Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lecture6-7 18757 Lecture6-7 18757 34
Lecture6-7 18757 Lecture6-7 18757 34
1
Acknowledgements
First thanks go to the fifty-two men and women who took part
in the research. They shared their experience and ideas with
me in order to help other people with schizophrenia have a
better life. They put a lot of thought into their contributions,
and a lot of time. Some preferred to remain anonymous, but I
am delighted that some agreed to be acknowledged by name.
They are:
Tracey Abraham, Christine Andrew, David Armes,
Bob Axford, Christina Burton, Emma Cox, Hywel Davies,
Robin Dickson, John Exell, Karl Fisher, Alan Foulds,
Keith Hall, Rosalind Graham Hunt, Robin Hanau, Malcolm
Hardman, Margaret Howarth, Robert Hughes, Edwin
Martin, Laurence Muspratt, Jamie Myers, Nina Rideout,
James Wooldridge and Zyra.
My steering group gave me companionship, support and
constructive criticism, and ensured that the perspective of the
individual living with schizophrenia remained central. They are:
Alan Foulds, Bob Axford, Christine Andrew, Edwin Martin,
A few of the people who James Field, Keith Hall, Robin Hanau, Sally Jones, Sophie
took part in the research. Jongman, Tina Burton, Tracey Abraham and Zyra.
Alison Faulkner and Brigid Morris, from the Strategies for
Living team at the Mental Health Foundation, gave external
supervision, shared their expertise in survivor research, and
offered invaluable encouragement.
2
Foreword
David Martyn and the service users who have contributed to this
report, deserve our congratulations and thanks for putting
together such an important and timely report which I have no
doubt will be widely read and digested.
3
Introduction
David Martyn
Self Management Project Manager
4
Contents
1 What is self-management?
5 Self-management initiatives
6 Further reading
5
1. What is self-management?
6
2. How people are affected by schizophrenia
While psychiatry defines schizophrenia by its symptoms, these “Anxiety – low self-
are not necessarily the most important problems for the people esteem – depression –
affected. Participants were invited to say for themselves how panic attacks – poor
they were affected by the condition. concentration –
thought overcrowding
Negative Effects – paranoid thoughts –
low assertiveness –
“It is worse than hell, dying, anything” prejudice – sensitivity
to stress – poor sleep
While many people described hearing voices, seeing visions, – lethargy – apathy –
experiencing hallucinations in other senses (touch, smell, etc.), or poor relationships with
having periods when they held unusual beliefs, others focused others – lonely – low
more on the distress of hospital admissions and the side effects self-confidence –
of medication. anger – frustration –
negative thoughts –
Others emphasised the social and personal effects, particularly agoraphobia – fear of
the loss of confidence and the difficulty relating to others. water – tranquilliser
addiction –
“It was a horrendous shock, painful, bleak, distressing, I was
confused sexuality.”
fragmented and unable to do very much for a long time”
(Anon)
A number spoke of their education being disrupted or losing their
jobs or careers. Some lost marriages and homes.
“Having a feeling for
Others spoke of the stigma and the sometimes thoughtless, sounds of words –
sometimes cruel, reactions of other people. loving music – feeling
at one with nature
and the universe –
Positive effects being strongly
affected by beauty in
A number of people stressed that there were positive aspects to
a positive way”
their condition. The creativity associated with the condition
(Anon)
emerged a number of times. One person “commanded” his
“demons” to write music. Another wrote of
SELF-MANAGEMENT
Interpersonal
self-management
Basic Occupation Recreation
living
skills An ordinary life: An (extra)ordinary Social
coping life: thriving life
Healthy
living
Personal
self-management
Information and
education
Managing having
schizophrenia Talking
therapies
Relapse
Managing
management Symptom Complementary relationships
management therapies with healthcare
Managing workers
medication
8
Maintaining morale, finding meaning
9
Relationships with other people
Other people Relationships with other people were one of the most important
contribute ... factors in participants’ ability to self-manage.
Hearing Voices Some people spoke of the role their children played in their lives.
Groups can be ...
Other ‘users’ and the ‘user movement’
“... a very important People found a high level of understanding and acceptance
part of coping and from others with similar experiences and problems.
self-management as
people are able to talk User groups, self-help groups and day centres provide places to
meet people with similar problems and discuss experiences and
freely and discuss
ways of coping.
details about the voices
that they could not do “Most of my friends are schizophrenics and that is my choice”
with their family.” (Chris Andrew)
(Chris Andrew)
“The user movement gave support – understood – friendship –
compassion – empathy – not judging – liberating – treating you
as yourself – listening” (Nina Rideout)
“...very intimate and
family-like. All share Others
their experiences to Many spoke of the importance to them of the services they
do with their voices used, be they day centres, supported housing or, for some, day
(and) telephone each hospitals. A number singled out one or more professionals who
other to check they are had been significant for them.
going to be at
“My psychotherapist helped me to understand my talents
the meeting”
as an artist” (Robert Hughes)
(Emma Cox)
For some, colleagues from work, education and recreational
activities provided support; for others, their church or faith
community. Other sources of community included the local pub
and the Labour Party.
10
An ordinary life: coping
Schizophrenia often disrupts people’s lives in adolescence and “I have had to learn to
early adulthood. As well as learning to live with the condition, live on benefits, having
people with schizophrenia often need to catch up on learning previously worked. I
they have missed out on. cost items and make
lists of basic
Basic living skills such as: necessities. When
• budgeting and “financial discipline” shopping I only take
• finding somewhere to live the amount of money
• home management needed. There is no
• shopping room for mistakes. I
• cooking have learned to be
• personal self-care
very self-disciplined.”
• getting medical attention for physical health needs
(Margaret Howarth)
Healthy living
Exercise, including walking, running, cycling, swimming, gym,
yoga and body building, was mentioned by several people. Relief
of stress was the most commonly mentioned benefit. “Light exercise – such
as a daily walk – helps
Also mentioned were: you to feel better
• eating well physically, counteracts
• giving up or cutting down on coffee the effects of some
• giving up or cutting down on alcohol medication, and keeps
• not misusing drugs your weight under
• getting good sleep control. Strenuous
exercise – such as
Personal self-management including: swimming – untenses
the body and often lifts
• self-assessment (identifying own strengths and a lot of headaches
weaknesses, talents and needs) and problems almost
• goal setting – long term and short term –
miraculously”
realistic and manageable
(Chris Andrew)
• being organised, planning small steps towards
larger goals
• stress management
Interpersonal self-management
A number of participants mentioned that social isolation was a
cause or a consequence of a breakdown, and a few reported
that learning specific skills or strategies was helpful.
Two people wrote of observing others to learn how to
communicate. One spoke of learning to compromise, learning to
fit in. Another mentioned learning assertiveness. Withdrawal from
social contacts during periods of breakdown was a valuable strategy
for some in maintaining social relationships.
11
An (extra)ordinary life: thriving
“Losing my job was a Beyond coping, people sought to build a life which was fulfilling
turning point in my life. and satisfying. For some the aim was to have a life like other
I have less stress and people while others sought to create a life which celebrated
anxiety; I’ve got more their difference.
time to make friends,
and I’ve gone from Occupation
strength to strength” Participants spoke about occupation more than any other issue.
(Malcolm Hardman)
Many people described long personal journeys, perhaps starting
with a need to reframe their ambitions in the light of their
condition.
“Activities in the user One person started a degree three times, finally completing it six
movement have years after first starting. He is now working for a Ph.D.
provided worthwhile
Another did an art foundation course and went on to art college
challenges and some
to do a degree. He is now running a community art project.
satisfaction in life”
(Bob Axford) Another occupied himself for 20 years with artwork, gardening and
voluntary work, and now has a paid job for the first time in his life.
Art, writing and other creative activities were a focus for many
people. Others took an active role in the user movement. One
“I lost my job and person spoke at conferences about her experiences. Others
no-one would interview organised user groups and networks. Others were involved with
me ... I have become a campaigning or the provision of mental health services.
parish evangelist”
(Rosalind Graham Hunt) Recreation
Reading, writing, painting, sculpting, photography, playing and
listening to music, dance, rambling, studying history, were some
of the activities that people spoke of.
Social life
Having a satisfactory social life is a large part of thriving for
most people. See Relationships with other people (Page 10)
for details.
12
Managing ‘having schizophrenia’
People had often been through a number of changes of I raised it again and
medication. One described his medication management regime nothing clear was said,
as follows: no helpful information
or discussion regarding
“Keep steady dose – change when side effects are bad – choice ensued.
I have to look after that – down to me to change if things are
going wrong. I raised it again with the
‘Only the Best’* pack in
Long trawl through different types: Chlopromazine –
Sulpiride – Risperidone. my hand.
Effort to go back to professionals – drug change itself is I sat there with the
difficult – have taken time off work to do a drug change psychiatrist, having all
(without telling truth – stressful in itself)” (Laurence Muspratt) the information before
my eyes and before
For some people, the newer atypicals were a great improvement. her eyes.
Others had negotiated being able to self-medicate – increasing
their dose within agreed limits at times of stress, and taking a Now I am on an
smaller, maintenance dose the rest of the time. atypical I myself
thought looked good
on the comparative
Managing relationships with healthcare workers
table in the pack.”
Many people had had some good and helpful relationships with (Anon)
professionals, but experiences were mixed.
Complaints included:
• saying that you were getting unwell and not
being believed
• being given behavioural treatments that were punitive
and damaging
• not being given choice over medication
• lack of guidance on managing hallucinations
Symptom management
It would take a much larger study than this to do justice to the
range of experiences and ways of coping with them that people
with a schizophrenia diagnosis have found. What follows is a
brief summary of what was said.
14
Hearing voices
Some people cope with their voices by giving them a set time
each day in which they will talk with them.
Others notice that voices are stronger when they are stressed,
and they cope by withdrawing from stressful situations.
Other hallucinations
One person described his managing hallucinations as a “lesson
in metaphysics”. He had to learn to distance himself from his
perceptions and not assume they were true. He compared his
approach to meditation in which you watch thoughts arise and “Complementary
pass away without attachment to them.
therapies are building
up my tolerance to
Talking therapies stress, and not just
helping me relax. If I
Talking therapies were mentioned by a number of people. had these three times
Their benefits included: a week I would be
able to go back to
• an opportunity to explore and understand the experience work. These therapies
• challenging ineffective ways of thinking and acting
work alongside
• challenging delusory beliefs, paranoia, etc.
• identifying talents and preferred futures
medication – I still had
• learning coping strategies psychotic episodes
• learning from others in group situations when I was on
medication alone.
Also, complementary
Complementary therapies therapies do not
dampen emotions as
Complementary therapies mentioned included nutrition, medication does. My
Alexander Technique, art therapy, reiki, aromatherapy, zest for life has really
acupuncture, meditation and massage. come back due to
these therapies.”
(Karl Fisher)
15
4. Building a Self-Management Project
“It is important that the Many people testified to the help they had received from sharing
project reaches ... experiences and ideas with others with similar experiences, and
people in day centres, proposed self-management support groups, either user-led or
hospitals, those co-led with a skilled facilitator.
isolated at home ...
people who are not One-to-one peer support, or mentoring by a more experienced
already aware of self- self-manager, was also proposed.
management.
(Comment at There was strong support for written material on self-
feedback conference) management, for use both by individuals and groups.
16
5. Self-Management Initiatives
National Voices
Forum National Voices Forum
www.voicesforum.org.uk
www.voicesforum.org.uk
National Voices Forum is the user and survivor network within
Rethink. It has a long-standing involvement in self-management.
It has been running annual self-management conferences since
1998 and members have supported the Rethink Self-
Management Project as participants and members of the
steering group.
Strategies for Living
www.mentalhealth.org.uk Strategies for Living
www.mentalhealth.org.uk
Strategies for Living, based at the Mental Health Foundation
(MHF), is a programme of user-led research into what enables
people with mental distress to live a full life. Their publications are
Wellness Recovery an invaluable resource for people interested in self-management.
Action Planning
(WRAP) Wellness Recovery Action Planning (WRAP)
www.mentalhealthrecovery.com
www.mentalhealthrecovery.com
Based on Mary Ellen Copeland’s personal journey of recovery
piers.allott@wlv.ac.uk
from depression and manic depression, WRAP combines a
focus on developing a ‘wellness toolbox’ – activities (and
avoidances) which maintain well-being – with planning ahead for
periods of illness through self-awareness of triggers and early
warning signs, and writing a crisis plan.
Accredited WRAP trainers in Britain may be contacted through
Piers Allott at piers.allott@wlv.ac.uk.
18
6. Further reading
Baker P (1995)
The Voice Inside: A practical guide to coping with hearing
voices. Hearing Voices Network.
Cooper J (2001)
Partnerships for Successful Self-Management: the Living
with Long-term Illness Project Report.
Long-term Medical Conditions Alliance.
Copeland M E (1997)
Wellness Recovery Action Plan. Peach Press (USA).
Guinness D (1995)
Inside Out: A guide to self-management of manic
depression. Manic Depression Fellowship.
19
“Allowing myself to feel
bad can also be a self
management strategy”
Anon
December 2003
20
rethink:design & print 024 7674 8602