Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research Paper
Research Paper
Research Paper
Nigeria.
of Ado-Ekiti, Nigeria.
This research article investigated home and school related factors as determinant of
indiscipline among Secondary School Students in Ibadan North East Local Government
Area of Oyo State.
The study adopted the descriptive research of the survey and ex-post facto types. The
population of the study consisted of all the Senior Secondary School Students in Ibadan
North East Local Government Area of Oyo State.
The sample comprised of 300 students that fall within ages thirteen (13) to sixteen (16)
comprising both male and female in the fifteen (15) selected Local Government Areas
using simple sampling technique. A self designed questionnaire titled ‘Home and School
Related Factors and Indiscipline among Secondary School Students’ (HSRFISSQ) was
used for data collection. The data collected were analyzed using face and content
validity. Test re-test method was adopted to ensure the reliability of the instrument with
the co-efficient 0.78. The data collected were analyzed using descriptive statistics. The
findings revealed that teachers who cannot be easily approached or do not really
understand the subject matter have significant effect on the students indiscipline,
findings also showed that the economic status of parents, family relationship and peer
group influences the indiscipline behaviour exhibited by students. It is therefore
concluded that discipline of students is very crucial to the growth of Secondary
i
education, hence teachers, parents all other stakeholders in the education sector should
ensure that students are disciplined.
Based on the findings of the study,it was concluded that teachers should be encouraged
to be more attentive to their students, school counselors should make issues concerning
students confidential so as to gain the trust of students and parents should be more
observant and be good role models for their wards.
Keywords: Home factor, school factors, indiscipline, discipline, school facilities, peer
INTRODUCTION
The family is the smallest unit of socialization and as the saying goes that charity begins at
home the behaviour a child is familiar with at home develops into what the child does after
he might have left the home. Various behaviours exhibited by students in schools have their
foundation from what is done around the child. So also students cannot rise above the quality
of their teachers and as role models they also affect the behaviour of the students they teach.
Indiscipline has for some time been an issue of concern for educators, policy makers and the
public at large but the situation has not been as worrisome as it is today, more especially
among secondary school students in Nigeria. It has been observed that there was a total
absence of indiscipline in schools at the secondary level across the country until a few years
before independence. The reason was that shortages of school places made pupils realize that
good behaviour at all times was an assurance for continuity in school. According to Kelly
(1999) the aim of education in Nigeria as elsewhere was to produce good men and women
capable of earning a useful life and of playing a constructive part as citizens in local and
international affairs. The system of formal education laid emphasis on the acquisition of
knowledge, practical skills and sound character. This view is supported by Ojedapo (2011)
who points out that most of the schools in the past were voluntary agency schools. There
ii
was a high degree of discipline in schools then. There was also harmony as principals,
The problem of indiscipline according to Yaroson (2004) permeates all facets of the life of
man and has brought man down to his knees. School discipline according to Gaustard (2005)
has two main objectives. The first is to ensure the safety of staff and students and the second
students’ misconducts involving violent and criminal behaviour defeat the goals of education.
providers and consumers could hatch a monster that will be difficult to exterminate
(Idu&Ojedapo 2011, and Tunor 2002). Minor samples of the envisioned problems are already
being encountered in the nation’s economic front. Many indeed believe that current economic
woes arising from corruption, robbery, killing, smuggling and pipeline vandalism are issues
of school indiscipline. Court injunctions and orders are indiscriminately flouted not only by
those who make or interpret the law, but also by those who took the oath to defend the law.
These acts of indiscipline in our national life likely began as a seed of disobedience in the
school.
The problem of indiscipline in secondary schools is not particular to Nigeria alone there have
been cases of indiscipline in different parts of the world including Europe, Asia, Australia,
Africa , Atlantica, North and South America .Cases of indiscipline have also been noted in
England where students engage in shooting and killings. The government then planned a
restriction on school indiscipline by giving schools authorities to search pupils for weapons.
According to the then Education Secretary, Hon. Charles Clarke, schools should be
encouraged to arrange for surprise police searches of the premises to reduce the problem of
indiscipline (BBC, UK version, 2004, Nov.18). UNESCO (1998) noted that unruly
iii
classrooms around the world had reached a very alarming proportion. According to their
USA, one student was reported dead and 30 wounded in a shooting associated with
indiscipline, while in Kobe-Japan a school child was killed by a fourteen year-old. Killings,
physical attacks, robberies, attempted arson and fighting between children which end in
tragedies have been making headlines all over the world. School indiscipline that involves
knives, baseball bats, marijuana, guns and even bombs have become common. Incidents are
The foregoing and current issues make school indiscipline a very important matter in our
armed robbery, rape, cultism, examination fraud and many other unruly behaviours which
make headlines in our print and electronic media (Vanguard, 2006; Ogwuda 2006; Komolafe
and Ajao 2006). Other misdemeanours may not be so widely reported yet their occurrences
are at higher frequencies in our schools and this is the reason why one has to look into the
various causes if indiscipline among students and the means by which these causes can be
The parental influence, teachers and childhood experiences are considered important factors
that are responsible for child’s development intelligence and discipline. Discipline in schools
is essential for effective learning, good teacher relationship and peer adjustment. A
democratic form of discipline leads to a healthy classroom environment that in turn promotes
respect for education and a desire for knowledge Ovell (2001). Mutua (2004) in her research
study on students unrest and indiscipline reported that discipline is considered vital for
students’ academic and social success. A good academic qualification without a good basis of
discipline of the individual is of no use to the individuals, their families and the society. The
society devotes heavily in the education of its people. A positive correlation between
iv
discipline and academic performance was found in the study showing that students that are
The behaviour of secondary school students is a reflection of the type of home they come
from and school they attend and these behaviour can either be positive or negative and is
later transferred into the larger society. The teacher’s attitude, home factors, school
facilities and peer pressure etc may either enhance students discipline or hinder discipline
of senior secondary school students. The problem of indiscipline affects all schools
irrespective of gender and school type though the degree and magnitude vary from school
to school cases of violence though less common, occur more often outside than on school
premises this behaviour may affect the family, performance of students in school, and the
society at large as such students will become too difficult to manage both at home and in
the school.
Against this background it is important to access home and school factors and understand
Indiscipline seems to have become a grave issue at the present level of secondary
education in Oyo State especially at Ibadan North East Local Government Area. The
home and school environment to a certain degree are contributing factors to indiscipline
truancy among others. However, there are other factors responsible for indiscipline in
these schools, namely: inadequate continuous dialogue between students and teachers,
poor management skills by the administrators and teachers, peer and mass media
influence. All these factors have a lot of influence on how well disciplined a student is.
v
It is for this reason that this study investigates the effect of home and school related
This study examines the extent to which home factors and school factors have contributed to
school, economic status of parents, family size and relationship as well as peer group have
Methodology
The study adopted the descriptive research of the survey and the ex post factor.
The population of the study includes all senior secondary students that fall within the ages
thirteen (13) to sixteen (16) comprising of both male and female in all the secondary schools
in Ibadan north east local government area of Oyo state. There are twenty eight (28) senior
secondary schools and a total of thirteen thousand and eighty (13080) senior secondary
The multistage sampling technique was used to select the sample for the study at the
firsts stage fifteen schools were randomly selected from the twenty eight {28}
secondary schools in the local government area. The second stage involved the use of
purposive sampling was used to select science students in selected secondary schools,
at the third stage the simple random sampling was used to select twenty {20} students
that fall within the ages thirteen {13} to twenty {20} in the selected secondary
vi
The research instrument for this study was a questionnaire tagged ‘Home and School Related
The researcher constructed the questionnaire after a careful review of some literature related
to the study. The questionnaire consisted two sections A and B. Sectin A consisted of simple
questions on demographic data such as school, age and sex while section B contained items
The rating scale was based on a 4-point likest scale ranging from Strongly Agree (4) points
Agree (3) points, Disagree ( 2) points and Strongly Disagree (1) point.
The validity of the instrument was ensured by subjecting the instrument to screening by
experts in the areas of educational management. The experts determined the appropriateness
recommendation and modification, the instrument was restructured and modified. The test re-
outside the sample twice within the interval of two weeks and the result correlated using the
Pearson’s moment correlation coefficient and a coefficient of 0.78 was obtained. This co-
efficient was considered high enough for the reliability. The instruments for the study was
administered by the researcher and five trained research assistants. Data collected for the
study were analyzed using descriptive statistics which includes frequency percentages, mean
vii
Table 4.1.1: Distribution of Respondents by sex
Sex Frequency Percentage
Male 135 45
Female 165 55
Total 300 100
Table 4.1.1 above revealed that 55% (165) of the respondents are female while the remaining
percentages 44% (135) are male. This indicates that there are more female than male
respondents in the study.
viii
taken as “Agree” while any mean lower that 2.5 was taken as “Disagree”. The hypothesis was
tested at 0.05 level of significance.
Research Question 1: To what extent does teacher’s attitude influence indiscipline among
secondary school students in Ibadan north east local government?
Table 4.2.1:
S/ Item SA A D SD Mean Std.
N Dev.
1. My teachers do not give 74 91 76 59 2.60 1.063
due attention to welfare of
(24.7% (30.3% (25.3%) (19.7%
students
) ) )
2. Little or no attention is 61 105 63 70 2.53 1.061
paid to students problems
(20.3% (35.3% (21%) (23.3%
by teachers in school
) ) )
3. Teachers in my school 63 100 73 64 2.54 1.048
often ignores students
(21%) (33.3% (24.3%) (21.3)
complaints
)
4. I talk and gist with my 85 137 45 33 2.91 0.932
friends whenever I am
(28.3% (45.7% (15%) (11%)
bored during classes
) )
5. I hardly talk to my 78 131 50 41 2.82 0.972
teachers on issues
(26%) (43.7% (16.7%) (13.7%
concerning my school
) )
work
The table above revealed that 55% (165) of respondents agreed that their teachers do not give
due attention to welfare of students. 55.6% (166) of them agreed that little or no attention is
paid to students problems in their schools. 54.3% (163) claimed that teachers in their schools
often ignore students’ complaints.
Also, 74% (222) of the respondents agreed that they talk and gist with their friends whenever
they are bored during classes. 70% (209) of them claimed that they hardly talk to their
teachers on issues concerning their school work.This indicates that the attitude of teachers in
public schools really influence indiscipline among secondary school students in Ibadan North
East local Government. These attitudes demonstrated by teachers may be as a result of the
poor remuneration and lack of motivation to work, if government can put in place merited
ix
promotional packages which will in turn motivate teachers to be more effective and efficient
towards their work will consequently have a positive implication on teachers attention to
students welfare.
Research Question 2: How do available facilities in the schools affect the discipline of
secondary school students in Ibadan north east local government?
Table 4.2.2:
S/N Item SA A D SD Mean Std.
Dev
Table 4.2.2 above showed that 71% (214) of the respondents agreed that inadequate
infrastructural facilities make students to behave unruly. 77% (231) of them claimed that
inadequate provision of laboratory and workshop equipment makes students to behave
unruly. 62% (185) of the respondents agreed that they can sneak in and out of classroom
because their classroom does not have doors.
x
Also, 54.2% (157) of the respondents disagreed that they sometimes decide to stay away
from school because they do not feel at ease. 50% (150) of the respondents agreed that
dilapidated buildings in their schools provide a hiding place for them when they decided not
to attend classes.
The findings above shows that available facilities in schools affect the discipline of secondary
schools students in Ibadan North East local government area of Oyo State to a greater extent.
If there are adequate provision of instructional materials, good infrastructure, laboratories
sport arena and convenient atmosphere for learning in public schools, students will find
school more conducive and vices such as loitering, truancy and sneaking out during lessons
will be curbed.
Research Question 3: To what extent does the economic status of parents have effect on the
Table 4.2.3:
N Dev
regularly because my
(20.7%) (23%) (35%) (21.3%)
parents do not provide
xi
3. I come to school with 97 83 69 51 2.75 1.085
school
4. My parents give me more 10 36 203 51 2.02 0.625
that belong to my
(16.3%) (27%) (34.7% (22%)
classmates because I do not
)
have them.
56.3% (169) of the respondents disagreed that they do not go to school regularly because
their parents do not provide necessary materials for them. 56.3% (169) of them also disagreed
that sometimes they go out to hawk to get money for their family when they ought to be in
school. 60% (180) of them agreed that they do come to school with empty stomach and this
Also, 84.7% (254) of the respondents disagreed that their parents give them more than they
need so they have excess to buy things they want. 56.7% (170) of them disagreed that
sometimes they take things that belong to their classmates because they do not have them.
The findings of the study reveals that the economic status of parents have effect on the
discipline of secondary school students in Ibadan north east local government. This maybe
workable ages in Nigeria and these problem can be addressed through the provision of jobs
and sources of livelihood for individuals within employable ages. The aftermath of these will
xii
be parents being able to cater for the needs of their children thereby limiting their exposure to
Research Question 4: How does the family size and family relationship affect the discipline
Table 4.2.4:
Dev
1. My parents often quarrel 49 63 113 75 2.29 1.017
the family.
3. I get away with unruly 122 50 77 51 2.81 1.145
behaviour because my
(40.7%) (16.7%) (25.7%) (17)
parents can’t read or write.
4. My parents hardly have 62 92 79 67 2.50 1.055
living together my
(21%) (31%) (28%) (19.7%)
behaviour would have
been better
62.7% (188) of the respondents disagreed that their parents often quarrel and fight at home.
59.3% (178) of them disagreed that when they do wrong their parents do not punish them.
xiii
57.4% (172) of them agreed that they get away with unruly behaviour because their parents
In addition, 51.4% (154) of the respondents agreed that their parents hardly have time for
them while 52% (156) of them agreed that if only their parents are living together their
This indicates that family size and family relationship affect the discipline of secondary
school students in Ibadan north east local government of Oyo State. Large family size is can
should organize public awareness programme using the media and social media to sensitize
the populace about the ills of having more children than they can adequately cater for this
will consequently lead to reduced birthrates which will enable parents have time to spend
with each of their children and also involved in their everyday life.
Research Question 5: What is the level of relationship between the peer group students
belongs to and the indiscipline behaviour exhibited by secondary school students in Ibadan
Table 4.2.5:
n Dev
1. My behaviour changed 66 87 90 57 2.54 1.035
xiv
to night parties at school (24.7%)
51% (153) of the respondents agreed that their behaviour changed because they want to be
like their friends. 58% (174) of them disagreed that they often decide to stay away from
school with their friends. Also, 58.3% (175) of the respondents disagreed that they often go
In addition, 55.3% (166) of them disagreed that sometimes they go against their own will to
please their friends and 53.2% (159) of them disagreed that their friends are their role models
and they can go any length to make sure they are acceptable among them.
The findings above revealed that peer group students belongs to do have positive relationship
with the indiscipline behaviour exhibited by secondary school students in Ibadan north east
local government. This means that peer group students belongs to influences the indiscipline
behaviour exhibited by secondary school students in Ibadan north east local government.
DISCUSSION
xv
The result from this research work shows that the attitude of teachers in public schools really
influence indiscipline among secondary school students in Ibadan North East local. Teachers
who cannot be easily approached or do not really understand the subject they are teaching
affects the discipline of the students they teach.
The findings also showed that that available facilities in schools affect the discipline of
secondary schools students in Ibadan North East local government area of Oyo State to a
greater extent. Students whose schools have dilapidated buildings tends to develop
indiscipline acts as such buildings serve as hideouts for them whenever they want to be
absent from lessons. Some classrooms in secondary schools do not have doors, this
encourages the students to move in and out of the classroom at will.
The result also reveals that the economic status of parents have effect on the discipline of
secondary school students in Ibadan north east local government. Parents who engage their
children in hawking during school hours encourage indiscipline among students. Such
students as labelled as truants, some students also engage in stealing from their classmates as
The findings from this work also indicates that family relationship affect the discipline of
secondary school students in Ibadan north east local government of Oyo State. A family that
fights, uses abusive languages all the time and shows no respect towards one another breeds a
child that fights, uses abusive languages in school and also shows no respect to both teachers
and classmates.
Another key finding from this work also reveals that the peer group students belongs to
influences the indiscipline behaviour exhibited by secondary school students in Ibadan north
east local government. The type of friends an adolescent keeps will have either negative or
Based on the findings in this study, the following conclusions were made:
xvi
1. The attitude of teachers in public schools influence indiscipline among secondary school
The number of available facilities in schools affect the discipline of secondary school
students, schools with dilapidated buildings encourage sneaking out of classroom and
The economic status of parents have effect on the discipline of secondary school students.
The type of relationship that exists within the family a secondary school student belongs to
Recommendations
1. It was recommended that education policy makers should inculcate core values of
discipline when formulating educational policies that will be of value to them so that policy
implimentators will be able to understand the causes of indiscipline and how best to handle
them from the home perspective. The Ministry of Education should encourage teachers at
school to be more attentive of their students. This will assist timely discovery of a disturbed
2. Teachers should be more understanding of their students by realizing that they come from
diverse backgrounds and have different needs emotionally and materially.The Ministry of
Education should develop a curriculum in the form of civic education for the general public
on how to improve their livelihood through self-employment. This can be done by giving
parents the information that their economic status may affect the level of discipline that their
children displayed in school. With this information, parents will be better equipped to
xvii
3. School councilors should counsel both students and their parents on proper behaviour that
should be exhibited in the presence of their children and home activities that can lead to
indiscipline of students is itemized. Guidance and counselling office should have an open
door policy where students can be comfortable to open up with no fear that their issues will
4. Parents should pay attention to their children so that the best will be brought out in them
and how parents can curb their wards from indiscipline acts and behaviour. It will also
encourage parents to live by example, because whatever habit they have will be copied by
their children.
5. The government should encourage parents to pursue further education, both formally and
informally. This will enable them to understand the needs of their children even as they
grow and get into advanced institutions of learning. A parent who has attended schools of
higher levels of education is better qualified to advice and prepare his/her child for the same
than the person who has no previous experience. These parents are better prepared to put
demands on their children that facilitate a healthy home environment. Also, parents should
be willing to change their parenting style as their children moves from childhood to
adulthood so that child-parent relationship will be adopted which will lead to more of
References
Nigeria Limited.
Alidzulwi, T. A. (2000). The role of parents in values education with special references to the
xviii
Amaele, S (2007) Moral Values in Nigerian Education: Issues, Problems and Prospects.
Bounty Press.
Publishers Limited.
Ajayi T, Shofoyeke A (2003). School Discipline, Teachers Attitude and Ethics of the
programme
Atanda, A.I & W.O. Lameed. (2006). Fundamentals of school organisation and classroom
Week, 23(37):3.
Donga, M.M., (1998). The causes and consequences of indiscipline in public and independent
xix
Early Childhood Education Journal, 39(2), 161-167 http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10643-011-
0443-3.
Edwards, C.H. (2008). Classroom Discipline and Management. (5th ed.). United States:
Fafunwa, A.B. (1974). History of education in Nigeria. U.K; George Allen & Urwin Limited.
Famade A.O. (2001). Sociological foundations of education. Lagos, Nigeria: Pumack Nigeria
Limited.
Federal Ministry of Education (2009a). Roadmap for the Nigerian education sector. Abuja,
Nigeria.
Gara, P. & Davis U. C. (2006). Peer group influence and academic aspirations across cultural
groups of high school students. Centre for research on Education, Diversity, and
xx
Gaustad, J. (2005). School Discipline. Erick Digest from:
George, G.B. & Jeffrey, F.D. (2008). Discipline, a Primary Goal of Education, Helps
Getzel, J.W. and E.G. Guba, 1997. Social behaviour and the administrative process. School
http//crede.berkeley.edu/research/sfc/3.5_final.html.
Ibukun, W.O. (2009, 5th October). Build the Future: Invest in Teachers now. Paper
Ige, A.M. (2011). Challenges facing Early Childhood Care, Development and Education in
Ige, A.M. (2012). Myths and Reality of Falling Standard of Education in Nigeria: The Way
Forward.
Ige, A.M., & Olowolabi, S. (2010). Student Unrest in Tertiary Institutions in Nigeria: Causes
and Remedies. Journal of Educational Research and Development, 4(3), 137- 146.
action Sage Publications Ltd. 6 Bonhill Street London EC2A 4PU United Kingdom.
xxi
Komolafe, F. & Ajao, N. (2005). Nans Warns Students Against Thuggery. Vanguard, June
30.
Kruger, A. & Van Schalkwyk (1997). Classroom Management. 2nd ed. Pretoria: Van
Schaite Publisher.
educational district in central Trinidad: Thesis University of the West Indies. Faculty of
educational district in central Trinidad: Thesis University of the West Indies. Faculty of
180028341/peer-group-influence-and.htm.
Louw, E & Barnes, M. (2003). Stout kind: dis die ouers se skuld. Die Huisgenoot, 10-11.
Archeological Research.
Marzano, R.J., and Marzano, J.S., (2003). The key to classroom Management.
Mutua, J.N. (2004) Investigation into the Alternative Strategies of Discipline in the Absence
xxii
University on Nairobi, Nairobi.
Obadara, O.E. (2005). Perceived full-range leadership, teacher factors and the academic
Odubunmi, O. (1993): Student’s Perception of the Classroom Interaction for Learning at the
Ojedapo A.P. & D.O. (2011). Indiscipline in Secondary Schools: A cry to all Stakeholders in
change.
Onyechi, K.C, Okere A, and Trivellor,U (2007). Deviant behavior as correlate of academic
Onyechi, K.C, Okere A, and Trivellor,U (2007). Deviant behavior as correlate of academic
xxiii
Onyije, A.C. and Ojedapo, D.O. (2010): Guidance and Counseling Services for Achieving
Ovell, S. (2007) Discipline in Schools Online resource from Nalanda Institute. Retrieved
Palmer, M. (2008). Peer group influence and selection in adolescents school burnout:
Purkey, S. & Smith, M. (1983). Effective schools: A review. Elementary School Journal, 83:
335-351.
Rayment, T. (2006). Managing boys’ behaviour. New York: MPG Books Ltd.
Reeves, D.G (2004). Accountability for learning: how teachers and school leaders can take
Rossouw. J.P. (2003). Learner discipline in South African public schools. Koers, 68 (4),
413-435. Stoner, J.A.F. and Freeman, R.E (1992). Management. Fifth Edition London:
Prentice-Hall.
Thornberg, R., (2007). Inconsistencies in everyday patterns of schools rules. Ethnology and
xxiv
Thornberg, R., (2008). School children’s’ reasoning about school rules. Research papers in
University of Nigeria.
Tutamwebwa, K.T. (2006). Social economic effects of alcohol abuse on families in Bumbaire
Walsh, M.W. & Williams, G.R. (eds). (1997). Schools and family therapy. Springfield:
Charles C Thomas.
Wolhuter, C.C. & Steyn, S.C. (2003). An international perspective on learner discipline in
Yaroson, M.C. (2004). Strategies for Curbing Indiscipline in Nigerian Secondary Schools.
Yaroson, M.C. (2004, 9th-11th August). Strategies for Curbing Indiscipline in Nigerian
Yeh, M.Y. (2006). Factors associated with alcohol consumption problem drinking, and
and Clinical Neurosciences, 60, 46-54, retrieved April 24, 2007 from
xxv
http://www.Blackwellsynergy.com
xxvi