Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Scissor Jack Design Report
Scissor Jack Design Report
CHAPTER I
INTODUCTION
A mechanical jack is a device which lifts heavy equipment. The most common form is a car
jack, floor jack or garage jack which lifts vehicles so that the maintenance can be performed.
Car jacks usually use mechanical advantage to allow a human to lift a vehicle by manual
force alone. More powerful jacks use hydraulic power to provide more lift over greater
distances. Mechanical jacks are usually rated for a maximum lifting capacity.
A scissor jack is a device which is used to lift heavy vehicles, partially or fully in the air for
breakdown and maintenance. Scissor jack includes one power screw which is rotating, two
fixed nuts, four links which is connected to nuts, eight pins used to fixed that four links, two
rings provided at screw end and load platform supported by upper two links. Now a day,
different types of car jacks are available for lifting vehicles. However available car jacks are
either manually operated or using external power operated.
Fig 1.1
A scissor jack is operated with the help of lead screw which is in rotary or turning motion. In
this case on the horizontal plane a small force is applied which is used to lower or raise the
load. Scissor jack is a mechanism made up of nut and bolt arrangement and its principle of
working is same as that of inclined plane. Where a shaft rotates in its bearing on which
threads are wound around it. Mainly there are three types of Jack. i.e. Screw jack, Hydraulic
jack and Toggle (scissor) Jack. Out of which screw jack and toggle jack uses lead screw or
power screw for their
Functioning and the hydraulic jack use liquid instead of screw for the same. The design of
power screw used in scissor jack decreases the intensity of force required to drive the
mechanism by the user. With better design of power screw it is possible to magnify the force
required to rotate the screw. Power screw is nothing but the shaft which has threads around it,
used to convert rotary motion into translator motion.
Scissor jack is one of the most widely used accessories for lifting vehicles and light or heavy
equipment’s. It is relatively cheaper than its counterparts and most widely and readily
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
1
Scissor jack design
available. It is made up of High Carbon Steel and other alloying elements which impart
strength and ductility. It is rigid in construction but flexible in its pattern of usage. In the
repair and maintenance of automobiles (car), it is often necessary to raise an automobile to
change a tire or access the underside of the automobile.
A scissor lift (jack) or mechanism is device used to extend or position a platform by
mechanical means. The terms "Scissor" comes from the mechanism utilized which is
configured with linked, folding supports in a crisscross 'X' pattern. The extension or
displacement motion is achieved applying of force to one of the supports resulting and an
elongation of the crossing pattern.
The force applied to extend the scissor mechanism may be hydraulic, pneumatic or
mechanical (via a lead screw or rack and pinion system).
Fig 1.2
Fig 1.3
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
2
Scissor jack design
1.2 BACKGROUND
Before the invention of weight lifting device such as scissor jack, hydraulic
jack, crane etc the early man apply a crude way of lifting object to great heights through the
uses of ropes and rollers, which was mostly applied in the construction area.
There also reports on car jacks which lead to a serious number of accidents. These are due
of safety features that are on conventional car jacks are not enough. A specified jack
purposed to hold up to 1000 kilograms, but tests undertaken by Consumer Affairs has
revealed that is fails to work after lifting 250 kilograms and may physically break when it has
a weight close to its 1000 kilograms capacity.
Because of the interference between machine and human lives there is need for
standardization of its component parts to improve its performance, efficiency and to reduce
failure. For this reason care has to be taken during production and assembly of its
component parts. Many tools and equipment’s used in automotive industry are designed to
help the personnel working effectively such tools include the lifting device generally called
JACKS.
Automotive parts are mostly made of metal, which is a major reason for
its large weight, and as such requires devices of lifting and displacement of same. In
an automobile production, assembly and maintenance facility, components have to
be raised to certain heights w hich could be more convenient to the pers onnel
w orking on it. When s uch device is not available workers are often forced to bend from
the waist to access the components which can lead to strains and major discomforts or even
serious injuries that could affect productivity Consequently, a scissor jack that will be
adjustable will be required for use in the automotive industry to improve the efficiency of
personnel working in a production, assembly or maintenance facility. In order to do
this, a mechanism is recommended to be incorporated into a scissor lifting platform
(scissor jack) where the height is adjustable.
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
3
Scissor jack design
Hydraulic operated lifting platform which utilize the pressure power developed
from hydraulic oil to raise or lower a load.
Pneumatic lifting device which make use of air to create pressure or vacuum to
raise or lower load.
All this lifting devices have contributed greatly to the advancement recently being
experienced in the automotive industry, but most of them are still faced with various
challenges.
The most common problem encountered while using scissor jack is the instability of jack
while giving jerks to loosen the wheel nut. Also the common jack having small base is unable
to provide proper support on uneven surface esp. off-road and no inclination in that jack is
tolerable. This report presents a scissors mechanism with a table platform that
will be horizontal at every level. The proposed mechanism is operated by manually and
we design a double scissors for stability.
1.5 OBJECTIVE
To design a scissor lifting machine (scissor jack) that can be used in automotive
industry.
To determine the various process to be used in the manufacturing of non-standards.
To identify and list the components which are standard
The specific objective of the design process is to meet the following conditions and
specifications:
4
Scissor jack design
The device will have a maximum lift height of 270 mm
This objective is desirable to be achieved through the rotation of the power screw to
raise or lower the scissor jack.
The project also aims at designing and finding stresses, efficiency, expected life of screw.
We endeavor to develop a scissor jack such that it is cost effective, having a long life and
Can be handled roughly.
1.6 SCOPE
The scope of design and manufacturing of the device is based on the material
availability and the application of knowledge we have.
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
5
Scissor jack design
CHAPTER II
LITERATURE SURVEY
Scissor jacks are mechanical devices and have been in use since 1930s. A
scissor jack is a device constructed with a cross-hatch mechanism, much like a scissor, to lift
up a vehicle for repair. It typically works in a vertical manner. The jack opens and folds
closed, applying pressure to the bottom supports along the crossed pattern to move the lift.
When closed, they have a diamond shape. Scissor jacks are simple mechanisms used to
handle large loads over short distances. The power screw design of a common scissor jack
reduces the amount of force required by the user to drive the mechanism. Most scissor jacks
are similar in design, consisting of four main members driven by a power screw. A scissor
jack is operated simply by turning a small crank that is inserted into one end of the scissor
jack. This crank is usually "Z" shaped. The end fits into a ring hole mounted on the end of the
screw, which is the object of force on the scissor jack. When this crank is turned, the screw
turns, and this raises the jack. The screw acts like a gear mechanism. It has teeth (the screw
thread), which turn and move the two arms, producing work. Just by turning this screw
thread, the scissor jack can lift a vehicle that is several thousand pounds. A scissor jack has
four main pieces of metal and two base ends. The four metal pieces are all connected at the
corners with a bolt that allows the corners to swivel. A screw thread runs across this assembly
and through the corners. When opened, the four metal arms contract together, coming
together at the middle, raising the jack.
Fig 2.1
When closed, the arms spread back apart and the jack closes or flattens out again.
A scissor jack uses a simple gear drive to get its power. As the screw section is turned, two
ends of the jack move closer together. Because the gears of the screw are pushing up the
arms, the amount of force being applied is multiplied. It takes a very small amount of force to
turn the crank handle, yet that action causes the brace arms to slide across and together. As
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
6
Scissor jack design
this happens the arms extend upward. The car's gravitational weight is not enough to prevent
the jack from Opening or to stop the screw from turning, since it is not applying force directly
to it. If a person applies pressure directly on the crank, or lean his weight against the crank,
the person would not be able to turn it, even though his weight is a small percentage of the
cars.
The common method for operating a scissor lift (scissor jack) is the use of power screw.
Power screw is a device which used in converting rotary motion in to uniform longitudinal
motion. The manually operated scissor jack is a device that makes use of a horizontally
placed power screw to overcome large load through less effort applied on the power screw.
One of the most important factors of lift platform is its stability. We know that stability is a
source of concern for a lift platform, its positioning should be placed or concentrated at the
Centre of gravity of the table. Other constraint to be considered is the deflection of the unit.
Deflection in scissor lift can be defined as the resulting change in elevation of all parts of a
scissor lift assembly, typically measured from the floor to the top of the platform deck,
whenever load is applied to or removed from the lift. The ANSI MH 24.1 safety equipment
of industrial scissor lift states that “all industrial scissor lift will deflect under load” the
design standard goes on to outline the maximum allowable deflection based on platform size
number of scissor mechanism within the lift design. Scissor lift deflection becomes more
critical in material handling application where the lift must interface with a joining, fixed
elevations, especially when transferring rolling load. In this case it is important that any
difference in elevation between a joining surfaces during material transfer must be minimize
or if not totally eliminated.
Before attempting to discuss how to limit scissor deflection, it is important to understand the
contributing factors to a lift total deflection. An open or raised scissor acts very much like a
spring would apply a load and it compresses. When we removed the load it expands. Such
component within the scissor lift has the potential to store or release when loaded and
unloaded (and therefore deflects). There are applications of specific characteristics that may
promote deflection understanding these root causes help to pin-point and apply effective
measures to limit them.
A scissor jack is designed to lift the car in an emergency. It usually comes with the car and
stored in the trunk close to the spare tire or with the vehicle toolkit. It is designed for just
enough to lift and change a flat tire and get back on the road. Most scissor jacks are very
cheap to buy and most are not build enough. By a single repair we can use it for few times
before replacing it.
A double scissor jack that the driving mechanism is which the driven lifting jacks is driven by
horizontal power screw which mounted at the middle of the jack and that helps to gradually
lift the vehicle from the ground. It is called a double scissor jack because it consists of
diagonal metal pieces that expand or contract in a manner of resembling a pair of scissors. It
operated simply by turning a small crank that is inserted in the one end of the scissor jack,
this crank is inserted in the usual shape on the end of the ring hole mounted or the end of the
screw, which applies force on the scissor jack.
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
7
Scissor jack design
A scissor jack usually uses a simple theory of gears to get its power. As the screw section is
turned, the two ends of the jack moves closer together because the gears of the screw pushed
up the arms.
ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES
Therefore in order to avoid this accidents we should place the screw on a level surface and
don’t apply excess load and also we have to use the jack for only built purpose.
Automobile industry
Fig 2.2
Construction sites
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
8
Scissor jack design
Fig 2.3
Fig 2.4
Frame
Power screw
Rivet
Coupling nut
Crank
2.6.1 FRAME:
The entire frame of the scissor jack consists of links (top and bottom), base frame and support
frame. The frame is manufactured by sheet metal processes and forming by low-medium
carbon steel.
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
9
Scissor jack design
Power screws are typically made from carbon steel, alloy steel, or stainless steel
and they are usually used with bronze, plastic, or steel mating nuts. Bronze and plastic nuts
are popular for 20 higher duty applications and they provide low coefficients of friction for
minimizing drive torques.
There are important terms and figures that need to be understood before designing power
screws:
Pitch: is the distance from a point on one thread to the corresponding thread on the
next adjacent thread, measured parallel to the axial plane.
Lead: is the distance the screw would advance relative to the nut in one rotation. For
single thread screw, lead is equal to pitch.
Helix Angle: is related to the lead and the mean radius by the equation below;
Fig 2.5
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
10
Scissor jack design
1. Square threads:
Is used for power transmission in either direction
Results in maximum efficiency and minimum
It is employed in screw jacks and clamps
Fig 2.8
2. Acme threads:
It is a modification of square thread
Efficiency is lower than square threads
The slope increases the area for shear
It is easily manufactured
3. Buttress Thread:
It is used when large forces act along the screw axis in one direction only.
It has higher efficiency like square threads and ease of cutting like acme threads.
It is the strongest thread of all
It has limited use of power transmission
Fig 2.9
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
11
Scissor jack design
There are only few parts in power screw. This reduces cost and increase reliabiliy
2.6.3 RIVETS
A rivet is a permanent mechanical fastener. Before being installed a rivet consists of a smooth
cylindrical shaft with a head on one end. The end opposite the head is called the buck tail. On
installation the rivet is placed in a punched or pre-drilled hole, and the tail is upset, or bucked
(i.e. deformed), so that it expands to about 1.5 times the original shaft diameter, holding the
rivet in place. To distinguish between the two ends of the rivet, the original head is called the
factory head and the deformed end is called the shop head or buck-tail.
A coupling nut is a threaded fastener for joining two male threads, most commonly threaded
rod. The outside of the fastener is usually a hex so a wrench can hold it. Variations include
reducing coupling nuts, for joining two different size threads; sight hole coupling nuts, which
have a sight hole for observing the amount of engagement; and coupling nuts with left
handed threads.
2.6.5 CRANK
A crank is an arm keyed at right angles to the end of a shaft, by which motion is imparted to
the power screw .It mainly suffers from torsional stresses so medium carbon steel is used as it
combines merits of malleability and sufficient torsional strength.
CHAPTER III
In order to design a safe scissor jack the design is either to formulate a plan for the
satisfaction of a specified need or to solve a problem. If the plan results in the design of
something having a physical reality then the product must be functional, safe , reliable,
competitive, usable, manufacturable……these forms are defined as follows:
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
12
Scissor jack design
FUNCTIONAL: the product must perform to fill its intended need and customer
expectation.
SAFE: the product is not hazardous to the user or surrounding property. Hazards
that cannot be designed out are eliminated by guarding (a protective enclosure); if
that is not possible, appropriate directions or warning are provided.
RELIABLE: Reliability is the conditional probability of a design at a given
confidence level, that the product will perform its intended function satisfactorily
or without failure at a given life time.
COMPETITIVE: the product is a contender in its market
USABLE: the product is “user friendly” accommodating to human size, strength,
reach, force, power and control.
MANUFACTURABLE: the product has been reduced to minimum number of
parts which suited to mass production with dimension, distortion, and strength
under control.
MARKETABLE: the product can be brought and repair is available.
It is important that the design is begin by how to recognize satisfactory alternatives, and how
to distinguish between two satisfactory alternatives in order to identify the better. From this
optimization we can be formed or selected the better, then the fallowing tasks unfold:
Materials require for the manufacturing of a components depends upon the following
factors:
I. Properties:
The material selected must possess the necessary properties for the proposed application.
The various requirements to be satisfied can be weight, surface finish, rigidity, ability to
withstand environmental attack from chemicals, service life, reliability etc.
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
13
Scissor jack design
IV. AVAILABILITY OF MATERIALS:
Some materials may be scarce or in short supply. It then becomes obligatory for the designer
to use some other material which though may not be a perfect substitute for the material
designed.
The delivery of materials and the delivery date of product should also be kept in mind
V. SPACE CONSIDERATION:
Sometimes high strength materials have to be selected because the forces involved are high
and the space limitations are there.
VI. COST:
As in any other problem, in selection of material the cost of material plays an important part
and should not be ignored.
Sometimes factors like scrap utilization, appearance, and non-maintenance of the designed
part are involved in the selection of proper materials.
Materials with relatively high design stress such as stainless steel and low alloy steel can be
used more efficiently than carbon steel. But the cost of stainless steel is very high. The
availability to select this material is relatively low than the others because of the cost.
14
Scissor jack design
In this design the material selected for link is cast iron because
Very effective in damping vibration energy
High strength
Lower oxidation at elevated temperature
Better resistance to thermal shock
High thermal conductivity
Cast iron can be classified in to grey cast iron, ductile cast iron, white & malleable
cast iron and compact graphite iron.
From these types we choose malleable cast iron because
It has relatively high strength
Has appreciable ductility and malleability
Best for connected rod materials
Therefore material selection for link is malleable cast iron 2% carbon, 1%
silicon[ASTM A 47]
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
15
Scissor jack design
I. First we have to analyze the maximum and minimum height of the scissor jack
according to the data we have
II. We have to calculate the force analysis of the scissor jack by using the lifting load
III. We have to design all parts of the scissor jack and calculate their stress analysis
torque analysis of these parts
o Link
o Power screw
o Nut
o Washer
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
16
Scissor jack design
o Pin
o Base
o Guide bar
o Roller bearing
IV. After this we have to analyze the manufacturing process of all parts of scissor jack
V. Then we analyze the tolerance and fit of the design of manufactured part of scissor
jack
VI. Then we have to assembly the parts of scissor jack
VII. Finally we have to do the cost analysis of the parts of scissor jack and we determine
the total cost of the assembled scissor jack.
Case 1: the double scissor jack when it is minimum height or at initial position
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
17
Scissor jack design
Fig 3.1
Assumption: a = 15 mm
B = 5 mm
ymin=hmin−( 2 a+ 2b )
¿ 160− [2 ( 15 ) +2 ( 5 ) ]
ymin=120 mm
ymin
opp 2
sin θmin= =
hyp L
60
L= ……………………………..eq 1
sinθmin
Case 2: the double scissor jack when it is maximum position or final positio
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
18
Scissor jack design
Fig 3.2
ymax=hmax −2 a−2 b
¿ 270−30−10
ymax=230 mm
115
sin θ max ¿ …………………………………..eq 2
L
To calculate the length of the link and maximum angular displacement [θmax ¿ by iterate
θminfrom eqution (1) and (2)
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
19
Scissor jack design
According to the above itteration table itteration number 14 is the selected dimension. ( the
exact dimension)
Therefore L=116
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
20
Scissor jack design
Fig 3.3
Consider link 1:
+↑ ∑ Fy=0
−W
+ Ay + By=0
4
w
Ay= −By ……………………eqn (1)
4
+→ ∑ Fx=0
Ax−Bx=0
Ax=Bx…………………………eqn (2)
+↺ MB=0
W L L
Lcosθmin− Ax sinθmin− Ay cosθmin=0
4 2 2
4
We multiply both side by
cosθmin
W −2 Axtanθmin−2 Ay=0 …………eqn (3)
Consider link 2
+↑ ∑ Fy=0
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
21
Scissor jack design
−W
+ Cy−Ay=0
4
W
Cy= + Ay …………………………eqn (4)
4
+→ ∑ Fx=0
Cx−Ax=0
+↺ Mc=0
−W L L
Lcosθmin−Ay cosθmin+ Ax sinθmin=0
4 2 2
4
Multiply both side by
cosθmin
Now we have six equation with six unknowns, which make statically determinable
Adding eqn (3) and eqn (6)
W −2 Axtanθmin−2 Ay=0
−W +2 Axtanθmin−2 Ay =0
−4 Ay=0
Ay = 0
W
Ay= −By
4
W
0= −By
4
W 7 KN
By= = =1.75 KN
4 4
7 KN
Cy= =1.75 KN
4
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
22
Scissor jack design
From eqn (3) or eqn (6)
W −2 Axtanθmin−2 Ay=0
W =2 Axtanθmin
W 7 KN
Ax= =
2 tanθmin 2 tan 31°
Ax=5.285 KN
Bx=5.285 KN
Cx=5.285 KN
Consider link 3
+↑ ∑ Fy=0
+→ ∑ Fx=0
−Cx+ Dx−Ex=0
+↺ ME=0
L L
CyLcosθm∈+CxLsinθmin−Dx sinθmin−Dy cosθmin=0
2 2
2
Multiply both side by
cosθmin
Consider link 4
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
23
Scissor jack design
+↑ ∑ Fy=0
−By−Dy+Gy=0
+→ ∑ Fx=0
Bx−Dx+Gx=0
Gx=Dx−Bx ………………eqn(5)
+↺ MG=0
L L
−ByLcosθmin−BxLsinθmin−Dy cosθmin+ Dx sinθmin=0
2 2
2
We multiply both side by
cosθmin
Let Cy = By = 1.75 KN
Cx = Bx = 5.826 KN
Now we have six eqn with six unknown which makes in statically determinable
2 Cy+2 Cxtanθmin−Dxtanθmin−Dy=0
−2 By−2 Bxta nθmin−Dy+ Dxtanθ min¿ 0
2 Dy=−2 By−2 Bxtanθmin+2 Cy+2 Cxtanθmin
But By = Cy, Cx = Bx and θ min ¿ 31°
2 Dy=0
Dy=0
Dy=1.75 kn∧Dy=0
Gy=1.75 KN
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
24
Scissor jack design
Dx=Cx=5.825 KN
Dx=5.825 KN
NOTE:
The total number of links are 8. i.e (4 on one side and 4 on another side)
One fourth of the load is applied on each of the upper four links
Due to the symmetry analysing one side of the linkage is enough.
REMARK:
The load in the upper linkages and in the lower linkages are identical. Therefore
the corresponding reaction load are equal.
CHAPTER IV
DESIGN
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
25
Scissor jack design
The link carry axial compressive loads, which rules them tend to fail due to
elastic instability, or buckling. Elastic instability is a condition of failure in which the shape
of the column is insufficiently rigid to hold its straight under load. Therefore it is necessary
treat the links as columns and design them with stand buckling of the link is a plane
perpendicular to the vertical plane.
The end fixity: the manner in which the ends of column are supported is called end fixity. In
this design we can observe that the links are pinned at both ends, so the fixity is pinned-
pinned.
N.B: the data is read from mechaics of material, 4th edition, beer and johnston(Appendix B)
Applied load on the link: The pattern and magnitude of the load on the links are the same .
therefore, it is enough to take only one of the link and contiue on the design process.
W = 7 KN Bx = 5.825 KN L =116 mm
Ax = 5.825 KN By = 1.75 KN
Ay = 0 θmin=31 °
Fig 4.1
Resolving component along the axis of the link or X ' axis
W
Wo= cos (90−θmin)
4
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
26
Scissor jack design
7 KN
¿ cos ( 90−31)°
4
Wo=0.9 KN
Ax '=Axcosθmin
¿ 5.825 KN cos (31 °)
Ax '=4.993 KN
Wo and Ax ' are in the negative X ' direction, so the compressive load [Fc] is:
Fc=Wo+ Ax '
¿ 0.9+ 4.993
Fc=5.893 KN
By ' =0.9 KN
Bx ' =Bxcosθmin
¿ 5.825 cos (31° )
Bx ' =4.993 KN
Bx ' and By ' are in the positive X ' direction, so the compressive load [Fc] is:
Fc=5.893 KN
¿=C × L
C= 2 ( one end is fixed and other is free ) ………from table 16.2 khurmi &
gupta(page604)
¿=2× 116
¿=232 mm
27
Scissor jack design
Pcr=29.465 KN
b h3
Ixx=
12
C π 2 EI
creeping load: Pcr= 2
(¿ )
Assume X-X section: one end is fixed and the other free, thus (Le)xx = 2L
L
Assume Y-Y section : one end is fixed and the other end hinged, thus ( ¿ ) yy= = 0.707L
√2
Inorder to have stability the connecting link equally strong in both plane creeping load
c π 2 EIxx c π 2 EIyy
2
= 2
( ¿ ) xx ( ¿ ) yy
Ixx Iyy
2
= 2
( ¿ ) xx ( ¿ ) yy
L
Since (Le)xx = 2L and thus ( ¿ ) yy= = 0.707L, we have
√2
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
28
Scissor jack design
Ixx Iyy
=
( 2 L ) xx ( 0.707 L )2 yy
2
Ixx
=2 Iyy
4
Ixx = 8 Iyy
b h3 b3 h
=8
12 12
h h
h2 =8 b2 ……………. b= =
√8 2 √ 2
Now we find depth of the link from X-X section:
b h3 h h3 h4
Ixx¿ = × ……………………..Ixx= and c = 2(one end fixed and the other
12 2 √ 2 12 24 √2
free)
2
( Pcr ) xx= c π 2EIxx = Pcr
( ¿ ) xx
h4
2 π 2 (165 GPa)( )
33.94 4 4
¿ =1.783 h N /m m
(232 )2
Where π 2=3.1416
( Pcr )=(Pcr ) xx
h 12
b= = =4.24 mm … … … … … … … … … . say b=5 mm
√8 √ 8
Radius of gyration is given by:
Ixx b h3
Kxx=
√ A
… … … … … … … … … … … . but Ixx=
12
∧ A=b ×h
¿
√ √ √
b h3
12 bh
=¿
h2
h
=¿
(12)2
12
=¿ √ 12 ¿ ¿ ¿
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
29
Scissor jack design
Kxx=3.464 mm
Pcr C π 2 E
σcr = =
A L 2
K ( )
take C=1 , E=165 GPa∧σcr=550 MPa ¿
2
L 2 π 2 E π (165 GPa)
( )
K
=
σcr
=
550 MPa
L 2
( )
K
=2961
( KL )=54.4
Now check the slenderness ratio of euler column either short or long column.
N.B: the euler”s formula holds good only for long column unless otherwise we use other
formula like:
Rankin formula for column
Jhonson”s formula for column
( ¿ ) xx
Kxx ( KL )… … for short column
<
( ¿ ) xx
Kxx ( KL )… … … .. for long column
>
Therefore our euler column is long ( from text book of khumi chapter 16). Thus our design
of links are safe.
σc
σ= … … … … … … … … . n=5∧σc=620 MPa
n
620
σ= =124 MPa
5
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
30
Scissor jack design
The induced stress is less than the allowable crushing stress [ i.e σ < σcr ].
h h
Total length: Lt = L+ +
2 2
¿=128 mm
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
31
Scissor jack design
N.B: The above data is read from shigely table A – 24 and (Pb) from khurmi table 17.7
(page 646)
n= ¿! ¿
π / 4 [ ( do ) −( dc )2 ] Pb
2
11.65 KN
¿
π /4 [ ( 26 )2 −( 21 )2 ] 12.6
Assume p = 5
n=5
L=25 mm
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
32
Scissor jack design
but σall (allowable compressive stress for nut) and
τall ( allowable shear stress for nut )
τsu
τall= … … … … … … … … assume n=5
n
Where τsu – ultimate shear strength
From brittle colomb mohor τsu is given by:
σut × σuc 151.6 ×572
τsu= =
σut +σuc 151.6+572
τsu=119.8 MPa
τsu 119.8
τall= = =23.96 MPa
n 5
σuc 572
σall= = =114.4 MPa
n 5
4 (11.65)(1.65)
Therefore Di=
¿ √ 213.98+441
√ π (114.4)
+(21)2
Di=25.6 mm … … … … … … .. say 26 mm
Do=2 ( 26 ) + 4
Do=56 mm
N.B the inner diameter of the nut is equal to the major diameter of the screw ( Di = do)
τind = ¿! ¿
πnDit
p 5
t= = =2.5 mm
2 2
Where p is pitch
11.65
τ ind =
π (5)(26)(2.5)
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
33
Scissor jack design
Since the induced shear stress is less than the allowable shear stress, hence our design is
safe (i.e 11.4 MPa < 23.96 MPa)
Inner diameter Di 26 mm
Outer diameter Do 56 mm
Length or height L 25 mm
Number of thread N 5
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
34
Scissor jack design
N.B: The above data is read from shigely table A – 24 and (Pb) from khurmi table 17.7
(page 646)
dmax =1.5 do
This is because the outer diameter of the cap must be greater than outer diameter of the
screw.
dmax=1.5 ×26
dmax =39 mm
tc=2.5 mm
Ar=π × do ×tc
¿ π × 26 ×2.5
Ar=204 .2 mm 2
11.65 KPa
τin= ¿! = ¿
Ar 204.2 mm 2
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
35
Scissor jack design
τin=57 MPa
Shear allowable and stress allowable for nut and cap are equal
τall=23.96 MPa
σall=114.4 MPa
We know that the induced shear stress for cap is less than allowable shear stress for safe
design. But induced shear stress is greater than allowable shear stress. Therefore our design
of cap is not safe !
τin= ¿! = ¿! ¿¿
Ar π × do ×tc
¿! 11.65
tc = = ¿
π ×do × τin π × 26 ×23.96
tc =5.9 mm … … … … … … … say 6 mm
Since the induced crushing stress is less than the allowable crushing stress, thus our design
is safe (i.e 21.94 MPa < 114.4 MPa)
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
36
Scissor jack design
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
37
Scissor jack design
Fig 4.2
Where: t – thickness of washer
Do – outer diameter of washer
Di – inner diameter of washer
Di=do+1=26+1=27 mm
From text book of R.S.KHURUMI and J.K.GUPTA ultimate shear strength is given by: (page
199)
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
38
Scissor jack design
¿ 0.8 ×320
Now we find the allowable compressive stress and shear stress by assuming the factor of
safety n = 4
σut 320
σall= = =80 MPa
n 4
τut 256
τall= = =64 MPa
n 4
πd c 2
σall=B ¿! … … … … … … ..but A= ¿
A 4
Where: dc - core diameter of the screw
B – overload factor
Fact – actual force, which is applied at the center of the cross bar
4 × 1.65 ×11.65
d c 2=¿ 4 × B× ¿! = =407.9 mm 2 ¿
πσall π (60)
dc=20.2 mm … … … . say 21 mm
Torrque to rise the load and overcome friction between nut and screw:
Using the above calculated core diameter we read from a text boo of machine
design R.S.KHURUMI and J.K.GUPTA table 17.2 (page 627)
do = 26 mm
p=5
μ=0.15−0.25 …………………from shigely table 8-5 (page 422)
We take μ=0.25 for safe design
Where: do – major diameter
P – Pitch
μ – coefficient of friction
do+ dc 26+ 21
dm= = =23.5mm
2 2
39
Scissor jack design
L=2 P=2 ( 5 )=10 mm
10
( )
α =tan−1 π ( 23.5 ) ¿ = 7.714°
¿
Where: ∅ - friction angle
α – helix angle
L – lead
Dm – mean diameter
τ =29.8 MPa
( σc ) max=51 MPa
Since the maximum principal stress is less than the allowable compressive stress [(
σc ¿ max<σall ¿] our desig is safe.
Maximum shear stress is given by:
(33.63)2 + 4(29.8)2
τ=√
2
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
40
Scissor jack design
τ =34.216 MPa
Since the maximum shear stress is less than the allowable shear stress [(τmax ≤ τall ¿],
thus our design is safe.
L
young”s modulus and slenderness ratio, namely .
K
Let: L= actual length of the column b/n supports
Le = effective length of the screw
C = constant dependent on the end fixity
K = least radius of gyration of the screw
The following data is already calculated from the previous:
L= 116 mm, θ min ¿ 31° ∧Ymax=120 mm
We take the initial posistion(hmin) to get large thread position
X =Lcosθmin
¿ 116 cos (31 ° )
X =99.5 mm
L= X +2Ce
Where X = length of the thread position
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
41
Scissor jack design
L = length of the link
Ce =clearance…….assume Ce = 3 mm
L=99.5+ 2(3)
L=105.5 mm
¿=cL
Where: c = 1.2 (for fixed fixed fixity)…..from shigely table 4.2 page 183
¿=1.2 ( 105.5 )
¿=126.6 mm
1 1 1
Pc=σc × A then = +
Pr Pe Pc
π 2 EIc
Pe=
L2
1 L2 1
= 2 +
Pr π EIc σc × A
1 L2 σc + π 2 E K 2 C
= 2
Pr π cE K 2 Aσc
cσc × A σc
Pr ¿
σc L 2 ( )
… … … … … … … … .let a=¿ 2 ¿
π E
( )( )
2
π E K
+C
cσc × A
Pr ¿
L 2
( a×( )
K
)+ C
MATERIAL 1/a σc ¿
Mild steel 7500 300
Wrought iron 8000 250
Cast iron 1800 560
Timber 1000 35
From the given data sure material is steel
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
42
Scissor jack design
1
=7500∨a=1.33 ×10−4 ∧σc=300 Mpa
a
4
πd c 4 π ( 21 )
I= = =9546.56 m m 4
64 64
2
πd c 2 π ( 21 )
A= = =346.36 m m2
4 4
I 9546.56
K=
√ √ A
=
346.36
=5.25 mm
L 105.5
Slemderness ratio: (S) ¿ = =20
K 5.25
1.2 ( 300 ) ×346.36
Pr ¿ 2
105.5
( 1.33 ×1 0−4 ( 5.25 ) )+ 1.2
Pr=99.4567 KN
Permissible buckling load (Pp):
Pr
Pp= … … … … … … … … … . assume n=5
n
99.4567 KN
Pp=
5
Pp=19.89 KN
Since the loading capacity of the power screw is less than the permissible buckling
load [ i.e Fact ¿ Pp ] or [ 11.65 KN ¿ 19.89 KN ]. Therefore our design of power
screw is safe.
Now we find the total length of power screw:
Let: tps = thickness of power screw = 0.75 do=19.5 mm
Dmax = maximum diameter of power screw = 2 do+ 4=56 mm
m = free thread clearance, assume m = 2 mm
Ln = length of the nut = 25 mm
X = length of the base = 100 mm
a = the clearance for self-locking = 5 mm
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
43
Scissor jack design
t = thickness of washer = 4 mm
tc = thickness of the cap = 6mm
do = major diameter of power screw = 26 mm
Lth = length of thread for power screw
Length of thread is given by:
ln ln
Lth=m+ + X−a+ +t +tc
2 2
¿ 2+12.5+100−5+12.5+4 +6
Lth=132 mm
Total length of power screw:
Ltotal=Lth+ a+t ps+ K … … … … … … … Where k=8
¿ 132+5+19.5+8
Nth=26.4 … … … … .. say 28
Core diameter Dc 21 mm
Major diameter Do 26 mm
Pitch P 5 mm
Bucking load Pb 19.89 KN
Maximum diameter Dmax 56 mm
Length of thread Lth 132 mm
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
44
Scissor jack design
Number of thread Nth 28
Thickness of power screw Tps 19.5 mm
Total length Ltotal 165 mm
Mean diameter Dm 23.5 mm
Assume y = 6mm
z = 10 mm
Fig 4.3
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
45
Scissor jack design
Brinell hardness BHN 80
The data is read from shigely text book table A- 24 (page 1047)
Fig 4.4
We assume normal person can apply force from F = 150 N – 350 N. For our case we
have choose a force of F = 350 N because for safe design we take maximum force
Thickness of the handle (th) = 20 mm
Length of the handle (Lh) = 80 mm
Height of the handle (Hh) = 100 mm
Ma=31500 N . mm
(it is also taken as a torque since due to rotation effect about A)
The combined stress due to bending moment and torque developed can be determined as
follows:
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
46
Scissor jack design
Mc
σb=
I
100
Where c= =50
2
I =∑ Icentroidal +∑ A d 2=∑(Icent + A d2 )
Y =45 mm
I =∑ Icentroidal +∑ A d 2=∑(Icent + A d2 )
1 1 1
¿ (60 ×2 03 )+60 ×20 ( 45−10 )2 + (6 0 3 ×20)+60 ×20 ( 45−50 )2 + (2 03 × 40)+ 20× 40 ( 45−90 )2
12 12 12
I =3,546,666.67 mm4
31500(50)
σb=
3,546,666.67
σb=0.444 MPa
Since the bending stress is less than the allowable stress [i.e. 0.44 MPa < 41.25 MPa]. Hence
our design is safe.
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
47
Scissor jack design
From text book of machine design R.S.KHURMI…ultimate shear strength is given by:
τut 416
τall= = =208 MPa
n 2
Now we find the diameter of the pin:
Fig 4.5
Where do = outer diameter of pin
L = length of the pin
d = inner diameter of the pin
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
48
Scissor jack design
t = thickness of the pin
c = clearance
Fig 4.6
2 Bx 2 Bx 2(5825)
τall=
πd 2
… … … … … … … .. d=
√
π ×τall
=
√
π (208)
d=4.22 mm
BxL π d4 d
M= ,I= , C=
8 64 2
Now bending stress is given by:
BxL d
×
M ×C 8 2 4 BxL
σall= = = =σb
I πd 4
π d3
64
From khurmi L =d – 2d, we take L = 1.2 d
4 Bx(1.2 d ) 4 ×1.2 Bx 4.8(5825)
σall=
πd 3
=
πd 2
… … … … d=
√
π (145)
d=7.83mm
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
49
Scissor jack design
Bx 5825
Bx=1.2d 2 × Pb … … … … d=
√ 1.2 Pb √
=
1.2(77)
d=7.94 mm
We take the largest diameter of the three cases. Therefore:
d=7.94 mm … … … … … . say 8 mm
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
50
Scissor jack design
The base is used to support structure of machine and heavy equipment that are
exposed to vibrational and over loads.
Fig 4.7
τut 240
τall= = =30 MPa
n 8
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
51
Scissor jack design
Mb@ (Y =O )=0
Mb@ (Y =50 )=87500 Nmm
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
52
Scissor jack design
Fig 4.8
MC
σb= … … … … … … … but C=7.5 mm , M =Mb=87500 mm∧I =281.25 w mm 3
I
87500 ×7.5
σb=σall … … … … … … … … =81.875
281.25 w
87500 ×7.5
w=
281.25× 81.875
w=28.5 mm
This indicates that the width of base must be greater than 28.5 mm for safe design [say w =
100 mm]
Now we check the width of the base by using induced shear stress:
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
53
Scissor jack design
V
τind =
A
Where: V - shear force, V = 1750 N
A – Area of base (A = wx = 100 ×100=10000 mm 2 )
1750
τin= =0.175 MPa
10000
Since the induced shear stress is less than the allowable shear stress [i.e. 0.175 MPa < 30
MPa] our design is safe.
N.B: the above design is for upper base and it also the same as for lower base
Total length of the base is given by:
Ltot=100+2 a=100+2 ( 10 )
Ltot=120 mm
Table 4.14: Safe dimension for base
Thickness T 15 mm
Length X 100 mm
Width W 100 mm
Area A 10, 000 mm2
Total length Ltot 120 mm
Force applied W 7 KN
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
54
Scissor jack design
Fig 4.9
t 15
Assume d=b= = =5 mm … … … … … … … … .∧l=X=100 mm
3 3
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
55
Scissor jack design
Height of bar D 5 mm
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
56
Scissor jack design
Since the induced bending stress is less than the allowable bending stress [ 82 MPa <
114.4 MPa ] hence our design is safe
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
57
Scissor jack design
Types of roller bearings:
1. Cylindrical roller bearings
2. Spherical roller bearings
3. Needle roller bearings
4. Tapered roller bearings
Now we select cylindrical roller bearing since these bearings have short roller
guided in a cage. These bearings are relatively rigid against radial motion and we have the
lowest coefficient of friction of any form of heavy duty rolling contact bearings
η %=33.94
The power output of power screw is given by:
Wout
Pout = =¿
t
Where; W – output work of the screw
t – Time in minute or second
W =×! πdm=11650 × π ×23.5=860 Nm
Assume t = 1 sec
860 Nm
Pout =
1 sec
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
58
Scissor jack design
Pout =860 watt
The power input is given by:
Pout 860
Pin= = =¿
η 0.3394
Pin=2533.5 watt
2 πN
P∈¿ T ×W … … … but W = … … . wher e n−number of rotational speed
60
T 2 πN Pin ×60 2533.5 ×60
Pin= … … … .. N= =
60 T ×2 π 54.2 ×2 π
N=446.4 rpm
N.B. the rotational speed of the power screw and roller are equal [N = N D = 446.4
rpm]. Where ND = desired speed
The desired load is not manufacturers test load or catalogue entry. The desired speed
is different from the vendors test speed, and the reliability expectation is typically
much higher than the 0.9 accompanying the catalogue entry.
The rating load for cylindrical roller bearing is given by:
1
C lo=F D
XD
XB( ) … … … … …. where a= 103 … … for roller bearing
a
60 N D L D L D 60 N D L D
X D= = =
60 N R L R L R LR
W W
F D=f × … … … … … … .. =1.75 KN (the radial support load)
4 4
where F D=desired load ( radial )∧f =load factor
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
59
Scissor jack design
ND – Desired speed in rpm
XD – multiple of rate life
60 N D L D
X D= … … … . since N D=446.4 rpm , L R=106 rev
LR
LD = [100 – 200] Khr = 100 Khr …………read from shigely table 11 – 4 (page 583)
f = [1.2 – 1.5]…..for light impact we take f = 1.32 ……….from shigely table 11 – 5 (page
583)
W
F D=f × =1.32 ×1.75 KN
4
F D=2.31 KN
1lb
1
X B= Xo+ ( θ− Xo ) ln ( Ro )
Where: Ro – Reliability contour ……..Ro ≥0.9 for safe design of cylinderical roll
We take Ro = 0.95
From weibull parameters Xo=0.02 , ( θ−Xo )=4.439∧b=1.483
1 l 1.483
1
X B=0.02+ ( 4.439 ) ln (
0.95 )
But for best design
1 1
ln =ln … … … … .. Pf =1−Ro
Ro 1−Pf
Where Pf – probability of failure
1lb
X B= Xo+ ( θ− Xo )( 1−Ro )
X B=0.02+ ( 4.439 ) (1−0.95 )1 l 1.483
X B=0.6088
1
XD
C lo=F D ( ) XB
a
1
2678.4
C lo=2.31 KN (
0.6008 )
3.333
C lo=28.6 KN
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
60
Scissor jack design
Assume for cylindrical roller bearing
Outré diameter (Do) = 62 mm
Width of roller = 17 mm
Co = 15 KN…………Read from table 11.3 (page 582) by using Clo
Now we check Co ≥ F D for safe∧Co≤ F D for not safe
Since Co ≥ F D [15 KN > 2.31 KN]. Our design is safe
Assume: inner diameter =30 mm
Ball race diameter = 8 mm
Table 4.20: Safe dimension for roller bearing
Outer diameter Do 62 mm
Width W 17 mm
Ball race diameter D 8 mm
Inner diameter Di 30 mm
CHAPTER V
MANUFACTURING PROCESS
Table 5.1: operations in links
DESIGN OF SCISSOR JACK
Material: cast iron
Quantity: 8
no Name of Machines Tools Power remark
operations sources
1 Blank layout Band saw Meters electric -
of shearing
2 Milling Milling machine Carbide tip electric Mill the
dimension
to width of
12 mm
3 Milling Milling machine Shell and electric Cut the
mill semi-circle
at one end
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
61
Scissor jack design
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
62
Scissor jack design
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
63
Scissor jack design
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
64
Scissor jack design
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
65
Scissor jack design
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
66
Scissor jack design
Quantity: 1
no Name of Machines Tools Power remark
operations sources
1 Blank layout Band saw Meters electric -
of shearing
2 Milling Milling machine Carbide tip electric Mile up to
we get the
exact
dimension
of facing
3 Facing Lath machine - electric -
4 Drilling Drilling machine Center drill electric Drill to
and drill bit diameter 10
mm
5 Bore Boring machine File - Boring
diameter is
26 mm
6 Welding Electric arc electrode Electric -
welding
7 Press fit Press machine electric -
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
67
Scissor jack design
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
68
Scissor jack design
CHAPTER VI
RESULTS
Table 6.1 DIMENSION AND TOLERANCES
a. Power screw
Dimension Tolerance
Core diameter[dc] 21 mm ± 0.02 mm
screw[Ltotal]
Mean diameter[dm] 23.5 mm ± 0.02 mm
b. Link
dimension Tolerance
Total length 128 mm ± 2mm
Length 116 mm ± 2mm
Width 5 mm ± 0.01 mm
depth 12 mm ± 0.02 mm
c. Nut
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
69
Scissor jack design
dimensions tolerance
Inner diameter of nut[Di] 26 mm ± 0.02 mm
Height of nut[Ln] 25 mm ± 0.2 mm
No. of thread of nut[Nn] 5 mm -
Outer diameter[Do] 56 mm ± 0.01 mm
e. Pin
Dimensions Tolerances
Total length[Ltot] 20 mm ± 6 mm
Inner diameter[Di] 8 mm ± 1mm
Outer diameter[Do] 12 mm ± 1mm
Thickness[t] 6 mm ± 2mm
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
70
Scissor jack design
($/kg) (birr/kg) ρ
( mkg )
3
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
71
Scissor jack design
A – 48
Guide bar Grey cast iron 1.9 43.7 7200
4.5%c ASTM
A – 48
cost
cost of power screw=m × =3.2×18.4 = 58.88 birr
kg
total cost of power screw=58.88 birr
V. Cost of base:
V =1.8 × 10−4 m 3∧m=1.29 kg
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
72
Scissor jack design
cost
cost of base=m× =1.29× 43.7=56.373 birr
kg
total cost of base=2 ×56.373=112.75 birr
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
73
Scissor jack design
Conclusion
My design of double scissor jack was carried out successfully. It meets the entire
needed standard. This product will be much preferable from other products of the
same function because it is much simpler than that of other scissor jack products.
Other cause of its preferebility is load. Generally we believe we make a safe design of
double scissor jack.
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
74
Scissor jack design
Selemonassefa77@gmail.com
75