Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Joint Less Pavements For Heavy-Duty Airport Application: The Semi-Flexible Approach Jean Mayer I & Mikael Thau 2
Joint Less Pavements For Heavy-Duty Airport Application: The Semi-Flexible Approach Jean Mayer I & Mikael Thau 2
ABSTRACT
In Copenhagen Airport, extensive developments in the field of Semi-Flexible
pavement structures have demonstrated high potentials for very heavy loads
and static loads in particular. The experience of the Semi-Flexible Pavement
(SFP) concept dates back 25 years. However, during the late eighties, a new
generation of this special product emerged which brought about further
development towards high quality pavements exhibiting very high strength
and durability. Today, it is possible to design Semi-Flexible Pavements for
type E aircrafts in regard of aprons, stand gates, de-icing stands, start-up
pads, taxiways and other heavy loaded areas. More than 300,000m 2 has been
applied in Copenhagen Airport. Of this area, 165,000m 2 are constructed from
1988 through 2000 utilizing the enhanced second generation technique.
The general SFP concept consists of a joint less wearing course composed of
an open-graded asphalt concrete filled with a special slurry grout. The
underlying bituminous layers are designed for high strength and high load-
bearing capacity. The Semi-Flexible wearing course will not develop cracks
due to shrinkage, nor will it show any plastic flow.
The joint less SFP have provided Copenhagen Airport with a high
performing pavement with a minimum of maintenance. The better economy
and advantageous technology offered by the SFP have been desirable
compared to concrete slab pavements. The new enhanced Heavy-Duty Semi-
Flexible Pavement structures are expected to be the desired solution for
pavements designed for heavy loads.
1
Jean Mayer, Manager of Constructmon,CopenhagenAirport, Luflhavnsboulevarden6,
2770 Kastrup, Denmark;phone +45 32313231;j.mayer@cph.dk
2Mikael Thau, Director, LOTCON, Roegen Hedevej 148, 8472 Sporup, Denmark;
phone +45 26228146; mt@lotcon.dk
87
Introduction
The first generation of the Semi-Flexible Pavement concept was developed
in the late sixties by the French construction company Jean Lefebvre and
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by New York University on 05/09/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
Photo 1: CopenhagenAirport
For the SFP, these climatic conditions dictate high resistance to freeze/thaw
effects, which lead to requirements for a very low residual void content. The
first generation of SFP did not provide a pavement layer in which the
residual void content was low enough. Especially a high void section in the
bottom of the semi-flexible layer subjected to freeze/thaw effects could
cause pavement failure. Consequently, Densit and Phoenix Contractors
representing a Danish mortar producer and a Danish asphalt contractor,
respectively joint forces in 1987 to develop a second generation of the SFP
system. The objective was to develop a system, which with a high degree of
reliability could be produced and laid to an appropriate low content of
residual voids. The output of this effort was named Densiphalt (2,4).
The second generation of SFP was optimized in two directions. First, the
open-graded asphalt concrete was optimized to get a higher fraction of the
total voids penetrable for the slurry grout. Second, a new type of High
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by New York University on 05/09/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
Photo 2 & 3: Structure within the Semi-Flexible wearing course (p. 2) and
surface appearance of the Semi-Flexible Pavement (p. 3)
9 Fast curing of SFP is very important for the efficiency of the airport.
9 Elimination of joints is important due to environmental requirements and
restrictions concerning penetration of any spillage to the ground.
The standard SFP structure has a history of being a very good performer
with regard to aprons for type C aircrafts. However, the introduction of the
SFP structure at stand gates equipped with modem electronic docking
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by New York University on 05/09/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
Temperature
Frequency 0~ 200(2 40~
0.1 Hz 15,700 5,300 1,300
1.0Hz 19,900 8,200 2,500
4.9 Hz 22,800 10,800 4,000
9.8Hz 23,900 12,100 4,800
19.6Hz 25,400 13,300 5,800
A linear elastic analysis was performed to investigate how the vertical stress
at the top of the bituminous layers depended on the thickness of wearing
course layer. This vertical stress was then compared to expected optimum
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by New York University on 05/09/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
days in the field. Assuming a daily effective loading time at the stand gate of
315 minutes, the transformation gave an equivalent time period of 1270
average annual days.
indicates that re-profiling of the surface may be necessary every eight to ten
years and will involve only the limited area affected by the main gears of the
aircrafts. The necessary work can be conducted within 24 hours and given
one to two days to cure the HP slurry grout, the total time for closing the
area is two to three days. An example of a HDSFP structure for type E
aircrafts is shown below.
Aircraft Type E
Semi-Flexible Wearing Course 100mm
High Modulus SBS Modified Asphalt Concrete1 90mm
High Modulus Asphalt Concrete2 60mm
Reclaimed Crushed Concrete3 250mm
Sub-base 250mm
Sub-grade assumed to exhibit CBR minimum 7%.
1. HighModulusSBS ModifiedAsphaltConcrete is designedwith 100%crushed granite
aggregate and hard asphaltcementmodifiedwith highcontent(>6%)of SBS polymer.
2. HighModulusAsphaltConcreteis designedwithhard asphaltcement.
3. Crushedgranularbase can be usedas alternativeto reclaimedcrushedconcrete.
The four stand gates constructed as standard SFP structure mentioned above
were partly reconstructed during 1999 as HDSFP, The part of the area,
which received the main loading was milled to a depth of 170mm and
replaced with 80ram High Modulus SBS Modified Asphalt Concrete
developed to resist extreme static loads. On the surface, 90ram of Densiphalt
was applied (a semi-flexible material). The performance of the replaced
section has been excellent.
The promising results achieved from the full-scale trial gave confidence in
the HDSFP structure, and the pavement concept was chosen to be used in
new construction planned for the year 2000. The construction represented a
total area o f 92,000rn 2 of SFP including de-icing stands, remote aprons, start-
up pads and taxiways for the use of all types of aircrafts including type E
aircrafts. Of this area, approximately 45,000m were constructed as HDSFP.
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by New York University on 05/09/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
Especially, the HDSFP structure is feasible for the use at de-icing stands due
to the impermeable pavement which facilitates safe catch and re-use of de-
icing chemicals. The area was taken into service in October 2000 and until
now the performance has been excellent.
poured onto the open-graded asphalt material and squeegeed over the surface
(Photo 4). The process continues until all voids are filled with grout.
The climatic condition is very important for the installation of the HP slurry
grout. The grout has a very low water content and in case of significant
evaporation in hot and windy conditions, the workability of the grout may be
reduced risking insufficient penetration into the open-graded asphalt
concrete and formation of pinholes. During hot days, the installation of the
grout should be done at night. The grout should not be installed at
temperatures below 5~
QC/QA
Quality control of the open-graded asphalt mixture contains asphalt content,
gradation and voids. The voids in the laid open-graded asphalt concrete shall
be 25-30%. If the void content is too low, it will not be possible to
completely fill the void structure and the final SFP will have insufficient
strength and durability. If the percentage of voids is excessive, the material
may not have enough flexibility. The void content can be measured on cores,
or the quality control can be managed during the installation of the grout.
During the installation of the HP slurry grout, the consumption of powder for
the grout will give an effective indication of the voids in the open-graded
asphalt concrete. In addition, the water/powder ratio should be controlled by
viscosity tests at the site. If necessary, cores can be cut to check for
appropriate filling of the open-graded asphalt concrete and to test the
strength either by compressive strength or by indirect tensile strength.
The final surface should be checked for pinholes. Pinholes some times
appear in the SFP surface. Generally, pinholes are not wanted. However, if
pinholes appear as a surface phenomenon (< 5mm depth) they will not hurt
the pavement, and the surface will normally be accepted if the area involved
represents less than 5-10% of the total area.
Further Developments
With the purpose to eliminate any risk of plastic deformation in the
bituminous layers of the pavement structure, an investigation has been
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by New York University on 05/09/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
initiated to study the possibility to exchange the bituminous layers under the
SF wearing course with a Semi-Flexible base layer (9).
In the structural layers, the resistance to fatigue has to be addressed. The
fatigue properties of the semi-flexible material Densiphalt have been tested
in a four-point beam bending test in accordance with the Dutch Road and
Hydraulic Engineering Division of Rijkswaterstaat doc. W-DWW-94530.
The result of the laboratory test gave the following fatigue response at 20~
~i : Initial strain
To get an idea of the shift factor to full-scale use, it was decided to run tests
in a full-scale laboratory wheel tracking machine located at the National
Danish Road Institute.
the slab, strain gauges placed in the bottom of the slab measure the
horizontal strain of the slab.
The results from the full-scale test justified a shift factor of 3. Currently,
Copenhagen Airport plans to put down a test section within the 2001
construction program to try out the concept in the field.
Conclusion
The Semi-Flexible Pavement (SFP) is a tough and durable surfacing material
that combines the flexible characteristics of an asphalt concrete with the
abrasion, wear and deformation resistance of Portland cement concrete. The
experience of the SFP concept in Copenhagen Airport dates back 25 years.
Several significant improvements have been added to the original concept
and a very high performance has been achieved. Today, it is possible to
design Semi-Flexible Pavements for all types of aircrafts including type E
aircrafts. Since the 1970s, a total of more than 300,000m 2 has been applied.
Of this area, 165,000m 2 are constructed from 1988 through 2000 utilizing the
enhanced second generation SFP technique.
In the pursue for alternatives to concrete slab pavement, the airport
introduced the Heavy-Duty Semi-Flexible Pavement (HDSFP) which could
be used on heavy loaded areas and especially areas subject to the repeated
static loads present at stand gates equipped with electronic docking systems.
The HDSFP structure utilizes thick Semi-Flexible wearing courses
representing 90mm for type C aircrafts and 100mm for type E aircrafts
respectively. The underlying bituminous layers are comprised of High
Modulus Polymer Modified Asphalt Concrete Binder layer and a High
Modulus Bituminous Base layer. Today, 50,000m ~ of HDSFP have been put
down in Copenhagen Airport.
A detailed QC/QA program has been developed and implemented. The key
parameter to correct the quality of SFP is the achievement of correct voids in
the final open-graded asphalt layer and effective installation of the slurry
grout.
The HDSFP design strives to minimize the total layer thickness of the
bituminous binder and base layers to minimize the risk of deformations in
these layers. However, some permanent deformations will be expected to
add up when subject to the repeated static loads present at stand gates
to the area affected by the main gears of the aircrafts, and the remedy work
can be conducted very efficiently within a total time of two to three days
when the area has to be closed.
The performance of the Semi-Flexible Pavement concept has proven successful
for more than a decade, and the new HDSFP structures are expected to be the
desired solution for pavements designed for heavy loads. Better economy with
possible savings up to 50%, the ease of construction and the elimination of
reflection joints have especially been desirable compared to typical concrete
slab pavements. Several uses are anticipated as potential applications for the
SFP concept. Today, the airport has applied standard SFP and HDSFP at aprons,
stand gates, de-icing stands, start-up pad, taxiways and other heavy loaded
areas. For the future SFP construction of touch-down areas on runways is under
consideration, and further enhancement of the concept to eliminate any risk of
plastic deformation is currently investigated.
References