Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Experiences With Zeron 100® Superduplex Stainless Steel in The Process Industries
Experiences With Zeron 100® Superduplex Stainless Steel in The Process Industries
Experiences With Zeron 100® Superduplex Stainless Steel in The Process Industries
SSW99-007
PAGE 613
Keywords: superduplex stainless steel, mechanical properties, design criteria, chemicals, corrosion
Alloy UNS no. 0.2% proof stress UTS (Mpa) Elongation (%)
(Mpa)
316L S31603 210 500 45
904L N08904 230 530 35
22 Cr duplex S31803 450 620 25
C-276 N10276 365 785 40
Zeron 100 (wrought) S32760 550 750 25
Zeron 100 (cast) J93380 450 700 25
Table 2. Typical mechanical properties of some common stainless steels.
from 20 to 300°C to all three codes are industry, and in many countries application
shown in table 3, which shows the higher to the national pressure vessel authority will
design stresses permitted by BS5500. permit the use of internationally recognised
Zeron 100 has good strength at high tem- standards such as BS5500.
perature and this is reflected by the almost
constant design stress to both ASME codes 2.2 Corrosion resistance
at temperatures from 150 to 300°C. Other The relative pitting resistance of stainless
alloys, such as austenitic stainless steels steels and nickel alloys is often compared
and 22 Cr duplex show a substantial loss of using the ASTM G48-A test in ferric chlo-
strength over this temperature range. ride. The high chloride content, low pH, and
By utilising suitable design codes such as highly oxidising nature of this solution is not
BS5500, it is possible to make substantial dissimilar to a number of solutions in use by
wall thickness reductions for duplex stain- the chemical industry. The temperature at
less steels compared to 316L and hence which pitting is first observed is known as
offset the somewhat higher cost of the the critical pitting temperature (CPT).
duplex material. The use of a thinner wall Figure 1 shows the CPT for a number of
means that there will also be a reduction in stainless steels.
fabrication costs and time, leading to over- It can be seen that the CPT of Zeron 100 is
all savings. The greater strength of ZERON superior to both 316L, 22 Cr duplex and
100 compared with 22% Cr duplex, partic- 904L and, while not so great as that of C-
ularly at high temperatures also presents 276, the value of 70°C for Zeron 100 is ade-
opportunities for wall thickness and cost quate for many applications.
savings. One recurring problem in chemical plants is
Table 4 shows the maximum design stress chloride stress corrosion cracking (SCC) of
at room temperature and 150°C for some 304L and 316L stainless steels. The duplex
stainless steels using ASME VIII and stainless steels are much more resistant to
BS5500. The figures clearly show the much chloride SCC than the austenitic alloys, as
higher stresses permitted by BS5500. This shown in figure 2.
code is widely used by the UK chemical Zeron 100 has shown no indications of
cracking in 3% sodium chloride solution
up to 250°C. Thus Zeron 100 offers the
Temp. (C) Alloy Design stress (MPa) chloride stress corrosion cracking resis-
ASME VIII BS5500 tance of alloy C-276 at a much lower cost.
20 316L 115 150 Zeron 100 was originally developed for
904L 123 * service in seawater, but it has subsequently
found applications in many other environ-
22 Cr duplex 155 289
ments. This is because of its exceptional
Zeron 100 188 319 resistance to hydrogen sulphide, acids and
150 316L 88 119 alkalis.
904L 104 * Figure 3 shows the resistance of Zeron 100
22 Cr duplex 150 209 to sulphuric acid, compared with 316L,
Zeron 100 178 281 alloy 20 and S32750. The latter is another
superduplex stainless, but without addi-
Table 4. Design stresses for some stainless steels to two codes at tions of copper and tungsten. It is these lat-
20°C and 150°C.
* not listed ter two elements which are believed to
contribute greatly to the resistance of Zeron
Figure 2. Temperature for the onset of chloride SCC in 3% sodium chloride solution.
Figure 3. Iso-corrosion curves (0.1 mm/y for some stainless steels in sulphuric acid.
100 to sulphuric acid. Even when there are produces a substantial loss of impact
chlorides in the sulphuric acid, Zeron 100 toughness. This takes thousands of hours
has very good corrosion resistance com- at 330°C but only 6 hours at 475°C, and
pared to many other stainless steels, as generally prevents the use of Zeron 100
shown in figure 4. above 300°C.
Hydrochloric acid is widely used commer- Zeron 100 is frequently used in applications
cially and is a by-product in many pro- where good impact toughness is required in
cesses. Figure 5 shows the resistance of fabricated units down to –46°C. In some
Zeron 100 to hydrochloric acid compared cases the alloy has been used at lower tem-
with 316L, S31254 (a 6Mo austenitic stain- peratures, and two recent applications
less steel) and S32750 (a superduplex involved –60°C and –120°C respectively.
alloy). As for sulphuric acid, it is the combi- One of these is described below.
nation of copper and tungsten in Zeron 100
that is believed to give its good corrosion
resistance. 3 Applications
Zeron 100 also has very good resistance to
commercial grades of phosphoric acid Below are some examples of the use of
(containing fluorides and chlorides) and Zeron 100 from a wide range of industries.
acetic acid (containing formic acid and/or The list is not meant to be exhaustive, but
halides) as described in Section 3, below. shows the diverse uses for the alloy.
Zeron 100 also has excellent resistance to
alkalis. The corrosion rate is ≤ 0.1mm/y up 3.1 Seawater
to 50 wt% caustic soda at 120°C. This Zeron 100 was originally developed as an
good corrosion resistance is not signifi- alloy for seawater service. Seawater lift
cantly affected by the presence of chlo- pumps and firewater pumps have been in
rides. Some applications in caustic service since 1986, with excellent results.
environments are described below. Wrought Zeron 100 has been extensively
used for seawater and firewater piping, fit-
2.3 Limits of use tings and flanges, as well as heat exchang-
Above 300°C all duplex stainless steels will ers and pressure break vessels.
precipitate the alpha prime phase, which
Figure 4. Iso-corrosion curves (0.1 mm/y) for some stainless steels in sulphuric acid plus 2,000 mg/l chloride.
Figure 5. Iso-corrosion curves (0.1 mm/y) for some stainless steels in hydrochloric acid.
Figure 6. Comparative erosion corrosion data for some FGD slurry pump alloys.
native to the nickel alloy C-276 (UNS tains hydrochloric acid. Zeron 100 was cho-
N10276). sen because of its high resistance to this
acid.
3.8 Mining/extraction Zeron 100 has been very successful in both
Zeron 100 has been used for pumps in the cast and wrought forms in acid leach min-
Canadian Potash fields, where strong solu- ing. There are a range of processes but they
tions of potassium chloride, with some all involve treating metal ores with sulphuric
sodium chloride (about 30% concentration) acid at elevated temperatures and pres-
are handled at temperatures around 80°C sures. These processes are used for
Zeron 100 has excellent corrosion resis- extracting gold, nickel, copper and uranium
tance and is more cost-effective than the and when the water used for making the
alternative nickel alloys. One user now slurry contains substantial quantities of
describes his pumps as ‘bullet-proof’. chlorides, the fluids are extremely corro-
The process for extracting alumina from sive. Francis et al. (ref. 7) have described
bauxite ores is based on the Bayer Process, the environments found in acid leach
discovered over 90 years ago, in which processing of nickel laterite ores and some
bauxite is dissolved in caustic solution. of the applications for Zeron 100. The uses
Ground bauxite (300 microns) is mixed with include the sparge pipes in the reactor at a
caustic soda solution, 120–220 g/l, at 165– gold mine, the slurry injection pumps for
240°C. The mixture is passed through nickel laterite ore processing, the exposed
steam-heated digesters where the alumina metal parts on the thickeners at both a ura-
is dissolved out of the suspended bauxite. nium mine and a nickel laterite ore project
The resulting hot slurry is diluted to help as well as for agitators and stirrers.
remove insoluble impurities such as sand Zeron 100 also has uses in the downstream
and iron oxide, and passes through a series processing area, e.g. vessels and pipework,
of vessels to remove silica. The liquor is particularly when pH’s are low and/or tem-
passed through pressure filters to remove peratures and chlorides are high.
residual impurities, cooled by evaporation
to 50°C, and is then passed into large 3.9 Engineering
capacity vessels where it is mixed with alu- Zeron 100 has also found some novel appli-
mina hydroxide (seed) to precipitate the alu- cations in general engineering. Weir Materi-
mina hydrate from the solution. After als has supplied cast Zeron 100 segments
filtration, most of the alumina hydrate for lining a tunnel section of the London
returns to the process as liquor. The hydrate Underground Railway. The ground water in
is washed, dried on disc and drum filters this 0.5km stretch consists of dilute sulphu-
and is fed into calcining kilns operating at ric acid plus chlorides which was causing
1300°C, producing alumina (Al2O3). The cracking of the existing cast iron lining.
spent liquor contains caustic soda, sodium Zeron 100 was chosen because of its
chloride and silica, typically at about 210°C. strength, corrosion resistance and ready
Every 10 days or so the piping is cleaned castability. Over 20,000 Zeron 100 fasten-
with inhibited sulphuric acid to remove sil- ers were also supplied for assembling the
ica scale. tunnel lining segments.
Zeron 100 is currently being used in one Zeron 100 has also found useful applica-
alumina plant in Eire for pipework handling tions in concrete constructions. This is
the hot slurry. This is both caustic and abra- because of its high strength and corrosion
sive and Zeron 100 has proven to have resistance in the presence of chlorides. The
good resistance to this environment. main concern is that the reinforcement
Inspection of a 16" spool after 2 years should not corrode even when the concrete
showed it to be in immaculate condition. is damaged. Because of the problems with
Zeron 100 is being used for the J-tubes in corrosion of steel reinforcing bars in con-
the spent liquor circuit, as an alternative to crete and the demand for Zeron 100 con-
nickel coated steel, which has only a short crete products, WML is now producing
life (2–3 years). Zeron 100 reinforcing bars. Applications
A titanium dioxide refinery in the Middle include alignment dowel pins for concrete
East is also using Zeron 100 pipework for blocks and special concrete fixings for
the spent acid lines. This plant uses the marine applications. Zeron 100 has also
chloride route and so the spent acid con- been used for concrete reinforcement bars,
support plates and piping in the refurbish- resistance in a wide diversity of environ-
ment of Devonport Dockyard. ments. Some of the wide range of applica-
Zeron 100 piping has also been used for tions have been described above and the
carrying electrical cables in aggressive range is expected to increase over the next
environments such as are found on offshore few years.
platforms.
Zeron 100 has excellent resistance to References
microbial corrosion, particularly SRBs 1 R. Francis and G. Byrne, paper no. 64, CORRO-
(ref. 8), and the alloy is now being consid- SION/94, Baltimore, USA, March 1994, NACE.
2 R. Francis, Keynote Lecture IV, Duplex Stainless
ered for several projects for handling sew- Steels ’94, Glasgow, Scotland, Nov. 1994, Pub-
age and similar waste water in sensitive lished by TWI.
areas where leakage must be avoided. 3 S. Winnik and B.J. Fitzgerald, paper no. 390, COR-
ROSION/94, Baltimore, USA, March 1994, NACE.
4 R. Francis, G. Byrne and K. Jones: ‘Performance at
Reduced Cost: Zeron 100 Superduplex Stainless
4 Future applications Steel Sets the Pace’, presented at IDA World Con-
gress on desalination and water re-use, Madrid,
The applications above cover just a few of Spain, 6–9 October 1997.
the potential uses of Zeron 100. Some other 5 R. Francis, G. Byrne and S. Hebdon, paper 497,
possible uses include vinyl chloride mono- CORROSION/98 San Diego, USA, March 1998,
NACE.
mer plant, teraphthalic acid plant, and the 6 J.T. Dallas and T.A. McConnel: ‘Solids Pumping’,
steel industry. Francis and Bukovinsky London UK Oct 1991. Published by I. Mech. Eng.
(ref. 9) reviewed several of these industries page 9.
and showed where Zeron 100 could be 7 R. Francis, G. Byrne and G. Warburton: ‘The Uses
cost-effective. It is expected that the com- of Superduplex Stainless Steel in the Nickel Mining
Industry’, CIM conference, Sudbury, Canada;
bination of high strength and good corro- August 1997.
sion resistance will increase the 8 R. Francis, G. Byrne and H.S. Campbell, paper 313,
applications of superduplex stainless steel. CORROSION/99, San Antonio, USA; April 1999;
NACE.
9 R. Francis and S. Bukovinsky: ‘The Chemical
Resistance of Zeron 100’, Duplex Stainless Steel
5 Conclusions ’94, Glasgow, Scotland, Nov. 1994, Published by
TWI.
Zeron 100 is a superduplex stainless steel
with high strength and good corrosion