Lower Limb Amputations at a Nigerian Private
93(9): 682-688. Tertiary Hospital. West African Journal of Medicine 2009; 28: 314–317.
3. Bradshaw D, Pieterse D, Norman R, Levitt NS. Estimating the burden of 27. Nehler MR, Coll JR, Hiatt WR et al. Functional outcome in a
disease attributable to diabetes in South Africa in 2000. Journal of contemporary series of major lower extremity amputations. Journal of
Endocrinology, Metabolism and Diabetes of South Africa 2007; 12: 65- Vascular Surgery 2003; 38: 7-14.
71.
4. Tollman SM, Kahn K, Sartorius B et al. Implications of mortality
transition for primary health care in rural South Africa: a population-
based surveillance study. The Lancet 2008; 372: 893-901.
5
Shenaaz I., et al Surg Chron 2019; 24(2): 64-69.
Corresponding author:
Dr. Shenaaz Ismail
Department of Surgery, Nelson R. Mandela School of Medicine, University
of KwaZulu-Natal, 719 Umbilo Road, Congella, South Africa, 4013
Email: shenaaz.b.ismail@gmail.com
Telephone: +27 712811401