Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Terrorism Financing in Australia 2014
Terrorism Financing in Australia 2014
financing in
Australia
2014
AUSTRAC contact details
If you have enquiries about the Australian Transaction
Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC), obligations
under the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter Terrorism
Financing Act 2006 or other related information, please
contact the AUSTRAC Help Desk:
Telephone: 1300 021 037 (local call cost within
Australia)
Email: help_desk@austrac.gov.au
Post: PO Box 5516 West Chatswood NSW 1515
The Help Desk operates from 8.30am to 5.00pm,
Monday to Friday.
Information is also available on AUSTRAC’s website at
www.austrac.gov.au
2
contents
Purpose 4
3
purpose
AUSTRAC has prepared this Terrorism financing As the global terrorism financing environment is
in Australia 2014 report to raise awareness and dynamic and rapidly changing, this report should
strengthen the national response to the serious be considered alongside any recent developments
threat of terrorism financing. The report is based that may affect Australia’s terrorism financing risk.
on a classified national risk assessment of the
Australian terrorism financing environment
completed by AUSTRAC in 2014 in collaboration How does AUSTRAC combat
with a number of key partner agencies, particularly
the Australian Federal Police (AFP).
terrorism financing?
This public report presents a consolidated picture AUSTRAC’s purpose is to protect the
of the Australian terrorism financing environment integrity of Australia’s financial system and
– current and emerging risks and threats, the contribute to the administration of justice
channels used to raise and transfer funds, through its expertise in countering money
indicators to help identify suspicious activity, and laundering and terrorism financing. It does
the legal and regulatory framework in place to this in two ways: as the national anti-money
help deter and detect terrorism financing. While laundering and counter-terrorism financing
classified and sensitive information has been (AML/CTF) regulator and as Australia’s
excluded from this public report, its key findings financial intelligence unit (FIU).
and terrorism financing methodologies, trends As the regulator, AUSTRAC monitors
and observations are consistent with the classified compliance with the Anti-Money Laundering
national risk assessment. and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006
This information will assist government, (AML/CTF Act) and takes enforcement
industry and the Australian community to action where necessary against breaches of
better understand terrorism financing risks the Act.
and vulnerabilities and implement appropriate In its capacity as Australia’s FIU, AUSTRAC
prevention measures. The report will also educate analyses financial transaction information
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | purpose
key community groups on the risks associated with and works with partner agencies, industry
sending funds to high-risk overseas destinations and international counterparts to identify
and recipients and promote understanding of patterns of suspicious activity and
AUSTRAC’s role and contribution to combating contribute to law enforcement operations.
terrorism financing.
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 complements
AUSTRAC’s Money laundering in Australia 2011
report to provide an overall picture of the
Australian money laundering and terrorism
financing environment. Combined with AUSTRAC’s
annual typologies and case studies reports, these
reports provide AUSTRAC’s reporting entities with
valuable background information to assess the
specific risks affecting their business.
4
key features of
the Australian
terrorism financing
environment
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | key features of the Australian terrorism financing environment
A risk to Australia’s national AUSTRAC has identified three key features of the
Australian terrorism financing environment:
security
»» Terrorism financing is largely motivated
Terrorism financing is a risk to Australia’s national by international tensions and conflicts.
security, financial system, commercial organisations Communal and sectarian links between groups
and not-for-profit organisations (NPOs). Primarily, overseas and individuals in Australia drives
terrorism financing is a national security risk as it Australian involvement in terrorism financing.
can directly enable terrorist acts both in Australia
and overseas. In Australia, individuals have been »» Use of conduit countries. In recent cases,
convicted of terrorism offences and funds have those sending funds out of Australia for
been raised to support domestic activity and terrorism financing tend to use conduit
overseas terrorist groups. countries rather than send the funds directly
In addition to funding individual terrorist to high-risk jurisdictions. This makes it more
attacks and operations, terrorism financing difficult for financial institutions to link the
helps establish and maintain terrorist groups in international funds transfers directly to
Australia and foreign countries and sustains the terrorism financing. Conduit countries may also
networks that connect them. Terrorism financing be used in an attempt to evade United Nations
supports the less violent or obvious aspects of Security Council sanctions and Australian
a group’s operations by paying for daily living autonomous sanctions.
expenses, travel, training, propaganda activities,
»» Commingling legitimate funds with
organisational costs, and compensation for
funds collected for terrorist groups. This
wounded fighters or the families and dependants
is especially the case for donations collected
of terrorists who have died.
through charities and NPOs. Commingling can
Terrorism financing also poses significant risks disguise funds raised for terrorism financing
to any organisation involved in the activity, even among legitimate donations. It can also add
if their involvement is unwitting. It can severely to the total pool of funds directed towards a
damage the reputation of financial institutions terrorist group.
misused as part of the process. The integrity and
work of non-government organisations such as
charities and humanitarian groups can be seriously
undermined if they are misused as a cover for
terrorism financing activity. 5
International dimensions Syria
Australia’s terrorism financing environment Australians have travelled to Syria to illegally
is largely influenced by international factors, engage in the conflict, raising a concern that they
particularly sectarian and other conflict in foreign will join terrorist groups engaged in fighting. This
countries beyond Australia’s immediate region. raises a significant risk that either they or their
Recent turmoil in parts of the Middle East and supporters will raise funds for terrorism-related
Africa raises significant terrorism financing risks purposes in Syria. At least two groups listed as
for Australia. Links exist between terrorist groups terrorist organisations by the Commonwealth
in these regions and radicalised individuals or Government, Jabhat al-Nusra (al-Nusra) and the
members of communities in Australia. Overseas Islamic State, are engaged in conflict against the
conflicts have prompted some Australians to Syrian regime. Hizballah has aligned itself with the
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | key features of the Australian terrorism financing environment
travel abroad to take part in combat and terrorist Syrian regime, and Hizballah’s External Security
or paramilitary training or to financially support Organisation is listed as a terrorist organisation in
armed political or terrorist groups. Australia.
Currently, the conflicts in Syria and Iraq pose Terrorist groups active in Syria have links with
the most significant terrorism financing risks radicalised individuals in Australia. The large
to Australia. Australian terrorism financing risks volume of humanitarian aid and financial
relating to the Syrian conflict are discussed in assistance sent from Australia to family
more detail below. Yemen and Somalia also pose and community members in Syria provides
ongoing terrorism financing risks and Australians opportunities for commingling or disguising funds
have provided financial support to, and travelled for terrorism financing among the legitimate
to train or fight with, terrorist groups in these transactions. Conflict in Syria creates a dynamic
countries. environment for terrorism financing, which may
lead to the use of new methods of fundraising and
Global terrorism financing risks may change
transferring funds.
quickly and unexpectedly where extremist groups
become involved in regional conflicts. Such Neighbouring countries including Lebanon,
scenarios can have a significant impact on the Turkey, the United Arab Emirates and Jordan have
Australian terrorism financing risk environment. been used as conduits to route money destined
The rapidly changing security situation in Iraq is for terrorist groups in Syria. These jurisdictions
a case in point. At the time of publication, the are targeted due to the comparative stability of
Islamic State1 occupied large parts of Iraq and their financial sectors and because funds sent to
presented a significant threat to the Government these countries are less likely to attract attention
of Iraq. With the involvement of some Australians than those sent directly to Syria. Cash may also be
in the conflict in Iraq, the risk of terrorism financing physically couriered into these conduit countries
involving Australia in relation to Iraq is likely to from Australia and carried overland across the
have increased. border into Syria.
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | key features of the Australian terrorism financing environment
own legitimately obtained funds to persons »» Charities and NPOs may be used to raise
engaged in conflict. There is also a significant funds for groups engaged in foreign conflict
risk that self-funding may be used to fund the and as a cover to transfer funds offshore. Funds
activities of any ‘lone wolf’ extremists within for legitimate humanitarian aid may also be
Australia. Lone wolf extremists act alone to plan diverted in Australia, or at their destination, and
or carry out violent acts in support of a group used to support terrorist groups.
or ideology, without support or assistance from
any group.
7
Terrorism financing indicators Terrorism financing indicators include:
Terrorism financing indicators are often »» Structured2 cash deposits and withdrawals,
indistinguishable from money laundering and international funds transfers to high-
indicators. Terrorism financing often, but not risk jurisdictions.3 These transactions may be
always, involves smaller amounts of money than conducted at multiple branches of the same
when illicit criminal funds are laundered. Funds reporting entity
intended for terrorism may also be derived from »» Multiple customers conducting international
legitimate rather than illicit sources, making funds transfers to the same beneficiary located
terrorism financing more difficult to detect. in a high-risk jurisdiction
Reporting entities may not always be able to
»» A customer conducting funds transfers to
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | key features of the Australian terrorism financing environment
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | key features of the Australian terrorism financing environment
»» Sudden increase in account activity,
inconsistent with customer profile
9
5 Ibid
Australia’s counter-
terrorism financing
framework
Australia’s AML/CTF regime »» conducting a money laundering and terrorism
financing risk assessment
Australia’s robust AML/CTF regime is the result
of close collaboration between AUSTRAC, »» developing and maintaining an AML/CTF
Australian businesses, domestic partner agencies, program
governments and international counterparts.
»» conducting AML/CTF training for employees
The AML/CTF Act and Financial Transaction Reports and agents
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | Australia’s counter-terrorism financing framework
Australia’s terrorism financing may raise funds for their own domestic use, as well as
provide funding to overseas groups with whom they
context sympathise.
Australia and its offshore interests continue to face
terrorist threats from individuals and groups who have The terrorism financing process
identified Australia as a specific target. In the past, The terrorism financing process typically involves
Australians have been the specific targets of overseas three stages:
terrorist attacks, while others travelling and working »» raising funds (such as through donations, self-
overseas have fallen victim to terrorist attacks directed funding or criminal activity)
at others. Individuals in Australia have also been
charged with and convicted of terrorism offences. »» transferring funds (to a terrorist network,
organisation or cell)
The amounts of funds generated to finance terrorism
vary between groups. Funds raised by groups that are »» using funds (for example, to purchase weapons
part of an international network can be significant, or bomb-making equipment, for payment to
particularly those with accounts and business fronts insurgents, or covering living expenses for a
established overseas. These groups have the financial terrorist cell).
infrastructure to undertake sizeable fundraising and
money transfer operations. Funds also need to be ‘stored’ at each stage of the
terrorism financing process. Storage methods can
Small domestic groups and lone wolf terrorists are
range from hiding cash in a private residence or in a
also a significant terrorism financing risk. While
‘sandooq’ (cash box) to depositing funds in a bank
the amounts raised by these radicalised groups or
»» self-funding from legitimate sources »» Funds sent overseas by charities with legitimate
intentions can also be intercepted when they
»» fraud, theft and drug trafficking reach their destination country and siphoned
off for use by terrorist groups.
15
Domestic charities and NPOs are at risk of being Self-funding from legitimate
misused by overseas terrorist groups which have a
supporter base among communities in Australia. sources
Some donors may willingly provide donations to
Smaller groups or individuals acting alone may
support the groups, while other donors, and the
seek to fund their activities themselves using
charities themselves, may be coerced, extorted or
legitimate sources, allowing them to raise
misled about the purpose of funding.
small-to-moderate amounts of money relatively
Charities and NPOs which operate in crises and inconspicuously.
war zones overseas are at risk of being infiltrated
In these cases, it can be difficult for financial
and exploited by terrorist groups in these areas.
institutions to distinguish transactions intended to
Funds sent to Syria and neighbouring countries
finance terrorism activities from ordinary day-to-
for humanitarian aid are at increased risk of
day transactions – in both cases the funds come
being used for financing terrorism if they are sent
from legitimate sources that are unlikely to attract
through less-established or start-up charities and
suspicion. For smaller extremist groups and lone
NPOs.
wolf actors, self-funding may provide them with
Those wanting to send funds to Syria for family sufficient resources to carry out an unsophisticated
and humanitarian purposes are advised to do so by but high-impact attack.
donating to a United Nations humanitarian agency
Self-funding can be as simple as a single extremist
or to an Australian humanitarian organisation. The
using legitimately obtained funds (in cash or from
Australian Council for International Development
a bank account) to make purchases to support a
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | raising funds to finance terrorism
16
case study
Suspects raised funds in
preparation for acts of terrorism9
Funds associated with the financing of terrorism The Sydney suspects regularly used false names to
can be derived from legitimate sources, including register mobile phones when purchasing supplies
the incomes of individuals or community donations, and materials for their activities. For example,
or through the proceeds of non-terrorism related members of the group established companies in
crimes (including fraud or robbery). By using a false names and used these companies to avoid
diversity of funding sources, those planning acts of suspicion when ordering and purchasing chemicals.
terrorism may attempt to distance themselves from
Four members of the Sydney group pleaded guilty
the origin of the funds generated to finance those
to various terrorism offences and received sentences
acts.
of imprisonment ranging between four years and
The following two related cases illustrate the eight months and 18 years and eight months. The
challenge of identifying terrorism financing, given remaining five members were found guilty by a jury
that it may model normal patterns of financial of conspiring to commit an act in preparation for a
behaviour, be undertaken through low-value terrorist attack under the Criminal Code Act 1995 and
transactions, or not involve the financial sector at all. sentenced to periods of imprisonment ranging from
23 to 28 years.
Part A – Sydney
Part B – Melbourne
18
Fraud, theft and drug trafficking Ransom payments
Funds from criminal activity such as fraud, theft Overseas terrorist groups use ransom payments
and drug trafficking have been linked to Australian to raise funds due to the large sums that can
terrorism cases. However, in Australia, ostensibly be generated. These groups have taken foreign
legitimate fundraising activities are more nationals hostage and demanded large amounts of
frequently used to fund terrorism than criminal money (from thousands to millions of dollars) from
activities. This is in contrast with the international the victim’s family, government or employer to
situation, where criminal activity features in a larger secure their release.
number of terrorism financing cases.
Kidnap-for-ransom is most prevalent in areas that
The low incidence of terrorism-related criminal are experiencing an active insurgency and are not
activity is one factor that currently distinguishes under effective government control. Australians
Australia’s risk environment from that of other living and working in these regions are at risk. The
democratic and economically advanced countries. Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT )
regularly updates travel advice for Australians
Criminal activity can generate large sources of
on the worldwide kidnapping threat and lists
funds reasonably quickly, making it attractive
countries where the threat of kidnapping is
to terrorist groups. In particular, small cells and
particularly prevalent.10
individual sympathisers may turn to crime if they
have no other significant source of income or Australia’s longstanding policy is that it does not
wider support network. In Australia, members of make payments or concessions to kidnappers
21
Australian financial institutions should ensure Compared to the banking sector, the remittance
their transaction monitoring programs are sector is involved in just a fraction of the total
dynamic and updated regularly to reflect current number of international funds transfers involving
terrorism financing threats. In particular, Australian Australia each year. However, while the total value
reporting entities should take into account of funds transferred via the remittance sector
international conflicts and tensions of concern is comparatively low, it is sufficient to assist in
to the Commonwealth Government because of obscuring low-value transfers associated with
their potential to affect Australia’s terrorism risk terrorism financing.
environment. Currently:
Remittance channels are commonly used by
»» funds sent to Syria and neighbouring countries migrant communities for legitimate purposes,
warrant scrutiny for possible terrorism financing particularly to send funds to family members
activity overseas. The sector exhibits a number of
characteristics that increase its risk of being
»» transactions involving other countries facing misused for terrorism financing:
insurgency or terrorist threats, such as Yemen
»» The sector is commonly used to transfer funds
and Somalia, or neighbouring countries with
to high-risk countries for legitimate purposes,
established financial sectors, may also involve
including jurisdictions where formal banking
terrorism financing risks.
networks may not be available. This can make it
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | transferring funds to finance terrorism
The Australian remittance sector is an attractive »» Remittance dealers who rely on ethnic or
vehicle for terrorism financing. Along with the cultural links to send funds to high-risk
banking sector, it carries a higher risk than most terrorism financing jurisdictions are at greatest
other channels of being exploited to transfer funds risk of being abused. However, these dealers
for terrorism financing. This is due largely to the are also well placed to identify and report
sector’s utility, including its low cost to transfer suspicious behaviour. They often provide a
smaller amounts of funds and its ability to reach service to customers from their own local
high-risk countries and regions where more formal community, and may know their customers’
financial channels are less accessible. financial activities better than many other
reporting entities, putting them in a good
Australian authorities have identified that some
position to identify unusual and suspicious
domestic remittance businesses have been
customer behaviour. These suspicions must be
misused for terrorism financing. To date, the
reported to AUSTRAC.12
amounts involved have been small, reflecting the
overall low incidence of terrorism financing in
Australia more generally.
23
what should I do if
I suspect terrorism
financing?
AUSTRAC reporting entities Individuals and non-reporting
Reporting entities under the AML/CTF Act must entities
submit an SMR to AUSTRAC if, while dealing with a Members of the community and businesses who
customer, they reasonably suspect a matter may be are not reporting entities under the AML/CTF Act
related to an offence, tax evasion or the proceeds can report suspicious activity via the Government‘s
of crime. National Security Hotline. Callers may remain
Terrorism financing in Australia 2014 | what should I do if I suspect terrorism financing?