Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Room of One's Own
A Room of One's Own
Own
Study Guide by Course Hero
AUTHOR
Virginia Woolf
a Main Ideas
YEAR PUBLISHED
1929
GENRE
Fire of Genius
Argument
Genius is a fire that wants to grow but needs fuel. In Chapter 4,
AT A GLANCE Woolf says "great artists" confirm a truth that Nature allows
In 1928 established English author Virginia Woolf was invited to each person to know intuitively—the artist's craft allows the
lecture on the topic of Women and Fiction at Newnham "the fire of genius to become visible." Genius, with all of its fire-
College and Girton College, two women's colleges of England's like qualities—illumination, burning, consuming—is one of the
A Room of One's Own Study Guide In Context 2
most important ideas in the essay. The genius of Shakespeare to writing. Having money allows a woman freedom to give voice
and Jane Austen "consumed all impediments." Genius occurs to her genius.
in some people—both men and women—but it needs a certain
environment and situation to become fully expressed. It needs At the end of the essay, Woolf encourages her audience to
food, literally—good food, not prunes. It needs space—a room strive for a room of their own and financial independence. This
in which to work uninterrupted. As a result, the history of step will act as a building block for future generations of
literature is dominated by men not because they had more women writers who will have more access to money and
genius, but because they had the right environment for the fire private spaces as they build on this legacy.
The patriarchal system is harmful to both women and men. truth is emphasized. Woolf is not just trying to argue a point.
Clearly, women are damaged by a system that is restrictive She is trying to show her ideas contain truth. This is essential
and gives them little power over their own lives. But the to her call to action at the end of the essay where she urges
destructiveness of the patriarchal system goes beyond the the audience to help build a foundation for future women
damage done to women. It creates a power imbalance that writers. A search for truth is very compelling.
d In Context
Money Means Freedom
The necessity of money—enough to live comfortably and World War I and Its Effect on
independently—is at the center of Woolf's essay. In addition to
the titular "room of one's own," women writers need a steady Gender Roles
income in order for their ability to flourish. Mary Beton, the
fictional narrator of much of the essay, enjoys a comfortable World War I (1914–18) was unlike any conflict that came before
income thanks to an inheritance. Before she received the it, as the effort required a huge number of capable men and
inheritance, she had a number of uninspiring jobs to make a women. While women's domestic roles were still valued, there
living. But each time she spends her money, she feels a little of were other opportunities for women—including women of the
the despair and shame of poverty fall away. This small life middle class—to enter what had been traditionally considered
lesson serves as a microcosm of the state of women. Poverty male occupations, at least for a time. Women took over jobs
is a hindrance to independence, and independence is essential that had belonged to men when those men left to serve in the
military. Overall, about one million more women were part of World War I put the women's suffrage movement on hold, as it
the workforce in 1918 than in 1914. Most worked in factories or took a back seat to more pressing worldwide concerns. And
labored in fields, but a few became dentists or architects. In the desire for things to return to their pre-war state was a
addition, some women served in the military as nurses and powerful force that pushed many women back into domestic
pilots. roles following the war. But the seed had been planted, and in
1918 women over the age of 30 who were also property
When the war ended some women were eager to return to owners were granted the right to vote. A movement to grant
their domestic roles. However, others found they relished the younger women the vote followed, especially since these
challenges and opportunities of work outside the home, and younger women had done a great deal of the work in the war.
they resisted a return to so-called "normalcy." At the same time Women over 21 were given the vote in 1928, just one year
some men who had been in combat took masculine pride in before A Room of One's Own was published. Woolf's essay
their military roles, but many others were traumatized by their came on the heels of adding 15 million women to British voting
experiences. Some of these men developed anti-war rolls, a time when women may have been looking to the future,
tendencies that were traditionally associated with women, wondering what's next?
such as a value for nurturing and caring for life. In addition, the
traditional household structure—which included a great
number of domestic servants—was evolving. There were fewer
jobs in domestic service, and women had to look elsewhere for
Modernism in Literature
work. The years after the war created an inevitable tension
Beginning in the late-19th and early-20th centuries, writers
between social progress and nostalgic traditionalism. Woolf's
began to focus on the unique inner lives of their characters.
views in A Room of One's Own occur in the roughly 20-year
The seeds of modernism grew quickly during World War I as
period between World War I and World War II (1939–45), in the
writers searched for new styles of writing to better express the
midst of this post-war tension. In Chapter 1 the narrator
new world that was beginning to emerge. Along with Irish
considers how men and women's expectations of the world
writers Samuel Beckett and James Joyce and British writer
have changed, thus fundamentally altering gender interactions.
T.S. Eliot, Virginia Woolf wanted to explore this new way of
writing and thinking about the world.
were mostly middle-class women, took a more genteel these modernist characteristics. Woolf asks the audience to
approach, preferring to use petitions and lobbying members of follow along as she creates a fictional narrator and a fictional
Parliament. Suffragettes, on the other hand, were more setting. The inner experience of having a moment of realization
disruptive. These mostly working-class women were willing to is connected to the external experience of seeing a pause in
break laws and go on hunger strikes. At first women were London's traffic and a leaf falling, for example. The idea of the
given the right to vote in some local elections, and in 1867 merging of two genders in one brain is connected to the
Parliament voted on an amendment that would give women external observation of a man and woman getting into a taxi.
Echoes of Orlando can easily be seen in A Room of One's Own. Leonard Woolf, whom she married in 1912. They formed the
In the essay Woolf argues the solution to the problem of core of the Bloomsbury Group, a circle of writers, artists, and
women's poverty is money and a room of one's own to write in. thinkers, which also included British novelist E.M. Forster,
But this solution is only practical because what is really needed British economist John Maynard Keynes, British painter
is for women to write without being constrained by their Duncan Grant, and Woolf's sister, Vanessa Bell. The group met
gender. Woolf's ideal is a mind in which both male and female periodically from 1907 to 1930. In 1911 Woolf, unmarried, lived in
elements coexist and work together. Thus, the character a house with other Bloomsbury Group males, a choice that
Orlando is the physical embodiment of this merging of male upset her family.
and female.
Woolf used both experimental and traditional styles in her
novels, beginning with The Voyage Out in 1915. Her varied
techniques led readers to call her "the multiple Mrs. Woolf."
a Author Biography Mrs. Dalloway, Jacob's Room, and To the Lighthouse are
Woolf's three major modernist novels (works that deviate from
classical or traditional forms) of the 1920s. She developed a
Early Life new aesthetic in these books, part of her goal to reform the
traditional novel. A committed feminist, Woolf wanted to put
the interior lives of women on the page. In 1928, as a result of
Virginia Woolf, born Adeline Virginia Stephen in London,
her success as a writer, she was invited to lecture on the topic
England on January 25, 1882, grew up surrounded by books.
of Women and Fiction at Newnham College and Girton
Her father was Leslie Stephen—historian, author, critic, and
College, women's colleges of Cambridge University. The
founding editor of the Dictionary of National Biography. Her
lectures she delivered on this topic were reworked into the
mother was Julia Prinsep Duckworth, model for Pre-Raphaelite
extended essay, A Room of One's Own, published in book form
painter Edward Burne-Jones and niece of the photographer
in 1929.
Julia Margaret Cameron. Her wealthy London family raised
their eight children in the late-Victorian era, and young Woolf Woolf had intimate relationships with women throughout her
educated herself through her father's library and private tutors life, most significantly with poet and novelist Vita Sackville-
while her brothers attended prestigious schools. The bustling West, whom Woolf met in 1922. Sackville-West was a
city and the tranquil seaside town of St. Ives, Cornwall, where glamorous outsider, similar to Sally Seton in Mrs. Dalloway.
the family vacationed, influenced the settings of most of Although the women shared a deep emotional bond, neither
Woolf's novels. openly identified as lesbian. Woolf stayed married to Leonard
Woolf until her death in 1941.
Woolf's mother died unexpectedly when the author was 13.
Grief caused Woolf to have her first mental breakdown. Nine
years later she suffered another breakdown after her father's
Leonard Woolf disregarded his wife's instructions to "destroy time. The essay traces Judith's life and how it diverged from
all my papers," and instead preserved Woolf's diaries, letters, her brother's. Both are gifted writers, but when Judith goes to
and unfinished novel, Between the Acts. British poet T.S. Eliot London to pursue her passion for theater, she is laughed at
wrote in Woolf's obituary, "With the death of Virginia Woolf, a and taken advantage of. Finally, pregnant and despairing, she
whole pattern of culture is broken." kills herself. This elaborate scenario helps to prove the point
that women cannot become great writers when faced with
these kinds of challenges. Men, on the other hand, have been
h Key Figures
able to allow their gifts to thrive. In order for the inherent
genius of women to become manifest in great works of
literature, they will need the financial independence and
privacy men enjoy.
Mary Beton
Mary Beton is one of the names Virginia Woolf suggests the Mary Seton
audience call her narrator, and it is the one that sticks.
Although Mary Beton has to be fictionalized because she visits Virginia Woolf suggests three names for her fictional
fictional places and interacts with fictional people as part of narrator—Mary Beton, Mary Seton, and Mary Carmichael—but
the essay, she basically speaks for Virginia Woolf and can be ends up settling on Mary Beton. Mary Seton, then, becomes
viewed as the author's alter ego. Mary Beton is also the name the name of the narrator's friend at Fernham. The two discuss
of the narrator's aunt, who died and left her an inheritance. The the poverty of women, consider the difficulty in raising money
liberating experience of having this inheritance is one of the to attend a women's college, and rail against their female
reasons she concludes a woman writer must have money and ancestors for failing to leave them money.
a room of her own.
Mary Carmichael
Virginia Woolf suggests three names for her fictional
narrator—Mary Beton, Mary Seton, and Mary Carmichael—but
ends up settling on Mary Beton. Mary Carmichael becomes the
name of the fictional female author of a mediocre novel, Life's
Adventure, that Mary Beton reads and analyzes. Mary
Carmichael stands in for female writers of Woolf's time, who
might not be great writers yet, but who are able to tell the
stories of women better than men. Mary Beton decides Mary
Carmichael's novel is not a work of genius, but it is a sign of
progress, and in time, with a room of her own and a little
money, she may write an even better book. Since Carmichael
Full Key Figure List Currer Bell was the pen name of
Charlotte Brontë, who—along with her
Currer Bell
sisters—took a pen name ending in
"Bell."
Key Figure Description
Victorian poet and playwright Robert Cleopatra (c. 69–30 BCE) was the
Robert
Browning (1812–89) was married to ruler of Egypt at the time of Julius
Browning
poet Elizabeth Barrett Browning. Caesar, and her relationship with
Cleopatra
Marc Antony is the subject of
Shakespeare's play Antony and
French essayist Jean de La Bruyère Cleopatra.
Jean de La
(1645–96) was well known for his
Bruyère
essay "Caractères."
Anne Jemima Clough (1820–92) was
Anne Jemima
a leader in the movement for women's
Member of Parliament Samuel Clough
Sir Egerton suffrage and education.
Egerton Brydges (1762–1837) was
Brydges
also a genealogist and writer.
English Romantic poet and literary
Samuel Taylor critic Samuel Taylor Coleridge
Englishwoman Frances (Fanny) Coleridge (1772–1834) wrote The Rime of the
Burney (1752–1840), also known as Ancient Mariner and Kubla Khan.
Frances Burney
Madame d'Arblay, was an early
female novelist.
Emily Davies (1830–1921) was a
founder of Girton College, Cambridge,
Scottish poet Robert Burns (1759–96) Emily Davies
one of the women's colleges at which
often wrote his poems in the Scots Woolf was first invited to lecture.
Robert Burns
language, and is known for the poem
"My Love is Like a Red Red Rose."
Victorian-era writer Charles Dickens
(1812–70) wrote many novels and
English novelist, essayist, and critic Charles
stories including Oliver Twist, David
Samuel Butler Samuel Butler (1835–1902) wrote The Dickens
Copperfield, A Christmas Carol, and
Way of All Flesh. Great Expectations.
A statue of Prince George, Duke of English poet and priest John Donne
Duke of
Cambridge (1819–1904), riding his (1572–1631) lived during the time of
Cambridge John Donne
horse sits at Whitehall, London. Shakespeare and was known for his
religious poetry.
Scottish writer Thomas Carlyle
Thomas Carlyle (1795–1881) wrote The French Lady Dudley, named Georgina
Revolution: A History. Lady Dudley Elizabeth Ward (1846–1929), was a
countess known for her beauty.
English poet and scholar Eliza
(Elizabeth) Carter (1717–1806) was Lord Dudley, named William Ward
Eliza Carter Lord Dudley
versed in classic literature and (1817–85), was the Earl of Dudley.
linguistics.
English philosopher and economist Roman poet Ovid (43 BCE–17 CE)
John Stuart Mill (1806–73) co-wrote Ovid wrote Metamorphoses and Ars
John Stuart Mill amatoria.
the essay The Subjection of Women
with his wife Harriet.
American writer Edgar Allan Poe
English poet John Milton (1608–74) is Edgar Allan Poe (1809–49) wrote fiction and poems
John Milton best known for his epic poem filled with suspense and horror.
"Paradise Lost."
Alexander Pope (1688–1744) was a
English novelist Mary Russell Mitford Alexander Pope poet and satirist famous for The Rape
Mary Russell of the Lock.
(1787–1855) wrote a five-volume work
Mitford
of fiction entitled Our Village.
Writer and literary critic Sir Arthur
English poet and artist William Morris Sir Arthur Thomas Quiller-Couch (1863–1944)
William Morris (1834–96) helped establish the Arts Thomas Quiller- edited the Oxford Book of English
and Crafts movement. Couch Verse and wrote The Art of Writing,
quoted in Woolf's essay.
across the grass. A man gestures to her she should stay on the
Florence Nightingale's sister Frances
Frances path—not walk on the grass. She visits the library, but a
Parthenope Verney (1819–90) wrote
Parthenope
Memoirs of the Verney Family during gentleman at the door tells her women are not allowed unless
Verney
the 17th century. accompanied by a Fellow or in possession of a letter of
introduction. She goes to an elaborate luncheon and enjoys
Roman poet Virgil (70 BCE–19 CE) wonderful food and drink. Dinner is at Fernham, a women's
Virgil
wrote the epic poem Aeneid.
college, and it is terribly plain in comparison. This contrast
leads to thoughts about the wealth of men and the poverty of
English playwright John Webster
women.
John Webster (c.1580–c.1632) lived during the time
of Shakespeare.
k Plot Summary
Chapter 3
Chapter 1 Mary investigates the question of why women in Elizabethan
times—the time of Shakespeare in the 16th century—wrote
Virginia Woolf has been asked to give a lecture on women and nothing. She concludes Elizabethan women had no money of
fiction and begins by discussing her thought process about their own, were forced into marriages, and did not have the
how to approach the topic. After some thought, she concludes, training or experience needed to become a writer. She invents
"A woman must have money and a room of her own if she is to a fictional sister for Shakespeare, a woman named Judith with
write fiction." She invents a fictional persona, "Mary Beton," the same gift and drive as her brother. While William went off
who will narrate a series of events and the thoughts they to school, married, had a child, and went off to London to seek
inspire, so the audience can follow the train of thought that led his fortune, Judith stayed home, was betrothed, and ran away
to her conclusion. to London to avoid the marriage. In London, her interest in
theater was thwarted, and she was taken advantage of. Unable
Mary sits on the bank of a river in Oxbridge (an imaginary
to express her gifts, she killed herself. Therefore, it would have
men's university akin to Cambridge or Oxford) thinking about
been impossible for a woman in Shakespeare's time to write
"women and fiction." After a while, she rises and begins to walk
plays. Gifted women would have become outcasts, suicides, or masculinity because women are demanding their rights and
prostitutes, as there was no way for them to obtain the things want to live more equitably with men. This has made women's
they needed to become a writer. The work of Shakespeare writing poorer because they are in opposition to the womanly
shows evidence of "a mind ... incandescent, unimpeded," but a part of their own minds. She concludes, "It is fatal for anyone
woman at the time would never have lived in circumstances who writes to think of their sex."
that allowed the development of this kind of mind.
Setting the persona Mary Beton aside, Woolf reasserts a
woman must have "five hundred a year and a room ... if [she is]
Chapter 5
Mary moves on to the writing of her own time. She invents an
imaginary author, "Mary Carmichael," and gives commentary on
Carmichael's book Life's Adventure. She notices the sentences
do not flow well, her scenes do not proceed in order, and
overall the book is not sublime. But the book has potential, and
given enough money and a room of her own to write in,
Carmichael might become a great writer, or at least a better
writer.
Chapter 6
Mary wakes up the next day, and as she watches the people in
the street, she observes two people, a man and a woman, get
into the same taxi. This becomes an image of what she thinks
needs to happen in the mind in order to produce great writing.
The male nature and the female nature—both present in the
mind—must coexist peaceably together. As British poet
Samuel Taylor Coleridge asserted, a great mind is
androgynous. However, men have doubled down on their
Chapter 1 of kings and queens, and how it endures based on the wealth
of businessmen and merchants.
Beton's thoughts are interrupted by the arrival of the confidence in superiority has been useful: "Without that power
restaurant bill, which she pays, using money inherited from her probably the earth would still be swamp and jungle."
aunt. She had been informed of her aunt's passing around the
same time women were given the right to vote. The money However, despite its usefulness, the confidence men have in
came as a great relief because the odd jobs she had prior were their superiority is ultimately destructive. A strongly patriarchal
difficult and did not pay well. When she spends money now, system is inherently self-defeating because it places both the
she is reminded of the fear and bitterness she felt during that powerful and the powerless at its mercy. The men had power
time in her life and how having money has caused those and wealth but "at the cost of harboring in their breasts an
feelings to ebb. eagle ... forever tearing the liver out." Now the truth of this
flawed system is becoming more evident, as the hidden "eagle"
Returning to her home, Beton sees people going about their is becoming more visible.
jobs and tasks, and she thinks about how, in the future, women
will cease altogether to be "the protected sex." The search for truth—the stated purpose of Beton's fictional
foray to the library—is ultimately not found in any of the books.
It is arrived at through intuition, from the surfacing of some
Analysis subconscious knowledge. In Chapter 1 Woolf explained that
fiction often reveals greater truths than reality. Here, she ends
This chapter proceeds as Mary Beton—Woolf's alter ego and up finding the "essential oil of truth" not in books but in her own
narrator of the fictional narrative embedded in this subconscious mind. She draws an angry Professor von X and
essay—goes to the library to find answers to her questions. senses in her drawing both his anger and her own. Thus
Unlike the Oxbridge library, which she was not allowed in, she art—fiction or drawing—reveals more truth than history. An
is welcome in the British Museum and its library. In Chapter 1 image might contain a fact dozens of nonfiction books cannot
Mary used her own observations and perspective to begin hold. This is a very important idea that surfaces again in the
asking questions. She noticed a contrast between men and final chapter, as an image sparks the narrator's moment of
women and wanted to find out more, so she consults books to insight into the solution to her problem. "Yet it is in our idleness,
gather knowledge. She wants to "strain off what was personal in our dreams," she says, "that the submerged truth sometimes
and accidental ... and so reach ... the essential oil of truth." comes to the top."
While this is a worthy goal, objective truth is not what she finds
Imagery is very important to understanding the ideas in Woolf's
in the books.
essay, including the image of London as a large, impersonal
Disappointingly, the books do not contain a great deal of machine made up of individual parts. "London was like a
objective truth. Rather, Beton finds they are filled with anger, machine," she notes, "We were all being shot backwards and
which in turn causes her to become angry. To explore this forwards on this ... foundation to make some pattern." This idea
"fact" of anger, she invents a fictional male author, Professor of a pattern hidden in the seemingly unrelated movements of
von X, who has written a book about why women are inferior to people suggests her search for truth means finding an
men in every way. She considers the way men and women underlying pattern to human behavior. It also foreshadows the
related to each other before the women's right's movement moment of insight she gains in Chapter 6.
and how they relate now. She concludes that men are angry
because their superiority is being questioned and challenged.
This superiority is something they had taken for granted and, in Chapter 3
fact, had been very useful to them, as it bolstered their
confidence and allowed them to take risks they might not have
taken otherwise. Despite the fact she claims to be angry, Summary
Beton's tone as she analyzes this situation is objective and
reasonable. She admits, "Life for both sexes ... is arduous, Beton still hasn't solved the puzzle of the effect of poverty on
difficult ... It calls for gigantic courage and strength," and men fiction, nor does she completely understand why women are so
had been used to finding this courage in their feelings of poor relative to men. She wishes for some "authentic fact." She
superiority over half of the population. She further admits this decides to approach it from another angle: Why, in the time of
something great. The answer is painfully obvious, and her angry about their limited situation. These things held them
sarcastic tone emphasizes this. back.
Chapter 4 Analysis
As Beton peruses the books on the shelves of the library, she
traces women's writing from where the essay left off in
Summary Chapter 3—the time of Shakespeare—to the 19th century. Little
time is spent on the quality of the writing, although Beton does
Of course, the idea that any woman would be able to have "a
offer some criticisms of its value, such as, "Clearly her mind
mind ... incandescent, unimpeded" in the 16th century is
has by no means 'consumed all impediments and become
ludicrous. Perhaps a rich lady, with free time, might have
incandescent.'" Rather, "it is harassed and distracted with
written something, but even her writing would likely be
hates and grievances." For the most part, she focuses on the
disturbed. A woman writer would likely have viewed men as an
circumstances in which these women were writing. She
enemy because they can block her from writing. She would
describes the small rooms they wrote in, harried by one
have to content herself with sharing her writing with friends.
interruption after another. She describes the way they are
Women writers from the time were not educated to make use
made fun of and spoken to by men. She describes how, even
of their genius, and so it poured out in chaotic ways as the
by the time of Jane Austen and George Eliot, women writers
writers spiraled into insanity. Some kernels of their ability can
were not taken seriously and often hid their work. Jane Austen
be seen in their letters, but this is not the same as writing
would cover up her writing whenever anyone came in the room.
fiction.
George Eliot hid behind a male pen name in order to publish
Mrs. Aphra Behn, a 17th century "middle-class woman with all without ridicule.
the plebeian virtues of humor, vitality and courage," was a
In addition, women writers were not able to experience life in
writer who proved a woman could make money writing. And
the varied way that produces material usually needed for
this was significant because it opened a door for women in the
writing a great work. Beton uses the example of Russian writer
18th century who might not have been financially independent,
Leo Tolstoy to show how the physical freedom of men gave
but who could use the extra money. And because money
them more options for writing. In particular, men were allowed
"dignifies what is frivolous if unpaid for," women's writing
to have sexual relationships and were not ostracized. In
gained a little legitimacy.
contrast, women who had sex outside of marriage were
By the beginning of the 19th century, there were far more shunned and were even more limited in their interactions with
books written by women. Unlike previous generations of the world. Tolstoy, however, could live "freely with this gypsy or
writers, who were mostly poets, these women wrote novels. with that great lady" and have all sorts of other experiences
Perhaps novel writing is an easier form of writing to do amidst that could be used in novels. Thus, the double standard
interruptions and a lack of privacy. Or it could be their regarding sexual activity also served to give male writers an
experiences, among people in the sitting rooms of their homes, advantage.
led them to novel writing: "The literary training ... a woman had
Beton links women's writing to their circumstances in very
in the ... nineteenth century was ... in the observation of
small, concrete ways. For example, she theorizes women were
character." Jane Austen, one of these novelists, even managed
able to write novels because they could be written in short
to write a really good novel. The narrator cannot "find any signs
spans of time between interruptions. In addition, their role in
that her circumstances had harmed her work in the slightest."
society—which required them to notice and interpret unspoken
Austen's "gift and her circumstances matched each other
social cues—honed in them skills of observation. They were
completely." Other women of the time were not so fortunate,
able to describe subtle interactions between people in ways
and their novels show signs of discontent or of promise and
that felt realistic. The trouble with this kind of women's writing
genius that could have been even greater. They tried to write
is that very few women were completely satisfied and suited to
like men, were ostracized because of sexual practices, or were
the role society demanded. She uses the example of Jane
Austen—who was able to write without thinking of her gender of previous women authors. She writes "as a woman who has
simply because she was by nature perfectly matched to her forgotten that she is a woman." In time, with "a room of her
situation—to show that this was an exception, not the rule. Of own and five hundred a year," Carmichael may write an even
all the women novelists writing in this era, only one escaped better book.
the limitations of gender. This is a step above the previous
generation, but a very small one.
Analysis
Overall, the progression of women's literature is one of forward
motion, even if it is at a snail's pace. This is presented as both In this section, Beton invents another Mary—Mary Carmichael,
an encouraging and a discouraging thought. At the end of this author of the mediocre Life's Adventure. Carmichael and her
chapter, Beton has arrived at the early 20th century—her own book provide a lens through which Beton can assess the
time. current state of women's writing. She evaluates Carmichael's
writing's merits—sentence structure, plot, coherence—in light
of her predecessors, such as Jane Austen. She finds things to
Chapter 5 criticize and finds the prose lacking overall. Yet she finds
things to praise. For example, Carmichael's writing is mostly
free of the consciousness of gender previously found in
Summary women's writing. It also describes relationships—between
friends or work colleagues—not found in other novels, either
Beton now speaks about writing in her own century. She notes those written by men or those by women. These observations
that women now write more than just novels and that women can be interpreted as Woolf's assessment of the state of
do almost as much writing as men. She invents an imaginary women's literature at the time. It is in transition, just as
author, "Mary Carmichael," and analyzes her book Life's women's roles in society are in transition.
Adventure. She observes the sentences do not flow well, her
Carmichael's life and potential also contain a hopeful message
scenes do not proceed in order—the author has broken the
for women writers. Although her work is not wonderful, it has
sentence and the sequence. However, Carmichael has every
potential. Carmichael, given the opportunity to write another
right to do this if she "does them not for the sake of breaking,
book, might greatly improve. Again, Carmichael represents all
but for the sake of creating." So she reads on. She comes to
of women's literature. Just as she might improve if she has 500
the sentence, "Chloe liked Olivia," and realizes women usually
a year and a room to write in, so will women's literature
do not like each other in literature. They are jealous of each
become better over time, as long as women writers have
other or are shown in love triangles with men—and always in
financial resources and a space to call their own.
relation to men. But in Carmichael's novel, two women are
friends and colleagues and share a laboratory in which they Notably, this chapter focuses on—and praises—the differences
work together on medical research. between men and women. Women can see things men cannot
see, and vice versa. Women and men can develop relationships
Many great male writers had "some need of and dependence
in which they draw some creative spark form each other. In
upon certain persons of the opposite sex." These men surely
fact, she suggests more genders would be even better: "If an
got more from women than just sex. Men and women both
explorer should ... bring word of other sexes ... nothing would
have creative power, but women's creative power "differs
be of greater service to humanity." Yet at the same time, these
greatly from the creative power of men." Women writers, like
differences should not cause men and women to see each
Carmichael, are better suited to tell the stories of women than
other as the "opposing faction." It is not differences between
are men, but they can also help to present a more complete
men and women that are problematic, but their antagonism.
picture of men by writing about men from a woman's
This recalls the idea in Chapter 2 that men's writing about
perspective.
women is full of anger because they are used to being in
Mary Carmichael's novel, the narrator concludes, is not a work power and having women support them, and they do not like to
of genius. But she does not view men as an "opposing faction" see this power challenged. Anger between men and women is
as writers before her had done. She only has a tinge of the fear fostered by a power imbalance, and this, ultimately, is bad for
everyone. time."
Chapter 6 have money and a room of their own. In a few generations, she
says, the "dead poet who was Shakespeare's sister will put on
the body ... she ... so often laid down," and will draw life from all
the women writers who came before her.
Summary
Beton wakes up the next day—the day after reading all those
Analysis
books, October 26, 1928—and notices London doesn't seem to
care much about women and fiction, or even about This chapter opens with a chaotic scene of a busy London
Shakespeare's plays, for that matter. Suddenly, as she street. The people are going about their business unaware of
watches the people in the street, there seems to a pause anything beyond their own lives. There are "no two people ...
during which a leaf falls and the river flows as if carrying alike; each seems bound on some private affair of his own." Yet
people along in its current. In this pause, she notices two as Beton watches, she has a moment of insight. This moment
people, a man and a woman, get into the same taxi. This is described almost as a moment out of time, or in slow motion:
coming together seems very different from the way she has "A ... suspension of traffic ... A single leaf detached itself ... and
been thinking—about the genders being separate, and about in that pause ... fell." In this paused moment, she senses an
her mind as separate from the rest of existence. This leads her invisible river bringing three things together from different
to conclude the genders were meant to work together, and, directions: a man, a woman, and a taxi. This image of a man
furthermore, each person has both a man's nature and a and a woman getting into a taxi takes on significance beyond
woman's nature: "In each of us two powers preside, one male, the concrete or literal. Beton's mind connects and resonates
one female." She contemplates English poet Samuel Taylor with this image, seeing in it an insight that might provide
Coleridge's assertion that the great mind is androgynous. answers to some of her questions. "The sight was ordinary
enough," she notes, "what was strange was the rhythmical
Beton opens a book by a male author, and she is at first
order with which my imagination had invested it."
comforted and at home in the directness of its sentences and
the confidence of its tone. But she quickly tires of it. She thinks This image of disengaged and separate people coming
male authors, now so very aware of and defensive of their together in some kind of union becomes a metaphor for the
maleness due to the women's movement, are beginning to unity of the mind. Beton realizes that she has been thinking
have less androgynous brains. "Men ... are now writing only more of the separations between things—between men and
with the male side of their brains," and their writing is poorer women, between herself and others—and this is part of the
for it. problem. The male and female parts of each person must be
unified in order for genius to be expressed without impediment.
To wrap up her thoughts, Beton concludes, "It is fatal for
To further elaborate on this idea, she describes reading a book
anyone who writes to think of their sex." At this point, Beton's
by a male author. She detects in his writing a consciousness of
part in the essay concludes, and Woolf explains that Beton has
gender she feels is detrimental to the truth of his work. This
shown her thoughts as to why a woman must "have five
supports the main idea of the destructive patriarchy. It shows
hundred a year and a room ... to write fiction or poetry." Woolf
how the imbalance of power erodes the work of not just those
rejects any thoughts about weighing men's writing against that
who have less power and so struggle against their limitations
of women or judging between the two. She defends her
(women), but also erodes of those who have more power and
insistence on a woman's need for material things, saying, "five
so must defend it against usurpers (men).
hundred a year stands for the power to contemplate," and "a
lock on the door means the power to think for oneself." She To conclude the essay, Woolf sheds her Mary Beton persona
goes on to reiterate the hardship women have had to endure and directly addresses her audience—presumably women
for centuries: "Intellectual freedom depends upon material writers. She encourages them to work incrementally for the
things ... women have ... been poor ... from the beginning of future of women in general, and specifically for women writers.
This recalls the imagery of Chapter 1, as she imagines the including those ideas and biases related to one's gender.
building of the great chapel and other university buildings and
the great wealth of generations that went into the building. It is
true—and her essay provides ample evidence—women are at a "The most transient visitor ... could
disadvantage because of generations of poverty and limited
existence. Yet progress has been made, and it takes time to ... be aware ... England is under the
build something great and lavish. Woolf exhorts the women
rule of a patriarchy."
writers of her time to obtain money and a room of their
own—and to write. They might not be the Judith Shakespeare
— Mary Beton, Chapter 2
who can write unhindered, but they can prepare the way for
her. "Without that effort on our part," she tells them, "without
that determination that ... she shall find it possible to live and Mary Beton reads a newspaper as she has lunch and reflects
write her poetry," such a Judith Shakespeare will never come on how truthfully it portrays England. It is absolutely clear just
to be. from a glance that men in England hold all the power and have
all the money. This realization is an essential ingredient of her
conclusion in Chapter 2 that men are angry because their self-
The search for truth is one of the driving forces of Woolf's "Imaginatively she is of the highest
essay. She wants her audience to search for the truth in her
words, and her fictional narrator, Mary Beton, is also searching importance; practically she is
for the truth in the words of books in the British Library. This
completely insignificant."
search means setting aside "personal and accidental" ideas,
makes the point that getting money for something legitimizes As she reads Mary Carmichael's book, Mary Beton worries "the
that very thing. Therefore, the more women are paid for their bishops and ... patriarchs" will obstruct Carmichael with their
writing, the more it will be accepted as literature. rules and conventions that keep women from rising. The first
sentence refers to the experiences Mary Beton has in Chapter
1—a man shoos her off the grass and onto the path, and
"Cleopatra's only feeling about another blocks her from entering the library. The second
sentence refers to the idea women are equipped for novel
Octavia is one of jealousy." writing but not other kinds of writing, and that graceful women
are more accepted as writers than less beautiful or wealthy
— Mary Beton, Chapter 5 women.
However, in Mary Carmichael's novel, two women are friends — Mary Beton, Chapter 6
and colleagues. They have a relationship apart from men, one
that is invisible to men. The "marriage of opposites" Mary Beton refers to is the
"marriage" of male and female parts of the brain. If these two
parts do not work together, the brain will be too female or too
"Suppose ... men were only male, both of which diminish the greatness of the writing.
Light A man interrupts Mary Beton's path across the grass. A bell
interrupts her thoughts. A restaurant check brings her
contemplations back to the present. The essay's fictional
narrative is littered with distractions and interruptions. These
Light symbolizes the genius needed to illuminate truth. Woolf constant interruptions mimic the distractions and interruptions
refers to "that hard little electric light which we call brilliance" Woolf imagines must have been the reality for writers such as
and notes that the "lamp in the spine does not light on beef and Jane Austen as they sat in their sitting rooms and were called
prunes." Therefore, light is genius, or artistic brilliance. Light upon to make conversation, rather than write uninterrupted in a
also symbolizes the ability to see truth, or to judge between room of their own. Woolf includes these interruptions to
truth and illusion. She refers to the "white light of truth" and symbolize the struggle of women writers, and the need for a
calls the reader to hold "every phrase, every scene to the light" private space in which to write.
because Nature has given the reader "an inner light by which to
judge of the novelist's integrity or disintegrity."
Oxbridge
Ten-Shilling Note
Oxbridge University is the imaginary university that provides a
setting for the Chapter 1 of the essay. Its magnificent buildings
As she pays for her lunch with a ten-shilling note—part of an become a symbol of the legacy men have built over many
income from an inheritance left to her by an aunt—Mary Beton years. The wealth of generations of men built the chapel,
wonders at the power of that note and its siblings, which seem placed in it lovely stained-glass windows, and made sure it was
to magically appear in her purse. They have the power to free filled with singers and scholars. Similarly, the literature written
her form the "rust and corrosion ... fear and bitterness" she had by men was built up over time, from the earliest male writers
built up when she was without money. Thus, the ten-shilling through English poet John Milton, Italian poet Dante Alighieri,
note comes to symbolize financial independence and the way and English playwright William Shakespeare through the
money has the power to lift the burdens women endure present. Male author built upon male author to bring about
because of their poverty. great literature, as stone is set upon stone to build a chapel.
Both kinds of "buildings" require money. In contrast, women do
not have a legacy of literature to draw upon because they
never had any money. Their colleges are plain and small
Prunes and Custard compared to Oxbridge, as is their literature. However, Woolf
makes it clear the building blocks of women's literature are
finally being set in place. She ends on a hopeful note,
After a sumptuous luncheon at Oxbridge—built on a legacy of encouraging women to keep building.
men's accomplishments and wealth—Mary Beton endures a
meager dinner of beef, prunes, and custard at the women's
college where she is staying. The dinner is not inspiring, and
she notes, "One cannot think well, love well, sleep well, if one m Glossary
has not dined well." This dinner symbolizes the poverty of
women compared to men and helps to make the case a androgynous (adj) both male and female
woman needs money in order to use her gifts to create works
of genius. composite (adj) made up of parts
e Suggested Reading
Degen, Michael E. Virginia Woolf's A Room of One's Own: A
Contribution to the Essay Genre. Telemachos, 2014.
All material contained within this document/guide is protected by copyright law of the US and various other
jurisdictions and may not be reproduced or distributed without the express written consent. Contact Course Hero
with respect to reproduction or distribution. This document was downloaded from Coursehero.com on 07-19-2021
by 100000817764887.