— | | Ve 4S Walter Ullmann Law and Jurisdiction in the Middle Ages Edited by George Garnett VARIORUM REPRINTS. London 1988, Historisches Seminar ddor Universitet Heidelberg(aioe iden sins eam) Ena” "5 Gane Ge ons 198 by 430, to Pub rt Brin by Yara Rept Open Mews London W260 Pine ie ras rin yall ites Lid Great Ym Ro Historleches Seminar ‘dor Universitit Heidelberg CONTENTS Prafice Supolemenary Biography fof the Weng of Water Uimann 1 Pobic Law as an tsrament of Government in stoned Pept: New Rome hd Old Rome in the Light of les «pose nl ei cap Bere Kooga und Papert im Spies (er Batumsbeciungen: ‘Size ene Reshubcologe 1 Fc sm Ine: Usher Wager, 186 1 on pein a fama SS 1 Alexander Ia the Conquest of Ireland Nate on the Rachroun ‘Paps sun io its YFredrick I's Opponent, Inaceat IV, Br Mlenedee FS an en 5 text em si mie sowu vu vu xt xu xv ‘The Medieval Papacy, $¢ Thomas and beyond Ins Te eis Sota Landon ‘vias Sen ‘do The A Pre, 40 The Developmen of he Medel ea oF oversee Bo rat eve Lx ‘A Medical Document on Papal Theres er Goverment ‘i Mort Reve x rey Pet Se stn ae Balds's Conception of Law Bla uc Revie LV ‘The Medieval Theory of Legal and Meal Organisations Fetes Guo Rei Medieval Prins of Evidence Belen ouvert fees Honoris 1 and the Proton ot tepat Sudes Ih res! eve Lx Ear a Medierat Views concerning P ‘bdistion ae ae Teh Exel Rcd LX Bt 160.201 ss1-410 386.399 285-291 ne wr186 nam XV The Defence of te Accs in Re Model nga XVI Historia Introdvton to “he Inguion of the Mile Ages, ty Henry Chare Le. London Bed Selena, 193 XVIL_ Refetions on Medial Torre art 500 Index (by Shay Lockwood) ustxi ond Met Orgone st el sins nal det cu it ure aon ave adh th pt fn onenstary au any ans hd oe fee y he is roy, sadn De ay ee ot he Fig Sattar a slp "Po ing fe ul rove ample einony fhe a oih bial tnt soho th fag ee tea Se me ras oa he Sh Sleytr ei olin age egeabele tales ae so ‘Eine wok he aig te ay ESSER i pp ate on nw pete at tate at pee sts ee oa cee, aa ace res Stake tia pny ee ny ep pans ‘eters alr ol aa ly {he ime ee fpr Saute mn af meron otra ie, hol nthe le nen to the tara of Mantels dot ree oe th ot step Sate Sn any veep ra ea oo XI DSEDIEVAL FRINEIPLES OF EVIDENCE, TF cnet de at te bl te, pd sd te Sa Le CESSES Ly Dee ado ee on rape SPSS aris iad aur agices mea ears aah Tonto t iether St cae eos eis an te See hoa eine ‘Posgloemtrs mee, witht exception, ees judges or ndvoces them SoS S See She hyn en ay phn et oS eres cy da Hina uatr Seta hots 8) B ‘ist et hci, a aay htt Cras Sine" Geia’ Asya, toe acne eed ret stellt i nl se Gs ue ‘Littl and rae! interplay rested, the, ithe eam ‘fcc amen pugs lh wa Wess pt tog {ip med dee uy welatomp th ely Ue Pie in Soe ae ey sone sal cts toe ban ot wpe paki, hs peta Int sy ‘pum thn depee af ony f wih the bean mand meee: Tota ope sh eee el Son arr akoxu "al Sa Sele re eee Rae Peter rare rete ESorkes ae ce smear nem See rat Ee eat et eet ton of te aie oneal ‘Gomes ty sr ei od om frre nee neces See ee eS Shi be ema ie cae ce Sgvenemeton elon a poets prt Badan taught exams the wisn edie of Bie » Pee Seas Seer hone Sly eee So Se oe BEBE “hat the eden te en Bed csr sera at was & ec hh te mei ita rny proed Te rgol ot Fry hd tsb ciel orto witbe te oped ‘Sen, A fac ich ae han sponte gl neon lppedica™ he Dlogera pti Nichols de Maso ae ‘ellen snsein incr Cacametcessely rove ey, Soncrapeaaacmme eters et Ree eee Spe iether gees ‘comin we old he i of te fg odo, Bat ae i 3 ri the ke the inde so ‘Sere fem ee cdenore inh aes seexn {Sie “Be queer of cs nna pep ed eet Sogo ts uh aay ae ener oe Seas acetone cane elm SS es Saeco eee cay 2S ee Soscae ote meee Seaver es Serpe ge ee proved ten gtag eiber isa por ‘aint aol sun able otha he oh cn Ss SA ee fo ey ‘i anne enn ia ed eek Seana ace oe Telecare sae TRS eee Secs eyo «bah eo Medic Pisces of Idec. a ete a sidan tt pognnt woman Wty naked ogo Tiga Lialy athe tates at ee pepe lak (Ee “Oa wou be ltd tyre fal omen ata sccm hey shirt re, {Ba ne nce his entfme ntl ew,” Thar Come aie, mace me ard Se Se eee oe eee ara Eiaim irl ave ‘Goran, twin Paro e Bloetoy hip Fret arte tai ‘Rens ta ato be ted, simon 2 tk {ste at at leprae a Ak he re, See ee Seno fo fren enn ol en xixu ‘Etta ‘aw pot sane 9y any ater aston ahough pai sie mre or esuel nas” a eben Jp ad quero gum por stone : ete pe iy tat ee v4, 3, and half pe Hae ro eset Pree of Bee « Sot eee sect enn of Be a igri ty ha Sena es Skee ces Fis Sa Ss ipa etn ain Te tenet rene 8 ESN i usec? mth eal Pore rn" meter he oe (ie eas tw el ele tra Nd Gini Mie aml fe pean ef eee ro natal xixu ‘rotates wins wie at hey appt Ir him ern Sea eS ta a ae Soi te wlohe wy of Soe gett fe cits {nl Teor nC wee fe aly teu Sf mn thee ‘eater wee tatoney a mt hema ee inital es sci eceog? Rona aan ace fake i hg eo tr ee sot fe ne ‘airy Psa sd “De, ‘Eeplantone Fog" Dvn vad tat te jg son watch eee bee eee ied nor nie ae a sucrotriautae ieee amen Se {acre si in hw Seat tpdando et blinds" al Se mh et mea eget Pn ply mie aes seams Ponce ences Pannen eae eee La eee Serres errata the ian cael » pont whih Wr comune f= eceesty, ihe Seen in aoe ete Samana si ge itso POTS a LMS ee ad on 0. ores sacra tect, Moda Pte of Roos ergs cette fe ofA he id ent {tno ols pew be ae he eget hea oe {fea pnentmtrtery cache” of teat fart rs th pte oe taste Mutha "stir wet be ven om gh ch war same ‘Epes hoi it wet vt he abene tte eel fg adie tng" De opr of iaxn po ecietaiys gt gaa pate Paonia Sree, teem cea Siegel ferent gel tl foes ee ae Fervor ie eee i nace Ean cae eee ote Sto tes Bes re Seg eh sie rt et SGie tech eeen eee: rr ESL eek Geant {he ier hn fly ove Te se i a ek oe ste Pn of tn 7 ste se gen tn oh Erie were see ee ase fees eee apook ESiigoaeest Siesiegy geet Ee sae nae craect aoe oh ea Enwie arte eee ts ‘me wee fhe tinction etwecewiney det ‘Siete ees Ss i eg Seachem ana Ties ee erereean ‘a,b al sol wpsnr nar om te tmery Tier Buon Wet ata tate dys, date Puta Fanci! see of ee bal pte ne cmc ot xu.Courts and Conflict in Twelfth-Century Tuscany CHRIS WICKHAM OXFORDsit ForLesuux and be cats Lbememony of Tin Rewrer (1947-2002) 2005 A 3342Acknowledgements Many prone save hid ih his ook Lam pra gate ‘vo Lai rebar pda Ree, who dyad a gud he ‘thle es ado Clan Str Sra sa Rove Bean, ‘Betane for Chapers4 aed 6. Su Bowen toed he wl oo with ht ‘Boal ary Bogs ow the pe Tae bong ae me es ‘owas found me obec ae ad erie pd me Mail ‘Alon Lacan Camby, Seno Caras, Mara Luxe Coca es, Dis Art ac, Rober alli od Jantes Pees Rico nd Bae Fano Cael acl to wham peal hk foe [Butng me toh Pa dou Asa Chagall Gaze ‘Ehret iy Mishap Gcmesy en any Eanes ‘hes rs Halo Naw Aston Pon Sepp, Css Palombl, ‘Nisan Pasbore, Rossen Reals, Pio Peale Mss Pe, Pal Ply Fans Repo, Cabrils Rosset, Magus Ryan lo Sala, Sena Sri, Cla re Storch wha sped has or ang ine taught a Rar Samoa, Cis Visa, Sepben se, Poe Worl and Anes Zor lestonde leo snc does verti whom dlneted eons fat fe pes pers ‘Sot of alo he aw an try Gro ofthe ales of Ox. Spologaet one sameeren ets hae wacked ‘hehe os there mat Be more Revere Lac, lve and a Stns fnddy Hos Rene rll Grain 1987 3889 aby he Une of Bemighan cue. Bien Jamar 1959Note to the English Edition ‘Tus raesner rex eh ond lino ok psi ane “ere con eco ee ey asd ‘nor oped egy as es ard Contents Lio Some Ce List Abbr Mars 1 odecion ‘ce The Derlopnen fi Prceares oes DapatngSereper orc: Dipt Selamet ous the Cy Teil Diptingin the Ten Die Ral and DiptinginTwelth Cnty Tsay neepyList of Sample Cases Landi Toeuen, Novebe ge Joon 195 Sin ee Dt ek inp boomin nonin Ape-Ocober £299 ‘eh enercon aia Spt ‘edobodgea Puccio ems ig oer en aso ‘Nene apps Deb 7p ‘ThebomanSemet Ro snd Cio 802 Teloesaltontensypsaye ‘omy nes Cle Goin ay 098 Reap en, Sneha ny srt to ay ‘cy ay sree ‘Teepe ny Pan ae Mes Notes on Terminology and Dating cents treatment ished ‘ova ect we of te pula ldo and Fe (sgl ce eyed ladle nd yee oo et eS iets x woohoo She jl Ge pb wu co te pl deen of md Tn ‘pial dc ee eee pe sce Te pon wa tow a8 eva’ are Re col br an amie abc ce pte eo wy oe = seri elas mone ee ‘ee ale opty wel cer Ti aw of emps pp and mug ve en ml ne ais sen vane hr heft on us tan ae ee ‘Sif engher Aer ug wees eda Roan sd ES Scmemobe shout "Teme of per sr fT oly Fle i) a snyder abe mrt ght he toes a “evi ein cate sn nol oping he ba (Ee ey od ae edging Lal teat PFs Remein Feta, ey Sens Sans." wernt en Be me ds at Arpt ome Tren hokey fe te aplgial cr ih a ascivesetngiietdBedidegaenmce “Themen ce as epee ge Max la ‘atago, we RdonLnapoa! ln i nae ond hancePy Nout on Tomiolgy ion w th say fl cine Going, a ne iwi ose etn el Spo tht tip mem ol Sr oy psy Co "Tecoma of Sr awn reed oso Ces papi Vi ‘taproot orm ee on alts sndeomnly presen Te pct pero est ‘Bic cic prny m ae, he oe ‘ined eles ecu cops ce fen ‘ano he vr sae pb sl has em np ‘eon Seow ope sop ay 8 "helo hes ees om hc we ee Boren, oud esse sind, dow trp ncn unedaecmpehee oe ‘conten dees eto ce, apne ans se ‘ov of operons aay ew aa en rnc wh wll ‘leur iehtenk howe hae wun tea n'ont {sn esr pion nies ile resect Secrest rosa sei ae A Scot Sloe sa ecaee oss ihieeneeneeees Treg ieee te LNT sens Pe ne potent Saridenauscine teneesaarae Seis rage assem eens iis a Nee om Termine si Alcea cheer in te Thee Bates auss Bete aby mo dni Roms Hern Mee ‘aogier ero erwin oo es setom die Tit norman PurseAbbreviations ‘Ture usr wrasse artic he achive hae consd have Frcs othe tolehcenuy, andl rts oe ‘alr nnn for Sn, Aran, Vos, apd Pt Mo of he oe fas heist a td tae te ele, bt oe is te eae om heeds of the ret bul of hci upset dow ‘ano belound in ta are oh Digan edie, Ua. ‘esta dif The eon ft ic acne ered ow, ‘epier mh ser nob rom laren have ted ‘Sra thearedocmen fave mined fr al nd new ens cies foo ry roca to Tua bt ek nd ope) "atherecny nw be For ote pushed eos a thf ls ‘hoe ed hese ep wa Av Annee Las tern acon en coms oh he Sees ten ok ee cn ending gin) hoc Ae de Cen Cali pie comers ei heen te ipo ese fe Renta se hot at ‘Sq ‘Ret atonipe aera eek s.1) rani enon = Atti asd is lp penn Bie ARG iocee cea ARCS etait sev Sie Comers, oer a ‘Caan, Corer dle Bede ‘Str aca Coarncab fa Gouin gfe eae) o ‘uta eset 1)ABresitone Di se» uane MP, Teese se’ coe adem ch ain, Tes el nei do creole SURV cpt oly pone way ope cas ‘he doesnoato'n chloe af ers) ‘Neva en oper chi it Peppa Are Ura tarmung, Act fotif romano ee eo ere Sahn tlc ee Col ies Repay se Cpl ne Sine Regs al Cher dat Sie ema Seer, Ye Ue edie ebro nt de Peas Pn oho) Ang See oem agpemmn i 9 a Teich ct anna etieront te 1496, tO. Bertolini anno sceademive 1962-3) ee _—=Ct«éaiéwissn ..—rC~s epee Cr es TEE nto tal oe -—-— | a ‘zademeo 1967-8) TRIGA ego ta ER nsatien eee Abtreiions si 1 Made Aplicada {EM da et cl ene ee ‘Seed moe d Valen dijon 4S eu E Stameacndenconnre cea te rc Um moma ala (ase yr Chto nes dene 35, Slugs Grn incre demons Revol rvaliacd Le Mason 4)’ Lm I | } jess Uhl1 Introduction ‘Tue sruo¥ oF Helnlegl rcedresinshe recur atlain che Lends Rome tA cept svcd ws oo the ‘panowndewsopmenin eel ropa othe cbse ‘Sn! prermentn tec nde the holo Ronan ed “Son we Bologna. Te fc el oo wes fen ecg Sintec tats bo alin bw wa ae eae nse hula may woyaconnctary Ont one and he iy oped traders afield exisedn apron two at Blog bat a0 ti elder Lombard aw choot a aaa oberg wi the insert eeurysucnmoe de opcmaotdy eae Each thse pened om long and abort teen, hones thereat ‘etd compl dear ben ep chalr that et had eae ‘era no miu ural a be est of atin Europe ach af ‘Remaluoha ington fot despa of couronm pati, wich Sesame al Spina ena “Taped wa gue item ty Caries poll sen iin {Ta ch sured te ep of the Kings themselves in they ‘ehectryandon began aot ect te emer Sicvay snd ofthe slat co sonorous cy cnmmes the Sesrarond anda 100 Theft cea of cee ws ped FSsore fel owe a he ses rng oes at wera lpincy ap ra lel ley and Geran bod Emperor tpt eged wo af hry: Come fae at [Soi tema cen in toe mnt reco tHe a, Geo a, thee me fone om whi courts any court tall eee ‘ooandrigoyendasytemat swe baa only opted mast Cheeta east eae in ths ese bt he pod ‘dle Kory fel commen iy pene noo Seton ne ah egal rion fran gy th mat developed tthe we ‘ery we wl these ie ce he Norah sath poi Snllog yume wreath wee inthe ene pro oli try tom poor pene "regen whens Gt Di gaa: Intaction deveopedin hee Toney werner cay. ha feeoyoota lisbon the probes ole ny or abo he pea ood Ita sorte cs comedy Lacey Pan Hoven pt ‘Muar artheawe spree doops el toch of pare te dues they sap on th mal yet we ‘Seton thar cranes: Bar that ser framing wpe oe ‘ough inthe bess anor ut ease we od ein th Soneconmers tsa he elbowed he fae Tee wayto dsingunhthed ganar tees sprain nd inataeal weaken wehbe commonly oe pesca Ieqtem: Telit one aoe Stadvo bens conine ‘enor incon: ure coed he lg holt si thea comm of Blog alfa ping etc ofc, ‘argued ht na lane or corempers oil pst at Ulied sod fen aw wee to backward acing tod omega teste and ot Romany soak war a ae eer abet ‘Sent of oneness ove the Corps acl, ‘red om eat! knee a ny Parl espe teste Indeed elves Roane desig wh prac ern as ‘erring smo ten he s-led r cheol, Gres he egret olgnte te necking oie he ots Hologne iis ncresngy crman ise loca alps inthe commana, ndingciesachas Pia whit adorn ‘spear Ramone iin te cel tr of Reman I ee hele Romemmindd eierar ko, of coun, he peal con of Frederick and amy Vi—i cor, Avoccanntaw, dee ahr tthe oeltvcenay papacy andthe egesion of brent Up ell whch wor onetbelas one fcr rocance oer ‘Siomeamnraretoecaaleat isis ase = Meee 110, tot Fl Goo Hine ly Cuca apes Renae at rr Bee enene Sint ewan agen pd ‘once sts of Lind Ine ws sloy wean he ht 9 ah Tintnot ose sz lea nmlege tall en desing with he {evoprt of ey comunity rh dspsig aa action, ‘onldbea mint “akon ay of dealing wih the elncip ewe a and pols hr avourel tym af hn lately few pl ad elec "Ents re have lode he moll xi be Seca, docs ‘Shanes sl pati nts of say Remain a ate {aceasagcrptty to Romans pci, Thiers eure Daca matte mated ang expla, ely do mac of ‘heramget aes enone real scar penasa 1 Europa hara ow eral themorg he rps Reem" ‘oman win ent and saterthentny Carney tnd a ee ‘ieto ines dacustoor aur he Spscty of skeubtcng cm ‘Tiwi Rotas law sale cad lex ons gers the omar Gopein the leh cere fn he pape of ‘ee pr yen a hn ool te srg of tear see ‘hk eiowm Bologna ogee lace te inry acral lp prcere ‘ctl the Gatton of How ar ed oman we ors ‘Reoduc tology, tard vcory ofthe ecm tt ‘Behera spc owl nd eves htt ey ba Peace boca whch every inertia olga Secor, ade Pines repeon by nuns how wes eiomanonlnion Thuy woes Ty and mee stil ccouap te cet of ‘eopbecedwormate cs tht be le rtm othe quer ‘fit eekernry ew whe ney? as ng beens wenkos, fiona of ead cena! Mideast lok and ‘contac econ es ye tat marae every wey ‘5 edn ty bu shapers Be if dcametd {oul age he shomenate eer Cate Speer Dee sant eccrine ‘a Sor ely Cr ar abt Hea big eb cB in Wa re Sy Ses Ee eee hee een epee ieee end ain eh eae sadn census(eSoamd 100m theca, tibet ey of es ia sel be otc aimecneenee faves cop ens etc Spend on sco be Sohishiomrnmet enna Se amore Seca iting apiecimens Su sepeeforitenea aerate BETAS canyons Sgesvent sacs heat “yrs or cl desma gal oes apes td ta Sagat ta ara te scarps andinehefaewor oles agmet sel Altbesechaceseas ‘found sneha Kegan as eo sch ‘onlay some chose wee merecmison anothers, at ‘Shoal scrng eatery tht arcane ed theconpeay ofpssenathrayettheeaedon of epaehrgvrte Pesos paca er Andy be adel ht reli geen [aan documentation in he welt Sou inading Soames ft ‘urine ond aebrone,meats ate ca y motes the ae top of hen dnuing res tha we ano anus es Eo ‘thepeewec,indcal smetin mene opty poe ‘cay ried wth achotbr. The proarer ht governed aly ie bok lourand the prt expects pope adhe wa Uy old emuniplaed aretomeins unl css Ashok othe pane ‘ace of keying dotnet of erin per wes 90 1 Elche, rested wo tain texas and cei ay aes, ‘Sala andownes een pena cn tested nn. “These areanvopolgial and sooo sues wel as kisorcal ons gdh ee aneced sobly by kel setcopeagy ensoes rides wld singlet price imporaeapreches mre ‘3 cde ce apyoach of Mon Gk sol at ho dt Proce osprey crcl of Gacean dc by one [esos Sly al Moore Sonn Ronan nf Coo Ties "le tenedscanbeneenseceparofdipangaeperst fn lyn he eon fhe ei thay a ure Hou. [ive apraces sr th the measly Sd rar the rip n eats rte ha with th als orm tn nosy Eamets Tr ot ey. Thiok in espe teed om the nerds of ius we sl Sx 8 owe ad Sh ‘coll more abou pexze an to bom pp rey behaved ‘Geach uke ara ewig and her ome fe hoop ey ‘oad. They elle whetons othe peone bake {ay wth nd convey cha hem ote ane eng tc ine nd eho so of ngs le col dso Soc eae ‘fcr the ext anf inl meat of ome bat can ‘hange ase pate popes be dale re seal ccs ‘nconetimete lolowed in some Soa Iam meretedn cong ‘Se amvoplogl debe wat isto, bt ks mgt ote ths thee str rer ooo apa ch sr roves one fhe bt wap desing le omits ln ac elas Bo a sieghhsr pe sae ats ten ces SES Speen a Sie es h W