Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Sociological Analysis of The Utilization of Social Media in Women Migrant Workers in Developing Social Entrepreneurship
A Sociological Analysis of The Utilization of Social Media in Women Migrant Workers in Developing Social Entrepreneurship
A Sociological Analysis of The Utilization of Social Media in Women Migrant Workers in Developing Social Entrepreneurship
Published By:
Retrieval Number: L38641081219/2019©BEIESP Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
DOI: 10.35940/ijitee.L3864.1081219 & Sciences Publication
4662
International Journal of Innovative Technology and Exploring Engineering (IJITEE)
ISSN: 2278-3075, Volume-8 Issue-12, October 2019
The Social Entrepreneurship Network of WMWs who Table 3. Entrepreneurship social network of women
have returned to their hometowns migrant workers in Kuripan Village and Jambenenggang
Networks have an important role in the Village.
implementation of social entrepreneurship. Analysis of social Region Bonding Bridging Linking
entrepreneurship digital networks in the current study uses the Wonosobo Women Microeconomic Labor and
(Kuripan migrant business actors: Transmigration
concept : bonding, bridging and linking (20). Bonding is in Village) worker Wonosobo batik, Agency of
the context of ideas, relations, and attention which are community Wonosobo UMKM Wonosobo, SARI
inward-looking, connecting family members, neighbors, close Wonosobo actors, snake fruit Social Analysis
friends, and business partners. Bridging is inclusive and farmers, coffee and Research
farmers, sweet Institute, the
outward looking, playing the role as a bridge for people or potato and cassava Regent of
communities in equal economic and political status. Linking farmers Wonosobo,
is outward looking with communities with economic and BNP2TKI
political statuses from various levels. The three concepts are
Sukabumi Migrant Minimarket Labor and
applied by WMW in developing social entrepreneurship and
(Jambenengg worker entrepreneurs, Transmigration
improving the existing business network. Bonding is related ang Village) community foodstuff sellers, Agency of
to relationships within the community which bonds and Sukabumi Indosat Wonosobo, SBMI
unifies them in both social and economic activities. Bridging (Indonesian
in the WMW community in Kuripan Village is characterized Migrant Worker
Union)
by building collaborations with other communities with equal
WMW in Jambenenggang Village were more involved
levels. The communities reached were migrant worker
in networks on the individual and group level. Collaborations
communities in Cilacap, Solo, and Semarang. Linking is very
with external parties were still scarce due to various
beneficial for the development of the community and is a
limitations. One of these was the limited organizational
means to share experiences, especially those related to
culture in migrant workers who worked in Middle Eastern
economic endeavors. The development of collaborations
countries. The situation in Middle Eastern countries limits the
between the community and a number of organizations and
freedom for organizations and networks among migrant
institutions has made it easier for them to access the market,
workers and with other parties. This condition was poles apart
for instance by participating in product fairs outside of
from the situation enjoyed by migrant workers in Asia Pacific
Wonosobo Regency. The position of Bonding, Bridging and
countries such as Hongkong and Taiwan who are given free
Linking are fairly significant in developing the WMW’s
rein in forming organizations and to network, especially
social entrepreneurship. WMW in Jambenenggang Village
during their days off. There are also a fairly large number of
had an almost similar bonding with those in Kuripan Village,
women migrant workers that have formal education, enabling
differing only in the linking and bridging aspects and that they
an improvement of knowledge and experience. Moreover,
were not as intensive or as widespread as the network built by
Asia Pacific countries such as Singapore, Hongkong, and
WMW in Kuripan Village. These can be seen in the table 3.
Taiwan have entrepreneurial work ethics. The employers of
The digital era has given a novel insight in relation to WMW are mostly entrepreneurs who give motivation to the
the Putnam concept of social networks [21]. Digital media women to also become entrepreneurs once they return to their
creates an opportunity to strengthen the social bonds in a hometowns.
community. This bond will be stronger if there are common
needs among women migrant workers. The digital media
community bond is preceded by naturally formed local bonds
(Gemeinschaft). The digital media network will spread the
social network and improve the bonds regardless of
geographic boundaries. A digital group community can
become a medium for communication and can mobilize the
community more effectively. All the information related to
women migrant worker activities is disseminated and
discussed within the group. From observations in this
particular WhatsApp group, economic activities which are
community-oriented was the most frequently visited topic.
This digital group often discussed plans for holding fairs
together to market the community products. All forms of
activities were also planned in this group. The production of Figure 1. Social Network Units and Levels.
local delicacies such as instant tiwul, plantain chips, and snake
The chart above explains that social network media is
fruit dodol which go through production chains from raw
found at various levels in life. In the first level, which is the
materials to the finished products was discussed in this
foundation of the social structure, is individual relationships.
WhatsApp group. Therefore, the distribution of raw materials
At the individual level, WMW generally have communication
and finished products could be quickly and effectively
devices such as smartphones or Android-based phones. In this
handled through this medium. From observations of the
level, almost all migrant workers have Android-based phones
WhatsApp group, the discussion and communication flow was
egalitarian even though a formal hierarchical structure existed
in this group in the real world.
Published By:
Retrieval Number: L38641081219/2019©BEIESP Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
DOI: 10.35940/ijitee.L3864.1081219 & Sciences Publication
4664
International Journal of Innovative Technology and Exploring Engineering (IJITEE)
ISSN: 2278-3075, Volume-8 Issue-12, October 2019
The devices most commonly used by women migrant remittance) gleaned from Asia Pacific countries were higher
workers were smartphones, iPhones and Android-based than that of Middle Eastern countries. Those working in Asia
phones, which are becoming more and more technologically Pacific countries had higher incomes than those working in
advanced. The smartphones are equipped with GPS and Middle Eastern countries. (2) Digital social media digital
Internet services for web browsing. Using these devices, could accelerate social entrepreneurship developed by WMW
women migrant workers could run various economic who have returned to their hometowns. The result of this study
enterprises and businesses. The community bond grew supports the theory by Van Dijk who stated that digital social
stronger because discussions and communication could be media can transcend the social structure existing in the
held wherever and whenever needed. The mastery and society. WMW, who were before considered a marginal
possession of digital technology and the mastery of both the group, are able to build social networks through social media
devices and the applications are strongly linked to the for the development of social entrepreneurship. The results of
economic remittance and social remittance during their this study also contradict Massey's theory that international
employment abroad. Through the ownership of digital migration would occur continuously. This was due to the
technology devices such as notebooks, tablets, computers, development of social entrepreneurship which is supported by
digital printing, and digital cameras, a number of economic social media, providing alternative job opportunities in the
and social activities were conducted. In the case of mobile migrant workers’ hometowns. The suggestions are that there
phones, for example, women migrant workers who worked in need to be preparations for prospective WMW who are
Asia Pacific countries were familiar with this technology even planning on working abroad to prepare for management of
before the technology became a trend in Indonesia. remittances, financial literacy training, and intensive digital
Applications they used were online trade business sites, technology training. The Government could apply digital
online trade, Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and WhatsApp. technology an integrated social entrepreneurship in the
The practices found were entrepreneurship, development of country.
business networks through online media, establishing
international language courses, building libraries for children, ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
developing tourism attractions, and innovations in local
foods. Activities such as clothing design, food product First authors thank for BUDI-DN 2016 of LPDP and RISTEK
packaging design, online networking, online marketing, and
online transactions were very much supported by digital REFERENCES
technology. 1. Martin SF. United Nations Division for the Advancement of
Table 6. The typology of the two study locations based on Women. Polit Geogr. 2003;2(4):1–31.
2. Hakim A. Survival Strategy of Former Women Migrant
their use of media, migration intensity, and their Workers(Case Study of Former Mowen Migrant Workers
connection with social entrepreneurship. Kaliwedi Cirebon District). Widyariset [Internet].
2011;14(1):257–65. Available from:
Internationa migration intensity http://widyariset.pusbindiklat.lipi.go.id/index.php/widyariset/art
Typology Category (economic and social remittance) icle/view/412
Low High 3. M Kolopaking L. International Lifestyle Migration and Social
Use of Low Jambenenggang, marginalization on the Tourism Village. Sodality J Sosiol
social Sukabumi Pedesaan. 2016;4(1):38–47.
media (social 4. Osili UO. Remittances and savings from international migration:
(intensity, entrepreneurship Theory and evidence using a matched sample. J Dev Econ.
scope, and less developed) 2007;83(2):446–65.
role) Fairly high Kuripan, 5. Tadjuddin NE. Worker mobility, remittances and business
Wonosobo opportunities in the Village. J Ilmu Sos dan Ilmu Polit.
(social 2004;8(2):213–30.
entrepreneursh 6. Irawaty T, Sri Wahyuni E. Migrasi Internasional Perempuan Desa
ip developed) Dan Pemanfaatan Remitan Di Desa Pusakajaya, Kecamatan
Pusakajaya, Kabupaten Subang, Provinsi Jawa Barat. Sodality J
The table above explains that the more often a migrant Sosiol Pedesaan. 2015;5(3):297–310.
worker goes abroad, the higher the economic and social 7. Ros A, González E, Marín A, Sow P. Migration and information
remittance. The intensity has a fairly significant effect on the flows. A new lens for the study of contemporary international
development of social entrepreneurship. The use of social migration. Work Pap Ser. 2007;3(7):1–37.
8. Oiarzabal PJ, Reips UD. Migration and Diaspora in the Age of
media also had a significant effect on the development of Information and Communication Technologies. J Ethn Migr
entrepreneurship. The development of social Stud. 2012;38(9):1333–8.
entrepreneurship in Jambenengang Sukabumi was not 9. Hunter A. Empowering or impeding return migration? ICT,
optimum because the use of media not as intensive and the mobile phones, and older migrants’ communications with home.
Glob Networks. 2015;15(4):485–502.
WMW’s departures were less frequent and were limited to 10. Platt M, Yeoh BSA, Acedera KA, Yen KC. Renegotiating
Middle Eastern countries, especially Saudi Arabia. On the migration experiences: Indonesian domestic workers in
other hand, in Kuripan Village Wonosobo, the development Singapore and use of information communication technologies.
of social entrepreneurship was quite rapid due to the New Media Soc. 2016;18(10):2207–23.
11. Yang D. International migration, remittances and household
migration intensity and frequent use of social media.
investment: Evidence from Philippine migrants’ exchange rate
shocks. Econ J. 2008;118(528):591–630.
IV. CONCLUSIONS 12. Wahba J, Zenou Y. Out of sight, out of mind: Migration,
entrepreneurship and social
The conclusion of the present study is that (1) the capital. Reg Sci Urban Econ
departure frequency and the destination country determined [Internet].
the benefits and income. The knowledge benefits (social 2012;42(5):890–903.
AUTHORS PROFILE
Eko Wahyono, S.Sos., M.Si, Doctoral Program of
Author-1 Department of Communication and Community
Photo Development Sciences, Faculty of Human Ecology, IPB
University, Bogor,. Publications :
Digital Networking and Social Entrepreneurship
Development Female Migrant Workers, research work :
Sociology, Communication
Published By:
Retrieval Number: L38641081219/2019©BEIESP Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
DOI: 10.35940/ijitee.L3864.1081219 & Sciences Publication
4666