Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Macroeconomics 1 Assignment Circular Economy and Its Application in Vietnam
Macroeconomics 1 Assignment Circular Economy and Its Application in Vietnam
Macroeconomics 1 Assignment Circular Economy and Its Application in Vietnam
MACROECONOMICS 1
Assignment
CIRCULAR ECONOMY AND ITS APPLICATION
IN VIETNAM
Team 1 – Class: KTEE204.3
Hoà
ng Lê Giang. MSV: 2012450015
Ngu
yễn Anh Tú. MSV: 2013450063
Ngu
yễn Quỳnh Anh. MSV: 2013450004
Chu
Nam Khánh. MSV: 2011450202
Hà
Phương Thảo. MSV: 2014450216
Trịn
h Thị Thu Hiền. MSV: 2013450018
Ngu
yễn Linh Chi. MSV: 2013450007
Ngu
yễn Kim Chi. MSV: 2013450008
Trầ
n Phương Ngọc. MSV: 2013450045
Trầ
n Hoàng Tùng. MSV: 2014450337
Ph
ạm Khánh Linh. MSV: 2013450032
Ng
Introduction 1
Chapter 1: Overview of Circular Economy 2
1.1. Definition of circular economy 2
1.2. Difference between traditional economy and circular economy 2
1.2.1. Difference in process 2
1.3. Components of circular economy 3
1.3.1. Closed cycles 3
1.3.2. Renewable energy 3
1.3.3. Systems thinking 3
1.4. Examples of circular economy in the World 4
1.4.1. Examples from Germany 4
1.4.2. Examples from Japan 6
Chapter 2: Potential of Circular Economy in Vietnam 8
2.1. Opportunities and challenges of circular economy in Vietnam 8
2.1.1. Opportunities of circular economy in Vietnam 8
2.1.2. Challenges of circular economy in Vietnam 8
2.2. The practical application of circular economy in Vietnam 9
2.2.1. Circular Economy Policy in Vietnam 9
2.2.2. Circular economy in Vietnam’s practice 10
2.3. Achievements and Limitations of Circular economy in Vietnam 10
2.3.1. Achievements of circular economy in Vietnam 10
2.3.2. Limitations of circular economy in Vietnam 11
Chapter 3: Recommendations for applying circular economy in Vietnam 13
3.1. Promoting research and technology development 13
3.2. Investing in renewable energy 13
3.3. Applying comprehensive waste treatment measures 13
3.4. Imposing "sustainable taxation" 14
3.5. Improving education and people's awareness 14
3.6. Continuing to reform the current legal framework 15
Conclusion 16
References 17
List of Tables
Table 1.1: Estimated CO2 Reduction by 2020 Compared to 2005 (UBA, 2020) 6
List of Figures
Figure 1.1: The large reuse of raw materials in a circular economy (PBL, 2019)
2
Figure 1.2: The difference between eco-effectiveness and eco-efficiency (EPEA
GmbH, 2013) 3
Figure 1.3: Some of the elements of a circular economy mentioned above and
others in relation to each other (Source: PBL, 2019) 4
Figure 1.4: Municipal Waste Recycling Rates in European Countries, 2004 and
2012 (Source: Eurostat, 2013) 5
Introduction
4. Methodology
The report uses qualitative research methods; however, due to restrictions of
geography and the wide scope of subjects, the report will derive and analyze data
through existing documents from various sources.
1
Chapter 2: Potential of Circular Economy in Vietnam
Chapter 3: Recommendations for Applying Circular Economy in Vietnam
2
Chapter 1: Overview of Circular Economy
There are 2 fundamental differences between circular economy and linear economy.
In a linear economy all products that are made from raw materials are often thrown
away after use. On the contrary, in a circular economy, All raw materials happen in
closed cycles, minimising the use of resource inputs and the creation of waste,
pollution and carbon emissions.
3
Figure 1.1: The large reuse of raw materials in a circular economy (PBL, 2019)
The way in which value is created or maintained is the primary difference between
the circular system and the linear.
4
Figure 1.2: The difference between eco-effectiveness and eco-efficiency (EPEA
GmbH, 2013)
According to Korhonen, Nuur, Feldmann & Birkie (2018), there are 3 main factors
making a crucial contribution to system change:
5
take this into account, the short and long term consequences must be considered, as
well as the influence of the entire value chain (Ellen MacArthur Foundation, 2015).
Figure 1.3: Some of the elements of a circular economy mentioned above and others
in relation to each other (Source: PBL, 2019)
In 1991, the German packaging law that was a recycling policy came into force,
obliged manufacturers to recycle all packaging materials. As a result, the German
industry has built and developed a collection system of recyclable materials and
regular waste-collection systems.Duales System Deutschland help improve the
recycling rate from the current level of 62 percent (Figure 1.4) of the municipal waste
(EEA, 2013).
6
Figure 1.4: Municipal Waste Recycling Rates in European Countries, 2004 and 2012
(Source: Eurostat, 2013)
For example, the Renewable Energy Act makes a profound contribution to boost
innovation and development in renewable energy industries, such as photovoltaics
and wind power. Businesses receive a feed-in tariff, which is well above the average
price to bridge the gap in the current price of thermal-powered electricity renewable
energies.
Description of the Key Policies Related to the Industry Case Study: National Policies
for Reducing GHG Emissions from Road Transport in Germany
7
Germany conducts the transport measures to reduce GHG emissions by 30 million
metric tonnes per year by 2020 compared to 2005 (ITF, 2010).
With the view to decreasing by 7 percent the CO2 releases related to diesel and
petrol consumption, the federal government is under obligation to expand the use of
biofuels. However, infact, it is impossible to gain emission when the entire impact of
the measures will not be sufficient. Thanks to the effective combination off the
measures, GHG emissions reductions are estimated to account for 28 million metric
tonnes or about 18 percent below the 2005 levels (IEA,2012).
Table 1.1: Estimated CO2 Reduction by 2020 Compared to 2005 (UBA, 2020)
8
The government put comprehensiveness and collaboration at the heart of the
system. The system has 3 key features:
- Recycling infrastructure is co-owned: The laws requires a consortium of
manufactures to run disassembly plants, ensuring they directly get benefit from
recovering materials and parts.
- Consumer friendly collection: For appliances, collecting old one for recycling
is so comprehensive and easy. For old IT equipment, the manufacturer can be
requested to get it by local authorities from the doorstep, or it can be taken to
any post office to be returned to them.
- Consumer pay fees up front: for electronics, the cost of transport and recovery
is paid for at the point of purchase, meaning that the customer does not have
any disincentive to participate when a product comes to the end of its life.
Penalties for fly tipping are also stiff.
In fact, The Government of Japan has developed a comprehensive legal framework
for the country’s move towards a recycling-based society (METI, 2004; Morioka et al.,
2005)
9
Chapter 2: Potential of Circular Economy in Vietnam
Third, encouragement and new mechanisms for the development of the private
economic sector in a competitive market will create ample opportunity for its
investment in implementing a circular economy in the future.
Last, circular economic development will receive high consensus and support from
the society since it addresses resource scarcity, environment protection, climate
change responses and brings about high economic efficiency.
10
First, it is a significant challenge to foster full awareness of the circular economy from
design to implementation in all sectors and fields among businesses, citizens and
managerial levels, and leaders to reach a common consensus.
Second, the circular economy is associated with technological innovation and model
design while Vietnam is a developing country with outdated technology and small-
scale production.
Third, Vietnam has not had a legal corridor for developing a circular economy. This
issue needs to be resolved; otherwise, the implementation of circular economy is
spontaneous and subject to market dynamics.
Fourth, Vietnam has not developed a set of criteria to identify, evaluate, summarize
and give an accurate classification of circular economy development. This is a major
challenge to learn to what extent the current economic development in different
industries, fields and localities has approached a circular economy.
Sixth, the implementation of circular economy requires good experts who are
capable of handling stages from designing to the final stage of reuse and recycling of
waste. Currently, there are no trained experts in this field and no training majors for
these experts.
Seventh, the circular economy requires classification and cleaning of waste before
being reused and recycled, which is a great challenge to the practice of Vietnam's
economy and the awareness of household sorting of waste at source.
The State Government issued plenty of strategies that supported one or more aspects
of Circular Economy, as follows:
11
- Sustainable Development Strategy of Vietnam period 2011-2020 included a task
to build a system of integrated solid waste management, in which solid wastes
are classified at source, collected, reused, recycled and thoroughly treated with
appropriate advanced technologies (Government of Vietnam, 2012)
- National Environmental Protection Strategy by 2020, with a vision toward
2030 detailed plenty of measures to enhance the reduce, reuse and recycle (3R)
(Government of Vietnam, 2012). The measures included improving the
institution and legal system for 3R, reducing the production and use of bags and
packaging that are difficult to decompose, waste-recycling capacity building
programs, etc. This Strategy was then followed by a plan for implementation
(Government of Vietnam, 2014) and Decision 50/2013/QD-TTg on prescribing
retrieval and disposal of discarded products (Government of Vietnam, 2013)
- The National Green Growth Strategy
- Strategy on Cleaner Production in Industry to 2020
- National Strategy for General Management of Solid Waste to 2025
- National Action Plan on Sustainable Production and Consumption up to 2020,
In sum, although the term “Circular Economy” has not been officially used in any
CPV’s document or Vietnam’s legal documents, many aspects of circular economy
have been addressed and supported. They include (i) consuming less raw materials,
reducing energy leakages and waste; (ii) enhancing the use of renewable energy,
limiting the use of fossil fuels; (iii) reducing the use of plastic and promoting the use
of environmentally friendly products, etc. These indicate that the Communist Party of
Vietnam and the State Government have great desire for the transition and have
actually initiated it toward Circular Economy.
We would like to point out the bio-based circular economy model. In a bio-based
circular economy, in an easy to understand way, material and nutrient flows form
loops and consequently, a significant amount of waste would be turned into useful
12
materials. So far, Vietnam has witnessed several notable good practices which are
Biogas in Huế, Bio-fertilizer in Đà Nẵng and Solid waste recycling in Đà Nẵng.
Unlike a linear economy, a circular economy is like a lake, using the recycling of
redundant materials and waste to create new products as the main operating
principle. For example, cleaning a glass bottle and using it again is faster and cheaper
than recycling the glass or making a new bottle from ore. Or to put it another way, in
this circulating "lake", the waste of one product is the input of another product, every
type of waste is analysed, researched and recycled.
Job Creation
The collection, repair, recycling, and re-production of waste is a long period, requiring
a lot of manpower to produce and research. So the Circulatory Economy is a model
that promotes job solving. Contribute to national construction and development.
13
Figure 2: Waste Consumption of Gè Cát (HCM City) Landfill in 2003.
Currently, the lack of infrastructure, investment capital and high technology is the
biggest barrier that makes Vietnam unable to make the Circular Economic model a
major development direction.
14
Chapter 3: Recommendations for applying circular economy in Vietnam
Besides, the government can also foster creativity and encourage inventiveness by
holding competitions in order to motivate learning and technology research.
According to the United Nations (2019), the global population will increase from 7.5
billion in current date to around 10 billion in 2050, which inevitably leads to a rise in
the demand for raw materials. New emerging economies and innovative technological
applications all require energy. Vietnam has enormous potential for wind, solar, and
tidal energy, with a coastline of more than three thousand kilometers. Being
considered a country with renewable energy potential in Southeast Asia, Vietnam
should find a way to optimize its potential. Renewable energy usage decreases the
burden to the economy and is one of the most important components of a circular
economy.
To be able to provide enough renewable energy and successfully apply the circular
economy model, Vietnam's main mission is to encourage the expansion and
development of renewable energy and gradually reduce its dependence on traditional
forms of electricity generation such as fossil energy. It has been forecasted by local
15
experts that the development of renewable energy will help Vietnam reduce fuel
imports by as much as sixty percent and mitigate the risk of fluctuations in fuel prices.
16
Vietnam needs to deploy extensive research on the development of circular
economy models from a global general approach to apply specifically to
Vietnamese circumstances and widely propagated to businesses, people,
managers to have the right view about circular economy.
Moreover, it would be useless when people are not taking steps to protect the
environment in their lives as the world's population grows substantially even if
the government invested heavily in the circular economy. Therefore, it is
necessary to consolidate social/cultural awareness towards environmental
sustainability which plays an important role in development of circular
economy, especially focusing on some kinds of waste treatment needs to be
sorted at source.
The government can encourage people to reduce using products that come
with non recyclable packaging, such as plastic or nylon bags, by using personal
baskets for goods from markets; to use personal wooden or bamboo cups,
spoons, forks, chopsticks… in place of one-time plastic one; to making use of
countless online resources; or to choose to use energy-saving devices and
renewable energy compatible appliances in your daily activities. Additionally, it
would be better for everyone to try to find and buy green products from
ecological companies, which apply the circular economy model.
Therefore, Vietnam needs to continue to revise and perfect its legal corridor to
serve the development of a circular economy. Enterprises should be required
to manage projects according to the life cycle, set up a roadmap for
development, and apply environmental standards equivalent to those of
17
advanced countries in the region. Along with that, accelerate the completion
and enactment of incentive mechanisms and policies to support the promotion
of environmental industries, including the recycling industry.
The government needs to develop a detailed and clear roadmap for the
transition to circular economic model development, identifying development
priorities based on market needs and social demands. The experience of the
UK, France, Finland, the Netherlands and more recently Malaysia shows that it
is necessary to have a roadmap to realize a circular economy.
Enterprises are the central driving force, the State plays a constructive role. The
creation role of the State is shown in creating an environment for circular
economic development. Vietnam should consider incorporating these
approaches to realize circular economy.
18
Conclusion
The circular economy is an economic model in which design, production and service
activities aim to prolong the life of matter and eliminate negative environmental
impacts. This is an economic model in which special attention is paid to resource
management and regeneration in a closed loop, in order to avoid creating waste and
polluting the environment.
19
References
1. Benton, D., Hazell, J., Hill, J., 2016. The guide to the Circular Economy. Greenleaf
Publishing Limited, UK
2. Ellen MacArthur Foundation Towards the Circular Economy vol.1. (2013). [online]
Available at:
https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/assets/downloads/publications/Ellen-
MacArthur-Foundation-Towards-the-Circular-Economy-vol.1.pdf.
3. Ellen MacArthur Foundation (2012). Towards the Circular Economy: Economic and
business rationale for an accelerated transition. Ellen MacArthur Foundation
Publisher, UK
8. Kenniskaarten - het Groene Brein. (2011). Circular economy: a definition and most
important aspects. [online] Available at:
https://kenniskaarten.hetgroenebrein.nl/en/knowledge-map-circular-economy/what-is-
the-definition-a-circular-economy/.
20
9. vietnamnews.vn. (n.d.). Việt Nam pivots to circular economy. [online] Available at:
https://vietnamnews.vn/economy/749321/viet-nam-pivots-to-circular-economy.html
[Accessed 18 Mar. 2021].
11. Anon, (n.d.). Vietnam and plastic pollution. [online] Available at:
https://blisssaigon.com/vietnam-starts-to-fight-back-on-plastic-pollution/.
12. Southeast Asia Globe. (2020). Vietnam’s long and winding road to plastic waste
reduction. [online] Available at: https://southeastasiaglobe.com/plastic-pollution-
vietnam/
13. vovgiaothong.vn. (n.d.). Vì sao người dân khó thay đổi thói quen dùng đồ nhựa
dùng một lần? [online] Available at: https://vovgiaothong.vn/vi-sao-nguoi-dan-kho-
thay-doi-thoi-quen-dung-do-nhua-dung-mot-lan [Accessed 18 Mar. 2021].
14. VIR, V.I.R. - (2018). Maximising advantages of the circular economy. [online]
Vietnam Investment Review - VIR. Available at: https://www.vir.com.vn/maximising-
advantages-of-the-circular-economy-63004.html [Accessed 18 Mar. 2021].
16. VIR, V.I.R. - (2018). Maximising advantages of the circular economy. [online]
Vietnam Investment Review - VIR. Available at: https://www.vir.com.vn/maximising-
advantages-of-the-circular-economy-63004.html.
17. Quoc, N., Hoang Phuong, N., Dinh, D. and Binh, N. (n.d.). European Journal of
Molecular & Clinical Medicine The Development Of Circular Economy In Some
Countries And Valuable References For Vietnam. [online] 07(03), p.2020. Available
at: https://ejmcm.com/article_5971_c40ddb2d224b57dd18bd3ac63685f075.pdf
[Accessed 18 Mar. 2021].
21
19. baodientu.chinhphu.vn. (n.d.). Phát triển kinh tế tuần hoàn là yêu cầu tất yếu của
phát triển bền vững. [online] Available at: https://baochinhphu.vn/Tin-noi-bat/Phat-
trien-kinh-te-tuan-hoan-la-yeu-cau-tat-yeu-cua-phat-trien-ben-vung/421015.vgp
20. Báo Nhân Dân. (n.d.). Hướng đến nền kinh tế tuần hoàn bền vững. [online]
Available at: https://nhandan.com.vn/nhan-dinh/huong-den-nen-kinh-te-tuan-hoan-
ben-vung-63129
21. vietnamnews.vn. (n.d.). Việt Nam takes action to reduce plastic waste. [online]
Available at: https://vietnamnews.vn/environment/505164/viet-nam-takes-action-to-
reduce-plastic-waste.html
22. United Nations (2019). Growing at a slower pace, world population is expected to
reach 9.7 billion in 2050 and could peak at nearly 11 billion around 2100 | UN DESA |
United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. [online] UN DESA |
United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. Available at:
https://www.un.org/development/desa/en/news/population/world-population-
prospects-2019.html.
23. Thien Nhien (2019). Suy nghĩ lại về nhựa - Giải pháp kinh tế tuần hoàn cho rác
thải biển.| Con người và Thiên nhiên. Available at:
https://www.thiennhien.net/2019/10/31/suy-nghi-lai-ve-nhua-giai-phap-kinh-te-tuan-
hoan-cho-rac-thai-bien/ [Accessed 20 Mar. 2021].
24. Nguyễn Thế Chinh, L. V. (2016). Trách nhiệm xã hội của doanh nghiệp với tăng
trưởng xanh. Hà Nội: Tạp chí Môi trường.
25. Parson Michael. (2019). Circular Economy - Doi moi. Ha Noi: Adviser for
Minister of Ministry of National Resoures and Environment.
22