Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VGB PowerTech 2015 12 NAVROTSKY Autorenexemplar
VGB PowerTech 2015 12 NAVROTSKY Autorenexemplar
Industrialisation of 3D printing
(additive manufacturing)
for gas turbine components
repair and manufacturing
Vladimir Navrotsky, Andreas Graichen and Håkan Brodin
für Industriegasturbinen der Baureihe SGT-750 earlier needed many logistical steps can Additive layer manufacturing (ALM) com-
dar. In diesem Fall war SLM die einzige Techno- be carried out on one single machine, prises a group of rapid manufacturing pro-
logie, die in der Lage war, diese Art von Swirler
zu fertigen. Die Ergebnisse haben den Erfolg der
Anwendung der SLM-Technologie in der Kons-
truktion, im Prototyping und in der Fertigung
neuer, verbesserter Brenner-Swirler bestätigt. l
Authors
3D CAD Data
Dr. Vladimir Navrotsky
Andreas Graichen
Dr. Håkan Brodin Fig. 1. To manufacture a component by AM technology, the following is needed:
Siemens Industrial Turbomachinery AB 1 = 3D model of the component
Finspong, Sweden 2 = appropriate powder and
3 = laser sintering equipment.
Post-treatment
properties from one generation of SLM between 10 to 160 µm. When the powder
systems to the next, is sieved to fit, for instance in SLM, a large Materials manufactured with AM tech-
–– on-line monitoring systems must be de- portion of the powder has to be recycled niques are, in many cases, superior to tra-
veloped and implemented in commercial with increased powder cost. If two comple- ditionally manufactured components even
products (F i g u r e 3). mentary processes are utilising the same without any post-processing. The materi-
powder, the yield in atomising will dra- als created are very homogeneous without
In order to address all these challenges in
matically increase. This would be the case internal flaws and defects. However, there
time and in proper order, cooperation be-
comparing SLM and EBM manufacturing. are a number of properties that might
tween AM equipment suppliers and cus-
tomers can be very beneficial for quick Several suppliers can provide powders cause problems (surfaces, internal stresses,
industrialisation of AM technology. As an suitable for additive manufacturing. Gas behaviour at extreme temperatures) that
atomised powder is required with sieving require improvements. Material response
example of such cooperation customisa-
fractions in a relatively tight size range. to external loading will also typically be
tion of EOS equipment for Siemens’ needs
Depending on equipment and setup (layer anisotropic. These, and other factors, will
can be mentioned. Based on Siemens’ re-
thickness), the sieved fractions will be in put requirements on post-treatments to
quest and specification, the company EOS
the range of 10 µm to 30 µm up to 10 µm further optimise component performance.
individually adapted and modified one of
45 µm for thin layer thicknesses. Depending on the type of post-processing,
its machines EOSINT M 280 for Siemens
the cost associated with the treatment can
gas turbine burner repair. The scale of the Process parameters be low (heat-treatment) or high (surface
machine’s interior was enlarged to accom-
Equipment for AM processes is readily improvement). However, the cost associ-
modate the 800 millimeter burner. The ated with establishment of a cheap post-
available. However, the knowledge regard-
manufacturer also amended further hard- processing operation might be substantial
ing how to set up and maintain an AM pro-
ware components such as a camera system (e.g., as in development of heat treatments
cess cannot easily be acquired. Knowledge
and an optical measuring system and made for optimal mechanical material properties
on laser or electron beam performance,
corresponding adjustments to the software. for different applications).
process parameter optimisation and pro-
AM value chain cess performance and stability it is hard to
Material data and design criteria
be gained from original equipment manu-
facturers (OEM). In many cases, the selec- As previously mentioned, material data
Powder materials
tion of available materials and correspond- generation can be required for a number
Understanding powder composition and of variations of one given material. The
ing process parameters does not match the
morphology are key factors to control cost associated with material data genera-
needs from large companies. Especially
when setting up and managing an AM pro- tion is very dependent on the application.
advanced materials for aggressive environ-
cess. Powder cleanliness, chemistry control ments and high temperatures are not read- Depending on the application, the cost
and powder homogeneity are some of the ily available. This means that large efforts associated with material data generation
parameters that must be well understood. need to be put into the equipment process and implementation for one material into
Since powder manufacturing, especially parameter development. In order to fully designer-friendly tools can range from
for AM processes requires tight alloying utilise the AM process, it is highly likely modest numbers up to 1 to 1.5 m €. If gen-
VGB PowerTech - Autorenexemplar - © 2015
element control and atomising equipment that several alternative process param- erated, this type of data is today typically
specialised to maximise yield and pro- eter packages could be available for one not readily available in open sources.
ductivity for the very specific powder size material. Depending on the component It is very likely that the full understand-
ranges used, large efforts are put into set- requirements, the process will need to be ing of AM materials can be gained only, if
ting up a process for additive manufactur- set up for best economy (speed), accuracy larger consortia are formed, where syner-
ing. A good example could be an AM plant (tolerances and surfaces) or performance gies will allow for good understanding of
where not only component but also powder (strength). residual stresses, mechanical properties
manufacturing is established. Through this and physical properties coupled to process
At Siemens Power Generation, authors are
set up, it is possible to maximise the value behaviour and part performance described
keeping high focus on establishment of the
added to any given component manufac- as dimensional accuracy or bulk and sur-
process parameters for nickel based mate-
tured. Also the powder can be better uti- face quality.
rials.
lised, since different AM processes will use
different fractions of the atomised powder. Process monitoring Design tools
Powder suitable for AM is typically sieved Process monitoring is, for all traditional Design criteria are not only material data
into fractions where the yield is gained manufacturing processes, a natural way and design data developed from material
References
[ 1] Navrotsky, V., Graichen A., and Brodin,
The platform lowers A new layer of metal The process is This process gradually produces a H.: Industrialization of 3D printing for gas
by a few micrometers powder is applied repeated, layer new burner tip that is melted onto
turbine components repair and manufac-
by layer the rest on the component
turing. VGB Conference “Gas Turbines and
Operation of Gas Turbines 2015”, 06/07
Fig. 6. SGT-800 & SGT-700 burner SLM repair procedure. May 2015, Lübeck/Germany.
[ 2] Brodin, H, Navrotsky, V, Graichen A.: 3D
technology is 10 times quicker than previ- ogy for this complex burner swirl, because printing at Siemens Power Generation Ser-
vice. Total Conference, Paris, France, 17-
ously used “conventional” repair proce- AM was the only technology that can pro- 12-2015.
dures, as it avoids quite a few manufactur- duce it. [ 3] Navrotsky, V, Graichen A, and Brodin, H.:
ing and inspection processes. In the next few years we are planning to 3D printing at Siemens Power Generation
Conventional repair procedure required Service. 3D printing technology, Las Vegas,
extend the scope of AM manufactured gas USA, 18-02-2015.
prefabrication of a large portion of the turbine components to burners, fuel strain- [ 4] Kumar, S.: Iron-based powders and SLS/
burner tip. This prefabricated burner tip is ers, heat shields and guide vanes. SLM for rapid tooling. PhD thesis, Katho-
used for replacement of the burner tip af- lieke Universitet Leuven, Leuven, Belgium,
(2008).
ter the specified operation time (the old tip Conclusion
was cut off and the prefabricated one weld- [ 5] Emmelmann, C., Petersen, M., and Goeke,
A.: Laser freeform fabrication for aircraft
ed on). Conventional repair procedure was Additive manufacturing enables a revolu- applications, In: Proceedings of the fifth
time-consuming, with a significant number tion in spare parts manufacturing and gen- international WLT-conference on lasers in
of sub-processes and examinations. erates the following values and opportuni- manufacturing, (2009), pp. 171-174.
AM repair process of SGT-700 & SGT-800 ties: [ 6] Srivastava, D., Chang, I.T.H, and Loretto,
M.H.: Intermetallics 9, (2001), pp. 1003-
burners is shown in F i g u r e 6. Lead time reduction and life cycle 1013.
Replacement of conventional repair pro- improvement for complex parts: [ 7] Santos, E.C., Shiomi, M., Osakada, K. and
cesses with SLM provided not only a sig- Laoui, T.: Int. J. Machine Tools Manuf., 46,
–– lead time reduction: faster technology (2006), pp. 1459-1468.
nificant reduction in repair time, but also validation and product development, [ 8] Costa, L., and Vilar, R.: Rapid Prototyping
an opportunity to modify repaired compo- shorter time to market, J.. 15, No. 4, (2009), pp. 264-279.
nents to the latest burner design. [ 9] Kruth, J.P., Froyen, L., Van Vaerenbergh,
–– reduced number of process steps: sim-
plified manufacturing and repair, faster J., Mercelis, P., Rombouts, M., and Lau-
Rapid manufacturing wers, B.: J Mater. Process. Technol., 149,
manufacturing and repair, (2004), pp. 616-622,
AM technology industrialisation is also
–– saving of material, [10] Kruth, J.P., Levy, G., Klocke, F. and Childs,
enabling new opportunities for spare part
VGB PowerTech - Autorenexemplar - © 2015
–– reduced number of parts in a compo- T.H.C.: Annals CIRP, 56, No. 2, (2007), pp.
and supply chain enhancement: 730-759.
nent: integrated functionality,
–– manufacturing of spare parts on de- [11] Ghany, K.A., and Moustafa, S.F.: Rapid
mand, –– eliminated tools: no time consuming Prototyping J. Vol. 12, No. 2, (2006), pp.
casting process, 86-94.
–– regionalisation of rapid repair and man-
–– on-demand, instant, de-centralized pro- [12] Kruth, J.P., Wang, X., Laoui, T., and Froy-
ufacturing of GT components, en, L.: Assembly Automation, 23, No. 4,
duction (e.g. for service).
–– simplification of logistics and investment (2003), pp. 357-371,
reduction on stocks. Efficiency increase through practically [13] Van Elsen, M., Al-Bender, F., and Kruth,
J.P.: Rapid Prototyping J., 14, No. 1,
Currently, Siemens Power Generation is unlimited options for internal and (2008), pp. 15-22.
focusing on industrialisation of SLM for external cooling duct design: [14] Mazumder, J., Choi, J., Nagarathnam, K.,
rapid repair and manufacturing of Siemens –– better heat transfer and lattice struc- Koch, J., and Hetzner, D.: The direct metal
gas turbine components. tures: thinner walls and larger surface deposition of H13 tool steel for 3D compo-
nents. JOM, Vol. 49 No. 5, pp. 55-60,
Today, we already have burner swirls in areas,
[15] Mumtaz, K.A., and Hopkinson, N.: J Mater.
commercial operation in one of our indus- –– improved mixing of fuel and air: ad- Processing Technol., 210, (2010), pp. 279-
trial gas turbines. We used AM technol- vanced nozzle designs, 287. l
600 K 43600
K 43 Volume
89/2009
1435-3199 · ISSN
· ISSN 14
Volume 90/2010 35-3199
K 4360
199 0
35-3
N 14
· ISS
009
e 89/2
Volum
Focus:
Furnac
Steam es,
Focus: Pro Quality G
and Stea enerators
m Turb
ines
The Pro-quality USC 70
e Approach
nanc 0
Techno °C Power
ainte ts logy
s: M
Focu wer Plan Quality in the
of Po Construction
Ultra-lo
w
of ts Combu NOx
epts lants of New Power Plan stion
Conc Power P
IGCC Quality Monitoring
of Replace
nt o f Strategy ment
ssme r Steam Turbine Sets Superh of a
Asse rators fo lants K4
360
0
eater St
Gene Power P l age
Wind Supply of Technica Econom Volum
for Documentations
e 89/2
combu ic Post- · ISSN 1435-3199
009
Data
nical stion C
Tech r Plants Capture
Process n
arbo
e
Pow ertie
s es K 43600
Prop 9
ation143O5-il3s19 Volume 89/2009 ·
ISSN 1435-3199 Congress Issue
Oxid Irb Sin
N e Interna K 4360
5u
of0T · S tio 0
for Elec nal Journal
20 tricity and
85/ Heat Ge
me International Jour
nal neration
Volu Heat Generation
Publica
onB tion of
for Electricity and l Ed VG
i ti PowerTec
r na tiona www.v h e.V.
Inte gb.org
Publication of tion
VGB PowerTech
e.V. International Edi
l tion www.vgb.org
urna t Genera
nal Jo ea
natio ty and H
Inter ci
ectri
for El
of
cation e.V.
Publi werTech Interna
Po tional Ed
VGB gb.org ition
.v
www
Focus:
in Com Power Plan
petito ts
n
New P
ower
: P ro je P la nt
ema s cts of
ktth ergien Focus: VGB Congres Eskom
pun n
wer re E Power Plants 2009 Qualit
Sch euerba ys fo r
y Assu
ra
Er n a N ew Po nce
thw vities wer P
n Pa Report on the Acti lants
roge rios of VGB PowerTech Advan
Hyd Scena ta
and 2008/2009 Flexib ges of
II – itions G
le The
rm
rk d enera al
swe Con tion
Kop vailing n EDF Group Reduce
s
Pre Desig its Carbon Footprin
t Marke
and t Overv
fo r Impo ie
ank ark rted C w
w B ind P Optimising Wind Farm oal
Arklohore W
Offs r ve Maintenance
te
Wa Direc ti
E U-
The mework Concept for Solar
Fra ts Internatio
Hybrid Power Plan for n
nal Jo
Electri ditio
ur
city an nal al E
d Heat tion
Genera rna
Pu Inte
Qualifying
blicati tion
VGB Po on of
ww rs werTech
Power Plant Operatow.vgb.org e.V.
on
rati
al ene
ourn Heat G
al J
tion ity and International Jour
nal
rna Heat Generation
Inte lectric for Electricity and
E
for of .V.
tion he
u blica erTec Pub lication of tion
P Pow rg VGB PowerTech
e.V. International Edi
VGB .vgb.o Interna
ww
w www.vgb.org tional
Edition
Please copy >>> fill in and return by mail or fax
Yes, I would like order a subscription of VGB PowerTech.
Name, First Name
The current price is Euro 275.– plus postage and VAT.
Unless terminated with a notice period of one month to
Street
the end of the year, this subscription will be extended for
a further year in each case.
Postal Code City Country
Phone/Fax
s
uch al
Jetzt a 4
re s - C D 201
Jah en
l e n A usgab
mit a l ch
werTe €
© Sergey Nivens - Fotolia
B P o
der VG s: nur 98,–
hre
des Ja
PowerTech-CD/DVD!
Kontakt: Gregaro Scharpey
Tel: +49 201 8128-200
mark@vgb.org | www.vgb.org
Ausgabe 2014: Mehr als 1.100 Seiten Daten, Fakten und Kompetenz
aus der internationalen Fachzeitschrift VGB PowerTech
(einschließlich Recherchefunktion über alle Dokumente)
Bruttopreis 98,- Euro incl. 19 % MWSt. + 5,90 Euro Versand (Deutschland) / 19,90 Euro (Europa)