Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2017 Me 121
2017 Me 121
2017 Me 121
Contents
Problem Statement:.......................................................................................................................2
Abstract:.........................................................................................................................................2
1 Introduction:...............................................................................................................................2
1.1 Effects of Module temperature on PV module:....................................................................3
1.2 Effect of Wind Speed on Efficiency of PV module:..............................................................4
1.3 Copper Indium Gallium Selenide:.........................................................................................5
2 Methodology:...............................................................................................................................5
2.1 Manufacturer List:..................................................................................................................5
2.2 Selection of Manufacturer:.....................................................................................................6
3 Mathematical Modelling:...........................................................................................................8
4 Calculations:................................................................................................................................9
5 Results:.......................................................................................................................................12
5.1 Without Wind Effect:............................................................................................................12
5.1.1 Effect of Daily module Temperature only on Efficiency of PV module:.......................12
5.1.2 Effect of Temperature and Wind Speed on Efficiency of PV module:..........................13
5.1.3 Effect of Month on Parameters of PV module:................................................................15
5.1.3.1 Without Wind Effects:.....................................................................................................15
5.1.3.2 With Wind Effects:..........................................................................................................16
6 Discussion:.................................................................................................................................17
7 Social and Economic Benefits:.................................................................................................19
8 Environmental Effect and Sustainability:..............................................................................20
9 Life Quality Index:....................................................................................................................20
References:...................................................................................................................................21
Problem Statement:
Effect of Temperature and Wind Speed on Efficiency of PV Module.
Abstract:
Lower conversion efficiency of local house built solar photovoltaic PV module gave rise to test
new materials in order to improve the conversion efficiency. Higher module temperature and
wind speed are the two most renowned causes of this low efficiency system. So, proper analysis
of these two parameters for any particular location is always been the keen interest of scientists
and engineers, which otherwise can increase the financial risk of system installation. However,
testing of new materials also attracted the manufacturer and certain materials are introduced
which exceeds the local PV module in efficiency and cell life time. Copper Indium Gallium
Selenide (CIGS) is one of them, the future contestant of PV family which beaten the local PV
silicon module in efficiency and has great potential to take solar market in near future on large
scale. This study aims to conduct the case study of KARACHI based CIGS PV module power
plant of 300 kW capacity and 300 W power per plate. Effects of temperature and wind speed is
evaluated on the efficiency of PV module and it is inferred that wind effects have increased the
efficiency to 19.95% as compared to temperature effect only where the efficiency was 19.81%.
Data quality checked is applied to one-year measured data for Karachi and it is observed that
little variations were there but not too much so we have used the daily given data for sample
calculations. Annual energy produced will be evaluated and compared with the capacity factor of
same capacity. Then, based on having low-capacity factor, effect of temperature and wind speed
will be evaluated and leading parameters will be highlighted among them. Then, levelized cost of
electricity LCOE and Tariff would be examined. Then, social and economic impact of CIGS PV
module will be manipulated for KARACHI alongside with its impact on the environment and
sustainability. At the end, life quality index LQI will be evaluated for KARACHI city.
1 Introduction:
Sun is the basis of all the other form of energy on earth. In an hour, sun gives the enough energy
on the earth that could power our planet for entire a year. Yet, we are stuck in the non-renewable
energies. Also, non-renewable resources are depleted at much speed since the last four to five
decades and thus the world is shifting to solar and other renewable energy conversion system and
research area is highly practicing the new tests and new materials are being introduced that can
Energy Resources and Utilization 7th Semester 2
Muhammad Hamza CEP Assignment 2017-ME-121
convert sunlight to electricity more efficiently than the previous ones. According to report,
fossils fuels still have enough potential to produce 80% of the world’s energy by 2040 but they
will be greater source of GHG and lower Life quality index. Proper harnessing of renewable
sources can cut this percentage of GHG down and improve the LQI enough to survive. So, solar
systems are tested everyday so that future of coming generation is secured and they live better
quality of life. One common application of solar power plant is photovoltaic system which is the
most commonly and ever-growing market. It directly converts sunlight into electricity and ready
to use.
Now, we have to understand the complete science of PV working so that effective environment,
cost benefits and social and economic benefits can be harnessed in a better way. So, our first
priority will always be cost effective, maximum energy generation and more capacity factor. So,
we should have a look at factors affecting the performance of PV module, so that controlling
these can give us maximum energy, low cost in producing a unit of electricity and more capacity
factor. Two of the main factors are
Wind Speed
T m−T a
Q loss=
RL
Higher the temperature difference, higher will be the heat losses. Like other semiconductors
devices, solar panels are also sensitive to temperature.[2] Due to little rise in temperature,
bandgap between the molecules gets weaker and electrons find enough energy to start traveling.
[3] This travelling result more heat and higher temperature encourages this transformation. So,
little rise in temperature result in more electrons to travel freely and dissipate their energy in the
waste heat and electricity conversion rate goes down.[4]
Also, higher cell temperature degrades its life time and cell got higher and more thermal stresses
are produced in the PV cell at higher temperature.[5] The material we are using CIGS for our
solar system has coefficient of power is -.0045/K which means for every 1 unit rise in module
temperature, its power goes down by .0045. From the radiation falling onto a PV panel only up
to 20% of the incident solar energy is converted to electricity. Remaining part is converted to
heat.[6, 7]
module temperature that reduces the convection heat transfer losses and increases the efficiency
of module.[9]
It seems out that wind is the cure of the 1 st problem associated with the module temperature. So,
efficiency of solar panels can be increased by
Installing the panels few foots above the roof above so that wind can pass through that
easily and reduce the plate temperature and causes increase in power output and
efficiency.
Choke the panels if temperature goes too high to not allowing damages to the lifetime of
panels.[2]
2 Methodology:
Four to five manufacturers are selected against the parameters provided and the properties of
their CIGS panels are recorded in the table 2 below. Due to new research potential of CIGS, we
were unable to collect enough data on CIGS.
[14]
China
optimum value of their parameters. Like, the maximum efficiency given by CIGS PV panel is by
Solar Motion Electronics Co., Ltd which s about 20%, so we will choose that manufacturer.
Other manufacturers are also listed down based on their optimum value of parameters in table 3
below.
3 Mathematical Modelling:
We will need mathematical modeling to solve part 4,5 and 6. As part 4 include the section of
calculation of actual efficiency of CIGS PV module for Karachi using one-year measured data.
So, we will do mathematical modelling to find the formula best suited to find the actual
efficiency. Actual efficiency Ƞ of panel depend on rated efficiency Ƞr, temperature coefficient of
power B, ambient temperature Ta and reference temperature Tr.[15]
Ƞ=Ƞ r [ 1−β ( T m −T r ) ] … … … … … … … … … .1
Now, to find actual efficiency, we need to find daily module temperature. Daily module
temperature is the function of ambient air temperature Ta, T NOCT is nominal operating cell
temperatures and global horizontal irradiance GHI which will be varying day-by-day and
second-by-second. It was impossible to find GHI value at each second. So, we found it for one
hour each day and then applied data quality check to filter the data which was fluctuating from
the rest of the data and then hourly data was concerted into daily data. Now, we have 365 value
of GHI and other variables which will be used for further calculations.[16].
GHI
T m=T a + [ ( T NOCT −20 ) ] … … … … … … … ..2
800
In 2, wind effects are not considered and there is specific reason of that. We will do these
calculations based on ambient temperature only and check how it affect the characteristics
operating parameters of PV module and then we will do all these calculations again by taking in
account both ambient temperature and wind speed.
Now, the modelling equation of ambient temperature taking in both the factors account is found
from paper and is written below. [17]
9.5 GHI
T m=T a + [ ( T NOCT −20 ) ] … … … … … … … .3
5.7 +3.8 V 800
Where V is the wind speed and also transformed into daily basis from hourly basis. This will
complete our part 4.
Part 5 demands annual calculation of annual energy generated and capacity factors.
Mathematical model of annual energy generation s also found from one of the papers and is
presented here.
365
AEG=∑ ¿ ¿
k=1
For capacity factor, we will find first energy generated by the PV module E dc at operating
conditions which will be different then energy that can be generated by PV module E stc at
Energy Resources and Utilization 7th Semester 8
Muhammad Hamza CEP Assignment 2017-ME-121
standard test conditions STC. The ratio of these two quantities gives us the performance ratio
which reflects how closely the PV module behave when in working to, when was tested in STC
conditions.[18]
Edc Ƞ
PR= = … … … … … … … ….5
E stc Ƞ r
Now, the last thing to calculate is capacity factor which is the energy produced by the PV
module to the maximum amount of energy that could be produced if the module would work at
100% efficiency at its full rated power 24 hours. The mathematical model to find capacity factor
is again found from some of the paper and is written below in equation 6.
E dc AEG × A
CF= = …………………6
Pt P× 365
Where P is the capacity of the module and t is the time duration usually taken 1 year and A is the
area of PV module. We will take the 1st highlighted manufacturer of table 3 in our sample
calculations.
LCOE is the plant’s cost to produce the unit cost of electricity over the lifetime of its period.
4 Calculations:
Annual energy generation calculations are in excel file attached below and other calculations can
also be found there.
2017-ME-121_KARA
CHI.xlsx
We are required to calculate LCOE for solar power plant of 300 kW capacity in Karachi and
using the manufacturer panel of highest efficiency. Firstly, we will find the daily average power
output by the panels.
14572.71407
Daily power output=
366
If we divide our capacity by power output, we will get number of solar panels required to
produce 300 kW.
300000
Number of panels required=
39.8161
According to manufacturer, cost of single panel was 53.724$, so cost of 7535 panels will be
From NEPRA, website, tariff for Karachi based OURSUN solar power plant of 50 MW is
converted to tariff for 300 kW for our capacity and tariff comes out to be .114 pkr/kWh.[19]
pkr
LCOE=1.1
kWh
In doing these calculations, it is assumed that total project cost is composed of only two major
factors, panel purchase cost and operation and management cost and other cost are neglected for
the sake of simplicity. Also, tariff of 50 MW plant is adjusted according tour capacity which
result I so much lower value of tariff. In our case, LCOE is greater than tariff. Electricity price
less than LCOE would result a lower yield return on capital and higher than LCOE result in
greater return on capital. In our case, it is lower, so we will expect to breakeven occur after the
predicted time and till that time, we will be in loss. If we look at the possible causes of this,
lower capacity plant always suffers this kind of problem and so is in our case too. As a result, for
profit, generally, power plants greater than 25 MW are constructed for 25 years lifetime of plant
so that tariff goes higher than LCOE and greater return on investment occur.
5 Results:
20
19.5
19
18.5
18
17.5
17
20 25 30 35 40 45
Daily Module Temprature C
Figure 3 Graph between daily module temperature and efficiency without wind effects
20.5
1.02
20
PR Efficiency %
19.51
0.98
19
0.96
18.5
Module
0.94
18
0.92
17.5
0.9
17
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
0.88
GHI W/m2
0.86
20 25 30 35 40 45
Daily Module Temperature C
Figure 4 Graph between daily GHI and efficiency without wind effects
Figure 5 Graph between daily module temperature and PR without wind effects
20.5
20
Efficiency %
19.5
19
18.5
18
20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40
Daily Module Temperature C
20.5
20
Efficiency %
19.5
19
18.5
18
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
GHI W/m2
Figure 7 Graph between daily GHI and efficiency with wind effects
1.02
1
0.98
0.96
PR
0.94
0.92
0.9
20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40
Module Temperature C
Figure 8 Graph between daily module temperature and PR with wind effects
20
19.8
19.6
19.4
Efficiency %
19.2
19
18.8
18.6
18.4
18.2
18
Dec-14 Feb-15 Apr-15 May-15 Jul-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Dec-15 Jan-16
Figure 9 Graph between month and efficiency without wind effects
1
0.99
0.98
0.97
0.96
0.95
PR
0.94
0.93
0.92
0.91
0.9
Dec-14 Feb-15 Apr-15 May-15 Jul-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Dec-15 Jan-16
60
50
40
APG W/m2
30
20
10
0
Dec-14 Feb-15 Apr-15 May-15 Jul-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Dec-15 Jan-16
20.2
20
19.8
Efficiency %
19.6
19.4
19.2
19
18.8
18.6
Dec-14 Feb-15 Apr-15 May-15 Jul-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Dec-15 Jan-16
1.01
0.99
0.98
0.97
PR
0.96
0.95
0.94
0.93
Dec-14 Feb-15 Apr-15 May-15 Jul-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Dec-15 Jan-16
60
50
40
APG W/m2
30
20
10
0
Sep-14 Dec-14 Apr-15 Jul-15 Oct-15 Jan-16
6 Discussion:
So far, we have evaluated different parameters of solar CIGS PV module for Karachi city and
got some results. Its time to discuss the results. The 1st graph is plotted between daily module
Energy Resources and Utilization 7th Semester 16
Muhammad Hamza CEP Assignment 2017-ME-121
temperature and daily PV module efficiency without considering the effect of wind speed. It is
found that efficiency has inverse relation with the module temperature. Increasing the
temperature increases the output power but also input power. Increase in the input power is
constant but that input does not completely get converted into output power and as a result input
increase more than output and overall efficiency decreases. This is validated by the data and
shown in graph below.
Figure 2 shows the variation of daily module efficiency with variation in the GHI which is
changing time-by-time, day-by-day and it can be inferred that both have inverse relation with
each other. Increasing GHI causes increases in daily module temperature which causes increase
in input and output power but effect of input is more than output and as a result, efficiency goes
down, still we are getting more output power as compared with low GHI value. Figure 3 shows
the relation between daily module temperature and performance ratio. It has the same physical
interpretation as like efficiency and has inverse relation with the module temperature. That’s
why, they have negative slope.
Now, parameters are evaluated accounting both factors e.g., module daily temperature and wind
speed and their effect is seen on daily module efficiency, performance ratio, capacity factor,
annual energy produced, LCOE and tariff. It is now seen that increasing the module temperature
increases the heat losses to surrounding and overall efficiency of plate gets decreased.
Introducing the wind effects cure that problem by keeping down the plate temperature to little
bit, thereby decreasing the heat losses of plate and maintain the normal working temperature of
the plate, so efficiency is expected to increases by taking both factors in account as compared to
temperature effects only. This thing will be validated by the graphs below. Figure 6 shows the
trend of module temperature and performance ratio taking in account of wind speed and module
temperature simultaneously. Now, increasing the plate temperature tries to increases the heat
losses from the PV plate but wind try to cancel that effect by lowering down the plate
temperature and thereby heat losses. So, performance ratio with wind effects should be higher
than that of without wind effects. It can be validated from the graphs and also excel file.
Figure 7 shows the monthly trend of module efficiency. It can be seen that efficiency is higher in
the winter season as compared to other seasons. The reason for this is lower plate temperature in
winter and hence lower convection heat losses and better cell maintain temperature. So, PV
Energy Resources and Utilization 7th Semester 17
Muhammad Hamza CEP Assignment 2017-ME-121
module run most of the time at its maximum efficiency. Also, in winter, lower GHI value is
observed, which result in higher module efficiency as can be seen from figure 2. Then this lower
GHI value decreases energy and power gain as we have discussed earlier and can be seen from
figure 9. Maximum energy gain is observed in the mid of summer months with maximum
module temperature and running at lower efficiency. Figure 8 shows the trend of performance
ratio with months. It gets increased in winter seasons just like efficiency and decreased in
summer and lowest occur in mid of summer.
Table 4 Peak Results
no fuel cost for them and once capital initial investment is done, only maintenance cost is
required which is not very big and thus are cost-effective over the life time of power plant.[20]
References:
1. Kessler, F. and D. Rudmann, Technological aspects of flexible CIGS solar cells and
modules. Solar Energy, 2004. 77(6): p. 685-695.
2. Greentech, C. How Does Heat Affect Solar Panel Efficiencies? 2018 [cited 2021 28/02];
Available from: https://www.cedgreentech.com/article/how-does-heat-affect-solar-panel-
efficiencies.
3. A.R. Amelia#, Y.M.I., W.Z. Leow#, M Irwanto#1, I. Safwati2, M. Zhafarina,
Investigation of the Effect Temperature on Photovoltaic (PV) Panel Output
Performance. International Journal on Advance Science, Engineering and Information
Technology, 2016. 6 No. 5.
4. Al-Khazzar, A.A.A., Behavior of four Solar PV modules with temperature variation.
International Journal of Renewable Energy Research (IJRER), 2016. 6(3): p. 1091-1099.
5. Igalson, M., et al., Understanding defect-related issues limiting efficiency of CIGS solar
cells. Solar energy materials and solar cells, 2009. 93(8): p. 1290-1295.
6. Daoudia, A., Y. El Hassouani, and A. Benami, Investigation of the effect of thickness,
band gap and temperature on the efficiency of CIGS solar cells through SCAPS-1D. Int.
J. Eng. Tech. Res.(IJETR), 2016. 6: p. 71-75.
7. Ahangharnejhad, R.H., et al., Irradiance and temperature considerations in the design
and deployment of high annual energy yield perovskite/CIGS tandems. Sustainable
Energy & Fuels, 2019. 3(7): p. 1841-1851.
8. Kaldellis, J.K., M. Kapsali, and K.A. Kavadias, Temperature and wind speed impact on
the efficiency of PV installations. Experience obtained from outdoor measurements in
Greece. Renewable Energy, 2014. 66: p. 612-624.
9. Muzathik, A., Photovoltaic modules operating temperature estimation using a simple
correlation. International Journal of Energy Engineering, 2014. 4(4): p. 151.
10. ENF. 300w flexible CIGS solar module. 2021 [cited 2021 28/02]; Available from:
https://www.enfsolar.com/pv/panel-datasheet/Thin-film/1091.
11. Solar Motion Electronics Co., L. SMFLEX275/300W. 2020 [cited 2021 28/02]; Available
from: https://www.enfsolar.com/pv/panel-datasheet/Thin-film/954?
utm_source=ENF&utm_medium=panel_profile&utm_campaign=enquiry_company_dire
ctory&utm_content=55241.
12. sinoltech.com. 260W.270W.280W.290W FLEX-03NL CIGS Flexible Solar Panel. 2020
[cited 2021 28/02]; FLEX-03NL CIGS Flexible Solar Panel 260W.270W.280W.290W
Model No.: 03NL-260W, 03NL-270W, 03NL-280W,03NL-290W]. Available from:
http://www.sinolsolar.com/flex-03nl-cigs-flexible-solar-panel-260w-270w-280w-290w-
300w.html.
13. Yangzhou Bright Solar Solutions Co., L. BR. 2021 [cited 2021 28/02]; Available from:
https://www.enfsolar.com/pv/panel-datasheet/Thin-film/1139?
utm_source=ENF&utm_medium=panel_list&utm_campaign=enquiry_product_directory
&utm_content=107973.
14. Shandong Sinoltech International Co., L. 2021 [cited 2021 28/02]; Available from:
https://www.enfsolar.com/sinoltech?
directory=panel&utm_source=ENF&utm_medium=cisFamily&utm_content=54822&ut
m_campaign=profiles_panel.
15. Dubey, S., J.N. Sarvaiya, and B. Seshadri, Temperature dependent photovoltaic (PV)
efficiency and its effect on PV production in the world–a review. Energy Procedia, 2013.
33: p. 311-321.
16. García, M.A. and J. Balenzategui, Estimation of photovoltaic module yearly temperature
and performance based on nominal operation cell temperature calculations. Renewable
energy, 2004. 29(12): p. 1997-2010.
17. Schwingshackl, C., et al., Wind effect on PV module temperature: Analysis of different
techniques for an accurate estimation. Energy Procedia, 2013. 40: p. 77-86.
18. Mussard, M. and M. Amara, Performance of solar photovoltaic modules under arid
climatic conditions: A review. Solar Energy, 2018. 174: p. 409-421.
19. Pakistan, N.E.P.R.A.I.R.o. Oursun Pakistan Limited. 2020 [cited 2021 28/02]; Available
from: https://nepra.org.pk/tariff/Generation%20IPPs%20Solar.php.
20. Lee, J. and M.M. Shepley, Benefits of solar photovoltaic systems for low-income families
in social housing of Korea: Renewable energy applications as solutions to energy
poverty. Journal of Building Engineering, 2020. 28: p. 101016.
21. Owolabi, A.B., et al., Validating the techno-economic and environmental sustainability
of solar PV technology in Nigeria using RETScreen Experts to assess its viability.
Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments, 2019. 36: p. 100542.