Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Fast Instantaneous Method For Sequence Extraction: Rodrigo Cutri / Lourenço Matakas Junior
A Fast Instantaneous Method For Sequence Extraction: Rodrigo Cutri / Lourenço Matakas Junior
Abstract –Harmonics and unbalance causes several III. PROPOSED METHOD FOR CALCULATING THE
problems to equipments connected in AC mains. This
INSTANTANEOUS REFERENCE
work proposes a real time method to obtain the positive
and negative sequence components and/or harmonics
that require nor coordinate transform neither signal A. Algorithm description
filtering. Numerical simulation and experimental results
are showed to validate the proposed method. Eq. (1) calculates the phasors of the symmetrical
• • •
components ( S , S , S ) of a set of
0 + − three phase signals
• • •
Keywords – active filters, harmonics, power quality, (current or voltage) ( S R , S S , ST ) [24] and [33]:
sequence extraction, protection relays
• • • (1)
S•0 1 1 1 S R S•R
I. INTRODUCTION S = 1 .1 1 120º 1 − 120º . S = M. S
•
•+ 3 S •S
S − 1 1 − 120º 1 120º • ST
Distorted and unbalanced voltages/currents in electric S
14444244443 T
systems cause several negative effects in power systems M
[7],[12], [23]-[29],[35],[36]. Zero sequence signals can be extracted using (2). To get
Real time extraction of unbalances and/or or harmonics is the unbalanced signals, in three-phase three wire systems, it
demanded in some applications like active compensators and is necessary to separate the negative sequence (3).
protective relays. Many strategies were developed for • • •
S (2) 0 0 S R (3)
unbalanced components and/or harmonics extraction [1]-[4], S 0 1 1 1 1 •R 0 0
0 = .0 0 0. S S 0 = 1 .0 0
•
0 . S S
[6], [8], [9], [11], [13]-[18], [20], [21], [22], [26], [28], [29], 3 • • 3
0 0 0 S S − 1 1 − 120º 1 120º •
[31], [32],[34] and [35]. Among them, the well known 0 ST
T
methods are: positive synchronous reference frame (RSP)
and negative synchronous reference frame (RSN) [8], [26], To obtain the desired signals in rst frame it is necessary to
the real time detection using space vectors (DTRVE) [32], multiply the signals of (3) by the inverse matrix (M-1) from
the instantaneous active and reactive theory (PQ) [2],[30] (1), so obtain (4).
and the direct injection of negative sequence (DSNI) [9]. A
comparative study about some of these strategies is done by • • • (4)
S ref _ r − 0 0 0 S R −1 1 60º 1 − 60º S R
[5], [10] and [19]. S • = M −1. 1 .0 • 1 •
ref _ s − 0 0 . S S = − .1 − 60º −1 1 60º . S S
This paper is based on the work developed by [10],[34]. It 3 3 •
S •
1 1 − 120º 1 120º •
S
T 1 60 º 1 − 60 º − 1 ST
proposes an algorithm based on the “symmetrical ref _ t −
components theory” that requires nor coordinate transform
neither signal filtering. It uses only algebraic calculations. The matrix operation showed in (4) can be divided into
This method allows extracting only the fundamental positive two matrixes: the first one contains the real terms and second
and/or negative sequence and/or harmonics (section 3). one the imaginary terms multiplied by –j, according (5).
Experimental results using Matlab - Simulink software and
Analog DSP ADMC401 are presented (section 4). 3 3 •
• 0 − (5)
S ref _ r − − 1 1 / 2 1 / 2 2 2 S R
S • = 1 .− 1 / 2 − 1 1 / 2 − j.−
3
0
3 •
. SS
II. APPLICATIONS OF THE PROPOSED METHOD ref _ s − 3 2 2 •
S • 1 / 2 1 / 2 − 1 3 3 S
ref _ t −
− 0
T
The proposed algorithm can extract positive, negative 2 2
sequence and harmonics components of a corrupt signal and For steady state operation ([10],[34],[37]) the phasor
be applied to active power filters, dynamic voltage restorers, equations (4) and (5) can be rewritten in time domain,
power quality analyzers and protective relays systems. resulting in (6) and (7). The phase shift of 60º (-60º) or -90º
(90º) can be implemented by time delaying the original
signals by a time interval corresponding to the desired angles
at the fundamental frequency. The time delaying can be
implemented by saving a determined number of samples.
The delay of 90º (signals (sr-90(t), ss-90(t), st-90(t)) can be
implemented by saving the last N/4 measured samples. The
1
Home
9º Congresso Brasileiro de Eletrônica de Potência - 9th Brazilian Power Electronics Conference
advance of 90º is accomplished by the delayed signals TABLE II – Gain and angle (degrees) for operations A,
multiplied by –1. The delay of 60º (sr-60(t), ss-60(t), st-60(t)) can B, C, D, A+B, C+D for even harmonics, positive and
be accomplished by saving the last N/6 measured samples. negative sequences.
The 60º phase advanced signals (sr60(t), ss60(t), st60(t)) can be operation A B C D A+B C+D
obtained by using the last N/3 measured and saved samples, 2ºseq+ 1
0
7
45
2
− 60
7
− 45
7
45
14
− 105
3 10 3 10 30 30
equivalent to a delay of -120º, with opposite signal. , (N is 2ºseq- 2 7 1 7 14 7
− 60 − 45 0 45 − 105 45
the number of samples per period, at the fundamental 3 10 3 10 30 30
frequency). 4ºseq+ 2
60
7
− 45
1
0
7
45
14
15
7
45
3 10 3 10 30 30
4ºseq- 1
0
7
45
2
60
7
− 45
7
45
14
15
s r − (t ) − 1 0 0 s r (t ) 0 1 0 s r 60 (t ) 0 0 1 s r − 60 (t ) 3 10 3 10 30 30
s (t ) = − 1 . 0 − 1 0 . s (t ) + 0 0 1 . s (t ) + 1 0 0. s (t ) 6ºseq+ 2 7 2 7 14 14
3 s s 60 s − 60 − 60 45 60 − 45 − 15 15
s −
0 3 10 3 10 30 30
s t − (t ) 0 − 1 s t (t ) 1 0 0 s t 60 (t ) 0 1 0 s t − 60 (t )
6ºseq- 2
60
7
− 45
2
− 60
7
45
14
15
14
− 15
(6) 3 10 3 10 30 30
8ºseq+ 1
0
7
− 45
2
− 60
7
45
7
− 45
14
− 15
3 10 3 10 30 30
3 3
0 − 8ºseq- 2
− 60
7
45
1
0
7
− 45
14
− 15
7
− 45
s r − (t ) − 1 1 / 2 1 / 2 s r (t ) 2 2 s (t ) 3 10 3 10 30 30
r − 90
s (t ) = 1 .− 1 / 2 − 1 1 / 2. s (t ) + − 3 0
3
. s s −90 (t ) 10ºseq+ 2 7 1 7 14 7
s− 3 s 2 60 45 0 − 45 105 − 45
2 3 10 3 10 30 30
s t − (t ) 1 / 2 1 / 2 − 1 s t (t ) s t −90 (t )
3 3 10ºseq- 1 7 2 7 7 14
− 0 0 − 45 60 45 − 45 105
2 2 3 10 3 10 30 30
(7)
For odd harmonics, operations A (C) presents the same
The same reasoning can be applied to calculate the gain for (1+6n) order positive sequence (neg. seq) harmonics
positive sequence, only changing 60º (-60º) to –60º(60º) (8) (n=0,1,2,....) and for (5+6n) order negative sequence
or -90º (90º) (9). (pos.seq.). Operations B and (D) presents the same gain for
(3+4n) seq+(-) and (1+4n)seq-(+) harmonics. The cascaded
s r + (t ) − 1 0 0 s r (t ) 0 1 0 s r − 60 (t ) 0 0 1 s r 60 (t ) application of operations AB (CD) presents the same gain for
s (t ) = − 1 . 0 − 1 0 . s (t ) + 0 0 1 s (t ) . + 1 0 0. s (t ) (11+12n)seq+(-) and (1+12n)seq-(+) harmonics. For even
s+ 3 s s −60 s 60
s t + (t ) 0 0 − 1 s t (t ) 1 0 0 s t −60 (t ) 0 1 0 st 60 (t ) harmonics, operations A and C presents the same gain for
(8) (2+6n), (4+6n) and (6+6n) harmonics. Operations B and D
presents the same gain for (2+4n) and (4+4n) harmonics.
(9) Cascaded application of operations AB and CD presents the
3 3
0
2
−
2 s (t )
same gain for (2+12n), (4+12n), (6+12n), (8+12n), (10+12n)
r+
s (t ) − 1 1 / 2 1 / 2 r
s ( t )
s (t ) = 1 .− 1 / 2 − 1 1 / 2. s (t ) − − 3 0
3
r 90
2
Home
9º Congresso Brasileiro de Eletrônica de Potência - 9th Brazilian Power Electronics Conference
Case 3: Harmonics
1-
3+,
1+, 1- 3-
3+, 3- 1+, 1+ 5+,
5+, 5- 5- 5-
etc, etc,
measured + Extracted
C D
signals signals
-
3
Home
9º Congresso Brasileiro de Eletrônica de Potência - 9th Brazilian Power Electronics Conference
Gain (p.u)
0,60 3-
signal frequencies slightly far from 60Hz. Figure 5 presents
5+
the frequency response for case 1 (CD operation). 0,40
5-
Operation without a PLL is only feasible for signals with 0,20
7+
small frequency variation, which occurs in equipment 0,00
7-
connected to strong, interconnected power systems. For weak -0,20
50 55 60 65 70
V. CONCLUSIONS 200,00
150,00 1+
This paper proposes real time algorithms to extract any 100,00
1-
combination of positive, negative sequence and/or harmonics 50,00
3+
Phase (º)
of a corrupted signal. The processing uses nor coordinate 0,00
3-
transform neither signal filtering. It can be easily -50,00 50 55 60 65 70
5+
1,2
[1] ABELLÁN,A ;GARCERÁ,G. ;BENAVENT,J. A New
1+
Control Method for Obtaining Reference Currents of
1
1-
Shunt Active Power Filters in Unbalanced and Non-
0,8
Sinusoidal Conditions. In:Industrial Electronics–
Gain (p.u)
3+
0,6
3-
ISIE’99 Proceedings of the IEEE International
0,4
5+
Symposium on,Jul.1999. Anais eletrônicos. v.2.
0,2
5-
[2] AKAGI,H. ;NABAE,A. The p-q Theory in Three-Phase
0 7+ Systems Under Non-Sinusoidal Conditions. ETEP, v.3,
-0,2 50 55 60 65 70
7- n.1, Jan. Feb. 1993.
Frequency (Hz) [3] BHAVARAJU,V.P. ;ENJETI,P.N. Analysis and Design
of an Active Power Filter for Balancing Unbalanced
Loads. IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, v.8,
Operation AB - Frequency Response n.4, Oct. 1993.
[4] BRITTAIN,J.C. Charles F. Scott : A Pioneer in
200
Electrical Power Engineering. IEEE Industry
150 1+
Applications Magazine, p.6-8. Nov. Dec. 2002.
100 1-
50
[5] CHANG,G.W. ;SHEE,T. A Comparative Study of
3+
Phase (º)
0 3-
Active Power Filter Reference Compensation
-50 50 55 60 65 70 5+
Approaches. IEEE 2002 Power Engineering Society
-100 5-
Summer Meeting, 21-25 July 2002. Anais, IEEE, v.2,
-150 7+
p.1017-1021. 2002.
-200 7- [6] CHEN,C.C. ;HSU,Y. A Novel Approach to the Design
Frequency (Hz) of a Shunt Active Filter for an Unbalanced Three-Phase
Four Wire System under Nonsinusoidal Conditions.
Fig. 4 Operation AB – Frequency Response of Case 2 for various In:Power Engineering Society Summer
harmonics and phase sequences Meeting,Jul.2000. Anais eletrônicos. v.2. p.1059.
Upper: gain Lower:phase [7] CHEN, Tsai-Hsiang. Criteria to estimate the Voltage
Unbalances due to High-Speed Railway Demands. IEEE
Transactions on Power Systems, v.9, n.3, Aug. 1994.
4
Home
9º Congresso Brasileiro de Eletrônica de Potência - 9th Brazilian Power Electronics Conference
[8] CHOI,S. ;LEE,W. ;HYUN,D. ;LEE, T. The Control [21] MCGRANAGHAM,M. Active Filter Design and
system of the Active Power Filter Considering Power Specification for Control of Harmonics in Industrial and
Factor in Unbalanced Load. In:Industry Applications Commercial Facilities. Electrotek Concepts,Inc.
Conference, Oct.2000. Anais eletrônicos. v.4. p.2123- Knoxville TN, USA. Disponível
2128. em:<http://www.dranetz-bmi.com/pdf/activeFilter.pdf>.
[9] CUTRI,R. ;MATAKAS JR.,L. Reference Currents Acesso em:2003.
Determination Techniques For Load Unbalance [22] NIKOLAENKO,V.G. Optimal Balancing of Large
Compensation. In:7º Congresso Brasileiro de Eletrônica Unbalanced Loads Using Shunt Compensators.
de Potência– COBEP’03,Fortaleza,Set.2003. CD-ROM In:Harmonics and Quality of Power , Procceedings 8th
[10] CUTRI,R. Compensação de desequilíbrios de carga International Conference on,Oct.1998. Anais
empregando conversor estático operando com eletrônicos. v.1. p.537-542.
modulação em largura de pulso. 2004. Dissertação [23] PENTEADO JR., A.A. Compensadores estáticos para
(Mestrado) -,Universidade de São Paulo. São Paulo. desequilíbrios : um procedimento de especificação e de
[11] CZARNECKI,L.S.Power Factor Improvement of Three- análises das interferências no sistema elétrico. 1985.
Phase Unbalanced Loads with Non-Sinusoidal Supply Tese (Doutorado) - Escola Politécnica,Universidade de
Voltage. ETEP, v.3, nº1, Jan. Feb. 1993. São Paulo. São Paulo.
[12] E.E.STAFF DEL M.I.T. Circuitos Magnéticos Y [24] ROBBA, J. et al. Introdução a Sistemas Elétricos de
Transformadores. Madri:Editorial Reverte S.A., 1965. Potência. 2ed. São Paulo:Edgard Blucher, 1996.
p.638-640. [25] SAMESIMA, M.I. Compensadores Estáticos de
[13] DIXON,J.W. ;GARCIA,J. ;MORÁN,T.L. A Control Reativos e de Desequilíbrios em Sistemas Elétricos de
System for a Three Phase Active Power Filter which Potência. 1984. Dissertação (Mestrado) – Escola
Simultaneously Compensates Power Factor and Politécnica,Universidade de São Paulo. São Paulo.
Unbalanced Loads. IEEE Transactions on Industrial [26] SENINI,S. ;WOLFS,P. Hybrid Active Filter for
Electronics, v.42, Issue:6, p.636-641. Dec. 1995. Harmonically Unbalanced Three Phase Three Wire
[14] HOCHGRAF,C. ;LASSETER,R. Statcom Controls for Railway Traction Loads. IEEE Transactions on Power
Operation with Unbalanced Voltages. IEEE Electronics, v.15, n.4, July. 2000.
Transactions on Power Delivery, v.13. n.2, Apr. 1998. [27] SENINI,S.T. ;WOLFS,P.J. Novel Topology of
[15] KIM,H. ;BLAABJERG,F. ;JENSEN,B.B. ;CHOI,J. Unbalanced Load in Single Phase Electric Traction
Instantaneous Power Compensation in Three-Phase Systems. In:Power Electronics Specialists
Systems by Using p-q-r theory. In:Power Electronics Conference,2001–PESC’2002- IEEE 33rd
Specialists Conference,2001–PESC’2001- IEEE 32nd Annual,June.2002. Anais. v.3. p.1208-1212. 2002.
Annual,June.2001. Anais eletrônicos. v.2. p.478-485. [28] VERDELHO,P. ; MARQUES,G.D. Design and
[16] KIM,H. Control an Active Filter in Unbalanced Non- Performance of an Active Power Filter and Unbalanced
sinusoidal Source Voltages. In:Power Conversion Current Compensator. In:Industrial Electronics,Control
Conference Proceedings of.,Osaka,Apr.2002. Anais and Instrumentation,Sep.1994. IECON’94,20th
eletrônicos. v.2. p.831-836. Acesso restrito disponível International Conference on. Anais eletrônicos. 1994.
em:<periódicos IEEE-Capes>. v.1. p.422-427.
[17] LEDWICH,G. ;GEORGE,T.A. Using Phasors to analize [29] WATANABE,E. ;AREDES,M. Teoria de Potência
power system negative phase sequence voltages caused Ativa e Reativa Instantânea e Aplicações – Filtros Ativos
by unbalanced loads. IEEE Transactions in Power e FACTS". Tutorial in the CBA'98 (XII Brazilian
Systems, v.9, n.3, Aug. 1994. Automatic Control Conference), Uberlândia, Brazil,
[18] LIN,C.E. ; CHEN,C.L. ; HUANG,C.L. Calculating Sep.14-18, 1998.
Approach and Implementation for active Filters in [30] WATANABE,E. ;AREDES,M. ;AKAGI,H. The p-q
Unbalanced Three-Phase System using Synchronous theory for active filter control : some problems and
Detection Method. In:Industrial solutions. In:XIV Congresso Brasileiro de Automática-
Electronics,Control,Instrumentation and Automation – CBA,2002.
‘Power Electronics and Motion Control’, Proceedings of [31] WILLEMS,J.L. Current Compensation in Three-Phase
the 1992 International Conference on,Nov.1992. Anais Power Systems. ETEP, v.3, n.1, Jan. Feb. 1993.
eletrônicos. v.1. p.374-380. [32] ZHANG, G.; XU, Z. A New Real-time Negative and
[19] MARQUES,G.D. A Comparison of Active Filters Positive Sequence Componentes Detecting Method
Control Methods in Unbalanced and Non-sinusoidal Based on Space Vector. In:POWER ENGINEERING
Conditions. In:Industrial Electronics Society – SOCIETY WINTER MEETING 2001,Jan.-Feb.2001.
IECON’98 Proceedings of the 24th Annual Conference Anais eletrônicos. IEEE, v.1. p.275-280.
of the IEEE,Aug.Sep.1998. Anais eletrônicos. v.1. [33] Fortescue, C.L. Method of symmetrical co-ordinates
p.444-449. Acesso restrito disponível em:<periódicos applied to the solution of polyphase networks. In:34th
IEEE-Capes>. Annual Convention of the America Institute of Electrical
[20] MATSUI,M. ;FUKAO,T. A Detecting Method for Engineers. Atlantic City, N.J. , June. 1918.
Active-Reactive-Negative Sequence Powers ans its [34] CUTRI,R.; MATAKAS JR.,L. A new instantaneous
Application. IEEE Transactions on Industry method for harmonics, positive and negative sequence
Applications, v.26, n.1, Jan. Feb. 1990. detection for compensation of distorted currents with
5
Home
9º Congresso Brasileiro de Eletrônica de Potência - 9th Brazilian Power Electronics Conference
static converters using pulse width modulation. In: 11º Brasileiro sobre Qualidade da Energia Elétrica, Belém,
ICHQP 11th International Conference on Harmonics and Pará, Brasil, Agosto, 2005.
Quality of Power 2004, Lake Placid, New York, [36] IEEE 519-1992 IEEE Recommended Practices and
September, 2004. Requirements for Harmonic Control in Electrical Power
[35] AHN,S.U.; JARDINI,J.A.; MATAKAS JR.,L.; Systems - Institute of Electrical and Electronics
KOMATSU,W.; MASUDA,M.; SILVA,F.; Engineers / 01-May-1992 - ISBN: 1559372397.
GALASSI,M.; MARTINZ,F.; COPELIOVICT,H.; [37] CUTRI,R.; MATAKAS JR.,L. A generalized
OLIVEIRA,M.A.; CAMARGO,J.; ZANETTI,E.; instantaneous method for harmonics, positive and
LIMA,E.; Implementação e testes da geração de negative sequence detection/extraction. PESC 2007
referência e controle em um protótipo de restaurador (IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conference) –
dinâmico de tensão.In: VI SBQEE VI Seminário Junho 17-21, Orlando, Flórida/USA