Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Comparative Analysis of Electrical Parameters For Three Phase
Comparative Analysis of Electrical Parameters For Three Phase
ABSTRACT
Busbar Trunking system is one of the most widely used in electrical power distribution in place of cable. The
major reasons behind the popularity of the BBT is flexibility in design, on-site installation times are reduced,
most efficient, safe and ideal system for electricity supply to industrial installations and high rise structures.
Busbar Trunking system is the need of electrical power distribution for low voltage and high current system.
Due to all reasons, basic design of Busbar Trunking System and effect of electrical parameters on design and
operation of Busbar Trunking System must be studied and analyse. Larsen & Toubro is currently in the process
of designing and testing of BBT for low or medium voltage and higher current ratings. For the design of busbar
trunking system used the standard IEC 61439 part 1 and part 6. As a consequence they are undertaking
considerable research into the design and operation of busbar and the factors affecting the busbar. This project
was undertaken in order to comprehensively understand the effect of various phenomena such as skin effect,
proximity effect, inductance, magnetic fields, electrodynamics forces, contact resistance and permittivity of
insulation material on the performance of busbar trunking system and its significance in design in real time
scenario. Another study that was undertaken for examine the temperature rise and its effects on a busbar
trunking system under normal operating conditions. The approach to these tasks involved considerable
research, the use of mathematical tools for the implementation and verification of any developed mathematical
models, and in some cases the use of software such as FEMM to understand certain phenomena affecting
busbars. Additionally, certain physical testing was also undertaken on a model at the Switchgear Testing
Laboratories.
Keywords: Busbar, Skin Effect, Proximity Effect, Electrodynamic force, FEMM, Magnetic Field, Reactance.
IJSRST1845485 | Received : 05 April 2018 | Accepted : 20 April 2018 | March-April-2018 [ (4) 5 : 1698-1709]
1698
Shivraj P. Kalane et al. Int J S Res Sci. Tech. 2018 Mar-Apr;4(5) : 1698-1709
operating conditions, the direct and indirect effects of general conclusion, the numerical model developed
these phenomena on the busbars and provide some can be considered accurate enough to use it in the
standardized procedures and mathematical models to first steps of the busbar design. A thermal model of a
cross-check existing designs and put these all together low voltage non-segregated three-phase assembly is
in a user-friendly manner for use by the design developed in this article using COMSOL
engineer. The main objective of the work was to study Multiphysics with the intention to obtain a
and understand various electrical parameters and their computational prototype which eases us the design of
effects on the design and operation of busbar trunking this type of BBT. The model results are validated by
systems. Develop a mathematical model for the means of the comparison with the results of a heating
calculation of certain basic parameters of a busbar test. This test has been performed according IEC
impedance and analysis with software result. A study standard.
of the impacts of fault currents was also required,
especially the resulting electromagnetic forces, and a According to Agus Risdiyanto, Maulana Arifin, Umar
study of the mechanical strength of the enclosure Khayam, Suwarno, The measurement of temperature
based on these studies. Additionally, there was a on busbar connection based on contact resistance and
requirement to study the temperature rise of the plating material in relation to the value of contact
busbars under normal operating conditions. Finally resistance. This study is intended to prevent failure
tested the permittivity of insulating material by when busbar connection is attached. The failure of
performing the high voltage test and suggest the new the electrical connection can occur due to bad
insulating material for BBT and also calculate the contact so that the contact resistance is increased,
contact resistance between the joints of BBT system high losses, overheating, and it can even cause a fire
for two shapes of spring plate. hazard. There are three test samples of modeled:
copper busbar connection without plating, copper
II. LITERATURE REVIEW busbar connection with nickel plating and copper
busbar connection with silver plating. The contact
According to F.Delgado, C.Renedo, A.Ortiz, The resistance of each sample was measured at contact
thermal behaviour of an industrial Low Voltagenon- pressure of 12 MPa. Subsequently the samples loaded
segregated three-phase Busbar Trunking is analyzed with the current of 350A and temperature at the
by means of the comparison of a 3D numerical model connection was measured and simulated until steady
with experimental results. This model has been state condition reached. The results show that the
carried out using COMSOL Multiphysics, software temperature at the contact area is higher than that of
based on finite element method. The numerical busbar appears caused by the contact resistance. Both
model replicates the short-circuit test, using the same measurement and simulation results show that busbar
geometry configuration and the boundary conditions connection with silver plating having lower contact
of the laboratory in which this assay is carried out. resistance and lower maximum temperature,
The standard IEC 61439 is applied, both in test and followed by the connection with the nickel plating
model, in order to obtain the steady state and busbar connection without plating.
temperatures in several parts of the busbar system. As
a result of the data comparison can be concluded that According to Y. J. Bao, K.W.E.Cheng, K.
the experimental testis replicated with sufficient Ding,D.H.Wang, The busbar has been widely used in
accuracy by the numerical model. In fact, the average electrical & electronic industry because of the
error of all the temperatures is smaller than 5%.As a demand of the high power transition and the rapid
development of the busbar technology. However, For the purposes of testing the models, developed
with increasingly demand in building applications, it several busbar dimensions, as specified in the
is needed to be developed for the high-performance catalogues of several companies were used. The
and multi-functional busbar. The materials used as following values for Aluminium and Copper
busbars and then different busbar types are given. conductor dimensions For Sandwich Insulated Busbar
After that, the busbar model and parameters are Trunking System.
discussed. Finally, some failure events of the busbar
system happened in cities are introduced and the Table 1:- Aluminium conductor dimensions For
reasons are analyzed, as well as some solutions Sandwich Insulated Busbar
proposed In modern cities, there are lots of the high- Trunking System.
rise buildings in different districts, the majority of
these buildings adopted the busbar system for power
transmission because of the limited space and
reliability consideration. In generally, the building
lifetime is more than 50 years, but the busbar lifetime
is generally not as long as that. So it is very important
to design, construct and maintain the busbar system
for the buildings.
problem geometry. Specify the depth of problem rectangular BBT system as per dimension given in
geometry into page direction. All the input enters the table 3 by using drawing tool in pre-processor mode.
window as shown in fig. 4.3. Figure 4.4 show the geometry of three phase four wire
rectangular BBT system as per given dimension. Enter
the Material property in block property dialogue box
and assign the material to the different parts in the
geometry, also define the boundary condition for the
problem. Figure 4.6 show the complete geometry in
preprocessor mode for meshing the model, analysing
the model, and viewing the results.
V. CONCLUSION
From the mathematical model values have been Surface”Joint International Conference on Rural
calculated and compared to the values given in Information & Communication Technology and
catalogue for resistance and reactance. Very small Electric-Vehicle Technology (rICT & ICeV-
percentage of difference between the experimental T)November 26-28, 2016, Bandung-Bali,
and calculate value. The mathematical model result Indonesia
also verified by using FEMM software. The [3] Y. J. Bao, K.W.E.Cheng, K. Ding, D.H.Wang,
electrodynamics forces were to be calculated based “The Study on the Busbar System and its Fault
on the short time withstand current (1 second) for Analysis” Power Electronics Systems and
the bus conductors in a three phase system. The Applications (PESA), 5th International
available force data provided to the Mechanical Conference, Dec 2013
Engineer. Based on these forces, sizing and design of [4] E. T. CARLSON, “Enclosed Busbar Electrical
the conductors, enclosures, accessories, and support Distribution System”IEEE Electrical
structures should be design such as they are Engineering, Volume: 60, June 1941
mechanically strong enough to withstand these
[5] M Chiampi, D Chiarabaglio, M Tartagli, “FEM
forces and maintain normal operation.
ANALYSIS AND MODELLING OF BUSBAR
As per the specific work undertaken, the model
SYSTEMS UNDER AC CONDITIONS” IEEE,
designed for the calculation of impedance is expected
International Conference on Computation in
to be used for validation in upcoming design projects
electromagnetics, August 2002.
of the conductors in three phase busbar systems. The
[6] S. Schlegel, S. Grosmann, H. Lobl, “Joint
electrodynamic forces are to be used by a mechanical
resistance of bolted copper - copper busbar
engineer for studies onto the mechanical withstand
joints depending on joint force at temperatures
of the busbar enclosure. The practical
beyond 105 °C” The 56th IEEE Conference on
experimentation on the insulation used for
Electrical Contacts, November 2010
Aluminium busbar trunking systems was a step in the
complete ad rigorous testing of the insulation. As the [7] Farhana Mohamad Yusop, Mohamad Kamarol
undertaken experiments were deemed successful it Mohd Jamil, Dahaman Ishak and Syafrudin
has since moved on to successive, more exhaustive Masri, “Study on the Electromagnetic Force
stages in its testing. From the available theoretical Affected by Short-Circuit Current in Vertical
data, we can easily designed and analyze, any range and Horizontal Arrangement of Busbar System”
of BBT system for future modification. International Conference on Electrical, Control
and Computer Engineering Pahang, Malaysia,
VI.REFERENCES June 21-22, 2011
[8] S. W. Kim, H. H. Kim, S. C. Hahn, B. Y. Lee, K.
[1] F.Delgado, C.Renedo, A.Ortiz, and I. Fernandez, Y. Park, Y. J. Shin, W. P. Song, J. B. Kim, and I.
“Numerical Model of a Three-Phase Busbar H. Shin, “Coupled Finite-Element–Analytic
Trunking System”Electrical Insulation Technique for Prediction of Temperature Rise in
Conference (EIC), Montréal, Qc, Canada, 19 - 22 Power Apparatus”, IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON
June 2016. MAGNETICS, VOL.38, NO. 2, MARCH 2002.
[2] Agus Risdiyanto, Maulana Arifin, Umar [9] S. L. Ho, Y. Li, X. Lin, H. C. Wong, and K. W.
Khayam, Suwarno, “Study on Temperature E. Cheng, “A 3-D Study of Eddy Current Field
Distribution at Busbar Connection Based on and Temperature Rises in a Compact Bus Duct
Contact Resistance of Different Plating Contact