Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Review On Mitigation Methods of Very Fast Transient Overvoltage in Gas Insulated Switchgear
Review On Mitigation Methods of Very Fast Transient Overvoltage in Gas Insulated Switchgear
ABSTRACT
The generation of very fast transient over-voltages is a
Keywords
severe concern in switching of unloaded GIS sections with EMTP; Very Fast Transient Overvoltage (VFTO); Gas
dis-connectors. In the figure, a measured VFTO During Insulated Substation (GIS); Damping Resistor; Ferrite Rings;
switching of dis-connectors (DS) in GIS a varying number Nano-crystalline Rings; Trapped Charge
of pre-strikes and re-strikes occur. Due to the very short
duration of the voltage collapse, traveling surges are 1. INTRODUCTION
generated in the busbar duct. These very fast transient The power framework is vast and interconnected one in which
over-voltages (VFTO) can become the limiting dielectric the transformer assumes a vital part and subsequently it is
stress which defines the dimensions at UHV voltage levels. extremely crucial to ensure it against the inside and outer
Switching operations generates very fast transient over shortcomings and also from the over voltages because of any
voltages (Very fast transient over voltages (VFTOs)) in gas reason especially when it is utilized as a part of gas protected
insulated substations (GIS) and it is very dangerous to substation since there is dependably probability persistently
transformers as it causes the damage to insulation because the probability of explanation behind very fast transient over
of its short rise time. Mitigation and analysis of very fast voltages. During switching of dis-connectors in GIS a varying
transient over voltages (Very fast transient over voltages number of pre-strikes and re-strikes occur. Due to the very
(VFTOs)) of power transformer is very important in gas short duration of the voltage collapse, traveling waves are
insulated substations (GIS) as very fast transient over generated in the busbar duct. The multiple refractions and
voltages causes’ damage to the insulation of the power reflections of these waves at impedance discontinuities within
devices like transformer. In this review work power the enclosures create complex waveforms, which depend on
transformer is considered as it plays major role in the the DS design, the operating conditions and the configurations
electrical substation (GIS). Initially the power transformer of the GIS. The transients are characterized by their short
rating of 500MVA in 765kV/400kV gas insulated duration and very high frequencies. The rise times are in the
substation has been considered and the simulation model range of some ns, with dominant frequency components up to
is developed using Mat Lab platform on the basis of very 100 MHz. The VFTO can become the limiting dielectric stress
fast transient (VFT).Mitigation methods like shunt resistor which defines the dimensions at UHV voltage levels. The first
and metal oxide surge arrester (MOA) have been three switchgear installations in the UHV demonstration
employed individually and then the effect of the proposed project in China are partially executed using gas-insulated
damping methods on peak magnitude of very fast design or as hybrid systems (Hybrid-IS), that is, as a
transient over voltages (Very fast transient over voltages combination of air-insulated and gas-insulated components.
(VFTOs)) has been evaluated. In the further stage, the One of these installations is being supplied by ABB/Xi„an
effect of terminal components on peak of Very fast Shiky as Hybrid-IS shown in Figure 1. Based on test and
transient over voltages (VFTOs) has been estimated 1ns. simulation results it was decided that no VFTO mitigation
The outcome of the proposed technique again is explored measures are required for the Hybrid-IS design.
to wavelet transform (WT) (Db4) for extraction of high This paper covers the estimation of VFTO at various locations
frequency signals. As wavelet transform (WT) is a in GIS for different switching operations. Furthermore, dis-
powerful tool for analysis very fast transient signals. The connector switching operations in comparison with the
results shows that peak value of Very fast transient over breaker switching are investigated. To estimate the VFTO
voltages (VFTOs) can be reduced to considerable level by magnitudes, the influence of trapped charge on the HV bus
employing the proposed damping methods and the have to be taken into consideration. Therefore the variations
terminal components of gas Insulated substation (GIS) of VFTO peak with different magnitudes of trapped charges
also influences the peak magnitudes of Very fast transient have been studied. In addition, the impacts of several methods
over voltages (VFTOs). of suppressing such as damping resistor, ferrite Rings and
Nano crystalline ring on amplitude of VFTOs have been
General Terms discussed.
analysis, damping, mitigation, surge, transients, wavelet
21
Resincap Journal of Science & Engineering
Volume 1, Issue 1, February 2017
22
Resincap Journal of Science & Engineering
Volume 1, Issue 1, February 2017
23
Resincap Journal of Science & Engineering
Volume 1, Issue 1, February 2017
placed around the inner conductor inside the GIS. For the tests
the GIS setup with short-circuited end was used. Rings of Figure shows a resonator schematically as it is used for first
different ferrite materials were investigated and the simulations and tests. The resonator consists of an aluminium
number of rings inside the GIS was varied between 1 and 6. tube which is connected to the inner conductor on one side.
Also the diameter of the rings was different. The rings are The other side of the tube forms a thin, but long gap between
shown in Figure. resonator and inner conductor.
24
Resincap Journal of Science & Engineering
Volume 1, Issue 1, February 2017
In this approach, the source-free Maxwell equations are The used alloy is based on iron (Fe) with silizium (Si),
discretized by using the finite element method (FEM). This boron (B) and other additives [12]. By means of a rapid
process results in a large sparse homogenous system of linear solidification technology the liquid metal is converted to
equations. very thin ribbons with a thickness of approximately 20 µm.
The mathematical eigenvalues of this system correspond to The thin tape is winded up to rings. Finally a heat treatment
the resonant frequencies of the resonator and could be with temperatures between 500 and 600 °C transforms the
analyzed performing time-domain and frequency-domain initially amorphous microstructure of the tape into the
eigenvalue analysis [10]. The simulations verify a significant desired nano-crystalline state with fine crystalline grains
damping of VFTOs. The optimum damping could be embedded in an amorphous residual phase. The average
achieved by termination of the gap with a resistor which grain diameter is between 10 and 40 nm. This material has
equals the characteristic impedance of the resonator. Also very specific properties which could be adjusted by means of
the resonant frequency of the resonator has to be in the range an external magnetic field during the heat treatment.
of the dominant harmonic component of the VFTO. In this Especially the permeability and the saturation flux density of
case a significant part of the energy of the VFTO is stored in these rings are very high.
the resonator. By dissipating the energy of the resonator a Different rings with an external diameter between 20 cm and
mitigation of VFTO will be achieved. 50 cm and a permeability between 8 000 and 45 000 were
In order to verify the results experimentally, two test used. The rings were installed inside the GIS setup as
arrangements were designed. The length of the first shown. Surge voltage, SF6 pressure and gap distance were
resonator is below 1 m and it has a resonant frequency of kept constant for all tests to ensure equal conditions.
about 57 MHz which is much higher compared to the exemplifies the difference between VFTOs measured during
dominant harmonic frequency component of the GIS setup. a test without rings and with 20 rings inside the GIS. It is
As a consequence the resonant frequency of the resonator has obviously that the VFTOs are damped by the rings. Even
to be reduced. the amplitude of the first peaks was significantly reduced by
As the gap between resonator and inner conductor forms the 20 %.
capacitance C and the cavity of the resonator represents the
inductance L, an increase of one or both of these
parameters decreases the resonant frequency of the
5. CONCLUSION
Before starting the design of an UHV substation, it has to be
resonator. For the tests the resonant frequency was
clarified whether VFTO have significant influence on the
adjusted by means of additional external capacitors in the
insulation co-ordination. The decision shall be based on the
gap. If the adjusted resonator gets stimulated by the VFTOs
maximum VFTO peak value that occurs with reference to the
sparking occurs in the gap. For the chosen resonator design
rated lightning impulse withstand voltage of the equipment.
the spark resistance has not been sufficient to mitigate the
If the maximum VFTO is below the LIWV, no measures need
VFTOs. To increase the mitigation effect an additional
to be taken. Otherwise it is necessary to design considering
resistor was mounted in the gap. The connected resistor is
the VFTO level as dimensioning criteria or to suppress VFTO
not homogeneous distributed around the gap and therefore
by damping devices. For the different sources of VFTO and
not an ideal termination. But using this simple solution, a
for the different equipment different mitigation methods are
slight damping effect was achieved as shown in proceeding
known.
figure.
The damping of VFTO by integration of a damping
4.3 Nano-crystalline material for VFTO resistor is one proven technology. The way to overcome
damping the drawback of such unwieldy design is to use other
Very promising results were found by using rings of a internal damping measures such as ferrite materials or RF
nano-crystalline alloy. To obtain VFTO mitigation these resonators. The VFTO damping solution utilizing ferrite rings
rings are arranged around the inner conductor of the GIS like has been analyzed and tested. The measurements show that
the ferrite rings. Experiments with different ring types, the damping effect can be achieved, but with an important
different sizes and different numbers of rings were carried drawback: the magnetic material goes easily into saturation,
out. which complicates the design and reduces its general
applicability and robustness
A new approach for damping is to implement compact
electromagnetic high-frequency resonators with low quality
factor specially designed to cover a wider frequency range.
The novelty of this idea is not only in designing the
resonators but also in dissipating the received VFTO
energy. The VFTO damping effect of the developed RF
resonator tuned to the dominant harmonic component was
confirmed by experiments…
Rings of a nano-crystalline alloy placed around the GIS
conductor leads also to a significant mitigation effect.
Depending on number, material and size of the rings good
results could be achieved.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
It gives me an immense pleasure to submit this study paper
Figure 7: Nano-crystalline rings with different entitled, “Review On Methods Of Damping Very Fast
permeability and diameters Transient Overvoltage In Gas Insulated Switchgear”. I wish to
25
Resincap Journal of Science & Engineering
Volume 1, Issue 1, February 2017
express our sincere thanks with profound gratitude to my Electrical Engineering Department, P.E.S.College of
guide Prof. M.S.Potdar and H.O.D. Prof. B.N. CHAUDHARI Engineering Aurangabad, India.
for their valuable guidance and constant encouragement
without which it would have been impossible. I would like to Prof. M.S. Potdar is working as associate professor in
extend our sincere thanks to our principal Dr. A.P. Electrical Engineering Department at P.E.S.College Of
WADEKAR and all the staff member for the guidance as and Engineering Aurangabad, India.
when required.
REFERENCES
[1] CIGRÉ Brochure 362 Working Group A3.22: “Technical
Requirements for Substations Equipment Exceeding 800 kV -
Field experience and technical specifications of Substation
equipment up to 1200 kV”, December 2008.
[2] CIGRÉ Brochure 456 Working Group A3.22:
“Background of Technical Specifications for
Substation Equipment Exceeding 800 kV AC”, April 2011
[3] Riechert, U.; Neumann, C.; Hama, H.; Okabe, S.;
Schichler, U., on behalf of CIGRÉ WG D1.36 and AG
D1.03: “Basic Information and Possible Counter Measures
Concerning Very Fast Transients in Gas-Insulated UHV
Substations as Basis for the Insulation Co-ordination”,
CIGRÉ SC A2 & D1 Joint Colloquium 2011, Kyoto, Japan,
PS3-O-5
[4] Riechert, U.; Krüsi, U.; Sologuren-Sanchez, D.: “Very
Fast Transient Overvoltages during Switching of Bus-
Charging Currents by 1100 kV Disconnector”, CIGRÉ Report
A3-107, 43rd CIGRÉ Session, August 22-27, 2010, Palais des
Congrès, Paris, France
[5] Riechert, U.; Holaus, W.: “Ultra High Voltage Gas-
Insulated Switchgear – A Technology Milestone”, Euro.
Trans. Electr. Power (2011), (wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI:
10.1002/etep.582.
[6] CIGRÉ Working Group 15.03: “GIS Insulation
Properties in Case of VFT and DC Stress”, Report 15-201,
36th CIGRÉ Session, Aug. 25-31, 1996, Paris, France
[7] CIGRÉ Working Group 33/13-09: “Monograph on GIS
Very Fast Transients”, Brochure 35, July1989
[8] Del Pozo, M.D.; Esteban, D.A.; Issouribehere, P.E.;
Barbera, G.A.; Funes, A.; Ledesema, A.:“Field measurements
and modelling of high frequency transients during disconnect
switch operations in EHV Substations. Assessment of their
effects on Current Transformers”, CIGRÉ Report A3-
rd
207,43 CIGRÉ Session, August 22-27, 2010, Palais des
Congrès, Paris, France
[9] J. Lijun, Z. Yicheng, Z. Xianggong, S. Yuzhuo,
“Characteristic parameter analysis on the suppressing VFTO
in GIS by ferrite”, Proceedings of 2005 International
Symposium on Electrical Insulating Materials, Vol. 3, pp.
825 – 828, 2005
[10] Smajic, J.; Holaus, W.; Troeger, A.; Burow, S.; Brandl,
R.; Tenbohlen, S.: “HF Resonators for Damping of VFTs in
GIS”, Proceedings of the 9th Int. Conference on Power
System Transients (IPST2011), Paper ID:185, Delft
University of Technology, The Netherlands, June 2011
[11] Smajic, J.; Holaus, W.; Kostovic, J.; Riechert, U.: “3D
Full-Maxwell Simulations of Very FastTransients in GIS”,
IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, Vol. 47, No. 5, pp. 1154-
1517, May 2011.
About Authors
Mr. Amol M. Dhaware1 has received his B.E. in Electrical
(Electronics & Power) from P.E.S. College of engineering,
Aurangabad (M.S) and currently pursuing M.E. (EPS) from
26