Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Physiotherapy Theory and Practice, 29(4):301–308, 2013

Copyright © Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.


ISSN: 0959-3985 print/1532-5040 online
DOI: 10.3109/09593985.2012.732196

DESCRIPTIVE REPORT

Guillain–Barré syndrome patient’s satisfaction with


physiotherapy: A two-part observational study
Diane Dennis1 and Rachel Mullins2
1
Physiotherapist, Bachelor Applied Science (Physiotherapy), Senior ICU Physiotherapist, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital,
Perth, Australia
2
Physiother Theory Pract Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Michigan University on 10/28/14

Physiotherapist, Bachelor Physiotherapy, Senior ICU Physiotherapist, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital, Perth, Australia

ABSTRACT
The purpose of this observational study was to assess Guillain–Barré syndrome (GBS) patients’ satisfaction with
physiotherapy in the acute and sub-acute setting, and provide an overview of inpatient case management, includ-
ing the number of complications. Twenty-seven patients admitted to Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital (SCGH) with
GBS between 1 May 2005 and 30 April 2010 were considered for inclusion. Nineteen patients consented and a
waiver of consent was granted for four other patients. Data were collected from case-note audit (n = 23) and tele-
phone survey (n = 19) during June and July 2011. Participants receiving physiotherapy (n = 16) reported they
were satisfied with management (87%), treatment frequency (88%), duration (94%), and timetabling (81%) of
For personal use only.

treatment and the professionalism and rapport (100%) of physiotherapists. Median length of hospital stay was
20 days (range 5–198) for 23 participants. Physiotherapists documented patient assessment within 2 days
from admission (range 1–5). First functional improvements were documented on day 6 (median, range 2–34).
Physiotherapists were most commonly first to mobilize patients to sit, stand, transfer, and walk (83%, 82%,
81%, and 90%, respectively). Twenty patients (87%) developed complications during their hospital stay, the
most common being low back pain (61%). This study has demonstrated that GBS patients were satisfied with
care provided by physiotherapy.

INTRODUCTION 2005). The weakness of all muscles including those


of respiration may progress to complete paralysis,
First reported in the early 1800s, Guillain–Barré and there may be altered sensation throughout the
Syndrome (GBS) remains the largest single cause of body, including pain (Hughes and Cornblath, 2005;
acute neuromuscular paralysis (Rees, Thompson, Ropper, 1992). There are also secondary effects of
and Hughes, 1998) in previously healthy people, prolonged bed-rest with paralysis, including ortho-
with a worldwide annual incidence of one to two per static intolerance, loss of muscle mass, joint range of
100,000 persons (Hughes and Rees, 1997). The man- movement, balance, and proprioception (Winkleman,
agement of the patient with severe and protracted 2009).
GBS provides a major challenge, as although progno- The amount of time physiotherapists spend with
sis may be excellent (Bersano et al, 2006; Rees, these inpatients is considerable and there are many
Thompson, and Hughes, 1998), complications are components of care in the acute and sub-acute
common (Bernsen, de Jager, van der Meché, and setting (Davidson, Wilson, Walton, and Brissenden,
Suurmeijer, 2005) and there may be residual deficits 2009). Respiratory physiotherapy may be indicated
in up to 20% of patients (Hughes and Cornblath, in the spontaneously breathing patient in order to
optimize and, in some facilities, monitor lung func-
tion. More frequent examination and treatment may
then be required with the progression to mechanical
Accepted for publication 12 September 2012
ventilation. Physiotherapists maintain joint range and
Address correspondence to Diane Dennis, Physiotherapist, Bachelor optimize patient positioning through stretches, trans-
Applied Science (Physiotherapy), Senior ICU physiotherapist, Sir
Charles Gairdner Hospital, Perth, Australia. E-mail: diane.dennis@ fers, and where necessary, splinting (Davidson,
health.wa.gov.au Wilson, Walton, and Brissenden, 2009). Tilt tables

301
302 Dennis and Mullins

are used to stand patients gradually in order to Participants


maintain muscle length, approximate joints to main-
tain bone density, and normalize the body’s blood The Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital (SCGH) Ethics
pressure response in the erect position (Chang, Committee approved this study (study number
Boots, Hodges, and Paratz, 2004). Physiotherapists 2010-078). All participants gave written informed
at also regularly document muscle strength and consent before data collection began. All acute GBS
sensation changes during recovery. cases attending the SCGH, a 600-bed tertiary hospital
There is significant scientific literature detailing in Perth, Australia, between 1 May 2005 and 30 April
residual disability (Bernsen, de Jager, van der 2010 were considered. A 5-year period was chosen in
Meché, and Suurmeijer, 2005; Bussmann, Garssen, order to generate a reasonable number of subjects who
van Doorn, and Stam, 2007; Fletcher, Lawn, were able to recall their acute hospital stay with some
Wolter, and Wijdicks, 2000; Forsberg et al, 2005; clarity.
Garssen et al, 2004; Kuitwaard, Bos-Eyssen, Prospective participants and their contact details
Physiother Theory Pract Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Michigan University on 10/28/14

Blomkwist-Markens, and van Doorn, 2009; were identified from the SCGH Allied Health Statisti-
Rekand, Gramstad, and Vedeler, 2009; Rudolph, cal (AHS) database during June and July 2011. An
Larsen, and Farbu, 2008) and health-related quality information sheet regarding the nature of the study
of life (Bersano et al, 2006; Forsberg et al, 2005; together with a consent form was posted to them.
Garssen et al, 2004; Merkies et al, 2002) in GBS Subjects were then contacted via telephone by a phy-
survivors. There are also papers that describe the siotherapist Rachel Mullins to answer any concerns
extent of physiotherapy intervention (Davidson, and if agreeable, arrange a time for telephone inter-
Wilson, Walton, and Brissenden, 2009) but little re- view. It was made clear to participants at this time
garding specific GBS physiotherapy protocols in the that the interviewer Rachel Mullins had had no prior
acute setting. Research describing the patients’ professional contact with them during their acute in-
experiences is also limited (Bernsen, de Jager, van
For personal use only.

patient stay. On receipt of a signed consent form,


der Meché, and Suurmeijer, 2005; Forsberg, Ahl- they were telephoned in order to undertake the
ström, and Holmqvist, 2008) and to our knowledge, survey. In addition, their case-notes were reviewed
there is no published data on GBS patients’ satisfac- and data regarding their hospital stay were collected.
tion with the acute inpatient care received, including Those who remained inpatients at any hospital
physiotherapy services. A recent Cochrane review facility at the time of the review were excluded, as
concluded that due to the paucity of rigorous they may have been concerned that their answers com-
studies examining rehabilitation in GBS, “clinical promised their current management.
practice trials” should be encouraged, whereby pro-
spective and retrospective data are collected without
disrupting the natural milieu of treatment (Khan Outcome measures
et al, 2010). These studies would provide details
about services provided, outcomes, implications for A case-note audit was undertaken with data collec-
clinical practice, and models of care. It was also tion relating to demographics and admission charac-
concluded that there are considerable gaps in the teristics as well as the length and location of hospital
evidence with a failure to incorporate the GBS stay, the extent of illness, the nature and timing of
patient’s point of view (Khan et al, 2010). medical and physiotherapy interventions, and the
The purpose of this study was to assess the GBS number and nature of complications. The achieve-
patients’ satisfaction with physiotherapy in the acute ment of rehabilitation milestones and discharge plan-
and sub-acute setting, and provide an overview of ning documentation was recorded and AHS data
inpatient case management including physiotherapy were reviewed and the occasions of service and dur-
and the complications of the disease. ation of treatments during inpatient stay data were
extracted.
A standardized form was developed to facilitate
data extraction. One investigator Rachel Mullins
METHOD extracted all data, and discrepancies in the timing
of interventions were resolved by cross-referencing
Design medical and allied health documentation. Discrepan-
cies in delivery of medications were resolved by cross-
This was a retrospective non-interventional observa- referencing medical and pharmacy documentation.
tional study with data collection from medical case- An “initial assessment” was defined as the documen-
notes, and patient telephone survey. tation of subjective and objective examination without

Copyright © Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.


Physiotherapy Theory and Practice 303

treatment, whereas a “treatment” constituted docu- Data analysis


mentation of examination as well as a specific
hands-on intervention. For patients who had more This study was conducted over a period of 2 months
than one volume of medical records, all volumes were and used a convenience sample. Analysis was descrip-
recalled and reviewed. The time taken to fully review tive using medians, ranges, proportions, and flow-
and extract all data relevant to the current study charts to illustrate findings.
varied between subjects, but was approximately
60 minutes.
A patient survey was also undertaken via telephone RESULTS
interview Rachel Mullins. This comprised 45 ques-
tions and was able to be completed in less than Patient flow and demographics
20 minutes. It provided data on patients’ recall of
their inpatient stay in terms of the professions that pro- Flow of participants is shown in Figure 1. Twenty-
Physiother Theory Pract Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Michigan University on 10/28/14

vided care, as well as the specific physiotherapy under- seven patients were admitted to SCGH with
taken. Patients rated their satisfaction on a scale of 1–5 confirmed GBS during the study period. Of these,
(where 1 was highly dissatisfied and 5 was highly satis- one remained an inpatient and was excluded from
fied) with specific elements of physiotherapy such as data collection and two died; one as an inpatient as
the frequency and length of treatments, timetabling, a result of GBS and one as an outpatient with cause
and communication. unknown. Nineteen patients consented to participate
For personal use only.

FIGURE 1 Flow of participants through study.

Physiotherapy Theory and Practice


304 Dennis and Mullins

TABLE 1 Number (%) or median (range) for admission TABLE 2 Number (%) or median (range) for complications of
characteristics and medically documented symptoms of respondents, n = 23.
respondents, n = 23.
Patients, n (%) 20 (87)
Age (years) median (range) 49 (19–80) Number per patient, median (range) 1 (0–5)
Male, n (%) 14 (61) Low back pain, n (%) 14 (61)
Living in metropolitan area, n (%) 10 (43) Pulmonary embolus/DVT, n (%) 2 (9)
Independent at home with partner, n (%) 22 (96) Pneumonia, n (%) 5 (22)
Length of symptoms prior to acute hospital 3 (1–13) Fall, n (%) 5 (22)
admission (days) median (range) Pressure area, n (%) 1 (4)
Sudden onset weakness, n (%) 21 (91) Contracture, n (%) 1 (4)
Sudden onset sensory disturbance, n (%) 22 (96)
Flu symptoms, n (%) 19 (83)
Other respiratory symptoms, n (%) 6 (26)
Physiother Theory Pract Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Michigan University on 10/28/14

ICU requirement in view of respiratory 7 (30)


compromise, n (%) ventilation was required in six cases (86%). The dur-
Mechanical ventilation required, n (%) 6 (86) ation of full mechanical ventilation was 37 hours
Myalgia symptoms, n (%) 12 (52) (median, range 10–201), with an additional 83 hours
weaning (median, range 32–222) using pressure
support ventilation. A tracheostomy was required in
six of the ICU patients (86%) for 31 days (median,
range 13–167). Only five (83%) of these patients
in the study. A waiver of consent was granted to review were subsequently decannulated, one (20%) in ICU
and extract inpatient data from the medical notes of and four (80%) on the ward. Five patients (22%)
those patients who had died (n = 2) or who were required splinting of upper or lower extremities.
unable to be contacted for consent (n = 2). The Twenty patients (87%) developed complications
For personal use only.

result was a total of 23 patients included in this during their hospital stay (Table 2), with the most
study. The majority of patients were male (61%) common being low back pain (61%). No data were
non-smokers (74%) who were fulltime students or collected relating to the severity of low back pain, or
employed (74%). There were slightly more patients the extent to which it persevered or interfered with
from country areas (57%) compared with metropoli- subsequent rehabilitation. Only one patient (4%)
tan and the most common presenting characteristics developed contracture, and one other (4%) developed
were sensory disturbance (96%) and weakness a pressure area.
(91%). Baseline demographic and admission charac- All 23 patients had an initial assessment documen-
teristics of the cohort are shown in Table 1. ted by physiotherapists. Physiotherapy is summarized
in Table 3. The majority of patients had a respiratory
initial assessment (70%) by day 2 (median, range 1–8)
Characteristics of hospital stay and range of movement exercises (87%) by day 3
(median, range 1–8). A mean number of five different
In terms of the provision of drugs, Intragram was physiotherapists attended each patient in ICU (SD
administered to the majority of patients (96%) com- 4.2) and on the ward (SD 6.2), with 15 (median,
mencing day 1 (median, range 1–9 days) for 5 days range 1–81) occasions of service in ICU and 10
(median, range 4–10 days). Both gabapentin (39%) (median, range 1–307) on the ward. The total dur-
and steroids (30%) were administered to less than ation of all physiotherapy in ICU was 7.2 hours
half of the cohort. (median, range 0.75–29.7) and 9.9 hours (median,
All 23 patients exhibited some degree of motor range 0.5–220) on the ward. In terms of mobilization,
weakness during the decline phase. The majority only 18 patient records (78%) had clear documen-
had significant sensory loss (83%), respiratory tation as to when patients were first sat out of bed,
muscle involvement (74%), and cranial nerve involve- the median being day 4 (range 1–11). Physiotherapists
ment (65%). Only five patients (22%) demonstrated were most commonly first to mobilize patients to sit on
significant hypersensitivity. Spirometry was under- the edge of the bed, stand, transfer, and walk (83%,
taken in 19 patients (83%), with 15 (79%) of these 82%, 81%, and 90%, respectively).
undergoing subsequent spirometry every 6 hours or Separation data are shown in Table 4. Overall hos-
more frequently. pital length of stay was 20 days (median, range 5–198)
Intensive care unit transfer was required for seven and 13 patients (56%) required transfer for extended
patients (30%). The duration of ICU stay was 9.2 rehabilitation. One patient died secondary to GBS in
days (median, range 0.75–22.6) and mechanical the inpatient setting.

Copyright © Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.


Physiotherapy Theory and Practice 305

TABLE 3 Number (%) or median (range) for physiotherapy Patient telephone survey
management of respondents, n = 23.
The majority of patients surveyed remembered their
General examination documented, n (%) 23 (100)
ward stay and physiotherapy staff (84%). Their recall
Initial assessment (days) median (range) 2 (1–5)
Subsequent frequency of examination
of the personnel involved in their care is summarized
Twice daily, n (%) 6 (26) in Table 5. The majority could differentiate between
Daily, n (%) 14 (61) health professionals (79%) and remembered specific
Less frequently, n (%) 3 (13) nursing (79%), medical (79%), and physiotherapy
Respiratory examination documented, n (%) 16 (70) (85%) personnel.
Initial assessment (days) median (range) 2 (1–8) Physiotherapy was received by 16 surveyed
Subsequent frequency of examination/
patients and their satisfaction with components of
treatment
Twice daily, n (%) 2 (12)
physiotherapy is summarized in Table 5. Nearly all
were satisfied with overall physiotherapy care (87%),
Physiother Theory Pract Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Michigan University on 10/28/14

Daily, n (%) 10 (63)


Once, n (%) 4 (25) the frequency (88%), and length (94%) of treatment,
Functional examination documented 23 (100) and the overall timetabling and reliability of treat-
Initial assessment, n (%) 17 (81)a ment (81%). Most patients were satisfied with the
Requirement for aids, n (%) 10 (59)b effectiveness of physiotherapy (75%), and they were
ROM, n (%) 10 (43)
unanimously satisfied with physiotherapists’ profes-
Provision of ROM exercises, n (%) 20 (87)
Implementation (day) median (range) 3 (1–8)
sionalism, and their ability to gain rapport and trust
Frequency (daily), n (%) 17 (85) (100%). The majority were satisfied with the infor-
Nature of ROM exercises mation provided by the physiotherapist regarding
Passive, n (%) 2 (10) outcome (87%), the team approach adopted (81%),
Active or active assisted, n (%) 14 (70) and the level of involvement of family in management
Both active and passive, n (%) 4 (20)
For personal use only.

(63%).
Subsequent changes in functional level 18 (86)a
Three patients, all men from country areas were
described, n (%)
Nil contractures noted subsequently, n (%) 17 (74)
unsatisfied with the effectiveness of physiotherapy.
Improvement phase Two had significant past medical histories (including
First improvement documented anywhere 6 (2–34) depression and alcoholism) and underwent prolonged
(days) median (range) hospital stays (188 and 37 days), one including inten-
Lung and strength treatment combined, 12 (67)c sive care and mechanical ventilation. Both patients
n (%) also sustained a considerable number of compli-
Respiratory function limiting functional 8 (35)
cations including pulmonary embolus, pneumothor-
rehabilitation, n (%)
Service delivery
ax, pneumonia, low back pain, and a fall, and both
Occasions of service (n) median (range) 12 (1–341) remained functionally dependent on transfer to a sec-
Total length of all treatments (hours) 10 (0.5–241) ondary hospital for further rehabilitation following
median (range) acute hospital stay. They received a combined
255 hours over 371 occasions of physiotherapy
Note: ROM, range of movement.
a
n = 21 as two patients fully ventilated and sedated.
during their acute stay. The other patient was up mo-
b
n = 17 requiring aids. bilizing by day 2 with the nursing staff, had only one
c
n = 18 documented. 40-minute session of physiotherapy, and was dis-
charged home after 3 days.
Another three patients, two men and one woman,
were unsatisfied with the involvement of their family by
physiotherapy. Their history and clinical course was
TABLE 4 Number (%) or median (range) for separation data of
respondents, n = 23. each quite different, although none required intensive
care admission. Two were from the country and one
Duration of hospital stay (days) median (range) 20 (5–198) was from the metropolitan area. There was variable
Discharge plan documented (days) median 9 (5–163) length of hospital stay (6, 18, and 21 days), and frequency
(range) (5, 8, and 21 treatment occasions) and amount of phy-
Direct discharge home, n (%) 9 (39) siotherapy (120, 355, and 950 minutes). All patients
Requiring transfer to rehabilitation facility, n (%) 13 (56) were able to undertake active or active-assisted range of
LOS rehabilitation facility (days) median (range)a 21 (6–218)
motion exercises within 2 days of admission. Two were
Death due to GBS during inpatient stay, n (%) 1 (4)
discharged home and one was discharged to a rehabilita-
a
Data only available for 11 patients. tion facility.

Physiotherapy Theory and Practice


306 Dennis and Mullins

TABLE 5 Number (%) for respondent recollection of personnel (n = 19) and satisfaction with physiotherapy (n = 16).

Strongly disagree Disagree Unsure Agree Strongly agree

I remember…
• my stay on the ward 0 0 3 (16) 2 (10) 14 (74)
• my stay in ICU, n = 4 0 0 0 1 (25) 3 (75)
• differentiating health professionals 0 1 (5) 3 (16) 4 (20) 11 (59)
• nursing staff 0 0 4 (21) 7 (37) 8 (42)
• medical staff 0 0 4 (21) 8 (42) 7 (37)
• physiotherapy staff 1 (5) 0 2 (10) 6 (32) 10 (53)
I was happy with physiotherapy…
• overall care 0 0 2 (12)a 2 (12)a 12 (75)
• treatment
Physiother Theory Pract Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Michigan University on 10/28/14

• frequency 0 2 (12)a 0 6 (38) 8 (50)


• length 0 0 1 (6) 4 (25) 11 (69)
• timetabling 0 1 (6) 2 (12)a 1 (6) 12 (75)
• reliability of timetabling 0 1 (6) 2 (12)a 1 (6) 12 (75)
• effectiveness 2 (12)a 1 (6) 1 (6) 3 (19) 9 (56)
• professionalism 0 0 0 3 (19) 13 (81)
• level of rapport and trust 0 0 0 2 (12)a 14 (88)
• treatment information 0 0 2 (12)a 5 (31) 9 (56)
• outcome information 0 2 (12)a 1 (6) 5 (31) 8 (50)
• team approach 0 1 (6) 2 (12)a 2 (12)a 11 (69)
• involvement of family 0 3 (19) 3 (19) 3 (19) 7 (44)a

Note: Only 16 of the 19 patients surveyed actually received physiotherapy treatment.


For personal use only.

a
Percentages of patients rounded down.

DISCUSSION the illness relating to their physiotherapy care. Results


demonstrate that satisfaction was high across all facets
This observational study provides an overview of inpa- of physiotherapy management and that physiothera-
tient case management including physiotherapy for pists were well recognized and remembered during hos-
GBS patients at a single site. It further provides data pitalization. This concurs with a recent Norwegian
relating to the GBS patients’ satisfaction with attending study (Normann, Moe, Salvesen, and Sørgaard,
physiotherapists. The findings are that in this cohort: 2012) where patients with multiple sclerosis reported
a high level of satisfaction with physiotherapists regard-
ing interpersonal and clinical skills, information, and
1 GBS patients receiving physiotherapy were most instruction. Although the often insidious onset of mul-
often satisfied across all domains with the phy-
tiple sclerosis differs markedly from the sudden
siotherapy service provided.
deterioration seen in GBS, the acute and sub-acute
2 Physiotherapists were involved in all patients’ care, neurological deficits may be comparable.
and were most commonly the first to mobilize
Of interest was the group of patients who were not
patients out of bed.
satisfied (18%) with the effectiveness of physiotherapy.
3 Low back pain occurred as a common complication It is possible that in two of these cases, past medical
in more than half of the cohort.
history and slow functional recovery may have
impacted on their ability to rate the effectiveness of
Significant gaps in the evidence base in rehabilita- physiotherapy highly. In the other case, where there
tion practice for persons with GBS have been identified was early mobilization by staff other than physiother-
(Khan et al, 2010), including a failure to incorporate apy, relatively quick recovery, and discharge home,
the perspective of the person with GBS. Although it may be that the relevance and importance of
studies have explored the GBS patient’s personal physiotherapy to this individual was overshadowed
experiences of falling ill (Forsberg, Ahlström, and by the natural recovery process.
Holmqvist, 2008) and their overall satisfaction Also of interest is the group of patients who were not
(Forsberg, de Pedro-Cuesta, and Widén Holmqvist, satisfied (18%) with the involvement of their family by
2006), to our knowledge, this is the first quantitative physiotherapy. The explanation of why this was so is
study to explore and report on the satisfaction of more difficult to discern, as they followed quite differ-
patients who have undergone acute management of ent individual clinical courses and had variable

Copyright © Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.


Physiotherapy Theory and Practice 307

physiotherapy input and functional outcome. It may be Limitations


that there was a mismatch between what was reasonably
expected and what could reasonably be delivered. One limitation of this study is the small number of
Researching the complex intervention of “rehabili- patients in a single-site cohort. Although this limits
tation” in the GBS patient population is problematic, the extent to which results may be generalized, there
because although the basic characteristics of clinical were positive trends, particularly relating to patient
presentation (muscle weakness, sensory disturbances, satisfaction.
and respiratory compromise) are consistent, there may There are also those limitations inherent with a
be a wide range of disability levels requiring an indivi- retrospective chart review including missing data, par-
dualized approach according to the resources available ticularly relating to muscle charting in this population.
across different programs and populations (Khan et al, Non-uniform data collection procedures were mini-
2010). In this study, all patients were reviewed by mized by having a standardized data collection form
physiotherapy, whatever the level of disability. This and survey, and the same individual review case
Physiother Theory Pract Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Michigan University on 10/28/14

finding in itself may be considered atypical as there notes and conduct interviews. This may have in itself
is literature to suggest that not all patients receive phy- introduced another limitation, in that respondents
siotherapy (Carroll, McDonnell, and Barnes, 2003; knew they were talking to a physiotherapist during
Davidson, Wilson, Walton, and Brissenden, 2009). interview, and this may have created a positive bias.
Despite the fact that patients were mobilized out of It was however made clear to them that the interviewer
bed relatively early, there remained a high rate of at had had no prior contact with them during their acute
least one significant complication among the cohort, inpatient stay.
which may be explained, at least in part, by prolonged
bed rest. An inability to independently reposition
has been shown to alter cutaneous pain perception CONCLUSION
(Angel, Bril, Shannon, and Herridge, 2007; Lowthian
For personal use only.

and Parish, 2007) and cause neurophysiological dys- This study provides insight into the extent of phy-
function in critically ill patients (Fletcher et al, 2003), siotherapy in the acute GBS setting, and the patient’s
with contributing factors including compressive nerve satisfaction with services provided. More controlled
injury and muscular morphological changes. While multi-centred trials are required to add to the body
these and other effects of bed-rest are outlined else- of knowledge supporting the use of physiotherapy
where (Needham 2008; Winkelman 2009), it may be and associated modalities in the treatment of GBS,
that disorders such as GBS that are associated with where there is thought to be considerable natural
inflammatory neuropathy, neuropathic pain, muscle recovery.
weakness, immobility, hypersensitivity, and loss of
independent function increase complication risk.
Of particular interest was the number of GBS Acknowledgments
patients who developed LBP during their acute admis-
sion. Current literature (Heneweer, Vanhees, and The authors gratefully acknowledge Charley Budgeon
Picavet, 2009; Schiltenwolf and Schneider, 2009) (Statistician, University of Western Australia) for her
describes a U-shaped correlation between physical statistical analysis and Tracy Beckwith and Leanne
activity and self-reported low back pain whereby both Cormack (Senior Physiotherapists, Physiotherapy
physical activity and inactivity can represent a back Department, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital) for
pain risk factor. Although this fits with the character- their general collaboration and review of the manu-
istics of this inactive cohort, it may be only part of the script. This study was funded by the SCGH Research
problem. Studies (Belavý et al, 2011; Ferreira, Ferreira, Advisory Committee and supported by the SCGH
and Hodges, 2004; Hodges and Richardson, 1996; Research Foundation.
Hodges and Richardson, 1998) have indicated that in-
effective muscular stabilization of the lumbar spine is Declaration of interest: The authors report no
highly correlated with the incidence of low back pain. conflict of interest.
As GBS is characterized by moderate to severe
muscle weakness or paralysis, this correlation may
also explain the incidence of LBP in this cohort.
REFERENCES
Importantly, the other perhaps more predictable
musculoskeletal complications including muscle Angel MJ, Bril V, Shannon P, Herridge MS 2007 Neuromuscular
shortening/joint contracture and pressure areas were function in survivors of the acute respiratory distress syndrome.
less evident in this cohort. Canadian. Journal of Neurological Sciences 34: 427–432

Physiotherapy Theory and Practice


308 Dennis and Mullins

Belavý DL, Armbrecht G, Richardson CA, Felsenberg D, Hides JA Heneweer H, Vanhees L, Picavet HS 2009 Physical activity and low
2011 Muscle atrophy and changes in spinal morphology: Is the back pain: A U-shaped relation? Pain 143: 21–25
lumbar spine vulnerable after prolonged bed-rest? Spine 36: Hodges PW, Richardson CA 1996 Inefficient muscular stabilization
137–145 of the lumbar spine associated with low back pain. A motor
Bernsen RA, de Jager AE, van der Meché FG, Suurmeijer TP 2005 control evaluation of transversus abdominis. Spine 21:
How Guillain–Barre patients experience their functioning after 1 2640–2650
year. Acta Neurologica Scandinavica 112: 51–56 Hodges PW, Richardson CA 1998 Delayed postural contraction
Bersano A, Carpo M, Allaria S, Franciotta D, Citterio A, Nobile- of transversus abdominis in low back pain associated with
Orazio E 2006 Long term disability and social status change movement of the lower limb. Journal of Spinal Disorders 11:
after Guillain–Barré syndrome. Journal of Neurology 253: 46–56
214–218 Hughes RA, Cornblath DR 2005 Guillain–Barre syndrome. Lancet
Bussmann JB, Garssen MP, van Doorn PA, Stam HJ 2007 Analys- 366: 1653–1666
ing the favourable effects of physical exercise: Relationships Hughes RA, Rees JH 1997 Clinical and epidemiologic features of
between physical fitness, fatigue and functioning in Guillain– Guillain–Barre syndrome. Journal of Infectious Diseases 176
Barré syndrome and chronic inflammatory demyelinating poly- Suppl 2: S92–S98
Physiother Theory Pract Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Michigan University on 10/28/14

neuropathy. Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 39: 121–125 Khan F, Ng L, Amatya B, Brand C, Turner-Stokes L 2010 Multi-
Carroll A, McDonnell G, Barnes M 2003 A review of the manage- disciplinary care for Guillain–Barre syndrome. Cochrane Data-
ment of Guillain–Barré syndrome in a regional neurological base of Systematic Reviews10: CD008505
rehabilitation unit. International Journal of Rehabilitation Kuitwaard K, Bos-Eyssen ME, Blomkwist-Markens PH, van Doorn
Research 26: 297–302 PA 2009 Recurrences, vaccinations and long-term symptoms in
Chang AT, Boots R, Hodges PW, Paratz J 2004 Standing with GBS and CIDP. Journal of the Peripheral Nervous System 14:
assistance of a tilt table in intensive care: A survey of Australian 310–315
physiotherapy practice. Australian Journal of Physiotherapy 50: Lowthian P, Parish LC 2007 Bedrest and cutaneous pain receptors:
51–54 An important relationship? Skinmed 6: 214–217
Davidson I, Wilson C, Walton T, Brissenden S 2009 Physiotherapy Merkies IS, Schmitz PI, van der Meché FG, Samijn JP, van Doorn
and Guillain–Barré syndrome: Results of a national survey. PA, Inflammatory Neuropathy Cause and Treatment (INCAT)
Physiotherapy 95: 157–163 Group 2002 Quality of life complements traditional outcome
Ferreira PH, Ferreira ML, Hodges PW 2004 Changes in recruitment measures in immune-mediated polyneuropathies. Neurology
For personal use only.

of the abdominal muscles in people with low back pain: 59: 84–91
Ultrasound measurement of muscle activity. Spine 29: 2560–2566 Needham D 2008 Mobilizing patients in the intensive care unit: Im-
Fletcher DD, Lawn ND, Wolter TD, Wijdicks EF 2000 Long-term proving neuromuscular weakness and physical function. JAMA
outcome in patients with Guillain–Barré syndrome requiring 300: 1685–1690
mechanical ventilation. Neurology 54: 2311–2315 Normann B, Moe S, Salvesen R, Sørgaard KW 2012 Patient satis-
Fletcher SN, Kennedy DD, Ghosh IR, Misra VP, Kiff K, Coakley faction and perception of change following single physiotherapy
JH, Hinds CJ 2003 Persistent neuromuscular and neurophysio- consultations in a hospital’s outpatient clinic for people with
logic abnormalities in long-term survivors of prolonged critical multiple sclerosis. Physiotherapy Theory and Practice 28:
illness. Critical Care Medicine 31: 1012–1016 108–118
Forsberg A, Press R, Einarsson U, de Pedro-Cuesta J, Holmqvist Rees J, Thompson R, Hughes R 1998 Epidemiological study of
LW 2005 Disability and health-related quality of life in Guillain–Barre syndrome in south-east England. Journal of
Guillain–Barré syndrome during the first two years after onset: Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry 64: 74–77
A prospective study. Clinical Rehabilitation 19: 900–909 Rekand T, Gramstad A, Vedeler CA 2009 Fatigue, pain and muscle
Forsberg A, de Pedro-Cuesta J, Widén Holmqvist L 2006 Use of weakness are frequent after Guillain–Barre syndrome and polio-
healthcare, patient satisfaction and burden of care in Guillain– myelitis. Journal of Neurology 256: 349–354
Barre syndrome. Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 38: Ropper AH 1992 The Guillain–Barre syndrome. New England
230–236 Journal of Medicine 326: 1130–1136
Forsberg A, Ahlström G, Holmqvist LW 2008 Falling ill with Guillain– Rudolph T, Larsen JP, Farbu E 2008 The long-term functional
Barré syndrome: Patients’ experiences during the initial phase. status in patients with Guillain–Barre syndrome. European
Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences 22: 220–226 Journal of Neurology 15: 1332–1337
Garssen MP, Bussmann JB, Schmitz PI, Zandbergen A, Welter TG, Schiltenwolf M, Schneider S 2009 Activity and low back pain: A
Merkies IS, Stam HJ, van Doorn PA 2004 Physical training and dubious correlation. Pain 143: 1–2
fatigue, fitness, and quality of life in Guillain–Barré syndrome Winkelman C 2009 Bed rest in health and critical illness: A body
and CIDP. Neurology 63: 2393–2395 systems approach. AACN Advanced Critical Care 20: 254–266

Copyright © Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.

You might also like