Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Evaluate The Quality Characteristics of Shea Butter and Palm Kernel Oil
Evaluate The Quality Characteristics of Shea Butter and Palm Kernel Oil
INTRODUCTION
Worldwide, natural plant oils are increasingly becoming important in cosmetics, nutrition and
commerce because they are sources of dietary energy, antioxidants, biofuels and raw material
Plant oils such as shear butter and palm kernel oil have long been used on the skin for
cosmetic and medical purposes because they have been found to have many positive
physiological benefits. For example, the application of shea butter and palm kernel oil may
act as a protective barrier to the skin by an occlusive effect, allowing the skin to retain
Shea butter is a natural creamy-coloured fatty product made from the nut products of Shea
tree (Butyrospermum parkii or "butter seed") and has a large number of applications. The
Shea tree grows normally in the wild Savannah belt over 20 nations across West Africa
(Addaquaye, 2004). Shea butter is extracted from the kernels of the sheu tree (Vitellaria
paradoxa). Shea butter is composed of triglycerides with oleic, stearic, linoleic, and palmitic
fatty acids, as well as unsaponifiable compounds (Maranz et al., 2014). Shea butter is
frequently used in the cosmetic industry due to its high percentage of the unsaponifiable
fraction (e.g., triterpenes, tocopherol, phenols, and sterols), which possesses potent anti-
inflammatory and antioxidant properties (Maranz and Wiesman, 2014). In the study of
effects through inhibition of iNOS, COX-2, and cytokines via the NF-κB pathway (Verma et
al., 2012). Additional research on AD has shown that the cream containing shea butter extract
such as Niger Delta and South Eastern parts of Nigeria (Warra, 2011). The palm kernel oil is
extracted from the walnut which has a hard hill or shell called kernel. It is also called lauric
oil because it has high content of lauric acid (William and Odom, 2015) the extraction of
palm kernel oil is made by various techniques and the obtained oil is used in the food
domain as well as non-domains. In the food domain, it is used in the preparation of certain
traditional dishes and enter also in the constitution of food fats. In the non-food domain, its
higher proportion of lauric acid gives to the oil an important characteristics used in the
industries of beauty care and soap factory. This property also characterizes, its use in
traditional pharmacopoeia (Warra, 2011). The acceptability of the products at world edible oil
market depends on its ability to satisfy basic standard tests for fats and oil (Yonas, 2014).
kernel oil (Lands, 2015). There is strong evidence that some compounds inherent in these oils
can be of benefit for good health, particularly with regard to cardiovascular disease, brain
development and function, arthritis and various other chronic inflammatory diseases
(Harwood and Caterson, 2016). Recently, there has been progress in elucidating the
mechanisms by which these oils exert this effect at the molecular level (Bordoni et al., 2017),
where they reduce the metabolism of n-6 fatty acids to pro-inflammatory mediators, produce
inflammatory cytokines and enzymes (Harwood and Caterson, 2016). The current study seeks
to proffer solutions to the increasing interest on this field by conducting an evaluation of the
i. To determine the medicinal value and health benefits of shea butter and palm
kernel oil.
ii. To determine the fatty acid present in shea butter and palm kernel oil.
iii. To assess the anti-inflammatory and anti-oxidant properties of fatty acids present
i. The findings from this study would reveal some usefulness of shea butter and palm
ii. The study would encourage the use of locally produced shea butter and palm kernel
iii. The findings from the study can also serve as a resourceful reference material for
LITERATURE REVIEW
Gaertner Karl (1807), who was a German botanist first named the Shea tree as Vitellaria
paradoxa and it belongs to the Sapotaceae family (Caroline et al., 2009). In 1961, it was
relabeled as Butyrospermum parkii (Maranz et al., 2003), with the “parkii” making reference
to Mungo Park (1771-1805), “who was the truly amazing Scottish traveler presenting Shea
butter to Europe” (Goreja, 2004). Some journals use Butyrospermum parkii, while many
others use V. paradoxa which is the currently approved name for the African Shea trees. The
Western Africa trees could be the subspecies “paradoxa” and the Eastern Africa one as
Masters et al. (2004), reported Shea trees growing across a 5000 km wide belt of savanna
such as from Senegal (West) to Sudan, Ethiopia, Uganda (East) and across the African
Region. The Shea tree develops normally in the dry Savannah belt and semi-arid areas
(Masters et al., 2004). The 19 countries in which Shea is found across the continent of Africa
are Benin, Ghana, Mali, Niger, Nigeria, Senegal, Chad, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Central
African Republic, Ethiopia, Guinea Bissau, Cote D’Iviore, Sierra Leone, Sudan, Togo,
This savanna belt is generally known as “Shea belt” among investors (Ferris et al., 2001).
The Shea tree usually develops to a normal size of about 15 m (height) with excessive
branches and a dense wax-like and greatly fissured bark that makes it fire resistant. The West
African Sub-Region where majority of Shea plants are found and where Shea products can be
found are shown in Figure 2.1. Amongst these nations, Ghana and Burkina Faso are
Figure 2.1: Cross-cutting Shea producing countries in Africa ranging from Senegal
The map zeros-in on the West Africa Sub-Region where the bulk of shea trees occur
and where Shea products can be found. The high shea production countries are Ghana,
Nigeria, Mali, Togo., Burkina Faso, Benin and, Cote d’Ivoire. Northern Ghana is
singled out as being one of the main sources of high quality Shea.
Plate 2.1: Shea tree Plate 2.2: Ripe Shea fruits
Plate 2.3: Fresh Shea nuts Plate 2.4: Dry Shea Nuts
2.1.2 Benefits of the Shea Industry: The uses of Shea and Shea products.
According to Paulsen (1981), the value of Shea tree follows the value of palm oil in Africa.
The Shea tree is the second most important oil plant and as it develops in areas unsuitable for
palm tree growth, it takes on primary importance in West Africa. In the early Nineteen
seventies, the value of the Shea to the economic system of Ghana increased extremely when
it was stated that, “it was one of only six plant varieties whose vegetable fat can be used in
the production of Cocoa Butter Equivalents (CBEs), in candy as well as being a valued
The Shea butter together with the oil palm represents significant resources of edible oil for
many houses in many areas of the Sahel Africa (Ndukwe et al., 2007; Chaffin, 2004).
Typically unprocessed prepared Shea butter is purchased from “loaves” in market places and
in cases where the Shea butter are prepared properly and wrapped in leaves, they are resistant
to oxidative rancidity and can be kept for years if not exposed to heat and air (Chaffin, 2004).
The Shea butter is also used as raw material for the manufacture of margarine, detergent and
Different enteric attacks such as dysentery, diarrhoea, helminthes and other digestive system
attacks, skin illnesses and injury attacks may perhaps be treatable by different parts of the
Shea tree such as leaves, roots, seeds, and others (Soladoye et al., 1989). Local healers use
Shea butter as a treatment for rheumatism, swelling of the nose, nose blockage, leprosy,
coughing, and minimal bone tissue dislocation (Tella, 1979; Badifu, 1989; Goreja, 2004;
Olaniyan and Oje, 2007). When Shea butters are produced and are of low quality, they are
smeared on earthen surfaces of homes which provides as water resistant to secure surfaces
during rain (Fluery, 1981). After circumcision of new born male child, treatment can be
multiplied using Shea butter and it can also be used to prevent stretch-marks in African
expectant mothers and as a bug resilient, offering protection against Simulium disease
(Goreja, 2004).
2.1.2.2 Use of Shea butter in the international market.
Shea butter enjoys its use as an element of aesthetic remedies (Akihisa et al.,
2010) and as an alternative for cocoa butter in chocolate sectors (Ogbonnaya and Adgidizi,
2008) although distinction in flavour has been noticed (Fold, 2000). In the chocolate market,
Shea butter is enhanced and deodorized to be used usually as Cocoa Butter Equivalents
(CBEs) since 1960s with its likeness in actual qualities to a more costly cocoa butter
(Alander, 2004). CBEs are plant fat which have identical and substance qualities to cocoa
butter containing no lauric acidity, and are mixable with cocoa butter in every amount
without changing the qualities of cocoa butter (Hee et al., 2013). Under the European Union
However, in the U.S, products that contain CBEs are not permitted to be called “chocolate”
(Lovett, 2004).
The drug market has taken advantage of the effectiveness of Shea butter as it is used as an
element in the treatment of inflammatory related illnesses due to its antiinflammatory action
(Masters et al., 2004). It has also been used to create solution to herpes lesions, joint disease,
acne, and to reduce blood cholesterol stages by a drug company, BSP Pharmaceutical
(Masters et al., 2004). High stages of unsponifiable matters have been revealed in Shea butter
as in comparison to other vegetable fats and oils (Alander, 2004). This results in more
possibilities to create Shea butter products showcasing “Shea butters’ therapeutic qualities
such as anti-oxidant, anti-inflammatory and other supposed activities” (Maranz et al., 2004).
2.2 Physical Properties of Shea Butter
According to Olaniyan and Oje (2007), moisture content decreases as heat temperature rises.
Moisture content of oil must be low, this is because oil with great moisture content are
inclined to recontamination or rancidity. The reported moisture contents of Shea butter vary
from 0.1% (Olaniyan and Oje, 2007) to 66 4.9% (Honfo et al., 2013).
This is the point at which Shea butter exist as oil. According to Alander and Andersson
(2002), Shea butter melts at approximately 3 oC – 35 oC depending on the variety and quality
of the nut from which the oil was extracted. Melting point 38.0 oC – 39.5 oC was observed as
2.2.3 Viscosity
According to Olaniyan and Oje (2007), Shea butter has an optimum viscosity of about 100
Yellow is the dominant colour of Shea butter at all heating temperatures. Heating above 90 oC
Refractive index varies with chain length, degree of saturation and to the ratio of cis/trans
double bonds. Hence, specific refractive index of fat and oils can be used for identification,
As a plant fat, Shea butter constitutes approximately about 90% of triglycerides and a minor
unsaponifiable fraction (Hee et al., 2013). The emollient properties of Shea butter are
attributed to the triglycerides it contains, while the unsaponifiable fraction is responsible for
Shea butter’s medicinal properties as it contains the bioactive substances that include
Fatty acids usually dominates Shea butter constituency and its composition includes palmitic
(16:0), stearic (18:0), oleic (18:1), and linoleic (18:2) acids. Stearic and oleic acids constitutes
40 – 45% of total fatty acids respectively and the range of 5 – 10% constitutes linoleic acid,
palmitic acid follows at 4% (Alander, 2004) with lower amounts of arachidic acid and others.
Shea butter contains relatively high amounts of saturated fatty acids in comparison with grape
seed oil, olive oil and canola oil which have saturated fatty acids less than 20% of total fatty
acids (Samman et al., 2008). The grape seed oil (total saturated fatty acids: 10.4 – 14.3% of
total fatty acids), olive oil (12.7 – 16.2%), and canola oil (5.5 – 7.7%) are generally liquid at
room temperature (Baydar et al., 2007; Damodaran et al., 2008; Samman et al., 2008). The
high amount of saturated fatty acids in Shea butter is responsible for its solid to semi-solid
state at room temperature. Shea butter fatty acids were found to vary across the African
Unsaponifiables are identified as substances which dissolves in fat and are insoluble in
aqueous solution but soluble in organic solvent after saponification (Hamilton and Rossell,
1986). Unlike the triglyceride fraction which comprises a larger part of the Shea butter,
unsaponifiables usually comprises only a small part of the Shea butter. Shea butter contains
The range by weight of unsaponifiables in Shea butter is 4 - 11% (Hamilton and Rossell,
1986; Lipp and Anklam, 1998; Alander, 2004). For many years now, research has
continuously been done on the unsaponifiables of plant oils and fats due to their various
portion of Shea butter is taken over mostly by triterpene alcohols, followed by hydrocarbons,
sterols, and other minimal components such as vitamin E (Itoh et al., 1974; Lipp and
2.4 Quality Control of Shea Butter: Available Standards For Shea Butter
ProKarité, a project managed by the World Agroforestry Centre and funded by CFC/FAO
quality standard for unrefined Shea butter. It is also approved by UEMOA (Union
Economique Monétaire Ouest Africaine) (Lovett et al., 2005). The ProKarité which is like a
regional standard board has proposed sensory, physical and chemical characters that define
These qualities includes: colour, odour, taste, moisture, free fatty acids, peroxide value,
insoluble impurities, volatile matters, relative density, refractive index, saponification value,
unsaponifiable matters, iodine value, melting point and soap content (Hee et al., 2013). This
organization has developed a grading system using the most important quality characters for
Shea butter.
Palm kernel oil is an edible plant oil derived from the kernel of the palm fruit (Ekweis
guineensis) (Hartley, 1997). Palm kernel oil which is semi-solid in non-temperature, is more
saturated than palm oil and comparable to coconut oil. It is very stable at high cooking
temperatures thereby being the best for commercial cooking. It can be stored longer than any
other vegetable oil. It is high in lauric acid (Poku, 2002). Palm kernel oil does not contain
cholesterol or trans fatty acids. Resembling coconut oil, palm kernel oil is packed with lauric
fatty acids (C H O ) and 12 24 2 therefore suitable for the manufacture of soaps, washing
powders and other personal care products. Lauric acid helps in quick lathering. A good soap
must contain 15% laurate for good lathering while soap made for sea water usage virtually
The palm kernel oil is highly different from palm oil. The two oil from same fruit are entirely
different in fatty acid composition and properties. Palm kernel is an important bio product
from oil palm mill/processing. Plant palm kernel constitutes about 45% - 48% by weight of
oil in which properties and characteristics are quite different from palm oil rather resembles
coconut oil (Gbasonuzo et al. 2012). The major fatty acid (lauric (C ) 12 accounts for about
48% of the fatty acid composition. Other constituents of palm kernel oil includes 16%
Palm kernel oil is used in manufacturing both edible and non-edible products has a great use
both in food industry and non-food industry (Oyinlala et al. 2004). Food usage of palm kernel
oil is more saturated and so can be in regenerated to wide range of products for the food
industries. It can be used alone or in blend with other oil for manufacture of cocobutter
substances, confectionary fats, biscuit dough's, filling cream, cake icing, and table margarine
(Bredeson, 1983). Palm kernel oil is known to confer special attractive physical features and
aroma to bakers of bread and other bakery products. It is also used in making chocolate and
some other related food products. It is used at home cook industry for cooking different types
of food.
Palm kernel oil can be directly combined with petrol diesel or use in making biodiesel for
diesel engines. Locally, Africans use the oil to fuel native lamps for lighting in rural
communities that are not connected with electricity (Shaver, 2005). It is used in making
grease/lubricants for machines, use in product plastics, use in drilling mud for petroleum
industry, printing inks, rubbe rs, pharmaceuticals products e.t.c. (Butcher, 2005). The process
involved in production of palm kernel oil are selection of good palmkernel-nuts, crushing the
nuts with the nutcrusher, heating the seeds with the mechanical seed fryer so as to excite the
oil molecules the transferring the heated – crushed nuts to the oil press. The oil pressing
machine presses the heated seeds and expels the oil content of the seeds through the oil exit
chamber and at same time expels the cake through the cake exit chamber (Oyinlala et al
2004). The crude oil is. collected in drum of high capacity or over head tanks and left to
settle. Since the sludge (sediments) or residue is denser than the oil, it settles below the oil.
Then the oil can then be collected over the residues and under goes further purification to
Palm kernel oil has many uses which include the following [3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12].
ii. The oil could be used to serve as lubricants and emulsifiers, ingredient in paint
confectioneries.
v. Palm kernel oil is extensively used to make soap. In fact, lauric acid from the oil
when boiled with alkali is used to make soap of the best quality due to its superior
lathering characteristics.
vi. The oil is used to produce glycerol as a bye-product of soap making process.
viii. Locally, the black oil extracted by the roasting process is used medicinally for
convulsion concoction.
ix. Residue cakes from palm kernel oil extraction are used for livestock feed
formulation, because apart from carbohydrates and fats the cake contains proteins.
x. Palm kernel oil could be modified and used as non petroleum-based alternative
fuel.
2.5.2 Composition of palm kernel and oil
Palm kernel is composed of oil, protein, cellulose, ash, some non nitrogenous matter, and
water (Table 2). The palm kernel oil itself consists of free fatty acids, volatile matter,
According to [14], [15] as reported in [16], characteristics such as free fatty acids (f.f.a.),
peroxide value (pe-value), thiobabituric acid (TBA) value, iodine value, saponification value,
colour, viscosity, refractive index, specific gravity, etc. are used in evaluating the quality of
vegetable oils. The free fatty acid is a good indicator of the level of degradation by
hydrolysis. The peroxide value is a measure of active oxygen in 1kg of oil, that is, it is a
measure of stability of the oil. The TBA is a secondary oxidation test used for detecting
incipient oxidation of lipids. The iodine value expresses the unsaturation level of the oil. The
triglycerides constituting the oil. Free fatty acid (f.f.a.) and peroxide values in vegetable oils
are often seen as quality parameters in the commercial transactions. High levels of f.f.a. are
associated with degradation by hydrolysis and high refining losses. It should be less than 5%
according to [17]. High peroxides are associated with rancidity development, and the value
Palm kernel oil extraction methods can be classified into three, namely: the traditional
i. Traditional roasting method: This method employs the principle of rupturing of oil
glands by heating. In this method, palm kernels are put into a clay pot and heated
over a fire. At a high temperature, oil is released by the kernels and is collected.
ii. Traditional pressure methods: The traditional pressure methods include the
following:
iii. Hand Pressing: Where crushed kernels are wrapped in cloths and hand pressed to
iv. Stone and lever pressing: Where wrapped, crushed kernels are pressed using devices
v. Pestle and mortar pressing (Ghanis method): The mortar is fixed to the ground while
the pestle driven by one or a pair of animals is inserted in the mortar to crush the
kernels by friction and pressure, and the oil runs out through a hole at the bottom of
the mortar.
vi. Traditional aqueous method: Where crushed or ground kernels are boiled in water to
liberate oil which floats on the water surface. The oil on the surface is scooped with
mug into another pot. The recovered oil is then heated to remove the water.
In this method, ground kernels are treated with a solvent which dissolves or washes the oil
out of the ground kernel. The pure oil is then obtained by evaporation of the solvent.
Solvent extraction processes can be divided into three main unit operations: kernel pre-
treatment, oil extraction, and solvent recovery from the oil and meal. For smallscale
operations, the solvent extraction process is an alternative for high capacity mills. However
Mechanical extraction involves several processes as shown in Fig. 7 and there are three basic
steps: (a) kernel pre-treatment, (b) screw-pressing, and (c) oil clarification. In these methods,
mechanical compressive forces are used to separate oil from solidoil systems under
permitting conditions. The mechanical methods of oil expression include the following:
2.5.4.4 Hydraulic pressing method
This method is based on the principle that pressure applied to a confined body of fluid is
used to press out oil from ground kernels. A modern hydraulic press consists of a stack of
horizontal boxes inside each of which is placed a batch of ground kernel particles wrapped in
a cloth. The stack of boxes is compressed by a hydraulic ram, and the oil moves out through
The screw press consists of a series of continuous worms built on a steel shaft that rotate
within a perforated housing and operates against a restricted opening. The worm flights
provide the means of conveyance for the kernels being processed. The conditioned kernels
are fed through a hopper into the housing and are forced along as the screw rotates,
compressing and heating up the mass. The heating and the crushing facilitate oil extraction
[7].
CHAPTER 3
Shea butter and palm kernel oil for the study were obtained from Eke market, Ishiagu in Ivo
Fatty acid composition of shea butter and palm kernel oil were analyzed by Gas
chromatography (Fisons, fitted with a flame ionization detector [FID]) using the method
described by Morrison and Smith (2014). The fatty acid methyl esters prepared using 14%
BF3 in methanol were separated on a fused silica capillary column (25 m 0.25 mm, Parma
bond FFAP-DF-0.25, Machery Negal GmbH Co., Duren, Germany). Individual fatty acid
was identified by comparing with the retention times of standards (Reena & Lokesh, 2011).
10 mg of oil was dissolved in 3 ml of hexane. 30 ll of aliquots were used for analysis. The
antioxidant values of the samples were determined by PCL as per the instructions provided
by the manufacturers of the instrument (Photochem, Analytik Jena, Germany) and results are
Sensory evaluation was determined by distributing score to twenty (20) panelist which will
comprise of lecturers from Home and Rural Economics department to evaluate the sensory
characteristics of the shea butter in terms of color, aroma, and texture were assessed upon
arrival of the samples. Color of the samples was visually assessed. Aroma or note was
assessed by smelling each sample. Texture was assessed by applying the shea butter on the
9 – Like extremely
8 – Like strongly
7 – Like moderately
6 – Like slightly
4 – Dislike slightly
3 – Dislike moderately
2 – Dislike strongly
1 – Dislike extremely
Results are represented as means ± standard deviation for each group. The data was analyzed
by one way ANOVA followed by a post hoc Tukey test to compare the control and treatment
groups; P-values less than 0.01 were considered as statistically significant. All statistical
analysis was performed using SPSS statistical software package version 20.