Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Unit - 5 Performance Appraisal/Performance Evaluation
Unit - 5 Performance Appraisal/Performance Evaluation
PART-B
Explain the steps for conducting PA
Explain the methods of PA
Outline the modern methods of appraisal
Explain 360degree appraisal with advantages and disadvantages
Explain MBO as method of appraisal
Advantages and disadvantages of MBO
What is BARS
Explain the errors in appraisal/Explain the factors distort PA
Importance /need/objectives of appraisal
Part –B
Explain the guidelines/Policy?principles for considering an employee for promotion
Explain Different types of transfer
State the advantages of Transfer
State the reasons for demotion and guidelines for demotion
Explain transfer policy in detail
Explain different methods of separation
CONTROL
What is control process
Outline the standards of control
What is budgetary control
Need for control
PART-B
Explain the process of controlling
State the importance of controlling
Outline the methods of controlling
State the components of effective control
GRIEVEANCE
What is grievance
What is discipline
State the reasons for grievance
Importance of grievance machinery
PART_B
Explain the process of grievance redressal/Grievance Machinery
Explain the reasons for grievance
Part – A
1. Explain the term performance appraisal?
Ans A performance appraisal is a process of evaluating an employee’s performance of a
job in terms of its requirements.
2. What is the purpose and importance of P.A?
Formal appraisal plan are designed to meet three needs, one of the organization and the
other two of the individual namely;
They provide systematic judgments to increments, transfer, demotion or termination.
Identify on which the subordinates want to improve i.e. Behaviour, attitude, skills and job
knowledge.
It is the basis for giving counseling and coaching the individual by the superior.
3. What are the objectives of P.A?
1. To enable an organization to maintain an inventory of the number of quality of all
mangers and to identify and meet their training needs.
2. To determine increments, rewards, promotion, transfer.
3. To maintain individual and group development by informing the performance
standards.
4. To suggest ways of improving the employees performance.
5. To identify training and development needs.
6. To plan for career development.
4. What is MBO?
It is a process whereby the superior and subordinate managers of an organization
jointly identify its common goals, define each individual’s major areas of responsibility
in terms of results expected of him and use these measures as guides for operating the
unit and assessing the contributions of each of is members.
5. What is BARS?
This is a new appraisal technique which has recently been developed. This is a
combination of critical incident and graphic scaling. This method uses an instrument-A
subset of incidents are used as “behavioural anchors” for the performance dimensions
6.Who can be an appraiser?
The appraisal can be done by one or more individuals involving a combination of the
immediate supervisor, other manager acquainted with the assesses work, a higher level
manger, a personnel manger, the assessee’s peers, the assessee himself and the assessee’s
subordinates.
8.What is promotion?
It is upward reassignment of an employee with increased pay and responsibilities It is a
type of job change. It is an upward advancement of an employee in an organization to
another job, which commands better pay/wages, better status/prestige and higher
opportunities/challenges, responsibility and authority, better working environment, hours
of work and facilities and a higher rank.
9.What is demotion?
It is downward reassignment of an employee The assignment of an individual to a job of
lower rank and pay usually involving lower level of difficulty and responsibility.It used
as a punitive measure when there are serious breaches of duty on the part of an employee
when it is often a preliminary to a dismissal.
10.What is transfer?
A transfer is a horizontal or lateral movement of an employee from ob e job, section,
department, shift, plant or position to another at the same or another place where his
salary, status and responsibility are the same.
11.What is resignation?
It may be put in voluntarily by the employees on grounds of health, physical disability,
better opportunities elsewhere, or maladjustment with company policy and officers, or for
reasons of marriage or they may be compulsory when an employee us asked to put in his
resignation if he wants to avoid termination of his services on the ground of gross
negligence of duty on his part, or some serious charge against him.
12.Short note on discharge?
A discharge involves permanent separation of an employee form the payroll for violation
of company rules or for inadequate performance.
13. Dismissal
A dismissal is the termination of the service of an employee by way of punishment for
some misconduct, or for unauthorized and prolonged absence from duty.
14.suspension
This is a serious punishment and is generally awarded only after a proper enquiry has
been conducted. For reasons of discipline, a workman may be suspended without
prejudice during the course of an enquiry. During suspension the employee receives a
subsistence allowance.
15.Retrenchment
It means a permanent termination of the services of an employee for economic reasons in
a going concern. The industrial disputes act 1947 defines retrenchment as the termination
by the employer of the service of workmen for any reasons.
16.Attrition?
Gradual wearing down of the size or the number of employees in the organization.
17.Turnover?
The rate of changes in the working staff of a concern during a definite period, it signifies
the shifting of the work force into and out of an organization. It is a measure of the extent
to which old employees leave and new employees enter into service in a given period. It
is sometimes defined as a measurement of inarticulate labour unrest.
PART – B
1. Briefly explain who is the rater and process of P.A?How do you conduct PA
The performance evaluation process:
A.Establishing performance standards:
The standard should be clear, it should be discussed with the supervisors to find out
which different factors (qualities like leadership, communication skill, attitude, etc)
are to be incorporated
B.Communicate performance expectations to employees:
The standards should be informed to the employees otherwise it would be difficult to
guess what is expected of them.
C.Measuring actual performance:
Four source of information are frequently used to measure actual performance,
personal observation, statistical reports, oral reports and written reports
D.Compare actual performance with standards:
Comparison of actual performance with standards and attempts are made to note
deviations between standard performance and actual performance.
E.Discuss the appraisal with the employee:
The results of appraisal are discussed periodically with the employees, where good
points, weak points, and difficulties are indicated and discussed so that performance is
improved.
Paired comparison method:Each employee is compared every trait with all the other
persons in pairs one at a time. With the technique, judgment is easier and simpler than
with the ordinary ranking method. This method is not suitable when a group is large
because in that case, the number of judgments becomes excessively large.
E.g. For the trait “quality of work”
As compared
A B C D E
to
A + + - -
B - - - -
C - + + -
D + + - +
E + + + -
Grading method:
Under this system, the rater considers certain features and marks them accordingly to a
scale. Certain categories of worth are first established and carefully defined. The selected
features may be analytical ability, co-cooperativeness, responsibility, self-expression, job
knowledge, judgment, leadership and organizing ability, etc, They may be : A-
outstanding; B- very good; C- good or average; D- fair, E- poor and –B very poor or
hopeless.
Graphical of linear rating scale:Method uses printed form An employee characteristics
are included such qualities as initiative, leadership, co-cooperativeness, dependability,
industry, attitude, enthusiasm, loyalty, creative ability, etc. these traits are then evaluated
on a continuous scale, wherein the rater places a mark.
Forced Choice description method:The rating elements are several sets of pair phrases
or adjectives (usually sets of four phrases two of which are positive, and two
negative) relating to job proficiency or personal qualifications. The rater is asked to
indicate which of the four phrases is most and least descriptive of the employee.
makes little effort and individual instruction;
organizes the work well;
lacks the ability to make people feel at ease;
has a cool, even temperament;
is punctual and careful;
is a hark worker and co-operative;
is dishonest and is loyal;
Is overbearing and disinterested in work.
Forced distribution method:A five point performance scale is used without any
descriptive statements. Employees are placed between the two extremes of good and bad
job performances; for example, 10 5% are placed at the top end of the scale, given
superior or outstanding merit; 20% given good rating; 40 % satisfactory ; 20% fair ; 10%
unsatisfactory. This method assumes that, of total personnel 10% must go to the top
grade, 20 % to the second grade, 40 % to the middle grade 20 % grade next to the lowest
end and 10% of the lowest grade.
Check list:A series of questions are presented concerning an employee to his behavior.
The rater then, checks to indicate if the answer to a question about an employee is
positive or negative. Mostly yes/ no questions are asked (close ended questions)
Weighted checklist_Giving additional weightage to the traits required for the job
Free essay method:The supervisor makes a free form, open ended appraisal of an
employee in his own works and puts down his impressions about the employees.
Critical incident method:The essence of this system is that is attempts to measure
workers’ performance in terms of certain events that occur in the performance of the
ratee’s job. These events are known as critical incidents. The supervisor keeps a written
record of the events either good or bad that can be easily be recalled and used in the
course of a periodical or formal appraisal. Feedback are recorded under such categories
as the type of job, requirements for employees, judgment, learning ability, productivity,
precision in work, responsibility and initiative.It is discovered after a thorough study of
the personnel working on a job. The collected incidents are then ranked in order of
frequency and importance.
Modern method:
MBO: management by objectives. It is a process whereby the superior and subordinate
managers of an organization jointly identify its common goals, define each individual’s
major areas of responsibility in terms of results expected of him and use these measures
as guides for operating the unit and assessing the contributions of each of is members.
The objective is to change behaviour and attitudes towards getting the job done. It is
results oriented. It stress goals rather that methods.
Process of MBO:
Set organization goals: establish of an organization goal, such goals are expressed
clearly and concisely and can be measured accurately.
Joint goal setting: establishment of short term performance targets between the
management and the subordinated in a conference between them. The individual manger
must clarify in his own mind the responsibilities of their subordinates. The manager and
subordinate then discuss them reach an agreement about them and put them in writing.
Performance review: during the initial stage of the MBO programme, monthly reviews
may be used and then extended to quarterly reviews. For maximum effectiveness,
reviews probably should be made more often then once each year. The actual
performance is taken.
Compare standards with actual: here the actual performance is compared with the
standard created so that the deviation can be find out and where they lack in and which is
the department lacks performance and which person.
Feed backs and corrective measures: the employees who receive frequent feedback
concerning their performance are more highly motivated than those who do not feedback
that is specific, relevant and timely helps satisfy the need most people fell about knowing
where they stand and improvement needed will also be found out.
Benefits of MBO Programme:
Increases employee motivation
Reduces internal conflict
Reduces role conflict
Helps in planning
Effective appraisal
Identifies problem earlier
Develops personal leadership
Disadvantages:
It looks sound but no evidence that it works
For a starter or a new employee effective appraisal is difficult
It becomes complex, it requires money and time
Fail in review will lead to waste.
A number of critical incidents were collected there and these were then clustered into
eight performance criteria viz.
1. knowledge and judgment
2. conscientiousness
3. skill in human relations
4. skill in operation of register
5. skill in bagging
6. organizational ability of check-stand work
7. skill in monetary transactions
8. Observational ability.
Then bases on the criteria 1-7 scale point is created and asked to rate the
performance of the employees.
Purpose of transfer
To satisfy such needs of an organization as may arise out of a change in the quantity of
production, fluctuations in work requirements.
To meet an employee’s own request when he feels uncomfortable on the job because of
his dislike of his fellow workers.
To utilize properly the services of an employee when he is to performing satisfactorily
and adequately and when the management feels that he may be more useful or suitable
elsewhere,
To increase the versatility of the employee by shifting him from one job to another so that
he may have ample opportunities for gaining a varied and broader experience of work
To adjust the work force of one plant with that of another particularly when one is closed
down for reasons beyond the control of the employees.
To replace a new employee by an employee who has been in the organization for a
sufficiently long time.
To help employees work according to their convenience so far as timings are concerned.
To penalize the employee transfers are also done.
Separation-Cessation of service with the organization for one or other reasons. The
employee may be separated from the pay roll of a company as a result of:
Resignation-It may be put in voluntarily by the employees on grounds of health, physical
disability, better opportunities elsewhere, or maladjustment with company policy and
officers, or for reasons of marriage or they may be compulsory when an employee us
asked to put in his resignation if he wants to avoid termination of his services on the
ground of gross negligence of duty on his part, or some serious charge against him.
Turnover: The rate of changes in the working staff of a concern during a definite period,
it signifies the shifting of the work force into and out of an organization. It is a measure
of the extent to which old employees leave and new employees enter into service in a
given period. It is sometimes defined as a measurement of inarticulate labour unrest.
What is job change and explain why people don’t go for changes?
It is a systematic moving of workers form one job to another. It may be from one
organization to another or inside the organization as promotion, transfer, etc,
What is the need for a grievance procedure and state its steps? (ref diagram frm
class notes ),Explain grievance machinery in detail
Need for grievance procedure
A grievance procedure is essential because it bring uniformity in the handling of
grievances. It gives confidence to the worker, for if he does not get a fair deal, he knows
what to do and who to approach to ensure that he does get justice. It also gives him
confidence that his complaints will be investigated and a decision given in a reasonable
periods of time.
Grievance procedure:
Step 1-The aggrieved employee verbally explains his grievance to his immediate
supervisor or in a conference or a discussion specifically arranged for the purpose. The
employee seeks satisfaction from his supervisor.
Step 2-The second step begins when the grievance is not settled by the supervisor. In this
case, it is sent to a higher level manager with a note in which are mentioned the time
place and nature of the action to which the employee objects.
The higher level manager is generally the chief business manager, a superintendent or an
industrial relations officer who goes into the grievance and gives his decision on the
matter.
Step3-This means that the grievance is to be submitted to the grievance committee since
the decision of the supervisor and of the higher level manager have not solved the
problem.
Step 4-If the decision or suggestion of the grievance committee is not accepted by the
grievant, he may approach the management or the corporate executive.
Step 5-An arbitrator is a third party intervention where is done not belong to the
management or the union, he is send by the government authorities. He will listen to the
both the management and the union and finally he makes suggestion which may or may
not be implemented, it is decided by the aggrieved party. This will take 7 days.