Pertites Articulo

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 21

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/270220024

Geochemistry of Feldspar Intergrowth Microtextures from Paleoproterozoic


Granitoids in Central India: Implications to Exsolution Processes in Granitic
System

Article  in  Journal of the Geological Society of India · February 2015


DOI: 10.1007/s12594-015-0204-9

CITATIONS READS

5 2,091

1 author:

Dinesh Pandit
Banaras Hindu University
68 PUBLICATIONS   387 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Evolution of Indian Sub-continental Lithospheric Mantle View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Dinesh Pandit on 31 October 2016.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


JOURNAL GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF INDIA
Vol.85, February 2015, pp.163-182

Geochemistry of Feldspar Intergrowth Microtextures from


Paleoproterozoic Granitoids in Central India: Implications
to Exsolution Processes in Granitic System

DINESH PANDIT
National Centre for Antarctic & Ocean Research,Vasco-Da-Gama - 403 804, Goa
Email: dpandit@hotmail.com

Abstract: Various forms of feldspar intergrowth microtextures occurred in granitic rocks. Characteristically, two
distinct types of microtextures formed due to intergrowth between K-feldspar and plagioclase i.e. perthites and
myrmekites. Malanjkhand and Dongargarh granitoids are two contemporaneous units of Paleoproterozoic granitoids
in central India. Three varieties of perthites have been identified in these granitoids i.e. flame, braid, and vein types.
Flame perthite bearing K-feldspar is common. Braid and vein perthites occur occasionally. Paleopiezometry estimation
indicates that flame perthite formed under the influence of low to moderate differential stress on granitoids. Most of the
perthites occurs in these granitoids are compositionally albite to oligoclase in nature. The composition ranges XAb: 0.98-
0.49 for the Malanjkhand and XAb: 0.96-0.49 for Dongargarh granitoids. Binary feldspar thermometry calculation indicates
that perthites have formed at moderate to high temperature conditions in the Malanjkhand granitoid whereas low to
moderate temperature conditions in Dongargarh granitoids during sub-solidus phase. Myrmekites is another feldspar
intergrowth microtexture found in these granitoids. Myrmekites are identified in these granitoids based on their
characteristic morphologies such as ghost, bulbous, rim, etc. These myrmekites were formed under moderate temperature
conditions during magmatic-hydrothermal transition phase. Formation of flame perthite can be explained by replacement
reaction mechanism (Na-K exchange) between K-feldspar and plagioclase under low to moderate differential stress
condition during rapid cooling. Further, extensive deuteric alteration results in the formation of braid and vein perthites.
Formation of myrmekites can be assumed by couple of replacement mechanisms (Na-K and Ca-K exchange) between
K-feldspar and plagioclase. Paleopiezometry and feldspar thermometry results infer that orthomagmatic-hydrothermal
transition in the Malanjkhand and Dongargarh granitoids were favored at upper or shallow levels in the continental
crust.

Keywords: Granitoids, Intergrowth microtexture, Perthites, Myrmekites, Central India.

INTRODUCTION Perthite is the intergrowth of albite-rich plagioclase in


K-feldspar (microcline, orthoclase) and plagioclase are K-feldspar grain whereas myrmekites are intergrowth
the major mineralogical constituents of granitoid rocks. microtexture of quartz, plagioclase, and K-feldspar which
Granitoids have very complex history during occurs in various forms. These microtextures have very
orthomagmatic-hydrothermal transition phase, mostly complex chemical composition hence difficult to resolve
related to feldspar reactions (Plumper and Putnis, 2009). their actual origin and evolution. To resolve this problem a
The formations of various secondary minerals such as number of scientific works (Phemister, 1926; Alling, 1938;
sericite, zoisite, kaolinite, etc., are the product of complex Buddington, 1939; Larsen, 1949; Higazy, 1949; Eskola,
transition processes. Although, co-existing pairs of K- 1952; Tuttle, 1952) have been carried out in the first half of
feldspar and plagioclase is very common feature in this rock the twentieth century. The microtextural study of feldspar
but microstructural features such as lamellae, intergrowth, mineral was first carried out by Thompson in 1843 (see
exsolution, etc., are occasionally observed. Various types Pryer and Robin, 1995). Later various workers (De
of microtextures were developed in granitoids, possibly due Lapparent, 1923; Phemister, 1926; Reynolds, 1936; Higazy,
to tectono-magmatic activities in the upper crust. Among 1949; Perrin and Roubault, 1953) have identified a
them, perthite and myrmekite microtextures are very significant number of feldspar microtextures such as perthite,
common in granitoids. antiperthite, myrmekites, etc. Further investigations based

0016-7622/2015-85-2-163/$ 1.00 © GEOL. SOC. INDIA


164 DINESH PANDIT

on microscopic observation and chemical analysis, a number plagioclase crystals occur. This study will discuss the
of hypotheses have been postulated to explain the origin mechanism of perthite and myrmekite formation in granitic
and evolution of intergrowth microtexture in feldspars. system. Further, an attempt is made to reconstruct the
Some of the important hypothesis for the origin of orthomagmatic-hydrothermal processes in Paleoproterozoic
perthite are well described by Becke (1908), De Lapparent granitoids in central India, which is responsible for the
(1923), Phemister (1926), Alling (1938) Buddignton (1939), development of these microtextures.
Higazy (1949), Cogne, (1951), Tuttle (1952), Heier (1955),
Robertson (1959), Hubbard (1967), Vogel (1970), Lorimer
GEOLOGICAL SETTINGS
and Champness (1973), Day and Brown (1980), Brown and
Parsons (1983, 1984a, b), Worden et al. (1990), Burgess et The Paleoproterozoic Malanjkhand and Dongargarh
al. (1992), Pryer and Robin (1995, 1996), Collins (1998), granitoids are two distinct units of Bastar/Bhandara craton
Sepahi and Collins (2002), Hashimoto et al. (2005), in central India (Fig. 1a). In proximity to the south of Central
Petrischeva and Abart (2009), Abart et al., (2009a, b), Indian Tectonic Zone (CITZ) which is demarked by Central
Parsons and Lee (2009), and Parsons et al. (2009, 2010). A Indian Suture (CIS) in the NW-boundary of the Malanjkhand
brief understanding of various hypotheses related to granitoid. Further southward, Dongargarh granitoid located
perthitization, it is summarized that exsolution and deuteric/ and situated about 50-60 kms south of CIS, devoid of any
hydrothermal sub-solidus processes (Yuguchhi and regional or local scale deformation features. Two granitic
Nishiyama, 2007; Petrishcheva and Abart, 2009; Abart et units are separated by bimodal volcano-sedimentary
al. 2009a, b) are dominant mechanism for perthite formation. formations of Nandgaon and Khairagarh group of rocks.
Mutual replacement reactions coupled by Na-K and Ca-K The Malanjkhand granitoid hosted one of the largest Cu-
(Yuguchi and Nishiyama, 2008; Parsons and Lee, 2009; Mo-Au deposits (Sikka, 1989; Sikka and Nehru, 1997). The
Parsons et al., 2009, 2010) control the composition of Malanjkhand granitoid had Rb-Sr whole rock age ~2.42 Ga
perthites bearing K-feldspar. (Panigrahi et al., 1993) with a revised age ~2.48 Ga (Pb-Pb
Myrmekites occur in both igneous and metamorphic zircon SHRIMP, Panigrahi et al., 2004). The younger age
rocks. It is one of the complex geological process resulting constrained from Rb-Sr whole rock chronometer possibly
in the development of intergrowth microstructure in due to extensive late stage hydrothermal alteration (Panigrahi
feldspars. The earliest document by Michel Levy in 1874 et al., 2008, 2009). Dongargarh granitoids located about 50
reported about myrmekite microtextures in feldspar grains km south of the Malanjkhand and comprises of three units
(see Yugushi and Nishiyama, 2008). Myrmekite can not such as Amgaon, Chichola, and Manpur pluton, reported to
considered as igneous texture because it is also reported in be barren except small scale fluorite mineralization at
various metamorphic rocks (e.g. Hall, 1966; Ashworth, 1972; Chandi-Dongari (Deshpande, 1984; Changkakoti et al.,
Nold, 1984) and hydrothermally altered granitoids (Yuguchi 2006). In the present study (Fig. 1b), Amgaon and Chichola
and Nishiyama, 2007; Collins, 1997a, b, c). Petrologists pluton is considered as Dongargarh granitoids. The
working on feldspar microstructures were come up with Dongargarh granitoids have wider age ranges such as
various hypotheses for origin of myrmekites. Some of the ~2.27 Ga (Rb-Sr whole rock, Sarkar et al., 1981), ~2.46 Ga
important proposition for the origin of myrmekites are by (Rb-Sr whole rock, Krishnamurthy et al., 1988), ~2.37 Ga
Becke (1908), Schwanke (1909), Sugi (1930), Spencer (Sm-Nd whole rock, Krishnamurthy et al., 1990), and 2.41
(1938, 1945), Dresher-Kaden (1948), Shelley (1964, 1973a, Ga (Pb-Pb whole rock, Pandey et al., 1993). Perhaps, these
b), Hall (1966), Hubbard (1966), Barker (1970), two granitoids are contemporaneous in age (~2.48-2.41 Ga).
Bhattacharyya (1971, 1972), Ashworth (1972), Phillips The geochemical classification indicates that Malanjkhand
(1974, 1980a, b), Hibbard (1979), Castle and Lindsley pluton is granite to granodiorite in composition (Panigrahi
(1993), Collins (1997a, b, c), Tsurumi et al. (2003), Menegon et al., 1993; Kumar and Rino, 2006; Pandit, 2008, Pandit
et al. (2006) and Yugushi and Nishiyama (2008). In general and Panigrahi, 2012) whereas Dongargarh pluton is mostly
the issue of origin of myrmekites is debatable and specific granitic in composition (Narayana et al., 2000; Pandit, 2008;
interpretation to understand its mechanism of formation in Pandit and Panigrahi, 2012).
granitoids is required. The Malanjkhand granitoid has been thoroughly
The Malanjkhand and Dongargarh granitoids are two investigated by earlier researchers (Panigrahi et al., 2009
prominent Paleoproterozoic plutons in central India (Pandit and reference within) because of its economic importance,
and Panigrahi, 2012), where characteristic feldspar whereas, Dongargarh granitoids has not received much
intergrowth microtextures between K-feldspar and attention. However, their genetic linkages, time of

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


GEOCHEMISTRY OF FELDSPAR INTERGROWTH MICROTEXTURES FROM GRANITOIDS IN CENTRAL INDIA 165

Fig.1. Geological map of Malanjkhand and Dongargarh granitoids, Central India (after Jain et al., 1995) with sample locations.

emplacement, common mineralogy, are some of the of mafic and felsic magma in various proportions
important factors that lead towards understanding their origin followed by mingling within a dynamic magma chamber,
and evolution (Pandit, 2008). Although, various genetic emplaced at shallow level in the crust.
models have been proposed, some of them have been 3. Stein et al. (2004, 2006) proposed that the Malanjkhand
selected and discussed, because of their scientific deposit and the surrounding batholith containing multiple
importance. Cu-Mo-Au prospect may be the vestiges of a microplate
1. Panigrahi et al. (2004) suggested that Malanjkhand captured along the north margin of the nearly
granitoid have been emplaced in a single magmatic pulse amalgamated southern Indian craton at 2.5 Ga. They also
and later undergone extensive hydrothermal alteration provided Re-Os model and isochrones ages of
(Panigrahi et al., 2008) resulting in the formation of ore molybdennite (2.49-2.44 Ga) from the Malanjkhand
deposits. deposit and interpreted them as discrete deformation
2. Kumar et al. (2004) and Kumar and Rino (2006) argued episodes and molybdenite deposition.
that Malanjkhand granitoid is produced due to mixing 4. Mazumder and Mamtani (2009) reported solid state

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


166 DINESH PANDIT

deformation fabrics in the north-western boundary of classification proposed by Smith and Brown (1988) is more
the Malanjkhand pluton and suggested syn-tectonic appropriate from petrographic point of view and hence
evolution of the granitoid synchronous with the considered in the present study. There are three types of
development of CITZ. This hypothesis favors the perthites observed in Malanjkhand granitoid, which is
syntectonic emplacement of the Malanjkhand granitoid discussed below.
at the time of suturing of northern and southern Indian Flame perthite: Thin lamellas of perthites are sub-
shields along the CIS (Stein et al., 2004). parallel with twining planes of hosts K-feldspar grains,
5. Pandit and Panigrahi (2012) concluded that the origin about 1-2 µm in width and variable in length (10-50 µm)
of Paleoproterozoic granitoids in central India are due (Fig. 2a). Generally, middle portion of the flame perthite is
to magma mixing process between crustal derived felsic wider with sharp and pointed edges. While larger lamellas
and mafic magma contributed by basaltic underplating of perthites are preferably oriented, such trend is not
in a continental rift environment, and finally emplaced observed in case of smaller lamellae.
at shallow crustal level. Braid perthite: It is composed of two superimposed
Development of deformation fabrics in the northern groups of albite blebs, oriented parallel to the cleavage
margin of the Malanjkhand pluton possibly due to craton planes of hosts K-feldspar grains adjacent to plagioclase
scale tectonic activities (CITZ) and considered as brittle- crystal (Fig. 2b).
ductile shear zone (Yedekar et al., 1990; Jain et al., 1991; Vein perthite: It has criss-cross pattern observed only in
Mishra et al., 2000; Acharyya and Roy, 2000; Stein et al., few grains of K-feldspar. These veins are interconnected
2004). The CIS comprises steeply northward dipping shear and occur in zones (Fig. 2c).
zones characterized by multiple bands of mylonites marked Three types of perthitic intergrowth microtextures hosted
as the northwestern boundary of Malanjkhand granitoid and in K-feldspar grains are also observed in Dongargarh
separates from Sausar mobile belt (Ramachandra and Roy, granitoids which are as follows:
2001). The E-W to ENE-WSW trending Sausar mobile belt Flame perthite: Commonly occurs within K-feldspar
comprises of migmatitic gneiss, felsic orthogneiss and gneiss grains. Fine, lenticular, parallel lamellae are nearly similar
with meta-ultramafites enclaves, meta-basites, metapelites orientation trends, quasi-parallel to host lattice of K-feldspar
and mafic granulites (Bhowmik et al., 1998; Acharyya and grain. The alternative band of grey and white colour
Roy, 2000; Acharyya et al., 2001). Two prominent ultra high appeared in the K-feldspar grain in polished thin sections.
temperature metamorphic events i.e. Paleoproterozoic Flame perthite is the dominant feldspar microtextures in
(~2.09 – 2.04 Ga) and Mesoproterozoic (~1.52 – 1.45 Ga) samples of Dongargarh granitoids. One of the special feature
are recorded based on the study of monazites from Sausar observed is a twined K-feldspar grain, which is separated
mobile belt within CITZ (Bhowmik et al., 2005). The by a thin calcite vein (~1 µm in width). In this sample,
Neoproterozoic age (~0.83 Ga) along with several perthite lamella is radiating from the direction of orientation
intermediate events (e.g., 1.40, 1.10, 0.97, 0.84 Ga, etc.) of calcite vein (Fig 2d).
are reported from Tirodi biotite gneisses (Roy et al., 2006). Braid perthite: Commonly, it is observed in groups of
The monazite chemical age of ~1.6-1.56 Ga is obtained aggregates; found in small, angular and irregular braid-
from Bhandara-Balaghat granulite domain (Bhandari et al., shapes (Fig. 2e). The lattice orientation of braid perthite is
2011). All available chemical ages of monazite represent nearly similar to that of host K-feldspar grains. Braid perthite
various Proterozoic tectonic events in the CITZ, related is restricted only to large grains of K-feldspar and showing
to post-emplacement history of Malanjkhand and very strong lamellar twinning. The twinning plane of
Dongargarh granitoids. Hence, it can be considered that perthite is also parallel to cleavage plane of host K-feldspar
both granitoids remained undeformed during emplacement. crystals.
Vein perthite: It is relatively coarse, irregular aggregates
of albitic (plagioclase) veins. Generally, elongated, thick in
PERTHITE MICROTEXTURES
the middle portion and terminated with wedge-shape. Their
The intergrowth microtexture of albite in orthoclase is lattice planes are orientated quasi-parallel to that of their
perthite (Spry, 1969). However, various types of perthitic host K-feldspar grains (Fig. 2f). Irregular vein perthites
microtextures within feldspar observed in different occurs in zones. These zones are clusters of vein perthites
rocks. Perthite is one of the characteristic microtextures with variable thickness. In few cases, characteristic
classified by various authors such as Smith and Brown thickening in the middle portion of the vein perthite due to
(1988), Cohen et al. (1997) and Collins (1998). The irregular blebs of quartz.

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


)LJXUH
&OLFNKHUHWRGRZQORDGKLJKUHVROXWLRQLPDJH

GEOCHEMISTRY OF FELDSPAR INTERGROWTH MICROTEXTURES FROM GRANITOIDS IN CENTRAL INDIA 167

Fig.2. Microphotographs of different types of perthites from Malanjkhand granitoids (a) flame, (b) braid or patch perthite, (c) vein
perthite and some representative perthites from Dongargarh granitoids (d) flame, (e) braid or patch, (f) vein types. Abbreviations:
Perth – perthites, Kfs – K-feldspar, Plag – plagioclase, Qtz – quartz, and Cal – calcite.

The first two varieties of perthites (flame and braid) are relatively high H2O content at low to moderate temperature
common in both granitoids. However, vein perthite is rarely conditions (Parsons, 1978) under the influence of differential
observed in the Malanjkhand granitoid and only in fractured stress at the time of their formation (Pryer and Robin, 1995).
grains of Dongargarh granitoids. Flame and patch perthite The braid or patch perthite crystallized at the expense of
never observed in zones as in vein perthites. flame perthite (microperthite) causing cracking along
Presence of flame perthite in granitoid rock indicates crystal planes (Ramberg, 1972). The coarse, braided, and

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


168 DINESH PANDIT

irregular grain boundaries of braid perthites indicate temperature exsolution occurs by spinodal mechanism as a
metasomatism and alteration of albite phase in host K- result of elastic distortions of crystal structure in feldspar
feldspar grains during orthomagmatic-hydrothermal fluid (Tullis, 1975). The spacing between flame perthite is very
activities (Worden et al., 1990). Perthitic microstructures sensitive to the initial temperature of exsolution (Yund
form either by exsolution or by replacement which and Chapple, 1980) whereas width of flame perthites
could be a post emplacement processes in granitoid slowly increase with temperature (Yund and Davidson,
rocks (Day and Brown, 1980). The metasomatic processes 1978). In the recent studies, Abart et al. (2009a) discussed
involve re-equilibration of mineral assemblages due to that perthites microstructures reflecting several stages
changes in pressure, temperature and/or physico- of exsolution and coarsening during slow cooling
chemical condition of the host rock (Putnis and Austrheim, where primary exsolution occurred by spinodal
2010). decomposition to form mesoperthite. However, the
spindle perthite are formed by nucleation and growth
mechanism. Further, Abart et al. (2009b) suggested that small
PALEOPIEZOMETER
precipitates with relatively high aspect ratio can grow rapidly
The recrystallized grain size is a function of differential over limited time intervals. The Na-K exchange between
stress applied that allows to be used as a paleopiezometer. perthites and host grain is independent of bulk composition
Presence of flame perthite in granitoids is an indicator of with respective to growth zones, followed by formation of
paleostress and could be used as a paleopiezometer (Pryer coarse grained patch perthite during deuteric alteration
and Robin, 1995). It can also be used as a powerful tool to (Abart et al., 2009a).
quantify the tectonic stress exerted on the host rock at
the time of their formation. The paleopiezometer proposed
ANALYTICAL TECHNIQUES
by Twiss (1977) is more acceptable for flame perthite
considering the elastic parameters of feldspar minerals and Polished thin sections of rock samples containing
width of recrystallized grains. The recrystallized grain size
Table 1. Grain size of flame perthite in Malanjkhand and Dongargarh
paleopiezometer is very useful in examining the tectonic granitoids
processes but precaution has been taken due to some
Sample No. Length Width Differential
limitations such as (i) it represents steady state recrystallizing (µm) (µm) Stress (MPa)
processes and (ii) theoretically, grain size must be more than
Malanjkhand Granitoid
double of its width.
004/18_12 41.9 3.1 163.5
In the Malanjkhand granitoid, the lamellae of perthite 004/18_12 35.7 2.0 200.4
are smaller in size; careful measurements were made using 004/18_12 32.5 1.5 228.1
Leica Qwin image analysis software attached with a Leica 004/18_12 29.5 1.1 262.0
004/18_12 35.3 1.5 221.8
DM4500 petrological microscope at Department of Geology
004/18_12 58.3 3.6 138.9
and Geophysics, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, 004/18_12 67.9 3.8 129.5
India. Observable sizes of flame perthites are considered 004/18_12 52.0 2.7 159.2
for the estimation of differential stress on the Malanjkhand 004/18_12 93.3 4.3 111.4
004/18_12 82.8 3.2 128.3
granitoid. The average size of the lamellae observed is
004/18_12 24.1 1.5 252.5
~50 µm in length having an average width of 2.5 µm. The 004/18_12 46.3 1.7 193.8
estimated differential stress ranges from 111-262 MPa Average 50.0 2.5 182.5
(Table 1) calculated using the formulation of Twiss (1977). Minimum 24.1 1.1 111.4
Maximum 93.3 4.3 262.0
The observed paleostress is nearly equivalents with the
lithostatic pressure 55-179 MPa estimated using fluid Dongargarh Granitoid

inclusion thermo-barometry (Panigrahi and Mookherjee, 115 491.5 19.9 37.6


115 506.9 17.3 39.0
1997). In case of Dongargarh granitoids, the lamellae of
115 550.5 12.8 42.1
perthite are larger in size compared to the Malanjkhand 115 473.0 13.7 43.3
perthites, the relevant length of perthite lamellae ranges 153- 115 405.1 15.3 43.9
550 µm with corresponding width ranges 6-20 µm (Table 115 325.3 10.7 53.5
115 153.4 6.5 81.8
1). A differential stress 38-81 MPa calculated using grain
Average 415.1 13.7 48.7
size paleo-piezometry. Minimum 153.4 6.5 37.6
Yund et al. (1974) suggested that at maximum Maximum 550.5 19.9 81.8

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


GEOCHEMISTRY OF FELDSPAR INTERGROWTH MICROTEXTURES FROM GRANITOIDS IN CENTRAL INDIA 169

feldspar intergrowth microtextures (perthites and perthite and their corresponding host K-feldspar grain were
myrmekites) were analyzed with a five spectrometer analyzed with EPMA for major element oxides
CAMECA SX100 Electron Microprobe at EPMA compositions. The major element compositions of flame
Laboratory, Geological Survey of India, Kolkata at a perthite and K-feldspar from Malanjkhand and Dongargarh
condition of 20 KeV accelerating voltage, 15 nA beam granitoids are presented in Table 2. The difficulty arises in
current, 1 µm beam size and 20 seconds counting time for analysing the flame perthite from Malanjkhand samples as
major element analysis. All natural silicate standards were they are of small size, however repeated runs were made to
used. A JEOL JSM-5800 scanning electron microscope determine the chemical composition.
(SEM) at Central Research Facilities, Indian Institute of In Malanjkhand granitoid, composition of flame perthite
Technology Kharagpur, India, operated at 20 kV used for comprises of Si content 2.682-2.994, Al content 1.0-1.357,
the study of feldspar intergrowth morphology. Samples were Ca content <0.211 cations per formula unit (cpfu), Na
coated with a thin film of gold with help of a Polaron sputter content 0.752-1.016, and K content <0.012 cpfu. Most of
coater before analysis. the flame perthites are Na-rich with significant quantity of
Ca. The composition of K-feldspar comprises of Si content
2.826-2.989, Al content 1.011-1.239, K content 0.933-0.984,
PERTHITE COMPOSITION
Na content <0.051 cpfu and Ca is below the detection limit.
Flame and patch perthite are commonly observed in both In Dongargarh granitoids, composition of flame perthite
granitoids whereas vein perthite rarely occurs. Only, flame comprises of Si content 2.971-2.983, Al content 1.011-1.032,

Table 2. Electron Probe Micro Analysis and structural formulae of perthite (plagioclase) and co-existing K-feldspar from Malanjkhand and Dongargarh
granitoids. Major element oxides are expressed in weight percent and elements are presented in cations per formula unit (cpfu)
Slide No Point# SiO2 Al2O3 CaO Na2O K2O Total Si Al Ca Na K Sum
Malanjkhand Granitoid
41 2 68.63 19.79 0.07 12.06 0.06 100.67 2.982 1.014 0.003 1.016 0.003 5.020
41 5 68.88 19.52 0.08 12.01 0.05 100.55 2.994 1.000 0.004 1.012 0.003 5.013
717 14 66.33 21.11 1.70 10.95 0.08 100.23 2.907 1.091 0.080 0.930 0.004 5.015
Perthite 004/18_12 24 68.30 20.25 0.58 11.71 0.11 100.95 2.962 1.035 0.027 0.985 0.006 5.015
(Plagioclase) 004/18_12 30 64.00 22.80 3.76 9.68 0.08 100.42 2.817 1.183 0.177 0.826 0.004 5.007
78(2) 33 60.06 25.78 4.42 8.69 0.21 99.35 2.682 1.357 0.211 0.752 0.012 5.020
78(2) 36 68.30 20.30 0.64 11.67 0.09 101.32 2.959 1.037 0.030 0.980 0.005 5.014
41 1 64.04 18.37 0 0.43 16.37 100.15 2.988 1.011 0 0.039 0.976 5.014
41 4 64.00 18.46 0 0.30 16.56 100.23 2.985 1.015 0 0.027 0.986 5.014
717 16 64.67 18.49 0 0.30 16.67 100.36 2.989 1.008 0 0.027 0.984 5.012
004/18_12 26 64.40 18.72 0 0.50 16.53 101.16 2.979 1.021 0 0.045 0.976 5.021
K-feldspar 004/18_12 27 64.26 18.57 0 0.42 16.40 100.80 2.985 1.017 0 0.038 0.973 5.012
004/18_12 28 64.14 18.54 0 0.42 16.54 100.48 2.983 1.016 0 0.038 0.982 5.019
004/18_12 29 64.16 18.61 0 0.32 16.65 100.69 2.980 1.019 0 0.029 0.988 5.018
78(2) 34 63.88 19.38 0 0.57 16.18 100.50 2.826 1.239 0 0.038 0.933 5.039
78(2) 37 64.62 18.46 0 0.47 16.44 100.46 2.955 1.057 0 0.051 0.956 5.020
Dongargarh Granitoid
d115 48 68.27 19.91 0.34 11.50 0.15 100.24 2.977 1.024 0.016 0.972 0.008 5.000
d115 49 66.47 19.19 0.16 7.46 7.40 100.88 2.971 1.011 0.008 0.646 0.422 5.058
d115 53 68.47 19.81 0.24 11.38 0.86 100.80 2.979 1.016 0.011 0.960 0.048 5.016
Perthite d115 57 68.53 19.71 0.24 11.81 0.12 100.47 2.983 1.012 0.011 0.997 0.007 5.012
(Plagioclase) d115 59 68.49 19.82 0.18 11.76 0.11 100.37 2.983 1.018 0.008 0.993 0.006 5.008
d115 60 66.45 19.36 0.07 6.91 7.81 100.71 2.971 1.020 0.003 0.599 0.446 5.042
d102 62 68.27 20.06 0.59 11.39 0.04 100.41 2.973 1.030 0.028 0.962 0.002 4.994
d102 70 68.26 20.13 0.72 11.21 0.12 100.57 2.970 1.032 0.034 0.946 0.007 4.990
d115 47 62.91 18.13 0.01 0.23 16.44 97.76 2.984 1.014 0.001 0.021 0.996 5.017
d115 50 64.92 18.46 0 0.19 16.89 100.48 2.994 1.004 0 0.017 0.995 5.010
d115 52 64.35 18.47 0 0.18 16.83 99.94 2.986 1.011 0 0.016 0.997 5.014
K-feldspar d115 55 64.23 18.41 0 0.28 16.87 99.87 2.985 1.009 0 0.025 1.001 5.023
d115 58 64.23 18.17 0 0.27 16.74 99.43 2.995 0.999 0 0.024 0.997 5.016
d102 63 64.46 18.78 0 0.52 16.22 100.02 2.980 1.024 0 0.047 0.958 5.010
d102 67 64.60 18.44 0 0.43 16.27 99.76 2.994 1.008 0 0.039 0.963 5.003

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


170 DINESH PANDIT

Ca content <0.034, Na content 0.599-0.997, and K content (Yuguchi and Nishiyama, 2008). Petrographic microphoto-
<0.048 cpfu. However, in few samples K content (0.422- graphs (Fig. 2a, d) and compositional variations in perthite
0.446 cpfu) is higher possibly due to presence of K-feldspar grains indicate that deuteric alteration was deeply influenced
inclusions in perthite. Most of the flame perthites are Na- these granitoids possibly due to Na-K exchange processes
rich but in some cases significant quantity of K content is between perthite and host K-feldspar grain. Systematic
also recorded. The composition of K-feldspar comprises of Na-K and Ca-K chemical exchange mechanism is observed
Si content 2.984-2.994, Al content 0.999-1.024, K content in Ab-Or-An diagrams (Fig. 3a, b) in Malanjkhand as well
0.958-1.001, Na content <0.047 cpfu, and Ca is below as in Dongargarh granitoids. Hence, the mutual replacement
detection limit (Table 2). mechanism (Yuguchi and Nishiyama, 2008; Parsons and Lee,
Composition of flame perthite from Malanjkhand 2009; Parsons et al., 2009, 2010) is considered as the
granitoid plotted on triangular Ab-Or-An diagram shows governing factor for the origin of perthites (Appendix:
high-albite to high-andesine type (Fig. 3a). In case of Reaction 1).
Dongargarh granitoids, flame perthites are high-albite and
two samples are Na-sanidine type (Fig. 3b). The composition
MYRMEKITE MICROSTRUCTURES
of host K-feldspar in Malanjkhand granitoid ranges Or96.6
to Or98.2 and the same for Dongargarh granitoids with Myrmekite is a vermicular or wormy intergrowth or
Or96.9 to Or98.9 (Table 3). Overall, host K-feldspar has more branching rods of quartz between plagioclase and K-
or less similar composition in both granitoids. Flame feldspar. It is one of the most common types of symplectite
perthites has wider range of compositional variation than (Shelley, 1997). However, since it occurs in various
host K-feldspar (Fig. 3a, b), which is uncommon in sub- petrological settings, it is difficult to explain the origin of
solvus granitoids (Worden et al., 1990). This may be a myrmekites (Ashworth, 1986). The myrmekite classification
possible case of deuteric/hydrothermal sub-solidus processes was proposed by Phillips (1974) based on the geological

Table 3. End member mole fractions of perthites (plagioclase) – K-feldspar co-existing pairs and temperature estimated using binary feldspar thermometry
(Benisek et al., 2004) at lithostatic pressure (100 and 200 MPa).
Malanjkhand Granitoid
Slide No 41 41 717 717 004/18_12 004/18_12 004/18_12 004/18_12 78(2) 78(2)
Point# 2 5 12 14 24 24 30 30 33 36
Perthite XAb 0.984 0.983 0.855 0.759 0.902 0.902 0.560 0.560 0.490 0.895
(Plagioclase) XOr 0.005 0.004 0.028 0.006 0.008 0.008 0.005 0.005 0.012 0.007
XAn 0.011 0.013 0.117 0.236 0.089 0.089 0.435 0.435 0.498 0.098
Point# 1 4 13 16 26 27 28 29 34 37
K-feldspar XAb 0.026 0.018 0.024 0.018 0.029 0.025 0.025 0.019 0.034 0.028
XOr 0.974 0.982 0.976 0.982 0.971 0.975 0.975 0.981 0.966 0.972
XAn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
P = 1 kb
Ab T(oC ) 414 406 466 535 462 457 683 666 780 466
P = 2 kb
Ab T(oC ) 426 418 466 547 474 468 698 681 797 478
Dongargarh Granitoid
Slide No d115 d115 d115 d115 d115 d115 d102 d102
Point# 48 49 53 57 59 60 62 70
Perthite XAb 0.933 0.491 0.895 0.952 0.962 0.465 0.903 0.878
(Plagioclase) XOr 0.012 0.487 0.068 0.010 0.009 0.526 0.003 0.009
XAn 0.055 0.021 0.038 0.039 0.029 0.009 0.094 0.113
Point# 47 50 52 55 58 58 63 67
K-feldspar XAb 0.014 0.011 0.011 0.016 0.016 0.016 0.031 0.026
XOr 0.985 0.989 0.989 0.984 0.984 0.984 0.969 0.974
XAn 0.001 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
P = 1 kb
Ab T(oC ) 422 315 415 417 412 281 466 472
P = 2 kb
Ab T(oC ) 434 324 427 429 424 289 478 484

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


GEOCHEMISTRY OF FELDSPAR INTERGROWTH MICROTEXTURES FROM GRANITOIDS IN CENTRAL INDIA 171

Fig.3. Ternary classification diagram Ab-An-Or for feldspar showing compositional variation in perthites and co-existing K-feldspars in
(a) Malanjkhand granitoids and (b) Dongargarh granitoids.

environment. It is used to identify various types of deuteric alteration in plagioclase is less prominent. Various
myrmekites such as rim, intergranular, lobate, bulbous, types of myrmekites observed in Dongargarh granitoids are
ghost (Collins, 1997a, b, c), and wartlike myrmekite (Collins, ghost, bulbous, rim, wartlike, enclosed, and intergranular
2003). (Fig. 4d-f). The microscopic intergrowth of quartz,
In the Malanjkhand granitoid, myrmekites are micro- plagioclase, and K-feldspar is strongly developed. Ghost
scopic in scale and characteristically occur along grain and bulbous myrmekites are commonly occur between
boundaries between plagioclase and K-feldspar crystals. It plagioclase and K-feldspar grain boundaries. K-feldspar
is grown inwards from grain boundaries, invading, and grain shows cross hatch twining adjacent to untwined
replacing K-feldspar. Quartz rods has bulbous appearance plagioclase grain hosting a rim of myrmekite. The wartlike
and branch out in parallel direction away from plagioclase. myrmekite (Fig. 4d) is characteristically different due to
Various forms of myrmekites are found in Malanjkhand presence of perthitic K-feldspar and plagioclase with
granitoid such as ghost, bulbous, rim, wartlike, enclosed, lamellar twinning. It indicates that myrmekite originated
and intergranular types (Fig. 4a-f). The ghost myrmekite from primary minerals. The enclosed myrmekite (Fig. 4e)
shown in Fig. 4(a), has grown towards K-feldspar grains. of size >100 µm is present within the large porphyroclasts
Altered plagioclase grains associated with ghost myrmekite of untwined K-feldspar adjacent to altered biotite. The
indicates deuteric alteration. Typical bulbous type myrmekite location of intergranular myrmekite (Fig. 4f) is completely
having a size >100 µm observed in Fig. 4(b), in which growth restricted to interfaces between K-feldspars and plagioclase,
pattern is towards K-feldspar. Quartz rods are present in which is extremely rare feature in Dongargarh granitoids.
ghost myrmekite as well as in bulbous myrmekite indicating Myrmekite is attributed to late-stage deuteric alteration
excess silica precipitation. The grain boundary of plagioclase reaction at moderate to low temperature between K-feldspar
migrates towards adjacent K-feldspar grain formed rim and plagioclase with intergrowth of vermicular quartz.
myrmekite structure (Fig. 4c), where inclusions of
saussuritized plagioclase provide strong evidence of deuteric
MYRMEKITE COMPOSITION
alteration. The wartlike myrmekite occur between biotite
and K-feldspar grain, and characteristic microcline twining Various types of myrmekites and their corresponding host
in K-feldspar indicates low temperature origin (Goldsmith K-feldspar grain were analyzed with EPMA for major
and Laves, 1954). The intergranular myrmekite is between element oxides composition. The major element
grain boundary of untwined K-feldspar and altered compositions of myrmekites and K-feldspar grains from
plagioclase characterized by the presence of long trails of Malanjkhand and Dongargarh granitoids are presented in
quartz rods. Table 4.
In Dongargarh granitoids, myrmekitic textures are quite The composition of myrmekites in Malanjkhand
similar to that of Malanjkhand granitoid but the nature of granitoid is Si content 2.994-2.908, Al content 1.002-1.090,

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


)LJXUH
&OLFNKHUHWRGRZQORDGKLJKUHVROXWLRQLPDJH

172 DINESH PANDIT

Fig.4. Microphotographs of various types of myrmekites from Malanjkhand granitoids: (a) ghost, (b) bulbous, (c) rim; and some
representative myrmekites from Dongargarh granitoids: (d) warlike, (e) enclosed, and (f) intergranular types. Abbreviations:
Myrm – myrmekite; Kfs – K-feldspar, Plag – plagioclase, and Qtz – quartz.

Ca content <0.085, Na content <1.017, and K content <0.046 K-feldspar present along with myrmekites comprises of Si
apfu but in sample no 41 (spot no 7) having 8.78 wt % of content 2.985 2.989, Al content 1.011-1.019, K content
K2O, quite high compared to other analysis. SiO2 content in 0.971-0.983, Na content <0.039 apfu, and Ca content is
sample no 78(2) is low whereas in sample no 41 it is high, below detection limit.
possibly due to silica mobilization during formation of In Dongargarh granitoids, the myrmekites have Si
myrmekites. Most of the myrmekites are Na-rich while some content 2.884-2.964, Al content 1.031-1.098, Ca content
of them have significant quantity of Ca. The composition of <0.108, Na content 0.793-0.972, and K content <0.007, but

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


GEOCHEMISTRY OF FELDSPAR INTERGROWTH MICROTEXTURES FROM GRANITOIDS IN CENTRAL INDIA 173

Table 4. Electron Probe Micro Analysis and structural formulae of myrmekite (plagioclase) – K-feldspar co-existing pairs from Malanjkhand and
Dongargarh granitoids. Major element oxides are expressed in weight percent and elements are presented in cations per formula unit (cpfu)
Slide No Point# SiO2 Al2O3 CaO Na2O K2O Total Si Al Ca Na K Sum
Malanjkhand Granitoid
41 3 68.30 19.39 0.07 11.83 0.07 99.66 2.994 1.002 0.003 1.006 0.004 5.009
41 6 68.97 19.75 0.13 11.68 0.07 100.60 2.991 1.010 0.006 0.982 0.004 4.996
41 7 81.98 10.35 0 0.15 8.78 101.26 - - - - - -
717 9 67.22 21.19 0.86 10.57 0.83 100.67 2.921 1.086 0.040 0.891 0.046 5.000
717 11 69.20 20.17 0.37 11.61 0.07 101.42 2.979 1.024 0.017 0.969 0.004 4.995
Myrmekite 717 12 66.57 20.01 0.77 11.23 0.37 98.95 2.949 1.045 0.037 0.965 0.021 5.021
(Plagioclase) 717 15 68.65 20.08 0.33 11.78 0.07 100.91 2.973 1.025 0.015 0.989 0.004 5.010
004/18_12 19 66.90 21.26 1.82 10.88 0.08 100.94 2.908 1.090 0.085 0.917 0.004 5.007
004/18_12 22 68.65 19.83 0.08 12.08 0.09 100.73 2.981 1.015 0.004 1.017 0.005 5.023
78(2) 32 49.75 36.94 1.27 7.70 0.54 96.20 - - - - - -
78(2) 35 40.43 46.24 1.64 5.69 0.16 94.16 - - - - - -
41 1 64.04 18.37 0 0.43 16.37 99.21 2.988 1.011 0 0.039 0.976 5.014
41 4 64.00 18.46 0 0.30 16.56 99.32 2.985 1.015 0 0.027 0.986 5.014
717 8 64.62 18.50 0 0.41 16.64 100.17 3.485 0.519 0 0.012 0.477 4.499
717 10 65.11 18.66 0 0.30 16.76 100.83 2.989 1.009 0 0.037 0.983 5.017
K-feldspar 717 13 64.95 18.76 0 0.40 16.61 100.72 2.989 1.010 0 0.027 0.983 5.010
717 17 64.66 18.56 0 0.39 16.42 100.03 2.989 1.008 0 0.027 0.984 5.012
717 18 64.30 18.56 0 0.40 16.40 99.66 2.988 1.011 0 0.035 0.969 5.007
004/18_12 23 64.09 18.56 0 0.36 16.33 99.34 2.985 1.016 0 0.036 0.972 5.011
004/18_12 25 64.70 18.80 0 1.40 14.94 99.84 2.985 1.019 0 0.033 0.971 5.008
Dongargarh Granitoid
d115 40 65.57 21.18 2.30 11.06 0.08 100.19 2.884 1.098 0.108 0.943 0.004 5.040
d115 44 67.25 20.09 0.58 11.36 0.06 99.34 2.961 1.043 0.027 0.970 0.003 5.004
Myrmekite d102 83 65.01 20.39 0.59 9.97 0.73 96.69 2.941 1.087 0.029 0.874 0.042 4.974
(Plagioclase) d135 89 67.42 19.94 0.52 9.87 3.51 101.26 2.955 1.031 0.024 0.839 0.197 5.047
d135 93 58.33 18.16 0.32 8.05 0.10 84.96 2.964 1.088 0.017 0.793 0.006 4.885
d135 96 66.66 20.03 1.25 11.36 0.12 99.42 2.943 1.042 0.059 0.972 0.007 5.026
d115 41 64.28 18.43 0 0.34 16.92 99.97 2.985 1.009 0 0.031 1.003 5.028
d115 46 64.22 18.29 0 0.29 16.75 99.55 2.989 1.004 0 0.026 0.996 5.018
K-feldspar d102 84 64.69 18.50 0 0.37 16.47 100.03 2.992 1.009 0 0.033 0.973 5.007
d135 88 64.04 17.97 0 0.22 16.81 99.04 2.998 0.992 0 0.020 1.005 5.017
d135 94 64.14 17.89 0 0.19 16.82 99.04 3.003 0.988 0 0.017 1.006 5.014

in sample no d102 the K content 0.197 apfu is relatively relatively higher during deuteric/hydrothermal alterations.
high compared to other analysis. The composition of In the present study, a combine effect of Na-K and
K-feldspar associated with myrmekites comprises Si Ca-K simultaneous replacement mechanism (Yuguchi and
content 2.985-3.003, Al content 0.992-1.042, K content Nishiyama, 2007, 2008; Parsons and Lee, 2009; Parsons et
0.973 1.006, Na content <0.033, and Ca content is below al., 2009, 2010) is observed among all varieties of
detection limit. myrmekites and also considered as one of the most
Composition of myrmekites plotted on triangular common chemical exchange reaction between K-feldspar
Ab-Or-An diagram indicates variation from high-albite to and plagioclase grains (Fig. 5a, b). The overall reaction is
high-oligoclase (Ab74.5 to Ab98.3) in Malanjkhand granitoids an open system (Appendix: Reactions 1, 2 and 3). The
(Fig. 5a) which is also similar (Ab 68.4 to Ab 90.3) for evidence of K-feldspar replacement during myrmekitization
Dongargarh granitoids (Fig.5b). The composition of K- is also supported by microphotographs in Fig. 4(a-f) where
feldspar in Malanjkhand varies from Or91.4 to Or97.8 and in myrmekite grows inwards into K-feldspar grain.
Dongargarh it is Or97.8 to Or98.9 (Table 5). This indicates a
restricted composition in both the granitoids (Fig. 5a-b) as
TWO FELDSPAR GEOTHERMOMETRY
a result of minimum hydrothermal alteration which is also
supported in microphotographs (Fig. 4a-f). In present Physical parameters like pressure and temperature plays
study, Si and Al content in myrmekites are variable in wide most significant role in partitioning of the elements between
ranges, which suggest that silica remobilization was plagioclase and K-feldspar. It may also attain kinetic

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


174 DINESH PANDIT

Table 5. End member mole fractions of myrmekite (plagioclase) – K-feldspar co-existing pairs and temperature estimated
using binary feldspar thermometry (Benisek et al., 2004) at lithostatic pressure (100 and 200 MPa).
Malanjkhand Granitoid
Slide No 41 41 717 717 717 717 004/18_12 004/18_12
Point# 3 6 9 11 12 15 19 22
Myrmekite XAb 0.983 0.973 0.806 0.935 0.855 0.942 0.745 0.980
(Plagioclase) XOr 0.006 0.006 0.063 0.006 0.028 0.006 0.005 0.007
XAn 0.012 0.022 0.131 0.06 0.117 0.053 0.249 0.013
Point# 1 4 8 10 13 17 23 25
K-feldspar XAb 0.026 0.018 0.024 0.018 0.024 0.023 0.022 0.086
XOr 0.974 0.982 0.976 0.982 0.976 0.977 0.978 0.914
XAn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
P = 1 kb
o
Ab T( C ) 415 411 497 431 466 433 550 475
P = 2 kb
Ab T(oC ) 427 422 509 442 466 445 563 488
Dongargarh Granitoid
Slide No d115 d115 d102 d135 d135 d135
Point# 40 44 83 89 93 96
Myrmekite XAb 0.703 0.903 0.839 0.684 0.916 0.813
(Plagioclase) XOr 0.005 0.005 0.061 0.243 0.011 0.009
XAn 0.292 0.092 0.099 0.072 0.073 0.179
Slide No d115 d115 d102 d135 d135 d135
Point# 41 46 84 88 94 94
K-feldspar XAb 0.020 0.017 0.022 0.013 0.011 0.011
XOr 0.980 0.983 0.978 0.987 0.989 0.989
XAn 0 0 0 0 0 0
P = 1 kb
Ab T(oC ) 574 447 471 444 429 490
P = 2 kb
Ab T(oC ) 587 458 479 694 717 588

equilibrium during cooling. Hence, application of two DISCUSSION


feldspar thermometry within the calibration range is Formation of various microtextures within feldspars
considered for formation of intergrowth microtexture were related with the cooling of granitic magma and post
between K-feldspar and plagioclase. Flame perthite (albite- emplacement conditions. The origin of perthite and
rich) within host K-feldspar is considered as co-existing myrmekite intergrowth microtextures in granitoid rocks is
pairs forming binary feldspar solid solution. The formulation highly debatable. Many researchers have used these
of two feldspar thermometry (Benisek et al. 2004) is microtextures as a tool to study the cooling history of the
applicable for estimating the temperature of flame perthite rocks (Harlov and Wirth, 2000; Nanda et al., 2009), which
formation. The calculated differential stress on granitoids is also related to exsolution and hydrothermal sub-solidus
as discussed above is considered as lithostatic pressure at processes. Feldspars in granitic rock are highly turbid to
which flame perthite was formed. A range of temperature some extent due to deuteric alterations, which occurred
406-780oC at 100 MPa is estimated for the formation of during the cooling of the rock through interactions either
flame perthite in Malanjkhand granitoid (Table 3). Similarly, with deuteric or hydrothermal solutions (Worden et al.,
a range of temperature 281-472oC at 100 MPa is estimated 1990). Intergrowth features between two different feldspars
for Dongargarh granitoids (Table 3). Suitable co-existing are common in these rocks such as perthites and myrmekites.
pairs of myrmekites (albite-rich) and host K-feldspar is also There are different types of perthites, among them, flame
considered for two feldspar thermometry. A range of and patch perthite having characteristic features associated
temperature 411-550oC at 100 MPa for Malanjkhand and with their physicochemical conditions. Flame perthite is one
429-574oC at 100 MPa for Dongargarh granitoids calculated of the important intergrowth between albite and K-feldspar
for the formation myrmekites (Table 5). (Stel, 1986) and its growth is dependent on the presence of

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


GEOCHEMISTRY OF FELDSPAR INTERGROWTH MICROTEXTURES FROM GRANITOIDS IN CENTRAL INDIA 175

Fig.5. Chemical compositions in various types of myrmekites and co-existing K-feldspars from (a) Malanjkhand granitoids and
(b) Dongargarh granitoids.

H2O (Parsons, 1978). A stress environment appears to favor 800 oC at a lithostatic pressure of 260 MPa with rapid cooling
the formation of perthite, where aqueous fluid pressure was and continued to late stage hydrothermal alterations around
significantly lower than lithostatic pressure during their 400 oC in upper crustal level. On the other hand, flame
formation (Pryer and Robin, 1995). perthites formed in Dongargarh granitoids within restricted
Petrographic observations suggest that formation of range of temperature 472-315 oC at a lithostatic pressure
flame perthite in the Malanjkhand and the Dongargarh <100 MPa with more or less similar reactions mechanism
granitoids was dominantly due to the Na-K ion exchange for flame perthite formations but continued <500 oC. More
mechanism between K-feldspar and plagioclase. A simplified Ca-rich perthite having high An-content indicate a higher
path of flame perthite formation was computed using temperature of formation (Yund and Ackermand, 1979).
mineral-mineral equilibria calculation by Na-K exchange However, in both the cases, there is no significant effect of
reaction (Appendix: Reaction 1) which indicates enrichment Ca-K reaction (Appendix: Reaction 2) during the formation
of Na content in albite with decreasing temperature in of perthites. Simplified computed trends of the flame perthite
Malanjkhand granitoid, whereas, it increases with rise in growth and the effect of temperature on their composition
temperature for Dongargarh granitoids (Fig. 6a). In are shown in the Ab (mole %) versus temperature diagram
Malanjkhand granitoid, perthite formation started around (Fig. 6b).

Fig.6. A mineral-mineral equilibria calculation shows: (a) equilibrium constant versus T (oC) during and (b) Composition of perthite
(Ab mole %) versus T (oC) during perthite formation. Symbols, solid circle represent Malanjkhand and empty circle for Dongargarh
granitoids, respectively.

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


176 DINESH PANDIT

Fig.7. A mineral-mineral equilibria calculation shows: (a) equilibrium constant versus temperature (oC) during and (b) Composition of
myrmekite (Ab mole %) versus temperature (oC) during myrmekite formation. Symbols as discussed in Fig. 6.

Petrographic and thermobarometric calculations suggest


that formation of myrmekites in the Malanjkhand granitoid
possibly due to the mutual replacement processes between
K-feldspar and plagioclase by coupled Na-K and Ca-K
exchange mechanism at low to moderate (422-563 oC)
temperature conditions (Fig. 7a, b). A simplified computed
path for myrmekitization indicates Na-enrichment during
cooling of these granitoids. Yuguchi and Nishiyama (2008)
suggested a systematic increase in SiO2 proportion in
myrmekite with decomposition of host K-feldspar which is
related to albitization of plagioclase via diffusive transport
mechanism. The equilibrium constant for the formation of
myrmekite is highly non-linear with respect to temperature
estimated using mineral-mineral equilibria calculation for
couple reactions (Appendix: Reaction 3). It indicates that
myrmekitization is not only depends on the temperature but
there are some other physicochemical parameters such as
original Ca content of alkali-feldspar (Philips, 1964) and
presence of H2O (Parsons, 1978) may be also responsible
for its formation.
SEM images are taken to study the morphology of
feldspar intergrowth microtextures. Perthitic intergrowths
behave as a single phase, incoherent subgrains of low albite
and microcline, with micropores at their boundaries.
Intracrystal microtextures in K-feldspar are anhedral in
shape, elongated flames as well as patches are observed
(Fig. 8a). Microgranular cavities and dissolution
Fig.8. BSE images in a polished thin section shows morphology
microtextures are well developed during growth of
of intergrowth microtextures in K-feldspar from
myrmekites. Myrmekitic intergrowth comprises of various
Malanjkhand granitoid. (a) Ab-rich flame perthite with
phases, micropores of SiO2 with incoherent sub-grains relatively broad lamellae and straight exsolution lamellae
of albite and microcline (Fig. 8b). In BSE images, of albite in K-feldspar. (b) Higher magnification image of
morphological features of perthite and myrmekite myrmekite intergrowth showing exsolution pits in K-
intergrowths indicates that mutual replacement processes feldspar grain.

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


GEOCHEMISTRY OF FELDSPAR INTERGROWTH MICROTEXTURES FROM GRANITOIDS IN CENTRAL INDIA 177

Fig.9. SEM images in a polished thin section shows intergrowth microtextures in K-feldspar from Dongargarh granitoids. (a) Intergrowth
microtexture shows transitions between braid perthite and K-feldspar. Braid perthite forms a regular, fine-scale intergrowth with
‘threads’ of microcline enclosing ‘lozenges’ of albite. Grain boundary is marked by dark grey line represent a calcite veins.
(b) Compositional variation in myrmekite microtexture with intergranular SiO2-rich veins. Albite is dark grey and microcline is
light grey.

in K-feldspar was one of the possible mechanism by which microtextures developed in primary K-feldspar, in some
these microtextures had developed (Pryer and Robin, 1995; cases, entire crystals are composed of flame perthite. But in
Yuguchi and Nishiyama, 2007, 2008; Parsons and Lee, 2009; SEM images, it is clear that these are relics of braid perthite
Parsons et al., 2009, 2010). (Fig. 9a). Further, regular boundaries are also observed
Flame perthite has changed to coarser braid perthite in which marked the outlines of ghost myrmekite intergrowth
large K-feldspar crystal have pervasively recrystallized by (Fig. 9b). Rod- and granular-shaped SiO2-rich phase
dissolution-reprecipitation reactions. Although perthitic observed as more grey colour feature within myrmekite.

Fig.10. Plots of chemical variations with temperature related to intergrowth of feldspar microtextures in the Malanjkhand (MG) and
Dongargarh granitoids (DG): (a) SiO2 vs. T (oC), (b) Al2O3 vs. T (oC), (c) CaO vs. T (oC), and (d) Na2O vs. T (oC) with arrow
mark showing cooling path.

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


178 DINESH PANDIT

Intergranular fluid infiltrated along grain boundaries and Temperature versus composition plots (Fig. 10a-d) indicates
limited deuteric/sub-solidus reactions with huge volume of that composition of intergrowth microtextures changes with
K-feldspar subject to mutual replacement caused cooling processes. Calculated temperature ranges suggested
development of myrmekites in granitoids (Yuguchi and that the exchange reaction took place in two stages such as
Nishiyama, 2007, 2008). exsolution and hydrothermal sub-solidus processes.
Intergrowth microtextures developed within K-feldspar
(perthites and myrmekites) in the Malanjkhand and
CONCLUSIONS
Dongargarh granitoids are indicators of moderate to hot
The careful petrographic observation of K-feldspar and tectonic regime at shallow level in the continental crust.
plagioclase reveals the presence of various types of perthites However, a more appropriate observation on perthitization
(flame, patch, and vein) and myrmekites (ghost, rim, and myrmekitization can be obtained on the basis of mineral-
bulbous, intergranular, wartlike, and enclosed). Intergrowth chemical data supported from other granitic plutons, which
phases are mostly albitic hosted in K-feldspar crystals. can be extended for future scope of this work.
Deuteric alteration of nearby plagioclase provide sufficient
amount of Na in the growth of perthites (Pryer and Robin, Acknowledgements: DP acknowledged to Council of
1995). However, coarser perthites, particularly vein and Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), Government of
patch types are usually associated with areas of hydrothermal India for financial support in terms of research fellowship
alteration and followed by deuteric coarsening below ~400 and the present paper is a part of his Ph. D research program.
o
C temperature (Parsons and Brown, 1984). On the basis of Prof. Mruganka K. Panigrahi, IIT Kharagpur and Dr. Rajesh
chemical composition and mineral equilibria calculation, it K. Naik, Geological Survey of India, Kolkata is duly
is suggested that flame perthite has originated by exsolution acknowledged for their consistent support in research during
mechanism imposed by differential stress on the host rock my tenure at IIT Kharagpur. Author also likes to thanks for
and subsequent growth of coarser perthites (braids and patch technical support from B. Chattopadhyay, S. K. Sengupta,
types) was controlled by deuteric/hydrothermal sub-solidus and S. Nandi, EPMA Laboratory, Geological Survey of
reactions. Thermobarometric calculations indicates that India, for the EPMA analysis at Kolkata. The instructive
myrmekite formation under moderate to high temperature comments of an anonymous reviewer greatly improved the
conditions (420-570 oC) influenced by mutual exchange content and structure of the manuscript and the editorial
mechanism between K-feldspar and plagioclase. advised by Prof. B. Mahabaleswar is greatly appreciated.

References

ABART, R., PETRISHCHEVA, E., WIRTH, R. and RHEDE, D. (2009a) ASHWORTH, J.R. (1972) Myrmekite of exsolution and replacement
Exsolution by spinodal decomposition II: perthite formation origins. Geological Mag., v.109, pp.45-62.
during slow cooling of anatexites from Ngornghoro, Tanzania. BARKER, D.S. (1970) Composition of granophyre, myrmekite, and
Amer. Jour. Sci., v.309, pp.450-475. graphic granite. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull., v.81, pp.3339-3350.
ABART, R., PETRISHCHEVA, E., KABNER, S. and MILKE, R. (2009b) BECKE, F. (1908) Über myrmekit. Mineralogie und Petrographie
Perthite microstructure in magmatic alkali feldspar with Mitteilungen, v.27, pp.377-390.
oscillatory zoning; Weinsberg granite, Upper Austria. Mineral. BENISEK, A., KROLL, H. and CEMIC, L. (2004) New developments
Petrol., v.97, pp.251-263. in two-feldspar thermometry Amer. Mineral., v.89, pp.1496–
ACHARYYA, S.K., BANDHYOPADHYAY, B.K. and ROY, A. (2001) 1504.
Comment on ’Two cases of continental collisions and related BHANDARI, A., PANT, N.C., BHOWMIK, S.K. and GOSWAMI, S. (2011)
tectonics during the Proterozoic period in India-insights from ~1.6 Ga ultrahigh-temperature granulite metamorphism in the
gravity modelling constrained by seismic and magnetotelluric Central Indian Tectonic Zone: insights from metamorphic
studies’ by Mishra C, Singh B, Tiwari V M, Gupta S B and reaction history, geothermobarometry and monazite chemical
Rao M B S V 2000 Precambrian Res., v.99, pp.149-169. ages. Geol. Jour., v.46, pp.198-216.
Precambrian Res., v.108, pp.335-338. BHATTACHARYYA, C. (1971) Myrmekite from the charnockitic rocks
ACHARYYA, S.K. and ROY, A. (2000) Tectonothermal history of the of the Eastern Ghats, India. Geol. Mag., v.108, pp.433-438.
Central Indian Tectonic zone and reactivation of major fault/ BHATTACHARYYA, C. (1972) Myrmekite from the charnockitic rocks
shear zones. Jour. Geol. Soc. India, v.55, pp.239-256. of the Eastern Ghats, India: a reply. Geol. Mag., v.109, pp.371-
ALING, H.L. (1938) Plutonic perthites. Jour. Geol., v.46, pp.142. 372.
ASHWORTH, J.R. (1986) Myrmekite replacing albite in prograde BHOWMIK, S.K, PAL, T. and ROY, A. (1998) Reworking of older
metamorphism. Amer. Mineral., v.71, pp.895-899. granulites during Sausar orogeny: an evidence from the

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


GEOCHEMISTRY OF FELDSPAR INTERGROWTH MICROTEXTURES FROM GRANITOIDS IN CENTRAL INDIA 179

northern margin of Sausar mobile belt in Central India. Indian metamorphism of hypersolvus granite, Rhode Island, USA.
Minerals, v.32, pp.19-20. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., v.72, pp. 353-365.
BHOWMIK, S.K., SARBADHIKARI, A.B., SPIERING, B. and RAITH, M.M. DE LAPPARENT, J. (1923) Lecons de Petrographie. Masson Paris,
(2005) Mesoproterozoic reworking of Paleoproterozoic pp.2014.
ultrahigh temperature granulites in the Central Indian Tectonic DESHPANDE, G.G. (1984) Petrology of the Dongargarh granties of
Zone and its implications. Jour. Petrol., v.46, pp.1085-1119. Chandi Dongari area, Drug district, Madhya Pradesh. Geol.
BROWN, W. and PARSONS, I. (1984a) Exsolution and coarsening Sur. India Spec. Publ., v.12, pp.7-15.
mechanisms and kinetics in an ordered cryptoperthite series. DRESCHER-KADEN, F.K. (1948) Die Feldspat-Quartz Reactions-
Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., v.86, pp.3-18. gefuge der Granite und Gneiss und ihre Genetische Bedeutung,
BROWN, W. and PARSONS, I. (1984b) The nature of potassium Berlin, Springer Verlag.
feldspar, exsolution microtextures and development of ESKOLA, P. (1952) On the granulites of Lappland. Amer. Jour. Sci.,
dislocations as a function of composition in perthitic alkali Bowen Vol Part I, pp.133-171.
feldspar. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., v.86, pp.335-341. GOLDSMITH, J.R. and LAVES, F. (1954) The microcline-sanidine
BROWN, W.L. and PARSONS, I. (1983) Nucleation on perthite- stability relations; Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, v.5, pp.1-19.
perthite boundaries and exsolution mechanisms in alkali HALL, A. (1966) A petrogenetic study of the Rosses Granite
feldspars. Phys. Chem. Minerals, v.10, pp.55-61. Comples, Donegal. Jour. Petrol., v.7, pp.202-220.
BUDDINGTON, A.F. (1939) Adirondack igneous rocks and their HARLOV, D.E. and WIRTH, R. (2000) K-feldspar-quartz and K-
metamorphism. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull., v.7, pp. 354. feldspar-plagioclase phase boundary interactions in garnet-
BURGESS, R., KELLEY , S.P., PARSONS, I., WALKER, F.D.L. and orthopyroxene gneiss’s from the Val Strona di Omegna, Ivrea-
WORDEN, R.H. (1992) 40Ar-39Ar analysis of perthite micro- Verbano Zone, northern Italy. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., v.140,
textures and fluid inclusions in alkali feldspar from the Klokken pp.148-162.
syenites, South Greenland. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., v.109, HASHIMOTO, K., AKAI, J. and NAKANO, S. (2005) Microtextures of
pp.147-167. alkali feldspar in the Tanakami granite, Southwest Japan and
CASTLE R.O. and LINDSLEY, D.H. (1993) An exsolution silica-pump their formation processes. Japan Mag. Mineral. Petrol. Sci.,
model for the origin of myrmekite; Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., v.34, pp.1-14.
v.115, pp.58-65. HEIER, K.S. (1955) The formation of feldspar perthites in highly
CHANGKAKOTI, A., PANDALAI, H.S., GRAY, J., AHMAD, S. and PERASUD, metamorphic gneisse.; Norsk Geol. Tidskr., v.35, pp.87-92.
E.R. (2006) Origin of fluorite mineralization and hydrothermal HIBBERD, M.J. (1979) Myrmekite as a marker between preaqueous
alteration at the Chandidongri deposit, Rajnandgaon district, and postaqueous phase saturation in granitic system. Geol.
Central India – evidence from oxygen and hydrogen isotopes. Soc. Amer. Bull., v.90, pp.1047-1062.
Jour. Geol. Soc. India, v.67, pp.33-40. HIGAZY, R.A. (1949) Petrogenesis of perthite pegmatites in the
C OHEN, B., DINSTEIN , I. and E YAL , M. (1997) A system for Black Hills, South Dakota. Jour. Geol., v.57, pp.555-581.
computerized classification of color textured perthite images. HUBBARD, F.H. (1967) Myrmekite in charnockite from southwest
Pattern Recognition, v.30, pp.1533-1545. Nigeria: a reply. Amer. Mineral., v.52, pp.920-923.
Collins, L.G. (1997a) Origin of myrmekite and metasomatic HUBBARD, M.J. (1966) Myrmekite in charnockite from southwest
granite: Myrmekite. v.1, pp.1526-5757. http://www.csun.edu/ Nigeria. Amer. Mineral., v.51, pp.762-773.
~vcgeo005/revised1.htm JAIN, S.C., NAIR, K.K. and YEDEKAR, D.B. (1995) Geology of Son-
COLLINS, L.G. (1997b) Replacement of primary plagioclase by Narmada-Tapti lineament zone of Central India. Geol. Surv.
secondary K-feldspar and myrmekite: Myrmekite. v.2. India Spl. Publ., v.10, pp.1-154.
pp.1526-5757. http://www.csun.edu/~vcgeo005/revised2. JAIN, S.C., YEDEKAR, D.B. and NAIR, K.K.K. (1991) Central Indian
htm shear zone: a major Precambrian crustal boundary. Jour. Geol.
COLLINS, L.G. (1997c) Myrmekite formed by Ca-metasomatism: Soc. India, v.37, pp.521-531.
Myrmekite. v.4, pp.1526-5757. http://www.csun.edu/ KRISHNAMURTHY, P., SINHA, D.K., RAI, A.K., SETH, D.K. and SINGH,
~vcgeo005/revised4.htm. S.N. (1990) Magmatic rocks of the Dongargarh Supergroup,
COLLINS, L.G. (1998) Metasomatic origin of the Cooma Complex Central India - their petrological evolution and implications
in southeastern Australia: Myrmekite, v.27, pp.1526-5757. on metallogeny. Geol. Surv. India Spec. Publ., v.28, pp.303-
http://www.csun.edu/~vcgeo005/cooma.htm 319.
COLLINS, L.G. (2003) Transition from magmatic to K-metasomatic KRISHNAMURTHY, P., CHAKI, A., PANDEY, B.K., CHIMOTE, J.S. and
processes in granodiorites and Pyramid Peak granite, Fallen SINGH, S.N. (1988) Geochronology of the granite-rhyolite
Leaf Lake 15-Minute Quadrangle, California, USA: suites of the Dongargarh Supergroup, Central India. 4th
Myrmekite. ISSN, v.48, pp.1526-5757. http://www.csun.edu/ National Symposium on Mass Spectrometry, Bangalore,
~vcgeo005/fallen.htm Preprint volume EPS-2, pp.1-5.
COGNE, J. (1951) Remarques Sur les schists crystallins du cours KUMAR, S. and RINO, V. (2006) Mineralogy and geochemistry of
inferieur de la Rance (IIIe-et-Vilaine). Bull. Soc. Geol. France, microgranular enclaves in Palaeoproterozoic Malanjkhand
v.6, pp.139-145. granitoids, central India: evidence of magma mixing, mingling,
D AY, H.W. and B ROWN, V.M. (1980) Evolution of perthite and chemical equilibration. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., v.152,
composition and microstructure during progressive pp.591- 609.

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


180 DINESH PANDIT

KUMAR, S., RINO, V. and PAL, A.B. (2004) Field evidence of magma K. (1993) Granitoids around the Malanjkhand copper deposit:
mixing from microgranular enclaves hosted in Type and age relationship. Proc. Indian Acad. Sci. (Earth
Palaeoproterozoic Malanjkhand granitoids, Central India. Planet. Sci.), v.102, pp.399-413.
Gondwana Res., v.2, pp.539-548. PANIGRAHI, M.K., NAIK, R.K., PANDIT, D. and MISRA, K.C. (2008)
LARSEN, E.S. (1949) Batholith and associated rocks of Corona, Reconstructing physico-chemical parameters of hydrothermal
Elsinore, and San Luis Rey quadrangles, southern California. mineralization at the Malanjkhand copper deposit, India from
Geol. Soc. Amer. Mem., pp.29. mineral chemistry of biotite, chlorite and epidote. Geochem.
LORIMER, G.W. and CHAMPNESS, P.E. (1973) The origin of the phase Jour., v.42, pp.443-460.
distribution in two perthitic alkali feldspar. Phil. Mag., v.28, PANIGRAHI, M.K., PANDIT, D. and NAIK, R.K. (2009) Genesis of
pp.1391-1403. the granitoid affiliated Paleoproterozoic copper-molybdenum
MAJUMDER, S. and MAMTANI, M.A. (2009) Magnetic fabric in the deposit at Malanjkhand: A review of status. In: S. Kumar (Ed.),
Malanjkhand Granite (Central India) – implications for Magmatism, Tectonism and Mineralization. Macmillan
regional tectonics and Proterozoic suturing of the Indian shield. Publisher India Ltd., pp.265-292.
Phys. Earth Planet. Inter., v.172, pp.310-323. PARSONS, I. (1978) Alkali-feldspars: which solvus? Phys. Chem.
MENEGON, L., PENNACCHIONI, G. and STÜNITZ, H. (2006) Nucleation Mineral., pp.2, pp.199–213.
and growth of myrmekite during ductile shear deformation in PARSONS, I. and BROWN, W.L. (1984) Feldspars and the thermal
metagranites. Jour. Met. Geol., v.24, pp.553-568. history of igneous rocks. In: W.L. Brown (Ed.), Feldspars and
MISHRA, D.C., SINGH, B., TIWARI, V.M., GUPTA, S.B. and RAO, Feldspathoids: Structure, Properties and Occurrences. NATO
M.V.S.V. (2000) Two cases of continental collision and related ASI Series C, Reidel Publishing Co. Dordrecht, pp.317–371.
tectonics during the Proterozoic period in India insights from PARSONS, I., FITZ GERALD, J. D., LEE, J.K.W., IVANIC, T. and GOLLA-
gravity modeling constrained by seismic and magnetotelluric S CHINDLER , U. (2010) Time-temperature evolution of
studies. Precambrian Res., v.99, pp.149-169. microtexture and contained fluids in a plutonic alkali feldspar
NANDA, J.B., GUPTA, S. and MAMTANI, M.A. (2009) Analysis of during heating. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., v.160, pp.155-180.
deformation fabric in an Alkaline Complex (Koraput): PARSONS, I. and LEE, M.R. (2009) Mutual replacement reactions
implications for time relationship between emplacement, fabric in alkali feldspars I: microtextures and mechanisms. Contrib.
development and regional tectonics. Jour. Geol. Soc. India, Mineral. Petrol., v.157, pp.641-661.
v.74, pp.78-94. PARSONS, I., MAGEE, C.W., ALLEN, C.M., SHELLEY, J.M.G. and LEE,
NARAYANA, B.L., MALLIKHARJUNA RAO, J., SUBBA RAO, M.V., M. (2009) Mutual replacement reactions in alkali feldspars II:
MURTHY, N.N. and DIVAKARA RAO, V. (2000) Geochemitry and trace element partitioning and geothermometry. Contrib.
origin of early Proterozoic Dongargarh rapakivi granite Mineral. Petrol., v.157, pp.663-687.
complex, Central India – an example for magma mixing and PERRIN, R. and RAUBAULT, M. (1953) Origin of the contrasting
differentiation. Gondwana Res., v.3, pp.507-520. mineralogy of extrusive and plutonic salic rocks: a discussion.
NOLD, J.L. (1984) Myrmekite in belt Super group metasedimentary Jour. Geol., v.61, pp.275-278.
rocks - Northeast border zone of the Idaho batholiths. Amer. PETRISHCHEVA, E. and ABART, R. (2009) Exsolution by spinodal
Mineral., v.69, pp.1050-1052. decomposition I: evolution equation for binary mineral
PANDEY, D.K., KRISHNAMURTHY, P. and GUPTA, J.N. (1993) Sm-Nd solutions with anisotropic interface energy. Amer. Jour. Sci.,
and Pb-Pb geochronology of the Dongargarh granites, Central v.309, pp.431-449.
India: implications to petrogenesis; 6th Fourth National PHEMISTER, J. (1926) The geology of Strath Oykell and lower Loch
Symposium on Mass Spectrometry Dehradun Preprint volume, Shin (Explanation of Sheet 102). Scotland Geol. Surv. Mem.,
pp.503-505. pp.220.
PANDIT, D. (2008) A comparative study of the Malanjkhand and PHILLIPS, E.R. (1964) Myrmekite and albite in some granites of
Dongargarh granitoids: implications to crustal evolution and the New England batholith, New South Wales. Jor. Geol. Soc.
metallogeny. Ph.D. thesis, Indian Institute of Technology Australia, v.11, pp.49.
Kharagpur (unpublished). PHILLIPS, E.R. (1974) Myrmekite - one hundred years later. Lithos,
PANDIT, D. and PANIGRAHI, M.K. (2012) Comparative petrogenesis v.7, pp.181-194.
and tectonics of Paleoproterozoic Malanjkhand and PHILLIPS, E.R. (1980a) Myrmekite as a marker between preaqueous
Dongargarh granitoids, Central India. Jour. Asian Earth Sci., and postaqueous phase saturation in granitic systems:
v.50, pp.14-26. Discussion. Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull., v.91, pp.672-674.
PANIGRAHI, M.K., BRENDAN, R,B., MISRA, K.C. and NAIK, R.K. PHILLIPS, E.R. (1980b) On polygenetic myrmekite. Geol. Mag.,
(2004) Age of granitic activity associated with copper v.117, pp.29-36.
molybdenum mineralization as Malanjkhand, Central India. PLUMPER, O. and PUTNIS, A. (2009) The complex hydrothermal history
Mineralium Deposita, v.39, pp.670–677. of granitic rocks: multiple feldspar replacement reactions
PANIGRAHI, M.K. and MOOKHERJEE, A. (1997) The Malanjkhand under subsolidus conditions. Jour. Petrol., v.50, pp.967-987.
Copper (+Molybdenum) deposit, India: Mineralization from PRYER, L.L. and ROBIN, P.Y.F. (1995) Retrograde metamorphic
a low – temperature ore – fluid of granitoid affiliation. reactions in deforming granites and the origin of flame perthite.
Mineralium Deposita, v.32, pp.133–148. Jour. Met. Geol., v.14, pp.645-658.
PANIGRAHI, M.K., MOOKHERJEE, A., PANTULU G, V.C. and GOPALAN, PRYER, L.L. and ROBIN, P.Y.F. (1996) Differential stress control on

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


GEOCHEMISTRY OF FELDSPAR INTERGROWTH MICROTEXTURES FROM GRANITOIDS IN CENTRAL INDIA 181

the growth and orientation of flame perthite: A palaeostress S.C. and PAL, A.B. (2004) A 2.5 Ga Cu-Mo-Au deposit at
direction indicator. Jour. Struct. Geol., v.18, pp.1151-1166. Malanjkhand, Central India: Implications for Late Archean
PUTNIS, A. and AUSTRHEIM, H. (2010) Fluid-induced processes: meta- continental assembly. Precambrian Res., v.134, pp.189 -226.
somatism and metamorphism. Geofluids, v.10, pp.254-269. STEIN, H.J., HANNAH, J., ZIMMERMAN, A. and MARKEY, R. (2006)
R AMACHANDRA, H.M. and R OY, A. (2001) Evolution of the Mineralization and deformation of the Malanjkhand terrane
Bhandara–Balaghat granulite belt along the southern margin (2,490-2,440 Ma) along the outhern margin of the Central
of the Sausar mobile belt of central India. Proc. Indian Acad. Indian Tectonic Zone. Mineralium Depost., v.40, pp.755-765.
Sci. (Earth Planet. Sci.), v.110, pp.351–368. STEL, H. (1986) The effect of cyclic operation of brittle and ductile
R AMBERG , I.B. (1972) Braid perthite in nepheline syenites deformation on the metamorphic assemblages in cataclasites
pegmatite, Langesundsfjorden, Oslo Region (Norway). Lithos, and mylonites. Pageoph, v.124, pp.289-307.
v.5, pp.281-306. SUGI, K. (1930) On the granitic rocks of Tsukuba District and
REYNOLDS, D.L. (1936) The two monozonitic series of the Newry their associated injection rocks. Japan Jour. Geol. Geog., v.13,
Complex. Geol. Mag., v.73, pp.337-364. pp.29-112.
ROBERTSON, R. (1959) Perthite formed by reorganization of albite TSURUMI, J., HOSONUMA, H. and KANAGAWA, K. (2003) Strain
from plagioclase during potash feldspar metasomatism. Amer. localization due to a positive feedback of deformation and
Mineral., v.44, pp.603-619. myrmekite-forming reaction in granite and aplite mylonite
ROY, A., KAGAMI, H., YOSHIDA, M., ROY, A., BANDYOPADHYAYA, B.K., along the Hatagawa Shear Zone of NE Japan. Jour. Struct.
CHATTOPADHYAY, A., KHAN, A.S., HUIN, A.K. and PAL, T. (2006) Geol., v.25, pp.557-574.
Rb-Sr and Sm-Nd dating of different metamorphic events from TULLIS, J. (1975) Elastic strain effects in coherent perthitic feldspar.
the Sausar Mobile Belt, central India: implications for Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., v.49, pp.83-91.
Proterozoic crustal evolution. Jour. Asian Earth Sci., v.26, TUTTLE, O.F. (1952) Origin of the contrasting mineralogy of extru-
pp.61-76. sive and plutonic salic rocks. Jour. Geol., v.60, pp.107-124.
SARKAR, S.N., GOPALAN, K. and TRIVEDI, J.R. (1981) New data on TWISS, R.J. (1977) Theory and applicability of a recrystallized grain
the geochronology of the Precambrians of Bhandara-Drug, size palaeopiezometer. Pure Appld. Geophys., v.115, pp.227-
Central India. Indian Jour. Earth Sci., v.8, pp.131-151. 44.
SCHWANTKE, A. (1909) Die Beimischung von Ca in Kalifeldspat VOGEL, T.A. (1970) Albite-rich domains in potash feldspar. Contrib.
und die Myrmekitbildung. Zentblatt für Mineralogie, pp.311- Mineral. Petrol., v.25, pp.138-143.
316. WORDEN, R.H., WALKER, F.D.L., PARSONS, I. and BROWN, W.L.
SEPAHI, A.A. and COLLINS, L.G. (2002) A study of intergrowth (1990) Development of microporosity, diffusion channels and
textures and their possible origins in the Alvand plutonic deuteric coarsening in perthitic alkali feldspars. Contrib.
complex, Hamadan, Iran. ISSN, v.24, pp.1526-5757. Mineral. Petrol., v.104, pp.507-515.
SHELLEY, D. (1964) On myrmekite. Amer. Mineral., v.49, pp.41-52. YEDEKAR, D.B., JAIN, S.C., NAIR, K.K.K. and DUTTA, K.K. (1990)
SHELLEY, D. (1973a) Myrmekite from the Haast Schists, New The central Indian collision suture. Geol. Surv. India Spl. Publ.,
Zealand. Amer. Mineral., v.49, pp.332-338. v.28, pp.1-43.
SHELLEY, D. (1973b) Myrmekite from the Haast Schists, New YUGUCHI, T. and NISHIYAMA, T. (2007) Cooling process of a granitic
Zealand: a reply. Amer. Mineral., v.58, pp.804. body deduced from the extents of exsolution and deuteric sub-
SHELLEY, D. (1997) Igneous and metamorphic rocks under the solidus reactions: Case study of the Okueyama granitic body,
microscope. Chapman and Hall London. Kyushu, Japan. Lithos, v.97, pp.395-421.
SIKKA, D.B. and NEHRU, C.E. (1997) Review of Precambrian YUGUCHI, T. and NISHIYAMA, T. (2008) The mechanism of myrmekite
porphyry Cu±Mo±Au deposits with special reference to formation deduced from steady-diffusion modeling based on
Malanjkhand porphyry copper deposit, Madhya Pradesh, India. petrography: case study of the Okueyama granitic body,
Jour. Geol. Soc. India, v.49, pp.239-288. Kyushu, Japan. Lithos, v.106, pp.237-260.
SIKKA, D.B. (1989) Malanjkhand Proterozoic porphyry copper YUND, A.R. and DAVIDSON, P. (1978) Kinetic of lamellar coarsening
deposit, MP, India. Jour. Geol. Soc. India, v.34, pp.487-504. in cryptoperthites. Amer. Mineral., v.63, pp.470-477.
SMITH, J.V. and BROWN, W.L. (1988) Feldspar Minerals. Volume I YUND, R.A. and ACKERMAND, D. (1979) Development of perthite
2nd Eds Springer New York. microstructures in the Storm King Granite, N.Y. Contrib.
S PENCER , E. (1938) The potash–soda–feldspars II. Some Mineral. Petrol., v.70, pp.273-280.
applications to petrogenesis. Mineral. Mag., v.25, pp.87-118. YUND, R.A. and CHAPPLE, W.M. (1980) Thermal histories of two
SPENCER, E. (1945) Myrmekite in graphic granite and in vein lava flows estimated from cryptoperthite lamellar spacing.
perthite. Mineral. Mag., v.27, pp.79-98. Amer. Mineral., v.65, pp.438-443.
SPRY, A. (1969) Metamorphic Textures.Pergamon Press, Oxford, YUND, R.A., MCLAREN, A.C. and HOBBS, B.E. (1974) Coarsening
England. kinetics of the exsolution microstructure in alkali feldspar.
STEIN, H.J., HANNAH, J.L., ZIMMERMAN, A., MARKEY, R.J., SARKAR, Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., v.48, pp.45-55.

(Received: 12 November 2012; Revised form accepted: 6 December 2013)

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015


182 DINESH PANDIT

APPENDIX

K-feldspar replacement by albite réactions:


KAlSi3O8 + Na+ = NaAlSi3O8 + K+ (A1)
The equilibrium constants for all the above reactions are:

ln K1 = ln ( a K + / a Na + ) + ln ( a Ab ) − ln ( a Kf ) (A2)
(A3)
ln ( a Na + / a K + ) = − ln K1 + ln ( a Ab ) − ln ( a Kf )

Equilibrium constant is calculated using SUPCRT92 software for reaction (A1)


At P = 2 kbar, log K1 = −3 × 10−9 T 3 + 8 × 10−6 T 2 − 6.4 × 10−3 T + 2.3668 (A4)

K-feldspar replacement by anorthite réactions:


2KAlSi3O8 + Ca2+ = CaAl2Si2O8 + 4SiO2 + 2K+ (A5)

ln K 2 = ln ( aK2 + / aCa 2 + ) + ln ( a An ) + 4 ln ( aQtz ) − 2 ln ( aKf ) (A6)

ln ( aCa 2+ / a K2 + ) = − ln K 2 + ln ( a An ) + 4 ln ( aQtz ) − 2 ln ( aKf ) (A7)

Equilibrium constant is calculated using SUPCRT92 software for reaction (A5)


At P = 2 kbar, log K = −2 × 10−7 T 3 + 3 × 10−4 T 2 − 2.573 × 10−1T + 95.633 (A8)
2

Combination of reaction (A1) and reaction (A5):


(2m+n)KAlSi3O8 + mCa2+ + nNa+ = (mCaAl2Si2O8 + nNaAlSi3O8) + 4mSiO2 + (2m+n)K+ (A9)

ln K 3 = m × ln K 2 + n × ln K1 (A10)

Where m & n are stoichimetric co-efficient of Ca2+ and Na+ ions in the reaction

JOUR.GEOL.SOC.INDIA, VOL.85, FEB. 2015

View publication stats

You might also like