Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Impacto Covid en Ortodoncistas
Impacto Covid en Ortodoncistas
Impacto Covid en Ortodoncistas
J Orthodontics
I
D Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
A Saptarshi Roy1, Kuldeep Dmello2, Atul Singh3
Abstract
Brief Background
As there have been 15,785,641 confirmed cases of
COVID-19 Pandemic, including 640,016 deaths around
the world till 26 July 2020, and Lockdown has been
implemented in most of the nations, the Orthodontic
specialty is affected extensively due to this. So a study
was conducted to determine the impact of the COVID-19
outbreak on the specialty of Orthodontics and how the
situation was being managed around the globe.
Discussion
DOI: 10.33882/jida.15.28786 Anticipating the situation that how this lockdown has
affected the Orthodontic practice, the results revealed
that most Orthodontists are bearing the repression and
repercussions together at the same time.
The 2 main steps for controlling the situation are Materials and Methods
to limit the spread of the infection and improve the
The survey was conducted from April 23rd, 2020 to May
healthcare system of each country. On January 30, the
06, 2020. The questionnaire was formed using Google
World Health Organization (WHO) announced that this
Forms because this platform is free and easy to use for
outbreak constituted a global public health emergency
both the researchers & respondents. The questionnaire
and declared it a pandemic. By declaring a nationwide
was created in English which consisted of 24 questions,
lockdown, India has retrenched the spread of this virus to
both close-ended and open-ended.
a certain extent. However, the total number of reported
cases as of 2:31 pm CEST, 26 July 2020, has crossed The first section was asked for general information
14,36,019 with approximately 32,812 deaths and these about the respondent like their Email address and work
numbers continue to rise. Because of the widespread area. In the second section, the respondents were asked
transmission of SARS-CoV-2, healthcare providers are at about their situation of practicing during the pandemic,
a high risk of getting affected by the virus and becoming how they are handling patients, and also the level of
potential carriers of the disease. awareness about WHO guidelines among Orthodontists.
The third section contained some questions related to
According to Occupational Safety and Health
mediclaim and life insurance they have if accidentally
Administration (OSHA), Dentists, including Orthodontists,
they get exposed. The fourth Section includes the
are placed in a very high exposure risk category because
involvements and mental condition during the outbreak
they work in close proximity to the patient’s oral cavity5.
and most importantly what they are expecting about
The routes of transmission may include, respiratory
post-pandemic economic crisis.
droplets coming from coughing and sneezing during any
Orthodontic Procedure, aerosol created while using an air The online link of the questionnaire was distributed
rotor during de-bonding, indirect contact such as droplets by e-mail via personal invitation, posted on Facebook,
32
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
Results
The Questions and their responses to the Survey are
illustrated in the tables and the figures (1-5).
Fig.4: How quickly you feel the need to open your clinic?
Fig.5: Sequence of Removal of PPE and Sequence of Putting on PPE (Source- CDC)
33
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
A total of 226 responses to the study were acquired practice. As 37.17% of respondents have rented clinics,
from all over India and 3 other countries. The invitation 50% of them opined that they are unable to pay the rent
was mainly sent to different WhatsApp groups of both of their clinic. Almost 47.79% of respondents opined
clinicians and PG students. The response rate was good. that more than 80% of their patients are well aware
Only complete responses were received, as most of the of this emergency and 46.02% have opined that they
questions were mandatory. receive only less than 2 calls a day from their patients for
orthodontic emergencies.
Table 1 shows that most of the respondents (38.94%)
were PG students. And 96.46% of all respondents believe The majority of the respondents (56.64%) expressed
that this Pandemic has affected their routine Orthodontic their opinion that they have not attended a single patient
Table 1
Govt Combination
Q. No/ Type of Academician Consultancy PG Student Private Total
Responses hospital/ of any of the
Respondents (4) (14) (88) clinic (44) (226)
college(12) above(64)
Percentage
Q1. What is your
of 1.77 6.19 5.31 38.94 19.47 28.32 100.00
area of work?
Respondents
Q2. Do you think Yes 75.00 100.00 100.00 97.73 95.45 95.31 96.46
Covid-19 has No 25.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.69 1.77
affected your
routine orthodontic Can’t Say 0.00 0.000 0.00 2.27 4.55 0.00 1.77
practice?
Q3. What is your Own 25.00 0.00 0.00 9.10 36.37 53.13 26.10
practice type if Rented 25.00 71.43 25.00 20.45 52.27 45.31 37.17
you are a private Not
practitioner? 50.00 28.57 75.00 70.45 11.36 1.56 36.73
Applicable
Q4. Are you able Able 100.00 40.00 0.00 16.67 26.09 20.69 27.38
to pay the rent of Not Able 0.00 40.00 66.67 66.67 69.57 77.33 50.00
your clinic, if you
practice in a rented May Be 0.00 20.00 33.33 16.67 30.43 9.05 22.62
clinic?
Q5. What <20% 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.14 4.55 4.69 2.65
percentage of your <25% 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.56 0.44
patients are aware 20%-40% 0.00 14.29 33.33 15.91 31.82 7.81 17.26
of the emergency
40%-80% 0.00 14.29 16.67 39.77 25.00 34.38 31.86
situation and
understand that
their treatment will >80% 100.00 71.42 50.00 43.18 38.64 51.56 47.79
be delayed due to
this pandemic?
0 0.00 7.14 0.00 3.41 4.55 4.69 3.98
Q6. From how
many patients <2 25.00 21.43 33.33 50.00 38.64 54.69 46.02
you get calls 2-5 75.00 28.57 58.34 34.09 43.18 21.88 34.07
on a daily basis 6-10 0.00 35.71 8.33 9.09 4.55 12.50 10.62
for Orthodontic 11-20 0.00 7.14 0.00 3.41 9.09 3.13 4.42
emergencies?
>20 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.13 0.89
34
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
during this lockdown (Table 2) and 65.7% complaints want to imply every possible method for protecting their
from patients in an emergency are with Broken brackets clinical practices from COVID-19. Maximum responses
and molar tube or bands. were for updating knowledge by watching Webinars and
reading books when they were asked about how they
Table 3 shows that 59.29% of assistance is being required
were engaging themselves during this lockdown. There
for the conventional Labial Bracket system. The majority
was a short answer type question in Q. no. 17 that,
of respondents believe that it would take 3-6 months
what are you going to do if you come across a COVID 19
for Orthodontic practice to be normalized. 91.59 % of
susceptible case accidentally? And Majority have replied
respondents are aware of WHO guidelines for health
that they will refer the patient to the COVID hospital
workers regarding COVID-19 but only 34.96% of
immediately and quarantine himself for 14 days.
respondents are certified for any online course by WHO.
38.50% of respondents do not want to burden the extra From Table 5 we could know that majority of respondents
cost of PPE to patients. don’t know the dosage of Hydroxychloroquine. The
majority of respondents want a financial package from
Table 4 tells that, 95.13% of respondents feel the need
Govt. and Major Orthodontists are scared of the situation.
for PPE for their assistants. About 63% of respondents
Table 2
Combination
Q. No/ Type of Academician Govt hospital/ PG Private
Responses Consultancy of any of the Total
Respondents (4) college Student clinic
above
0 75.00 42.86 25.00 69.32 38.64 59.38 56.64
Q7. How many
emergency <5 25.00 28.57 66.67 23.86 27.27 26.56 27.88
Orthodontic 6-10 0.00 14.29 8.33 4.55 27.27 7.81 10.62
patients have 11-15 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
you attended in 16-20 0.00 14.29 0.00 2.27 2.27 4.69 3.54
this lockdown?
>20 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.55 1.56 1.33
Q8. Select the Loose Ligatures
options for (Elastomeric or 27.5%
which you are Metallic)
receiving most
number of Broken/loose
calls from your brackets, bands 65.7%
Orthodontic or molar t…
patients in this
Lockdown. Impinging wire 52.2%
(multiple
Loose TADS
options can be
or any such 2.8%
selected)
auxiliary
Loose
Functional 6.7%
Appliance
Loose Retainers 12.4%
Swelling or
11.2%
trauma
Soft tissue
24.2%
soreness
None 9%
35
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
Table 3
Combination
Q. No/ Type of Academician Govt hospital/ PG Private
Responses Consultancy of any of the Total
Respondents (4) college Student clinic
above
Aligners 0.00 0.00 0.00 50.00 0.00 50.00 100.00
Conventional
Q9. What 1.49 6.72 2.99 41.04 23.13 24.63 100.00
labial braces
appliance system
Functional
is requiring 0.00 4.55 22.73 27.27 27.27 18.18 100.00
Appliances
maximum
Lingual braces 7.69 3.85 3.85 50.00 3.85 30.77 100.00
assistance during
the lockdown? Removable
0.00 0.00 25.00 50.00 25.00 0.00 100.00
Appliances
None 0.00 9.38 3.13 25.00 15.63 46.88 100.00
0-1 Month 0.0 14.29 16.67 3.41 13.64 3.13 6.64
Q10. According
1-3 Month 25.00 35.71 16.67 38.64 18.18 29.69 30.53
to you how much
time will it take 3-6 Month 75.00 14.29 58.33 28.41 29.55 42.19 34.07
to normalize >6 Month 0.00 35.71 0.00 25.00 36.36 21.88 25.22
orthodontic Can’t Say 0.00 0.00 8.33 4.55 2.27 3.13 3.54
practice once the
pandemic COVID
19 is over?
36
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
Table 4
Combination
Q. No/ Type of Academician Govt hospital/ PG Private
Responses Consultancy of any of the Total
Respondents (4) college Student clinic
above
Q14. Do you Yes 100.00 92.86 100.00 93.18 95.45 96.88 95.13
feel need of No 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.41 4.55 0.00 2.21
PPE for your
Assistant? Can’t Say 0.00 7.14 0.00 3.41 0.00 3.13 2.65
Q15. What Aerosol aspirator 10.1%
are other PPE 18.5%
modifications
Fumigation 11.8%
you are going to
apply for your HEPA Filter 5.1%
practice in post Ultraviolet
COVID era? Germicidal 6.2%
Irradiation
Infrared
7.9%
thermometer
Disinfection
12.4%
spray
Disinfect
waterlines using 9.6%
0.01% NaOCL
All of the Above 63.5%
None of above 2.8%
Q22. How
Updating
did you keep
Knowledge
yourself 78.7 %
by attending
occupied during
webinar…
this lockdown
period?
Exploring old
(Multiple 44.4%
hobbies
options can be
selected) Doing Yoga or
42.1%
home fitness
Watching movies
49.4%
online
Totally Stressed
8.4%
out or depressed
Learning a new
technique or 33.1%
hobby
Other 15.7%
37
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
Table 5
Govt Combination
Q. No/ Type of Academician PG Private
Responses Consultancy hospital/ of any of the Total
Respondents (4) Student clinic
college above
Q16. Do you Yes 25.00 35.71 8.33 31.82 36.36 20.31 28.32
think that the No 25.00 28.58 33.33 29.55 29.55 32.81 30.53
prophylactic
dose of hydroxyl-
chloroquine
applicable to Can’t Say 50.00 35.71 58.33 38.64 34.09 46.88 41.15
Orthodontists
treating a
susceptible case?
Q18. Do you feel Yes 25.00 42.86 50.00 69.32 63.64 68.75 64.60
that the Govt. No 0.00 21.43 8.33 11.36 13.64 17.19 13.72
should give a
package for May Be 75.00 35.71 41.67 19.32 22.73 14.06 21.68
Orthodontists to
come out of this
crisis situation?
Q19. Do you feel
Yes 100.00 100.00 83.33 93.18 72.73 82.81 86.28
scared for you and
your family with No 0.00 0.00 8.33 2.27 15.91 7.81 6.64
regards to COVID
19? Can’t Say 0.00 0.00 8.33 4.55 11.36 9.38 7.08
Q20. Do you Yes 50.00 35.71 16.67 25.00 25.00 39.06 29.65
have sufficient
Mediclaim No 0.00 57.14 50.00 62.50 54.55 43.75 53.54
insurance to cover
yourself for any
unwanted health
Can’t Say 50.00 7.14 33.33 12.50 20.45 17.19 16.81
situation including
COVID-19?
Q21. Do you have
Yes 100.00 50.00 41.67 44.32 68.18 65.63 56.19
any Life insurance
for yourself to
No 0.00 50.00 33.33 50.00 29.55 32.81 39.38
safeguard and
cover your family? Can’t Say 0.00 0.00 25.00 5.68 2.27 1.56 4.42
Q23. How quickly Open clinic as
you feel the need soon as this 25.00 21.43 8.33 2.27 31.82 23.44 15.93
to open your Lockdown ends
clinic? Take all the risks
and open clinic
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.27 3.13 1.33
very soon even if
lockdown extends
Can't take any
risk and will wait
till the situation
75.00 71.43 41.67 57.95 52.27 67.19 59.73
goes to normal
and then open
my clinic
CAN'T SAY 0.00 7.14 50.00 39.77 13.64 6.25 23.01
38
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
Q24. With the Yes 50.00 66.67 66.67 63.64 75.00 76.56 69.03
decline in income
of the people No 0.00 41.67 8.33 14.77 6.82 14.06 13.72
and fall of Global
economy, do you
expect a decline
in orthodontic Can’t Say 50.00 8.33 25.00 21.59 18.18 9.38 17.25
requirement in the
World?
Although a major portion of respondents (53.54%) don’t and equipment, rent of clinics, salary to staffs, the bill
have any Mediclaim and but 56.19% have life insurance for water, phone, electricity, internet, etc. And now this
to safeguard their family from any unwanted condition. Pandemic added some extra expenditure that includes
Most of the respondents (59.73%) don’t want to take newer personal protective equipment (PPE), N95 masks,
any risk and wanted to open a clinic when the situation face shields, head, and shoe covers, alcohol-based hand
goes to normal. Maximum respondents (69.03%) believe rubs, additional disinfectants, chemomechanical agents,
that there will be a decline in Orthodontic treatment need aerosol reduction measures such as HEPA filter, HVAC,
around the world, with a decline in the global economy. and newer antiretraction hand-pieces.
39
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
Most of the respondents want to imply every possible vaccine against coronavirus among several other Vaccine
method for protecting their clinical practices from candidates those are in trials, as it goes for phase III. And
COVID-19 because a majority of them are scared of the Phase I & II had shown commendable results as claimed
situation according to this study and for this, they don’t by the co-authors. Serum Institute of India (SII), which
want to open their clinic until all situation goes normal. had a partnership with AstraZeneca for manufacturing
Universal precautions are crucial to minimize the spread the University of Oxford vaccine candidate, has got
of this virus and its associated disease. That includes 1) permission from the Drugs Controller General of India
Taking of proper History of the patient before starting (DCGI) for conducting Phase II and III human clinical trials,
treatment, 2) Use of PPE, Face mask or N95 respirators, which will be named as Covishield in India.
face shield, Goggles, 3) Must use of HVAC, 4) Keeping air
Covaxin, which is Developed by Bharat Biotech in
in and air out system in clinics whether its AC or combined
collaboration with ICMR and the National Institute of
with exhaust. 5) Using Disposable covering for chairs and
Virology (NIV), has started its Phase I trial in AIIMS and
panels, 6) Proper donning and doffing of PPE, face mask
PGI Rohtak recently.
and face shield, 7) Proper Hand sanitization[8,9].
Conclusion
Proper hand hygiene practices play an important role
in preventing the spread of infection. “Five Moments Collected data of the survey shows that COVID-19 has
of hand hygiene” by WHO, defines key moments that affected Orthodontic practice in various aspects. We
Orthodontists must carry out before and after each need to modify and adapt ourselves for each and every
procedure. The CDC recommended alcohol-based hand orthodontic procedure to be done in the future. From
rub or handwashing with soap and water for at least 20 Diagnosis and treatment planning to Leveling &Alignment,
seconds. Space closure, Finishing & detailing, Debonding, and
Retention phase we need to update all our practice
All respondents were well aware of using personal procedures. We need to implement a huge modification
protective equipment (PPE) for post-COVID-19 in the clinical setup, sterilization protocols, personal
Orthodontic practice. The CDC has provided Interim hygiene & safety, safety for staff and receptionists.
Infection Prevention and Control Recommendations Several challenging situations may arise constantly for
and sequence for “donning and doffing” PPE10(Fig. 5). the Orthodontists regarding economic constrain, treating
The N95 respirator should be preferred over a normal patients, and many more. But there is a phrase: “Even the
surgical face mask while performing aerosol-generating darkest night will end and the sun will rise.” So we must
procedures on patients, otherwise, a normal Surgical face keep in our mind that this period is not the end, it is just
mask is enough. Disposable face shields and gloves must a pause, which is to reform ourselves with positivity and
be used while performing clinical procedures. Proper wisdom.
disposal of the used masks and gloves must be learned
and maintained. Acknowledgments
A special Thanks to the Indian Orthodontic Society, We are really grateful to all 226 Orthodontists who
Dental Council of India and so many Dental colleges for responded to the survey. We respect the valuable time
conducting a lot of webinars and keeping all Orthodontists paid for the questionnaire by all of them. We salute them.
occupied in this lockdown period as told by the majority A special Thanks to Dr. Asesh Chakrabarti who have
of respondents. Physical and mental health improvement done the statistical analysis and helped us in every step
by doing yoga, meditation, and consuming fresh air for this article to be framed.
is essential for the Orthodontists in this testing time to Ethical Apology
relieve the psychological stress.
The episode of this pandemic & this Lockdown is totally
Although a ray of hope is seen as a team of scientists new for our generation and society, so, there might be
at Oxford Vaccine Group (Department of Paediatrics) and a biasedness or intuition among the respondents while
Oxford University’s Jenner Institute are at the doorstep responding and so, a scientific logical analysis might not
for the discovery of a safe, effective, and accessible justify the results.
40
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Impact of COVID 19 upon Orthodontists: An Opinion Study
References
1. Zhou P, Yang X-L, Wang X-G, et al. A pneumonia outbreak 6. American Dental Association. “What constitutes a dental
associated with a new coronavirus ofprobable bat origin, emergency” https://success.ada.org/~/media/CPS/Files/
Nature, 2020; 579;p.270–3. Open%20Files/ADA_COVID19_Dental_Emergency_DDS.pdf
2. Zhu N, Zhang D, Wang W, et al. A novel coronavirus from 7. Gyawali R, Pokharel PR, Giri J. Emergency appointments
patients with pneumonia in China, 2019, N Engl J Med, 2020; inorthodontics,APOS Trends Orthod,2019; 9(1); p. 40-3.
382(8); p. 727–33.
8. Khadijah A. TurkistaniJeddah, Saudi Arabia. Precautions and
3. Parin Bhanushali, Farhin Katge, Shantanu Deshpande, Vamsi recommendations fororthodontic settings during theCOVID-19
Krishna Chimata,Shilpa Shetty, and Debapriya Pradhan. outbreak: A review,Am J OrthodDentofacial Orthop, 2020;
COVID-19: Changing Trends and Its Impact on Future of
Dentistry, HindawiInternational Journal of Dentistry,Volume 9. Sunjay Suri; Yona R. Vandersluis; Anuraj S. Kochhar; Ritasha
2020; Bhasin; Mohamed-Nur Abdallah Clinical orthodontic
management during the COVID-19 pandemic,Angle Orthod,
4. World Health Organization: Coronavirus disease 2019 2020; 90 (4);p. 473–84.
(COVID-19)-73, situation report, www.who.int/docs/default-
source/coronaviruse/situation-reports/20200402-sitrep-73- 10.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Interim
covid-19.pdf?sfvrsn=5ae25bc7_6 ,April 2, 2020, (accessed July infectionprevention and control recommendations for patients
26, 2020) with suspected or confirmed coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)
inhealthcare settings, www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/
5. Srirengalakshmi M., Adith Venugopal, Paolo Jesus P. Pangilinan, hcp/infection-control-recommendations.html, April 13, 2020,
Paolo Manzano,Jassin Arnold,Björn Ludwig,Jason B. Cope,S. (accessed July 25, 2020)
Jay Bowman. Orthodontics in the COVID-19 Era:The Way
ForwardPart 1 Office Environmental and Infection Control, J.
Clin Orthod, 2020; p. 334
41
J I D A - Jou rn al of I n d i an D ent al Asso ciatio n - Vo l 15 - Issue 6 - June 2021
Copyright of JIDA: Journal of Indian Dental Association is the property of Indian Dental
Association and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a
listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print,
download, or email articles for individual use.