F O O D F O R

T H O U G H T
T O S PA R K
C O N V E R S A T I O N

PART OF THE CCHF SHABBOS TABLE MACHSOM L’FI PROGRAM • PARSHAS EIKEV 5781 • ISSUE 251

Wrong Words PARTICIPANTS

SPEAK
Are Never Right

Lakewood
I had to let you know what an
amazing book Master Your
Words, Master Your Life is.
You stumble into a situation in which someone is being spoken about.
No one is saying he’s committed an aveirah or displayed any bad trait; It’s easy reading, relevant,
it’s just information that isn’t positive. Is it wrong to listen? well written and practical – it
really speaks to me. It leaves me
empowered and with a lot of food
T H E T H E for thought.

DILEMMA HALACHAH Thank you for all the wonderful

CCHF publications and programs!

S S
himmy is at it again, making fun of his himmy’s words C.M.R.
wife’s family from Atlanta. He says it’s fall under the Lakewood, NJ
“all in good fun,” but the impression he category of general
creates is that his wife’s father, who never went derogatory statements,
to yeshivah, is ignorant. He loves to quote his which are not permitted.
father-in-law’s mispronunciations, said with a This includes comments
thick southern accent. on a person's physical
strength, intelligence, FOR QUESTIONS AND
He brings up this pet subject at his family’s
family background and COMMENTS, EMAIL
Chanukah party, getting loud laughs from his
sins for which a person Shabbosmenu@cchfglobal.org
siblings and a mild, “Oh, Shimmy, stop it. It’s not
nice!” from his wife. has repented. Words that
are forbidden to be
“You know I love your father,” Shimmy spoken are also

refrains
replies. “I’m not saying forbidden to be
anything bad about him. heard and “One who habitually
It’s amazing what he’s accepted.
accomplished all on his

free of all
Sefer Chofetz
own. It’s just funny, Chaim
that’s all.” Hilchos Loshon   from loshon hora
Hora 6:8 will eventually be
If Shimmy isn’t
actually criticizing
his father-in-law, are transgressions between
the others allowed man and his fellow.”
to listen and accept
– Sefer Shmiras Haloshon,
what he’s saying? Shaar HaZechirah Ch. 1

Sponsored L'ilui Nishmas

Reviewed by Rabbi Moshe Mordechai Lowy. For discussion only; actual halachic decisions should
be made by a rav or halachic expert on a case-by-case basis. Malka Breindel a"h bas Shmuel Fishel ylch"t
 SS HH AA BB BB OO SS M
M EE NN UU nn II SS SS UU EE 44 47
S SH HA AB BB BO OS S M ME EN NU U •   n I SI S U
SEU E2 54 12

R
A
O
sageadvice
sage advice
advice
In 1970, abbi Rav Dovid ShabseGoldwasser
Frankel embarked was invited on a
revolutionary
vie neGold
year at
project:
was Camp
to
sitting
produceSimcha,shiva a for
camp
anManchester
accurate
his
to address the renowned
revered father, Mr. Jack (Yaakov)
Halachah Clarified
version of Yeshivaj.for
Rambam’schildren
Arriving who
Mishneh are
at the suffering
Torah,
airport, from
including
he
an
Yaakov
ahim
hisGold,
invaluable
asked
to hisPollack,
cross-referencing
serious
hosts newintoresource,
October
illness,
make a
heRabbi
communities index
two1976.
the
stop
of any
found
of
boys Rabbi
from different
Mafteach,
before
Congregation
themselves
mention
taking
of
fool
A Ten-Second
Make the
Sure to yetzer
Invite hora
Moshiach
Question:
hotel; wanted to daven at the
Shomrei
together
Rambam
kever of in
Chassidish
orEmunah
the one
its bunk.
sources
great
community
in Boro
Yoeli
Manchester camePark
in hundreds
in Williamsburg,
from
Rosh and
ofthe a
ancient
Yeshivah,
and Danny
Answer
Rabbi Lowy, shlita
thehalachah
onInthe
answers, a Shabbos
inJudges,
times of the issue“My
42.
Table Machsom member’s questions
yetzer hora never quits! How can I ever
there was a tremendously wealthy man. He had 30 sons and 30
and contemporary
maggid
Rav Yehudah shiur at Yeshiva
Zev sefarim.
Segal, University,
zt”l, the tzaddik enteredwho conquer loshon hora for good?”
daughters, and whenYoueach
are of them got married, he made them Both
lavishyou
weddings. In fact, he

T
came from the Modern Orthodox community THE DILEMMA: one of two
If you were given ten seconds to offer mean-salespeople in a store. and your
tointhe
Answer:
the known
was house for andhis satunwavering
down. He devotion said to the
he NJ. first volume of the Frankel Rambam, made two
coworker
ingful useweddings
advicethe cash for each child
register
to a“Just to ring
chassan/kallah – one for hisAfter
up sales. family and friends
a customer and
leaves, one
youfor thethe
hear in-laws’
other
Teaneck,
mourners,
mitzvah “You’re Haloshon.
of Shmiras probably wondering why you’rejust
tell himI thought not before
really they
shirtshegiving itgo to
up. You’re just
published in 1975, was welcomed with theside. All
salesperson
chupah,told,
tell athis man
stock-boy,
what made 120
“Uh-oh.
do youand weddings;
think by the
those
you would time was
were done,
on “everyone
sale.” At
say? Would it be commu- who
the end ofwas
the
I came
United
Rav bytotheir
Segal be
not desire
great enthusiasm byavel,
menchem
only to forget their
guarded thethis since
year neither
mitzvah
entire
of
Torah holding
day,
anyone” off
hadfor
your boss now.”
finds a shortage
attended at least one of blames
these you for it. May you tell him that it was your
events.
sickness
Avie Over
norbut andJack treatments,
Gold ever the differences
davened mostly
inHaloshon
my nicate? Perhaps
co-worker madebe
whocomes the there
mistake?for each other? Maybe you would think that
himself, hefollowing
created the Shmiras The answer from Dovid Hamelech, who would set The out man,beis
for the
world. the three decades, many However, one man had been excluded. Thisbe
man
fell away.
shul.
Yomi
However,
I’llYisrael’s
calendarexplain one night
it to youtalmidei
designating
Yoeli
with decided
story: to
twoahalachos
the most important thing should tohad view no children.
each other wealthy
l’kaf zechus?knowing
of Eretz greatest
play a trick on Danny. While Danny was out, Yoeli
chachamim medrash
THE with
HALACHAH: the yetzer
The hora
answer tagging
is along,
complicated. saying,
If a person “You’ve
makes
that the childless man had no way to return his hospitality, decided not to invite him angot a million
innocent mistake
to any
to“Many
be learned
labored to produce each theday. He would
remaining give this
volumes of When
things
(and youHaGaon
to
aretake HaRav
care
therefore of!Aharon
not Who’s
obligated Leib
got Shteinman,
time
to inform to
the shlita,
sitstorekeeper,
and was
learn?”asasked this question,
you would his
be if he stole
poured ayears bottle of ago Pepsi an Orthodox
on his mattress. Jewish Danny of the weddings he made. This insensitivity, perpetrated by a man who had been blessed by
calendar
the Mishneh to those
Torah. who
Rav came
Shabse to him
dedicated in theiran short,
the three-word
money), you areanswer was unequivocal:
not allowed to name the person “Levater,wholevater, levater
did it just – toyour
to clear givename.
in, to give,
You
mangot was driving in Queens and feltnear a Jewish Hashem
“Oh, you inthink
every I’m
way,going
arousedtoHashem’s
learn?” attribute
the ofwould
justice. All 60 of“I’m
the wealthy man’s
soon
darkest
untold amount
under
times,
his covers
ofguaranteeing
money towardthat
the cold
thislearning
liquid
project, the and are, however,
to give allowed
in.” That was toit, say
threethat you
words did not
to guidedoking
ait.couple
If there arereply.
only atwo
towards
really
possible
successful
going
culprits,
marriage.
cemetery
soaking
left no stone
halachos
into when
would
unturned
he noticed
his pajamas.
bring inahis
Yoeli was an elderly
quest toWhen
yeshuah.
already up
ensure thethe tochildren
as intake died.you
this care
case, of some
can makeimportant
that denialbusiness.”
only if the other person’s actions were, in fact,
woman
and running. standing
From then under on, the a bus twoshelter.
boys avoided He What isGemara
Theyetzer
the middah underlying
tellsthinking
thisif story
this ability to “let of things go,” to give in,Innot
in Megillas
toRus
give
utmost
time accuracy
came for Ravof the Segal “Frankelto Rambam.”
leave this world, improper;
The
up? It is
forhora,
the
instance,
middah of anavah,
hetohumility.
the cashier explain
had had
won, thewould
been
In
words
negligent
contrast,
Naomi
goin making
away
people
to the
long
who
Rus error.
enough
are unable
general,
fortoDovid
let go,
pulled
each other.over and asked her in Yiddish where accepting the
(3:1), afterto blame
Rus is considered
tells her that a meritorious act, unless you will be unjustly penalized.
heone
At askedjuncture,that his Rav calendars
Shabse be buried
was told that
aboutwiththe Hamelech
people who are direct
makpid his feet Boaz
about to thehas
many
shown
beis
things, are
her special kindness. “I seek security
medrash. assumedly propelled by the middah
she
Manytheywas
yearswere heading.
later,hisYoeli She
had answered
recovered from she
his (manoach) for you,”someone
she says.inNaomi was referring to an episode from Boaz’s
him; “passport to Olam Haba.” May I speak
Inyounger
His against
kindness, order
thisto vindicate myself?
existence
was going
illness
of
and become
an ancient
home atosuccessful manuscript
Brooklyn, of a portion
and she told
businessman. of gaavah, years inHashem
haughtiness. which he allows
excluded ruse
the to work
childless whenever we’re
Manoach—who faced with a
eventually

Question:
challenge. The truth is, it’s not the yetzer hora that his children’s weddings.we
falls for the trick, it’s who
of
UponRambam’s
him arriving
where Mishneh
sheatnever
Rav Torah,
lived.Segal’s one
He regained kever,
replied of that
theRabbioldest
he became the father of Shimshon Hagibbor—from Fearing
Danny, however, quite his strength. Rav Shteinman’s answer of “levater, levater,
such texts
Goldwasser still extant.
began toHowever,
recite a obtaining
perek of it was fall for it,
that aisunionbecausebetweenwe’re If there
falling arein only
the two people
direction and the person is not
result again in the heartbreaking go.
in which we really want allowed
to
Hewas headingontoa the
depended same neighborhood
wheelchair to get around. He levater” completely inRus
syncand Boaz
with would
anivus being
not simple,
Tehillim on as it wasofheld
behalf
and he would be happy to drive her home.
wanted to purchase a a in a museum
troubled
wheelchair-accessible individualin Egypt.
car, to say
death "Not
of me,"
Boaz’s what can
offspring, he or
Naomi
the middah underlying vatranus. After all, Rav
she say?
told her This year help bring
He
who puthad
“During
purchase,
began
together
but finding
that
asked
the
that the
and
large
drive
him
spent
I was
price
sums
do
toyears
saying
so.of
was
Brooklyn
“Imoney
out realized
pursuing
the she the
wrong
for the I
of reach,after
explained
he
elusive
perek,” Answer:
TALK has What
daughter-in-law
Shteinman
ABOUT
forManoach.”
a big,
Find
to are
become make
The
him,
thesure
legendary
best
dramatic
dangers
way
invite him
for of
to “seek
out
change?
his
is
making
to theWhat
disdain
to try to
ORDER
the CDs
worldwide
contacted
thatout
Rabbi
sent she anhad
Chai
Goldwasser
Lifeline
yahrtzeit
email
for help.
relates.
seeking and
ksav
donors. had
The organization
yad. come
“Instead of to the
saying
gaavah.
justify ITwhat are the benefits?
happened to
wedding, and let him know he’s wanted. minimize negative
of th
ORDER
e Conve ntion
tisha YOUR b'av
cemetery to daven.
38, I was saying 39.” However, She had been
Finally,since waiting
he
the museum fallout
NOTE: A by explaining
situation
Thebelittles
message
thatparty
in which one
of this story
“I know thatdominates,
consistently
whichismust
thatbeignoring
it was a FREE
AT
MAGNET
TOD AY!
programTODAY
toCCHF.GLOBAL
your
t 116
community
Yoeli sawbus theto email insults, another is one addressed by
takeand knew rightThey awaycordially
what he
for the
had
wanted
already
conversed
continue
to do.until
started, her
he home.
felt agreed
that hetoshould
He went to the Chai Lifeline office
to the he portion of
sell
the
a mistake.
was or meant.”
special
It
professionals.
excluding
your
be stopped;
wasn’t
Such those
father
it is not
done
a situation
one that
intentionally.
is defined
who,
was.”
No harm
as abuse, and it must
for whatever
calls for vatranus.
10,000
845.352.35People
05 ex
and handed over a check for $60,000, the full price reason, are difficult to invite to our simchos Call Chazak Every Day
dropped
and her off
Question:
end
of the car. “Don’t tell him who it’s manuscript A or
from,” Yoeli said. —
renewed
our home, wave of awe andactlove
is a destructive thatwashed to Hear Rabbi Dovid Ashear
in front of her
then over Jack What
Gold’s bereaved is“Itconsidered
children.

Another
“Just tell him it’s payback for the soda.” generates destruction. However, there’s he
seems,”
home. "unjustly
a beautiful
Their penalized"?
“other
father’s side
chessed of the coin.”
was
told hissoThe much
assistant,
1 2 3
Pathways

Answer:
Some time later, Danny fulfilled a life-long dream Daily
Personal to
“Almost
and went to Eretz Yisrael. However, while there offspring
more of
thanRus and
even Boaz
Rabbi was the
Pollak
“that root
Heavenknew Learning
Programs Stories Personal
Anything that would

Coffee
Growth
a year
he became sick with pneumonia. The hospital of the family treeJack
– because leading Gold to does
Moshiach.
did not not live
wish for
compromise
When we his
invite present
others or
into future
our
us joband
circle
to disseminate
4 5 6
later,
would only release him if he had an oxygen Chizuk Shabbos Shalom,
prospects or histhatstatus at work thewould beof

going
Shalom
the manto use at the home where he was staying.
machine show them they count, we invite
contents and
Emunah
and
Yom Tov Bayis and
“unjust.”
redemption He is notthe
into obligated
world. to suffer
this manuscript any LOCAL Shidduchim

forcalled
Once again, the price
an exorbitant price.wasRavtoo high. And once
Shabse SPONSORSHIP:
7 8 9
financial loss and is even allowed to Klalto name the
Yisrael.
the elderly
jumped at the opportunity. After asking
again, Yoeli came to the rescue, years to remain By R’ Yitzchok TALK Hisiger Gemach Easy-to-Use
$180
Live

ABOUT IT Lists Teleconferences

my way
culprit to prevent any loss on his part.
System
But your coffee brought to you Instructions
and Timely

woman
ofanonymous and except for the message,
cost, the “Payback for
by HAKHEL Topics
effort, and at enormous spilled. Here’s
the soda.” What are some other ways to acknowledge and
siad, ‘Since
manuscript was finally in his possession. FIND OUT
Sponsor WHY!
this event as a
another appreciate
one.” people who are not part of our inner

keeping
we
Danny’sboth have
health to bewith but
improved, zechus forTODAY:
CALL a loved one.
He entered his office thethe doctor told
precious, newlyhim circle?
Rav Shabse Frankel z”l was a renowned talmid
at was
he the cemetery
not strong onHethe
yad.enough same day
to flyitback
on ato and
America.
acquired
weassistant
He
ksav
live inhave
would the
placed
same neighborhood,
desk for
I’m was chacham who led a ground-breaking undertaking Call 845-352-3505
NEW YORK
ext 113
718.258.2008..................

his to toexamine. The excitement TORONTO 416.800.0656

....................

Paid Back
theLove
watch
going
stay in to
Eretzpick you
Yisrael up and we’ll go to the cem- in the world someone
anywhere of
nearTorah thepublishing.
Rabbi’s him Butthat
mother. justaas Norgreat ERETZ YISRAEL ........... 03.929.0707
say
palpable. But as he reached out to look at the informing Chofet z Chaim Herit age Foundat ion
was his sterling character. Only one who had 44.203.375.1580
etery
awhile
38. Astogether,
manuscript, tohecontinue and theninadvertently
the assistant I’ll drive youknocked
home.’ did he have a yahrtzeit
penthouse on the
had been same for
reserved day. ENGLANDCCHF ..........GLOBAL

recovering. But worked his entire lifeheonopened

refiningthe himself tocould
MENU OPTION 4, THEN 1
continued, he He had simply
him. As offered himself –
door his time,
with
over a cup
“The scene of coffee he had been drinking.
repeated itself for a number of have reacted the way he apartment,
did.
where
was
Before would
struck
he he react, the coffee had spilled all
with
could patience, companythe luxurious and conversation he was– to
years,
stay? He until
got the elderly woman passed away. ______________________
greeted by a fantastic array of fellow
food,
amazement
over at
the manuscript, rendering it unreadable. take a little bit of the burden off one
a“Before
the
The call fromshe
words
fragile, that died,
hadpaper
ancient the woman
been mentioned
“accidentally”
simply shriveled placed
up; in Thanks
he went to Hotza’as
to
Jew’s shoulders. fruits,
Shamayim Shabse
snacks Frankel
and
he was forstill
lots the
of biographical
soda.
guarding,On
information,
theand
wall tohung
a memberatobig ofsign:
Rav Shabse’s
“Payback family for
for the
ainthehisstory
second, mouth: to precious
the her son
“I will andmy
guard
document toldways
him the
hadfrom name
become ______________
still asking all of us
verifying the details of the story be careful with our
of the man
sinning
worthless. with who
Themy drovefroze,
mouth.
assistant Iher
will to the cemetery
guard
unable my mouth
to say or mouths,
Excerpted because
with soda.”
permission thefrom entire
from Stam world
Torah, byand our
Rabbi
Reprinted with permission an article in Yated Ne’eman
Daniel Staum
do every
with year on the yahrtzeit.
a muzzle.”
anything. lives depend on it.”
Astonishingly,
TALK ABOUT IT
“I“The elderly
realized theRavwomanShabse
power ofinthedidn’t
the Rosh flinch.
story was Hemy
Yeshivah,” TALK TALK
TALK
What were some of the
ABOUT
ABOUT
middosABOUT
IT IT
IT
that went into Rav Our Mission
Our Mission
walked
said
mother, outand
Rabbi ofGoldwasser.
thetheroom
manand returned,
“Not
was holding
onlyfather.
your did he Soa
What are somemightofthere the many forlessons about the Our Mission
FOUNDATION
THE CHOFETZ CHAIM HERITAGE FOUNDATION
HERITAGEFOUNDATION

cup
stand
when of coffee.
guard
I heard forhethepassed
mitzvahaway of Shmiras
I came to What Frankel’s
reason reaction? Why How becan
did Yoeliwe gowork
Rabbi to such on great
these
Goldwasser at the Chofetz Chaim Heritage
at the Chofetz Chaim Heritage
best
to beway
the to do chessed
recipient
middos ofat ourthat
Rav
lengths own we can
level?
Segal’s
to appease learn from
“message”? Foundation is to Chaim
inspire Heritage
Jews around
Haloshon
express my while he was and
gratitude alive,tobuttelleven after
you how this man’s selfless act? Danny? atFoundation
the Chofetz
Foundation
Foundation the
is
isworld
to
toisinspire
inspire
JewsJews
totoinspire
grasp
Jews
around
around
the aroundthe world
the
life-enhancing to
world grasp
giftto grasp
of Shmiras
CHAIM HERITAGE

thethe
world to grasp thegift
life-enhancing life-enhancing
of Shmiras
Haloshon, Ahavas Yisrael and
To Join
Free
Children's
Children's Teen
Free
Teen giftHaloshon,
of shmirasAhavas haloshon, ahavas
Yisrael and
‫לע״נ חיים יחיאל מיכל בן‬
Inspiration
Line Line
Inspiration
Line
Shalom,
Yisrael,
Shalom,
and to provide
and shalom,
and to provide
easy
and to provide
easy
CHOFETZ CHAIM

Line access totoaawide array ofofoptions

‫רפאל פייוועל שניאור ז״ל‬
24/6
THE
THE SHABBOS
SHABBOS TABLE
TABLE
24/6 easyaccess
accessto
designedto aspark
tospark
widearray
wide arrayof
personal
options
options
growth.
designed
designed to spark personalgrowth.
personal
THE CHOFETZ

growth.
‫נלב״ע ערב שבת קודש‬ MACHSOM
MACHSOM L'FI
L'FI
‫תשע״ז‬
Lakewood 732.806.8599 ‫ אלול‬845.356.6665
Monsey ‫י׳‬ powerofspeech.org/shabbos
Visit: powerofspeech.org/shabbos
Visit: Lakewood 732.806.8599 Monsey 845.356.6665 More450,000
More than52,000
than
25,000 52,000 students
students
Hotline
Books
2017 THE

212.444.1119
212.444.1119
New York 718.258.2008 Toronto 416.800.0656 use our curriculums each week.
.‫ה‬.‫ב‬.‫צ‬.‫נ‬.‫ת‬ orininthe
or theUSA,
USA, text: shabbos to
text: shabbos to 313131
313131 New York 718.258.2008 Toronto 416.800.0656
Eretz201.855.8255,
201.855.8255, 212.596.8255
Yisrael 03.929.0707 212.596.8255 use our curriculums
calls each week.
daily
in print.
© 2021
©© 2017

Eretz718.305.6960,
03.929.0707 845.738.1066
718.305.6960, 845.738.1066
Yisrael England 44.203.375.1580 England 44.203.375.1580

CHOFETZ
CHOFETZ
CHOFETZ CHAIM CHAIM
CHAIM
HERITAGE
CHOFETZ HERITAGE
HERITAGE
FOUNDATION
CHAIM 361FOUNDATION
HERITAGE FOUNDATION
SPOOK ROCK361
FOUNDATION 361
361SPOOK
SPOOK
ROAD, ROCK
ROCK
SUFFERN,
SPOOK ROCK ROAD,
ROAD,
NY 10901 SUFFERN,
ROAD, SUFFERN,
TEL: NY
NY
NY 10901
10901
845.352.3505
SUFFERN, EXT.TEL:
TEL:
# 104845-352-3505
845-352-3505 EXT.
EXT. SHABBOSMENU@CCHFGLOBAL.ORG
FAX: 845.352.3605 104
104 FAX:
FAX: 845-352-3605
845-352-3605