Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

GENERAL DENTISTRY

Delivering dental care as we emerge from the initial phase


of the COVID-19 pandemic: teledentistry and face-to-face
consultations in a new clinical world
Pascaline Kengne Talla, DMD, PhD/Liran Levin, DMD, FRCD(C)/Michael Glogauer, DDS, PhD/
Cheryl Cable, DDS, MBA, FRCD(C)/Paul J. Allison, BDS, FDSRCS(Eng), MSc, PhD, FCAHS

At a time when access to health care and services for the global scend some of the existing traditional barriers in clinical and
population is a concern due to the COVID-19 pandemic, health technological workflows. The aim of this paper is to provide in-
professionals and their teams are struggling to find a way to adapt sight and propose future directions concerning the use of teleden-
their practices. Dental professional organizations and deci- tistry for dental care in crisis situations such as the COVID-19 pan-
sion-makers are required to provide guidance in a rapidly evolving demic as well as the continuous implementation of teledentistry
environment based on the current data, available research, and in noncrisis scenarios. This paper provides information to support
existing knowledge. Continuous progress in the information com- the use of teledentistry as a promising avenue for dental profes-
munication technology field and universal access to social com- sionals when possible, during and possibly beyond the outbreak.
munication platforms have allowed clinicians to creatively tran- (Quintessence Int 2020;51:672–677; doi: 10.3290/j.qi.a44920)

Key words: crisis management, dental trauma, emergency, evidence-based practice, telehealth

The world is facing an unprecedented situation due to the tion and control measures in dental practice because of COVID-
COVID-19 pandemic. There are millions of cases and thousands 19.7 However, continuous progress in the information techno-
of deaths related to this disease worldwide to date.1,2 People are logy field has allowed clinicians to transcend some of the
instructed to stay at home in order to “flatten the curve” (reduce existing barriers in clinical and technological workflows.8
or limit the propagation of the pandemic and spread out the From mid-March 2020, as dental offices across the world
volume of patients in hospitals that would otherwise become closed down, dental regulatory authorities provided guidance
overwhelmed) and to reduce the risk of cross-contamination on the use of teledentistry5,9-12 for managing emergency and
caused by close contact. At a time when access to health care urgent dental problems. As the leadership of dental professions
and services for the entire population is a concern, many health across the world plan returning to dental care beyond emer-
professionals and their teams struggle to find ways to adapt gency and urgent problems, and consider how best to guide
their practices accordingly. Dental professional organizations dental care providers in their return to work following the initial
and decision-makers are required to provide guidance in a rap- acute phase of the COVID-19 pandemic in the next months,
idly evolving environment, based on continually evolving data, there is an excellent and beneficial opportunity to incorporate
research, and knowledge. Many dental regulatory bodies have teledentistry in routine dental care. Used in an appropriate, evi-
recommended limiting services to emergency and/or urgent dence-informed manner, teledentistry has the potential to help
visits during this early phase of the pandemic.3-6 There is a new dental professionals and staff manage their patients’ health
requirement for stricter implementation of infection preven- problems while addressing access-to-care issues. Several sys-

672 QUINTESSENCE INTERNATIONAL | volume 51 • number 8 • September 2020


Talla et al

tematic reviews have shown that teledentistry may provide ■ consultations between clinicians: for example, a general and
many new opportunities for general and speciality dental prac- a specialty dental practitioner share images and records
tices,13-15 as well as teleradiography.8 Moreover, a systematic obtained from the patient followed by a review and treat-
review reported that patients and dental professionals were ment planning discussion
satisfied by this approach.14 Some studies regarding dentistry ■ a face-to-face consultation in real time by video conference
in crisis situations16,17 reported on the importance of teleden- between a general dental practitioner or a specialist and a
tistry, while others report that it may provide a promising alter- patient or a member of his or her family located in a sepa-
native for remote assessment, screening, advice, monitoring, rate, distant location
referrals, or prescriptions to patients for dental problems.14,18 ■ remote monitoring of patients, where data is collected in
That said, while teledentistry shows much promise for certain real time, transmitted to dental professionals at a distant
forms of care, it remains a field that needs more research to location for review, and action as needed.
demonstrate where it is and is not effective and efficient.13-15
This paper aims to i) briefly review the state of knowledge
Teledentistry as an adjunct to standard
of the use of teledentistry prior to the pandemic; ii) apply this
care for patients with access-to-care issues
information to discuss how teledentistry can be used during
and as we emerge from the pandemic; and iii) highlight import- Teledentistry can be utilized as an adjunct to standard care for
ant areas of research needed to demonstrate the interventions patients with access-to-care issues such as immunocompro-
for which teledentistry is and is not effective and cost-effective. mised patients, elderly patients, patients in remote locations,
and disabled or disadvantaged individuals. Vulnerable patients
may need adapted care for continuity of treatment. Patients
Teledentistry
who cannot afford travel, stays in remote housing, or are not
Teledentistry is the use of information technology and telecom- comfortable leaving their communities due to social, cultural,
munications for dental care to deliver and support certain re- or mental health challenges need to be acknowledged and
mote services. It is a virtual encounter of communication be- empowered. People in pain and those in palliative care may be
tween a dental professional and a patient and/or another disinclined to leave their place of security and comfort for a
health professional. Teledentistry is a delivery modality that can quick “check-up” appointment. The practice in dentistry has vir-
be used in rural and urban settings to improve the accessibility tually always been for patients to come to clinics. Teledentistry
and the availability of dental care.13-15 It has proven especially affords the opportunity for certain patients with certain condi-
useful in remote areas where patients must travel long distances tions not to have to visit the dental clinic.
to meet health care providers. Dental emergencies can happen Communication with dental patients, regardless of whether
in remote environments with specific concerns such as: limited the appointment is an emergency exam, a follow-up post-ex-
access to care, lack of equipment, and often a scarcity of care traction appointment, or other, might better be performed
workers. Dental emergencies can also happen within various using teledentistry. It can be used to assess progressing symp-
contexts such as natural or manmade disasters. In an emergency toms and pain management, to discuss further treatment
situation like the COVID-19 pandemic, teledentistry can act as a options, or to complete a video visit as an initial consultation to
promising method of delivery for maintaining patient contact gather more information about the patient’s dental concerns
and some elements of dental care, including for screening, triage, and desires. The dental professional can discuss over the phone
pharmacotherapy, referrals, education, and research.19,20 a potential diagnosis and determine if a clinic appointment is
necessary. Patient triage at this time can expedite data collec-
tion or allow for the patient to be referred to an appropriate
Platforms for teledentistry
clinician where necessary treatment can be provided.
Many platforms can be used for teledentistry. Some of these Today, dentistry, along with every other profession, is
include telephone, text, or email for initial patient contacts, or adapting to the rapidly changing environment. Teledentistry
videoconference solutions such as Zoom Pro, Microsoft Teams, or modalities are imperative tools for every dental clinic whether in
Webex. hospital or private practice. Outside of a “true emergency” situa-
There are three primary ways that teledentistry can be used tion, teledentistry can be incorporated into routine care even
as a service modality.21,22 These include: during dental clinic shutdowns and upon reopening in stages

QUINTESSENCE INTERNATIONAL | volume 51 • number 8 • September 2020 673


GENERAL DENTISTRY

as mandated by governing bodies or supply chain manage- dental emergencies during the COVID-19 pandemic or other
ment limitations. scenarios,24,25 but there is an opportunity to extend the code
Teledentistry has the opportunity to improve patients’ oral and practice of telehealth beyond emergency provision only,
health outcomes, including reinforcing self-care, patients’ edu- so as to become an accepted standard of care.
cation, and empowerment, and reducing psychologic anxiety. Guidance for the use of teledentistry must be used in con-
Teledentistry can also be a tool for improving the general health junction with all applicable organizational standards, proto-
of patients, reducing dental professionals’ and their staffs’ expo- cols, policies, and procedures for dental care service provision.
sure to possible contamination and the use of consumable per-
sonal protective equipment (PPE), while also enabling contin-
Clinical standards and outcomes
ued dental care delivery, removing or reducing transportation
barriers, reducing patients’ risk for contamination, monitoring Teledentistry services follow the same principles as face-to-face
of treatment prescribed, and providing and encouraging access dental care. Dental professionals should give the patients ade-
to a wider range of specialist advice and services. quate, current, and ongoing dental care information. If in-per-
son consultations require the use of interpreters or the pres-
ence of family members or care providers, those same supports
Challenges to teledentistry
should be arranged for teledentistry services. Recording a
Challenges to teledentistry are diverse14,18 and complex. There is teledentistry session is not typically performed due to the unse-
an initial need for willingness of dental practitioners and their cure nature of most platforms. If recordings are retained as part
team to accept teledentistry. Not all providers and patients are of patient care records, then patient consent must be obtained.
familiar with and/or equipped to use current technologies. Train- Dental professionals must recognize the limits of teleden-
ing and continuing education efforts will be needed to make the tistry (eg, the lack of ability to directly examine a patient) and
field more accessible and endorsable by the dental community. must explain to the patients the potential challenges and ben-
The effectiveness of teledentistry services is predicated on signif-
f efits of teledentistry and its limits for clinical diagnosis/man-
icant preliminary planning processes and focused training for agement. Reasonable expectations on diagnostic abilities must
dental professionals prior to implementation of a teledentistry be vocalized. Communication must be clear and expectations
program. Infrastructure requirements vary by location, but cer- realistic. This is both for the patient and the dental professional.
tain basic technology is essential to provide high-quality services. Lack of facial, vocal, or physical cues can lead to misunder-
Another aspect that needs to be considered is patient standings and misdirection.
record acquisition, management, sharing, and storage of per- Dental professionals must also follow protocols and pro-
sonal information. Privacy and security of patient health infor- cedures related to informed consent (verbal or written) as well
mation across delivery systems should be assured to the patient as privacy and confidentiality about personal information, per-
and be constantly updated. Consent of the patient to utilize sonal communications, and the consulting space. Having a
potentially unsecure teledentistry modalities must be obtained. strategy for confirming patient identity is necessary to avoid
Teledentistry services must also be recognized by the dental the risk of misidentification and exposure to inappropriate
regulatory bodies as well as the insurers in order to encourage interventions for a patient with whom one is communicating.
dental professionals to utilize the delivery of dental care and to Failure to correctly identify patients may result in a range of
increase the accessibility for the patients.23 Increased clinical adverse events such as the patient receiving information meant
efficiencies, expediting care, and reducing long specialist wait- for a different person. As always, documentation is an import-
ing lists would save patients, clinicians, and insurance compa- ant aspect of the patient records and ongoing treatment.
nies in the long term, with the common goal of providing the The same ethical principles that apply in any face-to-face
most appropriate care for patients in need in a timely manner. patient interaction apply to teledentistry encounters (integrity
Remuneration can be a significant disincentive to involving of services, standards of quality, practice standards). It is essen-
dental professionals in teledentistry. Time and other unique tial to pay special attention to the elements that characterize
considerations related to technology and delivery of telecare the patient-clinician relationship, such as communication, the
will need to be considered for appropriate remuneration of dental practitioner’s behavior (degree of empathy, profession-
teledentistry consultations. Temporary codes from regulatory alism), clinical services (assessment, diagnosis, prescriptions,
dental authorities may be an appropriate way of dealing with treatment, etc), the relationship of trust between the clinician

674 QUINTESSENCE INTERNATIONAL | volume 51 • number 8 • September 2020


Talla et al

Figs 1 Teledentistry could be used for discussion among experts on a treatment plan for a patient. Multiple disciplines could be involved in a
conference call presenting clinical and radiographic findings to add to the discussion.

and patient, and measures for ensuring confidentiality and pri- a specialist to guide a general dental practitioner in a remote
vacy.26 Identify immediately every person who is present for the region to perform certain forms of care? And linked to this,
teledentistry session on each side of communication. Respect. does having teledentistry consultations with patients in rural
Listen. Document. Empower. and remote settings really save transport costs or does it result
in missed disease or wasted appointments for un-needed care?
The limits of teledentistry as a communication tool with differ-
Research needs going forward
ent sectors of the population, particularly more vulnerable
Having briefly reviewed the literature on teledentistry and groups, needs to be explored. For instance, teledentistry could
made suggestions on how it could be used going forward potentially be an excellent tool to screen for oral health prob-
beyond the acute phase of the COVID-19 pandemic, it is import- lems among residents of centers for elderly patients, but it is
ant to recognize the limitations of the evidence supporting its important to ensure that patients in such centers understand
use in dental care. In short, what can, and very importantly what teledentistry communication. Furthermore, it may be an excel-
cannot be done effectively and cost-effectively using teleden- lent form of “outreach” care for younger, marginalized groups,
tistry needs to be documented. The care that can be performed, but it must be ensured that care needs identified through
the communication approaches that can be used, and the effi- teledentistry are followed up. And does having a “tele-dental-
ciencies that can be gained using teledentistry need to be iden- clinic” interspersed with in-person care enable efficiencies and
tified. For instance, well-designed research is needed to demon- cost savings for both dental practitioners and patients? These
strate whether teledentistry can be used as a screening tool, and many other research questions need to be answered
investigating, just as is done with other screening tools, the urgently as the dental profession explores expanding the use
sensitivity and specificity of the approach for different condi- of teledentistry. We need to look to our colleagues in other
tions. On top of this, can teledentistry be used, for instance, by health professions who have been using telemedicine/tele-

QUINTESSENCE INTERNATIONAL | volume 51 • number 8 • September 2020 675


GENERAL DENTISTRY

health approaches with success for many years. These pro- screening, and treatment for emergent and urgent dental issues.
grams have many lessons that we can learn from immediately However, teledentistry may lead to a transformation of standard
as we explore teledentistry. dental practices and requires organizational, clinical, technolog-
ical, and ethical standards. A fee-for-service remuneration for
dental practitioners and their team must be recognized by den-
Conclusions
tal regulatory bodies and employers/insurance companies out-
Teledentistry is an evolving, innovative approach to delivery of side of emergency situations. Infrastructures, appropriate equip-
dental care and access issues, which does not require close con- ment, and accessories are important to ensure a quality practice
tact with the dental professional. Dentistry has been slow in the environment and the quality of dental services. Teledentistry
adoption of communication and information technologies for highlights the potential to offer additional dental care beyond
dental care, in comparison to others health care domains. The dental emergencies, during and post COVID-19. Recognition of
dental profession’s rapid turn to teledentistry in the acute phase access-to-care limitations and empowerment of those who need
of the COVID-19 pandemic provides an excellent opportunity to help the most must not be lost in future conversations. With the
explore how teledentistry can be adopted in dental care in the rapid evolution of communication and information technologies
long, as well as the short term. Teledentistry has the potential to and their use in our lives, dentistry must change in response.
help dental professionals begin to address some of the lon-
ger-term problems of access to dental care, as well as providing
Declaration
safe and secure means to provide quality care while reducing the
risk of contagion. During a crisis like the pandemic COVID-19, The authors declare there are no conflicts of interest associated
dental professionals can use teledentistry to provide advice, with this manuscript.

References
1. World Health Organization. Coronavirus 5. Royal College of Dental Surgeons of 10. Alberta Dental Association and College.
disease 2019 (COVID-19) Situation Report – Ontario. Emergency screening of dental pa- COVID-19: Dental Emergency Protocol 2020.
77. https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/ tients using teledentistry. https://az184419. https://www.dentalhealthalberta.ca/wp-
coronaviruse/situation-reports/20200406- vo.msecnd.net/rcdso/pdf/standards-of-prac- content/uploads/2020/03/COVID-19-Dental-
sitrep-77-covid-19.pdf?sfvrsn=21d1e632_2. tice/Emergency%20screening%20of%20 Emergency-Protocol.pdf. Accessed 24 April
Accessed 6 April 2020. dental%20patients%20using%20teleden- 2020.
2. Gouvernement du Canada. Maladie à tistry%20(PDF)%20-%20March%2026,%20 11. Ordre des dentistes du Québec. Soins
coronavirus (COVID-19): Mise à jour sur 2020.pdf. Accessed 1 April 2020. dentaires d’urgence par télédentisterie en
l’éclosion. https://www.canada.ca/fr/sante- 6. Ordre des dentistes du Québec. Édition contexte COVID-19. 2020. http://bulletin.
publique/services/maladies/2019-nouveau- spéciale: Corona virus. http://bulletin.odq.qc. odq.qc.ca/T/OFSYS/
coronavirus.html. Accessed 6 April 2020. ca/T/OFSYS/SM2/786/2/S/F/6469/1018212/ SM2/786/2/S/F/6469/1049596/A8tIFZXy/
3. American Dental Association (ADA). h4GcQ4px/698134.html. Accessed 1 April 698147.html#guide. Accessed 8 April 2020.
What Constitutes a Dental Emergency? 2020. 12. National Health Service. COVID-19
https://success.ada.org/~/media/CPS/Files/ 7. Meng L, Hua F, Bian Z. Coronavirus Dis- guidance and standard operating procedure:
Open%20Files/ADA_COVID19_Dental_Emer- ease 2019 (COVID-19): Emerging and future Urgent dental care systems in the context
gency_DDS.pdf?utm_source=cpsorg&utm_ challenges for dental and oral medicine. J of coronavirus. 15 April 2020. https://www.
medium=covid-cps-virus-lp&utm_content= Dent Res 2020;99:481–487. england.nhs.uk/coronavirus/wp-content/
cv-pm-dental-emergency&utm_campaign=- 8. Joda T, Bornstein MM, Jung RE, Ferrari M, uploads/sites/52/2020/04/C0282-covid-19-
covid-19. Accessed 3 April 2020. Waltimo T, Zitzmann NU. Recent trends and urgent-dental-care-sop.pdf. Accessed 9 May
4. Alberta Dental Association and College. future direction of dental research in the dig- 2020.
Guidelines on emergency treatment. 2010. ital era. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2020; 13. Alabdullah JH, Daniel SH. A systematic
https://www.dentalhealthalberta.ca/wp-con- 17:1987. review on the validity of teledentistry. Tele-
tent/uploads/2020/03/Guidelines-on-Emer- 9. American Dental Association. Policy medicine J E Health 2018:24:639–648.
gency-Treatment_3.28.2020.pdf. Accessed 3 Statement 6.28 – Teledentistry. 24 April 2020. 14. Daniel SJ, Wu L, Kumar S. Teledentistry:
April 2020. https://www.ada.org.au/Dental-Professionals/ a systematic review of clinical outcomes,
Policies/Dental-Practice/6-28-Teledentistry/ utilization and costs. J Dent Hyg 2013;87:
PS6-28-Teledentistry_11-12Apr19_Approved. 345–352.
aspx. Accessed 9 May 2020.

676 QUINTESSENCE INTERNATIONAL | volume 51 • number 8 • September 2020


Talla et al

15. Estai M, Kanagasingam Y, Tennant M, 20. Abdelrahim A, Shimpi N, Hegde H, et al. 25. Society for Maternal and Fetal Medicine
Bunt S. A systematic review of the research Feasibility of establishing tele-dental ap- Coding Committee. SMFM Coding White
evidence for the benefits of teledentistry. J proach to non-traumatic dental emergencies Paper: Interim Coding Guidance: Coding for
Telemed Telecare 2018;24:147–156. in medical settings. Am J Dent 2020;33:48–52. Telemedicine and Remote Patient Monitor-
16. Smales FC, Samaranyake LP. Maintain- 21. Center for Health Workforce Studies. ing Services during the COVID-19 Pandemic.
ing dental education and specialist dental Case Studies of 6 Teledentistry Programs: 2020. https://www.smfm.org/covid-19-
care during an outbreak of a new corona- Strategies to Increase Access to General and white-paper. Accessed 3 April 2020.
virus infection. Part 1: a deadly viral epidemic Specialty Dental Services. Albany: University 26. American College of Emergency
begins. Br Dent J 2003;195:557–561. of Albany, 2016:1–108. Physicians. Ethical use of telemedicine in
17. Smales FC, Samaranyake LP. Maintain- 22. Billings RJ, Kopycka-Kedzierawski DT, emergency care: Policy statement. 2016.
ing dental education and specialist dental McLaren SW, Mendicino Jr AJ. The Eastman https://www.acep.org/globalassets/new-
care during an outbreak of a new coronavirus teledentistry experience: past, present, fu- pdfs/policy-statements/ethical-use-of-tele-
infection. Part 2: Control of the disease, then ture. Rochester: Eastman Institute for Oral medicine-in-emergency-care.pdf. Accessed 3
elimination. Br Dent J 2003;195:679–681. Health, 2019:1–121. April 2020.
18. Avula H. Tele-periodontics – Oral 23. Smith AC, Thomas E, Snoswell CL, et al.
health care at a grass root level. J Indian Soc Telehealth for global emergencies: Implica-
Periodontol 2015;19:589–592. tions for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19).
19. Binaisse P, Dehours E, Bodéré C, J Telemed Telecare 2020;26:309–313.
Chevalier V, Le Fur Bonnabesse A. Dental 24. American Gastroenterological Associ-
emergencies at sea: A study in the French ation. Commercial COVID-19 telehealth
maritime TeleMedical Assistance Service. J coding policies. Bethesda: American Gastro-
Telemed Telecare 2020;26:285–293. enterological Association, 2020:1–3.

Pascaline Kengne Talla Pascaline Kengne Talla Assitant Professor, Faculty of Dentistry,
Laval University, Quebec, Canada
Liran Levin Professor, Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, Univer-
sity of Alberta, Alberta, Canada
Michael Glogauer Professor, Faculty of Dentistry, University of
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Cheryl Cable Associate Professor, Faculty of Medicine and Den-
tistry, University of Alberta, Alberta, Canada
Paul J. Allison Professor, Faculty of Dentistry, McGill University,
Quebec, Canada

Correspondence: Prof Liran Levin, University of Alberta, Faculty of Medicine & Dentistry, 5-468 Edmonton Clinic Health Academy, 11405
87 Avenue NW, 5th Floor, Edmonton AB, T6G 1C9, Canada. Email: liran@ualberta.ca

QUINTESSENCE INTERNATIONAL | volume 51 • number 8 • September 2020 677

You might also like