Blasphemy Law: Coming a full circle

BY BUSHRAS ON OCTOBER 14TH, 2011 | COMMENTS (51)

It was bound to happen. When you have a vaguely worded law

with so many loopholes, and a clergy hell bent on defining
religion in asphyxiating, rigid boundaries, its supporters and
enablers were bound to get scorched themselves. The law
was eventually going to come and bite them in the back and
that is exactly what happened two weeks ago.

According to the news story, a student of a religious seminary

in Chakwal, Junaid Ahmad was arrested for being
blasphemous. He was apparently seen burning pages of
Quran a week ago, was beaten by a crowd and handed over
to the police. Ironically, however, a shaken and frightened
Junaid claimed that he was in reality disposing off Quran’s
loose pages to save them from desecration.

The story behind Junaid’s action was simple enough. His teacher, who belongs to Tehrik Khuddam Ahl-i-Sunnat, had
told him that burning Quranic pages was a legitimate way of disposing them along with putting them in flowing water
(stream etc) and burying them. As he was unable to find the other two options, Junaid resorted to the third one. It was
just his luck that the man who saw him as he set the pages on fire had heard from another cleric that burning the
Quran amounted to desecrating it. What followed is an ominous reminder of sharply converging, and rigid,
interpretations among various schools of religious thought.

Diversity, whether religious or cultural, is always a good thing. But here, this diversity of belief within sects and sub-
sects is stamped with unflinching righteousness, intolerance, and violent knee-jerk reactions. Leaving the organised
sectarianism between Shias and Sunnis aside, these widely varying interpretations in such an environment result in
friction and veiled hatred towards other sects within one’s circle. In such a situation, incidents like the one in Chakwal
are in reality a mere prelude to what can follow. One of the most obvious possibilities, while remaining within the
ambit of law, is the misuse of the blasphemy law against those who are fanatically in favour of it.

This misuse has already started albeit it is infrequent at the moment. In January this year, an imam and his son from
Dera Ghazi Khan were convicted for life for committing blasphemy. They were accused of ripping posters from
outside their grocery shop which advertised an event to observe Eid Milad un Nabi (the birth and death anniversary of
Prophet Muhammad). There was strong speculation that the issue was not of blasphemy but difference of belief. The
Deobandi philosophy, to which the imam and his son prescribed, do not believe in commemorating such days. So
where the incident might have simply been that of removing a poster from their personal property, it was forcefully
catapulted in the sphere of intentional blasphemy.

The problem, boiled down to its essence, is this: In all this ritualistic madness, this manic obsession with the act
rather than the intention behind it, these “men of faith” have lost the plot. And that is an under-statement. Here school
girls are ostracised for misplacing a dot in a word. Doctors are locked up for throwing away a person’s visiting card
who shared the prophet’s name. People are persecuted for greeting others in Arabic language. Supporters of
blasphemy laws obsessively defend its need to deter people from taking the law in their own hands; but when a man
defies this very logic and kills a sitting governor whom he had taken an oath to protect, they cheer and holler
themselves hoarse in his support.
So far, most of the victims of these laws are minorities and those belonging to lower and lower-middle income groups.
But it won’t remain the same forever. With ferocious intolerance being allowed to breed unchecked in our country, it
was only a matter of time before the factions started using this law to target religious rivals at will.

Right now a broad spectrum of religious right is united in its defence of murderer Mumtaz Qadri. Their slogans,
demonstrative of their tunnel-minded support for his actions, should be deafening alarm bells for the rest of us.

It is a matter of time before these stout believers, momentarily united in their hate against
“liberal fascists”, turn on each other. With such varied interpretations of religion, how will the courts interpret criteria of
blasphemy? Will they take the easiest way out and just continue sentencing people in the hope the High Courts will
correct the injustice? Will these cowardly actions really serve as a long-term pre-emptive solution or will the religious
factions soon interlock horns?

If there is a legal or public showdown between people of different beliefs, the result will be more bloody, brutal and
long drawn out than we can imagine. With all sides equally sure of their virtue and willing to die or kill for it, there
might not be anyone standing at the end.

On a sardonic note, that will work out just right for the rest of the country.

Bushra S is an editor based in Lahore and can be found conversing on twitter  here.

The views expressed by this blogger and in the following reader comments do not necessarily reflect the
views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.
CHAKWAL: An additional district and sessions judge in Talagang sentenced a man to death
on Tuesday for committing blasphemy.

Judge Rana Zahoor Ahmad also imposed a fine of Rs50,000 on 29-year-old Abdul Sattar, a resident
of Larkana, who was sent to prison in Jhelum.

Mohammad Saeed, of Talagang town, had filed a complaint with the city police station on Feb 5 last
year. He said he had been receiving derogatory text messages and calls from a wrong number for
several days. He told police that contents of the messages and conversation of the caller
blasphemed Holy Quran, Prophet (PBUH) and Sahabas (companions of the Prophet).

A case was registered and District Police Officer Syed Ali Mohsin set up a special inquiry committee,
headed by then Superintendent of Police (Investigation) Malik Matloob.

The committee collected data of calls and text messages sent by a cell number belonging to Abdul
Sattar.

“We took permission from the home department for a raid in Larkana and arrested the accused,” SP
Matloob told Dawn on phone from Rawalpindi.

He said Sattar had confessed to have committed the crime. “The accused behaved quite normally
when arrested,” the SP added.