Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effects of Supine and Lateral Positions Cardiac and Intracardiac Experimental Study
Effects of Supine and Lateral Positions Cardiac and Intracardiac Experimental Study
VENTRICULAR PERFORMANCE
ABSTRACT Hemodynamic measurements in human subjects and in experimental animals are gener-
ally made in the supine position; not much attention is paid to potential beneficial or harmful effects of
right or left lateral positions on cardiac output or other hemodynamic variables. To evaluate the
potential influence of such positional changes on cardiac performance, we measured cardiac output and
left and right ventricular pressures (with micromanometer catheters) in anesthetized experimental
animals (eight dogs and nine pigs) in the supine, right lateral, and left lateral positions. Cardiac output
increased from supine to left lateral (mean SD, 2.6 +- 0.9 to 3.1 1.0 liters/min; p < .001) and
±
associated decrease in arteriovenous oxygen saturation difference from supine to left lateral position
(31 + 8% to 24 4%; p < .001) and from supine to right lateral position (32 9% to 25 6%; p <
± ± ±
.001). Left ventricular systolic and end-diastolic pressures increased from supine to left lateral (128
17/9 ± 2 to 147 19/16 4 mm Hg; both p < .001) and from supine to right lateral positions (128 +
±
19/9 2 to 141 16/16 7 mm Hg; p < .01 and p < .001, respectively). Similarly, right ventricular
± ±
systolic and end-diastolic pressures also increased from supine to left lateral (30 7/3 + 2 to 38 +
±
Downloaded from http://ahajournals.org by on August 6, 2021
7/8 2 mm Hg; both p < .001) and from supine to right lateral positions (31 8/3 + 2 to 43 + 8/11
± ±
+ 4 mm Hg; both p < .001). Systolic and end-diastolic right ventricular pressures were significantly
higher in the right lateral position than in the left (both p < .001). Heart rate did not change with
positional maneuvers. Neither the sequence of positional changes nor the species of animal (dog vs pig)
had any apparent influence on the results. Roentgenographic analysis of the differences in height of the
right ventricle relative to the inferior vena cava suggests that changes in hydrostatic pressure may be
entirely responsible for the increases in right ventricular end-diastolic pressure when animals are
changed from the supine to the left or right lateral positions. We conclude that a change from supine to
lateral position significantly increases intracardiac pressures and cardiac output in experimental ani-
mals. If confirmed in humans, these findings may have significant implications for the assessment of
hemodynamic status of patients in intensive care unit and catheterization laboratory settings and for the
treatment of patients in low-cardiac output states.
Circulation 73, No. 3, 579-585, 1986.
IN INTENSIVE CARE UNITS, catheterization labo- beneficial or harmful effects of right or left lateral
ratories, and animal research facilities, cardiac output positions on cardiac output or other hemodynamic va-
is usually measured with the patient or animal in the riables. Indeed, there are few data concerning the in-
supine position; not much attention is paid to potential fluence of supine and lateral positions on cardiac out-
put in experimental animals or human beings. In
From the Charles A. Dana Research Institute and the Harvard-Thorn- pregnant women in the third trimester, cardiac output
dike Laboratory of the Beth Israel Hospital, Department of Medicine,
Beth Israel Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston. increases by a mean of up to 27% with a change from
Supported in part by grant RR-01032 from the General Clinical Re- supine to lateral positions.' In nonpregnant human
search Centers Program of the Division of Research Resources, Nation-
al Institutes of Health. Data analysis was performed on the Clinical subjects, contradictory results have been reported.1' 4
Center Core Lab Facilities. Some investigators have described a higher cardiac
Address for correspondence: Patricia C. Come, M.D., Department of
Medicine, Cardiology Division, Beth Israel Hospital, 330 Brookline output in the supine position as compared with right
Ave., Boston, MA 02215. and left lateral positions.4' 6 However, Whitman et al.'
Received June 12, 1985; revision accepted Nov. 29, 1985. found cardiac output to be higher in the left lateral
*Present address: First Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of
Medicine, Kagoshima University, Kagoshima City 890, Japan. position than in supine and right lateral positions,
Vol. 73, No. 3, March 1986 579
NAKAO et al.
recorded during end-expiration. A No. 7F Swan-Ganz catheter alent millimeters of mercury by dividing the number of centi-
was inserted into the pulmonary artery via the right femoral vein meters by the conversion factor of 1.36. Changes in height of
in each animal. Cardiac output was measured by the thermodilu- the inferior vena cava relative to the right ventricle with alter-
tion method (Edwards 9520A cardiac output computer, Santa ations in position from supine to left lateral and from supine to
Ana, CA). The injectate was 10 ml of normal saline at a tem- right lateral were then computed.
perature of 00 to 10 C. Each cardiac output value was the mean To assess the possibility of position-related compression of
of at least three consecutive determinations having variation of the inferior vena cava, seven additional pigs were studied. A
less than 10%. Oxygen saturations of systemic arterial and Swan-Ganz catheter was inserted into the right femoral vein and
mixed venous blood, drawn from the left ventricle and the advanced into the right atrium, where the position of the tip was
pulmonary artery, respectively, were measured by the reflec- confirmed by pressure recording. With the fluid-filled catheter
tance oximeter method (Reflection Oximeter, American Optical system, simultaneous pressures were then recorded in supine,
Corporation, Buffalo, NY). right lateral, and left lateral positions both from the catheter tip
Experimental protocol. All 17 animals were evaluated ini- in the right atrium and from the side-hole in the inferior vena
TABLE 1
Effects of change from supine to lateral positions on hemodynamic variables (mean ± SD)
n Supine Left lateral Supine Right lateral
HR (bpm) 17 117+20 115+18 116+21 115+19
CO (l/min) 16 2.6+0.9 3.1+t .OA 2.6+0.9 3.1 + .A
AVO7SD(%) 11 31 +8 24 4A 32 9 25 6A
LVSP (mm Hg) 12 128 17 147 19A 128 19 141 16A
LVEDP (mm Hg) 12 9+2 16+4A 9+2 16±7A
RVSP (mm Hg) 17 30 7 38 7A 31+ 8 43 + 8AB
RVEDP (mm Hg) 17 3+2 8 2A 3+2 11 ±4A.B
HR = heart rate; CO = cardiac output; AVO2SD = arteriovenous oxygen saturation difference; LVSP = left ventricular
systolic pressure; LVEDP = left ventricular end-diastolic pressure; RVSP = right ventricular systolic pressure; RVEDP = right
ventricular end-diastolic pressure.
Ap < .01, right or left lateral vs supine.
Bp < .01, right vs left lateral.
580 CIRCULAT1[ON
LABORATORY INVESTIGATION-VENTRICULAR PERFORMANCE
cava located 30 cm from the catheter tip. The zero reference NS NS
I I 1 i p .
point of pressures was taken at mid chest in the supine position. / -
Statistical analysis. Measurements for all variables were 160r
determined to be normally distributed by the Wilkes-Shapiro
test, permitting use of parametric comparison methods. Var-
iances for each species (obtained from two-way analysis of 150 k
variance) were demonstrated equivalent by F test and the data
were therefore pooled. Resulting distributions were normal by
the Wilkes-Shapiro test, with homogeneous variances (Le- 140k
vene's test). Data were then analyzed for statistical significance
with an appropriate multiple-sample comparison test (two-way -
4
each of the 11 animals with measurements of both (L) and right lateral (R) positions in 17 animals. Values in dogs and pigs
cardiac output and oxygen saturations, the increase in are shown by solid and dashed lines, respectively. Mean values are
cardiac output observed with a change in position from represented by the horizontal bars.
supine to right or left lateral was associated with a
p<O.OO 1 p<O.OO 1
corresponding decrease in arteriovenous oxygen satu- r
/
4.0 /
alteration in position in each animal, reached a stable /- -----
50 r 30
40F
1-
0 30t
I 20
E
CO E
cnJ
0
C0 *..I -.,m
I1
_ _
201
W
_>
10k io1
wU- -4
0 1 1 A
S L S R
FIGURE 3. Changes in arteriovenous oxygen saturation difference
(AVO2SD), given as differences in percent saturations, from supine (S) 1) 1
to left lateral (L) and right lateral (R) positions in 1 1 animals. Values in S L S R
dogs and pigs are shown by solid and dashed lines, respectively. Mean FIGURE 5. Changes in left ventricular end-diastolic pressure (LVEDP)
values are represented by the horizontal bars. from supine (S) to left lateral (L) and right lateral (R) positions in 12
animals. Values in dogs and pigs are shown by solid and dashed lines,
respectively. Mean values are represented by the horizontal bars.
Downloaded from http://ahajournals.org by on August 6, 2021
170 A,?
50
160 -
150 _ 40 _
0)
I
0) 140 _ E
E E
E
a- 130h 0- 30F
0c
CO 120 _ cc)
_i 20-
110!_
100 _
101
90 -
T
S L S R
n
S L
.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
S R
FIGURE 4. Changes in left ventricular systolic pressure (LVSP) from FIGURE 6. Changes in right ventricular systolic pressure (RVSP) from
supine (S) to left lateral (L) and right lateral (R) positions in 12 animals. supine (S) to left lateral (L) and right lateral (R) positions in 17 animals.
Values in dogs and pigs are shown by solid and dashed lines, respective- Values in dogs and pigs are shown by solid and dashed lines, respective-
ly. Mean values are represented by the horizontal bars. ly. Mean values are represented by the horizontal bars.
582 CIRCULATION
LABORATORY INVESTIGATION-VENTRICULAR PERFORMANCE
The results of roentgenographic analysis of catheter third trimester, a change from supine to lateral posi-
position are shown in figure 8. In the two dogs studied, tions has been shown to increase cardiac output by a
the height of the right ventricle relative to the inferior mean of up to 27%. l-3 Compression of the inferior vena
vena cava differed by 8.4 cm with a change from cava by the gravid uterus in the supine position and
supine to left lateral position, equivalent to a difference relief of this compression upon changing to the lateral
in hydrostatic pressure of 6.2 mm Hg. In the two pigs, position are thought to be the physiologic basis of this
Dogs Pigs
S L R S L R
RV
RV RV IVC
lVC &--~ =1
T oVC _-
RV~~Iv lvc
IvC
.
1R
(IVCP) and mean right atrial pressure (RA) in supine and lateral posi- fluid-filled catheters. When such catheters are used,
tions. The pressures were measured simultaneously in seven pigs by the zero reference point should optimally be changed
means of fluid-filled catheters. whenever a patient's position is altered during the
course of a study.'2 Since identification of the proper
observation. In one study of women in the last trimes- zero reference point in each position may be difficult,
ter of pregnancy, however, cardiac output was not actual changes in intravascular pressures may not be
increased by a change from supine to left lateral posi- detected. To exclude the potential for such error, we
tion, and it was lower in the right lateral than in the used high-fidelity micromanometers that do not re-
supine and left lateral positions.' quire that the zero reference point be changed in each
In nonpregnant subjects, previous studies have pro- position. In our experimental study, both systolic and
vided conflicting data regarding the effects of supine end-diastolic left and right ventricular pressures were
and lateral positions on cardiac output. Ueland et al.' significantly higher in lateral positions than in the su-
reported no change in cardiac output, measured by dye pine position.
dilution techniques, with changes from supine to later- The differences in height of the right ventricle rela-
al (side not defined) positions in women who were 6 to tive to the inferior vena cava, as determined from
8 weeks postpartum. Atkins et al.4 also observed no roentgenographic studies, suggest that changes in hy-
significant differences in cardiac output, estimated by drostatic pressure may be entirely responsible for the
impedance plethysmography, in supine and left and increases in right ventricular end-diastolic pressure
right lateral positions in 19 women. Newman et al.' when animals are changed from the supine to the left
however, reported higher cardiac output, estimated by lateral position and from the supine to the right lateral
transcutaneous Doppler flowmeter, in the supine than position. The increase in hydrostatic pressure would be
in left and right lateral positions in 30 women. And expected to increase right ventricular diastolic filling
Whitman et al.,5 measuring cardiac output by thermo- and stroke volume, accounting for the increases in
dilution technique in 50 adult patients after cardiac cardiac output and left ventricular filling pressure in
surgery, observed a slightly higher cardiac output in the lateral positions. The hydrostatic pressure differ-
left lateral than in right lateral or supine positions. ences, however, are somewhat larger than the changes
584 CIRCULATION
LABORATORY INVESTIGATION-VENTRICULAR PERFORMANCE
in right ventricular end-diastolic pressure observed in deterioration in arterial oxygen saturation that often
the 17 animals studied with micromanometer-tipped occurs when patients with bilateral pulmonary disease
catheters. This would raise the possibility of variable assume the left lateral position.13-15
compression of the inferior vena cava, perhaps by the
liver, in the three positions. Indeed, the pressure gradi- References
ents recorded between the inferior vena cava and right 1 Ueland K, Novy MJ, Peterson EN, Metcalfe J: Maternal cardiovas-
atrium with fluid-filled catheters, which are insensitive cular dynamics: IV. The influence of gestational age on the mater-
nal cardiovascular response to posture and exercise. Am J Obstet
to changes in hydrostatic pressure, support the possi- Gynecol 104: 856, 1969
bility of compression and suggest that compression 2. Vorys N, Ullery JC, Hanusek GE: The cardiac output changes in
various positions in pregnancy. Am J Obstet Gynecol 82: 1312,
may be greatest in the left lateral position. 1961
Several limitations of this study should be empha- 3. Lees MM, Scott DB, Kerr MG, Taylor SH: The circulatory effects
of recumbent postural change in late pregnancy. Clin Sci 32: 453,
sized. First, there are no data with regard to chamber 1967
volumes. Although thermodilution cardiac output 4. Atkins AJF, Watt JM, Milan P, Davies P, Crawford JS: The influ-
ence of posture upon cardiovascular dynamics throughout pregnan-
measurements and changes in arteriovenous oxygen cy. Eur J Obstet Gynaecol Reprod Biol 12: 357, 1981
saturation differences suggest that increases in preload 5. Whitman GR, Howaniak DL, Verga TS: Comparison of cardiac
are responsible for increases in left and right ventricu- output measurements in 20-degree supine and 20-degree right and
left lateral recumbent positions. Heart Lung 11: 256, 1982
lar end-diastolic pressures in the lateral positions, oth- 6. Newman B, Derrington C, Dore C: Cardiac output and the recum-
er contributing factors, such as changes in ventricular bent position in late pregnancy. Anaesthesia 38: 332, 1983
7. Smith JJ, Bush JE, Wiedmeier VT, Tristani FE: Application of
compliance, variable compression of the right ventri- impedance cardiography to study of postural stress. J Appl Physiol
cle by the left, and alterations in right or left ventricular 29: 133, 1970
8. Rankin LS, Moos S, Grossman W: Alterations in preload and
afterload, cannot be excluded. Second, inferior vena ejection phase indices of left ventricular performance. Circulation
caval flows were not measured. Therefore the possibil- 51: 910, 1975
9. Newton KM: Comparison of aortic and brachial cuff pressures in
ity of variable, position-related compression of the flat supine and lateral recumbent positions. Heart Lung 10: 821,
inferior vena cava cannot be assessed further. Third, 1981
although we can conclude that positional changes in 10. Effers GWN, de Groot WJ, Tanner CR: Hemodynamic changes
associated with various surgical positions. JAMA 185: 81, 1963
two animal species significantly affect intracardiac 11. Kennedy GT, Bryant A, Crawford MH: The effect of lateral body
Downloaded from http://ahajournals.org by on August 6, 2021
pressures and cardiac output, it has not been deter- positioning on measurements of pulmonary artery and pulmonary
artery wedge pressures. Heart Lung 13: 155, 1984
mined that similar changes occur in other animal spe- 12. Grossman W: Cardiac catheterization and angiography, ed 2.
cies. In particular, whether and under what circum- Philadelphia, 1980, Lea & Febiger, p 1 1 1
13. Wood FC, Wolferth CC: The tolerance of certain cardiac patients
stances positional changes affect cardiac performance for various recumbent positions (trepopnea). Am J Med Sci 193:
in human beings must be clarified. If similar hemody- 354, 1937
14. Mills RM, Mudge GH Jr, Lesch M: Coronary sinus blood flow in
namic changes are confirmed for man, they may help trepopneic angina: case report. Ann Intern Med 84: 295, 1976
to explain several clinical observations, including the (letter to the editor)
preference of some patients with congestive heart fail- 15. Zack MB, Pontoppidan H, Kazemi H: The effect of lateral posi-
tions on gas exchange in pulmonary disease: a prospective evalua-
ure or angina for certain positions (trepopnea) and the tion. Am Rev Respir Dis 110: 49, 1974