Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Understanding The Self
Understanding The Self
Understanding The Self
Socratic Method
Greek Philosophers in Miletus
● This is Socrates’ method for discovering what is
•They Chose To Seek Natural Explanations to events and
essential in the world and in people
phenomena around them instead of seeking supernatural
● In this method, Socrates did not lecture, he instead
explanations from God that were passed down through
would ask questions and engage the person in a
generations.
discussion
•These philosophers observed changes in the world and
● He would begin by acting as if he did not know
wanted to explain these changes by understanding the laws of
anything and would get the other person to clarify their
nature
ideas and resolve logical inconsistencies (Price, 2000)
•Their study of change led them to the “idea of permanence”
•Using this method, the questioner should be skilled at
(Price, 2000)
detecting misconceptions and at revealing them by asking the
right questions
“The early philosophers sought to understand the nature of
•The goal is to bring the person closer to the final
human beings, problems of morality and life
understanding
philosophies”(Price, 2000)
TRUE SELF
•The touching of the soul,may mean helping the person
to get in touch with his true self
•The true self, Socrates said, is not the body but the 2. The Forms are unchanging and therefore
soul. Virtue is inner goodness, and real beauty is that permanent
of the soul (Price,2000) 3. The Forms are unmoving and indivisible
PLATO (428-348 BCE) •He considered human beings as microcosm of the universal
macrocosms i.e. everything in the universe can also be found
•His real name is Aristocles on people – earth, air, fire, water, mind and spirit (Price,2000)
•He was nicknamed “Plato” because of his physical built which
means wide/broad • Even if the materials of the human body and the physical
•Left Athens for 12 years after the death of Socrates world are imperfect, humans have an immortal, rational soul
•When he returned he established a school known as “The which Plato believed is created in the image of the divine.
Academy”
Theory of Forms SOUL
•Plato’sMetaphysics(philosophical study on the causes Plato described the soul as having three components:
and nature of things)
•Plato explained that Forms Refers To What Are Real 1.The Reason is rational and is the motivation for
•They are not objects encountered with the senses but goodness and truth
can only be grasped intellectually 2. The Spirited is non-rational and is the will or the
Plato’s Forms have the following characteristics: drive toward action
1. The Forms are ageless and therefore external
3. The Appetites are irrational and lean towards the (Moore and Bruder, 2002)
desire for pleasures of the body.
Christian Philosophers
Plato believed that people are intrinsically good. Sometimes ● Their concern was with God and man’s relationship
however, judgements are made in ignorance and Plato with God
equates ignorance with evil. (Price, 2000) ● These Christian philosophers did not believe that self -
knowledge and happiness were the ultimate goals of
Theory of Becoming and Love man.
● What people see are only shadows of reality which Greek Philosophers Christian Philosophers
they believe are real things and represents knowledge
Sees man as basically good Sees man as sinners who
● What these people fail to realize is that the shadows and becomes evil through reject/go against a loving
are not real for according to Plato, “only the Forms are ignorance of what is good God’s commands
real”
Plato’s Love
St. Augustine of Hippo (354-436 CE)
● Plato’s love begins with a feeling or experience that
there is something lacking ● Hippo, Africa
● This then drives the person to seek for that which is ● Became a priest and bishop of Hippo
lacking ● Initially rejected Christianity for it seemed to him then
● Thoughts and efforts are then directed towards the that Christianity could not provide him answers to
pursuit which is lacking questions that interested him
2. The Sinfulness of man Through math, he discovered that the human mind has
● The cause of sin or evil is an act of man’s TWO POWERS:
freewill
● Moral goodness can be only achieved through 1. INTUITION or the ability to apprehend direction
the grace of God of certain truths
2. DEDUCTION or the power to discover what is
The Role of Love not known by progressing in an orderly way
● That the man searches for happiness “For God is love from what is already known
and he created humans for them to also love”
● Disordered love results when man loves the wrong View of Human Nature
things which he believes will give him happiness. Descartes deduced that a thinker is a thing that doubts,
understands, affirms, denies, wills, refuses and also
St. Augustine explains… imagines and feels (Price, 2000)
1. Love of physical objects leads to sin of greed
2. Love for other people is not lasting and excessive love The Mind-Body Problem
for them is the sin of jealousy The body, according to Descartes, is like a machine
3. Love for the self leads to the sin of people that is controlled by the will and aided by the mind.
4. Love for God is the supreme virtue and only through
loving God can man find real happiness
John Locke (1632-1704)
● Born in Wrington, England
● Interested in politics; Defender of the parliamentary
Rene Descartes (1956-1650) system
● Father of Modern Philosophy ● At 57 years old, He published a book which played a
● One of the Rationalist Philosophers of Europe significant role in the era of Enlightenment (Price,
● Cartesian Method and Analytic Geometry 2000)
Moral good depends on the conformity of a person’s behavior In examining the patterns of thinking, Hume formulated three
towards some law principles on how ideas relate to one another:
View of Human Nature and The Self Freud in his 1920 book, “Beyond the Pleasure Principle”, he
presented 2 kinds of instincts that drive individual behavior:
“When the self sees an object, it tends to remember its
characteristics and applies on it, the forms of time and space” EROS – Life Instinct; the energy is called LIBIDO and urges
necessary for individual and species survival like thirst, hunger
● The term he used for this experience of the self and its and sex
unity with objects is TRANSCENDENTAL THANATOS – Death Instinct; behavior that is directed towards
APPERCEPTION destruction in the form of aggression and violence
In the matter of God, Kant stated that the Kingdom of God is View of Human Nature
within man
● God is manifested in people’s lives therefore it is man’s “Man’s behavior by his pleasure seeking life instinct and his
duty to move towards perfection. destructive instinct is said to be born with his ego already in
conflict”
Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) ● Man then lives his life balancing the forces of life and
● Austrian Neurologists death making mere existence a challenge
● His psychodynamic theory has characteristics of
philosophical thought Gilbert Ryle (1900-1976)
● Freud made use of methods like free association and ● English Philosopher
dream analysis for his clinical practice ● Contradicted Cartesian Dualism
● Stated that many of the philosophical problems were
Structures of the Mind caused by the wrong use of language
In Freud’s illustration, he made use of the typical iceberg to
show how the mind works based on his theorizing
View of Human Nature and Knowledge ● Aims to explore the relevance of the neuroscientific
studies to the philosophy of the mind
Ryle touched two types of knowledge:
Patricia claims that the man’s brain is responsible for the
KNOWING-HOW identity known as ‘the self’
Using facts in the performance of some skill or technical ● The biochemical properties of the brain according to
abilities this philosophy is really responsible for man’s thoughts,
KNOWING-THAT feelings and behavior
Refers to knowing facts/ information
View of Human Nature
“A person may acquire a great bulk of knowledge but without
the ability to use it to solve some practical problems to make “Man is endowed with more than just physical or neurological
his life easier, this bulk of knowledge is deemed to be characteristics. Despite research findings, neurophilosophy
worthless” states that the self is real, that it is the tool that helps the
person tune-in to the realities of the brain and the extant
reality”
Patricia & Paul Churchland
Maurice Merleau-Ponty(1908-1961)
Patricia Churchland ● French Phenomenological Philosopher
● Born on July 16, 1943 ● ‘Philosopher of the Body’
Pau lChurchland ● Center of his philosophy is the emphasis placed on the
● Born on October 21, 1942 human body as the primary site of knowing the world
Patricia coined the term NEUROPHILOSOPHY, who together View of Human Nature
with Paul was dissatisfied with the particular approach of According to Merleau-Ponty, The world and the sense of self
philosophers and instead sought to guide scientific theorizing are emergent phenomena in the ongoing process of man’s
with philosophy and guide philosophy with scientific inquiry ‘becoming’
The philosophy of neuroscience is the study of the philosophy In addition he stated that perception is not purely the result of
of the mind, the philosophy of science, neuroscience and sensations nor is it purely interpretation. Rather,
psychology.
consciousness is a process that includes sensing as well as At the center of his theorizing is the concept of
interpreting/reasoning self.
Linguistic Anthropology
● Human survival is primarily linked to their ability to Theory of Cultural Determinism
communicate and an essential part of human ● Where culture has a strong impact on how an
communication is language. individual views himself.
● Language –identifies a group of people; words, ● According to this theory, human nature is determined
sounds, symbols, writings and signs that are used are by the ideas, meanings, beliefs, and values learned as
reflections of a group’s culture. members of a society.
● Linguistic Anthropologists used language to discover a ● Who or what a person is maybe determined by the kind
group’s manner of social interaction, to create and of culture he is born into and grew up in.
share meanings to form ideas, concepts, and to ● Having different cultures, Cultural Anthropologists
promote social change, and how language changes suggest that there is no universal or right way of being
over time. human.The right way is always based on culture.Since
● Language is reflective of the time and mode of culture varies, there is no one way of understanding
thinking of the people using it. As societies change human nature.
and technologies develop, so do the symbols and
meaning people use through language as their way of This theory has positive and negative implications
communicating.
Positive Negative
Cultural Anthropology
● Culture –group of people’s way of life. Including their Human beings can be People have no control over
behavior, beliefs, values, and symbols that they accept, shaped to have the kind of what they learn. They blindly
life they prefer. There is no accept the learning their
socially transmitted through communication and
limit placed on the human culture exposes them to.
imitation from generation to generation. ability to be or to do They are seen as helpless
● Cultural Anthropologists focus on knowing what makes whatever they set their and do only what their
one group’s manner of living particular to that group minds and hearts into. culture instructs them to do.
Cultural Anthropology be inferred from the way people act and react to
● Cultural diversities are manifested in different ways and circumstances and situations.
at different levels of depth. Symbols are considered Ex: Kissing of the hand of elders
the most superficial level of culture and values belong
to the deepest level or are considered as the core of
culture.
● Ways in which culture may manifest itself in people:
○ Symbols The Self from the Perspective of Anthropology
○ Heroes ● Anthropology makes the person aware that what he is
○ Rituals may be determined by his past, and present condition,
○ Values his biological characteristics, the way he
● Ways in which culture may manifest itself in people: communicates, the language that he uses and the
○ Symbols –words, gestures, symbols, that have manner in which he chooses to live his life.
recognized meaning in a particular culture.
Ex: Rings that signify commitment
● Ways in which culture may manifest itself in people: PART 1_Lesson 4: From the Perspective of
○ Heroes –people from the past or present who
have characteristics that are important in a
Psychology
culture. They may be real or fictitious and are
models of behavior. William James (1842-1910)
Ex: Real –Jose Rizal Fictitious –Darna ● American Philosopher and Psychologist
● Professor of Psychology and Philosophy at Harvard
● Ways in which culture may manifest itself in people: University
○ Rituals –activities, may be religious or social, ● “Theory of the Self”
participated in by a group of people for the ● One of the great pragmatists
fulfillment of desired objectives and are ● Wrote a book entitled “The principles of Psychology”
considered to be socially essential.
Ex: Baptism, Wedding THE ‘ME’ AND THE ‘I’
● Ways in which culture may manifest itself in people: 1. All human thoughts are owned by some personal self.
○ Values –are unconscious, and can neither be 2. All thoughts are constantly changing or are never
discussed nor be directly observed but can only static.
3. There is a continuity of thoughts as its focus shifts ○ Refers to the self that is more concrete or
from one object to another. permanent when compared to the material and
4. Thoughts deal with objects that are different from and social selves.
independent of consciousness itself. ○ The most subjective and intimate part of the
5. Consciousness can focus on a particular object and not self.
others. ○ Always engaging in the process of
introspection(self-observation).
Women Men