Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Culture For Regional Development
Culture For Regional Development
Culture For Regional Development
REgIONAl DEVElOPMENt
CUltURE FOR
Regions and Cities REgIONAl DEVElOPMENt
In this new volume, 28 Scandinavian researchers and others who are active in arts and culture seek to
answer the questions: What has been the effect of regional and local investment in arts and culture?
A scANdINAVIAN PERsPEctIVE
And what positive and negative experiences have there been? This book describes and analyzes the
extent to which cultural investments at local and regional levels have stimulated development and led
to essential processes of change for the community in general.
Of special interest is how different places manage to ‘turn the tide’. What do their development
processes involve? Which ways and means do they use to go forward in order to change their paths
and start anew? These are just a few of the important questions addressed in this book. One of the
most important findings is that while you can never transfer the successful renewal of one place to
another like a blueprint, certain common patterns in the cultural processes are discernible.
The contributors to this book show the breadth of theoretical tools that can be used to increase
awareness of the significance of culture for regional development. Throughout the book readers will
find a multitude of theoretical concepts, from entrepreneurship theory, organizational institutionalism
GEOgRAPHY/EcONOMIcs/BUsINEss
Cover image: © Shutterstock
Regions and Cities
EdItEd bY LIsbEtH LINdEbORg
www.routledge.com ANd LARs LINdKVIst
Routledge titles are available as eBook editions in a range of digital formats
The Value of Arts and Culture for
Regional Development
In this new volume, 28 Scandinavian researchers and others who are active in arts
and culture seek to answer the questions: What has been the effect of regional and
local investment in arts and culture? And what positive and negative experiences
have there been? This book describes and analyzes the extent to which cultural
investments at local and regional levels have stimulated development and led to
essential processes of change for the community in general.
Of special interest is how different places manage to ‘turn the tide’. What do
their development processes involve? Which ways and means do they use to go
forward in order to change their paths and start anew? These are just a few of the
important questions addressed in this book. One of the most important findings is
that while you can never transfer the successful renewal of one place to another
like a blueprint, certain common patterns in the cultural processes are discernible.
The contributors to this book show the breadth of theoretical tools that can be
used to increase awareness of the significance of culture for regional
development. Throughout the book readers will find a multitude of theoretical
concepts, from entrepreneurship theory, organizational institutionalism and
cultural economy, to cultural planning and art management. This book will appeal
to scholars and practitioners of urban and regional studies, and cultural and
creative economics.
Managing Editor
Gillian Bristow, University of Cardiff, UK.
Editors
Maryann Feldman, University of Georgia, USA,
Gernot Grabher, HafenCity University Hamburg, Germany,
Ron Martin, University of Cambridge, UK,
Martin Perry, Massey University, New Zealand.
16 An innovation lost: The Ice Dome Concert Hall Project in Piteå 252
HANS GELTER AND JENNIE GELTER
Index 356
Illustrations
Figures
Tables
The basis for this edited volume is the anthology called Kulturens Kraft för
Regional Utveckling that was published in 2010 by the Swedish publishing
company SNS Förlag, www.sns.se/forlag/kulturens-kraft-regional-utveckling. In
that book, 22 Swedish researchers present mainly Swedish and some non-
Scandinavian examples of the power of culture for regional development. So far
nearly all of the copies of this book have been sold.
Instead of releasing a new edition we, together with researchers from other
Scandinavian countries, have decided to put together a new book in English, with
examples from all over Scandinavia, for the international market. We soon found
that Routledge suited us best to establish cooperation with.
As editors we wish to extend our gratitude to Simon Holt and Robert Langham
at Routledge for nursing this manuscript into book form, to Michelle Mello for her
remarkable attention to detail in finding more useful words and synonyms in her
proofreading of the manuscript and to Anders Olsson for help with the
standardization of the manuscript. The editors also want to thank the Dean at the
Linnæus University for financial support with finishing the book.
Lisbeth Lindeborg: Do you remember the British economist Mark Blaug and the
book he edited, The Economics of the Arts? I think it was published some time in
the mid-seventies.
Lars Lindkvist: Yes, yes – I remember. It was in 1976. He was early with his
theories, like David Throsby’s and Glenn Withers’ The Economics of the
Performing Arts which was published around the same time and Tibor
Scitovsky’s Subsidies for the Arts: the Economic Argument which came a few
years later.
Lisbeth: Yes. It was Blaug who wrote about a cultural lag – a state of affairs
and a state of mind, which characterized our societies for quite a long time after
the Second World War. At that time cultural activities and the arts were
marginalized within the framework of planning and development. Cultural policy
was not high on the agenda and, when mentioned, it was often seen as a luxury
commodity. For artists struggling to survive that was insulting.
Lars: Also, that view of culture changed in the late seventies with the
publishing of the Journal of Cultural Economics and the founding of the
Association of Cultural Economics International. Real pioneers – of course –
were William Baumol and William Bowen who wrote about the economic
dilemma of performing arts back in the sixties.
Lisbeth: That’s it – you had the artists themselves and some economists who
knew of the different great values – including the financial ones – of arts and
culture. But it has taken time to get politicians involved in the issue. And we know
from the chapters in this book that it is crucial to have support from politicians
when promoting arts. When influential politicians finally came out and proposed
investments in cultural infrastructure it meant a lot. In France, for example, the
Minister of Culture Jack Lang was one of the first European ministers to really
push cultural politics. Another great political personality at the time was the
famous political author and politician Jean-Jacques Servan-Schreiber. In an
article for Le Figaro in 1988 he proposed that the cold war powers should be
replaced by creative powers, literally. A great idea.
Lars: Yes – thanks to personalities like that, today we are en route in an
existing cultural society. There is no doubt about that. We only have to look at
concepts which were dismissed and that caused controversy 20 years ago, like
2 Lisbeth Lindeborg and Lars Lindkvist
cultural infrastructures, creative industries and cultural investments – they are
fully accepted today.
Regional diversity
Lisbeth: The other concept which we use is region – regional development. It is
interesting how our authors conceive of it. When, for example, someone would
call Scandinavia a region, this is the interpretation which you find in American
research. There, a region is a limited amount of states which are loosely connected
in one way or another – it is a global area like NAFTA, OAS, EU, etc.2 Very often
the common denominator for these states is a common market factor (Nye 1968;
Haas 1975; Fawcett and Hurrell 1995; Telo 2001).
But in Europe a region is the third level of four: the EU as a supra-state
structure is the first level, the nation states make up the second, the regions the
third and the local communities the fourth. To really understand the third level
you can look at the map Tabula Regionum Europae published by the Assembly of
European Regions (AER).
Lars: Yes. I have seen the map – it is an interesting and unusual view to see the
regions instead of the countries.
Lisbeth: What is really thrilling is that there is a regional taxonomy – there is a
regional diversity (Weihe-Lindeborg 2001/2005). If we refer to the AER
definition of region, which is, and I quote:
This is the first paragraph in the Declaration of Regionalism in Europe and it is the
accepted definition in the EU. So territoriality is the first criterion of a region. In
our book, Kronoberg region is such a region.
Lars: It is an administrative unit and has been so since Sweden was divided into
counties (län) in the seventeenth century.
Lisbeth: But that is not enough. Beside regions there is the concept of a
microregion. They are normally smaller regional contexts – although larger than
local authorities – which can vary. They are territories within. Compared to the
basic region, the territory and the existence of a microregion is determined by
geographic-topographic factors – like the island Furillen in our book, or
historical-cultural factors like Turku or Stavanger, or economic factors like
Roskilde, or administrative factors like Holstebro.
Lars: And the cross-border regions?
Lisbeth: That is a third category emerging from intensified cross-border
cooperations in neighbouring states. Our two examples in this book are Jämtland-
Tröndelag and the Finnish archipelago. A kind of cross-border regions are
En route in the cultural society 9
macroregions which are mostly transnational being made up of regions in two or
more neighbouring states, for example the Barents Euro-Arctic Region
(Lindeborg 1995).
Lars: And what about the other cases in the book like Dalhalla, Hultsfred, Piteå,
Kristiansand, Stiklestad, Horsens, Skagen and Fredrikshavn?
Lisbeth: Well they are cities or towns – that is local communities – but they are
part of a regional context.
The book
Lisbeth: In this book we wanted to show how quite a few places – no matter how
small, no matter how tedious – manage to ‘turn-the-tide’ from an unsuccessful
status quo to something new. So how do they proceed? What do their
development processes involve? Which ways and means do they use to go
forward in order to change their paths and start anew? How long do these
processes take? When can one expect to see results of the efforts, etc.?
Lars: And we wanted to show the breadth of theoretical tools that can be used to
increase the awareness of culture’s significance for regional development, instead
of concentrating on one or two theoretical perspectives. In the various chapters
you will find a multitude of theoretical concepts, from entrepreneurship theory,
organizational institutionalism and cultural economy (where the authors calculate
the value of, for example, Vara Concert Hall and the Watercolour Museum in
Skärhamn, Sweden, for the region’s residents) to cultural planning and art
management.
Lisbeth: Among the most important findings is the basic fact that although you
can never transfer the successful renewal of one place to another – like a
blueprint – certain common patterns in the cultural processes are distinguishable.
One of these findings is that cultural development is an ongoing process, which
never ends.
Lars: The guideline for each chapter includes a portrayal of one or more
cultural ventures and in-depth analyses of why certain projects were started and
how they proceed, and an evaluation of their results for regional development thus
disclosing practical and theoretical know-how for the benefit of other places. And
we discuss the mechanisms triggering this cultural revolution and how awareness
of culture as a building block in our societies has grown. Culture as a growth
factor can be found everywhere – not only in urban contexts but also in the
countryside and small villages.
Lisbeth: The book and the examples also show the significance of the
Europeanization and regionalization processes as driving forces for cultural
development in any one place. That leads on to the fact that there is increasing
competition between regions, between cities and between villages. Is there a risk
that they outdo each other? A second issue is the instrumentalizing of culture for
commercial reasons. Where is the limit to be drawn? At the same time we
discover that there is a growing polarity between an event-based versus art-based
culture.
10 Lisbeth Lindeborg and Lars Lindkvist
Lars: There are lots of questions that have been raised by our authors,
28 Scandinavian researchers, and others who are active in arts and culture. What
has regional investment in arts and culture led to? What are the positive and
negative experiences? We also show a few places where the cultural assets were
not taken care of, and where the possibility of an outstanding cultural profile
was lost.
Lisbeth: Yes, and in comparison to the positive experiences, the negative or
unhappy ones are few. I think that has to do with at least two things. First of all –
if you are researching a city or a region – making a field study – you tend to
choose a place where the effects on the whole are positive. For most cases it is an
up-and-down process. Hultsfred is a good example of that. Another reason that
our cases are positive is that most of them are fairly new – they are still on their
way up – and forward. That is why Holstebro is so interesting, having succeeded
for almost fifty years – it is a veteran among our cases – and you want to know
the reason for its success.
Lars: Another important issue is how we have chosen to organize the book. The
book is organized with cases from the four Nordic countries, Denmark, Finland,
Norway and Sweden as the starting point. The book could have been organized
based on different themes with, for example, festivals as one chapter heading and
museums as another. However, we felt it would be more valuable to present the
chapters according to the respective countries. We have made our selection so as
to illustrate as many cultural expressions as possible.
Lisbeth: We wanted to present Scandinavia. And there is also the notion
today, with so much virtuality around us, that people need places which they can
refer to. Although culture and the arts are immaterial resources – ‘software of the
mind’3 – they require spatial frameworks and cultural infrastructures in order to
develop. Finally, before we get into the content of the book’s different chapters,
don’t you have a good quote that is said to be by Winston Churchill?
Lars: Yes, it is not confirmed that he really said it, but it is a good statement. In
many Nordic and European debates, investments in culture are pitted against
investments in other areas of the public sector, with the argument that it is better
to invest in the care of the elderly than in the theatre. Lars Nordström, President of
the Cultural Affairs Committee in Sweden’s Västra Götaland region (which is
spending three times as much on investments in arts and culture than other
Swedish regions) responds to this in the region’s annual report (Franck 2005), by
quoting Churchill. During the First World War there were many who wondered if
it wasn’t time to cut cultural spending and instead invest in defence at a time when
England was so beset by the Germans. Churchill disagreed, when it was suggested
to him that he needed to make cuts in arts and culture, he allegedly asked: ‘Then
what are we fighting for?’
The chapters
Starting out is Peter Aronsson with the historical background. He shows the
Nordic culture as an asset with many faces. The chapter argues that the persistent
En route in the cultural society 11
political viability of Nordic culture in new political settings is dependent on its
foundation as a plastic construction originating outside politics.
In the first section with cases from Denmark, Lisbeth Lindeborg analyses the
development in Holstebro. In order for Holstebro and its surrounding region to
survive, the maxim of culture and arts as a growing development factor was
adopted. Which strategy was developed? What risks had to be evaded and how
did Holstebro proceed in its endeavour, steadily going forward from one
milestone to the next? These are some of the questions that are answered. Anne
Lorentzen explores and discusses one of the most spectacular culture projects
developed in a small city in Denmark, the Days of Tordenskiold in Frederikshavn.
A response to severe industrial decline, its aim was to establish a new urban
identity, based on a maritime – and heroic – history. While in itself a great
achievement, the developmental impact of the festival is considerable. Lise Lyck
analyses two places, Skagen and Horsens, where arts and culture have been
the main driver for economic and regional development. Both are success
stories that have similarities and differences, presenting perspectives on how
the arts including design can be a generator of economic development and
regionalization. Jon Sundbo analyses the importance of a rock festival for the
town of Roskilde, particularly its importance for industrial development. The
festival has developed from a social and musical event to something that is also
business, innovation and regional development.
In the Finnish section Niina Koivonen describes and analyses Tampere – the
Manchester of Finland – which has undergone a painful transformation from
textile and mechanical engineering industries to an international hub of ICT and
creative industries. Alf Rehn et al. discuss what forms of expectations arose when
the city of Turku arranged a cultural mega event, i.e. acted as the European
Capital of Culture in 2011. They have also looked closer into the complex issues
involved in managing contemporary expectations ‘on the power of culture’.
Katriina Siivonen analyses two regional development projects in the Southwest-
Finland Archipelago. She raises the question: Why didn’t local culture as a
resource ensure socio-cultural well-being in the region? Saara L. Taalas focuses
on the Kotka-Hamina Region in Finland as a case for exploration of creativity
connected to industrial production processes and sites that have become to some
degree redundant. The analysis suggests an alternative reading to creativity that is
not focused on the original and novel but on the reinterpretation of production set-
ups and industrial sites for the future.
In Norway Trine Bille examines a very special case of using culture and
creativity to develop a region, namely the foundation Cultiva in Kristiansand,
Norway. The case is special in the sense that a lot of money has been allocated to
the foundation and the returns on this capital must be invested in projects that
develop the region in economic and social terms by using arts, culture and
creativity as the instrument. Anne-Britt Gran takes a closer look at one example of
the local and regional upswing represented by the theatrical genre of the historical
play and the way these plays are sponsored. Combining theories of theatre
anthropology, theories of cultural sponsorship and theories about globalization
12 Lisbeth Lindeborg and Lars Lindkvist
provide new insight about cultural power in local and regional development.
Hilmar Rommetvedt analyses the beliefs in culture as an instrument for regional
development among the citizens, leading politicians, civil servants and business
managers in the Stavanger region, both before and after the European Capital of
Culture event in 2008.
Representing the biggest country in regards to geographical size and number of
inhabitants, there are more Swedish chapters. The underpinning of John
Armbrecht’s and Tommy D. Andersson’s chapter is that rational decisions about
cultural institutions cannot only be based on cost analysis but must also consider
the value created. Furthermore, if value created can be measured in monetary
units, as costs are, it will be possible to compare value created to costs of
producing culture. Contingent valuation methods are used to assess user as well as
non-user values of a concert hall and a watercolour museum. Per Frankelius
analyses the creation of an opera arena, Dalhalla, in an old limestone quarry. The
main conclusion is that nature, if managed right, can very well be part of art. Such
combinations, in turn, can result in novel phenomena that can have a huge impact
on regional development. A model is developed describing critical factors in
making ideas like this come through. Hans Gelter and Jennie Gelter tell the true
story about an innovative dream of an Ice Dome Concert Hall made completely of
snow and ice in Piteå, northern Sweden. An ice artist’s dream and desire to
produce great art soon met the reality of cultural projects and the accompanying
slow bureaucracy of financing and project planning. This chapter illustrates the
problem of how creative and innovative ideas cannot always be transformed into
local and regional development projects. Lars Lindkvist et al. describe how the
cultural planning method in the Kronoberg County is about looking from a
bottom-up perspective at which cultural resources can be found in a region and
how they can be used to develop the area and strengthen its identity. In the next
chapter Lars Lindkvist describes the development of Furillen, a small island just
outside Gotland in Sweden, and analyses the value of art and culture in terms of
cultural entrepreneurship, the creation of meeting places, a design hotel and a
‘culture cube’, which can be used by people who want to work alone, or work with
others in different cultural and creative projects. Tobias Nielsén draws lessons
from the rise and fall, and rise again, of Sweden’s biggest rock festival. He raises
the questions: Who should be responsible for taking the risks with the outcome of
cultural events being uncertain? Should it be the passionate social and cultural
entrepreneur alone, or do other organizations and the public sector have
responsibilities? Can some support, however, be counterproductive? He finds the
answers in Hultsfred – a small town with an internationally famous rock festival
as a platform for a ‘creative cluster’. After thirty years of existence, the rock
festival faced serious economic problems and the organizers were forced into
bankruptcy but after one year the festival started up again.
The last two chapters are on the cross-border regions of Barents Euro-Arctic
Region and mid-Scandinavia. Among the many thrilling and intriguing cultural
hotspots in Scandinavia, Lisbeth Lindeborg sees the Barents Euro-Arctic Region
(BEAR), founded in 1993 with the participation of thirteen regions in the four
En route in the cultural society 13
countries around the North Pole, as the most exotic. With 600 cultural projects in
its first five-year period it increased the cultural activities in the area by 240 per
cent. One objective of the cultural cooperation is to strengthen the common
identity of the Barents Region in order to further regional development. In their
chapter, Stig Westerdahl and Wilhelm Skoglund focus on the role of arts and
culture in two mid-Scandinavian regions: Jämtland, Sweden and Tröndelag,
Norway. These border regions try to strike a balance between a long history of
cross-border cooperation and loyalties to the nation state. Several cultural projects
illustrate the tension.
Notes
1 According to World Creativity Forum the twelve districts of creativity are:
Flanders, Baden-Württemberg, Rhone-Alpes, Nord-Pas-de-Calais, Lombardy,
Catalonia, Scotland, Tampere, Oklahoma, Quebec, Shanghai and Karnataka (India).
2 NAFTA stands for North American Free Trade Area, OAS stands for Organization of
American States, EU stands for the European Union.
3 The expression ‘software of the mind’ was used by the Dutch management researcher
Geert Hofstede in the title of his book, Cultures and Organizations: Software of the
Mind (1991).
References
Baecker, D. (2003) Wozu Kultur?, Berlin: Kadmos.
Baumol, W.J. and Bowen, W.G. (1966) Performing Arts: the Economic Dilemma; a Study
of Problems Common to Theatre, Opera, Music, and Dance, New York: Twentieth
Century Fund.
Blaug, M. (ed.) (1976) The Economics of the Arts, London: Martin Robertson.
Fawcett, L. and Hurrell, A. (eds) (1995) Regionalism in World Politics. Regional
Organization and International Order, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Franck, A. (ed.) (2005) Kultur Västra Götaland 2004/2005, Uddevalla: Kultursekretariatet
Västra Götalandsregionen.
Gould, P. and White, R. (1992) Mental Maps, London and New York: Routledge.
Gulmann, S. (2005) Citydesign – byudvikling for borgere, Copenhagen: Gyldendals
forlag.
Haas, E. (1975) The Obsolence of Regional Integration Theory, Berkeley: Berkeley
University Press.
Haraldsen, T., Flygind, S.K., Overvåg, K. and Power, D. (2004) Kartlegging av
kulturnaeringene i Norge – økonomisk betydning, vekst- og utviklingspotential,
Lillehammer: øf-rapport: 10/2004.
Hofstede, G. (1991) Culture and Organizations: Software of the Mind, London:
McGraw Hill.
Lindeborg, L. (1991) Kultur som lokaliseringsfaktor, Stockholm: Industridepartementet,
Ds 1991:22.
——— (1995) Regionalt samarbete i Europa – med tyska erfarenheter, Rapport 87,
Stockholm: Expertgruppen för forskning om regional utveckling.
(Weihe-) Lindeborg, L. (2001/2005) Zum regionalen System. Stellenwert der
Versammlung der Regionen Europas, Marburg: Tectum Wissenschaftsverlag.
14 Lisbeth Lindeborg and Lars Lindkvist
Lindeborg, L. (2007) ‘Kulturen som arbetsmarknad expanderar kraftigt’, in B. Ayata
(ed.), Kulturekonomi. Konsten att fånga osynliga värden, Lund: Studentlitteratur,
105– 139.
Nye, J. (ed.) (1968) International Regionalism: Readings, Boston: Harvard University
Press, Center for International Affairs.
Plaza, B. (2006) ‘The Return on Investment of the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao’,
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 30(2): 452– 467.
——— (2008) ‘On Some Challenges and Conditions for the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao
to be an Effective Economic Re-activator’, International Journal of Urban and Regional
Research, 32(2): 506 – 517.
Plaza, B. and Haarich, S.N. (2009) ‘Museums for Urban Regeneration? Exploring
Conditions for their Effectiveness’, Journal of Urban Regeneration and Renewal,
2(3): 259– 271.
Plaza, B., Galvez-Galvez, C. and Gonzalez-Flores, A. (2011) ‘Testing the Employment
Impact of the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao via TSA’, Tourism Economics,
17(1): 223 –229.
Scitovsky, T. (1982) Subsidies for the Arts: the Economic Argument, Santa Cruz:
University of California Press.
Siemiatycki, M. (2005) ‘Beyond Moving People: Excavating the Motivations for Investing
in Urban Public Transit Infrastructure in Bilbao Spain’, European Planning Studies,
13(1): 23– 44.
Telo, M. (2001) European Union and New Regionalism, Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
Throsby, D. (2008a) ‘The Concentric Circles Model of the Cultural Industries’, Cultural
Trends, 17(3): 147 – 164.
——— (2008b) ‘Modelling the Cultural Industries’, International Journal of Cultural
Policy, 14(3): 217– 232.
Throsby, D. and Withers, G.A. (1979) The Economics of the Performing Arts, New York:
St Martins.
References
Marineforeningen(2010) ‘Tordenskiolddagene i
Frederikshavn’, Marineforeningens Tidsskrift Under
Dannebrog, 97(3): 12–15.
universitet.
Kirjallisuuden Seura.
Carpelan, C. (2002b) ‘Arkeologiset lo¨ydo¨t aikaportaina’,
in R. Gru ¨ nthal (ed.), Ennen,
Seura.
World, Lanham & Boulder & New York & Toronto & Oxford:
Rowman & Littlefield
Publishers, Inc.
Finland.
——— (2012b) Steel, Glass and Wood. These are what Maritime
Centre Vellamo is Made of. Available at:
www.merikeskusvellamo.fi/en/Building/Facts (accessed 21 May
2012).
den? – Hvem besta ˚ r den af? – Hvad betyder den for det
danske samfund?, Aarhus: Klim
forlag.
Commission.
Tidsskrift, Oslo.
stiftelsen.
School.
Copenhagen.
Vegvesen.
Available at:
Comedia.
Nilsson, S. (2003) Kulturens nya va ¨ gar – Kultur,
kulturpolitik och kulturutveckling i
la
Routledge.
Nomos.
dokument/verksamhet/cat_view/80-verksamhet/82-publikationer/83-utveckling-och