Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Paper CHURCH CONFLICT RESOLUTION IN AFRICA
Paper CHURCH CONFLICT RESOLUTION IN AFRICA
By
Abstract
Introduction
The Church is one of the sacred institutions in the society. Before
the advent of Christianity in Africa, Africans worship God in
their traditional way through various deities and cult groups.
However, the Europeans make us to see the way we worship God
as barbaric and paganistic in nature. With the introduction of
education and religion, especially Christianity, Africans embrace
church than shrine i.e. Africans started to worship God in a
foreign way.
1
worshippers; for example, worshipper of Ogun (god of iron) and
worshipper of Osun (goddess of water). When this occurs,
sacrifices and appeasement will be carried out by the priest.
Hence, despite the advent of church and conversion by Africans
to Christianity, conflict became part of the Church which cut
across the Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant and the Pentecostal
Churches with several cases of schism, leadership tussle,
immorality, mismanagement of church fund, and various
doctrinal issues.
Conceptual Clarification
Church
The word “church” conveys various meanings and is subject to
many usages. The word “church” in the English Bible is
2
translated as ekklesia. The word ekklesia has a Greek
background. William Barclay1 describes its usage in the
following way:
In the great classical days in Athens, the ekklesia was the
convened assembly of the people. It consisted of all the citizens
of the city who had not lost their civic rights. Apart from the fact
that its decisions must conform to the laws of the State, its
powers were to all intents and purposes unlimited. It elected and
dismissed magistrates and directed the policy of the city. It
declared war, made peace, contracted treaties and arranged
alliances. It elected generals and other military officers. It
assigned troops to different campaigns and dispatched them from
the city. It was ultimately responsible for the conduct of all
military operations. It raised and allocated funds. Two things are
interesting to note. First, all its meetings began with prayer and
sacrifice. Second, it was a true democracy… It was an assembly
where everyone had an equal right and an equal duty to take part.
1
Barclay, W. A New Testament Wordbook. S.C.M. Press. 1955. p. 34.
2
M’Clintock, J. D. and Strong, J. S. Cyclopaedia of Biblical Theological and Ecclesiastical Literature.
Vol. I-II. New York: Arno Press.1969. p. 322.
3
7. the religious establishment of any particular nation or
government, as the Church of England; and
8. the sum of the various Christian denominations in a
country, as the Church of America.
Conflict
Conflict can be defined in many ways and there is no unanimity
among the scholars about what constitute a conflict. Schmidt
argued that conflict is inevitable in all human social relationship.
Due to the pervasive nature of this phenomenon, the term conflict
has attracted quite a lot of definitions4. Conflict is a hallmark of
the church and it is birthmark. It is inescapable. This assertion
3
M’Clintock, J. D. and Strong, J. S. p. 323.
4
Schmidt, A. Forum for Early Warning and Early Respite. London Thesaurus and Glossary. 2000. p. 12.
4
shows that conflict is inevitable and it is a trait in the church that
we cannot do without because it is inborn5.
Conflict Resolution
Conflict resolution implies approaching the conflict in a
problem-solving, constructive and non-violent way, recognising
the values of the identities of all parties in the relationship, their
human needs and interests, rather than a violent, destructive
solution or a mere settlement that ‘freezes’ the current power
distribution between opponents7. It refers to efforts, processes
and approaches aim at ending or resolving a conflict. It involve
recognition by the conflicting parties of one another’s interest,
5
Mickey, P. A. and Wilson, R. L. Conflict and Resolution. Nashville: Abingdon Press. 1973. pp.13-14.
6
Pneuman, R. W. and Bruehl, M. E. Managing Conflict. A Complete Process-Centered Handbook.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.1982. p.2
7
Schmid, A. P. Thesaurus and Glossary of early warning and Conflict Prevention Terms. London: Forum
on Early Warning and Early Response. 1998. p.26.
5
needs, perspectives and continue their existence in a peaceful and
mutually respecting atmosphere.
Turner, N. W. Leading Small Group: Basic Skill for Church and Community Organisations. Valley
10
6
these were creatively handled and produced a good result (e.g.
Acts 15:5-27, 36-41; Gal 2:9-14)12. The effects of conflicts can
either be negative or positive. But the underlying fact is that
every conflict has its own effect on both parties depending on
what form of conflict it is.
Ajayi, S. A. Baptist Work in Nigeria 1850-2005. A Comprehensive History. Ibadan: Book Wright
13
For details, see Afolabi, O. O. Church Conflict Management in the Nigerian Baptist Convention.
14
7
noted that there are some other conflicting local churches
cooperating with the NBC that have conflict which have led to
withdrawal of fellowship by the Convention from the church and
factional groups started new Baptist churches such as Ori-Oke
Baptist Church, Ogbomoso Ijeru Baptist Church, Ogbomoso,
Agodi Baptist Church, Ibadan. The factional groups started Tarra
Baptist Church, Ogbomoso, Living Truth Baptist Church,
Ogbomoso and Samuel Fadeji Memorial Baptist Church, Ibadan
respectively. Though, the Ministerial Board of the NBC that were
saddled with the responsibility of resolving church conflict in
Baptist churches made effort to resolve them according to the
constitution of the Convention.
www.cacworldwide.net/info/headline.asp?idm=541
16
Ajagbe, S. O. 2010. Crisis in Christ Apostolic Church 1990-1995. Causes and Solution. B.Th. Project of
the Nigerian Baptist Theological Seminary, Ogbomoso. pp. 16-34.
9
was established that the A.I.P.C.A. appealed to the colonial
government for assistance in reconciling its leaders. It was thus
concluded that from its inception, the Church has never had
avenues for resolving conflicts. Contributory factors such as
ignorance of the Church constitution, cultural nationalism,
leadership ambition among some members, political patronage,
financial constraints and lack of education and training of
ministers, revolved around an ineffective institutionalization of
the Church17.
10
avoid Church conflicts in Africa, the Church must educate its
members about the true mission of the Church.
Audu, B. “Culture and Tradition in Conflict Resolution”, in C. Garuba (Ed.). Capacity Building for
20
Onoge, O. “Social Conflict and Crime Control in Colonial Nigeria”, in T. N. Tamuno et. al. (eds.)
21
Policing Nigeria Past and Future. Lagos: Malthouse Press. 1993. p. 15.
11
In African societies, each person, family head, and community or
kingdom leaders were held responsible for the maintenance of
peace. Any breach of the peace by an individual or collectivity
was punished through ritual, (deities), legal (use of authority),
and moral sanctions (public disgrace).
12
their ancestors even though these ancestors are not construed as
actual personality, but the ideal24 of fundamentalism of social
relations. The relationship may be based on different models. It is
profoundly dyadic among the Irigwe of Nigeria and triadic in the
world view of the Tiriki in Kenya25.
Among the Sisala of northern Ghana, the ancestors are perceived
as a reflection of social relations quite often extended to
symbolic expression26. The ancestors are regulators of disputes
among the Lugbara of Uganda27.
Response to Fortes’s Critics”, Man, Vol. 15, No. 2, June 1980. p.30.
25
Sangree, W. H. “Youths as Elders and Infants as Ancestors: The Complementarity of Alternate
Generations, both Living and the Dead, in Tiriki, Kenya and Irigwe, Nigeria”. Africa Vol. 44, no 1.
January 1974. pp. 69-70.
26
Mendosa E. L. “Elders, Office-holders and Ancestors among the Sisla of Northern Ghana”. Africa, vol.
46, No. 1. 1976. p. 57.
27
Olaoba, p.140.
28
Mendosa, pp. 61-62.
13
consult the ancestors in every matter of
importance, etc. The ancestors are thought to have
the right and duty to discipline the living, by
bringing affliction upon the lineage, just as a
father has right and obligation vis-à-vis his child.
Living beings can only remain on the correct path
by continually consulting the ancestors through
diviners and making the appropriate sacrifices and
propitiations.
29
Olaoba, p.143.
PCS 703 African Approaches to Conflict Management. A Term Paper on the Impact of African
30
Ancestors on Conflict Resolution. Institute of African Studies, University of Ibadan, Ibadan. pp.17-18.
14
In Matthew 18:15, Jesus says, “And if your brother sins; go and
reprove him in private; if he listens to you, you have won your
brother”31. The Greek word translated ‘won’ was originally used
for accumulating wealth in the sense of monetary commodities.
Here, it refers to the gaining back of something of value that is
lost, namely, an erring brother. When there is conflict between
two brothers, a valuable treasure is lost which is the love that
existed between them, and the church should not be content until
the conflict is resolved.
Step Two (Matt. 18:16): But if you are unsuccessful, take one or
two others with you and go back again (v.16a). The purpose of
taking other believers is “so that everything you say may be
confirmed by two or three witnesses (v. 16b). In other words, the
witnesses are present not only to confirm that the issue of dispute
between both parties but to act as mediators in resolving the
conflict. The presence of additional witnesses is to act as neutral
third party in addressing the root-cause(s) of the conflict by
moderating discussions, assisting and finding solution to the
prevailing conflict. These witnesses must be neutral, credible and
be respected by both parties. At this point, it should be noted that
31
New Living Translation Bible.
15
the presence of one or two witnesses will be sufficient to resolve
the conflict and restore back the relationship between brothers.
Step Four (Matt. 18:17b): If the church decides you are right,
but the other person won’t accept it, treat that person as a pagan
or corrupt tax-collector (v. 17b). A pagan is a non-Jew who held
to the traditional paganism and had no part in the covenant,
worship, or social life of the Jews. On the other hand, a ‘tax-
collector’ was an outcast from the Jews by choice, having
become a traitor to his own people. Jesus’ use of these terms
doesn’t mean that the church is to treat these people badly. It
simply means that when a professing believer refuses to accept
the decision of the church, he is to be treated as if he was outside
of the fellowship. They are not to let him associate and
participate in the blessings and benefits of the Christian
assembly.
Conclusion
Conflict in the Church and African States is a reality. As several
approaches have been proposed in resolving and managing
conflict in Africa, the Churches in Africa should strive to resolve
their conflict through Christianisation of African approach in
resolving disputes and to put into practice, the Biblical approach
to conflict resolution. Thus, Africans can strive as much as
16
possible to be at peace with one another and to resolve
differences amicably. The church should be an epitome of peace,
unity and manager and resolver of conflict.
References
Afolabi O. O. 2011. Church Conflict Management in the
Nigerian Baptist Convention. Germany: Lap Lambert
Academic Publishing.
Ajagbe, S. O. 2010. Crisis in Christ Apostolic Church 1990-
1995. Causes and Solution. B.Th. Project of the Nigerian
Baptist Theological Seminary, Ogbomoso. pp. 16-34.
Ajayi, S. A. 2010. Baptist Work in Nigeria 1850-2005. A
Comprehensive History. Ibadan: Book Wright
Publishers. p. 317.
Akpuru-Aja, A. 2009. “Basic Concepts of Conflict”, in M.
Ikejiani-Clark Peace Studies and Conflict Resolution in
Nigeria. A Reader. Ibadan: Spectrum Books Ltd. p. 21.
Audu, B. 1998. “Culture and Tradition in Conflict Resolution”,
in C. Garuba (Ed.). Capacity Building for Crisis
Management in Africa. Abuja National War College. p.
149.
Barclay, W. 1955. A New Testament Wordbook. S.C.M. Press.
p. 34.
Calhoun, C. J. “The Authority of Ancestors. A Sociological
Reconsideration of Fortes’s Tallensi in Response to
Fortes’s Critics”, Man, Vol. 15, No. 2, June 1980. p.30.
Kamau, M. W. “Leadership Conflicts in the African Independent
Pentecostal Church of Africa: with particular reference to
Gitothua”. Retrieved 15th Jan., 2013 from http:www.//ir-
library.ku.ac.ke/ir/handle/123456789/4900
17
Katz, D. 1964. “Approaches to Managing Conflict”, in K. Robert
and K. Bouldings (Eds.) Power and Conflict in
Organisations. New York: Basic Books. p. 85.
Mail, D. and Curtis (Eds.). 1960. Our Community. New York:
New York University Press.
M’Clintock, J. D. and Strong, J. S. 1969. Cyclopaedia of Biblical
Theological and Ecclesiastical Literature. Vol. I-II. New
York: Arno Press. p. 322.
Mendosa E. L. 1976. “Elders, Office-holders and Ancestors
among the Sisla of Northern Ghana”. Africa, vol. 46, No.
1. p. 57.
Mickey, P. A. and Wilson, R. L. 1973. Conflict and Resolution.
Nashville: Abingdon Press. pp.13-14.
Moenga, C. “The Root Cause of Church Conflicts”. Retrieved
12th Jan. 2013 from http://www/weekendpost.co.bw/
index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=2944:the-
root-cause-of-church- conflicts&catid=59:debate. 2011.
New Living Translation Bible.
Nwolise, O.B. C. 2005. “Traditional Models of Bargaining and
Conflict Resolution in Africa”, in I. O. Albert (ed.)
Perspectives of Peace and Conflict in Africa. Essays in
honour of Gen. (Dr.) Abdulsalami A. Abubakar. Lagos:
John Archers Publishers Ltd. p.154.
Olaoba O. B. 2005. “Ancestral Focus and the Process of Conflict
Resolution in Traditional African Societies”, in I. O.
Albert (ed.) Perspectives of Peace and Conflict in Africa.
Essays in honour of Gen. (Dr.) Abdulsalami A. Abubakar.
Lagos: John Archers Publishers Ltd. p.140.
Onoge, O. 1993. “Social Conflict and Crime Control in Colonial
Nigeria”, in T. N. Tamuno et.al. (eds.) Policing Nigeria
Past and Future. Lagos: Malthouse Press. p. 15.
Pneuman, R. W. and Bruehl, M. E. 1982. Managing Conflict. A
Complete Process-Centered Handbook. Englewood
Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. p. 2.
Sangree, W. H. “Youths as Elders and Infants as Ancestors: The
18
Complementarity of Alternate Generations, both Living
and the Dead, in Tiriki, Kenya and Irigwe, Nigeria”.
Africa Vol. 44, No1. January 1974. pp. 69-70.
Schmid, A. P. 1998. Thesaurus and Glossary of early warning
and Conflict Prevention Terms. London: Forum on Early
Warning and Early Response. p.26.
Schmidt, A. 2000. Forum for Early Warning and Early Respite.
London Thesaurus and Glossary. p. 12.
Turner, N. W. 1996. Leading Small Group: Basic Skill for
Church and Community Organisations. Valley Forge:
Judson Press. p. 43.
PCS 703: African Approaches to Conflict Management. A Term
Paper on the Impact of African Ancestors on Conflict
Resolution. Institute of African Studies, University of
Ibadan, Ibadan. pp.17-18.
---------- 2010. Genesis of the Conflict. Retrieved Aug. 25, 2012,
from www.cacworldwide.net/info/headline.asp?idm=541
19