Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Leadership Authenticity - Thesis (Final Copy)
Leadership Authenticity - Thesis (Final Copy)
Leadership Authenticity - Thesis (Final Copy)
A THESIS
PRESENTED TO THE
KIDAPAWAN CITY
____________________________________
____________________________________
BY
APRIL 2019
CHAPTER I
THE PROBLEM
A. Introduction
One basic right of Filipino children is “the right to education”. The children go to
school where they can be educated. In the school, there are several important persons
and factors that contribute to the effective learning process. There are teachers who
facilitate learning and the school head or is the one who has the greatest responsibility
for the management of a school. School heads are responsible for the overall operation
of their school.
Schools have not always had principals. Around the beginning of the twentieth
century, as schools grew from one–room to schoolhouses into schools with multiple
grades and classrooms, the need arose for someone to manage these more complex
organizations. This need was filled initially by teachers, who continued to teach while
also dealing with their school’s management needs. These teachers were called
principal teachers. As schools’ continued to grow, principal teachers became full – time
administrators in most schools. Most principals soon stopped teaching because of the
the instructional program, and overall school matters. The management role included
some curriculum and instruction supervision, but overall school management was the
primary role principals played until the early 1980s. As the accountability movement
gained momentum, the role of the principal changed from school managers to school
instructional leader and then to school reform leader. With this shift in role focus,
principals retained their management roles. Principals currently play multiple roles:
successful over the long term. Philosophers, religious leaders, and thinkers from ancient
times have given emphasis on the importance of authenticity and ethicality for leaders, if
they are to attain effective governance in any circumstances. Leaders are obliged to
demonstrate the highest moral standards and ethical demeanor in their everyday talk,
actions, decision, and behaviors so that others in their organizations can follow suit. The
most recent financial crisis has originated from failed corporate leaders who believed in
manipulations of accounts and indulged into blatant unethical corporate practices. The
shocking financial irregularities that have been uncovered in companies like Tyco
Transmile [52] etc. bring to fore the need for ethical leadership more than ever before.
Ethical perspective has been discussed in the authentic model of leadership [25].
Authentic leaders display high degree of integrity, have deep sense of purpose, and
committed to their core values. They build enduring organizations that meet the needs
of all stakeholders. As a result they promote a more trusting relationship in their work
groups that translates into several positive outcomes such as job satisfaction,
between leaders and members of the work group is central to their effective functioning.
Though leaders play the primary role in establishing and developing trust, little research
has examined the specific leadership practices which engender trust towards them.
There are some evidences, however, to suggest that some leaders, such as authentic
for effective functioning in organizations such as banks where tasks are complex and
require high levels of interdependence, cooperation, information sharing and above all
trust.
B. Hypotheses
School Heads leadership authenticity may influence teachers’ trust and school
climate that will have an effect in imparting learning to the pupils.
HO1: There is no significant relationship between school climate and leaders’
authenticity.
authenticity.
C. Theoretical Framework
Faculty trust in the principal is one variable principals affect in teachers that could
have a positive impact on student achievement (Bryk & Schneider, 2002; Sweetland &
Hoy, 2000; Tschannen-Moran, 2001), the challenge for principals is knowing what will
impact their teachers’ trust in them (Blake & MacNeil, 1998). In schools, this means
teachers who trust their principal are more likely to take risks that may result in
teachers, and the teachers are directly influenced by the principal (illustrating a
which factors influence their teachers’ trust in them and which factors do not.
D. Conceptual Framework
Teachers’ Trust
Faculty trust in the school
head Principals’ Leadership
Faculty trust in colleagues Authenticity
Faculty trust in clients Self-awareness
Internalized moral
perspective
This study will be conducted to identify the relationship between School Heads
leadership authenticity with the School Climate and Teachers’ Trust perceived, by
teachers in three districts, the Tulunan East District, Tulunan North District, and Tulunan
South Districts. The respondents of this study will focus on both the elementary and
illustrated by the conceptual model and identifying the possible influence of School
Heads leadership authenticity on teachers’ trust and school climate in varying school
leaders can use to increase teachers’ trust and improve school climate.
F. Definition of Terms
School Principal a person with leadership skills, who can maintain accountability,
see potential and creative value in fellow teachers, peers, and students to enable them
to strive for higher education by focusing on goal setting and daily objectives that are
productive to the overall community, family and the individual person. The principal
another party based on the confidence that the latter party is benevolent, reliable,
and reflects norms, goals, values, interpersonal relationships, teaching and learning
School climate refers to the quality and character of school life. School
school life and reflects norms, goals, values, interpersonal relationships, teaching and
fosters youth development and learning necessary for a productive, contributing and
satisfying life in a democratic society. This climate includes: • Norms, values and
expectations that support people feeling socially, emotionally, and physically safe. •
People are engaged and respected. • Students, families and educators work together to
develop, live, and contribute to a shared school vision. • Educators model and nurture
attitudes that emphasize the benefits and satisfaction gained from learning. National
Collegial leadership: refers to the extent to which teachers perceive “the behavior
Academic press: refers to the extent to which teachers perceive that the “school
al., 2006).
“degree to which the school can count on involvement and support from parents
and community members and the extent to which the school provided the
al.,2006).
another party based on the confidence that the latter party is benevolent, reliable,
competent, honest, and open.Our research has led us to conclude there are at
least three dimensions of faculty trust – trust in the principal, trust in colleagues,
another based on the confidence that the other is benevolent, honest, open, reliable,
CHAPTER II
Leadership Authenticity
antecedent to authenticity. That is, trustworthy leaders are seen as more authentic.
Reference [36] viewed that consistency; integrity, openness, promise fulfillment, and
receptivity to suggestions and input are also some of the core components of
leader's legitimacy through honest relationships with followers which value their input
and are built on an ethical foundation. Generally, authentic leaders are positive people
with truthful self-concepts who promote openness. By building trust and generating
enthusiastic support from their subordinates, authentic leaders are able to improve
individual and team performance. This approach has been fully embraced by many
leaders who emphasize profit and share price over people and ethics. Authentic
recently grown from obscurity to the beginnings of a fully mature concept. [1]
Despite the popularity of the construct, many foundational papers on this topic have
recently been retracted or called into question because of issues surrounding the
reporting of data and the inability of the authors to produce their original data. [2]
[3]
Moreover, there have been some recent high-profile criticisms of the theoretical basis
measurement tools, unsupported knowledge claims and a generally simplistic and out of
School Climate
assessment of school climate includes major spheres of school life such as safety,
relationship, teaching and learning and the environment as well as larger organizational
patterns. It is much like the air we breathe – it tends to go unnoticed until something is
seriously wrong. The concern for the climate or atmosphere of the school and its effect
on the student and the learning environment, has been a concern of the educational
community for more than a century. School administrators at the turn of the twentieth
activities of two or more persons and influences their behavior (Barnard, 2010). The
school as an organization has certain aims and objectives which it has to achieve
(National Policy on Education 2009). In order to achieve the aims and objectives, the
organization climate of the organization including the school system is very important.
This organization climate refers to the working condition among super ordinates (school
heads) and subordinates (teachers) in a bid to achieve the aims and objectives of the
school system.
Very few managers are leaders. The difference between the two? A manager is
someone who has people reporting to him. A leader is someone who people will follow,
even if they don’t report to him. What separates the two is the trust and respect of his
people.
When the leader establishes trust within the team, it truly shows. Team members
feel secure in sharing their opinions without the fear of judgment or retribution, freely
share information and openly collaborate on projects and know that if the leader pushes
them, he does so with their best interests in mind. The result? Highly motivated and
productive workforce.
A leader is only as effective as his team. But building trust takes time and
Here are the behaviors one needs to display to earn trust of his/her team every
single day:
Lead by example
Leaders who don’t walk the talk lose trust. If you want your team members to
display certain behaviors, you need to display them first. You cannot ask someone to do
something that you wouldn’t do yourself. For example, if you expect your team to work
late,do so as well. Showing your team that you are one of them and their equal in being
Overcommunicate
True leaders are direct and honest. And they communicate all the time. Lack of
People can smell you hiding something a mile away. If there is some information
you can’t share with the team just yet, tell them what you can and show them you got
their backs. This is especially critical in the times of reorganization or layoffs. Always
Publicly own up to your mistakes when you make them. Admitting you were
wrong isn’t a sign of weakness, but strength. Acknowledge the mistakes and outline the
new course.
No one knows everything. We all have our limitations. Build a team around you
that complements you – and each other – in knowledge, skillsets, and capabilities. Don’t
try to do everything. Let your team members drive certain projects and outcomes. That
will make them feel valued and will make you look good. But always have their back
No one trusts those who don’t keep their word. So keep your promises and, if
Every now and then, however, there are circumstances outside your control that
might come into play. In those cases your team will understand, as long as you display
And always remember: take the blame, but give away the credit. Acknowledge
people for their contributions. The more credit your give away, the more motivated your
team will be to move mountains for you. And when something goes wrong,
acknowledge the fact that the mistake was made under your leadership and don’t throw
No one is perfect. All of us learn as we go, even towards the end of our career.
Ask your team for feedback: what you can be doing as a leader to help them be more
productive, how you can improve their work environment, what process you can change
for the whole team to be more effective, how you can better communicate with them,
etc. And when the feedback is provided, accept it with grace and say "thank you." It’s
not easy to hear constructive feedback, but it helps you improve as a manager and as a
professional.
member and create team rules that you expect everyone to respect and follow, such as
a “don’t gossip” rule, for example. Some leaders create the team rules collectively with
their teams which ensures that everyone agrees to uphold the same set of standards.
ensures that there are no surprises. This takes extra stress out of the daily routine.
Each employee knows what they are expected to deliver and are not surprised during
Don’t gossip
Gossip kills trust. Effective leaders set – and follow – a rule of not discussing one
Listen
Take the time to get to know every single member of your team.
Ask questions, consistently. And then listen. You will be surprised what you can learn if
you keep quiet during discussions or meetings and just let others talk.
expectations. I’ve worked for managers before who would be happy one day and
infuriated the other, who would set out one path one day and totally change it the next
day. This creates uncertainty, frustration, and distrust. I am not saying don’t pioneer
change and stay agile. I am saying that whenever possible provide your team with
unwavering support that they can rely on and a set of rules and expectations that will be
When your team knows that you are in it for your own success, they won’t give
you their best. Ever. Instead show them that you put them ahead of your own ambitions
(or at a minimum let them in on your ambitions and give them a seat at the table in
achieving them). And again, I can’t stress it enough: take the blame, give away the
credit.
At the end of the day, success of your team is your success as well. The two go
hand in hand. But in your desire to climb the corporate (or start-up) ladder, don’t leave
behind or forget those who made it happen. None of us can achieve success alone,
remember that.
In summary…
Trust leads to loyalty. And loyalty leads to people doing their best to deliver
results for you and the company. To earn trust and respect you have to give trust and
respect, as well as look out for your people. And if you do, there will be no limit to what
Community Engagement
Community engagement is the extent to which the school fosters a constructive
relationship with its community. It describes the degree to which the school can count
on involvement and support from parents and community members and the extent to
which the school provides the community with information about its accomplishments.
Collegial Leadership
Collegial leadership refers to the behavior of the principal that is supportive and
Teacher Professionalism
committed to their work and are willing to work cooperatively with one another.
Academic Press
Achievement press refers to a school wide tone that is serious orderly, and
focused on academics.
vocal parents and citizen groups. High vulnerability suggests that both teachers and
principals are unprotected and put on the defensive (Climate Instrument section,).
Collegial Leadership
needs of the faculty and achieving the goals of the school. The principal treats teachers
as colleagues, is open, egalitarian, and friendly, but at the same time sets clear
Achievement Press
Achievement press describes a school that sets high but achievable academic
standards and goals. Students persist strive to achieve, and are respected by both
students and teachers for their academic success. Parents, teachers, and the principal
all exert pressure for high standards and school improvement (Climate Instrument
section).
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
This chapter presents the researcher design of the study, research respondents,
research instrument used, data gathering procedure employed and the statistical
A. Research Design
exploring the leaders’ authenticity of the School Heads and its influence to teachers’
B. Research Locale
C. Research Respondents
The respondents of this study are both elementary and high school teachers of
municipality of Tulunan of Cotabato Division. They are the three hundred fifty (300)
teachers who will be ask to answer the survey questionnaire from which relevant
The researcher will prepare a letter asking permission to conduct the study and
stipulating the purpose of conducting it. The researcher will submit it to the three school
After getting the approval from the district supervisor, the researcher then furnished
a copy of the approved letter to the school heads, for information and reference so the
researcher could start the data gathering procedure. The approval to conduct the study
In the gathering procedure, the researcher will administer the research instrument to
the respective respondents and briefed them on the proper filling in of the questionnaire.
The researcher will assure the respondents that their identification and responses shall
be treated confidentially. They will be given enough time to read, think, and analyze
Finally, the researcher will collect the administered, tallied and tabulated data in
E. Research Instrument
http://people.uncw.edu/nottinghamj/documents/slides6/Northouse6e
%20Ch11%20Authentic Survey.pdf, while Part II and Part III was adopted from the
2009. It was used as the primary data gathering instrument with focus on identifying the
leaders’ authenticity and its influence to teachers’ trust and school climate. These
identified respondents will be asked to answer the survey questionnaire which will be
the main source of data and information for the formulation of the research findings,
5 - Strongly Agree
4 - Agree
3 - Neutral
2 - Disagree
1 - Strongly Disagree
The survey questionnaire will be given to the respondents to answer honestly the
items as required to fully utilize its purpose. After the retrieval of question, the
researcher will consolidate and analyze the data and information and employ
F. Statistical Treatment
For a clear interpretation of the data gathered from the survey questionnaire, the
researcher will use the following statistical procedures: Mean, Pearson r and Multiple
Regression.
G. Ethical Consideration
In this study, the researchers asks permission from the school heads by sending
letter to conduct a survey regarding their Leadership’s Authenticity and its influence in
The respondents answered the questionnaires with their full consent and to protect
their dignity and privacy, confidentiality will be prioritized. The questionnaires did not
contain any degrading or discriminating or any other unacceptable remark that maybe
Part 1 Questionnaire
SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE
different leadership. Indicate how much you agree or disagree with the following
4 - Agree
3 - Neutral
2 - Disagree
1 - Strongly Disagree
A. SELF-AWARENESS 1 2 3 4 5
My school head…
1. is aware of his/her weaknesses.
2. is aware of his/her strengths.
seeks feedback as way of understanding who
3.
really he/she is as a person.
4. accepts the feelings about himself/herself.
B. INTERNALIZED MORAL PERSPECTIVE
My school head…
1. reflects his/her core values through actions.
2. do not allow group pressure to control him/her.
knows where he/she stands on controversial
3.
issues.
is guided by her morals on what he/she does as a
4.
leader.
C. BALANCED PROCESSING
My school head…
seeks others’ opinion before making up his/her
1.
mind.
listens closely to the ideas of those who disagree
2.
with him/her.
do not emphasize his/her point of view at the
3.
expense of others.
listens very carefully to the ideas of others before
4.
making decisions.
D. RELATIONAL TRANSPARENCY
My school head…
1. openly shares his/her feelings with others.
2. let others know who really he/she is as a person.
3. rarely present a “false” front to others.
4. admits mistakes to others.
Instructions: Indicate how much you agree or disagree with the following statements.
head’s actions.
8. believe that the school head is competent in
each other.
2. Even in difficult situations, teachers in this
other.
5. Teachers in this school have faith in the
other.
7. When teachers in this school tell you
good job.
4. Students in this school can be counted on to
do their work.
5. Parents in this school are reliable in their
commitments.
6. Teachers in this school trust the parents.
7. Students here are secretive.
8. Teachers here believe that students are
competent learners.
9. Teachers in this school believe what parents
tell them.
10. Teachers in this school trust their students.
Instructions: Indicate how much you agree or disagree with the following statements.
A. COLLEGIAL LEADERSHIP 1 2 3 4 5
1. The principal is friendly and approachable.
The principal puts suggestions made by the
2.
faculty into operations.
The principal explores all sides of topics
3.
and admits that other opinions exists.
The principal treats all faculty members as
4.
his or her equal.
5. The principal is willing to make changes.
The principal lets faculty know what is
6.
expected of them.
The principal maintains definite standards of
7.
performance.
B. TEACHER PROFESSIONALISM
The interactions between faculty members
1.
are cooperative.
Teachers respect the professional
2.
competence of their colleagues.
3. Teachers help and support each other.
Teachers in this school exercise
4.
professional judgment.
Teachers are committed to helping
5.
students.
Teachers accomplish their jobs with
6.
enthusiasm.
Teachers “go the extra mile” with their
7.
students.
Teachers provide strong social support for
8.
colleagues.
C. ACADEMIC PRESS
The school sets high standards for
1.
academic performance.
Students respect others who get good
2.
grades.
Academic achievement is recognized and
3.
acknowledged by the school.
Students try hard to improve on previous
4.
work.
The learning environment is orderly and
5.
serious.
Students seek extra work so they can get
6.
good grades.
D. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Our school makes an effort to inform the
achievements.
Our school is able to marshal community
2.
support when needed.
Parents and other community members are
3.
included on planning committees.
Community members are responsive to
4.
request for participation.
Community members attend meetings to
5.
stay informed about our school.
Organized community group (e.g. PTA,
issues.
School people are responsive to the needs
members.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/265685753_The_Interconnectivity_of_Trust_in
_Schools