Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Crowd Sourcing Haiti
Crowd Sourcing Haiti
Crowd Sourcing Haiti
Grady Johnson
December 2010
Introduction
the field of humanitarian assistance. Through the use of new media technologies,
rescuers can harness the efforts of locals on the ground, humanitarian workers and
situation. Further, by tapping into the global network (including social media like
Facebook and Twitter), crowdsourcing platforms like Ushahidi can aggregate the
massive and often labyrinthine data flow into coherent and substantiated reports. It is
well know that in a crisis information is a precious resource and crucial to an effective
response.1 As the recent case of the 2010 Haitian earthquake shows, the potential for
But this approach raises certain questions. For instance, who constitutes „the
mapping reflect the reality on the ground or merely the level of access to the network?
Beyond this, it is no secret that the media (and social media spheres as well) have a
tendency to focus on high profile cases, often to the detriment of others in similar
discriminate against those lesser-known cases? Crowdsourcing‟s recent rise into the
A review of the literature to date reveals that no such assessment has been
1
Coyle, Meier. New Technologies, 9.
qualitative in their approach, these authors appear to be caught up in the fervor of this
solely on the benefits, with hardly a token discussion of the downsides of relying on
exactly constitutes the crowd and, more importantly, who is left out. Crowdsourced
crisis mapping may be effective, but this does not necessarily mean that it is fair.
This myopia in the literature may have real consequences for those individuals made
during this disaster that crowdsourced reporting really came into its own. Much of
the humanitarian response in the immediate aftermath was driven by this type of
emergency services, such reports were often the only information available.4
providing timely and critical information that could not have been garnered by other
reliance on this innovative resource.5 The unique context of the Haitian earthquake
response mechanisms.
Were certain at-risk groups or regions rendered invisible because they lacked
2
Howe. Power of the Crowd, 9.
3
Munro. Crowdsourcing Haiti, 1.
4
Munro. Crowdsourcing Haiti, 1.
5
Munro. Crowdsourcing Haiti, 2.
adequate access to the network? Did this lead to an unequal distribution of
humanitarian resources?
Hypothesis
Methodology
assessments and population distribution, and comparing this to the distribution and
ground. Discrepancies in need versus reporting may suggest that certain at-risk
The 2010 Haitian earthquake is a particularly salient case study for two
reasons. First, it is the first time that crowdsourced reporting was widely used, and
Lack of intact emergency infrastructure meant that rescuers were practically forced to
rely on crowdsourced maps, perhaps to a higher degree than they would have under
6
Munro. Haiti Emergency Response, 10.
earthquake is a highly localized event. A rudimentary assessment of need can be
Disclaimer
Before proceeding with the analysis, it must be clarified what this paper is and
platforms like Ushahidi are highly promising, and carry with them the potential to
dramatically enhance our ability to respond effectively to crises. This has already
that crowdsourced reporting has saved lives and its validity as an integral part of
for those who may be left out of the loop. As crowdsourcing becomes part of the
recognized as the invaluable tool that it is and that through careful planning
Analysis
On the 12th of January 2010, at 16:53 local time, a 7.0 magnitude earthquake
7
Munro. Crowdsourcing Haiti, 2.
8
http://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eqinthenews/2010/us2010rja6/#details
9
Munro. Crowdsourcing Haiti, 1.
by the near-total loss of public infrastructure, including the destruction of key
government buildings, such as the National Assembly,10 and the loss of the UN
mission‟s headquarters in the capital.11 The final toll left over 230,000 dead, 300,000
injured, one million homeless and a country in ruin.12 Among the dead was the leader
and lacking the confidence of many Haitians, was ill-equipped to deal with the
much more difficult to respond”.15 The chaos and lack of central organization left a
critical gap which crowdsourced crisis mapping was uniquely qualified to fill.
Within hours of the disaster, the architects of Ushahidi had set up a crisis-
mapping tool for Haiti.16 Reports from a number of sources, including NGOs, media
outlets and social media platforms were collated and geo-coded onto the web-based
map in near-real time. Within three days the site had received 33,000 unique
visitors.17 While the platform proved an effective tool for collaboration and
10
http://www.thestar.com/news/world/haiti/article/754255--haiti-s-leaders-face-hell-
of-a-job
11
Informal Briefing by Alain LeRoy, 12 January 2010
12
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8511997.stm
13
Informal Briefing by Alain LeRoy, 12 January 2010
14
http://www.thestar.com/news/world/haiti/article/754255--haiti-s-leaders-face-hell-
of-a-job
15
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8510900.stm
16
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-
dyn/content/article/2010/01/15/AR2010011502650.html
17
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-
dyn/content/article/2010/01/15/AR2010011502650.html
Shortly thereafter, an SMS short code, 4636, was established for Haitians and
non-Haitians alike to submit reports via text message. In addition to aggregating time-
sensitive data, Ushahidi provided a crowdsourced translation service that was critical
speak the local language. Over 40,000 reports were received in the first six weeks,
and “the average turn-around from a message arriving in Kreyol to it being translated,
identified [Ushahidi] as the most up-to-date crisis mapping service”19 and its
information was employed by several agencies, including USAID, the World Food
Program and the UNDP20. Not only did Ushahidi augment conventional emergency
services, in some cases the crowdsourced reports also filled critical knowledge gaps;
one salient example was when the “World Food Program delivered food to an
informal camp of 2500 people, having yet to receive food or water, in... a location that
niche to fill. Platforms like Ushahidi can aggregate information in sheer volume and
with such speed that far exceeds more conventional methods of information gathering
because it provides “additional data at levels of granularity and timeliness that could
18
Munro. Crowdsourcing Haiti, 1.
19
Munro. Crowdsourcing Haiti, 2.
20
Munro. Crowdsourcing Haiti, 2.
21
Munro. Haiti Emergency Response, 10.
22
Zook et al. Volunteered Geographic Information, 12.
Herein lies the rub. Without question, crowdsourcing does have an important
role, and as proponents are quick to remind us “some information... [is] better than
none.”23 But how much faith do we put in this information? Does crowdsourced
reporting give us a truly objective and accurate assessment of the situation on the
ground?
Regional Discrepancies
The case of Léogâne is telling. Located just west of the quake‟s epicentre, this
coastal town was nearly completely destroyed. Of its 181,000 inhabitants, nearly
10,000 were killed, and many thousands more were left homeless.24 A UN survey
team sent to assess the damage found that Léogâne was "the worst affected area with
as “apocalyptic”.26 In the gruesome aftermath nearly every home had collapsed27 and
When reporters described the scene as “even more dramatic than in the
capital”30, they did not exaggerate. But was this level of destruction reflected in the
crowdsourced maps?
23
Okollah, Ushahidi, 65.
24
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703569004575009493976627772.html
25
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/01/17/2794043.htm?section=justin
26
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8463938.stm
27
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/01/17/2794190.htm
28
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/01/17/2794043.htm?section=justin
29
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8463938.stm
30
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8463938.stm
Figure 1: Reports by Region
2500
Port-au-Prince
2000
Number of Reports
1500
1000
500
Lé ogâne
0 Jacm e l
1 2 3 4 5
Weeks after Earthquake
Port-au-Prince is far and away the most densely populated region of Haiti.31
While not located directly at the quake‟s epicentre, its proximity to the disaster and its
shown in Figure 1, reporting from Port-au-Prince dwarfs that of Léogâne and Jacmel,
though both were closer or equidistant to the quake‟s epicentre and suffered
Table 1 shows that both Léogâne and Jacmel consistently produce roughly
31
http://www.ihsi.ht/produit_demo_soc.htm
32
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8466385.stm
Table 1: Reports Per Thousand Persons
Source: http://haiti.ushahidi.com/
Reports by Population
1.2
1 Port-a u-Prince
Reports per thousand
0.8
Léogâ ne
0.6
0.4 Jacm el
0.2
0
1 2 3 4 5
Weeks after Earthquake
Source: http://haiti.ushahidi.com/
Prince far outstrips that of Léogâne and Jacmel. At first, a dearth in reporting outside
damage assessments show that Haiti‟s cell phone towers, built to withstand
earthquakes, had largely survived intact.33 Digicel, the largest mobile company in
Haiti, reported that their cellular network, though congested, was still operational.34
Further, as Figure 2 illustrates, by the fifth week this disparity in reporting had
not only persisted, but in the case of Jacmel it had actually increased. To be fair, the
their way to the capital in the hopes of finding refuge. However, the consistency
with which Léogâne and Jacmel were underrepresented suggests that the focus on
Port-au-Prince may have occluded the plight of individuals in these two regions.
The glacial pace of aid reaching Léogâne only served to reinforce local
perceptions that the government did not see them as a priority.35 As rescuers were
preoccupied with the situation in the capital, it took several days for aid to reach the
beleaguered city.36 Despite the dire need of Léogâne‟s citizens, residents in Port-au-
Prince were clearly able to attract far more attention on a per capita basis. This may
While this trend is disturbing, a comparison of the reports between urban and
Discrepancies in reports per capita between rural and urban areas are even
more pronounced than those between cities. In contrast to the urban sprawl of Port-
33
http://www.internews.org/articles/2010/20100125_msnbc_haiti.shtm
34
http://www.indiaprwire.com/pressrelease/telecommunications/2010011441347.htm
35
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703569004575009493976627772.html
36
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703569004575009493976627772.html
37
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/01/18/AR2010011803833.html
au-Prince, half of Haiti‟s roughly ten million inhabitants live in the countryside38, yet
reporting from most rural areas is scant or absent.39 Even four months after the
disaster, the crowdsourced map draws little attention outside urban areas. The
scattering and infrequency of reports from the countryside would seem to suggest that
the earthquake were larger, concrete buildings, most of which were in urban settings.
individuals but of myriad issues involving water, sanitation, shelter and medical
needs. Of course, the urban population was highly vulnerable, but the question
remains as to how much the discrepancies in reporting were driven by need and how
2.5
Reports Per Thousand
1.5
0.5
0
District Ave ra ge Ja cm e l R e st o f District
Location
38
http://www.ihsi.ht/produit_demo_soc.htm
39
http://haiti.ushahidi.com/
As Figure 3 illustrates, there is an alarming disparity between rural and urban
reporting in the Sud-Est District. Jacmel, with its 40,000 inhabitants, comprises
roughly 7% of the district‟s population, yet accounts for 73% of the reporting. No
doubt, Jacmel sustained heavy damage40 and warranted significant attention, but
many areas of the Sud-Est district were closer to the epicentre and yet account for
Source: Digicel41
Digicel‟s (the largest cellular service provider) mobile network map, shown in Figure
4. As seen here, there are large gaps in the network represented by the white spaces;
40
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8466385.stm
41
http://www.digicelhaiti.com/en/coverage_roaming/coverage_map
after all, mobile coverage is driven by demand, which is driven by socioeconomic and
market factors. Rural areas, with their higher incidence of poverty and lower
What is eerie about the mobile coverage map is how closely it resembles the
crowdsourced crisis map. Areas with low coverage (or none at all) are conspicuously
membership in “the crowd”. To begin with, one must have access to the network.
While many take such access for granted, in some contexts this connection is far from
In the case of Haiti, there were real obstacles determining who could submit
reports. Due to congestion of the network, text messages were the only effective way
to communicate and contribute reports43 yet only 37% of Haitians had cell phones.44
Further, Internet penetration was around 1%.45 Of course, this does not necessarily
suggest that only a third of Haitians had access; one could conceivably submit reports
on others‟ behalf. But it does suggest that we should not assume that open access is
communication. Those in the crowd can only participate if they are first made aware
that such participation is possible. Thus, the crowd consists only of those who can be
42
http://haiti.ushahidi.com/
43
Munro. Crowdsourcing Haiti, 1.
44
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ha.html
45
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ha.html
reached initially by the organizers. Knowledge of Ushahidi‟s existence was likely a
Both access and knowledge were almost certainly restricted for Haiti‟s rural
population. With the breakdown in public infrastructure, lack of mobile coverage and
low population density46, communication both to and from the countryside would no
doubt have been difficult. As the data shows, some 500,000 Haitians in Sud-Est
The consequences of this low incidence in reporting are uncertain, but this
Conclusion
significantly higher in the capital and other urban centres while in smaller towns and
rural areas there is a significant dearth in reporting. This is alarming, given that by all
accounts their need is no less immediate. It would appear that there are other factors
responders, but our optimism must be tempered with the knowledge that the number
crucial question that needs to be addressed is who is doing the reporting, and who is
left out.
46
http://www.ihsi.ht/produit_demo_soc.htm
For instance, do women have equal access to ICTs? Are the poorest groups,
the discrepancies in our disaster response, which may otherwise have gone
undocumented.
option is to expand on the efforts of organizations like Télécoms Sans Frontières, who
and Léogâne. Unfortunately, due to resource constraints, their activities were limited
option would be to revamp local emergency services (after all, 911 is one of the oldest
the preceding analysis indicates, there are a number of potential pitfalls to over-
47
http://www.tsfi.org/en/action/emergencies/112-seisme-en-haiti-tsf-deploie-ses-
equipes
48
https://irevolution.wordpress.com/2010/09/22/911-system/
reliance on this kind of data. However, it should be acknowledged that these obstacles
are not insurmountable; crowdsourced reporting still retains enormous potential and
has a vital role to play in the future of humanitarian response. We must only be wary
http://ushahidi.com/media/c_Ushahidi-Election_Monitoring_Guide.pdf
http://irevolution.wordpress.com/2010/04/16/photosynth-to-allsynth/
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/14.06/crowds_pr.html
Howe, Jeff. Why the Power of the Crowd is Driving the Future of Business.
New York: Three Rivers Press, 2008, 2009.
http://mobileactive.org/howtos/mapping-sms-incident-reports-review-
ushahidi-and-managing-news
http://irevolution.wordpress.com/bio/
Greenough, P.G.; Chan, J.L.; Meier, P.; Bateman L. and Dutta S.
Applied Technologies in Humanitarian Assistance: Report of the 2009
Applied Technologies Working Group. Prehospital and Disaster Medicine,
Volume 24 (2), 2009.
Mills, Alexander; Chen, Rui; Lee, JinKyu and H. Raghav Rao. Web 2.0
Emergency Applications: How useful can Twitter be for emergency
response? Twitter for Emergency Management and Mitigation, 2009.
http://swift.ushahidi.com/
http://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eqinthenews/2010/us2010rja6/#de
tails
http://www.thestar.com/news/world/haiti/article/754255--haiti-s-leaders-
face-hell-of-a-job
Informal Briefing by Alain LeRoy, 12 January 2010 Informal Briefing by
Alain LeRoy, 12 January 2010 (available at
http://www.un.org/en/peacekeeping/missions/minustah/documents/nkolo_
haiti_statement_13012010.pdf)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8511997.stm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8510900.stm
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-
dyn/content/article/2010/01/15/AR2010011502650.html
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB100014240527487035690045750094939766
27772.html
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/01/17/2794043.htm?section=justi
n
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8463938.stm
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/01/17/2794190.htm
http://www.ihsi.ht/produit_demo_soc.htm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8466385.stm
http://haiti.ushahidi.com/
http://www.internews.org/articles/2010/20100125_msnbc_haiti.shtm
http://www.indiaprwire.com/pressrelease/telecommunications/201001144
1347.htm
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-
dyn/content/article/2010/01/18/AR2010011803833.html
http://www.digicelhaiti.com/en/coverage_roaming/coverage_map
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ha.html
http://www.tsfi.org/en/action/emergencies/112-seisme-en-haiti-tsf-deploie-
ses-equipes