Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pygmalion: What's Inside in Context
Pygmalion: What's Inside in Context
e Suggested Reading .............................................................................. 28 Victorian social behavior. Likewise, a sense of order and
stability stemming from British confidence in commonly held
social values, social identity, and meaningful religious faith
characterized English society.
j Book Basics However, sharp divides existed between the upper, middle,
working, and lower classes of society. Women felt these social
AUTHOR barriers more keenly than men. Their social, political, and
George Bernard Shaw economic rights and options were far more limited. As the
Victorian era wore on, artists and writers began to confront
FIRST PERFORMED
these idealized notions of proper behavior and social
1913
stereotypes. They took aim at the conventions of the Victorian
GENRE era; in particular, a woman's perceived place in society. Their
Romance efforts were in line with another challenge to these
conventions: the socialist movement.
ABOUT THE TITLE
The title, Pygmalion, refers to a Greek character in Ovid's poem
Metamorphoses who sculpts a woman so perfect that he falls
in love with her. With the intervention of the goddess Venus,
Pygmalion Study Guide In Context 2
One outspoken advocate of socialism and the new theater of In 1916 Shaw wrote the sequel to the play—a lengthy
Ibsen was George Bernard Shaw. In 1884, he joined the explanation in which he established that Eliza marries Freddy,
recently established Fabian Society. The society was not not Higgins. Nevertheless, to Shaw's frustration, audiences
radical but aimed to peacefully implement social reforms persisted in believing that Eliza marries Higgins.
Shaw was born in Dublin as the third and last child of George Shaw's career as a playwright began in 1891 when he met J.T.
Carr and Lucinda Elizabeth Gurly Shaw. He suffered what he Grein, the director of The Independent Theatre—a new,
described as "a devil of a childhood." His father was a civil progressive venue for "the theatre of ideas" inspired by the
servant turned unsuccessful corn merchant, as well as an realistic "problem plays" of Henrik Ibsen. Grein offered to read
alcoholic—all of which reduced the family to living in genteel Shaw's play, Widowers' House. He accepted it almost
poverty. His mother—the daughter of a well-to-do immediately, and it was first publicly performed in 1892. Over
family—found escape from the family difficulties in music. A the next six years, Shaw completed a collection of dramas
professional singer and student of the conductor George called Plays Pleasant and Unpleasant. Each attacked with
Vandeleur Lee, she eventually followed him to London to varied ferocity the social evils of the day. His writing successes
pursue her own career and improve her situation. These life continued to the eve of World War I, when Pygmalion opened in
events encouraged Shaw to be a life-long teetotaler (person Vienna in 1913 and in London in 1914. It was a hit. However, with
who does not drink alcohol), imbued him with a strong interest the outbreak of war, Shaw's plain-spoken antiwar views and
in music, and kindled his sensitivity to the plight of women in pamphlets created uproar. He was shunned by friends and
Victorian society. ostracized by the public. Nevertheless, he continued writing
plays, and by 1923, with the production of Saint Joan, he
In 1876, Shaw joined his mother and Vandeleur Lee in London. succeeded in reviving his career. In 1925, Shaw was the
He expanded his knowledge of music to include literature. He recipient of the Nobel Prize in Literature.
read voraciously, attended socialist lectures and debates, and
pursued a career in journalism and writing. His first attempts to Pygmalion remains one of Shaw's most famous plays. It was
write prose—a string of five novels—were rejected by adapted to film in 1938, earning Shaw an Academy Award for
publishers. However, he did land a job as a freelance critic for screenwriting. Continuing its rise to fame, a musical
an influential daily paper, the Pall Mall Gazette. The liberal adaptation—My Fair Lady—opened on Broadway in 1956 and
political leanings of the paper were in line with Shaw's growing ran for more than nine years. A film version of the musical hit
interest in socialism. His articles and critiques of art, music, and the movie screen in 1964 and earned eight Academy Awards.
theater written for this and other publications brought him at
Shaw continued writing until his death on November 2, 1950, at
last to the attention of London literary society.
age 94. At the time, he was working on yet another play.
h Characters Pickering
In addition to his expertise in language, Colonel Pickering is the
"author of Spoken Sanscrit" and is a master of Indian dialects.
Higgins He is an "elderly gentleman of the amiable military type," and
throughout the play, he demonstrates a generous and
In addition to being an authority on phonetics, Henry Higgins is courteous nature, particularly noticeable in his treatment of
the author of Higgins's Universal Alphabet. He is described as Eliza—both as a flower girl and a lady. In fact, it is Pickering
"a robust, vital, appetizing sort of man of forty or thereabouts" who kindles Eliza's feeling of self-respect when, on the day she
and is "of the energetic, scientific type, heartily, even violently first comes to Wimpole Street, he calls her "Miss Doolittle."
interested in everything that can be studied as a scientific Thereafter, he shows her in "a hundred little things" that she is
subject." He is also "careless about himself and other people, "something better than a scullerymaid" and to him, she will
including their feelings." This trait becomes most evident in his always be a lady. For his part in the experiment, Pickering pays
treatment of Eliza. Yet his "genial bullying" and "stormy for Eliza's lessons and clothes. He also provides a
petulance" are balanced by a forthright manner and lack of any counterbalance to Higgins's chronic insensitivity. He is
malice, so that "he remains likeable even in his least reasonable sincerely alarmed when Eliza, driven by anger and hurt, leaves
moments." Throughout the play, his complex temperament the professor's home and indicates that she will not be
serves as a catalyst for events, beginning with his ill-mannered returning. His final words to her before accompanying Alfred
eavesdropping on Eliza and boorish comments about her Doolittle to the former dustman's wedding are, "Do stay with
English in Act 1. His continued inability to see and treat Eliza as us, Eliza."
anything more than a lowly flower girl forces her to take a
stand for independence and self-respect. While Higgins
remains fundamentally unchanged by the end of the play, he
gains a new perspective on Eliza and holds her in higher regard
Doolittle
and with more respect.
Alfred Doolittle is described as "an elderly but vigorous
dustman." A happy member of the undeserving poor, he
"seems equally free from fear or conscience" and exhibits skill
Eliza at wheedling money out of others. "He has a remarkably
expressive voice" and, as Higgins discovers, no morals at
Eliza Doolittle, also called Liza, is a girl perhaps 18 or 20 years all—he is willing to turn his daughter over to Higgins, no
old. Her initial appearance as a flower girl is quite unattractive: questions asked, for five pounds. During the course of the play,
dirty, shabbily dressed, and in need of a dentist. Her Cockney Doolittle comes into money and, as a result, is vaulted into
accent and "kerbstone English" place her in London's lower middle-class status. Lacking the courage to reject the money,
class, yet her intelligence and ambition allow her to aspire to he finds himself forced to align with the higher standards of
something finer. The flower girl who presents herself at middle-class morality, which includes marrying his live-in
Higgins's laboratory is a "deplorable figure," making her missus. In misery he laments that "happier men than me will call
transformation to a lady who can pass for a duchess all the for my dust ... and I'll look on helpless, and envy them."
more awesome. Yet, as Eliza points out to Pickering, her fine
speech and manners are acquired skills, nothing more.
Learning them was "just like learning to dance in the
fashionable way." The real transformation comes with being
Mrs. Higgins
treated like a lady and, from there, gaining self-respect. By the
Mrs. Higgins is a gracious member of the upper class. Her
end of the play, Eliza emerges as a poised, independent
affection for Higgins does not shield her from irritation at his
woman who knows her own worth and intends to make her
lack of manners, and she is adept at putting him in his place.
own way in the world.
Intelligent and perceptive, she soon discerns the problems that
her son's experiment will cause for Eliza, and sympathizes with
Freddy
Freddy is a young man of 20, a member of the upper class,
good-natured though somewhat weak, and a true gentleman.
He is infatuated with Eliza, writes to her daily, and is happiest
just spending time on the street where she lives. At the end of
the play, Eliza suggests that she might marry Freddy, though
he has no money to support them both and seems unfit for
work. But he is devoted to her, can offer the kindness that she
needs, and, unlike Higgins, he won't try to make something out
of her.
Mrs. Pearce
Mrs. Pearce has been Higgins's housekeeper for some
time—long enough to know his singular ways and, without fear,
to reproach him when needed for his lack of social graces. She
has a strong sense of propriety, and takes it upon herself to be
sure that Eliza is cared for properly while in the house. A bond
between them grows, and Mrs. Pearce frequently pushes
Higgins to show consideration for Eliza and to think about her
future.
Character Map
Higgins
Mother Housekeeper
Professor of phonetics;
expert in speech and
manners
Friends
Pickering
Doolittle
Teacher Kindly gentleman and
Dustman (garbage man)
language expert
Father Patron
Eliza
Flower girl who wants
to be a lady
Surrogate
mother
Advocate
Mrs. Pearce
Mrs. Higgins Admirer Middle-class expert in
Stately older lady
proper behavior
Freddy
Young gentleman
Main Character
Minor Character
Clara Eynsford Hill, also the daughter The second landing footman is a
The second
in Act 1, is sister to Freddy and one of servant at the embassy. He appears
Clara landing footman
the first to meet the new, more in the 1941 text.
ladylike Eliza.
The taximan drives Eliza home in Act
Mrs. Eynsford Hill, also the mother in 1, and later drives her and Freddy to
The taximan
Mrs. Eynsford Act 1, is the mother of Freddy and Wimbledon Common in Act 4. He
Hill one of the first to meet the new, appears in the 1941 text.
more ladylike Eliza.
pedestrians sprinting for shelter or taxis. Beneath the portico "playing with your live doll" without considering what will
of St. Paul's Church, several people have gathered, including a happen to Eliza when the experiment is over. She points out
young Cockney flower girl, an older gentleman of military that Eliza will have the refinements of a lady, which inevitably
bearing, and a man taking notes on the flower girl's speech. will bar her from earning a living. Untroubled by this prospect
the two depart, and Mrs. Higgins cries out in frustration, "Oh,
The flower girl assumes the note taker is a policeman. men! men!! men!!!"
Terrified, she protests her innocence of any wrongdoing. Soon
it becomes clear that the man is only interested in phonetically Months later, after Eliza has further honed her skills, Higgins
noting her "kerbstone" English—"English that will keep her in and Pickering put Eliza's accomplishments to the test, and she
the gutter to the end of her days." He boasts that he could performs flawlessly. Back at the Wimpole Street laboratory,
teach her to speak like a duchess in three months. It turns out Higgins and Pickering bask in the victory, with no thought of
that he is the famous phonetician Henry Higgins. The elderly Eliza. Higgins declares "Thank God it's over," so now he can go
gentleman is Colonel Pickering, an admirer and fellow speech to bed "without dreading tomorrow." Directing Eliza to turn off
expert. Higgins invites Pickering to come around the next day the lights, Higgins starts upstairs, but then returns to get his
to his home on Wimpole Street. Then, flinging a generous slippers and finds Eliza weeping with rage. She flings the
collection of coins at the flower girl, Higgins departs for supper slippers at him and asserts that they mean more to him than
with the colonel. she does; she has won his bet for him, and now he will toss her
back into the gutter. The stormy scene that ensues ends with
The next morning, the flower girl—Eliza Doolittle—boldly shows Higgins stalking out and slamming the door. In his anger and
up at Higgins's home. She explains that she wants to be a lady hurt, he is oblivious to the fact that Eliza intends to leave.
in a flower shop, and she offers to pay him to teach her to "talk
more genteel." Pickering, who is present, says he will cover all The next morning, Higgins and Pickering visit Mrs. Higgins to
expenses if, in six months, Higgins can pass Eliza off as a lady. tell her that Eliza is missing. Shortly, the parlor maid announces
Intrigued, Higgins accepts the terms of the bet. Mr. Higgins's that a gentleman is waiting to speak to Mr. Higgins. His name is
housekeeper, Mrs. Pearce, urges Higgins to consider the girl's Mr. Doolittle. Higgins learns, to his astonishment, that an
future: "What is to become of her when you've finished your offhand mention of Doolittle in a letter to a rich American has
teaching?" she asks. "You must look ahead a little." made the former dustman very well off. Far from pleased by
this turn of luck, Doolittle accuses Higgins of robbing him of his
While Higgins's housekeeper bathes Eliza and orders new freedom and happiness. Now he is trapped by middle-class
clothes, another visitor arrives: Alfred Doolittle—Eliza's ne'er- morality and on his way to get married, like a respectable
do-well father. A poor dustman (garbage man), he has no citizen.
paternal interest in Eliza beyond handing her over to Higgins
for five pounds. His callousness is slightly diminished by the In this, Mrs. Higgins sees good fortune for Eliza, who now will
fact that he believes Higgins's motives are honorable. Higgins have someone to support her. She reveals that the young lady
gives him "a fiver," and Doolittle departs. is upstairs and defends Eliza's choice to leave him and
Pickering. The two have behaved heartlessly and selfishly
Some months later, Higgins takes Eliza on a surprise visit to his toward her.
mother, an intelligent and dignified lady. While the girl's
pronunciation is quite good, she needs to learn what to say, A calm, composed Eliza comes downstairs and greets the men.
and Higgins hopes his mother can help. Also at the get- She thanks Pickering for treating her with respect from the
together are Mrs. and Miss Eynsford Hill, a mother and very beginning. To Higgins she explains that he will always
daughter encountered earlier in Covent Garden, as well as treat her like a common flower girl, though now she has it in
Pickering and Freddy. Though Eliza now looks and acts the her power to be his equal. No, she will not come back.
part of a fine lady, her vocabulary and unfortunate choice of
topics gives away her humble beginnings. With some difficulty, Higgins is pleased with Eliza's unexpected transformation from
Higgins covers her gaffes, and Freddy is smitten with the lovely whimpering girl to self-assured woman, and tells her so. All the
Eliza. same, as she leaves with Mrs. Higgins to see her father wed,
Higgins cannot resist instructing her to buy some gloves and a
Later, Mrs. Higgins scolds her son and Pickering both for tie for him. Eliza replies, "Buy them yourself," and sweeps out.
Plot Diagram
Climax
11
10
12
9
Falling Action
Rising Action 8
13
7
6 14
5
15
4
Resolution
3
2
1
Introduction
Climax
Rising Action 11. Enraged by Higgins's boorish insensitivity, Eliza runs off.
7. Eliza's first test in public is a marginal success. 14. Higgins accuses her of ingratitude, yet asks her to return.
Resolution
15. Eliza departs, but Higgins is sure she is not gone for good.
Timeline of Events
(Clara) represent the genteel poor—those born into wealth but Eliza takes a taxi to her lodgings. Shaw describes the damp,
who have fallen on hard times. The bystanders represent dreary room decorated with pictures torn from newspapers—a
classes in between—those who work in service or at a trade hint that Eliza dreams of something better for herself. When
and those who have the potential for upward mobility. the light of the gas lamp goes out, she is torn between
spending another penny for light or going to bed. At the time
The origins of all the characters can all be identified by their that Shaw wrote Pygmalion, people paid for the gas supply for
patterns of speech. For example, Eliza's Cockney accent a room or house as needed by depositing a coin in a meter.
places her home in Lisson Grove, a former slum area in central Eliza's "gnawing sense of the need for economy" wins and she
London—not "fit for a pig to live in," according to crawls into bed, sleeping in her clothes to keep away the cold.
Eliza—urbanized during the mid-19th century and remaining In this scene, Shaw shows the deprivation that Eliza endures
poor into the 20th century. Higgins identifies the bystander as and will attempt to escape.
coming from the seaside village of Selsey, and the sarcastic
bystander's speech patterns place him in the trade and
manufacturing center of Hoxton. Shaw uses the characters,
especially Eliza, to establish the main premise of the play: the
Act 2
role of language in determining a person's place in society.
Shaw asks, can an expert in speech teach a common girl
speaking "kerbstone English" to pass as a member of the elite
Summary
class?
The morning after the gathering under the portico of St. Paul's
Higgins specializes in helping people hide their places of origin Church, Pickering visits Higgins at his home and laboratory on
by teaching them to speak properly. As he says, it "is an age of Wimpole Street. As the professor winds up an exhaustive
upstarts," and society is changing. Industrialization and demonstration of the various devices he uses to study speech,
capitalism have created the possibility of upward mobility. Yet, his housekeeper, Mrs. Pearce, announces the arrival of a
Victorian class standards still prevail, and speaking properly is young woman. She is "quite a common girl," has a dreadful
key. As Higgins says, men who begin in Kentish Town—a accent, and insists on seeing Higgins. Thinking this may offer
working-class district of London—and end in upper-crust Park an opportunity for further demonstrations, Higgins tells Mrs.
Lane "want to drop Kentish Town; but they give themselves Pearce to send the young woman in.
away every time they open their mouths." Just as he claims to
Immediately he recognizes the flower girl from the night before
help them, he says that he could pass Eliza off as a duchess at
and, having no further use for her, tells her to go away. But the
an ambassador's garden party if given just three months with
flower girl, whose name is Eliza, stops him with the revelation
her. This plants the seed in Eliza's mind that leads her to
that she has come for speech lessons, "and to pay for em, too."
Higgins's home in Act 2; it also foreshadows her later triumph
Eliza aspires to become a lady in a flower shop "stead of
at the ambassador's party.
selling at the corner of Tottenham Court Road. But they won't
Clothing is also an important feature in this act and throughout take me unless I can talk more genteel." She reminds Higgins
the play. Eliza's dirty, shabby clothes, worn boots, and soot- of his claim that he could teach her, and offers him a shilling an
blackened hat are clear indications of her impoverished state. hour to do so—quite a substantial sum for a person with her
In contrast, the fine evening clothes of Pickering, Freddy, the income. The challenge intrigues Higgins. Pickering says he'll
mother, and Clara place them in the upper classes. When pay for the lessons if Higgins succeeds, and count him the
Higgins is first mistaken for a policeman or informer, the greatest teacher alive. Higgins accepts the wager, vowing to
bystander points out, "It's all right: he's a gentleman: look at his "make a duchess of this draggletailed guttersnipe" in six
boots." As the play progresses, Eliza's clothing will reflect months. Then he instructs Mrs. Pearce to find a room for Eliza
various stages of her transformation into a lady. to stay in and to give her a bath, burn her clothes, and order
new garments.
In the 1941 published play, Shaw added scenes inspired by the
film adaptation of Pygmalion, which starred Leslie Howard and Mrs. Pearce chides Higgins for thinking he can "take a girl up
Wendy Hiller. The first one appears at the end of Act 1 when like that as if you were picking up a pebble on the beach." She
advises Eliza to go home to her parents, but Eliza says they sweets. Otherwise, everything is useful and handy, set up for
have turned her out to earn her own living. Mrs. Pearce sternly Higgins's tastes, interests, and pursuits. Even the art on the
asks Higgins on what terms Eliza will stay in the house and walls echoes his scientific nature, featuring subdued
what will become of her when the experiment is done. architectural engravings and portraits in steel or copper. There
Impatient with such details, Higgins leaves them to Mrs. Pearce are no paintings, which reflects his preference for austerity
to settle with Eliza. over Victorian art's vibrant colors.
While Eliza bathes, "an elderly but vigorous dustman" who When Eliza presents herself to Higgins, she has attempted to
claims to be Eliza's father visits Higgins and Pickering. He is clean herself up and dress for the occasion. There is verbal
Alfred Doolittle, a callous, unprincipled scoundrel who has irony in her exchange with Higgins when he calls her "so
come to touch Higgins for money in exchange for Eliza. deliciously low—so horribly dirty." Knowing no better, Eliza
Higgins is struck by Doolittle's natural gift of rhetoric and wails in reply, "I ain't dirty: I washed my face and hands afore I
shocked by the man's lack of morals. But Doolittle unabashedly come, I did." However, there is nothing to laugh at when Eliza
explains that he is too poor to afford them, and he assures reveals her reason for wanting lessons. She is nothing but a
Higgins that the money will be well spent: "There won't be a Cockney flower girl yet she dares to tell two gentlemen—one
penny of it left by Monday ... Just one good spree for myself of whom has shown her little respect—that she dreams of
and the missus." As he leaves five pounds richer, he being a lady in a flower shop some day. It is a bold, courageous
encounters a young "Japanese lady" in a blue kimono. Begging leap that could have cruelly ended in crushed hopes. The
her pardon, he is astonished to discover that it's Eliza. She has willingness to take a risk is one of Eliza's strengths. Other
cleaned up quite nicely. With a last word of advice to Higgins to strengths were glimpsed earlier in Act 1, such as her inherent
take a strap to her if he wants her mind improved, Doolittle self-respect ("My character is the same to me as any lady's")
departs. and a strong sense of propriety ("I'm a good girl, I am").
Eliza is darkly pleased to see him go and has no desire to see Higgins takes on the challenge of turning Eliza into a lady
him again. Moments later, her new clothes arrive, and with a without thought to what it will mean to Eliza. The prospect
howl of delight she rushes from the room to try them on. fascinates him, and he considers it one of life's "inspired follies"
Higgins and Pickering can see they have "taken on a stiff job." that should not be missed. Pickering is similarly interested,
though from the beginning he views Eliza as a person and
treats her kindly. Throughout the play, he will act as a foil for
Analysis Higgins—his respectful demeanor and consideration for Eliza
counterbalancing Higgins's rudeness and insensitivity.
Act 2 sets up the experiment that will raise Eliza from low- to
upper-class status. It also reveals the personal reasons Eliza, Higgins's housekeeper, Mrs. Pearce, does her part in
Higgins, and Pickering have for taking on the daring task. Two protecting Eliza from Higgins—at first, pressing him to be
additional characters are introduced—Mrs. Pearce and Alfred reasonable and to send Eliza back to her parents. Discovering
Doolittle—who will play minor, though influential, roles in Eliza's that Eliza is on her own, Mrs. Pearce then asks Higgins to
story. consider what's to become of her when he completes his
teaching. She knows Higgins is not cruel in his thoughtlessness
As described, Higgins's laboratory was intended to be a and is equally reckless about outcomes for himself. "When you
drawing room—a room in a large private house in which guests get what you call interested in people's accents," she says,
can be received and entertained. The fact that Higgins has "you never think or care what may happen to them or you." She
turned it into a laboratory symbolizes his disregard for assumes a motherly sternness as she takes Eliza in hand, gets
convention as well as conventional behavior or expectations. In her scrubbed and cleaned, and presents her to Higgins and
general, the room reflects the character of an intellectual, Pickering. This relationship will continue to strengthen as the
social nonconformist who has the enthusiasm for his field of play progresses.
study and the required skill to gamble on transforming a flower
girl into a lady. There are spots of comfort, like the easy chair The introduction of Eliza's father, Alfred Doolittle, provides
near the fire and the dessert dish heaped with fruits and insight into Eliza's rough upbringing and her father's
perspective on being one of the "undeserving poor." Doolittle further surprises her with news that he has asked a common
has no interest in Eliza's welfare beyond the money he can flower girl whom he has taught to speak properly to come see
wheedle out of Higgins. "What's a five pound note to you?" he her. However, as he explains, while her pronunciation is quite
asks Higgins. "And what's Eliza to me?" While Eliza wants to good she still needs to learn what to talk about. He hopes his
better herself, Doolittle has no desire to better himself. He mother can help. The extent of the problem soon becomes
explains, "Undeserving poverty is my line. Taking one station in humorously clear.
society with another ... it's the only one that has any ginger in it,
to my taste." There is little love lost between daughter and Mrs. Higgins's other guests arrive, and among them is Mrs.
father, and Eliza states after Doolittle leaves, "I don't want Eynsford Hill, the genteel lady from Act 1 who purchased the
never to see him again, I don't. He's a disgrace to me." flowers spoiled by her son, Freddy. He, too, is present, as are
her daughter, Clara, and Pickering—the last to arrive before
As in the previous act, Shaw carefully describes clothing and Eliza makes her entrance. Elegantly dressed, the former flower
appearances. Doolittle's dustman (garbage man) garb and girl creates an impression of exceptional beauty and
"professional flavor of dust" leave no doubt as to his social sophistication while she perfectly articulates her greetings. As
status. Eliza's appearance after her bath represents the first Mrs. Higgins later comments, Eliza is "a triumph of [her son's]
step in her transformation. The dirty flower girl is gone, art and of her dressmaker's." Nevertheless, in a scene that is
replaced with "a dainty and exquisitely clean young Japanese both hilarious and nerve-racking, Eliza soon slips into an
lady in a simple blue cotton kimono" that even her father does unsuitable family tale of a "pinched" straw hat, a suspected
not recognize—until, of course, she speaks. murder, and some hard gin drinking. With a bit of quick
thinking, Higgins passes it all off as "the new small talk," and
Two optional scenes are included in the 1941 version of Act 2. Eliza tells the tale so charmingly that the Eynsford Hills
The first is the bath scene, which is only alluded to in the suspect nothing. Freddy, in fact, is captivated by her loveliness
original text. Here, Eliza expresses genuine dread of taking a and odd ways. As she leaves, he takes her to the door and
bath, certain that it will be the death of her. The idea of the inquires if she intends to walk home. Her reply, "Not bloody
bath also offends her sense of decency, as she will have to likely. I am going in a taxi," is shocking but fails to destroy the
remove her clothes. When Mrs. Pearce tells her that she will be overall delightful impression she has made.
expected to remove her clothes nightly and wear a proper
nightdress, Eliza's fear that she will "lie awake shivering half the Once alone with Higgins and Pickering, Mrs. Higgins passes
night" provides a glimpse into the deprivation that she has judgment on the whole affair, telling them that Eliza is not
dealt with. "But you don't know what the cold is to me," she presentable and gives herself away "in every sentence she
says, "how I dread it." utters." Learning more about the experiment, she chides both
men for treating Eliza like a live doll—a thing to be dressed and
The second optional scene, placed at the end of Act 2, taught to speak but with no feelings or future. The results of
presents Eliza's first speech lesson. Though it ends in tears of teaching Eliza to look and sound like a fine lady will likely leave
frustration, Eliza shows that she has a quick ear and the talent her caught between two worlds—one in which she still needs
to learn. to earn a living, the other in which her new status disqualifies
her from doing so. Both men miss the point completely, vaguely
assuring Mrs. Higgins that "we'll do what's right." Then they
Act 3 leave with plans to take Eliza to a Shakespeare exhibition.
Alone with her frustration over the obtuseness of the two, Mrs.
Higgins cries out, "Oh, men! men!! men!!!"
Summary
In later editions of the play, an important "optional scene"
follows, influenced by the screenplay Shaw wrote for the film
The story moves to the drawing room at the home of Higgins's
adaptation of Pygmalion. The setting is a party one summer
mother. Elegantly furnished, it reflects a woman of wealth and
evening at an embassy in London, where Higgins puts Eliza's
refinement. It is Mrs. Higgins's day for receiving visitors, and
education to the final test. The greatest obstacle to her
she is not pleased when her son bursts in without warning. He
success is Nepommuck, a Hungarian interpreter and Higgins's
lacks social graces and tends to insult her guests. Higgins
former student who may expose her as an aristocratic However, both women are wearing a mask and putting on a
impostor. Nepommuck does accuse her of being a fraud, but show. Clara is aware of her family's decline in wealth and
for speaking English too perfectly. He determines she is a exhibits "the bravado of genteel poverty." Eliza knows where
Hungarian princess. The experiment proves a success, and she comes from and does her best to imitate a lady.
Higgins wins the wager with Pickering.
In this act, new relationships form, which will have far-reaching
effects as the play continues. The first is one of sympathy
Analysis between Mrs. Higgins and Eliza. Despite her modern leanings,
Mrs. Higgins is a product of the Victorian Era, which confines
The key developments in Act 3 are the introduction of Mrs. women to strictly defined roles in society. She conforms to her
Higgins, Eliza's first appearance in London society, and the role and sees the dangers for Eliza. Though some women are
outcome of that incident. demanding increased political and legal rights and greater
economic opportunities, Mrs. Higgins recognizes that those
Just as Higgins's laboratory expresses his character, Mrs. opportunities may not be available to Eliza—her son and
Higgins's drawing room reflects an educated, free-thinking Pickering are jeopardizing the girl's future. Her sympathy for
woman of wealth, sophistication, refined taste, and modern Eliza is established when Higgins carelessly replies, "There's
leanings. Her home is situated in Chelsea, an artist's quarter in no good bothering now. The thing's done."
London. The Morris wallpaper, curtains, and similar decor show
her interest in a popular decorative and fine arts movement of A second relationship forms between Freddy and Eliza. He is
the time: the Arts and Crafts Movement. The movement smitten with her beauty and unconventional ways. Later, his
developed from a concern over the effects of industrialization adoration will be a source of comfort for Eliza and of irritation
and set standards for home decor that aligned with emerging for Higgins.
ideals of beauty. Designer and artist William Morris was a
The optional scene at the end of Act 3 in the 1941 version of
leading figure in this movement. Mrs. Higgins further proclaims
Pygmalion provides a deeper insight into Higgins's character.
her modernity with open spaces and uncluttered surfaces,
Curious and clever Nepommuck divines—incorrectly—that Eliza
rejecting the fussy Victorian style that left nothing unadorned.
is a Hungarian princess, proving Higgins's premise that
Her taste in artwork is refined, and her portrait is in the
acquiring proper speech will breach social barriers. However,
romantic style of the Pre-Raphaelite artist Dante Gabriel
Higgins is disappointed that it was so easy to fool his former
Rossetti, whose work led to a widespread recognition of the
student and the elites at the party. Instead of reveling in the
need for beauty in everyday life.
victory, he says to Eliza and Pickering, "Let us get out of this. I
Mrs. Higgins's home is the perfect setting for Eliza. In her have had enough of chattering to these fools."
clothing and mannerisms, the Flower Girl has made great
strides. Even her speech is perfectly articulated. However, her
choice of topic hardly matches either her exquisite appearance Act 4
or language, especially her use of bloody, a word considered
obscene in Shaw's time. It should have given her away, yet it
does not. In this way, Shaw demonstrates the foolishness of Summary
making judgments based on appearances.
It's midnight, and Eliza, Higgins, and Pickering are returning to
In the encounter with the Eynsford Hills, Clara is a foil for Eliza.
Wimpole Street after the exhausting but highly successful final
As a lady of the upper class, Clara has the education and
test of Eliza's skills. Higgins scornfully remarks, "Oh Lord! What
refinement that Eliza desires. She has always been clean and
an evening! What a crew! What a silly tomfoolery!" Then,
well dressed and is at home in society. Eliza, in contrast, is
complaining that he cannot find his slippers, he takes no notice
rising from the ignorance and squalor of poverty. She knows
when Eliza finds and places them before him and continues to
what it is to be dirty, cold, and ill dressed. Clara represents
sound off about the party, saying, "Thank God it's over!"
everything to which Eliza aspires and, in the meeting, is the
Oblivious to Eliza's growing resentment, he labels the whole
benchmark against which her progress will be measured.
experiment as a "bore" and "simple purgatory," and then states
that he "can go to bed at last without dreading tomorrow." Eliza feelings?" Higgins replies, "Oh no, I don't think so. Not any
holds her temper until Higgins and Pickering leave the room, feelings that we need bother about." Clearly, nothing has
and then bursts into tears of rage. changed for Higgins. Eliza now feels the sting of his words
deeply when he acts as if the experiment has been a bore and
Moments later, Higgins returns, once more searching for his the outcome somewhat meaningless. When Pickering
slippers, and she throws them at him with all her strength. She compliments him, saying, "There's always something
has won his bet for him, and now he has no more use for her. professional about doing a thing superlatively well," Higgins
"What's to become of me?" she demands. Higgins attempts to answers, "Yes: that's what drives me mad: the silly people don't
persuade her that she is simply tired and suffering a case of know their own silly business." In other words, they were easy
nerves; a good night's sleep will make things right. After all, she to fool and no thanks to Eliza.
is now free and can do what she likes. Gradually, he
understands that she has no idea what she is fit for or what will The crisis comes when Eliza gives vent to her anger and
become of her. Clumsily, he suggests that she could find a rich frustration, finally standing up to Higgins in the face of his
man to marry who will take care of her—a solution Eliza rejects: insensitivity. Fear floods her at the thought that, having no
"We were above that at the corner of Tottenham Court ... I sold further use for her, he will abandon her, throwing her into the
flowers. I didn't sell myself." street—just as her father and stepmother had done. She has
had a taste of life as a lady and acquired all the necessary
Refusing to take the problem seriously, Higgins starts off for attributes. Her dreams have grown beyond merely working in a
bed. He stops when Eliza quietly asks, "Do my clothes belong flower shop. As Mrs. Higgins had predicted in Act 3, she now
to me or to Colonel Pickering?" She wants to know what she has "the manners and habits that disqualify a fine lady from
can take with her and doesn't "want to be accused of stealing." earning her own living" and has no means of supporting herself.
He is shocked, then further angered when she hands him the
jewels he rented for her along with a ring that he bought her, Higgins dismisses her fear, suggests that now she could marry
telling him she doesn't want it anymore. Dashing the ring into well, and advises her to take a good look in a mirror—"you
the fireplace, he stalks out and slams the door. won't feel so cheap," meaning, worthless. Throughout the
experiment, Higgins has viewed Eliza as his creation, and the
In another important "optional scene" Eliza changes clothes changes he has imposed are superficial: language, clothing,
and leaves the house. Outside, she comes upon Freddy gazing and manners. Therefore, in his perception Eliza is what he can
up at her window. Love-struck, he spends most of his nights see and hear, and he assumes this is all that matters to her as
there on the street. Hungry for comfort, Eliza falls into his arms well. In Act 3, he speaks to his mother about the human soul,
and responds to his passionate kisses—until first one, then saying that proper speech can fill up "the deepest gulf that
another constable tells them to move along. They end up in a separates class from class and soul from soul." Even so,
taxi with a plan to drive around all night. In the morning, Eliza Higgins has not yet seen that Eliza possesses this feature.
will visit Mrs. Higgins and ask her advice on what she should
do. In the 1913 version of the play, Higgins takes the ring Eliza
returns to him along with her rented jewelry and throws the
ring violently into the fireplace. The scene ends with Eliza "on
Analysis her knees on the hearthrug," searching through the ashes for
the ring—an image suggestive of the fairy tale character
In this act, the evening's success is the culmination of all Eliza Cinderella. In the 1941 version, this scene leads into the
and Higgins have worked to achieve. Yet, the turning point in optional scene with Freddy. Eliza retrieves the ring and puts it
the play occurs after the victory. Eliza's contribution to the on the dessert stand where she knows Higgins will find it,
evening's triumph—her months of tireless study and fine being so fond of sweets. She then goes upstairs, changes her
performance—go unacknowledged by Higgins and barely clothes, and leaves. Outside, when Freddy sees her he
touched upon by Pickering. The professor still sees Eliza as properly addresses her as "Miss Doolittle." Judging herself by
little more than a means to an end, a way of proving his theory Higgins's behavior, Eliza rebukes him, saying, "Don't you call me
about language and his genius as a teacher. In Act 1, Pickering Miss Doolittle, do you hear? Liza's good enough for me." She
asks, "Does it occur to you, Higgins, that the girl has some "knows" she is only a low-class flower girl masquerading as a
lady. Nevertheless, Freddy's affection is comforting and the any differently than anyone else, that he treats everybody
tonic she needs. rudely. Then he softens a bit and tells her that he will miss her
if she leaves. Knowing Higgins will never change and refusing
to be trapped by sentimentality, Eliza suggests that she may
Act 5 marry Freddy and support them both by teaching phonetics,
possibly as an assistant to Nepommuck. Outraged, Higgins
grabs her and threatens to wring her neck if she does. Yet he
"A woman who utters such garden party. I could even get her
— Higgins, Act 1 The ultimate test will be the ambassador's party, where Eliza
will mingle with members of the highest-ranking social class.
With her speech and manners on full display, she will either
Referring to the flower girl, Higgins is speaking to Pickering, a
pass the test or be revealed as a fraud.
gentleman who shares his interest in language. Higgins's
offhand remarks sow the seeds of future events and will bring
the flower girl (Eliza) to his laboratory at 27A Wimpole Street.
"What is life but a series of
inspired follies? The difficulty is to
"I want to be a lady in a flower
find them to do. Never lose a
shop stead of selling at the corner
chance: it doesn't come every day.
of Tottenham Court Road. But
I shall make a duchess of this
they won't take me unless I can
draggletailed guttersnipe."
talk more genteel. He said he
could teach me." — Higgins, Act 2
"I'm interested. What about the "Well, the matter is, sir, that you
While Mrs. Pearce takes Eliza away for a bath, Pickering and
Higgins discuss the experiment they are about to begin. In this Eliza's father, Alfred Doolittle, learns that Eliza is moving into
question, Pickering confirms his nature as a gentleman and his Higgins's home. Her reasons for doing so do not concern him
genuine concern for Eliza's well-being. Throughout the play, he much, but he sees an opportunity to "touch" the professor for
is a foil or contrast for Higgins, especially in the kindness and money. From his point of view, his "rights" as a father amount
respect with which he treats Eliza. While tactless, insensitive to nothing more than the money he can get for Eliza. Through
Higgins sees her as a creature to be molded, Pickering treats Doolittle's morally corrupt attitude, Shaw shines a light on the
her like a lady before she takes the first step in that direction. dark side of the Victorian Era, where society turned a blind eye
on prostitution and child trafficking.
the fact that he does not treat everyone equally. For example, her a new wardrobe. By Act 4, Eliza the lady presents a stark
his conduct toward his mother and Pickering is invariably contrast to Eliza the flower girl. On the night of her triumph,
courteous, whereas his conduct toward Eliza is often callous she is clothed in an "opera cloak, brilliant evening dress, and
and rude. On the other hand, Higgins expresses a highly moral diamonds, with fan, flowers, and all accessories." Her clothing
and worthwhile ideal: that people, no matter their gender or reflects her thorough and willing transformation, inside and out.
class, are fundamentally equal and should be treated as such.
Eliza's dustman father, Doolittle, illustrates that a change of
clothing may alter other people's perceptions, but those looks
can be deceiving. When he makes an entrance in Act 2, he is
The flower shop represents the dream that drives Eliza to the parlor-maid. However, his new look is misleading. While his
Higgins's laboratory in Act 2: "I want to be a lady in a flower social standing has risen, his only gentlemanly attributes are
shop stead of selling at the corner of Tottenham Court Road," those that have been forced upon him as "middle class morality
she tells Higgins and Pickering. "But they won't take me unless claims its victim."
I can talk more genteel." It is the dream for which she is willing
to transform herself. Later, when she has achieved her goal
and has the speech and manners of a lady, she anxiously asks
Higgins, "What am I fit for? What have you left me fit for?" Her
Mirror
situation is as Mrs. Higgins predicted in Act 3: Eliza has been
given "the manners and habits that disqualify a fine lady from
earning her own living." Though Higgins suggests that the old In Act 2, Eliza is given a bath for the first time in memory.
idea of a florist's shop might be the answer, Eliza may have Shocked that the procedure requires removing all her clothes,
outgrown that particular dream and will have to rethink her she is even more shocked to find a mirror in the bathroom. She
future. doesn't know "which way to look" and finally hangs a towel
over it. However, this represents the moment when Eliza
unguardedly "sees" herself as she is—dirty, disheveled, and far
from ladylike in her personal habits. The bath proves to be a
Clothing treat, and the positive effects are immediately evident. Cloaked
in a blue cotton kimono, she emerges looking like "a dainty and
exquisitely clean young Japanese lady." Her own father, who
Throughout the play, clothing reflects the social status of has come to see what Higgins is up to, fails to recognize her at
characters. For example, Higgins's slippers represent his class first, and then comments, "Well, I never thought she'd clean up
as well as his disregard for Eliza. As a symbol, clothing as good looking as that, Governor. She's a credit to me, ain't
represents Eliza's metamorphosis from flower girl to lady, and she?" Eliza's glimpse in the mirror reveals to her the need for a
Doolittle's rise from dustman to gentleman. When Eliza is change, and the results of the bath prove that change is
introduced in Act 1, she is "not at all an attractive person." Her possible. Thus, the mirror symbolizes self-awareness and
sailor hat of black straw is coated in London soot. She wears a identity.
long, worn black coat and a brown skirt with a coarse apron.
She has worn-down boots, and in general she is quite dirty. In
Act 2, as a step toward her transformation, Higgins's
housekeeper, Mrs. Pearce, burns Eliza's old clothes and orders
that this aspect of her metamorphosis was sparked by behavior of Eliza's father, Doolittle, as he is introduced in Act 2.
Pickering. In Act 5, she asks the colonel, "But do you know His crude speech and manners, dustman's clothing, poor
what began my real education? ... Your calling me Miss financial state, and questionable morality are all indicators of
Doolittle that day when I first came to Wimpole Street. That his station in life as a happy member of the "undeserving poor."
was the beginning of self-respect for me." She further explains, He has no use for middle-class morals, spends his life
"The difference between a lady and a flower girl is not how she "touching" others for money, and at this point he has never
behaves, but how she is treated." pretended to be other than what he seems.
All three facets of Eliza's transformation—sight, sound, and However, appearances can be deceiving and mask the true
soul—come together when, at last, she breaks free of Higgins, essence of a person. In Act 1, Eliza is a dirty, disheveled flower
her creator. Like Pygmalion's ivory sculpture, she is brought to girl who butchers the English language while wheedling a few
passionate life. No longer a "squashed cabbage" or even a coins from pedestrians in exchange for flowers. Nothing about
duchess, she becomes an independent woman. It is important her appearance suggests the intelligence she possesses, her
to note that Shaw is pointedly contrasting Eliza to Pygmalion's desire to be a lady, or her potential. Only her protestations of
idealized statue. In Ovid's version of the story, Pygmalion and "I'm a good girl, I am" and distress at the idea of losing her
Galatea, the statue now brought to life, marry and live happily character hint at hidden qualities that later emerge. In the
ever after. But Galatea is nothing more than a blushing bride reverse, her father, once he comes into money, is taken for a
with little agency. Shaw rejects this version to show the gentleman by his fine clothes and his adopted middle-class
foolishness of a man who would fashion a human being in this ways.
simplistic way.
At the same time, appearances can be a vehicle for changing
identity. This idea is demonstrated in Eliza's transformation as
well as her dilemma once she becomes a lady. Under the
Appearance and Identity guidance of Higgins and Pickering, she evolves in speech and
dress, etiquette, and expectations. However, she discovers
that she no longer fits into her former situation. That self is lost
to her. Her identity—who she is and where she fits in the
In Act 1 of Pygmalion, Henry Higgins is thought to be a
world—must adjust.
policemen, though one bystander points out, "It's all right: he's
a gentleman: look at his boots." Throughout the play, The fundamental nature of identity is expressed well by
appearances identify the social status of characters. How they Higgins, who recognizes, perhaps too late, that what lies
speak, how they dress, their money (or lack of it), and their beneath the beautiful language and clothes—the essence of
manners and morality all serve as indicators. Yet the signs are Eliza—is what matters to him. In Act 5, when he tells her he has
superficial, often contradicting reality, as in the case of Henry become accustomed to her voice and appearance, she retorts,
Higgins who has all the trappings of a gentleman and few of "You have both of them on your gramophone and in your book
the expected social graces. And as Eliza demonstrates most of photographs. When you feel lonely without me, you can turn
clearly, it is the reality beneath appearances that matters. the machine on. It's got no feelings to hurt." Higgins replies, "I
While exploring the relationship between appearances and a can't turn your soul on."
person's identity, Shaw suggests that the outward show can
be a reflection, a mask, or a means of changing identity.
do not change whether he is speaking to Clara and her mother, women and established firm boundaries for femininity among
the flower girl, or Higgins. Another example of this theme is the social classes. In Pygmalion, Shaw illustrates these class
boundaries and roles through various characters. At the
bottom tier of the hierarchy is the flower girl, Eliza, a member learned. By exercising this choice, she can breach established
of the working-class poor. Mrs. Pearce, Higgins's housekeeper, boundaries and define for herself a new femininity.
represents the servant class. Doolittle's wife-to-be—once the
dustman comes into money—represents the middle class that
has achieved a higher standard of living through work. Mrs. and
Miss Eynsford-Hills, members of the genteel poor, do not work. b Motifs
Occupying the top tier is Mrs. Higgins, an upper-class lady of
some wealth who has raised a family and keeps a home. Shaw
aims to show in Pygmalion that such boundaries, with their
fixed roles and definitions of femininity, are artificial and can be
Pygmalion and Galatea
breached.
The basis for Shaw's Pygmalion is a Greek myth retold by
Victorian society envisioned the ideal woman as inhabiting a Roman poet Ovid (43 BCE–17 CE) in his masterwork
separate sphere from a man: the home, an oasis to which the Metamorphoses. Young Pygmalion sees women as so morally
man escaped from the moral taint of the business world. As flawed that he rejects all thoughts of marriage and resolves to
wife and mother of his children, she was calm, cheerful, live alone. Nevertheless, he uses his great skill as a sculptor to
efficient, and morally superior (the "angel of the house"), and carve out of ivory a woman so perfect that he falls in love with
certainly did not aspire to life outside the home. Marriage and her. In fact, she is so beautifully fashioned that she nearly
motherhood were her means of securing financial security. seems to live and breathe, and as time passes, Pygmalion's
adoration grows.
Shaw envisions a new ideal in Pygmalion: a free-spirited,
educated, self-reliant, and career-minded woman. Higgins's One day, at the festival of Venus—the goddess of love, beauty,
mother provides the model upon which the final and sexuality—Pygmalion offers a prayer that he might be
creation—Eliza—is based. Mrs. Higgins is intelligent, cultured, given a wife like his ivory virgin. The goddess hears and
educated, and independent. Higgins himself says, "My idea of a understands what the young man dares not ask: that his
lovable woman is something as like you as possible" (Act 3). creation may become his wife. Venus grants the sculptor's
She sympathizes with Eliza as the subject of her son's heart's desire. Upon returning home, he kisses the statue and
experiment and eventually becomes her champion. However, it finds that he is touching not cold ivory but warm, yielding flesh.
is too late for her to more fully break the social mold. She runs Venus has given life to the sculpture, and her name is Galatea.
her household as expected and upholds the customs of the
Like Pygmalion, Higgins becomes Eliza's creator, using the
day. The next step must be taken by a younger woman.
power of language to create a lady from a "draggletailed
In Eliza, Shaw creates a fresh ideal—a woman with all the guttersnipe." Like the "scores of American millionairesses"
attributes of Higgins's mother but with the time, spirit, and whom he has taught to speak, Eliza is nothing more than a
ambition to go her own way. Like the mythic artist Pygmalion "block of wood" from which he will carve a duchess. In the final
who sculpts the ideal woman, Higgins and Pickering fashion stage of her transformation, a surge of passion brings Eliza to
Eliza into the perfect lady—refined, self-reliant, and with all the life, and she becomes aware that she is an independent being,
potential this implies. Nevertheless, the question remains: Can separate from her creator, and able to stand on her own. At
she break through the reigning Victorian definition of femininity the very last, Higgins is left behind in his mother's drawing
set for middle- and upper-class women? Or has she room as Eliza "sweeps out"—no longer an immobile creature
exchanged one set of limitations—those of a working-class but an individual able to make her own way.
flower girl—for another? She still must have a means of
Shaw's ending is markedly different from Ovid's. In Shaw's
financial survival.
Pygmalion, Higgins (who, unlike his ancient counterpart does
It seems that society has left her three options—to marry not get to keep his Galatea) is exposed as foolishly misguided.
Higgins, Pickering, or Freddy. Yet in Act 5, Eliza herself In this way, Shaw seems to reject the Ovidian version. It's
conceives of a fourth. She, indeed, may marry Freddy, but now worth noting that Ovid also reveals an ironic attitude toward
she has a career choice—the capability to teach what she has many of his characters (Ovid makes the deluded and bitter
e Suggested Reading
Berst, Charles A. Pygmalion: Shaw's Spin on Myth and
Cinderella. New York: Twayne, 1995. Print.
All material contained within this document/guide is protected by copyright law of the US and various other
jurisdictions and may not be reproduced or distributed without the express written consent. Contact Course Hero
with respect to reproduction or distribution. This document was downloaded from Coursehero.com on 07-19-2021
by 100000817764887.